<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Elisabeth on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Elisabeth on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ejogart?source=rss-d1d10d392afa------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 09:16:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ejogart/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Void, Which Occupies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ejogart/a-void-which-occupies-c251d4aa1d24?source=rss-d1d10d392afa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c251d4aa1d24</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leigh-ledare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lacan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kristeva]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oedipus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Elisabeth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Apr 2019 07:04:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-04T06:07:39.143Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/588/1*_O_fI6KGfA3eUHlhRRp7_g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Leigh Ledare, <em>Mom as Baby Jane</em>, 2005</figcaption></figure><p>Tina Peterson was an aspiring model with a promising career with the Joffrey Ballet in New York City. That was in 1966, the year she was profiled in <em>Seventeen</em> magazine. “To be a good dancer, you must really give yourself to it,” she told <em>Seventeen</em>. “The thrilling, ethereal effects of a performance are very difficult to achieve. But to me, there are so many other important things–nature, friends, reading, painting. I design my own clothes and breed St. Bernard dogs, too. Without all this I would feel incomplete.”</p><p><em>Mom on Top of Boyfriend</em> (2002), <em>Mom Spread with Tiara</em> (2002), and <em>Mom Fingering</em> (2004) are three portraits of Tina Peterson captured by her son, the photographer Leigh Ledare. Following the termination of her father’s funding, Tina Peterson moved back in with her parents in Seattle, which in turn cut short her gig with the Joffrey. An unexpected pregnancy cemented the raw deal. To make ends meet, she turned to stripping and sex work. Peterson plays a leading role in Ledare’s series of photographs, <em>Pretend You’re Actually Alive</em>. As their titles suggest, the photographs portray Peterson engaged in a patchwork of erotic acts. She mainly appears in these photographs naked, spread, or in the act, although the series also includes non-sexual portraits of Peterson as well as photographs of her partners and of Ledare’s wife, brother, and grandmother, and Ledare himself.</p><p><em>Mom Spread with Red Heels</em>, a 2003 portrait included in <em>Pretend You’re Actually Alive</em>, is the very essence of fantasy. In it, Peterson is pictured sitting atop a bed, her straightened arms propping up her torso. Her knees are bent and spread, the points of her stiletto heels touching, her hairless genitalia exposed. True to the title, she wears red high-heeled shoes as well as an embellished diamond necklace: her sole accessories.</p><p>In content, the fantasy is carnal: the red shoes, the jewelry, the full-frontal nudity serving as erotic clichés. These fetishistic objects juxtapose with startling flagrancy the all-too-real personal effects of Peterson’s home: telephone with twisted cord, plastic filing drawers, and Chinese-style jade lamp, all visible in soft focus in the background. A rustic white quilt, the quintessence of domestic comfort, is spread over the bed on top of which Tina’s legs, too, are spread. Sexual, perverse, uncanny, such sprinklings of personal and domestic detail are spun into a psychological fantasy, like a David Lynch film still.</p><p>The lighting furthers this effect. Frontally lit, the subject casts a harsh shadow as the strong, artificial light overelaborates what is impossible to miss. The figure’s skin meanwhile gleams with a magenta cast. Most disconcerting of all is the way Tina directs her stare into the lens with off-putting severity, which sears straight into the viewer’s gaze.</p><blockquote>“Maybe the most Freudian thing of all is our obsession with incestuous slippage”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/637/1*ILhWaZoFF3PJ21keTxccAg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Leigh Ledare, <em>Mom’s Profile in 17 Magazine</em>, 1966</figcaption></figure><p>It is easy to read the series as Oedipal, and glaringly so, but people also delight in the Freudian and seize on any opportunity to spot such slippages. Perhaps the Freudian overtones in Ledare’s photographs in fact confront a culture with its own collective thirst. We devour the Oedipal, which recurs in countless films, works of art, and tabloid newspapers. Ashton Kutcher weds Demi Moore, a woman sixteen years his senior; Benjamin Braddock enters a fraught affair with Mrs. Robinson, his love interest’s mother; Marty McFly must evade advances from his own pre-maternal mom; Norman Bates serially hacks up young, beautiful surrogates for his dead mother, whose skeleton he preserves and keeps company; and men and women at large are said to choose partners like their parents. But to what extent are these themes incorrigibly constitutive of the human psyche, and at what point do we promulgate them into existence? In its bounty, the Oedipal has become a cliché. Maybe, after all, the most Freudian thing of all is our obsession with incestuous slippage.</p><p>Although Ledare’s work makes merry in the Oedipal, it gets off on the abject. While it may most immediately be read as sensationalist, seeing it through such a lens ignores the more complicated themes that operate far below its erotic facade. Julia Kristeva identified the “abject” as anything which transgresses norms and upsets propriety. The abject is something “radically separate, loathsome;” it is “the in-between, the ambiguous, the composite,” “a weight of meaninglessness, about which there is nothing insignificant, and which crushes me.” In Ledare’s work is found a bounty of eroded boundaries. He excavates the ruins by way of the actual bodies and alleged sites of the Oedipal complex, supposed to be universal, that is, by way of mothers and maternal surrogates. Through this literal staging of Oedipal loss, Ledare stages a much more elusive scene: the ultimate emptiness that attends such an attempt to recapture the primordial site of desire, which eludes the here-and-now.</p><blockquote>Although Ledare’s work makes merry in the Oedipal, it gets off on the abject.</blockquote><p>A key to Ledare’s tableaux might be found in Jacques Lacan’s theory of registers. Lacan proposes a schematic of human experience composed of three orders: the Imaginary, the Symbolic, and the Real. Each interact in an ecology of mutual dependence. The Imaginary, our conscious experience, is how we appear to ourselves, who others appear to be in our minds, what things mean to us. The Symbolic is the realm of structures. Encompassing institutions, customs, language, and orders, the Symbolic is our main interface with society and the one which most influences us from the day we are born. Finally, the Real is by definition elusive, but is also elusively defined. In his initial formulation, Lacan describes the Real as that which lies beyond the limited pale of perception, “an absolute fullness, a pure plenum devoid of the negativities of absences, antagonisms, gaps, lacks, splits, etc.” In later formulations, though, Lacan devises the Real in more-or-less dialectical terms as a “convergence of opposites.” Applied to the Oedipal family structure, the mother belongs to such a dialectical space. The infant’s source of all provision and love, she is both omnipotent and obscure, at once too distant and too cloying.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*eE6FOue-oWTrWR6d5ogAIQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Leigh Ledare, <em>Mom Spread with Tiara</em>, 2001</figcaption></figure><p>Its selfhood bound up with that of its mother, the infant must cast its mother away in order to achieve autonomy. The “pushing away” required for autonomy is foundational to Kristeva’s notion of the abject, which she compares to milk skin:</p><blockquote>When the eyes see or the lips touch that skin on the surface of milk–harmless, thin as a sheet of cigarette paper, pitiful as a nail paring–I experience a gagging sensation and, still farther down, spasms in the stomach, the belly; and all the organs shrivel up the body, provoke tears and bile, increase heartbeat, cause forehead and hands to perspire. Along with sight-clouding dizziness, <em>nausea</em> makes me balk at that milk cream, separates me from the mother and father who proffer it. “I” want none of that element, sign of their desire; “I” do not want to listen, “I” do not assimilate it, “I” expel it. But since the food is not an “other” for “me,” who am only in their desire, I expel <em>myself</em>, I spit <em>myself</em> out, I abject <em>myself</em> within the same motion through which “I” claim to establish <em>myself</em>.</blockquote><p>Wanting to jettison any and all identification with such repellant and smothering love, the infant pushes herself away. In so doing she begins to ingratiate herself in the realm of structures, onto which she latches her identity instead. Her alterity cemented, the mother becomes the site of first loss.</p><p>The Mother is the ground zero of desire. In Lacanian terms, the subject attempts to recapture this “more-than-empirical,” prototypical object with a substitute in the present, the erotic object. A fissure appears between the original, chimerical lost object and the available, empirical stand-in, and herein lies Ledare’s most vital theme. Like Kristeva’s milk skin, the superficial layer of Ledare’s project produces repulsion, the roots of which delve much farther below their surface.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PqJAMwwDfUKSf_ECZlGMQA.png" /><figcaption>Leigh Ledare, <em>Mom Spread with Red Heels</em>, 2003</figcaption></figure><p>The layers at work in <em>Pretend You’re Actually Alive </em>do not so much consist of a number of symbols as they do of a single symbol playing a medley of conflicting roles. To start, the series includes real mothers and symbolic mothers. As Elena Filipovic put it in her essay “The Mother of Photography,” “The denominator ‘Mom,’ makes her both universal and particular. She is the photographer’s mother, yes, but ‘Mom’ is also a stand-in for the category of motherhood in itself.” The mother, as we have established, is the lost object, but not in the sense that she is literally absent. Instead the mother is the symbol of loss attending independence and adulthood. Ledare’s mother, the main subject of <em>Pretend You’re Actually Alive</em>, is a real mother–<em>his</em> real mother. As such, she operates as a sort of symbol-within-a-symbol: the Imaginary, the Symbolic, and the Real.</p><p>And then there are fictional mothers. Just as the original Oedipus, the tragic hero who kills his father and marries his mother, is a character in a fictional staging of filial incest and rage, so too is Tina Peterson a character in a staging of a mother-son relationship. Finding herself before a device ostensibly used to capture, document, and expose, expose she does, even as she conceals, performing to audience and photographer alike. As Ledare sees it, these portraits served as a creative outlet for her as much as him. “As a fantasy space it also allowed her a context to fictionalize her life. There’s a kind of masochistic theater in how she performed herself and the negation of the narrow social expectations placed on her.” In a tangled role play through which she undermines the social mores she is presumed beholden to, Peterson enacts her own fantasy as a performer and an artist.</p><p>Crucially, Ledare’s work enacts and distorts social performances of the sort we take part in every day. As such, Tina Peterson’s performance should not be thought of strictly in theatrical terms. As Filipovic observes, “The ‘Mom’ in these images appears sexualized, desirable, available, needy, a victim–and it is first and foremost to her son that she enacts these roles.” The scenarios Ledare photographs do not just communicate to the audience; more principally, a communion between parties takes place and is channeled through a voyeuristic arena. Peterson avails herself of her sexuality–her sole remaining artistic medium–in order to, in Ledare’s words, “shield herself from the fact that she’s aging, to seek affirmation from me and my brother, out of a total sense of play as well, and also as a means of flipping back on my grandfather, and on society at large, the issues around how she should behave and what her propriety should be as a mother and a daughter.” The photograph is just another method of conveying herself to her kids, to her father–her own Electra object–and to herself.</p><p>Consider for a moment Ledare’s larger body of work. He is, at times, an art patron of sorts, but one who is concerned with manufacturing encounters. His 2008 project <em>Personal Commissions </em>involves classified ads resembling those his mother was known to place. In a reversal of the usual photographer-subject dynamic, Ledare responded to these ads, behaving as an object for women to dress or undress, arrange, and photograph as they saw fit. Discussing this series with Ledare in an interview, the writer Chris Kraus pointed out that “these women expose themselves more nakedly through their aesthetic choices than they would if you’d performed as expected.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*CtL4-tEAFDj5HFYg7A04iw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Leigh Ledare, <em>Double Bind (Meghan Ledare-Fedderly Photographed by Adam Fedderly)</em>, 2010</figcaption></figure><p>Another such project is <em>Double Bind</em> (2010/2012), a photographic and collage installation centered on Ledare’s recently remarried ex-wife, Meghan Ledare-Fedderly. According to the provisions established, Ledare and Meghan travelled together to a remote cabin where they stayed for four days, during which time Ledare photographed her. The project was then repeated with Meghan’s new husband, Adam Fedderly, assuming the role of photographer.</p><p><em>Double Bind</em> does not so much explore affect as it explores authorship. Exhibited with black or white mats to delineate Ledare’s portraits from those taken by Fedderly, the question of <em>whose</em> gaze is clearly key. Ledare said of Fedderly’s photographs of Meghan, which stand in contrast to his own, “They present a permission to look, at the same time that his looking defines my position as a lack of possession or access.” Like a set of visual correspondences, such implicit delineations capture the back and forth of personal entanglements, which extend beyond a simple subject-object exchange. Legal contracts, documents, and written exchanges serve as framing devices for these staged encounters. The effect of such agreements is not so much to document performance as it is to underscore other sorts of implicit contracts that abound in society at large.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/1*Oe4rDk3CH6oIz1AEXBL-bA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Leigh Ledare, <em>Double Bind (Meghan Ledare-Fedderly Photographed by Leigh Ledare)</em>, 2010</figcaption></figure><p>Considered as a whole, Ledare’s body of work reveals social performance as communication and as communion. The subjects do not just reveal themselves, they reveal themselves <em>in</em> <em>relation to one another</em>: to an audience, to Ledare. What his subjects expose when they expose themselves before and through the camera—which Ledare describes as “a surrogate” that “records and transmits information”—is how they in turn see Ledare, how they want to be seen by him, and how they want the world to see them.</p><blockquote>“The image breaks down the viewer’s “me,” which presumes itself independent of the relations being played out before her, when in fact she is intimately bound up in the performance.”</blockquote><p>And yet, in the end, what is communicated is the spectator’s own subjectivity. Concerning the portraits of his mother in <em>Pretend You’re Actually Alive</em>, Ledare notes a tendency for the audience to get swept away in his vérité techniques, which viewers readily accept as truth-telling. Instead, these works contend with “the photographic image’s claims to documentary truth, capturing instead the way authenticity, or reality, like identity, is itself a construction.” The viewer, who inevitably injects her own inherited worldview into the scene, enters the arena of performance. Thus implicating the audience, the image breaks down the viewer’s “me,” which presumes itself independent of the relations being played out before her, when in fact she is intimately bound up in the performance. On a stage that willfully conflates the Symbolic with the Imaginary, cultural taboos, according to Ledare, “[call] the authority of our frameworks into question.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*Reg4G-bV90R9Ci2QjZ7tCw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Leigh Ledare, <em>Mom in New Home</em>, 2007</figcaption></figure><p>Ledare’s photographs are rife with mothers, surrogates, subjects, and objects, all of whom are alchemized into symbols pointing back to a single origin of acquisition and loss. The question of who is subject and who is object—“who is exploiting whom?” as Kraus puts it—is central to the work, although not in the sense that these relations become untangled. Julia Kristeva notes a tendency in art to purify the abject, which is “above all ambiguity,” through reductive attempts at pinpointing the elusive, at un-problematizing the problematic. Ledare’s work, by contrast, cannibalizes his personal relationships, spitting back at us a picture of our anxious, erotic, and precarious social roles that are every bit as troubled as the Oedipal symbols we crave.</p><p>Symbols exist at a remove from what they attempt to communicate. For Kristeva, they are born out of an attempt to recapture what’s been lost, but symbols could be said to actually precede loss, as actually generating it. Said another way, a label creates a fissure between name and named. Ledare grapples with such a fissure, but like the abject it is ungraspable. As the possibility of symbolizing the Real becomes ever more remote, the very question of the Real begins to break down. <em>What </em>the symbol displaces becomes irrelevant as increasingly it seems that perhaps symbols are all there is, and the Real dissolves into just another fantasy.</p><p>Ledare’s project proposes a <em>void-as-thing</em>. “What’s made visible is always a facade,” he explains, “a kind of screen to project onto. … Any given image is underwritten by an ecology: by structures, interrelations, and circumstances.” Believing in the advantages of full-disclosure, Ledare further argues that such “insistence on the subjective and its affects — sexuality, confusion, shame, guilt, attraction, all this and more — problematizes our tendencies to dissimulate.” Ledare’s work strips away superficial defenses. More through excess than negation, the surfeit and extremity build like milk-film until surface is all that is left. The vacancy that remains is not truly empty; rather, it is pregnant with significance. As Kristeva stresses, the abject is a nothingness, “but not nothing, either<em>.</em>” In such a way, Ledare’s is a void, which <em>occupies</em>.</p><p><strong>Works Cited</strong></p><p>Filipovic, Elena, et al. <em>Leigh Ledare, et al.</em> Brussels: WIELS Contemporary Art Centre, 2012. Print.</p><p>Johnston, Adrian. “Jacques Lacan.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Stanford University. 02 Apr. 2013. Web. 10 Dec. 2016.</p><p>Kristeva, Julia. <em>Black Sun: Depression and Melancholia.</em> New York: Columbia UP, 1989. Print.</p><p>Kristeva, Julia. <em>Powers of Horror: An Essay on Abjection</em>. Trans. Leon S. Roudiez. New York: Columbia UP, 1982. Print.</p><p>“Leigh Ledare.” Interview by Chris Kraus. BOMB Magazine. BOMB Magazine, Summer 2015. Web. 5 Dec. 2016.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c251d4aa1d24" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Meyerowitz Stories,” Selected but Not New]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ejogart/meyerowitz-stories-selected-but-not-new-359256f8d592?source=rss-d1d10d392afa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/359256f8d592</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[noah-baumbach]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Elisabeth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jan 2018 21:43:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-06T01:37:47.261Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*RoQJ-9paA4jvlxo57HPdXg.png" /></figure><p>Noah Baumbach is a lone wolf when it comes to carrying on the tradition of cinematic New York à la Woody Allen, and that includes the comedy auteur himself.</p><p>Speaking of carrying on, his characters do a great deal of it: Much like his breakthrough feature, <em>The Squid and the Whale,</em> Baumbach’s latest film, <em>The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected),</em> chronicles an egomaniacal father and his thoroughly maladjusted kids, now adults. The film’s title, at least at the surface, alludes to the métier of the Meyerowitz family’s recalcitrant artist-patriarch, Harold, played by Dustin Hoffman, whose legacy looms large. The plot revolves loosely around the prospect of a group show at Bard College, where Harold once taught, the initially “insulting” opportunity becoming, as the film progresses, laden with promise.</p><p>Title cards structure the film into character segments beginning with “Danny,” Harold’s eldest son, capably played by Adam Sandler. Harold spends much of the film belittling his kind-hearted “house-dad” son, who has yet to stand on his feet following a recent separation. At his best, Harold meets his children’s attentiveness with disregard. More often, though, he treats them with mild disdain. Harold’s daughter, Jean (Elizabeth Marvel), a project manager at Xerox, has the presence of a footnote as she patiently awaits notice despite being routinely skimmed over. The neglect Harold shows Danny and Jean is matched with equal parts pride and indignation for his conspicuously absent younger son, Matthew (Ben Stiller), a bigwig celebrity financial manager living in Los Angeles whose failure to follow in his father’s footsteps is an acute point of contention.</p><p>Harold’s behavior is atrocious, but also pitiable. His public esteem fallen by the wayside, he is unable to conceal his perverse envy of better careers, a peevish hubris that forms the central through line of his narrative. He bitterly diminishes one of his oldest friends and contemporaries as “a talented, pretentious enigma.” But it is clearly Harold who is inclined to pretentiousness. Barely a sentence escapes his lips which does not label something a “minor work” or someone a “minor artist.” This pet word betrays his own entirely human fear of being not just a minor artist but a minor <em>person</em>.</p><p>As the film’s parenthetical title suggests, personal stories are pruned for showmanship. It speaks, too, to the beds people make for themselves, the only way some even know how to sleep at all. Times change, kids grow old, relationships new (and selected) dissolve, and the film’s characters (and we as viewers) are left to deal with the present through reinventions of the past. Though, of course, there is no escaping it. Where Danny exhibits their father’s angry outbursts, Matthew appears to have inherited his egocentrism. But when Harold falls critically ill mere days before his group show, his children momentarily check — or rather redistribute — their egos as they rally around their father. Here, the siblings’ until-now isolated flaws meld into a symphonic trio of maladjusted borderline personalities so grandiose as to almost do their chronically disappointed, raging-narcissist father proud.</p><p>If the family’s signature revisionism were a wholly healthy coping strategy, the film could not claim to carry the banner of New York Jewish neuroticism, a style which manifests as much through its characters and dialogue as through its artistic decisions. It’s no searing insight to mention that Baumbach’s films can be aesthetically nostalgic. This isn’t a bad thing necessarily, though creative details from film grain and costuming straight down to the Randy Newman score did cause minor distraction fifteen minutes in as I paused to wonder, “Wait, is this a period piece?” (It’s not). And while the cinematic homage does attempt, at times, to subordinate itself to true human emotion, when emotion finally does arrive it has been contaminated by farce and vitriol.</p><p>Even if Baumbach does tend to ambiguously evoke the early 1980s, a better age for cinema and the Big Apple both, it seems altogether separate from the question of au courant thematics. Harmless though the director’s stylistic proclivities may be, I take issue with the film’s egregious throwing-back to the threadbare subject of male-centric crisis. It seems too obvious to need stating — for women it certainly is; nevertheless, it is high time we view male, existential torment through the rebranded lens it deserves, what I dub “<em>sexist</em>entialism.”</p><p>Take Jean: An ostensible main character, she provides little more than comic relief as a middle-aged loser. This, despite the attention lavished onto Danny’s and Matthew’s relationship, which devours the narrative’s bulk. By the time we find out Jean is not so clueless as we’d been led to believe, the film is nearly over. In a humanizing scene, she divulges to her brothers an incident involving their father’s long-time friend in which he exposed himself to a then-teenage Jean. The scene, which lasts less than five minutes, comes off as little more than character padding. Moreover, instead of furthering Jean’s own plot line, it just propels that of her brothers. Taking Jean’s trauma as an excuse to smash in the car of their father’s friend, now in his 80s, the brothers mistake their testosterone outburst as admirable vindication for the violence that had been imposed on their sister so, so many years before; in the process, they efface another’s trauma.</p><p>On top of the played-out theme of male struggle, perhaps it is the film’s reliance on its leading men’s celebrities that feels tired. Ben Stiller, an actor I have long been fond of, here feels stilted and weary of his own jig. Granted, no one plays uptight better, but he does so without his usual brio. Adam Sandler’s performance, on the other hand, has been the subject of much buzz, and this is owing to how, rather than shying away from his comedic infamy, he gives it a gracious nod. He largely carries the tenderized meat show with his signature “sensitive guy with anger issues.” But while it’s easy to deride Sandler, it is just as facile to marvel at his occasional displays of ability as if we’d never been graced with his decent-enough chops in films like <em>Punch Drunk Love</em>, <em>Funny People</em>, and even the fun-loving rom-com <em>The Wedding Singer</em>. In <em>Meyerowitz</em>, these old “Sandlerisms” feel surprisingly genuine. That being said, trying to separate this performance from the kind of adolescent buffoonery he popularized was not an altogether seamless experience.</p><p>By comparison, Harold’s checked-out, alcoholic fourth wife, Maureen, delightfully played by Emma Thompson, remarkably adds a spring to the step of an otherwise caustic family drama. Between drunken foibles like radically undercooking seafood to “crashing” the car into a tree at a sluggish pace, Maureen’s closet drinking should not so easily deceive her equally oblivious counterpart, but alas. Thompson pulls off an alchemy of hyperbole and restraint that allows her character to fade in and out of the background like a welcome refrain. Even leaving me wanting more, her incidental presence is forgivable considering the law of diminishing returns that one could apply to her rank among Harold’s string of current and former spouses. Given Maureen’s treatment, we might go so far as to read so blatant a staging of the “invisible older woman” trope as a wry dig at chauvinism. But to repeat it with Jean, a would-be main character in a film allegedly structured around a man’s three children, is more than unjustified: it is absurd. If only a <em>half</em> sibling — as Matthew likes to point out of her and Danny — Jean is, after all, as much a half-sibling as either of her brothers.</p><p>It is especially disheartening to see the trope repeated here so lazily given the rare opportunity of a family saga to articulate the plight of an overlooked female character. Indeed, Elizabeth Marvel shines in the role, no thanks to the script. To be clear, it is one thing to portray the social invisibility of such a woman; it is quite another to reiterate her invisibility using the filmic form as a tool.</p><p>As far as serious female characters go, the film puts its eggs in the basket of Danny’s video-artist daughter, Eliza (Grace Van Patten), who unexpectedly emerges as the hopeful bastion of her grandfather’s legacy. An entering film student at Bard with avant-garde proclivities, Eliza is starry-eyed, ambitious, and real. Her seriousness, though, is undermined by the film’s attention to her sex appeal, dedicating much of her screen time to cutaways of her feminist films, which, funny as they are, are played to brazenly sexed effect. At the end of the day, this is still a film about Men.</p><p>There is a tender moment near the end when the pressures of greatness foisted on young men are finally considered. By this time, though, Baumbach has traded the honesty of early scenes for juvenile routines more forgivable during his directorial immaturity. The low-simmering drama we see in the first third succumbs to slapstick as Baumbach dials up the spectacle of dysfunction. While such antics make for a fun watch, trying to walk it backward from screwball is ill advised. While I can appreciate the attempts at heart, they feel misguided alongside the rollicking scenes surrounding them, akin to re-reading “eloquent” passages from your seventh-grade journal, years later. Want as you might to sympathize, you’re mostly just embarrassed. Ultimately this film lacks the heightened honesty of Baumbach’s earlier endeavors <em>Frances Ha </em>and <em>Mistress America</em>. On further glance, more credit may be due to those films’ co-writer and starring actor, Baumbach’s partner Greta Gerwig. <em>Meyerowitz</em> makes valiant stabs at human emotion and manages to entertain in the process, and that’s why we watch. But the film’s unforgivable flaw is rooted, paradoxically, in its strengths: Its constant trivialities are all the more insulting alongside brief flashes of poignancy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=359256f8d592" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>