<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Digital Intent on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Digital Intent on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@digintent?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 02:23:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@digintent/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Form and Manage a High Functioning Advisory Board]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/how-to-form-and-manage-a-high-functioning-advisory-board-7d34eccfee54?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d34eccfee54</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[manage-advisory-board]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advisor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advisory-board]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[form-advisory-board]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Feb 2019 19:25:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-19T18:01:50.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Advisors improve the speed and outcomes for the businesses they advise. Discover what they do, why they’re valuable, and how to best leverage them.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*nlARbb492NlEjRzMW8Eacw.png" /></figure><p>Building a successful business is really hard. So you should do everything you can to improve your likelihood of success. Startup advisors often play an important role in improving the speed and outcomes for the startups they advise. This article explores what advisors are, what they do, and how to get the most out of them.</p><h3>What is an advisor?</h3><p>Startup advisors help management teams make better decisions, move faster, and improve outcomes. Examples of the sorts of things advisors often help with include:</p><ul><li>Advice on business model strategy and positioning</li><li>Advice on key areas of the business (e.g., user acquisition, product architecture)</li><li>Honing your pitch decks and presentations</li><li>Introductions to potential investors</li><li>Introductions to key customers</li><li>Help identifying and recruiting talent</li><li>Acting as a sounding board for organizational and people issues</li></ul><p>Advisors are almost always experienced business people or domain experts who know things or have relationships the startup management team doesn’t.</p><h4>What advisors are not</h4><p><strong>Advisors are not mentors</strong>, at least in our lexicon. Mentors offer personal support and advice to entrepreneurs, not to the broader company. Advisors work on behalf of the company and all of its shareholders.</p><p>By definition, <strong>advisors are not employees</strong>. To the extent they formally engage (the relationship is often informal), they are independent contractors.</p><p>Legally and practically, <strong>advisors are not board directors</strong>. Directors also advise and support the company, but the context is quite different. Board directors have a legal status that comes with certain rights and duties that don’t accrue to advisors. Directors have the right to contribute to decisions about the strategy and operations of the company, and a right to be informed about the company. They also have a fiduciary duty to act on behalf of the interests of all the company’s shareholders, ensure they remain suitably informed about the company, and a duty of care in performing their duties. Advisors have no such duties or rights outside those expressed in a written advisory agreement.</p><p>Because advisors are not employees or directors, they often act more like mentors — meaning they emphasize the interests of the management team over the other shareholders. For that reason, in many cases entrepreneurs find they can be more open with advisors and more easily avoid conflict with them when dealing with high stress situations.</p><h3>Do advisors invest in the company?</h3><p>Advisors may invest in your company as well. Many of them are wealthy, and if they’re interested enough in what you’re doing and believe enough in you to actively help, it shouldn’t come as a surprise when they ask to invest.</p><p>But there are many reasons why advisors might not be able or willing to invest. Some simply don’t have the cash. Others might have external constraints that make it too difficult, for example corporate employer policies on equity holdings, or venture capitalists who have to avoid even the appearance of conflict for LPs and partners. Frankly when you’re early on, many advisors are waiting to see where you get before they decide to push any cash your way.</p><p>It’s trite to say (as some do) that entrepreneurs shouldn’t engage advisors who aren’t willing to put some money into the company. There’s almost always a point on a company’s path when it’s interesting enough for some advisor attention, but still too uncertain for them to risk cash on it. Cash is emotionally and practically different from time, particularly for non-entrepreneur advisors who may not have as much experience with risk capitalization.</p><p>Advisors who do invest are very often more engaged and attentive, so it’s almost always a good thing when they do. One potential downside is that advisors who invest sometimes begin to feel that you have an obligation to listen to their advice, or even an obligation to heed it.</p><p>My advice generally is to first focus on the value contributions and working relationship you have with advisors. Any conversations about investment should flow naturally, and should be viewed in the context of their advice more than their money — unless of course they are sophisticated investors with enough capital to really move the needle for you. And don’t exclude promising advisors just because they won’t invest. In the end, there are no hard and fast rules here, and you should constantly seek to optimize for a faster, better outcome.</p><h3>Are advisors important?</h3><p>In a word: yes. The right advisors engaged in the appropriate way can dramatically speed progress, reduce risks, and increase your likelihood of success. Changing the way things work (e.g., creating a new business model), inherently involves a level of complexity that requires diverse expertise and difficult problem solving. Advisors can offer operating experience and insights into areas of expertise that you’re very unlikely to have available on your early stage team. Those insights can have a fundamental impact on your company.</p><p>One of the most important things a good advisor will do is force you to reconsider your assumptions. It seems intuitive that diversity improves decision-making by bringing to bear differing perspectives. That’s true, but it doesn’t tell the entire story. Research out of Kellogg School of Management <a href="https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/better_decisions_through_diversity">demonstrated that</a>:</p><blockquote><em>“Diverse groups outperformed more homogeneous groups not because of an influx of new ideas, but because diversity triggered more careful information processing that is absent in homogeneous groups.”</em></blockquote><h3>Real world examples</h3><h4>The product did too good of a job</h4><p>In 2008, I was doing a startup turnaround as CEO of a recruiting technology venture portfolio company. I had no experience in recruiting at the time, hadn’t been part of making the original investment, and stepped in as a venture capitalist on behalf of my firm to try to fix a company that was quickly headed in a bad direction.</p><p>We made a seemingly impossible turnaround on the product in six weeks (the product team I brought in was amazing). But we were surprised that the recruiters targeted by our product were ambivalent about it. It was one of our advisors who pointed out a perspective that seemed alien to us: our product was doing too good of a job. Recruiters report their value to their bosses in part by filtering thousands of resumes into a much smaller set of good candidates. Our product automated a lot of that work for them, giving them more time to be good at the parts of their job only a human could perform. But because it made them feel left out of the loop, they felt threatened and diminished by it.</p><p>The solution was fairly quick and easy; we built in more participation and choices on their part, and ensured all of the reporting showed the scale and complexity of the applicant funnels they were managing. Their satisfaction immediately improved.</p><p>As performance-driven entrepreneurs without an insider perspective we would likely have remained blind to the recruiter concerns until it was too late. Score one for advisors.</p><h4>Near premature scaling</h4><p>A number of years ago I was on the advisory board of a startup operating a two-sided marketplace connecting small businesses and consumers. Registered user growth was strong, and CPAs (Cost Per Acquisition) were in line with industry averages. Unit margins were good, and NPS (Net Promoter Score) was great. It was early and low scale, but the founder was convinced things were working well enough to ramp up growth by increasing spending on acquisition.</p><p>However, I was concerned the acquisition model wouldn’t scale — it relied too heavily on street marketing by the team, which I believed was artificially skewing the CPAs down. I also was concerned that the CAC (Customer Acquisition Cost) was higher than it should be because consumer geographic demand had to match the small business supply geography, which often didn’t occur. In other words, newly registered users often couldn’t convert into a paying customer due to lack of local coverage. And finally, I thought they should factor in the cost of acquiring the other side of the market (their small businesses) into the equation because it was very costly, and the volume per business location was too small to justify the volume they generated on the consumer side.</p><p>I recommended a strategy of focusing intensely on each geographic area to create a sustainable cycle instead of trying to scale more broadly. At first, the team pushed back. But as they looked further into it, they saw the risk of premature scaling. They paused a planned funding round, and refocused on achieving sustainable metrics. Within a year, the business was humming and they later sold to an acquirer. But things could have gone a very different direction had they attempted to scale before resolving the core unit economic elements of the business.</p><h4>Scale can sneak up on you, too</h4><p>This next example shows the other side of the scaling dilemma. This founding team was purchasing goods at Costco for resale to their corporate customers. It was intended to be temporary: an expedient way to learn what worked without too much up front cost and complexity. Their instincts were right, but they hadn’t done the math or thought through the implications of switching their process too late. We pointed out to them that:</p><ul><li>Their volume was low, but growth seemed to be reaching an inflection point</li><li>The time and energy to set up wholesale sources would be very painful if the transition occurred when they were already at scale</li><li>The payment timing for Costco (immediate, or at least 30 days on a credit card) was generally worse than they could get working with a wholesale provider</li><li>Costco shopping wouldn’t scale (nor would their credit card)</li><li>Costco prices at scale would significantly impair their working capital cycle</li><li>The limited choices at Costco constrained their ability to effectively test demand</li></ul><p>Thankfully, the team listened to us and acted quickly. Within a few weeks we had them set up with wholesale vendors who extended them credit based on our relationships with them. It was disruptive, but manageable at their then current scale. The result was a significant improvement in margins and cash flow cycles, as well as further increases in growth because the founders could spend more time selling — and less shopping. If they hadn’t made this change, they would have quickly run into a wall where their working capital was insufficient to support continued growth, but it would have happened without enough warning for them to raise the capital needed to support continued operations. Thankfully they avoided that existential threat, and continued on to grow 11x in topline revenue over the next 12 months. Cash flow was really tight, but they made it happen.</p><h3>Helpful mentors dramatically increase fundraising success</h3><p>Examples like the above are probably why startups with helpful advisors raise so much more money than ones that don’t. The Startup Genome Report shows that average funding raised by stage was dramatically higher for startups with helpful advisors.</p><figure><a href="https://digintent.com/advisory-boards/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*N4ozegEVBuTYJu0W.png" /></a></figure><p>Funding raised is a reasonable proxy for startup success and progress. The findings from the Startup Genome Report imply that beyond validation stage in particular, startup advisors add tremendous value. In fact, it appears that startups that “don’t have helpful mentors” don’t raise any money at scaling stage — another way of saying that most never get there.</p><h3>It’s all about REAL advisors</h3><p>Unfortunately, many founders seem to think of advisors as more of a checklist or branding exercise than a real resource. We regularly see advisors listed in pitch decks only to find later that the advisors have virtually no interaction with the team.</p><p>Starting up is hard, lonely, and often frustrating. It often feels like the world just doesn’t understand the potential for what you’re working on. That’s probably why so many founders treat advisors as a sort of endorsement or validation, particularly early on. “Take me seriously, look at my advisors!” or “You know I’ll be successful with advisors like this!”</p><p>The problem is that advisors do no good unless they’re actively engaged. What sort of an endorsement is it to have a headshot in a pitch deck but the advisor isn’t willing to take the time to actually help? And what good will an amazing advisor do by merely appearing in a pitch deck and taking a call or two?</p><p>That’s why having inactive advisors in a pitch deck is a form of vanity that at best offers no real benefit, and at worst reflects very poorly on founders. Venture capitalists are very likely to check in with your advisors — we certainly do — and it’s quite awkward for entrepreneurs when we find that the advisor almost never speaks to the team. We occasionally find that the advisors don’t even recall the company or the team and is confused as to why we’re asking about them. That’s a sure-fire way to eliminate your fundraising prospects with that VC.</p><p>The lesson here is simple: have (and list) only real, engaged advisors.</p><h3>What to look for in advisors</h3><p>Founders too often look for obvious or flashy advisors rather than focusing on finding the ones who will add the most value to the business. Another common mistake is settling for the most readily accessible people instead of taking the time to identify and cultivate relationships with the most valuable advisors.</p><p>As we said previously, flashy but uninvolved advisors aren’t helpful. Poorly suited advisors can be even worse. That’s why I recommend a thoughtful and planned approach to identifying and recruiting advisors. I recommend looking for advisors who:</p><ul><li>At least understand the realities of running a startup (some should be seasoned startup executives)</li><li>Have a deep understanding of the domains that touch upon your business (e.g., technology, industry)</li><li>See the world differently from you and from each other</li><li>Know people, particularly people you don’t know who might be useful</li><li>Aren’t afraid to challenge you and ask tough questions</li><li>Have the time to focus and actually help</li><li>Share your passion and are inspired by your vision</li></ul><p>And don’t forget about actively incorporating diverse perspectives. It can be incredibly eye-opening (and value creating) to witness a very different perspective being laid out before you.</p><p>Some checkboxes you should probably be able to check in terms of advisors:</p><ul><li>Someone who has successfully built a company with a similar business model and customer (e.g., enterprise SaaS)</li><li>A veteran of your target industry who knows the prevailing attitudes and many key players personally</li><li>A customer meta-expert: someone who really understands how your target customer thinks, feels, and behaves, and preferably is also one of them</li><li>A serial entrepreneur who knows the ins and outs of building startup teams, operations, and cultures</li><li>A technology or product expert, preferably with experience building teams</li></ul><h3>Forming your advisory team</h3><p>Attracting advisors is similar to seeking funding; you have to inspire them with excitement about the vision for what you’re doing. Transactional advisor relationships are unlikely to work well. After all, startups are highly risky and unpredictable. Convincing an uninspired advisor to help — and potentially expose her brand and network to risk — via transaction is unlikely to happen. Vision is a critical component of a successful entrepreneurial venture. You’ll definitely have to bring it out to attract quality advisors.</p><p>It also often takes personal interactions over an extended period of time to instill a sense of excitement in potential advisors and to identify the ones who can actually help you. That’s why I recommend building your advisory team gradually over time. Building gradually helps avoid bringing on poorly fitting advisors, and enables you to avoid the clutter imposed by unnecessary advisor interactions. Time is precious, and you certainly want to avoid too much management overhead in the formation and maintenance of your advisory team.</p><h4>Evolution of your advisory team</h4><p>I tend to think of advisors existing at three distinct levels:</p><ol><li>Advisory network</li><li>Advisors</li><li>Advisory board</li></ol><p>I also tend to think about forming your advisory team in the context of slowly building from level 1 to level 3 above.</p><figure><a href="https://digintent.com/advisory-boards/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0B3zXmRTlu0M8pvd.png" /></a></figure><h4>Advisory Network</h4><p>Your advisory network comes first. It’s a relatively broad set of people who have an expressed or at least implied willingness to offer advice and assistance to you. How do you find these people? I recommend constantly asking people for advice. Invite the smart ones to your advisory group.</p><p>Probably the best way to interact with this network is via regular (quarterly) emails supplemented with targeted asks depending on needs and advisor capabilities. The regular emails should keep the advisors abreast of what’s going on to keep them engaged and reduce friction when you do get around to making asks of them. These regular communications can also incorporate your most important general asks. On top of the regular emails you can reach out directly to appropriate members of the advisory network as needed.</p><p>As I mention later in this article, your advisor network members shouldn’t be compensated, and shouldn’t be asked to sign advisory agreements or NDAs. It’s just not worth the cost and complexity for you or for them. If there’s something you’re worried about sharing with them (you probably shouldn’t be), then be careful sharing it or tone down the details.</p><p>Your advisory network is most likely to offer fairly passive and infrequent contributions such as pointing out interesting companies, a few introductions, and general ideas and feedback. When members of the network come to you with more specific contributions, consider moving them to an advisor role.</p><p>One minor risk that’s worth pointing out is that if you have an advisor who engages too deeply, and starts to feel that she has made meaningful intellectual property contributions to the company, you could find yourself in a legal dispute about IP absent an advisory agreement. That’s one more reason to consider pushing someone to advisor status if they’re becoming more active in helping you.</p><h4>Advisors</h4><p>Your advisors should form naturally from your advisory network. These will be the people who provide the most value to you, both because their capabilities match your needs and because they reliably offer assistance — and come through with it.</p><p>Advisors may or may not be compensated, as mentioned later in this article. In many — in my experience most — cases advisors are doing it because they like to help, not in the hopes of compensation. But in the end, I recommend compensating your advisors for reasons discussed in later.</p><p>As you get to know your advisors you will start to identify a few who can stand out for their advice and assistance. It tends to happen naturally due to the nature and direction of your business. That’s when you might consider adding an advisor to your advisory board.</p><h4>Advisory Board</h4><p>Your advisory board should be formed of key advisors who agree to engage on a regular cadence for a specified tenure. This board should have a regular call and meeting schedule — perhaps monthly calls with once quarterly in-person meetings. The board should be small enough to be nimble, but large enough to offer the key expertise and experience that you need during any given time period. That usually means between 2–4 people.</p><p>The tenure of members of your advisory board should map to likely evolutions in the needs of your business. I strongly advise an explicit tenure (e.g., not open ended) for several reasons:</p><ul><li>Your needs for advice and assistance are likely to evolve over time</li><li>It sets expectations in advance, and makes it much easier to transition people off as needed without offending them</li><li>It constrains their commitment, making it more likely for busy people to accept the role</li></ul><p>Terms should probably be for one to two years. If you have a near-term need that’s unlikely to persist, one year might work. Otherwise, two years probably makes more sense because things always seem to take longer than you think, but two years probably offers enough time to get a lot of value out of an advisor.</p><h3>Advisor Compensation</h3><p>As I mentioned previously, you should generally expect to compensate your advisors with some equity. I do not advise offering equity to your advisory network; presumably they will accept this light level of engagement without an expectation of compensation. It would also be hard to justify the cost in both equity and time (and legal costs) of offering equity to a fairly broad set of people in an advisory network.</p><p>Your advisors, and certainly your advisory board, however, will probably expect some equity. And even if they don’t, there are good reasons you may want to give it to them. Offering equity allows you to require an advisory agreement, which can clarify expectations and offer important intellectual property protections for the company. If you have an advisor who’s clearly adding value and appears to be a level-headed, reasonable person, you probably don’t have to worry about getting her under contract. But less sophisticated or rational people should probably be under contract — or maybe shouldn’t be advising you at all.</p><h4>How much equity do advisors get?</h4><p>Advisor equity commonly ranges between 0.10% and 0.25% for a (typical) two-year engagement. In unusual circumstances it can be much higher: 1% or more. Generally I think it’s a bad sign if an advisor expects too much equity. It implies she doesn’t assign too much value to the company, and likely means she isn’t particularly passionate about your vision.</p><p>The amount of equity that’s appropriate depends on several factors:</p><ul><li>Stage / value of the company</li><li>Level of effort</li><li>Expected contribution of the advisor</li></ul><p>On the other side of the coin, this isn’t a time to be an equity skinflint. I’ve already pointed out how much value an advisor can generate. So instead of thinking about how much equity you’re giving away, I’d recommend thinking about how much net value their participation will add to your company. If you give away $25,000 worth of equity, but see a $100k increase in enterprise value, you’ve made a good deal for everyone involved.</p><p>Another way to think about it is that startups are extraordinarily unlikely to achieve a meaningful liquidity event. But when they do have meaningful exits, they’re often really (really) meaningful. As such, I advise optimizing more for the likelihood of a positive outcome rather than the amount of it you own at the time. One-hundred percent of nothing is — wait for it… nothing.</p><p>To put things in context, for a startup with a post-money valuation of $10 million, a 0.10% award is nominally worth $10,000. If an advisor allocates three hours a month on average over the course of two years, that’s $138.89 per hour — theoretically. For one thing, value is in the eye of the beholder and many startups are overvalued and advisors know it. For another thing, advisors are typically awarded common equity, which is worth less than preferred equity, so it’s not as simple as multiplying equity percentage by post-money valuation to get the equivalent value.</p><h4>Advisor equity structure and vesting</h4><p>In my opinion, advisor equity should be in the form of common stock options. There’s no reason to add complexity to your cap table and voting structure by offering preferred equity to advisors. And as long as the option strike prices are properly set (e.g., at a reasonable fair market value at the time of award), advisors can expect to defer any tax payments until the time of liquidity. As always, consult your tax and accounting professionals and pay attention to regulatory elements such as 83b elections.</p><p>All advisor equity should vest. The timeframe should map to the expected time horizon for value creation, which is typically one to two years. I recommend a three month cliff because there’s always a risk that an advisor won’t work out. And if that happens it’s likely to be obvious fairly quickly. A cliff enables you to end the relationship with the advisor with the three month window without losing any equity, and without having to deal with a hard to explain entry on the cap table.</p><p>Advisor equity should feature 100% acceleration on single trigger. In other words, if you sell the company before they’re fully vested, they should get everything they would have gotten over the entire vesting period upon sale. After all, they probably did their job, and there shouldn’t be an expectation for them to hang around to advise the new owners.</p><h3>Advisor contracts</h3><p>You need an advisory agreement for any advisor who will receive equity. There are many reasons to put it in a legal document:</p><ul><li>Putting expectations in writing ensures clarity and a “meeting of the minds” about the nature and level of contributions that can be expected</li><li>A contract makes it harder for them to skimp on their duties</li><li>It shows that both parties are serious and actually committed</li><li>Establish clearly that the advisor is not conflicted, and that she will inform you if she becomes conflicted</li><li>A properly constructed agreement protects intellectual property that you may expose from them, or even receive from them (e.g., patentable ideas that by law can lose protection in the absence of NDAs)</li><li>It provides an opportunity to vest advisor equity over time, which is an important tool for recapturing equity that wasn’t really earned</li></ul><p>Some advisors will agree to an NDA, IP assignment, and even non-competition without complaint. Sophisticated ones will almost always balk at some or all of those provisions. Venture capitalists, for example, generally won’t sign any of these sorts of provisions. We see so many deals and so many ideas that it’s far too risky to expose ourselves to claims of infringement. Corporate executives are likely to balk as well, for similar reasons. If you do end up at an impasse about any provisions like these, I would recommend dramatically narrowing the scope of your requested protections. The risk that any of your advisors will take advantage of you is vanishingly small. And it’s nothing compared to the value they might create for you. If you construct appropriately narrow provisions, then you can probably protect yourself against the actual bad actors without capturing the 99.99% of good actors in your net.</p><p>It’s generally a good idea to seek legal counsel when constructing important agreements. A good lawyer, for example, can play a critical role in negotiating an appropriately narrow agreement for an advisor who is concerned about your standard provisions.</p><p>Alternately, there are standard forms that might work if you’re really tight on capital. Here are two good ones worth considering:</p><ul><li>Founder Institute’s <a href="https://fi.co/fast">standard advisor form</a></li><li>Upcounsel’s <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WUz_j4UjYIln_kThHHYANYXm8RwtpyVU3Qgn_umcKPY/edit">standard advisor form</a></li></ul><h3>Maximizing advisor contributions</h3><p>It’s not enough to just find and recruit advisors. You have to take the initiative necessary to maximize the value of their contributions. For the most part your advisors will be very busy, and it will be up to you to ensure that you pull the most value from them.</p><p>Just as importantly, you ought to minimize the management overhead associated with your advisory team. Startups feature a crushing enough workload as it is.</p><p>I’ve seen advice to focus on transactional engagements with advisors to minimize overhead. I think that’s a poor idea. Instead, a regular and thoughtfully managed advisor system can ensure that your advisors remain informed about what’s going on with your business and the industry so you don’t have waste cycles on reeducating them every time you interact with them.</p><p>And a properly managed advisory board can offer a very strong incentive for busy advisors to brush up on things and bring their A-game to advisory board meetings; the last thing they want to do is look like an idiot in front of their advisor peers. And it forces you to think through your needs and goals in advance, which is likely to lead to a more efficient and productive meeting.</p><p>Advisors also tend to have strong opinions and inherent curiosity. And for many (most?) advisors, their role helping you is a rare chance to indulge in things that interest them rather than having to be disciplined about their own affairs. As a result, it’s not unusual for them to barge into areas of the business where they’re uninvited and maybe even unhelpful. At least there is a risk they won’t focus on the areas where you need them most.</p><p>That’s why I recommend some best practices for working with advisors:</p><h4>Structured interactions</h4><p>It’s best to set a regular cadence for core interactions with advisors. For example, I recommend monthly calls and quarterly in-person meetings with your advisory board. This ensures that they can plan ahead to be available, and makes it easier for them to maintain an awareness about what’s going on. If you let things stretch too long between engagements, they’re likely to forget context, requiring inefficient catch-up cycles and increased confusion. That’s not to say that you shouldn’t reach out to advisors on an as-needed basis as well. It’s just that your ad hoc requests should be on top of regularly established interactions.</p><h4>Share information in advance</h4><p>You should prepare advisor briefs in advance of advisory board meetings — something like a board deck. You should also try to do brief write-ups before every meeting or call with an advisor to give them context. This ensures that you can spend your time creating value rather than catching up. Experienced business people are accustomed to walking into meetings well-informed.</p><h4>Focus on specific issues / asks</h4><p>Most advisors help companies at least in part because they enjoy it. And because they’re not involved in the daily activities of the business, they are often curious about how things work, and may have ideas about directions the business could go. I would recommend listening to whatever it is they want to talk about, but balance that with the need to keep them focused on the task at hand. That’s why your write-ups and initial framing of conversations should be very specific. I recommend listing the specific area(s) where you’d like their help, and where possible describe the options you’re considering. Once you’ve framed the issue(s), you’re much more likely to cover the things that matter most to you.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Advisors can be a critical resource for startup teams. Yet many founders make strategic errors in assembling and managing their advisor group. Don’t assemble a fake or perfunctory advisor team. My advice is to treat it as an important initiative that will require time and energy to achieve full potential.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/advisory-boards/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on February 14, 2019.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d34eccfee54" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/how-to-form-and-manage-a-high-functioning-advisory-board-7d34eccfee54">How to Form and Manage a High Functioning Advisory Board</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[5 digital transformation risks to avoid]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@digintent/5-digital-transformation-risks-to-avoid-865fb05d304a?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/865fb05d304a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-transformation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Feb 2019 19:26:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-13T21:49:27.833Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The five most common digital transformation risks we consistently see, and how to avoid them.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*v4b6m7_qNCCxFbM-CpcOQA.png" /></figure><p>Embarking on a digital transformation effort is full of potential risks. According to McKinsey, <a href="https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/retail/our-insights/the-how-of-transformation">70% of digital transformation efforts fail</a>.</p><p>And while there are dozens of reasons your transformation initiative might run into trouble, there are a couple of consistent traps we’ve encountered. As with most situations there’s usually some pareto optimization opportunity. We believe avoiding the following 5 issues will address a big chunk of your risk as you start a digital transformation project inside your organization.</p><h3>Faulty digital transformation premises</h3><p>If you’ve seen the movie The Big Short you’ll recognize the following quote: “It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you in trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so.”</p><p>It’s a wonderful encapsulation of what led to the irrational exuberance leading to the 2008 financial crisis. It also illustrates something we see in large companies engaged in digital transformation.</p><p>For example, many large companies are in the throws of an end-to-end ERP upgrade to the cloud, or are planning to get started. The premise is that an ERP upgrade gets you the business results that increase profitability and improve operations.</p><p>But this is simply not true. We’ve consistently seen evidence of this. Big company implements large ERP provider. 36 months later they have difficulty identifying where the value is.</p><p>This isn’t because implementing a cloud based ERP is a bad idea. It’s a great one. But typically this gives you the <em>capability</em> to do new things with your data that can create opportunities for profitability and operational improvements. It doesn’t accomplish it by itself.</p><h3>Driving innovation without a production deployment skill set</h3><p>Many companies now have Chief Digital Officers in place. Some have innovation teams, perhaps even an innovation fund. Even organizations lacking a formal innovation governance model have begun holding <a href="http://digintent.com/after-the-design-sprint/">design sprints</a>, hackathons and other innovation-focused activities.</p><p>These are great things to have. But often what’s missing is the skill set necessary for bringing the ideas that are surfaced into full scale operations.</p><p>Unless you’re a team that’s experienced at bringing a wide variety of emerging technology to market from concept to successful user adoption, your teams will struggle. Many large companies have learned this lesson the hard way.</p><p>Many of these initiatives are expected to be implemented by the existing IT and development infrastructure. But the workflow for these types of engagements is <a href="http://digintent.com/bimodal-it-strategy/">typically much different</a>.</p><p>With innovation projects, you’re ideally engaging in <a href="http://digintent.com/product-iteration/">rapid, iterative testing</a>. You’re delivering incremental value in the form of minimum viable products, testing or piloting them with internal or external stakeholders, and rapidly improving them as you deploy to progressively larger sets of users.</p><p>There’s also often the issue of technology stacks. While the end product will need to integrate with internal systems, you’re often better served early by using technology stacks that favor speed and ease of deployment over enterprise systems.</p><p>Even organizations like SAP have realized this, providing the ability to “bring your own language” (BYOL) into build packs that work seamlessly with the larger enterprise architecture.</p><p>But adopting those languages and knowing how to leverage them is often met with (understandable) internal resistance. And so teams attempt to execute on lean startup principles with legacy or enterprise tools that make such speed and agility difficult.</p><h3>Going it alone.</h3><p>“Data is a team sport”.</p><p>“There’s no I in team”.</p><p>“If you want to go fast go alone. If you want to go far, go together”.</p><p>All of these maxims get at the same idea. If you’re going to innovate, do it as a team.</p><p>This doesn’t necessarily mean mean staff up and build internal skill sets, although in many cases that might make sense. But in many cases, it pays tremendous dividends to bring in outside team members to either execute or provide perspective.</p><p>Teams with start up experience know the fastest path to market is often cobbling together existing third party solutions. They focus on staying close the user, delivering value, and accept that code or platform debt is part of the trade. They fully expect to replace and refactor work later. That’s a perspective internal teams often lack.</p><p>Likewise, people with startup backgrounds (and to a lesser degree agencies) often have pattern recognition that internal teams are missing. Part of why DI is able to provide value at a <a href="http://digintent.com/workshops/product-strategy/">product strategy</a> level is our experience building startups ourselves. That perspective is incredibly helpful when trying to make product decisions like:</p><ul><li>What data represents leading indicators for success or risk.</li><li>How to design for internal power users and novice external users simultaneously.</li><li>How to overcome chicken and egg problems when dealing with marketplace businesses.</li><li>The critical importance of first time UX and <a href="http://digintent.com/how-to-minimize-product-friction/">how to optimize for adoption</a>.</li><li>The techniques that can drive referral and increase incremental revenue.</li><li>How to architect products that have self-priming growth loops.</li><li>The potential pitfalls with <a href="http://digintent.com/bots/">conversational interfaces</a> or <a href="http://digintent.com/voice-interfaces/">voice enabled devices</a>.</li></ul><p>Even if your internal team does the heavy lifting, bringing in an external team to provide guidance and feedback can be incredibly helpful.</p><p>A common approach we have leveraged is to co-create solutions, in the beginning leaning heavily on the external team for execution while the internal team learns the ropes, and over time transitioning more responsibility to the internal team as they develop the necessary skills and perspectives.</p><h3>Not having mentors.</h3><p>Along the same lines, a common gap is the higher level strategic perspective. While internal teams have deep domain expertise, they also often suffer from being too close to the problem, or lack the pattern recognition that comes from seeing a variety of different industries and organizations.</p><p>Again startups provide a great model. Most venture backed startups have a board of directors, as well as third party advisors. These are indispensable resources who can identify and help avoid potential obstacles, bring novel solutions from other industries, and make business-transforming introductions. They also can provide coaching to navigate the slog of iteration.</p><p>Creating a similar board of advisors, either at an individual initiative level or at the portfolio level, can often mean the difference between success and failure.</p><h3>Not proving the value.</h3><p>According to <a href="https://hbr.org/2018/03/why-so-many-high-profile-digital-transformations-fail">Harvard Business Review</a>, a common pitfall is lacking a clear hypothesis around value creation.</p><p>This mistake often leads to funding projects that were executed on well but still had no value associated with the win. Allocating resources, driving team energy and engagement, and crossing the finish line without tangible value creation to point to can often be the kiss of death for innovation teams and the leaders within them.</p><p>Successful innovation initiatives often take time. And there’s a definite need for patience and sufficient air cover at the executive level to give fledgling ideas room to iterate and find value. But that doesn’t mean you need to start an engagement with no clue how you’ll extract value out of the other end if successful.</p><p>Modeling out potential options for growth and value creation, understanding the potential addressable market, having a hypothesis for “exit” (even if that exit is simply bringing the initiative in-house) are all great strategies to leverage to de-risk this pitfall and ensure that successful initiatives represent legitimate wins for the organization.</p><h3>Create plans to mitigate these digital transformation risks</h3><p>As you put your digital transformation agenda in place, it can be helpful to outline all of the potential risks you can see and develop mitigation strategies for each. Conduct a “pre-mortem” — try to anticipate what could go wrong, and make sure you have the right systems, processes, and partners in place to execute on your digital transformation initiatives brilliantly.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/digital-transformation-risks/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on February 4, 2019.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=865fb05d304a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scaling SpotHero and the Future of Mobility]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/scaling-spothero-and-the-future-of-mobility-24d481763fff?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24d481763fff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mobility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disrupter-interview]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Dec 2018 17:04:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-29T12:31:00.766Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Future of Mobility [Disrupter Interview]</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c1G_CP660JhR0cmpYB6hEQ.png" /></figure><p>How do you scale something 10x and then scale it again? The answer is surprisingly simple, and yet very few organizations have the discipline to do it. My guest today is <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/elanmosbacher">Elan Mosbacher</a>, Senior Vice President of Strategy and Operations at <a href="http://spothero.com/">Spothero</a>. In this conversation we talk about how Elan and his team made went about growing SpotHero to the largest mobile parking platform in the country.</p><p>Elan has a ton of experience around building marketplace businesses, pursuing strategic partnerships and more. He’s also very thoughtful about the future of mobility in general, and we get into a pretty fascinating conversation around autonomous vehicles and where things are headed.</p><figure><a href="https://apple.co/2QrtJoJ"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9b3x7apgBx3k7qVqtndm6Q.png" /></a></figure><h3>How to scale quickly</h3><p><strong>DI: I know when you first joined Spothero, you were primarily in a marketing capacity and your explicit mandate was to help them 10x. And then to do it again. And I remember you talking about how the things you did to 10x the first time were very different than the second. What were some of the lessons you learned trying to scale something that quickly?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan:</strong> Early on, the most important thing was to figure out who our best customer was. There have been probably 200 different companies in our space, and I think the thing that really set us apart was our understanding of our customer. We figured that out and aligned ALL of our initiatives around acquiring that best customer and making the experience as good as possible for them.</p><blockquote><em>“The thing that really set us apart was our understanding of our customer. We figured that out and aligned ALL of our initiatives around acquiring that best customer and making the experience as good as possible for them.”</em></blockquote><p>Fast forward several years later, we see our best customers are still buying from us. And that’s what made us really big relative to our competitors who didn’t focus on the best customer. Today they might be acquiring roughly the same number of customers every month, but don’t have, three, four, five, six, seven years of people who joined their app, who are still buying.</p><p>Another big lesson is just about <strong>scaling yourself</strong> and scaling your team. As a leader of a start-up, you have to scale yourself as fast, if not faster, than your company. It’s hard to do that when all you’re doing is working on your company, you also have to work on yourself.</p><blockquote><em>“As a leader of a start-up, you have to scale yourself as fast, if not faster, than your company.”</em></blockquote><p>For some people that might be a part-time MBA, for others an executive coach, or reading, or podcasts, or mentors, or board members. But it’s really important to invest in yourself to make sure you’re at least one step ahead of where your company needs to be.</p><h3>How to Scale Yourself</h3><p><strong>DI: What did that look like for you? What were the areas you identifying as needing growth in and how did you go about doing it?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>I think I probably used all of the above. I started an MBA part-time just before joining SpotHero, so I focused a lot of that time on how do I apply it to the job. Everything from, how do we figure out who our best customers are, to how to lay out a business plan to, how to manage our team, how to recruit and hire.</p><p>I also read a lot. I have a busy life so I’ll go a month or two without reading, but then I’ll read four or five books in a weekend.</p><p>SpotHero also had the very good fortune of assembling a pretty remarkable board. So having an opportunity to learn from board members, and during board meetings, and from other mentors has been really instrumental.</p><p>You have to find what works for you. You have to find a way to learn, outside of just doing your day-to-day job.</p><h3>How to figure out who your best customers are</h3><p><strong>DI: Going back to the finding your best customers — it seems like that’s a pretty common problem for start-ups. They take in some money, they have this mandate to grow really quickly, they end up putting a lot of that money into paid acquisition, and either it takes them a little while to figure out those users aren’t sticking around, or they’re not measuring the right things. They’re mistaking top-line growth for product/market fit. How did you avoid that and figure out who those best customers were?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>By the time we turned into SpotHero, we had a product that people used to find parking. We had decent product/market fit, but I asked Mark, our CEO, who is our best customer? I actually asked everyone on the team, who do you think our best customer is? No one really had a good answer.</p><p>So we started looking at who bought the most times, actually interviewing them. From there we sent out a survey, did some statistical analysis. We found there’s a certain segment of customers who use us for a specific reason, and were like <strong><em>13x more profitable</em></strong> than anyone else. In fact they were the only profitable segment at the time.</p><p>From there we focused on building out our parking inventory around the needs of that customer. We focused on channels to reach that best customer. Our sales and customer service focused around the best customer. With all that focus, we didn’t necessarily acquire the most customers, but we acquired better more profitable ones who are still with us all these years later.</p><p>Along the way we acquired one of our competitors who was not part of our SpotHero family but had a very different approach. It was interesting for us to look at how do we do things and how do they do things, and the differences. One thing was we had enough capital to focus on maybe more expensive channels where our best customers could be found. They were more capital constrained, so their approach was to find customers who were profitable on the first transaction. And when we looked into it, they did a really good job of building out inventory, and aligning their company around that customer.</p><p>So there are multiple ways to attack things. But whatever approach you choose you need to align all your efforts toward that customer archetype. I will say though that I think our focus on that profitable customer, even though they were more expensive to acquire, allowed us to become much bigger than them over time because of the repeat business. And now we have the best of both worlds because we have the customers who are really sticky, but we also have this great channel with customers who maybe only buy once, but they’re profitable on the first transaction.</p><p><strong>DI: Are you targeting those people in different ways with different messages? Or are you using the same messaging and you just realize that some of those people are going to look like this, and some of these people are going to look like this?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>So the tricky thing there is the highest volume bottom of the funnel channels most start-ups use, like search, actually acquire the worst customers. And the trickiest channels, the most expensive channels, the riskiest channels, are the ones that are probably the best customers.</p><blockquote><em>“The highest volume, bottom of the funnel channels most start-ups use, like search, actually acquire the worst customers. And the trickiest channels, the most expensive channels, the riskiest channels, are the ones that are probably the best customers.”</em></blockquote><p>So that was a challenge for us. But by having that insight into our best customer, we had the conviction to spend on offline, and on other more expensive, harder to measure channels early on. We still do a ton of SEO, paid search, those types of things. But those customers for our business don’t repeat as often.</p><h3>Selling big strategic changes to your board</h3><p><strong>DI: That sounds like a big turning point for the company. When you’re bringing that to your board, I would imagine things like your total addressable market (TAM) look smaller. It might impact the projections that were made earlier on. That pitch of “we think our most profitable customers are this sliver of the market, and acquiring them is going to be a lot more expensive.” Aside from having great board members, are there strategies you used to paint that story in a compelling way?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>I think there’s been two periods of time where we went through that. One was on the advertising side — how do we invest in these more expensive channels?</p><p>The other was on the product side. We actually developed a product called SpotHero for Business, which honed in on a customized version of our product for a really strong audience and very strong customer segment. In both those cases we had that conversation.</p><p>On the advertising side it was pretty simple. A simple formula of, stacked rank, ROI by channel is really helpful. Basically what’s the lifetime value, what’s the customer acquisition cost, what’s the payback by channel? Where are we going to get the most efficiency? Where is the LTD impact ratio best? Where are we going to get the most volume? If we realize that the highest LTD customers are going to come from slightly more expensive channels, that’s fine as long as the ROI is there. There are some pretty proven frameworks to at least have that discussion.</p><p>The other piece we did is have a set amount of our budget, say 80%, allocated to proven channels. And then 10% to 20% was to try new things. Some of those would be expensive, and some of those would not be that measurable, and some of those would be kind of crazy. We didn’t really count that money against ourselves, because we knew at any moment we could shut that off if it wasn’t working.</p><p>On the product side when we said, we want to make a major investment to improve the product for our best customer, the feedback from the board was, “Why didn’t you do this six months ago?” So that was a pretty easy sell as well.</p><p>I think the main lesson there, in terms of incubating a start-up within a start-up was <strong><em>having a separate P&amp;L</em></strong>. Operating as two different entities.</p><p>If you are always looking at the trade-off between a really big thing and a small thing, the ROI on the big thing in the short term is always going to be better than the ROI on the small thing or the new thing in the short run. So bifurcating those two projects was definitely a big thing that we’ve done to help us set ourselves up for success when trying new things.</p><p><strong>DI: You’ve talked about the need to avoid copying what other people do. In the marketing or “growth hacking” community, there’s a ton of content around tactics, lots of “Uber did this one trick, so you should too.” And I know you feel like that’s probably a misguided approach.</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>I would say start with the why. It’s perfectly acceptable and expected to learn from others. To look at who’s done it before and figure out what they done that could work for us. The mistake is copying tactics without thinking about the strategy behind it.</p><p>We often look at analogs of companies in mobility or that are further along in their journey, looking at tactics to evaluate if they fit within our strategy. And that’s okay. But I’ve seen companies that just copy the competitor. If you’re not in a leadership position and you’re trying to catch up by copying what the leader does, it isn’t going to help you very much.</p><blockquote><em>“If you’re not in a leadership position and you’re trying to catch up by copying what the leader does, it isn’t going to help you very much.”</em></blockquote><p>We target drivers. At one point we hired some folks to stand at the exit to one of the highways in Chicago with a big sign saying “Use SpotHero” with a promo code. A few days later someone doing marketing a totally different vertical told me their CEO saw it and was wondering why we don’t do sign flippers too. Well, we’re targeting drivers a few minutes away from parking and we want to remind them. This is a great tactic given our audience and our strategy, but that’s not your target audience. Why would you copy that?</p><p>One other example. In 2015 or 2016, there were all these on demand apps for everything. There was on-demand valets, on-demand food. All these apps popping up. And they were spending a ridiculous amount of money on Facebook app installs. The cost of app installs is crazy now. But we had all sorts of people saying we should do it too. But we kept trying it, and it kept not working, and at a certain point we just stopped. It’s just not the right channel for us.</p><p>So understanding what you’re trying to achieve and aligning the tactics to what you’re trying to do is important.</p><h3>Channel mix when trying to 10x</h3><p><strong>DI: When you do have a mandate to scale aggressively, it does seem like one of the perceived advantages of Facebook, Google, etc. is speed to scale. You can scale quite a bit before saturating that channel. So with some of these other channels like outdoor, that seems a lot harder. How does that fit into the mandate to 10x something — are those channels able to get you all the way there, or do you still have to supplement with some of the more common channels, to make up the deficit?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan:</strong> I think it depends on what kind of business you run. There are really successful businesses that spend almost nothing on marketing, growing through the product and word-of-mouth. There are other businesses that rely entirely on one channel, so it depends.</p><p>Back when we were in a crazy growth phase, we were trying to decide whether we should spend or not on a channel. And that that point, the decision was if we don’t spend we lose, if we do spend, we might lose. So we spent.</p><p>In terms of channel, it really depends on your business. In most businesses, certainly marketplace businesses, there’s usually one or two primary channels. Often that’s Google or Facebook, which is why they’re so valuable as companies. But other companies have different channels.</p><p>There are things you can do inside of the product as well, refer-a-friend or conversion rate optimization or whatever. But there’s rarely one silver-bullet. Usually it’s one, or two, or three primary channels, and then a whole bunch of other tests and optimizations. Things that work for a day, a week, a month, a year, and then kind of go away.</p><p>Our business is a little different because we’re a marketplace business and we’re also based on geographies. Sometimes we’re advertising to customers, but it’s actually less focused on volume of consumers and the profitability of those consumers. Sometimes it’s actually about filling the merchant or the supply side of the business.</p><p>The more customers you get the more inventory you can get. If you’re starting a new vertical or geography, you want to acquire a bunch of customers and enough supply to keep them happy, even if it’s not super profitable. It’s similar to Uber — when they started a new city, they paid drivers a minimum amount until they got enough demand that they didn’t have to do that anymore.</p><h3>Strategies for scaling marketplace businesses</h3><p><strong>DI: Let’s talk a little bit about marketplaces. That’s a challenging model for a lot of people. What are some of the other lessons you’ve learned trying to build out two sides of the marketplace at the same time?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>Ten years ago there wasn’t a ton of information about this, and the chicken and egg problem was the big question. But these days it’s actually pretty well documented. One of our investors, Insight Venture Partners, has this document called the <a href="https://www.insightpartners.com/blog/insights-periodic-table-of-online-marketplaces/">Periodic Table of Marketplace Businesses</a> which talks about all the metrics you have to look with example benchmarks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1t_3egP0S-Vl1YHg.png" /></figure><p>One of the things that served us really well was focusing on liquidity over geography, meaning start with one geography or one vertical before you try to scale. I like to use Facebook as an analogy for this. Facebook started at Harvard, got saturation, then moved on to Ivy League schools, then east coast, then colleges, then high school, then adults, then businesses. Whereas some of their competitors were open to everyone from day one.</p><blockquote><em>“Focus on liquidity over geography. Start with one geography or one vertical before you try to scale.”</em></blockquote><p>We were only in Chicago for several years, and in fact our business was bigger in Chicago than any competitor who was national. We only really expanded beyond Chicago once we got the playbook down, and as a result we were able to move much, much, much faster when we launched in new markets.</p><p>It’s very easy to spread yourself too thin if you try to go too broad in the beginning, so that’s probably the biggest lesson learned.</p><p>In terms of chicken or egg, in most businesses you want to focus on the supply side. The merchant is the one who is more patient because a merchant. They realize it might take a while to get a ton of value out of your platform while you build up demand. But consumers will go to your site once and you don’t have what they want, they’re going to leave pretty quickly.</p><h3>Partnerships</h3><p><strong>DI: One of the channels that is a little less commonly talked about is partnerships. I know you’ve been pretty aggressive about pursuing those. How do you think through which types of partnerships make sense? There’s opportunity cost in getting those things set up. What decision making criteria do you use to evaluate what makes a good partnership versus a bad partnership?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>In the last decade or so of doing this I’ve often started as the first marketer in various start-ups. Inevitably after two or three years, you get to this point where you’re like okay, I’ve got Facebook, I’ve got Google. What’s next? And it always ends up being partnerships.</p><p>I mentioned earlier the importance of mentors and finding ways to learn outside of the day-to-day. An old mentor of mine who spent a lot of time doing business development recommended a book called <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Sumo-Advantage-Leveraging-Development-Heavyweights/dp/0986046000">The Sumo Advantage</a>. Really good book, and it basically outlines the business development process for start-ups.</p><p>There’s a few ways I think about this. The difference between sales and business development or partnerships is this: with sales, you generally go to someone and say, I’m going to do this, and you write me a check. With business development or partnerships it’s generally we’ll do this thing together to serve our mutual audience. So you have to think through who the customers are whose lives we’re both trying to improve with different solutions. Where’s the symbiosis?</p><p>Another thing to think about — when you’re really big everyone wants to do a deal with you. But when you’re small, how do you get attention? In a partnership, the smaller company is usually looking for customer acquisition and the bigger company is usually looking for a stickier product or more retention.</p><p>If I’m Salesforce, I’m looking for all the other software companies to plug into my marketplace, so that when people use Salesforce they also have all the other tools they need. If I’m really small business, I want Salesforce’s customers, so I plug into Salesforce in order to get a small fraction of the companies that use Salesforce to also use my product too.</p><p>When you’re a start-up, the approach I’ve found is to say “Hey BigCo, there’s a feature set missing in your product. I can make your product stickier, increase your LTV and differentiate you from your competitors.”</p><p>For SpotHero, we look at the segments or verticals of companies targeting similar audiences. Who has a big audience of drivers? Well, car companies and navigation and mobility type apps and eventually autonomous vehicles. Then we look at who the leaders are in that space. Then we work to figure out the mutual value prop for our customers. Then we pitch and see where things go.</p><p>Most recently we did a partnership with Waze in the City of Chicago. One of the challenges Waze had was their GPS works really well when there’s cell reception, but if you’re driving in a tunnel or an underground road, you don’t have cell reception, or GPS doesn’t work. The problem for us was there were drivers in Chicago who were trying to park in garages that were underground and it was really hard for our customers to find those garages.</p><p>So we partnered with Waze and introduced them to the City of Chicago. We installed Waze beacons in all the underground roads in Chicago. And now they have a better product for their audience, and our customers are able to find the garage they want to park at, and the City of Chicago has better traffic flows and all the benefits of having navigation work.</p><p>Another partnership was with Google Assistant. That was announced at CES, and Google announced that though Assistant and eventually Android Auto, you’d be able to buy coffee from Starbucks, or buy a parking spot with SpotHero. That’s another example of more of a product innovation.</p><p>We’ve done distribution deals where we partner with folks who plug into our API so they can offer parking to their audience, and we’ve done deals with smaller companies where we take their technology and plug into our app to it stickier and better for our audience. Those are all examples of partnerships and ways we’ve approached it recently.</p><h3>Mental Models</h3><p><strong>DI: Changing gears a little bit, you and I have talked several times in the past about this idea of mental models. You talked earlier about reading and ways that you’ve tried to level up yourself, and I know you’ve tried to cultivate a different way of thinking, or thinking about how you think. How have you gone about doing that?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>There are a lot of frameworks I like to use depending on the situation.</p><p>One of the questions that I like to ask myself is “What would Elan five years from now do in this situation?” That really forces you to step outside of short term thinking and I’ve found it helps me operate at my best.</p><p>A slight variation on that question when trying to evaluate two different things to do is “what will matter in five years?” Am I going to remember being at that event, meeting that person, closing that deal, or am I going to remember that I was Inbox Zero today? So that’s two variations of a question I use on a personal level.</p><p>In terms of team decisions, the framework we use there is to try to think in extremes. On one hand do we shut this project down? On the other hand, do we have every single person in the company focus on this project? On one hand, do we have no resources, on the other hand, do we hire the best person in the world to go do this? By pushing the boundaries initially, you tend to get comfortable with some kind of decision in the middle. So that’s often how I think about strategy and where we want to spend our time.</p><p>On a company level, one of my favorite frameworks is based on a book called <a href="https://predictablesuccess.com/">Predictable Success</a>. Once you’ve done this a few times, you start to see patterns and the evolution of a start-up, and you’re like oh, yeah, it’s always this way. Predictable Success is a framework that talks about that evolution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZfVwDnZclDyW8Bdl.png" /></figure><p>Imagine an arch, like a rainbow, and at the bottom there’s <strong>survival</strong>. Call it trying to get to product market fit. And many companies never make it past there.</p><p>If you do, phase 2 is called <strong>fun</strong>. When you’ve figured something out and you’ve got funding it’s fun. The founder has some money in the bank, they maybe get a salary, they’re in the press, their friends are like, oh, maybe you’re not as crazy as we thought. You hire a few people, you get an award, all that fun stuff that comes with getting funding or actually getting paid by a customer. You have a handful of people and everything is great.</p><p>But then as you work your way up the rainbow, at the top of the rainbow is this thing called <strong>predictable success</strong>. That’s where you set a goal and you hit it, and you set a goal, and you hit it, and you can think about some of the world-class companies today that are probably there.</p><p>There’s this middle stage between fun and predictable success called <strong>white water</strong>. Imagine you’re rafting and you hit these rapids where there’s bumps in the road and things get a little hard. And maybe in life maybe that’s your teenage years where you’re struggling with who you are and what the world looks like.</p><p>You start to get big enough where the people you had early on who worked hard and learned fast but maybe hadn’t done it before aren’t necessarily the right people anymore to lead a team. Sometimes they are, but often they aren’t.</p><p>Things start to break. The process that you built for communication when you had two people, or five people, or 10 people doesn’t work for when you have 100 people, or 200 people. The technology you built when you had a few customers doesn’t work anymore when you have millions of customers.</p><p>White water is really about getting the right people, processes, an technology in place so that you can get to predictable success and operate like a world-class business. The reason I like that framework so much is it provides context. It’s a really good tool for communicating to your team about why things feel like they do.</p><p>When you start to hit white water, it can be tough. Team members say things like “It’s not as fun as it used to be.” Or “I don’t get to spend as much time with the CEO anymore.” Or “Why’d you hire this experienced person to be my boss?” Those are all real pain points that can kind of kill a culture. But if you’re really transparent and communicate with your team about where you are on the journey, giving people context can help a ton.</p><p>The other thing it’s helpful for is communicating to new team members. You bring someone in and they look under the hood and ask why this process in place, why things are such a mess. And I can just say “If I had optimized my process for communicating with 200 people when we were two people, I would have never earned the right to be here. I would have never gotten through survival and fun, into this white water phase. I’ve hired you to build the process to get us from white water into predictable success.”</p><h3>Succeeding early</h3><p><strong>DI: Most of your recent experience at least has been operating in hyper growth mode. But I know in a previous life you were involved at an incubator. For people in a corporate innovation group or a similar incubator type situation, any advice you would give to increase the chances of success there?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>Yeah, I was at Sandbox. It was really a neat place at the time because on the same floor you had people in venture capital, and these entrepreneurs in residence starting businesses, and people running the businesses. So it was this really neat mix and it was a really great opportunity to learn.</p><p>When you’re first getting a company off the ground, it’s really hard to do a lot of things well. You have to pick one. You live and die by speed, momentum, and traction, and change, and testing.</p><p>All these things that are really the antithesis of a big company, where you want to be slow and careful, and not make a mistake, and not lose your job, and not mess up, and not upset your customer, not ruin your reputation.</p><p>Like I said before, putting a wall between those two with different P&amp;Ls, different teams, different goals, different evaluation criteria, is really helpful.</p><h3>The future of mobility</h3><p><strong>DI: At SpotHero you’ve elevated your thinking, or broadened your thinking. It was about helping people find parking, you’ve executed on that really well. And now a lot of your thinking these days is about thinking into the future. About what the future of mobility might look like, and how changes in transportation impact a business like yours. What you think the future of transportation looks like? And secondly, how do you make decisions at a strategic level with something so fuzzy? How do you place bets?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>We’re in a really interesting time for transportation. If you think about the tech world, the 2000s were about the web and SaaS and user generated content and social networks. The last decade has been focused on mobile. I think there’s going to be a pretty massive revolution in the next decade or so around transportation.</p><p>SpotHero started at the beginning of the mobile revolution. With the thought “Why do I have to drive downtown and circle around the block, and not know where to park, and not know how much it’s going to cost, and have to pay cash?” All these things felt very outdated for a mobile world.</p><p>Our business has evolved from selling parking on a website, to a mobile app. But as we think about the future much of parking will be driven by API. You’re going to use a variety of interfaces — a computer in your car, a smart speaker in your car, another mobility app you use to get around, or perhaps even the car parking itself. So that’s what we’re working to position ourselves for.</p><p>In terms of transportation in general, there are a lot of challenges. Cities are getting denser, and if you look at data around population and urbanization, cities are going to be way more dense in the future than they are now.</p><p>Traffic has gotten way worse over the last few years. Ride share is a huge part of that. There are so many cars now that commutes are 10–30 minutes longer in some cases than they used to be. That’s another major challenge.</p><p>Another challenge is consumer expectations have changed. People are no longer willing to stand at a bus stop, not knowing when the bus will come. People aren’t willing to deal with a cab not accepting a credit card. Expectations around how transportation should be have changed. But because of the infrastructure, and government regulation, and all sorts of crazy things it takes longer to change transportation then it does to change our expectations.</p><p>In terms of the future, I think it’s important to remember that just because something is said in the press doesn’t mean it’s going to happen. When people started to talk about autonomous vehicles the headlines were like “Parking’s dead because autonomous vehicles will be here next year.”</p><p>But autonomous vehicles aren’t going to be here next year — it’s going to take time. And when that does happen, are they going to be in perpetual motion, driving around the streets 24 hours a day? No. That would only cause even more traffic and congestion. The biggest cost associated with autonomous vehicles will be them being on the road and the wear and tear, so that doesn’t make any sense.</p><p>Then the headlines became, “I’ll take my autonomous vehicle to work and then it’ll just drive back to my personal garage.” So then traffic gets even worse — instead of one leg back and forth every day, there’s two legs back and forth every day.</p><p>If you’re actually an inside of the industry, and you talk to car companies and you talk to autonomous vehicle companies, they’re all highly interested in a few things.</p><p>They’re interested in <strong>navigation.</strong> How am I going to figure out where the car should go?</p><p>They’re interested in <strong>entertainment</strong>. When someone’s in the car or the car’s driving itself, are they going to be entertained during that period of time?</p><p>And they’re interested in <strong>parking</strong>. Where’s the car going to park, where’s it going to get charged and where is the fleet going to get cleaned and taken care of.</p><p>Going back to ride share, it has become so popular and so cheap that it’s actually not pulling that many people from driving. It’s pulling a lot of people away from public transit. Why take a subway in New York which is hot and crowded if for an extra dollar you can be in a Via for example.</p><p>Waze carpool announced they’re expanding nationally. Their thesis is the cost to improve the infrastructure to accommodate all the people and cars to fix traffic is insane. But what if you just rode to work with your neighbor, or someone in your community, and had people share cars when they’re going from work to home and back and forth.</p><p>So I think you’re going to see a lot more innovation around how we get smarter about getting around, whether that’s on a scooter or car autonomous vehicle.</p><h3>Challenges to autonomous vehicle adoption</h3><p><strong>DI: In terms of autonomous vehicles, you mentioned it’s not a year away, There was a ton of press around pilots, and it seems like a lot of those have either gotten more modest, or they’ve been shelved entirely. For folks that aren’t following the space, what are some of the challenges that have to be addressed in order for the autonomous thing to become a legitimate reality from what you understand?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>One is the technology. There’s a reason that autonomous vehicles are becoming relevant now, because there’s a handful of technologies that have emerged to make it possible. But there are still some technology things that have to be solved.</p><p>There is infrastructure and insurance and regulation, For example there is this concept of “duty of care”. As a driver you have to do your best to keep everyone else safe. But what if you’re a machine? What if you’re a car being driven by an algorithm, what does duty of care look like?</p><p>Ethically, or morally, how do we program these algorithms so if you have to make a trade off between hitting person A or person B, how do you make that decision? So there’s some things that as a society, we have to figure out. That’s a big one.</p><p>There’s others. The average car is on the road for 11 years. So let’s say tomorrow, autonomous vehicles are everywhere. What are you going to do with your car? If you still have your car, it’s going to be cheaper and more convenient for you to just use your own car, because you have it. And if everyone tries to sell their car at the same time, there’s going to be an amazing amount of supply of used vehicles and low demand, so there’s some things that are going to happen there. There’s a natural evolution that’s going to take time.</p><p>I think there’s going to be use cases where autonomous vehicles make a lot of sense, but there’s some where it doesn’t. If you’re a senior citizen, part of a retirement community in a suburb of Arizona where there’s not crazy things happening on the road and maybe you can’t drive, autonomous vehicles are amazing. The risks are relatively low. But what happens when there’s three feet of snow in Chicago? Or you’re in these places where there’s real world challenges that are pretty complex. So those are some of the things people are thinking about.</p><h3>Scooters</h3><p><strong>DI: What about scooters? You mentioned urbanization and how cities are going to get a lot more dense. How do those fit into your picture of the future of mobility?</strong></p><p><strong>Elan: </strong>In the last week I’ve been on a plane, I’ve been in a car, I’ve been on the train, I’ve used ride share. Chicago doesn’t have scooters yet, but I’ve tried them out in other cities. So I think we’re entering a multi-modal world with transportation. The more options or ways to get from place A to place B is really a good thing for the world.</p><p>It seems like everyone has their niche. If you’re 50 miles out of the city, you’re probably going to want to take the commuter train in. If you’re 10 miles out of the city, you’re probably going to want to drive. And if a neighbor or two or three are down at one time you’re probably going to want to do ride share. If you’re going half a mile to a mile, scooters are really interesting. They’re not going to take you 15 miles away, but they might give me five more minutes in the office every day if I can get from my office to the train faster. So I think there’s a place for all of them.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/scaling-spothero-and-the-future-of-mobility/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on December 13, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24d481763fff" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/scaling-spothero-and-the-future-of-mobility-24d481763fff">Scaling SpotHero and the Future of Mobility</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Importance of Innovation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@digintent/the-importance-of-innovation-21e8addfc619?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/21e8addfc619</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Dec 2018 15:24:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-03T17:09:11.427Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BjS_nuco47dFr0uYV5YD2w.jpeg" /></figure><p>We have <a href="http://digintent.com/what-is-innovation/">mentioned previously</a> that corporations often view innovation as a useless buzzword. So often the word has little or no substance. But if you believe that innovation really is important — at least the kind that has substance — then you’re not alone:</p><blockquote><em>“Business only has two functions: marketing and innovation.”<br> — Peter Drucker</em></blockquote><p>And for good measure (and from the person who developed the theory of “<a href="https://economics.mit.edu/files/1785">creative destruction</a>”):</p><blockquote><em>“Carrying out innovations is the only function which is fundamental in history.”<br> — Joseph Schumpeter</em></blockquote><p>Yet it’s worth exploring, both to assess whether we’re right, and if so to understand why. Knowing why will power our conversation about what to do about it.</p><p>Maybe we can set a threshold by finding some industries where innovation is <strong><em>not</em></strong> particularly important. And if we have trouble identifying any, that might go a long way towards establishing that innovation is broadly important.</p><h3>Is innovation important in government?</h3><p>Governments tend to be slow and stable. Significant change can take decades. After all, stability is one of the key demands we tend to make of government. Without a stable government it is difficult to maintain a stable currency, assured property rights, reliable market transactions, and public safety.</p><p>Perhaps governments should avoid innovation, which can be risky and destabilizing.</p><p>Sometimes it’s not that easy. The <a href="https://www.history.com/topics/middle-east/arab-spring">Arab Spring</a> of 2011 resulted in very rapid change in at least seven governments. And it’s nothing new; history is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_revolutions_and_rebellions">replete with revolutions</a> and other forms of civil unrest. That sort of existential risk seems like a good reason for innovation in government — whether to crack down on it, or avoid it. So there’s likely a tension between stability and innovation when it comes to government.</p><p>Even long-term stable governments such as the US seem to be constantly evolving. The US federal government typically <a href="https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/statistics">enacts between 200–500 laws per two-year Congress</a>. Some involve commemorative coins, but others such as the <a href="https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/jobs-act.shtml">JOBS Act</a> or <a href="https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/dodd-frank.shtml">Dodd-Frank</a> are more far-reaching.</p><p>So, while we’ve only changed the US Constitution 27 times in 200+ years, we’re still actively evolving some pretty important parts of our government. Stable governments frequently evolve in the face of changes in technology, society, and international affairs.</p><p>If that’s not a form of innovation, I don’t know what to call it. And given that it’s one of the key activities of government, innovation seems awfully important even for government.</p><h3>What about highly regulated industries?</h3><p>Maybe innovation isn’t particularly important in highly regulated industries. After all, they’re likely protected from most threats by regulatory moats.</p><h4>Taxis</h4><p>Most major cities strictly limit the number of cabs out on the streets, as well as their appearance, tools / technology, and pricing. Those constraints tend to work in favor of incumbents. That’s probably why Yellow Cab Company, <a href="http://www.encyclopedia.chicagohistory.org/pages/2912.html">which formed in Chicago in 1907</a>, flourished for almost 100 years. But it succumbed to ride sharing services, <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/san-franciscos-biggest-taxi-operator-seeks-bankruptcy-protection-1453677177">filing for bankruptcy in 2015</a>.</p><h4>Banks</h4><p>US banks are highly regulated. And the government effectively erected a defensive moat by only issuing one new bank charter between 2010 and 2017.</p><p>That, combined with heavy regulation after the 2008 financial crisis is why in 2007 the top three US banks held 20% of the country’s deposits, but as of the end of 2017 <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/biggest-three-banks-gobble-up-2-4-trillion-in-new-deposits-since-crisis-1521711001">they held 32%</a>. In the meantime they have allocated capital to technology improvements, but <a href="https://www.bankrate.com/banking/jpm-big-banks-spend-billions-on-tech-but-theyre-still-laggards/">little to innovation</a>.</p><p>Apparently, business as usual is working pretty well for them.</p><p>Yet digital disruption is <a href="https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/Accenture/Conversion-Assets/DotCom/Documents/Global/PDF/Dualpub_11/Accenture-Future-Fintech-Banking.pdf#zoom=50">a looming threat</a> to even the largest banks. CB Insights <a href="https://www.cbinsights.com/research/disrupting-banking-fintech-startups/">writes eloquently</a> on the topic, explaining that “emerging companies generally don’t attack incumbent players head-on, but rather focus on tackling specific verticals.” They go on to show an image of “Unbundling The Bank,” which demonstrates the multitude of smaller players eating away at the various components of traditional banking.</p><p>My friend Tom Loverro at IVP <a href="http://tomloverro.com/post/102797126721/banking-is-under-attack-heres-a-screenshot-of">wrote a great post</a> in 2014 pointing out the existential threat to the banking industry posed by startups:</p><blockquote><em>“Non-bank actors are attacking just about every valuable and revenue-generating activity that traditional players engage in”<br> — Tom Loverro</em></blockquote><p>The government is speeding things up with its new fintech <a href="https://www.occ.gov/news-issuances/news-releases/2018/nr-occ-2018-74.html">special purpose bank charters</a>, which will make it easier for new players to <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-treasury-fintech-lawsuit/new-york-sues-us-to-stop-fintech-bank-charters-idUSKCN1LU21O">displace traditional banking</a>. These<a href="http://digintent.com/innovation-in-financial-services/"> fintech innovators</a> often focus on underserved markets to rapidly establish meaningful market share. For example, the <a href="https://medium.com/@financialclinic/closing-the-underbanked-gap-in-the-united-states-8cc2325dc7ae">20%+ of US households that are underbanked</a>. And capital partners are ready and willing to finance this disruption: $31 billion alone went towards<a href="https://home.kpmg.com/xx/en/home/media/press-releases/2018/02/global-fintech-funding-tops-us-31b-for-2017-fueled-by-us-in-q4-kpmg-pulse-of-fintech-report.html"> fintech investing in the US in 2017</a>.</p><h4>Electric utilities</h4><p>Electric utilities in the US are typically monopolies whose profits are effectively set by regulations. Surely they aren’t threatened by disruptive innovation. Their maximum profitability is determined by what’s called a “rate base” calculation derived from a percentage return on assets, with a US average of 14.5% as of 2015 (read <a href="https://blog.aee.net/how-do-electric-utilities-make-money">this blog post</a> by Coley Girouard on Advanced Energy Perspects for more information).</p><p>But as Coley points out, changes in dynamics in the energy industry are putting significant pressure on electric utilities. Aging and outdated infrastructure combined with improvements in energy efficiency at the edges of the grid — for example residential solar — are threatening the stability of the entire industry.</p><p>At DI we have engaged with a number of major utilities in the US. It’s clear they are very aware of the need for innovation even in this regulated monopoly industry. Apparently even a government mandated monopoly and preset profitability model aren’t enough to protect an industry from disruption.</p><h3>What about intellectual property monopolies?</h3><p>Government regulation can create effective barriers in other ways. For example, intellectual property rules might protect some industries or organizations from disruption.</p><h4>Pharmaceutical companies</h4><p>Drug discovery can be extraordinarily expensive — it costs on average over $2 billion to <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2017/10/16/the-cost-of-developing-drugs-is-insane-a-paper-that-argued-otherwise-was-insanely-bad/#3c82f892d459">bring a drug to market</a>. But successful new drugs are typically protected by patents that create effective monopolies for up to 20 years (usually less due to patenting process).</p><p>Health care rules and procedures often ingrain effective treatments into “standard of care” rules that generate guaranteed revenue streams for many drugs. Distribution, insurance coverage, and channel partnerships favor incumbents, too.</p><p>But it’s not all unicorns and rainbows for the pharma industry.</p><p>Regulatory and market dynamics are putting drug companies in a tough spot as health care costs rise, and pharma costs are put in the spotlight. The solutions that promise to lower discovery costs — such as AI or “in silico” drug testing — or to improve overall efficiency — such as the rise of PBMs (Pharmacy Benefits Managers) and digital patient engagement systems — are alien to pharma companies.</p><p>Other new technologies such as <a href="https://www.vox.com/2018/7/23/17594864/crispr-cas9-gene-editing">CRISPR</a> and <a href="http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/01/you-could-soon-be-manufacturing-your-own-drugs-thanks-3d-printing">3D drug printing</a> and trends such as personalized medicine present increased chances for leapfrog innovation. Meanwhile, companies such as Amazon are more comfortable with disruption, and have increasingly powerful positions in the consumer and health care markets.</p><p>As a result, they’re edging into important parts of the drug market, and putting pharma companies at increasing risk. Even normally conservative hospitals are <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/18/health/drug-prices-hospitals.html">banding together to enter the drug business</a>. It’s definitely a brave new world for pharmaceutical companies.</p><h4>Consumer Packaged Goods</h4><p>CPG companies enjoy intellectual property protections that can create competitive barriers to entry. Their trademarks and trade dress rights combined with marketing expertise and massive manufacturing and distribution reach can lead to significant long-term profitability.</p><p>Proctor &amp; Gamble (P&amp;G) was founded as a soap and candle company in 1837. P&amp;G is known as <a href="https://hbr.org/2011/06/how-pg-tripled-its-innovation-success-rate">one of the most innovation CPGs</a> in the market. In 2013 they did almost $83 billion in revenue. By 2017 they had dropped to $65.7 billion — an almost 21% decline.</p><p>Much of this is due to dropping about 100 underperforming brands to focus on their big money makers. That strategy resulted in a much smaller drop in EBITDA during the period: $17.5 billion in 2013 down to $16.8 billion in 2017. Meanwhile their market value during the period grew from almost $200 billion to almost $240 billion.</p><p>Yet some argue that <a href="https://seekingalpha.com/article/4133352-procter-and-gambles-biggest-risk">P&amp;G’s recent success is unsustainable</a> without significant change. Per a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/03/business/dealbook/online-upstarts-pose-a-threat-to-procter-gamble.html">2016 NY Times article</a>, P&amp;G’s CEO suggested that the <em>“rise of e-commerce and social media has reduced the cost of entry for new competitors.”</em></p><p>One key element of that is the increasing importance of direct-to-consumer sales, for which large CPGs were not built and are not well suited. But it’s probably much more than the rise of e-commerce that presents a threat to major CPGs.</p><p>An article from BCG <a href="https://www.bcg.com/en-us/publications/2017/strategy-products-how-big-consumer-companies-can-fight-back.aspx">presents it in stark terms</a>: <em>“[s]cale was once all important. On its own, however, it no longer guarantees competitive advantage… FMCG companies… need a new playbook.”</em> Niche products and brands are taking market share away from the large incumbents. They point out a number of factors including: asset-light production, expanded distribution options, variable-cost marketing, and ease of coordination as underlying factors enabling the small players to beat the big ones at their own game.</p><h3>How about network effects businesses?</h3><p><a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/2096399">Network effects</a> can create substantial competitive barriers to entry. From railroads to faxes, network effects have been instrumental in the formation of sustained value creation. Are businesses that benefit from network efforts largely insulated from disruption?</p><p><strong>Microsoft</strong> built an empire based in part on network effects. As described in a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/07/technology/07iht-07google.14282611.html">2008 NY Times article</a>:</p><blockquote><em>“Microsoft attracted consumers and software developers to use its technology, the software that controls the basic operations of a personal computer. The more that people used Microsoft’s operating system (DOS and later Windows), the more that third-party developers built products to run on Windows, which attracted more users.”</em></blockquote><p>That same article points to Google as the new king of network effects, suggesting that the Internet and open standards have eroded Microsoft’s competitive advantage.</p><p>Despite that, Microsoft’s <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/218089/global-market-share-of-windows-7/">share of the PC operating system market</a> was over 90% in 2013, and remains almost 83% today. So while their desktop market share is declining, it remains dominant. Their profits during the period have remained strong with the exception of a significant dip in 2015. In mid 2018 Microsoft <a href="https://www.geekwire.com/2018/microsoft-posts-110b-revenue-year-cruising-past-wall-street-expectations/">reported their best fiscal year ever</a> both in terms of revenues and profitability.</p><p>It certainly appears that something is working for Microsoft. But they have run into some significant challenges as well — challenges which might persist for the long term.</p><p>Their business has been built around a partnership model rather than a direct-to-consumer model. While they have had some success in gaming, <a href="https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsofts-steady-retreat-from-consumer-products-is-nearly-complete/">their pursuit of mobile and music have largely failed</a>. Their enterprise business is thriving, but given the rising power and importance of direct-to-consumer models, it’s probably not safe to say they’re not out of the woods yet.</p><p>Businesses such as <strong>Facebook</strong> have also leveraged network effects to build powerful competitive barriers to entry. Once most of your friends are connected to you on a social platform, it’s probably hard for another platform to convince you to switch until they have both a persuasive reason and enough of your friends to create a critical mass. Given the cost of building a mass market social network, that probably makes it hard to fund competitors, on top of the difficulties challenging a network effects incumbent.</p><p>But it’s not impossible.</p><p>Instagram and WhatsApp both came at the market from a different angle, and Facebook ended up buying both of them. If their competitive power were unassailable, Facebook probably would not have had to make those acquisitions.</p><p>Snapchat has also made a good run at Facebook. That is part of a larger — and potentially existential — threat to Facebook from the changing dynamics of young consumers.</p><p>Many see Facebook as <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/feb/16/parents-killed-it-facebook-losing-teenage-users">the product their parents use</a>, and therefore less desirable. At the same time, the fundamental structure of Facebook may not weather well as consumers continue to explore new modes of social interaction and engagement.</p><p>Facebook obviously isn’t going away any time soon, but that doesn’t mean that they don’t need to continue to focus on continued innovation.</p><h3>Local businesses?</h3><p>So far, we have not done a great job of identifying industries where innovation isn’t important. There’s another type of business that might do the trick for us: local businesses.</p><p>Think hair salons, private schools, or independent retailers. They tend to be driven by geography, personal relationships, and brand intimacy. Most of these sorts of business models haven’t changed considerably in the past several decades. Are they mostly immune to disruption?</p><p>For decades,<strong> independent retailers</strong> were a key part of the fabric of our economy. They have long benefitted from personal relationships and geographic ties.</p><p>At first they were pressured by big box retailers such as Wal-Mart. Many went out of business. And then e-commerce and delivery systems combined to create an increasingly viable solution to bypass small and large retailers alike.</p><p>Big retailers have by-and-large adapted with their own e-commerce offerings. Independent retailers, despite their competitive advantages of geography and personal relationships are increasingly falling down in the face of market (and social) evolutions.</p><p><strong>Hair salons</strong> are a good example of a local business. They, too, tend to be built on personal relationships and geographic ties. On top of that they are a service-oriented offering, and thus should be harder to disrupt via e-commerce. Their fundamental business model hasn’t changed for over 50 years.</p><p>Are they at risk of disruption? They are at least at risk of losing meaningful business.</p><p>Take for example the brands offering a <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/these-ingenious-at-home-hair-color-brands-are-disrupting-the-salon-scam-1525273730">direct-to-consumer e-commerce solution</a> for hair coloring and related products. The same article mentions a hybrid solution where a salon professional applies a direct-to-consumer formula and teaches consumers how to do it. Or what about Salon64 and its <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/bridgetarsenault/2018/02/09/how-one-person-is-disrupting-the-entire-beauty-industry/#b80c104dc18b">hybrid salon, workspace, and coffee bar</a>?</p><p>Even service oriented local businesses probably aren’t safe from disruption.</p><p>What about <strong>private primary and secondary schools</strong>? In most bigger US cities private schools occupy an elite niche, commanding their market due to a persistent supply demand imbalance — in favor of the schools. Parents fret about getting their kids into the right school. It has been happening for decades, and is only getting worse (for parents).</p><p>But there are warning signs for schools. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/20/nyregion/private-schools-startups-wework-wegrow-new-york.html">New entrants with innovative technology and learning experiences</a> are making a push for market share. Even WeWork is <a href="https://www.wework.com/blog/posts/wework-launching-school-to-grow-children%27s-minds-hearts-and-spirits?utm_campaign=2017-11-07-NYC-RPN-school-announcement-email&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_source=wework">launching its own school</a> called WeGrow.</p><p>Parents are understandably reluctant to try new things on their kids. These new schools are made possible in part by the exclusivity of the schools, and the increasing cost of private education. It’s likely that many private schools in the US will be faced with a need to consider more aggressive (e.g., higher level) innovation.</p><h3>Innovation is broadly important</h3><p>If you think your industry is mostly immune from the forces of disruption, you’re probably wrong. Virtually every industry is facing real threats — and in many cases existential threats — from disruptive innovation. There are many potential responses:</p><ul><li>Stick your head in the sand (perhaps the most common)</li><li>Improve your ability to <a href="http://digintent.com/innovation-portfolio/">innovate internally</a></li><li><a href="https://digintent.com/contact">Engage with an outside firm</a> to enhance your innovation capabilities and to create new value creation models / products</li><li>Invest in and / or acquire promising startups</li><li>Utilize a <a href="http://digintent.com/innovation-framework/">hybrid approach</a> (probably the best approach)</li></ul><p>All of this brings up an interesting question… have things changed? Is innovation increasingly important? Those are the questions I will address in the next post.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/importance-of-innovation/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on December 3, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=21e8addfc619" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to get 1,6 million customers: Mike Rome’s crash course on building a growth team]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/how-to-get-1-6-million-customers-mike-romes-crash-course-on-building-a-growth-team-8eac39a1f34b?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8eac39a1f34b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth-hacking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Nov 2018 20:22:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-23T21:31:01.208Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How to get 1.6 million customers: Mike Rome’s crash course on building a growth team</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WVMpO_VQ-DxhyigjushoWw.jpeg" /></figure><p>One thing many high growth startups have in common is the growth team — a multi-disciplinary group tasked with moving bottom line product metrics.</p><p>Unlike traditional marketers that focus on acquisition, they are tasked with iterating on the product to improve things like retention, referral, and average revenue per user.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*1VnuWHkTGGuxDxOG.png" /><figcaption>Mike Rome</figcaption></figure><p>Mike Rome leads growth at Eat Street, and in his career has helped acquire millions of users for a number of startups. In this discussion Mike shares how he approaches growth, his methodology for prioritizing experiments, the components of a good growth team and more.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fanchor.fm%2Fdisruptors%2Fembed%2Fepisodes%2FHow-to-get-1-617-418-customers-Mike-Romes-crash-course-on-building-a-growth-team-e2i310&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fanchor.fm%2Fdisruptors%2Fepisodes%2FHow-to-get-1-617-418-customers-Mike-Romes-crash-course-on-building-a-growth-team-e2i310&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fs3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com%2Fanchor-generated-image-bank%2Fproduction%2Fpodcast_uploaded_nologo400%2F686243%2F686243-1531423214935-a083f65bd3f72.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=anchor" width="400" height="102" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d3741f14aa47805d92cb31a8870ba24b/href">https://medium.com/media/d3741f14aa47805d92cb31a8870ba24b/href</a></iframe><h3>The 5 levers for growth</h3><p><strong>DI: You’ve talked about the intersection of growth and product. When you say things like “the product is the marketing,” or that a lot of the levers that you can influence from a marketing perspective actually live inside of the product itself, what do you mean?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> One problem with all the data out there now is the noise degrading the signal. What you really want to do is operate above the blizzard. You want to figure out the metrics that actually put you on a path to sustainable growth.</p><p>I like Dave McClure’s <a href="https://www.slideshare.net/dmc500hats/startup-metrics-for-pirates-long-version">“Startup Metrics for Pirates”</a> which talks about 5 levers for growth: acquisition, activation, retention, revenue, and referral. We can just run through the definitions really quick.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ISRJAqltEGQcpmOL.png" /></figure><h4>Acquisition:</h4><p>Acquisition is essentially marketing. How do we get people to this thing that we build? How do we get people who we think we might be solving a problem for with this new solution to this thing?</p><p>Lots of people do this. When they are thinking through growth, they’re thinking about the channels they could potentially tap to acquire customers.</p><p>When I’m looking for success in an acquisition channel, the two things that always matter are scale and unit economics.</p><p>Scale means “can we find a sufficient amount of customers relative to whatever the goal is?” Unit economics is the cost to acquire them relative to the value that they create. We talked about that generally as LTV.</p><p>Like I said, most teams do this. But many companies lean too heavily on acquisition or marketing as an engine for growth.</p><h4>Activation</h4><p>Activation means once we get people to this thing that we have, how do we get them to do what we want. Depending the size of what you’re selling, it might be a purchase if it’s an easier sell. If it’s something way more expensive, it might be a sign up or even watching a video or something like that</p><h4>Retention</h4><p>Retention is how to get them to continue to come back and do what you want. Probably the most important of them all, because it’s the most indicative of a good product.</p><h4>Revenue</h4><p>Revenue is how you get them to engage in some sort of monetization behavior. And there’s ways to do that beyond bringing people to your site and letting them buy what they think they want.</p><h4>Referral</h4><p>The last one is is referral. How do you get them to have such a great experience that they become the marketers for you?</p><p>The really big takeaway: of these five levers, only one of them is marketing. All of these other things happen once people get to the product itself.</p><p>People don’t spend enough time trying to study, reflect on, and experiment with those product levers, and ultimately they’re a much more ROI-friendly way of growing. If you already have people coming to something and you’re able to use the resources you have in-house to build a better product to raise order values or encourage them to become marketers for you, you get a lot more like bang for your buck.</p><h3>Growth Process</h3><p><strong>DI: I would imagine that a lot of people who do marketing would say “I stand up referral campaigns. I build funnels to activate.” They might think this sounds the same as what they do now. What are some of the process or competency differences that you think distinguish growth from marketing?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> Sure. I think you’re hitting on this idea of <a href="https://digintent.com/the-key-to-growth-process/">putting growth process before tactics</a>. Which is one of the bigger differences I’ve seen.</p><p>Early on when I got into tactics, a lot of it was informed by who’s just yelling the loudest in their content marketing on social media. You’d read something and be like, “Oh, that sounds interesting, right? We should go try that.”</p><p>The danger and putting tactics before process is unless you have a way of continually starting and finishing tasks, it’s very easy to get left behind. Everyone who’s listening to this podcast is going to be resource-constrained. If you don’t have a process to thoughtfully prioritize and have conviction around what you’re doing, you’re just going to waste too much time.</p><p>Our process at a high level is to start with a brainstorm around those five letters that we talked about — acquisition, activation, retention, referral, revenue. We try to go for unbridled ideation and think of things hat you don’t even think will work.</p><p>Maybe they’re just marketing channels that are less intuitive. Sometimes that stuff gets really interesting because they’re generally less crowded less saturated stuff. Once you do that brainstorming to get all the ideas down, I would pair it with some sort of quantitative audit to assess potential impact.</p><p>It’s okay if you’re just starting up and you don’t have any internal data to reference to inform what tactics within those levers you might hit first. Secondary research works — there’s stuff out there, maybe future competitors in the space or general insights that have been written about either the problems you’re trying to solve or even solutions that exist.</p><h3>Looking for growth opportunities</h3><p><strong>DI: If they do have data, what are you looking for to assess impact — things like bottlenecks? Is that what you mean when you say doing an audit of what they already have? What should they be looking for?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> I think one of the dirty little secrets of trying to grow something is that often the best things are just fixing stuff that’s broken.</p><p>A lot of people hear this term growth or growth teams, and it’s a sexy notion. But the reality is a lot of times we’re just finding hiccups in the product and taking things away or just making things work as we thought they would work, across all platforms or all browsers.</p><p>Outside of fixing stuff, we’re looking for where inputs and outputs not equal. How do we spend a low effort on high-potential, high-impact, high-confidence tasks?</p><p>We use something called <strong>ICE scoring</strong> to prioritize. ICE is just an acronym for impact, confidence, and effort.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3fGIuCb8cLGKQxvm.png" /></figure><p>So after brainstorming and doing that audit, you have all these things you want to test or these new product ideas as it relates to activation, retention, etc.</p><p>For every single idea, you should start with <strong>impact</strong>. Ask, “If this thing were to work, what’s the impact? What’s the payoff?”</p><p>You can put together a quick and dirty <a href="https://digintent.com/growth-model">model</a>. It doesn’t have to be perfect, just go through the exercises and figure out what’s important.</p><p>Next is <strong>confidence</strong>. It’s great if you find an idea and you’re like, “Wow. If this works, the impact is huge.” If you don’t have a lot of conviction around the impact though, and there’s not a lot of primary or secondary data to support what you’re saying, it’s probably not the first thing I would do. Confidence matters just as much as impact.</p><p>The last thing, the most important thing when you’re starting up, is <strong>effort</strong>. What’s it going to take to actually test this new idea? Can I do it myself? Can someone on my team do it? Do I need a developer? Do I need a designer? Do I need multiple developers?</p><p>The Holy Grail is the low-effort, high-impact, high-confidence ideas. And that’s where you want to start.</p><p>The reason I would weigh effort so much is in the early days, momentum is everything. If you think about the formula for growth, it’s number of experiments you can run multiplied by impact multiplied by success rate.</p><p>So you have these three inputs and really only one of them is in your control, and that’s the number of experiments you start and finish.</p><p>And the reason starting and finishing so experiments is important is because that’s how you learn. Most of the things you’ll do don’t work. You don’t get demoralized. You ask yourself ask yourself “Why didn’t this work? What was our hypothesis that was disproven and how does that re-inform our priorities? How do we move stuff around based on what we’ve learned?”</p><p>The more tests you can start and finish, the quicker you learn, and the quicker you learn the higher your success rates. And that’s when you get that flywheel spinning.</p><h3>Baking growth into your organization</h3><p><strong>DI: What would you say to somebody that says, “Hey, this all sounds awesome. I would love to try to implement something like this for my team, but I have folks who come from a different sort of mentality?” How do you try to make something like that happen inside of an organization?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> It’s really important when you have those conversations not to think that that you have all of the answers. Starting from a place where your path is the only path is a bad idea.</p><p>I recommend this path just candidly because I’ve seen it work for me. But I’m always mindful that our process is a living process. It’s broken. We are changing it all the time and trying to get better.</p><p>And so I would ask questions. “Why do you think that the best approach?” It’s important to try to persuade people that you’re just trying to develop a better mechanism for how to move forward.</p><p>Everyone thing every realizes is there are a thousand different things they could be doing. So I’ve told people that process is piece of mind. It gives you confidence in what you’re doing and not doing. And looking at it from that lens is really helpful.</p><p>The other thing is to realize it’s only part of the equation. There’s still the need for brand marketing. In my job today, I spend a half my time on marketing and customer acquisition and the other half on product. But my side is very data driven.</p><p>The other part of customer acquisition for our company is brand-focused. I’ve learned they complement each other super well. If you execute on creative, whether it’s TV or radio or out of home, they can really lift up direct response and what my team does. So they’re symbiotic.</p><h3>The risks of “faking” growth</h3><p><strong>DI: It seems like if you were to start on the product side, get some wins, demonstrate the process works, and then ask for a seat of the table around acquisition, that might help.</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> I think that’s a great idea. It’s also important to stress that they have their job, which is to get people to the site, and you have your job which is to make sure the product does what you sold.</p><p>One of the big mistakes I’ve made and I know is common is that it’s really easy to fake growth. The number-one way to do that is to <a href="https://digintent.com/the-danger-of-cheap-acquisition/">find channels where you can acquire lots of inexpensive customers</a> without being mindful of the unit economics on the other half of that equation of successful customer acquisition.</p><p>It’s equally important to start with the product and to worry about levers and retention to make sure you’re ready for marketing. If you haven’t built something that enough people want and ideally are willing to pay for, it won’t work.</p><p>You want to get enough people using the product to see if some of those activation retention metrics are improving; you just want to know if you’re steadying the foundation. A lot of times the foundation isn’t steady, and when people get into customer acquisition it’s intoxicating to see lots of app downloads or lots of views or even purchases but, you know, those are one-time purchases. If people aren’t coming back, that’s the biggest mistake.</p><p><strong>DI: You see that a lot with startups who have investors setting expectations around consistent growth period over period, and now you have to keep plowing increasing amounts of money into it to continue to show what they’re expecting, even if your foundation is shaky underneath.</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> Absolutely. You have to acknowledge that even even if you have really great investors and backers, your incentives are never perfectly aligned.</p><p>If you look at the unit economics of how most investors or funds make money, it’s not because they have lots and lots of wins. It’s usually one big whale that carries the fund.</p><p>So they have an incentive to figure out who’s going to boom or bust as fast as possible. They want to figure out if they should spend their time and energy with a business or even put more capital into it. As a result there is a lot of pressure to spend money to drive scale, even if it doesn’t make the most sense for the business.</p><p>I’m lucky, in that we’ve got really awesome investors, and we can have these kinds of conversations about what’s responsible. But there’s always pressure to spend faster and you really want to make sure you’re spending in a way that’s sustainable.</p><h3>Innovation accounting vs. traditional accounting</h3><p><strong>DI: We run into that in an innovation context where organizations are used to measuring success the same way they measure the success of the core business. There’s a strong tendency to want to show immediate results and to make it look bigger than it’s ready to be. that whole that concern around premature scaling. But </strong><a href="https://digintent.com/3-ways-to-maximize-your-digital-innovation-efforts/"><strong>it takes time to iterate and find product-market fit</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> One of the best pieces of advice I would give to folks who are part of larger organizations and working on an innovation teams is you have to have buy-in from the top that this is going to be a long and demoralizing road and, if people don’t have the stomach for it, it’s just tough.</p><p>It’s very exciting at the beginning. But what really drives success is the people and teams who can persist in the trough of sorrow. It comes down to determination and commitment because of all the startups that I’ve studied or been a part of, there’s always that slog. You have to have that buy-in from the top.</p><p>Someone told me the other day that one of their best qualities was they take bad news very well. I think that’s actually an amazing competitive advantage. You’ve got to be excited enough about the problem you’re solving to keep going. If it can’t hold your attention span, or the attention of your organization, it’s really tough.</p><h3>How to execute the process</h3><p><strong>DI: Getting back to process — what does that look like concretely? Can you think of examples of focusing on things that weren’t acquisition related and were able to generate meaningful upside for the organization?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> Sure. So in the early days before we had good language around this, again we were really resource constrained like most of the people probably listening to this.</p><p>We were hitting the database and seeing where users were getting hung up. Or going to a coffee shop and user testing a signup flow with people. Talking to users and digging into the product. You can talk to customer service people and figure out where people are getting frustrated.</p><p>You obviously have to have good tracking in place to mine for good inputs in the database. All the steps mapped out. In our case it was medical fundraisers. So activation was getting people to start fundraisers and make some money for the fundraiser up front.</p><p>We had enough events in place within the products to look at all of those steps and just see where it was broken, and those were always great examples of just not having enough innovative ideas for how we could improve the flow. Mostly it was things not working as we’d communicated or intended for it to work.</p><h3>How to run experiments faster</h3><p><strong>DI: Talking about the experiments and speed and number of experiments that you’re running is the one metric that you’re able to really control. Are you running a bunch of experiments at the same time to move one metric? How can organizations move faster and control that one variable?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> It’s a million-dollar question. I think tracking is really tough and it’s hard to know what the optimal things you should be doing at once are.</p><p>I think sometimes people get hung up trying to start and finish an experiment and definitively know what it means.</p><p>Take acquisition. In most cases you just need to know if there’s something there, or if it’s a hard pass. Assuming you get some results, and you know there’s scale, that’s probably sufficient. So you don’t always need to have absolute certainty about something — often directional certainty is sufficient.</p><p>That’s really important when you’re resource constrained. Even for me — I work for a later stage startup with hundreds of employees and tens of millions of dollars in revenue — I’m still super resource constrained. I don’t always have the luxury of running 5 product experiments at once.</p><p><strong>DI: People that think of testing probably think of Amazon’s hundred shades of blue. But unless you have scale, it’s going to take way too long to find wins that way, especially since most experiments fail.</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> Yeah. I think early on that’s good advice. If you’re only changing this one thing and it’s very early and you have a small subset of customers, you’re probably not testing ambitious enough things.</p><p>Don’t worry about this idea of not knowing your goal; you want to acquire twice as many customers or you want to improve the signup flow by 50%. You’re not looking for a five percent relative improvement, you’re looking for a 50% absolute improvement.</p><p>If you adopt that mentality, you have the freedom to change more things. You just have to get content knowing that even though you’re better off, you might not be exactly sure why things are working and that’s OK sometimes.</p><p><strong>DI: I’ve told our team before — lacking causation, I’ll take correlation. I don’t know if this is actually causing it, but it seems to be correlated and that’s good enough for me for now. Let’s deploy and move forward.</strong></p><p>There’s also a team member education piece to this, where you’ll run the test higher up in the funnel — on your registration page for example — and if it works and you see a 15 percent lift, they’re thinking that’s going to trickle down to a 15% bottom line bump.</p><p>But it usually doesn’t work out that way. Any change that you make changes the way people interact with your product. Their behavior is going to be different.</p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> Yeah, there are people a lot smarter than me on A/B testing. <a href="https://www.evanmiller.org/ab-testing/">Evan Miller</a> writes some really thoughtful things around what to pay attention to when you’re testing different experiences.</p><p>I think you have to be OK with some of this ambiguity and not knowing if you want to move forward fast enough.</p><p>It’s a delicate balance though. How do you make sure you’re using data to have conviction around what you do next, while operating above the blizzard of data?</p><h3>Good enough data</h3><p><strong>DI: For us, often clients have the reverse problem where they don’t have any tracking set up, at least not at the event level. They track sales or registrations, but not all of the events that lead up to that. So we usually we usually have the reverse problem.</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> Well I think the larger takeaway here is, when it comes to starting something even if you don’t have data, that’s fine. Go make data. Go talk to potential customers. Don’t sit in a conference room and ideate with a bunch of the executives who aren’t going to be the user of the product.</p><p>I don’t think this whole idea of “we don’t have analytics set up” or “we don’t have users” should get in the way of putting in the work. Go talk to talk to people. Even if it’s bad news. The best feedback you can get when you want to build something is figuring out it doesn’t work. Figure out why and improve.</p><p><strong>DI: I was having a conversation with our creative director about design thinking. We often do “how might we” exercises that are similar to the unbridled ideation you were talking about.</strong></p><p>He said a lot of UX is about pattern recognition, and is dependent on the inputs you have. Someone cold off the street can throw out ideas, and it’s better than nothing. But they’ll be less informed than if you do some research in advance of a workshop. If I know what my customer says and how they use my product, you have much better inputs and the session is more productive.</p><p>You mentioned the potential risks of becoming prescriptive and looking at what other people have done and just copying it. At the same time, those are inputs I can bring and say, “Hey, this product or completely unrelated industry solved a similar type of problem by doing x.” Does that make sense at all?</p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> I think it’s a really powerful point. I think again, especially when you’re starting, don’t get hung up on not having certain inputs. And don’t get hung up on this idea that you need hundreds of pieces of input.</p><p>There’s plenty of reading out there around picking up UX patterns. And from a user testing perspective, it takes a small subset of users to figure out what things would satisfy 80 percent of the product needs.</p><p>Don’t get hung up on the idea that your inputs aren’t good enough. Just go find any inputs. If you’re curious and you’re bringing inputs to the table that are rooted in actual user feedback, not just from your head but from talking and listening to a potential customer, that’s useful.</p><p>Paul Graham talks a lot about how users have lots of the answers. Nine times out of ten, I can’t think of a better use of time than just going and listening to some users and studying them, either using the product or reacting to you talking through a product.</p><h3>Building a growth team</h3><p><strong>DI: Let’s talk about team. I know it looks different depending on the stage of an organization, but in order to execute on growth, it seems like you need more than just a person with a marketing mind. What skill sets are necessary?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> Curious people are a big deal. You want to find people who are comfortable with bad news. They’ve got a lot of persistence and determination — the whole idea of a rapid rate of learning is the reward and that’s enough. I think all of those are really good things.</p><p>In terms of the makeup of an early team, you should have people on the team who are essentially the customer. It’s hard to build something if you’re not the customer and you have to guess at what the customer wants. Be the customer because then you can move a lot faster. You can just think about how you would create value for yourself.</p><p>When it comes to actual skill sets, it’s good to have a developer to execute on experiments. And you need some design help. Design matters.</p><p>I think technical marketers are important — people who are really into direct response marketing. They’re good because they’re generally detail-oriented, so they can double as product managers.</p><p>They also have empathy for developers and designers to respect what they’re asking them to do. It’s really easy for someone to say a couple of sentences and create five weeks of work for a developer. Knowing what you’re asking and why that’s hard is important. It’s just good for the morale of the team.</p><p>You also need someone with some analytics background. Have someone who is a truth seeker and is going to keep you honest.</p><p>I think if you just find people who are excited to build shiny new things instead of building things that actually solve a real and deep problem, that would be difficult.</p><h3>Getting developer resources</h3><p><strong>DI: One of the issues with growth teams has been getting access to developers because so many teams are resource constrained. How do you recommend advocating for getting resources when you’re just getting started?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> When it comes to getting developer time, you have to find someone who’s excited about the opportunity. You need to find a developer who gets fired up about the work. You can’t understate the importance of being excited about the problem. At some point it’s going to get hard. And if you’re not excited about the problem, it’s tough to keep going.</p><p>When you’re trying to get buy-in from the top, explaining the value the work could create for the business is a good approach. Just let the facts do the talking. It forces you to be really well researched and prepared. It’s not very hard to show that working on x versus y could have a financial benefit to the business.</p><p>Figure out who you’re trying to get buy-in from. What are the things that make them look good? What do they care about? It’s tough, but politics matters. Especially if you’re in a larger company.</p><h3>Growth models</h3><p><strong>DI: One of the tools that we’ve been using a lot more in the last year is a </strong><a href="https://digintent.com/growth-model"><strong>super granular growth model</strong></a><strong>. Trying to visualize and quantify all of those levers, figuring out the six steps during activation here and the three different referral loops inside of a product.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kMVrgDYX8v7mo0Gv.png" /></figure><p>Now, instead of saying let’s spend three months on this feature because is’t next on the roadmap, showing how something will influence a variable and doing a sensitivity analysis is really helpful in making that case.</p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> The reason detailed models are are very helpful is it opens your eyes to the road ahead. Getting a sense of awareness before you start and a degree of humility is going to help you. You want to make sure everyone has the stomach for what’s ahead and then is still excited.</p><p>I took a look at it. You sent it over to me a little while ago and I was super impressed. I mean, a lot of that stuff was more savvy than some of the stuff I’m using, so hats off.</p><p><strong>DI: Everybody gets it from other people. That was that was all </strong><a href="https://brianbalfour.com/"><strong>Brian Balfour</strong></a><strong>. It’s incredibly helpful for vetting potential investments as well. Founder says, “I’m raising $1.5M and our plan is to get to 50,000 customers over the next twelve months.”</strong></p><p>And I ask, “How do you plan on getting there?”</p><p>And they’re like, “Well, there’s this bucket of money and we’re going to do word-of-mouth and we’re going to do paid marketing.”</p><p>When you show them the model, they start to realize that getting to 50,000 is going to take a lot more work than they thought. When they talk about doing content marketing, you have to find out how many articles you’re going to have to write to rank. What’s the monthly search volume on all of those and your expected click-through rate, etc. They start to realize they need to really buckle up and plan on hustling.</p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> I couldn’t agree more.</p><h3>Creating a growth culture</h3><p><strong>DI: You talked about process and you’ve talked about team. I know you’re a big believer in culture too. Once you’ve got the team together, what are some recommendations for instilling a culture of growth to make this this stuff stick?</strong></p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> A great shortcut is to find people who fit the mold. There’s certain things you can’t teach. You have to find people who are determined, who are okay being wrong a lot, who are curious and truth seekers.</p><p>Setting the precedent up front helps too. Making sure people really understand how difficult the road ahead is going to be and are bought in. I don’t mean to talk about it negatively because I love it. But the learning curve is just ridiculous. You grind it out for six months and hit some hard times. But you come up for air you just you’ve built this new skill set and that high rate of learning never stops. There are certain people who just have an appetite for it.</p><p>Ask some tough questions in the early days to make sure people are doing this for the right reasons. Get people who aren’t just here because it seems like a cool idea. It needs to be something more — people really need to believe in the idea.</p><p><strong>DI:</strong> I know you have a reputation for keeping people’s enthusiasm levels high throughout the slog. And you also have a reputation for modeling behavior — getting your hands dirty instead of just barking orders. Were those deliberate choices?</p><p><strong>Mike:</strong> I’ve always appreciated people that are still in the trenches. That carries a lot of weight for me.</p><p>The other thing is that lately I’ve just been trying to get out of the way a little more. We’ve been at it for a while; the team’s been a formal team for several years now. And I think sometimes you need to get out of the way.</p><p>I think about all of the best growth ideas that have happened on growth teams that I’ve been a part of and not one of them was my idea, and so getting comfortable with that idea is something I’ve been working on.</p><p>The thing I’m always focused on bringing to the table is just making sure there is a culture of meritocracy, where best idea wins and it doesn’t matter who it comes from. Use ICE scores, make sure people have the tools and time to execute, and get out of the way.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/how-to-build-a-growth-team/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on November 19, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8eac39a1f34b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/how-to-get-1-6-million-customers-mike-romes-crash-course-on-building-a-growth-team-8eac39a1f34b">How to get 1,6 million customers: Mike Rome’s crash course on building a growth team</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[After the Design Sprint]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/after-the-design-sprint-5cf81a8a898c?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5cf81a8a898c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mvp]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-sprint-to-mvp]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-sprint]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Nov 2018 17:08:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-13T15:06:01.447Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>5 ways to gain momentum and move from a design sprint to MVP.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XT5Hj3VKzJdvzPV_WhZuTA.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://digintent.com/design-thinking-process">Design Thinking</a> has become an essential part of how innovation teams surface ideas.</p><p>One specific tool has been the design sprint — typically a 5 day exercise using user-centered design methodologies to quickly arrive at a potential solution to a problem.</p><p>It’s fantastic tool — one we use ourselves and teach to our clients. But coming out of them, there’s often the problem of what to do next.</p><h3>Getting Stuck</h3><p>In our conversations with innovation teams, its extremely common to run a bunch of design sprints, identify a bunch of potential solutions, but then get stuck.</p><p>In many cases, the rough prototype and the small sample size of customer feedback, even if positive, isn’t enough to earn the resources internally to move to an MVP build.</p><p>And so instead of a stack of ideas piling up, there’s now a stack of somewhat validated prototypes piling up instead. You’ve moved the ball forward, but not by much.</p><h3>Validating the rest of the Lean Canvas.</h3><p>A great tool for summarizing a potential solution on a single sheet of paper is the Lean Canvas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yn_TG_tCkFfdIEdB.png" /></figure><p>Underneath an idea is a set of assumptions:</p><ul><li>You’re assuming a certain stakeholder (or set of stakeholders) has a problem.</li><li>That you have the solution to that problem.</li><li>That the problem is solved in a way that creates value for the stakeholder — enough for them to either start paying for it or otherwise incorporate it into their lives.</li><li>That there are enough of these stakeholders out there (and that you can get access to them easily enough) to make the time and effort worth it.</li><li>That the cost to get them to use it is cheap enough relative to the value you extract from their use to make it worthwhile.</li><li>That the solution is defensive enough to avoid being copied immediately.</li></ul><p>Design sprints can help solve a subset of these, but obviously not all of them.</p><p>Assuming you are following the practices of user-centered design, you’ve done the work of validating stakeholders need before starting your design sprint. And through the sprint process you uncover at least to a degree that the solution could potentially solve the problem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UIyE2P8BCAYa0lY4T5nUAw.png" /></figure><p>But just like a venture fund is unlikely to invest in a company on the basis of a clickable prototype and 6 conversations with end users, your growth board or other innovation governance team likely won’t consider that sufficient to green light the resources to build an MVP.</p><p>So how do you close that gap, improve your case and move the initiative forward? Here are 5 suggestions that have helped other clients break the logjam.</p><h3>Polish the prototype and get more data points</h3><p>You make something quick and dirty to capture user feedback during the sprint. Now it’s time to create high fidelity versions of that prototype.</p><p>This doesn’t need to be working software. It can still leverage tools like Invision. But it should have the look and feel of a finished product.</p><p>With that in hand, go outside the conference room and show it to more users. Capture their feedback around willingness to use and if necessary willingness to pay.</p><p>Don’t be surprised when you get lukewarm feedback or objections. Use those to improve the prototype, and go back out there.</p><p>Getting more data points can help build your case. And interestingly, simply having a highly designed version of your prototype can increase internal momentum as well. It gives the impression that there’s a “there” there.</p><p>Showing pretty screens can often generate more enthusiasm than talking about an idea in the abstract (or even showing lower fidelity versions of an idea, which signal that it’s half baked.)</p><h3>Create a functional spec</h3><p>Assuming the solution is a piece of software, a fantastic next step is to turn the prototype into a functional spec document. This typically includes:</p><ul><li>Writing out the user stories in detail.</li><li>Outlining all of your assumptions around integration points and other data that needs to be captured.</li><li>Creating a product roadmap, with the functionality you envision in the MVP and subsequent releases.</li><li>Most importantly, using that information to get a timeline and budget estimate for the build.</li></ul><p>Doing this gives your internal team the data they need to make the case from a level of effort perspective, which is obviously an essential part of your case.</p><p>It also helps you craft the message in a way that increases the likelihood of success. Too often teams try to pitch the grand vision. They ask for the budget to create the product as it will ultimately be. But this increases your cost and risk, both perceived and actual.</p><p>Instead, identify the “core experience” that belongs in the MVP. Focus your effort on nailing the first time UX and the core experience. Defer the rest.</p><p>This is a good practice anyway, as simpler, tighter products tend to result in higher user satisfaction and limit the amount of behavior change needed to adopt.</p><p>Getting timeline and budget numbers also help you identify potential trade offs, shaping what that core experience includes and doesn’t include. It helps you make a more modest ask for MVP development, while providing visibility into the costs of the potential long term roadmap as well.</p><p>We typically recommend getting an estimate from an external vendor at this phase, even if your internal team plans to build. This addresses two potential issues:</p><ul><li>It avoids the objection that the internal team has too many other things going on.</li><li>Often the internal estimate is <em>higher</em> than the estimate from the vendor, both in terms of budget and time. Having a second data point is incredibly useful in making the case.</li></ul><h3>Create a growth model.</h3><p>We’ve talked in detail about <a href="https://digintent.com/growth-model">how we use growth models</a> to put realistic assumptions around getting traction. We’ve found it to be an invaluable tool for making the MVP case.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*P-ZgvagCvxlXQ2CP.png" /></figure><p>The model makes a series of detailed assumptions at every layer of the customer or stakeholder funnel:</p><ul><li><strong>Acquisition</strong>: How will we get people to find out about the solution? From what channels? How much will those channels cost? What’s the audience size of those channels?</li><li><strong>Activation</strong>: What are the steps necessary for a user to go from awareness to adoption? What are our estimates for conversion rates at each step of that onboarding process?</li><li><strong>Retention</strong>: What do we think retention will look like over a 3/6/12 month period of time? (note that benchmarks are incredibly helpful here.)</li><li><strong>Revenue</strong>: If these users are being monetized in some way, what are our assumptions around monetization? Number of ad impressions, % of free to paid subscribers, etc.</li><li><strong>Referral</strong>: If there is a referral component, what does that loop look like? Number of invites sent per user, % who accept the invite, their onboading behavior (note that it’s often different than a user acquired cold because of the referral), etc.</li></ul><p>These are obviously all assumptions. But they demonstrate to your team that you’ve given things way more thought. That you have a rational plan for how you will grow the product once it’s launched, and that your estimates for ROI are backed by a detailed breakdown of the levers that influence it.</p><h3>Create a smoke test</h3><p>To further validate some of the assumptions in your model, you can create a smoke test to test acquisition.</p><p>A smoke test can take many forms — often it looks like a landing page (with your pretty screens) with a call to action to sign up. Behind that is a page saying we’re not ready yet, asking for an email address to be notified when you launch. You supplement this with a tactical paid acquisition campaign to acquire potential customers.</p><p>This helps you validate a whole host of things:</p><ul><li>Which channels are most cost-effective for generating traffic from our target users?</li><li>What value proposition and create treatment is most effective?</li><li>What percentage of people, once made aware of our product, are interested enough to click a sign up button?</li><li>Once they see that it’s not ready yet, what percentage still think it’s compelling enough to provide their contact information?</li></ul><p>As an optional intermediate step, you can even add a pricing page (if relevant) in between the landing page and email collection. This lets you test various pricing models as well.</p><h3>Conduct cold outreach</h3><p>Finally, when dealing with b2b solutions, we often advocate for taking that smoke test and supplementing it with an aggressive cold outreach campaign.</p><p>You want the landing page up because it gives the idea credibility. You supplement the landing page with email addresses and linked profiles of people who “work” there. You build a list of targeted potential customers, and you craft a multi-modal outreach campaign to generate potential leads (typically some combination of email, phone and social selling.)</p><p>This again forces you to get outside of the building and test for value prop — customer fit.</p><p>While we believe in doing stakeholder research in other ways at the front end (validating pain through problem interviews, etc.), we do believe there is value in trying to sell the solution at this stage.</p><p>Getting meetings with potential customers who think the solution exists in some form is helpful because they’re no longer just giving you advice. They’re being sold, which increases resistance. As a result you get a ton of new useful information:</p><ul><li>It surfaces objections you’ll eventually need to learn to overcome.</li><li>It begins to help you map the buying process by understanding who the decision makers might be for a solution like this.</li><li>If coupled with an signed offer letter when there is interest, you give your team the most compelling reason to move forward of all — a signed commitment to purchase the product once it’s live.</li></ul><h3>Design Sprints are important but insufficient</h3><p>Please, continue to do design sprints. We know of no better tool to quickly make progress on a concept for a solution.</p><p>But realize it’s not a magic bullet. You still have to do the work of building your case to earn the right to move forward with it.</p><p>You can fundamentally de-risk an idea and earn the resources to build an MVP, in very little time and with very low cost. Consider baking the tools above into your process to increase your velocity of tested ideas.</p><p>DI has done all of the above for clients many times. We’d be happy to help you execute on any of them. To learn more, <a href="https://digintent.com/contact">contact</a> us.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/after-the-design-sprint/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on November 12, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5cf81a8a898c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/after-the-design-sprint-5cf81a8a898c">After the Design Sprint</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Digital Intent’s Innovation Framework]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@digintent/digital-intents-innovation-framework-977517e44e14?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/977517e44e14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Oct 2018 17:28:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-22T22:22:06.794Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The four-stage innovation framework DI uses to quickly navigate complex problem spaces and arrive at novel solutions.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Yr5DW5scvkT5SHiUmrCSFA.png" /></figure><p>Digital Intent uses a specific <a href="https://digintent.com/what-is-innovation">definition of innovation</a> that we believe provides utility for innovators. But our definition is still pretty broad. Given the work we do, certain types of innovation are more meaningful than others.</p><p>We propose a framework for distinguishing innovation based on four levels of increasing complexity. This approach is neither the only framework — there are many — nor necessarily the best for every purpose. But we do believe that it is the best framework for understanding how to pursue different types of innovation most effectively.</p><h3>Existing Innovation Frameworks</h3><p>Consultants and academics often codify their experience into frameworks, designed to abstract experience into principles that can be broadly applied to a variety of situations. By operating within frameworks, they’re able to quickly navigate complex problems and arrive at novel solutions.</p><p>Many experts have described ways to distinguish between different types of innovation. What vectors of differentiation do they tend to use?</p><p>Our goal is to identify a consistent way to differentiate between various types of innovation that will inform us about when it’s appropriate to change our process and decision-making.</p><h4>Extent of innovation</h4><p>Some distinguish innovation based on the extent of novelty, complexity, or change involved. The OECD describes <a href="http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTECA/Resources/257896-1314820419212/chapter1.pdf">four different types of innovation</a>, one of which is incremental innovation:</p><blockquote><em>“Incremental innovation: innovation that builds closely on technological antecedents and does not involve much technological improvement upon them.”</em></blockquote><p>“Incremental” and “sustaining” are two words commonly used for modest or low risk innovation. In a corporate context we often talk of “exploitation” (versus exploration) as well. The other end of the spectrum is described with a variety of words, each of which incorporates some nuances or variations of meaning. Examples include:</p><ul><li><a href="https://hbr.org/1995/01/disruptive-technologies-catching-the-wave">Disruptive innovation</a></li><li>Breakthrough innovation — generally used to describe significant, complex, and particularly meaningful innovation</li><li>Radical innovation — similar to breakthrough, but more likely to emphasize the novelty or risk associated with the process</li></ul><p>Disruptive innovation is a term coined by Clayton Christensen in the mid 1990’s to describe a specific form of creative destruction which is rooted in Joseph Shumpeter’s concept of <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Capitalism-Socialism-Democracy-Perennial-Thought/dp/0061561614">creative destruction</a>.</p><p>Steve Blank <a href="https://steveblank.com/2014/03/31/esade-business-school-commencement-speech-2/">called out Christensen</a> (and Shumpeter’s) theories in a 2014 speech:</p><blockquote><em>“Disruptive innovation — this is the innovation we associate with startups. This type of innovation creates new products or new services that did not exist before. It’s the automobile in the 1910’s, radio in the 1920’s, television in the 1950’s, the integrated circuit in the 1960’s, the fax machine in the 1970’s, personal computers in the 1980’s, the Internet in the 1990’s, and the Smartphone, human genome sequencing, and even fracking in this decade. These innovations are exactly what Schumpeter and Christensen were talking about. They create new industries and destroy existing ones. And interestingly, in spite of all their resources, large companies are responsible for very, very few disruptive innovations.”</em></blockquote><p>The term has become very popular, but has also <a href="https://jawwad.me/criticism-of-christensen-theories/">been critiqued</a>. Christensen <a href="https://hbr.org/2015/12/what-is-disruptive-innovation">defended his theory</a> in 2015 by re-emphasizing the narrow scope of what he considered disruptive.</p><p>Specifically, Christensen’s term described innovation by upstarts targeting unmet needs in “low-end footholds” that the incumbents had ignored or been unaware of. He also clarified that for something to be disruptive (according to his definition at least), the existing market had to consider it undesirable at first. He went on to argue based on these tests that Uber is not a disruptor. Commence head scratching.</p><p>It appears, by the way, that Steve Blank probably understood disruption to be a broader concept than Christensen intended. After all, automobiles, television, and the fax machine are hard to fit into the notion of a low-end foothold.</p><p>Christensen has since <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestreptalks/2016/10/03/clayton-christensen-on-what-he-got-wrong-about-disruptive-innovation/#28a2a368391b">walked back from his position</a> that Uber is not disruptive, but the fundamental fact remains that the term he popularized — to him at least — is quite narrow, and rooted primarily in Joseph Shumpeter’s original concept of creative destruction.</p><p>The concept of creative destruction, while useful, is still largely a theoretical construct. Christensen inarguably contributed to economic theory with his notion of disruptive innovation, but it’s not clear to us due to its narrowness that it offers a particularly useful rubric for understanding innovation.</p><p>When most people use the word disruptive innovation, they probably mean the broader notion of innovation that disrupts an industry. That’s the meaning we assign to it at Digital Intent unless we specifically invoke Christensen.</p><p>In this broader conceptual vein, using the extent of innovation to distinguish types of innovation seems useful. If you’re doing something incremental, it seems more likely that traditional management orthodoxy would be appropriate. If you’re doing something disruptive, it seems much more likely that you would need to adopt new strategies to accommodate. But still, the terms we’re discussing feel like blunt instruments that don’t offer enough utility for our purposes. Let’s keep looking.</p><h4>What you’re trying to improve</h4><p>Another way to think of innovation involves what you’re trying to improve. For example, <a href="http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTECA/Resources/257896-1314820419212/chapter1.pdf">the same OECD report</a> mentioned above describes product, process, marketing, and organizational innovation. Each of these appears to distinguish between the types of resources or capabilities an organization is trying to improve. An example:</p><blockquote><em>“Product innovation: development of new products representing discrete improvements over existing ones.”</em></blockquote><p>A different approach has been written about by Doblin in its <a href="https://www.doblin.com/ten-types">Ten Types of Innovation</a>. They focus on the ten different innovation targets, including: profit model, network, structure, process, product performance, product system, service, channel, brand, and customer engagement.</p><p>It’s definitely a worthwhile read. Jay Doblin, the cofounder, was an iconic designer with expertise in systems thinking and design theory. As a result, their approach tends to be derived from a product design perspective, and may not be as useful when it comes to the broader context, and specifically in the context of technology and business model innovation.</p><p>Steve Blank <a href="https://steveblank.com/2014/03/31/esade-business-school-commencement-speech-2/">also talks about process innovation</a>, but his version is different and would probably be labeled incremental or sustaining innovation by most:</p><blockquote><em>“Car companies introduce new models each year, running shoes grow ever lighter and more flexible, Coca-Cola offers a new version of Coke. Smart companies are always looking to make their current products better — and there are many ways to do this. For example they can reduce component cost, introduce a line extension or create new versions of the existing product. These innovations do not require change in a company’s existing business model.”</em></blockquote><p>In fact, today this sort of innovation seems a lot more like everyday execution than innovation.</p><p>Steve also talked about <a href="https://steveblank.com/2010/01/25/whats-a-startup-first-principles/">business model innovation</a>, which probably falls under the “what you’re trying to improve” umbrella.</p><p>What’s a business model? That has been described many different ways, much like the <a href="https://digintent.com/what-is-innovation">definition of innovation</a>. And similar to innovation, we have a preferred definition, specifically Blank’s:</p><blockquote><em>“A business model describes how your organization creates, delivers, and captures value.”</em></blockquote><p>Business model innovation and disruption often go hand-in-hand; successfully creating new ways of creating, delivering, and capturing value is often disruptive. (By the way, around Digital Intent you’ll hear us use the term “value creation model” frequently in place of business model. That’s a nod to the fact that commercial value creation isn’t the only game in town.)</p><p>Is defining innovation based on what you’re trying to improve the best approach for our purposes? Probably not.</p><p>Innovating a product or process, for example, probably has a lot of similarities from the perspective of team, organization, and the path it takes — and as a result aren’t as useful for our clients trying to take a strategic approach to innovation.</p><p>It’s probably more important to understand how radical the change is than what’s being changed. The exception might be business model innovation due to its likely implication of breakthrough or disruptive innovation (when successful).</p><h4>Time horizon</h4><p>Ralph-Christian <a href="http://timkastelle.org/blog/2016/05/a-model-for-dual-corporate-innovation-management/">outlines a concept</a> he calls “Dual Corporate Innovation Management” that involves a balance between exploitation-oriented and exploration-oriented initiatives.</p><p>He identifies three (time) horizons for innovation based on balancing exploitation (“enhancing existing business models or technological capabilities”) and exploration (“novel, and often disruptive, business models or technological capabilities”) for establishing organizations. He advocates an innovation management system based on a portfolio approach driven by a gap analysis. Importantly, he points out that exploitation and exploration require different approaches to achieve success. In the end, he describes three horizons of innovation: core, growth, and future. His approach is useful from a corporate strategy perspective, and is rooted in traditional management orthodoxy. But it’s not really aimed at distinguishing different types of innovation.</p><p>McKinsey also describes <a href="https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/enduring-ideas-the-three-horizons-of-growth">three horizons of growth</a>:</p><ul><li>Horizon 1 — maintain and defend core business</li><li>Horizon 2 — nurture emerging business</li><li>Horizon 3 — create genuinely new business</li></ul><p>As they say, “Time, as noted on the x-axis, should not be interpreted as a prompt for when to pay attention — now, later, or much later. Companies must manage businesses along all three horizons concurrently.”</p><p>This seems like a sort of GTD (Getting Things Done) for corporations (Inbox, Today, Someday). It’s useful as a tool for allocating time and energy, but not as useful for understanding the nature of the innovation you’re undertaking, and not particularly informative about how you organize, lead, and manage the team that’s involved. It’s also not particularly useful outside of the context of an existing corporation.</p><h4>Greg Satell’s 4 types of innovation</h4><p>Greg Satell <a href="https://hbr.org/2017/06/the-4-types-of-innovation-and-the-problems-they-solve">describes a matrix-style approach</a> he describes as the “4 Types of Innovation.” His model incorporates the notions of domain and problem, asking the following questions:</p><ul><li>How well is the problem defined?</li><li>And how well is the domain defined?</li></ul><p>From that, he outlines a four-part matrix that includes:</p><ul><li>Basic research</li><li>Disruptive innovation</li><li>Breakthrough innovation</li><li>Sustaining innovation</li></ul><p>A key insight he offers is that when the marketplace shifts, often “innovating your products won’t help — you have to innovate your business model.” We find his approach to be insightful and interesting. But we believe his emphasis on problem as one of the vectors misses an opportunity. Whereas clarifying a problem is very important, particularly early on, we don’t believe it’s as useful to focus on that vector.</p><h3>Digital Intent’s 4 levels of innovation</h3><p>Digital Intent borrows from Greg Satell’s approach, but replaces the system (e.g., the value creation model) for the problem. Our two vectors:</p><ul><li><strong>System</strong> is the value creation model (e.g., business model)</li><li><strong>Domain</strong> is the combination of resources and context, including underlying technology, geography, and other components to the system of value creation.</li></ul><p>We also change the nature of the questions asked. Instead of asking how well the vectors are defined, we ask “how familiar is it?” The answer ranges along a spectrum from familiar (to the team), to unfamiliar (to the team), to novel (to the world):</p><blockquote><em>Known to me — New to me — New to the world</em></blockquote><p>This enables our framework to view the vectors more simply and objectively. It also more explicitly accounts for both the novelty and the relationship between the novelty and the organization involved.</p><p>We believe this new approach changes the model significantly, making the framework more useful. For example, this model makes it more natural to recognize tiered levels of innovation, which we found to be useful when we first looked at distinguishing innovation based on extent (above). It also recognizes that innovation can be experienced differently for different organizations.</p><p>Digital Intent’s four different levels of innovation:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/802/0*1vjlsVQaxw6nIQ3W.png" /></figure><h4>Level 1 — Optimization: Familiar system and domain.</h4><p>This is a known system of value creation using known resources and technology. These sorts of innovation tend to have clear proxies, and offer predictable timing, budget, and resource requirements. It’s easy to measure and manage risk, and it’s reasonable to expect a steady upward progress. It’s arguable this isn’t even really innovation, although we think it’s fair to use the term here as long as we’re careful to differentiate from other types of innovation.</p><h4>Level 2 — Change: Unfamiliar system and / or domain.</h4><p>There’s nothing truly novel (to the world) here, but something is unfamiliar to the team. Perhaps it’s the implementation of new (to you) technology or a new (to you) revenue model. This sort of innovation still offers a relatively predictable path, but it’s riskier and harder to predict than level 1. These innovations tend to take longer than level 2 innovations.</p><h4>Level 3 — Transformation: Somewhat novel system and / or domain.</h4><p>Level 3 innovation often involves new technologies and business models, albeit not radically so. Usually there are somewhat close proxies or partially understood or known technology. It starts to become hard to predict path, timing, budget, and required resources. Risks are very hard to assess. Often the complexity is in the combination. This sort of innovation tends to take a longer time.</p><h4>Level 4 — Breakthrough: Truly novel system and / or domain.</h4><p>Breakthrough innovation is the process of bringing to market a truly novel business model or domain. Either or both of the system or domain is new to the world. These sorts of innovations tend to take a very long time and are fraught with risk and uncertainty. They also tend to create significant value when they’re successful.</p><h3>The Benefits of Innovation Frameworks</h3><p>This approach to distinguishing types of innovation has the benefit of simplicity, with only two factors to consider. Each of the levels also has natural implications for key factors such as level of uncertainty and risk, volatility, predictability, typical timelines, etc. That’s useful because these are the factors that typically force changes in strategy, organization, and process to maximize the odds of success. By tying them naturally to the levels of innovation, we are increasing the usefulness of the framework.</p><p>The framework also works both in the context of a corporation, and for startups. And it recognizes that what might be transformative for one organization might be mostly change or optimization for another.</p><p>It has some weaknesses as well. The rating of the vectors is subjective. The model also may miss nuances (or perhaps substance) in the differences between innovation based on system vs. domain. After all, core technology innovation likely has meaningful differences from business model innovation.</p><p>Overall, however, we have found it a useful approach to differentiating innovation for the purposes of understanding how best to drive efficient value creation for our clients.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/innovation-framework/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on October 22, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=977517e44e14" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Innovation in Financial Services]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/innovation-in-financial-services-33a6d98f3350?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/33a6d98f3350</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fintech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[financial-services]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Oct 2018 04:41:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-11T10:31:43.010Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q6Nbr7guu3vvPcOEGQBmzA.png" /></figure><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fanchor.fm%2Fdisruptors%2Fembed%2Fepisodes%2FS1-EP6---Innovation-in-Financial-Services-e25cvl&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fanchor.fm%2Fdisruptors%2Fepisodes%2FS1-EP6---Innovation-in-Financial-Services-e25cvl&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fs3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com%2Fanchor-generated-image-bank%2Fproduction%2Fpodcast_uploaded_nologo400%2F686243%2F686243-1531423214935-a083f65bd3f72.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=anchor" width="400" height="102" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/78f3155b0ab5339da05df902c0cad1f6/href">https://medium.com/media/78f3155b0ab5339da05df902c0cad1f6/href</a></iframe><p><em>The financial services industry impacts us in broad sweeping ways, perhaps more than any other industry. And technology is forcing legacy institutions to adapt while juggling massive compliance, security, and legacy platform concerns.</em></p><p><em>In this discussion with Jason Henrichs we talk about how financial services companies can adapt more successfully, leveraging unique frameworks that keep the existing business moving while enabling rapid tests and decision making. We also discuss how various emerging technologies are going to impact financial services going forward.</em></p><p><strong>DI:<em> I know you’re working on several things almost always. What are you up to these days?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> The main thing is I’m co-founder and managing director of a company called <a href="https://www.ftforge.com/">Fintech Forge</a>. We’re a managed service business that helps financial institutions extend their innovation capacity, and we’ve developed a proprietary way of looking at innovation in a highly regulated environment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*9ZMUO_xuhuzDnm51BRJmQQ.png" /></figure><p>Related to that, my partner JP Nichols and I are the co-hosts of <a href="https://breakingbanks.com/"><em>Breaking Banks</em> with Brett King</a>, which is the largest fintech podcast in the world. And we use that platform to talk with innovators and push the evangelism of the need to evolve and better serve our customers with financial services</p><p>Lastly, I am the chairman of <a href="http://www.fintex.org/">FinTex</a>, which is a non-profit industry association growing the financial technology ecosystem in Chicago and the broader Midwest. We try to push both incumbents and startups to build better financial service products that are more inclusive.</p><h3>Innovation and Regulation in Financial Services</h3><p><strong>DI:<em>You mentioned regulatory issues being one of the more unique aspects of financial services. What are some of those challenges or problem, and what are some ways organizations try to navigate that?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> When we think about regulation, it really has three components.</p><p>First is <strong>intent</strong>. What is the intent of this new thing that you’re trying to do?</p><p>The second thing is the <strong>policies and procedures</strong> around how it’s delivered. And the last are the <strong>outcomes</strong>.</p><p>We’ve avoided measuring intent because that requires personal judgment. And outcomes are hard to measure — it often takes a long time to develop.</p><p>So the emphasis from a compliance point of view has been to audit policies and procedures. This leads to the people, processes and technology being optimized around scalability, reliability, and compliance. And as a result they’re very rigid. They’re expected to deliver with 5 nines.</p><p>It turns out people don’t like if you send a wire transfer and it doesn’t arrive. Doing your job 80 percent of the time isn’t going to cut it.</p><blockquote><em>When we think about innovation — doing something </em>new<em> to create value — if you’re doing something new, you have to learn. And learning requires actually having things go wrong, which is the antithesis of optimizing for the highly reproducible five-nines.</em></blockquote><p>So how do you actually build these two organizations that can work together simultaneously? We would never suggest throwing out all of your policies and procedures, regulation be damned. You can’t just treat your existing business like a startup — that doesn’t work.</p><p>When you’re executing your existing business for the types of results that you’ve come to expect, you can predict with high accuracy and high precision — just keep doing what you’re already doing.</p><p>But when you’re looking at something new, you’re probably going to have dramatically difference results. You might have a 50% completion rate, and you’re looking to get it to 80. You need to go do experiments and do things very differently.</p><p>And that’s where our frameworks around doing experiments comes in. We call it <strong>FIRE</strong> building on the forge as an analogy. How do we do Fast Iterative Responsive Experiments?</p><ul><li><strong>Fast:</strong> shorten the time between the discussion and actually having a result that can be debated.</li><li><strong>Iterative:</strong> take the result and you continue to build on it.</li><li><strong>Responsive:</strong> you need to respond to what you learn and it needs to change your mind.</li><li><strong>Experiment</strong>: at least half the time it isn’t going to work as you expect.</li></ul><p><strong>DI: <em>Do you recommend that the team responsible for the core business is also executing on the innovation stuff? Or do you recommend carving out a separate team, like a </em></strong><a href="https://digintent.com/bimodal-it-strategy/"><strong><em>Bimodal IT methodology</em></strong></a><strong><em>, where they have a very different mandate to move fast and break things, they’re measured differently, etc?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> For the majority of institutions, if you’re looking to actually transform your mainline business, disconnecting it completely from that customer-facing experience actually makes it a <em>bigger</em> challenge because you need the customer to be driving what innovation looks like.</p><p>If you’re creating a separate group that focuses on innovation where the mandate is about complete reinvention, we think it’s totally appropriate to create an innovation team that’s completely separate.</p><p>In most organizations, we’ve found it’s very successful if they work in that bimodal mode. They work in the core business, but then they jump in and participate on FIRE teams with very different objectives. It actually becomes a badge of honor to spend time on a FIRE team.</p><p>As an interesting byproduct, people often carry those practices back into the other parts of their job. We’ve found over and over that job satisfaction actually goes up as a result of feeling like they’re doing something new. It gives them a special sense of purpose.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Once you get this team carved out and they adapt to this way of working and they’re moving quickly and they fall in love with that approach, and they want to bring it back in, how do you how do you maximize the likelihood that the organization, when they do kind of get folded back into the mothership, welcomes that change and adapts accordingly?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> One of the important things is the fire team doesn’t actually leave its day job.</p><p>The fact that we’ve asked people to take on more work than they’re already doing, and they consider it a badge of honor and job satisfaction goes up is not what you’d expect.</p><p>But they’re feeling purpose because they’re helping drive change, and they find some other areas where they can either free up time or use time that was being misallocated anyway.</p><p>But remember, these experiments are meant to be as incremental as possible. And the results are being published continuously. The whole idea is to quit doing things that aren’t working sooner.</p><blockquote><em>So that’s part of how we change the cultural stigma around stopping a project. It isn’t failure; pursuing it even though we know it isn’t going to work or meet our expectations would be the failure.</em></blockquote><p>So by publishing those things along the way we can adjust as we go and work with the body of the organization.</p><p>It’s like using your own stem cells to grow your replacement organ. It’s not like a fancy consultant can come in and successfully say, “Here’s your innovation strategy, go execute it and call us when you’re done and successful.” That’s just not likely to be adopted.</p><p>It’s our perspective that the best ideas are by the people who are closest to the business, but what they haven’t had is a toolkit and a governance process for how to actually take ideas and evolve them into what will ultimately be successful.</p><h3>Using Innovation Accounting in Financial Services</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>When you’re teaching a team to think this way, they are probably used to measuring success in a certain way and they’re used to measuring things of a certain size and a certain degree of scale. But when you’re talking about some of the more disruptive stuff, they probably look really small. How do you teach them to understand the definition of success with an initiative like that is going to look a lot different than how you may be used to evaluating success or failure?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> We’ve created several lenses for the executive leadership teams to create innovation portfolios around. Those lenses need to take into account each organization’s individual strategy.</p><p>For some, innovation might be focused on new revenue growth. For others, it might be around expense reduction. So they’re going to be heavily focused on the tactical and the back office and what they’re doing for others. It’s transformation.</p><p>We work with a small bank that is in the Midwest that is not growing. In fact, it’s shrinking. Your ability to take share against competitors in a shrinking population environment is relatively limited. So they’re trying to create a new business unit that is going to act as the banking rails for fintech startups. That’s a transformational lens.</p><p>A lot of what we do is also give them the concept of <a href="https://digintent.com/crafting-the-ideal-innovation-portfolio/">building a portfolio of innovation</a>. You’d never have your retirement tied up in a single place. Likewise, you need to tailor your portfolio to what your strategic objectives are in your portfolio.</p><p>You’d never allocate, the same amount to every single thing. You don’t say, “Hey 25 percent fixed income, 25 percent large gap, 25 percent in small caps, 25 percent in emerging markets. And boom, I’m done.” That might work at some point in your life. But as you get closer to retirement, you’re probably shifting things, but you keep small allocations.</p><p>Artificial intelligence is a great example, especially around doing some of the natural language processing and the ability to translate that into advice, etc. For most institutions, you can’t write a really good business case right now. If you’re dealing with things that are emphasizing learning, you’re either deluding yourselves or it’s just never going to pass the hurdle. So you need to redefine what the hurdle is.</p><p>So using AI as the example, don’t make a huge investment, but begin to play with it a little bit. Invite some companies in that are working in this space, whether that be IBM or a start-up, to just begin to open your eyes. Say, “We’re in the exploratory phase. It’s a small investment. It’s an investment of time.”</p><p>Or you take the next step which is “Hey, you know, is there a platform that we can redraw what the hurdle, redraws what the risk is we’re willing to take?” We call that in our nomenclature your FIRE break.</p><p>And so what’s the risk appetite? What’s the investment appetite? Let’s run an experiment and see what happens. Do customers engage with it? Do they not engage with it?</p><p>You can easily convince yourself to just be a fast follower and wait until someone else is successful. But that is actually really dangerous. The likelihood you will catch up is very low. And you can’t just take this same technology and assume your customers are going to use it because someone else did it. You need to tailor your innovation efforts to your unique strengths, weaknesses, and vision of what you’re trying to become in the future.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>You and I have talked in the past about the Volcker Rule and how that adds some complexity for banks in terms of being able to execute on things that would be considered speculative. Do these innovation initiatives fall under that and, if so, how do people mitigate that?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Volker was specific to investments in terms of financial returns, and some of that’s been repealed. But if we speak broadly around regulation, my view is deregulation isn’t the answer and over-regulation isn’t the answer.</p><p>Regulation is <em>monumental</em>, and here’s how I define a monument.</p><ul><li>It’s normally done in response to something really, really bad that happened.</li><li>It takes a long time to build.</li><li>The only thing that tends to visit the monument afterwards are the pigeons.</li></ul><p>When I say monumental, I really mean it’s like building one of these monuments that becomes overgrown. The problem with that is deregulation says “let’s hold back for as long as possible and see what happens”. Well that tends to be really bad, and so then we overreact and go to the other extreme.</p><p>Dodd Frank’s a great example of this. By the time the bank’s got everything implemented, the world moved much further and faster past it, so we’re creating this backlog of systemic risk.</p><blockquote><em>We work with a state bank regulator. And the regulation they’re using for cryptocurrency is from the pre-civil War era that was created to regulate the interstate transfer of private currency via steam boat. But it’s the only regulation on the books that is applicable in the same way.</em></blockquote><p>We talked about testing and learning in our approach to innovation. I think we need to take a very similar approach in how we think about regulation. We need to not be afraid of trying something not working and taking it off the books and saying, “Nope. No longer applicable.”</p><p>The UK did this with the FCA when they decided they’re going to be the fintech capital of the world. They actually merged all of the agencies, put them into one that only had two arms, and one of those arms is really around looking at how it helps pursue innovation, and cleared the rest out.</p><p>We’re not going to do that in the US any time soon. But there are ways that we can take a more engaged, proactive approach.</p><p>Arizona just passed a fintech sandbox bill. There’s lots of discussion with this idea of an OCC — the office of comptroller of currency — doing a national charter that says not every bank needs to do all of the functions of a bank. This is an important first step.</p><p>It was challenging when the CFPB first came about and I was running one of the first Challenger banks in the world called Perk Street. One of the things they actually did well for as much heat as they take is they would be willing to sit down and have conversations. Historically, regulators have been sort of “Well, we’ll let you know when we come and do an exam and tell you whether what you did was right or wrong.”</p><p>In the post-meltdown world, some of the other financial implications of this — where your auditor isn’t supposed to give you guidance in advance of the audit — is like, it’s almost like having your doctor say, “I can’t give you any advice until you’re sick.” That doesn’t make any sense. Wouldn’t it be better if I didn’t get sick?</p><h3>Innovation sandboxes in financial services</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>You mentioned the innovation sandbox. I don’t know if they’re using the definition of sandbox the same way that you have used it in the past, but for folks that maybe don’t know, can you talk about why you believe having an innovation sandbox inside of an organization is important? And then to the degree that it is relevant and that there is overlap with legislation? How is that either enabling or making it more difficult?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> You hit the nail on the head with part of this when we talked about the financial accounting versus innovation accounting.</p><p>If you take a new endeavor and try to hold it to the same standards of your existing business, it’s not going to match up. This is the innovator’s dilemma by Clayton Christensen — the incumbents have a tendency to over-invest in what they already have because the incremental investment is a lot more certain than pursuing something new.</p><blockquote><em>I like to say the competitive advantage of startups is their desperate. If I don’t figure out how to sell you stuff at a price point that I can make money on I before I run out of money myself, I will go out of business. So they will very quickly develop products that customers want, versus the incumbent will continue to optimize, get that 2 to 5 percent growth, cut out 2 to 5 percent of cost and it works very nicely.</em></blockquote><p>You need the sandbox to say, “OK, we can’t throw all the rules out. We actually just need a different set of rules.” And those are the rules are going to govern the boundaries and expectations.</p><p>I think you’ve heard me use this phrase before around innovation theater. The purpose of innovation isn’t to be like, “I have an idea that. There’s going to be Legos on the tables and it’s going to have all the slogans.” How many companies have you been in that that’s their innovation effort. They use Macs versus PCs, and they don’t actually have any outcomes.</p><p>That’s why our <a href="https://digintent.com/what-is-innovation/">definition of innovation</a> is “doing something new to produce a tangible result”, which is really important because when economies take downturns, that’s when those programs quickly go out of favor, or even before that when the CFO says, “We spent how much on this lab?? What has it produced?”</p><p>It needs to actually have an end in mind in terms of the problem you’re solving, and needs to be making steady measurable progress against it.</p><h3>Measuring the success of innovation initiatives in financial services</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>Do you ever run into a sunk cost issue, where even if they identify success criteria, they run experiments and they don’t hit that goal, but they got 80% of the way there? How do you navigate that gray area there around success and failure?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> I mean, it’s a great question. There is this tendency where no one likes to be wrong, particularly in financial services. If you have a loan officer that has a 5 percent loss in their loan book, that’s going to be an ex-officer.</p><blockquote><em>But if you have an innovation department that has a 95 percent success rate, I will tell you you don’t actually have an innovation department there. Just a group executing on things that are already there.</em></blockquote><p>The flip side is, you can’t just celebrate every failure and say, “Yay, we failed fast.” You actually need healthy tension in the organization to have debates on getting results, even if they weren’t what you were expecting.</p><p>There are three outcomes to one of these experiments.</p><ul><li>I’ve identified another experiment that needs to be done to de-risk this.</li><li>I’ve learned all I can and we should just table it.</li><li>It’s ready to graduate into the mainstream business and we want to actually roll it out much more broadly.</li></ul><p>That should be a spirited debate, and it’s one of the reasons that we take a very strong view on governance. The fire team comes up with what the experiment is and then presents it to the governance group. They’re the ones proposing which of those three outcomes we’re at.</p><p>That’s why we don’t want an over-funded project, because that’s where the inertia comes in, and the sunk costs. It’s one of the reasons we find the CFOs become some of our biggest advocates.</p><p>One of the things we do to help teach this is we’ll take an executive leadership team, and we’ll sit them down to play poker.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Bankroll management.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> It is. Put them on teams instead of individuals. They have to place their back before they see any of the cards. They only get to see what’s in their hand, like typical Texas Hold’em, before they get to see any of the incremental cards. They place their bets and then they’re done.</p><p>Well guess which team wins every single time? It only takes a few hands. But the one that gets to see the incremental cards and can then decide to fold or not fold, they win.</p><blockquote><em>And then we turn around say, “Then why do you run your business this way where you fund a two-year plan to go do this innovation thing? Instead, as part of your standard annual capital planning process, put aside a pool of resources — those are dollars and people — for your innovation budget.”</em></blockquote><p>Don’t allocate it to a specific project, because that’s going to create the inertia you talked about. If it’s fully funded to specific programs, surprisingly it always gets spent.</p><p>My wife works in advertising. Success for her is on time in 98 percent of budget. If they do that, the client is thrilled, except they know what they’re actually spending it on.<br> If your innovation program is like, “Hey, we spent 98 percent of the budget. We spent it on time.” Well that isn’t necessarily success. So you need that ability in-flight to course correct.</p><h3>Unbundling in financial services</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>From a startup’s perspective, where you’re dealing with, not even 800-pound gorillas —</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Trillion-pound gorillas?</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Yeah, exactly. By definition they probably have to take an approach where they take off a small piece of something and try to just focus on that, and maybe over time if they’re successful they can layer additional things. Do you feel like the trend around unbundling happening with financial services customers? Do they want to interact with fifteen or twenty different apps all loosely connects through APIs? Are the days of getting the majority of services through a single monolithic institution over?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> I think this is one of the biggest impacts the iPhone had, other than keeping us glued to the screen for ten hours a day. It’s conditioned us to tailor a whole set of point applications into a single device. People don’t care if they have to flip between five different buttons on a phone to get what they want because it’s highly personalized, right?</p><p>Call it the “app genome” on your iPhone or your Android. It’s highly tailored to you. And you don’t care because it exactly matches your needs.</p><p>You want to tailor your music? Hello, Spotify. You want to personalize your mutual fund? Hello, Betterment. That propagates all the way through our financial lives, particularly as digital allows us to take so much of the friction out.</p><p>That’s actually where too often we just put digital lipstick on the analog pig. We don’t solve the underlying actual experience issues. We just put a digital interface in front of it. So let’s think about your mortgage application. I’m not sure the last time you got a mortgage.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Two years ago. So still relatively fresh.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Yeah, and were you shocked that even though it was more digital, it was still excruciatingly painful and it never made you want to buy or sell property?</p><p><strong>DI:</strong> <strong><em>Yeah. It was still eighty-seven steps. It was lots of e-mails that didn’t tell you anything where you had to log into a special interface due to security concerns. You couldn’t access it via your phone, so I had to wait until I was in front of a laptop. </em></strong><a href="https://digintent.com/how-to-minimize-product-friction/"><strong><em>It was tough from a friction perspective</em></strong></a><strong><em>. If you talk about BJ Fogg’s behavior model — my motivation was sufficiently high where I was willing to overcome all of those issues. But it was definitely tedious and the efficiencies gained from the tech were marginal at best.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> I’m sure someone there was very proudly talking about their all-digital experience. But if you said, “I don’t care about my digital experience I care about my user experience,” it was horrible.</p><p>But look at someone like Rocket Mortgage. They didn’t just make it all digital. They re-plumbed the system and the processes they go through. I don’t care if my existing bank offers me a mortgage unless it’s at a rate that is significantly better if they’re putting that much friction in the process.</p><p>Why do I have to give you my bank statement? You’re my bank. That was my experience two years ago. It makes no sense to have to keep explaining these things. You didn’t actually solve the problem. I’m going to gravitate to whoever can actually solve my problem.</p><p>Now am I going to pay a tremendously higher rate for that? No. But whoever can deliver the most value and just get me through the process as fast and as easy as possible is who I’m going to go to.</p><h3>The rise of robo-advisors in fintech</h3><p><strong>DI:<em> You mentioned transparency. I think about robo advisors and the sarcasm I would imagine financial advisors probably had when it came out that consumers are going to trust a robot more than they’re going to trust you. And then it turns out “Yeah, actually, I do believe that they’re going to do a better job than than Joe who took however much training.” It’s got to be disruptive for them.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Well, look at the three biggest custodians, Schwab, TD, and Fidelity, that sit behind the majority of advisors now all offer their own robos. I don’t think the advisor goes away completely, but their role is changed dramatically.</p><p>How do you build wealth?</p><ul><li>Well, you need to invest consistently, regardless of market going up and down.</li><li>You need to do with a market exposure that is cost efficient from both the fees and the taxes.</li></ul><p>Nothing does that better than a robo does. Except the robo doesn’t have human empathy and understanding the human condition to help you go solve these other things. It’s a joke that John Stein at Betterment and I’ve kind of had as an argument for close to a decade now, which was no one wants to talk to their advisor until they <em>need</em> to talk to their advisor, at which point the machine doesn’t cut it.</p><p><strong>DI:</strong> <strong><em>When you need to be talked off of a ledge. The robo advisors haven’t dealt with a severe market correction yet. It’ll be interesting to see how that unfolds.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> I think we’re going to see the future is going to belong to the cyborg. It’s to be no longer this environment where it’s either all people or all do-it-yourself. Those two things need to blend.</p><p>The ability to charge 1% fees as a financial advisor — those days are quickly waning. They’re going to need to figure out how to do it efficiently. And as compliance and technology costs go up for them. They either need more big clients or to serve a lot more smaller clients. The only way they’re going to be able to do that is through technology.</p><h3>Leveraging data for financial services innovation</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>Have you seen examples of organizations that are leveraging data well, not just sending me a more tailored to e-mail based on my interests, but actually improving customer experience. Is anybody doing that really well?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> There’s a huge advantage to the incumbent because they have the data. They just need to choose to use it differently than they have before, because right now too often they spend all of their time mining for the wrong things.</p><p>I like that they do my fraud protection, but they do a horrible job of learning my actual behaviors. They do very little to experiment with what they can do differently.</p><p>Imagine Amazon. They have a whole host of data about you and they’re really good at mining it to deliver non-intuitive offerings to you just based on the experiences they’ve seen. I don’t know about you, but Amazon recommends something and it wasn’t even something I was searching for, but it’s something I want.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>With financial services, it seems like it would be harder because I’m not trying to change checking accounts or add credit cards on a regular basis, and active investing isn’t necessarily even a good idea.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Let’s just take “active” and cut “investing” and this is where I think so many banks can exist at the user experience level. They’re used to selling you products. If they were to think about selling you actions or outcomes, then suddenly the host of this data and what they can be able to provide you as a service that you’d be willing to pay for is very different.</p><p>Instead of saying, “Hey Sean. Here’s a new credit card for teachers or a checking account that has incremental little value compared to what you had, but I’ll give you 500 dollars to do it.”</p><blockquote><em>What if they were to say, “Hey, Sean, we’re going to help you live a better financial life. We’re going to use this data to help you save more and save in the right places to use credit when you need to, and there’s a monthly fee attached to it. But we’re going to show you based on your history, here’s your trajectory. And here’s how we bend that curve.”</em></blockquote><p>I bet you would pay that, and I bet that you’d be a much stickier customer, and you’d be a much longer term profitable customer, and then they could find products that they could layer in that are better for you.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>We’ve talked internally about some of the relaxing around in accredited investors and some of the things that would theoretically open up. It’s been a little surprising to me that you haven’t seen more offerings tailored to those types of investors through some of the traditional financial institutions. Maybe there are good reasons for that.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> I can tell you what some of the good reasons are. I don’t know if you looked at what bank profits are lately, but they’re at record highs when the cost of borrowing for the bank is practically zero. Slightly above that now, but they just got a massive corporate tax cut and the economy is booming, so you’re not seeing default rates go up and the prices that they can charge are up, whether it’s their commercial or their consumer customers.</p><p>That’s one of our problems with banking — the profitability is driven by debt. What is the spread on how I can get money in versus what I landed out at? We need to rethink that model.</p><h3>Blockchain in financial services</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>Let’s talk about blockchain. In the hype cycle it seems like we’re probably in a trough of disillusionment. There’s been a lot of pilots, but it doesn’t seem like there’s a ton that’s happened in terms of in production applications, either in the private blockchains or otherwise. What are your thoughts on the underlying tech with distributed ledgers? How do you feel about folks’ interest in either providing exposure to tokens or even leveraging their own tokens?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Great question. Lots of parts there — let’s start with the first one.</p><p>Distributed ledgers are not new. They’ve been around for a really long time. And the answer to everything is not always blockchain. Why use a blockchain when you could use the traditional distributed ledger that is cheaper to operate and works just as well. And why you a distributed ledger when it’s actually a database you need?</p><p>It’s so easy to play buzzword bingo. When’s the last time you hired a hammer company? You don’t hire a hammer company, you hire a construction company, and the type of the company you hire is different if you’re building a high-rise or you’re building a house. So why do we throw around the idea of “blockchain companies?” If the problem you’re solving is blockchain, that’s a circular reference.</p><p>Is there a lot of legitimate use for blockchain? Yes. I had the CEO of Currency Cloud on <em>Breaking Banks</em> a couple months ago and we’re talking about the last mile problem.</p><p>The episode is actually titled “<a href="https://breakingbanks.com/episode/solving-the-last-mile/">The Last Mile</a>” on Provoke.fm. The challenge being if you’re solving the middle part of the problem, it’s really painful to get the information in or the information out. If I’ve accelerated the middle part, have I actually solved any of the problem?</p><p>So where I’m seeing the most interesting applications, in particular with blockchain and distributed ledgers, is either being wholly used within a single organization or within closed networks.</p><p>A great example is there’s a very large bank that we spend a lot of time with that is putting all of their treasury management on the blockchain. It is a global bank. So every day they have to reconcile what their risk capital is and what they’re holding in reserve by putting it on an internal version of blockchain. They have to share pieces of this with regulators and with outside audits, and blockchain allowed them to share pieces of it versus everything, so they freed up hundreds of millions of dollars that they already had on their books that now they can actually use for lending.</p><p>Now another company, they use Bitcoin to move money from one country to another and instantly change it back into fiat currency, but it is faster and cheaper for them to do that internally then it is to do a traditional bank transfer.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Seems like there would potentially be like in our even an arbitrage opportunity for them there too. Just because I know that there’s fluctuations in price across borders — that doesn’t sound like the primary reason why they would be doing that, though.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Yeah, that’s one of the things we’re trying to get out it. In the three days that it currently takes me to be transferring money around I’m taking currency risk whether I like it or not. This a way to take the currency risk out as well as the time factor, and they control the transaction completely.</p><h3>AI in financial services</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>What else are you interested in from an emerging tech perspective, either specifically as it applies to fintech or just sort of in general?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> I’m simultaneously fascinated and scared to death of where we’re going with AI. Not in an Elon Musk sort of way, although I can see his point. But I start to begin to question and worry about the moral implications of when we’ve completely abdicated our own sense of ownership over it.</p><p>Yet at the same time, one of the reasons I can’t let it go is I look at the financial situation of the majority of Americans and it scares me and it scares them.</p><p>There’s Pew research that shows 84 percent of Americans say their number-one or their number-two stress is running out of money. And that’s something that’s getting worse, as we take away social safety nets and that stress level goes up.</p><blockquote><em>With AI, we could have a person on your shoulder who answers every question for you. Can you afford that vacation, Sean? Should you be getting this mortgage versus that mortgage?</em></blockquote><p>But the question is, who’s providing that? Facebook reminded us that if you’re not paying for it, you are the customer. I would say I accept that they own all of my information and will be monetizing it some way and I’m fine with that because of what I get out of it.</p><p>But if I’m looking at the ability to bring great advice that alleviates stress to the masses, what are the implications for who owns that and how are they monetizing it?</p><p>What does that mean for us as the individuals — is it being used for good or is it being used for bad? Is it actually taking our own sense of ownership away from us? At the same time, it’s here and it’s not going away.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Are you concerned that we might be widening the income gap? Now the people who are going to have access to the best information or the best machines will have the most data to train on and are able to learn the fastest. We’ll concentrate wealth more than we already have. Is that a legitimate worry or is that less of a concern from your perspective?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> I actually think it might go the opposite.</p><p>One of the most exciting things about financial technology broadly, not just AI, is what used to be either unprofitable market segments or unprofitable products I can now actually bring to the masses.</p><p>The potential for fintech to be one of the greatest drivers of financial inclusivity and hopefully to shrink those gaps — well, I don’t know that you ever shrink the gap completely. But can we close the disparity between the 99 percent up to the last 2 percent in a much better way than we ever have before.</p><h3>Basic Income</h3><p><strong>DI: <em>Do you get involved in conversations around basic income?Are people talking about that with any level of seriousness? Economically, it seems like there’s some problems with that idea.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Are there?</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Logistically, how much money do you have to create to do something like that?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> There have been some economists that have said that it actually could end up saving us money.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Really? Interesting. Where would you recommend reading about that?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Oh now you ask the challenging question. I’ll have to find it for you.</p><p>But this is this is what I would point you to. Do you know that the UN publishes an annual report on happiness — on global happiness. It looks at if you really want to look at the well-being of a country, GDPs are the <em>worst</em> possible measure. They’ve been to several countries with economists who have been pursuing this idea of “gross domestic happiness.”</p><p>One of the things they found is that the countries that do the best on gross domestic happiness are in the Danish region. And what do they have in common?</p><ul><li>They all have universal health care.</li><li>They all have universal free education that’s top-notch.</li><li>They put in place a whole bunch of social safety nets including a version of UBI, and happiness goes through the roof.</li></ul><p>Now you could also argue that the US is hands-down one of the most productive countries and one of the most innovative countries. Don’t we need that pressure to cause innovation?</p><p>Yes, to some degree. I don’t think that necessarily goes away.</p><p>Jeffrey Sachs is the economist from Colombia that leads that UN effort, and he talks about looking at the trade-off. Would you rather have universal misery or trade off some of the fast pace and the innovation — which, by the way, some of it might be moving faster than it should — and generally raise the level of life satisfaction. Is that a trade-off we’d be willing to make?</p><blockquote><em>The beauty of fintech and other technology is the ability to do some of this is going up, and the question will become, “So where you we actually derive the purpose that gives life satisfaction,” which is another key ingredient in the happiness index.</em></blockquote><p>I think personally if we were to shift the stress people feel in their financial lives and replace it with another purpose like family and community and creative endeavors, whether that creative endeavor is something like invention or art or gardening, not only would general happiness go up, I actually think our overall productivity as a society would go up.</p><p>Let’s think about some of the things that are completely unproductive. Well from a financial point of view, the amount of money spent on treatment of illnesses, many of which are based on bad lifestyle choices like obesity, is a lot.</p><p>If people actually had financial incentives to live better lives versus feeling stuck in what they’re doing, or if people had more time to be with family — you know, one of the signs for being at risk is actually the absence of a father figure in the home.</p><p>Can we act on what is one of the biggest drains on society? We incarcerate so many of certain parts of a population that if we can address some of the grassroots issues of this — let’s not talk about prison reform, let’s talk about how we need fewer prisons.</p><h3>The opportunity for fintech to create social good</h3><p>But there’s the opportunity within financial technology to promote financial inclusion and to bring more people into the system.</p><p>With those resources, they can do other things that make the other parts of their life happier and more productive and to me that’s the promise and the number one reason I’m excited about fintech.</p><p>We need innovation, to bring it full circle. If we maintain the status quo of how we approach the world and people’s finances and companies’ finances, that isn’t sufficient for me.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>So for folks who want to learn more about the stuff you’re working on, how can they find you?</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Listen to <a href="https://breakingbanks.com/"><em>Breaking Banks</em></a> at <a href="http://provoke.fm/">Provoke.fm</a> or you can check out what we do at <a href="http://ftforge.com/">Forge</a>.</p><p><strong>DI: <em>Awesome. Jason, thanks for being super generous with your time. I really appreciate it and always learn a ton from you. Thank you for taking the time.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Jason:</strong> Thank you, sir.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/innovation-in-financial-services/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on October 9, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=33a6d98f3350" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/innovation-in-financial-services-33a6d98f3350">Innovation in Financial Services</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Is Innovation?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@digintent/what-is-innovation-18ffde825747?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18ffde825747</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Oct 2018 14:02:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-01T15:20:57.941Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MC6Bhr3tMfTv4GdL7Wpffw.png" /></figure><p>By <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/josephdwyer/">Joe Dwyer</a>, partner at <a href="https://digintent.com/">Digital Intent</a> and Kellogg professor.</p><p>Definitions matter; it’s hard to have effective discussions and build on concepts without them. And the best definitions offer utility.</p><p>Mention the word innovation in a corporate context, and you’re likely to see some eye rolling. The word “innovation” has turned into something of a buzzword whose application is so broad and nebulous that it often feels useless.</p><p>But innovation is critical in the modern economy. That’s why we’re going to come up with a clear and useful definition for innovation.</p><p>For our purposes, a useful definition of innovation probably:</p><ul><li>Has easy to understand tests for filtering</li><li>Reliably filters out the sorts of activities that set corporate eyes rolling</li><li>Rarely excludes things most of us would consider meaningful innovation</li><li>Is brief and simple</li></ul><h3>Various definitions of innovation</h3><p>It won’t take much Googling to see that the definition for innovation varies widely. Here are some paraphrased selections from <a href="https://www.ideatovalue.com/inno/nickskillicorn/2016/03/innovation-15-experts-share-innovation-definition/">an article by Nick Skillicorn</a> based on interviews with 15 innovators:</p><ul><li>Application of ideas that are novel and useful</li><li>It’s about staying relevant</li><li>Great idea, executed brilliantly, and communicated well</li><li>Feasible, relevant offering with a viable business model perceived as new and adopted by customers</li><li>Introduction of new products and services that add value to an organization</li><li>As long as it includes “new” and addresses customer needs, any variation goes</li><li>Fundamental way companies bring constant value to their customers</li><li>Work that delivers new goodness to customers in new markets and radically improves the profitability equation</li><li>Implementation of something new</li><li>Implementation of creative ideas to generate value</li><li>Anything new, useful, and surprising</li><li>… and so on</li></ul><p>There are good concepts in those definitions, but none seem to strike the right balance of clarity, utility, and brevity. We probably need to look elsewhere.</p><p>Webster’s definies innovation as <em>“the introduction of something new.”</em> It’s hard to dispute that’s accurate. But it doesn’t seem particularly useful.</p><p>Perhaps that’s because innovation exists outside of our business mindset. By their definition, introducing a new paint color that’s a half-shade different from any others known in the market is innovation. Most of us would not consider that “innovation,” at least not in a useful way. It might be the absolutely perfect shade for your new house, but I think we need a better definition for our purposes.</p><p>Peter Drucker <a href="http://a.co/d/adkt6MG">said</a> <em>“Innovation is the specific instrument of entrepreneurship… the act that endows resources with a new capacity to create wealth.”</em></p><p>It’s eloquent. The concept of endowing resources with a new capacity to create value is interesting. But still it doesn’t feel like a particularly <em>useful</em> definition.</p><p>Scott Berkun <a href="http://scottberkun.com/2013/the-best-definition-of-innovation/">thinks</a> <em>“Innovation is significant positive change.”</em> That’s starting to sound better to me. He adds the notion of “significance.” If it doesn’t matter (to someone), should we call it innovation? I think not.</p><p>But this definition focuses on the outcome rather than the process. If you don’t know whether something is innovative until after the fact, it’s hard to apply the definition proactively. And while the word “change” implies novelty, it’s probably too broad. What if we’re looking at a change to a well-known business model that results in a loss in stock value but an increase in stability? There’s <em>something</em> novel about that, but it doesn’t feel like innovation to us.</p><p>Tim Kastelle <a href="http://timkastelle.org/blog/2018/01/it-doesnt-have-to-be-the-way-it-is/">writes</a> innovation is <em>“not just having an idea — but executing it so that it creates value.”</em> I like that he incorporates three key concepts: an idea, execution, and value creation. You’ll see below this is probably the closest to our definition.</p><h3>A proposed definition of innovation</h3><p>Here’s how we define innovation:</p><h4><em>“Innovation is the process of creating value by applying novel solutions to meaningful problems.”</em></h4><p>The reason we believe it has utility is in the three explicit tests for “innovative-ness” we can apply:</p><ul><li><strong>Is it novel?</strong> The notion of novelty is baked right into the word “innovation.” If it’s not new, it’s probably more optimization than innovation.</li><li><strong>Does it solve a meaningful problem?</strong> If not, maybe it’s art instead of innovation. That’s not to say art isn’t valuable, but it’s generally not designed to solve a problem. To us, innovation is.</li><li><strong>Does it create value?</strong> If not, maybe it’s an invention rather than innovation. Inventions can lead to value creation, but usually not until someone applies them through innovation.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HiGWlXhlUoCEMCaMj_kbnQ.png" /></figure><p>It also points out that — at least where we’re concerned — innovation is a process. It’s not the result itself per se, but the path to get there. We know it’s possible to innovate unsuccessfully — there’s plenty of evidence that innovations often fail. What’s key is that you’re seeking to create value by applying a novel solution to a meaningful problem.</p><p>According to this definition, innovation isn’t limited to the commercial context. Non-profits can be innovative; their value creation metric is simply different.</p><h3>The Value of Definitions</h3><p>Don’t underestimate the role that definitions and language can play in getting your team on the same page. Even revisiting the way your organization defines this can unlock new ideas and help organizations prioritize initiatives. And it ensures that your team is making meaningful progress toward creating truly innovative solutions.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/what-is-innovation/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em> on October 1, 2018.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18ffde825747" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Growth models: the missing piece in your product strategy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hackernoon/growth-models-66339c778ce3?source=rss-74501dd9165------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/66339c778ce3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[product-marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth-hacking]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Digital Intent]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Aug 2018 16:04:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-31T18:41:28.729Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dihQAEOhfy69k_VZQQNMmg.png" /></figure><p>A growth model is one of the best tools we’ve seen for <a href="https://digintent.com/digital-product-development">product management</a>. It helps you plan for exactly how you’ll get to success. It helps you identify the levers you can manipulate to acquire and keep users. It can tell you whether the expectations you’ve set (or have been set for you) are realistic. And they help you prioritize decisions for what to build or optimize next.</p><p>We first heard about growth models from <a href="https://brianbalfour.com/">Brian Balfour</a>, and they’ve become increasingly common in high growth startups. But we’ve never seen an enterprise product team implement one in our consulting engagements, nor have we seen one when listening to startup pitches at our sister company’s <a href="http://founderequity.com/">venture fund.</a></p><p>Which is unfortunate. Growth models aren’t just helpful when you’re riding a rocket ship. They can be useful pre-product market fit (and even pre-launch) to validate assumptions and provide rationale for how you’re going to get from here to there.</p><p>Here’s how to create one.</p><blockquote><a href="https://digintent.com/growth-model/"><strong>We’ve created a sample growth model you can play with. You can get immediate access here (scroll to the bottom).</strong></a></blockquote><h3>Identify your north star metric.</h3><p>The first step in building out a growth model is to identify the key metric that will determine product success.</p><p>While there will certainly be other metrics you’ll be monitoring, there is tremendous value in identifying a single metric to focus your team.</p><p>A good north star organizes everyone’s thinking. It helps you communicate with your team (or investors, or growth board or steering committee). And in our experience it tends to get teams to move faster since they’re trying to improve one thing.</p><p>A good north star metric is typically a <strong>retention or engagement metric</strong> of some kind. For most products, unless you have solid retention you don’t have a viable long term business.</p><p>It’s important to keep in mind the nature of your customer relationship — you might have a desire for your user to engage with you on a daily basis, but that might not map to their desire. My mortgage company might want me to have their mobile app on my phone and for me to log in regularly, but if I never have to deal with my mortgage company again I’m happy.</p><h4>Some examples of good north star metrics:</h4><ul><li><strong>Daily active users:</strong> good for collaboration apps that are an essential part off my job (email, slack, CRM, etc) or social sites.</li><li><strong>Monthly active subscribers:</strong> good for box model or subscription sites. It sounds like it might be good for SaaS products as well, but it typically is a lagging indicator — ideally there is usage data that you can identify that is predictive of eventual churn if you don’t intervene.</li><li>Marketplace businesses usually have some version of a chicken and egg problem. The answer is usually to <strong>prioritize the supply side</strong> of the equation, as this will lead to the demand side if successful.</li></ul><p>That said, consider the nature of your business. WhatsApp prioritized number of messages sent per day, realizing that they were competing with SMS and had a usage pattern of many times per day if successful.</p><p>LinkedIn for a long time prioritized number of profiles created. While total accounts is usually something that savvy investors would discount (they care about active users, not total users), LinkedIn realized recruiters were how they made money, and recruiters cared about having lots of resumes to search on.</p><h3>Figure out the inputs that lead to that metric.</h3><p>Let’s say you decide monthly actives are the critical metric. The next step is to figure out how to get there.</p><p>The goal is to identify the levers that will get you to your end state. Each of these can be manipulated to increase (or decrease) your north star metric.</p><h4>Acquisition</h4><p>For acquisition, ask yourself what marketing channels you plan to use. What do you think are realistic numbers for each in terms of visits? How do you think you’ll get there?</p><p>Take SEO for example. Often a team will say organic search will be one of the ways they get customers. But how will they get them?</p><p>Well, organic search is a function of the number of keywords you rank for, the search volume for those keywords, and the expected clickthrough rate for ranking in a particular position. It’s also likely that ranking will take time. You’ll most likely be engaging in some content marketing strategy coupled with link building. So how many articles will you create each month? Make a guess on average search position across all keywords. Assume that you won’t show up on page one for a while, and that it will take 12 months at least to reach a top 3 position. What does that look like?</p><p>Again, the point of all this granularity is to help you frame expectations for yourself and your team. “We’ll get users from SEO” sounds great. But without clear assumptions for how you’ll get there you’re stumbling in the dark and likely to create disappointment when you can’t hit those numbers.</p><p>The same should apply to all your other channels:</p><ul><li><strong>PR</strong>: how many articles will you show up in? Can you estimate the average page views for an article on that site? What’s the expected click through rate on an article?</li><li><strong>Paid Acquisition</strong>: what channels will you be using? What’s the estimated audience for each? What’s the anticipated cost per click and clickthrough rate?</li><li><strong>Social</strong>: how do you anticipate growing your audience? What are reasonable numbers for organic reach? How many posts will you be publishing each month?</li></ul><h4>Activation</h4><p>What happens once people land on your site? At DI we talk about activation instead of “user registration” because activation is more predictive of long term engagement, and there’s often a drop off between registration and them engaging in your core experience.</p><p>Identify the steps users have to take between visit to registration, and between registration and activation. Create some estimates for conversion rate for each step (if you have data already, plug that in instead. Try not to throw up.) Now you’ve identified the areas of <a href="https://digintent.com/how-to-minimize-product-friction/">product friction</a> within your product and can work toward reducing them.</p><h4>Referral</h4><p>People often get confused when trying to model out referral. But it’s not that difficult — the key again is granularity.</p><p>Identify every opportunity to refer that makes sense. There are often more opportunities than simple having an “invite friends” screen. For example, lets say I have a collaborative todo list app. I could have an invite screen during onboarding. I could have another one from the dashboard. And I could have an “assign task” flow whenever a new todo is created. Again, take into consideration the nature of the customer relationship. I’m probably not going to send an email to my contacts suggesting they get a mortgage.</p><p>For each, document each step and make assumptions on conversion rate. On the invite screen, the user will send X number of invites on average. X% of users will see the invite and click through. X% of those will create an account, and x% will activate.</p><p>Add those new users to your total activated users. What you’ll quickly see is the power of referral. While it’s rare to have an app that’s truly “viral”, most apps can get some lift from referral. Which drives down your CAC.</p><h4>Retention</h4><p>You have to plan for churn. And for most products, churn is actually pretty steep. Look for baseline metrics for retention 1 month, 3 months, and 6 months later. And build that into your model in the form of cohorts.</p><h3>Don’t be surprised when it looks ugly.</h3><p>Once you’ve documented all this, step back and play with your model. You’re probably going to see that it’s going to take WAY more work than you thought to hit your numbers.</p><p>That’s okay. Kind of like getting your financial house in order, the first step is to confront reality. You’re not going to get on Techcrunch and be staggeringly successful. It’s going to be grind.</p><p>The growth model helps you understand what it’s going to take. It can help you and your team steel yourself for the slog that’s about to come.</p><h3>Use it to manage your team</h3><p>The real power of the growth model is as a management tool. You don’t want to create it once time and then ignore it. As you start executing, plug the results into your model. Adjust your assumptions as you start to capture real data.</p><p>Use the model to prioritize decision making. Whenever you’re discussing a new idea for a feature or <a href="https://digintent.com/success-comes-after-the-launch-the-di-approach-to-iteration-and-analysis/">product iteration</a>, ask yourself which variable in the model is it going to impact and estimate what that impact will be. this can be extremely helpful in seeing which work will have the biggest impact if successful. It can help diffuse conflict around what to focus on (or salespeople who rely on anecdotal data, or a boss that’s typically the loudest person in the room.)</p><p>Use it to set realistic goals for your team. If you’ve decided to prioritize SEO, it’s helpful to show your team how much content they’re going to have to crank out and how many links they’re going to have to acquire to hit their numbers. It can help you be realistic while also creating urgency.</p><h3>Get access to our growth model template.</h3><p>There are few tools we’ve seen that have been more useful for product teams than a growth model. It sounds tedious, and the model will 100% be inaccurate. But the time it takes will be more than worth it in terms of setting expectations, prioritizing the right things, and measuring impact.</p><blockquote>We’ve created a growth model template with detailed assumptions for a fictional product that you can customize to fit your needs. <a href="https://digintent.com/growth-model/">Click here to get immediate access</a>.</blockquote><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://digintent.com/growth-model/"><em>digintent.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=66339c778ce3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon/growth-models-66339c778ce3">Growth models: the missing piece in your product strategy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hackernoon">HackerNoon.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>