<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Eliott Edge on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Eliott Edge on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@eliottedge?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 16:19:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@eliottedge/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Widow’s Bay a transcendent new horror and comedy]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/widows-bay-a-transcendent-new-horror-and-comedy-28ef7d9e17b8?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28ef7d9e17b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[streaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Sep 2026 06:06:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-07T06:06:33.635Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Widow’s Bay a new masterpiece of horror and comedy</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Gx0j9AALuczvLBVr2KUgpw.jpeg" /></figure><p>WIDOW&#39;S BAY - A+ To call Kate Dippold&#39;s &#39;Widow&#39;s Bay&#39; a masterpiece would be selling it short. The 10 episode series, renewed for a second season, balances a shelling of comedy with some of the most unnerving horror I&#39;ve seen in memory. I also never knew what was coming next. The shocks were truly shocking. The jumpscares were deservedly earned. And the humor had me worrying about lung collapse. If there was a score higher than A+, I&#39;d give it.</p><p>&#39;Widow&#39;s Bay&#39; follows a small New England community that lives on a cursed island in the vein of Stephen King. The town&#39;s perpetually stressed-out mayor Tom Loftis, played by Mathew Rhys, is trying to drive tourists to the island in hopes of boosting their economy and bringing in a more cosmopolitan demographic to an otherwise insular and superstitious populace. Longtime resident and town crier Wyck, played to perfection by the legendary Stephen Root, enters the mayor&#39;s office during a meeting and declares with all pathos that Loftis must send the tourists away. An ominous fog has rolled in signaling the bad times. &quot;It&#39;s a HAUNT!&quot; he cries. And Root isn&#39;t alone in knocking out the humor. He&#39;s opposite Rhys&#39;s: a determined, lying, wiry public official that is only mayor because he ran uncontested. Rhys resists Roots craggy doom forecasting with a nervy hilarity as he tries to keep things in order.</p><p>Loftis could&#39;ve been written as just a besieged wreck trying to make it work, but to my surprise, his character is given plenty of moments of tenderness that actually reaches points of real power in the show.</p><p>But it&#39;s Katie O&#39;Flynn, Loftis&#39;s assistant Patricia Moyer, that gives a comedic performance that is nothing short of for the ages. O&#39;Flynn plays a tragically awkward yet unbreakable underling a physicality that is so mesmerizing I can easily imagine revisiting the show again and again, if only to see O&#39;Flynn&#39;s dynamism. She squints, frowns, shakes her head, and throws her limbs around in these ways that you won&#39;t forget. I want to compare her to early Jim Carrey, but not in terms of his over-the-top outrageousness: but in terms of the enchantment a physical performance. When O&#39;Flynn&#39;s on, she&#39;s who you watch. You can&#39;t wait to see what she&#39;ll do next and how she&#39;ll do it.</p><p>The great performances don&#39;t end there. The show doesn&#39;t suffer from a single miscast. It&#39;s a miracle of an ensemble really and everyone, absolutely everyone on screen acts at a height that doesn&#39;t let you go. And these characters are not flat. Some are purely comic, like the chain-smoking Rosemary, but you love them and they feel rich. They satisfy in a way that makes you feel: this is what acting is about.</p><p>The other thing &#39;Widow&#39;s Bay&#39; does that has to be mentioned is it plays with the tropes of American Horror on a meta level, particularly Stephen King. I&#39;ve always had a problem with King. His work is very adaptable for screen, but I haven&#39;t been able to finish one of his books or short stories. Maybe that&#39;s a problem with me. But the issue I&#39;ve usually had, particularly with his stories about small town America (a good deal of them) is I don&#39;t care for the characters or interactions between the townsfolk. And I&#39;m a former New Englander. I am never pulled into them. The characters are just too... &#39;overcooked&#39; might be the word I&#39;m looking for. Too black and white with childhood trauma in-between. Some people are just sadists, some people are just stupid. And maybe that’s true, but I don’t really enjoy the way King portrays that. In the cracks of King&#39;s tension, and lore, and horror we have these &quot;Bill Parkers&quot; and &quot;Mike Sullivans&quot; and &quot;Old Bill Learys” or what have you and I just simply don&#39;t care about them. Of course there are exceptions like &#39;Dolorous Claiborne&#39; but even Joe St. George in that is a little too plainly evil for me to enjoy.</p><p>I recently rewatched &#39;The Mist&#39; a film somewhat misremembered for being better than it actually is. (SPOILERS) In that tale, a mist filled with Lovecraftian creatures forces townsfolk in a department store to barricade themselves in. Of course, King’s stock characters show up: a zealot emerges, a guy from the city who cries racism (which maybe he’s right to), the hicks don’t have a lick of sense, and our dad hero tries to keep people calm—I care about none of these exchanges. King concertized these kinds of characters having these kinds of interactions, whether its in The Mist or Storm of the Century, another tale about an island, a supernatural weather pattern, and a community that eats itself alive—he simply can’t seem to get me to care.</p><p>Whereas ‘Widow’s Bay’ does something truly remarkable. It somehow celebrates King while doing him better—at least in terms of satisfying entertainment. ‘Widow’s Bay’ is what would’ve happened if King discovered humor and could deliever it as well as he does his horror. So while they’re kind of celebrating King, they&#39;re also taking the piss out of him, and they&#39;re also doing him better.</p><p>The meta level comes into focus as Dippold said in an interview that orginally the script was only jokes. Dippold, a UCB alumn, is also a horror fan herself and she slowly began to do more serious service to the genre. And it shows. It’s as much a zenith in horror as it is in comedy. In fact, it does it so well that I can’t think of any other horror-comedies that compare. I think my mouth dropped open over as many jokes as it did horror. It was alot. The last episode I hardly kept my mouth closed.</p><p>That’s probably the most honest thing I can say about the show, I find it hard to compare to in terms of the perfection of it’s execution. It&#39;s shot beautifully, scored fantastically, and moves seamlessly between terror, heart, and very very funny humor—and It does this so extraordinary well, I can only think of someone like Beethoven to compare it to. It’s that transcendent.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28ef7d9e17b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Compassionately Euthanizing an Obsolete Democratic Party]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/compassionately-euthanizing-an-obsolete-democratic-party-df81843bafaf?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df81843bafaf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2024-elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[republican-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democrats]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Nov 2024 21:28:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-07T21:28:18.727Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*DERLoOT0sOzXspZD93Er0Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>The devastating 2024 Republican sweep has occurred for one reason and one reason only: the establishment Democratic Party itself. The responsibility lies entirely at their feet.</p><p>It’s time well-meaning American liberals accept what progressives have known for a long time: the Democratic Party is obsolete. It has been for at least a decade, though they have been out of touch for much longer than that — perhaps since the emergence of the Green Party and Ralph Nader, which they went out of their way to attack. When exactly they lost the script is irrelevant; what matters is that it is now clearer than ever that they are The Party of Utter Failure.</p><p>If they were truly the “adults in the room” they so snidely LARP as, they would acknowledge this truth. But since they are thoroughly in the pockets of anti-progressive interests — sewn into its very hem, as it were — they cannot. Admitting this would require not only a backbone but the motive to do real progressive good, both of which are entirely lacking.</p><p>Instead, they will blame racists, sexists, non-voters, and other “stupid people” rather than look in the mirror and admit that their own obstructionism and echo chamber have allowed such painful, humiliating misadventure. They chose to ally with Liz Cheney rather than Bernie Sanders.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HlpOS5sfbLQfiqCZQec9iw.png" /></figure><p>The Democrats peaked (in terms of sheer optics) with Obama. They will never reach that level again. Charismatic establishment Dems have been nonexistent since.</p><p>The Democratic Party will never deliver universal healthcare, nor end genocide, nor effectively tax the super-rich, nor create a better world. These are simply not their true agenda and it arguably never has been. Their aim is to uphold the status quo; meanwhile, they’ve lost their base, their credibility (among those liberals who still gave them the benefit of the doubt), and power. From here on, they will continue to lose, and in doing so, they will continue to enable the Right. And if they ever win again, they will simply perpetuate the “soft fascism” of neoliberalism, which has become their bread and butter. They are now little more than a relic fit for a museum — a reminder of what aimless political destitution truly looks like.</p><p>In recent years, the Democrats have accomplished little besides enabling the Right while supporting genocide and squelching true progressives, even within their own ranks. They have done nothing to win over the poor and working people in America’s flyover states — which should’ve been easy. At best, they resemble what Republican centrists once were in the 20th century.</p><p>Yes, we can call the Republican Party ugly, but not in the same way we can call the Democratic Party corrupt, lost, and a collective failure. Right-wingers are what they are everywhere — authoritarian, statist, callous, xenophobic, sexist, and so on. But the Democrats are demonstrably more insidious and ineffectual because they masquerade as progressives while denying that they are just another arm of the Right. This is more odious than the Republican Right, which at the very least makes its intentions crystal clear. The Democratic establishment is the true toxic force of against the American people, again, because the ape as if they are the good guys. The reality couldn’t be further from the truth.</p><p>The Democrats believe they are engaging in some kind of mature realpolitik. If they were, they wouldn’t be so bad at the political game. Instead, they represent the professional managerial class: accomplishing nothing while bureaucratizing everything into a paralyzing standstill that benefits only themselves, as the room fills with bodies around them — at the cost of their base and their ability to oppose a more zealous Right that has effectively taken their jobs out from under them.</p><p>For now, this is a democracy. When you lose your job in a democracy, you can not blame such a widespread, overwhelming loss on anything other than yourselves. You can try, but it will only serve as a balm to help you sleep at night. “I’m not wrong. They’re wrong!” It’s the last gasp of a loser before drifting into fitful sleep.</p><p>I am reminded of the avowed anarchist Terence McKenna, who said, “We are led by the least among us — the least intelligent, the least noble, the least visionary.” This may apply to the Right, but at least they have a vision to enchant their base and charismatic, media-savvy talking heads to carry the message. The same cannot be said for the Democrats who operate with a playbook from a pervious century.</p><p>They careened into this election like a car without brakes or steering, running a doomed campaign from the moment Biden announced another run, and suspended the primary. The instant they cast aside the democratic process of the primary, they abandoned their base, choosing a virtually unknown vice president who contradicted her own record, couldn’t speak off-script, and had no play beyond “I’m not the other guy” — all while Bernie, who was once projected to beat Trump by a 17-point margin, waited in the wings. That is why they lost.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YjXAM4DKCbVCjjWj9JlSxQ.png" /></figure><p>How could it be that the Democrats had such a huge chance for victory, and yet buried it so thoroughly? The answer is simple. Bernie is a progressive, and they are simply against progressivism. They would rather lose and lose <em>this badly</em> than the alternative.</p><p>But this has always been the Democrats’ platform. Their vision is, “I’m not that guy.” Vote for us, or else it’s that guy. It’s a threat. The only play they have is threat. They’ve coasted on this for decades, with no visionaries and no sense of purpose. For those who work within the Democratic Party, it’s just another job, like climbing the corporate ladder at Walmart. Nothing miraculous will happen with this party.</p><p>Well-meaning liberals, understand: the Democratic Party is the enemy of real progress. They make progress impossible by insisting it’s unachievable. While making life easier for the deep Right, they have no idea how to fight a 21st-century political battle in the realm of American spectacle media. They cannot compete with figures like Trump and long-form podcasts. They are trapped. They are destitute. They are obsolete. And they are doomed.</p><p>Thanks to the Democrats we have mass deportation, dangerous back-alley abortions, assaults on trans rights, a general aura of thuggery and gangsterism in the air, a more precarious climate, a possible theocratic ethnostate, and national and global embarrassment to look forward to for at least another four years. Possibly longer. Centrists enable fascists.</p><p>When you lose this completely, you can not continue to claim relevancy without insulting your own intelligence. You cannot blame it <em>solely</em> on “crazy white nationalists”, or non-voters, or some other group. It is your failure as a party to align with progressive populist issues while catering to your lobbyists, “think” tanks, corporate masters, and other status quo interests.</p><p>This is why you failed again, and why you will fail again. You lost because you are as morally bankrupt as you are spineless.</p><p>The only question left for well-meaning Democrats and liberals is: how much more humiliation will you tolerate? How much worse must things get? How many times must you burn your hand on the stove? If this is you at your best, I’d hate to see you at your worst. At your best, you’ve handed this entire country to the Right — the Executive, Legislative, and Judicial branches. You’ve lost in a way that’s difficult to fathom.</p><p>If you want to do good with whatever time you have left, step aside (or evolve) and accept the progressive will of the people. Or keep going, and enable an even darker future for us all. With the game you’ve been playing, you wouldn’t know how to win hearts and minds if you owned the world’s cutest baby animal petting zoo and actually paid guests to visit it.</p><p>If there is any silver lining to the Democrats’ utter humiliation, it is the hope that this failure of a party will finally dissolve entirely. That’s the one thing we have to look forward to: the end of a party that has long worn out its welcome.</p><p>Stay tuned.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/1*-bHgsrhithbMD0xtUAk_vQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df81843bafaf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[3 Essays on Virtual Reality (Excerpt)]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/3-essays-on-virtual-reality-excerpt-5d63aa735334?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5d63aa735334</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[virtual-reality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[simulation-hypothesis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Apr 2024 16:58:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-09T17:42:52.567Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/667/1*e2wRh7kKcMwx-WXK3PYOxQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>“It is worth pointing out that we have been making virtual realities for a very, very long time. That language, spoken language, is the original code for hacking virtual reality. When you sit the children down around the fire and begin to tell the old, old stories and pictures rise out of the flames — that is virtual reality.”</em></p><p><em>“We live in a condensation of our imagination.” </em>— Terence McKenna</p><p><strong>INTRODUCTION</strong></p><p>Every living being on this earth exists within a Virtual Reality (VR), whether it knows it or not. For human beings, this is especially so. Human beings don’t just have to navigate through the VR that their sensory experiences produce, or the VR of the physical universe itself. Human beings have complex languages, mathematics, religions, ideologies, art, culture, and civilization to wade through. This makes for an even trickier and slipperier ontological situation for every member of our species.</p><p>Human beings create cultural and personal VRs with undying enthusiasm. We have done so since the time of cave painting. We create worlds out of the world. We do not just live in the universe, we distort the universe to match up with an inner belief system that we have about it. We live in Christian, Hindu, animist, Freudian, and secular universes; and these universes are all human-made VRs.</p><p>At the center of this VR strangeness is consciousness itself. It seems to me that consciousness may require VRs to operate competently within the universe — a universe that, according to many serious physicists may, in fact, be a VR itself.¹-⁹ If we imagine all that we experience (both in terms of what arrives through our external senses, as well as the thoughts, feelings, and intuitions we feel internally) to be fundamentally information, then this supports the case that consciousness processes this flux of internal and external information in an effort to generate usable and valuable impressions of the world. In short, it is the role of consciousness to produce virtual realities based on our sensory inputs.</p><p>Thus, we have a layer of cultural virtual reality, then another layer of VR from our simulating imagination, which is combined with our VR biological sensory impressions, and all of these arrive to interpret a very strange physical universe that seems like it might very well be — you guessed it — a virtual reality as well.</p><p>I’m far from alone in in ruminating on different forms of VR interacting with each other. Slavoj Žižek used VR to discuss the psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan’s work in the excellent documentary lecture-essay <em>The Reality of the Virtual.</em>¹⁰ In the early 1990s Linda Jacobson proposed four different kinds of technological virtual reality: desktop virtual reality, simulation virtual reality, projection virtual reality, and immersive virtual reality.¹¹ VR is rarely just about interactive images shoved into a helmet or visor. VR is actually about everything we can think of.</p><p>Most of the time, but certainly not all of the time, I find myself writing about two different kinds of virtual reality. One kind refers to the idea that our very universe is something of a virtual reality, or a computational simulation. This idea is such a vogue concept in science and philosophy that it is a difficult one to avoid in the popular and scholarly literature of today. The second kind is the virtual reality of human experience. Our cultures, our media, our thoughts, our identities, and languages — indeed <em>all levels and forms of human civilization are virtual reality-like in nature.</em> The <em>worldviews</em> we have made for ourselves to grow, work, and play in, and the monuments and infrastructure that we have erected, are all analogous to virtual realities as well. Even a road or a sign is a VR cutting through the otherwise uninterrupted Earth that tells us, “This way, fellow human.” The empire of the ‘human world’ is but one manifold VR. I typically refer to this kind of VR as ‘humancentric’.</p><p>This collection of essays contains references to both the VR universe, and the VR human-verse we’ve created, which we normally think of as ‘culture’ and ‘civilization’.</p><p><strong>Why so much Virtual Reality?</strong></p><p>Press me hard enough and I’ll frequently concede — “<em>I think virtual reality might be one of the few things that we </em><strong><em>actually know</em></strong><em> for sure is indeed going on.</em>” How did I reach such a brutal and contemporary opinion?</p><p>Some time ago I granted myself permission to fall down the virtual reality rabbit hole as far as I could, largely just to see what I would rub up against. What I found was as plentiful as the “endless fields” that Morpheus describes in the 1999 film <em>The Matrix</em>. My exploration led to an abiding opinion that the concept of the <em>virtual reality</em> is robust and powerful enough to deserve an eternal seat at the table of Science 101, Philosophy 101, Media 101, Mysticism 101, and Religion 101. Whilst not a unique opinion, it is one that has now become personally profound the more I consider it.</p><p>The virtual reality metaphor is an unusually powerful concept. Indeed, it applies to philosophical ideas as old as Plato’s Cave.¹² Questions as enduring as, “what is thought, what is mind, consciousness, and experience?” can be discussed using VR analogies.¹³-¹⁵ Additionally, it appears VR is a possible key to understanding and answering the famously strange probabilistic and statistical experimental observations that we consistently find in quantum mechanics.¹⁶ ¹⁷ VR is also an immediate social crisis of our time, as it slowly becomes the prime technological medium for everything from pornography,¹⁸ to warfare,¹⁹ and even torture.²⁰</p><p>The next leg of this century will doubtlessly center on VR and simulations for good reason. VR is becoming an increasingly common interface. Large- scale simulations of our personal data are now the norm among tech companies and government organizations with millions of customers and citizens to calculate.²¹ ²² We use simulations in meteorology, astrophysics, and all kinds of research and design. The ever-increasing list goes on, but suffice it to say, VR and simulation terminology is quickly becoming the language of the day. We are moving from the Information Age — marked by the computer and the Internet — into the Virtual Age, an era wherein we begin to soak ourselves more completely in the accumulated outputs of the Information Age (and all the eras before it as well). Digital VR is, like the Internet before it, a new country, a new frontier — a New World. We are only just beginning to tame the landscape and plant our flags upon it.</p><p>Now, the plot twist actually came around the time of the emergence of behavioral modernity in Homo sapiens (about 40–50,000 years ago); that is when we started our journey into what I see as, to quote myself, “a march into cultural virtual realities, a march that would span the entirety of the human enterprise.”²³ Our <em>Great Leap Forward</em>, as it’s called, was in fact a dive headlong into virtual reality. This makes sense because virtual reality is really all we’re left with when we push communication, imagination, thought, meaning, and felt experience, up against the mirror of itself. You’ll find that all these phenomena and processes are all just like simulations. Because of this, it is a vital conceptual crossroads to reach for complex, meaning-making, potentially <em>ecocidal</em> animals such as ourselves. It is an idea that might prove to be unexpectedly helpful as we face what <em>we are really doing as a species</em>. If you ask me, VR is telling us what we are <em>actually</em> doing as culture creating lifeforms. We’re not merely ever-evolving our own cultures and institutions; unconsciously, we are erecting virtual universes made of meaning that have real world consequences on the physical stage that all life shares.</p><p>One of the reasons why I’m obsessed with VR is because it is covertly one of the central methods through which we have moved from the trees to the high-rise. We built this place by imagining it. We made up the human world. Breakthrough after breakthrough we imagined — simulated in our minds — what could be, and what could work by “playing it out” (simulating) in the theater of our conscious awareness. I feel this reading further demands that we eventually have to become both hip and savvy to its ways, not merely eager believers or deniers when it comes to all that the VR metaphor has in store of us. We have to appreciate VR’s historical evolution — for digital VR technology is an echo, a reincarnation of the fire-lit cave painting.²⁴ And the cave painting is one of the earliest physical depictions of the invisible and yet experienced VR that we call the imagination. VR is how our minds imagine where food can be found, and what next weekend will be like. VR is how we mentally experience expectation, assumption, memory, and make predictions. We believe through the medium of our mental VRs.</p><p>I see VR as an opportunity to have a broader dialogue about the nature of reality, consciousness, culture, thought, self, and our place across these planes.</p><p><strong>Awakening</strong></p><p>Going back to the origin of this obsession, I became interested in VR and simulations thanks to several key life events. Of course there was <em>The Matrix</em>, Virtual Boy and video game craze that has been taking over popular consciousnesses since the 1980s and ’90s, and the cyberpunks. I recall a computer animated VHS tape of <em>The Incredible Crash Dummies</em> released in 1993 that my brother and I obsessed over.²⁵</p><p>But one outstanding event occurred while thinking about the fact that just as we have media literacy and criticism today, we will quickly require a kind of common VR literacy and criticism tomorrow. In imagining what VR literacy would look like, a thought caught my attention that eventually overwhelmed me: “<em>It would look like Civilization Literacy</em>.” Since every digital VR presentation has the potential to be a little culture — or civilization, or planet — it became obvious that the popular VR tech of today was just like shoving an entire world up against our eyeballs. How similar to virtual reality the effects of Times Square, or the ruins of Giza our whole world began to feel for me. Suddenly, a wall was never just a wall again. The wall was a message. This observation is echoed by the Director of the MIT Initiative on Technology and Self, Sherry Turkle, in her 2011 book <em>Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less From Each Other</em>; “Winston Churchill said, ‘We shape our buildings and then they shape us.’” Turkle then adds, “We make our technologies, and they, in turn, shape us.”²⁶</p><p>The world we create for ourselves, the environ, molds us all. And all our human-made environs are human-centric virtual realities.</p><p>This realization occurred maybe six or seven years before the publication of these essays for the IEET (around 2009–10). Running into the unexpected link between civilization-making and the concept of virtual reality went on to radically change my thinking about what it means to be a human being.</p><p>Both civilization (architecture and media especially) and VR technology use elements to present a worldview, and the worldviews they create are immersive and pervasive. Indeed, sometimes we kill over them.</p><p>Another idea that tended to ride alongside this “VR is covertly equivalent to civilization” reading arrived through my years in psychedelic publishing and research. I picked up a line supposedly attributed to Timothy Leary, but popularized by Robert Anton Wilson — <em>Reality Tunnels.</em> A reality tunnel refers to the cultural virtual reality and the belief system that you acquire through socialization, conditioning, and exposure; the psychosocial orthodoxy that arrives thanks to everything from your local place of worship, to your language, to the shape of your home. You are what your neighborhoods make you. We become our scenery and our scenes. We become the local VR. Indeed, VR headset technology is designed to throw us into a reality tunnel in the exact same way that walking through a metropolitan street boggles our senses into a very particular worldview.</p><p>One of Wilson’s well-known remarks on the reality tunnel:</p><blockquote>We’re all looking from the point of view of our own reality tunnels. And when we begin to realize that we’re all looking from the point of view of our own reality tunnels, we find that it is much easier to understand where other people are coming from. All the ones who don’t have the same reality tunnel as us do not seem ignorant, or deliberately perverse, or lying, or hypnotized by some mad ideology, they just have a different reality tunnel. And every reality tunnel might tell us something interesting about our world, if we’re willing to listen.²⁷</blockquote><p>Wilson also observed: “‘reality’ is always plural and mutable.”²⁸</p><p>I think that culturally, once early humans started speaking and thinking in terms of an animal world and a spirit world, or distinguishing between a waking world and a dream world, we began to plant the seeds of the VR dialogue. VR then, is a way of discussing the multilayered shared fantasy called the human world.</p><p>Appreciating the worldview-generating effects of reality tunnels, civilization, language, culture, media, architecture, and seeing how they were all very much like VR, captured my imagination. Even the otherwise simple standing stones dotting the British countryside have VR-generating “magical” effects. They activate the imagination. It wasn’t long after that the observation came to mind: “There is likely no more singularly important consideration than the consideration of alternative worlds, illusory worlds, projected worlds, and manipulable worlds.”²⁹ That is — there is likely no deeper issue, in philosophy or otherwise, than that of the possibility of more than one world or one worldview. For a worldview is merely a virtual reality. This is Plato and his Cave.</p><p>Yet another event that pushed me beyond the veil of hyperspace was the fateful arrival into my reality tunnel of Tom Campbell, a NASA, Department of Defense, Army Technical Intelligence nuclear physicist and consciousness researcher who I discovered around 2008. Campbell, who has a résumé longer than most people’s arm, published a model of the universe as a virtual reality simulation in 2007 called <em>My Big TOE: A Trilogy Unifying Philosophy, Physics, and Metaphysics. </em>In it he describes the universe as a simulation, and our consciousness as the nonphysical computer that “renders” the physical universe into existence via the act of what physicists call “measurement.”³⁰-³² Campbell’s major follow up to his book was a paper published online in March 2017, in the <em>International Journal of Quantum Foundations</em>, called “On Testing the Simulation Hypothesis,” which also focused on the issue of measurement and “wave collapse.”³³ After Campbell, I started reading other scientists who wrote about nature and computation, virtual reality worlds, simulated universes, digital mech- anics, video game thought experiments, and observations in nature that we have historically branded with the moniker ‘spooky.’ I devoured Nick Bostrom, Edward Fredkin, Brian Whitworth, Seth Lloyd, David Chalmers, Sylvester James Gates, Roger Penrose, Paola Zizzi, Zohreh Davoudi, John A. Wheeler, and other mathematicians, scientists, and philosophers who were also absorbed in the issues of computation, simulation, and virtual worlds. Brian Whitworth may have summarized the longstanding problems in physics best when he wrote:</p><blockquote>VR theory is only on the table because objective reality theory doesn’t explain modern physics. In an objective reality time does not dilate, space doesn’t bend, objects don’t teleport and universes don’t pop into existence from nowhere. We would not doubt the world’s objective reality if only it behaved so physically, but it does not. Adjectives like “strange”, “spooky” and “weird” apply, and common sense concepts like object, location, existence, time and space simply don’t work. The world of modern physics doesn’t behave at all as an objective reality should.³⁴</blockquote><p>It became clear that virtual reality was not just a philosophical or cultural issue; it was a deeply scientific one as well.</p><p>After all, a universe popping into existence seemingly out of nowhere for apparently no reason — completely with freakishly fine-tuned physical laws, as well as with all the matter and energy that will ever exist simultaneously — makes a hell of a lot more sense once you think of a computer hitting GO.</p><p><strong>Living on the Holodeck</strong></p><p>I talk about VR so much because I feel it is a way of diving into what is really going on. As mentioned, every life form necessarily produces its own biological virtual reality. If we think of the whole universe as just information, bodies of varying kind come along and distort and compress that information through the channels of their senses. Every living body takes in the world and from that produces a virtual world, through its sensorium, that it can understand, and where it can operate meaningfully and competently. No lifeform experiences the universe directly — rather we experience our sensory compression of the universe as provided by our unique bodies and minds. We are always in at least two holodecks: the body and the mind.</p><p>What that peculiar phenomenon we call the mind accomplishes on its surface is magic. It’s witchcraft. It makes worlds — worlds out of words — code and creation. The world the mind makes is magic, is virtual reality. We overlook this. It is common to us. We miss the grandeur and the precedent. We are walking and talking through the rooms that mind made.</p><p>The city — the city is what virtual reality looks like when we secrete a world of ideas beyond ourselves. These cities, these nations, these states are all also states of being. Anyone who travels beyond their home borders realizes this. These worlds, states of being — they are all relative. They are all entirely our own construction. They are VRs. When you walk through the city listening to music coming in through your headphones, you can drastically change the emotional character, the ambience and mood of yourself and the moment. That’s programming a virtual reality experience. And the clothing you wear as you walk through the city is yet another layer of VR.</p><p>In an essay contained in this collection, I talk about the temple and cathedral, and how these are virtual reality helmets and environments that we have been creating for thousands of years.³⁵ But think about mosques — their imageless yet vibrantly colored pixelated splendor. If the stained glass is God’s image, God’s still life, the Islamic mosaic is God’s dot matrix. And at the root of it all is consciousness. All of it is rainbow light coming in through a keyhole — a keyhole ultimately of our own crafty and bias design.</p><p><strong>No Escape</strong></p><p>Let’s take a moment to look at three immediate zones of experience for every human being: the mind, the body, and the universe. Here’s an example of why the VR metaphor is so very robust.</p><p>If you asked the most orthodox diehard material reductionist neuroscientist how the brain, the nervous system, and all our bodily sense platforms manage to take in the universe and turn it into an invisible picture show, they would give you a VR metaphor. They would tell you human beings take in a certain, measurable fraction of the available sounds, sights, tastes, and smells and form that into a useable collage for the conscious and autonomic mind. They would say we cannot physically see the entire electromagnetic spectrum, nor do we have smell or sight as sensitive as a dog’s. We get a mind- bogglingly wee portion of what the universe has to offer. That sensory information is then translated into an experience that the conscious mind can use. That is a virtual reality. This would not necessarily impress your run-of-the-mill neuroscientist as being a breakthrough reading. However, it does set the stage — just beginning with how our senses take it and make a world, we find the specter of virtual reality. Naturally, it doesn’t end there.</p><p>Now that we have quickly conquered the body, next on tour is of course the mind. Thought is particularly interesting here. As I elaborate in an essay contained herein, thought is on its surface a kind of virtual reality.³⁶ If we can agree that the mind and thought work in reference to images, it is very easy to make the case from there that mind is like a VR. Starting with images; the mind uses images to comprehend and navigate through the world. But image implies something static, and the mind is anything but static. The mind is more of a collage of many moving images — animations. Push this analogy one step further and the mind is not just fooling around with animations, but is in fact producing simulations. If we accept that thoughts are simulations, we can easily say the mind works using invisible and yet profoundly experiential virtual realities. So not only is bodily sense experience a VR, but the mind is a VR as well.</p><p>Finally there is the universe and physics. Here we reach the modern arguments in math, science, and philosophy regarding the physical universe. If you stack the last 100 years of physical observation, it turns out that virtual reality, computer simulations, and information actually provide a powerful analogy to the oddities found throughout quantum mechanics. To this concept, there is a growing body of literature making this case. In fact it would be very difficult indeed to make a complete list of all the published material by scientists, mathematicians, critics, and philosophers on the topic. The reason being is that computation, information, simulation, and VRs provide an extremely formidable position from which to answer some of Nature’s most pressing mysteries.</p><p>Some scientists and philosophers may not like these digital metaphors, but the fact of the matter is the competition against them is slim and only getting slimmer. Many of the leading contenders for Theories of Everything rely on the assumptions of certain objects, or mechanics, or fields to exist which we have yet to observe. Some of these theoretical entities can probably never be observed due to the levels of energy that would be necessary to reach out and measure them. Cosmic strings for instance — things that have never been seen — are being assumed as the roots of reality. Scientifically, philosophically, and logically speaking, starting from such assumptions is a big problem.</p><p>In our most common everyday ideas of who, what, and where we are — the body, the mind, and the universe — within all three domains we find effortless compatibility to virtual reality. To wit, when it comes to virtual reality, there is apparently no escape.</p><p>David Chalmers put it quite simply, “No amount of reasoning or observation could ever completely rule out the hypothesis that I am in a Matrix right now.”³⁶</p><p><strong>How to deal with the Virtual Onslaught</strong></p><p>One of Denzel Washington’s last lines in the 1992 Spike Lee film <em>Malcolm X </em>— which, as most of Washington’s lines are in that film, is beautifully and rapturously delivered — is one that often touches the surface of my mind when I think about not just virtual reality, but where we are, what we are, and ultimately what we are doing here; “Assume nothing, brother!”</p><p>Sister, brother — assume nothing.</p><p>Nothing.</p><p>This is the lesson of Plato’s Cave.</p><p>This is the lesson of <em>The Matrix Trilogy</em>.</p><p>This is what we have today with virtual reality. And this is what we need to fix our attention on most of all: <em>Assume nothing</em>.</p><p><em>NOTHING</em>.</p><p>Why? The only way to overcome any situation, worldview, or institution is first to perceive it for what it always is — a projection and a filter. A projection we use to fill in information, and a filter we use to block out information. This is perception on a moment-to-moment basis, both physically and psychically. Ultimately, it all leads to a life or death game entirely of our own design.</p><p>To overemphasize this point, I often flatly use the word <strong>fake</strong> when describing cultures in the VR context. This is particularly true of the essay featured in this collection, “How VR Gaming Will Wake Us Up to Our Fake Worlds.” I have sometimes received flak for using the word. But, I like it and I like the pressure that <em>fake</em> creates. ‘Fake’ has the same kind of meaning as ‘virtual,’ ‘simulation,’ and so on. A fake means it is a show, a presentation, it is not entirely as it seems, or as we make it out to be. It is not “God’s glory” — that being natural phenomena. These are our own devices. We pretend that they are fundamentally sound, concrete. When in fact, they are our own construction and confabulation. They are our own stories that we tell each other and ourselves. We made it all up. That’s what I mean when I say <strong>fake</strong>. That’s what I mean when I flippantly remark, <em>“Canada is fake.” </em>Part joke, part truth; but all-in-all, Canada is a virtual reality scenario. We are trapped in these shows and contexts we have made for others and ourselves.</p><p>Capitalism, communism, and fascism are all as legitimate as any other VR scenario — that is to say, that deep down they aren’t legit at all. They are man-made rules, man-enforced perceptions, man- made opinions that are all built out of ephemera, agreement, and assumption. They are all games we simply invented; worlds we built brick-by-brick and thought-by-thought. They do not represent the emanations of God the Divine on Earth. They represent our failure to dream up and implement something more thoughtful and beautiful — something actually worth our time.</p><p>I believe we require a new meta-context to wake us up out of all the many contexts we have already made for ourselves. We need to see this. If not through the VR metaphor, then perhaps through some other kind of jarring awakening; some other deep radical re-contextualization that helps us release ourselves from the models and systems we believe we’re trapped in. Without a drastic new context we will likely continue our premature death march into the fossil record. For it is our imagined- up VR cultures that have brought us so horrifyingly close to total destruction.</p><p>To me, virtual reality is the meta-context necessary for our wake-up call.</p><p>I feel one of the strongest points to all of this is that virtual reality is a way of thinking that, when explored, becomes a powerful referent. Since VR can be used quite easily to think about thinking, it can be cast as a tool for meta-thinking. Indeed, thinking about VR is mentally simulating VR. We simulate a simulation when we think about VR. As I love to point out: <em>try thinking of a thought that isn’t a simulation.</em> The virtual reality helmet of late-20th century fame was a technology that gave us a disorienting new way to think about what we have been doing inside our own heads all along. The VR helmet is another head that we place over our own so we can think and experience in alien new ways. It shows us what we do when we adopt any belief system; we color the world with the belief.</p><p>It is worthwhile to linger here and compare the sensory inputs and outputs that cover the human head, and consider how virtual reality helmets are designed to work. So let’s think about heads. Appreciate the array of specialized organs found punctuating the heads of many different types of animals. Think about a human head. Now think about a spider’s head. Think about a dolphin’s head, then an anglerfish’s head, with that funky light dangling above it. Think about how an owl’s head experiences amplified sight and hearing. Think 20 about an elephant, with that unique trunk — think about how that gargantuan hose helps experience the world in a very particular way. Now think about the unique eye control and whiplash tongue of the chameleon. Imagine a cat’s head, as opposed to a dog’s head. Each of these very different heads all bear modifications of the same kinds of organ arrays: eyes, tongues, ears, mouths, noses. All of them we could think of as different kinds of VR helmets. Each produce a different VR. Each sensor is tuned to detect different qualities at different volumes. Sense information is experienced and interpreted differently for each. If we were to design a VR helmet and program it to imitate a fox’s sensory experience as it arrives through its particularly tuned array of sensory organs, we would be treading very close indeed to wearing a fox’s head upon our own. Take this same line of reasoning and flip it around; if we were to take our human experience and put it into a VR helmet, and then place that helmet on another animal’s head, they would be treading very close indeed to the human ordeal. You could even provide the experience of not just standing upright, but of using hands, wearing clothing. In this example the VR helmet plays the role of a blank slate; it is an entirely programmable, modifiable sensory experience- producing array. It is a head by design. The important takeaway is this: the VR helmet is the customizable head. If you can make a VR helmet mime or approximate any animal’s sensory experience, how different is the VR helmet from <strong><em>any</em></strong> animal’s head? When all the world is information, all heads are VR helmets.</p><p>The <em>Brown-Driver-Briggs Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament</em> points out that the Hebrew word for eye (pronounced <em>ah’-yin</em>), was also a word for <em>fountain</em>.³⁷</p><p>If we take into account considerations such as that we can never see the whole EM light spectrum, that we cannot see our own physical blind spot, that we already fill in the blanks when it comes to the physical process of sight, and then compound all of these with the reality that we really tend towards seeing what we want, or allow ourselves to see psychologically speaking, then the idea of sight as as a fountain spilling out bias perceptions holds as much — if not more — weight as the idea of sight framed as collecting photons through your eyes. While we do take in light, sensing its touch on our retinas and upon the surfaces all around us, we helplessly color it, filter it, and fill it with meaning. Cones of light and the cones in our eyeballs provide us with the raw stuff we use to make up our reality tunnels. Here again, we find filtering and projection.</p><p>Our whole experience of life, from the mind, to the body, to the universe is a bunch of intersecting VRs, holodecks we cannot escape — thus, the best course of action is to become deeply aware of this. Or, as we would say in meditation and self-inquiry schools of thought, we would do well to become conscious of consciousness.</p><p><strong>Last Words for Now</strong></p><p><strong><em>Indulge</em></strong> is a word that spontaneously arrived early on in my contemplative life. I was 18 or 20 years old at the time and found myself courting Zen, Advita Vedanta (non-dualism), and any text, video, or podcast I could find on meditation, self-inquiry, and — for want of a better term — brain-change. Enlightenment — and what comprises Enlightenment — was a strong interest at the time as well. During this period of regular reading, practice, and research into mediation and meditation philosophies, I noticed a tendency for certain words to grab my attention, and in some cases these words stayed with me for many years after their rather unexpected arrival. ‘<em>Virtual Reality</em>’ was one such term. ‘<em>Indulge</em>’ was another. Discovering the value of otherwise innocuous words like these during meditation came with a sensation akin to realization, awe, and sudden understanding. It was distinct. The feeling was very much like unlocking something. Rediscovering the value or power of certain words felt like some kind of new access had been granted. A stream of knowledge and understanding was now available, thanks to the arrival of these special words. A new context was created for me through them. Words became keys.</p><p>‘Indulge’ — the verb — arrived specifically while I was thinking heavily about virtual reality. I was thinking about competing thoughts, competing worldviews, competing opinions, cultures, feelings, ideologies, and points of view. <em>“Who wins?”</em> I wondered. <em>“What really makes one VR take center stage over another? What makes a worldview or opinion or belief endure? It is certainly not the most logical or the most loving that wins the day. So what then?”</em> And then ‘indulge’ arrived. <em>The one that is </em><strong><em>indulged</em></strong><em> is the one we must endure.</em></p><p>What we indulge basically makes up our experience of the world and life. If you indulge miserable thought-loops, logics, or beliefs then you are likely to live a relatively unpleasant existence. If you take phrases or ideas like, “I am the way, the truth, and the light,” or “an eye for an eye,” or “Capitalism is the only system that works,” or “The United States is the greatest country in the history of the universe,” and you indulge these ideas as true, then reality is changed for you. Reality is also changed for everyone around you — social reality for sure. If we all indulge the king as being a legit circumstance, then that king is real for us all (but in reality, he, the king, is only ever just <em>real enough</em>). All classes and roles, royalty on down, are virtual roles in our social virtual realities.</p><p>‘Indulge’ has become such a valuable and empowering word that whenever exploring or discussing the issues of VR, I have continued — year after year — to find myself bringing it into the fold of what we should strongly consider when we interrogate all that comes with VR.</p><p>When thinking about VR — or our everyday experience of the world and ourselves, for that matter — considering questions like, “What do I indulge? What does it mean to indulge something? How does the mechanism or reflex of indulging operate within me? What does indulging this or that ultimately result in?” have all remained key in helping me uncover the otherwise covert, the undetected, and the invisible. For VR works most seamlessly when you indulge it as being something more than just a VR. VR is most potent when you don’t realize it is present. An effective VR is one that cloaks its virtualness completely. A quote attributed to cyberpunk author William Gibson aptly illustrates this; “The deadliest bullshit is odorless and transparent.”</p><p>Walk through a crowded room, one flooded with conversation, and listen. How many different opinions, different beliefs, worldviews, and philosophies are indulged? How many people attempt to have their vision indulged and validated? What have they indulged and what are they trying to get others to indulge as well? You’ll notice there is a wide difference between merely thinking a thought and indulging a thought as being truth itself.</p><p>Along with ‘VR’ and ‘indulge’ there is another word that I abuse with abandon — <strong><em>savvy</em></strong>.</p><p>From our friends at the Online Etymology Dictionary, ‘savvy’ means:</p><blockquote>“Practical sense, intelligence”; also a verb, “to know, to understand”; West Indies pidgin borrowing of French savez(-vous)? “do you know?” or Spanish sabe (usted) “you know,” both from Vulgar Latin *sapere, from Latin sapere “be wise, be knowing” (see ‘sapient’). The adjective is first recorded 1905, from the noun. Related: Savvily; savviness.</blockquote><p>I enjoy ‘savvy’ so much due to its connection to the Latin word <em>sapere</em>, from which we get the word sapient — as in Homo sapiens. Thus, taxonomically speaking, ‘savvy’ is exactly what we’re supposed to be (‘wise person’).</p><p>Virtual reality teaches us to abandon any hubris about what we think we know, and instead become savvy. We cannot escape the idea of VR. It is at least as old as the Ancient Greeks; old as māyā before them. We have been unable to overcome or out-think this idea. Instead we have only identified more and more forms and kinds of virtual reality. This means we should begin to embrace VR as a fundamental part of the fabric of our human ontological crisis. That means we cannot be authentic and at the same time fail to see the pervasiveness of the VR metaphor embedded in the world around us. To be whole we must accept VR as part of the immediate human experience. Already, VR is always an issue we must all wrestle with. We should approach the entire world, as well as ourselves, with the keenness that any persuasive VR demands.</p><p>Philosophers — all thinkers of all calibers really — aim to be savvy. We all want to be hip to what’s going on in our little corner of the universe. We all have a desire to know what’s going on. VR, as Plato observed via the Cave, is a prime referent in the toolbox of inquiry to becoming philosophically savvy.</p><p>It is what we have indulged that has permitted our global project to shamelessly flirt with not just ecocide, but terracide — the killing of a whole planet. We have to become savvy about what has brought us to this circumstance. These unchecked cultural VR super-games (like unfettered capitalism and other pan-destructive ideologies) that we have played with, as if they are not games at all, have led us disturbingly close to a grim and embarrassing end for our species and our planet. Becoming savvy to this and seeing what we build as but VRs in VRs in VRs, might give us the pause and consideration necessary to begin to dedicate ourselves to something more thoughtful, more beautiful, more meaningful, and wiser than most of the cultural games we have in play right now.</p><p>We might as well start getting savvy about VR because since the time of Plato we have been unable to get ourselves out of VR.</p><p>So, why talk so much VR? <br>Because VR is a key to the Kingdom, <br>and all Kingdoms are secretly VRs.</p><p><strong>FOOTNOTES</strong></p><p>1. Wheeler, J. A. “Information, Physics, Quantum: The Search for Links.” Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium: Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in the Light of New Technology. Physical Society of Japan, 1990, pp. 354–368.<br> <br>2. Lloyd, Seth. Programming the Universe: A Quantum Computer Scientist Takes on the Cosmos. Jonathan Cape, 2006. “The primary consequence of the computational nature of the universe is that the universe naturally generates complex systems, such as life. Although the basic laws of physics are comparatively simple in form, they give rise, because they are computationally universal, to systems of enormous complexity.”</p><p>3. Zenil, Hector. A Computable Universe: Understanding and Exploring Nature as Computation. World Scientific, 2013. “The contributors are world-renowned experts who have helped shape a cutting-edge computational understanding of the universe. They discuss computation in the world from a variety of perspectives, ranging from foundational concepts to pragmatic models to ontological conceptions and philosophical implications.”</p><p>4. Beane, Silas R., Zohreh Davoudi, and Martin J. Savage. “Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation.” The European Physical Journal A, vol. 50, no. 9, 24 September 2014, paper 148. “Observable consequences of the hypothesis that the observed universe is a numerical simulation performed on a space-time lattice or grid are explored.”</p><p>5. 2016 Isaac Asimov Memorial Debate: Is the Universe a Simulation? American Museum of Natural History, 8 Apr. 2016, (<a href="http://www.amnh.org/explore/news-blogs/podcasts/2016-isaac-asimov-memorial-debate-is-the-universe-a-simulation/">www.amnh.org/explore/news-blogs/podcasts/2016-isaac-asimov-memorial-debate-is-the-universe-a-simulation/</a>). Panelists Neil deGrasse Tyson, David Chalmers, Zohreh Davoudi, James Gates, Lisa Randall, Max Tegmark. “What may have started as a science fiction speculation — that perhaps the universe as we know it is a computer simulation — has become a serious line of theoretical and experimental investigation among physicists, astrophysicists, and philosophers.”</p><p>6. Solon, Olivia. “Is our World a Simulation? Why Some Scientists Say it’s More Likely than Not.” The Guardian, 11 Oct. 2016, [link](<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/oct/11/simulated-world-elon-musk-the-matrix">https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/oct/11/simulated-world-elon-musk-the-matrix</a>). “Quite frankly if we are not living in a simulation it is an extraordinarily unlikely circumstance […] Recognizing we live in a simulation is game-changing, like Copernicus realizing Earth was not the center of the universe.”</p><p>7. Templeton, Graham. “Neil deGrasse Tyson Says it’s ‘Very Likely’ the Universe is a Simulation.” ExtremeTech, 22 Apr. 2016, (<a href="https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/227126/neil-degrasse-tyson-says-its-very-likely-the-universe-is-a-simulation">https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/227126/neil-degrasse-tyson-says-its-very-likely-the-universe-is-a-simulation</a>). “This is the crux of Tyson’s point: If we take it as read that it is, in principle, possible to simulate a universe in some way, at some point in the future, then we have to assume that on an infinite timeline some species, somewhere, will simulate the universe. And if the universe will be perfectly, or near-perfectly, simulated at some point, then we have to examine the possibility that we live inside such a universe. And, on a truly infinite timeline, we might expect an almost infinite number of simulations to arise from an almost infinite number or civilizations — and indeed, a sophisticated-enough simulation might be able to let its simulated denizens themselves run universal simulations, and at that point all bets are officially off. In such a reality, simulated universes might outnumber real ones by an infinity to one, and so to assume we live in the one and only real universe would be the height of arrogance.”</p><p>8. Tegmark, Max. Our Mathematical Universe: My Quest for the Ultimate Nature of Reality. Penguin, 2015.</p><p>9. “Rebooting the Cosmos: Is the Universe the Ultimate Computer?” YouTube, uploaded by World Science Festival, 09 Dec. 2014, (<a href="https://youtu.be/atMuFCpxnUQ">https://youtu.be/atMuFCpxnUQ</a>). Performances by John Hockenberry, Edward Fredkin, Seth Lloyd, Fotini Markopoulou-Kalamara, and Jürgen Schmidhuber.</p><p>10. Reality of the Virtual. Directed by Ben Wright, performance by Slavoj Žižek, Olive Films, 2004. “Today everybody is talking about virtual reality but I think frankly, that virtual reality is a rather miserable idea. It simply means; let us reproduce in an artificial digital medium, our experience of reality. I think that a much more interesting notion, crucial to understand what goes on today, is the opposite: not virtual reality, but the reality of the virtual.”</p><p>11. Jacobson, Linda. “Welcome to the Virtual World.” In: Richard Swadley (Ed.). On the Cutting Edge of Technology. Sams, 1993, pp. 69–79.</p><p>12. Plato. Republic.</p><p>13. Barlassina, Luca, and Robert M. Gordon. “Folk Psychology as Mental Simulation.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Stanford University, 8 Dec. 1997, substantially revised 28 Mar. 2017, (<a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/folkpsych-simulation/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/folkpsych-simulation/</a>). Accessed 10 July 2017. “In common parlance, we talk of putting ourselves in others’ shoes, or empathizing with other people. This talk is typically understood as adopting someone else’s point of view, or perspective, in our imagination. For example, it is quite natural to interpret the request ‘Try to show some empathy for John!’ as asking you to use your imaginative capacity to consider the world from John’s perspective. But what is it for someone to imaginatively adopt someone else’s perspective? To a first approximation, according to Simulation Theorists, it consists of mentally simulating, or re-creating, someone else’s mental states.”</p><p>14. Hesslow, Germund. “Conscious Thought as Simulation of Behaviour and Perception.” TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences, vol. 6, no. 6, 1 June 2002, pp. 242–247, [link](doi.org/10.1016/S1364–6613(02)01913–7). “[T]hinking consists of simulated interaction with the environment, and rests on the following three core assumptions: (1) Simulation of actions: we can activate motor structures of the brain in a way that resembles activity during a normal action but does not cause any overt movement. (2) Simulation of perception: imagining perceiving something is essentially the same as actually perceiving it, only the perceptual activity is generated by the brain itself rather than by external stimuli. (3) Anticipation: there exist associative mechanisms that enable both behavioural and perceptual activity to elicit other perceptual activity in the sensory areas of the brain. Most importantly, a simulated action can elicit perceptual activity that resembles the activity that would have occurred if the action had actually been performed.”</p><p>15. Buckner, Randy L., and Daniel C. Carroll. “Self-projection and the Brain.” TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences, vol. 11, no. 2, 22 Feb. 2007, pp. 49–57, DOI:10.1016/j.tics.2006.11.004. Caltech Division of Humanities and Social Science. “[W]e refer to the mental construction of an imagined alternative perspective as a ‘simulation.’ Four well-studied cognitive abilities are candidates for using related forms of simulation: episodic memory, prospection, theory of mind and navigation. All four forms rely on autobiographical information and are constructed as a perception of an alternative perspective or, in the case of theory of mind, is a simulation that considers another individual’s perspective.”</p><p>16. Campbell, Tom, et al. “On Testing the Simulation Hypothesis.” International Journal of Quantum Foundations, vol. 3, no. 3, July 2017, pp. 78–99, (<a href="http://www.ijqf.org/archives/4105">www.ijqf.org/archives/4105</a>). “It is also now well understood, in the domain of game development, that low computational complexity requires rendering/displaying content only when observed by a player. Recent games, such as No-Man’s Sky and Boundless, have shown [the methodology of displaying] vast open universes (potentially including “over 18 quintillion planets with their own sets of flora and fauna”) by creating content only at the moment the corresponding information becomes available for observation by a player, through randomized generation techniques (such as procedural generation). Therefore to minimize computational complexity in the simulation hypothesis, the system performing the simulation would render reality only at the moment the corresponding information becomes available for observation by a conscious observer (a player), and the resolution/granularity of the rendering would be adjusted to the level of perception of the observer. More precisely, using such techniques, the complexity of simulation would not be constrained by the apparent size of the universe or an underlying pre-determined mesh/grid size but by the number of players and the resolution of the information made available for observation.”</p><p>17. “Double Split Experiment with Delayed Choice Quantum Eraser.” YouTube, uploaded by Cach Doan, 2 June 2015, (<a href="https://youtu.be/xo176uIPmbY">https://youtu.be/xo176uIPmbY</a>). “We live in a probabilistic reality [not an objective reality] […] You are ingrained from your culture with the concept of an objective reality. You believe that is the way it is so when you see this or hear about it, it just doesn’t make sense.”</p><p>18. Newcastle University. “The ‘Reality’ of Virtual Reality Pornography.” Phys.org — News and Articles on Science and Technology, 18 May 2017, (<a href="https://phys.org/news/2017-05-reality-virtual-pornography.html">https://phys.org/news/2017-05-reality-virtual-pornography.html</a>). Accessed 09 July 2017. “Pornography has played a key role in the development of new and emerging technologies — from the stereoscope in the 1800s through home video and now virtual reality. But what VR offers, for the first time, is the opportunity to move from being simply an observer to being a participant, and this changes the experience massively.”</p><p>19. Warren, Tom. “Microsoft’s HoloLens Could Power Tanks on a Battlefield.” The Verge, 03 Nov. 2016, (<a href="https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/3/13507278/microsoft-hololens-military-helmet-concept">https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/3/13507278/microsoft-hololens-military-helmet-concept</a>). Accessed 09 July 2017. “The helmet is designed for tank commanders to use alongside a Circular Review System (CRS) of cameras located on the sides of armored vehicles. Microsoft’s HoloLens gathers feeds from the cameras outside to display them in the headset as a full 360-degree view. The system even includes automatic target tracking, and the ability to highlight enemy and allied soldiers and positions.”</p><p>20. Macaulay, Thomas. “The Future of Technology in Warfare: From AI Robots to VR Torture.” Techworld, 13 Jan. 2017, (<a href="http://www.techworld.com/security/future-of-technology-in-warfare-3652885/">www.techworld.com/security/future-of-technology-in-warfare-3652885/</a>). Accessed 09 July 2017. “Research suggests that the embodiment enabled through VR could make it an effective torture device.”</p><p>21. Lanier, Jaron. Who Owns the Future? Penguin, 2014. “Some of the prominent present-day Siren Servers include high-tech finance schemes, like high-frequency trading or derivatives funds, fashionable Silicon Valley consumer-facing businesses like search or social networking, modern insurance, modern intelligence agencies, and a multitude of other examples.”</p><p>22. Hinchliffe, Tim. “CIA ‘Siren Servers’ Can Predict Social Uprisings 3–5 Days in Advance.” The Sociable, 07 Oct. 2016, (sociable.co/technology/cia-siren-servers-social-uprisings/). Accessed 09 July 2017. “CIA Deputy Director for Digital Innovation Andrew Hallman announced that the agency has beefed-up its “anticipatory intelligence” through the use of deep learning and machine learning servers that can process an incredible amount of data.”</p><p>23. Edge, Eliott. “How VR Gaming Will Wake Us up to Our Fake Worlds.” Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies, 28 June 2016, (<a href="https://ieet.org/index.php/IEET2/more/Edge20160628">https://ieet.org/index.php/IEET2/more/Edge20160628</a>). Accessed 10 July 2017.</p><p>24. Blascovich, Jim, and Jeremy Bailenson. Infinite Reality: Avatars, Eternal Life, New Worlds, and the Dawn of the Virtual Revolution. William Morrow, 2012.</p><p>25. “The Incredible Crash Dummies.” Fox Kids, 16 May 1993, (<a href="http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0445989/">www.imdb.com/title/tt0445989/</a>). “But I need my body! It’s got my arms and legs on it!”</p><p>26. Turkle, Sherry. Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other. Basic Books, 2011. “From the earliest days, videogame players were less interested in winning than in going to a new psychic place where things were always a bit different, but always the same. The gambler and the videogame player share a life of contradiction; you are overwhelmed, and so you disappear into the game.”</p><p>27. “Robert Anton Wilson on Reality.” YouTube, uploaded by RorschachReality, 17 Sept. 2008, [link](<a href="https://youtu.be/GuOplymDx4I">https://youtu.be/GuOplymDx4I</a>). “We’re trapped in linguistic constructs. All that is, is metaphor. I believe someone said that before me. I have decided we can’t get beyond words. What we’ve got to do is get more cynical about our words.”</p><p>28. Wilson, Robert Anton. Cosmic Trigger: Final Secret of the Illuminati. New Falcon Publications, 1986. “My own opinion is that belief is the death of intelligence. As soon as one believes a doctrine of any sort, or assumes certitude, one stops thinking about that aspect of existence. The more certitude one assumes, the less there is left to think about, and a person sure of everything would never have any need to think about anything and might be considered clinically dead under current medical standards, where absence of brain activity is taken to mean that life has ended.”</p><p>29. Edge, Eliott. “Fake Worlds”</p><p>30. Campbell, Tom. My Big TOE: A Trilogy Unifying Philosophy, Physics and Metaphysics. Lightning Strike, 2003.</p><p>31. “Physics, Metaphysics &amp; the Consciousness Connection 3 of 18.” YouTube, uploaded by Tom Campbell, 12 Apr. 2008, <a href="https://youtu.be/zQQaSXUP_Jk">https://youtu.be/zQQaSXUP_Jk</a>. “It changes the results of the experiment if we look […] Looking is the same as a measurement.”</p><p>32. Faye, Jan. “Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Stanford University, 3 May 2002, substantially revised 24 July 2014, (<a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-copenhagen/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qm-copenhagen/</a>). Accessed 12 July 2017. “According to von Neumann, the shift from a type 2-process to a type 1-process takes place only in the presence of the observer’s consciousness. So what causes such a collapse seems to be the mind of the observer.”</p><p>33. Campbell, Tom, et al. “On Testing the Simulation Hypothesis.”</p><p>34. “Simulating Space and Time.” Prespacetime Journal, March 2010, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 218–243.</p><p>35. Edge, Eliott. “Fake Worlds.”</p><p>36. Ibid.</p><p>37. “The Hard Problem: The Science Behind the Fiction.” Roots of The Matrix. Directed by Josh Oreck. Ultimate Edition DVD, Warner Bros., 2004.</p><p>38. Brown, Francis, S R. Driver, Charles A. Briggs, James Strong, and Wilhelm Gesenius. The Brown-Driver-Briggs Hebrew and English Lexicon: With an Appendix Containing the Biblical Aramaic : Coded with the Numbering System from Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance of the Bible. Peabody, Mass: Hendrickson Publishers, 1996.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5d63aa735334" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[TRUE DETECTIVE? MORE LIKE BOO DETECTIVE: NIGHT COUNTRY]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/true-detective-more-like-boo-detective-night-country-d9978ca9da31?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d9978ca9da31</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[true-detective]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hbo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[country-night]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Jan 2024 19:08:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-02T19:55:50.551Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>True Detective: Night Country is not good.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*1x_Eb1bPSZG_tKS_EHUQCw.jpeg" /></figure><p>You can always count on the American crime drama <em>True Detective</em> to pull you into the world of the darkest recesses of the human psyche. Through intense characters with conflicted inner lives that walk the line between light and shadow, between civility and evil — yes, <em>True Detective</em> is where Americans go to be entertained by their favorite cultural pastime: moral ambiguity. Unless you are watching <em>Night Country</em>. Then you are not sure what you’re watching at all.</p><p><em>Night Country</em> (EP1) is a departure from <em>True Detective</em>’s schematic in the worst possible way. Previously, the show has been all about its characters’ personas and their depths of internal contradiction, but so far <em>Night Country</em> is about surfaces and identities. Sadly, I have no idea who these characters are. As opposed to the world famous first season and the criminally neglected third (I skipped the second on consensus authority); I couldn’t even tell you the names of these characters (I had to look them up for this review.) I could tell you they bicker a lot. I could tell you they have no chemistry. I could definitely tell you we are deep in woke this season — which wouldn’t be a problem if the characters were compelling, but they aren’t. And the supernatural has moved gracelessly from a background ambiance to the stark forefront.</p><p>What made Nic Pizzolatto’s work such a departure from the standard crime procedural was its emphasis on very well-developed characters, and particularly on how they think. Season 3, for instance, is nothing short of a tear-jerker about the nature of aging, friendship, memory, loss, and marriage. It is a brilliantly humane turn for a show that’s previous centerpiece was on an anti-natalist and a hypocritical adulterer. <em>Night Country</em> certainly <em>has</em> characters in it, but to describe it as <em>character-driven</em> would be a disservice to what its previous incarnations have until now accomplished so superbly.</p><p>“Well, that’s only the first episode,” I can imagine a detractor retorting. So what? S1 and S3’s first episodes pulled you right into the leads’ heads while getting the mystery going so elegantly that it was impossible to walk away from it unhooked. The first episode had no scene in it like Rust showing up drunk to Marty’s house with a bouquet of flowers (“I’m sorry, Marty.”) It has nothing like Wayne and Roland shooting rats in a garbage pile, reminiscing on Steve McQueen, where Roland takes aim at a fox that wanders into the fray, and Wayne tells him, “I’ll give you a dollar <em>not </em>to shoot it.” There is no moment where you are drawn into the leads world — slowly finding out who they are. Stuff just happens. There is no musical rhythm to the story. Liz plays Fantasy Football. Navarro steals a Spongebob Squarepants electric toothbrush from her FWB. That’s all I can tell you about these leads so far. We haven’t entered the heads in the way that the show is so well appreciated for.</p><p>The other terrible lack is of emotional resonance. Where S1’s emphasis is on just how dark a human could can become via both Rust and the crime he and Marty are investigating, Night Country was weirdly void of emotion. S3 is nearly overflowing with emotion. Wayne asks his wife Amelia to end their argument because otherwise he’s going to start crying. Roland is in tears when he complains to Wayne that they haven’t seen each other in years for a beer or to watch a ballgame as he promised they would. These are wonderful moments, and they make us interested in what’s going on.</p><p><em>Night Country</em> was like: okay, Log Lady from <em>Twin Peaks.</em> Check. Insert shots of: <em>The Thing </em>on DVD<em>, </em>a copy of <em>Blood Meridian, </em>a Wilco t-shirt (clues effectively telling us, “<em>Men</em> were here… Probably that last men you’re gonna see again in this show.”) Copy that. What else is going on? Everyone seems pretty mean in Ennis, Alaska. No one seems to be getting along. Not the men, the women, the enbys — everyone talks down to each other. The Natives don’t seem to like the other Natives. And the animals are all computer-generated. It’s tiresome stuff.</p><p>All the hints are there saying, “this is not really <em>True Detective</em>.” The fact that it is the first season to have a sub-title, or Nic Pizzolatto posting “True Detective S1–3 (NOT Night Country)” on his Instagram profile are all leading us to this obvious conclusion. I don’t blame him. I also would distance myself from a creation that amounts to a fundamental misunderstanding of my beliefs as a writer and artist.</p><p>It’s not that the show centers on women, or is written and directed by a woman that makes it bad. That would be a foolish, sexist, bullshit reading, and it is something producers have been using as an easy deflection when their work is less than good. What makes <em>Night Country </em>bad is that its a poorly written and directed first episode. It makes it doubly bad that its attached to the <em>TD</em> brand. That’s why people don’t like it.</p><p>And to claim that “toxic fanboys” are review bombing this show purely over sexism is to neglect the above: that the show isn’t really <em>True Detective, </em>because, so far, it is not about complex characters nor is it about moral ambiguity in the face of a profoundly <em>human</em> evil. (No supernatural force will ever be as haunting as the first time we saw Reggie Ledoux.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*82Ve9zsU1_bjTl6lG0xo7w.gif" /></figure><p>I said it before in my review of <a href="https://eliottedge.medium.com/amcs-interview-with-the-vampire-truly-sucks-1caf81e8ef25">AMC’s Anne Rice’s Interview with the Vampire</a>: good writing is not <em>telling</em> me what I should think and feel. Good writing is <em>guiding</em> me to those thoughts and feelings, while engaging me along the way. In a phrase: artful manipulation.</p><p><em>Night Country</em> will not be as long as previous seasons. Based on the strength of its first episode, it is not hard to imagine why. There is simply not that much to say.</p><p>I will tune in for Episode 2 with a mix of hope and morbid curiosity. To see how far the show can go off the rails. The wheels on this train already have an arm busted off, that’s just slamming and digging into the dirt.</p><p>My bet is that some point near the end, our white police chief Liz, who pokes fun at Navarro’s Native heritage, will have some kind of encounter with the supernatural that changes the way she sees the world. Maybe a rainbow-colored aurora will lead her to a clue.</p><p>D.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d9978ca9da31" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How VR Gaming Will Wake Us Up To Our Fake Worlds]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/how-vr-gaming-will-wake-us-up-to-our-fake-worlds-64baf91894ff?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/64baf91894ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thoughts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virtual-reality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Sep 2023 02:42:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-09T02:42:24.898Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How VR Gaming will wake us up to our fake worlds</h3><p>“It has no relationship whatsoever to anything anchored in some kind of metaphysical superspace. It’s just your cultural point of view […] Travel shows you the relativity of culture.” Terence McKenna, <em>Taxonomy of Illusion¹</em></p><p>Human civilization has always been a virtual reality. At the onset of culture, which was propagated through the proto-media of cave painting, the talking drum, music, fetish art making, oral tradition and the like, <em>Homo sapiens</em> began a march into cultural virtual realities, a march that would span the entirety of the human enterprise. We don’t often think of cultures as virtual realities, but there is no more apt descriptor for our widely diverse sociological organizations and interpretations than the metaphor of the “virtual reality.” Indeed, the virtual reality metaphor encompasses the complete human project.</p><p>Virtual reality researchers, Jim Blascovich and Jeremy Bailenson, write in their book <em>Infinite Reality</em> “[Cave art] is likely the first animation technology,” where it provided an early means of what they refer to as “virtual travel.”² You are in the cave, but the media in that cave, the dynamically drawn, fire-illuminated art, represents the plains and animals outside — a completely different environment; one facing entirely the opposite direction, beyond the mouth of the cave. When surrounded by cave art, alive with movement from flickering torches, you are at once inside the cave itself whilst the media experience surrounding you encourages you to indulge in fantasy, and to mentally simulate an entirely different environment.³ Blascovich and Bailenson suggest that in terms of the evolution of media technology, this was the very first immersive VR. Both the room and helmet-sized VRs used in the present day are but a sophistication of this original form of media VR tech.</p><p>Today, philosophers and critics have pointed out that businesses such as McDonald’s and Starbucks are like virtual realities in and of them-selves. They have a specific and immersive decorum as well as sanctioned behaviors, symbols, and even philosophies. When you enter Starbucks, you enter Starbucks World. In contemporary jargon, these are called <em>hyperrealities</em> — they are microcosms with their own purposes and messages.⁴ Disneyland and Times Square are the epitome of consumerist hyperrealities in the United States. These hyperrealities are cloned (copied and pasted) and hold a global footprint in an ever-homogenized worldwide monoculture. They are a touchstone of the global capitalist project; many stores in many locations that are nearly exactly the same. (Similarly, even restaurants that aren’t franchise mega-chains offer differing atmospheres; competing little worlds to wine and dine in.) Where did the hyperrealities that typify contemporary life get their start? What happened between the cave paintings and these franchises that nearly everyone on the planet today knows intimately well? I’d like to suggest they got their start with the codification of certain places of worship and the belief systems that joined them.</p><h3>In the Beginning…</h3><p>A simple illustration of the origin of our more complex cultural virtual realities is found in the temple or the church, which acted as the centerpiece of many cultures as they began their voyage into modernity. When we strip the church of the concepts and objects about it, what are we left with? Unoccupied, we are left with a mere building. Yet as we add the corresponding accouterments into and around this building, its virtual reality generating effects amplify and multiply. A church has its altar, its sacred texts, costumes, rituals, sermons, perspectives, symbols, architecture, and so on. All of them are meaningful. The religion is built from this assemblage. Outside, the church is just a building. Inside, the church is a virtual reality — the nodal point of a given religion and a given people. They all work together to reinforce a very specific perception of the world.</p><p>Indeed, no one ever actually “enters a church.” One in fact stumbles headlong into the <em>idea</em> of a church — a hyperreal onslaught that the very constitution of the church building is purposefully designed to generate. Entering a church is really entering a church-shaped thought. The church building was an early virtual reality headset. From within the church building one looks outward from it and magically the world becomes that religion. The primordial incarnation of this building-sized headset was none other than the very same image-laden, torch-lit caves of our pre-architectural ancestors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Da2jmMnt5qULHmho1TjcYg.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1 — VR Head Church Man</em></figcaption></figure><p>We see this virtual reality-ness in all the objects around and inside a given church or temple, but one very blatant example can be seen in the Christian handiwork of stained glass art. We have here a nigh on literal representation of key features of contemporary virtual reality technology: filtering and projection. The stained glass is a projective filter that works in both directions simultaneously: light coming into the building is transformed to bring the cultural program of meaningful images into the interiors of the sanctuary, where they are contemplated and dogmatized; and back out of the building, where the observers inside look outward to a terra firma that is now obfuscated or filtered by the media-messages embedded in the stained glass. The stained glass itself is an evolution of the cave painting. Stained glass would go on to evolve into the pixel. Indeed, stained glass was really a stop between the cave painting and the pixel.</p><h3>Language, Culture, and Religion are all Virtual Realities</h3><p>Take another criterion of human civilization and culture in terms of the virtual reality metaphor: language. Regarding text, Kevin Kelly has stated:</p><blockquote>The human mind is actually, has a propensity, a natural gift to move into other realities. When you are reading a book, a novel, when you’re totally engrossed in a story, particularly one that’s not visual, that you’re imagining in your own mind, you’re creating a kind of version, a kind of virtual reality.⁵</blockquote><p>When we read we decode the text. That translation directs the theater of our minds to run or play out a given simulation (“See Spot run! Run Spot run!”). This whole phenomenon of reading and imagining takes place in the invisible holodeck of our minds (more on the term ‘holodeck’ later). Taking this analogy and bringing it back to the ‘inner’ virtual reality of the ‘voice in our heads,’ one reads a religious text that is then projected outward, creating a now religiousized ‘external’ reality. This is how the vision of a Christian world or a Hindu world is actualized: by deeply absorbing and projecting text-induced mental simulations like “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one can come to the Father except through me.” Once I have faith and believe this to <em>actually</em> be true, I am then living in a Christian virtual reality. I have imagined this particular program into being. I have assimilated x-religion’s VR and now live and think in it.</p><p>Undoubtedly, not all religions can be said to be ‘true.’ All these different religions are supposedly interpretations of reality or the human condition. The mathematical likelihood of all religions being entirely true is zero, for, despite overlap, they contain different codes, perspectives, accounts, conclusions and so on. They represent humanity’s endless struggle with the pressing matter of our shared circumstance — that circumstance being: existing, living, and dying in a vast, mysterious universe. What all these religious interpretations do share however is that they are not at all dissimilar to virtual realities. They are all self-contained little worlds. However, the virtual reality metaphor doesn’t stop at religion. Similarly, different cultures and civilizations are no more ‘true’ than any other. They too are self-contained little worlds. The virtual reality metaphor includes cultures, ideologies, and all other kinds of frameworks and belief systems. Communism, atheism, scientism, Freudianism are as much cultural virtual realities as the perspectives of the world that come from totalitarian North Korea, or American fundamentalist Evangelical Christianity. They have different rules, but they are all bubble-like points of view that change what would otherwise be the raw experience of the world into their own code, their own vision of how things are or ought to be.</p><p>Take the concept of a nation. A nation is really just a set of notions; their only extra active value is that the notions of a given nation are <em>mandated</em> (forced). Laws and legislation, orders, decrees, calendars, cycles, and taboos are each VR nation’s programming — their cultural code of conduct. They represent what is permissible and accepted in this world or that. A flag is a VR designating icon, a technology, that whips and colors our minds as much as it does the wind, the sky, and the otherwise uninterrupted terra firma.⁶ Our navigational and national lines that crisscross the face of the earth are invisible, imaginary, virtual lines. Where one nation begins and another ends marks the boundaries between separate sets of notions, separate virtual realities. Kings, politicians, lawyers, judges, soldiers, police, executioners, and other “officials” represent an entire class of enforcers of the notions of a nation. These are the rules and rulers of any given cultural VR world. Guns, badges, robes, gavels, jumpsuits, chains, and legalese have VR-generating effects that make the processes of ‘officialdom’ appear as if they are legitimate, objective, incorruptible, and deep.</p><p>Since, like religions, societies seemingly can-not approach a more ‘true’ incarnation, or state of being; all that might be said about x-culture versus y-culture in terms of which is ‘better’ might be argued in terms of how well each nurtures the health, wellbeing, and freedom for all the people, animals, plants, and other environmental factors in each. So other than considering an across the board prosocial and ethical gauge, they are all nonetheless always already entirely self-contained relative virtual worlds — none more ‘true’ than any another.</p><h3><strong>You are Virtual Reality</strong></h3><p>The robustness of the virtual reality metaphor spans not just religions, cultures, nations, ideologies, and other belief systems, but continues right down to the individual. The individual perpetuates their own personal virtual reality — their <em>reality tunnel</em> as described by Timothy Leary and Robert Anton Wilson. Wilson states:</p><blockquote>Once you look down at your reality tunnel, whether your reality tunnel is Ohio Methodist or, New York Jewish or, Morin County hippie or, Tokyo capitalist Zen Buddhist or, Iranian Muslim fundamentalist, once you get to the level when you’re outside of your reality tunnel looking down at it you can compare reality tunnels and then you’re at a higher level of intelligence already because you are no longer a conditioned mechanism just following the reality tunnel that was accidentally imprinted or conditioned and you can start choosing between reality tunnels.⁷</blockquote><p>Reality tunnel may be a new term for some, but its simplicity in conveying the altogether all too well-known immediate experience in the differences between say <em>“being American”</em> as opposed to be <em>“being Vietnamese”</em> is unmatched. Even phrases like “to have blinders on” or “tunnel vision” mean the inability to access or appreciate another point of view other than one’s own preferred cultural virtual reality, or VR programming. One can’t look beyond it. One can’t deeply consider other points of view as they are more or less glued into their favorite virtual reality; that being their culture, their belief system, its agenda, its definitions of classes, self, others, and so on. Christians and capitalists alike read their given reinforcing texts, and critique the texts of those they deem outsiders or even enemies. They then spam the world and their peers with the would-be revelations of their world, their reality tunnel. And, appropriately enough, a reality tunnel is very much what is induced when you strap yourself into a VR headset. As one might imagine, all this talk of reality tunnels puts the focus on the ego.</p><p>The ego is the first and final enforcer of a given cultural virtual reality, a given reality tunnel. Part of the process of ego generation and calcification within a certain cultural virtual reality gestates in private experience, with the phenomena of conscious and unconscious self-talk. First, one is both physically and psychically immersed in a given cultural VR. Then our minds chatter away, finding concepts, words, ideas, images, symbols, slogans, behaviors, rituals, billboards, logics, (dis)beliefs, fears, frameworks, memes, heroes, villains, and interpretations — all to either dismiss or indulge within that cultural VR. The ones we’re most attracted to we cling onto, even if they are sadomasochistic or result in neuroses or pathologies; cognitive dissonance, unhappiness, violence — it doesn’t matter. People are hard pressed to relinquish their reality tunnels and all the easy or favorite answers that they offer. What human beings have proved over the centuries is that they can believe or disbelieve almost anything — reason is frequently moot. This chatter, dismissal, comparison, and indulgence builds up the levels and dimensions of the waking ego. Our thoughts grow our sense of self in this way. Our conscious personality (and often what we ‘claim to be’ in terms of ideology, religion, philosophy, class, career, and so on) is what living in human-made virtual reality cultures and frameworks ultimately and inevitably creates. We accept our roles, becoming projectors, filters, propagators, true believers, subscription customers, evangelists, defenders, critics, missionaries, ‘Romans,’ and so on. We are active players in our favorite cultural virtual reality super-drama and it is our playing, our indulging, that keeps it all afloat.</p><p>In considering what we supposedly are and what we are not, it is interesting to mention that in gender and queer theory we find concepts that sexual identity is just as much a virtual reality as anything else we’ve been discussing. Gender, in these interpretations, can be as non-fundamental and virtual as any religion is. Judith Butler has explored a key concept here with <em>Performativity</em>: gender is intimately tied with the performance of gender, which is irrelevant to biological sex.⁸ “Girls will be boys and boys will be girls,” as The Kinks aptly observed. Furthermore, the human body is (supposedly) the first filter of the ‘external’ information that we call ‘the world.’ If this is true, then the world can only ever reflect our own bodily senses. So even the body itself could be viewed as a virtual reality bubble as well. The body is the first filter taking in the input of the cosmos and all its manifestation. On a physical level the funnel of our bodily organs receiving information from the universe always distorts the universe into the shape of our own senses. This is why we can only physically see a few bands of colored light. We are only directly privy to 0.0035% of the total electromagnetic spectrum. In a human body you can’t see the whole spectrum⁹; you can’t see all of reality as it truly is. You only have access to a human-centric version (a sliver) of reality. A version that amounts to a simulation of reality provided by the human body and mind. In science and philosophy this has been called <em>naïve realism</em>¹⁰ — human bodily senses are deeply limited in their ability to accurately perceive the world as it truly is. Anaïs Nin wrote, “We don’t see things as they are. We see things as we are.”¹¹</p><h3>All Thought is Virtual Reality</h3><p>Finally, there is the entire faculty of thought itself, and with it, imagining. Recall Kevin Kelly’s comments on reading at the beginning of this paper: “[When reading a book] you’re imagining in your own mind, you’re creating a kind of version, a kind of virtual reality.” In a similar line of reasoning, Blascovich and Bailenson write:</p><blockquote>‘Virtual reality’ typically conjures up futuristic images […] But we believe that virtual reality really begins in the mind and requires no equipment whatsoever. Have you ever spoken face-to-face with someone whose mind wandered off? […] Hungry people imagine what they’ll eat.¹²</blockquote><p>Imagining, and indeed thought itself, is the first, most immediate form of virtual reality (alongside bodily sense data). Similarly, the mind has often been referred to in both Eastern and Western literature as working from ‘images.’ Yet ‘images’ today implies something static, and thought is anything but static. Our mental images move about chaotically, giving the impression of an animation. Take this analogy one step further and we can easily substitute ‘animations’ with ‘simulations.’ Even ‘reasoning’ is very much the same as simulating. And simulation, or simulating, quickly becomes analogous to virtual reality. In the language of popular culture, thought and the mind is very much like the aforementioned holodeck from <em>Star Trek</em>.</p><p>Like the holodeck, the mind is like a room that will become anything you or others tell it to become. Almost anything you tell it (program it) to become, the mind will oblige. This can be achieved through words, grunts, language, and text but also through any and all forms of comprehensible media or gesture. You, the reader, have been playing out simulations in your own mental holodeck as you’ve read this paper. This is how we manage to both imagine and participate in such a diverse ecosystem of vastly differing nations, religions, cultures, ideologies, opinions, scenarios, reality tunnels and so on. Virtual reality is how we’ve made our human world.</p><h3>Approaching our Fake Worlds</h3><p>As we have seen, the virtual reality metaphor relates to many domains of human experience; from how our bodies take in information, to how our minds work, to the impact that cultures, nationalities, and religions make on our point of view. This is the utter strength of the metaphor of virtual reality and why it is foundational to some philosophies and religions, though frequently presented using other language (māyā, skepticism). There is likely no more singularly important consideration than the consideration of alternative worlds, illusory worlds, projected worlds, and manipulable worlds. In the contemporary cinematic “jazz mythology” of The Matrix (as Peter B. Lloyd describes it)¹³, Neo’s awakening to the presence of the Matrix is not so much a cyberpunk fantasia as much as it is a 58 commentary on human civilization, culture, and consciousness as a whole. This contemporary allegory retrieves sentiments found in Plato’s Cave, Shakespeare’s musing that “All the world’s a stage,” and much of the philosophical and spiritual thought throughout the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*opO9ddPiCWcYZ_x88dtWkA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2 — Everything human is approximately equal to Virtual Reality</figcaption></figure><p>Cornel West brings our attention to the dramatic nature of actually taking on whole and fully confronting this paramount philosophical consideration. West states on the Philosopher’s Commentary track on <em>The Matrix</em>, “What’s very interesting is the relation between awakening and danger. Once you begin to question you begin to constitute a threat to whatever authority is keeping track of you.”</p><p>And then:</p><blockquote>Socratic energy has to do with contesting authority, being deeply suspicious of authority, trying to undermine the assumptions and presuppositions upon which authority is predicated. And this process, which is an endless process, it’s an incessant process, but it goes step-by-step and stage-by-stage. And at the very beginning now we get the staging of what happens when one initiates a process of awakening in which you render various authorities relative. You begin to contest and call into question those various authorities.”¹⁴</blockquote><p>This point of “render[ing] various authorities relative” is going to be more central as we move forward.</p><p>Our situation becomes more interesting when we consider the growing popularity of virtual reality headsets. Given the growing availability of VR gaming headsets to consumers, it’s natural to begin conjuring with the psychological, sociological, and ontological auxiliary effects that they may end up engendering. After all, they will be changing previous contexts even as they create new contexts. It seems certain that the proliferation of virtual reality and augmented reality entertainment technology will have psychological effects that bleed out far beyond their intended use and into the thoughts of our daily lives, long after we’ve put our VR gear down. When they do, they might inadvertently start rendering more and more aspects of authority outside them utterly relative and non-fundamental. A VR gaming induced pan-queerification, if you will. Sentiments may arise like: “<em>This game outside is as virtual as that game inside.</em>” The VR headset could underscore an awakening to our already well in place, indeed pervasive, projected human virtual realities (our cultures, etc.) as they exist today. Maybe we’ll bump into the joke (or conundrum) that when we take off our VR video gaming visor we aren’t really re-entering the “real world” at all. We are only ever re-entering the local fantasia, our own personal fantasia, and our responses to the fantasias of others — a place as constructed and limited by human ideas as the one we just left. The ultimate irony then becomes this: the apex in spectacle entertainment, the immersive VR, may end up being the final panacea against all forms of ideological fundamentalism, extremism, and dogma — be they Western colonialism or North Korean totalitarian necrocracy. That might be wishful thinking indeed but once you can fit a civilization into a VR, then we’ll quickly see that any civilization is a VR already.</p><p>After all, does it not seem predictable that we are going to test-run different worlds and social orders in VR games? Naturally some gamers will be so moved by their experiences there that they may even return to waking IRL culture and attempt to mold it in similar ways. Does it not seem inevitable that we will also test out new forms of conditioning, indoctrination, brainwashing, and propaganda using VR? What about when political parties begin having their national events in VR spaces? Can’t you see the VR megachurch coming? Do you think that once we’re in that VR megachurch we will realize that the churches were all already VRs to begin with? That all that we can declare to be the ‘human world’ was always just one human-centric VR or another?</p><p>The VR metaphor reminds us that all of our institutions are fundamentally projections. We give these projections (and the virtual worlds they create), power by participating, and most importantly, by <em>indulging</em> them as legitimate. All cultures and civilizations are relative. So much so, we might well remind ourselves through reaffirming this VR metaphor, if we are to remain steadfast in seeking whatever can be found and developed far beyond their assumed thresholds and limits of vision. Perhaps the cultural apocalypse (‘apocalypse’ as in ‘unveiling’) we require in order to free ourselves from the bondage of our current ecocidal project can also be found with this metaphor. Maybe VR will give us the psychic breathing room necessary to reexamine what are <em>fundamentally </em><strong><em>our</em></strong><em> creations</em> — currency for instance. Breathing room for a new vision and a new culture to develop that doesn’t so breezily permit catastrophe upon catastrophe. Indeed, culture wouldn’t be a problem if our current attempts at culture didn’t create so many problems (externalities, classism, ecocide, etc.)</p><p>Ultimately, the speed, variety, liquidity, and accessibility of VR games will begin to challenge the ways of life outside them. After all, if life is different or even better in an entertainment-based game VR, why shouldn’t our cultural virtual realities mutate to be equally as pleasant, if not better?</p><p>Almost too simple to possibly be true, Jiddu Krishnamurti often repeated; “Thought is responsible for all of this.”¹⁵</p><p>Indeed: <em>Thought </em><strong><em>is</em></strong><em> responsible for all of this. </em>It’s a comment that demands consideration, especially because we rarely think about what thought is (‘simulations’), let alone what thought has unleashed upon the world. We have projected this nightmare scenario and followed it through mercilessly and diligently. It did not arrive in a vacuum. We built this place and fostered these conditions. We imagined it and made it, ad infinitum. Every man-made disaster, intentional or otherwise, is largely thanks to one virtual reality or another. Even industrial accidents that occur under the watch of multibillion-dollar corporations often occur because of a fixed perspective on profit, and a lax perspective on what seems to be almost anything else. We caused these problems, or excused them, or permitted them, thanks to each cultural VR’s framework, that being their rules and values.</p><p>Maybe VR will remind us that all of this is so. We are living within cultures for sure, but really these cultures are made of thought, and both thought and culture are analogous to virtual reality. They are projected simulated worlds and scenarios. Such a universally relative perspective is really a radical embrace of <em>Subjectivity</em> as being an obvious fundamental player in the human enterprise. There is no objectivity in this regard. There is no objectively ‘true’ civilization, nor a ‘true’ religion. Any civilization is built and maintained by projected thoughts, associations, actions, images, behaviors, rules, and so on.</p><p>Admissions such as these frequently generate vertigo. People generally don’t like the arguments for near total subjectivity — because they often give off an air that there is, as the saying goes, “Nothing to hang your hat on.” Indeed, the rendering of major icons of reality and authority as being relative is almost always characterized by an experience of extreme disorientation. This is why Neo vomits at the feet of the revelation that the world he’s been living in is a total illusion. (He repeats, “I don’t believe it! I don’t believe it!”) Our ever-diverse human worlds were always ever just our own minds creating virtual realities to evolve, exchange, and play in. Chogyam Trunpa Rinpoche captured it well with the comment; “The bad news is you are falling through the air, nothing to hang on to, no parachute. The good news is there is no ground.”¹⁶</p><h3>Consciousness and the thresholds of VR</h3><p>If all we’ve made, and all we think, are deeply analogous to VR, the question should come: What exists that is not a VR, or even like a VR? What isn’t our human-made VR masquerading as the real? What is fundamental? It may be better to suggest an approach, rather than claim any particular fundamental reality (although, I will do this later anyway).</p><p>Terrence McKenna suggested one such approach. He advocated for; “[A] philosophy not made around the campfire. But philosophy based on the acquisition of extreme experience. That’s how you figure out what the world is. Not by bicycling around in the ‘burbs but by forcing extreme experience.”¹⁷ McKenna’s suggested approach is through the well-known cultural vaporizing effects of psychedelic experiences. Peter Sjöstedt-H has given presentations on the historic use of consciousness-altering compounds by philosophers from the Ancient Greeks to Aldous Huxley in the pursuit of knowledge gained from beyond one’s culture.18, 19 He even argues that Plato’s Cave is a perfect allegory for the benefits of the psychedelic experience. Pioneers in the computer revolution like Steve Jobs, Douglas Engelbart, Kevin Herbert, as well as the founders of Google are known to have had important encounters with psychedelics.²⁰ Dr. Kary Banks Mullis won the Nobel Prize for his LSD-fueled DNA research leading to the invention of PCR.²¹ Carl Sagan and John C. Lilly were also well-known fans of psychedelics.²²-²³ Artists of all stripes swear by the value of visionary intoxicants in their role of inspiring some of the most beloved masterpieces of all time. Literature suggests that there is a deep value in the compounds, plants, substances, and practices that help us human beings “break on through to the other side” — that “other side” being the domain beyond our familiar and pervasive human VRs and frameworks.</p><p>It is interesting to note that VR headsets and visors actually mirror the psychedelic experience in many ways. They mirror it in that when you don the headset you enter a new world. You put on the new head. And when you do, you see another possible vision of how reality could be. When you are done and take off the headset, you are hit with a second insight: the relativity of this world, this cultural virtual reality, or universe, to the headset-VR world you just exited. Returning from your trip is as valuable as going on the trip in the first place, because now you have a more robust mechanism by which to compare worlds. Suddenly they are both non-fundamental. Suddenly they are relative. If you’ve never left Sri Lanka or the Amish way of life for example, then that’s your threshold of knowledge and the height of your interpretive powers. What we are left with after these encounters with cultural relativity (regardless of the means by which it is achieved) is that, to quote McKenna; “Most of reality is illusory. It’s just we do each other the courtesy of not pointing this out.”²⁴ However it should be deeply appreciated that the VR headset experience at this time cannot rival the awesome panoply of titanic revelation that digesting certain plants and compounds can offer. VR offers a parallel to psychedelics (some, McKenna included, have argued that VR is the technological shadow of the psychedelic experience), but it is not at all the psychedelic experience proper, in all its quaking, annihilating, and mind-expanding glory.</p><p>Beyond doing whatever you can to temporarily escape your local VR programming, an admission would be that <em>consciousness itself is fundamental to all our virtual realities.</em> Consciousness is the media through which all our cultures, religions, civilizations, thoughts, and reality tunnels play out. So although what we have created can be regarded as virtual realities, consciousness itself doesn’t necessarily fit the criteria. Consciousness is real, ‘Canada’ and ‘Canadian’ is imaginary, is virtual. Consciousness plays within the framework of ‘Canada’ and ‘Canadian’ but it isn’t those constructs on a fundamental level. Consciousness is not virtual reality, though it uses virtual realities to operate in. What are we without our virtual realities? We are alive and indeed life itself. We are the end result of billions of years of cosmological evolution. And we are consciousness. One of the all-time best comments for underscoring the insidious depth of this virtual reality projecting faculty of the mind is found in a saying: “At the end of the day, a real Buddhist realizes that there is no such thing as a real Buddhist.” It is all the mind.</p><p>It is not as Morpheus says; “As long as the Matrix exists the human race will never be free.”²⁵ We will always be building a Matrix to see, move, and operate through. Instead, as long as the Matrix exists and remains <em>deeply unacknowledged as a Matrix and ever-indulged as “true,” </em>the human race will never be free. Consequently, nor will the global ecosystem likely survive; for as long as it remains a mere supporting character — or worse, has no role whatsoever — in our reality tunnels, the prominence it deserves in our decisions cannot be realized.</p><p>Let us not be like innocent, forgiving, or unassuming children in the face of our entirely relative, projected, cultural virtual realities. For they more or less entirely dominate our thoughts and lives. Nonconformity is frequently met with alienation at the very least. At this point our virtual realities also make up a likely cause of death for the planetary ecosystem. The capitalist VR is one such obvious culprit in terms of large-scale environmental and species devastation. At one point in the past these forms of engagement seemed to have risen up organically alongside the evolution of our meaning-making neocortex. Today however it would be naïve to assume that they are harmless — especially considering the expansion and proliferation of various forms of power centralization, and the violence that typifies them. Our cultural virtual realities have values and institutions that clearly exist to keep the power status quo well maintained and far removed from the majority. They also devastate every corner of the planet that is within reach, frequently in the pursuit of transforming it into altogether virtual “profit.” McKenna pointed out:</p><blockquote>Someone rather intelligent once said, ‘Language was invented so that people could lie.’ In other words, it gives you that fudge factor of obfuscation where someone says, you know, “Why did you do that?” Well the best approach is, ‘’I didn’t do that!’ You know, ‘You thought I did that. What you thought you saw you didn’t see!’ In other words, I suppose that lawyers are probably the people who have done the finest work with language and behind them politicians. And the true potential for language to elevate and unite the community was early on betrayed into the production of illusory and ideological goods which could then be marketed among the people and to spread confusion.²⁶</blockquote><p>Culture is great for lying. This is as unsentimental, unflattering, and indeed honest as it gets. The leaders, profiteers, true believers, indeed the leading-edge of the lie, are more than likely in on the con — for they execute undying efforts, regardless of how absurd or atrocious, to keep it all maintained. McKenna once again; “It’s not like there is [a situation] where greybeards in white coats tend the sacred vestal fires of reality. There <em>is</em> no reality. There are only people who know this and people who don’t know this and are therefore being manipulated by the people who do know it.”²⁷</p><p>So, what’s the valuable or worthwhile course of action considering all we’ve covered? Wilson suggested; “On a planet that increasingly resembles one huge Maximum Security prison, the only intelligent choice is to plan a jail break.”²⁸</p><h3>Never forget: we made it all up</h3><p>The only way out of any cultural VR is to first accept that you are more than likely always already on the user-end of one or another. The first thing a fish must do if it is to escape the water is to identify that it is in fact water to begin with. That there exists both water and not-water. After making that discovery, it can then begin the slow climb of exploring the hitherto before unknown environments and dimensions, as well as the accompanying new states of being necessary to participate in them — that is: legs, lungs, wings, and the like. Step one is seeing your culture for the virtual reality that it is. This is the essence of “awakening” as the colloquialism goes. It is also the essence of becoming “hip.” Simple enough: If you were born in another country and grew up in another culture, another VR, you’d like have a different opinion on a myriad of subjects. But, like the fish before it discovered the land, it is difficult, if not impossible, to imagine prior to experience. Culture is a virtual reality with which we see and move through the world — and cultures are entirely of our own making. As we have seen, these VRs exist in myriad domains and forms of human experience and behavior. Why is it so important to realize everything we’ve gone through is a virtual reality? So that you, dear reader, feel empowered to change it, to overcome it, to not accept it as “business as usual” or “the way things are.” “Business as usual at this point is a death sentence on the human race,” McKenna claimed.²⁹ These are all virtual realities. None of them are anchored to any transcendental wisdom or truth. How these VRs have informed us isn’t fundamentally true. Largely, they are arbitrary. They amount to convenient contrivances. Our game is just a game. The rules are our own. We made all this up. There is no need to indulge any culture or framework as being the final word on reality or social organization. Indeed, we are the elephant in the room. When we discover that we are all responsible for the shadows dancing on the wall, we will realize that we are both the cause and the solution to all of our problems. From here new frontiers shall open. It is the goal of any system of intelligence to transcend itself. This is paramount in assessing the world we have created and the world we are leaving behind, not just for our future ancestors, but for all lifeforms on this planet. Ralph Waldo Emerson is credited with the remark, “The end of the human race will be that it will eventually die of civilization.” If we bear in mind pollution, warfare, national or cultural tensions, and the unbridled excesses of capitalism, then Emerson’s comment on civilization is far from obscure. Similarly, McKenna stressed: It makes no sense whatsoever to speak of a human future. There is no human future. It’s inconceivable, given where we are today, that to speak of the human world a thousand years from now or five hundred years from now, it is literally, it either doesn’t exist, or it’s beyond our power of imagining.30 Our world today has a few perilous demands: drop the old games (our projective filters and madeup rules), see through them, outgrow them entirely if necessary, and begin to imagine and participate in better ones. As Mark Booth closed his seminal and endlessly peculiar, 2010 book The Secret History of the World, “Imagination is the key.”³¹ Just imagine cultural virtual realities that are more meaningful, beautiful, ecumenical, compassionate, sustainable, efficient, and indeed more loving to play in. In a word: wiser. The call upon the present generation is to radically shift gears and awaken to what we are really doing. We will accept our responsibility for this crisis or we will go down in the history of the universe as another menagerie of pseudo-intelligent space bumpkins at the far end of the galactic arm who collapsed into dust under the weight of their own illusions. This is the warning shot echoing through modernity fired by none other than Mary Shelley in Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. We will end at the hands of none other than both our own psychic and physical creations — our virtual reality worlds — unless we evolve them. Rendering these cultural VRs relative is an essential part of the process in transcending and evolving them. Again, why do they demand to be transcended and transformed? Because they simply aren’t up to snuff; they do not match the moral and ethical reasoning that is necessary to handle the pan-destructive forces that our fathers and grandfathers have already unleashed upon the surface of the earth. It’s really that simple. Our most powerful and influential cultures are far from benign. Culture eats nature; our worst VRs eat the world. The challenge and the gift that we have given ourselves is a whole planet on the brink — the ultimate narrative, the life or death game par excellence. The creator’s creation now threatens the continuity of life itself, when its hope was supposedly always to uplift. All in all, it’s a very exciting time to be alive. You won’t get a better opening act to the primate’s next stage of awakening than the one where it has fallen into its own otherwise brilliant, multi-millennia in the making death trap. The question bubbling up as the Information Age gives birth to the Virtual Age is; “What will end up being born out of our totally humanized enclosure when we push hard enough against the thresholds of our collective fantasy worlds?” You will know where you really stand by comparing the writing on the wall against the acidity index of the world’s oceans.</p><p>Originally published in the IEET 2016. Republished in <em>Three Essays on Virtual Reality, Overlords, Civilization, and Escape.</em></p><p><strong>FOOTNOTES</strong></p><p>1. <em>The Taxonomy of Illusion.</em> Sound Photosynthesis,<br>1993. Performance by Terence McKenna.<br>Videocassette. The first category or grand family<br>of illusions which we would put into our<br>taxonomic key would be social illusions, and<br>when I, and — you know, later we can argue this,<br>but at this point in the discussion, illusion is slash<br>delusion, so the great social illusions/delusions<br>are sexism, racism, xenophobia, egoism, so far,<br>classism. The world is riddled and ruled by these<br>social illusions and no one is free of them, and so<br>they constitute one broad category.</p><p>2. Blascovich, Jim, and Jeremy Bailenson. <em>Infinite<br>Reality: Avatars, Eternal Life, New Worlds, and the<br>Dawn of the Virtual Revolution.</em> William Morrow,<br>2012. [F]or ancestral humans, words were not<br>enough — so graphics were invented. The room is<br>a large cave. At the entry, a sign informs you that<br>the cave is a replica of one in Lascaux, France,<br>where cave paintings date back at least thirty<br>thousand years. The cave walls are covered with<br>several primitive drawings, some of large animals<br>in motion, some of hunters, and some of<br>curvaceous women […] The fire casts his shadow<br>on the cave ceiling. He entertains everyone with a<br>series of hand and finger motions creating a<br>panoply of moving shadow animals. You realize<br>that this is likely the first animation technology.</p><p>3. <em>Cave of Forgotten Dreams.</em> Directed by Werner<br>Herzog, IFC Films, 2010. For these Paleolithic<br>painters, the play of light and shadows from their<br>torches could possibly have looked something<br>like this. For them, the animals perhaps appeared<br>moving, living. We should note that the artists<br>painted this bison with eight legs, suggesting<br>movement, almost a form of proto-cinema. The<br>walls themselves are not flat but have their own<br>three-dimensional dynamic, their own<br>movement, which was utilized by the artists. In<br>the upper left corner, another multi-legged<br>animal. And the rhino to the right seems also to<br>have the illusion of movement, like frames in an<br>animated film.</p><p>4. Kellner, Douglas. “Jean Baudrillard.” Stanford<br>Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Stanford University,<br>22 Apr. 2005, substantially revised 7 Mar. 2007,<br>https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/baudrillard/.<br>Accessed 02 July 2017. [Baudrillard’s]<br>postmodern universe is one of hyperreality in<br>which entertainment, information, and<br>communication technologies provide experiences<br>more intense and involving than the scenes of<br>banal everyday life, as well as the codes and<br>models that structure everyday life. The realm of<br>the hyperreal (e.g., media simulations of reality,<br>Disneyland and amusement parks, malls and<br>consumer fantasylands, TV sports, and other<br>excursions into ideal worlds) is more real than<br>real, whereby the models, images, and codes of<br>the hyperreal come to control thought and<br>behavior. Yet determination itself is aleatory in a<br>non-linear world where it is impossible to chart<br>causal mechanisms in a situation in which<br>individuals are confronted with an overwhelming<br>flux of images, codes, and models, any of which<br>may shape an individual’s thought or behavior.</p><p>5. <em>The Hard Problem: The Science Behind the<br>Fiction.” </em>Roots of The Matrix. Directed by Josh<br>Oreck. Ultimate Edition DVD, Warner Bros., 2004.</p><p>6. Huineng, and Hsüan Hua. <em>The Sixth Patriarch’s<br>Dharma Jewel Platform Sutra: With the<br>Commentary of Tripitaka Master Hua.</em> Buddhist<br>Text Translation Society, 2002. At the monastery<br>the Master met the two monks arguing over the<br>topic of the wind and a flag. One said the wind<br>moved, the other said the flag moved, and he told<br>them, ‘You are both wrong. Neither the wind nor<br>the flag is moving. Your minds are moving. If your<br>minds were not moving, then neither the wind<br>nor the flag would move.</p><p>7. Wilson, Robert Anton. <em>The Acceleration of<br>Knowledge: The Jumping Jesus Phenomenon.</em><br>Sounds True, 1991. Audio cassette. Recorded 29<br>February 1986, in Denver, Colorado. Most<br>futurists don’t make predictions that outrageous,<br>because most futurists are trying to be<br>respectable. Those of you who heard me in<br>Boulder last night know that I have no desire to<br>become respectable. I am in a much more<br>dangerous business than that. I am trying to<br>provoke new thoughts.</p><p>8. Butler, Judith. <em>Gender Trouble: Feminism and the<br>Subversion of Identity.</em> Routledge, 1990. Gender is<br>not a noun, but neither is it a set of free floating<br>attributes, for we have seen that the substantive<br>effect of gender is performatively produced and<br>compelled by the regulatory practices of gender<br>coherence. Hence, within the inherited discourse<br>of the metaphysics of substance, gender proves to<br>be performative — that is, constituting the<br>identity is purported to be. In this sense, gender<br>is always a doing, though not a doing by a subject<br>who might be said to pre-exist the deed.</p><p>9. Gendler, Robert, and R. Jay<br>GaBany. <em>Breakthrough!: 100 Astronomical Images<br>that Changed the World.</em> Springer, 2015. The<br>unaided eye and brain are equipped to<br>distinguish only a small fraction of the full<br>spectrum of light produced by the universe. On a<br>logarithmic scale of frequency, visible light<br>represents only 2.3% of the entire<br>electromagnetic spectrum, and if the scale is<br>linear it is reduced to a mere 0.0035%.</p><p>10. Heflick, Nathan. “Why We (Often) Believe Fake<br>News.” Psychology Today, Sussex Publishers, 31<br>Mar. 2017, <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/">https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/</a><br>the-big-questions/201703/why-we-often-believe-<br>fake-news. Accessed 02 July 2017. One line of<br>work consistent with Naive Realism is the ‘bias<br>blind spot.’ This work has asked people, for<br>instance, how susceptible they are to a wide<br>range of psychological biases. So, a study might<br>explain hindsight bias (the tendency for people to<br>think they knew it all along when they didn’t),<br>and then ask people how much they themselves<br>are susceptible to this, and how much they think<br>others are. People will almost always say that<br>they are less susceptible. This work further<br>shows that even when people admit to using<br>biased sources, they still think they reach<br>unbiased, objective conclusions.</p><p>11. O’ Toole, Garson. “We Don’t See Things As They<br>Are, We See Them As We Are.” Quote Investigator,<br>9 Mar. 2014, quoteinvestigator.com/2014/03/09/as-we-are/.<br>When Nin wrote the adage she did not take credit<br>for the notion. Instead, she pointed to a major<br>religious text: Lillian was reminded of the<br>talmudic words: “We do not see things as they<br>are, we see them as we are.” In 2005 an article in<br>Newsweek magazine contained an epigraph that<br>matched the adage under investigation. The<br>statement was identified as an English<br>translation of a comment from a section within<br>the Talmud: “We do not see things as they are.<br>We see things as we are.” — Rabbi Shemuel ben<br>Nachmani, as quoted in the Talmudic tractate<br>Berakhot.</p><p>12. Blascovich and Bailenson. <em>Infinite Reality.</em></p><p>13. <em>Return to Source: Philosophy &amp; ‘The Matrix’.<br>Roots of The Matrix.</em> Directed by Josh Oreck.<br>Ultimate Edition DVD. Warner Bros., 2004.</p><p>14. <em>The Matrix</em>. “Philosopher’s Commentary”<br>Narrated by Cornel West and Ken Wilber,<br>directed by the Wachowskis, 1999. Ultimate<br>Edition DVD. Warner Bros., 2004.</p><p>15. “Jiddu Krishnamurti: Learning That Transforms<br>Consciousness.” YouTube, uploaded by<br>KrishnamurtiArchive, 7 Mar 2011,<br>https://youtu.be/y4jsj4ZukXs. “My<br>consciousness and yours, if we have been<br>brought up, programmed, conditioned to be<br>individual, then my consciousness is all this<br>activity of thought — fear is thought, we will go<br>into that presently. Pursuit of pleasure is the<br>movement of thought. And the suffering, the<br>anxiety, the uncertainty, the deep regrets,<br>wounds, the burden of centuries of sorrow, is<br>part of thought. Thought is responsible for all<br>this.” — 2nd Public Talk, Saanen, Switzerland, 14<br>July, 1981.</p><p>16. “50 Best Quotes, Photos: Chögyam Trungpa,<br>Buddhist meditation teacher.” Elephant Journal, 9<br>Oct. 2010, https://www.elephantjournal.com/2010/10/50-<br>best-quotes-photos-chogyam-trungpa-buddhist-<br>meditation-teacher/. Accessed 05 July 2017. In<br>the garden of gentle sanity, May you be<br>bombarded by coconuts of wakefulness.</p><p>17. <em>A Few Conclusions on Life.</em> Performance by<br>Terence McKenna. Audio. –<br>https://archive.org/details/PsychedelicSalon136<br>-mckennalessonsaboutlife</p><p>18. “The Psychedelic Influence on Philosophy.”<br>YouTube, uploaded by Ontologistics, 19 Mar.<br>2016, https://youtu.be/X2eY4n37FC0. Lecture<br>given at the University of Exeter (10 March<br>2016). A description of which Western<br>philosophers have been influenced by<br>psychoactive substances; and suggestions<br>towards a future philosophy of psychedelics.</p><p>19. Sjöstedt-H, Peter. “The Hidden Psychedelic<br>History of Philosophy: Plato, Nietzsche, and 11<br>Other Philosophers Who Used Mind-Altering<br>Drugs.” High Existence, 27 Sept. 2016,<br>highexistence.com/hidden-psychedelic-<br>influence-philosophy-plato-nietzsche-<br>psychonauts-thoughts/. Accessed 03 July<br>2017. Philosophy itself often arrives as a mind-<br>altering experience, a new mode of perception<br>unto our cosmos, at times so radical as to be<br>hazardous. Thus can philosophy be seen as a<br>psychoactive substance — yet the place of<br>psychoactive substances in philosophy is not<br>apparent. In this mildly chronological overview<br>we shall shed light upon the history of the<br>notable Western philosophers who took<br>psychedelic chemicals and how this may have<br>influenced their thought — how psychedelics<br>influenced philosophy.</p><p>20. Grim, Ryan. “Read the Never-Before-Published<br>Letter From LSD-Inventor Albert Hofmann to<br>Apple CEO Steve Jobs.” The Huffington Post, 08<br>July 2009, www.huffingtonpost.com/ryan-<br>grim/read-the-never-before-pub_b_227887.html.<br>Accessed 05 July 2017. Psychedelic drugs,<br>Markoff argues, pushed the computer and<br>Internet revolutions forward by showing folks<br>that reality can be profoundly altered through<br>unconventional, highly intuitive thinking.<br>Douglas Engelbart is one example of a<br>psychonaut who did just that: he helped invent<br>the mouse. Apple’s Jobs has said that Microsoft’s<br>Bill Gates, would “be a broader guy if he had<br>dropped acid once.” In a 1994 interview with<br>Playboy, however, Gates coyly didn’t deny having<br>dosed as a young man. Thinking differently — or<br>learning to Think Different, as a Jobs slogan has<br>it — is a hallmark of the acid experience.</p><p>21. <em>D’autres Mondes.</em> Directed by Jan Kounen, A.J.O.Z.<br>Films, Tawak Pictures, 2004. “What if I had not<br>taken LSD ever; would I have still invented PCR? I<br>don’t know. I doubt it. I seriously doubt it.”<br>Nobel Laureate Dr. Kary Mullis.</p><p>22. Davidson, Keay. “Carl Sagan and Pot.” High Times,<br>May 2016, hightimes.com/news/carl-sagan-<br>and-pot/. Accessed 05 July 2017. Astronomer<br>Carl Sagan had been a regular marijuana user<br>from the early 1960s on. He believes the drug<br>enhanced his creativity and insights. His closest<br>friend of three decades, Harvard psychiatry<br>professor Dr. Lester Grinspoon, a leading<br>advocate of the decriminalization of marijuana,<br>recalls an incident in the 1980s when one of his<br>California admirers mailed him, unsolicited, some<br>unusually high-quality pot. Grinspoon shared the<br>joints with Sagan and his wife, Annie. Afterwards,<br>Grinspoon recalls, Sagan asked if he could have<br>the last joint because he had so much work to do<br>the next day and that it would really help.</p><p>23. Riley, Christopher. “The Dolphin who Loved me:<br>The NASA-funded Project that Went Wrong.” The<br>Guardian, 08 June 2014,<br>https://www.theguardian.com/environment/20<br>14/jun/08/the-dolphin-who-loved-me. Accessed<br>05 July 2017. For the actor Jeff Bridges, who was<br>introduced to Lilly by his father Lloyd, Lilly’s self-<br>experimentation with LSD was just part of who<br>he was. “John Lilly was above all an explorer of<br>the brain and the mind, and all those drugs that<br>expand our consciousness,” reflects Bridges.<br>“There weren’t too many people with his<br>expertise and his scientific background doing<br>that kind of work.”</p><p>24. McKenna. <em>Taxonomy</em>.</p><p>25. <em>The Matrix</em>. Directed by the Wachowskis. Warner<br>Bros., 1999.</p><p>26. McKenna. <em>Taxonomy</em>.</p><p>27. McKenna. <em>Taxonomy</em>.</p><p>28. Wilson, Robert Anton. Cosmic <em>Trigger II: Down to<br>Earth</em>. New Falcon Publications, 1991. That year<br>[1900] Max Planck published his first paper on<br>quantum mechanics, beginning the process by<br>which science in this century would gradually<br>abandon Aristotelian logic and evolve in a non-<br>Aristotelian, almost Buddhist direction. We were<br>learning that the “one” “objective” Aristotelian<br>“real world” previously posited by all Western<br>thought existed only as a concept in our linguistic<br>structures: that the only worlds we knew were<br>plural and created by our senses and scientific<br>instruments, all of them uncertain to some<br>degree and all of them given structure by the<br>inbuilt hardware and software of our senses and<br>instruments.</p><p>29. McKenna. <em>Taxonomy</em>.</p><p>30. <em>The World and Its Double.</em> Performance by<br>Terence McKenna, Sound Photosynthesis, 1993.<br>Videocassette. [T]he basic message of<br>materialism is that the world is what it appears<br>to be: a thing composed of matter and pretty<br>much confined to its surface. The world is what it<br>appears to be. Now, this, on the face of it, is a<br>tremendously naïve position, because what it<br>says is the animal body that you inhabit, the eyes<br>you look through, the fingers you feel through,<br>are somehow the ultimate instruments of<br>metaphysical conjecture, which is highly<br>improbable. It seems to me, metaphysical<br>conjecture begins with the logic of the situation,<br>and then proceeds in whatever direction that<br>logic will carry you. Well, if logic is true to<br>experience then we have to make room in any <br>theory for invisible connectedness between<br>people; anticipation of a future that has not yet<br>occurred; shared dreaming; all kinds of<br>possibilities that materialism has denied. For<br>approximately 500 years, the great era of the<br>triumph of modern science, materialism has had<br>the field all to itself; and its argument for its<br>preeminence was the beautiful toys that it could<br>create. Aircraft, railroads, global economies,<br>television, spacecraft. But that isn’t — that is a<br>fool’s argument for truth! I mean, that’s after all<br>how a medicine show operates, you know? The<br>juggler is so good, the medicine must be even<br>better!</p><p>31. Booth, Mark. <em>The Secret History of the World.</em><br>Overlook Press, 2010. The truth is that we must<br>use our imagination. When we travel any<br>distance in either direction, when we leave the<br>confines of this little island of matter, we cannot<br>but enter the realms of imagination. Of course<br>materialists tend to distrust the imagination,<br>associating it with fantasy and illusion. But the<br>secret societies hold an especially exalted view of<br>the imagination. Each individual mind is a<br>protrusion into the material world of one vast<br>cosmic mind, and we must use the imagination to<br>reach back into it and to engage with it. It was<br>using the imagination in this way that made<br>Leonardo, Shakespeare and Mozart god-like.<br>Imagination is the key.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=64baf91894ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Uncanny of Point Pleasant: Mothman, Madness, and Mourning]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/the-uncanny-of-point-pleasant-mothman-madness-and-mourning-3d4498c390e2?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3d4498c390e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[freud]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paranormal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[academic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Apr 2023 02:27:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-28T02:27:35.505Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EC8ajVThqY7LBYo_Tiqz3w.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://www.gofundme.com/f/uncanny-mothman-talk">I am raising funds </a>to attend the academic conference <strong>Haunted Landscapes: Nature, Super-Nature and Global Environments</strong> at Falmouth University in the UK this July. I will be speaking on Mark Pellington’s <em>The Mothman Prophecies — </em>one of the most underrated and misunderstood horror films of the last 20 years.</p><p>My abstract, “The Uncanny of Point Plesant: Mothman, Madness, and Mourning” has been accepted!</p><p>Y’all helped me get to Australia to speak at the <strong>Feasting on Hannibal Conference</strong> in 2016. Attending that talk changed the course of my life.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FOzOuOf1YKZw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DOzOuOf1YKZw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FOzOuOf1YKZw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/256729bc3d32ce70b47462fe464baac7/href">https://medium.com/media/256729bc3d32ce70b47462fe464baac7/href</a></iframe><p>Now we’re doing it again with <em>The Mothman Prophecies</em>! We are using Freud once again to clear the way.</p><p><strong>The Uncanny of Point Pleasant: Mothman, Madness, and Mourning</strong></p><p><strong>ABSTRACT</strong></p><ul><li><em>The Mothman Prophecies </em>(2002) is a psychological horror film loosely based on John Keel’s 1975 titular Fortean book, which documents paranormal phenomena that besieged the small town of Point Pleasant, West Virginia between 1966–67. While met with near-universal criticism due to its perceived narrative ambiguity and confusion over its ultimate meaning, the film takes on a sharp focus when read psychoanalytically. This presentation will clarify <em>Mothman’s</em> famously murky narrative while underscoring its psychoanalytic value as a text worthy of further examination. Two of Freud’s foundational essays, namely “The Uncanny” (1919) and “Mourning and Melancholia” (1917), will be used as keys to unlock the film. While horror literature has been a benchmark for psychoanalytic interpretation beginning with Hoffmann’s “Der Sandmann” (1817), <em>Mothman </em>has remained a neglected work that holds immense interpretative usefulness for analytic consideration. The film includes unique representations of eeriness and the uncanny; hauntings from the loss of past love-objects, but also retrocausal hauntings that spring from the inevitable loss of future ones; a shapeshifting, disaster-forecasting antagonist that functions as an entire town’s “emissary of the id” (Horsely 2009); doppelgangers, dreams, and death omens. In <em>Mothman</em>, Point Pleasant is indeed haunted, but the cause is not a ghost, curse, or demon. Rather, the psyche and its unconscious foreknowledge of death and disaster is itself the haunter. While the film’s professorial Dr. Alexander Leek (Alan Bates) remarks, “We’re not allowed to know,” the riddle of <em>The Mothman Prophecies </em>unfurls when we <em>know</em> we are not allowed to know.</li></ul><p><strong>I</strong> <strong>ADORE </strong>Pellington’s little treasure of a film. The way it captures eerieness is wholly unique. I haven’t seen anything like it in a movie before or since. I am hoping that, in some small way, this talk helps bring more attention to this neglected masterwork.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/962/0*atZ8nuzbQjvjYwbM.jpeg" /></figure><p>Furthermore, there are little-to-no psychoanalytic interpretations of the film, which is shocking because it is filled with Freudian themes. I hope that this talk will also encourage more analysts to see the film, as it’s an amazing resource when it comes to the uncanny, the unconscious, the id, and the darker material that Freud explored.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k83gv-Yd1Wf1_60z2zlVPg.png" /></figure><p>In a sense, the goal of this talk is to open up that possibility, because my presentation does not close the book on <em>Mothman</em>. Rather, it opens it.</p><p>Remote presentations are not an option for this conference.</p><p>Here’s a little bit about me —</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/463/0*C0z_r1Dw7QbVCJKc" /></figure><p>I am an independent researcher, author, artist, and lecturer. “Independent” means I do all of the above entirely by myself, outside of university or institutional support. I enjoy doing it this way because it lets me devote myself to my passions — albeit, under my own steam. That means between shifts while working in restaurants.</p><p>(Here’s a YouTube version of a talk a gave at the CG Jung Center on Trickster Archetypes)</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F3uWcD-Bxm4k%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D3uWcD-Bxm4k&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F3uWcD-Bxm4k%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9573f1f1fd6f2c5cc52ce01f8cb163dd/href">https://medium.com/media/9573f1f1fd6f2c5cc52ce01f8cb163dd/href</a></iframe><p>Events like these are a way of forwarding my career as a writer, and as expensive as they can get, they are one of the ways I get myself and my work out there in the world.</p><p>One of the things I have become devoted to is genre fiction, particularly horror and sci-fi. I don’t just love to watch it — I love to explore and study it critically like the hopeless nerd I am.</p><p><strong>GIFTS FOR HELPING ME!</strong></p><p>Everyone who donates will receive a free digital copy of my critically acclaimed book <em>3 Essays on Virtual Reality: Overlords, Civilization, and Escape!</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/581/0*lSJxMBIYHdyprOQQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Donate $100 or more and I will also send you an original sketch of the Mothman drawn by me in the style of the drawings in the film!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/574/0*szg8FjsYqNuKcA9e.jpeg" /></figure><p>I will also be uploading a YouTube version of the talk online!</p><p>So, if you’d like to save my family from my endless monologues on why <em>Mothman</em> is such a great film, and help me my reading out there to a larger audience that will appreciate my obsession with delicious bits of psychological minutiae —<a href="https://www.gofundme.com/f/uncanny-mothman-talk"> <strong>donate today!</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3d4498c390e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Infinity Pool and the Infinite Sadness]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/infinity-pool-and-the-infinite-sadness-6cfcc0ed95da?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6cfcc0ed95da</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[infinity-pool]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cronenberg]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 18 Feb 2023 17:08:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-03T03:51:57.774Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/985/1*W2v7m9ijSHmaij9nTrn5Dw.png" /></figure><p>Brandon Cronenberg is back with his third picture <em>Infinity Pool</em>, and if it tells us anything it’s that just because a film is loaded with extreme violence, orgiastic sex, hallucinogenic drugs, human degradation, deformity and mayhem it doesn’t magically transform what’s presented on screen into something worth watching.</p><p>The film stars Alexander Skarsgård as James Foster, a struggling novelist visiting an exclusive resort, in effort to find some kind of inspiration to overcome his writer’s block. He’s joined by his exasperated wife Em, played by Cleopatra Coleman. Things take a turn for the weird when they come upon another couple, Gabi and Alban Bauer, played by Mia Goth and Jalil Lespert. Goth plays an actress who loves James’s first novel, but things are, of course, not at all as they seem. <em>Infinity Pool</em>’s performances are very good, but it’s not nearly enough to hold up the story, which is meandering, fat, unrefined, and worst of all dull.</p><p>Just over halfway through the film, I checked to see how much was left of it, looking forward to its ultimately unsatisfying climax — which is exactly what I got.</p><p>The only thing of note that’s interesting in the film is when you compare it to Brandon Cronenberg’s previous film <em>Possessor</em>. In that light, we see clearly the themes that BC is attracted to: doubles or imposters, which might have something to do with being the son of the iconic filmmaker David Cronenberg.</p><p>(I wouldn’t wanna be the son of a world renowned artist for the same reason why I wouldn’t want to be Jakob Dylan.)</p><p>That’s what this movie is really about. “Daddy issues,” writer’s block, emasculation, imposters, and a father’s death are all brought up in the film; but they are merely brought up. They aren’t meaningfully explored. Nothing really compelling happens. As a line from the film goes, <em>Infinity Pool</em>, “has nothing to say and lacks the words to say it.”</p><p>The only thing of note in this film that is worth considering is exactly this: a new filmmaker in the shadow of his father’s work, and it’s morbidly interesting if you read it like that.</p><p>The major problem of BC’s films lies in his craft as a writer. The camerawork and direction are fine to great in his films; but he has yet to get me to care about his characters, nor the stakes involved in his stories. In the case of <em>Infinity Pool</em> there seems to be no stakes at all.</p><p>The story is bloated; it’s about witnessing your own execution, male emasculation, and the leisure class behaving badly — the leisure class angle we’ve also seen done better in <em>Triangle of Sadness</em>. If it focused on one of these things, it may have been good. But that would require BC to write richer, more compelling characters, which he simply doesn’t know how to do yet.</p><p>If you are going to make a film about emasculation, you are covering ground that other films have already done really well. <em>Back to the Future, About Schmidt, The Apartment, Cape Fear, </em>and <em>Fight Club</em> all wrestle with it. It’s a trope, and it’s kind of boring if you don’t sincerely work on it as a major theme. In <em>Infinity Pool</em> the supposedly emasculated James (we don’t see much of this claim that he is, nor does he portray the character as such) will do anything and everything to prove to his new lust object (Goth) that he truly is a man. (See <em>The Shape of Things</em> for a truly pointed example of this kind of “I’ll do anything” behavior.) The tedium here is that anyone secure in themselves knows that’s no way to prove your salt, male or otherwise. It’s weak sauce that we’ve tasted before, particularly in horror films, and worse, it’s lazy, easy writing.</p><p>The film suffers from the same thing movies like <em>Neon Demon</em> suffer from, and that’s style over substance. What we are left with are movies that are at their best conceptually interesting, and at their worst vacuous.</p><p>That’s the word I would use to describe <em>Infinity Pool</em>: vacuous. It’s like seeing glittery air on a screen, but with nothing to shape it, or make it meaningful. The addition of graphic violence, two sequences with prolonged strobe lighting/editing, glossy lighting, and beautiful nude bodies doesn’t bring anything extra to the table. It’s more like covering up an unprepared meal with getting your guests drink on several conflicting wines instead. It feels like cotton filler, rather than beams that hold up or advance a compelling story.</p><p>I reminded of the character Anthony Blanche in <em>Brideshead Revisited </em>here:</p><blockquote>But when dear Sebastian speaks it is like a little sphere of soapsuds drifting off the end of an old clay pipe, anywhere, full of rainbow light for a second and then — phut! — vanished, with nothing left at all, nothing.”</blockquote><p><em>Infinity Pool </em>is a very bad movie; but, that being said, I can easily see myself within the next 12–36 hours changing my mind and admitting that it’s actually a terrible movie.</p><p>It is normal to follow in your parents’ or a mentor’s footsteps, but eventually, you have to brach off and discover your own voice.</p><p>Eventually, Brandon Cronenberg will likely make a great movie. He casts well, directs well, and he isn’t afraid of the bizarre. However, until he lands it as a writer, or finds a great screenplay, he will continue to make pretty-looking, vacuous, gory yawns.</p><p>D</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6cfcc0ed95da" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do we still need film critics?]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/do-we-still-need-film-critics-89b5946175b1?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89b5946175b1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[streaming]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Feb 2023 18:30:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-04-07T13:14:46.988Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*CkVcl2ua8v0o9md5zV9MzA.jpeg" /><figcaption>“I’ve wasted my life!”</figcaption></figure><p>Today, everyone is a critic and virtually everyone writes reviews. I am all for democratization, but that doesn’t at all mean that the popular opinion will be a “good” opinion. All you have to do is see who gets elected to the presidency every four years to start to have doubts slide across the surface of your mind. But we are not here to talk politics or the electoral process. We are here to talk about film.</p><p>Case in point: the Internet Movie Database. Before Rotten Tomatoes, IMDb was the only widely used resource to find what the man-on-the-street thought about a picture. According to this global repository of film opinion, the #3 greatest film in the canon of cinema is Christopher Nolan’s <em>The Dark Knight</em>. Forget it filmmakers and movie-goers, <em>The Dark Knight</em> is where you pack your bags and disembark. Movies simply don’t get much better than watching Batman fall from a skyscraper, fail to deploy his grappling gun, smash onto a car with lass in arm and neither suffer any physical injury. The rescued damsel, Rachel Dawes (Maggie Gyllenhaal), doesn’t have the air blown out of her lungs or a concussion, but instead has the pithy wherewithal to remark, “Let’s not do that again.” This is it, folks. This is the apex of the craft and the story of our lives. Number 3, best film ever made.</p><p>My point should be clear already: just because everyone has an opinion and a platform to share it on, doesn’t mean it’s good. Or even useful. Enter the “true” critic; the person that, through fire, fury, and mojo of circumstance, seems (<em>seems!</em>) to know what the hell they are talking about.</p><p>Now, I think <em>The Dark Knight</em> is fine. It’s not great. It wouldn’t be in my top 5 films list. It wouldn’t even be in my top 100 list. Maybe it would find a place in my top 500 films, if I ran out of movies I can recall seeing.</p><p>What makes it so well liked on IMDb? Heath Ledger carries the film for forty minutes in a deservedly praised performance. It is one for the cinema history books, no doubt. He displays that rarest magic we yearn for in a performance: the actor transforming entirely into their character. But except for the sound design and booming musical score, Ledger is the only element of notable caliber in the film. The other performances lean towards wooden. Even Christian Bale admitted it. Saying, “I feel a little bit dull by comparison.” But that’s not Bale’s fault — everyone is dull beside that performance.</p><p>What else? The script is forced and the plot is termite-infested. The less you think about what you are actually seeing on the screen, the more enjoyable it is. Many movies suffer from this ailment, the: <em>How did this happen? Whatever, take it and move on. The Dark Knight </em>doesn’t tell us anything deep or nuanced about the human condition. But it doesn’t have to. No character feels like they truly love each other, even though love is a theme in the picture. And we’re rooting for the villain throughout, because, not so deep down, we know Ledger is the only thing keeping us somewhat invested in this nearly three-hour spectacle. We walk away wowed, but no one walks away enriched.</p><p>I remember the first time I saw the film in theaters with my brother and mother. We were entranced by Ledger. He was unpredictable and otherworldly. Completely captivated, we couldn’t get enough of him, and we couldn’t believe what he was doing on screen. But even during the complete pleasure of absorbing Ledger’s show-stealing scene, after show-stealing scene, we all saw cracks in the film the size of canyons: <em>A bomb hidden in a guy’s stomach? How did that help Joker escape without blowing himself to smithereens? The people of Gotham will always stand up for what’s right? Always? I thought they were famously downtrodden, jaded, and cynical. Two-Face looks like he really shouldn’t be able to get around like that. Batman landed on a car? A car!?</em></p><p>Just because a film has some great stuff in it, doesn’t mean it’s a great movie. A great movie is when almost everything seems to magically come together. <em>The Dark Knight</em> simply isn’t an example of that. <em>Alien </em>is an example of that. <em>The Mothman Prophecies</em> is one of my favorites. It captures a feeling of eeriness that I haven’t seen in any other film before. But it is far from a great movie.</p><p>So what’s the value of a true critic? Well, being a critic of every single medium is difficult. A music or art history critic is going to have other things to say than those of us who spend most of our time watching film and television. That being said, film critics are a wilder breed. We need to have a roving understanding of the arts. That’s because our medium of fascination is a synthesis of photography, music, theater, writing, design, and other production arts. Being a film critic, you end up having to know a little about a lot. And it’s not an easy game because you have to watch long productions that sometimes fall flat, or never learn to stand up at all. Then the urge to warn others of danger becomes overwhelming. Similarly, when a film is great there is an equal need to shout it to anyone who will listen, because it’s closer to the magic of what this art form is truly capable of.</p><p>It was probably Ebert who said it best:</p><blockquote>“I believe a good critic is a teacher. He doesn’t have the answers, but he can be an example of the process of finding your own answers. He can notice things, explain them, place them in any number of contexts, ponder why some ‘work’ and others never could. He can urge you toward older movies to expand your context for newer ones. He can examine how movies touch upon individual lives, and can be healing, or damaging. He can defend them, and regard them as important in the face of those who are ‘just looking for a good time.’ He can argue that you will have a better time at a better movie. We are all allotted an unknown but finite number of hours of consciousness. Maybe a critic can help you spend them more meaningfully.”</blockquote><p>There’s plenty of ink that’s been spilled on the theory and history of criticism, but that’s about as good a defense for the purpose of a film critic as one is likely going to get. But maybe Rachel Dawes was on to something too in <em>The Dark Knight </em>when she turned to Batman after they both crash-landed on a car and said, “Let’s not do that again.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89b5946175b1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Suburban Sasquatch’ and The Joy of Disaster Darlings]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/suburban-sasquatch-and-disaster-darlings-45375b6575d3?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/45375b6575d3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[independent-film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[funny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Nov 2022 17:54:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-31T01:04:03.012Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/973/1*4dh5P7rwxhOCHGp1PGHDWA.png" /></figure><p>Picture this:</p><p>You are walking in a spottily wooded area just within sight of a neighbor’s backyard porch. It is a bright, completely unthreatening day when you hear a bizarre sound like a man pantomiming what a monster’s growl should sound like, but it’s recorded too close to a cheap microphone. The odd sound loops, cutting in on itself as if it was mixed on a single audio reel. You look and see not a horrible beast, but what is clearly a man in a homemade bigfoot costume — one that sports large paper mache breasts with tea dish-sized collapsed areolas. It approaches, then fades out like an effect that a middle school student discovered on their laptop’s built-in video editing software. It reappears before you and effortlessly tears out your own arm from your shirt sleeve — which turns out to be a Halloween store prop. Digital blood sprays unnaturally — not from where the wound should be, but from somewhere around your chest area. The man in the monster costume then pretends to beat you with the prop arm as you act as dead as you can for the excited director just off camera.</p><p>This is the glory that is Dave Wascavage’s 2004 cult hit <em>Suburban Sasquatch.</em></p><p>It is a movie complete with abrupt edits that inspire jags of unplanned humor, an unmiked cast of nonactors, day-for-night shooting, a Latina as a Native American huntress, and CG that is as painfully fake as the monster costume itself. These are just a few of its absolute delights. The film has everything it takes to be a strong addition to that rare, exalted annal of cinematic history where a film magically bends backwards onto itself like an ouroboros and becomes so bad it’s good.</p><p>The story follows a supernatural bigfoot as it dismembers suburbanite after suburbanite due to humanity’s encroachment into nature. A cub reporter Rick Harlan, played by Bill Usher (who has one of the best IMDB profile pics I’ve ever seen) is on the beat, trying to uncover the mystery of these mutilations in aim of writing a Pulitzer Prize winning story, but the chief of the local police department (also wearing a homemade costume) stops him at every turn. Eventually he teams up with Talia (Sue Lynn Sanchez) who has been charged by her grandfather (we assume) to kill the beast with a magical bow that fires slow-moving CG arrows. She also occasionally hurls CG battle axes. <br> <br> But it is not the story that matters here. It is the execution that makes it a beloved monstrosity. The film<em> </em>reminds us that there are good films, bad films, and then there are disaster darlings.</p><p>A disaster darling is separated by other kinds of otherwise great bad movies like <em>Brain Damage </em>or <em>Nightmare on Elm Street 2 </em>in that involves four key features: (1) Widespread technical, narrative, and/or acting incompetency. (2) Unintentional hilarity. (3) Absolute sincerity. (4) An utterly joyful viewing experience.</p><p>In the nineties and early aughts the curators of disaster darlings were the wit-snark masters of the ironically titled Best Brains Inc. and their masterpiece of television <em>Mystery Science Theater 3000</em>. Through their keen eye for the unskilled, hundreds of disaster darlings came into public consciousness. <em>Manos: The Hands of Fate, Danger Death Ray, Samson Versus the Vampire Women,</em> and <em>Mitchell</em> would likely never be seen by more than a relatively few people if it wasn’t for them. These dustbin films are now icons of underground entertainment.</p><p>Following in <em>MST3k’s</em> tradition, the new connoisseurs of cinematic pan gristle can be found at <em>Red Letter Media</em> and their staple program <em>The Best of the Worst</em>, where <em>Suburban Sasquatch</em> found wide attention and appreciation. As Jay Bauman described it, “It’s so bad, so stupid, and so charming.” Even <em>Rifftrax, </em>hosted by Mike Nelson, Kevin Murphy, and Bill Corbett from <em>MST3k</em> gave <em>Suburban Sasquatch </em>a much deserved once over.</p><p>Mike Stoklasa of <em>Red Letter Media</em> explains, “The magical thing about it and the very, very important thing that makes <em>Suburban Sasquatch</em> work is that it’s a movie that they took seriously making. It comes off like a movie you’d intentionally make a bad movie” [sic].</p><p>That’s the key referent for when it comes to whether or not a film qualifies as a disaster darling: the filmmakers must take their project absolutely seriously. This is the takeaway of films like <em>The Room </em>and <em>Birdemic, </em>or the movies of Neil Breen, Ed Wood, and A.J. Cross. To make a picture like this the filmmakers nor the actors can not be “in on” just how awful the film they are making is.</p><p>A self-shot, self-conducted 2003 interview <em>Making of Suburban Sasquatch</em> with the director Dave Wascavage displays his total conviction that what he’s produced is a serious picture, “I’d like this to have a little bit of a statement about life and humanity pressing onward into nature.” Wascavage goes on to say that his goal was to make a “commercial oriented product.” Nearly twenty years since its original release, it has been successful in that regard (it was just rereleased as a blu ray from Visual Vengeance.) Although not at all successful in the way he originally intended.</p><p>Wascavage, in an interview recorded this year, reflects on this saying, “The intention was never to create a cult movie and get it out there. It was a fully formed big concept.”</p><p>Like Tommy Wissaeu and James Nguyen, Wascavage has embraced <em>Suburban Sasquatch’s</em> disaster darling status, citing Red Letter Media for its spike in popularity and stating in an interview, “It was all intended to be this operatic large story.” <em>Sasquatch </em>is about as far from operatic or large as a movie can get. It’s as small as a tin can and as operatic as various beeps a car makes when you turn the engine on. “If it ends up being somewhat humorous then that’s okay!”</p><p>It is that kind of level-headedness that makes Wascavage a far more welcome filmmaker than more assured to the point of unsettling directors of disaster darlings like Neil Breen (although, lovers of these kinds of movies should certainly take a look at Breen’s work. Breen may be the modern master of this subgenre.)</p><p>This makes a disaster darling different from more self-conscious, intentional camp disasters like <em>Troll 2,</em> <em>Demons at the Door, </em>or <em>Sharknado. </em>They cannot be aped. A filmmaker is more hard pressed to make a disaster darling than they are to make a good or decent movie. <br> <br> <em>Suburban Sasquatch </em>is joyful, and I do mean it. <em>Suburban Sasquatch </em>is a laugh a minute. The computer generated imagery in <em>Suburban Sasquatch</em> are, like the rest of the film, endlessly hysterical. Wascavage has discussed in his <em>Making of </em>documentary that he went to great efforts to make the CG trees and thunderbirds appear more lifelike, when they look stiff, and comically unnatural. “When I did <em>Fungicide</em> there were billions of mistakes. And I would think to move to the next level and do <em>Sasquatch,</em> I have to move that down to just millions of mistakes.”</p><p><em>Suburban Sasquatch </em>has nothing but mistakes from the first frame to the last — but that’s what makes it a gut-bustingly wonderful time. It is a collection of errors. Little makes sense, but it doesn’t have to and you never expect it will.</p><p><em>Suburban Sasquatch </em>is a joyride — not like a rollercoaster — but like a car that’s blown a tire as it speeds through the aisles of a department store that caters exclusively to deaf clowns in training.</p><p>Wascavage reminds us that the only thing better than a good movie is a really fun bad movie. <br> <br> To the curious, I suggest eschewing any clips of Wascavage’s disaster darling masterpiece and see it for yourself at Nitehawk on November 17th.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=45375b6575d3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Oliver Stone’s ‘Nixon’ is still a masterclass in political drama]]></title>
            <link>https://eliottedge.medium.com/oliver-stones-nixon-is-still-a-masterclass-in-political-drama-291038c1d9?source=rss-30cca741dca7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/291038c1d9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oliver-stone]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nixon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eliott Edge]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Oct 2022 00:09:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-17T00:09:27.517Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJWRVyaKnGcA&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJWRVyaKnGcA&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJWRVyaKnGcA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e4a080470afd91b869daaf90eb220b02/href">https://medium.com/media/e4a080470afd91b869daaf90eb220b02/href</a></iframe><p>Every two years or so I watch Oliver Stone’s 1995 political masterpiece <em>Nixon</em>. Stone is one of the few directors who’s director’s cuts are arguably better than his theatrical releases — which are also damn good. The DC of <em>Natural Born Killers</em> includes an extended sequence of the prison riot as well as other scenes of impossible violence, and the DC of <em>JFK</em> features about 20 minutes more of the endlessly juicy conspiratorial intrigue. Stone’s unduly neglected <em>Nixon</em> is another fantastic film and also sports a fantastic director’s cut.</p><p>To really get an idea of the strength of this movie, I have to turn to the comments of Rodger Ebert:</p><blockquote>“Anthony Hopkins is very powerful in the role and he wisely doesn’t try to do a Nixon imitation. He suggests Nixon rather than impersonating him and the result is powerful, almost Shakespearian. A performance of a man who tastes both glory and the ashes of his own self defeat. This is one of the best films of the year.”</blockquote><p>Hopkins in the role and Stone’s direction do together alchemize a kind of modern Shakespeare for me. It is tragic, the characters are larger than life, yet also connect with emotions and thoughts common to all humanity. I can’t help but feel a kinship here with <em>Citizen Kane</em>. <em>Nixon</em>, like <em>Kane</em>, is about as good as a political drama can get.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ugM6_IyAqo1UOXv38g0T4A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Stone originally tapped Hopkins for the role, but Hopkins hesitated. He feared that he, a Welshman, would be incapable of portraying the infamous rural California republican. Stone later baited Hopkins, telling him, that he was thinking of offering the role to Gary Oldman, which caused Hopkins to do a 180 turn and snatch up the part. We’re blessed that he did.</p><p><em>Nixon</em> is far more accomplished, far more nuanced, far more human, and far more deep than any political drama that Aaron Sorkin, the popular political dramatist of our time, has ever produced. In fact, Stone’s one film <em>Nixon</em> makes the body of Sorkin’s work (pick any of them; save for maybe <em>The Social Network</em>) look like a collapsable cardboard box in competition against Michelangelo’s Pietà.</p><p>The tragedy here is that more people have been exposed to Sorkin’s pedestrian, manichaean, finger-waving, spoon-feeding diatribes onscreen than this single outstanding film.</p><p>Hopkins offers probably the best onscreen portrayal of the disgraced 37th president and likely the best that ever will be portrayed. Stone’s <em>Nixon</em> does not offer an evil, venomous man, but instead a complicated, deep, secretive, brooding individual who Hunter S. Thompson eulogized: “He was the real thing — a political monster straight out of Grendel.” Nixon, the man, was so good at politics that it made him at times almost inhuman. But underneath all that strategy, secrecy, and policy was a pained and flawed living human being. Stone and Hopkins capture this exquisitely.</p><p>If you haven’t seen Stone’s <em>Nixon</em>, and you’re a fan of political drama, do yourself a favor and watch the masterclass in the genre. If you want to really treat yourself (and it is the season for gorging on treats), watch it alongside the 1992 director’s cut of Spike Lee’s <em>Malcolm X</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=291038c1d9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>