<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:08:59 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Path of Braided Dialectics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/a-path-of-braided-dialectics-f6757a80daa7?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6757a80daa7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dialectics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dhamma]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Sep 2026 17:18:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-14T06:11:09.361Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IxhHKGqo5DVddf9ndhNCEQ.png" /></figure><p><em>(The accompanying piece to this essay is — </em><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/a-song-of-braided-dialectics-e7a53453589f?sharedUserId=dolessforpeace"><em>A Song of Braided Dialectics</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>Dialectical and Historical Materialism (DHM), as originally developed by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, has long served as a powerful and unique analytic, strategic, and predictive tool for the advancement of social history. Through his materialist inversion of Hegelian dialectical thought, Marx demonstrated how movements of social progress are fueled by the forces of class-conflict arising from the development of society’s productive forces and relationships. Historical Materialism describes how advancements in the social relations of production — such as the growth in wealth and productive power of capitalist industrialization through the exploitation of wage-labor — simultaneously create their own contradictions: poverty, resource-depletion, and alienation. Those most negatively affected by these antagonisms eventually rise to confront and overturn the very same system that created them.</p><p>The movement of history, traced along the concrete currents of convulsive causation, can therefore be described dialectically as a development of opposing forces, each in its ascension causing contradictions that will inspire its own negation, creating a unity of progressive advance and structure of developmental coherence over time. In this way, dialectical conflict/negation is not merely destructive, but also preserves a through-line of development, representing a unity structured by opposition.</p><p>Engels later elaborated on the concept to form Dialectical Materialism as a means of expanding the philosophical underpinnings of Historical Materialism to encompass patterns of change at other levels of the natural world. The unified framework is not merely an analytical tool: most importantly, materialist dialectics are a technology that can be strategically applied to social and economic relations to advance the historical push toward a world that overcomes class domination.</p><p>Because each moment of this development is historically specific, Dialectical and Historical Materialism insists that social phenomena cannot be appropriately understood or judged outside of their direct historical context and conditions. As Lenin would later state succinctly, “Truth is never abstract, it is always concrete.”</p><p>But what are the specific concrete historical conditionings of materialist dialectics itself? The Chinese Communist Party has long understood its own advancement of Marxist dialectics has a specific Chinese character, informed by a long lineage of philosophy and social thought rooted in the dynamic interaction of opposites — mostly clearly elucidated in Taoist, Confucian, and to some degree Buddhist lineages. Hegel’s dialectics were themselves drawn and developed from other historical currents, including those of Christian mystics such as Jakob Boehme. Centuries before Hegel, Boehme had threaded the notion into his own work from ancient hermetic texts of Egypt. There, in antiquity, the lineage is obscured as the concept is revealed the product of conflict and syncretism of Egyptian, Greek, Roman, Jewish — and certainly other — lineages brought into correspondence via the complex cause and effect dynamics of conquest, trade, and religious and social interactions in all their dialectical complexities. While DHM is aptly fit to the task of revolutionary change in our time, the fundamentals of dialectical thought point to truths repeatedly recognized and valued across vast swaths of time and space and human culture: an understanding of a tension at the heart of all unities that at once disrupts its own stability and provides the structure of further development.</p><p>Indeed, humans from a multitude of traditions have long fathomed an aspect of reality that appears around and within us as a dynamic interaction of opposites propelling life forward. The non-static opposition and interdependence of daytime and night, birth and death, female and male, internal and external, and visible and invisible along with countless symbols and interactions we observe and experience point to an unfolding philosophy I believe we can broadly — if cautiously — hold under the term dialectic. While the details vary widely across cultural-historical conditions, in an expansive field of general conception it can be described as Marx and Engels did: as a kind of magnetic inner-tension between opposing forces that produces movement and change, whose conflict is so fundamental and mutually reinforcing that it also, paradoxically, represents a coherent unity.</p><blockquote>Dialectics, however, is nothing more than the science of the general laws of motion and development of nature, human society, and thought.</blockquote><blockquote>Every kind of thing therefore has a peculiar way of being negated in such a manner than it gives rise to a development, and it is just the same with every kind of conception or idea.</blockquote><blockquote>Men thought dialectically long before they knew what dialectics was, just as they spoke prose long before the term prose existed -</blockquote><blockquote><em>~ Frederick Engels, Anti-Duhring </em><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-1"><em>1</em></a></blockquote><p>From this position, we can therefore meaningfully consider the dialectics of tinku in Andean cosmology <a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-2">2</a>, of yin and yang in ancient Chinese thought, or even of non-dual advaita vedanta lineages of Indian philosophy. We could plumb the depths of the complex dialectics between the opposing but mutually interdependent aspects of Quetzalcoatl and Tezcatlipoca in Aztec thought, or in Hawaiʻi, the relationships between the wild and the domesticated represented by Kane and Kanaloa, or fertility and war as between Lono and Kū. While dialectical action is not the only meaningful dynamic tendency at play in the cosmos, in nature, in society, and in our internal development — it is one that has be noticed and tracked for millennia.</p><p>In the multitude of cultural and political-economic forms across Oceania we encounter a kaleidoscope of dialectical variations. From The Epic Tale of Hiʻiakaikapoliopele <a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-3">3</a> in Hawaiʻi, for instance, we find this,</p><blockquote>The house of the coral, dwelt in by the sea.</blockquote><blockquote>The house of the sea, dwelt in by the coral.</blockquote><blockquote>Thus, the pattern unfolds.</blockquote><p>While this quotation creates an elegant scaffolding for numerous social, material, and cosmological implications, it also reveals an important potential tension with Dialectical and Historical Materialism. Marxist dialectics depend upon an interaction between opposing forces of negation that develops progressively over time by the overcoming of contradiction — an act of sublation (German: <em>aufheben</em>) that results in what is often referred to in Hegelian glossing as “synthesis.” This Hawaiian quotation points to a different possibility: that of an ahistorical endless repetitive unfolding of a pattern. Whether or not this quotation is rooted in such a belief or not is not as important here as the recognition that other systems of duality, polarity, complementarity, or agonistic tension may not fully align with dialectics regarding the nature and quality of interactions between these opposing forces, or the ultimate goal of revolutionary social change implied within them.</p><p>This contradiction, if and when it exists, need not be an end to the conversation, but instead provides a locus of meaningful application of dialectical engagement with Dialectical and Historical Materialism. To the degree that the worldviews of other traditions may be better described as non-dialectical dualisms, I believe they can still be meaningfully transposed into true dialectical frameworks — perhaps in ways that are hinted at in Chinese Communist Party development of Taoist and Confucian principles along Marxist lines <a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-4">4</a>. Other cosmologies and frameworks may not have been formed from the same strict rational-materialist basis or lineage of Western thought and may have profoundly divergent orientations in regard to social, environmental, and spiritual transformation. Nevertheless, many of them are clearly rooted in observations of direct material reality and I believe can be brought into meaningful conversation with Marxist dialectics.</p><p>Why is this important? Many anti-imperialist movements of national liberation — particularly in indigenous communities — have taken up these ancient frameworks as a way of reclaiming knowledge, cultural cohesion, and material possession of what was stolen and fractured by processes of capitalist colonization and development. They are actively used as a means of healing the metabolic and cultural rift created between people and our natural and social environments as well as creating strategic confrontation with capitalist modernity wherever it can be encountered. Many of these practitioners have positioned themselves against the global capitalist-imperialist order, and (as a result of the historical development of that very same order) are also engaging Marxist dialectics in concrete historical ways. These traditions have vast layers of meaning implicit and explicit about internal process, social relations, and relations between the human and natural world. Therefore, the question of how we begin to build a meaningful correspondence between other dialectical traditions and Dialectical and Historical Materialism in ways that further the movements’ capacity for revolutionary change should be of primary urgency.</p><p>Principally, the approach must itself be dialectical, which will take stretching on all sides to be rigorous and yet non-dogmatic nor deterministic. Here are a few suggestions,</p><ul><li>For all its insistence on materialist foundation, DHM must respect the dialectical opposition of paradigms that are predominantly spiritual or idealist. Given the fact that modern science — long honored by historical materialists — still cannot definitively answer the questions as to the nature and relationship between mind and matter, space and time, causation and entanglement, there is rational cause for revolutionary communists to be open-minded and enthusiastically engaged regarding the various unique analytic, strategic, and predictive value and legitimacy of other dialectical paradigms with whom they are called to build. Rather than get fixated on old European philosophical arguments about the fundamental nature of reality or truth, determine carefully what is actually vital to advance the contradictions of the world we are in now in and the conditions we currently face.</li><li>For their insistence on “the traditional way” culturally-rooted paradigms must acknowledge that they are now being brought to bear as anti-capitalist tools within different historical material conditions under which the cosmovisions were formed and developed. As is true for all social manifestations, cultural traditions don’t reflect stagnant fixed ahistorical truths from an abstract past but are always in dynamic process of active formulation over time — and should still be considered alive in their development. If these frameworks were developed in feudal or pre-feudal conditions, care must be taken to consider the degree these social relations are romanticized or eternalized by the cosmologies themselves. In the present moment, these are distinct, legitimate, legible, and indeed historically inevitable dialectical responses to concrete material reality based on differing trajectories of development, currently positioned against capitalist imperialism.</li><li>While Marxist dialectics have much to learn from the insights of other dialectical approaches, and their development will be mutual, DHM is unique among other most systems in its clear and explicit orientation toward revolutionary social change in a modern context — one that demands an overthrow of the capitalist relations of production that create class oppression. To to the degree that we seek that end, DHM must be considered paradigmatic and dialectics, even if reenvisioned, must remain core.</li><li>This is not merely an attempt to bring Marxist dialectics into power-generating relationship with indigenous worldviews. There are numerous other frameworks such as democratic socialism, anarchism, and even at times bourgeois liberalism with which we must learn to incorporate in a dialectical process of negation and sublation — which is also a coherent integration.</li></ul><p>The question here is not which dialectic is more true. Rather, by what dialectical process can we come to realize the value of Dialectical and Historical Materialism in relationship to other anti-capitalist worldviews and political schemas of vision, analysis, and strategy in order to build enough power to overthrow Capitalism? As Lenin wrote, “We are fighting on the ground of a definite state; we unite the workers of all nations living in this state; we cannot vouch for any particular path of national development, for we are marching to our class goal along all possible paths.”</p><p><strong>What is the method by which these paths can build coherent power?</strong></p><p>Seeing that humans have grasped powerful truths about dialectical dynamics since ancient times, it may be instructive to reflect on what is likely a very early example of humans fathoming it and putting this knowledge into practical material use: the creation of cordage through plying. One of the most ancient and basic shared human technologies of social production — the creation of cordage — is often dependent upon an application of a dialectical method: wrapping fibers in one direction while twisting them in the opposite — counter-twining — creates the strategic friction from which all thread, string, lashing, fishing line, nets, ropes, and weaving yarns were traditionally made.</p><p>Loose fibers stripped from plant stalks or the inner bark of trees do not function well as cordage in their natural, loose state. But by plying these strands in a dialectical manner, all early human social production becomes possible <a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-5">5</a>. This elegant and profound piece of ancient human technology creates a form held together precisely by the unifying tension created by its natural tendency to fall apart structured to work against itself. It is this contradiction that supports the structure and development of the unified form itself, and that results in a transformation of quality beyond the primary materials into something whose uses are widely applicable. The cordage that is produced satisfies the “laws” of Dialectical Materialism that Frederich Engels would later develop of: 1. a unity of contradiction; 2. a transformation from quantity to quality, and; 3. development via negation (negation of negation).</p><p>In those ancient times when the practical and the mystical, the material and the spiritual, the technological and the philosophical were generally less clefted than we tend to encounter today, in this unity of opposites humans developed a mechanical understanding of a fundamental and profound aspect of reality. Whether we used the thread for stitching and repairing, rope for thatching our roofs, rigging our boats, or string for playing games like cat’s cradle — it is all dependent upon this conscious application of a materially-inspired philosophical truth onto social production.</p><p>For our work here, a single cord of counter-twined fibers can be considered as a metaphor any of the individual dialectical paradigms we have considered: the development and movement of class antagonisms via historical materialism, of form and spirit, of yin and yang, of ocean and coral, etc. An action from one side inspires a reaction from the other, and a coherent cord is made via the mechanism of dialectical interaction.</p><p>In many human societies, the arts of braiding and weaving are simply considered dimensional extensions of this same philosophical technology as plying cordage. And so for guidance on how to build along “all possible paths” — even amid our differences — I believe that the metaphor of braiding various distinct dialectical cords of anticapitalist perspectives might be a meaningful approach — one that likely follows the same philosophical rules of dialectical action and develops each strand independently but along a coherent structure — which is to say, rooted in tension/negation. Braiding, or plaiting, is a skill that enables the construction of true rope — stronger than strands of cordage as it binds together two or more distinct dialectically-produced cords into a stronger material. This new material one that does not sacrifice the distinction of the individual strands but uses their tension to progressively develop a structure that is more robust than any of them would be alone.</p><p>Braided Dialectics, then, is a way of being, working, and movement building that is dependent neither upon complete concord nor discord but builds a structure of unity that assumes moments and dynamics of both. The practical metaphor of braided dialectics strategically develops the contradictory relationship between conflicting dialectical perspectives in a way provides an adaptable structure for building real social power — without needing to agree or resolve these tensions in every moment and context. Braided Dialectics allows for the conservation of our distinct approaches, developing through conflict with comrades, while avoiding the pitfalls of endless schisms so common to left organizing.</p><p>Right-wing movements have long intuited this process and integrated it into their movement work. Coalition platforms that manage to build power without concern for the contradictions between white nationalism, religious fundamentalism, and fiscal conservatism are perfect expressions of this: an ideology that feels cultural and understands that power is more important than perfection (or even basic ideological coherence).</p><p>There is a braided dialectical relationship between “this is how things are,” “this is how things work,” and “ this is how we do things” which must be learned and shared between people in order to develop social power. Braiding is a social practice, a social art. It is cultural: a socialized way we produce rooted in a direct relationship with material reality. Because the work is laborious and complex, people socialize while braiding hair, plying cordage and netting, making lei — and all related skills. Elders demonstrate simple knots and braids to children who eventually learn from them the traditional designs, patterns, and techniques — including string games and corresponding storytelling traditions. It is a way of being — internally and externally and collectively, a process of social learning, and perpetuation of knowledge, that build cohesion through the application of artistic tension.</p><p>What, then, might be the practical procedures of this dialectical “braiding” as movement work? While a braid is a more complex form than simple cordage, the dialectical principles are likely preserved. For the sake of this exploration, it is most important to simply consider the braid as a higher-order structure brought to the more fundamental materials of distinct dialectical strands. The classic three-stranded braid is the most complex form we will imagine here, but one can conceivably braid an infinite number of strands — though with each additional strand, it is increasingly hard to fathom their interactions in detail <a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-6">6</a>. Isn’t this all that the universe, by some reckonings, is?</p><p>This work is not designed to explore this most expansive version of the braiding metaphor: that all currents of action in human society — and beyond it — are woven together one way or another and thus represent a social/cosmic totality of braided dialectics. Yes, of course all our actions are interwoven and interconnected in one way or another, and the beauty and mystery of the woven universe is worthy of exploration. But the scope of this inquiry is narrower. It is to focus on the strategic braiding of movement dialectics that are expressly interested in some form of leftist or anti-capitalist human emancipation. Determining what material is to be included and which not is an essential aspect of cordage-making and braiding, and as dialecticians, something we should not presume abstractly but rather deal with concrete examples under concrete conditions.</p><p>In order to be in correspondence, we must first overcome all resistance to placing Dialectical and Historical Materialism in the same conceptual plane as other dialectical frameworks. This will take stretching on all sides<a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-7">7</a>. To engage in this process honestly, Marxists must be willing to have their own assumptions interrogated, negated, and sublimated — again and again.</p><p>For example, the opening composition of this work — A Song of Braided Dialectics — is an attempt to transpose Dialectical and Historical Materialism onto the traditional framework of Theravada Buddhism in greater detail as to bring them into meaningful conversation. As a result of dialectical braiding with this other paradigm, a friction is revealed with two positions of Dialectical and Historical Materialism: 1. There is a single valid form and flavor of active dialectical negation/response to a given historical reality; and therefore that 2; Dialectical action always results in real historical progress. These tensions and others arise in the braiding with other modalities as well, and so it is worth briefly examining their implications.</p><p>Regarding the first point, many other systems may recognize valid dialectical responses in social reactions that are not necessarily explicitly opposing, but may instead be recoiling, evasive, or transforming in various ways. These provide cogent and reasonable challenges to the narrow definition of “negation” which has dominated Dialectical and Historical Materialism. Has history since the industrial revolution not shown us that there are numerous inevitable responses to class oppression which complicate the historical movement toward revolutionary change? Can reactions outside of explicit direct opposition still considered dialectical? If so, how might it transform our understanding of the mechanics of dialectical change? How might an approach of braided dialectics help develop these tensions in ways that build power?</p><p>Regarding the second point, contrary to Dialectical and Historical Materialism, many non-western systems and cosmologies that may recognize the unity of opposites, nevertheless point toward a dialectic of cyclicality between chaos and order or an eternal call for humanity to come-to-balance within a greater order. These frameworks therefore may emphasize the personal and social priority of maintaining balance or aligning toward equilibrium rather than the pursuit of advancement. In the Theravada Buddhist system, described in the preceding text, the volitional quality of the action conditions whether the result is progressive, regressive, or cyclical.</p><p>For all its proponents’ insistence on their socialism being “scientific,” braiding forces us to consider whether Dialectical and Historical Materialism are unconsciously rooted in notions of perpetual progress of the concrete historical conditions of Victorian Europe in which they were developed. Marx and Engels came to insist that a socialist revolution was structurally inevitable in history. But as Aldous Huxley posits, “a fanatic is a man who consciously overcompensates a secret doubt,” so we also imagine that “a cynic is one who overcompensates a secret faith.” Is there a secret faith behind Marx’s materialist dialectics that may be described as a hidden teleology appearing as a belief in the structural inherence of dialectical progress? Whether or not “progress” is built into the fabric of cosmos is a question unresolved by DHM alone and further interrogation is needed to advance the contradictions 8.</p><p>To briefly explore another contradiction, history has shown us that it is only through militant movements of nationalist independence that many countries are able to protect themselves from imperialist oppression while developing the internal productive forces that can lead to socialization of the society. These movements often depend upon a process of cohering of cultural identity as a nation. At the same time, many right-wing nationalist movements, including Zionism, depend upon ancient cultural mythologies to legitimize one group’s eternal claim on specific land and resources. Is this an issue to be resolved by argument and a party line or a tension to be advanced through praxis? Can braided engagement with Dialectical and Historical Materialism help leftist frameworks mature beyond limited ethnic nationalistic or feudal-nostalgic tendencies while at the same time help counteract any of DHM’s dogmatic and materialist chauvinist patterns? Can movements work together from a variety of angles to hassle the empire and weaken the force of capital even if they are not fully aligned in all aspects of analysis, vision, and strategy?</p><p>The practical potential for braided dialectics is broader than navigating Dialectical and Historical Materialism’s complex relationships with other socially-applied cosmovisions. Other socialist projects which (from the perspective of DHM) might be considered opportunist, reformist, petty-bourgeois, anarchist, culturalist, identitarian, pacifist, etc. — can also be understood as alternative dialectical paths with whom our relationships may be reconsidered. How might braided dialectics help us build power together, amid — and indeed fueled by — the potent tension within our differences?</p><p>Across time and space, we see examples of where non-violent protest movements and militant revolutions have succeeded where history entwined them and failed where they refused to utilize their tensions within the same movement structure — with each merely disparaging the other, often unproductively — or where clarification was reached, was not shared. Braided dialectics offers us a path forward of advancement through these kinds of tensions without needing to resolve or suppress contradictions that so often lead to the self-destruction of left movements. In fact, it is precisely their tensions which provide the structure for development. What might it look like in this context? Without losing the integrity of each Way, braiding might encourage: 1. pacifists to renounce their sanctimonious conflation of the processes of spiritual and social change while still valuing the power of moral discipline; 2. militants to acknowledge the ethical dimension as real, meaningful, and dangerous in terms of process and outcome without losing their clarity of analysis and action; and, 3. social democrats to recognize that we are actually at war — and endless “reasonable” pragmatism ultimately serves to strengthen capitalist domination, while still recognizing most people just want to live simple, stable, peaceful lives.</p><p>Finally, braided dialectics is also a way of consciously bringing the development of self and society into conversation with one another. Aspects of all these conflicts are likely to be alive inside of us individually, depending upon our own array of cultural influences, traditions, and contradictions. Who among us lives without any ideological tension from contradictions in our lives — internally or in terms of friends, family, work, and the broader society? Do we not already navigate them every day in all facets of our lives? Is life not already a braid of various dialectical cords? How do we develop ourselves in regard to the relationship between these paradoxical threads? Braided Dialectics gives us a tool for inner-development via contradiction and negation rather than fixating on complete ideological purity, coherence, or resolution.</p><p>Most of us have learned to aim for a greater sense of unity, of coherence, within conflicting priorities and dynamic tensions in our political vision and lived experience. The push is often flavored by the fantasy that either one thread will finally come to dominate all others or a natural resolution between tensions will somehow occur. But if we take the approach of Braided Dialectics in regard to the contradictions at various scales — individual, collective, and the social totality, and in regard to how we hold the past, present, and future — another path opens before us: one of constant adaptation, flexibility and rigor that doesn’t require losing the clarity of any one position through negation or integration but instead provides a process of continual development toward our goal — structured by the very tension we so often long to resolve. In this way, conflict, contradiction, paradox, and even hypocrisy — are not treated as obstacles, but rather signs that we are called to engage more profoundly — with greater rigor, agility, and open-mindedness — with the material before us. It is the productive tension that drives us forward, not the dogmatic or naive abandonment of contradiction for the sake of unity or shared identity.</p><p>Simply put, Braided Dialectics is a means by which different social projects can use a shared conceptual language and relational structure that builds unified power through rigorous negation. Those of us dedicated to advancing Dialectical and Historical Materialism need not water-down our analysis or integrate eclectic forms via a sloppy new-age syncretism. Rather, if dialectical rigor can be brought to other forms, different facets and mechanisms and truths can be revealed that can help us inform our own praxis and help develop others. Different dialectical frameworks require their own rigor and internal process of development and clarification. This is the intention behind A Song of Braided Dialectics, which hopefully will be but one of many.</p><p>Through Braided Dialectics, different Ways can be in rigorous dialectical correspondence with each other as a path to building social power. This requires robust relationships — internally, between people, and between movement elements — that are flexible, humble, determined and adaptable to changing historical conditions. It does not require agreement or coherence of analysis, vision, strategy, or tactics. It depends on leveraging in ever-changing ways moment-points of unity and moment-points of contradiction to clarify the integrity of each cord and build the structure of power that advances movement in the multitude of ways we need to develop in order to one day finally overthrow the system by which the value we create by our labor is stolen and used to turn the world against us.</p><p>In most contemporary contexts, if the term “dialectics” evokes any recognition at all, it is as a disembodied academic, intellectual, esoteric, and abstract philosophical framework largely detached from day-to-day material reality. This is as true for the general population as for the non-Marxist left.</p><p>The discrepancy points to the chasm between leftist intellectual production and movement development. But on some level, the fundamental truths and dynamics of dialectics are largely intuitive, concrete, historically rooted, and alive for many people — if perhaps still undeveloped and eclectic in their range of interpretations. By bringing the conversation of dialectics back into the foreground of movement-building, we have the opportunity to tap into a deep, rich, broadly shared range of concepts that are intimately meaningful to the lived experience of many people and can provide the structural framework for the building of an equitable and free future society.</p><p>The conversations may seem divergent — and surely dissonant — on many levels. But via the approach of “braiding” distinct dialectical cords we gain an avenue for the development of historical materialist dialectics that becomes broadly legible, and in fact cultural, for a greater and greater swath of the population. Having dialectics be a shared language matrix for analytical and strategic thought will help address a number of concrete challenges we face in our work against capitalist imperialism.</p><p>☆</p><p>Cover image based on the ﬁlm poster “Y La Noche Se Hizo Arcoiris”by Ñiko, 1979. Used with permission.</p><p>See more at: ñiko.com</p><p>☆</p><p>Notes</p><p><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-anchor-1">1</a></p><p><a href="https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1877/anti-duhring/">https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1877/anti-duhring/</a></p><p><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-anchor-2">2</a></p><p>The cosmovision of ancient Andean societies are replete with complex notions of the range of interactions of opposites. Here is a short list of vocabulary that gives a glimpse of some of the nuance,</p><p>(adapted from <a href="https://threads-of-time.carlos.emory.edu/exhibits/show/essays/dialoguesinthread">https://threads-of-time.carlos.emory.edu/exhibits/show/essays/dialoguesinthread</a> )</p><p>* Ayni represents duality and mutuality as the basic reality of any phenomena, including dynamics of reciprocity in society and nature.</p><p>* Yanantín, points to the complementary and interdependent opposites of existence, while manantin is the experiential manifestation of that unity</p><p>* Q’eswa is a word for rope created by counter-rotational symmetry. It signifies the spiraling of two things and so encapsulates a particular kind of duality.</p><p>* Tinkuy (as a verb) or tinku (as a noun) which means generally “to meet,” specifically when two things converge and form a new third entity — like a confluence of rivers. This unification can be conflictual, and is honored in some places by ceremonies of violent ritual combat, resulting in a reconciliation that is more potent than what existed previously.</p><p>* Ukhu means “inner” or “interior” and signifies that what is inside, even when invisible outwardly, is actively influential to the whole. Like ayni, this signals another type of dual balance, here between the unseen and the seen, between the understood or potential and the apparent or manifest. **</p><p>* Camay loosely means “to put into existence” through an exchange of energy, making the unmanifest manifest, often symbolized by flowing water.</p><p>* Q’iwa is the concept of irregularity, of imbalanced singularity in life. An acknowledgement of the unpredictability, the concept of q’iwa comes from music and specifically stands for playing a high, dissonant note on certain Andean flutes and related to the concept of Ch’ulla, which means single, alone.</p><p>* Ushay is the state of perfect harmony and supreme balance between elements.</p><p><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-anchor-3">3</a></p><p><a href="https://uhpress.hawaii.edu/title/the-epic-tale-of-hiiakaikapoliopele/">https://uhpress.hawaii.edu/title/the-epic-tale-of-hiiakaikapoliopele/</a></p><p><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-anchor-4">4</a></p><p>From the Chinese Communist Party, we can read an interpretation of dialectical thinking that is clearly rooted in Chinese cultural forms as well as Hegelian thought,</p><p><em>Chinese theory realizes the dialectical unity of “interpreting” and “adapting,” grounding the effort to build a new world in profound understanding, observance, and application of historical laws, thereby demonstrating the advanced nature of scientific theory. It also adheres to the dialectical unity of “borrowing” and “indigenization,” consciously fostering the growth of humanity’s intellectual heritage within the soil of Chinese civilization through a high degree of theoretical subjectivity. It is committed to the dialectical unity of “particularity” and “universality,” offering answers to global questions from the standpoint of China’s realities and responding to shared concerns through Chinese practice-establishing the universal value and world-historical significance of its theory through distinctive features. Furthermore, it upholds the dialectical unity of “upholding fundamental principles” and “breaking new ground,” opening an appropriate path for theoretical development by staying firmly rooted in Marxist positions, viewpoints, and methodologies while emancipating the mind and keeping pace with the times to produce ongoing theoretical innovations. Chinese theory elevates the idea of “China in theory” to the commanding heights of truth and morality, demonstrating immense spiritual power.</em></p><p><a href="http://marxism.cass.cn/en/marxist/202512/t20251203_5953711.shtml">http://marxism.cass.cn/en/marxist/202512/t20251203_5953711.shtml</a></p><p><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-anchor-5">5</a></p><p>While some people learned to develop cordage in an S or Z structure by twisting fibers in a single direction, much stronger cordage is created by countertwining.</p><p><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-anchor-6">6</a></p><p>I recently met a paniolo (Hawaiian cowboy) who described how he originally learned to braid a 4-strand rope, before eventually moving on to the standard 6-stranded rope. He told me of a local master who would regularly braid rope from 12 and then 24 strands of rawhide. <em>That fucka could braid</em>… he admired</p><p><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics#footnote-anchor-7">7</a></p><p>There are centuries-long contentions regarding the relationship between Engels’ later dialectical work and the concepts he and Marx created together. The question is something like, does Engels’ work on the Dialectics of Nature deviate into metaphysical and cosmological determinations that Marx intended only to describe as laws of social transformation? Without delving into the minutiae of it, I posit that the works of Marx and Engels are indeed coherent and unified and also delve into the mystical/teleological — and this is precisely how we get it in conversation with other historical dialectical human perspectives.</p><p>It is reasonable any theory of the laws or mechanics of one part of reality should ultimately expand to try to include more and more of the totality. All scientific, social, and metaphysical discoveries will explore their relationships to a broadening field over time. And all will encounter their limits. This is part of how something becomes a more comprehensive worldview — indeed what we might call a Way — and also how it discovers its limits and its needs for growth and development. There are always edges encountered that do not fit the framework, the maths, and thus new, deeper, laws are discovered and developed and applied. In true dialectical fashion, these new laws are not necessarily a denial of the original laws but point to the fact that at certain levels of reality other laws must be at play — which may or may not cross a threshold of scale — and only by understanding these do we come to be able to approximate a total understanding of reality. The current irreconcilability of quantum and classical physics is a perfect example.</p><p>Engels’ development and expansion of his and Marx’s work does indeed tread into territory and positions that may appear to be at odds with their original “scientific” thinking but nevertheless expresses and clarifies contradictions at the heart of their work and, for our purposes here, lands it squarely into the realm of other human dialectical frameworks — from which we can then begin to understand their relationships.</p><p>It is precisely by the inclusion of Engels’ Dialectics of Nature that we begin to reveal the hidden teleology of Marx’s work (e.g., the historical inevitability of proletarian revolution) and, indeed, the mystical (e.g., the money form as the material transubstantiation of surplus labor power). While this may feel like a betrayal of the scientific socialism in which they insisted, it is also what puts Dialectical and Historical Materialism on the same footing as so many other Ways: a legitimate and powerful framework for understanding the social totality, even if inevitably, naturally, and inherently limited.</p><p>As with other Ways, it is best to see DHM as a unique frame of reference, a perspective, an analytical process which if rigorously followed allows us to see social reality, human reality, natural reality, etc in a very unique way and important because of the certain lens we are viewing it through. This view would not be clear with another lens, and points to something real — particularly if our interest lies in the goal of revolutionary human emancipation. At the same time, it must be recognized that other views also show something real, offer valuable and unique insights, etc. — and for a variety of goals and rooted in various concrete historical realities. Its truth may not necessarily be exclusive, but that doesn’t make it unreal.</p><p>We all want to be able to say, “this is how things work” and feel like the mechanics of things are coherent across scales, time, and space. But human exploration and investigation of various systems at different levels reveal other laws, sometimes contradictory. This is what allows Dialectical and Historical Materialism to be consider “a way” and therefore can be in conversation with other “ways” — in dialectical terms.</p><p>[8] There are centuries-long contentions regarding the relationship between Engels’ later dialectical work and the concepts he and Marx created together. The question is something like, does Engels’ work on the Dialectics of Nature deviate into metaphysical and cosmological determinations that Marx intended only to describe as laws of social transformation? Without delving into the minutiae of it, I posit that the works of Marx and Engels are indeed coherent and unified and also delve into the mystical/teleological — and this is precisely how we get it in conversation with other historical dialectical human perspectives.</p><p>It is reasonable any theory of the laws or mechanics of one part of reality should ultimately expand to try to include more and more of the totality. All scientific, social, and metaphysical discoveries will explore their relationships to a broadening field over time. And all will encounter their limits. This is part of how something becomes a more comprehensive worldview — indeed what we might call a Way — and also how it discovers its limits and its needs for growth and development. There are always edges encountered that do not fit the framework, the maths, and thus new, deeper, laws are discovered and developed and applied. In true dialectical fashion, these new laws are not necessarily a denial of the original laws but point to the fact that at certain levels of reality other laws must be at play — which may or may not cross a threshold of scale — and only by understanding these do we come to be able to approximate a total understanding of reality. The current irreconcilability of quantum and classical physics (and now beyond quantum) is a perfect example.</p><p>Engels’ development and expansion of his and Marx’s work does indeed tread into territory and positions that may appear to be at odds with their original “scientific” thinking but nevertheless expresses and clarifies contradictions at the heart of their work and, for our purposes here, lands it squarely into the realm of other human dialectical frameworks — from which we can then begin to understand their relationships.</p><p>It is precisely by the inclusion of Engels’ Dialectics of Nature that we begin to reveal the hidden teleology of Marx’s work (e.g., the historical inevitability of proletarian revolution) and, indeed, the mystical (e.g., the money form as the material transubstantiation of surplus labor power). While this may feel like a betrayal of the scientific socialism in which they insisted, it is also what puts Dialectical and Historical Materialism on the same footing as so many other Ways: a legitimate and powerful framework for understanding the social totality, even if inevitably, naturally, and inherently limited.</p><p>As with other Ways, it is best to see DHM as a unique frame of reference, a perspective, an analytical process which if rigorously followed allows us to see social reality, human reality, natural reality, etc in a very unique way and important because of the certain lens we are viewing it through. This view would not be clear with another lens, and points to something real — particularly if our interest lies in the goal of revolutionary human emancipation. At the same time, it must be recognized that other views also show something real, offer valuable and unique insights, etc. — and for a variety of goals and rooted in various concrete historical realities. Its truth may not necessarily be exclusive, but that doesn’t make it unreal.</p><p>We all want to be able to say, “this is how things work” and feel like the mechanics of things are coherent across scales, time, and space. But human exploration and investigation of various systems at different levels reveal other laws, sometimes contradictory. This is what allows Dialectical and Historical Materialism to be consider “a way” and therefore can be in conversation with other “ways” — in dialectical terms.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-path-of-braided-dialectics"><em>https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com</em></a><em> on September 12, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6757a80daa7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Song of Braided Dialectics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/a-song-of-braided-dialectics-e7a53453589f?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e7a53453589f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dialectics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dhamma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Sep 2026 19:20:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-14T06:10:13.386Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*E-8YXTWhLpl47QjHNRT4Mg.png" /></figure><p><em>(The companion essay to this poem is— </em><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/a-path-of-braided-dialectics-f6757a80daa7"><em>A Path of Braided Dialectics</em></a><em>)</em></p><h3>I. The Dialectic</h3><p>Fibers culled</p><p>from plants of the land</p><p>and pulled into strands</p><p>Ancient hands split two bands</p><p>twisting to the left</p><p>while wrapping to the right</p><p>Over again and over</p><p>the plying chore</p><p>threads make a cord</p><p>the cord becomes tight</p><p>Strands merely twisted will tend to unwind</p><p>but wrapped in opposition</p><p>friction develops the bind -</p><p>unified by contradiction</p><p>Taut from inner tension</p><p>wisdom is seeded</p><p>a knot is not needed</p><p>cordage plyed from thinner threads</p><p>spun sunwise &amp; twisted widdershins</p><p>emerge as a dialectic:</p><p><em>▪ a unity of opposition</em></p><p><em>▪ a contradiction advancing through negation</em></p><p><em>▪ a change in quantity becoming a transformation in quality</em></p><p>Conflict at the core</p><p>creates the structure for something more</p><p>of fleeting filaments we ply these cords</p><p>crafting conditions for what’s in store</p><p>with our hands and our hearts</p><p>and in our world</p><p>There are no people</p><p>who didn’t learn this lesson</p><p>to thatch their huts and lash their vessels</p><p>and ponder</p><p>how daylight and night</p><p>relate to weakness and might</p><p>blindness and sight</p><p>blessing and blight</p><p>wrongness and right</p><p>and how to align our world</p><p>toward peace through this fight</p><p>and gain, at last</p><p>the prize in our sights</p><p>Contradiction is created by every advance</p><p>an instability, an imbalance, that inspires the dance</p><p>of dialectical negation, a counter-formation</p><p>not as erasure, but sublation</p><p>conflictual integration</p><p>that lifts and builds through dynamic relations -</p><p>contesting, preserving, incorporating,</p><p>developing the thread</p><p>of creation</p><p>The example from nature is plain -</p><p>in soil-sown grain</p><p>come sun, come rain</p><p>from the inner domain</p><p>seed sprouts scion</p><p>this sprig, a negation of seed</p><p>sublation in deed develops the weed</p><p>negated by the flower</p><p>and through the force of an inner power</p><p>the blossom expires but fruit then sires</p><p>hundreds of seeds</p><p>through all this negation</p><p>so much has changed</p><p>but something remains</p><p>preserved and perpetuated -</p><p>Affirmation in negation</p><p>Preservation in destruction</p><p>Hegel, Mao, Tinku, and Tao -</p><p>dialectical notions in motion</p><p>are world renowned</p><p>in nature and society</p><p>a process that’s hectic, often dyspeptic</p><p>analytic, strategic, and prophetic</p><p>not of static truths, abstract and eternal</p><p>but concrete realities of a world</p><p>and its turning</p><p>This self-movement of mind and matter</p><p>seems mad as a hatter</p><p>scattered and splattered</p><p>when unity is momentary</p><p>and conflict, complimentary</p><p>Not all duality is dialectical -</p><p>not every paradox or polarity, complementarity or disparity</p><p>pushes to overcome its central contrariety</p><p>Sometimes an act of philosophical heresy</p><p>is necessary to bring systems to parity</p><p><em>This is what we call braided dialectics</em></p><p>The Buddha’s Dhamma and Marx’s drama</p><p>can be brought into such a dialectical unity</p><p>which is to say, opposition</p><p>but instead of derision, something magnetic</p><p>between fusion and fission</p><p>diametrically and dialectically opposed</p><p>reveal a productive collision</p><p>How, in Buddhist terms, do we transpose negation?</p><p>look at first to the chain of relations</p><p>translated usually as “dependent origination”</p><p>simplified here in considered invitation…</p><p>At each of our senses</p><p>a fountain of change</p><p>arising and passing</p><p>pleasure and pain</p><p>no moment the same</p><p>each calling forth</p><p>a response of the brain</p><p>There is not a body</p><p>nor is there a mind</p><p>but a concatenation</p><p>that’s hard to unwind</p><p>of moments of mentality and materiality -</p><p>a co-conditioned ladder</p><p>of mind and matter</p><p>whose persistent sublation in rapidity</p><p>creates the sense of dimensionality -</p><p>of self, of the world</p><p>An external object</p><p>inspires a physical sensation,</p><p>a thought, a sound, a smell,</p><p>a taste, or sight and alights</p><p>the mind &amp; propels the way to</p><p>▪ cling or reject</p><p>▪ care and connect</p><p>▪ or observe, unperturbed, it’s passing away -</p><p>conditioning a new formation of mind or matter in its wake</p><p>Or consider the same vision</p><p>but from a different position:</p><p>The six sense-doors</p><p>(five of the body and one of the mind)</p><p>encounter concrete conditions — contact -</p><p>phenomena negated by mind’s ethereal emissions:</p><p>cognition, ignition, description, volition,</p><p>which, in their turn, foment further mind/matter nutrition</p><p>The bind of life, then,</p><p>a braid of six-sense-strands</p><p>not a metaphysical notion, but moments in motion</p><p>empirically observed, discretely discerned</p><p>for the trained and the brave -</p><p>concrete dialectics perceived as a wave</p><p>Of these strands</p><p>we braid our lives</p><p>and cannot deny</p><p>the tension that binds -</p><p>the dialectic that builds rather than merely unwinds</p><p>building nothing less</p><p>than the sense of Me</p><p>Moment by moment</p><p>Plying the thread</p><p>binding moments of body</p><p>to the heart, to the head</p><p>progress is possible but not inherent -</p><p>mostly we spin and wander</p><p>instead</p><p>The quality of a negation</p><p>conditions its effect</p><p>volition reflecting a factor in the action</p><p>that connects impulse to a traction</p><p>we can track to its to outcome</p><p>like a seed to a tree</p><p>or a spring to the sea</p><p>result is traced back</p><p>to its facts of foundation</p><p>whose inner and outer effects</p><p>form a dialectical unity</p><p>a complex relation -</p><p>called kamma or labor</p><p>where ownership of action</p><p>meets alienation</p><p>Reality is momentary</p><p>unstable fluctuation</p><p>in response</p><p>three flavors of negation</p><p>with which we braid our lives and relations,</p><p>our movements, our world,</p><p>our tribes, our nations:</p><p>Aiming for stability, we</p><p><em>▪ struggle and wrangle,</em></p><p><em>▪ or confront at love’s angle,</em></p><p><em>▪ or let it all go, release, and untangle</em></p><p>As life unfurls</p><p>we propel these tendencies onto the world -</p><p>the Warrior, the Healer, and the Sage</p><p>each has its place, its role on stage</p><p>The movement is frayed</p><p>and while we may each be committed</p><p>primarily to one of these Ways</p><p>which will ultimately work -</p><p>who can actually say?</p><p>Each of these paths aims toward its own goal</p><p>but braided together</p><p>they negatiate the road</p><p>The proposal here is merely to say</p><p>that all three play</p><p>a part in the work</p><p>that dawns the new day</p><p>And it is the relationship between each of these flows</p><p>that determines how, whether, and where</p><p>our power can grow…</p><h3>II. The Warrior</h3><p>Hardship arrives</p><p>pleasure departs</p><p>dreams are deferred</p><p>flooding the heart</p><p>Endless tides</p><p>relentless streams</p><p><em>Things are not how we want them to be</em></p><p>Joy arises,</p><p>in heart-throws singing</p><p>in moments of loss,</p><p>woes grow, clinging</p><p>Contacted with pain</p><p>despised but in vain</p><p>we try to attain</p><p>the beauty again</p><p>Protect what we love</p><p>reject what we hate</p><p>correct what is wrong</p><p>deflect what can wait</p><p>A dialectic in opposition:</p><p>we wrestle with reality</p><p>to make it how we want to be</p><p>Moments are born, live, and cease</p><p>tension, release</p><p>tension, release</p><p>propelled and propelling</p><p>compelling, unceased</p><p>What is threatened, lost, or harmed</p><p>we defend and protect</p><p>trying to retain or reclaim what remains</p><p>and reject, resist, destroy, defame</p><p>what we’ve named as the cause and source of our pain</p><p>It’s not crazy</p><p>but the outcome is hazy</p><p>and follows the law -</p><p>the gnashing of teeth, the flashing claws -</p><p>the sound of inevitability</p><p>The current of history</p><p>strumming this song</p><p>the momentum of moments pulsing along</p><p>tangling the tangle</p><p>netting the throngs</p><p>Confront, control, attain, destroy,</p><p>provoking a propulsion of pain, not joy</p><p>deny, defend, lament, foment, dement, repent</p><p>the tit for tat for this and that</p><p>the drama of kamma</p><p>It’s true, of course -</p><p>They keep the good for themselves</p><p>and share only the bad</p><p>so how can we judge</p><p>the militant lad?</p><p>Sometimes we’ve gotta fight</p><p>go out in the night</p><p>and defend what is right</p><p>We need to push back</p><p>as a matter of fact</p><p>to defend and attack -</p><p>an incredible force is needed</p><p>to knock a train off its tracks</p><p>and find our way forward</p><p>with a different tack</p><p>Proceeding meekly from a legal basis</p><p>good-gracious</p><p>results feebly in social stasis</p><p>but when the state abandons its own laws</p><p>and about-faces</p><p>it has itself entered the revolutionary races</p><p>must we not respond</p><p>with appropriate paces?</p><p>The revolution</p><p>will not have perfect manners -</p><p>there will be fires in the streets</p><p>and fire-spangled banners</p><p>to expect otherwise</p><p>is the oppression of scammers -</p><p>composure enforced by moralistic planners</p><p>guided by the reason</p><p>of petty-bourgeois handlers</p><p><em>Asi es la lucha -</em></p><p>just the way it is, how it all began</p><p>pushing and pulling, tugging and toiling</p><p>over and under and over again…</p><p>But stepping back, when we have a chance</p><p>do we actually see</p><p>advance in this dance?</p><p>In some ways, yes, we can trace a thread</p><p>of improvement through history</p><p>dialectically blistering</p><p>but to measure those dead</p><p>from progress is a mystery</p><p>Are we sure this is forward?</p><p>or just spinning the wheel of the endless negation?</p><p>plying the cord of volatile stagnation?</p><p>the predictable recompense</p><p>of action and its consequence?</p><p>Backlash dominant</p><p>cyclically prominent</p><p>samsara, the wandering</p><p>reinforces the obstinate</p><p>Replicating what we hate</p><p>perpetuating fate</p><p>trading pitted debate for what it conflates</p><p>this negation’s commitment to conflagration</p><p>whose principle sublation is:</p><p>me, the Self</p><p>Yes, every temple has lions at the gates</p><p>but don’t confuse violence</p><p>with what inside us awaits</p><p>to flourish</p><p>Anger was surely born as care</p><p>about a pain it couldn’t bear</p><p>and found within the warmth a flare</p><p>that bitter sharpened talon’s tear</p><p>Violence</p><p>is understandable</p><p>but what it provokes</p><p>is rarely what’s planned -</p><p>unmanageable and undependable</p><p>when rage’s flames are fanned</p><p>Pain, inevitable as rain</p><p>rarely befalls the rich</p><p>as much as the poor</p><p>unleashed for sure</p><p>in the misery of war</p><p>Not all restriction is oppression</p><p>nor liberty a blessing</p><p>but if what we defend in the end is betrayed</p><p>destroying the goodness we are trying to save</p><p>then with violence let’s not be thrilled</p><p>and the eternal wound</p><p>of a hand that has killed</p><p>A serious question</p><p>to get under one’s skin -</p><p>do we really want power enough to win?</p><p>any answer</p><p>should make our head spin</p><p>Not all authority is authoritarian</p><p>but suppression of evil</p><p>itself can cause sin</p><p>or rather than sin -</p><p>let’s say moral consequence</p><p>Resolute and seeing red</p><p>in cycles</p><p>like the menses we know</p><p>revolution will never come about</p><p>by consensus</p><p>ideological incontinence</p><p>or spiritual providence</p><p>but beware</p><p>wantonness in dominance -</p><p>Consciousness of pompousness and</p><p>cognizant of the commonness of malfeasance</p><p>in the common sense of the populous</p><p>inspires ominous confidence</p><h3>III. The Healer</h3><p>The propulsive convulsive</p><p>instability of life</p><p>does not ensure</p><p>the inevitability of strife</p><p>Joined with pain, separated from pleasure</p><p>with compassion</p><p>gladness, not madness</p><p>can be the moment’s measure</p><p>Toward pain, this warm negation</p><p>is the treasure for those who seek</p><p>and those who train against stagnation — relief</p><p>as a parched desert, blessed by rain</p><p>Each hectic moment, if met with love</p><p>effects a dialectic</p><p>that rises above -</p><p>cutting new grooves in the path of the heart</p><p>practiced in earnest, in fits and starts</p><p>after years as method, love becomes art</p><p>Our ancestors strained</p><p>to be freed in vain</p><p>we heal the wounds</p><p>of generations of pain</p><p>Superseding the need to entrench in hate</p><p>release the bait</p><p>unclenched from greed</p><p>from its stench, the mind soars</p><p>freed</p><p>We hold some near</p><p>and reject many others</p><p>though deep down we know</p><p>we’re all sisters and brothers</p><p>it is natural for care to be shared</p><p>we’d all want to be smothered</p><p>in love’s warm glow</p><p>if we all had our druthers</p><p>Start with the easy</p><p>unconcerned with the enemy</p><p>love will pervade when we let it be</p><p>not an invasion</p><p>but an invitation, an accompanying</p><p>the dignity of composure</p><p>the domination of friendliness</p><p>Commitment to morality is merely discipline</p><p>comrades of integrity inspire us to listen in</p><p>and make us wonder</p><p><em>Do we need to hit to win?</em></p><p>Or is there something deep within</p><p>can transform the heart</p><p>that’s gripped in sin?</p><p>(oops, sorry — there it is again)</p><p>The love supreme is here on earth</p><p>not bound to dreams</p><p>but in flesh, in dirt</p><p>When we abide in this pervasive love</p><p>reclaiming our humanity</p><p>in culture, music, art -</p><p>beauty in the face of the tragedy</p><p>can it be that culture, creativity</p><p>can cure the contradictions</p><p>and insanity?</p><p>Love is the medicine</p><p>but to let it win</p><p>you have to let it in</p><p>Love even the resistance to love</p><p>Love the opposite of love</p><p>Love through the tension</p><p>so that every moment of attention</p><p>in every direction</p><p>strengthens the flavor of tender connection</p><p>A drop of kindness toward the pain</p><p>slowly forms a gentle rain</p><p>until the mind like a hurricane</p><p>showers love the same</p><p>across mountains, valleys, coasts, and plains</p><p>Overcoming invective without being selective</p><p>enthralls with beauty, this holy perspective</p><p><em>Oh yes, it’s so lovely</em></p><p><em>but is it effective?</em></p><p>Is love alone sufficient for change?</p><p>If honest we sense it’s deficient</p><p>in some part of its range</p><p>How can that which is by nature ethereal</p><p>be concretized in the world</p><p>in a way that’s material?</p><p>Is love a social power sufficient on its own?</p><p>to topple a throne</p><p>and not get swayed by the voices of “reason”</p><p>to each in due time, to each in its season?</p><p>History bears a mystery there</p><p>and those we’ve esteemed</p><p>have secrets they bear</p><p>and sometimes for shame</p><p>are unwilling to share</p><p>While anger’s dialectic is dependably cyclical</p><p>the outcome of love is hardly predictable</p><p>this negation whose sublation is oneness of mind</p><p>can’t stop crime</p><p>can’t protect a life from the strife of its time</p><p>If we cling to care</p><p>because we can’t bear the pain</p><p>we are prisoners of oneness</p><p>oppressed by its reign -</p><p>and oppressing the same</p><p>The longing for unity</p><p>is the desire for stability</p><p>in a world always changing</p><p>we see love’s fragility</p><p>We can use concentration</p><p>to suppress the sensation of separation</p><p>but if duality seems a threat</p><p>our lion’s roar will never mature</p><p>from a kitten’s purr</p><p>careful, instead, and always ensure</p><p>that good’s allure</p><p>not make us haughty, righteous, oversure</p><p>The world, we know, hates a thing too pure…</p><p>Understand the weight of violence -</p><p>smudge it but don’t judge it</p><p>or begrudge those who see no alternative</p><p>from its drudgery</p><p>The world is in turmoil</p><p>the pain can be repressed</p><p>and in relief we are blessed</p><p>in a wound firmly dressed</p><p>But overriding pain doesn’t unbind</p><p>we can’t understand hate</p><p>by just being kind</p><p>Anger and anguish must be fathomed, not hidden</p><p>avoided, denied, contained, overridden</p><p>The dictatorship of love has a shadow -</p><p>without a relationship to anguish</p><p>we grow powerful, not wise</p><p>if the complexity of the vexity is not allowed to rise</p><p>Above a discomfort with duality</p><p>where merging and oneness</p><p>provide a rationality</p><p>for the denial of laws of consequence</p><p>and causality</p><p>Too high</p><p>disconnected from reality</p><p>with body and society transcended</p><p>the material, at times, is left unattended</p><p>the world, vulnerable in fact, undefended</p><p>Weakened by our need to heal</p><p>we can’t ignore the pain of what’s real</p><p>and feel the anger sometimes needed</p><p>to change the dynamics and turn the wheel</p><p>Love can also through contrast bring clarity</p><p>sharpen the disparity</p><p>reveal the evil that has long been concealed, purifying the field</p><p>releasing toxins — cancerous, congealed</p><p>but it’s not pretty</p><p>And love is still involved in increase and decrease</p><p>more and less, worse and best</p><p>it can’t reach the peace</p><p>of a deeper release</p><p>which only comes through wisdom…</p><p>Love and light cannot mend</p><p>the brokenness at the heart</p><p>of everything</p><h3>IV. The Sage</h3><p>Finally, then,</p><p>the path of peace</p><p>stable, secluded, matured in release</p><p>According to conditions</p><p>things come and go</p><p>what seemed solid, dust</p><p>what was stuck, flows</p><p>A peace unbound</p><p>to fluctuation</p><p>relief is found</p><p>in cessation’s ground</p><p>surcease from the round</p><p>through contemplation -</p><p>perpetuation stopped in meditation</p><p>From what was gained</p><p>sprang grief</p><p>what we lost</p><p>had us bound</p><p>losing nothing and no one harmed</p><p>clinging nowhere -</p><p>sight nor sound, heaven nor ground</p><p>relief abounds</p><p>security found</p><p>Clinging abandoned</p><p>hatred appeased</p><p>untethered, free</p><p>the heart unravels</p><p>the weave</p><p>in release -</p><p>the dialectics of disenchantment</p><p>From every angle, disentangled</p><p>the negation-sublation of peace</p><p>overcomes the dialectic</p><p>entirely, with no remainder</p><p>No investment, or expectation</p><p>in the future or of the past</p><p>finding no allure in what can’t last</p><p>with absolute trust</p><p>forsaking the rust</p><p>no more stake in the dust</p><p>of that which can never satisfy</p><p>Seeing the danger</p><p>of a mind attached, polluted</p><p>sorrows and their cause</p><p>dispatched, uprooted</p><p>People seek stability</p><p>in what is destined to fail</p><p>security in what’s frail</p><p>refuge</p><p>in what is engulfed in flames</p><p>Not to cling or reject</p><p>nor self-project</p><p>in every moment</p><p>serene respect</p><p>is all that’s left</p><p>Discerned without blame</p><p>that all sides appear the same</p><p>releases the pressure</p><p>oppressing the brain</p><p>the sage finds their way</p><p>out of the game</p><p>Acceptance of the truth</p><p>of the way things are</p><p>is not condoning</p><p>but understanding the nature</p><p>of action and its consequence</p><p>Laying down weapons and tools</p><p>wanting no part in the power</p><p>gained by fools</p><p>peace is a jewel</p><p>as a rule -</p><p>without value</p><p>How true?</p><p>This kind of winning</p><p>of an arahant’s grinning</p><p>will never be defended</p><p>by the world and its spinning</p><p>And why should it?</p><p>You can’t relinquish your role</p><p>and its robes</p><p>and hope to be called back</p><p>to headline the show</p><p>The dialectic of unraveling</p><p>unbowed in patience</p><p>negation of negation</p><p>should not be expected — or allowed</p><p>to lead the operation</p><p>You can’t deny</p><p>what you’ve seen with your eyes</p><p>but don’t be surprised</p><p>when the swine doesn’t fly</p><p>the law of the earth</p><p>holds no sway in the sky</p><p>in the realm of the social</p><p>these rules don’t apply</p><p>Don’t presume to assume</p><p>that spiritual liberation</p><p>has anything to offer</p><p>the world’s conflagrations</p><p>This flavor of freedom</p><p>doesn’t translate at scale</p><p>the needs of the plankton</p><p>oppose the needs of the whale</p><p>their bondage is built</p><p>in a reciprocal jail</p><p>To confuse revolution</p><p>with enlightenment</p><p>is dangerous, deranged</p><p>and to insist on moral perfection</p><p>in radical action</p><p>is equally insane</p><p>What cares the world</p><p>about the peace of your absence?</p><p>Mind doesn’t matter</p><p>and matter doesn’t mind</p><p>don’t confuse the two</p><p>as one of a kind</p><p>Teachers and cooks</p><p>have different tools in their drawers</p><p>hunting and farming</p><p>don’t obey by the same laws</p><p>why should the rules of the world</p><p>be beholden to yours?</p><p>Generating no tension</p><p>professing no mission</p><p>the sage is of no use</p><p>to worldly ambitions</p><p>The unbound has no sound</p><p>invisible, it’s so clear</p><p>it can expect no mirror</p><p>in a world trained only to hear</p><p>the harmonies of love</p><p>and dissonances of fear</p><p>It is in this way, useless</p><p>to the movement -</p><p>which only through tension can sing -</p><p>except, perhaps</p><p>in the perspective it brings</p><p>The proper relation</p><p>of spiritual revelation</p><p>to social liberation</p><p>is not coherent integration</p><p>but dialectical conversation</p><p>Wisdom is real</p><p>and what it reveals</p><p>can have value to those</p><p>who wield sword and shield -</p><p>the warriors and healers out in the field</p><p>Action without attachment</p><p>dedication without identification</p><p>motivation of clarity beyond anger</p><p>are concepts to which wisdom is no stranger</p><p>useful as well to those knee-deep in the danger</p><p>Dialecticians of old</p><p>confused progress of thought</p><p>with advancement in mind</p><p>but sweet fruit is not wrought</p><p>by shining the rind</p><p>Tense or tranquil</p><p>spiteful or kind</p><p>the quality of attention</p><p>prevents rot from inside</p><p>Reliance on “science”</p><p>in defiance of insight</p><p>uses unpliant compliance</p><p>to determine what is right -</p><p>brittle and bitter</p><p>Peace doesn’t come</p><p>by averting one’s gaze -</p><p>dazed in the haze</p><p>of self-absorbed rays</p><p>but by sitting unphased</p><p>in the heart of the blaze</p><p>and working through the maze</p><p>of a mind that is crazed</p><p>as the structure of self</p><p>in stages</p><p>is razed</p><p>It is a long, scary path</p><p>this road to humanity</p><p>inviting profanity</p><p>The uprooting of vanity</p><p>is a risk to one’s sanity</p><p>But in fulfillment</p><p>their presence is a sanctuary, a relief</p><p>one thus gone, outside of itself</p><p>beyond hope and grief</p><p>they offer a vision so vast</p><p>of the vexing complexity</p><p>of the net that’s been cast -</p><p>even if this sharing of peace</p><p>may be subtle and brief</p><p>Letting go</p><p>of wrestling and wrangling</p><p>the sage’s cord is left unraveled</p><p>dangling</p><p>but braided in with other strands</p><p>it prevents them from tangling</p><p>and provides a little slack</p><p>to keep it from strangling…</p><h3>V. The Braid</h3><p>Many insist</p><p>these threads are exclusive</p><p>but in history and heart</p><p>evidence is elusive</p><p>Instead of seeing the others</p><p>as intrusive or diffusive</p><p>each way may benefit</p><p>from an approach more inclusive</p><p>Life indeed can be deemed</p><p>as a perpetually constructed</p><p>braid of these:</p><p><em>▪ fighting with reality to make it how we want it to be</em></p><p><em>▪ love negating hate, appreciation superseding greed</em></p><p><em>▪ unbinding our hearts from enchantment in release</em></p><p>Is each not, in its own way, credible</p><p>in the world? Inevitable, even</p><p>that dialectics from these</p><p>three perspectives unfurl?</p><p>Each has its weakness</p><p>as an individual path</p><p>that limit its strength</p><p>and capacity to grasp</p><p>But braided together</p><p>a new form emerges</p><p>contradictions persist</p><p>the tension of urges</p><p>a compensatory twist</p><p>of plaiting that purges</p><p>purifies and clarifies</p><p>as development surges</p><p>Three dialectical dynamics at play</p><p>braided together</p><p>composing the way</p><p>physical reality and mental reaction</p><p>of contraction, supersession, and unbinding</p><p>creating the scaffolding, providing the traction</p><p>of a braided totality</p><p>How could we expect the world’s riddle to be solved</p><p>when we ourselves remain unresolved?</p><p>But our contradictions need not be absolved — just developed</p><p>by deciding which threads we exclude</p><p>and which we envelope</p><p>This is not a call for oneness!</p><p>or even coherence</p><p>but perseverance</p><p>beyond accord and discord</p><p>or naive adherence</p><p>The exercise of power</p><p>requires structures of unity</p><p>conditional hierarchies</p><p>if not towers of impunity</p><p>but wedded to solidity</p><p>is dependence on morbidity</p><p>and grasping for stability</p><p>weakens our ability</p><p>The plateau of identity</p><p>is a fantasy security</p><p>The world isn’t stable</p><p>nor could it be</p><p>nor should it be</p><p>so how would we?</p><p>The braided dialectic</p><p>doesn’t seek the extinction of distinction</p><p>or peace between factions</p><p>but to advance our action</p><p>through release and contraction</p><p>Tension provides the structure</p><p>for the development of all and each</p><p>as a vine on the wall</p><p>quickly grows beyond reach</p><p>No need to agree</p><p>but with relational rigor</p><p>patience and vigor</p><p>bonded in tension</p><p>we braid something bigger -</p><p>moving forward, building power, and clarity</p><p>Our disparity is, in fact, an illusion</p><p>historically these threads always arise</p><p>in contradictory unison</p><p>Purifying and strengthening each other</p><p>these strands create bands</p><p>that are useful in ways</p><p>as from it cordage, ropes, nets,</p><p>leis, and baskets are made</p><p>Don’t rush to ply</p><p>or weave</p><p>or braid</p><p>take the time with the raw materials</p><p>getting them straight</p><p>firmly coherent in our structure within</p><p>so much work happens</p><p>before the braiding begins</p><p>Material must be processed</p><p>before it is plied</p><p>prepared and purified</p><p>sorted, softened, straightened, and cured</p><p>made sound and pliable,</p><p>worthy, assured</p><p>Scraping, beating, laughing, crying</p><p>cleaning, washing, rinsing, drying,</p><p>prepping, plying, straining, sighing</p><p>Dialectically deficient</p><p>some integration will remain insufficient -</p><p>diverting our band into a contrary braid</p><p>leaving our structure distorted, contorted</p><p>knotted and frayed</p><p>Collected, protected</p><p>and carefully inspected</p><p>in the end, many fibers will be rejected</p><p>whole currents must be corrected or deflected -</p><p>the integrity of the aim must be respected</p><p>We need just enough tension</p><p>to build structure but not break</p><p>develop strength but not rigidity</p><p>pliability without feebleness</p><p>flexibility without infidelity</p><p>Productive contradiction</p><p>propels forward motion</p><p>providing defense, at times</p><p>against poisoned implosion</p><p>Iron without alloys</p><p>is brittle when battered</p><p>overdiluted the blade won’t hold its edge</p><p>against the sedge</p><p>when it matters</p><p>There are those that fight</p><p>and those that heal</p><p>and those whose faith in the real</p><p>is beyond our capacity</p><p>without training to feel</p><p>We need warriors in the battlefields</p><p>Healers in the hospitals</p><p>Sages in the caves</p><p>in its friction with each</p><p>the other is saved</p><p>The warrior -</p><p>soothed by the healer</p><p>balanced by the sage</p><p>is guided by vision</p><p>and not merely by rage</p><p>The healer -</p><p>purified by the wise</p><p>grounded by the fighter</p><p>doesn’t avoid pain</p><p>by believing they’re lighter</p><p>The sage -</p><p>chastened by the warrior</p><p>softened by the healer</p><p>remains beholden to the world</p><p>and all of its theater</p><p>The warrior’s power</p><p>is the self grown stronger -</p><p>The healer’s strength</p><p>is oneness and rapture -</p><p>The sage’s release</p><p>is nibbana -</p><p>the negation of negation</p><p>unbound and uncaptured</p><p>We long for resolution</p><p>through love, release, or revolution</p><p>but can focus too much</p><p>on abstract concepts</p><p>of distant solutions</p><p>over the dialectical truth</p><p>of what’s facing us now</p><p>We have our suspicions -</p><p>skeptical of critical errors and omissions</p><p>but can we be humble enough</p><p>to pursue our ambitions</p><p>without withering derision</p><p>toward comrades</p><p>whose decisions are driven</p><p>by a different angle</p><p>of the vision of the overarching mission?</p><p>And while critique and conflict</p><p>can surely expand</p><p>can we not also try to understand?</p><p>rather than demean the rest of our band -</p><p>or deny our own conflicting internal strands?</p><p>The right, by the way, has always intuited</p><p>that power can be built on a platform that’s fluid</p><p>Firm in our principles</p><p>but flexible in our tactics</p><p>determined in strategy</p><p>while learning to adapt it</p><p>Rejecting without ejecting</p><p>appreciating harmony but not needing it</p><p>allowing uncertainty but not feeding it</p><p>accepting division but not breeding it</p><p>with patience and urgency</p><p>dedicated to the digestion</p><p>of meta movement metabolism</p><p>through means unseen</p><p>or as yet, unrevealed -</p><p>we are learning</p><p>Braiding is a social art</p><p>rigorous correspondence</p><p>to weave in tension without falling apart</p><p>requires relationships of trust</p><p>as the horse follows the cart</p><p>And it is reflected</p><p>in our own inner complexities -</p><p>in the vexity</p><p>between who we expect to be</p><p>and who we project we be</p><p>but with some braided flexity</p><p>the tension can actually be</p><p>the nexus of release -</p><p>right next to peace</p><p>We are the sheriffs of our own evictions</p><p>thinking we could live without contradictions</p><p>when it’s history’s own concrete conditions</p><p>that force our lives into conflicting convictions</p><p>Instead, the pressure of these places</p><p>can be a fulcrum for growth</p><p>spring-load the tension, advancing them both</p><p>common good and personal liberty</p><p>inspired rebellion and retired stability</p><p>moral conviction and ethical agility</p><p>dialectical conflict is not fragility</p><p>and if diligently developed</p><p>is a strength that can structure</p><p>the movement’s ability</p><p>A braid, of course</p><p>is not all tension and friction -</p><p>it’s tender and firm</p><p>made with loving conviction</p><p>an expression of beauty revealed</p><p>through caring precision</p><p>a vision rehearsed from ancient traditions</p><p>If we were told the ways</p><p>of the olden days</p><p>behold and praise -</p><p>Culture!</p><p>The way we do</p><p>was deduced</p><p>the patterns repeated</p><p>response to concrete conditions</p><p>of how we produced</p><p>Culture is practiced</p><p>and not automatic</p><p>not static</p><p>or fixed onto a past</p><p>that we hope one day to return to at last</p><p>that time is gone, if it ever existed</p><p>beware of a fantasy projection onto history</p><p>as we’d wished it</p><p>How do these ways apply</p><p>to our present conditions</p><p>and help us weave our way through</p><p>its derisions and schisms?</p><p>This is how we keep culture</p><p>relevant and living</p><p>growing and giving</p><p>The complex mystery</p><p>of internal external</p><p>feels like a paradox</p><p>as infernal and eternal as</p><p>nocturnal diurnal</p><p>individual collective</p><p>force and faith</p><p>method and attitude</p><p>alienation and gratitude</p><p>past present future</p><p>birth life death -</p><p>and we advance the contradictions</p><p>Our inner culture</p><p>is the ceaseless terrain of learning -</p><p>yearning for solid views we lose</p><p>the churning role of each of the pieces</p><p>the burning heart that seeks to fight</p><p>and love and then</p><p>in peace</p><p>releases</p><p>And so braided dialectics</p><p>will surpass all its skeptics</p><p>not trapped by dogmatic correctives</p><p>reflective in its selective objectives -</p><p>expective of opposition</p><p>The power of our path</p><p>can’t be measured by math</p><p>in abstraction</p><p>but only gains traction</p><p>through concrete action</p><p>reflection and reaction</p><p>loving and rigorous</p><p>Taking up the task</p><p>of braiding at last</p><p>we work our way forward -</p><p>outward, inward</p><p>near, far</p><p>luchar, amar, notar</p><p>soltar</p><p>superar</p><p>¡Sublevar!</p><p>☆</p><p>Cover image based on the ﬁlm poster “Y La Noche Se Hizo Arcoiris”by Ñiko, 1979. Used with permission.</p><p>See more at: ñiko.com</p><p>☆</p><p>☆</p><p>Cover image based on the ﬁlm poster “Y La Noche Se Hizo Arcoiris”by Ñiko, 1979. Used with permission.</p><p>See more at: ñiko.com</p><p>☆</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com/p/a-song-of-braided-dialectics?r=eqkg2"><em>https://decorvaletudo271547.substack.com</em></a><em> on September 11, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e7a53453589f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Work:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/on-work-5a265d90693a?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a265d90693a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[woodworking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[craft]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Jul 2024 12:56:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-15T15:38:47.837Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Action, Ownership, Culture, and Karma</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*m5G0rFs12Fwk19Jub1MfKw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>Listen to learn it,</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Learn it to tell it,</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Tell it with love…</em></strong></p><p>Garnet ribbons of apple peel slid from my grandmother’s knobbed knuckles, forming a sweet, soft pillow in the kitchen sink. Beside them, the juicy trimmings from my own efforts plopped audibly. Alerted by the sound, my grandmother plucked up my refuse, knife in hand, and pushed it toward my eyes. The brown spots and blue veins of her nearly translucent hands amplified my sense of her concern. <em>You’re cutting too much apple,</em> she said worriedly, tossing my rejected work back into the sink. <em>Here</em>,<em> </em>she recomposed her patience<em>, Watch.</em> She proceeded to slice off the paper-thin peel of an entire apple in a single slow but steady stroke. Raised in a frugal Mennonite community in rural Ohio, her gesture revealed a precision one might mindlessly call “mechanical,” but that in such a word we would lose the recognition of the firm but pliant intuition of the bones of her hands, the archetypal training of her muscles, and the dexterous clarity of her mind.</p><p>Memory merges this moment messily with a resonant evening peeling potatoes with my other grandmother, from Ecuador. In both instances the skill of their knifework humbled me. Certain that one vital factor must have been the relative sharpness of our tools, both times I checked — only to find their knives quite duller than mine.</p><p>As I got older, my memories were fascinated less with their skill and more by the sense of satisfaction with that skill that each of them held and, ultimately, with the seriousness of the home economy which they defended each time they applied pressure to the blade. While they took pride in their work, these skills were no project of vanity. The process was satisfying, but everything was always at stake.</p><p>The people of Haida Gwaii have an old saying, “life is as sharp as a knife.” My grandmothers knew that the whole world was balanced on the tip of that blade and so acted with appropriate severity and grace.</p><p><strong><em>Wind makes corporal the air</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>What once was not, now is there</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Deeds wrought with spite or birthed in care</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Who at last will be their heir?</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aCA8dOnWUKAj7nAoAK1nbg.jpeg" /></figure><p>When I heard the news one day that a nephew would be born, I pruned a limb from an apple tree in my mother’s yard and from it carved a twisted caramel spoon<em>.</em></p><p>After roughing out the shape with an axe, I soaked the wood in water to keep it from cracking. Even after a hundred years sitting in the dust, a piece of wood will draw and release moisture through its tense fibers, the inner mechanism of circulation and life not yet released, perhaps, from its inclination toward hope, or duty of self-production. When the spoon was close to finished, I dried it out over a period of a few days — in an out of plastic bags — while finalizing the details of the curves. Once bone-dry, I sanded it down and replaced the water with walnut oil: massaging it in and using the wood’s natural longing to <em>cure</em> it of its life-spasms. No longer drawing water in, nor pushing it out, the oil will instead hold back, for a time, the cracks, fissures, and pressures of decay.</p><p>It is a process I learned from a teacher, who had learned it from his, who had given him a spoon made from a Maine pear tree, grown from a cutting of a tree at Ghandi’s Sabarmati ashram in India. It was a lineage of labor and dignity that he freely passed onto me.</p><p>My spoon was certainly not stamped from a machine. There is evidence of me throughout it — cuts, contours, decisions made coherently, hesitantly, absent-mindedly, too early, too late. Beautiful and imperfect. Is there a <em>me-ness </em>held within it? Does it <em>contain</em> me as kerosine contains the sun? As a dollar contains the labor power of a million aggregated moments of human effort? I’m not really sure. Not without another mind to mend that meaning, I don’t think. Where would the me in it live? Is it directly perceivable? Is it smoothed away by sandpaper or by use? It seems to me that there is no essence within it. Just as there is no essence within me to share if I had wanted. If it could be shared, would it truly be an essence? And yet, there is something about it that is different — perhaps a hard to pinpoint element of human labor.</p><p>Any time I finish a spoon, I hold it before me, examining. I feel proud, accomplished, but also braced for disappointment. Will it be appreciated? Loved? Will it be used? If so, will it be cared for? In what drawer or on what shelf will it gather dust? Sometimes I think of these objects as artifacts from a culture that does not yet exist and which will crumble long before it does. The oil is not yet hardened and the shadow of distance between myself and this creation is already stretching long. I think of Marx, fascinated by the foreignness of the products of our labor, how they stand outside of us, distant: opposed to us.</p><blockquote>The alienation of the worker in his product means not only that his labor becomes an object, an external existence, but that it exists outside him, independently, as something alien to him, and that it becomes a power of his own confronting him; it means that the life which he has conferred on the object confronts him as something hostile and alien.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Karl Marx, Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844</blockquote><p>This spoon in my hand doesn’t feel particularly hostile — but that would be hard for any spoon. (Though the Mayan Popul Vuh tells of a time during the last epoch where the kitchen utensils rose up violently against their human owners — for lack of proper care). Whatever tensions I may feel with my spoon are largely muted by the feeling of control I have over it. It is a sense of my future plan to conjure good feeling for myself and for another by gifting this spoon to my nephew. I expect some gladness in another’s enjoyment of it. Perhaps even a return of gratitude, of praise. This is all rooted in the sense that I own it and so can exert some influence over its future ability to nourish me back — whether materially or mentally.</p><p>The sense of ownership is one thing. But the experience of ownership is not necessarily about the relationship between people and things. It is about <em>the relationship between people in regard to things</em>.</p><p>Did my grandmother’s apple pie feel like it was hers? With us, she certainly exerted authority over who was to partake in its sweetness. But that was an authority and expectation granted by the fabric of our social world. She learned to make pies as a young woman, employed as a domestic worker for a family who required she bake a pie every day. In that case, it was the sweet-toothed family — probably the father — who we would say <em>owned</em> the daily pie, since he paid for her labor to produce it.</p><p>What responsibility to, what authority over do we have with an object or idea, a slice of pie, a wooden spoon, a piece of land, a water wheel, a speech, a song? Can we understand and reimagine these things without reimagining ourselves — without bringing our own sense of me and mine-ness under consideration?</p><p><strong><em>Watch me to weave it</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Weave it and wear it</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Wear it and wonder…</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fuTUToGK8i9hke38Q0L-yw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Somewhere in the decaying colonial grandeur of Old San Juan, Puerto Rico, there may still be a mediocre but self-important restaurant where I once worked as a waiter. On a street named for a saint, beside a convent-turned-hotel, I rehearsed the role of fleeting retainer to momentary masters who would arrive and depart with the cruiseships. One night I was granted the responsibility of serving the hotel owner and his sparkling entourage.</p><p>As someone thirsty for recognition but also invisibility — and knowing what it meant for the security of my position — I did my best. When the long night eventually ground into a lower gear, the big table having now been split up and deserted by several other patrons, my manager approached me and warmly placed his hand on my shoulder. Smiling generously, he shook my hand. “Well done,” he affirmed, as if blessing me with the most reassuring compliment someone of my station could bear, “The owner told me you have a natural talent for serving.”</p><p>The flip side of my servile temperament is a rageful dignity that takes very little to spark aflame. In the presence of my boss, I suppressed the conflagration as best I could, resulting in psychic distortions that seemed to bend the universe around me. But afterwards, when given room to breathe, it consumed me for days. Yes, there was something about bringing people what they wanted, feeding them, attending to their wishes that felt pure, even beautiful. Yet the often careless and carefree disrespect of me by customers, and my own permissiveness of this for the sake of tips — was degrading. I had worked in kitchens before, as a low wage cook, where the exploitation was still obvious but somehow didn’t dig into and twist the cracks of my identity.</p><p>In the kitchen I was merely a worker that could swear and curse my station with ease. As a waiter, the adoption of performance of worthlessness was an aspect I could not long bear. Within a few weeks I quit my job and held myself firmly to finding a way forward in this life that allowed what goodness I could generate to be offered without restraint, but without participating in my own diminishment.</p><p>It turns out to be not such an easy task to avoid being integrated into these dynamics of human subjugation — and perhaps not even a heroic one. Marx long held the belief that resisting this process of proletarianization is regressive, and a sign of the untrustworthiness of the so-called petty-bourgeoisie. For him, it is only through mass proletarianization that workers come to realize their power against capital. The heroic — but much harder — choice is not to avoid our alienation, but to organize around it, confront it, and overthrow the entire system.</p><p>But me, like any number of petty-bourgeois radicals, for the past 25-or-so years since quitting that job in Puerto Rico I have tried my best to produce nothing of monetary value — for myself or anyone else. I have created quite a bit of value, I think, outside of that specific monetary form. I have done work, largely for non-profits, and much of it has been valued, but less and less of it has been — or could be — bought or sold. It has not been “productive labor” in Marx’s sense: labor which, through the appropriation of surplus value, produces capital for the owning class.</p><p><strong><em>Compose then profit, deposit, and save</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Repose in your coffin, decomposite in grave</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>In throws we can’t stop at the crest of a wave</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Suppose that we drop it and rest in a cave</em></strong></p><p>Respiring amid the stone-rimmed fields of central Massachusetts, the unacknowledged estate of a Buddhist retreat center hides amid the marshes and pastures. The surrounding forests have been largely restored from colonial era over-grazing, protected by extensive and expensive conservation efforts. Behind the thickets of mountain laurel and honeysuckle, mosquitos and ticks flourish in the bogs and bramble, and the morose stiffness of the puritanical past is yet to be fully allayed.</p><p>These days, I am a Buddhist teacher of a form of meditation called <em>vipassana</em>, and was for some years a welcome voice at this place. The Buddha was explicit that his teachings were to be given freely, not treated as commodities, so I offer my expression of them without cost and am supported only by any donations, or <em>dana</em>, that is offered to me. In my tradition, <em>dana</em> along with <em>sila </em>(ethical conduct), are considered the essential foundations of our <em>bhavana — </em>mind cultivation, sometimes translated as “mental culture.”</p><p>Because the sacred glow of this commitment to dana is so bright, it can obfuscate another angle of our working reality: that the entire programming of centers like this one are provided by people they don’t have to pay. In fact, these places have no responsibility to the teachers at all in terms of health care, retirement, long-term contracts, or housing — even though without our freely-offered labor they would have no program to offer and no reason to exist.</p><p>Monks and nuns in Southeast Asian meditation centers or monasteries are not paid either — but they are cared for, fed, clothed, and generally supported by their affiliated institutions. Many of us have no other means of livelihood and have very little leverage in terms of defining the conditions of our work beyond the presumed goodwill of our retainers. In our community, we are often honored as the scared holders of these ancient teachings and practices. But in our employment, we are gig workers — profoundly revered Uber drivers for the <em>chariot to nibbana</em>. It can feel like a rather distorted way of honoring the letter of the tradition while abandoning the spirit of it.</p><p>When the first westerners attempted to bring these practices and teachings back home, the dual action of their cultural and economic maneuvering was profound: on one hand, they quickly shed the monastic skin of our tradition, but rather than introduce a dynamic modern innovative structure, the organizational culture of many of these places remains essentially medieval: replete with a king and a queen, a royal court, and a peasant class of low-wage staff — with itinerant teachers operating in a poorly-defined proto-merchant middle area of these three. While unconscious and problematic, this feudal system still seems better than many of for-profit corporations who have ejected the foundational elements of the tradition entirely — including the Buddha himself — and have packaged and sold mindfulness as a pure commodity in the capitalist mode of production.</p><p>A few years ago, it became clear that the institution intended to re-package and resell the video recordings without our knowledge, our consent, or any agreement as to our compensation. When I questioned the integrity of this, I was simply told by the Executive Director, “Truly, everything about the online programming is different.” But this didn’t feel different at all. Rather, the product of my labor being stolen from me with a smile felt distinctly familiar — as did the rumbling in my spine, the heat in my heart, and the bending of spacetime around and within me.</p><p>Our team then accidentally became aware of a long-standing policy regarding our dana: if donations of under $800 intended for us came in “late” (over a week after the end of our program) the money was not given to us, but instead was integrated into another organizational fund — without notifying us or the donors. When I erupted in astonishment, the director again denied and avoided engagement.</p><p>I did not go along with it. Conflict ensued. At an impasse with the executive director, I reached out to the royal court of Guiding Teachers for intervention and received no response. After a harshly worded and emotional protest on my part, the director finally acquiesced and promised not to sell the videos our teachings. Eventually, with no other acknowledgement or path forward, I posted a frustrated and damning statement on social media.</p><p>And lo! The drowsy conclave jumped into action. A courier was swiftly sent from their chambers to inform me I was now under probation. If I wanted to teach there the coming year, I was not allowed to communicate directly with staff and if I had any perceived attitudinal infractions over the next few years — in any setting — I would not be welcome back.</p><p>I wrote a letter apologizing for the vehemence of my tone while also condemning the injustice of their actions. I informed them that I would easily and happily agree to their terms if they, 1. stopped stealing our dana; 2. agreed that teachers’ held the publishing rights to our recorded works; 3. began a collaborative process for developing equitable contracts with the teachers, and; 4. some process be put into place institutionally for precisely these kinds of conflicts.</p><p>Shifting from institutional directives to personal deflections, I was approached by a representative with whom they clearly imagined I would have natural allegiance with and sympathy for. I quickly realized that their purpose for contact was not for actual dialog, but merely to press me to agree to their terms without themselves committing to address any of mine. While privately I was told that the organization was moving forward with <em>all</em> of my recommendations, publicly I was offered stale refrains about the need for patience with a logistically complex and inherently slow process.</p><p>At one point in my life, I might have been amazed — even seduced — by the organizational switcheroo which uses institutional protocols to avoid responsibility for failed personal relationships, and then go and try to use personal relationships to evade institutional responsibility for failed organizational protocols. But at this point in my life, it just seemed dumb, so I decided to stop teaching there.</p><p>Several years before this incident, I had been trying to form some sort of union or guild among my colleagues — aware that we were vulnerable to this exact kind of dynamic. But for reasons any labor organizer would be familiar with, it didn’t amount to much more than a handful of decent conversations.</p><p>After 20 years of doing all I could to craft a livelihood that ducked out from under the dynamics of capitalist exploitation and alienation, I had been caught in the place in the very place I had taken refuge. The Buddeoisie had gotten rid of me.</p><p><strong><em>In the strain of thirst, a dream is created</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>A vision of a thought of an illusion, unsated</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Let loose the line and confusion’s abated…</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*wRThMxPozPJKWO06z0C4rA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Pali word <em>kamma</em> (Saskrit, <em>karma</em>) is understood by many people in the West to be a kind of mystical force of morality underpinning our lives and the universe. But in the dusty dictionaries of Theravada Buddhism, kamma is principally translated simply as “action,” “work,” “doing,” i.e. “labor” — activities which are not necessarily seen as distinct from the word’s more mystical implications. Volitional action generates future results, results that are experienced according to natural (sometimes obvious, sometimes incomprehensible) law. Our kamma is not merely our fate, but something we are actively responsible for generating.</p><p>It is a concept that does not firmly differentiate between a deed, its moral character, the doer, or the result. And while the word is most conventionally translated into English as “action,” it is not incorrect to translate it as “work.” For example, “kammakassa” is plowing, “kumbhakārakamma” is the work of a potter, while “pāpakamma” can refer to a bad deed, one who has done a bad deed, and/or the effect of a bad deed.</p><p>Using “work” for “kamma” we read,</p><blockquote>One becomes a thief by work (<em>kamma</em>).</blockquote><blockquote>by work one becomes a soldier.</blockquote><blockquote>One becomes a priest by work,</blockquote><blockquote>by work one becomes a king.</blockquote><blockquote>So that is how the wise</blockquote><blockquote>see work as it really is —</blockquote><blockquote>seers of dependent origination,</blockquote><blockquote>skilled in work and its result.</blockquote><blockquote>By work the world goes around</blockquote><blockquote>By work the population goes around</blockquote><blockquote>Sentient beings are fastened by work,</blockquote><blockquote>which is like the lynch pin of a moving chariot…</blockquote><blockquote>— Buddha, Sutta Nipata 3.9</blockquote><blockquote>Of work (<em>kamma</em>) I am constituted. Work is my inheritance; Work is the matrix; Work is my kinsman; Work is my refuge. Whatever work I perform, be it good or bad, to that I shall be heir. This must be reflected upon again and again by one who has gone forth (into monastic life).</blockquote><blockquote>– Buddha, Dasadhamma Sutta</blockquote><p>and</p><blockquote>Students, beings are owners of their work, heirs to their work; they originate from their work, are bound to their work, have their work as their refuge. It is work that distinguishes beings as inferior and superior.</blockquote><blockquote>- Buddha, Cūḷa Kamma-vibhaṅga Sutta</blockquote><p>One day, it is said, the Buddha gathered his robe and bowl and went out into the village of Ekanālā<strong> </strong>for alms. The Buddha decided to stand by the estate of a great landowner, Kasi Bhāradvāja, as he and his workers stopped for their midday meal. Kasi Bhāradvāja was not impressed,</p><blockquote>“I, contemplative, plow &amp; sow. Having plowed &amp; sown, I eat. You, too, contemplative, should plow &amp; sow. Having plowed &amp; sown, you (will) eat.”</blockquote><blockquote>“I, too, brahman, plow &amp; sow. Having plowed &amp; sown, I eat.”</blockquote><blockquote>“But, contemplative, we don’t see the Master Gotama’s yoke or plow, plowshare, goad, or oxen, and yet the Master Gotama says this: ‘I, too, brahman, plow &amp; sow. Having plowed &amp; sown, I eat.’”</blockquote><blockquote>Then Kasi Bhāradvāja addressed the Blessed One with a verse:</blockquote><blockquote>“You claim to be a plowman, but we don’t see your plowing.</blockquote><blockquote>Being asked, tell us about your plowing so that we may know your plowing.”</blockquote><blockquote>(The Buddha:)</blockquote><blockquote>Conviction is my seed, austerity my rain, discernment my yoke &amp; plow,</blockquote><blockquote>moral shame my pole, mind my yoke-tie, mindfulness my plowshare &amp; goad.</blockquote><blockquote>Guarded in body, guarded in speech, restrained in the requisites,</blockquote><blockquote>I make truth a weed-cutter, and composure my unyoking.</blockquote><blockquote>Persistence, my beast of burden, bearing me toward rest from the yoke,</blockquote><blockquote>takes me, without turning back, to where, having gone, one doesn’t grieve.</blockquote><blockquote>That’s how my plowing is plowed.</blockquote><blockquote>It has as its fruit the deathless.</blockquote><blockquote>Having plowed this plowing, one is unyoked from all suffering &amp; stress.</blockquote><blockquote>- Kasibaradvaja Sutta</blockquote><p>Worldly labor seeks to extend life into the future. The spiritual effort of the Buddha, on the other hand, was intended to put an end to the cycle of continued existence fueled by greed, hatred, and ignorance. The awakening experience is frequently defined as an end of work — in both the spiritual and material realms. It is an end of production of Self, of compulsive existence, of indentured conscription to the rounds of rebirth and self-production — as well as the culmination of spiritual endeavoring after which there is no more to be done.</p><p>Upon his awakening, the Buddha’s is said to have exclaimed,</p><blockquote>Birth is destroyed. The holy life has been lived. Done is what had to be done. There is no more coming to any state of being.</blockquote><p>It is a phrase repeated throughout the Pali cannon by those who have attained the goal of enlightenment: <em>done is what had to be done.</em> No more coming to any state of being, no more becoming. The stream is cut, kamma production comes to a halt. While his past kamma still rolled along playing out, keeping him alive, he did not generate new kamma, and was referred to for the rest of his life as the Tathagatha — “one thus gone.”</p><p>In producing, we create ourselves and our world. We recreate the world materially through our actions, but alongside and intertwined with that process is mental/emotional one in which we tend to conjure and reaffirm ourselves conceptually — and it is in this conceptual experience of <em>becoming</em> we mostly tend to live in and be bound by. According to the Buddha, the creation and cultivation of the sense of Self that is one of the most consequential — and delusional — outcomes of these volitional moments of action, of work.</p><p>Marx recognized this in his own way,</p><blockquote>Let us suppose that we had carried out production as human beings. Each of us would have, in two ways, affirmed himself, and the other person. (i) In my production I would have objectified my individuality, its specific character, and, therefore, enjoyed not only an individual manifestation of my life during the activity, but also, when looking at the object, I would have the individual pleasure of knowing my personality to be objective, visible to the senses, and, hence, a power beyond all doubt. (ii) In your enjoyment, or use, of my product I would have the direct enjoyment both of being conscious of having satisfied a human need by my work, that is, of having objectified man’s essential nature, and of having thus created an object corresponding to the need of another man’s essential nature … Our products would be so many mirrors in which we saw reflected our essential nature.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Karl Marx, “Comment on James Mill” (1844)</blockquote><p>Even Marx — the master of materialism — unknowingly acknowledged that is only through reflection — the most insubstantial of phenomena, visually or conceptually — that we are assured of ourselves, our existence, our supposed “essence” and of the social world of which we are a part. This so-called essence is actually an inferred phenomenon, not a direct experience at all. The Buddha argued that precisely because it cannot be directly experienced, we can understand this sense of Self-essence as something constructed, fabricated. When we learn to observe the mind-body process carefully enough, the production of Self can be directly witnessed — not as the essential “me” at the center of existence, but as a hologram generated by mental push and pull in response to direct sensory experience — the most fundamental kamma/labor of the mind.</p><p>These insights do not mean that we don’t exist, but rather that we are misinterpreting existence in a way that perpetuates it. Likewise, the world outside of us certainly exists, but we are often not really living there. We mostly abide in this “hall of mirrors” of Self and World that we perpetually and relentlessly construct and reinforce in our minds.</p><p>We cleave ourselves into the future through imagined action. The sandwich I will eat. The call I will make. The accolade I will receive. The retribution I will dispense. This is how we <em>become</em>. We imagine ourselves in some future state and try to pull ourselves toward it. Though we grasp at shadows, thinner than air, we instigate our becoming through action motivated by this impulsive force of mind — wanting, thirst. We cobble, compose, construct, compound, posit, reify, assert, form, compile, establish, fashion, forge, produce, rear, manufacture, and fuse, ourselves together again and again in springing contraction to each decaying moment. We do it through wanting, through fixation on views that define and defend our existence. We do it through aversion, anger, fear — the constriction of the mind around an object that — even in agony — feels like home. The sense of Self is the most consistent and insistent product of our labor, our kamma. But like all conditioned things, as soon as it is born it immediately crumbles, and so requires immediate and relentless reassertion.</p><p>This is the tension of existence. The most fundamental sense of alienation we experience is not of a being separated from ourselves, or our labor, of the products of our labor, or other people — as Marx may have it — but the stress of a continually disintegrating illusion of Self that we are terrified to live without. Though it is agonizing, the work of becoming is not difficult to do. In fact it is compulsive. We are slaves to becoming. And becoming is exhausting.</p><p>The energy it takes to maintain an idea, a body, a state, a self, a union, a hope — is suffering, stress: <em>dukkha</em>. But to stop this process, to slow it down, question or even investigate it goes against the deepest urgency of existence, of being, of life. To accept the dukkha of existence is to recognize the instability at its heart — and the terror that it inspires. The Buddha spoke of <em>iti kammakkhayā dukkhakkhayo</em>: “the end of misery through the end of kamma.” And so we can begin to recognize the immense relief and the magnitude embedded in the phrase, “done is what had to be done.”</p><blockquote>O house-builder, you are seen! You will not build this house again. For your rafters are broken and your ridgepole shattered. My mind has reached the Unconditioned; I have attained the destruction of craving.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Buddha, Jaravagga Sutta</blockquote><p><strong><em>Making mind matter takes more than chatter</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Spittle and spatter go into the batter</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Pounding it flatter, pounding it flatter</em></strong></p><p>From the Buddhist perspective, the production of the Self is nearly inseparable from the experience of ownership — something considered equally, and dangerously, illusory. Ownership implies the ability to control, which never exists in any unconditional way. Because all phenomena are impermanent, unstable, undependable, and subject to decay, we cannot truly own any external objects. The fact of a house being <em>mine</em> wont keep it from deteriorating. The fact of a mother being <em>mine</em> wont keep her from dying.</p><p>Internally, the body and mind we think of as “ours” are equally inconstant: impermanent and undependable — subject to changing conditions beyond the reach our desires for them, thus defying the notion of our owning them. Nothing can be owned because it cannot be controlled, but also because there is no real owner.</p><p>The Buddha proposed that any belief in ownership, any fixation on it, and any ambitions or attachments toward it are rooted in delusion. This is why he so highly praised the ideal of the <em>akincana</em>, “one who owns nothing, who is ownerless.”</p><blockquote>The ignorant dullard who creates acquisition</blockquote><blockquote>encounters suffering again and again…</blockquote><blockquote>Having seen renunciation as security</blockquote><blockquote>do not take up or reject anything.</blockquote><blockquote>— Buddha, Sutta Nipata 5.4</blockquote><p>Or</p><blockquote>Owning nothing, taking nothing:</blockquote><blockquote>this is the island with nothing further.</blockquote><blockquote>I call this nibbana (nirvana).</blockquote><blockquote>the extinction of old age and death.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Buddha, Sutta Nipata 5.10</blockquote><p>According to Marx, the tension at the heart of capitalist economy is that workers do not own the products of their labor and are paid less than the value they create. The value generated by their labor is appropriated by those who employ them. This appropriation is the source of all profit, which expands outside of the workers’ control or benefit, and which they eventually encounter as a force outside of themselves — as Capital — to which they are eternally subject on every social, political, and economic front. This multi-faceted dynamic is the source of the experience of alienation, or estrangement (German, <em>entfremdung</em>), from 1. the product of their labor; 2. the act of production itself; 3. their own essential nature; and 3. other workers/people. The product of our own labor, which we are forced to sell, is used to dominate us and reinforce that domination at every angle.</p><p>The vast implications of this system are hard to fathom. As the cycle progressed historically, money became not just a medium of exchange — but the whole point of production. Commodities were no longer produced by a craftsperson for their own use or for barter — but primarily for their exchange value. Thus, the money form of Capital essentially becomes congealed labor power and is, more than anything else, control over the labor power of others: a kind of <em>materialized kamma</em>.</p><blockquote>…only at the very culmination of the development of private property does this, its secret, re-emerge, namely that on the one hand it is the product of alienated labor, and that secondly it is the means by which labor alienates itself, the realization of this alienation… Though private property appears to be the source, the cause of alienated labor, it is really its consequence.</blockquote><blockquote>- Marx, Grundrisse</blockquote><p>At some level, this material perspective is not out of accordance with the Buddha’s in which dukkha is produced by mutually generative loops of reinforcing cycles of <em>ownership</em> and <em>Self</em> in place of <em>private property</em> and <em>alienation</em>. But it also highlights the contradiction that while Marx perceived the source of alienation from Self-essence (rooted in social subjugation) to be the original pain of capitalism, the Buddha understands the belief in Self-essence (rooted in ignorance) to be the foundational source of human suffering. While many would see these contradictions as mutually annihilating, I think of them as more fruitful than that.</p><p>If there is no essential Self and ownership is an illusion, what is the solution to the experience of alienation and subjugation? Is it merely wisdom? This is the classic suspicion that many leftists have of spiritual practice: that it blames the exploited for their suffering and proposes only an individualistic spiritual solution, acquiescing to the material and social relationships of oppression.</p><p>But if it is actually true that the ending of the Self is the ending of ownership — how might Marx’s framework be reconsidered with these adjustments to the foundation?</p><p>Marx’s solution to alienation is the collective ownership of the products of social labor. People should have equal access to all that is produced — and in a way that is not mediated by any kind of exchange of their labor power: <em>to each according to their need, from each according to their ability.</em></p><blockquote>“Communism deprives no man of the power to appropriate the products of society: all that it does is to deprive him of the power to subjugate the labor of others by means of such appropriation.”</blockquote><blockquote>~ Marx / Engels, The Communist Manifesto</blockquote><p>In his vision of the communist ideal, all society has equal share in the ownership of the social production, thus relieving the causal source of their alienation. Because all labor is considered social labor, it is a vision of communal ownership of collective action. And so, to cross streams, if alienated labor is the source of private property, ownership of action (in Pali, <em>kammasakka</em>) is the source of its destruction.</p><p>Marx saw collective ownership as a reification of the self in society, but the Buddha might still be suspicious that the framework of mine versus ours are two sides of the same coin. I think that it may not be merely semantic to suggest that collective non-ownership, rooted in the abandonment of kamma, might be another way forward that allows us to overcome some of the obstacles to Marx’s vision.</p><p>In our society, Self and ownership are two of the most fundamental experiences by which we define our sense of security — and so defending those is only natural. We cannot merely expect people to feel safe taking those away. What does it take to truly see “Renunciation as security?” It cannot be one in which we expect people to keep their sense of Self and lose their sense of ownership. Both must be interrogated at the same time.</p><p><strong><em>Now roll it and fold it,</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Sew it and stitch it,</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Mash it and mix it…</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*jnzo5pGSLqJcLQvSWtonVA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Shadows of swaying trees fluttered through the warm autumn sunlight of my grandfather’s living room. My mom had fallen asleep on the couch and the hush of the wind could just be heard behind the quiet fullness of the room. There was nowhere to go. Nothing to be done. It felt like an almost mystically perfect Sunday afternoon.</p><p>But my grandfather was anxious. At 94, his sense of internal and external composition no longer had the stability of his younger self, and he didn’t like it. I asked him what was wrong,</p><p><em>My memory is still there, but sometimes I just have a hard time…</em> he searched… <em>understanding where I am… and what I am supposed to be doing.</em> His face was strained. <em>We are in Ohio- is that right?</em> My mom had awoken by then and was alert enough to affirm this framework. <em>It just seems like there is no… no direction… no… plan of attack, for lack of a better phrase… I don’t have any idea what is happening with the company. It seems like I should be getting some kind of report, some kind of statement of our position, what we are planning, what we are supposed to be doing. People keep telling me I am in charge of the company, but I don’t feel like I am. </em>He sighed.<em> I feel like I should be doing something. I don’t have the slightest idea what is going on with the company. Nobody tells me. I mean, are we solvent? Who is making the decisions? </em>He trailed off inwardly, exasperated.</p><p>Of course, there was no company and there never had been. But he was losing his sense of internal organization, structure, of action and direction that had given his sense of self a purpose. And without it, in the beautiful quietude of the fall, he was not only lost but disturbed.</p><p>Sometimes, usually when spanning vast swaths of space and time zones, I will wake up in the dark and not know where I am — or even who I am. For some years, when this happened, I would strain to regather myself and re-orient as quickly as I could. <em>Ah, OK, I am in such in such town, in so and so’s house, in this bed, in this room… </em>But over the years I have learned to enjoy those spaces, appreciate the unknowingness of all the views that normally constellate my sense of Self and position in the world.</p><p>In the days that proceeded my father’s death from a brain tumor, his ability to compose and maintain the structure and meaning of his world shifted as well. At first, his fantasies of responsibility were rather solid: Representatives of the Red Army were asking him to come to a meeting about the situation in Ukraine. But as the walls bounding his mind crumbled more fully, the visions became more abstract. He spent hours opening drawers in the air, pulling invisible things out, putting invisible things in — organizing, processing, storing. But his activity was not calming. It steadily escalated into deepening anxiety — an ever-expanding sense that there was much more to be done, outpacing his ability to keep up with it all.</p><p>Earlier in the week, when his mind was more intact, I had warned him that in the coming days things were probably going to get a little weird. During long periods of my meditation practice, I had watched various kinds of unraveling of my own mind, I had experienced the letting go of the structures of self and of composing meaning in the world, and I knew how scary these spaces could be. Without orientation, without direction, without measurability, we don’t necessarily experience the loosening of the framework as liberating. The deeper patterns of restlessness and anxiety, that reach for composition to find stability, are still present. But I knew that with death or disease, when the mind cannot clench back the world of fabrications into familiar terms, it could be bewildering and nightmarish.</p><p>I encouraged him to remember love: to remember the people that he loved, and the people around him that loved him. I have complete faith in these recollections, and in the equanimity that comes with wisdom, to provide a stability much deeper than the fantasies and formations we conjure in our heads. But it takes a long time and a lot of practice for the mind to trust disintegration as safety, “renunciation as security” as the Buddha said. It is not really reasonable to expect someone to spontaneously develop this capacity at the very end of their lives, when the disintegration is most threatening, and they are least capable energetically of mounting the necessary forces of meaningful engagement. Not that it isn’t still good to try. But it is better to train in neutral terrain when our capacity is great rather than wait until hostile territory when we are at our weakest.</p><p>Considering his lack of training or familiarity with the deconstructed mindscapes he encountered, my father did well. But a vague and haunting existential agitation, an unnamed and invisible restless dis-ease, slowly dominated a blurred landscape filled with a proliferation of signless incoherence. It was only pharmaceuticals that finally and mercifully provided him the ease he needed to let go of this self he believed he was constructing, the work he was so determined to pursue. And if for no other reason, this is why I practice meditation. I never want to miss the opportunity to lie in the lapping rippled sunlight of an autumn afternoon and let go of who I am.</p><p>When love is strong, when equanimity is at its greatest crest, or even when concentration is firm, the mind doesn’t need to compose anything, cling to anything, defend against anything. Phenomena can arise and pass clearly seen, without interference or wobble — without the need to construct a Self or a world around it. When those factors are not there, and the mind encounters conditions it has not yet learned to perceive clearly or compassionately, the mind posits itself in dialectical response to the array of sensory phenomena arising and passing in and out of existence. We get caught in grasping, rejecting, conceiving — working and becoming.</p><p>My own meditation practice is now mostly watching the mind cling to fabrication when it doesn’t feel protected by love or wisdom, and letting go of control when it does. The content of the thoughts, the objects of fantasy or anger, are almost entirely irrelevant when one begins to see they are mostly just dull mechanisms designed to construct a coherent sense of me and what feels like mine. These spasms bother me less and less because the goal is not to control my mind, but to understand it. Where I don’t see clearly, I suffer. Where I do, I don’t. The process cannot be forced. But it also cannot be abandoned. All that is composed will decompose. It is only through insight into the undependable changing nature of all conditioned phenomena that the mind unclenches and stops asserting itself in response to sensory experience. The mind will be free when it is ready to be free.</p><p><strong><em>Where never dark, nor ever sunny</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>A pleasureless treasure which costs no money</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Empty of flavor, sweeter than honey…</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gqiNawDuycmLXNvplIs2EA.jpeg" /></figure><p>We must recognize that the undependable nature of existence is scary, and that the fear is valid and primordial and requires profound effort, training, and support to overcome. By releasing us from the dialectic of Self, reclaiming responsibility for our karmic labor, and abandoning the illusion of ownership, vipassana meditation may be the smallest scale at which we can build the faith needed to accept a society not based on private property for its sense of stability.</p><p>But how does it translate to scale? If we are to learn to trust generosity and solidarity as foundations for society, of collective responsibility and non-ownership of social labor as the deepest safety, it is going to take practice. The loss of the illusion of private property evokes more fear than relief in many, and faith in these a new order of property relations can only come through experimenting over and over. Marx made clear that the erasure of private property didn’t mean people would not have personal property, only that they could not use their personal property to subjugate the labor of others. But the subtlety of that distinction is often lost in the political tendency toward bold pronouncements.</p><p>One way to begin to uncover and explore these ideas is to break down the experience of what we call “ownership” into various facets. When we talk about any piece of land, any project, any factory, any building whose property relations need reconsidering, the acronym NARABIWIRO may be of use. Considering past, present, and future: Who has the Need? Who has the Ability to be involved? Who shoulders the Responsibility? Who has Authority? Who Benefits? Who is Injured? Who does the Work? Whose Ideas are valued? How do we Repair past harm? What are the Origins of the situation? These categories may not always been completely distinct, and there may be others not included here. But it is one way to consider their interrelationships over time, and to reinvision new modes of social production.</p><p>We can experiment in creating work that no one owns, that creates no value, that cannot be bought or sold: work whose product is unbinding, that dismantles the Self entirely and that does not create and recreate human subjugation. If we want the world to plant trees whose fruit we may never taste, people need to learn to love the experience of doing good because it is good, not because we will personally reap the harvest.</p><blockquote>It must be kept in mind that the new forces of production and relations of production do not develop out of nothing, nor drop from the sky, nor from the womb of the self-positing Idea; but from within and in antithesis to the existing development of production and the inherited, traditional relations of property.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Marx, Grundrisse</blockquote><p>And we cannot worry too much about the scale of these experiments. Revolutionary practice is increasingly threatened with corruption as it grows, so maintaining it at a small scale always helps keep it protected.</p><p>I teach meditation and spoon-carving, though the spheres are small and contained. I participate in a number of cultural, social, artistic, culinary practices that are all part of small, simple communities of practice on the fringes of the mainstream. In their isolation, they take place in a protected field in which people can explore something profound about who we are in relation to one another without needing the results to be validated or sustained by the market economy. Existing outside the dominant modes of production, utilizing unnecessary and unproductive labor, they enter a different world of human activity. From one vantage point, they may be called something like “hobbies.” But they are also cultural, and in my view, the experience is something closer to a sacrament.</p><p>In religious contexts, ceremony reenacts the miracle, remembers the vision, aligns us with the world as it should be, as it is promised to be. It is the small thing that remembers, replicates, and reasserts the possibility of the big thing. It is the ritual which preserves and protects knowledge of this across generations, time, and space.</p><p>The practices I am drawn to conjure a container to hone my ability to witness and take responsibility for the profound and subtle forces at play in the creation of Self and world. Their meaning is not only consummated through their consumption, but their production. They are practices that are a process, that result in more clear understanding of ownership and action, of non-alienated labor, of kamma that is dignified and unowned. Frederick Engels wrote “Freedom is dependency acknowledged.”</p><p>I have produced, gathered, and given away a collection of ceremonial objects for which there is no ceremony other than cooking, eating, and feeding. I have baked pies, sang songs, helped teach skills that have no purpose greater than sharing. They are ceremonies of quotidian self-production, an honoring of the mysterious yet discernable forces at play in the creation of our world.</p><p>When I carve a spoon, I don’t need a boss, a patron, or a customer to realize its value. Its purpose is not fulfilled by purchase or exchange — which would rather diminish its integrity. All I need to find someone who eats or someone who serves, for it is only by use or by giving that the external value is realized without betraying the inner value of the process of creation.</p><p>When I offer a spoon to my newborn nephew, the kamma is of an entirely different quality than if I had bought it at a store. In mine, a lineage of non-exploitative relationships remains in-tact: from Ghandi’s pear tree, to my teacher’s guidance, to mother’s apple tree, to my love for my brother, to this child’s nourishment, the lineage of action is clear and unbroken. The spoon may sit in the same drawer as a stainless-steel spoon from a factory in China but they are the result of very different relationships, different processes, and recreate very different worlds.</p><p>Mine is also inefficient and non-essential. It does not serve its purpose as a spoon any better.</p><p>The practice of creating and giving away helps me work through the entanglements of attachment and identification — whether the form is a spoon, a song, pie, or an essay. Though most people might not be particularly interested in the goal of dismantling the Self, I wonder if we can transform our social dynamics of ownership without at least the willingness and tools to reconsider it.</p><p>During periods of intensive meditation retreat, I generally don’t like to carve, write, make music, or create anything because it is very hard to craft something without also creating my Self alongside it. There are times when I am beyond my capacity to manage the disintegration, and I know I need that raft of Self, and so can use these techniques to reconstruct it in relatively wholesome form. We can still explore the process by trying to create something beautiful — internally and externally, even if identification and ownership arise. The value of the learning is immense, and quite literally priceless. As the Haida artist Bill Reid said, <em>“Joy is a well-made object, equaled only by the joy of making it.”</em></p><p><strong><em>Now, here’s where we trim, here’s where we skim.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Here’s where the center comes over the brim…</em></strong></p><p>My mother and I stood above the kitchen sink with a pile of apples before us and a small array of knives at our disposal. We were testing cheap new knives from an historic-now-touristy store in nearby Amish country. <em>These definitely peel better, but they don’t core well, </em>she commented, while sticking with the new knife as I switched to an old dull one. <em>Both your grandmothers really intimidated me with their peeling skills, </em>she admitted,<em> I was always so nervous. They were from a different era… where it was like a sin to waste anything.</em></p><p>Her ribbons were certainly thinner than mine, but at least they didn’t look as if we were practicing entirely different skills. She had shown me how to make a pie before, but this felt like a more rigorous transmission. We had several cookbooks out and websites open as she explained her experience with the matrices of butter and shortening, temperature and sweetness, pan materials, and mixing techniques.</p><p>That day, only my grandfather and aunt were in the other room, but we were reenacting a ceremony that had involved countless others through the years. Many of the stories, memories, and lessons we had learned or collectively shared came back to us as we rolled out the dough and prepared the filling. We all knew who needed coffee with their pie, who liked to pour cream over theirs, who preferred vanilla ice cream, who liked it dry, and who preferred it with a slice of cheese. (“Apple pie without the cheese is like a kiss without the squeeze,” my grandfather would still repeat every time he took a satisfied bite of cheddar before chasing it down with a forkful of pie.) My family culture was brought back to life each time this ceremony was re-enacted.</p><p>And a single truth became immediately clear to me: if there was pie, it would always be shared. No matter who unexpectedly came to the door, we would cut the pie to accommodate. If somehow we could not cut a thinner slice, people would share, or the cooks would discretely go without. But anyhow, that is why we always made two. Help was always appreciated, but this was not an exchange. No one had to pay with money or labor or even appreciation, though appreciation is always appreciated.</p><p>It was not complicated. It was obvious. Pie is always freely offered without restraint or condition. It is the simple culture of unowned goodness:<em> from each according to their ability, to each according to their need.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MU039Sm_3tlykHEhxLy1Vw.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a265d90693a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Principles of Guerrilla Warfare]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/principles-of-guerrilla-warfare-92dec64bc5a5?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/92dec64bc5a5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guerrilla]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Aug 2021 07:09:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-19T18:00:55.004Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Principles of Guerrilla Warfare — for activists and organizers</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*IlYHe2lUHy49PO60dXdiDw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Valdepeñas Uprising against Napoleonic Troops. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guerrilla_warfare#/media/File:6-de-junio-1808.jpg">source</a></figcaption></figure><p>The following points are from <a href="https://dolessforpeace.org/"><em>Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi</em></a> — a text (<a href="https://dolessforpeace.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/insurgentheartpdf.pdf">pdf</a>) that considers guerrilla tactics as a metaphor for an approach to the process of Buddhist awakening.</p><p>Here, they are offered for consideration as guidance to non-violent social movements and organizations seeking radical change — internally and externally. This exploration in no way condones violence or war — but recognizes guerrilla strategy can be meaningful in a broad array of other, socially constructive endeavors.</p><p><strong>1. Sabotage:</strong></p><p>Disrupt the processes and channels by which the enemy produces and distributes its resources. You may never need to attack enemy strongholds directly if you have destroyed the economic, military, communication infrastructure that allows the centers to thrive.</p><p><strong>2. Indigenous Knowledge:</strong></p><p>Develop clarity about what specific detailed knowledge of local culture, terrain, weather, infrastructure, etc can give an advantage over an invading force.</p><p><strong>3. Contact:</strong></p><p>Direct confrontation with a superior force should only happen on your terms. Attacks must be sharp, focused, clear, and quick. Only attack when there is a high probability of success.</p><p><strong>4. Mobility:</strong></p><p>Land and bases from which to operate must be acquired and developed. But they should be easily abandoned at a moment’s notice. Be able to adapt to changing conditions with strategic coherence but tactical flexibility. A guerrilla movement rarely seeks to gain and hold terrain. It exhausts the enemy through constant harassment. It moves like the wind.</p><p><strong>5. Distrust:</strong></p><p>Healthy suspicion of all potential enemies and allies is not cynicism — it is survival. The movement must develop the quality of rigorous investigation of all information and relationships, rather than habitual dismissal or naive faith. We also need allies and must avoid over-insularity.</p><p><strong>6. Medicine:</strong></p><p>Healing the physical, psychological, spiritual wounds of conflict must be a priority. This necessitates concrete training, material resources, safe houses, and adaptability for the field.</p><p><strong>7. Retreat:</strong></p><p>The guerrilla exists because they are in conflict with a stronger enemy. They survive because they know when to engage and when to run. Constant defeat is demoralizing and destructive. Retreat can be an offensive maneuver. The movement must be prepared to have long periods of retreat and hiding punctuated by periods of intense engagement.</p><p><strong>8. Diversion:</strong></p><p>The enemy can be lulled into complacency if they believe the attention of the movement is focused elsewhere. It is often better to feign non-existence than to feign power. In other terms, the intensity of conflict must be balanced with — and fueled by — play, rest, and connection to humanity.</p><p><strong>9. General Strike:</strong></p><p>Large-scale organized (non)action is a powerful tool if the conditions are ripe and there is enough material and spiritual movement support for those taking the risk. The appropriateness of this tool requires an assessment of the coherence and strength of the movement across rural and urban sectors. It is a risk. Do not confuse the powerful feelings of anger, righteousness, and ideological coherence with actual social and political power.</p><p><strong>10. Community:</strong></p><p>The camaraderie of revolutionary community is a fundamental force for a movement’s power. Internally, it requires a profound, dedicated effort of love and discipline — not merely based on the need for shared views, which can be a poison, but a sense of shared humanity. With the communities that are served externally, it requires trust, respect, listening, and sacrifice. Material support should flow both ways. If you represent a foreign element in the community, take care to be more helpful than strange. You only need a minority of people to join a vanguard force, but you need support of a huge community behind that force to make it thrive.</p><p><strong>11. Independence:</strong></p><p>At all levels of organization, guerrillas are burdened with profound responsibility for and authority over their individual actions. Balancing inspired and inventive tactics with the strategies of other comrades is essential.</p><p><strong>12. Intelligence:</strong></p><p>Education on all aspects of the effort must be thorough and organized by the movement itself: from the basic technology of the work, to the array of revolutionary theories, to propaganda, to art and culture, to intelligence on the workings and philosophy of the enemy.</p><p><strong>13. The Revolutionary Spirit:</strong></p><p>Fostering determination and faith in all ranks of the movement is essential. It should be motivated by positive social and spiritual alignment as well as moral rectitude. It can only be a source of true power if there is room for doubt and critique.</p><p><strong>14. International Support:</strong></p><p>Financial, material, and propaganda support from international allies is essential. Nearby friends can provide safe haven across their borders. International pressure can be a primary force in diminishing the willingness of foreign aggressors to continue their campaigns.</p><p><strong>15. Protracted War:</strong></p><p>The movement must anticipate a long, drawn-out struggle. If a guerrilla force can find the patience and willingness to pace their efforts for the long-haul, history has proven over and over again that they can win. There are three main paths. Most guerrilla campaigns will never directly topple a regime. If they do, it is because the insurgents eventually develop many aspects of a regular army, with an institutional force and coherence that can meet the enemy directly and win. Otherwise, they just create enough instability in a regime to make the country ungovernable, at which point the regime vacates. Or, they provoke the enemy into such atrocities that international pressure forces the regime out.</p><p>Compiled by Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=92dec64bc5a5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Headlines from My Life that Sound like Medium Claptrap]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/headlines-from-my-life-that-sound-like-medium-claptrap-a5dc59531895?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a5dc59531895</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[headlines]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 18 Apr 2020 03:08:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-19T23:28:06.970Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NCuV4vSZJOF_aMbZQ0lxrA.jpeg" /></figure><p>—</p><h4>I’m 41 and Bought my First Toaster Oven. It Has Changed my Life.</h4><h4>The Present Moment Sucks — That’s Why You Keep Running Away.</h4><h4>I Did This for 30 Days and Nothing Happened.</h4><h4>I Was Going to Spend 10 Days Doing This – but I Stopped Because it Seemed Dumb.</h4><h4>Not Feeling like Yourself? Maybe you Aren’t.</h4><h4>Don’t Worry about Saving Money — You’re Probably Going to Die Soon.</h4><h4>Are You Using the Right Pillow? The Answer May Surprise You.</h4><h4>Yes, Adults Can Learn to Play a New Instrument — They just Won’t be Very Good.</h4><h4>The Universe is Expanding AND Contracting: Could That be why You Feel Disoriented?</h4><h4>Is it Better to Drink Water Cold or at Room Temp? We Asked the Experts.</h4><h4>The Body Doesn’t Hold Trauma — It Is the Trauma.</h4><h4>I Went to the ER 4 times with Difficulty Breathing – and all I Got Was this Dust-mask… and a Bill.</h4><h4>Feeling Down? Just Remember: Your Skull is Always Smiling</h4><h4>This One Thing Really Tied the Room Together – and it Cost and Damn Fortune.</h4><h4>Why is all Pollen Yellow? Maybe Someone Should Ask the Bees.</h4><h4>This Kitchen Tool Doesn’t Exist — and You Can’t Live Without It.</h4><h4>Everyone is Talking about COVID-19 but Here’s Why You Should Hold Out for COVID-20.</h4><h4>Billions of People Have Experienced Birth — When Will we Stop Calling it a Miracle?</h4><h4>Let Your Garden go to Seed — and It’s Not Why You Think.</h4><h4>I Ate Bat Soup Every Day for a Month — Here’s What I Learned.</h4><h4>Plant, Water, Feed, Weed: Low-Energy Gardening for Low-Energy Gardeners.</h4><h4>I’ll Tell You My Symptoms If You Tell Me Yours — On Zoom.</h4><h4>You Have a Million Schemes — but They’re All Ridiculous so Stop Thinking About Them.</h4><h4>Tea or Coffee?… Who Cares?</h4><h4>You’re Probably Brushing Your Teeth Wrong — and It May Kill You.</h4><h4>“Someday this Pandemic’s Gonna End” and Other Sad Refrains from Introverts.</h4><h4>In Just a Few Hours of Mind-Bending Work, Using Tools and Materials that are Difficult to Find, with Ancient Methods a Little Tricky to Learn, You Too Can Make an Over-elaborate Probably-Not-That-Useful Non-Medical Face-Mask — in Just 716 Steps!</h4><h4>Nothing You Do Will Ever Amount to Anything — Maybe That Should Be a Relief.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a5dc59531895" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {15} Afterword]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-15-afterword-9c47ee7fdab9?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c47ee7fdab9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Feb 2020 07:22:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-20T21:46:36.484Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {15<strong>}</strong> Afterword</h3><h4><strong>MINDFULNESS: A Balm or a Bomb for Babylon</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/921/1*no2v3kox5sD63DO0NVzkjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>OSPAAAL poster image by Rafael Zarza / Image courtesy Lincoln Cushing / Docs Populi</figcaption></figure><h3>Table of Contents</h3><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Preface</strong></a></p><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Introduction</strong></a></p><ol><li><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-1-5c0155ab82e"><strong>Sabotage</strong>: Dana / Sila</a></li></ol><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-2-3e2e7dfa6567">2. <strong>Indigenous Knowledge:</strong> <em>Bhavana</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-3-21b24f9c0675">3. <strong>Contact:</strong> <em>Aim /Attack / Harass</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-4-7e8180ac694d">4. <strong>Mobility:</strong> <em>Bases / Fluidity / Agility</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-5-c56e648af1c">5. <strong>Distrust:</strong> <em>Suspicion / Investigation</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-6-4cd23b6d08ae">6. <strong>Medicine:</strong> <em>Metta / Divine Abodes</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-7-6a55c91a04d">7. <strong>Retreat:</strong> <em>Encirclement / Escape</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-8-9f84a4893c4">8. <strong>Diversion:</strong> <em>Distraction / Misdirection</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-9-fed71316dfc0">9. <strong>General Strike:</strong> <em>Invisibility / Cessation</em></a></p><p>10. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-10-6a404425d159"><strong>The Guerrilla Band:</strong> <em>Camaraderie / Community</em></a></p><p>11. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-11-863b429e9269"><strong>Independence:</strong> <em>Responsibility/ Self-Retreat</em></a></p><p>12. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704"><strong>Intelligence:</strong> <em>Education / Reporting</em></a></p><p>13. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0"><strong>The Revolutionary Spirit:</strong> <em>Discipline / Determination / Faith</em></a></p><p>14. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806"><strong>Protracted War:</strong> <em>Land Reform / Regular Army / International Support</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-15-afterword-9c47ee7fdab9">15. {<strong>Afterword} Mindfulness: </strong><em>A Balm or a Bomb for Babylon?</em></a></p><h3>MINDFULNESS:</h3><p>A Balm or a Bomb for Babylon?</p><blockquote><em>In our dreams we have seen another world, a world decidedly more fair than the one in which we now live. We saw that in this world there was no need for armies: peace, justice and liberty were so common that no one talked about them as far-off concepts, but as things such as bread, birds, air, water, like book and voice…This world was not a dream from the past, it was not something that came to us from our ancestors. It came from ahead, from the next step we were going to take. And so we started to move forward to attain this dream, make it come and sit down at our tables, light our homes, from in our cornfields, fill the hearts of our children, wipe our sweat, heal our history. And it was for all. This is what we want. Nothing more, nothing less.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>~ Subcomandante Marcos</em></blockquote><p>HUMANS HAVE LONG IMAGINED an ideal condition in which the “kingdom of God” and the “kingdom of man” are in perfect alignment. From jihad to the kingdom come, from zion to the beloved community, from the stateless communist society to indigenous alignments of human activity with the greater forces of the universe, people have envisioned a society which is the manifestation of spiritual perfection.</p><p>While utopian visions may provide a useful north star for some of our social movements at times, they have also sown seeds of our world’s greatest tragedies: from the crusades to the con- quest of the Americas to Al Qaeda and ISIS, state communism, the killing fields, and cults of all flavors. The efforts to attain symbiotic perfection on the individual and collective levels of human existence is so compelling that the impulse arises again and again. And yet efforts are so fraught with suffering that many simply give up the aspiration.</p><p>The question <em>how do we all get along together? </em>has dimensions that are material and spiritual, social and individual. The most simplistic proposals put forward by utopian idealists tend to insist that either 1) the process of individual spiritual salvation brought to scale will result in the material liberation of society as a whole; or 2) that the emancipation of social- productive relations will inevitably result in broadly-shared spiritual blossoming. People who are invested in both aspects of change are drawn to propose that the two issues are fractal: essentially the same problem at different scales.</p><p>Part of where so many utopian efforts fail, I believe, is a false-equivalence of the spiritual and social projects. Though we may long for a grand-theory that aims to resolve the mani- fold dimensions of suffering in the world, I have come to believe that the inner revolution and the outer revolution are ultimately distinct. At different scales (internally, between individuals, and within large human systems) the nature of “liberation” and the mechanics of the process toward liberation seem to have meaningfully distinct qualities. They are founded in related but distinct human problems and rely on related but distinct mechanisms for change. Each project may support or harm the other, but they cannot be entirely dependent upon one another nor should they be seen as essentially the same process. To treat them as the same, or to insist on their meta- morphical and metaphorical harmony, might not allow us to fully explore the depths and potency of the dialectical alchemy between them that is mysterious and real. <strong>{1}</strong></p><p><strong>DIFFERENT PROBLEMS / DIFFERENT SOLUTIONS</strong></p><p>At the heart of existence — of the process of being and becoming — is a grief, an agony, a torment that no amount of social security, universal healthcare, racial or gender equality, worker ownership, free childcare, basic income, education, or any other transformed social relation is going to heal. The problem of human dissatisfaction will not be solved by creating stable material conditions because no conditions are ultimately stable enough to be satisfying. The mind itself is not stable enough to be satisfiable.</p><p>And just as the goal of social revolution cannot primarily be one of spiritual awakening — because it doesn’t address the root causes of human suffering— the goal of spiritual awakening cannot reasonably be collective liberation. Social oppression is not merely a function of aggregated individual immorality. Oppressive dynamics are systematized in human relations in ways that are beyond the conscious moral acts of individuals.</p><p>For example, most of us need to buy food. The exchange of money —itself congealed and alienated labor power — for that commodity necessarily involves the exploitation of someone’s labor. We may make ethically-based choices about the social impact of our consumption — boycotting one product or another — but we cannot be held individually responsible for the basic fact of a worker’s exploitation in commodity-creation because we are born into a web of social relations in which money is used to control the labor power of others. <strong>{2}</strong></p><p>Capital has a beingness to it, a kind of artificial intelligence. It survives and thrives because of conditions that propel and permit it to seek growth beyond any single human’s effort. It will only die — or cease to reproduce itself — when the conditions are no longer favorable. It is not a question of mass enlightenment about the nature of reality but rather of transformed social agreements about the nature of society.</p><p>While the social revolution will not rid the world of loneliness, despair, or immorality, we are nevertheless still called to work toward this revolution because the profound hardship that arises from the oppressive toxicity of our social relations can still be greatly alleviated. A society can be structured in ways that are supportive of the human spiritual effort — of whatever flavor — or can make it much harder.</p><p>How we interpret the world may influence how we explore the nature of the Self. What we do with our vipassana insights may influence how we see the world. But how a person learns to analyze and interpret the history of the world and the nature of society has nothing to with the ability to clearly perceive the nature of reality as experienced directly by the senses. They are not the same thing.</p><p>Society can’t wait for all individuals to get enlightened before it is free. Each individual can’t wait for society to be liberated before they get free. And so we move forward.</p><p><strong>ENGAGED BUDDHISM</strong></p><p>Of course, many people believe that the pursuits of political and spiritual perfection are entirely at odds. But one need not probe too deeply to sense that Marx himself had a rather religious attitude toward the working class, the inevitability of revolution, and the faith in its ability to provide individuals with a sense of spiritual completeness.</p><p>Part of the leftist critique of the contemporary mindfulness movement is that it provides a balm for Babylon rather than a bomb. It is accused of trying to sooth the suffering caused by our social conditions on an individual level instead of applying pressure to the larger power-structure to enact change at a collective level. <em>Navel-gazing is an avoidance of the real work of organizing!</em> might be a good summation of the critique. Of course this has roots in historic leftist thinking: religion being an opiate of the masses and so forth. <strong>{3}</strong></p><p>While I believe <em>sati</em> (mindfulness) can social value, I also believe it should be honestly acknowledged that it is not a tool that the Buddha designed or taught for social change. It’s goal has essentially nothing to do with the transformation of material conditions of human society. While he certainly encouraged leaders of his day to commit to basic moral values and frowned upon corruption and wickedness in the world, the Buddha largely deferred to established oppressive social relationships during his lifetime in order that his teachings find a protective home in his social reality. <strong>{4}</strong> It is therefore understandable for critics to point out that his teaching has dimensions that can be seen as condoning — or even augmenting — social harm rather than decreasing it.</p><p>On the other hand, there are certainly ways that these tools can be integrated into liberatory social practice for the betterment of our social movements and of society in general. Activists can learn to have more caring and transformative relationships with their thoughts, emotions, bodies, and each other which can have a profound impact on the quality of organizing. These practices should be explored and exploited. But it is best not to pretend that in doing so we are bringing the practice home to its true work as the Buddha intended. And it is essential that we also acknowledge and wrestle with the places where these impulses of inner and outer transformation may be at odds with each other.</p><p>The relationship of any spiritual tradition to the work of social change will have its own particular dynamics to explore. In some, the projects are explicitly entwined. All seem to have elements that can be used to defend and inspire both right and left-wing movements. The contemporary growth of progressive “socially engaged” Buddhism and the rise of right-wing nationalist Buddhist movements around the world demonstrate that Buddhism is no exception. It is not inherently a tool for one or the other, no matter how much its proponents feel in their heart of hearts that it might be.</p><p>Many of us have bent over backwards trying to make the Dhamma fit our political viewpoint. It is one thing to contort our minds to make it all fit: those acrobatics are only natural and are part of the process. But is another thing altogether — a far more insidious thing — to try to contort the Dhamma to reaffirm our <em>ditthi </em>(view).</p><p>Contemporary secularized mindfulness — as propagated in the west — promises satisfaction over disenchantment, fulfillment over renunciation, acceptance over discernment. It has been pointed out by others how this contortion fits the capitalist consumer culture very well. But we can also see that in the field of contemporary spiritual activism it is often this dumbed-down, decontextualized, capitalist, colonialist, buddeoisie “mcmindfulness” which is also easier for progressive social movements to digest because it doesn’t call upon the practitioners to test the boundaries and tensions between the inner and outer work, between the personal and the social. It glosses over them to avoid the complexity that would actually make the relationship more rich.</p><p>When we re-center the radical nature of the Buddha’s call to liberation from sense-desire, it actually becomes harder to integrate into our social justice work because most activists aren’t interested in the destruction of craving. They want a better night’s sleep and to prevent burn-out from their overwork. The goal of social revolution is to improve the cycles of social production and reproduction. The goal of Dhamma is not ultimately about “self-improvement” at all but rather to escape from the cycle of reproduction of Self entirely. No reasonable social change movement would aim for the cessation of becoming. On a basic level, the goals don’t match.</p><p>These mismatches are not trite and we gloss over them to the detriment of our deeper work — internally and externally. This tension in the relationship of honest Dhamma (rather than “mindfulness”) to social justice work is an investigation we should not shy away from because it is the only way mindfulness actually has a meaningful chance at being part of a transformation of society rather than a tool and victim of further exploitation and alienation. These uneasy places (and many others) are not easily resolved but they provide us with a foundation for important conversations.</p><p>For social change, we need metaphorical balms and bombs. We need healing from our wounds of historical trauma but we also need to dismantle and restructure society so it stops making those wounds.</p><p><strong>NON-VIOLENT GUERRILLA TACTICS</strong></p><p>When we incorporate the methods of guerrilla warfare into our vipassana practice we generate particular orientation toward the pursuit of inner liberation. As we digest this integration, we can also fold this guerrilla yogi orientation back into the world of social change. In doing so we see that it may give us a kind of refracted clarity regarding some meaningful aspects of our approach to creating a more just world. Through this double-digestion of guerrilla metaphors and spiritual insights, we can build the foundation for a social re-expression that maintains the principles and militant notions of guerrilla warfare but that has integrated the full expression of non-violence, love, compassion, and peace.</p><p>Even with the spiritual dimensions excluded, each chapter of this book outlining the guerrilla strategic framework can provide guidance for our non-violent movements for social change. I hope these can be investigated. For now, I will focus my reflections primarily on the places where the learning of the guerrilla yogi can have resonance with the strategic imperatives for social liberation. There are a few places which seem to get to the heart of the project trying to use some of the wisdom of the Dhamma to support our non-violent social justice movement.</p><p>As a starting place it is essential to acknowledge that the left already lives in the basic formula of a guerrilla movement. We are in the minority position. We are poorly funded. We are disorganized and largely leaderless. We are motivated. If the left could understand itself this way and strategize and organize appropriately we might refine or tap into a range of new approaches that could significantly increase the potency of our strengths and decrease the impairments of our weaknesses.</p><p><strong>UNITY AND DIVERSITY</strong></p><p>Contemporary activists want to feel the goodness of unity but not at the expense of ignoring our differences. Because of our allergy to the hegemonic flavor of many solidarity efforts, a lot of lamentation has been expressed about the silo-ing of movement work. The divergence of priority, analysis, cultural norms, and strategies within movements focused on racial justice, economic justice, gender equality, and environmentalism (for example) is seen as a threat to that most cherished leftist attainment: solidarity. But if we consider that solidarity is in many ways akin to the spiritual call for concentration, we may appreciate the ways that in their diversity our contemporary movements for change are intuitively prioritizing a deeper value. Understanding how the forces of mindfulness and concentration work together in vipassana practice is one framework that can help us develop healthy approaches to both in our organizing.</p><p>As we know from previous discussion, concentration — the ability to maintain a firm connection with an object over time — is powerful and necessary capacity in our meditation practice, but it will always be haunted by its patriarchal and non-investigative shadow. Concentration is a kind of control that can easily be overdone. In its effort to stabilize it can repress and obfuscate reality and undermine our path. Because of this, the guerrilla yogi must be extremely careful that their concentration be developed only when in service of mindfulness — the actual transformative tool of insight.</p><p>One fundamental way that concentration can be ensured to serve mindfulness is when it is oriented not to stabilize an object but rather to stay with it over time <em>as it changes</em>. The guerrilla yogi does not depend on or over-value the experience of absorptive concentration <em>jhana</em> which creates a powerful sense of stability between mind and object. They trust, instead, that the practice of <em>kanika samadhi</em> (momentary concentration) can ultimately lead to the same power of mental concentration, indeed to <em>vipassana jhana</em>, but it does so by being in concurrent relationship with reality rather than overriding it.</p><p>Coherence for a moment is actually all we need. If we let the connection go and allow for a new coherence at the next moment and the next, we will be far better off than insisting on or aiming for a fixed solidity of attention over a long period of time. In this way our efforts toward concentration strengthen the mind’s ability to see the true nature of all phenomena.</p><p>Our movement work can likely benefit from a similar understanding. As concentration serves a necessary repressive function to the flood of fabrications and mental impulses, solidarity organizes the energy of a group to generate enough power to make impact in the world. Mindfulness, on the other hand, has a natural investigative quality that has more resonance with an appreciation of diversity. In social change work, we want to move forward collectively but not at the expense of an appreciation of our diversity — which proves to be as complicated a task as finding the right balance of concentration and mindfulness.</p><p>Notions and practices of intersectionality — that aim to create solidarity across a range of diverse experiences of oppression—have metaphorical resonance with a balanced approach to the vipassana practice of the guerrilla yogi. The work of coming to intersectional solidarity, though, can feel conflictual and chaotic and therefore exhausting and depleting. Just as without any concentration our meditation practice struggles to connect meaningfully with any object, without any base of solidarity, the tendency to get caught in conflictual process without direction is the shadow of diversity.</p><p>We need some concentration — some boundaries to our attention — to create a basic sense of stability in our practice, just as in the movement we require some basic sense of cohesion to fruitfully hold whatever conflict or difference emerges. If we never get a sense of the beautiful taste of togetherness we can lose all inspiration to stay connected. But if stability and unified strength are all that is valued, we lose the underlying dynamism and trust that fuels our search for a deeper wisdom and freedom.</p><p>Just as in meditation, this <em>kanika solidarity</em> approach to social change may often look messier than one based on an repressive unity. It will also likely not have as many of the dramatic signs that we intuitively read as “progress” — like those that come from a forceful punch of movement power. But this orientation will invite us to be sensitive to the more profound, if more subtle, cohesion that can and does arise between people in varied ways if we are aiming for it. And it will feel more real and more nourishing because it is not phony or built on erasure of difference, as traditional solidarity can be. That reality and the energy that comes from it quenches us over the long haul in ways that the more enthralling and ecstatic experiences cannot.</p><p>Kanika solidarity can also give us access to meaningful connection with people who we may even consider our enemies: people who hold fiercely opposing positions than us around most points of social liberation. Brief periods of alignment that don’t have expectation for long commitment can allow for the connection to be pure and meaningful in a way that moves a position forward without threatening greater antagonism, paving the emotional path for future relationship and perhaps eventual long-term solidarity.</p><p>In fact, mindfulness hardly the only other mental quality besides concentration we need to develop. Social change movements that are only obsessed with the need for greater unity and greater strength are also in some ways akin to a vipassana yogi concerned only with concentration and energy while disinterested in the other <em>bojjhanga</em> (factors of awakening) of mindfulness, investigation, rapture, calm, and equanimity. As vipassana yogis, sometimes the cultivation of these other factors complicates our efforts toward energy and concentration in ways that we don’t immediately value. They can seem like distractions. But without their development, our inner movement is skewed toward a kind of inner fascism. Without the purification of motivation that comes from these, or the development of the <em>pañcabalāni</em> (five powers) of faith, energy, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom, or the <em>pāramī</em> (ten perfections) of generosity, morality, renunciation, wisdom, patience, honesty, determination, loving-kindness, and equanimity — or any number of other associated heart-trainings — our efforts will be misguided and undermine themselves. In their dull ambition they actually become obstacles to our development. These other qualities of mind are not only good in and of themselves and they don’t merely balance concentration and energy: they all purify and strengthen each other in dynamic interplay. In the end, our energy is not tainted by striving, our concentration not flavored by craving.</p><p>Because of our fixation with power and energy in our social movements, they also can incline toward fascism. In what ways might we benefit from the broadening of the priorities of our revolutionary training? What would it mean if our campaigns were equally concerned with calm as they are with energy? Or generosity as much as determination? Not just as a value but as a revolutionary necessity? In what ways might we resist these practices as distractions because they are threats to internalized patriarchal models of collective movement building?</p><p>Recognizing this, some revolutionary theories value democratic process as an essential component to the program of power-building. What else might there be beyond that? If we treat movement-building as a practice in the way of a guerrilla yogi, we won’t be disheartened by the immeasurability of our progress. We will recognize the non-linear as essential and understand and integrate the value of the lessons we are learning along the way.</p><p>This is one place where our individual capacity to be in healthy relationship to our emotional and physical world, to our triggers and our habits, can help us be more helpful participants in group dynamics. When we can learn to access genuine interest, compassion, forgiveness, and care for people who are sometimes dramatically different than or difficult for us, we build the capacity of a group to move forward through what would otherwise be insurmountable challenges. Our ability to take responsibility for our emotional world and hold ourselves capable of transformative dynamics within them is essential to our individual and collective growth.</p><p>Some of these kinds of Buddhist principles will be easier to integrate into our justice work than others. Some may not be appropriate. The most difficult things to reconcile between the Buddhist framework and external revolutionary work are groupings such as those of <em>viveka</em> (seclusion), <em>viraga</em> (dispassion), <em>nirodha</em> (cessation), <em>vossagga</em> (release). While these are essential to the path of enlightenment, they can feel like a direct threat to the work of movement building. After all, their opposites: community, passion, creation, and attainment are often the quintessence of our frameworks for social change. In one path we try to build, in the other we learn to dissolve. We don’t need to reconcile these if they don’t fit, but we should keep the conversation open, especially if the individuals within our movements are called to fulfill these spiritual priorities for themselves.</p><p>Mostly our inner incoherence as a movement is experienced as squabbles, annoyances, and frustrations with comrades. But if we were in a revolutionary moment or actually held social power, we can imagine the consequences of these tensions could be much more intense. During the Algerian war of independence, French forces used countless deceptive tools to undermine the cohesion of the FLN. They augmented distrust, heightened paranoia, and spread factionalism. Like many revolutionary forces, the FLN barely maintained cohesion through the end of the conflict. The solidarity they did maintain was often secured through repressive violent purges and deceitful power-plays within their own organization. This orientation continued as independence was won and infected the new state to its core.</p><p>If we do not have different spiritual and social practices to fall back on and that are ingrained in our structures, this movement toward repressive unity will always be the human default in times of organizational stress. There are few revolutionary movements that are able to trust the slow burn of the <em>kanika solidarity</em> approach. Out of an honest and legitimate fear of division most fall inwardly and outwardly into violent tactics of repression during their campaigns and again into the states they come to control.</p><p>Perhaps the spiritual notions such as “honesty” or “wisdom” or “generosity” are not themselves the perfect analogs to what an organization needs to practice radical change. But what might they be instead? What might be the 7 factors of collective liberation? How do we determine what they actually are vs. what we want them to be?</p><p><strong>ATTACK THE WEAK POINTS AND CHIP AWAY</strong></p><p>Without the narrow fixation with (and measurement by) solidarity, power, and energy, our movements’ approaches to the use of power externally can also be transformed.</p><p>The basic strategy of a guerrilla campaign is generally to avoid large confrontations of fixed positions. Instead, it is to quickly attack where the enemy is weak and immediately retreat in order to gain as many victories as they can and avoid the devastation that results from trying to attack the enemy’s strongholds. It is a lesson we ignore to our detriment. Of course we should be fighting against everything that is wrong, and have a long-term vision to defeat our most entrenched elements of social adversity, but we may gain a sense of strength and momentum when we primarily gather our effort around easily winnable campaigns.</p><p>The non-violent guerrilla campaign understands itself as an irritant that is committed to a long-term process of chipping away. We fight where we can win, no matter how small or petty a victory it might seem, and from that we gather supplies, momentum, intelligence, confidence, and recruits over time — not worrying about the perfectly aligned and perfectly coordinated battle. When we can converge with others and fight together in a more momentous way, great, we should. We must value the small victory like the air of each breath.</p><p>We should be ready for the internal struggles that are bound to play out when we try to organize across significant difference: attend to them when it is fruitful and leave them behind when it is draining our power. Not avoiding conflict but sensitive to the boundaries of our growth, we come together, we disperse. We come together, we disperse. We come together, we disperse. We don’t become enchanted with the coming together and in the dispersal we see no loss. Over time, as a result of this orientation toward prolonged struggle, we build greater demonstrable power as a mass movement.</p><p><strong>THE REVOLUTIONARY SPIRIT</strong></p><p>We may also benefit from recognizing that revolutionary fervor — as it is commonly recognized — may be more of a personality disposition than a political one. If our revolutions only have space for people who are loud and angry, or are just dominated by them, we are going to exclude the participation of 90% of the population of any community.</p><p>Organizers are often trained to agitate the undeveloped frustrations of workers and citizens, inspire them to act out of frustration. This is understandable and can be incredibly effective. It often takes crisis for people to mobilize around their care. But it is also worth exploring the possibility of organizing around other emotions. What would that look like if what we commonly deem or recognize as a “revolutionary attitude” were not so narrowly defined? Could patience be a revolutionary emotion? Or equanimity? Can we imagine an un-agitated revolutionary? What would that mean about the process of transformative change? Could it change the primary role of crisis as crucible? Can love truly be a primary force for cultivating revolutionary change? Joy?</p><p><strong>THE DIMINISHING BREAK-THROUGH MOMENT</strong></p><p>As meditators we are forced to go through the highs and lows of how the mind can experience reality over and over again. There are times of incredible struggle and times of incredible elation. When we are in the midst of their spell, we are often convinced that each will last forever. We rarely wonder why the painful times don’t go on — we are just relieved when they disappear. But we chronically interrogate ourselves — or the practice, our teachers, or the world around us — about why the insights don’t seem to last, why the times of clarity and release seem to so easily become overwhelmed with the clouds of confusion and stress.</p><p>This is just the truth of uncontrollability, of conditions and conditionality. We also come to learn that if we follow the lows all the way to the bottom we open up to greater range a the top. Coming to terms with this by experiencing the full spectrum over and over again is one of the most important parts of our meditation practice and is the most direct doorway to our liberating disenchantment. This lesson may also be useful for the broader movement which similarly suffers from disintegration after victory, the falling apart after coming together, the loss of momentum after a big win. If we can accept, adopt, and integrate the conditional nature of this process and divest ourselves from fantasy of ever-increasing momentum and the disappointment of disintegration, it may help mature and strengthen our approach over the long-run. If we aren’t so enchanted by the thrill of winning or so disheartened by the pain of loss, our relationship to the whole process is transformed.</p><p>Equanimity is this profound acceptance of the truth of reality, based in understanding, that is the source and the gift of this process over time which will help our movements burn at a cooler rate, move at a calmer pace, and weather the ups and downs with greater integrity and faith.</p><p><strong>WE WILL BE FREE WHEN WE ARE READY TO BE FREE</strong></p><p>We have many examples of people’s movements overthrowing an existing power structure but then not having the collective maturity to be able to actually maintain power or protect society for very long. From the Communards in France to the Arab Spring across North Africa we have seen the lesson play out over and over again — that our desire for liberation may exceed our capacity to be liberated. It is of great benefit to be humble and conscious about this fact.</p><p>For the yogi, this gap between gusto and capacity is persistently clear. We want to be free from greed, hatred, and delusion but we do not have the capacity of mind to actually be with reality in all its volatility without them. We come to see greed, hatred, and delusion as the entirely understandable responses of the untrained mind to deal with the flux of formations, to get some kind of hold on the great unleashing of our kamma.</p><p>Can we recognize this in our communities as well? Can we see the ways which our violence, our poverty, our addictions, our fantasies might serve as protections? Protections from outer influence and further exploitation, from reckoning, gentrification, from bearing the weight of our past actions or truly feeling the pain of the harm that has been done to us and that we have perpetuated?</p><p>In our meditation tradition, the yogi must come to acknowledge that their mind is not yet trained, not quick or stable or tender enough to fully bear the intensity of reality as it unfolds moment to moment. That the stream of pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral experiences is actually too overwhelming. But the yogi also recognizes that it is simply a matter of training, of practice, and that through moments of increased capacity, of being with a difficult mental or physical sensation with great peace even for a few moments, the faith in our ultimate capacity and potential for total liberation is developed. In this way we come to see that we will be free when we are ready to be free, and there is nothing we can do to control that process more than simply apply our practice to our unfolding being as much as possible.</p><p>Our society may be similar. We want freedom. We want to end human exploitation, violence, oppression, addiction, and deception in all their forms. But we can also see them as crutches, as ways of managing a world as best people are capable of right now — as horrifying as that might be. This doesn’t mean we don’t continually strive for greater perfection, or lose a sense of that possibility and hold ourselves capable of more. But it does mean that we recognize that we don’t have the skills or understanding yet about how to do it fully. We cannot even get along with our families or our colleagues — how should we expect the world to simply fall into alignment with our fantasy of freedom? Our world will be free when it is ready to be free.</p><p><strong>QUIET EMANCIPATION</strong></p><p>To hope for a world without conflict is to hope for a world without gravity or rain. Violence is a shortcut to power when understanding and interest aren’t present in a greater quantity than pain or urgency or greed. Perhaps we don’t need to aim for a vision of a perfect static utopia but rather one that at least has processes, practices, systems by which it is managing, attending to, negotiating, and overcoming conflict: one that has the tools to work with what arises and, when it doesn’t, knows to pull back rather than create more harm.</p><p>On the left, we must push both a program and a process. Why not let go of program and just focus on process? Because, as guerrilla yogis we know that practice can only be successful if allowed to bear fruit under certain conditions of baseline safety for some period of time. True honest communication and exploration between people is very hard under conditions of oppression and so the process itself must be determined, to some degree, by an enforced alignment with the greater program. It is another form of concentration. Those conditions can be framed as some kind of quietude, spaces and patterns where the tendency toward interpersonal volatility are dampened, where conflict can still arise but in a container that can hold it, or give space, protection, healing, when needed. We can create spaces where joy and celebration can emerge in a way that is not distant from pain and trauma and the shared work we do to heal. Whether this is a counseling session, a meeting, a classroom, a block party, a community forum, or some formation we don’t yet know, many of the principles are shared. Conditions matter on the road to conditionless freedom.</p><p>It seems unlikely that profound social change at scale will come by the pursuit of consensus — certainly not in time to prevent a climate crisis— and so it is easy to get frustrated by process. As the guerrilla yogi needs some concentration to allow for mindfulness to do its work safely, we need power to defend the parameters of dialog that can lead to liberatory agreement. Knowing that change which comes only through the enforcement of power can create such misery, we must always ask, do we want power enough to win? Do we want responsibility enough to win? When we are in power do we spend as much energy instilling healthy social process as we do trying to push forward our agenda and maintaining our authority?</p><p>It is probably realistic to expect a future world where personal violence still exists, where anger is not contained or held in healthy internal process all the time, where greed and delusion play out in painful ways. But we can easily imagine a world with less organized violence: violence coordinated by race, gender, capital, bureaucracy, or other forms of concentrated power. We can imagine a world in which there are fewer social positions in which people can steal from others, harm others, abuse others, or ignore the needs of others, and the ballast that this would give the heart in the wild seas of change. The people who dismantle those systems will be greatly informed if they also understand how to do so internally and are inspired by how good it feels.</p><p>We don’t become enlightened by fixating on the person we wish we were and manifesting it. Rather, under conditions of profound commitment to doing good and refraining from harm we make a concerted effort to understand who we actually are in a profoundly intimate way and thus the fetters to our freedom dismantle themselves.</p><p>If we lived in a society with greater power to enforce ethical behavior — which is to say our social-relations of production and consumption — and also a greater commitment to collective processes of investigation and understanding, we could come to live together with more vitality, equality and, ultimately, liberty. If so, it is important to remember that the world we are aiming for is not outside of the world we are living in — it is inside it and available at any moment.</p><p>We also might consider that in the end, our <em>vimutt</em>i (emancipation) might be <em>samatho</em> (tranquil, quiet). That throughout the process of social convulsion, of conflict and agreement, of control and release, of resonances and dissonances, we might develop a way of being that learns from these movements of society, generating patience and determination and love as we get deeper and deeper to the heart of the matter. The path of the guerrilla yogi requires that these resonances and dissonances be engaged in their fullest way possible to fuel the deepening process of liberation.</p><p>Pau.</p><h4>NOTES</h4><p>{1}</p><p>This chapter is entirely insufficient for the problem it is trying to address. I do believe one meaningful exploration of the relationship between individual and social transformation could be made by a thorough rigorous reflection on and refraction of Theravada Buddhist abhidhamma and Marxist materialist frameworks. It would be a worthwhile endeavor and a wonderful contribution to both fields and to that of “spiritual activism.”</p><p>In particular I believe the question of the nature of mind and of matter and of their relationships as described in notions of dialectical materialism (Marx) and dependent origination (Buddha) deserves a serious theoretical and practical treatment.</p><p>And I am not going to do it: now or in the future.</p><p>Until someone does, my hunch is that the most fruitful and frustrating tensions between our efforts to transform the inner world and the social world are rooted somewhere in the dissonance between Buddha’s notion in the Dhammapada that “The mind is the forerunner of all phenomena; they have mind as their chief; they are mind-made,” and Karl Marx’s view that, “It is not the consciousness of men that determines their being, but, on the contrary, their social being that determines their consciousness,” as he states in<em> A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy.</em></p><p>{2}</p><p>To entirely extract ourselves from the social dimensions of production and consumption is one solution that avoids participation in exploitation but it then also withdraws us from social significance and leverage to change. Avoiding capitalist relations may give us some reprieve. And this reprieve can be essential to our regaining our sense of humanity, of de-alienating ourselves and our labor. But the avoidance itself doesn’t hurt capitalism.</p><p>{3}</p><p>The full quotation is more interesting than is usually considered, if still inadequate.</p><p><em>“The foundation of irreligious criticism is: Man makes religion, religion does not make man. Religion is, indeed, the self-consciousness and self-esteem of man who has either not yet won through to himself, or has already lost himself again. But man is no abstract being squatting outside the world. Man is the world of man — state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world. Religion is the general theory of this world, its encyclopaedic compendium, its logic in popular form, its spiritual point d’honneur, its enthusiasm, its moral sanction, its solemn complement, and its universal basis of consolation and justification. It is the fantastic realization of the human essence since the human essence has not acquired any true reality. The struggle against religion is, therefore, indirectly the struggle against that world whose spiritual aroma is religion.</em></p><p><em>Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people.</em></p><p><em>The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.”</em></p><p><em>Marx, K. 1976. Introduction to A Contribution to the Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right. Collected Works, v. 3. New York.</em></p><p>{4}</p><p>One of the great disappointments for the honest yogi who deeply values their own liberation and the liberation of the world will at some point be the Buddha himself.</p><p>By all legitimate accounts, the Buddha consistently expressed individual salvation as the priority in his teaching. A myriad of socially-beneficial values and actions are encouraged and developed along the way toward this goal, but one would be very hard-pressed to find an expression of radical leftists social vision in the Pali texts. The Buddha was not really a social disruptor. Over and over again he appears comfortable with the class divisions of the pre-feudal society in which he was born and raised: comfortable with hierarchy, with baseline social inequality. He sought to influence the core ethics of that society and how the social relations were subjectively experienced and enacted but (in a way that would not be dissimilar from contemporary bourgeois paternalism) did not seem interested in revolutionizing the structural nature of those social relations.</p><p>To this day, during the long ceremony that ordains a man as a Buddhist monastic, he must answer the question of whether or not he is a slave; an archaic question used to ensure that people were not using the monastic sangha as an escape from that particularly oppressive human social relation.</p><p>While currently women cannot fully ordain as monastics in most countries because of later-era sexism, the weaknesses in the nuns’ order were instilled from its inception. The Buddha’s reluctant admission of women into the monastic sangha came after great effort from Ananda (considered the most dedicated male monastic advocate for the bhikkhuni order) and with the conditions of extra precepts. Some of these additional rules may very well have protected them in practical ways. But mostly they protected the Buddha from social criticism while they burdened the nuns with restrictions that would weaken their long-term struggle for survival.</p><p>The Buddha is regularly lauded for his openness to receiving sangha members from the lowest social caste, but this was a trait shared by most renunciate sects of the time and was in no way unique to his order.⁠ (To get a fuller picture, read: <em>The Social Dimensions of Early Buddhism, Uma Chakravarti. Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers; 2008</em>)</p><p>A few words must be said about the Mahayana and Vajrayana traditions, whose ancient texts commonly denigrate the traditions of early Buddhism (in which vipassana practice is rooted) as the hinayana, “lesser vehicle.”</p><p>Because these practitioners take a “bodhisattva vow” to liberate all beings before themselves, there is a popular and broadly-shared notion that they are naturally in more perfect alignment with a vision for social liberation than the Thervada-descended lineages who appear to them to be overly self-interested.</p><p>Firstly, I follow historians in considering these “greater vehicle” teachings to be disconnected from the direct activity of the historical Buddha. The imperative to forgo one’s own enlightenment for the sake of saving all beings, and committing to a path of countless rebirths to ensure that eventuality, is a teaching that is at profound odds with the clear and direct expressions of the Buddha to attain arahantship in this very life — or as soon as possible.</p><p>There are other discrepancies regarding the essential nature of the mind that arise from these schools which I wonʻt go into here. I will just point out the basis of my opinion that the Bodhisattva commitment is inherently flawed as a revolutionary social-change strategy: Since those old texts are not talking about the material salvation of all beings but rather their spiritual salvation, the strategy is fundamentally evangelistic. The scheme for world liberation would require all beings to eventually become Buddhists — a dubious and profoundly distasteful social change strategy that is probably incongruent with the values of most contemporary leftists and Buddhists — if they ever stopped to think about it.</p><p>I consider the Mahayana and Vajrayana traditions as no more and no less naturally aligned with a vision for world-liberation than the Theravada, though the complexities of the dynamics are different and won’t be explored in any more detail here.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806"><em>Click here for Chapter 14 (</em><strong><em>PROTRACTED WAR</em></strong><em>: <br>Land Reform / Crisis / Building a Regular Army)</em></a></p><h3>I hope you have enjoyed what you have read so far!</h3><h3>In accordance with my tradition, I do not charge money for Dhamma teaching and am supported only on the freely-offered generosity of others.</h3><h3>If you have benefited from what you have read so far and want to support me or the promotion of the work, please consider two options for offering your generosity:</h3><h3>1. You can donate directly to me (as a tax-deductible contribution to Vipassana Hawaiʻi) <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=29&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>or</h3><h3>2. You can make a tax-deductable gift to a fund that will help promote and publish this book in a printed form that will be freely available to all by clicking <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=43&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>Thank you for your efforts to continue to propagate the Dhamma in this era in a way that holds the integrity and purity of the teachings.</h3><h3>~ Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c47ee7fdab9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {14}]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc55ba5c3806</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vipassana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Dec 2019 08:28:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-01T06:53:00.102Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {14}</h3><h4>PROTRACTED WAR: <br>Land Reform / Crisis / Building a Regular Army</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/921/1*no2v3kox5sD63DO0NVzkjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>OSPAAAL poster image by Rafael Zarza / Image courtesy Lincoln Cushing / Docs Populi</figcaption></figure><h3>Table of Contents</h3><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Preface</strong></a></p><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Introduction</strong></a></p><ol><li><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-1-5c0155ab82e"><strong>Sabotage</strong>: Dana / Sila</a></li></ol><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-2-3e2e7dfa6567">2. <strong>Indigenous Knowledge:</strong> <em>Bhavana</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-3-21b24f9c0675">3. <strong>Contact:</strong> <em>Aim /Attack / Harass</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-4-7e8180ac694d">4. <strong>Mobility:</strong> <em>Bases / Fluidity / Agility</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-5-c56e648af1c">5. <strong>Distrust:</strong> <em>Suspicion / Investigation</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-6-4cd23b6d08ae">6. <strong>Medicine:</strong> <em>Metta / Divine Abodes</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-7-6a55c91a04d">7. <strong>Retreat:</strong> <em>Encirclement / Escape</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-8-9f84a4893c4">8. <strong>Diversion:</strong> <em>Distraction / Misdirection</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-9-fed71316dfc0">9. <strong>General Strike:</strong> <em>Invisibility / Cessation</em></a></p><p>10. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-10-6a404425d159"><strong>The Guerrilla Band:</strong> <em>Camaraderie / Community</em></a></p><p>11. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-11-863b429e9269"><strong>Independence:</strong> <em>Responsibility/ Self-Retreat</em></a></p><p>12. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704"><strong>Intelligence:</strong> <em>Education / Reporting</em></a></p><p>13. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0"><strong>The Revolutionary Spirit:</strong> <em>Discipline / Determination / Faith</em></a></p><p>14. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806"><strong>Protracted War:</strong> <em>Land Reform / Regular Army / International Support</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-15-afterword-9c47ee7fdab9">15. <strong>Afterword ~ MINDFULNESS:</strong> <em>A Balm or a Bomb for Babylon?</em></a></p><h3>~Chapter 14 ~</h3><h3>PROTRACTED WAR: <br>Land Reform / Crisis / Building a Regular Army</h3><blockquote>Thus it is clear that guerrilla warfare is a phase that does not afford in itself opportunities to arrive at complete victory. It is one of the initial phases of warfare and will develop continuously until the guerrilla army in its steady growth acquires the characteristics of a regular army. At that moment it will be ready to deal final blows to the enemy and to achieve victory. Triumph will always be the product of a regular army, even though its origins are in the guerrilla army.<br> ~ Ernesto “Che” Guevara, Guerrilla Warfare</blockquote><p>One of Mao’s great accomplishments during the Chinese revolution was his ability to inspire and organize the movement by the dual insistence that winning was possible and that it would be an undoubtedly long and hard road to victory. He called the overall strategy one of “protracted war.” The strategy recognized the humbling discrepancy between the power of the invading Japanese forces and the native Chinese ones as well as between the forces of the nationalist and communist Chinese. Firmly rooted in reality, it still discerned that the potential for victory lay in a long-term commitment to tactics that leveraged and augmented their own strengths and the weaknesses of the enemy to the greatest degree possible.</p><p>In 1934 the nationalist forces of Chiang Kai-shek took a break from their conflict with the Japanese to prepare a major offensive against the Communist capital, Ruijin in Jiangxi province. To avoid a fatal confrontation with the stronger enemy, Zhou Enlai and Mao Zedong orchestrated a massive retreat in what became known as the Long March. The Long March lasted an entire year in which they maneuvered the Red Army in a circular swing south, west, north and then east, while feigning attacks in other areas to disguise their movements.</p><p>The nearly inconceivable effort that took the army through nearly 8000 miles of treacherous terrain led to numerous casualties from fatigue, hunger and cold, sickness, desertion, and fighting. Of the original 100,000 soldiers who began the Long March, only 8,000 made it to the final destination in 1935.</p><p>On the other hand, while immensely costly, by avoiding decisive battles the Long March gave the Communist Party of China the protective conditions that ultimately allowed its army to recuperate and rebuild in the north. Peasants, the social group which the Army was most dependent upon for survival and legitimacy were won over by the magnitude of the determination and moral code of these soldiers who had trekked so many miles in extreme conditions and terrain for the sake of national liberation.</p><blockquote>The Long March is a manifesto. It has proclaimed to the world that the Red Army is an army of heroes, while the imperialists and their running dogs, Chiang Kai-shek and his like, are impotent. It has proclaimed their utter failure to encircle, pursue, obstruct and intercept us. The Long March is also a propaganda force. It has announced to some 200 million people in eleven provinces that the road of the Red Army is their only road to liberation.<br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><h4>THE LONG ARC</h4><p>In meditation practice, progress is measured by our ever-increasing realization that the enemy is much greater than we ever imagined — much more entrenched and powerful — accompanied by an increasing faith and determination to pursue the cause to its end.</p><p>Often, enthusiasm provides the most vigorous momentum in the early days of our practice, when the inner revolution has just begun. There can be a fervor, an excitement, a fascination with every aspect of what we encounter. Sometimes this can actually get out of balance. A yogi becomes so enthusiastic they are even sometimes annoying to the people around them: constantly proselytizing, trying to convince family members or friends that they need to go on retreat, start meditation, need to accept the teachings of the Buddha. If this fervor is not convincing to others it can lead to a sense of isolation. While this quality needs to be tempered eventually, the excitement about the practice and the prospects of liberation are inspiring and deeply motivating. When we look, we see, and we see that seeing is liberating. The sense of transformation can be very fast and significant moments of change can keep us exceptionally motivated. The faith that can arise is very potent and powerful.</p><p>But as time goes on our faith and intensity of motivation can wane. As we begin to connect with deeper but also more mundane levels of experience, the long slog of the war, the sense of insurmountable odds can take its toll. Doubt can arise and persist. This path will bring us through the desert — the vast barren landscapes of the mind and body — which is where so many lose their way, their hopelessness not yet purified.</p><p>The excitement of our early practice can be lost as we see “the same” material go around over and over and over and over in our minds for years. For long stretches the practice can feel aimless or fruitless. Our usual standards of measurement are confused. This barrenness is an essential ingredient to the process of disenchantment but caught in expectation and mirage, we forget to see the beauty of the barrenness.</p><blockquote>As the stars rose we agreed that we must march upon Orion. So we started and marched on Orion for hour after hour, with effect that Orion seemed no nearer, and there were no signs of anything between us and him. <br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>We all must struggle to come to terms with the fact that this practice is not about reaching some perfect state and staying there. Rather it is a profound, unrelenting, and liberating disenchantment with all forms of experience — including the blissful states — that leads us to freedom. In the desert of the heart we are confronted with our longing for more — more intensity, more profundity, more knowledge, more excitement. We are brutally and repeatedly faced with the challenge of the heart’s ability to see this longing squarely, to fully accept it, and to fully abandon it. It is at this stage in practice that many vipassana practitioners choose to abandoned the path for Tibetan practice or ayahuasca — anything that seems more exciting, more engrossing — because they cannot bear the penetrating boredom of the heart’s dullest longing.</p><p>How devastating, because this purification is the doorway to our most important deepening. It is the suffering that ends suffering. We must not only bear the desert, the monotony, but even develop a taste for its tastelessness: Create a home there, receive it as a freedom, a great relief, recognizing that it is only the wanting of some other experience that is so painful. It is the wanting that is the war. When we reject this we refuse the quenching the cup of equanimity for the fantasy of a bitter wine.</p><p>We are trained to believe that pleasant and unpleasant sensations are the hardest challenges we will encounter. But neutral vedana, especially for long periods, can be much more difficult to bear. People are amazed to see how often they would prefer the intense fires of racking pain to the dry desert of neutrality. Instead of clinging to some distraction of intensity perhaps we can take inspiration from Lawrence’s desert comrades as they came upon an abandoned house in the desert,</p><blockquote>The clay of its building was said to have been kneaded for greater richness, not with water, but with the precious essential oils of flowers. My guides, sniffing the air like dogs, led me from crumbling room to room, saying ‘This is jessamine, this is violet, this is rose.’</blockquote><blockquote>But at last Dahoum drew me: ‘Come and smell the very sweetest scent of all’, and we went into the main lodging, to the gaping window sockets of its eastern face, and there drank with open mouths of the effortless, empty, eddies wind of the desert, throbbing past. That slow breath had been born somewhere beyond the distant Euphrates and had dragged its way across many days and nights of dead grass, to its first obstacle, the manmade walls of our broken palace. About them it seemed to fret and linger, murmuring in baby-speech. ‘This,’ they told me, ‘is the best: it has no taste.’ My Arabs were turning their backs on the perfumes and luxuries to choose the things in which mankind had no share or part.</blockquote><blockquote>~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><h4>LAND REFORM</h4><blockquote>Only by implementing land reform, giving land to the tillers, liberating the productive forces in the countryside from the feudal yoke can we do away with poverty and backwardness, strongly mobilize the huge forces of the peasants to develop production and speed up the resistance war to complete victory.<br> ~Ho Chi Minh</blockquote><p>The responsibilities of the guerrilla movement are beyond waging war. They must also imagine, install, and defend the social and productive structures of a new society. Once a territory is determined to be stabilized in revolutionary hands, the process of land reform and structural social change must be addressed in order to legitimize the revolutionary program and build the spiritual and material support for the ongoing cause. The peasants have put up with a great deal of instability and risk during the campaign, so there must be something to show for it — spiritually and materially — long before final liberation.</p><p>Classically, in communistic revolutions, this has involved schemas of land redistribution where old landlords, business owners, and aristocrats are removed from their positions of social power and replaced by people and systems that are intended to be more democratic and egalitarian. A more fair distribution of wealth and goods, improvements to education, infrastructure, and healthcare, as well as the collectivization of many aspects of social and economic life are commonly the key ingredients to making good on the promises of the revolution and solidifying support among the peasants.</p><p>The guiding principle for land distribution is to take villages as units, to allot land to those who previously tilled it, to take into consideration the quantity, quality, and situation of the land, to give a greater share of land to those who do not have enough, to give fertile land to those who have but poor land, to give land which is situated near the village to those who have only land situated far from their houses, to give priority to the peasants who previously tilled the land to be distributed.</p><blockquote>The die-hard elements who are determined to sabotage land reform, and the traitors, reactionaries, and despots who are sentenced to upwards to five years’ imprisonment will not receive land.<br> ~ Ho Chi Minh</blockquote><p>The guerrilla yogi too must feel some benefit for the work and risks that they have taken. There must be some sense that this practice is “worth it” long before the trumpet of final liberation is sounded. This is not often a concern for the initial stages of the path of practice. For a long while, excitement can be its own motivation. But at some point the revolution must be able to provide what the enemy cannot. It must also wrestle with — and be realistic about — how hard it is to provide a lot of what the enemy already does naturally. Greed can (temporarily) provide experiences of all kinds of gratification. There is no way an egalitarian society can produce the same degree of entertaining and trifling consumer goods without the underlying oppressiveness at its core. A guerrilla yogi cannot expect the same degree of sense satisfaction that they can easily aspire to during the regime of ignorance. What is the satisfaction provided by a regime of mindfulness? How do we learn to value it?</p><p>The movement of secular mindfulness will defend itself by proposing that it can offer you all the mindless life has and with more vibrancy and satisfaction. Ironically, it is taught as a kind of gospel of prosperity. Mindfulness will supposedly make us more successful, more efficient, more likable. It will heal our relationships, fix our family, help us enjoy our terrible jobs. With mindful parenting we will have perfect children. With mindful investment we will get rich and help the world. With mindful sex we will give and receive perfect pleasure. With full mindfulness we will walk through life with in a lush and vibrant sensory ecstasy. It is the missing ingredient to everything in life. We are promised fulfillment here on earth.</p><p>People are told they can have it all: the job, the partner, the family, the vacation, the car, the house, the golf swing, and enlightenment like a cherry on top. There is no acknowledgement that renunciation (nekkhamma) might be a necessary aspect of the practice life, that we might need to make sacrifices for our practice, that these process — of spiritual liberation and social success — might actually move in different directions. It certainly isn’t even in the same solar system as Sri Nisargadatta Maharaj who penetratingly said,</p><blockquote>Truth gives no advantage. It gives no higher status, no power over others; all you get is truth and freedom from the false.<br> ~ Nisargadatta Maharaj</blockquote><p>Indeed, if we want anything out of the practice we undermine it: even peace, even freedom. We want equanimity but it is the wanting that keeps equanimity out of reach.</p><blockquote>It is a curious thing to observe how at that time many people had the idea of profiting by the Revolution. They did little favors here and there, everyone of them expecting great rewards from the new State.<br> ~ Ernesto “Che” Guevara</blockquote><p>Any long-term yogi knows this is true. Social life and relationships will not be the same after the revolution. Over time we may become more distant from people or cut down our social interactions and social investments. We may very well become less adjusted to society: more sensitive, less functional: less willing to betray our moral principles for comfort within the dictatorship. When we cause harm or when others harm us we may become more sensitive to the impact of it.</p><blockquote>Why oh why didn’t I take the blue pill?<br> ~ Cypher, the Matrix</blockquote><p>This creates a paradox — before, when less sensitive, we had less of a feeling for our failings. Now, more sensitive, we see the deep roots and are more disturbed by them. We may become less willing to undermine our deepest aspirations for the satisfaction of our sensual longings. We become less tantalized by the ephemeral and hollow. With these kinds of experiences as evidence, people unprepared for the impact of insight complain that mindfulness is flawed. But it is not a flaw of mindfulness that leads to this — it is its design. The heart’s desire for fulfillment will never be quelled by attainment, because fulfillment is always fleeting. Satisfaction is always temporary and mindfulness training is designed to see this and to come to peace through it.</p><blockquote>We wanted no rice-converts. Persistently we did refuse to let our abundant and famous gold bring over those not spiritually convinced. The money was a confirmation; mortar, not building stone. To have bought men would have out our movement on the base of interest; whereas our followers must be ready to go all the way without other mixture in their motives than human frailty. <br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>The value of this peace, then, is contentment. The dedicated yogi comes to see the value and beauty of small and meaningful connections and is motivated by their fleetingness rather than embittered. This process is a desalinization of the heart. Meeting life with the basic sense of goodness is the early and enduring fruit of the practice. The relationships that we do cultivate are rooted in this goodness. Everyday friendship can feel like the breeze of blessings bolstering us through the day. Our more profound sampavankas become comrades in the most honest and durable sense. Our lives can become more simple, more nourishing, less toxic, less chaotic — based on decisions that honor our own spiritual and material needs as well as our commitments to the world. It may mean we live a more simple life, but it is a more satisfying one more aligned with our values.</p><blockquote>The vital necessities of the guerrillas are to maintain their arms in good condition, to capture ammunition, and, above everything else, to have adequate shoes.<br>~ Ernesto “Che” Guevara</blockquote><p>To achieve the spiritual pinnacle of our aspirations ultimately requires us to restructure the material foundations of our lives. This may very well be a slow and careful process that happens over many years but is nonetheless essential. If the guerrilla approach is focused on the military campaign, we must also have a political wing to negotiate the practical dynamics of our lives. We are preparing our minds for the purity of an arahant. But are we living a life of an arahant? To what degree need we be in order to fulfill that possibility?</p><p>Throughout the Pali suttas, every story in which a layperson becomes an arahant, they either join the monastic sangha immediately or they die that same day. It is impossible to determine the veracity or general applicability of this dynamic, but there is something true we must grapple with about the challenges an arahant would face in the normal day-to-day life of a householder.</p><p>We must let go of all of the fantasies of what we would like full enlightenment to mean. Instead we might nestle into our own experiences and the experiences of the many yogis who have gone before us. While the ideal of the fully-enlightened person who is also fully-engaged in society — as an activist or a family person or whatever — is compelling to many people, we must accept that it is at least possible that while these two paths, though they may deeply inform each other, at some point may need to diverge.</p><p>What we see from experience is that a deeply peaceful mind, when equanimous at all sense doors, doesn’t have the tension that may be necessary to attend to functioning in society. Functioning in daily life — keeping up with the myriad tasks and responsibilities of food and family and work and taxes and bills and passwords — actually requires a certain degree of agitation in order to be successful, to survive. So even if it is not true that a person must go be a monastic, it certainly must be a life of great quietude and protection that would allow an enlightened being to thrive. With that in mind, we should always ask ourselves if we are living the life of an arahant? If not, something in the mind will always hold back from letting go. We will progress along the path only so much if we are not ready to destabilize the social foundations of our own livelihood.</p><p>The process of learning how to build a life in the Dhamma — in this culture, in this time, in this place, within these social relations, that allows us to support ourselves — is a challenge. This process may take a long time, it may never be realized to the complete extent of our wishes, but we can craft this kind of life and in doing so begin to make the possibility of of a wholesome and profound dhamma life for the next generation that much more of a possibility, and that much easier.</p><p>For a monastic, the question of right livelihood is solved. For a guerrilla yogi, the question is ongoing, and one of ongoing importance for consideration and purification. The guerrilla embraces instability as a tactic but not as a goal. During the Buddha’s time it was normal — or at least known — for a householder to move into the life of a wandering ascetic. The social relations supported it. Society valued that renunciation and so food, shelter, medicine, and robes were offered to monks and nuns in a way that deeply honored these spiritual value. These people let go, but society was there to catch them. It is not so in our times.</p><p>A guerrilla yogi needs a position of some stability from which to fruitfully observe and engage the instability of all phenomena. Stability is good. Stability is supportive. It does not help to enter the wilderness of the mind from a life that is chaotic. What measures as stable for any of us can be relative and in response to conditions. It is not simply a matter of wealth, though poverty, ambient violence, and lack of protection in many ways will certainly lead to less stability from which to launch our attack. Whatever stability we create we must also train ourselves to abandon it when the time is right.</p><p>The guerrilla yogi has the razor’s edge challenge of trying to get free from the cycles of the world without fully withdrawing from it. They maintain a foothold in the society way of life but must slowly train in the recognition that at some point, both feet must firmly be on the path of renunciation. We develop the conditions of safety and security to use as artillery in the battle of insight that develops a more profound safety and security independent of conditions.</p><p>Western Dharma has not yet configured the social mechanisms that will allow all those who long for intensive retreat to be able to do fulfill that wish, and we should aspire and conspire to build those tools and create those resources and make them as accessible as possible. Until then, we have to find ways of making do, of deepening our practice and our commitment to liberation in all the nooks and crannies of our lives where there is room to gather our attention and create protective conditions — so that when we do have the opportunity to sit for a longer period of time, we ride the momentum of a practice that is powered by the energy of our daily lives.</p><p>There are many variables in our lives that make this kind of retreat impossible but also create the general conditions that are supportive to insight. It may mean staying in a job we don’t like for longer than we’d like for the sake of some financial stability. But it also may mean taking a risk and leaving a job so that we are not betraying our deepest longing for ourselves each day we work against our self-interest. Sometimes we have to change our lives dramatically, let go of some friends, gain others, move away from some relationships with family members, or finding ways to bring them more close.</p><blockquote>People must contribute money in proportion to the money they have. Farmers will be required to furnish a certain share of their crops to guerrilla troops. Confiscation, except in the case of businesses run by traitors, is prohibited. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>Much of our practice can look like the process of recreating what was coined by the anarchist Hakim Bey as “Temporary Autonomous Zones,” periods of time and space where radical experiments in freedom are explored but never intended to be permanent. The consciousness of their inherent limitability is what gives them strength and potential but one for which a revolutionary must have a long-scale view of history in order to expect satisfaction and development from. Occupy Wall Street is an important example in our era of a strategy in which people spontaneously and collectively took to the streets in the form of experimental, exploratory, radical presences that helped seed, incubate, flower, and disseminate ideas and methods across time and space. The tactics of the Temporary Autonomous Zone as they arise and disappear over time, slowly perforate society and provide us with the experience of freedom that is necessary to give us the taste we are longing for, something of a north star in our escape from the subjugation we are freeing ourselves from. Their significance is not lessened because of their temporary nature. In fact, their ephemerality is the essence of their strategic value. For the guerrilla yogi, a period of retreat, a trip to the bathroom, a moment of nibbana are all TAZs that help build our momentum without cultivating attachment or the wrong view that they should be permanent.</p><p>The path of liberation that the Buddha laid out was most coherently designed and propagated for monastics — social renunciates who abandoned the burdens and responsibilities of society to pursue this path without distraction. This basic fact of livelihood means that our approach as lay people will have a wide variety of intensity: periods where our efforts are more general and relaxed, and periods where we can practice with more intense concentration and protection.</p><h4>CRISIS / POLARIZATION / CONFLICT</h4><blockquote>…a Marxist cannot regard civil war, or guerrilla warfare, which is one of its forms, as abnormal and demoralizing in general. A Marxist bases himself on the class struggle, and not social peace. In certain periods of acute economic and political crises the class struggle ripens into a direct civil war, i.e., into an armed struggle between two sections of the people. In such periods a Marxist is obliged to take the stand of civil war. Any moral condemnation of civil war would be absolutely impermissible from the standpoint of Marxism.<br> ~ V.I. Lenin</blockquote><p>When guerrilla warfare is enough to topple a regime or to vanquish an invading force, it is through the practice of constant destabilization: by undermining all normal functioning of society, the resistance forces bring a nation to crisis and make it ungovernable. By forcing government leaders to take more oppressive measures, their inherent brutality is exposed and the population resists with greater and greater volatility. If foreign pressures are enough, if the rebels can actually manage civic responsibilities, and if the social sector is sufficiently organized and supportive, this period of crisis can cause a power structure to collapse on its own, without ever leading to full scale war. In this opening, the revolutionary regime moves in and takes the reins.</p><blockquote>The polarization of society and a consequent collapse of state power is a direct result of sustained violence on the part of a revolutionary minority.<br> ~ Carlos Marighella</blockquote><p>The dangers of this approach should be obvious. There are numerous examples around the world where intensifying crisis and deepening polarization led only to chaos, suffering, and prolongation of hardship. The entrenched forces tend to dig in more deeply, subjugating the local population to more intense pressure, after which they are more likely to turn on the revolutionaries and side with the forces of familiar stability — as horrendous as it might be. The independence movement in Northern Ireland, for example, failed when it became clear that the people were weary and tired of years of violence and upheaval.</p><p>The guerrilla yogi must be extremely sensitive to how much crisis they want to introduce into their system, how far toward instability they can wisely push their efforts. The natural and liberatory collapse of the dictatorship of Self as a result of insight is entirely different than psychotic or life-structure break that leads to ungovernable chaos in our lives. As said in an earlier chapter, I have had students so enthusiastic about the practice that they abandon their jobs, homes, and network of support to go practice intensively for long periods in Asia. There are times when this has been wise and fruitful but more times when it has proven catastrophic: people have dismantled the foundations of their life’s stability only to jump into a fire that is much too hot and find that they needed to take a slower approach to their unbinding — a process now hampered by the need to rebuild the foundations of their livelihood.</p><p>Still, there have been more of examples of the opposite, where people fit retreats into their life structure on occasion but never take enough risk, aren’t putting enough on the line, to make real progress. There ought to be some degree of revolutionary polarization in our lives, of taking a stand in regards to which side are we on — but a guerrilla yogi should always stay sensitive to the dials of this intensity and learn how to adjust and respond appropriately to changing conditions.</p><p>It is not just bhavana that can push our lives toward crisis, but dana and sila as well. As mentioned earlier, I spent 10 years refusing to pay my federal income taxes because I felt that the amount going to pay for war and oppression was out of alignment with my basic moral precepts. It put my life in an intense period of purification that ultimately was too destabilizing for my life and mind to stay with, but I did not regret the intention or the process I put myself through. If we commit to some aspect of social justice in our lives as a moral stand, we should expect a process of purification to result from that. It is essential to learn to manage the volatility of that purification with skill. We reach, we strain, but not to the degree that it weakens our capacity for the fluidity tactics of the guerrilla yogi — for self-care, sustainability, wellness — or where our motivation becomes distorted.</p><p>We cannot and should not completely shy away from the tension we are trying to build in the system of our lives. Even if the current internal regime is not ready to collapse, not ready to be replaced by the revolution of the heart, some pressure must be exerted, some strain with samsara must be attuned to. The pain of dukkha must be felt. We cannot make progress without letting go of things, without the ethic of renunciation at the heart of our practice. We will have to let go of all of the world eventually, either through death or nibbana, and if we don’t practice in the small ways, we will never be able to do it in the big way.</p><h4>BUILDING A REGULAR ARMY</h4><blockquote>That is one of the clear things about guerrilla forces in modern war: they may be able to hold out, but they cannot win except in combination with striking forces that can meet the enemy in open battle.<br> ~ Bert “Yank” Levy</blockquote><p>As we progress, certain aspects of the path become easier. Much easier. Other aspects become harder. Much harder. We can expect that as we get closer and closer to the core patterns of the heart’s ignorance, the intensity of engagement will increase. At the same time, the degree of training that we have under our belts at that point is immense, making us increasingly capable of confronting the enemy directly.</p><p>It is very rare that a war of liberation can be won solely along the lines of guerrilla warfare. In general, and over time, a traditional army will likely need to be created, trained, and perfected: based on the guerrilla training but also capable of increasingly intense, positional, and direct engagement with the forces of greed, hatred, and delusion in the heart/mind.</p><blockquote>Our internal discipline must be strengthened. The soldiers must be educated politically. There must be a gradual change from guerrilla formations to orthodox regimental organization. The necessary bureaus and staffs, both political and military, must be provided. At the same time, attention must be paid to the creation of suitable supply, medical, and hygiene units. The standards of equipment must be raised and types of weapons increased. Communication equipment must not be forgotten. Orthodox standards of discipline must be established. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>What does this traditional, positional warfare look like? It is the ability to hold ground and successfully defend against retaliation and reprisal. Over time, the capacity of the 7 factors of awakening (bojjhanga of mindfulness, energy, rapture, calm, concentration, and equanimity) as a unified force is greatly increased. With this, we create an altogether different caliber of weapon in the war against Mara. When the 5 faculties (faith, energy, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom) gain in strength, they achieve a different degree, and even have a different name, “powers” (bala) as enormously forceful transformative and transcendent capacities.</p><blockquote>Sariputta, all the words were true, yet listen to what I have to say. Here, Sariputta, the bhikkhu, having partaken of his meal and returning from his alms round sits in the cross legged posture. Setting his body erect, bringing his mindfulness to the fore, he determines “Until my mind is released from desires, I would not change this posture.” Such a bhikkhu, Sariputta, adorns most the Gosinga Sala forest.<br> ~ Buddha, Mahagosinga Sutta</blockquote><p>Over a lifetime of practice it is at some point important to explore and develop the mind’s capacity for jhāna — concentration to the degree of classic absorption. Jhāna can help us clarify our understanding of many aspects of the practice: the difference between concentration and mindfulness, the relationship between mind and body, etc. More commonly, in pursuit of absorptive states people become enamored, transfixed, seduced by experience and resist the discomforts of bare vipassana. They cannot see their attachment to pleasant mind-states, and over and over again use them to avoid pain and acquire pleasure. Their deeper practice is perpetually derailed based on a hidden identification with these experiences.</p><p>People’s practice should be well-established and mature before moving into these explorations, preferably after they have had an initial experience of nibbana. Only then can jhāna be more safely utilized for their sincere value and not provide more ammunition and power to the forces of delusion in the heart. Ultimately, the most important thing to remember is that khanika samadhi, momentary concentration that is developed through rigorous vipassana practice, has the capacity to bring the mind to “access concentration” which is a vipassana jhāna, entirely sufficient for the cause of deepening insight.</p><blockquote>The fundamental problems are: first, spiritual unification of officers and men within the army; second spiritual unification of the army and the people; and, last, destruction of the unity of the enemy. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><h4>DICTATORSHIP OF THE PROLETARIAT</h4><blockquote>Long before me, bourgeois historians had described the historical development of this struggle between the classes, as had bourgeois economists their economic anatomy. My own contribution was (1) to show that the existence of classes is merely bound up with certain historical phases in the development of production; (2) that the class struggle necessarily leads to the dictatorship of the proletariat; [and] (3) that this dictatorship, itself, constitutes no more than a transition to the abolition of all classes and to a classless society.<br> ~ Karl Marx</blockquote><p>Marx predicted that the perfected communist society would be classless, and since the State is an important mechanism by which one class maintains power over another, it would eventually be rendered obsolete by the proletarian revolution. But he also recognized that immediately following the revolution, counter-revolutionary elements of the owning class would try to undermine the revolution, re-establish themselves as the ruling party, and reimpose the old social relations. To defend against this inevitable reaction, Marx argued that in the period directly after the revolution, the State, now controlled by the proletariat, would actually need to be maintained in order to protect the revolution until that time which bourgeoisie elements were sufficiently integrated into the new relations of production of the new society.</p><p>This notion of the “dictatorship of the proletariat” was intended to be a transitional period, after the initial revolutionary act and before the revolution is entirely matured. It is a tension that modern communists continue to wrestle with: Should the post-revolutionary society be in some sense “less free” in order to stabilize the revolution? If so, at what point do the efforts to stabilize the revolution entrench a bureaucratic class and undermine the progress of the revolution?</p><p>History has shed skeptical light on the notion that the State will simply “wither away,” as Marx and Engels imagined. What has mostly been seen in the post-revolutionary societies is an increased consolidation of power in the state and a the formation of a new hierarchical society simply played out along a different kind of class lines. Though none of the communist revolutions so far have followed the historical course Marx and Engels prescribed, a critique of the un-democratic and consolidating tendencies of the dictatorship of the proletariat are legitimate — concerns that anarchist critics feared all along.</p><p>However we feel about the notion of a proletarian dictatorship, history shows that Marx’s concern was a fair one. After learning that the collapse of the democratic Guatemalan revolution resulted from CIA and capitalist interference with their internal democratic process, Fidel Castro and Che Guevara recognized that their revolution in Cuba could only succeed with a certain degree of autocratic organization. It is hard to argue with the reasoning, especially with the hindsight of decades of CIA plots to overthrow the Castro regime, the Allende regime in Chile, and their undermining of Guatemalan, Nicaraguan, Colombian, Venezuelan, Peruvian, and Bolivian (to name a few) revolutionary movements.</p><blockquote>Between capitalist and communist society there lies the period of the revolutionary transformation of the one into the other. Corresponding to this is also a political transition period in which the state can be nothing but the revolutionary dictatorship of the proletariate.<br> ~ Karl Marx</blockquote><p>The metaphor for the guerrilla yogi is an important one. First is the notion that the success of the revolution comes at various stages. The Theravada framework recognizes four distinct stages of enlightenment: the stream enterer (<em>sotāpanna</em>), the once-returner (<em>sakadagami</em>), the non-returner (<em>anāgāmī</em>), and the fully enlightened (<em>arahant</em>). As the revolutionary forces of our minds reach their pinnacle of power and skill, they realize increasingly profound insight into the nature of phenomena. The deepening stability of mind in a wider and wider range of territory need only be for a moment to produce the right conditions under which the mind can puncture a hole in the “whole mass of suffering.”</p><p>There are stories in the suttas of people for whom these four successive stages happened in quick succession, as with the Buddha himself. Most of the time, though, practitioners have a breakthrough experience and it takes quite a few years for the insight to be fully digested and for the mind to restabilize to a degree that the forces of liberation are able again to penetrate the fortress of delusion, each time with deepening impact. The first experience of this is considered to be a success from which the yogi can never backslide. The inevitability of final liberation has been secured, though it may still take many lifetimes.</p><blockquote>For us, it was a victory that meant that our guerrillas had reached full maturity. From that moment on, our morale increased enormously, our determination and hope for victory also increased, and although the months that followed were a hard test, we now had the key to the secret of how to beat the enemy. This battle sealed the fate of every garrison located far from larger concentrations of troops and every small army post was soon dismantled.<br> ~ Ernesto “Che” Guevara</blockquote><p>In our spiritual path, even after we achieve the seemingly impossible initial stage of enlightenment and are considered sotāpanna, stream enterer, our battle has really only just begun. The long path from stream winner to 2nd, 3rd, and 4th stage — final liberation — is likely to be an arduous one, where we use our training to tackle more and more established strongholds of delusion in more and more subtle corners of the mind. It is certainly one place where the necessity of a true sampavanka is clear. The texts say that only a Buddha can surely know the degree of attainment of any person. And so any evaluation of our progress along the path of insight should be protected in the discrete and careful context of the teacher-student relationship.</p><p>There is no formula about when and where to get more restrictive or more slack in our approach. But remembering the notion of the dictatorship of the proletariat, it is crucial to remember that after any meaningful experience of insight we cannot simply ease up and think our work is done. Very often people achieve a breakthrough to the depth of practice only to find, in the words of Robert Aiken Roshi, “it doesn’t stick.” This is partly because people begin to put their guard down and become arrogant and over-certain about their attainments. They don’t recognize that at best they have pushed Mara, our internal bourgeoisie, into a corner from which he is desperate to escape. If anything we are called to be more vigilant in our practice because any success of ours in practice is an existential threat to Mara, making him more dangerous.</p><p>An initial enlightenment experience is usually a very small glimpse into the freedom of the unconditioned. But this glimpse alone is said to uproot identity view, attachment to rights and rituals, and doubt in the teachings. From there, the principles of our approach have not changed and our training is best served by continuing to perfect the guerrilla approach. Our technique is still in need of a lot of development, but our capacity to show up fully to more and more direct confrontation with greed, hatred, and delusion is also evident.</p><p>Realization of 2nd stage puts a bigger dent in the armor of delusion, but most of our defilements are still left intact. It is said that the stage of the Sakadagami the strength of sense-desire and ill-will are greatly damaged.</p><blockquote>It is absolutely natural and inevitable that the uprising should assume the higher and more complex form of a prolonged civil war embracing the whole country, i.e., an armed struggle between two sections of the people. Such a war cannot be conceived otherwise than as a series of a few big engagements at comparatively long intervals and a large number of small encounters during these intervals.<br> ~V.I Lenin</blockquote><p>At the 3rd stage of enlightenment, the mind has entirely mastered concentration and so has developed the capacity of a full-strength army that can engage Mara head-on. It is said that the anāgāmī has totally uprooted craving and ill-will, though the subtle and powerful fibers of delusion are not yet totally eradicated. Surely the tools of the guerrilla are perfected and still in use but they are complemented by a magnificent momentum of strength and purity of mind that pushes undeterred toward the final goal.</p><blockquote>The third stage will be the last in the protracted war, and when we talk of persevering in the war to the end, we mean going all the way through this stage… In the third stage guerrilla warfare will again provide strategic support by supplementing mobile and positional warfare, but it will not be the primary form as in the second stage.<br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><h4>FREEDOM</h4><blockquote>Someday this war’s gonna end.<br> ~ Colonel Bill Kilgore, Apocalypse Now</blockquote><p>The mind of an Arahant is totally quenched, totally at peace. Like a hand moving freely through the air, the liberated mind is entirely unhindered by attachment or aversion and finds no resistance anywhere. Its unwavering aim is love, compassion, sympathy, and peace. Freed entirely from conceit, from restlessness, and ignorance, the arahant is unoppressed by anything they encounter.</p><blockquote>Not harsh, not greedy, not perturbed, everywhere in tune: this is the reward, I say when asked, for those who are free from pre-conceptions. For one unperturbed, who knows there is no accumulating, abstaining, unaroused, he sees security everywhere.<br> ~ Buddha, Attadanda Sutta</blockquote><p>We are trained to believe that security comes through control. The Self is a pattern rooted precisely in the insecurity we feel in the uncontrollability of nature, of life. The powerful impulses of the mind to consolidate and cohere reality through grasping, rejecting, and fantasy — are the most fundamental way in which we try to stop and solidify all that is unstable and changing. That pattern ends when we no longer feel threatened by reality. As the mind is more fully trained in reality — knows it’s objects inside and out, up and down, through and through — it develops greater and greater ease within the uncontrollable.</p><blockquote>What use is there for a well <br>if there is water everywhere? <br>When cravings root is severed <br>What should one go about seeking?<br> ~ Buddha, Udana</blockquote><p>When one sees clearly, there is understanding. When there is understanding, there is acceptance. When there is acceptance there is fearlessness. When there is no fear, the mind will let go. Thus we cannot expect the mind to let go until it is seeing clearly.</p><p>Arahantship may seem like an unattainable fantasy for many of us. On one hand, it is good to be humble and to respect the challenge of the path. But while a mind entirely freed from all hindrance is indeed a lofty goal whose pace of progress can feel insurmountable, it is also nothing that isn’t available to us directly in the experience of a single moment of mindfulness. If we develop a taste for the relief of that moment — of the refreshing and nourishing condition it creates in the heart — full enlightenment is the logical, natural, and inevitable conclusion of any effort we make to develop that capacity.</p><p>This is the value and function of chanda, the desire to act. None of this will happen on its own. We must put forth the effort now to attain that which our heart so powerfully longs for. And we must get in touch with the pain of this longing and use it as a motivator to achieve that freedom which is beyond comprehension.</p><p>We always have the option of heading to the monastery to take robes and ordain as monastics. Just knowing that is an incalculable refuge. However it is worth considering that for those of us seeking full liberation in these times we may have a responsibility to figure out how to do it as lay people in the social relations of our age. The west is in need of arahants and every experiment and effort we make toward that end will be of fruit to ourselves and to future generations looking for guidance and models of arahants who lived lives similar to theirs, born into conditions similar to theirs, folded their revolution back into society for the benefit of all.</p><p>We can do this. It is possible. But it will not happen on its own. It takes a profound development of skills that are considered dangerous to the regime of delusion we have lived under all our lives. Our skills of love and wisdom are not only a threat to the empire of our own delusion, but also to the greater society around us that is formed under Mara’s influence. Few will understand our longing nor the methods that we must take to cultivate the liberating power of the mind. Sangha and Sampavanka can support and inspire us. It is not possible to do it without them. But ultimately, our determination must come from within as our success or failure depends entirely upon our own efforts.</p><p>Talaputa Thera was a monk during the time of the Buddha. Trained as an actor, he came to the holy life after years of common disregard for his mind. After meeting the Buddha, he was eventually moved to abandon that life and live as a renunciate to follow the way of peace. “In no long time,” as it was commonly said, he himself became an arahant and achieved that happiness of peace which people of the ages have aspired to. Here are his words of longing as a layman, that may help incite the same beautiful aspiration toward freedom in our own hearts,</p><blockquote>O when will I come to live in mountain caves,<br>divorced from desire,<br>seeing clearly the impermanence of all that comes to be?</blockquote><blockquote>When will I, wearing patchwork robes,<br>be a true saint of yellow cloth,<br>without a thought of what is ‘mine’ — and from all cravings purified,<br>with lust and hate and illusions slain,<br>to the wild woods gone, and in bliss abide?</blockquote><blockquote>When will I see and know this body as unstable<br>a nest of dying and disease, oppressed by age and death,<br>and live free from fear, alone within the woods?</blockquote><blockquote>When will I, with insight’s sharpened sword<br>cut this vine of desire,<br>with all its tendrils twining far and strong,<br>breeder of many fears, bearer of pain and woe?<br>Yes, when will it come to be!?</blockquote><blockquote>When will I draw the sageʻs sword<br>forged of wisdom with fiery splendor <br>And swiftly shatter Mara and his host,<br>While seated still in the lionʻs pose?</blockquote><blockquote>When will I be seen in the noble company <br>of those who hold the Path in reverence, <br>given to noble toil, masters of their faculties <br>they who see to the heart of things,<br>When will this come to be?</blockquote><blockquote>When will slackness, hunger, and thirst distress me no more, <br>nor wind, nor heat, nor insects nor creeping things wreak harm<br>while I practice bent on my own goal in the wilderness?</blockquote><blockquote>O when will I, composed, intent,<br>with clarity come to touch<br>that which the great Sage understood -<br>the Four Noble Truths -<br>so difficult to see.<br>When will it be?</blockquote><blockquote>When will I, fastened to meditation’s calm<br>with wisdom see the innumerable sights and sounds,<br>odors, tastes, physical sensations, and objects of the mind<br>as things ablaze and burning?</blockquote><blockquote>When will I be unmoved by abusive speech,<br>and even when my praise is sung,<br>again be stilled in peace?<br>When will this come true for me?</blockquote><blockquote>When wIll I hold all the factors of my life:<br>wood, grass, vines, and all the countless objects known by sense, internal or outside,<br>judging them all alike — hollow, impermanent?</blockquote><blockquote>When will the purple storm-cloud of the rains break above my head<br>and with fresh torrents drench my robes in the woods,<br>in which I walk my way<br>along the Path the Seers have trod before?<br>When will this thing come to be?</blockquote><blockquote>When in a mountain cave, having heard the peacock’s cry,<br>that crested twice-born bird down in the wood,<br>shall I arise and summon thought and will<br>for attaining the ambrosial deathless?</blockquote><blockquote>O when will I, by spiritual powers<br>cross over the Gangā, Yamunā, Saraswtī rivers<br>unsinking, yes, float over the awful mouths<br>of hell-flung ocean waters?<br>Yes, when will this come to be?</blockquote><blockquote>When, like a charging elephant in battle,<br>shall I break through desire for sensual pleasure,<br>and, rapt in meditation, shun the marks <br>of outward beauty?</blockquote><blockquote>O when will I, like a pauper pressed<br>discover a hidden treasure,<br>and be filled with joy,<br>having attained the refuge of the Great Sage?<br>Yes, when will these things come to be?<br> ~Talaputa Thera</blockquote><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-15-afterword-9c47ee7fdab9"><em>Click here for the Afterword: </em><strong><em>MINDFULNESS</em></strong><em>: </em><strong><em>A Balm or a Bomb for Bablyon</em></strong><em>?</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0"><em>Click here for Chapter 12 (</em><strong>INTELLIGENCE</strong>: <br><em>Reporting / Education / International Support)</em></a></p><h3>I hope you have enjoyed what you have read so far!</h3><h3>In accordance with my tradition, I do not charge money for Dhamma teaching and am supported only on the freely-offered generosity of others.</h3><h3>If you have benefited from what you have read so far and want to support me or the promotion of the work, please consider two options for offering your generosity:</h3><h3>1. You can donate directly to me (as a tax-deductible contribution to Vipassana Hawaiʻi) <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=29&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>or</h3><h3>2. You can make a tax-deductable gift to a fund that will help promote and publish this book in a printed form that will be freely available to all by clicking <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=43&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>Thank you for your efforts to continue to propagate the Dhamma in this era in a way that holds the integrity and purity of the teachings.</h3><h3>~ Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc55ba5c3806" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {13}]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a2ebbf8f82e0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Dec 2019 08:24:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-01T06:52:29.529Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {13}</h3><h4>INTELLIGENCE: <br>Reporting / Education / International Support</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/921/1*no2v3kox5sD63DO0NVzkjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>OSPAAAL poster image by Rafael Zarza / Image courtesy Lincoln Cushing / Docs Populi</figcaption></figure><h3>Table of Contents</h3><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Preface</strong></a></p><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Introduction</strong></a></p><ol><li><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-1-5c0155ab82e"><strong>Sabotage</strong>: Dana / Sila</a></li></ol><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-2-3e2e7dfa6567">2. <strong>Indigenous Knowledge:</strong> <em>Bhavana</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-3-21b24f9c0675">3. <strong>Contact:</strong> <em>Aim /Attack / Harass</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-4-7e8180ac694d">4. <strong>Mobility:</strong> <em>Bases / Fluidity / Agility</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-5-c56e648af1c">5. <strong>Distrust:</strong> <em>Suspicion / Investigation</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-6-4cd23b6d08ae">6. <strong>Medicine:</strong> <em>Metta / Divine Abodes</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-7-6a55c91a04d">7. <strong>Retreat:</strong> <em>Encirclement / Escape</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-8-9f84a4893c4">8. <strong>Diversion:</strong> <em>Distraction / Misdirection</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-9-fed71316dfc0">9. <strong>General Strike:</strong> <em>Invisibility / Cessation</em></a></p><p>10. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-10-6a404425d159"><strong>The Guerrilla Band:</strong> <em>Camaraderie / Community</em></a></p><p>11. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-11-863b429e9269"><strong>Independence:</strong> <em>Responsibility/ Self-Retreat</em></a></p><p>12. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704"><strong>Intelligence:</strong> <em>Education / Reporting</em></a></p><p>13. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0"><strong>The Revolutionary Spirit:</strong> <em>Discipline / Determination / Faith</em></a></p><p>14. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806"><strong>Protracted War:</strong> <em>Land Reform / Regular Army / International Support</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-15-afterword-9c47ee7fdab9">15. {<strong>Afterword} Mindfulness: </strong><em>A Balm or a Bomb for Babylon?</em></a></p><h3>~ Chapter 13 ~</h3><h3>INTELLIGENCE: <br>Reporting / Education / International Support</h3><blockquote>Intelligence should compile all the information it can on all members of the guerrilla unit, all enemies, those indifferent to the movement; on the location of water, springs and rivers; on roads, highways, trails, bridges; on the conduct of the guerrilla members; on sympathizers who wish to join the unit; on soldiers, informers, spies, etc. At the same time it will obtain or make maps of the terrain and the principal targets in the sector assigned to the unit. It will conduct espionage and counterespionage activities, keep records on unit personnel regarding all combat performance whether outstanding or unimpressive; and carry on cryptographic work (coding and deciphering messages, documents of courts martial, etc.). <br> ~Alberto Bayo Giroud, One Hundred Fifty Questions to a Guerrilla</blockquote><p>One of the most essential and difficult aspects of the Guerrilla campaign is the process of amassing, discerning, and putting to use information from a variety of sources — public, experiential, clandestine, rumor, and theoretical. Understanding that the enemy will begin their own sophisticated disinformation campaign, it is vital for a rebel movement to be confident in its ability to get accurate reporting and to trust its sources — or at least have a sense of what degree and in regards to what spheres each can be trusted.</p><p>Being able to keep tabs on the enemy, get a sense of their movements, understand how they work often requires covert operations. For the guerrilla this means having a network and program of espionage and informants whose lives are embedded in the opposition camp or in the public domain where the enemy spends time — formally or casually. For the guerrilla yogi, this means that it is necessary to gather intelligence from within the fortress of delusion, by building networks of information and applying a careful and measured relationship with wholesome and unwholesome mental factors. First and foremost it means developing a program for both practical and theoretical knowledge.</p><p>In order to discern the truth about what we are learning from various sources the guerrilla yogi must rely on both experiential and theoretical tools. We try our best to observe all experience directly, internally and externally, from the most subtle to the most gross, but it is also important to have a theoretical framework — based on study and education — that helps us make sense of what we are seeing, to learn the lessons of what we observe, to interpret correctly, and make functional use of our observations. The flood of experience we are trying to observe can be so overwhelming that we need conceptual frameworks to translate our direct experience into knowledge of what would otherwise seem simply chaotic.</p><p>It is important to distinguish early-on the difference between direct and conceptual knowledge. Both kinds of knowledge have their place in our deepening ability to understand what we see. Primarily we are concerned with empirical reality, ultimate truths — <em>paramattha sacca</em> — as directly experienced through vipassana practice. Secondarily we uplift value and role of conceptual knowledge of conventional truths —<em> samuti sacca</em> — that we may encounter in the literature and logic of the tradition, as aspects of conventional reality still supportive of our training and development.</p><blockquote>At first a few of us lived together in a house and we had to teach the young people how to handle a weapon. Men took to the weapons quickly, but for women it was harder and more alien, so we placed special emphasis on it. Then came the theoretical discussions about what defense is and how people can protect themselves. This process gave the families trust, and so more women came to us.<br> ~Karaçox, YPJ fighter, Rojava, Syria</blockquote><h4>REPORTING</h4><blockquote>It is necessary for guerrillas to know how to make speedy and accurate reports. You must write clearly, using block letter if your handwriting is at all indistinct, and always printing clearly the names of places, persons, regiments and so on, also the words NO and NOT. Always use the 24-hour clock. Number every message you send back so that your commander will know if the previous one is missing. When you have put every known fact into you message — answer the questions: What? How many? Where? When? Going where? Doing what? What weapons?” — you can draw a line and then put your own comments as to what you think the event reported probably means. Do not mix your guess with the known facts.<br> ~ Bert “Yank” Levy</blockquote><p>One of the ways that we begin to subvert this tendency to live in the conceptual is through the process of mental noting, of labeling experience as it arises. This method is important as part of our momentary experience in practice, releasing us from concept and developing the mind’s ability to stay directly in relationship to actual arising and passing experience. It is also important to create a chart of our experience over time. By keeping track of our mental notings we are offered an important means of tracing our progress, creating a map of our inner terrain, developing appropriate strategies and tactics based on past experiences. This involves learning to formulate detailed and accurate reports of our experience — for our own review or for the review of a teacher who is supporting us. The Mahasi Sayadaw method of reporting is one such way that is invaluable to this process.[1]</p><p>When reporting to your teacher or simply taking notes for yourself, your observation of body and mind can be reported according to the following three-step procedure:</p><p><strong>1. What is your primary target?</strong> i.e. the rising and falling movement of the abdomen, hands touching, the body, sound, etc.<br><strong>2. What did you note / notice?</strong> i.e. what you became aware of in terms of qualities, sensations, textures, and characteristics.<br><strong>3. What happened to the object when observed?</strong> i.e. what you noticed over time as the object persists, dissipates, increases in intensity, decreases, changes, etc.</p><p>For example,</p><p><em>I watched the abdomen rise (or fall).<br>I labeled it as “rising, rising” (or “falling, falling”).<br>I became aware of stretching, pressure, stiffness, tension, etc. and noted accordingly.<br>I felt pressure increase gradually (or, perhaps, when falling, I felt pressure decrease).</em></p><p>It is very important to describe your primary object in clear, simple and precise terms with all the accurate details you have observed. Only after that should you continue to report on the secondary objects.</p><blockquote>On the air, keep your messages clear and to the point to guarantee speed and security in communication.<br> ~ Alberto Bayo Giroud</blockquote><p><strong>Secondary Targets </strong><br>The secondary targets can be (but are not limited to) the following:</p><p><strong>Bodily sensations:</strong> pressure, throbbing, itching, etc.<br><strong>Thoughts:</strong> ideas, planning, remembering, thinking, etc.<br><strong>Emotions: </strong>anger, pride, joy, happiness, etc.<br><strong>Other Sensations:</strong> Sounds (hearing), images (seeing), etc.</p><p>While mindfully pursuing the primary target, if any secondary targets become predominant, a yogi can turn the mind toward that target and mindfully observe it. After the reporting on the primary target, meditators also report the experience of the secondary targets according to the above three-step procedure. For example,</p><p><em>I noticed a painful sensation in the knee and I noted it as “pain, pain.”<br>I looked more closely and noticed warmth and a stabbing sensation. I noted as “stabbing, stabbing.”<br>After some time, I experienced it as slow pulsating hardness. I noted “hard, hard, hard”<br>I began to notice a decreased in intensity at the end of each pulse.<br>After a few more minutes it disappeared altogether. <br>Then I went back to the primary target which is the rising and falling movement of the abdomen.</em></p><p>Our initial recognition may be something conceptual like “hearing a car” or “feeling pain” but the yogi is always encouraged to look more deeply than the conceptual and investigate the non-conceptual experience that we still may find a label for. “A rumbling sound” or “intense pressure” might be better descriptions of our actual direct experience. When reporting different kinds of thoughts such as planning, imagining, judging, daydreaming, etc, or emotions such as anger, frustration, happiness, etc, meditators should report them objectively without mentioning whom or what they are thinking about or who or what makes them angry, etc.</p><p><em>I found myself lost in thoughts.<br>I noted as “thinking, thinking” or “planning, planning” or “remembering, remembering.”<br>I noticed frustration arise and I noted “frustration, frustration.”<br>After a while, it disappeared and I noticed warmth in the area of the heart. <br>These sensations were pleasant and so I noted “pleasant, pleasant”<br>Then I went back to the primary target.</em></p><p>A Sample of a Comprehensive Report:</p><p><em>I noted the rising and falling movement of the abdomen as a primary object of meditation. When I noted the rising, I experienced tension and pressure and noted them. Then I noted the falling motion as “falling, falling.” My experience of falling was not very clear. I found my mind wandered and noted it as “wandering, wandering,” and after a while it stopped. I then went back to the primary target of rising and falling movement of the abdomen.</em></p><p><em>A painful sensation arose in my back. I noted it as “pain, pain.” When I looked more closely, it intensified and I saw it as throbbing. I noted “throbbing, throbbing” then “warmth, warmth” and eventually it lessened and finally disappeared. I noticed a sense of mental relief and noted “relief, relief” and then returned to the rising and falling movement of the abdomen.</em></p><p><em>Suddenly, a sound occurred. I noted “hearing, hearing” and then an itching sensation arose in the face. I noted it as “itching, itching.” I noticed irritation and noted “aversion” and a strong desire to move my hand to scratch which I labeled “wanting, wanting.” At some point I found myself lost in thought which I noted as “thinking, thinking.” The itch had disappeared and I returned to the primary target of the rising and falling movement of the abdomen.</em></p><p>Your experience in the walking meditation can be reported using the same method,</p><p><em>In my walking meditation I began by noticing the sensations of lifting at the bottom of the foot. I noted “light, light” as the pressure got less intense. Then I noted “stretching, stretching” as I felt the foot move forward through the air, “placing, placing” or “dropping, dropping” and “heaviness” as the foot moved back to the ground. Finally I noted “light touch, pressure, hardness”, and coolness as the foot made contact with the ground…</em></p><p>The encouragement is toward a non-conceptual precision and as much detail as possible. When the mind is not so clear as to provide such intense detail, it is important to note that and to note the other factors of mind arising before and after any given experience. After all, we are not only learning to observe the body but eventually seek to observe the mind as well and then follow the process of unfolding experience as it relates to this dynamic. Walking meditation can be our most important entry point into the investigation into nama and rupa because we can more easily observe how the mental intention to move leads to the physical activity of the body, and then how the physical experience of the body leads to body consciousness in the mind. Observing this process profoundly is considered to be the beginning of our formal insight journey and can lead all the way to the end. But for most yogis their first experience of nibbana can be so fleeting as to seem unnoticeable and without this precise training of mind — impossible to see and understand fully.</p><p><strong>1) Try to keep your report to your direct experience, not your interpretation or judgement of it.<br> 2) A good report is a condensed snap-shot of a few minutes, or even just a few moments, of our most clear sitting or walking period.<br> 3) Don’t feel too much pressure to be too precise or too perfect — just note what you observe!</strong></p><p>Over time our reports may have more or less detail and may describe a range of experiences. Don’t expect this kind of reporting description to simply go in one direction of what we imagine “progress” to look like. We may notice more or less mental activity, more or less concentration, more or less anything and it may not mean what you think it does. A single report is best understood in relationship to a series of reports over time. With experience, a yogi begins to see patterns in their internal experience. For example, when pain arises we may notice that doubt soon follows. Patterns become familiar and less personal. We can become interested in processes and relationships that used to frustrate us. Keep your scent on trail. Keep records. Commit as much as you can to memory.</p><h4>EDUCATION</h4><blockquote>Information must be factual to build up confidence among the people in the national movement. What it must do it this:<br> 1) Give the people tenacity to stand up to the enemy by showing them the struggle is worthwhile and necessary. They must be made aware that the national struggle will be victorious in the end — but that the end depends on them.<br> 2) Get world public opinion behind the just fight of the people.<br> 3) Undermine the enemy’s morale and his propaganda by exposing his methods and by constant emphasis on the unjustness of his cause.<br> 4) Be the spiritual mainspring of those actively engaged in the national movement so that they understand the need to destroy the enemy and his power forever.<br> ~ Handbook for Volunteers of the Irish Republican Army</blockquote><p>Though the Buddha had a variety of teachers with whom he trained in a range of meditative techniques (mostly related to concentration), none of them had attained the complete liberation he aspired to and so could not offer him guidance toward that final goal. He had to figure it out for himself. The amount of faith that must have been necessary for Siddhartha Gautama to fulfill his mission is utterly staggering. Finding one’s own way to freedom in the dark, with no sense that it had been done before, not even that it was possible, took human qualities of inconceivable beauty and magnitude. Indeed, one of the particular points of reverence for the Buddha is that he was samasabuddhasa — “rightly self-awakened.” The deeper into the path we get, the more profound can be our appreciation for having the guidance of the Buddha himself as well as multitudes of others who have attained the path before us.</p><p>This guidance should be taken up, studied, questioned, explored, and ultimately integrated into our own practice: accepted if it works, rejected if it backfires, transformed where that is called for, but all with the most rigor and care that we can muster. No one else’s word should be taken as fact until we have experienced it. No oneʻs word should be rejected until we are absolutely confident in its fault. Nothing should be changed without the utmost reserve and testing. We will benefit from reading, listening, learning, questioning, and wrestling with the words and teachings, the traditions and cultures, that have come before us. They should not be accepted without inquiry but neither should they be rejected outright just because they don’t immediately align with our philosophy of what we think should be true.</p><blockquote>Theory is very necessary but unmethodical study yields no result. <br>Therefore in studying theory we have to stress that theory must be integrated with practice.<br> ~ Ho Chi Minh</blockquote><p>We must rigorously differentiate between what we believe to be true, what we want to be true, and what we know to be true. This requires a careful, whole hearted, and honest process of praxis — of theory and experiential application. Even when it comes to Buddhist theory, though, we have so much to choose from that it can be overwhelming. Bookstores are filled with meditation and “mindfulness” instruction in many flavors and with many variations. All of it should be approached with utmost skepticism. It is rare in the world to find people truly interested in release, in disenchantment, in the ending of constructed being. Most authors will seek to use the practice in ways that reaffirm their identities and yours. But the Dhamma “goes against the stream” and we should always measure any book by the relationship to what has been said by the ancients.</p><p>An important encouragement for the guerrilla yogi is to trust the tradition as the foundation of your theoretical knowledge. Not without healthy skepticism, but the ancient texts — the Pali cannon and the collection of Nikaya suttas that are available in book form and online — will serve you well as the primary basis of the framework of your exploration. There is a rich, robust, and diverse array of teachings therein that form a coherent structure of profound relevance as well as historic interest.</p><p>Who can say that the texts of the tradition are entirely trustworthy? Who can say that they all truly offer the words of the Buddha? No one. There are many questions to wrestle with in regards to translation, to the potentially detrimental impact of oral transmission over hundreds of years, to the patriarchal agenda of the early compilers, to the nature of Buddha-hood and whether the Buddha himself, enlightened as he was, had enduring aspects of personality that were more complex than the tradition would like to admit. Many of these are things that will never be resolved and so we can take our inheritance with profound gratitude, open-mindedness, and a healthy a dose of rational but engaged skepticism. A guerrilla yogi knows that they cannot trust all information from all sources. But because of the broad general coherence of the suttas, one begins to get a sense of where to be suspicious, where to have confidence, and where to be careful.</p><blockquote>There are some militarists who say: ‘We are not interested in politics but only in the profession of arms.’ It is vital that these simple-minded militarists be made to realize the relationship that exists between politics and military affairs. Military action is a method used to attain a political goal. While military affairs and political affairs are not identical, it is impossible to isolate one from the other. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>Ancient devout teachers and practitioners put vast amounts of time and consideration into the interpretations of the suttas as well as formulations of method and frameworks that are invaluable — if not always entirely trustworthy. The compilers of the tradition had agendas — some obvious, some hidden, some unconscious — that impacted their motivations and their decisions about their efforts. Where the Abhidhamma succeeds most brilliantly is in its description of momentary experience of consciousness. Where it comes up short is often in trying to create an objective explanation of material reality outside of consciousness. Just because we know to be suspicious of some of the data from this source doesn’t mean we disregard the whole body. There are pieces we learn to absorb and trust and others that will call us to look at our experience with more earnest investigation.</p><p>For example, abhidhamma literature suggests that one cannot be mindful of anger because you cannot have a moment of sati and dosa arise at the same moment — a moment of mindfulness is a wholesome moment not tainted by greed, hatred, or delusion and so cannot exist at the same moment as anger. It recognizes instead that the arising and passing distinct moments of anger and mindfulness in rapid succession can feel as if we are being mindful of anger, and so we can observe it fruitfully. Is this true? When we look as closely as possible what do we experience? Does our sense of this change one day to the next? It is also said that the physical water element cannot be experienced directly, that what we notice actually is the combination of air, earth, and fire elements in quick succession, providing the sensation of cool cohesion. Is this true? Check it out. The literature says that visual shape does not exist as a fundamental reality of which we can be conscious, but color does — and so shape is a product of mental perception in relationship to the boundaries of color. Is this true? Check it out.</p><p>Theravada abhidhamma presents experience in particle form: life, being, as a chain of momentary experiences, arising and passing, each conditioning the arising of the next. Life as we begin to see it is a flux between nama and rupa, name and form, in dynamic interplay giving the perspective of dimensionality. Modern science recognizes that all light and matter have a dual nature: both a particle form and a wave form, depending on how we look at it. We should not assume that the particle form of the abhidhamma is the only way to see or understand reality, but it is a helpful and true one that puts our normal perspective in a liberating light.</p><blockquote>79. How will our men be busy when there is no immediate task?<br>They will relax during the day, wash their feet daily and take care of their toenails since feet and legs are the engines of the guerrilla. They will study the maps of the region, memorizing the names of all nearby villages, and their population and some of the names of the people, they will identify on a blank chart all rivers, tributary rivers, springs, reservoirs, and wells. They will learn the distances between different points within that sector and the location of bridges and sewers that might be used for train sabotage. In other words they must learn by heart whatever piece of information might be helpful to carry on the war or to facilitate the tasks of other sections of the militia.<br> ~ Alberto Bayo Giroud</blockquote><p>The closer in time we get to literature formed in the present, the more questions arise about of caliber of the material and the minds that created it. There is good writing out there, but it takes a lot of sifting through to find it. Since we only have a certain amount of time to dedicate to our studies, it is always best to go with the Nikayas and commentarial literature.</p><p>At best, the Nikayas can be deeply informative and inspiring. On the other hand, they can sometimes hold such a high standard that we wither and feel ourselves humiliated in comparison. We don’t measure up. The tone in many of the suttas can also be very male, very macho, and striving oriented. This is likely because it was men who dominated the tradition for a very long time, and a particular kind of man has thrived in that religious culture and been empowered to pass it down. In this way, what is offered as universal does not have the self-awareness of the historic and cultural particularity that it embodies. That is how mainstream privilege works and why the voices at the margin are so important.</p><blockquote>Classes were run in caves; each village sent a person to study for a few days, then he went back and taught his co-villagers. When his knowledge was exhausted he returned to the class and learned some more. While teaching others, the teachers also learned themselves. Such was the method we adopted for the mass education work and for its development into a movement…</blockquote><blockquote>The organization of teaching should be in accordance with the living conditions of the learners, then the movement will last and bear good results. Our compatriots are still poor and cannot afford paper and pens, therefore a small pocket exercise-book is enough for each person. Reading and writing exercises can be done anywhere, using charcoal, the ground, or banana leaves as pens and paper. Clandestine cadres were to teach and make one person literate every three months.<br> ~ Ho Chi Minh</blockquote><h4>INTERNATIONAL SUPPORT</h4><blockquote>Our Party grew and developed in the favourable international conditions created by the victory of the great October Revolution. The achievements of the Party and the people are inseparable from the fraternal support accorded us by the Soviet Union, People’s China and the other socialist countries, the international Communist and workers’ movement and the national-liberation movement and also the peace movement. We were able to surmount all difficulties and lead the people to glorious victories because the Party did not divorce the revolutionary movement in its own country from the revolutionary movement of the world proletariat and the national-liberation movement of the oppressed people.<br> ~ Ho Chi Minh</blockquote><p>The Algerian war of independence from France was one of the first coherent uses of international pressure to support a guerrilla liberation movement. The leaders of the FLN used relationships with western media outfits to highlight French war-atrocities in order to garner international public sympathy. They strategically used the policy mechanisms of the United Nations to apply pressure to France and leveraged cold-war tensions between the United States and the Soviet Union to gain support from both for their independence cause.</p><p>Cuban and Vietnamese revolutionary struggles would not have succeeded without funds, arms, and strategic guidance offered by more developed sympathetic states. Vietnam could never have resisted American interference for so long and with such success without the financial and military support of the Soviet Union and China. Many guerrillas in African struggles needed and utilized bases across borders in friendly countries to run back to for security. Vital support comes not only from states but from individuals living in foreign lands. Algerian forces in the revolution depended upon financial support from Algerians living in France. The IRA depended on funds from Irish Americans. The Republican side of the Spanish Civil War depended on volunteers from around the world to form the ranks of their battalions. In many ways the revolution cannot be bound by national boarders.</p><p>Accepting the support of hegemonic institutions larger and more powerful than yourself is fundamental to success but it is also a dangerous game. To what degree are policies dictated from afar? When do the foreign mandates clash with our native interests? When are we beholden to these forces even when they are in the wrong or when their deeper motivations run counter to our long-term goals? What are the costs of allegiance to foreign establishments and institutions of power?</p><p>A similar dynamic can be found in our relationships between our mode of practice and our tradition in Asia we well as our relationships with other Buddhist traditions, or other religious traditions entirely.</p><p>For a long time I believed that it was unnecessary to go and practice or pilgrimage in Asia. Meditation can be practiced anywhere because the Dhamma can be found anywhere, in any object, in any moment, in any cultural context, in any time and place. We have good teachers in the West. We have supportive facilities. We have a growing body of resources that are available to more and more people, in books, online and elsewhere. But after going to Burma year after year, where my tradition is rooted, I have come to see how important a connection this is for me: in personal relationships, certainly, but perhaps more uniquely in having the opportunity to spend time in a cultural context where the Dhamma is the norm, where the dominant culture is a Buddhist culture, and a baseline respect for the Buddha, the Dhamma, the Sangha, and for intensive practice is unquestioned and honored. To be in a place where faith in the Dhamma is all around you is incredibly supportive, like filling a vitamin deficiency you didn’t know you had. This may be especially true in our early years of practice when we may feel at odds with the dominant culture, where we may need to hide our Buddhist-ness. To be “out” and to be open and to share and be nourished by the ambience of faith is no small thing.</p><p>There is a profound experience to be in a place where people speak of the Buddha as if he just walked through the village last week — as if we had just missed him — where they still wrap his statue in a shawl when the night is cold. To be in a village where people speak of arahants known to be alive today, ones they met as children, or whose bodies are still entombed in a nearby pagoda, provide an unfamiliar comfort. To hear the multitude of stories of meditators whose striving has inspired people for generations, to walk beside a field where it is said one monk flew across every day to get his breakfast, to walk into a cool limestone cave and feel the all-pervasive vibe, like the opposite of a nuclear bomb, of someone who attained enlightenment there a hundred years ago — has an impact and can give you the energy and momentum of faith that a tradition is supposed to provide.</p><p>If we pay close enough attention and keep our investigative minds sharp, spending time in a Buddhist culture is both inspiring and disenchanting. The deep social integration of ethics and Buddhist mythology is profound and important. At the same time we find that these societies are equally subject to the same forces of inequality, prejudice, violence and greed, as our own or others. The institutions of the Dhamma themselves are not free from scandal or degradation, and these things can be very challenging to negotiate. Many of our traditions come out of orthodox religious institutions that are troubled in one way or another or at the very least have dramatic blind spots that are antiquated or oppressive. Most stark are often the deeply sexist traditions embedded in the religion and culture that have resulted in the prohibition of full female monastic ordination. Even more basically we encounter the fundamental subservience of nuns to monks within the traditional sāsana ordination. Of course one can effortlessly find representatives of the Dhamma who hold views that are racist, classist, prejudiced in one way or another.</p><p>In many countries where Buddhism is the religion of the majority — and/or practiced by the majority ethnic group — we find that it has all the trappings of any dominant culture, especially when it comes to the relationship with minority ethnic or religious communities. Persecutions, injustice, ethnic superiority, nationalism, and prejudice of all kinds are just as evident in Buddhist societies as Christian ones. Buddhist religious infrastructure can be just as sinister and imperious and dedicated to oppressive social economic power-structures as Christian churches are in the West or Muslim mosques are in the central Asia or North Africa. The recent Bamar-Buddhist violence against the Rohingya Muslim people in Burma is only the most recent — if most atrocious — explosion of vitriol on the part of the Buddhist majority against minority ethnic groups in the country. These realities can help us pierce the fantasy of a Buddhist majority in the west, obliterating the notion that mindfulness will save any society.</p><p>Generally, we will still be able to find in some corner a person or place that we feel deeply embodies the shining path of liberation that we are deeply drawn to, and this may be in the midst of a multitude of things we find disheartening. It can cause us to question our assumptions about the social value of the Dhamma, of the lineage that we are a part of. This is good. It is so much better to wrestle with our tradition than to blindly follow it, or blindly dismiss it. Indeed, in the west our habitual arrogance of view is a fundamental weakness that should be kept always in check. Our relationship to traditional Buddhist cultures — especially those still rooted in rural village life — can help give us fresh eyes on notions of obedience, admonishment, cosmopolitan privilege.</p><p>When we come into deeper engagement with our spiritual heritage, we complicate and enrich our path. These relationships with people and cultures are necessary as we collectively learn to practice together, to struggle together, to develop solidarity amid real differences, real problems. We are living in a time where shared learning has untold potential for fostering vitality to the contemporary expression of the sāsana.</p><p>The guerrilla yogi by their nature holds deferential respect for the ancient institutions of our tradition (and of others) but also assumes the highest degree of personal responsibility and freedom of movement in terms of general operational functioning. We are certainly not beholden to them when it comes to issues of social oppression.</p><blockquote>We on the Arab front were very intimate with the enemy. Our Arab officers had been Turkish officers, and knew every leader on the other side personally. They had suffered the same training, thought the same, took the same point of view. By practising modes of approach upon the Arabs we could explore the Turks: understand, almost get inside, their minds. Relation between us and them was universal, for the civil population of the enemy area was wholly ours without pay or persuasion. In consequence out intelligence service was the widest, fullest and most certain imaginable. <br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>There are countless sources of wisdom in the world and different experiences and expressions of it can be supportive of our practice — and relationships across these differences can be a dynamic blend of challenging and nourishing. We will benefit from that flexibility to find our own sources of inspirational materials, while always begin careful to understand what is and what isn’t in precise alignment with the teaching of the Buddha as our tradition holds it. Cold Mountain, Rumi, Hafiz, Mary Oliver, Rilke, Tupac, or Biggie may inspire us — and we can value that inspiration while still understanding the limits of their resonance, where the frequency doesn’t quite match.</p><p>Of course we prefer our wisdom organic, free-range, and freshly-squeezed when possible. But knowing how vast wilderness is and how disorienting the desert can be the guerrilla yogi eats where there is food and drinks from whatever source they find. In desperate times, they are not so proud as to refuse wisdom from a can.</p><blockquote>We had to arrange their minds in order of battle just as carefully and as formally as other officers would arrange their bodies. And not only our own men’s minds…We must also arrange the minds of the enemy, so far as we could teach them; then those other minds of the nation supporting us behind the firing line… then the minds of the enemy nation waiting the verdict; and of the neutrals looking on; circle beyond circle.<br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>[1] Much of the content of this section has been adapted from the reporting instructions of the Panditarama Meditation Center in Burma.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806"><em>Click here for Chapter 14 (</em><strong>PROTRACTED WAR:</strong> <br><em>Land Reform / Crisis / Building a Regular Army)</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704"><em>Click here for Chapter 12 (</em><strong>The Revolutionary Spirit:</strong> <em>Discipline / Determination / Faith)</em></a></p><h3>I hope you have enjoyed what you have read so far!</h3><h3>In accordance with my tradition, I do not charge money for Dhamma teaching and am supported only on the freely-offered generosity of others.</h3><h3>If you have benefited from what you have read so far and want to support me or the promotion of the work, please consider two options for offering your generosity:</h3><h3>1. You can donate directly to me (as a tax-deductible contribution to Vipassana Hawaiʻi) <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=29&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>or</h3><h3>2. You can make a tax-deductable gift to a fund that will help promote and publish this book in a printed form that will be freely available to all by clicking <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=43&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>Thank you for your efforts to continue to propagate the Dhamma in this era in a way that holds the integrity and purity of the teachings.</h3><h3>~ Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a2ebbf8f82e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {12}]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/830412dfd704</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vipassana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Dec 2019 08:22:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-01T06:51:59.806Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {12}</h3><h4>THE REVOLUTIONARY SPIRIT: <br>Discipline / Determination / Faith</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/921/1*no2v3kox5sD63DO0NVzkjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>OSPAAAL poster image by Rafael Zarza / Image courtesy Lincoln Cushing / Docs Populi</figcaption></figure><h3>Table of Contents</h3><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Preface</strong></a></p><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Introduction</strong></a></p><ol><li><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-1-5c0155ab82e"><strong>Sabotage</strong>: Dana / Sila</a></li></ol><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-2-3e2e7dfa6567">2. <strong>Indigenous Knowledge:</strong> <em>Bhavana</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-3-21b24f9c0675">3. <strong>Contact:</strong> <em>Aim /Attack / Harass</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-4-7e8180ac694d">4. <strong>Mobility:</strong> <em>Bases / Fluidity / Agility</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-5-c56e648af1c">5. <strong>Distrust:</strong> <em>Suspicion / Investigation</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-6-4cd23b6d08ae">6. <strong>Medicine:</strong> <em>Metta / Divine Abodes</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-7-6a55c91a04d">7. <strong>Retreat:</strong> <em>Encirclement / Escape</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-8-9f84a4893c4">8. <strong>Diversion:</strong> <em>Distraction / Misdirection</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-9-fed71316dfc0">9. <strong>General Strike:</strong> <em>Invisibility / Cessation</em></a></p><p>10. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-10-6a404425d159"><strong>The Guerrilla Band:</strong> <em>Camaraderie / Community</em></a></p><p>11. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-11-863b429e9269"><strong>Independence:</strong> <em>Responsibility/ Self-Retreat</em></a></p><p>12. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704"><strong>Intelligence:</strong> <em>Education / Reporting</em></a></p><p>13. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0"><strong>The Revolutionary Spirit:</strong> <em>Discipline / Determination / Faith</em></a></p><p>14. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806"><strong>Protracted War:</strong> <em>Land Reform / Regular Army / International Support</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-15-afterword-9c47ee7fdab9">15. {<strong>Afterword} Mindfulness: </strong><em>A Balm or a Bomb for Babylon?</em></a></p><h3>~ Chapter 12 ~</h3><h3>THE REVOLUTIONARY SPIRIT: <br>Discipline / Determination / Faith</h3><blockquote>These forces should have a strict discipline, a high morale, and a clear comprehension of the task to be performed, without conceit, without illusions, without false hopes of an easy triumph. The struggle will be bitter and long, reverses will be suffered; they will be at the brink of annihilation; only high morale, discipline, faith in final victory, and exceptional leadership can save them.<br> ~ Ernesto “Che” Guevara, Guerrilla Warfare</blockquote><p>Within the scope of historical guerrilla movements there is an enormous range of structure in regards to hierarchical command and centralized coordination. Every movement must define these structures according to internal and external conditions specific to their situation. All orientations will have their strengths and weaknesses. But even in the least coercive guerrilla formations that seek to create a society that is entirely free from hierarchy, some level of obedience to authority is necessary.</p><p>We live in an era where among the left-leaning there is a broadening assumption that an egalitarian and democratic ethic is assumed to be best in all circumstances. Activists increasingly hold authority — even temporary authority — as suspect. It is an understandable stance, and generally the result of a healthy affirmation of personal dignity and resistance to oppressive human systems. But this resistance has a shadow: the tendency to tear down all leaders is something that frequently holds movements back from gaining power and momentum. Vague leadership leads to lack of direction and tendency to get bogged down in process and indecision. Fear of action can be confused for inclusivity and patience. It is again a place where we must embrace paradox in order to make the most of the dilemma.</p><p>Over the centuries, lay and monastic Buddhist communities, like all others rooted in patriarchy, have at times supported abusive and manipulative behavior by their leaders. This reality helps fuel the contemporary concern that unrestrained spiritual authority has too deep a tendency toward corruption to be an effective model. While this is a vital concern whose charge will be of great value when brought into Buddhist community in healthy ways, it must also be balanced with the ability to use the benefits of authority when it is of value to ourselves and to the system as a whole. It is good to acknowledge that some people have more experience and training than we do, more profound understanding of vipassana insight than we do. If we accept this then some degree of sublimation of one’s own impulses and ego and submission to the guidance of a teacher is going to be fundamental to progress along the path.</p><p>In the old days, monastic teachers were often stern and severe. They were not there to entertain: they were at war with the greed, hatred, and delusion in your heart and were going to give you as little room as possible to evade the confrontation they were dedicated to. Burmese monks would hold a fan in front of their faces when giving Dhamma talks to make it clear that the teaching was not about personality — as a protection from the projections of their students onto them. Nowadays, lay teachers in the west are expected to be funny, engaging, likable, worldly, friendly, emotionally and temporally available, without rough edges or fault. People want their teachers to be a projection of their own fantasy selves and will abandon them at the first sign of disagreement or firm boundary-holding.</p><blockquote>In any revolutionary army, there is unity of purpose as far as both officers and men are concerned, and, therefore, within such an army, discipline is self-imposed… because only when it is, is the soldier able to understand completely why he fights and why he must obey. This type of discipline becomes a tower of strength within the army, and it is the only type that can truly harmonize the relationship that exists between officers and soldiers. In any system where discipline is externally imposed, the relationship that exists between officer and man is characterized by indifference of the one to the other. The idea that officers can physically beat or severely tongue-lash their men is a feudal one and is not in accord with the conception of a self-imposed discipline. Discipline of the feudal type will destroy internal unity and fighting strength. A discipline self-imposed is the primary characteristic of a democratic system in the army. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>There is a lack of strong ethic or expectation of commitment. People bounce from teacher to teacher, abandoning a method at the first sign of difficult challenge, critique, or even boredom. Like a child, a yogi doesn’t want to hear the word “no.” But until they are mature enough to see the powerful forces of delusion at play in the mind, they must subject themselves to some degree of mirroring and restraint in order to learn.</p><p>Part of the problem today is certainly capitalism. Conventional yogis are tempted to relate to the process as consumers — shopping around until they find someone who tells them what they want to hear and in the way they want to hear it. People know that their teachers are not Gods. This is refreshing and necessary. But the pendulum can swing so far as to not respect the teacher at all. A common attitude is that the teacher is working for the student, hired as a consultant or therapist, and this is extremely dangerous for the yogis, for the teachers, and for the future of the Dhamma. The yogi is never pushed to hear the truth beyond their delusions and teachers are more and more compelled to speak what is profitable and popular rather than what is true.</p><blockquote>Further, in such an army, the mode of living of the officers and the soldiers must not differ too much, and this is particularly true in the case of guerrilla troops. Officers should live under the same conditions as their men, for that is the only way in which they can gain from their men the admiration and confidence so vital in war. It is incorrect to hold to a theory of equality in all things, but there must be equality of existence in accepting the hardships and dangers of war. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>Students should be very careful about selecting a teacher. But when they do find someone they can trust, it is important to resolve to staying with them. This doesn’t mean we submit to abuse but certainly through challenges, disappointments, and conflicts. A yogi will be profoundly hindered in their progress with only their own preference as their guide.</p><p>Yogis who do commit to a teacher discover for themselves how refreshing it is to be humble, to be grateful, to acknowledge that there are others who know more than they do. This is true even if, especially if, they also seem to share many of their imperfections. It can be truly inspiring to learn that what you want to be true may not always be the truth, and the the actual truth may not be what you want to hear. We will benefit from an attitude where we seek to have our eyes cleared and the truth revealed, not one where we seek to have our views reaffirmed. Something is wrong with our motivation if we are not open to learning and just want to shore up all the beliefs we want to maintain about ourselves and the world. To receive the help and guidance of a teacher and feel that sense of gratitude and dedication is fulfilling and powerful. To find a teacher that you respect and trust and are willing to follow is a wonderful and an essential component to the path.</p><p>When I first met my own teacher I quickly realized that I had found someone who I trusted: who understood my practice, my mind, who had herself been thoroughly trained and understood her own practice and mind better than anyone I had ever met. While I have learned things of great value from many people, I have had only one teacher. I needed nothing else and I knew I didn’t need to shop around. When one has found master why go search for flavors of mediocrity?</p><p>While a guerrilla yogi ought to acknowledge the authority of a teacher for guidance, instruction, and to occasionally lend them faith, they also know that can never depend on their teacher to provide the fundamental impulse toward revolutionary change. It is their own determination and longing for freedom which must be the ultimate force behind their endeavor.</p><blockquote>The basis for guerrilla discipline must be the individual conscience. With guerrillas, a discipline of compulsion is ineffective. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>If we rely only on self-direction, we will inevitably be motivated by forces that we do not acknowledge or even see. If we only learn to rely on externally imposed discipline, we wont learn how to operate on the edges of our motivation and never learn to distinguish discipline from something like determination, which is a more profound and healthier relationship to our behavior. Ultimately, dedication and determination are much more vital than discipline because on some level discipline is always going to be a behavior that is enforced based on an idea of how things should be, rather than internally born from that reality itself. It is imposed rather than inspired, and while it may at times be necessary, we should never imagine that discipline requires even a fraction of the potency that determination does. Over our entire practice lives we can learn to be skillful about the places where we trust our own decisions, where we are experimenting with them, and where we voluntarily place ourselves in conditions where a kind of discipline is protected and encouraged/enforced. All of us need to explore this range of terrain and learn to make wise decisions and evaluate the outcomes.</p><blockquote>More than any other soldier the fighting morale of the guerrilla must be on a very high plane. Every volunteer is imbued with aggressive confidence in his fighting skill and the importance of that skill to his comrades and to his people. This pride will lead him to do the apparently impossible — and the “impossible”will seem easy as a consequence. His enthusiasm will be infectious and generate such power that no force on earth can stop it. For the fight he is engaged in is worthy of nothing less.<br> ~ Handbook for Volunteers of the Irish Republican Army</blockquote><p>Early in our practice life we generally come to see that there is a wavering point between our determination to get free and our desire to sleep, check our email, read the news — or really do anything besides sit. Do we want to be liberated or do we just want a cookie? Do we really want to be free or do we just want things to be the way we want them to be? Often we will find that the wanting of the sense-object is stronger than the wanting of freedom from wanting. In these circumstances, three related outcomes are very likely:</p><p>1) We succumb to our more base wanting; <br>2) We feel bad about it; and <br>3) We believe we should be more disciplined.</p><p>On one hand, it is important for us to have successful experiences with something we might call “discipline” — restraint or engagement that is not based on preferences. The experience of moving past a strong resistance to practice — of deciding to get up and sit at five a.m., for example, when we would normally be asleep — builds up a sense of freedom from the gravitational pull of unconsciousness. Restraining our compulsion toward addictive physical, verbal, or mental behavior can lead to a sense of possibility, self-confidence and strength — of our power for piercing through the mass of delusion.</p><p>On the other hand, there is a kind of discipline that we can generate that is not particularly healthy, not conducive to our practice. This kind of discipline overrides the investigative capacity of the mind. It deadens the ease and flexibility that we are trying to cultivate. It reinforces a hardness of mind, a stiffness of spirit, an overly tight control — rooted in aversion or ambition — that crushes our spirit and prevents learning. Discipline may or may not be motivated by wisdom and so we must treat it as a dull tool. We want rigor but not obsessive perfectionism.</p><blockquote>They used to think me boastful when I said so: but my confidence was not so much ability to do a thing perfectly, as a preference for botching it somehow rather than letting it go altogether by default. <br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>If we rigidly hold ourselves to a fantasy ideal, we risk losing the chance to learn about the pushings and pulls of the human heart. Sometimes we see an array of dietary discipline that confuses the energizing effects of control with the peace of wisdom. It is not uncommon to hear people say things like “Be mindful about how much food you take,” which is actually an indirect request to restrain one’s consumption — something quite different than the meaning of the word sati in Pali. There are likely many good reasons to be careful about how much food we take or consume — but it is not entirely a matter of mindfulness. In fact, the ability to be mindful of decisions made in craving or aversion is actually very important. We need to be able to have a relationship of understanding with these parts of ourselves in order to understand them — something that pure abstract discipline can cut us off from.</p><blockquote>Any of our Arabs could go home without penalty whenever the conviction failed him: the only contract was honour. <br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>If we resolve to go through suffering rather than inflict it on the world around us, it takes courage, confidence, and discipline. There are times when we must do what we don’t want to do, when we drag ourselves to the cushion or chair to sit with ourselves even when it is the least compelling thing we could imagine. But the strongest discipline is one rooted in our own personal experience, our own desire to be free, not in an idealization of another or hatred of our selves. We are not trying to create an authoritarian internal police state. We are not recreating the thing we are fighting against. Rigor, yes. Enthusiasm and zeal, yes. Determination that is flexible and dynamic, in which we can learn, observe, recognizing that the deepest change comes through understanding, yes, but not hate-based control or suppression.</p><blockquote>In the regular Arab Army there was no power of punishment whatever: this vital difference showed itself in all our troops. They had no formality of discipline; there was no subordination. Service was active; attack was always imminent: and like the Army of Italy, men recognized the duty of defeating the enemy. For the rest they were not soldiers, but pilgrims, intent always to go the little farther.<br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>How does our enthusiasm become internalized? It happens as we build faith, as we encounter more and more challenging obstacles and are able to face them clearly, with compassion and clarity, and are less and less subject to every whim and fleeting compulsion. As we find more and more comfort in a greater and greater terrain and are able to move with more ease through a range of challenging territory, our rigor becomes more natural and invigorating, not compulsive or self-subjugating.</p><h4>THE REVOLUTIONARY SPIRIT</h4><blockquote>The officers must be men naturally endowed with good qualities which can be developed during the course of campaigning. The most important natural quality is that of complete loyalty to the idea of people’s emancipation. If this is present, the others will develop; if it is not present, nothing can be done. <br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>While the guerrilla approach to the Buddha’s path resists enforced uniformity, there are elements of attitude that can be seen as broadly shared. First and foremost, one must be a revolutionary. One must aspire to the total liberation from suffering for themselves — in this lifetime or in another. The complete uprooting and destruction of greed, hatred, and delusion. Love and sympathy unrestrained for the plight of all beings in all directions. People are drowning in the great flood. The Buddha’s way offers a raft, a shore, an island, but most people demand only warmer water. This is what distinguishes the revolutionary from the appeaser, the person whose mind is bent on freedom from the person whose mind is bent on accommodation who is just looking to be “more productive,” find more “work/life balance” or some such thing. This process is a takeover not a makeover. Which is not to say that the guerrilla yogi is dogmatic or closed to tactics of temporary strategic compromise: they do at times let themselves find temporary sanctuary in pleasure. But whatever nourishment they take in rest from the battle is always understood to be in strategic service to the larger cause. We may make mistakes, we may lose our way, but we try as best we can to always keep our eyes on the prize: The utter destruction of craving and aversion, the uprooting of ignorance, the fulfillment of the holy life.</p><blockquote>We were a self-centered army without parade or gesture, devoted to freedom… a purpose so ravenous that it devoured all our strength, a hope so transcendent that our earlier ambitions faded in its glare. <br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>The qualities that count as revolutionary mature over time and a broader and broader palette of mental and emotional experience can be folded into what might be considered revolutionary characteristics.</p><p>If we think only certain qualities are ultimately able to uproot the enemy, then only a fraction of our experience will ever hold up. In a workplace, only a small percentage of people are going to be the types who are natural agitators, organizers, rabble-rousers, but an organizing campaign must allow for the people who are not those types to feel they have a stake in the struggle, and join it bringing their special gifts and talents. The agitated, rabble-rousing, angry, zealous — yes — but also the bored, the sleepy, the mischievous, the scared. The revolution must include everyone.</p><p>Social revolution is haunted by its dependency on a limited range of motivational forces for its success: anger, intensity, enthusiasm, tenacity, crisis, etc, and therefore suffers even when successful, from lack of coherence and longevity. Very few people can stay angry forever. Nor can they stay agitated, excited, rebellious for very long. At some point, people want to rest, live their lives, go to work, play, raise their families. They don’t want to stay in unending revolutionary fervor. Even if they did, most cannot. It is not human, it is not natural. Those that can, the Lenins of the world, are a little demented. It is more natural to have periods of intensity and periods of rest, periods of clarity and periods of uncertainty. It is possible to have a sense of determination underlying all of this, a drum or heartbeat behind the action, that doesn’t pretend that the motivating force of change is going to be constant. We can learn to have a consistency within that changeability that is more natural, more attainable, and ultimately more powerful. It holds the key to a resiliency that prevents us from abandoning the path every time we feel disillusioned.</p><blockquote>One of the basic questions that we need to look at is how to convert merely rebellious attitudes into revolutionary ones in the process of radical transformation of society. Merely rebellious attitudes or actions are insufficient, though they are an indispensable response to legitimate anger. It is necessary to go beyond rebellious attitudes to a more radically critical and revolutionary position, which is in fact a position not simply of denouncing injustice but of announcing a new utopia.<br> ~ Paolo Freire</blockquote><h4>PARADOX</h4><p>Because of the consistency of changeability, the guerrilla yogi will benefit from trying to live in, lean into, and learn from paradox. There are many forces required in our engagement that may seem in conflict with one another. The resolution of them is not merely a process of bringing these forces into “balance.” At the very core of our practice life might be the dynamic rhythms, resonance, and tensions between the mental factors of spiritual urgency (<em>saṃvega</em>) and patience (<em>khanti</em>). I once asked a great teacher in Burma, the Mya Taung Sayadaw, about the tension between them. How do we reconcile this tension in our hearts? But he couldn’t answer my question because he didn’t acknowledge any tension. We must have saṃvega. Yes. We must have khanti. Yes. There is no contradiction. The Buddha describes this using an agricultural metaphor: though a farmer must hurry to prepare the field on the appropriate day of the season — plow the earth, plant the seeds, and water them — he cannot then command them to grow and bear fruit according to his own preference.</p><p>The path to full awakening must be considered as the most extreme example of this dynamic. A yogi commits to develop these important qualities of mind but cannot control the timeframe in which they ripen. We cannot simply put a quarter into the machine and get our prize. But neither is it a slot machine of pure chance. As the 14th century Chinese hermit poet Stonehouse wrote, “getting free isn’t luck.” Conditions matter, intention matters, action matters — practice matters — but the road is long, mysterious, and unpredictable. So effort must be made urgently, but non-attachment to outcome rooted in a patience far beyond patience is also required.</p><p>What is patience beyond patience? The word patience, as we tend to use it, connotes a kind of posture of forbearance held for a time until inevitable and eventual satisfaction. “Just be patient” usually implies that your prize will come if you wait. It still is ruled by and dependent upon hope for a future outcome. But to be truly patient we must give up hope, give up longing, because while we all want peace, nothing is a greater threat to peace than wanting. This is not hopelessness as despondency. It is the hopelessness of peace that is not invested in the future at all.</p><p>Concentration and mindfulness can themselves feel contradictory at times and at other times are mutually dependent. Love and wisdom, body and mind, intensity and relaxation, narrow or open awareness, deep or surface, resistance or surrender, dukkha and nibbana. In the list of the seven bojjhanga, or “factors of awakening,” factors on either side of the list can seem contradictory: Investigation and concentration, energy and calm, rapture and equanimity. We have no coherent self and yet we are entirely responsible for our actions. We can free ourselves from hope without drowning in hopelessness.</p><p>To put forth energy toward a goal without any expectation of accomplishment, of outcome, is one of the hardest things for the human heart to accomplish. The entire life of practice can be seen as a giant tool of purification of motivation. As we come to see how so much of our motivation for practice is rooted in clinging and craving to certain experiences or certain fantasies of a future self, an investment in the experience of the next moment. To put forth our full effort and have no attachment at all to what comes next is a true miracle — more than any other fantastic magic that the saints have come up with in their times. The humility of perseverance, the purity of heart that is its fruit, is a precious doorway to freedom.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that the guerrilla yogi walks around all day long with perfect motivation. It means they are committed to the greatest humility in seeing over and over and over again how most of the time their motivation is more rooted in craving and aversion. This degree of honesty is of paramount importance and not as a matter of self-denigration but in fact as one of wisdom because we start to see all of these impulses as impersonal, as rooted in nature and the trajectory of ancient kamma.</p><p>In the Vesali Sutta, the Buddha encouraged his monks to consider the body with nibbida — defined variously as “revulsion,” “disgust,” “dispassion,” or “disenchantment” and reflect continuously on it as such. He then went into seclusion for several weeks. During that time, sixty of these monks were so demoralized by the disgusting nature of the body that they killed themselves or “sought an assassin” to do it for them. Upon emerging from his retreat, the Buddha asked Ananda, “why does the community of monks seem so depleted?” Ananda informed the Buddha of the tragedy. The Buddha immediately asked Ananda to gather the remaining monks before him and proceeded to describe to them about how mindfulness of breathing should be enjoyed as a pleasant abiding,</p><blockquote>Monks, this concentration through mindfulness of in-&amp;-out breathing, when developed &amp; pursued, is both peaceful &amp; exquisite, a refreshing &amp; pleasant abiding that immediately disperses &amp; allays any evil, unskillful mental qualities that have arisen. Just as when, in the last month of the hot season, a great rain-cloud out of season immediately disperses &amp; allays the dust &amp; dirt that have been stirred up, in the same way this concentration through mindfulness of in-&amp;-out breathing, when developed &amp; pursued, is both peaceful &amp; exquisite, a refreshing &amp; pleasant abiding that immediately disperses &amp; allays any evil, unskillful mental qualities that have arisen.<br> ~ Buddha, Vesali Sutta</blockquote><p>The Buddha wasn’t wrong to encourage disenchantment with the body, but the intensity of that realization must be counter-balanced with the buoyancy of wholesome pleasure. One of the great balancing acts in practice is to be sobered by these insights while not growing embittered or drowning in despondency or despair. We come to understand that nothing is stable enough to ever satisfy the hunger of the mind. The mind itself (arising and passing each moment based on conditions) isn’t stable enough to be satisfied.</p><p>A heart bent on satisfaction will only find suffering. A heart inclined toward unbinding from expectation will undoubtably attain freedom. The most important mechanism of liberation is disenchantment. Weariness — even to the degree of revulsion — with the conditioned world and the heart that keeps searching for stability within it, is a key factor in the success of the revolutionary mind. We need to ultimately feel the dukkha of the oppressive and exhausting tendencies of the mind. It is the only way to tap into the “desire for deliverance” that propels the mind to the final stages of liberation insight. But when tired or otherwise vulnerable to the forces of doubt, we should stay away from this feeling of repugnance with the body or the mind. That frame of mind will tend toward despondency and depression instead of liberatory animation — and this should always be taken into strategic account. We can learn instead how to focus on and adhere to the pleasant side of practice in order to keep our efforts buoyant.</p><p>We can watch a nature show on television and be inspired by the beauty and wonder of it while at the same time feel horrified by the imprisonment of beings in the cycle of consumption and re-production, the stress of continued existence. Our practice should be rooted in humility and compassion for ourselves and all beings living under the powerful dictatorship of saṃsāra, of craving craving for continued existence. If we do not allow this kind of openness to paradox — to allow both to be true — the mind tends to teeter between overzealous faith and hopelessness.</p><blockquote>The spring itself was a thread of silvery water in a runnel of pebbles across delightful turf, green and soft, on which we lay, wrapped in our cloaks, wondering if something to eat were worth preparing: for we were subject at the moment to the physical shame of success, a reaction of victory, when it became clear that nothing was worth doing, and that nothing worthy had been done.<br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>As guerrilla yogis, we need to learn to acclimate and find familiarity and safety within the full terrain of the body and mind. We must learn to be as agile in the jungle of doubt as we are on the mountaintop of zeal, as stabile in the ocean of wonder as we are in the desert of hopelessness. As free in the green pastures of contentment as in the valley of the shadow of death. This is the essence of vipassana: not controlling terrain but knowing the full terrain of existence so intimately as to not be seduced or disturbed by any of it, to have no preference for one or the other, no clinging to any states of existence. We cannot fake it and there is no way to rush it. We must go through it all over and over again and feel the glory and agony of it all, and the pain of our own clinging and rejection of it all — for this, in the end, is our true challenge, to recognize and not resist the pain in the heart that is always there.</p><blockquote>To be of the desert was, as they knew, a doom to wage unending battle with an enemy who was not of the world, nor life, nor anything, but hope itself; <br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p>While the Buddha’s path of vipassana is considered the most direct path to enlightenment, the road is not straight and we will have to weather great challenges when it seems like we are lost, or stuck, or going backwards.</p><p>This is why in the 5 faculties (<em>iddhipāda</em>) faith (<em>saddhā</em>) precedes energy (<em>viriya</em>), concentration (<em>samadhi</em>), mindfulness (<em>sati</em>), and wisdom (<em>pañña</em>). The mental support of conviction, confidence, faith are power bases for our mind’s effort and their undermining is our greatest concern. Viccikicca, doubt, loss of faith in ourselves or in the path is absolutely the greatest threat to our practice and our success, threatening our access to all that lies up river. This is not meant to imply that we don’t question the path or the teachings or our method, but this form of doubt is a doubt that is disinterested, disconnects us, that believes in, is driven by guided by, hopelessness and meaninglessness and despair.</p><p>When trudging through the desert of dryness, we cannot expect ourselves always to be perfectly equanimous and simply relate to it without any agitation. We can remember to observe our dislike, or hope, our wanting of something else, something more exciting, anything, to be happening rather than what is happening, and recognize that we simply need to keep on the slog, that we cannot trust our minds at all in their analysis, interpretation, and evaluation of our experience. It will help us to find that small spark of willingness, of chanda, hidden as it might be beneath shadow’s of doubt and resistance, and just keep moving and acknowledge that the pain is not about the object “out there” but of the wanting within our own hearts.</p><blockquote>In a war of long duration, those whose conviction that the people must be emancipated is not deeply rooted are likely to become shaken in their faith<br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>Even when we lose track of the breath or practicing metta but find ourselves getting repeatedly and overwhelmingly distracted, we have to see that there is almost always a thin thread of connection that we can maintain to our anchor, our primary object. The problem is mostly the standard we hold ourselves to. If we allow that the mind is going to wander off, and that there is no way of keeping that intense clarity of mindfulness of breath all the time, we attune to what degree of attention is there and let that be enough. Soon we will find that we have much more consistency and concurrence that we ever thought we did, but that it may ebb and flow like the tides.</p><blockquote>Owing to the loss of big cities and the hardships of war, vacillating elements within our ranks will clamour for compromise, and pessimism will grow to a serious extent. Our tasks will then be to mobilize the whole people to unite as one man and carry on the war with unflinching perseverance, to broaden and consolidate the united front, sweep away all pessimism and ideas of compromise, promote the will to hard struggle and apply new wartime policies, and so to weather the hardships.<br> ~ Mao Zedong</blockquote><p>When there is hardship we have to lean on our faith. When there is no faith, we fall back on courage. When there is no courage, we fall back on our training. When our training is insufficient, we fall back on the teachings. When the teachings don’t inspire, we take a break, remembering that countless other people have encountered these same obstacles you are facing and have persevered. We may need to rest but that does not mean we give up. And if we give up, that is only for a few moments. We can be ready to pick the sword back up in the next. Even if our break lasts a few years, that is nothing in comparison to the lifetimes we have been at it — moving in and moving away.</p><p>There will be setbacks. What matters most in these times is not merely doing the right thing but the undercurrent of our character that keeps us going. We can align toward a thread of evenness through ups and downs. We cannot stop them from happening but can we be willing to ride them all the way through to the end? Sometimes we have to go to the darkest recesses of the mind. When things fall apart and there is equanimity, it feels liberating. When there isn’t, the same experience can be terrifying. Other times we find ourselves in the desert of the doldrums for days, weeks, or longer. We can lose our orientation. It takes an undercurrent of faith, and incredible perseverance, to not deny fear or bewilderment and to gently try to make sure we are still watching and noting each arising and passing as best we can.</p><blockquote>Old Don Antonio taught me that you are big as the enemies you choose to fight, and as small as the fear is big. ‘Choose a big enemy, and it will make you grow as you confront him. Lessen your fear because if it grows, it will make you small,’ Old Don Antonio told me one rainy May afternoon, in the house when tobacco and words reign.”<br> ~ Subcomandante Marcos</blockquote><p>A few years ago as I walked to the open-air dhamma hall to open a weekend retreat, our entire space was swarmed by millions of flying termites. All of us were covered with them: in our hair, in our mouths and ears, and under our clothes. They were everywhere. We turned off the lights and covered ourselves in shawls. I tried my best to orient the yogis to our retreat and encourage them to persevere. The next day, the termites had all died and were covering the floor in a thick exoskeletal carpet. As we cleaned the hall, swept off our beds and rededicated ourselves to the practice, I discovered that only one yogi had decided to leave the retreat. Her note read, “I’m sorry but I am just not enlightened enough to sit peacefully though a swarm of termites crawling all over my body.” I understood. But the truth is that none of us were so enlightened. That was not what kept us there. It was the longing to be free, the aspiration to be liberated from dependence upon conditions that kept us invested in the process.</p><p>During our closing circle, many yogis reported the same insight: when they focused their determination to explore the direct sensations of the termites on their skin they realized that it was not entirely unpleasant. In fact, many found the light tickling touch to be mildly pleasant. It was only when the idea of what was happening penetrated and took over their mind did they find themselves in agony. But when they noticed it as thinking and returned back to the direct sensations, they were calm and engaged. They had broken through an important aspect of our suffering related to the difference between concept and reality. They did so not because they were free but because they so deeply wanted to be.</p><blockquote>The Arab army was so weak physically that it could not let the metaphysical weapon rust unused. It had won a<br>province when the civilians in it had been taught to die for the ideal of freedom: the presence or absence of the<br>enemy was a secondary matter.<br> ~ T.E. Lawrence</blockquote><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0"><em>Click here for Chapter 13 (</em><strong>INTELLIGENCE</strong>: <br><em>Reporting / Education / International Support)</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-11-863b429e9269"><em>Click here for Chapter 11 (</em><strong>Independence:</strong> <em>Responsibility/ Self-Retreat)</em></a></p><h3>I hope you have enjoyed what you have read so far!</h3><h3>In accordance with my tradition, I do not charge money for Dhamma teaching and am supported only on the freely-offered generosity of others.</h3><h3>If you have benefited from what you have read so far and want to support me or the promotion of the work, please consider two options for offering your generosity:</h3><h3>1. You can donate directly to me (as a tax-deductible contribution to Vipassana Hawaiʻi) <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=29&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>or</h3><h3>2. You can make a tax-deductable gift to a fund that will help promote and publish this book in a printed form that will be freely available to all by clicking <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=43&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>Thank you for your efforts to continue to propagate the Dhamma in this era in a way that holds the integrity and purity of the teachings.</h3><h3>~ Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=830412dfd704" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {11}]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-11-863b429e9269?source=rss-15c29d300354------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/863b429e9269</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dharma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 Nov 2019 03:46:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-01T06:51:22.206Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Insurgent Heart: A Vipassana Manual for the Guerrilla Yogi — {11}</h3><h4>Independence: Autonomy / Self-Retreat</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/921/1*no2v3kox5sD63DO0NVzkjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>OSPAAAL poster image by Rafael Zarza / Image courtesy Lincoln Cushing / Docs Populi</figcaption></figure><h3>Table of Contents</h3><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Preface</strong></a></p><p><strong>~ </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-0-81b0f998f072"><strong>Introduction</strong></a></p><ol><li><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-1-5c0155ab82e"><strong>Sabotage</strong>: Dana / Sila</a></li></ol><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-2-3e2e7dfa6567">2. <strong>Indigenous Knowledge:</strong> <em>Bhavana</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-3-21b24f9c0675">3. <strong>Contact:</strong> <em>Aim /Attack / Harass</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-4-7e8180ac694d">4. <strong>Mobility:</strong> <em>Bases / Fluidity / Agility</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-5-c56e648af1c">5. <strong>Distrust:</strong> <em>Suspicion / Investigation</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-6-4cd23b6d08ae">6. <strong>Medicine:</strong> <em>Metta / Divine Abodes</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-7-6a55c91a04d">7. <strong>Retreat:</strong> <em>Encirclement / Escape</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-8-9f84a4893c4">8. <strong>Diversion:</strong> <em>Distraction / Misdirection</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-9-fed71316dfc0">9. <strong>General Strike:</strong> <em>Invisibility / Cessation</em></a></p><p>10. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-10-6a404425d159"><strong>The Guerrilla Band:</strong> <em>Camaraderie / Community</em></a></p><p>11. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-11-863b429e9269"><strong>Independence:</strong> <em>Responsibility/ Self-Retreat</em></a></p><p>12. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704"><strong>Intelligence:</strong> <em>Education / Reporting</em></a></p><p>13. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-13-a2ebbf8f82e0"><strong>The Revolutionary Spirit:</strong> <em>Discipline / Determination / Faith</em></a></p><p>14. <a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-14-fc55ba5c3806"><strong>Protracted War:</strong> <em>Land Reform / Regular Army / International Support</em></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-15-afterword-9c47ee7fdab9">15. {<strong>Afterword} Mindfulness: </strong><em>A Balm or a Bomb for Babylon?</em></a></p><h3>~CHAPTER 11~</h3><blockquote>Outside of the support he gets from the people among whom he operates — and this support must never be underestimated for it is vital to his eventual success — he fights alone. He is part of an independent formation that is in effect an army by itself. He must be self-contained.</blockquote><blockquote>If necessary he must act alone and fight alone with the weapons at his disposal — and these very often will not be of the best. He must find his own supplies. His endurance has to be great: and for this he needs a fit body and an alert mind. Above all he must know what he is fighting for — and why.</blockquote><blockquote>~Handbook for Volunteers of the Irish Republican Army</blockquote><p>Sometimes the drama of community, of relationship, is too much of distraction and the guerrilla yogi, realizing that they have limited energy, determines to use that energy to direct the mind inwardly. There is work and benefit of sangha culture that is important and valuable. But we should never lose sight of the primary field of our own practice as the foundational locus for this battle, even in the midst of social crisis.</p><p>Why should other people’s minds be so hard to bear? It is because in them our own minds are unbearably brought to light. Our reactivity to other peoples’ views and actions, as well as our attachment to our own, can trigger deepening cycles of aversion, delusion, or craving in our hearts that can be increasingly hard to untangle. Spending time alone, having each moment be a reflection of internal impulse whose impact we take responsibility for is a profound gift that requires its own conditions and accommodations.</p><p>There is a story from the suttas. The death of the Buddha was imminent and a certain monk was asked to join an assembly to help make preparations for the transition of the sangha. We can only imagine the pressure elder monks faced in helping ensure the future of the dispensation after the Buddha was gone. But while there were certainly endless important matters to discuss, this particular bhikkhu refused, deciding his energy was better used trying to attain final liberation while the Buddha was still alive. Other monks even went to the Buddha to complain about this bhikkhu. But the Buddha upheld him as the ideal.</p><p>The value of sangha cannot be overstated, but neither can its potential threat. Even in the greatest expression of sangha we can imagine, each of us must do our own work and win on our own terms in our own way. In the end no comrade can fight for you. While the emotional and material support is essential, each of us must fight our own war and sometimes this means periods of greater intimacy or distance with others, with community, with the greater society, as always: dependent upon conditions.</p><p>The guerrilla yogi may find the path frustrating and lonely at times if the Buddhist communities that are available do not feel like they offer supportive conditions for their development. For any number of valid reasons, the culture of any given sangha may feel too dissonant with or distant from our current needs.</p><p>When our options for sangha are repeatedly frustrating and dispiriting, we have the choice to 1) get involved and accept it; 2) get involved and try to change it; or 3) as the Buddha himself encouraged,</p><blockquote>As a deer in the wilds,<br>unfettered,<br>goes for forage wherever it wants:<br>the wise person, valuing freedom,<br>wanders alone<br>like a rhinoceros.</blockquote><blockquote>In the midst of companions<br> — when staying at home,<br>when going out wandering — <br>you are prey to requests.<br>Valuing the freedom<br>wander alone<br>like a rhinoceros.</blockquote><blockquote>…</blockquote><blockquote>Unstartled, like a lion at sounds.<br>Unsnared, like the wind in a net.<br>Unsmeared, like a lotus in water:<br>wander alone<br>like a rhinoceros.</blockquote><blockquote>Like a lion — forceful, strong in fang,<br>living as a conqueror, the king of beasts — <br>resort to a solitary dwelling.<br>Wander alone<br>like a rhinoceros.</blockquote><blockquote>At the right time consorting<br>with the release through good will,<br> compassion,<br> appreciation,<br> equanimity,<br>unobstructed by all the world,<br>any world,<br>wander alone<br>like a rhinoceros.</blockquote><blockquote>Having let go of passion,<br> aversion,<br> delusion;<br>having shattered the fetters;<br>undisturbed at the ending of life,<br>wander alone<br>like a rhinoceros.</blockquote><blockquote>~The Buddha, Rhinoceros Sutta</blockquote><p>Stars at the center of a solar system burn at a relative close distance to each other: light-days or light-weeks apart. But throughout the rest of the universe, this is actually very rare. Most stars find themselves an average of five light-years — about 30 trillion miles — away from their nearest neighbor. A guerrilla yogi must be able to look up into the night sky and find solace in that isolation, relief in that potential for seclusion, as if that might be us in a future life, burning up our last remaining kamma in the cold depths of the dark expanse of the universe.</p><h4>NON-COMBATANTS</h4><blockquote>A guerrilla force can operate successfully only in an area in which the civilian population is not merely passively in sympathy with them, but in which there is a far proportion who will give them active and willing support.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Bert “Yank” Levy</blockquote><p>The ideal in the Rhinoceros Sutta of a lone monastic wandering in the woods is a fantasy that may never have been broadly realized in reality — even in the time of the Buddha. To the degree that it did exist, the solitary wanderer in his day was held by a broader culture that supported and valued that kind of renunciation and commitment to awakening — a social reality that was essential to its functioning. To this day monks and nuns continue to be entirely dependent on donations from lay people and so could never wander or live too far from a village. The fact that multitudes of others were operating in monasteries created the cultural context for the lone wanderer to succeed in those more “independent” conditions. In this same way, a guerrilla fighter without a revolution is just a vigilante, and a guerrilla yogi can never truly be considered alone because of the context of other yogis in the world.</p><blockquote>Though I have no family of my own, yet I have a very big family — the working class throughout the world and the Vietnamese people. From that broad family I can judge and imagine the small one.</blockquote><blockquote>~Ho Chi Minh</blockquote><p>So it is important for a guerrilla yogi to consider the relational conditions of their lives that support or threaten their solitude, and the strength or strain that this solitude puts on their social relations. The guerrilla yogi lives at the tension between householder (gahapati), and renunciate — and this tension must be addressed. Neither fully outside of society nor fully inside it, they ride the razor’s edge between the worlds. In the case of our families and non-dhamma acquaintances, there are tensions that can arise between our need to struggle and our need to be in healthy relationships.</p><p>The Ignoble Path factor of Right Irresponsibility shows us that we need, at times, to be willing to let down the people that want so much from us. We decide not to go out to a party, rest instead of answer the phone, sit instead of respond to email, disappear onto retreat — for longer and longer periods of time — and we are sometimes resented for it. The people in our lives who do not understand our dedication, who do not share in our interest, feel that they are losing us to something that threatens them and their needs. If we disappear into the battle for a weeklong retreat, that sometimes can be OK, but when we are gone for a month, three months at a time, six months, a year at a time — we are inevitably gone during someones illness, during a birth, a death, some up or down in friends lives, where the specter of death looms, people get married, have children, graduate, get a promotion, get divorced, and you are not there to share it with them.</p><p>Family and friends need to be trained to accept this reality. But as a guerrilla yogi you cannot expect them to keep pace with your own enthusiasm. Because they do not understand or share your goal of the happiness of peace, they are less concerned with your journey toward it than with their own beliefs in what would make you happy or in getting their own needs from you fulfilled. Part of their training is slow progressive comfort with longer and longer times away, but it is also demonstrating the value of your time away for them. They must come to recognize that you are a better version of yourself when you have had time away, that you are happier, kinder, more patient, more understanding. They can learn to recognize that if you do not get this time away you are more contracted in the heart — and this effects them negatively. A guerrilla yogi must train their friends and family to feel as if they have already died — and that any time you show up is a miracle for which they eventually become grateful, if not sated.</p><blockquote>A new spirit permeated the Sierra. Peasants would come and greet us, no longer fearful. We, in turn, had more confidence in them. Our relative strength had increased and we felt safe against any surprise attack; we also felt that a closer bond existed between us and the peasants.</blockquote><blockquote>~Ernesto “Che” Guevara</blockquote><p>Sometimes we become aware that we need more significant distance from certain people in our lives in general — not just when we are on retreat. We come to see that engaging too regularly or casually with them leads to more and more conflict and strife and drama that effects our mind and overall wellbeing. Letting go can be hard but at some point we learn to stop betraying our own needs for the sake of others. It does not mean that we never stretch or sacrifice for the wellbeing of another, of course not — but rather that we are not ultimately going to undermine our own potential for liberation to satisfy someone else’s defilement-based needs of us. To dedicate your life to feeding insatiable hungry ghosts might be kind but it is not heroic, nor wise. It is folly. A guerrilla yogi can be relieved to consider: Beings are numberless. I vow to disappoint them all.</p><blockquote>All food taken from them must be paid for at a good price, thanks must be repeatedly expressed and peasants made aware that they are helping their own cause. Our men will try to repair things in the house such as beds, closets, tables that might be ruined. They will help the peasant in fencing his lot or in sowing or clearing the fields, and in so doing they will clearly show our sympathy and attract the peasants to our cause so that we may eventually request their help any time.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Alberto Bayo Giroud</blockquote><p>The guerrilla yogi desires to help but is not here to “save” all sentient beings and is not trying to convince anyone about the Dhamma. If someone is inspired to join the cause, wonderful — as rare as they are, we never leave the opportunity for a new sampavaṅka on the table. But we leave salvation to others. Besides the obvious unrealistic aspect of that aspiration (after all, even the Buddha did not save all sentient beings) it is unavoidably evangelical — because salvation can only mean that they convert to the Buddha’s path. In our tradition, we help people and society as much as we can, in as many ways that we can or are moved to, but we also recognize that people are the owners of their actions. Just as no one can save us, there is no saving anyone else. We can support them and struggle with them in all imaginable ways but we also must be thoughtful and considerate in regards to the proportion of our energy that goes into our practice versus the world around us. We need to be in healthy relationship to society, whatever that may mean at any given stage of our struggle. But at some point we must recognize that we cannot have it both ways: we are either committing to samsara or committing to liberation and it is fantasy to hope that those paths can be the same.</p><p>True isolation is not something most people can handle for very long. The Buddha encouraged monastic life near villages and towns: apart from society but still in relationship with it. The monastic sangha is entirely dependent upon laity for their livelihood. This dynamic must never be forgotten. The guerrilla yogi is no different that others — and must defend against conceiving of themselves as better, worse than, or equal to — but must recognize where their aims and the aims of society are different, where they align, and how to manage that tension. We are a part of and apart from society, and that is a role that requires firmness and flexibility.</p><blockquote>The urban guerrilla must know how to live among the people, and he must be careful not to appear strange and different from ordinary city life. He should not wear clothes that are different from those that other people wear. Elaborate and high fashion clothing for men or women may often be a handicap if the urban guerrilla’s mission takes him into working class neighborhoods, or sections where such dress is uncommon. The same care has to be taken if the urban guerrilla must move from the South of the country to the North, and vice versa.</blockquote><blockquote>The urban guerrilla must make his living through his job or his professional activity. If he is known and sought by the police, he must go underground, and sometimes must live hidden. Under such circumstances, the urban guerrilla cannot reveal his activity to anyone, since this information is always and only the responsibility of the revolutionary organization in which he is participating.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Carlos Marighela</blockquote><h4>SELF-RETREAT</h4><p>For the guerrilla yogi, the ideal of the rhinoceros takes its most dramatic form in the process of self-retreat. Intensive periods of practice are generally supportive to all guerrilla yogis but there may be times in our lives where being in a large retreat container — with the distraction of numerous other yogis, an inflexible schedule, costly expenses, travel challenges, etc — that can be inappropriate or impractical. Sometimes our practice is simply at a point of maturity where we need to test our capacity for our independent action. For these reasons it is important to learn how to go on a self-retreat.</p><p>We encourage all yogis to attend a number of formal organized vipassana retreats before embarking on a self-retreat. There is a lot to learn about our relationship to structure, to the formal process, and that holds and protects us for moments of crisis and confusion that we may not otherwise be trained for. There are so many opportunities to get caught in wrong-view, to strategize based on preference rather than wisdom, to be overwhelmed in isolation and hindrance patterns that we must really have a good handle on basic training in a community before we try to go off on our own.</p><p>When we do decide to try a self-retreat, it is best to start small: a daylong or a weekend. Try doing a number of short self-retreats to get a sense of the logistical and spiritual challenges to trying to create the protective conditions for practice.</p><p>Often we will need to sit self-retreats in our own home. This can really only be done successfully if you live alone or at least have the space to yourself for the time of the retreat. Turning your day-to-day living arrangement into a space of intensive practice can be a challenge but also very fruitful in terms of the long term possibility of getting quiet in your daily life. Of course issues such as internet, household chores, cooking, shopping, etc will arise in relationship to this independent form of intensive practice. Your relationship to the space takes on a different character that goes a long way toward the “integration” that we all long for. Just remember: you are not in a remote cave deep in the Himalayas. Don’t pretend you are. Don’t hold yourself to that standard of seclusion. But, a high degree of seclusion is often possible and it is worth finding those boundaries and flexible places.</p><p>There are a number of things important to the process of preparation for a self retreat. Of primary concern is how best to create the conditions of seclusion and renunciation in a space in which there is no sense of authority watching over you, no social pressure to keep you within the bounds of approved yogi behavior. This lack of pressure is fundamental to training for our own attunement to our determination but also has the risks of over-slackness in our endeavor or an overly porous container for our mind.</p><p>Protection from technology and our addiction to it is an ever-increasing challenge and vitally powerful for a guerrilla yogi. Set an automated email “away” message, leave an appropriate message on your cell phone, turn off your wifi, delete compelling apps from your phone, turn off automatic password entry, put your phone and computer in harder to reach places. These are all things that can help you keep these tendencies at bay. Have a mala — a string of prayer beads — that you carry with you on your wrist (or in your pocket instead of your phone) so that when you have the impulse to “check” you find your beads and can practice metta rather than get sucked back into social media, news, work, etc. Be careful about using your phone for an alarm or even a meditation timer. Most timer apps are now integrated social apps as well and it can be hard to maintain the protection of seclusion. On the other hand, having a sense that you are sitting with others can be a psychological support for some yogis on self-retreat. Let yourself explore.</p><p>Try to organize some teacher support during your longer retreat. Can you ask for a phone or video chat interview at some point so that a teacher can check on you, hear about your practice, and give you guidance?</p><p>Just walking around your living space can be very distracting as you notice all the little projects that you suddenly have time to attend to. Be careful. There is nothing wrong with a little yogi job each day but don’t let yourself get entirely distracted by the long list of projects you have been meaning to get to. There are a number of understandable and typical distractions that we should be wary of:</p><p>• If you need to exercise, OK but keep it boundaried.<br> • If you need creative time, OK but keep it boundaried.<br> • If you need to read, OK but keep it boundaried. <br> • If you need to do work, keep it very boundaried.<br> • If you need to use technology, keep it very very very very boundaried.</p><p>One can easily see how those five things could take up your whole day and entirely undermine our efforts for seclusion and concentration. With too much other stuff to do, you’ll never meditate. The point of secluded retreat time is to build enough strength to be with yourself without the distractions — external or self-imposed. So much of what we do to fill time or entertain ourselves is a kind of escapism from moment to moment reality. Self-retreat shouldn’t be a prison, and there should be pressure release valves for us when we need them. But the baseline should be renunciation so that we don’t need to lean on distractions for sense of peace. It’s the only way to build up confidence in the mind’s ability to be with unmitigated reality.</p><p>Make a schedule. Don’t make it too tight, too constrictive. But don’t make it so loose that you find yourself wandering around wondering what to do. Let it be based on sense of natural rhythm with your day. Give yourself room to breathe and space for cooking, cleaning, rest, and space for other unexpected variables, inspirations. Make sure you get outdoors, even if it feels difficult. If that means going out of seclusion, take it seriously and follow the Moscow Rules laid out below.</p><p>One of the biggest logistical challenges for being on self-retreat is food: Its purchase and preparation. The best scenario is if you have a situation in which you can purchase all of your food ahead of time. If this is not possible, you will need to leave the protective conditions of your retreat container at times and enter areas outside of guerrilla control. This should be done as infrequently as possible and with the utmost care and protection. If you have a sampavaṅka who is not on retreat and willing to support you in your worldly errands, all the better.</p><p>If a yogi on retreat must leave their protected container they should try to blend in as much as possible in the outside world and not draw too much attention to themselves by strange yogi behavior: walking super slow, not speaking when spoken to, looking unkempt, or wearing unfresh clothes,</p><blockquote>Do not forget that your uniform is designed to bend with the prevailing colors of the countryside. If you wear civilian clothes, choose things of a neutral colour, brown or dark grey — not white, light grey, black or navy blue…</blockquote><blockquote>~Bert “Yank” Levy</blockquote><p>The “Moscow Rules” are a list of heightened precepts that intelligence agents in the CIA use when operating deep in enemy territory. Most of these rules are perfectly relevant for a guerrilla yogi who is on self-retreat and must enter enemy territory on occasion for supplies. When a yogi who is on intensive self-retreat needs to go into town for supplies (or for any other reason) they should follow these same rules to secure the protection of their own minds. Here is one list, culled from various sources:</p><blockquote>1. Assume nothing.<br>2. Never go against your gut.<br>3. Any operation can be aborted. (If it feels wrong, it is wrong)<br>4. Everyone is potentially under opposition control.<br>5. Do not look back; you are never completely alone.<br>6. Go with the flow, blend in. Maintain a natural pace.<br>7. Do not attract attention, even by being overly careful.<br>8. Vary your pattern and stay within your cover.<br>9. Do not harass the opposition.<br>10. Lull them into a sense of complacency.<br>11. Pick the time and place for action.<br>12. Keep your options open.<br>13. Technology will always let you down.<br>14. Once is an accident. Twice is a coincidence. Three times is an enemy action.<br>15.There is no limit to a human being’s ability to rationalize the truth.</blockquote><p>This may all seem a bit paranoid, but when you are a yogi who ventures out into the world after days, weeks, or months in silence you will not regret having this guidance. When negotiating the world of non-combatants it is unlikely you will be able to note as precisely about each breath or physical sensation. Instead, a general noting of “seeing,” “smelling,” “body,” “thinking” can be of enormous support. Of course you cannot be expected to maintain perfect silence while out in enemy territory, which would draw too much suspicion and potentially (and unnecessarily) alienate you from neighbors, and members of friendly samsaric society — who you are invested in over the long haul. It is best to act relatively normal but try as hard as you can to maintain your sense of seclusion.</p><p>With one foot in the spirit world and the other on the gas, simply driving a car while being a yogi can be a harrowing experience. Going outside of your sacred container can be a challenge before, during, and after returning back. It also can provide powerful perspective on your understanding of the value of the container as we often become aware that we are quieter than we think we are when we are forced to puncture the boundary. We learn to trust that our system knows how to get solid if it needs to — knows how to normalize — often to a degree that is painful once we return home. We can feel afterwards as if we have lost all of our momentum, our concentration in particular. We might feel agitated, exhausted, beset by the hindrances in a powerful way. We should take it as a learning opportunity. If our car breaks down out there in enemy territory, we have an opportunity to show up to a stressful experience with more momentum of mindfulness than we tend to in daily life. We also get a sense of enemy’s society and hopefully find ourselves drawn back thankfully to the seclusion of our retreat container.When we come back to our base camp after a run to get groceries we are hit with the impact of the kamma of the past few hours and it can be shocking — not in the least because we recognize that we are going through this every day without the time, space, or tools to recover and so the trauma of daily life builds.</p><blockquote>I remember a small girl who kept watching me as I listened to the women who came to me, with an almost religious attitude, in an effort to find out the reason for their various illnesses. As the girl’s mother approached my office — a corner of an old palm-thatched hut — the little girl said to her: “Mamma, this doctor tells every one of them the same story.”</blockquote><blockquote>The little girl was right. My experience as a doctor was limited; moreover, everyone of them had told me, unwittingly, the same horrible story. What would have happened if the doctor had come to the conclusion that a young mother of several children complained of fatigue following her daily task of carrying a bucket of water from the stream to her house, simply because she did not have enough to eat? It is useless to try to explain the reason for that fatigue to a woman of the Sierra. She will argue that she has done that kind of work “all her life” and it is only now that she gets this sudden feeling of tiredness. There is the whole sad story: People in the Sierra grow like wild flowers, unattended. Then they fade away constantly busy at a thankless task. It is due to our daily contact with these people and their problems that we came firmly convinced of the need for a definite change in the life of our people. The idea of an agrarian reform became crystal-clear, and communion with the people ceased to be a mere theory, to become an integral part of ourselves.</blockquote><blockquote>~Ernesto “Che” Guevara</blockquote><p>Food preparation is another challenge — for time and for the mind. For the guerrilla yogi, tasty foods that are simple and quick to prepare are the best. Two meals a day should be enough. If a recipe is too complicated the mind becomes stressed and too much time is spent on the complicated task. Casseroles or soups that contain proteins, vegetables, starch in one dish are of particular efficacy.It is sometimes helpful to cook basic ingredients most simply and make an over-sufficient quantity so that the left-overs can be used in a new way, with new amendments, for a new meal. A basic tomato sauce can be used in pasta one night, add a few spices and it can be added to a soup, used to fricassee chicken, or to poach eggs. Left-over vegetables and grains can be added to eggs for a frittata. Basic beans can be had one night and then one can add different ingredients each day — spices or squash — to give the yogi a bit of variety.</p><blockquote>… it is very pleasing to a soldier subjected to the extremely hard conditions of this life to be able to look forward to a seasoned meal which tastes like something. (One of the great tortures of the war was eating a cold, sticky, tasteless mess.)</blockquote><blockquote>~ Ernesto “Che” Guevara</blockquote><p>A guerrilla yogi on self-retreat cannot forget the ignoble path factor of Right Treats. Some sweets or snacks that provide a boost to our spirit can be a helpful in case of emergencies — or the pervasive doldrums. On my first long self-retreat I was in a cabin in the woods for 2 months with little more than a stock of rice, beans, canned fish, oatmeal, powdered milk, and tea. Toward the end of my retreat I started to feel desperate for something fresh: a salad, some fruit! Oh how my mind started to think about oranges. And then one chilly December morning, after my trek through the snow to gather sulfurous water from the well, I returned to my cabin to find a bowl of oranges at my door! The caretaker of the facility had gone into town and brought me this amazing gift. It was an act of generosity that helped me get through the last few weeks in ways I cannot express.</p><p>Our recently appointed monastic teacher at the Kyaswa Monastery Fusion retreat in Burma, met our yogis outside of the hall as they exited after the morning sitting with a box of donuts and cupcakes — to their delight! These kinds of offerings are of such value and inspiration we cannot forget them. The sweetness of the metta pervades long after the sweetness of the sugar has dissipated. We cannot always depend on our good karma for treats to miraculously show up so we should take steps to plan ahead as much as possible and benefit from the special circumstance of when we are both the donors and receivers.</p><blockquote>Salt is one of the essential supplies… The inhabitants of the zone should have on hand a minimum of food supply that will permit them at least to survive, even though poorly, during the hardest phases of the struggle. An attempt should be made to collect rapidly a good provision of foods that do not decompose — such grains, for example, as corn, wheat, rice, etc., which will last quite a long time; also flour, salt, sugar, and canned goods of all types; further, the necessary seeds should be sown.</blockquote><blockquote>~ Ernesto “Che” Guevara</blockquote><h4>HAPPY YOGI CONGEE</h4><p>This recipe is for a congee that is a great breakfast, lunch, or snack and balances simplicity with mental buoyancy. All one really needs for congee is rice, water, and salt and so this recipe can be made with any of the ingredients listed here or just the three. The more ingredients, the tastier it will be. It is said in the Visudhimagga that greedy types should eat very bland and flavorless food, while aversive types need really good food to keep them uplifted enough. You can make your own choice about what kind of nourishment you need.</p><p>It can be used breakfast — or any meal — for several days. It refrigerates well. Simply add water and reheat.</p><p>3 tbs peanut oil (or any oil, preferably not olive)<br>1 cup white or brown rice<br>10 cups water (or 5 cups chicken broth/5 cups water)<br>1 onion, peeled whole<br>3 cloves of garlic, peeled smashed<br>1 2-inch piece of ginger, peeled smashed<br>2 bulbs of lemongrass, smashed<br>1 hot chili pepper, diced<br>4 tbs soy sauce<br>bunch of mushrooms (fresh or dry), chopped<br>1 chicken breast (optional)<br>Salt to taste<br>Pepper to taste</p><p>poached egg:<br>1 egg<br>water<br>2 tbs vinegar<br>salt to taste</p><p>Garnish with cilantro, soy sauce, hot sauce, etc</p><p>For the congee:<br>1) Sauté the rice in the oil until browned and popping.<br>2) add everything else<br>3) Bring to a boil, lower heat, and let simmer gently for at least an hour, stirring occasionally so it doesn’t stick and burn.<br>4) Remove the ginger, lemongrass, onion</p><p>For the poached egg:<br>1) bring water to boil<br>2) add vinegar and salt<br>3) crack in eggs <br>4) lower heat for a soft roll, cook for about 3 minutes for a still-soft yolk</p><blockquote>If there is no barber, it is unimportant. If there is an insufficient number of cooks, any member of the company may be designated to prepare food.</blockquote><blockquote>~Mao Zedong</blockquote><h4>VARIABLES</h4><p>Self-retreat has its particular challenges in the beginning, the middle, and in the end. The end can be particularly hard for many. As the bubble of our container starts to break, the psychic barrier weakens and we find that people start to call, text, message. We are often faced with greater doubt, restlessness, etc. Our concentration may seem to falter. The five hindrances (craving, aversion, sloth and torpor, restlessness and worry, and doubt) can be harder to see and therefor more powerful when we don’t have a group or teacher to reflect the situation back to us. Just remember: they are normal tactics of the mind to defend itself from the changeable, undependable, core-less qualities of reality that the mind is just not well-trained to navigate. They are understandable but we don’t want to be beholden to their power. Be kind to yourself and be careful about believing in these phenomena as true — especially doubt, which is the most insidious. Whatever cracks arise in the container, simply commit to the structure and begin again. Over time you will be amazed at how the present moment awareness continues to provide sanctuary no matter how the conditions of the mind or body have changed.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-12-830412dfd704"><em>Click here for Chapter 12 (</em><strong>THE REVOLUTIONARY SPIRIT</strong>: <br><em>Discipline / Determination / Faith</em>)</a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@dolessforpeace/insurgent-heart-a-vipassana-manual-for-the-guerrilla-yogi-10-6a404425d159"><em>Click here for Chapter 10 (</em><strong><em>The Guerrilla Unit:</em></strong><em> Comrades / Community)</em></a></p><h3>I hope you have enjoyed what you have read so far!</h3><h3>I will be releasing three chapters each month so that the entirety of the book will be available online by January 2020.</h3><h3>In accordance with my tradition, I do not charge money for Dhamma teaching and am supported only on the freely-offered generosity of others.</h3><h3>If you have benefited from what you have read so far and want to support me or the promotion of the work, please consider two options for offering your generosity:</h3><h3>1. You can donate directly to me (as a tax-deductible contribution to Vipassana Hawaiʻi) <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=29&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>or</h3><h3>2. You can make a tax-deductable gift to a fund that will help promote and publish this book in a printed form that will be freely available to all by clicking <a href="https://vh1220.z2systems.com/np/clients/vh1220/donation.jsp?campaign=43&amp;&amp;test=true">HERE</a></h3><h3>Thank you for your efforts to continue to propagate the Dhamma in this era in a way that holds the integrity and purity of the teachings.</h3><h3>~ Jesse Maceo Vega-Frey</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=863b429e9269" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>