<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Denham Sadler on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Denham Sadler on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@denhamsadler?source=rss-b26b2265480a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 15:15:40 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@denhamsadler/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Distance From Reality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@denhamsadler/a-distance-from-reality-916da024b365?source=rss-b26b2265480a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/916da024b365</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Denham Sadler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 May 2015 09:48:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-19T09:50:51.072Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Execution of Rodrigo Gularte</p><p>Rodrigo Gularte was all alone when he found out he was going to die.</p><p>He was in Tangeran District Court in Indonesia on drug charges. It was ten years ago, and his lawyer had long ago fled with a large amount of money, while his family weren’t told of the sentencing hearing in time. Report say Gularte’s attempts to defend himself, while not being able to speak the language, were drowned out by anti-drug protesters.</p><p>The three judges quickly sentenced him to death for attempting to smuggle six kilograms of cocaine into Jakarta in 2004.</p><p>But ten years later, up until the very end, it seems Gularte didn’t truly understand his death sentence. According to family, friends, lawyers, and doctors, he was suffering from paranoid schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, and had from a young age. His new lawyer, Ricky Ganawan, joined the case earlier this year, and said that in Gularte’s own warped mind the death penalty had been abolished worldwide, and he believed he’d soon be taken back to Brazil.</p><p>“It’s something he didn’t know anything about,” Gunawan said.</p><blockquote>“He had a distance from reality.”</blockquote><p>In the ten years since his sentencing, Gularte spent most of his time in prison talking to animals and inanimate objects, and listening to the voices in his head. He tried to kill himself the year after his trial, and his mental health rapidly deteriorated in the years following.</p><p>Rodrigo Gularte liked to be listened to.</p><p>“He’s highly schizophrenic and paranoid, and the big thing for him is being listened to and respected,” Father Charlie Burrows said. Father Burrows counselled Gularte in his final days. He listened to him talk for at least four hours on the morning of his execution, as he recounted his life and what it was like to grow up with such severe mental illness.</p><p>“He went right through it all, he gave a great description of what his life was like being mentally unwell, with voices in his head all the time, the noises, feeling empty, low esteem,” Burrows said. “He kept repeating, ‘my fault, my fault, my fault’.”</p><p>Gularte’s cousin Angelita Muxfeldt, who fought for him till the very end, said that morning was the best he’d been in years. “She asked me to write all that down, which I have,” Burrows explained. “She wants to use that for the family back in Brazil when they bury him.”</p><p>Gularte was still talking when he was placed on a wooden cross in front of an Indonesian firing squad. Father Charlie Burrows was still listening until the very end.</p><p>“The most important thing for him was being listened to.”</p><blockquote>The Slippery Slope</blockquote><p>Rodrigo Gularte was born into wealth, of both money and opportunity. His family was well-off, and lived in Foz do Iguacu, Parana in southern Brazil. But his family say Rodrigo fell into depression following his parents divorce when he was 13 years old. He began his descent on the slippery slope of drugs and mental illness that would eventually lead to that court room in Indonesia.</p><p>He had always loved surfing. But it was this that would eventually contribute to his downfall. Police found six kilograms of cocaine in his surfboard case as he was trying to enter Jakarta. Gularte was with two friends, but he took all the blame. They both returned quickly to Brazil, but Gularte would soon be on Indonesia’s notorious Prison Island.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/597/1*yZEcdNL8mAmpp14ZI1wtyw.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>“Am I being executed?”</blockquote><p>At around 12.30am in the early morning of the 29th of April Rodrigo Gularte became another victim of the Indonesian government’s ruthless and often brutal war on drugs. He was killed along with the Australians, Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran.</p><p>Father Burrows, an Irish-born Catholic priest, said the condemned man had become increasingly paranoid in his final days. He felt safe within the prison walls in his cell, but believed a sniper would shoot him, or a bomb would go off if he left. That’s what the voices in his head told him.</p><p>He was taken from his cell and into a waiting car in handcuffs to the execution site. The handcuffs were replaced with white rope. It was only when chains were placed on his legs that he began to realise what was about to happen to him.</p><p>“It was only at that stage Rodrigo said to me: ‘Oh, am I being executed?’,” Burrows recounted. “He just hadn’t got the message. I had to say that I’m very sorry, but that’s the situation.”</p><p>He was then tied to a wooden cross. The priest was only given a handful of minutes with him before he was hauled away. Gularte had transformed from an uneasy, highly paranoid individual to an annoyed and distraught one.</p><p>“His attitude was annoyed,” Burrows said. “But one of the things they said he did, they said he screamed. He didn’t scream.”</p><p>“Rodrigo is a really passive sort of guy, he was just annoyed,” he continued. “He was saying ‘Why am I being executed? I did wrong, I made a mistake. The punishment should be life in jail. This is wrong. This is unjust.”</p><p>Ten years after he had been sentenced, it seemed Gularte had finally started to realise how he would die.</p><p>The priest was soon taken away to a nearby tent with other religious counsellors. They began to sing ‘Amazing Grace’ together, but shots soon rang out in the night and cut through their voices.</p><p>Rodrigo Gularte, along with seven others, was shot by a firing squad of 12 men, with three carrying live ammunition. His body was quickly taken to a nearby makeshift morgue. As the ambulance carrying the coffin went past, Angelita wanted to see her cousin for one last time.</p><p>After convincing the policemen, Burrows helped to unscrew the coffin. It was then that it all became very real. “She was very upset, it was a very hard time for her,” Burrows recalled. “We said a few prayers together and then closed the coffin.”</p><p>Gularte’s body was taken to Jakarta before he was finally taken back home to Brazil.</p><blockquote>The Past Tense</blockquote><p>I started writing this story weeks before Gularte was shot and killed by specially trained</p><p>Indonesian police. There was still hope back then. His lawyer explained to me in depth the various legal options they were still exploring after the Indonesian government revealed their own report. That never happened. There were constant whispers that government officials had acknowledged he was mentally ill and would finally be receiving treatment. This never happened.</p><p>I had to go back and change much of this story to the past tense. It was a difficult and surprising introspective process. There was still hope back then, in the present tense.</p><p>The fight to save Gularte’s life was a long and complicated one, revolving around technicalities in Indonesian law, and differing medical opinions.</p><p>According to his family and lawyers, Gularte had been treated for schizophrenia as far back as 1996. They produced documents showing he was prescribed antidepressants, antipsychotics and mood stabilisers by a psychiatrist back in Brazil. His legal team have amassed 22 documents relating to his mental condition.</p><p>Last year the Gularte family, along with the Brazilian embassy, requested a medical report on his mental state. The report was eventually released in February, and declared Gularte to have “schizophrenia and bipolar disorder with psychotic features”. It stated that he needed to “Immediately receive intensive psychiatric treatment with medications in a hospital”. But he was never moved from the island prison of Nusa Kamgangan until he was in a coffin in the back of an ambulance.</p><p>The Indonesian government repeatedly refused to believe that Gularte was actually mentally unwell. Despite reports from government-approved doctors, they commissioned another study into his condition, which has never been released, not even to Gularte’s lawyers.</p><p>“Their report was according to the testimony of fellow inmates, and this is obviously invalid,” Gunawan said. “They don’t have the capacity or qualification to say that Rodrigo is in good or bad mental health.”</p><p>Gunawan said the government and attorney-general’s office were uncooperative until the end. Weeks before the executions he told me something that would soon seem very true and all too real. “It seems they have the desire to execute him without considering the validity and legitimacy of the evidence we have.”</p><p>Article 44 of the Indonesian Penal Code states that any person with a mental disorder cannot be sentenced for a criminal act, and should be treated in hospital. It is illegal under international law to execute a person with a mental or intellectual disorder. Despite this, Indonesian AG H.M. Prasetyo repeatedly claimed he was fit to be executed, and eventually ordered it to go ahead.</p><blockquote>The Voices In His Head</blockquote><p>A large part of the problem was Gularte’s inability to admit he was unwell. He reportedly repeatedly refused medication. As Father Burrows recounts, whenever he was told about his mental illness, Rodrigo would say: “No, no no, I’m not sick. I’m very well.” He’d also flatly reject the reality of his impending execution. “Oh no, I’m not going to be executed, I’m going back to Brazil next year,” he would say.</p><p>“That’s what the voices were telling him, and he believed the voices more than anybody else,” Father Burrows explained. “That was the problem.”</p><p>The fight for Rodrigo Gularte’s life is over. It was ended abruptly by a firing squad on a remote island in Indonesia. But the fight for his legacy, and for justice, seems to only be beginning. His voice will still be heard through his family, his lawyer, and Father Charlie Burrows as they work to clear his name posthumously.</p><p>“We are still involved in the casework. We still have an administrative lawsuit ongoing,” Gularte’s lawyer Ricky Gunawan told me. “We also plan to file the 2nd PK [Peninjauan Kembali, a reexamination of the case in the Supreme Court] in the hope to clear his name and to prove that Indonesia really killed a sick person.”</p><p>For Gularte’s family, it’s about clearing Rodrigo’s name and proving his mental illness, but for Gunawan it’s also about the larger issue of the death penalty in general. “We hope that what we are doing will demonstrate that the death penalty is really awful and has inherent errors.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=916da024b365" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE CHILDREN OF THE DUST]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@denhamsadler/the-children-of-the-dust-12a7181dc838?source=rss-b26b2265480a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/12a7181dc838</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Denham Sadler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Apr 2015 11:16:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-30T11:16:51.692Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><em>Operation Babylift’s Australian Legacy</em></blockquote><p>An American army aircraft carrying 243 orphan children departs Saigon-Tan Son Nhut airport in the dying days of the Vietnam War.</p><p>Landon Carnie is one of those children. He and the other infants are placed in cardboard boxes in the airplane’s cargo hold, held down by large straps. It’s the 4th of April, 1975, and Vietnam is in complete chaos. The central city of Da Nang has just fallen, and Saigon is standing for only a matter of time. The war will be over in less than a month.</p><p>Twelve minutes after take off, the Lockheed C-5A Galaxy is flying over the South China Sea. At an altitude of over 7,000m, the locks on the rear loading ramp fail. There’s a large explosion as the cargo door is blown open, and the plane rapidly decompresses. A whirlwind of fog and debris surround the babies as the aircraft begins to free fall. The captain wrestles with the controls and manages to direct the plane and its precious cargo back towards the airport.</p><p>There’s a brief calmness, before the plane suddenly begins to drop again.</p><p>At 4.45pm, the aircraft crashes into a muddy rice paddy field on the outskirts of Saigon. It skids for a few hundred metres, becomes airborne again over the Saigon River and breaks into four pieces in a rice field. Landon Carnie is left lying in a field near the burning wreckage with his twin sister. The one year olds were thought to have perished, but were somehow left unharmed.</p><p>A local farmer rummaging around the crash site eventually finds them days later, clinging to each other, a small miracle surrounded by death and destruction.</p><p>Seventy-eight orphans were killed in the plane crash, along with 35 Defense-Attache Office Saigon personnel. To this day, it’s the deadliest accident involving a US military aircraft. It was the first flight of Operation Babylift, the largest international removal and adoption of children ever undertaken. Over 3,300 orphaned infants and children, believed to be in immediate danger from the Communist forces, were sent as far away as Australia.</p><p>At the same time, two Australian Hercules were sitting on the tarmac of Saigon airport. One departs a few minutes after the American aircraft, and a plume of ominous smoke soon appears over the runway. It’s initially feared the Australian aircraft has crashed. The babies were eventually flown to Bangkok, before being transferred to a QANTAS jet that flew to Sydney.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/403/1*_ODF_DLPCurYhwoWflYOXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Carnie and his sister were flown out of Vietnam a few days later, and eventually taken to Colville, a small conservative town of 5,000 people in Washington State, USA. They were adopted by a family who had already taken in another girl from Vietnam, and Carnie enjoyed a mostly normal childhood. “I knew I was different but at the same time I never really thought I was different,” he explains. “I always assumed I was white, even though I wasn’t.”</p><p>The legacy of Operation Babylift is still felt today, 40 years on from those fateful flights. The ramifications of this event, with 281 babies transnationally adopted in Australia, are only properly being recognised today.</p><p>Weeks after the first flights, two more Australian Hercules took part in Operation Babylift. It was April 17th, 1975 at an RAAF base in Butterworth, Malaysia and Commanding Officer Dr Wally Smith’s superior was arguing with Canberra via Telex. They wanted Smith and a team of nurses to travel to Vietnam earlier to examine the infants. They would eventually get permission when Smith was already well on his way to Saigon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VT0Fey6ji6OrhY6sdjJk7Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image via Dr Wally Smith</figcaption></figure><p>That night he watched explosions around the outskirts of Saigon from the hotel rooftop. They looked like fireworks, until he realised people were dying underneath them.</p><p>The next morning, Smith examined a group of 70 infants, before accompanying them on one of two Hercules flights from Saigon to Bangkok, before they were taken to Melbourne on a QANTAS plane.</p><p>Many of the babies were very unwell. Dr Smith recalls a two year old boy on the verge of death. “He was grey,” Smith says. “He was flat as a tack.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/791/1*nTyQzCTxbRpuMHKhRvJXzQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image via Wally Smith</figcaption></figure><p>Suffering from gastroenteritis, he had been healthy the day before. Smith tried to get a drip into his veins, but they collapsed. Eventually he tried the top of the boy’s foot, and it worked.</p><p>The boy’s health began to pick up. He was still alive when the Hercules left Saigon. He was still alive when the plane arrived at Bangkok. But from there, Smith doesn’t know. He doesn’t know whether he made it to Melbourne, or where he may be today.</p><p>“I would dearly love to know whether that kid survived,” Smith laments. “I never will, but I would dearly love to know.”</p><p>Even once the babies were placed in cardboard boxes acting as makeshift seats in the Hercules, not all survived the perilous journey to Thailand. Doctor Wally Smith still remembers what one young boy was wearing. “He was dressed in a blue cotton baby suit, from head to toe.” The baby was dressed in preparation for Melbourne’s colder weather. But it was still very warm inside the aircraft.</p><p>The Hercules left the airport and did a ‘battle climb’ over the airport in order to avoid surface-to-air missiles. As Smith struggled to hold on, he saw a pediatrician huddled on the floor, giving CPR to a baby.</p><p>“It was the little kid in the blue suit,” Smith says. “And he was dead.”</p><p>These fleeting, chaotic moments will stay with Smith for the rest of his life. His words falter and shake delicately as he describes what happened, but his details are exact. It was nearly 40 years ago, but he recalls it as if it happened last week. “He wasn’t one of the sick ones, he was okay.”</p><p>The conditions within the cardboard boxes were much warmer than the rest of the cargo hold, causing the baby to fatally over-heat. It had been Smith’s decision to use the cardboard boxes, but there was no other option. Iconic photographs show that the American flights also used boxes. “It wasn’t just us,” Smith muses. “I felt a little better I suppose.”</p><p>Cath Turner was in one of those cardboard boxes 40 years ago. She survived. Turner was on the first plane to Sydney and she was taken in by family in Armidale, a country town of about 20,000 people in New South Wales. She’s now a journalist living in Sydney, and until recently worked for Al Jazeera. Her family made an active effort to ensure Operation Babylift was a constant presence in her childhood.</p><p>“It was always part of my upbringing that I was different, and I had another mother somewhere else,” she says. “It was never a secret, we never pretended it was anything it wasn’t.”</p><p>Growing up with three older sisters, Turner felt like a normal child until she encountered racism in high school, placing her Vietnam heritage at the forefront. “That’s when I started really feeling the effects of being different,” she details. “A lot of my childhood memories are caught up in the unpleasantness and nastiness, the bullying. It’s what tended to derail me sometimes.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dbA-DmXToh7-j_h9fFiURg.png" /><figcaption>Via Al Jazeera</figcaption></figure><p>After years of bullying, Turner wanted nothing to do with Vietnamese culture. “I just rejected it. I didn’t think it was interesting, or a part of me,” she says.</p><p>“I was at an age when I was trying to be the same as everyone else, and I certainly didn’t want to invest in something that set me apart from everyone else.”</p><p>Landon Carnie had a different experience with Vietnamese culture throughout his childhood, seeing it as “fun and interesting”. “I started to realise that I’m not that special anymore,” he says. “You meet all these people and realise you’re not alone, there are other people like you in the same situation.”</p><p>It took Carnie and Turner a long time to return to their birth country. They were both in their 20s when they did, but had vastly differing experiences. Carnie discovered a culture that he immediately connected with. He gleefully describes travelling across Saigon, befriending a rickshaw driver and riding around from dawn until dusk, discovering local restaurants and sites along the way.</p><p>He would later return for good.</p><p>When Turner came to Vietnam, she found nothing she could connect with. “I just didn’t feel accepted by Vietnamese culture,” she confesses. “It felt very foreign and I wanted to get out.” She was 27 years old, and visited Saigon with her best friend in an attempt to find her birth mother, but she just “pounded the pavement for two weeks”, with little luck.</p><p>“We had the wrong leads, we were asking the wrong questions, we had the wrong people,” Turner laments. “I didn’t cope very well. It was really exhausting, annoying and frustrating.”</p><p>Buoyed by his first return to Vietnam, Carnie found it hard to adjust to his nine to five job in America. He left his job and travelled to Melbourne to study, before becoming a lecturer at RMIT’s Saigon campus.</p><p>He’s still there today. “I’ve been here for more than ten years now, it was supposed to be a year or two,” he says, laughing.</p><p>Turner went back with her adoptive parents in 2003. It was a holiday, not another search mission, an opportunity for Turner to show her family just how different her life could’ve been. But their translator took an interest in her story, and began to piece tidbits of information together.</p><p>The trip became much more than a holiday.</p><p>The moment is captured in a documentary Turner made for Al Jazeera. “I’ve been waiting 30 years for this moment,” she whispers. She’s sitting in a small room, waiting for her birth mother to appear from a nearby door. After waiting more than half an hour, an old Vietnamese lady walks into the room. She slowly inspects Turner’s face, then nods.</p><p>Cath Turner had found her birth mother.</p><p>A translator was required, but the innately human connection between a mother and her child was obvious. The most important piece in the puzzle of her childhood had been found.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*swRSTSRro607AcX51YNNHg.png" /><figcaption>Via Al Jazeera</figcaption></figure><p>Landon Carnie has never tried to track down his birthmother. While Turner had a letter from her birthmother, all of Carnie’s documentation was destroyed in the plane crash. “Maybe I don’t want to pursue it because of the effort it would take, or maybe it’s because of the disappointment,” he admits.</p><p>Even after Turner found her birthmother, it was still difficult to maintain a relationship. They can’t speak over the phone without a translator, emailing is time consuming and difficult, and flights from New York are long and expensive. “I’ve lost pretty much all contact with my Vietnamese family, which is sad and difficult,” Turner laments.</p><p>“It’s the tyranny of distance.”</p><p>While Turner and Carnie have had contact with others involved with Operation Babylift for most of their lives, Dr Wally Smith has only just reconnected with some of the children he treated during those flights, after finding a Facebook group bringing those involved together.</p><p>“To me, it was such a significant event. It was these little kids, and we lost one, and there were sick ones that I don’t know what happened to them,” he says. “I’m just so grateful I found it. It’s filled a bit of a gap in my life.”</p><p>There’s a scene in Turner’s documentary where the entire construct of her childhood comes shattering down. It was the first interview she filmed for the documentary, with a former CIA agent involved in Operation Babylift and it was the moment she realised, despite her initial resistance, the film would be deeply personal.</p><p>The agent is mercilessly blunt in claiming the operation was an attempt to persuade politicians to spend more money on the war, but it didn’t work. “You were a way of making the world think Saigon was worth saving. It was the only way.” he says to an emotional Turner. “There was a term we used for people like you: children of the dust.”</p><p>“Those were the orphans of war, they were the least among us and nobody cared about them really.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GIB5l5XG_5gbQXHkGDA5Jw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The words hit Turner so hard she had to stop the interview. Her understanding of the entire purpose of her adoption had been changed in those few minutes. According to him, the adoptions were a political facade, and she was a tool of war. Turner has now come to terms with this reality. “There was so much more at stake than just rescuing 3,000 babies,” she explains. “I do think we were pawns.”</p><p>For the 3,300 children involved in Operation Babylift, there’s a constant struggle to reconcile the vastly different cultures they are a product of. This is even more difficult for Turner, who was born in Vietnam, grew up in Australia, lived in New York, and, until recently, worked for an Arab media organisation. “I always identify with being Australian,” she says confidently. “That was the culture I was brought up in, and surrounded by, the language I grew up hearing, the humour I have. There’s definitely an infusion of Vietnamese in me, and certainly my mother’s spirit and personality. I’m at peace with that.”</p><p>Carnie has also only recently come to terms with the different facets of his identity. “When I’m in America I can easily be American, when I’m in Vietnam and I’m walking the streets, eating at a restaurant or when I’m on my bike, I’m Vietnamese,” he details. “It’s quite easy to transition between identities now.”</p><p>The events of those few weeks towards the end of the Vietnam War also form a part of the identity of those involved with its operations. “It was one of the most fascinating, enthralling and tragic days of my medical career,” Smith says. “It’s not the sort of thing a doctor does every day of the week.”</p><p>Operation Babylift was a confounding event in history, with its repercussions still felt today. It can’t just be brushed under the rug like other controversies of war, with those involved approaching their 40th birthdays, and many are still coming to terms with what was done to them as babies. According to Turner, something like this will never happen again, “not in a million years.”</p><p>“Taking children out of their homeland is an absolute last resort,” she continues. “I can’t imagine another government wanting to take responsibility for that.”</p><p>But 40 years ago, it did happen. Landon Carnie, Cath Turner, and more than three thousand other babies were flown out of Vietnam and into the Western World. This year’s anniversary isn’t a happy one for everyone involved. “It’s not an anniversary I particularly want to mark,” Turner explains.</p><p>Operation Babylift was a staggeringly controversial and historic event. For those involved, it will always define a part of their identities. But Cath Turner, like many others, says it’s certainly not the only jigsaw piece in the puzzle of her identity.</p><p>“I don’t want to be defined by it.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=12a7181dc838" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Still Standing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@denhamsadler/still-standing-f820bed3a72b?source=rss-b26b2265480a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f820bed3a72b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Denham Sadler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Oct 2014 11:14:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-10-12T05:40:05.745Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The fight to save the Palace Theatre</p><p>A man’s voice booms across a busy Melbourne street, pleading for a cause that many believe to already be lost. He is ignored by most.</p><p>A handful of musicians don acoustic guitars and serenade the passing workers on their way home after a long week. Others hold makeshift signs out to the passing peak-hour traffic, receiving the occasional honk of approval.</p><p>The man speaks passionately to those gathered, before turning to an adjacent tram stop and imploring the commuters to listen to his arguments.</p><p>It’s five o’clock on a typically cold Melbourne evening, and a gaggle of around 20 people are gathered outside the Palace Theatre, holding a vigil for the doomed venue. These are the people who still have hope despite almost everyone else resigning to defeat.</p><p>The man is Ezekiel Ox, a local musician who has been helping to organise these gatherings for the last three months. He is confident, self-assured and articulate; he doesn’t shout, but his voice resonates across Bourke Street.</p><blockquote><strong>“This building is a symbol now. We are not fighting for something we can’t achieve,” he says. “Big business reigns supreme while live music dies.”</strong></blockquote><p>It’s a far cry from the political demonstrations seen recently just across the road at Parliament House. It’s not really even a protest. It’s hardly loud, not disruptive and rarely angry. It feels more like a memorial held outside a venue on its deathbed.</p><p>Passers by hardly take notice of the group. One older man in a suit begins to clap along with the music, a rare sign of recognition.</p><p>Scrawled in concrete on the sidewalk outside the theatre are the words: “Save live music. Save our culture. Save our heritage. Save the Palace”. It’s merely walked over by most as it slowly fades away into the pavement, perhaps an apt metaphor for the dwindling support for the historic building.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EfCn_pWJcqmClnRIHQSYqw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Palace Theatre has been abandoned by nearly everyone.</p><p>Its owner, development company Jinshan Investments, announced plans late last year to demolish the building and build a luxury hotel in its place. After a long struggle, the operators were forced out, and the venue ceased to host any shows.</p><p>The last and perhaps most damaging loss was the public’s support. After much outcry following the original announcement, it seems most have given up on the venue, resigned to it being another victim of gentrification and urbanisation.</p><p>But not all have given up.</p><p>Rebecca Lesley runs the Save The Palace group, which formed after plans to demolish the theatre were announced last year.</p><p>Lesley has received some good news on the day I speak with her, but she’s learned not to get too excited about any seemingly positive developments. She’s been disappointed before. Melbourne City Council planning officers had made a recommendation to reject the building proposal, but Lesley is skeptical.</p><blockquote><strong>“Am I supposed to be happy? You can be happy for a minute, but don’t get too excited.”</strong></blockquote><p>It’s another step in what’s been a long and arduous fight to save the Palace Theatre, one that’s seen far more setbacks than positives like this one.</p><p>Speaking from her 9–5 job, Lesley says she began running the group after attending a community meeting that was called following the announcement of the building plans.</p><p>“Once it became known that it had been sold to a development group that wanted to demolish it, a kid started a Facebook page, and within 24 hours there was like 20,000 people on it,” Lesley says. “The original rally following the community meeting was scheduled for August [last year] and it got cancelled, so we all went ‘what the hell’s going on?’ So that’s when we got involved.”</p><p>“I remember before the community meeting I was thinking, ‘Oh will I go or won’t I go’, and it was a shitty night too. But then I thought, ‘no, I actually care about this, I really care’. So I went along to the community meeting, and that was it.”</p><p>The Save the Palace Facebook group now has over 35,000 ‘likes’, and regularly posts updates surrounding the ongoing struggle to prevent the venue being transformed into a high-rise hotel and apartment complex.</p><p>“I think you always watch this stuff, with things keeping getting closed down and the problems with live music in Melbourne when we’re supposed to be supportive of it, and then I saw this. I love the Palace, it’s my favourite venue in Melbourne and I’ve seen my favourite bands there.”</p><blockquote><strong>“It’s not just a live music venue, it’s an experience.”</strong></blockquote><p>The Palace Theatre is one of Melbourne’s most historic buildings, one that has transformed and adapted along with the constantly evolving city it inhabits. It began operations in 1860 as the Excelsior Hotel, featuring a main hall that showcased performances and boxing bouts. In 1911 it was transformed into a theatre, with seating on three levels and bedrooms on the first floor. After extensive remodelling in 1923, it was rebranding as ‘The New Palace’, until it became a cinema in 1940. After operating as the Metro Nightclub from 1986, it was sold in 2007 and reverted back to The Palace that we know now.</p><p>The loss of the Palace would leave a gaping hole in Melbourne’s live music landscape. It’s a beautiful, unique venue to witness a show, featuring three levels, multiple balconies, and numerous vantage points. But most of all, it has something that is sorely lacking from most music venues: character.</p><p>A statement by the operators earlier this year read: “Effective from the 31st May 2014 this building and its previous incarnations…which started trading in 1860, will cease trading to make way for a proposed apartment and hotel development”. The Palace had been defeated.</p><p>In a final humiliation for the once proud venue, a ‘closing down’ sale took place in May, with everything from furniture and light fittings to audio and lighting gear up for grabs. This offered a chance to “purchase a part of history”, but it seemed more like a final recognition that it was all over.</p><p>The venue has played host to some of the biggest Australian and international bands of our generation, with over two million punters visiting the Palace over the last eight years it has been a music venue.</p><p>It’s also a crucially important venue logistically for the Melbourne live music landscape. With a capacity of just under 2000, it’s one of only two venues capable of playing host to mid-sized international bands, those that can’t fill Festival Hall or the cavernous Rod Laver Arena, but are far too large for smaller rooms such as the Corner Hotel or Prince Bandroom, which each hold less than 1000.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W1FCWAcEChfv1XGxJl-HTA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The weekly vigils began after the former operators left the venue, and have now been going for more than 11 weeks.</p><p>“It’s giving people a place to come and actually say that even though they’ve kicked out the operators, this building is still significant to Melbourne and the live music lovers,” Lesley says. “You don’t just replace 100 year old theatres. You don’t just replace a three-level theatre tomorrow, you can’t lose it.”</p><p>These vigils usually feature a similar array of people, along with the odd newcomer, as well as some enthusiastic passerbys. They attract a wide and diverse range of people; it’s not just young gig-goers.</p><p>“There’s a girl that comes every week and brings her three kids with her. Every week she turns up with a wad full of objection letters that’s she’s gone through shopping centres and had completed,” Lesley says..</p><p>“You realise that there are other people that are out there fighting for this, and that’s an incredible thing.”</p><p>But is it hard to maintain hope and enthusiasm when seemingly everyone else has given up, resigned to the venue’s fate?</p><p>“Not at all,” Lesley simply replies.</p><p>But actually getting people from the 35k-strong Facebook group to leave their laptops and campaign on the streets has proved to be a much more challenging issue.</p><p>“You care about it, but it’s how much you care about it, whether you’re prepared to get off your arse and do something about it,” she says.</p><p>“We don’t want to dishearten them, there are still so many opportunities to save it. It was really hard to come back from when the operators said they were out. It’s been really hard to maintain momentum on it because it’s not over. Yes they’re out, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t other operators waiting on the sidelines if it does get saved.”</p><p>Back outside the theatre, the weekly vigil is coming to an end. A brief chant of “hands off our city” sees the small group united in voice, while also delivering a clear message to bystanders: “we’re here for you”.</p><p>With an agreement to return next week at the same time and a resolute confidence to never give up, the small but dedicated group slowly disperses, fading away into the dreary Melbourne night. But not before one final message from the group’s ringleader.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“If we win this one, we’ll be back to fight for the next one. If we lose this one, we’ll be back to fight for the next one.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Rebecca Lesley knows that it’s a tough battle. She knows that all the odds are against her. But she also knows that it’s an important one, a fight that she won’t give up on until the building is in rubbles.</p><p>“It’s a battle just like any other. It’s just another battle.”</p><p>And it’s one that a select few have refused to lose.</p><p>____________________________________________________________________</p><p>@denhamsadler</p><p>Originally published in Catalyst Magazine, Issue 4, Volume 70.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f820bed3a72b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>