<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ellen P. Goodman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ellen P. Goodman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ellgood?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 07:29:18 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ellgood/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[As climate disclosure laws go, so go AI disclosure laws]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/as-climate-disclosure-laws-go-so-go-ai-disclosure-laws-51c5488bb6a7?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/51c5488bb6a7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[first-amendment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[xai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Nov 2026 17:30:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-12T17:30:25.213Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/819/1*SlbRN41qLyzLcRVgvGc_tA.png" /><figcaption>ChatGPT generated</figcaption></figure><h4>Lessons from U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez (9th Cir., 11/9/26) for xAI v. Bonta (oral arg. 11/18/26)</h4><p>Oral argument in the 9th Cir. in San Francisco in <em>xAI v. Bonta</em> challenging <a href="https://www.caidp.org/cases/training-data-transparency/">California’s Generative AI Training Data Transparency law</a> (AB 2013) is scheduled for November 18. The same court just released an opinion in <a href="https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca9/25-5327/25-5327-2026-11-09.html"><em>U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez</em></a><em> </em>striking down parts of California’s Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (SB 253) and Climate-Related Financial Risk Act (SB 261) on First Amendment grounds creating precedent for AI disclosure laws. California should take comfort from the fact that <em>Sanchez </em>upheld the climate disclosure mandates that are closest to the disclosures AB 2013 require of AI model developers, though how much comfort depends on the panel of judges. The <em>Sanchez</em> panel split 2–1, with the dissenting judge taking a more hardline approach against the state. At the same time, the <em>Sanchez </em>court’s reasoning for striking down other climate disclosure mandates clouds the future of other recently enacted California AI transparency laws, such as the <a href="https://legiscan.com/CA/text/SB53/id/3270002">Transparency in Frontier AI Act (SB 53).</a></p><p>The climate disclosures at issue in <em>Sanchez</em> were designed to inform consumers and shareholders about product and firm-level climate impacts, and also to reduce carbon emissions. Similarly, AI accountability disclosure laws are typically designed both to inform markets and to achieve substantive AI safety goals. <em>Sanchez</em> teaches that mandatory disclosure of information that is standardized, readily obtained, within the entity’s control, factual, and not requiring any controversial normative assessment should survive First Amendment commercial speech review. But information that is farther from the entity’s own commercial activity and entails value judgements on a politically fraught subject will be considered noncommercial speech and struck down under strict scrutiny review.</p><p>California’s Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act requires companies of a certain size to disclose information about carbon emissions related to their products and services. The Chamber of Commerce and others challenged the disclosure provisions as unconstitutionally compelling noncommercial speech. They won with respect to provisions requiring companies to disclose carbon emissions from upstream and downstream sources. This requirement, the court wrote, “compels companies to collect, synthesize, and report information about the conduct of independent actors across complex commercial networks.” The court regarded such information, which the companies presumably don’t possess and may struggle to collect, as too distant from the companies’ own commercial activity to constitute commercial speech. Once deemed to trench on noncommercial speech, it was nearly inevitable that the provisions would fail the applicable strict scrutiny test (narrowly tailored to further a compelling state interest). And fail they did.</p><p>By contrast, the court looked more favorably on two other disclosure requirements that it regarded as <em>commercial</em> speech compulsions, mostly because of the nexus between the information and the commercial activity and because of the type of information required. The provisions make companies disclose carbon emissions from sources they own or control, or from their own energy usage. The court first found these disclosures to be commercial speech because they are “sufficiently tethered to the reporting entity’s own commercial operations and capital transactions.” The second move was to find the information itself to be uncontroversial and factual (even if climate change is a controversial topic) because carbon emission measurements are now standardized and routine. A central question in commercial speech cases is whether the standard of review should be intermediate (<em>Central Hudson</em>) or deferential (<em>Zauderer</em>) depending on the information at issue. The court didn’t decide because the requirements survived even the more stringent intermediate scrutiny standard: they directly advance the State’s substantial interests in mitigating information asymmetries and reducing emissions, and are no more extensive than necessary.</p><p>Another set of compelled disclosures come from California’s Climate-Related Financial Risk Act. Companies must report on climate change-related financial risks and opine on the value of risk mitigation. Here, the <em>Sanchez </em>court found the First Amendment problems even more pronounced than the value-chain carbon emission disclosures. That’s because the information in the court’s view is noncommercial <em>and </em>controversial. It considered speech involving such speculation and normative assessments about competing priorities and values to be definitionally noncommercial. Therefore, the requirement had to be strictly scrutinized and failed. An analytically sounder approach might have been to deem the disclosures commercial and controversial, since commercial speech need not be merely descriptive (see, e.g., advertisements). But that probably would not have changed the outcome.</p><p>Much of what California’s AI training data transparency law at issue in <em>xAI v. Bona</em> requires looks like the information that the <em>Sanchez</em> court ruled was permissibly compelled. Developers have to disclose the general sources and characteristics of training data, how datasets relate to the system’s intended purpose, the approximate size and IP status of the data, whether the data contains personal or aggregated consumer information, and whether synthetic data are used. Most of these are facts about the developer’s own inputs under the developer’s control, although xAI disputes that. Seen this way, it is likely that the 9th Circuit will uphold the district court’s refusal to enjoin the law.</p><p>The Transparency in Frontier AI Act will be a tougher road for California if and when it’s challenged. It requires frontier model developers to publish annual reports on catastrophic risk, mitigations, alignment with recognized safety standards, cybersecurity practices. For new or substantially modified models, they must publish information about intended uses, restrictions, and catastrophic-risk assessment results. On the one hand, this is information that the frontier labs will have and generate themselves, satisfying the nexus considerations for commercial speech. On the other hand, these disclosures would seem to require predictive and normative judgments about controversial outcomes, like the climate risk disclosures the <em>Sanchez </em>court struck down. If it comes to this, survival of the law may well depend on the enormity of the State interests and the degree to which disclosures actually advance safety.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=51c5488bb6a7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lament and Repair]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/lament-and-repair-ee270f322e0c?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee270f322e0c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-zionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sad]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tisha-bav]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jews]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 05:39:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-24T12:51:12.350Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GxASDm0OePbxIB5ExoHr8w.png" /><figcaption>“If I forget you Jerusalem, let my right hand wither.” Psalm 137</figcaption></figure><p>We Jews have just observed the day of lamentations, Tisha B’Av, some of us sitting on the floor in candlelight. Others finding meaning in political protest. It was a fast day remembering the Babylonian destruction of our civilization in Judea in 586 BCE and then again, after we had returned, the Roman destruction in 70 CE. We mourn our dispersal from the land of Israel and then repeated expulsions from deceptively precarious Diaspora communities in England (1290) and Spain (1492) and so on. It is also an occasion to consider what part we played in our devastation, and how we can be better.</p><p>I will begin in Part 1 lamenting with many American Jews the here and now of anti-Jewish hate. I lament with world Jewry the exclusion of Jews and Israelis from places of public accommodation, institutions, and event spaces. I lament the physical and verbal assaults on members of our communities. Because we are a small nation of ~16 million, thickly connected, the attacks can feel close and personal even if far away.</p><p>Part 2, in the Jewish tradition of lamentation, turns to introspection. We are a people rebuilt from those destructions. Central to that peoplehood is responsibility for each other and for our collective. As strongly as I reject the anti-Jewish hatred that scapegoats Jews for the suffering we didn’t cause, I take seriously our responsibility for the suffering we <em>have</em> caused or could mitigate. Our tradition teaches us, especially through the prophetic rebukes (tochecha), that we have agency always.</p><p><strong>I. Rage and sorrow</strong></p><p>I’m sorry that the progressive movement is letting anti-Jewish hate curdle beautiful aspirations. I know it doesn’t feel that way to many fellow progressives. They will say their invocation of AIPAC as public enemy number one is justified on the merits. They might say, drawing on intersectional theory, that AIPAC and Israel are at the heart of capitalist oppression. Perhaps this is what Mayor Mamdani meant when he called AIPAC supporters “monsters.” AIPAC is one of the biggest single-issue campaign spenders, and I don’t like that at all. But its single issue just isn’t closely related to the problems that most concern Americans. Certainly the anti-AIPAC credential is inexplicable in campaigns for American state and local offices divorced from foreign policy. It’s possible that people don’t know that scapegoating “Jewish interests” has featured in every anti-Jewish hate movement of the last 2000 years. At the very least, then, the AIPAC obsession is <a href="https://jewishmajority.org/open-letter-from-rabbis">relentlessly insensitive</a>.</p><p>The fact that fidelity to an anti-Israel orthodoxy has become the litmus test for progressive politics is inseparable from an inherited, perhaps unconscious discourse about THE JEWS. Tropes from<a href="https://rlandes.substack.com/p/the-great-lethal-projection-anti?r=lo3t&amp;utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&amp;utm_medium=web&amp;triedRedirect=true"> the Protocols of the Elders of Zion</a> — the counterfeit document that supercharged conspiracy theories about Jewish power in the late 19th century and helped the Nazis and the Bolsheviks justify their murder of Jews — populate contemporary antizionist graphics and slogans. That there are plenty of Jews who participate in this discourse does not cleanse the bigotry. It’s at this point that I might be expected to engage in the obligatory throat clearing of the liberal Jew that of course “the Netanyahu government is revolting…” There’s a whiff of the placatory in that, as if political bona fides were required to raise these points. As for Bibi, there are actual opportunities to help change Israel’s government in the coming elections; I wish more Americans who care about the region would engage with Israeli opposition activists instead of boycotting them.</p><p>I lament that living a full-throated Jewish life has become dangerous in the Diaspora. By this I don’t mean that we are confronted with argument and discomfiting narratives. That’s a good thing and “argument for the sake of heaven” is a central pillar of our Torah. I mean it can be physically dangerous to walk the street speaking Hebrew or wearing a kippah. Rather than recognizing anti-Jewish hate, many prefer to brush off Jews and allies as “weaponizing” what they see as trivial episodes (presumably not the murders and assaults). If one views Jews as safe and powerful, the hate incidents may seem trivial. Safety and power are relative and fragile. You can have them in some respects, in some times, but not in others. For many Jews, primed by their own traumas or those remembered, the accumulated incidents form a drumbeat: “This is how it starts.” It is true that the Trump Administration has weaponized antisemitism to achieve objectives that have nothing to do with Jewish safety and that’s bad for all of us. Here as elsewhere, that the Administration cynically exploits real fears for illegitimate aims does not delegitimize those fears.</p><p>The weaponization calumny may also stem from the fear that Jewish dignity comes at the expense of Palestinian dignity. The president of<a href="https://washingtonmonthly.com/2026/07/15/when-anti-zionists-become-censors/"> PEN America</a>, Dinaw Mengestu, resigned in protest over his organization’s own report documenting the unofficial censorship of Jewish and Israeli literary voices. The report reiterated PEN America’s opposition to censorship and cultural boycotts. Mengestu seemed to think it’s impossible to acknowledge the marginalization of Jews without, in so doing, marginalizing Palestinians or delegitimizing economic boycotts of Israeli products (thereby conflating human and economic rights). In reporting on interviews with writers and publishers, <a href="https://www.wsj.com/opinion/pen-america-equivocates-on-boycotting-israel-c31e6fcb">Meg Keene noted</a> that “Jewish writers are acceptable only if they are willing to disavow Jewish self-determination.” Joshua Hoffman uses the language of “liberalism” to describe the false binary between Jewish and Palestinian human rights: “Once human rights depend on the identity of the victim, they are no longer human rights….Liberals did not lose their credibility by caring about Palestinians. They lost it by acting as though caring about Palestinians required them to stop caring about Jews.”</p><p>This is not about the Jews, we are told, just Israel. This is followed by a truism so incontrovertible as to be almost irrelevant: “it’s not antisemitic to criticize Israel.” I mean, obviously. Along with millions of Israelis, I’ve been involved with protest movements against Israeli governments for a long time. Criticize away. Again, that’s our Torah. Our peoplehood began with Abraham criticizing God for not living up to God’s own values. But two specific features of the current anti-Israel movement reveal an anti-Jewish substrate. First, absent is the insistence that we liberals care about the lives of all people of the region. The embrace of eliminationist language and groups among many American activists and even some leaders conveys the opposite: an apparent indifference to the survival of 7 million Jews in Israel (and perhaps also the self-determination of 2 million Israeli Arabs and Palestinians). Second, the insistence on separating the “Jewish faith” from the survival of nearly half the Jewish people deforms Jewish identity for many and, I would argue, is structurally anti-Jewish.</p><p>Here is the structural point. Psalm 137 expresses the pain of the Jews in Babylonian exile. “By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat, sat and wept, as we thought of Zion.” And as we wept, we vowed, “If I forget you Jerusalem, let my right hand wither.” This is one of hundreds of sacred texts, some recited daily in our prayers, centering collective self-determination in Zion. The price of Jewish entry to many progressive coalitions is exactly what the psalm denounces: forget Zion, sever your limb. Maybe there’s a way to see all of this Zion stuff as metaphor rather than a real place, and surely some Jews do. But not most. When Mayor Mamdani says he reveres Judaism as a faith, but cannot tolerate Jewish self-determination, this is either lecturing Jews about who we are or a bid to have us convert to something else. Who we are is <em>Zion-ish</em>.</p><p>What about Zion-ist? I tend to avoid using the word. Many use Zionist and Jew interchangeably (see outrage over “Zionist” Adam Sandler officiating Taylor Swift’s wedding). One might insist on the<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/01/opinion/zionism-jewish-israel.html"> actual definition of Zionism</a> as a 19th century political movement for Jewish self-determination in the land of Israel, culminating in a Jewish and democratic state with equal rights for all citizens. But I wonder if just too many people understand the word differently. For that, we can thank devilishly successful 1970’s Soviet propaganda. It maligned Zionism in an effort to oppress Soviet Jews and attract Arab allies — a move that <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rg1Lzgvwd4">Senator Daniel Moynihan decried</a> at the UN as a “great evil.” That campaign, amplified by Islamists and various academic theorists, has had lasting effect. Case in point is the DSA’s evolution from founder <a href="https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/history/articles/when-americas-democratic-socialists-proudly-supported-israel">Michael Harrington’s sympathetic understanding of political Zionism</a> to its rejection today. But we also have Israeli policies to thank for the word’s corruption. Government officials like<a href="https://www.timesofisrael.com/understanding-the-ominous-rise-of-israels-most-notorious-ultra-nationalist/"> Itamar Ben Gvir</a> bear responsibility for perverting what he calls Zionism with racist aspirations and abuses.</p><p>I would never insist that Jews are or should be political Zionists, even using the dictionary definition. I do think that the Jewish people are structurally <em>Zion-ish</em>. Zion is constitutive. The rootedness of Jews in Judea resides deep under the earth and is baked into more than three millennia of Jewish life and practice. That we will not let go of Zion or of each other has always vexed other nations. It makes us “cosmopolitan” with connections to communities abroad. It makes us “foreign” wherever we reside. These connections confound the categories of religion and nationality that we use in the West. As <a href="https://sapirjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/how-to-teach-the-jewish-story.pdf">Dara Horn has noted</a>, majorities have always put Jews into the identity boxes that make sense from their own hegemonic perspectives. Christianity and Islam are universalist credal faiths. It was convenient to shoehorn Judaism beside them. Except it doesn’t really fit. The Jews are a multi-ethnic, multi-racial family descended by birth or choice from Abraham and Sarah, which became a collection of tribes in Judea, which became a nation dispersed by force. The people of Israel are connected by the Hebrew language, Torah, the festivals, and shared history and aspirations, all running through the land of Israel. As Horn says, it takes a lot to say that in English. It takes only two words in Hebrew: עם ישראל</p><p><strong>2. Shared responsibility</strong></p><p>Here, I want to shift to something more constructive, if just as painful. I take seriously the position that we Jews are a nation, a single people. The Talmud (Shevuot 39a) tells us <em>Kol yisrael arevim zeh bazeh</em> — all Israel is responsible for each other. This thick connection to each other and to Zion — as a structural feature of Jewish peoplehood even if not a subjective feeling in the heart of every Jew — makes it difficult to untangle antizionism from anti-Jewish hate. The same thick connection means that I bear some responsibility for the Jewish future and failings.</p><p>This is a burden. It’s one that Jews like my great-grandfather, Judge Horace Stern, did not want to bear before WW2. As a leader in what they called the Jewish non-Zionist movement of the 1920’s, he thought Jewish sovereignty would be a liability. Typical of German Jewish leaders, whether still in Germany or in America, he hoped for assimilation in the Diaspora. A Jewish state, he thought, would hurt these efforts. In any case, that kind of separatism was incompatible with the post-WWI idealism that we might just be done with national conflict. He signed a letter along with other likeminded Jews to President Wilson in 1919, objecting to American support for a Jewish state and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/1919/03/05/archives/protest-to-wilson-against-zionist-state-representative-jews-ask-him.html">expressing</a> hope that a newborn League of Nations would safeguard Jews and all people without separatism.</p><p>One reason my Opa resisted Zionism was that a Jewish state would impose responsibilities on Jews who could exercise little control over it. He was right to worry. Writing later, the great Rav Soleveichik embraced this responsibility. “The Jewish people bear collective responsibility for one another and towards one another. We are held accountable for the wrongdoing of our brethren, both in the eyes of Heaven and the eyes of the world…The identification of the activities of the individual with the deeds of the nation is a fundamental truth of the history of our people.”</p><p>By 1934, in the wake of vicious pogroms in eastern Europe against Jews and then the start of Nazi persecution, my Opa had converted — if not to political Zionism — to the program of supporting Jewish refugees in Zion. With all countries turning away fleeing Jews, his political ideology bowed to the demands of peoplehood and human rights. “We Jewish folk,” he said in a fundraising appeal, “stand in the shadow of an almost incredible tragedy.” He never imagined how deep those shadows would deepen. This was a brutal lesson for all like him — all that had once hoped that the need for Jewish self-determination was passé in the 20th century. We are asked to believe it again in the 21st century.</p><p>Rabbi Soleveichik’s instruction is consistent with the words of our prophets that we must be worthy as a collective to merit the land of Israel. Mijal Biton writes in the<a href="https://mijal.substack.com/p/the-chutzpah-of-blaming-ourselves"> <em>Chutzpah of Blaming Ourselves</em></a><em> </em>that on Tisha B’Av, as furious as we are at the Babylonian and Roman destruction of our thriving communities in Jerusalem, we also look inwards. Were we actually thriving? What did we do wrong? This is not victim-blaming. It’s taking responsibility. The Talmud shares stories of corruption, infighting, and baseless hatred among our people. We find the story of Kamsa/ Bar Kamsa and how the great and mighty in our community refused to stand up for the weak. <a href="https://www.chabad.org/library/bible_cdo/aid/16457/jewish/Chapter-1.htm">Eicha</a>, the Book of Lamentations read on Tisha B’Av, is replete with self-examination. “Jerusalem sinned grievously, therefore she became a wanderer; all who honored her despised her, for they have seen her shame; moreover, she herself sighed and turned away.”</p><p>Jerusalem sins — not alone, not as the DSA alleges — but she sins. We should not turn away. I don’t want to be misunderstood. I don’t mean that Jews and Jewish institutions are proxies for Israel and appropriate addresses for anti-Israel protest, much less violence. I don’t mean that Babylon or Rome get to impose collective responsibility, often expressed as collective punishment. Rather, I think of responsibility as a practice we assume voluntarily, as a mitzvah. The inquisitor who demands we renounce Zion trespasses on our dignity. The Jew who rages only at Babylon and Rome misses lamentations’ invitation to improve.</p><p>I wondered if I should close this with specific actions I’m taking, but that seemed annoying. I’m happy to share ideas about how we might improve life in Israel/Palestine, in the U.S., and for Jewish generations to come.</p><p>Shalom.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee270f322e0c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Goodbye Dad]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/goodbye-dad-b8f59ba655be?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8f59ba655be</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[obituary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fathers]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Dec 2025 23:57:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-01T03:24:49.346Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Frank Ira Goodman z’l 11.20.32–12.26.25</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nqj3cr1xfI5MOo0q5-E24Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Frank Goodman</figcaption></figure><p>Dad’s life ended not far from Independence Hall and the surrounding worn cobblestones and soaring London Plane trees he loved. He left a loving wife, four children, eleven grandchildren, and one great grandchild.</p><p>He loved big sky and horizons maybe because he was born in Omaha and grew up in San Antonio. He was the cherished only son of Alice Adler and Israel Goodman. By the time he graduated from Thomas Jefferson High School, he had collected every medal for academic and tennis achievement there was to be had. He competed across the Southwest in every debate or writing contest and on every court. Dad spent his vacations with his Adler aunts and cousins: Brodkeys, Zysmans, Trustins, Blocks, Binders, and Ripps — good people descended from Jacob Adler the fruit wholesaler and Lizzy Brenner, who told her children to stick together “shoulder to shoulder.” They were scrabbling through Depression-era America that was opening up to Jews and they were lucky kids.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/1*O8pIKDecku7haSwYNcSozw.jpeg" /></figure><p>They were musicians and soldiers, cowboys, and poets, among them Frankie, my dad — omnivorous reader, music lover, fast runner, tennis powerhouse. For him, there was nothing that Alice and Israel (Shrolly) wouldn’t do or give. Alice rescued and sold fine early edition books to raise money for Brandeis University. Their household revered books and dad would forever be a collector and protector. Israel (Shrolly) worked 6 days a week, 12 hours a day in an over-heated automotive supply shop to launch their wondrous son into the world.</p><p>Dad the boy listened avidly to Roosevelt’s radio addresses, CBS classical music concerts, and baseball games — a listening habit he’d continue well into old age, holding a transistor radio up to his ear (including in school auditoria and even during theatrical productions) so as not to miss anything. As a young constitutional law professor at Penn Law in the fall of 1973, Dad showed up during the first days of the Yom Kippur War with a radio, and would stop class every so often to check the news, he was so worried about Israel’s survival (he had volunteered at Nahal Oz in 1955 and was a fierce patriot).</p><p>Few went east to college from San Antonio in those days and no one in his family knew about Harvard or really much about any university. Dad read <em>Yankee from Olympus, </em>Catherine Drinker Bowen’s biography of Oliver Wendel Holmes Jr. Harvard was the school Justice Holmes went to, so Harvard it would be for dad. Once something was dad’s, whether it was a family, a people, a sports team, or a country — that was it, he was do or die. He graduated with a summa in 1954, playing varsity tennis, trained only by hitting relentlessly against a concrete wall and Texas turf. He went on to Oxford’s Magdalen College as a Rhodes Scholar, earning a first in PPE in 1956, and then passed through Harvard Law School (’59), where he edited the law review and collected parking tickets (literally piling up on the windshield of his car and awaiting some responsible adult to be paid).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NSpQ825NT7vSPlIyVtn8bQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dad was a classmate of Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s at HLS before she transferred to Columbia. He would occasionally push her baby Jane in the carriage and admired her immensely even then. We heard a story at shiva that when someone passed on my dad’s best wishes to Justice RBG at a party, she said that she remembered him as the only man in the class who treated the very few women students as equals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dej6ePrl1fbZLL3wPQUCrQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dad loved female achievement in politics, scholarship, sports. Maybe it was being around all those strong aunts. He encouraged my mom to push herself professionally (though he was incapable of pitching in on domestic duties) and never expected less of me and my sister than of our bothers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9xsQ3Lq0vbzChhdsEztHLA.jpeg" /></figure><p>It was in Cambridge that dad met mom. It’s through her eyes that I knew this brilliant, odd, child-like, athletic, soulful, impractical young man. She was used to strivers maneuvering for professional success. Dad was different. He didn’t care about success in any traditional sense, only excellence. He didn’t pay any attention to rank or class, color or sex. He was as interested in the opinion of the guy sitting next to him in the nosebleed bleachers as he was in that of an illustrious judge in a box seat. He could talk politics (liberal), sports (ultimately, all the Philly teams), music (classical), film (especially Hitchcock), philosophy and literature, history, art, law …and also soap operas, and Wendy’s versus McDonalds. Transfixed by classical music, silenced by a redwood, dad revered beauty. When traveling in Italy, for example, he kept track of sunset times (before that was easy) and made pilgrimage to the best viewing locations.</p><p>Dad would call mom in the wee hours to take a walk in the moonlight at Walden Pond. He’d drag her to chamber orchestras. She pretended to like these things, and for the sake of his curiosity and character, she chose to overlook the unpaid tickets, ratty dressing, and incompetence with respect to any household chore (which never changed). She wanted to marry him; he was in no hurry. So, while dad was clerking for Judge William Hastie on the 3rd Circuit in Philadelphia, she told him time was up and she had moved on. While lacking in general courtship skills, he had just the skills to win her back. She tells the story of how he drove up from Philadelphia to her parents’ Manhattan apartment simply to say hello. He ended up driving her to the train station, from where she was headed back to Boston. She had to be in grad school classes the next morning and he in chambers. Through New York, Connecticut, and Rhode Island, he kept driving and talking and driving and talking, until he dropped her in Boston late that night, and drove through the night all the way back. That drive sealed it, so stimulating and impractical and loving it was.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/880/1*qOVn0MsiC3AoTuRgmy21VA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dad loved America and, not surprisingly, chose to marry on July 4, 1960. Immediately after the wedding, Frank and Joan got in a big Chrysler and drove out to Los Angeles where dad worked for a few years as an entertainment lawyer. Though he had a few professional achievements, like writing Groucho Marx’s will, he wasn’t capable of making the second-best arguments if that’s what served the client. Nor could he manage paperwork or deadlines effectively. Camelot called and they moved back east for his stint in Archibald Cox’s Solicitor General’s office. After a few years of that, they moved back to California to a tenure track job at Berkely (Bolt) Law School. This is where I came into the picture.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*etyaPQwZhpd8CCAaQ_3wZA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dad loved the sun and I remember him pacing the balconies of our Spanish-style house in the Berkely Hills, flipping a Parker pen and vocalizing the scholarly paragraphs he would sometimes or often never actually write down. There was a pool called Strawberry Canyon and once dad came out of the dressing room having undressed, but forgotten to put on his swimsuit. He was completely absorbed in his thoughts. But he also loved to move, to hike, to run, to play tennis, and to celebrate his kids’ athletic pursuits.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/1*VVf9F1h_3v7MVxIbqrvpjQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>A political moderate, dad was anti-Vietnam war, but on the “wrong” side of the radical Berkeley protests of the late-1960’s. He wrote his tenure piece in 1972 showing the constitutional harms of de facto segregation — a rather leftist position. At the same time, he resisted proposals for mandatory federal busing as a remedy, arguing instead for voluntary and state measures to promote integration. At dinner conversations, whatever the topic, dad would push on both sides, discontent with what he saw as “knee jerk” positions, forcing his opponents to sharpen their arguments… or sometimes go running from the table. One finds many many thanks to dad for his help with law review articles, and from across the political spectrum. His devil’s advocate style of argumentation didn’t always go down well — not with guests and not with children. But the arguments were “for the sake of heaven”. They were never personal or for personal advantage. And they passed with the occasion, leaving twinkling eyes and a broad smile that was dad’s resting face.</p><p>From Berkely, dad found a job at Penn Law school, where he remained for the next 40 plus years. Dad did not author a lot of his own scholarship. He was seized by a paralyzing perfectionism and doubt that what he had to say was sufficiently new or worthwhile. He spent his time on the work of others, on mentoring students and sharpening colleagues’ scholarship. He was known to wait after class to talk with students sometimes for hours as a walk back to the office led to seminars in advanced constitutional theory or lunch and conversations about their experiences, sports, music, whatever.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*r-A9ob1rZWgXUgN2i6oNIg.jpeg" /></figure><p>One student recalled: “What struck me the most was his total engagement in the ideas we were discussing. Time and place had no meaning.” Dad took the job of writing letters of recommendation for students as a sacred duty and spent weeks on each one. His letters helped place students at all levels of the federal judiciary. One student commented that he was stunned with the process: “Rather than quickly noting that I was a good student who did well in his classes, Professor Goodman studied me over weeks. He read my resume and writing samples; he pored over my law school application, taking stock of my personal statement and letters of recommendation; he invited me to lunch and asked me about my background and passions. And in the end, he wrote a letter that — according to my surprised interviewers — highlighted who I am as a person, and not just as a student.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vNVfU0mtFEf1LSQazP507A.jpeg" /></figure><p>His absent-mindedness combined with his unassuming warmth struck everyone. His beloved administrative assistant, Sylvana, wrote this to dad of their first meeting: “You came into the office not knowing who I was and you had your radio on listening to a game. You had lost the tassel to your graduation cap and asked me to help you retrace your footsteps. We never did find that tassel but … that was the start of … a friendship. I felt at ease from the first time meeting you. You kept the same demeanor as if you’d known me for years…. I will never meet such a kind, genuine, warm hearted human being as you.” Another assistant wrote that while other professors knew nothing about her, dad “took time to greet everyone; he asked about our families; he talked with us about current events.”</p><p>Dad’s egalitarianism shaped how he responded to people asking for money on the street. Outside the law school, there were frequently several and dad decided to enter into contracts with them. He would agree to pay a certain amount each week and then stick to it. This arrangement created predictable expecations on both sides and recognized the dignity of the recipient. My older brother wrote of dad: He was “a<br>man without artifice, or pretense, or bitterness. A man who never spent a<br>minute scheming, or trying to aggrandize himself at the expense of<br>someone else. A man who talked to Supreme Court justices and law school<br>secretaries and homeless people with the same directness and respect. A<br>man full of guileless love for all of us.”</p><p>I would sometimes help dad carry books from the parking lot on 34th street into his office. He would trail books — many overdue from the library — and folders full of bluebooks (usually graded for the last possible deadline). At any given moment, he might be reading a new biography of Mozart or Churchill, a book on a mathematical theorem, along with Commentary and Sports Illustrated magazines — all while also watching a basketball game in his recliner in running clothes. In the photo below he is reading two objects and listening to the radio; no doubt the TV was on as well. In the other photo, at my law school graduation, you can see the band from his radio sticking out of his jacket.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/705/1*fgRV21ldtQd747RYrU53xQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>All this intensity was not always charming. There were many fights about his use of the radio in inappropriate settings. He was a screenager before his time. We would poke at him to tuck in his shirt or replace his moth-eaten sweater, to maybe do a dish or take out the trash. But I did absorb something wonderful from dad’s disheveled and multimodal engagement. I learned that you didn’t have to privilege highbrow over lowbrow culture. You didn’t have to choose among genres or kinds of people to befriend or accept pre-packaged political commitments. You could take ideas on their own terms as worthy or not with an open-minded receptivity to pursuing truth as you could find it and standing in rapt appreciation before the mysteries.</p><p>It was both a fault and a great virtue that dad didn’t think too much of his own professional advancement. He didn’t have those vanities. If someone had asked him for notes on a manuscript — whether it was a child or a colleague, his wife or the friend of a friend of a friend — that was his focus for as long as it took. And it took a long time because he went through line by line. One colleague, reflecting on dad’s contributions to the intellectual life of the law school wrote of “Frank’s combination of intellectual rigor, deep curiosity and passionate engagement. I can think of few of my colleagues who can be relied on to provide comments over as broad a range of intellectual terrain. I can think of no other friend or colleague with whom I have gotten into a shouting match over the meaning of the Eleventh Amendment. And I can think of none from whom I have learned more.”</p><p>I ended up following in dad’s footsteps to college and law school and then even to the law firm (Covington &amp; Burling) he had worked in as a summer associate, and later to the law professoriate. At each of those stops, he pushed me to value what he saw as greatness: the great scholars (John Rawls and Al Sacks), the great statesmen and consummate lawyers (Dean Acheson and Tommy Austern), the great aspirations (beauty, truth, justice). It was cozy to be in the legal world along with dad, but none of that mattered as much as the simple love I felt from him and the love he shared for the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SM9KE_VqgRX0lih9bNf9LA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Beneath his cerebral and analytical ferocity, he just loved. He wept. He wept at music, at poetry, at Churchill’s sonorous speeches of defiance. He laughed uproariously at improbable juxtapositions and we giggled together to the last days. He loved his grandchildren simply and deeply. He lit up when one of us walked in the room and to me would exclaim “You’re so terrific Elsie Bells.” He often expressed love as ambition for our advancement in whatever the task might be. In my grandpa’s last months, dad would help him walk the halls and encourage him to break his time record for the circuit. He stood at the side of the track with a stopwatch and at his own end, we counted steps from the chair to the elevator and back. Back in time to catch an SPCA ad about an abused dog we needed to save, a news story of injustice we needed to rectify, a Phillies game we needed to cheer, and ice cream in its simple glory we needed to savor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/685/1*oN_kqwnNsqD6FS4YjSSCOw.jpeg" /></figure><p>There was not a day of dad’s life, even at the end, where he didn’t find something to marvel at. He took eight-mile walks on the Schuylkill River long after others would have packed it in. He hiked the Rockies and the Appalachians easily and as often as he could. He marveled at savage and sublime landscapes and at the sky always. Back in the day, he ran and played tennis. He loved sunsets and clouds and trees and most of all, he loved Joan Friendly Goodman. She was his “Jonie Ponie” and he could never get enough of her company.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AeYijith-u4Yexo6qEOuzw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I am deeply grateful for this flawed, wonderful father. I am grateful for the America that enabled him to have the life he had. He loved all that was his and all that was on offer. He loved the Jewish people, he loved Harvard, he loved the Philadelphia sports teams, he loved America and the Democrats, he loved animals and mountains, and he loved fairness and justice. He loved us. He loved life. May his memory be a blessing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/526/1*T2CEBNnyxMRQM-Ry7kcdxQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8f59ba655be" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jewish Peoplehood on our Minds]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/jewish-peoplehood-on-our-minds-c006e17cb6bb?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c006e17cb6bb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[diaspora-jews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antisemetism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish-peoplehood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Nov 2025 16:59:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-03T01:44:05.121Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Ellen P. Goodman &amp; Leora Zabusky</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0LfibIgb_aFXkbY0IgIZGw.png" /><figcaption>Classic Menorah with Anemone — AI generated</figcaption></figure><p>Not long ago, we Jews unscrolled the Torah and began again at the beginning. We are the people of Israel, Am Yisrael. As we enter what — God willing — is a new chapter for Israel, for Gaza, and the whole region, we all have the chance to begin again. Will there be leadership in Israel capable of binding up the country’s divisions and finding a new covenant? Will Jewish values of <strong>life</strong> and <strong>justice</strong> overcome the evil impulse let loose among some of our people in Judea and Samaria/West Bank? Will Palestinians have leadership ready to capitalize on the immense worldwide support at their disposal to build towers instead of tunnels? Looking at each other across many time zones, emerging from these past two years battered and changed, how should Jews, Am Yisrael, here and there, po v’sham, think of each other going forward?</p><p>The two of us spent several months considering these questions as part of a diverse group of diaspora Jewish and Israeli leaders. The group was convened by the Jewish Federation of Philadelphia’s JCRC, and led by Meir Zimmerman and Jason Holtzman. We learned from each other, and also from some of today’s preeminent thought-leaders on these topics, including Yossi Klein Halevi, Mijal Bitton, Elana Stein Hein, Barak Sella, and others. Here are some of our takeaways:</p><p>1. A commitment to Jewish peoplehood and the responsibility of Jews to care for each other is a core feature of being a Jew. For most Jews, Zionism (self-determination for Jews among the other nations of the word) is an important expression of Jewish peoplehood. Western constructs put Jews into the box of “religion”, but Am Yisrael is a people, a nation. National sovereignty — to live as Jews with the means to perpetuate Jewish culture and preserve Jewish life is a right and responsibility. While Zionism is a term of rather recent vintage, remembering, yearning for, and rebuilding Zion is at the beating heart of our ancient traditions and daily prayers. This is a point that Harvard students <a href="https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/11/12/letter-ethicist-zionist-friends/">made beautifully</a> in response to a Harvard Crimson column that condoned “defriending” Zionists. Those students wrote: “Jewish practice is incomplete without a central connection to the Jewish national homeland… Israel and Judaism are inextricably and profoundly intertwined.”</p><p>2. And still, we must recognize that not all Jews are Zionists. Non-Zionist Jews do not center the traditional Jewish yearning for a return to Zion, or they distinguish that yearning from the political project that birthed Israel. The difficulty, as <a href="https://rachaelcerrotti.substack.com/p/a-conversation-with-harvard-researcher">Barak Sella</a> noted, is that whatever an individual Jew’s relationship is to Zion, the world associates Jews with Israel. This presents challenges even for Jews who share the basic aspirations of Zionism because there is growing daylight between how they understand these aspirations and certain facts on the ground in Zion. The complexity of these relationships between Diaspora Jews and Israel has pushed Jewish community-builders to consider a range of postures. These include, at the margins, ones that place Israel at the periphery of Jewish identity and community. More centrally, there is an understanding that Diaspora Jewish life must lean into diverse sources of identity and expressions of Jewish peoplehood and practice.</p><p>3. Many Diaspora Jews are reckoning with feelings of betrayal by their fellow citizens, friends, professional and social groups, and national leaders over the past two years. People have taken strong positions about Israel, its past, and its future in ways that seem uninformed or willfully blind to Jewish experience, pain, self-understanding, and safety. Polities and political projects to which Jews have been devoted have quickly allied with movements and language awash with antisemitic tropes. These projects disclaim Jew hatred, but the denials come off as “Jew-splaining” to many Jews who recognize the patterns in their kishkas. <a href="https://mijal.substack.com/">Dr. Mijal Biton</a> focused on how American Jews are trying to navigate a seismic shift in their sense of place. To understand this shift, Biton elaborated on two fundamental, complementary beliefs that shaped American Jewry post-1967: 1) Israel being at the center of Jewish moral and mythical imagination, and 2) American Jewish exceptionalism, whereby American Jews would escape the hate that every other diasporic community from Marrakesh to Munich has experienced. Both of these beliefs are being severely challenged.</p><p>4. Many Diaspora Jews are also reckoning with the sense that they are not seen by Israelis who have understandably been absorbed in their own tragedies. There have always been asymmetries in the relationship between Diaspora and Israeli Jews — Jews face Jerusalem. And so it is natural that Diaspora Jews would feel Israel’s pain deeply, but Israelis would background what is happening in Diaspora communities. While the asymmetry may be natural, it is a source of stress and constraint on mutual understanding.</p><p>5. Israel will rise or fall on its ability to resolve, or at least mitigate, the internal tensions that have grown too serious to survive. These are tensions around the values of the country, the nature of shared sacrifice, and the commitment to democratic norms and institutions. <a href="https://forward.com/forward-newsletters/looking-forward/539432/israel-protests-judicial-reform-democracy-halevi-yossi-klein-netanyahu/">Yossi Klein Halevi</a> emphasized how efforts to undermine Israel’s judiciary fractured the Zionist “mainstream” majority and sparked a crisis over the very meaning of democracy. Most of this work is for Israel to do, but Diaspora Jews and organizations will have an important role to play. As exemplified by this group, Israel will need to lean into discomfort and dialogue across difference.</p><p>6. Diaspora Jews will struggle to figure out what place Israel has in their schools, camps, synagogues, and other aspects of their Jewish communities. And these efforts will necessarily intersect with the work Israelis are doing to forge a new direction. If, as we hope, Israel becomes more deeply an Israel for <em>all </em>Israelis — Jewish and not — its connection to Jewish communities abroad will change. And if Diaspora Jewish communities are able to strengthen expressions of Jewish life that do not necessarily center Israel, that will also change the connection. For us, it seems obvious that Israel — home to more than half of the Jews in the world, the homeland of the Jewish people, the font of Hebrew language and culture — is necessarily core to Jewishness and Jewish national expression. But we know there are other views on this and we respect them. We also believe that for all Jews, it is imperative to identify a shared <em>ethical floor</em>, which <a href="https://hadran.org.il/beyond-the-daf/din-daf-setting-the-ethical-floor-the-ethical-ceiling/">Dr. Elana Stein Hain</a> identified as a basic least-common-denominator set of values or commitments that Jews share as a feature of their peoplehood.</p><p>7. As Diaspora Jews and Israelis move forward on their parallel and interconnected projects, they will need to look at each other full on …….פנים אל פנים……and build points of connection and support. Building those relationships must reach in both directions. With Israel’s acute need for healing from the war, compounded by the earlier and continuing internal division, Diaspora Jewry can support Israel’s rehabilitation and rebuilding. At the same time, Israelis need to do a better job of understanding and responding to the challenges of Diaspora life — generativity and joy, antisemitism and political alienation, exclusion and security risks, solidarity and internal division — and support efforts to find a common language and shared commitments.</p><p>8. There is no going back to what was — not for the Diaspora, not for Israel, and not for Am Yisrael. The relationship between Diaspora Jewish communities — or at least the American one — and Israel forged in the mid-20th century ended on October 7, 2023. In that preexisting paradigm, Israel supplied identity and pride and the Diaspora supplied resources and unconditional love. Many in the Diaspora never really understood or grappled with Israel’s startling complexities and contradictions, preferring instead to hold fast to a cherished, if simplistic, set of ideas. Similarly, most Israelis lack a full appreciation of Diaspora Jewish life and changing realities.</p><p>Dr. Sara Labaton evoked <a href="https://www.sefaria.org/sheets/183958?lang=bi">Rabbi Benne Lappe’s theory of Master Stories</a> in describing the current moment for Jews as a crash. The old narratives have crashed into crisis and new narratives must emerge. Jews survived the Roman destruction of the Second Temple and conquest of our land by building a narrative for a broken people around rabbinic Judaism. There was in that story an unshakable commitment to national cohesion across dispersion, and a longing for an ingathering in Zion. From Torah to Talmud, one lesson could not be more clear: <a href="https://www.sefaria.org/Yevamot.13b?lang=bi">lo titgodedu</a> — do not cut yourselves into factions. Kol Yisrael arevim zeh bazeh — all of Israel is responsible for each other. What new narratives will arise for Jews after 7 Oct.? How will we navigate new relationships among different parts and commitments without falling into irreconcilable factions? This is bridging work that divergent Diaspora Jews and Diaspora and Israeli Jews must do together. We didn’t get this far only to get this far. !לחיים</p><p>****************</p><p><em>Our participation in this program — distinguished by the depth and honesty of discussion — has profoundly impacted our thinking. As Jewish Diaspora communal leaders, we hope to bring our sharpened insights to our respective spheres of influence. May Philadelphia’s model serve as a template for other communities who want to engage across difference to redefine Diaspora-Israel relations and deepen Jewish life.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c006e17cb6bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AI Accelerationists Take the State: Trump’s OMB AI Memo]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/ai-accelerationists-take-the-state-trumps-omb-ai-memo-9e0c165f5805?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e0c165f5805</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[procurement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Apr 2025 22:40:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-17T22:40:34.980Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/706/1*g_PT7sjLNjfAXLlnpla0zw.png" /></figure><p>With its recently released 2025 OMB Memo on federal use and procurement of AI, <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/M-25-22-Driving-Efficient-Acquisition-of-Artificial-Intelligence-in-Government.pdf">Driving Efficient Acquisition of Artificial Intelligence in Government</a> (M-25–22), the Trump Administration all but erases the Biden Administration’s 2024 predecessor OMB Memo, <a href="https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/M-24-18-AI-Acquisition-Memorandum.pdf">Advancing the Responsible Acquisition of Artificial Intelligence in Government</a> (M-24–18).</p><p>Gone is any discussion of “responsibility” and the previously adopted testing requirements for “rights-impacting” and “safety-impacting” AI systems. Not surprisingly, gone are mentions of “equity” and “bias” and “environmental.” The Trump OMB Memo basically picks up where Trump 1 left off with AI policy, as if the intervening four years of AI policymaking and state capacity building had not happened — with one notable exception. The federal agency Chief AI Officers — a post that the Biden OMB Memo created — remain, although their duties have shifted from managing risk to speeding acquisition. <br> <br>I’ll get to some specifics after this general observation: The difference between the two OMB approaches is not just the U-turn on AI risk and harms. The Biden Administration adopted the theory of “<a href="https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3464203">procurement as policy</a>” (Deirdre Mulligan &amp; Ken Bamberger). Its OMB Memo sought to use the federal procurement power to shape the market for more trustworthy AI. If the government leveraged its purchases (as well as grants) to demand risk assessments, transparency, risk mitigation, and ongoing adversarial testing from its vendors, then those practices would become standard throughout the market for AI products and services. The Trump OMB Memo evinces very little interest in using procurement as policy. Given that OMB Director Russell Vought wants to make the federal government small enough to drown in a bathtub (approximating <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grover_Norquist">Grover Norquist’s</a> quote), he is not too interested in policy. Rather, the focus of his OMB Memo is almost exclusively on deploying AI systems faster, cheaper, and with favorable terms around IP and data. Still, there is a bit of policymaking in the Trump OMB Memo, maybe incidentally. It really seems to want to prevent vendors from locking the government into particular proprietary systems. To support competition, it pushes agencies to favor open model weight systems, open APIs, and interoperability and portability in system architectures. If most of the new OMB Memo is a rejection of what came before, this one piece is an amplification.</p><h3>NIST and Consensus Standard-Setting are Gone</h3><p><strong>Biden OMB Memo</strong>: It had required alignment with <a href="https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework">NIST’s 2024 AI Risk Management Framework</a> to ensure standardized risk assessment. The memo had also lifted up international standards, the formation of which NIST plays (or played) a leadership role.</p><p><strong>Trump OMB Memo:</strong> There is no requirement to follow NIST’s AI RMF; agencies are free to come up with their own performance standards. The whole emphasis is on performance, rather than risk. Performance standards are surely needed, given <a href="https://www.cs.princeton.edu/~arvindn/talks/MIT-STS-AI-snakeoil.pdf">how much AI doesn’t actually work</a> (Arvind Narayanan). But the sidelining of NIST is another example of this Administration’s squandering American soft power and state capacity. What NIST has to say about AI sociotechnical governance impacts the whole free world. The Trump OMB Memo ignores it.</p><h3>Equity, Civil Rights, Environmental Considerations Are Gone</h3><p><strong>Biden OMB Memo</strong>: The list of requirements for “rights-impacting” AI systems was long. In short, agencies had to ensure that vendors conducted risk and impact assessments and evaluations on an ongoing basis, conducted adversarial testing and red-teaming, and complied with various transparency and notice provisions. Many of these values were set forth in the 2022 <a href="https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/ostp/ai-bill-of-rights/">Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights</a> and in the 2023 <a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/11/01/2023-24283/safe-secure-and-trustworthy-development-and-use-of-artificial-intelligence">Executive Order on AI</a>. The Memo had also acknowledged that high energy consumption for compute was a consideration that agencies should take into account in making procurement decisions. .</p><p><strong>Trump OMB Memo: </strong>It mentions civil rights compliance, and expects agencies to reserve the right and have access to conduct evaluations as necessary. But that’s about it. It replaces the “rights-impacting” and “safety-impacting” typology of the Biden OMB Memo with the single term “high-impact AI.” Agencies are told to determine as best they can whether it’s a high-impact AI that they’re seeking and then let vendors know that they will have to meet additional transparency and impact assessment requirements. The term refers to:</p><blockquote>“AI with an output that serves as the primary basis for decisions or actions with legal, material, binding, or significant effect on: an individual or entity’s civil rights, civil liberties, or privacy; or an individual or entity’s access to education, housing, insurance, credit, employment, and other programs; or an individual or entity’s access to critical government resources or services; or human life, well-being; or critical infrastructure or public safety; or strategic assets or resources, including high-value property and information marked as sensitive or classified by the Federal Government.”</blockquote><h3>Generative AI Guidance is Gone</h3><p><strong>Biden OMB Memo:</strong> It had required agencies to make sure the generative AI systems they procured transmitted watermarks, metadata, and other provenance markers on possibly deceptive synthetic content. Those systems also had to provide information about training data, data labor, compute, model architecture, and relevant evaluations. And they would be contractually bound to make best efforts to filter out CSAM, NCII, and other toxic content.</p><p><strong>Trump OMB Memo:</strong> It will develop “playbooks” on GenAI, but otherwise doesn’t deal with it.</p><h3>Implications for Federal AI Deployment and the AI Market</h3><p>If the Trump OMB Memo is implemented, we can expect agencies to move fast in acquiring AI systems. They will be focused on cost and effectiveness, but not much on safety or harms. There may be a positive spillover from the OMB’s ostensible commitment to a competitive AI marketplace. If the federal government really favors smaller players, open model weights, and modular systems that pose less risk of lock-in, maybe new entrants will have a shot at big federal contracts. Among the <strong>many</strong> likely negative spillovers is the thing that <em>won’t</em> happen: a robust ecosystem of AI measurement and evaluation methods and standards. There’s <a href="https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/for-government-use-of-ai-what-gets-measured-gets-managed">widespread agreement that this has to get a lot better</a> if buyers are going to be able to compare systems and the public can trust that they work well and fairly. (Mathew Burtell &amp; Helen Toner). The Biden OMB Memo sought to turbocharge that development through federal demand. The Trump OMB Memo doesn’t ask for it and seems to view that kind of science as an obstacle to AI adoption.</p><p>The next shoe to drop will be the Trump Administration’s recission of Biden’s <a href="https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2024/10/24/memorandum-on-advancing-the-united-states-leadership-in-artificial-intelligence-harnessing-artificial-intelligence-to-fulfill-national-security-objectives-and-fostering-the-safety-security/">National Security AI Memo</a>. There too, the Biden Administration had sought to use the massive heft of federal demand to shape the market for trustworthy AI. Undoubtedly, the revision will trash that approach. There too, I suspect, the accelerationists will have their way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e0c165f5805" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tyranny. com: Technologies of Unreason]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/tyranny-com-technologies-of-unreason-f0a1feede076?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0a1feede076</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy-and-rule-of-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 19 Mar 2025 17:02:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-08T01:43:18.285Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CpkKbl6Ohr2vCZiVmFY-nA.png" /></figure><p><em>Hundt Family Lecture in Honor of Avi Soifer, Richardson Law School, Univ. of Hawaii 3/25 [forthcoming Hawaii Law Rev.]</em></p><p>I was invited to consider for this lecture <a href="https://www.abrahamlincolnonline.org/lincoln/speeches/lyceum.htm">Lincoln’s 1838 Lyceum Address entitled “The Perpetuation of our Political Institutions.”</a> Everyone will understand the relevance of his great speech that lambastes tyranny, warns of mobs, preaches reverence for rule of law, and worries about the fragility of the American republic. For nearly a decade, lovers of democracy have been anxiously citing Tim Snyder’s “On Tyranny” and checking off the steps on the slide down. Authoritarian slippage has come to seem more like a lurch as President Trump and his commissars explode all constraints on executive power, issue unconstitutional orders, and pardon January 6 militants, sending the message that violence in service of the leader is acceptable if not welcome.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></p><p>I could spend our time together lighting every strand of hair on fire cataloging the demolition of law and the corruption of our political institutions. But you know it already. Mindful of Avi Soifer’s great love of history and his work on Constitutional meaning in service of liberty and equality, I do want to ground this talk in the moment and meaning of Lincoln’s address to his Jacksonian audience. It was a time of roiling violence and lawlessness in American life, when it was not clear — least of all to Lincoln — whether the wildly ambitious and deeply compromised vision of the founders would be buried with them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/1*Waoxjf8OMpbc4CKvmnLpZA.png" /></figure><p>Today, as we approach the nation’s 250th birthday next year, we are mindful of how Benjamin Franklin replied when asked in Old City Philadelphia about the form of government the founders had just created: “A republic, …if you can keep it.” Has his skepticism been vindicated? This republic is founded on rule of law, with legal constraint binding up of a diverse and energetic populace. The insurrectionist in the Oval has moved with shock and awe to undo legal constraint. The flex of strength in the face of the law is the point. Legal constraints even where they remain simply cannot scale when a culture of impunity takes hold.</p><p>Culture is the subject of this talk, and particularly the transmission of culture through communications. The grip of law and political institutions, the exercise of small “r” republicanism is dependent on a supportive culture — something that Lincoln centers in his Lyceum Address. He alludes to the fact that that reverence for the law is a <em>demand side</em> proposition. The people have to want it. Virtue signaling in our public sphere can be obnoxious, but at least it bespeaks a cultural appreciation for virtue. By contrast, vice signaling — of the kind we saw this week in the joint session of Congress — celebrates a disdain for virtue, maybe that virtue is a sucker’s game. Communications technologies, I suggest, are central to what signals are amplified.</p><p>Trump has mastered each medium of communications starting with the tabloids through reality television, talk radio, and social media. It’s possible that each medium has made it harder for our political institutions to function. The rule of law exists, to use Henry Steele Commager’s term, in an “empire of reason.” Reason with a capital R is the centerpiece of Lincoln’s address. It is friend to science, antithetical to arbitrary power and chaos, mother of ordered liberty. Each communications technology promises to enlarge reason’s empire, but each has delivered only fitfully. Today’s media assaults us with what journalist <a href="https://www.404media.co/you-cant-post-your-way-out-of-fascism/">Janus Rose</a> has called “impenetrable nonsense” designed to get us “to post and seethe and doomscroll into the void”, to “overwhelm and paralyze.”</p><p>***</p><p>I will start my talk with a look at Lincoln’s Lyceum address and what it says about law, reason, and the mob. The heart of the talk is an argument that the communications technologies President Trump has mastered have increasingly worked to subordinate reason to passion, constructive compromise to performative obstruction, and ordered liberty to “mobocracy,” to use Lincoln’s term. I would add my word to that: “trollocracy.” Policymakers and citizens have always worried about these tendencies and sought ways to mitigate their effects. In fact, government policy can have only marginal impact in a free society. Whether we can nurture a culture that leverages communications technologies to support Reason, is the question I’ll end with.</p><h3>Part 1. Rule of Law Required</h3><p>In January of 1838, a 28-year-old Abraham Lincoln took the stage at the Young Men’s Lyceum in Springfield Illinois. He was a relative newcomer to Springfield in the early days of Van Buren’s presidency, which continued Andrew Jackson’s populist reign.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/694/1*q-vytCEuL_P4TvF-wHv4vQ.png" /></figure><p>In the eyes of Lincoln and his fellow Whigs, Andrew Jackson had desecrated the office. He was personally violent, a duelist who had engaged in gunfights and defied the Supreme Court in an extermination campaign against native Americans. Every day, there were street fights animated by ethnic hatreds and lynchings to put down the stirrings of African American liberation. Indeed, the 1830’s were probably the most violent time in American history outside of war.</p><p>The gangly lawyer and part time legislator rose to deliver his lecture only a year after the last of the founding fathers had passed away, with the death of James Madison. Lincoln began with a paean to the founders, who he said had bequeathed a legacy of “blessings” and “a political edifice of liberty and equal rights.” How would <em>this</em> generation, fallen as it was, sustain those blessings? From the start, Lincoln was engaging with Franklin’s provocation asking with evident fear how this now orphaned nation would perpetuate the American experiment in self government.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/645/1*EV6Rmf2gDKmoQIge9g2qfQ.png" /></figure><p>The fear was about “something of ill-omen, amongst us,” by which Lincoln meant “the increasing disregard for law which pervades the country; the growing disposition to substitute the wild and furious passions, in lieu of the sober judgment of Courts; and the worse than savage mobs, for the executive ministers of justice.”</p><p>On the minds of the Springfield audience would have been the recent murder in Illinois of Minister Elijah P. Lovejoy, a prominent abolitionist — the first lynching of this kind in the north. The mob had taken it upon themselves, as Lincoln put it, to “shoot editors” and “throw printing presses into rivers.” The leaders of that mob had just been acquitted by — I kid you not — a judge named Lawless.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/854/1*DRRRDo3TCS1I9l2fCCcaew.png" /></figure><p>Historians believe Lincoln’s audience would have had contempt for Lovejoy and agreed with that judgement. So Lincoln elevates two other episodes to make his point about the dangers of a “mobocracy.”</p><p>There had been a lynching in St. Louis of a mixed-race man named McIntosh. McIntosh had killed a cop and was awaiting what would probably have been a death sentence. A mob that could not wait for official sanction dragged the man from custody and set him on fire. The other episode concerned murders in Mississippi of gamblers. Describing this mob violence, Lincoln observed the strange fruit of the dead “literally dangling from the boughs of trees upon every roadside; and in numbers almost sufficient, to rival the native Spanish moss of the country.”</p><p>In telling these stories, Lincoln positions the mob and governmental or legal authority as distinct and contrary forces. Today, corruption of legal authority is happening in <em>collaboration</em> with the mob. A mobocracy need not take the form of people with pitchforks or bear spray. It can be online anons doxing the vulnerable or oppositional, or swarms of bots harassing people, even government officials, into silence. Rewards for intemperance plus virality can bring the physical mob to any place at any time. Think how bar fights and street spats are now content to be captured and monetized, and sometimes used to mobilize. When these techniques of conquest <em>cum</em> performance enter <em>into</em> government — when they influence or become governing tools — the mob merges with legitimate authority. There is then no clear line between a mobocracy and our political institutions.</p><p>In his address, Lincoln has 3 things to say about mobocracy:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/1*YfZ37gxW3W1JdXMYKjlj-A.png" /></figure><p>1. <strong>It metastasizes. </strong>“The lawless in spirit, are encouraged to become lawless in practice; and having been used to no restraint, but dread of punishment, they thus become, absolutely unrestrained. Having ever regarded Government as their deadliest bane, they make a jubilee of the suspension of its operations; and pray for nothing so much, as its total annihilation.”</p><p>Elon Musk’s DOGE is dismantling agencies with gleeful abandon. Musk is a man and not a mob, but he performs DOGE’s every move for his 200 million X followers using the mobocratic tools of inflammatory lies. The historian Quinn Slobodian identifies the anti-government sentiment in the Administration as having 3 sources: traditional anti-New Deal ideology; the private equity tactic of smash and grab; and what he calls “the extremely online world of anarchocapitalism and right-wing accelerationism.” Musk is an exemplar of this last category. The goal is not a smaller government. It is the annihilation of government as we know it, yielding to governance by AI and those who control it.</p><p><strong>2. The mob comes for you</strong>. The “mobocratic spirit” is uncontainable. Once it is loose, arbitrary power reaches for everyone. Says Lincoln: “The innocent, those who have ever set their faces against violations of law in every shape, alike with the guilty, fall victims to the ravages of mob law; and thus it goes on, step by step, till all the walls erected for the defense of the persons and property of individuals, are trodden down, and disregarded.”</p><p>The American Bar Association has tacitly recognized the mob’s omnivorousness in its <a href="https://www.americanbar.org/news/abanews/aba-news-archives/2025/02/aba-supports-the-rule-of-law/">unusual letter standing up for the rule of law</a>. Whatever your views on particular policies, it wrote, “no one wants their neighbor of family to be treated this way” — meaning subject to arbitrary exercises of power. Trump voters who have been summarily fired have found out the hard way that walls breached fall on them too.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/633/1*CXU9GwaEI_n4hily1q4ZsA.png" /></figure><p>3. <strong>The mob abets tyranny</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/641/1*kUTlesdWn6dQHzlCfXbIag.png" /></figure><p>In Lincoln’s telling, the mobocratic spirit sets itself against government capacity. When government is no match for the mob, and destructive passions are unleashed, a tyrant will arise to offer order. This will be “some man possessed of the loftiest genius, coupled with ambition sufficient to push it to its utmost stretch” for whom the difference between doing good and harm is as nothing, so long as the doing brings “distinction.”</p><p>Today, we’re seeing that the mobocratic spirit can <em>partner</em> with tyranny, not just precipitate it. Those who question the propriety of what Musk or others in the Trump Administration are doing, whether they are judges, elected officials, or bureaucrats, risk being harassed by online mobs or the govt. itself. This threat secures obedience perhaps not less than official sanction.</p><p>Concern over the mobocratic spirit is not isolated to the political Left. In his <a href="https://www.uscourts.gov/data-news/judiciary-news/2024/12/31/chief-justice-roberts-issues-2024-year-end-report">year-end report on the federal judiciary</a>, Chief Justice Roberts expressed alarm about the threats facing federal judges. He noted that “the volume of hostile threats and communications directed at judges has more than tripled over the past decade.” In the past five years alone, federal marshals “report that they have investigated more than 1,000 serious threats against federal judges.” The Chief Justice goes on to blame doxing, social media mis and disinformation, and foreign campaigns — sounding very much like critics on the Left. He complains of agents feeding “false information into the marketplace of ideas. For example, bots distort judicial decisions, using fake or exaggerated narratives to foment discord within our democracy.” He went on to write that “we must as a Nation publicize the risks and take all appropriate measures to stop them” for the sake of public confidence in judicial “processes and outcomes.”</p><p>What to do about the mob? Is it already too late? For Lincoln, the answer is upstream of politics. He prescribed that “the people” must “be united with each other, attached to the government and laws, and generally intelligent, to successfully frustrate [the tyrant’s] designs.” In Lincoln’s view, the only way to combat tyranny is to make reverence for the rule of law the civic creed.</p><p>Sanford Levinson, in his book Constitutional Faith, observes how this call was taken up in post-bellum America and animated the reborn nation. The creed lives on in the oaths that federal officers take to the constitutional order. Oaths and reverence surely meant something different in an America that treated oaths as sacred acts. And still we see today how many courageous feds are asserting the primacy of those oaths.</p><p>***</p><p>As every autocrat will tell you, rule of law and respect for political institutions are rather malleable phrases.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/1*YTwHcqzm06IXh2Aawx2nBA.png" /></figure><p>Avi pointed out to me that Rule of Law is an anagram for Awful Lore. Lincoln’s assassin thought that HE was the tyrant. After all, he had suspended habeas corpus, which most experts at the time and later did not think was within the President’s power. He censored the telegraph and imprisoned journalists in his prosecution of the Civil War. Lincoln has been hero to repressive as well as liberatory leaders. <a href="https://www.friendsofthelincolncollection.org/lincoln-lore/6804/">Opponents of the Civil Rights movement in the 1960’s leaned on the Lyceum speech </a>to push against “lawless” civil disobedience. In 1966, for example, Chicago Mayor Richard J. Daley quoted Lincoln in an effort to quell civil rights protesters. Earlier, Senator Joseph McCarthy had quoted the Lyceum Address’ warning about domestic threats as support for his anti-Communist crusade. We can acknowledge that Lincoln himself had a complicated relationship with the law… all to end up ushering in a new and better constitution. Who knows, maybe we have before us constitutional amendments and new births of freedom. Let us pray.</p><p>Lincoln closed his address with an elegiacal salute to the founders’ revolutionary passion. That passion did its work in the founding era, he says, but “it will in future be our enemy.” In place of the mob’s passion, Lincoln says “cold, calculating, unimpassioned reason” will defend the Republic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*KyqEOST50kYn55WQ8FayCA.png" /></figure><p>Appetite for and ability to reason would have to be inculcated, parented, educated into the citizenry. Let reverence for law, Lincoln says “be breathed by every American mother, to the lisping babe… — let it be taught in schools, in seminaries, and in colleges…let it be preached from the pulpit, proclaimed in legislative halls, and enforced in courts of justice.”</p><p>All this teaching and preaching builds demand for rule of law and attendant democratic deliberation. Good governance is downstream of culture. It’s notable that Lincoln gives this speech in a local voluntary association designed to foster learning and participation — the sort of place that delighted De Tocqueville. In his Democracy in America (also from the 1830’s), he wrote that such associations cultivated the practice of democracy for the American who plunges “into the wilderness of the New World with his Bible, a hatchet, and newspapers.”</p><h3>Part 2. The Demand-Side Problem</h3><p>Few would say that TikTok, X, BlueSky, YouTube, or Facebook are fostering an empire of reason. These platforms follow on predecessor technologies, each of which has worried critics that it would unfit the population for democratic self rule, or to use Lincoln’s language, that it would supplant reason with passion. And with each new technology, citizens and their representatives have tried to better align it with the requirements of a democratic republic. Notwithstanding these interventions, there really has never been the will or institutional commitment to support the cultural project Lincoln imagined.</p><p>Far from bathing us in cool reason, our communications systems evolved to promote ever hotter and more inflammatory exchanges of information. It has become easy to activate and assemble mobs, even if only on screens that average (depending on your demographic) 4–6 hours of daily attention. Social media pair hot takes with data-driven personalized messaging and addictive design to hack and <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/24/opinion/attention-economy-education.html">frack attention</a>. The frayed quality and polarized directions of our attention make it hard to imagine even a shared language around terms like “rule of law” or “political institutions.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/549/1*FOo90q5JiXIEylA-U1A5cg.png" /></figure><p>How did we get here? We might as well start with the year of the Lyceum speech, for it was in 1838 that Samuel Morse brought the telegraph to the U.S. Capitol in hopes of securing Congressional funding to develop the new technology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/577/1*-ozwQ2YmY57i8UMlpMDenw.png" /></figure><p>Morse acknowledged that the telegraph — like most technologies — was multivalent. In a letter to the Chairman of the House Commerce Committee, he wrote: “This mode of instantaneous communication must inevitably become an instrument of immense power, to be wielded for good or for evil, as it shall be properly or improperly directed.”</p><p>While Unionists initially thought the telegraph would bind the nation together, they soon discovered it exacerbated sectional tensions. Richard John in his book <em>Network Nation</em>, quotes a Unionist calling the telegraph a “’treacher’” which sends an “‘electric thrill of panic’” every hour after the transmission “of misleading news reports to the home front that had been sent by irresponsible journalists from the theater of war.” (108).</p><p>Western Union allied itself with the Associated Press — both monopolies in their domains — to furnish newspapers with news of the day. Between the two of them, they controlled the news and could also read private messages. Sort of like a digital platform can control a newsfeed and DMs.</p><p>In the razor thin Presidential Election of 1876, Western Union backed Rutherford Hayes. Apparently, Republican Hayes was losing to Democrat Tilden when the telegraph company provided Hayes with internal messages from Tilden’s campaign, helping Hayes to re-orient his efforts. Tim Wu in his book <em>The Master Switch </em>holds up this event as an example of how power over communications networks can confer political advantage — we might say it’s a synergy of tyranny.com and tyranny.gov.</p><p>The federal government would eventually regulate the telegraph as a common carrier to mitigate the effects of monopoly. On the newswire end, it wasn’t until 1945 in AP v. United States that the Supreme Court reined in AP for antitrust violations. Justice Black wrote one of the defining aspirations of American free speech jurisprudence in that case: what was necessary for a “free society” was to promote “the widest dissemination of information from diverse and antagonistic sources.” Cracking open tyranny.com was a way of preventing tyranny.gov.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/645/1*3Ebvgt8oUkM7G8espdrlcg.png" /></figure><p>Diverse and antagonistic voices include nonsense. The telegraph was a principal driver at the end of the 19th century of yellow journalism, named after this little yellow man cartoon.</p><p>Rival news magnates Joseph Pulitzer and William Randolph Hearst both used it, competing with each other in newspapers throughout the country with sensational false or unverified stories. Hearst was very much in favor of the U.S. going to war against Spain in the Caribbean.</p><p>So he transmitted conspiracies blaming the Spanish for blowing up the SS Maine to enflame the public. Fake news was nothing new. John Adams complained of it bitterly. What <em>was </em>new was the use of nationwide economic power to propagate lies. Yellow journalism coincided with a period of repeated economic shocks, monopoly growth, government corruption, mob violence in the Jim Crow south, and attacks against immigrants in the fast-industrializing north.</p><p>Reformers trained their eyes on media.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/627/1*7Sg5YDTRzC65huiXeBpy_w.png" /></figure><p>By the 1920’s, the media advertising model was mature and Edward Bernays, nephew of Sigmund Freud, published his pioneering work <em>Propaganda </em>on how to exploit human irrationality to sell cigarettes and politics. Accelerating social change stoked anxieties about democratic governance.</p><p>Walter Lippmann despaired of the public’s ability to manage their political affairs and favored heavy elite intermediation. Newspapers, he thought, should be subjected to technocratic control to ensure that people received carefully curated information.</p><p>John Dewey, took a different view, more aligned with Justice Black’s. People could be trusted to overcome their irrationality and low quality information, if only they had more civics and media literacy. This debate between elite direction, and bottom-up muddling through — albeit under the tutelage of the virtuous — continued to shape media policy over the next century.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/717/1*ZMJJ2xFxbKuBJI7Y-cqlZg.png" /></figure><p>By the 1930’s, with the spread of radio broadcasting, “yellow journalism” was more compelling as it streamed into people’s living rooms. This time, America Firsters were antiwar and the messaging viciously antisemitic and pro-fascist. Father Charles Coughlin reached about 1 in 3 Americans by the end of the decade (30 million). When he blamed Kristallnacht on its Jewish victims, some of the radio stations that had carried his sermons took a step back.</p><p>Major networks like NBC and CBS decided to ban paid political and religious programming altogether for a time, presaging the move of digital platforms in the 2020’s to experiment with deplatforming and selective algorithmic promotion. The “vibe shift” against Coughlin’s incitement in the 1930’s had much more effect, both because of the control broadcasters exercised and because of the regulatory pressure the newly constituted FCC (1934) could bring to bear.</p><p>The vibe turned decidedly after WWII. At least among elites, there was a return to something a little like Lincoln’s rhetoric. Having escaped the fascist and communist waves that swept Europe, the United States, it was argued, needed to set its sights on demand-side democracy. Communications again were a central part of this project.</p><p>Looking back, people understood the important role radio had played in promoting Hitler and his project in Germany. In the U.S., in addition to the Coughlin scourge, there was a hoax radio broadcast in 1938 that scared the bejesus out of Americans. Orson Welles had broadcast on CBS radio a fake play-by-play of a Martian invasion. It was so realistic and alarming as to sew panic among thousands of listeners. The government noted broadcasting’s power to make worlds and shape reactions. Seeing this, Henry Luce, CEO of the great Time-Life media empire, thought industry should get out ahead of possible regulation.</p><p>He sponsored a Commission of leading intellectuals, chaired by University of Chicago President Hutchins, to figure out what media should look like in the post-war era.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/643/1*-XBmTGrhhP0aB7jLY3eYOQ.png" /></figure><p>One of my mentors, the late legal scholar C. Edwin Baker wrote in 2007 that the Hutchins Commission report is ‘‘the most important, semiofficial, policy-oriented study of the mass media in U.S. history.’’</p><p>It articulated the social responsibility theory of the press which goes something like this: self-government requires a press that acts as the 4th Estate, independent from government, and committed to the service of truth. Very much echoing Lincoln’s prescription of cool reason, the Hutchins Commission imagined a press that provided dispassionate information without fear or favor in service of a self-governing citizenry. To fulfil this function, the press itself would have to exercise republican virtues and self-restraint in its own sphere.</p><p>Breaking the Watergate story and associated corruptions in the 1970’s might have marked peak social responsibility press. These were the years that produced lawyers like our honoree and our sponsor Reed Hundt. The social responsibility press, like many liberal commitments, posits the possibility of operating outside of politics and passion. It imagines that White House reports can collaborative on a press pool for basic facts, for example. That there is a distinction between fact and opinion is central not only to this conception of journalism, but also to law and democratic governance. When the White House exerts control over the press pool and shuns “unfriendlies,” it is attacking that basic distinction.</p><p>In any case, by the 1970’s, Americans’ attention was migrating to television entertainment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*pP2PEocWTftH0d347faeZA.png" /></figure><p>FCC Chairman Newton Minow famously had warned in 1961 that much of television was a “<a href="http://Television and the Public Interest">vast wasteland.</a>” He was focused on banal content. When the media scholar Marshall McLuhan wrote in 1964 that the “medium is the message,” he was arguing that content didn’t matter that much. More important for culture were the technical affordances of media and the ways in which they related to our rational faculties. Using Lincoln’s temperature metaphor, [and borrowing from the socialist Claude Levi Strauss,] McLuhan divided media into hot and cool. Hot media demand from us little cognitive work or reason. Cool media ask us to participate in the construction of meaning. Weirdly, he thought TV was a cool medium.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/811/1*4cjbhEcYlOHzGbkdsBVtFw.png" /></figure><p>Not so one of his students, Neil Postman. In his book Amusing Ourselves to Death, which is 40 years old this year, Postman essentially predicts the way someone like Trump will use a hot medium to take control. Very much in keeping with Lincoln’s Lyceum forecast, he writes that America will be conquered from within. “People will come to love their oppression, to adore the technologies that undo their capacities to think… what we love will ruin us.”</p><p>With nostalgia for a past era of patient discourse around oratory and print, Postman dates the decay to the telegraph, which created “a neighborhood of strangers and pointless quantity; a world of fragments and discontinuities.” (70). Historian Daniel Boorstin observed that television encouraged the production of “pseudo events” or meaningless happenings imbued with fake significance. Postman used the term “disinformation” <em>not </em>to mean intentionally false, but maybe something worse: beside the point, distracting, numbing.</p><p>Ultimately, Postman wrote, TV creates a “culture overwhelmed by irrelevance, incoherence, and impotence.” (76) One of his most incisive observations was that TV collapsed context, presenting events immediate and faraway, relevant and irrelevant, grave and trivial in a single flickering stream of images that discouraged discerning engagement.</p><p>These were President Reagan’s 1980’s and the spirit was deregulatory. These were Donald Trump’s 1980’s and the bywords were go-go and greed. These were the early days of an expansion of TV options with Fox, talk radio, and then cable channels. If there was a policy response to concerns about TV’s impact on democracy, it was to foster competition.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/534/1*swE3aeam_r__rWQAFBhfsw.png" /></figure><p>There continued to be tepid support for the Great Society project of public broadcasting. Ambitious in goals, if not in funding, the creation of a noncommercial broadcast network was responsive to another blue ribbon commission of luminaries, the Carnegie Commission. To this body, the author <a href="https://current.org/1966/09/e-b-whites-letter-to-carnegie-i-2/">E.B. White had written </a>that TV should “address itself to the ideal of excellence” through programs that “arouse our dreams” and a system of local stations capable of becoming — wait for it — “our Lyceum, our Chautauqua, . . . and our Camelot.” The hope was that hundreds of local stations spread out across the country from small towns and farm communities to big cities would produce programming and also convene in person public discourse. Reasoned inquiry — if not cold reason — was a core value.</p><p>One thing local and national public media always did well was to platform new voices and formats left out of the mainstream. Here we got the first reality television programming which would serve Donald Trump so well. Big bird and kids TV, science and documentary programming, and even some conservatives had their beginnings here. However much public and burgeoning commercial media might have advanced Justice Black’s ideal of diverse and antagonistic voices, this was nothing compared to what the early internet birthed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/731/1*lB_YaeLhghTzasQJ4v9fNw.png" /></figure><p>There are few people who know more about the 1996 Telecommunications Act than Reed Hundt, who as FCC Chairman was responsible for implementing it. Some combination of DARPA investments, Tim Berners-Lee, and the Act made the internet. Law fostered infrastructure development and liability shelters for digital intermediaries. When signing the law, President Clinton made a comment similar to what had been said on Capitol Hill about the telegraph. “We know the Information Age will bring blessings for our people and our country. But like most human blessings, we know the blessings will be mixed.” Like the Unionists, Clinton imagined the Information Superhighway would bring Americans together. “That same spirit of connection and communication is the driving force behind” this law. And with that, he handed the pen to the Information Superhighway’s champion, Al Gore, whose father, Senator Al Gore Sr., had sponsored the Interstate Highway Act.</p><p>The decade or so that followed was filled with tech optimism for what Douglas Rushkoff called “open source democracy” (2003). This was the Dewey dream: that internet-enabled communication and decentralization would advance democratic self rule. I never quite shared that optimism. I was more inclined to trust those like Evgeny Morozov who in 2011 in his book <em>Net Delusion </em>warned that autocrats and oligarchs would figure out how to capitalize on the technology. As soon as tech companies figured out how to build platforms that would engage people in a mostly passive media experience, the industry consolidated the telegraph’s one-to-one communication with the broadcaster’s reach. Add to that network effects and algorithms that enclosed people in particular corporate architectures, and the decentralized web of the early aughts was gone.</p><p>The Supreme Court last term in <a href="https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/603/22-277/">Moody v. Netchoice</a> continued to refer to social media platforms as the “modern public square,” gesturing towards that Dewey ideal. So it is that. But it sunders apart as much as it convenes. If television proved to be a fiery medium, social media communications are an inferno.</p><p>The social science around what exactly social media has done to our discourse and reasoning continues to evolve. Recent studies seem to confirm McLuhan’s insight that the technological affordances are most important. These include the tenor, speed, and amplification of content, as well as the mobilization of radicals and incentives for bad behavior. These features hack our attention in ways that undermine cool reason and abet mobocracy. I’m not suggestion that communications and culture alone explain our current moment. But it’s hard not to see that Trump, Musk, and those around them have turned internet “trolling” culture into a governance agenda. It is a trollocracy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/594/1*YhYgJKSFdNjnkLmkBrblOQ.png" /></figure><p>I’ll focus on three social media design features: (1) incentives; (2) amplification; and (3) mobs.</p><p><strong>Memes, Rage, Trolling &amp; LULZ</strong></p><p>If it once took significant investments from Orson Welles and CBS radio to fool the nation into believing it was under attack, digital media makes it trivially easy to concoct and spread lies that seem realistic, especially among those inclined to believe them. Viral content is more likely to be low quality, unverified, or flat out false. Postman noted “context collapse” in TV. It’s so much worse online with bits of audio or video flying around untethered to any context. Editorial standards, fact checking, and distinctions between news and opinion are simply not rewarded or even understood. Boorstin’s pseudo-events now constitute much of our politics with electeds and constituents alike performing for likes and shares.</p><p>As with previous technologies, the affordances of social media are multi-valent. One of the delights is meme culture. These visual jokes can wonderfully make light of and defuse difficult subjects. They can also swiftly convert subversive chuckles into radical positions. The new right has perfected the use of memes, “just joking,” and in it for the LULZ to valorize political violence, Nazi salutes, and violence against women and other “out groups.” Is it just a joke? Just Edgelord trolling? The media scholar Joan Donovan’s work on Meme Wars documents how memes and viral rage led the militia curious to pitchforks on January 6.</p><p>Trump is a master of meme culture. When he posts from the official White House site a picture of King Trump wearing a crown, he’s “just joking.” Or not. Not for nothing, Musk named DOGE after layers of memes: a meme coin named for an older meme of a Sheba Inu dog with broken English. Reverence for the rule of law requires first of all a sense of reverence. There are no sacred cows in meme culture. It is revolutionary or reactionary, but never reverent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/523/1*Ozp_Cc1t3N7kO7TbKSOHjA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Algorithms and Data</strong></p><p>Algorithmic amplification further intensifies angry communication. Leveraging personal data, platform recommender systems and feeds direct hot rhetoric to willing consumers. With this architecture, it is no wonder that the work of government becomes bite-sized rage performances. The Hutchins and Carnegie Commissions believed that communications companies should support self- governance. That might mean fair and serious news coverage or helping local communities to cohere. In the digital world, the entities with that power are the platform designers. They do not feel much responsibility, and in the past few months have been completely liberated from any vestige of the responsibility they did assume.</p><p>Rule of law ultimately relies on widespread acceptance of the legitimacy of the law. It relies on people accepting a sphere of neutrality in which equal application of the law is possible. Our digital platforms — by virtue of the power of influencers and algorithms — flood us with repeated assertions that things are not on the level. With context collapsed, you will easily see that the “other side” or “those people” are crooked. What you’ve been told is not true. If you believed in neutral principles, you were a sucker. These narratives spin out on both Left and Right: in the form of populist attacks on institutional authority and expertise, rejection of fair journalism, and illiberal ideologies. The result is an environment in which reasoned compromise gives way to zero-sum power struggle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*rFVcl_UaOty8ZNgNRkTwsQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Pile Ons and Mobs</strong></p><p>The last feature of social media brings us back most clearly to Lincoln’s fears. We love to feel that we are part of a tribe; that we are empowered to take action. The ability to rouse a following to a cause, and to join that cause, is one of the delicious affordances of social media. It’s what fueled the Iranian Twitter revolution in Iran in 2010 and the Ukranian Maidan revolution in 2014. Distinguishing a protest from a mob shouldn’t depend on whose side you’re on. As Lincoln used the word, mobs usurped the state’s legitimate monopoly on force. Online mobs rarely go this far, but they sometimes do. Just ask the Sandy Hook families. And they frequently <em>threaten</em> to. At the very least, for most people, being harassed, doxed, and lied about will quickly silence their diverse and antagonistic voices.</p><p>In his first administration, Trump brought the online pile into the White House, calling out particular people for MAGA harassment. Those practices are now much more widespread. Lawmakers fear that mobs will be directed to their houses, as Justice Roberts was afraid for his colleagues. We can only wonder whether online mob culture has softened the ground for mob actions in the government. Uncredentialed DOGE functionaries exercising illegitimate authority is arbitrary power — cousin to the mob.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/478/1*pyItpdVcqtF1YQsBMl0EdA.png" /></figure><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Let me take you back to the Lyceum Address as we close. One of the rhetorical moves Lincoln makes in his Address is to tell the stories of the mob twice: once in a way that makes the victims of mob violence sympathetic and once much less so. For example, in the second telling, he says the Mississippi gamblers were “worse than useless in any community” like “plague or small pox.” By doing this, he’s challenging his audience to distinguish policy from process. Even if you agree with the policy outcomes of the mob, you surely can’t condone the lawless process. This is what the ABA was saying in its letter. Patience is required for rule of law. The mob that lynched McIntosh could not wait for justice. And this is why the Trump Administration does not use its compliant Congress to pass laws. It uses the tools and temperament of the mob, and the troll.</p><p>Where rule of law requires patience, our communications privilege immediacy. Where ordered liberty makes distinctions between proof and conjecture, political and legal, gangster and government, our communications collapse categories and context. This collapse then manifests in Washington D.C.</p><p>Dorothy Thompson wrote in 1938 just after Welles’ War of the Worlds broadcast: “The greatest organizers of mass hysterias and mass delusions today are states using the radio to excite terrors, incite hatreds, inflame masses, … abolish reason and maintain themselves in power.” (Jill Lepore, These Truths, 470). What Welles had done was just performance art. The real threat is the fascist use of media. When government itself is the performer capitalizing on mass hysteria and delusions, a democratic culture must resist.</p><p>I wish I had a list of 10 correctives for our media culture, something like Tim Snyder’s list in reverse. There are a lot of good design ideas out there about how to build better social media, how to reduce the control of algorithms and the logic of big tech, how to cultivate better information sharing hygiene and literacy especially in the AI age. Some of these involve law and policy, but this seems hardly the moment.</p><p>There are also good ideas that are much older than that, about building democratic culture in real places like the Lyceum.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*EYxF6s04a9oheUcTi90wxg.png" /></figure><p>In the early 19th c, there were 3000 Lyceums scattered in towns across a much smaller U.S. There’s a movement now to bring them back. Touch grass. Whatever the distribution method, we should take seriously the demand side of rule of law and reasoned discourse. As Lincoln knew, storytelling is at the heart of the matter. Lincoln’s lessons that the mob metastasizes, it comes for you, and it abets tyranny all have to be brought home in actual stories. These are stories about the corrupt prosecution, the shuttered federal service, the crooked contract diffused through every medium and using all affordances. That used to be the job of journalists, and it still is, but it’s the job now of everyone.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0a1feede076" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jon Blake: Mentor, Friend, Law Partner. 1939–2024.]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/jon-blake-mentor-friend-law-partner-1939-2024-016d5220d47d?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/016d5220d47d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[in-memoriam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mentorship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law-firm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 May 2024 01:45:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-29T01:45:06.902Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>May his memory be a blessing.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nuOwsy9JGpgocH5AcKqwGg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jon Blake retired from Covington &amp; Burling and set his sights on reforming the Electoral College. He didn’t live to see it happen, but it will happen, as with everything that Jon willed into being.</p><p>You can Google Jon Blake and you won’t find too much. He was Covington &amp; Burling’s managing partner for a decade, steering the firm through the opening of new offices and its transition to a 21st century multinational business, without losing its early 20th century professional ethics or intellectual ambitions. He won an Emmy for guiding the broadcast industry’s transition to digital. He helped create the cellular and commercial satellite industries and earlier save the Washington Post’s television stations from a vengeful President. But you won’t find many of the details because Jon stood behind, and often under the crushing weight, of the firm’s clients (he would never say his). In fact, Jon led certain clients to where they didn’t know they wanted to be and assembled groups of them to get there all together. That was the soccer coach in him. I could go on forever talking about Jon’s achievements as the preeminent communications lawyer of his time, of his deft advising those who generally brook no counsel, of his graceful writing and sharp strategizing, of the lyrical and deeply appreciative way he saw people who are invisible to many in his position. But I want to write about what Jon was to me.</p><p>I sit with a redweld folder of the kind Jon would carry tucked under an arm around the firm.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/224/1*hHb6kZOsZvkRoh16KPTt0Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mostly I see him in the firm as I knew it on Pennsylvania Avenue with long halls of hardwood under Persian rugs, grandfather clocks, and sparkling brass.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/210/1*aWPDnqhUYi75CfZC_rquXA.png" /></figure><p>He would carry the redweld, or sometimes just a cream-colored legal pad, as he covered ground, commenting on the baby picture on an assistant’s desk or telling a funny story about the provenance of a print on the wall. Grabbing a cab to a meeting across town, he would tuck the redweld under his arm and fold his runner’s body into whatever was the least comfortable seat, coatless like John F. Kennedy. In <em>my</em> folder are a decade’s worth (1993–2003) of Jon’s hand-written notes, typed musings, routing slips, and cards from my time at the firm, first as a star-struck associate and then as a young partner. In the two decades after I left the firm, Jon and I continued to correspond, but those letters are much more likely to be emails. There’s something just so Jon about his longhand racing across the page fluently with nary a correction that this scoping seems right.</p><p>These cherished papers sparkle with Jon’s life of letters: “I must tell you of a recent book about Lincoln concerning his liberalism — melding Adams’ and Jefferson’s — and his religious tradition from New England.” Alongside the generous comment about a co-worker’s shining moment or self-effacing confession or error, there are cultural allusions — always casual and never pretentious — describing an interaction as a “Thomas Hardy coincidence” and a lawyer as the “Giotto” of email. He appreciates religious traditions, while acknowledging that he consciously adheres to none. Of my Jewish faith, he is solicitous of the holidays and attentive to the strains of Shabbat observance. Long after I have forgotten, he reminds me of what I once told him of Tzelofechad’s daughters (the daughters who insist on their property rights).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/204/1*bShSZ4UvKwn1ZHtendo7lg.jpeg" /></figure><p>In response to my description of a raucous and combative family seder, he wrote that he would have liked to be a fly on the wall, and this is probably exactly what he meant, because for all his obsidian forcefulness on matters of client service and loyal friendship, he is shy and happier in the background.</p><p>Jon worked very hard. People frequently applied the word “prodigious” to him; some may have used “workaholic.” His voicemail provided his home number, before there were cell phones (which, again, he made happen), and encouraged calls at all hours. “Really, I don’t mind,” he’d say. But he never expected others to keep those hours. He was committed to a professional tradition of excellence and what he called “ethical, honorable, and winning” performance instantiated in the “perfect brief.” He recognized the “difficult practical problems” with the insistence on work-life balance alongside professional excellence. He did not want the “hard but rewarding apprenticeship of learning the practice — an apprenticeship that goes on and on — to be compromised in its essential rigor.” At the same time, Jon wrote that firms need “to provide room for lawyers’ personal lives.” It seems obvious now, but not every senior partner spoke this way.</p><p>Jon drove hard to be very, if not perfectly, responsive to clients and colleagues. Was it from him that I learned to respond to every call or email within 24 hours and to manage deadlines such that if there a delay, there would never be a surprise? He also respected commitments and passions far from the law office. He knew who was trying to write a novel, run a marathon, raise a child, learn a language, care for a parent. Jon knew that, though <em>he</em> managed to balance an intellectual life, five children, sports, friends, travel, culture, timely billing (which he hated), and tireless work, most of us struggled. I could not hide feelings of inadequacy, guilt, and perfectionism. Jon was similar in this regard. Once he wrote “let’s just stipulate to our mutual feelings of unworthiness.” Still, he ventured to counsel me on “how to cope with overwork: (1) self-diagnosis; (2) confide in others; (3) shift work; (4) minimize self-imposed pressure; (5) keep eyes on task at hand; and (6) maintain a sense of fun.” He urged me always to keep in mind the greats of the firm and the unbroken tradition of integrity, quality work, and personal relationships. “Allow yourself to acknowledge that you serve an ever growing adhesive function” in these respects.</p><p>If we’re honest, Jon didn’t always take his own advice. I can’t presume to know how balanced his life was, but I know he slept very little. He acknowledged this:</p><blockquote>“You gently chided me for setting an example as Chair of being too work-driven. It was inconsistent with the humanity of the place that I said I cherished. I said: ‘Can’t I be the warrior that loves peace and does battle to gain it?’ I came across a quote that goes to your point and suggests my current challenge. ‘War makes men barbarous because to take part in it, one must harden oneself against all regret, all appreciation of delicacy and sensitive values. One must live as if these values did not exist and when the war is over, one has lost the resilience to return to those values.’ So, now my task, amidst others pointing in the opposite direction, is to return to a more balanced regimen.”</blockquote><p>So he tried and sometimes failed and tried again to balance one enthusiasm with another. Jon went all the way on everything. The visage of Jonathan Dewey Blake might have illustrated the dictum of Ralph Waldo Emerson: “When you do a thing, do it with all your might. Put your whole soul into it. Stamp it with your own personality. Be active, be energetic, be enthusiastic and faithful, and you will accomplish your object.”</p><p>One was always a little breathless trying to keep up with him. The saving grace was that he saw this. In my redweld are dozens of notes showing consideration for how tough it could be. He saw the invisible work, and frankly often the woman’s work, of meticulously checking pleading mailing lists and preparing exhibit binders as we did. He wrote when I was pregnant with my first child that he and other partners “worry about calibrating our demand with your supply, while at the same time being appreciative and often in awe. The one way we can, at the least, express our gratitude is to be sensitive to your pressures — professional and personal. Please, please keep us posted.”</p><p>Gratitude was a constant theme of Jon’s notes. Gratitude for his family, and especially for his wife Liz.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tQ8lNQVlQGICXrg6VIoznA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Gratitude for his firm teachers and honorable management committee colleagues. Gratitude for the clients who — at least in his telling — were summiting mountains they had themselves willed into existence. So many thanks he offered, some of which he would codify in his routine “kudos reports” on the good work of practice group lawyers, paralegals, and assistants. In one note to me, Jon expressed thanks on “three levels” for my effort with a client. He spoke in the same paragraphs he wrote with a roadmap of enumerated points, which perhaps was a skill born of dictating memos. “What I owe you for your assistance and encouragement, for your commitment to the highest standards and values and for your friendship cannot be measured or recorded. It subsides into an affection and admiration that I ask that you always keep in your hip pocket — ready for use when you need it.” And how I have needed it!</p><p>Jon charmed everyone. Like an Impressionist painter, he rendered ordinary tasks with romantic wonder. After he became ill, he would write of sitting for hours during treatment and being so “tickled” to learn of Nurse x who immigrated from country y and whose son wanted to become a chef and how Jon had put the young man in touch with z, but the real point was that Nurse x was so capable and Jon could see how she rebounded from prejudice and slights and was the heroine of the clinic. Heroes abounded in Jon’s life. There is not a single note of Jon’s that is mundane and few that fail to credit someone for something wonderful. Even if it’s about lobbying meetings or contract negotiations, there is usually an aside about an historic drama or storied locale. Here are just some of the places that Jon loved and brought to life on legal pad paper.</p><p><strong><em>· </em>Washington</strong>: “As I ran home tonight in the warm rain to soften the edges of my fatigue, there came into alignment just north of the Mayflower on Connecticut Ave., place, memory, and present circumstances. From nowhere, I remembered a night maybe 9 years ago when in that same place a tall handsome man, maybe 30 years old and dressed in white tie and tails, stopped me and asked if I would like him to sing me a song. ‘Melancholy or jubilation’, he asked. I chose jubilation and he sang proudly and well.”</p><p>· <strong>Deerfield Academy</strong>: Jon remembered an old classmate Al who attended Deerfield Academy with him. Jon had a soft spot for the misfits, because he so often felt himself to be on the margins. Al had another quality Jon loved, which was that he overcame and shined. “The only thing more incongruous than his going to Deerfield was that he later represented the Beatles.” Al’s father, a Russian Jewish immigrant, “wanted his son to live the American dream — shades of Calvin Trillin” and so sent Al to school wherever the boss’s son went. That turned out to be Deerfield, which at the time “was pretty obscure and still poor. There were no fire escapes. If you had a second floor room, it was equipped with a knotted rope, tied at one end to the radiator.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/275/1*itPu6IWNYTRBbcGNijGX1w.jpeg" /></figure><p>In another letter, Jon wrote of “poking around in a bookstore” on his vacation in Maine and happening upon a 1937 book written as part of a New Deal program. It chronicled the town of Deerfield, where there had been massacres when Deerfield was an American “frontier” town. The description went as follows: “’The ghost of a town, its dimness almost transparent, its quiet almost a cessation, it is probably the most beautiful ghost of its kind, and with the deepest and most poetic significance to be found in America.’”</p><p>· <strong>New Hampshire</strong>: This is the beginning of a portrait of Rockywold/Deep Haven where Jon’s family vacationed. “One hundred years ago, two unmarried New England ladies — who spent their adult lives teaching in Black schools in North Carolina, were pantheists, and were regarded as eccentric by their friends and dotty by their critics — formed a little family camp on a modest point jutting into Squam Lake under Rattlesnake Mountain… The lake is very deep, clear and sand-bottomed, almost unheard of in New England. At dawn and dusk especially, it echoes with the sound of loons.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/312/1*sIUOBubAK0xoK5Yj1RBtbg.jpeg" /></figure><p>· <strong>Maine</strong>: “There cannot be a more beautiful library than Squirrel Island’s. It sits in a stand of White Birches, wild roses — pink on white — sprawling artlessly here and there and its shingled exterior looking as if it had grown organically in place. In two weeks, it celebrates its 100th anniversary, and the Ladies Improvement Society (I could not make up such a name) is planning a celebration.”</p><p>· <strong>England</strong>: “There’s a dip in the road on the way to Cornwall, a place called Little Petherick, I think. It is nothing special, a stream, a perfectly situated tree overhanging where it widens out into a small pond… I have never crossed that bridge without thinking that Hitler would never have overcome the Englishman’s love of his land. Of course, that’s wrong, although Cornwall was rarely vanquished in all the waves of migration and invasion, and to this day its festivals are pagan without so much as a veneer of Christianity.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/245/1*BefYox3hxVlVVVunjVPRXg.jpeg" /></figure><p>About nothing was Jon more of a romantic than he was about the firm. If a law firm can be a main character, a holy principle, a destiny and moral obligation, Covington &amp; Burling was that and more for Jon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/367/1*iuXWE76UQMWhiLNDtL_B_A.png" /></figure><p>He started his career there in 1964, before I was born. He didn’t clerk, though he had the perfect pedigree in those days for all the fanciest clerkships. He didn’t go into the government, though many of his colleagues were in and out of high service in federal offices and Jon easily could have been as well. From the start, he had a family to support. He had a firm to serve and grow.</p><p>He felt he was the steward of a great tradition handed down from Judge Covington and Mr. Burling to represent clients and the legal profession with flair, integrity, and excellence. Not excellent sometimes. Not sort of excellent. Before his time, Jon understood that including people of different backgrounds with different kinds of strengths is what would enable the practice of law at the highest level. He loved all the firsts — the first Black partner in this, the first female leader in that — and also Covington’s long tradition of valuing the brilliant legal analyst who could barely look someone in the eye alongside the super social rainmaker alongside the first generation professional who never dropped a ball.</p><p>It was to sports that Jon frequently analogized both the struggles of law practice and the satisfactions of teamwork. In one letter confessing his exhaustion and self-doubt, Jon drew on his past as a college track star. He said he felt like he was in the second half mile of a two mile race. “You can’t imagine keeping up the pace for a whole mile more. The other guy seems fresh and confident and your gut and your quads are burning. You try not to think of the laps to come or how far the other side of the track seems to be. You know that, at all costs, you cannot lose touch with the leaders if you hope to beat them at the end.”</p><p>In another letter, Jon wrote about his feelings about being asked to extend his service on the Management Committee when he had other personal and work objectives. “I want a respite from making hard decisions that are consequential for people I care about. I hated having to run another lap beyond the promised finish line. Still, there is such pleasure to be gained from our special and splendid people…They have insights that dazzle, determination that awes, zest that infects, and a sweetness of nature that affects me like the first log fire of the fall.”</p><p>Jon also played football. In one of his congratulatory letters about a project well done, he wrote 200 words on how the quarterback and end must be in perfect silent communication, with knowledge of angles, and velocities, and cuts, and attacks. Needless to say, Jon was the quarterback on the field. And just as predictably, he gave that role to me in the writing: “Every time I cut, there was the ball you had thrown me ready to be caught. Just as there are many kinds of passes, I received the Board resolutions, checklists, rationales, power points, edits.” For me and many other young lawyers, Jon’s praise ennobled the practice of law. He made one feel one was in the arena.</p><p>If I had Jon Blake’s mind, I might have flattered him with an excerpt from a Yeats poem that describes his effect on a room. In fact, the passage is one that Jon surfaced to describe conduct he admired: “We can make our minds so like still water that beings gather about us that they may see, it may be, their own images and so live for a moment, with a clearer, perhaps even a much fiercer, light because of our quiet.”</p><p>Jon was indeed often quiet. His volume was inversely related to his resolve. In another of his pitch perfect summoning of literary greats, Jon quoted Raymond Chandler after a very difficult set of meetings: “That’s the difference between a champ and a knife-thrower. The champ may have lost his stuff temporarily or permanently, he can’t be sure. But when he can no longer throw the high hard one, he throws his heart instead. He throws something.” Jon kept throwing his heart and more until the day he died. It was more than 15 years, if I’m not mistaken, from his prognosis of only a few.</p><p>In preparing an 80th anniversary note to the firm in 1998, it seemed that Jon had collected observations from early firm partners. Among them were from two of the greats: John Lord O’Brian and Tommy Austern. You can see what Jon treasured by what he treasured in them. O’Brian, whom Jon would only refer to as Mr. O’Brian, writes of going to the Supreme Court and seeing Chief Justice Edward Douglass White, the devoutly Catholic Confederate soldier of yore, sitting beside Oliver Wendell Holmes, the agnostic Union soldier. “You could see those old fellows start home at night, arm in arm — they used to walk a half-dozen blocks every night. It was quite a sight. It was quite a lesson in what the word ‘tolerance’ means.”</p><p>This virtue of tolerance to which Jon was so committed makes another appearance in Mr. O’Brian’s description of “the intimate relationship [between lawyer and client] of patience and tolerance.” Then we see the next generations carrying the baton. Jon quotes from Austern recalling meeting Mr. O’Brian “in the Fall of 1930, when I was privileged to hear him argue with Justice Holmes as to whether William or Henry James was more profound.” These firm luminaries walked beside Mr. Blake, who wrote “I’d give a lot to know who took which side.”</p><p>On Jon’s telling, Covington was an unusually tolerant place. Whether this is true or not doesn’t matter to me. It was Jon’s truth and so it became mine: “I love our firm because it enables many of us who are diffident or different to come together as a professional community. Common purpose allows us to cross the boundaries of our personalities, while (at our best) respecting others’ individuality.”</p><p>One of the themes of our correspondence was my Hamlet-esque indecision about staying at the firm or leaving. There were a few opportunities I wanted to take, maybe because I couldn’t see myself at the firm for the long haul or maybe because I didn’t trust that I was good enough. Jon urged me to read Beatrix Potter’s “The Fierce Bad Rabbit.” Lean into leadership. Value humility, but not excessively. He tried ceaselessly to promote me and give me confidence. “If you think I can recede from a project, please let me know. You are ready to soar higher, more frequently.” He wrote this in a card picturing a girl playing a saxophone “You are entitled to blow your own horn if only quietly and to yourself.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/379/1*Lxg8oEIolyx4CGJXy27yiQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Though I did end up leaving the firm eventually, my path was forever changed by his encouragement. In a letter resigning my partnership, I wrote of meeting “that force of nature, that storm of creativity and care, Jon Blake.” I recalled being a first year associate with a half-baked idea that I hesitated to share. Walking home from the office at night, stewing, I stopped at “a payphone and left Jon a message. The next day, he had mobilized around the idea. He called the client, he started me writing. It was a transformative moment for me. Jon often said that his philosophy of leadership can be distilled into one objective: the nurturing of individual potential.”</p><p>My friendship with Jon continued long after I moved away, as did his mentorship in professional and personal matters. In both areas, he was hesitant to interfere. Imagine a senior partner writing a cover note to a junior associate with a marked-up pleading: “The great majority of these changes are suggestions only…I am not at all sure that the suggestion is an improvement and I leave it to you to decide.”</p><p>So sensitive was he about overstepping or being presumptuous that Jon tended to advise in a roundabout way. This is one reason he was a singularly talented counselor. Noting, for example, the similarities between what I was struggling with and managing the firm, he wrote: “despite professed realism going in which we need to camouflage a certain romanticism, the challenges are harder than we each thought, requiring more self-abnegation and calculations that are razor thin in their margins for error. Crafting compromises is more difficult than we anticipated; our lot is more tiring and more lonely. Trying really hard, caring really a lot is not enough.” Then he offered observations to help with both of our challenges:</p><p>- “when one in a partnership is angry or aggressive, it is often because he or she is hurt or scared and not always at the hands of the other.”</p><p>- “restraint is the wise man’s antidote.”</p><p>- “smart really quick people need to be careful about what they say; a miscalculation so easily can cross the line into injury.”</p><p>- “It is worth it<strong>.</strong>” (I don’t remember Jon’s using exclamation points. He didn’t need them. But if he had, I believe “it is worth it” would have had them and been in all caps and bold. So much was “worth it” to him).</p><p>Many people knew Jon. They may have gone to school with him, worked with him, competed in the Price Moot Court competitions he judged, played tennis against or with him, etc. I bet every single one of these people will say that they’ve never known anyone like him and, what’s more, that they don’t make them like Jon anymore.</p><p>I know he is absolutely singular for me. He was easily moved, endlessly curious, and he remembered everything. He could turn a story about one of his daughter’s skinned knees into a mediation on resilience and hapless parenting and bonding over failure and strength. Not only that, but he would know the name of the flower that grew up in the bush that scraped his girl and the history of the rocky mound on which it happened. And he’ll tell it all with a sparkle in his eye and a sly smile, aware that the story is charming, but wearing it ever so lightly. Jon was my family. Second only to my parents, he wanted to hear about my achievements and rage in his restrained way about the losses. He was fiercely and totally “on side.” From the start, Jon invited me into a collaboration and allowed me to think with him. He’s now so much a part of everything I am and do and think, that collaboration will last the rest of my life. The enthusiasms of Jon Blake will never, I think, be exhausted.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=016d5220d47d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Kaddish]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/my-kaddish-5c7a55cc681d?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5c7a55cc681d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[terror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaza]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Oct 2023 15:12:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-20T22:57:55.916Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/402/1*yvSa3UcUiMgU7WtHSNJdng.png" /></figure><p>Days of mourning. Days of rage. Days of trying to work and thinking about 200 hostages in Gaza and what might have become of them. Even as I write, I feel the stabs of critique: “well what about the thousands of Palestinians in Gaza fleeing their homes?” “what about the occupation in the West Bank and the settler violence?” I hold that pain too. I hold it and have been holding it. I want to write without links, if that’s ok, because I don’t want to stop to provide support. Everything is easy to find and most people know it anyway, and this is not a polemic. It’s a wail.</p><p>I’m a Jew. I’m ricocheting between the experience of my Israeli friends and family and the experience of us here in America. Those experiences are both intertwined and totally distinct. As are the experiences of American Jews and the Americans we thought were our allies in the struggle for tikun olam/social justice.</p><p>I have been fighting alongside my Israeli brothers and sisters opposed to this horrible Bibi government: fighting for a shared society for everyone. It has been 10 months of protests mostly in Israel, but also here, against settler fanaticism and illiberal fiats. For me, and for many Israelis, the continuing West Bank occupation (kibush — conquest) was a core part of the problem. Two states for two people remained possible, we hoped. We are the types who have supported co-existence between Palestinians and Jews, peace, mutual understanding, and all that. We are the types who rejoiced in 2005 when Israel evacuated its settlements from Gaza, even at the end of a gun. And we thought the recent infusion of money, even though controlled by Hamas, and easing of the border controls between Gaza and Israel was all to the good.</p><p>In Israel, after the massacres of October 7, the mourning and shock is viscous and all encompassing. The fear is existential — that terrorists overran their defenses and murdered with zeal and that Iran, Hezbollah, and others are ready to pounce raises the specter again of anihilation. I watch Israeli TV and there are survivor stories of sadistic torture and also of unbelievable bravery. There is constant discussion of betrayal: betrayal of the social contract to protect, betrayal of the Palestinians who came from Gaza to work and ended up gathering intel and coming back to slaughter. And then there are all the faces of the kidnapped and the weeping and red-eyed determination of the hostage families.</p><p>I think my Israeli family needs the stories of the heroes especially. Their identity is bound up in NOT being vulnerable to pogroms. That was the old country. Those Jews couldn’t defend themselves. For a long time, no one wanted to talk about the Holocaust because there was a completely undeserved sense of shame that the victims didn’t resist more (the Warsaw Ghetto warriors, one could speak of). So it’s important to focus on the “gevirut” — the heroism exhibited on October 7. While the state and the awful government and a million other things failed that day, the people were as valiant as Israeli self-image needed them to be. Those people included Palestinians and Bedouin who saved and died. Do the mourning Israelis think about the endangered and innocent Palestinians in Gaza? Yes. They should not be targeted. But the mourning and anxiety and sense of being vulnerable to further attack overwhelms humanitarian concerns. That’s my sense.</p><p>I am with Israel, feeling all those feelings, understanding what it means when they say “we have no other land.” This was the source of the fierce protests for most of the last year, week after week, hundreds of thousands in the streets. “Ayn lanu eretz acheret” — we have no other land — is the antithesis of being colonists. There is no mother ship to turn back to. This is it.</p><p>At the same time, I am here in America. What for us has been shattered? The notion that we’re safe. The confidence that we’re not hated. I told a friend that there’s this thing Jews do, so deep is the trauma of the Holocaust and expulsions and pogroms that sent our families here. We think, often dream, about being chased by Nazis (usually) or maybe Cossacks. And we wonder who around us would hide or save us. It has to do with having been butchered or given up by neighbors and fellow citizens, colleagues and friends. So who can we trust? Who would take a risk for us? We think about how long we could run and how we would survive. I’m sure not every Jew does this, but it’s very common.</p><p>I thought a few things were true. 1. That the opposition to the occupation, which I share, is about the West Bank. That’s where the apartheid or proto-apartheid or whatever one might call the injustice is, not within Israel where all citizens have political rights. 2. Allies for progressive causes did not support “death to the Jews.” We have been shaken awake — awoken — in the past week. Perhaps it’s a small segment, but it’s a very voluble segment, of our progressive allies have made it clear that we were wrong about 1. They think the attack on Israelis (Jews and non-Jews) within the Green Line — just basic small Israel — is part of a righteous process to eliminate Israel ANYWHERE. The thing is, sanctioning the maximalist claims of Hamas is essentially an endorsement of its genocidal mandate. Israel won’t surrender. We are ever farther from a “Free Palestine” and the prospects for a peaceful settlement of a still unfinished war. I feel such grief — for my hopes for peace as well as for what’s happened. About 2., I don’t need to say too much. Should we believe that when masses of protesters yell “there is only one solution, intifada revolution” that they didn’t choose “one solution” on purpose?</p><p>We’re hurt. We’re afraid. And I know others are also and have long been hurt and afraid. There’s enough pain to go around. How do we find enough compassion? Here is where I feel a fissure between my experience and responsibilities as an American and the rage and grief of my Israeli family. I’m scared, but I’m not fighting for my life. Not yet anyway. So the question of Palestinian suffering in Gaza is more pressing for us than for them. And the rights of my fellow Americans to say and believe what they want, be it hate speech or taunts of genocide, means that I can’t support doxxing or other methods to shut them up. I have to take it. I know that we can’t center our pain for long, though it engulfs. I am centered in it without choice. We can’t because there are other pains to take in and absorb and protest. There’s that. There’s also this thing: for whatever reason, Jewish pain is simply unacceptable to the world. It is exasperating and maddening and boils the blood. That is the great mystery and a familiar one. When they killed us they laughed. That’s what survivors who hid under their parents’ bodies or in bushes said.</p><p>May the hostages be returned safely to their homes and may our neighbors hold us and our pain as we do them and theirs.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5c7a55cc681d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thoughts on a New Digital Public Sphere: The US Public Media Mission and New Directions for…]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/thoughts-on-a-new-digital-public-sphere-the-us-public-media-mission-and-new-directions-for-64b563afad82?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/64b563afad82</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[broadcast-internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[information-disorder]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[resilience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media-reform]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jul 2022 21:07:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-14T21:09:15.282Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Thoughts on a New Public Sphere: Public Media and a new resilient future with public broadcasting</h3><p><em>By </em><a href="https://law.rutgers.edu/directory/view/1020"><em>Ellen P. Goodman</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/marc-hand-279416a"><em>Marc Hand</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://derekslater.carrd.co/"><em>Derek Slater</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KhZpf14gcMS9mIHKMsJZaA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Every day, there is a new spike of anger, recrimination, or legislation directed at “<a href="https://www.aspeninstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Aspen-Institute_Commission-on-Information-Disorder_Final-Report.pdf">information disorder</a>,” with concerns that people are steered towards harmful misinformation, radicalized by conspiracies, hived off into polarized media, and worse. To many, major social media services are the <a href="https://www.reset.tech/">primary cause</a> and <a href="https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Donovan%20Testimony%20(updated).pdf">amplifier</a> of these ills, an inevitable consequence of market pressures and the current commercial incentives that platforms have. Even though <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/culture/annals-of-inquiry/we-know-less-about-social-media-than-we-think">the research </a>on social media’s harms is inconclusive, contested, and complex, and even though the “disorder” has <a href="https://oxford.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.1093/oso/9780190923624.001.0001/oso-9780190923624">roots in traditional media</a> and <a href="https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/P/bo24660595.html">elsewhere</a>, <strong>social media must improve</strong> to foster a better information ecosystem.</p><p>Many proposals to reimagine social media focus on <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1oo-lP0MdSuO8mThAqpmxnLsAv7rlf6zKD2I_-_Dfzyo/edit?usp=sharing">regulating and rearchitecting </a>today’s commercial services, particularly very large players with significant market share. Other (not mutually exclusive) proposals seek to bring <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Markets_Act#:~:text=Rationale%20%20%20%20Sectors%20%20%20,%20%2090%25%20%205%20more%20rows%20">more competition</a> to the market. Rather than acting to directly restrict or shape what today’s platforms do, they seek to drive better market outcomes by giving consumers more choices.</p><p>Those choices should not simply be other commercial alternatives. Expecting commercial social media to fill our society’s most important information needs is like expecting a chain bookstore to do a library’s job. We should not count on the market to provide for all of our information needs. Just as market actors’ decisions will not fully account for negative externalities, they won’t account for positive externalities either, including the benefits of an informed public. <strong>Noncommercial alternatives</strong>, including public serving media institutions and libraries, have historically been a key part of meeting civic objectives.</p><p>The importance of a digital public sphere has another feature long associated with public serving media: <strong>resilience</strong>. <a href="https://www.google.com/books/edition/Media_Markets_and_Democracy/bCYvXzjh2uoC?hl=en">Freedom and democracy depend on diverse control of communications systems</a>. Today, even essential information produced by mayors and governors, even the outreach of independent community organizations and the work of universities all rely on the same concentrated commercial systems and infrastructure (including cloud services and distribution), making the system <a href="https://www.weforum.org/reports/global-risks-report-2022/in-full/chapter-3-digital-dependencies-and-cyber-vulnerabilities">brittle</a> and potentially undemocratic.</p><p>There are a <a href="https://publicinfrastructure.org/">number</a> of <a href="https://newpublic.org/">efforts</a> underway to create a <strong>new digital public sphere</strong> that supports communities with communications that foster constructive dialog, rather than poisoning it. To varying extents, these efforts rely on <a href="https://www.commonsnetwork.org/2021/09/27/nathan-schneider-keep-the-internet-public-the-market-will-thank-us-later/">cooperative </a>models and<a href="https://openfuture.eu/tag/digital-public-space/"> take inspiration </a>from Wikipedia, Mozilla, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commons-based_peer_production">open source software</a>, as well as from traditional public service institutions like local libraries and <a href="https://milobs.pt/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Public-Service-Media-and-Public-Service-Internet-Manifesto.pdf">public broadcasting stations</a>.</p><p>Could public broadcasters in the US play a greater role in the new digital public sphere and perhaps even in reimagining social media? They have <a href="https://www.gmfus.org/news/full-stack-approach-public-media-united-states">long been innovating</a> in new digital services that serve their communities and are capable of doing much more. Below, we’ll talk about one example that inspired this post. While we don’t prescribe how broadcasters can or should operate, we think it’s an important area for further exploration, and we’d welcome other pointers to people thinking along these lines.</p><p><strong><em>Moments of crisis prompted investments in noncommercial media</em></strong></p><p>If we find these adolescent years of social media to be disruptive and unstable, so were those <a href="https://books.google.co.il/books/about/America_s_Battle_for_Media_Democracy.html?id=JLyZBAAAQBAJ&amp;redir_esc=y">salad days of radio and television</a> in the twentieth century. To address fears that these new media would hurt democracy, the US government made bold moves to provide optionality in the form of <strong>investments in noncommercial media and infrastructure</strong>. In the 1930’s, it reserved radio spectrum to support the growth of noncommercial radio, ensuring there could be a trusted place for farmers and students to get relevant information. In the 1960’s, it invested in technologies and structures that put public television into every community, controlled by local entities responsible to their publics and not the market.</p><p>Over time, US investments in public media have tried to respond to technological changes by ensuring that public media kept up and could continue to provide independent, noncommercial, locally-based, and trusted services. Those investments included satellite interconnection and a transition to digital broadcasting. This is on top of investments the government has made in often subtle ways to foster a <a href="https://global.oup.com/academic/product/saving-the-news-9780190948412?cc=de&amp;lang=en&amp;">robust press</a> that fights for truth.</p><p>Investments have also gone towards ensuring media institutions serve broader civic roles within their communities; for instance, just as the internet was coming online, the major public broadcaster WHYY embarked on a “civic space” <a href="https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&amp;hl=en&amp;user=A2dbya8AAAAJ&amp;citation_for_view=A2dbya8AAAAJ:_FxGoFyzp5QC">strategy</a>, focused on convening and supporting organizations and people within its local communities, and then extending those engagements into the digital realm.</p><p>That said, it’s fair to say that there has been a more limited effort in the US to strengthen a nonmarket civic communication infrastructure in the digital era than in connection with past innovations. This isn’t because of data suggesting that public media is no longer important; in fact, research shows that countries with more robust public service media are better able to address concerns around political polarization. Moreover, this isn’t because of a lack of will among broadcasters; to the contrary, with relatively limited resources, broadcasters continue to work to innovate in ways that serve their communities.</p><p><strong><em>US public broadcasters’ continued evolution in providing information services</em></strong></p><p>Today, the introduction of ATSC 3.0 is an important example of how broadcasters continue to innovate in information services and could provide more vital digital services in the future.</p><p>ATSC 3.0 (NextGen TV) is the world’s first <strong>IP-based television standard</strong>, meaning it can transmit IP data files — just like the internet — and deliver internet services alongside traditional over-the-air broadcast signals. It can deliver high-quality video, immersive audio, and data files to any device in any location using the existing television infrastructure​. ATSC 3.0 is also more efficient than the current broadcast standard, increasing delivery capacity and allowing broadcasters to expand their number of program streams.​</p><p>One of the most important elements of 3.0 technology is datacasting, an efficient, reliable method of delivering content through the television spectrum. Dubbed “<strong>Broadcast Internet</strong>” by the FCC, 3.0 datacasting is secure and addressable, and there are no per-person or per-device costs to deliver materials — so whether a station is reaching 100 users or 1,000, the cost is the same. And unlike traditional broadband, <strong>hardened broadcast transmission</strong> sites are designed to operate during natural disasters and other crises. What’s more, public media can help reach people who are un- or under-served by broadband with data services.</p><p>Potential use cases for this technology are wide and varied, and public media has been innovating in 3.0 for years now, almost completely independent of commercial station groups. Just a few examples: The <a href="https://comartsci.msu.edu/nextgen-media-innovation-lab">NextGen Media Innovation Lab</a> at WKAR/Michigan State University has been experimenting with interactive educational content and services since 2019. The <a href="https://informationequity.org/">Information Equity Initiative</a>, a nonprofit created in 2021 by three PBS stations, is working with teachers, students, and school districts to bridge the digital divide using datacasting. Public station VPM Media in Richmond, VA, is piloting education datacasting for correctional centers with Southside Virginia Community College’s <a href="https://southside.edu/campus-within-walls">Campus Within Walls</a> project.</p><p>For public broadcasters, ATSC 3.0 presents important opportunities that directly speak to their public service mission. Public media’s nationwide system reaches 98% of the US population, and with more than 25 million American households lacking internet access, NextGen TV could be a game-changer for <strong>economic opportunity, civic engagement</strong>, news and information, health and wellness, public safety, and education. Public media’s innovations in new digital services using NextGen TV technology are helping the industry build resiliency, communications independence, and the non-market alternatives that could help sustain public media and continue to provide essential services to the American public.</p><p><strong><em>Could broadcasters play a greater role in new social media and online public spaces?</em></strong></p><p>The deployment of ATSC 3.0 offers the only digital space for engagement<strong> independent</strong> of the internet and other intermediaries. Innovations like the Information Equity Initiative shows how public media can innovate to serve communities, but it’s only one example. Imagine if the same idea were applied to support other information services, delivered for free at high speed to everyone with local accountability and the stewardship of still-trusted public media.</p><p>In Europe, broadcasters are already leading such innovation. In his work making the case for reimagining social media and public media, Ethan Zuckerman highlights the <a href="https://publicspaces.net/the-coalition/">Public Spaces Coalition</a>, a group of Dutch broadcasters working together to both serve their communities and ensure they are not unduly dependent on commercial intermediaries to reach their constituencies. One outgrowth of this Coalition is a project called <a href="https://pubhubs.net/">PubHubs</a>, a set of tools for community institutions that want to create communication services for their members. Specifically, their tools are built around <a href="https://matrix.org/">Matrix</a>, an open, decentralized communication standard that functions a bit like Slack or Discord.</p><p>Will this work be successful, and could similar innovation develop in the US (perhaps in cooperation with a global network of public service media institutions)? Perhaps. Certainly, funding is a major constraint, given the way public media’s existing activities are relatively underfunded.</p><p>Along with funding, public policy could also enable this sort of innovation in other ways — specifically, through <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/339950172_Unpacking_interoperability_in_competition">interoperability</a>. Today’s social media benefits from strong network effects, with billions of people already on today’s services, and not on a new entrant’s; switching costs matter even though toggling between new apps is trivial, the cognitive load for managing myriad apps matters, as do default settings, alongside losing the ability to access and reference the content in existing commercial services. Interoperability requirements (or at least <a href="https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/03/make-social-media-work-better-make-it-fail-better-0">clearing legal barriers to potential interoperating services</a>) could help overcome these barriers; if one could use an alternative social network while retaining the ability to connect with users on other services, new public service media services could more easily gain users. Even if only a minority of users took advantage of this capability, it could still impact the overall ecosystem, creating a competitive check on today’s large platforms and proof of concept for new internet structures.</p><p>Generations ago, the US media landscape was described as a “<a href="https://time.com/4315217/newton-minow-vast-wasteland-1961-speech/">vast wasteland</a>.” Public broadcasting was one of the responses. It created a public service component to mass media that delivered more variety, independence, access, and service than the market had done before. While public media has been in the digital business for decades now, it has been a marginal player. Concentrated commercial control of the internet has made all legacy media dependent on the logic of digital platforms. Now, with new broadcast technology, public media has a chance to take a leap forward, carrying public media values into new broadband communications on its <strong>own infrastructure</strong>. The vision is there. What’s needed is an ecosystem of partners and funding.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=64b563afad82" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Five Directions for the FTC on Data & Surveillance: Consumer Protection Rules]]></title>
            <link>https://ellgood.medium.com/five-directions-for-the-ftc-on-data-surveillance-consumer-protection-rules-a2a54de559ff?source=rss-367534137fd2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a2a54de559ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillanc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ftc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ellen P. Goodman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jul 2021 18:15:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-26T18:15:43.215Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EwDNxLKckzKNhjs6zXFytg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The FTC has been tasked in <a href="https://ellgood.medium.com/bidens-economic-liberty-agenda-adjures-strong-ftc-action-76a9ac3ae330">Biden’s Executive Order on Competition</a> with tackling unfair and deceptive data and surveillance practices. <strong>More enforcement actions are needed, but so is a rulemaking and other ex ante guidance. </strong>For at least two decades, Congress has been “about to” pass comprehensive privacy legislation. As Jessica Rich, former Director of the Bureau of Consumer Protection <a href="https://www.brookings.edu/blog/techtank/2021/01/14/after-20-years-of-debate-its-time-for-congress-to-finally-pass-a-baseline-privacy-law/">put it</a>, the FTC made privacy law recommendations “just a few years after the internet became an everyday medium, four years before Facebook was created, and seven years before the iPhone would be introduced.” Below are five categories of high impact data use and abuse that the FTC should regulate or, at the very least, guide.</p><p><strong>Why now? </strong>There are several pretty good comprehensive privacy bills out there, including ones introduced by <a href="https://www.brown.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/brown-proposal-protect-consumers-privacy">Senator Brown</a> and <a href="https://www.cantwell.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/COPRA%20Bill%20Text.pdf">Senator Cantwell</a> that would increase FTC authority (or create a new agency). Maybe Congress will act soon; probably it won’t. It’s past time for the <strong>FTC to start making rules</strong> under Section 5 (Mag Moss) or under other statutory authority (e.g., COPPA), <strong>issuing guidance</strong> on unfair data practices, <strong>conducting 6(b) investigations</strong>, and using whatever <strong>enforcement authority</strong> it still has, like a penalty offense authority for companies on notice that what they’re doing is illegal. This is all even more urgent,</p><p>- <em>After the </em><a href="https://www.bu.edu/bulawreview/2021/07/21/standing-and-privacy-harms-a-critique-of-transunion-v-ramirez/"><em>Supreme Court’s 2021 Transunion decision</em></a><em>, which makes it harder for individuals to vindicate their data and privacy rights.</em></p><p>- <em>After the </em><a href="https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=218125068102114124124081028093102010103082061020005063086101084127013122113103117078123118100120050104112112075080126016003098020059005039077088124107096127075086111026009024115127089008001069022087117065099026074113003123095064018072122111003022098064&amp;EXT=pdf&amp;INDEX=TRUE"><em>11th Circuit’s 2018 LabMD decision</em></a><em>, which makes it harder for the FTC to hold companies responsible for data breaches without clearer standards.</em></p><p>- <em>After the </em><a href="https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-508_l6gn.pdf"><em>Supreme Court’s 2021 AMG decision</em></a><em>, which kneecaps the FTC’s ability to order financial restitution under 13(b).</em></p><p><strong>There is now bipartisan support at the FTC for making rules about data governance</strong>. Republican Commissioner Christine Wilson in April <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/1589180/opening_statement_final_for_postingrevd.pdf">told Congress</a> that the FTC should act. Two months before, she had signaled as much at the University of Colorado Law School’s Silicon Flatirons event, to which Colorado <a href="https://twitter.com/BenRemaly/status/1360271192184217609">Attorney General Phil Weiser responded</a>, “I wish I could give you a virtual hug.”</p><p>While rulemaking will take a long time, the process could <strong>drive support for comprehensive data legislation</strong>, provide thought leadership and convening for stakeholders, help concentrate civil society efforts, develop the record supporting theories of harm and modes of redress, create moral hazard for wrongdoers, increase enforcement in the states and at the FTC, etc.</p><p><strong>So what to do?</strong> The FTC doesn’t have the authority or the resources to regulate in all the ways that Congress could legislate to limit data collection and use, require transparency and accountability, and give consumers more control and relief — all the things peer countries have been doing for years and along the lines of what President Obama called for almost a decade ago with his administration’s consumer data privacy <a href="https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/privacy-final.pdf">Bill of Rights.</a> What the agency can and should do is begin to establish guidance for “tip of the spear” practices that are most harmful and will if regulated have most impact on business practices, consumer welfare, and liberty.</p><p><strong>1. Focus on most vulnerable consumers and communities</strong></p><p>The FTC has already started to focus on the intersection of civil rights/human rights and data. In AppFolio, it enforced FCRA against <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2020/12/tenant-background-report-provider-settles-ftc-allegations-it">biased tenant screening</a> which can unfairly deny people housing they have every right to obtain. The ACLU and Upturn have petitioned the FTC to turn this concern into guidance, for example, making it clear that it is a violation of FCRA to use “unreliable or overly loose matching criteria, such as name only searches, to match applicants with public records” and “reporting sealed or expunged records.”</p><p>Health information is also shared in ways that can subordinate the vulnerable. In Flo Health, the FTC enforced against a company abusively sharing women’s <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2021/01/developer-popular-womens-fertility-tracking-app-settles-ftc">ovulation data</a>, which is one of many examples of health data unprotected by HIPAA being shared in unfair and harmful ways that not only compromise individual privacy but can feed predictive algorithms responsible for systemic harms.</p><p>Children are a vulnerable group being exploited for data in captive environments where they have little choice but to relinquish biometric and other sensitive data. <a href="https://mkus3lurbh3lbztg254fzode-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/Privacy-And-Digital-Rights-For-All-A-blueprint-for-the-next-Administration.pdf?eType=EmailBlastContent&amp;eId=10143248-78e5-4887-a7cc-cd751a536706">Civil rights</a> groups have called on the FTC to issue a rulemaking under its COPPA authority on discriminatory practices in ad tech and ed tech that affect children.</p><p>Hiring algorithms that make it especially hard for people of color and other diverse constituencies (unlike past hires) are the target of an <a href="https://www.aclu.org/sites/default/files/field_document/2021-07-13_letter_to_white_house_ostp_on_centering_civil_rights_in_ai_policy_1.pdf">ACLU and Upturn</a> letter that urges a rulemaking on biased hiring algorithms. <a href="https://epic.org/privacy/ftc/ai/EPIC-FTC-AI-Petition.pdf">EPIC</a> has sought the same. What is so useful about such a project is that FTC guidance on what counts as biased and unfair automated decision systems in hiring can either be applied or be instructive for other algorithmic operations. For example, if a hiring algorithm is unfair because it relies on facial recognition, such a finding might apply more broadly to all automated decision systems that use facial recognition.</p><p>The recent revelations about the spyware <a href="https://www.theverge.com/22589942/nso-group-pegasus-project-amnesty-investigation-journalists-activists-targeted">Pegasus</a> being used for comprehensive surveillance of journalists and dissidents highlights the special vulnerability of the brave. The FTC has jurisdiction over only commercial entities. But even if the entity doing the spying is a government, businesses that develop the spyware and sell it for undisclosed and abusive purposes may be engaging in unfair practices to the extent they threaten vulnerable populations who are consumers of the infected devices. The consumer harm is there, nested in an attack on the trust and freedom necessary for self-governance.</p><p>This touches on a more general point that I’ll address in a later post. What President Biden’s Executive Order did so well was to <a href="https://ellgood.medium.com/bidens-economic-liberty-agenda-adjures-strong-ftc-action-76a9ac3ae330">connect</a> democracy, economic liberty, equity, and the prevention of abusive data practices. In its guidance, rulemaking, and enforcement actions, the FTC should look for the nexus of these interests and go after the practices that erode intersecting fundamental interests alongside consumer harm.</p><p><strong>2. Define the meaning and function of fair algorithmic audits</strong></p><p>A principal intervention to prevent biased hiring and other algorithmic harms is to require algorithmic audits. <a href="https://legistar.council.nyc.gov/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=4344524&amp;GUID=B051915D-A9AC-451E-81F8-6596032FA3F9&amp;Options=ID">Draft legislation</a> calls for this. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951720983865">Civil society groups</a> have called for it. But what should auditing look like? To what extent should it be standardized? What should be the role of independent auditors? How should audits differ across sectors and how public should audit results be? <a href="https://onezero.medium.com/the-algorithmic-auditing-trap-9a6f2d4d461d">Mona Sloane</a> of NYU has written very perceptively about these questions. These should all be addressed in a rulemaking or guidance, following the development of a record.</p><p>Relatedly, what should an algorithmic impact assessment look like? The proposed <a href="https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Algorithmic%20Accountability%20Act%20of%202019%20Bill%20Text.pdf">Algorithmic Accountability Act</a> tasks the FTC with overseeing these. Commentators have <a href="https://ainowinstitute.org/aiareport2018.pdf">put great faith in the use of this tool</a> to avoid algorithmic harms, much as NEPA’s environmental impact statement was designed to stop bad projects. What should an assessment accomplish? How thorough must it be? At what point in the lifespan of automated decision systems that are dynamic and constantly updating? These are all questions for rulemaking and guidance.</p><p><strong>3. Get to internet of things data abuses before they are intractable</strong></p><p>The FTC settled a case with <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2020/04/canadian-maker-smart-locks-settles-ftc-allegations-it-deceived">Taplock</a>. the manufacturer of smart locks, for deceiving consumers about how secure the locks were. It went on to advise internet of things businesses that they should implement “security by design.” What is this? More guidance is needed to ensure that people’s smart home devices are not hacked or their data unfairly or deceptively shared. Because smart home data is in the home, data abuse abets <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/23/technology/smart-home-devices-domestic-abuse.html">domestic abuse</a>. Home surveillance abets <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/08/28/doorbell-camera-firm-ring-has-partnered-with-police-forces-extending-surveillance-reach/">police surveillance</a>. And <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-42989073">one arm of a company can exploit the data gathered by another</a>, resulting in economic and dignitary harms to consumers and harm to competition. Competition and consumer protection interests will intertwine when consumers are locked into a smart home device platform or ecosystem because Nest and Echo systems, for example, don’t interoperate. The FTC should address what security and interoperability obligations IOT companies should have, especially in the home, and how providers need to empower vulnerable consumers.</p><p><strong>4. Re-theorize the harms for ad tech abuses and dark patterns</strong></p><p>The FTC held a <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/events-calendar/bringing-dark-patterns-light-ftc-workshop">workshop on dark patterns</a> that push consumers to give up data they don’t want to. Apple has now provided a natural experiment to see how much consumers actually object to having their data culled and shared by advertisers — apparently 96% of iPhone customers <a href="https://developer-tech.com/news/2021/may/07/report-96-percent-american-ios-users-opt-out-ad-tracking/#:~:text=According%20to%20a%20new%20report,ask%20for%20explicit%20user%20consent.">are taking advantage of Apple’s do not track option.</a> So much for the privacy paradox!</p><p>The financial and non-financial substantial harms from current practices in ad tech and platform design abound. Just look at <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/24/technology/joseph-mercola-coronavirus-misinformation-online.html">COVID misinformation</a>, supported by advertising and pushed on consumers profiled as good marks, and its attendant physical and economic harms. At the same time, the leading ad tech companies are engaging in anticompetitive behavior, which the <a href="https://judiciary.house.gov/uploadedfiles/competition_in_digital_markets.pdf">House Judiciary Committee detailed</a> and which the FTC will learn more about from its <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2020/12/ftc-issues-orders-nine-social-media-video-streaming-services">6(b) investigation</a> of social media companies. It makes sense for the FTC, with its limited resources, to prioritize data practices that are both anticompetitive and unfair/deceptive. Ad tech data practices fit the bill.</p><p>Relatedly, the FTC should provide guidance or adopt rules on unfair/deceptive social media and website practices as they relate to Section 230 immunity. As <a href="https://poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=448116089123102081097065126113100081056087054032028010066007098074002103073009121030002122118022114055124103024120095100126075014010033010014099098066095071085077001060023103079066101006071008008085002124018126087006031003023102097120068004101091113&amp;EXT=pdf&amp;INDEX=TRUE">Chris Hoofnagle has shown</a>, the FTC has already used its Section 5 authority to carve out a small space from the Section 230 privilege for companies that design their websites to inflict consumer harm (discussing Abika.com, which helped people buy confidential records from third party private investigators). Proposals to reform Section 230 that would empower courts to assess liability in more cases, such as <a href="https://scholarship.law.bu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1638&amp;context=faculty_scholarship">Danielle Citron</a> and <a href="https://www.gmfus.org/publications/safeguarding-democracy-against-disinformation">I</a> have made, would work much better if the FTC provided guidance on where it thinks internet service providers are responsible for harming consumers.</p><p><strong>5. Address the connections: B2G and B2B</strong></p><p>In 2012, <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052970204880404577225380456599176">Julia Angwin</a> came out with a story about how Google bypassed Apple protections against third party cookies to force them on consumers, resulting in an <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2012/08/google-will-pay-225-million-settle-ftc-charges-it-misrepresented">FTC enforcement action</a> for deception. Then in 2013, just after the Snowden revelations, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/12/10/nsa-uses-google-cookies-to-pinpoint-targets-for-hacking/">Ashkan Soltani</a> broke the news that the NSA used Google cookies to find hacking targets. Of course there was nothing the FTC could do about that.</p><p>It is now of course unremarkable that government grabs the data that companies collect, causing substantial injury to consumers as well as to liberty interests. Indeed, this nexus between government surveillance and promiscuous commercial data collection is what seems to have warmed Commissioner Wilson to FTC data regulation. <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/1590440/wilson-fourth-amendment-wyden.pdf">She wrote to Senator Wyden</a> in praise of the Fourth Amendment Is Not For Sale Act “which closes the legal loophole that allows the federal government to purchase commercial data on individuals without a warrant.” At the state and local levels, the connections between invasive data practices of tech companies (e.g., Clearview) and government surveillance are multiplying fast as <a href="https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/flr/vol88/iss2/4/">smart city applications</a> give public functions to private entities.</p><p>President Biden’s EO tasked the FTC with creating more space for small businesses by enforcing antitrust law and creating rules for fair competition. Consumer protection law and rulemaking can help here too. The FTC not long ago started something it called <a href="https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2018/06/operation-main-street-targets-scams-against-small-business">Operation Main Street</a> to take down scammers targeting small businesses. There is a data corollary to this effort and guidance or rules on fair data practices between businesses with market power and their dependents could be important. The EU has undertaken this with its <a href="https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32019R1150&amp;from=EN">platform business regulation</a> on promoting fairness and transparency for business users of online intermediation services. These rules require of platforms to give businesses some of the same rights that data protection gives to individuals, including transparency about how they are treated (e.g. ranking, data collection) and means of redress. Empowering smaller businesses like this is likely to give consumers more power in data protection battles.</p><p>***</p><p>It has been time for the FTC to make rules on data and surveillance for a long time. For many practices, it’s past time. For many more practices, there is still time for the FTC to exercise leadership and, it seems, the right team in place to do it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a2a54de559ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>