<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ed. Condon on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ed. Condon on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 20:06:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ed.condon/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lighten up, nerds]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/lighten-up-nerds-2ba8bf5ebc0?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2ba8bf5ebc0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Jun 2023 18:19:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-04T18:21:58.152Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R86cq_43huwWbUzBKRnIYw@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Jametlene Reskp on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><p>NASA’s independent committee looking into UFOs held its first public meeting this week, with a four-hour live stream session.</p><p>I probably sank more time than I should have into catching up on it between the hours of midnight and 3am on Thursday morning. I thought they must have something interesting to report if they needed four hours to cover it all.</p><p>Instead, what we got was a very worthy presentation on how some 98% of what we now are supposed to call “unidentified anomalous phenomena” are overwhelmingly likely to be perfectly explainable tricks of the light when you’re cruising at the rim of the stratosphere at high speed.</p><p>And, the 16-member panel said, they’d be able to better say exactly how these tricks happen if they had access to better data and more reliable accounts of these close encounters with apparently thin air.</p><p>Unfortunately, the panel said, there’s a lot of “stigma” attached to coming forward with information and footage of unidentified anomalous phenomena. Fair enough, I thought, people are worried they’ll be called nuts if they phone in a flying saucer.</p><p>And, so I thought, these must be some angry skeptics since the chairman kicked off by saying that “it’s disheartening to note that several [of the committee] have been subjected to online abuse due to their decision to participate on this panel.” So much so, he said, that a NASA security team is addressing the issue.</p><p>(Side bar: NASA security team? Isn’t this what we have a Space Force <em>for</em>?)</p><p>“We at NASA are acutely aware of the considerable public interest in UAP, however it is critical to understand any form of harassment towards our panelists only serves to detract from the scientific process, which requires an environment of respect and openness.”</p><p>I admit I was surprised. I could understand a little crank-shaming of friends and family, or that guy at the other end of the bar, if they started talking about the lights they saw in the sky on the way home, but who is dragging serious scientists for taking a dry-as-toast look at what’s been reported?</p><p>I had a <em>shufti</em> online for this abuse and from what I could see, these scientists really are being harassed. But not by people who think UFOs are a joke. They’re being targeted by the online enthusiast crowd — the sort who, and I don’t want to generalize here, might spend their free time somewhere in the New Mexico desert looking for little green men.</p><p>Apparently, the consensus among the believers is that the panel are cover-up artists, and shills for the big conspiracy keeping us from the truth about extraterrestrials.</p><p>Now, I confess to mixed reactions here.</p><p>Online abuse is bad, even (and even especially) when it’s coming from an insular group with more than its fair share of loonies. I want to be clear about that.</p><p>But on the other hand, were I on this panel, I’d probably be doing my best to egg them on for my own amusement.</p><p>I mean, I don’t know how you can talk about UFOs, sorry UPAs, for four hours without winking to the camera, or archly referencing classified information, at least a little. Honestly, if I were the panel chair, I’d probably have done the live stream from Ft. Knox, just to screw with these people. Come on guys, have a little fun here.</p><p>For all the panel’s talk about being “acutely aware of the considerable public interest in UAP” they really aren’t doing much to capitalize on it. Even the term UPA seems to have been brought in because the nerds worried that saying UFOs made people, well, think of UFOs. It’s just a killjoy move.</p><p>Look, I’m not saying NASA’s sitting on a flying saucer over at Area 51. And I don’t have any actual hope or expectation that the night sky is alive with ETs. But if 98% of these sightings can be rationally explained, can we at least leave a little space to play around with the 2%?</p><p>Scientific discovery is, for sure, serious business and needs to be rooted in the pursuit of the facts by rationally weighing the evidence. But it is also a process driven by capturing our imagination with semi-serious, even silly questions that we just can’t leave alone and then letting ourselves see what answers we can come up with.</p><p>And if the eggheads at NASA allowed themselves to pander just a little to the popular imagination, it might help them, too.</p><p>If they would just give us a little permission to look up and wonder, I bet it would take some of the “stigma” keeping people from sending in the data they want. And I bet it would help crowd out the crazies online, too, if they weren’t the only ones interested in the truth out there.</p><p>For myself, I want to believe. But those 16 rocket scientists could do just a bit more to help my unbelief.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2ba8bf5ebc0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the McCarrick Report]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-the-mccarrick-report-5df3a3a044a8?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5df3a3a044a8</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Nov 2020 17:32:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-16T14:23:09.893Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On the McCarrick Report</p><p>So, the McCarrick Report has finally been released. Almost two and a half years after the former cardinal’s lucifarian fall, many Catholics, especially in the United States, hoped they would finally read, among the horrific details, the voice of a penitent hierarchy. They did not.</p><p>Served up with the Secretariat of State’s customary sensitivity and elan, the ponderous, 450-page slab of scandal, abuse, and bureaucratic obfuscation thudded onto the breakfast tables of American Catholics Tuesday morning like a dead labrador.</p><p>While the report’s revelations are real, and the details painfully gruesome, it provided little beyond a long and at times confusing narrative. What many Catholics longed for was, alongside a catalogue of past errors, a sense that responsibility had been taken and lessons learned. In this, they remain disappointed.</p><p>The report concludes by quoting Pope Francis, quoting St. Paul: “If one member suffers, all suffer together with it.”</p><p>“The pain of the victims and their families is also our pain, and so it is urgent that we once more reaffirm our commitment to ensure the protection of minors and of vulnerable adults.”</p><p>There is little sense in the report’s pages that the pain of victims was much felt by its authors, or the ranks of curial officials and American bishops who repeatedly dismissed, diminished, or outright ignored McCarrick’s predations for decades.</p><p>Nor is it clear that any particular lessons have been learned from the shocking catalogue of inaction chronicled in the report.</p><p>While McCarrick’s prolific fundraising and gift-giving is acknowledged, this is dismissed as immaterial to his rise through the Church’s ranks. Though the report records that he gave large gifts to Vatican officials and his brother bishops, no names are named, and no indication is given about where the money came from, or went.</p><p>The McCarrick report has many words but, in the end, speaks with no one’s voice, and seems addressed to no one in particular. It is detailed, but it is also incurious, impersonal, and ultimately without a clear conclusion or purpose.</p><p>To be sure, Pope Francis has made dramatic — even historic — strides in increasing episcopal accountability in the wake of the McCarrick scandal. The promulgation of Vos estis lux mundi has proven to be anything but a dead letter, as several American bishops have discovered.</p><p>But while some American Catholics may take a grim satisfaction in that their leaders are being more effectively policed, what is still lacking is an authentic sense that the bishops share their pain and outrage, something crucial to rebuilding any kind of trust.</p><p>Next week, the American bishops will hold a virtual Fall General Assembly. There will be, for sure, some time given over to performative McCarricking.</p><p>There is likely to be some statement of group remorse, group shock, group pain, group resolution to learn lessons. But, after decades of corporate mea culpas, these unanimous resolutions are likely to fall on the ears of Catholics as so much white noise.</p><p>What Catholics crave is personal accountability, and there is not likely to be unanimous consensus for that.</p><p>Although it is known that McCarrick gave large cash gifts to senior clerics, the McCarrick Report did not name them. How many of those will be logging on to the USCCB meeting and signing on to whatever statement they decide to release? Undoubtedly some. How many will be willing to step out of the shadow of the McCarrick Report’s sealed source documents and admit so in public? I doubt any.</p><p>The U.S. bishops conference will speak, as it always does, with one voice. But behind that façade of unity, there will be some who owe their careers to McCarrick’s intervention, some who profited personally from his generosity, and many more who never had anything to do with McCarrick and the network of patronage which sustained him for years. For the last two years, the former have found shelter in the shadow of the latter. The bishops must now ask themselves, will they continue to do so?</p><p>The McCarrick report answers many painful questions about the specific crimes of Theodore McCarrick. Unanswered are the questions many Catholics have about his enduring legacy among their leaders; how many of their bishops knew and did nothing? How many took money from McCarrick? How many suspected?</p><p>Answering those questions is simply something the bishops cannot do as a body. The first, best, possibly last hope of U.S. Catholics in their leaders is that some, as individuals, will be willing to break silence and break ranks.</p><p>McCarrick’s former dioceses of Metuchen, Newark, and Washington all sent volumes of documents, correspondence, and records to Rome for the Vatican’s investigation. Will those bishops, and cardinals, now release what they sent?</p><p>Will those who knew and trusted McCarrick, and profited from that relationship, speak with their own voice — I, not we — and give their own honest account and apology?</p><p>Perhaps most importantly, will the bishops who knew nothing of McCarrick, and saw nothing of his crimes or coin, continue to tolerate the silence of their colleagues who did?</p><p>While the Holy See no doubt hopes that the release of the McCarrick report will mark a final end to the story, it will not. New details will continue to emerge. Questions the report refused to confront will be taken up by others.</p><p>What the U.S. bishops have now, again, is a narrow window to act first, to show individual moral leadership. Will they take it, at last?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5df3a3a044a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the ‘virtue’ of democracy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-the-virtue-of-our-democracy-d85762d56d8e?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d85762d56d8e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Sep 2020 00:01:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-04T03:15:19.365Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On the ‘virtue’ of democracy</p><p>It is part of American self-conception that democracy — ‘our democracy’ as we must always call it — is not just a good way to run a country, but a good in itself. In reality, democracy is more agent of decay than vehicle of virtue, and we may have finally decayed past the pretensions of our founding myths.</p><p>Our democracy is divisive — essentially so. The American founding fathers knew this, or intuited it. It is why we have institutions which check unfettered democracy — like an electoral college and a senate. It’s also why some were openly opposed to allowing political parties to form.</p><p>In this country, democracy began with a broad set of common assumptions on all political sides — about morality, religion (to an extent), and values. Divisions were drawn, and elections contested, along other lines: centralism vs subsidiarity, expansion vs consolidation, economics, foreign engagement, and so on. But endless political campaigns mean an endless need to stake out new positions, draw new lines of difference.</p><p>Safeguards notwithstanding, a society ordered on contested political ideology is ever degrading, with every election cycle like a half-life, shortening each time; so much so that now even the parties are themselves as divided as they are dividers. It is the slow-motion shattering of consensus, not its creation.</p><p>In democracy there must be elections, and each victory must be at the expense of another; you cannot propose ‘me,’ without insisting ‘not them.’ The means to power is a zero-sum game and, inevitably, it must be played out to the voters in those terms, with the stakes made — or sold as — ever higher.</p><p>In the end, consensus and unity are at odds with the acquisition and retention of power, which is why actual political unity traditionally comes only in times of crises and external, existential, threat — like war.</p><p>Division in democracy, like alcohol in fermentation, is both essential byproduct and toxin. Eventually it’s concentration becomes so high it poisons the ecosystem which creates it, until we arrive at a true threat — a pandemic, for example — and have not the will, or even desire, to face it together.</p><p>—</p><p>Baked in to the practice, indeed the premise, of American democracy is the idea that it is inherently virtuous as a system; that the casting of votes to elect a government is not just relatively equitable or expedient, but an objective good in itself.</p><p>This original fallacy has seeped into our social conceptions such that ‘free’ and ‘democratic’ are considered, if not synonymous, at least inseparable when describing a justly ordered society. And it is false.</p><p>While there is much to commend the fruits of the American experiment, it spent nearly 100 years being demonstrably ‘democratic’ without being ‘free’.</p><p>That eventual freedom was delivered by war and the disputed exercise of executive authority, not by democratic means. And it was followed by the democratic Blaine Amendments to curtail Catholic participation in public life, and, of course, by Jim Crow.</p><p>Yet, today, our ‘free and democratic’ society still insists that the very exercise of our political process to be inherently virtuous — ‘I voted’ stickers are one of the last virtue signals common across the divide.</p><p>If voting is not just responsible but ‘good’, and if democracy itself is virtuous in its very premise and exercise, then, by extension, it’s results are cloaked in goodness and virtue. It’s a premise both absurd and, at times, obscene.</p><p>Aaron Sorkin, the great hagiographer of American politics, described it as ‘really something every two years we get to overthrow a government.’ The assumption that the process makes virtuous the result allowed him to give the line, unironically, to a character championing partial birth abortion.</p><p>A system that creates this assumption isn’t virtuous, it is vicious. And our public life is getting more vicious by the day.</p><p>—</p><p>The atmosphere of our democracy has certainly declined somewhat since Sorkin’s sanctimonious heyday. Earlier this year, some armed demonstrators occupied state capitols. Other, differently motivated, demonstrators have burned buildings and looted stores.</p><p>Whatever the result of the election in November, it will surely be contested in the media and the courts, and protested in the streets — ‘mostly peacefully’, I’m sure.</p><p>Neither side of the partisan divide will accept victory by the other as legitimate — they are, each to each other, radicals, saboteurs, enemies of the state.</p><p>At its heart, our current crisis is one of faith. If the utility of democracy is its accountability, its supposed virtue is in our capacity to govern and hold ourselves to account. The founding promise of democracy is that we are, together and as individuals, up to the task.</p><p>The Enlightenment, which provided the philosophical DNA of the American revolution, coded into the genes of our politics that we are our own authority, the rational creators of our own moral and political order, democratically expressed and sustained.</p><p>But, so many half-lifes from that beginning, we no longer have the common values or the will necessary to sustain our own founding myth.</p><p>Whatever our paper money may say, America has no god but Caesar, and we have discovered that it is a false idol.</p><p>It is for this reason our current moment feels so frantic, so irrational; it isn’t a civil war, it is a religious schism, and no election result can repair it.</p><p>We are left, as a country, with only two options — two competing creeds to embrace: the will to dominate the other, or the desire to love them. Only one of these can build truly just and free society. But only the other appears on the ballot.</p><p>None of this is to say that our democracy is dead, or irredeemably bad. Or to suggest that our political order can or should be reinvented into something new. But acknowledging that it is not inherently good, or virtuous, is essential.</p><p>Frankly accepting that our system both creates and feeds upon division and vice can provide a moment of moral epiphany. It can enlighten our choices and mark a beginning to recover some of what we have lost: a common interest in each other, not just ourselves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d85762d56d8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Biden, abortion, and Communion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-biden-abortion-and-communion-93ef5f4bb1d?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/93ef5f4bb1d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[joe-biden]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[catholic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Aug 2020 21:27:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-23T02:40:56.071Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This week, Joe Biden cemented his choice of Kamala Harris as a running mate. For only having one term on at the federal level, the California senator brings an impressive amount of baggage to the campaign trail.</p><p>As a state and local attorney general, she distinguished herself as a fearless scourge of mostly-poor, mostly-minority, truant children, whose home lives she endeavored to improve by jailing their parents.</p><p>In a law and order election cycle, she can also lay claim to ensuring that death row inmates stay there, possible exculpatory evidence be damned.</p><p>But she is best known, to Catholics anyway, for her work on the Senate Judiciary Committee with Mazie Hirono — an interlocutor so dense that answers from judicial nominees bend around her like light. The two managed to make the Knights of Columbus sound like badasses, terming them ‘extreme’ for holding Catholic views on abortion.</p><p>Ms. Harris does not, she has made clear, believe there to be a place for Catholics in public life if they oppose a woman’s “right to choose” to end an unborn life. On this score, her new ménage with Joe Biden will not trouble her.</p><p>Biden’s Damascene conversion on the campaign trail, from which he emerged as a champion of unfettered abortion, was largely sealed by Harris herself when she demanded Biden express ‘regret’ for his past beliefs during a primary debate.</p><p>Having made the necessary act of contrition and profession of the pro-abortion faith, Biden is now in full communion with Harris and the party he leads.</p><p>—</p><p>Communion and abortion will, no doubt, recur as an issue for Biden in the future. While the pandemic has made attending Mass less regular for all Catholics, he is bound to eventually present himself in church between now and November.</p><p>At a previous stop on the campaign trail last year, a South Carolina priest denied Biden Communion for his public stance on abortion. A predictable section of the media, both secular and Catholic, rushed to condemn the priest for ‘politicizing’ the Eucharist and supposedly wielding Communion as a stick to beat the poor former VP.</p><p>Just as predictably, most commentators either mangled or ignored the clear Church teaching — and standing policy in the local diocese — that those like Biden who ‘consistently support abortion on demand are cooperating with evil in a public manner’ and ‘especially those running for, or elected to, public office are not to be admitted to Holy Communion.’</p><p>‘Jesus ate with sinners!’ they said, and will again. Indeed he did.</p><p>The Eucharist is not a reward for the righteous, they quote Pope Francis as saying, correctly.</p><p>But, of course, neither is Communion just a symbol, a matter of “eating with,” or a badge of belonging. It is — if you believe in that sort of thing — the actual body and blood of Christ, and taking it while in a state of grave sin does you grave spiritual harm. It is for this reason, among others, that priests are not to admit politicians like Biden — not just as punishment but to prevent them doing further harm to themselves.</p><p>But, of course, most of the people — in and out of the Church — who upbraid priests for denying Communion to politicians don’t believe in the Eucharist, not really.</p><p>Last year, a truly frightening poll showed just how few American Catholics actually believe what the Church teaches about its most important sacrament — but they didn’t come to this unbelief by themselves. It was instilled in them by a particular class of celebrity Catholic and Twitter cleric. Not for them Pope Francis’ field hospital Church, welcoming all but administering the unique medicine each patient needs. For them, Mass is McDonalds — all that matters is that you are served when it’s your turn in line.</p><p>—</p><p>Many Catholic politicians are happy to be in the Church but outside the faith as it suits them. Catholicism, for them, is an aesthetic to be indulged or not as useful; a comfy, colorful, cultural pashmina to wrap themselves in when they want to preach about social justice, but to be discarded on more black-and-white moral issues like abortion.</p><p>Of course, even in the discarding Catholicism is useful.</p><p>Until recently, Biden supported the Mexico City policy and Hyde amendment, which prevent taxpayer dollars from funding abortions. There was even a time when he publicly mused that Roe v. Wade ‘went too far.’ Ditching those stances was, in part, how he showed Harris his thinking had, to use her word, ‘evolved’.</p><p>Heading into the final weeks of the election and looking to bank every liberal vote and campaign contribution available, being denied Communion is practically the best pro-abortion street cred there is — something not lost on many bishops.</p><p>Cardinal Timothy Dolan has previously pointed out that many pro-abortion Catholic politicians, like New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, are essentially hoping for the condemnation of the Church so they can present themselves as ‘proud to dissent’ and ‘as a kind of martyr to the cause.’</p><p>It’s the politicians who are the ones playing politics with the sacraments, the thinking runs, and giving them the progressive merit badge of being condemned by the Church would be counterproductive.</p><p>Perhaps.</p><p>But this studied stance of many bishops risks playing politics with the sacrament right along with the politicians. It can give the impression that it may endanger Biden’s soul to receive the sacrament while professing views that place him outside a state of grace, but that’s his problem. It does not project a clear message of pastoral concern for Biden, the sacrament, or the wider community.</p><p>Of course, it is understandable that many bishops want to shy away from publicly confronting politicians about their faith, and many say they have privately told them to refrain from presenting themselves for Communion. But this seems to have had little effect.</p><p>Meanwhile, giving the impression that politics trumps Church teaching sends a message about what Catholics should put first — a message Joe Biden and others have already taken to heart.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=93ef5f4bb1d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On making good choices]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-making-good-choices-1a2aefa0152e?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1a2aefa0152e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Aug 2020 04:52:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-06T22:43:50.198Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On making good choices</p><p>The country is gravely divided, and President Donald Trump is not a unifying figure. On these points, any sane two people can agree.</p><p>Trump has, from the moment he was deposited at the bottom of the golden escalator, like a hefty bag of cottage cheese, been a divider — first of the Republican Party, then of the country. It is credited as his greatest flaw, and his strategic genius.</p><p>In a time of crises: pandemic, escalating social unrest, a likely recession, and a burgeoning foreign policy crisis with China, Trump’s performance has systematically polarized, rather than rallied, the nation.</p><p>The commentariat and intelligentsia consume Trump’s every word, and then each other, under nesting categories of opposition; Trump, anti-Trump, anti-anti-Trump, anti-anti-anti, and so on forever, like a Russian doll of bilious obsession.</p><p>November must, the consensus goes, see a return to normal, to business as usual. Trump cannot possibly win.</p><p>And yet, he might.</p><p>More to the point, win or lose, Donald Trump can comfortably count on the support of a third of the nation at least. Whatever the result on election day, unity is not just coming over the hill, and a fancied return to ‘business as usual’ will not remove the wedge already buried deep in the national psyche.</p><p>Pleas for a ‘return to normal’ often demand, or assume, that reluctant or begrudging Trump supporters must now defect to the camp of Joe Biden, placing the dire need for a return to norms and normalcy above quotidian concerns about individual policies on conscience protections or religious freedom, to say nothing of life issues.</p><p>Perhaps some will heed this call, but others will surely not. In between lies an unplumbed depth of voters who understand that, whatever they may make of Trump, there is no room for them under Biden’s tent.</p><p>—</p><p>Biden has done well keeping himself out of the president’s way, intervening no more than he absolutely must. In much the way Trump rallied an incoherent confederacy of the disaffected four years ago, pitching himself as ‘anyone but them’, so today Biden seems to be broadly willing to be the avatar of ‘anyone but him.’</p><p>But despite the genial pretensions, the ‘anti’ candidate to the ‘anti’ presidency offers little consolation to those who remember the eight years that came before — and led to — Trump. While the popular myth has it that genial Joe has room for everyone who values a return to decency in public life, his party has made it clear there is fine print on the welcome sign.</p><p>All are welcome, but there are terms. Even for Joe, the invitation to victory came with articles of surrender.</p><p>The primary campaign trail marked the final arrival in Biden’s long journey from private-pro-lifer to full throated abortion champion. The man who once said Roe v Wade went ‘too far’ has now promised to enshrine its fullest application in federal law. He was made to shed his previous support for the Hyde amendment and Mexico City policy, along we presume with his opposition to ‘partial-birth’ abortion, on the road to leading the party that has made it explicitly clear there is no room for pro-life members in its ranks.</p><p>No Catholic, no person who believes that abortion will haunt our history with the same poisonous shame as slavery, can support such a movement, or accept such a compromise to power.</p><p>Some might tell themselves that Biden’s taking the pledge on maximum abortion rights is mere primary season signaling, but to whom? According to all available polling, his new stance places him well outside the mainstream, not only with the public but even among self-described pro-choice Democrats.</p><p>At the same time, his party has already sought to attach riders to government spending bills tying federal operational funds to the repeal of conscience protections for doctors and nurses who do not wish to be ordered to perform abortions or participate in the Frankenscience of gender reassignment.</p><p>Hopes that, after four years of spittle-flecked rancor, gentle uncle Joe will usher in a new era of neighborly live-and-let-live miss every sign of the times.</p><p>Within hours of the Supreme Court ruling on the issue, Biden broke cover to denounce executive action exempting the Little Sisters of the Poor from cooperating in the purchase of contraceptives, sterilizations, and early-stage abortion drugs. Biden vowed to repeal their exemption once in power, effectively pledging to put the sisters back in court as soon as possible.</p><p>Biden steered a remarkably studied middle course over the ‘mostly peaceful’ protests which gripped many cities after the death of George Floyd, to much approval. But while he was able to resist donning the Law &amp; Order war paint, he could not, it seems, risk appearing to be soft on nuns.</p><p>—</p><p>Where does this leave people of sincere conscience? The pragmatists and the relativists will make their peace with one party or the other and, much as they have in past decades, spend four years trying to convince themselves and everyone else that their moral calculus was justified.</p><p>Good luck to them.</p><p>Those who write in their choice are said to throw their votes away, and are usually blamed (never credited) for a share of the result. But there is a moral complicity, too, in accepting a false choice, time and again, between the lesser two of degrading evils.</p><p>Voting is an act of affirmation, not equivocation. And we forget that at our peril.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1a2aefa0152e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On John Roberts, who loves his children]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-john-roberts-who-loves-his-children-19ebff223d9f?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/19ebff223d9f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Jul 2020 13:19:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-01T15:25:22.956Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On John Roberts, who loves his children</p><p>For many, the concurring opinion on Monday of Chief Justice John Roberts in the case June Medical Services v Russo was a surprise. Who could fail to support a state law that required doctors performing surgical procedures have admitting privileges in a hospital? Who would want to?</p><p>The tempting answer is, of course, ‘because abortion,’ as it almost always is when our judiciary dissolves into abstruse sophistry.</p><p>The four reliable votes against any measure which could limit the ability to end an unborn life are well documented; their principles are absolute, and absolutely hierarchical, the law and argument secondary. What else would bring feminist stalwarts like Ruth Bader Ginsburg to strike down a law that would have demanded that doctors who exclusively ‘treat’ women be held to the same standards as those who treat men?</p><p>But not so for Roberts. He is something different.</p><p>His concurring opinion Monday was delivered not to abort a law to improve medical standards or even close bad clinics, but to save a precedent.</p><p>Judicial precedents are the children of a court, the progeny who live on, who mark history and shape the future. For the Chief Justice, all the court’s children are his children, and he protects precedent as jealously as any parent.</p><p>This is not to say he is proud of them all.</p><p>Indeed, in the case of Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt, the 2016 decision to which Roberts said Monday’s case must defer, the Chief Justice was a reluctant father.</p><p>Siding with the dissenting minority in that case, which also treated a state law imposing new (but by no means higher relative to other facilities) standards of care on abortion clinics, Roberts lent his name to an observation of “the Court’s troubling tendency to bend the rules when any effort to limit abortion, or even to speak in opposition to abortion, is at issue.”</p><p>One might have expected to see Roberts welcome the chance to revise the outcome and uphold justice — at least for women and for the legislative process in Louisiana if not directly for the unborn. But no. However little he might see of himself in the precedential progeny of the court, he owns them all, hugging them tight as his very own.</p><p>Four years might seem a short period for a decision to become the settled will of the people and law of the land, and reasonable jurists might argue that swift revision of bad verdicts is essential to avoid the principle of stare decisis becoming a tyranny of past errors. But for Roberts, a precedent is a precedent, no matter how small.</p><p>Some hold aloft Roberts’ dedication to the immortality of his own defeats as proof of character. They laud the perceived impartiality and commitment of a man who will uphold that which the court has said before, though he knows it to be unjust. Perhaps it was such noble judicial principles that helped keep Plessey v. Ferguson on the books for fifty-eight years.</p><p>That Roberts’ judicial concern for the courts’ children trumps his personal concern for the unborn seems increasingly settled. And few should be surprised. The lesson of the court is, and has always been, that it rejects only those of its decisions already long-since rejected by the people as a whole.</p><p>If there is a good to come from Monday’s decision, it may be that those bending all their political will and effort to ending abortion must finally part with the expectation that a Supreme Court decision will deliver a sudden result.</p><p>Abortion will end, but when it does it will come at the end of a slow, grinding march of inches. It will require renouncing the convenient truces which have defined much of the pro-life movement’s politics. If justices will not deliver instant success, then, perhaps at last, they will no longer be taken as the only hard currency of political support.</p><p>Instead, legislators can actually prove themselves by legislating — passing laws of the kind which have been carried with bipartisan support, like the Unsafe Abortion Act of Louisiana. While that law has been struck down, the effort of its passage united what is now the most reliably pro-life state in the country under both parties.</p><p>Skeptics insist that winning a broader cultural battle is impossible, that respect for life can only be imposed by the court from above, not on it from below. But the country is already changing its mind.</p><p>Some have dismissed the heartbeat bills enacted in many states last year as a stunt, noting that none of them have remained unchallenged and on the books. But the very fight to pass them has brought change.</p><p>According to Rasmussen, when told a fetal heartbeat can be detected at six weeks, fifty-six percent of Americans favor banning abortion from that point.</p><p>An overwhelming number, nearly seventy percent, of New York Democrats think their own state’s abortion laws are too extreme, but only two of their state senators agree. Eighty percent of Americans would ban abortion after thirteen weeks.</p><p>These are people waiting for a pro-life conversation, a conversion, a point of contact. They are not waiting for a PAC.</p><p>Building a culture of life is more than a slogan. Culture captures politicians and forces justices to abandon their precedents.</p><p>Building a culture is much harder than winning a campaign. It takes more than fundraisers and mailing lists, and success is measured in less tangible — but more impactful — ways than judicial nominations. It is also less glamorous and offers less immediate proximity to power.</p><p>Building a culture of life is the work of a generation, not an election cycle, a labor for saints, not judges.</p><p>After Monday, maybe that is clearer now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=19ebff223d9f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On this house divided]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-this-house-divided-51cd28d326e6?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/51cd28d326e6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Jun 2020 20:32:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-16T23:57:51.910Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On this house divided</p><p>The Monday decision by the Supreme Court to equate “gender identity” with biological sex will likely prove more significant, and more damaging, to what remains of our common public life than any in recent memory.</p><p>Bostock will open a new front in the relentless, bitterly cold culture war in America.</p><p>It remains to be seen how many shops, schools, beauty parlors, women’s shelters, sports teams, and sundry enterprises will be dragged to court for being disinclined to allow anatomical males to hang loose in areas reserved for the safety and privacy of women and girls. I’m prepared to bet it will make the post Obergefell bakery battles appear like a storm in a teacup.</p><p>This is before getting into the ramifications for religiously affiliated schools and charities, which will now find themselves targeted for the full Bob Jones treatment. The very essence of what it is to be man, to be woman, to be human, has now been revised, in law if not in fact.</p><p>“At the heart of liberty is the right to define one’s own concept of existence, of meaning, of the universe, and of the mystery of human life,” said the majority decision in Planned Parenthood v Casey. Many will hail the court’s decision Monday as a vindication of this anthropology of relativism.</p><p>Yet, as they do so, they ignore the next sentence: “Beliefs about these matters could not define the attributes of personhood were they formed under compulsion of the State.” Yet now they are, and so, presumably, they must.</p><p>The vision of humanity, of the person and its innate character, meaning, and dignity has been redefined by the act of stripping away its definition. It is a nihilistic vision in which the great fallacy of the Enlightenment, <em>cogito</em>, <em>ergo</em> <em>sum</em>, is elevated from intellectual narcissism to law of the land.</p><p>Of course, what the court giveth, the court can taketh away — blessed be the name of the court. Many are now predicting, based on Justice Gorsuch’s pointed reference to religious liberty, that we may soon see a companion decision which significantly broadens the ministerial exception. The court may yet allow, in the name of free exercise, for a host of religiously minded institutions to suddenly deem their social workers, teachers, administrators, even janitors, to be ‘ministers’ of the faith.</p><p>Such a ‘solution’ would, in fact, solve nothing.</p><p>Rather, it has the potential to screw the lid down tighter on the pressure building up on both sides: among those who believe with sincerity that male and female are not states of mind but facts of being, and those who believe that a person can redefine themselves at will as fundamentally as they are seeking to redefine our history and society.</p><p>A super-sized ministerial exception may provide an enlarged port in a storm for many institutions, it may even cause a number of small businesses to ‘get religion’ in the hopes of keeping their beliefs — Christian spa days, anyone? But it would also usher in a judicial separation not of church and state, but of the secular and religious.</p><p>Our society will be, ever more formally, a house divided, to invoke a different disagreement about the basics of humanity and rights.</p><p>We will be left with, in essence, two parallel societies: one for believers in religion, nature, biology, (and women’s rights), and another for those who believe in cutting edge psychology, perpetual revisionism, and the absolute primacy of the will. Both sides will strive to entrench their legal gains and protections against the other, with the courts struggling to fashion a new compromise of division, with a line running between the two halves of our country.</p><p>Legally, it is as untenable now as it has ever been. Even for the most elastic of constitutional interpretations, the concept of ‘religious freedom’ is simply not expansive enough to shield every school, beauty spa, and soccer team in the country that happens to believe biology is not just a state of mind.</p><p>Socially, it is simply impossible for one country, one people, to hold diametrically opposed views on the origin of basic human rights and dignity. Individuals may — and at all costs should — seek out the other in the imperative to love our neighbor. But the beliefs of both sides are, at their core, an existential affront and threat to the other.</p><p>It cannot possibly last. This house cannot possibly stand.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=51cd28d326e6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On why it all gets worse: Three simple rules]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-why-it-all-gets-worse-three-simple-rules-6e10950d70ae?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e10950d70ae</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Jun 2020 04:20:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-12T04:20:21.173Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On why it all gets worse: Three simple rules</p><p>The first rule of animal husbandry is: you can’t put the shit back in the horse. It’s a truth that’s hard to confront, harder in proportion to the size of the mess.</p><p>In the ongoing manure fest which is our public life, it’s tempting to wish for an end. In the fourth year since the most divisive election result in living memory, the country has endured the trauma of a pandemic, the brutal shock of sudden mass unemployment, and the mental stresses of lockdown measures.</p><p>Added to that has been the pain released by the death of George Floyd, the eruption of anger at our national original sin of racism, never far from the surface, and the reality of lethally brutal policing methods.</p><p>Riots and looting have, in places, overshadowed what were, and are still, legitimate mass protests. In Seattle, American’s urban Petri dish of social insanity, a group of armed. secessionists (?) have declared the Capital Hill Autonomous Zone.</p><p>Any sane person would be left shutting their eyes, beating their fists on their temples and wishing things would all just go back to normal. But there is no going back, there is no normal — just the crapulent disorder of our present, strewn across the streets like road apples after the Macy’s parade.</p><p>Some might be hoping that this will all blow over in a few months and we can all get on with our lives. But our social and political institutions have been weakened well past the point of absorbing these overlapping and unfolding crises. Things are not getting any better any time soon.</p><p>—</p><p>The first rule of parenting is: you don’t negotiate with terrorists. It is clearly a lesson lost on the people in charge of some fairly prominent institutions just now.</p><p>Through protests on streets and in tweets, the instinctively just cry of ‘black lives matter’ mutated into the demand ‘defund the police’ in about 10 days.</p><p>Maybe some actually just want imaginative changes in how local municipal services are delivered and budgets are allocated, but that’s a lot to fit on a sign, I guess.</p><p>Others may just want to stop seeing local cops decked out like they’re extras in Starship Troopers and rolling around in armored personnel carriers; maybe ‘demilitarize the police’ is hard to spell on the fly.</p><p>But as policy, ‘defund the police’ is about as useful a recommendation as ‘eat the rich’ for workability. Yet whether out of the fear, naïveté, or impenetrable stupidity, local leaders are signing up.</p><p>Led by their president Lisa Bender, the Minneapolis city council have renounced ‘failed attempts’ at ‘incremental reform,’ vowing instead to ‘end policing as we know it.’</p><p>In Seattle, Councilwoman Kshama Sawant literally unlocked the doors of city hall for protestors, who turned around and warned her not to try to co-opt their presence or think she could win their support.</p><p>Bill de Blasio, who has managed to get some New Yorkers feeling wistful about Anthony Weiner, didn’t quite go that far, but he did promise a budget cut for the NYPD.</p><p>Only the crazy or the truly sinister would suggest our local and national leaders can or should be deaf to the national cry for justice that has followed George Floyd’s killing, and, shamefully, there are plenty of both in this country. But policy cannot be made on a posterboard, and handing the keys (real and figurative) to an angry crowd creates chaos — witness Seattle.</p><p>Rage can be powerful, transformative, even righteous. But it cannot, of its nature, be coherent or constructive. The work of leadership is to unite, to reconcile, to heal, to build anew. While many may recognize this, few seem able or willing to act on it. As we approach a general election in November, the prospect of real leadership emerging, on any side, seems vanishingly unlikely, at least if the recent past is anything to judge by.</p><p>— -</p><p>The first rule of oral hygiene is: don’t smoke meth. Sure it gives you a quick high, but once it is in your system it’s almost impossible to purge the urge, disfiguring the body and soul past recognition. Sadly, our politics has been on the pipe of rage and division for years, and the results are written across the face of the nation.</p><p>Some continue to hold out for November, imagining that a change in the White House will suddenly snap the country out of its current nightmare. This idea is itself a dream. Long before people spoke seriously of ‘sending in the troops’ to our own cities and Donald Trump’s Twitter feed became a terrifying window into the executive Id, our national conversation had already become hopelessly weaponized.</p><p>Assuming, for the sake of argument, that Trump is a one-term president, those ‘deplorables’ who elected him and would again — more than a third of the country at least — are not going to disappear. Nor is the administration that follows likely to usher in a national group hug.</p><p>Just ask Dan Lipinski, one of the most thoroughly honorable, decent humans in the House, who was primaried out of the party earlier this year solely for his pro-life views. Or the Knights of Columbus, a Catholic fraternal society that organizes winter coat drives and soup kitchens. Not so many months ago, Senate Democrats branded their group “extreme” and suggested that its 2 million members should be treated as a suspect class in public life.</p><p>Further back in time, some may recall it was Joe Biden who told a room full of African-American voters that Mitt Romney (the guy marching with Black Lives Matter demonstrators last week) wanted to put them ‘back in chains.’</p><p>Those longing for a return to normal forget that the old normal got us here, one election cycle at a time. If you think there’s a fast road back to a happier time, all I can tell you is: see the first rule of animal husbandry.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e10950d70ae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the week Twitter came to life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-the-week-twitter-came-to-life-f5ee87c4182c?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f5ee87c4182c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 May 2020 23:51:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-08T22:06:25.095Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On the week Twitter came to life</p><p>There are riots on the streets of Minneapolis. I always expected to read that sentence one day, though as the opening of a sarcastic take on the city.</p><p>Like the American women’s football [soccer] team, I confess to casually associating the place with asymmetrical haircuts and middle-class indignation.</p><p>An angry mob in the Twin Cities, in my imagination, is made up of mostly white mostly women, taking to the steps of city hall to demand more access to goat yoga and a better class of vegan restaurant, like an Indigo Girls concert that got out of hand.</p><p>Of course, that is not what has been going on.</p><p>The killing of George Floyd has ignited a fire of only-ever-barely contained outrage at the way black men in America are killed without apparent thought or remorse.</p><p>No doubt, many of those who marched, and shouted, and swore, and wept in Minneapolis and other cities did so in full righteous rage and despair at the real racial violence which stains our cities and institutions like the cultural original sin that it is.</p><p>Perhaps, too, they were some of those who threw stones at police precincts and patrol cars — a lawless yell in the face of authority without apparent accountability. Of course, at this point the caveats start kicking in: violence is its own evil, and lawlessness cannot be vindicated by a demand for justice.</p><p>But it is clear that at least some, many, maybe in places most, of those who took violently to the streets in Minneapolis, Atlanta, Los Angeles, Houston, Chicago and elsewhere did so for other reasons.</p><p>Comparisons are rightly drawn with the Rodney King riots, and the incoherence of looting stores and burning cars as an act of solidarity with the local community against oppressive authority. But in the selfie era, there is a new performative aspect.</p><p>A reasonably careful study of the videos circulating online will also show the confused sloganeering of the more politically violent individuals, and the incongruence of angry white people in expensive shoes joining in to vent their own rage against the police… and a Waffle House?</p><p>Some, it may prove, did indeed come from out of town, even out of state to take part. What drew them? It would be a thin silver lining to think that there was this level of cultural buy-in to opposing racial violence against black men, even to the point of violent chaos. But if that were so, Target would not be the target.</p><p>No. Sadly, I suspect that many of those who arrived to cause mayhem did so because they saw, thanks to the cultural acne of social media, a chance to break something, to burn something; to vent their indiscriminate rage indiscriminately. To take the selfie that might get them liked.</p><p>Not long ago, it was fashionable to worry that the release of the film The Joker would cause a rash of mass shootings and copy-cat killers. That did not happen. But while people may not take their cues from the false reality of a film, they are, perhaps, doing so from the half-reality of Twitter, which these riots resemble more than a little.</p><p>The culture of Twitter, and other social media sites, encourages and rewards performative rage, imagined violence, and cultivation of mob behavior. What people have seen, liked, retweeted, and imitated online for months, even years, is now suddenly happening in a city center near them.</p><p>Months of lockdowns, spiraling unemployment, and the looming specter of an unseen viral killer have acted like a cultural instant pot for a society already bitterly atomized — at once desperate for human contact and steeped in a language of total confrontation.</p><p>I would wager that many of those who lost — thanks to lockdowns — what little real-life society they had to balance their online activities are now bringing their alt account world to life.</p><p>Online rage and mob action have long been dismissed as ‘not the real world.’ What people do in the virtual world of Twitter affects only the ‘extremely online’ while normal people carry on with normal life. But now the overlapping circles of online rage — more spiral than venn diagram — are breaking through the screen, venting their rage at once pointedly and incoherently at CNN, Wells Fargo, and Wendy’s.</p><p>Search for videos with the hashtag #JusticeforGeorgeFloyd and you will encounter more than a few studies in college educated, porcelain outrage. Young white men and women, pictures of isolated insecurity under their androgynous fury, vowing to “say what no one else will” and take to the streets.</p><p>Well, they are: Twitter has become real life.</p><p>Most people, we are told by political pollsters, are moderates. But humanity is a river that always courses towards one extreme or another, wherever people find themselves in the flow. Where our culture, our society points towards is as important as where it is.</p><p>At the most basic level, we are shaped by the realities of death and each other. Who we are, as individuals, is defined by our answer to these two unavoidables: at heart, do we choose to die for our neighbor, or to kill him?</p><p>Beginning with the cop with his knee on his neck, the death of George Floyd has shown our consensus answer has been trending the wrong way for many years.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f5ee87c4182c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the unreasonableness of it all]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ed.condon/on-the-unreasonableness-of-it-all-c3a7ca9cab37?source=rss-3b9be6f7ca65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c3a7ca9cab37</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ed. Condon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 May 2020 03:24:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-23T12:03:25.386Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On the unreasonableness of it all</p><p>The president today has said that churches and houses of worship should open as soon as possible. Some will see it as a permission slip for behavior likely to spread contagion. But it will come as a welcome encouragement to many.</p><p>Earlier this week, the bishops of Minnesota announced that churches in the state will defy the governor and reopen to congregations at one-third of their capacity. They tried to work with Gov. Tim Walz on a mutually agreeable plan, but he declined their offers.</p><p>While shopping malls and big-box stores are free to open at 50 percent, welcoming hundreds in the process, Gov. Walz considers it a clear and present danger to public health for more than 10 people to gather in the cathedral of St. Paul — seating for 3,000. The bishops put it mildly, saying the governor’s order “defies reason.”</p><p>Walz, of course, leads a state that has previously elected a professional wrestler as governor, so defiance of reason is not unknown to his office. But he is not alone in appearing to have a particular concern about the contagious nature of religion.</p><p>Increasingly, local government leaders are shifting gears on social distancing, the insufferable neologism of our age, from ‘observance’ to ‘enforcement.’</p><p>Also this week, in Chicago police fined churches for holding services at 10 percent of capacity, instead of 10 people or fewer. Last month, the mayor of New York made it clear to the city’s Jewish community that “the time for warnings has passed,” and that if they persist in trying to gather at funerals the way others are at Manhattan bars, they will be arrested.</p><p>Washington, DC — so far as I am aware the only major US city with a serving councilman who thinks the weather is controlled by the Rothschilds — waits with bated breath to see what its enlightened administration has in store.</p><p>Religious leaders have a right to feel aggrieved, and insist on their rights. And the bishops have a special responsibility to defend the integrity and independence of the Church from the secular order. But they will likely find, as the bishops of Minnesota did, that they are trying to reason with the unreasonable.</p><p>— -</p><p>While the mayors and governors seek to impose their wills on bishops and rabbis, we should expect to meet similar unreasoning impositions in our own daily lives.</p><p>Churches may not be allowed to open in many places, but malls, casinos, and other “essential” public spaces are. While the best advice seems to be observing reasonable precautions for the time being — wearing masks when in close quarters, washing our hands with the kind of regularity we should have been anyway etc. — we can be sure many will not, and many more will not want to.</p><p>However wrongly, and whatever the real risks of reinfection, many people will likely file ‘pandemic’ away with ‘plane crash’ and ‘mass shooting’ as terrible things that happen on the news. To other people.</p><p>Since our governors and mayors already have the police busy staking out church parking lots, there will be a need for someone to patrol our parks and restaurants and theaters as they reopen, ensuring that social distancing is being observed.</p><p>In all likelihood, keeping us safe in this brave new world will be ranks of newly minted social distancing officers; a thin line of polyester standing between us and each other.</p><p>Britons have long since become accustomed to Community Support Officers stalking their streets like demented hall monitors, armed with the power to harass and fine the public for a range of nebulous ‘anti-social behaviors,’ like smoking, swearing, or talking too loud.</p><p>I doubt it will be long until we see something similar in America.</p><p>Much as the tragedy of 9/11 changed air travel forever, so I suspect this is how coronavirus will change our daily lives — not altering them beyond recognition, just making them inescapably more tedious. And much as the creation of the TSA has shown, the mix of serious public safety concerns with the vast scope for petty enforcement authority is nothing to look forward to.</p><p>Anyone who has flown in the last 20 years can tell a story of suffering at the hands of arbitrary, unreasonable authority visited upon them just because it was their day. And they will not welcome being told their table is a little too close to the next one at a restaurant, or that they are sitting too near someone else in a park.</p><p>They will have to be made to respect the rules — probably with fines. And when a local government starts fining people as a deterrent, you can usually start the clock on how long it will take to become an essential revenue source, turning an emergency measure into the ‘new normal’ we are all waiting for.</p><p>It is a vision of the future at once Orwellian and banal. The TSA, everywhere. Forever.</p><p>— -</p><p>Of course, we should not be surprised if our authorities are unreasonable. Even if we were grown up enough to wash our hands, it would not be enough to ward off the nanny state. We are the henpecked citizenry of a petty tyrant class, and the truth is we would be henpecked whether we washed our hands or not. And most of us like it that way.</p><p>As a people, we have long since turned our politics — and therefore our government — into an exercise in dominating ‘the others’ among us.</p><p>The baseball hats we wear, the stickers we put on our cars, the signs we stake in our lawns, are not expressions of solidarity or identity, they are provocations; a way of ‘owning’ whoever it is who is against us.</p><p>As a society, we have never had so much discussion — on TV, online, in our media — but none of it is reasonable. So much of it is characterized as being conducted in bad faith, and this is true to a point. But it would be better to say we have no faith — in our institutions, in our common society, in each other. I think Yuval Levin has a new book on this, but I cannot be expected to keep reading books during a pandemic.</p><p>St. John Paul II wrote one of his many great encyclicals on the essential link between faith and reason, how the one elightens and guides the other in the search for understanding. Currently we are spoiled for choice with examples about what happens when the link is broken: In many places, requests to take basic precautions, like don a mask when entering private premises, are met with hostility — even violence.</p><p>Otherwise adult members of society openly tout for internet conspiracy theories over the warnings of medical experts — some are prepared to believe the virus is spread by cellular phone towers (no, seriously) instead of close human contact.</p><p>How did we possibly get here? As the bishops of Minnesota will tell you, there is just no reasoning with a lack of faith. In the divine, and in each other.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c3a7ca9cab37" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>