<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Doug Matheson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Doug Matheson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@dougmatheson?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 19:50:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@dougmatheson/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Improving our Collective Problem-Solving… Commitment to Honesty Even When Uncomfortable and…]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/improving-our-collective-problem-solving-commitment-to-honesty-even-when-uncomfortable-and-64902133a067?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/64902133a067</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[intellectual-honesty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[problem-solving]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-history-of-religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-beyond-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Nov 2025 18:22:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-30T18:26:26.399Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Improving our Collective Problem-Solving… Commitment to Honesty Even When Uncomfortable and Unwelcome:</strong></h3><p>a look at a key root of the fact — alternative fact phenomenon</p><p>by Doug Matheson</p><p>In February of 2020 I happened to stop by a SmashfestUK science expo in London, and talked with two young-adult staffers. The theme for their expo that year was imagined strategies and techniques to combat a ‘Space Plague’ epidemic which supposedly started right there. After complementing them on this ingenious way of engaging youngsters in science, I commented that the virus which we really need to figure out how to fight is not a virus affecting cells, but a social virus manipulating and misdirecting how we think, how we figure things out. They heartily agreed, and we enjoyed a brief discussion on this point where science and society struggle. The timing of this science expo was an interesting coincidence, as the planning and preparation for engaging students in strategies and techniques to stop this Space Plague had been done before COVID-19 was known. COVID was new… anti-fact, anti-science, anti-expertise, and anti-openness-to-change were not new, but were growing significantly in their impact.</p><p>How have we gotten to where we are? Informed and concerned citizens ask this question about our polarized politics, and academics in various disciplines ask this about us in the broad context of civilization, and about us as a species. Fields from paleontology to genetics, from history to psychology, from neurophysiology to archaeology, from the study of religions to the dynamics of social power structures, from linguistics to evolutionary biology, and many more, each explore this question, sometimes in direct ways, and sometimes in very indirect ways.</p><p>Many today are justifiably concerned with the direction of civilization. I submit that an informed and responsible approach to problem-solving and priority-setting in terms of where we’re going from here, <em>require</em> an accurate knowledge of how we have gotten to where we are. Fairly late in life, with firsthand exposure to horrific and deadly civilizational hiccups in Lebanon and Rwanda, with up-close exposure to widely varied religions, and a career in science education, I became drawn to anthropology because I saw it as a potentially insight-yielding intersection of the broad fields of science, psychology/the study of religion/sociology, and history/political science/economics, where a rich cross-disciplinary process of distillation and synthesis could best take place. This could draw on maximizing the accuracy of understanding how we’ve gotten to where we are in order to better help us chart a course towards responsible societal choices, the end-goal being to increase the odds of us creating a decent, stable, and enjoyable social and physical environment for our descendants.</p><p>Thus I found myself in London, a grad student again, already in my 60s, in a new discipline. It was at first a surprise and then a puzzle to find in my studies that what I thought would be recognized as two of the giants on whose shoulders social anthropologists, in at least one important sense, stand — specifically physical anthropology and archaeology — seemed very often completely ignored. My thought-context came from many years of teaching high school biology, and recognizing that all organisms have deep evolutionary roots and corresponding stories behind them. After all, we largely got to who we are <em>as a species, </em>with natural selection acting to favor or eliminate mutations among our ancestral early cavemen and <em>their</em> ancestral creatures<em>,</em> <em>before</em> we developed civilization, initially simple but ultimately complex, around us.</p><p>A broadly educated audience reading here may well have not, like I had not, noted the detail of: physical anthropology and archaeology (after basic paleontology and with genetics) uncovering and processing clear evidence of our evolution as a species <em>and </em>thus logically the development/evolution of religion, <em>but</em> social anthropology being split — some researchers and authors directly addressing the reality of religion having an entirely human origin, and noting some of the risks posed by religion today, while other researchers and authors, even while directly exploring religion x, y, or z, remaining completely mute on both the real risks posed by an absolutist/ fundamentalist approach to faith, and the overwhelmingly likely origin and evolution of this human phenomenon, religion writ large. I write to share an exploration of why this lack of honesty on how we’ve gotten to where we are matters.</p><p>Later in this essay I will argue for greater communication between a concerned public which includes millions who seek to be broadly and reasonably deeply and accurately informed, and academics, including social anthropologists. In that vein, attempting to constructively walk my talk, while I address myself primarily to concerned and involved citizens who regularly work at being well and accurately informed, I will add a plea directed at academics, particularly any social anthropologists who might be among the audience which reads this.</p><p>I plan to express my concerns without bogging down the general reader with unending specific citations, though I will suggest a number of further readings. A personal disclosure: I was raised a missionary kid, educated in private Christian schools until my first masters 40 years ago. I had to find my own way to seeing beyond my indoctrination. I then spent most of my career teaching biology and chemistry in high school, later switching to history.</p><p>Thoughtful citizens, not limited to university settings, fairly often focus on evaluating and responding to ideas. Among them: Are there more constructive ways — and more destructive ways — to live? With this question in mind, a central focus can be put on how we live collectively, with a particular eye to how large groups can impact the whole of civilization? Drawing from history, psychology, science, and the discipline of anthropology, these citizens can thoughtfully participate in this evaluative and responsive process. As pointed out, anthropology should be well positioned to help broad society better understand how we’ve gotten to where we are, as a species and as civilization, and through that learning, improve our decision-making moving forward. But we everyday citizens need to cultivate habits of sincere and open exploration, honesty in evaluation, and involvement in communication about important ideas, including uncomfortable or unwelcome ones, in the circles in which we live.</p><p>So, allow me to suggest just two reasons why this lack of honesty and openness about humanity’s deep roots (how we’ve gotten to where we are) as a species matters. First, despite seeded doubts and drummed up controversy, there is a clear preponderance of evidence, and hard-earned consensus, that climate change is real, very significantly anthropogenic, and urgent. (If you aren’t yet persuaded of that, a whole separate paper is needed here.) We need not be concerned that life on earth won’t survive; it will. It is the <em>civilizational chaos</em> that rapidly shifting conditions on a densely populated and resource-limited earth will cause, that should concern us. More details on connecting climate change dismissal and the habit of believing what we want and shrugging off what we don’t like coming shortly.</p><p>I should explain in slightly more detail that part of what spurs me on to be willing to express unpopular ideas is that I was working in Rwanda when the genocide hit. I have indelible memories of the sights and sounds and smells of rampant death amidst that chaos. Western readers tended to hear only about this being an ethnic conflict, the Hutu vs. the Tutsi. Beyond the ancient origins, migrations, different ways of life, and then the added complications of colonialism, what few outsiders could understand, because it wasn’t often explained, was this: Rwanda was the most densely populated country in Africa, and that whereas in 1940 the average family had about 12.8 hectares to live off (more than they could hand-cultivate), by 1990, that was down to 2.7 hectares. (* Explanation of calculation in end-note.) When power-mongering and manipulative would-be mass murderers broadcast on local radio waves that “It’s either kill these cockroaches (term they used for Tutsis) now, or they’ll kill you later,” what, a generation before, would likely have been dismissed as nonsense, was now received as believable. Corner human beings in what they <em>perceive</em> as a fight for a basic survival resource, in that case enough land to feed your family, and most will behave like a cornered and dangerous animal. (It may be worth reminding ourselves here of the justification and encouragement Hitler offered to the German people in getting them on-board with taking neighboring lands, and wiping out selected locals: “Lebensraum.”)<strong> </strong>I do want to ultimately focus on solutions, not fears, but for now permit me to point out that global-scale civilizational chaos could create a death spiral, leaving the proportionately few survivors, as some have predicted, living as scattered hunter-gatherers.</p><p>The second specific reason for this lack of honesty about our deep roots mattering is that we live in a time when fact vs. alternative ‘fact’, evidence-based consensus vs. sincerely held belief, the importance of real expertise vs. the power of various forms of modern ‘tribal’ authority, real problem-solving vs. problem denial or deferral, and the open-minded willingness to learn, to update, vs. the tendency to double-down, to stick with ‘our’ tradition, are muddled and confused at best, then ignored, or reversed in valuation at worst<strong>. </strong>This objectivity, basic honesty, is essential in science as a habitual and expected way of coming to understanding things, including how we got “here” <em>and</em> how best to meet challenges and solve problems has further implications, and deserves some analysis.</p><p>In a list of my self-evident truths, I included: “That we owe a decent, stable, and (hopefully) enjoyable planet to future generations.” To be up to this challenge, we’ve got to be at our best as problem-solvers. That requires being honest with evidence, and not simply selecting evidence we like, dismissing what we don’t like. To cultivate a tendency in that direction, we also need to be honest about things that get in the way of that. We must recognize that: it’s human nature to habituate to believing what we want to believe, and to expecting that your beliefs should be ‘respected,’ which we interpret as going unchallenged; and that we must <em>learn</em> to question things. We must then ask: Where in human experience do we get the most practice at, the most reinforcement and refinement of, habituation to believing what we want, and expecting that to be respected, to go unchallenged?</p><p>I have now spent the last two decades searching, and a year studying anthropology, to find the best answer that I can to this question. I have yet to find a better-supported answer than: a typical training within a community of those with sincerely held religious beliefs. From childhood we learn that we don’t directly and openly challenge others’ beliefs — even if we do try to share our faith, our ‘better’ beliefs, and within our communities we might call their beliefs nutty or dangerous — in exchange for the same absence of open challenge directed at us.</p><p>It is a very short step then, in our brains, to expecting non-religious beliefs to also be respected, to go unchallenged. Interestingly, this seems to be increasing in very recent years. Flat-earthers now hold conventions, but don’t like real challenge. Some deny plate tectonics; some of the same people promote a very young earth, and don’t like being challenged. Racists have re-emerged, and while they seem very willing to engage in a physical fight, they don’t like a deep and evidence-based intellectual challenge. Some say vaccines are dangerous conspiracies, and feel attacked if challenged. And — elephant in the room — many dismiss climate change, and don’t want a discussion of serious physics, or broad evidence, won’t read deep and detailed reports and analyses if they can superficially tell that it doesn’t agree with their opinion, <em>and</em> feel that <em>their</em> <em>opinion</em> is of equal weight to the evidence, reasons, and concerns explained by experts. Habituation does, habits do, matter.</p><p>I realize that some readers might already be balking at the idea that strong religious communities contribute to believers expecting that whatever “our” beliefs are should not be challenged, so brace yourself, I’m taking this a step further.</p><p>Members of the many varied religious communities scattered around our globe have often never heard an evidence-based explanation of religion’s origins and history. There are many anthropologists who have contributed to our understanding of this, but for brevity here, I draw significantly from Pascal Boyer’s <em>Religion Explained </em>(and would also suggest reading Daniel Dennett’s <em>Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon, </em>and Jesse Bering’s<em> The Belief Instinct</em>).</p><p>As noted, we’ve figured out this story through the closely related fields (the shoulders/foundation we now build on) of physical anthropology combined with archaeology (with more recent refinements from fields including cognitive psychology). The details they’ve painstakingly worked out tell the story, supported further back by basic paleontology, of human evolution.</p><p>We can see the earlier brain-case volume increase, and then, between 100,000 and 50,000 years BP, a relatively sudden change and increase in our tool technology and symbol use, and ceremonial burial. Even more so than our stepped-up variations of tools, our increasingly complex use of symbols is a strong indicator of growth in breadth and depth of our very mental capacities, among them: agency detection — real and imagined, deepening self-awareness, theory of mind (TOM) and increasingly complex social interaction, and everything that goes with increased intelligence and communication ability, including simply pondering things. Noting the word mental <em>capacities</em>, not capacity, is important. The interplay between different inference systems is vital to beginning to adequately understand our development.</p><p>Our early ancestors developed agency detection naturally because it was selected for. (Better a false positive that the rustling in the grass might be a predator, than a false negative, that it was ‘nothing.’) They also had a seemingly endless set of puzzlers which they could not understand, and which seemed to call for agency. What makes the river rise seasonally when it hasn’t rained in months on our horizons? What occasionally makes the moon go blood-colored and then quickly come back to normal? What is that very rare strange fuzzy light with the long tail in the night sky that even the stories of our ancestors never mention? What makes the very regular tides of the ocean? What causes different sicknesses? What <em>is</em> the sun? What causes thunder, and what causes lightning, and even wind? What are these images I <em>see</em> in my eyes sometimes when I sleep? And what do they mean? By far the most likely agency which people in those primitive circumstances could, and probably did, come up with were spirit-world explanations. Naturally, these would have been passed down in stories, becoming oral histories, and <em>their</em> collection of spirits became part of their clan’s identity… probably contributing a unifying, and sense-of-belonging-creating, adaptive feature, with no obvious maladaptive costs in that context.</p><p>In addition to this mental capacity for detecting real agency and imagining others, we then include TOM and possible motives in other real people and various potential agents, and that our early ancestors also developed greater levels of self-awareness. When a caveman saw his brother’s eyes fade to the blank stare of death after being gored on a hunt, and saw the same thing happen in his toddling daughter’s eyes from just a couple days of watery crapping — he probably came not only to wonder about and possibly fear death in a sense beyond what animals do, but he and his clan would likely have also created stories of what might be possible, what might happen, after death… stories which could reduce fear and add hope, thus being a possible helpful and adaptive mechanism for dealing with their very hazard-filled life.</p><p>It is no surprise that as hunter-gathering ways gave way to the green revolution and to living in communities, that as labor specialized and society stratified, these spirit-world agents and realms solidified into increasingly formalized religions, with symbols and rituals to go with them… and a priest class to rule this domain. Through this came the great variety of gods, and faiths, varying with location and time.</p><p>A few quick side notes: Because some might already be thinking of theistic evolution, and a god perhaps later breathing a soul into man, as a still-religious explanation of the evidence, I will here simply remind us of Occam’s razor. To go further with just one example which we’ve heard in various forms, it is <em>possible</em> that I am nothing but a worm off in space with a vivid imagination. I’ve imagined my life, in all its details, including this ‘conversation.’ It’s also possible that you are the worm off in space with the vivid imagination, and you’re imagining your life, including this conversation. I submit that we’re much better off when we spend our time dealing with high probabilities rather than mere possibilities. I am aware that this understanding of the origins of religion, particularly during anthropology’s postmodern emphasis on uncertainty, fell out of fashion shall we say. More on a few issues with this story as we go.</p><p>In addition to this seldom-avoided <em>first risk</em> that religion is accompanied by habituation to expecting one’s beliefs to be respected, to go unchallenged, and of that spreading in our thought processes, rendering us immune to evidence and facts which we don’t like, affecting practical and non-religious fields like climate change, there are three other risks which have tended to go with strong religious belief which I feel compelled to briefly share for your consideration.</p><p><em>The Second Risk</em>: Those with strong faith tend to be quick to jump on the bandwagon of war in the name of their ‘right’ god, book, and people. “For God and country” is a recruiting tool which both history and our modern world demonstrate. Many in the west will think first of this implicating terrorists, pointing our fingers outward. To reduce the shallow temptation of stopping there, I offer the verifiable fact that when President George W. Bush was rallying the American public to invade Iraq and take down Saddam Hussein, it was largely the American Christian right which instantly rallied in support, and the secular left which attempted to have us pump the brakes, double-checking our assumptions and the evidence. As an attentive citizen, I observed this in real time. But readers can and should be skeptical, and so I provide this well-researched article: <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/4153098?refreqid=excelsior%3Ae61d1c01129a299a2a80509259805cb3">https://www.jstor.org/stable/4153098?refreqid=excelsior%3Ae61d1c01129a299a2a80509259805cb3</a> ; <em>Religion and American Attitudes toward an Invasion of Iraq</em>; Sociology of Religion, <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/i388459">Vol. 66, №3 (Autumn, 2005)</a>, pp. 243–261; Oxford University Press. A hundred million modern Americans is not just a tiny network of radicals.</p><p><em>The Third Risk</em>: Those with strong faith tend to presume that everything is in their God’s hands, believe that they are too small to make a difference when it comes to earthly problems or challenges, and that there’s a supernatural solution (think the 2nd coming) in the end. Attempting to take our challenges seriously much less urgently then <em>seems</em> a waste of effort, and unnecessary in any case.</p><p>And <em>fourth</em>: That the most disenfranchised groups (the poor, less educated, minorities, and too often particularly the women among them) have for millennia been persuaded to put all their eggs in the basket of hope for a future better life, whether in some heaven or in an upgrade in their next life here. They then are nearly infinitely patient and long-suffering in putting up with abuse, unfairness, and subtle (and direct) discrimination. All this while they could and should be organizing and finding ways to significantly improve their own lives here and now, and, perhaps more importantly, greatly improving the chances that their descendants will have a realistic shot at equality of opportunity, and a decent, stable, and sustainable ecological and social environment. (Sadly, the most affected people are exceedingly unlikely to be reading this. It is the responsibility of those of us privileged to have the time and focus, to bring this to their attention, and help them reduce their patience for abuse in the here and now, and to find, impatiently find, just and effective ways to create change through the tools and ideals of democracy.)</p><p>To be clear, I do not go about advocating that every person should become an atheist, and am certainly not asking any of us, or any discipline, to do that. On a practical level, that’s not going to happen, and further, such a direct effort would cause deeply rooted resistance. Rather, I simply beg of believers to become aware of these four risks, and to self-monitor so as to avoid making the risks become realities. Today, on a crowded and resource-limited planet, these risks mean religion carries much more in impactful negatives than it did in the days of cavemen or early civilization. The trouble with this set of negatives is that they’re not the type that will exert their influence slowly through natural selection; they’re much more likely to take things out with a figurative bang. If believers today put sincere effort into self-monitoring against those risks, sticking with a religion that they feel adds something to their lives no longer carries baggage harmful to the rest of humanity.</p><p>I am also convinced that more openly placing each religion in the context of the myriad others throughout history would be a helpful and honest step. With the acknowledged likelihood that, since they all tend to believe and claim that they are relatively (or absolutely) right and the others relatively wrong, while it is <em>possible</em> that one of them is in fact ‘right,’ and all the others wrong, that probability points decidedly against that. This reality could play a constructive role in cautioning against the risk of quickly jumping on the bandwagon of war in the name of their ‘right’ god, and shrugging at serious challenges as not being in our hands. It might also be helpful in getting more people to understand and embrace the necessity of <em>cooperation</em> in facing and solving many global-scale challenges, and this is no trivial matter!</p><p>To step back, we need to more often be part of reminding each other to ask and attempt to answer some big questions that are important. Keeping in mind Kierkegaard’s quite condensed comment on truth, “There are two ways to be fooled. One is to believe what isn’t true. The other is to refuse to accept what is true,” we need to follow this simple fact with a vitally important question: What does history show has been humanity’s <em>best</em> tool, even if never perfect, for figuring out what <em>is </em>true?</p><p>While I have heard individuals from various modern claims-based traditions (religions) temporarily offer the answer that our best tool for figuring out what is true has been their book, some discussion usually finds them willing to reconsider. It is beyond simply arguable that it is: to take a science-like approach to things. We put our ideas, our temporary understandings, to the test in the most objective way(s) we can, and we verify the evidence, and then we change our minds, adjust our conclusions, when the evidence warrants it. This evidence-based approach is profoundly different than a claims-based approach, and it applies beyond the hard sciences, to the social sciences.</p><p>In the years that I have argued that while science is not perfect, that it is still what history has shown to be our best tool for figuring out, as best we can, what <em>is</em> true, I have summarized that the central realization of the Scientific Revolution was that it was not only <em>okay</em> to question… everything, it was <em>good</em> to question. (As opposed to accepting assertions from authority, be it Aristotle, the Church, or any other person or organization.) This Revolution then fleshed out details on what became the scientific method, but the broad important concept was that in questioning everything, we should question even our own beliefs/ understanding. The new proposed answers to our questions, suggested understandings and beliefs in their tentative forms, we came to call hypotheses, but terminology isn’t nearly as important as the idea. Another important and broad feature is that we must verify and then <em>respect</em> evidence, whether we like it or not, and let consensus form around the best of it. This requires personal honesty, an openness to changing our minds, to admitting that a cherished previous idea turned out to be wrong. This willingness to change one’s mind in response to the best available evidence is not just the final step, it is in fact a precondition to the whole process. To carry this quickly and briefly forward, in essence The Enlightenment then took this “okayness” of questioning and applied it in the social realm. Did Kings really have a Divine Right? Were women really 2nd-class citizens? Was slavery just fine? Were “races” fundamentally unequal in capacities, and therefore in rights?</p><p>Here’s what I hope a plurality of us can embrace: Can we do all we can to help us avoid the worst of potential civilizational chaos; can we refuse to accept that we essentially fiddled while the kindling under Rome was ignited. I’m inviting, yes challenging, the many of you everyday citizens who have a commitment to being broadly informed and who actively support the idea of honesty with evidence in our collective problem-solving, <em>and</em> academics with deeper roots and a much more developed knowledge-base than mine in how we’ve gotten to where we are, to consider the same hope. Yes, many may be aware that a good number who are directly or indirectly involved with social anthropology (Berliner, Boyer, Dennett, Laidlaw, and many more) directly and honestly address human evolution and the origins of religion, and that others (Ingold, Lindholm, Sidky, and many more) do openly advocate for applying the strengths of a science-like approach in social anthropology, in contrast to an ever-softening postmodern indefinite uncertainty which indirectly encourages all manner of ‘alternative fact’ in today’s society. But perhaps fewer also know that too many ethnographies on religious groups are so cautiously written exploring and explaining, “through the eyes” of the subject group, that when the many members of said groups get the book and read about themselves, they never see their religion in the context of the myriad others past and present, and never hear human evolution and an academic, evidence-based, understanding of the origins of religion explained, and therefore only feel affirmed and all the more certain of being ‘right.’ These group members, and some members of the broader public, may not yet (or ever) see these suggested at-least-postscript explanations of religion as plausible, but <em>we need </em>introductions to and then<em> </em>reminders that what reveals ideas as more connected, or less connected, to realities… is the verifiable evidence, not the intensity of conviction. We need reminders that in democracies — where voters hire the crews that run the ships of state, citizens having ‘mindsets’ that are <em>not</em> set on pre-formed claims-based beliefs, and are, rather, open to change, to verifiable evidence — this honesty about the need to overcome our tendencies to believe what we happen to like and to dismiss the rest, is vital. Two prime examples of beautifully written and empathetic ethnographies which miss the opportunity and responsibility of providing perhaps unwelcome but needed context of one religion among myriad others, and the development of humanity and of religion, are: Tanya Luhrmann’s <em>When God Talks Back,</em> and Saba Mahmood’s <em>Politics of Piety</em>.</p><p>Broad, deep, and evidence-based summaries of how we’ve gotten to where we are have been written. Yuval Harari’s <em>Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind</em> is among the most comprehensive. That for over 10 thousand years after the green revolution, largely leaving our hunter-gatherer ways, and the development and dominance of many varied religions, we changed and progressed relatively little <em>until</em> the key steps of the Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment, has become increasingly clear. It was then that advances in our understanding of life and the universe, our concepts of the universality of human rights, and so many measures of our quality of life, took off and grew at ever-increasing rates. Another fascinating read focused on this particular aspect of change is Stephen Greenblatt’s <em>The Swerve: How the World Became Modern.</em></p><p>A couple final clarifications: This is not a call for atheism to be a litmus test in any academic field, including social anthropology. Anthropologists know that informative ethnographies have been written, useful theories advanced, aspects of power, injustice, politics, and economics revealed, and new perspectives on social stability and change, by believers (Evans-Pritchard, Douglas, the Turners, and more), but I would suggest that <em>in our current world circumstances</em>, greater honesty is called for in the writing, in the contextualizing and explaining of religious traditions. And I will add the caution that an anthropologist who is a believer today bears an extra obligation to publicly explain to their readers how they self-monitor so as to limit the risks that have gone with faith, which can cloud and limit urgently needed problem-solving, and confuse what could and should be sound public/collective policy decisions.</p><p>I hope we can appropriately handle the tempting sidetrack of disagreements on the particulars of any single example of telling the stories of the rise of humanity and then of religion. This sidetrack could cause us to forget that it is vital that we honestly recognize and face psychological factors which get in the way of us realistically addressing urgent issues like climate change. These factors contribute to confusion when considering the profound difference between consensus on the most plausible explanation of evidence, as compared to collections of alternative facts, recent conspiracy theories, and sincerely held beliefs — Lindholm’s warned-of mingling of “fact and fantasy.” (<em>Logical and Moral Dilemmas of Postmodernism</em>; Author: Charles Lindholm; Source: The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, Vol. 3, №4 (Dec., 1997), pp. 747–760.)</p><p>If you are persuaded that the social/civilizational risks and challenges associated with climate change are great and are urgent, and if you are persuaded that in order to collectively be good problem-solvers on a global scale, we need to reduce the level of habituation to believing what we want and expecting that to go unchallenged, thereby remaining of unchanged mind on multiple issues, then I hope you might also find yourself persuaded that we, as individual concerned citizens and/or as academics, must engage in open discussion with our fellow-citizens, of the avoidable but serious risks that have tended to go with strong faith.</p><p>We are often enough reminded of the difficulties of speaking truth to power. I submit that we need to give more thought to the challenges of speaking truth to the masses. I’m not speaking here of those hanging on by their economic fingernails; they can be forgiven for their necessary preoccupation, and helped toward less precarity. I am speaking of the many who are concerned but too often confused; who work at being informed, but are slowed and distracted by not having a fairly reliable way to evaluate information for accuracy; who intend to and often do vote; who sometimes do question things; who participate in types of public dialogue, whether simply with family and co-workers, reading (or writing) op-eds and blogs; and who participate in other social media where ideas, for better or for worse, can do their viral thing. In would-be democracies, this matters. Vital messages are not necessarily popular. My plea to anthropologists: Please, more frequently take advantage of anthropology’s solid position for helping broad society better understand how we’ve gotten to where we are by writing with a public audience in mind, far beyond a collection of other ivory towers. This is not about ending ivory tower dialogue; it’s about helping some of the understandings developed there reach the rest of us, everyday concerned and involved citizens, and make a difference. I hope most reading here might find yourselves persuaded to openly and unapologetically advocate for our <em>best</em> tool for finding relative and probable truth — this science-like approach, and persuaded that a more honest and frequent (even if for some, unwelcome) reminding of the human story — including at least a postscript explanation of religion — is needed, and would be constructive.</p><p>*Calculated using land area minus National Parks &amp; Forests, divided by # of families. Families derived from population divided 8 individuals/family; based on 1940 population of 1.5 million; family size of 8 from initial 10 because of fertility rate=8.2, and child mortality rate about 250/1000 births; 1990 population of 7.1 million; family size of 8 from initial 9 because of fertility rate=7.2, and child mortality rate of 150/1000 births.</p><p><a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?locations=RW-ID">https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?locations=RW-ID</a></p><p><a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?locations=RW">https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?locations=RW</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=64902133a067" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[After Trump’s Conviction]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/after-trumps-conviction-80902b105a21?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80902b105a21</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump-and-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[our-current-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump-conviction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[beyond-tribal-loyalty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2024-elections]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 Jun 2024 00:26:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-02T00:26:12.716Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Watching various talking heads, Senators and Representatives, and selected interviewed common citizens, say things like: “No law was broken;” “This is the result of a weaponized Justice Department;” “This was purely political;” “He didn’t even know what he was charged with;” is truly remarkable.</p><p>If we’re honest, and attempt to be objective, we can find common ground and reasonable conclusions. One item at a time:</p><p>New York, and Oregon, (and I’d venture to guess all the other states) do have laws requiring the accurate recording and reporting of basic bookkeeping/accounting. Doing so falsely is illegal; it is a broken law.</p><p>When a law is broken, those in law enforcement across the country regularly ask: What was the motive for an illegal action? This is not an exceptional question, and it often-enough leads to revealing further law-breaking.</p><p>A Grand Jury of regular citizens considered the evidence and concluded that this case merited going to trial. The Justice Department had nothing to do with this. Further, at trial, a jury concluded — based on the clear documents with signatures and all, corroborated by multiple witness testimonies which stood up under cross examination — that Trump was guilty of trying to hide just one of his serial wife-cheating affairs by means of buying the woman’s silence <strong><em>In Order To</em></strong> limit the damage to his already pussy-grabbing reputation in the run-up to the 2016 election. Further, despite him regularly talking at impromptu press conferences, Trump passed on his opportunity and right to testify in his own defense under oath in court. How does he, how do any of these people complaining about a “rigged process”, complain when you pass on what a truly innocent person could most probably make into the central part of demonstrating their innocence?</p><p>Do these talking heads, politicians, and still-Trump-supporting regular citizens actually manage to avoid simply asking themselves how loudly they would be protesting if a leading politician on the left had done the same things?! Put any number of specific individuals into this hypothetical, and we can all imagine the decibel-level of their outcries; they would scream if it wasn’t brought to trial, and/or if he wasn’t convicted.</p><p>About the still-coming trials, ask <strong><em>this same question</em></strong> if a leader on the left had: tried to get specific states to change their election results; had encouraged a direct overthrow of the last steps in the peaceful transfer of power, even if it included violent means; had continued to maintain that the election was stolen, even after literally dozens of investigations and court cases had, by transparent processes, concluded that the election was not corrupt or stolen, and was in fact fair and secure; had taken and then carelessly kept Top Secret national security documents; had tried to claim that they can’t be held accountable for <strong><em>anything</em></strong> they did while in office. Any of this by a leader from the left would have been met by screaming condemnation from people on the right… people who right now are amazingly silent, and even outspokenly supportive(!), about Trump having done all of this.</p><p>I borrow here from Joseph N. Welch, who helped bring the McCarthy hearings to an end by asking: “At long last, have you left no sense of decency?” Why do you, friends or strangers to me, bother being so transparently hypocritical? You don’t have to permanently lack decency… or a sense of shame. Liz Cheney, John Bolton, Mark Esper, Mike Pense, Mark Milley, John Kelly, and many, many, more top Republican insiders, reached a point of realizing they must change their minds, their position on Trump and this election. Please, who out here among the us regular viewers-from-a-distance know better than these insiders?</p><p>One final point: Trump has on numerous occasions expressed his disrespect for Generals, for top scientists, for doctors, And for members of our armed services who paid the ultimate price in defending our freedoms, our democratic republic, our way of life, and our very lives. What can we reasonably conclude about his respect, or lack thereof, for the “ordinary” man or woman? Come on; be real. Why do you give your loyalty, support, and even money, to a person who has spat in the faces of dead soldiers, and surely has no more respect for you. The list of leading republican insiders given above quit making excuses for their loyalty; they changed, and put the good of the country over any silly sense of trying to maintain some tribal pride. You have that option too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80902b105a21" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Gaza… Israel… Palestinians… and aspects of Inevitability]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/gaza-israel-palestinians-and-aspects-of-inevitability-9f0d15269460?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f0d15269460</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[palestinian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inevitable-reactions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[terrorism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaza]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Nov 2023 00:44:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-11T00:44:33.054Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We have been watching the Gaza/Israel/Palestine tragedy, with degrees of personal angst, targeted or confused anger, and, for many of us, more a sense of helplessness and resignation than hope. I am not a member of our state department, but I lived and worked in Lebanon for a school year, travelled in Israel and Jordan, and much later worked for another school year in Oman. All along the way I engaged in many conversations, asking a lot of questions, and doing a lot of listening… followed by years of reading and thinking. I offer here some thoughts for your consideration.</p><p>When you and I, and Israelis, and most of the world, reacted to the October 7 terrorist attack, the murder of many Jewish members of Israel near Gaza, and thought and said that this was “barbaric,” “uncivilized,” “inhumane,” etc., these reactions were really a “duh” moment. OF COURSE these thoughts and words, and then the Israeli Defense Force’s actions, were Going to Happen… it was all inevitable, completely understandable.</p><p>I want to explore with you though, a background phenomenon which is also inevitable and completely understandable, but which most do not stop and think about.</p><p>When I had conversations with both Israeli settlers and displaced Palestinians in my time there in the summer of 1981, it was painful to hear the combination of hopes and fears expressed. The immediate past was spoken of, but more-so, the unknown future.</p><p>A Palestinian father, with his 10-year-old son listening, described watching bulldozers destroy his neighborhood to build an Israeli settlement. He noted that in just the four years since 1977, the population of settlers in the West Bank seemed to have well more than doubled. (We now know that in fact it had quadrupled.) He wondered if what he’d witnessed would stop at some soon-coming point, or would continue indefinitely.</p><p>Now let’s use our ability to concretely imagine. That 10-year-old, and his peers, would have been 24 by 1995, 29 by 2000. They could have 20-year-old children of their own by now. They, collectively, have witnessed the population of settlers increase from roughly 20,000 in 1981, to over 450,000 today. They have watched, again and again and again, the bulldozing of their communities, and have heard, again and again, the empty discussions of an independent Palestinian State (nation). (Don’t consider me an authority on the facts here; google them.)</p><p>Over the decades, what genuine hope could the father I spoke with offer to his children and grandchildren? Here is a central point for us to recognize, to fully grasp. When young Palestinians grow up repeatedly witnessing the slow-motion violence of bulldozers on their and their friends’ and relative’s homes, and when they hear of the endlessness from the past into the future, we should be able to see another “duh” moment. When one can’t find grounds for honest Hope… that’s when commitment to acts of violent retribution begin to develop roots. Future acts of terror are not completely random. To take violent action Knowing you’re going to die in the process requires a strong sense of desperation, driven by a lack of actual hope.</p><p>Some will attempt to dismiss this conversation as “excusing, justifying” terrorism. It is not. Not any more than studies of child abuse or wife-beating excuse or justify that. To grow our understanding of a negative phenomenon, to see significant “explanations,” is not to justify it. This is about coming to recognize a very tragic positive feedback loop, a downward spiral, where X generates Y, which continues X.</p><p>We need to recognize that although the time-scale of bulldozing is hours and days, not fractions of seconds as in a terrorist bomb, (both continuing for decades), it is no less violent in the hearts and minds of those repeatedly on the receiving end. I submit that we <em>should</em> find endless bulldozing and settlement-building to be equally abhorrent, inhumane, and completely unacceptable. Sadly, it is the failure of the west in general, and of successive US administrations, that has allowed this slow-motion violence to continue, generation after generation. (We have failed: to draw a line in the sand, to firmly and concretely state, “Enough! Any more settlements, which tear out simple hope, and create desperation, and we will implement financial consequences as just the beginning. This. Must. Stop.”, and <em>then</em> to follow those firm words with actual actions.)</p><p>That we find the recent Hamas terrorist attack to be repugnant, uncivilized, and completely unacceptable is indeed a duh moment/thought/reaction. Many more of us <em>should</em> also be able to react in an equally duh way by recognizing that repeated and endless bulldozing and settlement-building is also repugnant, uncivilized, and completely unacceptable, and if ignored will inevitably generate terrorism rooted in hopelessness and resultant desperation, for as long as any semblance of genuine and honest hope is cut short.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f0d15269460" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fiddling, or Being Willing to Advocate for Unpopular Positions:]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/fiddling-or-being-willing-to-advocate-for-unpopular-positions-46ad54a65a30?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46ad54a65a30</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Aug 2022 03:13:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-30T18:15:54.977Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>a look at a key root of the fact — alternative fact phenomenon.</p><p>(This essay has been significantly updated, refined, and slightly expanded, and is also published here on Medium. See <em>“Improving our Collective Problem-Solving…”</em>)</p><p>by Doug Matheson</p><p>In February of 2020 I happened to stop by a SmashfestUK science expo in London, and talked with two young-adult staffers. The theme for their expo that year was imagined strategies and techniques to combat a ‘Space Plague’ epidemic which supposedly started right there. After complementing them on this ingenious way of engaging teenagers in science, I commented that the virus which we really need to figure out how to fight is not a virus affecting cells, but a social virus manipulating and misdirecting how we think, how we figure things out. They heartily agreed, and we enjoyed a brief discussion on this point where science and society struggle. The timing of this science expo was an interesting coincidence, as the planning and preparation for engaging students in strategies and techniques to stop this Space Plague had been done before COVID-19 was known. COVID was new… anti-fact, anti-science, anti-expertise, and anti-openness-to-change were not new, but were growing significantly in their impact.</p><p>How have we gotten to where we are? Informed and concerned citizens ask this question about our polarized politics, and academics in various disciplines ask this about us in the broad context of civilization, and about us as a species. Fields from paleontology to genetics, from history to psychology, from neurophysiology to archaeology, from the study of religions to the dynamics of social power structures, from linguistics to evolutionary biology, and many more, each explore this question, sometimes in direct ways, and sometimes in very indirect ways. Many today are justifiably concerned with the direction of civilization. I submit that an informed and responsible approach to problem-solving and priority-setting in terms of where we’re going from here, <em>require</em> an accurate knowledge of how we have gotten to where we are.</p><p>Fairly late in life, with firsthand exposure to horrific and deadly civilizational hiccups in Lebanon and Rwanda, with up-close exposure to widely varied religions, and a career in science education, I was drawn to anthropology because I saw it as a potentially insight-yielding intersection of the broad fields of science, psychology/the study of religion/sociology, and history/political science/economics, where a rich cross-disciplinary process of distillation and synthesis could best take place. This could draw on maximizing the accuracy of understanding how we’ve gotten to where we are in order to better help us chart a course towards responsible societal choices, the end-goal being to increase the odds of us creating decent, stable, and enjoyable social and ecological environments for our descendants.</p><p>Thus I found myself in London, a grad student again, already in my 60s, in a new discipline. It was at first a surprise and then a puzzle to find in my studies that what I thought would be recognized as two of the giants on whose shoulders social anthropologists, in at least one important sense, stand — specifically physical/biological anthropology and archaeology — seem most often completely ignored. My thought-context came from many years of teaching high school biology, and recognizing that all organisms have deep evolutionary roots and corresponding stories behind them. After all, we largely got to who we are <em>as a species, </em>with natural selection acting to favor or eliminate mutations among our ancestral early cavemen and <em>their</em> ancestral creatures<em>,</em> <em>before</em> we developed complex civilization around us. I didn’t yet know that the ethnographic aspects of anthropology had well-preceded the development of physical anthropology as a discipline. I soon noted that this ignoring of physical anthropology seems particularly acute in much ethnographic material when it centrally addresses or even touches on religious aspects of society/culture. Now, a full century after the early stages of the discipline of physical anthropology, of studying our development as a species, it seemed to me that the anchor of honesty when it comes to addressing the basic evidence for and reality of evolution, specifically human evolution, and therefore for the origins of religion writ large, is simply completely skipped by too many, not even being given mention in a postscript in social/ethnographic anthropology writing.</p><p>Later in this essay I will argue for greater communication between a concerned public which includes millions who seek to be broadly and reasonably deeply and accurately informed, and academics in various subfields in the social sciences. In that vein, attempting to constructively walk my talk, herein I will be addressing my thoughts sometimes to one of these groups, sometimes to the other, and most often to both. It is my hope that to some degree this can reach a broad audience of concerned citizens who seek to be broadly informed, <em>and</em> academics in the social sciences, including some social anthropologists.</p><p>Having completed my studies merely to the MA level, I now know that what was a surprise to me is old news to anthropologists with deeper roots than mine; <em>the heart of what I share here is why this lack of honesty and openness about human evolution and the origins of religion matters, and matters to civilization in practical ways beyond the disciplines in the social sciences.</em> (I plan to express my concerns without bogging down the general reader with unending specific citations, though I will suggest a number of further readings. Anthropologists reading here can certainly quickly list well-known ethnographies significantly focused on religion, which illustrate the absence of even mentioning human evolution, established by physical anthropology, and the origins of religion. Any follow-up discussion can arise where it will, and be as citation-rich as warranted. While in parentheses, a personal disclosure: I was raised a missionary kid, educated in private Christian schools until my first masters 40 years ago. I had to find my own way to seeing beyond my indoctrination. I then spent most of my career teaching biology and chemistry, later switching to history.)</p><p>Thoughtful citizens, not limited to university settings, fairly often focus on evaluating and responding to ideas. Among them: Are there more constructive ways — and more destructive ways — to live… with a central focus on how we live collectively, with a particular eye to how large groups can impact the whole of civilization? Drawing from history, psychology, the hard sciences and the social sciences, including anthropology, these citizens can thoughtfully participate in this evaluative and responsive process. As pointed out, anthropology is well positioned to help broad society better understand how we’ve gotten to where we are, as a species and as civilization, and through that learning, improve our decision-making moving forward. Keeping in mind the adage that “Just because we can, doesn’t mean we should,” I wish to specify here that anthropologists and other social scientists not only can engage in this process, but that we also should do so in ways which might maximally impact our collective societal thinking, choices, and therefore actions, even if some of these ways of engaging might be uncomfortably honest ones, and therefore be unwelcome in some quarters.</p><p>So, allow me to suggest just two reasons why this lack of honesty and openness about humanity’s deep roots (how we’ve gotten to where we are) as a species matters. First, despite seeded doubts and drummed up controversy, there is a clear preponderance of evidence, and hard-earned consensus, that climate change is real, very significantly anthropogenic, and urgent. (If you aren’t yet persuaded of that, a whole separate paper is needed here.) We need not be concerned that life on earth won’t survive; it will. It is the <em>civilizational chaos</em> that rapidly shifting conditions on a densely populated and resource-limited earth will cause, that should concern us.</p><p>I should explain in slightly more detail that part of what spurs me on is that I was working in Rwanda when the genocide hit. I have indelible memories of the sights and sounds and smells of rampant death amidst that chaos. Western readers tended to hear only about this being an ethnic conflict, the Hutu vs. the Tutsi. What few outsiders could understand, because it wasn’t often explained, was that Rwanda was the most densely populated country in Africa, and that whereas in 1940 the average family had about 12.8 hectares to live off (more than they could hand-cultivate), by 1990, that was down to 2.7 hectares. (* Explanation of calculation in end-note.) When power-mongering and manipulative would-be mass murderers broadcast on local radio waves that “It’s either kill these cockroaches (term used for Tutsis) now, or they’ll kill you later,” what, a generation before, would likely have been dismissed as nonsense, was now received as believable. Corner human beings in what they <em>perceive</em> as a fight for a basic survival resource, in that case enough land to feed your family, and most will behave like a cornered and dangerous animal. (It may be worth reminding ourselves here of the justification and encouragement Hitler offered to the German people in getting them on-board with taking neighboring lands, and wiping out selected locals: “Lebensraum.”) I do want to ultimately focus on solutions, not fears, but for now permit me to point out that global-scale civilizational chaos could create a death spiral, leaving the proportionately few survivors, as some have predicted, living as scattered hunter-gatherers.</p><p>The second specific reason for this lack of honesty about our deep roots mattering is that we live in a time when fact vs. alternative ‘fact’, evidence-based consensus vs. sincerely held belief, the importance of real expertise vs. the power of various forms of modern tribal authority, real problem-solving vs. problem denial or deferral, and the open-minded willingness to learn, to update, vs. the tendency to double-down, to stick with our tradition, are muddled and confused at best, then ignored, or reversed in valuation at worst. This objectivity, honesty, of science as a habitual and expected way of coming to understanding things, including how we got “here” <em>and</em> how best to meet challenges and solve problems has further implications, and deserves some analysis.</p><p>In a list of my self-evident truths, I included: “That we owe a decent, stable, and (hopefully) enjoyable planet to future generations.” To be up to this challenge, we’ve got to be at our best as problem-solvers. That requires being honest with evidence, and not simply selecting evidence we like, dismissing what we don’t like. To cultivate a tendency in that direction, we also need to be honest about things that get in the way of that. We must recognize that: it’s human nature to habituate to believing what we want to believe, and to expecting that your beliefs should be ‘respected’, which we interpret as going unchallenged; and that we must <em>learn</em> to question things. We must then ask: Where in human experience do we get the most practice at, the most reinforcement and refinement of, habituation to believing what we want, and expecting that to be respected, to go unchallenged?</p><p>I have now spent the last two decades searching, and a year studying anthropology, to find the best answer that I can to this question. I have yet to find a better-supported answer than: a typical training within a community of those with sincerely held religious beliefs. From childhood we learn that we don’t directly and openly challenge others’ beliefs — even if we do try to share our faith, our ‘better’ beliefs, and within our communities we might call their beliefs nutty or dangerous — in exchange for the same absence of open challenge directed at us.</p><p>It is a very short step then, in our brains, to expecting non-religious beliefs to also be respected, to go unchallenged. Interestingly, this seems to be increasing in very recent years. Flat-earthers now hold conventions, but don’t like real challenge. Some deny plate tectonics; some of the same people promote a very young earth, and don’t like being challenged. Racists have re-emerged, and while they seem very willing to engage in a physical fight, they don’t like a deep and evidence-based intellectual challenge. Some say vaccines are dangerous conspiracies, and feel attacked if challenged. And — elephant in the room — many dismiss climate change, and don’t want a discussion of serious physics, or broad evidence, won’t read deep and detailed reports and analyses if they can superficially tell that it doesn’t agree with their opinion, <em>and</em> feel that their <em>opinion</em> is of equal weight to the evidence, reasons, and concerns explained by experts. Habituation does, habits do, matter.</p><p>I realize that some readers might already be balking at the idea that strong religious communities contribute to believers expecting that whatever “our” beliefs are should not be challenged, so brace yourself, I’m taking this a step further.</p><p>Members of the many varied religious communities scattered around our globe have often never heard an evidence-based explanation of religion’s origins and history. There are many anthropologists who have contributed to our understanding of this, but for brevity here, I draw significantly from Pascal Boyer’s <em>Religion Explained </em>(and would also suggest reading Daniel Dennett’s <em>Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon</em>).</p><p>As noted, we’ve figured out this story through the closely related fields (the shoulders/foundation we now build on) of physical anthropology combined with archaeology (with more recent refinements from fields including cognitive psychology). The details they’ve painstakingly worked out tell the story, supported further back by basic paleontology, of human evolution. I don’t pretend to ‘inform’ anthropologists reading here of this story, but to provide a reminder and a simplification (I know that’s risky in itself), and thereby an illustration of a form of the story that could be refined without overwhelming lengthening.</p><p>We can see the earlier brain-case volume increase, and then, between 100,000 and 50,000 years BP, a relatively sudden change and increase in our tool technology and symbol use, and ceremonial burial. Even more so than our stepped-up variations of tools, our increasingly complex use of symbols is a strong indicator of growth in breadth and depth of our very mental capacities, among them: agency detection — real and imagined, deepening self-awareness, theory of mind (TOM) and increasingly complex social interaction, and everything that goes with increased intelligence and communication ability, including simply pondering things. Noting the word mental <em>capacities</em>, not capacity, is important. The interplay between different inference systems is vital to beginning to adequately understand our development.</p><p>Our early ancestors developed agency detection naturally because it was selected for. (Better a false positive that the rustling in the grass might be a predator, than a false negative, that it was ‘nothing’.) They also had a seemingly endless set of puzzlers which they could not understand, and which seemed to call for agency. What makes the river rise seasonally when it hasn’t rained in months on our horizons? What occasionally makes the moon go blood-colored and then quickly come back to normal? What is that very rare strange fuzzy light with the long tail in the night sky that even the stories of our ancestors never mention? What makes the very regular tides of the ocean? What causes different sicknesses? What <em>is</em> the sun? What causes thunder, and what causes lightning, and even wind? What are these images I <em>see</em> in my eyes sometimes when I sleep? And what do they mean? By far the most likely agency which people in those primitive circumstances could, and probably did, come up with were spirit-world explanations. Naturally, these would have been passed down in stories, becoming oral histories, and <em>their</em> collection of spirits became part of their clan’s identity… probably contributing a unifying, and sense-of-belonging-creating, adaptive feature, with no obvious maladaptive costs in that context.</p><p>In addition to this mental capacity for detecting real agency and imagining others, we then include TOM and possible motives in other real people and various potential agents, and that our early ancestors also developed greater levels of self-awareness. When a caveman saw his brother’s eyes fade to the blank stare of death after being gored on a hunt, and saw the same thing happen in his toddling daughter’s eyes from just a couple days of watery crapping — he probably came not only to wonder about and possibly fear death in a sense beyond what animals do, but he and his clan would likely have also created stories of what might be possible, what might happen, after death… stories which could reduce fear and add hope, thus being a possible helpful and adaptive mechanism for dealing with their very hazard-filled life.</p><p>It is no surprise that as hunter-gathering ways gave way to the green revolution and to living in communities, that as labor specialized and society stratified, these spirit-world agents and realms solidified into increasingly formalized religions, with symbols and rituals to go with them… and a priest class to rule this domain. Through this came the great variety of gods, and faiths, varying with location and time.</p><p>A few quick side notes: Because some might already be thinking of theistic evolution, and this god perhaps later breathing a soul into man, as a still-religious explanation of the evidence, I will here simply remind us of Occam’s razor. To go further with just one example which we’ve heard in various forms, it is <em>possible</em> that I am nothing but a worm off in space with a vivid imagination. I’ve imagined my life, in all its details, including this ‘conversation’. It’s also possible that you are the worm off in space with the vivid imagination, and you’re imagining your life, including this conversation. I submit that we’re much better off when we spend our time dealing with high probabilities rather than mere possibilities. I am aware that this understanding of the origins of religion, particularly during anthropology’s postmodern emphasis on uncertainty, fell out of fashion shall we say. More on a few issues with this story as we go.</p><p>In addition to this seldom-avoided <em>first risk</em> that religion is accompanied by habituation to expecting one’s beliefs to be respected, to go unchallenged, and of that spreading in our thought processes, rendering us immune to evidence and facts which we don’t like, affecting practical and non-religious fields like climate change, there are three other risks which have tended to go with strong religious belief which I feel compelled to briefly share for your consideration.</p><p><em>The Second Risk</em>: Those with strong faith tend to be quick to jump on the bandwagon of war in the name of their ‘right’ god, book, and people. “For God and country” is a recruiting tool which both history and our modern world demonstrate. Many in the west will think first of this implicating terrorists, pointing our fingers outward. To reduce the shallow temptation of stopping there, I offer the verifiable fact that when President George W. Bush was rallying the American public to invade Iraq and take down Saddam Hussein, it was largely the American Christian right which instantly rallied in support, and the secular left which attempted to have us pump the brakes, double-checking our assumptions and the evidence. As an attentive citizen, I observed this in real time. But readers can and should be skeptical, and so I provide this well-researched article: <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/4153098?refreqid=excelsior%3Ae61d1c01129a299a2a80509259805cb3">https://www.jstor.org/stable/4153098?refreqid=excelsior%3Ae61d1c01129a299a2a80509259805cb3</a> ; <em>Religion and American Attitudes toward an Invasion of Iraq</em>; Sociology of Religion, <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/i388459">Vol. 66, №3 (Autumn, 2005)</a>, pp. 243–261; Oxford University Press. A hundred million modern Americans is not just a tiny network of radicals.</p><p><em>The Third</em>: Those with strong faith tend to presume that everything is in their God’s hands, believe that they are too small to make a difference when it comes to earthly problems or challenges, and that there’s a supernatural solution (think the 2nd coming) in the end. Attempting to take our challenges seriously much less urgently then <em>seems</em> a waste of effort, and unnecessary in any case.</p><p>And <em>fourth</em>: That the most disenfranchised groups (the poor, less educated, minorities, and too often particularly the women among them) have for millennia been persuaded to put all their eggs in the basket of hope for a future better life, whether in some heaven or in an upgrade in their next life here. They then are nearly infinitely patient and long-suffering in putting up with abuse, unfairness, and subtle (and direct) discrimination. All this while they could and should be organizing and finding ways to significantly improve their own lives here and now, and, perhaps more importantly, greatly improving the chances that their descendants will have a realistic shot at equality of opportunity, and a decent, stable, and sustainable ecological and social environment. (Sadly, the most affected people are exceedingly unlikely to be reading here. It is the responsibility of those of us privileged to have the time and focus, to bring this to their attention, and help them reduce their patience for abuse in the here and now, and to find, impatiently find, just and effective ways to create change through the tools and ideals of democracy.)</p><p>To be clear, I do not go about advocating that every person should become an atheist, and am certainly not asking social anthropology as a discipline to do that. On a practical level, that’s not going to happen, and further, such a direct effort would cause deeply rooted resistance. Rather, I simply beg of believers to become aware of these four risks, and to self-monitor so as to avoid making the risks become realities. Today, on a crowded and resource-limited planet, these risks mean religion carries much more impactful negatives than it did in the days of cavemen or early civilization. The trouble with this set of negatives is that they’re not the type that will exert their influence slowly through natural selection; they’re much more likely to take things out with a figurative bang. If believers today put sincere effort into self-monitoring against those risks, sticking with a religion that they feel adds something to their lives no longer carries baggage harmful to the rest of humanity.</p><p>I am also convinced that more openly placing each religion in the context of the myriad others throughout history would be a helpful and honest step. With the acknowledged likelihood that, since they all tend to believe and claim that they are relatively (or absolutely) right and the others relatively wrong, while it is <em>possible</em> that one of them is in fact ‘right’, and all the others wrong, that the probability points decidedly against that. This reality could play a constructive role in cautioning against the risk of quickly jumping on the bandwagon of war in the name of their ‘right’ god, and shrugging at serious challenges as not being in our hands. It might also be helpful in getting more people to understand and embrace the necessity of <em>cooperation</em> in facing and solving many global-scale challenges, and this is no trivial matter!</p><p>To step back, we need to more often be part of reminding each other to ask and attempt to answer some big questions that are important. Keeping in mind Kierkegaard’s quite condensed comment on truth, “There are two ways to be fooled. One is to believe what isn’t true. The other is to refuse to accept what is true,” we need to follow this simple fact with a vitally important question: What does history show has been humanity’s best, even if never perfect, tool for figuring out what <em>is </em>true?</p><p>While I have heard individuals from various modern claims-based traditions (religions) temporarily offer the answer that our best tool for figuring out what is true has been their book, some discussion usually finds them willing to reconsider. It is beyond simply arguable that it is: to take a science-like approach to things. We put our ideas, our temporary understandings, to the test in the most objective way(s) we can, and we verify the evidence, and then we change our minds, adjust our conclusions, when the evidence warrants it. This evidence-based approach is profoundly different than a claims-based approach, and it applies beyond the hard sciences, to the social sciences.</p><p>In the years that I have argued that while science is not perfect, that it is still what history has shown to be our best tool for figuring out, as best we can, what <em>is</em> true, I have summarized that the central realization of the Scientific Revolution was that it was not only <em>Okay</em> to question… everything, it was <em>Good</em> to question. (As opposed to accepting assertions from authority, be it Aristotle, the Church, or…) This Revolution then fleshed out details on what became the scientific method, but the broad important concept was that in questioning everything, we should question even our own beliefs/ understanding. The new proposed answers to our questions, suggested understandings and beliefs in their tentative forms, we came to call hypotheses, but terminology isn’t nearly as important as the idea. Another important and broad feature is that we must verify and then <em>respect</em> evidence, whether we like it or not, and let consensus form around the best of it; this requires personal honesty, an openness to changing our minds, to admitting that a cherished previous idea turned out to be wrong. This willingness to change one’s mind in response to the best available evidence is not just the final step, it is in fact a pre-condition to the process. To carry this quickly and briefly forward, in essence The Enlightenment then took this “Okayness” of questioning and applied it in the social realm. Did Kings really have a Divine Right? Were women really 2nd-class citizens? Was slavery just fine? Were “races” fundamentally unequal in capacities, and therefore in rights?</p><p>Here’s what I personally hope for: I want to do all I can to help us avoid the worst of potential civilizational chaos; I don’t want to accept that I essentially fiddled while the kindling under Rome was ignited. And I’m inviting, yes challenging, the many of you everyday citizens who have a commitment to being broadly informed and who actively support the idea of honesty with evidence in our collective problem-solving, <em>and</em> social scientists, including anthropologists with deeper roots and a much more developed knowledge-base than mine within social anthropology, to consider the same hope. Yes, we know that a good number who are directly or indirectly involved with anthropology (Berliner, Boyer, Dennett, Laidlaw, and many more) directly and honestly address human evolution and the origins of religion, and that others (Ingold, Lindholm, Sidky, and many more) do openly advocate for applying the strengths of a science-like approach in social anthropology, in contrast to an ever-softening postmodern indefinite uncertainty which indirectly encourages all manner of ‘alternative fact’ in today’s society. But we also know that too many ethnographies on religious groups are so carefully written exploring and explaining, “through the eyes” of the subject group, that when the many members of said groups get the book and read about themselves, they never see their religion in the context of the myriad others past and present, and never hear human evolution and an academic, evidence-based, understanding of the origins of religion explained, and therefore only feel affirmed and all the more certain of being ‘right’. These group members, and some members of the broader public, may not yet (or ever) see these suggested at-least-postscript explanations of religion as plausible, but <em>we need </em>introductions to and then<em> </em>reminders that what reveals ideas as more connected, or less connected, to realities… is the verifiable evidence, not the intensity of conviction. We need reminders that in democracies — where voters hire the crews that run the ships of state, citizens having ‘mindsets’ that are <em>not</em> set on pre-formed claims-based beliefs, and are, rather, open to change, to verifiable evidence — this honesty about the need to overcome our tendencies to believe what we happen to like and to dismiss the rest, is vital. (Two prime examples of beautifully written and empathetic ethnographies which miss the opportunity and responsibility of providing perhaps unwelcome but needed context of one religion among myriad others, and the development of humanity and of religion, are: Tanya Luhrmann’s <em>When God Talks Back</em> and Saba Mahmood’s <em>Politics of Piety</em>.)</p><p>Broad, deep, and evidence-based summaries of how we’ve gotten to where we are have been written. Yuval Harari’s <em>Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind</em> is among the most comprehensive. That for over 10 thousand years after the green revolution, largely leaving our hunter-gatherer ways, and the development and dominance of many varied religions, we changed and progressed relatively little <em>until</em> the key steps of the Scientific Revolution followed by the Enlightenment has become increasingly clear. It was then that advances in our understanding of life and the universe, our concepts of the universality of human rights, and so many measures of our quality of life, took off and grew at ever-increasing rates. Another fascinating read focused on this particular aspect of change is Stephen Greenblatt’s <em>The Swerve: How the World Became Modern.</em></p><p>A couple final clarifications: This is not a call for atheism to be a litmus test in the social sciences, including anthropology. Anthropologists know that informative ethnographies have been written, useful theories advanced, aspects of power, injustice, politics, and economics revealed, and new perspectives on social stability, and change, relationships, and space shared, by believers (Evans-Pritchard, Douglas, the Turners, and more), but I would suggest that <em>in our current world circumstances</em>, greater honesty is called for in the writing, in the contextualizing and explaining of religious traditions. And I will add the caution that an anthropologist who is a believer today bears an extra obligation to publicly explain to their readers how they self-monitor so as to limit the risks that have gone with faith, which can cloud and limit urgently needed problem-solving, and confuse what could and should be sound public/collective policy decisions.</p><p>I hope we, especially social anthropologists, can appropriately handle the tempting sidetrack of disagreements on the particulars of any single example of telling the stories of the rise of humanity and then of religion. This sidetrack could cause us to forget that it is vital that we honestly recognize and face psychological factors which get in the way of us realistically addressing urgent issues like climate change, factors which also contribute to confusion when considering the profound difference between consensus on the most plausible explanation of evidence, as compared to collections of alternative facts, recent conspiracy theories, and sincerely held beliefs — Lindholm’s warned-of mingling of “fact and fantasy.” (<em>Logical and Moral Dilemmas of Postmodernism</em>; Author: Charles Lindholm; Source: The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, Vol. 3, №4 (Dec., 1997), pp. 747–760.)</p><p>If you are persuaded that the social/civilizational risks and challenges associated with climate change are great and are urgent, and if you are persuaded that in order to collectively be good problem-solvers on a global scale, we need to reduce the level of habituation to believing what we want and expecting that to go unchallenged, thereby remaining of unchanged mind on multiple issues, then I hope you might also find yourself persuaded that we, as individual concerned citizens and/or as social scientists, must engage in open discussion with our fellow-citizens, of the avoidable but serious risks that have tended to go with strong faith.</p><p>We are often enough reminded of the difficulties of speaking truth to power. I submit that we need to give more thought to the challenges of speaking truth to the masses. I’m not speaking here of those hanging on by their economic fingernails; they can be forgiven for their necessary preoccupation, and helped toward less precarity. I am speaking of the many who are concerned but too often confused; who work at being informed, but are slowed and distracted by not having a fairly reliable way to evaluate information for accuracy; who intend to and often do vote; who sometimes do question things; who participate in types of public dialogue, whether simply with family and co-workers, reading (or writing) op-eds and blogs; and who participate in other social media where ideas, for better or for worse, can do their viral thing. In would-be democracies, this matters. Vital messages are not necessarily popular. To social scientists: Please, more frequently take advantage of anthropology’s solid position for helping broad society better understand how we’ve gotten to where we are by writing with a public audience in mind, far beyond a collection of other ivory towers. This is not about ending ivory tower dialogue; it’s about helping some of the understandings developed there reach everyday concerned and involved citizens, and make a difference. I hope most reading here might find yourselves persuaded to openly and unapologetically advocate for our <em>best</em> tool for finding relative and probable truth — this science-like approach, and persuaded that a more honest and frequent (even if for some, unwelcome) reminding of the human story — including at least a postscript explanation of religion — is needed, and would be constructive.</p><p>*Calculated using land area minus National Parks &amp; Forests, divided by # of families. Families derived from population divided 8 individuals/family; based on 1940 population of 1.5 million; family size of 8 from initial 10 because of fertility rate=8.2, and child mortality rate about 250/1000 births; 1990 population of 7.1 million; family size of 8 from initial 9 because of fertility rate=7.2, and child mortality rate of 150/1000 births.</p><p><a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?locations=RW-ID">https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.TFRT.IN?locations=RW-ID</a></p><p><a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?locations=RW">https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.MORT?locations=RW</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46ad54a65a30" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Behind our Polarized Society:]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/behind-our-polarized-society-bfeaad175690?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bfeaad175690</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[who-do-we-trust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-polarization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[skepticism-applied]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[beyond-political-clan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[why-do-we-trust-some-more]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Jan 2022 04:12:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-06T02:57:28.746Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Figuring out Why We Trust Who We Trust Most.</p><p>One of the most impactful personal decisions people today make, most make at a gut/instinctual level, without deliberate thoughtful consideration. That decision is this: What group of people do we trust the most? To be clear, we can hope that most don’t completely and blindly trust any group, but we do trust some people-groups very significantly more than we trust others. The question is: Which group do we trust the <em>most, </em>and more so<em>, why</em>?</p><p>While you reflect on this in your case, you might separate what you think you <em>should</em> <em>be</em> doing from what you think you <em>have been</em> doing.</p><p>Before delving directly into this, let us consider a very related thought. Danish philosopher Soren Kierkegaard made this observation: “There are two ways to be fooled. One is to believe what isn’t true. The other is to refuse to accept what is true.”</p><p>People around the globe and across the ideological spectrum can agree that this is clearly the case. To help us in our exploration, we need to ask a question that comes up after this observation. The question is this: What has history shown to be our best “tool” for figuring out what IS true?</p><p>I’ve asked this of individuals and groups here in the US, and in the Middle East, and in Europe. In a good number of instances, I’ve heard people initially claim that the best tool for figuring out what is true is <em>their</em> holy book… sometimes the Bible, sometimes the Quran, sometimes still other books. After noting that “others” around the world make different <em>claims </em>than they do, and that conflicting sincerely held claims/beliefs are just that, and really get us nowhere, we took a look at history since the Scientific Revolution.</p><p>What was new then was that up until then, what we “knew” (or thought we did) was handed down from authority (Aristotle; the Church; etc.). What changed then was the realization and spread of the idea that it was not only <em>okay</em> to question things, it was positively good. Further, that this questioning must include our own assumptions, and even cherished beliefs; and that we must devise the most honest/objective ways we can to gather verifiable evidence to answer our questions; and lastly, that we must be honest with ourself and others by being willing to face this verified evidence, and to impose it on our beliefs/claims, resisting the temptation to attempt to impose our beliefs on the evidence (by selecting only what we like, or denying, or ignoring what we don’t like).</p><p>It is worth noting that all the progress since then has depended on people applying this science-like approach both inside science, <em>and </em>beyond it. In the social sciences we asked: Are Kings really endowed with some divine right, and can they indeed do with any commoner as they please? Are women really 2nd class citizens who belong in the kitchen, and who don’t need independent voices in democracy? Are races intrinsically unequal, making things like slavery, apartheid, and legal discrimination justified?</p><p>Coming back to our initial impactful decision, and question with it, on what people-group we trust the <em>most</em>…</p><p>In the many cultures I’ve lived in, the answers are frequently quite similar. Some have said they most trust their religious group and its authorities, including their group’s interpretation of their book. Some have said their extended family. Some have said the very wealthy, saying they must be both smart and ‘favored by God.’ Some refer to political party, a new extended family.</p><p>What do you think? …. Might I suggest that we ask about the broad effects if large portions of populations, perhaps whole countries, trusted any people-group which doesn’t have an established system demanding and ensuring a willingness to take an evidence-based as opposed to the above claims-based approach. If a group has a track record of being willing to honestly face evidence, to update, to drop a now-refuted old claim, and develop a new and improved understanding based on the best and clearest evidence, that group certainly seems to have earned my trust <em>more than</em> others who live for generations in intransigent denial of evidence in order to prop up their preferred status quo.</p><p>This not to say that this science-like approach is perfect, not at all. It is simply the <em>best</em> tool we have. In the messy process of developing a consensus on any particular, there are conflicting ideas, with conflicting and strong personalities behind them. The struggle before consensus has been reached can last years or decades, or long ago, even centuries; it is most important to note that when the dust has settled for the most part, it was not and is not the majority at any moment in time that matters, nor the loudest voices, but the preponderance of the most clear verified evidence that determines where consensus will develop.</p><p>When I look at all the directly conflicting varied religious groups whose assertions are all claims, and who so often contradict each other, and who choose to continually attempt to impose their various claims on the evidence, and insist on centuries of refusing to update, to change, to face good evidence, I can’t find a way to convince myself that they as a broad group of different faith-based subgroups, or one single group within it, has earned my trust as our best tool for figuring out what is true. Any race is also clearly not a standout as having a track record of having the best record of figuring out what is true. Any immediate or extended family group works as trustworthy… while one is a child. I doubt though, that anyone could make a coherent argument for extended family having a track record for being anyone’s best tool for figuring out what is true on into adult life. And of course now we have the modern conglomerate hybrid of extended family and religion: political party. There is plenty of demand here for allegiance, for trust, but before choosing blind trust, let’s continue to explore.</p><p>Coming back to science as a way of approaching things — It’s about asking questions… even painfully honest ones. To those who are reflexively critical and dismissive of science and scientists, and apparently all types of expertise, I honestly ask what you propose as a group which has a better track record on being self-correcting? Science fixes its misunderstandings. Sometimes in months; sometimes in decades. Doesn’t that beat <em>not</em> fixing them, and sticking with your old poor understandings? A scientist with a really strong personality, and who once had the best explanation of the best evidence, will get left in the dustbin of history if he/she won’t acknowledge and face newer and better evidence which indicates that his/her old explanation needs major modification. If he/she chooses to be intransigent, the rest of the scientific community doesn’t go down that suicidal drain with him/her.</p><p>A few words reflecting on the opposite of Trust. Skepticism is a good thing if it doesn’t lead to cynically quitting… involvement or even caring. But unidirectional skepticism is simply bias. I would encourage everyone who must honestly face up to the reality of having been skeptical <em>primarily</em> of science, and <em>not</em> their extended family, <em>not</em> of the blogs they read, <em>not</em> of the echo chamber bouncing around the anecdotal stories of individual cases here and there, not of their party: How has your chosen network of trust shown a centuries-long track record of being self-correcting, and insisting with each other that verifiability, and actual verification, matters? This calls for, this deserves, your further thought. Go ahead and be <em>honestly</em> skeptical. Ask tough questions; ask them everywhere. But also be willing to explore, and deepen your understanding of, what a rough and tumble process the struggle to develop a consensus entails. The numbers of people around the world, the egos and mental horsepower involved, the competitive desire to show your ‘adversary’ up, make a broad and lasting conspiracy virtually undoable.</p><p>Let’s be practical <em>and</em> principled. We have big challenges. You may not like being in a proverbial global village, but whether it’s viruses or terrorism or cultural or political influence, the reality we’re living in is that many things don’t recognize borders. We share one ocean, one atmosphere, one planet. And we share challenges which will demand our cooperative efforts to address. Honesty in seeking good responses found in effective problem-solving will continue to make it necessary to use our best tool for figuring things out. To not be perfect does not make that tool drop out of being our <em>best</em> tool.</p><p>Can we reduce our temptation to shout out our group’s claims more loudly than the next group shouts out theirs? I believe we can. It’s going to take a basic combination of honesty, insight, and courage. The next generations deserve our best effort.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bfeaad175690" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bridging the Divide with Honesty Intact]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/bridging-the-divide-with-honesty-intact-c2031b5cee12?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c2031b5cee12</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Jan 2021 01:06:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-18T03:43:30.754Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Like most in America, I have friends on both sides of our current political divide. After a brief nod to our varied psychological differences, I want to explore how we might, with honesty intact, communicate better, and perhaps find something resembling constructive common ground. (I acknowledge that the QAnon and Capitol Building invasion supporters on the right, And the promoters of communism on the left, can’t be persuaded, but I hope that most of the rest, from those who still speak of a stolen election, to those who find that incomprehensible, can still be thoughtfully engaged.)</p><p>Our basic differences aren’t about good and evil; they’re just differences. Conservatives tend to prefer the status quo over change; tend to focus on perceived immediate risks over more vague long-term ones; tend to prefer black and white clarity over nuance; tend to be okay with what they might see as ‘necessary’ concentration of power, emphasize discipline and punishment over rehabilitation and accompanying training and education; tend to want tight and clearly drawn circles of ‘us’, with ‘them’ being suspected, rejected, and fought. Liberals tend to like and sometimes promote change, and feel limited by what they may see as unfair status quos; they tend to be more concerned with what they see as ‘big picture’ long-term risks, and not feel the same stresses with what others see as immediate risks; they acknowledge and like exploring gray areas, don’t like concentrations of power, and prefer rehabilitation and training over punishment; they tend to like less tightly drawn circles of ‘us’, and prefer to grow that circle to include ‘others’ in various ways.</p><p>It is safe to say that if all cavemen had been strongly conservative, if they had survived they’d still be living the exact status quos of their times; it is also safe to say that if cavemen had all been strongly liberal, they’d have probably not survived because of disregarding the potential dangers of some new food, place, practice, belief, or people. We kind of need each other.</p><p>(If you wish to explore some of the basic liberal-conservative leanings, one starting point is: <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/psychological-differences-between-conservatives-and-liberals-2018-2#research-also-suggests-shared-values-likely-matter-more-than-shared-politics-when-it-comes-to-who-we-vote-for-13)">https://www.businessinsider.com/psychological-differences-between-conservatives-and-liberals-2018-2#research-also-suggests-shared-values-likely-matter-more-than-shared-politics-when-it-comes-to-who-we-vote-for-13)</a></p><p>That being said, can we gain insight about our tendencies, let history teach us some valuable lessons, and bridge this gap with honesty and wisdom intact and in use?</p><p>The first difficult question that must be asked is how, for example, educated people who seem to think, come to what seems like instantaneous conclusions like: 1. The election was fraudulent, manipulated, stolen, and must be overturned somehow; and, 2. The election was monitored, carefully and fairly executed, and ‘the most secure’ in our history?</p><p>It is obvious that we humans, often subconsciously, come to <em>Trust</em> certain people or groups or principles, and distrust others. We must consciously explore this. This trust, while not completely blind, does tend to be strong, and is most often not even realized, nor thoughtfully explored.</p><p>Exploring this on a personal level can be confusing and frustrating in today’s world of information overload, especially so when so much of this information in social media And in supposed ‘News’ sources has clearly become polarized, biased, and clearly far too frequently includes straight-up lies. How do we identify lies, or truth?</p><p>If it’s not hopelessly obvious, This Matters.</p><p>When 99.9999% of us are not real experts in <em>any</em> field, we really ought to consciously assess where we place the shades of gray in our ‘trust’ world. There are common answers in practice: Family/extended family; Church group; Neighborhood affiliation; Racial group; Political party, and more.</p><p>If any one of us pictures slipping into the shoes of a different person, in a different family, faith, culture, country, neighborhood, race, or political party, we can quickly realize that we’d likely have a different ‘trust’ zone/group. If we think that most of these ‘other’ people don’t have a good trust group, hopefully we can also realize that they suspect the same of us, And that the lack of persuasiveness of our trust group is likely well-founded if it’s primarily based on one of those shallow groupings of people.</p><p>So, is there any different and <em>better</em> way of placing our greatest level of always-conditional (never completely blind) ‘Trust’? In exploring this, I want to look briefly at an observation by Danish philosopher Soren Kierkegaard: “There are two ways to be fooled. One is to believe what isn’t true. The other is to refuse to accept what is true.”</p><p>This is so obviously true that there can seem to be nothing to be gained in contemplating it. The significance emerges when we add this question: What has history shown to be humanity’s best tool for slowly but surely figuring out what IS true?</p><p>Various cultures/faiths have made the claim that their writings, ‘from’ their god, are the best source of what is true. We don’t even need to side-track into the weeds of interpretation; we can simply acknowledge that these various claims in different centuries and cultures, directly conflict in many ways, and don’t stand the test of scrutiny of verifiable evidence. That approach is, simply but clearly put, claims-based. And interestingly, that seems to be where our politics is right now. But just making claims about one’s perception of things does not make those claims true or trustworthy.</p><p>Does history offer us something better? Something that has stood the test of centuries? Something that stands up to scrutiny, that takes verifiable evidence as centrally vital?</p><p>Before the Scientific Revolution, our understandings of things were taught and learned based on assertion of authority, be it Aristotle, the medieval church, or other. What was new in this revolution was the very idea that questioning things was not only okay, it was good. At the same time we realized that questioning everything must include questioning our own assumptions/beliefs/claims, and that in seeking to answer these questions, we must gather the most objective evidence we can, let and encourage others to refute or verify it, and then respect the evidence (whether we initially like it or not) in reaching our always-temporary conclusions. This implied a willingness to change our minds, to recognize when a previous cherished claim turned out to not be well supported.</p><p>This science-like approach, applied to Everything, has been humaniy’s best tool for figuring out what IS true. Note that no-one claims that science is perfect; it isn’t. It’s simply the best we have, in very significant part because it has a track record of being self-correcting. When a new idea is promoted because it better explains the then-known evidence, that idea itself is later significantly modified or even tossed out when further verifiable evidence show that it must be. No other human endeavor has this track record.</p><p>Note further that this applies beyond the hard sciences; it applies to the social sciences and more. We extended this revolution into the Enlightenment, and questioned and then re-evaluated a multifaceted series of things: whether Kings indeed had some ‘divine right’ to rule; whether women should indeed not vote or get educated or have professional careers; whether slavery and racism were fine and good; whether child labor was ethical; whether monopolies were good; whether industry’s cheapest route to rid themselves of waste and pollution were simply their right; etc., etc.</p><p>To point out what might be missed even if to others it is obvious, central here is the idea of verifiable evidence, of facts, <em>real</em> facts. Any and all of us Should be able to recognize that when we resort to ‘alternative facts,’ we’ve begun to fool ourselves, and to attempt to fool others. A bit of personal honesty here should help us recognize that <em>expecting others to take us seriously</em> when we resort to claims, to alternative (not verified or verifiable) ‘facts’, is a real stretch. The vast majority of readers here don’t think the world is supported on the back of a turtle, that it is flat, that the continents don’t move, or that the sun goes around us. If we enjoy the technological products that make our lives easy and long, shouldn’t we respect the process of science, of respecting and demanding verifiable evidence, that has made this possible?</p><p>I accept that as a person who is left of center, I have a responsibility to challenge those who would promote communism, and I have and do. I would ask those who think of themselves as right of center, but not in QAnon or involved in advocating for your flavor of fascism, shouldn’t you be involved in calling out the nonsense common in denying the good of vaccines, in promoting chem-trails as real, in denying climate change, and in denying what the intelligence agencies and courts have verified as a secure election. Perpetuating theories which lack verifiable evidence simply adds more mud to the water when so many around us are already frustrated and confused.</p><p>Ask yourself: Is confusion your goal? What does that in itself say? As the documentary “Merchants of Doubt” lays out clearly, the tobacco industry spent decades (and many, many millions of dollars) simply spinning doubt, that we really didn’t <em>Know</em> if tobacco itself was addictive or harmful.</p><p>I submit that we can and should <em>be</em> better than that. We will still have political debates which necessitate compromise. Things like justifiable and efficacious tax rates, the best size for government, current circumstances considered, can and should be vigorously and productively debated, but these debates shouldn’t include contrived and evidence-defying lies.</p><p>We have recently downgraded facts, evidence, the very process of science, the very concept of truth, and the value of hard-fought consensus among those best-informed on many subtopics. These things matter. If we slide back into the pre-scientific era, we do so at our own peril, and worse, we place those severe risks on future generations who deserve better.</p><p>Having made a living in construction, commercial fishing, sales, research science, and management, besides a good number of years in science education, and then recently adding a very different 2nd MA in anthropology, I am a reasonably deeply and very broadly informed citizen… but I am <em>far</em> from being an expert in <em>any</em> field. I thoughtfully defer to experts in virtually every field. I simply don’t know better than they do. Because there are strong disagreements even among these experts, I can’t and don’t agree with them all. A tool I use is to check for multi-decade-long shifts in the consensus among the experts. Current debates are typically on the frontiers of our learning, our understandings. But a few decades of debate usually yield a consensus. I suggest that if I am going to disagree with a newly developed consensus which took decades to develop, I ought to have some very good and deeply understood reasons, with solid evidence, for doing so. I simply should <em>not</em> cherry pick my favorite ‘expert’ (or Representative/Senator) primarily because I like that he or she happens to be on my side of the argument, regardless of where the consensus has developed. At the bottom line, who am I to dismiss a painstakingly-arrived-at consensus?!</p><p>Again, this applies beyond the hard sciences. What kind of sense, and what contribution to informed debate and peacefully arrived at agreement, does it make for me — a common citizen — to dismiss a multitude of Judges (appointed by the whole spectrum of administrations) and Secretaries of State (from both parties) who have looked into and heard out the background details of the election, and determined through multiple means that it was secure and fair… but I don’t like their conclusion, so I insist that “I” know better?</p><p>Investigating evidence and grounds for changed consensus is indeed more complex than simply doubling down on any of ‘our’ trust-groups, but it is so much more honest, and has real potential for progress, and not simply the stalemate of a never-ending fight… and it is not impossible!</p><p>My friends, let us not flush evidence, process, actual facts, the best verified truths we can honestly determine, and the stability of our democracy, all down the drain. We don’t have a better place to hang our hats.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c2031b5cee12" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Social Anthropology dissertation on the Religion-exiting Experience:]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/a-social-anthropology-dissertation-on-the-religion-exiting-experience-4b41cb901403?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4b41cb901403</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[exiting-religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anthropology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[re-evaluating-faith]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Jan 2021 06:55:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-12T06:55:38.586Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Personal Journeys of Exploration Beyond Early Learned Faith Subcultures</em></strong></p><p><strong>Introduction:</strong></p><p>Politics and religion are reputedly the two topics most advisedly left untouched at an extended family Christmas dinner. They certainly are personal, and often fraught with an intensity of emotion, making that advice perhaps sage. That being said, academic exploration of topics as forbidden from normal conversation as child abuse is constructively undertaken, and can yield insights which may well guide deepened understanding of human nature, history, and future policies in democracies claiming “the social contract.”</p><p>To clarify the title of this study, I have not focused here on people exploring beyond the faith of their upbringing and then confirming and returning to it; I focused on people leaving the faith of their upbringing, whether becoming agnostic, atheist, or switching to a fairly different faith (with the significance of difference being largely left to the perception of the respondent).</p><p>In the very recent book, “Handbook on Leaving Religion,” (2019; Enstedt, Larsson, and Mantsinen; p. 3) the authors note that academic study in this area has not yet settled on any broadly accepted definition of ‘what “leaving” entails’, and that “the study of leaving religion” could be seen as a “neglected topic.” As we will see though, that has started to change, and this study is an attempt to modestly contribute to that change.</p><p>It is understandable that this has begun to change. Gerhard Lenski’s 1961 prediction that “religion in the modern world is merely a survival from man’s primitive past, and doomed to disappear” (1961; Lenski; p. 3), coupled with Peter Berger specifying in 1968 that what remains of religion in the twenty-first century would amount to it being “likely to be found only in small sects, huddled together to resist a worldwide secular culture” (1968; Berger) have by now become infamous. Obviously that has not become our current reality, as religion is showing no signs of erosion in the developing world; however, recent changes in the west are noteworthy. Summarizing changes from just 2007 to 2015, Michael Shermer points out that in 2007 16% of Americans claimed no religious affiliation, but by 2015 that figure was up to 23%, with about 35% for those born since 1980. (2018; Shermer) After noting that these non-affiliateds can include ‘spiritual but not religious’ like new-agers, he goes on to share some informed speculation from University of Kentucky psychologists Gervais and Naile who point out that there could well be many more atheists than the polls have shown because “social pressures favoring religiosity, coupled with stigma against religious disbelief…, might cause people who privately disbelieve in God to nonetheless self-present as believers, even in anonymous questionnaires.” This is not to pretend that growth in the secular community is the only growth, as there has been growth among evangelicals or other specific small groups too, but that is not the focus of this research.</p><p>The US is not the only place in stages of multifaceted change. In the chapter focused on people leaving Catholicism in “Handbook on Leaving Religion,” Turpin focused on Ireland. He points out that “…self-identification as nonreligious is rising (growing from 269,800 to 468,400 people between 2011 and 2016, a relative increase of 73.6 percent,…).” He adds to this by noting that in the leadup to that brief time-period, religious ‘practice’ measured by weekly mass attendance had already declined from “85 percent in 1980 to 35 percent in 2012.” (2019; Turpin; p. 187)</p><p>Yes, globally speaking, the 1960’s predictions of religion’s demise have not come about, and no-doubt never will, but understanding what’s behind the growth of the non-religious in the west is a real need. They’re coming from somewhere… from within religion. Any group this large and more actively growing now than 40 years ago, whose process of evolution or becoming has been a neglected topic, calls for study.</p><p>To this general need I would add this: atheists have frequently been viewed in negative lights such as not trustworthy, a key factor discussed by Will Gervais (2011; Gervais) in noting that in 2008, 84% of American said that they were not ready to accept an atheist President, while majorities said they were ready to accept a black, a woman, a Jew, a Hispanic, or a Mormon. Further, those leaving a religion are often, we could say understandably, viewed negatively by those they left. Thus it is clear that if a degree of cohesion and general confidence/trust is a constructive factor and worthwhile goal in a democracy, that there is a need to increase an understanding of these atheists and leavers so as to decrease, to the degree possible, the fear and misunderstanding of these. It is important here to distinguish between ‘better understanding’ in contrast to ‘promotion.’ The former is a standard goal in social anthropology, the latter clearly not.</p><p>The goal then of this research was to explore the reasons for, experiences during, and perceived results of, the faith-exiting personal lived-narratives of a small variety of people from a variety of faith backgrounds. Because this study is exploratory, the central question is rather broad: What are some of the key factors which prompt exiting, how does that experience transpire, and how do the long-term results play out?</p><p>Questions of Belief- some theoretical considerations</p><p>General</p><p>In the title I have used the short phrase ‘faith subculture.’ Since that is perhaps not in common use, for simplicity and clarity let me state that what I refer to there is any given religion. The use of the term religion in anthropology has seen a winding path.</p><p>Berliner and Sarro (2007; p. 4) summarize part of this by noting that the early anthropologist Edward Tylor defined religion <em>as</em> “belief in supernatural spiritual beings.” They point out that before long Geertz revised that to ““a system of symbols through which people constructed a meaningful world,” pointing out that <em>belief</em> is not included. They add that later Talal Asad, William Arnal, and several others dismissed defining religion as “futile,” and that it “should be given up.” They point to the pinnacle of this rationale being that for some, religion (including this form of belief) does not exist as a <em>thing</em> to study.</p><p>They clarify though that we simply <em>can’t</em> assert that “…whatever it is that we… call ‘religion’ (be it their inner convictions or social institutions) is something that just came ‘out of the blue.” They point to people living in society, experiencing socialization there, and that religion is “sometimes” included. (Berliner and Sarro, 2007; p. 5)</p><p>Because among my respondents the role of ‘belief’ as a factor in their experience varied, I want to here briefly address the belief aspect of religion. As warned about by many anthropologists, western academic anthropology was significantly influenced by Christianity, which in general viewed belief as quite central to religion. Rodney Needham (1972; p. 152) argues that belief is not a universal feature of religion, but only “…the arbitrary product of an intricate and unique historical tradition.” He clarifies that belief is applicable, accurately, only to western religions (Greek, Jewish, Christian). “The crucial mistake has been the uncritical acceptance of a traditional Western definition of a mental state called belief.” (Needham, 1983; p. 41) Even inside Christianity, the idea of belief became more significant <em>after</em> the Reformation. (2013; Dein)</p><p>In summary here, I will simply suggest that it seems reasonable that even in Geertz’s constructing of meaning, <em>inside</em> this ‘constructed’ meaning — once put in descriptive words — would be found some beliefs. But this case need not be belabored. In a summary which I find very accurate, appropriate, and applicable to my analysis of my respondents’ stories, Kaufman’s early crystallization seems balanced and insightful: “In religion<em>, practice, feeling, and belief</em> are intertwined, and every definition that would see the essence of religion in just one of these three facets is too partial.” (Kaufman, 1961) (my emphasis)</p><p>I feel compelled to note here that the field of anthropology broadly has at times proposed explanations to the very rise, evolution and existence of religion, and at other times backed completely away from even the effort toward such. A discussion of this would be interesting and potentially lengthy, and there is much that I would recommend an interested person read, from Frazer’s 1890 publication of “The Golden Bough” to Boyer’s 2001 “Religion Explained,” but much more significant than the controversial nature of considering the evolution of or an explanation of religion per se, an exploration of the <em>exit experience</em> of different individuals from different religions does not require an exploration of theoretical proposals on its origin broadly, or any attempts at consensus on such; a discussion of such here might only serve to cloud an understanding of these experiences.</p><p>A Note on the “Native Anthropologist”</p><p>Before dealing with any of the details from the literature on this, I must disclose to any reader that the reason I bring this up as relevant is that in this instance I am acting in the role of the proverbial <em>native</em> anthropologist. That is to say, I am a leaver; in my late 30s I left the faith of the Seventh-day Adventist church, a protestant denomination, in which I was raised as a missionary kid, educated in until graduate school when I was in my mid 20s, and for which I worked for nearly a decade. Thus, as I study the exit experiences of various others, I too have had my own exit experience and after-life.</p><p>Kirin Narayan (1993; Narayan) leads her readers on a delightfully convoluted exploration of many nuances of the native anthropology experience, positionality, and perspective from which I summarize here several factors. She notes that the ‘native — non-native’ distinction should not be considered fixed; the anthropologist has constantly shifting identifications. She also points out that a single aspect of positionality, in the case of her analysis it being culture, is only one of many — there also being education, age, gender, sexual orientation, class, race, etc., in my case the exit experience.</p><p>Narayan also gives the very practical and wise advice that what matters is not so much the commonality <em>or</em> the differences, but the quality of the relations, the communication. One might be an insider in some way and an outsider in many others, as is certainly the case with me and my respondents, but the question is, do you become a trustworthy person in the eyes of the people sharing their perspectives, their life experiences and values, from their heart? In my case this has been possible in a good number of cases where we have known each other quite well for considerable time, but, as I will discuss in my section on methods, with those whose relationship with me is recent and focused on this research, with <em>some</em> the back and forth has been in depth, with openness and trust increasing, but with others I simply accepted the story as told, necessarily limiting the back and forth to fewer respondents.</p><p>Lanita Jacobs-Huey adds some important specifics to this issue of native anthropology. She put some emphasis on honestly facing the issue of positionality in consciously noticing whether one’s presence and perceived position may <em>influence</em> those being studied, and seeking to limit that possibility. She also spoke of the danger of having an axe to grind, and of being perceived to have such. (2008; Jacobs-Huey) To me, a primary illustration of this in my position is that while I attempt to better understand the perspectives and experiences of leavers through their eyes, and to share that understanding, that I am not then going on to mingle that with justifying and advocating these positions.</p><p>The Exit Experience</p><p>As I alluded to in the preamble, the exit experience could be considered a neglected topic, but that is changing. I noted there a very recent work that is a substantive part of that change: Brill’s “Handbook on Leaving Religion,” edited by Daniel Enstedt, Goran Larsson, and Teemu Mantsinen, with over 25 contributing expert authors. (2019; Enstedt, Larsson, and Mantsinen) Before drawing on some important selected elements, I am briefly here providing for any interested reader a general description of what this work covers. After a general orientation to the field and overview to this point, this work is divided into three parts: Part 1. Historical and Major Debates, in which broad looks are taken of the exit phenomenon in the contexts of Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism, and in Antiquity; Part 2. Case Studies, in which many specific sometimes (though not always) ethnographic studies, from leaving Mormonism, to leaving the Amish, to the case of Queers leaving Islam, and many more, are shared; and Part 3. Theoretical and Methodological Approaches, in which the subfields of statistics, geography, historical approaches, and the subapplications of psychology, sociology, media, and autobiography are addressed as related to leaving.</p><p>In their Chapter 1 introduction to this business of leaving, these editors clarify that one way of viewing leaving is to use the term deconversion. They point out that conversion has been greatly studied, not so with deconversion, and that it is fundamentally different enough that it should not be considered simply a reverse process. (p. 3) This particular simple but profound point was made much earlier in a broad sense, not focused on religion, by Helen Ebaugh in “Becoming an Ex: The Process of Role Exit” with the neat summary that “role exit is not simply… role entry played in reverse. It is unique.” (1988; Ebaugh; p. 8)</p><p>A point that is touched on in the introduction to the Handbook is brought home in powerful terms a number of times later in the book. The point is this: Leaving involves more personally powerful factors than dogma — it involves “core identities,” forming “new selves,” (p. 203), “an overhaul of one’s previous conception of self, a re-creation of one’s way of being in the world,” can be a “crash,” a “pulverization of my fortress,” and because of this “it is rarely smooth.” (p. 164) The thoughts in this paragraph, and the all-encompassing aspects of one’s life potentially impacted shared briefly in the paragraph after next, have given me an almost frightening sense of being privileged to peer into what may be some of the more private and gut-wrenching corners of my respondents’ life experiences.</p><p>Several ways in which exit experiences can vary, and to which a researcher can usefully be attentive, include: one can compare the different facets of reasons, processes, and consequences (p. 2); if looking at reasons, they might varyingly be based in “intellectual doubt, moral criticism, emotional suffering, and disaffiliation from a community” (p. 2); and the experience might be manifest “early/ late, shallow/deep, and mild/transformative,” with any single case showing different combinations. (p. 3) I will point out here that my stated focus on “reasons for, experiences during, and perceived results of” closely align with these editors’ three terms: reasons, processes, and consequences.</p><p>Keeping in mind the potentially powerful nature of such a change in core identity , way of being in the world, the editors raise the reader’s attention to the range of factors which could well be impacted, from food, clothing, music, social network, family, politics, addictions, vocabulary and speech patterns, sexual orientation and behavior, status, to risks of exclusion, severed family relations, fear, guilt, notions of punishment, grief, or even hate crimes, and (fortunately relatively rarely) being killed. (p. 4–6, 69, 85, 93, 204)</p><p>Because I didn’t succeed in contacting someone who had left Judaism or Hinduism, I am here going to draw some from their chapter on leaving Orthodox Judaism, and from an essay by Hari Sri in New Humanist. And finally here amidst this connection with the literature, particularly because the two ex-Muslim respondents I was planning on receiving stories from have either suffered intervening circumstances or may have changed their minds, I will draw significantly from another recent substantive work in the field of leaving: Simon Cottee’s “The Apostates: When Muslims Leave Islam.”</p><p>I earlier pointed out that deconversion cannot simply be viewed as an exact reverse of conversion. The author of the chapter on leaving Orthodox Judaism, David Belfon, explains that one key difference in nature is that those deconverting are not given “readily available scripts” with which to <em>tell</em> their story (and I would suggest, first <em>understand</em> it), as those incoming converts regularly are. (p. 144) Thus there can be much greater confusion and sense of disorientation, of not having <em>any</em> community to which one feels they belong. Although this observation is made in the context of Judaism, from my other reading, I would contend that this can be reasonably generalized more broadly.</p><p>It is interesting to ponder the possible broader applicability of another observation developed by Belfon in studying leaving Judaism. He suggests that many respondents had “a similar trajectory of dissatisfaction, questioning, investigating alternatives, surreptitious leavetaking, outing themselves or being outed, and new identification as different.” (p. 148) Although I don’t find a nearly identical list among other writers, I do find elements of this description showing up in many varied ways. It is my observation in both my reading and my life experience living in, not simply visiting, seven countries beyond the US and Canada, that <em>exposure </em>to alternatives (only then is <em>investigation</em> at all likely) is one of those almost ‘necessary but not sufficient’ factors for this type of change.</p><p>A perhaps noteworthy difference brought out by Belfon in the case of leaving Orthodox Judaism is that <em>returning</em> in degrees to variants of Judaism seemed relatively commonplace. (p. 149) This may well be at least partially understood as possibly coming from the fact that being a Jew is both a religious descriptor <em>and</em> an ethnic descriptor, discussed in Part 1’s (Historical and Major Debates; not Part 2’s Case Studies) chapter on Judaism. (p. 55) The identity component significantly remaining intact because of ethnicity then, the belief component seems to have more flexibility for renegotiated fit with one’s life, making a degree of ‘return’ more likely.</p><p>The essay connected to leaving Hinduism, by Hari Sri, is titled “Why I am not Hindu.” The focus in this New Humanist publication is more on reasons than experience, with nothing on results. Hari expressed objection to “the pressure to fulfil a predetermined role in society,” the presence still of “violence and chauvinism,” and most intensely to Hinduism being “intrinsically misogynistic.” This conclusion seemed to be drawn primarily from realizing that under even updated Hindu expectations, his mom couldn’t attend his dad’s funeral when he dies because women are “too mentally fragile, thus incapable of being able to withstand loss.” (2014; Sri) He made no pretences of these reasons forming an exhaustive list, or being broadly applicable; they were <em>his</em> reasons.</p><p>In Simon Cottee’s “The Apostates: When Muslims Leave Islam,” he puts his focus in simple and clear terms: “… the central concern of this book is to explore the social situation of ordinary non-activist ex-Muslims,” not focusing on the expressed opinions of famous or politically active ones. Based on his extensive interviews with 35 ex-Muslims living in Britain and Canada, he explores “what it means to renounce religion in toto and to live a life beyond religious belief and practice,” and adds, “This subject remains neglected in the social sciences.” (2015; Cottee; p. 9) In honest anthropological fashion he states that he does not see apostasy from Islam as either “a moral problem in need of correction…” or as “a moral achievement.” (p. 10)</p><p>Cottee identifies the “core issues” in his ex-Muslims’ internal deliberations as being both belief — “what is true?” and identity — “who am I?” (p. 54) In exploring what he called “pathways to” doubt holistically (not exclusively focused on belief), he summarized these five routes: personal experience; exposure to alternatives; scriptural discoveries; spiritual alienation; and political events. (p. 35)</p><p>A theme that shows up many times in his interviews with his respondents is the depth of personal angst in process and in result. For example, some respondents left “internally,” but in terms of public appearances remained hidden in the closet. The degrees of openness-closetedness varied completely, from everyone knowing, to no one knowing, obviously with many increments along the way. Speaking of this closet, his summary is that:</p><p>“It is endured because it is supposed to preserve and protect relationships with family members and friends. But because of all the deceit required to sustain it, and the emotional distance this creates, it ends up imperiling these, as well as fueling resentment and distrust between loved ones.” (p. 153)</p><p>The highly variable mixed bag of results is illustrated by these words from one respondent: “In the end I really did miss belonging to something.” He went on to describe the struggle to sort out and hang on to elements of culture which aren’t directly religious. (p. 155) The sense of loss and the perceived threat of further loss were palpable in the conversations of many. Still, although some leavers went back in, it was temporary, and they left again, seemingly with greater certainty and finality. Whatever the price was in each case, it appears that it was worth paying in order to not pretend, at least to one’s self, to believe and practice with sincerity that which is no longer part of one’s beliefs and identity. It struck me that along with perhaps a few other faiths, the combination of price actually paid and risk of higher potential further price is among the highest in the case of leaving Islam. One can objectively argue, and we in anthropology <em>should</em> argue, that whatever might be right or wrong about any faith or all faiths, that the modern recognized right to believe according to one’s own conscience, and thus to change faith, including leaving any such, ought to exist in principle and in reality, without threat of any kind.</p><p>Before moving on to my methods and the personal stories of my respondents, I want to draw on several ideas from one more very recent book, Alec Ryrie’s “Unbelievers: An Emotional History of Doubt.” (2019; Ryrie) As can be suspected from the title, the ideas I wish to share here connect not so much with the leaver’s processes/experience, or consequences/results, but with reasons, things related to doubt.</p><p>Ryrie argues that while many vaguely attribute the rise of doubt (of faith) to leading figures of the Scientific Revolution and then the Enlightenment, that there are many records showing that doubt was not only common in cities like Paris, but that in the 1590s it was said that “there is no sect now in England so scattered as Atheism”, and that clear back in 1305 a Florence preacher warned that “the question ‘how can it be that God exists?’ was being ‘put by madmen every day.’” (p. 3) Ryrie summarized his point here this way: “Intellectuals and philosophers may think they make the weather, but they are more often driven by it.” (p. 4) I would argue that modern history as illustrated by US Supreme Court rulings from ending segregation to allowing gay marriage further strengthen this point.</p><p>Ryrie spends considerable time making the case of doubt being not simply intellectual, but emotional, an “unbelief of anxiety,” someone “so paralyzed by the possibility of being wrong that he will never settle on anything as right.” (p. 107) But a good number of times he touches on things more of the head than of the heart. In discussing what he called “doubting piously” (Chapter 6; p. 173-) he mentions seekers who refused the comfort of easy answers, who, while continuing to live wrapped in good behavior, still asked deep questions.</p><p>In bringing this into relatively modern times, he notes that after WWII “It now seemed plain that cruelty, discrimination and murder were evil in a way that fornication, blasphemy and impiety were not.” (p. 202) These new ideas were the result of doubting old ideas.</p><p>He wraps up his exploration of doubt, relative primarily to Christian faith, with what seemed to me to be a surprisingly practical <em>and</em> principled way. He points out that believers hoping for a return to the past “…are deluding themselves. Indeed, they are in some danger of being tempted by authoritarian nationalist voices that want to unlearn the Second World War’s moral lessons.” He ends with “Our cultures’ moral frameworks have shifted before and they will do so again. Our beliefs will, inevitably, follow. Believers and unbelievers alike share an interest in where that story goes next.” (p. 206)</p><p>The Method Used Herein</p><p>This being an exploration of the variety of experiences in leaving faith, I have chosen to have respondents from some variety of different faith backgrounds, ages, and nationalities, both men and women. As mentioned earlier, my plans to include Judaism, Hinduism, and Islam did not work out.</p><p>So as to limit my potential influence on their thoughts and memories, I chose to give them a writing-prompt (see the appendix), and not interview them. In several instances, probing follow-up questions were able to help me gather further enriching background, explanation, and perspective. The more typical ethnographic technique to use in exploring this might have been the informal interview. As mentioned, I was concerned about my potential influence in an interview for two specific reasons: my position as a ‘native’ anthropologist, and the fact that the initial eight respondents whom I had in mind because I knew they were leavers (but didn’t know their details) were people with whom I was fairly well to quite well acquainted. That mutual knowledge, of them knowing that I too am an ex, combined with me asking questions live, and following up live, posed risks of me unintentionally directing the conversation.</p><p>A practical consideration was that in most cases an interview would have been by phone or skype/zoom, which I felt left me with the potential negative of my influence and <em>without</em> the positive of direct person-to-person conversation, facial expressions, body language, and human warmth included.</p><p>A writing prompt, after several iterations, encouraging honesty and depth, but deliberately cautioning on emotionally hazardous material (“…deal with those in levels of depth that work for you.”), would limit more concretely my influence, especially when we were mutual acquaintances.</p><p>One of the strengths or having respondents do autobiographical writing when touching on particularly sensitive topics, in the case of Andrew Gorman-Murray’s research (2007), stigmatised sexuality, and in this case leaving a faith, is that it “offers an unobtrusive means to explore…” A clear limitation is that not everyone has well-developed writing skills and comfort levels that make for expressing complex thoughts, emotions, and experiences. In the case of two respondents, they expressed a preference for not writing, and for interviewing instead, and I readily agreed. One of these worked out, and one quit responding when trying to schedule the interview.</p><p>Particularly in asking a few follow-up questions, I was drawing on myself having gone through this experience, thus in a sense acting the well-known anthropological positionality of participant observation.</p><p>In deference to depth over breadth, and on academic advice, I am focusing on discussing just three of the 13 responses. Of the three axes, early/ late, shallow/deep, and mild/transformative, mentioned in Handbook on Leaving Religion, I used shallow/deep and mild/transformative as my key criteria for selecting which three to focus discussion on, choosing the more deep and transformative relayed experiences. (In addition to my acknowledgments, I wish here to clearly thank <em>All</em> my respondents; any story not discussed here still broadened and deepened my understanding. I was limited by strict word-length rules; I genuinely appreciate your time, effort, and choice to participate. I thank you!)</p><p>I will add here that my participants also knew that, separate from my studies and my dissertation, I am also planning to later pull together and publish an anthology of exit experiences.</p><p>Religious backgrounds are listed in the appendix.</p><p>A table summarizing Type / Degree of Change is also there.</p><p><strong>The Three Cases told and discussed at length:</strong></p><p>Case A:</p><p>Amy grew up the child of missionaries, who themselves had grown up as missionary kids. Faith saturated her young years in happy ways, extending outward from her family to encompass other workers for and members of the Seventh-day Adventist church. A life-impacting event when she was four left her needing leg braces. In her words, these braces</p><p>“didn’t seem to slow me down any. My playmates and school mates in grade school and academy were kind and supportive.</p><p>The only fly in the ointment was that except for 3 instances during my 4 years (in the boarding high school), I didn’t have any dates. It hurt to be ‘an old maid’ with no dates or steady boyfriends like most of the other girls had. My only life dream was to be a missionary wife and since that didn’t look like much of a possibility, I resigned myself to the idea of being an ‘old maid’ with 15 cats!”</p><p>When finished with high school she returned to North America to study nursing, in Adventism one of what she calls the ‘sanctified’ professions. The social challenges associated with leg braces continued. Faith was a major way of dealing with this:</p><p>“During my teen years there was a prominent movement within the church teaching the ABC’s of Prayer — Ask, Believe, and Claim the Bible promises. I was born with an independent nature and a ‘can do’ happy nature which was fostered by my parents especially in the face of my handicap. I chose not to dwell on marriage because then if it didn’t happen, I would be all the more depressed. So only once during my college years did I let myself claim the ABCs of Prayer for a husband.</p><p>My world revolved around mission work, God and the Adventist church, which I believed to be the truest interpretation of the Bible.”</p><p>She then met and married a “tall, handsome, fun and talented” Adventist fellow nursing major who was also interested in missions. A match made in heaven…</p><p>“My survival as a person with a handicap had depended greatly on leaning on God to get me through. It was deeply tattooed in my brain that God loves people as a father and He never gives bad gifts. I considered it a direct answer to prayer that God had reached out his septre and deemed that I could be married. Adult mission field surrogate aunts and uncles even told me how they had been praying that I would find someone and what a miracle it was that God had given me such a wonderful husband.</p><p>I had followed church standards carefully and devoutly. Since I didn’t have boyfriends I had very little chance to hold hands or kiss as a teenager and I was a virgin on my wedding night. I had done as God wanted and saved myself for marriage.”</p><p>But the wedding night, and then three decades plus of marriage and ‘general’ love, never made her feel that she generated real physical passion in her husband.</p><p>“Because of my physical handicap I came to think that his lack of interest in sex was because I was not womanly, sensual or sexy enough. It was easier to suppress my own sexuality than to build anticipation and then suffer disappointment. … By the end of our marriage, I had suppressed my sexuality to the extent that when I stood naked in front of the mirror my mind fogged out my boobs and pubes as they do in news reports.</p><p>I felt depressed and trapped.”</p><p>Despite this, they had two sons. And then</p><p>“At age 21 our youngest son revealed he is gay. Then my husband told me how he had suspected all of our son’s life that he was gay. Surprising to me was my husband’s ability to accept our son’s gayness. He had been very critical of our son for his worldly music and his earrings. How could he accept him unconditionally when he revealed he was gay?”</p><p>Insights, new perspectives and understanding, came in fairly rapid-fire.</p><p>“I’ve always been close to my kids. When Alex came out he sat with me into the wee hours of the morning while we worked on a project. He talked of the fear that homosexuality carries. People threw things at him and his boyfriend as they walked down the street. People on bikes tried to run them over. Alex spoke of all the beautiful, fun, talented girls he had dated in high school. He was tall, handsome, musical, funny, interesting, intelligent and the life of the party, and basically could have dated anyone he wished. But, he said, “they were all soul sisters, Mom. I had no sexual feelings for any of them, but when a good-looking guy walks by on the street, the chemistry is there unbidden!” He talked of how he had known since grade school that he was attracted to boys and was able to name his crushes. He said, “There is no way that I would choose to be gay and put myself in this danger and hurt you and Dad the way that this hurts you. I didn’t choose this and can’t make it go away.”</p><p>Where some parents choose disowning, Amy chose reflecting, re-evaluating. She came to accept, and to <em>understand</em>, that this was not a choice.</p><p>One of the consequences was that in her rural conservative “rigid and unbending” church congregation, it was like living in Russia where you never know who’s hidden KGB. She briefly went into her own sort of closet of hiding.</p><p>“Within a few months I became a very strong advocate for lgbtqi individuals. I could identify with them on a deep level in 3 areas of emotions. 1) I had grown up as a Third Culture Kid, wanting to be accepted into the community of locals, but continuing to be different from them. … I was an amalgamation of 2 cultures and not fitting 100% in either one. 2) I had a physical handicap I hadn’t chosen and couldn’t change that strongly defined me, as a differing sexual orientation defines the lgbtqi community. I can feel their pain and desire to fit in 100%. 3) Because of my lack of dates and attentions from the boys in my expatriate community, I developed feelings for a local boy and he was attracted to me. Because our religious community viewed a mixed racial relationship or marriage as ‘being unequally yoked,” we had to hide our feelings for each other. I believed in that era and community a ‘mixed’ relationship would have ruined my 4 grandparents’, my aunt and uncle’s, and my parents’ missionary reputations. … So our attraction had to go underground and consisted of a silent attraction to each other; conjuring up benign situations where we could be together; secret looks; holding hands once secretly and him giving me a good-bye kiss on the cheek when I left for college.</p><p>But I was left with a feeling of deceit and dirtiness for something innocent and pure. I felt like a slut.”</p><p>Then the big kicker:</p><p>“Five years after our son came out and after 33 years of marriage, my husband Anthony revealed that he is gay and has known since he was a child. He learned in dormitory worship that he should marry a nice straight girl and all those homosexual feelings would go away. He married me in great anticipation but discovered that his homosexual feelings didn’t evaporate.</p><p>It hadn’t been about me! Nothing was wrong with my womanliness, femininity, sexuality and sensuality! I couldn’t believe what it had taken for him to be in the closet and pretend to be attracted to me. I knew that I could never pretend to be attracted to a woman and live in a lesbian relationship. I knew from the knowledge I’d gained from Alex’s journey that homosexuality wouldn’t be prayed or counseled away.</p><p>Through those first months after Anthony came out I was a deer in the headlights. I cried for months. Couldn’t sleep. Had to live in the closet myself for 9 months, telling only my kids and a couple of cousins. So I hid out in my house a lot. I couldn’t trust anyone with the news that Anthony was gay. I was sifting alone through the rubble of what had been my life like a Katrina (hurricane that hit New Orleans) survivor sifts through the wreckage for any small piece of their former life and identity. I now had to separate my life from my former identity as a wife, church pillar, leader, missionary and mentor. My journey with the church was tenuous after my son came out and it was completely finished when my husband came out.”</p><p>Re-evaluations led inevitably to new tentative conclusions, certainly initially driven primarily by emotion, but then by far more. Issues as deep as one’s very identity, role, and a sense of betrayal don’t make for easy processing.</p><p>“I was and still am very angry at Christianity and God. My sense of betrayal by God was overwhelming. I couldn’t hear references about God, religion, his fatherly love, his omniscience, omnipresence, omnipotence or any religious music without feeling that I was suffocating. I’ve never been raped, but I imagine my emotions were parallel to those of a rape victim when thrown back into the presence of the rapist again.</p><p>I trusted God, and He let me down. He couldn’t find any husband for me (a handicapped girl) besides a homosexual ‘fake’ husband. — to me the very definition of kicking someone when they are already down. If Christianity/SDA Biblical interpretation is so wrong about homosexuality, why would I have any trust for the rest of their Biblical interpretations such as women in ministry, the Sabbath, tithing, dress, diet and behavior?</p><p>Religion of any kind has become to me nothing but other people’s mental crutch and delusion. A way for rulers, leaders and powers to hold sway over the populace. The Bible to me now is a book of fables and fiction. Prayer now holds the same meaning to me as the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy. It is an exercise that one does to trick their mind into a sense of control and complacency — pie in the sky!</p><p>If God truly existed and was all loving and accepting why would one need to request thousands of people around the world in prayer chains to beg God to do something. Why would thousands of prayers have more power than my single prayer?</p><p>My belief system has evaporated. I’m not even sure there is a higher power. I do think there is energy in the universe. The best way I can describe myself is as an atheist. I’m repulsed by the con-tactics of religions and their proselytizing methods; by the way children are brainwashed into Christian perspectives and thought processes before they can even think for themselves.”</p><p>Early on, Amy had approached church leadership in search of support, understanding, and counsel; later she shifted to attempting to make recommendations to church leadership, having seen how they were hurting people. Sadly, the responses, and non-responses, revealed a lack of understanding, a refusal to change.</p><p>In looking back, looking at the now, and looking ahead, while she is honest, even with pain, fortunately Amy is not preoccupied with bitterness. While she had been conditioned to</p><p>“think that those who left the faith carried a heavy mantle of guilt. I’ve found in leaving the religious community that there is amazing freedom and peace. … No religion, or community of any kind will ever ‘own me’ again.</p><p>I’m now happily married to a heterosexual man the last 13 years and know what was stolen from me in my first ‘marriage’.”</p><p>But she does list her angers: her youth is gone, her only experience of true marriage is in her ‘old age’, and that she can’t share having and raising children with her true husband.</p><p>Among many constructive focuses in her life, Amy has dedicated considerable effort to getting religious leaders of all kinds to <em>not</em> counsel young homosexuals to go into hetero marriages in the hopes that that will ‘cure’ them.</p><p>Some who might experience such emotional jarring might simply double down on their traditions in an effort to stay oriented, but Amy moved on to re-evaluation of fundamental practices and beliefs.</p><p>In follow-up I asked Amy if she thinks she would eventually have questioned and re-evaluated so much from her past if she had not had such an emotionally jarring experience.</p><p>Her response gives anyone room to continue reflecting on issues like this. It “might have delayed my departure and kept it from being so abrupt, but not prevented it.” The complexities shown in Amy’s experience remind us that Kaufman’s “practice, feeling, and belief” are indeed very “intertwined.”</p><p>Case B:</p><p>Brady describes his deep roots and close-knit Mormon community with seeming pride, but with honesty too, giving some details on the restrictions, from entertainment, to friendships, to diet.</p><p>His first moment of some discomfort with his church occurred following a conversation he had with a non-Mormon junior high friend. Brady had asked why outsiders often viewed his church harshly, and his friend had replied that it was polygamy. Brady replied that that was the old days, and his friend challenged him with, “Homie, ask your parents. I guarantee it’s still happening.”</p><p>After his parents gave him an explanation for the old days, he replied,</p><p>“Ok, that makes sense. But why did he say it’s still happening?” My parents looked at each other, straining to come up with a satisfactory response. My father started, “Well son, it technically is still happening. In the temple, your mom and I were sealed, remember? If Mom were to die, I could, if the Lord willed it, be sealed to my new wife as well.” I was flabbergasted, “Mom would you do the same thing if Dad died?” My mom sighed, “No son, I am only sealed to your father.” I became a little frustrated; “How does any of that make sense? Why would Dad need a second woman? Wouldn’t that take away from the love you have for Mom? For ETERNITY???”. My parents denied that there would be love lost or diminished. It was at this moment that I first officially disagreed with the Mormon Church.”</p><p>On finishing high school, he had what he calls a “crisis in faith” when he had to choose between pursuing a career in atypical Mormon music and going on the expected Mormon mission. He chose the mission, and never looked back, but it wasn’t an easy road.</p><p>He had faced one “worthiness interview” before being baptized at eight, and now took his second and more intensive one. He remembers knowing that he was lying when affirming that he supported the church’s “spiritual polygamy” belief. His questioning was at least briefly acute during the peculiar and formal temple endowment ritual before being sent to one of the “missionary training centers” when he consciously questioned “…am I in a cult?”</p><p>After only five weeks in the training center he became progressively sicker, and after several levels of prayer and blessings failed, he was finally taken to a doctor and diagnosed with a rare fungal infection of the cerebrospinal fluid, and went home for treatment and recovery. With the seriousness with which the Mormon mission is viewed, this setback was unfortunately accompanied by lots of hurtful rumors within his church community.</p><p>After eight months of treatment and rest, he was well enough to go on his mission. Among what he otherwise described as an enjoyable experience, an unanticipated challenge arose from the fact that local politics in that state included an effort to pass a law against same sex marriage… and most people knew that the Mormon church was a chief sponsor of this effort. While some appreciated that political effort, many didn’t, and made sure that the young missionaries knew that.</p><p>Eight months into his mission, his csf fungal-induced fever returned, he was given an honorable discharge, and went home. Two side benefits to his mission were strengthening his Spanish language skills, and meeting another young Mormon who would later become his wife.</p><p>Although she was from a Mormon family too, she was somewhat a cultural outlier in that she felt fine not only having real thoughts and opinions on things, but also expressing those. Some members of his family, in more typical Mormon fashion, struggled with that.</p><p>College was next. Among the eye-opening experiences in college was simply getting to know a happily gay-married man who, instead of being “evil and disgusting” as he’d been “conditioned” to believe, was a very decent man who loved his husband like Brady loved his wife. Although he was still involved with formal responsibilities (Financial and Membership Clerk) in his local church, this contradiction led him to begin to “distance myself from the church.”</p><p>A very troubling discovery made in carrying out his church responsibilities was witnessing the level of financial micro-managing and privacy invasion done in providing any financial help to poorer members… all the while sending “shocking” sums to Salt Lake. “Realizing that the church had billions of dollars in real estate and other financial holding made me sick… My connection with the church continued to wane.”</p><p>He also studied more deeply into religions, including his own. He realized that Joseph Smith was a “dishonest child who became an adult conman.” He learned of plagiarism involved in the Book of Mormon, of church history “filled with lies, murders, massacres, and polygamy” which he found “appalling.” With these epiphanies, some walls of prohibition crumbled, and he tried alcohol… and liked it.</p><p>In this confusing time he admits to periods of depression because “Not only was I doubting the church, but I was losing my faith in God.” This expression says a lot: “I was all alone.” Extended family wouldn’t understand, and he felt he couldn’t even share honestly with his wife. He “suffered in silence for over a year.”</p><p>Perhaps wondering how alone he in fact was, he searched “atheist mormon” on Youtube. One of several that he watched was a talk by Richard Dawkins “speaking plainly about Joseph Smith.” Emotionally he says he “went from sadness to anger.”</p><p>Looking for a new sense of orientation, he took a Nietzschean philosophy class, joined a Freethinkers group, and attended a live talk given by Dawkins, with whom he was afterward able to have an extended personal conversation. Though still formally in the church, he began to post questions on Mormon history and doctrine on social media. Responses weren’t kind or accepting. Members on both sides of the family “were angrier than a kicked hornet’s nest.” Examples: “I am so ashamed to have you in our family”, “What is wrong with you? Are you a satanist”, “You should just leave the family if you are going to leave the church.”</p><p>The strained relations included that between his wife and him. He admits that “She got hit with the emotional shrapnel” because he was angry.</p><p>He finally resigned from his position at his church, and, perhaps looking for a sign of progress, stated that he would no longer be attending until the church changed its policy that children growing up with gay parents could not be baptized until they were 18 and had denounced their parents, ending their relationship.</p><p>He had managed to calm down enough to have had some non-intense conversations with his wife, and she had started to understand his “side of things.” His parents came for his graduation, and,</p><p>“Sitting on the back porch after my graduation, the mood took a turn. It went from light banter to annoyance, then frustration and then righteous indignation… “You are spitting in the face of your great grandparents”, “You are breaking up our family”, and the worst thing said was “You are spiritually abusing your wife and children by your actions”.</p><p>“I remember holding a glass cup of water. Then I saw red. The glass ended up shattered on the ground, supposedly I threw it down as I stood up. I remember shouting, “I am ashamed that you think so little of me. I am still the same son you raised. I love my wife and kids. If you honestly believe I am abusing my family spiritually, get the fuck out of my home and never come back. You are never welcome here again!” With that, I turned around and stormed into my house. I remember walking in to check on my toddler son napping in his crib. All of a sudden, I hear my wife shouting at my parents, defending me. She told them they should be ashamed of themselves, and that she has never felt spiritually abused. She then asked them to leave.”</p><p>Slowly though, anger changed to an ability to simply ignore “big Mormon events because they no longer mattered.” For two years things were uneventful, without his being formally disfellowshipped or him formally resigning his membership.</p><p>The last move in his saga occurred because Sam Young, previously a Mormon Bishop, was putting pressure on the church to properly investigate and prosecute many cases of grooming and sex abuse particularly during the leadup to the pre-baptismal worthiness interview at age eight. The church preferred the quiet of secrecy and internally handling everything, and Sam Young’s 23-day hunger strike and demonstration in front of church headquarters brought public attention. Instead of listening to a man trying to protect the vulnerable, they formally excommunicated him.</p><p>Brady and his wife watched as Bishop Young read his excommunication letter. They wept. “It’s time to fully resign my membership,” he told her. She couldn’t quite join him, but she understood, and so accepted and supported.</p><p>Brady’s trajectory included broad ethical issues of questioning basic equality (or its lack) of treatment and value, of women, and of homosexuals. Shortcomings there led him to notice the heavy-handed power structure that caused or permitted other unethical inequities, including financial. It seems to snowball; noticing certain failures leads to noticing more. The lack of truth, the very use of lies in church history, led on to doubting the existence of a god. Exposure to other ways of seeing things, alternative understandings, was again a significant factor. And again, things of the head didn’t remain in some isolated domain; they connect to the heart, to one’s sense of identity, of belonging.</p><p>Case C:</p><p>A few of the mileposts of her young Catholic life Cindy summarizes neatly with, “I was baptized when I was two months old, received my first communion at eight, and was confirmed at age 14,” but then notes of the latter two that at that point she “had very little understanding of the world, my own religion, other religions, and of myself.”</p><p>In high school she began to seriously expand her initially small, sheltered, small-town American world to include issues from world poverty, to religion, to disease, to globalization, to varieties of ways of life. On going off to college, her world of steady and deliberate horizon-widening was quite quickly torn much more open “with several hardships. Sexual abuse, being a victim of bullying, my parents divorcing, more sexual abuse, suffering from severe anxiety and anorexia, and the unexpected death of a friend.”</p><p>She naturally turned to the faith that had been a constant background foundation in her life, and remembers “screaming out to god, begging for help, and feeling as though I was never heard.” She searched for the comfort that family and others reassured her was there, but instead found confusion, shame, hopelessness, and fear.</p><p>Her questions went beyond the personal of her case, to mix in the broad ethics of what was likely reality. She puzzled that</p><p>“though god was all loving, he should be feared. It seemed that although god created you in his image, could forgive your most horrible sins if you repented, and loved you more than you could ever comprehend, god also had absolutely no problem sending you to hell so that you could burn for all eternity.”</p><p>In painful summary, she says: “I was scared. I didn’t feel loved. I felt controlled. I felt obligated, restricted, and as though I was always walking on thin ice.”</p><p>Amidst all these clanging emotions, Cindy tried to use a sort of anchor point she had learned to respect intellectually. Studying in a biology major, she had learned the importance of testing ideas, of gathering objective evidence before forming conclusions, and of being willing to change one’s mind. She was encouraged, and believed it was good, to use this even</p><p>“outside of class. I feel the need for things of high importance to have credibility, proof, and reproducible results. It’s hard to say prayers are answered when those praying in Texas live in a developed world full of simple luxuries all the way to excessive luxuries, but those in areas of sub-saharan Africa, who pray just as much, do not have access to basic human needs. It’s hard to say “God has a reason for everything” when you consider there are hospitals full of children with horrible forms of cancer that will take their lives, or why so many women on this planet are oppressed, sexually abused, and raped. When you consider the number of children who die every year from malaria or for the horrific non-sensible amounts of violence seen in nearly every single nation on this planet, how are you supposed to believe this holy benevolent force is watching over you and protecting you? We simply lack proof of this “wonderful deity”.”</p><p>To this she added:</p><p>“I know that religion is supposed to be a faith, and that you follow it blindly, without legitimate proof. But how can Christians say that Muslims are wrong? (Or vice versa). Most Christians I know who feel this way know very little about Islam… the overwhelming sense of “we are right and you are wrong” has destroyed “faith” and has become a divisive way to frame an “us versus them” dynamic that only caters to the ego…”</p><p>In the process of re-evaluating her faith, and religion and god broadly, Cindy gave herself open latitude on exploration. For an English class group blog assignment on religion, she chose to learn and write about a modern version of Satanism whose central purpose is primarily advocating “for religious pluralism and diversity. In reality, they fight for what the founding fathers fought for,” adding, with an obviously very intact sense of humor, “except the Satanic Temple wears more leather and eyeliner.”</p><p>In looking back and reflecting on her own relatively young life, and noting her appreciation for tradition and music and architecture and history, and still being able to be comfortable in a Cathedral and with ‘certain’ religious rituals, she adds that “I don’t consider myself religious now, but I consider myself spiritual even though that is now the most cliché thing to say. I like to believe that there is some type of unseen energy in this world that we can’t quite explain.”</p><p>She takes this reflecting a bit further:</p><p>“I have spent most of my life feeling negative and cynical, and sometimes I just want to feel hope and connection. I know that hope and connection is why many stay devoted to their religion, but because I couldn’t stay with my own religion, I made my own beliefs that are open for change and different interpretations. For many years now, I have felt particularly connected with Buddhism because it does not have a god. I am fine with Buddha being a teacher that followers look up to. Buddhism does not instill fear into its constituents, nor does it try to tell you that everyone else is wrong and going to suffer in the afterlife.”</p><p>Expressing confidence that she would have arrived at a similar conclusion even if by another route, she states that, “Religion did not make me happy, and I feel freer without it. I do believe I would have reached this same conclusion had I not experienced all the trauma in my early twenties as I had already been questioning my beliefs for years.”</p><p>Her final reflection reveals some of the depth to which a science-like approach to testing ideas, and being open to changing one’s mind, has impacted even her approach to something as personal as religion.</p><p>“I am not a Satanist, and I still read books about Buddhism but do not consider myself a Buddhist. I think it’s a shame that I lead my life happily, I have a master’s degree in biological sciences, I do volunteer work, I try to lead a respectful and peaceful life and despite those positive things I am still told my soul is destined to burn in hell, simply because I do not believe in god. The more I learn about this world the more I cannot fathom the possibility of an all loving deity. Would I ever change my beliefs if I was given concrete proof? Yes, I will always do my best to follow a path of truth and evidence, even if it means admitting I was wrong.”</p><p>The last sentence of her introductory paragraph turns out to be quite insightful about herself and her approach to living. Of her lack of understanding of receiving communion and being confirmed, and of the world, her religion, and others, and of her very self, she says, “I am still learning about all of these things and will always be until the day I die.”</p><p><strong>Analysis</strong></p><p>One of the features that these stories share is that of exposure to and deepening awareness of <em>other</em> ways of seeing/understanding life, of alternate belief systems. In Amy’s case this was vaguely the background to her whole life experience, then brought into focus when intensely emotional experience brought into focus inconsistencies and contradictions in her up-until-then perspective. She quite quickly moved from ‘I no longer subscribe to X, therefore I also re-evaluate Y and Z; there are other ways of seeing this.’ In Brady’s case this began in junior high with a friend’s critique of polygamy, and accelerated in college with both formal classes/seminars/groups, after some somewhat difficult times associated with his Mormon mission. Again, the snowball of other perspectives can grow quickly when triggered. In Cindy’s case this began in general awareness of other in high school, and then accelerated in college, triggered again in part by some significant emotional turmoil.</p><p>One can see in these cases a generally more emotion-involving triggering set of events, but I would caution on making too much of that. On one hand, those with some degree of inside exposure to strong faith/belief have no doubt heard many stories of emotionally intense experiences resulting in doubling down on one’s faith. And on the other hand, it is important to note that in these three cases they were ready and open to honest if uncomfortable re-evaluation of their previous perspectives. The idea that ‘If this particular experience had not prompted a fairly time-compressed response, I still would eventually have realized what I did, and made the same ultimate changes’ is there.</p><p>One also sees in these cases that a key factor in their re-evaluating existing beliefs was to view them in a broad ethical sense of what is, in simple terms, fair, decent, just, and if applied to the concept of a deity, worthy of worship. Accepting that ‘I not only <em>can</em> judge what I find acceptable and will support, but that I <em>have the responsibility to</em> make this kind of judgement’ seems to be a common denominator.</p><p>It must also be recognized that in each of these cases, there were at least temporary prices to be paid in emotional pain of the process itself.</p><p>Recommendation</p><p>This being a preliminary investigation, I will simply acknowledge that there is no doubt that there is much more unknown than known in this field. I am sure only that there is much room for the in-depth study of many PhD dissertations taking this orders of magnitude deeper.</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>Berger, Peter. 1968. Quoted in <em>A Bleak Outlook Is Seen for Religion</em>. The New</p><p>York Times, 25 February, 1968</p><p>Cottee, Simon. 2015. <em>The Apostates: When Muslims Leave Islam.</em> C. Hurst &amp; Co.</p><p>Dein, Simon. 2013. Editorial <em>How Useful is ‘Religious Belief’ in the</em></p><p><em>Anthropology of Religion?</em> In Anthropology, 2:1, 2013</p><p>Ebaugh, Helen. 1988. Becoming an Ex: The Process of Role Exit. University</p><p>of Chicago Press</p><p>Enstedt, Daniel; Larsson, Goran, and Mantsinen, Teemu. 2019.</p><p><em>Handbook on Leaving Religion</em>. Brill, Leiden and Boston</p><p>Gervais, Will. 2011. <em>Finding the Faithless: Perceived Atheist Prevalence</em></p><p><em>Reduces Anti-Atheist Prejudice</em>, in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 37(4), 2011</p><p>Gervais, Will, and Naile, Maxine. 2018. <em>How Many Atheists Are There</em>?</p><p>Social Psychological and Personality Science, January, 2018</p><p>Gorman-Murray, Andrew. <em>Sexy Stories: Using Autobiography in Geographies</em></p><p><em>of Sexuality</em> [online]. Qualitative Research Journal, Vol. 7, №1, 2007: doi: 10.3316/QRJ0701003. Availability: &lt;https://search.informit.com.au/documentSummary;dn=644662946804369;res=IELHSS&gt; ISSN: 1443–9883. [cited 22 Jun 20]</p><p>Jacobs-Huey, Lanita. 2008 <em>The Native Are Gazing and Talking Back:</em></p><p><em>Reviewing the Problematics of Positionality, Voice, and Accountability among “Native” Anthropologists</em>. American Anthropologist, 7 January, 2008</p><p>Kaufman, Walter. 1961. <em>Critique of Religion and Philosophy</em>. Harper and Row</p><p>Lenski, Gerhard. 1961. <em>The Religious Factor</em>. Doubleday</p><p>Narayan, Kirin. 1993. <em>How Native is the “Native” Anthropologist?</em> American</p><p>Anthropologist, Vol. 95, №3, September, 1993</p><p>Ryrie, Alec. 2019. <em>Unbelievers: An Emotional History of Doubt.</em> Harper</p><p>Collins Publishers</p><p>Shermer, Michael. 2018. <em>The Number of Americans with No Religious</em></p><p><em>Affiliation is Rising</em>. Scientific American, April, 2018</p><p>Sri, Hari. 2014 <em>Why I am not Hindu.</em> New Humanist, 23 January, 2014</p><p><a href="https://newhumanist.org.uk/4545/why-i-am-not-hindu?fbclid=IwAR3wOTy-NnmzDdXceiHAMT2SyAQ9toPTcrmhHqLTG19LkeUcxRhQriEmhf0">https://newhumanist.org.uk/4545/why-i-am-not-hindu?fbclid=IwAR3wOTy-NnmzDdXceiHAMT2SyAQ9toPTcrmhHqLTG19LkeUcxRhQriEmhf0</a></p><p>Tsuda, Takeyuki. 2015. <em>Is native anthropology really possible?</em></p><p>Anthropology Today, 26 May, 2015</p><p>Turpin, Hugh. 2019. Chapter 15. <em>Leaving Catholicism</em>, in Handbook on</p><p>Leaving Religion. Brill</p><p><strong>Appendix</strong></p><p>The writing-prompt:</p><p>For inclusion in <em>Personal Journeys of Exploration Beyond Early Learned Faith Subcultures,</em> thank you for being willing to tell the story of <em>your journey</em> out of the general belief system of the family you grew up in, to where you are now. Please include thoughts, emotions, questions, experiences, etc. that played a part in your journey, and deal with those in levels of depth that work for you.</p><p>Please write in the first person. If in the telling, though, you are recreating conversation where you were called by name, feel free to use your real name OR to choose a pseudonym. When you refer to your mom or dad or siblings or neighbors or relatives or teachers or pastors etc., you may well choose to protect their identities through the anonymity of pseudonyms.</p><p>While I would ask that you identify the general faith community which you ultimately grew out of, please don’t put your readers through a comprehensive list of what that group believes. However, when there are specifics which were relevant to your evolving thoughts and questions, do describe in any chosen level of vivid detail the mental picture(s) of what you were taught, and of course why you questioned or embraced it. It may also be useful to your readers to be able to picture the country/culture/region/geography/city or even neighborhood, of events in your life.</p><p>If you have some thoughts on <em>why</em> you are willing to share personal details from your life, on perhaps what you hope a reader might consider or learn, feel free to include that explicit explanation.</p><p>You are being given a wide range in length. I hope you can comfortably tell your story in 1,500 to 10,000 words.</p><p>My masters dissertation involves my collecting, reading, and thoughtfully writing about these various journeys. In this dissertation, no one’s story will have very long sections of it treated as a giant quote. (The later pulling together of these stories to then publish an anthology will be a separate step.)</p><p>After reading your story, I may follow up with some questions for further exploration, but you obviously have the right to withdraw from this research project at any point in time.</p><p>There probably is no “typical” experience, so don’t worry about fitting in. While relatively few people will probably read my masters dissertation, the later anthology which would carry your story and a good number of others, without my application of anthropological theory, could be read by many. These people would read this anthology with different perspective, and different motives. Do tell your story in a way which will hold their attention, and perhaps provoke thought, but never resort to fiction. Let this be true… your truth.</p><p>You will have a right to request a copy of my dissertation.</p><p>(I will be in contact later about the publication of an anthology.)</p><p>Thank you in advance for your participation.</p><p>Table summarizing <strong>Type / Degree of Change</strong></p><p>(sadly, this table can’t seem to be formatted to work here)</p><p><strong>Starting point</strong> <strong>Ending point</strong></p><p>Denominations included</p><p>Baptist, Buddhist, Catholic 2, Christian Science, Jehovah’s Witness, Mormon, non-denominational Chr. 2, Orthodox Chr., Pentecostal, and Seventh-day Adventist 2.</p><p>Acknowledgements</p><p>I wish to again acknowledge the time, effort, and perhaps pain, each of my participants so willingly gave and subjected themselves to. It was and always will be deeply appreciated. I also wish to thank my Professor of Religious studies in Anthropology, and mentor and advisor, Dr. Emma Tarlo, for the many insights and useful advice she contributed to my studies in anthropology, and to this dissertation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4b41cb901403" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Toughest Application of Critical Thinking]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/the-toughest-application-of-critical-thinking-e077a597c975?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e077a597c975</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-like-approach]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[openness-to-questioning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[behind-our-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Apr 2019 03:44:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-08T03:44:49.728Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Without either falling for another doomsday scenario or assuming that everything will be just fine, it seems hopelessly obvious that we, whether defined as a nation and culture or as humanity globally, have huge challenges that must be faced. That “must” isn’t optional; ignoring these challenges isn’t going to make them go away. Having been personally surrounded by some of the darker side to our behavior in both Lebanon and Rwanda, I feel compelled to help shed some light on certain little-discussed aspects of these challenges. But some of what needs understanding can be viewed as controversial, politically incorrect, or worse. So the question must be asked: Why bother, why ruffle feathers? I hope to persuade you that it has to do with the urgency to facing key challenges in our times.</p><p>We won’t delve here into the details of challenges like the national debt, stressed ecosystems, climate change, sustainable economics and agriculture, and conflict of multiple types in numerous locations, but I want to ask you to consider how so many not only don’t engage in discussion of possible solutions, they seem to ignore the very existence of these challenges. Granted, some are so smothered by the struggle to just stay afloat that they don’t have the time, and haven’t developed the capacity to look at the broader picture, but I venture that doesn’t accurately describe you reading here. Many though have — without examination — stayed comfortably reassured that there is a supernatural solution to our problems. Wrapped in that same bundle of religion is the central human tendency to simply believe that which we want to believe. This tendency isn’t by any means exclusively limited to people of religious faith; we all must learn to be on guard against that natural inclination.</p><p>That said, religion is a special place where cultivation and reinforcement of this tendency is particularly refined. Growing up, unless we have highly unusual parents, we are simply told what is ‘true.’ It comes from our family <em>and</em> from a modern version of ‘tribe’, our church group. We are not only <em>not</em> taught or encouraged to question, to explore, or, above all, to examine verifiable evidence, but we are encouraged to simply accept, to <em>believe</em>, what our tribe’s holy books say. We are taught, and of course accept without critical analysis, that <em>authority</em> behind any assertion, whether part of our tribe’s text or from a figurehead up the chain in our group, matters infinitely more than any kind of verifiable evidence. These Beliefs of Preference then can and do become habit. Think about it. They spill out of the habituated process that believes things like “Our God is the right God,” and “I can live forever,” and “Those ‘others’ are the bad guys who have the wrong God,” etc., and they permeate other parts of our thinking, our very beliefs.</p><p>We stay comfortable… not exploring significant material if it might be troubling, not needing to check and verify facts, or we tell ourselves that everyone ‘selects their facts,’ and so we can too. This, although it comes naturally to us, gets reinforced and developed within religion, and it leads to us not facing uncomfortable realities. These include climate change, the national debt, ridiculous wealth gaps especially when viewed globally, ecological stresses — terrestrial and marine — that scream for attention, and sociologic trends (re-emergence of hate groups; “We’re # 1!” nationalism that leads to modern imperialism, etc.), all of which must be acknowledged <em>first</em> in order to be faced and then solved.</p><p>Let’s look at some facts. A person feeling better believing in the God of the Bible, the God idea of the shoes they were raised in, doesn’t make it so. Had any individual been born into any number of different families, in any number of different cultures, in any number of different centuries or millennia, they would have had an overwhelming likelihood of believing in a different God. There are many, many, millions of people out there who are sure their God is the right one. Do we want to be just like them?!</p><p>Ask yourself what cavemen, or early civilizations, thought of eclipses or comets, of floods or lightning or droughts, of disease, of birth or death? They gave spirit-world explanations to things they couldn’t possibly understand. Religion slowly formalized in various places, in various forms, out of that beginning. (If some are inclined to think I’m playing loose with history, you can google burial among “early man”, or “primitive people” among many other topics. Read deeply and broadly what archaeology and paleontology have revealed.)</p><p>Of the illiterate in outback Afghanistan or deep jungle Congo or our own equivalent, we can’t expect anything different than their adhering to what they were indoctrinated into, what they were raised in. They can’t analyze it, and they can’t see the negative consequences of sociocentric conflict. But does that make a good excuse for us staying stuck there?</p><p>Indoctrination is a reality, and it doesn’t come from evil, conniving people. I was indoctrinated by good, loving parents. And almost certainly, so are most around the world. Our parents meant no harm; they intended good. But in an age when so overwhelmingly much in astronomy, in geology, in paleontology, in genetics, in ecology, in sociology, in psychology, in history, and more, has been painstakingly figured out, and put in clear and comprehensible laymen’s terms, what excuse do we have for discarding, without deep, thorough, or <em>honest</em> investigation, the explanations and understandings which put this all together is sensible ways?</p><p>Imagine a circle of knowledge, of understanding. At two o’clock on this clock face place the sciences, particularly those which help us grasp our place in time, space, and process: astronomy, geology, paleontology, and the environment’s interaction with genetics. At six o’clock place history, archaeology, and aspects of sociology. At ten o’clock place religion, psychology, and other aspects of sociology. Now imagine a large spoke radiating toward the center of the circle from each of these fields. The hub, the intersection of these spokes where one discipline sheds light and perspective on others, is where great searching, and great honesty, is needed.</p><p>Consider a few short quotes and note how they apply here. “The ultimate ignorance is the rejection of something you know nothing about, yet refuse to investigate.” — Dr. Wayne Dyer. Let’s substitute the word “little” for “nothing” in this. We must be careful in reassuring ourselves that we know more than nothing, when in truth, we know very little. There is so much to learn. We don’t have to become experts, but we can become well, and fairly deeply, informed. To not venture into the hub of that circle of knowledge is to choose a superficial understanding of life. But to venture without openness to and respect for the best of our painstakingly figured out data and the best and most reasonable interpretations thereof is arrogance and bigoted folly. For just one example, in terms of understanding the evidence and the story of life on earth, we would do well to read substantially on the rapid re-diversification of life forms after each of the five mass extinctions. There is verifiable data, and great consensus.</p><p>The next quote — “When an honest man discovers he is mistaken, he will either cease to be mistaken, or he will cease to be honest.” Reportedly anonymous, so I wish I could claim it. And I believe the next is at least close to a quote from Carl Sagan: “The only sacred cow in science is that there <em>is no</em> sacred cow.” That is to say, everything can and should be questioned and analyzed. Conclusions must be kept open to modification by better, verified, data — by facts that don’t have to fit one’s preferred filter.</p><p>The reason to recognize and to take on the phenomena of beliefs of preference, again, is to make us better problem-solvers. This requires honesty, less inclination to fool ourselves. But it’s not easy; parts of the process itself, and advocating for it, can be tough, even unpleasant. A well-meaning friend told me in 2012 to relax, to be happy in my own life. Well, let’s ask ourselves, if the Titanic is headed through iceberg-laden waters, are we fine just “being happy” with the cruise? In a democracy, the “passengers” get to help chart the course; we hire the crew. If happiness depends on being under-informed, on being mostly focused on the state of being happy, what kind of happiness is that? Let’s not personify “ignorance is bliss.”</p><p>Among my list of self-evident truths is this: “That we owe a decent, stable, and enjoyable world to future generations.” Every step we make toward fulfilling that obligation gives one a much deeper sense of satisfaction than any shallow, self-centered, reassurance of preferred belief ever can. I contend this should be the drive and focus of a responsible adult’s life.</p><p>For purposes of contrast in how and why we live, consider this: “The purpose of life is not to be happy. It is to be useful, to be honorable, to be compassionate, and to have it make some difference that you have lived and lived well.” — Ralph Waldo Emerson. And, “The moral purpose of a man’s life is the achievement of his own happiness.” — Ayn Rand.</p><p>Let’s make a few more observations on happiness, on enjoyment. Many of us can no doubt remember a sermon on something like “Don’t fall for the ‘If it feels good, do it’ mentality.” Well, ask yourself, what is the ultimate ‘feel good’ item? Keep in mind that ‘thinking’ something, ‘believing’ something, is every bit as much ‘doing’ something as throwing a ball, or shooting up heroin. What is more ‘feel good’ than clinging to the belief that “I can live forever”?</p><p>On first blush, some of us may need to be patient with ourselves and with key ideas; this included me. It can take time. But just like kids get over realizing that key figures in children’s stories, yes even Santa Clause, aren’t real, we can do this. People can get over their sense of loss. Again, the reason it’s important to face reality is that we stand a much better chance at leaving our great-great-grandchildren a quality planet, ecologically and sociologically, if we become better problem-solvers… and that requires undoing our habituation to beliefs of preference. Honesty — over fooling ourselves — is paramount in any and every field.</p><p>Back to our cruise ship with dangerous waters ahead, and we passengers electing the crew — Some passengers simply want to listen to their favorite cello solo; others complain about the tea being too hot, or too cold, or late; others obsess about finding a way to upgrade their first class ticket to a luxury suite; some faithfully help deliver extra soup to the steerage passengers once a week, and although they do nothing to help them improve their real conditions or the structure of how things are, these helpers seem to sleep better for it; and nearly everyone ignores the direction and speed of the ship, or simply trusts that stuff like that is all in the hands of the powerful and out-of-reach crew chiefs, or the hands of God, and accepts that whatever will be will be.</p><p>In terms of taking a hard second look at some common beliefs of preference, let’s imagine a few things. Say we could end disease, and war, and even accidents, and then end aging. Without older generations moving on, any new births would put ever greater strain on the sustainability of everything. We’d reach a point where before anyone could have kids, their great-grandparents would have to agree to move on.</p><p>Also imagine having to sit somewhere for the last 4.6 billion years and watch our solar system and our planet do their thing. If you watched The Green Mile, you may remember the mouse and the old man who were sentenced to never finishing their life cycle.</p><p>We can learn to find great purpose, and therefore happiness, in doing a good job of leaving a quality planet to our descendants and to the whole society which will surround them. This brings us to the need to constructively confront not only “believers” who fail to take action because everything is in the hands of their God, but to also confront libertarians who insist that “I am in no way my brother’s keeper,” whose personal freedoms should not be limited in any way, and who have already claimed their personal lifeboat.</p><p>I’ve asked people to consider ‘enlightened self-interest’ as opposed to just self-centeredness of the moment. Most people do want the best for their descendants. But if you just want to set your descendants up to compete well, or to withdraw, either one of those doesn’t do anything to try to ensure the basic quality of the society that will surround them… and if you think that won’t matter, please think again. That is a big challenge, but do you really want to give up without trying? Margaret Mead said, “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed it is the only thing that ever has.”</p><p>In addressing some suggestions of how to constructively ‘confront’, I want to mention some categories of people who I think deserve a pass. The illiterate, the extremely poor, or the significantly slow don’t need their boats rocked. Neither do the very elderly. Another group which I think we should leave in their comfort are those who death touched at a particularly sensitive time in life. A person who lost a parent while they were young; a parent who lost a child who was still a kid. The need to have another run, a forever, can simply be essential to sanity. What about the rest of us? Wouldn’t we do well to ask ourselves how grownup we can be about this?</p><p>So, assuming at least some of you buy into the need to constructively confront, allow me to make some suggestions. With simple questions one can often lead people to realize a number of things: That the family and culture and century of birth is by far the greatest determinant of most people’s faith. That none of these faiths are any more verifiable than any other. And therefore that faith is a really lousy excuse for war, but obviously has been and still is used for one. (read “C Street”) That the habit of believing what we simply want to believe is just not honest with the evidence, however common it might be. That the tendency to die for, and kill for, your right God is not only history; it is still with us. That with a global population headed toward 8 billion people, the tendency to fight over basic survival resources (from arable land, to water, to energy, to jobs) can’t be managed once given momentum; it must be preemptively avoided or managed ahead of time. That there is no more room for the “it’s all in God’s hands” failure to face challenges. That there is no more room for the libertarian denial that the broader good can mean imposing itself on an individual’s personal freedoms. That hope and optimism are still possible, but it is going to take a commitment to honest problem-solving, which requires a respect for the best evidence, and thus a willingness to change our minds on issues. (no sacred cows) That on an increasingly crowded planet whose life-sustaining capacity is being stretched, we are all in this together, so while we can’t be doormats, we must be willing and able to <em>cooperate</em> in the interest of the general welfare. That the conservative tendency to hang on to tradition must be replaced with a willingness to change when the evidence demands it. That Republicans in the days of Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt were the progressives. That if you study deeply that intersection at the center of the circle of knowledge, and have a conscience, you have no choice but to be a progressive.</p><p>Keep in mind that in the days of Copernicus, then Bruno, and then Galileo, it took the authorities of the day, and the common man, over two centuries to come around to the evidence. Now a century and a half after Darwin published what he figured out, way too many still live in denial, in chosen ignorance, in tenaciously guarded belief of preference. Today, with our global population, with our tendency to fight over survival resources, to fight for our ‘right’ God, with stretched ecosystems, and strained atmosphere and oceans, do we have that kind of time flexibility? Picture what the next few decades will bring if we don’t get rational, evidence-based, thinking to rule the day. We <em>can</em> problem-solve, but <em>will we</em>?</p><p>Consider what the crux issue of today is. What do you think it is? While you mull that over, let’s consider the crux issue in 1860. It was slavery. Those who insist that it was State’s Rights just need to note what State Right they were most committed to fighting for. Note that those who argued and then fought against slavery used a broadened social conscience, further progressed enlightenment thinking, to work at changing things. Those who argued and then fought to justify and keep slavery used — you may or may not have guessed it — scripture. They clung to the traditions they grew up with and knew, the ones that made them feel secure, and kept their privileges.</p><p>And so today — Below the various surface arguments of today, there lies this great divide, this crux issue. Some insist on using their cultural tradition, as handed to them in their holy book, interpreted and selected by their family and modern tribe, to maintain their status quo. These are conservatives in the broad sense. If you doubt this, ask yourself where the denial of climate change, and the support for invading Iraq, came from… the secular left or the religious right? Look at how this is being played out by some. Both “sovereign citizens” and “oath keepers” use the Constitution and scripture to bolster their twisted world view… just like those who fought against the Civil Rights movement of the 50’s and 60’s. Because inflexible fixity of belief, refusal to be open to changing one’s mind, interferes with good (honest) problem-solving and leads to unnecessary fights, the very real potential for trouble is great if we as a population keep conservatism as a highly influential cultural force. If we fail at problem-solving, or at avoiding unnecessary fights, it will be more than casual trouble.</p><p>Others, and I hope it might come to include you, recognize that it’s not all about us, that we are our brother’s keeper, that the Founding Fathers were right to include “to promote the general welfare” in their statement of the very purposes for this new government, that we must keep an open mind in all things and be willing to change our minds in favor of the best verifiable evidence. These are progressives, again, in the broad sense. If we are persistent and wise and strong, we can win the domestic political argument, and we can work with increasing numbers of our fellow humans around the world to leave a decent, stable, and enjoyable planet to future generations. It won’t happen in a day, but it can happen.</p><p>If you are inclined to doubt this, ask yourself what possible future scenarios lie out there for us. Considering our global population and our tendencies (to fight over survival resources, to fight for our ‘right’ God, to believe what we want to believe and therefore to deny what we don’t find convenient), do you see the three most obvious futures? 1. Organized competition/conflict. War. Keeping in mind all the modern possibilities, consider whether it is naïve to assume that there would be winners, period; 2. Disorganized competition/conflict. Somalia or Syria on steroids, but not at some safe and ignorable distance; and 3. Cooperation; active, rational, problem-solving.</p><p>On this crux issue and its consequences, I once shared Soren Kierkegaard’s observation that “There are two ways to be fooled. One is to believe what isn’t true. The other is to refuse to accept what is true,” with a religious friend. He enthusiastically embraced it and said “So true!” I then asked him, and I ask us here, “What is our best tool for slowly and painstakingly figuring out what <em>is</em> true?” I’m suggesting that this matters, and, because it directly affects our approach to addressing serious and pressing challenges, that it is urgent to get on with being honest with the evidence, and honest with ourselves.</p><p>Now, I am not proposing that everyone must become pure atheists. If some have an overwhelming internal need to have a God and an eternity, I beg of them this. Acknowledge and guard against these three intrinsic risks to faith: 1. Those with unshakable conviction that their God is the right God are significantly quicker to dive headlong into conflict with the belief that God is on their side; 2. Many use the reassurance of a supernatural solution to calm them into not taking problems seriously or urgently; and 3. Many form the habit of settling into ‘beliefs of preference’ rather than carefully evaluating verifiable evidence, and this affects our approach to many challenges. If a person consciously self-monitors against these risks, they may find a way to keep a very untraditional faith, and cause minimal harm because of it.</p><p>I do understand hesitation, outright reluctance. For well over a decade after I realized that our various notions of God and formations of religion were almost certainly the product of early man’s search to explain and understand, followed by centuries of various refinements and formalizations, I too made the live-and-let-live choice. I was not remotely on a soapbox; I kept my questions, my exploration, and my uncomfortable conclusions, to myself. I didn’t think there was harm in belief. But watching the history of the last several decades unfold further, this fresh realization became inescapable — even most modern societies fall for ‘God is on our side,’ and for competition for what they perceive to be basic survival resources. There is overwhelming harm in the habit of beliefs of preference, of simply believing what we want to believe. It overlooks or dismisses problems, it imagines magical solutions, it justifies war, and cultural and material imperialism, and it thinks sustainability is irrelevant. This is why we must call out beliefs of preference for what they are, even if some feel picked on. I beg of you to seriously consider what I’ve found too well-founded and too important to dismiss.</p><p>This is a tough and real choice. If some choose to stay in their beliefs without consciously guarding against these risks, or simply to live and let live by never challenging others of traditional belief and never pointing out the risks, they aid and abet other believers; they are, in essence, aiding and abetting blind traditionalists today. How is that different than those who aided and abetted tradition almost 160 years ago? Yes, it was slavery then, but it was still the conservatism, the tradition — the refusal to update and look at things anew — of the day.</p><p>Let me re-clarify that I’m not pushing atheism per se. I’m promoting active, honest, problem-solving on a broad societal level. As I’ve pointed out, it is the religious right which, in seemingly ideologically bulletproof allegiance to their tradition, continues to deny challenges that are real and urgent. Since that is the case, I’ve come to openly challenging habituation to beliefs of preference and its point of primary reinforcement and refinement. I think some may keep a kind of faith with a conscious grain of salt, with deliberate humility. That’s not the end of the world, and it is the only kind of faith that avoids being part of the problem. I am asking you to not aid and abet today’s blind tradition. You might feel that slavery was clearly wrong, and it was, but I would point out that if slavery hadn’t been ended for another 20, 30, 40, or more years, that would have been tragic for the poor suffering people who continued to live, and many die, under that yoke of bondage, but it wouldn’t have had farther-reaching disastrous sociologic or ecologic consequences affecting hundreds of millions and quite probably billions. So who risks the greater ethical (moral) wrong — the conservative then who defended slavery, or the conservative today who has a mindset still resistant to change, still willing to deny abundant verifiable evidence, perhaps beginning with the fossil and ice core records, but continuing (and not ending) with climate change, and honest looks at societal stability. As stated earlier, there is overwhelming harm in the habit of beliefs of preference, of simply believing what we want to believe.</p><p>Some have argued that we must care about what others ‘do,’ but shouldn’t invade what others ‘believe.’ I ask us to note that beliefs are the well-spring of actions, of what we do. Among the things we do — We hire the crew on our ship. Each of us not only has the right to examine, and to challenge, the beliefs of whoever the current crew is, but also those of our fellow passengers. This isn’t about casual disrespect; it is about seeking to “form a more perfect union,” to get ever closer to getting it right, to leaving a decent, stable, and enjoyable planet to future generations.</p><p>Interestingly, the fastest growing group in America today are the rational, evidence-respecting, secular humanists. As a whole civilization, we have hope; the question is whether or not we have enough time. You can be part of accelerating this growth, not of inhibiting it with reinforcing the foot-dragging.</p><p>Also interesting is that some seem to need to be forced into others’ shoes in order to open their eyes. Dick Cheney is a conservative in every area but one… and he was only shaken into viewing sexual orientation more broadly, progressively, because of his own daughter. Must we all be that intransigent? Can’t we think about things from other perspectives than what we were born and raised in, and with evidence outweighing any tradition?</p><p>A Greek proverb says, “A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in.” I’m trying to plant trees; I hope in your own various ways, you will too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e077a597c975" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding and Using what’s Most Likely True.]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/finding-and-using-whats-most-likely-true-e3648d479026?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3648d479026</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[re-evaluating-beliefs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring-our-political-crew]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conservative-v-progressiv]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Oct 2018 05:38:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-08T17:28:52.159Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Over the last couple decades, I’ve increasingly attempted to engage in discussions on aspects of how we everyday citizens figure out what is likely true, what we believe, and where we stand on things. Even among the well-educated, 99.9…% of us aren’t experts on anything, let alone everything. I’ve tried to have this discussion in a variety of settings: face to face; small groups; with my chemistry and physics students; and on social media.</p><p>No one reading this needs to have much imagination to picture that this discussion is not easy, and I’ve been tempted to simply quit trying to engage. Why continue with a difficult task? Well, there’s this — we have the privilege and responsibility of voting, and thus of hiring the crew that runs the ship. No one wants one-party rule or monolithic thinking, but especially at a time when this fairly new idea of alternative <em>facts </em>further confuses and can lead to cynicism, it seems to me that it would be very constructive to still find ways to engage in honest dialogue, and attempt to find somewhat common ground-rules so we’re at least playing in the same ballpark.</p><p>Do we blindly trust the experts, or go to the other extreme of dismissing them as useless and elitist? Do we just trust our clan, be they an ethnic extension of our family, or — more recently — people of the same religious or political upbringing? Is there, or is there not, something like a strategy which everyday folk can use to help figure out what <em>is</em> <em>likely</em> true, and come to consciously understand <em>why</em> we choose to take the stands we do? And then can we use the insight and perspective gained to figure out <em>how</em> to do necessary things in facing the challenges of our times?</p><p>When we get used to mixing any combination of beliefs which we simply like, and don’t critically analyze the bases for those beliefs or the intrinsic incongruities among them, we get comfortable just not worrying about, even thinking about, the underpinnings of any of what we claim to be our truths. We get, we have <em>already</em> <em>gotten</em>, comfortable just believing what we want to believe, and dismissing whatever we don’t initially like, without ever exploring or risking discovering the underpinnings of things we don’t immediately like.</p><p>What’s the problem with that? Soren Kierkegaard observed that “There are two ways to be fooled. One is to believe what isn’t true. The other is to refuse to accept what is true.” As is hopefully obvious, we must follow that duh truth with the tough question of “How <em>do</em> we figure out what <em>is</em> true?” Can we remotely presume that we just got lucky in being born into the ‘right’ culture and subculture? What have the centuries shown to be our best ‘tool’ for figuring out what is true?</p><p>Consider: It’s the process of figuring things out in a science-like way where we put our ideas to the test. In doing this we commit to respecting verifiable evidence, and we pre-commit to being <em>willing</em> to change our minds, to update our ideas to best fit the preponderance of the evidence that we have. Let’s see how this fits as a thorough and honest way of figuring out what is likely true.</p><p>Do we just leave this process to the experts, the scientists in both the hard sciences and in the social sciences? And then do we allow ourselves to dismiss the most informed people, these experts, these scientists, when they then reach conclusions which we don’t like? How do we, the vast majority of whom are non-experts in any field, decide where we tentatively stand on all kinds of issues, and therefore how we will vote on related matters?</p><p>Most anyone would readily concede that simply going with a majority opinion is not wise, and is lacking in any substantive depth. After all, when Copernicus first advocated for heliocentricity, he was in a very tiny minority. So was Wegener with plate tectonics, and… we have some idea how long this list could get.</p><p>So if not a simple majority vs. minority, what then? Consider this: Ask if there has been a multi-decade-long, clear and continuing, <em>Shift</em> in where the experts take their stand. This idea stands the test of time. We can even picture it graphically. On the horizontal X axis we have time (often in years and decades; sometimes centuries), and on the vertical Y axis we have % consensus. One curving line on our graph represents an existing idea, a line sometimes with deep roots in time; it starts out at, let’s say 99%. Another curving line represents a new understanding, and starts out at 1%. Over the decades those lines cross, the first on its way down, the second on its way up. Again, history is full of examples beyond earth-centered shifting to sun-centered, and fixed continents shifting to moving continents.</p><p>And importantly, there are examples of this science-like approach being self-correcting. In the first half of the 1800s the idea of phrenology got going, with trained scientists, including physicians, behind it. The new idea was taking off; it was climbing significantly from 1% upward and upward. But it never got anywhere near even 75%, never mind 95%. It turned back and headed down. Why? Because the evidence didn’t support it. A consensus of explanation didn’t and couldn’t evolve in support of something which didn’t have evidence coming from a number of different directions.</p><p>The reason that this is important is that this is how scientists and engineers solve problems… and it’s how whole societies, and civilization writ large, must also face and solve broad problems. To ignore evidence, to dismiss newly developed explanatory and predictive consensus, primarily because you don’t <em>like</em> the evidence and the consensus, is to stay stuck with an old idea which has been shown to not hold water in light of newer evidence. Scientists and engineers can’t and don’t do that (and stay relevant), and neither can we (and be able to meet the challenges of our times).</p><p>Further, think of how remarkable it is for us, non-experts, to say of a newly developed consensus and the evidence which led to it, “I’m sticking with the traditional idea which I happen to like, and I think I know better than you all.” Would we classify it as “courageous,” or “blind, regressive, and ignorant-while-arrogant” to defend and stick with: geocentricity, fixed continents, a flat earth, racist beliefs in white superiority and black sub-humanity, etc. We must ask the same of so many things. What about special creation of every species, the vast majority of which are found only in the fossil record — never showing back up after one of those 5 mass extinctions? What about insisting on a young earth?</p><p>The reason these old ideas aren’t harmless if quaint relics of times past which can be left alone, is this: When <em>this</em> <em>habit</em> of dismissing whatever we don’t like, and doubling down on what we simply want to believe, is either ignored or accepted &amp; cultivated &amp; reinforced, it then gets in the way of honestly addressing the challenges of our times. As we will see in a moment, there is real harm to the broad society, to all of humanity, when this is done.</p><p>Before going on with the challenges of our times, I must pause and point out that there is a model which works quite well wherein we <em>can</em> ignore, without harm, various ideas which in no way, shape, or form meet our test of being grounded in objective evidence and in consensus among those most informed on a topic.</p><p>Today virtually no one who is not Amish takes a fair number of their beliefs any more seriously than we take the assertion that the earth is the center and is flat. Why don’t we hear public challenges to Amish ideas? Think about it. No one remotely needs to challenge their ideas <em>because</em> the Amish don’t try to impose their ideas on the rest of us, they don’t try to make the whole of society fall in line with their ideas by trying to manipulate things in such a way that a democracy might vote that policy into effect. It must be noted here that because no one needs to challenge their beliefs, they are free to practice their beliefs, they aren’t bothered, and they don’t feel picked on, complaining that their beliefs aren’t enacted into law for everyone to live by.</p><p>I want to briefly address here our frequent use of the terms conservative and progressive. Let’s clarify that it would be wrong to take the position that either conservatism or progressivism has some intrinsic moral inferiority, or moral superiority. Modern research has shown that at their core, in conservatives we’re looking at personality preferences for (and fears of) certain things: tradition, authority, obedience, punishment, training, recitation, conformity, order, an absence of gray areas, constancy, a greater emphasis on perceived immediate risks which could affect “us”, and a smaller and tighter circle of “us”. In progressives we’re looking at: change, questioning, exploration, ambiguity, rehabilitation, education, nuance, variety, a greater emphasis on perceived long-term risks which could affect all, including “others” (including future generations), and a broader and looser circle of “us” with an inclination to draw “them” in, creating new understandings of “us”. There’s much recent research in this area. It’s interesting to see ways in which our previous simpler understanding and labeling of these characteristics has become more deeply explanatory. We used to consider any communist, anywhere, to be on the liberal, not conservative, end of politics. Yet in the early 1990s, after the Soviet break-up and at the tail end of Russia’s brief flirtation with capitalism and democracy, frightened Russian Conservatives, trying to protect their status quo, their tradition, what they knew, worked to take Russia back to what the masses thought would be communism again, though it turned into simply authoritarianism with oligarchs mixed in strange ways with the central committee… and they succeeded.</p><p>Again, nothing about these differences in personality or preferences is intrinsically morally or otherwise “better” or “worse.” I submit however, that a trip back through time might be fairly revelatory here.</p><p>On the ship of our nation, we passengers hire the crew which runs the ship. In our weighing of the relative merits of conservatism and progressivism, let’s ask ourselves about these general philosophies and actions through the generations. It is worth noting that as the last half millennium ticked by, one of the consistent features of conservatism has been a striving to maintain one’s tradition, whether specifically focused on governance, religion, economic policies, or general societal habits.</p><p>Conversely, one of the central features of progressivism has been a push for, or at least willing acceptance of, change in these things. It is important to note that conservatives, in the American context, have not always been Republicans, nor progressives always Democrats; for essentially a century prior to 1960, a good southern conservative was a Democrat.</p><p>It is worth noting that over the centuries -</p><p>Conservatives wanted to maintain monarchies; progressives wanted to move toward democracy.</p><p>Conservatives wanted to guard the buying of indulgences to ensure going to heaven; progressives wanted a flexible theology which could be re-evaluated, and changed to fit new senses of justice, right, and a broader understanding.</p><p>Conservatives wanted to maintain slavery; progressives wanted to end it.</p><p>Conservatives wanted women to stay within roles which were and are limited in multiple ways; progressives wanted to broaden women’s roles in society, including voting, opportunity in an ever- wider array of careers, and something as fundamental as the seriousness with which their thoughts, memories, and very words are taken.</p><p>Conservatives wanted capital to be the central controlling power in industry, even if it meant workers (including children) were significantly exploited; progressives wanted to promote workers’ rights, including better pay, more reasonable hours and safer working conditions, and the legalization of collective bargaining.</p><p>Conservatives wanted to keep things like interracial marriage illegal; progressives wanted to leave things like that to the individuals, meaning it should be a legal choice.</p><p>Conservatives wanted to maintain as much racial separation as possible, including the ability to legally discriminate in residential, business/employment, and political (voting) policies; progressives wanted to push for firm civil rights for all.</p><p>Conservatives wanted to minimize encumbrances on business by avoiding regulations as to how they dispose of noxious waste products; progressives wanted to protect water, air, and land for all generations, even if it meant some inconvenience and expense to waste management.</p><p>Conservatives wanted and still want to maintain traditional limitations on access to the legal rights and privileges of marriage; progressives wanted and still want to allow consenting adults who want to marry to do so, be they two people of any particular nature.</p><p>Conservatives want business to be able to pay employees whatever market conditions permit, which in practice means whatever they can get away with; progressives want to ensure that equal work merits equal pay without regard to sex or race, and that a full-time job yields more than a poverty existence.</p><p>It is interesting that the common features of these philosophical and practical battles put on display the justifications used to maintain the tradition of the day, including the use of key cultural authorities like scripture. (i.e. Kings were “God’s anointed;” “Slaves, obey your masters;” and “Women, obey your husbands… and don’t speak up in church.”)</p><p>It is also worth noting that on most features, the policies advocated by each camp have over time maintained a fairly standard scenario. One case in which an interesting reversal occurred fairly early on is that of the relative size of government which they advocate for. In the days of monarchies, those in power of course wanted to keep power, and as conservatives wanting to maintain their (privilege) tradition, they liked big government, including intrusive law and big police and military might. Progressives back then wanted to weaken the monarchies, and thus wanted more limited government.</p><p>At first the change from this was relatively slow; but as democracy grew past infancy and developed the beginnings of stable roots, and the power of kings was increasingly constrained if not overthrown completely, progressives found that one of the most effective tools through which to push for reforms was through the power of the sub-branches of democracy like legislatures (not to leave out the executive and judicial branches which have also played roles).</p><p>As this developed further, progressives began to favor bigger government, for through it they could legislate change. Those who had occupied previous positions of privilege and power relative to the general population now didn’t want these new and unrelenting forces of change to succeed, and thus they came to favor limited government. The reversal was now fairly complete.</p><p>Before moving on from this “size of government” issue, let’s note a motto often used by conservatives. We’ve all heard someone say, “that government which governs best, governs least.” If that were true in anything near an absolute sense, anarchy would be a symptom of “good” governance. The other end of the spectrum can also be overplayed; there really is such a thing as too much government. In seeking a situation-appropriate middle ground, we would do well to recognize that on an increasingly crowded planet with evermore thinly spread and limited resources being competed over with greater intensity, that in order to not begin a descent toward anarchy, we’re going to need solid and wise governance. This doesn’t have to be a top-down break away from democracy; it can <em>best</em> be achieved by participation-intense direction provided by educated, informed, concerned, and involved citizens who hire and fire crews in order to guide the ship of our nation, and the ship of civilization, away from unnecessarily troubled waters.</p><p>So, as I look back on our many conservative-progressive struggles, I ask myself — Would we actually like to turn the clock back on any of these changes? Were the conservatives right in opposing change? Were the progressives wrong to push for these changes? Does this give us any potential lessons on our inclinations today? Have there been points in history when we had it just right… all the needed changes had already been made, and no further changes should be made? You and I must seek honest answers.</p><p>What kind of country, and more broadly, what kind of civilization, do we want to have participated in creating?</p><p>I hope we might eventually create a world where a Muslim, a Jew, a Christian, a Hindu, a Buddhist, and more, will all say, “I know that had I been born in another family, culture, or century, I would most likely believe in a different God; I can no longer pretend that my God is any more right or legitimate than other people’s Gods, and I certainly won’t kill over it.”</p><p>And yes, I hope we might eventually create a world in which more and more of us will, with conviction and commitment, say, “You know what, I will no longer try to impose my beliefs on the evidence; I <em>will</em> impose the evidence on my beliefs. I will constantly be open to changing my mind, just show me the money, let me check the evidence. I will seek solutions to the challenges of our times, and personal convenience can <em>not</em> be a factor.”</p><p>Some have argued that this is simply expecting too much, that it is asking for what <em>doesn’t</em> come naturally. Well, it is asking a fair bit, and it does indeed not come naturally measured at the level of simple animal instinct. But let’s ask a few more things.</p><p>We, like all creatures, have a lengthy history, deep roots. A hyena which ate really well the evening before, might wake up and think about getting a drink, or mating, or defending their turf, but it is not going to think about a vigorous chase to kill and eat. It doesn’t think about tomorrow, or next week — month — or year, never mind generations ahead. It operates on instincts which worked well when focused on the moment, the day.</p><p>Is that what we’re limited to? I respect and appreciate all life forms, but even elephants, dolphins, and the great apes, can’t ponder, re-evaluate, learn, and anticipate on anywhere near the level that we can. With a world this filled and stretched, consider substituting one word — they “… can’t ponder, re-evaluate, learn, and anticipate on anywhere near the level that we <em>Should</em>.” (instead of simply ‘can’)</p><p>I think we’re up to this; we can do it. We can learn from history. We can reach into the depths of our humanity and grow to go well beyond instinct. Chief Seattle is credited with saying that we ought to consider how our decisions and actions will affect the lives of our descendants seven generations from now. Do you think that is something which we should genuinely aspire to and actively work toward?</p><p>We each need to evaluate for ourselves the degree to which we are willing to accept and embrace this from Philosophy Professor Peter Boghossian, and determine how willing we are to apply it to our lives and our politics: “The only way to figure out which claims about the world are likely to be true, and which are likely to be false, is through reason and evidence. There is no other way.”</p><p>Hopefully it is by now clear how this all connects to honestly facing and then constructively figuring out, based again on the best evidence and any clear consensus developed by those best informed, <em>how</em> to approach doing things about key challenges in our times. This includes taking the long- and the broad- view of things from economic policies (in a world of rapidly accelerating mechanization including robotics, will we need to re-evaluate what we consider to be “a full-time job”?), to environmental policies and actions. The elephant in the room here is clearly that a very significant number of people who do have the habit of believing what they simply want to believe and of dismissing expertise if they don’t like its consensus, continue to follow that habit when even <em>considering</em> taking a second look at climate change. In part 1 of this instinct, people focus on perceived immediate risks and clearer lines of us vs. them (leading to near complete preoccupation with things like ISIS and foreign-based extremist Islamic terrorism while ignoring domestic homegrown white-male-Christian terrorism). In part 2, people ignore longer-term risks to “others” (including our own descendants). This demands our deliberate efforts to do what we <em>should</em> do in going beyond instinct to engage our human intellects, to deeply consider and to plan how to best move toward numerous aspects of sustainability. (Please resist the temptation to let that too-oft-used word slide off your brain… Do quality surroundings — measured socially, economically, and ecologically — for your descendants and their peers matter, or not?)</p><p>So, while I’m not interested in either protecting or attacking any or all religion, I am interested in us honestly evaluating when it has played the role of hurdle, preventing faster progress toward honestly facing evidence, and then effectively problem-solving. I am asking people who feel the need to stay with their faith, please consciously put effort into avoiding the key downsides to such. Resist falling for the habit of dismissing evidence you don’t happen to like, and doubling down on ideas you like even if you don’t have the best evidence and consensus behind them. If you wouldn’t like to live in a theocracy run by Muslims or Hindus or…, don’t try to impose your Christian religion on our broader society. Don’t be remotely quick to follow history’s pattern of jumping on board with a war effort when it should be obvious that all sides, including yours, are again using the notion that “our God is the ‘right’ God,” and then killing over that age-old idea. And don’t presume that a supernatural solution is going to make deliberate and not-always-easy environmental efforts unnecessary.</p><p>There are several hurdles to negotiate in even getting started up this hill of more honestly figuring out what is likely true. I’ve lived the majority of my life here in America surrounded by a generally Christian culture, and closely surrounded by many Christian relatives and friends. I’ve also lived though, for a good number of years of my life, surrounded by Hindus, and by Muslims, and had significant exposure to other belief systems. From this life experience I’ve seen that it’s quite natural for people to become well indoctrinated. I’m not labeling the people behind this as evil in any way; I’d call my parents good, loving, and well-intentioned people, and they indoctrinated me into the strong Christianity that pervaded more than three decades of my life. My point here is that we should recognize that since there clearly are cultures with very different starting points for what many use as their primary way of coming to believe that X is true, that <em>the assumption</em> that faith is a reliable and constructive tool for figuring what is likely true and where we stand, itself must be thoughtfully examined.</p><p>Inasmuch as this essay will at least initially be read by a primarily American audience, I will address elements of one of the first hurdles we encounter in seeking reasonably thorough and objective ways of figuring out what is true and where to stand — this hurdle is the case of modern American Christianity.</p><p>For a little bit here then I will be critiquing certain aspects of how a majority of our modern American rendition of Christianity has come to present their perception of reality. I’m going to proceed with the assumption that most of us would generally agree that internal consistency matters.</p><p>On this theme, I submit that at the center of Jesus’ message is this: Live a non-self-centered life (lay down your life; care for the least of these; turn the other cheek; love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you; etc.) which is Less prone to drawing lines which divide “us” vs. “them.” He said “enough already” with Jew vs. Gentile, or any other such junk. It was not rich vs. poor, it was the rich having some responsibilities to care for the poor, and not blow them off in some judgmental way. It is up to us to figure out how to constructively do that, but it certainly didn’t include corporate welfare while we whine about some imperfections (which do need work toward fixing) in individual welfare; and it did include health concerns and therefore care for all, with no objections if that care is somehow subsidized by the broader society. Can you actually imagine Jesus being against subsidized health care? And he added the illustration of the workers who showed up early and those who showed up late to the task getting paid the same. (Obviously that can be taken too literally and would have non-constructive results.) He clearly wasn’t against paying one’s taxes, and wasn’t remotely obsessed with resisting governmental authority, and he had abundant opportunity/excuses to do so and say so if he wanted us to spend our lives focused there. And beyond Jesus’ words, as Christianity evolved, we find the book of Acts clearly on-board with many aspects of socialism. Shouldn’t we ask: Are modern American Christians free to just glibly dismiss all of the above?</p><p>There are many non-Christians, not religious at all, who certainly seem to live less self-centered and more other-inclusive lives than many Christians. Can we recognize that much of modern American Christianity promotes sharp lines of “us” vs. “them” without so much as broadly based and deliberate efforts to build bridges to and with other people-groups unless it includes the drive or need to convert them to our “right” religion, and/or exploit their resources and labor?</p><p>Can we be more honest with these realities, or must we just persist with the age-old tendency to remake our version of God in our updated image?</p><p>Thus I would encourage modern American Christians to — Either: 1. Re-read and reconsider the central messages of Christianity and their applications to national and social policy, OR, 2. Go ahead and just declare that they want to draw any dividing lines they want (racial, sexual, religious, economic, etc.) as sharply as they want, without trying to justify narrow bigotry and prejudice with their religion. At least then we have honest advocacy of clear policy with the cards being laid on the table, the motives being much more transparent.</p><p>As is, we have a smoke-screen of mixed motives which may be coincidental for many modern individuals, but aren’t at all accidental when their roots are traced. A useful starting point would be to read “What’s the Matter with Kansas” and “One Nation Under God: How Corporate America Invented Christian America.” Yes, these are more than blog posts, but can we really afford to knowingly and willingly accept our stunted attention spans to the point that reading whole books is asking too much of ourselves?</p><p>So, why do I advocate for honesty even if some of that honesty would clearly be ugly? Because we at least reduce the likelihood of being fooled by wolves in sheep’s clothing, and then failing to meet the challenges of our times.</p><p>If your faith is irrevocably a central peg in your life, might I suggest that you could do some positives with it. Jesus’ words and the book of Acts are full of the “social gospel”. Why not put time and energy into that?</p><p>Finally, whether you identify as a conservative or progressive, don’t feel that your personal and natural reflexes are automatically good or bad, but do be willing to use our human intellect to learn from repeated patterns in history, to analyze our instincts, and to do better than an animal which can’t think about long-term impacts and future generations, let alone thoughtfully plan, using the best of information which we can get our hands on. We <em>can</em> thoughtfully and honestly consider the vital role that a slowly and painfully developed consensus among those best informed on any particular topic can and perhaps should play in helping all of us everyday folks figure out what is most likely true. Then we can better figure out where we should stand, and how we can use that perspective to collectively hire a crew which will make decisions to direct our ship of state away from the most perilous waters. With more ships of states also making farsighted and well informed decisions of direction, the influence on the direction and on the sustainability of civilization on our pale blue dot can only be good.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3648d479026" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Struggles with the Why behind Difficult Questions]]></title>
            <link>https://dougmatheson.medium.com/struggles-with-the-why-behind-difficult-questions-727d5e816126?source=rss-ca7de2e7e7d7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/727d5e816126</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[polarized-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cross-cultural-talk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fundamentalist-religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alternative-facts]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Doug Matheson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Jun 2018 19:14:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-12T22:05:18.394Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Struggles with the <em>Why</em> behind Difficult Questions</strong></p><p>Familiar words from Frost: “Two roads diverged in a wood, and I — I took the one less traveled by, and that has made all the difference.” After exploring together various mental trails, I want to circle back to focus on what fork in the road makes the most vital difference.</p><p>I spent the 2017–18 school-year in Oman. My friends and I there didn’t have the luxury of all being fluent in a single language as we do here. My circle of friends and acquaintances quickly included Indians and Pakistanis working there, for I had grown up in India, and still speak semi-functional Hindi. The limitations of my Hindi and my friends’ English did not, however, limit the things we <em>tried</em> to discuss. Gathered around a few cheap plastic tables outside a café on a street in the southern Omani city of Salalah, the follow-on conversations after a shared meal of delicious curry and roti were sometimes trivial, but sometimes probing, deep, and honest. Our combined linguistic shortcomings contributed to moments that ran the gamut from hilarious, to frustrating, to awkward.</p><p>It helped that when I did frequently need to resort to some English vocab, in that setting I reflexively did so in a south-asian accent which helped their understanding. If you’ve participated in or just listened to a conversation in which single sentences were seemingly random conglomerations of Spanish and English, Chinese and English, _____ and English, you can imagine our conversations. That circle of some of my meal-time friends provided me with various elements of food for thought, and contributed very preliminary answers to a casual bet I made with some American friends before going there.</p><p>In conversations with my local Omani friends, I didn’t have the Arabic ability to meet them half way as I did in Hindi, so I was limited to conversations with fairly English-fluent friends, several of which I made of adult students in my more advanced English classes.</p><p>In both of these conversational cases, I sometimes pushed the envelope of what some would consider wise when you’re the visitor in another country and culture. I found though that many will engage in honest conversation when it’s obvious you’re not lecturing and you’re not trying to assert sociocentric pride in your ‘superior’ country or culture, even if some of the questions you’re posing aren’t easy, and may be thought-provoking to the point of troubling.</p><p>One of my Omani students directly asked me, “Why do you discuss difficult things with some of us? And why do you give us honest answers when you know that answer will trouble us?” Why indeed would I be nutty enough to explore topics including science, politics, and religion, when those topics can make for rough sailing even when there are no linguistic or cultural hurdles to navigate?</p><p>My childhood in India was because my parents were missionaries, and I was educated in Christian schools until graduate school. Despite a loving Christian indoctrination, I came to realize that when beliefs and evidence are in contradiction, personal honesty requires imposing the evidence on one’s beliefs, and not the reverse. This path toward change and openness to new understanding was furthered by thought provoking experiences while teaching in Lebanon in 80–81, and doing public health work in Rwanda from 91 to April of 94 and the beginnings of the genocide.</p><p>As a young man in my mid-twenties, I was still confident that my God and my book were the “right” ones. When the fighting in Beirut flared, I asked my Lebanese students about who was fighting whom. It became clear that the notion of the crusades — that we will fight for, die for, and kill for, our “right” Gods — is beyond dusty history books, it is alive and well — and still leads to people bleeding out, from bullets and bombs if not swords and spears. This confidence in our various right gods clearly has a dark side with a long track record.</p><p>As I slowly re-evaluated <em>my truths</em>, I tried to tell myself that the years it was taking were because of intellectual patience, and not because of my desire to find ways to end up keeping those <em>truths</em>. I knew that the Scientific Revolution was fueled in part by the realization that it was not only <em>okay</em> to question everything, including what had been viewed as authority and tradition, it was <em>good</em> to question… and then to test our ideas with the best honest (controlled) experiments we could design. And finally, and perhaps most importantly, to then be willing to accept verifiable evidence, even when we don’t like what it points to, and thus be willing to recognize when we are wrong, and then to change our minds.</p><p>When exposed to Soren Kierkegaard’s observation that “There are two ways to be fooled. One is to believe what isn’t true. The other is to refuse to accept what is true,” I simply added the conscious question: What have the centuries shown to be our best tool for slowly but surely figuring out what <em>IS</em> true? It seemed obvious that it has not been the conflicting claims based in different books, proclaiming different gods. And it seemed equally obvious that it has been the application of the approach of science — putting our ideas to objective tests, and then respecting the evidence, and changing, updating, our always-temporary conclusions.</p><p>It seemed clear to me that the value of a science-like approach should also apply to and would offer benefits in the social sciences — from history, to economics, to sociology, to anthropology, and… something else. If I went there, I knew I’d be stepping in it.</p><p>After I had shed my religious filter for life’s information and decision-making processes, I spent about a decade and a half just keeping that to myself. For nearly all the people I knew well, this wasn’t a welcome conversation.</p><p>I had a new filter, what some would call a new bias. The track record of the approach of science, now with a half-millennium of history behind it, told me that this was the best and most honest (though not perfect) way to evaluate and re-evaluate information and to make decisions on where I would stand on issues. But I didn’t say anything to anyone about my internal change.</p><p>Many months after 9–11, as I watched our national focus shift away from al Qaeda and trying to capture bin Laden to the run-up to invading Iraq, I could read and hear which portion of America was urging caution and questioning the justifications used, and which portion of America was gung ho about getting on with this invasion. The strong confidence I had witnessed (and I had had) as a young man, that “My God” was the <em>right</em> god, and by extension that “Our Book” and “Our People” were also <em>right</em>, easily led to people rallying to war “For God and Country.” It was then that I realized that anything resembling fundamentalist religion was not only not the solution, it was core to our problems, our tendency to draw sharp lines of Us vs. Them, and then being willing to quickly and enthusiastically turn those lines into action.</p><p>I had seen localized levels of chaos in Beirut, and then seen more ugly and much broader chaos in the launch into the genocide in Rwanda in April of 1994, and so began to re-evaluate my silence.</p><p>In the sights and sounds and smell of death, I had seen the fabric of civilization significantly fray. I began to engage in conversation, to write and to speak. I couldn’t find a way to feel that I was being a responsible citizen of America or in a global sense, or even being a responsible dad to my kids, if I kept silent about the risks that tend to go with strong faith.</p><p>In addition to the risk that those of strong faith tend to be quick to jump on the bandwagon of war in the name of their god, I shared two additional risks. The second is that those of strong faith tend to believe that everything is in their god’s hands, that there is a supernatural solution coming, and therefore that we don’t need to take natural or man-made problems seriously much less urgently. The third is that those of strong faith tend to have formed the habit of believing what they want to believe, and expecting those beliefs to be respected, which they interpret as going unchallenged.</p><p>When a person has repeatedly experienced an absence of direct challenge to their particular articles of faith, it does become a fairly absolute expectation, and — here’s where it becomes very practical and problematic — it spreads from expecting religious beliefs to go unchallenged to expecting any number of personal beliefs to be respected, to be treated as equal alternatives, and to not be challenged.</p><p>I know a number of people of faith who manage to minimize to essentially zero the first two risks: more quickly jumping on the bandwagon of war in the name of their god, and dismissing problems because “It’s all in their god’s hands and there’s a supernatural solution coming.” But the third risk — that we habituate to believing what we want and expect personal beliefs of nearly every type to go unchallenged — is much more insidious, much harder to successfully self-monitor against.</p><p>Although I’ve lived and worked in a number of places, I recently completed a stretch of over two decades living and working in rural Oregon, and I’ve watched America’s recent drift toward increasing polarization. This is certainly multifactorial, but on all sides we must recognize that it is not constructive. To work toward reducing this means increasing real communication, and reducing our temptation toward several things: living in well insulated ideological echo chambers; equating opinions with facts; and expecting our beliefs to go unchallenged.</p><p>Some strenuously object to attempting to change the last point. They Want to be able to believe any X, and to have that respected, to go unchallenged. Some have said “So what if somebody believes in a flat earth, or young earth, or old earth, or intelligent design, or evolution? What difference does it make?”</p><p>That is an important<em>,</em> question. I worked on offering an answer while in Oman, and on my return to America… and I’m still working on it.</p><p>Today most countries have some degree of democracy. We citizens are “passengers on the ship.” We get to vote, and thus hire the crew which runs it. We can hire wise crews which consider the best of evidence in making decisions on how to avoid the worst of troubled waters and dangerous shoals, or we can hire crews with firm and immune-to-change opinions because they are immune-to-the-evidence if they don’t happen to already like it. This habituation to expecting our prior beliefs to be respected, to go unchallenged, shows up in very practical, concrete, ways.</p><p>Dismissing climate change has strong and direct parallels to dismissing the risks of tobacco (credit here to “Merchants of Doubt” by Naomi Oreskes), and this dismissal must be challenged. Dismissing the current risks to our national and global environment, air, land, and sea, must be challenged. Dismissing the destructive challenges to democracy posed by easy money, corrupting money, in politics, must be challenged. Dismissing the distinction between fact and opinion, between real/verifiable fact and alternative ‘fact’ must be challenged. Dismissing the risks of unnecessary and easily exacerbated cultural conflicts must be challenged. We can and must learn to move past the fairly human obsession with competing with ‘others.’ On a crowded planet with stressed ecosystems, meeting the sheer scale of the challenges of our times is going to require figuring out how to cooperate in meeting and solving our mutual problems.</p><p>I feel I should clarify here what I’ve clarified many times, in many places. I am not advocating that everyone should just become straight-up atheists. I am advocating that people of any and every faith should moderate their faiths (recognizing that they could have been born into a culture and faith they now consider to be their worst enemy), and should consciously and actively self-monitor against these three risks so as to prevent the risks becoming realities. We can do better at the honest problem-solving and the cooperation needed to meet the scale of today’s problems.</p><p>Both in America and around those plastic tables outside my regular café in Salalah, I asked a few extended questions. The first is, “What is the greatest determinant of most people’s faiths?”</p><p>After some conversation, which sometimes meanders, but other times cuts right to the chase, we reach a consensus that it is the coincidence of birth… the family, culture, and century into which a person is born. We’ve illustrated this truth in <em>time</em> with Thor, Zeus, etc., and in <em>culture</em> with India-Pakistan, Iran-Saudi Arabia-Israel, Thailand, Mexico, and more. It isn’t comfortable, but people get it.</p><p>The second question involves a more extended illustration.</p><p>I’ve asked my discussion partners to imagine a big hotel to which we bring two people of every faith on earth, including the many offshoots of all those faiths. From each faith, one of the two people must be a top priest, rabbi, scholar, mullah — highly educated in his faith’s literature and dogma; the second person need not be a scholar, but should have a reasonable general education and be a very sincere believer.</p><p>These hundreds of people of faith, arranged in their pairs, are told that they will be provided with a comprehensive library, internet access, and food and water, and asked to create an initial document listing 50 central, important, beliefs of their faith, while including distinguishing beliefs which make their faith different. “You will all be locked in the hotel until you have met and discussed enough to persuade each other on what “truth” is so that you can write out an agreement on One list of 50 truths which at least 95% of you agree to.”</p><p>“When will they come out of the hotel?” I ask.</p><p>They always smile and say, “Never.”</p><p>I then ask them to imagine a second hotel, to which we bring scientists who have various disagreements on broad or specific ideas held within science today.</p><p>These scientists make their lists of 50 things they hold to be true, again including some that are distinguishing (on which they disagree with others). Again, they are provided with food and water, and library and internet, and laboratory equipment and space as needed, and then locked into this continuous science conference of a hotel where they can meet, argue, go back to their labs for weeks, months, or years, and meet some more. They are told that they can come out when their current lists have changed to where at least 95% of them agree on One list.</p><p>Again, I’ve asked when they’ll come out. My discussion buddies have each time been insightful enough to note that while they might be stuck there for years, even for decades, that they wouldn’t be stuck there forever. They’ve seemed to know that while science isn’t perfect, and there are strong egos and disagreements, that science produces a forward movement as it develops consensus around ideas which are very well supported by verifiable evidence.</p><p>In both America and in Oman, the group response to these two questions and illustrations is neither completely uniform nor always good humored. I’ve seen people sit in stone-faced silence as others participated in lively discussion.</p><p>Now, you may remember a casual bet I mentioned at the outset of this conversation. As I contemplated my options on ending a career as a science and then history teacher, I looked around at America’s increasing divides. I’d heard various Americans dismiss Muslims as close-minded and dangerous as a whole group while considering themselves to be enlightened and open-minded. It occurred to me that I could teach English in the Middle East, and live among and work with these Muslims. My casual bet was that I would find close-minded Muslims, <em>But</em> that I would also find open-minded ones, and that it wouldn’t be starkly different than in our good ol’ U.S. of A.</p><p>I’ve seen individuals doing open and honest exploration, with puzzled reevaluation-in-process written clearly on their faces in both America and Oman. <em>And</em> I’ve seen that stone-faced silent resentment of any challenge to one’s beliefs, and a clear unwillingness to even contemplate change in both our culture and theirs.</p><p>Some would point out that I didn’t pick to go try this informal study surrounded by ISIS, and indeed I didn’t. But I would point out that I’m not comparing this to the Westboro Baptist Church either. Further, and more importantly, fundamentalist evangelical Christianity makes up a Much, Much, greater fraction of America’s society than ISIS does within Islam.</p><p>Can we learn that (to quote Sen. DPM) “We’re all entitled to our own opinions, but we’re not entitled to our own facts”? Can we face the fact that some claims about reality (some beliefs) are indeed checkably connected to reality, and some Are Not? This fact is central to what makes opinions Not all equal.</p><p>Among those in both cultures whose first reaction is resentful silence, some have hung around and ended up expressing themselves, and after I’ve listened to them, some of them have done a little more listening. I’ve shared that while I realize that I’m stepping on toes and it’s often not welcome, that if the Titanic (yes, they know that movie in Oman too) is headed for an iceberg and many passengers are preoccupied with sipping their tea and enjoying the beautiful sounds of a string quartet, that efforts toward alerting more of the passengers and then hiring a crew which pays deliberate attention to verifiable facts might turn out a lot better than not disturbing the peace until it is too late to make a difference.</p><p>In our recently more polarized American culture, some Facebook friends have posted fact-checkably wrong info, and when I challenged the point of their post, they’ve asked me to quietly move on if I don’t like something they post. I’ve responded by encouraging them to challenge me if and when they feel I’m factually wrong, or on the wrong side of history. It has made little difference. It’s as if too many now actually <em>Prefer</em> their self- and technology-made echo-chamber. In order to be left alone in theirs, they offer the bargaining chip of leaving you alone in yours.</p><p>This is the something else I referred to stepping in. Politics is ostensibly forbidden territory around the Thanksgiving table, but it has also become off limits if what you’re about to do is break into a person’s or a group’s echo-chamber with other information or perspective. If we’re going to avoid the troubled waters and dangerous shoals our ship — or the whole ship of civilization — could face, we <em>need</em> informed, concerned, involved, and aware fellow-passengers who can and will engage in constructive conversations based in real, verifiable, facts. These conversations can’t be expected to be easy or comfortable, but they can be civilized, and connected to checkable evidence in science and real lessons from history.</p><p>Here we are. I know people who genuinely think that other people of faith X or Y are thoroughly evil and must be fought, or are simply badly deluded and must not be accepted or allowed freedom, <em>While</em> they think that their unique beliefs are right and make them part of this God’s special people. They won’t engage in an attempt at public dialogue on how we establish truth, won’t thoughtfully challenge (very different than dismissing) other belief systems because they don’t want their own challenged… but they’ll support a general cultural war <em>and</em> a military one aimed primarily at those ‘other’ people.</p><p>Among the many forks in the road of life, at which intersection is it that our choice can make the most vital difference? I submit that it is this: every time <em>we</em> — as individuals or as societies — realize that there is a contradiction between what we believe, what we claim as our truth, and what the best evidence and consensus around it says, we have a choice… we can try to impose our beliefs on the evidence by dismissing, manipulating, selecting from among it, OR, we can impose the evidence on our beliefs, being willing to recognize that we had been wrong, and then updating, changing our minds, and moving constructively forward.</p><p>This isn’t necessarily easy, it doesn’t come naturally; so, considering the intensity of some of the arguments this may generate, we have to ask if it matters. What difference does it make? Well, any scientist who won’t impose the evidence on his or her prior beliefs, and change their mind, won’t be able to honestly and effectively solve problems, and will become irrelevant in their field. And, with the scale of our challenges today, if enough concerned citizens won’t step up to this level of honesty, we too won’t effectively solve problems, and civilization itself will become irrelevant.</p><p>I am sure that we Can do better, and that we Must do better. I continue to explore, to push frontiers, to ask uncomfortable questions, to see what we’re willing to consider, to learn, and I check for the ways in which we’re willing to change. And I challenge any fellow-citizen, any thinking fellow-human anywhere, if you want to consider yourself to be honest and open-minded, let’s walk our talk; at that fork in the road, let’s take the right road until it becomes the one <em>more</em> traveled. That will make all the difference.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=727d5e816126" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>