<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mary Braun, MD on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mary Braun, MD on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@doctormary?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 08:31:08 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@doctormary/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Depressing Beliefs and Stoic Therapies]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/depressing-beliefs-and-stoic-therapies-f9929ac03613?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f9929ac03613</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[depression]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stoicism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pyrrhonism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[beliefs-as-blinders]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Sep 2023 13:40:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-10T13:40:08.514Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/504/1*h50fB8iMA3kpnT-joKaWDg.png" /></figure><p>As far back as medical records go, physicians have been part therapist, part philosopher, part translational scientist. Today in semi-rural New Hampshire, in exam room number three, that tradition continues. But can the doctor heal herself?</p><p>John, my ten o’clock patient, loves his paycheck, but hates his boss. More specifically, John feels that his boss treats him disrespectfully. In order to keep working at his job he must face the question “Am I willing to let people treat me disrespectfully for money?” He does not want to believe that he is this sort of person. He can’t decide to stay because that’s demeaning and he is unwilling to leave because he fears he’d be poor. He’s stuck in a kind of limbo of perpetual deciding. Spending all this energy spinning meaninglessly causes him to be depressed.</p><p>I want to say to him, “John, I hear you! I am stuck myself. My work is fine, but let me tell you about what is going on with my boyfriend!” I would tell him, if my professionalism didn’t stop me, that he’s not right for me and I know it. I know that I am not the sort of woman who would be afraid to be without a boyfriend, but I can see that I am. I feel bad to be unwilling to be alone; I deny to myself that I feel that way; I manufacture reasons I’m staying because I can’t admit the real one: I’m afraid to be alone. I have no ability to think any other thoughts or feel any other feelings because my brain is trapped in perpetual deciding, spinning, spinning, spinning.</p><p>In both of these cases the depressed person has two beliefs about themself that are in conflict. “I do not let people disrespect me,” “I will not be happy unless I make the amount of money I make at this job,” “I am independent,” “I cannot be alone.”</p><p>They all hinge on self-judgments: Am I the kind of person who…? I do not want to be that kind of person, and yet I seem to be acting in that fashion. The cognitive dissonance set up by knowing one doesn’t want to be someone who XYZs and the fact that one is such a person makes one depressed. It saps the energy for paying attention to anything else.</p><p>People have a difficult time doing anything about the situation that has made them unhappy because they cannot unbelieve either belief. Often these beliefs are so deep that at first one does not even know one has them or one may not recognize them as beliefs. Any progress one can make in identifying, fleshing out, and unbelieving these beliefs can be helpful in getting one unstuck.</p><p>I am John’s doctor, not his friend or therapist, but my pills are not really helping very much. I feel we are at the end of what medicine has to offer. Perhaps pointing in the direction where I think the real problem lies would help. Might we explore what exactly you mean by disrespectful?</p><p>Me: What exactly do you mean by “disrespectfully”?</p><p>John: Making me clean up other people’s messes.</p><p>Me: So it is bad to clean up other people’s messes for money? Is it bad, say, to pump portapotties?</p><p>John: No, because someone has to do that and if no one did it, we’d all be awash in our poop.</p><p>Me: Well, if no one did the stuff they ask you to do at work, XYZ would happen.</p><p>John: Yes, but that’s different.</p><p>Me: Exactly how?</p><p>John: That’s their job; they have a contract to do that.</p><p>Me: Well, it’s your job, too.</p><p>John: But I didn’t sign a contract saying I’d do it.</p><p>Me: Did you sign a contract saying what you would do at work?</p><p>John: Well, no, but there are just certain things I shouldn’t be asked to do at work.</p><p>Me: Are there certain things no one should be asked to do or are you special?</p><p>John: No one should be asked to clean up other people’s messes.</p><p>Me: But we’ve already determined that sometimes that’s ok, like cleaning portapotties so maybe that’s not the case.</p><p>Yes, you’re going around again, but your belief in “it is disrespectful that my boss has me cleaning up other people’s messes” is a little bit weaker because you’ve just found at least one time when cleaning up other people’s messes is OK. Try it again and again. What other arguments can you find? When else is it OK in your worldview to clean up other people’s messes? What would have to change for you to think it is OK in your case?</p><p>This is, of course, not a real conversation (because all details have been changed to make the patients unidentifiable), but it’s similar to ones I’ve had many times. There are other ways to attack “disrespect” once you have figured out what it means to you.</p><p>Once John understands the belief (It is bad that my boss is treating me disrespectfully), I might next invite him to question it. I do not do this next step with patients because it is not a doctor’s role, but if John were a friend next I might suggest to him to be as creative as possible with attacking disrespect. How might this not be disrespect? Maybe your boss recognizes that you’re the one who will do these things correctly the first time. Maybe one of the other workers has a bum knee or fear of heights you don’t happen to know about. Maybe having to do things you don’t want to do is how being paid to do a job actually works. Maybe there is a benefit to you of doing it that you haven’t considered. Maybe other people are cleaning up other things you don’t know about. Maybe you’re not being paid as much as other folks, but you’re still being paid enough and that’s good enough. All of these need to be thoroughly looked at and taken apart. This is the kind of work people do in CBT which I recommend frequently.</p><p>If John were a friend and not a patient, once he was a little wobbly on “my boss treats me disrespectfully,” I would recommend a dose of Marcus Aurelius. Sure, my boss treats me disrespectfully, but this is not a bad thing. What is it to you how your boss treats you? Does his treatment of you (which is out of your control) affect anything that actually matters about you? Does it damage you in any way? Maybe it’s simply a consequence of the way you act, for instance. Maybe it’s just the way she is. If you simply ignore what feel like snubs does anything bad happen? The purpose of a job is not to make friends. Maybe it doesn’t matter if you and your boss don’t really like each other.</p><p>Now, we’re ready for some Pyrrhonism. The easiest path in might be to apply, “Nothing is good or bad, but thinking makes it so.” What if the way your boss treated you was something like the weather, where you like sunny weather when you have a picnic planned, and rain when your grass is dying? Is it possible that you don’t like your boss treating you this way, but do like it when he treats others this way, for example? What if you reformulated your belief as “I don’t like the way my boss treats me.” Now, it is no longer a belief, but a simple statement of fact and notice that much of the sting for you is removed. This is the power of Pyrrhonism; it teaches you to pull the venom out of a belief and makes life much less painful.</p><p>After you’ve got that side squared away, looking at the other belief causing pain, “I will not enjoy my life unless I make X amount of money.” This needs to be evaluated. Figure out if you really need everything you’re spending money on. Of course, you need food, clothes, and a place to live that is safe. What kind of food? Which clothes? How big does that place to live need to be? Do you need a new car? Every time you get into your beat up car, it can remind you that you are saving money so that you can maybe cut back your hours at work. Every time your friends make fun of your car, you can think about how they complain about their jobs and decide if you want to be trapped in a job you hate in order to impress your friends who are trapped in a job they hate in order to impress you with their nice car. Do you need the boat? Remember that the boat keeps you anchored at a job you may not like.</p><p>I notice that the money issue often comes down to “There are certain things I need in order to make things nicer for my kids than they were for me.” This can be attacked from many angles: How much nicer? How will you know things are nicer for your kids than for you? Might things already be nicer enough? What things are a benefit for your child? Might there be a point at which making things “nicer” no longer benefits your child? How will you know if you’ve passed that point? Is the downside of having things be nicer really worth the nicer? But the most fruitful angle to attack it from is often Why do things need to be nicer for my children than they were for me?</p><p>Me: Because some things about life were hard for me and I don’t want those things to be hard for my kids.</p><p>Also Me: Is there any chance that life is just hard? Is there any chance that if you remove one struggle, they will find another struggle? Is there any chance that there’s a benefit to the struggle?</p><p>Me: But other kids made fun of my cheap jeans and I hated that. I couldn’t be friends with some kids because I didn’t have nice stuff.</p><p>Also Me: And have those kids turned out to be adults you really want to spend time with now?</p><p>Me: Well, actually, no.</p><p>Also Me: And what about the other kids like you who wore unfashionable clothes? Have they turned out to be adults you want to spend time with?</p><p>Me: Actually, yes, I do still hang out with them.</p><p>Also Me: Maybe if your children are forced to find their friends among the less cool kids they will end up with friends who are worth spending time with when they’re sixty. Maybe it is not worth the extra hours at work to buy them things so they can attract friends who may grow up into adults neither you nor they like.</p><p>Me: But I want to pay for a college education for them. I don’t want them saddled with a huge educational debt.</p><p>Also me: I understand this impulse. In order to fully evaluate it with you, we’d have to consider whether or not a college education is really a good thing for all children and that is way off topic.</p><p>Me: Is there any chance that what is really going on here is that you’re trying to avoid conflict and do not wish to touch areas of social controversy?</p><p>Also Me: Well, yes, you’re right.</p><p>Me: Is conflict always bad? Maybe conflict can be a good thing? Maybe it will cause you to get more readers and more people will be exposed to your ideas and thus their lives will be less painful. Isn’t that your goal?</p><p>Also Me: Yes, it is, but I fear if we get side-tracked onto that discussion, we will “lose the plot” of this article which is about how philosophy can help people become less depressed.</p><p>Me: And does your idea that conflict is bad sometimes cause you to be depressed?</p><p>Also Me: OK, fine. Yes, it does. How about if I come back to that after we finish this article?</p><p>I think you will find that “I want things to be nicer for my kids” often boils down to “I don’t want my kids to have the same bad things about their life that I did and by throwing money at the problem, I imagine I can improve it. Often consideration of these facts is useful. There are limited hours in a day and we all have finite energy. Is spending time at work better for your children than spending that same time with them?</p><p>Dislodging the belief that has kept a person stuck can provide them with enormous relief. I have seen multiple people in various shades of the hate-my-job problem who “just woke up one morning and realized that all this material stuff–my boat and big house and TV equipment–doesn’t really make me happy. It’s just not worth the job. I found a new job and I’m so much happier with less stress.” Their blood pressure, weight, and diabetes control will improve over the next few visits.</p><p>Or sometimes people just wake up and realize that if their boss wants to pay them their skilled rate to do unskilled work, that’s ok with them.</p><p>Or sometimes people just wake up and realize that what has kept them from looking for another job is lack of confidence and they are going to take a deep breath and just do it.</p><p>This “waking up and realizing that” can be helped along by finding the belief that has you stuck and challenging it. The “realizing that” experience is when the old belief has come dislodged. These techniques can help you “realize that.”</p><p>Yes, well, John, I can help you get unstuck. But is the doctor brave enough to “unstuck” herself?</p><p>Mary Braun, MD is a primary care and hospice physician working in southern New Hampshire. You can subscribe to her you-tube channel, <a href="https://emea01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2F%40adultdoctor&amp;data=05%7C01%7C%7Ca1f95091113c4adc275d08dbafa41039%7C84df9e7fe9f640afb435aaaaaaaaaaaa%7C1%7C0%7C638296891411677008%7CUnknown%7CTWFpbGZsb3d8eyJWIjoiMC4wLjAwMDAiLCJQIjoiV2luMzIiLCJBTiI6Ik1haWwiLCJXVCI6Mn0%3D%7C3000%7C%7C%7C&amp;sdata=egIzmvBi%2B1k6wn%2FJKizIa97OaGJ6KNEFxdso54%2FGSZs%3D&amp;reserved=0">https://www.youtube.com/@adultdoctor</a> to hear her thoughts on medicine, philosophy, and the natural world. Her most recent article in Stoicism Today was <a href="https://modernstoicism.com/i-wouldnt-hit-you-if-you-didnt-make-me-so-angry-by-mary-braun/">“I wouldn’t hit you if you didn’t make me so angry.”</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f9929ac03613" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Depression Hacks from a Doctor]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/depression-hacks-from-a-doctor-c1dea426dd22?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c1dea426dd22</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-care]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anxiety]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[depression]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Oct 2021 14:31:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-07T15:27:56.842Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Those who think they might be depressed will benefit from these tricks.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*PTmSxdOdOkuka2Po" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@vijendrashivaansh7?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Vijendra Singh</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The absolutely-sure-they’re-not-depressed-but-tired-of-their-family-pestering-them-about-it, will also benefit. As will the somewhat depressed. Not everyone can DIY away from depression, but maybe you can. It is worth a try.</p><p>If you are seriously depressed or feeling suicidal, skip these DIY hacks and get personal, individualized help in the real world. Call 1–800–273–8255, 911, or a trusted person. This article is not personal medical advice. It does not take the place of a good relationship with a doctor you trust. People who are severely depressed need more aggressive approaches than these hacks. How can you tell if you are seriously depressed? You can’t from an article. That requires personalized medical care which this article is not. If you think there is any chance that you have severe depression, stop reading this article, and get real world, in person help.</p><p>Many of these techniques are simply good self-care. The relationship between depression and neglecting one’s self-care is strong. In general, the worse your self care gets, the worse your depression becomes. The worse your depression becomes, the less care you take of yourself. The trick here is about reversing this cycle, and the hacks are about improving your self care and improving your depression along with it.</p><p>You have to do these hacks regularly. Doing anything regularly when you are depressed is difficult.</p><p>Here are our first hacks. Enlist your friends and relatives to help — perhaps even the same folks that have asked you if you’re depressed. You could tell these folks, “I don’t think I’m depressed. I think I just need help doing XYZ regularly. Would you like to help me by being my XYZ buddy?” Call up a friend and boast every time you do XYZ. Post it on instagram. That’s the peer pressure approach.</p><p>Next, there’s the bribery approach. Pay upfront for XYZ so that you have to do it or feel you’re wasting the money. Or promise yourself a reward if you do XYZ daily for a week (be sure to deliver on your reward). Or make yourself a lottery with tickets that you can pull whenever you do XYZ. Write a really good prize on one of those tickets. Buy yourself a bouquet of flowers or a new plant or a DVD or concert ticket every fifth or seventh or thirteenth time you do your new habit.</p><h3><strong>Out of your head and into your body</strong></h3><p>Activities that get you out of your head and into your body are often effective to combat depression.</p><p>Exercise — regular exercise helps your mood. It doesn’t have to be that much, but the key seems to be regular. Here is a dopey trick I have used to help people get exercising. [https://doctormary.medium.com/develop-an-exercise-habit-with-this-one-dopey-trick-from-a-doctor-3ee1a0f43f12] If you have a friend you trust, ask them to help you get to the gym or go for a walk every other day for two weeks. This trick can be even more effective if you secretly think your friend needs the exercise more than you do. You’re asking them to help you, but secretly, you’re helping them. (Also known as the old who rescued-whom? trick.) Muscle-building exercises raise testosterone. This can become a self-reinforcing activity because testosterone in small amounts improves mood.</p><p>Yoga — If you hate to sweat, give yoga a try. Yoga helps you get into your body and helps you gain mastery of your mind. Many yoga studios are starting to re-open post-Covid. There are also lots of yoga videos online. Yoga class attendance tends to be highly skewed towards women. This may be an added incentive for some people, as it is possible to make friends through yoga classes which may help with your depression above and beyond the benefits of yoga.</p><p>Walking — Putting one foot in front of the other for thirty to sixty minutes is a time-tested way of getting exercise and improving one’s mood. Walking is not as good as more strenuous exercise for getting you into your body, but it doesn’t require a membership or internet connection and it’s accessible to almost everyone. If you get a walking buddy, you can combine exercise and social activity and get a two-fer.</p><p>Being in nature — If you can do your walking in nature, even better. Contemplating nature helps one get out of one’s head and if one is exercising even a little, this can help you redirect the focus of attention to your body. If you can learn a little bit about the nature you’re walking among, that can be helpful. How big is a tree as old as you are? What are the names of those flowers? How far do the animals you see travel in a typical day? Or over their lifetime? These days few people know such basic facts about the natural world around them. With modest effort you can be an expert about the things you are seeing on your walk. Impressing the people you happen to run into with your knowledge of nature is also good for one’s mood. I find that time in nature pays me back in triplicate, with better mood, increased productivity, and a more appropriate sense of my place in the world. Many people have an idea of “hiking therapy” which is going for a multi-hour hike on a trail in the wilderness. I find this works best on trails where the traffic is low and I run into other people infrequently, but any place where one can safely do a multi-hour walk will work just fine.</p><p>Meditation — Meditation can help you pay less attention to the depressing noise inside your head. If you are like me and have a tough time doing meditation regularly, consider paying for an app. I feel if I’ve subscribed to an app for a year, I better get my money’s worth out of it and will be more faithful to it. There are a number of apps. Keep signing up for free trials until you find an app that works well for you.</p><h3><strong>Caring for your body</strong></h3><p>Get enough sleep — Getting enough sleep can be a problem during the summer. Not only are the nights short, without good air conditioning the heat can produce sleeplessness. Having a set bedtime and sticking with it improves mood. Avoid electronics and screens for an hour (or as long as you can stand) before bed. In fact, avoid anything that might get you agitated. While the saying “never go to bed angry” may be standard advice, my experience is the saying “the morning is wiser than the evening” is a more successful approach for dealing with family conflict. Set the conflict aside (meditation can help in learning to do this). Go to bed. Deal with it tomorrow.</p><p>Similarly, getting up at a consistent time also improves mood.</p><p>You may need room-darkening shades (Make this your first prize for improved sleep hygiene). For some people an alarm clock that wakes you with light and birdsong rather than a buzzing sound helps start the day in a better mood. (A potential prize for getting to bed on time for seven days in a row) Make your bed nice with comfy sheets. (Further prizes.)</p><p>If you are having difficulty falling asleep, you can learn to meditate (more on this, below) and then meditate while you’re struggling to fall asleep. If you continue to fail to fall asleep, the meditation will help substitute for the sleep.</p><p>Avoid caffeine — What happens with caffeine is a vicious cycle where you feel down and you take caffeine. This energizes you, but then it wears off and you feel down again. So, you take even more caffeine, and so on. As time goes on your body gets used to the caffeine so it takes more to get the same effect you used to get with a smaller amount. Before long you need caffeine to feel as down as you used to feel without caffeine, but now you’ve got palpitations and a little nausea. You also now have the unnecessary sugar and artificial colors and flavors that often come with caffeinated drinks. None of these things are good for one’s mood. Don’t come off caffeine all at once, though. You will get withdrawal symptoms that will make your depression even worse. Just aim to reduce the amount of caffeine you consume each week by about a quarter.</p><p>Avoid fast food — Watch the entertaining and frightening documentary <em>Supersize Me </em>to see the effect of fast food on your body and mood.</p><h3><strong>Putting Substances in Your Body</strong></h3><p>If you are pregnant, think you might be pregnant, contemplating pregnancy, might become pregnant, or are breastfeeding, do not ingest any herbal or supplement without talking to your doctor. Do not ingest any herbal or supplement without talking to your doctor if you are taking any medications.</p><p>Herbal treatment — The evidence for St John’s Wort in depression is pretty good. However, the problem with herbals is that you are relying on the good will of the manufacturer and everyone in their supply chain to make sure the product is what it says it is, has been handled in the correct fashion, contains the correct plant parts, treated correctly, and not sprayed with a carcinogen, does not contain extra ingredients you don’t want (such as prescription drugs), and is not so old that it is inactive. Also St John’s wort interacts with some medications and has not been proven safe for a developing fetus.</p><p>Supplements — I have found no evidence that I find convincing for any supplements. I usually tell my patients that if the supplements worked, the manufacturer would patent them and get FDA approval, as that would make them far more money. Yet, some people swear by them. That’s fine.</p><p>Placebo — The evidence for placebo is convincing. For some conditions, placebo is effective even when people know they’re taking a placebo.</p><p>Multivitamin — The standard advice is that for people with a varied diet, a multivitamin is not needed. However, I have frequently found vitamin deficiencies in my patients when I have gone looking. Fixing a deficiency will often make someone feel better. You might consider a daily multi-vitamin. I like gummy vitamins because then I feel like I’m getting away with something. Vitamin D and B12 are particularly thought to affect one’s mental state, and there’s little risk of getting too much of these vitamins (vitamin D can be associated with kidney stones). You might consider just adding supplements of these instead of a multivitamin.</p><h3><strong>Other Bodies</strong></h3><p>Social activity — Social activity is protective against depression. If you have a friend you think might be depressed, you can be social with them. The social activity will be good for both of you and you can tell yourself that you’re doing it for their sake. Social activity can come in many varieties. You can do something new and stimulating with a friend such as learning to kayak or visiting a museum or contra-dancing. Also, don’t forget going to the gym or cooking healthy food as a social activity.</p><h3><strong>In conclusion</strong></h3><p>A problem with things like regularizing one’s schedule or exercising is that it takes a lot of energy. Energy is what is in short supply when you’re depressed. I hear things like “my diet’s not that bad so I’m sure there’s no benefit there and I’ve always been a bad sleeper so going to bed at the same time and waking at the same time won’t possibly work for me and if I don’t drink caffeine, I can’t wake up in the morning so those are all suggestions that won’t work for me.” Fact is, they do work, there is, and you can. It’s not easy, but maybe you can find one little hack that will help and then maybe you can find a way to build on that hack to add in another hack and eventually they will become mutually reinforcing.</p><p>The tough thing about these hacks is not only do they take a lot of energy, but you have to do them fairly regularly for a medium length of time before they work. The upside of this is that missing one or two opportunities to do them is easy to recover from. Don’t beat yourself up about it. In fact, you might consider for every five or seven times you do your hack, writing yourself a pass so that you can accidentally miss one opportunity without having to feel guilty.</p><p>You undoubtedly have a lot of reasons why you cannot do any of these suggestions and in that case, you might want to consider seeing a doctor. Or you might want to consider which of these techniques is least odious and give it a good try, daily or more often for a good piece of time, four to six weeks, and see what happens.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c1dea426dd22" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Develop an exercise habit with this one dopey trick from a doctor.]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/develop-an-exercise-habit-with-this-one-dopey-trick-from-a-doctor-3ee1a0f43f12?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ee1a0f43f12</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[weight-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fitness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motivation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Jul 2021 16:44:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-07T15:38:04.443Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>To put it simply: Start very small. Even smaller.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*14gTC7GxhbcaSscaqkc3Ag.jpeg" /><figcaption>Her shoes waiting by her door, taken by the author.</figcaption></figure><p>Here’s your new exercise plan: put your walking shoes on and touch your front door frame every single evening.</p><p>You have been trying to do an ambitious exercise plan and failing. We’ll get there by starting here.</p><p>This is something you can do. For the first week, or maybe the first two weeks, if you get your walking shoes on and get to the door, you get to celebrate yourself. That is your goal. That’s it. You achieved it! Now that you’ve gotten your shoes on, you may decide to go further or you may not. Either way, <em>either way, </em>it’s a win. You made your goal!</p><p>You have to be honest with yourself in order for this to work. If you made your goal, you have to be pleased and give yourself positive feedback. Yay, me! I got my shoes on and touched the front doorframe. Doing more, doing your eventual goal is not required for success. You might choose to do more, and that’s wonderful, but more is not required to feel good about yourself. You got your shoes on. You did it. Go, you! Post it on your instagram. You did it! You are on your way to your fitness goal!</p><p>Every day, faithfully do your exercise routine. It is a small step; you should be able to do it every day, but if not, don’t beat yourself up, just get back on it the next day.</p><p>That is your exercise program for the first week. Maybe for the second week. You’re already doing more than you used to. Soon, you may feel ready to push yourself a little harder, but don’t do it until you are ready.</p><p>The real trick is to recognize your success. If you have a shred of “I got my gym clothes on and took the elevator to the fitness center; big deal. I really need to…” in your mind, you will lessen the impact of the technique. Let me say it differently: remind yourself firmly, if you get to your exercise goal every day, even if you think it’s a small goal, you have done great. If you have driven to the gym parking lot most days of the week, you have done really well. If you think “This is bullshit, I won’t really succeed until I…” this technique will not work. If you met your goal, you have succeeded. You have set yourself up to succeed tomorrow. You have to celebrate this victory. You have to be honest with yourself. You are developing a new habit and it’s hard and you’re taking it one step at a time.</p><p>Once you have the first step of your new exercise routine cemented, you can add the second step onto it. Maybe now you are putting your shoes on and walking around the block. Go, you! Look how much progress you’ve made! You can slowly (or not so slowly; these things can build their own momentum) add steps onto your routine.</p><p>Set your new goal carefully: walk to the corner, take the elevator to street level. Again, if you manage more than that on any particular day, you’re an overachiever! You are doing so much more than you were doing before. You have been doing an exercise program on a regular basis for two weeks now! You may not see it on the scales, but you have lost a pound of inertia. Go, you!</p><p>It is a dopey trick, but it works. Give it a try. Surely, even you have time every night to put on your running shoes and touch the doorframe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ee1a0f43f12" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I wouldn’t hit you if you didn’t make me so angry]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/i-wouldnt-hit-you-if-you-didn-t-make-me-so-angry-61d3abe22611?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/61d3abe22611</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anger]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stoicism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 01 May 2021 20:25:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-26T11:36:27.968Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>I Wouldn’t Hit You If You Didn’t Make Me So Angry</h3><h4>Soon, I would be making the discovery Marcus Aurelius did. Other people cannot control how you feel.</h4><p>About four years after my adoption, my mother and I were having a mini-vacation at her friend’s house and without provocation, she began telling me how horrible a person I was.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8NcEWEb1BphDaAUfd8QWdA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me at summer camp</figcaption></figure><p>I had treated our host badly. We do not treat people this badly. We do not treat people like this. I had made our host feel very badly. It is never ok to make someone feel as bad as I had made our host feel. We were guests here and I was making our host sorry to have invited us. I was a shame and embarrassment to her. Only bad people made other people feel bad.</p><p>And it went on and on. And on. I was unaware of having done anything rude. I thought I had done everything I had been trained to do. My intentions had always been to be respectful. I never learned what I had done to upset our host, but whatever it was, I felt bad about it.</p><p>Using the tools available to me as a twelve year old, I did my best to make sense of what she had said. Stripping the argument of its rhetorical niceties left:</p><ol><li>My mother is a reliable source of information.</li><li>Good people do not make other people feel bad.</li><li>I made our host feel bad.</li></ol><p>Therefore, I am not good.</p><p>No problems with this train of logic. I was well acquainted with it and my family regularly told me that I was not a good person.The conclusion was familiar and it flowed easily from the propositions above it which are all known to be true. No news here.</p><p>A second set of propositions could be brought up:</p><ol><li>My mother is a reliable source of information.</li><li>Good people do not make other people feel bad.</li><li>My mother is making me feel bad.</li></ol><p>Therefore, she is not good.</p><p>The conclusion could not be right. Something must have gone wrong. Steps 1 and 2 were givens. There must be something wrong with step 3: my mother was making me feel bad.</p><p>Perhaps I didn’t feel bad even though I was pretty sure that’s what I felt. This was a possibility, but seemed silly. Alternatively, maybe I was feeling bad, but maybe I was feeling <em>just a little bit</em> bad. Maybe our host was feeling <em>really </em>bad. I was making other people feel even worse than my mother was making me feel! That would be horrible because I feel pretty bad! And if I’m making other people feel even worse than this, that is very terrible! I’m so sorry! This logic makes other people’s feelings more important and more reliable, than my feelings. It is easy to see how growing up with this belief could get someone into trouble.</p><p>Another belief that got me into trouble is the idea that people can make other people feel a particular way, that one person can control another’s feelings. I am responsible for how other people feel. It raises the possibility that other people are responsible for how I feel. Believing that I am responsible for how other people feel means that they can get me to act in ways that they want by telling me I am making them feel bad. It makes me easily manipulable. Believing that other people are responsible for how I feel absolves me of responsibility for the contents of my own heart and steals my power to control my own life.</p><p>Alternatively, perhaps there was an exception for my mother to the rule “good people don’t make other people feel bad,” because she was the adult and I was the child. It was OK for the adult to do whatever they felt needed to be done in order to correct the child. I already knew that I was going to have a hard time in life because I had so many undesirable traits so I should really be grateful for all the correction I could get. At least I wouldn’t drive people away by making them feel bad. I had to guess what I had done that was upsetting our host so much, but that was the least of my problems. From interactions like this, I would be left thinking that if someone said they were trying to help me, they could be as mean as they wanted. It is easy to see how this belief would prove unhelpful.</p><p>Perhaps there was another reason that the rule “good people do not make other people feel bad” did not apply to me. Perhaps I was such a bad person, that I, myself, was the exception. I could be made to feel bad without contradicting the rule because I was so bad it didn’t matter. This was a real possibility. Clearly, I was very bad. My mother had just spent fifteen minutes telling me so. Surely someone as loathsome as I could be made to feel bad with impunity. It is not difficult to see how this would cause adult me problems.</p><p>In the usual pattern, after the lecture went on for a while, my mother would say, “You make me so angry” and begin hitting me. Because we were at her friend’s house, she did not hit me, but confined herself to a semi-whispered tirade. With my adult brain, “you made me so angry that I hit you” is laughable, but when your full size parent says it, it is tough to argue with. Little Mary, of course your mother was able to control herself. She did not hit you when she deemed it inappropriate. She never hit you at her friend’s house, or while she was driving, or in church. She only “lost control” when there were no witnesses. Have you ever, Mary, become so overcome by emotions that you have hit someone else? You, loathsome as you are, can control yourself and your mother cannot? The problems with this statement became obvious to me when I was just a little older.</p><p>My mother’s tirade hinged on being convinced that another person can make you feel a certain way. This is a very complicated thing. It was obvious to me that other people could affect my emotions. My mother was making me feel bad (more accurately, sad, ashamed, remorseful, embarrassed, and unworthy) so it made sense to me that I had made her feel “bad,” too. However, as I aged into adolescence, my self awareness was growing. Soon, I would be making the discovery Marcus Aurelius did. Other people cannot control how you feel. Marcus says it in book 7:</p><blockquote>Let there fall externally what will on the parts which can feel the effects of this fall. For those parts which have felt will complain, if they choose. But I, unless I think that what has happened is an evil, am not injured. And it is in my power not to think so.</blockquote><p>I knew from my own experience, when someone in the room feels angry and yells at me, I felt afraid. When someone told me I was lazy, dishonest and unlovable, I felt bad. When I became a little older, I realized that it lasted for a brief moment and then often I was able to have a more reasoned response to the lecture. My response was consistent with what Viktor Frankl describes:</p><blockquote>Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom.</blockquote><p>This was the beginning of developing my own Stoicism. I have previously written that the Stoic maxims can be like a foot shoved into a slamming door and can help me avoid giving assent to the initial feeling I have and spiralling into feeling “bad.” There is the stimulus (angry person in the room) and I cannot help the initial flash of feeling, but assenting to that feeling in the next moment is voluntary. If I can do something besides assent to it, I do not have to react to my emotion. I am in control of myself.</p><p>Figuring out that other people do not control my emotions was a huge freedom. That freedom didn’t make it hurt any less to be hit, but it did start to provide a way to look at “If you didn’t make me so angry, I wouldn’t hit you” differently. After this discovery, things in my family actually got worse as I experimented with saying, “It doesn’t really matter if I line the silverware up correctly” for the pleasure of watching my mother’s face contort in rage. I would think, “I did that. I can make her lose control of herself so easily. And she cannot make me lose control of myself even by grabbing my hair and using it as a handle to knock my head against the wall.”</p><p>The idea of controlling my response to my emotions provided me with a way to evaluate her statement that I made her angry and provided me with the start of a way to resolve the cognitive dissonance that I have described above. But it also provided me with more pain. Sadly, I could only control my mother in one direction. Try as I might (and I sure tried hard!) I could never find the switch that turned her into the generous, fun, loving mother that she could be every now and again.</p><p>And now thirty years after those lectures have ceased, I am still learning about the space between the impulse and the response. I know to notice what I am responding to when there is an angry person in the room. When things are going well, I will feel the anger, notice it, point it out to myself, remind myself that the person is angry, carefully check that I’m not responding to make their anger go away, remind myself that I am safe, and then attend to the situation at hand. This is easier to do professionally and more difficult to do with my family. Some days I’m successful and some days I’m not. I am still living out the legacy of believing other people control one’s emotions but I am better at logic than I used to be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=61d3abe22611" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Frailty as slow moving PTSD]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/frailty-as-slow-moving-ptsd-81ea5c125974?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81ea5c125974</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[narrative-medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[geriatrics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[illness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ptsd]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Apr 2021 13:28:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-20T12:01:41.457Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/631/1*RmKQGB-L752dLZhdF75CBw.jpeg" /><figcaption>My arm, pre-operatively. photo by me.</figcaption></figure><p>A week after surgery, I removed my splint to take a shower. Now, unprotected, my wrist was made of glass.</p><p>With my splint on, I was clumsy, but invincible. I did not feel frail until I removed my splint.</p><p>The shower floor did not feel very different from the ice on the lake. My thoughts were whirring along like this: I cannot squeeze the shampoo bottle with my injured hand. It is also painful to raise that palm up to squeeze the shampoo into it with the other hand. Don’t spill the shampoo because that would make the floor slippery. It will feel so good to get that shampoo on your hair. Don’t let it drip off your hair! Careful not to get shampoo in your eyes because having to close them will make you more likely to fall.</p><p>The shower floor did not feel very different from the ice on the lake. The memory of how it felt to have my feet slide out from under me and all of the other unpleasant feelings that followed were jostling for attention. I concentrated on keeping my feet firm; I could not attend to these memories, but they were there, intruding into my concentration, unrequested.</p><p>The shower floor did not feel very different from the ice on the lake. Some part of my brain was exquisitely aware that I was in the same state I had been in before I fell. It knew that my future quality of life was dependent on my attention to each step.</p><p>I navigated the shower successfully. I have not re-injured myself. I have had the time to contemplate the intense fear I felt in the shower, and I have people who will talk with me about it. I have written and re-written this piece. My life has been able to show the panicked parts of my brain that it is OK. The shower is not a threat. Daily life is not a threat. Things with the wrist are getting better. I do not need to be on high alert.</p><p>If instead of this ideal recovery, I had fallen again or I had had to use my arm for an essential task that kept re-injuring it or if I had had a less tolerant family or no ability to write, I would not have been able to process the experience. Each time the wrist hurt even just a little, I would have been afraid. Each time I felt fearful, I would be more likely to avoid the activity that had triggered the fear. Don’t go upstairs, don’t pour liquids where they might spill, don’t leave the house in winter, don’t wear clothes that require a stretch or bend of your arm to put them on, only take sponge baths. My life would contract and contract, and soon enough, I would be frail.</p><p>This may sound a little like PTSD, and I think a less intense version of the same system is at work here. I wonder if thinking about frailty as though it were slow-moving PTSD would help us prevent its advance. I challenge you to listen for PTSD when you listen to your not-yet-frail elders and see if you can help them stay robust.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81ea5c125974" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I am a natural Stoic.]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/i-am-a-natural-stoic-8c125b58ae0f?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c125b58ae0f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[orphans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stoicism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stoic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Jun 2020 00:03:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-20T12:02:29.392Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am a natural Stoic. I was able to find many of the ideas of Stoicism on my own, by struggling to make sense of my life as a young person.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/908/1*-bTvlgDi2YfPbzsFG03meg.png" /><figcaption>The author as a child, photo by mother</figcaption></figure><p>When I encountered Stoicism as an adult, I could see how closely aligned the ideas of the ancient Stoics — whose lives were unimaginably different from mine — were to those I had arrived at in my youth. I have talked with other adults who grew up in similarly difficult circumstances and have found that re-creating elements of Stoicism on one’s own happens frequently.</p><p>Here are some parts I came up with as a young person:</p><ul><li>virtue is the only good</li><li>kindness is the greatest virtue</li><li>no one errs on purpose</li><li>many things are not under my control</li><li>Much of what is wrong with the world is caused by other people trying to control things they cannot</li><li>things that are vitally important can disappear at any moment</li><li>many of the things that people claim bring happiness do not do so</li><li>we can reason our way to wisdom</li></ul><p>The particulars of what happened to me in my early life that lead me to synthesize the above principles all began when I was seven, when, I became an orphan. My mother knew she was dying, and made plans for what she thought would be best for me. Although my mother could have chosen one of her aunts or her father and stepmother, she chose someone she knew from work, a childless female executive, and her husband, also a successful executive. They were much better off than anybody in my family — my mother and I lived in subsidized housing — and they lived in a lovely house in the toniest of the Detroit suburbs.</p><p>My new parents did not want my old family around. So, they somehow arranged for all the people I had previously known to disappear from my life. No one explained this to me. I inferred they no longer cared about me. After a few weeks in my new household, it was clear that I was on my own in this new world and there was no escape.</p><p>My new parents were prone to frequent, strong anger. For the first ten years of their marriage they operated under a kind of truce whereby they didn’t interact much. This truce broke down with the arrival of a seven-year-old, grieving child in the house. Neither of them had had so much as a younger sibling or cousin. They knew nothing about children. It turns out that caring for children takes time and family coordination. Having their busy, stressful work routines disrupted by a seven-year old apparently destabilized their mental health.</p><p>On top of that, everything about me was wrong, largely because I had come from a lower income family with a correspondingly different set of manners, behaviors, vocabulary, and pronunciations than they wished me, as their child, to present to the world. They set about fixing everything about me. Nothing in my world was stable except the contents of my head. I had to figure out how to navigate this environment. I developed Stoicism.</p><p>I think I remember the moment it crystallized. My new mother and I had listened to a news program about a person who was in a Soviet prison for decades. She asked me, “Do you know what the only thing is that no one can take away from you?” I liked riddles and this was a good one. I had personally had the experience of my family, house, school, clothes, furniture, pets, and friends being taken away. People could even cut off your hand but I was pretty sure if they took out your brain you’d die. That seemed like the best answer.</p><p>“Close!” she said, “Your memories. If you were in prison for years, like the man we just heard about on the radio, you could comfort yourself by thinking about how nice your last Christmas was. I would think about my vacation to Spain with your father. Then I wouldn’t feel so bad. Your jailers couldn’t make you forget your happy memories, no matter what kinds of torture they did.”</p><p>“Really?” I thought. Someone is torturing you and your best defense is thinking about lying on a beach? Beaches are nice, but these pleasant thoughts felt so flimsy against the kind of onslaught I knew someone could bring to you. I imagined a pleasant memory: when my older cousin showed me how to use a sewing machine. It was a lovely memory, basking in the attention of my older, incredibly cool, college freshman cousin.</p><p>Then I imagined the rain of blows that was likely to happen later that evening, blows that happened most nights, for reasons I could never understand. This memory, nice as it was, actually made things worse. It was unattainable; I had not seen my cousin in a long time. I could not do anything to get to see her. What sustained me through those episodes was thinking that I would not allow them to change who I was. Outward things that didn’t matter, like how I said, “milk” and what clothes I wore could change, but I would make sure that these blows could not reach inside of me, to the real me. I would remain virtuous. I would know I was still virtuous because I could see how I treated other people. I would never become mean or violent like my new parents. I could not understand why they wanted me to be unhappy, but I would not allow them to succeed. And, what’s more, I would never act in a way to make anyone else feel the way they were evidently trying to make me feel.</p><p>I would not yell at other people or call them names or hit them regardless of how angry I was or what they had done. No one could make me be mean. They could torture me as badly as the Soviets tortured the guy we heard about on the radio, but I wouldn’t cave. I would not give in to them. I would not treat other people badly.</p><p>I worked on my philosophy of life as I got older. I did not nail down the four cardinal virtues, but arrived at my own. If one was virtuous, it led to deep happiness. I could not define this deep happiness, but I could tell when I was there. My highest value was compassion really understanding what the other person had going on inside and trying to nudge them in a direction that might lead them towards more virtue, and thus some of this deep happiness. I see these as proto- ataraxia, sympatheia, and wisdom.</p><p>I noticed that people who avoided extremes tended to be happier. For example, being under the control of food — either because one was always searching for delicacies or because one was trying to avoid eating — led equally to unhappiness. A teenage version of equanimity.</p><p>I valued justice, but justice was always confusing me because compassion felt more fundamental. I would think I had figured out what was just and then someone else would come along and explain why their claim was greater and I’d be confused again.</p><p>I did not identify courage as a virtue, but certainly lived it.</p><p>I valued honesty. I vowed never to lie, even if it would have gotten me out of punishment.</p><p>My new parents demonstrated daily that money and power did not lead to happiness, another Stoic theme.</p><p>Every day, every interaction, demonstrated to me more clearly that having my own inner retreat and keeping my inner sanctuary untouched by the outside world was valuable.</p><p>As an outsider in my new family, I could see patterns of behavior that other people simply accepted as the way things were. I could notice things about one or another family member and recognize that they were acting oddly. I would wonder why they were the way they were and then often times, because I am a good listener, these people would explain themselves to me, and even as a child, I could see that they were responding to internal forces and old, extinct situations, even though their actions were affecting living people around them in the present. When I first heard the Evelyn Waugh phrase, “To understand all is to forgive all,” I felt as though a light bulb had gone off in my head. There was a way to say what I had been feeling for years in just seven words. I feel this is a succinct way of saying Meditations II.1 “Begin each day by telling yourself that today I shall be meeting with the insolent…”</p><p>As a person whose mother had died, and whose family had disappeared without warning, I understood <em>memento mori</em>.</p><p>These circumstances, death of a parent and having my family re-assigned, also led me to recognize the very limited collection of things that were under my control, compared to what was outside of my control. When I first saw the serenity prayer, I thought it weird that recognizing that most things were out of one’s control was a challenge for other people. I watched other people throwing themselves over and over against the wall of desire for wealth or fame which seemed an obviously losing strategy. No one is such a massive wrecking ball that they can breach these things by sheer force of will. In the process, everyone gets horribly banged up. Having been schooled in “you don’t control much” very early in life turned out to be quite useful.</p><p>The situation could not have been better designed to make it clear to me that I was on my own. There was no escape, except to turn eighteen. All I could do was make the best of it until then: develop my own plans to satisfy all my needs while keeping my core virtues intact. Many people who as children have been trapped in unpleasant situations have told me that they too developed a system for themselves involving an inner citadel, a core of their own personal virtue, and often a sense of <em>memento mori</em>. I think developing the core features of Stoicism is a natural human response to being in a difficult situation. I think that there are legions of natural Stoics, very few of them as articulate as Seneca, most of us born in a time when we were not particularly encouraged to share our ideas on philosophies of life.</p><p>William Irvine, in “On Desire,” describes the way humans superimpose their own life plans on top of the life plan that evolution gives us.</p><blockquote>Consider, after all, the situation of actual slaves. They may not be able to escape from their master and his system of incentives, but they can form their own personal plan for living and superimpose it over his plan for them. They might, for example, refuse to let their bondage undermine their values. In particular, they might vow to do all they can to help their fellow slaves. This will entail periodically refusing to help their master achieve his goals, since doing so would undermine the goals they have set for themselves, in accordance with their plan for living. If for example, the master orders them to whip another slave, they will refuse. Of course, if they do this, they will likely be punished by the master’s overseer, but this will be a small price to pay in order to have a meaningful life — not meaningful in the cosmic sense, perhaps, but meaningful in the personal sense, and that is arguably what counts.</blockquote><p>I developed my own plan for living, the core of which was that I would not make other people feel the way my new parents seemed to want to make me feel. What I have attempted to describe is the way my self-developed philosophy of life was not dissimilar from Stoicism.</p><p>I recognized virtue as the only good. I had a crowd of virtues, not a few cardinal ones. I had the germ of cosmopolitanism. I recognized the dichotomy of control. I had my own inner citadel. I agreed with the supremacy of reason. When I was introduced to Stoicism at the age of fifty, I saw that many of the ancients had been there first, confirming what my life had taught me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c125b58ae0f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to help each other survive covid]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/how-to-help-each-other-survive-covid-744b8859a058?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/744b8859a058</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Mar 2020 01:47:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-20T12:03:11.695Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uA--SfZ6eEx8-IeRpQFk_g.jpeg" /><figcaption>photo by author</figcaption></figure><p>Dear Patient,<br>I am writing to you about coronavirus, now typically called “Covid” or “Covid 19.” Although at this time Covid appears to be contained in New Hampshire, in the weeks and months ahead, Covid appears destined to become widespread, massively disrupting the lives of everyone, sickening a large portion of the population, and threatening to kill more people at the same time than any of us have ever seen due to disease. In these precious few weeks or even days before Covid becomes widespread, as your doctor I need to let you know about the disease and how to protect yourself from it.</p><p>How Covid is likely to affect you depends a great deal on your age and how healthy you are. Young, healthy people tend to get symptoms no worse than the common cold and often even no symptoms at all. Some people, usually the elderly or otherwise ill, get so sick they must be hospitalized. The death rate of those who require hospitalization is scary. There is no cure. All we can do is to help support the sick while their immune systems fight off the infection. Sometimes this requires life-support equipment, such as ventilators,<br>for those who cannot breathe.</p><p>Worldwide so far, the death rate for people over 80 is about 15%. The death rate for people 70–79 is about 8%. The death rate for people 60–69 is 3.6%. Under age 50 the death rate falls below 1%. Healthy children appear to be at almost no risk of death.</p><p>Age is not the only risk factor. Pre-existing conditions, particularly heart disease, lung disease, diabetes, and immune-system failures also put one at risk. The more pre-existing conditions you have and the older you are, the more you are at risk.</p><p>You can protect yourself and get through this epidemic. The rest of this letter is about how to do that.</p><p>If you take prescription medications, I am temporarily loosening rules on refills to allow my patients to stock up on their prescriptions now, before Covid becomes widespread. Please review your prescription needs and call us for refill requests.</p><p>Once over 80% of the people in the population have had Covid and recovered from it, Covid is likely to die out and disappear. Even if Covid doesn’t disappear, later we will likely have better treatments and perhaps a vaccine. If you are at high risk, you should self-isolate during the epidemic to prevent catching Covid.</p><p>Even if you don’t mind taking your chances with Covid, I urge you to avoid getting Covid for the sake of other people. When Covid becomes widespread, a huge number of people are going to be sick at the same time. If you are at risk of getting very sick from Covid, we, your healthcare providers, desperately need you to try hard to stay well during the epidemic so that we can care for others. There’s a very real danger that we will not have enough doctors, nurses, hospital beds, and life-saving supplies and equipment during<br>the height of the epidemic. Therefore we need everyone who is at high risk and who can protect themselves to do so until the epidemic is over.</p><p>If you are at high risk and choose not to protect yourself, the most likely way you will catch Covid is from a loved one, as these are the people you have the closest and most frequent contact with. One of the most awful burdens I see with the families of patients I take care of is knowing they were responsible for the death of their loved one.</p><p>How you should protect yourself from Covid depends on what kind of protection you are able to achieve and your need for protection.</p><p>If you are older, with health conditions, and without substantial responsibilities, you should self-isolate to prevent getting Covid.</p><p>If you are young, healthy, and have work and family responsibilities, you should take only annoying and burdensome precautions. These precautions will slow down the rate at which people get Covid. The slower the epidemic progresses, the fewer people who will be sick at the same time. If we can prevent having a large number of people sick at the same time, we can avoid or shorten lockdowns and travel restrictions and we can reduce the danger that our healthcare system will become overwhelmed.</p><p>Starting right now, everybody should be following these seven simple steps to stopping Covid.<br>1. Try to stay at least 6 feet away from other people. The virus can only travel as far as a sneeze. Do not make exceptions for people who look healthy. Many people will get Covid and have no symptoms.<br>2. Avoid places with other people. Go shopping when it’s less busy. Skip every gathering you can. Especially avoid hospitals and nursing homes.<br>3. Do not shake hands. An elbow bump works just fine.<br>4. Avoid touching anything touched by others. Wear gloves. Wash your hands. Use hand sanitizer.<br>5. Upon arriving at home, wash your hands thoroughly.<br>6. Touch your face only with freshly washed hands.<br>7. If you get sick, regardless of what made you sick, stay home until 2 days after you feel well. You can be contagious even when you are feeling better.</p><p>If you are young and healthy, for now the only thing beyond these steps that you need to be concerned about is ensuring you have one or two weeks’ worth of food and household supplies on hand. You should also now be connecting with other people who can help you if you get sick and with those whom you can help if they get sick or need help maintaining self-isolation. While getting Covid is likely to be only an annoyance for you, or even less — you may get Covid and not even know it — for others it is going to be life-threatening. For healthcare workers it is going to be exhausting, if not also traumatic. You can help by doing everything you can to keep from infecting others. We are likely to experience a government-mandated lockdown, as has happened already in Italy and China.You need to comply, even if you and everyone you know seem to be fine.</p><p>If you are at risk due to existing health conditions and age, and if you are capable of self-isolating, I urge you to do so. Self-isolating means that you are going to end all face-to-face contact with anyone who is not also self-isolated with you. Except for extreme necessities, such as needing to repair essential home functionality, such as burst water pipes, you must not allow anyone to enter your home. That includes your loved ones. While you can go outside, you must not get near anyone else. Anything you need brought to you will need to be left at your door. Bring it in. Put it away. Wash your hands. If you have to touch them again within 8 hours of their delivery, wash your hands.</p><p>If you have a chronic illness or are over 80, I urge you to call your clinic today to request refills on your prescriptions and to make one last shopping trip tomorrow to pick up those prescriptions and to stock up on household items. If possible, today or tomorrow see your loved ones face to face. Then — and certainly no later than this weekend — begin self-isolation.</p><p>If you are a bit younger and healthier than that, you can start self-isolating a little later, but no later than when Covid starts spreading in your community. Here in NH that may be as little as a week from now. The data I’m seeing right now suggest that this is probably 2 to 4 weeks away. In these last few weeks or days before Covid becomes uncontained, you should do everything you need to do that involves contact with other people.</p><p>Based on what we’re seeing elsewhere in the world, Covid will rage locally for many weeks. I’m estimating people will need to stay self-isolated for 2 to 4 months.</p><p>If you’re going to self-isolate, start stockpiling essentials now. You should stockpile two to four weeks of food, medications, and other essentials. (Don’t forget your pets’ needs). You should figure out now how you plan to be re-supplied. Do you have young, healthy friends, family, or neighbors who can shop for you? Do you have backup people to cover for those if they get sick? Some local grocery stores have delivery or pickup options such as Hannaford and Walmart.</p><p>You do not need to stockpile like you are preparing for the apocalypse. Even the areas affected worst by Covid have experienced nothing more than short-term disruptions in deliveries. Remember, there are plenty of young healthy people who will experience Covid as no more than a cold and who will keep food and fuel flowing. You need to prepare only for the possibility of short-term disruptions and so you can minimize how often you need deliveries.</p><p>If the high-risk members of our population keep themselves safe from Covid by voluntarily self-isolating, and if the low-risk members act to slow the transmission of the disease, we can keep our healthcare system from hitting the breaking point, we can have a much lower death rate than other countries have so far experienced, and we can shorten and perhaps even prevent the need for lockdowns and travel restrictions.</p><p>If you get sick, call us. The advice we will give will depend a lot on your personal circumstances and what is happening with the epidemic at the time you get sick.</p><p>The situation can be expected to change as we learn more about Covid and how our society copes with it. Expect that what I’ve said here may need to be added onto. Expect announcements from public health authorities as the epidemic progresses. Please comply with government directives for containing the epidemic. Already the failure of a single person in NH to follow isolation orders has shortened our local lead time by perhaps weeks.</p><p>It’s been 100 years since our country has faced an epidemic like this one. In med school, epidemics were one of the things we studied, but never expected to have to deal with. Never before in my career have I had to present my patients with such difficult moral decisions which have to be made on the basis of such uncertain information.</p><p>Some patients I’ve already talked with have told me they feel that following the advice I’ve provided here is a moral duty to protect others from harm, provide fair access to strained healthcare resources, fight a deadly pathogen, avoid restricting the freedoms of others, and a patriotic duty to protect each other and our society.</p><p>Other patients have told me that what I’m requesting here is too onerous. I know it is onerous. I know that over the next few months you will miss seeing your grandchildren, going out to eat, visiting your friends, etc. But when this is all over, what will have been the hardest thing to bear about the Covid epidemic? Will it have been the time you were stuck at home, bored, or will it be knowing that your choices during the epidemic made it worse, or maybe even caused the death of a loved one?</p><p>Dr. Mary Braun<br>Internist, XXX FQHC &amp; XXX Nursing Home</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=744b8859a058" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Stoicism for Something Bad]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/stoicism-for-something-bad-a7a5cd064a21?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a7a5cd064a21</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stoicism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Feb 2020 21:17:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-08T21:17:09.259Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>John (not his real name, details changed) hates his job. He is healthy and comes in every few months to talk about getting off his anti-depressant. He thinks his boss is a jerk who makes him do demeaning things that should really be the job of the newer people on the team. He makes more than he thinks he could anywhere else because he’s been at this job a long time. Maybe, he thinks, his boss is trying to make him quit so he can be replaced with a cheaper, younger new hire. He wants to quit his job. He doesn’t want to take a decrease in income. Quit. Stay. Quit. Stay. He explains both points to me every time he comes in. He’s so depressed he doesn’t do much besides watch TV when he comes home from work. He doesn’t mountain bike which he used to love and he’s made no progress on that genealogy project he’s been talking about for a decade. He’s stuck. Clearly, the meds aren’t working sufficiently for him. We’ve changed them a couple times and that makes no difference. He’s tried therapy with three different therapists and that doesn’t seem to help. This is the type of patient to whom I suggest Stoicism.</p><p>Stoicism is not medicine and I am reluctant to suggest it to anyone who seems to have an active medical issue. The idea of my patient going to the emergency room for treatment that I could have given them in the office if I hadn’t been too busy suggesting they give Stoicism a try is appalling. I’m a doctor, not a philosopher. I am competent to diagnose pneumonia, but am I competent to suggest or teach philosophy? On the other hand, I think Stoicism works and would help a patient like John. Is it compassionate to withhold it? Just like, I don’t need to be a surgeon to diagnose appendicitis, I don’t need to be a philosopher to diagnose “needing a life philosophy.” But if I’ve diagnosed his problem as “needing a life philosophy,” suggested he start exploring life philosophies, and then another doctor makes him better by giving him a pill that I could have prescribed, would he be justified to be upset with me?</p><p>A doctor’s business is care of the body, and my official title is “health care provider.” We can define “health” as broadly as we like, but I do not think it can be expanded enough to include “needing a life philosophy” and, yet, I see people who are suffering for lack of one. One of the ways I solve this problem is to have philosophy books in my exam rooms and to run late. It used to work better. Now that everyone has an iphone, I find people are more likely to be watching cat videos than taking advantage of a chance to read Irvine for free.</p><p>Another of the ways I solve this problem is to preface anything I say about Stoicism by saying, “I am telling you this, not as your doctor, but as a fellow suffering human being.” These are my credentials for philosophy teaching. Sometimes life sucks and I’ve had to cope, too.</p><p>I have to prioritize what we are going to talk about with every patient. It is rare that I get to things like would you like a shingles vaccine and even rarer that I get to “wear your seatbelt.” I feel that I cannot help my patients with their existential issues until all of their physical issues have been addressed and yet sometimes the existential issues are driving the physical issues.</p><p>If I have a patient who is not healthy physically, I feel obliged to spend all of our precious time together talking about traditional medical topics. By coming to see me, my patient has declared in which realm they think their problem lies. If their teeth were troubling them, they’d see a dentist. If their soul was troubling them, a chaplain. At least in theory, if my patients were seeking a life philosophy, they would be at the philosopher’s office. Since they have come to a doctor’s office, we talk about their body, not philosophical issues.</p><p>Because of this, the rare healthy may get an inoculation of Stoicism from me. The unhealthy, who would benefit more from it, do not. The patient who would benefit the very most from a discussion of Stoicism rarely gets even a homeopathic dose of it from me. He (or she) is one who has recently been diagnosed with Something Bad. Having Something Bad means that now one probably knows what is going to kill one and using google, one can easily find how long before 50% of the patients with one’s very own diagnosis die. Examples of Something Bad are acute leukemia, metastatic colon cancer, severe COPD, or Lewy Body Dementia. There are plenty of others. A diagnosis of Something Bad challenges one’s life philosophy like little else.</p><p>Having your philosophical techniques honed before your doctor says “I don’t like the feel of this lymph node,” or “Let’s get a biopsy of that shadow on your chest xray” works better than scrambling around while you’re waiting, at home, awake at 2 am, for the results. If you haven’t gotten your diagnosis of Something Bad (yet), let’s stop wasting time! If however, you have recently been told you have Something Bad, do not despair. These techniques are just what one doctor wishes she could order and they will start helping you immediately.</p><p><strong>Dichotomy of Control</strong></p><p>A common starting place for Stoic reading is Epictetus’ Enchiridion which opens with “Some things are in our control and others not.” Because there are two options, it is called the dichotomy of control: thing are under one’s control or they are not under one’s control.</p><p>Having Something Bad is not under one’s control. Some Bad Diagnoses have risk factors which are under our control: smoking, sun tanning, or excessive drinking, for example. However, which person with the risk factor gets the disease and which doesn’t is not under our control. Every smoker, regardless of their level of smoking knows a smoker who smoked more and died at an old age from something completely unrelated to smoking. “It’s not fair. How come they didn’t get lung cancer and I did?” Every cardiac patient who eats well and jogs daily also knows a dozen obese people much older than him who have not exercised since their youth and who do not have cancer. Certainly, there are risk factors, but who gets a particular Bad Diagnosis and when is a matter that is not under our control.</p><p>Bill Irvine uses the idea of a trichotomy of control (some things are partially under my control). I happen not to find this extra division helpful, but some people do. I would grant that sometimes having Something Bad is sometimes partially under my control, but certainly not fully. Whether or not I smoke is under my control, but whether or not I get lung cancer, regardless of how much I smoked, is not.</p><p>I observe that people who remember that getting their Bad Diagnosis is out of their control tend to do better. “Getting lung cancer was out of my control. I have it. The more energy I waste in thinking about why I got lung cancer, the less I will have available for figuring out what to do about it.”</p><p>When I consider my own history, I can feel very upset that my mother died at 39. Why did she get such a bad diagnosis? On the other hand, I can recall that I have taken care of children with cancer who died before graduating from high school. Why was she spared this fate, a precondition for my very existence?</p><p>An exercise that I find helpful is to turn “Why me?” around into “Why not me?” Whenever I wonder “Why me? Why did my mother die when I was seven?” I can challenge myself with “When my mother died is out of my control. Why was I lucky enough to have my mom for seven years? Plenty of women die in childbirth. This was equally out of my control.”</p><p><strong>Gratitude</strong></p><p>A very easy step from “Why not me?” is to gratitude. Continuing the personal example above, I am grateful my mom was alive for my first seven years.</p><p>If you wonder how important the classical Stoics thought gratitude was, read the first book of Meditations. Marcus lists people and situations he is grateful about. This goes on for page after page.</p><p>I do find that patients who are more grateful are happier. There is research supporting this that you can google easily.</p><p>If you have just gotten a Bad Diagnosis and wants to start developing a gratitude practice, consider what getting your diagnosis exactly a year ago would have meant for you. Consider what getting it during an earlier season of your life would have been like. It may come easily to you to be grateful that you did not get your diagnosis as you were helping plan your child’s wedding last year. Perhaps you will simply feel gratitude for the ensuing year of everyday experiences you have had and the bigger store of wisdom and coping skills you have attained.</p><p>Another easy way to identify things you are grateful for is to consider the things you will be saddest to let go of whenever you die. Those are, in all likelihood, things you are grateful to have now.</p><p><strong>Fasting, taking cold showers and other tough guy techniques</strong></p><p>The Stoics, and especially their philosophical cousins the Cynics, emphasized trials of doing without various niceties of life to help one recognize how few the true needs are. They would fast for a while or eat only lentils, sleep on the ground, or do without servants. One would be able to recognize that, while a soft bed is comfy, it’s not at all required. Gratitude for that soft bed would come more naturally. Whether or not you sleep on whatever bed you have is completely under your control, unlike your Bad Diagnosis. The practices build on each other naturally.</p><p>Having practice with what is essential and what is not can be helpful when one is called upon to make medical decisions. The treatment of Something Bad may require one to reclassify some bodily functions from essential to non-essential. It can be surprising to learn which of the things you thought you required prior to getting your diagnosis is actually nice, but not necessary. Your disease may ask you “what is life without the nicety of a functioning anal sphincter?” And you will have to answer in order to choose your treatment path.</p><p>You will have to make decisions in coping with Something Bad. Some doctors disagree with me, but I think it is helpful to notice when there is a choice to be made and to be explicit that one has made a choice. If you have a diagnosis of Something Bad, you have likely made some choices already. Most people with Something Bad have chosen to work up their symptoms. Some people with incredibly severe symptoms prefer not to know more and do not take the steps you may have taken to get your diagnosis. Or maybe you opted to have a mammogram. Not everyone does. Chances are good you’ve made a number of choices already. Chances are good you have many, many more choices yet to make.</p><p>Patients will frequently come to me and say, “I have no choice. The oncologist says I have to do this medication or surgery or radiation treatment.” Nothing could be further from the truth. You do have a choice! You don’t have to do anything you don’t want to do! It’s your body! What the cancer doctor is saying is that if you do this treatment, it will give you an increased likelihood of living longer, or better. You are deciding (or are allowing the cancer doctor to decide for you) that the nuisance, pain, discomfort, nausea, whatever of this treatment are worth the likely benefit. Because you are making this choice, you really are in control. You are not in control of what benefit you actually get from the treatment or how bad the side effects are for you, but it’s your decision to do the treatment.</p><p>My observation is that people who realize that they made a choice are less disturbed by their symptoms. Yes, I have not been able to eat for three days, but that is a side effect of this chemo. I chose this chemo knowing it would be tough because it would give me a better chance of living longer.</p><p>Some people decide that the potential to live longer is not worth the loss of function it would require. Some people decide that it is. Having been the one to make that decision for themselves, however, makes the suffering which ensues from whichever choice they have made much more tolerable. The Stoic practice of finding out how much one can do without can help inform these decisions. Sometimes how little one needs to be happy is a shock.</p><p>Once I took care of a young woman who would die soon if she didn’t accept being fed through her veins. She and her husband had owned a restaurant together. Eating and drinking had been such an important part of her life that she was not sure that life would hold any meaning if it continued beyond the point where she could eat and drink. She said no. Her husband begged her to try, however, so she did. The next time I saw her, she was beaming. “It is so intimate to have him hook me up every night and give me what I need. I love it. It has brought us closer.” She lived another very happy, very intimate six months.</p><p>Something Bad will demand that you consider what delicacies of life are actually essential. It may be that you will determine that life without functioning bowels or bladder or eating or walking or seeing is actually perfectly acceptable. Or it may be that you will decide such a life is not acceptable.</p><p>Stoics may take cold showers, but patients with Something Bad are cutting to the bone. They often discover that very basic things healthy people consider essentials are actually niceties.</p><p><strong>Premeditatio Malorum</strong></p><p>People often identify Premeditatio Malorum as the distinctive Stoic practice. The Stoic imagines their fear (my cancer will progress) in as great a detail as they can tolerate (I will be unable to control my bowels, I’ll have to use a bag, I’ll be too weak to take care of it myself, my family will have to do it for me, I’ll be so embarrassed) and then considers this state in light of their basic virtue (will I still be able to be wise, just, courageous, and equanimous in this state? Clearly, I would be. The opportunities to practice these virtues would be multiplied, not diminished. Thus my basic value is not decreased.) Not all patients would view the maintenance of virtue as the thing that keeps their life worth living, but the question one asks can be adapted for what is important to the individual doing the exercise. The practice remains very valuable if one remembers to do the whole practice and doesn’t allow one’s self to start in the middle or get side tracked before the conclusion.</p><p>This first step is not a Stoic step. Starting here will allow you to adapt the exercise for your own belief system, if it is a non-Stoic belief systems. If one is a Stoic, one believes that virtue is the only good. Being virtuous is what gives one’s life meaning. If one does not believe this, the work starts here. The beginning step is to figure out what one’s deepest hope is, or possibly what one feels one specifically offers to the universe. For some people this can be accessed as what gives their life meaning. If I were doing this practice by myself, I might write the answers down on an index card. These deep issues are where you’re going ultimately. If this seems like too abstract an idea for your life, keep reading anyway. Give me a chance to bring it down to the concrete and accessible. We’ll get there. I have helped people with all kinds of belief systems with this exercise. I bet you’ll find it helpful, too.</p><p>The thing about having Something Bad is that you know Bad Things are coming. You are quite likely to die from Something Bad and in fairly short order. This fact — death is in sight — sits at the back of the mind of every patient with Something Bad. Every patient I’ve ever met does the “identify your fear” part of Premeditatio Malorum instinctively. Going the next step and determining that their virtue, or whatever gives their life meaning, would not be affected by the losses they are imagining is what makes this practice special. Doing the middle steps only can get people into trouble and the patients that I see who are having the hardest time are often those who get stuck, wandering in the fear part of this practice.</p><p>If I happen upon a patient who is suffering because they have started down this path and gotten lost, I will spend the time with them to get them unstuck, even if it means I will be running late for the patients who come after them. This is very important work to do. Patients who are stuck here have imagined the thing they are most afraid of in great detail. I ask them to look at it and listen to what they say. Starting with the first step “what makes life meaningful to you?” would be greeted with derision or possibly anger. But that is what I am trying to figure out with the hurting person in front of me.</p><p>People will often tell me things like, “I worry how my kids will grow up without me to watch over them.” (Their worry might be can my kids grow up well without me? or it might be how will my kids survive the viciousness of the world? or it might be will my kids feel the abandonment of my death so acutely that they will be unable to trust others in the future?) Sometimes I hear “I don’t want to burden my loved ones with cleaning me up when I can’t control my bowels any more.” (Their question is something like “Will my family still love me if I am helpless or disgusting?” Or it might be “Do people love me only because I am strong and independent?”) I try to explore these things to learn what is the deepest belief or wish. Oftentimes, the patient cannot put words to it themself. I take my best stab at what it might be and then wander around with them until by a change in their demeanor I can tell we’re close.</p><p>Stoics find it helpful to realize that they will still be able to be virtuous even if their worst fear comes to pass. Christians could gain comfort from premeditatio malorum by recalling that they can still love Jesus even if their worst fears come to pass. Often there is a deeply held belief like “If I were a good mother, I would find a way to keep from dying.” that is causing pain. It can be tough to find, but doing this work will help ultimately.</p><p>The final step in premeditatio malorum is to consider what impact on one’s deepest hope is caused by the fears that one is ruminating upon. For the woman who believes “if I were a good mother, I’d find a way to keep from dying,” I would concentrate on helping her find ways to be a good mother after her death (writing letters or other means of posthumous communication, perhaps). For the person who is worried about who will help guide their children after their death, we might identify people who could help and figure out if giving her children this list or talking to the potential helpers or some other action would be most helpful. For the person who wondered if he’d be loved in his weakened state, we’d consider times that others were loved when they were weak, perhaps, or possibly an open conversation with the patient’s family about what her he was likely to need, what they thought they would be able to do that their abilities have nothing to do with their love for him, and where else they might get help would likely ensue.</p><p>After we have identified the painful belief, visited the worst fear in great detail, figured out what is essential to do, figured out that we have control over at this point and made some plans to do those things, I circle back and try to help the patient see that the thing they were most in fear of is not a threat. Usually they have figured this out for themselves already.</p><p><strong>Call things by their true natures</strong></p><p>One of the funny places in The Meditations is where Marcus describes sex as friction followed by mucous. The technique of describing things prosaically can be helpful when one has Something Bad. “A single cell has decided its chances are better if it goes it alone,” “They’ll put a little tube into my kidney that will poke out my back and drain my urine directly into a bag,” “I’m done breastfeeding babies, so those parts have outlived their utility.”</p><p><strong>Meditate on your mortality</strong></p><p>Stoicism emphasizes the reality that we are all well on our way to death. Really meditating on this requires a certain amount of courage as well as imagination for the average person. A Bad Diagnosis sets one’s imagination on fire and provides the courage needed to get started. It is much easier to always be aware of the fact that I am dying if I know there is only a fifty percent chance I’ll be alive in five years. Prioritizing one’s life as though one is going to be dead soon tends to produce decisions oriented towards the deeper desires. Remembering that one will be dead soon tends to cause one to consider how one will be remembered by loved ones after one’s death. Acting in a way that seems likely to cause good memories in the future is also likely to cause a better today. Thus, the person with the Bad Diagnosis benefits from regarding their imminent death.</p><p>Different people have different hopes for the time around their death. I hope yours is as easy and as meaning filled as you would like it to be. My observation is that these practices help when you get a Bad Diagnosis. And, what is Life but a universally fatal condition? What diagnosis could be worse than Life? Our Bad Diagnosis is coming soon enough. Let’s get practicing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a7a5cd064a21" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Kitten to Tiger: the CT scan]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/kitten-to-tiger-the-ct-scan-6d819abce011?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d819abce011</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[geriatrics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aging]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Feb 2020 02:08:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-03T02:08:21.025Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>First, you have to call up your daughter to pick you up and take you to the lab. It’s hard for the nurse to find your vein. The pain from his fishing around in your arm is not nearly as bad as the pain you always have in your hip, and back, and shoulders, but it’s the straw that breaks the camel’s back, and you cry a little bit. The phlebotomist doesn’t notice, but your daughter does.</p><p>A couple of days later, your daughter drives you and your latest bruise up to the front door of the hospital. She parks while you walk in.</p><p>You have trouble deciding whether she’ll get parked so quickly that it’s not worth the effort of sitting down and the even bigger effort of getting up again. As you stand there indecisively, your daughter appears, and the two of you get on the elevator. She somehow already knows which floor to go to. Perhaps she asked someone as she walked by the front desk. That’s not something you could have done. It now takes all of your concentration just to walk.</p><p>When you get to the reception area, you get to sit and rest while your daughter checks you in. That was nice because this long walk has tired you out. Next, you go into the locker room and change into their gown. You can keep your underwear, but your bra has to come off. Getting that wretched thing on and off has become hard with your stiff shoulders. There’s not even a good place to sit down while you do this, but fortunately, your daughter helps you without your asking.</p><p>Now that you’ve got the gown on, you start noticing you’re feeling a little weird. You’ve missed your 9:30 meds. This morning you weren’t sure if you should take your diuretic and risk having to pee constantly or not take it and risk being short of breath. You took half. Now you’re feeling a bit short of breath, and you have to pee. You grab your walker and head off to the toilet.</p><p>When you get out of the toilet, you find that the staff is already waiting for you. You’re holding up the show. The nurse puts an IV into your other arm and leads you to the CT scanner. She has you sit down on a curved piece of plastic and gets your feet up so you can lie down on this cold, slightly padded thing. The technician says, “Yes, you have to be flat on your back, but it won’t be long at all,” and she slides you into the machine.</p><p>You lie there, worried about what will go wrong. The IV doesn’t fall out when they put the contrast through. You don’t have a pee accident. You were able to hold your breath when they asked, and your back didn’t hurt too much. The technician slides you out of the machine and helps you up. As she does, you feel a sharp pain shoot through your back. You know that kind of pain. It means your back will hurt for a week, but at least the scan is over with. The nurse removes the IV. You go back into the locker room. On your way there, you notice you’re feeling even weirder than you were before. You’re now due for your 10:30 meds. You start wondering how high is your blood pressure is now, and when you get home, should you take your 9:30 and 10:30 meds together or has it been so long now that you should skip your 9:30 meds, or is this the combination of meds where they just don’t work as well if you take them together or the one where it could mess up your heart rhythm if you take them together? You can’t figure it out and trust that your daughter will remember. You wish it wasn’t so complicated and that you could remember all the details about your meds that your heart doctor, your kidney doctor, and your primary care doctor went over with you.</p><p>While you were ruminating about your meds, you’ve managed to get half-dressed. Now you notice you have to pee again. You feel bad that you’re making your daughter wait, so you try to hurry. As you get up from the toilet, you reach for a bar to help you stand. The end of your shirt slips down into the yet-to-be-flushed toilet. This is what happens when you’re someplace different and not doing things the way you’re used to.</p><p>You get back to the locker room and tell your daughter about the shirt. You feel bad because she does so much laundry for you. She helps you get dressed and out to the car, the reverse of the steps coming in. You arrange yourself carefully so as not to get your damp, contaminated shirt on the front seat. Your back is really killing you now, and you feel a little dizzy from not taking your medications.</p><p>When you get home, you change your shirt and all the other clothes it got wet. Your daughter tells you to take your 9:30 and 10:30 meds and the rest of your diuretic dose altogether. Your back is killing you. You go straight to bed and turn on the TV.</p><p>A week later, about the time your latest bruise has started to fade, and your back is mostly recovered, the doctor’s office calls you. The nurse cheerfully says, “Your CT scan was fine. It turns out that your chest X-ray showed overlapping shadows, and there was nothing there after all.”</p><p>You know your daughter wants to know how the scan came out. You call her, feeling bad that she had to take half a day off of work for all of this.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d819abce011" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dr. Imperfect Will See You Now]]></title>
            <link>https://doctormary.medium.com/coping-with-my-imperfections-e7554724b10d?source=rss-5caf20a4172c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e7554724b10d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mistakes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare-system]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doctors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doctorpatientrelationship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mary Braun, MD]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Jan 2020 12:44:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-17T11:55:46.151Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Because everything around us usually works, it can be easy to forget how fragile some of the workings are. My patients see this with their bodies, as they fail, but not so obvious to them are the fragilities of the healthcare system that we doctors get to see.</p><p>Despite what the if-it-bleeds-it-leads press might have you thinking, our healthcare system is pretty good. Good however is never good enough, at least not for doctors. Med schools select people who have always aimed to be better than good. So, we all entered the doctor-making factory with that predilection, and having matters of life and death thrust into our hands daily pushes us all to be more than just a “good” doctor.</p><p>Meanwhile, we’re all horribly busy.</p><p>Suppose a specialist has diagnosed a patient with something rare. The patient’s primary care doctor has not heard about this condition since medical school. It’s late in the day. He’s tired, or dinner is waiting, or the kids have a soccer game. The doctor is pretty sure he doesn’t really need to look it up to make sure that memory serves, at least not right now.</p><p>Many doctors keep a list of things to investigate on the weekend and things like this might go on it, but some weekends, other tasks such as writing notes, responding to refill requests and writing lab letters are more pressing and the to-do list might not get done or might not get done until next week.</p><p>For this particular patient, there might be three pieces of information that need to be held simultaneously in attention.</p><p>1. The patient has condition X.</p><p>2. Medication Y is bad for people with condition X.</p><p>3. The patient is taking medication Y.</p><p>The patient will be safe if someone has all three simultaneously.</p><p>When the patient is at the specialist, many things could go wrong preventing the patient from conveying the fact that he is taking medication Y. Patients often don’t remember the complicated names for their medications. Many patients need written lists of them, but like all written lists, these can be misplaced or forgotten about, or outdated, or in error, or never obtained in the first place, or not asked for. Occasionally specialists don’t have that vital third piece of information about what medications the patient is taking.</p><p>Meanwhile the patient may know what condition they have and what medications they’re taking but have no idea that they’re taking a medication that’s bad for their condition unless the specialist mentions it, and does so in a way that the patient can understand.</p><p>Alternatively, when the patient gets home after their appointment they’ll realize that they failed to tell the specialist about their medication and will have somehow been alerted to the fact that it might be bad for them. This is more sophistication than should ever be expected of a patient, but it occasionally happens.</p><p>What usually happens is that an electronic note of the visit to the specialist is generated, which is automatically sent to the patient’s primary care doctor to review. Primary care</p><p>doctors see about forty of these a day. The note says that the specialist has diagnosed the patient with condition X. The specialist might also mention in the note that medication Y is a problem for such patient, or the primary care doctor will happen to remember this. Next the primary care doctor has to check the list of medications the patient is on to ensure that they’re okay to take. This may require an extra step of looking up detailed information about those medications with respect to the patient’s new condition. In one of these ways, all three of our necessary facts finally appear together. Once this happens, the primary care doctor can call the patient or the specialist and make a plan.</p><p>The astonishing thing about this whole process is how fragile it is. It relies on one brain having all three pieces of information at once and recognizing their significance. And this is a simple case! Sometimes there are five or ten pieces of information, some of which come from one organ system’s needs and some of which come from another’s.</p><p>As I write this and notice the fragility of a system that relies ultimately on the contents of one brain — mine! — to keep a patient safe, I see that it is no wonder I feel stressed and insufficient so much of the time.</p><p>What I do matters. I like that. I chose this job because I wanted what I did to matter. Now, I have gotten what I wished for. I am trying to balance that my provision of perfect care matters with the fact that I am not perfect and that my imperfections need to be allowed, somehow.</p><p>Making peace with this fact, loving it some days, hating it others, and respecting it always, is what needs to be done in order to be a sane primary care doctor.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e7554724b10d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>