<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Oleg Derrunda on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Oleg Derrunda on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@derrunda?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 10:47:32 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@derrunda/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Duration of Ruins]]></title>
            <link>https://rocknheavy.net/the-duration-of-ruins-e3ea8a70602c?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3ea8a70602c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[greek-mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[odyssey]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oleg Derrunda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Oct 2026 18:49:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-15T16:50:38.098Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Christopher Nolan’s <em>The Odyssey</em> and the Changing Shape of Victory</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8bZzGfhGPiFdtJ6ROHetFg.png" /><figcaption>Official poster for <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><h4>Overcoming Distances</h4><p>Our world has heard the <em>Odyssey</em> bequeathed by Homer thousands of times. Having received the name of an ancient hero as a gift, the epic acquired, over the centuries, a double that outgrew it into a common noun and gathered a multitude of new stories into itself. The king of Ithaca yielded his place to new characters, passing on the hardships of the road as an inheritance. Today an odyssey may directly recall the distant past or serve as an expressive image, in either case evoking a long journey filled with dangers and unexpected turns.</p><p>Its rebirth as a concept bearing existential weight spared it the fate of becoming a synonym for mere travel, with its linear course and goal, a plotted route and human control. The element of an odyssey is the sea, where a compass set by will or fate matters more than a map, for the road itself leads the traveler.</p><p>And every journey ends in something. Perhaps the only thing one can be certain of carrying away from it is a memory of the journey itself. The gaze that once had to anticipate what lay ahead in order to find its bearings in a world without signposts turns back, seeing everything as it is able to imagine it. At times it makes the person who bears it a participant in events, and at others it draws that person away, inviting a view of the scattered wreckage of what happened as though it were something alien. For all the factual reality of what took place, imagination never relinquishes its singular part: it stitches together patches of past episodes that cannot be summoned all at once, arranging them into a flawless sequence. Two contrary movements, one anticipating the journey and the other returning to it, establish the poles of the shifting world of interpretation.</p><p>Returning to a work, whether book or film, also resembles a journey. There is a point of entry and a point of exit, and it leaves memories that change along with us. Passage through fiction literally unfolds as an overcoming of time, measured in pages, frames, running time, and the mere movement of clock hands accompanying the intellectual effort. Interpretations are generally indulgent toward walks through the outskirts of a work’s principal meanings. They even favor justified departures from the main route and the play of associations, since the guiding thread lies in the interpreter’s hands. Yet any persuasive interpretation still keeps, in one way or another, to the principal road emerging from the work as it unfolds in reception.</p><p>This balance calls for an important premise: the work being interpreted possesses a frozen arrangement. Add the figure of the author, and the echo of the maker’s intention joins it. We can go a step further and say that the completion of the work is a constant of that work, the reason it is not merely endowed with a structure but possesses it as part of its own nature. Umberto Eco called this <em>intentio operis</em>, the intention of the work: its internal meaning and logic, beyond the ambitions of either author or reader. Discerning that intention protects interpretation from license that would turn analysis into reflection and a stream of associations.</p><p>Christopher Nolan’s work has many predecessors. Still, it does not sound in perfect unison with them, and thus freezes between a repetition of Homer’s story and a common noun — as an oblique telling. Arising, then, not out of nowhere, it lets us see the filmmaker’s decisions, the fundamental departures from the original narrative that bear witness to a choice, along with less consequential decisions that follow from the major shifts.</p><p>Entering Christopher Nolan’s <em>The Odyssey</em> is another journey, one that leads away from the film and back to it. Alongside judgments drawn from the categories of “good” and “bad,” we can address Nolan’s film with a neutral gaze, taking it strictly as a work conceived and realized by its maker. This set of axioms gives us a foothold for speaking about the meaning-generating arrangement of Nolan’s <em>Odyssey</em>, and, separately, for a symbolic interpretation that lays a weaker claim to the unconditional validity of its findings.</p><p>If our purpose is to understand the design legible in the film itself, we must locate where the work becomes independent, attaining the maturity that allows it to be called auteur cinema: at once self-sufficient and open to new memories. The foundations of the structure that gave rise to a new <em>Odyssey</em> grow out of Nolan’s fascination with the central motifs of the story Homer told. Our journey therefore begins beyond the film.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aXHapklrfXj8F3z1zitfQA.png" /><figcaption>Film still from Interstellar (2014), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Paramount Pictures / Warner Bros. Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>Nolan’s creative career already contains a reprise of the <em>Odyssey</em>. It is <em>Interstellar</em>, a journey on a cosmic scale. Matthew McConaughey’s character, Cooper, also left home in answer to a summons, then remained away for an extraordinary length of time, at one point vanishing even from part of his crew and disrupting the narrative’s chronotope. He managed to break through the obstacles, plunging into a whirlpool of time and space to reach a home that had become different. Yet Cooper returns — and does not stay: he finds his daughter dying and almost immediately sets off once more. His return, then, places a full stop, but one that cannot hold the ending in place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6Qnzc0EWUZnUn4RCcxj24A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Film still from Dunkirk (2017), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Warner Bros. Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>Another significant clue is Nolan’s interest in time and space. Its fruits took shape in <em>Dunkirk</em>. Disconnected strands of narrative stretch the fabric of the plot, pursuing one another at different tempos of events. They trace their courses through the same theater of war, but across three measures of time — a week, a day, and an hour — until they converge at a single point.</p><p>There is reason to believe that Nolan carried an image of the <em>Odyssey</em> in his mind for many years, although we are, of course, powerless to enter the cradle of his work — his consciousness and imagination. What we can say is that a change of scenery and props is not enough to give an odyssey a new incarnation or to fill its journey with drama. One can alter the relation to a road already traveled, one can transform the course of wandering, yet the decisive part still belongs to the logic of a counterforce to motion. A force that reduces leagues upon leagues of distance to the unimaginable difficulty of a single step, and decades to a few minutes capable of overturning everything. The journey then acquires genuinely existential overtones and resembles an act of creation, in which, as is well known, the hardest part is to begin and to put the final full stop.</p><p>In <em>The Odyssey</em>, the director’s two interests meet. Space defines the distances between hearths of human settlement, with their hopes, aspirations, and values. Time measures the delay between an act and its meaning. Both distances demand to be overcome, and both seem capable of being overcome: the sea can be crossed, the years waited out.</p><p>What, then, resists completion in <em>The Odyssey</em>?</p><h4>Tale and the Production of the Past</h4><p>Nolan opens his film with a feast on Ithaca, one of the countless feasts that have depleted the storerooms day after day, without end, for years. An unnamed storyteller, played by Travis Scott, takes the floor. He holds a staff, marking the caesuras with it as he utters a handful of words capacious enough to contain both the pain of defeat and the joy of victory.</p><p>Homer’s <em>Odyssey</em> begins differently, more than three hundred lines before this scene, with the council of the gods, Athena’s intercession, and the reception Telemachus gives her, disguised as a traveler, according to every rule of hospitality. Only then does Phemius sing to those gathered in the kingless palace of the bitter homecomings of the Achaeans, until Penelope interrupts him, longing to hear what she cannot yet hear.</p><p>Besides displacing the poem’s first lines, Nolan adds two more telling strokes to the opening. He places a staff in the storyteller’s hands, an attribute of the rhapsode, or itinerant reciter. Unlike “rhapsode,” which entered Greek usage later and appears, for instance, in Plato’s <em>Ion</em>, the word <em>aoidos</em> belongs to the poem itself. Yet Nolan gives the nameless singer, credited as “bard,” an instrument firmly associated with the later profession, and epochs blur within a single figure. One traditional account of the word “rhapsode,” moreover, understands it as a “stitcher of song.” Several minutes after the opening scene, we see Penelope at her loom, unraveling what she wove during the day, and it turns out that singer and queen practice the same craft with opposite signs.</p><p>As for the name of Homer’s singer, missing from the credits, it has not vanished without a trace. Echoing the ancient Greek φήμη — rumor, speech, prophetic word — it passes in the film to a man in Odysseus’s crew. The name of rumor belongs to one who will die, while the one destined to pass on the story remains unnamed.</p><p>Thus the first echo of the celebrated war comes from a storyteller who knows it through other people’s memories, and contracts into a few words. “A face, a fleet, a war, a man, a thought, a trick — a trick to break the walls of Troy and burn it screaming to the ground!” Each listener receives a small portion of signs, like knots drawing together scraps of memory that survived along with the witnesses to the conflict.</p><p>The story has an indisputable order of signs, and this, it seems, is what everyone knows. A schematic sketch from the outbreak of strife to its conclusion: Helen, war, horse, victory. Yet even that unquestioned dotted line still lacks meaning and substance, leads nowhere, and so no one quite knows what that victory meant. The pressing question occupies the starting point of the film’s meaning-generating construction.</p><p>Gradually the film enlarges its circle of narrators, and we encounter six different views of events twenty and eight years in the past, framing the military campaign.</p><p>The singer, or bard, gives voice to public memory. He shows what everyone knows and, more importantly, how an event has been compressed into a striking sequence of signs ready to absorb new particulars. His voice needs no name, for an epic is being produced from the events at Troy.</p><p>Penelope pulls us back into what is the present for every character. She has had enough of the song of her husband’s martial exploits, his image mired in recurring memories, and of a triumph that has become, for her, another name for captivity among uninvited guests. Her response introduces a note of personal pain into the shared legend — the price she must pay hour by hour, from which the trophies of “victory” offer no release.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3duYe-t2gOk_yUsKgj_kQA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Tom Holland as Telemachus in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The third perspective belongs to Telemachus, a son raised without a father and an heir without a memory. He does not remember the war at all. For him Troy belongs to the present, where the outlines of myth meet the expectation he shares with his mother. From fragments of the past he must assemble his father, and himself as well, because with a parent who remains a spectral figure he lacks any clear status in his own home. So, heeding the advice of a wanderer who attended yet another feast, he sets out for Menelaus, hoping to learn Odysseus’s fate.</p><p>For other inhabitants of the ancient oikoumene, too, Odysseus’s return is part of a myth. It has passed beyond the horizon of the visible, lost on a map of frozen figures. Menelaus, offering the fourth perspective, takes up precisely where the song left off. We hear the memory of a victor and a professional warrior. His account carries us into the most confined space in the entire film — the belly of the Trojan horse — and presents Odysseus’s plan as deliverance from an irresolvable siege, a brilliant feat of arms. The recollection stops short of what might alter the meaning of victory when Menelaus tells Telemachus, “I think you know the rest.” But Telemachus does not know. He came precisely to be delivered from that blindness. Menelaus applies a formula of common knowledge to someone who does not possess it, and transmission breaks off out of courtesy, for myth presupposes a listener who already knows it and lives within it. The architecture of triumph disappears from sight again, concealing the nature of the deed beneath the myth of a victory sanctioned by the gods, its skeleton now bearing a little more flesh.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dzpHlxW4q_yvTgxZ0f1NAA.png" /><figcaption>Jon Bernthal as Menelaus in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>Homer’s Menelaus, unlike Nolan’s, offers more information. He tells Telemachus what Proteus said about Odysseus being held by Calypso. By removing this episode, Nolan closes off a crucial direct channel through which the horizon, obscured by an endless refrain, might have opened a little, foreshadowing an end to the various repetitions. Odysseus’s return thus remains a spectral possibility, something like a vestige in the biography of the living.</p><p>Here we begin to look at the past through Odysseus’s eyes, receiving a participant’s counter-narrative. He gives explicit content to the bard’s last words, restoring murder, a law violated through deception, and his own responsibility to the legend. Yet his version, too, reaches the spectator differently than in the original poem. Nolan dispenses with the staging of the long succession of verses describing Odysseus’s encounter with the Phaeacians. At this point the main contrast between the poem and its adaptation is achieved by subtracting two features.</p><p>The Phaeacians’ reception, as Homer depicts it, is suffused with peace. There Odysseus tells his misfortunes in the first person, spanning the war and his encounters with mythical beings and peoples. The inhabitants of Scheria are portrayed as a prosperous, well-oiled social machine, where hospitality and trust can still be the norm — an impossibility in the world Nolan recreates. In contrast with the original verses, discord and tension reign there, making it difficult to receive a stranger and take that stranger at his word at the same time. The changes reach Odysseus as well. In Nolan’s film, whenever he plunges into memory, he must break through a veil hiding the past, a veil he himself has cast over it. Reminiscences arise in fragments and with difficulty, like flashes of illumination sent as punishment. The director thereby takes away his protagonist’s right to tell his own story. Memory instead overtakes the man who willingly rejected it, so that it may be drawn out of him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mVypWG6sYfbEjdJlP7tnhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Robert Pattinson as Antinous in The Odyssey (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The last perspective gathers around Antinous, pieced together from truths about him told by Eumaeus, the blind swineherd, and much later by Sinon, who fell at Troy, as well as from Antinous’s own lies. He invents the past as he goes, deliberately writing himself into the present and thus forestalling questions about his presence among the living. According to him, Odysseus graciously left him on Ithaca to look after Telemachus and Penelope. Despite their conflicting disclosures, Antinous’s and Eumaeus’s accounts have points in common. The viewer’s preference for one or the other is guided by sympathies arising from the characters’ behavior. Yet these disparate lines of memory cannot be fully disentangled, for they seek confirmation from the figure of a man who is absent and saw everything from beginning to end.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qp2n6Xkx5Jjc4AauD-Yc6g.png" /><figcaption>Lupita Nyong’o as Helen in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The six perspectives we have encountered dispute the outcome, but there is a seventh that disputes the origin. The nature of the war — its cause — begins to unravel as well. Helen, celebrated as the most beautiful of women, bears a scar on her face and, at Menelaus’s feast, scarcely receives a glance from her husband or anyone else. Her beauty is cut in half, and Menelaus likewise halves the fleet when he says that of the thousand ships that sailed for her, five hundred remain. To the doubts planted by her appearance, Helen adds words spoken at the table and later whispered to Telemachus in farewell: she can hardly serve as a complete justification for the war and its dead, being only an echo of a beautiful, convenient story. Her reluctance to become an apologia for a long and bloody struggle resonates with the parting conversation between Odysseus and Penelope, when the king of Ithaca observes that Helen is rather a pretext concealing Agamemnon’s ambitions for power.</p><p>This distinction between a publicly acknowledged occasion and the deeper causes of the conflict has a strong affinity with ancient historiographical thought, though there is no reason to assert that Nolan intended an allusion to Thucydides. The celebrated author of the <em>History of the Peloponnesian War</em> distinguished the grievances openly advanced by the opposing sides from what he called the “truest cause”, least often spoken of aloud, or <em>prophasis</em>: the growth of Athenian power and the fear it inspired in Sparta. Thucydides’ language bears a notable kinship with the medical thinking of his time, accustomed to distinguishing a visible symptom from the source of an illness concealed in the depths. Nolan similarly divides the antagonism surrounding Helen, pointing toward the story people believe and the prosaic motives visible behind it. The move harmonizes with the tale’s central concern: the origin of the war is as dependent on interpretation as its consequences.</p><p>All the major and minor discrepancies coexist within a single fabric capable of accommodating them. The topos of the Trojan War runs like a common thread through the divided memories, even as each gradually veers away from the others, diverging and disappearing into the enclosed perspective being drawn. The collapse of a single narrative, its seams unraveling, is echoed by the ordeals of the returning Greek fleet and the disintegration of human bonds between islands scattered across vast archipelagos. It gapes in the atmosphere of the age itself, casting twilight across past and future. The war ended comparatively recently and its participants are still alive, yet it is already surrounded by myths growing apart from one another, and is itself becoming a myth. As direct testimony gives way to song, participants preserve dimming shards of the past, Odysseus suppresses what happened and flees it, and the consequences keep redrawing the meaning of victory itself — the mythologizing of the war outruns its transformation into a past that can be understood, and the war prematurely takes on the spectral aspect of antiquity. In the end, antiquity, governed by the rules of myths and legends, is born not from a distance of three thousand years. Its <em>prophasis</em>, its true cause, is that the world already finds it difficult to reach what has happened to it.</p><p>The conflict and the tale told of it are almost the last things to retain meaning in this world and to make possible an oikoumene in which peoples live alongside one another. The film seems to begin after its own catastrophe. Its events still precede the Bronze Age collapse, but the first thing Nolan shows is the form in which such a world will be able to survive its own physical disappearance. If we temper that hyperbole, there remains, at the very least, the sensation of standing on the brink of disintegration.</p><p>The account of Agamemnon’s homecoming offers one last flash of a fullness already lost. For a moment the past regains its splendor, filling with objects and visual definition. A brief reminiscence depicts the picturesque life of a ruler and triumphant conqueror, only to reveal the final break, exposing an antiquity that refuses to submit and the fragility of the human world.</p><p>The open spaces Nolan shows are striking in their immensity. Often generously flooded with sunlight, they bear almost no traces of human presence. Settled places, by contrast, are low, cramped, sharply localized, barely piercing the darkness with little lights from torches and braziers. The arrangement produces an asymmetry in which the camera sees a world far wider than the characters can inhabit or are prepared to comprehend.</p><p>Human dwelling occupies tiny islets upon the colossal masses of actual islands and continents, resembling archipelagos with names of their own but without rightful masters. Just as oral performance wanders while huddling in dim, man-made light, so the characters move among spaces illuminated by the faint glow of their own grandeur. The visibility of so little amid the breadth of surrounding reality determines the distribution of signs in <em>The Odyssey</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uRHAPPlhNvH_47-oNQ1vJw.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The main dramatic collisions that weave together and pull apart human destinies take place within exceptionally narrow bounds. They unfold on confined stages, whether in the palaces of Ithaca and Sparta, in Polyphemus’s cave, aboard a ship, at Circe’s house, in a clearing in the woods, or inside the horse. By this logic, the horse becomes the ultimate expression of human deeds. A vast historical catastrophe begins not on a visible battlefield crowded with soldiers and feats of arms. Instead, it unfolds inside the most constricted artificial space, where the decision of many is concentrated before spreading outward in destructive waves.</p><p>Those waves are powerful, for they crush the memory of what has been. Distances obstruct their transformation into new events, slowing the spread of consequences and often turning the thunder of deeds into a faint echo. Despite the natural continuity with which the future arrives, filling the present with events, almost every character is condemned to remain in a particular place. The Trojan War carries such weight that passing it by, simply ignoring it, is unthinkable — it has already woven together a great many lives. Everyone must peer into the past, not out of enchantment but because, for the moment, there is nothing else to be done. Its effect has become a chronotope of its own, like a labyrinth: each step is a step within a past not yet sufficiently broken open, a past that affords no footing for further movement. All become heirs to an already distant conflict without the right to dispose of this past. It resists, it overtakes them as punishment, the offspring of crimes and errors.</p><p>Perhaps the only character who deals sovereignly with the past is Circe. She lived as a recluse, and the military campaign to which the oikoumene sent its sons passed her by. Her world is small, but she gathers it around herself: unlike other dwellings, her house is filled with things taken from unlucky travelers and with ordinary household objects. She learns what is new and, more than that, remembers and understands what is happening well enough to guide Odysseus. The future, meanwhile, scarcely interests her, which may be what gives the travelers from Ithaca the alignment they need between their intentions and her powers. They must make sense of their past in order to escape the loop of blind wandering. From a labyrinth in which every path leads back, Circe points toward an exit no one would seek inside a labyrinth. She sends them downward, into the depths of the past — to Hades, where the countless fallen will appear before the surviving crew and blind Tiresias will show them the way home. Thus Circe redraws the geometry of the odyssey.</p><p>Human time, meanwhile, belongs to a different tempo, slowly spreading through the oikoumene until its most turbulent portion — the events wrought by the conquerors of Troy — finally comes to rest in an equilibrium that can be grasped. The past reaches its utmost depth when the present touches the eternity of the underworld, and for a moment it seems history may now move forward. Hades reveals the scale of a past resistant to any final severance. Distance and time steadily thin the ties running between the communities of the oikoumene. News arrives late, deeds and their consequences outrun those who made them and break away. An earlier unity that promised a positive outcome from interaction gives way to a negative one. The new unity rests upon a myth of threat. The secret of this threat, forever distant in time from the characters and only ever catching up with them, is the rejected truth about the victorious campaign and those who took part in it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IQC98UB_PMHr0f7m6lVyrQ.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The long-awaited future enters the film as an ill omen. It is present as a rustle coming from the traces of what is not yet before the eyes, and this is precisely why the meaning of what occurs lags behind the occurrence itself. The world is compelled to return to the past, finding fresh testimony there each time and inevitably losing something. Searching merges with wandering, while repetition gradually reveals traces previously unseen, from which the future begins. Yet these too may become distorted, for the thread of the labyrinth is held in human hands.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8BqN7RzVB6mStBI02yQiUg.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><h4>Tokens of the Future</h4><p>The condition of the past, its scraps separated by great distances and growing together out of order before they can fall into their proper sequence, brings the question of witnesses and testimony to the surface. Nolan places the turns of <em>The Odyssey</em> on the threshold of the Late Bronze Age collapse. Around the twelfth century BCE, much of the former administrative and economic system falls with the Mycenaean palace centers. There follows the period traditionally called the Greek “Dark Ages.” Linear B, used for palace recordkeeping, also disappears. With the palaces, the world loses one of its institutional ways of recording the order of its existence. Several centuries later, the world of the Greek poleis will arise in place of the old order, and writing will return with it, now alphabetic.</p><p>Nolan’s <em>Odyssey</em>, accordingly, records a decline. Its archives, once collecting what people knew of themselves, have also gone missing. Until the film’s ending, we hear nothing of records and see no texts or tablets. Proof here runs into questions for which no documentary answer can refer us to written sources. Indications of the past must be sought in accounts, and they reside in objects and in marks on the body as well. This latter pair possesses a peculiar material endurance, yet that in itself guarantees no understanding, for evidence may survive the few people capable of discerning its meaning. Both the film and Homer’s poem are filled with such vulnerable systems of recognition, binding small groups of people together.</p><p>Odysseus, who draws the expectations of almost every major character toward himself, can be recognized by only a handful. Argos the dog knows his master stands before him without needing confirmation. Once a hunting dog, Argos has lost the power to pursue prey or influence what happens. Like the faithful servants, he has preserved his former bond with his master while the whole household changed under the sway of other people’s claims and stories. His entire being is directed toward a single gesture, and once he has performed it, he dies. Old Eurycleia, a servant in the Ithacan palace, recognizes her lord by his scar when she washes his feet after he has returned in the guise of a stranger bearing news Penelope has long awaited. Penelope tests the genuineness of the reports about her husband with the fibula. The bow establishes the master of the house through action: only the former or the new king of Ithaca — either way, the genuine one — can string it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2Oce_-wtGoNsjq9v3LXSYg.png" /><figcaption>Kate Fuglei as Eurycleia in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The problem of marks of the past that secure the legitimacy of the future brings us to the concept of <em>ekphrasis</em>. It is a term from the schoolroom, emerging from the <em>progymnasmata</em>, the elementary exercises in rhetoric. It was defined as speech that circles an object and sets it before the eyes. The essential quality of ekphrasis was <em>enargeia</em>. Broadly speaking, it gave an impression of immediate presence, a vividness that turns the listener into a spectator. The textbook narrowing of ekphrasis to “a representation of a representation” is a twentieth-century convention, whereas originally enargeia, and ekphrasis through it, belonged to a technique of testimony that allowed one person to see what they had not witnessed and, in doing so, to believe.</p><p>We watch Odysseus tell Penelope a story about himself as though about another person, in effect resorting to ekphrasis and enargeia. His testimony, grounded in the description of an object that persuades Penelope of his words’ truth, grows into an account of his own biography. A similar mechanism operates in the other characters’ memories. Identity is thus attested by the memory borne by a body or an object, or through a redistribution of trust between people. In this company, Eumaeus’s blindness is all the more striking because his Homeric counterpart can see. Nolan deprives him of sight while preserving his ability to hold the past of other people.</p><p>Each of these means of recognition is intensely personal and intimate. Each depends on particular people or objects, making their very existence a necessary condition for the continued memory of the past. And on reflection, outside a few exceptional circumstances, such a logic is fundamentally insufficient to draw scattered communities into a single civilization. Odysseus, like the other veterans of the Trojan War, has many lives intertwined with his own, but often they belong to only one household or a few. The binding force needed for an interconnected inhabited world is supplied by the ideal — <em>xenia</em>, or what Nolan’s film calls Zeus’s law.</p><p>Scholars understand xenia as a law of hospitality and a bond between households, which is to say, between different communities. It entails three rules. A host must first feed, give drink to, and warm the traveler, acquiring only afterward the right to ask who the stranger is and why they have come. An unspoken alliance arises between guest and host, hence the prohibition on attack. Finally, on parting they exchange gifts. Xenia appears repeatedly in Homeric epic, for example in the <em>Iliad</em>, when Glaucus and Diomedes stop fighting upon discovering that their grandfathers were linked by hospitality shown to one another, and exchange armor in the midst of battle. The bond thus passes to descendants, binding ever more people together. This is that <em>“greatest thing”</em> capable of embracing all people, from departed ancestors to living descendants, across distances and local cultural boundaries. It resembles a shared memory, and perhaps Nolan demonstrates as much symbolically in the encounter with the dead, the most expansive episode by the film’s own measure. Though human beings always have more future than past, here the future pales beside its twilight twin.</p><p>Reinterpreting xenia, Nolan gives pride of place to its sacred sanction and renames it Zeus’s law. The theological emphasis supplements its ethical content, reminding us that the stranger may be the Thunderer himself in disguise, so that breaking the law threatens an irreparable error and divine wrath. The foundation of civilization, then, rests on certain possibilities being withheld, on principle, from use against another person. Yet we see common gods and their memory used to cause harm. The Trojan questioning the dying Sinon explains his decision to admit the horse in a few words: “Common gods. Respect their offering.” He is right, for Greeks and Trojans pray to the same gods and observe the same rites. Shared boundaries ought therefore to remain boundaries even in enmity. His being right is what kills him, initiating a distortion that touches space and time, spreading as an invisible flaw.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8wi-kbh4eLPuaswg4ILxrQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Anne Hathaway as Penelope in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>News of the Sea Peoples spreads through the oikoumene, their motives obscure and their movements following an unknown beat. They remain unseen, like the binding force that eludes the eye, yet they have a name because they matter to people. Penelope weaves a burial shroud and unravels its threads at night, preventing the work from being completed. The suitors feast every night. The ending of this succession of events, growing into one another, belongs to an uncertain future. Time seems to flow more slowly, thickening and congealing into recurring forms: the same shroud, the same feast, the same waiting. The present comes apart between expectation and recollection, and beneath it a threat that has no face yet opens up. The victory at Troy, which never received a final meaning in the moment of victory, is redefined by wandering, the threat of the Sea Peoples, disintegration, return, song, and finally Homer’s <em>Odyssey</em> itself and Nolan’s film. Each time, meaning exists through the traces of earlier interpretations and shifts once more.</p><p>None of this is enough to break open the succession of repetitions and give rise to an event that would shift not only the local meaning of the past but also the structure now permeating the order of the world. Repetition gives an image duration, and the present is spent sustaining the intensity of what has already happened. The feast eats through the house, triumph through lives, the song’s refrain through the meaning of victory. How, then, can the relentlessness of a frozen “now” be resolved, if even Odysseus’s return fails to place a full stop at the end of the road? What can the future rest upon at all? As the film has it, the slaves are left to keep faith with the future. Their insignificance — social and in terms of screen time — is offset by the weight of their words and deeds. They belong to their places, from which they often set the plot in motion, preserving the continuity of human relationships. Alongside them stand politically free people whose existence is far more deeply enslaved. They are in bondage to their situation, fixed to a place and to repeated actions, faithful to the ambitions with which they entered their predicament.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BKWwdCSRbPNDGbR680A3XQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Benny Safdie as Agamemnon in The Odyssey (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>Personal ambition drives Agamemnon, who gathered the Greeks around him, and likewise draws the suitors around Antinous, who also seems to be regarded as a leader and to whom they have long since ceded the right to claim the throne. The path of the great king, who sacrificed so much to realize his design, brings him back to a home turned hostile — the final outcome of his life. The triumph upon whose altar so many lives were laid sets a limit, closing in upon itself and excluding the king. Thus it closes the doors to the past, preserving it in the form of a tightly drawn knot of legends and prophecies, above which Agamemnon can no longer rise and with which he cannot exist as an equal. As for Antinous, who won his position through deception by inventing a past and interweaving many lives, that lie swallows him too, turning him into a figure of the past who cannot exist outside the very myth it produced.</p><p>Odysseus and Telemachus, who has embarked on a miniature journey of his own, are guided in turn by regret and love. Feelings rooted in the worth of another person join risk with sincere faith and hope. For all their prosaic quality, they stand in sharp contrast to the surrounding world, locally taking the place of civilization’s eroded foundation and revealing still more clearly how far that foundation is subject to people. The law of hospitality was understood as a common good that could be turned into an instrument when necessary. Love and attachment are experienced more personally, and responsibility for them is more readily seen in the presence of another, which is why they are destined to become the last threads binding people together. As the fibula fastens Odysseus’s cloak, so this token of separation, promising reunion, binds him to Penelope and his native Ithaca.</p><h4>The Sign That Lies</h4><p>An apotropaic defense against lies, a guarantor of meaning’s absolute presence, is faith in shared gods and in retribution for treachery. Although the names of the ancient pantheon are heard, the immortals themselves have been almost entirely removed from the frame. The hardships that befall the conquerors of Troy read more like weather and bad luck than divine anger. The depth of the sacred appears chiefly in the actions of human beings themselves, who bear responsibility for humanity’s fate. This makes the paradox of faith in the inviolability of shared rules and ideals all the more conspicuous. In themselves, these remain hollow forms, filled with content by human belief. The more firmly that content takes root in people’s minds, the more dangerous becomes the possibility of preserving the familiar shell while replacing what lies within. It is faith in the impossibility of such substitution that turns a force opening the way to a shared future into a breach through which another person’s ambitions may enter.</p><p>The depths of the sacred, nonetheless, harbor a meaning that is not neutral: what promises favor to one side may bring the bitterness of defeat to another. The horse is accepted as an offering to Athena — literally a gift with a false bottom, like its makers’ designs or the nature of the campaign against Troy. In the Epic Cycle, Odysseus and Diomedes’ theft of the Palladium, the construction of the horse, and its dedication to Athena already stand together in one ill-fated sequence. Virgil would later place that sequence within Sinon’s lie, which presented the horse as atonement for the sacrilege committed in stealing the sacred image.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZdZ4TqMLrVqYUsZL8BtyXA.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>If the success of the horse can still be read as evidence that the gods favored military cunning, genuine sacrilege takes place within the besieged city. Before Odysseus’s eyes, in Nolan’s account, flashes the killing of a young priestess of Athena, set in parallel with the beheading of the goddess’s own statue. Troy then shares its end with its conquerors. In ancient tradition, the misfortunes of the homeward-bound Achaeans were already associated with sacrilege against Athena. In the prologue to Euripides’ <em>Trojan Women</em>, the goddess demands punishment after Ajax’s assault on Cassandra at her sanctuary and the other Greeks’ failure to intervene. Nolan retains the leitmotif of calamities descending on the returning conquerors, while reshaping the distribution of responsibility so that its center shifts ever more insistently toward Odysseus. He was not the executioner, but he opened the gates, setting in motion a chain of actions that could no longer be restrained.</p><p>The logic of consequences is sustained by other episodes of the journey as Nolan portrays them. Polyphemus calls on Poseidon and curses his tormentors. A tragic fate overtakes the remnants of Odysseus’s crew after the prohibition on the island of the sun god is broken. Each event takes place literally beside Odysseus, who in one instance gave the order outright and in another failed to remain sufficiently watchful. Beside him, too, appears the only image of an Olympian deity — Athena, accompanying him in the likeness of the murdered priestess and therefore of his guilt. A single act born of readiness to step beyond a common rule for the sake of victory becomes the beginning of a new order disfigured by crime. At the start of the film, the singer reduced the fall of Troy to the formula “a face, a fleet, a war, a man, a thought, a trick,” with “thought” sounding almost like praise for ingenuity. Now we see the belly once hidden behind the chain of signs: Odysseus’s small decision creates the conditions for an avalanche of deeds he is no longer able to control.</p><p>In a single night, as Troy falls, the disintegration of values reaches a paroxysm. The grand campaign that rallied the Greeks beneath their banners reduces their alliance, within hours, to a source of corruption, splitting the community apart. The road to a point comparable in intensity — not of crime now, but of remorse — is long. In the meantime guilt disperses among the victors, and homecoming increasingly takes the shape of catastrophe. Near the end, Odysseus and Telemachus spill blood in Athena’s temple and set the sanctuary alight. Deception in the goddess’s name, the killing of her servant, the burned temple — three desecrations directed at the one whose name once provided cover at the gates, allowing the Greeks to enter another people’s home. Only afterward does a second paroxysm arise in Odysseus’s biography, this one moral, answering the transgression with the intensity of acknowledgment when he finally accepts the connection between his own thought, which had bestowed the victory, and everything that followed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FQjZ3R_NxG2pE_wUNgrrRg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>Within his biography, the break passes through his own recurring image of the hunt. In a fleeting hunting scene, the young Odysseus insists that an attack must not come by stealth, since even violence presupposes openness and a rule. It is then that he receives his scar. The horse abolishes that rule altogether, leading onward to the shot fired at the Cyclops without warning, essentially without anything to gain now, solely to satisfy revenge, turning the repudiation of an earlier personal rule into a habit. Thus the ethical code Odysseus once proclaimed with his own voice breaks in the wake of the order of the oikoumene.</p><p>The hunt is also present in the tokens that frame Odysseus’s biography. He and the truth about him are recognized by the scar left by a boar’s tusk and by a golden dog gripping a fawn, depicted on a brooch, or fibula. These form a balance of symbols in the poem. Nolan takes the first directly from Homer and rewrites the second image, replacing it with Athena wreathed in grapevine. Penelope gives Odysseus the fibula before he leaves for war, invoking the goddess’s protection so that her husband will be returned to her. At the same time the king’s wife turns the ornament into a sign capable of exposing false reports about him. The meaning literally placed within it does not stop with what was spoken, gathering flesh over the course of the narrative, in which the protectress merges with the figure of the victim and of conscience, never leaving Odysseus even after the betrayal committed under the aegis of her sacred name. The goddess pursues Odysseus relentlessly, like a hunting dog running down its prey. He sees her in scenes of returning memory, from which he flees again and again — farther each time, all the while retaining an ineradicable inner tension, just as, when the storm cast him onto Calypso’s shores, he kept the brooch clenched in his hand. The wanderer’s body thus bears the trace of a principle its owner betrayed. More tragic, then, are the words that finally bring the chronicle of his biography to remorse, as Odysseus acknowledges that at Troy they violated all that was sacred between people and turned battle into a hunt. The many-sided traces of the chase, embodied in contradictory deeds and in his own verdict upon himself, meet at last.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*38yPmw-0-MaoS40TZTgsVQ.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>By then the deceit of signs has filled past and present alike, showing itself as the outline of a threat in every event. The Trojan horse turns trust into vulnerability. The ruse carries the unthinkable into the realm of what has been done and now demands to be understood, enlarging the boundaries of cultural experience. From that moment even what had stood beyond the ordinary order of life must be distinguished, exposing its dark underside. Polyphemus, the suitors, and Odysseus himself emerge as different configurations of one problem. The Cyclops receives guests in order to eat them. The suitors use their status as guests to devour their host’s house. The Greeks exploit the expectation of hospitality to destroy a city. The Sea Peoples, another name for those who prevailed in the war and now bring danger to others instead of the pure joy of return, are a natural extension of the same pattern.</p><p>A world in which an absolute sign can lie is one whose guarantors of a standpoint beyond the human have departed. The absence of the council of gods at the beginning of Nolan’s <em>Odyssey</em> lays the first stone of its emphasis on the immanence of the human world. Such a film, in fact, cannot begin on Olympus. The director therefore abandons the mode of divine existence proper to Homer’s epic, systematically subtracting and reshaping episodes in which the gods appear. The mythical monsters encountered on Odysseus’s journey are reconsidered as well. Beings usually treated as creatures of fairy tale retain only half their fabulousness, either illustrating the two-faced nature of signs or serving as the engine of a plot that reveals its characters.</p><p>Polyphemus, son of Poseidon, appeals to his father as he does in Homer. In the film he speaks only then, after his eye has been pierced. The Ithacans recognize their own language, ancient Greek. Here, too, meaning arrives after the deed. Both sides had a common language from the beginning, yet neither tried to speak. The barrier is the difference between human beings and what is older than humanity, a barrier shared speech cannot cross. A common language means no more here than the common gods at Troy’s gates. By eliminating communication and leaving it an unrealized possibility, Nolan removes the episode in which Polyphemus twists the very vocabulary of xenia. In Book Nine he promises Odysseus an openly ironic guest-gift — to eat him last. The other Cyclopes, who answered the blinded giant’s cry, disappear as well. These changes produce in the film something between a hermit and a chthonic likeness of a human being, whose shelter or home lies outside the coordinates linking space to commonly recognized values. At the same time Polyphemus remains beyond speech as far as human beings are concerned, bringing him still closer to an offspring of the elements than to an anthropomorphic creature of myth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tS7DUAU4dLtSNzxGalxxXQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Polyphemus in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>A chthonic nature is also visible in the Laestrygonians, who descend upon Ithaca’s warriors like a mute force of nature. They enter the narrative without dialogue or any declaration of motives. A brief moment of untranslated speech from a girl among them gives way to her scream, answered without words by dozens of adults. In Homer, Odysseus’s scouts first meet the king’s daughter, then the ruler himself, after which the Laestrygonians begin a true hunt, being cannibals. The director depicts them as foreign, anthropomorphic creatures of whom we know little beyond the fact that they have children. Their attack looks less like a manifestation of hatred than a blind rejection of an intruding stranger.</p><p>Polyphemus and the Laestrygonians therefore differ from mythical monsters merely stripped of enchantment. Nolan preserves their nonhuman otherness, but places it in spaces that have fallen outside the oikoumene as a system of common rules. A cave, an island, or another territory may imply a home, but no longer a home bound to others through a shared ethic. Such places come to resemble the very immensity of a world existing by its own laws and under no obligation to answer humanity in kind. The weight of guilt changes accordingly, for betrayal presupposes an acknowledged rule. Polyphemus and the Laestrygonians cannot be accused of betraying a shared ideal with the same confidence as Odysseus, who knew that ideal and once proclaimed it. The more indifferent the surrounding world becomes, the more densely responsibility gathers around the man who knew the rule he was acting from, and who can judge his deeds by a measure now lost.</p><p>Farther still from the oikoumene are the Sirens, Scylla, and Charybdis, forming a third type of mythical being. They have scarcely any space that could be called a home and included in a web of shared rules, for they belong to the sea. The Sirens sing in a recognizable tongue. Scylla and Charybdis lack even that and act almost as properties of the journey itself. They are bound to the undifferentiated sea, one of the world’s hypostases, and remain alien to any ideals. In place of a distorted home they therefore bring the pure function of trial, in which social ethics falls entirely to the wandering Ithacans. They lose what they have as they follow their tangled route across the dark waters. The sea promises nothing and therefore violates nothing, for it stands closer to the absolute than any human law, and human beings alone must pay the price of passage.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PD4IYcTE351gsc1XvZK0yw.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The principal symbol that has absorbed the poison of signs filled with lies is the home. It receives the consequences, becoming the place where distortion takes material form, for there a lie spoken aloud or enacted becomes a thing, permeating the walls with mistrust and dread. After Troy, walls no longer signify protection. Increasingly they show how, within the bounds of comfort and order, violation concentrates in the hands of those already admitted inside or those who entered against the host’s will. The oikoumene exists above all as a web of homes that recognize shared rules in one another. A single profound crack that overturns accepted laws thus becomes a common problem, confusing one’s own with the foreign, what is safe with what threatens. In Nolan, the home is destroyed twice: first as a refuge, then as a memory.</p><h4>Home</h4><p>A journey always leads away from home. When the stage of return begins, this symbol is destined to become a guiding star in reverse. In the age of the poleis, the ancient Greeks gave this symbolic prospect a ritual form by adopting the custom of carrying fire from their own hearth when traveling to found a new settlement. Home thus moved symbolically with its inhabitants, who had temporarily become seafarers, embodying a center of continuity around which a home could remain that same home despite changes of time, place, and the people surrounding it.</p><p>In the time of the <em>Odyssey</em>, the sacredness of the hearth was honored differently: the poem’s heroes call Zeus as witness and swear by the hearth, the <em>hestia</em>. Flame had a special place on Ithaca too, where it flickered like the beating heart of a home that promised protection to strangers and suppliants.</p><p>In Nolan, the light of that fire is meager. The comfort of a secluded corner of an immense world looks like a miniature oikoumene — the living ties between islands and mainland dominions are scaled down to houses that communicate with one another. It is comfort itself that falls victim to the director’s interpretation, comfort whose removal so easily turns familiar halls into vessels of the uncanny. Some of the scenes that propel the narrative take place in unconquered lands. Others unfold in cramped fragments of space at the service of human beings standing against the vastness of the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HhjidbCpPzlZpZOjBgsESQ.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The film’s enclosed locations form a long chain of decisive encounters and crimes. The horse establishes the cornerstone model, a cast of how human beings are inscribed in the world, the very arrangement from which human will arises. Within it, safety collapses from inside an act of trust in another’s lie. Agamemnon, returning victorious, is murdered in his own bedroom. Polyphemus’s cave, sheltering the giant and his harmless sheep, becomes a tomb for its guests. In Ithaca’s royal halls, guests eat through their host’s house, their repeated feasts digging a hole in the present as though they might reach Odysseus’s skeleton. The unceasing celebration drags a dark reverse side behind it, anticipating two occasions for a feast of its own — a new marriage and the <em>perideipnon</em>, a funeral meal — and seems to seek, by its very persistence, to bring them into existence. Athena’s temple becomes the final resting place of the priests and of the assassins sent after Telemachus, then burns. Across the film’s different temporal strata there grows a single genealogy of crimes, almost always committed beneath the roofs of places that ought to be safe.</p><p>Enclosed space is the very condition that allows unifying values to be betrayed at close quarters with the person who relies on them. Once the rule is revoked, the building becomes a trap. The only room to regain the image of a home is the same hall on Ithaca. This is accomplished by one who dealt differently with what lay buried than the uninvited suitors did. By endlessly repeating the same claim, the suitors assert the version of Odysseus’s absence convenient to them, gradually turning uncertainty into a spurious certainty of his death. At the borders of Hades, Odysseus acts in the opposite way. Rather than giving the past the form he needs, he summons the departed to hear what has already occurred and accept it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R6YrXeDrulYEQ1sLiQq_Bw.png" /><figcaption>Film still from The Odyssey (2026), directed by Christopher Nolan. Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>What has been gives way to what is to come, as absence gives way to a return home, where Troy’s conqueror reproduces the design of the ruse that began the disintegration. Odysseus enters his own palace under the name of Sinon, the man he left beside the Trojan horse to die. In the ancient epic he hid behind emptiness, from “Nobody” in the Cyclops’s cave to the invented brother of Idomeneus in conversation with his wife. Now the returning king takes the name of a dead man, just as at the beginning the name of Homer’s singer Phemius was given to one of Ithaca’s king’s comrades. The ruler is received as a stranger, after which he retakes his domain, turning violence against those who made hospitality a means of appropriating another’s home. The Trojan ruse returns to its maker with a different moral sign, yet still fits the old form of substitution. Names in this world, it turns out, wander too.</p><p>Setting these names right takes the whole film. Neither Penelope nor Telemachus, nor the guests and subjects, are enough to move the drama forward — all these figures remain in precarious, intermediate positions that prevent their statuses from fully unfolding. Odysseus’s arrival alone is likewise insufficient and must culminate in recognition. As we recall, Penelope puts Odysseus to the test, and the house puts him to the test as well. Nolan’s treatment of the fibula and the bow provides the desired convergence of circumstances.</p><p>According to Homer, Odysseus’s final test comes when Penelope orders their marriage bed to be carried out of the bedroom, bewildering her husband, who built it with his own hands upon the stump of a living olive tree. By that point in the film, the image of a bed has already been marked by Agamemnon’s death, which turned the symbolism of marriage and home into a sepulcher. Odysseus’s secret is disclosed through description, bringing us back to ekphrasis and the fibula. In both cases an object bears witness to a person’s genuineness while existing for the listener primarily in a verbal image. Nolan preserves this mode of recognition but changes the sign’s spatial fate. The brooch travels with Odysseus, while Homer’s bed cannot be parted from the place where it was built. In Homer, the sign of home cannot be carried away from home. In Nolan, by contrast, the sign of home must be carried along.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kwm6xcWn5hgFs1q1GkdLww.png" /><figcaption>Matt Damon as Odysseus in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The trial of the bow adds action to verbal testimony. The years of wandering have not taken away Odysseus’s mastery of the weapon through which he reasserts his position. In Homer, the bow has a biography of its own, bound up with the custom of xenia. Odysseus received it from Iphitus in an exchange of gifts that inaugurated their friendship. Iphitus later died at the hands of Heracles, who disregarded hospitality. Now the weapon, preserving the memory of that bond and its bloody violation, finds itself once more in the hands of its owner, who must restore the desecrated order of his own palace.</p><p>Fulfilling the promise he made to the dead, Odysseus hands power to Telemachus and departs westward with Penelope, into the unknown. The attained goal is granted only a moment, long enough to fill the frame, and the image recedes into the depths, where it need no longer subject reality to itself. Homer’s hero finds no rest in his return to Ithaca either. Tiresias instructs him to carry an oar deep inland until a passerby calls it a winnowing fan. Only Odysseus will discern the promised omen in another person’s name for the thing. Where a familiar object takes on a foreign meaning, he must plant it in the ground, make a sacrifice to Poseidon, and set out for home once more.</p><p>Like the wavering flame of the hearth, the past emerges from the gloom and then dissolves into it again. Lines of time, scraps of memory, are stitched together by things resembling ideals — things easily lost even while held in one’s possession. The continuity of human dwelling depends on what a person can carry with them: memory, a promise, an object, a rule. Thus the most fragile and promising world rests on the most vulnerable means, which may fall silent along with their bearers the moment they forget what those means signify.</p><h4>Song Within Forgetting</h4><p>Memory, too, knows its odysseys. Before the slaughter of the suitors, Homer compares Odysseus mastering the bow to a skilled singer tightening the string of a phorminx. Under his hand the bowstring sings like a swallow. Nolan takes up the rhyme. An object that other hands tried in vain to command fills the hall with its voice, and a brief sound breaks the house’s paralysis. We can already hear in it the approach of an ending filled with action that has yet to become a story.</p><p>Unstable lands readily consign promises and other spoken words to oblivion. They weigh too little to hold their place in the material world without scattering under the winds of history. The polarity of disappearance and return finds a place in the image of a song that preserves and inevitably forgets.</p><p>For Odysseus, the risk of forgetting had long been a goal, promising relief like medicine. His stay with Calypso, as Nolan depicts it, can hardly be called captivity. She cares for him and listens to his wishes. She speaks of love and well-being, and Odysseus, it seems, hears what the audience hears. Life on Ogygia passes in flight from the past, from every mark of what has been lived, and that flight is destined to last forever, as Calypso promises. In Homer, forgetting is divided between two means. The lotus makes its eaters forget the way home, as in the encounter with the Lotus-Eaters. Helen’s nepenthe softens grief and makes it possible to speak of Troy without tears. Nolan brings these effects together in Calypso’s lotus: relief from the past becomes a loss of memory of oneself. Forgetting, it follows, heals Odysseus along with the very part of his person that needs healing, silencing that part as a consequence. The reverse process begins close at hand — literally upon the material ruins of memory. In the poem, Calypso gives Odysseus an ax, and he fells trees to build a raft. In the film, what he has for his new departure is what survived of his former ship. From the wreckage the errant wanderer assembles a raft while Calypso urges him to assemble his own story, recovering both the goal and the reason he chose to drop out of history.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*15ttmBvz-hf0kIcCRBsTCw.png" /><figcaption>Matt Damon as Odysseus in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>Besides the lotus, which offers a deficiency of memory, forgetting has another face. Before meeting Calypso, Odysseus hears the song of the Sirens. Homer’s temptresses lure him with complete knowledge, and whoever gives in to them will never return home. Their song seems already composed and unbreakable, poised to begin and shed light on every secret by telling of the turns of fate among Argives and Trojans at Troy, and all that happens upon the earth besides. The story placed in their mouths foretells flawless completion, as though they were another poet offering a perfect recollection after which nothing remains to be added.</p><p>History entrusted to human beings cannot be completed without qualification — we see this throughout the film’s narrative. Nolan reinterprets the Sirens’ offer together with the object of Odysseus’s inner conflict. The rift arises from the meaning of home: a place on a map and the reason a journey can be called a return. For, in essence, the king leaves the meaning of home upon Troy’s ashes, where it crumbles among other ruins and remains suspended in that condition. He flees the history produced by human beings, perhaps seeing in Polyphemus, Circe, and the Laestrygonians a repellent reflection of himself, one that compels him to travel farther and to lose ever more with each encounter. Nolan’s Sirens sing of broken promises, carrying Odysseus back to the event frozen in place from which he has been escaping for so long. Their song becomes a painful recollection, turning the impossibility of forgetting into the temptation of oblivion to which the king will later yield with Calypso.</p><p>In Homer, the song of Troy overtakes Odysseus at the Phaeacian court, where, still unnamed to those around him, he asks the blind singer Demodocus to sing of the Trojan horse. Hearing his own past in another voice, he cannot hold back his tears. The poem compares him to a woman mourning her husband, fallen in defense of his city, and the victor’s weeping is heard through the grief of the defeated. Alcinous notices his tears and asks the guest who he is. Then Odysseus’s account begins. The song tells him nothing he does not know, but rather offers him what he cannot yet say in the first person. Back on Ithaca, still incognito, Odysseus admits to Penelope that songs make him weep for lives and years lost. He speaks in his own person, from behind a stranger’s persona, one step short of the fullness of his identity — he has not yet been recognized by all.</p><p>The impossibility of forgetting makes its way into the film’s frames, following the king of Ithaca at every step, while the world freezes amid an excess of scattered memories it is compelled to remember. On the individual level, the past appears as trauma, a broken image, guilt, Athena. Odysseus must turn the recurring past, losing its outlines as it returns, into a coherent account so that he can stop fleeing it.</p><p>Yet the duration of these images is finite. The world shows no mercy to the fragility of the past, making the need to carry it through catastrophe all the more acute. At the film’s end, Odysseus sets history in motion and achieves the exile both promised and desired, now with a goal before him, however uncertain. He speaks of an approaching collapse, associating it with the disappearance of writing, and observes that their story will survive in song. As we now understand, it is the poets’ lot to perform it, for poetry is given the power to answer to the world’s mutability and to keep memory. Yet Odysseus strips that promise of any claim to fullness: “…our mistakes will once again be forgotten.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8rWIt8jT52X3Po1spakMBw.png" /><figcaption>Matt Damon and Anne Hathaway as Odysseus and Penelope in <em>The Odyssey</em> (2026). Credit: Universal Pictures.</figcaption></figure><p>The song’s age keeps filling for as long as the people who sing her bring her words. Wavering between victory and crime, she can outlive the witnesses to what was done, and then the memory of that distinction itself. Existing within forgetting, she contracts, loses details, changes emphasis, and gathers new substance in other people’s memories. Each new voice inherits a past already transformed in a dynasty of repetitions and differences that give rise to something new. Penelope unraveled what she had woven, postponing the wholeness of the image and the ending whose inevitability others longed for. The singer stitched scattered memories together, giving events form, though the song once performed was no longer his alone. The spectator sees more than any of the characters, as though the vacant place of the Olympians had fallen to him, a vantage from which connections and parallels concealed from those within the events become discernible. The gift of seeing like the gods retains the flaw of the human gaze. We must comprehend depth as all the characters do — through an account that cannot encompass the past in its entirety.</p><p>What, then, resisted the completion of the odyssey? The sea can be crossed, the years can be waited out. The depth of what was done keeps its substance in spite of distance and time. We must return to it, reaching the limits where the past can still break through the silence, and carry what we have heard back into the world of the living. Poetry is the form memory takes once it has acknowledged that forgetting cannot be defeated.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3ea8a70602c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://rocknheavy.net/the-duration-of-ruins-e3ea8a70602c">The Duration of Ruins</a> was originally published in <a href="https://rocknheavy.net/">Rock n’ Heavy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Spirit of the Machine]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@derrunda/the-spirit-of-the-machine-2b28fc940e70?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b28fc940e70</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cyberpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fausin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oleg Derrunda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Jul 2026 23:14:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-28T23:14:55.581Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Mediator of Perception and Understanding. From “The Aesthetics of Decay”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jqOrLVk4kAnQW78lc-OVGw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hito Steyerl, Factory of the Sun, 2015. Installation view, German Pavilion, 56th Venice Biennale.</figcaption></figure><p>To certain elements of the book I have devoted essays intended to clarify their specificity and character. Here, however, the subject will be the “spirit of the machine,” a construct with a tinge of mysticism, though in essence there is no mysticism in it.</p><p>The spirit of the machine, as you may infer, is connected with technology. Beyond technology, the context of the concept is determined by the word assemblages. Later I will translate the whole chapter.</p><p>The spirit of the machine describes a phenomenon that manifests at the level of the assemblage. An isolated thing is not enough here; what is required is a dense articulation of devices and a forming infrastructure. Why? Consider the following example. Imagine a single boat, a product of engineering thought. Taken by itself, it scarcely offers a foothold for possession and habit.</p><p>The situation changes once it enters a network of ports, names, sensors, navigation, trade chains, and signals. Reality changes: within it, the boat no longer simply is, because it begins to transmit rules of perception and thought. It will determine what counts as distance and what kind of distance, and establish a conception of risk, coordinates, cargo, and the event as a whole.</p><p>This scenario also applies to the structure of the spirit of the machine. The spirit of the machine begins where technology ceases to be an instrument used by the human being and gives rise to an environment in which the human being is born, thinks, and discerns. The metamorphoses encompass fundamental parameters beyond mere actions: how we are capable of seeing, understanding, and experiencing.</p><p>This, in fact, is the essence of the spirit of the machine: it acts upon the content of the categories of space and time in the human being’s orientation in the world, thereby securing for itself the status of a condition of the possibility of experience.</p><p><strong>Boundaries of the Visible</strong></p><p>It is unlikely that anyone would venture to claim that the human being perceives the world in all its fullness. We perceive what we discern. Sometimes this is only a part of what is available to discernment. Technology, in turn, produces discernibility and visibility through lighting, various interfaces with sensors, notifications, maps, and so on. In effect, what will count as seen depends on it. Consequently, an event becomes an event not because it occurred, but by entering the field of vision.</p><p>Reality, then, opens itself to the degree that it appears within the technical circuit. Events deprived of support from the technogenic environment risk losing the status of events altogether.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*en18R7fvEW89QYmS.jpeg" /><figcaption>Roman Opałka, from <em>OPALKA 1965 / 1 — ∞</em>. © Estate of Roman Opałka.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Sense of Space</strong></p><p>Because of this, it seems necessary to me to refine the metaphor of the landscape as applied to the spirit of the machine and technology. A landscape presupposes a background, a neutral stage. Technology, however, reprograms space as reachability and accessibility. It determines where one can get, how, how quickly, across which thresholds, and even whether one needs to get there bodily at all. A screen makes reachable what once required movement: a library, a museum, an archive, a city not one’s own.</p><p>Roads, the illumination of streetlamps, cables, radio signals, navigation, and logistics are not merely added to space; they establish its boundaries and density. We understand what is near, what is far, what is really present, and what “does not exist” as experience. In this sense, the spirit of the machine describes a mapping distinct from the description of a landscape.</p><p>What I am leading to is that an individual device requires an initial activation. From then on, it may be switched on and off under the regulation of a technical multiplicity whose cycles of activity determine the operating states of its components. Outside the vacuum of the museum, technology cannot persist as a ruin in the manner of other artificial material objects: it either works or it does not. The actuality of technology is bound up with its activity, through which its function is realized.</p><p><strong>The Inner Sense of Time</strong></p><p>Another aspect of the spirit of the machine concerns time. How do we speak of time? Ordinarily, we think of time as history, and we do so anthropocentrically. Human beings have dynasties, inheritances, plans, a history that binds. The “historicity” of the technogenic environment, minus the maker’s involvement, is a prolonged embeddedness. The technogenic environment is either active or not, and in the course of its operation produces a continuous “now.” This temporal category differs from the human present, which is always colored by past and future.</p><p>The technical “now” is duration without biography, an ongoing mode that insistently demands continuation.</p><p>The human being is born already within this duration. It resembles a premise for a particular form of existence, because it provides the rules for thinking time: schedules, synchronizations, deadlines, statuses in messaging apps and social networks. The technogenic “now” precedes the human being because it marks out the horizon of the future before that horizon has time to become personal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gI8sQqMMtvk8v5a8.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ryoji Ikeda, from the <em>test pattern</em> series. Installation view.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Structure of Attention</strong></p><p>The transformation of the sense of time also affects questions of communication and interpersonal ties. Communication as an event with boundaries, a beginning, and an end appears almost anachronistic. Communication ceases to be itself — that is, an event — and is replaced by endless contact. The assemblage stretches contact into infinite possibility, making it a background in which presence is possible without encounter, and connection without conversation.</p><p>Through this change, the spirit of the machine produces a rationality in which human attention approaches the status of an operational resource, distributed among the system’s elements. Something thrown into relief by infrastructure will be regarded as a priority; something else as secondary, insignificant, and even nonexistent, although from the perspective of data and another human being, it is.</p><p><strong>The Structure of Thought</strong></p><p>If we move deeper from the plane of attention, we arrive at the subject of thought as such. Our contact with the new is cognition: it involves the method of analogy and prompts us to pose questions. The spirit of the machine acts upon the shape of questions, repurposing them for the analysis of functions. From this angle, the world opens itself as a set of operations with parameters. These parameters are productive descriptions. Technology produces reality through attributes that may not exist in nature at all, yet will live as more real than the material thing.</p><p>Is a boat matter and an idea that has given matter form? Or is a boat a unit of a route, a carrier of cargo, an object of observation, a flag, and a name? The more parameters there are, the stronger the sense that reality is obliged to be measured and mapped. The spirit of the machine is capable of representing as though its representation were more real than matter.</p><p><strong>The Immanent and the Transcendental</strong></p><p>As a principle of the system, the spirit of the machine has no need for external transcendence. It is self-sufficient as the ground of an immanent network, in relation to which it may be called transcendental. The spirit of the machine establishes forms of accessibility and visibility, norms of time, and limits of cognition, thereby fulfilling the role of a condition of the possibility of experience. The principal impulse of this transcendental principle is the impulse of expansion, concentrated in connectedness itself. A successful connection demands the next.</p><p>Technogenic assemblages reach toward one another; every successful articulation motivates the inhabitant of the technogenic environment to expand infrastructure. Technology has no generations in the human sense. In its case, the alternative is the continuity of operative embeddedness and the growth of connectedness, which makes it increasingly difficult for the human being to imagine a point at which this can be stopped. An individual, perhaps, is altogether incapable of interrupting what appears as the natural continuation of progress.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>An assemblage always has a material embodiment. To describe the impulse or intention that has taken up residence in the expanding arteries of cables, roads, and pipes, I propose the phrase spirit of the machine. It is an emergent property of the assemblage, the impersonal agency of the technogenic environment, which reshapes the human being’s perception and thought. The spirit of the machine changes our sense of time; it acts upon our conception of the limits of cognition. With it, the future continues technical duration.</p><p>Thus technology passes from service to the enactment of power.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b28fc940e70" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Cyberpunk Believes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@derrunda/what-cyberpunk-believes-fe7bcc9e640d?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fe7bcc9e640d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cyberpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neoplatonism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esoterism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gnosticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oleg Derrunda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Jul 2026 23:23:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-27T23:23:51.078Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Esotericism, the Spirit of the Machine, and the Promise of Another World</h4><p>The present text is a fragment from the book, and therefore some of the threads that run through it may seem broken off here. Nevertheless the core devoted to cyberpunk remains, and it gathers around itself reflections on the traces of the sacred in this cultural condition.</p><p>The connection between cyberpunk and Gnosticism has a recognizable set of identifying marks, and the reader has almost certainly encountered at least one of them. Philip Dick, for whom the Empire never ended, and for whom knowledge arrived as a pink beam and was salvific in the most direct sense, which he described in the novel <em>VALIS</em>. William Gibson, for whom the body is called meat, and for whom the exit from the meat of the bodily shell is described as an ecstasy available to anyone who knows how to handle a deck.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*rtK8_iEDpmlkB_7_.jpeg" /><figcaption>Tyrell receives his creation at the top of the pyramid. It is an audience granted, not a meeting. Still from Blade Runner (1982), dir. Ridley Scott. Credit: Warner Bros.</figcaption></figure><p>The corpo Tyrell from <em>Blade Runner</em>, who dwells at the summit of a ziggurat and receives his own creation, which has climbed up to demand from its maker an extension of life. The Puppet Master from <em>Ghost in the Shell</em>, born in the net and offering fusion in place of death. Lain Iwakura from <em>Serial Experiments Lain</em>, dissolved in the wires to such a degree that the question of her body ceases to have meaning. <em>The Matrix</em> with its pill closes this series and at the same time spoils it, because it has managed to become a ready-made skeleton key for any entrance into this subject.</p><p>The most influential form was given to this observation by Erik Davis in <em>TechGnosis</em> of 1998. He traces the mystical charge of information technology from hermetic hieroglyphics through the spiritualist currents of the telegraph and electricity understood as a life force, all the way to cyberspace and the reveries of disembodiment. Davis states his method honestly, emphasizing that what interests him is an archetypal lens through which the unconscious metaphysics of information culture can be seen. A secret teaching handed down through a chain of initiations serves rather as an ineradicable background that accompanies the parallels like a train of associations. He also has a line in which the machine enchants through its own effects, and a separate chapter on the most enchanting machine is devoted to it. My own line, set out below, is best described, given the proximity just named, as carrying this second line through to its end.</p><p>As my point of departure I take the interpretation of cyberpunk as a limit state, one that presupposes a particular relation to time, to history, and accordingly to the generation of meanings. In the limit state technology produces a Gnostic structure by its own means, doing without any preceding transcendence. What comes out is a form of faith that has kept the marks of ritual and has lost its content at its very foundation. That is, in fact this is a simulation of inheritance in place of full inheritance. I proceed from the premise that technology continues the human being, yet with the passage of time and after years of diffusion, during which it took root in cities and in the lives of people, it has come to continue the human for an entire society. Technology works toward the result placed within it and calibrated by connections in the assemblage, yet a radical change of course and a reorientation toward qualitatively new meanings are beyond its powers. The consequence of this is the retransmission of the distorted human, for which it is natural to disclose the human striving beyond itself, and which, when reproduced by technology, closes upon itself, upon the remainder available to technology.</p><p>From this follow the divergences between the particular conclusions of this chapter. The first of them concerns the point of destination. The flight from the flesh leads to the archive. The archive moves away from the image of a limited collection of documents and presents a mode of existence of a world that goes on registering traces after the addressee has disappeared, and the culmination of its historical evolution — the postapocalyptic city that has turned into a sleeping library. Owing to switched-on technology that sustains its own activity, it turns into a repository mechanically replenished with data, which it goes on doing in the absence of people as well, on the final impulses of technology. Salvific knowledge in such a repository is hollowed out into data, and what remains is knowledge from which salvation itself has been subtracted. The bliss of reunion with the whole is replaced by the bliss of being informed.</p><p>The accumulation of data is led by the spirit of the machine, an emergent property of the assemblage and the impersonal agency of the technogenic environment. It is the spirit of the machine that breathes life into the city of the future. Together with this breath, consonant with the infinitely mobile pneuma that joins what has been scattered, cyberpunk acquires something like a metaphysics. An event becomes an event for the human being by entering the field of vision, when reality opens itself to the degree that it appears within the technical circuit. The spirit of the machine establishes reachability and accessibility, the norms of time and the limits of cognition, owing to the fact that it takes the place of a condition of the possibility of experience, passing from the functional extension of human capacities to the enactment of power. The human being leaves traces that are digitized instantaneously and become part of the image of the city that the spirit of the machine records and edits. The former subject thus becomes an object itself, and the subjecthood once transferred by the subject-creator, who has now become an object, is concentrated in technology. The spirit of the machine, over and above the will of the authors of technical devices, a will faceted by the understanding, joins together the activity of all technical devices in the urban environment. Designs and ideas are alien to it, and it strives toward the result. And since the synthesis of a multitude of scattered results is beyond its powers, it produces only a momentary, that is to say a constant, activity, and in this it comes close to the nature of an elemental force. In this condition it enciphers being, mapping it no longer for the human being — for itself.</p><p>Gnostic cosmology knows the sparks of light that have fallen into the darkness of matter and are subject to release. In the field of the analogy being built here, the role of cosmology is assigned to the digital megalopolis, which controls the fall and the last flicker of these sparks. The secret script of Nature within these bounds is the cipher of the spirit of the machine, a form of oscillation between presence and meaning, that in which the human being, which once created technology, slips away from itself.</p><p>The vertical of power, which we habitually accept for the description of accumulation and growth, is inverted in the process. The esoteric conceived the supersensible as the hidden ground of the material, as its preceding source and the cause of its emanation, from which the classical path of the human being to itself opened up and further on — to the origin that produced it. Cyberpunk brings the virtual out onto the surface of matter — onto faсades, displays, and advertising projections — and its city reads as an inverted pleroma, where the summit holds pure power and the virtual, while the bottom receives the statistical sediment, the fallen matter of the digital. Time too is arranged otherwise. In Davis’s <em>TechGnosis</em> it remains an eschatological event. I look at it as an eternity illusorily recreated under the conditions of the genre and of the city of the future itself. It arises from the coincidence of limit speed with complete immobility. The past exists insofar as it is fixed in data, while the future instantly turns into the present. Finally, Gnostic liberation was achieved through awakening and the recognition of one’s own origin, and this scheme knew no judge. Freedom from the burdens of an imposed world must be deserved. In its turn, the demand is addressed to the heautonomous elemental force of the machine, which is responsible for the Umwelt, or the environment where the human being of the future dwells.</p><p>For his argument Davis needs a mystical plot found in culture and traced through the epochs. What I need is an analysis of the structure of the limit state itself, and therefore the same structure is discovered where the familiar technical iconography of the genre is absent altogether. Davis answers the question of where the mysticism in technoculture came from. What occupies me is the very fact of the presence of mysticism in a world where there is nowhere left to seek salvation. This is gnosis after the disappearance of the pleroma.</p><h3>Traces of the Sacred</h3><p>The genealogy of all Western European esotericism proceeds from a group of teachings including Gnosticism, Kabbalah, Neoplatonism, various echoes of Eastern religions, and Hermeticism. Many similarities can be traced among them, sometimes acquired through interaction and sometimes arising from a common source in particular cults. The cornerstone of the proclaimed connection between cyberpunk and esotericism is the conception of the human being’s relation to the world. According to a commonplace shared by Gnostic teachings, the human being originally belongs not at all to the material world, into which it fell by the will of the Demiurge. Physical reality is not a gift but a curse or a trial. Metaphorically — a prison. In a more neutral formulation — a place, freedom from whose burdens must be deserved. Reveries of liberation from the fetters of the material weave the dreams and illuminations of mystics. Cyberspace resolves the conflict with an inspiring ersatz of controlled liberation here and now, carrying the human being into another dimension.</p><p>For cyberpunk, with its laconic formula “high tech, low life,” the priority of rootedness in the digital environment over belonging to material life manifests itself in the decay typical of the genre. That is, in an overt crisis of reality — a symptom crossing the boundary of anchoritism with asceticism as non-possession, non-involvement, and leading into darkness. Practices of reclusion are replaced by the abandonment of the individual principle in an immense society, resorting to new means for escapism and the overcoming of hypothymia, freeing one from the weight of the body and from solitude amid the tumult of touch (let us recall Elias Canetti’s <em>Crowds and Power</em>) through the wearing out of the physical shell. The road of self-destruction runs, whether as a path promising illumination, when the comprehension of the dark leads to the struck spark of an inner spiritual fire, or as a route promising, through the quasi-satiation of the bodily, the swift attainment of revelations and a smoldering away. The illusoriness of this excess lies in the exaltation of the here and now, relying on the retention of the presence of a material being in the virtual dimension, whose duration nevertheless runs out, while also giving no guarantees of a coming eternity to the experienced stay. At the same time, the methods characteristic of the artistic image for the transhumanist prolongation of life through organ replacement or intervention in cells pick up two lines of transformation. First, a violation of the natural course of time, most vividly represented in immersion in the digital environment, with all categories of time mixed in an emphatically enduring Now. Second, at least episodic liberation from the body and boundaries — the Gnostically understood limitations imposed by matter.</p><p>Another significant feature affirming the connection between cyberpunk and esotericism, Gnosticism in particular, is the conception of the afterlife. In essence, Paradise, Eden, or another concept of blessed existence makes the human being, in the corresponding form (say, as a soul), open to the divine and to genuine reality, and together with them — to all the rest of humanity. The human being reunites with the whole. This process creates an imaginary archive where absolute knowledge triumphs, capable of ensuring the bliss of being informed. Another matter: this knowledge, or its alternative — information — is hollowed out into a state close to data with one-dimensional content, pure bliss. The digital archive likewise disposes of access to all accessible information accumulated by humanity, and of a special type of communication, in some sense embodied through information and digital technologies. With their help, the essentially pure Now, owing to the intensification of the moment, becomes an analogy of eternity, at the same time disclosing a soteriological leitmotif as well: salvation in the digital and an eternity of enjoyment, variations of bliss. The theme of data is also significant in the context of concepts of signatures and natural language that grew out of Gnosticism — everything that sets Nature before the human being as a divine secret script, concealed by matter and composed of the smallest symbols. The virtual world too shows through as invisible code beneath the physical flesh of devices, wires, streets, and buildings, promising the human being access to that which constitutes the existent.</p><p>At the same time, localization by means of the preposition “under” is a lexical convention pitched to the visual character of the ideal city. Cyberpunk is far more familiar with the deliberate movement of the virtual <em>over</em> matter: the weave of wires stretching along walls and facades, flickering signs and advertising holograms, the placement of displays and screens over silent concrete. The tendency of a city from the cyberpunk universe to bear upon itself the network of connections that affirm it (since its symbolic core lies over a ground secondary in relation to the geometry of nature and being) usually coincides with something like an ontological rupture in the organization of everyday life. The cause of the rupture is the distance in the distribution of power and goods. Accordingly, the difference in levels of comfort among strata of the population, producing a middle surface of consumption through existence (in the remnants of symbolic spaces) and a lowland of existence through consumption (of the remnants of goods descending from above). The summit, meanwhile, belongs to figures of pure power, which has not yet been distributed or concretized but is concentrated in potentiality, and to the virtual, always lying “over.” These two instances frame the texture of the inhabited urban ensemble, passing resources through it. Here, ideas serve as resources, gradually acquiring expression, which is just as gradually lost as they reach the very bottom, where all that remains of them is a statistical and secondary sediment in echoes of data about the inhabitants. That is, not the original, released idea, but the consequence of its realization, likewise intelligible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*x9sGFnhjLo4T6XN1.jpeg" /><figcaption>Emanation drawn as a diagram, with the pure held at the apex and expression thinning on the way down. Hilma af Klint, Altarpiece №1, Group X, 1915. Courtesy of the Hilma af Klint Foundation.</figcaption></figure><p>From this arise the slums of the future, with their technical innards turned outward, and the main arteries of movement with high-rise buildings hung with advertising projections. Thus, cyberpunk’s virtual, in its different hypostases (as innards and as a digital image of the virtual), is carried outward, forming two levels of a navigation system, of the city map: either directing flows of information and energy in pure form, or overseeing the movement of information and energy concentrated in the human being as an inhabitant of the economic, political, and cultural spheres. The esoteric, by contrast, almost always tells of the metaphysical or supersensible, which is located beneath matter as its precondition, the cause of its emanation. It also leads to the absolute beginning, primary in relation to the material, that is, hidden beneath it. This order gives the human being the classical path to itself, from which it can move toward Nature and the divine, which together produced it. And it is hardly evident amid the order governing the futuristic image.</p><p>Something consonant with cyberpunk can also be recognized in the Kabbalistic image of Adam Kadmon, the notional first human being. The reason for the qualification is that this is not a human being in the strict sense, but the first creation, formed infinity, the infinity that Ein Sof is, limiting itself through material emanation and acquiring expression. The sefirot are contained in Adam Kadmon. In essence, he is the Tree of Sefirot itself. The analogy with cyberpunk is again based on the potential of the virtual issuing from technology to engender a new world or its double, allowing the principal spheres of the human to emanate by means of technology. In this way the virtual gathers into a subject surpassing the human being, into an allusion to a community — the city, where unique areas of meaning take shape.</p><p>And if the cornerstone of the connection between cyberpunk and esoteric teachings is an exit into another dimension of existence, then the center on which reality’s imprinting in its new guise depends is distortion. A disruption of time and history, owing to which, within the concept of the past, priority is given to the past fixed in data. What was opens as a continuous line, as thick as a screen with an interface, resembling raw material for the construction of meanings and events, rather than as a palimpsest compelling one to undertake archaeology for the sake of discovering the unknown. Under the effect of distortion, the future demonstrates ontogenesis more clearly, instantly turning into the present because it is situated in a space where it can be constituted. Or existing as a pure topos in a past undiagnosable by the digital, somewhere beyond the ordered digital archive — in the history of matter. Thus, cyberpunk approaches a condition of dwelling in eternity, where a companion of postmodernism and its successors makes itself known — a paradox caused by the coincidence of intensive movement and immobility, of disclosing being and eternity. After all, upon reflection, cyberpunk also gives a postapocalyptic image of a city deprived of — or freed from? — people, turned into a sleeping library. A repository perhaps mechanically replenished with data through the final impulses of technology, in whose operability the finitude of people and the potential eternity of the machine have coincided.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FKge-yeHuEMI5nNZ.jpeg" /><figcaption>An archive that cannot be read. Some two hundred books cast in lead, shelved and waiting for no one. Anselm Kiefer, Zweistromland / The High Priestess, 1985–89. © Anselm Kiefer.</figcaption></figure><h3>Simulation of Eternity</h3><p>Personally, when I imagine a tragic scene of oblivion devoured by sepia (associated with decrepitude and simultaneously opposing it in terms of its chemical effect), I mechanically recall Nick Land’s work <em>CyberGothic</em>. It strives visionarily to transmit thoughts about the future from the future, to be that which does not <em>yet</em> exist and nevertheless to command the speaking author — like an elemental force — and the objecthood of the utterance. The breadth of the alluring text nevertheless gathers and fits beneath a plaque bearing a title that lodges in memory, furnishing a double for the more familiar word “cyberpunk.” Why Gothic? In my view, the author’s choice is driven by a desire to reconfigure a familiar genre with its inherent clichés, probably unconsciously bringing to the foreground the submerged current of Romanticism, running for many centuries, with its neo-Romantic artistic mask. Seeking in chaos a Gothic elevation of the dark or of the new low, reanimating, in Spengler’s words, the Faustian prime symbol — infinite space confronting the human being at every moment of life. The only magnitude commensurate with the pleonexia of human nature.</p><p>The text of <em>CyberGothic</em> devotes considerable attention to an echelon of ideas gravitating in one way or another toward the domain of psychoanalysis. Along the course of reading, we encounter Georges Bataille’s base materialism. Reminiscences from works by Deleuze and Guattari come our way. There is room as well for the more muted overtones of Schelling and Nietzsche. At the center of the work is the problematic of the interaction between object and subject, the reverse movement from the ideal to the real, the proximity of the unconscious to the elemental. The aggregate of parameters summed in the matrix of the text, first of all, helps in principle to trace a fine line connecting medieval mysticism with various forms of German Romanticism (the Göttinger Hainbund, Sturm und Drang, variegated Jena Romanticism, Heidelberg Romanticism, their dark literary epigones) — then with Schelling, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, Freud, Bataille, Deleuze, and finally Land himself. Secondly — to see the cradle of the concept of the unconscious in the seething of the elemental: will or the Dionysian, <em>Ungrund</em> or the heterogeneous. The apotheosis of the irrational is the rationality of the machine, which resembles an elemental force set in motion by the human being and continuing to work apart from people, drawn by the current into the timeless (or ahistorical) principles of the generation and organization of meanings assigned to it.</p><p>The elementality of the machine is limited by the material form it acquires, although boundless in the potential of the digital environment. In other words, it achieves totality in its own fragmentariness, by analogy with the Romantic fragment — a finite form opening the path to the infinity of the supersensible. It should be added that the Romantic fragment in its perfect state is precisely a text transforming the world by the will of the subject. It follows that the text, transmitting a representation and an image, contains the motif of depicting being. I consider acceptable the formulation that the text functions as an image, following from the author’s thinking and provoking the thinking of a recipient who both proceeds from the givenness of the fragment and continues it.</p><p>In the textbook philosophy of Romanticism, the fragment allowed its own growth in dialogue and contributed to it, striving toward the format of an all-embracing encyclopedia. With what threads can everything be drawn together? With the threads of poetry, operating with the word and animating language, and with it — the imagination and will of the artist, filled with longing for the infinite and enchanting the world. Returning infinity to the world of the given. The principle joining the mechanism of layers over reality is magical realism, a method of poetic reconceptualization. It is subjective, because it represents the vision of an individual human being, and objective, because it is oriented toward comprehension of the experience of contact with the sensible world. Actually, this duality is what is substantiated as the magical component. It is affirmed in poetry, carrying out a qualitative potentiation of reality. The fruit of active poetic creation, subjugating the fabric of being, will be myth transforming the perception of the world.</p><p>The machine, for its part, increasing the volume of data subject to it, strives to accumulate everything or potential infinity. With the assistance of data it also transforms reality, laying thoroughfares into the inexhaustible digital dimension through the poetics of the word-code. To some degree inventing a unique myth that renews the picture of the world. This is the reverse side of the Enlightenment coin, conceptualizing Nature anew. The Romantic impulse is also visible through the prism of the genre evolution of this style in the externalization of feelings, which at the early stage of the movement were represented in total subjectivity, that is, in a subject wholly filled with feeling oriented toward the external world, in the aforementioned longing for the infinity of the external within oneself. Later the subject fragmented into echoes in matter, into attempts to secure infinity in the external. Through an outward movement multiplied by the possession of material anchors of detailed feelings, decadent literature matured. In its epoch, the construction of personality made its way outward, congealing in the decor surrounding the human being, memorable trinkets and objects of the interior, in writings and letters developing the expansion of fragments of the “I,” reaching toward dialogue. The physical seizure of space has its underpinning in the fixation of time. Feelings and impressions weave memories. Their attachment to matter with which one can surround oneself is akin to a commemorative practice, in turn similar to a hierotopy of the “I,” where the boundaries of one’s own finitude are overcome through the concentration of subjectivity in a multiplicity of forms upon appropriated and inhabited space. Perhaps possession is a fitting concept, recalling Bataillean sovereignty and desire, which impel one to increase the emitted power <em>to be</em> and to concentrate it around oneself, at the same time metaphorically giving weight or fullness to oneself, the one who holds these objects in a biography.</p><p>Something comparable we observe in Land’s application of the concept of base materialism developed by Georges Bataille, whose intention is to grant amnesty to the dark or simply rejected sides of human existence dispersed across the history of the world, in order to eliminate the artificial bifurcation into high and low. Land’s base materialism is likewise centered on the subject, on its desires inscribed by the sphere of the economy. It is coupled with the idea of “zero” and timelessness. According to Land, modernity created irreversible time, which, in fusion with science and capital, produces entropy. Bearing in mind Land’s intellectual biography, we can discern an episodic dialogue with Kant, who wrote of the inner sense of time — a sense destroyed in the context of <em>CyberGothic</em>, which leads to the diagnosis of a crisis of subjecthood. For if the sense of time, the formedness of experience, slips away, subjecthood, which posits itself in the space of the phenomenal and the noumenal, is lost as well. Immanent subjecthood, that is, concentrated within us, gives way to subjecthood carried outward, determined and regulated by anything but one’s own hand. The dominant instance is the heautonomous elemental force of the machine, which has broken free from the order of Nature and the purposiveness of the human being, to some extent acquiring a monopoly on the production of meaning and thus entering into an analogy with solipsism, which concentrates within itself the source of values and meanings in which the world actual for the subject exists. A solipsism adjusted to the human being but managing the constitution of meanings without regard for the selfhood of the Other.</p><p>Nick Land’s future is dark. In it speed reaches its apogee, becoming the abyss of zero, of immobility. Amid the tangledness of time and the structure of events, cybernetics calls the tune, leading to the edge of history composed by the human being. To the position of singularity at which the evolution of the human being as a human being freezes, encouraging a movement toward the submaterial and the low as opposed to the connotations of the concept of elevation. The root “Gothic” in the title of Land’s text can thus be interpreted as the personification of the state of a realized dream of immortality and eternity, which nevertheless are inaccessible to the human being in the material world without a high price, and one of the variations is the infinity of decadence and longing for the acquisition of absolute desire, leading beyond the exhumation of the archives of one’s traces.</p><p>The position of the highest point in the fictional image makes intuitively intelligible the possibility of joining the unjoinable: the rejected past lying beneath the dunes of history and the realization of the idea of progress, tirelessly leading forward. Their alloy transforms linearity into a spiral, distorting in a postmodernist ritual the course of history and imparting to the position of the human being that shakiness or loss of ground which impel one to reanimate all the past, subjugating information in search of the future. Into a spiral leading along superstructures with centrifugal force, holding one within the bounds of an infinite approach to an illusory core. Information itself, in this heliotropic movement before the eye of reason, loses the marker of a description of the actualized or the hypothetical, decomposing into pure data that describe everything in the potentiality of combinatorics. The rearrangement of the terms and their reconceptualization time after time generates a multitude of interpretations, new information, which gives representation form depending on the circumstances. That is, the data are modified into a givenness of some kind, satisfying the need for intensive cultural consumption.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7BcqUvgg-4yVRTQ2.jpeg" /><figcaption>Matter after the end, where architecture and body have set into a single rock. Max Ernst, Europe After the Rain II, 1940–42. Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art, Hartford.</figcaption></figure><p>In the condition of cyberpunk, the imaginary metropolis is capable of becoming a receptacle (attaining such a state in essence) and of presenting itself as one (embodying that state visually), an artery of data with their appearing in the guise of information, its peak values extending equally to people and things. As though equalizing them before the face of the principal subject — the city, behind whose facade the machine is concealed. Such a city presents the secular equivalent of the sum of the models of ancient cities: Athens, Rome, and Jerusalem with Babylon. The operation of addition of unique symbolic matrices provokes a contest for primacy among their specific orders, consequently relegating secondary traits responsible for their individuality to the background and allowing the most important, common to all, to survive. Concentrations of power and meanings rising above the ground or spread over it breadthwise. No longer an origin but the frontier of culture and history, a city drifting in the fausin of the human. A treasury that bewitches with its gleam.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fe7bcc9e640d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mud Instead of Neon: ‘Hard to Be a God’ as Cyberpunk]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/theuglymonster/mud-instead-of-neon-hard-to-be-a-god-as-cyberpunk-9600d71ffcdc?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9600d71ffcdc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oleg Derrunda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Jul 2026 00:30:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-29T08:16:00.131Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Science Fiction | Philosophy</h4><h4>Frozen eternity, a god whose power makes no history, and the medieval present we deserve</h4><h3><strong>How to Forget Words So We Can Find Them Again</strong></h3><p>What cyberpunk do we deserve? The question has acquired a meme-like intonation. And yet it makes one want to look around, while the neon lights of films and noir slums surface in memory, clad in the roar of machines and the reflections of a churning crowd. Sometimes, on the contrary, it is silence. A world gone still, where drops of light from signs and lit windows run down the facades of buildings.</p><p>Different scenes are bound by a shared cyberpunk mood, one that does not always arise from advanced technologies set out as in a display window. The sense that this is precisely the genre before you is recognized instead in the balance of other traits, suggesting something situated just beyond our “now.”</p><p>Must cyberpunk look modern enough for our present to be discernible in its outlines? And what is modernity? The search for an answer leads to the hypothesis of a lost picture — a film in which the genre’s familiar traits have dispersed, leaving behind its naked body, which has forgotten how to speak of itself.</p><p>Modernity is a phenomenon unevenly distributed. It is easy to catch locally but far harder to capture the clear silhouette of the modernity that might be called global. A baker in Liguria, a banker in the City of London, a trader on the outskirts of Lagos — we can imagine all of them living in the same moment of time and go from there. Imagine how, over the course of their working days, they will meet without knowing it across the expanses of the internet, looking at the same meme. Finally, imagine how they will experience the quite actual consequences of movements in market quotations and news of events on the other side of the Earth — events whose reality, until the encounter with their consequences, had remained informational for them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5yGNJLrJkiFyO7gtR7RaIw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Old Sana’a, Yemen. Photo: yeowatzup, CC BY 2.0</figcaption></figure><p>Global modernity has an unstable image, acquired and sustained by the digital environment. Yet on the ground it exists as a combination of the incompatible, because its digital manifestations have actual anchors holding it on the surface of our life-world. And that world does not always keep pace with it.</p><p>Advanced technologies open access to all the ideas in the world, while everyday amenities in the shadow of those ideas often look archaic. A satellite dish above a wall of mud brick, or a smartphone in the hands of a Tuareg on a camel, is the result of such a formula of distribution. If modernity is arranged this way, cyberpunk must have a version filmed from a future that can be imagined on the underside of our world.</p><p>Aleksei German’s <em>Hard to Be a God</em> is a candidate for this role. This is the last cyberpunk that modernity wants to imagine, let alone reproduce, for it offers no neon to give back the familiar reflection. The film is a free reworking of the Strugatsky brothers’ 1964 novella about Earthling observers embedded on a planet whose history failed to pass from the Middle Ages into the Renaissance. One of them lives in Arkanar, the capital of the eponymous kingdom, under the name Don Rumata and is known as the son of a god. His knowledge and the technologies at his disposal are incommensurate with the environment, yet he is almost entirely forbidden to apply them.</p><p>Little of the allegory that once invited an ideological reading of the book survives the screen. German plunges us into this world headfirst, its viscosity and tactility crashing down on us. A brief preface, read in the narrator’s slow voice, does not distribute the mud and suffering that have opened before us into their places.</p><p>The cramped frame, speech drowning in clamor and noise, faces and objects intruding into the camera lens suggest the illusion of presence in this world as one more body, slowly receding into the depth of the frame, scarcely strong enough to resist. And the authorial voice and the figure of Don Rumata seem to suggest that the future is present, perhaps even too close, yet remains behind the image. As though it rose not as a misty summit but became lost underfoot, submitting to the power of the present.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wxG8hbwMGyFOx4a-VadbRQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from “Hard to be a God” (2013), dir. Aleksei German. Credit: LLC “Studio Sever”</figcaption></figure><p>The setting provokes a reasonable question. Can a film that has removed from the frame almost everything by which the genre is usually recognized be called cyberpunk? And even if the answer is yes, do we deserve such cyberpunk? The second question, as though issuing a challenge and continuing to resist the comparison of Arkanar with cyberpunk, conceals an important leitmotif. To deserve something is to come into a correspondence affirmed not by the one corresponding. Between a human being and what is due to them, an external instance arises: a judge, custom, history, the gaze of another. Sometimes simply a force that allowed the world to come together in precisely this way and continue to be. For now, let us leave this instance unnamed. What matters more is that the question of deserved cyberpunk quietly asks not only about our guilt. It asks before whom the present must confirm its right to its own image of the future.</p><h3>Neon</h3><p>Uneven modernity possesses its own image of the future, an image that gathers it into one. For half a century now, cyberpunk has served as this image, disclosing itself as a mythologeme. Instead of a direct account of what is to come, it offers a model of the limit city, through which the asynchronous places of the world look in one direction. This optic brings together everything from which our environment is woven. Technology sends its roots deep beneath cities, collecting and archiving data without the refinement of a collector; politics mingles with the economic, seeking power in accumulation; eclipses and flowerings of knowledge arrive at once.</p><p>This optic leads to a single outcome: the human being already lives in New Nature, artificial and symbolic. It is lavish in promises — presence, memory, immortality, actuality — and fulfills them, but each time in another currency. Immortality is paid in archive: the possibility of persisting despite time, but in the form of a trace. Memory — in data cleansed of everything subjective that led to corrosion and forgetting. Presence — in visibility, actuality — in a succession of appearances. Being was promised — manifestness was paid out, deprived of the ground where existence is held. In New Nature, one can hold an occupied place for as long as one wishes; it is simply reluctant to share the ground beneath one’s feet.</p><p>New Nature determines what in the world is accessible to appearance, memory, and distinction. And yet its own fundamental myths are almost impossible to find within it. Cyberpunk is full of cults, legends, promised saviors, and stories of golden ages broken down into advertising, subcultures, slogans, and styles of consumption. None can gather society into movement toward another state. Myth remains as a sign that has lost its horizon. Society unlearns how to be its symbolic expression, and inflorescences of symbols circulate within society alongside other goods and data. Cyberpunk is a myth whose content is the impossibility of myth. It is the mythologeme of a limit state.</p><p>A limit state does not necessarily arise from catastrophe or display the final stage of development. Rather, it marks an interval that has lost its outside. Events continue, powers succeed one another, technology is updated, bodies move, yet change does not lead the world out of itself. It changes the scenery and rearranges the available figures. The line of progress, having reached the horizon of meanings sufficient for a future, refracts and begins to grow sideways. This is why cyberpunk looks inhabited and mobile. Life seethes within it, with no time to become history.</p><p>The balance that holds this interval can be explained through the role of speed. The structure of cyberpunk absorbs a logic of acceleration in which data are extracted from information and converted back into it, until the exchange of information reaches a pace that turns the very conditions of circulation into an allusion to eternity. To be in cyberpunk resembles infinite movement at infinite speed over a limited distance. The outline of every object becomes blurred and present everywhere at once. Time does not stop — it burns up in turnover. A pure calculative cycle arises, flowing from the essence of technology — a functional everydayness usually placed after the end of history. Perhaps cyberpunk is its inhabited form.</p><p>A limit state has another coordinate — knowledge. The metaphor of a line refracting the vector of its growth borders the horizon of meanings sufficient for a future. To match it, two ways of handling knowledge appear. The first is bound to the control of light or clarity, when a ruling instance decides what should be known and determines the metering of manifestness. Knowledge here is regulated through an excess of information, a directed flash of news and advertising. Light as an image of what is manifest undergoes an internal inversion, because from the element of clarity it becomes pressure compelling visibility. It thereby helps to conceal by overexposing. The most reliable place for a secret in such a world is the middle of an illuminated display window or its underside. We see this in stories unfolding underground, in slums and labyrinths of technical spaces, in black markets and simply on the city’s periphery.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LfCcqbF0QBcL5LP__kcU8Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Tyrell Corporation ziggurat in the glow of its own lights. Still from “Blade Runner” (1982), dir. Ridley Scott. Credit: Warner Bros.</figcaption></figure><p>The second strategy is the control of darkness. Then the instance decides what must remain concealed and governs through removal. Knowledge here is eliminated together with its bearers. Literacy becomes evidence, a book a sentence. In this dark order the silhouette of Arkanar is already unmistakable, its black-and-white language wielding shadows. The first way, ordinarily intersecting with the exchange of subjectivity and knowledge for the comfort of life, appears modern. The second, which denies progress, naturally appears archaic, although both produce the same thing: a population unable to keep pace with the instance that produces representations of it. The difference lies only in the experience of unknowing. The inhabitants of the light limit do not know what is hidden from them. The inhabitants of the dark know that knowledge is forbidden. Arkanar establishes itself precisely through inaccessibility, cutting off every shoot that strives too high or too far.</p><p>The ordering of knowledge also distributes modes of reality. The material, the virtual, and the symbolic differ in their manner of appearing while retaining the power to direct human existence. This feature of global modernity can be called polyonticity, when several ways of being real coexist in noncoincident orders. The same person exists simultaneously in several realities, and each makes its own demands. Cyberpunk’s cultural multiplicity extends beyond the adjacency of peoples and styles. The cyberpunk world openly declares itself ready to contain everything. Yet within its city, realities touch that coincide geographically and diverge ontologically. They occupy one place without a common world.</p><p>This is why a convincing totality of a purely political instance rarely arises in cyberpunk. Political power is tied to land, to a people and a border, to its own nomos. Even when it lays claim to universality, it has a cradle from which it came. The economic is more mobile and plastic. Corporations exist in the field of exchange and the desires they have sown, crossing cultural and national borders. In cyberpunk, the economic acquires a religious intonation. <em>Credit</em> and <em>credo</em> descend from a common root — trust; their etymological kinship throws continuity into relief while revealing a divided inheritance. Corporate dogma is replaced by the promise of uninterrupted exchange, while practices of confirmation of belonging take over the role of confession. The economy of cyberpunk resembles a church without theology, with surviving rites of correspondence.</p><h3>Dust</h3><p>Space is conceived differently here. For cyberpunk, the city is primary — a megalopolis grown to unimaginable limits and yet endowed with borders within which it concentrates the human. It is an artificial world woven from ideas and values that exist by virtue of their significance for human beings, yet the figure of the individual human being diminishes within it. The archive becomes the stronghold of the virtual — a network that does not so much connect the multitude as concentrate data. The archive frees data from the circumstances of their birth and thereby erects its own form of objectivity. The human being is localized down to a symbol woven into myriads of relations, down to an informational trace. The trace permits infinite reproduction and needs the one who left it less and less. Settled dust keeps the imprint longer than the step that created it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8iG6KyegrMQ4Gy2opYeuhQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from “Hard to be a God” (2013), dir. Aleksei German. Credit: LLC “Studio Sever”</figcaption></figure><p>Initially, technology simply extended the human being. Within it, the human — will, desires, quests, ideas — was concentrated beyond a measure possible by nature. It articulated what was already there, expanding or hypertrophying it. Today, and within cyberpunk, its impulse toward expansion persists. Technology encompasses more and more utilitarian domains and additionally supplies them itself, creating needs for which it then becomes the condition. Joining with other extensions of human beings, it gradually acquires powers that go beyond extending organs or individual practices. It expands in the name of communities, institutions, the human as a whole. Then technology stands before the human being like a mirror that manages to produce a reflection before the one reflected can distinguish their own features.</p><p>Thus an instance external to the individual human being appears, convincingly passing itself off as the concentration of the human. One has to keep pace with it as it produces representations of us. The external force concealed in the word “deserve,” from the question returning as a refrain, receives its first name. The world deserves its own image of the future when it begins to coincide with the representation of it that this instance is capable of producing.</p><p>In such an environment, the archaic returns without a literal step into the past. Keeping pace with technology in understanding its mechanical architecture is almost as difficult as it once was to decipher the secret script of Nature. Thought is held on the surface of repeated practices from which knowledge of their historical source gradually falls away. Technology or its rudiments remain; the capacity to reproduce and develop them is lost. The world, created by human beings for human beings, seems to be passed through a mechanism that rearranges symbols once familiar to the human eye and releases a cipher. This mechanism is time, laying distances between human beings, so that one can easily find oneself in the middle of a text already being written, begun by the hand of an author so other that his image is inaccessible to the gaze from the position the reader occupies. Thus a new Middle Ages arises, an epoch after progress and a life among results no longer invented by human beings. They disclose themselves as an inheritance indifferent to the subject and deprived of a creator. In the universe of <em>Warhammer 40,000</em>, this is made literal — the machine becomes a relic and an object of worship. But a similar shift occurs without cosmic cathedrals wherever use replaces understanding and a system update is experienced as a natural or sacred event.</p><h3>Mud</h3><p>The puzzling label “cyberpunk,” applied to Arkanar frozen amid the omens of endless Bruegelian suffering, now has ground on which to put down roots. If cyberpunk is a limit state, an interval where changes obscure every outside, then Arkanar satisfies the definition more fully than many neon megalopolises. It is a flattened, compacted castle holding the proportion of new and old in the inertia of air gone still inside a locked casket. Its present is a viscous normality that has become the constant of timelessness. Before us is cyberpunk from which the future has been subtracted. The subtraction did not destroy the genre — it laid bare its structure.</p><p>It is tempting nonetheless to see Arkanar as the past, a costumed Middle Ages — and this temptation should be resisted. Arkanar belongs to a present that has fallen out of modernity’s representation of itself. Earth and Arkanar coexist chronologically and are divided historically, and the same relation connects the centers of the global world with its peripheries in reality. The observers in German’s film look upon contemporaries who have refused modernity.</p><p>First of all, the position of the virtual is laid bare. For the inhabitants of Arkanar, its place is occupied by a religious caricature. The black monks of the Order emerge from the shadows, veiling political aspirations and promising an invisible order above visible mud. At the beginning of the film their power is still vulnerable, although it spreads like a subcutaneous infection, seeping into others’ decisions before those decisions take shape as events. But Arkanar’s true virtual contour is entirely invisible to its inhabitants. It is the network of Earthling observers. Arkanar exists in two ontological modes. From within, it is the only world; from outside, a historical object whose inhabitants leave traces in an archive without suspecting its existence. In this gap between reality for the one living and reality for the one observing, polyonticity passes from a theoretical word into the arrangement of a place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rYgli1AweDO-cejgbCl8HA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from “Hard to be a God” (2013), dir. Aleksei German. Credit: LLC “Studio Sever”</figcaption></figure><p>Both states of knowledge are combined in one location and distributed on opposite sides of an invisible pane of glass. From within, Arkanar is governed in shades of darkness. Books and literate people are removed; thought is destroyed together with its bearer. From outside, the world possesses an exceptional visibility accessible to observers. Darkness for its own people, light for the archive. Yet light does not become action. The Earthlings know enough to see the pattern and are denied the right to make knowledge generally accessible. Before us is a strange cybernetics where the channel of observation operates without a channel of control. The world is turned into rootless information and for that very reason left to itself. God here is a doomed observer forbidden to belong to his own eternity.</p><p>Frozen eternity has two asymptotes. The megalopolis of classical cyberpunk reaches it from above, tending toward limit speed. Arkanar reaches the same eternity from below, arriving at zero speed: standing water, rain with no determinate time of day, a black-and-white frame in which changes in illumination cease to count time. The acceleration of exchange and the slowing of decay converge in an interval where the future ceases to differ from the continuation of the present. German’s Middle Ages and Gibson’s metropolis lie opposite one another as two limits of a single impossibility of exit.</p><p>This impossibility has its architecture, and the genre recognizes it from the very first frame — in the figure of the tower. The image of the future was supposed to work like a tier we climb in order to see ever farther, laying claim in thought to boundless lands. The cyberpunk tower is built the other way around. Its height is turned inward, into depth. It does not so much rise as condense, drawing what has accumulated inward, toward the base, until verticality becomes compression. This new height is indifferent to the outside. It measures the volume of what can be held within, becoming a repository. The same reversal overtakes light. Skyscrapers and ziggurats block out the sun, giving precedence to interior light — lamps, neon, lights distributed across the levels of a hierarchy in which the higher the level, the brighter the light. The metropolis sets its own day and night. While the tower commands knowledge, the city meters out the flicker of light. Such a future prefers to see and contemplate itself rather than the world around it.</p><p>Arkanar’s vertical is immediately given as compression, a refuge of inversion in which the low is equated with the normal and the high. The image-tower is hewn from the block of the Castle sinking into mud. Abandoning even the attempt to pretend to be a beacon, it offers a thickening of atmosphere, causing its ancient gift of seeing and directing to fall away as a rudiment of history. Roads leading wanderers and traders change nothing. The city appears to the viewer in fragments. At one moment fog obscures it, at another rain. Corridors, courtyards, stairs, and overhanging constructions gather space into density, where it is impossible to step back and see the whole. People are driven to the back alleys of their own city, into narrow niches between things and alien intentions. The same substantiality of the environment found in Gibson is composed here of stone, wood, cloth, and mud.</p><p>The power of Arkanar repeats the structure of the city. Its amorphousness is composed of forms stuck together. The political, the economic, and the religious act as organs of one undifferentiated body. They coexist in primordial indistinction. Classical cyberpunk fuses the same spheres after the separation of their logics. There, the corporation takes over the functions of church and state. Arkanar presents the same fusion from the other end, before any demarcation. The grays and the blacks replace one another without bringing about a change of epochs. The Order is a church, an army, an administration, and a corporation in the old sense of the word — a body whose existence matters more than any content. It is a leviathan brought to anatomical, ubiquitous manifestness. A mask embodying the multitude and left with no face — muscle alone; the grays and the blacks, the flesh of a figure that is itself no one. The transcendence of such a leviathan is immanent and locked within the closed borders of Arkanar. More than that, it gapes with an emptiness capable of absorbing any formula so long as the formula strengthens the right to remove. This is a power whose signs promise nothing beyond belonging.</p><p>The nearest contemporary referent for such a Middle Ages is Yanis Varoufakis’s <em>Technofeudalism</em>. The book’s diagnosis is useful, although it is driven by an <em>idée fixe</em> about the radical significance of the distribution of property and income, leaving it silent about the rest: how the future and the very thirst for the future were canceled; whether biography is possible where will merely rearranges bodies; what remains of the “I” in an environment without a single stopping point. Arkanar allows the outline of these problems to unfold into questions of ontological and existential dimension. German’s film lingers in the very space where nothing else begins beyond the gates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3om1xVjw8a8B_MiC78FqDA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from “Hard to be a God” (2013), dir. Aleksei German. Credit: LLC “Studio Sever”</figcaption></figure><p>Gibson’s axiom — “the street finds its own uses for things” — is inverted in Arkanar without leaving its conceptual terrain. In classical cyberpunk, the environment appropriates technology that exceeds it, tears it from the creator’s design in order to turn it into a key to change. The street of Arkanar can digest the new in a strictly literal sense. An idea, or the book that has imprinted it, appears as a foreign body that must be hidden, distorted, or destroyed together with those capable of using it. The scholars, perceived as a threat to order, are drowned by Arkanar’s guards in latrines, cast into the belly of the streets. Instead of unexpected functions of things, everyday life creates nonreproducibility. Ideals familiar to us are spread underfoot and trampled because people cease to distinguish them.</p><p>Inversion reaches the hero. The cyberpunk hacker usually acts from below, breaking through as an impulse from a blind spot. Rumata is placed above. He is named the son of a god and possesses technology, knowledge, and near physical invulnerability. The hacker — social insignificance with an excess of access. Rumata — an excess of position with the barrenness of deed. The traditional cyberpunk hero is defined by gaining access that does not turn into power over the whole. He can cross systems without ever opening a door to the outside within them. Rumata can win any duel, slaughter the blacks and the grays. Each of his actions is exhausted by a moment indifferent to history. Arkanar absorbs even a hint of a stone for a new path, digesting every precedent of difference.</p><p>This God is imprisoned in eternity. Rumata knows the people of Arkanar as historical types and at the same time encounters each of them as an unbearable singular body. Theory invites him to see a stage, while the architecture of existence demands intervention now. There is no reconciliation between these perspectives. By intervening, he destroys his own position as observer, losing the right to be the subject of a new history. God descends into the world and discovers that his power is fit only for the already ordinary extermination of people fused with the stagnation that produced them. The only savior myth inherited by Arkanar refuses to fulfill itself, because fulfillment sentences it to its end.</p><p>Arkanar’s stagnation penetrates deeper than power and myth, appropriating language and will. The speech of its inhabitants is indistinct. Their language sticks in diction, tangles itself in fragments of phrases and noise, as though meaning had ceased to leave the mouth. The voice belongs to the speaker only bodily, returning what is uttered to the environment as part of its clamor. Will, which ought to be in the human being’s power, also separates from the subject. Prisoners bound into a common wooden construction move as a single bearer of another’s intention toward an ending indistinguishable from the beginning. Arkanar speaks through their mouths and moves their bodies, living through its own endless biography. For individual human beings, repetition proceeds without distinction. An individual biography has nowhere even to disappear, because it never has time to gather itself. The true dictator of Arkanar — the city itself — attaches the body in advance to an alien trajectory of existence.</p><p>Arkanar’s deafness has a literal anatomy. Rumata brings music from his life on Earth, music that the inhabitants of Arkanar do not know how to hear. They hurriedly cover their ears and begin to grimace, resisting the melody. Yet Rumata himself is famous for having cut off his opponents’ ears in countless duels instead of killing them. The prohibition on killing leaves behind a collection of damaged organs of hearing. The one who tries to bring music into the world maims the very capacity to receive it. The image of the enlightener among the deaf splits apart. His civilizedness, itself in need of confirmation, is inscribed into the ubiquitous inversion of Arkanar. Mercy takes the form of mutilation, branding the hand that judges. Thus the poetic tries to come through a hand that has learned to punish the ear. Noble Rumata suffers from the deafness of the world and participates in its production.</p><h3>Glass</h3><p>German’s nearly three hours are an ordeal by duration. The viewing itself reproduces the position of the observer, holding the viewer inside Arkanar. We lose distance; in its wake, time too is stripped of clear divisions. The film works like an anti-frame. Its borders remain in place, having lost the capacity to guarantee order. German leaves intervals, intrusions, and obstructions that prevent the image from becoming a convenient object. A face looks into the lens, an object blocks the action, the camera leaves the hero for an unknown body, again and again, until even the thread of the plot slips away. The image does not provide the viewer with an overview — it notices the viewer’s presence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8tub7i4JskL9d7pO-vsLIA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from “Hard to be a God” (2013), dir. Aleksei German. Credit: LLC “Studio Sever”</figcaption></figure><p>A chain of observers arises. The viewer from Earth watches the Earthling Rumata living among the people of Arkanar. The people of Arkanar themselves repeatedly look straight at us. We counted on the privilege of the outside, only to be woven into the chronicle of the archive as one more layer. The camera remains in Arkanar even where an Earthling could leave, and in this way distinguishes the viewer from the hero. While Rumata retains the right to return to the future, the viewer is condemned to remain with the image of Arkanar. The exceptional visibility to which the planet’s inhabitants were previously subjected passes onto the beholder as a curse, moving out of the frame and into the theater. The peephole of the archive points both ways.</p><p>The question in the title receives a literal scene, and the instance its final name. The external force before which the world deserves its own cyberpunk is the beholder. But the beholder’s judgment is granted no power to judge. The beholder can recognize the correspondence between Arkanar and the present, and carry the film beyond the film itself. Only intervention in what has already been seen remains impossible. Thus the viewer’s position repeats the prohibition imposed on the Earthling observers. Earth, Rumata, the camera, and the viewer occupy the outside in turn. None of these places leads to an exit. Fullness of understanding, which in cinema usually arrives with the denouement, comes here together with the consciousness of powerlessness. The beholder’s knowledge is enough for a diagnosis. Nevertheless, any knowledge is too little to begin a new history. Cyberpunk ceases to be only a condition of the represented world and becomes a form of relation to it. The world reaches limit observability at the moment when observation discovers its complete historical helplessness. The genre, having forgotten how to speak of itself, speaks of how open it is to the gaze and closed to historical deed.</p><h3>Snow</h3><p>Perhaps the meme-like formula of the very first question should be turned: what cyberpunk are we prepared to imagine? The idea of deserving does not disappear; authorship simply ceases to belong to nameless fate. Imagination here organizes the outside of the interval, at first only as a stopping point where the present ceases automatically to continue itself. Such a stopping point is fragile and promises no exit. It restores the difference between “now” and the next moment, without which the future cannot even begin.</p><p>Rumata refuses to return to Earth and remains to play his music in the snow before people to whom it causes pain. For the first time, the snow thins the overcrowded space, yet leaves it as a cover over the mud and the corpses that will return in spring. Music holds a pause that does not coincide with Arkanar’s cycle, and Rumata himself is inside that pause — a human being who has already lost the divine role and still convulsively resists the fate of a prop. All is still. Perhaps this is the most honest image of the future left by the film. A moment held by a human being inside an interval that will not end.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eN5ltJp07iROOML_3KPY8w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from “Hard to be a God” (2013), dir. Aleksei German. Credit: LLC “Studio Sever”</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9600d71ffcdc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/theuglymonster/mud-instead-of-neon-hard-to-be-a-god-as-cyberpunk-9600d71ffcdc">Mud Instead of Neon: ‘Hard to Be a God’ as Cyberpunk</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/theuglymonster">The Ugly Monster</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Life Imitates Art]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@derrunda/life-imitates-art-977fdf1d1273?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/977fdf1d1273</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oleg Derrunda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Jul 2026 13:37:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-28T23:02:04.772Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>From «Aesthetics of decay»</p><p>The great weapon of contemporary culture is inversion. An overturning that deconstructs hierarchies and logics long fused into a seamless sequence. In his letters to Milena, Franz Kafka once called love a knife with which he digs inside himself. It seems to me that the distinguishing property of contemporary culture is its great love for itself and fascination with itself, impelling it to rummage through its own heart — the pulsing muscle of the “human,” binding ephemeral flesh together. This is not the chill of a scalpel gliding with surgical precision, but heat, an agitated touch guided by a thirst for infinity that has learned meticulousness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jyJP91C4wr8rYOoOSQOC5g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Every linkage realizes a modified idea of addition, of combination. The process of addition becomes essence — that is, a foundational characteristic establishing a stage of embodiment and sooner or later attaining completion in a sum or a fused totality of elements. Deconstruction, in the process of inversion, makes it possible to go beyond addition. It decomposes a multiplicity perceived as a unity into separate elements or terms, acting upon them and upon the slightest possibility of symbolic charge between them, rather than upon the sum. The underside is exposed, emphasizing the tension of the components, their potential heterogeneity under shifts of emphasis, promising disintegration. The mobile tectonic plates of meanings and knowledge do not destroy the metaphorical globe of culture; they refit its constitution.</p><p>Naturally, every method has rules and conditions characterizing the logic of its application. The two principal and perhaps final conditions required by inversion and echoing one another (everything else is drawn into the whirl of what is subjected to its action, thereby defining only peaks rather than the smooth constitution of a graph of transformation) are not even the limits of its application. They are, first, a point of application of force by which the whole is drawn into the process and, second, a perspective, likewise imaginable as a point at the beginning of a ray directing that force. The actualization of these two points is gradual and entails transferring the center of gravity and the point of pressure from oneself — the active principle initiating the inversion — to the medium being inverted, compressed into a region for the application of intellectual force, in the course of which the two points converge into one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*2uUThPlQabZq4snZdiav8Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is the Nothing. The very perspective of collapse, the risk that the alloy will be unbound, an instance both displaced and displacing. The Nothing as the possible rather than the impossible; not negation or denial; as absoluteness, darkness reflecting itself and illuminating the split out of the initial tense fullness of unity (as though in Jakob Böhme and Robert Fludd); as a medium in which being opens — the pure potentiality of what comes to pass, the plane of contingency in contrast to the dimension of the human subordinated to order. The fabric of intrusion, experienced in the fullness of lack, where meaning is an anxious glimmer of the possible.</p><p>Classical mimesis asserts that art imitates life or actuality. This principle of classical aesthetics requires being as it opens within the realities accessible from the outset: the speculative and the physical. The two realities effortlessly gather into one, continuing one another. The world continuing in time and space passes through the human being, acquiring small projections, cliffs, observation points, and equally provisional halting places upon a monolithic plane extending from the presumed Nothing toward an equally presumed fullness of every possible extension. And it seems that it cannot be otherwise. For even a new world raised on the underside of old Nature out of its potential organizes the same chthonic impulses and elemental forces, the same submaterial reality concealed behind the veil of the natural. With one difference: it is governed by another model, that is, guided by something other. Mimesis acquires an analogue represented on a plane of ideas alone, ideas drawn not from the reception of Nature but as a consequence of reflection — a simulation that permits the imitation of what has never existed. The human being now imitates Nature not through selection by distinguishing a multiplicity of discrete phenomena, but entirely, joining the ideal and the material while assigning matter an openly secondary role, turning to the logic of mimesis as to the habit of a canonical recipient rooted in tradition. With this alteration, a vulnerable artificial construction appears above the Nothing, on the far side of Nature; in the Nothing — crossing it as though it were a threshold of transgression — imitations of everything that exceeds the experience of an individual human being multiply. The point of departure is not the experience of existing in the world, but an experience of existence that generates a world. Humanity performs an inversion, making plausible the mirror truth: life imitates art.</p><p>Mirror modernity reflects the old — the temporally determining link from which it arose along the traditional line of history. And yet reflection rearranges the terms, producing not a reproduction but a copy without an original, for the original stands apart from the reflection in the act of inversion, which encloses within the bounds of mirrorhood and always grasps only a moment, an event. Old representational conventions undergo a predictable crisis here. They are powerless when applied to the elusive world of old mimesis, which strives to remain beyond the city limits as beyond the frame of the mirror. And everything that fits within the contemporary mirror-city — the hyperimage — proves to be a work of art, the fruit of an act and an effort prepared to contain absolutely anything yet let nothing back out. Thus the mirror is invariably secondary, though singular in its own way; it cannot release anything back. A step beyond actualizes the contradiction. The lifeless fruit of human life will begin to disintegrate, above all as a convention of meanings manifested in the object. The pure simulacrum — a reflection resting on grounds other than those of the initial model, and therefore embodying original and copy at once, remaining in tension because of the instability of each ontological state — becomes artificial ground for a technogenic (artificial) quasi-nature.</p><p>Reflection is always something other in relation to the original. The original as genuine, as it ought and should be. Yet we know that simulacra exist as well. The environment in which they arise is the domain of the city, of human mythology, a sacred land blessed by the comfort and humanism of life. Does the absence of an original prevent simulacra from being authentic, from being themselves, or, in principle, from being at all — in at least some ontological dimension? Perhaps the lot of the simulacrum lies in the vampire’s fate: to receive no reflection of its own, remaining an anchor that holds in place the reality to which it belongs, itself a reflection of the human, feeding on its likenesses farther along the branch of evolution. The substitute of fiction makes the human being greater, allowing the human being to outpace imagination and experience, to have something like a head start over the duration of being. In fact, simulacra are given authentically; their genuineness is the genuineness of an edge of meaning, of a value that exists insofar as it means something to people. The frame of gaping darkness, which will reflect everything that looks into it, is indifferent to their simulative autonomy. It will reflect them as a fragment of the human representational glossary, leading toward the epicenter of the Other within — to the human being.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TFLCDe0WyUzSOZVVg0zH-w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mirror reality, or the reality of new Nature, lies on the far side of originary Nature. One can be reflected only by setting oneself apart, by acquiring a line of demarcation that divides the manifest world, discerned by mind-body and body-mind. The hierarchy of interaction between body and mind is such that, in a parliament of two, the character of the event determines the decisive weight. To be human is, unquestionably, very close to being capable of abstract thought, withdrawing from physical actuality and continuing the line described earlier, with its movement beyond oneself. At the same time, it is also to be feeling, sensing, present within an episode of the world as it endures. At times sensation outruns thought, prompting reflexive action like the automatic writing of an event coming to pass. Reflection through the Nothing bears the aura of a limit-situation, an emergence onto the frontier of being where, as a verb-principle, the silhouette of death flickers; yet in becoming conscious of ourselves before it, we also become conscious of ourselves before an interval of existence echoing the existence of billions, just as death brings us close to all bearers of human nature. The speculative gaze leads onward from the point, moving along the plane of Other being — a being that leads from mind to body, mobilizing the constitution of presence before what is greater.</p><p>The urban world of the palimpsest resembles an immense archive, always within reach thanks to the digital medium. Enough vivid analogies and metaphors have been found for thinking the new human being: bricolage, layering, the museum of the imagination. The contemporary crowns the colossal experience of culture, offering a whole host of modes for transmitting knowledge: literature, cinema, television, booklets, zines, magazines, chats, memes. Often the roles assimilated by a human being refer to repeated iterations of practices by those around them and by their predecessors, quotations of behavioral models and values from these sources, offering someone else’s experience, not independently undergone. This is especially apparent in cinema, which shows how one may act and live. Within them dwell models for imitation that anticipate the experience of presence in related or even identical events, thereby only intensifying the effect of inversion and mixture, the replacement of independent discoveries by the partial assimilation of models.</p><p>Where, then, is art, and along what paths does it move in the contemporary? Among art historians it is customary to distinguish the avant-garde from modernism on the basis of the avant-garde’s aspiration to break with preceding traditions, as opposed to modernism’s reinterpretation of the inheritance in order to maintain continuity. Such a distinction is convenient and meaningful, though the two concepts have points of contact. For the sake of simplicity, and of precision in setting out thoughts — a precision revealed when one moves beyond this text and begins one’s own search — I suggest adhering to this distinction.</p><p>One path taken by art in the contemporary is imitation, mimesis in a new medium. This is the art of transaesthetics, capable of turning literally everything in everyday life into an object of aesthetics, when the image becomes real and complicates the ensemble of buildings, objects, and signs. At times such art becomes an art of onomastics, or naming: the application of visual labels and the ordering of an assemblage of objects, because the city and its environment invariably require communication. The art of modernity attempted precisely to observe the principles of old art, cultivating the concept of mimesis and transposing itself into the space of modernity, then postmodernity, and the contemporary. It unquestionably bears artistic value, but its visibility adjoins the visibility of other objects in its surroundings, becoming absorbed and dependent upon the openness they manifest. Thus even an exhibit from the scenarios of art’s appearing presented in the section “Art and Time” appears for haptic contemplation, fashioned for visual contact as a complex surface.</p><p>Another route of art is movement toward the Nothing. It is the event of a collapsing flaw and a distortion of the new reality. It need not take form as the avant-garde search for non-objectivity. This movement may be performance, actionism, anything that breaks everyday life and tears one out of routine. The very event of the disintegration of the logic of appropriateness. Performance is always surrealistically human; within it, the Romantic need for a recipient or interlocutor — opposed to the image of antiquity, independent of the observer — is released; only, as a reply, a replica is offered: a staging at the boundary with the Nothing. The Nothing reflects (or mirrors back) the perceiver and returns them to themselves. At the ground of artistic movement toward the Nothing lies, for the most part, the articulation of categories: an attempt to synthesize, through expressive means, deeply abstract and submaterial phenomena, expressed in some form yet exceeding the shell of the event. Corporeality, violence, the ugly, the beautiful, speed, multiplication, even feeling — all lie on the plane of originary Nature and therefore require a bridge across the Nothing, leading out of the new environment. At times their primitiveness borders on the enigmatic, on a puzzle that compels the recipient to experience a split in reality: expectation encounters deception, a distortion of the habitual. This primitiveness, clearly demonstrated by Malevich’s “Black Square,” is a characteristic feature of categories that are, in essence, uncomplicated and simple. Yet this simplicity is difficult to express and to read, since both results depend upon the medium lying on the far side of, and at the ground of, the mirror reflection. Ruins convey a similar simplicity: their external complexity is an accumulation of details barely joined together, while their internal simplicity is the simplification brought by the loss of function, objecthood, and inclusion in networks of social significance. In this respect, ruins, like the human being torn from the succession of social roles, resolve the paradox of the city by breaking the imposed frames.</p><p>Both Natures, new and old, are in essence deeply material; they grow into one another. The indeterminate boundary between them — the abstract surface of the mirror, performing the functions of reflection and containment — is a moment of the Nothing, of absolute non-objectivity, of unreflectedness, when the two realities have not yet come into contact; a space of pure potentiality and submateriality where nothing is depicted. A moment at the site of collapsing actuality, splitting the inhabited and mastered world into two realities, each infinite in its own way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*9qeRIuJaZnT0QjWh8QFSwQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The hand reaching with a blade toward the heart of culture rummages through the agitated fabric. Crimson glitches close in around the fingers in a cascade of disturbed code-ruins. We call such consequences of malfunctions artifacts. An error of natural origin within an unnatural simulation. I see what is not there, obscuring the already absent emptiness. Thought performs a pirouette as the body does a somersault: the pupil turns backward, seeing me having ended up here. Apart from this, there is nothing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=977fdf1d1273" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Poetic as a Condition of the Human]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@derrunda/the-poetic-as-a-condition-of-the-human-12a7d87b102b?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/12a7d87b102b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fausin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oleg Derrunda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jul 2026 00:24:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-28T23:20:44.157Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Beginning of Philosophy at the Edge of the Fausin.</p><blockquote><em>Ni lu, ni compris?<br>Aux meilleurs esprits<br>Que d’erreurs promises!</em></blockquote><blockquote>Paul Valery, “Sylph”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Lf-9N-YmMB7mBm--EqDcrQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Words make the world more understandable, more visible. Perhaps speech has a vocation in clarification, however illusory that clarification may be. We are accustomed, with the help of language, to turning toward the reality of meanings scattered for us and by us. We are accustomed to giving outlines to the multitude of what has been seen and undergone in experience. It also happens that experience is possible only thanks to language, which is like a magnifying glass, or eyes in the back of the head, showing what is invisible. Yet at times one of us, capable of bringing meanings, falls silent.</p><p>Our silence will not spread to the world. The voice of thought strives to nourish its own existence, un/resting upon the thick layer of experiences that sustain a fragile cultural crannog. Therefore, when language falls silent, we will probably take what appears before us for tectonic plates colliding like icebergs of unknown depth. As the embodiment of the mutability proper to reality. The sum of what has not yet been thought through, and can scarcely be thought through in a fullness that would satisfy curiosity, is invisible as a sum. The outlines of the world collide even at a distance. In the geometry of relations on the underside, in a feeling of anticipation flickering like a spark at the fuse of intuition and imagination, we grope for the causes of what we observe, not always having the strength to name what has been foreseen.</p><p>Thanks to words, the colossal shards of reality appear in a new guise, open to intent scrutiny and to being broken down into details. We owe to words our striving to discover ourselves, or something beyond us, in the world. To put it otherwise, the use of words goes back to the desire to localize, to carry out navigation in space. To transform the verb into a noun — topos.</p><p>A curious word: “space.” As with astigmatism, when a wave of light scatters and fails to focus at a single point on the retina, the meaning of the concept doubles, arranging two dimensions or approaches to reality. Space is a point on the map where the sought-for thing may be found. Space is an environment from which something proceeds, or in which it abides, even exists, with all the active and passive essence of the verb. Somewhere we can come to and somewhere we can leave.</p><p>The double meaning, caught in doubleness, spreads like erosion, preventing the interpreter from holding the desired position. Meaning barely gathers itself even in its double — “location,” which attempts to bring together two poles of signification. I write “location,” tracing the outline of a patch of speech. In the pattern of letters there are enough mirrors edging the white emptiness of the cell, outlining yet another position — the position of the graphic sign. The word taken in hand serves as a mirror to itself as well. It simultaneously contains a lexical meaning, or appears as a location, a space, and is itself localized, that is, found among other words that breathe into it a life suited to the utterance.</p><p>To be somewhere and to be somehow. A gathering of synonyms — location, toponym, place, environment, position, region, area, domain, topos, locus — only defocuses our intellectual vision, emphasizing the doubleness of the picture that displays the root of the effort of speech. It consists in pointing to being somewhere and to a position in relation to something. Yet amid multiplicity one can become lost, and it is hardly possible to belong to everything at once.</p><p>Carefully, I say: a human being wants to find himself. At least to be found, to see a brief summary of his position in the world, to relate himself to something. With the passing of years, I have nevertheless come to know the feeling of disorientation. The threads woven into the fabric of the routine around me are easily stirred by winds blowing from afar, driving clouds and pursuing sunsets together with dawns. I, too, take on this unrest: holding, or holding on to?, a bundle of invisible reins in my palm, looking around and looking over, searching with my gaze for precisely that which exceeds my capacity to see, gathering light in my pupils. Searching, and seeking myself as well. However intently I peer, in the darkness of being there remains being, whose echoes arrive with tidings and with the inclination to posit an unshakable order: whatever is not eternal has an origin.</p><p>I, too, am not eternal. The relation in the pair “eternity” and “I” is unconditional and obvious: we lie apart, even if I am capable of thinking what I lack. Eternity is a form of time, unlimited and yet closed within a single word. Time, where searching is carried out and loss takes place.</p><p>Philosophical systems know well the coordinates that make it possible to solve the task of building a navigational system in the world. The introduction of a grid of toponyms may be accepted as a necessary premise from which a model grows outward. Sometimes it is otherwise. Guiding designations take on the role of the final stroke, the result that gives contour to an externally produced speculative reality. Such a ghostly fruit of the mind seems to lead inward, with an origin not foreordained — for the human being decides upon something while waiting.</p><p>The difference between these approaches often arises from their relation to human nature. A set of anthropological postulates, accepted as given, lays a path outward, away from oneself. And, conversely, their gradual derivation directs us toward the center, answering questions about the character of our thinking, about our origin, about our traits and our possibilities of knowledge.</p><p>However persistent the attempt to overcome anthropocentrism may be, flight from the human being hardly leads us away from ourselves. The grain of sand that is the human figure is lost in the majestic and frightening infinity of the cosmos, but it does not vanish altogether. Thought hastening to leave the human being still possesses space as a potential for expansion: it tries to hold the universe, and it dwells in the human mind.</p><p>There we may also encounter eternity, instantly dimming to the state of two seeing eyes. That is how tiny we prove to be. The boundless cosmos shades the flash of the thinking “I.” It shifts the horizon backward as well, placing it behind us, demonstrating the breadth of trajectories of movement — upward, downward, and even backward — beyond the standard linear model. We distinguish ourselves as a unity in the midst of the abyss. The totality that fills everything around mixes us into itself, seizes us, and takes away the point of balance from beneath our feet. We recognize the open One also as a multitude capable of being assembled in an intellectual effort. Correlating it with ourselves, we involuntarily draw another distinction, one that also implies resemblance: we are an element, a term, something that finds within itself a thirst for ground.</p><p>The allegory of time is ruins, which exist in the process of a lasting disappearance, present in a state of movement toward absence. For the pair “eternity” and “human being,” or “I,” ruins are a threshold given, laying into the form of matter the elusive and unsubduable idea of ceaseless slipping-away, that is, of eternity. A bold stroke: the human being is close to ruins, as the skeleton of a personality is close to their skeleton. They are a trace; he, too, is a trace that leaves traces, even if unknowingly, while trying to take root in the world and to hold on within its eternal continuation, observed in the mind.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*u-E4MbNxjUKmxW4M.jpeg" /></figure><p>The agitation caused by the whim of thought, capable of surpassing the speed of light and embracing all being in the briefest span, of thinking being, catches the flesh and the weave of vessels and neurons unawares — this biological mass trying to leap beyond itself, diminishing the nature it has inherited, and inevitably arriving back at itself. At the place we can never leave. Discursive thinking inexorably turns into the flight of an anxiously hovering petal that has concentrated within itself a grain of “I.” This is a moment of precarious flight from oneself, of detachment and belonging, drawing a line inaccessible to physical sight between absence and presence, where fear gapes open.</p><p>Flight from oneself leaves us alone with ourselves all the more strongly the farther we go, producing new constructions that complicate our position but report the same thing: we are in search of a point from which at least some path might begin, and this point is a return to ourselves, inventing distances.</p><p>Culture preserves phrases that settle almost into muscle memory, capable of outrunning our efforts to say and pronounce. The ground gives way beneath one’s feet. The loss of a point of balance. A colossus on feet of clay. To knock the ground out from under one’s feet. Or the topos of the Golden Age — the “promised land.” Cultural memory gives us a second nature, an artificial one, acquired in the process of becoming within a continuing (or enduring) synonym of infinity and of time in general — being. The idioms I have written out are like a guiding sign, pointing attention both toward metaphorical feet and toward the feeling that runs through us, which need not literally touch earth or ground; it is enough to make such ground out of what is drawn from cultural memory. But to traverse it all, to assimilate it completely, is beyond our power. Sooner or later it leads us to a thought about its own nature — to the desire to last and not to end. As though we freeze in the moment when we choose words.</p><p>An acquaintance with language opens the space of words and meanings. At the same time, turning to them is an effort that follows the desire to formulate, to clarify, to say. Sometimes philosophy is said to begin with wonder. The purity of the exclamations “oh” and “ah,” articulating a bodily and respiratory action, releases the primary disposition between us and the world, composed of a cascade of sensations: wonder, agitation, embarrassment, fascination, etc. It is noteworthy that we are capable of surpassing sighs and exclamations — our primary intuitions — by means of the word, while still losing before the face of infinity and sinking into the incalculable selection of hypnotic correspondences. A name was invented for this strategy of reception: poetry, which admits incompleteness and cares for incompleteness. In a sense, it crushes the very idea of ground, replacing it with the inexhaustibility of analogies and approximations, staging before us the essence of centrifugal force, akin to flight around oneself in flight from anthropocentrism.</p><p>Infinity threatens ground with annihilation. Finitude is inevitable completion. Poetry — a sorcerous form of speech — combines these two forms of being and time. Can poetry kill God? Let us recall the author of the most famous verdict.</p><p>Nietzsche’s nihilism may be characterized as negation, that is, a tendency toward the demolition of the metaphysical foundation in European culture, of absolute grounds belonging to an inaccessible world: from Platonic ideas to the objective reality of science. “A tendency toward” is only an attempt to preserve approximation as an effort that does not necessarily grow into an act of destruction and critique. Even on the approaches to an activity that begins with a strike, there is a point of departure — a moment of crisis and of questions ripening, addressed to oneself, compelling one to reopen the Self. The tragic fate of antiquity does not belong to detached figures or to outsiders, external “others”; it lies in the palms of descendants, that is, of those who came out of it as from a cradle, nourished and raised by antiquity as it collapses or is brought down.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*TdnsL3GjQayJxbGp.jpeg" /></figure><p>I have come to the impression that the delta of a river made of cracks in a monolithic worldview project can be traced outside the channel of the crisis of Christianity and religion. The rupture in a crumbling ground, where emptiness rushes through the fissures, stretches from the Renaissance humanist model, which inspired confidence in human strength and satisfaction with human nature. In the eyes of the humanists, the human being appeared as the work of a taxidermist: not only a continuation of the will of the Lord, but a special creature capable of thinking itself the center of the universe and the cosmos. It is commonly held that the subject, with its autonomy to know and to act upon the world, triumphed over its former involvement in the vortex of accidents and imperatives. The triumph, in my view, ended in anxious chords passing into the lamentations of an enlightened mind that does not burn, but burns out.</p><p>The Enlightenment clutched at the fruit of the union between the Renaissance image of individuality and Cartesian developments; it brought together power and despotism as meanings, adding to them the state machine, covered over by reforms “for the people,” but far more often by reforms more diligently occupied with inventing humanity. An ideological totalization took hold, making use of the unifying beginnings of the designated type of personality. With the Enlightenment trust in rationality, the monolith of the Absolute was also displaced. Many religions consider God-the-creator as a maker who, after the greatest gift to being and to people, withdrew into rest, or, at best, took the position of a contemplator. The deistic disposition expressively formulated a similar, if not identical, truth that one may accept or reject: history takes place without the direct participation of the author of all.</p><p>The figurative opponent, in my view, which provided the trajectory later developed by the Deleuzian nomadic conception, was the fragment. Or the idea of fragmentariness, of the incompleteness of the world and of the human “I,” developed by the German Romantics. Fragmentariness is consonant with incompleteness, dysfunctionality, and also with the unfreedom to act freely, articulated by the natural drive of human nature in its desire to be whole, included in being. The innovation, as often happens, is also a response to crisis, a summary of lack. The decline of culture was captured by the Jena Romantic Friedrich Novalis, who took an active part in entering the concept of the “fragment” into the chronicle of philosophical ideas: “God has become in the West an idle spectator of that great and moving game which scholars and artists began in the light of their reason.”</p><p>The origin of the feeling of incompleteness described here can also be found in the medieval tradition of Christian mysticism, but it appears far more curiously in contrast with Enlightenment ideas and Kant’s Copernican revolution. He declared not that the human being was the center of everything around which an open and accessible world revolved, but that the world was the point of attraction for the human being, who was forced to adapt and to pore over the elusive, demanding object of knowledge.</p><p>Meanwhile, somewhere in the shadows, on the outskirts of the material world condemned as low, the corpus of aesthetic ideas was expanding. The skeleton of a capacious epistemological construction was growing flesh, gradually gaining a weight that led no longer toward the heights but toward the depths: it found itself in a revision of bygone times. From that revision, as from an illuminated initial of the verb, the pages of the tragedy of the diminishment of the human position amid the universe, in the domain of the beautiful and the sublime, were filled with content.</p><p>Alexander Baumgarten separated aesthetics, explicating it from the state of an implicit appendage to philosophical systems and assigning it the position of a lower mode of apprehending the world, while at the same time actualizing its ancient interpretation. The literal translation is “sensuous perception.” In his philosophical system, aesthetics implied sensuous cognition, emphasized bodily sensations, adhered to a number of Cartesian principles, for example the unity of the body, and preserved ancient connotations.</p><p>Soon there was added to it a verdict on the higher cognitive faculties. More precisely, almost a proclamation of their absence or limitation, synonymous with dead-endedness. Kant, in his conclusions about the unknowability of things-in-themselves, was unexpectedly optimistic about the human being; contrary to every burden, he considered it a great good to be free in the world of morality and to be free to constitute one’s humanity through decisions “to be somehow.” Only not everyone shared his optimism. The motive of divergence is clearly visible in the genesis of the category of the sublime, to which he personally contributed. Burke, Kant, Schlegel, and Schopenhauer attributed to the sublime the provocation of discomfort, the challenge of “pleasure from displeasure,” the approach of the human being to the dark beginnings of nature. Perhaps the darkness mentioned here appeared clearly mainly in the texts of the Romantics and of minds consonant with them, from whose pens philosophical pessimism began. The cornerstone of pessimism, in contemporary terms, is the feeling of nostalgia.</p><p>The future is a specter; the present is incompleteness answering with longing; and the past, which has simultaneously absorbed everything and bears the seal of “nothing” as inaccessibility, is the phantom image of the Golden Age. The pursuit of the phantom, a chase without a clear route. In the end, reality for melancholic intellectuals was painted with palettes of nostalgia, warming and depressing. Here the rupture is visible above all in temporal terms, that is, on the map of history. But the participation of time in various ruptures of being is also present in Schopenhauer, in the context of superiority over the dynamics of the world will — in essence, the moving plate of reality — as a result of which the subject is capable of becoming a pure subject, freed from the snares of ceaseless striving toward the future as in a kaleidoscope of new phenomena. The moment of the asserted superiority over such an order may be defined as elevation.</p><p>According to a number of philosophers, the sublime in postmodernity rests on the slipping-away feeling of a ghostly past, or on the play not of imagination, as in Kant, but of memory operating by means of imagination. Thus we feel the “invisible” that touches us in the act of creation or dreamy leisure. The rupture inherent in the “sublime,” if we maintain the line of usage set in this text — the consequence of fear in Burke, of dissatisfaction with the non-purposive in Kant, of the world will growing numb in the individual and of his elevation above the stormy currents of desire in Schopenhauer — is expressed, for example, in Lyotard as the dissonance of reception in subjects belonging to two contradictory discourses that have come into contact. Behind the disagreement, it is not difficult to discern the fracture of antiquity with its characteristic mode of thought, into which the gaze of the modern human being penetrates with a collection of assumptions and premises of perception relevant to him.</p><p>The radical verdict on history, as is well known, was passed by Friedrich Nietzsche, who placed on the pages of The Gay Science the words “God is dead,” words that let the blood of eternity — of time frozen still. Equivalents of the aphorism can be found among Nietzsche’s predecessors as well. In the constellation of the ideologists of Romanticism there were those who not only believed in the return of the “Golden Age,” like Hölderlin, but supposed the death of God, after which the world would awaken. Heinrich Heine, in his book On Germany, wrote of a beginning that follows the end and gives ground for the transformation of all structures separated from one another, when sensualism and spiritualism would merge into one. Similar hopes were held by Novalis, who indulged in fantasies of combining disciplines distant from one another, of fusing art with science and the humanities with the natural sciences.</p><p>Nietzsche’s dark formula carried a rather descriptive function, serving as an attempt to bear witness to what had occurred and opening a path toward a conversation about the prophetic theme of the “overhuman.” The one to whom it is allotted to overcome the human being, descended from God. Between the advent of the overhuman and the collapse of the human, together with the host of old values sunk into decadence, there is an interval.</p><p>The need for the eternal can be regarded as an attribute of human nature, standing in the same row as the thirst for fullness and for ground. But the eternal collapses; its waters acquire a stale taste, no longer nourishing with their former force the desire to be eternal “in precisely this way.” Fullness encounters otherness and the portrait of the Other, composed of fragments of a crumbling and dismantled culture. Ground gives way to the abyss, where what remains is the eternity of falling and the fragile fullness of the person set against the surpassing fullness of the Nothing. For the Nothing is always full of emptiness.</p><p>With Nietzsche, the position of the aesthetic seemed to return to the field of life’s vicissitudes, resisting the increasingly aggravated tradition of constructing aesthetic theory, which was reincarnating itself in literary studies with its center of gravity in literary monuments. Although, after the fact, Nietzsche’s offspring was rather the accentuation of the cognitive powers hidden in aesthetics and directed toward catching the past in the many-faced manifestations of art.</p><p>The pillars that had propped up the world began to list, giving rise to the territory of a dynamic history of the “I,” of shifting boundaries of signs and symbols that allow us to see not a “tree” of meanings, but a rhizome. The rhizome is not ideal; even as it sprouts, it rather uncompromisingly deprives itself of ground than produces it, dispersing in an attempt to survive. The loss of the dictate of the Absolute indirectly secured the triumph of the subject’s autonomy, already complete in terms of its possibilities. It gave the sought-for personal “elevation,” but exposed a wound in the fabric of being and existence, requiring either a funeral feast or endless sacrifices of the “high” as it merges with the low in the process of laying ground beneath the feet of a human being hovering in the abyss of life. The rupture displayed not only power; with it came anxiety, vulnerability, and, finally, the celebrated existential horror before the Nothing, or that Nietzschean abyss into which one was destined to gaze.</p><p>In antiquity, rhapsodes wove into the naming of events threads whose ends stretched from the laws of Logos and of order opposing chaos. The poets of the nineteenth century exchanged laurel wreaths for crowns of thorns, proclaiming not the poetry of divine and mythical forces overcoming chaos, but, with their voice, dispersing the chill from the cooling lips of Orphic being and of the single universe. Such poetic art remains beautiful, in my view, by more clearly absorbing the transgressive nature of the sublime, tracing on the map of the universe ruptures in whose emptiness being disappears. Jean Baudrillard called such poetry a “dissolution of the particle of the signifier,” a continuation of the all-encompassing song of nihilism that leaves the human being alone with himself.</p><p>Poetry and singing. A moment of solitude and of self-manifested abandonment. The last and yet the first manuscript, still holding the warmth of the hand. When silence overtakes us as a form of rest — for example, in an automatic action — we may hum verses that become song. Music fills external space, while text passes through us, orienting itself toward inner space. It is not for nothing that text is kin to painting. It writes, paints, depicts, awakening dormant imagination. In pronouncing text, we move from the external into the internal, immersing ourselves and once again reproducing the principle of oscillation — we are carried from the internal into the external, accepting perspective. All perspectives, as in the plot of overcoming anthropocentrism, are spoken through the human being. Through himself, too, the human being discovers fear, mirrored in a portrait that depicts the truth: the human being is a continuation of being.</p><p>We possess a multitude of models whose configuration is arranged in the relation between the human being and being, laying itself bare through fear and wonder, tracing the contours of philosophical thinking. The beginning of philosophy is assigned to an indistinguishable boundary of wonder and questioning. But is the question a continuation of thought, or does it follow after a surge of feeling, provoking thought? Can it exist outside the form of language?</p><p>Intuitions lead to the selection of words, to the complex organization of experiences that turn toward layers of meaning and are turned by them. Intuitions, too, ripen somewhere on this finest boundary, a stroke in the technique of sfumato. A concise name for the ghost of the boundary is crisis. But all this is already philosophy, enduring and unfolding. What, then, anticipates the question? The broadest and essentially pure striving to become conscious of oneself, to be reflected in consciousness, to discover and accept. To recognize one’s presence as a given, appearing much later in the formula of “the unfreedom to be / free.” To find the strength to be, interrupting the inertia of existence. To accomplish this is to arrive at readiness to pose the question.</p><p>Poetry clearly exists within the boundaries of the boundless effort to be, accepting its own finitude.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*OGzStPaA-1pFNtmV.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=12a7d87b102b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Jennifer’s Body’, ‘Obsession’, and the Desire Given Too Much Being]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/theuglymonster/the-hunger-of-the-other-within-ac0bec2b5614?source=rss-e7a7a00e1089------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac0bec2b5614</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-studies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oleg Derrunda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Jul 2026 12:22:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-13T07:18:47.423Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Horror | Philosophy</h4><h4>The hunger of the Other within</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tuEiecC1K2bfFCQNEQCk6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Luca Ciamberlano “Studies of seven hands, two of which are joined together”, 1600–1630 (The British Museum)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>Verlangen brennt in mir<br>Gedanken — sie verdunken sich<br>Versuche nicht sie zu ergründen<br>Meine Blicke sie — sie suchen Dich<br>Sie zwingen mich zu handeln<br>Ein Sturm tobt in mir<br>Hunger brennt in mir</blockquote><blockquote><em>:wumpscut:, “Hunger” — Cannibal Anthem, 2006</em></blockquote><h3>The Other within</h3><p>The fingers of my hand touch my cheek. In my mind, like a revealed truth, the adjective “my own” attaches itself to the noun. The pads of my fingers press into the skin a little more firmly than a playful gust of wind might touch it, or a petal lost in the euphoria of flight. There is no mirror before me, yet nothing prevents me from saying: “this is me.” In my imagination there rises a blurred silhouette of my face, familiar from photographs or reflections. It always resembles a guest from a dream: elusive, difficult to fix in place. Nevertheless, it is me. I am in the spasms and tension of muscles, in effort, in the breath tearing itself against the palm near my face, and finally in the thought that gathers all the revelations of the flesh into one.</p><p>Something else. Besides me — that “I” which commands, reacts — there is also the “I” that keeps silent and is not so forthcoming. I seek confirmation of myself and notice <strong>the Other within</strong>. Something can live without self-consciousness. I, however, know that I have an <strong>I</strong>: from the beginning to the end of my days it — or I, as a possessing, sovereign being? — will be at home with ourselves. The horizon of my experience will contain all the time of the world. More than that will not be given to me, and so everything begins and closes in this single letter, cutting through the streams of an imaginary history. Yet even in automatic actions, where the trace of will is hardly visible, there is a shadow accompanying the “I”. A trail of excess acquired from presence in the oversaturated reality of the human, which says what I am and what I can become.</p><p>Where the body begins, the certainty of the self does end. The ensemble of thoughts suggests the conviction that it stands obediently before the eyes. Even in moments of turmoil. The body, however, can resist far more visibly than thought. It can fail, disappoint, and unmistakably affect the sovereign halls of consciousness. Where there is a body, battles for our “I” take place. And behind the strokes of even the most free-thinking decisions, behind the right hand slicing the air in an imperative gesture that divides or appropriates, there flickers the shadow of <strong>the Other within</strong>. At best, it is partly “one’s own,” a stray echo of the “I,” its offspring, not quite entered into the genealogy of thoughts, having made kinship with intuitions and affects. More often, it is a purely self-willed beginning. A convulsion in need of a name and remaining nameless.</p><p>Our body, as a fully legitimate material object, is capable of being reflected (from the surface of a mirror), and at the same time of reflecting (through action) <strong>the Other within</strong>. Oh, it will hastily tell of us, since, contrary to every dispute, it is woven into the genealogy of those very acts. It will also tell of itself, that is, of <strong>otherness</strong>, which obstructs usurpation under the banners of a single “I.”</p><p>Besides the “I” and <strong>the Other within</strong> that inhabit us, there remains an even more external, alienated reality. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Others</strong>.</p><p>Our “I,” extended by the body, opens itself to the eyes and touches of <strong>the Others</strong>, always occupying an angle. The body appears, and as such it will be perceived. It belongs to the trap of events, where it is and where it is given. It can experience these events itself and only partly find its own boundaries in them, while <strong>the</strong> <strong>Others</strong> can discern this very body, that side of it which instills the conviction that it has been grasped by the gaze of <strong>the Other</strong> in its entirety. The external is easy to mark, fix, see, remember, inseparably distinguishing its alienation from oneself. The body itself, however, because of the sense of time and the intensity of experience, can fall out of the dotted line of time onto a line, a sheer slope, from which there is a risk of being lost altogether behind even the underside of the body as a managed chronology of actions and impulses.</p><p>Thus the body is almost the doom of the manifestation of the “I.” A declaration that should be inseparable from us, but precisely it — convincing us of tangibility and of belonging to a shared event — is torn away from us by being seen otherwise. <strong>The Others</strong> embody the gaze that makes the body excessively determinate. It appears beautiful, dangerous, guilty, attractive. It is read, and the reading itself writes the text, outrunning the authorial hand. <strong>The Other within</strong> is not quite mine. It is hunger, arousal, shame, trembling, involuntariness. It takes place in me and yet is not completely with me.</p><p>The gap between two kinds of belonging calls upon the human tendency to understand and explain — to designate by naming. Attempts to assert one’s own sovereign right immediately are futile. Incomplete belonging gapes like a fatal breach; it is the cradle of desire. Desire does not arrive as a clear intention directed toward an already chosen object. Its lineage begins in the body’s knowledge, which anticipates thought: when the gaze lingers before decision, and within, certainty thickens into the density of impenetrable darkness, never becoming a word. In desire, <strong>the Other within</strong> is still bound to me, because it happens in me; yet it reaches toward the world, differing from me.</p><h3>Betrayals of the Flesh</h3><p>The body betrays me twice. From within, because <strong>the Other within </strong>lives in it. From without, because <strong>the</strong> <strong>Others</strong> see it as an accomplished image, even if it is still coming true before their eyes. What I perceive as myself, or at least as my extension, plays a cruel joke on me.</p><p>We often turn to an interpretation of the inner world as a clear space, illuminated by reflection and the light of reason. <strong>The Other within</strong>, it would seem, can hardly replace the “I.” Light appears destined to disperse darkness. Yet <strong>the Other</strong> <strong>within</strong> grows, gains strength within. Its shadow thickens, turning into darkness, and the speculative gaze turned toward the source risks losing itself in an unpierceable gloom.</p><p>It lacks a face with which one could argue. It has no speech by which one could answer back; nor is it moved by a design. It does not think in my place and does not dispose of me like a second master. The character of its presence sketches the outline of <strong>the Other</strong> like a caricature of a human being, while it is a pre-subjective excess of the body, whose insistence lets it outrun explanation. The first form in which this dark excess receives a direction outward is offered by desire.</p><p><strong>The Other within</strong> happens in me, tries to actualize itself. It occurs as a flash of dusk thinning the hall illuminated by clarity. Sometimes it is encountered before I come up against <strong>the Others</strong>. But it is precisely <strong>the Others</strong> who turn this inner otherness into a visible image, a sign, a clue, an object of desire. <strong>The Other within</strong>, fanned like a fire by the breath of faces whose intent gaze outlines it, can take on monstrous forms.</p><p><strong>The Other within</strong> does not immediately become desire. At first it exists as a murkiness ripening in residual tension. Enchantment, sudden pull, impulse, obsessive intuition. The dark excess of the body turns into movement: a pull outward, into breadth, toward an object not yet distinguished and, most importantly, toward one with which <strong>the Other within</strong> cannot merge because of its kinship with us.</p><p>Yet it is precisely through desire that <strong>the Other within</strong> acquires a trajectory of expansion, reinforced by gestures, names, cultural tropes, and words. It becomes increasingly apparent that desire forms an intermediate region between <strong>the Other within</strong> and <strong>the Others</strong>. It is like a word on the tip of the tongue, abiding in the liminality of lethologica: it strives to be pronounced and does not give itself all at once. For desire is ceaselessly becoming, never fitting into the sound of the uttered.</p><p>Born as an internal discord, desire almost immediately needs external confirmation. Gradually, this role distinctly falls to the Other, not simply to the one who is desired. While the cavalcade of chosen names stretches out, never quite falling from the tongue, <strong>the Other</strong> is stretched as well. He becomes a surface upon which <strong>the Other within</strong> tries to read its own form.</p><p>The films <em>Jennifer’s Body</em> and <em>Obsession</em> show different destinies of desire once it has been allowed to leave internal darkness. Both stories, perhaps, might not have happened, even if we accept the reality of magic at face value. The actors in these cinematic worlds might not have met; the characters who undertook the fulfillment of desires might have gone another way. The original nature of their desires, ignoring another’s independence, effectively condemned those desires to concealment, to preservation in the vacuum of a secret. In reflection, such secrets are skirted around. Too easily they carry one away into dreams, whose taste begins to be distinguished on the tongue, after which there remains only a tormenting, inflamed pain from the impossibility of catching the cherished, alluring being — the myth of one’s own completedness in another form. And yet these desires became real. The characters chose necromancy, resurrecting unborn desires that likely were fated to remain a dead weight of unrealized strivings in the catacombs of the inner dwelling.</p><p>The viewer sees their desires in the state of hunting for their own fulfillment. In both cases they make their way outward, ceasing to be part of the internal order. Then they return to the source, to the center of their world, already as an alien and merciless force.</p><h3>Hic sunt leones</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*emAtVAQ3L36AceOPElR8ig.png" /><figcaption>Michael Johnston as Bear and Inde Navarrette as Nikki in <em>Obsession</em> (2025). Credit: Focus Features/Universal Pictures</figcaption></figure><p>Desire is naively imagined to be only ours. Just as we strive to be beyond ourselves, constantly inscribing ourselves into a future that has not yet come, desire too longs to be embodied, urging us to be in accordance with it. It is much larger, because it lies beyond our limits, beyond what we are not yet.</p><p>In <em>The Erl-King</em>, Michel Tournier tells the story of Abel Tiffauges, a Frenchman who witnessed the gaping emptiness of hope in the split between the First and Second World Wars. The owner of a small garage is described as a man who carries a monster within himself, one among many. The author names him an Ogre, a character from an unfinished myth. He is infinitely alone and yet does not feel himself deficient. This infinity is an abyss full of emptiness. It is far from lack; on the contrary, it is an excess overflowing in the form of a thirst for solitude as completedness. That is why even in Abel’s routine behavior there shows through a monstrosity that arises before any fanged maw.</p><p>The hero often calls himself a man-eater. Nevertheless, we never encounter cannibalistic scenes. Despite his attraction to flesh, meat, wounds, and bodies, Abel’s thirst is not physiological. He desires the ingestion of meanings and signs with which he unconsciously seeks to nourish his own emptied existence. He is drawn by a hunger for the fullness of being, sung in the conviction that he has a destiny and is an elected figure. The belief that he bears a special sign, a colossal mythical potency, is ineradicably strong in him. It seems to be part of his nature. But this goal, drawing a boundary on the map of the “I,” is unknown to him: he is delivered to himself as a myth that wants to be born. Desires ripening within us must be constituted in the external and from the outside, that is, fastened to a reality that narrates and is narrated about. Therefore the indeterminacy of the inner myth returns him to <strong>the Others</strong>, who instill a brief certainty that his fate has been confirmed by external being.</p><p>Tiffauges’s monstrosity is semiotic. It exists alongside more literal cannibals belonging to the Nazi elite and devouring nations. The contrast in scale makes visible the result of the aspiration to ingest what is, to pass it through the interpreting maw behind which a world is ripening. As the material embodiment of the myth of war sinks into oblivion, leaving behind shattered fragments and an echo, so the Ogre disappears into the swamp of signs. The last minutes of Tiffauges’s life, nevertheless, are far from caricature. He manages to attain the cherished existence in an aura of chosenness that can be seen from without. In addition, the optics set by Abel’s gaze, by his diary entries, allow us to perceive the rituality and saturation of his separate existence, rooted in the world. We find his monstrosity as captivity to the desire to be more, to inscribe himself into the enormity of being, endlessly stretching beyond the visible horizon and the ruins of epochs. This monstrosity, splitting into lesser desires subordinated to the single cherished desire that does not fully yield to naming, carnivorously interprets the bearer of <strong>the Other within</strong> and <strong>the Others</strong>. The external world is food for it.</p><p>Tournier’s cannibalistic image stands on a border: the maw has not yet opened literally, although the world has already been given to the inner myth as food. Abel ingests the world as a sign. His hunger, growing under the star of monstrosity, still seems internal, diaristic. In the process of becoming, his desire ceases to be a private feeling and learns to read the world carnivorously. After Abel it becomes easier to see how <strong>the Other within</strong> passes from internal shadow outward.</p><p>One object is not enough for it. <strong>The Other within</strong>, manifested in desire, darkens thoughts, compels the gaze to search, and the body to set out in search of nourishment: searches which, instead of leading along some road, draw every route toward the Other as the center of all maps and itineraries, generating meaning.</p><h3>The Queen Jennifer’s Two Bodies</h3><p>People rarely know themselves well enough. The same is true of desire, an exile from their inner labyrinth. What they know is only the image that suggests their position in the world and society, offering a fantasy of themselves. Outside the focus lies the rupture separating them in the present from the fruit of imagination to which the gaze is harnessed by the reins of desire.</p><p><strong>The Other within</strong>, what we are at the edge, in the shadows of ourselves, manifests in us precisely as desire. It blends with the “I” or displaces it. The shadow can easily surpass that which cast it. Thus <strong>the Other within</strong> stretches out as an underside that twists the geometry of the thinking and feeling “I.” It rises within as a force for which it is too late to seek justification, and enters the territory of the face. Desire devours the human being.</p><p>We tell ourselves that we desire a person, while in fact desiring the impossible and untouchable: their image, a cultural trope, an insurmountable thicket of symbols. Jennifer appears as a ready-made hermeneutic exercise. Genre, autoerotically occupied with its own codes, the labor of marketers, context, and the viewer’s memory of Megan Fox meet her before she has time to become an event for herself or for the viewer. Her body is known in advance: as beauty, danger, promise, screen canon.</p><p>The motion picture <em>Jennifer’s Body</em> holds two key images. Jennifer, as she exists in the architectonics of the work: seductive and fatal, dangerous and carnivorous. She entices, becoming the object of desire, and devours the one who desires. The image of the media figure Megan Fox, Jennifer’s prototype: a digital canon that taught the public to react in a certain way. Cinematic magic needed only to give Megan Fox a fictional name for the media body to enter the plot as a character. This image has liminal significance. It connects the veil of signs with which Megan Fox was surrounded to the way perception of the character was prearranged.</p><p>Their source is Megan Fox, hidden by the myth of her. Both images are braided into the contour of a single desire attributed to the sex symbol. They do not coincide completely, yet they grow together into a state that begins beyond the cinematic universe. Jennifer gives a hypertrophied and situational embodiment of Megan Fox as a celebrity who herself exists situationally, or eurhythmically. She appears in society pages, in photographs, in stories from a preset angle, according to the laws of an environment transcendent in relation to ordinary people. In an almost ritual action she appears to the gaze, remaining an essence inaccessible directly.</p><p>The Hollywood industry of the 2000s constructed an absolute mythical Body, an analogue of the political body of the sovereign or corpus mysticum. It does not belong to the real Megan Fox, because it was created to bear the weight of touches within the gazes of millions and the pressure of the environment that ensures its manifestness. This body is immortal and affects the name surrounded by others’ ways of seeing. It exists as one of the limit-images of sexuality through which culture trains the gaze, and lies beyond real experience: only a limit-image can withstand limit-attention. But such exceptionality requires elementarity. Such a body cannot bear a multitude of equal traits, biographical complexity, internal contradiction, and the freedom of the subject. In order to remain at the limit, it must be almost mercilessly reduced to the function for which culture exalted it: sexual manifestness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZNMo7Af_AyCcfAD_uiR6iw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Megan Fox as Jennifer Check in <em>Jennifer’s Body</em> (2009). Credit: 20th Century Fox</figcaption></figure><p>In the film, the image designed for exceptionality is placed onto a character named Jennifer. The viewer sees precisely the canonical body, created as the fruit of desire, though with a flaw: this fruit does not strive to remain transcendent. It longs to be fatal and stunning by itself. Yet the demonic trap proves weaker than the rules of mass culture. Additional meanings were grafted onto this body: threat, interiority, subjectivity, sinister irony, the right to look back. But the media Body rejects excess, ignoring the will of the subject, because it belongs not only to the character and not only to the actress. It belongs to the transcendent environment of cinema, celebrity, and screens, beyond which the ordinary person observes almost as if watching gods: from afar, through a permitted angle, at a moment of apparition appointed not by him.</p><p>Within the film this logic acquires a ritual form. In the plot of <em>Jennifer’s Body</em>, the band Low Shoulder approaches Jennifer as the bearer of the ritual trait they need: virginity. To it is added beauty, which drew their attention, and the very meaning of sacrifice upon the altar of success for their project. Jennifer’s body was supposed to confirm all the signs that <strong>the Others</strong> had placed into it in advance, having decided that they had read her without remainder. Yet they were mistaken about her. This error brought about the birth of a monster. Not from the mystery of a femme fatale, but from their own empty certainty, including the certainty that they understood themselves.</p><p>It is noteworthy that the idea of innocence was laid by them upon beauty as an intensifying modifier; in reality, it was an illusion, which later turned into an underside and allowed the succubus, the antonym of innocence, to take possession of Jennifer. The transmutation of meanings brought to light what they in fact desired, only in a hypertrophied, catastrophic volume. Jennifer opened in another grammar, already reading <strong>the Others</strong> herself in a way convenient to her: as beauty that had rejected moderation. What remained of her was the unkillable remainder of the fantasy of her, an image to which inner darkness had returned.</p><p>The old doctrine gave the king two bodies. One was mortal and open to illness and age. The other, the jurists insisted, was free of natural defect and could not die. Both doublings rest on a single operation. A second body is obtained by subtracting time from the first. What the lawyers of the crown once achieved by removing death from the king, the industry of the canon achieves by removing from the star the hours in which an ordinary life goes on. The body of Queen Jennifer is the one assembled wherever the gaze already waits for her. It is radiant and dangerous, complete at every appearance, as though nothing had happened to it between one apparition and the next. The body of the real Megan Fox lives in the subtracted hours. It knows fatigue and age, as any flesh does, and for this body the public language has no words, since the mass imagination permits a person to exist only in the familiar form, and a step outside that form begins to resemble disappearance. Where the old doctrine crowned a single immortal body in each realm, the culture of screens crowns many. Every such crown is also a sentence.</p><p>Read this way, the ritual of Low Shoulder is the old doctrine taken literally. They kill the body natural, and the second Body walks on. The queen is dead, the Queen continues to appear, and the sacrifice turns out to be a coronation. Yet this fullness is unstable. Admirers sustain it with their attention, victims with their vitality, and when the nourishment ceases the body begins to disintegrate. Jennifer has taken into herself an entity that intensifies her traits to their limit, and her beauty now exists at an intensity no ordinary body could withstand. Radical beauty arouses delight precisely because the threat of disintegration is already contained within it. It reaches the final moment of fullness, after which the form must collapse or change. Jennifer attempts to prolong this moment. A brief peak of manifestation becomes for her a permanent condition, and the price of such intensity is the lives of others. Beauty preserved through sacrifice becomes monstrous without ceasing to be beautiful.</p><p>The cannibalism embedded in the plot and in the film’s marketing presentation turns back against the viewer. It appears as a pure gesture of consumption. The haptic, predatory gaze, touching the flesh that must be an epiphenomenon of a digital canon, an inaccessible, almost transcendent image, takes on a literal form, turning the maw in the opposite direction. The gaze devours the one who contemplates. The viewer wanted to use the body as a sign; the film shows a sign to which a body has been given. A surface intended for the gaze receives inner experience and teeth.</p><p>When the visible yet unspoken content of desire came outward, everything seemed to become obvious. Nevertheless, the reaction to the film was built around the dominant image of Megan Fox herself. The same certainty in reading without remainder played its role here. Megan Fox as a person was almost immediately displaced by her own screen trace.</p><p>Regardless of intention — whether defense, countercultural statement, or rethinking of an image — an oversaturated image can continue its former work in renewed form if it again takes its prototype as a convenient figure through which to explain an epoch. The clearer culture knows how to look at Jennifer, the more terrifying the moment when this gaze ceases to be safe. Thus, perhaps, the real horror happened in reality, when the media image of Megan Fox and the image written into the film’s script reached toward the dark temptation in viewers’ thinking: to think the character in proportion to the inaccessible phenomenon of Megan Fox. Hence Jennifer became a packaged, clear symbol.</p><h3>The Invention of Nikki</h3><p>The story of Bear and Nikki in <em>Obsession</em> is different. We fulfill our desires. Their fulfillment by <strong>the Others</strong> is an intimate moment of surprise, of a dream come true: a subtle reading and interpretation, attuning two people to a shared private myth, isolated and protected from outsiders. Between people arise points of emotional contact, underground meanings known only to them in trivial phrases. All these lines of meaning are sewn into a thin fabric, elusive to another’s gaze and hearing, like a palatine wrapping both of them away from the outside world. The absolute completion of a limit-desire by a third force indifferent to both the subject of desire and its object leads to the collapse of the stitching of biographies. Reality simply accommodates a spontaneously appeared and self-fulfilling desire.</p><p>At first Bear carries within himself a desire with an obvious psychological subtext. Psychology is a convenient way to explain the point of departure. Bear appears in the story as a small man: neither possessed of the ambitions of a romantic sovereign nor marked by some great vice. He is simply undergoing a crisis of loss. The order of his personal life, where there had been instances that produced familiar meanings for him independently of him, has collapsed. Unable to cope with the fullness of loss, he sets out in search of the fullness of life. The shortest path is to experience another’s need for him, to find someone who will confirm to him that he is alive and that his existence means something.</p><p>He tells himself that he is in love with Nikki. From this moment the scale of events changes. The desire for reciprocated feeling grows together with the learned cultural lessons about how one is supposed to love and suffer from unrequited feeling. Gradually desire acquires details, since through its prism Bear perceives the surrounding world, and through it he may also have come to know himself as the one who desires.</p><p>Desire leads us to our limits because its fulfillment requires efforts that transform us as well. In other words, we must cease to be ourselves in all fullness and become those for whom fulfilled desire is part of reality. Bear, however, yielded to the temptation to save himself from the risk of remaining alone with himself. He cannot endure the slow birth of desire, its fading blossoms, its indeterminacy, which guarantees nothing. By letting a third force intervene in the magic wand, he releases <strong>the Other within</strong> outward, where it acquires a body and autonomy. This is no longer desire as a private myth uniting two people. For desire has a heautonomous manifestness that builds its own world. Words no longer restrain it. When such a desire is not bound by the frame of a word leaving the lips in expectation of actions that will draw it nearer to appearance, it goes further. It fulfills itself and surpasses the one who desired, absorbing the force of all the words fit to mark its boundary. As if in a process of erosion, they expose the path to neighboring words, adjacent meanings, side corridors of the formula: “I want Nikki to love me more than anyone in the world.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FkEW7swop0abz2t4gGZceQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Inde Navarrette as Nikki in <em>Obsession</em> (2025). Credit: Focus Features/Universal Pictures</figcaption></figure><p>Nikki’s body suffers as any matter suffers from the intensity of a growing desire capable of overcoming every threshold and expanding outward. For desire always leads to thresholds, to the underside of ourselves, and is calibrated by our resolve to become other than ourselves. Nikki becomes a body from which another’s desire has expelled interiority. Her “I” freezes in catalepsy, in a tormenting position: precisely incapable of loving and condemned to be territory occupied by a double that exists in service to the uttered desire.</p><p>Nikki is frightening not because she loves too strongly. Her obsession, the dark side of Bear and the meanings he did not tame, lies in the fact that her love for Bear continues to appear even when he ceases to recognize it. Bear dimly understands himself; Nikki, too, is disclosed to him in darkness. His attempt to restore internal order rests upon the invention of an inexorable love. It continues throughout all reality as far as the ceaselessly generated meanings can reach, gathering around Bear, the center of a myth not for a human being but for a perfect feeling. And this perfect feeling, having become external, has no need of the one who desired at all. It looks upon its progenitor like a curse; it reworks almost recognizable gestures, jealousy, tenderness, other signs of attention, into an environment where it will cease to be <strong>the Other within</strong>, having obtained itself. Bear becomes the outsider. For a curse is always the external encroaching upon the internal.</p><h3>The Sovereignty of the Ugly</h3><p>Both films rely upon an ancient mythologeme: the human being desires to reach the desired in a single step. In <em>Jennifer’s Body</em>, a rock band sacrifices Jennifer for success; in <em>Obsession</em>, naive Bear, craving a reciprocation that exceeds even his own feelings, sacrifices Nikki’s autonomy. When the hapless characters undertake to shorten the path toward desire, they step across humanity and the human in order to arrive at an image.</p><p>The image is poorer than the human being, because it does not live in history. Yet it can become stronger than the human being, because it binds itself to many people through culture. Culture prefers schemes to living unpredictability. The human being carries within himself the potential of an excess of possibilities; the character contains the potential for the hypertrophy of traits. A fantasy is tolerable while it is silent, while it lives on the surface of the screen or in a myth shared by many. The distance between the internal and the external serves as a guarantee of safety. If life is concentrated in the model, however, this model risks becoming oversaturated, allowing two poles to touch arbitrarily. Thus in both films desire receives <em>too much being.</em></p><p>Here the question of sovereignty arises. The characters of these stories want desire to confirm their ontological force. Low Shoulder hope to turn someone else’s body into future fame. Bear wants another’s love to return weight to his own existence. Each of them enters desire as a promise of increase. But desire, having reached the limit, does not return the human being to himself without loss. It pushes further.</p><p>Jennifer’s canon — merciless beauty — was meant to become an offering. The excess of her vitality, of her captivating seductiveness, was intended for a profitable bargain. Jennifer is the classical <em>La Belle Dame sans Merci</em>, the Merciless Beauty. Her beauty depends directly on the amount of blood spilled. Her canon is also the digital image of Megan herself: the way she is depicted and thought, the way it is convenient to think her. This image was given interiority; it was supposed to write a story in the career of Megan Fox as well, establishing a point of support for a rethought image. The inner life of this image returned as a maw; it underwent an erosion that devoured the meanings natural to it. Her own, more real image, the image of the film actress, collided with an embodiment pulling her to the edge of culture. The risk of falling into Nothing is almost invariably resolved by culture in one way only: the blind multiplication of the same. And culture created an image without a right to inner sovereignty.</p><p>In <em>Obsession</em>, desire also does not belong to the subject, because, once fulfilled, it becomes stronger than his ability to dispose of the consequences. In the end, Bear, the musical group, and the viewer in the case of <em>Jennifer’s Body</em> all reaped the fruits of cultural tropes. They entered desire as a bargain and found themselves in a sacrificial fire. The attempt to treat desire as exchange shattered against the fact that desire must lead into the realm of expenditure, where the subject will not receive himself back in his previous form. To desire, one must know how to lose.</p><p>Only one figure in either film learns this. Needy inherits a portion of Jennifer’s power, and the payment takes everything that tied her to the ordinary world, from Chip to the innocence of her own gaze. The force that annihilated its buyers consents to be carried by the one who did not enter desire as a bargain.</p><p>The buyers knew nothing of loss. Their desires were not born of sovereignty, and such desires easily acquire sovereignty of their own. In this sense desires, including amorous and erotic ones, are close to an act of creation. Eroticism almost inevitably leads to the violation of the boundaries of a separate being. It is alien to harmonic fullness, to the triumph of union. It is the whining feeling of something greater, the call of the abyss, passing along the boundary of the loss of form — close to Nothing and, accordingly, hand in hand with the ugly.</p><p>By “the ugly,” I do not mean mere ugliness, but a broader aesthetic category that includes the formless, the grotesque, and the image-threatening. It names the point where form begins to deform from within. It can be, and often is, part of something extraordinarily beautiful, because every manifestation carries the threat of its own excess: a beauty too intense for the laws of reality that allow it to appear.</p><p>Yet eroticism lays bare the “I” in which desire ripens; it makes the human being visible to himself. In the films, however, the subject is excluded, and with him the sacrifice that a person is prepared to make for the fulfillment of his own desire is excluded as well. And in every sacrifice we lose a small part of ourselves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U3kdVEbYZS6HTi3YAisWeg.png" /><figcaption>Art from ‘The Aesthetics of Decay’</figcaption></figure><p>Embodied images drown in the ugly. As I wrote in ‘<em>The Aesthetics of Decay</em>’, the ugly arises in limit-manifestness, breaking form from within. It exists in everything that ought not to exist yet appears inexorably. Jennifer does not cease to be beautiful. On the contrary, her beauty becomes too efficacious. Nikki almost invariably resembles a loving woman. Only love becomes deprived of inner boundaries and of the readiness to retreat. In both cases the desired continues to appear, disregarding reality and reworking it for itself. There is an excess in it, because of which form begins to darken, thickening the world around it as well. <strong>The ugly</strong>, the underside of horror, merely takes up the unbearable nature of perfection for reality.</p><h3>The Catacombs of My “I”</h3><p>Awakened desire speaks the language of ontological excess, not at all as my will. It speaks as though it needs the body more strongly than I do. Like an untamed beast ready to push me into Nothing. The letters of the thought “this is me,” once instilling calm, now seem an agitated ligature.</p><p>The body hardly promises complete power over itself. And if it does promise it, then it offers empty assurances. It turns to everything that will instill faith in its belonging to reality: rituals, common hopes, genres, and other images. The threat, nevertheless, comes from the “I,” without which there is neither desire nor its monstrous potential. As toward a dark mirror, I bend over the lakes of my soul. From there comes a call addressing me by name. It is woven from scraps of the external world, of which I learned from <strong>The Others</strong>, thinking that I had learned to read myself without remainder. It demands a body, a gaze, weaknesses, faith in one’s own exceptionality. This is the abyss into which I must look, because it has been waiting for me, looking back, since the moment of birth.</p><p>And only one question remains: what exactly in me has learned to desire the world in my name?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7iRUaqUGVmwpgm6rQgPJpw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Megan Fox as Jennifer Check in <em>Jennifer’s Body</em> (2009). Credit: 20th Century Fox</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac0bec2b5614" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/theuglymonster/the-hunger-of-the-other-within-ac0bec2b5614">‘Jennifer’s Body’, ‘Obsession’, and the Desire Given Too Much Being</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/theuglymonster">The Ugly Monster</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>