<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Eli Lyons on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Eli Lyons on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@elilyons?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 23:19:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@elilyons/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Americans Love Crying in Their Car]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/americans-love-crying-in-their-car-3d3b30a1a2b0?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3d3b30a1a2b0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Apr 2026 04:13:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-29T04:15:03.825Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Why else would they record themselves doing it?</p><p>Is that a triggering enough title and subtitle? Are you mad at me? Are you getting ready for me to have a bad take?</p><p>What did you do the last time you saw a TikTok, a YouTube video, or an Instagram video of someone crying in their car? I would put my polymarket bet on…nothing. You did nothing. You evaluated. Were they in the right…were they overreacting….etc. You observed, you judged. You did nothing of note.</p><p>Americans have the highest rate of crying in their cars per capita.</p><p>I made up that statistic.</p><p>But it’s probably more likely to be accurate than the unemployment rate.</p><p>Should I have included an AI generated picture of someone crying in their car to increase engagment?</p><p>When I first moved to Japan in 2011. I saw a beautiful woman across from me on the train. She was dressed in that kind of classical elegant style that Japanese women in Tokyo aspire to, and often succeed at. Grammarly wants me to add a comma after ‘classical’. Fuck you. Don’t interrupt me. I’ll shut you off now.</p><p>Better.</p><p>So this beautiful woman, she was crying. And I happened to have a gucci hankerchief in my bag. My Japanese friend, one of my absolute solid motherfucking has my back, has put up with a lot of my shit when we were room mates in San Francisco friends, gave it to me. For my birthday maybe.</p><p>The train was quiet. People were ashamed to look. Because if you don’t see it, you don’t have to address it. Very Japanese. But everyone does it to different extents.</p><p>I went and offered the hankerchief. After an initial hesitation out of politeness, she took it. I couldn’t help think maybe she was a side-chick and found out the guy wouldn’t leave his wife or something. Maybe I thought that because she was spending so much money on her appearance when she was already beautiful. Maybe because I thought otherwise she would have finished crying when she was with the guy. Who knows.</p><p>When she got off the train she tried to give the hankerchief back, but I refused it. I gave it to her, I didn’t lend it. But I also kinda thought, look lady, you seem like you are gonna need this more than me.</p><p>That was in 2011. I still remember. I watched Perfect Blue a year or so ago. Might even watch it again this year. It’s too good. Movies like that are so good that most viewers can’t even comprehend how good it is. A creepy guy voyerhistically watches a performer, pretending she’s dancing on his hand. Later the creep gets a camcorder. The movie includes the early internet in the supporting cast. Prescient.</p><p>It’s 2026. Over the weekend one of the things I thought about is, when did I start to become more passive, more of an observer? COVID was one of the triggers. A lot of my friends were the same. But the factors compound. It all wears on you.</p><p>Of course Americans don’t love crying in their car. They’ve just built systems and structures that don’t work. Trusted when it wasn’t earned. Given in to their more hedonistic and selfish desires. Everyone wants attention. Everyone wants to be on stage. Oh, but not you, nono, you never do anything wrong, you never lose your shit. You do your job. You have the right opinions. You’re on the right side of everything.</p><p>No.</p><p>You’re the creep with the camcorder.</p><p>My first novel will be coming out in a month or two. It’s a psychological tech-noir.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3d3b30a1a2b0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Probalistic Fallacy of Smoke Detector Principle in Psychiatry]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/probalistic-fallacy-of-smoke-detector-principle-in-psychiatry-1299a0265ddf?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1299a0265ddf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Jan 2023 07:06:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-07T13:18:17.868Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Yikes</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SmzmmcjSU8o-gVz7-gzhTQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@keyursphotography?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Keyur Nandaniya</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/images/animals/lion?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The Smoke Detector Principle is used in clinical medicine, public health and psychiatry to explain emotions such as anxiety.</p><p>The very core concept is one I agree with, that an emotional response mechanism that includes a response to false alarms is a useful behaviour. However, there are three very problematic points in this ‘principle’ which really disturb me.</p><p>Here is a classical example of this principle:</p><p><em>The decision to flee from a noise that could have been made by a lion depends on the cost of a response (CR), the cost of not fleeing if the danger is present (CD) and the probability that the noise was made by a lion (pD). If a response provides complete protection, fitness is maximized by expressing a response whenever pD&gt; CR/CD.3 For example, a response that eliminates a 10 000-calorie cost of a lion attack will be worth its 100-calorie cost whenever pD &gt; 1/100, i.e. whenever the noise indicates a 1% or greater chance that a lion is present. This means that 99% of responses will be false alarms that are nonetheless normal (Table 1).</em></p><p>&lt;<a href="https://academic.oup.com/emph/article/2019/1/1/5229271">https://academic.oup.com/emph/article/2019/1/1/5229271</a>&gt;</p><h4>Issues</h4><ol><li>The principle uses ensemble probability instead of time probability. This is a mistake that Nassim Taleb has observed in other work and a topic which I find interesting &lt;<a href="https://medium.com/@elilyons/passion-and-time-probability-9d36765f7924">https://medium.com/@elilyons/passion-and-time-probability-9d36765f7924</a>&gt;. In the Smoke Detector Principle, the claim is that fitness in the presence of a lion is maximized by calorie cost. This is absurd. The fitness due to threat detection is maximized by something like the amount of increased survival time, or reproduction increase due to the increase of survival time (of course this also means an increase in calories consumed). A lion attack is what I called an ‘acute terminal event’ in my old essay. A simple example:</li></ol><p>Sample A, Let’s call them Lion Chow, does not have anxiety at all when a lion sound or similar sound is present. Lion Chow likes berries. On the 43rd time they are collecting berries a lion eats them. And then on the 44th time, they ARE NOT ALIVE TO COLLECT ANY FUCKING BERRIES.</p><p>Sample B, let’s call them Anxious Survivor, always has anxiety when they detect something that sounds like a lion. Anxious Survivor successfully collects berries 1000 times, and encounters 10 lions that they run from. They have 40 panic attacks during this period as well, due to false alarms. The PD= 20% according to the psychiatrists. However, 950 times Anxious Survivor went berry collecting they encountered no false alarms and no lions, so the calorie benefit for the person in a realistic non-ergodic system is actually much higher for the anxious survivor than predicted by the psychiatrists! Therefore the Anxious Survivor has time to reproduce, maybe a lot more time. Like, more than 10x the time Lion Chow had.</p><p>2. The analogy between a smoke detector and a human with anxiety is weak. First, a false detection by a smoke detector is a ‘minor annoyance’, but a false detection by a human leading to anxiety may be a larger problem. Second, a smoke detector has a detection threshold that is fairly consistent among all smoke detectors, while the detection ability by humans for danger may have a larger variance. Third, this analogy fails to include an element that is important, that modern technologies have increased information that can set off such a detector. The analogy may be improved if the smoke detector were replaced with ad-blocking or virus-scanning software on your computer, something else that scales. If all the smoke detectors in a 100-mile radius were connected to your apple watch or something, this would be no longer a minor annoyance.</p><p>3. If a field is naming something a ‘principle’ when it has fairly obvious major errors in it, this is a signal that something is wrong with the culture in the field. The people in the field are not rigorous enough. This is not that surprising to me considering the track record of the field of psychiatry (lobotomies, recent SRRI controversy…etc). More rigour, especially in statistics (and I consider myself very poor in statistics) is needed.</p><h4>Other fun stuff</h4><p>What if the Anxious Survivor population has an increase in chronic terminal events or weaknesses (e.g. arthritis) in old age due to the anxious response? This is probably what would be expected according to the work of Randolph M. Nesse.</p><p>Let’s add another character/sample in the mix.</p><p>Sample C, Lion Hunter, gets a boost of adrenalin in response to lion sounds. Their mind starts trying to find a way to kill the lion. They do kill it. When there is no lion they feel bored. Irritable. They sometimes drink too much. Collecting berries is boring. They don’t want to listen to the berry collectors talking about berries all day. They daydream of a lion to hunt.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1299a0265ddf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Debate is a Luxury]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/debate-is-a-luxury-c3e036b42999?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c3e036b42999</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Jan 2023 07:02:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-26T08:14:32.286Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>But torture in the classroom</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*vcjL73jKib0L77RgLACq7g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@evangelineshaw?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Evangeline Shaw</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/nwLTVwb7DbU?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>My previous essay &lt;<a href="https://medium.com/@elilyons/the-cases-when-ad-hominem-arguments-are-not-a-fallacy-c49e49316710">https://medium.com/@elilyons/the-cases-when-ad-hominem-arguments-are-not-a-fallacy-c49e49316710</a>&gt; was about a ‘logical fallacy’ that is often cited in social studies and classes that purport to teach you how to be prepared for the world through the deconstruction of, and practice of, arguing.</p><p>Formalized debates have always confused me, and my opinion has only moved from ‘this seems stupid’ in high school, to having more experience to further entrench in this position.</p><p>I remember two debate experiences, one in high school and one in college Chinese class. In the high school social studies class, we were split into teams and given some controversial topic — I believe ours was about terrorism used by the Palestinians. If I recall, we were provided with some articles discussing the topic and instructed on how to extract opinions and facts and put them on note cards for the debate. There was some kind of chess-like element to this exercise, where team members that like to get high marks try to predict what the other side will say in their opening argument and prepare rebuttals on note-cards for various scenarios. This might have been a traumatic experience for me, since I’m still talking about it.</p><p>I remember the sensation that something is wrong.</p><p>Why don’t we just talk with the opposing side and tell them which points we will neutralize and save everyone some time? How about we just hand the note cards to the judges and go for an early lunch? Only as an adult did I discover this is kinda what lawyers end up doing in practice.</p><p>The people that enjoy publicly debating are the kind of people that imitate the sounds of whatever porn star an algorithm shows them when they have sex. But are confident about it. Really lean into it.</p><p>Teachers may say something like if you want to be a lawyer you need to orally debate, but in reality, most legal work is writing arguments in essay format or mediating a conflict, sealing a deal.</p><p>In college, I was an exchange student in Taiwan. I had a class or two with a Taiwanese-born American student from UC Berkeley. She was kind of annoying — made sure everyone knew she was studying for MCATs. We were split into teams and given a day or two to prepare. The topic was whether it was ethical for Google to censor its results in China. Looking back, I kind of like this topic. I think my partner and I had a pro-google in China position (assigned?), and argued that the censorship was actually limited from Googles side. We googled some things like Tiananmen Square to verify the results were not as mainstream media sensationalized about Google.</p><p>The structure of the debate was different from the US style (this was the most interesting bit!). The UC Berkely google made her opening argument. I could tell from her argument that she had read the articles about Google’s presence in China, but had not tested anything herself.</p><p>In this debate style, I had a brief amount of time to ask questions in the debate as part of my rebuttal, almost like an interrogation. So I asked if she had actually performed the searches on the topics she had described. She replied with some kind of description of her sources or something, then I pressed her about not answering my simple question. She tried to ramble and the teacher also may have interjected, trying to get her to answer the question. The student started crying. She complained the debate structure in the US was different (in a tone that implied ‘better’). The teacher, while recognizing the childishness of the student, also recognized the debate had degenerated into <em>somebody needs a nap</em>. So the teacher cancelled the debate.</p><p>This was actually an excellent lesson! In the real world, the opportunities to have a serious debate are rare. I actually think this is how most debates in school should go. Halfway through it gets cancelled, or the judges intentionally vote for the worse team. You have three judges, and one asks each team leader in private for a bribe. This would make the exercise much more useful. If a student reports this bribe, the administration may or may not look into and then the judge gets detention and the teacher gets a warning. The whole exercise repeats next year.</p><p>There are at least three reasons why debate is a luxury, to be enjoyed among friends, family, and lovers, and not something that should be formalized and practised as a team exercise. Debates are a way to improve mental models, but academia and popular culture have neutered this dog, added too much coconut milk to this curry, taken away the parts that make it what is what meant to be in the real world.</p><h4>One — Power and Social Structures</h4><p>True debate almost exclusively occurs when two conditions are both satisfied:</p><ol><li>Power between all parties in the proposed debate is close to equal.</li><li>All parties want to engage in the debate, and are able to engage in the emotional journey that may occur as their mental models are changed.</li></ol><p>Debate rarely occurs because in many human social structures, like companies, a large city government, or a television show claiming to discuss the major issues and current events, the managers of these organizations often act to <em>suppress</em> it. This is because someone in charge stands to lose something tangible from a potential debate.</p><p>The first rule of debate, is you don’t talk about debate club. In our current world a respectable debate should be antisocial in nature like Fight Club. What is so appealing about fight club, is that it hit on emotions that real men at the time were feeling, and continue to feel- that the ideas they are presented with of what a good life is, and the modern life many men lead, is missing something, and that even discussing this thing, or the activity of doing what this something is — is a threat to corporations and social structures. Therefore, it must be done in secret.</p><p>That’s why there are so few debates in adult life. Power is rarely distributed evenly, and people are rarely emotionally strong enough to engage sincerely in debate. As anxiety and depression increase [<a href="https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)02143-7/fulltext">1</a>][<a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/07/12/a-growing-number-of-american-teenagers-particularly-girls-are-facing-depression/">2</a>], the probability of debate decreases, people can’t handle a serious debate in that state, maybe even a minor one.</p><p>One of the things I’ve noticed is that not all families have a genuine debate and this seems to have a deep emotional effect and colour the nature of how people perceive debates as adults. What kind of discussion can you have at the dinner table? How did people behave? Is this now your expectation every time you start to argue with others?</p><h4>Two—Incentives to keep secrets</h4><p>Often there are incentives for someone not to debate, especially if they have a minority viewpoint. This is because secrets, and correct predictions, sometimes lead to making money if there are mechanisms available to someone to do so. Stock trading is a great example. Stock traders don’t engage in much debate, they put skin in the game (or could be argued often put other people’s skin in the game). As a personal example, I invested in Uranium before it took off and before the war in Ukraine. Nuclear power had become unpopular in many countries. My opinion was that ‘renewable energies’ have significant problems at this time and in the past, and nuclear power is more environmentally friendly and safer than people perceive it to be. I didn’t bother engaging in debate with anyone on this topic. I just made a bet that many people would discover they were wrong about nuclear in the future, maybe after some energy crisis. (One point I hadn’t considered at the time, that makes nuclear even more appealing, is that a country relying on sources outside of sovereign territory for energy is a moral hazard that can be removed through the use of nuclear). If I had engaged in debate on this topic it is possible I could have changed a few people’s minds, but almost certainly not enough to change public policy, and I would have spent the time doing so with no benefit to myself.</p><p>Debate is kind of reserved for things that can’t be immediately tested, or if a party cannot obtain a reward for their opinion without changing someone else&#39;s. For example, abortion rights. I (hopefully) can’t easily make money off of a change of policy in abortion rights that I predict or prefer, but society becomes better, and we can all benefit, when there is consensus on abortion rights and that is reflected in policy. Similarly, in my company, we are well-incentivized to have the same opinions on how the company should operate, so there’s a return on investment on debate.</p><p>The best way to change someone’s mind is through empirical proof. Sports competition, company trade secrets and proprietary processes, other kinds of experiments, show through evidence that some idea, some method, works better than another. Empirical proof is the debate killer.</p><p>Often trying to change someone’s mind is a difficult task with no guarantee of reward, usually because of the reasons listed in part One above. Add to that all sorts of issues, like opinions as a part of someone’s identity, the destabalizing effect of changing someone’s mental model of the world to the point it’s like breaking their inner reality, and it can be seen that not only is there often little incentive to debate, it can actually be costly. To be clear, this is not to argue debate should never be done, but to clarify the judgement required to know when it is useful and beneficial, and to further elaborate on why it can be a gift, a luxury.</p><h4>Three — Dulling of the mind</h4><p>Debate becomes a greater luxury as the number of people with the ability to participate in the activity at a high level decreases, and/or the environment is such that fewer opportunities appear that meet the requirements laid out for debate in part One.</p><p>This leads to two questions:</p><ol><li>Are people (especially younger people) getting better or worse at being able to model the world and debate?</li><li>If there is a change is critical thinking ability/modeling, what is the cause?</li></ol><p>These are some questions that I don’t have good answers to, but are worth investigating and pontificating on.</p><p>The highest-profile debates are performative in nature, presidential debates or TV news show debates. For presidential debates, the plans to accomplish goals are not described in enough detail to asses, and there is no analysis of the how often a president or politician executed plans or achieved goals that they declared in debates. In news shows, the debate performed to make the audience feel good about there existing position. A warm blanket for a cold world.</p><p>Other examples of performative debates are podcasts like Joe Rogan or Lex Friedman when they have someone like Mark Zuckerberg on, or a venture capitalist. First, Joe Rogan and Lex Friedman have little expertise in the areas that are topics worthy of discussion and debate with their guests (e.g. censorship). Second, there is no expert that has an opposing view to press the guests in any serious way. Often times they are some type of friend or in the same social circle. Nowadays, Jordan Peterson, who came to fame largely due to his preparation for debate with very ignorant interviewers with virtually no scientific training, is now regularly getting interviewed by his daughter on his podcast (ep. 322). This happened in a matter of years.</p><p>In act two of episode 402 of This American Life (great episode!), an inside look into a philosophical debate that has been held since 1998 at the University of Montevallo- The Life Raft debate.</p><p>The premise is that global catastrophe (e.g. nuclear war) and the student body (the audience) have a life raft with one last spot remaining. Six professors, each representing an academic department, must make the case that they deserve the last spot on the life raft.</p><p>The podcast looks into how over years the debate devolved into gimmicks and entertainment, the professors making lame appeals to the student&#39;s shallow desires and weak characters.</p><p>Fortunately, every year they also have a Devil’s Advocate, who every year advocates for not selecting any professor for the position on the life raft. Usually the Devil’s Advocate fails, except in 2007, when an untenured English professor goes off-script to criticize the lack of actual argument contributed by any of the department representatives. It reminded me how easy it is for entertainment to trump debate if people are not careful. The Devil’s Advocate gave some great examples of pathetic arguments that these professors made. It’s also a great example of how things are not always getting better, even in small communities.</p><p>[potentially add something here after reading The Coddling of the American Mind]</p><p>[potentially add something from The Myth of Normal]</p><p>One thing I notice as a generational shift, is that gen z has lots of opinions on topics that my friends and I had zero opinions on at the same age. We were busy studying and/or trying to make money to live independently. So it’s hard to compare, but it seems now gen z has a stronger emotional attachment to abstract ideas and internet cultural phenomena, which is related to the ability to debate. I suspect that this is due to a fundamental <em>feeling</em> of lack of control of their lives and rich personal lives, or of something that provides a sense of security. The comedian Jen Kirkman (Gen Xer) has a great bit where she says Gen X forgot to tell Gen Z that there’s nothing much you can do to win against the powers that be, Gen X tried. Jen sympathizes with Gretta Thunberg, but she just wants to put her arm around her and teach her how to smoke a cigarette.</p><p>Now young people worship half-baked youtube stars that give 5 min answers on complex topics. The loyalty and adoration to these stars gives the sense of looking for religion. At the same time, Millennials use tiktok nearly the same amount as gen z [<a href="https://thesocialshepherd.com/blog/tiktok-statistics#:~:text=TikTok%20is%20Most%20Popular%20With%20Younger%20Generations&amp;text=Ages%2010%2D19%20are%2025,49%20is%2020.3%25%20of%20users.">source</a>], but Millenials didn’t <em>grow up</em> with the same technology. Didn’t Americans always worship celebrity to some degree? However, I never worshipped celebrities when I was in my twenties, and few of my friends seemed to either. This leads me to ask, has celebrity worship increased? Yes, it seems so [<a href="http://www.jssshonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/JSSSH_Vol.7_No.1_2021_66-75_Sr.-No.7.pdf">source</a>].</p><p>Two youtube videos I saw recently really struck a cord on how many people don’t even have a shared understanding of fundamental facts and reasonable expectations anymore. One was an interview video that Aba and Preach reviewed, that asked women what salary they wanted a male partner to have [<a href="https://youtu.be/BGQiVTEABBs">source</a>]. What was fascinating is that they each had a desired salary for a potential male partner, yet had extremely poor knowledge of salary distributions for men, and all guessed too high (by a LOT) for median salaries and top 1% salaries. Another video was by a health exercise YouTuber, who shared that when he shared his fitness gains, many people criticized him for not making impressive enough gains, and other people claimed his gains were so much that he must be using steroids [<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nf2AbgYg724&amp;ab_channel=ATHLEAN-X%E2%84%A2">source</a>]. I just don’t think this was the case twenty years ago. People’s model of reality for these kinds of things was more accurate. Hyperreality.</p><p>It’s a strange thing to observe. For me, my psychology follows maslov’s hierarchy pretty closely. When I was young and poor, I had to work so hard that I would fall asleep at any break I could get. I had trouble sleeping, not because of anxiety, but because I was sleeping on the floor, or a couch, or a piece of foam. Or because I had a literal roommate who was making noise, or I could hear a flatmate having sex, or I had just finished my shift as a security guard and my body was still wound up. I would sleep on the train and on the bus. I would find a place at university, a couch in the student union, or even behind the couch if it was occupied, and sleep on the floor in the hour between my classes, and then startle and shock the new people who had rotated onto the couch when I woke. If I took a twenty-minute nap I might dream. I struggled to be alert in the next class. I felt disoriented. I felt physically terrible all the time. But not anxious or depressed. I envisioned a day when I could buy a house and have a highly skilled job that did a bit of good. Maybe I could have a wife that appreciated me. Today people feel ill because of their relationship with the world or society, independent of their basic needs being met. Because of things they are told to want. They fantasize about being youtube and tiktok stars when this just further moves to the commodification of the individual by corporations [<a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/social-media-influencers-86-of-young-americans-want-to-become-one/">source</a>][<a href="https://twitter.com/LukeMiani/status/1603127879113523201">source</a>].</p><p>I suspect most people’s brains are just not meant to handle the current internet and predatory anti-social societies. Maybe the threat of a predatory environment presented in media, even if it is not actually imminent, is enough to cause distress like a real imminent threat for many people. Hyperreality. Maybe in a sense, their basic needs <em>are not</em> being met. I suppose I have felt anxious sometimes when I have thought about the future of society or my own. Tim Dillon had a great bit on that recently at the end of his episode 328. His only 2023 prediction was that there would be more public high-profile mental breakdowns. He cited Kanye West and Elon Musk in 2022 as just funny samples from society as a whole.</p><blockquote>“We are having a kind of collective mental collapse as a society. We know how fake everything is. We know how unfair everything is. And we’re all expected to keep going along. We have flashing lights in our face every minute. And new apps and gadgets and contratpions that keep us distracted. The onslaught of news coming into anybody’s palm of their hand, in their phone, even if you only paid attention to a tiny bit of it, you would start to lose your mind. It would be impossible to feel safe, anywhere….It’s causing a collective mental breakdown.”</blockquote><blockquote>“You gotta be strong person for your brain to not be melted….You have to be able to block out a lot of stuff…If you’re too sensitive now, if you let too much in, you’ll be destroyed, that’s all<em>…”</em></blockquote><p>There are too many factors. I’d like to have a view of people a hundred years ago. Maybe things haven’t changed much. Maybe it’s just the exposure, the information. Maybe it’s the new forms of manipulation. But people have always been in pain, and looked for relief.</p><p>I’ve been thinking about alcohol since New Years was a few days ago and I had a wicked hangover. I have to be careful with alcohol, not necessarily because of what I do when I’m drunk or that I am in danger of becoming an alcoholic, but because I actually kind of like hangovers, I think at this age I’m a connoisseur. I appreciate the dulling of the mind, the muted senses, the indifference. It reduces my hypervigilance to a pleasant degree. I think ‘this is what it’s like to be normal’. I’m reminded of when I was out to dinner with my ex-girlfriend and a drunk guy on the sidewalk was potentially going to fall over a railing into the street. My ex said something like “That guy looks like he’s blahblah…” and I said, “I see him.” Distressed and anxious, she asked me to explain. What I meant is that I’d seen him before she had, I was watching him while she had been talking, and would intervene if he seemed to be in imminent danger. It’s all of those little things that can go away with a proper hangover. Sometimes a break is nice. Most people are on a break for hours at a time every day. Instagram, Youtube, TikTok, Netflix…etc. Life is hard, it’s hard to find the will to keep the mind sharp.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c3e036b42999" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Cases When Ad Hominem Arguments are Not a Fallacy]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/the-cases-when-ad-hominem-arguments-are-not-a-fallacy-c49e49316710?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c49e49316710</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[succession]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Dec 2022 06:41:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-04T08:52:13.270Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Oh the falshoods they teach in school</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Xg57tjND0FguH_B55fl3kQ.png" /></figure><p>I almost failed out of high school. And after being a PhD student at a top university, publishing scientific research, and working in industry, I can say with confidence that I was right about the pointlessness of most of high school ‘education’. However, not only is high school often a waste of time, you can actually learn the wrong things. Sometimes in college as well. I remember a class called Critical Thinking. I remember Logical Fallacies. Yet, I believe you can learn more of value from watching the show Succession than from a year of high school or a college Critical Thinking course.</p><p>(very minor spoiler alert)</p><p>There’s a scene in Succession where Kendal is in a tough position in a power struggle for his father’s company and gives Tom a pitch to team up. Tom rejects Kendal’s sneaky offer:</p><blockquote>“Having been around a bit, my hunch is that you’re (Kendal) going to get fucked. Because I’ve seen you get fucked, a lot. and I’ve never seen Logan get fucked once.”</blockquote><p>And this is why ad hominem arguments are not always fallacies.</p><p>This is also why Nassim Taleb uses phrases like ‘Intellectual Yet Idiot’.</p><p>What schools teach is that arguments need to follow something like boolean logic to be correct, and these are the kinds of arguments we should present publicly or in a debate. This is misleading. Arguments need to be useful. Ad hominem attacks are often useful for multiple reasons and I’ll cover two important ones here:</p><h4>One</h4><p>The case when the audience has difficulty assessing the logic used by a party in the debate, but can assess an ad hominem attack. This is kinda like what Trump does, sometimes passive-aggressively. This resonates with people because debates are just words, but character often matters more in many real-world situations. For example, say I tell some guy I am going to kick his ass. It doesn’t matter if I explain why I think that to be true, we’ll probably have to find out the truth through experimentation. That’s what’s going on in Ukraine now — playground logic. If I tell my friend I will meet him for lunch tomorrow but I flaked on him last time, it doesn’t matter how good my argument is, it matters if I have the kind of character that shows up. Most real-world (meaning a place that’s not a classroom) situations are <em>not </em>abstract discussions of logic, but rather discussions about what will happen in the future, or what we should actually do! Execution matters. I’m not promoting this ad hominem use case, but it has utility.</p><h4>Two</h4><p>Ad hominem arguments work when they represent a collection of events so complex, that all the data samples can’t be analyzed in detail clearly, or when a previous sample and a current sample are only vaguely similar. This is what most people learn from a young age, and why this logical fallacy has always seemed a bit off to me. Just like Tom, we know some people are often right and some people are often wrong. In the end, that’s much more information, like a meta-analysis on prediction accuracy, and more robust, than analyzing the inductive logic of an argument. This is perfectly useful and may lead to the correct result more than an attempt at analyzing a complex situation with many unknowns (isn’t a debate usually this case?), especially if you think probabilistically anyway. That’s how machine learning and such methods work as well. So Tom thinks that there’s a higher probability that Logan won’t get fucked and Kendal will, that’s what his training data predicts. No boolean logic. And it’s completely ad hominem.</p><p>The real world is extremely complex. You cannot even articulate all the processing going on in your brain in a debate. Note that Tom doesn’t say he thinks Logan will always win in the future, which is another common error, making incorrect predictions when the number of observations is low, he is just making a decision based on the observations he has so far…Tom is the modern day philosopher we didn’t know we needed. So the nuance is that ad hominim attacks are not always a fallacy, but even when they are not, they do not guarantee a correct result.</p><p>Of course, using this method of assessing an argument or predicting the future needs to be constrained by the context of the training data. For example, Tom is kinda considering Kendal’s argument in the context of business. People naturally trust experts in a field (sometimes too much), and what seems to be happening lately (or always has?) is that people start to apply that trust outside the context of the training data. For example, Elon Musk becomes a trusted source on ethics or in a somewhat new technology area, and creates a company that doesn’t deliver what it promises.</p><p>Usually, you have a friend that is a trusted source for the best restaurants, another that has good taste in movies, or another friend that always picks the wrong man to pursue. You don’t always need to pick apart the argument about why this one is <em>not</em> different from the other ones they’ve pursued, in fact, probably one of the reasons that won’t work is because one of the presented facts is just wrong and you have no way to prove it yet. “He has a great sense of humour!” cannot be argued against easily. “<em>You</em> have a poor sense of humour” is ad hominem, but also shows the reason they often picked the wrong man, they cannot consciously perceive the quality and nature of their judgement objectively.</p><p>Finally, ad hominim arguments include the ‘appeal to authority’ fallacy, because anytime you attack someone’s character, this is equivalent of saying the person is not an authority, and if the opinion of an authority is appealed to, this is ad hominim because it implies the opposing party opinion is not equally credible. I notice this is also often used when the person executing the fallacy does not have sufficient technical skills to analyze a situation or is lazy…etc. Of course sometimes appeals to authority can also yield the correct results, but often not…Remember when parents and universities told you going college would allow everyone to have a middle-class life, a life of luxuries like a house and maybe a german car? You MUST master the five paragraph essay! That will prepare you!</p><p>My next essay will be on why <em>debates</em> are a luxury.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c49e49316710" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Most Important Lesson from the Kanye West Documentary Jeen-Yus]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/the-most-important-lesson-from-the-kanye-west-documentary-jeen-yus-fbf59aa86746?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbf59aa86746</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Oct 2022 11:10:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-20T15:07:25.126Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Lesson on Power Distribution and Limit Setting</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1012/1*5qnXWZt23DWiN0vdKQCNPw.png" /></figure><p>The Jeen-Yus documentary followed a video-maker Coodie Simmons as he started his career following Kanye West on his journey, and shows the meteoric rise of Kanye and some of his personal challenges. It’s a bit of a tragedy/parable because once Kanye gets all the fame and money he wanted, his mental illness seemingly becomes more severe and goes largely unchecked. It’s a great demonstration that using American popular culture definitions of success hide a dangerous moral hazard, or many.</p><p><strong>The first moral hazard, is that it is dangerous not to set limits on oneself.</strong> This contradicts catchphrase marketing ideologies such as ‘Be all you can be’, ‘Just Do It’, or the concept of living without limits — obtaining as much money as you can, for example. The world would be a nightmare if everyone followed these catchphrases at face value.</p><p>For example, maybe it was not a good idea for Kanye to run for president. And from the documentary it seemed Kanye had surrounded himself with ‘yes-men’, which is a pattern that seems to happen to many people who’s resources exceed their judgement. If Kanye didn’t have so much money and power that he could pay people for everything, maybe he would have a friend that would have told him <em>not to </em>run for president, not just because it may create a distraction from other issues in his life, but the backlash may actually be damaging.</p><p>A prime example from the documentary of this moral hazard is when Kanye is having a meeting with some real estate agents in the Dominican Republic. Kanye suggests creating a church in the area. In the next moment he’s asking the real estate agents, “Have you guys ever been locked up in handcuffs and put into a hospital because your brain was too big for your skull?” and as things continue Kanye gets more riled up and rants, possibly having a minor episode, with zero response from all the people there. The problem is that Kanye West pays almost everyone there, or they would like to be paid by Kanye. To his credit, Coodie turns the camera off, clearly concerned for his old friend that by this time has drifted away into a new life.</p><blockquote>At a high level of wealth, the wealthy person obtains centralized power/judgement to such a degree that it is inevitable that a they make a huge mistake. A scenario is created in which a psychological ‘blind spot’ cannot be covered, due to the social structure that the wealthy person operates in, which has been created by the wealthy person themselves.</blockquote><p>I wonder if Kanye would have actually been happier if he had only made 2 million or 10 million dollars. It’s even possible he may not have developed such serious mental illness because he would have worked less, not entered into a marriage where he would get divorced, and been put into a situation early on where he’d have to asses his mental well-being and outward behaviour because of the influence of other people.</p><p>How to solve this moral hazard? What if Kanye had setup a company with a bylaw that automatically donated all profits after 10 million? Maybe you’d have to have a trigger to automatically reduce his voting power at the company at the same time. Of course the same characteristics required to succeed at such a high level are probably what prevents one from setting such healthy limits. What if society had a limit on wealth (will return to that later)?</p><p>Often times limits for an activity are most effective if they are created before one starts the activity. That’s my experience anyway. It’s because when you are engaged in the present you have trouble mentally simulating the future. If I have something to do in the morning and I’m going to a party, I like to decide in advance the latest I’ll stay at the party, or maybe the maximum number of drinks I’ll have. It’s harder to set reasonable limits on oneself when you are under the influence of alcohol, fame, or something with an addictive quality. However, this strategy creates a difficult situation, in which a present you, needs to trust the past you, or assess the present situation and see if it matches the constraints that the past you made a decision under. For example, maybe I’ll have another drink if there is something to celebrate I wasn’t expecting.</p><p>A great example of the cognitive differences between Japanese people and Americans regarding limits when selecting a mate. It’s become a main-stream cultural discussion point that American woman are looking for a man that makes six figures, but in Japan, their hopes are exceedingly more realistic &lt;<a href="https://soranews24.com/2018/05/12/japanese-women-show-continuing-decline-in-how-much-they-expect-a-husband-to-earn-in-survey/">https://soranews24.com/2018/05/12/japanese-women-show-continuing-decline-in-how-much-they-expect-a-husband-to-earn-in-survey/</a>&gt;. Anecdotally, I have been told (and/or read quotes somewhere?) that Japanese sometimes don’t want their husbands to make <strong>too much </strong>money, because they believe it increases the chances of the husband having an affair or over-working.</p><p>And then there are times when you should move personal limits. When it comes to competition, maybe you turn off your limits completely. It’s okay to hurt a competitor under the rules of competition, but you don’t want to hurt your training partners. Maybe you run that 10k race as hard as you can. But this shows that removing limits is the rare case, not the normal day-to-day.</p><p><strong>The second moral hazard is that it’s dangerous for a society not to set proper upper limits. </strong>This may come off as banal, but I never hear people in America talking about it even though they talk about the problems in the country all the time. For example, what should the limits on the power of the president really be? As of October 8, 2022, President Biden has signed 102 executive orders, and Trump signed 220. Should there be a limit on the total number of executive orders a president can issue? Or, since some of them have ultimately failed, as they were not legal, should the privilege of issuing an executive order be taken away if a threshold of bad orders is reached (e.g. 3 orders that are illegal)? Should there be a limit on personal wealth? Should there be a limit on the market cap of a private company? I would say yes to all, because they create extremely dangerous scenarios. The whole concept of the formation of the US government was distribution of power, which creates checks and balances, of which Kanye West is severely lacking.</p><p>A limit is a boundary, and it’s useful to implement them both at the societal level, and also at the personal one. When I was living in San Francisco, where people are very flaky and often don’t make concrete plans, I came up with a limit, two flakes and I won’t make an appointment with that person again. After the first flake/cancellation I would explain my rule so my boundary was understood. Meanwhile I would watch friends and acquaintances without clear limits treat each time as a first rodeo, and complain or be upset each and everytime when someone canceled on them to go to a concert or a better party. While it’s reasonable to be upset when you get flaked on, if it happens regularly it’s a personal responsibility to manage the situation. For example by filtering your friends for characteristics by clarifying your boundaries/expectations.</p><p>Returning to the national level, what exactly are the limits on central banks? By looking at Japan for example, having no limits on the purchase of government bonds is a huge moral hazard. Having no limit on debt is a moral hazard. Japan at a national level has basically gone insane this past decade — by repeating the same behaviour (Quantitative Easing) and expecting a different result even though it has failed every year. Many cities in the US have gone bankrupt precisely because the limits for debt (as municipal bonds) was not low enough and the city didn’t grow as much as expected or businesses left...etc so the city couldn’t pay back the debt it took out.</p><p>I’ve only bet money at a casino once (I left the table when I was up!), but that’s a place where you probably want to set a limit on acceptable losses before you start, and really many things are like that. And then the question arises, should the casino to set a limit on how much a person can lose before they have to stop?</p><p>There’s always tension between society and the individual, which should be healthy, it’s when there is not tension, not checks and balances, when an individual or an organization grows too powerful, <strong>that</strong> is when problems occur.</p><p>Of course now I’m basically just getting into regulations, about rules. A rule is often a limit, but often binary. For example, in some places you can’t drink alcohol in public, it’s a binary rule, a limit of anything &gt;0. But often rules with limits are for behaviours that are good in moderation, that we want to encourage, like drinking and driving. Oh no wait, I mean like gambling, errr, I meant to say activities that are good in moderation. Wealth generating, like making rap albums and fashion lines, or useful technologies like search engines or social media. Making money is good, but too much in a centralized place, maybe not, in the long-term.</p><p>Failure to set limits is possibly where the greatest failure has been in the last decade (well, there were many failures of the sort in the last century). Technology improves at a faster rate and the quality of the political leadership may not be improving at all. It seems painfully obvious social media should have been regulated ten years ago (considering current conditions, parents should be regulating it at home). My friend Kento brought up a good example today, that it seems likely the A.I. based realistic photo-generation will be available soon for the consumer. For example, say a high schooler spreads a rumor that a classmate had sex with the whole football team, and then provides a photo to prove it (A.I. generated). Maybe the bully quickly has the A.I. Software create 200 photos that are used for cyberbullying. While this could be handled as cyber bullying in the courts, maybe to prevent this situation, there should be a limit on the realism that a person, in control of a photo or video generator, can create of an individual, without the individual&#39;s consent. There likely aren’t that many laws that thoroughly cover this as the problem did not exist before. This is a good example because memes are funny, but deepfakes often less so.</p><p><strong>Setting lower limits tends to be more obvious than setting upper limits in a philisophical/ethical sense, but even there I find thought-provoking issues to consider. </strong>For example, returning to the topic of wealth, it is more obvious to people that in society there is a minimum on the resources we should provide to people who are vulnerable and suffering. The elderly, the physically injured, the mentally injured or limited, but really, there is a moral argument that the quality of a society is largely evaluated by the lower limits of human experience that exist in the society. Often these questions are:</p><p>To what level are the weakest or the minority raised up?</p><p>Is there any lower limits to the pain and suffering people in the society can experience legally? How does this balance with freedom of the individual?</p><p>Many developed countries have a formal support system for wealth (e.g. social security) or discrimination (e.g. constitutional rights). And it seems to me smaller communities are less tolerant of people in the community suffering in the lower limits. I’m reminded of my Aunt’s husband finding an elderly relative in Ireland, a former farmer, and while clearly living the old man was living in poverty, he had neighbours that would stop by and care for him. Then getting to the individual level, what are appropriate lower limits? Some things are maybe obvious, 10,000 steps a day they say. Or returning to an earlier topic, making sure to have <em>at least</em> three beers before you get behind the wheel. Focusing on the individual interacting in society, what is the minimum frequency that you call your parents? What is the minimum that you talk to your friends to maintain the friendship? Maybe it’s unnecessary to quantify, but thought-provoking. What is the poorest I allow my friend to become before I help them?</p><p>As I’ve described, I notice that many problems occur when people have not decided on the upper and lower bounds that are acceptable at the personal, community, and national level. The tragedy is that it’s often easier to identify the upper and lower limits that are acceptable than the optimal level to achieve. For example, it’s difficult to answer:</p><p>What’s the optimal level of debt for the country to have?</p><p>What’s the optimal percentage to spend on defense budget?</p><p>What’s the optimal amount of stock portfolio to split between stocks and bonds? (If you say ‘60/40’ then you didn’t check your portfolio this year)</p><p>What’s the optimal term for the president or a congress-person?</p><p>I could go on and on with difficult questions no one can give me good answers to. But often you can easily know when something is too much or too little.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbf59aa86746" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Esteem, Identity, and Reality]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/on-esteem-identity-and-reality-dfd1bc35295c?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dfd1bc35295c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Sep 2022 06:55:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-29T00:36:54.844Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I just want the insanity to stop.</p><p>I suppose it’s my fault, I watched one too many youtube videos, read too many headlines, and listened to too many explanations.</p><p>You could say that I was better off not knowing the reality of the situation.</p><p>In physics, there is a concept called ‘frame of reference’ which clarifies the context in which a scenario or problem is discussed.</p><p><strong>Example one:</strong> Electricity is moving on a wire and creating an electric field. What direction is the electric field in? Well, the orientation of the electric field is created by the direction of the electric current, so the frame of reference of the electric field is usually based on the electric current direction.</p><p><strong>Example two:</strong> Two people are traveling at radically different speeds, maybe Bob, an astronaut, goes traveling in space nearly at the speed of light compared to his friend Janet who is staying on earth. When Bob returns his friends all throw him a big party. At the party Janet’s alcoholic sister asks, “how long was he gone?” The physicist from NASA glares at her, has two more drinks quietly, and gets in a fender bender on the way home. &lt;<a href="https://www.phy.olemiss.edu/HEP/QuarkNet/time.html">https://www.phy.olemiss.edu/HEP/QuarkNet/time.html</a>&gt;.</p><p>People often use the word ‘perspective’, which shares some of the meaning with frame of reference, but perspective includes ‘attitude’.</p><p><strong><em>Perspective: </em></strong><em>a particular attitude towards or way of regarding something; a point of view.</em></p><p>Pay attention when someone’s giving you directions for something, driving directions, directions on how to disarm a bomb in Mission Impossible 6, or how to box. Do they give the directions from your frame of reference or theirs? I pay attention to that a lot, because I think people are the same for everything &lt;<a href="https://elilyons.medium.com/the-cultural-adjustment-curve-and-the-hype-cycle-curve-are-similar-because-people-are-the-same-for-51eccfed9a6d">https://elilyons.medium.com/the-cultural-adjustment-curve-and-the-hype-cycle-curve-are-similar-because-people-are-the-same-for-51eccfed9a6d</a>&gt;. When people discuss social issues, it seems to me they almost always use their favorite group of people, or themselves, as the frame of reference.</p><p>In America, this seems to be especially pronounced, as many people have a psychological identity that is partially based on a vague political affiliation.</p><p>I notice that a lot of people say things without creating a frame of reference, some extremists use a frame of reference that does not characterize the reality that most people are sharing.</p><p>For example, let’s take the concept of self-esteem. Self-esteem is the model a person builds in their mind of their worth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/230/1*KYuSJMI5RBeh6jVjKHqs5g.png" /></figure><p>Another way to evaluate someone’s worth is by public perception, we could call that ‘public esteem’ or something.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y-jrIT11HQGP_2iyQIwcBQ.png" /></figure><p>Now, someone like Jordan Peterson says something like, “only public esteem is important” (He actually just released a video titled “The Idea That Identity Is Subjectively Defined Is Utterly Preposterous”…well your title-making is preposterous…how about “Identity is Not Subjective” or “Subjectively Defining Identity is Preposterous”….Who’s the alpha daddy now?…Anyway, this is what he thinks:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cuvOrjgliJHdwHep5YHY7A.png" /></figure><p>And then someone else says, “No, what I think about myself is the most important thing and what the public thinks doesn’t matter, or they should agree with my mental model.” (I actually don’t know, or care, what Elliot Page says, maybe Page doesn’t think that, this is just an example).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OYEbxeziVl6kYmz1ugn7Dw.png" /></figure><p>The larger frame of reference is something like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1008/1*ZnPqZjtwMwA8E2YhtwuaIA.png" /></figure><p>In a reference where an individual with self-esteem interacts with a public, both the self and the public perspectives are essential in modelling the system, and this can be called ‘Comprehensive Esteem’. How important is each component comparatively? Who fuckin knows. That’s non-generalizable. Depends on the situation. But basically, people who put x or y as zero values in the equation above are nuts.</p><p>Change esteem out for ‘identity thing’ and we can observe similar phenomena occurring (mostly in America).</p><p>I suspect one of the reasons this is such an emotional subject for many people, is because this is a fundamental component to building a model of how society works, and even reality itself.</p><p>We build a shared reality by communicating and agreeing on the fundamental things we observe and measure with a high degree of certainty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9nxkqMdy_XhiDdBdXeAD1A.png" /></figure><p>Of course we still have our own inner realities that are different from someone else’s reality. We have our personal lives, and we have different sets of information about the larger world. Sometimes a guy with a tie on has some information they don’t want to share with the public in order to make money, this is called ‘insider trading’. But usually we agree on fundamental aspects of reality that we are sharing experiences of, like the weather yesterday or how chocolate cake tastes. And we each have our own low confidence predictions that we don’t need to agree on, like who will be the next president.</p><p>Things get weird when people get confident about things that don’t warrant confidence. It’s an emotional thing. Lots of reasons. In my experience most people can’t deal with uncertainty, it causes them too much anxiety (maybe it was different in the past when people’s lives were different?). Or they want to show someone they are knowledgable about politics, or they want their life experience to be respected.</p><p>When you discover your model of shared reality is drastically wrong, like someone discovering their spouse has been cheating on them (an example from Jordan Peterson), it’s extremely jarring in a deep way, and that’s one thing I would agree with him on. It’s a shock that’s difficult for humans to process — when they discover their inner model of reality was way off, that’s for sure. I think it’s the shared reality parts that involve people, that we want to be consistent, probably because that’s how we survive as social animals.</p><p>Communication is really important to build a shared model of reality. Problems seem to occur when someone builds a model of reality without any input from other people, or a large group of people builds a model that is totally wrong and refuses input from another group of people or fails to include new information in their model of reality.</p><p>After listening to the Supernova in the East podcast miniseries by Hardcore History, I often think about this. When the US entered WW2, it was clear early on that Japan could not defeat the US. Even ignoring the atomic bomb factor, the Japanese had access to the information that allowed them to estimate that the US would build waaaay more planes than them. Yet they continued to fight for a long time. Before the US entered the war, Japan may have been producing more planes than the US, but even in the first year (1941) the US entered the war, the US produced 47,836 planes, compared with 8,861 by Japan. By the end of the war the US had produced 324,750 planes by itself, compared with Japan, Germany, and Italy producing 206,813 COMBINED. I mean it’s just nutsos &lt;<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_aircraft_production">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_aircraft_production</a>&gt;. I really wonder what they were thinking.</p><p>Another great story from the podcast was about the hazing of Japanese soldiers in the Pacific. A new Japanese recruit would be pressured to torture and mutilate a prisoner of war. Then, the officers would tell them something like, “Now if the foreigners catch you, they will do the same to you! So you must fight until the bitter end! Till your last breath!”</p><p>But in reality, the foreigners did not reciprocate the behaviour. In the minds of the Australians, they thought the Japanese were war machines, total twisted psychopaths, and they better make sure they shoot them dead for their personal safety. But the Australians weren’t into torture, and there was no open communication between the two parties.</p><p>The idea that Japanese soldiers had such a wrong model of reality, with high certainty, and that it had such a visceral result, really sticks with me. Every single day the behaviour of the Japanese soldiers was so strongly shaped by completely wrong beliefs.</p><p>In my experience, you can build a better model of reality simply by asking someone else what their experience is. And in previous decades we built models of our local reality that way. I remember learning about a tribe in South America, that doesn’t have a writing system, and had trouble understanding how an American visitor could believe in Jesus. Did you meet Jesus? Well no…Oh, did your friend meet Jesus? Not exactly….</p><p>The tribal peoples&#39; way of building a model reality is built on first-person experiences, and then second-hand experiences from trusted sources, being told face to face. I notice that there is a lack of dialogue in American society, I haven’t seen Elliot Page on Jordan Peterson’s podcast or seen pictures of them having brunch.</p><p>New technologies, like writing, actually make it easier to deceive people on large scales, if that becomes a major source of information. In today’s world, I fear people are getting used to having fewer personal conversations, and getting more information from social media, youtube and other corners of the internet. The merit of these technologies is that good ideas can spread faster and the model an individual has of the larger world can become better. Of course it can also go the other way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JMoSCp7O8eMr6JKasIdJeg.png" /><figcaption>Yikes, now add social media to that.</figcaption></figure><p>Maybe that’s why, when having feelings of anxiety or other problems, it’s advised to focus on elements of your surroundings, sights and sounds that you can experience first-hand. You can focus your mind on a reality you experience, instead of the outcomes you are simulating in your head (often the bad possibilities). If you meditate often you are taught to focus on your breathing or other bodily sensations. When trying to sleep, it can help to focus on relaxing your muscles, one muscle group at a time.</p><p>There are two issues I wonder about:</p><p>Does an increase in the amount of information from non-first person and second-hand experiences (communicated person to person) correlate with an increase in anxiety? Because when the majority of someone’s information is from the internet, deep down, they know the model of reality they are building in our minds is more likely to be false or incomplete within the context of its use? I imagine this might be a non-linear relationship. Is this independent of the accuracy of the model of reality we build?</p><p>Have people lost a core sense of self, of the fundamentals of how the world is operating, because of how they are experiencing the world? One time a mentor/father figure of mine was annoyed about a colleague getting upset with him about something minor and went on a rant about how some people have no core. We talked about it but I don’t recall exactly what was said except it was on the way to kitesurfing, which is important because that was an expression and exercise of the core. What is the core? It’s a set of values, or sense of self that is resistant to noise, to minor stresses. It’s having the ability to satisfy oneself, instead of relying on the news or netflix to signal you when to feel happy or sad. It’s a sort of inner-strength but also related to how you interact with the larger world, nature. A tree that can withstand a typhoon has a core. Maybe the core is self-esteem. My father figure confirmed I have a core, and that conversation made it stronger.</p><p><em>“It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so.” — </em>Mark Twain.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dfd1bc35295c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Real Reason Why the Monty Hall Problem is Counterintuitive]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/the-real-reason-why-the-monty-hall-problem-is-counterintuitive-3cc8b830dc1?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3cc8b830dc1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Sep 2022 00:05:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-08T02:30:40.583Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s because the problem is stupid, and people are easily confused and mean.</p><p>Or maybe people are easily certain, when they should be confused. I think that’s it. One of my most outstanding qualities is that I’m often confused when other people are certain.</p><p>A very good discussion of the Monty Hall Problem can be found at priceonomics &lt;<a href="https://priceonomics.com/the-time-everyone-corrected-the-worlds-smartest/">https://priceonomics.com/the-time-everyone-corrected-the-worlds-smartest/</a>&gt;, including the controversy that ensued over Marilyn’s answer, including a lot of potential ‘mansplaining’ that Marilyn had to endure (I don’t like to use ‘mansplaining’ recklessly because it’s difficult to know the difference between someone who is wrong, and a sexist who’s wrong, though a good way to tell is if they use ‘mansplaining’ recklessly). TLDR, over 10,000 people wrote Marilyn letters to tell her she was wrong, and I’m pretty sure she didn’t get 10,000 apologies when she prevailed in defending her position.</p><p>Here’s the question:</p><p><em>“Suppose you’re on a game show, and you’re given the choice of three doors. Behind one door is a car, behind the others, goats. You pick a door, say #1, and the host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say #3, which has a goat. He says to you, “Do you want to pick door #2?” Is it to your advantage to switch your choice of doors?”</em></p><p>Take a moment to consider the problem.</p><p>.</p><p>.</p><p>.</p><p>Maybe the answer you got is that it doesn’t matter if you switch or not, because your probability of winning on the switch is the same as if you stay, which is 1/2. This is incorrect. This is what Marilyn says:</p><p>Marilyn’s answer: <em>“Yes; you should switch. The first door has a 1/3 chance of winning, but the second door has a 2/3 chance.”</em></p><p>This can be seen by playing out the probabilities if the player switches or stays, for the subset of probabilities where the initial choice is always the same:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Mq9WoW8YCPC5yQurjim8CA.png" /><figcaption>Player always switches</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6nP0t-Vgq49zOPwL-K6YmQ.png" /><figcaption>Player always stays</figcaption></figure><p>The initial probability of choosing the correct door is 1/3. If the player switches after the host opens the door, the probability of winning is 2/3, compared with 1/3 if they stay. Okay, so far I haven’t added anything much to what priceonomics and others have already shown.</p><p>However, I wonder, is this scenario realistic?! You’re telling me that the host is giving you the opportunity to increase your odds from 1/3 to 2/3?!</p><p><strong>I think this is the real reason this problem is counterintuitive. Because deep down, people know that gameshow hosts are not trustworthy. </strong>And indeed, if you think the game is zero-sum, let’s say the show producers prefer to give away as few cars as possible, in the beginning the Host has a 2/3 chance of winning, and by opening a door with a goat and offering the opportunity to the player to switch, the Host’s chance of winning could be reduced to 1/3! Why would the host do that?</p><p>A <strong>realistic scenario</strong> is when the Host <strong>only</strong> opens a door with a goat when the Player chooses correctly. So let’s game that out with two kinds of players.</p><p>Suspicious player</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VbwbxPLJTHLUhDmMTG4HrA.png" /></figure><p>Naive Player</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WZ8pOnQk1GitOXqNN5q3Cw.png" /></figure><p>So we see, from the perspective of the Host, if the host opens the door with the goat and offers the player a chance to switch only in the case where the player’s first choice is correct, then when the Host encounters a suspicious player, his chance of winning is 2/3, and when he encounters a naive trustworthy angel who doesn’t yet know the horrors of the world, then the Host could win that game and the Hosts overall probability of winning against all players would increases above 2/3, even if the number of naive players is small in the population, the Host’s winning percentage will increase, which undoubtedly goes into the ‘ol cocaine budget after a long week of opening doors, leading the fat American farm animals around the set, and also tending the goats.</p><h4>More Doors Scenario</h4><p>I wanted to see how the probabilities changed with four doors: A, B, C, D. This time shown with boolean logic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_IGCIu4q_IdFdjBEmHJ8HA.png" /></figure><p>Of course, like the tables above, there are more scenarios but they are just essentially copies of the above scenarios. As we expect intuitively, when the number of doors with goats increases and the number of door openings stays at one, switching doesn’t have as much of an positive effect for the player. The probability of the player winning if they switch in this case is 3/7, or 12/28 in total possible scenarios. This is still better than the 1/4 starting probability of choosing correctly which stays as 1/4 if the player stays with their initial choice.</p><p>What if, in the fairytale version of the four-door game the Host opens two goat doors every time after the player’s initial choice? The player will have a 3/4 probability of winning if they switch.</p><p>Okay, also maybe it’s not intuitive because probabilities are tricky. I like the priceonomic explanation with the 100 doors.</p><p><strong>Another way of thinking about the general problem is that your chance of guessing right the first time is always 1/(total number of doors), but once the host opens doors with goats, the probability that one of those remaining closed doors has the car is always <em>higher, </em>because every time a door is opened the new probability is 1/(total number of doors — number of open doors), so you gotta switch.</strong></p><p>Another lesson from this problem is that if you’re abnormally logical in this world, you should probably also be tough, or be quiet. I bet Marilyn is a tough cookie.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3cc8b830dc1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Understanding the Impact of True Positive Rate on Population Testing]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/understanding-the-impact-of-true-positive-rate-on-population-testing-5734a08016e2?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5734a08016e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Sep 2022 03:54:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-06T00:17:28.905Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The last few years has brought to my attention that most people don’t understand basic statistics regarding day to day matters that effects them, and my own understanding could also be improved.</p><p>Here’s a question that was sent to Marilyn Vos Savant’s column <em>Ask Marilyn</em>:</p><p><em>Suppose we assume that 5% of people are drug users. A drug test is 95% accurate (i.e., it produces a correct result 95% of the time, whether the person is using drugs or not). A randomly chosen person tests positive. Is the person highly likely to be a drug user?</em></p><p>Now some people might think that if the drug test is 95% accurate, then if you randomly choose a person to test and they test positive then that person is 95% likely to be a drug user.</p><p><em>Marilyn’s answer: Given your conditions, once the person has tested positive, you may as well flip a coin to determine whether she or he is a drug user. The chances are only 50–50. But the assumptions, the make-up of the test group and the true accuracy of the tests themselves are additional considerations.</em></p><p>Yikes, 50% chance versus 5% chance of having a false positive are pretty distant ways of thinking about something.</p><p>On the back of The Power of Logical thinking by Marilyn (1997) — haven’t read it but considering buying it — there’s a line, “She examines an America where statistics are abused as a national pastime and a logically illiterate public accepts as truth far more than it should.” Eowww. Tell us what you really think Marilyn.</p><p>The standard explanation of why you have a 50% chance of a false positive is by example:</p><p>Total Population: 10,000</p><p>True Positive Rate: 5%</p><p>Testing Accuracy: 95%</p><p>Number of True Positives: 10,000*0.05=500</p><p>Number of True Negatives: 10,000**0.95=9,500</p><p>Number of True Positives that test positive: 500*0.95=475</p><p>Number of True Negatives that would test (false) positive: 9,500*0.05= 475</p><p>So now it can be seen that Marilyn is right, and the reason is that since the True Positive rate is low (5%), you end up with a lot of false positives.</p><p>However, I like to have robust mental models that can be used for decision making without mathematical calculation. So let’s see how the probability of getting a false positive changes when you have a low true positive rate (5%), and there is higher and lower testing accuracy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yxzRHMhZl_2PRfO7OCcPdg.png" /></figure><p>As a check, it can be seen that at 95%, there is indeed a 50% probability of a false positive, and at 98% testing accuracy, that probability is still about 30%. What’s interesting is that this is non-linear! As Testing Accuracy decreases lower than about 90%, the slope decreases a bit.</p><p>So it’s clear that with low true positive rates, even high testing accuracy results in a high false-positive probability.</p><p>In the figure below, we can see what happens when the True Positive Rate is increased. As a check, at a 50% True Positive Rate, a Testing Accuracy of 90% would only result in 10% flase positives, and a Testing Accuracy of 95% would result in 5% false positives…etc.</p><p>As a rule of thumb, <strong>if the True Positive rate is less than 50%, then the false positive rate will be higher than the inaccuracy rate of the test.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YPZMIH7HJ-2-3dw_iKzuiA.png" /></figure><p>We can also see that even when the test is very accurate (98% accuracy), at low true positive rates you still have a large False Positive Rate (e.g. at 10% true positive rate you have a 15% False Positive Rate, and at 5% True Positive Rate you have almost a 30% False Positive Rate).</p><p>Notice that at low True Positive Rates the difference in testing accuracy results in a large difference in false positive rate.</p><p>Since this is non-linear, I find that, let’s say, a good rule of thumb might be something like “At true positive rates less than 20%, even accurate testing (&gt;90%) results in a lot of false positives.” And the shape of the probabilities can be remembered.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5734a08016e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Trolley Problem is Not the Problem]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/the-trolley-problem-is-not-the-problem-b32dfeecdd80?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b32dfeecdd80</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 May 2021 10:28:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-05T09:58:54.388Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8HOoocjWJkcn4P8UaIW5ug.png" /><figcaption>&lt;<a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Trolley_Problem.svg#/media/File:Trolley_Problem.svg">https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Trolley_Problem.svg#/media/File:Trolley_Problem.svg</a>&gt;</figcaption></figure><p>The trolley problem is a thought experiment, often used as a basis for starting a discussion about ethics. There are five people in the way of an oncoming trolley, do you pull the lever to divert it to kill only a single person?</p><p>You may recognize this as similar to the ethical issues that arise with self-driving cars. A grandma is in the middle of the road, should the Tesla swerve away, knowing that it will then hit a man on the sidewalk?</p><p>The answer is that it doesn’t matter what your answer is, unless you also are involved at the society level problems.</p><p>Let me pose a third question.</p><blockquote>Why do airplanes have pilots?</blockquote><p>The other day I asked this question to a college student.</p><p>“Because we don’t have the technology.”</p><p><em>We’ve been flying automated missiles, we have automated space ships, and in fact, have had them for a long time. When I was in college, my engineering professor in college asked this question to our class, and at that time he was confident that we already the technology before then! So, technology is not the problem.</em></p><p>“The computer could malfunction.”</p><p><em>So you just make a backup system, or even two backups. You can have more backups than human pilots.</em></p><p><em>The reason we don’t have self-driving planes is about liability. If a plane crashes, and there is no human pilot, who do you blame the crash on? The company that made the automation software (if outsourced)? The software engineer? The company that made the plane?</em></p><p>If there is a human pilot, there is a point of liability. This point of liability is one that the pilot, the airline, the passengers, and society at large seem to find agreeable. Tesla is facing the reality that society may not have agreed yet about who is liable regarding the autopiloting of cars. They are facing a lawsuit for a pedestrian&#39;s death. Tesla argues the human sitting in the driver’s seat bears responsibility. &lt;<a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/lanceeliot/2020/05/16/lawsuit-against-tesla-for-autopilot-engaged-pedestrian-death-could-disrupt-full-self-driving-progress/?sh=1fea1e8d71f4">https://www.forbes.com/sites/lanceeliot/2020/05/16/lawsuit-against-tesla-for-autopilot-engaged-pedestrian-death-could-disrupt-full-self-driving-progress/?sh=1fea1e8d71f4</a>&gt;. Well this certainly creates a risky situation for a potential purchaser of a self-driving car, it is very difficult to asses the <em>value</em> of a car with autopilot against the <em>risks</em> of using the autopilot.</p><p>As Nassim Taleb points out, ethics is about symmetry. We should be careful not to create a system in which agents can profit when they do their job well, and avoid losses when they kill someone.</p><p>When I buy a ticket to fly in a plane I do not take on liability as the pilot. Tesla is in a difficult situation, in that it advertises its product as an auto-pilot. Well, pilots have responsibilities.</p><p>I think there’s one more reason society likes having human airplane pilots. A human pilot may appropriately handle a situation that has never occurred or is not expected to occur. An emergency landing in a river. Or Iron Man flying next to the plane. While these are extremely rare events, we currently trust humans to find the correct solutions more than machines. So, if it’s Halloween and someone is dressed as a green traffic light, a human driver likely won’t run them over.</p><p>As for cars and planes…etc. I would use autopilot under the following conditions:</p><ol><li>Autopilot-making-company takes on liability.</li><li>Autopilot shows performance equal or better than the best human performers with a minimum of 95% confidence.</li><li>Autopilot covers some known edge cases. For example, if a deer runs into the road, the autopilot drives straight (human drivers often do the more dangerous action, which is swerving off the road).</li><li>Autopilot is not more vulnerable to being compromised than a human. This is difficult to determine because humans and machines become compromised in different ways. Human doctors may be compromised by Pharmaceutical companies by what the elites would call ‘rebates’ or some other such incentive system that is typically called bribes by working-class people. Software systems can be compromised by hardware modification, hacking and modifying the software…etc.</li></ol><p>As automation increases, our societies will have to make similar decisions in other fields. Medicine will be a big one, as doctors will soon take the role of pilots in airplanes if we are not careful (e.g. da Vinci surgical robot and diagnosis/imaging analysis software…etc). The four conditions I stated above can apply to various automation areas that have a direct relationship to human safety.</p><p>If I were asked the Trolley problem, I would ask several questions in return. Do I have permission to use the lever? What authority provides permission to use the lever? What are the current laws related to malpractice of a trolley-track-lever-puller? What are the precedents for legal cases involving trolley track-lever-pullers? Has a similar situation arisen before where there was a trolley with no driver that has killed someone? Maybe the big question is, if I use the lever, does the trolley company take liability, or do I?</p><p>So clearly, the problem is that it’s difficult to agree on who has the liability, and who makes the ethical decisions. Does Tesla get to decide their solution set to various Trolley problems? California government? Federal Government? Should we even allow cars to be sold with autopilot when the company making the autopilot bears no responsibility? These are the real problems.</p><h4>A Brief Note on Human Ingenuity, Liability, and Fire</h4><p>The Mann Gulch Fire was a disaster that occurred in 1949. The book, Young Men and Fire, details the disaster, which was a fire ‘blowup’, and follows the author’s journey researching the tragedy. It’s part forensics, part fire-science, part history, and part personal journal. It’s the author’s way of expressing his own connection to fire, and the empathy he builds with the men who died in the fire through comprehensively researching who these people were, what lead to their horrific deaths, and what may be done to prevent these situations in the future. This book was published after the author’s death, and is more like a journal than a book, partially because the publisher intentionally only performed basic editing.</p><p>The book also deals with liability, as the men that died were all very young (including two 19-year-olds), with the oldest being 28. Should the government be recruiting such inexperienced smokejumping firefighters for such missions? Were the recruiting practices for firefighting negligent? Furthermore, the team was not experienced working together, making the mission exceptionally risky.</p><p>As the fire chases the men up a hill, the men run in panic towards the ridge. Suddenly the foreman, Dodge, stops. He kneels down. Lights a match in front of him, and walks into the fire. He had yelled at the others to stop but they didn’t understand what he was trying to communicate and do. He seemed to have lost his mind. He wets a handkerchief with water, puts it over his mouth, and lies in the fire he had just set as his fire burns forward in front of him. Dodge, on the spot, before winds had gotten too strong and just before the blowup, had created an ‘escape fire’. Dodge’s fire was in the backdraft of the main fire, and therefore burned straight up the hill in front of Dodge and the main fire, causing the main fire to burn around, not through, where Dodge lied down. Dodge’s escape fire allowed him to avoid the full brunt of the blowup and become one of the few that survived. The author notes that while Native Americans may have used a similar gambit, this idea had never been reported within the American Fire Service. Dodge had never had this idea before he was running up the hill, a huge fire chasing him, his life on the line.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b32dfeecdd80" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Japan Already has Universal Basic Income]]></title>
            <link>https://elilyons.medium.com/japan-already-has-universal-basic-income-ec5bce0611b7?source=rss-b6b5c88246b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec5bce0611b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[japan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eli Lyons]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Apr 2020 05:37:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-23T00:35:35.581Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*auDMic_Tu9Ctu6ov_INZzw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A picture I took years ago.</figcaption></figure><p>The picture is what it looks like. A man holding a light stick at a construction or maintenance site, while a machine that serves the same function also operates at the same site. This is Japan’s flavor of Universal Basic Income (UBI). In this essay I will briefly describe it, the merits and demerits I’ve observed, and discuss.</p><p>You see it all the time. Elderly at some construction site, sweeping in front of an apartment building, or the plethora of admin workers at a university or office.</p><p>In Japan, many “正社員” (Seishain), full-time employees, meet the definition of people working under universal basic income, except that they do have a ‘job’.</p><p>Westerners tend to discuss UBI as being a government subsidy.</p><p>However, in Japan’s version of UBI, which has already been in operation before it became a vogue discussion topic in the West, both companies and government subsidize citizens&#39; living expenses together.</p><p>Japanese companies subsidize citizen living expenses because they do not perform layoffs or fire as often as in the west. Many of these employees do not contribute significantly to the bottom line of the company and could be automated away. A mix of labor laws and cultural values enforce this.</p><p>Japanese government subsidizes citizens by subsidizing, bailing out , and investing in Japanese companies that are failing, or companies fundamentally unable to operate without subsidies. Example: &lt;<a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/us-japan-display-funding/apple-supplier-japan-display-gets-920-million-bailout-from-ichigo-idUSKBN1ZU0ZH">https://www.reuters.com/article/us-japan-display-funding/apple-supplier-japan-display-gets-920-million-bailout-from-ichigo-idUSKBN1ZU0ZH</a>&gt;</p><p>Further examples include subsidies for farmers, tariffs, and government grants to private companies. The Bank of Japan owns at least around 80% of domestic ETFs and in 2018 was a top shareholder of 40% of all of Japan’s listed companies &lt;<a href="https://www.ft.com/content/aba02f8c-3eab-11e9-9499-290979c9807a">https://www.ft.com/content/aba02f8c-3eab-11e9-9499-290979c9807a</a>&gt;. I wonder what those numbers are now.</p><p>On a related side-note, the Bank of Japan owns nearly 50% of government bonds &lt;<a href="https://www.japanmacroadvisors.com/page/category/economic-indicators/financial-markets/jgbs-held-by-boj/">https://www.japanmacroadvisors.com/page/category/economic-indicators/financial-markets/jgbs-held-by-boj/</a>&gt;. This topic is too complex to discuss in this essay, but is further evidence that Japanese people have no problem with government intervention in the economy.</p><p>This is not a government-lead economy. This is a government-owned economy. It’s a chimera of capitalism and socialism.</p><p>Years ago I read an article written by a Japanese economics professor (If my memory serves correct) that said Japanese society believes that the primary purpose of companies is to provide employment, not profits. This is an important distinction with America’s priorities, that corporations should provide profits to shareholders, and societal damage as a secondary effect is also a secondary priority.</p><h4>Merits</h4><ul><li>Society is more stable. You do not suddenly see companies appear and disappear. People do not suddenly lose their job or switch jobs.</li><li>Because work is more stable, people’s psychology seems somewhat more stable than in the US, for example, with people experiencing fewer extremely chaotic and stressful situations.</li><li>Society is less divided. There is a sense that everyone has a role, and that each role is important. That the CEO isn’t taking a huge payout and leaving everyone behind. There’s a sense of <em>society</em>.</li><li>Increased dignity. Sometimes. The psychological benefits are very difficult to quantify.</li></ul><h4>Demerits</h4><ul><li>Makes innovation harder. For example, it’s hard to sell software that automates something like calendar scheduling and basic accounting to a manager, when they have an employee who does those tasks, which they won’t fire, and the manager doesn’t know what that employee should do if they did buy the software and had an employee with the free time.</li><li>Pay is very low while at the same time the people in these low-paying jobs do not have the freedom and time to learn more useful skills.</li><li>Pay is very low. This should be emphasized. This is especially important as costs, like the Japanese consumption tax (sales tax) increase.</li><li>People are not incentivized to obtain more useful skills. Say an employee tells their boss, “Hey boss, I can pay a small monthly fee for this software that will automate one of my tasks.” Many bosses would just point out that some processes would have to change and it’s hard to convince the boss that the worker can do more valuable things with their time. They only see the cost of the software.</li><li>People are more fragile if they do get laid off. I met a Japanese man who was laid off from a global company when the US corporate office decided to cut unnecessary costs in Japan. He basically only knew how to coordinate delivery of the chemicals the global company was producing, and all the nuances that come with that job. All the relationships that were critical to doing that job. After he was laid off he moved out of Tokyo. I don’t know what he will do for work.</li><li>These domestic companies are fragile in the global economy. How many companies in Japan eventually get crushed when a foreign competitor comes in? Examples of foreign products replacing domestic include Apple and Samsung phones, Facebook, Amazon (when they decide to hit the gas)…etc.</li><li>Lack of meaning in work. I wonder what the man in the picture at the top thinks about his job.</li><li>There’s an element of insanity. People waste their time doing futile work. I remember a woman I dated started working at Panasonic out of Unversity. She moved to Osaka and lived in the company dorm. In Tokyo she probably could have made more money as a non-full-time employee at an izakaya and living at home. But Japanese society values ‘full-time’ status. It seems something like a ‘career’. She would tell me her department is operating in the red because they couldn’t compete with the Chinese. So they were working harder every year. That’s insanity. To do more of the same every year, and lose more every year, and keep going.</li></ul><h4>Discussion</h4><p>I don’t think Japan’s strategy is sustainable if they are going to continue to participate in the global economy as it currently looks today. The domestic environment generally stifles the birth of companies with the characteristics that would allow them to compete globally. However, it does create social stability, which can be pleasant on a day to day basis.</p><p>My general guideline is to let the companies die and it’s usually much better to subsidize the expenses of citizens directly, both in the US and Japan. Lay people off as well, but provide excellent unemployment benefits.</p><p>Japan’s current strategy is basically just burning money doing futile work. Resources would be better spent subsidizing people who would be free to form new companies, write poetry, or walk on the beach.</p><p>Dignity is a word I have no recollection of hearing in the US before I moved to Tokyo. I remember two of my close friends in Tokyo using it, a Canadian and a British. I remember how shocking it was to hear it those first few times. The idea that I should consider that in our discussion. It seemed, un-American.</p><p>When I reflect, the person that I became due to growing up in America, was not the kind of person I think I wanted to be when I was younger. America makes it difficult to be kind, to be considerate of others.</p><p>“I look at these people, these Americans,” Eliot went on, “and I realize that they can’t even care about themselves any more — because they have no <em>use</em>. The factory, the farms, the mines across the river — they’re almost completely automatic now. And America doesn’t even need these people for war — not any more. Sylvia — I’m going to be an artist.”</p><p>“An artist?”</p><p>“I’m going to love these discarded Americans, even though they’re useless and unattractive. <em>That</em> is going to be my work of art.”</p><p>(God Bless You, Mr. Rosewater)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec5bce0611b7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>