<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Edward Mandla on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Edward Mandla on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:04:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Seven Executives Walk Into the Same Meeting]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/seven-executives-walk-into-the-same-meeting-fa75b4710ee8?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fa75b4710ee8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[board-of-directors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decision-making]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[executive-leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Jul 2026 10:31:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-29T10:31:18.798Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why intelligent executives can examine the same evidence and still reach completely different conclusions.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t2II8Y1SbuQcfb4FZpRSiQ.png" /></figure><p>Seven intelligent executives walk into the same meeting.</p><p>They are presented with exactly the same information. They are experienced, they trust one another and many have worked together for years. Yet, an hour later, they leave with seven different conclusions and, quite often, no decision at all.</p><p>None of them is irrational. None of them is dishonest. None of them has ignored the presentation.</p><p>So why do they disagree?</p><p>For years, I assumed the answer was straightforward. Someone had misunderstood the presentation or missed an important detail. Perhaps a key person had not been included in the discussion. Maybe politics, personality or ego had overridden the evidence. There was always an explanation if you looked hard enough.</p><p>The problem was that none of those explanations seemed to fit consistently.</p><p>The longer I spent interviewing executives, sitting on boards and watching leadership teams wrestle with difficult decisions, the less convinced I became that disagreement was simply the product of personalities or politics. Something else was happening, although for a long time I could not quite put my finger on it.</p><p>I first recognised it in executive hiring.</p><p>The process always seemed deceptively simple. After months of searching, interviewing and debating, the hiring manager, usually the CEO or another member of the executive team, would finally settle on a preferred candidate. There was a sense of relief. The search had produced its answer.</p><p>The candidate would then face one final hurdle: a panel interview with the rest of the executive team.</p><p>An hour later, the obvious candidate was no longer obvious.</p><p>Sometimes the executive team preferred the person who had previously been the clear second choice. On other occasions, they rejected everyone, leaving the hiring manager with no option but to ask us to begin again.</p><p>“Find me another number one,” they would say. “Let’s hope this one gels better with the team.”</p><p>I have spoken about this phenomenon with board chairs, performance coaches and senior executives for years. Much of the advice centres on team dynamics and groupthink. Organisations say they want people who will challenge the status quo, yet when the moment arrives, they often gravitate towards the candidate who will rock the boat only gently.</p><p>There is truth in that explanation, but it never felt complete.</p><p>One of the most useful conversations I had came from an unexpected source. Instead of asking psychologists or organisational consultants, I started asking exceptional technology salespeople what they thought was happening.</p><p>These are people who sell technology that, on the surface, nobody inside a large organisation is actively looking to buy. They often represent companies the customer has barely heard of, proposing solutions that were never included in the budget and will require the business to rethink priorities that have been in place for years.</p><p>Yet twelve months later, some of those same salespeople walk away with a ten million dollar purchase order.</p><p>Over the years, I have interviewed many of the world’s best enterprise salespeople. Some earn more than the chief executives they sell to. I began asking them why the same presentation could produce completely different reactions from equally intelligent executives sitting around the same boardroom table.</p><p>Although they answered in different ways, the underlying message was remarkably consistent.</p><p>Different executives do not simply interpret the evidence differently.</p><p>More often than not, they are trying to solve entirely different problems.</p><p>I see this most clearly when a significant sales opportunity is being forecast inside a technology company.</p><p>The salesperson walks into the meeting full of optimism. The opportunity is substantial, the client appears committed and the client CEO has already offered a quiet nod of encouragement. If the deal proceeds, it has the potential to transform the technology company’s year.</p><p>“This deal will close this quarter,” the salesperson says.</p><p>Everyone wants to believe it.</p><p>The opportunity is entered into the forecast. Hiring decisions may begin to depend on it. Investment may be brought forward. Expectations start to form around revenue that has not yet arrived. In a listed company, the confidence attached to that opportunity may begin to influence what the business tells investors or the market.</p><p>Inside the technology company, the logic appears compelling. The client has a problem. The proposed solution addresses it. The CEO understands the value and appears supportive.</p><p>Once the presentation finishes, I often ask a simple question.</p><p>“What does the client’s CFO think?”</p><p>The answer is surprisingly predictable.</p><p>“I haven’t spoken to them. This is additional revenue for their business, not cost cutting. It’s not really their area.”</p><p>That answer has always fascinated me because, in my experience, the opposite is usually true.</p><p>The salesperson is looking at the opportunity from the outside. They can see the business problem, the strategic value of solving it and the strength of the relationship they have built with the client CEO. The proposal has momentum. It feels real.</p><p>But somewhere inside the client organisation, the same proposal is about to become something else.</p><p>I once put exactly this scenario to an experienced ASX listed chair who had spent much of their executive career as a CFO. I asked how they would respond if a proposal requiring a ten million dollar investment landed on the client’s board agenda.</p><p>“I’d block it,” they replied, without the slightest hesitation.</p><p>The first time I heard those words, I assumed I had misunderstood the question.</p><p>Surely every board wants growth.</p><p>Of course it does.</p><p>But growth is only one part of what the board is being asked to approve.</p><p>By the time the proposal reaches the client’s board, the salesperson may already regard the deal as highly likely. The client CEO may genuinely believe in it. The strategic case may be persuasive and the commercial logic may appear sound.</p><p>Then the discussion begins.</p><p>Nobody argues against the opportunity. Nobody dismisses it as unrealistic. Nobody suggests the investment is unimportant.</p><p>A question is asked about funding.</p><p>That question leads naturally to implementation. Implementation raises questions about technology capacity, which exposes capability gaps and recruitment requirements. Recruitment broadens into organisational readiness. Someone asks whether the executive team has the capacity to oversee another major transformation. Someone else asks what will happen to the projects already under way.</p><p>The conversation continues to widen.</p><p>What appeared from outside to be a technology purchase begins to reveal itself as a capital allocation decision, an operating model decision, a people decision and a test of the organisation’s ability to absorb change.</p><p>The proposal itself has not changed.</p><p>The room has.</p><p>The client CEO’s support was real. The salesperson did not imagine it. The business problem remains. The strategic opportunity may be every bit as important as first described.</p><p>But the proposal now sits alongside every other commitment the organisation has already made.</p><p>It must compete for capital, leadership attention, technology resources and organisational energy. It must survive scrutiny not only as an idea, but as something the business will have to deliver.</p><p>By the end of the meeting, the opportunity may look very different from the one the salesperson forecast.</p><p>From outside the organisation, it can seem as though enthusiasm has slowly been drained from an otherwise compelling proposal.</p><p>From the board’s perspective, exactly the opposite has happened.</p><p>The opportunity has finally been examined in its entirety.</p><p>This is where large enterprise forecasts often begin to unravel.</p><p>Not because the client was dishonest.</p><p>Not because the CEO’s encouragement was meaningless.</p><p>Not because the salesperson misunderstood the need.</p><p>They begin to unravel because interest, sponsorship and approval are not the same thing.</p><p>A chief executive can support a proposal without having secured the commitment of the CFO. A business can recognise an opportunity without possessing the capacity to pursue it. A board can believe strongly in the strategic value of an investment and still decide that the timing is wrong.</p><p>The salesperson sees the strength of the case for action.</p><p>The board sees the consequences of acting.</p><p>For years, I assumed somebody in that room had to be wrong. I imagined a naturally cautious executive had introduced just enough doubt to derail an otherwise outstanding opportunity.</p><p>I no longer believe that.</p><p>What changed my thinking was the realisation that the executives were rarely disagreeing about the proposal itself. More often, they were answering entirely different questions.</p><p>The salesperson wanted to know whether the client would buy.</p><p>The client CEO wanted to know whether the investment could create strategic value.</p><p>The finance executive was considering the consequences if the assumptions proved wrong.</p><p>The technology executive was thinking about implementation, architecture and capacity.</p><p>The people executive was wondering what the promise would demand from an organisation already carrying other commitments.</p><p>The chair was testing whether the opportunity justified not only the investment, but everything the organisation would have to delay, dilute or abandon in order to pursue it.</p><p>The CEO, meanwhile, was carrying the weight of all those questions at once.</p><p>Ultimately, theirs was the hardest question of all.</p><p>If we do this, what are we choosing not to do?</p><p>Watching these discussions over many years, something slowly became obvious to me.</p><p>Experience teaches us what to notice.</p><p>That may sound self evident, but I do not think we appreciate how profoundly it shapes judgement. Every executive arrives at the table carrying the accumulated weight of decisions they have made, projects they have led, mistakes they have survived and responsibilities they continue to shoulder. Those experiences quietly become the lens through which new opportunities are evaluated.</p><p>A finance executive who has watched ambitious projects quietly destroy shareholder value begins to recognise financial exposure almost instinctively. Someone who has spent years rescuing troubled technology implementations notices operational complexity long before anyone else in the room. Sales leaders hear buying signals that others overlook, while marketing leaders notice shifts in customer behaviour and people leaders sense the organisational strain hidden beneath an ambitious plan.</p><p>None of them is trying to be difficult.</p><p>None of them is deliberately resisting progress.</p><p>They have simply spent years learning to recognise different patterns, and those patterns become the questions they ask when an important decision arrives.</p><p>That is not necessarily bias.</p><p>It is experience.</p><p>The distinction matters because experience is not merely a collection of things that have happened to us. Over time, it becomes a form of pattern recognition.</p><p>A seasoned executive often notices something before they can fully explain why it matters. A phrase sounds familiar. An assumption feels too convenient. A promise resembles one they have heard before. Their judgement has been shaped by hundreds of previous decisions, many of which ended well and some of which did not.</p><p>This is what makes experience so valuable.</p><p>It allows someone to see a danger before it is obvious to everybody else. It enables another person to recognise an opportunity while everyone around them is still waiting for certainty.</p><p>But experience carries its own risk.</p><p>The better we become at recognising the patterns we have been trained to manage, the easier it is to assume those patterns are the most important ones in the room.</p><p>A CFO who has spent years protecting cash may see exposure before potential. A sales leader who has built a career by pursuing difficult opportunities may see caution as a failure of ambition. A technology executive who has inherited the consequences of poorly governed implementations may hear complexity where others hear possibility.</p><p>Each may be right.</p><p>Each may also be seeing only part of the whole.</p><p>Experience sharpens our judgement, but it can also narrow our field of vision. We become remarkably good at recognising the things we have been trained to manage, while becoming less aware of what someone else has spent an equally long time learning to see.</p><p>Once I understood that, executive hiring began to look different as well.</p><p>Perhaps the CEO and the executive team were never evaluating exactly the same candidate.</p><p>They were looking at the same person through different lenses, each shaped by the responsibilities they carried every day. One might notice commercial judgement. Another might be listening for evidence of discipline. Someone else may be watching how the candidate speaks about people, conflict or change.</p><p>The CEO may see a person capable of transforming the business. The CFO may hear an executive who has never managed capital carefully. The people leader may notice a style that will either strengthen the culture or unsettle it. The operations leader may be asking whether this person can deliver change without destabilising everything around them.</p><p>One executive notices ambition.</p><p>Another notices risk.</p><p>Someone else notices whether the candidate listens.</p><p>The candidate has not changed.</p><p>The questions have.</p><p>This does not mean every opinion deserves equal weight. Nor does it mean that all disagreement is constructive. Executives can still protect territory, avoid accountability, misread evidence or allow personal preference to masquerade as judgement.</p><p>Politics exists.</p><p>Ego exists.</p><p>Poor judgement exists.</p><p>But those explanations are too easy to reach for, particularly when another person’s conclusion makes little sense from where we are sitting.</p><p>It is far more difficult to ask what responsibility, experience or prior failure has taught them to see.</p><p>I have come to suspect that this is why intelligent leadership teams disagree so often. It is rarely because someone is smarter than everyone else in the room, or because somebody has ignored the evidence. More often, years of responsibility have trained each executive to notice different things and to assign different weight to what they see.</p><p>The danger begins when those different questions remain invisible.</p><p>When the sales leader believes everyone is discussing whether the opportunity can be won, while the CFO believes the discussion is about whether the organisation can afford to be wrong, the resulting disagreement can feel personal.</p><p>The sales leader hears a lack of courage.</p><p>The CFO hears a lack of discipline.</p><p>Both may leave the meeting convinced the other has failed to understand the evidence.</p><p>In reality, they may never have been having the same conversation.</p><p>This is one reason meetings can become repetitive without becoming clearer. Each person continues to produce more evidence in support of their own question. The sales leader offers additional proof of customer commitment. The finance executive asks for more certainty around cash and timing. The technology executive requests a clearer implementation plan.</p><p>Everyone believes they are moving the discussion forward.</p><p>Yet each answer creates another question because the underlying problem has never been agreed.</p><p>The meeting appears to be about the proposal.</p><p>It is actually about what the proposal means to each person in the room.</p><p>When we look back at failed strategies, abandoned projects, poor appointments or missed opportunities, we usually ask why intelligent people failed to recognise what now appears obvious.</p><p>I am beginning to think that may be the wrong question.</p><p>A better question might be this:</p><p>What problem did each person believe they had been asked to solve?</p><p>That question changes the nature of the discussion.</p><p>Instead of asking why the CFO is being negative, we might ask what risk they believe has not yet been addressed.</p><p>Instead of dismissing the sales leader as optimistic, we might ask what customer signals they can see that others cannot.</p><p>Instead of labelling the technology executive resistant, we might ask what implementation pattern they recognise from experience.</p><p>Instead of insisting that everyone evaluate a candidate in the same way, we might ask each executive to make the question they are answering explicit.</p><p>What are you looking for?</p><p>What are you worried about?</p><p>What responsibility are you carrying into this decision?</p><p>What have you seen before that the rest of us may not be able to see?</p><p>Those questions do not eliminate disagreement.</p><p>They make it useful.</p><p>Because organisations do not simply collect evidence.</p><p>They interpret it.</p><p>The evidence passes through experience, responsibility and judgement before it ever becomes a decision. By the time a board reaches consensus, every person around the table has been looking at the same facts through a different window.</p><p>Perhaps that is not a weakness of leadership.</p><p>Perhaps it is the very thing that makes good judgement possible.</p><p>A leadership team composed of people who all notice the same things may reach decisions quickly, but speed is not the same as wisdom. Agreement can reflect clarity, but it can also reflect sameness. When nobody sees the implementation risk, the cultural strain, the financial exposure or the opportunity cost, consensus may be little more than shared blindness.</p><p>The value of an executive team lies partly in the fact that its members do not see the organisation in the same way.</p><p>The finance executive should notice what the sales leader misses. The people executive should hear what the technology leader overlooks. The operations executive should recognise the strain hidden inside an ambitious strategy. The chair should ask what happens if the assumptions fail.</p><p>The CEO should understand that these are not interruptions to the decision.</p><p>They are the decision.</p><p>The challenge is not to eliminate those different perspectives.</p><p>The challenge is to recognise that they exist before we mistake them for disagreement.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fa75b4710ee8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Evidence Was There All Along]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/the-evidence-was-there-all-along-19173fbd231a?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/19173fbd231a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-behavior]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decision-making]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Jul 2026 00:04:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-15T00:04:36.009Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>After twenty five years interviewing executives and serving on boards, one question continues to bother me: why do intelligent, experienced people sometimes miss what later seems obvious?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZHXa5EIvnwM7mzZ7zJfrpw.png" /></figure><p>For many years, my writing has centred on executive search, leadership, boards, technology and business growth. They are subjects I know well and have been fortunate to observe closely.</p><p>The more I wrote, however, the more I realised they kept leading me back to the same question.</p><p>Why do intelligent, experienced people sometimes miss what later seems obvious?</p><p>I do not know the answer.</p><p>In fact, the longer I spend around founders, executives and boards, the less convinced I become that there is a single explanation.</p><p>This essay is the beginning of an exploration. I hope you’ll challenge my thinking, contribute your own observations and, perhaps together, we’ll better understand why intelligent people looking at the same evidence can arrive at completely different conclusions.</p><p>For more than twenty five years, I have had a front row seat to one of the most fascinating parts of business.</p><p>As an executive search consultant, I have spent my career interviewing founders, CEOs, board directors and senior executives. I have met extraordinary salespeople capable of transforming businesses, visionary technology leaders, exceptional strategists and experienced directors entrusted with steering organisations through uncertainty.</p><p>Today I also serve on a number of boards and have been involved in three successful company exits. That has given me another perspective. Not simply the judgement involved in selecting leaders, but the judgement required to set strategy, allocate capital, assess risk, challenge management and decide when to persist, when to change direction and, ultimately, when to sell.</p><p>Along the way I have listened to thousands of conversations about strategy, competition, growth, culture, leadership and the future. I have reviewed board papers, sat through executive presentations, debated business cases over countless coffees and dinners, and listened carefully as intelligent people explained why they believed one course of action was clearly the right one.</p><p>People often ask me what I am seeing.</p><p>Which markets are changing?</p><p>Which companies are growing?</p><p>Where is the talent moving?</p><p>Are there patterns emerging that others have not yet recognised?</p><p>It is one of the great privileges of my profession.</p><p>Executive search is not simply about finding people.</p><p>Board service is not simply about attending meetings.</p><p>Both place you remarkably close to the moments when organisations decide who to trust, what to believe and which version of the future they are prepared to back.</p><p>Over those years I have watched many of the people I placed become exceptional leaders.</p><p>I have also watched some fail spectacularly.</p><p>Neither outcome surprises me.</p><p>What continues to surprise me is something else entirely.</p><p>It is not that intelligent people make poor decisions.</p><p>Everyone does.</p><p>It is not even that organisations sometimes delay important decisions.</p><p>Waiting can be wise.</p><p>What fascinates me is how often intelligent, experienced people fail to recognise something that later appears obvious.</p><p>The warning signs were there.</p><p>The evidence existed.</p><p>Yet somehow it wasn’t recognised until much later, when everyone looked back and wondered why they hadn’t seen it sooner.</p><p>I have been asking myself the same questions for years.</p><p>Why does this happen?</p><p>Is it bias?</p><p>Is it experience?</p><p>Is it pressure?</p><p>Is it incentives?</p><p>Does success make us overconfident?</p><p>Does inexperience make us overly cautious?</p><p>Do we simply see what we expect to see?</p><p>Or do intelligent people, acting in good faith, genuinely interpret the same evidence in very different ways?</p><p>I have seen growth executives measured so heavily on short term profitability that they quietly stopped pursuing growth while competitors accelerated past them.</p><p>I have watched accomplished leaders arrive in new organisations convinced the formula that made them successful elsewhere would work again, only to discover that every organisation has its own history, culture and unwritten rules.</p><p>I have seen sales forecasts accepted with complete confidence despite major opportunities slipping quarter after quarter, while unexpected deals emerged from places no one had anticipated.</p><p>I have watched organisations dismiss new technologies, only to embrace them enthusiastically a few years later.</p><p>I have seen outstanding candidates overlooked while less suitable appointments progressed through apparently robust hiring processes.</p><p>I have also seen boards confront uncomfortable evidence early, change direction decisively and create extraordinary value. The three successful exits I have experienced were not the result of one brilliant decision. They were the product of hundreds of judgements made over time, some confident, some contested and many made with incomplete information.</p><p>That matters because poor judgement is only part of the story.</p><p>Intelligent people also make extraordinary decisions under uncertainty.</p><p>They recognise weak signals before others do.</p><p>They ask the difficult question no one else is asking.</p><p>They change their minds without losing authority.</p><p>They act before certainty arrives.</p><p>So perhaps the more interesting question is not simply why judgement fails.</p><p>Perhaps it is why the same qualities that produce exceptional judgement in one situation produce poor judgement in another.</p><p>These are not isolated stories.</p><p>They are recurring patterns.</p><p>I have seen them in boardrooms.</p><p>I have seen them in executive teams.</p><p>I have seen them in listed companies.</p><p>I have seen them in founders’ offices.</p><p>I have seen them in government.</p><p>Different organisations.</p><p>Different industries.</p><p>Different personalities.</p><p>The same underlying question.</p><p>Why do intelligent, experienced people sometimes fail to recognise what the available evidence is telling them?</p><p>I do not know the answer.</p><p>In fact, the longer I observe these moments, the less convinced I become that there is a single explanation.</p><p>Perhaps judgement is the product of experience, incentives, identity, pressure, optimism, fear and countless other forces that shape how we interpret reality.</p><p>Or perhaps the explanation is something else entirely.</p><p>I suspect I’ll continue returning to this question because it sits beneath almost every important decision organisations make.</p><p>The more I observe, the less convinced I become that there is a single explanation.</p><p>Perhaps that’s exactly what makes it worth exploring.</p><p><strong>The evidence doesn’t always arrive late. Sometimes our understanding does.</strong></p><p><strong>About the author</strong></p><p>Edward Mandla is the founder of Mandlason Executive Search, a board director and leadership adviser. He writes about leadership, organisational decision making and the patterns that shape how intelligent people make difficult decisions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=19173fbd231a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Best Candidates Do Not Bend to Your Hiring Process]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/the-best-candidates-do-not-bend-to-your-hiring-process-da816cb4e599?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da816cb4e599</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[workplace-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[executive-search]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remote-working]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jul 2026 22:39:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-08T22:39:25.667Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Work from home is not the real issue. It simply shines a light on leadership consistency and hiring judgement.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ddf_gc6JuMRDR3ifRQV2WQ.png" /></figure><p>A co founder of an American investment firm has reportedly launched a US thirty million dollar lawsuit after being fired for allegedly ignoring a return to office mandate he helped sign.</p><p>At first glance, it sounds like one of those perfect modern workplace stories. Founder tells everyone to return to the office. Founder does not return to the office. Founder is fired. Founder sues.</p><p>It is easy to laugh. It is also easy to turn it into another tired argument about remote work.</p><p>But I think the more important lesson sits somewhere else. This is not really about whether people should work from home or return to the office. It is about leadership consistency, founder behaviour and the way companies repel exceptional people by trying to make them fit a rule before they have understood what makes them exceptional.</p><p>The reported facts are messy, contested and legal. William Nieporte says the policy did not apply to him because he was an owner, not merely an employee. He also alleges the termination was used to push him out and affect his twelve per cent stake in the business. Bramshill denies the claims and says he was terminated for dereliction of duty.</p><p>So this is not legal commentary.</p><p>It is a leadership and hiring commentary.</p><p>Every founder, CEO and board should pay attention to the perception created when leaders impose rules they do not appear to live by themselves. In growing companies, founders often underestimate how closely they are watched. Every arrival time is noticed. Every early departure is noticed. Every special arrangement is noticed. Every exemption is noticed.</p><p>A founder might think they are being practical. The team may see double standards. A founder might think they have earned flexibility. The team may see entitlement. A founder might think the circumstances are different. The team may only see the rule that applied to everyone else.</p><p>This is why I have long told founders they need to build a degree of aloofness from their staff.</p><p>Not arrogance. Not distance for the sake of status. Aloofness in the sense of disciplined separation.</p><p>Founders are human. They will falter. They will contradict themselves. They will have bad days. They will make compromises. They will take shortcuts. And in a scaling company, there are eyes everywhere. Perception becomes reality long before the founder has finished explaining the nuance.</p><p>That is the internal leadership lesson.</p><p>But there is also a hiring lesson, and it matters even more.</p><p>I am hearing from some of the best headhunters in the world that clients are increasingly saying things like, “If the candidate mentions working from home, discount them immediately.”</p><p>I think that is ridiculous.</p><p>It may feel decisive. It may sound strong. It may satisfy a board or executive team that wants to send a message. But it misunderstands the very essence of executive search.</p><p>The best candidates are usually not sitting around waiting for your job. They are the backbone of their current company. They are stable, valued, well paid and often happy. They may not have looked at a job advertisement in years. They are not desperate to move. They are not trying to escape. They are not looking for the first company willing to take them.</p><p>That is precisely why they are worth approaching.</p><p>My role as a top tier headhunter is not to push them through a process and see whether they comply. My role is to understand them deeply enough to know whether a move could make sense.</p><p>I need to know their remuneration to the cent. I need to understand exactly how their short term incentive is calculated, measured and paid. I need to understand their long term incentive, including vesting, leaver provisions, valuation, taxation and what they may be walking away from. Sometimes I will suggest they obtain legal advice so they properly understand their equity position before making a decision.</p><p>But the financial detail is only part of it.</p><p>I also need to understand what makes them perform. How do they work? What rhythm suits them? What support do they need? What does their family situation look like? What does success currently depend on? What would they be giving up that is not visible in the salary package?</p><p>Because at the end of the process, every serious senior candidate takes the offer to the kitchen table.</p><p>That conversation is rarely about the job description. It sounds more like this: I thought you were happy. You are stable. Your long term incentive looks valuable. You are trusted where you are. So you are going to take probation? You are going to work longer hours while you settle in? We are going to see less of you during orientation? You are going to give up flexibility? You are going to go into the office every day? Are we really better off?</p><p>That is the conversation companies forget.</p><p>They think they are competing against other offers. Often, they are competing against the candidate staying exactly where they are.</p><p>And staying is powerful. Staying avoids risk. Staying protects family rhythm. Staying protects equity. Staying protects reputation. Staying protects confidence.</p><p>So when a company begins the conversation with rigid rules, it may never get to the point where the candidate can seriously imagine joining.</p><p>This does not mean every role can be remote. It does not mean office attendance is irrelevant. It does not mean leaders should be absent. Culture matters. Apprenticeship matters. Informal learning matters. Presence matters. The room matters.</p><p>But the question is not whether the office matters.</p><p>The question is whether your rule helps you attract and unlock the best person, or whether it merely gives you comfort that everyone is being treated the same.</p><p>Sameness is not always fairness. And it is rarely excellence.</p><p>Exceptional people often have exceptional operating systems. The magic that makes someone successful may include deep work from home. It may include early starts. It may include family stability. It may include avoiding a pointless commute. It may include quiet space. It may include being in the office three days a week with intense purpose rather than five days a week with performative presence.</p><p>If you remove the conditions that underpin their performance, do not be surprised when they do not perform for you.</p><p>This is where many companies get hiring wrong. They say they want the best, then design a process for the available. They say they want judgement, then screen for compliance. They say they want leadership, then punish the first sign of adult negotiation. They say they want someone who can change the company, then insist the person first proves they can submit to the company.</p><p>That is not how you secure the best of the best.</p><p>The best candidates need to be understood before they can be persuaded. A hiring process should discover the person, not merely test whether they will bend.</p><p>The right question is not, “Will this candidate comply with our preferred working model?”</p><p>The better question is this:</p><p>What conditions have made this person successful, and can we recreate enough of them here for the move to make sense?</p><p>That is a much harder question. It requires judgement. It requires curiosity. It requires confidence. It also requires the organisation to accept that hiring exceptional people is not the same as filling a vacancy.</p><p>Boards and CEOs should be very careful about blunt instructions such as, “discount anyone who mentions working from home.”</p><p>That sentence may feel like strength. It may actually be laziness.</p><p>It avoids the harder work of understanding trade offs, motivation, family reality, financial risk and performance conditions. A candidate who asks about flexibility may not be entitled. They may be thoughtful. They may be senior enough to know how they do their best work. They may be testing whether your company is mature enough to have an adult conversation.</p><p>The irony of the return to office debate is that both sides can become ideological. Some leaders pretend the office solves everything. Some employees pretend flexibility has no cost.</p><p>Both are wrong.</p><p>The real issue is judgement. What does the role require? What does the company need? What does the candidate need? What is negotiable? What is not? And is everyone being honest about the trade offs?</p><p>The Bramshill story is fascinating because it carries a familiar warning. Rules are easy to announce. They are harder to live. And they become dangerous when they are used as substitutes for judgement.</p><p>Founders should remember that staff watch what leaders do far more closely than what leaders say. Boards should remember that policies can have consequences far beyond the immediate employment issue. And hiring teams should remember that the best candidates are not waiting to be disciplined into your model.</p><p>They are waiting to be understood.</p><p>That is where real headhunting begins.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da816cb4e599" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Everyone Becomes a Forecaster]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/when-everyone-becomes-a-forecaster-6f04aaad60f2?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6f04aaad60f2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sales-leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[executive-leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jul 2026 07:27:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-08T07:27:10.404Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The budget has been approved. The hiring plan is ready. The market has turned negative. This is when sales leaders discover whether they are managing reality or managing commentary.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_ThMajJb0nSi7k9cuqgxRw.png" /></figure><h3>The moment the market changes</h3><p>When the market turns negative, everyone becomes a forecaster.</p><p>A director has read something troubling about the economy. The CEO has spoken to another CEO who says customers are delaying decisions. The CFO is watching cash more carefully. The sales team is hearing more hesitation in the market. Investors are nervous. The media is negative. Government policy looks poor. The Reserve Bank is warning that the brakes may have been applied too hard. The property market looks fragile.</p><p>Suddenly, every conversation carries a warning. There is talk of slowdown, caution, pressure and risk. The mood changes quickly. People who were confident during the budgeting cycle only a few weeks ago now begin questioning whether the assumptions still hold.</p><p>And yet, inside the business, the number has already been approved.</p><p>The new financial year has started. The budget has been signed off. The hiring plan has been agreed. The team is expecting leadership. The board is expecting delivery. Management is expecting confidence.</p><p>Somewhere in the middle of this, the sales leader is on winter break, supposedly resting, but not really resting at all. Because the same question keeps circling.</p><p>Is the number still real?</p><h3>The difference between confidence and theatre</h3><p>This is the moment that tests leadership.</p><p>Not when the market is buoyant. Not when customers are buying freely. Not when the hiring plan is easy to justify and the forecast feels obvious. Leadership is tested when the number has been agreed, but the world around it starts to feel different.</p><p>In these moments, many businesses become confused. They mistake noise for information. They mistake mood for evidence. They mistake confidence for optimism. They mistake caution for wisdom. Most dangerously, they mistake a budget for reality.</p><p>A budget is an internal commitment. Reality is external.</p><p>The customer does not care what number was approved at the planning offsite. The market does not care what growth rate was promised to the board. Procurement does not care how many salespeople are supposed to be hired. Economic conditions do not adjust themselves to fit the spreadsheet.</p><p>That does not mean the number is wrong. It means the number has to be tested.</p><p>This is the uncomfortable work of leadership.</p><p>When the market turns negative, the natural response is emotional. Some people want to retreat immediately. They want to cut the number, freeze hiring, protect cash and see how the first quarter plays out. Others want to push through. They want to hire the people, lift the activity, work harder, position value more clearly and tell the team this is where winners win.</p><p>Both instincts can be right. Both can also be dangerous.</p><p>The problem is not optimism. The problem is optimism without evidence. The problem is not caution. The problem is caution without analysis.</p><h3>Separating anxiety from evidence</h3><p>In a negative market, the leader’s first responsibility is to separate anxiety from evidence.</p><p>That sounds simple, but it is not. Anxiety is contagious. It enters the business quietly and often sounds more intelligent than it really is.</p><p>A delayed deal becomes a market signal. A cautious customer becomes proof of a slowdown. A missed forecast becomes evidence that everything has changed. A negative headline becomes a reason to question every assumption. Before long, the business is no longer discussing facts. It is discussing fear.</p><p>Fear often presents itself as prudence. It says, “Let’s be realistic.” It says, “Let’s not overcommit.” It says, “Let’s see how the first quarter plays out.”</p><p>Sometimes fear is right. Sometimes the number really is no longer achievable. Sometimes the hiring plan should be paused. Sometimes the market has moved faster than the business is willing to admit.</p><p>But sometimes fear is just fear.</p><p>If the business reacts too quickly, it can create the very outcome it was trying to avoid. It loses momentum, delays critical hires, signals uncertainty to the team, gives competitors room and allows good opportunities to pass. A difficult market can become a defeated culture.</p><p>That is why the decision cannot be made by mood. It has to be made by judgement.</p><p>The first question is not whether people are nervous. Of course they are nervous. The first question is what the business actually knows.</p><p>What is happening in the pipeline? Are customers still buying, or merely talking? Are deals progressing, or simply sitting in the forecast? Are decision makers engaged? Is budget approved? Are business cases being built? Are sales cycles extending? Are average deal sizes changing? Are discounting pressures increasing? Are existing customers expanding? Are new opportunities being created at the rate required?</p><p>This is where leadership separates itself from commentary.</p><p>Commentary says the market is bad. Leadership asks where it is bad, how bad it is, and what evidence supports that conclusion. Commentary says customers are cautious. Leadership asks which customers, at what stage, and with what consequence. Commentary says hiring should stop. Leadership asks which hires are essential, which are speculative, and which are unlikely to affect the year. Commentary says the number is too high. Leadership asks which part of the number is at risk and why.</p><p>The great danger in a negative market is that everyone sounds informed. Everyone has a data point. Everyone has a conversation they can reference. Everyone has a headline they can quote. Everyone has a reason to worry.</p><p>But not every worry deserves to become strategy.</p><h3>The hiring plan must earn its place</h3><p>This is particularly important when it comes to hiring.</p><p>A hiring plan approved during budgeting can look very different once the year begins. On paper, additional sales headcount looks like capacity. In reality, a new salesperson is not a spreadsheet cell.</p><p>They need to be found, interviewed, hired, onboarded, trained and coached. They need to be given a territory, vertical or account base that has a real chance of producing revenue. Then they need to build pipeline, create trust, qualify opportunities and move deals through a sales cycle.</p><p>In a slower market, that ramp can take longer.</p><p>So the question is not simply, “Can we afford the hire?” The better question is, “Can this hire become productive quickly enough to affect the result?”</p><p>Some hires will still make sense. They may be tied to an underdeveloped territory, a neglected customer segment, an overloaded senior seller or a strategic product launch. Those hires are not luxuries. They are part of the plan.</p><p>But other hires may be speculative. They are based on the hope that more people will create more revenue. Hope that the market will improve. Hope that activity will compensate for weaker demand. Hope that new headcount will fix a problem that is really about positioning, qualification, conversion or leadership discipline.</p><p>That is not a hiring plan. That is expensive optimism.</p><p>This is why a sales leader cannot simply stand in front of the team and say, “We just have to work harder.” Harder may be necessary, but harder is not a strategy.</p><p>In a tougher market, the answer is not simply more calls, more meetings, more pressure and more noise. The answer is sharper judgement, better qualification, more precise value, cleaner forecasting, earlier honesty and greater discipline around which opportunities deserve time and which do not.</p><p>A team can follow that. A team can respect that.</p><p>What they cannot follow for long is theatre.</p><h3>Calm commercial honesty</h3><p>A team cannot follow a leader who pretends nothing has changed when everyone can feel that something has. They cannot follow panic either. They need something harder and rarer.</p><p>They need calm commercial honesty.</p><p>That honesty might sound like this:</p><p>“The market is harder. We are not going to pretend otherwise. But we are also not going to let headlines run the business. We will inspect the facts. We will focus on customers with real pain, real budget and a real reason to act. We will proceed with the hires that are essential to the plan, and we will pause the hires that are speculative. We will be ambitious, but we will not be careless. We will be honest early if the evidence changes.”</p><p>That is leadership.</p><p>Not blind optimism. Not retreat. Not panic dressed up as prudence. Leadership.</p><p>The right response in this situation is rarely dramatic. It is usually disciplined.</p><p>Rebuild the forecast from the ground up. Inspect the pipeline with greater rigour. Get closer to customers. Separate engagement from intent. Separate interest from urgency. Separate pipeline from wishful thinking. Separate essential hiring from speculative hiring. Agree the leading indicators that will be watched weekly. Define the trigger points that would justify a reset.</p><p>Then lead the team with the truth.</p><h3>The real risk is losing contact with reality</h3><p>This matters because the worst outcome is not missing the number.</p><p>Businesses miss numbers. Markets move. Customers delay decisions. Budgets get reviewed. Economic conditions change.</p><p>The worst outcome is pretending the number is still true long after the evidence says otherwise.</p><p>That is when the organisation starts to lose contact with reality. Forecasts become managed rather than examined. Hiring continues because stopping would require an uncomfortable conversation. Salespeople are told to be positive when they need sharper direction. Management is told what it wants to hear. The board receives confidence instead of clarity.</p><p>Gradually, the business stops managing reality and starts managing commentary.</p><p>That is the real risk.</p><p>Not the negative market. Not the difficult quarter. Not even the ambitious number. The real risk is allowing fear, optimism, politics or pride to replace judgement.</p><p>When everyone becomes a forecaster, the leader’s job is not to have the loudest forecast. It is to ask better questions.</p><p>What do we know? What are we assuming? What has changed? What has not changed? Where is the evidence? Where is the risk? Which hires still make sense? Which hires should pause? Which part of the number is still credible? Which part needs to be watched more closely? At what point do we escalate? At what point do we change course?</p><p>The leader’s job is not to be positive.</p><p>The leader’s job is to be clear.</p><p>Clear enough to see the market as it is. Clear enough to protect the business from panic. Clear enough to protect the team from false confidence. Clear enough to keep ambition alive without losing discipline.</p><p>Because when the market turns negative, everyone becomes a forecaster.</p><p>But not everyone becomes a leader.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6f04aaad60f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Trust 80 Year Olds With Nations, But Not 50 Year Olds With Jobs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/we-trust-80-year-olds-with-nations-but-not-50-year-olds-with-jobs-eb52590cebc9?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eb52590cebc9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of-work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[age-discrimination]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Jul 2026 22:34:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-01T22:34:35.949Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>AI supported hiring systems may be screening out experienced candidates before human judgement ever begins.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PgVJXm_1UHdElEq1RswqRg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I nearly dropped my toast at breakfast.</p><p>The radio mentioned Donald Trump’s 80th birthday.</p><p>Thanks for reading Edward’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.</p><p>Whatever you think of Donald Trump, and people think many things, one thing is hard to deny. He has energy. He has presence. He has stamina. At 80, he is still operating at the centre of global politics.</p><p>Then I heard Pauline Hanson was addressing the National Press Club. At 72, she was standing before the Canberra press gallery, still shaping national debate and clearly not behaving like someone ready to disappear quietly from public life.</p><p>Then my mind went to Clover Moore, who has been Lord Mayor of Sydney for more than two decades and remains one of the most recognisable figures in Australian local government.</p><p>And then I thought about a conversation I had years ago while coaching a group of internal recruiters.</p><p>They were bright, energetic and mostly in their mid twenties to mid thirties. They were also the gatekeepers of Applicant Tracking Systems inside significant organisations. Not small organisations. Serious organisations. Organisations where hiring decisions move the needle.</p><p>One of them looked at an application and said something like:</p><p>“I can’t believe a 50 year old has applied for this role. I expect to be retired by then.”</p><p>Really?</p><p>Retired by 50?</p><p>Not applying for roles?</p><p>Not contributing?</p><p>Not learning?</p><p>Not building?</p><p>Not leading?</p><p>It was said casually. That was the worrying part. It was not said with malice. It was said as if it were obvious.</p><p>And that is where the real danger sits.</p><p>Age discrimination is often not loud. It is not always cruel. It does not always announce itself as bias.</p><p>Sometimes it is just a young person in front of a screen, assisted by AI, deciding that 50 is old.</p><h3>The contradiction</h3><p>We live with a strange contradiction.</p><p>We will allow people in their 70s and 80s to lead cities, political parties, major companies and countries.</p><p>We will watch investors, judges, scientists, artists and founders remain productive deep into later life.</p><p>We will celebrate late life achievement when it is famous enough.</p><p>Yet in ordinary hiring processes, especially corporate hiring processes increasingly supported by AI, people can begin to be treated as questionable at 50.</p><p>Not incapable.</p><p>Questionable.</p><p>That is the subtle shift.</p><p>Will they have the energy? Will they understand the technology? Will they fit the culture? Will they take direction? Will they want too much money? Will they be here for long? Will they be too set in their ways?</p><p>These questions are often implied before anyone has assessed the person.</p><p>And with AI screening, the more serious problem is that the questions may never be asked at all.</p><p>The candidate can be excluded before a human being has paused to consider whether the person might actually be capable, current, energetic and valuable.</p><p>This is not judgement.</p><p>It is assumption, now embedded into workflow.</p><h3>The 50 year old applicant</h3><p>Let’s sit with that 50 year old applicant for a moment.</p><p>What might that person actually represent?</p><p>They may have led through recessions. They may have seen technology cycles come and go. They may have managed people older and younger than themselves. They may have made painful decisions. They may have hired badly and learned from it. They may have been through restructures, acquisitions, board pressure, founder pressure, investor pressure and customer pressure.</p><p>They may know the difference between activity and progress.</p><p>They may know when a forecast is real.</p><p>They may know when a confident executive is bluffing.</p><p>They may know how to sit in a room full of tension and not make it worse.</p><p>That does not mean they are right for the role.</p><p>It means they deserve assessment, not dismissal.</p><p>The problem with age bias is not just that it is unfair to candidates. It is that it damages hiring judgement.</p><p>A good hiring process should ask whether the person can do the work. Whether they have solved problems like this before. Whether they are still learning. Whether they have the energy for this context. Whether they can absorb complexity, work with the people around them and make good decisions under pressure.</p><p>But if an AI supported process screens the person out at the first pass, the question never gets asked.</p><p>That is the real danger.</p><p>We can pretend the system is improving efficiency, when in reality it may simply be making old assumptions faster, cleaner and harder to see.</p><p>Age is a poor proxy for capability.</p><p>There are tired 35 year olds and curious 70 year olds. There are rigid young executives and highly adaptive older executives. There are people who stopped learning at 28 and people still reinventing themselves at 75.</p><p>The question is not age.</p><p>The question is evidence of current capability.</p><h3>Retirement is not a universal aspiration</h3><p>There is another assumption underneath all of this.</p><p>The assumption that retirement is the natural goal.</p><p>For some people, retirement is wonderful. They have earned it. They want it. They have other things to do. Family, travel, sport, community, grandchildren, study, writing, service, rest.</p><p>Good.</p><p>But for others, work is not merely income.</p><p>It is identity. It is purpose. It is contribution. It is structure. It is social connection. It is mental challenge. It is usefulness.</p><p>We should be careful about designing hiring systems, cultures and career pathways that assume people should quietly disappear from productive life because they crossed an invisible line.</p><p>The better question is not when should people retire.</p><p>The better question is what kind of contribution does this person still want to make, and are they capable of making it?</p><p>That is a more human question.</p><p>It is also a better business question.</p><h3>The gatekeeper has changed</h3><p>One of the uncomfortable parts of modern recruitment is that the first gatekeeper is often not the hiring manager.</p><p>It is not the CEO.</p><p>It is not the board.</p><p>It is not even necessarily an experienced recruiter.</p><p>It is often a junior person operating an AI supported workflow.</p><p>Applicant Tracking Systems were originally built to create order. They manage volume. They help process applications. They make recruitment administratively possible.</p><p>But once AI is layered into this process, the risk changes.</p><p>The system does not merely store applications.</p><p>It can rank them.</p><p>It can recommend them.</p><p>It can downgrade them.</p><p>It can interpret them.</p><p>It can decide who deserves attention and who disappears quietly into the rejection pile.</p><p>That can be useful when the system is well designed, properly governed and used by people who understand its limits.</p><p>But it can be dangerous when it gives false confidence to weak judgement.</p><p>A keyword filter can downgrade a career. A graduation date can become a silent age marker. A long career can be interpreted as overqualification. A career break can be treated as a defect. A senior candidate can be marked as too expensive, too slow, too traditional or too risky without anyone ever saying those words out loud.</p><p>A person who has built, led, failed, recovered, learned and grown can be reduced to a mismatch score.</p><p>And the organisation may never know what it missed.</p><h3>AI does not remove bias</h3><p>One of the great myths of technology is that if a machine is involved, the process becomes neutral.</p><p>It does not.</p><p>AI does not remove bias simply because it is technical.</p><p>It can industrialise bias.</p><p>It can learn from historical patterns that already favoured younger candidates. It can infer age through proxies. It can reward career shapes that look like previous hires. It can prefer the language of people who have been trained to write for the machine.</p><p>It can make exclusion feel scientific.</p><p>And once a candidate is screened out at the top of the funnel, no one ever gets the chance to exercise judgement.</p><p>No one asks whether the candidate is still learning.</p><p>No one asks whether their experience is directly relevant.</p><p>No one asks whether their maturity might be useful in a complex environment.</p><p>No one asks whether they have the stamina for the role.</p><p>No one asks whether they might be exactly what the business needs.</p><p>That is not efficiency.</p><p>That is premature exclusion.</p><h3>Age does not guarantee wisdom</h3><p>There is an equal and opposite mistake here.</p><p>Age does not automatically create wisdom.</p><p>Experience can become insight.</p><p>It can also become scar tissue.</p><p>Some older candidates are not current. Some have stopped learning. Some want status without pressure. Some are expensive relative to the problem. Some are looking for the job they used to have, not the job that now exists.</p><p>Some confuse tenure with value.</p><p>So this is not an argument for romanticising older workers.</p><p>It is an argument for judging them properly.</p><p>The same standard should apply to everyone.</p><p>Do not hire the 30 year old because they seem energetic.</p><p>Do not reject the 60 year old because the system has marked them as a poor fit.</p><p>Do not promote the internal candidate because they have waited.</p><p>Do not dismiss the external candidate because their career looks different.</p><p>Assess the evidence.</p><h3>This is a governance issue</h3><p>Boards and executive teams talk constantly about talent.</p><p>They talk about succession, capability, resilience and transformation.</p><p>They talk about AI adoption.</p><p>They talk about productivity.</p><p>They talk about workforce strategy.</p><p>But how many ask whether their hiring systems are quietly excluding experienced talent?</p><p>How many ask what their ATS and AI tools are filtering out?</p><p>How many ask whether age is being used directly or indirectly as a proxy for energy, adaptability or cultural fit?</p><p>How many ask whether “overqualified” is being used as a polite word for “too old”?</p><p>How many ask whether their AI supported hiring process is improving judgement or simply accelerating bias?</p><p>These are not administrative questions.</p><p>They are governance questions.</p><p>Because talent risk is business risk.</p><p>Potential is not owned by the young.</p><p>Potential is the capacity to keep growing.</p><p>Some people have it at 25.</p><p>Some people have it at 75.</p><p>Some never had it at all.</p><h3>We need to stop retiring people in our minds</h3><p>The most damaging retirement is not always the formal one.</p><p>It is the retirement imposed by other people’s assumptions.</p><p>The moment someone is mentally moved from possible to past it.</p><p>The moment a recruiter sees a date and stops reading.</p><p>The moment an AI supported system filters out a person before a conversation can happen.</p><p>The moment a hiring manager says “too experienced” when they really mean “too old”.</p><p>That is where talent is lost.</p><p>Not because people are incapable.</p><p>Because we stopped looking.</p><p>The world is ageing. Careers are getting longer. Health spans are changing. Work is changing. The old model of education, work, retirement is already breaking apart.</p><p>And yet too many hiring systems are still built around a narrow image of what ambition is supposed to look like.</p><p>Maybe the 50 year old applicant is not the problem.</p><p>Maybe the problem is the person who thinks 50 is old.</p><p>Maybe the problem is the AI supported system that agrees with them.</p><p>And maybe, before we let algorithms decide who has a future, we should ask whether the humans behind them understand how long a useful life can really be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eb52590cebc9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AI Is Exposing Which Executives Are Still Evolving]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/ai-is-exposing-which-executives-are-still-evolving-74cd329dc752?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/74cd329dc752</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[executive-leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of-work]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Jun 2026 08:45:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-11T08:45:52.085Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>AI is not reducing the need for senior executives. It is raising the standard they are being measured against.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_WzlSiD7qHQsK0nyPm36ow.png" /></figure><p>AI Is Exposing the Executives Who Have Stopped Evolving</p><p>I spend a large part of my life on the phone with CEOs, Chairs, Directors, founders and senior executives.</p><p>One question is coming up more often than almost any other.</p><p>What is AI doing to executive hiring?</p><p>My answer is becoming clearer.</p><p>AI is not reducing the need for senior executives. It is increasing the demand for senior executives who can interpret more information, make better decisions and reshape the way work gets done.</p><p>The best executives are getting better.</p><p>They are using AI to test market strategies, interrogate customer feedback, prepare for client meetings, analyse competitive positioning and rethink workflows inside their own organisations.</p><p>They are more productive. They are better prepared. They are freeing up time for more strategic work.</p><p>Anecdotally, I am not seeing a reduction in their working hours. If anything, many of the strongest executives have a new spring in their step.</p><p>They can see the leverage.</p><p>They are not treating AI as a toy, a shortcut or a delegation tool for junior work. They are using it to sharpen their own judgement and to lift the operating rhythm of their teams.</p><p>I now see executives using AI after client visits to capture insights, identify patterns and challenge their own assumptions.</p><p>I see them using it to reshape roles, redesign workflows and question whether their existing organisational structure still makes sense.</p><p>This is creating a new kind of conversation.</p><p>I am being called in more often to discuss organisational charts, role design and job shaping for key executive positions.</p><p>The question is no longer simply whether someone has done the job before.</p><p>The question is whether the job itself has changed.</p><p>And in many cases, it has.</p><p>There is also a much harder side to this.</p><p>I am receiving more calls from CEOs, Board Directors and Chairs asking how AI savvy their executive team needs to be.</p><p>The pattern is becoming familiar.</p><p>The executive is usually well liked. Often, they are deeply respected. They have been loyal, committed and culturally important. In many cases, they have helped take the company to its current stage.</p><p>But the concern is almost always the same.</p><p>They no longer seem close enough to the detail. They are not interpreting the new data flowing through the business. They are not applying technology to the way they lead. They are not changing the workflows inside their function.</p><p>The issue is rarely whether they are good people.</p><p>The issue is whether they are still evolving quickly enough.</p><p>Many organisations are reaching an AI inflection point.</p><p>The executives who got the company to its current stage may not be the same executives who can lead it through the next data and workflow journey.</p><p>That does not make them bad executives.</p><p>It does not erase what they have contributed.</p><p>But it does create a leadership question that Boards and CEOs can no longer avoid.</p><p>Can this executive still scale with the business?</p><p>Can they absorb new information quickly?</p><p>Can they interpret data, not just receive it?</p><p>Can they redesign the way their team works?</p><p>Can they bring rigour to the Boardroom?</p><p>Can they move beyond experience and demonstrate current judgement?</p><p>I believe the days of a Head of function walking into a Board meeting and winging it with optimism, anecdotes and thin reporting are coming to an end.</p><p>Boards are expecting more.</p><p>They want to see the new workflows.</p><p>They want to see better research.</p><p>They want to see a higher level of accuracy.</p><p>They want executives who can evaluate more sources of information, distinguish signal from noise and explain what should happen next.</p><p>This is not about replacing human judgement with artificial intelligence.</p><p>It is about using artificial intelligence to expose the quality of human judgement.</p><p>That is why executive hiring is becoming more demanding, not less.</p><p>A strong executive today needs more than charisma, loyalty and functional experience.</p><p>They need adaptability.</p><p>They need curiosity.</p><p>They need intellectual honesty.</p><p>They need the ability to rethink the operating model of their function while the business is still moving.</p><p>As economic conditions become tougher, organisations are running the ruler over everything.</p><p>Cost structures.</p><p>Headcount.</p><p>Market strategy.</p><p>Sales productivity.</p><p>Customer retention.</p><p>Technology investment.</p><p>And now, increasingly, executive adaptability.</p><p>AI is accelerating that scrutiny.</p><p>It is making strong executives stronger.</p><p>It is also revealing executives who have stopped evolving.</p><p>That is the real impact of AI on executive hiring.</p><p>It is not just changing the tools executives use.</p><p>It is changing the standard they are being measured against.</p><p>First published on Substack: <a href="http://edwardmandla.substack.com/">edwardmandla.substack.com</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=74cd329dc752" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Executive They Said Would Never Leave]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/the-executive-they-said-would-never-leave-7985b47a6f69?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7985b47a6f69</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[executive-search]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Jun 2026 07:29:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-03T07:29:09.587Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The assumptions that almost caused everyone to miss an exceptional candidate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kHuLpfoPvGqnGguRXU28Ww.png" /></figure><p>One of the most dangerous phrases in business is:</p><p>“They’ll never leave.”</p><p>I heard it again this week.</p><p>I was presenting my preliminary research for a senior leadership appointment to a CEO and Chair.</p><p>One of the messages I always leave with clients is that Executive Search works best when it is collaborative.</p><p>The leadership team often knows exceptional people.</p><p>Current staff often know exceptional people.</p><p>Board members often know exceptional people.</p><p>A client should never reject a referral without investigation.</p><p>That’s my job.</p><p>To assess the person.</p><p>To understand their motivations.</p><p>To protect the reputation of my client.</p><p>Over the preceding week, referrals had started flowing in and we reviewed them alongside my own research.</p><p>We discussed backgrounds, strengths, career trajectories and possible reasons someone might consider leaving a successful organisation.</p><p>Then the Chair suggested a name.</p><p>I brought the profile up on the screen.</p><p>Three employers in eighteen years.</p><p>A strong promotion history.</p><p>Increasing responsibility.</p><p>A senior executive within an ASX listed company.</p><p>The sort of career progression most boards would admire.</p><p>Before I could say much more, the CEO interrupted.</p><p>“Great person,” he said.</p><p>“I’ve bumped into them at industry events for years. I’ve dropped subtle hints from time to time.”</p><p>“The answer is always the same.”</p><p>The CEO paused.</p><p>“They haven’t finished what they’re doing.”</p><p>“They’ll never leave.”</p><p>The Chair nodded.</p><p>“Even if they did, I’m not sure we could afford them.”</p><p>Both comments were entirely reasonable.</p><p>And both turned out to be wrong.</p><h3>What LinkedIn Couldn’t See</h3><p>When I approach people, I rarely begin by talking about my client.</p><p>I certainly do not begin with a job description.</p><p>And I never begin with salary.</p><p>Most recruiters do exactly that.</p><p>They lead with the company.</p><p>The opportunity.</p><p>The package.</p><p>The benefits.</p><p>The problem is that exceptional executives are rarely looking for a job.</p><p>Their default response is predictable.</p><p>“Thanks, but I’m happy where I am.”</p><p>The conversation ends before it starts.</p><p>Instead, I focus on the individual.</p><p>Their career.</p><p>Their ambitions.</p><p>Their frustrations.</p><p>Their future.</p><p>Where do they see themselves in five years?</p><p>What are they trying to achieve?</p><p>What do they enjoy most about their current role?</p><p>What would they change if they could?</p><p>Only after trust is established do the interesting conversations begin.</p><p>During our discussion, I asked a simple question.</p><p>“You’re not planning on being carried out of the company in a coffin, are you?”</p><p>The executive laughed.</p><p>“No.”</p><p>“I just love my team.”</p><p>That seemed entirely consistent with everything the CEO had told me.</p><p>Then I made another observation.</p><p>“It must be nice working somewhere that everything is going perfectly.”</p><p>The answer came back immediately.</p><p>“I love my people.”</p><p>“But the new leadership team, not so much.”</p><p>Interesting.</p><p>We kept talking.</p><p>The layers started coming off.</p><p>He had consistently delivered results.</p><p>He had recently been recognised as a top performer.</p><p>Yet there had been no salary increase.</p><p>The long term incentive plan had been cancelled.</p><p>A replacement had been promised but had still not materialised six months later.</p><p>The culture was changing.</p><p>The business was changing.</p><p>And while he respected the new leadership team, he was no longer sure he fitted where the organisation was heading.</p><p>What I eventually discovered was something I see quite often.</p><p><strong>The price of loyalty.</strong></p><p>His remuneration had gradually fallen behind the market.</p><p>Not dramatically.</p><p>Not enough to trigger an immediate resignation.</p><p>Just enough to create doubt.</p><p>The company believed they had a highly engaged executive.</p><p>The executive believed he was highly valued.</p><p>Neither side had fully tested those assumptions.</p><h3>The Opportunity</h3><p>A few days later, I asked whether I could run something past him.</p><p>No company name.</p><p>No CEO name.</p><p>No sales pitch.</p><p>Just an anonymised role description.</p><p>We met for coffee after he had read it.</p><p>“This sounds exciting,” he said.</p><p>“I can see the opportunity.”</p><p>“I can see how I could put my mark on something like this.”</p><p>“I can see how I could contribute to company strategy.”</p><p>The conversation then moved to economics.</p><p>I explained that the base salary would likely be higher.</p><p>The short term incentive would probably be lower.</p><p>But the long term incentive could be genuinely meaningful.</p><p>He listened carefully.</p><p>Then he smiled.</p><p>“I think I’m in.”</p><p>Only then did I tell him who the company was.</p><p>He looked genuinely surprised.</p><p>“I know them.”</p><p>“I’ve met the CEO many times.”</p><p>“He’s always been polite and respectful.”</p><p>Then he paused.</p><p>“I had no idea the business had evolved that much.”</p><p>The company he thought he knew no longer existed.</p><p>Another assumption.</p><p>Gone.</p><p>The CEO and Chair were delighted when I called them.</p><p>Not because we had secured a candidate.</p><p>Not because we had made an appointment.</p><p>But because we had learned something important.</p><p>The executive everyone thought would never move was willing to have a serious conversation.</p><h3>The Real Lesson</h3><p>This is not really a story about Executive Search.</p><p>It is a story about assumptions.</p><p>The CEO assumed the executive would never leave.</p><p>The Chair assumed they could not afford him.</p><p>The executive assumed my client was still the company he had known years ago.</p><p>His employer probably assumed loyalty meant engagement.</p><p>Every assumption was wrong.</p><p>Nothing had actually changed.</p><p>The executive had not suddenly become unhappy.</p><p>The company had not suddenly become attractive.</p><p>The market had not shifted overnight.</p><p>The only thing that changed was the quality of information.</p><p>The assumptions disappeared.</p><p>I see this pattern everywhere.</p><p>Boards make assumptions about CEOs.</p><p>CEOs make assumptions about customers.</p><p>Founders make assumptions about investors.</p><p>Managers make assumptions about employees.</p><p>Employees make assumptions about leadership.</p><p>The further away we are from the facts, the more confident our assumptions often become.</p><p>That is why the best leaders stay curious.</p><p>They ask questions.</p><p>They listen carefully.</p><p>They test what they think they know.</p><p>Most opportunities are not hidden.</p><p>They are sitting in plain sight behind assumptions.</p><p>The assumption that a customer is happy.</p><p>The assumption that an employee is engaged.</p><p>The assumption that an executive will never leave.</p><p>The assumption that a company has not changed.</p><p>The assumption that we already know the answer.</p><p>This week reminded me why assumptions can be dangerous.</p><p>Everybody in this story was intelligent.</p><p>Everybody was experienced.</p><p>Everybody had good intentions.</p><p>And everybody was wrong.</p><p>First published on substack: <a href="https://substack.com/@edwardmandla">https://substack.com/@edwardmandla</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7985b47a6f69" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Companies Fail When Leaders Start Managing Commentary Instead of Reality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/why-companies-fail-when-leaders-start-managing-commentary-instead-of-reality-9c662bd58c1d?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c662bd58c1d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sales]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[private-equity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[saas]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 May 2026 07:39:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-27T07:39:35.835Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IIuS67Co2U3mAoQftU0_MA.png" /></figure><p>Companies rarely fail because of one catastrophic moment.</p><p>More often, they fail slowly when leadership teams stop confronting operational reality and start managing commentary instead.</p><p>First published on Substack: <a href="https://edwardmandla.substack.com/p/the-killer-of-companies?r=7f0wba">https://edwardmandla.substack.com/p/the-killer-of-companies?r=7f0wba</a></p><p>I often read shareholder updates full of optimism about the pipeline.</p><p>Strong activity.<br>Major opportunities progressing.<br>Significant deals expected next quarter.</p><p>And I sometimes find myself wondering:</p><p>Are these the same deals we forecasted six months ago?</p><p>Because in many companies, there comes a point where the pipeline stops being a forecast and starts becoming a protection mechanism.</p><p>A deal is no longer truly alive, but nobody wants to declare it dead.</p><p>The sponsor has left.<br>Procurement has gone quiet.<br>The project has stalled internally.<br>The budget has shifted.<br>The urgency has disappeared.</p><p>But somehow the commentary survives:</p><p>“It’s progressing.”<br>“There’s still strong engagement.”<br>“We expect movement next quarter.”</p><p>Sometimes, it is better for a major deal to be deemed lost than endlessly buying into the comfort of “it’s progressing.”</p><p>Because the longer organisations refuse to confront reality, the more expensive the optimism becomes.</p><p>This is where companies develop what I call “happy ears.”</p><p>Leaders begin hearing what they want to hear, rather than what is actually happening.</p><p>And it is rarely limited to sales.</p><p>CEOs want reassurance that the strategy is working. Sales leaders want to protect the team and avoid difficult conversations. Board directors do not want to overreact too early. Investors prefer optimism to impairment.</p><p>Over time, the entire organisation slowly drifts away from reality.</p><p>Pipelines stay inflated. Headcount remains too high. Non performers stay protected.</p><p>Forecasts drift further away from execution while expense lines continue growing.</p><p>Then eventually the company returns to the market for more capital, still explaining that the opportunity ahead is enormous.</p><p>This is not confined to scale ups or founder led businesses.</p><p>I have seen it in large established companies, listed organisations and particularly in PE backed environments where growth expectations, exit timelines and valuation pressure can unintentionally reward optimism over accuracy.</p><p>The irony is that sophisticated investors usually want the truth early.</p><p>But somewhere between the frontline and the boardroom, organisations can start filtering information in a way that sounds commercially reassuring rather than operationally real.</p><p>A delayed deal becomes “high probability.”<br>A stalled project becomes “timing related.”<br>A weak quarter becomes “pushed into next period.”</p><p>And gradually the company stops managing reality and starts managing commentary.</p><p>I have sat in enough forecast reviews and board discussions to know this rarely begins with bad intent.</p><p>In technology companies particularly, this can become culturally dangerous.</p><p>A business can convince itself that because the Total Addressable Market is large, success is inevitable.</p><p>But markets do not pay companies for potential energy.</p><p>They pay for execution.</p><p>And often the most dangerous companies are not the ones confronting bad news early.</p><p>They are the ones continuously explaining why the bad news is not really bad news yet.</p><p>I have also seen “happy ears” destroy hiring judgement.</p><p>An executive candidate interviews well.<br>The references sound positive.<br>The narrative feels compelling.</p><p>Meanwhile the warning signs are sitting in plain sight.</p><p>Revenue outcomes are vague.<br>Teams were inherited rather than built.<br>The difficult questions are answered with polished commentary rather than specifics.</p><p>But everyone wants the hire to work, so the organisation hears confidence instead of risk.</p><p>Boards are not immune either.</p><p>One of the hardest things for directors is distinguishing between temporary delay and structural weakness.</p><p>Because optimism is socially rewarded in boardrooms.</p><p>Scepticism often is not.</p><p>The director who asks difficult questions can quickly become “negative” while the person reinforcing the growth narrative appears supportive and aligned.</p><p>But great boards do something differently.</p><p>They create environments where bad news travels quickly.</p><p>Strong companies do not punish reality.</p><p>They surface it early.</p><p>They force clarity around pipeline quality.<br>They challenge assumptions.<br>They remove emotion from forecasting.<br>And they understand that losing a deal early is often healthier than carrying false hope for another two quarters.</p><p>Great companies are not built on optimism alone.</p><p>They are built on the ability to confront reality earlier than competitors.</p><p>Because bad news rarely destroys companies.</p><p>Delayed recognition of bad news does.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c662bd58c1d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Titles Don’t Build Companies. Capability Does.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/titles-dont-build-companies-capability-does-68c348f657a8?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/68c348f657a8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 May 2026 06:15:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-20T06:15:50.652Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EFJOM_yJRMu_RLlEuczTRQ.png" /></figure><h3>Why experienced investors and executive search professionals quietly worry when narrative starts outrunning operating capability.</h3><p><em>First published on Substack by</em> Edward Mandla at <a href="http://edwardmandla.substack.com/">edwardmandla.substack.com</a></p><p>There is a strange moment that happens in many founder led companies.</p><p>You read a shareholder update and something feels off.</p><p>Not fraudulent.<br> Not catastrophic.<br> Just… inflated.</p><p>The language becomes larger than the business.</p><p>The narrative starts running ahead of the operating reality.</p><p>The adjectives multiply faster than the revenue.</p><p>You see references to:</p><p>• strategic partnerships<br> • global expansion plans<br> • institutional capital pathways<br> • transformational branding<br> • market leadership positioning<br> • AI capability<br> • executive appointments<br> • five year growth visions</p><p>And somewhere in the middle of it all, your instincts quietly whisper:</p><p>“Something here feels more ambitious than proven.”</p><p>If you have spent enough time around scaling businesses, particularly founder led technology companies, you know exactly the feeling.</p><p>The challenge is what comes next.</p><p>Because as a minority shareholder, particularly one without control, you quickly discover an uncomfortable truth:</p><p>Being right and being effective are not always the same thing.</p><h3>The Emotional Trap</h3><p>Many minority shareholders make the same mistake.</p><p>They react emotionally.</p><p>They fire off the long email.<br>They critique management.<br>They attack the strategy.<br>They point out the obvious gaps.</p><p>Usually, none of it changes anything.</p><p>In fact, it often achieves the opposite.</p><p>Management becomes defensive.<br> The shareholder gets labelled “negative.”<br> Access to information narrows.<br> Relationships deteriorate.<br> Future raises become more dangerous.</p><p>The irony is that many of these shareholders are not wrong.</p><p>They are simply early.</p><h3>The Difference Between Narrative and Operating Substance</h3><p>One of the most important skills in business is learning to separate:</p><p>storytelling<br> from<br> operating reality.</p><p>Great companies eventually develop both.</p><p>But during scaling phases, many businesses overdevelop one before the other.</p><p>You start seeing:</p><p>• advisory firms before scalable sales systems<br> • branding exercises before repeatable customer acquisition<br> • executive titles ahead of executive capability<br> • pipeline optimism ahead of conversion evidence<br> • expansion plans before domestic dominance</p><p>This does not automatically mean the company will fail.</p><p>That is the dangerous part.</p><p>Some businesses grow into the story.<br>Others never do.</p><p>The market eventually decides.</p><h3>Where Executive Search and Hiring Judgement Actually Matter</h3><p>One of the dangers in scaling companies is that ambition starts influencing hiring decisions.</p><p>Titles become aspirational.</p><p>Capability becomes projected rather than proven.</p><p>Energy gets mistaken for leadership maturity.</p><p>This is where genuine executive search differs from transactional recruitment.</p><p>Real executive search is not about producing a pile of enthusiastic candidates and hoping one works out.</p><p>It is about judgement.</p><p>The best search operators spend enormous amounts of time distinguishing between:</p><p>• potential and readiness<br> • confidence and capability<br> • storytelling and execution<br> • commercial activity and commercial leadership<br> • emerging talent and proven executives</p><p>One of the reasons many scaling companies get senior hiring wrong is that founders understandably want momentum.</p><p>Someone energetic.<br>Someone positive.<br>Someone commercially aggressive.<br>Someone who says yes.</p><p>But executive leadership roles are not developmental playgrounds.</p><p>A premature executive appointment can damage:</p><p>• culture<br> • forecasting credibility<br> • investor confidence<br> • customer trust<br> • internal leadership alignment<br> • board confidence</p><p>The strongest executive search firms and Hiring Judgement operators are often doing something very unfashionable.</p><p>They are slowing the process down long enough to ask difficult questions.</p><p>Is this person genuinely operating at executive level?</p><p>Or are we projecting future capability onto current enthusiasm?</p><p>That distinction matters enormously.</p><p>Particularly in founder led companies where optimism and commercial pressure can unintentionally inflate both roles and titles.</p><p>Good executive search should not manufacture executive capability.</p><p>It should identify it.</p><p>And good Hiring Judgement should not simply validate enthusiasm.</p><p>It should pressure test whether the individual can genuinely operate in the complexity, ambiguity and accountability of the role.</p><h3>The Most Common Founder Mistake in Scaling</h3><p>One pattern appears repeatedly in growing companies.</p><p>Founders confuse sales energy with sales leadership.</p><p>They hire someone enthusiastic.<br> Someone articulate.<br> Someone who interviews well.<br> Someone who creates momentum.</p><p>But scaling a commercial engine is very different from creating commercial activity.</p><p>Enterprise growth requires:</p><p>• forecasting discipline<br> • hiring judgement<br> • pipeline mathematics<br> • pricing confidence<br> • operational cadence<br> • customer qualification rigour<br> • executive stakeholder management<br> • repeatability</p><p>The gap between a strong individual contributor and a genuine commercial leader is enormous.</p><p>Yet title inflation in scaling companies is common.</p><p>Particularly when founders are trying to create the appearance of institutional maturity.</p><h3>The Quiet Risk Minority Shareholders Understand</h3><p>Most minority shareholders are not actually worried about the shareholder update itself.</p><p>They are worried about what comes next.</p><p>Capital raises.</p><p>Because once a company begins discussing:</p><p>• institutional investment<br> • accelerated expansion<br> • global growth<br> • scaling infrastructure</p><p>there is usually more capital coming.</p><p>And for minority shareholders, the critical issue is rarely whether new capital is raised.</p><p>The critical issue is:</p><p>At what valuation?<br> On what terms?<br> With what protections?</p><p>That is where value is preserved or destroyed.</p><p>Not in the quarterly update.</p><h3>The Discipline of Staying Calm</h3><p>Experienced operators learn something important.</p><p>Not every concern requires immediate confrontation.</p><p>Sometimes the highest leverage move is observation.</p><p>Watch:</p><p>• customer retention<br> • expansion revenue<br> • repeatability of sales<br> • executive turnover<br> • governance maturity<br> • dependence on founder relationships<br> • quality of hires over time<br> • how management behaves under pressure</p><p>Eventually the operating truth reveals itself.</p><p>The best minority shareholders are rarely the loudest.</p><p>They are:</p><p>• patient<br> • commercially grounded<br> • emotionally controlled<br> • highly observant<br> • selective about when they intervene</p><p>Because in founder led businesses, timing matters.</p><p>A perfectly accurate criticism delivered at the wrong moment can permanently reduce your influence.</p><h3>One Final Observation</h3><p>Some of the most valuable businesses I have seen looked chaotic early.</p><p>And some of the most polished businesses I have seen were effectively PowerPoint companies.</p><p>That is why judgement matters.</p><p>Not cynicism.<br> Not blind optimism.</p><p>Judgement.</p><p>The ability to quietly distinguish between:</p><p>• ambition and capability<br> • narrative and traction<br> • activity and momentum<br> • hiring theatre and leadership depth<br> • temporary immaturity and structural weakness</p><p>For minority shareholders, that discipline is often the difference between compounding value and becoming emotionally entangled in battles they cannot win.</p><p>Sometimes the smartest move is not silence.</p><p>It is strategic patience.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=68c348f657a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are Technology Sales Leaders the Best Sales Leaders in the World?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@edwardmandla/are-technology-sales-leaders-the-best-sales-leaders-in-the-world-5416732eb7e2?source=rss-a5c9935150e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5416732eb7e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startupş]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Edward Mandla]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 May 2026 08:01:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-13T08:01:31.961Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1ytLH7fClDxh9_68kuaW7g.png" /><figcaption>Over the years I’ve watched technology companies import sales discipline into traditional industries, and traditional industries attempt the reverse. The outcomes are rarely symmetrical.</figcaption></figure><h3>Are Technology Sales Leaders the Best Sales Leaders in the World?</h3><p>Technology sales leaders are among the highest paid commercial executives in the market.</p><p>First published on Substack:<br><a href="http://edwardmandla.substack.com/">edwardmandla.substack.com</a></p><p>Their compensation alone suggests the market believes they are different.</p><p>But are they actually better?</p><p>Or have they simply developed inside environments that demand a level of commercial discipline many other industries never require?</p><p>I think that is the more interesting question.</p><h3>The Question Nobody Really Tests</h3><p>There is another part to this discussion that we rarely get to test properly.</p><p>Many non technology or partially technology enabled businesses rarely hire elite technology sales leaders because the salaries feel prohibitive. The founder or board simply cannot justify paying what a top tier technology sales leader expects to earn.</p><p>So the real question is not whether these people can survive outside technology.</p><p>It is this:</p><p>What would happen if a relationship driven, less structured business actually paid up and brought one of these operators in?</p><p>My suspicion is that in the right environment, the impact would be profound.</p><p>Because one thing I consistently see in non technology businesses is this:</p><p>relationships, partnerships, founder reputation, networks and personality get the business to a certain point.</p><p>Revenue exists.<br>The founder is respected.<br>Customers like the business.</p><p>But eventually the model stops scaling.</p><h3>When Founder Led Sales Stops Scaling</h3><p>The sales function slowly drifts into:<br>• daily standups<br>• motivation sessions<br>• “let’s go get them” energy<br>• activity theatre</p><p>But very little discussion around:<br>• deal progression<br>• qualification<br>• forecasting<br>• coaching<br>• why deals stall<br>• how opportunities actually move through the funnel</p><p>The result is familiar:<br>• lumpy quarters<br>• bluebird deals appearing from nowhere<br>• star reps suddenly missing numbers<br>• forecasts built on optimism rather than evidence</p><p>Most importantly, the CFO often cannot clearly explain to investors what the sales engine actually is, or how additional investment will reliably scale it.</p><p>At that point, the business does not really have a scalable sales engine.</p><p>It has momentum.</p><p>And momentum is not the same thing as a system.</p><h3>Technology Sales Leaders Run Systems</h3><p>This is where I think elite technology sales leaders are genuinely different.</p><p>Not because they are smarter.</p><p>Not because they speak better in boardrooms.</p><p>And certainly not because they came from SAP, Oracle, Salesforce or Microsoft.</p><p>They are different because many grew up in environments where:<br>• two bad quarters can end careers<br>• forecasting accuracy matters<br>• CRM discipline matters<br>• pipeline hygiene matters<br>• deal inspection matters<br>• process matters</p><p>In weaker sales cultures, the CRM becomes an administrative burden updated on Friday afternoon.</p><p>In stronger technology businesses, the CRM becomes the operating system of the commercial engine itself.</p><p>Hiring decisions, territory planning, product priorities, forecasting confidence and investor communication all flow from it.</p><p>The best technology sales leaders are not just running sales teams.</p><p>They are running systems.</p><p>And that distinction matters enormously once a business moves beyond founder led growth.</p><h3>Why Non Tech Sales Leaders Often Fail in Technology</h3><p>Interestingly, the reverse experiment has been run many times.</p><p>Sales leaders from outside technology almost always struggle once they enter serious technology sales environments.</p><p>The logic behind hiring them is usually the same:<br>• they are seen as strong relationship operators<br>• they are viewed as “in the field” sales weapons<br>• and importantly, they are cheaper</p><p>But the failure rate is often brutal.</p><p>The problem is not intelligence or effort.</p><p>It is credibility.</p><p>Technology sales teams are used to leaders who inspect deeply, understand deal mechanics, challenge qualification rigorously and know every meaningful detail across the pipeline.</p><p>The moment a leader cannot operate at that level, the sales team knows it almost immediately.</p><p>And once credibility is lost in a serious sales environment, it is extraordinarily difficult to recover.</p><h3>The Real Difference</h3><p>Now, to be fair, not every technology sales leader succeeds outside technology.</p><p>Some struggle badly once founder intuition overrides process, relationships outweigh systems and ambiguity replaces structure.</p><p>And some were never truly elite operators in the first place. They simply learned how to survive inside a highly engineered environment.</p><p>But the best ones bring something many growing businesses desperately need:</p><p>the ability to turn sales from personality driven chaos into something observable, coachable and scalable.</p><p>That is often the difference between a business that grows and a business that can actually scale.</p><p>That is often the difference between a business that grows and a business that can actually scale.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5416732eb7e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>