<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Tom Maddox on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Tom Maddox on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@dthomasmaddox?source=rss-6fdb107e2469------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 20:02:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@dthomasmaddox/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Us Here, Now and Then]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dthomasmaddox/us-here-now-and-then-a7d877a0723c?source=rss-6fdb107e2469------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a7d877a0723c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pleasure-dome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anne-carson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[laurie-anderson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parietal-caves]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spectacles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Maddox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Jun 2018 01:37:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-16T02:08:30.888Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jPElOmMfj8Yf8s_p.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*7-ZA2sv8URPGQ9NNbkOSQw.png" /></figure><h3>Part 1. <br>The Dome, Hungry Ghosts, the Spectacle,</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/568/1*71_c-aOMSNri8cbKOll8oQ.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>What is the Pleasure Dome made of?</em></strong><br> <em>Everything and nothing: particles of energy; images; structures; machinery; hallucinations; exaltations; terrors; carnival “rides”; live sex; prayer services in front of thousands, maybe millions; athletic contests; restaurants; opium dens … really, whatever excites you or makes you euphoric.</em></p><p><strong><em>When is it open?</em></strong><br> <em>Always.</em></p><p><strong><em>Who is it for?</em></strong><br> <em>Everyone.</em></p><p><strong><em>What can I do there?</em></strong><br> <em>Make your desires explicit, refine and enjoy them.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*4lDwr-kkXFwW0TNz8lWSww.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Can I take drugs?<br></em></strong><em>Of course. Their effects can greatly enhance your experience of the Dome.</em></p><p><strong>What if I die?</strong><br><em>It’s complicated. Drugs, accidents, coronary arrest or other medical misfortunes</em> — <em>specific calamities can seldom be predicted. The consequences of particular deaths are unknowable.</em></p><p><strong><em>Who owns it?</em></strong><br> <em>That is not your concern.</em></p><p><strong><em>What is the entry fee?</em></strong><br><em>None, immediately. There is a condition: You must be accompanied at all times by your hungry ghost. Depending on circumstance — this happens on an individual basis, without malice — you might lose everything you did have, do have, will have, could have.</em></p><p>_________________________________________________</p><p><strong><em>A hungry ghost posed to me its own question. I suspect it may have been in a dream, but I’m not sure.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*-Kj7ul4xvCXmKhFXjxZEFQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Hungry Ghosts Watched Over by Bodhisattva</strong></figcaption></figure><p>A classic hungry ghost from Chinese and Japanese stories, he wore only a loincloth with a distended stomach hanging above it. His hair squirreled off in several directions; his lips smacked, and his tongue darted in and out, and his attention frantically shifted from place to place — and thing to thing, person to person, image to image.</p><p>He asked me, “What am I?” He repeated his question a number of times, quickly, compulsively. He was frantic along several axes — gestures, grimaces and tics, stuttering speech — an ensemble of unfilled needs twitching constantly. Like a corrupted video image, he jittered; then the signal recovered, and he came into deep focus … then jittered again, then refocused …</p><p>The only answer I had for him was this: Wrap distraught frenzy in a skin, compel it to fill needs that can’t be filled, and you have the ongoing existence of a hungry ghost. Terribly long periods of time and ultimate mercy can stop the frenzy — these or extinction, in whatever form; remember, there have been five extinctions that we know of, that erased almost all life from the Earth. Time is long, and living creatures are mayflies.</p><p><strong><em>However, our hungry ghosts, here and now, are of a somewhat different kind than the traditional one. These are formed from data that once existed only as records in dataspace, everything about each of us that can be digitized wanders through the Pleasure Dome, held together loosely by our names and numbers.</em></strong></p><p>In this ghostly mode, we are <em>uncanny</em>, very lifelike but <em>off</em>: we are ensembles of data seen from varying perspectives, constantly examined for possible manipulation and use, in endless growth as data are added. Machines see us clearly, as do organizations that use the clear-seeing machines. With human beings, we are of course products of our embodied existence and thus are poorly seen.</p><p>As hungry ghosts, we are haunters, and though built of data we crave something but aren’t sure what — incessantly, frantically, pathetically grasping at every shiny thing we hope we can possess, or that we believe will gratify us by its presence, its shiny and fluttering shapes, its unceasing musics, its seeming freedom across space and time. The shiny things can be images or material or something in between, like “apps” on smart phones or in various expressive decorations. Some appear inside us as visions or dreams or episodes that excite or depress us. It doesn’t matter.</p><p>When digital worlds came into existence, they escalated and intensified the fundamental power of the Pleasure Dome, which grew like the sphere of an explosion, a nuclear one. These worlds are now rewriting our lives; they have their own logic and power, their own narratives, their own effects, unknowable before their inception and now woven into our lives in ubiquitous and surprising ways, transforming and dislocating, promising more surprises constantly to come.</p><p>As I’ve implied, they are the software for all the amusements in the Pleasure Dome — places, processes, carnival rides, image streams, videogames, dens, virtual and real, <em>every kind of stimulation</em> <em>and distraction</em> — constantly becoming more disorienting and nauseating, more capable of inducing sexual arousal, generalized ecstasy, hypnosis, terror, and nausea, among other states. It’s an ever shifting and growing field of existing and possible sensations, images chief among them. Rimbaud’s “systematic derangement of all the senses” describes it all nicely, but no poetic vision is being served; derangements and distractions are ends, not means.</p><p><strong><em>Where mermaids sing each to each, and they will sing to you. Guaranteed.</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/0*xhTO2kQgHzH5SoFw" /></figure><p>There is beauty, noises to soothe and excite us and to trigger memories that are variously cherished, fading, fictive — created for us in the mass and as single, fleshly creatures. And of course the spaces of the Pleasure Dome are mined with triggers for our instinctual pleasures at their most urgent — for instance, sex presented in various guises to excite our rawest fancies and fetishes; shrieking fear; revulsion; defilement.</p><p>The fabric of everyone’s lives around the globe is disintegrating because of a continual rewrite of the human world, materially, intellectually, morally, sensuously, perceptually; because of the ascendance of the dome and our ghosts’ places in it. The ghosts cannot be quieted, cannot find any peace, and so by virtue of our mysterious manifestations as ghosts, neither can we.</p><p>We are addicted to distraction, in our flesh or out of it. No matter what we have, we <em>want</em> more, we <em>need</em> more.</p><p>When Aldous Huxley’s <em>Brave New World </em>was<em> </em>written in 1932, there were few mass technologies. Huxley nonetheless saw <em>us</em> with weird accuracy; foresaw our ceaseless pursuit of amusement as we chase shiny things like cats jumping at tens of thousands of laser dots on a wall. Unlike the cats, however, we don’t lose interest or grow tired; we continue to jump and bat at the innumerable shiny things that come our way, a number that increases with every minute in number and distractive capacity. The Distracted Cat might be the familiar of the Pleasure Dome.</p><p>Television had already arrived when <em>Brave New World</em> was written, though in nascent form. But the television networks, spawning from radio networks, shortly came into being, and they discovered a simple and lasting model: present new and changing amusements, advertise products, reap the profits. TV evolved like a radioactive mutant in a comic book into larger and sharper devices, the networks that fed it multiplying like honey fungus, supplying more and more various stimulations to an insatiable and constantly expanding number of needs.</p><p>With the coming of computer networks and the rapid invention and spread of the technologies of image and sound, TV’s children filled the Internet, beginning with the web, making available information in every form — print, audio, video, virtual reality, archives of the past and inducements to certain futures. We could only watch TV passively, while pretending to share in the intimacy of the millions. But the evolved Pleasure Dome allows us the more compelling illusion of being part of the screen, of playing along, of helping create our own amusements — these are delusions, seductive ones, and hungry ghosts are quickly drawn to them and by them, though they find no satisfaction.</p><p>Some thought deeply about the evolution of television and image production. Daniel Boorstin, a conservative historian, says:</p><blockquote>We are haunted, not by reality, but by those images we have put in place of reality. These [pseudo-events] are events staged and presented as though something important were happening. Reality, by anyone’s measure, is less telegenic, less entertaining, less coherent than the pseudo-events. Images show the pseudo-event as they believe we want to see them: meaningful, perfectly filmed and edited, “hosted” by explainers who function as shills for the events themselves. Images and sound are the dynamos of their hypnotic power.</blockquote><blockquote>What we need first and now is to disillusion ourselves.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Deniel Boorstin, The Image</em></blockquote><p>Imagine that, <em>disillusioning ourselves</em>, the selves that have wrapped themselves in illusions. Illusions hold us together; for each of us, they can even become a <em>brand</em> — the individual as brand being one of the most insidious, ghostly, and ghastly ideas of our time — for branded persons, disillusion would be disintegration as they shattered into millions of pieces.</p><p>What are our illusions made of? Guy Debord, a French Marxist revolutionary, says:</p><blockquote>In societies where modern conditions of production prevail, life is presented as an immense accumulation of spectacles. Everything that was directly lived has receded into a representation.</blockquote><p>Guy Debord, <em>The Society of the Spectacle</em></p><p>The Pleasure Dome comprises the accumulation of spectacles. Our experiences of the Spectacle also combine with other pleasures. Now we can satisfy our connoisseurship of many psychoactive states, some beyond euphoria and hallucination, even at the borders between life and death, a special set of places to explore, for instance, in the pursuit of opiated delight, arrangements particularly inviting to the ghosts and also to the sad beings for whom opiates-with-death are preferable to lives-without-opiates. A little of <em>Brave New World’s</em> soma would fit right in but couldn’t take top billing — our pharmaceuticals are far more evolved than the book’s.</p><p>As Debord explains, the spectacle is effective as the most powerful form of commodity fetishism: a notion that was first presented in Karl Marx’s <em>Capital</em> and has remained one of the most persuasive and far-seeing of Marx’s ideas.</p><blockquote>It is nothing but the definite social relation between men themselves which assumes here, for them, the fantastic form of a relation between things. In order, therefore, to find an analogy we must take flight into the misty realm of religion. There the products of the human brain appear as autonomous figures endowed with a life of their own, which enter into relations both with each other and with the human race.<br> (Karl Marx, <em>Capital, Part 1, Chapter 1, Section 4)</em></blockquote><p>Setting aside the economic mechanisms that drive these relationships, the phenomenon described here is “the fantastic form of a relation between things.” From this grows our involvement with things, real and illusory, as objects of desire, and from that grows the spectacle:</p><blockquote>The fetishism of the commodity — the domination of society by “intangible as well as tangible things” — attains its ultimate fulfillment in the spectacle, where the real world is replaced by a selection of images which are projected above it, yet which at the same time succeed in making themselves regarded as the epitome of reality. <br> (Debord, <em>Society of the Spectacle)</em></blockquote><p>Material things may be involved in any scene of the Spectacle, but they need not be. We may be dealing with pure manifestations of the imaginary. Hence the nature of the Pleasure Dome: real to the point of injury and death; absolutely illusory to any degree that illusions can be created and broadcast.</p><p><strong>Commodity fetishism → the Spectacle → the Pleasure Dome … <br>repeated endlessly</strong></p><p>To understand some subtleties of this relationship, let’s examine a pervasive and successful feature of the Spectacle. Consider an automobile commercial done in video: its colors are super-saturated, with intensities seldom if ever seen in real life; the motions of the vehicles in it flow along diagonals, the most exciting of vectors — upward and downward at a slant because normal horizontals are boring (and verticals are science fiction). In the ads, the shoppers browse showrooms that are little capsules of the consumer universe. The showrooms gleam as the vehicles do, and car sellers stand ready to inform the shoppers — who may be canny or dopey, clued in or clueless — about whom the relevant fact is that they <em>may</em> be persuaded to buy a vehicle. The stakes are high for the salesperson, who is really present in order to usher the shoppers into the beautiful fictions and to see that the offered pleasures are experienced so they can take hold.</p><p>Once the prospective buyers are sent on the way, either to take a “test drive” of the vehicle or to take possession of it, the video ads show them possessed by joy at the wheel of the vehicle. They steer along the strangely diagonal highways, through cities of romance, where buildings shine in the night and beautiful strangers watch their passing with interest and commendation, across expanses of desert where sand boils around them, or along cliff side vistas where they can drive without hindrance above beautiful blue ocean.</p><p>The consumers are aroused, wet and tumescent: how could they not be? Perhaps they have orgasms on their fantasy rides, perhaps not — the ads coyly withhold in this regard. Mostly, though, the shoppers are in love with the experience of being in image love — with vehicles, vistas, seeming cascades of possibility and joy beyond end — a concentrated and freebased fetishism delivered by the Spectacle. They don’t concern themselves overly with the brute facts of car purchase and ownership and the real-world experiences of driving and maintenance — why should they? — but with enchantments focused on desire.</p><p>Our relationship to these dense moments of the Spectacle is driven by <em>our desire invested in the network of images and sounds that bind us to our goods, real or imaginary, to what we acquire or want to acquire or think we can acquire.</em> It is the infrastructure that makes the Pleasure Dome possible.</p><p>Guy Debord says that when we look at its face, we do not see the Spectacle’s essential nature, its structures, its goals, its cultural totality: if seen, they would interfere with the Spectacle’s presentation of itself. They would break the spell, and in the Spectacle, the spell is prized above all. This relationship between commodity fetishism and the Spectacle holds together the consumer economy. Marketing and advertising have become mechanisms of sensory-rich abduction that never speak their true aims.</p><p>As we relax and watch the play of light and form and listen to the music and noises, the presenters of the episodes pick our pockets, rifle through our private belongings, discover our secrets or expose our little privacies, search our homes, and do their very best to ensnare us in networks whose ostensible purposes can be anything from “friendship,” to dating, to ill-defined “sharing” but whose real purpose is to create false communities of desire which we can “share” only through selling our selves. Literally: as many have pointed out, <em>we</em> are the payment for the pleasures we purchase.</p><p>What do we know about the evolution of these things? Not much. In such domains there is very little that once would have been called “news.” As Neil Postman repeats in various ways, in books such as <em>Amusing Ourselves to Death</em>, when the news must be entertaining, it changes into entertainment, whose practices, virtues, and defects are very different from the news as we once knew and experienced it. And entertainment, meanwhile, has metamorphosed into incessant distraction.</p><p>How this immense series of distractions penetrates into how we read, think, and criticize — perhaps rendering them strangely different — is a deeper, more mysterious question, one whose answers are emerging as the years of distraction move along, though ultimate outcomes remain in doubt.</p><p>However, as is clear at this point, things are much worse than the mere metamorphosis of news into entertainment. Television represented an enormous leap beyond print and audio cultures and, of course, prepared the ground for the deluge, for the Internet and the Web and all that has come with it — including, for dazzling example, smart phones, which represent the ultimate development of the Spectacle …</p><p>For the moment. If the purveyors of the Spectacle have their way, implants and enhanced realities are on the way, promising an infinite capacity for amusement and further distance from the real, from reason, evidence, critical questioning and analysis, even simple understanding.</p><p>Here’s my guess: if we cannot master Huxley’s “infinite appetite for destruction,” then we likely cannot escape the worst that could happen, whatever it is. Through our addictions to amusement, perhaps we won’t consume the products of the Spectacle; perhaps they will consume us.</p><p><strong>Part II. When Your Thought Moves</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*6EKc7UKE6LCExh5SAoio2Q.png" /></figure><blockquote>Caves discovered recently in Spain show 65,000 year old Neanderthal art; Alistair Pike, an archaeologist at the University of Southampton, UK, who co-authored the report on these caves, says: “It wasn’t simply decorating your living space. People were making journeys into the darkness.”<br> Emma Marris, “Neanderthal artists made oldest-known cave paintings”<br> &lt;https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-02357-8&gt;</blockquote><blockquote>The attributes of liminality or of liminal personae (“ threshold people”) are necessarily ambiguous … Liminal entities are neither here nor there; they are betwixt and between the positions assigned and arrayed by law, custom, convention, and ceremonial … Thus, liminality is frequently likened to death, to being in the womb, to invisibility, to darkness, to bisexuality, to the wilderness, and to an eclipse of the sun or moon.<br> Victor Turner, <em>The Ritual Process</em></blockquote><blockquote>It was pitch black; there were, for some reason, no lights. Some of the children actually have families, but [are] not safe at home and so [are] sent by their parents to this place instead. There were no real activities for them; they seemed to spend a lot of time just being in this dark room.<br> Debra Efroymson<br><em> &lt;https://healthbridge.ca/blog/entry/joy-in-darkness&gt;</em></blockquote><p>Around<em> </em>70,000 years ago, something seems to have happened to <em>Homo sapiens</em>, often called the Cognitive Revolution. In <em>Sapiens: a Brief History of Humankind</em>, Yuri Harari describes what he thinks it was and why it was important. The source of the change was language, a particular capability of it, he maintains. From the time in a group’s existence when they could speak it to one another, worlds opened to <em>homo sapiens </em>because they could talk about fictions.</p><blockquote>[T]he truly unique feature of our language is not its ability to transmit information about men and lions. Rather, it’s the ability to transmit information about things that do not exist at all. As far as we know, only Sapiens can talk about entire kinds of entities that they have never seen, touched or smelled. Legends, myths, gods and religions appeared for the first time with the Cognitive Revolution.</blockquote><p>Stories, fictions — not lies or deceptions. Harari says:</p><blockquote>[F]iction has enabled us not merely to imagine things, but to do so collectively. We can weave common myths such as the biblical creation story, the Dreamtime myths of Aboriginal Australians, and the nationalist myths of modern states. Such myths give Sapiens the unprecedented ability to cooperate flexibly in large numbers.</blockquote><p>Some believe these tales to be true. I wish them luck but consider the stories Harari invokes to be neither true nor false but fiction, which can enable the imagination simply by beginning with some statement or context that announces, “Once upon a time,” or “Think of it this way,” or some other codified phrase: “Sing, muse, in me.”</p><p>What follows these phrases is not a lie; it is a story intended to amuse and instruct us, often to communicate individual visions and imaginations. Without them, human beings wouldn’t have amounted to much, thinks Harari. As do I.</p><p>When Richard Feynman drew the diagrams of sub-atomic particles that came to be named after him, he was not drawing the things themselves; he was imagining their portraits, ones that like so many great portraits revealed truths about their objects. His fictions became canonical in quantum mechanics, natural and understandable ways of picturing sub-particle interactions, which can occur and disappear so quickly that they are virtual, nor real, and they are simultaneously enormously intricate and, because of the deeply weird and only partly understood nature of the world of quantum interaction, unreasonable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/336/1*Ow-F84GIH4OxmDgNPj-DSA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Two electrons exchange a photon.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The most useful fictions create a space where criteria of truth and falsehood are shaped by the needs of the fiction, the story, its expressions and form, not constrained by our criteria for truth and falsehood, whatever the time, place, or domain, whatever the standards. However, fictions that enable thought experiments and hypotheses can choose to include elements of the real, in fact, must do so to be effective at all. Portraits represent what they portray: <em>mimesis</em>.</p><p>In my own telling, the next step in this story comes around 65,000 or more years ago, when people began to decorate the walls of caves with images — pictures implicitly connecting through what the artists chose to paint or sculpt, implying tales though having no way to communicate them directly to us. The stories’ meanings are utterly imponderable but obviously portray the world and the creatures in it.</p><blockquote>I dig out beautiful caves behind my characters; I think that gives exactly what I want; humanity, humor, depth. The idea is that the caves shall connect, &amp; each comes to daylight at the present moment …</blockquote><blockquote>It took me a year’s groping to discover what I call my tunneling process, by which I tell the past by installments, as I have need of it.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Virginia Woolf, </em>A Writer’s Diary<em><br> 30 August 1923</em></blockquote><p>Early on in the caves’ history millennia ago, red dots or images of hands began to appear, also cryptic markings. Then came figurative images, on cave walls around the world: typically of animals, though there are a small number of human and therianthropic figures.</p><p><strong>The Toros of Altimira</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/340/1*BXdrOJrZ93VoggzOgmwnZw.png" /></figure><p>In the Nineteenth Century, we — that is, sapiens, current iteration — began finding cave art and trying to make sense of what we found. In 1879, five-year-old Maria de Sautuola, accompanying her father inside a cave on his property announced, “Toros! Toros!” pointing to the many bison on the ceiling of what is now called Altamira Cave, in Northern Spain near the French border.</p><p>And so the modern age of cave art discovery began. We have found, explored, named, and celebrated caves, especially in France and Spain: Chauvet, Lascaux, Altamira, Trois-Frères, for instance, that I think of as cathedrals, but around the world there are hundreds more — smaller, less esthetically overwhelming perhaps; chapels if you will — on all continents except Antarctica.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/369/1*UMKq8IQKbjyVyJzsL_aHTQ.png" /></figure><p>Most of the cave images are of animals, predators and prey. The oldest figurative image found to date is of a “babirussa” or <strong>“</strong>cave pig bear,<strong>”</strong> also known at times as a “cave pig deer,” from Indonesia. The dating process tells that this image of a babirussa is 39,900 years old.</p><p>And here are panels from Chauvet Cave, with some of the most evocative images of all.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*91Rj72oQfTYgoSdiDT5GQQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*KJWxbN3fEJlfp5g7AXk8hQ.png" /></figure><p>We find the cave art compelling, hypnotic. We recognize ourselves in it and it in ourselves. And beyond the circumstances that caused the artists to paint the cave walls — which in the older caves we know nothing of — we have come to understand that the creators of them invented and passed to us the essential tools of visual art:</p><blockquote>After a visit to Lascaux, Picasso reportedly said to his guide, “They’ve invented everything.” What those first artists invented was a language of signs … perspective, a technique that was not rediscovered until the Athenian Golden Age; and a bestiary of such vitality and finesse that, by the flicker of torchlight, the animals seem to surge from the walls, and move across them like figures in a magic lantern show (in that sense, the artists invented animation). They also thought up the grease lamp — a lump of fat, with a plant wick, placed in a hollow stone — to light their workplace; scaffolds to reach high places; the principles of stenciling and Pointillism; powdered colors, brushes, and stumping cloths; and, more to the point of Picasso’s insight, the very concept of an image. A true artist reimagines that concept with every blank canvas — but not from a void.</blockquote><p><em>The New Yorker</em>, “Letter from Southern France,” June 23, 2008, Judith Thurman</p><p>All over the world parietal art (art on cave walls), continues to be discovered, and dates for the creation of the art continue to be pushed back in time. The discovery of the Chauvet caves rewrote the origin in time of parietal art; the Indonesian caves, home to our pig bear, pushed the origin even further back. Then the discovery of parietal art attributed to Neanderthals pushed the dates even further back, to 65,000 years ago.</p><p>Here is an example of Neanderthal cave art, with glyphs that seem to imply a logographic communication :</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/449/1*i6IuKY8QMBFhuZPwdX_cjg.png" /></figure><p>We sometimes call prehistoric sapiens “cavemen” — like the archeologists who for years dismissed the prehistoric dating of the Altimira art. They believed strongly that sapiens from that time were “savages” and could not have created such beauty. Marcelino Sanz de Sautuola, discoverer of Altimira, died still accused of being a fraud or a dupe, the beauty of the caves scorned. Not long after, the dating of the caves as prehistoric was confirmed. I regard this as a cautionary tale for those who think they understand the caves and their history.</p><p>To find cavemen and to understand them, we might look to ourselves, to our own caves, both real and fictive.</p><p><em>Once upon a time, </em>near 380 B. C., Plato wrote <em>The Republic</em>, which contains his allegory of the cave. He didn’t know anything of Upper Paleolithic cave art; he didn’t know anything of the evolution of visual art yet to come; certainly knew nothing of the image and sound technology of our time. In sum, he can tell us nothing directly of cave art that will help us understand its past or future. Yet for me, his allegory forms a hinge between 65,000 years ago, let’s say, and now. It points in directions Plato could not have foreseen.</p><p>Here is the heart of the allegory:</p><blockquote><strong>The Cave</strong></blockquote><blockquote>SOCRATES: Imagine this: People live under the earth in a cavelike dwelling. Stretching a long way up toward the daylight is its entrance, toward which the entire cave is gathered. The people have been in this dwelling since childhood, shackled by the legs and neck. Thus they stay in the same place so that there is only one thing for them to look at: whatever they encounter in front of their faces. But because they are shackled, they are unable to turn their heads around.</blockquote><blockquote>A fire is behind them, and there is a wall between the fire and the prisoners</blockquote><blockquote>SOCRATES: Some light, of course, is allowed them, namely from a fire that casts its glow toward them from behind them, being above and at some distance. Between the fire and those who are shackled [i.e., behind their backs] there runs a walkway at a certain height. Imagine that a low wall has been built the length of the walkway, like the low curtain that puppeteers put up, over which they show their puppets.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>The images carried before the fire</strong></blockquote><blockquote>SOCRATES: So now imagine that all along this low wall people are carrying all sorts of things that reach up higher than the wall: statues and other carvings made of stone or wood and many other artifacts that people have made. As you would expect, some are talking to each other [as they walk along] and some are silent.…</blockquote><blockquote><strong>What the prisoners see and hear</strong></blockquote><blockquote>SOCRATES: What do you think? From the beginning people like this have never managed, whether on their own or with the help by others, to see anything besides the shadows that are [continually] projected on the wall opposite them by the glow of the fire.</blockquote><blockquote>GLAUCON: How could it be otherwise, since they are forced to keep their heads immobile for their entire lives?</blockquote><blockquote>SOCRATES: And what do they see of the things that are being carried along [behind them]? Do they not see simply these [namely the shadows]?</blockquote><p><em>The Republic,</em> Plato, Book Seven. Thomas Sheehan trans.</p><p>As the prisoners sit focused on the projected images, one of them has his chains removed, is shown the structure of his cave, and is brought to daylight and thrust into world outside.</p><p>Adventures ensue. He goes through the many difficulties presented by the bright, sunlit world and his discovery of the many falsities of his beliefs and understandings. Ultimately he decides to return to the cave and tell the prisoners all the truths he has discovered.</p><p>Socrates believes this would end in tragedy. Untutored, naïve, the returning prisoner who tried to liberate the prisoners would be killed. Many who remain prisoners will continue to kill anyone who tries to release them and take them to the world outside.</p><p>I’ll ask you to set aside for the moment the chains holding the prisoners’ gaze to the cave wall in front of them and to remember that the prisoners gaze at <em>images</em>, and that the images are presented by <em>puppeteers</em>. Put it another way, the <em>prisoners could be watching TV</em> … or a movie or animation or a videogame or any other stream of images from our time.</p><p>Unlike Plato’s prisoners, we have no chains but gaze willingly at the fascinating image streams. We crave the distractions of the stream, composed of local channels of the Pleasure Dome, roughly speaking. In our time the caves have been fitted with sound, the images transformed into three dimensions — and both sight and sound media are constantly improved. And of course they have been made comfortable, with couches and easy chairs, drinks and snacks, enhanced by drugs of choice.</p><p>But Plato did not understand the world to come. He had his point to make about where truth can be seen, which is that our sensations could give us only a limited view of the world while the forms behind perceptions, properly understood, especially through the twisty applications of philosophical dialogue, can show us the truth.</p><p>But we can’t discover something beyond the image stream by escaping to the the world outside our caves , where the Pleasure Dome dominates. Consider that we might need to escape into the caves further below, dark or barely lit spaces, suspect terrain full of shape shifters. If we escape the chains, we can perhaps take others with us, into dancing light and shadow, into darkness.</p><p><strong>Shamans Bodhisattvas</strong></p><p>Some of the most natural creatures in liminal spaces, like the spaces themselves, are in transition. We can call them shamans, also therianthropes: part-human creatures who are undergoing metamorphoses from human into animal, in part or whole.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/294/1*sQEK6oB7y2HbM7FyZ_GQ-Q.png" /></figure><p>For instance, here is one from Trois Freres Cave, photographed and drawn by Abbe Breuil.</p><p>And here’s another from Lascaux, from an isolated place known as The Shaft. It shows a recumbent stick figure, by some observers thought to be displayed with an erect penis, a strange being perhaps threatened by a bull, perhaps guarded by a bird. There is more to wonder about than to know about this scene.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*Cn9ia-A0m3Ik2ouceMYqMg.png" /></figure><p>And from the last and deepest of the Chauvet Cave chambers, here is the Salle du Fond, where carbon dioxide and radon levels necessitate only a brief visit, and some of the most interesting figures cannot be directly approached because of the fragility of the cave floor:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*5FuXLVNrtJb42DB0B0-Zhg.png" /></figure><blockquote>The black pubic triangle of the Venus is at eye level and seems to be the heart of the composition. It is shaded in with black pigment. The white vulva slit appears to have been done later with a pointed tool and is clearly indicated by a vertical line incised strongly enough to cut through both the black pigment and the yellow surface film of the rock. The legs, with plump thighs, finish in a point with the feet not shown.<br><em> &lt;http://www.bradshawfoundation.com/chauvet/venus_sorcerer.php&gt;</em></blockquote><p>This description is almost entirely interpretation, of a dubious sort. Though we can recognize us in images, them in us, we know almost nothing about what they meant and what the people who saw these images understood or felt about them. Every word we say or write about the images on the cave walls is conjecture, guess, projection, desire.</p><p><strong>Workshops </strong><br> I have questions about the artisanship of the puppeteers in Plato’s cave: Where did they get the things they carry? What was their role in the entire simulation of reality? What were their rewards for this endless labor? Were they gifted with a deep and esoteric knowledge of the true nature of things? Or did they just have a steady paycheck, maybe with guaranteed room and board? You know, hard work but decently rewarded.</p><p>Imagine the woodshops that would have to exist in order to make the images used by the puppeteers in the allegory of the cave. The objects they carried had to be made — on some workshop floor there had to be wood dust and shavings, piles and scraps, workbenches and tools for cutting, shaping, drilling, and joining wood, such as glues, oils, and glazes. And, of course, there would have to be skilled teams of carpenters and sculptors and painters. At least all that.</p><p>Let’s carry this workshop into our time. To see examples of our workshops’ size and complexity, simply stay for the extensive listings of credits that come at the end of movies and video games. Particularly in a video game, you will see a scrolling list of hundreds of specialists representing every craft — and there are many — required by video game production. In the Spectacle at large, every credit you see can be multiplied by thousands, from best boys and caterers to visual artists and audio producers, key grips and directors, even writers, of course, also to rare and exotic artisans who work in the deepest magic of the digital.</p><p><em>The Pleasure Dome — the emanations of the spectacle, ever evolving global matrices of image and sound and sensation — cannot be big enough, thrilling enough, or self-renewing enough to continuously gratify our hungry ghost cravings for images and stories</em>. But the producers and distributors of what is ironically called “content” are working hard, building on the already vast amusement production matrix to make the images and stories big enough, as thrilling as the audience can stand (without, say, involuntarily transforming into werewolves or dying of fear or ecstasy), and always new — and their fond wish is to produce new scenes every hour, day, week, month, year.</p><p>Imagine a thrilling new video series of connected stories, in whatever technical manifestation, that contains character-driven drama, comedy, violence, sex, and horror, with brilliant effects for all; that also presents dreams, imaginary mindscapes of anyone who appears on the “screen” — or floating holograms or direct retinal transfer or any damned thing the puppeteers can come up with — and immensely detailed environments, exterior and interior. All new, all the time, until the end of our world.</p><p>The puppeteers of the Spectacle want to saturate our perceptions — visual, auditory, olfactory, tactile, vestibular, proprioceptive; sensations of heat and cold, of nausea and satiation, of sensual pleasure and pain, ecstasy and deep sorrow, of ambient sound and music … I think you take my point. Television, movie, Web, and virtual reality have all made astounding (or alarming, depending on your position) progress in fooling our sensorium. It seems unlikely that their abilities to do so will come to a halt any time soon.</p><p>And of course there are the technologies that have enabled our current condition. Information in the abstract has transmuted into content and medium as each new technical capability emerges. Since the mid-19th century we’ve seen photography, telegraph, telephony, radio, television, miniaturization, satellites, enabling the processing and transmission of vast amounts of information at enormous bandwidth across the networks that emerged. Digitization became the norm, instantaneously coming from wherever it is produced and transmitted to anywhere we wish.</p><p>Images and stories and sound strike us more deeply and strongly with every new day. We are lovers of image and sound, the more detailed and moving the better, the more implicated in human drama the better — the better to distract you with, my dear.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/669/1*yELlzbhMMAHjZHSR5ZTk4g.png" /></figure><p>If Rome burns, we won’t fiddle, we’ll watch and listen with all the media at our disposal — almost certainly including images and sounds of fiddling. As the music plays, we’ll remain fastened to the spectacle of the aftermath, to the burned and wrecked buildings, to corpses and grieving survivors, to the wounded and crippled; and to the heroic responders, searching hour after hour, day after day. We will assume there were culprits and long to know them in every detail. If the script plays out as it often has, there will be discoveries to make us weep, to make us smile, above all, <em>to keep us tuned.</em></p><p>Watching the unfolding destruction, we the audience, on the couches in our modern caves, will cry out some versions of, “O! the humanity!” as chants against evil or prayers for mercy. We will “participate” through preposterous insertions into the ongoing stories of survey questions, random interviews, and the cacophony of social networks— where people express their thoughts and feelings just as though they mattered to the corporations who control the process, or to much of anyone else.</p><p>The people on the top floors of the corporations, especially the ones in the corner offices, will celebrate their good fortune at being able to “cover” the event. You can almost feel the tip of fortune, as more billions are transferred to the already preposterously moneyed.</p><p>While the rest of us have empty simulacra of agency or power, void of potential, the remnants of our distraction —</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*rQ4OboCKOywvxirq.jpg" /></figure><p><strong>The Others: Liminal Personae</strong></p><p>Fortunately for us all and our hopes, there are others, not puppeteers, of whatever specialties and skills. Among the others are creators of music and dance and art and architecture and live performance, of all forms of drama and comedy and writing and speaking, especially poetry — but whatever the medium or genre, their work lies outside the formal limits of the spectacle.</p><p>Their works are intercessory. They call to us, many from far away in time, others from our here and now, and can show and tell us and sing to us of things far beyond simple distraction and cravings. The cave artists are certainly among them. When we open ourselves to them, they reveal possibilities — beauty, truth, love — that can armor us against distraction by their insight, intelligence, skill, imagination, and hard work.</p><p>Earlier times had their own issues, but here, amid the dazzle and noise of the pleasure dome, we particularly need intercessors who are transitioning through the testing liminal zones of our time.</p><p><strong>Strange Angels: Laurie Anderson and Anne Carson</strong></p><blockquote>The poem begins with the urbane and orderly sound of a herald summoning male citizens to their rational civic business in the Assembly and the Council. The poem ends with the otherworld echo of women shrieking in the wolfthickets. Moreover, the women are uttering a particular kind of shriek, the <em>ololyga</em>. This is a ritual shout peculiar to females … These words do not signify anything except their own sound. The sound represents a cry of either intense pleasure or intense pain. To utter such sounds is a specialized female function.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Anne Carson, “The Gender of Sound”</em></blockquote><p>They are both creatures in the process of change, witchy women with appropriate gifts and skills: Laurie Anderson, a musician and performance artist; Anne Carter, a writer and performer and artist. They have extraordinary presences in transitional spaces, frontiers, borders.</p><p><strong><em>They offer to take us with them when they can, which I think is their true function.</em></strong></p><p>Everything about their work — all of it, really, for both — can be and has been described in terms that indicate fragments, palimpsests, collages, and paste-ups, samplings, fragments shored against our ruins — these are words that suggest some of their essential qualities.</p><p>Both not only love fragments, but also are masters of assembling them. With them, the ordinary acquires new registers, metaphorically transposed from orchestra and libretto or piano sonnet into, say, <em>gamelan</em>, weeping dump trucks, and monkey cries, blues guitar, pentatonic flute, and electric crickets, all with the human voice delivering its deepest emotions to us. Poetry turns to prose, prose to poetry — with every iteration, full of new and unanticipated forms in the service of strange projects, redirections, commitments.</p><p>This all can be a bit confusing. If it weren’t, they wouldn’t be guides for us, and speakers to us in the chaos. They’d just be the usual shills and hacks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/264/1*kh4MKAlidmZSTtJFyFOrYA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/206/1*BlmGt1cDYrtEx3Qwe3ezDA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Laurie Anderson</strong> writes music and sings and plays instruments such as electric violin and keyboards, among a number of audio processing and transforming widgets; she also sings, talks, dances, fronts her various bands (and the Kronos Quartet), and weaves images projected in various ways into the sounds and her presence on the stage and anything else generated in the moment.</p><p>I first saw her when she performed in Richmond, Virginia in the early 1980s, with both live and recorded video and audio and a live band. I had never seen or heard anything like it. The world of performance opened up right in front of me in ways I hadn’t thought of or expected.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/275/1*6_hCfaZJpafBzWUuLSDicA.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>Suddenly, an illustration of Ms. Anderson’s face materializes and begins speaking. “This is my dream body,” she says, “the one I use to walk around in my dreams.” It’s her version, I think, of “Once upon a time.”<br><em> “‘Heart of a Dog,’ Laurie Anderson’s Meditation on Loss,” Manohla Dargis, </em>New York Times<em>, Oct. 20, 2015</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*WGtG40sZaP4o0egpj1mK1Q.png" /><figcaption>Lou Reed, Laurie Anderson, Lolabelle</figcaption></figure><p>For me, <em>Heart of a Dog</em> is perhaps most completely and compellingly <em>her</em> in performance — given that she wrote it, directed it, starred in it, narrated it, and did the music for it, this is not a surprise. Her voice, tonally various and expressive, describes her experiences of love and loss: her mother, her husband, Lou Reed, and her rat terrier, Lolabelle. I’m so moved by the combination of images and voice and music, by her evocations of mortality and love, that I don’t much want to analyze it. Go watch it and listen to it — that is pretty much what I have to say. Or to put it another way, follow her down.</p><p>I’ve followed her work through the decades, and I remain devoted to it, and amazed by her creation, intelligence, soul, innovation … I could ring up quite a series of attributes here, but here is a summary point: her work is exalting, perception altering, fascinating, enjoyable, surprising, and eloquent in voice, music, and movement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/433/1*wA6015QCun8xS-TBqqHXUw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Laurie Anderson Introduces Anne Carson.</strong></p><p>When I began putting Laurie Anderson and Anne Carson into this story, I had no idea that they knew one another. When I discovered that they were close friends, I was amazed and delighted.</p><p>Anne Carson writes in a distinctive chorus of voices and mixtures of poetry and prose — a novel in verse, chapbooks in a box, an opera, a fictional essay in “tangos,” pastiches of classical Greek plays and poems, where ancient collides with modern in essentially impossible ways — and I think that is enough of that: I’m not trying to classify her variety but to give a sense of how various and unexpected it is. Laurie Anderson says:</p><blockquote>Once I went to Central Park with the poet Anne Carson, who’s a friend of mine, and she said, “Let’s try a new sport, and it’s called Snow Standing.” I said, “Really, what’s that?” She said, “Well, we just stand here, and snow’s on us, and that’s it.” I said, “That sounds really nice, so we just stood there and it was that snowstorm a long time ago, when The Gates were on in Central Park and we stood there and the snow piled on our heads and our shoulders and the gates were blowing around, and it was really a wonderful sport. I sometimes can’t tell the difference between a sport and a ride, or a sport and a something else. How much effort do you put into it? Of course, you do put in quite a lot of effort to stand still [so] the snow will pile correctly.</blockquote><blockquote><em>&lt;https://lithub.com/laurie-anderson-on-the-time-she-invented-a-sport-with-anne-carson/&gt;</em></blockquote><p>And here’s a brief instruction:</p><blockquote>‘When your thinking is still, watching TV or whatever, thinking the same thing you’ve always thought, you might as well be dead… Living happens when your thought moves.’<br> <em>“Interview with Anne Carson,”<br> &lt;http://www.thewhitereview.org/feature/interview-anne-carson/&gt;</em></blockquote><p>And from one of her most visible and startling books:</p><blockquote>This was</blockquote><blockquote>when Geryon liked to plan</blockquote><blockquote>his autobiography, in that blurred</blockquote><blockquote>state between awake and asleep</blockquote><blockquote>when too many intake valves are open in the soul.</blockquote><blockquote>Like the terrestrial crust of the earth</blockquote><blockquote>which is proportionately ten times thinner</blockquote><blockquote>than an eggshell, the skin of the soul</blockquote><blockquote>is a miracle of mutual pressures.</blockquote><blockquote>Millions of kilograms of force pounding up</blockquote><blockquote>from earth’s core on the inside to meet</blockquote><blockquote>the cold air of the world and stop,</blockquote><blockquote>as we do, just in time.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Anne Carson, from</em> Autobiography of Red, <em>page 60</em></blockquote><p>And this:</p><blockquote>But for myself I do not believe this, I am not quenched —</blockquote><blockquote>with Thou or without Thou I find no shelter.</blockquote><blockquote>I am my own Nude.</blockquote><blockquote>And Nudes have a difficult sexual destiny.</blockquote><blockquote>I have watched this destiny disclose itself</blockquote><blockquote>in its jerky passage from girl to woman to who I am now,</blockquote><blockquote>from love to anger to this cold marrow,</blockquote><blockquote>from fire to shelter to fire.</blockquote><blockquote>What is the opposite of believing in Thou —</blockquote><blockquote>merely not believing in Thou? No. That is too simple.</blockquote><blockquote>That is to prepare a misunderstanding.</blockquote><blockquote>I want to speak more clearly.</blockquote><blockquote>Perhaps the Nudes are the best way.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Anne Carson, From ”The Glass Essay”</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/467/1*RObb-cxUbhEcvApU7oDcJw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Anne Carson, in red cowboy boots as often, performing</strong></figcaption></figure><p>My engagement with these wonderful books, music, events, and videos — all the work Carson and Anderson do — has been random as raindrops; also filled with joy, love, pathos, illumination and surprise.</p><p>Through their work, we can be led through the crowds and distractions and wreckage into spaces far away from the Pleasure Dome and its yells and screeches and fluttery, shiny, evanescent things.</p><blockquote>Late 14c., extasie “elation,” from Old French estaise “ecstasy, rapture,” from Late Latin extasis, from Greek ekstasis “entrancement, astonishment, insanity; any displacement or removal from the proper place,” in New Testament “a trance,” from existanai “displace, put out of place,” also “drive out of one’s mind” …<strong>Ecstasy (n.) <em>Oxford English Dictionary</em></strong></blockquote><p>We might find ourselves in a cave with images on the walls that simultaneously calm and exalt us. Light flickers, shadows come and go as we see the Neanderthal images. We might find ourselves in cave tunnels that stretch out endlessly into darkness. There is music of flute and drum and voice — ululating, keening with the sounds of wailing women, of <em>ololyga</em>. And of course there are poetry and songs. We might find ourselves standing beside ourselves, displaced from the “proper” places, the usual ones that is, and we see the Pleasure Dome on fire. And we might find our own forms of ecstasy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ooJtvjJKMHWkhzfxwMRXOg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>If images and sounds are beautiful, and built around their own integrity, they no longer serve the Pleasure Dome. They give us beauty and knowledge, and they allow us to follow them go where we will, away from distraction, the spectacle, the pseudo-event. We can make our journeys into darkness and light, into sound and silence, following images and sounds not created to control us. We can explore our own lives, our own loves and fates, including inevitable loss and oblivion. Our thoughts will move along our own paths.</em></strong></p><p><strong>Coda</strong></p><p>LINE THE WORDCAVES<br> with panther skins,</p><p>widen them, hide-to and hide-fro<br> sense-hither and sense-thither</p><p>give them courtyards, chambers, drop doors<br> and wildnesses, parietal,</p><p>and listen for their second<br> and each second and second<br> tone.</p><p>Paul Celan, trans. Pierre Joris</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a7d877a0723c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Real Virtual Human]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@dthomasmaddox/real-virtual-human-tom-maddox-4588c68145d4?source=rss-6fdb107e2469------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4588c68145d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Maddox]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Aug 2017 20:21:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-16T01:20:49.479Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*hA-rglfQ539wBI37ZsGyHQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The disclosures of the impermanence of the past suggested, and suggest, an impermanence of the future. Little of what we have believed has been true … <br> Wallace Stevens, <em>The Necessary Angel</em></p><p>Old people have always noticed how much has disappeared. For most of human history, this has meant family, lovers, friends, neighbors, all vanished along with many of the artifacts they’d grown up with — the human-built places of their youth, the house that burned down years ago or the abandoned farm, the cities ravaged by fire and plague and war. While tragic (sickness, death, destruction, material decay), these things are in a weird way, manageable. If there’s no solution for something dreadful, there’s no problem — it’s a condition of existence, and we cope as best we can.</p><p>In the early 20th century, Rilke sensed something different was on the way:</p><blockquote>Now, from America, empty indifferent things are pouring across, sham things, dummy life…. A house, in the American sense, an American apple or a grapevine over there, has nothing in common with the house, the fruit, the grape into which went the hopes and reflections of our forefathers … Live things, things that are alive — that are conscious of us — are running out and can no longer be replaced. We are perhaps the last to have known such things.</blockquote><p>Now, however, in the early years of the 21st century, what Rilke feared has expanded beyond anything he could have foreseen. Not just <em>things</em> but the fabric of everyone’s lives around the globe is disintegrating, because of war and disease, certainly, but also because of a continual rewrite of the human world, materially, intellectually, morally.</p><p>Now the old are not witnesses to what has disappeared but survivors mumbling about all that has been lost, all that has disappeared over an event horizon and thus has gone from our universe. They are fearful and uncomprehending — it’s as if aliens had visited our planet and destroyed the things we knew, then gone away, leaving behind their trash, their rootless and incomprehensible ways, their incessantly changing, polymorphic artifacts.</p><p>For both young and old, the rate of change has accelerated to a nauseating pace, as if we have been sentenced to live on a chaotic and terrifying carnival ride. Beliefs, from world religions to tribal animism, and ways of life (courtship, marriage, family, for instance) are warped, challenged, destroyed. They become contested domains or new ones. What people thought were self-evident truths about fundamental human practices can become battlegrounds. Whatever you cherish in your heart, it may be gone by the time you read this.</p><p>#</p><p>People have not worn these changes well.</p><p>The dispossessed — their traditional ways of life now ill-recalled memories, their current lives subject to war, ethnic conflict, disease, poverty — move on as best they can, trying to create new ways of life. Megacities pop up like metastasized hobo jungles, with ten million and more inhabitants. They are places of uncertain refuge for people whose way of life has become unsustainable on farms and in villages. So they flee to Mumbai, Mexico City, Delhi, Jakarta, Karachi, Lagos, Kinshasa, Abidjan, Cape Town. Most live in shantytowns or favelas — such as the Red Zone in Mexico City, Dharavi in Mumbai: by whatever name, these improvised communities are mutant slums, semi-civilized, semi-permanent. The migrants try to survive in these fearful places; often they live without water or sewage or most formal civic structures. Yet even in the midst of privation, danger, and damaged human dignity, these places become defenses against the chaos, loci of community and self-rule.</p><p>Dislocated from their onetime physical homes and landscapes, their local customs and rituals, the millions also go to the cities for <em>work</em>, in the terrifying euphemism. They seek to be paid, but really they will be devoured. They occupy vast dormitories and work as long and hard as told for very little. If they despair and leap out of dormitory windows, thousands line up to replace them.</p><p>And there are others still more desperate: they simply flee from the apparently endless wars of the contemporary world — from Afghanistan, Syria, Somalia, Iraq — country after country where violence and chaos and privation drive out the inhabitants. They carry their children in their arms, whatever goods have not been destroyed in carts or on their backs. Their emblem is a drowned child washed up on the Mediterranean shore.</p><p>Behind them they leave their dead and what were their homes, which are now mostly piles of rubble, along with the ever present threats of air strikes and mechanized armies that kill them without much thought and with less remorse. They beg wealthier and more peaceful countries to take them, to provide them refuge.</p><blockquote>In terms of continents, Asia hosts 3,5 million refugees on its soil, more than the Middle East (2,6 million), Europe (1,8 million) and America (800.000). 86% of all refugees have fled to so-called developing countries, the highest percentage in 22 years.<br> <em>Arte</em>, September 5, 2014</blockquote><p>We, the comfortable, with the richest material lives, are the least hospitable. No surprise there.</p><p>The refugees’ suffering turns in the hands of bureaucracy into abstract, bloodless categories — <em>immigrants, displaced persons, aliens, illegal aliens</em>. Nation-states and the professionals who administer them know how to deal with categories, if not the people. Consider as a searing example the U.S. Department of Homeland Security Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which has made virtue out of cruelty and indifference to others.</p><p>They are only one among the many organizations who pour salt on the wounds of the suffering. These institutions exist to sort the deserving from the unworthy — without empathy, even common kindness — and they condemn those who suffer to absurd, sometimes terrible fates at apparent whim. On Manus and Nauru, two Pacific islands, Australia holds more than 2000 refugees and asylum seekers:</p><p>Australia has reduced the men, women and children on the islands to namelessness, referring to them by registration numbers. Asked their names, kids often give a number. It’s all they know. At least the digits are not tattooed.<br> (New York Times, August 8, 2017, Roger Cohen, “Australia’s Desperate Refugee Obstinacy”)</p><p>Meanwhile the carnival ride continues, hatred of the other has become a resurgent fact of our globalism, and the gap between mortal poverty and obscene wealth (the billionaire lifestyle, if you will) in which the world is for sale and all its people for hire creates bitterness, despair, overwhelming resentment, self-loathing, envy. In our anger, we, whoever we might be, spit venom at those different from us, and this has become one normal way of finding an object for loathing of our ways of life, of ourselves, of the dilemmas we find ourselves in. It also expresses our rage at what has been lost, orders of understanding and practice that may have been racist, misogynistic, that may have expressed the orders given by power, but were nonetheless ours — our beliefs, our rituals.</p><p>So billions of us try to cope with the constant churn of geography and politics.</p><p>Climate change, meanwhile, threatens to rewrite the globe and certainly not to our advantage, perhaps to our extinction. Processes that have taken years to do their work quickly raise the oceans, heat the atmosphere, and rewrite the ecosystems that sustain life on the earth, and we let the chances we had to halt or slow these changes pass without doing much at all.</p><p>Small groups of the rich continue to collect the money made by destroying the world while assuring us the world is not being destroyed. We are paralyzed at the enormity of the challenge and sit like scared children peering out our cellar door at approaching funnel clouds as big as the sky.</p><p>#</p><p>The destruction and disintegration I’ve been describing is hardly the whole of the story, indeed it’s just a partial sketch of our grief and despair and loss sketched with the broadest of brushes.</p><p>That’s one side of our recent history, but there are others: the virtual worlds that have come into existence and are now rewriting our lives; they have their own logic and power, their own narratives, their own effects, unknowable before and now woven into our lives, transforming and dislocating, promising more surprises to come. The rides at the carnival constantly become faster, higher, more and more disorienting and nauseating.</p><p>Many of us accept that we cannot make sense of our world in any comprehensive manner. There is no grand narrative.</p><p>From the <em>Oxford Reference</em> article on <em>grands récits</em> ‘big stories’<em>:</em></p><blockquote>Lyotard’s term for the totalizing narratives or metadiscourses of modernity which have provided ideologies with a legitimating philosophy of history. For example, the grand narratives of the Enlightenment, democracy, and Marxism.…Lyotard argues that such authoritarian universalizing narratives are no longer viable in postmodernity, which heralds the emergence of ‘little narratives’ (or <strong>micronarratives,</strong> <em>petits récits</em>): localized representations of restricted domains, none of which has a claim to universal truth status.</blockquote><p>There are only more or less illuminating and relevant micronarratives. So far we have been looking at the brute material of the world in its transmutations and the human suffering that accompanies it.I’ll offer a few of the micronarratives that I’ve found useful over the years. Each is written by someone with a consuming, unifying idea, not a grand narrative but an obsessive way of looking at our world:</p><p>· Guy Debord, <em>The Society of the Spectacle, </em>1967</p><p>· George W. S. Trow, <em>Within the Context of No Context</em>, 1980</p><p>· Neal Postman, <em>Amusing Ourselves to Death</em>, 1985</p><p>So if we want to understand the evolution of smartphones, streamed videos and music, all that, we need to learn from television, particularly what it offers in terms of desire and projection. (At this point in our cultural transformations, there’s really little point in trying to explain the Web. We are soaked in it. We don’t need to have the Web’s complexities explained to us anymore than we do the layout of our living rooms.)</p><p>Debord’s central idea is the <em>spectacle:</em></p><blockquote>In societies where modern conditions of production prevail, life is presented as an immense accumulation of spectacles. Everything that was directly lived has receded into a representation.</blockquote><p>And the vehicle of the spectacle is commodity fetishism: a notion that was first presented in Karl Marx’s Capital, it has remained one of most persuasive Marxist ideas.</p><blockquote>It is nothing but the definite social relation between men themselves which assumes here, for them, the fantastic form of a relation between things. In order, therefore, to find an analogy we must take flight into the misty realm of religion. There the products of the human brain appear as autonomous figures endowed with a life of their own, which enter into relations both with each other and with the human race.<br> (Karl Marx, <em>Capital)</em></blockquote><p>Setting aside the economic mechanisms that drive these relationships, the phenomenon described here is “the fantastic form of a relation between things.” From this grows our involvement with things as objects of desire, and from that grows the spectacle:</p><blockquote>The fetishism of the commodity — the domination of society by “intangible as well as tangible things” — attains its ultimate fulfillment in the spectacle, where the real world is replaced by a selection of images which are projected above it, yet which at the same time succeed in making themselves regarded as the epitome of reality. <br> (Debord, <em>Society of the Spectacle)</em></blockquote><p>Material things may or may not be involved in any scene of the Spectacle, but they need not be. We may be dealing with pure manifestations of the imaginary.</p><p>To understand this relationship, let’s examine a pervasive and successful feature of the Spectacle. Consider an automobile commercial done in video: its colors are super-saturated, with intensities seldom if ever seen in real life; the motions of the vehicles in it flow along diagonals, the most exciting of vectors — upward and downward at a slant because normal horizontals are boring (and verticals are science fiction). In the ads, the shoppers browse showrooms that are little capsules of the consumer universe. The showrooms gleam as the vehicles do, and car sellers stand ready to inform the shoppers — who may be canny or dopey, clued in or clueless , about whom the relevant fact is that they want to buy a new vehicle. The stakes for a salesperson are high, as he is really present in order to usher the shoppers into the beautiful fictions.</p><p>The buyers are in a state of arousal, consumer desire at a high level, with deep feeling. As the video ads show us, they are possessed by joy once at the wheel of a vehicle, as they steer along the strangely diagonal highways, through cities of romance, where buildings shine in the night and beautiful strangers watch their passing with interest and commendation, across expanses of desert where sand boils around them, or among cliff side vistas where they can drive without hindrance above beautiful blue ocean. The consumers are aroused and tumescent: how could they not be? (Perhaps they have orgasms, perhaps not. The ads are a bit coy in this regard.) Mostly, they are in love with the experience of being consumers in love — with vehicles, vistas, seeming cascades of possibility and joy beyond end. Not with the brute facts of car purchase and ownership and the real-world experiences of driving, but with enchantments focused on these things.</p><p>Again, note that our relationship to these dense moments of the Spectacle is driven by commodity fetishism: our desire invested in the network of images and sounds that bind us to our goods, to what we acquire or want to acquire. This relationship holds together the consumer economy, which supports and is supported by the Spectacle.</p><p>Absent the Spectacle, Apple would have no factories in Asia, no Apple stores in the U.S., no “Geniuses.” There might be machines with all the capabilities of any Apple but without the special combinations of marketing design and advertising that gave birth to the iPod and all Apple has shoved in front of us as supremely desirable consumer products. They could not engage our desires without stages on which to show them.</p><p>Here in the First World, where affluence is common, ambition has scope, and consumers have the illusion of infinite choice, what we see in the ads, whatever they try to sell us, is the face of the Spectacle: Guy Debord says,</p><blockquote>When we look at its face, we do not see the Spectacle’s essential nature, its structures, its goals, its cultural totality: these are for the most part unseen, as they would interfere with the Spectacle’s presentation of itself. They would break the spell, and in the Spectacle, the spell is prized above all.</blockquote><p>Marketing and advertising have become mechanisms of sensory-rich abduction that never speaks its true aims.</p><p>Simply, the relationship between commodity fetishism and the Spectacle holds together the consumer economy.</p><p>We — by which I mean the privileged — arrived here by years of technological development, economic and political struggle, of ever more fragmentation of groups and selves until the primary fact of our daily lives is the ongoing show across every possible medium of bright, shiny things to hold our attention — and yes, as we watch the play of light and form, the presenters of the shows pick our pockets, rifle through our private belongings, discover our secrets or mere privacies, search our homes, and do their very best to ensnare us in networks whose ostensible purposes can be anything from “friendship” to dating to ill-defined “sharing” but whose real purpose is to create false communities of desire which we can “share” in only through selling our selves. Literally: as many have pointed out, <em>we</em> are the payment for the pleasures we are offered.</p><p>How did all this come about? The story is now mythic and well-worn: of the technological advances that made all our virtualities possible; of the scientists, mathematicians, and technical geniuses who created the technologies, and of the heroic struggles of the visionaries and entrepreneurs who oversaw the creation of whole new enterprises (search, social networking, the iEverything), as though Ayn Rand’s wettest dreams of being dominated by heroic entrepreneurs all came true, almost instantly.</p><p>Trow and Postman focus on the media that dominated the spectacle when they wrote: in a simpler time, television and its endless strategies for entertaining us, to our detriment.Note that these are pre-Web books, and that their shared focus is how our attention is grabbed by television. Given that the Web (or, more generally, the Internet) is an extension of television by other means, everything that television offered and inflicted has become totalizing. TV evolved like a radioactive mutant in a comic book into computer networks, and its children fill the web, makes available print, audio, video, files of every conceivable type presented in their native format. And, of course, it allows us the illusion of playing along. We could only watch TV passively while pretending to share in the intimacy of the millions.</p><p>Postman starts off from Aldous Huxley, from <em>Brave New World</em>.</p><p>[I]n Huxley’s vision, no Big Brother is required to deprive people of their autonomy, maturity and history. As he saw it, people will come to love their oppression, to adore the technologies that undo their capacities to think.</p><p>And in a speech given the year before he died, Huxley said:</p><blockquote>In regard to propaganda the early advocates of universal literacy and a free press envisaged only two possibilities: the propaganda might be true, or the propaganda might be false. They did not foresee what in fact has happened, above all in our Western capitalist democracies — the development of a vast mass communications industry, concerned in the main neither with the true nor the false, but with the unreal, the more or less totally irrelevant. In a word, they failed to take into account man’s almost infinite appetite for distractions.<br> “Man’s Almost Infinite Appetite For Distractions”</blockquote><p>The notions of distraction and amusement seem harmless enough, but when inflated to their current dimensions, media of distraction and amusement interfere with how we think, as Huxley says. Our experience of the world is skewed by viewing it as a series of amusements.</p><p>Trow’s evocation of television strikes more mysterious chords: “Television does not vary. The trivial is raised up to power. The powerful is lowered toward the trivial.”</p><p>Worse yet, television works a peculiar magic:</p><blockquote>It is bewitching.<br> It interferes with growth, conflict, and destruction, and these forces are different in its presence. <br> ’Entertainment’ is an unsatisfactory word for what it encloses or projects or makes possible.<br> No good has come of it.</blockquote><p>He concludes, “Television is a mystery.”</p><p>Television was what we might call the needed ground for the global flowering of the Spectacle, because it was the first ubiquitous communicator of sound and images — which bewitched and manipulated, and largely immobilized us, which is the state in which the purveyors of the Spectacle want us. Watching TV, we careen from image to image, pulled along all the paths of desire.</p><p>As Postman repeats in various ways, when the news must be entertaining, it changes into entertainment, whose practices, virtues, and defects are very different from the news as we once knew and experienced it. How this series of infinite distractions penetrates into how we read, think, and criticize — perhaps rendering them strangely different — is a deeper, more mysterious question, one whose answers are emerging as the years of distraction move along, though most ultimate outcomes remain in doubt.</p><p>However, as is clear at this point, things are much worse than the mere metamorphosis of news into entertainment. Television represented an enormous leap beyond print and audio cultures and, of course, prepared us for the deluge, for the Internet and the Web and all that has come with it — including smart phones, a nausea inducing phrase, certainly, but a descriptive one. And the phones represent the ultimate development of the Spectacle … for the moment. If the purveyors of the Spectacle have their way, implants and enhanced realities are on the way, promising an infinite capacity for amusement and farther distance away from the real, from reason, evidence, critical questioning and analysis, even simple understanding.</p><p>At this point we have two domains for us to consider: the material and the virtual. The material: the domain of war, famine, plague, the world of new things — alien artifacts, notionally or metaphorically — of nomadism and hyper-urbanism; also the domain threatened by climate change, which can turn the screws on our species in horrible ways, at present only dimly seen because unexpected consequences will become the norm when we live and die in hot, wet, shifting environments, terrible places for our and other species. And the virtual domain: where reality can be superseded, perhaps banished, and where we seek endless amusement and more, deep gratification.</p><p>Can there be any doubt which domain will rule our fates? Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon, the great and spectacular structures of the virtual, can disintegrate and collapse if the Internet connections fall into disrepair, the fragile networks that blanket us no longer function, the satellite networks disintegrate, and the hyperkinetic carnival rides of our world will lie in smoking ruins. There are hundreds, maybe more scenarios portraying just such events in more or less convincing ways. Collectively, these dramas say essentially one thing: the world as we know it can disappear almost overnight.</p><p>Imagine that the billions will no longer be able to afford the luxuries of social networks with their billionfold chatter, of shiny videogames and things for sale. People will instead be searching for protection from misery and destruction, for shelter, clothing, and food, for medical care and medicines in scarce supply in a chaotic world and its disintegrated civilizations.</p><p>Will we despair? Will we, like Chauncey Gardner in <em>Being There</em>, point our TV remotes at reality and <em>click click click</em>, attempting to change the channel because the one we are watching is threatening, terrifying? Will we live among the ruins and do the best we can to survive as global civilizations disintegrate around us?</p><p>As of the moment, world population numbers around 7.5 billion human beings: how many will survive the destruction of their habitats and the affordances of their technologies and current ways of life? Perhaps human resiliency and the whims of fate will allow us to escape the worst consequences of our global, drunken, destructive sprees, perhaps not. If we cannot escape our darkest, most violent and greediest impulses — and <em>we</em> here are not the privileged but all of us on this world — and if we cannot master Huxley’s “infinite appetite for distraction,” then we likely cannot escape the worst. Our hatreds and greed and addiction to amusement will consume us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4588c68145d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>