<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Elizabeth Syben King on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Elizabeth Syben King on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@elizabethonline?source=rss-4b4789c27661------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:58:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@elizabethonline/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Learning to Teach Online: Understanding & Optimizing an Online Learning Experience]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@elizabethonline/learning-to-teach-online-understanding-optimizing-an-online-learning-experience-e26cbd0fa460?source=rss-4b4789c27661------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e26cbd0fa460</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[online-teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remote-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tutoring]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Elizabeth Syben King]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Mar 2020 21:09:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-14T21:09:43.612Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>I’ve been teaching since ’03 and exclusively online for about a decade. Here’s what I wish I’d understood while I made the switch myself.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*lMwxsOPk3k0dyuUs-DR7sA.jpeg" /></figure><p>As many schools and colleges are moving to online learning models in light of COVID-19, I’ve been bombarded with questions about teaching online — both by school teachers and by private tutors and teachers looking for ways to move their studios to virtual environments.</p><p>I remember the sincere trepidation I felt when travel demands meant I had to switch to teaching online, and I thought I’d share what I wish I’d understood while I made the switch myself.</p><p>What follows <em>is not intended to be an exhaustive list</em> of things to consider if you’re new to teaching remotely or a deep dive into developing curricula specifically for online teaching. I’d also like to preemptively say that while I have quite a bit of experience teaching special needs populations, this article is not intended to serve as a deep dive into teaching students online with special needs, unusual circumstances, or profound learning differences.</p><h3>Know What You’re Up Against</h3><p><strong>As in all learning contexts, proactively managing the delicate interplay between student motivation and teacher engagement is the biggest dictator of success in online education.</strong></p><p>Children are not known for self-regulation.</p><p>Today’s students have an average attention span of something like eight seconds and they aren’t skilled at staying focused without your external reminders. You know this from teaching them live in a classroom or studio; you’ll need to use your experience to consider the predictable problems with engagement and comprehension and manage them <em>even though they may not be happening right in front of you.</em></p><p>That being said, students live most of their lives digitally. An average student will likely experience much less stress at transitioning to a virtual learning environment than their GenX teachers might.</p><p>You’ll get through this. Here’s how:</p><h3>Plan To Actively Manage and Call for Attention</h3><p><strong>Offer specific instruction on how to quiet distractions before you begin actually teaching anything else.</strong></p><p>Tell students to modify their device and computer settings to turn off banner/screen alerts for their iMessages, Instagram, etc.</p><p>They’ll need to turn off the vibrate mode for incoming texts, too, as many phones will vibrate during a FaceTime or Skype call.</p><p>Many students stream things from YouTube on mute on their laptops while you’re teaching, just the same as if they’d muted the TV in the background to, say, watch the game. Acknowledge this and encourage them to turn other streaming players off.</p><p><strong>Verbally note ahead of the lesson what supplies students need to have on hand in order to be ready to take notes or participate effectively.</strong></p><p>Most students will start a FaceTime call or press play on their computer or device to learn online otherwise empty-handed. When you say “jot that down” or “put that in your calculator,” they will either walk away or need to interrupt the stream of ideas and tell you to hang on if you haven’t warned them ahead of time to be prepared.</p><p>Do they have their notes from last time? Pencils? Calculator? Google doc for note-taking already open? Get them set up ahead of time.</p><p><strong>Create a new (and perhaps ridiculous) code words for key points.</strong></p><p>In my practice we call these “jelly beans.” Students are accustomed to tuning out teachers in school, and it’s that much easier to do when they’re online. My students know that when I say, “This one is a jelly bean,” I mean to recapture their attention and emphasize that this particular idea is not to be missed. Because the term <em>jelly bean</em> is contextually absurd, students hear it outside the jargon of whatever topic we’re exploring and realize that we’re in a point of emphasis.</p><p><strong>If you want to excel at this, you’re going to have to be on camera.</strong></p><p>Expecting students to watch you webcast a Power Point presentation with you hiding behind the mic is about as engaging to them as an insurance broker presenting a webcast slideshow about next year’s rates. Your genuine best bet for engagement is to teach in as close to the same environment as you’d be in if you were teaching in person — and that’s going to need to include your smiling, enthusiastic face.</p><p><strong>Direct student behavior even if you can’t see your students.</strong></p><p>Don’t be afraid to use phrases like “eyes up here” even though your students aren’t in the room. If you’ve exhausted a point and are about to transition to a new idea, call attention back to your face on the screen and encourage students to regroup.</p><p>Experience will guide you here. Indeed, every student is a special snowflake, but you also know at what point in teaching the process of, say, completing the square, most students check out. When you’re engaging on something particularly frustrating or protracted, make an extra effort to remind your students — who know you aren’t able to see them mentally check out — to stay on point rather than sinking into the comfort of explaining something blithely unaware of your utterly confounded audience.</p><p><strong>It’s counter-intuitive, but bite-sized lessons often discourage note-taking and memorization.</strong></p><p>This issue isn’t specific to online learning, but it’s amplified when you’re at virtual arm’s length: a well-conceived five-minute lesson is a thing of beauty, and you’ll need to remind students to take notes after small lessons because they <em>genuinely</em> believe they’ll remember for the long term whatever little <em>bon mot</em> you’ve just dropped because you made it so fast and easy.</p><p>Quick lessons are easy to swallow but difficult to absorb.</p><p>I am perpetually saying to my students, “I know that sunk in right now, but you won’t remember it if we don’t talk about it for two weeks. Write it down so you can review.”</p><p>Continually encourage students to write things down, <em>especially</em> if you’re working in smaller chunks.</p><h3>Pre-recording lectures or webcasting to groups?</h3><p><strong>Recognize that typical students will be doing their schoolwork in bed if given the opportunity.</strong></p><p>This is true for one-on-one live lessons, too, but it’s almost ubiquitous for students watching pre-recorded videos. This doesn’t matter much except that you have to remember that <em>your audience is genuinely more likely to fall asleep while you’re teaching.</em></p><p>Keep your energy up and your ideas on-point throughout your video.</p><p><strong>If you’re recording a lecture, imagine using the same clarity of expression you’d need to use if you were lecturing your passenger while driving down a city street with the radio on.</strong></p><p>Because a recorded lesson is naturally less interactive, it’s incumbent upon you to predict sticking points and objections to any given lesson and address them as you go along.</p><p>The beauty of this is that you’re about to uncover places in which you need to refine your lessons — and everyone has places to grow.</p><p>You’ll also be contending with the new distractions of siblings or YouTube or the waitress at Panera Bread where your student has gone to steal WiFi to study.</p><p>If you’re re-scripting lessons to fit a new platform, use the classic introductory writing rule of thumb: tell them what you’re going to tell them, tell them, and tell them what you told them using different language.</p><p>Again, language that calls attention, like “don’t miss this,” or “did you catch that” and “let’s make sure we’re clear” brings students back to your one-sided conversation.</p><p><strong>Bite size is good, but thorough is better.</strong></p><p>I’ve seen a lot of advice out there to keep recorded lessons to around five minutes — an obvious nod to fleeting attention spans. That being said, inexperienced teachers often overestimate what students already understand and take for granted their own front-loaded fundamentals.</p><p>When you feel like you’re in a rush to teach a bite-sized lesson online, it’s easy to lean towards the same predilection for skipping the basics.</p><p>In reality, you’re better off teaching two five-minute lessons to cover a single, simple topic than squeezing everything into a shorter lesson. Trust yourself to stretch the material for clarity rather than truncating it for time.</p><p><strong>Be kind: encourage the rewind!</strong></p><p><em>Verbally </em>encourage students <em>in your video </em>to rewind and watch something again if it’s important. It’s not a poor reflection on you if a student doesn’t “get it” the first time around. Advocating for a rewind-and-re-watch transmits that your students’ comprehension is most important to you and that it should be to them, too, rather than just the completion of the assigned video viewing.</p><h3>Start Simply</h3><p>If you’re an individual like a tutor or music teacher looking to teach online, you do not actually need to launch a branded virtual learning platform and get a studio with lighting and learn Ruby on Rails and become a podcaster and buy microphones and get the blue check mark on Twitter and earn a certificate in Adobe After Effects and write an ebook. K?</p><p><strong>In some ways, teaching online is really making a glorified phone call.</strong></p><p>Here’s how to get started in a pinch:</p><p>· Use Skype or FaceTime for one-on-one calls.</p><p>· Send Dropbox links via text message or email for PDF or audio files.</p><p>· If you don’t already have a stylus for your iPad, order an inexpensive, low-end Wacom tablet so you can write on a live white board space. These tablets install on your computer via USB or Bluetooth and allow you to use a pen to write on screen with your mouse.</p><p>· There are as many free to practically free live white board spaces as there are hairs on your head — Scribblar and Conceptboard come immediately to mind. You do not need to subscribe to something that’s $75 to $100 a month. Use something that mimics a pen and paper and you should be good to go.</p><p>Only after you’ve started and taught online for a while will you be able to sense if there are real bells and whistles you need.</p><p>· Students who are having lessons on their iPhones or iPads can record their screens under Settings&gt;Control Center&gt;Customize Controls.</p><p>The transition to teaching online is largely psychological — manage your own psychology and your students’ experience to maximize the experience and minimize interruptions.</p><p>Good luck!</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MlxfVF2WEzd6GFFNnzzTRg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Elizabeth King is a public scholar, the author of Outsmarting the SAT ’08 and Acing the ACT ’15 (both Ten Speed Press), and principal tutor at her boutique test preparation company, Elizabeth King Coaching, Inc.. She has been teaching high school curricula, writing, and her proprietary test preparation methods to students across the United States and around the world for almost two decades. A graduate of Mount Holyoke College, Elizabeth is a contributing test authority at Syndicate Media, Inc., a 2020 50CAN National Voices Fellow advocating for equal educational access and excellence, and a class of ’21 graduate student at Vanderbilt University’s Peabody College pursing a degree in Learning &amp; Design. Find her at eliabethonline.com or on Twitter @elizabethonline.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e26cbd0fa460" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Twelve in ‘15]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@elizabethonline/on-twelve-in-15-8a1f278692a5?source=rss-4b4789c27661------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a1f278692a5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[imho]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Elizabeth Syben King]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Feb 2015 18:42:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-02-10T18:42:46.222Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cDsxDZG04CB2qHuSV2f89g.jpeg" /></figure><h3>or, The Art, Age, and Audience debacle</h3><p>I remember the first time I saw Maddie Ziegler, now twelve, in <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2vjPBrBU-TM">Sia’s video <em>Chandelier</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>My breath went shallow. My vision narrowed. I think I actually cried.</p><p><em>Right, well, with all your feminism and freaking out about girls’ issues and stuff, of course you were disgusted. We saw that coming from a mile away.</em></p><p>Nope.</p><p>I was moved and thrilled to see thoughtful choreography and insight expressed by such a young girl — and not in some cloistered Balanchine work at the New York City Ballet but in a pop culture project they’re pumping on MTV.</p><p><em>But she was wearing a nude leotard and dancing to a song about drinking!</em></p><p>Yup.</p><p>Her 2015 Grammy performance of <em>Chandelier </em>with Sia and Kristin Wiig only serves to underscore how exciting Maddie –and Sia — are.</p><p>Last month Sia, co-director Daniel Askill, choreographer Ryan Heffington, and Maddie Ziegler released the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KWZGAExj-es">video <em>Elastic Heart</em></a>, this time adding (who knew?!) performance artist Shia LaBeouf — and, as if by clockwork, those great cultural critics known as the American people and media flipped out.</p><p>In fact, that’s how I heard about its release: Sia’s apology for the video was trending on social media shortly after its release:</p><blockquote><em>I anticipated some ‘pedophelia!!!’ Cries for this video. All I can say is Maddie and Shia are two of the only actors I felt could play these two warring ‘sia’ self states. I apologize to those who feel triggered by Elastic Heart My intention was to create some emotional content, not to upset anybody. ~ Sia [sic]</em></blockquote><p>So, I don’t want to write about the <em>Elastic Heart </em>video itself except to say it, just like <em>Chandelier</em>, is beautifully moving and carefully crafted. It is important to note that the video is not in any way sexual, and the dancer’s nude costumes are there simply to not distract from the frankness of the human form and the identities developed by the dancers and choreography themselves. If you think this is about sex, I’d suggest you might need to live a little.</p><p>Otherwise, an analysis of exceptionally effective lyrical modern dance is not what interests me and is better left to, I guess, people who know about dance.</p><p>What does interest me, though, is that perpetually tiara-clad Sophie Grace Brownlee, 11, originally of YouTube and <em>The Ellen Degeneres Show</em>, dropped her first single video, <em>Best Friends</em>, within 48 hours of <em>Elastic Heart. </em>The coincidence went largely unnoticed in the media.</p><p>With Sia’s Grammy performance, which demands and quietly promulgates more complex artistic thinking, only serving to underscore her creative brilliance, I want to explore some of the problems in the conversation around these videos because they’re indicative of much larger problems with critical thinking and cultural critique overall.</p><h3>1. First, the basics: allusion to nudity does not equal sex</h3><p>I did a little research on the response to the <em>Chandelier </em>video and found an <a href="http://www.csmonitor.com/The-Culture/Family/Modern-Parenthood/2014/0512/Maddie-Ziegler-in-Sia-video-Right-choice-for-an-11-year-old">article in the Christian Science Monitor</a> under their Parenting category in which writer ­Lisa Suhay captures two of the biggest criticisms of Maddie and her leotard in Sia videos.</p><p>For starters, Suhay purports to be very concerned for Maddie’s well-being in <em>Chandelier</em>, trotting out the clever byline phrase “compromising with trends and compromising a child.” Acknowleding Suhay’s assertions is important, as the Monitor is a serious journalistic entity with a critical and respected editorial staff.</p><p>After watching the video,</p><blockquote><em>“…it felt like we may have just witnessed the girl’s birth as an underage sex symbol,” Suhay remarks early on in her article.</em></blockquote><p>Did it really?</p><p>Upon that observation, one might think that Suhay is going to expound on her concerns for Ziegler, but if read closely, it actually reads as though Suhay seems to be far more inconvenienced herself by having to grapple with the video’s existence:</p><blockquote><em>I am happy to see this extraordinarily talented young dancer become an overnight success, yet I wonder where parents must now re-draw the line between making a compromise to insure a child’s success and compromising the child.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>That thought comes to me because I saw this video — not through the lens of a pop culture devotee, ruthless dance coach, or music video marketing person — but through the filter of my 10-year-old son who stood mesmerized at my computer this morning.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>My guess is that right now, close to 5 million people might think: The song is powerful. The little dancer is transcendent. So, what’s the problem?</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>It’s not so much a problem, as a conflict for parents like me — who suddenly find ourselves in the odd position of having a 10-year-old boy who wants to watch a video of an 11-year-old girl in a costume designed to trick the eye into thinking she’s a nude version of the singer, whom we are hearing lament her inability to stop being a drunken “party girl.”</em></blockquote><p>Suddenly Suhay’s concern for Ziegler’s personal well-being sounds far-fetched and more like a thinly veiled complaint: if we really listen to the language up until this point, Suhay is primarily concerned that Ziegler is being compromised because Suhay’s <em>son </em>is into watching the video.</p><h4>To be more specific, it’s as though the video of Ziegler is compromising because it has opened her up to the possibility of the 10-year-old male gaze.</h4><p>Really, this presents an inconvenience for Suhay, who decides to “banish” her son to the other room because he’s apparently not mature enough to watch the video, even though Ms. Ziegler is not, in fact, nude.</p><p>This is fine, objectively. Ms. Suhay’s decision about what her son can be exposed to is obviously up to her, but to insinuate that Ziegler’s parents made a bad judgment call directly because of the possibility of a ten year old boy objectifying her seems lazy at best, and serves as embarrassing cultural criticism coming out of the Christian Science Monitor.</p><h3>2. We need to reframe how we look at artists’ projects, not as vehicles but as efforts</h3><p>Something much more insidious and alarming about the state of the zeitgeist is explored in Suhay’s article: she devotes a great deal of energy to the proposition that the choice to permit Ms. Ziegler to appear in the video was a “compromise to insure a child’s success.”</p><p>Not only is Ziegler being sexually objectified by pre-pubescent boys, but it’s happening because the young dancer and her mother could only be purely motivated by success in The Biz.</p><blockquote><em>As I watched, I wondered if Maddie’s mom felt this adult-themed, sad, dark material is her best option for </em>making her child into a household name. <em>[emphasis mine]</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“Parents don’t have to go that route to get their kids known,” says Lisa Wallace, dance teacher and choreographer for Hurrah Players, a family theater company in Norfolk, Va.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“I have watched Dance Moms, seen Maddie dance, and I can tell you there are too many other avenues available to young dancers for a mom to be making that choice to go with something so mature and negative as a vehicle for her child,” says Ms. Wallace.</em></blockquote><p>Indeed, Maddie Ziegler and her sister and mother are on Dance Moms, the Lifetime reality show about a dance school in Pittsburgh. This should come as no surprise in 2015, when bombastic reality television has become the <em>de facto </em>method for people to get “discovered” who are not the daughters of Kelsey Grammar or John Voigt or Demi Moore.</p><p>But that’s where the conversation is left: Ziegler’s appearance in the video is purely a “vehicle,” a way of getting…. somewhere else.</p><p>Where it is we’re going other than “fame,” I could not say.</p><p>It certainly doesn’t sound like Destination Art.</p><blockquote><em>Seeing this storyline played out by what appears to be a naked child in tenement-like rooms makes me wonder how we evaluate how we are using children in music videos, especially if the result is a child in a video we wouldn’t let our children watch…</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Whether we are Dance Moms, sports parents, or drama dads, if we want our kids to make good choices for themselves, I suggest that we lead by example and make better choices on their behalf today that will aid them in navigating their own futures tomorrow.</em></blockquote><p>…and that’s where the Christian Science Monitor left it, with pearl-clutching warnings of Ziegler becoming the next Miley Cyrus (daughter of Billy Ray), laments that America’s ten year old sons can’t watch this actually-not-naked eleven year old, and tactical observations that appearing in this video is a poor choice of a ‘vehicle’ for fame, the implication that <em>that’s the whole point here.</em></p><h3>3. Speaking of vehicles and eleven year olds: We Need To Talk About Sophia Grace</h3><p>No stranger to lip gloss, tiara love, and best friendship myself, I should confess that I legitimately hoped to get a kick out of 11 <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdsIVUuO7GM">year-old Sophia Grace’s video <em>Best Friends</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Coincidentally, I also remember the morning I first saw this four minute and twenty-four second frosted confection. I had been reading about <em>Elle </em>magazine’s new project The Agenda, for which “forty-three female powerhouses” have been tapped to mentor young women. Granted, the median reader of Elle magazine is a little over 37 years old, so their readers may be a little late to the party, but still, it seems like a solid idea, and I was thinking about how to mentor young women who are <em>significantly </em>younger than 37.2, as that’s central to my work.</p><p>After all, when it comes to girls’ outcomes, what they see early on is what we get.</p><p>Now, women and girls love the “girl power” lyrics of Best Friends:</p><blockquote><em>Stupid boys come around</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Me and my girls shut ‘em down</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Nobody can stop us now</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Gonna take ‘em, we run this town</em></blockquote><p>Fine. I’m no stranger to stupid boys (er, men) either. That’s cute, I guess, and arguably empowering, if we want to lob around that variety of gratuitous language. Given the prepubescent singer and context, it seems <em>Best Friends </em>is definitely gunning for the “boys have cooties” trope.</p><p>Before I go on, I want to be clear that I am <em>in no way </em>indicting or picking on Sophia Grace Brownlee personally.</p><p>I <em>am</em>, however, thinking about the <em>clear </em>direction Matt Alonzo and team had for her video. Just as Maddie Ziegler was expressing the creative vision of Sia and Daniel Askill, Sophia is an actor in a work ultimately expressing the vision of her management team.</p><p>Here’s the vision:</p><p>1. Have a party. Invite over your girlfriends.</p><p>2. Raid mom’s closet for amazing clothes. Look in the mirror.</p><p>3. Get scolded for being in the closet and, instead, go to K-Mart.</p><p>4. You and your girlfriends go bananas over getting to go to K-Mart.</p><p>5. Shop for clothes at K-Mart from your eponymous clothing line.</p><p>6. Scream and jump around in the pink toy aisle, exulting like you’ve won the Power Ball.</p><p>7. Bring your clothes back to the house with your girlfriends, stare into the mirror more, put on gobs of makeup, check out how all the dresses look on you, stage a fashion show with a couple of questionable shoulder-baring moves from your girls</p><p>8. Be the center of attention.</p><p>9. Sing incessantly about being our number one girl.</p><p>10. Do all this despite the noticeable absence of your actual “hype girl” best friend cousin Rosie who heretofore was in all your appearances and business deals.</p><p>So here’s the $100,000 question: Would Ms. Suhay from the Christian Science Monitor allow her ten-year-old son to watch this video? What if she had a ten-year-old daughter?</p><p>After all, <em>Best Friends </em>is aimed at children.</p><p>It seems to me that the general consensus is that this video’s contents should be considered totally benign. Nevertheless, it’s receiving major criticism: people are picking on Rosie for having a softer version of a prepubescent child’s body [despite not having appeared in a nude leotard]. Indeed, the primary criticism here is of this child’s physique.</p><p><a href="http://www.thefader.com/2015/01/12/the-creepiest-thing-about-pops-child-stars-is-us">One author at The Fader</a>, incidentally, whose analysis is notable because Sia herself approved of it and linked to it, has this to say:</p><blockquote><em>…when was the last time you saw a mainstream music video that depicted a girl going shopping and hanging with her best friends with zero sexual messages and no concern for boys? Sophia Grace did it. When was the last time you saw a mainstream music video that depicted the inner strength of a woman through the medium of a 12-year-old girl with enough talent and power to battle a grown man? Maddie Ziegler did it. The presence of both these girls in our pop cultural bubble is refreshingly uncynical.</em></blockquote><p>The implication here is that neither video is meant to result in a particular behavior from its intended audience and they’re both just simple messages of girl independence and powerful identity.</p><p>Gosh. I wish that were true.</p><h3>4. The Inextricable Relationship between Exploitation, Audience, and Connoisseurship</h3><p>Folks, if Maggie Ziegler’s exquisite performance of lyrical dance intended for a mature audience is what young girls should <em>not </em>be doing and Sophie Grace Brownlee’s hocking big-box product to other tweens and children is what they <em>should </em>be doing, we have a major problem.</p><p>In fact, there is a deep irony in that the Sia objector camp is angry about purported images of child abuse and “triggering,” when we could easily argue that it’s Sophia Grace Brownlee who is being overtly used. Granted, that’s what advertisers do, but we should make no bones about the reality that <em>Best Friends </em>amounts to a four-minute advertisement for her clothing line and K-Mart products in general.</p><p>Part of the reason I’d imagine it’s easy to condemn the Sia/Ziegler videos and performances is because to do so requires nothing of us but superficial reaction. If we don’t take the time (or are ill-equipped) to understand the work, it’s effortless to get angry and disgusted at <em>what these adults are letting Maddie do </em>or to get self-righteous because the material might not have made us feel all warm and cuddly and up-with-people. Meanwhile, I have yet to hear anyone say, “I won’t let my daughter watch the Sophie Grace video because I don’t want her to believe that completely brainless shopping and makeup application are what it’s all about when we’re really being girls.”</p><p>Which brings us to the what’s really at stake in the discussion: media and art can’t be completely defined or evaluated without specifying its anticipated audience.</p><p>Moreover, it’s too bad that these Sia objectors aren’t actually prepared to explore the human content of or flat out <em>appreciate her art.</em></p><p>In other words: ‘Merica, it’s time to talk about <em>age</em>, <em>art, </em>and <em>audience.</em></p><h3>5. Critical Context: the space beTween</h3><p>Sophie Grace Brownlee is about seven months younger than Maddie Ziegler, who turned twelve last September. Lisa Suhay’s son is presumably now eleven or so.</p><p>Whether we like it or not, this is a complex age and largely marks the onset of adolescence and initial rumblings of parental separation. The average American girl currently gets her first period at twelve years old. The average age for first time internet porn exposure is eleven.</p><p>One need look no further than the photographer Sally Mann’s 1988 collection of images <em>At Twelve: Portraits of Young Women</em>, a project entirely focused on girls at this precise age, to sense the complex histories and perspectives that young girls amass — even as she documented those who were living in the analog age. Interestingly, the outrage around <em>Elastic Heart </em>smacks of the controversy (the New York Times went so far as to call it “disturbing”) Mann stirred with the subsequent release of <em>Immediate Family</em>, a 1992 project in which Mann published dozens of photos of her prepubescent children in various states of undress alongside other family intimacies.</p><p>As in, the kids were actual, leotard-free, naked. Even so, no legal action was ever taken against Ms. Mann (and rightly so).</p><p>So how can we so easily dismiss the concern that Elastic Heart, even with its inclusion of minimally clad Shia LaBeouf, is erotic or inappropriate? In the forward of Nude Body Nude, the 1992 photographic collection published by Howard Schatz, Owen Edwards explains that images that are erotic are those of bodies that are presented as clearly “capable of sex.” Nude Body Nude unapologetically offers those sorts of images.</p><p>Is Maddie presented in these works with the intention of compelling the viewer to consider her in a sexual way?</p><p>No.</p><p>It’s that simple. It’s not perverse; it’s not abuse.</p><p>Are the themes Sia explores dark and challenging? Absolutely, and the truth is that some young people are insightful enough to deal with them and explore them artistically.</p><p>We lose when we as an audience suffer from this lack of critical thought and frames of reference: we lose the human experience of having our emotions stirred and the ability to empathize with other viewers.</p><p>The overall issues we have to address as a critical culture, then, are twofold: one, we’re generating distracting noise around what’s actually intelligent and provocative pop art that adds to our cultural fabric. In fact, criticizing Maddie’s appearance purely in the context of it being a “vehicle” for becoming famous completely jettisons that she has actually presented us with a work of deep creativity and skill that’s worthwhile <em>for its own sake.</em></p><p>The kid made great art whether or not she becomes the next face of Pepsi.</p><p>Two, by criticizing Maddie’s participation, we’re tacitly reinforcing the damaging and totally un-empowering mandate that little girls should only be seen in lip-gloss, cupcakey slumber party vignettes in which they shop and stare at themselves in the mirror — but “with their girls.”</p><p>I applaud Sophie Grace Brownlee’s family for striking while the iron is hot, but we as consumers of media and as the builders of our own culture are doing a terrible disservice to girls, to the adults that they become, and to art, by doing anything but welcoming images of younger girls participating in challenging and complex media moments outside the ornaments of a tiara.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a1f278692a5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>