<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Steven Deobald on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Steven Deobald on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@deobald?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 00:51:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@deobald/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ethical Software for Everyone]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/ethical-software-for-everyone-87f485784038?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/87f485784038</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[federation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[encryption]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[open-source]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Nov 2019 10:56:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T14:43:16.514Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Can I interest you in a nutrition label?</p><p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-11-28-ethical-software-for-everyone/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><h3>Ethics! We all have a few.</h3><p>Every day, my personal ethics evolve in varying degrees. It seemed harmless to speak loudly and abrasively in my early twenties — a speech full of arbitrary and contrary words. Who was I hurting? Now I know. The increments of personal ethics evolution are slow and sometimes the work takes decades. Crossing the bridge of intoxicants, for example. On one side, a world in which I saw no harm in smoking, drinking, and encouraging others to do the same. On the other, a dark shadow of the former world: a decade spent on the far side of the earth waiting to return to the people I smoked and drank with in 2006. A decade is enough time to see both the damage and the role I played in setting it up.</p><p>Everyone will have a different set of ethics governing their opinions about topics as varied as space travel, immigration, social programs, and personal product consumption. But while most of us can only wax poetic about space travel or write angry Facebook posts about our temporary government’s temporary immigration policy, we all have nearly consummate autonomy over the behaviours we engage in and the products we buy. And in this world of individual ethics, we all tend to prefer a manageable world — a world simplified and distilled into categories we can use as meaningful approximations of our true feelings. We may choose some rough trajectories: <em>I’d like to eat less meat. I won’t buy clothes just for the sake of buying clothes.</em> But the approximations we like best are the specific ones we can point to and say <em>I am/do/buy </em><strong><em>this thing</em></strong><em>. I am vegan. I ride a bicycle. I buy GMO food.</em></p><p>Labels are helpful. They are a tool, a means of avoiding the untenable situation wherein we rebuild our ethics from first principles every single day.</p><h3>Software Ethics: How deep is the rabbit hole?</h3><p>As it turns out… pretty deep. And for most people, that depth is beyond meaningless. Even those of us who really enjoy software licensing discussions eventually get numb to the idea of filing off the edges from one more debate on ethics and legalities, largely mired in nerd-porn semantics and contexts which are impossible to faithfully reconstruct. In response to my essay on the topic (<a href="https://medium.com/siggu/eff-software-fc19e1abca46"><em>EFF Software Ethics</em></a>), even the nerdiest of my friends told me it was too long and too detailed. The difficulty is one of specificity. What does it mean for software to be “federated”? What are the nuances between “free software” and “open source”? What are the differences between the GPLv3 and the AGPLv3? And who cares?</p><p>Most people don’t care and they shouldn’t have to. But even for those of us who actually love this stuff, it would be nice to segregate the conversation. There is a world of difference between discussing your GMO preferences with your family and buying (or avoiding) GMO products at the store. That difference doesn’t really exist for the world of software ethics at the moment.</p><p>What kind of labels could we employ in the landscape of software ethics? How specific should they be?</p><h3>Veg / Non-veg: Simple, Universal, Reproducible</h3><p>There are many things to love about India but the veg/non-veg iconography is easily in my top ten, where design is concerned. What I love about it, in part, is that I have no idea where it came from. It was mandated in 2006 but has been around for much longer than that. The icons couldn’t be simpler (caveat: they’re actually a little <em>too </em>simple, as we’ll see). They are universally understood across India. And they are very easy to reproduce. Reproductions are often inconsistent: shapes and colours are slightly distorted, words are added. These mutations don’t seem to matter because the essence is always understood.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*vJHNkipSl72V9bwwCrMMgA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The failure of the veg/non-veg icons is, of course, their structure. Red/green colour blindness is common and differentiating by colour alone is a substantial iconographic mistake. The design principles can be borrowed though. Can we come up with labels for software ethics which are simple, universal, and reproducible?</p><h3>What kinds of software do we need to label?</h3><p>For the most part, software today follows a sufficiently standard format. It’s likely that I’m going to lose some people here, but I would argue that almost all software these days is a client-server architecture of some sort and that, although the advent of ubiquitous computing hasn’t quite happened yet, we are definitely progressing <em>toward</em> ubiquitous computing. That means that users have to start caring about this client-server architecture. Sorry. In the context of a conversation about software ethics, <em>client-server</em> can be replaced with the contemporary lingo of <em>app-service</em> and we’re still on the same page. (Where <em>app</em> is short for either <em>application</em> or <em>appliance</em>.)</p><p>Some quick counterexamples and defences: Operating systems? Where are the updates coming from? Microsoft, Google, Apple, RedHat, and Canonical are your service providers. Roomba firmware? If iRobot isn’t sending you over-the-air updates, they soon will be. Cryptocurrencies? P2P is the very definition of the federation endgame.</p><p>If all software is a variation of app-service, then all software has to answer to these three static, ethical queries: Are you Free? Are you encrypted? Are you federated? It is up to you to decide which of these axes define meaningful software ethics for you. Your ethics are yours. But wouldn’t it be nice if someone put a label on the box so you knew what was inside?</p><h3>The Grid: Alpha v0.1</h3><p>To review, we first want some extremely simple, (potentially) universal, easily reproducible labels. These labels should be easy to recognize at a glance, even when they are reduced to black-and-white, which means we must make them identifiable by shape in addition to colour. Optionally, they could include text in any language. Secondly, they should tell us this at-a-glance information about the three axes of software ethics: Encrypted? Free? Federated?</p><p>Let’s give it a try.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7koI7BlWYiyO2W4IySmHcw.png" /><figcaption>Software Ethics nutritional labels for you and your family. ❤</figcaption></figure><p>Similar to seeing veg/non-veg icons for the first time, these icons might not be immediately obvious. Let’s break them down:</p><p><strong>The encryption row</strong> is probably the least ambiguous I could manage. Red sadface open lock? That’s no encryption. Yellow open lock? That’s weak encryption. The three yellow categories are both the hardest to define and the most flexible. <em>Weak encryption</em> could mean many things. Maybe the encryption isn’t end-to-end. Maybe it is only available on certain channels. Maybe the code can’t be audited because it’s completely closed-source. A green lock is strong, end-to-end encryption that’s always on and completely under your control. You’re not getting a green encryption label with a red Freedom label, obviously.</p><p><strong>The freedom row</strong> gets progressively ambiguous as a software’s status improves. (Given that most software we use won’t qualify for a green badge any time soon, maybe that’s fine?) A sadface black box swimming in a red circle is proprietary, closed-source software. A yellow <a href="https://opensource.org/">OSI logo</a> is open source, with all the usual caveats attached to that term. Maybe the company that builds this software sells closed or proprietary upgrades? Maybe some of their features are hidden behind black-box services? A green swirl is Free Software that you can self-host. The green swirl is a bastardization of the Debian logo because the Debian Free Software Guidelines have an inherent network effect that software licenses applied to individual pieces of software do not. The swirl is also kind of an extension of the OSI logo, which is sort of… half a swirl? I’m obviously open to better ideas here. There’s always some confusion about self-hosting. The requirement that software can be self-hosted has <em>nothing to do with actually performing a self-host</em>. The fact that users can self-host means that <em>anyone can self-host</em> and that users will never be forcibly dependent on one government, agency, or vendor. PS: If <em>freedom row</em> leaves a bad taste in your mouth, swap it out for <em>audit row</em>. Close enough.</p><p><strong>The federation row</strong> is, in some ways, the simplest. But as most people I talk to about this are very confused as to what federation is exactly, let’s draw our lines in the sand. A red sadface circle-in-a-circle is a centralized service. A service may be free/open, easy to self-host, and fully encrypted but it can still fail this test very easily. <em>Centralization</em> is best defined in terms of what it is not: A yellow federation label with two connected service bubbles (that’s what those circles are) means that <em>services</em> can share data over a federated protocol. If a service does not do this, it is not federated at all and gets a red label. And if the lines between <em>service</em> and <em>app</em> (or server and client) begin to blur, we’d apply a green label with three service bubbles (and no little client dots). This is the world of peer-to-peer federation protocols: most blockchain implementations, Gnutella, and kin.</p><h3>Text-only Alternatives?</h3><p>My friend <a href="https://arunraghavan.net/">Arun</a> suggested that Creative Commons-style text labels would be useful as a shorthand. Similar to the <em>BY-NC-SA </em>labeling, we could have Not Encrypted, Weakly Encrypted, Strongly Encrypted; No Source, Open Source, Free Software; No Federation, Service Federation, Peer Federation:</p><blockquote>NE|WE|SE — NS|OS|FS — NF|SF|PF</blockquote><p>Looking at modern password managers, for example, Bitwarden is SE-FS-NF, KeePassX is SE-FS-NF, and 1Password is WE-NS-NF.</p><p>If we wanted to get obsessive about symmetry, we might be tempted to try Not Encrypted, Weakly Encrypted, Fully Encrypted; No Source, Weak Source, Free Software, No Federation, Weakly Federated, Fully Federated:</p><blockquote>NE|WE|FE — NS|WS|FS — NF|WF|FF</blockquote><p>Preferred naming convention? Cast your vote by mailing me a cheque.</p><h3>Let’s label some software!</h3><p>If every piece of software came with these labels, you would still need to decide which matter to you — and when. Just as we don’t attempt to max out the number of labels on our food, the goal here is not to limit yourself to software that gets three green badges. In 2019, it’s pretty unlikely that any of us want a federated password manager and so a good password manager probably gets labels like the ones we saw for Bitwarden and KeePassX. 1Password, on the other hand, rates a D-minus in software ethics. In full colour, the ratings for 1Password and Bitwarden look like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rXk0wGuf2uO6lO4Sobbd_w.png" /></figure><p>Remember that 1Password can’t even get a green badge for encryption (which they claim to be very good at) unless we can audit their code.</p><p>Let’s take a brief look at Slack?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l4cceQJQyOxsa6P-LIh4sg.png" /></figure><p>Mom won’t be happy with that report card. Moving on. This article is on Medium. What is Medium’s ethics score?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8XY2KVELXX7XjSCopa-80w.png" /></figure><p>Ugh. Okay. How about we choose a piece of software that actually earns some clean grades?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vs3idBxKDVOYfsxlxfW5jQ.png" /></figure><p>Sigh. If only Signal was actually enjoyable to use, we’d be making some progress here. But it isn’t. Signal is a chore. This brings us to another comment Arun made on this whole idea: wouldn’t it be nice if we could somehow capture a software’s <em>health</em>?</p><h3>Coda</h3><p>Software ethics isn’t enough. Despite the fact that most of the software we use every day struggles to even find its way onto the ethics spectrum, we simultaneously need to open up the conversation on ethics (with tools like the nutrition label) while moving <em>beyond</em> ethics to include other aspects of software as well.</p><p>A software’s health could be measured across any number of variables. How many active users does the software have? How many for the service? How many for the app? How many active servers exist in the federated network? How many actively maintained clients exist in the federated and peer-to-peer scenarios? How many commits-over-time are the developers making? How many of those commits are feature-building commits and how many are security-hardening commits? What is the system’s code complexity by objective metrics? What is the overall lifetime of the system? Does the UX suck? Did it suck yesterday? Is it getting better or worse?</p><p>The difficulty with all these measurements, of course, is their purely organic nature. They will all change day to day and can’t be stamped on a box, a homepage, or a Wired article. Measuring software’s health demands a real-time metrics dashboard… which means it’s beyond my pay grade. But I would love to see such a system emerge in the future.</p><p>In the meantime, enjoy these Software Ethics Nutritional Labels for evaluating the technology around you. Remix them, try them out for yourself, and tell me where they fail so they can be improved. I hope someone finds them beneficial.</p><h3>Appendix</h3><ul><li>The badge SVG can be found here: <a href="https://github.com/deobald/siggu.org/raw/master/article-content/software-ethics-badges/badges-v2.svg">https://github.com/deobald/siggu.org/raw/master/article-content/software-ethics-badges/badges-v2.svg</a></li><li>The draft SVGs and other images can be found here: <a href="https://github.com/deobald/siggu.org/tree/master/article-content/software-ethics-badges">https://github.com/deobald/siggu.org/tree/master/article-content/software-ethics-badges</a></li><li>According to this labeling scheme, Bitwarden and KeePassX are not equivalently <em>networked</em> but they are equivalently <em>federated</em>. Did I mention that these conversations can quickly devolve into nerd semantics?</li><li><a href="https://nirbheek.in/">Nirbheek</a> pointed out that the official status of the veg/non-veg symbols in India require that they are green and <em>brown</em>, not red. I think I can count on one hand the number of times I’ve seen a brown dot in a brown square, but the mandatory labels defined by the <em>Food Safety and Standards (Packaging and Labelling)</em> laws of 2006/2011 are not actually the ones I’m referring to in the <em>Veg / Non-veg</em> section. Much more interesting, in the context of this discussion, are the implicit simple symbols which were universal because of their ease of reproduction long before the laws ever came into effect.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=87f485784038" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/ethical-software-for-everyone-87f485784038">Ethical Software for Everyone</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[RFC: Hacker Villages]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/rfc-hacker-villages-45d49369bf8c?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/45d49369bf8c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hackerspaces]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[off-grid]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Nov 2019 12:03:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T13:35:34.642Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aYF2fz_rnhQYsAdWLI7rJw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The site of our Hacker Village in Canada.</figcaption></figure><p>The inevitable advent of जादूगरों का गाँव.</p><p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-11-20-hacker-villages/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><p>“Land in Canada costs <em>how much</em>?” Ragul queries me a second time. His eyes are wide and I can tell he’s asking me to confirm the cost of property in Eastern Canada because half of him doesn’t believe it.</p><p>“Yeah, I know,” I say, “$23,000 CAD for 20–30 acres is…” I pull out my phone and start punching the forex conversion into the search box but he gives me the answer off the top of his head before I can finish.</p><p>“Twelve lakhs. That’s only twelve lakhs. For <em>twenty. acres. of. land. </em>You know in India that will buy you 2000 square feet? Square feet! Maybe it will buy you one acre on some remote mountainside.”</p><p>I feel the need to backpedal a little, as if I otherwise run the risk of selling magic beans. “There’s no road, though. And no electricity or water service. It’s just a forest by the ocean. And not all Canadian provinces are that cheap.” But I could tell he was already sold on the idea, just as I was a decade earlier when I bought that little piece of Nova Scotian forest with some friends. The Hacker Ethos finds gravity not in immediate value but in <em>potential value</em> and large, undeveloped plots of land are nothing but. An empty plot of land, a blank canvas, or a system which exists only on a whiteboard — they all whisper <em>maybe this could work</em> into the ears of prospective creators.</p><p>We’ve come to Pondicherry for the weekend. We’re living 100 kilometres away in Mahabalipuram, a little temple town which nearly splits the distance between Pondicherry and Chennai. Pondi is a strange place. A French colony which only received its official independence in 1962, it is already full of vocabulary and architecture unlike anything you’ll find in the rest of India — or the rest of France. Add to this unique Tamil-French mashup the buildings of Sri Aurobindo (or the corporation which adopts his logos, I suppose) which regularly punctuate the streets, acting as a constant reminder of the nearby experimental township of Auroville, and you’re unlikely to forget that you are visiting a peculiar city indeed.</p><p>But we’re not visiting Pondicherry to drink French coffee and gawk at <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matrimandir">The Golden Golfball Temple</a>. We’re just stalking rental properties like regular schmucks and our host happens to be Ragul, a member of the Maitri Collective. When I told him we were coming to Pondicherry he insisted that Maitri host us and we happily accepted. It’s a Saturday and half a dozen people end up crashing on the floor of the Maitri building in central Pondicherry. Before we make our beds in the outer hall, an artist collective uses the inner hall as a space for a sketch class. Furniture is modest at Maitri but the inner hall has bookshelves stacked to the ceiling. The sketch class resumes Sunday morning, following the weekly meeting of the local Free Software chapter. We chat well past midnight about books, Vipassana, bootstrapped software, off-grid, and mesh networks. The next day we meet Maitri members whose current project is researching and digitizing ancient Tamil mathematics literature. It’s as if we’ve found the secret guild of art and technology in Pondicherry. A tiny hacker paradise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9T3sOI324xhAvkkJ" /><figcaption>Yes. This golden golfball.</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve been bouncing the idea around in my head for years now: a Hacker Village. Since the Maitri Collective is a rough microcosm of this idea, I thought I’d try running the idea past Ragul. It’s not an easy idea to convey, of course. <em>Hacker Village</em> has so many connotations — connotations I’d like to avoid. जादूगरों का गाँव (Wizard Village) is probably helpful terminology for many people but it’s not better for an idea to smack of robes and magic wands than electronica and DIY… just different. <em>Hacker</em> usually implies computer experts and, at worst, the limiting world of computer security experts. The word has developed a broader meaning, though. For a while, O’Reilly Media and <em>Make: Magazine</em> tried to construct a convincing replacement in <em>Maker</em>, but that word is so vague as to be almost meaningless. Rather than stretching the word <em>hacker</em> until it loses all value, we can mix it with a word like <em>wizard</em> to give it a dash of silliness and a pinch of mystery. The more images we add to the aggregate picture, the more perspectives we get, and the clearer that picture becomes.</p><p>But Ragul doesn’t require this expounding of terms. He gets it immediately. He’s been bouncing this same idea around in his head for years and has even scoped out a potential location near the Kalrayan Hills to start his own hacker village. It becomes clear as we talk that this idea isn’t our own. The idea has a core, a foundation, which is itself emergent. Since I’m not the creator of this foundation — no one is — I’ll undoubtedly get some details wrong. Consider this essay an early RFC.</p><h3>Abstract</h3><p>The idea of escaping traffic, smog, noise, and concrete seems to repeatedly surface in spheres I witness, in the flesh and on the web. There is no single motivating factor and there is no single solution. Some people just want a tree or two in their front yard. Some are exasperated by the marketing machine gun, pointed squarely at our metro areas: <em>buy this watch, drink this beer!</em> Many of us, especially in India, are literally choking on air that is more dust than oxygen.</p><p>The great cities of the world all have something special to offer. The bicycles of Copenhagen, the discourse of Kolkata, the love of San Francisco, the convenience of Bangalore. This essay contends that building a city is no longer the gargantuan task it once was. Though still an organic process, growing a new city can now begin with clear intentions: zero waste, zero pollution, plenty of flora, high value public spaces, and accommodating private spaces. The new city won’t be an unrealistic utopia. It will simply start with the best the modern world has to offer. As a bonus, you won’t need to take a metro (or cab or bike) ride covering multiple kilometres to see your best friend. They will probably live down the street.</p><h3>The tools of the villagers</h3><p>A Hacker Village, née Wizard Village, demands precisely the sort of magic with which our generation has been blessed. Computation, the foremost magic of the 21st century, is cheap and easy to perform. The recent advent of <em>pocket computing</em> (differentiated from <em>personal computing</em>, which for some recondite reason was doomed to categorize only desktop computers of the home) and the inevitability of near-term <em>ubiquitous computing</em> have forced our species’ hand on a few fronts. We don’t like software or hardware that is badly designed. “Complex” is nearly synonymous with “bad” in this context. Everyone is, consciously or not, increasingly aware that the best technology is that which has no user interface at all. Second-best is technology with almost no user interface. We have learned this before with indoor plumbing and electricity. When you turn on the tap and potable water comes out, the system is working. When anything else happens, the system is broken. Infrastructure and its interfaces are best when they are invisible. The only infrastructure we notice is the infrastructure which is either dying or suffering an adolescent growth spurt. (I will postscript, of course, that there are sinks on this planet which attempt to predict when you want water and when you don’t and that I have personally never seen one of these work. A tap is the bare minimum of the Water User Interface and hopefully always will be. Telling the machine when we require its services should always be up to us.) The technology of the hacker village will be simple and useful. Although the hacker village will be technology-heavy, it’s unlikely to be a “smart city” for the same reason it won’t have any “smart” water taps. I hope.</p><p>Paradoxically, the magic of physical utility infrastructure is more difficult to come by in the hacker village. There is a reason for this. The hacker village isn’t a Gandhian commune, setting about the task of locally regressing society back a century and building everything from scratch. Plastics and computers are hard to come by and hacker villages will need those. The village will get its computers from China just like you did. If a hacker village grows into a city one day it might build these things for itself but at the apex of humanity’s interconnectedness it’s downright childish to pull a city up by its bootstraps. Computers are easy to import from China and move around. Sewers and roads are difficult. The magic of modern physical utility infrastructure is that it can happen very quickly. Singapore, with unbelievable before-and-after photos of its skyline spanning only a single decade, is the poster child for the accelerating pace of public infrastructure. But you can see it in many cities under active development.</p><p>It is here that the Hacker Ethos and global telecommunications unite to bring us the present wave of New Grid experimentation. “Experimentation” means that no one is getting it right. If someone had really figured out this New Grid thing, off-grid, micro-grid, and smart-grid would all be products you could order off of Amazon. They’re not. The off-gridders and micro-gridders of today are the Steve Wozniaks of yesteryear, puttering around with the next big thing because it’s cool and fun. But the shrink-wrapped off-grid setup you buy from Amazon and it’s jumbo cousin, the micro-grid (which might power our hacker villages), are definitely coming. Community-sized electricity storage, whether that takes the form of a battery the size of a shipping container, molten salt, or water pumped underground at high pressure, are under development in almost every country. Power sources like solar panels and wind turbines are already off-the-shelf.</p><p>Clean water and sewer systems already exist in micro-grid and off-grid sizes, courtesy waste stabilization ponds and septic fields. So that’s handy.</p><h3>From tools, a prototype</h3><p>The final blessing bestowed upon our era is the very notion of “done.” Previous generations have fought to get more, to have more, because it was unclear if there was more to have or not. And it’s always worth trying, right? But thanks to Hans Rosling and The World Bank, we now have a system (<a href="https://www.gapminder.org/dollar-street">Dollar Street</a>) which describes when we’ve made it — as a household, village, or nationstate. Is your house a comfortable temperature, clean and unpolluted, with 24/7 utilities (water, gas, electricity, internet), a toilet, a stove, a fridge, a washing machine, and hot water to bathe? Congratulations! That’s basically it. You are “Level 4” and the scale doesn’t go any higher than that. Growth will always continue toward Level 4, generation after generation, but growth <em>beyond</em> Level 4 represents little more than greed and waste, since the returns quickly diminish.</p><p>For this reason, I have come to think of the infrastructure supporting a Level 4 house as a <em>Minimum House</em>. Once you own a Minimum House you aren’t left wanting for anything and you are free to get on with the more meaningful work of a human life: learning, exploring, building, and helping others. Examples of the Minimum House abound: Singapore government housing (which houses 80% of its population, no less), University residences for staff, and the more extreme example of the British <a href="https://www.homelessthf.org/ikozie-micro-home/">iKozie Micro Home</a>. House a village in less than Minimum Housing and you will see the citizens invest their time, energy, and money acquiring precisely that — Minimum Houses — rather than building something interesting. This is why the Minimum House is the starting point for a hacker village, where everyone is hellbent on building something interesting. An eco village of mud huts and tents won’t cut it.</p><p>The blueprint hacker village now has a goal and a path to achieve that goal: Minimum (Level 4) Houses and the cleanest infrastructure to create them. Every aspect of the path mentioned so far is limited to the material, though. We will require something immaterial to bind them.</p><h3>Who are these hackers, anyway?</h3><p>The Maitri Collective is a microcosm of the hacker village not because of infrastructure. Quite the opposite. Maitri uses their space to the absolute maximum. It is a microcosm because the Maitri ethos is the Hacker Ethos.</p><p>The Hacker Ethos, <a href="http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/729">as defined by Steven Levy</a>, has seen modernization since he transcribed it, Aṣṭādhyāyī-style, in 1984. But the core remains: Access to anything which might teach you something about the way the world works should be unlimited and total. All information must be free. Promote decentralization. And perhaps most importantly:</p><blockquote>The MIT group defined a <em>hack</em> as a project undertaken or a product built to fulfill some constructive goal but also out of pleasure for mere involvement.</blockquote><p>These rules carry corollaries. Where better to begin learning about how the world works than in your own home, using your own home as the textbook? “Where does the water come from? Where does my garbage go? What happens when the toilet flushes? How many kilowatt-hours did I consume today? How do I build it myself?” — these are the questions of the curious off-gridder, the hacker of houses. If all information must be free then it should be easy to learn the answers to these questions. And if we promote decentralization it makes sense for as many people as possible to learn the answers. Once many of us know the answers both intellectually and experientially, by reading and sharing and building our own infrastructure, we must follow the project to its logical conclusion: Don’t Repeat Yourself.</p><p>The Hacker Village won’t have any interest in hazing new citizens with a right of passage. Thus, when you arrive in 2030 the mayor won’t hand you a PDF printout of <em>how_to_build_a_house.tex</em> from 2019 and then leave you to your own devices. The intoxicating quality of hacker collectives like Maitri is the shared desire to <em>do something cool</em>. Let’s learn to paint, let’s research materials for electrical turbines, let’s map the city using open tools, let’s build a waiter robot! Doing something cool usually means doing something <em>original</em>. Building the same Minimum House, ad nauseam, clearly isn’t part of that game. Replication is the natural consequence of the Hacker Ethos. First you learn, explore, and research; then you experiment; then you build; finally, you iterate.</p><p>Iteration. The last step of Project A becomes the first step of Project B. Whether constructing a Minimum House, digging the village well, putting up point-to-point telecommunications, or buying books to stock the public library, we will want to replicate the project in the future. Doing so should be cheap and simple — or at least cheaper and simpler than it was the last time. As a consequence, after a dozen iterations perhaps, living on <a href="https://www.gapminder.org/topics/four-income-levels/">Level 4</a> in a Hacker Village should not require $1000/mo (PPP) in expenditures. Level 4 in a Hacker Village will ultimately be defined by standard of living, not superficial economics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KWyAOGrkMUdd97-yaq9jzA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The library at Maitri Collective</figcaption></figure><p>The Village will borrow other characteristics which shine brightly from hacker collectives: safety, inclusiveness, and a love of literature. We enjoyed the company of people of all stripes during our two brief days in Pondicherry. While modern corporations struggle to understand inclusiveness before etching it into employee handbooks, members of Maitri are just that — friendly, in the most unassuming of ways — and the idea of including people of any sex, age, race, caste, creed, or political leaning is felt, not read. (<em>Maitri</em> means <em>friendship</em> in any number of Indic languages.)</p><p>Perhaps <em>Maitri Village</em> is a good image to add to the existing <em>Wizard-Village-plus-Hacker-Village</em> amalgam. It is very likely that the first communal building to go up in the Maitri Village will be a <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/37707827-palaces-for-the-people">Palace for the People</a>: a public library. It is not hard to imagine Eric Klinenberg’s other social infrastructure examples popping up shortly after: parks, schools, gyms, open universities, tea houses and coffee shops. I also hope that a <a href="https://medium.com/siggu/silent-spaces-160d3a44fa3d">Silent Space</a> would appear early in the development of the village, whether a Vipassana Centre was nearby or not.</p><h3>Don’t step in the leadership</h3><p>Let’s pause for a minute to examine my dig at modern corporations because adding <em>friendship</em> to <em>wizardry</em> and <em>hacking</em> only amplifies some of our already burdensome connotations. To dissolve some of these connotations, it is informative to describe the village in terms of <em>what it is not</em>. The village isn’t an escape from society, governments, globalization, or capitalism. Whether you, a citizen of the village, love these things or hate them is irrelevant. This is the world you live in. Imagining you are starting from a different square on the board is wishful thinking and wishful thinking is a waste of time, a distraction from actually getting things accomplished.</p><p>This means there are going to be corporations in the village, big or small. There will be politics, internal and external. There will be import and export (of knowledge, if nothing else). The village will not be a hippie commune, a resort, or a sanctuary for early retirement. If the village is healthy, it will grow through the adolescence of township into adulthood: a city. If the village is unhealthy it will die.</p><p>Because cities of the future will require different kinds of corporations and different kinds of politics to survive, it is safe to assume the village will start with different kinds of corporations and different kinds of politics. Cooperatives, tech unions, federations, and neighbourhood parliaments based on Sociocracy are some good examples but many of the future incorporated entity templates don’t even exist yet. The bylaws of the village will be unfamiliar. For example, internal combustion engines and open fires are likely to be illegal. In the near future, human-operated vehicles will probably be illegal, too. The village won’t be anarchy; it will instead try to codify inevitable laws ahead of the curve. Ragul suggested we capture this with வழிகாட்டி கிராமம் (Village of Guides), adding one more limb to our aggregate.</p><p>In 2015 I described a blueprint for <a href="http://blog.deobald.ca/2015/12/bangalore-2030.html">Bangalore 2030</a> but, while I still subscribe to this ideal, it has become clear that growing into it will require the same work to happen at all scales, inside neighbourhoods and across megacities. Bangalore is a legacy megacity. It will eliminate air, water, and noise pollution — eventually. But a hacker village need not endure industrial era growing pains. In the language of software projects, Bangalore is a multi-year refactor and the village is a from-scratch rewrite.</p><p>Like many of my friends, I find Bangalore too toxic in 2019 and I’m searching for alternatives. Successful hacker villages will have their own challenges when they, too, grow to populations in the millions: digital privacy, artificial intelligence laws, and bioengineering ethics are hardly solved problems. Thankfully, hackers love solving problems.</p><h3>From blueprint to poured concrete</h3><p>When we leave Pondicherry, conversation has already shifted from the potential to the real. We start planning a trip to the Kalrayan Hills to look at the proposed site of Ragul’s Hacker Village. It’s cool there, he says. Salem, the nearest city, has hot summers but the hills and their valleys stay comfortable.</p><p>Every location has its challenges. Our property in Nova Scotia is oceanside and metal or fabric, left to the elements for even a few days, will begin to rust or rot. Canada is cold and demands indoor heat just to survive. Materials are expensive, as are tools, and hired construction is out of the question most of the time. Perhaps cheap land is the only advantage Canada has to offer. That, and Universal Healthcare.</p><p>India, on the other hand, has very expensive land but cheap materials and labour. The weather in some locations is comfortable enough to eliminate the need for heating or cooling. Instead, extreme weather comes in the form of monsoons and even a modest village will require considerable storm sewers to manage the yearly assault. Multi-year rainwater harvesting is a necessity, since global warming has completely disrupted the heartbeat of India’s climate and rainfall is no longer consistent from year to year.</p><p>There will never be a one-size-fits-all blueprint for Hacker Villages, which makes the Hacker Ethos all the more important: free and open literature, documentation, resources, and education are a hard requirement for an activity which, by its very nature, demands mashups and remixes.</p><p>I’m excited to write about these Hacker Villages as they materialize in the hills and valleys. Whether we call them வழிகாட்டி கிராமம், Maitri Villages, or जादूगरों का गाँव, I hope an increasing number of people soon call them <em>home</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uOXryAx3Tor-6SBVP3sP1w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Be gentle with the foothills when you begin your Hacker Village — this is a fragile ecosystem.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=45d49369bf8c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/rfc-hacker-villages-45d49369bf8c">RFC: Hacker Villages</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Compassion for Donald]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/compassion-for-donald-75a88f582a5d?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75a88f582a5d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vipassana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Oct 2019 11:48:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T13:09:29.899Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JcTxE0rFEhCeaOEEjDs_Jw.png" /></figure><p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-08-28-compassion-for-donald/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><p>The 2019 Canadian federal election is over. I doubt anyone feels very good about it. Not because a minority government threatens to immobilize the Canadian government. I mean, there is that. But the suffocating air of this election was far less tangible, far less quantifiable, than counted ballots. The outmoded left-right political spectrum is gasping for breath through a death rattle and, for those of us who plan to be here on the far side, it’s disgusting to watch. From the campaign trail to the leaders’ debates through to the election night speeches, our country’s assessment of this election has been summed up with a box of adjectives on a shelf. “Nasty” and “divisive” are not the adjectives we want in our box — but we need to turn off the TV and our phones for a second to figure out exactly how <em>we</em> put them there.</p><p>I arrived back in India one week ago. The political climate here hasn’t changed a great deal in the five months I was home in Canada. It would be fair to describe politics in India as “nasty” and “divisive.” In fact, it’s safe to say India’s adjective box is much like Canada’s these days. That’s surprising, given that India’s current government is led by a war criminal (or <em>state terrorist</em>, if you prefer). But Canada’s? Our federal avatar is a bumbling pretty-boy doofus. In a world where the chief is paraded around as though he or she were not a representative, but the government itself, these two fellows hardly seem comparable. Why are our two wildly disparate political environments painted in the same tones? It is perhaps because it seems there is a global movement to paint all politics in these colours. The Movement is not the toxic brew of modern, ever-present polar media and Facebook-slave-fueled data science, in the form of “free” news and entertainment and whatever sequel we are to expect from Cambridge Analytica. The Movement is us.</p><p>We tend to think of observation as a passive act, immaterial and innocuous. Whether or not the books we read and movies we watch influence our decision-making process is somehow still a point of contention among people who grew up during the overreactive days of early video games. But science, and even the most superficial self-observation, speaks quite clearly to the nature of adult neuroplasticity — you don’t need double-blind studies across multiple research labs to tell you that binge-watching <em>Breaking Bad</em> will leave you dreaming about Walter White and reflecting on his behaviour during your waking hours. Physically, emotionally, and intellectually we cannot help but digest this sensory fertilizer. Our constitution is not reflective of what we’ve consumed. Watching Joaquin Phoenix perform his danse macabre for 122 minutes of your life will not ensconce you in his suit just as eating a Happy Meal won’t throw you into a BMI category for the Morbidly Obese. Change takes time. Only through repeated exposure and constant reinforcement will the nutrients or poisons targeting the mind really take hold. Their effects are also obviously not guaranteed. But, handy for their producers, they are self-reinforcing. A well-designed TV series won’t just entertain us but it will drag us through all five seasons, achingly curious to find out what happens next. Sometimes this concoction of curiosity and craving will literally leave us feeling poisoned. <em>Perhaps I shouldn’t have watched six episodes in a row. I have an early morning meeting tomorrow.</em> But there is an inflection point where the fresh memory of sodium and fast carbohydrates competes with the unpleasant sensations associated with their very integration into our body and we find ourselves craving another dose.</p><p>If our physical cravings are sufficiently confusing in their capacity to cause us harm, in the classic one-sided abusive relationship between the addict and the object of his devotion, then our cravings for the intangible are even more bizarre. We eat up small videos, tweets, short essays, talkshow monologues. We carry this bodiless candy in our pockets all day. We reach for it first thing in the morning and it’s often the last thing we witness at night. But it is not our own craving which makes this new routine so remarkable. It is the craving of the machine, the craving of those same tweets and talkshow monologues. Yes, we want to watch — but not nearly so much as the the machine wants to be watched.</p><p>With every morsel of infotainment we consume, we are altered, bit by bit. But the object of observation is also changed. Observation is not a passive act.</p><p>So we want to watch the machine, the machine which craves our attention and will do whatever it must to receive it. When we spend this currency of attention we alter the machine, we move the market. This being a highly liquid market, it moves so quickly that it is difficult to see where the observer ends and the observed begins. Despite our universal tendency to look for agency and actors in the market, it has become clear in recent years that the market decides the actors and not the other way around. Even an actor like Cambridge Analytica is merely the byproduct of previous market movements. There is no grand conspiracy and no great puppet master behind the scenes. Without our attention, Cambridge Analytica would not exist, nor its children. We, the people of Earth (including, but not limited to, the citizens of the USA), are responsible for the advent of Donald Trump.</p><p>What we seem to have taught the machine, this gossamer network of unfederated artificial intelligence, is that we have a lust for conflict. We want an enemy who, like us, will exacerbate our artificial differences until our cognitive biases become our personal truth and our categorization of other humans by the simplest of qualities becomes a sort of Baader–Meinhof Phenomenon for personalities. We want Voldemort, Sauron, or Vader. We all know the feeling. It’s a simple feeling: <em>righteousness</em>. They are in the wrong and I am in the right. If only they could <em>see</em>.</p><p>Thanks to us, the machine gave us Donald Trump. The icon. The avatar.</p><p>Donald Trump is not special. He is merely this era’s canonical example of the market’s aggregate will, reified. He is just a man.</p><p><em>Trump</em> carries too many peculiar playing card connotations and the tone of it is too reflective of the daily portraits painted of him, as though he has any agency, as though he were even some sort of Primary Agent, that it is difficult to speak about him as a man (rather than an avatar), using that word. Let us refer to him instead as <em>Donald</em>. <em>Donald</em> was a 4-year-old boy. <em>Donald</em> was a serial killer without a high school education. <em>Donald</em> was the first diagnosed autistic. <em>Donald</em> was a duck.</p><p>Donald has problems.</p><p>Donald hurts people. He calls them names. He divides them. He encourages violent words, violent acts. He condones murder — of the very citizens he was hired to serve. He actually <em>relishes</em> the murder of anyone he can claim as an enemy. (Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, most recently.)</p><p>Donald steals. He takes what is not given, from his employer, the citizens of the United States.</p><p>Donald rapes. He has hurt women. He has touched them without their permission. He has openly admitted this, without repercussion. Without being taught right from wrong, it is hard to grow as a human being. In fact, one regresses.</p><p>Donald lies. Much of what Donald perceives to be his is borne of lies. These lies have become so frequent, so meaningless, that they fold in on themselves.</p><p>It is tempting for us to see Donald, holding such a powerful office, loudly influencing so many people (ourselves included), and acting out so violently, so frequently, as a just target for our fear, anger, and hatred. But if we extract ourselves from the equation momentarily we can reassess how we see Donald — how we observe him and how we react.</p><p>There is no technique or tool other than Vipassana which can teach a person what passing thoughts do to the psyche. As far as I’m aware, no other tool even claims to do so. Anything which would make this claim would inevitably become synonymous with, or a subset of, Vipassana: inspect the body with the mind, down to the tiniest detail and try to answer the question <em>What am I?</em> The “revelations” of this painful and difficult procedure are as banal as posters in Kindergartens or the basic texts of every religion:</p><blockquote>Do Unto Others As You Would Have Them Do Unto You. <br>Love Thy Neighbour.<br>Do not take more than is given.</blockquote><p>For this reason, one need not meditate Vipassana or know these lessons intimately to appreciate their inherent truth. When we hurt or kill someone, when we steal, when we rape, when we lie? We are harming someone else, no doubt. But we harm ourselves first and foremost. Nature itself punishes us at the deepest level. We <em>know</em> these behaviours are wrong. In the depths of self-observation the tiniest lust or the most minute anger can feel so overwhelmingly unhealthy that it makes one feel like it is causing total obliteration… destroying the mind, the body, and the soul all at once in a flood of acid and fire. Yet obliteration is not the end. We must survive this, knowing that our processes of mind and body are constant and continuous. Deep down, we feel these repercussions all the time.</p><p>So we take a step back. We put ourselves in Donald’s shoes. He doesn’t limit himself to unwholesome thoughts but will repeatedly concretize them as actions. How vile he must feel inside. How broken, how alone, how unhealthy. When he exits the stage, the world will think as little of Donald as it did before him. For all the screaming and jokes penetrating our newspapers and television and internet networks, history will not have anything of significance to say about this weak and insignificant man because there was hardly anything to say about him when he was alive. A historical footnote, he will at best present a case study for the patterns in the market of information which bred him. These mental habits of his, however, will not — can not — evaporate so easily. He will walk through every day of his short remaining life, suffering himself, rotting inside. Barring a miracle, the mind of a murdering rapist liar will become a tortured and self-mutilated mess. He will no doubt die alone and unhappy but it is the path to death which matters most.</p><p>We ought to be ashamed of ourselves.</p><p>No matter which artificial “side” of this mess we identify with, we are responsible for the genesis of an environment supportive of someone like Donald. There are others “like Donald” and if we do not work to improve this environment, there will continue to be. We need new adjectives. As long as our behaviour is best described as “nasty” and “divisive” we can’t hope to expect any better from our leaders.</p><p>When we mock Donald, we mock the weak. He is a weak man. If we consider him beneath us then we debase ourselves with our patronizing, comedic criticisms. Such a broken man should not be a source of entertainment but a source of pity. A source of compassion. We can learn to use his example to begin taking healing steps, to unwind our own anger, and to redirect the energy of a global consciousness spinning out of control.</p><p>Donald deserves your attention only where it serves to teach him. At this stage in his life it is unlikely he will ever learn how deeply he is hurting himself through his own actions (though we can hope — and there is a very real possibility of him attending a Vipassana course in prison) but he can learn from punishment. He should be punished for the crimes he has committed — and they are many. He, like every person on this Earth, deserves the patience of justice. Examine his behaviours. Punish the behaviours which break the law. Vengeance, anger, hatred, and ill-will do nothing to serve this cause.</p><p>While Donald temporarily holds the office of the President of the United States, pay attention to the President’s behaviours only as they are relevant to you. Start with zero and work upward. Recognize that it was your attention which put him in this position of disproportionate power in the first place. If you think that perhaps he is on the receiving end of too much of your attention, you are probably right. Stop.</p><p>As you inevitably encounter more emergent actors “like Donald,” practice patience and walk away when you need space for yourself. I can tell you from personal experience that spending half a year offline will show you how very <em>little</em> changes in this span of time, and how much less our observation and influence matters. The less you pay attention, the easier it will be for you to know when your attention is essential. A world experiencing armageddon every day will not recognize the harbinger of true armageddon before it is too late. Remind yourself that attention is the currency so you also remember to keep some for yourself.</p><p>The disappointing Canadian Federal Leaders’ Debate (in English) held weeks before the election contained perhaps one small glimmer of hope for us and our future leaders, from Elizabeth May:</p><blockquote>[L]et me just say up front I think leadership is service. I think the thing that makes a good Prime Minister is recognizing that we’re public servants. We haven’t won some kind of lotto. We don’t get to lord it over everybody. We’re here as your employee, and we want to work. And I have a little quibble with our introduction tonight saying who will get “invited” back. It’s not to be <em>invited</em> to go to Parliament; it’s to sign up to work and to be a public servant. I believe in service leadership.</blockquote><p>Those who serve themselves deserve your compassion. It is only those who serve the public who deserve your attention in a democracy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75a88f582a5d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/compassion-for-donald-75a88f582a5d">Compassion for Donald</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I started meditating… now what?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/i-started-meditating-now-what-dc9f05d44cf3?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dc9f05d44cf3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anapanasati]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vipassana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Oct 2019 16:29:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T12:55:48.002Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-08-21-i-started-meditating-now-what/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><p>Two weeks ago, a friend struck up a conversation with me about his meditation practice. His query was</p><blockquote>Hi Steve</blockquote><blockquote>I started meditating like a month ago. Nothing fancy, just sitting down and observing my breath. I did it because my anxiety was really, really bad and I couldn’t sleep at all most nights. It was horrible. At first the meditation made no difference. But then things started improving. Now after a month, I can get reasonable sleep on most days, and really good sleep once in a while And even on days I don’t sleep, my anxiety is not as bad as it used to be. This is great and I want to do it forever. Should I be reading something? I don’t want to get apps or make things more complicated than they need to be.</blockquote><p>…to which I replied with my standard logorrheic brain dump. Eventually, I got my ideas across but he suggested that I sit down and focus those thoughts so that the next person could simply read a coherent article.</p><h3>Apps</h3><p>There are few things in this world which make less sense shrink-wrapped into an app than a meditation practice, especially when your practice is in its early phases. I’d strongly recommend avoiding apps with two notable exceptions.</p><p>First, if you are the sort of person who benefits from the gamification of activities or a supportive community, you might find an app helps you stay on track with your practice. My friend’s practice has been self-sustaining, but for many people that simply isn’t the case. I can’t name an acute issue (like insomnia or anxiety) my practice resolves. It makes my whole life better, like exercise, sleep, and vegetables. But for that same reason, in the early days, I was often quite willing to neglect it. Initially I would meditate to a one-hour timer in my phone’s Clock app but I found that both the cute gongs and the supportive community in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insight_Timer">Insight Timer</a> app helped me maintain a daily practice, even if only a little.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/322/1*AZ1cy5L8e0FFySZtiComMw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Insight Timer UI, once upon a time.</figcaption></figure><p>The second case is that of specific practices with specific apps which support that particular practice. In the case of Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction (MBSR) there are …three?… <a href="https://www.mindfulnessapps.com/the-apps">official apps</a>. Why three is beyond me. Why they cost money is also beyond me. But if MBSR is your thing, I guess you can dish out $10 a pop for these things. In my case, there is a <a href="https://www.dhamma.org/en/about/mobile-app">dhamma.org app</a> which offers basic Anapana (breath) meditation instruction for users who haven’t taken a 10-day course and about a dozen one-hour recorded meditation periods for people who have taken a course. I do use the dhamma.org app for one fairly boring feature: it tracks my meditation periods so I can honestly answer the question “how often do I meditate?” for myself.</p><p>The reason I hesitate to recommend apps to anyone is because of the risks posed by learning from an app. Apps are, more often than not, designed to sell you something… and your meditation practice isn’t something you should entrust to the base instincts of capitalism. Treat meditation like you would a new drug prescription. As with drugs, you can really harm yourself — don’t self-medicate. Find a flesh-and-blood teacher you trust. Then if the system of meditation he or she has taught you is augmented by an app, by all means, make use of that app.</p><h3>Books</h3><p>Unlike apps, which I think can create real problems for the new meditator very early on, books tend to have the opposite effect. Every book you read, meditation-related or not, adds tools to your meditation repertoire. Although there are a few meditation books I’ve read from authors who indulge in mystifying the reader, pointless handwaving, or self-indulgence, they’re usually easy to spot in the first half a dozen pages. I’ll reproduce the shortlist I gave my friend and then explain it, but first I first feel I need to strike off two items I often see people mistakenly reading in hopes of understanding meditation, Buddhism, or Buddhist practices.</p><p>When I first started meditating I naturally started getting interested in Buddhism. Turns out, most fiction written about Buddhism is pretty crappy. The aforementioned mistakes are <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddha_(manga)"><em>Buddha</em></a><em>, </em>the manga series by Osamu Tezuka, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siddhartha_(novel)"><em>Siddhartha</em></a> by Herman Hesse. These writings both tell the life story of Siddhartha Gautama and, in that respect, they are perfectly enjoyable. Buddhist mythology need not be confined to stories scrawled in Pāli or Tibetan. The danger both works present is in their painfully inaccurate interpretation of Gautam Buddha’s teachings. <em>Buddha</em> relies on repeated imagery of “the interconnectedness of all things” and <em>Siddhartha</em> falls even further with a meaningless interpretation of non-dualism which equates a man and a rock. These books will teach you nothing about meditation or the Buddha’s teachings.</p><p>The shortlist is obviously flawed and incomplete, but I may try to revise it as I come across work I wish I’d had when I started meditating.</p><h4>Practice:</h4><ul><li>Way to Ultimate Calm (Webu Sayadaw)</li><li>Mindfulness in Plain English (Henepola Gunaratana)</li><li>Tao Te Ching (Gia-fu Feng or Victor H. Mair translations)</li><li>Nothing Special (Beck)</li><li>Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind (Suzuki)</li><li>Not Always So (Suzuki)</li></ul><h4>Practical Theory:</h4><ul><li>The Doors of Perception / Heaven and Hell (Huxley)</li><li>Altered Traits (Goleman and Davidson)</li><li>The Art of Living (Hart)</li></ul><h4>Philosophy:</h4><ul><li>Meditations (Marcus Aurelius)</li><li>Letters from a Stoic (Seneca)</li><li>In The Buddha’s Words (Bikkhu Bodhi)</li><li>The Timeless Way of Building (Alexander)</li><li>Finite and Infinite Games (Carse)</li></ul><p>This list requires some explanation. It exists on a spectrum and is ordered within the sub-lists on that same spectrum. At the top are some of the most practical meditation-specific books a meditator might look to for inspiration. At the bottom are books which do not deal with meditation directly but lend themselves to readings which will certainly boost a meditator’s analysis of what she is learning in meditation and perhaps provide guidance in the space between the mundane and the supramundane.</p><p><em>The Way to Ultimate Calm</em> is a collection of talks given by Webu Sayadaw in his humble monastery to lay pupils. His teaching is direct and unambiguous yet warm and full of his sense of humour, even when translated from Burmese.</p><p><em>Mindfulness in Plain English</em> has its issues. My caveat is to disregard his advice regarding bodily sensations. Most of the book deals with breath meditation and it provides plenty of background for that. If and when you want to start working with bodily sensations, attend a Vipassana course or a Zen sesshin so you can do so under the guidance of a trained teacher.</p><p>Few modern interpretations of the <em>Tao Te Ching</em> label it a manual for meditation, but I find it hard to read any other way. It’s paradoxes present the reader with meaningful koans which work on many levels and hidden in its eighty-one pages are the true “secrets” of meditation:</p><blockquote>Controlling the breath causes strain.<br>Can you be as a newborn babe?<br>Are you able to do nothing?</blockquote><blockquote>…</blockquote><blockquote>Misfortune comes from having a body.<br>Without a body, how could there be misfortune?</blockquote><p>Obviously, reducing one’s breathing to that of a newborn child and then using it to erase the body is… easier said than done. But there are many pages of the <em>Tao Te Ching</em> I have revisited over the years and found to express profound ideas in timeless language. My caveat with the <em>Tao Te Ching</em> is to ensure you do not pick up a Stephen Mitchell translation. Despite being the most common (as it seems he’s translated it dozens of times) it is easily the worst.</p><p><em>Nothing Special</em> may not pertain to the beginner’s practice yet, but it does a fantastic job of answering some of the weirder questions which come up repeatedly during meditation practice. Beck is a straight-shooter and refuses to introduce mundane, surface-level paradox into her Zen teaching.</p><p><em>Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind</em> and <em>Not Always So</em> are not so straightforward and can, at times, border on the sort of mysticism that Zen tends to engender in its teachers. They are comprised of essays and talks, however, and you can probably pick up any one of them, read through it in a matter of minutes, and decide whether or not Suzuki is right for you.</p><p>The books in the “Practical Theory” category are more diverse and I wouldn’t say the three of them share much in common beyond their category. Huxley’s work is essential reading, in my opinion, for capturing Homo Sapiens’ global environment. Why does every culture drink? Why does the world seem to narrow and solidify with each passing year of human life? Why do humans seek something greater, in religion or spirit or booze or psychedelics or sleep deprivation or fasting or self-mutilation or meditation? Huxley has invested an inordinate number of days of his life attempting to answer these questions and his theories are worthy of consideration.</p><p><em>Altered Traits</em> is far away from Huxley’s work but just as useful. The scientifically-minded will find solace in another lifetime of effort poured into the difficult science behind meditation. The author’s prefer the results of quantitative research performed with active controls and their standards are strict enough to disqualify all but 57 of the world’s roughly 8000 major meditation studies until now. There is hard science behind meditation and this book is the nexus.</p><p><em>The Art of Living</em> is in a third category altogether. The theoretical aspects of Vipassana meditation, given as evening lectures during a 10-day course, have been condensed into this book. Available for free as both a PDF and audiobook, it’s perhaps worth reading before attending your first Vipassana course… but I wouldn’t count on it. I read this book before attending my first Vipassana course and it did little but confuse me. A Vipassana course is almost ridiculously systematic and the flow of these lectures follows that systematic teaching. Without the practice, they don’t mean much. [As a side note, the phrase “The Art of Living” was, uh, borrowed by Ravi Shankar (a student of S.N. Goenka’s) after he decided to water down, Hindu-ify, and commercialize the meditation he’d learned. Ravi Shankar’s organization has nothing to do with this book or Vipassana.]</p><p>On to philosophy.</p><p>Marcus Aurelius’ <em>Meditations</em> is not really about “meditating” in this sense, but it’s wholly applicable. Meditation itself is pretty… boring and straightforward. Follow breath, accept whatever is distracting you as being okay, come back to breath, repeat. It’s the outcomes that are interesting and I think Aurelius captures quite a few of those very well. <em>Letters From a Stoic,</em> similarly.</p><p><em>In The Buddha’s Words</em> is more of a day-to-day manual. For those of us who were largely ignorant of Buddhist… anything… before we started meditating, <em>In The Buddha’s Words</em> captures some very simple aspects of everyday life which do, oddly enough, come up in meditation. The Buddha wanted you to meditate, sure. But he also wanted you to do the dishes, brush your teeth, and give gifts to your friends and family. For those of us caught up in meditation it can become easy to forget about some of the basics that meditation is supposed to bring us back to and this book is a handy reminder.</p><p><em>The Timeless Way of Building</em> is ostensibly a book about architecture but it reads like a bible. In the leaves of this wonderful little work of art are hidden instructions for optimizing the surface area of strawberry slices to maximize flavour. And other stuff. Like <em>Doors of Perception</em>, this book stands at the nexus of our environment and our innermost psychology and I couldn’t recommend it more highly.</p><p><em>Finite and Infinite Games</em> was my most debated addition to the list but as many meditation experiences are entirely ineffable, one needs to look to literature which approaches the problem from a completely different angle. If you start reading this and it doesn’t strike you, <em>Winnie The Pooh</em> and <em>The Little Prince</em> make acceptable stand-ins.</p><h3>Teachers</h3><p>I gave my friend some specific recommendations regarding meditation centres and one zendo near Bangalore, but I realize that those suggestions won’t apply to most people reading this. My general find-a-teacher advice is to start with a Vipassana course and work your way backward from that. You won’t find an experience deeper or more intense than Vipassana, but that’s not to say it’s the best or only practice you should bother with… just that it will take you to the depths of meditation so you can decide how deep you want to go, long term. I have a number of friends who have sensibly chosen the Zen path and if you don’t feel ready (or able) to attend a Vipassana course, a Zen sesshin is a valuable experience and a good opportunity to decide whether the local teacher is someone you want to entrust your practice to.</p><p>There are also many worthwhile teachers teaching Samatha (Anapana) and Vipassana meditation at a different pace but it becomes increasingly difficult to help someone find an appropriate teacher as the teachings become less and less systematic.</p><p>I hope this little blurb has been of use to you! I would love to hear feedback on the book list and other recommendations. Take care.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dc9f05d44cf3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/i-started-meditating-now-what-dc9f05d44cf3">I started meditating… now what?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Silent Spaces]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/silent-spaces-160d3a44fa3d?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/160d3a44fa3d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[urban-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Mar 2019 09:49:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T12:37:53.822Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M01APcmSsxabCGnE4unUpg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>How often do we experience real silence?</em></p><p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-03-01-silent-spaces/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/universal-spaces-d0e0110a0ccc"><em>Universal Spaces</em></a> was written out of necessity. There is nothing profound about the idea of universal spaces — spaces without any form of exceptional availability — but no preexisting terminology satisfies the requirement of defining spaces only in terms of that quality. Universal spaces require an identity, something we can point to when we presuppose them as a superset of <em>Silent Spaces</em>.</p><p>It is quickly becoming cliché to attack contemporary human habitats as a hellish landscape: cities screaming incessantly in the tone of exploding fossil fuels and painted in the colours of technological overstimulation. But it is no less true for these repeated acknowledgements. Rather, this points to our acceptance of our noisy, intrusive world. The volume differs from neighbourhood to neighbourhood and country to country but at one volume or another we have come to expect noise pollution as a default characteristic of our environment.</p><p>A Silent Space is a universal space with the single purpose of turning the volume down to zero. It exists so its visitors may experience silence. To meditate. This is a recursive definition where meditation means any silent and introspective activity. Whether one adopts the Stoic definition of meditation, of deep and penetrating thought, or the religious definition of solitary prayer, or the attention-based definition of intentional practice, a Silent Space exists for the purpose of meditation. Silence is a prerequisite of meditation.</p><h3>The home as a Silent Space</h3><p>By dictionary definitions alone, <em>universal spaces</em> and <em>silent spaces</em> are self-evident. Due to this obvious nature, a Silent Space may not seem special at first. For example, people are often tempted to point to a library as a silent space. A library or a park is a <em>quiet</em> space, not a <em>silent</em> space. As there are many spaces which are nearly universal spaces, there are many (perhaps many more) spaces which are nearly Silent Spaces.</p><p><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/79766.A_Pattern_Language"><em>A Pattern Language</em></a> describes a number of such locations. Patterns such as <em>Sacred Sites</em>, <em>Quiet Backs</em>, <em>Holy Ground</em>, <em>Common Land</em>, <em>Zen View</em>, <em>Tree Places</em>, and <em>Garden Seat</em> all speak to something adjacent to Silent Spaces. However, each of these architectural patterns adds or subtracts something from unadulterated silence (or unadulterated universality). Christopher Alexander’s writing highlights comfort and habitability as the crux of good design and therefore frequently paints images of the home, so let’s start there.</p><p>First we must acknowledge that almost no one’s home is a universal space. The home, by its very nature, tends to be an incredibly exclusionary place. When we are not in our home it is usually empty. We return home to find solitude and, once there, we invite only those with whom we want to share the space. Some homes are more universal than others, of course. During the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maharashtra_floods_of_2005">Mumbai Floods</a> and the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_South_Indian_floods">Chennai Floods</a> many households opened their doors to complete strangers, offering them food and shelter. My mother once ran into some cross-country cyclists at the grocery store and invited them home to stay the night. A friend’s mother recently said, as we were leaving her house after a week of her hospitality, “you too are our children — you are welcome in our house any time.” I can think of many people capable of extraordinary generosity which far outstrips what I will ever achieve in my life. But most households do not open their door to the general public.</p><p>Universality is a spectrum with binary folds: Universality is on one side and Discrimination is on the other. Even though private homes are fully within the discriminatory half of this binary, there are increments within this half which inch them toward universality. It is in these less discriminatory homes that we see the tension between silence and universality; as one’s home becomes more welcoming and more universal it tends to become less silent. More people often mean more noise, more politics, more jokes, more music.</p><p>Charlotte Joko Beck writes in <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/551604.Nothing_Special"><em>Nothing Special</em></a><em> </em>about a story she tells her students, a small pseudo-allegory involving her meditation practice. She sits in front of a locked door in the attic, meditating. After many hours of meditation, the door will finally open so she can go inside but she finds it only leads downstairs to her front room. She goes back up to the attic to find the door is locked again and she must start all over. However, every time the door unlocks and she passes through it there is more life in the front room. More guests, more family, more activity, and more shared experiences. The door represents the challenges she experiences in meditation but the guests are literal and the attic may very well be where she meditates — a silent space within her home. I do love this allegory but it leaves me to wonder how often these guests are welcomed into the attic.</p><h3>My first Silent Space</h3><p>Have you ever walked past a prayer room in an airport? They are usually tucked off in a remote corner of the terminal, hidden under escalators or down an unmarked hallway that seems covered in an invisible <em>Staff Only </em>caveat. Have you ever wondered what they’re like inside or what goes on in them?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uIc6T2L8dCI7inIy_X1cBw.png" /></figure><p>The common prefix “multi-faith” always intrigued me but, having no faith to speak of, I could never bring myself to even sneak a peak through the door. That is, of course, until I learned how to meditate. Meditating at home can be difficult simply because it is home. Puttering, exercise, books, or a pot of tea all sound a great deal easier and more enjoyable than the hour of hard work meditation usually implies. But airports are bright, loud, uncomfortable places. I rarely want to read or write in an airport and every sip of tea just reminds me how much more likely a bathroom break during the flight will be thanks to my small caffeine indulgence. My first Silent Space was a multi-faith prayer and meditation room during an eight-hour layover and it wasn’t silent at all.</p><p>First of all, the space was divided in a way I found peculiar. Near the door there was an inviting plaque insisting I could use the room as long as I remained silent. The plaque had a large graphical ring of all the world’s religious logos enveloping a cartoon Earth. It included the standard entries plus more esoteric religions like Zoroastrianism, Taoism, and Bahá’í. There were some logos I didn’t recognize. All faiths were welcome — including no faith at all. Between the inclusion of the word “meditation” in the room’s title and the explicit mention of the faithless (like me) I was convinced the space would be functional for the purposes of secular meditation. But as I took off my shoes and walked in, I found the room divided into three clear sections: Islamic male, Islamic female, and Generic Christianity. I really didn’t belong in any of those categories but I could find a spot to sit cross-legged by process of elimination: I’m a man and the section for Christians was full of chairs so I defaulted to sitting on a rug on the male Muslim side. I was the only one in there anyway and I figured it didn’t matter a great deal.</p><p>I was half an hour into meditating when people started to trickle in. I heard some women whispering quiet prayers on the other side of the curtain. I heard a man come in and lie down for a nap, despite signs all over the room declaring <em>NO SLEEPING</em> in bold type. Someone’s mobile phone rang and he quickly silenced it. My foot hurt. This meditation was more difficult than I’d anticipated but it was completely disrupted when the prayer battle started.</p><p>My meditation was already in a shamble of paranoid thought (<em>am I offending anyone? should I not be sitting on this rug? will someone ask me to leave?</em>) when the volume went up on the Christian side. A prayer suddenly became substantially louder from over there and a fire-and-brimstone epic, probably from the <em>Old Testament</em> but possibly from <em>Revelations</em>, began to take shape. My eyes were closed so I wasn’t sure how many people I was sharing my third of the room with but it included at least one Muslim man who wasn’t having any of this crap. His prayers became both louder and more musical in an attempt to dwarf the fellow reading his favourite biblical passage on the far side of the room. The haunting musical chants beside me were set upon by Christianity’s weaponry of prayer: repeated crescendo. Phrases like <em>And God said unto him!</em> were at a near-shout now, flanked by a false nadir of prayer that was equally haunting and shouted just-quietly-enough-so-you-know-this-is-the-quiet-part.</p><p>This continued. By this point I had a smile on my face and I’d completely forgotten about my foot as I couldn’t believe that <em>this</em> was what went on in these multi-faith prayer rooms, a hilarious rap battle of belief structures bundled up in scripture. <em>They should sell tickets! This is a thousand times more interesting than anything else that’s going on in the airport,</em> I thought. I was convinced my meditation experiment had failed but the prayers eventually died down and most people left. The timer on my phone gave a little gong and I opened my eyes to see a middle-aged man praying silently with his head on the floor and his son staring at me, mind cranking away behind the round whites of his eyes, visibly bewildered at my presence. <em>I don’t know what I’m doing in this room either, kid.</em></p><p>I put my shoes on and went to go find a cup of tea.</p><h3>The secrecy of Silent Spaces</h3><p>It is by design that an airport’s “prayer room” or “meditation room” is hard to find. In the same way that universal spaces often give way to Lesser Universal Spaces, Lesser Silent Spaces — quite common and relatively easy to find — are usually protected by a religion. Because airport prayer rooms would likely come under a lot of flak from the New Atheists and adjacent belief systems if they weren’t deemed universal, there is usually a plaque declaring them as such. The New Atheists, with their arbitrary and academic interest in the universality of public spaces, get their way and atheists of all statures rarely set foot in the prayer room… everyone wins. But the airport shoves the chapels, prayer rooms, and meditation rooms in remote corners with minimal signage just to make sure heathens aren’t tempted to spend their layover sullying a silent space.</p><p>In my experience it’s a rare occurrence to find the meditation room from airport maps, google maps, or signage. Years after that first prayer room experience, I have tried to find the meditation room in every airport, even if I don’t have time to use it. This exercise usually requires speaking to the Information Desk and in some cases even they won’t know where it is.</p><p>The airport example again speaks to the tension between the silence of a space and its universal nature. Democratization is expensive and the currency is comfort. An airport meditation room is technically universal but hidden in such a way as to discriminate against anyone who isn’t determined to find it. This is necessary. As systems exist to prevent patrons from changing a bicycle tire in a public library, systems exist to prevent patrons from making noise in a Silent Space.</p><p>But society’s classic spaces for silence take this discrimination to the extreme. While most religious buildings welcome all visitors, the institutions which own those properties and support these visits usually prefer visitors who already wear their logo. There are exceptions. Sri Lankan Buddhist temples are not intimidating in the same way temples from other Buddhist sects are. Very old churches and temples may transition, at least in part, from religious space to historical landmark — yet retain a silence rule, written or not. The Bahá’í Lotus Temple in Delhi welcomes all visitors for silent meditation and contemplation. But in general, the silent spaces of religions have a certain level of secrecy to them even when they are built in plain sight.</p><p>Many other Lesser Silent Spaces choose to do away with universality entirely. Democratizing a space, to any degree, comes at an expense. But thrift in the currency of comfort saddles visitors with other costs in the realms of economy and status. If you are willing to dispense with universal access, your silence is easier to maintain. Build a spa, resort, or themed hotel. Alternatively, build a hidden commune with hippie ideals, a mysterious and uninviting donation-based permaculture farm, or an invite-only sanctuary.</p><p>The tension between silence and universal access is real and the choice to make a silent space exclusive is understandable. Lesser Silent Spaces need not be condemned. However, as our collective and individual worlds close in on us, from the street and from our phones, we need to look for Silent Spaces which choose to exist as selflessly and as virtuously as the humble public library.</p><p>As with libraries, access must exist in every town and neighbourhood. If libraries are the antidote for illiteracy, silent spaces are the antidote for noise. The weight of illiteracy is linear. Noise, on the other hand, burdens society with its multiplicative nature. Noise first accumulates, then escalates, stacking sound on sound is an arms race, competing to be heard. If a horn can’t be heard over the diesel engine of a truck, we get a louder horn. If our friends can’t hear us over the jackhammering and traffic, we shout into our phones. The city. Nowhere is the antidote of silence so desperately needed.</p><h3>Noise poison and the city</h3><p>Try <a href="https://www.google.com/search?ei=pKZiXNneHtrb9QPBtZToBQ&amp;q=silent+spaces">googling for “silent spaces”</a>. The results are enlightening… and a little sad. There are a number of noble endeavours listed such as parks and community projects which endeavour to provide citizens with a space for silence in urban spaces. Dig through these websites, however, and the limitations of these projects emerge. First in expectations of the spaces themselves:</p><blockquote>How different might life be if green places for silent reflection were easily accessible to us all? … For a couple of hours each week, visitors to these quiet areas were invited to switch off from technology and to stop talking.</blockquote><p>And then of the visitors’ requirements:</p><blockquote>Even as little as five minutes will help us to enjoy the restorative benefits of being peaceful in a green place.</blockquote><p>The assumptions that a Silent Space will be effective on a highly restricted schedule or that it must exist outdoors both have obvious failings. Making time for silence is hard enough for most people; forcing visitors’ schedules to align themselves with the “silent time” schedules of their local park is untenable. Outdoor spaces, particularly green spaces, have myriad admirable qualities (many of which are described in impeccable detail by Alexander in <em>A Pattern Language</em>) but… sometimes it rains. Even a twenty-four-hour Silent Space is of restricted use if it has no indoor component. Lastly, the idea that silence only needs to be available in the same five-minute doses in which we receive YouTube videos is obviously insufficient for those who require it in minimums of one hour. While these silent spaces are imperfect they are still Universal Silent Spaces — and any city with such spaces benefits from them.</p><p>Returning to our google search, we don’t need to scroll far to find truly dystopian interpretations of “silence”: <a href="https://www.silentspace-oad.com/">This eponymous noise-masking device</a> for shared office spaces listens to the noise level in the office and generates <em>more white noise</em> to mask the din. This is not progress. This is escalation.</p><p>I have come to think of the usual term <em>noise pollution</em> in other terms: <em>noise poison</em> and <em>noise weapons</em>. Labelling urban noise as <em>pollution</em> brings up the wrong connotations: self-victimization, othering, and blame. Pollutants are abstract and they don’t immediately identify themselves with those who suffer their consequences. Poisons hurt us and we need to spend as little time with them as possible. Weapons hurt others and we need to wield them as conservatively as possible. When it comes to noise, we need to stop hurting ourselves and we need to stop hurting those around us.</p><p>I am in a street-side cafe. I can hear a bird, a phone ringing, a business conversation in Hindi, a phone call in Kannada, an angle grinder in a construction site across the road, the azaan from a nearby masjid, the putter of a small lorry, the prolonged and violent honk of an impatient but otherwise impotent taxi, and —miraculously— the flutter of leaves in the tree beside me. The sound of the city tells me that it is alive. Commerce is happening, people are engaged in their daily activities and the neighbourhood throbs and hums with the work of automata within this superorganism. Even a city as scattered and chaotic as Bangalore is beautiful and tempting. There are very good reasons thirteen million people live here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y1WsjYhLq19LuqjKdFBfRw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The tree beside me, a construction site in the background</figcaption></figure><p>But the city is poisoning us. Day and night, shouting, honking, bells, political rallies, religious festivals, two-stroke and diesel engines pound on the windows. We get to work and put in earphones to drown out loud phone calls and conversations (or, god forbid, turn on the office noise-masking device). We get home and poison ourselves with Netflix. The sound is incessant. Since the dose makes the poison, we simply need to dilute it. As we become less poisoned, we will be less tempted to inflict this poison on others. If we want to dilute the poison for everyone, even selfishly, so that society’s reciprocation mirrors our own and all the weapons of noise are dulled, then the space without the poison must be available to everyone.</p><p>The antidote must be universal.</p><h3>Meditation Centres</h3><p>It is almost impossible to identify true Silent Spaces in our cities, save a few sectarian, albeit universally welcoming, examples. Most spaces which happen to be silent are simply not universal.</p><p>Meditation centres are a collective exception; spaces designed for meditation are spaces designed for silence. Quite a few fall into the trap of sectarianism, and thus exclusivity, or part-time silence, filling other times with festivals and noise, but spaces designed for the singular activity of silent meditation tend also toward universality. Silent Zendos and Vipassana Centres are good examples but Vipassana Centres are more consistent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S6RD31OUYUmmc504t2a6Aw.png" /></figure><p>Vipassana centres around the globe are designed in the same way, run entirely on donations and volunteer efforts. Courses are free and anyone is welcome to apply to take an introductory 10-Day course to learn how to meditate. All Silent Spaces come with restrictions and this is the key restriction of a Vipassana Centre: you must know how to meditate as an old student in Vipassana to make free use of the centre. In fact, the restrictions of Vipassana Centres are actually a bit stricter than this. They remain universal spaces, however, because they are strict in terms of their uses, not their users. <em>Silence</em> is escalated to <em>Noble Silence</em>. Not only is the meditation hall of a Vipassana Centre free of talking and phones, Noble Silence forbids touching, eye contact, reading, writing, and bodily noises.</p><p>Because of this strict focus on a precise definition of silent and an individual form of meditation, the universality of formal meditation centres is far from perfect. If I need a couple of hours to think deeply about a difficult problem in silence, a Zendo or a Vipassana Centre is not the space for it. Thankfully, not every Silent Space must incorporate these strict rules. Meditation centres provide us with an architectural aspiration. Their extreme example is a template of what humanity will soon need to build into in every neighbourhood of every town or city.</p><h3>A Canonical Silent Space</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-2fjEFmTQ4QU5WGx6dTKcA.png" /><figcaption>The canonical Silent Space</figcaption></figure><p>The canonical Silent Space is almost painfully obvious but it does have some distinct and non-negotiable characteristics. There must be:</p><ol><li>Signage</li><li>Sound barriers</li><li>A building</li></ol><p>Signage should be posted in clear view, in all relevant languages, explaining unambiguously that visitors are in a Silent Space. In Bangalore, such translations of the local Kannada would definitely include Hindi, Tamil, and English. It would be advisable to include Telugu, Marathi, and Malayalam. Clarity and disambiguation is the aim of such translations. The level of detail depends on the space. The large, one-word <em>SILENCE</em> sign at the beginning of this article was enough to keep anyone from speaking, running, clapping, or using their phones when we visited the Theosophical Society Gardens, where I took that photo. If the space is meant to elevate silence from simply external to internal, disallowing physical bodily contact, sleeping, or reading, it should mention this explicitly.</p><p>There will be little debate about the fact that flora make the best sound barriers. Most architects of Silent Spaces surround them with trees, perhaps constructing walls around the trees, often making the route into the Silent Space indirect to prevent sound from entering. When the land available to the Silent Space is limited, recessing the entire space into the ground and adding shrubbery to trees helps dampen the sound from nearby roads and buildings. The internals of the Silent Space might include additional greenery or outdoor seating.</p><p>When designing a Silent Space, it would be wise to exploit any of the adjacent patterns from <em>A Pattern Language</em>. Shelter for the space suggests at least two obvious patterns: <em>Sacred Sites</em> and <em>Holy Ground</em>.</p><blockquote>Whether the sacred sites are large or small, whether they are at the center of the towns, in neighborhoods, or in the deepest countryside, establish ordinances which will protect them absolutely — so that our roots in the visible surroundings cannot be violated.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/305/1*IwDUQQCnddO7Y1e7Qr_8ZA.png" /></figure><blockquote>…. And above all, shield the approach to the site, so that it can only be approached on foot, and through a series of gateways and thresholds which reveal it gradually — <em>Holy Ground (66)</em> ....</blockquote><p><em>Holy Ground</em> helpfully complements, and expands on, this idea. In the <em>Holy Ground</em> pattern, multiple sound barriers are elevated to thresholds which provide an intuitive understanding that the space is silent and demands a visitor’s respect:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/365/1*S38k4De7rw-mpbv7pB_pXA.png" /></figure><blockquote>In each community and neighborhood, identify some sacred site as consecrated ground, and form a series of nested precincts, each marked by a gateway, each one progressively more private, and more sacred than the last, the innermost a final sanctum that can only be reached by passing through all of the outer ones.</blockquote><p>Alexander’s patterns leave it up to the imagination of the final architect to determine what belongs in at the centre of a <em>Sacred Site</em>, the innermost sanctum of a <em>Holy Ground</em>. We do not. At the centre of a Silent Space is the location of maximum silence: a building for meditation. As simple as a small pavilion or as impressive as a full-blown temple or meditation hall, the specifics of the building do not matter. If it protects meditators from the elements and adds to the diffusion of sound, it serves its purpose.</p><p>A universal meditation hall in a universal silent space is best left unadorned — no logos, no sculptures, no paintings. If these decorations are added, try to keep them to a minimum or you soon risk ostracizing potential visitors. Think of meditation rooms in airports — include features which feel inclusive and avoid those which give preference to a particular philosophy, belief, dogma, or sect. Chairs, floor mats, and cushions are necessary seating. A statue of Buddha or Ganesha serves no practical purpose.</p><p>Gandhian economics are dead and at no point will society in the large turn back to a simple agrarian lifestyle in the hills, no matter how attractive or romantic this may seem. A few of us may run away to join the <a href="https://onestrawrevolution.net/">one-straw revolution</a>, but our cities will experience accretion for a long time to come as the majority of humanity abandons a rural existence to populate them.</p><p>Earth’s cities should be a joy to live in. We should be free to enjoy both the high energy and activity that these hubs of society represent and frequent pockets of silence and reflection within them. Universal Silent Spaces can be counted on one hand in most major world cities today, but as both silence and meditation are claiming mindshare across the world we will need a Silent Space in every neighbourhood.</p><p>Neighbourhood ubiquity requires an appreciation for Silent Spaces which will only emerge once the spaces themselves begin to emerge. This emergence will be twofold between the creation of new Silent Spaces and increasing awareness of existing Silent Spaces. Initially, it will be frequent travellers who are most likely to require Silent Spaces as they develop a daily meditation practice and quickly find that a truly silent room, open to anyone, is a very rare occurrence everywhere on the planet.</p><p>The next article in this series will be a call for proposals. <em>The Silent Spaces Project</em> (or perhaps <em>The Suññagara Project</em>?) will map and describe all the Silent Spaces across the globe so meditators and seekers of silence will never feel trapped when traveling away from home. Let’s start with the airports?</p><p>arraññagato va<br>rukkhamålagato va<br>suññagaragato va</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=160d3a44fa3d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/silent-spaces-160d3a44fa3d">Silent Spaces</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Universal Spaces]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/universal-spaces-d0e0110a0ccc?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0e0110a0ccc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[urban-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[infrastructure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Feb 2019 13:49:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T11:59:03.894Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-02-05-universal-spaces/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><p>Yesterday we visited Chennai’s <a href="https://www.ts-adyar.org/">Theosophical Society</a>. Prior to this visit I knew little of Theosophy and nothing about the space. The Society is staggering in size. Bountiful gardens spread across 260 acres. Although it is dwarfed by large city parks like Central Park (850 acres) in New York and Stanley Park (1000 acres) in Vancouver, the Theosophical Society Gardens have an even more surprising quality: they are privately owned.</p><p>Think what we might about the Society’s belief systems, what became clear on our journey back home from an hour of meditation in the gardens was that they constitute an example of an idea Siggu has tossed around for a while: Universal Spaces. These gardens are open to anyone to enjoy. Their purposes are restricted to silent activities. The Society would prefer you walk, read, pray, think, or meditate. Entertaining yourself by blasting a fun <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsXVk37bltHxD1rDPwtNM8Q">Kurzgesagt</a> video on your phone will attract the guards, however — mobile phones are forbidden in the gardens.</p><p>The idea behind the term Universal Spaces regards the universality of access. If everyone is allowed to enter a space and if everyone is allowed to use the space for its intended purpose then that space is a Universal Space. There are a few subtleties which prevent Universal Spaces from existing in a strict dichotomy with limited, restricted, and exclusive spaces, but they’re pretty easy to spot in general.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/959/1*OalLwS9JINiBmJhVZWZt9A.jpeg" /><figcaption>A temple in the Theosophical Society, Adyar</figcaption></figure><h3>A Universal Space is not a free-for-all</h3><p>When I first thought to pin down my understanding of Universal Spaces, I had just finished a run on the <a href="https://goo.gl/maps/iHsYEorpBR12">Ulsoor Lake Pathway</a> in Bangalore. The pathway is a sort of slender park which runs along the west shore of Ulsoor Lake. The path is a dirt trail wide enough for vehicles, if they weren’t forbidden. The western edge of the path is dotted with benches, public toilets, trees, an outdoor gym, and a football field. Running back and forth over this path day after day, I couldn’t help but think of what an unbelievably civilized and noble space it was. This wasn’t some magical property specific to the Ulsoor Pathway but a property of the category the Pathway exemplifies: parks.</p><blockquote><strong>Therefore the sage goes about doing nothing, teaching no-talking.<br>The ten thousand things rise and fall without cease,<br>Creating, yet not possessing,<br>Working, yet not taking credit.<br>Work is done, then forgotten.<br>Therefore it lasts forever.</strong></blockquote><p>Everyone is welcome in a park. At Ulsoor, young couples canoodle, old couples walk hand-in-hand, some children stare at the lake and fantasize about rowing boats across it while others quietly read books in the shade alongside snoozing street dogs, teenagers take turns battling it out on the football field, and those of us who use the park as a running path silently observe it all from behind our sweaty eyebrows. The first quality to strike an observer is that the park does not discriminate. Every religion is represented there. Every age group. Every caste, class, and race. A park is a universal sanctuary only because it holds no opinions about its visitors.</p><p>And yet, there are rules and guidelines. Anywhere else in Bangalore, police and security guards struggle to prevent motorcycles and cars from driving on any narrow stretch of earth that will accommodate the planet’s most impatient drivers. Footpaths and bicycle lanes will only lack motor vehicles when the laws of physics prevent them. But the park is free from vehicles. It is an unwritten rule that one should be relatively quiet in the park. It is understood that one shouldn’t pluck flowers or cut down trees, whether or not there is a sign. The municipal corporation might install signs about garbage and cleanliness but everyone already understands this intuitively. A park is a church for the entire city, a temple of a universal religion.</p><p>It is tempting to try to clump Universal Spaces into obvious preexisting categories like <em>Club Goods</em>, <em>The Commons</em>, and <em>Public Interests</em>. Although Universal Spaces certainly intersect with these categories, they do not fit cleanly into any one of them. Compartmentalizing goods is predominantly an economics exercise but Universal Spaces are nearer to the <em>Common Good</em> of Philosophy than the <em>Common Goods</em> of Economics. It is equally tempting to politicize Universal Spaces to bring them under banners of altruism, social justice, etc. but to be truly universal requires transcendence of these labels; the labels themselves are exclusionary. There is a romance to the Universal Space which creates ontological difficulties but it does exhibit distinct qualities which themselves impart clarity.</p><p>Universal Spaces hold opinions not of their users but of their uses. The Pathway and the Theosophical Society are both open only for restricted hours and restricted behaviours. They exist for a reason, even if that reason happens to be open-ended, and they will serve society selflessly to this end as long as they exist.</p><h3>The Highest Virtue</h3><p>If we imagine some Universal Spaces as human beings they graduate from selfless to saintly. My favourite example is that of the public library.</p><blockquote><strong>The highest good is like water. <br>Water gives life to the ten thousand things and does not strive.<br>It flows in places men reject and so is like the Tao.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>In dwelling, be close to the land. <br>In meditation, go deep in the heart. <br>In dealing with others, be gentle and kind. <br>In speech, be true. <br>In ruling, be just. <br>In daily life, be competent. <br>In action, be aware of the time and the season.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>No fight: No blame.</strong></blockquote><p>The library holds zero opinions about its patrons. At first, this doesn’t seem like such an accomplishment. Of course a public service shouldn’t hold opinions about its patrons. A bus driver doesn’t get to tell people how to dress or where they’re taking the bus or why. However, I’ve used an exercise recently to put such spaces into perspective. Redesign them from scratch. What if I could build my own library? It would be beautiful. A wonder of human knowledge, intellect, and accomplishment. As its creator I would dwarf myself in the genius of the human collective. The library would keep the highest value literature — educating children, engaging young adults, and shaping our contemporaries. The library can be so much, if you think about it! It can be the inspiration and the manual, the tool and the muse, by which we rebuild our global society as a compassionate, loving, and productive species. Imagine curating the perfect library.</p><p>Imagine ruining it.</p><p>The public library has no such vision. It has but a single aim: to help us be literate. A modern public library has a rather broad definition for <em>literacy</em>, mind you, including computer literacy and life skills literacy. But under the narrower banner of <em>reading</em>, whether we choose to read magazines, websites, comic books, romance novels, cookbooks, the constitution, murder mysteries, self-help books, biographies, diaries, or thousand-page manifestos… it’s all the same to the library.</p><p>This is not at all to say that there is no space for a curated library. A curated library, open to all, is still a Universal Space. But a public library is <em>more</em> universal because it applies its universality to both sides of the market it so selflessly serves. Readers and authors alike are told “you are welcome here.”</p><p>The library is an awe-inspiring paradox. Thanks to inter-library loans, the library is effectively infinite, a behemoth which exists purely to serve. And its incomparable size springs from the most humble of ideas, that the service it provides should be utterly selfless.</p><p>A moment of gratitude is never wasted on a library or a park.</p><h3>The Lesser Spaces</h3><p>If not all Universal Spaces are created equal, we can start to examine them in terms of this virtuous nature. As long as one lives in a country with a stable government, it might be fair to say that privately-owned spaces such as the Theosophical Society Gardens are less universal than their publicly-owned equivalents. It’s sort of in the name. But there are other axes a person might be tempted to plot along. What is the purpose of the universal space in question? How can it be accessed?</p><p>Beaches, state- (rather than city-) owned parks, public transportation, and roads all qualify as Universal Spaces when they are free. If they ask money of their guests, they should be considered Lesser Universal Spaces — or, preferably, they should be disqualified from the title entirely. Economics are not an interesting quality of such spaces. Even a token amount in a <a href="https://www.gatesnotes.com/Books/Factfulness">Level 4 country</a> might be difficult for a guest with a Level 1 income to produce. Universal Spaces are inherently <em>global </em>spaces and some will have the leg up on others in this respect. A road might demand that you not walk on it, barring those who cannot afford a vehicle. (Roads in India rarely have such restrictions and are definitely Universal Spaces. Roads in North America disallow pedestrians, making sidewalks the only universal part of the street.) A city’s metro rail might not have wheelchair access. These are not the sorts of restrictions discussed in <em>A Universal Space is not a free-for-all.</em> Instead, these restrictions limit the space’s universality. Very quickly, such restrictions strip a space of its <em>universal</em> label altogether.</p><p>Of course there is not, and never will be, a badge for Universal Spaces. You won’t see parks labeled or graded on their universality with logos like those we see for food product trends. An ecologist might rank a national park as more virtuous than a national library in her partial ordering of spaces, thanks to the national park opening its doors not just to all human beings but all living things. She isn’t wrong. Neither is a libertarian wrong for ordering privately-owned spaces ahead of publicly-owned spaces due to her distrust of the government, or a socialist the reverse. Universal Spaces are communal by their very nature but they are not communist. Universal Spaces do not preach any particular political or intellectual ideology. Although not a common occurrence, nothing prevents a corporation from creating a Universal Space.</p><p>The institutions we often associate with the tired left/right political axis are often incapable of transcending it the way parks and libraries do. Universities are the perfect example. Pillars of <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/33606119-why-i-m-no-longer-talking-to-white-people-about-race">structural racism</a> and self-reinforcing class-based discrimination, universities are hardly candidates for the title. Their park-like appearance, safe infrastructure, and noble intentions give them the appearance of a Universal Space but they are never accessible to all for their core purpose of higher education. It might be difficult to imagine “public universities” with the structure and ubiquity of public schools but it’s more difficult to believe such an institution is impossible.</p><h3>Circles Around Trees</h3><p>When you venture out of your house tomorrow, keep an eye out for Universal Spaces. You will start to notice them all over. They need not be as grand as Central Park or your local library. Even an old church or temple, whatever its history or connotations, is a Universal Space for the purpose of silence if it is always open to the public.</p><p>In India, large trees are often garlanded in a concrete bench (மரத்தடி திண்ணை or <em>marathadi thinnai</em> in Tamil) which serves both to protect the tree and to provide a shaded seat for people to socialize or wait for a bus. It’s a simple construction so unassuming as to appear a completely natural feature. It is often spaces like these, spaces whose design is so simple and obvious they give the impression they weren’t designed at all, which lend themselves best to the virtue of universality.</p><blockquote><strong>uni·​ver·​sal :</strong></blockquote><blockquote>including or covering all or a whole collectively or distributively without limit or exception</blockquote><blockquote><em>especially</em> <strong>: </strong>available equitably to all members of a society</blockquote><p>There is no accounting for Universal Spaces but in the absence of exception.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GAsELUaBz8m1p7-Ye07dbg.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0e0110a0ccc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/universal-spaces-d0e0110a0ccc">Universal Spaces</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[India has a Three-Body Problem]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/india-has-a-three-body-problem-b61090fe4cc6?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b61090fe4cc6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[futurism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Feb 2019 12:33:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T11:03:18.696Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gxy_c5MJhdfidGwAD79ykw.png" /></figure><p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-02-01-india-has-a-three-body-problem/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><p>When I moved to Bangalore six years ago, I had no interest in India’s garbage management problem. I moved here to build a software company, not to muck about with garbage bins. But every time I would fly between the subcontinent and the Americas, I would find relief on my home continent and exhaustion on my continent of immigration. Living in a giant garbage heap is mentally taxing. Every moment spent outdoors is either an angsty mental rundown of how I might help, complete with acute feelings of powerlessness, or searching for someone to blame (my brain’s lazy personal favourite is a generic and completely unhelpful “the middle class”).</p><p>Reprieve comes in the form of resignation as the mind finally comes to accept a dangerous and unsustainable situation as inevitable. Telling yourself “this is just the way it is” at least allows you to enjoy a cup of tea or a single workday without obsessing about the garbage fire you will inevitably inhale on the bicycle ride home from the office.</p><p>But that doesn’t work for very long. The workday eventually ends and that bicycle ride inevitably happens. As you hold your breath and ride through the plume of smoke from a smouldering pile of trash on the side of the road, you ask yourself <em>why in the sweet fuck do I even live here</em>? And the answers instantly follow. Your friends are here, your home is here, your job is here. On the smallest scales some part of you belongs in India and on the largest possible scale you recognize that India’s problems of today are Earth’s problems of tomorrow. You can’t ignore them forever.</p><p>So you sit down and think about those problems. A lot.</p><h3>What is garbage?</h3><p>It may seem like a silly question but all sorts of variations have been asked of me over the years. “Why does garbage stink?” “Why can’t we just focus more attention on reuse?” and “Where do the costs of sanitation come from?” come to mind. If you’ve ever thrown something in the trash bin without asking yourself <em>just where is this going to end up?</em> you don’t really know what garbage is. The answer to this question changes with almost every piece of trash, with almost every bin, and definitely with every city.</p><p>Garbage is anything society’s majority decides it doesn’t want anymore. This extremely poisonous polystyrene Starbucks lid has served its purpose! I have a litre of burnt coffee in my stomach which means it’s definitely time to poop. Thanks for the assistance and off you go, immortal little lid, to know every worm that crawls by you until the sun of the milky way engulfs the Earth in five billion years and finally incinerates you. While this may be the future the majority plans, our little lid might never make it there. The lowest classes of human society repurpose garbage, sell garbage, and burn garbage to keep warm. The convenience of the healthy, educated elite are a disgrace to our species but, unexpectedly, the response of those at the bottom of the pyramid actually informs the way we <em>should</em> behave. This is because they know what garbage is.</p><h3>Back in Canada, we don’t know what garbage is</h3><p>One difficulty with living in a rich country backed by a huge resource economy is that it’s pretty easy to get self-righteous about how people in that country live, even if that way of life is far from perfect. It wasn’t that long ago that the garbage dump outside my hometown still burnt most of its garbage in open fires. (No one in southwest Saskatchewan bothers with that “landfill” euphemism.) It was on one of my many trips back and forth between India and Canada that it struck me how poorly we deal with waste in Canada.</p><p>Setting an example matters. If a country with the resources, time, money, and literacy of Canada can’t figure out what to do with our plastic bags or Styrofoam (Thermocol) it’s hard to imagine how any other country could do it. Canada leans on its unbelievable land mass and access to cheap fuel when it chooses to dump garbage in holes. As the world’s population distributes itself more evenly over the coming generations the sweep-it-under-the-rug approach will quickly bring the problems which plague India today to every other country on the planet. The problems of India today are the problems of Earth tomorrow.</p><p>Because <a href="https://www.gatesnotes.com/Books/Factfulness">Level 4 countries</a> like Canada generally don’t appreciate garbage, Canada needs countries like India and China to show it the way. Canada has 3.7 crore (37 million) citizens; India has 134 crore (1.3 billion). Canada’s country-wide garbage solutions need to scale thirty six times over or they are a failure on a global scale.</p><p>Thankfully, India’s garbage crisis is a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavior-shaping_constraint">forcing function</a>. Every day the garbage piles up inside and around India’s cities, the weight of it poisons us. Garbage on the street is an opportunity for the average citizen to stop and think about where her plastic milk packets go after they leave her house. Paradoxically, this is India’s opportunity to lead the rest of the globe.</p><h3>Garbage is a small riddle</h3><p>As an individual human being, there are only two steps to understanding our garbage. First, we need to deconstruct it. Second, we need to identify each component.</p><p>My friend’s question <em>why does garbage stink?</em> has an answer he could have puzzled out himself and it is arguably the first component of our deconstruction: some garbage is organic. Things we consume which were once alive are still alive on a microscopic level when they come to us. Living things stink. Or they will, eventually. The nice thing about this entire category is that every single item in it falls into the broad category of Organic. Biodegradable. Compost.</p><p>In India, <em>biodegradable</em> is often dubbed <em>wet waste</em> but I have issues with that nomenclature. It confuses people. A plastic tray with <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panipuri">panipuri</a> juice in it is certainly wet but it is in no way wet waste. If people understand that the green bin only means biodegradable, they’re less likely to throw plastic in there. Prior to our most recent train journey we took note of the waste signage in the Chennai Central railway station. The signage had other issues (which we’ll come to later) but the translations were on-point: <strong>biodegradable waste</strong> is <strong>सड़नशील कचरा</strong> in Hindi and… well, Preethi tells me those other words are the right ones in Tamil, whatever they say. The value of the word <em>biodegradable</em> is that it elevates the conversation. Are supposedly biodegradable plastics okay? Are coconut shells biodegradable enough, since they’re more like wood than food? The <em>Wet Waste</em> terminology doesn’t beg these questions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zBN32UqSTodKN1XplpBd0Q.png" /></figure><p>Our second component comes from the other end of the biodegradability spectrum: plastics. The ubiquitous blue bin has come to mean recyclable material in general but it is plastic that stands apart from all other materials. No matter how many times you reuse that plastic bag, plastic chopstick, or plastic toy it will eventually have an end and that end should neither be the garbage dump nor a trash fire. Plastic needs to be recycled or broken down or we live with it forever.</p><h3>The Three-Body Problem</h3><p>This is where India gets stuck. There are many different methods of deconstruction and most of them don’t work. Any system which acknowledges the importance of our first two categories (organic and plastic) inherently creates a third: Everything Else.</p><p>This often stems from an enthusiasm to solve the garbage crisis. A city like Jaipur sees the problem of unsegregated waste and attacks it head-on… with the wrong weapon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rhPF6BaixRYWWK67q_4JYw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A garbage lorry in Jaipur</figcaption></figure><p>We recently visited the <a href="https://jaipurliteraturefestival.org/">Jaipur Literature Festival</a> and found ourselves pleasantly surprised by the city’s ubiquitous, segregated public waste system. Jaipur has segregated bins <em>everywhere</em>… but only blue and green bins and only blue and green garbage trucks. Blue/Green, Two-Body segregated bins are a step in the right direction. The citizens of Jaipur see these green and blue bins every day. Whether they respect the bins’ colours or not, a part of their subconscious starts to acknowledge that not all garbage is created equal.</p><p>A single look in these bins, however, will show you just how horribly ineffective a Two-Body system is. The green bin is full of dirty styrofoam plates. The blue bin is full of dirty, mixed waste. These broad, mutually exclusive strokes of <strong>Green = Wet Waste</strong> and <strong>Blue = Dry Waste</strong> mean that we must choose one of these two categories for Everything Else. A wet plastic dish full of panipuri juice is the least of our troubles. Where should I put a snot-filled tissue? A dirty diaper? Roadkill? Paint chips? Construction rubble? A used sanitary napkin?</p><p>Yeah. I don’t know, either. <em>You need three bins.</em></p><p>This question of “other garbage” helped us persuade the building management of our Bangalore apartment complex to let us install a three-bin system: green for organic, blue for recyclables, red for everything else. “Everything else” is labelled <em>reject</em> on our bin but that’s just a fancy way of saying <em>old-fashioned garbage</em>. We actually encouraged our building-mates to put everything in the red bin until they were absolutely certain it belonged in the green or blue bin. A whole bin of clean compost is worthless if a single person poisons it. A whole bin of clean recycling is worthless if a single person dumps chutney all over it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a4c8lG-W18-iU-Qws1oRAw.jpeg" /></figure><p>For months, before we were allowed to install the bins, the building manager repeatedly insisted that “a three-bin system will be too complicated” and “the municipal corporation waste-pickers don’t know what to do with three different bins.”</p><p>Over the years before <a href="https://medium.com/@preethig">Preethi</a> and I installed these bins, we had heard every brand of argument against segregating garbage: <em>it’s too complicated, the waste-pickers just throw it into one pile anyway, the system is corrupt, the residents / staff / citizens won’t follow the rules</em>, and on and on and on. I’ve fought this battle so many times I’ve even <a href="https://github.com/deobald/waste-maturity-model/raw/master/waste.pdf">codified my arguments for a Waste Maturity Model into a presentation</a>. Thanks to battling these talking points with our families, friends, and coworkers, we were well-equipped to fend off the argument that the combination of a green and blue bin would be sufficient.</p><p>In the end, where does a diaper go? <em>You need three bins.</em></p><h3>Confusing your citizens in two easy steps!</h3><p>On our way back from Jaipur to Chennai, we flew through Bangalore and it gave us a chance to see three different cities’ broken waste segregation messages.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*e8-ZwKTNAXem9x6CSAv0_A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/632/1*J3i0CiKK-WRGHyVsJOciGw.png" /><figcaption>Bangalore’s useless airport segregation completely flies in the face of the actual state guidelines</figcaption></figure><p>Bangalore actually has brilliant state-wide waste segregation guidelines, published in a dozen languages. They answer questions I wouldn’t think to ask (<em>where do my coconut shells go?</em>) and they are <a href="http://bengaluru.citizenmatters.in/2-bin-1-bag-order-order-by-high-court-bangalore-8019">actually written into law</a>.</p><p>Despite the law, the Bangalore International Airport thinks a 4-bin system is better than a 3-bin system. And, much to our chagrin, none of those bins is for reject garbage. Where do I put my snotty tissue in the Bangalore airport? Is a snotty tissue <em>food</em>, <em>plastic</em>, <em>paper</em>, or <em>cans</em>? None of the above. Hold onto it until you get to Chennai, I guess.</p><p>Chennai, on the other hand, has functional segregation at the airport. Hooray! For some unknown reason, they eschewed the standard international green/blue/black colours (or the slightly modified green/blue/red used in Karnataka). But that’s okay. At least I know where to dump my half-eaten dosa, the plastic spoon the chutney came with, and the wrapper with chocolate all over it that melted in my pocket during the flight.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w_0cRBoZeiu7GdKXcsAxow.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9JOgCJlnqxRIyf6tVG4Ljg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Chennai airport has real waste segregation but the city has zero</figcaption></figure><p>Unfortunately, as soon as you get into the city the <strong>only</strong> bins you will find are for “non-recyclable waste” — giant green dumpsters akin to those of mid-twentieth-century American cities. If you want to figure out compost or recycling as a citizen of Chennai, you’re on your own.</p><p>Moving from one city to another can often be as drastic as moving from one country to another but moving from the airport to the office shouldn’t be. It’s little wonder that citizens are confused, waste-pickers are frustrated, and government officials feel overwhelmed.</p><h3>India can lead. India must lead.</h3><p>It is the perfect time for Indian states to unify on their understanding of the top three categories of waste. Whether we choose to label them <em>wet, dry, and reject</em> or <em>organic, recyclable, and mixed</em> or <em>green, blue, and red</em> or any other three titles, unity from the top will help us pick away at the many difficulties plaguing India’s streets and water bodies.</p><p>Over time, these three categories will spawn other categories. Separating plastics from paper from metal from glass from e-waste is a good way to split up the blue bin full of generic recyclables. If you want to split up the city’s plastic, there are at least seven plastic recycling symbols to go by. There are over forty international recycling symbols.</p><p>Baby steps, though. Keep the plastic out of the green bin and the chicken grease out of the blue bin. Then maybe we can discuss the road to Zero Waste.</p><p>Waste management is a form of project management. The project is massive, distributed, and constantly moving. It is global in scale and influenced by every single human being on Earth. Once it happens, successful waste management in India and China will be the gold standard for the rest of the globe.</p><p>These are the biggest projects. If we can do it here, we can do it anywhere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UudDo0dKMa5Q9Z19RS6GMg.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b61090fe4cc6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/india-has-a-three-body-problem-b61090fe4cc6">India has a Three-Body Problem</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to disconnect]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/how-to-disconnect-1040de82072a?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1040de82072a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life-hacking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[millennials]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Jan 2019 13:08:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-04T07:24:06.682Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*oKoPf_xCrLM98xDpSgzU9w.png" /></figure><p>This essay has moved to <a href="https://www.deobald.ca/essays/2019-01-16-how-to-disconnect/">https://www.deobald.ca/essays</a></p><p>For those of us who grew up in the 1990s (Gen-Y-ers? Pre-Millennials?), the sound of connecting was</p><blockquote>Pshhhkkkkkkrrrrkakingkakingkakingtshchchchchchchchcch*ding*ding*ding</blockquote><p>and there was a certain romance to the ritual of Getting On The Internet. At least, there is a certain romance <em>now. </em>Now that we live in the era which precedes the era of <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/108957.Everyware">ubiquitous computing</a>, with all our nerdy fantasies fulfilled, the internet is everywhere and the ritual is our lives.</p><p>The fulfilling of these connectivity fantasies was exciting every step of the way. Remember your first ADSL connection? The first time you used a T1? The first time you connected to the ethernet port at a forward-thinking hotel? The first time you used wifi on a plane? Faster than you can tweet a GIF that visually represents “millennial burnout,” the Earth has irreversibly changed its configuration. All of a sudden everything is connected, all the time, and we find ourselves craving Lycos and WebCrawler and Geocities. But the internet is a shitty preteen and you don’t solve your shitty preteen’s problems by forcing them to become a 3-year-old again, no matter how curious/adorable/innocent that 3-year-old seemed. Also most preteens don’t merge with the fabric of society and enmesh with the very notion of our species, as we perceive it, so the analogy kind of breaks down there.</p><p>We can, however, make use of our nostalgia without regressing humanity’s greatest invention.</p><h3>Some writing is bad</h3><p>Before we get to some potential solutions, I would like to point to the article that forced me to write this article. It is this: Anne Helen Petersen’s <a href="https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/annehelenpetersen/millennials-burnout-generation-debt-work"><em>How Millennials Became The Burnout Generation</em></a>. I don’t suggest you read this article; I think it’s terrible. But the friends who shared the article felt connected with its message and I wanted to address what is so accessible about it and why I feel the thesis — a dark belief in the inevitable ineffectuality of an entire generation, held by more people than you might expect — is so incredibly misguided.</p><p>This belief that Millennials are intrinsically tied to digital addictions is even held by those with some real, meaningful solutions. Think what you might about Simon Sinek’s tone and demeanour in that <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hER0Qp6QJNU"><em>Millennials in the Workplace</em></a> interview, he’s got some really good ideas about phone usage toward the end of that 15 minutes:</p><ul><li>No phones in meetings</li><li>No phones at the dinner table</li><li>No phones for alarm clocks</li></ul><p>For any of us who have had unsatisfying social interactions (or caused them) those are concrete, actionable solutions to acute problems. “No phones in meetings” means you leave them outside the room, in a box. “No phones at the dinner table” means you leave them at home or in another room. “No phones for alarm clocks” means you buy an alarm clock and charge your phone in the living room. You can do these. And you don’t have to be a millennial.</p><p>His advice for millennials, however, looks more like:</p><ul><li>Learn some fucking patience</li></ul><p>This isn’t very good advice. It’s not concrete. It’s not actionable. And the reason it’s not is probably because the problem statement is unbelievably vague.</p><blockquote>“Millennials (born 1984 and after) are accused of being entitled, narcissistic, self-interested, unfocused, lazy.”</blockquote><p>That’s barely a problem statement. But at least he makes an effort to come up with one and an effort to provide some solutions… even if they fall flat.</p><p>Petersen’s article, by contrast, has the <em>reverse </em>problem statement: <em>millennials are so hardworking they can’t manage to feed themselves or register to vote.</em> She proposes no solution beyond “write a painfully long and self-referential article about millennial burnout for a few days of catharsis.” She also does not suggest that anyone born prior to 1984 …or 1982? 1981? …whenever it is that we’ve decided the “millennial” generation started… might be suffering from this overall burnout or any of its constituent symptoms. If your mental model for the upcoming generation of professionals really is that described by Sinek at the start of his interview — or the paradoxically-inverse-but-also-somehow-the-same model stomped all over by Petersen throughout her article — then I agree the situation is hopeless.</p><p>Thankfully, the demographic they describe is rather narrow. It’s quite apparent they haven’t interviewed lower-middle class office workers in China or recently-landed refugees in any country. The problematic intersection of millennials suffering from digital attention deficit seems to have high coincidence with a WEIRD (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, And Democratic) demographic. The group which shared Petersen’s article in the first place happens to be predominantly Indian — but everyone in it is definitely EIRD, even if they’re not from the West. The problematic demographic may not require all five categories but it definitely requires most of them.</p><p>So, the “entitled, narcissistic, self-interested, unfocused, lazy” problem isn’t universal for an entire generation. But phones are. And they are universal for any generation with access to them. It doesn’t matter much who I sit down to dine with these days — everyone has a phone out at some point in the meal. Everyone. From the eldest in the family down to the youngest person permitted to own a mobile phone.</p><p>I haven’t found a satiating solution to my desire for “impact,” which I happen to have despite being of a non-millennial generation. Perhaps I never will. But I have found some concrete, actionable solutions to the problem of connectivity. And, coincidentally, as I relearn how to stand at a train station for an hour without repeated dopamine hits from my phone, I’m also relearning some patience.</p><h3>Unfollow everybody</h3><p>While we all pick our poison we often forget <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_dose_makes_the_poison"><em>sola dosis facit venenum</em></a><em> — the dose makes the poison. </em>And where this is forgotten, we are likely to get our biggest hints. During my three years working in finance in Chicago I drowned in a drinking culture that not only tolerated alcoholism but actively supported it. Given that, despite my mental density, I sort of <em>knew that</em> in the back of my mind, it really stood out one Monday when my coworker Alex took me aside to tell me she was disappointed in me because of my drinking. I’ve never thanked her for that but the memory is still sharp because I can count on one hand the number of people who did express such disappointment.</p><p>Digital addiction is no different — and our potential audience is wider. My friend Toby’s compassion mirrored Alex’s in the form of a tweet:</p><blockquote>“You’ve been tweeting a lot. Is everything okay?”</blockquote><p>Twitter is my poison, though I’ve made a cocktail of other digital services. Reddit and YouTube mean I’ve reached the bottom of my emotional barrel. Instagram is as disastrous for me as it is for everyone else, <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/16/time-on-instagram/">it seems</a>. I’ve been sucked into long, meaningless discussions on WhatsApp and Slack and LINE and Telegram.</p><p>Where software permits you to unfriend and unfollow people, I try to do that. A ruthless cull which trims the fat from the top of the time-sink should leave that software providing me updates on longer intervals. How few people would you need to follow on Instagram to ensure that you rarely saw new material in your feed, even if you only checked it once a day?</p><p>A social network is a graph. Adding nodes causes a combinatorial explosion. If you can get by with zero nodes, you’ll never be burnt. We don’t follow anyone with the <a href="https://twitter.com/siggudotorg">@siggudotorg</a> account on Twitter because it’s entirely unnecessary, by definition — organizations don’t “follow people”. Because of this, when we log in to Twitter to post something we are never sucked into a pit of zippy-looking articles and dog GIFs.</p><h3>Log out</h3><p>Notice I just said “when we log in.” We’re getting into more difficult territory here but with every service, with every account, with every app — log out. It makes every interaction with that app an explicit activity. An explicit activity is one you need to sign up for consciously. You need to say to yourself “I am going to use Twitter now” if you have to log in to check your feed or to post a tweet.</p><p>Annoying? Yes. That’s the point.</p><h3>Choose a mode</h3><p>If logging in and out of a plethora of online services doesn’t seem manageable, I try to use modes. My most recent is <a href="https://github.com/deobald/siggu.org/blob/master/article-content/chat-mode.sh"><strong>chat-mode</strong></a>. chat-mode off is the command I throw at the computer to tell it <em>“I’m going to work now”</em>. chat-mode on is an explicit intention I must express to open all my chat apps and suffer through the updates that have emerged since my last bout of chatting.</p><p>Modes can come from other places. Multiple desktops, multiple logins, multiple devices. Have an iPad and a laptop? Make one your work device and one your play device. Did your company give you an iPhone? Great. Turn it off when you leave the office if you’re not on-call.</p><h3>“Mom, can I use the computer?”</h3><p>While I endorse the <a href="https://betterhumans.coach.me/a-phone-setup-that-will-make-you-more-mindful-1c5d8be7e661"><em>Mindful Phone Setup</em></a> (and encourage you to try it out) the real gold of that article is the description of a toothbrush.</p><blockquote>“Your toothbrush is the greatest tool of all time. Why? You only use it when you’re supposed to, for as long as you need to and never forget what it’s for.”</blockquote><p>The incremental adjustments in that article are helpful but the concept of <em>explicit intentions</em> is one we can apply everywhere. Let’s be nostalgic again for a minute. We pre-millennials remember a time when <em>Using The Computer</em> was as explicit an activity as setting the dinner table or brushing our teeth. A time was set aside for the activity, the computer was booted up, and computering happened for a few hours. We might not even choose to do this activity every day.</p><p>Explicit, intentional activities can occur at every level, from the physical (“which device am I using? let me turn it on first.”) to windows to tabs to apps to accounts. In general, making activities single-threaded is almost always an improvement over our usual scattered modes. One device. One tab. One app. The higher up this hierarchy you go, the more you gain for free. You are using zero tabs and zero apps when you turn your phone off or put it in another room.</p><h3>Pay for it</h3><p>In Yuval Noah Harari’s <a href="https://www.ynharari.com/book/21-lessons/"><em>21 Lessons for the 21st Century</em></a>, his first truly piercing and concrete advice comes in Chapter 17: Pay for the media and information you consume. When we choose to use free services (the irony of publishing this on Medium isn’t lost on me), we must always remember that we are the inventory, not the customer.</p><p>Diversity is a good thing and competition in the digital market should only increase as the solutions provided by our current tools become passé. Where there is competition, we are served by paying to consume.</p><h3>Delete your account</h3><p>As silly and contemporary an idea as “fear of missing out” might be, when I’m honest with myself I can identify the feeling and observe its intensity. A fear, by its very nature, is an irrational emotion. It serves little purpose for modern humans in 99% of the environments we’re presented with. Okay, no. Women experience legitimate fear of men all the time and black people in America experience legitimate fear of police all the time. But it’s rare that our fears which amount to an <em>existential crisis</em> are ever legitimate.</p><p>My existence on Instagram does not matter. I’ve deleted it. My existence on Facebook is really the reverse: I like Facebook as a sort of global phone book and that’s how I use it. My existence on Twitter doesn’t matter but I don’t have the guts to delete my account and logging out doesn’t prevent me from wasting time on it. The dose makes the poison but abstinence always reduces the dose well below the LD50.</p><p>Your existence on social media does not matter.</p><p>Experiment: For one social medium, try reducing your friends/follows to your favourite aunt and one hero. See how that affects your life after one week.</p><h3>Test your free will</h3><p>All of the above suggestions can be run as single-data-point experiments on yourself. They work best as a temporal comparison: one week on, one week off. See if it helps. If it doesn’t, throw it out and try something else.</p><p>The reason most of these tricks and self-manipulations are required at all is because our environment no longer constrains us. We no longer need to ask Mom if we can “use the internet” — we can’t even ask ourselves. The internet is asking if it can use us and for many of us the answer is almost always <em>yes</em>. Why?</p><p>Free Will is oft-debated in the New Religion of Atheism but rarely identified as a spectrum. Many of us still subscribe to Freud’s iceberg diagram of the conscious and unconscious (Super Ego and friends aside) with only the existence of the water mark as a point of debate. Freud’s iceberg image of the conscious and unconscious is as unoriginal as it is incorrect. It’s a helpful visualization insofar as acknowledging that there is some “underwater” portion of our consciousness which seems to react to stimuli beyond our active intentions but this idea has its roots in millennia-old philosophy. In Pali, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vij%C3%B1%C4%81na"><em>viññāṇa</em></a> and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sa%E1%B9%85kh%C4%81ra"><em>saṅkhāra</em></a> both refer to components of the mind — each acting discerningly on the surface or generating blind reaction, respectively.</p><p>Simple meditation — of any sort — is a great litmus test. It helps us place ourselves on the spectrum, in gross terms. Sit down and try to follow the touch of your breath as it flows in and out beneath your nostrils for an hour without interruption. One finds a constant interruption of thoughts — conscious thoughts — which have a reactive and unknown origin completely outside of our control. [1]</p><p>The appearance of unwanted thoughts in our consciousness demonstrates that our Will is certainly far from Free. One need not take a 10-Day Vipassana Course to see this effect but ten days without a phone or email certainly presents it to us in a stark contrast.</p><p>The purpose of inspecting ourselves in this way isn’t to satisfy some arbitrary intellectual curiosity. Every time we reestablish our awareness this way, reifying the truth about our lack of free will, we reinforce the need for environmental support. Bit by bit, we’re more likely to keep phones off the dinner table, unfollow an internet celebrity, or delete our Netflix account.</p><p>[1] If you’re not a fan of meditation, get on the treadmill or stationary bike and push yourself with a difficult hour-long workout but refuse yourself the permission to look at the clock or the machine’s readout. Answer honestly: How many times did you look?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1040de82072a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/how-to-disconnect-1040de82072a">How to disconnect</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Does smoking marijuana harm your meditation practice?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/does-smoking-marijuana-harm-your-meditation-practice-a683ea752220?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a683ea752220</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cannabis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Jan 2019 16:15:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-11T16:15:36.244Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/778/1*Wnf3Ggw1cvvqezAthPXGhg.jpeg" /></figure><p>tl;dr: Yes, it does.</p><p>A friend with very little drug experience recently asked me if smoking (or eating) marijuana would harm her nascent meditation practice. She had a few follow-up questions, one of which was “have you ever written about this?” which caused me to turn our conversation into this post.</p><p>First off, on the broad topic of drugs and meditation, I have written about my experiences and categorized the options once before in <a href="http://blog.deobald.ca/2015/01/drugs-meditation-warnings.html"><em>Drugs, Meditation, Warnings</em></a>. Upon reading this she probed on my categorization of marijuana as “dangerous”:</p><blockquote>“Dangerous in what way?”</blockquote><p>I feel that no one has done a better job of explaining Earth’s human habit of alcohol and marijuana consumption than Aldous Huxley. In <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5128.The_Doors_of_Perception_Heaven_and_Hell">The Doors of Perception &amp; Heaven and Hell</a>, he does a brilliant job of examining our global consumption of narcotics and why certain narcotics are blessed by the state and even the church as socially acceptable. He also explores the topic of our need for <em>something else</em>, whether that is religion or ritual or physical self-destruction or meditation or drugs. A completely sober life devoid of spirituality, intoxicants, video games, or self-harm is unsatisfying to us humans. So we reach for aides. The easier and more potent, the better.</p><p>I classify marijuana as “dangerous” precisely because it feels like it shouldn’t be. You can get it cleanly, legally, and easily now. You no longer need to smoke it. You will now (or soon) find it socially acceptable to indulge in it on a daily basis.</p><p>And you have nothing to gain from these experiences.</p><blockquote>“But does it alter the mind in some way?”</blockquote><p>Indeed it does — but so do alcohol and cigarettes. As a heavy user in my youth, I don’t think there is anything informative or enlightening about weed. Hallucinogens, mind you, are in another category altogether: sometimes they can really show you something you haven’t seen before. They can provide you a sixth or seventh sense. When taken, the brain’s machinery for generating this sense of self can be temporarily short circuited. [1] But I still wouldn’t recommend doing them. All drugs demand a deeper commitment tomorrow to retain yesterday’s experiences and none of these experiences will ever be the totality of mind itself. You can’t get there from here.</p><p>(For more on an altered state of mind, see <em>“How would you compare the calmness of weed to the calmness of meditation?”</em> below.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/917/1*GQ0RoT5Q7VBm-gMPgX7-YQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The small alterations marijuana and alcohol make to my mind come with a significant cost. When I first attempted a daily vipassana practice, I was still drinking and smoking and they both <strong>destroy</strong> meditation practice.</p><p>For me, even one beer would throw me off completely when it was in my system. Though it probably seems obvious to most people that you can’t meditate when you are one drink in, it is the effects in the days which follow which are harder to detect. If I drank (even one drink) and then attempted to meditate the next day, my attention would wander more aggressively but my ability to <em>catch it wandering</em> was diminished. A more frightening recursive side-effect was that when forcing myself to meditate a day or two after drinking I would end up doubting the value of the meditation, from the ground up. Because of the fog on my senses and intelligence the experience was so frustrating and self-defeating that I would often stop my practice entirely.</p><blockquote>“Does weed stay in the system longer than alcohol?”</blockquote><p>I would say yes. Alcohol’s passive effects on the mind and the body last two or three days; marijuana’s effects last almost a week. I only have my early marijuana experiences to measure this accurately, as does anyone. I’ll explain in a moment.</p><p>I started smoking in college with my more experienced cousin. This would normally take place on a Saturday night and it would leave me absolutely catatonic on Sundays. I loved those Sundays. The stresses of university and the anxiety of living off a limited income peal off the mind when one can barely think at all.</p><p>The rest of the week was less enjoyable. After those first few Saturdays, I usually couldn’t focus in my classes or study properly until Wednesday. Naturally, the more I smoked the less I noticed. After three or four Saturdays with my cousin, I completely lost the ability to observe the effects. Years later, I started smoking every day and a whole new host of effects became apparent. It made me paranoid. It made me lazy. It made me stupid.</p><blockquote>“So does marijuana become a part of living at some point?”</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29338547">For some people</a>. I’m not even sure I thought of it that way… the addiction kind of creeps up on you because it’s not chemical, at all. It’s 100% psychological. Unlike caffeine and alcohol, if you stop smoking nothing bad happens to your body. Armed with that knowledge, a person can easily smoke every day and retain the staggering belief that it isn’t actually a ritual component of their life.</p><blockquote>“But I keep hearing about how people use it in a constructive way? That it isn’t recreational. That it’s more than that. That marijuana has a function in work and enhancing creativity?”</blockquote><p>That’s not 100% untrue. Marijuana use can supposedly amplify alpha waves in the brain. But even if that’s true, it’s just not very much.</p><p>Ask anyone who’s smoked a lot and kept a “stoner book.” Many people do it. You write down all these marvellous things you think are the epitome of your capacity for ground-breaking genius when you’re high. When you look at them the next day with sober eyes and un-amplified brain waves you realize your brain had basically melted. Separate yourself from your ideas. Your ideas seemed profound to you because you were temporarily transformed into an idiot. This is what my girlfriend (a heavy smoker in a former life) refers to as a “total waste of time.” The thing to keep in mind is that sometimes it’s fun to waste time, which is why people do it. But convincing yourself that you are lifted to the level of trans-dimensional artiste by THC is self-delusion.</p><blockquote>“If it doesn’t enhance creativity, it does at least calm some people down. How would you compare the calmness of meditation to weed?”</blockquote><p>The opposite. First off, the goals of meditation stretch far and beyond “calming down.” That is rarely the aim of serious meditation but I won’t go into that here. If you do happen to be chemically inclined in such a way that weed calms you down, the more you smoke it the more you need to smoke it for it to calm you down. Like any drug, the effects get weaker with every high. On the other hand, the effects of meditation (calming or otherwise) get stronger every time a person practices. This is at least true for zazen and vipassana — I’m not sure I would say that for any meditation technique that doesn’t focus directly on the nervous system.</p><blockquote>“So then meditation can be addictive?”</blockquote><p>My colleague <a href="https://twitter.com/deepa_v">Deepa</a> asked me this just before I left <a href="https://nilenso.com/">nilenso</a>: “Do you think people can get addicted to Vipassana?”</p><p>I’m pretty firmly in the “no” camp.</p><p>Nobody meditates all day because they’re enjoying some kind of ride. (Again, restrict the definition of “meditation” to zazen and vipassana for my responses.) Meditation is too much work.</p><p>I have heard the term “bliss out” in other meditation schools and it definitely freaks me out. I hate the idea of being trapped in meditation all the time just because it’s an easy way out of real life. Then it is no better than drugs.</p><p>Vipassana, at least, forces you to stare reality in the face every single time you do it. Even if it can sometimes be relaxing it is never relaxing the whole way through. The hard truths of reality aren’t always enjoyable.</p><h3>Coda: What about meditating <em>while</em> high?</h3><p>My friend didn’t ask me this question but it’s a natural one and therefore worth addressing. While I have never had a positive experience meditating with alcohol in my bloodstream, the same can’t be said for meditating under the influence of marijuana or stronger drugs. It’s possible that these substances will make your meditation experience quite pleasant and in that respect they cause even more harm than they would had you simply tried to meditate the following day.</p><p>Mixing drugs with meditation causes quite a few difficulties for the meditator. First of all, concentration is damaged. Any enjoyable experience is usually the byproduct of daydreaming; one isn’t really meditating in any meaningful sense at all. Even if concentration is possible and sensation is enhanced, the enhancement is artificial. The second difficulty comes once the artificial stimulant to meditation is removed. Now the meditator compares sober meditation to stoned meditation and starts finding fault in the former. Meditation is often <em>very boring</em> and if there is a way to inject some artificial entertainment into it, the temptation to do so will be increasingly strong.</p><p>The final difficulty comes in the following days. The meditator’s concentration is damaged in a subtle and imperceptible way. Meditation seems more boring, more difficult, and more pointless than it did in the first place — and meditation already frequently feels boring, difficult, and pointless on the best of days for those of us who have just started this journey. The ease of marijuana use and the damage it causes to meditation practice are painfully disproportionate. A single evening of stoned experimentation can send your meditation practice for a toss for months.</p><p>Meditation, unlike other skills, does not subscribe to the 10,000 hour rule. The rule extends to something that more realistically looks like 40,000 hours. At this point in my practice, I have personally put in over 5000 hours. Although I still consider myself a raw beginner I wouldn’t sacrifice my practice for anything else in my life. Certainly not for the small pleasures brought by marijuana.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PJLfznGn_P7fFA_gsokLZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>[1] <a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/109/6/2138">Hallucinogens can quieten the cortical midline structures/default mode network and evoke feelings of “oneness with universe.”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a683ea752220" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/does-smoking-marijuana-harm-your-meditation-practice-a683ea752220">Does smoking marijuana harm your meditation practice?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[EFF Software Ethics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/siggu/eff-software-fc19e1abca46?source=rss-f6b24d2dc678------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc19e1abca46</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crypto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[open-source]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Deobald]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Jan 2019 03:51:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-06T06:44:35.184Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>or Steve Yegge, you are half right (Part Two)</h4><p>In <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/38820046-21-lessons-for-the-21st-century"><em>21 Lessons for the 21st Century</em></a>, Yuval Noah Harari repeatedly emphasizes the need for society to apply critical thinking to the future of software, algorithms, and artificial intelligence. Harari is one of the more forward-thinking philosophers when it comes to disruptive technology and <em>21 Lessons</em> lucidly collects the requirements for our species’ future: our new tools must sustainably respect future arcs of aggregate data use and they must do so globally.</p><p>This is no simple task. To respect the future of data is to anticipate it and we will often be wrong. Aggregate data use is the province of statisticians and data scientists today — of artificial intelligence tomorrow. Knowing when and how we need to respond to the risks posed by our own creations is a daunting task. It requires that we play to our strengths and trust in the science of disciplines beyond our field of expertise.</p><p>In <a href="https://medium.com/siggu/steve-yegge-you-are-half-right-part-one-5560054e2922">Steve Yegge, you are half right</a> I proposed a thorough reexamination of today’s startup economy and its reckless offspring, using Yegge’s article about the Southeast Asia ride share economy as a bit of a punching bag. I mean him no disrespect but his views are a loud echo of the majority and I’m a dissenter. Since I am first and foremost a technologist, in this article I will shift focus — from the present to the near future and from business models to technology.</p><h3>The problem</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/655/1*h6D0_sDvOP0kQDQChjpHNA.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://twitter.com/aaomidi/status/1075621119028314112">Amir Omidi</a>, regarding Slack’s <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-46642760">unwarranted account ban</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>This December, Slack users got their umpteenth sampling of the dangers associated with centralized services. Although Slack has a notoriously fragile Privacy Policy and weak service record, the fundamental problem is not Slack’s policy-making but its business model. I choose to pick on Slack because it is the antithesis of sustainable technology in a crowded market. But this fragile business model is the status quo. Slack is fragile for the same reasons Grab and Airbnb and Dropbox are fragile: unencrypted data delivered exclusively over a central point of failure to an end product the buyer does not own or control.</p><p>If you are a programmer, the first networked application you wrote was almost certainly a chat service of some sort. It might have been distributed or a simple client/server design. It might have been CORBA (like mine) or it might have been written on top of HTTP. It might have transferred binary blobs or JSON. It doesn’t matter. For programmers, chat feels like a solved problem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9QJ8ACu6x92Cy4Coihl3Rg.png" /></figure><p>It’s not.</p><p>Even if you’ve never written a line of code in your life, you’ve almost certainly used chat. A chat. Some chat. But not <em>the chat</em>. Normal humans will remember Google Talk, ICQ, and MSN Messenger. Nerds maintain their nostalgia with memories of IRC and their optimism in <a href="https://www.matrix.org/">Matrix</a>. My friends and I all have Slack and Signal and Keybase and we are disappointed in each service. Slack is unencrypted and provides its service on a whim (apparently). Signal is ugly, slow, broken, and undistributed. Keybase has a closed source server and a design that could hardly be more confused.</p><p>There is no single protocol to which we can ascribe the notion of digital chat the way we can with digital mail — but there should be. Why doesn’t it exist?</p><h3>Encryption</h3><p>Data needs to be encrypted. It wasn’t long ago that intentional encryption use was limited to security-conscious nerds, techno-preppers, and governments. In a few swift years, trolling, doxxing, and identity theft have jumped from the esoteric language of mailing lists to household names thrown about by national news anchors.</p><p>Public awareness of cryptography has been assisted by two watershed releases: Bitcoin, in 2009, and WhatsApp end-to-end (e2e) encryption, in 2016. [1] All features of quality software live on a spectrum and of them cryptography is the hardest to quantify. End-to-end encryption implementations are numerous and there is debate about which approaches to e2e should be considered safe at all. (In the broader world of cryptography, the math used in Bitcoin bears no resemblance to that of WhatsApp’s e2e message encryption; it’s an apples-and-oranges comparison and not meaningful to this discussion.) What matters to the global user base is not the specific algorithm or the lengths to which one must <a href="https://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2013/03/09/here-come-encryption-apps/">air gap that algorithm</a> to make it truly secure. When six-and-a-half billion literate humans care about cryptography they care about higher levels of abstraction. “Can my government see my casserole recipe? Can the police see these naked photos of me? Can the 4chan trolls rally a small army of the socially inept to make rape and death threats against my family?”</p><p>One fourth of that global literate population uses WhatsApp today and with every message they send they are taking encryption for granted, whether they know it or not. For them, <em>it is granted</em>. WhatsApp has no option to turn e2e encryption off. Users can dump their unencrypted messages on Google Drive but they will always be encrypted in flight for a definition of “always” that equates to “as long as Facebook, Inc. sees fit.”</p><p>As an entrepreneur or software architect, you have little choice about whether or not you encrypt the messages your software creates or consumes. If those messages are essential to the success of your business, sooner or later you will encrypt them. When you do, you will care about the algorithms you choose. Your users, on the other hand, will care when and if your choice fails to keep them safe. Your B2C users don’t want to be spied on and your B2B users don’t want their business laid bare for other entities to train their AI models on. In less than a decade, the act of encrypting data means as much to the average business as paper shredding did in the previous decade. In another decade, expect every business to put “encryption” in the same essential asset category as “email server.” In the grand scheme of things it probably doesn’t matter much which email server you choose — but you definitely have one.</p><p>How will businesses guarantee that this essential feature of encryption is trustworthy and sustainable in the services they pay for? No business owner trusts their entire company to Facebook, Inc. or Slack, Inc. Those who do so will quickly reconsider the moment a staff member checks her Slack messages while attending a wedding in Iran. Whoops! The whole company is banned from Slack because she has friends in other countries. Again, keep in mind that the problem isn’t <em>Slack</em> but Slack’s <em>business model</em>. Keybase, for all its fancy encryption, is no better.</p><p>Sensible businesses cannot put their faith in a single corporation or even a single government; change at that scale happens too quickly in the 21st century. Since encryption over a single point of failure is meaningless the businesses of the coming decade will inevitably stop relying on services with a single point of failure.</p><h3>Federation</h3><p>Services need to be federated. Slack can <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/slackban">close down your company’s account without notice</a>, Uber can <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/ellenhuet/2014/10/30/uber-driver-firing-policy">fire you without reason or recourse</a>, and Dropbox can <a href="https://www.zdnet.com/article/dropbox-faces-questions-over-claims-of-improper-data-sharing/">share “anonymized” data about your files</a> you thought you had safely stored in “the cloud”.</p><p>Some folks in the tech industry tend to throw around “distributed” as a synonym but that word already carries some heavy connotations and dilutes the understanding of the user as to which risk it mitigates. Slack, Uber, AWS, and Google are distributed for some definition of “distributed.” They operate in multiple data centres in multiple countries. Their network architectures, data stores, and runtimes are all redundant. But they all share a common point of failure: the corporation. [2]</p><p>In <a href="https://www.ynharari.com/book/sapiens/"><em>Sapiens</em></a>, Harari solidified in our minds the understanding that homo sapiens’ shared belief in — and cooperation around — imaginary entities is what brought us our present success as a species. Some of these entities are more plastic than others. Money is more plastic than gods or states. In a world where we hand more and more control over to corporations in exchange for the useful services they provide, we need a method of introducing plasticity to corporations. This plasticity is called <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federation_(information_technology)"><em>federation</em></a>.</p><p>Federation is a little difficult to define because it is a nebulous concept which describes, well, a nebula. Federation in software is not all that different from its physical world counterparts. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative_federation">Cooperative federations</a>, for example, pool individual cooperative corporations into a unionized corporate body to achieve higher goals. Federated software services pool individual services into higher goals. Imagine that in 2028 the world governments get tired of a broken, centralized Facebook ruining all their elections; they dismantle Facebook and federate it. The federated Facebook of 2028 allows you to use any Facebook-compatible client to connect to any company running a Facebook-compatible service. Compatibility is defined by an Internet Engineering Task Force standardized RFC describing the Facebook Protocol and users choose a service provider which meet their needs: pay a monthly fee for an ad-free experience or use a free service which serves up ads and recommendations. Not happy with Service X? Move your data to Service Y. All your images, messages, and contacts are compatible across networks in the same way email messages from <strong>@deobald.ca</strong> can find their way to Gmail’s servers containing <strong>@gmail.com</strong> email addresses. The many Facebook services of the future each make a lot less money than the Facebook, Inc. of 2018 — but they also cause a lot less damage.</p><p>Federation, like encryption, lives on a spectrum. Thankfully, federation is easier for everyone to understand at various points along this spectrum. It also has many meaningful analogues in the physical world.</p><p>Everyone will have a different total ordering for the items on the federation spectrum but most people can probably agree on some basic partial orders. Open data formats are closer to federation than closed data formats. An API which accepts messages from a foreign server node is closer to federation than an open API which only accepts messages from clients. The blockchain is the most distributed and most federated networking technology — and we have negligible real uses for it. That sort of thing.</p><p>A sample total ordering might look like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/1*tiQpNJ7PfabUSPNaRk77KQ.png" /></figure><p>Not everyone is familiar with all of these concepts but most of these are easy to understand with examples. In 1998, an .xls file from Office ’98 was a closed data format. Google Maps provides an open, commercial API with a single point of failure. <a href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2616">HTTP</a> is a standardized protocol. <a href="https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc821">SMTP</a> and <a href="https://xmpp.org/extensions/">XMPP</a> are federated protocols. But the most successful federated services are easiest to understand when we use their household product names: Telephones. The Web. Email.</p><p>It is unreasonable to expect we will ever live in a utopia of perfectly-engineered federated services. Designing a good protocol is difficult and it’s often profitable in the short term to take an easier way out. But there is always value in pulling services to the right end of that spectrum, even if it’s just from <em>closed format</em> to <em>open format</em> or <em>closed API</em> to <em>open API</em>. Regardless, the clear unifying theme seen in those examples — which pulls them toward federation — is openness.</p><h3>Freedom</h3><p>Services need to be <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_software">Free</a>. It is hard to trust encryption software that isn’t Free or open source. WhatsApp <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/jan/13/whatsapp-design-feature-encrypted-messages">makes internal design trade-offs</a> and asks that you trust Facebook, Inc. not to build backdoors. Even if the loopholes of closed source encryption and threat of backdoors never materialize as failings, closed hardware ensures the <a href="https://www.wired.com/2017/03/wikileaks-cia-hack-signal-encrypted-chat-apps/">least trustworthy hardware</a> sits <a href="https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/07/26/german_cops_pwn_phones/">right in the hands of the user</a>.</p><p>It is equally hard to trust federated software that isn’t Free or open source. We trust SMTP servers like Microsoft Exchange and GMail to respect the protocol despite the fact that they are closed source; the SMTP protocol simply outweighs them. Newer protocols like Matrix and underused protocols like XMPP do not carry this weight and cooperation via federation demands that their first successful installations be Free. If the reference implementation of the Matrix server were closed source freeware or a Google service, users would have no reason to believe the protocol was destined for future success. What’s to stop Google from <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Talk">shutting down federation of closed source services</a>? Correct: nothing.</p><p>Innumerable time sheets have been thrown into the fires of the Free/open software debate and I don’t intend to do that here. [3] If you don’t already believe Free software carries <em>inherent</em> value, I want to convince you of that fact about as badly as I want to convert a climate change denier or explain the health and economic benefits of the smallpox vaccine to an anti-vaxxer. For everyone else, I want to explain the <em>mode</em> of Free software I’m suggesting.</p><p>I am not discussing Alpha Nerd open source. The labyrinth of open source libraries and tools on GitHub are not at issue here, nor are well-meaning hacker tools like <a href="https://plaintextaccounting.org/">plaintextaccounting.org</a> or org-mode. There are open source projects which succeed, to varying degrees, at marketing, design, profitability, <em>and</em> engineering. The designers of tomorrow’s protocols have their hands full as they will need to bake in all of these success factors from the ground up.</p><p>It is possible to design and build a successful, global, federated protocol in a suburban garage. It’s just a lot more likely to happen in the headquarters of a multinational corporation or the mailing list of a standards task force.</p><h3>The software ethics triangle, version 1.0</h3><p>I have worked on the structure of EFF Software for a long time and its initial incarnation looked something like this, in diagram form:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2iawN2JyVDom4WcRyO4Crw.png" /></figure><p>Notice that the original nodes of the triangle were outcomes, not prescriptions: code will be open, content will be owned by users, and only operations (services) will be charged for by software companies.</p><p>This diagram could be worse but it was more than a little naive and it did not announce a clear stakeholder: GDPR is decided by a multinational governing body but federation is largely a choice of a company providing a particular service. The triangle lacks symmetry.</p><p>The nodes (code, data, and operations) may at first appear to be technology-focused but they are, in fact, today’s business models. There are other names for these business models. Some would call it selling a product, a service, or data. Or SaaS, IP, and content. A company which exploits more nodes of the triangle has, in the short term, built a more fragile system in exchange for a more profitable business. Slack sells you use of their IP as SaaS and sells your data to third parties — that’s all three. Unless you’re an advertiser, Twitter and Facebook don’t sell users <em>anything</em> — remember that when software costs you $0.00 you are the inventory, not the customer. Their customers (advertisers) buy use of their IP as SaaS; that’s two nodes of the triangle. AWS arguably sells the least fragile system in this set of examples: SaaS, often built on open source IP.</p><p>To avoid wishful thinking about world governments, version 2 of this diagram is focused on engineers and technologists like those who work at the aforementioned companies. The scientific community went through a pubescent stage in which it learned to appreciate and apply ethics. The broad field of technology is now <a href="https://www.computer.org/web/education/code-of-ethics">screaming for ethical standards</a> and they are much easier to apply to historical software like Twitter, Slack, and Uber than they are to disruptive AI and biotech. A strong ethical base in today’s software will help ensure we make fewer mistakes with tomorrow’s. Hence, the triangle looks more like this now, quickly doodled in marker:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pZhEvhQrai3uB1ZE5G0Svg.jpeg" /></figure><p>EFF (Encrypted, Federated, Free) Systems are ethical. They do a better job in an environment of ethical regulation but they do not require it. These are merely the pillars of well-engineered ethical systems which, as a bonus, avoid fragility.</p><h3>The sexy ethics of design and the boring ethics of policy-making</h3><p>Every contemplative hacker I know thinks about policy, even if it is largely out of their hands. My old colleague Shafeeq once described its universal nature:</p><blockquote>Governments regulate the wireless spectrum precisely because it is a national resource. The services built on top of regulated resources become inherently federated and it seems like the time is ripe to regulate one of the nation’s most precious resources: the privacy of its citizens.</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/s/612588/its-time-for-a-bill-of-data-rights/">Martin Tisné agrees</a>, but suggests that data ownership will soon not be enough and governments need to go a step further to construct a bill of data rights. He seems to assume Free software as part of his ethical framework for his imagined future of data rights:</p><blockquote>The team examines the algorithm used by the study and discovers the link to the employment profiling.</blockquote><p>“Examine the algorithm” means “read the source code.” If we hope to have data ethics applied at this level, we had better we build a solid foundation for our lawmakers.</p><p>Policy ethics are boring ethics not because they don’t matter but because we have so little agency over them as technologists. The fight is worth fighting but unless you work at the EFF or the FSF, the fight probably isn’t your day job.</p><p>On the other hand, when we hear “design” many of us still conjure up images of architecture magazines and slick iPhone apps. Ethical design tends to be a lot less sexy and a lot more hard work. The hard work we put into federation prevents vendor lock-in; the hard work we put into localization and internationalization prevents culture and language lock-in. With any luck, policy will guide, and even enforce, good design but the ethics of EFF Systems must coincide with questions like “does this run on low-power devices?” and “will message delivery be guaranteed in areas of weak network connectivity?”</p><p>We can’t build everything all at once. You will be forced to choose between the EFF pillars and design. Leave yourself room to grow.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*u6AQuv6oh-vVjZoeMXJErg.png" /><figcaption>The Software Ethics Triangle</figcaption></figure><p>This ridiculous doodle [4] is our final Software Ethics Triangle. The nodes of the triangle are our pillars, all interdependent: Encrypted and federated services necessitate open source licensing. Federated software which sends unencrypted messages isn’t safe and encryption without federation guarantees that sooner or later, you will lose access to the service or lose your encryption. Open source software services which lack encryption or federation are as backward as any equivalent closed source software. The three pillars form a totality. Design is not a pillar; ethical design is what will make your service a success above and beyond its bare utility. Policy sits outside of, but adjacent to, design. Your software company probably has little agency over policy but policy may dictate that you design ethically.</p><h3>What will you build next?</h3><p>If I had written this article in 1999 when winner-take-all business models were all the rage in the software industry, I’d sound like a nut. Or perhaps I’d just have an entry in <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/StallmanWasRight/"><em>/r/StallmanWasRight</em></a> now. But I wouldn’t be singing in tune with a household understanding of software systems. These days, it’s a weekly (if not daily) occurrence to have even the mainstream media shout at us that we should be re-reading Stallman and Doctorow. From every sort of nontechnical user I hear the complaints. “Why can’t the police just check if the phones are doing something evil?” and “How can a company possibly keep my data without my permission?” To me, the answer is clear: one of the pillars is broken.</p><p>As the engineers of this disaster, let’s try a little harder when we pick our next jobs. Given the charges of this article, would you be happy to work at Slack today? Microsoft? Twitter? Facebook? Google? Amazon? Strava? Spotify? Medium? Uber? Go-Jek? Grab?</p><p>Under their current business models, I couldn’t work at any of them.</p><p>If Steve Yegge honestly believes that the big players have stopped innovating and the little guy is blazing a righteous new trail for the world’s users he might want to use the predictive function from <a href="https://medium.com/siggu/steve-yegge-you-are-half-right-part-one-5560054e2922">my previous article</a> to anticipate just what sort of outcomes he’s a party to.</p><p>[1] Yes, WhatsApp released encryption based on the Signal Protocol in 2014. However, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WhatsApp#End-to-end_encryption">release to all platforms and an official announcement</a> which put it in the public eye wasn’t until 2016.</p><p>[2] As feedback for this article, a friend suggested non-profits as a sustainable alternative to corporations. In the context of federation, where federation distributes responsibility of the service to more nodes of the network, what <em>brand</em> of single point of failure you choose is irrelevant: a corporation is a religion is a government is a university is a non-profit. All imagined entities share the fragility of <em>being imaginary.</em> Little strength is gained by choosing a better imaginary friend. Strength comes from diversification.</p><p>It’s worth remembering there’s no clear hierarchy to federation and distribution, either, but in general: more actors is preferable to fewer actors, trustworthy actors are preferable to bad actors, and a protocol which defines an evolving system architecture is preferable to one which hopes to get it all perfect the first time (even if it’s not the first time). There are systems which, initially, require centralization. It’s hard to imagine a federated Airbnb or TransferWise <em>the first time around</em>. But, whether in two years or in twenty, the design of TransferWise will be no more interesting or revolutionary than ride-share services are today. If the solution to the problem statement <em>I want to easily and legally move rupees out of India online</em> is still the monopoly of TransferWise in 20 years, we’ve spent 20 years wasting a lot of resources on a very boring problem.</p><p>[3] I will use “Free” and “open” interchangeably for most of the article. I’m picking my battles and I make no apologies.</p><p>[4] If you have the <a href="https://homestarrunner.com/sbemail58.html"><em>Skills of an Artist</em></a> and care to replace this with a more polished drawing, I will happily accept such donations.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc19e1abca46" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/siggu/eff-software-fc19e1abca46">EFF Software Ethics</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/siggu">Siggu</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>