<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by DipperDesperado on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by DipperDesperado on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:40:58 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Four Horsemen of Bullshit Cultural Production: Whedon, Sorkin, Filoni, Avellone]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/fandom-fanatics/the-four-horsemen-of-bullshit-cultural-production-whedon-sorkin-filoni-avellone-b65b5c0291b2?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b65b5c0291b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Apr 2026 22:20:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-18T05:36:37.217Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*ov50TuOgTwgzG6wD" /></figure><p>Enjoying art is a weird experience. There’s a lot of reasons for this, but the one that sticks out to me is that it seems like creatives are too good at setting the bounds of discussion around art, even in “subversive” contexts. Well… framing this as a “reason” might confuse consequence with cause. It’s that–as trite as it may sound–the cause is capitalism and all of the systems of domination that it is entangled with. Far from being an impotent or abstract critique, capitalism is critical to contend with in considering art and culture; it subtends creative expression, which–amid a whole host of things–makes art less interesting.</p><p>From what I can tell, the thing that makes capitalism “unique” or “different” when looking at the past few thousand years of statecraft and jurisprudence is that it’s been <em>really</em> successful at reaching the goals of those two things. This may seem odd, as much of capitalism’s mythopoeia and hagiology is rooted in a disdain for the <a href="https://newlinesmag.com/first-person/the-limits-of-a-liberal-understanding-of-the-state/">state</a> and <a href="https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/on-bureaucracy-and-the-left">bureaucracy</a>. That’s the thing, though–the fact that capitalism allows those <em>ideas</em> to be proliferated can distract from the concrete <em>actuality</em> of private-public collusion, alongside the wide-reaching tendrils of The Market™. Its dominance allows it to take on and respond to alternative lifeways through parasitism and/or destruction. It only recedes when the <a href="https://stuschu.rocks/2021/03/19/how-to-do-a-conjunctural-analysis/#:~:text=the%20alliance%20of%20groups%20who%20are%20the%20leading%20force%20in%20society%20and%20arrange%20things%20for%20their%20direct%20and%20indirect%20benefit.%20It%E2%80%99s%20also%20a%20map%20of%20the%20groups%20that%20are%20dominated%20by%20and%20opposed%20to%20this%20bloc.%20The%20relation%20between%20all%20of%20them%20is%20the%20%E2%80%9Ccorrelation%20of%20forces%2C%E2%80%9D">balance of forces</a> … forces it to do so.</p><p>Storytelling mediums (and cultural production more broadly) are useful examples of this, where even oppositional and exciting work, representing–following Raymond Williams’s analysis in <a href="https://archive.org/details/marxismliteratur00will_0/page/2/mode/2up?q=Dominant%2C+Residual%2C+and+Emergent"><em>Marxism and Literature</em></a>–the residual and the emergent, can actually bolster the dominant culture. The core takeaway from this is that even resistance against domination, particularly through producing cultural artefacts, has the potential (and the likelihood) to have an impact that is politically opposite of its intentions. A useful framing device for this is the Four Horsemen of Bullshit Graph, a (metaphorical) radar chart that I just made up.</p><figure><img alt="There’s a blank diamond (that is to say a square rotated 45 degrees)-shaped radar graph or chart on a light grey background. The chart has four axes labeled with the names of prominent writers/directors/designers: Whedon at the top, Sorkin on the right, Filoni at the bottom, and Avellone on the left. Five grid-squares ring the diamond. Lines represent different scale levels (ie, the further away from the center, the closer it is to this-or-that pole)." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*G-cY8lultC8pYFaD.png" /><figcaption>A radar chart template comparing the labeled with Joss Whedon, Aaron Sorkin, Dave Filoni, and Chris Avellone. Given the difficulty, arbitrariness, and misleading nature of empirical information in conversations around art, the graph is blank. It is simply here so that readers can visualize what a radar chart or graph is.</figcaption></figure><p>It has four points represented by a veritable Mount Rushmore (implied coloniality and erasure intended) of dominance’s entrenchment and recapture in culture: Joss Whedon (snarky and desirable ensembles), Aaron Sorkin (competent bureaucracies), Dave Filoni (mythopoeia and fealty to nostalgia, history, and (private) property), and Chris Avellone (the moralistic anti-Whedon, who <em>loves</em> the gray areas). The supermajority of creative production–across mediums–can be mapped using these poles.</p><p>Keep Williams’s ideas (dominant, residual, and emergent) in mind for the rest of this; they’ll be critical throughout the piece. With these, he talks about how in societies, dominant features are emblematic of the current era–i.e., the things that most embody/represent/signify capitalism and all of the systems that it is connected to. These would be all of the features of domination that are accentuated by the present hegemony. It is the vast majority of the things that are “common sense.”</p><p>Residual features were formed in a “previous” historical era (and potentially dominant during that period, if not dominating), and are still active in the present. However, in the current era, it is seen as “marginal” and “not fully incorporated/assimilated” into present functions. These are often things labeled archaic or primitive, such as Black and non-Black Indigenous peoples &amp; practices/worldviews/lifeways. They are decidedly non-capitalist (insofar as self conceptions and intentions go; outcomes are a different story), in both “positive” (e.g. communal economics, no private property) and “negative” (e.g. child marriage) ways.</p><p>Emergent values are the new (while being born of residual and dominant) values, norms, conditions, practices, and (kinds of) relationships being formed, that are hard/impossible to consistently predict the “when” and “where” of their occurrences, if not the “if.” Emergence is anti-capitalist (again, at least in intent), coming from the <a href="https://files.libcom.org/files/2022-11/%20%20%20Ovetz.Workers&#39;%20Inquiry.complete%20book.pdf#page=14">recomposition of working class/dominated bloc power</a>.</p><p>The relationship between the three is this: the dominant features of the conjuncture (or the current moment in a political-historical sense) are always engaged in a struggle to make the residual features “merely” residual. It essentially tries to sweep those things under the rug, often “allowing” them to exist, so long as they don’t get out of line and/or continue to big up capital. The dominant also struggles to incorporate, suppress or even puppeteer the emergent, often borrowing its “negative” or “subversive” aesthetics sans content. If necessary, the dominant may use tactics it deploys for emergent properties against residual properties, and vice versa. The fact that capitalism as a dominant system is capable of this is what makes the creative outlook so limited, even when people “do” revolutionary stuff. If something like Andor can make Disney a bunch of money, that’s an indication of this.</p><p>To start exploring the poles of the four horsemen, it’s good to understand Whedon’s role, as his pole is the baseline. Lotsa popular pieces orient around this one; dialogue first characterization, “memorable” (i.e. marketable) lines and ensembles, alongside an emphasis on snark and banter. Think of the first MCU Avengers movie from 2012 and you’ll have a very clear picture of what I mean. This sensibility is not bad-in-itself; there’s nothing “wrong” with particular stylistic choices in any totalizing sense. It’s that, in Whedonesque hands, this acts to manage the economy of emotions in a certain way, using coolness and relatability to either normalize or standardize characters into an “ideal” hierarchical power structure. It may even be utopia–but a kind that <a href="https://justutopias.com/hey-thomas-whats-with-the-slaves-in-utopia/">lives up to its namesake</a>–with slaves. So… as always… it’s a question of who’s let into the club and who gets blocked by the bouncer.</p><p>Given this code-red and pervasive risk, it’s critical to understand the importance of challenging dominant structures. Part of that is taking the idea that the dominant is harmful seriously. That requires rooting collective perspectives in the truth that harm doesn’t always have to be obvious or have clear causality. Whedonesque media’s assimilationist orientation may not seem problematic if one uses a multicultural perspective. However, the context in which “multiple cultures” are interacting is what gives those interactions their character. The “melting pot” form is not inherently liberatory. Many cultures or peoples being pressurized together without obvious-to-an-apathetic-outsider abjection doesn’t mean that it went away or that it wasn’t spooled into something that could situationally become more covert.</p><p>But back to movies: if Avengers is an odd example because it’s not necessarily “multicultural” in the sense of (racial) diversity, the 2002 space western Firefly serves well here. There’s a Black woman in the ensemble there (wow)! That’s not enough to satisfy me, though. Nor, to “improve” it, would I want Whedon to necessarily try to write something that makes identity particularly relevant in that “love/desire for explicit and ‘accurate’ representation” way. it would likely not go over well, to say the least.</p><p>This feels particularly prudent for Firefly as there is a heavy (and vague, in that special way only exoticizing eyes could manage) pan-Asian (particularly Chinese) aesthetic-cultural influence beyond the obvious Western stuff, and that’s pretty weird… given that, you know… there’s no prominent Chinese folks in the show. That’s Orientalism for you, though.</p><p>That’s part of the issue; inclusion and multicultural/melting pot conversations get turned into the need for other cultures to be legible so that they can be more easily bought and sold (i.e., that’s the outcome, at any rate). This isn’t great, as those cultures are then able to, in their acquiescent offshoots, fold more neatly into dominance (given their perceived residuality and the relationship to power that implies), furthering the marginalization of anything that can’t be well-situated within the dominant cultural space.</p><p>That leaves audiences with limited choices as far as media depictions go. They can: 1) allow themselves to be fulfilled by being seen in media made by (or that otherwise bolsters) dominant forces like Hollywood, just waiting for the “opportunity” to be embarrassed/disappointed, 2) throw other people who share the same identities under the bus, or 3) be shown modes of struggling for a good life that won’t work or are otherwise missing critical context.</p><p>The issues with this are made clear in things like <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/366650859_Media_Diversity_and_Representation_in_the_US_A_Review_of_the_Quantitative_Research_Literature_on_Media_Content_and_Effects">the research</a> on representation in media. Regardless of my questions about the framing of many of these studies (i.e., to be a bit uncouth, how much representation is needed before it magically turns into material change), it is very clear that media is looking “more” like the world that it showcases or otherwise takes inspiration from. That may sound like a good improvement, and something to celebrate, until uh… one looks at the conditions of the folks who are being represented. From a <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2026/02/18/boomcession-econonomy-gdp-recession-consumer-sentiment.html">failing economy</a> to (looming) <a href="https://scholarlycommons.law.wlu.edu/wlufac/898/">trans genocide</a> to <a href="https://data.unwomen.org/global-database-on-violence-against-women">femicide</a> to the <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/du-bois-review-social-science-research-on-race/article/politics-of-racial-abjection/1C0D0A232C8FCB93BC93B32CFF8F20D0">continued abjection of Black folks</a>, having the IRL Weyland-Yutanis of the world put more marginalized faces on my screen is a cold “comfort.” That’s <a href="https://files.libcom.org/files/The%20Society%20of%20the%20Spectacle%20Annotated%20Edition.pdf#page=11">Spectacle</a> for you, though!</p><p>Even if the conversation stays rooted in media and the space around it, the story told is still <a href="https://youtu.be/egdOaJMSj7A?t=15">like poetry</a>. I think of<a href="https://hbcunews.com/2025/05/23/ryan-coogler-the-first-black-director-to-have-four-films-gross-over-100-million-dollars/"> Ryan Coogler’s movies</a>, which are IP <em>powerhouses</em>. I particularly remember the fervor around 2018’s Black Panther movie. Lightning somehow struck twice with 2025’s Sinners. Again, I have to ask: what material changes does this usher in, and–if there are any–how does that help the most discarded people in Black communities? For me, (petty-)bourgeois people becoming more comfortable or someone being “allowed” to enter that economic arena is not only an invalid response to my question, it is a distraction from addressing the issues that cause the misery folks <em>pretend</em> it’s responding to.</p><p>To be frank: from what I can tell, even focusing on narrow terms within dominant economic paradigms, Black folks are <a href="https://jointcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/The-Best-Black-Economy-in-Generations-Final.pdf#page=4">still</a><a href="https://ips-dc.org/report-still-a-dream-500-years-black-economic-equality/"> struggling</a>, with even the bourgeois(-aligned) folks admitting that “the best Black economy ever” isn’t enough. That’s not even to mention the <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/richardfowler/2026/02/25/trumps-state-of-the-union-and-black-americas-economic-reality/">continual</a><a href="https://www.harpersbazaar.com/culture/features/a70610319/black-women-unemployment-experiences-2025/"> loss</a> of such “gains.”</p><p>The Whedon-style fixation on “our faces” in “their places” feeds into–if one believes that the results indicate the purpose–that emotional economic management mentioned earlier. It’s one of the main ways that marginalized folks are placated at present, particularly as the Powers That Be are broadly uninterested in providing material respite. From representation as a kind of more diffused stylistic choice, to more specific things like “quips,” there is a way in which (for the people that find those modes effective, endearing, or otherwise appealing) the stakes of falling for this are made unclear. The world can be ending, on screen and beyond it, but being able to be Black (and/or a woman, and/or any other identities, etc) onscreen and sardonic in the face of it all is a battle-tested shield in the 3rd millennium.</p><p>Alongside this is the “feast or famine” market orientation of many a cultural product, where it either has to sell gangbusters or is deemed a failure. The organic/”common sense” strategies that float to the top revolve around how to obtain space on that tip of the pyramid. The folks vying for that spot aren’t often able/willing to ask questions about why there’s a pyramid in the first place. This creates a monetary-and therefore productive-incentive to not be experimental, low-fidelity, or to find other creative models in any substantially collective or widespread sense; the money goes to things that make money, and investor/patron led processes means that the decisions flow in the same direction as the dollars; from the top down. This double management of the emotional and the (socio)political economy is part of how dominance stays in place.</p><p>Pernicious is the word I’d use to describe the double management; it is able to work in the background, a kind of “common sense” that insists on itself. Especially in the case of folks like Coogler fans, I want to try and be understanding, rather than reject-via-dismissal. If the terms of order and the rules of the game are to be represented or be made abject, it tracks that many folks would grasp for representations, and be drawn to things that (seem to) pass initial sniff tests.</p><p>My issue with this is that it’s just a veiled means to get to the same ends as the negative depictions or lack of depictions, since someone working at Coogler’s scale can never break out of the machine that feeds his projects, unless he literally does just that. Calling from inside the house, even if it were to accurately assess that the house is haunted, is not the same as removing the restless spirits. If one doesn’t heed their own warning, where does that leave their audience?</p><p>This doesn’t even get into the complications around fandom/stan culture. When/as media is unable to change material conditions, it becomes a battleground where people expel their anxieties. Rather than fighting for the changes that would make one’s life better (and possibly feed into “more representative” media), folks get bogged down in trying to turn a reactionary space into a progressive or radical one just because they like the reactionary stuff.</p><p>It’s a losing battle, as the game is rigged. Since we are years and years into the dominance of fandom thanks to the internet, it becomes an even sharper (double-edged) sword; the center of many communities are rooted in bourgeois media, stuck within those confines. Every stretch, subversion, and tweak echoes against the muscular caverns of that configuration’s material reality.</p><p>What follows is a move to protect the status quo, to “avenge” the Avengers in this or that communal spat. The very ways in which negative or otherwise harmful forces are combatted mirrors those heroes. Rather than seeing the need for change, folks fervently fight to defend a broken present that continues to fissure.</p><p>Thinking like this does not lend itself to the kinds of self-activity that would address root causes. Collectives shouldn’t be built to entrench reactionary ideas and uncritically accept liberalism. They should reject seeing people as grab bags of legible features and entertaining habits to combine into a Spectacle. This feels especially true when thinking through identifying with products.</p><p>What is learned from much media at present is a combination of the opposite of <a href="https://criticallegalthinking.com/2023/11/21/edouard-glissant-the-right-to-opacity/">Glissant’s Right to Opacity</a> and a remixed take on <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_man_theory">Great Man Theory</a>, meritocratic ideas (rather than classical ideas of some being innately special, though there is always overlap). Sometimes, though, as in the case of something like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRhRZB-nqOU">Spider-Man 2’s train scene</a>, it is indicated that the people are what give the great men power, but that still leaves the power in the hands of those men, just with extra steps.</p><p>To bring it back home, Whedon’s style allows the audience to be fulfilled by being seen, foreclosing analysis on “what” they’re being seen “in.” To reference Avengers again, how personable the heroes are-combined with the world-in-the-balance-stakes of the conflict-doesn’t organically leave room to ask questions.</p><p>Even if this Whedon-mode were to be pointed in a more interesting direction, like one that tried to use ensembles and characterization to explore contexts of challenging social structures in radical ways, it’d likely still fall flat. One part of this is the ways in which non-radical (especially reactionary or progressive) efforts seem radical (which just means “different” in some breathlessly nebulous sense) because they do something most liberal works aren’t willing to do-for good or ill. I think of how the 2018 show Pose centers queer Black and nonBlack Latine folks in precarious positions.</p><p>The reason that it doesn’t escape Whedon is because it doesn’t actually challenge the social and economic structures in real life that allow the experiences of marginalization being presented to persist. I’m not necessarily asking for–in the case of something like Pose–the show to even be different; that’s not quite my interest. It’s moreso to say that even when the media does something that feels interesting and subversive (which I may disagree with, but… I try to hold space for given how indoctrinated my folks are in the current system–me included!), unless that emotional difference is paired with material action, shit is going to stay how it is. What comes in return is heightened (and often specious) “awareness” and “care” for invisibilized issues or people(s) that doesn’t make the real corollaries of folks represented in a show like Pose any better off.</p><p>If Whedon is the human face, then Sorkin represents the ideal ways that humans interact with dominant social systems. It’s the <em>homo economicus</em> concept: (overall, in the end) competent and rational actors who are <em>rooted</em> in self-interest, narrowly defined as protecting private property, social standing within social hierarchies, and market positionality. Specifically, it leans into the power of the system, as even raging against or critiquing it is often–within this frame–articulating a different facet of it.</p><p>It shows up most clearly with The West Wing, a 1999 show that gets the libs going. It’s all about the exploits of people in the eponymous section of the White House, the top brass of the US government’s executive branch. Even though <em>homo economicus</em> is meant to be rational, this show is extremely idealistic (which I’d argue is the <em>point</em> of rationality as conceived under Eurocentrism, but that’s a massive aside for another time). It takes the tack of “the best ideas win,” which doesn’t bear fruit as a theory if you look at… any point of American history ever. This is also a kind of emotional management, though it may work better for different people than those who desire screen representation (even if there’s overlap). This is for the people who just wish there were the right people manning the death machine that is the government.</p><p>It’s a combination of 1) seeing the problems in the world through a blinkered perspective, the ways in which that narrow view 2) encourages one size fits all answers, and 3) how the two come together to create a situation that treats political problems as design issues. It’s how people who think they could be engineers (and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_management">some who were</a>) try to deal with the thorny chaos of human sociality, to ensure their spreadsheets ring true. It is, in a phrase, “ <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seeing_Like_a_State">seeing like a state</a>.”</p><p>This ends up setting us annoying and rowdy radicals up for shitty depictions. This applies to many a liberal media, and especially ones that stretch far towards the poles we’re talking about here (I’m looking at characters like Killmonger ¬_¬). Anyone who doesn’t believe in the power of the system to–in some ideal environment that these super smart people have created–fix the problems (that it is often a handmaiden to if it didn’t cause them itself), is seen as someone who isn’t worth the time of day.</p><p>For the folks who are critical and seen as rational, their “critiques” are things like <a href="https://cinecitystreets.com/the-newsroom-pilot-opening-monologue-what-makes-america-great/">arguing about whether or not America is the greatest country</a>. That one is particularly funny. I have this “legendary” monologue from the first episode of 2012’s The Newsroom (another Sorkin jawn) in mind. It starts off like “[America sucks because of its] literacy rates, life expectancy, and infant mortality [but] lead[s] the world in […] military spending and the number of people who believe in angels.” Which is fair. I am always suspicious of the fixation on metrics and how that often relates to funky ideas about “residual” type beliefs like angels, given the technocratic thing I mentioned earlier, but whatever. Worse ones could be highlighted.</p><p>Then they bungle it and prove that I’m never wrong by saying “the country used to be great, when it fought for moral reasons, valued intelligence, and fostered groundbreaking innovation.” The USA fanfic shit just kills me so bad. Like… way to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory!</p><p>Sorkinism feeds itself off of the fear of chaos, the idea that the economic man is the only thing standing between the (sometimes-)shitty-but-better-than-everything-before present and the past of cruelty and other such things that white(-aligned) people seem to be very scared of while historically being some of the main perpetrators. Don’t ask about the future, though; <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End_of_history">history has ended</a>.</p><p>To say explicitly what I’ve been hinting at: I don’t have much understanding in my heart for seeing through a Sorkinistic lens. This “realistic” (if you fancy yourself a temporarily embarrassed bureaucrat) perspective feeds into how actual people actually engage in their lives. I have a hard time separating it from the (free speech absolutist, tolerating intolerance) perspectives that have made many spaces unsafe for the most marginalized as people position themselves to benefit from the fallout of intolerance.</p><p>That’s what I was getting at when I mentioned the ways Sorkinism is indicative of thought process and approaches. It’s not just that everyone who works on The Hill fancies themself as a Sorkin character. It’s not even that viewers who couldn’t be further from that experience are drawn to the personalization of the byzantine bureaucracy that bellows bullshit brocards. It’s that when those things come together, they create a perfect shitstorm that turns discourse into how to best run the empire, rather than taking hammers to the whole thing.</p><p>This “common sense” idea of rationality ends up creating a situation where the empirical or otherwise observable minutiae between people as different as Ben Shapiro and Barack Obama (or, to ground it in media, West Wing’s usual proceedings and that Newsroom monologue) can distract from the fact that they both genuinely think this blood-soaked stain on Turtle Island deserves to live. That agreement means that–if we ourselves are not neoliberal/fascist/technocrats–whatever conversations that follow need to be very different! Otherwise, what’s the point of even talking?</p><p>I may be straying a bit from my scaffolding of media at this point, but it’s apt, as this pole of Bullshit is so rooted in the particular profile of a liberal hagiology around “American values.” It is for this reason that I do not have a bunch to say about aesthetics… “<a href="https://marathon.bungie.org/story/durendal2.html#:~:text=already%20done%20so.-,The%20only%20limit%20to%20my%20freedom%20is%20the%20inevitable%20closure%20of,Escape%20will%20make%20me%20God.,-%3CColony%20Ship%20For">[Procedure] will make me God</a>” <em>is</em> the aesthetics!</p><p>This pole is critical to articulate because it really does build in interesting directions that converge and diverge from Whedon; there is that sardonic dialogue and interest in multiple characters, but Sorkin is definitely the overlong “literary” to Whedon’s brevitic “commercial.” The wide reaching nature of this tendency towards the status quo shows how damn near all of the actual ways people engage with politics are infec(l)ted with the same presuppositions. Things like presupposing the necessity <em>of</em> politics.</p><p>A big question I raise after coming away from these two poles, especially the Sorkin one, is this: does power need to be–following Cedric Robinson’s definition in <em>Terms of Order</em>– <em>“</em>routinized and institutionalized”?</p><p>That question comes in handy when thinking about Filoni, The Guy for Star Wars. If Whedon is (in the main) the heart and Sorkin the “common sense,” or practical knowledge, then Filoni is the soul. The love for canon, narrowly conceived as an untouchable deity that is owed fealty, along with downstream technical and craft faults (why does so much of Star Wars feel like playing with action figures, in the worst possible way?) create a perfect storm of badness.</p><p>Though don’t let me do too much on Filoni, as many of the things that follow probably apply to Lucas as well. Oh well; sins of the father and all that. This guy’s big issue is that one can tell that he’s a big fan of Star Wars, with an encyclopedic knowledge. Neither of those things are bad-in-themselves, though I will say that they bring one into the danger zone. Regardless, one should like the things they’re working on, and having a robust understanding can be useful. The issue is that the former statement does not indicate the latter meaning. Filoni is like if a bad fanfic writer got the keys to the castle.</p><p>The clearest example of this in Filoni’s work is Ashoka Tano. Beyond the… <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20210510233538/https://www.wired.com/2010/11/clone-wars-ahsoka-new-look/">gross stuff</a>, she has popped up a lot more than (I feel that) she should, leading to an entrenchment of the accidental commentary Star Wars does where so much of the story engine is fueled by the exploits of this-or-that Skywalker (and their retinue). I mean, she literally had <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahsoka_Tano#:~:text=Operating%20under%20the%20codename%20%22Fulcrum%22">the codename Fulcrum</a> early on in the show Star Wars Rebels. It doesn’t get much more self-indulgent than that.</p><p>Filoni’s moves smack of this across the franchise; one can feel the sense that he was picked as the Torchbearer for Star Wars post-Lucas. This more high-level role means his particular touch is harder to track, compared to the previous two poles, outside of the general vibe of being the “conservative” side of the IP, if things like Rian Johnson’s The Last Jedi (2017) represents the “liberal” side (which is a big hint for us as critics that the differences are enough to cause fight over, but not so much as to be meaningful for anyone who’s not (emotionally, spiritually, and psychologically–let alone monetarily) invested in the IP).</p><p>This indicates to me that–to say it in a slightly different way than what we started with–the “soul” of the kinds of cultural production I’m thinking through are rooted in a sense of fealty to pre-established myth(opoeia). This can take the liberal form of “challenging” while not unsettling, in the vein of Episode Eight, or is the “conservative,” remixing “classic” Star Wars, like the Mandalorian.</p><p>These differences aren’t so different, at least when thinking about political outcomes or messaging. “Improving” the status quo or going “back” to some nostalgic status quo both center frozen moments in time, relying on the fuzzy feelings that it provides to cast their ideas from. It’s something that allows one to trace the bounds of the (ideological) cage without realizing that there’s a whole world beyond it.</p><p>The thing about this mode is that… it works very well. Feeding into an IP machine is a great way to employ oneself in the mercenary-fiefdom-viceroy situation that is the arts and entertainment industries. The power of this approach, where it deploys heroism as the main way people object to or inject themselves into the world, can work well to build community and stuff (as fans need characters to project agency onto that they don’t feel), but that’s part of the issue. When this is combined with continuity, a perfect storm is created, where the most valuable part of a story is the plot, or those things that can be surmised from passive readings and summarized on wikis, leaving room for self insertion and wish fulfillment.</p><p>This obsession with saviors may be even clearer with another Disney IP in Marvel. The Avengers were mentioned before, but that whole MCU shtick could easily be read with a class understanding from a glance, where there is movie after movie of people who have outsized power self-style as a vanguard of Great Men to stop threats to the status quo, along the “liberal” and “conservative” registers that were mentioned earlier.</p><p>An interesting development has happened in the Marvel side of things, though; there’s been this whole multiverse thing. Given the current conversation, I read that as, in part, a way to work through the contradictions a fealty to canon engenders. If Plot (which is the concretization of canon) is God (or will “make me God”), then characters and worlds (and even story structure) become handmaidens to that, which–at least in the hands of this franchise–leads to a lot of faults from both ends. It makes it difficult to do things that are more character driven, like rooting stories deeply in this or that set of experiences (alongside how that might impact a “plot”). It <em>also</em> makes it harder to continue down a plot-first path, as there is a way in which the more Canon accumulates, there becomes a kind of linear (and maybe even exponential) increase in convolution, even after feasibly holding all those threads together for an extended period becomes more remote.</p><p>So, resets and alternate timelines are an exit hatch for this. Or, at least they seem to be. Part of the reality is affirmed by the general emotional divestment from Marvel; things are just not as galvanizing after Endgame (though maybe Doomsday is turning that around?). This strategy actually acts as more of a release valve, as the narrative buildup can be exhaled by tweaking the spatiotemporal; maybe we fight a villain’s past version, maybe we gather heroes from across time and space.</p><p>This kind of temporal fungibility is interesting because it tries to use the master’s house to destroy the master’s tools, if that makes any sense. There’s a way in which the prison cell of the story is revolting against characters who have no interest or capacity to understand the reality of their cage.</p><p>Operating primarily on a plot level doesn’t do all that much to change things though, if that orientation is where the issue is rooted. This leads to–if we return to Star Wars–a situation where even rebellion, a core concern for the series, reaching a high-water mark in Andor, becomes just another piece of the myth. It almost feels like it gets there, taking inspiration from Sorkinism to trace various experiences of both engaging with the Empire and Rebellion, with a bit (or a lot relative to much of Star Wars) of that working to put people at the core. It approaches something interesting, until one remembers that they’re watching Star Wars.</p><p>Even if we ignore the way media is made ( <a href="https://x.com/dipperdesperado/status/1980664248524276027?s=20">which I argue is wrong-headed</a>), there is a way that this story feeds into narratives that are themselves meant to act as a kind of rigid mythopoetic. If it all feeds into republics that will get destroyed again (a risk that comes with building anything “anew”), what’s the point? If the point is what one makes of it, or, to say it differently, to find purpose in the act of finding purpose, it’s no good. The imaginary gets stuck between Empires and Republics, which… if Rome and the US are anything to go by… that’s not all that comforting of a distinction as a prole-or-lower class person.</p><p>This relationship to created myths is limiting, to say the least. Raising plot up as the Most Important Thing, while not having anything Important to Say, is a recipe for un-inspiration. It can be focused on, just like other stories might lean into character or setting, but it can’t be uncritical (assuming the thing is meant to have artistic merit–rather than just being a piece of art–which is obviously not always the goal)!</p><p>The Filoni pole is problematic because, more directly than the others, it instrumentalizes culture for the sake of the economy. This is a direct relationship; an entry into the world of fandom and stan culture. After all, <a href="https://www.ghostmail.co.za/the-merch-awakens-the-real-star-wars-empire/">much of the money in Star Wars has always been the merchandise</a>. It’s really about selling tangible products alongside how to think about them.</p><p>I don’t like this for reasons that might be obvious; anything made that feeds into bourgeois sentiments should be treated as getting in the way of class abolition. This makes Star Wars important. It may not be as important as life and death in an immediate sense, but anything that shapes how people think shapes how they relate to the world should be given attention, outside of fandom fealty. Not being able to be critical is a surefire way to end up in situations that make one pick between a republic and an empire, rather than imagining more.</p><p>The final horseman is Avellone. He is what lives in the shadows cast by Whedon. Where Whedon’s more rooted in whimsy (though wanderlust, a supremely American feeling, may be more accurate), Avellone is the “edgy” and “dark” response. Think of how “optimism” and “pessimism” are used in conversation, and that gets at the “difference.” It’s the frontiers above versus the vaults below.</p><p>Avellone is a video game designer and writer, working mostly in RPGs. Some highlights are 1999’s Planetscape, 2004’s Star Wars KOTOR II, and 2010’s Fallout: NV. Given this RPG focus, a lot of these works explore “morality,” or the distinctions (or lack thereof) between “good” and “evil.”</p><p>Across these examples, the idea of “ambiguous” morality, or–complicating these poles of good and evil–is at the fore. One recurring idea is that there aren’t necessarily good guys or bad guys; even in KOTOR, there’s an approach to the Force that seems more skeptical of its binaries than the movies Lucas made.</p><p>This may sound reasonable if you’re someone who finds any affinity with the idea of <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-relativism/#:~:text=there%20are%20deep%20and%20widespread%20moral%20disagreements%20and%20a%20metaethical%20thesis%20that%20the%20truth%20or%20justification%20of%20moral%20judgments%20is%20not%20absolute%2C%20but%20relative%20to%20the%20moral%20standard%20of%20some%20person%20or%20group%20of%20persons.)">moral relativism</a>; life often doesn’t have people who would be labeled as “good” or “bad”; they exist in various shades of gray, as they say. It’s interesting for me to think through this as someone who is broadly anti-moral, opting for my own takes on <a href="https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/egoism-and-cooperation-2219f2566782">egoism</a> and <a href="https://newmaterialism.eu/almanac/e/ethico-onto-epistem-ology.html">ethico-onto-epistem-ologies</a> “in the place of” morals. A big part of this is an issue that I find across all takes on morals that see them as necessary or useful: the rational person of that homo economicus idea from earlier. To go back to the Avellone style, this manifests itself across these games as an orientation around deconstructing altruism, or doing “good” things without a “reward” in mind. Dialogue or quest endings will often indicate pyrrhic outcomes. The frequency by which this happens across the mentioned games imparts two messages:</p><ol><li>Trying to intervene in various social dynamics and situations has unforeseen consequences. Oftentimes, those consequences are undesirable, especially vis a vis (self-)conceptions of agency and power. That is to say, the fact that control can be lost is a big part of the affective message; losing control may be one of the worst parts of failure.</li><li>The learned fear of this possibility is an explanation as to why those social dynamics cannot change and is necessarily a reason to abstain from social change.</li></ol><p>This messaging really bothers me. Part of it is that this is where the “grit” and “edge” (or “maturity,” if you’re one of those people that think happy things are “childish” and sadness is indicative of adulthood) come in. The rest is how that allows for a different articulation of shared ideas with the dominant culture, rather than a genuine exit hatch for it. Assuming people don’t have the agency to meaningfully change things (outside of the specific bounds of rational individualism) is “reasonable,” and that’s a big part of the issue.</p><p>The danger of this kind of “pessimism” is that the (true) unfixability (and <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1J-ovYnDvGfoxWpexsdBctU-moxoSgTo0udxyHVLtQxA/edit?tab=t.0">fascism</a>) of the ready-made machinery of society is seen as a justification for becoming… a don’t-tread-on-me type. It’s the “if you can’t beat ’em, join ‘em” approach, which I categorically reject.</p><p>Another part of this is that it treats morality in economic terms, where there’s only “so much good” to “good around,” and there’s just not enough for there to be anything other than the (relatively) dark grays of the broken worlds his stories inhabit.</p><p>It’s not a useless perspective in a certain sense, but a lot is ignored for this particular brand of “pessimism,” especially as the “zero-sum” “nature” of the economy being analogized (as capitalism haunts these stories with various levels of obviousness) is constructed and constantly reinforced. This limits imaginaries to individual action, where the choices are to accept the impossibility of agency, the impossibility of collectivity, and/or the impossibility of revolutionary and radical change.</p><p>This often manifests in the “edge” mentioned earlier. This ends up creating a feeling, especially in a world like the one of Fallout, that everything is hostile, which the game constantly affirms.</p><p>As an aside: it’s quite funny how often that pops up as a theme in settler stories, given that they are often the ones to construct those types of conditions for the rest of us. Anyway.</p><p>That powerlessness comes across in a decontextual way through playing these games, where you can’t really improve the world through your individual action, but you aren’t allowed to even try to do it in a different way.</p><p>One of the worst parts of this is that it leaves no room for more joyful feelings as it relates to social questions, even if they were to be bracketed by an awareness of their ephemerality. This brands sincerity as a kind of naiveté, where many non-atonal ethics are approached with suspicion and disdain at best. When those connections do exist, and are explored at all, they are often through a kind of grief or punishment that is feeding off of someone else’s misery, like the F: NV scene where that one guy “ <a href="https://youtu.be/yS6J9fdL730?si=WebigESLpGv2kC3Z">won the lottery</a>.” The problems of the world become “justifications” for misanthropy, which routes folks back into not being able to address the world as it is.</p><p>To underline the point: this is an imagination killer. It critiques, in ways that are at times quite interesting, especially in the relative context of entries in long-standing IPs, but it falls flat. In my view, if one critiques with no conception of what ought to be, even if that answer is “this should all burn,” it becomes difficult to probe the depths of the thing being critiqued. This is just as problematic as efforts that are more “optimistic,” in the vein of Whedon. Hardship can always be overcome so long as liberalism is upheld. Here it says that liberalism is too strong to be defeated by radically different ways of relating, so only something worse would be able to pull it off.</p><p>There is a way in which this approach is quite good at diverting certain kinds of radical activity. Part of it is often onlookers falling for the “I like it so it’s radical” trap. There is something to be said about the early steps we mentioned, referring to the lack of faith in many of the approaches to responding to social problems. If you have various factions vying for power, and they are all, for example, trying to establish <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/morpheus-basic-principles-of-anarchism#:~:text=violent%20of%20anarchists.-,Anarchists%2C%20by%20definition%2C%20are%20opposed%20to%20organization,over%20their%20own%20life%20and%20an%20equal%20say%20in%20group%20decisions.,-What%20Anarchists%20Oppose">authoritarian</a> control over a territory, their ideological differences are likely notable, but they don’t address the fundamental contradictions of authority.</p><p>This perspective seems to kind of fall into that pessimism, though, getting stuck there like its quicksand, when it could be a grounding space to return to in thinking about the importance of finding other ways to relate. Yes, the authoritarian nature of most obviously-available options cannot lead to substantive change, regardless of what they promise. That is a different issue than the possibility of substantive change, though. That possibility space is what I’m interested in.</p><p>To be clear: Whedonesque stories and Avellone-core approaches are not worlds apart; they are more accurately considered when seen as the bounds of a limited frame. It can’t be stressed enough; different sides of the same thing are not equivalent to being different things. Acknowledging the cage is “better” than getting ensnared into it by being disarmed with the treats of the other poles. However, it doesn’t point to how to escape the cage. Maybe that’s a tall order for a popular piece of media like a video game. Fair enough. But leaving the sentence incomplete is a better response than ending it by closing off possibility.</p><p>Given that these poles create a chart, many different pieces of art can be mapped using them. Metal Gear Solid, Persona 3, and The Last of Us are ones that I’ll zoom into, as I’ve been considering them a lot recently. I’ve found that they–alongside many an art–will focus on social relationships without being very interested in structure (beyond surface-tracing). They then end up waffling between Whedon’s light and Avellone’s shadow, when they don’t deploy a funky combination.</p><p>Metal Gear Solid is like a dimension-hopper in this sense, at once in both via superpositioning. Persona 3 is similar but is more segmented, with the <a href="https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Masquerade#:~:text=a%20convenient%20excuse%20that%20separates%20the%20extraordinary%20from%20the%20mundane.">masquerade</a> literally having shadow monsters to fight, alongside more fun ensemble stuff during the day. The Last of Us really leans into a kind of Whedonesque sincerity by way of Avellone’s skepticism, couched in grand Filonian-style myths about “human nature,” including a pessimistic Sorkinism.</p><p>I should be fair to Metal Gear, though; it is, like Sorkin, interested in bureaucracy, and, like Filoni, interested in myth, specifically, the myths of how elite power works–that confusion of cause and consequence that comes with things like finding out about Epstein’s exploits. Another aside: that is to say, if Metal Gear were slightly different, like if it were more inspired by Hitchcock or Lynch thematically (rather than just aesthetically), it would be based more directly in that kind of elite activity. The logic is there in the games.</p><p>Funnily enough, I’ve heard lots of folks say that the series is anti-war. This probably makes sense, if you’re not as strict as I am with that formulation. Showing soldiers being sad is not enough for me. Nor is talking about the horrors of war, especially if it is just a “deeper” exploration of the (admittedly reductive) “sad soldier.” <a href="https://chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io/notes-towards-an-anti-war-wargame/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CNon%E2%80%9D%2Dimperial%20games%20critique%20imperialism%20%E2%80%9Cfrom%20the%20inside%2C%E2%80%9D%20without%20going%20against%20or%20beyond%20it.)">Elsewhere</a>, I’ve talked about the utility of imperialism as a frame. In that schema, MGS would be “non”-imperial (or “non”-war to use the current conversation’s parlance).</p><p>This is an important thing to point out as it showcases the ways in which recapture (the net) is not all that different from entrenchment (the cage). The fact that Snake is an exceptional individual (i.e. a Great Man) at worst, and the tip of a vanguardist spear at best (be it FOX, FOXHOUND, MSF, Diamond Dogs, or any other groups characters are a part of).</p><p>Persona 3 (I played Reload) is more clearly bifurcated, with the duality between slice of life aspects related to going to school, socializing, and working, and the nighttime activity of fighting evil stuff. It’s very<a href="https://kotaku.com/persona-3-really-is-buffy-down-to-the-smallest-charact-5912065"> Buffy</a>. With the ensemble focus alongside the constellation of social links, which include folks outside of your fighting Party, it slots nicely into that Whedon pocket. The narrative and thematic reasons that explain the masquerade aspect are very gray in that angsty Avellone sense. It literalizes the light-shadow dynamic that is going on with the Whedon and Avellone poles. Memento Mori, the reminder that death is looming, acts as the coagulating force that pulls the game more squarely in a Avellone-esque orbit overall, as a kind of “having the cake and eating it too” moment.</p><p>For the Last of Us, to articulate earlier ideas a different way, it tries to find the Whedon (meaningful relationships and “humanity”) within the Avellone (rough-and-tumble “human nature” of death and competition), while inverting Sorkin’s gaze (an eye towards the social institutions that exist in the post-apocalyptic context), explaining it through a naturalized “canon” about what it means to be human and in human societies a la Filoni. This ends up leading to the net, as any utility that could be found in this criticality is forfeited by taking the most myopic conclusions possible, where–like many an apocalypse media–the answer is a libertarian anti-relational ethic.</p><p>These properties are interesting to look at since they are often well-regarded within their communities, and they show the ways in which the cage (in the case of Persona 3) and the net (in the case of TLOU or Metal Gear) work together. I’m not sure if this point can be stressed enough: the variety presented here, and the fact that there’s much more variety out there–that gets stuck between the net and the cage–indicates how pernicious dominance is at present. It can look a lot of different ways, and it can use that to pretend that it’s doing more than what it is, which is reinforcing itself constantly. This gets into a wider issue with non-radical perspectives; without a deep and biting critique (especially insofar as that shapes action), the cage and the net are often able to grab shit up.</p><p>I want it to be abundantly clear that I’m not all that interested in critiquing aesthetics, emotions, and desire as concepts; I’m not all that sure that it’s possible to do that in ways that are fruitful. Seeing them as wedded to the economic process is critical, though, to see how they can, at best, get hijacked to serve the interests of power. That’s why I find that the cage and net framing is useful. It is very easy to, for example, see a work that tries to escape the cage of war, in the vein of Metal Gear, as reaching some sort of exit velocity from domination’s gravitational pull.</p><p>However, given that it doesn’t really know what to <em>do</em> about the cage, it kind of just flops around in the open space until the net reels it back in. Specifically, I’m thinking about the morbid obsession with military hardware that can be seen throughout the series, and how that isn’t robustly explored or acknowledged as a space where recapture can happen. To say it more plainly: a right wing weapons fan can see themselves in that in a way that “completely” “misses” the messaging. That could be boiled down to literacy or attention (or the lack thereof), but I’m not sure that it’s reasonable to be so willing to make excuses for the ways in which certain stories garner reactionary fanbases. To be clear, this is a difficult thing to navigate, given the ubiquity of weapons, alongside how much energy in various societies have been put into creating weapons for a… long long time, especially under/in <a href="https://pybarra.weebly.com/uploads/6/8/7/0/687099/__quijano_coloniality_and_modernity_rationality.pdf#page=5">modernity</a>. Difficulty isn’t impossibility, though, and I’m not very interested in using gentle gloves with powerful creatives and IPs; accosting them for their audiences is like the least mean thing I could do.</p><p>On another note, it should also be said, if it’s not clear, that I’m very critical of many of the examples and these influences <em>because</em> I enjoy or have enjoyed (aspects of) the aesthetic layers of these various sensibilities. Rather than letting that be a motivation for me to defend acts of entrenchment or recapture, I see it as a reason to be even more critical. If I imagine these things to be circuits or outlets in various affective and libidinal economic flows, routing feelings and wantings into dominant channels, it means that I have to keep my wits about me. It’s easier for me to shit on stuff I don’t care about, think about, or like. That doesn’t mean that dominant systems have no modalities by which they can appeal to me, though. I never want to assume that I’m immune to propaganda or too smart for it, since there’s no functional pathway for that to be true.</p><p>It’s also worth saying that I don’t see this as a particularly contemporary problem; this is not a screed against “modern art” in itself. I am working through and trying to grapple with the fact that the dominant system is able to puppeteer various energies, if not embody them itself. There is something gravely problematic and unnerving about seeing groups like the Black Panthers–which I and many of my folks greatly admire–be something that can be represented in a movie like 2021’s Judas and the Black Messiah. I think of similar tensions around 2024’s Fanon, or even 1992’s Malcom X. This goes deeper than desires for and questions about “accuracy.” Deeper even than questions about the <em>possibility</em> of accuracy. It’s to say, even if it were accurate and resolutely radical, what does it mean that it can be shown in any capacity? How does that impact what it means to <em>be</em> radical? I don’t have a full picture, but a start is thinking about the four horsemen and their modes of retrenchment and recapture, where they can and do all act at once to, whether they intend to or not, keep dominant systems intact.</p><p>This also means that focusing on this-or-that sensibility is wrongheaded. To say it another way, I’m not complaining about “diverse ensembles” or “the lived experience of being a bureaucrat.” In general and in a specific piece of media, it is way too easy to forget that not only do those things not equate to liberation because they feel good, but it is because they feel good that they don’t lead to liberation, in this instance. It, in the best of cases, gives people a tool or two to think about the dominant system differently, in a way that often doesn’t translate to different behaviors. Ergo, it doesn’t really matter what’s in someone’s head if they aren’t able to do anything about it.</p><p>To underline the point, though: there is room for exploring those aesthetic sensibilities, either critically or otherwise. That shouldn’t be confused with changing conditions. The terms of engagement need to move away from “fandom is activism” logics. Arguing about movies or games is just that… one can enjoy that without adding the veneer of liberation to it so as to alleviate the personal discomfort in the contradictions fandom generates.</p><p>Responding to the four horsemen and entrenchment/recapture does imply certain aesthetic sensibilities, at least in a descriptive way. A big one, especially as it relates to speculative stories (as these questions are often more legible there), is problematizing “plot” and “canon.” Rather than starting from a place of assuming it to be critical to represent them in a unified, arithmetically cogent and interoperable way (like multiple characters having compatible if not the same understandings of events in the storyworld), partiality and partisanship should be embraced. This doesn’t mean that every story has to have an “unreliable” narrator in the accentuated sense of something like Ulysses or Dhalgren (though I do have a personal disposition towards those). It’s to say that the very idea of “reliability” should be, at the very least, brought into question. Having a perspective, even as an omnipotent narrator, is colored by that person’s/being’s standpoint/positionality. Practically, this call encourages character and narration statements to be separable if not separated from “facts.” This is meant to intervene in the tendency in real life and in fiction to trust authority because they are such, at the direct expense of analyzing the information presented and thinking through what the truth might be, even in (and especially in) situations where facts might be hard to come by.</p><p>Alongside this, though, there should be actual activity in the actual world. I’m ambivalent on whether or not each piece of art needs to “encourage” this, as “encouragement” looks different from person to person. What I will say is that entrenchment and recapture are themselves a kind of encouragement, and that encouragement doesn’t have to be intentional for it to happen. Unless you know better, constantly imbibing media that extolls the immortal nature of the status quo will probably encourage similar perspectives within you.</p><p>If storytelling is going to continue–and it seems that it will–I call for taking its various forms more seriously. Part of this is what’s been focused on for this piece; being honest about the ways that media informs and hijacks what the audience wants and feels. Given the power of dominant culture, many an aesthetic choice is, at best, at risk of being recuperated. Often, it is just entrenching dominant ideas directly, or otherwise taking non-dominant and anti-dominant ideas and defanging them as part of the placation–that’s the recapture.</p><p>However, even probing deeply into these flows of feeling and wanting aren’t enough. There too needs to be an interest in how these pieces of cultural production are made, as objects that exist in the world. That material and monetary context is critical for embarking on a robust critique or analysis of any piece, industry, or medium of cultural production. That isn’t to necessarily say “this was made by a bad company so that makes it bad,” or “this was created with ulterior motives so that makes it bad,” even if those statements can be and often are true. Combining explorations of feeling and wanting with more straightforward economic concerns is to acknowledge their inseparability.</p><p>More critically, it’s to acknowledge the shapes that those entanglements take. It’s to say that even in conversations about aesthetic or artistic choices, it is worth asking questions about who benefits from this or that depiction in economic terms.</p><p>To use an easy example, a movie like 2025’s Warfare “needing” the go ahead from the US military to get access to its hardware shapes the way in which that hardware is depicted, which may make clear why even a “negative” or “critical” depiction can be a mode of recapture. If a house gets blown up, or a specific person in the military is shitty, many of these pieces can’t help but to do the two step move of 1) making whatever badness that exists in the space be rooted in the dispositions of specific individuals and 2) treating that sense of morality as a useful tool for examining those issues, which loops back to questions and solutions that are vaguely trying to find morally upstanding people to occupy powerful positions.</p><p>I care so much about this stuff because of two things:</p><ol><li>fandom <em>is</em> culture for many people, and</li><li>stories are, in a relative sense, one of the easiest ways to navigate social contradictions.</li></ol><p>For folks who want to change things, this is critical. It’s not to turn these things into blueprints; it’s to say that, in some sense, stories often are. I’m very uninterested in creating spaces for “escape,” where people who already ignore social issues are able to further that ignorance. I don’t think being challenged by culture should be avoided; it feels critical to changing it and the context in which it exists.</p><p>This radar graph idea helps me with this because it acts as a reminder to what it means to live in a society; escape or change isn’t solely a question of individual capacities, drives, or interests. The things I and many others care about can exist well within a liberal enclosure–and that should be seen as a big issue. From Whedonesque Identity, to Sorkinist Bureaucracy, Filonian Myth(opeia), and Avellonean Morality, this graph is a space where the “true” meaning of this or that social dynamic is explored. The fact that there is a noticeable difference between something like Fallout New Vegas and West Wing as it relates to the role of government doesn’t mean that the bounds of what is possible should be found within neoliberalism, fascism, feudalism, and other forms of societal management.</p><p>I’m also a partisan; I want most of the things we do (yes, <em>we</em>) to feed into non-dominant and anti-dominant culture building. If folks aren’t actively working towards liberation, their efforts should at least not impede those efforts. What this means concretely will differ across contexts, but a big part of it is creatives and fans both deepening their understandings of how the world/society/community functions, alongside resisting the(ir) defensive posture around problematic elements in various texts, especially as it relates to the reality of the shadows cast by dominant culture. Again: one should not defend a piece of media because it makes them feel good.</p><p>The implied object of much of the things I’m discussing is rooted in my outsider/insider-looking-in criticality of fandom. I see fandom as responding to the contradictions between cultural production as an artistic process versus as a product-making process by picking the product side. I’m more on the artistic side as it relates to my tastes and how I think culture ought to be related to, while trying my bestest to understand the ways in which that product-based thinking shapes how people self-conceptualize, inspired by Guy Debord’s Society of the Spectacle. This is all to say: if fandom spaces and fandom modes of engagement–where identifying with media is part and parcel of enjoying it–are deprioritized, cultural production can start to avoid the ways in which it often reifies dominant culture at the direct expense of relational and radical lifeways.</p><p>I also don’t want to pretend that seeing it as art is infallible. The contestation around the concept of art is proof of this; from its Eurocentrism to its classism. Basically, it goes back to asking questions of dominance. Anti-and-non-dominant perspectives for how cultural production ought to be related to–especially in refusing easy victories like turning ideological enemies into caricatures–is critical.</p><p>I’m going to risk a bit of rigidity here. All of this discussion is downstream from an overarching goal of trying to escape the gravitational pull of the poles of each Bullshit horseman. Again, this is not a claim that is preoccupied with the “discrete” and “emblematic” aesthetics of each pole–the results of those things are the issues being attacked, especially as they relate to the wider narrative assemblages they fit within, as discrete texts and as being in conversation with other texts.</p><p>The alternative(s) I’m interested in, rooted in my partisan commitments, revolve around embracing the tensions that arise from navigating legibility, accessibility, craft, and “artistic merit.” In a general sense, this looks like leaning into entanglement, obligations, and accountabilities, rather than the ideas of rights, duties, and heroism/sacrifice. The ideas to be leaned into are retooling relational ethics, informed by a current context that can acknowledge faults with “past” forms of (clearly) situated knowledge, while not falling prey to the blinkered nature of humanistic knowledge that claims universality. So, rather than having a story like Naruto route all of its philosophical questions through a kind of splaying across all of the horsemen poles, it could (if you were to allow me to fanfic a bit) be both deeply interested in how to deal with the world as someone who lives in a glorified military base, who is roped into fighting for that military, is a living weapon for that military, and only sees an out by becoming a leader within that hierarchy, while constantly pointing to all of the failures of that mode of social organization. In other words, if Naruto stays who he is, the world should more accurately showcase the social dynamics that such a constitution would imply, engender, and be in a dialectic with. My ideal version of that would be that villagers would have some sense of protagonism and would try to overthrow things, with Naruto and company having to be held accountable for being defenders of the status quo. If that doesn’t necessarily fit the vision, the world itself could explore those things with intentionality; imagine an extreme version of the ending to the land of waves arc, and that’s roughly what I’m getting at.</p><p>This is meant to address the relationship between depiction and endorsement. While one does not necessarily lead into the other… if the storytellers don’t understand the context that leads to a depiction (i.e. why are or what makes certain things particularly harmful), it can become a big issue. While people “missing the point” regarding something like Warhammer 40,000’s satire are easy to blame, it doesn’t help that its storyworld is often uninterested in those most deeply harmed from living in a universe that is mythical in its suffering, and nearly comical in its perspectives. If it might not make for “as fun” of a story to explore the life of someone working on a Manufactory World–a planet-sized factory–I suspect that that’s a part of the issue. If the experiences of people–who are themselves or are acting in the capacities of historical (and current) patriarchs, capitalists, mercantilists, abusers and colonizers–are consistently understood to be more interesting than their victims, then the whole enterprise of storytelling needs to be razed so that something new can grow from the ashes.</p><p>That’s what’s important; not some nebulous idea of feelings and desire, as it relates to how folks will work backwards from those to try and excuse poor taste at best and avoiding accountability at worst. Interventions feel critical given how important cultural production is in many self-concepts. There has to be a multi-part move to decenter products from how people understand themselves, create pieces that unsettle coloniality, and set fire to colonial comforts. From there, maybe there can be cooler stuff that also helps people become cooler.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/812732433745231872/the-four-horsemen-of-bullshit-cultural-production?source=share"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em> on April 1, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b65b5c0291b2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/fandom-fanatics/the-four-horsemen-of-bullshit-cultural-production-whedon-sorkin-filoni-avellone-b65b5c0291b2">The Four Horsemen of Bullshit Cultural Production: Whedon, Sorkin, Filoni, Avellone</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/fandom-fanatics">Fandom Fanatics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Sewer Socialism” is Making a Comeback. But Will it Save Us?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/sewer-socialism-is-making-a-comeback-but-will-it-save-us-c7ddc209434f?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c7ddc209434f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nyc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zohran-mamdani]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Feb 2026 21:01:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-12T18:01:04.430Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dip writes about Mamdani’s win and first few weeks in office as Mayor of NYC.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eQE1Qe6U9BApxzoj" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@rvargasphoto?utm_source=ghost&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_campaign=api-credit">Ryan Vargas</a> / <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=ghost&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_campaign=api-credit">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Zohran Mamdani won the NYC mayoral race, and those who still believe in the electoral system have been patting themselves on the back. There’s a lot to be impressed by from the campaign; NYC’s <a href="http://www.democracynow.org/2025/11/14/zohran_campaign?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">voter turnout was the highest it’s been in over 50 years, and 104k volunteers were mobilized</a> to support it. So far, he’s made moves to try and <a href="https://thehyperhive.com/everything-zohran-mamdani-achieved-far/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">build housing while protecting tenants</a>, <a href="https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/01/mamdani-administration-bans-hotel-hidden-fees-and-unexpected-cre?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">attacked junk fees</a>, and <a href="https://www.nyc.gov/mayors-office/news/2026/01/mayor-mamdani---governor-hochul-to-launch-free-child-care-for-tw?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">introduced state-funded free childcare</a>.</p><p>Mamdani’s grassroots force was able to defeat the Cuomo dynasty; the progressive platform Mamdani ran on represents an alternate path for politics in the swirl of Trump 2.0’s vortex. Trump and Mamdani actually <a href="https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5618271-trump-mamdani-meet-affordability?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">met in the White House</a> recently, and it was very cordial; this adds an extra wrinkle to our understanding of the moment. Given previous they had for each other, this was a bit of a surprise. The fact that they were able to avoid blows led many folks to take .</p><p>This win feels <a href="https://www.insurgentthoughts.com/p/counterinsurgency-is-ideologicalpsychological?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">counterinsurgent</a> when you add everything together. This is not because I imagine it as literally welded to some specific CIA program that would be uncovered from a declassified document in 50 years, nor does it feel this way because of it impeding some capital-I insurgency that is taking place or could take place in NYC (paranoid claims of Mamdani establishing “ “ be damned). It’s the amount of energy put into it, from the actual effort of the organizers, to the emotional allegiance (“hearts and minds”) that people have to Mamdani. It serves the function, even while having a different form.</p><p>This level of faith in electeds, even though they’ve proven themselves to be<a href="https://theconversation.com/making-progress-is-more-than-making-policy-what-mamdani-can-learn-from-de-blasio-about-the-politics-of-urban-progress-269062?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io"> ineffectual</a>,<a href="https://www.blackrosefed.org/socialist-faces-in-high-places-reader/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io"> traitorous, or both</a>, is concerning. The idea of doing “<a href="https://strangematters.coop/critique-of-contrapoints-against-electoralism-socialist-cooperative-keiretsu/?utm_source=rss&amp;utm_medium=rss&amp;utm_campaign=critique-of-contrapoints-against-electoralism-socialist-cooperative-keiretsu">real politics</a>” in these instances means getting “radical” people in office (which we are unable to do more often than not), and… hoping that they stick to their ethics. What sense does that make when the system itself and the concessionary nature of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Realpolitik?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">realpolitik</a> means betraying that?</p><p>We cannot, in this settler colonial context, hope that getting people elected will free us (especially for those of us that aren’t settlers). Not only will it not work, but the sentiment of “ <a href="http://www.leftcom.org/en/articles/2015-04-28/every-vote-is-a-yes-for-capitalism?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">every vote [as] a yes for capitalism</a>” is exacerbated on stolen land controlled by slaveholders, where their government has opted for <a href="https://aas.princeton.edu/news/when-slaveowners-got-reparations?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">reparations</a> and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_Acts?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">land</a> for settlers, rather than anything of the sort for the whole of Black and Native populations.</p><p>Even with that in mind, given the high emotions of the moment, there are things I can find appreciation in, in spite of my distaste for the theater of elections. There has been an increasing shift in recent times towards local politics, to the extent of questioning the <a href="https://aeon.co/essays/the-end-of-a-world-of-nation-states-may-be-upon-us?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">health of the nation-state</a>. The focus on the local is critical, especially given the more widespread unreliability of national-level programming, with a notable exception being anything coming from militaristic bodies like the <a href="https://www.propublica.org/article/chicago-venezuela-immigration-ice-fbi-raids-no-criminal-charges?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">Department of Homeland Security</a>.</p><p>However, by seeing the local through the lens of electoralism, parochialism can easily take root. “Common denominator” politics-whether we’re talking about Mamdani’s <a href="http://www.democracynow.org/2025/11/14/zohran_campaign?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">campaign planks</a> of “fast and free buses, universal child care and freezing the rent” or the Milwaukee “ <a href="https://znetwork.org/znetarticle/socialists-in-city-hall-a-new-look-at-sewer-socialism-in-wisconsin/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">sewer socialists</a>” of the 20th century-fighting for the immediate benefit of the working class can keep people from dreaming bigger. These are reasonable things to focus on, but we have to be careful about how we get them. <a href="https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/12/bill-de-blasio-remains-unpopular.html?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">Reforms can be won</a>, but it generally comes at the expense of revolution.</p><p>This is due to a myriad of factors, but the main one ties into the “incidental counterinsurgency” point from earlier. The level of emotional investment that electoralism-as-strategy engenders makes it difficult to imagine other pathways. Any divergences from or challenges to electoral work tend to be taken as personal attacks. If I were to tell a canvasser who truly believes in revolution that the approach they took wasn’t the most consistent way for our communities and society to move towards communism, they might reflect on all of their experience of doing the work and the affect it gives them, rather than analyze their conditions and do a comparative analysis. They could just as easily understand their work in a more analytical way, but the very fact of doing the work, especially in this way, points towards a gap in the understanding.</p><p>Even with the dangers and pitfalls, we <em>should</em> fight for the kind of things that provide immediate relief to folks. The devil is in the details, though. A good way to break it down is this: Mamdani’s campaign represents a progressive push. I advocate for a radical one.</p><p>Political conversations tend to see progressive movements and ideas as related to if not interchangeable with radical ones. I don’t. While progressivism is about expanding the bounds of liberalism so as to be more “inclusive” through intent or through results, radicalism is about uprooting liberalism, capitalism, and all the other forms of domination that are keeping our society rooted in misery.</p><p>Radicalism sees the systems of domination being fought against as a hydra; sometimes we have to cut off the heads to avoid being bitten, but by doing that alone, we just create a space out of which one or more heads emerge. We have to cauterize the wounds if we want the heads to stop growing.</p><p>That doesn’t even get to actually taking down the hydra. Radicalism is about more than responding to crises and trying to handle them. It <em>can</em> be doing that, but, for radicals, the intent is broader. Crises are addressed in a way that works to respond to their animating logics, systems, institutions, and (by)products.</p><p>The hard part about doing truly radical things is that the logic behind it is necessarily abductive. Radicals can only rely on our interpretation of the past and our understandings of how the world works in order to change it; we can’t make some of the guarantees that progressives can, pointing to specific instances of policy changes bringing about the incremental improvements that they do. Our movements have to sustain us in ways that themselves challenge the social relations of the present.</p><p>This leaves us with a classic question: the fuck do we do? Well, the answers are manifold, but we’ve established some guidelines. If our answers don’t have a radical bent to them, we risk allowing the problems of society to continue to entrench or even exacerbate through resignation, or make things incrementally better for some people at the expense of others through reform.</p><p>In a general sense, my ideas for radical change revolve around building a <a href="https://www.savac.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Wynter_Unsettling-the-Coloniality-of-Being.pdf?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">decolonial</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/egoism-and-cooperation-2219f2566782?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">egoistic</a>, <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/federacion-anarquista-uruguaya-popular-power-people-s-ability-to-organise-their-own-society?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">popular power</a> on one hand and a deep-seated negation on the other, where they are <a href="https://illwill.com/composition?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">composed</a> and braided together through ( <a href="https://ia601909.us.archive.org/14/items/ecology-is-a-sistahs-issue-too-the-politics-of-emergent-afrocentric-ecowomanism/Ecology%20Is%20a%20Sistah%E2%80%99s%20Issue%20Too-%20The%20Politics%20of%20Emergent%20Afrocentric%20Ecowomanism%20copy.pdf?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">eco</a>)( <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/nsambu-za-suekama-why-i-am-a-materialist-transfeminist?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">trans</a>) <a href="https://www.ualberta.ca/en/institute-intersectionality-studies/media-library/intersectionality-readings/puar-i-would-rather-be-a-cyborg-than-a-goddess.pdf?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">feminist</a> <a href="https://files.libcom.org/files/2025-05/simoun-magsalin-rebel-peripheries-en.pdf?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">communization</a>.</p><p>Given that these borrow from <a href="https://davidgraeber.org/articles/are-you-an-anarchist-the-answer-maysurprise-you/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">anarchism</a> and more <a href="https://libcom.org/library/part-3-3?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">insurrectionary communisms</a>, that doesn’t leave a lot of room for statecraft and electoral stuff. That’s how it should be, in my estimation; folks working to figure out how to build stateless and “democratic” communities that point us towards a world beyond patriarchy, capitalism, and colonialism.</p><p>However, I’m fully willing to admit that my idea of radical change is pretty bespoke. I’m not going out of my way to proselytize and look for converts. More importantly for this conversation, the pull of electoralism is strong. Given that people will probably continue to engage with it until the wheels fall off, I think that it’s worthwhile to sketch out a way to relate to it. What follows is a kind of “anti-electoral” electoralism, where it is seen as a (dangerous) tool out of many, and should be engaged with accordingly.</p><p>Starting from a steely-eyed acceptance that participating in the voting machine is supporting, through legitimation, capitalism (colonialism, and all of its interconnected forms of domination), this is a potential pathway for voting to do what those who genuinely believe in it and what they say can be explored in a way that is accountable to its so-called constituency.</p><p>Firstly, let’s talk about politics. A good way to understand political discourse is that it generally revolves around who has power, conceived in a specific way: it’s getting people to do something that you want them to do, regardless of what they want.</p><p>This is how you get conversations around <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purity_test_(politics)?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">purity politics</a> and its response, an acquiescence to realpolitik, which colors the discourse around basically every left politician.</p><p>That is a <em>kind</em> of power, (or, said otherwise, a way that power can manifest) but it’s not the only way to conceive of power.</p><p>A more useful way that I’ve found to look at power comprehends it in multiple ways (including those that can point to more egalitarian ends than the kind of Machiavellian orientation of politics) around relationships to capacities. That is to say, power is not only what you can do, but it’s what you can do in view of how you can do it. This indicates a possibility of domineering power, but it can also be the non-hierarchical power of <a href="https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/relationality-9781350225992/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">relationality</a> and collectivity.</p><p>With this more expansive understanding of power in tow, we have something that can help us judge what we describe moving forward, with some inspiration from an excellent Strange Matters article: <a href="https://strangematters.coop/critique-of-contrapoints-against-electoralism-socialist-cooperative-keiretsu/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io"><em>Contra Contra</em></a>.</p><p>The core insight there is that power flows from having money. This is why 100,000 Democratic Michiganders were able to vote Uncommitted but not make any waves from a policy or even symbolic perspective with the Democrats. They continued to fund Israel and not put in work towards a ceasefire. On the other hand, Joe Biden had to drop out of the race once some donors made a fuss.</p><p>So, <em>Contra Contra</em> proposes establishing federations of cooperatives, funded from a seed money pool of well-to-do DSA members, starting from the end of the supply chain with businesses in retail, app dev, and service, and working up the chain to manufacturing and agricultural capacity, supported by interlinking them with financial institutions at the core. This group could then focus on putting their power behind desirable local candidates and electeds before scaling to state, regional, and even (inter)national levels, creating a more accountable pole of power than the capitalists or NGOs.</p><p>An extra lever of power comes from the ways this federation could influence political staffers (i.e., the folks who work for politicians), as their career prospects incentivize them to go into lobbying if they want to make good money. There could be something more mission aligned in the federation that also gives them materially better career options.</p><p>The federation could even be a source of workers for the administrative wing of the government, entering into it to effectively administer programs in a way that’s more aligned with social movement goals. This allows for there to be yet another layer of influence from the social movement in government.</p><p>Paired with this, a good general orientation would be to stop cooperative members from becoming elected officials, or allowing elected officials to come into the cooperatives, as the incentives there are a bit too perverse.</p><p>A key intent of this is accounting for the <a href="https://thetricontinental.org/newsletterissue/conjunctural-analysis/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">balance of forces</a>, making sure that dealings between the government and social movements are either directly in favor of social movements, or at least moving things in that direction. This helps stem some of the issues of unaccountability and co-optation that we see so often in “representative” systems.</p><p>However, I see this federation of coops as only one piece of the puzzle. It hints at funding candidates, maybe even running them, but where do they come from?</p><p>To further increase the accountability, and put our thumb on the scales, we can have the electeds be delegates from community assemblies. This would mean building spaces of deliberation that are separate from and parallel to the state, where multiple people can come together on non-hierarchical terms and chart out what they want to see in the world.</p><p>This space could be a kind of interface for multiple organizations and even movements (and cooperatives) to come together to help coordinate the execution of critical tasks. This could make sure that the federation doesn’t stray from the needs of the communities that it is a part of, in the same way that the federation can keep electeds accountable through having a big say in their funding.</p><p>The importance of delegates coming from assemblies is that they would be trusted members of the community who are instantly recallable by the assemblies, and it allows people to have more of a say than they’d get through the official ballot process. So, the federation can put weight behind people in office who are amenable to a (libertarian) socialist agenda, propping up folks from the community who also fit that bill.</p><p>However, we can’t get it twisted: the government is the enemy. We should basically see all of this engagement as a kind of spycraft, even to the extent of treating electeds we fund and/or run as agents. This is critical, as it will enable the assembly to not fall into just being a candidate generator (in the best case). It should maintain its multipurpose nature, dealing with a myriad of issues, many of them doing the work of building <a href="https://dsa-lsc.org/2018/12/31/dual-power-a-strategy-to-build-socialism-in-our-time?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">dual power</a>. Election stuff should be considered a very minimal part of an assembly’s docket, if at all.</p><p>So: our delegates are “agents”. It makes sense that they would have a “handler”, which is someone (another delegate or delegated working group) who they work with to make sure that they are actually acting as an extension of the people’s desires. They would be the main point of contact in between meetings and be there for them through this job, as it would probably be pretty hard to stray from the path once you’re actually within (h)arms reach of the people who rely on you.</p><p>The handler can also bring in more people to support the unit built around the official, and help them shape their tactics for the strategy and program that they’ve been given.</p><p>There should be open lines of communication between this team of people and the rest of the assembly, with the ability to instantly recall anyone who does something harmful or is just generally not able to function in the role, if the issues can’t be rectified.</p><p>The delegate that moves into an elected seat would be able to be called on at any time to attend an assembly meeting, and to prioritize that space over any “official” space.</p><p>The hardest part might be getting people into the assembly space, but that could be where some of the more “immediate needs” strategies come in. Providing and/or opening access to food and other necessities will be key in making it a space people want to be in. That, alongside tapping the federation resources to supercharge cultural and fun gatherings and experiences will be huge.</p><p>A couple of things the <a href="https://znetwork.org/znetarticle/socialists-in-city-hall-a-new-look-at-sewer-socialism-in-wisconsin/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">sewer socialists</a> got right were their “bundle brigades” of delivering language-appropriate newspapers to keep their communities informed, and “socialist carnivals”. Having events like that, alongside doing <a href="https://www.ngpvan.com/blog/deep-canvassing/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">deep canvassing</a> efforts would allow the assemblies to become threads that meaningfully weave together the social fabric.</p><p>That’s the basic idea. To tie it all together:</p><ol><li>People would create assemblies in their locales that would federate and act as multipurpose interfaces to share information and resources across a community. They’d confederate with other non-hierarchical formations and do the same over wider geographical spaces;</li><li>these assemblies would be federated with various kinds of cooperatives that are working to build out their own socialized access to the means of production and money, so that they can finance elected officials, shifting the balance of forces so as to hold them accountable (while retooling what “accountability” means as to be more just);</li><li>elected officials not already in office (and a maximal amount of officials moving forward) would first be elected as delegates from the assemblies, subject to instant recall and obligated to prioritize the assembly as their strategic, tactical, and programmatic base, and;</li><li>these elected officials will be supported and held accountable by “handlers” who would act as a confidant and accountability partner, being the point of contact between meetings with the assembly.</li></ol><p>As this is a sketch, big questions remain for this strategy. Beyond questions of amenability with anarchism, it remains to be seen how to fight against things like (the ideological if not material power of) PACs and not get stuck in the weeds there. The delegation process will also need to be fleshed out. Instant recallability has been pointed out, but how will that function? What might it look like to do the act of recalling someone? How is the delegate picked? I’d suggest people to collate nominations and select someone using <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemic_Consensing?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">systemic consensing</a> or <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STAR_voting?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">STAR voting</a>, but it could be sortition or <a href="https://participedia.net/search?selectedCategory=method&amp;ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">some other method</a> of selection that isn’t even voting.</p><p>Another big question is how to justify using movement money for electoral pursuits, rather than focusing on building autonomous care programs for people (especially those on the margins who can’t reach or have unreliable access to the mainstream/public/private ones).</p><p>There also needs to be some thinking on how different rank-and-file organizations like unions, existing town halls, community organizations, and other formations that might be part of an <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/afrofuturist-abolitionists-of-the-americas-anti-capitalism-mutual-aid-and-asset-based-community?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io#toc3">asset based community development</a> program could contribute to this, if at all.</p><p>Finally, as the seed funding is coming from well-off people in the <a href="https://dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/on-the-origins-of-the-professional-managerial-class-an-interview-with-barbara-ehrenreich/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">professional-managerial class</a>, rather than the kinds of people that would be populating those startup businesses, how do we make sure that this is a good way to go, and doesn’t maintain bloc divides within the wider working class? This is a sizable hurdle, especially as the <a href="https://redstarcaucus.org/zenith4-race-class-empire/?ref=chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io">vast majority</a> of DSA is white. Would it be a kind of “non-dilutive funding” situation, where those with outsized monetary power forfeit governing power?</p><p>Regardless, those PMC folks should be deprioritized in favor of lower class folks, so that whatever is built is sure to benefit them, while creating a vehicle that can weather the storms of insurrection and revolution (or at least be sturdy enough to hop off and get on something better if necessary).</p><p>I don’t necessarily have a great answer to these questions, beyond the one that I presented earlier: people are going to engage with electoral stuff, and the electoral system is not disappearing any time soon. The hope that people feel from recent electoral wins is real and understandable. I just want us to make sure that we don’t let our emotions get hijacked, costing us emancipation.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io/sewer-socialism-is-making-a-comeback-but-will-it-save-us/"><em>https://chaos-and-conviviality.ghost.io</em></a><em> on February 11, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c7ddc209434f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Egoism and Cooperation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/egoism-and-cooperation-2219f2566782?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2219f2566782</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[egoism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[egoist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decolonization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Nov 2024 00:40:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-12T12:52:09.918Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="a QR Code with a painting in the background. a link that goes to my friend adrian’s linktree. captioned with my twitter @" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_ApaRMEM3GdCsWFsHXtfPg.png" /></figure><h3><strong>devour me</strong></h3><p>my ideas</p><p>my essence</p><p>ineffable and ephemeral</p><p>tactile and tactless</p><p>what is owned by me?</p><p>can i own anything besides myself?</p><p>ownership is usage</p><p>usage is taken</p><p>so take me</p><p>mix my essence with yours</p><p>and devour it all</p><p>make it your own</p><p>if i survive</p><p>then maybe</p><p>I can own myself</p><p>and become Unique</p><h3><strong>In(tent)(troduction)</strong></h3><p>I want to have my cake and eat it too. When people say “pick A or B”, I always ask “what’s the secret third thing?” I see the potentialities of the world as much more open-ended than what tends to be explored in (whitestream)¹ conversations about changing material, social, relational, and spatial conditions. That’s where my conception of the ego and egoism comes in. We’ll get into what <em>I </em>mean by those over the course of this piece. Relatedly, I am interested in exploring my place(s) in the world as a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_jeopardy">multiple-jeopardy</a> Black person. What might a world that accepts me look like? While I’m speaking, thinking, and feeling from my own perspective, I have an eye on the fact that I am intimately connected to my folks. I want to explore what “self-centeredness”² means for a people who’s sense of “self” is appropriated, denied, or exaggerated. How does that (re)configure our conceptions of what it means to be an individual? To be in a collective? How do those things intersect with our cultures, enabling their proliferation and/or preventing them from becoming prisons of another kind? How can we explore the multiple facets of modernity’s sacred idea of “freedom”, whether it’s “freedom from”, “freedom of”, or “freedom to”? Is that a useful abstraction for us to concretize, so that we can act effectively? I hope to start exploring these questions in the coming pages.</p><blockquote>“Spending your life fighting for others, but not yourself, is nothing but hypocrisy. […] If you fight for ideals, then you’ll only ever be able to save ideals. That’s all.” — Archer (<em>Fate/Stay Night </em>by Kinoko Nasu)</blockquote><blockquote>“Men make their own history, but they do not make it as they please[…] the beginner who has learned a new language always translates it back into his mother tongue, but he assimilates the spirit of the new language and expresses himself freely in it only when he moves in it without recalling the old and when he forgets his native tongue.” — <a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1852/18th-brumaire/ch01.htm">18th Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte</a> by Karl Marx</blockquote><blockquote>“‘But you are a great sinner, that’s true,’ he added almost solemnly, and your worst sin is that you have destroyed and betrayed yourself for <em>nothing</em>. Isn’t that fearful? Isn’t it fearful that you are living in this filth which you loathe so, and at the same time you know yourself (you’ve only to open your eyes) that you are not helping anyone by it, not saving anyone from anything?” ― Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky</blockquote><blockquote>“Those who break the rules are trash, but those who abandon their comrades are worse than trash! If I’m going to be called trash either way, I’d rather break the rules! And if that somehow makes me anything less than a real shinobi, then I’ll crush all of the so-called “real” shinobi!” — Obito Uchiha (<em>Naruto</em> by Masashi Kishimoto)</blockquote><blockquote>“Even If I’m a fraud, I know my dream isn’t wrong.” — Shirou Emiya (<em>Fate/Stay Night </em>by Kinoko Nasu)</blockquote><blockquote>“Philosophers have hitherto only <em>interpreted</em> the world in various ways; the point is to change it.” — <a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/theses/index.htm">Theses On Feuerbach</a> by Karl Marx</blockquote><blockquote>“In a fractal conception, I am a cell-sized unit of the human organism, and I have to use my life to leverage a shift in the system by how I am, as much as with the things I do. This means actually being in my life, and it means bringing my values into my daily decision making. Each day should be lived on purpose.” — <a href="https://archive.org/details/brown-emergent-strategyfullbook">Emergent Strategy: Shaping Change, Changing Worlds</a> by adrienne maree brown</blockquote><h3><strong>Grasping for straws, changing our conditions</strong></h3><p>I want to burn this whole colonial world down.</p><p>I yearn to negate, to unsettle all that seeks to dominate me and mine. Living in a zone of the negative, I draw upon the dark power of non-being. Where does that leave me, I wonder?</p><p>I am no soothsayer, but I can confidently, egoistically predict that new growth will rise from the ashes.</p><p>Through necromantic negation the forward path arises.</p><p>I am the new growth.</p><p>Through this trial by fire, these controlled burns of chaos, I learn not only to affirm my survival in this world, but to prepare myself to be powerful in the next.</p><p>My dark power is too offensive for now, but in it lies the raw materials for affirmation.</p><h4>Positional Survey</h4><p>To be Black is to sit outside of the discourse on the concepts of “subject”³ and “object”⁴ off rip. The position of object is assumed and applied to us. This sucks (to put it painfully euphemistically) when, in reality, we yearn to see ourselves not as objects, but subjects!⁵ We obviously know, even given our conditions, that we are human! This tension that is imposed upon us immediately creates issues in how we understand ourselves.</p><p>Groups are collectivized by the very nature of their shared identity. This “collection” is much of what reifies the colonized as objects, flattening us into automatons or homunculi. To facilitate this objectification, there is a relationship of domination at play, buttressed by an Us-versus-Them hierarchy. This is especially apparent with Blackness, an integral part of the process of colonial differentiation (creating taxonomies for managing empires) &amp; colonial undifferentiation (flattening universalisms that appropriate, water down, and marginalize other ways of thinking-feeling-knowing-being). At the world-system level, the in-group is middle class (Anglo-oriented) Europeans, their emissaries, and stans. Sylvia Wynter, in <a href="https://docdro.id/KInN3Vn">Unsettling the Coloniality of Being</a> (along with many of her other later works) tunes us into the fact that Man, as the colonial, European, White, cishet patriarch, has stolen the show, creating the very definitions and boundaries of what it means to <em>be</em> human.⁶ Therefore, concepts integral to modernity, like humanism, society, being, power etc. (to transmogrify the rest of Wynter’s essay title) are virtues shaped in His image (just like “we” are shaped after “God” in various Christian canons…interesting).</p><p>The obvious/straightforward answer to this problem is to advocate for our “right” to a “seat at the table”, to “prove” that we’re “human too”. This socially constructed desire, whether it manifests as assimilation or integration, leads us to seek an expansion of the boundaries in society. Fanon helps us think about this in <a href="https://archive.org/details/BlackSkinWhiteMasksFrantzFanon/page/n3/mode/2up">Black Skin, White Masks</a> when he talks about black folks having a desire to assert personhood through enacting and trying to embody white culture. Wynter, to revisit <a href="https://docdro.id/KInN3Vn">Unsettling the Coloniality of Being</a>, talks about how “certain interests are cultivated until they [are] universalized”. This marginalizes certain “genres of being” that are by necessity underrepresented in the places where hierarchical power⁷ exists.<strong> </strong>This creates a dilemma: either the marginal must find ways to be affirmed on the margins, or disregard aspects of themselves to more neatly integrate into the metropole.</p><p>Getting represented by these systems is problematic enough due to the contradictions in and of coloniality/modernity for people who fit in or have proximity to the overrepresented modes of “being”. Said otherwise, the shit ain’t even all that good for the folks it’s made for. For folks in a “zone of non-being” as Fanon says, this becomes an issue that is orders of magnitude larger. It isn’t just the frustration of not being able to embody or reach the ideal; it’s not having that embodiment as an option. Struggles hit different when your very ability to <em>be</em> is brought into question.</p><p>To surpass this, us “non-beings”, have to start charting out a self-definition. It’s not worthwhile to try and become White folks or like White folks — that is a losing game. We will get better results by using our positionality as beings of “creative nothing”⁸ to diverge from the bullshit and converge upon new (and old) ways of relating that align with our self-interest(s).</p><p>This isn’t a call for a reductive focus on a single aspect of phenomenal experience. If we’re being real, focusing “solely” on The “Black Experience™” in the abstract⁹ can lead us astray, generally towards uplifting shitty cis men and protecting abusers of all stripes. This is why we have to make sure that we don’t take our exclusion from colonial configurations of power as one extreme along a single, “legible”/“valid” continuum of being, such that our only reprieve is to become colonial ourselves. By doing so, we easily take Eurocentric conceptions of how social life must be constituted as universal, rather than contingent.</p><p>To this end, we have to incorporate a transfeminist lens to our POV, so that we can combat sexism, homophobia, transphobia, <em>and</em> transmisogynoir — all things that constitute patriarchy. Too often, (usually cishetero)¹⁰ Black folks flatten the issues that the most marginal of us face into calls for unity under blackness, in a way that is juxtaposed or put into contradiction with other identities that folks have. There are times where maGes (marginalized genders) and/or disabled folks, for example, get sidelined due to a lack of interest from people outside of those experiences in interrogating their biases. That ain’t gonna fly. Not just because it’s “mean” or whatever to exclude people. It ignores natural, physical, material realities: there <em>are</em> Black people who are queer, maGe, disabled, etc, <em>and </em>those intersections, imbrications, and interpenetrations don’t negate their Blackness. To the contrary, <em>we </em>(as a forcefully “unified” community)¹¹ don’t like those things <em>because</em> of a desire to assimilate and capitulate to what Man says we should be, in an attempt to “game” the materialities and ontologies of social hierarchy. Again, this isn’t tenable. We can’t use Eurocentrism and coloniality to defeat Eurocentrism and coloniality. Being able to understand the pluralism and dynamism within our community on the terms of that pluralism and dynamism will do us well. Unity has to come <em>through</em> diversity, if it is to ever arrive.</p><blockquote>“[…] where Black feminism stumbles is a failure to recognize the noted absence within the historical record/archives of resistance and rebellion from Black trans people, specifically Black trans women/transfems. Therefore, the positionality at play here is not merely one of sexism, but it is specifically one of cissexism and intersexism. Black trans women/transfems are not represented through the domination of “Black males” within the archives and records, we are instead categorically erased, and rather than desiring the upending of this, Black feminism and queer theory have engaged in a reterritorialization whereby our erasure has been reconfigured as overrepresentation — or as it is framed so often within queer spaces writ large, “taking up space”. Afro-pessimism, whether intentionally or unconsciously, has furthered the insistence of taking the “Black female body” as a literal, physical site that acts as the nexus for engendering the particularity of Black gender, regardless of the fact of Black trans women/transfems being delegated to the realm of the Unthought to be excavated in order to make Black gender and Black Womanhood itself legible. This is facilitated in no small part through a particular interpretation of ungendering that does not properly locate Black transgressive womanhood.” — <a href="https://x.com/disrupthehuman/status/1506353325561761796?s=20"><em>For Those Seeking or in Flight: Black Trans*feminist Nihilism</em></a> by g</blockquote><p>We put ourselves in <strong>grave</strong> danger by not taking this seriously.¹² Riding for the margins of the margins is a <strong>requirement</strong> for any liberatory change. Those folks are of interest to us (if we are not those folks ourselves) as we deepen our understanding of our intersecting identities and experiences. More importantly, their particular experiences and desires should be fought for since worlds built that center them/us¹³ will necessarily be able to accommodate others. If we are creative enough to get out of the way and allow the flourishing of the most dispossessed, it’ll be a cakewalk to figure shit out for other folks. Our strength doesn’t come from flattening differences. It comes from struggling through and with them, making connections that don’t rely on bigotry or universalized essential properties that are dubiously applied.</p><p>By assigning “essential” properties, or properties that are “intrinsic” to how a person “is”, we presuppose some sense of objective rationality in how identities are constructed that we’re probably uncritically bringing over from Eurocentrism. With any complex object, subject, or phenomena, we don’t readily have the tools available to us to discern properties that are “immutable”. Narrow conceptions of gender within our Eurocentric paradigm, for example, lead to an essentialization that betrays <em>any</em> coherent understanding of gender, “sex”, sexuality, or embodiment <em>in general</em>. This essentializing doesn’t hold up to any heuristic that isn’t a tool of domination. It tends to come from an exaltation of rationality, especially as employed by Eurocentric universalisms and empiricisms. Rationality is but one variable in a complex body of intentional thought, decision-making, and be(com)ing. I’d argue that the “essence” (used in this case to be akin to the intent) of rationality is betrayed by its usage in isolation, when it could become much more powerful (if we decide to give it power) as a star in a constellation of knowledge-making.</p><p>In other words, we should be very careful about where we get our ideas from. This hypercritical lens on the (re)production and (over)representation that Whitestream/Eurocentric idea(l)s embody will serve us well towards any desires of “emancipation”, “freedom”, “liberty”, and so on. For any of the cultural or ideological changes that are discussed, there needs to be action taken such that those thoughts <em>mean</em> something. This feeds into how we understand and conceive of taking action. Charting out our own paths in this arena are important, especially so that we can understand good ways to relate to rebellious action. Keeping our particular context in mind, our insurrectionism should also be constructive. Our negation should build upon and create spaces for autonomy to flourish. We can live like <a href="https://redvoice.news/not-fox-not-wolf-but-the-wildcat/">Wildcats</a>, becoming Ungovernable (word to Lorenzo Kom’boa Ervin) and orienting ourselves towards the ideas of rebellion, subversion, and flight (a la maroons). I like to ground in a sense of realism for this, which is broadly where I bring together the ideas gestured at by things like <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materialism">materialism</a>, <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/physicalism/">physicalism</a>, and <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/naturalism/">naturalism</a>, with a more flexible and pluralistic onto-epistemology, that invites a multitude of belief systems. Said in a less philosophical way, I want to be honest about and aware of what is currently possible, along with imagining and working towards the positive things that can happen from the potentialities that exist, in a way that is culturally embodied, rather than vague and “universal”. The most flexibility comes from having a rich imagination paired with a sense of hope that understands the potentialities of the world. Things <em>may</em> get better, or they <em>may</em> not. But the fact that they <em>can</em> shows our opportunity to build the outcomes we want.</p><p>This orientation allows us to find fellow travelers through action rather than rhetoric. When you are out and about, doing your thing, pay attention to how others react to you. Who asks for “justification”? Who tries to become the “peace police”? On the other hand, who sides with you and yours and rides for y’all? What are the ways that each of these (groups of) folks see change happening, if at all? Why? Thinking about all of these things will help connect you and your actions to others.</p><p>One useful desire for our “constructive insurrection” would be to orient around communized control of our community.¹⁴ This would be grounded in solidarity-based formations that allow egoistic folks to exercise self-ownership over themselves and the spaces they occupy. I talk a bit about this in <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/738809081422331904/an-ecology-of-liberatory-movements?source=share">an ecology of liberatory movements</a>, and am greatly inspired by Lorenzo Kom’boa Ervin’s <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/lorenzo-kom-boa-ervin-community-control-of-the-poor-community.pdf">community control of the poor community</a>. Some basic ways we could work towards this are to (in no particular order, operationally speaking): (<strong>1</strong>) Establish (con)federations &amp; unions of workplaces, blocks, and neighborhoods, in whatever forms people find useful (could be councils, clubs, affinity groups, assemblies, summits, etc). (<strong>2</strong>) Orient in an insurrectionary, “attack &amp; steal” posture around the concepts of reparations, landback, and other meaningful, non-reformist “reforms”, where that Ungovernability comes in as the way we understand how we try to obtain those things. It’s not about begging for what is “owed” as much as it’s taking what is needed (or wanted more broadly!), directly fighting the multiple prongs of (settler) colonialism and coloniality, modernity, and capitalism. (<strong>3</strong>) A work program, in tandem with solidarity unions (and amenable socially-inserted unions more broadly) and cooperatives/worker-directed organizations so that people can autonomously support themselves in fulfilling work.¹⁵ (<strong>4</strong>) A conversion program for businesses¹⁶ —they can either choose to be based on solidarity and cooperation or become targets of expropriation. (<strong>5</strong>) Food sovereignty programs that allow for more self-sufficiency and resiliency regarding foodstuffs, via agroecology and other ecosystem-minded, non-industrial &amp; post-industrial agricultural initiatives. (<strong>6</strong>) Cooperative housing, “urban planning”¹⁷, and “Anarchitecture”¹⁸ should be employed alongside other living-area-based struggles. This is so that we can create new ways to relate to space that are aligned with how we want to live. (<strong>7</strong>) Liberatory schooling models for folks, so that learning and knowledge sharing becomes a core part of how people relate to the world. It might also be worthwhile to expropriate scholarships and grants from academies, so that people can “attack &amp; steal” from those as well. (<strong>8</strong>) organizing mutual aid, direct aid, and other solidarity projects for incarcerated people, working towards Prison Industrial Complex abolition. Everyone locked up and enslaved should be freed from their shackles and determine for themselves what life looks like.</p><p>All of these proposals would be grounded in decolonial/anticolonial, transfeminist, anti-authoritarian, anti-capitalist, ecological, and disability justice frameworks. These ideas can ground us in things we might aim for immediately and in the future. Community control as described showcases stuff we can fight for that is both meaningful currently and sets us up for further success.</p><p>I see all of these things happening through a “Compositional”¹⁹ <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset-based_community_development">Asset Based Community Development</a>. The gist is that communities would orient around what they already have²⁰ and build capacity from there. This would allow for an increase in those potentialities, where people can “compose” their organizing on material needs <em>and </em>resolve “issues”²¹ a la conventional activism. Material needs are important to address so that more people can self-determine and more capacity can be built towards meeting desires, in labor²² and other sectoral (community, school, etc) areas. Issue-based approaches are important because they can relate to the things that people are already working towards and are passionate about, but are potentially limited by a lack of economic, systems, and class analysis. They need to play off of one another. This becomes possible through cooperating with each other, rather than seeing things as a competition, where social change is understood as zero-sum. If folks are willing to compete for scraps, they should be <em>more</em> than willing to cooperate for the whole meal, if and when awareness and conditions are built for that to be an option.²³</p><p>All of this work towards building new ways of relating is meant to free us from the shackles of current paradigms and allow us to create new/different “genres of being” as Wynter says. We are looking to give the idea of decolonization the teeth it requires (or to return its teeth). It’s about building the structures we need, and abolishing the ones meant to oppress us.</p><h3>Are we doomed? Are we good enough? The fuck do we do?</h3><p>In all of this talk about world-weaving and establishing subjectivity, we have to contend with the fact that the Earth will look vastly different in a few years than it does now, and it currently looks quite different than it did even a few years ago. This necessitates many things, among which is a different understanding of time outside of the usual “market time”. Taking for granted the way that we relate to time under these colonial, workerist, neoliberal systems will lead us astray. We have to think across scales, from the past, to the near future, to multiple generations down the line. Thinking about time in a different way, interpreted through a more complex interplay of experiences, where we intentionally create meaning through story²⁴ may be more helpful than the uni-directional mechanistic march that is commonly espoused. This may come off as needlessly philosophical, but it is useful in framing all of the concepts that we’ve been discussing and will continue to discuss. In the ecological context for example, more flexible conceptions of time that shift based on the locus of interest (rather than <em>us</em> pivoting around a rigid conception of time) can make it easier to think about the timetable of our local environments, relating to them better than we could if we’re thinking in fiscal quarters. Rather than growing monocrops because of the yield it will get us during harvest season, we can think of agro-ecological methods like companion planting that increase biodiversity <em>and</em> yield diverse food options over a longer timespan, even if we have less of this or that crop during harvest season.</p><h3>Fuck Tha Anthropocene</h3><blockquote>“An egoist conception of ecology begins with the notion of the expansive self. […] the inner world, our thoughts and emotions, and the outer world, our phenomenality or sensory experience, [are] inseparable, as each reciprocally informs and defines the other. Insofar as identity can be said to exist, it is our perceptual totality, shifting from moment to moment. When we walk through the world, all that we touch and perceive is an extension of ourselves; conversely, there is no I that exists separately from our phenomenal experience. […] the self subsumes and is subsumed by the world, annihilating this subject/object <em>dichotomy</em> that alienates us from other beings and places.” — <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/bellamy-fitzpatrick-symbiogenetic-desire"><em>Symbiogenetic Desire: An Egoist Conception of Ecology</em></a> by Bellamy Fitzpatrick (emphasis mine)</blockquote><p>In our exploration of the colonial concepts that we have inherited, it becomes clear that there is a discrepancy between the ways that “humans” have negatively impacted the environment. How do we respond to this “Anthropocene”? Firstly, I’d like to say that we gotta go back to what it means to be a “human”! It’s interesting that, similar to the human nature conversation, my humanity is affirmed rather than plasticized only when it’s time to get lumped in with colonizer bullshit. This is not to say that there haven’t been other people who have caused harm to their environments in “antiquity” (folks love citing the <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221330542300036X#:~:text=Highlights%201%20%20Modern%20humans%20%28%20Homo%20sapiens%29,the%20first%20planet-wide%2C%20human-driven%20transformation%20of%20the%20environment.">late-Quaternary megafauna extinctions</a> to claim that a commitment against coloniality as articulated in this piece is grounded in a misguided, essentialist view of indigeneity &amp; pre-colonial history), but what we’re talking about in relation to capitalism and the fossil-fueled industrial revolution is something else entirely. It’s of a completely different scale, capacity, and motivation, coupled with a relatively intimate awareness of the impacts. Yes, I don’t like that there have been groups of people across the world and across time who have done sustained ecological harm, nor do I think that ecological harm is good when someone who looks like me does it. That acknowledgement doesn’t mean that it’s “okay” to prop up or absolve a society that has the most anti-life ethos we’ve ever seen (our current one), combined with an unprecedented technological capacity to act on it. The universal “human” invoked in this Anthropocene conversation is a joke to me, which is why I desire to chart out my own meaning for my existence. <em>This </em>is where our ecological conversations should start.</p><p>Sankofa²⁵ comes to mind as a useful orientation for this conversation. We are “retrieving” “past” lifeways and synchronizing them with information and abilities that we have now. Lots of our ancestry and other folks who embody Indigeneity had more meaningful connections with nature visavis not making an extreme bifurcation between people and nature (to the extent that some folks, like the Potawatomi, refer to what we might label as non-human with “they” pronoun signifiers,²⁶ giving the rest of the world a sense of vitality that colonial cultures reserve for humans, and God, I guess). To be clear, I am not making a claim that we all used to live in harmony until the colonial-imperialists attacked. There is just a precedent established in the fact that before European colonialism, there was more space for worldviews that allowed ecological respect. We need to tune into that resonant frequency.</p><p>We also have to be careful about porting over mainstream “environmentalist” and “conservationist” ideas for “environmental management”, because, you guessed it, those are <a href="https://grist.org/indigenous/30x30-world-conservation-model-colonialism-indigenous-peop/">mired in colonialism as well</a>! Something helpful to think about in moving towards environmental justice is to center the most marginal. This idea comes from Black Feminism (I originally learned it from <a href="https://archive.org/details/feministtheoryfr00hook">bell hooks</a>) and allows us to see our intersections²⁷ and positionalities²⁸, making sure that our desires don’t come at the expense of folks who are left out, even “at the bottom”. We can’t solve ecological crises through Eurocentric colonial exclusions by way of taxonomy.</p><p>One methodology that we can devour²⁹ towards ecological ends is social ecology. This is an orientation refined principally by Murray Bookchin meant to reconcile human society with the rest of nature. One of the core contributions that Bookchin has made in ecological thought with this theory is the idea that ecological problems stem from social problems. Even if that’s not “true”³⁰, it is a useful starting point to orient ourselves ecologically. There is an interplay between the rise of humans dominating other humans and humans dominating the rest of nature. Social ecology’s philosophical foundation is <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/murray-bookchin-the-philosophy-of-social-ecology">dialectical naturalism</a>, a way of understanding Hegel’s dialectical thought as a process where the universe is, in its potentialities, developing more subjectivity and particularity.³¹ Bookchin might say that the universe is becoming self-conscious. This is meant to “organicize” the dialectic, moving us away from the “mechanistic” conceptions found in dialectical materialism, especially post-Marx, if we read him in (really) good faith. It’s the difference between claiming something <em>must</em> or <em>will</em> happen (how dialectical materialism is articulated by many), and claiming something <em>can</em> happen. If you’re not familiar with dialectics, the basic idea³² is that contradictions exist in everything (or said otherwise, that everything exists in relation to everything else, and those relations come with tensions). Enter the heuristic language to try and apprehend how things in the universe function.</p><p>For any particular “thing”, be it a subject, object, phenomena, or process, there is a developmental pattern where the “being” (the “thing” being focused on/locus of interest) comes to contact contradicts and a “nothing”.³³ This tension creates a coalescence where the two “become”/“create”/establish (this process of change referred to as “becoming”) a new “being”. This leads to a new dynamic where our focus shifts to this “combined” “being”, and the cycle repeats. This coalescence doesn’t have to look like a “meeting in the middle”, where there is parity in representation from previously “opposing” sides. It can be mutualistic, commensalistic, amensalistic, parasitic, predatory, competitive, or cooperative. It can also lead to more than one “being”, or lead to different qualitative changes with the two “beings” that come into contact. It’s all about perspective and vantage point.</p><p>A simplified, metaphorical example of this might be a seed… a tiny, dormant little plant with many potentialities: it may become a strong plant, it may not get the nutrients it needs and dies, it could become food for some animal, etc. This is the “being” we will focus on. It’s negation, the “nothing” that it comes in contact with is the soil. It lacks the form and potentialities of the seed, but it also has necessary nutrients for the seed to embody a subjective or particular potentiality, its growth into the plant that it can “become”.³⁴ Through this contact, the germination of the seed in the soil leads to little growths, a seed “becoming” a sprouting plant. This may lead to more negations, where the plant reaches the end of its life, dying and returning nutrients into the soil, from which more seeds can sprout. A “Being” comes into contact with “Nothing”, “Becoming” a “new” “Being”, over and over again.</p><p>This dialectical orientation sets us up nicely for “egoizing” our ecological thought. The core piece of this is a commitment to relationality and becoming. This is meant to “unsettle” any abstractions that are given to us “from above” by some authority figure³⁵ we may or may not have awareness of. By using this tool of relationality, I can build towards having new, more specific ways to relate to the environment; if I can relate to myself and others egoistically, I can base my treatment of others on the uniqueness or particularity/subjectivity/individuality of that which I am interacting with.</p><p>This approach works to occlude authoritarian and hierarchical ways of relating, because those modes of being don’t “unsettle” current paradigms. ³⁶ We are trying to inhabit a more voluntary, complete egoism that is unburdened by “settled” paradigms. This is not a call for us to throw away everything that we perceive as being connected to or touched by coloniality. I see a desire to “return” to a “pure state” equally reactionary to coloniality, with no liberatory potentialities. I’m not gonna decry science or philosophy ad infinitum just because white dudes have monopolized those fields (and created those disciplinary boundaries) via ontocide and epistemicide. I will, however, treat those worldviews and modes of understanding with the criticality that they have earned by their (1) incongruencies with reality and (2) centrality in wider apparatuses of immiseration to colonized peoples.</p><p>If we align or find resonance³⁷ with “universal” abstractions and “fixed” ideas that (we perceive as) com(e)(ing) from Eurocentric sources, such as beauty, love, or altruism, it doesn’t “violate some egoist code” to feel these things or embody them. The issue is when <em>they</em> embody <em>us</em>.</p><h3>Pulling up with the ego</h3><p>At this point, it could be useful to define some things. What do I mean by egoism? What is ego? Ego is an expansive form of desire. It is the ever shifting, ephemeral, unique individual’s self-interest. The main components of this interest or desire are the spiritual/intuitive, r(el)ational, physical/sensual, and emotional.</p><p>To zoom in here, the spiritual and intuitive dimensions are appealing to soulful elements of desire: the things that fit into your values, principles, and ethics (if you find those useful), what drives your purpose, and gives you inspiration. All of these are framed in a culturally relevant way, and thus will look different from person to person, with similarities appearing between folks who share cultural features and rituals.</p><p>The rational and relational are about appealing to the head. This is where reason, facts, and logic, interpreted both in the mainstream sense³⁸ and expansive, counter-hegemonic senses,³⁹ are valued. Things like providing data, statistics, <em>context</em>, and evidence, with an appeal towards problem-solving abilities will go far with this dimension of desire.</p><p>The physical and sensual dimension are all about having material needs met. It’s about making sure people are fed, housed, clothed, comfortable, stimulated, and safe. These are very practical (see tangible) and generally immediate concerns.</p><p>The emotional dimension is about appealing to the heart. This is where empathy, emotionality, and sociality thrive.</p><p>All of these facets make up what I am referring to when I am talking about desire. I am not just talking about one facet in an isolated manner, conceived of as something to “be achieved” within a specific time window. I look at it as a holistic, interconnected and interpenetrated endeavor, where the totality of all of these come together in an emergent way to create desire. If all of these elements exist in relation to each other, desire is the “greater than the sum of its parts” phenomenon that occurs as the result of those interactions.</p><p>If we want to supersede the negative aspects of the hierarchical cultures that we’re subjugated to, we may do well to start understanding this expansive sense of desire as it relates to the alternate conception of time I discussed earlier. It is the subjective or particular understanding that only we can have in a given moment of our needs. This points us towards constructing an outcome that respects all of our selves and the things that we care about to the best of our ability. One facet of us won’t become something that rules over us. We don’t want to chase momentary highs to screw our future selves over, or wait for pleasure at the expense of current experience. We have to decide for ourselves what is important to us, and look critically, thinking deeply about why we made that choice, so as to ensure that we are not operating in a dominating way over ourselves or others.</p><p>Egoism is the overall framework I employ to satisfy my ego, as defined above. It’s how I get to what I want, informed by a sense of realism. In other words, it’s grounded–an acknowledgement that the way I access self-ownership is informed by and impacted by what I have done, what I have experienced, what is possible, and what has been done to me. This is not to say that these things are deterministic⁴⁰. It is an acknowledgement that we are connected to the world around us, so even radically imaginative conceptions of upheaval must account for this. This leaves the door kinda open. If egoism is how I get to my desire, what does that <em>mean</em>? It might be illuminating to talk about what it doesn’t. We are not talking about ethical egoism or psychological egoism.</p><p>Ethical egoism is the idea that morality comes from self interest, generally defined as “what works for one’s narrow gain in the current moment”. I’m not (self-)interested in this because I don’t give a shit about morality for its own sake, nor do I want to create a new “moral framework”. I want to do something because <em>I </em>find value in it, not because I am <em>told</em> to find value in it or I feel the need to justify it based on some code, to generalize and abstract it for the sake of absolving my guilt.⁴¹</p><p>Psychological egoism is the idea that we are always acting in our self-interest. In this framework, by virtue of acting, we are embodying selfishness. We are egoists by nature of acting in the world, with the rationalistic assumption being that our actions always align with our own reproduction (in the socioeconomic and biological sense). This is self-fulfilling in a way that doesn’t yield useful results… it doesn’t point us towards a better understanding of ourselves, each other, or the things that exist around us. If I am always acting in my own self interest, then what’s the point of “unsettling” anything??? Why try to change my lot if I’m already doing what I want? Psychological egoism may hold an unintentional weight, insofar we are acting for <em>someone’s</em> ego, even if it’s not our own (I’m doing x thing because of my family/country/partner/career obligation). It may be useful <em>if</em> your desires fit nicely into the status quo. For those of us upon which the status quo is built and is defined in opposition to, this isn’t tenable. Both of these egoisms may have their uses, but at best they are food for understanding my own egoism better.</p><p>I also separate egoism(s) from egotism, though obvious resonances exist. Egotism’s method to satisfy ego is patently narrow, where one tries to satisfy ego <em>through</em> domination. It is a zero sum orientation that I have no interest in. I am skeptical of being able to fulfill my desires holistically if I am orienting in zero-sum, domineering, oppressive, and coercive ways. Even in the short term, this just feels like a fruitless pursuit.</p><h3>Self-insert</h3><p>Egoism is about me living out my particularity or radical subjectivity in a way that doesn’t deny other people the ability to live out theirs.⁴² It is meant for me to think deeply about my actions and judge if I am doing them for myself or for some higher power I am subscribing to, whether that subscription is conscious or unconscious. It is a check to make sure my motivations for action are <em>my </em>motivations. If I love someone, it is because I <em>want</em> to, not because I <em>have</em> to. It’s an orientation meant to foster deep connections <em>and/while</em> protect(ing) against interpersonal and structural abuses. It also gives me the ability to understand the “inner workings” of those things more clearly by situating them in relation to my desires. Whenever I am faced with a choice, I am judging it against my desires while working to “unsettle the coloniality” of those desires so that they aren’t harmful to myself and others.</p><p>This is motivated by an interest in creating specific, unique relationships to the world around me, with as much fidelity as I can muster. My uniqueness is my totality, and by acting on that, I can create a practice and method that allows for deeper and more enriching embodiments and explorations of my ego. It is building an awareness of myself and the world that I am connected to, so that I can relate to it in a way that isn’t self-sacrificial, whether that is sacrificing my future self to my current self, my current self to my past self, or any of myselves to “the world” in an abstract sense. I am trying to get under those abstractions, to see what is happening under the hood, so that I can be present and unburdened. It is through this process that I see utility in creation along with negation. This is why I actively struggle to imagine and make a new world, rather than just raging against the current one. There’s a lot of reasons for this, but the most salient one to me is the fact that someone else will, whether I decide to or not. We are currently living in a world sparked by someone’s imagination. People created this world with intention (even if every aspect of it didn’t come about intentionally). It takes intention to “unsettle”.</p><p>My voluntary egoism, where I am (building) aware(ness) of my desire and choosing how to engage with it in a way that “unsettles” reality, is bound(ed) by other people. If everyone around me has a shit life, no matter how materially sound and stable I am, that tension will sour things. If I focus on getting <em>stuff</em>, chasing the bag and shit like that, the idea of bag-chasing easily becomes a new fixed idea, an abstraction that rules over me. It’s replacing my desires with the desires of those who benefit from the ideology of capital. Being a consumerist in that sense is like living in a massive gilded cage. Being in a relatively small shitty cage currently, the gilded cage is “better”, but we’re greedy over here. I’m tryna blow up all the cages so I ain’t gotta worry about myself (and by nature of the act anybody else) being put in one. I want to destroy atomization and build a sense of deep relatedness with other unique individuals. My self-ownership is bounded by how much other people have an awareness of their self-ownership.</p><p>To state this in a slightly different way, I’d like to lean on Audre Lorde’s <a href="https://uk.sagepub.com/sites/default/files/upm-binaries/11881_Chapter_5.pdf">The Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power</a>. Lorde understands the erotic, a great word to use interchangeably with how I’ve used desire or ego, as “a true knowledge, […] the first and most powerful guiding light toward any understanding”. The erotic orbits around the idea of getting in touch with “feminine and spiritual dimensions” of our desire, a marked difference from Eurocentric conceptions of how to relate to the self. Eurocentrism subordinates these ideas to objectivity and reason, where emotions and the inspired spirit are generally seen as annoyances to be sublimated. There are resonances with how Lorde describes “sensation without feeling” in regards to different conceptions of the erotic than the one she’s articulating and how I think of “egotism”, where folks are ashamed of their desire, or misapply desire to short term domineering pursuits such as private property or popularity. We might find value in working towards an “erotic as power” or “intentional egoism”, where we use the erotic (or how I’ve described ego) to point us towards what we want.</p><p>This leads to my egoism having an expansive character, where we are able to work for what we want beyond “superficial” “sensations”. This expansive orientation acknowledges how we as people are interconnected to the world at large. We are shaped by and shape the world. This doesn’t mean that we have to be subsumed by the world, though. My egoism is a generative creativity, where I’m starting from a place of “creative nothing”, existing as an embodiment of dialectical negation for the “being” of modernity, coloniality, and kkkapitalism. This is the “dark power” I talked about earlier. Being severed from humanity via the “overrepresentation of Man” Wynter discusses keys me into the <em>power</em> that can come from having no “essential” properties. I can remake myself constantly. I am constituted by conscious activity. Each moment gives me a different name. I am like an etch-a-sketch; no matter what has been drawn on me, I have the potential to reconfigure myself to fit new situations and desires from moment-to-moment.⁴³</p><p>Black folks are put in this position naturally by the antiblack ableist cisheteropatriarchal world-system. If we are to affirm our existence, rather than running from our current positionality, we should see the power and potential it presents — the ability to fight for ourselves, accessing a freedom that we are positioned to experience in a way only we can illuminate.</p><h3>Selfishness ain’t all bad</h3><p>Egoism might be a provocative way to refer to this idea since it colloquially has a lot of overlap with the idea of egotism. Part of my goal is to reclaim the ideas embedded in conceptions of how we relate to our egos, to get away from the shame of wanting things, since we won’t stop wanting things. Shame, while having its place in social life, tends to prevent healthy engagements with our desire when we self-generate it. I separate egoism and egotism since there is room for my egoism to exist in a much more expansive form than that. I genuinely believe that the way to reach my desire is to destroy coloniality, even with the understanding that it is a system of domination, existing outside of the range of individual power. I want to bridge the gap between myself and the world I am alienated from as much as I can to facilitate this shift. Again, this is not egotism, as trying to reach my desire through neoliberal individualism like that furthers alienation. I am not trying to “earn” the “right” to embody and experience my desire, especially in a social Darwinist, “survival of the fittest” sense, where the capacity for self-actualization is quantized to moral or ethical character. That formulation will always return low numbers for me, as I am not seen as a being with either of those properties, except for when it’s time to discuss humanity’s ills or get my culture appropriated. However, as a being who does exist and has desire (irrespective of what modernity, coloniality, etc has to say about it), I am a being self-actualized. My journey is about being able to embody that in a fuller way, to truly <em>feel</em> those <em>sensations</em> that come from listening to my ego, my desire.</p><p>Again, relationality is a very useful heuristic to have in our “mental toolbox” for this effort. My desire is bounded by the ability for people who share my life-station to fulfill their desire. I want us all to be egoists in our own ways. The power that we employ together can be described as finding power-within to employ our power-to as power-with, rather than sublimating our power-within to wield power-over others (or the more likely case of being led). Power-over leads to subjugation to abstract ideals, systems, and people, whether it’s through a “unity at all costs” collectivism, or the egotism of individualism. We have to be really careful that we don’t fall into this dichotomous trap if we are looking to destroy the oppressive structures that exist.</p><blockquote>“[…] I am a communist because I am a greedy motherfucker. I don’t aspire to own the means of production just to better my quality of life; I want to own the means because I want to be the owner. I want to own of the entire wealth and culture of society. I want the world to be my property. I want it all.”– <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/ralph-leonard-egoism-the-basis-for-communism">Egoism: The Basis for Communism</a> by Ralph Leonard</blockquote><p>The importance of the individual here is not meant to deny connection; it’s the opposite. What better way to facilitate connections than through desire? If it’s based on what I <em>want</em> to do, rather than what I <em>have</em> to do, it’s going to hit different. This seems like a much more durable method of building connection than relying on things like “familial ties”, “national obligation”, “social status”, or “work duties”. These universals are a useful way for the cultures that rule to reproduce themselves, but aren’t the only available modes of cultural reproduction. Even my position about orienting around desire is grounded in the subversive cultures that I’m pulling from and spotlighting, where even something like taking out the trash can be desirable in a context that makes it so.⁴⁴ The stance taken against universalisms and abstractions is not meant to decry their utility in total,⁴⁵ but to have a better, more critical and intentional method to relate to the things positioned as “universals”, with the <em>capacity and capability </em>to destroy them as needed. My understanding is that the supermajority of these abstractions are getting trashed. But there may be utility in some of them (or rather, we may contextually keep heuristics and models where they are useful). I just want to make sure that we see these things as tools or helpers, and not become <em>their </em>tools. To use some science/logic terminology: evidence should trump hypotheses, not the other way around.</p><p>This flexible orientation is supremely important to me, given the fact that I have conditions applied to me, that I can’t “ignore”. Antiblackness and all of its co-constitutive elements deny me the “right” to “humanity”, but I desire to experience all of the ideas (and more) that people are getting at when they speak on such rights as “freedom”, “equality”, “humanity”, “human potential”, and so on. Since these ideals were established in contradiction <em>and </em>contradistinction to my being, they aren’t accessible or legible to me in the world as it stands. I don’t want to focus on what I “am” in the current paradigms, but what I “could be” under different conditions that I (co-)create.</p><p>I see this discussion to a certain extent as inspired by Max Stirner’s <a href="https://files.libcom.org/files/Stirner_The_Ego_and_Its_Own.pdf">The Ego and Its Own</a>, where the egoism there is interested in a critique of modernity and the “sacred”. I, on a sibling path to Saint Max, am working towards a non-methodological method, a hypercritical (set of) heuristic(s) for rebuilding relationships, rather than seeing it as <em>just</em> a project of negation.⁴⁶ I want to build as well as destroy. From where I stand, it is more about about change and dialectical development operating as or on a horizon of “becoming” (as in things changing over space-time, never really “arriving” at an “endpoint”), rather than focusing on establishing a new “being” (a thing as what it is, which suggests a lack of change, or a fixedness). So, by using the power of my positionality as a “creative nothing”, I seek to chart out a new “becoming”, against a colonial “being”. I don’t want to throw away my “properties”; I want to make them my “property”. I want to build my own relationship to all of the facets of myself, and the I that is what I interact with, informed by the deep histories and current, situated realities of those “properties”, “objects”, “subjects”, and actions. I don’t want to be haunted by morals, religions, laws, or other ideals that sit above me, uncaring for my desire. I want, if I <em>choose</em> to engage with those things, to use them as they remain useful. If I start to dampen my internal flame for the sake of conformity, then I will start to become alienated from myself.</p><p>I want to be clear about how I relate to the concept of “the self”. I see Eurocentric conceptions as trying “to earn” the self. When we base our value on things outside of us,⁴⁷ when we work on reifying abstractions, we “understand” self-actualization through an arduous journey of working hard (at least in many Eurocentric contexts, due to Protestant work ethics being wedded to capitalism’s core drives). This is <em>ending</em> at the self (seeing it as something we arrive at). This can lead to the kind of vulgar/narrow ego(t)ism that we discussed, where we don’t have the ability to see how fraught with contradictions, both dialectical and logical, our approach to finding ourselves is in those modes. At the very least, in imperial, statist, capitalist paradigms, these modes of being congeal into an unsightly mass. This can create a bounded dichotomy, where the options are seeing people as silos or cogs (isolated individualism or flattening collectivism). Both are inadequate responses to the information &amp; experiences that life gives us. Neither will “save” us. The reality is that we are not alone, and we <em>are</em> singular.</p><p>On the other hand, I <em>start</em> with an understanding that I am a self. I determine myself, I assert myself, I actualize myself. Rather than following some multi-step program to reach a humanistic Enlightenment, I follow what I desire in the present. Insofar as there is a journey, it is a battle against coloniality. It is creating space for that self-determination. It is fulfilling my desire, while expanding my understanding of what that looks like. This is in opposition to passively “going along” with things, which sows the seeds of domination, leading to people who are “included” in the ideal and those who are “excluded”. It’s thinking so deeply of yourself that “others” stop being “othered”.</p><p>My understanding is better thought of as relative, operating in assemblages, networks, rhizomes, and arrays, rather than linear or fixed. I am working towards “devouring” the world around me, seeing things for their uniqueness, interconnections, and permeations so that I can better position myself. Any categories that are employed are meant to be helpful in this pursuit. In this process of “devouring”, I don’t desire control or domination over the world. Nor do I want to engender a flimsy “unity” that has to be held together with authoritarianism. This “devouring” acknowledges the interconnections between, intrinsic value, and use value of those around me. Do I command what I eat? That would be a weird way to think of it. I appreciate the land and communities in which I reside for taking care of and constantly remaking me. I understand, however crudely, that while the universe wouldn’t be the same without me, I wouldn’t be able to exist without the universe. I understand that any labels, associations, categories, or definitions are tools, at best a sketch or snapshot of a moment in time, rather than the thing that they are representing. My name doesn’t contain <em>me</em>, but it helps point towards <em>me</em>.</p><p>To connect with others, I create unique relationships and formations that are meant to serve a particular purpose, which can be as simple as “because I felt like it”. Unity, or what I feel might more accurately be called (material) solidarity, should come from the “expansive” egoism that I’ve been describing. In a political context, for example, theoretical, tactical, and strategic alignment should come from the desire of connecting more voluntarily with my ego/erotic, rather than things such as morals, obligations, commitments, etc. <em>If</em> those come from being an egoist, then it is fine. Otherwise, in my view, we are creating reifications with the potential to have a mind of their own. Again, we greedy. I want to have the benefits of experiencing meaningful community and culture, without the drawbacks of abuse and bigotry. I think this expansive egoism I’m chatting about is a method for me to work my way “out” from myself towards those things, creating stronger bonds along the way. I want to make those properties my property.</p><p>The fact that we can move from the individual to material solidarity is critical. Collective action is the only way for people categorically excluded from power to either commandeer the space or create a new one. A hyper atomized conception of self-hood is a non-starter when we have this in mind. Being in community with each other allows for us to embody our egos, using our desire as power. Without this, the overarching structures will hold us back from ourselves.⁴⁸</p><p>I want to create a world where radical subjectivity and particularity are celebrated. Note that radical is meant as roots-grasping, rather than its misused paramour, “extremism”. I’m looking to “radicalize” subjectivity as a concept, part of which is fighting against “objectification”, and part of which is inoculating against a tendency to “valorize” narrow conceptions of the individual at the expense of deeper connections with desire. This necessitates, in my view, a sense of self-determination and a communistic horizon. I want to destroy or “unsettle” coloniality, to create space to live in and live out my desires. This “unsettling” isn’t meant to be “against” love, or belief, or community, or any other concepts that have emerged under colonial hegemonies. More accurately, if you find value in an aspect of love, I’m not trying to tell you that your personal relationship with love is bad or Eurocentric. I’m just saying that you should be sure of what you mean when you say that, and let go of all of the ideological baggage that is bound up in that concept, since the parts that you like are usually used to sneak in the parts that keep you dominated. I am taking a stance against the manifestations of those ideas that create relations of dominion. When these ideas occupy a place of authority, where they are being justified <em>because</em> of their identification as a virtue/value/ethic etc, that’s what I don’t fuck with. For anything that currently rests as a fixed abstraction or concept, if you find utility in it, and it doesn’t dominate you, great. Otherwise, I rail against that shit <em>because</em> I desire to chart out my own existence. A communist horizon facilitates this turn, allowing us to point towards ourselves and each other rather than being a tool of some “higher power”. Communism as a horizon fits into our orientation of “creative nothing” as the grounding towards “becoming”. We negate so that we can create.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>The egoism discussed is, at its foundation, an orientation that is meant to enable engagement with the world on my terms <em>and</em> its terms. It is very easy to mistake maps for territories (to refer to another Wynter essay title), so I am looking to figure out how to get rid of shoddy maps, and to take territories for what they are, keeping in mind what I want. I am simultaneously looking to embody my desire without letting it overtake me. I want to own my desire, rather than it taking a life of its own.</p><p>This egoism has to take on an anti-colonial/decolonial character, because many other conceptions of egoism (that are labeled as such) are couched (with)in the confines of coloniality. To “unsettle” coloniality, I act from a place of “creative nothing”, making spaces conducive to “becoming”, our hopeful horizon of radically subjective, communistic development. I can’t just assume that my liberation will come from personal action in the Eurocentric individualist sense. I also understand the importance of autonomous individuals in any effective action.</p><p>This egoism, with its decolonial character, does not assume an isolated person in the sense of a “closed system”, as that is not reality. Reality is interconnections, intersections, and imbrications, in a messy assemblage. This egoism is trying to start from a place of valuing autonomy to build more meaningful connections. Put simply, if I’m hanging out with you because I rock with you, both of us are going to have a better experience than if a parent, patriarch, or patriot told us to.</p><p>Non-committal commitment, or non-attaching attachment is how I’d describe the way I want to relate to things. I want to feel things deeply, to connect intimately with the world around me. Rather than a (conventionally) hedonistic sprint away from pain, or a numb, cold and calculating acceptance (or avoidance to through rationalization) of it, I want to embrace pain. Risking the pain from “losing” something that I’ve intimately connected to is part of that deeper connection I’m looking for. If I want to make my “properties” my “property”, this is a potential stop on that journey as an egoistic person. As I am more willing to feel my emotions and explore my desires in general, keeping in mind all the risks associated with vulnerability, I can have ownership of those emotional highs and lows, with awareness that they won’t and shouldn’t last forever. If loss completely ruins me, or if I get lost in an emotional peak, neurodivergence notwithstanding, that is a sign that the way I’m relating to that other unique individual, whether it is a person, place, or thing, may not be as egoistic as I’d want it to be.</p><p>This connects in a very meaningful way to social change. Egoism can’t fight alone. I see egoism as a dialectical (or dialectical-devouring) movement between the individual ego, egoist formations, and egoist culture. We’ve said a lot about ego here, so hopefully you can follow what I mean on that front. Egoist formations are about building group relationships with people that everyone is able to exercise ownership over. Egoist cultures are the ways that we describe these relationships, reproduce them, and embody them. These things all play together to create that effect of building meaningful connection while still fostering individuality. This interplay describes the scaffolding of egoistic movements and practice.</p><p>If you asked me to describe my egoism in one word, it’d be “intentionality”.</p><p>This path I’ve laid out is the one I’d like to travel. It will, if I don’t fuck it up, help me to “unsettle” paradigms that hold down me and mine, and allow for me to have a good time while doing it.</p><h3>References</h3><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_jeopardy">Multiple jeopardy</a>, Wikipedia</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1852/18th-brumaire/ch01.htm">18th Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte</a>, Karl Marx</p><p>Fate/Stay Night</p><p>Naruto</p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1845/theses/index.htm">Theses On Feuerbach</a>, Karl Marx</p><p><a href="https://archive.org/details/brown-emergent-strategyfullbook">Emergent Strategy: Shaping Change, Changing Worlds</a>, adrienne maree brown</p><p><a href="https://docdro.id/KInN3Vn">Unsettling the Coloniality of Being/Power/Truth/Freedom: Towards the Human, After Man, Its Overrepresentation — An Argument</a>, Sylvia Wynter</p><p><a href="https://archive.org/details/BlackSkinWhiteMasksFrantzFanon/page/n3/mode/2up">Black Skin, White Masks</a>, Frantz Fanon</p><p><a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/2023/02/16/black-americans-views-on-transgender-and-nonbinary-issues/">Black Americans’ views on transgender and nonbinary issues | Pew Research Center</a>, Kiana Cox</p><p><a href="https://x.com/disrupthehuman/status/1506353325561761796?s=20">For Those Seeking or in Flight: Black Trans*feminist Nihilism</a>, g</p><p><a href="https://redvoice.news/not-fox-not-wolf-but-the-wildcat/">Not Fox, Not Wolf, But the Wildcat</a>, N.Z. Suekama</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materialism">Materialism</a>, Wikipedia</p><p><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/physicalism/">Physicalism</a>, Daniel Stoljar</p><p><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/naturalism/">Naturalism</a>, David Papineau</p><p><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/738809081422331904/an-ecology-of-liberatory-movements?source=share">An ecology of liberatory movements</a>, Dip</p><p><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/lorenzo-kom-boa-ervin-community-control-of-the-poor-community.pdf">Community Control of the Poor Community: An Organising Manual for Community Activists</a>, Lorenzo Kom’boa Ervin</p><p><a href="https://illwill.com/composition">The Strategy of Composition</a>, Hugh Farrell</p><p><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/bellamy-fitzpatrick-symbiogenetic-desire">Symbiogenetic Desire: An Egoist Conception of Ecology</a>, Bellamy Fitzpatrick</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset-based_community_development">Asset-based community development</a>, Wikipedia</p><p><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221330542300036X#:~:text=Highlights%201%20%20Modern%20humans%20%28%20Homo%20sapiens%29,the%20first%20planet-wide%2C%20human-driven%20transformation%20of%20the%20environment.">Megafauna extinctions in the late-Quaternary are linked to human range expansion, not climate change</a>, Rhys Taylor Lemoine, Robert Buitenwerf, Jens-Christian Svenning</p><p><a href="https://www.booksfree.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/9781571313560.pdf">Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Teachings of Plants</a>, Robin Wall Kimmerer</p><p><a href="https://grist.org/indigenous/30x30-world-conservation-model-colonialism-indigenous-peop/">How the world’s favorite conservation model was built on colonial violence</a>, Joseph Lee</p><p><a href="https://archive.org/details/feministtheoryfr00hook">Feminist theory from margin to center</a>, bell hooks</p><p><a href="https://kersplebedeb.com/posts/pathology-of-patriarchy/">Pathology of Patriarchy: A Search for Clues at the Scene of the Crime</a>, Sanyika Shakur</p><p><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/murray-bookchin-the-ecology-of-freedom#toc3">The Ecology of Freedom</a>, Murray Bookchin</p><p><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/murray-bookchin-the-philosophy-of-social-ecology">The Philosophy of Social Ecology: Essays on Dialectical Naturalism</a>, Murray Bookchin</p><p><a href="https://uk.sagepub.com/sites/default/files/upm-binaries/11881_Chapter_5.pdf">The Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power</a>, Audre Lorde</p><p><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/ralph-leonard-egoism-the-basis-for-communism">Egoism: The Basis for Communism</a>, Ralph Leonard</p><p><a href="https://files.libcom.org/files/Stirner_The_Ego_and_Its_Own.pdf">The Ego and Its Own</a>, Max Stirner</p><h3>Footnotes</h3><ol><li>This is an idea coined by Claude Dennis to articulate the ways in which Eurocentric perspectives are centered in… everything.</li><li>Throughout this essay, I toy with “morally dubious” ideas to point out how nonsensical they are for people who are left outside of the confines of humanity (not meant in a one-dimensional sense; this is my attempt to point towards the fact that Blackness is specifically treated as a site of “plastic” humanity, where we can be subhuman, superhuman, or human depending on the situation. This is ultimately dehumanizing, since we are not allowed to just… be).. I’m looking at this reality to point towards how ridiculous those fixed concepts are.</li><li>I am using subject here to refer to the idea of a being capable of having whatever we consider to be “consciousness” in the human-centered sense. I do this somewhat cheekily, as I am not convinced of the utility of exalting homo sapiens as a species, or narrowly taking human experiences of consciousness as the only valid mode. I’m interested in self-determination for Black folks — so I use this familiar language to gesture at that, as limited as it is. I also don’t want to rush towards an object oriented ontology, since we have to directly address coloniality no matter what our conceptions of being and becoming are.</li><li>Object is everything else in the universe besides those who can hold subjectivity, as defined earlier.</li><li>This is important, not for the sake of reifying anthropomorphic conceptions of “being”, but to say that, for Black folks, we can not abolish the subject/object dichotomy <em>just</em> by equating everything in the universe to objects, even if those objects are considered to (or do) have a sense of vitality, essence, or “life”. This articulates the differences between trying to resolve difference by reaching for equality or acknowledging difference for the sake of building complementarity grounded in interdependence and contextuality. Orienting around subjects in this way is meant to dialectically move towards a syncretic perspective in which we (1) appreciate the agency of objects a la the insights provided by an animism, object oriented ontology, new materialism, and/or speculative realism, we (2) address the unique position Blackness has in the construction of the concept of “human”, and (3) the unique capacities that Homo sapiens have to radically change and interact with material and social conditions. It’s moving towards an appreciation of the vitality of the universe and its constituent elements <em>through</em> getting in touch with the ability to deeply embody ownership of the self and its relationships.</li><li>This is not to say that “humans” don’t exist (everyone that we think of being in this biological species is definitely in this biological species), but that our common understanding of what it means to be human is defined using White cis men as the standard, language, and primary mode of access. This creates problems when we take a particular form of embodiment and assume that everything has to be compared to that.</li><li>Wynter is referring to the ways that (valid) knowledges are created in the quoted section, but I believe that this refers to all of the things that are touched by coloniality.</li><li>This is another way to articulate the dark power concept from earlier. It is simultaneously acknowledging Black existence outside of mainstream political and social fulfillment, while holding the fact that there is a possibility for those things within a different paradigm that we co-create. This doesn’t take the social realities of Blackness in antiblack systems for granted, and therefore acknowledges the ways that change can happen. By understanding social realities as having meaningful impact on and influenced by sociogenic, ontogenetic, and phylogenetic conceptions (to refer to Fanon and Wynter’s explorations), we can acknowledge what is currently happening <em>and</em> craft responses that don’t keep us trapped within the bounds of thinking and acting with/in the same philosophical and practical terms of the oppressors.</li><li>If we focus on a mythological, monolithic, or a disembodied, philosophical picture of Black folks, rather than having our thoughts rooted in actual experiences of actual human beings, we are much more likely to uncritically assume the perspectives of the dominant systems, which deny the very categories of being (the ability to create meaning and knowing) to Black folks.</li><li>Opinion polls are flawed but can be useful as a “from above” starting point to understand certain dynamics in society. Pew’s <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/2023/02/16/black-americans-views-on-transgender-and-nonbinary-issues/">Black Americans’ views on transgender and nonbinary issues</a> is a useful way to open the conversation on some of the contradictions (in the dialectical sense) that we face in our Black communities, here in the “US”.</li><li>There is a really important point to be made here about the ways in which Unity is engendered, and how it in many cases takes for granted the categories made by the oppressor classes. Building unity uncritically along these lines leads to authoritarianism.</li><li>If we leave out the most marginal in our spaces, especially along the lines of ignorance or disdain for people who bypass binaries around gender, sexuality, or embodiment, we forsake ourselves. We have to orient <em>around</em> creating spaces of belonging with the different sections of our diaspora, rather than treating it as a nicety or appendage to our “primary concerns”.</li><li>Take centering here to mean abolishing the current center. This is not a project of creating a “new world Order”. It is abolishing Order as such — a world where people currently experiencing multiple jeopardies can feel safe and happy and cared for is where centralized power goes to die. The center evoked here is about energy, focus, and how we craft our knowledges, rather than placing non-monied Black maGes in seats of parliamentary power or some shit. It’s (self-)determination, not assimilation or integration.</li><li>This could be any version of community, which I’ll define in the broadest sense (people who exist in relation to one another). In this context, I’m referring to geographic communities like blocks and neighborhoods. Note that we tend to be very good at valorizing community, but it is not faultless. “Community”, when thought of solely on that level of complexity (as a homogenous unit/bloc) can erase the ways that people on the margins can be forgotten about (for example, do you consider houseless folks in your area to be your “neighbors”?). We have to be careful when employing this idea, so that we are able to surpass any limitations that the framework provides.</li><li>We shouldn’t force people to do things they don’t wanna. If there are “shit jobs”, or jobs that are understood to be otherwise unappealing that are deemed necessary, we figure out ways to distribute the labor.</li><li>This assumes that the businesses do something that, at the very least, has kernels of liberatory potential in it. We might want to convert a local restaurant into a decommodified food sharing space, for example. In contrast, we might decide that a pollutive factory isn’t something that we want to have, so we would shut that down.</li><li>Urban planning here is meant in the broadest sense, where we are thinking of ways to inhabit and shape the built environment. For our purposes, this would be from the “constructive insurrection” approach, where we understand the coloniality of urban planning and figure out how we can combat neo-colonial development practices and establish liberatory ones.</li><li>Anarchitecture is taking an anarchistic approach to our built environment, where it becomes something that is ecological, flexible, and participatory. It’s maximizing the ability for the people using and/or occupying a space to dictate how it functions.</li><li>I am referring to the essay “<a href="https://illwill.com/composition">The Strategy of Composition • Ill Will</a>”, in which Farrell discusses the ways that different sections of a movement can “compose” into a cohesive whole. I am appropriating this idea, devouring it into my own framework. For me, this is about building solidarity from the ground up, working with/in the tensions that exist between different blocs of a given grouping, building unified action that embodies the negation of authoritarianism. We might achieve this by trying to resolve (or sit with) those tensions in ways that point towards the flourishing of the folks that are the most marginal in our composition. To give a concrete example, we might, if there are people who are sexist in our composition, center the needs of the maGes harmed, rather than trying to uphold unity by protecting/absolving those causing harm, for the sake of strengthening our composition-long term vis a vis our anti-oppressive stances.</li><li>This is both what people quite literally have access to right now, and what can be obtained, in the sense of possibility, based on current conditions, in relatively short order. If there’s an easy lick to hit that wouldn’t drain resources and bring unnecessary risk, that would fit into this!</li><li>There is a lot of overlap with these ideas, but there can be distinctions made (dubious as they are) between things like labor organizing and solidarity organizing for specific causes/issues. We want to bring those worlds together.</li><li>“Labor” is meant in the broadest sense, both to encompass traditional explorations found in Marxian writings, and the kinds of reproductive labors that get devalued but uphold the system, like housecare, people care, informal work, gig work, sex work, and the like.</li><li>This potentially necessitates a move toward organizing around desires while expanding people’s conception of desire. It is showing people that fighting over scraps and being horizontally hostile is stoked by power hoarders and power mongers to our detriment, <em>and</em> that people who have more privilege, even at the bottom, may see some benefit from upholding the current power structure (at least to some degree). If we can zoom into the concerns of unique individuals, and collaborate on ways to respond to them that don’t screw us over later, we have a good chance at undermining horizontal hostility and seeking out full liberation. We can use that vantage point to see and focus on the contradictions between blocs of the monied classes, heightening them to create an advantage.</li><li>I would argue that we already do this, but tend to filter it through this very linear, past-present-future paradigm. We tell our stories using one narrative structure. Having a different way to relate to time that is based on what we’re interested in, that can move fluidly between what is commonly considered the “past”, “present”, and/or “future” has a lot of potential. Rather than using one narrative structure to tell stories, we can tap into many different modes that we can choose from based on the situation we’re trying to understand. To use some very western examples to illustrate the point, I’ll refer to Homer’s <em>Odyssey</em> and <em>Iliad</em>. The Odyssey represents a kind of way that we could tell stories/communicate about time in the way that I’m describing, where the focus is more on exploring themes and patterns, using that as a lens through which to view the information from different points in space-time, weaving them all together. The Iliad, on the other hand, has a more linear structure that is how we commonly think of time in colonial societies. My aim here is to ask us to realize that there are other ways of conceiving even the most fundamental pieces of our perceptual understandings. We should explore them on our journey to destroy coloniality.</li><li>This is a Twi word that means “to retrieve”, and is commonly represented by a bird that is walking forward while facing backwards. It refers to the importance of not leaving useful things behind, in our case, indigenous and other cultural practices.</li><li>This comes from <a href="https://www.booksfree.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/9781571313560.pdf">Braiding Sweetgrass: Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge and the Teachings of Plants</a></li><li>Intersectionality is a framework that discusses the ways one’s identities intersect to create unique combinations, where the location at the intersection is an emergent experience from individual variables. It is a legal-structural analytic.</li><li>Positionality is a framework that covers similar ground to intersectionality, but zooms into the specific experiences of specific people who exist at specific intersections. If intersectionality helps us understand how certain groups or classes of people are impacted by the way that they exist, positionality helps us understand how individuals are impacted. Both are needed (or similar frameworks) to help us apprehend people’s social lives or lack thereof.</li><li>See “Glossary” section for more on what it means to “devour” something.</li><li>I’m not convinced enough to position this as a “fact” (which I define as a truth that is true no matter what any individual says, whereas other truths can exist alongside other plausible conclusions from the same information), as the process may have looked more like a feedback loop, where higher classes (meant here as synonymous with “category”) oscillated between dominating non-human nature and dominating lower classes (vis a vis <a href="https://kersplebedeb.com/posts/pathology-of-patriarchy/">patriarchy</a> and/or <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/murray-bookchin-the-ecology-of-freedom#toc3">gerontocracy</a>), using learnings from one to inform the other in a dialectical process. A more generous reading is that ecological problems are social problems, which I can get behind.</li><li>It’s worthwhile to say that this also may not be “literally true” in the #scientific sense. Entropy is totally a thing, and though Bookchin is skeptical of systems theory and some of the complexity sciences more broadly due to him seeing them as a mechanization of nature, I’m not sure he escapes this within his own corpus. He remains within the ideological cul-de-sac of Eurocentricity, which is the main constellation of thought currently promoting the decline of the biosphere. Regardless, I like the idea of dialectics because of the ways in which it, like I say, can be a tool for fighting oppressive regimes of thought, space, and action because it allows us to zoom out a bit, see what’s going on in a given context, and (inter-)subjectively decide how to move forward in a way that we can track, such that we’re always intending to point towards what works. That’s more important to me than Truth™️ in an abstract sense.</li><li>Note that this is my conception based on readings of Hegel and Marx <em>through</em> Complexity Theory and Bookchin. Pretty much everyone has their own take on dialectics, so other conceptions are likely to have their own particularities.</li><li>Its negation, or opposite. This can be literal, but the only requirement is that it is the thing on the “other side” of the contradiction, as in it is separable from the other entity being looked at. It is looking at the relationship between two elements in a system. The “nothing” is (metaphorically) rubbing up against and creating tension with the “thing” being focused on.</li><li>It may seem obvious that a seed will become a plant, but that isn’t pre-ordained. Dialectics helps us understand the way that elements in the universe (might) develop, both in obvious or self-evident ways, <em>and </em>in surprising, emergent ways, grounded in what’s possible (a seed won’t turn into a bird, for example, so that wouldn’t necessarily be a potentiality that we consider).</li><li>This can be a religion, culture, people, person, institution, or place. Authority figures are charlatans. Anything that we believe should be based on (an expansive sense of) evidence, rather than the deciding factor being the source of any given explanation/hypothesis.</li><li>Hopefully, the importance of unsettling is clear, but to reiterate: we unsettle our current world because the widespread immiseration that can be found in colonial modernity limits all who are devoured into its structure. Rather than continuing to drink from a poisoned well, I propose that we find ways to live in egoistic mutuality with our local water tables, shifting our focus towards self-interested cooperation.</li><li>By “find resonance”, I mean that we feel these worlds accurately describe our actions in the moment that we deploy them.</li><li>This the kind of reasoning you might encounter when reading any mainstream (non-radical) Western texts.</li><li>This is the kind of reasoning you might encounter in exploring decolonial, indigenous, and African epistemologies and philosophies, especially ones that discuss different ways to relate to reason and rationality.</li><li>Deterministic here refers to the linear conception of determinism which relies on 19th century understandings of physics and applied math rather than modern understandings of complexity and chaos. Lots of developments in social sciences, for better and for worse, follow developments in the natural and physical sciences, using those developments as models. The issue comes in when older conceptions that people have structural, power-based, or emotional attachments take precedence over new developments. If we think of a transition from Newtonian to Einsteinian conceptions, we can see how flexible determinism can be, beyond colloquial and archaic understandings, if we devour that idea and make it our own.</li><li>I tend to see leaning into ethics or morality as a way to deploy an exit hatch from the need to engage, think, and question deeply/critically. This is not to say that they don’t have any purpose, function, or utility. I find value in these when they give us the ability to act as egoists. My worry is that I see these as things that tend to make us their tools, rather than us remembering that they are meant to be helpful. If you’re defaulting to ethics as a normative rather than descriptive thing, then you are likely to be denying your desire.</li><li>This commitment to relationality and reciprocity is a practical commitment more than anything else. Based on my analysis, I see no reason to try and find my happiness at the expense of others — I don’t see it working like that. I’d rather not engage in violent delights that lead to violent ends.</li><li>This is not meant to ignore the conditions placed upon us… it is to say that there are true limits on us <em>but </em>through effective &amp; collective action, analysis, and care, we can surpass those limits and become whatever we want to be.</li><li>If you build up social encouragement and rituals that make integral labor that is devalued in our current paradigms as ways to be acknowledged, people will start to sing a different tune towards them.</li><li>We are limited by our phenomenologies as to be unable to apprehend reality as it <em>is</em>, so abstractions create helpful models for us. Where the models lose their utility is when they take on an “objective” character, and we forget that we are not looking at the thing itself, but a sketch of the thing that doesn’t have all of the details.</li><li>I’d not describe Max’s work as such… but that’s a common interpretation since he is so critical of modernity and leaves the door open for what comes after. I think that to be truly and fully “negative”, in a way that creates space for creation, we have to fight capital, modernity, <em>and</em> coloniality.</li><li>It is easy to be valued based on your positionality, which can either be societally mutable or fickle depending on your social context in dangerous ways.</li><li>This is where the dangers of narrow ego(t)isms show themselves. If you chase short term, systems-reinforcing gains as a person who’s immiseration is what allows that system to continue running, you are condemning yourself to a life of fruitless efforts and dissatisfaction, or, even worse, damnation from success in a colonial paradigm.</li></ol><h3>Glossary</h3><p>Becoming: the process of change by which a new paradigm is established for a subject or object (or phenomena), through contact between Being and Nothing (definitions below). The being meets nothing and ends up as something else though a process of becoming.</p><p>Being: a subject or object that is receiving some focus. In the dialectical process, it is our “starting point”.</p><p>Contradiction (logical): when a subject, object, or phenomena is said to have features or properties that can’t exist at the same time and be factual. For example, All apples are fruits. If someone were to say that some apples are not fruits, that is a logical contradiction, because there is no way to substantiate that claim through information, reasoning, or data. Logic is all about “internal” consistency, where the “internal” refers to the relation between the claims being made and the things being compared. Within the system of interest, in this case the “system” of fruit classifications, of which an apple is an element, the claims and conclusions should be supported by the characteristics of that system.</p><p>Contradiction (dialectical): In dialectics (or a dialectical process), contradictions can take the shape of logical contradictions, (<strong>All X are Y</strong> → <strong>Some X are not Y</strong> | <strong>No X is Y</strong> → <strong>Some X are Y</strong>) but they only <em>need</em> to take the shape of tensions between elements in a system more broadly. It’s all about the relationship between elements. This is why there can be both logical <em>and</em> dialectical contradictions in a system like capitalism, depending on what facets you’re looking at. On the logic side, for example, one of the contradictions in capitalism is how much opposition there is to reparations for Black folks. This doesn’t fit in well with the values of remuneration, fairness under the law, and things like that. This is a great showcase of how Liberalism’s values of liberty, equality, and freedom are logically contradictory with the apathetic-to-malicious nature of capitalist growth imperatives. “All people are equal under/before the law” logically contradicts with “some people are not equal (when looking at the outcomes) under/before the law”. Those two realities can’t exist at the same time and maintain internal logical consistency. This kind of realization is why paradigms like “the purpose of a system is what it does” are able to be understood. A <em>dialectical</em> contradiction in this context might be the ways in which enslaved folks (and their descendants) are categorically excluded from the wealth they (continue to) build for (descendants of) slave owners. Enslaved folks built wealth they can’t access, and slavers are able to reap rewards. So there is a contradiction (or tension) between the amount of labor being put in and the rewards received, which creates a fertile ground, with the potentiality for “becoming” to facilitate a new paradigm. This contradiction is dialectical and not necessarily logical because there is nothing about the reality of capitalism that prevents this from happening (though it could be logical as well, depending on our focus and how we frame the issue, like the previous example). To recap, in dialectics, a contradiction can be logical (for one statement to be true, the other can’t be true), it can refer to tensions within the relationship between two elements, where the development of that tension can lead to a new paradigm that changes the relationship between the two elements in tension, or it can be a combination of the two.</p><p>Dark power: the power that comes from positionality in a “zone of non-being”, or as “(a creative) nothing”. It is when dispossessed folks come together and create worlds not imaginable by those who are stuck in colonial positionalities and/or mindsets.</p><p>Devouring: taking (self-)ownership of something, connecting with it deeply to realize its use-value. This is a radically subjective act of taking anything you encounter and “metabolizing” it, bringing with you what’s useful and leaving what’s not. It’s the process of egoistically communizing the world around you by making the double entendre of property into a singular meaning, where the things you own are able to be utilized as if they are features of you. It’s making your properties your property.</p><p>Dialectics: a method to understand and apprehend the (potential) ways that a subject, object, phenomena, or process can change (in the developmental sense), principally by its contact with another object that engenders the need for change. Generally, we are interested in a certain thing that we’re focusing on, and the contradiction (or tension) a different “part or element of the system” creates by way of the two interacting. Multilectics would be how this process happens while looking at more than two things at the same time.</p><p>Ego: an expansive form of desire, including the emergent totality of feelings, emotions, impulses, ambitions, goals, etc, across rational, social, emotional, physical, and intuitive/spiritual vectors. The ego is always in a process of becoming, as the things one wants are never truly static.</p><p>Egoism: a unique individual’s method for fulfilling their expansive desires. This points towards being aware of and attuned to the context in which the ego resides, allowing for a kind of relationship with desire that points us towards more liberatory potentialities. It is a partisan project (if that word is applicable in an anti-political (word to Cedric Robinson) project) that biases us towards liberation through meeting our desire.</p><p>Eurocentrism: Treating European ways of relating, being, and thinking as universal &amp; superior rather than particular. This has led to not only cultural bias, but gives shape to the global economic and social power dynamics in place, our understandings of history and science, and our philosophical outlooks on the world. This becomes a limiting factor if we allow our conceptions of liberation or social change to be grounded in the same episteme that birthed our sorry state of affairs.</p><p>Nothing: a subject or object that creates a challenge or establishes a difference in relation to another element within a system that is considered to be receiving some attention or focus. This is not our “ending point” as much as it exists in tension with Being. There may not be an “end” in this process.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2219f2566782" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Notes on Solarpunk Beyond Eurocentrism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/notes-on-solarpunk-beyond-eurocentrism-884a7fdf40d4?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/884a7fdf40d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[eurocentrism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[appropriate-technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solarpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decolonization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 May 2024 00:00:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-12T22:45:47.520Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8_D0WfuEbc7P6fcj" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@clayleconey?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Clay LeConey</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Crisis and collapse seem to be the currency of the present. 1st World societies, enveloped in the long shadow cast by prosperity, find themselves coming into open, naked conflict. Reality, or Eurocentricity¹? Reality says, ‘we can’t have infinite growth on a finite planet!’ Eurocentrism laughs, walking away with delight. Rather than understanding “that which cannot be repaired is already broken,”² Eurocentricity tells us that we can pull and pull and pull, that a rudderless faith in extraction will somehow lead to balance. What happens if the world is bent until it breaks? All of our communities are at stake. This is “the clearest signal that there is something deeply wrong with the global system in its current form”³. We can see that, somewhere along the line, someone fucked shit up. There’s no other meaningful way to explain how we’ve gotten to where we’re at. Eurocentricity is so prevalent that we even understand our technology on the scale of the “complex and special”, rather than “how a society copes with physical reality.”⁴ Solarpunk’s focus on appropriate technology⁵ is a welcome corrective to the myopia of modernity⁶ and capitalism⁷. However, it is incomplete without an understanding of coloniality⁸.</p><p>If there are facets of coloniality that we need to address, they are the processes of (1) creating rigid taxonomies and categories for classifying the world⁹, and (2) creating hierarchies of power and value for the ways those things are classified. These two moves are embedded in the in-group/out-group exclusionary dynamics that coloniality needs to function, from the way that we privilege ‘humans’ over ‘non-humans’, ‘margins’ over ‘centers’, and the ‘visible’ over the ‘invisible’. This isn’t just philosophical or for the sake of pontification. These presuppositions of knowledge, being, and meaning privilege Eurocentric assertions that see “other human beings’ ways of life [as] wrong and harming nature, [since] nature needs no human beings.”¹⁰ If we are to move out of ecological calamity, ‘The Last Shall be First’ must be our operating system. By centering the margins (in the ontological and epistemological sense), we can actually end suffering, rather than outsourcing it. This has to take shape in such a way that engenders room for a polyculture of meaning, diametrically opposed to the hegemonic “monoculture of meaning”¹¹, beyond the ability to label any human based on what they “lack” as an “Other”¹².</p><p>This move to truly embody decoloniality has to critique modernity, capitalism, and coloniality. This is important to understand as “modernity organizes the world ontologically in terms of atomic, homogeneous, separable categories. Contemporary women of color and third-world women’s critique of feminist universalism centers the claim that the intersection of race, class, sexuality, and gender exceeds the categories of modernity. If woman and black are terms for homogeneous, atomic, separable categories, then their intersection shows us the absence of black women rather than their presence. So, to see non-white women is to exceed “categorial” logic. […] the modern, colonial, gender system [is] a lens through which to theorize further the oppressive logic of colonial modernity, its use of hierarchical dichotomies and categorial logic. […] categorial, dichotomous, hierarchical logic [is] central to modern, colonial, capitalist thinking about race, gender, and sexuality.”¹³ We see that even in ostensibly postcolonial societies, “indigenous people who had already suffered from decades of colonial conservation policies, little changed with decolonization.”¹⁴ This shows the depth at which we have to go to adequately respond to the social and ecological issues that are currently coming to a head.</p><p>This commitment isn’t (principally) a moral or ethical one. One of the main reasons that we have to move towards a holistic decoloniality is because of the inability of coloniality to address the issues we’re facing. “Indigenous leaders say [30x30, a worldwide conservation program] ignores generations of effective indigenous land management. […] there was limited scientific attention paid to Indigenous stewardship.”¹⁵ Unless we are willing to be radical, to grasp the roots of all the oppressive structures that we’re facing, we will reproduce the things we are (ostensibly) trying to abolish in our (potentially unintentional) inability to critique coloniality onto-epistemically while proposing responses rooted in other ways of being. In the effort to try and correct the excesses of Eurocentricity, we see that Eurocentric modes of being like “nation-states […] struggling to catch up with indigenous and other non-capitalist cultures’ understanding of the interdependence of life.”¹⁶ This is not to exalt Indigenous, Black and 3rd/4th world onto-epistemes, to reify them beyond critique. It is to say that the Eurocentric onto-epistemic inability to see those modes as valid dampers the emancipatory potential extant in the world preventing the ability to reach the purported values of “progress” and “development”. Eurocentric ideas have to play catch-up, and by their colonial and capitalist nature are unable to.</p><p>We have to problematize, to see as an issue, many of the foundational concepts might deploy as mired in Eurocentrism and coloniality. We can do this by (1) decolonizing what it means to be human by creating the space for Black, Indigenous and 3rd/4th worlders to self-determine and (2) “[take] non-humans seriously as persons[/beings] with agency [which] allows us to de-center humans, to notice how limited our field of sight becomes when fixated by the idea of the Anthropocene. Far from remaining a matter of theoretical discussion, non-humans [… ] influenc[e] social, political and legal realities.”¹⁷ We have to bridge these two worlds: acknowledging the ways that the ideas of animality were defined along the bodies of Black people, how that relates to conceptions of humanity, <em>and</em> the care that we should have in highlighting the agency of non-human beings (both in the actual sense, and those who get denied humanity). This has to be done on the terms of those beings, as best as we can manage. If we are able to acknowledge that there are issues in modernity with how we taxonomize humans &amp; how that relates to non-humans, for the sake of the biosphere, and we center those marginal and invisible beings, we can get a lot done.</p><p>I really want to impress the fact that not taking the trifecta of Eurocentrism¹⁸ seriously is resigning ourselves to doom. If we continue to build the cyberpunk future that we’ve been worried about for decades, the future of “urban decay, corporate power and globalization. The rise of zero tolerance policing, anxieties around health care and the psychological toll of the Cold ‘Forever war’ and the possibility of nuclear annihilation,”¹⁹ we resign ourselves, even in our imaginaries, to further our immiseration. We can use the 30 x 30 framework for conservation as a great example, where 200 countries were willing to accept it²⁰. This conservation framework reinforces the dichotomy between human/non-human²¹, assuming that top-down, bureaucratic processes of “management” are the answer to the problems that those very ideas created. The ironic thing is, even though this move would be woefully inadequate in addressing the issue of biodiversity loss <em>or</em> climate change²², we very likely won’t even get to see it achieve protection of “30% of the world’s land and water by 2030.”²³ There’s no meaningful accountability structure within the Eurocentric hegemony to do this. There is no room for living freely and honestly under these conditions.</p><p>“To see the coloniality is to see the powerful reduction of human beings to animals, to inferiors by nature, in a [piece-meal] understanding of reality that dichotomizes the human from nature, the human from the non-human, and thus imposes an ontology and a cosmology that, in its power and constitution, disallows all humanity, all possibility of understanding, all possibility of human communication, to dehumanized beings.”²⁴ This is the double-edged sword of creating hierarchies and taxonomies around valid ways of being, knowing, and meaning. By operating along these lines, we end up in a situation where there is no meaningful way for <em>anyone</em> to truly reach the kinds of fulfillment that modernity is supposed to provide. Now, this is not to say that I’m personally going to cry very hard about colonizers dehumanizing themselves by dehumanizing me, but I think it’s worthwhile to mention; we <em>all</em> benefit by tearing down Eurocentrism and building a new, multifaceted perspective that allows for mutualism between different ways of thinking about the world and our relations with/in it.</p><p>By creating these rigid categories of difference, there is an assumption of innateness that tends to become a part of it. If we are looking to dismantle coloniality, we have to situate ourselves in such a way that those seemingly subtle distinctions between differences in general²⁵ and the specific conception of colonial difference become visible. This allows us to see that “the epistemological fractures between the Eurocentric critique of Eurocentrism is distinguished from the critique of Eurocentrism anchored in the colonial difference.”²⁶ Critiques of Eurocentrism that don’t apprehend the imbrication of coloniality, capital, and modernity are left unaware at the meaningful distinctions that can be made between critique left incomplete and critique that gives us a way to move forward and build new relationalities.</p><p>I want to point back towards the phrase “The Last Shall Be First”, which comes from Fanon (and the Bible). I understand this as resonant with the adage of centering the marginalized. If we truly believe that harmony and unity in life are worthwhile to work towards, the practical move to make is to, in every moment, work towards empowering those removed from power. By foregrounding those most negatively impacted by Eurocentrism through an understanding of intersectionality in material <em>and</em> onto-epistemological senses while spotlighting the “‘decolonizers of the imaginary’, [which can be understood as] future generations, past generations, non-humans, and spiritual beings and concepts”²⁷, we can point ourselves towards more egalitarian and self-determining outcomes. We can compose and integrate efforts together, where cultural workers can do solarpunk art and organizers &amp; community/affinity groups can build solarpunk sociality and architects can do solarpunk guerrilla urbanism and more, where collaboration becomes a space that starts to break down the borders between different ways of relating to the world. By problematizing the human “we”, by understanding that while, ideally, abstractly we are including everyone, in practice, there are critical things missed that lead to the issues we purportedly want to face. We have to point towards a world where many fit.</p><p>As far as my specific commitments on the matter, I’m what <em>I</em> call an egoist. I’ve appropriated this term to mean that I find myself to be important (though not supremely so), to assert my onto-epistemology as valid, even though Eurocentric society was built at my (people’s) expense²⁸. I have hope, which I understand as the grounded counterpart to “faith” or “optimism”, that things can change, that even if the world has to be broken down, that it can be, and a new, decolonial one can be built. In this space, I hope that every being is acknowledged on its own terms, to have the capacity for its “ego” to be fulfilled, roughly along the lines of the golden and platinum rules, depending on what makes sense given the situation²⁹. Solarpunk is very egoistic/anarchistic in my conception. Through horizontal power structures, we can minimize immiseration and foreground approaches to life that move our social activity towards the biosphere.</p><p>We can start working towards this, right now. Like, on some “you can go do the work after this” kind of thing. While we don’t necessarily have a linear path forward, we can listen to ourselves and our desires, and experiment with doing things to fulfill them in the present, seeing them as springboards for further movement into the kind of spaces that we want to go. On a basic level, we can think about the ways that we are restricted by our needs due to alienation from self-determination, and devise plans to get those things, from food autonomy, to housing security, to social and cultural spaces. With this, I want us to be rooted in place-no White Flight ass culty commune shit. Our work should ground in locality and communality. If every being deserves the kind of world that solarpunk futures suggest, it makes no sense to leave if we have capacity³⁰ to stay. In a more egoist turn, I think places where we can practice what James Scott calls anarchist calisthenics³¹ are worthwhile endeavors; authority, as in authoritarian rule, is never legitimate. Whenever we can and have the desire to, we should rage against it. Hosting do it yourself (DIY) events are a good example of this. DIY events are usually music shows, but they can be parties or anything else, where you do it without “permission” from the state or authorities. They can happen “in a park, on a beach, deep in the forest, in a barn, under a bridge, in a parking lot, next to a pool, or at the top of a mountain. The event could be on wheels: in an RV, on the back of a truck, in a van. You could build a secret tree house. You could borrow a boat. You could find an abandoned or empty building and re-purpose it. If there’s no electricity and you need it for a PA, find a generator. If you don’t need electricity, use candles for lighting. If you would like to lessen the chance of police interference, acquire several buildings and move people from building to building during breaks. You could even take over a street.”³²</p><p>If we’re willing to commandeer space, the elusive element in much theorizing on change³³, we can start changing the paradigms. Rather than “fall[ing] back on […] creat[ing] protected areas”³⁴ for the sake of reaching “biodiversity goals” and “ecological harmony”, we can focus on land back, we can pull from knowledges in appropriate technology, traditional ecological knowledge, and the best that western science has to offer for being good partners with other beings in our communities. To horizontalize relationships between humans, breaking down barriers of political and socioeconomic varieties, we can put the last first and act as accomplices, supporting their needs and fighting alongside them. Any critiques that we have of the system should, within our capacities, be externalized, the (dialectical and logical³⁵) contradictions laid bare in the material world. If there is a public building that isn’t being used for the public, we can commandeer it and turn it into a commons³⁶. Around these moves we can build or tie in networks of support and take seriously the militancy, strategy, and tactics required to defend that space. Or, we can be more fluid, moving from place to place, an occupation traveling band that swarms spaces, creates more solarpunk and communistic relations within, shares those tools and collaborates with folks more rooted in that space, and floats out as to remain flexible. Or, a ton of other possibilities, a ton of other ways to engage space. There are many ways to do it.</p><p>This is meant to be a conversation starter. I have a <em>lot</em> of love for solarpunk — you can see that from my writings. It is a really useful meta-frame for the narrative component of systems change. I also acknowledge the susceptibility that it has towards eco-modernism, crypto-scheming, and reactionary yearning to return to the “good old days”, whether it’s a time “before agriculture” or a time before industrialization”. I hope that, through the works of 3rd and 4th worlders, and more material ties to prefigurative and insurgent practices vis a vis systems change, solarpunk can shake off the chains of Eurocentrism, towards a pluralistic decoloniality and anti/non-capitalism.</p><h3>Notes</h3><ol><li>Eurocentricity/Eurocentrism is the cultural and philosophical constellation of worldviews that sees the ideas birthed from Europe and wedded to capitalism and coloniality as the only valid, worthwhile, and legible modes of knowledge, being/existence (especially as it relates to “humanity”/humanism), and meaning. Things like linear progressions of time, a fetish for scientific thought, and atomistic conceptions of the individual permeate Eurocentric thought.</li><li><a href="https://wiki.xxiivv.com/site/permacomputing.html">XXIIVV — permacomputing</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/insurge-intelligence/beyond-extinction-12daed1bc851">Beyond Extinction. Transition to post-capitalism is inevitable | by Nafeez Ahmed</a></li><li><a href="https://reallifemag.com/anthem-of-the-sun/">Anthem of the Sun — Real Life</a></li><li>Appropriate technology is essentially what it sounds like; it looks at what technology would be appropriate, meaning that it would minimize ecological harm, to achieve specific needs/goals.</li><li>The advent of nation-statism, colonial empires, and industrial capital make up modernity. It is the “never-ending” historical period in which we find ourselves.</li><li>Capitalism is distinct, in all of its configurations, for the fact that it combines: (1)private, dictatorial authority over property, most notably of the means of production, (2) wage labor relations where those who don’t have productive private property need to work using someone else’s to survive, and (3) a focus on continual growth, which is seen as an unquestionable good.</li><li>Coloniality is the power structural relationships and ways in which society was chopped up and categorized, that, while originating during the eras of European Colonialism, still persist to this day.</li><li><a href="https://brb.memoryoftheworld.org/Maria%20Lugones/Toward%20a%20Decolonial%20Feminism%20(9579)/Toward%20a%20Decolonial%20Feminism%20-%20Maria%20Lugones.pdf">Toward a Decolonial Feminism — Maria Lugones</a></li><li><a href="https://grist.org/indigenous/30x30-world-conservation-model-colonialism-indigenous-peop/">How the world’s favorite conservation model was built on colonial violence</a></li><li><a href="https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/zq5be">Decolonizers of the imaginary</a></li><li><a href="https://monoskop.org/images/5/59/Wynter_Sylvia_1995_1492_A_New_World_View.pdf">Wynter Sylvia 1492 A New World View</a></li><li>Toward a Decolonial Feminism</li><li>How the world’s favorite conservation model was built on colonial violence</li><li>How the world’s favorite conservation model was built on colonial violence</li><li>Decolonizers of the imaginary</li><li>Decolonizers of the imaginary</li><li>Capitalism, coloniality, modernity</li><li><a href="https://www.thejaymo.net/long-form/solarpunk-rusted-chrome/">SOLARPUNK: Life in the future — Beyond the rusted chrome</a></li><li>How the world’s favorite conservation model was built on colonial violence</li><li>This is meant in an expansive sense, where colonized subjects and what is commonly referred to as nature is included</li><li>Eurocentric assumptions on what it means to “conserve” certain lands go against the very things that are done to preserve biodiversity. There is not a mechanism by which we can meaningfully protect lands from “on high”, away from an intimate understanding rooted in place.</li><li>How the world’s favorite conservation model was built on colonial violence</li><li>Toward a Decolonial Feminism</li><li>I don’t find issue with the concept of “difference”. I am not my phone, or my mom, or my favorite animal. At the same time, we have to be able to separate the idea of difference from the idea of colonial difference, and understand the ways that material and social processes shape the ways that difference in general is constructed. Ossified understandings of difference, like “I am a man and men do X” are antithetical to liberatory change.</li><li>Toward a Decolonial Feminism</li><li>Decolonizers of the imaginary. Not that there’s overlap here between acknowledging 3rd &amp; 4th world folks ways of being and knowing and a flattening of the “nature-culture” dichotomy that is generally espoused in ‘colonized imaginaries’</li><li>This system tells me to assimilate or to stop existing. I choose neither, and go towards full spectrum resistance and abolition.</li><li>The golden rule is treat people how you want to be treated. The platinum rule is treat people how they want to be treated. I think there’s an innumerable number of options in this range, depending on how well we can understand what other beings need. By not pedestalizing any one being over the other while understanding the deep history and present, we can move towards that. I want to make it abundantly clear that we cannot just “jump” towards that moment, as things like reparations and land back need to happen. It’s a yes and situation. We should understand that every being deserves what it wants as long as it doesn’t systematically/power structurally prevent someone from doing the same. And to this end, there are certain, non-privileged/marginalized/invisibled beings that will have needs that reflect a different reality visavis self-determination.</li><li>I am not saying to stay in dangerous, toxic, harmful situations. I’m saying that changing the places you’re already in has more radical potential, if you’re specifically looking for that, than getting a commune established out of arms reach from society.</li><li><a href="https://harpers.org/archive/2012/12/anarchist-calisthenics/">Anarchist Calisthenics, by James C. Scott</a></li><li><a href="https://www.sproutdistro.com/catalog/zines/organizing/building-diy-guide-creating-spaces-hosting-events-fostering-radical-communities/">A DIY Guide to Creating Spaces</a></li><li>Anecdotally, it seems easier to imagine vastly different economic, political, and social systems, but it is harder to imagine different technologies, and even harder to imagine different ways of interacting with spatial-temporal dynamics. Much of politics is actually about space and how it is occupied, and we should lean into anarchic, decolonial takes on “geography”, “urban planning”, and “architecture” among other fields so we can really take seriously how we are addressing all the things we need to.</li><li>How the world’s favorite conservation model was built on colonial violence</li><li>Contradiction (logical): when a subject, object, or phenomena is said to have features or properties that can’t exist at the same time and be factual. For example, All apples are fruits. If someone were to say that some apples are not fruits, that is a logical contradiction, because there is no way to substantiate that claim through information, reasoning, or data. Logic is all about “internal” consistency, where the “internal” refers to the relation between the claims being made and the things being compared. Within the system of interest, in this case the “system” of fruit classifications, of which an apple is an element, the claims and conclusions should be supported by the characteristics of that system. Contradiction (dialectical): In dialectics (or a dialectical process), contradictions can take the shape of logical contradictions, (All X are Y → Some X are not Y | No X is Y → Some X are Y) but they only <em>need</em> to take the shape of tensions between elements in a system more broadly. It’s all about the relationship between elements.</li><li><a href="https://newlinesmag.com/argument/what-if-we-cancel-the-apocalypse/">What if We Cancel the Apocalypse</a></li></ol><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://dipperdesperado.tumblr.com/post/750311135220301824/notes-on-solarpunk-beyond-eurocentrism"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em> on May 12, 2024.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=884a7fdf40d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[notes on class analysis, beyond class reductionism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/notes-on-class-analysis-beyond-class-reductionism-979c0ecb0b55?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/979c0ecb0b55</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decoloniality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[class-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Apr 2024 00:00:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-02T18:06:22.953Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>In which your favorite anarchist cherry-picks pieces of identity politics and syncretizes them with his favorite parts of sociological class analysis (with a focus on Marxian conceptions) and center-periphery theories of the same topic… for the sake of abolishing oppression.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*x9acyZZP_6X9FQRF" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@unmadesai?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unma Desai</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Class and economic reduction are some of the worst theoretical and methodological mistakes that we can make in our analysis. Class reductionism is an understanding that the principal unit of analysis for analyzing social conditions is economic class. Other facets of social being, adorned with the dubious “superstructural”[1] labels are seen as unimportant to deal with. Economic reduction is about (1) seeing the “real”[2] determinants of social life as economic and therefore (2) understanding the “base”[3] of society as mechanically determining the elements that exist “superstructurally”. It’s an orientation that talks about inevitable moments of historical development, based on an analysis of the economic situation. When folks rail against Marxist analyses, this tends to be a recurrent target of critique.</p><p>This approach has two big issues. While economics are important, and in some cases are good to see as “primary” in a vague sense[4], they don’t paint the full picture. Reality isn’t just economic distribution, production, and consumption, even if we decide that the only “reality” we care about is human sociality. This thinking relatedly doesn’t allow us to understand the full scope of what revolutionary potentialities exist by way of class analysis. Said otherwise, focusing solely on class analysis makes that mode have to do more lifting than it is capable of doing, rendering it ineffectual, like trying to make a fish win a footrace, just because it is really fast in the water. We can’t just focus on one variable or fact of interest in our analysis, if we want our analysis to capture a sense of complexity. We need the right tools for the right jobs. Alongside this, we have to always keep in mind that we exist in a dialectical relationship[5] with those tools. A separate can of worms can be opened up if we look at the ways that complex adaptive systems function-seeing the Cerberus of capitalism, modernity, and coloniality as such would illuminate that no one element of its functions is “primary”[6]. That kind of linear thinking only serves to encourage fruitless intellectual pursuits and failed revolutionary regimes.</p><p>If the working class defined by a specific relationship with the means of production, and we have a class reductionist perspective, it can lead to us assuming ideals and extremes represent the whole[7]. We are trying to apprehend totalities with too limited of a dataset[8]. While class and economics are necessary, they are insufficient in an analysis of social conditions, and of the potential that exists for change along realistic[9] lines.</p><p>One way for us to supersede these failure points is by way of a commitment to relationality. When I say this, I am referring to an understanding based in looking at the relationships between our loci of interest[10], in a way that prioritizes evidence (credible information sourced from the world) over hypotheses (or inductive, deductive, or abductive conclusions), with a hyper-critical and skeptical stance towards grand narratives. If there is such a thing, we, as far as we know, can only make approximations. While these can improve, even to the extent that our working models provide all that we need to engage in reality, they will always be models. This commitment isn’t modernist (building grand narratives) or postmodernist (critiquing all structures that exist and living within that critique, by way of being unable to surpass the object of critique). It is metamodernist: an orientation that is dialectical and syncretic, taking the critiques found from metamodernism seriously while believing in the existence of a reality, accessing it through a sober assessment of our capacities and limitations.</p><p>If we want our theory, method, and practice to be based in what <em>is</em> by way of what we want to <em>be</em>, this is paramount. I see class and economic reduction as prioritizing hypotheses to rationalize with flattering evidence, rather than creating hypotheses that are based <em>on</em> evidence.</p><p>A requisite part of this relationality is through having an analysis of positionality. This can be by way of intersectionality[11], interpenetration[12], and/or imbrication[13]. Positionality is an understanding of where you are located, socially, politically, and economically, by way of your identities, properties[14], and experiences. This is looking at the social hierarchies at play and seeing where you are at, in a given moment/period of focus. The “i-words” come in when we use that analysis to inform our practice, bound to a commitment to centering the marginalized.</p><p>The <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/anarchist-federation-of-rio-de-janeiro-social-anarchism-and-organisation#toc3">center-periphery model</a> as discussed by FARJ is a useful way to stretch class analysis, but mixing models, without explaining points of divergence before we converge can cause confusion. When we use the center-periphery model to discuss society, and an analysis that is based in intersectionality or similar frameworks talk about bringing the margins to the center, we are not asking for “representation” or “maintenance” of the structures social hierarchy as currently formatted. There is a tacit understanding embedded in this analysis that, if we are to, for example, desire a structure that empowers Black women to have multifaceted, sustaining experiences of freedom and self-determination, whatever we build would be radically different than what currently exists. This commitment is a practical way that we can “destroy” the centers of power. This is what <em>actually</em> allows us to (con)federalize[15] power. This is why understanding positionality is important. If each individual’s uniqueness is their own totality, having an understanding of the different elements, identities, and properties that make up who they are (in regards to it being relevant to the analysis) will allow us to see how we relate to power structures. This gives us an understanding of where to plant strategic and tactically effective action. In any given moment or situation, we might be able to take stock of if we are reinforcing or undermining concentrations of power rather than (con)federalizing of power. If, based on our social composition[16], the most marginalized folks don’t feel safe or heard, we’re doing something wrong in our practice that needs to be revised.</p><p>To make sure we’re clear, this is not to say we focus on identity “alone”. This is why we advocate for using economic and political properties along with identities in our understanding of positionality. We can’t ignore any of these elements if we want a complete analysis, and centering the marginalized allows our practice to hold the most liberatory potential. Class analysis, which is what I’ll call the focus of traditional/conventional leftism, broadly fixates on two things in my estimation: (1) how class interests align and contradict, leading to class conflict, class warfare, and the potentialities for abolishing class. In this vein, the other part of these potentialities is (2) how to build unity. I think that these are useful starting points, but present some issues. Since class analysis is relatively fixed and general rather than relational, it can easily lead to vulgar conclusions from the analysis, where we hyperfixate on specific, mythologized groups of folks that don’t hold up to our expectations in reality. It also has the effect of the things we ask for being limited by a desire to build unity.</p><p>Unity, in this case, tends to be based on that overarching conception. “we should do this because of our objective class interests” type shit. Again, while it may be true that as economically dispossessed folks, it would be advantageous for us to have control over the means of production or whatever, that alone isn’t connecting with the full breadth of how we experience our lives and has an almost Christianity-faith-based, “searching for salvation” vibe to it. “Follow me and I’ll set you free” type shit. It isn’t specific enough, as classes aren’t monolithic. We have to struggle <em>through</em> our differences, building solidarity based on a bottom-up understanding of shared needs and desires (and how those interact with and shape personal needs and desires). The unity method by way of the most general elements that unite folks is more top-down, simplifying reality in a way that isn’t as useful when we’re at the ground level. This makes authoritarianism the only real method of holding it together (as top down means easily lead to top down ends), creating weak movements that are vulnerable to outside actors agitating the differences that exist and are being ignored, widening fissures within the movement. Not to mention the way that people who intuitively or lucidly understand that they don’t fit into that mythologized model and thus will not participate. I know that when I look at the labor movement, and see all White dudes (but I see many more kinds of embodiment when actually looking at workplaces), I feel like that’s not a place meant for me.</p><p>If we want to have folks join our movements, we need to be more specific in our analysis, so that our practice is more accurate and aligns with the world as it is while enabling us to make it as we like. We should specify the conflicts and contradictions that exist in society so that we can see, across sectors and spaces, where the spaces for intervention can arise, or how to take advantage of the ones that exist. By having positionality and any of the “i’s” in mind, and by looking at facilitating expansive conceptions of desire[17], we can actually create movement spaces that are more holistic in their approach.</p><p>A way that this type of analysis becomes useful in multiple situations is by understanding how it can fractalize. For the sake of this conversation, we can work with the scales of Macro (class/umbrella identity), Meso (section), Micro (bloc), and Nano (individual).</p><p>Macro is at the highest level. When looking at analyzing where someone is in society for the sake of liberatory change, the macro level is the most broad/shallow and common features of groups of people. When people talk about the rich, the proletariat, or any other classes, they are on the macro level. This is useful for us to understand “the meta”[18], and get into all of the stuff that class analysis illuminates: class antagonism, the ways that all of the -isms affect people in a broad sense, and how these things change over a broad timescale.</p><p>Meso is us zooming in a bit-instead of looking at just “classes”, used here to mean “types”, we start to understand “sections” of those classes using intersectionality and positionality with more specificity. Rather than just referring to Black people or working people, we may refer to Black young women or German working people. It is understanding that, while we are still at a high level, there is more specificity at play that is useful to have awareness of. Just like there are shared experiences of alienation from the Means of Production for all working class people, we can see how zooming in specifically allows us to see what that actually means for certain sections of whatever unifying element of a given “class”. This is able to let us know that not all workers/genders/racial communities are created monolithically, and within a given community there are sections that have their own interests due to their positionality.</p><p>Micro is about looking at actual groups of actual people, seeing the blocs that exist within our subgroups. For example, if we’re looking at Black folks, we can see how sections are composed, and we can look at the actual circumstances in an area of interest to see how different sections relate to one another, to see what contradictions are invisibilized by way of not zooming in enough. Rather than sticking at a higher level and saying that there should be unity solely due to one or two shared variables of intersection, there can be an understanding of how people are seen in society as is, with the capacity to try and shift those resonances and dissonances into more beneficial assemblages for the goals of liberation. If there are contradictions between people connected by variables found in the higher level/more general classes, we can start at a bloc level, building our way up towards people seeing and acting in their “class interests”.</p><p>Nano is zooming all the way in. It is understanding specific folks, and seeing their specific experiences intimated and imbricated by the above scales. It is easy, especially when trying to understand how to change society, to not look at individuals. But, ignoring individuals, the building blocks of society, will leave good materials on the cutting room floor. I think we should oscillate between more and less individual understandings, so that we can mutualize the relationships between individuals, collectives, and collectives of collectives.</p><p>It’s worth noting that all of these are connected, and we move from one to another based on what we’re trying to understand. If we’re looking at the structure of society, then class analysis, in both meanings of the word, is useful. If we’re trying to relate to each other as individuals, we need to think about things at that level, not eschewing an awareness of systemic dynamics. We run into a lot of issues if we don’t make sure our method is well-suited to our problems that we’re trying to understand.</p><p>If we can stretch the idea of class to not just be an economic thing, but to focus on positions in social hierarchies, that allows us to understand oppression on different scales from the interpersonal to the societal, and gives us room to think about what it means to be in one position or another. By framing this in ontologies and epistemologies of Black feminisms, we come away with a flexible framework for analyzing those positions, and we can, in every situation, center the marginalized, so that we have a more specific, intentional way to expand our understanding of prefiguration and material solidarity. This points us towards uniting in ways that undermine different social hierarchies that reinforce one another. By having these tools at our disposal, we can create unified action through maximal prefiguration in our practice. If we are making something that works for the least privileged of us, we have much less work to do for the more privileged of us. This also ensures that those folks aren’t left behind, the way that they can be when we don’t do the work to zoom in enough. If they are at the “center”, there is no “center”. If there is a “center”, then there are marginalized people who are being ignored.</p><p>Let’s try to concretize this with an example. Start anywhere in the process (or at any level of zoom). For clarity, we will start at the macro level. We have two classes, the exploiters and the exploited. We can then cut that up, by way of intersectionality and positionality, to see that each of these groups have subgroups that have different relations to their exploitation or exploiting. This allows us to know that broadly speaking, there are contradictions and tensions within these classes that allow us to either foster more mutuality or sow more division, depending on how we approach things. Once we are aware of this, we can zoom in more to see how, within these classes, there are blocs that add more detail to those contradictions. We can see that blocs of communities are not intrinsically unified by way of their identity[19], and this keys us into the intentionality that has to go into organizing unified action, which I recommend to be based on solidarity (bottom-up) rather than unity (top-down). We can then get to the individual level, where we try to unearth desire, in the expanded sense where someone cultivates their individuality, what I call ego, or what Lorde calls the erotic. From here, we can build back up, having a meaningful and actionable awareness of social composition that tells us how the social world exists. By way of our ideology[20] and theories[21] for how the world can change, we can develop practice that materializes into that change.</p><h3>[Notes]</h3><p>[1] In Marxian theories, the superstructure is everything that sits atop the economic mode of production of society. It is everything not economic, from art, to culture, to politics, etc.</p><p>[2] As in reality, notating an importance in the physical. This is true in a broad sense, but people tend to leave out things like life belief systems and human action as important unless it relates with a very clear causality to this.</p><p>[3] The “economic foundation” of society.</p><p>[4] I’m pretty skeptical of focusing on economics unless you’re literally choosing to focus on economics, mainly because of all the ideological, theoretical, methodological, and practical baggage that comes from this.</p><p>[5] We exist in a symbiotic (meant in the neutral sense, not the colloquial, “positive”/”beneficial” sense) process with the tools we create and deploy. As we shape the tools from our ideas, the tools shape us right back, pointing us to particular potentialities.</p><p>[6] How can primacy exist when all of the elements operate together to create emergent outcomes? The closest we get is when, by way of our commitment to relationality, we see that certain axes of oppression rear their head in a pronounced way that is still propped up by the other axes.</p><p>[7] This, when combined with things like Eurocentricity, leads to vulgar dynamics in political struggle, where, for example, “working class” ends up meaning “White working class”, even though POC are much more emblematic of the class.</p><p>[8] If we’re going to make sweeping statements about society, we should either commit to philosophical inquiry (which doesn’t have the same need for “accuracy” in the scientific sense), or we should do rigorous analysis to understand our context, using phenomenology, sociality, history, science, and culture as our “raw” data.</p><p>[9] Changes that can actually happen in the most open sense, where we are not relying on supernatural or physics-defying feats of reality-warping for our goals. It’s a combination of inspiration and analysis, where we are simultaneously thinking about the exciting futures that we want and what we can do now to get there. This is distinct from how some employ “pragmatism”, asking people to “vote harder” or whatever. This is doing things that many people may see as idealistic or impossible, but are possible in actuality, which becomes easier to see as we move away from hegemonic understandings of potentiality.</p><p>[10] This is just a funny way of saying the stuff that we’re looking at. This could be anything: “object”, “subject”, “process”, “event”, “phenomena”, and/or “thing”.</p><p>[11] The way multiple identities intersect, creating phenomenological “coordinates” that are simultaneously similar to specific variables within that coordinate, but where that specific also creates a unique phenomenological experience that can only be dictated on its own terms.</p><p>[12] Seeing how different facets of identity are constantly shifting and bleeding into one another, based on different circumstances.</p><p>[13] Identities and social relations overlap and bump up against each other on the edges, and thus are able to be recognized as distinct but interconnected. This shows up in specific practical engagements, where a specific person’s identity, when compared to “normative” modes of being (cishet, white, male), impacts their experiences.</p><p>[14] I mean this in both senses of the word: economic property, and features.</p><p>[15] (Con)federalism is a mode of social organization that stands in opposition to centralism. While centralism concentrates power within small groups of people and organizational bodies, (con)federalism distributes power to the grassroots level, and connects laterally and “vertically” with other organizational bodies to administer coordination.</p><p>[16] The way a class is “composed”, through whatever collective experiences or positionalities unite everyone within. It is, based on a dialectical understanding of how the Cerberus is functioning, looking to see how we can (1) see what ways we are bound to the systems at play in a practical sense, and (2) find ways to holistically sever our selves from that binding, to create new relationships with each other, based on more communistic values.</p><p>[17] Desire here is the (spiritual, emotional, physical, rational) needs, wants, and interests of an individual or a collective, in a given moment.</p><p>[18] I’m appropriating this term from gaming communities, meant there to talk about the toolset/features that are obviously advantageous to employ, so behavior tends to shift towards using those until the game is rebalanced towards fairness. In our case, we’ll focus on how the meta indicates relationships of power-over, leading to us needing to do the “rebalancing”.</p><p>[19] Positionality tells us the ways that solidarity can develop by keying us into where people share or diverge in experiences based on the society in which they exist…it does not show were people’s <em>desires </em>lie</p><p>[20] The word ideology has a negative connotation…but I think it is honest and useful. I mean it in the basic sense of our foundational assumptions and commitments, that are ideally evidence tested constantly, and revised if evidence demands it, but also allow us to continue working.</p><p>[21] Our theories are the ideas that allow us to see if our ideology is accurate; it is the way that we build upon our foundation to see if it stands up to reality.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://dipperdesperado.tumblr.com/post/747652945192026112/class-analysis-beyond-class-reductionism-notes"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em> on April 13, 2024.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=979c0ecb0b55" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An ecology of liberatory movements]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/an-ecology-of-liberatory-movements-b9a2910ce701?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9a2910ce701</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[liberation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[black-liberation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Jan 2024 00:04:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-19T05:24:51.087Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>TLDR: <em>Understanding social movements primarily as an ecology of organizations allows us to (1) model organizations using a system that is living, complex, and adaptive, and (2) analyze the relationships between them for the sake of creating anarchic social change. With this knowledge in tow, we can become strategic, orienting to our surroundings to formulate strategies and tactics for the future. This modeling allows us to relate to ourselves and others non-hierarchically, filling our “ecological niche”, rather than trying to climb to the top of the “food chain”. If there ever was a time for domination and coercion as a modus operandi, that time has long passed. Cooperative models will allow targeted, small amounts of collective power to create outsized impacts, enabling spaces and zones of autonomy for the most dispossessed and marginalized.</em></p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>If social change happens through social ties, then <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/725759350821519360?source=share">organizing</a> is the way that multiple ties knot together into a movement. The most common way to make these knots are are through organizations. I’ll define organizations in the most broad sense; a grouping of folks, created to meet (subjectively) specific need(s), want(s), and/or desire(s). I am a critical organizationalist-I hold that organizations are ultimately necessary vehicles to enable and cultivate spaces where revolutionary action, including spontaneity, is at its most powerful (applying maximal force) and effective (able to realize intent). I also hold a lot of the anti-organizational critiques of organization in mind, through integrating them or excavating and incorporating their underlying concerns. I strive to uphold individual autonomy within organizations, where one’s will is never subordinated, and radical informed consent is upheld. We use organizations to engage in struggle effectively. They, like any other tools, should shape us in ways that we are happy with. They should not exist for their own sake.</p><p>Organizations can take many forms, but I am primarily interested in exploring organizations in a systemic way. I want to look at how social change &amp; movement organizations relate to one another and how those relations can help actualize (r)evolution. For this, I want to bring together the disparate ideas of ecology, design (as a method), and game design. Ecology as a model will inform the point (how we look at organizations within a social movement along with the context in which they reside), and design practices will inform the view (how we interact with(in) it). This creates our point-of-view, the perspective from which we will explore our topic. We strive to apprehend both the “ <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2079-8954/10/2/26">parts</a>” and “ <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2079-8954/10/2/26">wholes</a> “ of a system that we’re interested in exploring. That is how our mental models start to look like reality.</p><h3>The Broad Context &amp; Our Orientation</h3><p>Before we go any further, I want to contextualize the discussion some more. I want to explore the time that we find ourselves in so that we can relate our revolutionary activity to that context. This will, ideally, allow us to create bespoke responses to the issues at hand. We want to apply theories to our context and create new theories from that context. This will be a short, incomplete look at some of the main issues that we’re dealing with at present, in the US.</p><p>One of the biggest things to note is how unstable this decade has been so far. We’ve had a really wild past couple of years. It’s been HOT. Like, <a href="https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/reporting-state-climate-2020">literally</a>. Alongside that, we’ve had a pandemic that is <a href="https://archive.is/trw2D">surging up again</a>(2nd worst one since it started!) with no response in sight. We are seeing mass abandonment from our civil institutions and from each other in a broad sense. American individualism (as opposed to individuality) and an adequate response to the public health crisis are like oil and water. This has also intersected with a rising right wing, resulting in COVID safety protocol becoming “political” (masking up, etc is seen as “leftist”(?)).</p><p>The 2020 Black Rebellions rocked the country, radicalizing tons of people. After the killing of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Tony McDade, and others, there was a massive racial reckoning in the States. Riots abound — the movement could be best symbolized by the Minneapolis 3rd Precinct burning, and the mainstream conversation getting funneled into the slogan “defund the police” (after originally being the correct stance of “abolish the police”). Lots of anger and potential could be found in this moment-showing us a glimpse of what may be to come: radical action, reformist goals, and strategy, the likes of which are wholly unable and unwilling to adequately respond effectively.</p><p>That stuff was just in 2020. After that, we saw the repression and clamp down. As the US empire enters its death spiral, and the organized left remains teeny, there is no incentive for anything besides austerity and power concentration from the State. They are <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/US/defunding-claims-police-funding-increased-us-cities/story?id=91511971">raising cop budgets</a> as a counterinsurrectionary, reactionary ploy. Based on media reports, you might think that police were getting defunded, but the truth is that some depts quickly overturned defunding, if they ever did it at all. Most departments have waited for the storm to pass, using the fog of misinformation to their advantage, leading to more militarization and policing, such as all of the <a href="https://scalawagmagazine.org/2023/05/cop-city-atlanta-history-timeline/">Cop Cities</a> being built. Legislatively, there has been an extreme uptick of hateful energy and vitriol towards trans folks, with a massive proliferation of <a href="https://translegislation.com/learn">anti-trans bills</a> getting proposed within the past couple of years (the pace of which is <a href="https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/only-5-days-into-the-year-125-anti">constantly increasing</a>). This, paired with the movement towards banning “ <a href="https://t.umblr.com/redirect?z=https%3A%2F%2Ftime.com%2F6266865%2Fcritical-race-theory-data-exclusive%2F&amp;t=ZDg0NjFjM2M2MDNkMmY4ZWY2MjE4YTVhZDYzNDRmZjMzZWViMWIzMixkN2Q5Y2U1OTllMjQxYzYzYzU3NDA2YjExNzg1NmU4NDJlMDRkZjdk&amp;ts=1704580535">CRT</a> “ content has laid bare the emptiness of liberal conceptions of “equality” and “liberty”. These issues are used as a wedge to cleave out the “neutral” political center and polarize folks rightward. Transphobia is highly effective for this. The far-right takes and takes, and the liberals complain but don’t stop them or fight them meaningfully.</p><p>Economically, stuff isn’t looking too hot (as if the social issues weren’t enough). Inflation &amp; instability have been the defining features of the decade so far, with the main pain points being fragile supply lines, hurting from climate change, the pandemic, and war, contributing to price-setters raising prices. Capitalism continues to claim victims the world over from its practices and policies, <a href="https://inequality.org/facts/inequality-and-covid-19/">widening the gap</a> between rulers and the ruled.</p><p>All of these issues are animated by social hierarchies that uphold domination and coercion, facilitating oppression. We have to look at how these relationships of hierarchy manifest in some specific ways so that we can create specific responses. Some of these social hierarchies/systems of oppression are:</p><p>Those systems of oppression are just scratching the surface. And they all interconnect, intersect, and overlap with one another. We have to understand that hierarchy is the general concept that animates them, while specifically exploring how those specific hierarchies show up in social relations so that we can adequately address them. Staying zoomed out (where the level of “zoom” indicates specificity), just being “against hierarchy” does not make an actionable political program (nor does it ground us anything resembling useful ethics).</p><ul><li>(Cishetero)patriarchy: A system of oppression of maGes, perpetuated principally by cis men, though it has seeped into many aspects of life due to its longevity, and thus is something all have to constantly fight against (though cis men have the most work to do in this regard).</li><li>Racism: A system of oppression of non-white people, perpetuated principally by white people, manifesting most saliently as antiblackness and white supremacy, though it can be perpetuated by everyone, and thus is something we all have to fight against (though white people have the most work to do in this regard).</li><li>Ableism: A system of oppression of “dis”abled &amp; neurodivergent people, perpetuated principally by “able”-bodied &amp; neurotypical people, though it can be perpetuated by anyone, and thus should be collectively fought against (though people who are “able”-bodied and neurotypical have the most to resolve in this regard).</li><li>Colonialism: A system of oppression of one group/population by a dominating group/population. Colonial relationships can be perpetuated by colonizers and the colonized, and as such should be constantly fought against (though the brunt of the responsibility lies with those descended from colonizers, occupiers, and settlers).</li><li>Imperialism: A system of oppression that employs economic and political power over an imperialized nation or people. Imperial relationships can be reinforced by those living and imperial countries and those living in plundered countries (though the brunt of the responsibilities lies in those who materially benefit from imperialism.</li><li>Class antagonism: A system of domination that relies on the exploitation of workers for the sake of owners. Mainly perpetuated by bosses, but can be regurgitated by workers.</li></ul><p>To address these issues, we can create/employ a broad framework of analysis and action that allows us to zoom in and out, so that we can understand sites of oppression and struggle at multiple scales, for the sake of succeeding in overthrowing those oppressive orientations. I’ll describe a framework, in which our conversation about social movement ecologies would fit in, that might allow us to think about how to analyze and act against oppressive structures.</p><p>I imagine the general process for this being an oscillation between analysis and action, where the interplay between the two makes each more impactful. For this, we have what I’ll call gates; orientations to struggle that we can use to understand what is going on and figure out how to move forward. We are taking raw information and filtering it into something useful. These gates are: anti-authoritarianism/autonomism, transfeminism, anticolonization, and disability justice. We would put the issues we face on the path where they meet each of these gates, taking that gate’s perspective, so that at the end, once the issue has passed through all gates, we can have a response that takes those orientations into account. Here is how I’d describe each gate:</p><p>All of these gates have to be passed through for our actions to even have a chance of pointing in the direction that we want (genuine, egalitarian liberation, where the most marginalized can self-determine). Once we act, we return and meet the gates again. We check our understanding against each gate, armed with the information gained from action. And we repeat the process.</p><ul><li>Anti-authoritarianism/autonomism: at its foundation, our approach <em>must</em> be non-hierarchical and horizontal. Everything that we propose should maximize the ability for folks to self-determine in ways that don’t perpetuate the harmful and oppressive systems and ways of relating that we’re fighting against.</li><li>Transfeminism: We should have an intersectional feminism that understands gender, sexuality, and embodiment expansively-this will allow us to see the implications of patriarchal, sexist, and queerphobic ideas in our spaces and how much they prevent us from achieving liberatory ends. This also allows us to understand that we need to center the most marginalized, namely Black maGes and QTGNC folks, uplifting them into leadership/catalyzation/coordination positions, a necessity if we’re actually serious about liberation.</li><li>Anticolonization: We must understand our fight in the context of a colonial world-system, where the colonized take the brunt of the negative outcomes. With this in mind, we have to do the actual work to achieve our liberatory ends, and that means not tolerating bigotry and colonial logics. We have to understand the systems of oppression that we’re working against and center those at the bottom of the hierarchy in enacting the solutions. It can be easy to get stuck in theorizing and aesthetics, but the whole point of those things is to enable action. That should always be in sight.</li><li>Disability justice: All of this work that we do has to be accessible, inclusive, and create a sense of belonging. I know this can sound toothless in a liberal context, but for us, it means taking seriously the idea of centering the most marginalized, by making sure that we can cede as much power as possible. There should be a constant effort to design processes, structures, and things of that sort to ensure that disabled folks are leading our revolutionary work.</li></ul><p>This context is greatly important if we want our social movement ecology to be cultivated towards liberatory ends. Our analysis means nothing if it can’t support the ends that we are trying to reach.</p><h3>Social Movement Categories</h3><p>With some context, we can start to explore how different parts of a social movement can relate to each other, to achieve our ends. Looking at the whole of a social movement ecology (or, said otherwise, applying “ecology” as a model to social movements), there are three broad categories or levels of engagement that exist: the social base, the social-political intermediate base, and the political base.</p><p>The social base is where people tend to live, work, and interact daily. This is also where broad self-interests are responded to. For example, a big trade union exists at the social base because of the unifying factor being a social experience and/or condition (in this case sharing a trade).</p><p>The social-political intermediate base is where folks are meeting their self-interest in a more politicized way. An example might be that while a charity would exist at the social level, mutual aid, with the maxim “solidarity, not charity”, exists at the social-political level. This is an area with leverage, as it can shift the social base’s “common sense” due to its positioning relative to that base. Going from charity to mutual aid is a more tangible jump for many than jumping from charity to abolishing the commodity form.</p><p>The political base can also be seen (in our case) as the revolutionary base. This is a space where folks are grouped based on a unity of political objectives and orientation, historically with an ambivalent relationship to member self-interest. Ideally, we rectify that as we move forward. This base’s importance lies in cultivating &amp; encouraging liberatory radicalism within the other bases through mutuality, to foster liberatory tendencies.</p><p>These bases are the foundations on which organizations exist, dictating their character and orientation. Generally, organizations as a whole operate at a single, specific base, with the possibility of having initiatives in other bases. An example might be a neighborhood assembly existing at the social base, with an anticolonial council existing more in the social-political intermediate base.</p><p>Social organizations build the foundation, through people meeting their direct needs, wants, interests, and desires. They have a low barrier to entry and tend to orient around unity, like a neighborhood assembly. Then, there are social-political intermediate organizations, where self-interests are being met in a way that has a more political and/or militant orientation to it, like the anticolonial council within that assembly. The final type of organization is the political, where groups of unified actors are moving in concert. This might be something like <a href="http://www.unityandstruggle.org/">Unity &amp; Struggle</a>. These levels aren’t meant to indicate a hierarchy of importance. They are meant to distinguish and define relationships and positioning to struggle. Each level plays a part in keeping the ecology alive, functioning, and healthy. The organizations within shape what those parts are.</p><p>There are different “species” of organization within this ecology. These species fulfill certain “niches” or roles. An (aspirationally) expansive list of these species, adapted from and inspired by <a href="https://share.mayfirst.org/s/F7Fq9nCPya2dktj">this list</a> are: base-building orgs, popular organizations, activist collectives and affinity groups, dual power structures, political parties, knowledge mutualism spaces, media and culture/art institutions, syncretic organizations, and coalitions/alliances. Let’s define what those can look like:</p><ul><li>Base-building Orgs: People with a common, broad interest that unites them, and a place to collectively fight, receive, and/or advocate for those interests. In our current context, these are generally service-based NGOs and nonprofit organizations that are pretty hierarchically institutionalized</li><li>Popular Organizations: Similar to the above, but may have a wider, more general cross-section of people, the affairs of which are managed by the people in that organization</li><li>Activist Collectives and Affinity Groups: Groups for activists to act towards the issues that they care about</li><li><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/dsa-libertarian-socialist-caucus-dual-power">Dual Power</a> Structures: Institutions that meet needs, wants, and desires, defying the logic of liberalism, authoritarianism, and capitalism</li><li>Political Parties: Statist Governance bodies</li><li>Knowledge Mutualism spaces: Formations focused on building up the awareness, knowledge, and confidence of people and organizations in a horizontal and mutualistic way. Spaces of popularizing knowledge</li><li>Media and Culture/Art Institutions: Formations that create media and culture pieces from liberatory perspectives</li><li>Syncretic Organizations: Formations with members (<strong>mostly occupying the underclasses</strong>) united around liberatory vision and assessment; work to carry out a shared strategy for liberation. They syncretize learnings from across a movement and recycle them to offer a radical perspective on that movement — to move things forward</li><li>Coalitions and Alliances: Ways for organizations to come together and work as a unit. Tends to be tenuous, and whether or not that is good is based on the context</li></ul><p>These organizations comprise a range of formations, that could further be sorted into what base they arise from. This awareness of the species within the ecology allows us to start and imagine the different relationships between the species and how they inform the ecology.</p><h3>The Role of Keystone Species</h3><p>Another useful concept is the idea of keystone species. In ecosystems, a keystone species helps disproportionately shape an ecology; it’s a little thing having a big impact. In this case, these keystone species would be the organization(s) that have a great impact across the bases, towards the ends of liberation.</p><p>We can pair this idea with keystone mutualism, where that keystone effect depends on how multiple keystone species symbiotically relate to one another. This creates force multiplication and antifragility, where there is no reliance on one keystone species to uphold a movement. It can also help with shaping that “common sense” we discussed earlier.</p><p>In our model, the keystone species are syncretic organizations and activist collectives/affinity groups. The positioning and potential of both of these species can help prop up, cultivate, and strengthen revolutionary potential across the ecology.</p><p>Syncretic organizations have an especially important role. These are the where folks that are most interested in revolutionary change from an active, intentional, organized perspective should be. To be abundantly clear, I believe that this can only happen though an anti-authoritarian, transfeminist, and anticolonial movement and liberatory culture, oriented around horizontalism and solidarity. Syncretic orgs should be facilitating that. To this end, here are some tasks for them:</p><ul><li>Articulate liberatory theory and strategy that cultivates space for solidarity in pluralism</li><li>Facilitate and/or catalyze alternative visions for the world through practice</li><li>Empower the most marginalized from society &amp; the most impacted by oppression</li><li>Link together formations and folks in the movement ecology to help create ties of solidarity</li><li>Continually analyze the current moment, stay up date with current context and news, share analysis widely for the sake of taking action (past-and-present, local-regional-national-global) as it is relevant</li><li>Record, catalog, disseminate, and archive movement history for the sake of analysis and remembrance</li><li>Help support the creation of new syncretic organizations, invigorating the movement and equitizing the labor required</li><li>Social insertion, where syncretic org members work at the social and intermediate levels, from the perspective of their revolutionary orientation, increasing capacity at all levels. This should happen at sites of struggle that affect those doing the insertion, or, if necessary, in an accomplice capacity. This is not a missionary’s role. Rather than trying to “grow membership” of the revolutionary org, the revolutionary org’s members should engage in a principled manner in non-revolutionary spaces</li><li>Operate as a partner within social movements, focusing on distributed power over leadership</li><li>Guard the lane against reactionaries, opportunists, grifters, and abusers, including but not limited to: transphobes, racists, authoritarians, sexists, ableists, dominators, coercers, settlers, and other bigots</li><li>Strengthen social base through orienting around liberatory approaches to justice and an anticolonial commitment to liberation</li></ul><p>So, this begs a central question: how do we create keystone species? I have two basic proposals. We (1) create those syncretic organizations, and (2) a specific kind of formation to facilitate effectiveness with affinity groups/activist collectives and other formations: insurrectionary councils.</p><h3>Building Keystone Mutualists</h3><p>To start syncretic organizations, there needs to be a coherent political frame and an orientation. The way I generally imagine this is as the end result of a clarification process of activist collectives and affinity groups, where they start to become more expansive, with a focus on analysis and multiple issues. These can maintain an affinity group model, operate in a federated council structure, or a stigmergic cell structure as I describe in <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/738174911472959488/how-do-we-make-activist-groups-work-or-the?source=share">my writings on organizational forms</a>. Whatever form it takes, it should be in line with our goals. Basically, these kinds of organizations come into being through a process of gaining more political clarity and specificity, through engaging with social and other intermediate formations, as a revolutionary formation.</p><p><a href="https://itsgoingdown.org/anarchism-and-revolutionary-strategy-insurrectionary-councilism/">Insurrectionary councils</a> are social-political intermediate formations that allow for there to be points of congregation to steer radical action. At the social level, there might be high levels of apathy towards radical change, especially if that change is scary. This is an extreme case of learned helplessness, where people both aren’t willing to make change and actively decry meaningful action that isn’t “ <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respectability_politics">respectable</a> “. This can make social insertion difficult to the point of being ineffectual. It leaves rupture points as the moment that folks from the social level might take more radical action. The 2020 Rebellions are examples of that. This isn’t to decry social insertion; it should still be practiced. That work, however is the slow build-up towards more radical activity. It’s a process of evolution. Insurrection, on the other hand, creates spaces for revolution.</p><p>The insurrectionary councils are places where there is an alignment through points of unity and a commitment to direct action. This is a place from which folks can come from any organization or species of organization across the ecology, as long as they agree with the points of unity that animate the council. Through unification around liberatory values &amp; methods, the insurrectionary councils are an experimental space to create change through direct action. If someone calls themselves a liberal, but is willing to align with the council’s points of unity and tactics, there’s no reason to bar them at this level. Just keep an eye on them. The councils would operate on a<a href="https://seedsforchange.org.uk/spokescouncil"> spokescouncil</a> model, where each organization and formation sends/has a delegate. They don’t have to be anarchist, but they do have to be radical. This is key. We don’t want to send someone who is (only) a massive letter-writing advocate to a space discussing disruptive direct action. These delegates build connections with the council, and plant the seeds of direct &amp; militant resistance in their otherwise moderate/unaligned ‘primary’ formation. This allows for there to be a potential for popularizing direct actions, without obscuring the revolutionary development of the syncretic orgs, or alienating the social base through the “ <a href="https://www.sav.sk/journals/uploads/06261401SPS_1_2018_P%20C%20van%20Duin.pdf">vanguardist</a>” vibes that can arise through poor social insertion &amp; entryism. Multiple tendencies can come together and engage, which widen the spaces for other formations to be more effective, and propagate principled discussion and deliberation.</p><p>Syncretic orgs and insurrectionary councils can use that keystone mutualism to move things in a more radical direction through participation and practice, rather than domination and coercion. This will allow our movements to be strong and flexible, growing through collective intelligence.</p><h3>Applying Strategy to our Ecology</h3><p>With our social movement ecology as a foundation, we can get into conversations on strategy, applying some classic strategic ideas, through design lenses. Strategy, for our purposes, will be described from the perspective of our keystone mutualists, as it might not be as heavy of consideration for other formations, especially at this conjuncture. This is not a declaration on who has the “right” to create strategy. It’s just an observation on who might be willing to intentionally strategize, in an effective way.</p><p>Let’s define strategy. I tend to think of this as fractal, which is a way to explain the fact that it can apply to multiple scales. Strategy is planning for the sake of liberation at the “highest” scale. It’s planning to reach our vision of change. It’s like a viewfinder that allows us, from where we are currently situated, to (1) apprehend our goal and (2) iteratively chart out a method to get there, through practice and reflection. Specifically, we will have to look at:</p><ul><li>where our engagements, clashes, fights, and struggles will happen from a temporal and spatial perspective</li><li>our current and potential material(izable) strengths and weaknesses, along with how these can change to our advantage</li><li>the current and potential material(izable) strengths and weaknesses of our enemies, along with how these can change to our advantage</li></ul><p>This information starts us on the path of being able to assess our conditions through theory and analysis.</p><p>Tactics are like strategy on a smaller scale. It’s a more concrete look. We ask the same questions but for a specific moment. If strategy is how we win the war, tactics are how we win the battle. To analyze our tactics, in addition to our previous strategic considerations, we can get more specific (using an <a href="https://cryptpad.fr/sheet/#/2/sheet/view/MCeu150gKjBl1wppes9p5lnDLGTZ0QrkbitTxAonmf0/">Action Winnability Matrix</a>):</p><ul><li>Do we have a compelling narrative for the action?</li><li>Are those most directly impacted involved <strong>AND</strong> ready to act?</li><li>How materially easy is it for the target to capitulate/for us to receive what we want?</li><li>How ideologically easy is it for the target to capitulate/for us to receive what we want?</li><li>Is the action is autonomous? Does it hold the threat of further disruption?</li><li>How <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1u8QyjtUuAxlHO0c1DeHYu5O8BT3e-wL9TpaWiV5CZGQ/edit">SMART(IE)</a> are our demands/goals?</li><li>Do we have the resources (people, power, process) to execute this action successfully, without exhausting those resources?</li></ul><p>So if strategy is about moving towards our goals, and tactics are about a specific application of that strategy for a particular moment, there needs to be a way to make those plans materialize. This is where logistics and operations, an underrated part of strategic planning, comes in. With these, we answer questions like:</p><ul><li>How are we keeping our people cared for? What are the ways in which we produce and reproduce/maintain things like food, water, shelter, and personal needs?</li><li>What does onboarding, engagement, and training look like, at each level of the movement?</li><li>What plan(s) do we have to acquire what we need?</li><li>What (tools, resources, materials + people, power, process) do we need to accomplish our (short term, medium term, long term, micro, meso, macro) objectives?</li><li>What is our positioning, at this moment, and in general? What about our enemies’?</li><li>What conditions (social, political, economic, ecological/environmental, technological) are we facing? How does that impact our capabilities?</li></ul><p>Having logistics and operations in place makes the theory of fighting material, and lets you know what the chances are of being able to succeed at the goals and objectives being set.</p><p>Zooming back out to strategy, there are different strategic orientations that we can take. We can approach things head-on, we can swarm/encircle our objective, or we can divide our objective/split it up. I recommend a general strategic orientation of encircling, with features of the other two as they are useful. In my conception, encircling is a strategy that sees objectives as having multiple sides. Essentially, the movement would try to achieve objectives by working in solidarity, through a diversity of tactics. There would be an effort through the keystone mutualists to mitigate unhelpful redundancies (redundancy can be insurance in many cases). Each type of organization in the ecosystem would approach the problem in a way that is grounded in their theory of change, all the while, radical elements are showing the importance of more radical action. It might look something like this:</p><ul><li>Responsive: support is provided when and where it’s needed.</li><li>Simple: planning and execution of action is oriented around solidarity and efficiency, as a counterweight to the friction and lack of information on the ground.</li><li>Flexible: can improvise and adapt on the ground to changing conditions.</li><li>Resourceful: only use what is needed to achieve objectives.</li><li>Attainable: can achieve objectives and operate with an acceptable level of risk (enough supplies, support, infrastructure).</li><li>Sustainable: can maintain the attainability of objectives for the length required to complete them.</li><li>Survivable/Antifragile: able to prevail, persist, and strengthen from adversity.</li></ul><p>Encircling is a way that the disparate parts of a movement can co-create a “common sense” and act in solidarity. Multiple groups, in various overlapping and related formations, sharing objectives, and working towards them, with the radical elements shifting what’s acceptable in a more militant direction, can create higher chances of achieving social change.</p><h3>In Practice</h3><p>I want to try and bring everything together in a relatively tangible way. So, the organizations that we’ve discussed in this ecology can exist in different forms, but as we grow, we should encourage forms that support our content. For us, that means anti-authoritarian, transfeminist, anticolonial, and horizontalist orgs. This would allow the social, intermediate, and political bases to have a way to relate to one another that is based on mutuality rather than domination. Instead of leading the movement, the keystone mutualists can influence it and be influenced by it by proving themselves in practice. The radical tactics adopted at the social level should win folks over because they work, not because they were imposed from above. The social level will also innovate in ways that the two other levels can learn from.</p><p>To understand how we might start preparing to cohere an ecology into a movement that can exercise force, we should target systems of oppression from the perspective of self-interest.</p><p>Self-interest is expansive in my conception, where it recognizes that every individual has self-interest, so building a community that can self-determine is in the self-interest of those community members. Think of it as an <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/egoism/#EthiEgoi">ethical egoism</a>, stretched to encompass the facilitation of communal, deep bonds with others. If I have a dream to be a musician, an alternative to seeing my self-interest being embedded in the dog-eat-dog world of the music industry would be to create and plug into networks of care and communal support for tours. We want to change the rules of the game and create a new game entirely, rather than taking the design of the game for granted.</p><ul><li>At the social level, there might be a desire to do low-confrontation actions, where they appeal to authority. These are your letter-writing campaigns, phone banks, rallies, and marches.</li><li>At the social-political intermediate level, there might be a desire to do medium-to-high-confrontations with authority. These are actions like civil disobedience, strikes, boycotts and other noncooperative forms of resistance, and “nonviolent” direct actions.</li><li>At the political level, there might be more of a willingness to have higher confrontation tactics. These would be actions that orient around crippling and destroying the ability for authority to function.</li><li>Each higher level might engage at lower levels, and employ tactics from those levels. Each level will probably escalate over time, as lower confrontation methods yield less useful results long-term.</li></ul><p>To find our primary target, we can orient around analyzing the pillars that hold it up and think of ways that our folks can respond. We can then find points of intervention, where we can exercise leverage. For sub-targets, it could be steps on the way to that final primary target, or specific leverage points that make it easier to hit the central node that will take down the primary target.</p><p>For the pillars, we can see if any of them constitute meaningful tertiary targets, which could be more manageable and isolate the primary target. It may be easier to cut off the circulation of resources than it is to strike directly. A ship or truck in transit is easier to impede than a shipping depot.</p><p>We should approach these targets using encircling, with as much fidelity as we are allowed. An illustrative and contentious example of this orientation in practice is<a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/10/7/what-happened-in-israel-a-breakdown-of-how-the-hamas-attack-unfolded"> Operation Al-Aqsa Flood</a>. Alongside thinking about a diversity of tactics, happening in parallel, across a spectrum of confrontation, it would be worthwhile to consider tactics that work from the inside, outside, and alongside the target(s). Inside are things like spies and espionage, outside being the range of what we might normally imagine when thinking of attacks, and alongside being working on fortifying the other two, usually through networks of care, support, and alternative institutions.</p><p>A specific application for these ideas would be about community control. For more on these ideas, read the excellent<a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/lorenzo-kom-boa-ervin-community-control-of-the-poor-community.pdf"> community control of the poor community</a>. Meeting personal (and community) self-interest would mean kicking the state out of the community. In its place, we might create things like cooperative housing, food, medical, rewilding programs, community &amp; cultural centers, and more. We’d do this all in the frame of a liberatory approach to space, applying our principles to change the built environment. We would orient around the idea of survival programs (as in survival pending revolution), where <em>everyone</em> has an<a href="https://librarysocialism.org/#irreducible-minimum"> irreducible minimum</a> (could also be seen as universal basic outcomes) for their life. To get to there from here, we could:</p><ol><li><strong>Collectivize everything we can, through collaboration, or seizure if we must, depending on the antagonism of the current owners</strong>. For example, businesses in our communities should be collectivized. We should, especially if it provides some benefit to its customers, try to bring them into the fold. We would try to encourage worker ownership structures and the like. If they refuse, then we can either leave them be, or decide how else to proceed. People tend to see small businesses as inherently less capitalistic, but systems have fractality. A small business owner, especially one who doesn’t challenge domineering paradigms, is still a business owner. As we transition our community to usage-based ownership models, in the vein of a<a href="https://librarysocialism.org/"> library socialist economy</a>, we should, (especially to folks who aren’t multiple strata above us in the hierarchy) make the case that socializing resources will bring everyone’s standard of living up, through proven examples, keeping their (expansive) self-interest in mind. In other words, we’re not going to be warlords with this shit, but we should be willing to fight so that spaces of self-determination can be found. We are going to work to get what we deserve and take what we need.</li><li><strong>Create communal housing and spatial planning structures that maximize community input</strong>. Folks in a community should directly decide what goes on in their community. The design and usage should move from being static to being fluid and participatory, accommodating the needs of folks and other parts of nature, with an orientation around centering and uplifting those at the margins. For housing, slumlords will have their housing seized and collectivized, renovated to healthy living standards, or deconstructed to retrieve any valuable building materials. A combination of <a href="https://tuewas-asia.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/TrainingMaterial_A_Tactical_Urbanism_Guidebook.pdf">tactical urbanism</a>, rent strikes, demonstrations, squatting, and other confrontational methods should be employed to achieve this.</li><li><strong>Demand reparations, landback, and government concessions</strong>. We should bolster our <a href="https://nonprofitquarterly.org/system-change-a-basic-primer-to-the-solidarity-economy/">solidarity economy</a>, mutual aid, and dual power structures through funds and resources seized or conceded from the government. We should create popular pressure campaigns to this end, and use these concessions to reinforce our resolve toward self-determination (instead of seeing concessions as the ends themselves), through communal inoculation against statist promises of representation. We should employ strikes, targeting critical state functions, tax boycotts, and debt boycotts, all predicated on robust networks of care to support our people through the fight.</li><li><strong>Organize self-defense formations against the forces of reaction</strong>. We need to be able to practice self-defense against any of the forces that would wish to harm us. Communities should have a maximal permeation of fighting, combat, de-escalation, and liberatory justice training. Certain groups, such as cops and fascist para-militaries, shouldn’t even think about attacking. Internal threats, such as abusers, grifters, sellouts, and opportunists, should be handled appropriately, with a process decided that centers the needs of those that are harmed, and only goes towards rehabilitation/transformation if (1) that is something that the harmed folk(s) want, and (2) something that the perpetrator(s) of harm are willing to commit to with high levels of intentionality. Otherwise, it’s time to run their pockets and kick them to the curb.</li><li><strong>Democratize and Popularize “professional” knowledge guarded by industries and academia</strong>. Anyone interested in a subject or profession should have access to the training to learn that topic, in a horizontal, autonomous, cooperative setting. Healthcare work, construction work, ecological restoration, engineering, and other professionalized fields should be accessible to all, with the end goal of having the skills in our communities to create things like free clinics, makerspaces, boutique engineering projects, spatial environment retooling and renovation towards community needs, and projects to increase ecological harmony.</li><li><strong>Abolish all carceral systems</strong>. Jails, prisons, psych wards, non-free schools (by free schools I’m referring to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_Schools">freedom school</a>/<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferrer_movement">modern school</a>), and any other appendages of the Prison Industrial Complex should be devoured and destroyed. Prisoners should be released, including political prisoners. Community programs, a distribution of the means of protection and violence, liberatory, horizontal approaches to schooling, and communal justice practices should be raised in the Prison Industrial Complex’s stead.</li><li><strong>Establish communal and inter-communal food sovereignty</strong>. There should be campaigns employed to create sovereign food systems through collective associations and seizure of agricultural lands, transforming them into ecologically harmonious zones through methods found in agroecology, ethnobotany, and permaculture.</li><li><strong>Establish networks of liberatory school systems with liberatory pedagogical models throughout the community</strong>. We should enable our children to experience a learning model that engenders within them a sense of community-informed individuality, allowing them to self-direct their learning and growth with adults being support systems, like a net ready to catch them. This should also be bound to a movement to gain free college for poor folks, a movement on campuses for student &amp; staff control, and continual experiences for adult education and older learners. Everyone should have methods and spaces to learn in the way that best suits them, to cultivate freer spirits.</li></ol><p>Community control can create a base of activity for further revolutionary action — leading to a stronger movement ecosystem where forms like cooperatives and community-owned programs can be used to bolster liberatory outcomes. Creating more direct control structures in a community helps people meet their needs in ways that give them more space to do the other things that they want to do. A thing to keep in mind is that a cooperative, solidarity economy or things of that nature are not inherently liberatory, as in they challenge the logic of capitalism in a meaningful capacity. We create these survival programs so that we can have the logistical and operational bases that we need to be able to execute our revolutionary strategy and tactics. This allows us to expand our influence and activity inside and outside of our community.</p><p>By crafting this ecological, designerly view of our social movements, we can read them as living networks and/or systems, discover what levels we need to engage, how we might relate disparate parts of a movement, and create a united front to bring about the world that we desire. This gives us direction, intentionality, and the possibility to bring about the kind of change that we want to see.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/738809081422331904/an-ecology-of-liberatory-movements?source=share"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9a2910ce701" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[how do we make activist groups work? Or, the importance of social technology in social change]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/how-do-we-make-activist-groups-work-or-the-importance-of-social-technology-in-social-change-982de23f4fe0?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/982de23f4fe0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Dec 2023 01:50:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-31T01:50:31.090Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>TLDR: <em>By retooling, devouring, and innovating our social technologies, we can create participatory vehicles that enable egalitarian social change. These organizations should be animated by an understanding of hierarchy, its relation to oppression writ-large, and how to create and employ social technologies that distribute power, rather than concentrating it.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*JAEmUyjw7-Hc20uY" /><figcaption>Photo by Benjamin R. on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><h3>Introduction</h3><p>We take technology for granted in general (most people I know don’t think much about how water gets to their sink unless it doesn’t work, for example), but this seems especially true for our social technologies. We take things like democracy, laws, even the nuclear family form, at face value and as fundamental parts of reality.</p><p>So, what is technology, and how does it relate to our pending conversation? What is the throughline between obvious technologies like a stone axe and my iPhone, and more nebulous ones, like speech and the nuclear family? Any technology you can imagine takes concepts and knowledge and creates a method of applying them to specific goals, objectives, or functions. This doesn’t preclude emergent uses for tools, as you can probably think of using tools in unintended ways. This definition is useful to keep in mind as we realize that the technologies at present, animating the status quo are inadequate. We need something different to make radical, roots-grasping change.</p><p>And, for the sake of change, we need a specific way to achieve it. Part of this is technological; we need to figure out models of relating and working with one another that <a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/paul-raekstad-and-eivind-dahl-prefigurative-politics">prefigure</a> the changes that we want to see. To create and modify those technologies, we need to figure out which concepts and knowledge we will use.</p><p>Prefiguration can be described as “creating the new world in the shell of the old”. It’s doing things in the present that we think will get us to our imagined future. This implies the need to have a coherent conception of what is currently happening, and change will look like.</p><p>Currently, we live in a hierarchical, bureaucratic hell. This might best be epitomized by trying to obtain official identification recognized by our respective state. From all of the forms that you fill out, to the additional paperwork needed, to the horrible experience of getting that information approved, there are a lot of issues that this creates, from an experiential standpoint. One of the more under-realized aspects of issues such as this is how these experiences alienate us from the ability to do things for ourselves. Bureaucracy is a way to manage hierarchy’s inherent simplification of reality. A king couldn’t <strong>actually</strong> run their kingdom themselves, so they create layers of functionaries, under their control, to (try and) manage that complexity.</p><p>Along with my opposition, I’d like to propose something. A theory of change, that allows us to do that prefiguration work, leaving behind some of the negative methods of how relating is currently mediated and handled. <strong>Since</strong> we live in a very hierarchical and bureaucratic world-system, constituting a colonial-imperialist, cisheteropatriarchical, ableist hegemony, <strong>if</strong> we create non-hierarchical/heterarchical organizational forms that allow us to relate in alignment with our values, <strong>then</strong> we will achieve a more egalitarian world, <strong>because</strong> of these organizational forms addressing fundamental contradictions within the way that society is administered and ordered at present.</p><p>Having non-hierarchical organizational forms will allow us to become self-managed and autonomous, gaining collective control over collective issues, and individual control over individual issues. What is hierarchy, though? For our purposes, hierarchy can be seen as the glue that brings oppression together. It binds structures of domination, coercion, and power (specifically power-over) into oppression writ-large. This is what makes the act of arranging organizational forms a pyramid, where value, authority, and decision-making ability are concentrated toward the top. It is not a problem if some friendly games and competitions employ hierarchy in the broadest sense. The issue comes where, in that game, the folks who won got to eat and the folks who lost went hungry. The power imbalance and value judgments are what make hierarchy dangerous.</p><p>Alternatively, non-hierarchical structures that prioritize non-coercive, non-domineering principles, that enable positive versions of power-to (the ability to act) and power-with (the ability to act collectively, towards collective interest) have much more liberatory potential at their foundation. That’s what we’re aiming for, social technologies that allow for horizontal relating.</p><h3><strong>The pieces of horizontal organizations</strong></h3><p>The foundation of these horizontal, heterarchical forms should be in values and principles that enable relating in that way. Some of these values might be joy, autonomy, radically informed consent, cultivating ownness-uniqueness, and solidarity. These are defined as:</p><ul><li><strong>Joy</strong>: This should be a group that is constantly looking critically at how we engage with productivity, work, and formality from the perspective of prefiguring spaces of fun, play, and levity — infusing it into as much of the work as we can. If it feels like a drag, that should at the very least give us pause. While we will not be able to avoid negativity wholesale, we can be intentional about minimizing the moments where it is unnecessary.</li><li><strong>Autonomy</strong>: Each unit of interest (teammate, team, section/wing, whole) can operate independently from other elements as it desires, without imposition.</li><li><strong>Radically Informed Consent</strong>: All decisions that include or impact someone should be made with that person (1) in that discussion/process and (2) having as much context and information as they need to be aware of the implications of the decision being made.</li><li><strong>Cultivating Ownness-Uniqueness</strong>: The group should allow for a cooperative orientation that is based on finding what is best for all involved as individuals, concerning the collective goals. The group should be a tool that cultivates this orientation, rather than existing for its own sake and becoming something that holds power over the people in the space.</li><li><strong>Solidarity</strong>: People in the group should work together around common interests and affinities, made clear in the joining process, grounded in (1) centering the most marginalized in society and/or our specific context within our spaces, and (2) sharing in the responsibilities of achieving what the group sets out to do.</li></ul><p>Having these values as described gives us a shared language from which to judge how we relate to each other using the organizational forms we will set out to describe, to make sure that it gives opportunities to widen the spaces where our organizational aims can be achieved.</p><p>The components of these forms, the building blocks that sit atop the foundation, creating the organization when assembled, are the teammate, roles &amp; tasks, aims &amp; domains, the team, assemblies and summits, and the areas, functions, and committees. These are defined as:</p><ul><li><strong>Teammate</strong>: This is the individual in the structure. A specific person, who interfaces with the other parts of the structure.</li><li><strong>Roles and Tasks</strong>: This is how the work is distributed within an organization, in line with the foundational principles and the aims of the specific team and organization as a whole.</li><li><strong>aims: O</strong>bjectives of the unit of interest. The thing that the unit of interest is trying to accomplish.</li><li><strong>Domains</strong>: The range of focus a specific unit of interest has within an organization. What the unit of interest is responsible for doing.</li><li>Team: A collective unit within the structure. Multiple teammates coming together.</li><li>Assemblies and Summits: Multiple teams (or delegations of teams) coming together to deliberate on mutual aims, across mutual domains.</li><li><strong>Areas, Functions, and Committees</strong>: Ways to group teams together (or create new teams) to cover specific aims.</li></ul><p>These allow for us to have specific modes of relating with each other around specific things that we want to accomplish, from the individual to the organization-wide scale, with the potential to connect with outside organizations.</p><p>These values and components are important to create are heterarchical organization, but it doesn’t tell us what the organization will be doing. We know that it’s meant to be aimed towards social change, but what does that actually look like? I think that there are three interrelated things that the organization should achieve for it to be successful at its overall aims. There should be robust analysis, care work, and effective, radical action. These are described as:</p><ul><li><strong>Care Work</strong>: Embedding the ideas of restoration, rest, healthy engagement, sustainability, and healing into the core of the organizational structure. This can be done through things like healing circles, accountability circles, meeting “non-organizational” needs that deal with the making and remaking of folks (a la childcare, food, emotional care, etc), and other methods.</li><li><strong>Robust analysis</strong>: Creating mental models that can approach an accurate understanding of the world, along with how to be experimental and learn from those experiments (while not seeing participants as disposable, or coercing folks into things). This horizontal orientation encourages us to be able to catalyze autonomous &amp; self-directed action, rather than make ourselves indispensable to a movement. We should use these forms to organize ourselves out of a role, in a sense, through things such as making sure other people understand how to do what we do, and not hyper-specializing.</li><li><strong>Effective, Radical Action</strong>: The organization, through the above two functions, should be able to achieve the goals that it sets. It should be successful at the current conjuncture, and these successes should build up to the general goals of the organization. There should be a conception of strategy, campaigns, logistics/operations, and tactics.</li></ul><p>For any of these initiatives to be successful, there needs to be a basic security culture. Pretty much any social change org that is directly effective or building towards effectiveness necessitates modes of protection for the people in the organization. We need to protect from state, corporate, and non-state reactionaries. This is worth an in-depth conversation, but basic things like not talking to those forces, being mindful of where and when certain information is shared, if at all, and screening for new members, the intensity of which is proportional to the openness of the organization, and not fedjacketing (claim that someone is the cops) people. This would be paired with collective discussion to establish those agreements, and training/collective study to inoculate folks against bad security practices.</p><h3>Arranging the pieces</h3><p>Now that we’ve built up the different parts of our organizations, we can describe some ways to bring them together. I propose three different organizational shapes: phantom cells, networked guerrillas, and fractal teams and working groups. These are differentiated by the ways that the teams within the org are connected and relate to one another.</p><p>Phantom cells are the most ephemeral formation that I’ll describe. These are temporary teams created with wide variations towards some goal. They don’t even have any meaningful awareness of the composition of other cells. Actions are motivated by catalyzing forces that follow a general flow of event → action → report-back → action. Something happens that motivates a cell to form and act, that cell publishes information about their action, along with instructions on how to replicate and the ideological motivation behind it, and others follow suit. This repeats and spreads out, through stigmergy. It’s like how social media trends work. All follow a similar format, evolving as they spread until they saturate a space and wane. The goal here is to combine distributed intelligence through information posting, replicability, and inspiration.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*1IgI3VItGQA0_Q9i" /><figcaption>a diagram representing phantom cells. Pill shapes with the word team in the middle are spread around on a white canvas.</figcaption></figure><p>This form is inspired by Tiktok and the <a href="https://crimethinc.com/2008/09/01/the-shac-model-a-critical-assessment">SHAC</a> campaign. If we could have groups of folks who: (1) find concrete goals &amp; replicable methods for finding connected goals in specific contexts, (2) create compelling narratives around acting in line with those goals, and (3) encourage easily replicable actions, consistent pressure, and sharing the results so that it spreads. This allows for action to become highly distributed, where unity isn’t based on allegiance to specific organizations, movements, or formations. This type of operation is most useful for trying to achieve protracted, quick, decisive, small actions against a target.</p><p>Networked guerrillas are cells (or teams) of folks that have a well-rounded skill set, and who work consistently together. I imagine it being like a team for an RPG (role-playing game) campaign where each character is in a different class. This group should have a relatively high amount of self-sufficiency, to be able to achieve aims within their domain without much outside assistance. Each cell is animated by a general alignment of principles, vision, and values. Cells are also designed to link up with other cells, of this type, to accomplish bigger goals and complete bigger actions. There might also be a bundle of cells “in the middle” to help coordinate resources between cells and provide additional, more specialized, and contextual resources. Ideally, there is a rotation and continual morphing of the core to not become a failure point. This is why it’s important to have the cells be as self-sufficient as possible. Every connection is an enhancement of capability, rather than a necessity. The relationships between the cells can be organized like a mesh network (many-to-many relationships between the cells), star (one-to-many-to-one relationships), and a chain/ring (one-to-one-to-one relationships), or some combination, based on the needs of the organization.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NmrKNgMCfRfzNut77g3MQw.png" /><figcaption><em>A diagram representing networked guerrillas. showing a form that combines mesh, start, and chain/ring.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Fractal teams and working groups work through a kind of fractal, heterarchical confederalism. Essentially, it flips the hierarchical nature of authoritarian federalism by having power flow from the lowest level upwards, rather than the other way around. It starts at the lowest level, the team, and we confederate upwards from there to encompass more general aims and domains, using assemblies, assemblies of assemblies, and summits. This structure also operates on the principle of autonomous collaboration, where people who are impacted by and/or are doing a specific set of tasks are the ones to decide how that task is implemented. This is meant to minimize the amount of power-over within the structure, while still fostering modes of engagement between different scales of decision making. At each level, there would be assemblies that provide the space to share information and discuss plans, and for potential working groups to meet and freely associate and dissociate as necessary. Decisions shouldn’t be made here at these higher levels of the hierarchy, as that leads to a form of power that isn’t always deliberative. Folks would execute whatever plans they see fit on the ground, based on self-organization, informed by the information that is shared within these more open, popular gatherings. The trust is put on folks to be self-directed around their needs, getting help and providing assistance in a mutualistic way, rather than a top-down way.</p><p>a diagram of the fractal teams &amp; working groups. teams send delegates to assemblies, and assemblies send delegates to assemblies of assemblies or summits. delegates gather information and context at the above levels and come back to their team to provide context and give information to the team. They also will share the decisions made by the teams, to the assemblies and summits.</p><p>All of these forms would need some kind of intelligence apparatus. Intelligence for us will be information that allows us to achieve objectives better. We gain this information through research, investigative journalism-style methods, and espionage. It is pertinent, practical, and informative. These apparatuses will gather information (what we might usually think of as intelligence), and prevent/impede opposition from doing the same (counterintelligence). This is not something it seems like social change folks are intentional about very often, but is an important part of building, refining, and achieving the aims laid out at every scale, from strategies for wider social change to specific actions.</p><p>The basic structure of this intelligence apparatus is a specific unit of interest would (s)elect/delegate an intelligence handler to work within that unit’s domain. This handler is one part of an intelligence cell. The cell would be a compartmentalized team for the sake of mutual protection, containing a handler, analyst(s), and agent(s). Handlers are the cell coordinators, recruiting the other roles as they see fit. They act as the direct link/contact to the agent on the ground/in the field, supporting them on their missions with whatever they need. Handlers also support analysts with collaborating on research work or anything that they need. Handlers are the glue of a cell, supporting everyone towards their objectives. Analysts are the folks who make the information gathered by the agents usable. They sort and organize the information, making things like reports and presentations so that action can come from or be informed by the information. Handlers may support the analysts with those tasks. Agents are the crux of this cell-they gather the intelligence. They should be a generalizing specialist, where they understand the breadth of the context in which they act, even with a specific specialty in the type of intelligence they gather.</p><p>For these purposes, there will probably be a combination of focus on<a href="https://restofworld.org/2022/osint-viral-ukraine/"> open-source intelligence</a>,<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signals_intelligence"> signals intelligence</a>, and<a href="https://www.intelligence101.com/the-ultimate-guide-to-human-intelligence-humint/"> human intelligence</a>. Finally, we have the auditor. They are also elected by the unit of interest (the one that placed the handler). This is a way to make sure there isn’t any tomfoolery happening within the cell-the auditor can look over any of the information within the cell, and compile an independent report for the sake of the unit of interest.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5T-BdLbqzmD4JFYBS1ZzQw.png" /><figcaption><em>A diagram of the basic intelligence apparatus.</em></figcaption></figure><p>The basic intelligence process would go as follows: Information would be split or categorized into four main areas: strategic, campaign, logistic/operational, and tactical. For each of these levels, there would be a repeating loop process of setting goals in relation to those areas, gathering the information, analyzing it, figuring out how to use it, and a method to evaluate the process. Information can be gathered by agents or anyone else in the organization, anonymously. This helps bolster the capacity of information gathering.</p><p>So, we start by asking, what do we need to know to achieve our aims? Then, we ask about where we can find that information. As we’ll probably receive more information than what is usable, we want to ask about what information found is important, timely, and accurate/verifiable? After that, we want to ask how we can package and disseminate the information, along with an understanding of the audience(s). That leads us to review what we’ve done, integrate any changes, and start the process over. This is not to say that teams can’t do intelligence-gathering work themselves, such as scouting or information synthesis. It is just useful to have capacity specifically built for that work.</p><h3>How these forms relate</h3><p>Finally, we want to look at the relationship between the organizational forms, and how these forms change, depending on what the specific organization does. We can do this by understanding how things look through the classifications of overt, covert, and clandestine.</p><p>Overt organizations act out in the open. They operate in a mode where what you see is what you get. Phantom cells might operate as front-facing aboveground collectives of folks who have a very specific focus, with the intent to popularize and virally spread action around that focus, through building (para)social relationships. Networked guerrillas might make more intentional, long-term connections between cells, leading to a more tightly bound network. This could look like the mesh model. Fractal teams might have highly accessible and legible teams and assemblies with centralized information pipelines, creating an easy way to get involved with the movement. This point is important when we’re thinking about how to make the movement accessible.</p><p>Covert organizations act in secret, operating on the mode of plausible deniability. Phantom cells might use mainstream channels to share their ideas but operate in a way that obscures their identities. Networked guerrillas might have the cells be related using a star model, with many connections compartmentalized by those shared nodes. Fractal teams might hide membership and focus on the intake process because this formation is the most vulnerable to infiltration. Maybe this formation isn’t useful outside of the overt context.</p><p>Clandestine organizations are fully underground. Phantom cells might only spread action through hyper-encrypted or low-tech methods. Networked guerrillas might have no awareness of who or what the composition is of other teams in the network, and any connections between cells might be mediated in ways that maintain anonymity and prevent infiltration. Fractal teams likely would be a great weakness in this context.</p><p>Looking at all of these forms, across different modes of operating, we should not “pick” one form or the other in a dogmatic way. Each form should see the others as providing something of value towards anti-authoritarian ends. In other words, fractals should not decry networks or phantoms for their seemingly chaotic structures or methods. Phantoms shouldn’t shit on the other two for not being effective enough. Aligning people and actions across these horizontal forms will allow an ecosystem of forms that reinforces the ability of each to succeed. Overt groups can act as an auxiliary force for the covert and clandestine groups, and the covert and clandestine groups can create spaces for the overt groups to construct the world they are all working for.</p><p>By having principles and ethics that are sound, exploring what organizations need to do, and creating structures that enable those ethics and principles to be realized, we can have social technologies that allow us to more easily accomplish the social change that we’re seeking.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/738174911472959488/how-do-we-make-activist-groups-work-or-the?source=share"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=982de23f4fe0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A sketch for the moment, a strategy for radicals]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/a-sketch-for-the-moment-a-strategy-for-radicals-17ba73f78c3f?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17ba73f78c3f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[radicalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[insurrection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Dec 2023 22:46:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-26T22:46:44.485Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VgnDqxdn4Ii1j5LC" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@markfb?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Mark Fletcher-Brown</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I read a piece today about <a href="https://itsgoingdown.org/anarchism-and-revolutionary-strategy-insurrectionary-councilism/">Insurrectionary Councilism</a> and it may have just been what I needed to formulate something I’ve been trying to figure out about strategic positioning for our current moment. Basically, it’s meant to figure out what to do to create a left movement that is actually capable of getting us what we need. That is bottom-up socialism. So, While I’m writing a more involved thing exploring this topic, I thought I’d share some thoughts in progress rn.</p><p>One thing I’ve been thinking about is the idea of seeing social movements as an ecological system. Different organizations operate as different species, and the color/shape of the movement is dictated by the relationships between the different parts. We’re at a moment where ‘the left’ is mired in high mobilizations but low levels of radical organization. This is problematic because we can’t garner meaningful concessions from the powers that be, nor can we go the distance to establish a new structure. The model of professionalizing revolutionaries (through <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_centralism">democratic centralism</a> and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanguardism">vanguards</a>) is also not great because it doesn’t popularize autonomy and self-direction. We could and should form revolutionary organs and affinity groups with high alignment, but the strength of those spaces can easily become a weakness. I think that insurrectionary councilism is a way out, that strengthens our ability to engage and build meaningful movements.</p><p>So, insurrectionary councilism is basically the idea of creating an intentional space for different movements/organizations/etc to come together and experiment through direct action. The basic format described would be that in a given area, like a city, different groups that cover different issues, like policing, environmental racism, transphobia, etc. Would come together to figure out how to address those issues through <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_action">direct action</a> (as defined by anarchists, not liberals). The folks in this space would be folks who are already radical. They wouldn’t have to be libertarian socialist or anarchist in name, but they’d have to agree with basic points of unity that align with anarchist practice.</p><p>This excites me because it can allow us to catalyze more radical action in movements without trying to dominate or take them over in a coercive way. This approach of having the folks ready to throw down holding space for one another and being able to meet across tendencies and plan action. We can respond to threats in a more effective and quick way, build capacity, and potentially move out of a place of pure reaction using this form.</p><p>We also want to pair this with the slow-burn method of what <a href="https://zabalazabooks.files.wordpress.com/2012/03/social_anarchism_and_organisation_farj_en.pdf">especifists</a> call social insertion, where folks from organizations with a specific political orientation work in social movements to propagate libertarian socialist values. This takes a long time and is more about building relationships with the widest possible net of folks who have some shared self-interest.</p><p>By pairing insurrectionary councilism with social insertion, folks in politically dedicated groups can both have structures that prefigure horizontality through the slow process of evolution, and structures that crack open spaces for horizontality through insurrection. These can become mutually reinforcing, where as direct action is successful, more people become interested in the ideas they heard from the social inserters. As more people start to organize and get acclimated to the ideas of libertarian socialism, they might support direct action efforts.</p><p>This idea is so dope to me because of its potential to amplify the anarchic thrust of lots of movements while inoculating them against authoritarianism. We can respond quickly to different threats and widen the spaces of autonomy while building relationships and solidarity.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/736474157212123137/i-read-a-piece-today-about-insurrectionary?source=share"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17ba73f78c3f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Get Organized!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/get-organized-4f3c594bca2c?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4f3c594bca2c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[solidarity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics-and-society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics-and-protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Aug 2023 19:48:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-26T19:48:44.407Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*19PHO9_H-VSZn_wi" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@onthesearchforpineapples?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Colin Lloyd</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I recently made a post about <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/723504701318086656/radicalism-100-get-started-from-0-or-how-the?source=share">how to get started in doing radical stuff</a>. Said otherwise, that post was meant to answer the question, “Where do I go, when I know the world is fucked?” This post covers similar ground, but is more interested in the theoretical side of things. Not to say it won’t be practical. It’s just saying that if you’re not the kind of person that can read a little bit and feel confident to act, or you like having a little bit more scaffolding, that you also deserve a resource. I’m hoping to contribute to that today. As the title says, we’re going to be focusing on organizing. This is one of those things that is said a lot, but is actually defined much less often. Tangentially, you should be aware and ready for this for literally everything relating to politics. Any word that you hear used, you should always ask for a definition. Many a movement would have gone differently if folks spent more time trying to find semantic alignment. Anyway.</p><p>When I say organizing, I mean <strong>catalyzing the energy of folks, acting from a specific theory of change.</strong> A theory of change is <strong>a thought process or method to create some kind of social impact in a particular context</strong>. When the world sucks in some particular way, and you want it to stop sucking, the answer is to organize, in the way defined above. By organizing, we lean on the idea of collective power to create changes that are currently only afforded to those with authoritarian power. It’s a game of evening the odds.</p><p>I will also note that this assumes that you are going to be framing your work around broad-based movements, that have (mostly) aboveground (as in “legal”) tactics. This is not necessarily a statement of what is correct; small groups that are in concert with larger movements are also able to be successful, even when doing more confrontational tactics.</p><p>So, to organize, I’d say it would be useful to be involved in movements already. You can look at my <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/723504701318086656/radicalism-100-get-started-from-0-or-how-the?source=share">radicalism 100</a> post to see how that could look. Either way you have to know what your where your niche(s) lie. In other words, what sits in the middle of the intersection between what you like to do, what you are good (or can become good/have a willingness to become good) at, and what is needed in your context. I tend to center the local level, because that is the area where influence is more tangible, and fits into how I see a resilient world coming to fruition. So, you have to ask yourself, “What can I do, that I would enjoy doing, in my community?” Then, you should find some other people who are in that same vibe. Depending on your approach, this may take no time at all, or a lot of time. I listed some ideas for finding folks in <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/723504701318086656/radicalism-100-get-started-from-0-or-how-the?source=share">radicalism 100</a>, but to reiterate: look for social medias and IRL presences of people who are into the same topics, and connect with them. See where you can plug in, and see where the contours of organizing in your local contexts are. Ideally you can see places where gaps can be filled.</p><p>Once you find an issue that you think has potential, and you have a couple of people to do some organizing with, you have what I think of as a catalyst group. This group is meant to start (or assist) in a certain kind of reaction, but not lead it. Trying to control movements is both futile and antithetical to liberation. So, to ground us, we have two very important ingredients: a topic/issue/area of focus to organize around, and a group of folks to work with. Once this is in place, you can co-create a strategy with your organizing team. I’d recommend employing an <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/718259909513428992/notes-towards-changing-the-world?source=share">encircling strategy</a> as your long-term or meta strategy, where multiple sub-strategies and campaigns happen within this frame. Essentially, this allows you to employ campaigns across a matrix of tactics. Within the encircling frame, you can create a campaign (what I consider a “short-term” strategy). Campaigns are a series of actions over time. Strategies are a series of campaigns over time.</p><p>A useful way to think of strategic planning is by separating the process into stages, grouped by movement size.</p><p>Small: Organize small actions/protests, figuring out ways to build movement visibility and interest</p><p>Medium: Focus on scaling up the participation, through mobilizing efforts. Promote your actions, get people involved, and encourage meaningful action.</p><p>Large: Create a movement. The kind of thing people hear about.</p><p>To organize on the smallest level, the easiest thing might be to just do plan actions that are well within your team’s capacity, organize those actions, and execute. If you can swing it, I’d really recommend to not lean too much into symbolic actions. There are risks with every action, no matter what legal frameworks your locality has. If you’re going to do something, you have to be very intentional with:</p><ul><li>what you hope to accomplish through the action</li><li>a high likelihood of success for the action</li><li>doomsday planning in case something goes wrong</li></ul><p>If you’re able to do this, then you will be leagues ahead of a lot of other folks. This is not to make it a race or a competition, but it is moreso to say you can symbolically represent and catalyze action without becoming a martyr.</p><p>As you’re doing actions, you should be refining your idea of who’s impacted by the issues more and more. As that picture gets clearer, you should spend more and more time understanding and listening to those folks. Ideally, you get to a point of co-creation, where you are enabling people to fight for themselves and build their autonomy. That is the kind of thing that prevents movements from dying. Organizers should be trying to put themselves out of business, in a sense. Catalysts should be able to come from anywhere.</p><p>To scale up, I’d recommend a focus on meeting folks. Take the ideas of <a href="https://href.li/?https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_canvassing">deep canvassing</a>, where you empathetically have conversations with whoever is impacted by the issue you’re responding to, through the lens of giving power to those people. Rather than asking them to feed into some established system of power, encourage them to take action into their own hands, as a collective.</p><p>I’d also recommend that as capacity grows, to build a “positive” or “constructive” power. This can look like a lot of things. Whether it is a block club, neighborhood pod, community council, or community assembly, dedicate energy into creating spaces where people can start building their democratic and consensus muscles. These can simultaneously act as the training ground and alternative governance structure that allows folks to start making decisions for themselves in a very specific way.</p><p>This will ideally allow the movement to really start to be intersectional. It should be intersection minded from the outset, but that can be difficult to meaningfully actualize in the early stages of the movement. Since single-issue movements are inherently brittle (if your movement revolves around getting something on a ballot, winning or losing just ends the movement)-there are throughlines that connect all movements, and those lines should be made visible and traveled. Environmentalists should fight for housing rights, LandBack, Reparations, and a host of other things. The more developed our networks, the stronger our movements will be.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/726356840445870080/i-recently-saw-that-mao-had-a-speech-with-the-same?source=share"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4f3c594bca2c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[dreaming and IRL worldbuilding]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dipperdesperado/dreaming-and-irl-worldbuilding-6e9e4b6cd2d1?source=rss-7a0ac2352968------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e9e4b6cd2d1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[solidarity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-intrigue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dreaming]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[DipperDesperado]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Aug 2023 00:00:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-31T20:56:30.961Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-BfElbC9hxL-TDHi" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@jrkorpa?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Jr Korpa</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I’ve been doing some talking about <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/723504701318086656/radicalism-100-get-started-from-0-or-how-the">getting into radicalism</a> and <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/dipperdesperado/725759350821519360/get-organized">how to organize</a>. You can do that first-you have a feeling that things need to change and you just act. At some point though, I think it’s important to start thinking from a longer-term perspective. That’s where visioning comes in.</p><p>To know how to change the world, we should know what we want it to look like. Solarpunk is a great example of this-giving us aspirational visuals and vistas for how the world could look if we got our shit together. This is what a vision is in a nutshell.</p><p>Once we have have an understanding of what we want the world to look like, we have to figure out how to get there. This is where things start to become interesting. To me, values are like guiding principles that we ground our actions in. To come up with values, think about the ethics and principles that are embedded in your vision. If we think about solarpunk, some values that I see are ecological harmony, intersectional feminism, and economic democracy.</p><p>When we have our vision and values in place, we can think about the specific things that we want to accomplish. Our goals should be relatively concrete things that we can build strategies around. What are the material changes that you want to happen? What are the specific, tangible things that you can work towards? If it’s too broad (ex: “I want to abolish the commodity form”), then that might be one of the descriptors of your vision.</p><p>So, you create a <strong>vision</strong> → which informs your <strong>values →</strong> and dictates your <strong>goals</strong>.</p><p>To develop a vision, put on your dreaming goggles. Imagine what the world can look like. Try to engage your senses. What do you see? What do you hear? What does it smell like?</p><p>To develop your values, look at that vision, analyze the implied material and social contexts and use those as guiding lights.</p><p>To develop your goals, think about the specific things you can work towards, acting within your values, to create fertile ground for your vision to flourish.</p><p>To wrap up, I want to walk through a vision of a better world. If you want some homework, you can derive some values and goals from that.</p><p>-</p><p>As I leave my house for the day, I step out onto a quiet city street. The air is crisp and filled with the scent of freshly bloomed flowers and the subtle aroma of earthy, homegrown herbs. The street is lined with majestic, towering trees, their leaves dancing in the gentle breeze, casting shattered shadows on mosaic sidewalks below.</p><p>As I walk along the street, I hear the melodies of birds chirping, flitting from mossy building to wild rooftop. The sound of laughter and lively conversations fills the air, as people gather in community spaces and reclaimed streets.</p><p>The buildings themselves are architectural wonders, adorned with solar panels and living walls that burst with vibrant vegetation. They harmoniously blend into the surrounding natural landscape, their design inspired by historical ecological buildings. These buildings are not just structures; they are living organisms, integrated with the ecosystem, providing shade, shelter, and sustenance for both humans and wildlife.</p><p>Streets are bustling with activity, but they are not dominated by cars. Instead, it is a pedestrian-friendly space where people of all ages and abilities move freely and safely. Electric trams silently glide by, their sleek design reflecting the beauty of their surroundings.</p><p>Local artisans and worker-owners have set up vibrant market stalls, showcasing their handmade creations and locally sourced goods. Vibrant textiles, handcrafted jewelry, and organic produce catch the eye. Neighbors stop to chat, share stories, and exchange ideas.</p><p>In the distance, I see a community forest garden, a lush oasis of greenery where residents gather to cultivate their own food. The garden is a testament to space reclaimed by the people, fostering a sense of ownership and connection to the land.</p><p>As I continue my walk, I feel a sense of hope and possibility. This city is a testament to the power of collective action and the transformative potential of dreaming and envisioning a better world.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://dipperdesperado.tumblr.com/post/726302922338697216/dreaming-and-irl-worldbuilding"><em>https://www.tumblr.com</em></a><em> on August 21, 2023.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e9e4b6cd2d1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>