<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Elaine Freedgood on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Elaine Freedgood on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@elainefreedgood?source=rss-73d799f156c9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 18:08:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@elainefreedgood/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Elaine Freedgoo]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@elainefreedgood/elaine-freedgoo-104e3fe748a0?source=rss-73d799f156c9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/104e3fe748a0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lung-cancer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grief]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Elaine Freedgood]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 May 2020 19:18:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-28T19:18:36.805Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Elaine Freedgood</p><p>Ef38@nyu.edu</p><h3>On Not Fighting Lung Cancer</h3><p><strong>1.</strong> <strong>Wings</strong></p><p>I am in a Facebook lung cancer support group with 9700 or so members and none of us ever die. We “gain our wings.” We “transition.” We become “angels.” This is what scholars call an “imperative estrangement” from death; a sense that we can indeed “<em>choose</em> to live.”<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> Just at the moment when a good hard look at death might be in order, we are told to look away and “be positive.” Even thinking about death may bring it closer. But I’ve been thinking a lot about death for over two years now and it doesn’t seem to be responding to my attention. Which is fine. But also exhausting and stressful: I can’t sleep, take too much stuff to sleep, cannot wake up.</p><p>Occasionally skirmishes break out in the Facebook group because someone says that they never smoked, and yet they are stage IV (and sometimes they are also 25 or 30 years old). The old smokers get cantankerous: “if you have lungs, you can get cancer” they like to say. But I too would be very shocked to have gotten lung cancer without doing what I thought was the requisite amount of smoking. And I did do that amount of smoking, while I was working on a cancer unit as a nurse. And I don’t blame myself: it probably would have been heroin if not nicotine, and I never would have finished night school. Cigarettes kept me awake, comforted me, they were a way of life. There are almost no pictures of me in my twenties without a pack of Newports at hand, or an individual one in hand or mouth.</p><p>II.<strong> Numb</strong></p><p>Advertising and news articles (which are often indistinguishable when it comes to cancer — indeed ads are much more informative in many cases since the list of side effects is required to be complete) suggest that great advances are being made. You will hear this from all kinds of people: colleagues who specialize in eighteenth-century British literature, your super, your endodontist, your partner’s friend’s cousin who had a totally different kind of cancer than you have, and of course your oncologist. Chemo is so much better, they say. Except it really isn’t. They just load you up with steroids so you have the side effects from them (water retention, skyrocketing blood sugar, and often psychosis, including hallucinations, aggression, and despair), in place of some of the side effects of chemo. Your life sucks. You get neuropathy so that your hands and feet feel numb or like they are on fire, your ears ring, you get confused, you sleep a lot, and food tastes bad so you start to waste although not in my particular case, I might add, but I refused chemo. I concede that nausea medicines have gotten better and in a lot of states you can get marijuana legally. But you still puke. I puked without being on any chemo at all. And my hair falls out apace. Perhaps I am doing chemo in my dreams.</p><p><strong>3.</strong> <strong>Images</strong></p><p>We live scan to scan: this thing shrunk a lot, this thing shrunk a little, this other nodule might have grown a bit and it’s not even clear that shrinking tumors are a positive prognostic indicator (see the vast medical literature that, cancer by cancer, investigates shrinkage and prognosis: this alone suggests that there is no necessary correlation). Indeed, “shrinkage” might be part of the current ideology of cancer, a scrim of false consciousness which is yet another spur to the patient to stay positive, endure any amount of pain, nausea, home foreclosure, bankruptcy and fear. We are taught to rejoice at possibly spurious indicators, like a millimeter or two of shrinkage, and then we die anyway.</p><p>People tell me I look good, I look fine, someone jokes that this is all a hoax. It is, but not the way they think it is. The hoax is that we love science, we imagine precision, we worship quantification and then we find out these things don’t exist the way we thought they did. CT scans and MRI’s are interpreted, not unlike poems and paintings. My neurosurgeon complains about neuroradiologists: “they never see an actual brain, just pictures of the brain.” Re-presentation. This thing that’s flagged on my MRI — “that’s a vein,” the neurosurgeon says, annoyed. I hope he’s right.</p><p><strong>4.</strong> <strong>True Crime</strong></p><p>Choosing not to fight is hard because everyone wants you to be a fighter, a warrior, a hero. You, on the other hand, just want to lie down and watch tv or listen to true crime podcasts that suggest you are still in a relation, however mediated, to reality. You are hearing people dying on recorded 911 calls, you wait with them for the police, ambulance, fire department or god as you wait for cancer to return or stay “quiet.” This recording in your ear is one of the places you can really be with the dying and 911 calls weirdly mirror your own experience: help, you say. What is your address, they say. I’m dying, you say. Please spell your last name, they say. And this is real. People are always asking you about the spelling of your name, your date of birth, the reason you are having an MRI of the brain today? Lung cancer with mets to the brain, I say. (I think: this can’t be me).</p><p>You don’t or can’t know your own reality. There are statistics and prognostics and yet none of it actually applies to a given individual.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> Why were statistics and individuals invented at the same time then? Nothing applies to you individually but when the five year survival rate for your cancer is less than 4% it’s hard not to take it personally. Although, in the sleight-of-hand statistical maneuvering that seems to always accompany “responsible” discussions of cancer, survival for stage 4 lung cancer patients has risen 400%! From 1% to 4%. The switcheroo from numbers, to percentages (often we don’t learn what the percentage is <em>of</em>) make your head spin. 47% of patients did well: how many patients were there? How well? The numbers and the language are fuzzy enough to feel really good, until you squint and see the endless spin of (mostly) fake progress.</p><p><strong>5.</strong> <strong>The Wealth of Nations</strong></p><p>When you don’t “fight” you cause not only disappointment in your immediate circle, you are also letting down capitalism itself: cancer is a 3.5 billion dollar industry. The national economy might well collapse if everyone abstained from chemotherapy, immunotherapy, radiotherapy and so on. My lung oncologist wears Gucci loafers and Paul Smith socks. He bought Gucci slippers for his son who wears them to play basketball. He brags about his wife’s shopping at the annual Paris sales. He sends her flowers every week, but she complains that the card always has the same message. What does this woman want? To be treated like an individual? She is a statistic, after all, a second wife whom I imagine is much younger than her husband, much cuter than her husband, and whom he can support in style because of lung cancer.</p><p><strong>6.</strong> <strong>Tin Mining</strong></p><p>There is confusion about treatment. There is confusion about survival. There is just a huge amount of confusion. And it becomes yours. And you live with it and live with it, anxiety always buzzing in the background like the first hint of an oncoming train that is going to flatten you, but that may at the moment be idling in a station in California, New Jersey or somewhere in between. I wrote a poem to demonstrate this confusion, and the potpourri of anxiety that develops around it. The following are all “topics” listed under articles that contain the key words “lung cancer”:</p><p>Topics, An Explanatory Poem with Intentional Repetition</p><p>Men, cigarette smoking, asthma</p><p>Siblings, women, palliative care</p><p>Radiotherapy, radon, compost</p><p>Bronchii, urban areas, lungs</p><p>White people, pipe smoking, underestimations</p><p>Chemotherapy, clinical trials, men</p><p>Mortality rates, second hand smoke, cigar smoking</p><p>Air pollutants, sputum, cigarettes</p><p>Emphysema, pneumonia, sputum</p><p>Cytology, asbestos, petroleum coke</p><p>Coal, snuff, mica</p><p>Asbestos, conifers, carpentry</p><p>Anthracite, shipyards, lungs</p><p>Women, metropolitan areas, prophets</p><p>Copper, autopsies, granite</p><p>Career risk, tin mining, meats</p><p>Histology, workplaces, men</p><p>Mining, canyons, beer</p><p>Arsenic, diesel exhaust, cancer vaccines</p><p>Alcohol drinking, Lutheranism, vitamin A.</p><p>The meaning of this poem brought to you by its author: there are a number of things associated with lung cancer and there are certain groups of people who are attended to with more frequency (men, white people). No one is sure of the significance of anything, so watch your conifers and try not to be a tin miner. Are canyons more dangerous than urban areas? Does beer have anything to do with anything? I have some in the fridge. I have never been a carpenter or a Lutheran. I did smoke cigarettes, as I’ve already noted.</p><p><strong>7.</strong> <strong>Burgers</strong></p><p>The worst part is the idea of leaving people who have loved you. You wish you could give them a refund on their investment in you: you won’t be around for their first kid’s birth or their graduation from college or their first book, or their death. You’re in the cat seat, whatever that means — you realize the leaving is the easiest part. And you also leave before you leave: you sleep more and more. I promised my partner of 32 years, in a birthday card some years ago, that I would outlive her. I wonder if maybe I still can: she’s almost 70; if I could last another year or two maybe she’ll have a heart attack or…I don’t know what else to write as a cause of death that would be bearable. I only want her to die before me, and painlessly. (She loves McDonald’s: maybe we should go there regularly?) I’d bear it if it meant I would be alone instead of her being alone because I don’t want her to be alone. I don’t want to be alone, but I’m so much better at watching t.v. and just not really caring about things that she feels must be fixed, painted, polished, and replaced. She has this faith in life “working” in some register that I just don’t have. I could sit here by myself and watch the apartment and myself fall apart. I could take all the drugs I’ve accumulated and see what happens. Once you have stage 4 lung cancer, the world comes alive with options. Not the ones you’ve cherished all your life, the ones that have to do with futurity, but the ones that have to do with ending.</p><p>Someone wrote on the FB cancer group page: “The hardest thing I do every day is take a shower. I’m not going to take any more.” I think this man’s time must be very short for that to be an option. But I guess if he lives alone, doesn’t go anywhere or see anyone, maybe he could live that way for a while? There are a lot of people out there doing this entirely alone. This dying, this living as a dying person.</p><p><strong>8.</strong> <strong>Failure to Die</strong></p><p>To what emotional planet do you flee when you don’t want to be a “good” patient, when you don’t want to partake of optimism and compliance and heroism? How to think about yourself: I am not a fighter, I am not kicking cancer’s ass, I don’t feel too bad, I’m grateful for my life, I can’t breathe well enough to run, my appetite is all too excellent. It’s almost spring and I’m still here, my first expiration date was months ago (my oncologist said one year and then added, after a long pause, maybe two). He was pissed that I had refused chemo, I think. Prognostic punishment? But what would my prognosis be with chemo? Almost exactly the same. Maybe two, he added, and now I am in the third year of this. I asked for a new prognosis and he said that if I have no recurrence by January (the two year mark), I have a 70% chance of living out my normal life span, with a very high risk of a second lung cancer. So first, what is my “normal” life span now that I’ve had 20 Ct scans and MRIs, most of them with radioactive dye, 2 PET scans with radioactive glucose, a shot of radiation to the brain, a lobe of my lung removed, and stress that is impossible to quantify? I wake up sometimes with a dread that leaves me feeling sick, with my heart pounding, and a sense that something really terrible is about to happen. I don’t consciously feel afraid of death. I have a friend who had breast cancer 7 years ago (so she <em>has</em> breast cancer: solid tumors don’t move into the past tense) and she tells me over and over again when she sees me that she is not afraid of death. It seems weird that she needs to repeat it so much. It makes me nervous when she does; not about death but about all the fucking repetition involved in this disease. The scans, the scares, the comments, the questions, the failures of knowing that attend every decision. Ok, yes, everyone is dying, people like to say to me (I hate this phrase more than any other), but they don’t have a prognosis. A prognosis is different than mortality. The clock is ticking. You hear it in everything: in ideas about next summer or winter, about what whether you will be able to travel in December or in February. Mortality is any time; a prognosis is also fuzzy but has a definition as in an outline or a shape. Or as Lochlann Jain has written, in a book about breast cancer, “Prognostic time demands that we adopt its viewpoint, one in which the conclusion haunts the story itself.”<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> I’m 62. I won’t die young, just sooner than I thought. But of course, I never really had an age at which I thought I’d die. I almost died violently at 21, but that’s another story.</p><p><strong>9.</strong> <strong>Failures</strong></p><p>I just read a post on my cancer listserv from a young woman in Bangladesh whose family is bankrupting itself to get her mother treatment: first in India and then in Singapore. The mother sounds end-stage; I suggest gently in the comments section that maybe treatment is no longer worthwhile. The daughter replies that she would feel like she was killing her mother with her own hands, although she admits, poignantly, that the disease is “metastasizing” to the whole family: jobs, education and money are all going down the tubes fast. The entire family is dying of lung cancer. We kill people with our disease: this happens all the time — to caretakers who give more than they have, who bankrupt themselves, who die of heart attacks and strokes from the stress of caretaking (my partner developed broken heart syndrome), who get cancer themselves and have no one to help them.</p><p>We are all in a giant clinical trial that is incredibly poorly organized. Where am I going to land in the statistics? In studies, there is rarely a category for people who refuse treatment (although we are useful for tracing what’s called the “natural history” of the disease). Some people “fail” treatment — it never fails you — and they get knocked out of trials. If I had had chemo or immunotherapy everyone would attribute my current pretty good health to those things. I did have a big shot of radiation to the brain. So I read everything with a grain of uranium. It feels like I might have some sawdust in there where that spot on my brain was, although the neurosurgeon says “stereotactic” radiation has no cognitive effect. But the other day I didn’t recognize my jacket on the back of a chair and it filled me, unreasonably, with terror. First, I was afraid I had taken someone else’s jacket at some point during the day. Then I was just afraid that my own (pretty old) clothing had become estranged from me. My scalp still hurts more than two years later: from the radiation, or the pins that held the giant metal thing in place, the metal thing that clips into a slot on the stretcher so that your head doesn’t move at all during the MRI and radiation. And I sleep at least 12 hours a day.</p><p>According to Margaret Shildrick, what makes the term neoliberalism “fizz with significance is the way in which specific traits of neoliberal capital are invested — and successfully so — in recuperating profit even in the face of inexorable deterioration.” We are encouraged to spend all kinds of money and time on “personal strategies of body management.”<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a> It’s all up to you, finally: medicine doesn’t have a clue so try anything or everything: drink green tea, have a shot of wheat grass, eat this thing or that, or don’t eat this thing or that. Or get in on travel cures and go to a country where something is legal that some people swear by: there’s a lung cancer vaccine in Cuba; you can get a lung transplant in Spain. If I bought everything that I’ve been told to try I’d have spent thousands already. I did drink a shot of wheatgrass today, and a bit ended up on the tip of my nose.</p><p><strong>10.</strong> <strong>The 1980s</strong></p><p>I was a cancer nurse before you were held so responsible for your own longevity, and when you could still smoke inside hospitals, which I did, next to the microwave in my ward’s kitchen. There was no fighting or fucking cancer. All of my patients except one died. I’d say about half had lung cancer: this was south Brooklyn, and this was when lung cancer mostly attacked poor people of color. My lung cancer patients died in two ways: from metastases to the brain, in which case they became drowsy, confused, fell into a coma and died or, they strangled and drowned from tumors in their airways. I have had mets to the brain, treated with gamma knife radiation — an option not available to them then, and I don’t know to what extent it’s available now to poor people who end up in non-teaching hospitals. I think of my patients and try to live up to their examples — it’s tough to be as stoic as they were even though I have it so much easier. They were so sick by the time they sought care it was all over, and most accepted suffering as if it were to be expected, with dignity and humor. Because for them suffering had been expected and it had arrived, punctually, all of their lives.</p><p>One woman was treated for severe hip pain for a year with Motrin. No imaging was done. It was a metastatic lesion on her femur from a colon cancer. She died within 6 months of that diagnosis. One woman, as I was sending her to the hospice in the Bronx aptly named Calvary, saw that I was tearing up and trying to choke out some kind of goodbye. She took my hand. “I lived my life,” she says. Looking back, I think she was a lesbian who was about my age now. We could never talk much because her tumor made it too hard to breathe and talk at the same time. I soaked her feet every day after her bath. Kneeling at your patients’ feet makes you a better person, even if only temporarily.</p><p>Anger keeps us going. It’s not necessarily the anger of why me, or why do I have to die? It’s the anger that gives you the energy to get up and keep living. It’s so easy to do absolutely nothing. We asked Johnnie Mae if she wanted to be resuscitated, to have a tube put in her throat, and a machine breathe for her. We would always make resuscitation and intubation sound like the worse thing in the world, because they kind of are, and they don’t tend to work. She would say yes, I want the tube. We resuscitated her and taped her eyes shut so that flies wouldn’t walk on her corneas. Dying on a respirator is really hard: you want to cough up the tube at the end, and you can’t, and we can’t pull it out (that would be murder, probably second degree). Now I wish I had committed a homicide or two (of course, I probably did, accidentally). Wish I had just pulled out some of those tubes rather than standing there like an idiot, holding someone’s hand who probably did not want their hand held because everything is annoying when you are being strangled by a plastic tube.</p><p><strong>11.</strong> <strong>Learning How to Bid</strong></p><p>This is not about auctions. I have taught in a medium-security prison for the past three years. In class one day, a student said “I had to learn how to bid.” “Bidding” is serving a sentence; a “bid” is a conviction. Learning how to bid means learning how to use your time, the time that remains. And I would say that to myself: I have to learn how to do this sentence. At moments of wanting to just collapse into self-pity and inertia, I told myself to learn how to do this, learn how to have stage 4 lung cancer as they learned how to serve decades in places like Attica and Sing Sing, Clinton and Auburn, Coxsackie and Greene. You can’t fight a sentence, but for my students, you don’t give up either. It’s kind of like standing in place, in a place, you don’t want to stand in, holding ground you don’t want to hold. But it’s in preparation for some other ground. In my case, the ground. Although I’ll be cremated after being dissected by medical, dental, nursing and physical therapy students (I have high hopes of a lot of attention) at NYU so I don’t know where my ashes will go. Nor do I care. I could go to Potter’s Field; I have many friends there from years of sending unidentified and indigent bodies there, including an unidentified man with part of his brain on his shoulder because someone hit him in the head with a pipe or a crowbar.</p><p><strong>12.</strong> <strong>Fear and Trembling</strong></p><p>“How does it start?” This stark question turns up on the lung cancer group page. The woman who posts it means, I think, how does the end begin? How do we start to die? Remarkably, people answer. Confusion. Withdrawal. Somnolence. Sometimes I am so tired and spend so many hours of the day in bed, I think to myself, “it has started.” But not yet. Although I guess the beginning of the end was at Urgent Care in Union Square when the doctor told me I had a mass, not an infection, in my lung and needed a CT scan. I knew the end began then, especially when I came home and popped the CD with the x-ray on it into my laptop and saw a crater that was unfortunately not a hole, not an absence but a huge presence. A tumor the size of a baseball. You can just walk around with a baseball in your lung. I was taking boxing classes until about four weeks before the diagnosis.</p><p><strong>13.</strong> <strong>Hypochondria</strong></p><p>And yet there is also a kind of hypochondria of cancer: everything feels like it might be a harbinger of the end. Stupid stuff: tingling hands, bad headaches, fatigue, wheezing. I’m telling you: don’t tell the oncologist. I think they really only care to note whether you are dead or alive. If you’re alive and having symptoms, those are not really of interest because there is mostly nothing they can do about them except send you on to other specialists who say you are fine: my stomach is “perfect,” my pulmonary functions “excellent.” I’m soon going to be embarrassed to still be alive. But still, things hurt or I lose my balance or I forget a word and I think, the jig is up. Is that arthritis in my shoulder or a metastasis to the bone?</p><p><strong>14.</strong> <strong>Geography</strong></p><p>We have a shout out on the Facebook cancer list: where are you from? Iowa; Belfast; Cape Town; Cape Cod; Leeds, AL; Leeds, UK; Manila; Pittsburgh; Bogota; Egypt; Las Vegas; Surprise, AZ; Malta; Hong Kong; Kamloops, BC; Slovenia; Prince Albert, Saskatchewan; North Dakota; Ypsilanti; East Stroudsburg, PA; Fairfield, OH; Syria; Yorkshire; NYC; Memphis; Denver; Romania. Lots of places in the Carolinas, in India, in Australia, in heaven, in the ground, in urns, in memories, in dead Facebook profiles that seem never to get deleted, in hearts, in craws, in the air, on the tip of the tongue, on headstones and wooden crosses, in hospital morgues and the coroner’s “office.” In December 2018, Los Angeles had a mass funeral for 1400 unclaimed bodies: some of those people must have died of cancer and had no one to claim them. This is for all of them and for all of you. This is for the woman in my Facebook group who has decided not to have a funeral because everyone has “stepped away.” And another woman who is not going to undergo anymore treatment because she feels she has no one to help her. And for the man in the group who posted “I have no friends, no money and no electricity. I’m going into hospice.” This is for the stage 4, 30-year-old woman in Ireland with three children under 6 who messages me sometimes and I can hear her accent in her writing: “how are you keeping?” This is for my mother, who died of another kind of cancer. Her brother, a Ford salesman in Calgary, died of lung cancer when I was still a kid. I remember from the symptoms my aunt reported to my mother that it must have metastasized to his cerebellum: he could not walk because of his loss of balance. I only met him once. He came to New York and we all went to a Rangers’ game, another terrifying experience.</p><p><strong>15.</strong> <strong>Math</strong></p><p>Two years have gone by: no recurrence, although many nodules on the “adenocarcinoma spectrum” dot my left and right lung: ground glass nodules, solid and semi-solid nodules. They might do something or they might not. I don’t know how to do the math of my survival at this stage: you have a strong chance of living and a strong chance of dying. I thought I was slated to die pretty soon with certainty. (My oncologist still seems to think so). In a bizarre turn of events, I am more optimistic than my partner is. I reserved a hotel for her birthday, but she didn’t want to know about it. She doesn’t even want to know where it is. She says, let’s wait til the next scan. In three months. Months are very important to us. I just accepted an invitation for an event that will take place eleven months from now. I want to throw a baby shower in May. I want to go to New Foundland in August and watch the shiny black backs of whales breach the waves. I want to drink Screech, the local rum, with an iceberg ice cube, as is the custom there, where icebergs float by in the spring and people harvest ice from them.</p><p>I try to get set for death. It’s not that I’m afraid to die (although I am), it’s just that I have work to do. I have to get busy, I think. And then I lie down.</p><p>NOTES</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Steinberg, “Bad Patient.”</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> See chapter 1, “Living in Prognosis,” of S. Lochlann Jain’s <em>Malignant: How Cancer Becomes Us</em> (Berkeley: Univ of California Press, 2013) for a truly helpful discussion of what it means to try to orient yourself to a prognosis that applies to a huge group of people, (40).</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Margrit Shildrick, “living on, not getting better.” <em>Feminist Review</em>. (111: 2015), p. 15.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=104e3fe748a0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>