<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@dylanozmore?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:25:47 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@dylanozmore/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HUMAN DYNAMICS: The Most Fundamental, Overlooked Aspect of Business]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/human-dynamics-the-most-fundamental-overlooked-aspect-of-business-344e4dcfe8cb?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/344e4dcfe8cb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Apr 2022 20:30:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-26T20:30:12.694Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*RTQsUV5agwVC42Tp" /></figure><p>The human dynamics are the most fundamental, overlooked aspect of business.</p><p>Business is the buying and selling of products and services that humans design, develop, and deliver to and with each other.</p><p>Simply stated: Business is <strong>humans</strong> doing stuff together.</p><p>In many ways, the human dynamics are overlooked <strong>because</strong> they are so fundamental. They are so foundational that they’re missed. It’s like water to the fish.</p><p>An old fish asked a young fish, “How’s the water?”</p><p>The young fish turns and asks, “What water?”</p><p>The most obvious realities can be missed.</p><p>The human dynamics are the water of business. They are what organizations are made of. They are what the entire world of business is “swimming” in.</p><p>And you’re the fish in this story.</p><p>That’s good news.</p><p>When the underlying and fundamental realities are illuminated — when they’re brought from the background to the foreground — then you have greater clarity, insight, and power in impacting those realities.</p><p>It’s very different from how we tend to relate to the human dynamics. For the most part, these realities are the most ignored, rejected, and resisted aspects of business. They’re too “soft,” “touchy-feely,” or only appropriate for the therapist’s office. Executives will invest tens of millions of dollars in a new technology platform, financial strategy, marketing launch, or an open office floor plan long before focusing on the human dynamics.</p><p>The human dynamics are relegated to one of the many teams within the broader HR/People Department. Usually under the heading of “culture” and grouped with the budget for ping pong tables, free beer on Fridays, and company BBQs. Or they’re grouped under “talent development” along with compliance trainings, mindfulness classes, and updates to the employee handbook.</p><p>Those days are coming to an end.</p><p>In today’s increasingly complex and competitive world, business leaders are recognizing that the human dynamics — how people show up, how they relate to each other, and how they do just about everything in the organization — are fundamental. It’s the unique ways of being, operating, and relating that comprise every company.</p><p>When Ray Dalio started focusing on the human dynamics, he created the largest and most successful hedge fund in the world. Steve Jobs was famous for his intense focus on <em>how </em>everything was done at Apple, not just on <em>what </em>was being done. Clients I’ve worked with are leveraging this approach to break new ground in the consulting, veterinarian, pharmaceutical, and technology industries. Developing the human dynamics is a competitive advantage that is nearly impossible for others to recreate because it’s not about a specific product, service, process, procedure, policy, or system. It’s about what is both underneath and yet threaded through all of that.</p><p>What’s possible is that the human dynamics take their rightful place at the top of the priorities of business leaders, not because they “should” or because it’s the “right” or “nice” thing to do, but because it’s essential to the future success of their organization.</p><p>When the human dynamics are deeply connected and integrated with the vision and strategy of the organization, it <strong>naturally</strong> accelerates growth, results, and profitability. It’s creates a truly creative, fulfilling and collaborative environment and an aligned workforce.</p><p>This isn’t more company retreats, off-sites, leadership programs, workshops, or trainings.</p><p>This is a whole new level of focus and sensitivity to the human dynamics of the enterprise. It is human-centered and results-driven leadership, effective and authentic communication, trust, radical collaboration and creativity, and the deep alignment of the vision, strategy, and people.</p><p>It’s investing in and developing your own skills in the human dynamics. It’s also hiring the right experts and specialists in the human dynamics, in the same way you’d hire experts and specialists in legal, strategy, branding, and finance.</p><p>If this sounds like a lot, it is.</p><p>It’s a new paradigm — a new way of doing business.</p><p>Actually, it’s not even that. This is simply illuminating <strong>what is</strong> <strong>already happening</strong>. That’s why this message doesn’t need to be believed or taken on faith. It’s what is already at play in the business world. The human dynamics are impacting every facet of your organization, whether you like it or not, whether you acknowledge it or not.</p><p>The fish is swimming in water, whether it knows it or not.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=344e4dcfe8cb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[hidden impact: You, Me, & Our Home]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/hidden-impact-you-me-our-home-6d9b062aab02?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d9b062aab02</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-impact]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[earth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Jan 2021 19:22:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-06T19:33:42.071Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>After my alarm went off this morning, I went over to the shower and turned on the water. It ran for a minute or two before it was hot, while I did my ritual morning pee. I took a shower, toweled off, got dressed, and made some eggs for breakfast. Then I took the trash out.</p><p>So, it was a pretty normal morning.</p><p>Now on one hand, this is anything but normal — it is the miracle of the modern world. All of this — the water supply, the sanitation system, the food, clothes — coming together with such ease like never before in human history. There isn’t sewage running down the street. I don’t need to walk miles to get fresh water like much of the developing world does. I don’t need to make my own clothes or raise chickens or hunt for food, like human beings have done for millennia. It’s amazing.</p><p>From another perspective, this is anything but normal for a different reason. And that is: that I don’t see the <em>impact</em> of my actions, the <em>impact </em>of the systems that I am a part of. For almost all of human history there was no hiding our impact. In fact, to do so wasn’t even an option because we didn’t have the technology. These days, it’s easy to hide.</p><p>What do I mean by the <em>impact</em>?</p><p>Let’s look at my morning again.</p><p>I live in San Diego, practically a desert, so where does the fresh water for my toilet and my shower come from? How much water was used while it heated up? What happens after I’ve used it? Who made the towel that I dried off with? Under what kind of conditions? Is it from a factory that pollutes our rivers? What about the eggs that I had for breakfast, where are they from? After I threw the garbage down the trash shoot, what happens to it? I assume a landfill, but where?</p><p>I don’t know.</p><p>But is that my responsibility? Shouldn’t the city and state officials be managing things like the water, sewage, and trash? Probably. But how good of a job are they doing? Is it sustainable? And who is looking after the other systems — the towel, clothes, and eggs?</p><p>The scale and complexities of these systems is unprecedented in human history. It can be daunting, overwhelming, and a source of confusion and despair. It is a full time job managing just one aspect of one of these systems.</p><p>So it’s <em>hidden</em>.</p><p>In some part, it’s hidden because that makes it easy. It cuts down on the complexity. It’s user-friendly!</p><p>“<em>Pipe the sewage away, I don’t want to be anywhere near that.</em>”</p><p>“<em>Don’t tell me about the eggs, just box them up and sell them to me.</em>”</p><p>“<em>Just keep the water flowing, I have enough to worry about.</em>”</p><p>But fundamentally I don’t think we hide it because it’s easy. I think we hide it because we’re uncomfortable with the truth.</p><p>If we’re honest, we can see that we avoid knowing about these things. They can be painful truths. What kind of conditions do the chickens live in where the eggs come from? What’s the status of the fresh water supply to desert cities like San Diego? What are the environmental standards like in India where my towel was made? If we knew the answers to those kinds of questions, we would naturally make different choices.</p><p>I remember being upset with organizations like PETA and documentaries like Forks Over Knives that used shock and awe to scare people into action. Showing terrible video clips of different aspects of these systems we’re talking about.</p><p>But recently I realized it wasn’t shock and awe. It was just the truth of what’s happening. And the truth was painful to me. The “shock” was simply the gap between what I saw in my day-to-day living and what was happening in the hidden peripheries of the systems that I participate in. Hidden peripheries like cow lots in Texas or conditions in Bangladesh or the lack of sanitation in Haiti.</p><p>You might think that my morning had nothing to do with that. It was only a short shower, a small bag of trash, and 2 eggs. What’s the big deal? But it matters. All of the little actions of the individual add up to a giant effect.</p><p>Our world is being deeply impacted by our accumulated actions:</p><p>· More than 1 million species are at risk of extinction. By mid-century, as many as 30–50% of the total species found on Earth will have disappeared.</p><p>· Sea levels are rising at the fastest rate in 3,000 years.</p><p>· Tropical forests are being destroyed at a rate of about 31,000 square miles a year — an area equivalent to the state of South Carolina.</p><p>· Approximately 9 billion chickens and 39 million cows are killed in the U.S. each year. (Cattle ranching is the leading cause of deforestation in the Amazon rainforest.)</p><p>· In just 55 years, humans have managed to wipe out 90% of the ocean’s top predators including sharks, bluefin tuna, swordfish, marlin, and king mackerel.</p><p>These and many other facts don’t need to end at being painful truths. Consider that pain is your own soul calling you to action, calling you to new clarity and vision. These can be opportunities to make a difference in the world, to contribute, restore, and heal. Each of our actions is a vote for the kind of systems that we want. Our actions are votes for a certain kind of world, a certain kind of future.</p><p>It’s possible to shed more light on the impact that each of our own individual actions have on the world.</p><p>It’s possible to bring more transparency to the systems that we participate in.</p><p>And it’s possible for each of us to have a new global awareness.</p><p>I think that is the real opportunity of our generation — <strong>to redefine “home” and to redefine “family” to include the whole world and all of the beings in it. </strong>The same technology and systems that can be used to destroy our planet can be used to connect and restore it. Our lives can contribute to that in small and large ways.</p><p>Let’s stop ignoring and running from our impact on the planet.</p><p>Let’s own our impact and create something new.</p><p>Let’s create a sustainable, beautiful home for our global family.</p><p>//</p><p><em>If you’re looking to learn more, check out some of the powerful documentaries that have come out recently. I’m thinking of Kiss The Ground (Netflix), David Attenborough: A Life On Our Planet (Netflix), and The Biggest Little Farm (Amazon Video). Take small inspired actions and build some momentum in your life in creating a more sustainable world.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d9b062aab02" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE ART OF NOT SELLING: An Organic Approach to Growth]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/the-art-of-not-selling-an-organic-approach-to-growth-f029cd3b264c?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f029cd3b264c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zen]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2020 22:23:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-10T22:23:29.555Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W1r0Cn__m5ymE4lXGIB-Xg.jpeg" /><figcaption>SpaceX launch</figcaption></figure><p>Back in the fall of 2007, I was a student at Carnegie Mellon University. I had just been elected to the leadership of the Undergraduate Investment Club — a student organization that focused on investing, finance careers, and business school events.</p><p>I was struck by how little us undergrads knew about what was happening in the business world. This was knowledge we needed to help us in investing and job interviews. The Wall Street Journal was available for free on campus — but who had time to read that? There were numerous finance websites, but all dedicated to professionals or specific niches like accountants or quantitative analysts.</p><p>I was passionate about the markets. I wanted to learn more and I wanted to share that knowledge in a way that was accessible to undergraduates like me. So I started a side project (or “side hustle” as the kids say).</p><p>I called it the Bulls &amp; Bears Press. It began as a short 3-page, weekly newsletter that was sent to members of the investment club. I e-mailed it out for a couple of weeks before finding out that it was a hit. Students had been taking the time to read it and send it to their friends. Some even reached out asking to write an article for the next issue.</p><p>The trend continued.</p><p>Several months later, I had an epiphany: If students at Carnegie Mellon found value in reading it, why not students at other schools?</p><p>I reached out to a friend who ran a student finance organization at the University of Pittsburgh down the street. Did she want to send the newsletter to the members of her organization? Yes. Did she want to contribute an article or two? Yes. Could I interview her for an upcoming issue? Yes.</p><p>I was on to something…</p><h3><strong>FLOW</strong></h3><p>Last month, I published my first essay on an <em>organic approach</em> to organizations (read: <a href="https://medium.com/@dylanozmore/an-organic-approach-to-organizations-77104bd9b017">here</a>). I talked about the power of aligning with the <em>flow </em>of what’s happening in your organization and the world. I wrote about the ways we interrupt <em>flow </em>by pushing and blocking it. I talked about the importance of trust and staying open. All of this in the name of unlocking a new level of vitality, creativity, and results in your organization. The <em>organic approach</em> has that kind of power.</p><p>I want to go deeper into a particular aspect of this approach. Specifically, I want to explore with you the idea that you don’t need to convince, persuade, or coax anyone into buying your products or services. In other words, it’s the idea that you don’t need to sell. Your business can succeed without it.</p><p>Skeptical? Good.</p><p>First, it’s important that we get clear on what selling is. What comes to mind when you think of sales? Maybe the stereotypical used car salesman. Or worse, sitting in a room for a timeshare presentation (like in <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S7P3s7Og52g">this</a> South Park episode). Or maybe you’ve had some great sales experiences — someone selling you something that ended up really improving your life.</p><p>At the most fundamental level, sales is simply the other side of buying. When a transaction is complete, someone has bought and someone has sold.</p><p>But what I’m referring to as sales is all the other stuff that comes with it. The world of convincing, persuading, and coaxing.</p><p>Sales is grabby. It attempts to force an outcome. “Just imagine how much better your life will be when you buy my product.” “You will look so much more beautiful in our makeup.” “You’ll feel like a real man if you use our shampoo.”</p><p>Sales is the source of many of the complaints about capitalism.</p><p>The bottom line about sales is that it is <em>inauthentic</em>. It’s about hitting a quota, getting paid commission, growing the company, or being the #1 selling brand in your niche. It’s not about being true to you and your organization.</p><p>A quick example: The stereotypical businessperson will look out into the marketplace and find an opportunity to make money. Maybe there is a coffeeshop on every corner, except one. So they find investors and sell them on the opportunity. They persuade people to work for them. They convince customers to stop by. And the shop may even make some money over time. But is that what they want to do? Is it <em>authentic</em>? Do they even like coffee?</p><p>The same inauthentic phenomenon at greater complexity happens all the time in the corporate world. Launching new products or services, opening new offices, contracting with suppliers, taking on investors — all in the name of sales or growth or profitability — but never pausing to see if it’s actually a fit for them and their organization.</p><p>The results are these behemoth inauthentic organizations that you see all around you. Companies that will sell anything regardless of what is true for them. They probably don’t even know what’s true for them so external is their focus (“Where’s the next financial opportunity?”) — and when they look internally, they find only dollar signs, not a soul with a truth and a perspective.</p><p>They’re lost.</p><p>And lost organizations need to sell, push, grab, and force their way to keep going. There’s no heart or soul — the natural engine of life and of all its aspects, including business.</p><p>When a business choice is <em>authentic </em>it is true to you and your organization. It is a fit, a match. It is an expression of something deep and true and real.</p><p>It’s probably obvious how this authenticity is needed in other areas of life. How you choose where to live or who to marry or what principles and values drive your life. But it’s just as true in business — that depth and authenticity are necessary.</p><p>How do you know if something is true to you and your organization? It has the quality, tone, and feel of truth, of alignment. It <em>flows</em>. It takes awareness and attentiveness to really know what’s true. It takes discipline. (It’s also how doing business becomes a spiritual practice. But that’s a story for another day.)</p><h3><strong>SHARING</strong></h3><p>The Bulls &amp; Bears Press didn’t start to grow because I “sold” it. It grew because there was passion and value to share. It was an authentic expression of who I was at the time.</p><p>That experience and many others that followed taught me that I didn’t have to sell. I didn’t need to persuade or convince people. (And if I felt like I did then I was working for the wrong company.)</p><p>I stopped being interested in sales and started being interested in <em>partnership</em>.</p><p>Partnerships that supported the visions of the people involved. I looked for win/win relationships. I looked for that place of overlap between what I was up to and what others were up to. I found the space between their dreams and mine.</p><p>When you <em>share</em> what you are passionate about — where your heart and soul are — then partnerships happen naturally.</p><p>When it’s authentic, when it’s true — that’s not selling — that’s <em>sharing</em>. You are sharing yourself, what you believe in, and what you stand for.</p><p>But isn’t this just sales by another name?</p><p>I understand if it seems that way but consider that I’m talking about a subtle but important distinction. The distance between the two maybe inches wide, but it’s a mile deep.</p><p>Have you ever met someone who was really passionate about their work? Their actions may look the same as other people. They both sit down for meetings, send e-mails, make phone calls, create presentations, and take lunch breaks. They may even work the same amount of hours. So what’s the difference?</p><p>It’s kind of hard to put your finger on, isn’t it? Because it lives in the realm of feeling or energy or context. It lives in the realm of <em>flow</em>. And even if on some level, the actions seem to look the same, they are not. An action aligned with <em>flow</em> produces a different kind of result, attracts a different kind of customer, and creates a different kind of work environment.</p><p>It’s the difference between selling and <em>sharing</em>.</p><p>Selling forces, <em>sharing</em> allows. Selling coaxes, <em>sharing</em> partners. Selling convinces, <em>sharing</em> shares. (I know it’s not proper English, but you get the idea, right?)</p><p>Selling creates fragmented companies.</p><p>Organizations have had to create their own sales departments to hone the skills of pushing their products. It’s something separate from the core of the business. You do your work and then you have to sell it.</p><p>But from the <em>organic</em> perspective they are one thing. There’s no sales department.</p><p>Doing-and-<em>sharing</em> is one continuous movement of the business. They naturally go hand-in-hand. They are both part of the process of the business itself — completely integrated.</p><p>When you stop putting energy into selling, you free up energy to invest back into your organization — into partnerships or into a better quality service or product — into something you don’t need to convince people to buy.</p><h3><strong>GROWTH</strong></h3><p>Now this may sound like a nice idea, but what does it actually look like? What’s the <em>organic approach</em> to growth?</p><p>Well, it stands on the foundation of everything we’ve talked about so far. The foundation of <em>flow</em>, authenticity, sharing, and partnership. And it consists of three pillars: Finding your people, places, and movement.</p><p><em>Find your people. </em>Find the people that are a match to you and your organization. The people who are authentically interested in what you are up to. The ones who most value it. The ones who want to support it as customers, investors, partners, or employees. This is different than just whoever you can convince to buy your product. Find <em>your</em> people, not just people. Regardless of what business you’re in, <em>your</em> people is not “everyone.”</p><p>After Steve Jobs returned to Apple in 1996, did the company grow because he hired better salespeople? Of course not. It grew because the way that Steve is (and the way that Apple is when he is there) naturally creates advocates. He knew how to find his people. Like his campaign of the following year: “Here’s to the crazy ones, the misfits, the rebels, the troublemakers, the round pegs in the square holes. The ones who see things differently…”</p><p>You can steal a page out of his book: Don’t just find customers, find advocates.</p><p><em>Find your places</em>. Find those places where you can most be yourself and have that valued. A certain website or physical location or community. Physical and digital venues that are a match to you and your organization. When you find your people (clients, partners, etc.), go there. That’s not “selling,” that’s meeting them where they are. That may mean setting up a storefront in San Francisco or starting a TikTok account. It’s different than going wherever people are or wherever you can setup shop.</p><p><em>Find your movement</em>. Stand for something. Stand for something that makes a difference — that moves the world forward. Stand for something with your products and services. Something that is authentic and true to you and your organization. And join a movement that is a match to that. If there isn’t a movement, then start one. Some of the fastest growing organizations have been the ones that stood for something when no one else would. If you can’t find something to stand for then you’re probably in the wrong business.</p><p>Those are the 3 pillars of organic growth. There’s actually one more important pillar, but first I want to clarify something.</p><p>In the business world, “organic growth” is typically used to mean growth without taking big outside investment and without mergers and acquisitions. It’s growth that is naturally fueled by the business itself. If it’s not obvious already, I’m using “organic” in a different way. I’m using it to mean what is deeply authentic and a match to you and your organization. That may mean taking outside investment or not. That may mean mergers and acquisitions or not. That may mean rapid growth or not. Hopefully that’s clear.</p><p>There’s one more important pillar and in my mind it underlies the others. It’s this:</p><p><em>Have a damn good product or service.</em></p><p>Pour your heart and soul into what you create. Have it be true and real and deep and meaningful. Have it be an expression of yourself. Have it be great.</p><p>To quote the comedian Steve Martin, “Be so good they can’t ignore you.”</p><h3><strong>A NEW ART</strong></h3><p>So what happened to the Bulls &amp; Bears Press?</p><p>Not long after the second university joined, I incorporated the company. I solidified our team. We launched a website. We polished up the newsletter. We expanded to 5 schools then 10 then 20.</p><p>Through word of mouth, advertisers eventually came knocking. We were the only newsletter that reached directly to undergraduates interested in business and finance. They wanted to be a part of it.</p><p>By the time I graduated, we had grown into a multinational financial publication distributed to tens of thousands of students across 70+ universities including Harvard, Princeton, Oxford, the National University of Singapore, the Indian Institute of Technology Delhi, and the University of Sydney. We were the mostly widely distributed collegiate publication at the time. And we had fun doing it. We even made enough profit that I was able to pay off a substantial chunk of my student loan debt.</p><p>I learned a lot from the experience, but more than anything I learned that an authentic passion for something can lead to exciting business opportunities. The project attracted enthusiastic students, interested advertisers, and committed partners. Almost effortlessly.</p><p>It was my first lesson in the art of not selling.</p><h3><strong>THE SELF</strong></h3><p>My intention in writing this was to unstuck you from “selling.” To free you from the burden of having to push, force, and grab customers. To translate that effort into quality, partnership, and creativity.</p><p>When you look for your people, your places, and your movement, there is a new kind of intentionality, and it’s not the intention of more sales or profit or growth (though those happen). It’s the intention of authenticity, of a match to you and your organization. You could call it a match to the “self” of your organization.</p><p>Just like you, your organization has a <em>self</em>. It is a complex and evolving network, but that doesn’t change the fact that there are actions and choices that are true to that self and those that aren’t. When you nurture the <em>self </em>of your organization — when you express it, share it, put it out into the world — you naturally attract people who are a match to it. You naturally attract a loyal, committed kind of employee. You attract a passionate kind of customer. You attract an enthusiastic kind of investor and partner.</p><p>You create an ecosystem where the art of selling isn’t needed.</p><p>Just the art of being yourself.</p><p>//</p><p><em>I’ve been putting this approach to work as a consultant for over 5 years. I’ve partnered with executives and organizations to help them find their people, places, and movements. If this sounds like a match to you, then reach out to me. If not, then discover what’s true for you and your organization — that’s where the growth is.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f029cd3b264c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Organic Approach to Organizations]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/an-organic-approach-to-organizations-77104bd9b017?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/77104bd9b017</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consulting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Sep 2020 21:08:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-24T19:54:59.699Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve been in the business world for almost 15 years now. In that time, I’ve been an entrepreneur, a financier, a salesperson, a consultant, and an author/artist. Probably like you, I’ve been overwhelmed and mostly disappointed with the endless number of theories, approaches, philosophies, systems, and steps to success. I don’t want to add to that. If anything, I want to subtract from it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*agQesFJcraffz-9f" /></figure><p>If you could subtract all of the stuff that doesn’t work in your organization — where it’s stiff and rigid, where it’s overstretched and burnt out, where it’s blocked and uninspired — if you could subtract all of that, you’d be left with a lot of <em>space</em>. There would be room to move and create, to evolve and expand, to innovate and transform.</p><p>I want you to create space in your organization. I want you to shed some layers and systems and beliefs and barriers. Something really special happens when you do that. Your organization opens itself to what is naturally there, to what the marketplace is already asking you for, to what you and the team already want to produce and create.</p><p>What begins as complex and dense becomes simple and clear. That’s tapping into the <em>organic</em>.</p><h3><strong>FLOW</strong></h3><p>What is the <em>source</em> of success, growth, and profitability?</p><p>Think about it for a second.</p><p>You may think it’s effort or discipline. You may think it’s the right people or structure or organizational design. You may think it’s the right values or mission statement or culture. But it’s not.</p><p><strong>The source of success is alignment with <em>flow</em>.</strong></p><p>Whatever success you’ve achieved up until now has not been a reflection of effort or discipline or any of those other things. It’s been a reflection of the extent to which you are aligned with <em>flow</em>.</p><p>The more aligned you are with <em>flow — </em>moving with it, growing with it, letting it evolve your organization — the more things work.</p><p>When you’re aligned with <em>flow</em> there are times of incredible effort and times of reflection, times of discipline and of disruption.</p><p>There’s no better teacher of this than nature. Nature teaches alignment with <em>flow</em>. Just observe the clouds or a tree or a river. They don’t fight to get somewhere or to prove themselves — to be the best tree or the largest cloud or the fastest river. They don’t cling to results or get attached to things being a certain way. They’re not stuck in any way — they move naturally with their environment.</p><p>We tend to think otherwise, but aren’t human beings as natural as a tree or river? Planet Earth has grown trees and rivers, just like it has grown people.</p><p>There is something at work here and it’s been at work for 14 billion years.</p><p>It’s the capital “F” <em>Flow </em>of existence and life. It’s the motion of the stars and trees and rivers and animals. I may sound like Yoda here talking about the Force — and in a sense, I am. It’s the source of it all. It’s the unfolding process of the universe. <em>That</em>. It’s beyond words, yet those point at it.</p><p>I call it <em>flow</em>.</p><p>If you think organizations and business have nothing to do with it, think again. Because you can’t escape it. You can’t get outside of it. You can’t contain it to certain areas of life.</p><p>It permeates everything. Including you.</p><p>It’s like the ocean and you and your team are sailing in it. <em>Flow</em> is the movement of the wind and water — the waves and rhythms and currents. Your success as a team is a function of your alignment with that <em>flow</em>. When you’re aligned with it, you get to your destination. When you’re not aligned with it, you go off course, get lost, and maybe even shipwrecked.</p><p>(That’s not a perfect analogy because it seems like you and your team are something separate from <em>flow</em>, but you’re not. You’re as much a part of it as the wind and water.)</p><h3><strong>INTERRUPTING FLOW</strong></h3><p>So deep down underneath all the layers and accountabilities and org charts, there is a <em>flow</em>. It is already running around and through your organization and its people. You can give it <em>space</em> and align with it or you can interrupt it.</p><p>There are two ways to interrupt flow: by <em>pushing</em> and by <em>blocking</em>.</p><p><em>Pushing</em> is more common, especially among successful organizations. Pushing is attempting to force an outcome. It’s the unnecessary extra effort and struggle to make things happen — usually done to prove something or “be the best” or “kill the competition” or “save the world.” It’s attempting to force a level of sales or growth or work ethic that is unnatural and inauthentic for your organization. It kills morale and burns people out. It chokes the vitality of your business. Over time, it destroys an organization.</p><p>Hardly anyone notices when pushing is happening because there’s usually lots of success and wins to go along with it. But eventually you pay the price if that growth is inorganic and unsustainable.</p><p>It’s the same as listening to your body. If your body is telling you to slow down when you’re working out and you don’t, then you’re sure to be dealing with burnout and injury in the near future. You’ll end up rehabbing your body with a physical therapist — being forced to slow down anyways.</p><p>On the other hand, <em>organic growth</em> is sustainable growth. It’s not a guarantee of future performance, but it’s sustainable. There is a strong foundation naturally there that the growth and success flowed out of. To quote an old friend, “Don’t push the river, it flows by itself.”</p><p>So that’s <em>pushing</em>. It’s trying to force the river to go further and faster. It’s being stuck in the future.</p><p><em>Blocking</em> is stopping the river from where it’s going in the first place. It’s being stuck in the past.</p><p>Blocking flow on the organizational level looks like keeping things the way they are because “that’s just the way we do things.” It’s the opposite of <em>space</em> and <em>flow</em>. It’s rigidity and stagnation. It is a claustrophobic and lifeless workplace. In this kind of organization there is little to no space for the new. <br> <br>On the employee level, it’s the same. It’s staying stuck in certain work routines, structures, and beliefs from the past that no longer serve you. For some reason or another, the flow has stopped and all that’s left is repetitive and mechanical work. It’s Groundhog Day where each day looks like the last.</p><p><em>Flow</em> isn’t being stuck in the future or past or even the present. It’s being <em>unstuck</em> altogether.</p><h3><strong>ALLOWING FLOW</strong></h3><p>Here’s the good news: When you don’t block <em>flow</em>, it happens naturally.</p><p>That’s why this approach isn’t about adding anything. It’s about subtracting everything that is not an expression of flow. When you remove what’s in the way, what’s left is <em>organic</em>.</p><p><strong>Organic is</strong> <strong><em>flow </em>and its <em>expressions</em></strong>.</p><p>You can’t add organic. Organic is what’s there when nothing is added.</p><p>That’s why I don’t say this is a new approach. It’s as old as nature itself. But it is a radical approach. Radical because of how entrenched we are in the additive-forcing-blocking, anti-flow paradigm. <br> <br><strong>To allow flow is to give <em>space </em>to the new.</strong> Space to new thinking, ideas, projects, and people. It is authenticity and transparency. It’s an organization that allows for and embraces the natural rhythms of creativity/contemplation, activity/passivity, and expansion/contraction. It’s an awareness and attentiveness to the environment in which you operate.<br> <br>The most important aspect of allowing flow is discovering the <em>feeling </em>of it, the <em>tone</em>, or <em>quality </em>of it. Outside the business world, sailors and jazz musicians know it. Judo masters know it. And deep down, you know it. It takes trust and practice to really tune into flow, but it’s as natural to you as your own breath and heartbeat. And it’s that natural to your organization as well.</p><p><strong>Find that feeling, that tone, that quality. </strong>Let it move you and your organization.<strong> </strong>You don’t move it — remember what my friend said?</p><h3><strong>CONCERN</strong></h3><p>There may be something unsettling here. It’s that I’m not giving you any answers. I’m not telling you what to do. “How fast should we grow?” “How many clients should we have?” “How long should our Monday meeting be?”</p><p>I’m not giving you the answers because I want <em>flow</em> to give them to you.</p><p>In a society addicted to the steps and concrete applications, this will challenge you. But anyone who sells you the one-size-fits-all, exact-steps system is cheating you. It’s the classic problem of when you have a hammer, everything looks like a nail. <br> <br>In reality, prescriptions and steps and recipes turn into rules, rigid structures, and untouchable laws which block flow. They may have been appropriate for a period of time, but more often than not they harden. They become sticky and just “the way things are done.”</p><p>An organization like that is predictable and easy to control. Things stay the same. The rules are clear and widely communicated. But this kind of organization can’t adapt or evolve with the market. It has no vitality or dynamism. It may succeed and have stellar results for a time, but as soon as the tide shifts, the organization fails.</p><h3><strong>RESULTS</strong></h3><p>Aligning with <em>flow</em> will challenge you.</p><p><em>Flow </em>may reduce your profitability. If you’re more profitable because you’re selling a product that you don’t actually believe in, then it’s time to discontinue it and focus on those you do believe in.</p><p><em>Flow </em>may slow you down. If your organization is growing at any cost while burning people out and sacrificing quality and partnership then it’s time to slow down. It may even be time to shrink — to regroup, reflect, and get back to basics. Growth is not a linear, straight-line phenomenon. Not in life, not in nature, and not in business. To attempt linear growth (+25% every year!) is to attempt to transcend the natural rhythms and there are major costs to doing that. Costs that the business pays and that you personally pay in your relationships and sanity.</p><p>In fact, <em>flow </em>may take you away from your business altogether. If you’re an entrepreneur but you really want to be fishing off the coast of a tropical island, then it’s time to sell the business and do that.</p><p>So taking an <em>organic </em>approach — attuning to <em>flow </em>— may mean less growth, less revenue and less profitability, at least temporarily (emphasis on temporarily).</p><p>But that’s OK. Actually, more than OK. That’s great. Because if it’s time for your organization to be sold or to discontinue a product or to slow down, then listening to that is <strong>vital</strong>.</p><p>So profitability and growth may happen or they may not. But what will happen is an openness, vitality, and creativity that will have you and the team operating at a whole new level. That I can promise you.</p><p>It’s the difference between a river that’s allowed to flow and one that isn’t.</p><h3><strong>THE HARDEST THING</strong></h3><p>If the <em>organic approach </em>is so promising, why is it so rare?</p><p>Because it requires a level of <strong>trust </strong>that we are unaccustomed to.</p><p>When you’re aligned with <em>flow</em>, it will take you beyond where you’re comfortable. It will bend and turn in ways you could never predict. It will move you into new areas of exploration, into new kinds of clients and products. It may slow you down before speeding you up again. It may have you expand then shrink then expand again. It will move you to something new just when you got comfortable with the old. It’s impossible to control, to pin down, and command.</p><p>In our culture, we think the absolute hardest thing is intense effort and discipline. To have the discipline to work day in and day out. To always be “on.” To smile when you don’t want to. To work when you need to rest. To have clients you dislike and to travel to places you’re not interested in. To do it all in the name of growth or success or some noble cause. And to do it until you’re spent and have nothing left to give.</p><p>Believe it or not, that’s not the hardest thing.</p><p>The hardest thing is to be clinging to a rock in the middle of a vast rushing current. Stuck there. Without seeing the safety of the riverbank. Without knowing where the river leads. Without knowing the terrain or what lies ahead. Without control or authority. Without knowing if you’re prepared. Without knowing how you’ll have to move and transform and evolve.</p><p>But you let go.</p><p>You trust.</p><p>And you let the <em>flow</em> take you.</p><h3><strong>THE EASIEST THING</strong></h3><p>If you’re clinging to the way things should be or to certain outcomes or to specific people, then you are out of alignment with <em>flow</em>.</p><p>To let go into <em>flow</em> — to trust it after years of forcing and blocking — may be the hardest thing.</p><p><strong>But being aligned with <em>flow</em> is the easiest thing</strong>.</p><p>When there is <em>space</em> for it to move you and your organization, everything begins to work naturally at a new level. The organic approach has that kind of power.</p><p>That doesn’t mean it won’t require effort, intentionality, or discipline a lot of the time. Of course it will. But even those are done within a different context.</p><p>They are done within the context of <em>flow</em>.</p><p>They have the feeling and tone of <em>flow</em>.</p><p>They have the quality of anything that’s done in alignment with the real source of success.</p><h3><strong>WHAT’S NEXT</strong></h3><p>So there you have it. That’s the heart of the organic approach.</p><p>I left nothing out — not in any fundamental sense at least. No secrets, no hidden steps, no up-sell after you read this to get the “inside scoop” from me. This is it. There’s no inside scoop.</p><p>Now of course there are numerous applications of this approach to the numerous aspects of business. What does leadership look like in an organic organization? What do sales and marketing look like? What about meetings? Culture? Financial targets? Investor relations?</p><p>But once you get the heart of this approach, it flows from there into all the applications.</p><p>It can help to talk with someone though. I’ve been putting this approach to work as a consultant for over 5 years. As you can imagine it’s a unique kind of work, much closer to an inquiry and investigation than coming ready-made with answers. Together, we find space for flow, we align with it, and allow it to unlock the new.</p><p>If you want to talk, reach out to me.</p><p>If not, then go where the flow is. That’s what I would tell you to do anyways.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=77104bd9b017" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conversation between Nathaniel Branden & Werner Erhard]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/conversation-between-nathaniel-branden-werner-erhard-332c5a6eb43b?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/332c5a6eb43b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nathaniel-branden]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[historical]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ontology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Jul 2020 23:51:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-29T00:28:53.244Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/0*jDl_4Q6rSHxupqMf.jpeg" /><figcaption>Nathaniel Branden (1970s)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Nathaniel Branden</strong> (1930–2014) was a Canadian-American psychologist and writer known as the “father of the self-esteem movement.” He was also known for being an associate of the Russian-American philosopher Ayn Rand during the 1950s and 60s. His nearly 20 books have been translated into 18 languages with more than 4 million copies in print. He said his mission was to inspire people “to honor their life and happiness.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/397/0*QB3zDrxT2aYWpXb7" /><figcaption>Werner Erhard (1977)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Werner Erhard</strong> (1935) is an American thinker and philanthropist known as the founder of <em>est</em>, which he launched in 1971. In 1977, he co-founded The Hunger Project with singer-songwriter John Denver and physicist Robert W. Fuller. In 1991, he sold the intellectual property of <em>est</em> to his employees who then established the personal growth and development company Landmark Worldwide. More than 2 million people have participated in the programs led by Landmark and its predecessor companies.</p><p>This document is a never-before-published conversation between Nathaniel and Werner that took place in early 1982.</p><p>According to Nathaniel’s personal notes, the two men first met sometime in 1976 when Werner was in New York City to give a talk. In 1978, Nathaniel and his wife Devers had lunch with Werner at the Franklin House in San Francisco, where Werner’s operations were based. The two men were also together later that same year with American psychologist Will Schutz during a filming of the popular Phil Donahue show (I can’t find a copy of this episode anywhere).</p><p>In early 1982, Nathaniel invited Werner over to his home in Los Angeles to discuss a number of themes from Nathaniel’s recently completed book <em>Honoring the Self</em>. Nathaniel recorded the nearly 2-hour conversation for his records.</p><p>Nathaniel’s widow, Leigh Branden, is a friend of mine. Last month, she found the recording in an old box of his archives and sent it to me. She granted permission for me to transcribe and share the conversation publicly. The conversation has not been altered or edited in anyway. I take responsibility for any mistakes or typos.</p><p><strong>Tape — Side 1</strong><br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Turns tape recorder on] Interview with Werner Erhard. January 29, 1982. <br> <br>WERNER: [Laughing, talking to Nathaniel’s wife Devers] Like inviting a trojan horse in.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: What I’m going to do is this. As I mentioned earlier, obviously, at some points, be playing straight man, in that I have an approximate idea… <br> <br>WERNER: [Interrupting, to Devers] Does the cigar smoke bother you?<br> <br>DEVERS: No, not at all.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I have an approximate idea of your ways of looking at certain things, but first of all, I don’t want to assume I know.<br> <br>WERNER: [Laughing] That’s nice. That’s unusual.</p><p>DEVERS: I’m going to take pictures too. <br> <br>WERNER: Some of the pictures of you two guys are really, really fabulous. Where did I see… Oh, the one on the book. Is it on the book? Yeah, this is very good. So is the one in the other room. [Laughing] I want you to know I had never taken a good photograph until…<br> <br>NATHANIEL: There was a beautiful one of you in the [est] Graduate Review.</p><p>WERNER: Yeah? OK. Maybe it’s my perspective.</p><p>NATHANIEL: We are very poor judges of ourselves. Devers and I always disagree on which of my pictures should be used for publicity purposes. I hate…</p><p>DEVERS: He wants to be very serious and tense.</p><p>NATHANIEL: In any event…</p><p>WERNER: [To Devers] This is a nice picture. Because it’s got quality to it. It’s obviously serious and…</p><p>NATHANIEL: What I want to do is ask some fairly simple questions and let you raddle with your permission to at certain points I may say, “OK. Enough. I’m going to re-direct now.” Fair enough?</p><p>WERNER: Yeah. This is your ball game and I’m playing in it. So you tell me what you want and I’m pleased to do it that way.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Thank you. Thank you. I’m fascinated by the fact… I guess part of my first question spins out of my knowledge of your interest for example in Zen and the influence which it’s had. Zen has had a very profound influence on the whole field of psychology. I’m intrigued by the fact that the word “ego” is of course Latin for “I.” Ego enjoys a very bad press in the world. It enjoys a bad press in religion. It enjoys a bad press often, not always, in philosophy. Certainly, it enjoys a bad press in transpersonal psychology. Our mutual friends or acquaintances in the San Francisco area never use that word, almost except in a negative sense. And yet all the word means, in origin, is “I.” Since I know you’re familiar with the phenomenon. I’m interested in your opinion as to why this is so. Why do you think it’s so that ego has acquired such a bad press. Because I don’t think the answer to that is self-evident.</p><p>WERNER: No. I don’t think so either. In fact, it’s really a beautiful question. It’s really totally switched by head when you asked the question the way you asked it. And it’s very interesting. It’s something which I haven’t given any thought Nathaniel, so I’ll have to think about the question. But my first reaction was that there was something off and people were looking for something to lay it on. And perhaps the understanding of the aspects of self were such that there wasn’t much around and so that was the one that was there most prominently, namely “I”-ness. And it might have gotten off on that sort of… So, my sense is that something’s wrong and that’s how ego got its bad name. But that’s pure guess work and historically I have no idea about the answer. But I don’t think you were finished with the question anyhow. Go ahead.</p><p>NATHANIEL: This is a good opening. Let’s develop this a little further. Because it’s so endemic among people that we know personally or know in common, what I’ll loosely call the whole transpersonal field.</p><p>WERNER: Oh! OK now that’s a little different question. Go ahead.</p><p>NATHANIEL: That is narrower, but let me say this. Let me feed a little more in that might stimulate it. I’m interested in the fact that there is this identification of ego or sometimes of self with only the narrowest, most petty vision of one’s own life, yet there’s nothing in the word which implies that. For example, it’s often the case that people in Eastern religions and philosophies will use “ego” or “self” when they want to refer to maybe an excessive or exclusive concern with not only my material concern, but my material concerns only of today, like it’s an inability to perceive my life globally or anything but the immediate physical dimension. Yet again, there is nothing in the concepts of ego or self which communicates intrinsically any such notion and indeed that notion of ego or self is enormously foreign to me personally. Do you understand what I’m saying?</p><p>WERNER: I understand. The thing which I find fascinating about the question is that your… First off, I think we need to say, and I think we both know this so it’s kind of just a pat on the head, that we’re not really talking about the word because we could be talking about “x” — at least I don’t think we’re talking about the word.</p><p>NATHANIEL: You’re right.</p><p>WERNER: But that — this word — which was inherently neutral to begin with, one would think, has taken on all these pejorative senses. And your question as I understand it is why did it take on these pejorative senses since it was… Now maybe there is something pejorative around, but why that word took on those pejorative senses. Why don’t we leave that word neutral? Why don’t we leave this “I” thing neutral? And say “X” is this pejorative thing. Why did we mix them together so to speak? That was what I got out of the question, which I never thought about before, which I think is a very interesting point.</p><p>So, just to respond — and now this is a little more than off the top of my head like the first one was — in part, there is an analogy. And the analogy would be that you have an automobile out in the front and somebody says “There is this new thing called the automobile and it gets you around to wherever you want to go and you don’t have to wait for it at the corner and it runs night and day. Not only that, but it’s a kind of enjoyable mode of getting to grandmother’s or wherever you’re going. And it’s out front and here’s the key.” So one takes the key, goes out front, starts it up, and grabs the rearview mirror and drives away with the rearview mirror in one’s hand because one has an incomplete awareness of this thing called the automobile so you can’t differentiate one aspect of it from another. And it works to some degree, it runs, and it often gets down to the bottom of the hill, usually there are a couple of crashes along the way and very rarely does it ever really get to grandmother’s, but it gets you closer to grandmother’s than you were when you started.</p><p>I have exactly the same notion about the totality of selfhood — of which ego is either another name or a part, depending on how the word is used. That we, as a people, human beings, have generally so little, so dim an awareness of the totality of selfhood, and the various aspects of it and the parts and the way they work, and that the steering wheel is used — though it turns left and right — than the rearview mirror and we’re kind of crashing through life in this mostly unsatisfying way, not unsuccessful, but unsatisfying way, and not too damn successful globally either. I mean a few of us have had a lot of success, but if you take the totality of 4.6 billion people there is damn little success as well.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Agreed.</p><p>WERNER: There’s an enormous confusion between success and satisfaction for most people. We don’t have good words for it. If we were so dimly aware of automobiles as we are of the totality of selfhood, the world of driving would be ridiculous. And we are that dimly aware of the world of selfhood. And now I want to draw another analogy. And that’s the analogy of the African herdsman who looks at cattle and sees, I think, 21 distinctly different, discernable states of brown. Whereas I look at the same cattle and see brown cattle.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Very good analogy.</p><p>WERNER: He, from those distinctions, knows exactly when that cattle needs water, whether he can walk to them water, when he needs to start walking them to the water, which one is sick, which one is healthy, which one is pregnant, which one isn’t pregnant, which one is this, which one is that, which one is the other thing. If I got dropped into the herdsman’s job, all of my cattle would be dead in short order.</p><p>NATHANIEL: That’s right.</p><p>WERNER: Because — and I want to make this one point Nathnaiel because I think it’s fundamental — because of a phenomenon which I’m going to label “discrimination.” I lack discrimination. And what discrimination is is the ability to draw distinctions. We are highly discriminate. That is so say, we can draw important, fundamental distinctions in an automobile. But in the domain of selfhood, we are rotten at discrimination. Our distinctions are fuzzy, arguable, for the most part merely conceptual, rather than actual. And for me, the whole mish-mash that ego and the confusion that you’re pointing at represents is a function of this dim awareness.</p><p>NATHANIEL: OK. I think the point is absolutely valid and I think the herdsmen is of course aware that his survival requires the ability to make discriminations. The world in which we live we need to make discriminations of other kinds, given the environment that we need to deal with. Whenever you’re trying to think about a concept, it’s always useful to remember — speaking of discrimination — as contrasted with what? Meaning, what is the alternative? <br> <br>WERNER: [Laughing] Right.</p><p>NATHANIEL: In a certain sense, when somebody says, “Life is good”. In a certain sense, even that I God knows feel most of the time, there’s a certain sense in which it’s a very strange proposition philosophically. As contrasted with what? [Laughing] What am I comparing it to? What is it that’s not good by comparison to which I’m saying this.</p><p>Anyway, “ego” or “I” is used basically one of two ways that I’m aware of. Either in differentiation from “we” or “you” or “non-ego” meaning “me” and “non-me”. Then there is a further sub-division either “I” and “we” or “I” and “you.” Alright?</p><p>WERNER: Alright. So I got the first distinction which is either “me” or “not-me.” But what is the other one?</p><p>NATHANIEL: “Me” or “not-me.” Or sometimes “ego” is used not to differentiate “me” and “not-me,” but “I” as contrasted with “we.” OK?</p><p>WERNER: OK.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Then that is the social use of the word “ego.” Then there is the metaphysical use of the word “ego,” in which the opposite pull of ego is as it were the universe or existence or the totality of things. So, that in effect we talk about losing the ego and experiencing the oneness of everything. Which is then the metaphysical sense. Now, what’s fascinating is that if one looks — to go back to the social for a moment — at all the cruelty and harm which human beings do other human beings, in terms of murder, expropriation, torture. The crimes committed in the name of “ego” or “self” are truly microscopic set against the crimes committed in the name of “we” or “us.” Because all the great butcheries of history, all the great barbarisms of history, are never — I mean, you could say to somebody who kills somebody or tortures them or chops their eyes out because he is personally angry at him — that is a spit in the ocean compared to what people do once it’s for a great cause or the true faith. True?</p><p>WERNER: That’s right.</p><p>NATHANIEL: What is very interesting though is “we” never got a bad name.</p><p>WERNER: Yeah. Interesting.</p><p>NATHANIEL: “We” never got a bad name. For example, early on, the first time when you and I were guest speakers at the YPO several years ago, and a woman in the audience was — it was interesting to me — raising a challenge against you, which is raised by many people who work in what I’ll call loosely call “folk appeal,” whatever that is, [joking] “I’m waiting to find out when I grow up what I’m going to do.” [Werner laughing]</p><p>In any event, what she said was something to the effect of — this is a paraphrase, not a quote — “Inculcation occurs with self-realization. Aren’t you in your own way encouraging selfishness?” One of my criticisms of many people in the human potential movement is how defensive they and how helpless they are when the specter of narcissism or the “Me” generation, as though it was some illicit activity. As though if encouraging people to move in the direction of expanded consciousness or self-fulfillment or anything which would contribute to their enjoyment of life or sense of their own fulfillment. This is somehow kind of an illicit activity which you have to apologize for or justify in terms of something else.</p><p>Here again what is interesting to me is that I don’t see a conflict between self and the other. I reject the whole notion of a conflict as I assume you would. But what’s interesting is that as soon as the issue is put in contention at all, low man on the totem pole is always — see the individual is always at the low end of the stick. And that is what I’m inviting you to meditate on with me or reflect on. Namely why it is that throughout history individual has always been low man on the totem pole.</p><p>WERNER: Yeah, it’s interesting Nathaniel because your question really reflects to some degree the difference in our approaches and what interests me here is that you’re actually bringing up questions which I have not considered.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Joking] Well then you must feel very indebted to me.</p><p>WERNER: [Laughing] I do. But what it reflects for me is the distinction or the difference in our approaches to things. Which is useful to me because it helps me to begin to understand where what you say comes from. And for me that’s actually senior to what anybody is saying. So that’s great.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I feel the same way about you in this context so that’s good. That’s good. <br> <br>WERNER: First off, let me make some comments to get me up to your question. I’ll probably make 3 or 4 and I think they’ll seem unrelated, but when they’re done they’ll come together.</p><p>The first comment is that I don’t like psychology very much as a discipline. I don’t like it very much as a discipline because I think that it is less than effective in understanding and empowering and giving insights into and enabling motions forward the area of my interest. Now, I’m back into playing psychology to some degree because the assumption is that what I’m doing has something to do with psychology and therefore I ought to be able to explain myself in psychological terms and therefore psychologists will understand what I’m doing, etc. I think psychology is great as psychology. And I’m not versed in it enough to be a critic of it in its own right. But I’m versed about my own things to be a critic of it in terms of the light it sheds or the darkness it makes in my own realm, so I have that kind of a problem. Recently I’ve begun to study philosophy again and that’s a lot richer in terms of helping me to understand what I’m interested in, shedding light on it, enabling breakthroughs, and so on and so forth. That’s statement number 1. <br> <br>Statement number 2. From the beginning of <em>est</em>, I kept trying to say — it was like a voice shouting in the wilderness — “This is not the human potential movement!”</p><p>NATHANIEL: Let me reassure you that maybe I had aired on the side of using shorthand. Because I understand you. I am not a great admirer of the field of psychology myself. It’s a kind of a shorthand because we lack a certain language.</p><p>WERNER: No. I know that you and I are on the same wavelength.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I completely understand what you’re saying.</p><p>WERNER: Yes. I know you do. I actually know that without you telling me because I know a little bit about your history and I know about your expression. So you and I might say different things about what I just said, but I know you would immediately understand what I’m saying. Let me say that I respect psychology in its own right. I certainly respect the human potential movement in its own right. And I have never thought that what we were doing was human potential.</p><p>I want to make the distinction about human potential and what we’re up to. Human potential is grounded in the notion of subjectivity. Grounded there. It’s grounded in the notion that there is some potential to be actualized. The pre-suppositional structure of the work that I’ve done is the antithesis of both of those notions. It’s not anti-subjective. It’s simply not subjective. And it’s based on the notion that there is <em>nothing</em> to start with rather than there is potential to start with. And it goes on from there.</p><p>For instance, operationally I’ll give you a distinction although this is only an example. The human potential movement, at least in a large part of its history, rejected intellectuality, and we’ve always embraced it. And that’s a kind of operational distinction. OK so much for those 2 [statements].</p><p>The last statement is that: if not the most important issue than certainly one of the two or three most important issues in all the work that I’ve done is this whole issue which you just brought up. I first off want to re-state what the issue is for me so that I’m talking out of my place to talk and you see where it fits into the question rather than my trying to figure out exactly what your question presupposes as a structure. I’m talking about the totality of the domain called “Self-hood.” I want to make sure that it’s clear that I distinguish Self and individual, so that Self and individual are not synonymous, in fact, they are unequivocally not synonymous for me.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: Oh, I understand that fully. In the sense in which you capitalize Self. I’m talking about self with a small ‘s’ and very often use Self with a large ‘S’ to have an entirely separate meaning, so I’m with you completely in my understand of that. Maybe I should mention one thing that could be useful here. This is really — from my point of view — a philosophical discussion and not at all a psychological discussion. I think one of the most intelligent comments that Fran Dever [?] gave me when he read <em>The Psychology of Romantic Love</em>, he said, “You know you really have done a magic act. This is a book of philosophy disguised as a book on psychology which is disguised as a book on romantic love. And it’s really a part of the development of a vision of life for which romantic love is the vehicle through which you’re operating.” So that in many ways, I feel that I am more basically a philosopher than a psychologist.</p><p>WERNER: Well, and your background would argue for that too. Not only that, but the precedents in the field of psychology are that. I mean James, who was more or less the father of the whole thing…<br> <br>NATHANIEL: That’s right. So I’m very much out of step with contemporary psychology, certainly, as you correctly with the anti-intellectualism of the human potential movement. This really for me is a philosophical conversation and maybe it’ll become a sociological one in a few minutes. But I’m not experiencing you yet as coming head on. Because forget labels for a moment and let’s go back to something…</p><p>WERNER: [Interrupting] No, as I said that part of the conversation was only to get me up to your question.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: Oh, then I beg your pardon, I cut in too soon. I apologize. <br> <br>WERNER: And the 3 or 4 things turned into 3 things that I wanted to say just to get me up to the question… so, Nathaniel say the question for me one more time. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] The question was we’re still exploring why it is that politically, ethically, religiously, philosophically, with some very rare exceptions, in the real world, the world in which we all live or die, smile or bleed, which is the only world that interests me in the end. A very important point. We are bombarded almost from the day of birth. “Listen kid, I’ve got news for you. Life is really not about you. It’s about something else.” What is the very first meaning when you call a child “good” or you say he “behaves”? What it means is: your first introduction to the word “good” is that you conform to somebody else’s expectations. “He is a good boy.” “He minds me.” “She is well-behaved.” What the hell does all that mean? It’s all variations on the theme of conformity and obedience.</p><p>WERNER: So the question — fundamentally — is: why does the “I” always take the rap, rather than the “we”? Is that…<br> <br>NATHANIEL: I’m asking you: you work with thousands of people, you work in a different arena, but you cannot do what you do without — at some level — these issues intersecting with what you do. Right?<br> <br>WERNER: Oh absolutely. They intersect massively. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: Right. They intersect in many, many different ways. Organizationally, in the seminars and such, so I’m really asking you to kind of just ruminate, almost viscerally, I’m not expecting any kind of philosophical… but just on that gut level of interacting with thousands and thousands of people and seeing the operation of this, you’ll have to have some sort of impressions. <br> <br>WERNER: Well, essentially, the glue for that view is inculturation. I didn’t say it started there, but I say what keeps it in place is that the environment is organized and you just gave the example about — you get patted on the back for behavior which enhances everybody else, you get at best begrudging acknowledgement for behavior which enhances “I”, even if the behavior does no harm to anyone else, or even if the behavior benefits others, if you have benefited royally then the appreciation is only grudging.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Right. That’s a very good way to put it.</p><p>WERNER: As I said, the thought police, the shapers of opinion, in this culture, reinforce that so that those of us who reflect those shapers of opinion reinforce that which each other. And I’m not talking about that as the starting place, that’s just the environment in which we operate. In a lot of ways, it’s really manipulating the individual personal drives and needs so as to produce behavior which is essentially contributing outside individual personal needs and so on and so forth. It’s a kind of true inauthenticity. In other words, “A” gets “B” to behave for the benefit of “We” utilizing motives which are inherent to “A,” not motives that are inherent to “A” for “B.” For instance, people are charitable because of the acknowledgement that it brings to them as an individual. That’s essentially inauthentic for me.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Yeah, agreed.</p><p>WERNER: [Pauses, thinking] …I’m trying to work my way down to the source of it.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Well, you may not actually have an opinion. One answer is, “Nathaniel, I agree with your description of the phenomenon and I don’t at this moment have an opinion as to its origins.” That’s a completely valid answer.</p><p>WERNER: Oh yeah, sure! Which is what I meant when I said, “You’re asking me questions in areas that I’m interested in and have thought about, but you’re asking the questions from directions that I haven’t looked at.” So I’m trying to work my way through the answer to the question to see what the hell is there.</p><p>DEVERS: Let me ask you a question. Why do you suppose Werner Erhard — “I” — who has really capitalized, I think, “I”, has really gotten so much rap and has been set apart and at times what does it make you feel not being “we”?</p><p>WERNER: That’s good. There are really two domains in which I got something to say there. The one area is — actually they’re the same area, but they’re looked at from two different sides. We were looking in a group with whom I was looking at this with, it happened to be the other [est] trainers and me, at why behavior was unacceptable or rejected or more accurately or more often misinterpreted. And the answer that we came to and it really fit for me after I looked at it carefully, is that in this culture no one is allowed to be “holy.” There are no “holy men” in this culture. You must have an explanation of yourself which does not include that you are in any way “holy.” That is to say you must have a structure of explanation of motives, which when backed down to who the hell is doing this and what their motives are, that there is nothing holy about it.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Not only that, but that there is in some sense base.</p><p>WERNER: Yes. Precisely. Therefore, if in fact, there is any expression which is holy — and I’m going to try to get into what I mean by “holy” in a little bit — if in fact there is an expression which holy, you either have to be inauthentic by representing it as something else in the explanation of your motives and who you are, or you have to be attacked if you are either not explaining yourself as a way of not being authentic or God forbid in anyway explaining yourself accurately and honestly. That’s part of the answer to the question you asked.</p><p>DEVERS: Yes.</p><p>WERNER: I think it’s really fundamental. This culture denies any innate holiness. What do I mean by “holy” and why does the culture deny? And to go back to the answer to your question initially. I’m going to repeat myself so I’m just going to do it in 1 or 2 sentences.</p><p>Because of the total — fundamental — and therefore total misapprehension of what Self is, all of this stupidity falls out. Again, I’ll use the analogy of the automobile. If we were as dimly aware of the automobile as we are of the Self, can you imagine the body of explanation and the disciplines that would come into existence to explain why automobiles didn’t work and why there were crashes and why nothing happened, when a simpleton could come along and say, “Don’t steer with the rearview mirror. Take your hands off the rearview mirror. Put your hands onto the steering wheel and steer with the steering wheel.”</p><p>Now, until someone came along and made that little stupid instruction, it’s not even a distinction yet, but just instruction, can you imagine the gurus and the scientific disciplines and the bodies of knowledge that would come along to explain how to make automobiles work and the bullshit that would be existent until that one little distinction was drawn by someone who could then give intelligent instruction, not to mention, perhaps go on to reveal the distinction, not to mention, go on to reveal that the whole problem was one of distinction.</p><p>So the answer to the question: why does the “I” always take the rap and the “we” never? Why is “I” always the fall guy? Why is there no room for “I”? I say that the answer to that is a fundamental and therefore total mis-getting of Self and the disciplines, the mores, and all that other stuff that comes up from that mis-getting is the stuff that you’re attempting to clarify by writing about and working on and it’s really the fundamental answer to why that junk is there.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Then would it be fair to summarize — I sort of want to move on, I feel a bit of [time] pressure — would it be fair to summarize that what you seem to be saying is that, at least provisionally, that you see the issue in terms of simply a consequence of an inadequate or faulty or a failure actually to understand what self and ego are or mean or entail?</p><p>WERNER: Yes.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Good.</p><p>WERNER: But I want to make it real clear as in something so simple — at the first level — as something so simply as trying to drive your automobile effectively with your hands steering on the rearview mirror. And then at a deeper level, a deeper misunderstanding, that given the basic lack of insight and appreciation, you will then build a world which looks like this world.</p><p>NATHANIEL: That’s right.</p><p>DEVERS: I would like you to add your explanation of a holy man because I feel that’s very important. The threatening quality of the “I” to the “we.” <br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Joking] Yes. What I need from you Werner, I want to cultivate your ability to speak aphoristically — in one liners. <br> <br>DEVERS: [To Werner] What is a holy man to you?<br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Joking] One of the characteristics of a holy man is that they zing one-liners. [Laughing] You understand?</p><p>DEVERS: I’m assuming because of who you are that you are a “holy man”? Speak to me as a holy man. The difficulties of an “I” when it’s much easier to be a “we.” <br> <br>WERNER: First off, we need to understand that what I mean by “holy man” is that which everyone is ultimately. [Devers laughing] I mean that. Oh, absolutely I mean that.</p><p>NATHANIEL: That sounds awfully close to “potential.”</p><p>WERNER: No, no. First off, you have to understand that it’s hard to talk in aphorisms because I’m essentially trying to do violence — that is to say, to break up — the whole structure from which the questions come.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I understand. I’m playing with you, the distinction we did “ultimately” and “potentially.” I’m just playing with you a little bit. I’m fully aware of the distinction.</p><p>WERNER: I think that more conversation in the paradigm of misunderstanding always, only deepens the misunderstanding.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Absolutely. As witness: any marriage.</p><p>WERNER: Exactly. So that my conversation is always intended — I didn’t say always does — but is always intended to do damage to the paradigm.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Please believe, I can’t prove it, then I’d have to give a lecture. But I really do understand that.</p><p>WERNER: [Laughing] Yes, I know you do.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: Now consider this…</p><p>DEVERS: [Interrupting] I want your answer to the holy man!</p><p>WERNER: A holy man — holy person — is distinguished, in part, by expressing him or herself in terms of where they’re coming from rather than in terms where they’re attempting to get to. So that when human beings are trying to get somewhere, they are what I call “motivated.” There is always a “because” which explains why they did what they did. When a human being knows whence they come, there is no “because,” where they’re coming from and the expression are one. There is no motive. There is no reason for doing it. Anymore than a flower has a reason for blooming — now, that’s only analogous, that’s not an example, a flower is not a “holy one.” But there’s an analogy in there. So a holy person is a person unmotivated.</p><p>Now here’s the problem with what I just said. The problem with what I just said is that on the dimension of reasons and where-I’m-going-ness, any intersecting action coming not from motive or going-to, can always be interpreted as “motivated.”</p><p>Let me repeat that. If you take the dimension of motivation and you intersect an action from another dimension — let’s say unmotivated — where it intersects, what you will see — the action — you will be able to explain as a motivated action and by explain I mean cogently and self-consistently so that it fits. Always observables from other dimensions when intersecting with the dimension on which the observation is taking place can always be explained in the dimension on which the observation is taking place. You can’t use the rules of that dimension to understand the behavior.</p><p>Which is the whole problem with trying to do quote “scientific” research into some of the things that we’re talking about, which is why this is more philosophy than it is psychology. Because the rules of investigation have to be consistent with the dimension which you’re investigating. You can’t take the rules of one dimension to investigate phenomenon of the other dimension except as they intersect and then you’re always going to get a fit with the dimension on which you’re looking, which proves nothing about the dimension which you’re trying to investigate.</p><p>NATHANIEL: This is of course one of the great faults of contemporary psychology is that it has worked within a grotesquely narrow vision of the total universe, and therefore requires that all of this explanation occur only within a very narrow band. Which is why they all break down at one point or another. <br> <br>WERNER: This answers the question that you [Devers] asked me personally about my own sense of the response that I’ve gotten in the world. I mean I expected and do expect a response because essentially I’m operating from and wish to announce the existence of a dimension which is unperceivable in its truth or actuality from the dimension into which I’m speaking. But that was the name of the game. I knew that was what I was doing to start with. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: A couple of fast observations and then next question. I think that what you said about the issue of holiness and our culture — only having a very limited repertoire of explanations is absolutely true. I think another element or 2 other elements I can think of which bear on my inquiry today is this: one, part of the consequence of the Puritan — should we say Christian ethic, Puritan ethic — is a certain divorcement between valuable achievements and pleasure. Meaning, a certain assumption that if there is not pain involved, then what you’re doing is dubious. [Werner laughs] Truly a very vicious notion, but a very prevalent one.</p><p>WERNER: Yes.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Therefore, if a person is doing something which at one level seems to be offering a human service, yet at another level does not appear to be entailing some momentous self-sacrifice on the person who is doing it, it is ethically suspect at the very least. That brings us right back to the start of this whole conversation. Collaterally with that, because I regard the animus against profit as a special case of the animus against the individual, if you are doing something which is useful to people and if God forbid you are earning your living, worse still a good living doing something which is useful to people, your motives have to be reducible to something ignoble. Or if not ignoble at least totally devoid of anything deserving admiration. Alright?<br> <br>WERNER: Yes.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Which is why it is a liability in my line of work to, it’s not desirable to appear starving because then you’re regarded as incompetent [Devers laughing], but it’s very funny a client will have to work through a lot of negative feelings coming up — now that I’m using that as a facility to see people in — where they’re getting off on dealing with “I’m coming for assistance and I see two God damn Mercedes in the driveway.”</p><p>WERNER: [Joking] A holy man doesn’t have two Mercedes, we all know that!<br> <br>DEVERS: [Joking] Camels maybe, but not Mercedes. <br> <br>WERNER: [Laughing] Very good. That’s a good little aphorism there.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] OK. I’m going to move very fast now and I hope we can compress because…<br> <br>WERNER: [Interrupting] Let me make one comment on the thing that you said. That is a real detriment to people who don’t have 2 Mercedes. That whole structure of thinking keeps them…<br> <br>DEVERS: [Interrupting] From getting a Mercedes!</p><p>WERNER: Not only keeps them from getting a Mercedes, but keeps them from having any satisfaction in their lives. Really.</p><p>NATHANIEL: That’s right.</p><p>WERNER: It’s very deeply destructive.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Yes. I don’t have any children of my own. I have grown daughters through Devers, but none of my own. But many years ago, somebody asked me if I had a child what would I most want to teach that child. And I never thought about it consciously until the question was flung at me more or less involuntary meaning spontaneously. I said number one — the fun of using your own powers, of using what you’ve got. And secondly, never allowing a split — using your own powers in a way that is personally pleasurable to you and the process of earning a living. Never regarding work as some onerous duty, apart from the process of the enjoyment of life.</p><p>WERNER: That’s a hell of a book [title] by the way: What Would You Teach Your Child? <br> <br>NATHANIEL: Right. To earn your living doing something that you love doing, if you’re able to do that, you have licked certainly one of the great issues of being human. That’s just an aside. Next question. I was listening a year or two ago to you being interviewed and here I’m definitely being straight man. I’m going to be provocative — moderately — to get a rise out of you. <br> <br>WERNER: Whatever go ahead. You can be very provocative. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: Werner Erhard is being interviewed on New Dimensions and he’s asked, “Will taking your program or seminar facilitate the process of people getting what they want out of life?” And Werner Erhard said, with some degree of polite impatience, if not to say contempt in his voice…</p><p>WERNER: [Laughing] I hope it’s not so obvious to everybody else, but go ahead…</p><p>NATHANIEL: It’s very obvious to me sweetheart. If there’s anything in this world I know it’s the human voice. Anyway, he says, “What people want is of no importance whatsoever. What I am teaching has got really nothing to do with aiding people in getting what they want because I don’t think what they want is of any importance.” Now, I’m listening and saying, “I know a context in which that might be said, in which people want a lot of naughty and — ” <br> <br>WERNER: [Interrupting] –nonsense. They want what they don’t want is what I was trying to say. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: But you didn’t succeed!<br> <br>WERNER: [Laughing] OK. I didn’t say I succeeded! <br> <br>NATHANIEL: I want you to imagine that 22-year-old Albert Einstein is sitting here beside me and is listening. And he says, “What the hell does this man mean? What I want most is to understand how the universe works. Is this mother telling me that what I want is unimportant?” So then I thought to myself, “Well, Werner would probably say, ‘No, no, no. That’s not at all who I’m talking about or what I’m talking about.’”<br> <br>WERNER: That’s correct.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: But then little Albert would say, “But then when you’re talking about what people want, why is it geared toward the schlemiels, meaning I am also the human race!” <br> <br>WERNER: That’s right. And he and you would both know what I meant. Because he would say, if I were to ask him, I happen to know a little about Einstein because he is one of the guys that I’m interested in, that what he wanted was irrelevant as well. That the so called “needs,” the fantasies which are articulated or expressed as “what I want” are of no consequence, should I get them, they wouldn’t satisfy me or make me happy. That what is really important is something a lot more authentic than that, which is what I really want. I make a distinction between what one wants and what one really wants. This happens to be an area in which I’m doing a lot of work. I could have answered Devers about what the hell I’m up to right in this area. It’s the area of vision. So let me tell my little story there. I’m going to get to one place aphoristically and one place delving-ly.<br> <br>To trivialize and therefore speed up the beginning of this thing, I’m going to do a talk on the Self. Very rapidly. So a person wants to know “Who am I?” And the analogy is that they are an onion. And they pick the onion up and they look at it and they say, “Oh! This is who I am. Now let me examine this very carefully. Oh wait, this is only the skin. Good. I’ll take the skin off and see who I really am.” So they peel the skin and they say, “Now I’ve got my self!” And they look at it very carefully and oh my God it’s another skin. Well they know what to do so they take the skin off. They keep taking skins off and getting “Oh this is who I am” and seeing that who I am is another skin. And finally get down to the bottom, they take the last skin off and what there is is <em>nothing</em>. <br> <br>As I said, that’s to trivialize this whole talk about the Self and getting back to the Self as nothing, which the Self is. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: Buddha, one thought I want to flash in here fast: I’m with you. I would say after you peel away the last skin, the Self is who asks the question.</p><p>WERNER: OK. Fine. That’s good.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] Carry on! Carry on!</p><p>DEVERS: [Interrupting, to Werner] Want some coffee? Want some hot coffee?</p><p>WERNER: Yes please. Thank you.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I would adore some. Thank you. <br> <br>DEVERS: [Joking, to Nathaniel] You would adore some?<br> <br>NATHANIEL: You didn’t ask me, but… [Werner laughing] I would adore some.</p><p>WERNER: So I just did the most important thing I could talk about aphoristically.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: You did it beautifully.</p><p>WERNER: So we’re starting with the Self — to put it into Heideggerian terms, “the clearing” — to put it in another terms, as: that without meaning, that without substance, that without purpose, from which all meaning, purpose, and substance comes. The Self is nothing and it doesn’t mean anything that the Self is nothing. You can’t feel badly about it because if you’re feeling badly about it, you haven’t gotten that the Self is nothing yet. OK starting from there.</p><p>NATHANIEL: That’s small ‘s’ [self] right?<br> <br>WERNER: No that’s big ‘S’ [Self] and small ‘s’ and now… This is the grand…</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Interrupting] Carry on!</p><p>WERNER: Oh wait — no — sorry, by small ‘s’ you mean something closer to “I”-ness?<br> <br>NATHANIEL: Yes.</p><p>WERNER: Fine. Then…<br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Interrupting] I don’t think you want to say that the big “S” [Self] is nothing. Do you?</p><p>WERNER: Oh yes, absolutely. Absolutely! But not the kind of nothing that you’re talking about for the moment. Just let’s leave that alone. We won’t get into it or we’ll get into it later if we get into it.</p><p>The first expression of Self is — coming from nothing, to take a stand on nothing from nothing, that is unmotivated, inexplicable, unreasonable, is one’s vision. We could say what you want. That’s what I mean by what people really want. People however are so far away from themselves, so unaware of themselves, that they mis-identify as themselves the play of thoughts and notions and feelings and attitudes and sensations. They mid-identify that as themselves. Once they do that what they want is of no consequence. That is to say: even if they get it, it won’t mean anything to them, not really, deeply, profoundly. Even if they get it, it won’t mean anything to the world, not really, deeply, and profoundly. That even good things, whatever that means, agreed-on positive things generated from that domain will lack a certain quality of making any difference in the universe, either for “I”, “we”, or any other entity, no matter how quote “good” they are.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: I’m having a little difficulty in how to interpret you. I’d like to make it personal because that’s very primitive. That might help to focus this a little more. The thing is that not only do you have a context that is not the ordinarily shared one, I do too, though it’s a different one perhaps. Therefore, we would really need time to understand each other.</p><p>WERNER: [Laughing] Oh yeah, we’re in real trouble. That’s right. What you said is really beautiful and very, very true. And often leads to misunderstandings with people whom I respect because we don’t make the distinction that neither one of us buys into the consensus.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Joking] It’s like a person from Mars meets a person from Saturn on planet Earth.</p><p>WERNER: [Laughing] That’s exactly right! <br> <br>NATHANIEL: Sometimes I get a clear insight when I tie it to my own personal experience. Let me briefly tell you a story. One of the things that I wanted for a long time — whatever the reasons aren’t important — I wanted to organize my life more and more around writing because I don’t overly enjoy — even though I’m a psychologist — I don’t overly enjoy a lot of involvement with people in a daily sense. The reasons are unimportant now. It all feels too slow for me.</p><p>WERNER: I understand.</p><p>NATHANIEL: So when I’m with Devers up in Lake Arrowhead [California], I’m really where I’m happiest and most fulfilled in every way. More and more of life has been organized around eliminating workshops, eliminating intensives, doing enough things that I can keep trying on new ideas on, I have…</p><p>WERNER: [Interrupting] Excuse me, I want you to give me 2 sentences before we leave on what you’re going to do this weekend. Are you going to do a workshop?<br> <br>NATHANIEL: Yeah, I’m doing a workshop.</p><p>WERNER: Or if you got a brochure, you don’t even need to tell me, just let me see it.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I’ll give it to you, sure.</p><p>WERNER: [Laughing] Good.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Anyway, when I’m there and we’re taking a walk together or I’m sitting at my desk looking up…</p><p>WERNER: [Interrupting] By the way, I have so total a sense of what you’re saying about yourself there, it’s like you’re evoking in me the experience rather than drawing me a picture of it.</p><p>NATHANIEL: OK good. I have said to Devers many times when we’re maybe just sitting or I come downstairs and we’re playing music or out for a walk, I say, “I don’t know what the fuck anybody wants out of life, but for me, this is it. I have nowhere to go from here!” Meaning, I’m not looking forward to the future. I’d love to have more of the same. I’d love us to have a long life together. But I don’t have the fantasy, really…</p><p>WERNER: [Interacting] Your life is not about what isn’t. At that moment, at least, it’s about what is. Not that there won’t be a what isn’t — a future.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: Right. There’s always new things, but the things now are new relative to 2 years ago.<br> <br>WERNER: Right. Exactly. I understand this state totally. You have communicated way beyond the amount of time it took you to say that and way beyond the words.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] OK. Thank you. So yesterday, I finished the new book [<em>Honoring the Self</em>]. I wanted to get my life stripped down. I got rid of a lot of so called friends, I really simplified my professional life. I knocked off a lot of things. So this is something that I wanted to do and when I do this daily existence will be more satisfying than when I am doing this. I projected a certain goal, I planned it out, I did it, and lo’ and behold, just as I thought, everything was more terrific. Now…</p><p>WERNER: [Interrupting] Now excuse me for one second, I must make a comment here. It concerns me that the source of this outcome is slightly different than that which you’re going to credit.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Oh, OK fine. We’re coming to the jist of it — we were 60 seconds away from that.</p><p>WERNER: OK good. Go ahead!</p><p>NATHANIEL: All I know is I know what conditions, I’m very jealous or resentful of what my mind has to be engaged with. [joking] I feel my most precious possession is my consciousness, not my virginity. [Werner laughing] And I’m really jealous about what anybody asks me to think about or… I know you’ll understand that.</p><p>WERNER: Oh absolutely.</p><p>NATHANIEL: OK good. So yesterday I finished this book and I feel like doing something, and so we go out to a nice place for dinner. And in the middle of talking there — I forget how it happened — I just wanted, Christ I really feel good, I want something which I can’t quite articulate yet, to mark this day of my life. We’re talking about the book, in connection with which this interview is happening, a book called <em>Honoring the Self</em>. And we get talking about I’m stuck on the right way to open it, to get into it. For me, I think very musically when I write, in terms of how I…</p><p><strong>[End of Side 1]</strong></p><p><strong>Tape — Side 2</strong><br> <br>NATHANIEL: …I had no idea if Devers would understand me or not. So I began to tell her this very spacey idea I had, totally unlike anything I’ve done before, and a lot of my readers would be surprised that I would come at it from this angle. Well, she immediately got where I was coming from. We had this fantastic conversation. Last night — it was very exhilarating — I was lying in bed, looking up at the ceiling, feeling absolutely happy, meaning, thinking, now, as long as I live, some days are happier than others. One of the things that one lives for happened between us tonight.</p><p>I have like pictures of the look on her face when we’re talking, what I was feeling, the visions for the book in my mind. And the feeling that the thing flowing between us and feeling that whatever happens tomorrow whatever happens next week — if a bomb falls, whatever the hell happens — this is life as I understand it. Now, I am aware that the basic condition of happiness is satisfaction resides as a capacity within the person and that it’s not something that the environment gives you in the obvious sense and that is of course the great mistake that people make is that they don’t understand what the source of the enjoyment of life is. You have to first be a person who is able to enjoy life that precedes what people call their victories, it doesn’t follow it.</p><p>WERNER: Yeah. Very good. I would ascribe your state more to your awareness of that which is kind of what you’re saying.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Oh damn right. Damn right. It’s like–making a fast analogy here — when people ask me about my view on romantic love and why it’s a relatively rare phenomenon in the terms in which I discuss it. You have to be a passionate person prior to meeting or falling in love.<br> <br>WERNER: [Laughing] That’s right. Right.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] You don’t take two nebbishes and then they meet — except in the movies — and then suddenly they get transformed. Two zeroes cannot transform each other. Two entities can enhance something which already exists, but they can’t… Anyway, my point back to you is very simple. Probably you can already anticipate the direction of my question. These are wants and when they are actualized — the things that I said that I want, I don’t feel later sour or like “Oh, that wasn’t it” meaning I really feel…</p><p>WERNER: [Interrupting light-heartedly] No, but you’re well-being waiting to happen! See, your story is…<br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Interrupting] You understand what I’m asking.<br> <br>WERNER: Absolutely. Your story is for me irrelevant. You could tell 20 different stories and the outcome would be the same. It doesn’t make any difference that you’re doing less, see, it’s not that you’re doing less of the things that are less stimulating for you and that’s one of the problems I got with psychology, is that psychologists, do this bullshit, and I mean bullshit in a very specific sense. Let me define bullshit. Bullshit is communication that makes no difference.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] Alright.<br> <br>WERNER: It’s the difference between let’s take one more comment about this issue. Let’s take the quarterback as the player then let’s compare what the journalist writes about the quarterback’s performance on Sunday with what the coach says about the quarterback’s performance on Sunday. True they both have different intentions but putting that aside. What the journalist says has no impact on the efficacy of the quarterback’s playing — it may change his mood — but it’s not designed to make him more effective. More journalism same effectiveness. The coach — to the degree that he is a good coach — will interact with the player and say something that actually makes a difference in his performance and therefore in his effectiveness.</p><p>So bullshit is the stuff that you say that doesn’t make any difference. It may sound wonderful, people may lap it up, it may stimulate their curiosity, their interest, etc. All that stuff. I’m not interested in that kind of conversation. I’m interested in the kind of conversation that can make a difference. Psychologists say you must do those things in life about which you are passionate. I say that that’s interesting stuff but that’s bullshit. Telling people that doesn’t make any difference in their lives. On the other hand, knowing that you are passionate first or you aren’t and you meet someone with whom you can express the passion or you don’t that makes a difference. Because if I ever get that, I start looking when I have a flat tire at the tires, not at the windshield, to use my old analogy of the cars. So, I explain your…<br> <br>NATHANIEL: [Interrupting] And you know how to review your environment for what’s relevant and appropriate. <br> <br>WERNER: Exactly! So naturally Nathaniel Branden knows how to adjust his environment as this and more of that and open that opportunity, but that’s a trivial comment that he knows how to do that. Anybody given the distinctions that you make about what self, life, one, we, etc. makes will do those things automatically, it’s no big deal that you tuned your radio in to the right station. I mean that’s trivial. That you know how a radio works, that’s nontrivial. That you share with me that it’s station x-y-z and how you get that — that’s trivial. That you share with me how the radio works, that’s profound. So that’s the end of that comment. You know, you are essentially, to put it in my terms, which I don’t think are any better than anyone else’s terms, but since I talk that way, you are I’ll say closer, I don’t mean that as an evaluation, I just mean it as a way to make a general comment…<br> <br>NATHANIEL: I’m not afraid of an evaluation. That’s OK. <br> <br>WERNER: Nah, see I think they’re bullshit so I don’t want to engage in them. I don’t mean this as an evaluation. What I mean is that as a statement about the source of your let’s call it well-being or better yet fulfillment or better yet self-hood is an accurate or a more accurate apprehension grasping of the true nature of self, others, life, however you want to say it, and not what you do. See, I don’t need to write books to be happy and do less seminars and all that other shit. And actually, neither do you. But that isn’t to say Nathaniel that you would have been just as happy had you not retuned your environment, but it’s not that you retuned your environment. That was inevitable given your grasp of the truth about what an automobile is about what self, life — it’s all about. So that’s, yeah. Period. I’m just going to repeat myself if I say anymore.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I think that where this becomes practical and where it makes a difference in my view would be this — is I agree with what you’re saying. Let me tell you where I think it becomes practical. It’s very obvious for example if one would be dealing with children and you want to give them tools — you want to create an environment — but it also implies for example this may sound like a negative consequence.</p><p>When I wrote <em>Romantic Love</em>, for example, a 50 year old man came up to see me after I wrote the book. And what he got from the book was that he wasn’t crazy. That he had been a good boy for too long, putting up with a very unhappy marriage. And what he got was a sanction or a permission, not to spend the rest of his life as unhappily as he spent the last 30 years. So I think there are contexts in which telling people to have more respect for their own internal signals and to pay more attention to what brings them joy or doesn’t or what they really want or don’t want is strategically and practically very important.<br> <br>WERNER: I like the word strategically. That’s right. I think that it is strategically very valuable. And if I didn’t think it was strategically very valuable I wouldn’t be interested in — I would just cut myself off from people who did that. I think it’s enormously valuable. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: You see what I’m saying?<br> <br>WERNER: Absolutely!<br> <br>NATHANIEL: I think that one of the worst of all human vices is passive resignation to suffering. <br> <br>WERNER: So Nathaniel, in part, I’m doing something personal between you and me in attempting to signal the distinction between my respect for something and it being other than what I personally am doing in what I am doing in my work.<br> <br>NATHANIEL: Oh sure! For goodness sake, I don’t assume that if my approach is a valuable one therefore it is the only approach which is valuable and that all people should participate in it. Christ, that never even entered my mind. Tell me, because I’m very interested, can you tell me about Russia and the workshop you’re doing there. <br> <br>WERNER: Essentially what has happened, it’s something about which we want to keep quiet for the moment because it’s essentially a politically or delicate thing, but what happened was that we were afforded an opportunity to interact with a high level Soviet person — the First Secretary of the Soviet Embassy in the United States. Who represents in this country the US/Canada Institute from the Soviet Union — a scientific institute, part of their scientific establishment, sorry the nomenclature escapes me for the moment. We struck up a relationship.</p><p>Now, first off, we were told that the quality of the relationship that we had with this guy is such that it should be a reflection of 8 years of interacting. We’ve been interacting for a little over maybe 2 years. My view of why we have this depth of relationship is, and you want to know that we’ve been very straight with the guy. We’ve taken him to task for everything that we think the Soviets have to be taken to task — and there’s plenty. We’ve tried to be authentic with the guy, we haven’t tried to maneuver him.</p><p>But we’ve done all of it, as an expression of a space from which we are coming, rather than as an expression of something we were trying to get to. And where we’re coming from is very simple. The United States and the Soviet Union are related whether anyone likes it or not. It’s probably one of the most important and fundamental relationships of these times. Now, the guy, kept trying to figure out what we wanted. So at first he tried to figure it out. Then he tried asking us. Then he tried suggesting it. In each case, we weren’t interested. Because always and only, the relationship was an expression of being related, not trying to get something. That’s why I think the relationship happened so powerfully.</p><p>We’ve had 2 exploratory trips to the Soviet Union. And by the way, we shifted our ground from the USA Canadian Institute to the Cybernetics Institute and they are really the people who are looking to do the invitation. The last trip to the Soviet Union was just at the end of last year. We showed a film on the 6th day that — you know there is a lot of stuff to tell you.</p><p>2 things about that trip. Time Magazine had gotten 50 industrialists and financiers from the United States and taken them to the Soviet Union. While they were in the Soviet Union, they attempted to arrange an official reception for them, an invitation to come talk. They could not get it done. Our two little people. One a physician. One is Raz, you guys probably know Raz Ingracia, at least from talking to my office, we’ve worked a long time together. Raz and Jack Mantos, Jack is a trainer. They were invited to come have a conversation. In contrast to way more powerful, etc. Not only invited them, but invited them to show a movie. There has been no American movie shown in the Soviet Union for something like a year and a half. None.</p><p>We have a little bit of a relationship with a guy by the name of Dusko Doder, who is the Washington Post correspondent in Moscow. And Raz asked him “Should we do it?” He said “Are you crazy? Absolutely. It’s an enormous acknowledgement of the interest in your work.” So we showed the thing. They were very, very excited about it. A psychiatrist who they had brought in to say, “Look this is a little more in your field, what are these guys doing?” Supported the thing as absolutely authentic, he said what you saw on the screen was real and happened. This as not a setup or editing. And so the interaction goes on.</p><p>The Soviets are ridiculously difficult for at least us to deal with — because this talk that you and I might have you don’t make the decision about anything, the next level up makes the decision, you report to them, they give you the decision, you tell me the decision. And there’s a lot of other bureaucracy. Essentially you’re dealing with a bureaucracy.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Of course.<br> <br>WERNER: But that’s the way that it is, so if you don’t like it, too bad. And that’s the way they want it to be. So it’s very delicate and it continues to go on very positively. When Jack and Raz were there last their proposal was let us invite you to come and do the est training once and let us see what happens. They said, “Look, you need to know that we’re not willing to keep importing you guys, we’re only willing to look at this if you’re willing to train us to do it.” We said, “Sure, at some point, we’re willing to train you to do it.” The last interaction was between Raz and this guy in the Cybernetics Institute that they should send 2–3 of their people to London or some place to do the training, then we would talk some more about going over there.</p><p>It all hinges around a kind of critical place where they have to do in writing an official invitation for us to come visit them to discuss this work with them. It’s a trivial thing this official invitation. But it seems to be the thing that breaks this thing from going uphill instead of going downhill.</p><p>DEVERS: Do you work through interpreters?<br> <br>WERNER: No there’s enough people there that speak English. They understand that we are not willing to make an agreement with them that they are not going to subvert this to their own use. We’re willing for them to make it available in their country. Now, that doesn’t mean that they have in mind not subverting it to their own use. So there’s this interplay. Anyway, we try to keep in touch with our own State Department to let them know what the hell is going on.</p><p>DEVERS: That’s exciting. Very exciting.</p><p>WERNER: Here’s the thing, it’s a big gamble in terms of it’s very unlikely that something will come out of it. However, the gamble is worth it because if something comes out of it it could truly make a difference — I mean, truly, no shit, make a difference. There’s no question about the fact that the people who have gone through the experience of the training who started out with totally divergent views will come out after the training, still with their totally divergent views, but with an ability to interact with each other.</p><p>And that’s what is missing in the Soviet and U.S. relationship is the ability to interact. Nobody ever thinks the Soviets are going to take our view. We’re not going to win them over to democracy and free market enterprise. And we’re sure as hell not going to take be taken over by their view. But the problem is how do we interact in ways that work and still maintain our separate views. So we think we can make a contribution. Now, like I said, the possibility of it happening is very, very small, but if it does happen the outcome is very, very big…</p><p>We’re also working — you know, we have a center in Israel — and we’re working in that domain. We’re going to start in the Arab world pretty soon. We’re doing north/south stuff. We have a center in Bombay that is very, very, ridiculously successful. While those guys were in Russia, I was in Greece, then we met in India. And we have commitments from the Indian government for formal invitations to work with the government. I actually worked with their planning commission and lots of different government people. And that’s the place where we’ve had a lot of interest for a long time. I mean it started out in the interest in the ordinary stuff, I mean, the holy man stuff in India. But it has really become a commitment to the Indian people and that whole issue there…</p><p>If I can take a minute, there’s a couple things which I don’t think you asked me, but which I want to say about this issue about ego and self and so on and so forth.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Yes, please do.<br> <br>WERNER: These are all maybe nothing you are interested in and I only want to say that at least you have a sense of where I’m coming from. I mean you’re going to use whatever I say in a way that’s appropriate to your book [referring to Nathaniel’s <em>Honoring the Self</em>] and I wouldn’t be here if I wasn’t willing for you to do that.</p><p>First off, just some flat-footed statements. For me, if I wanted to put myself in camp, I would say that I am an existential thinker, not an existentialist. And there is an important distinction there and anyone who is hip to those distinctions will know what I mean. And people who aren’t hip to those distinctions, it doesn’t make any difference. My ground of being is that there are so things which must be said about the self and they must be said with enough accuracy to make driving the car possible. And without these two knowledges — awarenesses — you can’t ever hope to drive the car successfully. The first statement is that ultimately the self is nothing. Or as Heidegger said, a clearing. The self has no position, no place, no time, no form, no expression, no nothing. So there is no meaning — -ultimately there is no meaning and it doesn’t mean anything that there isn’t any meaning. It doesn’t mean anything that it doesn’t mean anything.</p><p>So my view Nathaniel is that until one works one’s way back through the structure to that fundamental place of nothing, one is always off significantly enough to keep it from really making any difference ultimately.</p><p>NATHANIEL: To keep what from making any difference?<br> <br>WERNER: One’s life, one’s contribution, etc.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Are you assuming then that making a difference… I think of life as self-justifying. I think that it’s very difficult to live intelligently or creatively without making a difference. But I think especially in an exchange society, it’s difficult not to in some sense make a difference. But at the same time, I think that life is intrinsically an end-in-itself. It doesn’t need to “make an external difference” in order to be valuable to itself.</p><p>WERNER: No, that’s right.</p><p>NATHANIEL: The most primitive example of what I mean, if you’ll forgive me, is does an orgasm make a difference? Well, I think anybody in their right mind would say, well the question is almost senseless and of no consequence. It’s entirely self-justifying.</p><p>WERNER: But that’s also true about a flower or a tree or anything else.</p><p>NATHANIEL: But let’s stay with human experience.</p><p>WERNER: No, then you and I disagree there to some degree. That a human being has the power to either recognize or imbue qualities to orgasm that animals don’t and therefore the innate validity of orgasm, whole absolutely true and unarguable worth, begs the question of orgasm in human beings. That there is something more to it than what you’re saying. That what you’re saying is totally true, unassailable and that there is something else. I don’t even want to say more because that would imply on top of what you said and therefore somehow alter what you said.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Well you see here is something I really hope we have the opportunity to explore. Because I’m absolutely fascinated in your approach. Absolutely fascinated with this theme of making a difference. Not because I don’t think making a difference isn’t important. But…</p><p>WERNER: [Interrupting] You don’t like it’s inherent-ness and neither do I. I don’t say that it’s inherent. I don’t say that it’s inherently valuable. It’s a construct. I agree.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I mean for example, you have known the experience where, I assume, you take a breath of clean air, and you feel wordlessly maybe, jeez it’s great to be alive. Period. Period!</p><p>WERNER: Period. That’s right! And there’s nothing more to it.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I don’t know how to say this, but I live in that place.</p><p>WERNER; See that’s a quarterback statement. That’s a wonderful quarterback statement. Let me see if I can make this distinction here because it’s very important. That means you’re a good quarterback. Good quarterbacks don’t necessarily make good coaches.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Of course.</p><p>WERNER: Now, good quarterbacks don’t necessarily make good journalists either. I acknowledge you unequivocally as a good quarterback. Now, the question is, about this other domain of coaching and/or journalizing. There’s an expression which is important that quarterbacking wants to become coaching or journalizing — totally up to anybody about whatever the hell they want to do — in which these other notions then become important. They are of no importance to quarterbacking. That is to say, a quarterback is a quarterback. Now, to take any other quarterback and to do something about coaching the other quarterback to be able to realize the state which you as the quarterback do realize may require expressions which you as a quarterback don’t make, but which you as a coach damn well better make.</p><p>NATHANIEL: That’s absolutely true! Absolutely true.</p><p>WERNER: So this whole notion about making a difference is a coaching notion, not a quarterbacking notion.</p><p>NATHANIEL: OK.</p><p>WERNER: See, look, it’s the old argument that Socrates went through when he went to meet the artists and the artisans and the politicians and see what they did, but none of them could tell him anything that would make a difference to anybody else. As a matter fact, what they told him was essentially bullshit — that is to say that it was noise that did not impact the other politicians to become better politicians or more effective politicians. This is getting a little too personal about you and I want to be really, really clear that I am not taking you to task as a coach, I just want to make the distinction between you as a quarterback — and don’t tell me how great you are as a quarterback — when we’re talking about coaching. And I recognize you as a good coach.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] I think the distinction is absolutely valid. I would never accuse you of the arrogance, not to say irresponsibility, which to a lesser mind, could have sounded like you were flirting with for a split instance.</p><p>WERNER: With what?</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] Huh? You got that didn’t you.</p><p>WERNER: For taking you to task?</p><p>NATHANIEL: No, no, no. I’m playing. You didn’t get that one?</p><p>WERNER: The arrogance from which I was flirting.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Yes!</p><p>WERNER: Oh, you see, except that I don’t think it’s arrogant to know something.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Of course not, hey.</p><p>WERNER: Although, in the social sciences you must never say you know anything.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Oh, I know that. The only thing you can know is what other people believe is true. To be an authority is know what other people believe is to true. But to say that something is true is to invalidate yourself.</p><p>WERNER: OK so let me make the other statement. That for me, in order to do effective coaching, not to mention, in order to be a great quarterback or to enable great quarterbacking, you must come to know, not just hear, think, conceptualize, but come to know that ultimately self is a space from which to come — a clearing, nothing. The other statement to complete it. And these two statements don’t merge, but they stand together is that the self is the stand it takes on itself. Self is the stand it takes on itself. Not to know that is to be inauthentic. Now, a lot of inauthenticity is successful because we live in an environment of inauthenticity. But it’s never, ultimately, fulfilling, whole-ing, completing.</p><p>That a lot of people who are whole and complete and fulfilled mis-explain the source of their wholeness and completion and fulfillment because they try to deal with it in the environment of inauthenticity and in that environment — in that domain of inauthenticity — one can in fact make it and one can explain why one made it, but one can never successfully coach making it. One can write and say and do a lot of things which make people feel better and nah nah nah and think this that and the other thing. See, I want, when I’m done reading a book or going to a weekend, I want not to be able to explain better. I want to be better! I don’t even want to be able to do better Nathaniel. I don’t even want a new set of instructions. I want who I am to be — now better is a stupid word — but be better. You know what I mean.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I’m with you a thousand percent.</p><p>WERNER: Now that’s the difference for me between journalism and coaching. Not that I want to dismiss journalism because journalism has its own validity, but it ain’t making better quarterbacks. Journalism doesn’t make better quarterbacks. And by the way, out of that thesis — out of those two fundamental places — then what you mean by ego, or what I mean you to understand by ego, is this self as the stand one takes on ones self. And what other people mean by ego and where the conflict comes and why all this nonsense about which you’re questioning is the mis-identification of the structures of personality or even structures of being — and there I’ll make a distinction between structure of being and being itself. And a mis-identification as self as those.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Yes. Let me give you a very fast example, I was conducting a seminar for Robert Frasier, the California…</p><p>WERNER: [Lightheartedly interrupting, speaking to Devers] This is the difference between conversation with men and women. Women leave a space between each statement. Men leave no spaces.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [To Devers] I’m sorry sweetie, but I’m just super conscious of time. I’m not meaning to be rude.</p><p>WERNER: Listen, I’ve done a little study about this because we really have a problem when we’re trying to have a discussion with men and women and what we discussion is that men are right after the next one. Somehow the women — their cadence is slightly different — this is a generality.</p><p>DEVERS: Would you rather — let’s put it this way — that women respect the fact that other people may want to come in and not be rude and interrupt so they just kind of pause.</p><p>WERNER: Maybe it’s that! But I’d rather…</p><p>DEVERS: [Interrupting jokingly] We could go on talking! We could keep the cadence going! We could keep it going. But we just think maybe, maybe somebody else wants to talk.</p><p>WERNER: No, I didn’t say that you couldn’t keep it going. I’m just talking about the distinction between men and women functionally. I’m not even talking about why.</p><p>DEVERS: Women are always aware of whoever is here, no matter how engrossed they are. I’m always aware of that.</p><p>NATHANIEL: There is greater relationship orientation.</p><p>DEVERS: Yes. I’m always aware there is someone, something else.</p><p>WERNER: They are all explanations of the phenomenon I was describing. I wasn’t trying to explain it, I just want to be clear.</p><p>NATHANIEL: All I was going to say was that I was doing this seminar for this group of graduate students. Bob Frazier [?] said to me — he was in Japan for 5 years studying Zen and aikido — and he said to me, “You know, one of my Zen teachers said to me, ‘It isn’t that we are opposed to ego, but we think of ego as a wild steed to be managed and controlled and directed.’” And I said to Bob, “What an interesting perspective. I think of ego as the force that does the controlling and it would never occur to me to think of ego as the steed. For me, ego is always the ultimate witness.”</p><p>WERNER: For that conversation, I think it’s required only because it’s too guys talking about brown instead of two guys with a model which distinguishes the 21 different kinds of brown.</p><p>NATHANIEL: OK. I don’t disagree with that.</p><p>DEVERS: I wanted to ask something because it happens to be my own personal opinion about the oneness of people, the separateness and feeling like an individual, or love everybody, we’re all one or whatever. You can take and train someone. Let’s say you have a trainer, Mr. X, and mechanically he can do what you do, but he’s not you. Mechanically he can get up and do X. But I’m taking this a step further than just ego. What makes you separate and different? If he’s doing it just the same as you. What would make you separate? Why would the audience feel the difference in the mechanicalness or be drawn to you instead? How would you explain that for you yourself as a human being?</p><p>WERNER: So the question is framed in what I call the structure of personality, so I’m going to try and answer the question that way. I have to tell you that I think the whole notion of structure of personality is bullshit, so that I don’t like the structure so that any answer I give you I don’t like. I’m going to try and answer you in a way in which I do like, which maybe less useful to you but more authentic for me.</p><p>The difference in “it”, when two people are doing exactly the same thing or close enough to be called the same thing, why the impact is different for people is that he will be coming from one place and I will be coming from another place because doing is always out front-ness and no matter how much congruence you get in out front-ness, that isn’t where the real power in something comes from. The real power comes from what’s behind it — or to put it in my terms, where one’s coming from.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I agree completely. Boy, do I agree with that.</p><p>DEVERS: I do too.</p><p>WERNER: Now that’s a distinction which almost no one draws. Where, particularly in this culture, is fixated on what is out front. We are suspicious, at best, usually totally ignorant of any coming-from-ness. That’s the difference. I like my answer better than thought I was going to.</p><p>NATHANIEL: It’s a very, very good answer and one to which both of can relate in very intimate ways. We address graduate students in psychology. It’s necessarily to learn a variety of technical procedures which have utility, but I love to ask graduate students, “Do you have the concept that somebody can come into the room with you and because of who you are something will happen inside of them. Never mind the techniques that I will talk about later.” For me, learning how to do psychotherapy is 90% me working on me and 10% learning certain skills. This relates directly to what I understand you just said. <br> <br>WERNER: Absolutely.</p><p>NATHANIEL: But there are certain people — to standard language — are healing personalities. You can play volleyball with them and it would be a transformative experience because of the quality. And this is very hard to persuade psychotherapists or students of it for a very, very simple reason. Since with rare exceptions, they are not such beings themselves, there is an excessive reliance upon technique or the learnable aspects of the art because that is the teachable and the transmissible.</p><p>WERNER: Two or three things that I want to say about that. I want to say one more thing about your question which I’ll come back to. A psychiatrist by the name of Bob Shaw and I started a thing which we call The Center for Contextual Study. What we’re doing at the moment is a training for professional therapists which we call Mastery: A Context for Psychotherapy. It started for the reason that you just described.</p><p>Bob is the head of a thing called the Family Institute in Berkeley. From time to time they bring very famous psychotherapists in and they do workshops with them. And this one guy who I happened to know about, Bob invited me to come by and see what the hell he was doing. So he was up on the platform when I got there, up on the platform working with a family, brilliant job of intervention with this family. You might not like the word intervention, but you know what I’m talking about. Big audience, like 150 professionals there. He’s all done, excuses the family, thanks them for doing it and so on. Takes a break. People are walking out. A lot of people walking by happen to know me, said “Wasn’t that great?” And I said, “Incredible. Remarkable.” They said, “Why did he do this? Why did he do that?” And I said, “Well, when he comes back, ask him those things.”</p><p>It was clear to me that the people in the room got almost nothing out of watching this genius quarterback at work. And when he got back, he explained everything he did, and it was clear to me that everything he said was pure journalism. Not one thing he said, an explanation of why he did what he did, was going to in any way empower those people to make any difference in their practice of psychotherapy. I was really struck massively by that experience.</p><p>And this whole thing that Bob and I are doing together is an attempt to open up the domain from which this guy was coming, rather than the domain from which this guy was doing and from which this guy from explaining what he was doing! Because the fucking explanations Nathaniel were great. They were totally consistent. They were beautifully rational. They were powerfully reasoned. All the things you need in a good explanation were there. But what wasn’t there was any capacity for these people to find these skills from within themselves. So you asked what we were doing. That’s another thing that we’re doing. And the thing is just really remarkable Devers.</p><p>DEVERS: Isn’t that sort of what Diana and Grindler [?] were trying to do?</p><p>NATHANIEL: They were modeling it at another level.</p><p>WERNER: But I think they were looking at that same problem.</p><p>DEVERS: Yes looking at that same problem.</p><p>NATHANIEL: Yes.</p><p>WERNER: Their response to it is quite a bit different.</p><p>DEVERS: Yes but they were looking for that.</p><p>WERNER: Now, I want to get back to the thing that you asked about two people doing the same thing and why does it make a difference. I’m going to make couple of assertions. Being and presence are distinct. What presents itself and being are distinct. One of the things which makes them distinct is being is not in time and presence is always in time. So that that which is the same in presence is not necessarily the same in being. And while it is almost entirely unseen, the impact in the world of presence is really less important than the impact of being. By that I mean, the impact of presence on presence has a kind of linear function and therefore is very weak, not very powerful. The impact of being on presence transcends the rules of linear function and can produce outcomes which are inexplicable, although once produced will be forced into the explanation or the explanation will be altered to fit them. That was my discussion before about intersecting dimensions.</p><p>One last thing. My whole thesis about what people think we’re up to — helping people, making them better, etc. Whatever this domain was when we started to talk — the human potential movement, whatever the hell it all is — is done in a model which is essentially faulty, in that it is seen that there is what is called being inaccurately, because it’s really experiencing. And the representation of experiencing. So we’ve got experiencing and we’ve got the representation of experiencing. I experience you and then I have a representation of my experience of you. The next time I come back to see you again I don’t experience you directly, I now experience you — to some degree — filtered through my representation of you. My experience of you now will reinforce my earlier representation of you because my new experience is filtered through that representation. The reinforced representation will more fully dominate my next experience of you, which will more completely reinforce the representation, and you get a vicious circle.</p><p>NATHANIEL: You’ve just given the great problem of marriage counseling. That is the problem of marriage counseling.</p><p>WERNER: It’s the problem that all modern therapy attempts to deal with. And all modern therapy — to the degree that it’s any good — does one thing: it breaks the hold of concept on experience, so that people begin to experience more directly, more authentically, without the reinforcement of the perception. Now, the problem with that is that it inevitably must go back into the vicious circle because the total model is the vicious circle model. That’s all modern therapy in my view. The best, the worst, what works, and what doesn’t work can all be explained in that model. Why it ultimately doesn’t make a difference is also shown in the model.</p><p>For example, you go to a really good encounter group, well done, well led, and you come away and you walk outside and you don’t see a tree, you see a TREE. And you don’t go home to your wife, you go home to some body, and you are deeply authentically connected with whoever you go home to. Now the problem is that whether that happens is turned into a representation of what happened, that representation of what happened becomes the filter for nah, nah, nah, and back down the vicious circle. So what I’m interested in is not working with the problems as they come up in the vicious circle, but in breaking the vicious circle and enabling people to have a domain from which experience can be derived which is not representational, but is purely creative.</p><p>See it’s exactly the thing that Nathaniel said about if you are a romantic person, you romance with the people that come into your life. That’s just a narrow application, albeit a very interesting one. So what I’m interested in enabling people, empowering people, to be that which they choose to be rather than to more effectively use that which they got. See I think it’s possible to create oneself — freshly, newly. As a matter of fact, I not only think it’s possible, I don’t think it’s possible to live ultimately, authentically without doing so.</p><p>DEVERS: Right. Agree.</p><p>WERNER: Now we go back to something underneath the question you asked. If I want to affect my circumstances, any nitwit knows that I got to do something. Because sitting here contemplating my navel is not going to interact with my circumstances. So we all know that you got to do something! So we all talk to people about what to do. However, while I accept unequivocally that only action — doing — affects things, that action derived from the domain of the things you’re attempting to effect, produce change with no difference. Let me say it again.</p><p>DEVERS: No, I understand.</p><p>WERNER: OK great. I’m interested in calling up, recognizing, making available to people, a domain in which they have absolute freedom, they’re not constrained by the circumstances. A domain in which they can generate what — I’m now going to give a name to, the name is unimportant — a “context.” From which context their experience derives, not the circumstances don’t derive their experience from, their filters they don’t derive their experience from, they now derive their experience from a self-created context. That experience then begins to reorganize the circumstances to look like the context or where they’re coming from — to use words I’ve used before. And it works almost inexplicably because most people are trying to figure out life and what is in a model in which there is just the experience realm, just the action realm, just the process realm, just the what-I’m-doing realm, just the who-I-am-as-experience realm, and the realm of circumstance. That’s what I call the vicious circle model.</p><p>DEVERS: And stepping outside the circle.</p><p>WERNER: Yes. Precisely. By the way, that’s who Self is for me, ultimately Self — this is a third statement. <br> <br>NATHANIEL: Wait, I, unfortunately have to go, but finish your sentence.<br> <br>WERNER: OK. Self is ultimately nothing with the capacity to create contexts. Self is a context-creating phenomenon or entity.</p><p>DEVERS: Alright. As you ponder and go away, answer this question for me in a letter or something.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Joking] Telepathic communication is also acceptable.</p><p>DEVERS: No, seriously. Because Marilyn Monroe did what you’re talking about as she put herself in another circle. Tell me how she could have gotten out of that. I’m using her as an example because I get clients like that all the time — they create outside, they go beyond this, everything you were saying. Now what happens?</p><p>WERNER: It’s very simple. Marilyn Monroe was a quarterback. In other words, she did that without knowing what she was doing. The one thing about being that distinguishes it from all other expressions of existence is that it must be self-aware in order to be complete. Had Marilyn Monroe known what she was doing, all the problems that went along with what she was doing could have by her been resolved.</p><p>DEVERS: So you’re saying that if she was aware when she stepped out of it that no problems would have arisen?</p><p>WERNER: No. She could have dealt with the problems as effectively as she dealt with that for which she did create a context.</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Beginning to exit the room] I think it’s a very good answer. <br> <br>WERNER: [Laughing] Nathaniel, I don’t know that our conversation was any good, but being with you is great.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I think the conversation was good. <br> <br>DEVERS: I wish we could do it for longer, as in you never have time, but we do have time in the mountains now, we’ve given up a lot of our work. And we’d love to see you.<br> <br>WERNER: That’s good for you.</p><p>DEVERS: [Laughing] Oh shut up Werner.</p><p>WERNER: Was that bad that I said that?<br> <br>DEVERS: [Laughing] No, no.</p><p>WERNER: [Laughing] I was pleased. I’m actually very, very pleased with my experience of where you all are at. I mean not that you give a damn what I think. <br> <br>DEVERS: Yes we do!<br> <br>WERNER: Well, at any rate, I didn’t say it because I thought you gave a damn, I said it because it’s true.</p><p>[Inaudible goodbyes]<br> <br>DEVERS: Having been sort of a salesperson, huckster, someone who has been out there many, many years myself, you really do enjoy what you do. It’s a wild stab at what I’m saying, but I really feel that you had a long path of monetary reward and now it’s more of a self-fulfillment thing, right? <br> <br>WERNER: No. It was never monetary for me.</p><p>DEVERS: Come on. Way back when?</p><p>WERNER: No.</p><p>DEVERS: Not even at the beginning? When <em>est</em> started?<br> <br>WERNER: Nope. It never was there. Honestly.</p><p>DEVERS: Because I really think that I don’t see that anymore. I feel like this is something you really believe in and that you want to do for humanity.</p><p>NATHANIEL: I said years ago before I knew you when I heard a lot of things, “I can tell you right now, whatever this fellow is about it’s not about money.” And that is before I knew you, I had that opinion about you. <br> <br>WERNER: Yeah, it couldn’t be and have what is happening, happen. But no one knows that at the beginning. You have to stand the test of time. <br> <br>DEVERS: But you really want to change things and you really believe it.<br> <br>WERNER: I do. <br> <br>DEVERS: [Joking] And Nathaniel you leave the tape running for posterity?</p><p>NATHANIEL: [Laughing] Well, we were still talking!</p><p><strong>[End of tape]</strong></p><p>To learn more about Nathaniel Branden’s work, I recommend reading his magnum opus <em>The Six Pillars of Self-Esteem</em> (1994). You can also visit NathanielBranden.com.</p><p>To learn more about Werner Erhard’s work, I recommend watching the documentary <em>Transformation: The Life and Legacy of Werner Erhard</em> (2006), which can be streamed on Amazon Video. You can also visit LandmarkWorldwide.com.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=332c5a6eb43b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE JOURNEY HOME: The Wizard of Oz & The Greatest Treasure in the World]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/the-journey-home-the-wizard-of-oz-the-greatest-treasure-in-the-world-6e94f1f6281f?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e94f1f6281f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wizard-of-oz]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Jul 2020 01:38:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-13T21:11:58.147Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zWJdo3TOH89T8d9Y" /></figure><blockquote>DOROTHY: Auntie Em, really — You know what Miss Gulch said she was gonna do to Toto!? She said she was gonna–</blockquote><blockquote>AUNT EM: Now, Dorothy, dear, stop imagining things. You always get yourself into a fret over nothing. Now, you just help us out today, and find yourself a place where you won’t get into any trouble.</blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: [to herself] Some place where there isn’t any trouble. Do you suppose there is such a place, Toto? There must be.</blockquote><p>A place where there isn’t any trouble.</p><p>I want to find that place too.</p><p>I recently re-watched <em>The Wizard of Oz</em> (1939), probably the most iconic film in U.S. history, and I was amazed by the journey that Dorothy and her friends take. The story has such incredible depth and richness that is easily missed. In fact, from a certain perspective, I think you and I can follow the Yellow Brick Road with Dorothy, all the way back home. I don’t mean home like a physical place, but <em>home</em> like a feeling place, like a spiritual place, like a <em>soul</em> place.</p><p>Now, I think <strong>the key</strong> to unlocking anything of real, lasting value from a film like this is to go beyond the surface level story. I call this the <em>metaphorical</em> or <em>mythological</em> level. At this deeper level, the story points beyond the specifics of the film to the archetypal challenges, triumphs, and characters that we all encounter in the journey of life.</p><p>One last thing before we dive into the film. I think<strong> the key</strong> to unlocking anything of real, lasting value from an essay like this is <em>to find yourself in it</em> — to read it like it matters, to read it like it could impact the quality of your life, to read it like there is something at stake. I’m not very interested in writing for your entertainment (though you may be entertained). I’m much more interested in writing for your <em>transformation</em> — in writing for a kind of impact or value or shift-in-perspective — so that by the time you’re done reading, you’re not the same person who started it. I know, I know, that’s a tall order. And for that to happen, both you and I will need to bring our full selves to this. If you’re game for that, I am too.</p><p>OK let’s go deep.</p><h3><strong>LOSING HOME</strong></h3><p>The movie opens on a country road in rural Kansas. Dorothy is running home, frazzled and upset. The neighbor Miss Gulch just hit her beloved dog Toto when she found him in her garden.</p><p>When Dorothy gets back home to the farm, she shares her troubles with the three farmhands — Zeke, Hickory, and Hunk. Then Aunt Em arrives and Dorothy tries complaining to her, but she won’t have it.</p><blockquote>DOROTHY: Auntie Em, really — You know what Miss Gulch said she was gonna do to Toto!? She said she was gonna–</blockquote><blockquote>AUNT EM: Now, Dorothy, dear, stop imagining things. You always get yourself into a fret over nothing. Now, you just help us out today, and <strong>find yourself a place where you won’t get into any trouble.</strong></blockquote><p>The encounter with Aunt Em is a catalyst for one of the most famous songs in movie history and for Dorothy’s spiritual journey (as we’ll see in a bit).</p><blockquote>DOROTHY: [to herself] Do you suppose there is such a place, Toto? There must be. It’s not a place you can get to by a boat or a train. It’s far, far away — behind the moon — beyond the rain —</blockquote><blockquote>Somewhere, over the rainbow, way up high,<br>There’s a land that I heard of once in a lullaby.<br>Somewhere, over the rainbow, skies are blue,<br>And the dreams that you dare to dream really do come true.<br>Someday I’ll wish upon a star<br>And wake up where the clouds are far behind me.<br>Where troubles melt like lemon drops,<br>Away above the chimney tops,<br>That’s where you’ll find me.</blockquote><p>As Dorothy finishes dreaming about “somewhere over the rainbow,” Miss Gulch arrives at the farm on her bicycle. She meets with Aunt Em, Uncle Henry, and Dorothy in their living room.</p><p>Miss Gulch threatens to sue them and have Toto “destroyed,” then shows them a letter from the sheriff giving her permission to take Toto. Aunt Em and Uncle Henry finally give in and hand over the dog. Dorothy is distraught and runs to her room crying.</p><p>Miss Gulch bikes off with Toto down the country road, but he manages to escape out of the basket and run back to Dorothy. Dorothy, overwhelmed with joy, quickly realizes that Miss Gulch will be back as soon as she sees Toto went missing. She decides to runaway from home.</p><p>We’re less than 10 minutes into the film and Dorothy has had her innocent, cherished dog Toto hit and threatened to be destroyed. In one scene, she’s dreaming of a land where “troubles melt like lemon drops” and “dreams really do come true.” In the next scene, in the safety of her own home, her trusted guardians handover Toto to the evil neighbor.</p><p>Can you see that this is the setting for an <em>existential crisis</em> — an identity crisis — a spiritual crisis? The contrast of the dream and reality. The threat to her innocence (Toto). The breaking of trust in her own home.</p><p>As Leon the Snowman told Buddy in <em>Elf </em>(2003), “<strong>This might be the golden opportunity to find out who you really are.</strong>”</p><p>Dorothy doesn’t have a Leon the Snowman, but she does have a Professor Marvel. She hasn’t run far away when she meets Professor Marvel, a traveling psychic. He pretends to read her fortune. He says he sees Aunt Em dying because she has runaway. Dorothy is mortified. She quickly grabs Toto, says goodbye to Professor Marvel, and begins running back toward home.</p><p>Professor Marvel may have lied about Aunt Em’s condition, but he did Dorothy a great service — like Leon the Snowman did for Buddy — he pointed her in the direction of <em>home</em>.</p><p>Back on the farm, Aunt Em, Uncle Henry, and the three farmhands are rushing around. A great tornado has started ripping through the area and the wind is howling.</p><p>(It’s interesting to note that all of this chaos is happening <strong>outside </strong>the farm at the same time that chaos is happening <strong>inside </strong>Dorothy. Coincidence? I think not.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/365/1*IJup3YfucR60_qhvHIOLhw.png" /><figcaption>The tornado</figcaption></figure><p>Taking cover, Dorothy runs into her bedroom, where the wind blows so hard that the shutters rip off and hit her in the head, knocking her unconscious. Her house is seen spinning up inside the tornado. She begins to wake. Finally, the house comes crashing down. Dorothy opens her front door and walks out. The movie turns from black-and-white to a full color picture.</p><p>“<em>Toto, I have a feeling we’re not in Kansas anymore.</em>”</p><h3><strong>WELCOME TO OZ</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*W-5gQKFY18Lb_7rP.jpg" /><figcaption>Waking up in Oz</figcaption></figure><p>Dorothy wakes up in the strange, magical Land of Oz. She meets the Munchkins and Glinda, the good witch, who informs her that her house killed the Wicked Witch of the East when it landed in Oz.</p><p>Just as the Munchkins finish celebrating her death, the Wicked Witch of the West shows up.</p><p>Glinda makes the ruby red slippers disappear off the dead witch’s feet and reappear on Dorothy’s. The Wicked Witch is furious. She vows to take revenge for killing her sister and taking the ruby red slippers. Then disappears.</p><p>The whole situation frightens Dorothy, who is now ready to go home.</p><blockquote>DOROTHY: Which is the way back to Kansas? I can’t go the way I came.</blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: No — that’s true. The only person who might know would be the great and wonderful Wizard of Oz himself! He lives in the Emerald City, and that’s a long journey from here.</blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: But, how do I start for the Emerald City?</blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: It’s always best to start at the beginning — and all you do is follow the Yellow Brick Road.</blockquote><p>The Emerald City. The Wizard of Oz. And the Yellow Brick Road.</p><p>You have those in your life too.</p><p>You have an Emerald City. It’s that place where you know everything will turn out. It’s your “fantasy land,” your “paradise,” your “utopia.” That distant, faraway land — that once you get there, everything will be OK. For Dorothy that was a large, shimmering green city. For you, it’s living in <em>that</em> home or <em>that</em> town or <em>that </em>beach. You know <em>that</em> beach? The one where there are no troubles, no worries, no drama, not a care in the world. <em>That</em> one. If you were <em>there, y</em>ou could finally relax, enjoy yourself, not need to look good or prove anything or “make it” in the world. You would be <em>home</em>. But not now. Not here. No. <em>Home</em> is a distant, faraway land — “over the rainbow.”</p><p>It’s not <em>this </em>grass, it’s that greener grass over there.</p><p>It’s not <em>this </em>side of the river, it’s that <em>other side </em>over there.</p><p>(See, when Dorothy first lands in Oz she exclaims, “We must be over the rainbow!”, referring back to her dream of the place where “troubles melt like lemon drops.” But almost immediately, Dorothy — in her encounter with the Wicked Witch — realizes that <em>this isn’t it</em>, this isn’t the place. It’s really the Emerald City, or more accurately, it’s in the Emerald City where she will finally be able to “get” <em>home</em> — <em>feel </em>at home, <em>be </em>at home.)</p><p>Maybe it’s not about the Emerald City for you — maybe it’s not about a place— maybe it’s about a <em>person</em>. Now, for Dorothy, that person was the Wizard of Oz. But who is it for you? Who is the person who will save you — who will get you <em>home</em>? The one who scoops you up out of obscurity, out of ordinariness, out of your little, rural Kansas farm life and takes you to the castle, takes you to the Emerald City, takes you home. It’s <em>them </em>you are waiting for. Right now, here, these circumstances — <em>this isn’t it</em>. You’re waiting for Prince Charming, “Mr. Right”, or Jason Momoa. Or you’re waiting for the “girl next door” or the Victoria’s Secret model or Scarlett Johansson.</p><p>Or maybe you’re not into fairy tales, not you, instead you’re waiting for your boss to finally notice you and give you the raise and the promotion you deserve — then things will really be OK (and you can finally afford that exotic vacation). Or you’re waiting for your dad to finally say “I’m proud of you” and “I love you”— that’s all you really need. Or you’re waiting for your mom to take care of you like she used to — that’s it — then<em> she</em> is your Wizard of Oz, she is your savior, your liberator.</p><p>But what’s the path to the Emerald City? How do you find the Wizard of Oz? That’s your Yellow Brick Road. That’s your journey. That’s the way back home.</p><p>Are you starting to find yourself in the story yet? Can you see yourself in Dorothy? Have you ever felt like you landed in a strange, magical place? Have you ever wanted to just get home? If so, stay with that feeling.</p><h3><strong>THE JOURNEY HOME</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*H-_ZvHTvRwiyQBlG.png" /><figcaption>Off to see the Wizard</figcaption></figure><p>Dorothy starts on the Yellow Brick Road. In short order, Dorothy (who wants to get <em>home</em>) meets the Scarecrow (who wants a <em>brain</em>), the Tin Man (who wants a <em>heart</em>), and the Lion (who wants <em>courage</em>).</p><p>Together as friends, they set off toward the Emerald City, toward the Wizard of Oz, toward <em>home</em>.</p><p>What a gift to have friends along for the journey. I’m reminded of what the American spiritual teacher Ram Dass said:</p><p>“<strong>We’re all just walking each other home.</strong>”</p><p>When they finally reach the Emerald City, it’s not what they expect (that happens to us a lot, doesn’t it?). Barrier after barrier is put up between them and the Wizard. At first, the gatekeeper refuses to open the main gate of the Emerald City. Then the taxi driver almost refuses to take them to the Wizard’s palace. Then the guard of the Wizard’s palace refuses to open the door.</p><p>When he finally does open it, the group travels through a long, dark corridor to at last reach the throne room of the Wizard.</p><p>The Wizard appears as a large, ghostly green head surrounded by fire and smoke. The group is terrified.</p><blockquote>OZ: I AM OZ, THE GREAT AND POWERFUL! <strong>Who are you?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: [Stammering] I… If you please… I… I am Dorothy… the small and meek. We’ve come to ask you —</blockquote><blockquote>OZ: [Interrupting] SILENCE!!</blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: Ohhh — Jiminy Crickets!</blockquote><blockquote>OZ: The Great and Powerful Oz knows why you have come. Step forward… Tin Man.</blockquote><p>The Tin Man, Scarecrow, and Lion — who haven’t introduced themselves, but who the Wizard already knows (<em>interesting, huh?</em>) — take turns stepping forward. The Wizard insults them for even daring to ask for a heart, a brain, and courage. When it’s his turn, the Lion faints out of fear. After Dorothy stands up for him, the Wizard admits that he has “every intention of granting” their requests. But first, they must bring him the broomstick of the Wicked Witch. Then the Wizard commands them all out of the room.</p><p>In the next scene, we find Dorothy and friends in the Haunted Forest on the way to the Witch’s castle. But the Wicked Witch has already sent her flying monkeys to capture Dorothy. They grab her and Toto and leave her friends in the forest. The Witch confronts Dorothy and casts a spell that will have her die when the red-sand hourglass runs out.</p><p>Meanwhile, Toto escapes, finds her friends, and directs them to the castle. They come up with a plan, sneak into the castle, and free Dorothy — requiring brains, a heart, and courage! Unfortunately, the Witch catches up with the group and corners them. When she sets Scarecrow on fire, Dorothy grabs a pail of water and goes to splash it on him, but misses and hits the Witch. Unbeknownst to the group, that’s her weakness!</p><blockquote>WITCH: Ohhh — you cursed brat! Look what you’ve done! I’m melting! Melting! Oh — what a world — what a world! Who would have thought a good little girl like you could destroy my beautiful wickedness!? Ohhh! Look out! Look out! I’m going. Ohhhh! Ohhhhhh….</blockquote><p>The Witch is dead and all begin to celebrate.</p><p>Back at the Wizard’s throne room, Dorothy presents the Witch’s broom to him. And again, things aren’t as they expect.</p><blockquote>DOROTHY: We’d like you to keep your promise to us, if you please, sir.</blockquote><blockquote>OZ: Not so fast! Not so fast! I’ll have to give the matter a little thought. Go away and come back tomorrow!</blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: Tomorrow? Oh, but I want to go home now.</blockquote><blockquote>OZ: Do not arouse the wrath of the Great and Powerful Oz! I said — come back tomorrow!</blockquote><p>Just as he says this, Toto runs over and pulls back a curtain, revealing a middle-aged man (Oz) who is speaking into a microphone. He tries to keep up the act — “<em>Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain</em>!” — but it’s too late.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/404/1*k6yzPENzXS0FuhCTGI785Q.png" /><figcaption>The man behind the curtain</figcaption></figure><p>They approach him and he admits to being a fraud. The group is furious. “What about that heart you promised Tin Man!?” “And the courage that you promised Cowardly Lion!?” “And Scarecrow’s brain!?”</p><p>In the original script, but not in the actual movie, the Wizard replies, “But you’ve got them! <strong>You’ve had them all the whole time</strong>.”</p><p>The four of them refuse to believe it. “Oh, no we haven’t!” they all say in unison. The Tin Man says, “You don’t get around us that easy!” The Lion, “Not no how!” The Scarecrow, “You promised us real things!”</p><p>Now in the actual movie, when they confront the Wizard, he replies, “Why anybody can have a brain.” And explains that the Scarecrow <em>already has a brain</em>. The Scarecrow then launches into a mathematical formula, thereby proving that he has a brain. “I’ve got a brain!” he exclaims. As a symbol of this, the Wizard awards him a “Doctor of Thinkology” degree. The Wizard goes on to explain to the Tin Man and the Lion that they already have a heart (kindness) and courage. Symbolically, he gives them a heart-shaped clock and a medal that says “Courage.”</p><p>When Dorothy asks about getting home, the Wizard says he’ll have to take her back to Kansas himself. He has a hot air balloon just for the occasion.</p><p>The people of the Emerald City all gather around the balloon. Just as it’s about to take off, Toto gets distracted and jumps out of the basket. Dorothy chases after him and Oz is helpless to stop the balloon. It’s already floating away. Dorothy yells after him to no avail.</p><p>Just then Glinda, the good witch, shows up.</p><blockquote>DOROTHY: Oh, will you help me? Can you help me?</blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: <strong>You don’t need to be helped any longer.</strong> <strong>You’ve always had the power to go back to Kansas.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: I have?</blockquote><blockquote>SCARECROW: <strong>Then why didn’t you tell her before?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: <strong>Because she wouldn’t have believed me. She had to learn it for herself…Now, those magic slippers will take you home in two seconds!</strong></blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: <strong>Oh, now?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: <strong>Whenever you wish.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>[Dorothy says her goodbyes]</blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: I’m ready now.</blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: Then close your eyes and tap your heels together three times. And think to yourself — “There’s no place like home.”</blockquote><blockquote>DOROTHY: There’s no place like home. There’s no place like home. There’s no place like home.</blockquote><p>Dorothy wakes up back home on the farm surrounded by her family. She attempts to explain her dream to them, but quickly gives up.</p><blockquote>DOROTHY: Oh, but anyway, Toto, we’re home! HOME! And this is my room — and you’re all here! And I’m not going to leave here ever, ever again, because I love you all! And — Oh, Auntie Em — there’s no place like home!</blockquote><p>The screen fades black and the words appear: “The End.”</p><h3><strong>HOME</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*a4xSqU4nC7IgMSbZ.jpg" /><figcaption>Back home</figcaption></figure><p>What’s this all about?</p><p>Because on the surface, it’s just a playful, entertaining movie about a girl who wants to leave home, does leave home, immediately regrets it, finds her way back home, and says she’ll never leave again.</p><p>Not particularly interesting.</p><p>I think you can go a little deeper. It’s pretty easy to find the archetypal hero’s journey. Dorothy leaves the safety and comfort of home — as all heroes do (think: Pinocchio leaving his father’s workshop or Luke Skywalker leaving his home planet of Tatooine). She enters into a foreign, strange, yet magical land (think: Coco in the Land of the Dead or Jake Sully exploring Pandora in <em>Avatar</em>). She makes new friends and fights the forces of evil (think: Moana and Maui teaming up to defeat Te Kā or Neo and team battling Agent Smith in the first <em>Matrix</em>). Finally, she defeats the forces of evil and returns home as a new woman (think: Frodo returning to the Shire in the final <em>Lord of the Rings </em>or Simba taking over as king after defeating Scar in <em>The Lion King</em>).</p><p>At this level, <em>The Wizard of Oz</em> takes its place among many other great films that share the timeless hero’s journey — films that can breathe new life into us, that can inspire us to travel outside our comfort zone, take risks, and follow our heart.</p><p>But I don’t want to stop there because I think <em>The Wizard of Oz </em>has something special to offer — lessons that are right there in the story, but not obvious at first glance.</p><p>Now, this is where it really starts to get interesting.</p><p>For starters, I don’t think Dorothy actually met any friends on the journey. None. They were made up. The Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Lion were all just aspects of her own self.</p><p>This is actually hinted at in the opening scenes of the movie. Remember when Dorothy complained to the three farmhands? Here’s how they each respond:</p><blockquote>HUNK: <em>[Who plays the Scarecrow in Oz]</em> Now look it, Dorothy, you ain’t using your head about Miss Gulch. Think you didn’t have any brains at all.</blockquote><blockquote>HICKORY: <em>[Who plays the Tin Man]</em> You know, you should have a little more heart yourself and have pity on her.</blockquote><blockquote>ZEKE: <em>[Who plays the Lion]</em> She ain’t nothing to be afraid of. Have a little courage, that’s all.</blockquote><p>It’s not the Scarecrow who needs a brain or the Tin Man who needs a heart or the Lion who needs courage — it’s Dorothy! Those three characters are just anthropomorphized versions of the <em>virtues</em> (intelligence, kindness, and courage) that Dorothy herself is seeking but doesn’t yet know it.</p><p>When she discovers those virtues, she’ll be home.</p><p>In the same way that the Blue Fairy told Pinocchio that to become a real boy, he must first prove himself “brave, truthful, and unselfish.”</p><p>Like Pinocchio, Dorothy is practically told this from the outset. And like Pinocchio, being told that <strong>makes no difference</strong> because — <em>in matters of the spirit</em> — “knowing” (intellectually) makes no difference. One has to discover it for themselves. The good witch Glinda knows that.</p><blockquote>SCARECROW: Why didn’t you tell her before?</blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: Because she wouldn’t have believed me. <strong>She had to learn it for herself.</strong></blockquote><p>So Dorothy is on the adventure to discover these virtues. To do so, she must travel along the Yellow Brick Road, reach the Emerald City, defeat the Wicked Witch, and return to the Wizard of Oz.</p><p>Do you remember <em>your </em>Emerald City? The place where it’ll all finally be OK. Or <em>your</em> Wizard of Oz? The person who will save you. If so, stay with that. (I wrote about reaching <em>my</em> Emerald City: <a href="https://medium.com/@dylanozmore/the-void-how-the-american-dream-chewed-me-up-spit-me-out-c942a9a78ab4">here</a>)</p><p>Dorothy finds intelligence and courage in defeating the Wicked Witch and finds kindness in her relationship with her friends and the people of Oz.</p><p>Now, she doesn’t know that yet. So at the end, when she returns the Witch’s broom to the Wizard of the Oz she says, “Where is what you promised us!?” Where’s my heart? My brain? My courage?</p><p>Do you remember his response? It’s gold.</p><p>He looks at them, stammers for a moment, then says: “But you’ve got them! <strong>You’ve had them all the whole time</strong>.”</p><p>Think about that for a second… The answer to “<strong>Where </strong>is what you promised us?” “<strong>Where </strong>is what I’ve been seeking?” “<strong>Where </strong>is what I really want?” is…</p><p>“<strong>Inside of you!</strong>”</p><p>Dang! That’s good.</p><p>Do you want to know where the greatest treasure in the world lies?</p><blockquote>When Dae Ju first came to Zen Master Ma-jo, the Zen Master asked him, “What do you want from me?”</blockquote><blockquote>Dae Ju said, “I want you to teach me the Dharma [the way of the Buddha].”</blockquote><blockquote>“What a fool you are!” said the Zen Master. “<strong>You have the greatest treasure in the world within you</strong>, and yet you go around asking other people for help. What good is this? I have nothing to give you.”</blockquote><blockquote>Dae Ju bowed and said, “Please Master, tell me what this treasure is.”</blockquote><blockquote>The Zen Master said, “Where is your question coming from? This is your treasure. It is precisely what is making you ask the question at this very moment. Everything is stored in this precious treasure-house of yours. It is there at your disposal, you can use it as you wish, <strong>nothing is lacking</strong>. You are the master of everything.<strong> Why, then, are you running away from yourself and seeking for things outside?</strong>”</blockquote><blockquote>Upon hearing these words, Dae Ju attained enlightenment.</blockquote><p>The right thing said at the right time can unlock you — it can set you free. All the rest is just <em>preparation</em>, just a <em>ripening</em>. It was all about Dorothy getting ready to hear it in that moment. I’m reminded of the “ripening” of the Israelites when they wandered in the wilderness for 40 years before entering the Promised Land. Or Jacob falling asleep and waking up to the fact that “God is in this place and I did not know it.” Or Pinocchio before becoming a real boy. Or Luke before becoming a Jedi.</p><p>Like the Zen Master, the Wizard of Oz unlocks Dorothy when he tells her that what she’s been seeking is already inside of her.</p><p>In fact — not only are the virtues already inside of her — but Dorothy had the power to go home the entire time.</p><p>What!?</p><p>She learns this after Oz flies off in the hot air balloon. Despite learning that the virtues are already inside of her, she still thinks that Oz is going to save her, that he’s still her ticket home. So she’s distraught when he flies off. But wait for it…</p><blockquote>DOROTHY: <em>[To Glinda]</em> <strong>Oh, will you help me!? Can you help me?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>GLINDA: <strong>You don’t need to be helped any longer.</strong> <strong>You’ve always had the power to go back to Kansas.</strong></blockquote><p>Dorothy can hardly grasp this, so she asks “Oh, now?” Like, can I go home now? Glinda says, “<strong>Whenever you wish</strong>.”</p><p>Whenever. You. Wish.</p><p>She’s always had the power… from the moment she landed in Oz. She’s had the power to get back <em>home</em> — back <em>home</em> like a feeling place, like spiritual place, like a soul place — the place where “dreams really do come true.”</p><p>She’s already had it, but she was <strong>unaware </strong>that she had it! Just like Dae Ju in the parable.</p><p>And just like you. Yup, you, dear reader. What you want from <em>your</em> Emerald City, from <em>your </em>Wizard of Oz — you already have inside of you.</p><p>Is that hard to hear? Maybe you’re like Dorothy who refused to believe it when the Wizard of Oz first told her. Remember what she said?</p><blockquote>“Oh, no we haven’t!” they all say in unison. The Tin Man says, “You don’t get around us that easy!” The Lion, “Not no how!” The Scarecrow, “You promised us real things!”</blockquote><p>Just look. Sure, maybe you don’t have the money you want or the promotion or the big house or the knight in shining armor. But is that what you <em>really</em> want? Dorothy didn’t really want to reach the Emerald City, she wanted to experience herself as intelligent, courageous, and kind. Now, <strong><em>that</em> is already inside of you</strong>. The joy, the happiness, the peace, the satisfaction, the love, the connection, the sense of meaning and purpose. That’s already there. Preparing. Ripening. Waiting to burst forth at the right moment — which is “whenever you wish.”</p><p>Jesus said, “The Kingdom of God isn’t something you can see. You won’t be able to say, ‘<em>Here it is</em>!’ or ‘<em>It’s over there</em>!’ For the Kingdom of God <strong>is already within you</strong>.”</p><p>The three thousand year-old Hindu holy books say <em>Tat Tvam Asi — </em>which means “Thou art THAT” or “<strong>You are IT</strong>!”</p><p>Dorothy woke up from Oz. She woke up from her dream. She woke up a new woman full of love and gratitude for her life and the people in it.</p><p>But wait a second… because if she was still in her bedroom when she woke up… then in actuality, Dorothy was<strong> already home the whole time</strong>.</p><p>All of the drama in Oz — all of it — the flying monkeys, the Wicked Witch, the Munchkins, the Emerald City, the Wizard, her friends… they were all made up. They were all just part of the dream. They weren’t real!</p><p>The reality was that Dorothy was <strong>ALREADY HOME</strong>, lying in her bed, <em>dreaming </em>that she wasn’t home.</p><p>It was only in her imagination — her <em>mind</em>, her <em>thoughts </em>— that she wasn’t home.</p><p>It wasn’t that she “always had the power” to get home. No. <strong>She was already home!</strong></p><p>That’s you too.</p><p>It’s only in your mind — your thoughts — that you’re ever away from <em>home</em>, that you’re ever separate from the Universe, from Spirit, from God, from Source, from Love. No. All of that is just a dream. The drama is made up. You’re not separate. You’re not lost. You’re not forgotten about.</p><p>There’s nowhere you have to go.</p><p>There’s nothing you have to do.</p><p><strong>You are home thinking that you’re not</strong>.</p><p>It’s right under your feet.</p><blockquote>One day a young Buddhist on his journey home came to the banks of a wide river.</blockquote><blockquote>Staring hopelessly at the great obstacle in front of him, he pondered for hours on just how to cross such a wide barrier. Just as he was about to give up his pursuit he saw a great Zen Master on the other side of the river.</blockquote><blockquote>The young man yelled over to the Master, “Oh wise one, can you tell me how to get to the other side of this river?”</blockquote><blockquote>The teacher pondered for a moment, looked up and down the river, and yelled back, “My friend, <strong>you are on the other side</strong>!”</blockquote><p>It’s that simple.</p><p>(You didn’t see all of this coming from an essay on <em>The Wizard of Oz</em>, did you?)</p><p>OK, I have to be honest… Remember what I said about it all being “preparation” and a “ripening” for the right moment? Well, this essay has been like that — it’s been a sort of long, winding Yellow Brick Road leading to the Wizard of Oz. All of the examples and references and quotes and stories were preparation so I could tell you this:</p><p>YOU ALREADY HAVE WHAT YOU SEEK.</p><p>YOU ALREADY HAVE THE POWER.</p><p>YOU ARE ALREADY HOME.</p><p>Now click your heels together 3 times and wake up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e94f1f6281f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[ONWARD: Discovering the Wonder, Adventure, & Magic in Everyday Life]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/onward-discovering-the-wonder-adventure-magic-in-everyday-life-e776183621f2?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e776183621f2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[disney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heros-journey]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pixar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[growth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 May 2020 17:21:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-12T18:19:48.745Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/409/0*u_olxk9Qc0v-VCQ1.jpg" /></figure><p>“Long ago, the world was full of wonder. It was adventurous, exciting, and best of all, there was magic. And that magic helped all in need. But it wasn’t easy to master. And so the world found a simpler way to get by. Over time, magic faded away. But I hope, there’s a little magic left in you.”</p><p>So says the narrator over the opening scene of <em>Onward</em> (2020), Disney/Pixar’s latest film. We watch as a magical world of elves, unicorns, and wizards devolves into a rendition of modern society where the elves are off to work at a corporate office, unicorns are eating trash like raccoons, and wizards don’t exist.</p><p>I love Disney movies and especially this one. I’ve seen it twice. I love that <em>Onward </em>makes the hero’s journey explicit, something that is only implied in most Disney movies. That may not sound like a big deal, but it is. That’s because the hero’s journey is the human journey. But more on that later.</p><h3><strong>THE KEY</strong></h3><p>Now, when I mention my love of Disney movies, I may lose you. A lot of us equate them and other animated films with children. It seems like these movies are made for kids with some adult humor sprinkled in for the parents. And there is some truth to that. But it’s far from the whole story. In fact, from a certain perspective these movies are more relevant to adults (more relevant to you!). But it takes a <em>key </em>to reveal that.</p><p>I’ll tell you the key right now because the fun part isn’t the key. The fun part is using the key to open the story — to unlock the magic, inspiration, and sacredness hidden in plain sight.</p><p>Here is the key:</p><p><em>These movies are to be watched as metaphor.</em></p><p>Stay with me here because this could dramatically alter how you watch these films. You can watch these movies as entertainment and take them at face-value. That’s how children watch them. You watch the hero or heroine leave home on an adventure, face challenges, meet strange people or animals, have minor triumphs, then a major challenge, a major triumph, and then the return home. Many of the Disney movies are coming-of-age stories, so they center around someone moving from adolescence to adulthood during this adventure — seemingly making it even less relevant to an adult audience.</p><p>But all of this is just what is happening on the surface. And if you’re watching the movie on that level, that’s fine. But you’re missing out on so much depth, so many more dimensions.</p><p>At a deeper level, every one of these movies is telling the human story. The journey that you and I are on. That’s the metaphorical (or mythological) level, where the story points beyond itself to the timeless human experience. The story points beneath the surface — past the specifics of the film — to the archetypal challenges, triumphs, and characters that we all encounter.</p><p><em>Moana</em> (2016) may be about a young girl who must travel beyond the protective reef, but on a deeper level it’s about anytime you or I have chosen to travel outside our comfort zone. <em>Pinocchio</em> (1940) may be about a wooden puppet who wants to become a “real boy,” but it’s also the story of anytime you or I have taken the journey toward a more real, authentic self. <em>Star Wars</em> (1977) may be about a young man who has to leave home to help save the galaxy, but it’s also about anytime you or I have been called to a commitment or purpose that is bigger-than-ourselves.</p><p>And we’ll see the same with Onward. What seems like a story about a 16-year-old boy discovering magic is really about how all of us can discover the magic and sacred in life.</p><p>That’s the key.</p><p>Hopefully, I’ve been able to make it clear for you, so let’s use it to unlock Onward and see what lies in the depths of this “children’s film.”</p><h3><strong>THE FALL</strong></h3><p>The movie begins in an ancient time when creatures of all types interacted with each other peacefully, including mermaids in the lakes, goblins in the mountains, and wizards bringing magic to all. The scene points to an existence like Adam and Eve had in Eden. But just like the Biblical story, there is a fall. Now the Disney movie isn’t so dramatic, but the landscape does change as the creatures of this magical world discover technology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qIEa4edFfV8n0ZaR.jpg" /></figure><p>A cyclops, who is being trained to master magic, quickly gives up and decides to use a light bulb to create light instead of his wizard staff — “It’s so easy!” he exclaims. More and more of the creatures are seen taking the “easy route.” By the end, the mermaids are no longer in a lake, they’re in a swimming pool. The goblins are out of the mountains and using an electric fireplace to create heat. A centaur is shown playing a version of Dance Dance Revolution.</p><p>I don’t think the point of the movie is to demonize technology, but rather to show that something was gained (comfort, ease, material progress) and something was lost (magic, ritual, wonder, community).</p><p>The modern equivalent may be how real food became fast food, friendships became Facebook friends, and Shakespeare became Netflix.</p><p>Can some of what was lost be recovered?</p><p>That’s the adventure.</p><p>(It’s interesting to note that the film is titled “Onward,” even though it’s about honoring and reviving aspects of the past. Maybe there is something from the past that can help us move forward?)</p><h3><strong>THE JOURNEY OF SELF-DISCOVERY</strong></h3><p>The story revolves around two elves: Ian and his older brother Barley. Their dad passed away when they were very young, but it’s Ian’s 16th birthday and his mom pulls out a wrapped gift from their dad that had been kept in the attic. It’s a wizard staff that he wanted them to have when they were old enough. It also includes a magical spell to conjure him up for one day so he could “see who my boys grew up to be.”</p><p>Barley is amazed and can’t believe that “Dad was a wizard!”</p><p>His mom corrects him, “Hold on, your dad was an accountant.”</p><p>They thought dad was just a boring accountant, but he was also a wizard and knew magic. This discovery immediately transforms how Ian and Barley view their dad. It’s the first of many such transformations in the film — shifts in how the characters view and relate to themselves, others, and the world.</p><p>(By the way, don’t die without letting your family and friends know that you’re a wizard.)</p><p>Ian, who up to this point has been an awkward teenager, is about to be set on a quest to discover who he is.</p><p>This was foreshadowed in the scene just prior to opening the gift. Ian asks his mom, “What was dad like when he was my age? Was he always super confident?”</p><p>“Oh no,” his mom replies. <strong>“It took him a while to find out who he was.”</strong></p><p>What an interesting response right?</p><p>She turns a question about confidence into one of identity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qTXfpqiykICJl_Sc.png" /><figcaption>Leon the Snowman</figcaption></figure><p>I’m reminded of <em>Elf </em>(2003), one of my favorite Christmas movies. Early in the movie, Buddy, played by Will Ferrell, is upset to learn that he is a human and not an elf like everyone else. Papa Elf comforts Buddy and tells him that his real father lives in a magical place called New York City. Buddy, feeling lost and confused, escapes outside into the snow where he encounters Leon the Snowman. Leon tells Buddy that, <strong>“This might be the golden opportunity to find out who you really are.”</strong></p><p>Most people watching Elf totally miss that line, but it is one of those lines that from a metaphorical perspective is incredibly rich.</p><p>I mean, what is that line even referring to? “Find out who you really are”? What does it mean when we say that someone is “trying to find himself”? Where did their self go? How did they lose it? Why do they need to travel to New York City (<em>Elf</em>) or Bali (<em>Eat Pray Love</em>) or the Land of the Dead (<em>Coco</em>) to find it?</p><p>I don’t have the perfect answer to those questions, but I think it’s something along the lines of discovering (“finding”) your authentic self. Discovering your real hopes, wishes, and dreams that may have been covered up by cultural conditioning, peer pressure, and fear. Discovering the courage, creativity, and love that often lies dormant in your soul. Discovering a new, deeper relationship to yourself, others, and the world around you.</p><p>This discovery is not a singular event, but rather a process that unfolds over a lifetime.</p><p>Disney movies can act as our Leon the Snowman. They can remind us that whatever we’re dealing with — turning 16 years old, changing jobs, opening a business, moving to a new city, making friends, starting a family, retiring, treating an illness — can be the “golden opportunity to find out who you really are.”</p><p>Maybe the magic that Onward is referring to is not literal magic, but rather the “magic” that is the love, courage, and creativity that we’re talking about here. Maybe magic is when you’re living from and sharing your authentic self. Maybe a “wizard” is someone who unlocks that magic in others.</p><p>But how do we do that? How do we find out who we really are? Where can we discover the magic and wonder?</p><p>That’s exactly what Onward is about.</p><h3><strong>THE 1st SOURCE OF MAGIC: HEART’S FIRE</strong></h3><p>Ian uses the spell and wizard staff to summon his dad, but something goes wrong and he’s only able to summon his legs. To summon the rest of him, they’ll need an incredibly rare Phoenix Stone. Fortunately, his brother Barley knows where they can start their search: the Manticore’s Tavern.</p><p>On their way over, Barley begins teaching Ian about magic. Barley, whose knowledge comes from a “historically accurate” role-playing game, knows all about spells, wizards, and quests. He starts Ian off with a levitation spell. Ian uses his wizard staff and says the spell (“Aloft elevar!”) to attempt to levitate a soda can. After several failed attempts, Ian is on the verge of giving up, but Barley jumps in.</p><blockquote>BARLEY: For any spell to work you have to speak from your heart’s fire.</blockquote><blockquote>IAN: My what?</blockquote><blockquote>BARLEY: Your heart’s fire! You must speak with passion! Don’t hold back.</blockquote><p>Barley has introduced us to the first source of magic: <strong>Heart’s Fire.</strong></p><p>This is part of what makes Onward such a powerful and beautiful film — that these sources of magic are made explicit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8t0WgVXYqRf1kC2O.jpg" /><figcaption>Ian</figcaption></figure><p>Each hero and heroine has their own sources of magic that they discover along the way. Like when the Blue Fairy tells Pinocchio to become a real boy you must be “brave, truthful, and unselfish.” Unlike Ian, Pinocchio is told these from the outset. But like Ian, Pinocchio must discover these for himself during the journey. (I mean, what kind of journey would it be if telling someone to be honest and brave was enough?). Intellectually understanding these things is a lot different than living them. The purpose of the journey is the discovery, experiencing, and living from these sources of magic.</p><p>Ian must first discover his own voice, his passion, his heart’s fire.</p><p>An earlier scene in the film had Ian so nervous to ask a group of school friends over for his birthday that he had to write down the footnotes on his hand (“Hey gang,” “Party,” and “Cake”).</p><p>Finding your voice is a popular part of the hero’s journey. In <em>The Little Mermaid</em> (1989), Ariel has to reclaim her voice from the evil sea witch Ursula. In <em>Coco</em> (2017), Miguel travels to the Land of the Dead to have his first opportunity to perform as a musician. In <em>Frozen</em> (2013), Elsa finds her voice and sings what is probably the most famous Disney song–“Let it go”–after she finally leaves an oppressive environment.</p><p>In my own life, I remember how nervous I felt when I started sharing my poetic meditations several years ago. At first, I was nervous to even share them with friends and family. “<em>What will they think? Is this stupid? I went to college for business, not poetry!</em>” Then I was nervous to share them publicly on social media. “<em>Once it’s online, then everyone can see it! I’m going to embarrass myself</em>.” Finally, I was most anxious to publish my first book <em>Words To Dance To</em> — a 200+ page collection of these poetic meditations… but I did it! And sharing my writing and art has been easier ever since.</p><p>Have you found your voice, your passion, your heart’s fire? If not, what’s the next step toward it? What do you need to face? What do you need to sacrifice or let go of?</p><h3><strong>THE TRANSFORMATION OF THE MANTICORE</strong></h3><p>Ian and Barley arrive at the Manticore’s Tavern, only to find out that the once legendary tavern has become a family restaurant. The tavern is still run by the Manticore, a winged monster, but she now wears glasses, goes by “Corey,” and wears pieces of flair on her work uniform (like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F7SNEdjftno">this</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ipUcyzh0XpD20T36.jpg" /><figcaption>Corey</figcaption></figure><p>When Barley approaches her, she’s anxious and skittish. Barley asks for the map to the Phoenix Gem that him and Ian need to bring back the rest of their dad.</p><p>Corey refuses. “No! My days of sending people on dangerous quests are over.”</p><p>Barley is startled. “What!? Why?”</p><p>“Because they’re dangerous!”</p><p>The conversation is cutoff because the karaoke machine is broken and a group of guests threaten to give the tavern a one-star review. When Ian confronts her (which would have been very uncharacteristic of Ian, but he has started to find his voice — his <em>heart’s fire</em>!), Corey reiterates her concerns about the danger and risks. “If you get hurt on one of my quests, guess who gets sued and loses her tavern? I can’t take that kind of risk.”</p><p>“You say you can’t risk losing this place, but look at that Manticore!” replies Ian as he points to an old painting of the Manticore holding a giant sword in one hand and the helmet of an enemy in the other. “She looks like she lived to take risks!”</p><p>“That Manticore didn’t have investors to look out for. She didn’t have payroll to cover. She could just fly out the door whenever she wanted… OK maybe this tavern isn’t as adventurous as it used to be. So it isn’t filled with a motley horde willing to risk life and limb for the mere taste of excitement” — she says this as an adult restaurant patron blows on his soup to make sure it’s not too hot before tasting it. “But so what? Who ever said you have to take risks in life to have an adventure?”</p><p>“Apparently, you did,” replies Ian pointing to an inscription above the old painting of the Manticore that says exactly that:</p><p><strong><em>You have to take risks in life to have an adventure. — The Manticore</em></strong></p><p>Have you ever felt like Corey?</p><p>Maybe back in the day you were a wild and crazy kid. You kicked and screamed and cried and laughed with joy and played with your food and danced like a lunatic and howled at the moon and stayed up all night.</p><p>But those days are long gone and now you’re more concerned about avoiding risk, appeasing the investors, and covering payroll.</p><p>What Ian points out to Corey ends up being the perfect therapeutic intervention. She immediately realizes how much she’s lost touch with her authentic, wild self. She feels the accumulated pain and anger of that lost self.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*YXl36qf9zWpB7G8F" /></figure><p>“What have I done? This place used to be dangerous and wild. I used to be dangerous and wild!” As she rips the costume head off a fuzzy Manticore mascot that has been parading around. “I’m living a lie! What have I become!?” She rips off her glasses, pieces of flair, and breathes out a stream of fire.</p><p>Ian and Barley manage to escape the tavern just in time with a map that leads to the next stop on their quest.</p><p>The transformation of the Manticore is the first major transformation of the film. There are more to come. One of the gifts of the hero’s journey is the transformation of the people around them.</p><p>Corey transformed. She reclaimed her wild self.</p><p>Just like in the world of Onward, in our own modern world we have hidden, repressed, and fought against the wild self.</p><p>In 1992, psychotherapist and storyteller, Clarissa Pinkola Estés, published her best-selling book <em>Women Who Run With the Wolves: Myths and Stories of the Wild Woman Archetype</em>. In her foreword to the book, she writes:</p><p>“<em>We are all filled with a longing for the wild. There are few culturally sanctioned antidotes for this yearning. We were taught to feel shame for such a desire. We grew our hair long and used it to hide our feelings. But the shadow of Wild Woman still lurks behind us during our days and in our nights. No matter where we are, the shadow that trots behind us is definitely four-footed.”</em></p><p>It’s not just women. In 1990, American poet Robert Bly published his best-selling book <em>Iron John</em> about a boy maturing into manhood with the help of the wild man. Bly writes:</p><p>“<em>Every modern male has, lying at the bottom of his psyche, a large, primitive being covered with hair down to his feet. Making contact with this Wild Man is the step the modern male has yet to take.</em>”</p><p>In our world of straight lines, cubicles, performance reviews, and 401Ks, we’ve lost touch with the wild self. We’re too put together, too manicured, too self-conscious and “perfect.” We’ve lost the power, the passion, and the magic that comes with being in touch with and owning our wild self.</p><p>We’re like the lion who thinks he’s a sheep.</p><p>The Roman Catholic priest and mystic Anthony de Mello used to tell this famous story:</p><blockquote>There was a lion that grew up in a flock of sheep and so he had no awareness that he was a lion. He would bleat like a sheep, he’d eat grass like a sheep.</blockquote><blockquote>One day they were wandering at the edge of a big jungle when a mighty lion let out a big roar and leaped out of the forest and right into the middle of the flock. All the sheep scattered and ran away. Imagine the surprise of the jungle lion when he saw this other lion there among the sheep. So, he gave chase. He got hold of him. And there was this lion, cringing in front of the king of the jungle. And the jungle lion said to him, “What are you doing here?”</blockquote><blockquote>And the sheep-lion said, “Have mercy on me. Don’t eat me. Have mercy on me.” But the king of the forest dragged him away saying “Come with me.” And he took him to a lake and he said, “Look.”</blockquote><blockquote>So, the lion, who thought he was a sheep, looked and for the first time he saw his reflection. He saw his image. Then he looked at the jungle lion, and he looked in the water again, and he let out a mighty roar.</blockquote><blockquote>He was never a sheep again. It only took a minute.</blockquote><h3><strong>THE 2nd SOURCE OF MAGIC: ATTENTION</strong></h3><p>Ian and Barley drive off from the Manticore’s Tavern with a map to Raven’s Point, where they expect to find the Phoenix Stone.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9_g5TSfUvs4lMICE.jpg" /><figcaption>Ian</figcaption></figure><p>They don’t last long before Barley’s beloved van “Guinevere” runs out of gas. They pull off the road with no gas station in sight. Fortunately, Barley has a gas can with a few drops of gas left. Ian can use a growth spell to grow the can and the gas inside it.</p><blockquote>IAN: OK heart’s fire. Here we go.</blockquote><blockquote>BARLEY: Whoa! It’s not that simple… A growth spell is a bit more advanced. Not only do you have to speak from your heart’s fire, but now you also have to follow a magic decree.</blockquote><blockquote>IAN: A magic what?</blockquote><blockquote>BARLEY: It’s a special rule that keeps the spell working right. This one states: “To magnify an object, you have to magnify your attention upon it.” While you cast the spell you can’t let anything distract you.</blockquote><p>Barley just introduced us to the second source of magic: <strong>Attention.</strong></p><p>It’s worth remembering that Ian and Barley are speaking in terms of literal magic and spells, but on a deeper level they’re talking about the sources of “magic” (love, passion, wonder) in everyday life and the “spells” (actions) that create it.</p><p>We all know from our own lives the power of focus and attention.</p><p>When we put our attention on what’s wrong, what’s upsetting us, and what we’re angry about, what happens? More of the same.</p><p>When we put our attention on love, gratitude, and passion, we also get more of the same.</p><p>You may have heard of the new-age philosophy called the “Law of Attraction” which states something very similar to the magical decree that Barley shared. The way that Jack Canfield, co-author of <em>Chicken Soup for the Soul</em>, describes the law is: “Whatever you focus on, think about, read about, and talk about, you’re going to attract more of into your life.”</p><p>Or as the popular phrase goes: “What you put out into the universe is what you get back.”</p><p>Your energy and attention matter. They have real impact.</p><p>In <em>Star Wars</em> (1977), Yoda is constantly teaching Luke the power of concentration and being present. When Luke lets go of his doubts, insecurities, and fears and is able to focus his energy and attention is when he is most powerful with the Force.</p><p>Wonder, magic, and love are always found here in the present. When we’re regretting the past, we miss it. When we’re worried about the future, we miss it.</p><p>Our attention — our focus, our energy — is precious and sacred. Like a wizard staff, we want to be careful and intentional about how we wield it and where we direct it.</p><p>There’s an old Cherokee story about two wolves:</p><blockquote>One evening, an elderly Cherokee told his grandson about a battle that goes on inside people.</blockquote><blockquote>“My son, the battle is between two wolves inside us all. One is evil. It is anger, envy, jealousy, sorrow, regret, greed, arrogance, self-pity, guilt, resentment, inferiority, lies, false pride, superiority, and ego. The other is good. It is joy, peace, love, hope, serenity, humility, kindness, benevolence, empathy, generosity, truth, compassion, and faith.”</blockquote><blockquote>The grandson thought about it for a minute and then asked his grandfather, “Which wolf wins?”</blockquote><blockquote>The old Cherokee simply replied, “The one that you feed.”</blockquote><p>As Barley might say, “To magnify the love and wonder in your life, magnify your attention upon it.”</p><p>Feed the magical wolf inside of you.</p><h3><strong>THE 3rd SOURCE OF MAGIC: TRUST</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*xyep1y7KylEmaFG6.jpg" /></figure><p>Ian and Barley get the gas they need. They drive far from the city, but just before reaching Raven’s Point, they come across a giant chasm.</p><blockquote>IAN: What is it?</blockquote><blockquote>BARLEY: A bottomless pit. Whatever falls in there, falls forever.</blockquote><p>Unfortunately, the lever to lower the drawbridge is on the other side of the chasm. Ian fails in trying to re-use one of the earlier spells.</p><blockquote>BARLEY: What we need is a Trust Bridge. It’s a spell that creates a magical bridge you can walk on.</blockquote><blockquote>IAN: (casts the spell, but nothing seems to happen) It didn’t work!</blockquote><blockquote>BARLEY: No, the spell is still going. You won’t know if your bridge worked until you step on it.</blockquote><blockquote>IAN: Step on what?</blockquote><blockquote>BARLEY: If you believe the bridge is there, then it’s there.</blockquote><blockquote>IAN: (terrified) I’m not going to step out onto nothing!</blockquote><p>Does this scene remind you of another movie? In <em>Indiana Jones: The Last Crusade</em> (1989), Indy has to do the exact same thing (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sBBbq2g7yf8">here</a>) to cross a chasm and help save his father. He has to take a “leap of faith” for the bridge to appear.</p><p>The scene introduces us to the third source of magic: <strong>Trust</strong>.</p><p>Now, this is a Disney movie, so of course Ian makes it to the other side.</p><p>But like Ian, when you’re standing at one end of a chasm, you’re terrified. And in real life, the length of the chasm is never clear. In fact, it’s rare that you even know there is an other side!</p><p>Real life requires the courage to take that step. And the trust (faith) in knowing that the other side is there waiting for you. It’s the trust that you will cross the void and eventually reach solid ground.</p><p>I had an experience of crossing the void in my own life. In my late 20s, what had been a clear path in life, turned vague and hazy. I felt scared, lost, and confused. I couldn’t see the next step. It took support from my community and the courage to take that step — even without seeing it. It took a while, but eventually I started to feel the ground under my feet again. (I wrote more about this chapter of my life <a href="https://medium.com/@dylanozmore/the-void-how-the-american-dream-chewed-me-up-spit-me-out-c942a9a78ab4">here</a>).</p><p>It’s crossing the abyss — taking that step into nothing.</p><p>As American environmentalist John Burroughs wrote, “<em>Leap, and the net will appear.</em>”</p><p>This is a specific scene in <em>Onward</em>, but it’s symbolic of the whole film. From the outset, Ian and Barley have no idea what’s next. They don’t know who they’ll encounter, what creatures, what obstacles, or what challenges. They have no way of predicting what the journey will require of them — what skills, wisdom, or sacrifices.</p><p>But isn’t that what defines their path?</p><p>Each step includes their unique encounters, challenges, or triumphs.</p><p>Their path — their life — is created each step of the way.</p><p>I love the story that the great mythologist Joseph Campbell used to tell:</p><blockquote>There is a moment in King Arthur’s banquet hall when all the knights are assembled around the Round Table. Then the Holy Grail showed itself to the assembled knights — not in its full glory but covered with a great, radiant cloth. Then it withdrew. All were left ravished, sitting there in awe.<br> <br> Finally, Gawain, Arthur’s nephew, stood up and said, “I propose that we all go in quest of that Grail.”<br> <br> Now we come to the text that most interested me: “They thought it would be a disgrace to go forth in a group. <strong>Each entered the Forest Adventurous at that point which he himself had chosen, where it was darkest and there was no way or path.</strong>”<br> <br>You enter the forest at the darkest point, where there is no path. Where there’s a way or path, it is someone else’s path; each human being is a unique phenomenon.</blockquote><p>Campbell sums it up this way:</p><blockquote>If you can see your path laid out in front of you step by step, you know it’s not your path. Your own path you make with every step you take. That’s why it’s your path.</blockquote><h3><strong>THE LAST SOURCE OF MAGIC</strong></h3><p>Ian and Barley’s path leads them to Raven’s Point, through an underground tunnel, and all the way back to their hometown where they face a giant stone dragon.</p><p>With the help of their mom and Corey, they destroy the dragon and save their dad, allowing Barley to have a short, but precious moment with him.</p><p>The film ends with a look into the new transformed world — a world that re-discovered some of the wonder, adventure, and magic of the past.</p><p>The final scenes point to the last source of magic: <strong>Community.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/420/1*dfauKH_CxUwVcaMWUJtZRA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ian &amp; Barley</figcaption></figure><p>The hero’s journey is usually seen as an individual undertaking. And there is truth to that (just like the King Arthur story alluded to), but it’s far from the whole story.</p><p>Because the whole story is that it’s a communal journey — many people, many characters, many masks, many roles, many paths.</p><p>Self and community are inseparable.</p><p>The transformation of self is the transformation of community.</p><p>The world transforms as you do.</p><p>It all comes together.</p><p>Ian and Barley discovered magic, confidence, and their love for each other. Their mom discovered her power and sense of adventure. Corey reclaimed her wild self. Many other minor characters were impacted too. Their mom’s boyfriend Officer Bronco regained his health and vitality and the pixies rediscovered their ability to fly.</p><p>Ian’s friends, the ones he was too nervous to even speak to early in the film, are seen inviting him to hang out later, which Ian confidently accepts. It’s clear that he’s more connected with himself and others.</p><p>When you “find yourself,” you find others.</p><p>That’s because the more you can see and experience your own humanity, the more you can see and experience the humanity of others.</p><p>Community and connection are a natural consequence of the journey. They are a source of magic, but they are also a result of it.</p><p>Can you see why I love Disney films?</p><p>From a metaphorical (mythological) perspective, they can have so much to offer. Onward shows us the power of discovering our Heart’s Fire, of focusing our Attention, and of deepening our Trust. There is magic there. And adventure. And wonder.</p><p>Take some of that for yourself.</p><p>Know that your day-to-day life, your problems, your challenges, your obstacles are so much more poetic and heroic than they may appear. You can find inspiration for that in unlikely places, like a “children’s movie.” You can look deeper and find yourself in the characters — in their stories, in their challenges, and in their triumphs.</p><p>This essay wasn’t really about Onward or wizards or spells.</p><p>This was about you, your life, your adventure, your community. I hope you read it that way. I hope you’re inspired to find a little wonder today, a little adventure, a little magic.</p><p>Who knows, maybe you will discover that you’re actually a wizard.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wQs3sEPNbd4FaKeS.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e776183621f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SERMONS IN STONE: The Death Of God, Waking Up, & Hearing A Bird Sing]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/sermons-in-stone-the-death-of-god-waking-up-hearing-a-bird-sing-d65c3abf40bd?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d65c3abf40bd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[existentialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dogs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jan 2020 19:30:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-23T18:46:39.316Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I feel compelled to put a disclaimer here: This is not a short read. This essay is more like a journey together. A journey we’ll take through the death of God, through the loss of meaning and purpose, through the Bible and a Disney movie and the Big Lebowski and a French play named <em>Waiting for Godot</em>. A journey to see if there is something on the other side of the despair, loneliness, and desperation of modern society. If that interests you, then keep reading…</p><p>“God is dead.” That’s what the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche declared in 1882. “God is dead. And we have killed him.”</p><p>It’s probably the most famous phrase in philosophy. Nietzsche wasn’t exactly thrilled about it. Although he did say, “We philosophers and free spirits feel illuminated by a new dawn,” he was afraid of something. He was afraid of nihilism. As he wrote:</p><p>“What I relate is the history of the next two centuries. I describe what is coming, what can no longer come differently: <strong>the advent of nihilism</strong>… For some time now our whole European culture has been moving as toward a catastrophe, with a tortured tension that is growing from decade to decade: restlessly, violently, headlong, like a river that wants to reach the end.”</p><p>“Nihilism” comes from the Latin <em>nihil</em>, or nothing — that which does not exist. It also has a cameo in the verb “annihilate,” meaning to bring to nothing — to destroy completely.</p><p>Nihilism is the belief that life is without any meaning, purpose, or value. It goes beyond “killing” God and kills all that is sacred and meaningful.</p><p>You may remember the nihilists from <em>The Big Lebowski</em> (1998) who threaten to cut off The Dude’s “johnson.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/759/0*eeenJCS14GcxhB9A.jpg" /><figcaption>The nihilists burning The Dude’s car (1998)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>Nihilist: We believe in nothing, Lebowski. Nothing! And tomorrow we come back and we cut off your chanson!</blockquote><blockquote>The Dude: Excuse me??</blockquote><blockquote>Nihilist: I said… [shouting] I zaid VE CUT OFF YA JOHNSON!!</blockquote><p>That’s exactly what Nietzsche was worried about.</p><p>I think Nietzsche was right about nihilism sweeping the world. In our busy, materialistic, noisy modern society we’ve lost <em>sacredness</em> — a sacred relationship with anything. The famous psychologist Abraham Maslow talked about this too. He called it “desacralization” — destruction of the sacred.</p><p>Sacredness has been destroyed by busyness, materialism, Instagram likes, fanny packs, duck lip selfies, avocado toast, the rat race, Angry Birds, viral cat videos, Kim Kardashian, Dan Blizerian, the Starbucks Unicorn Frappuccino, and Sharknado.</p><p>It’s funny to think of Henry David Thoreau escaping into the woods. He had to escape society to “confront the essential facts” and “suck out all the marrow of life.” This is in the 1850s —and to remind you what life was like back then — the telephone had not even been invented (!).</p><p>In reflecting on society at that time, he wrote:</p><p>“The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation… A stereotyped but unconscious despair is concealed even under what are called the games and amusements of mankind.”</p><p>Quiet desperation. Unconscious despair.</p><p>Imagine what he would make of modern society.</p><p>We are lost in a kind of no man’s land where nothing is truly sacred. My work? No, not sacred. That’s to make money, pay the bills, and besides, I hate my boss. My friends? I hardly get to see them, they’re too busy. Sex? No, porn and Tinder ruined that one. My family? I’ll see them next year during the holidays. My creative projects? I don’t have any. I’ll do those when I’m retired.</p><p>I agree with the mythologist Joseph Campbell who said, <strong>“The world without spirit is a wasteland.”</strong></p><p>The world without the sacred — where nothing is holy, where nothing is divine — is a <strong>wasteland</strong>.</p><p>The only thing to do in a wasteland is to <em>survive</em>. And when physical survival is taken care of (like it is for a lot of us in the West), survival means <em>social survival</em>. Be the best dressed. Or the highest ranked. Or the most envied. The richest. The smartest. The funniest. The prettiest. Most talented. Most artistic. Most loyal. Most “holy.” Most sacrificial.</p><p>And while you’re doing that — while you are surviving — you’re waiting around for the wasteland to <em>transform</em>. Right? You don’t want it to stay a wasteland. And you have ideas when that transformation will happen — usually when you win the game of social survival.</p><p>The transformation will happen once I get into a good college, then life will be good. Once I get a job, then I can relax a bit. Once I buy a house, no, it’s once I’m married and have kids, then I’m respectable and mature. Once I get the promotion, then I’ll have the money for that nice vacation I’ve been dreaming about. Once the kids are out of the house, then I can have some peace and quiet again, no, it’s once I sell the house and retire then I can really take it easy and enjoy myself. Once I get this hip replacement so I can walk again…</p><p>I can’t think of better material that captures this situation than the French play <em>Waiting for Godot</em> (1953) by Samuel Beckett.</p><p>My high school English teacher Mr. Cohen made us read it. And the only reason I remember it is because we also created a video re-make of the play in my basement–which included my younger brother (who was not in the class with me) wearing a coat and top hat as “Pozzo.”</p><p>Stay with me here. I want to go deep with you on this play because it’ll shed light on the darkness, confusion, and despair of this nihilistic world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ne7tT0dhl70wCJD6.jpg" /><figcaption>Estragon and Vladimir in Waiting for Godot (1953)</figcaption></figure><p>The play is divided into two acts — each act is a day in the life of the characters. There are only two main characters: Estragon and Vladimir. They are visited at different points by Lucky, Pozzo, and an unnamed boy.</p><p>The set is bare. The stage directions say only: “A country road. A tree. Evening.”</p><p>The scene opens with Estragon sitting down, struggling to get his boot off. He pulls at it with both hands, gives up, rests, tries again. Fails.</p><p>Vladimir enters.</p><blockquote>ESTRAGON: [giving up again] Nothing to be done.<br>VLADIMIR: I’m beginning to come round to that opinion. All my life I’ve tried to put it from me, saying, “Vladimir, be reasonable, you haven’t yet tried everything.” And I resumed the struggle. [He broods, musing on the struggle. turning to Estragon.] So there you are again.<br>ESTRAGON: Am I?<br>VLADIMIR: I’m glad to see you back. I thought you were gone forever.<br>ESTRAGON: Me too.<br>VLADIMIR: Together again at last! We’ll have to celebrate this. But how? [He reflects.] Get up till I embrace you.<br>ESTRAGON: [irritably] Not now, not now.</blockquote><p>It’s only the opening lines of the play but the mood is already set. Can you feel it? It’s a totally bare set, except for a tree. They talk past each other right in the first two lines of dialogue. Estragon irritably refuses to hug his friend, then reveals that he spent the night in a ditch where he was beaten by an unknown group, again.</p><p>Not long after, we find out why they’re even meeting under the tree.</p><blockquote>ESTRAGON: Let’s go.<br>VLADIMIR: We can’t.<br>ESTRAGON: Why not?<br>VLADIMIR: We’re waiting for Godot.<br>ESTRAGON: [despairingly] Ah! [Pause.] You’re sure it was here?<br>VLADIMIR: What?</blockquote><p>They are waiting for Godot. Now, there are a lot of ways to interpret this play, but it seems clear to me that Godot is pointing to God and meaning and purpose and the sacred and holy.</p><p>Estragon and Vladimir are in the metaphorical <strong>wasteland </strong>— actually, not that metaphorical because it’s just them and a dead tree.</p><p>They are in the wasteland and they are waiting for Godot to show up and transform it.</p><p>After some waiting, they get bored and contemplate hanging themselves — but then argue over who should go first. Two new characters Pozzo and Lucky show up. Estragon mistakes Pozzo to be Godot and then admits that <strong>“I wouldn’t even know him if I saw him”</strong> (!). They chat some more and then Pozzo demands that Lucky, who hasn’t spoken yet, “think” as entertainment for them. His “thinking” consists of long rambling philosophical nonsense that begins with:</p><blockquote>LUCKY: Given the existence as uttered forth in the public works of Puncher and Wattmann of a personal God quaquaquaqua with white beard quaquaquaqua outside time without extension who from the heights of divine apathia divine athambia divine aphasia loves us dearly with some exceptions for reasons unknown…</blockquote><p>By the way, this is the same play that was voted the <strong>“most significant English language play of the 20th century”</strong> in a poll conducted by The British Royal National Theatre. And that the famous critic Clive Barnes called, <strong>“one of the true masterpieces of the century.”</strong></p><p>Anyways, after Lucky’s “thinking”, an unnamed boy shows up and says Godot “won’t come this evening, but surely tomorrow.”</p><p>The boy leaves and they agree to wait until tomorrow. Act 1 ends with Estragon saying, “Well, shall we go?” Vladimir nods, but then neither move.</p><p>Curtain closes.</p><p>A dead tree. Sleeping in a ditch. Contemplating suicide. “Thinking” as philosophical nonsense. It’s a window into a nihilistic world.</p><p>No Godot yet.</p><p>No. He’ll be here <strong>tomorrow</strong>. It’s always tomorrow isn’t it? That’s when the wasteland will transform. Tomorrow or “someday” is when the promotion will come or the house or retirement. Tomorrow is when the happiness and love and meaning and purpose and passion and beauty and awe and wonder and aliveness will come.</p><p>Tomorrow.</p><p>Some day.</p><p>Eventually.</p><p>Not today? No, of course not — look around! This is a wasteland!</p><p>But is this a fantasy? This waiting around for a transformation?</p><p>Doesn’t it sound like waiting for Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny or Superman?</p><p>Is Godot a fantasy?</p><p>Maybe there is nothing and no one coming and we’re all fooling ourselves. Maybe there is no escape from the wasteland. Maybe we’re trapped in it. Maybe nothing was ever sacred and nothing ever will be. Maybe there is no God, purpose, meaning, or sacredness. It was all invented to make us feel good. It was all invented to survive the wasteland that is human existence. Nietzsche didn’t really think we “killed” God. He never thought there was a God. It was all just made up, invented.</p><p>Shakespeare captured the spirit of this, when he has Macbeth say:</p><blockquote>Life’s but a walking shadow, a poor player,<br>That struts and frets his hour upon the stage,<br>And then is heard no more. It is a tale<br>Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,<br>Signifying nothing.</blockquote><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4LDdyafsR7g%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4LDdyafsR7g&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4LDdyafsR7g%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/88b604fb0c633d3e39d77d46509725ad/href">https://medium.com/media/88b604fb0c633d3e39d77d46509725ad/href</a></iframe><p>Maybe you don’t believe that as your philosophy or religion or life orientation, but have you ever <strong>felt</strong> that way? Felt like Macbeth? Like nothing and no one is coming — that there will be no transformation — that anything other than the wasteland was made up? I have.</p><p>(And with tens of millions of Americans on anti-depressants, I know others have felt that way too.)</p><p>I think Jacob felt that way. Jacob from Genesis — the first book of the Bible. If you read my last essay “HERE I AM” (<a href="https://medium.com/@dylanozmore/here-i-am-the-bible-disney-movies-answering-the-call-95c4a1159101">here</a>), you know I’m reading the Bible for the first time (!).</p><p>Jacob is kind of like Biblical royalty because his dad was Isaac and his grandfather was Abraham (the patriarch of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam).</p><p>We catch up with Jacob in Beersheba (modern day Israel) when his father is blind and near death. His father is about to bless Esau, Jacob’s older brother, but Jacob steals the blessing. He steals it by dressing up like Esau and lying to his dad. Now in the Bible, stealing a blessing is not like stealing some change out of your dad’s wallet. The blessing was handed down from God to Abraham to Isaac and now supposed to be Esau. But Jacob steals it. Esau is so upset by this that he vows to kill Jacob once he has mourned his father’s death. His mother hears of this and to avoid his being killed, she immediately sends Jacob off to get married.</p><p>So Jacob has just lied to his father (while on his deathbed) and his older brother wants to kill him. He’s left home, left his safety net, left his family, left his friends, and is traveling alone.</p><p>The Bible doesn’t say much about his emotional state, but you can imagine, right? I skipped ahead in the Bible and found this (Psalm 77) that probably describes his emotional state.</p><blockquote>Hands lifted toward heaven,<br>but my soul was not comforted.<br>I think of God, and I moan,<br>overwhelmed with longing for his help.<br>You don’t let me sleep.<br>I am too distressed even to pray!</blockquote><p>Is that Estragon or Vladimir speaking? Or Macbeth? Or Nietzsche?</p><p>At that moment of leaving home that may have been Jacob’s experience. He may have been in the wasteland.</p><p>See I don’t think nihilism is primarily a philosophical or theological issue. I know it’s talked about like that, but I don’t think that’s it. I think essentially nihilism is an <strong>experiential </strong>and<strong> emotional issue</strong>.</p><p>When we’re depressed and dejected and alone, we all become nihilists, if only for a moment. We’ve lost the experience of God. We’ve lost the feeling of the sacred. We’ve lost meaning and purpose and aliveness.</p><p>It’s not that we’ve lost the philosophy or theology of God. We’ve lost the feeling. We’ve lost the experience.</p><p><strong>The wasteland is an experience.</strong></p><p>(Something to ponder: Are ‘meaning’ and ‘purpose’ something to be figured out intellectually or argued about philosophically and theologically — or are meaning and purpose something to be <em>discovered</em>, something to be <em>experienced</em> and<em> felt</em>?)</p><p>So what happened to Jacob? Did he stay trapped in the wasteland?</p><p>There he is wandering through the desert. Alone. The sun is setting and it’s starting to get cold. He stops for the night at some seemingly random spot, sets up camp, and finds “a stone to rest his head against and lay down to sleep.” (How tough is your life when you’re using a stone as a pillow?)</p><p>He lays down. He drops in. He lets go. He surrenders.</p><p>And he falls asleep.</p><p>Then the magic starts.</p><p>He has this incredible dream of “a stairway that reached from the earth up to heaven. And he saw the angels of God going up and down the stairway.” And at the top of the stairway was God.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6ELtPHpLe0jY3gU7.jpg" /><figcaption>Jacob’s Dream by Gustave Dore (1866)</figcaption></figure><p>But it’s just a dream. No big deal, right? What happens to Jacob next? Let’s see what the Bible says:</p><blockquote>Then Jacob <strong>awoke from his sleep</strong> and said,</blockquote><blockquote>“Surely <strong>God is in this place and I wasn’t even aware of it</strong>!</blockquote><blockquote>What an awesome place this is!</blockquote><blockquote>It is none other than the house of God, the very gateway to heaven!”</blockquote><p>Jacob woke up, like, really woke up. He broke through to the other side. He didn’t try to survive the wasteland. He didn’t try to win. He didn’t fight it. He let go, he surrendered, and woke up from his slumber. He woke up to the divine. He woke up to the sacred. He woke up to God.</p><p>I love what he says: “<strong>God is in this place and I wasn’t even aware of it.</strong>”</p><p>God was there and he wasn’t aware of it.</p><p>Let that sink in.</p><p>God</p><p>was</p><p>there</p><p>and</p><p>he</p><p>wasn’t</p><p>aware</p><p>of</p><p>it.</p><p>Maybe God is in this place and you’re not aware of it.</p><p>Maybe the sacred, the meaning, the deep love is right here, right now and you don’t see it.</p><p>Maybe the very gateway to heaven is right where you are.</p><p>Maybe.</p><p>Now for me this points at a certain kind of God. Most of us when we hear God we think about a very large, bearded white man who lives in the clouds, sits on a golden throne, and acts like a ruler and controller over what happens on Earth. I’m not talking about that God. I’m talking about the God that is the <em>ground of Being</em> or the capital S <em>Sacred</em> or the capital S <em>Self</em>. The Divine that is permeating everything. Mountains, trees, rocks, people, birds. (And you.)</p><p>Did God come down from his golden throne and enter Jacob’s dream?</p><p>Or…</p><p>Did Jacob wake up to that God was already there? Already there and he wasn’t aware of it. Already present, already permeating the space and everything and everyone in it.</p><p>Shakespeare could write hauntingly and cryptically like he did through Macbeth, but he could also write beautifully and poetically. In his play <em>As You Like It</em>, he speaks through the role of Duke Senior:</p><blockquote>Sweet are the uses of adversity<br>Which, like the toad, ugly and venomous,<br>Wears yet a precious jewel in his head;<br>And this our life, exempt from public haunt,<br>Finds <strong>tongues in trees</strong>,<strong> books in the running brooks</strong>,<strong><br>Sermons in stones</strong>, and<strong> good in everything.</strong></blockquote><p>Have you ever had a tree speak to you? Or read a book in a river? Or heard a sermon from a stone?</p><p>(Hang onto that phrase “good in everything.” We’ll come back to that.)</p><p>Jacob didn’t hear a sermon in stone — but he did wake up transformed. Then he turned his pillow-stone into a memorial to God.</p><p>Pocahontas had a tree talk to her. In the Disney film, she wakes John Smith up to the world of the sacred — including a talking tree (“Grandmother Willow”). In the most famous song of the film, Pocahontas compares John’s experience with her own.</p><blockquote>You think you own whatever land you land on<br>The Earth is just a dead thing you can claim<br><strong>But I know every rock and tree and creature<br>Has a life, has a spirit, has a name</strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/0*E7liEftILwJaMuZV.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Pocahontas talking to Grandmother Willow (1995)</em></figcaption></figure><p>It’s the same thing in <em>Avatar</em> (2009). Neytiri helps Jake Sully discover the Spirit in everything.</p><p>The entire world is buzzing and singing and talking and flowing.</p><p><strong>There is a cosmic dance happening around us making God the beautifully-sacred-poetic-magical-transcendent-extraordinary-divine process that is the whole thing</strong>.</p><p>So what happened in Act 2 — the second day — of <em>Waiting for Godot</em>? Does Godot appear!?</p><p>The stage directions read simply: “Next day. Same time. Same place.”</p><p>Estragon claims to have been beaten again last night, despite no apparent injury.</p><blockquote>VLADIMIR: Who beat you? Tell me.<br>ESTRAGON: Another day done with.<br>VLADIMIR: Not yet.<br>ESTRAGON: <strong>For me it’s over and done with, no matter what happens.</strong></blockquote><p>There’s no Godot. They try desperately to pass the time and fill the silence. (Ever tried to do that? Fill the space with mindless chatter or by picking up your phone?)</p><blockquote>VLADIMIR: Likes ashes.<br>ESTRAGON: Like leaves. [Long silence.]<br>VLADIMIR: Say something!<br>ESTRAGON: I’m trying. [Long silence.]<br>VLADIMIR: [in anguish.] Say anything at all!<br>ESTRAGON: What do we do now?<br>VLADIMIR: Wait for Godot.<br>ESTRAGON: Ah! [Silence.]<br>VLADIMIR: This is awful!</blockquote><p>They try to leave.</p><blockquote>ESTRAGON: Let’s go.<br>VLADIMIR: We can’t.<br>ESTRAGON: Why not?<br>VLADIMIR: We’re waiting for Godot.</blockquote><p>The same exact lines as the previous day. They are seemingly trapped in a kind of Hell wasteland — a Groundhog’s Day loop without any escape. Pozzo and Lucky come and go. Vladimir is left wondering:</p><blockquote>VLADIMIR: Was I sleeping, while the others suffered?<strong> Am I sleeping now?</strong></blockquote><p>The unnamed boy appears again. Can you guess what he says?</p><p>He says that Godot won’t be coming this evening. He’ll be coming <strong>tomorrow</strong>.</p><p>Tomorrow.</p><p>Some day.</p><p>Eventually.</p><p>Then the boy leaves.</p><blockquote>ESTRAGON: I can’t go on like this.<br>VLADIMIR: That’s what you think.<br>ESTRAGON: If we parted? That might be better for us.<br>VLADIMIR: We’ll hang ourselves tomorrow. [Pause.] <strong>Unless Godot comes.</strong><br>ESTRAGON: <strong>And if he comes?</strong><br>VLADIMIR: <strong>We’ll be saved.</strong></blockquote><p>They’ll be saved. Transformed. Out of the wasteland. But not until Godot comes. The scene ends with:</p><blockquote>VLADIMIR: Well? Shall we go?<br>ESTRAGON: Yes, let’s go.<br>[They do not move.]</blockquote><p>Curtain closes. The play ends.</p><p>No Godot.</p><p>Waiting, wishing, hoping for a fantasy.</p><p>In this case, Nietzsche was right. Macbeth was right.</p><p>Or were they?</p><p>I think Vladimir and Estragon missed it.</p><p>Missed what?</p><p>Godot.</p><p>They missed Godot.</p><p>How?</p><p>Because <strong>Godot had already arrived.</strong></p><p>Yes.</p><p>Godot was already there.</p><p>Yes.</p><p>Godot — God, the sacred, divine — was right there and they couldn’t see it. Just like Jacob before his dream. Just like John Smith before he met Pocahontas. Just like Jake Sully before he met Neytiri.</p><p><strong>God was there and they weren’t aware of it.</strong></p><p>Yes.</p><p>This is not a wasteland.</p><p>The Earth is not a dead thing.</p><p>Human existence is not meaningless and purposeless.</p><p>God is not dead.</p><p>The essential nature of existence is holy and sacred and divine — and good. So is the essential nature of life. So is the essential nature of you.</p><p>Remember that “good in everything” phrase from Shakespeare? Well, do you know how the Bible starts?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/429/0*ciRHlprY9sCQ4ZTF.jpg" /><figcaption>The Creation of Light by Gustave Dore (1866)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. The earth was formless and empty, and darkness covered the deep waters. And the Spirit of God was hovering over the surface of the waters.</blockquote><blockquote>Then God said, “Let there be light,” and there was light. <strong>And God saw that the light was good.</strong></blockquote><p>Then he created land and plants and animals and humans.</p><blockquote><strong>God looked over all he had made, and he saw that it was very good!</strong></blockquote><p>It was very good!</p><p>What was? The whole thing! The land, the water, the animals, the trees, the human beings.</p><p>The whole thing is good and beautiful and poetic and sacred and holy.</p><p>The divine is in everything.</p><p>Vladimir and Estragon and Nietzsche and Macbeth missed it. They missed God. They missed the sacred and divine. It was hidden from them. It was there and they were unaware of it. They missed the final secret of Zen.</p><p>The final secret of what?</p><p>The final secret of Zen is exactly what we are talking about — God, the sacred, divine, holy — where deep meaning and purpose and aliveness is found.</p><p>Here is the famous, classic Zen story to bring it all home for you.</p><blockquote>The disciple was always complaining to the Zen Master, “You are hiding the final secret of Zen from me!”</blockquote><blockquote>And he would not accept the Master’s denials.</blockquote><blockquote>One day they were walking in the hills when they heard a bird sing.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>“Did you hear that bird sing?”</strong> asked the Master.</blockquote><blockquote>“<strong>Yes</strong>,” said the disciple.</blockquote><blockquote>“<strong>Now you know that I have hidden nothing from you.</strong>”</blockquote><p>When you’ve really heard a bird sing, when you’ve really felt the beauty of nature, when you’ve really connected with another person, when you’ve really gotten in touch with reality, you wake up from your slumber, you transform the wasteland.</p><p>God, the sacred, the divine — is right here.</p><p>With you.</p><p>Around you.</p><p>In you.</p><p>That’s it.</p><p>So why did I spend several weeks putting this essay together? It wasn’t to convince you or persuade you of anything. I am not trying to be a philosopher or theologian or a spiritual teacher or even a social commentator. I don’t want you to become a Christian or a yogi or a Zen student or to read the Bible.</p><p>I just want to inspire you to hear a bird sing.</p><p>Then you will know that nothing is hidden from you.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d65c3abf40bd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HERE I AM: The Bible, Disney Movies, & Answering the Call]]></title>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/here-i-am-the-bible-disney-movies-answering-the-call-95c4a1159101?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/95c4a1159101</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[purpose]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Dec 2019 18:25:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-18T18:57:02.590Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kwXIqH7WMyasVTTY.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Abraham’s Journey from Ur to Canaan </em>by József Molnár (1850)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Some time later God tested Abraham. He said to him, “Abraham!”</em></p><p><em>“Here I am,” he replied.</em></p><p><em>— Genesis 22:1</em></p><p>I’m reading the Bible for the first time (!). I’m 31 years old and I’m reading the Bible. I didn’t think I would ever read it. I’m not Christian. I wasn’t raised a Christian. My only experience with the Bible when I was younger was when my family stayed at a hotel and they had one in the bedside drawer (how did that start?). But I never read it.</p><p>And now I am. (And I’ve been hanging out at a church a lot — but that’s <a href="https://medium.com/@dylanozmore/the-new-christianity-is-one-of-the-most-exciting-things-happening-right-now-f65063fe9b38">a story</a> for another day.)</p><p>I used to have no interest in reading the Bible and now I feel late to the game. Late, as in I would have liked to read it sooner. I’m actually surprised we don’t read it in grade school. I went to a public school and we didn’t even discuss it, let alone read it. Separation of church and state I guess? We read Shakespeare. It seemed important that we do because of the impact and influence of his writings. But the impact of Shakespeare on Western culture doesn’t hold a candle to the impact of the Bible (sorry, William) — that’s just obvious right?</p><p>Anyways, I’m reading the Bible. I haven’t gotten far — just through Genesis (the first book of the Bible) and already a couple things stood out.</p><p>First, this is not easy reading. The Bible is not exactly a page-turner (neither is Shakespeare in my opinion).</p><p>Second, how short some of the famous stories are. Big, famous stories, ones that I’ve actually heard about are sometimes only sentences long. The whole story of Adam and Eve is barely a full page. Cain and Abel is 3 paragraphs. And the Tower of Babel is like 2 sentences.</p><p>Third, Abraham’s response to God calling on him. He says, “Here I am.”</p><p>Right now, I want to talk about that last one. Well, write about it.</p><p>For those who haven’t read the Bible, which is most people I know, here’s a little background on the Abraham story…</p><p>Abraham is the common patriarch of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. He was a descendant of Noah (famous for the flood). He and his two brothers were born in Ur of the Chaldeans, which is modern day Iraq. He married a woman named Sarah who was unable to have a child. One of his brothers died in Ur before his family set off for Harran. They settled there and his father died. Then God calls on him.</p><p>God calls on him and — without knowing the ask — Abraham stands up and says, “Here I am.”</p><p>Wow.</p><p>God — the Universe, Source, Spirit, Energy, the Divine — calls on him. It’s a call from the beyond. Beyond what is known and established and safe and secure and predictable. A call into the unknown.</p><p>All that and he says “Here I am.”</p><p>(Actually, in the original Bible he didn’t say that because it wasn’t in English. It was in Hebrew. He said, “Hineini” — הִנֵּֽנִי — pronounced <em>hee-NAY-nee</em>), which translates as “Here I am.” Hineini is the joining of two words: hineh and ani, meaning here and I.)</p><p>“Here I am.”</p><p>It’s like a badass Biblical “Let’s do this.”</p><p>Or a giant “<strong>YES.</strong>”</p><p>Back in 2017, my partner Jessica and I moved into a beautiful 2 bedroom apartment in downtown San Diego. We signed a 1 year lease and given that we didn’t own any furniture, we went out and furnished the whole place. I had been working at a consulting firm for several years. I liked the team, I liked the work, and I was paid well. I was comfortable and happy.</p><p>3 months after moving into the new place, I was on a flight to a client’s office in Canada, reading a book, minding my own business. When out of nowhere a very clear thought popped into my head: “It’s time to do something totally different with your life.” Huh? What? “It’s time to do something totally different.” Like what? No thanks! I’m happy here. My life is on a good track. No change needed. And besides, I just signed a lease! I just furnished this apartment! Then again: “It’s time to do something totally different.” God? Universe? Hello? My own crazy mind? How could I be sure? But the call was undeniable.</p><p>Disney movies are so good at portraying the call. Every one of their movies starts out by setting the scene, all seems secure and predictable for the main character, and then comes the call. (<em>By the way, next time you watch a Disney movie try watching it from the perspective of the hero’s journey — the call to adventure, the early challenges and triumphs, the ultimate challenge, the ultimate victory, and the return home.</em>)</p><p>Maybe you’ve seen Moana? Moana is called to travel beyond the protective reef.</p><p>Or Coco? Miguel is called to become a musician.</p><p>Star Wars? Luke Skywalker is called to help save Princess Leia.</p><p>The call is a beautiful idea. A wonderful concept. But not exactly our idea of a good time. Change (and death — but isn’t death just change?) is probably what we fear most as human beings. Leaving our current circumstances is always a risk. Most of us would rather stay in bad circumstances than take the risk. Who knows — maybe the risk will mean even worse circumstances!</p><p>How many times does God — the Universe, Source, Spirit — call on us and we refuse? We’re too busy. We’re too comfortable. We’re too rich. We’re too narrow. We’re too scared. We’re too tired. So we refuse the call. We stay where we are.</p><p>Moana stays on the island and is trained to become the next chief.</p><p>Miguel stays at home and is stuck secretly playing his guitar in the attic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*0CN_PGIwQcqA3SqJ.jpg" /><figcaption>Miguel in the attic, Coco (2017)</figcaption></figure><p>Luke Skywalker’s refusal is the best. Him and Obi-Wan have just finished watching the transmission video of Princess Leia which ended with: <strong>“This is our most desperate hour. Help me, Obi-Wan Kenobi, you’re my only hope.”</strong> This is our most desperate hour (!). Let’s see how Luke responds.</p><blockquote>[Transmission video ends]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Obi-Wan:</strong> You must learn the ways of the Force if you’re to come with me to Alderaan.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Luke:</strong> (laughing) Alderaan? I’m not going to Alderaan. I’ve got to go home. It’s late, I’m in for it as it is.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Obi-Wan:</strong> I need your help, Luke. She needs your help. I’m getting too old for this sort of thing.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Luke:</strong> I can’t get involved! I’ve got work to do! It’s not that I like the Empire. I hate it! But there’s nothing I can do about it right now. It’s such a long way from here.</blockquote><p>Luke can’t help save the galaxy in its most desperate hour. He has to go home! It’s late! He has work to do! Sound like anyone you know? Maybe it sounds like you? I know I’ve been there. “Nope, can’t help, I have work to do!”</p><p>We refuse the call.</p><p>We say “No.”</p><p>God calls us — the Universe, Source, Spirit calls us — and let’s be honest we rarely say “Here I am.” No. We hide. We run. “Sorry, not right now. Gotta go! Bye!”</p><p>Fear. Worry. Panic. Dread. Whatever the emotion is, we allow it to stop the call.</p><p>Just like Jonah did. You know Jonah? The one who got swallowed by the whale?</p><p>I haven’t read that far in the Bible yet, but I skipped ahead and read his story (I know, kind of bad of me right?). Here’s how the Book of Jonah starts:</p><blockquote>The word of the Lord came to Jonah son of Amittai: “Go to the great city of Nineveh and preach against it, because its wickedness has come up before me.”</blockquote><blockquote>But Jonah ran away from the Lord and headed for Tarshish.</blockquote><blockquote>He went down to Joppa, where he found a ship bound for that port. After paying the fare, he went aboard and sailed for Tarshish to flee from the Lord.</blockquote><p>Then he was swallowed by a giant fish.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6gVEP-AdKJxBWGQ8.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Jonah and the Whale</em> by Pieter Lastman (1621)</figcaption></figure><p>He ran from his destiny.</p><p>Have you ever met someone who ran from their destiny? They’re still walking around like they’re trapped inside a giant metaphorical fish? Dark, cold, wet. No oxygen, no food, no life, just kind of flopping around from one thing to the next. Yeah, not a pretty sight.</p><p>Maybe Jonah was afraid of the unknown? He didn’t know what traveling to Nineveh would lead to. Maybe he was afraid he would fail? That he wouldn’t be good enough for the task at hand? (<em>Have you ever been called to something big and then your next thought is “I’m not good enough for that”? Yeah me neither.</em>)</p><p>The famous psychologist Abraham Maslow (you may know him from Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs) has an interesting take on the Jonah story. He didn’t think that Jonah was running from fear of not being enough. No. Maslow says Jonah was running from — get this — running from fear of his own greatness. Fear. Of. His. Own. Greatness. Whatttttt.</p><p>He called it the Jonah Complex.</p><p>Running from your own greatness.</p><p>Look what he says:</p><blockquote>“We fear our highest possibilities…We are generally afraid to become that which we glimpse in our most perfect moments, under the most perfect conditions, under the conditions of greatest courage. We enjoy and even thrill to godlike possibilities we see in ourselves in such peak moments. And yet we simultaneously shiver with weakness, awe, and fear before these very same possibilities.”</blockquote><p>Maslow would ask his students which of them will write the next great novel, be the next great composer or world leader.</p><blockquote>“Generally, everybody starts giggling, blushing, and squirming until I ask, ‘If not you, then who?’…If you deliberately plan to be less than you are capable of being, then I warn you that you’ll be deeply unhappy for the rest of your life. You will be evading your own capacities, your own possibilities.”</blockquote><p>Refuse the call? Run from your destiny? Run from your own capacities and possibilities? You’ll be deeply unhappy. Miserable. There’s no way around it. Kind of like being trapped in a giant fish.</p><p>Maslow is pointing at the <em>cost </em>of refusing the call. There were costs to Jonah running. There were costs to Moana, Miguel, and Luke.</p><p>Sometimes we’re aware of the cost, sometimes we’re not.</p><p>But I’m afraid it gets worse than running. (It’ll get darker here, but I promise there is light at the end of the tunnel!).</p><p>It gets worse than refusing the call.</p><p>What could be worse?</p><p>Not</p><p>Hearing</p><p>It</p><p>At</p><p>All.</p><p>What’s worse is missing the call entirely. Not even knowing the call came in.</p><p>“Huh? What call?”</p><p>“Save the galaxy? What? No one asked me to do that.”</p><p>Maybe you were too busy checking social media that you missed it. Too occupied with weekend plans. Too focused on the latest Netflix special. Too angry about the promotion you didn’t get. Too upset with the 5 pounds you didn’t lose. Too depressed you’re still single. Too anxious about what other people think of you. Too much noise. Too much mental chatter. Too much in the way.</p><p>You can’t refuse a call you didn’t know came in.</p><p>You can’t read a sign when you’re driving 120 miles an hour.</p><p>You can’t hear a whisper at a rock concert.</p><p>How many times have you missed the call?</p><p>Don’t know. You can’t know. It already came and went.</p><p>How could you miss it?</p><p>This gets into the <em>nature</em> of the call. Because <strong>I don’t think the call is a booming voice coming down from the heavens, it’s more like a whisper coming up from your heart.</strong></p><p>As Jiminy Cricket says to <a href="https://medium.com/@dylanozmore/pinocchio-the-journey-to-the-center-of-your-being-73172657f4f8">Pinnochio</a>, it is that “<em>still small voice</em> people won’t listen to.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/0*d8g06b1cmx9Qlwt8.jpg" /><figcaption>Jiminy Cricket &amp; Pinnochio (1940)</figcaption></figure><p>The call isn’t a booming voice? I used to think that’s how God spoke — that’s how the call worked. But not anymore.</p><p>In the Book of Kings (I skipped ahead again in the Bible), the prophet Elijah has just run away from Sinai for fear of being killed. He ends up exhausted and alone in a mountain cave. Then God speaks to him.</p><blockquote>“Go out and stand before me on the mountain,” the Lord told him. And as Elijah stood there, the Lord passed by, and a mighty windstorm hit the mountain. It was such a terrible blast that the rocks were torn loose, but the Lord was not in the wind. After the wind there was an earthquake, but the Lord was not in the earthquake. And after the earthquake there was a fire, but the Lord was not in the fire. And after the fire there was the sound of a gentle whisper. When Elijah heard it, he wrapped his face in his cloak and went out and stood at the entrance of the cave.</blockquote><p>Not in the wind. Not in the earthquake. Not in the fire.</p><p>In a gentle whisper. (!)</p><p>Makes you reflect, doesn’t it?</p><p>Wait around for a booming voice and you miss all the whispers.</p><p>Moana’s grandmother, who is also a sort of shaman, warns her in the opening song not to miss that voice.</p><blockquote>Mind what he says but remember<br>You may hear a voice inside<br>And if the voice starts to whisper<br>To follow the farthest star<br>Moana, that voice inside<br>Is who you are</blockquote><p>Pinnochio. The Bible. Moana. Have you seen Frozen 2 yet? Same thing.</p><p>The call can be so quiet, so small, such a whisper, that we need to be <em>open </em>to even know it comes in. To hear it we need to be quiet ourselves. We need to have slowed down. We need to be present and open and aware. You need to be present and open and aware.</p><p>Open your senses.</p><p>Open your mind.</p><p>Open your being.</p><p>When you close those off you implicitly say “No” to the call, usually without even knowing it.</p><p>When you open those up you say “Yes.” You invite the call. You invite possibility. You invite adventure.</p><p>Part of what makes the Disney stories so beautiful and compelling is that they all eventually heed the call. Moana sails beyond the protective reef to save her tribe. Miguel travels into the Land of the Dead to become a musician and rescue his family. Luke learns about the Force and goes to save Princess Leia.</p><p>They all stood up and said, “Here I am.” I will answer the call.</p><p>God called and Abraham stood up and said, “Here I am.”</p><p>In 2017, I said, “Here I am.” I finished that work flight to Canada. I gave it a couple days to make sure that the message to do something totally different was still alive and burning — which it was. So that Monday I put in my resignation. I didn’t know what was next. I didn’t know what I was meant to do. I had a lease and bills and prior plans. It felt like stepping into nothing. It’s strange how stepping into a “Yes” can sometimes be stepping into nothing. It wasn’t nothing like a black pit. It was more like a blank canvas. And despite the fear and uncertainty, I stepped in. And over time things began to emerge. Travel plans. A book. Photography. Another book. More travel. New adventures. New struggles. New communities. New projects. And I’m left here with a new heart and a new mind. Not perfect. But transformed. Altered. New. And open. Open to the next call. Open to the next whisper.</p><p>We have to heed the call. For ourselves, for our family, for our communities, for society. And for God, for the Universe, for Source.</p><p>…for God? What does God care? What does the Universe care?</p><p>Because God also says, “Here I am.”</p><p>Check this out from the Book of Isaiah.</p><blockquote>Then you shall call, and the Lord will answer;<br>You shall cry, and He will say, ‘<strong>Here I am.</strong>’</blockquote><p>and it continues:</p><blockquote>Then your light will shine out from the darkness,<br>and the darkness around you will be as bright as noon.<br>The Lord will guide you continually,<br>giving you water when you are dry<br>and restoring your strength.<br>You will be like a well-watered garden,<br>like an ever-flowing spring.</blockquote><p>The Universe is for you. Source is for you. God is for you.</p><p>We tend to think of calls as one-way. The sender and the receiver. But the kind of call I’m talking about here is different. It’s two-way. It’s a <em>dialogue</em>. It’s a <em>relationship</em>. You and your destiny. You and God. You and everything.</p><p>Don’t take my word for it. Yoda says it all: “For my ally is the Force, and a powerful ally it is. Life creates it, makes it grow. Its energy surrounds us and binds us. Luminous beings are we, not this crude matter. You must feel the Force around you; here, between you, me, the tree, the rock, everywhere, yes. Even between the land and the ship.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*ZiY7UfAvV7XEf-2wrjOGVg.png" /><figcaption>Yoda and Luke (1977)</figcaption></figure><p>A powerful ally it is.</p><p>The Force was there for Luke.</p><p>The ocean was there for Moana.</p><p>The spirits of his ancestors were there for Miguel.</p><p>You can miss the call. You can even refuse it. But <strong>the Universe is conspiring <em>for you</em></strong> — for you to respond — for you to say “Yes” — for you to live an incredible, creative, loving life.</p><p>Remember Jonah? He ran from his destiny and got stuck in the belly of a giant fish? Well, that wasn’t the end of his story.</p><p>There he is stuck inside this wet, cold, dark place. Scared, full of shame and guilt, depressed. And then he surrenders. He stops clinging to fear and he opens his heart and being. He opens up and prays.</p><blockquote>I sank beneath the waves,<br>and the waters closed over me.<br>Seaweed wrapped itself around my head.<br>I sank down to the very roots of the mountains.<br>I was imprisoned in the earth,<br>whose gates lock shut forever.<br>But you, O Lord my God,<br>snatched me from the jaws of death!<br>As my life was slipping away,<br>I remembered the Lord.<br>And my earnest prayer went out to you<br>in your holy Temple.</blockquote><p>God heard him. The Universe heard him. And he was spit out by the fish! Spit out of depression and angst and shame — and born anew. Transformed. Altered. And off to fulfill his destiny.</p><p>Just like you.</p><p>God, the Universe, Spirit won’t give up on you. You’re not alone. It’s your most powerful ally.</p><p>You have the adventure of a lifetime ahead of you.</p><p>So the next time you hear a whisper, stand up and say,</p><p><strong>“Here I am.”</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=95c4a1159101" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The New Christianity Is One of the Most Exciting Things Happening Right Now]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://dylanozmore.medium.com/the-new-christianity-is-one-of-the-most-exciting-things-happening-right-now-f65063fe9b38?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/928/0*iFxVPuWL2WwsPscI.jpg" width="928"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">Driverless cars. Vegan meat. Cryptocurrencies. Sustainable fashion. Composting toilets. And the new Christianity.</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://dylanozmore.medium.com/the-new-christianity-is-one-of-the-most-exciting-things-happening-right-now-f65063fe9b38?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://dylanozmore.medium.com/the-new-christianity-is-one-of-the-most-exciting-things-happening-right-now-f65063fe9b38?source=rss-ae87f60bfa1e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f65063fe9b38</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[church]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Nathaniel Ozmore]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Nov 2019 19:06:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-20T19:06:11.599Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>