<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ezekiel Lengaram on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ezekiel Lengaram on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@elengaram87?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 20:40:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@elengaram87/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rates, youth and fixed income puzzle!]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-snippet">By Ezekiel Ngitoria Lengaram</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://elengaram87.medium.com/rates-youth-and-fixed-income-puzzle-b422328be192?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/rates-youth-and-fixed-income-puzzle-b422328be192?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b422328be192</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Sep 2026 18:56:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-29T18:56:35.958Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Inflation Shaped Tanzanian Livelihoods (1960–2020)]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/how-inflation-shaped-tanzanian-livelihoods-1960-2020-ebb574c97b93?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ebb574c97b93</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[1960-2020]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ezekiel-lengaram]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tanzania-inflation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Dec 2024 15:44:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-30T15:44:31.889Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>How Inflation Shaped Tanzanian Livelihoods (1960–2020)</strong></p><p>When an economic agent buys or sells bonds it doesn’t just affect financial markets, it affects government policies, it affects the value of our pensions funds and the interest rate we pay on our mortgages. Thus, bond traders fear inflation and you should too. The lethal danger that inflation poses is that it undermines the value of being paid for the fixed interest in a bond. If inflation goes up by 10 percent and the value of fixed interest is only five, then that means that the bondholder is falling behind inflation by 5 percent. That is the reason why at first whiff of high inflation- bond prices fall and sometime continue to fall.</p><p>Of course, Tanzania fixed income market is very small and have insignificant transactions in bond markets to suede the country economy. Yet the country has not been free from the malaise of corrosive inflation. Looking at the simple trends of consumer price index, provide valuable lessons of what happens to Tanzanian wealth in the past 60 years? Beside paltry growth, inflation also joined the dance of making us poorer.</p><p>From the graph below, Tanzania’s 60 years in term of price stability is not without perilous moment. 1984 and 1991 brutal inflation stretch peaked at 37% , while other years it sputter precariously and hover above 10% for many years till 1998 when it started falling below ten till 2008, a blip fall in 2010 and a upward resumption in 2011 and 2012 followed by a decline in 2013 till today in 2021 where the inflation stand at a single digit of 4.2%- actually driven move by the ongoing pandemic than monetary mismanagement. If the data are any guidance substantial work has been done in minimizing inflation. See the subnotes for the benefit of having low inflation in the graph.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*K1I2FIbzajbDP5VqB9ay-Q.png" /></figure><p>The subject of inflation is often not well understood, and many people confuse it with sporadic spurts of price rise, often driven by market volatility or political volatility. It is, however, understandable why inflation is hard to manage and hard to get people to understand despite the merits it warrants. First, inflation is a very to complex measure or forecast accurately. The source is often not immediately clear. The effect also depends on the nature of inflation, expected or unexpected. The received wisdom is that unexpected inflation is more harmful than expected inflation. Of course this makes sense, because expected inflation provides the policymakers with latitude to respond beforehand and therefore dampen the negative effects.</p><p>From the figure above, one can immediately conclude that Tanzanian wealth in 1970–1999 was decimated at an extremely high rate. For example, in 1990, it only took two years for one’s money to lose more than 50%, compared to 2020, where it takes approximately 15 years.</p><p><em>Why is inflation bad or is it bad?</em></p><p><em>“Inflation hurts everybody, more so the poorer segments of our population whose incomes are not indexed- Shri Manmohan Singh- India 1991–92 Budget Speech”</em></p><p>Inflation is considered not good because it accelerates inequality, it erodes away the purchasing power of fixed income earners who often have less discretionary income and rewards borrowers and hurts lenders as the amount they receive is less in terms of purchasing power at the time of payment than when they lent it out. The cost of inflation is closely linked to redistribution of purchasing power. Yes, inflation is harmful, and probably the best way to deal with it besides robust central bank mandate to manage it, is to find ways to safeguard the victim of it, those with extremely low levels of income in our society. And the best way to decrease privation known to man so far is to increase economic growth. The hard challenge is growth is a long-term phenomenon, while persistent price shocks are mostly unpredictable.</p><p><em>Where does inflation come from?</em></p><p>Inflation is either caused by supply shocks, that is an increase in input cost often termed as cost push inflation or it could also rise from demand shocks, where excess supply of money in the economy is more than the production capacity. The interesting thing is that inflation in Tanzania was severe after the Ugandan war of 1976. Even though inflation was higher (above 30%) during the war, the worse days were still ahead of us. Benjamin Mkapa era was the best period for Tanzanian in terms of inflation, for inflation fall for his entire period of presidency. Alli Hassan Mwinyi often is called “Rukhusa” to denote the period of free to do as you wish, yet the period also coincided with the highest period of inflation in our country independent history. The last double digits inflation experienced in Tanzania is in 2011–2012, during Kikwete era, he following years recorded record low inflation, which is very interesting. What happens?</p><p><em>Is inflation targeting the panacea?</em></p><p>When the central bank target inflation through interest rate setting, one need to remember that as the corollary of the monetarist prescription of a constant (or shrinking) money supply rule has its limits: by targeting inflation this way one might miss out on growth opportunities, two; it does not always ensure price stability, when there is deflation, and the interest rate hits zero lower bound (never experienced in Tanzania history) there is no policy prescription, three; it does not ensure financial stability (see Patrick Bolton et al. 2024: Money Capital). However, one will be remiss not to acknowledge the shrewd management of the economy so far in terms of inflation management. I intend to write about economic growth in future articles.</p><p>Since the subject in point is Tanzania, I recommend you read “<em>Tanzania: The Path to Prosperity</em>” by Christopher S. Adam, Paul Collier and Benno Ndulu (2017).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ebb574c97b93" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chama Cha Mapinduzi is no longer a Revolutionary Party]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/chama-cha-mapinduzi-is-no-longer-a-revolutionary-party-13f143c8d3d8?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/13f143c8d3d8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ccm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tanzania]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 22 Sep 2024 16:55:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-22T16:55:55.132Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Chama Cha Mapinduzi</em> is no longer a Revolutionary Party</strong></p><p>If the role of a political party is to get in power and decide on the governance of the people, and the role of government is prevention of war or civil strife among others, then we ought to understand it. In fact, whatever one may think about the desirability of other aims of government, if the prevention of war or civil strife take precedence, and if achievement lies solely in limiting government to this and few other main purposes, these other ideals will have to yield .</p><p><strong>CCM on democracy</strong></p><p>CCM has been accused countless times of its inability to embrace democracy for democracy’s sake. The notion that democracy is built based on rational debate, reason and compromise is foreign to most of CCM members of today. CCM is becoming a patronage group which passes favors among themselves and has parted ways with the democratic practice of competition. The assumption that democratic competition is the most just and efficient way to distribute power and that the most appealing and competent politician should rule, is reserved only the Chama’s Manifesto, and not in practice.</p><p>Over time CCM as a party has become not only undemocratic, but it has also become anti-competitive and anti-meritocratic. Positions in CCM did not and do not go to the most capable but, they went and they continue to be awarded to the most loyal. Those who advanced did not advance because of talent or industry but because of their willingness to conform not even to the party’s mandate, but to the rules of their leader .</p><p>CCM politics has so far strangled Tanzania’s creative souls by reconfiguring the benchmark of success and aspiration of our society. The very elite of the party have taken to practicing elaborate jokes and speaking in riddles in public.</p><p>CCM as the founding party of democratic practice in Tanzania is blamed for fostering democratic fragility which is currently undermining the multi-party democracy. Listening to CCM high ranked officials often gives one the common sense of any stereotypical politician — radiation of self-importance and arrogance. The competition to outshine one another among party leaders signals private ambition amongst them everywhere you look.</p><p><strong>On leadership</strong></p><p>Chama cha Mapinduzi connotes the revolutionary party, and one will be misled to expect her inception is based on some form of revolutionary war, quite the contrary. It only gained the name from the marriage of TANU and Afro-Shirazi Party (ASP) after the Zanzibar archipelago and Tanganyika reunion to form a republic of Tanzania. That is revolutionary.</p><p>Escaping the bloodbath of wars of independence which colored most African countries in 1960 is revolutionary. Having a strong stance on the economic model to pursue, regardless of whether it succeeds or fails, is revolutionary. Defending a country against invasion in 1976 is revolutionary. Unifying a diverse society to embrace the very idea of nationalism “Utanzania” is itself revolutionary.</p><p>To adopt and embrace democracy was revolutionary. The list is endless, and worth a book of its own. All of these are the results of CCM political discourses which required trade-offs and sacrifices. But as the saying goes, calmness is the seed for crisis. Today CCM is a disintegrating institution on autopilot.</p><p>Since I am writing about leadership, let’s see how CCM leadership is going off the rail. To see the leadership of the party now has a price tag. Whoever can pay, gets the pass to meet them. Such arrangements undermine the duty of these leaders to their citizens. The election of representatives is marred by corruption and nepotism to the extent that NEC overrules the appointed members and passes those it deems fitting for the leader, not the people. Call it the death of democracy within the party itself.</p><p>The party elites line their lineage to party positions; from cousins, children, and uncles, to farfetched relatives and family friends. Of course, one will argue this is not a new or inherently CCM character, for they have seen it elsewhere. But without strong institutions to moderate this, one day even CCM itself will wake up to a reality it never expected. That of one strong family of these folks, take <em>it</em> hostage, turning <em>it</em> into an authoritarian party and state. If man’s quest for power is engendered in various forms, concentrating on a few men and women of same families will spell disastrous for the wellbeing of the many. Of us all.</p><p>The departure of Chama cha Mapinduzi from Fisher’s Fundamental theorem of natural selection is bad for all of us as a society. If you don’t know Fisher’s natural selection theorem, it is the idea that variance equals strength, because the more diverse a population is, the more chances it must come up with new traits that can be selected for.</p><p>By narrowly self-selecting, CCM becomes fragile in all manners of ways, from ideas, identity and even vision. That is a sure path to her collapse. Good leadership is to have empathy, humility and to treat people with respect, things which the current CCM’s elite are devoid of.</p><p>Will it be an exaggeration to argue that even the party apex is surrounded by sycophants and not politically astute folks who share the vision of the party manifesto? The weekly reshuffling of government officials who by default are the products of the party members does not signal assurance, but rather instability. Yet one appreciates the swiftness of actions. Does the leadership recognize the fact that if one is dealt a bad hand in a game of cards, no sufficient reshuffling of cards at hand will improve the player’s odds of winning?</p><p>“<em>A failure of leadership may allow a state to weaken itself with internal strife. At the end of the process a decisive defeat in war may bring a final blow or barbarian invasion from without may combine with barbarian welling up from within to bring the civilization to a close. Remember life has no inherent claim to eternity, whether in individuals or in states. Death is natural, and if it comes in due time, it is forgivable and useful, and the mature mind will take no offense from its coming.”</em></p><p><strong>How does</strong> <strong>Day 2 look for Chama Cha Mapinduzi</strong></p><p>“<em>Nobody scented the revolution, it is incredible to see the security and inauspiciousness with which these privileged spokes of goodness, mildness and the innocence of the people when 1793 was already upon them</em>”- French Revolution.</p><p>As the saying goes “failure comes from failure to imagine failure”. In terms of CCM leadership, the cracks and dead wood are everywhere for everyone to see, just not themselves! The assertion that “<em>Nyani haoni kundule</em>” might be fitting. Yet it is extremely obvious that the party have reached an inflection points in terms of ideology, political discourse, pragmatism and even vision. From short term propaganda to outright failure to communicate her success and petty tacks of memes and jibes on social media platforms, which all amount to low grade politics. One will not associate CCM of today with her founder’s politics. The ability to contest power using political ideals and debate issues publicly died with them.</p><p>Of course you might ask, so what, and how does day 2 look like for CCM? To quote Jeff Bezos shareholders letter of 2016, “<em>Day 2 is stasis. Followed by irrelevance. Followed by excruciating, painful decline. Followed by death</em>.” This is not my wish or prediction for CCM, but rather a question we all owe to discuss and even wonder whether upon her coming to face day 2, do we have a better alternative? If you read Jeff Bezos’ 2016 letter, he discusses how to fend off day 2 in terms of business, it will be interesting to hear from others how CCM ca fend off day 2 as a political party.</p><p>One might ask, don’t you wish for the end of the CCM regime? Aren’t you suffering from CCM incompetence fatigue? Why would you even want to speak about her signs of tremors and blisters of decay? With all the violence it has projected onto her people through her failing, aren’t you glad she is facing day 2?</p><p>All these are warranted questions. I don’t desire ill fate for CCM, I want a strong, competent and just CCM and a stronger and equally just ad competent opposition. I don’t seek political substitute at a national level, I rather seek complementary parties, a subject for my future writing.</p><p>Maybe it is time for Chama cha “eminence grise” to take the center stage to rescue her from a speeding decline. One to remind them that leadership during a crisis with abundance of fear and uncertainty demands providing what is scarce: trust, and accurate, honest and timely information. Clear plans of preparedness that create high confidence. Conversely, attempts to manipulate the public to avoid fear by suppressing information, downplaying or spinning statistics, and even ridiculing the cries of the many, only serve to create distrust, fear and outrage.</p><p>The Maasai people have a famous saying which is fitting for the subject of CCM today: “<em>Meenteeng’ai Olosho linoo katitu natiu</em>” which translate to,“you can’t bemoan the type of family you are born in, your job is to work to build the one you desire”.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=13f143c8d3d8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The demise of the Tanzania Judiciary]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/the-demise-of-the-tanzania-judiciary-6d2422f8708a?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d2422f8708a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[judiciary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tanzania]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Jun 2024 21:32:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-05T21:32:39.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The demise of the Tanzania Judiciary</strong></p><p>“<em>You must understand that there are two ways of contending, by Law, and by force: The first is proper to men; the second to beasts; but because many times the first is insufficient, the recourse must be had for the second</em>” — The Machiavellian and the Defenders of Freedom-James Burnham.</p><p>Reading and watching daily news about the scourge of citizens who have resorted to the political elite for the injustices they face makes you wonder what happens to the three-legged assumptions of state; the Executive, the Parliament and the Judiciary. Specifically, the Judiciary part.</p><p>When few men and women from the political class rise as the arbiters of law and justice, one must also contend with the end of democracy. For the fundamental instinct of humans to misapply power is natural, and the Judiciary is there to be a guiding star in mitigating this. However, when such a fundamental institution is scandalized with corruption, hijacked by the political class for their publicity ends, consequently, the society stands to suffer.</p><p>Currently there isn’t a clean separation of power among these entities. In a democratic country, which spends ungodly amounts of time marketing itself as ‘democratic’, one would have expected that the activities of the judiciary to be left to it, and not left to presidential appointees becoming law givers and law takers.</p><p>Such arrangement work only if Tanzania want to be an authoritarian state. Else, a strong Judiciary is a desirable and vital institution in our country. As citizens we owe to at least demand that and protect it when the few (but powerful) attempt to undermine it.</p><p>It is a fundamental error to assume that those entrusted with power will not misuse it. Currently those in positions of power will not want a strong constitution or judiciary. They fear it will bring an end to their powers and privileges. That it will circumvent and overly regulate their not so democratic actions.</p><p>“<em>If our interest is in man as he is on this earth, so far as we can learn from facts of history and experience, we must conclude that he has no natural aspiration for peace or harmony, he does not form states in order to achieve ideally good society, nor does he accept mutual organization to secure the maximum social welfare. But men, and a group of men, do by various means, struggle among themselves for relative increases in power and privileges</em>.” -<strong>The Machiavellian and Defenders of Freedom.</strong></p><p>The distinctiveness of the Tanzania system is the structure of our government — one aspect of it is the lack of independence of the Judiciary or parliament. Of course, the malice of inept dissents from state law makers in the international arena will be a long topic to discuss. The three pillars of the government have merged to one and run a soup of contradictions. Elements and signs of a failed state or failed state awaiting? You tell me! Nevertheless, institutional decay has been a common phenomenon in our country, whether we want to agree or not.</p><p>The silence about the lack of separation of powers in the government has cascaded from the past administrations to current administrations. The political elite assert that the judiciary is a corrupt institution which has failed to ameliorate the society injustice. So the political elite has decided that it is their responsibility to correct that.</p><p>Quite seductive a proposition it is, though void of substance of due process. Yet if they are now the arbiters of law and justice, who holds <em>them</em> accountable?</p><p>What about those subjects which require legal interpretations, does a political appointee garner sufficient competence to deal with such matters? Currently one must engage in a willing suspension of disbelief to be able to accept what is happening to the Tanzania Judicial system. It is sad and shameful.</p><p>It will not be an exaggeration to argue that our Judicial system is a mere shell of its old self and is currently being exploited by the autocratic cliques for their own ends with no regard for public interests.</p><p>It is not like the public opinions of the homo politicus are unknown. And yet it is hard to reconcile their presumption that they would always be able to identify the public interest and act single mindedly upon it.</p><p><em>The philosopher king hypothesis</em> is in full operation in Tanzania today and one will struggle to not see it in nearly everything going on. One can’t help but wonder whether they will ever grow to face up to Karl Popper’s problem of <em>“what if the elite turn out not to be benevolent Philosopher Kings?”</em></p><p>Even if we are to agree that our philosopher kings are right, we still need to remember that the surfeit of self-confidence is perhaps understandable in a brilliant politician, however a presumption of immortality is not. When the philosopher kings meet their fate, as we all will one day, society will still need institutions. Will it not be madness to assume or to be sure of a replete availability of ‘rational’ philosopher kings?</p><p><em>I </em>would rather have strong institutions.</p><p>Currently, we must be content with the opportunistic politicians who will exploit the desperate conditions of the people, but who choose not to rescue them from the quagmire of destitution or injustice.</p><p>Proverbs 21:3</p><p>(The judiciary acts as a check and balance.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d2422f8708a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Computation as a “new” old -frontier]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/computation-as-a-new-old-frontier-35c5ca764c57?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/35c5ca764c57</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[computing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ezekiel-lengaram]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 May 2024 16:51:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-01T16:51:58.899Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Computation as a “new” old -frontier</strong></p><p>Human are not designed to think in exponential terms! Ask your friends basic numerical questions and see how quickly they can enumerate the answers. However, try ask them about 789 x 789, the machine collapse.</p><p>During high school, I remember being considered smart if you could impute some random calculations of various form ranging from algebra to calculus. Of course, not to diminish the matter, there is value in doing those exercises and probably survivorship biased might affect my valuation of them now. Yet, it soon became obvious that one mental competence is not actually good at solving these calculations mechanically by hands, but rather understand the underlying principle and let the computers solve them for you.</p><p>First, in computational applied you will learn the invaluable lessons of a computing power in doing all those non-linear computations which will make your hair go gray very quickly if you try doing it manually. Here one gets to appreciate the novelty of computing power, at least at small scale. Even more interesting is to think that the two-by-two simultaneous equation solvable by simple rows and column manipulation can become very complex as soon as one scale the number of equations in it. Immediately, the human brain is at the mercy of the computer in solving these problems quickly.</p><p>Now that might not seem like a valuable use of computational power, until you start considering it is use in other areas. Computational power is lifesaving tool. Think of going to a hospital in Tanzania in 2024. At arrival, often a nurse will go through ungodly number of files to search for you card which record your last visit or else you should just lie about you having visited the hospital previously to fast track the process. Well, but that will cost you money, so you are immediately out of pocket even before receiving treatment, this can be infeasible for most poor folks so they will partake the manual search exercise. Some die waiting for their last visit form to be found. Could computing systematization of sorting and storage solve this problem, you bet it does.</p><p>Computation is very valuable, and one might not appreciate it until one spend some time thinking what is achievable using computation in solving interesting problems. From designing rescue robots in war zones, nuclear accident in Japan, logistics planning around the world, the beloved financial world of trillions of transactions in a matter of hours to sorting cucumbers in supermarkets. Computing is everywhere. Computing also free humans from some dreadful jobs, reduce accidents and improve quality of life. Just imagine how computation have rid us of those repetitive tasks.</p><p>If you live in a world with little understanding of technologies you get to appreciate, how lack of it affect society perceptions. Say a choice of a partner in a world where technologies have not rid human of cooking, washing chores and the likes. Observe how value is attributed in a partner. “Good cook can keep the place clean and so forth” all of these signal a need of mechanical turk than a partner, it seems to me.</p><p>In fact, in low computing environment, people valuation has more to do with mechanical computing (physical labor), chores and the like than other things. Of course this is not general, but neither it is not marginal.</p><p>This quarter me and my reading collegue are reading about AI, to educate ourself a little bit about the apex of computing power. So far I can recommend you read</p><p>1. The Worlds I see by Dr. Fei Fei</p><p>2. Chip War by Chrill Miller</p><p>3. A brief History of Intelligence by Max Bennett</p><p>Have a happy worker day</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=35c5ca764c57" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[1Percent Built]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/1percent-built-1c8e027df6ad?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1c8e027df6ad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tanzania]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[1percent-built]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ezekiel-lengaram]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Mar 2024 16:24:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-31T16:24:39.984Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Benjamin Fernandes @Benji_Fernandes likes to quip that “<em>payment in Africa is one percent built</em>” It made me wonder, if that is true? What else is one percent built or even below one built and can start being built today?</p><p>How did Benji come up to that number? — What metrics did he use? It is not as if it is obvious, but living abroad I can attest, it is very hard to move money around in the world. Starting in 2009 in UK while in high school to South Africa 2024, moving money is hard. I remember sending money from my “Mpesa” to an SA account from Tanzania to South Africa. I run an experiment, so I sent a minimum amount and see how long it will take! Well, let us just say that money went into an ether. I never received the money on the other end and could not spend all the time to track it.</p><p>Anyway, physically or in a software world, many things in many African countries are marginally built or none existence. Which one will be easier, physical or bits, and how does one actually go about building it, financial highways is an obvious area for Benji because first the demand is obvious, the building blocks are already there- the biggest challenge is more of George Stigler issue of regulatory capture of incumbents than skills and capital in the financial sector. Of course, we all have heard political rent seeking behavior constraints being a major challenge faced by builders in Africa.</p><p>You must understand it is not for the lack of ambitious, or intellectual acquit that many young people do not try to solve interesting problems. Nevertheless, there is an elephant in every room a youth walk in, some old man or lady tasked to guard the door. Some will want some greasing the wheel, some ask for 30 percent equity of your business and others a bitter/ sour who will outright block your dreams. “Ever heard the say- as long as am here, your idea will never see the light of the day?” Ask dreamers-they have many tales to tell. Any way do not get disappointed and keeping looking for areas, which are 1 percent, built and do your little part. Remember as Brewster says, “<em>Our highest responsibility might be to unsettle the status que rather than preserve it</em>”</p><p>It worth asking, what was are the drivers of what get built anyway? Why was the road built? Most of things are built to either solve the builder pain-point, while other things are built as a measure of ambitions. Now remember ambition is a function of technology, what are built also reflect the type of technologies that society is endowed with. If you live in a city with little to no technology, your aspiration will emulate the technologies surrounding you at most.</p><p>How things come into existence, say galaxies — in astronomy 101, one learn that astronomy is a time machine, which give us visualization of the past. Looking back a cosmic history, help us to understand how did these galaxies use to look like and what was their composition. The lessons are that earlier baby galaxies started forming via conglomeration of earliest atoms, and those earliest gas clouds produce the earliest stars, which were very simple, compose of mostly hydrogen and nothing else. In fact the constellation of stars are little factories which as they shine they create heavier element in their core through fusion process. When these stars run out fuel in their core they often disperse these material that they have created into the interstellar and it get caught up in the next generation of stars (recombination or laws of thermodynamic at play of course).</p><p>This means, that over time these galaxies that are full of these stars that are coming and going are maturing and their sizes are measurable. Even the sun, which is a very important star for our survival is not, a first generation star, it took light years of formation for it to come into existence. So all that is into existence is the results of progression of the universe from a bust of energy and transition of energy into matter to form gravitationally bound stars such earth and the like. Truly, there are stages of things in the cosmic world where only 1 percent formation has taken place, and will require either time, technological change to accelerate it to reach their maturation. The same can be in on our planet. The various technologies we enjoy have a progression path, which is not accidental, but intentional to make it happens and the like of @fernandez is doing with his time in NALA for the African market. His audacity and effort should arouse a sense of awe, curiosity and wonder from all of us. First it give us a validation that just as stars emanate from microscopic fusion reactions in the galaxies, so we can build great products which transcend our village geography.</p><p>Just as we know that there are hundreds of galaxies in the observable universe and even potentially more in yet unreached end of the cosmos, it is also true that, there could be potentially infinitely many technologies, which can be brought to light, besides those recent to our minds. For example what does it mean to be above average in finance, like you have trained yourself to be as competent in this area to a degree of say above one percent of the population in the world! How long will it take and what attitude will it require?</p><p>The formation of stars and galaxies should fertilize more curiosity in us to learn more about how great things come into existence and what can we do to aid them to be, even if it will at margins. Not to think and try to pursue to the ultimate scope of our abilities the possible frontiers of knowledge and making tangible product out of it, is a fundamental abdication of responsibility handed to us by our forefathers. Our parents achievements, though minor in a large scope of things are testament of new possibilities. Steve Job famously said most of what you see is built by men and women who are not necessarily smarter than you are. Bias for actions trump genius –everyday and always.</p><p>Psalm 8:3–9</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1c8e027df6ad" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Vijana na Ramli”]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/vijana-na-ramli-076ea8817eb7?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/076ea8817eb7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tanzania]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vijana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[betting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[youth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Feb 2024 18:10:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-29T18:10:43.721Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>“Vijana na Ramli”</strong></p><p>In the advent of mass unemployment and coupled with disinterested political class, who are more concern in keeping scores between themselves than working to improve the social welfare of the society, youth who feel left alone- will seek various activities to fill such a vacuum.</p><p>I would not have expected that in the event of lack of employment coupled with price rot (inflation) one would have resorted to a strange activity of betting about events they have no marginal information competence as a way to entertain themselves or fill the void left with lack valuable employment. The assumption is that provision of prediction markets for uncertain events gives those who bets an incentive to be correct. The market will have been a good mechanism to filter out signal and noise and remove those with no skin in this game. Only if the predictors are on average somehow informed.</p><p>Am not sure what to call it, but betting is probably one activity where someone is happy to loose R100, but also get outrages to pay the same amount for a cup of tea. Of course, the house does not really care about the immorality of exploiting the worse in human nature. In fact, it will hire your favorite celebrity to advertise the odds. Will be interesting to know whether the celebrities themselves are betting! Media houses are in competition to nudge you to undertake bets, which defy reality. Even predictions, which are covered with all signs of irrationality, have never deter participants placing bets.</p><p>Walking around in any capital city in Africa today, one will find a plethora of betting points call it “Kibanda Umiza” or whatever they call it in your locale. The sole role of these shops have been to occupy these “wall people” –the name given to young people of age 17–23 years old in Algeria who are unemployed. The reason why they are named such is “because all they do is lean against the wall and watch street go by”. Bruce Berkowitz view gambling as “in an extreme form gambling is a sickness” It is hard to refute his claim since some people actually prefer gambling and loosing than not gambling at all.</p><p>Besides- being unemployed, in the nation which have failed to create jobs and run the risk of social unrest from the mass unemployment devised a mechanism to keep the unemployed occupied, betting on European leagues(all sort of them, not merely football) –oddly end of the world sport contest — not based on any game theory or statistical competence strategies but by pure close your eyes and choose. The need for understanding the difference between risk and uncertainty is not the required knowledge on the side of the players- it is the received knowledge on the side of the game designer. On the choice of what to bet on, the frequency of play does not improve the odds of the player, however in aggregate it improve his/her cumulative loss, whether they know it or not.</p><p>Despite the type of the game, these folks play- it is designed in a manner that, they keep playing which is both good for the house and the lazy political class who have absconded from seeking better option for the youth. The ability of players to differentiate risk which is measurable and priciable to uncertainty, which is unmeasurable, and one cannot attach a price it is not something privy to unemployed youth in the continent. However, if one design a game, which provide a potential signal of potential eventual winning chance- people will not care how big those odds are stacked against them. In absence of better option such option are better than none. The net winner in this arrangement is the house and the state. Betting is the best way to tax the unemployed- the joke goes as those who bet pay tax twice, for being ignorant of the game; they are playing and the common consumption tax. The actors do not immediately understand even the comprehension of risk dimension regarding the danger of impulsive betting behavior. Even though the risk dimension tends to reduce the need to worry about them, than having one risk, it does make wonder whether how long does one play the game before figuring out the Ponzi nature of it?</p><p>Fundi Mudi excitement on the prospect of him winning big one day tell the tale. He work on piece jobs in construction sites and share his erratic income flow with the house, betting on football matches in far geographies which he have little knowledge of the team or the league. At best, he try to figure out whether the team won the last few matches- not knowing past performance is not a good proxy for the future performance. Even the best statisticians often come behind in their predictions with all their Monte Carlo simulations and their massive chest of knowledge on the subject. “Kibanda umiza” is a market place designed for “Mudi” and the likes to engage in trying to solve a multi complex multi-dimensional problem of possible outcomes by thumb sucking.</p><p>Yes “Kibanda umiza” is there to facilitate weath transfer from those who gamble to the house. After all, the betting house leverage the basic instinct of human nature; greed, laziness and the desire to get rich quickly. Human want less complex, minimum effort to gain maximum reward. This explain the like of “fundi Mudi” take risks and bet and also why betting have existed throughout history.</p><p>My friend @lswendo likes to think that prediction markets are mechanism through which market communicate true information. However, he does not tell me whether such true information is that in aggregate “ramli” players will lose! Neither, does he tell me that the player understand the price design- in fact, that price is not a single dial which aggregate all the inputs or even whether the players are aware of such? Whether he think players, playing willingly a game of crossing a high-speed railway line blindfolded is such a fantastic idea. Of course, price has many dimensions whether one knows or not.</p><p>For every transaction, especially those where information asymmetry rain supreme, the guy on the other side of the table often is well informed about the game, have more money than you have more power than you and more experience than you who is betting. The ultimate sucker at the table is you. One would have wish the players to at least have some guarding rails in these contests. Truth is that the ultimate looser when all is said and done is a society replete with gamblers who are used to take reckless bets and cant reason any more, probably this is not a desirable outcome we all want, but it is the one we are cultivating.</p><p><em>“I think the record shows the advantage of a peculiar mindset-not seeking action for its own sake, but instead combining extreme patience with extreme decisiveness”-</em> Charlie Munger</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=076ea8817eb7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bank of Tanzania Policy shift]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/bank-of-tanzania-policy-shift-0e96783aa180?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0e96783aa180</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bots]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interest-rates]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Jan 2024 18:52:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-31T18:52:47.926Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Bank of Tanzania Policy shift</strong></p><p>As announced today 3rd of January 2024, the Bank of Tanzania (BOT) is moving away from its traditional policy framework of managing quantity of money to interest rate framework.</p><p>As started in the bank memo, the aim of such implementation is to achieve the following:</p><p>(i) Efficiency (ii) effectiveness and (iii) resiliency</p><p>Although not that explicitly, that is the message I gather in the A4 document. Simply put:</p><p>The <strong><em>efficiency objective</em></strong> will ensure that the bank delivers this interest rate control without imposing excess cost in terms of time or money to all users, and without soliciting any inconvenience expenses from the central bank.</p><p>The <strong><em>effectiveness requirement</em></strong> to ensure that the framework should be effective in transmitting the policy rate to the broader economy and financial markets. Thus, this rate set by BOT will the base rate for all other interest rates.</p><p>The last objective of the policy shift is to guarantee <strong><em>resilience</em></strong>-, which means that, this shift should works under a broader set of scenarios. As stated, it can be used to stabilize the economy during recession (rates should be decreased) and expansion (rate should be raised). The memo also highlights that this rate will move in line with other policies such as fiscal policy to guarantee its effectiveness.</p><p>The motives for the bank shift could be the increasing economic turbulence globally which have been ongoing since COVID-19 pandemic and the dual wars in Ukraine and Middle East. Under this scenario, no pre-existing playbook that the bank can use to stabilize the economy and of course the incentive to search for new tools. In world of rising uncertainty and recurring economic and political shocks, it is judicious for BOT to adopt such a mechanism, which help it to adapt and respond quickly to these changes. Agility and resilience will definitely be a competitive advantage in these choppy environments. Although it is not immediately clear, I think Mr. Tutuba is in the money on this one.</p><p>From the investor’s point of view the growing influence of central bank in the management of rates, is going to have overreaching consequences on stocks, fixed income returns and will likely to only reflect in wealth effect in long term window than short. Investors will do well to study history of bank’s policy shift around the world to draw lessons of similar nature. Such view and take is a worth exercise.</p><p>Prominently the global uncertainty caused by war and the pandemic have caused huge supply shocks ranging from supply chain disruptions, undermined labour force participations, which have also coincided with other structural shifts in globally. All these have accelerated the need for change in monetary policy for many economies. Some of these structural changes are such as the climate change, energy transitions, deepening geopolitical divide and fragmentation of global economy into competing blocs, which have resulted in trade and investments restrictions between countries, the potential challenge or regional integrations. All these conditions will have over reaching consequences to the inflation dynamic.</p><p>Few economies including Tanzania have experienced a mild episode of FX shortages and rapid prices swings in imported goods such as fuels and consumer goods. Others economies in the region are still not out of the wood with their debt interest payment dues and reserves shortages. In time like these, prudence macroeconomic policies are invaluable. The old adage of “the dollar is ours but is your problem” remain valid today and so long as nation do not have a better substitute, they will have to work overtime to remain liquid in these hard currencies. Gold purchase was my previous article- titled Bank of Tanzania goes Gold shopping-which explain the rationale.</p><p><em>So what are the Pros and cons of the policy shift; few there are!</em></p><p>The quantity of Money frame work (old stance)</p><p>For those less initiated in the lingua Franca of economic- quantity of money framework is premised on the assumption that changes in the quantity of money causes changes in its purchasing power, as measured by some price index say CPI. The biggest critique of this framework is that it lack the link between aggregate output and employment.</p><p>For example, speed- the quantity of money framework as monetary policy transmission mechanism is slow, therefore often less effective in harmonizing the economy in the event of any deviations arising from either endogenous or exogenous shocks. There is some evidence of the bank policy working, looking on it is unannounced move towards single digits in its treasury paper issuance, which have helped to direct capital in other investments and reduce the liquidity drought or could it just be January effect? It will be interesting to monitor those premia throughout the year.</p><p>Another interesting challenge the bank faced using money supply as policy is that money supply is not only a crucial determinant of long run inflation in the economy, but also a strategic variable in the bank transmission mechanism which price level dynamic in the long run and income and employment dynamic are linked to policy actions. In 2024, the expectation is that many economies including Tanzania, will have operate in the world were competing policy (monetary and fiscal policy) in a high debt, high interest rate world. It worth remembering that stable public debt dynamics around a well-defined steady state is a precondition to ensure price stability when the central bank use interest rate as their policy instrument and public obligations are nominal (Woodford, 1994).</p><p>However, the theory is clear on policy preference between fiscal and monetary. Monetary policy is superior when it comes to implementation. Example discretionary monetary policy can be executed rapidly (wraps speed during COVID- go see the data on growth of money supply then) than fiscal policy can. An if you happen to have sat in any economic class during macro session you will recall that monetary policy is much less subjected to implementation lags compare to fiscal policy. If not go back to your notes and of course, you can always read Taylor (2000) and Fontana (2009) on the subject. Actually, Taylor (2000) expound broadly the limitations of fiscal policy as policy tool during economic cycles.</p><p>The fundamental assumption regarding quantity of money framework implemented previously by the bank was based on the assumption that it does gear the monetary policy to the pursuit of money-growth targets. However, there is no sufficient causative evidence to validate this position, which could explain the bank shift away from it. Moreover, the enjoyed speed of monetary policy during COVID-is now becoming costly as inflation keep raging in advance markets.</p><p>The expectation is that this adoption will enhance all the 3 mentioned benefits of the framework and all financial markets will be in sync with BOT policy rate which of course will create credibility in the economy, both locally and globally. After all, accommodative monetary policy have often being used as a moderating tool to drive economic growth, especially when there is an upsurge in public investments spending. From this position, it is hard to fault Tanzania in government investment spending. Of which it has resulted in short-term stable growth and likely to increase productivity capacity in the long run. The Central Bank as government banker have results to show. Even the move to buy gold as an FX volatility mitigation move, although is marginal currently, might just be golden bullet in the future. Yet, policy asymptote are hard to forecast and this one is no different. The economy does not respond symmetrically to policy changes and therefore we should expect sometime before the effects of the change being pronounced in other economic activities and data at least.</p><p>From the literature, policy choices of central banks varies depending on the nature and the structure of the country economy and therefore there is no one size fit all. In fact, it policy framework shift is risky despite all its merits. However, as the BOT memo explained the policy shift is adopted because it fit well with the Tanzanian economic context and the bank mandate which is to stabilize price (manage inflation) and promote long-term economic growth. Moreover, of course the rather odd comment given that, they are doing because the other in the region have done so. Nevertheless, the document, though not explicitly seems to suggest that the bank (BOT) ability to supply liquidity without losing interest rate control is also suitable in maintaining financial stability.</p><p>Whether BOT dual mandate of price stability and economic growth is an achievable goal , it remain to be seen, for it will require the bank to report the results upon tinkering with rate on its success on its mandate, that is how does changes in the bank rate’s aid in incentivizing human action. Does the bank action aid human actions, which can enhance human productivity and therefore prosperity or is does it frustrate human action and therefore impede the cause of human productivity?</p><p>These are the questions, which its answers are not immediately clear, and no obvious mechanism in place to put the bank policies in accord with public interest.</p><p><em>This is my own views on the bank policy, and it is not financial advice or guidance on monetary matters- do your own research, the only objective here is to entertain and educate.</em></p><p>Genesis 47:15</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0e96783aa180" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Culture and risk]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/culture-and-risk-587bb88168dc?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/587bb88168dc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tanzania]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[risk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Dec 2023 20:10:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-30T20:10:21.887Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Culture and risk</strong></p><p>Culture plays a fundamental role in the outcomes of any society. The famous quote of society gets what it celebrates mask a lot of meaning from the first reading, but upon reflection, it gives deeper meaning which are not immediately obvious.</p><p>Our culture does not tolerate failure, the implication of this is that, many first generation risk takers will only attempt to do things which are on the edge of commonality. The vector of possibilities is constrained by the views culture has on failing.</p><p>The most ambition pursuits in term of scale often encircle farming (Agribusiness) is catchy phrase adopted to sanitize agriculture, however, it embodies all the past process and void of any new technology apart from drone for taking pictures and water sprinklers which are as old as agriculture itself. The expectation is that it should not have been very hard to disprove the agriculture thesis as an economic pathway to prosperity. If science is any guidance, Karl Popper thought experiment should apply. Popper argued that “empirical truth cannot be known with absolute certainty, and that even scientific theories can’t be verified beyond a shadow of doubt, they can only be falsified by testing” He also insist that one only need one failed test to falsify a claim, but no amount of conforming instances is sufficient to verify. From his point of view, Tanzania agriculture does not pass the Popperian test, however it survive the conformist experiment.</p><p>The idea that the technology of ambition explain what happens in certain society is well exemplified in our society. The confirmed high IQ generation be by the higher learning institutions or otherwise, spend their marginally earned capital in investing in short term (less risk) activities such as poultry and other consumables (the meme economy). You will struggle to find investments areas which have high risk and the feedback is 10 years or 25 years. Even the previous national development plan entail ideas which are so obvious you would not need someone to hire a committee for them. The riskless portfolio often include agriculture and its complements and nothing on the unknown unknown orthogonal. Yet we all agree that the future is unknown and we owe to treat is with a multidimensional plan.</p><p>Our culture is also lacking in term of technical accomplishment borne out of our universities and high learning institutions financed by our financial system. The 10% lending rates afforded to farmers or maintained their fancy name agriprenuers the Bank of Tanzania is sign that we are the ultimate conformist with single consensus. Any such deviation won’t be tolerated. Both the financial sector and government policies do not reward outside the traditional perimeter. It is actually dangerous for any generation to dream outside their culture in term of productivity matrix.</p><p>Even our financial system engages more on casino behavior between each other than financing productivity. It is not such an outlandish stand to claim that Vikoba (stockvels) finance a large part of productivity in Tanzania than the financial sector does. We go back to the type of risk and reward matrix that exist within our culture. To reinforce this, in Tanzania we have approximately 50 banks, yet their footprint is scant, and the largest financial highway is from telecommunication operators which have created countless mini ATM across the country as the last mile banking, charging margins from each transaction. Technicians of these highways call themselves fintech startups and hold conferences to discuss the 5th industrial revolution and AI. One would have thought that an institution which hire north of 1000 people paid billions of shillings in salaries would have produced something bigger than what 100 people in a start-up would build.</p><p>The central bank out of shame of looking irrelevant, find new frontiers to regulate, and that is vikoba of women located in areas the bank have never set foot one in its entire existence. So the most productive financial sector now has to follow regulations designed by an institution which could not innovate at the first place. If you ask me, one would have expected that the bank leave things which are working and making it look like it is doing a great job on it is mandated conviction of fighting inflation. I suppose one will opine on the bad actors in vikoba and the need for regulation, however how has it been regulating itself? Second what is the delta of say BOT regulations in vikoba performance? What could be the returns of such effort if placed in other areas beside vikoba? If BOT as a regulator failed to control bad actors in “Halmashauri” loans which is tax payer’s money, what make us trust that they can do in a new area?</p><p>The interesting thing about vikoba is that anyone can be a member of that community, but then the rule of that community apply to you as well, contrast to the legacy financial sector which create tranches of KYC for different participants. The only critique of vikoba ecosystem will be the non-scallability of it. On risk, the member’s network similar to insurance use of law of large numbers to minimize risk and the loan return cycle make vikoba NPL (lowest non-performing loan) I know. This does not exclude those blown out event of imprudence from the intellectual class designed scams and appropriate others of their hard earn cash.</p><p>On the second strand of risk is the intolerance of first generational success. Our culture does not tolerate or even celebrate first generational success. Visibly, the common conversation one hear about successful people are associated with wild attributes such as witchcraft (easily falsifiable), or other odd convenient, simple and varying explanations (not that credible and hard truth does not vary). The implication of this is that many first generation success are often the mirror image of the past success (not new), not ambitious-just matching the past.</p><p>The young generation aspiration to building things which transform key aspect of our society is not only a technological challenge, but also a culture challenge. There is an agreement on what problems we are going to solve and which one we are not going to solve.</p><p>As a young person you need to achieve all this accepted success metrics quickly so you can move on to do other, things which are outside this agreed matrix. But to do this one will need to ignore the status quo and accelerates on how to get out of the consensus cycle. Understand that you can take a lot of risks, provided that none of them is fatal. You can build many things which seems initially as impossible and not within the reach of your abilities. You can also leverage dead talent to build on whatever you want to build. But initially solve the lowest denominator first, then leverage it to scale up.</p><p>This year I spend time reading a lot about complexity economics, and my lesson has been, that wherever you can find the complex product, you are likely to have greater per capita GDP. It is also true that wherever you find ubiquitous non-complex product, destitution is also high. So probably one will do well to increase the production of various complex products over time. Interestingly even the lack of variation in the products from the high density resource in a place, also signal of sclerosis in technology. An example of this, one can have maize, but when you count products out of maize as an input, you find very little besides the common old set. Phenomenon like this call into question all the investments done per sector countrywide. If government invest X amount into the research and development, and at the same time, year after year, no commercially produced product on the shelves of the market locally or globally, why can’t it do a self-analysis and change path? The innovation winter in our country has to change. Young people will be rewarded immensely if they put their energies in building(innovating) solutions which create markets.</p><p>In 2022, Nyerere would have been 100 years old. If you are Tanzanian and happens to travel across the country, you are guaranteed to find his sculptures in many cities as a national hero-deservingly so. Yet Nyerere sculpture should also inspire other questions, where are the Nyerere sculptures equivalent in term of science, technology etc.? What does the absence other’s heroes sculptures tell of the malaise of our culture? Surely the long arrows of history did not start in 1922 and end in 1961. It is obviously in the best interest for everyone to do something which has a proportionally high risk, but with also a huge upside if it works. May be invest both time and money in building a product that in 10 years if it works it makes all other achievements footnotes. Preferably that is a desirable culture and probably need to be tolerated and encouraged often. Have a minimal budgetary allocation on risk areas which long feedback loops.</p><p>In term of leadership risk, CMM leadership behavior have exhibited a stable narrow distribution in the past. This did help in informing investment decisions of private sector. As the say goes capital goes where it is well come and stay where it is well respected. If FDI data are any guidance the past 60 years show that, Tanzania has been a risk place for capital investment. Looking in the future, the ballot is still out. Will the party leadership management narrow distribution on the negative side change? Hard to tell.</p><p>Just as anything else, reform start from the part and never the whole. Thus as a society we owe to do a continuous auditing of our culture in term of science, traditions and even religions. Going forward, as a society we owe to work hard to increase the risk spectrum and variance of things we can do with more risk. But mostly the culture has to see risk differently. The state has a big role to play in shaping culture and tradition, to assume otherwise is tantamount to making a grave mistake.</p><p><em>“Man creates culture and through culture creates himself”</em> <strong>Pope John Paul II</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=587bb88168dc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Public Dish Part 2]]></title>
            <link>https://elengaram87.medium.com/public-dish-part-2-d8a7509fde2a?source=rss-758964e4cb04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8a7509fde2a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poor-policies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ezekiel Lengaram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Nov 2023 18:14:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-14T18:14:35.305Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Public Dish Part 2</strong></p><p>In December 3rd 2021, I listened to minister Ummy Mwalimu, bemoan the education status of our country with both sadness and bemusement at the same time. Why sadness, because she was contradicting herself-first she got issued a notice by her quasi-senior minister of education then Dr. Ndalichako to ban all extra tuitions activities to all public school kids in Tanzania. At the same time, she admits that these public schools are under-resourced, from science and math teachers to even sufficient classes.\</p><p>She explains that poor kids are overworked, why should they have to remain back in school for extra tuitions class, while we have this comprehensive syllabus showing what children are supposed to cover during each semester? She missed the difference between having the syllabus and implementing it. They are not the same thing. Get your fact right, minister!</p><p>She further, bemoans the commercialization of education as source of the problem and not the results of the problem in education sector. Incentives matter — Madam Minister, “show me the incentives and I will show you the outcomes”</p><p>The honorable Minister, said her kids do not do all this extra tuitions, but did not care to tell us whether the school they go to, have sufficient teachers or is under resourced as the majority of these institutions across the country? The moderators recoiled to question or contradict the minister; after all, it is ill manners in my country tradition to question your guest speaker in any material sense? Unless is Udaku breaking!</p><p>I asked my question through backchannel to Moderator of Jamii Forum session. My questions were as follow:</p><p>1. What happen to freedom of choice?</p><p>2. Why should the government have a say on private choice- parent choosing to get tuitions for their kids?</p><p>3. Why is the line between the government and individual sovereignty?</p><p>4. Should the citizen have choices besides those given by the government?</p><p>5. Since government ban the extra classes [tuitions], how can it be accountable for the outcome? Can citizen sue government for their kids underperforming?</p><p>6. What is Ummy going to do if I hire a tutor for my child, come arrest me? Using what law?</p><p>Well none of my question were asked, apart from being acknowledged, as you might know, acknowledgment is the best you can get. Even the responses often rhyme with, “that is a very good question” followed by either inactionable response or pure diversion. We are caution not to ire respectful pleasantries. The rest of the responses were at best knee jerked which pass unsuspectingly.</p><p>The results are already abysmal in public schools in Tanzania, but Ummy said publically firing head teachers and ward councilors is illegal. Remove all accountability? What outcome is she honestly trying to get?</p><p>Ok a little economic lesson- if you impose a ban on a service you get not only deadweight loss which adversely affect consumer welfare, but you also give all these other incentives of inception of black markets. People will not take your instructions as religious; neither will they take you seriously ever again. Credibility damage? Go figure. People will device their new form of getting what you ban, from zoom tutoring, to all form clever methods-which will require Ummy to quit her ministerial job and run a special operation of getting these law breakers, deploy more resources of the already lean government. However, naah it cannot be that serious, Ummy will realize the impracticability of her proposal and will ignore it over time and more on to issue other “Matamko” — of course, life must go and the newsmakers need catchy new headings.</p><p>Worst-case scenario- the minority few will take up my line of thinking above, ignore Ummy, and get their kids all the support they can get in a failing system and get ahead. Majority of will take her world as gospel and even take to heart and put it into practice, device chores for their kids as the ministers suggested “Watoto watajifunza lini kupika?” As if these kids’ aspirations are to become a kitchen girl or a garden boy? When chicken come to roost, I bet Ummy will be a minister of [choose your department], and we won’t remember she ordered the current outcome in yester-years. Ok is there any law to hold her accountable? Actually, no- plus she explicitly said she is merely executing her senior instructions without questioning them. Fall in line or you fall out! Political animal turned policy animal?</p><p>The true victim of not bad policy –but political “matamko” are the citizens, especially when matamko become the order of the day-they tend to impinge clear thinking if actually there is any thinking at all. It creates chaos! Nevertheless, even it demoralizes actors in the sector. We have the red queen effect in the opposite direction in our education system. Run at the same pace in giving matamko to remain in the same place when it comes to outcomes which matters for upward mobility.</p><p>If I was to be asked given the conditions of our public school, Minister Ummy and Ndalichako have their plate full. They should focus on getting sufficient number of teachers to schools, build enough schools, and all other necessary infrastructure and stay out of private citizen choices. After all they never have the right to determine what happen to people children after school-just as we don’t have a say for her own kids. Everyone should stick to their task.</p><p>If education is the greater equalizer that ensures upward mobility and Ummy has opinions about it which there is no any material way of making her accountable of those opinions, why should I take her seriously in her pleasantries public exchange about education? On the other hand, why should anyone else?</p><p>If the most important source of wealth in any economy is human capital, have we done a brilliant job in investing in our own human capital to a point it warrant to limit it? From the economic point of view which put value on human capital above all else as the most fundamental source of national wealth, when I look at Tanzania future accounting for Ndalichako and Ummy comments, I am less optimistic. Their statements only serves to limit Tanzanian youth energy, talent and ambition, and therefore they should not be taken seriously.</p><p>Dear parent, if you have to be named the tiger parent of the year, be it. Make sure your loved one get the best education money can offer. The free things are rare in this world — probably the only free thing I notice lately is Ummy statement nothing else is. Ummy advice is not to over-study, the advice to your child is not to under study for education is the only thing which is good and plenty in this world-so when it is passed around, you don’t want to be bashful, but reach out and take a big helping every time. You will find that education is the only thing lying around loose in this world, and that it is about the only thing a fellow can have as much as he/she is willing to haul away. Everything else is screwed down tight and the screwdriver is lost.</p><p>My ending quote today is from Piggy letters as usual {“the first thing that any education ought to give a man is character, and the second thing is education.}Remember this as you plan for your child education.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8a7509fde2a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>