<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by emer gentway on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by emer gentway on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@emergentway?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 09:46:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mindful Spontaneity: The Gift of Embodiment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/29-mindful-spontaneity-the-gift-of-embodiment-ae84af2cfac?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ae84af2cfac</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[openness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[somatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Jul 2021 00:04:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-15T01:59:06.119Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zjjy5KAQuaX1wRKolvuV7w.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Disturbances dissolve in letting things be as they are, and troublesome thoughts melt like snow falling on the warm waters of non-interference. (Dzogchen classic)</em></p><p>Imagine yourself stuck in a boring lecture. You have already heard it many times over. The speaker is dull and self-absorbed. The talk is dragging on, droning on a handful of worn-out themes, with no end in sight. How hard would it be for you to stop paying attention? Not hard at all, I bet. Unless you force yourself to keep listening, chances are you would readily tune out. Similarly, all it takes for the voice in your head to lose its mesmerizing appeal is to see the speaker for what it is. Carefully observe your mind as an entomologist studying a buzzing insect, and you may be surprised at how effortlessly it falls silent.</p><p>~~~</p><p>“Mindfulness of the body” is the first among the “four foundations of mindfulness” presented by the Buddha. As <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/231780/the-strange-order-of-things-by-antonio-damasio/">Antonio Damasio</a> has pointed out, the body is not a mere vat that houses the brain. Rather, our entire mind is built on the foundation of a nervous system that originally evolved for maintaining the homeostatic stability of its host body. In our minds, this feedback loop is experienced as feelings. For example, thirst and fatigue drive us to drink and rest, thus helping restore the body to its ideal state. By getting more attuned to our bodies, we get closer to life. A continuous stream of rich and unpredictable bodily sensations can serve as a physical foundation of openness, reminding us of impermanence and flux, which was proclaimed by the Buddha as a fundamental characteristic of existence.</p><p>Just as the mind gets stuck in its story, the body gets stuck in its flesh. Protracted tightening that follows an injury is a healthy protective mechanism that shields damaged tissues from strain and impact to promote healing. However, once the healing is complete, contracted muscles must be released to restore the natural motion of the body. The stiffness that persists past the point of recovery often creates mobility restrictions and results in chronic pains that are no longer related to the original injury. They may even radiate to other parts of the body, leading our minds away from the actual source of the disturbance.</p><p>Similarly, mental fixations lead to rigidity, confusion, and suffering. Just as chronically contracted muscles result in physical pain, unquestioned beliefs lead to emotional anguish. And just as our willingness to undergo uncomfortable therapy may help relieve the pain caused by unresponsive muscles, our willingness to endure psychological discomfort may help release our mental constrictions and eliminate the mobility restrictions of our minds.</p><p>The mindfulness of the body is a versatile tool for developing openness. While seemingly enclosed within its deceptively crisp boundary of skin, the body is a complex system actively engaged with its surroundings. Within the body, proprioception and movement are merged into a visceral feedback loop between sensation and action. Meditation grounded in body awareness suspends the reciprocal feedback loops that define our self, shifting our attention away from the world’s affordances to the flow of experience.</p><p>As a vessel through which we carry out volitional action, our body can be an excellent lab for exploring the experience of “free will” and perhaps discovering more effortless ways of being. While our cravings and aversions take place in the brain, they are felt through the body, making it a clear window into the roots of our conditioning. Our perishable vehicle is a prominent source of self-serving beliefs and outright self-deception. Its limitless potential for underscoring our imperfection and vulnerability invariably comes to mind whenever I glance, reluctantly, into the bathroom mirror.</p><p>~~~</p><p>From the <em>somatic</em> viewpoint, there is no boundary between your self as a subject and your body as an object. Somatics focuses on the internal sensations of movement. The approach is based on the concept of the <em>soma</em>, “the body as perceived from within.” Mindfulness of the body is radically different from the external image of what others may see as your “body.” From the inside of ourselves, observed <a href="https://www.hachettebooks.com/titles/thomas-hanna/somatics/9781549189388/">Thomas Hanna</a>, we are not aware of the body itself but only of the feelings that emanate from it. The lifelong subconscious distortions within our habitual body image invariably “feel right.” Yet even something as intimate as our own body can be rediscovered afresh.</p><p>According to Damasio, feelings are homeostatic responses to the state of life in the body’s old visceral and musculoskeletal interior. They arise not only in response to movements but also to thoughts and emotions. Throughout our lives, observed Hanna, our systems continually respond to daily stresses and traumas with specific muscular reflexes. Accumulating anxieties create layers of habitual muscular contractions. Habituation is a slow, relentless adaptive act, imprinting the patterns of responses onto the brain. As it “forgets” how to accurately experience and control its body, <em>sensory-motor amnesia</em> sets in. (It can be a startling experience to discover that we have been actively doing something all along without realizing it.) However, since a contraction is triggered by a signal from the central nervous system, when the signal stops, so does the contraction. If a maladaptive response of the brain was learned, suggested Hanna, it can also be unlearned.</p><p>Similarly, the opposite of chronic tension is not relaxation but aliveness. Compulsive exertion can become mindless and automatic, unresponsive to changing circumstances. Pulling on a knot to untie it will only make it tighter. Instead of relying on brute force, we need to carefully examine the cord before undoing the tangle. Similarly, trying to force an involuntarily contracted muscle to release will only make it tighter. However, when we move slowly and gently, the brain receives precise and uncluttered sensory feedback.</p><p>Traditional holistic somatic practices (such as yoga, qigong, and tai chi) have long relied on proprioceptive awareness. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mosh%C3%A9_Feldenkrais">Moshé Feldenkrais</a> observed that even the smallest movement in one part of the body involves the entire body. To support the effective, graceful, efficient movement, he said, the entire body needs to organize itself to move as a whole. To get a flavor of such a whole-body response, clench your fist tightly and then follow the sensations in your hand to release it slowly. Notice how, even for such a small movement, your entire body is adjusting slightly as your fingers are extending back into the neutral position.</p><p>Incidentally, a clenched fist is often used in Zen as a metaphor for the self. Seemingly tangible and solid, it reveals itself as little more than a temporary arrangement of independently moving parts.</p><p>Where did the fist go after you opened it?</p><p>~~~</p><p>In the spirit of the emergent way, we can venture to discover a meditation practice that fits seamlessly into our unique life circumstances without demanding unrealistic adaptations or sacrifices. By being open to deviating from traditional practices, we would be following in the very footsteps of the Buddha. (At least, for as long as it doesn’t go to our heads.)</p><p>Formal sitting postures have evolved over millennia to ensure stability and comfort during extensive meditative retreats. By creating sensory deprivation and eliminating proprioceptive feedback, quieting the restless mind, and imparting an air of calm, physical stillness may help dissolve the boundaries of the self and create a sense of openness and oneness. Besides its contribution to mystical experiences, meditative absorption may allow even the toughest skeptics with little interest in spirituality to personally witness the ceaseless construction and dissolution of their self.</p><p>Unfortunately, nowadays, sitting is often likened to the new smoking. Those of us who are burdened with the hazards of a sedentary lifestyle (engendered by full-time office jobs and inescapable traffic jams) may wince at the thought of enduring even more sitting regardless of its potential benefits. (Traditional Buddhist monks responsible for supporting their livelihood through farming and gathering alms were unlikely to enjoy the luxury of extensive sitting outside of their formal practice.) Unless you are an advanced meditator (or aspiring to become one), relaxing the stringent requirements of the sitting posture may let you taste some fruits of traditional meditation, at least until you are encouraged to undergo fundamental changes to your lifestyle.</p><p>Finding a physical space for practice throughout the day may take some planning. Since your unhindered attention follows feelings, sights, and sounds picked up by our senses, it may get overwhelmed by the barrage of ambient stimulation. If you love nature, you may find trees, flowers, streams, and birds as a relaxing backdrop. Alternatively, if you prefer fewer distractions, a quiet room may be a welcome respite. The ideal settings are for you to discover. A bottle of ketchup on a supermarket shelf may highlight your freedom from it, while a beautiful tree in a pristine forest may create a lasting attachment as your mind carries away its wholesome delights.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Imagine a very small change to your day. On waking up in the morning, instead of checking your social media, scrolling through the news, drinking a cup of coffee, making plans for the day, or jumping into the routine, allow yourself some space of openness. Just a few minutes of not knowing how to get up, what to think about, or even who you are.</p><p>If you are a practitioner of traditional meditation accustomed to observing your breath, try experiencing it as an unknown rather than a familiar “conceptual” image. From your life-long uninterrupted experience with breathing, you may naturally expect the in-breath to alternate with the out-breath, the abdomen to rise and fall, and the nostrils to feel cool air passing through them. However, you don’t <em>really </em>know when the next breath will naturally arrive, how it will unfold through your body, and what it will feel like at that moment. Evidently, even something as intimately familiar as your breath is ripe with opportunities for insight.</p><p>As your embodied meditation unfolds, embrace any experience as it is arising and receding into the undifferentiated awareness, remaining open to anything that is about to manifest next. Blend into the flow of feelings as if awakening into a new body. Sitting, standing, or lying down, allow your slow and careful movements to nourish your brain with fresh sensations. Become aware of your body’s discomforts and tensions without fighting them. Simply experience and accept your body the way it is. Suspend your expectations, pause, and let the movement emerge, flower, and unfold from within. Then your meditation will feel comfortable, free, and full of <a href="https://www.feldenkraisresources.com/Mindful-Spontaneity-Returning-to-Natural-Movement-p/1170.htm">mindful spontaneity</a>.</p><p>Open and sensitive, you will be dwelling on your embodied koan, teetering on the brink of the uncharted present.</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>The Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with an </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ae84af2cfac" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/29-mindful-spontaneity-the-gift-of-embodiment-ae84af2cfac">Mindful Spontaneity: The Gift of Embodiment</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sitting Quietly, Doing Nothing: Choiceless Awareness and the Art of Freedom]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/28-sitting-quietly-doing-nothing-choiceless-awareness-and-the-art-of-freedom-d0c94ea93c31?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0c94ea93c31</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nonduality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[openness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 23:31:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-15T01:28:35.133Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RVia951vicq7LpQbISBlLw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Do you have the patience to wait until your mud settles and the water is clear? (</em><a href="https://stephenmitchellbooks.com/translations-adaptations/tao-te-ching/"><em>Lao Tzu</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>Make sure you have no urgent chores to take care of. Set up a timer with a soft ring. Sit down comfortably and resolve to remain motionless without thinking of anything — like a frog on a lily pad — until the timer rings.</p><p>How did it go? Chances are, you have found it impossible to stop your mind from chattering even briefly. Unless you happened to be amid a crisis (which wouldn’t be a good time for such existential reflections in the first place), you were probably lost in a daydream or alternating between a variety of distractions, with idle ruminations chugging along in the background. The compulsive quality of thinking may have felt a lot like addiction. But what is your mind addicted <em>to</em>?</p><p>Closer observation may reveal distinct visceral sensations behind each thought. (What was its emotional “texture”? Anxious? Comforting? Pleasantly entertaining? Self-gratifying? Reassuring?) Was your mind compulsively rehashing your to-do list, suppressing unsettling concerns from bubbling to the surface, or scratching the itch of a recent encounter that you wish you had handled differently? Did you actually enjoy your thoughts, or did you feel driven to dwell on them like a true addict, to avoid the discomfort of facing some unpalatable realities of your life? Were these thoughts in any way related to you? And would you still be addicted to them if you didn’t take them personally?</p><p>~~~</p><p>Buddhist meditation is a powerful ancient tool for gaining insight into our conditioning and dysfunctional beliefs. The word usually refers to a particular technique, but we can think of meditation as simply a state of mind immersed in the raw experience of being. It allows us to observe our deceptively solid self — from the most basic physical sensations to the most elaborate life stories — being continuously pieced together. It opens our eyes to the reality of impermanence, the undeniable fact that nothing in the stream of mental and physical phenomena has the quality of separate, independent, and lasting existence.</p><p>For millennia, mystics have described extraordinary states of consciousness in which their habitual feeling of separation gave way to the blissful sense of universal oneness. Such experiences of “non-duality” (whether of meditative, clinical, or psychedelic origins) suggest that the self is not as indispensable as it likes to think. Perhaps, by quieting down the chatter of the evolutionarily recent brain areas through deep absorption, we let the primordial experience of reality, untouched by the divisive conceptual thought, shine through?</p><p>Yet there is nothing esoteric about meditation. As neuroscientists continue to peer into the brains of advanced practitioners, the nature of mystical experiences may someday be described in modern scientific terms. Altered states of consciousness, however, are not essential to Buddhist meditation. Its primary focus is the transformation of the ordinary mind. Experienced meditation teachers invariably connect formal practices to everyday living. Yet due to the intricacy of our thought with its inexhaustible potential for carrying us away from the present, the depth of our attachments, and the ingenuity of our self-deception, a simple, grounded practice may be essential for the contemplative insights to sink into our bones.</p><p>~~~</p><p>One way of approaching a resilient problem, either a practical or an existential one, is to keep struggling until our habitual efforts are exhausted, we get stuck, and stop trying. An alternative is to openly contemplate the problem from the outset.</p><p>Imagine your mind as an ocean with familiar solutions and simplistic heuristics floating on the surface. Giving yourself the luxury of time to remain with the problem at hand and resisting the temptation to pick from seemingly suitable answers laying within a comfortable reach allows you to see more clearly into the ocean&#39;s depth.</p><p>Buddhist secular meditation does not attempt to manipulate or control the mind. By staying receptive to whatever arises — thoughts, emotions, or sensations — and refraining from tampering with it, the practitioner allows the unfolding experience to manifest freely. Meditation is sometimes referred to as “the science of freedom”, though perhaps a more (scientifically) accurate description might be “the art of freedom.” As with any science or art form, we may not know in advance where our inquiry and creative inspiration may take us and what is there for us to discover.</p><p>Meditation, said Jiddu Krishnamurti, “is like the breeze that comes in when you leave the window open.” It makes us notice, observes <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/348402/buddhism-without-beliefs-by-stephen-batchelor/">Stephen Batchelor</a>, how we fail to register what is happening in the present while “reliving an edited version of the past, planning an uncertain future, or indulging in being elsewhere.” It allows us, adds <a href="http://www.actiontheater.com/ruth.htm">Ruth Zaporah</a>, to see the moment as a “kaleidoscope of changing events, colors, movements, and histories.”</p><p>At the core of meditation lies <em>mindfulness</em>, a simple nonjudgmental awareness of bare facts. It doesn’t require deliberately “watching” for anything since you don’t know what to look for or where to look for it. Being mindful simply means paying attention to whatever arises in the awareness — a thought, an emotion, or a sensation — without resistance or interference, and staying with it until something else comes in. By remaining mindful, we gradually become more aware of our habitual compulsions and distractions, including the assumptions that had been taken for granted or the concerns that had been hidden out of sight.</p><p>Although mindfulness is often tied to concentration and alertness, it does not require willpower. Most naturally, it could stem out of simple curiosity and wonder, a genuine desire to stay open and see life for what it is. For a very simple example, by staying open, you could suddenly notice that you are biting your nails. A mindful way to quit smoking, reports <a href="https://yalebooks.yale.edu/book/9780300223248/craving-mind">Judson Brewer</a>, encourages smokers to become aware of the taste that the smoke leaves in their mouths. Once they recognize it as unpleasant, the spell is broken, and they grow “viscerally disenchanted” with it. (Of course, breaking an addictive habit may take a lot more than a single recognition — yet it could be the necessary first step.) Such simple awareness is what mindfulness is all about: the willingness to turn toward our experience and realize that the sought-after rewards may not be as juicy as we imagine them to be.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Many of us are familiar with introspection — the meticulous monitoring of our mind by shining the “flashlight” of attention into its gears. In contrast, mindfulness is a much simpler act — not even an act, as it doesn’t require an “actor” — which introduces our mind to its own secrets hidden in plain sight. This subtle distinction goes deeper than the contrast between active engagement and passive openness. Given the constructive nature of our experience, the introspective journey of discovery may inadvertently turn into one of invention. Mindfulness, in contrast, witnesses the process of construction itself.</p><p>Since meditation disables our lifelong distractions, denials, and self-deceptions, many of our discoveries may not be particularly pleasing. The historical Gautama started on his famous quest upon recognizing the inevitability of old age, sickness, and death, as well as his desperate — yet ultimately unattainable — desire to escape them. He spent years contemplating the human condition determined to resolve this existential predicament. Our views and lifestyles may have changed dramatically in the twenty-five hundred years since the Buddha presented his liberating teaching to a handful of fellow ascetics. Yet we are still grappling with the same troubling questions as he did before the flash of insight put him at peace with himself. While people often come to secular Buddhism for more mundane reasons, such as to solve personal problems or to placate a general sense of discontent, their motivation tends to evolve as the practice advances. Rather than offering an escape from reality, meditation puts us in touch with it.</p><p>When they say that meditation is “hard,” they don’t mean that it is difficult to understand or learn. Rather, it is painful to face the facts about ourselves that we have diligently avoided for our entire life. But we don’t have to probe the ultimate depths of our minds from the start. The immediate benefits of meditation offer reassurance and enhance our motivation to persevere. For example, by contemplating our thoughts as if they belonged to someone else, we may become mindful of our self-serving beliefs. Due to this realization, suggest <a href="https://www.hmhbooks.com/shop/books/Mistakes-Were-Made-but-Not-by-Me-Third-Edition/9780547416038">Carol Tavris and Elliot Aronson</a>, we may stand a better chance of breaking out of the vicious cycle of dissonance.</p><p>One exercise the Buddha suggested to his disciples was to imagine a rotting corpse and then reflect on their own body, “Such is its nature, such is its future, such is its unavoidable fate.” A practice like this may be disquieting or even dangerous for those in a highly stressful or unsafe situation, survivors of major trauma or loss, people with clinical depression, or those with a variety of other psychological conditions and psychiatric disorders. Meditation is gentle but tough. If you resolve to give it a try, please come prepared.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Meditation techniques are sometimes differentiated into “exclusive” and “inclusive,” based on the quality of the practitioners’ attention. Naturally, the split is a simplification, as the two forms of practice are often complementary. The difference is primarily a matter of emphasis.</p><p>As the name implies, exclusive meditation “excludes” most of the stimuli that could otherwise become part of our experience. To that end, attention is steadily kept on a meditation object (such as the breath, sound, candle, elaborate image, a body sensation, or a paradoxical statement). Such props may help practitioners return their minds to their immediate experience. When their attention drifts away, practitioners are instructed to gently bring it back to the “anchor.” Over time, they develop an ability to rest in the present, recognizing thoughts and emotions as they arise in the flow of experience but no longer getting lost in the storyline.</p><p>The concentration inherent in exclusive meditation requires exerting control, however subtle. As modern life ceaselessly demands our sustained attention, we are continually pressured to exercise willpower in social settings and the privacy of our homes alike, pushing ourselves to maintain the proper social image while keeping up with daily chores. For those tired (or incapable) of self-control, the “inclusive” or “natural” meditation may hold a special appeal.</p><p>Often referred to as an “open” (or “choiceless”) awareness, natural meditation involves no control of attention, advising us to remain passively receptive to whatever becomes manifest in the mind. Popular across multiple Buddhist and Taoist meditative traditions, this wholehearted and intimate practice, which requires no special techniques, brings about the panoramic and receptive qualities of awareness. Experiencing something as a “distraction” simply suggests that we must have been holding on to something else. Instead, we are encouraging ourselves to open up to the experience and let it permeate us completely. For example, when listening to music, rather than focusing on a particular sound, you would be allowing the sound to enter your ears.</p><p>As a “method of no-method,” natural meditation invites us to abide in openness, observing things, to the extent possible, “simply as they are.” It makes us acutely sensitive to the thoughts and feelings floating through our minds. One can observe the sense of self as it arises through the subtle identification with sensations, thoughts, emotions, and memories. When we become aware of thoughts and feelings on par with sights and sounds, no distinction is made between the “inside” and the “outside” of our mind. As the boundary ceases to be maintained, it gradually fades away.</p><p>Natural meditation has a soothing quality to it. Spontaneous shifts of attention are usually triggered by our brain’s “caution and warning” system, prompting us to investigate any disturbances registered by our senses that were deemed potentially significant by our subconscious mind. Our attention may shift when we hear an interesting sound (such as our name), feel an unexpected sensation, or remember something urgent. Otherwise, it just pokes around like a mental tongue, making sure that no troubles or opportunities are hiding in the crevices. The unrestricted flow of attention allowed by natural meditation reassures our anxious brain that things are under control, reinforcing a sense of security and ease. It invites us to remain with ourselves without taking sides.</p><p>As Bashō Matsuo poetically described the spirit of natural meditation, “sitting quietly, doing nothing, spring comes, and the grass grows by itself.”</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>The Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://emergentway.medium.com/29-mindful-spontaneity-the-gift-of-embodiment-ae84af2cfac"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0c94ea93c31" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/28-sitting-quietly-doing-nothing-choiceless-awareness-and-the-art-of-freedom-d0c94ea93c31">Sitting Quietly, Doing Nothing: Choiceless Awareness and the Art of Freedom</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Emergent Way: A Journey into the Unknown]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/27-emergent-way-a-journey-into-the-unknown-ddcdc15fca73?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ddcdc15fca73</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[complexity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[effort]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taoism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 22:57:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-14T17:52:43.961Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ceug6Ryj4u1D4mjnwHOUrA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>You do not need to leave your room. Remain sitting at your table and listen. Do not even listen, simply wait, be quiet, still, and solitary. The world will freely offer itself to you to be unmasked, it has no choice, it will roll in ecstasy at your feet. (Franz Kafka)</em></p><p>Those of us who didn’t learn to swim as babies have to rely on the intuitions developed through our experience with solid ground. To run, we push back to move the body forward. Not surprisingly, when submerged for the first time, we start pushing aggressively against water, as if trying to run in it. However, our old intuitions may be of limited use in the new medium. Having an implicit expectation of a stronger push producing greater propulsion, we may fail to notice that most of our energy is wasted on creating drag, slowing (indeed, dragging) us down instead of speeding us up. And while our bodies get adjusted to the new reality, we just keep paddling harder.</p><p>When we cease defining ourselves in the context of a life story, we are transported to a new medium where our intuitions may provide little useful guidance. Having no solid ground of fixed identity to push against, we may find it hard to count on our beliefs as reliable stepping stones. How do we propel ourselves through life once we have acknowledged that both the destination and the traveler are in flux? Can we approach every moment, in the words of <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/175559/zen-mind-beginners-mind-by-shunryu-suzuki/">Shunryu Suzuki</a>, “as the last one” rather than “a preparation for something else”?</p><p>The notion of “presence,” popular among New Age writers, may sound deceptively simple yet elusive. Our mental “now” is a construction that emerges as the delayed awareness of perceived events continuously blending into the simulation of the incoming ones. With the chronological present off the table, does presence mean the absorption into the raw sensory experience? A recreational drug would do the trick. The mind free of thoughts? A lobotomy offers a quick fix. Perpetual alertness? We couldn’t do better than having a chipmunk for a guru. And whose presence is it, anyway, if the experiencer continuously arises and fades away?</p><p>~~~</p><p>In philosophical <a href="https://stephenmitchellbooks.com/translations-adaptations/tao-te-ching/">Taoism</a>, all things are seen as returning to the Tao “as rivers flow into the sea.” The yielding, effortless action following the way of Tao (“wu-wei”) is believed to preserve harmony with the natural order. Thus, one way of holding the presence is through experiencing ourselves as a fluid happening, akin to clouds and waves. Rather than trying to ground ourselves in the present, we can simply witness the insubstantial nature of our enduring self. Once this perspective is internalized, there is no longer a need to contrive the elusive “here and now.”</p><p>In keeping with the Taoist spirit, let’s call the road unfolding before us the “emergent way.” While walking along this path, we can allow ourselves to emerge unfettered with every step. After all, a path is nothing more than a space that is clear of obstacles. While it implicitly constrains the infinity of alternative paths we could have taken, countless new paths branch out at every junction. To follow such an uncertain path is, in the words of <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/348383/verses-from-the-center-by-stephen-batchelor/">Stephen Batchelor</a>, “to discern the living contours of contingency.”</p><p>Like the ineffable way of Tao, the emergent way rests on the dissolution of rigid forms, taking us further into the unknown, leaving behind the comfort of traditions and the certainty of convictions. It would be naïve to pour over ancient writings in search of authoritative instructions for navigating the challenges of modern living. However, we can hold the wisdom of their poetic contemplations as “invisible beacons” to illuminate the intangible mileposts of the path.</p><p><a href="https://www.sacred-texts.com/bud/glg/index.htm">The Gateless Gate</a> book of koans has a story about a Zen student who visited the dwelling of his teacher and was peppering him with endless questions. Finally, the teacher said, “The night is getting old. Why don’t you retire.” The student bowed and opened the door to go out, observing, “It is very dark outside.” The teacher offered him a lit candle, but as soon as the student received it, the teacher blew it out. At that instant, the student’s mind was opened.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Openness is not a goal to strive toward. The irony of trying to let go of effort is often lost on us. The very desire to be open can become an effort of the self, which only creates resistance, observed <a href="https://jkrishnamurti.org/">Jiddu Krishnamurti</a>. After all, we do not know how to be open. We can only become aware of being closed. Letting go happens when we recognize our habitual patterns of grasping and holding that used to “feel right.”</p><p>In Zen, openness is seen as the unconditional readiness to suspend our assumptions. It is a tacit recognition of the mismatch between our small mind and the daunting complexity of the world that it has been unceremoniously dropped into. Openness helps us resist the natural temptation to fall back on ready-made answers. Instead, it invites us to put down the burden of the past and approach every question as an enigmatic koan.</p><p>When practicing the art of the sword, ancient Japanese samurai trained to keep their minds open to every possibility. You can safely experience this nimble quality of attention by playing “sensing hands,” a foundational tai chi practice. The players take turns applying gentle pressure to their partner’s bodies with the intent of unbalancing each other. As soon as you resort to brute force or resistance, you experience the benefit of instant feedback by flying off your feet.</p><p>A medieval samurai, however, didn’t have the luxury of learning by trial and error. A single premature guess could be his last one. A famous samurai’s resolve was to live his life as if he was “already dead.” Incidentally, it also helped their Zen training off the battlefield.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Mind and body, writes <a href="https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Untangling-Self/Andrew-Olendzki/9781614293002">Andrew Olendzki</a>, naturally respond with an attitude the Buddhists call “grasping.” Whether holding onto something or pushing it away, we unwittingly impose constraints on our self to ensure its persistence in the present form. Grasping is not simply done by the self; rather, self and grasping give rise to each other. As the Buddha put it, “only when there is what belongs to a self is there a self.” In the moment of trying to hold on to what is continually slipping away (or pushing away what is relentlessly advancing), a self is conjured up.</p><p>The word “effort” may invoke a sense of overcoming resistance or forcing things to do something different than they would do otherwise. The urge to apply effort (such as yanking a stuck drawer) comes from the memories of previously successful attempts (such as having the drawer open with a snap). The visceral sense of “trying hard” may not amount to much more than a brain’s heuristic for energizing the body toward achieving the implicit goal.</p><p>Yet while resistance naturally begets effort, we usually have some freedom to contemplate the problem until an insight reveals the source of confusion. When a drawer is stuck, something must be in the way (perhaps, a sock or a bent nail). When a car is stuck in snow or sand, it must be too slippery for the wheels to generate sufficient traction. When a teenager is stuck in the trance of worthlessness, she must be under a spell of dysfunctional memes. Once we understand the obstacle, however, we don’t have to face the false choice between resorting to brute force or giving up.</p><p>Seeing the tentative nature of our self dissolves the knots of resistance, making us more impervious to the personal barbs aimed at our “essence,” as if having shrunk to a point or become transparent. The boundary to what we can accept without resistance and denial, observes <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/16998/radical-acceptance-by-tara-brach/">Tara Brach</a>, is the boundary to our freedom. “See them, floundering in their sense of mine, like fish in the puddles of a dried-up stream,” said the Buddha, “and seeing this, live with no mine, not forming attachment for states of becoming.”</p><p>~~~</p><p>According to the Taoist wisdom, “if you realize that all things change, there is nothing you will try to hold on to.” Effortlessness is neither a state of mind to be cultivated nor an action to be performed (like surrender or relaxation). Rather, it is a perpetual readiness to let go of anything we are holding onto and engage with anything that is arising. If we give up trying to control our lives, we can get out of our own way and dissolve into the situation as it unfolds.</p><p>The emergent way is neither active nor passive since the very distinction assumes an independent actor: Either you made it happen or it happened to you. Yet every expression of Tao contains both an acting agent (“yang”) and a listening subject (“yin”) penetrating each other. When acting, you are fully engaged, yet there is a seed of readiness to change the course — otherwise, you would be endlessly stuck in your groove. When listening, you are fully receptive, yet there is a seed of action — otherwise, you would remain forever indecisive.</p><p>Listening against the background of noise requires a refined quality of attention — <em>sensitivity</em>. The word may refer to the ability of an organism to detect a faint external stimulus, of an immune system to respond to a mild allergen, of an electronic device to detect a weak signal, or of a mathematical model to produce noticeably changing outputs to the slightest variations in the inputs. Despite their apparent distinctions, all these definitions point to the same fundamental quality of discernment and responsiveness. (We can cultivate our sensitivity without turning “sensitive” in the modern sense of the word — on the contrary, becoming less brittle and more resilient in the process.)</p><p>For example, an old neurological method for measuring physical sensitivity involves gently touching a blindfolded patient with two adjacent needles and asking them to report whether a pinprick feels like a pair of distinct needles or a single one. The higher the sensitivity, the closer the needles have to be positioned before they become indistinguishable. Similarly, one is more sensitive when lifting a feather than when raising a barbell, as it would be easier to detect a fly landing on a feather. And when our sensitivity is not on par with the complexity of the challenge we are facing, we may fail to notice it, recognize it, understand it, and respond to it properly.</p><p>Sensitivity applies not only to our physical senses but also to our minds. Sensitive minds notice the shades of their thoughts and feelings, including how they are triggered and how their experiences unfold over time. Greater sensitivity lets us discern the subtleties that have escaped our notice earlier. It allows us to appreciate the dynamic complexity within ourselves and our interactions with the world. It helps restore healthy feedback loops, bringing us closer to our roots in living nature. Embracing the inherent uncertainty of life lets us choose sensitivity over willpower — or in the words of Ray Bradbury, touching our life instead of strangling it.</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>The Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://emergentway.medium.com/28-sitting-quietly-doing-nothing-choiceless-awareness-and-the-art-of-freedom-d0c94ea93c31"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ddcdc15fca73" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/27-emergent-way-a-journey-into-the-unknown-ddcdc15fca73">Emergent Way: A Journey into the Unknown</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Painting Legs on a Snake: Emptiness, Suchness, and Waking Up from the Story]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/26-painting-legs-on-a-snake-emptiness-suchness-and-waking-up-from-the-story-88377d38da74?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88377d38da74</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taoism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emergence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zen]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 20:41:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-14T17:15:41.408Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZO0VUdYZqxyuaKlN-HuWYA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Emptiness is relinquishing opinions. Believers in emptiness are incurable. (</em><a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/348383/verses-from-the-center-by-stephen-batchelor/"><em>Nagarjuna</em></a>)</p><p>The wetness of water emerges from the interaction of water molecules. It takes a handful of them to start exhibiting water-like properties that are distinct from those of individual molecules. In fact, our skin doesn’t even have specialized “wetness” receptors — the sensation arises from a complex combination of temperature and texture. The same holds for any complex system. The “catness” of a cat emerges from the interaction among its organs, cells, molecules, atoms, and so forth. To heed the warning of <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/681/the-ultimate-hitchhikers-guide-to-the-galaxy-by-douglas-adams/">Douglas Adams</a>, “if you try and take a cat apart to see how it works, the first thing you have on your hands is a non-working cat.” To spare the cat, imagine taking apart a car (a model one if you are frugal). There is no “car” in the pile of parts. Complex systems do not exist apart from the pattern of interaction between their elements.</p><p>A close observation of emergent phenomena such as “wetness” or “catness” reveals no permanent core, no essence that defines them. Referring to them as appearing and disappearing may be appealing but misleading. The rain starts upon a certain combination of atmospheric conditions — and when those conditions no longer hold, the rain stops. It does not go anywhere; it just no longer happens. Similarly, the sense of being an embodied self — a sentient entity we experience “inside” our body — is a manifestation of being a complex organism. Just like “catness” cannot be found among the parts of a cat, the embodied self cannot be found in neural processes, since it emerges from their interaction. And when the balancing loops that hold the system together unwind, its emptiness reveals itself. All that’s left behind are the building blocks, which are promptly absorbed by other, similarly empty systems.</p><p>The seemingly immaterial emerging properties have very tangible physical consequences. The self is a powerful and pervasive entity, exerting a very real hierarchical control over our perception and action. It would thus be misleading to treat it as a mere illusion. It takes a whole cat to put its legs in motion when its eyes see a mouse, and it takes a whole self to turn thirst into the action of walking toward a refrigerator. The intention to catch a mouse or to take a drink of milk can only be found in a cat and a self. It isn’t just my brain but my self, acting as an agent, that causes me to pour milk into a glass — with my thirst imposing constraints on my neurons to enable the action.</p><p>Neither cats nor selves exist independently of their parts. As emergent wholes, they are no less real than any of their parts. Nor are they any more real.</p><p>~~~</p><p>While the science of complexity is relatively recent, the concept of emergence is ancient. Great sages were particularly keen on glorifying the magic of something coming out of nothing. Taoists poetically conceived the universe as being fundamentally composed of “qi” and “li.” <em>Qi</em> described energy and matter in the universe, and <em>Li </em>depicted how energy and matter were organized. The interplay of qi and li was believed to determine every aspect of reality. Together, they were the manifestations of the <em>Tao</em> — spontaneous, creative, and indescribable, “the eternal void filled with infinite possibilities.” Taoist philosopher <a href="https://stephenmitchellbooks.com/translations-adaptations/tao-te-ching/">Lao Tzu</a> described being and non-being as creating each other. As he pointed out, it is the space within the vessel that makes it useful.</p><p>In some Buddhist traditions, the Taoist “eternal void” has been referred to as <em>emptiness</em>. According to <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/348383/verses-from-the-center-by-stephen-batchelor/">Stephen Batchelor</a>, Buddhist philosopher Nagarjuna described his teaching of “contingency” as the way to “ease fixations,” by which he meant our existential responses to uncertainty. Fixations imbue both the self and the things that surround it with tightness and solidity. Instead of enjoying the fluid reality of conditions that incessantly give rise to each other, wrote Nagarjuna, we prefer the safety of the one that appears predictable and manageable. Yet the insistence on being an independent self leads to a ceaseless conflict with the deeply interconnected world.</p><p>Just as water can only hold the shape imposed by the walls of a vessel, every living organism is a constellation of constraints that jointly hold the local biological processes at bay. Like the shape of a vessel, each constraint creates a potential for something to occupy the place within it. It is a placeholder for what is not there but could be. It points to the property of being restricted. It imposes limits on the system’s openness and freedom. In the words of <a href="https://wwnorton.com/books/Incomplete-Nature/">Terrence Deacon</a>, we are like the space in a mold that “represents a potential statue.”</p><p>Naturally, we can hardly imagine a world without constraints. The dissolution of social constraints annihilates society and produces anarchy. The dissolution of linguistic constraints annihilates meaning and produces gibberish. The dissolution of biological constraints annihilates life and produces death. The dissolution of physical constraints… What could be the practical benefit of dwelling on this ultimately dystopian vision? Yet hidden within it lies a simple realization that the insight into the nature of our constraints creates an opening for us to let go of the ones that have overstayed their welcome.</p><p>The Buddha identified the attachment to fixed forms as the very source of suffering and letting go of it— as a path to liberation. Our delusion, observes <a href="https://www.degruyter.com/columbia/view/title/515460">Evan Thompson</a>, is to mistake something dependent and contingent for something that’s independently existing. We don’t have to deconstruct our self or dismiss it as an illusion. But we can wake up to the dream of independent existence without having to wake up from dreaming.</p><p>~~~</p><p>A Buddhist allegory suggests that no courage is required to face a rope unless it is mistaken for a snake. We may routinely prefer the illusory safety of a familiar life story to the spontaneously unfolding reality. Yet we naturally stop being petrified by a nightmare upon realizing that we are dreaming and stop being afraid of horror movies after taking a moviemaking class. Similarly, as we gain deeper insights into our minds, we become more comfortable with letting ourselves be “consumed” by our creations.</p><p>Claiming an experience as “mine” amounts to simply inserting an unnecessary protagonist into an unfolding narrative — or, as a Zen saying goes, “painting legs on a snake.” Accepting the difficult chapters of our life story wouldn’t feel so painful if the story wasn’t about us. And when we recognize our stories as impersonal, our fears subside, transforming the challenges that appeared daunting into routine practical matters.</p><p>Paradoxically, the idea of ceasing to identify with the story of our self could become deeply embedded in our identity. It may feel tempting to entertain an image of walking as a “non-self” among confused selves (and perhaps, even posting a “no-selfie” on Facebook). Succumbing to this temptation, however, only feeds into the story, further complicating the challenge of seeing through it. Such “spiritual bypassing” is viewed by some Buddhist teachers as a common “peril of the path,” reflecting a widespread desire to “transcend” the self so that we could avoid dealing with our unresolved personal problems, circumvent life challenges, and boost our self-esteem. Stemming from the tradition of releasing the “spirit” from its physical confinement, observes <a href="https://www.hachettebooks.com/titles/jon-kabat-zinn/wherever-you-go-there-you-are/9781401394677/">Jon Kabat-Zinn</a>, it entices us to avoid the messiness of everyday living.</p><p>“Suchness,” a peculiar Zen attitude (often described as “nothing special”) keeps us from taking both the self and the one who sees “through it” too seriously. It encourages us to carry out everyday activities for their own sake. “Just sitting, just standing up, just putting on your shoes, just walking, just eating,” wrote <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/175559/zen-mind-beginners-mind-by-shunryu-suzuki/">Shunryu Suzuki</a>, without “adding anything extra.” We should expect most of our personal quirks, both good and ugly, to survive even the most profound insights into the emptiness of our nature. This sobering realization was succinctly brought home by a coworker of an ardent Zen practitioner who had just returned from a meditative retreat: “Same jerk but calmer.”</p><p>~~~</p><p>The word “self”, writes <a href="https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Untangling-Self/Andrew-Olendzki/9781614293002">Andrew Olendzki</a>, points to the essence beneath the changes that project stability and order. Nouns are artificial constructions, useful for everyday discourse but inadequate as tools for looking closely at the nature of reality. In contrast, the Buddha saw everything as being so thoroughly in flux that only verbs could describe the arising and passing of events.</p><p>Buddhist monks, writes Batchelor, reflect on everything that becomes manifest in their awareness through the lens of emptiness: “This is empty of a self or what belongs to a self.” For the Buddha, recognizing mental and physical processes as “empty” of self was the way to dispel the confusion of holding the self “as a fixed and opaque entity that feels disconnected from the dynamic, contingent and fluid processes of life.”</p><p>The experience of emptiness, observes Batchelor, is neither “a descent into an abyss of nothingness nor an ascent into a separate realm.” Rather, it is experienced as letting go of fixed ideas about oneself and the world, recovering the freedom to adapt oneself to the “ambiguous sands of life.” Emptiness “removes the false veneer of inherent existence.” Being empty of a fixed identity allows one “to enter fully into the shifting, beautiful and tragic contingencies of the world.”</p><p>Having recognized the illusion of persisting as a separate entity, do we simply dismiss our insight as a passing oddity and go on treating ourselves as residents and owners of our body, the recipients of our feelings, and the authors of our thoughts? Or can we learn to see ourselves as a process among processes rather than an object among objects? Can we flip our intuition about the self as if it were an optical illusion, from experiencing it as a self having a “stream of consciousness” to experiencing it as a consciousness having a “stream of selves”? Can we retain the memories of what was thought, felt, and done without identifying with them? Can we replace the “subject of experience” with the “subjectivity of experience”? Can we wake up from the story of our life?</p><p>And if we could, what would it feel like to be us?</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/27-emergent-way-a-journey-into-the-unknown-ddcdc15fca73"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88377d38da74" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/26-painting-legs-on-a-snake-emptiness-suchness-and-waking-up-from-the-story-88377d38da74">Painting Legs on a Snake: Emptiness, Suchness, and Waking Up from the Story</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The End of Becoming: Breaking the Spell of Enduring]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/25-the-end-of-becoming-breaking-the-spell-of-enduring-852dec1257c3?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/852dec1257c3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[illusion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 20:19:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-14T03:03:27.439Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vGMz9eNTvNH7wysg3Zni3Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>The more a thing tends to be permanent, the more it tends to be lifeless. (</em><a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/205321/the-wisdom-of-insecurity-by-alan-watts/"><em>Alan Watts</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>The abundance of magical transformations in fairy tales reveals our ancestors’ aspirations to shatter the confines of the original form. In ancient Greek mythology, the Phoenix was a symbol of regeneration and renewal, which routinely burned up in flames and then swiftly arose from the ashes. Was the Phoenix one bird or many? At each moment, the Phoenix had the body of a particular bird, but when it was gone, only the bird ceased to exist — the Phoenix came back to life again in the body of a new bird.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Time-lapse photography is simple. You capture static images at constant intervals and then play them together. Different intervals between shots create different experiences of the world. Seconds, and a turtle is galloping across the room. Minutes, and clouds are flooding the sky like a torrential river. Hours, and a caterpillar is solidifying into a chrysalis and exploding into a butterfly. Days, and a seed springs up, shooting out leaves. Weeks, and a baby is turning into a toddler. Months, and a toddler is becoming an adult… But why stop there? Years, and a forest is erupting from a prairie. Centuries, and a river is changing its course. Millennia, and mountains are rising and falling. Epochs, and stars are forming and exploding, flickering like fireflies as they spin wildly inside their galaxies.</p><p>This is not the world we are used to inhabiting. Turtles and clouds move slowly, plants are mostly inert, and mountains appear immune to change for most practical purposes. We are naturally inclined to experience the human frame of reference as privileged, but that doesn’t make it special. Observing anything on a long enough time scale would reveal its <em>impermanence </em>or the lack of a fixed form. From that timeless vantage point, we may notice, in the words of <a href="https://www.newharbinger.com/nothing-grasp">Joan Tollifson</a>, that life flows naturally through the “cycles of darkness and light, summer and winter, birth and death, grasping and relaxing, expanding and contracting, inhaling and exhaling … all of it one undivided movement.”</p><p>The very notion of impermanence seems to go against the grain. It may strike us as peculiar to view something as being “stuck” with remaining itself. We take the homeostatic stability of biological entities for granted and rarely pity a flower for being doomed to remain a flower. Persisting as a particular object is just a single configuration out of the virtually infinite space of all possible particle arrangements. There are always more ways of not being something than of being it. Having a particular meaning is just a tiny island in a vast sea of gibberish. Similarly, remaining “yourself” is just a single instance out of endless possibilities of being a person. As far as surviving as a particular individual is concerned, most changes are for the worse. It is therefore not surprising that everything tries to maintain itself by relying on a few familiar patterns to ensure its own persistence.</p><p>Most human cultures value tenacity. Adherence to the chosen course of action “no matter what” is often touted as a sign of perseverance — even if we wouldn’t have chosen it again with the benefit of hindsight. Psychologists call the inclination to dig in our heels and resist change no matter what “the escalation of commitment,” and economists refer to it as “honoring the sunk cost.” We often persist to save face, avoid dissonance, and most importantly, maintain a coherent life story. Managers justify their continuous investments into doomed projects by the money already spent. Generals justify protracted military conflicts by the lives already lost. Gamblers justify raising the stakes with bets that can no longer be recovered. The rest of us justify the need for watching a boring movie or gobbling down a tasteless meal by pointing out that they have already been paid for — even though we would have politely declined to indulge in either if it were offered to us for free. And, of course, we often stick by our emotional investments into committed relationships that we would not have entered the second time around.</p><p>Yet not all cultures choose to resist change. For example, Buddhist monks have been celebrating the beauty of impermanence for many centuries. An ancient practice in the Tibetan tradition involves meticulously constructing mandalas out of vividly colored sand grains, dropping one after another for days and weeks. When the mandala is finally completed, the monks spend a few hours celebrating the intricate image — then sweep it away, turn around, and leave.</p><p>~~~</p><p>We express our resistance to change by ceaselessly struggling to preserve our identity on every level — while also ardently seeking to transcend it. This ambivalence reflects the propensity of all organisms to maintain their present form while “striving” to evolve. But when it comes to impermanence, we have a way of departing from the rest of living nature. Most animal babies arrive into the world with their sensory-motor system fully operational and start following their mothers within minutes of being born. Humans, in contrast, may take years to mature, which allows them to adapt to the environment they find themselves in.</p><p>Unlike a computer that gets assembled in a factory and turned on for the first time after it is complete, points out <a href="https://stevenpinker.com/publications/blank-slate">Steven Pinker</a>, “the brain is active while it is being assembled, and that activity may take part in the assembly process.” Perhaps, suggests <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/217866/livewired-by-david-eagleman/">David Eagleman</a>, our minds may become less flexible with experience not because of aging but as a byproduct of an evolutionary survival strategy? Once our brain believes it has figured things out, why fix what ain’t broken? Do we really want to regain the plasticity of a child only to avail ourselves of new mistakes over and over again?</p><p>One might assume that our brains simply grow new connections as we grow older. Yet it turns out that the brains of newborns have more neural pathways than those of adults. Such flexibility makes it easier for human babies to engage with anything they encounter in a variety of ways. Full of curiosity and wonder, they explore the world with all of their senses — looking, listening, touching, smelling, licking. They sure wouldn’t miss a gorilla stomping across the room.</p><p>Our brain maps start out looking more like old towns crisscrossed with narrow roads than urban centers connected with fast highways. However, as we grow older and more “experienced,” our brains prune out the connections that are used infrequently and strengthen the ones that we tend to rely on more often. “Maturity” limits our focus to a cramped space of familiar possibilities that have been of relevance to our past successes. Instead of focusing on a single object of interest and shutting down everything else, observes <a href="http://alisongopnik.com/ThePhilosophicalBaby.htm">Alison Gopnik</a>, babies “seem to be vividly experiencing everything at once” as they “paddle in the pond of consciousness instead of coursing down that rushing stream.” The “attentional spotlight” of adults is an “attentional lantern” of babies that has narrowed down as we have gotten older.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Our perception creates the illusion of enduring entities by segregating the steady influx of sensory impressions into familiar categories and then integrating them into perceived events. It makes us experience a stable world full of objects that we can keep track of. We usually see movement rather than a chain of independent static images and hear meaningful statements rather than a cacophony of sounds (as if listening to an unfamiliar foreign language).</p><p>Stage magicians rely on the illusion of continuity when substituting an object to create an impression that the original one was magically transformed. Similarly, rapidly alternating static frames give rise to an immersive experience of a motion film. Just as the mind sees the succession of still photos as a single fluid event, observes <a href="https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Untangling-Self/Andrew-Olendzki/9781614293002">Andrew Olendzki</a>, it sees the succession of discrete “selves” as part of a cohesive self. Once we shake off the illusion and find ourselves staring at the flashes of light dancing on a flat screen, the plot loses its grip, and we are left to continue enjoying the director’s ingenuity without falling compulsively under its sway.</p><p>We unwittingly maintain the apparent continuity of the self through numerous feedback loops powered by our idiosyncratic habits and preferences. (The trance may be occasionally lifted when we become completely immersed in an absorbing activity and “lose ourselves” in it.) If we give ourselves time to patiently observe our experience, we eventually discover a thorough-going flux in which everything is inseparable from everything else.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Next time you are standing at the ocean shore, try to remain still while watching the waves. Their crests may look like stable “chunks” of water advancing toward the shore and disappearing into the sand. However, observes Tollifson, no wave is any closer to the ocean than any other one. The ocean does not go anywhere. A wave is (mostly) an up-and-down motion that propagates energy across the ocean surface. When the waves meet, they simply pass through each other instead of trying to negotiate their identity. You may suspend the illusion of a moving wave by noticing that a floating object (such as a resting seagull) is not getting any closer to the shore. You can also re-create the illusion at home by tying a soft rope to a door handle and shaking it. The wave will appear to “travel” from your hand to the door, while the rope will just as obviously remain in place. No wave exists as a separate or persisting thing — there is simply “waving.” Perhaps, the universe is simply “selfing”?</p><p>The “self” is no more different from “selfing” than the dance — from dancing. It must appear as something distinct from the stream because that’s precisely what a self is — an imaginative construction that presents itself to us as an independent subject of experience moving through time. Yet we continuously fail to see it as waves of impersonal awareness rising and falling away. Instead, our brain stubbornly creates the appearance of a continuous self just as it generates the illusion of a solitary wave traveling across the ocean surface toward its sandy grave.</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/26-painting-legs-on-a-snake-emptiness-suchness-and-waking-up-from-the-story-88377d38da74"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=852dec1257c3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/25-the-end-of-becoming-breaking-the-spell-of-enduring-852dec1257c3">The End of Becoming: Breaking the Spell of Enduring</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[At One with Everything: The Paradoxes of Teleportation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/24-at-one-with-everything-the-paradoxes-of-teleportation-3bc267ba8737?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3bc267ba8737</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[empathy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thought-experiment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 19:35:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-14T02:46:01.947Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wqxYwzr7hYdwk2ItW-qFLQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>If I had direct access to the other’s experiences, the difference between the two of us would disappear. (Edmund Husserl)</em></p><p>You press a button, lose consciousness, and wake up after what seems like a moment later. While you were unconscious, a replicating device (the Scanner) extracted all your information and beamed it to Mars. Your Original body was then destroyed (by the Recycler). Meanwhile, on Mars, another machine (the Replicator) reconstructed you as an organic Replica, identical to the Original. In fact, the Replica believes to be you and remembers living your life up to the moment when you (the Original) pressed the fateful button.</p><p>This isn’t a Transporter from Star Trek but a classic thought experiment on personal identity. Without getting hung up on sci-fi technicalities, let’s consider the real question: Assuming the technology involved has proven to be perfectly safe and reliable, would you be willing to press the button? Do you believe that “you” would survive the teleportation (as the Replica) and find “yourself” on Mars? Or would you become someone else who only looks, thinks, and feels just like you but isn’t the real “you”? In other words, do you believe that after the physical destruction of the Original, your awareness would cease?</p><p>Responding that you will <em>not </em>survive the teleportation would betray an implicit assumption that “you” are more than anything physical that could be re-created with a distinct set of particles (even though the particles in your own body are routinely refreshed). So, for now, let’s assume that your Original experience will indeed persist in the Replica following the teleportation.</p><p>Now, let’s take some creative license with the story. It turned out that the technology was not perfectly reliable after all. Instead of destroying your body before it was reconstructed on Mars, the Recycler jammed, and you will now have to wait until tomorrow before it is fixed and you (the Original) can be properly annihilated. Meanwhile, you got a call from the Replica who assured you that your awareness has been perfectly preserved. Does teleportation still feel like a good idea? Would you (the Original) feel better if you found out that the Replicator glitched, and it was your Replica destined to die tomorrow instead? Do you think Replica would have shared your preferences? (You are still pretty much identical, after all.)</p><p>If you are feeling somehow suspicious about comparing the Original with the Replica, let’s have two blueprints beamed out to Mars, with the Original timely destroyed. Which of the two copies (if any) will be the “real you”? In other words, upon waking up after the teleportation, which of the two space travelers will you find yourself persisting as?</p><p>Still unsure? Let’s do away with the classic setup altogether. A blindfolded technician has performed an MRI scan of your body and produced two carbon copies on a biological 3D printer, so precise that no physical test can possibly distinguish between the two Replicas and the Original. Which one is the “real” you? Or are there now three “real youse” existing in the world? (The proper plural of the pronoun “you” is a matter of heated debate in some philosophical and linguistic communities.)</p><p>By now, you may be convinced that the question has been meaningless all along. If we assume that “you” are the result of a material process, it follows that your self can be endlessly replicated. Hard as it might be to imagine, you are not bound to remain unique.</p><p>Are you satisfied with this conclusion? Then let’s throw in another twist.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Until now, we have been treating the Scanner and the Replicator as precise (albeit glitchy) technologies for creating “perfect twins.” In addition to taking something real and imagining it to be perfect, thought experiments can take something perfect and mess it up. (At least, mine do.) From now on, our technology will keep both the Original and the Replica alive and well — but not necessarily fully identical.</p><p>Suppose that you (the Replica) wake up on Mars experiencing yourself as the same person who walked into the Scanner earlier that morning. There is a minor difference, though. When you think back to being picked up by a cab on your way to scanning, you recall it as being yellow — whereas, in fact, it was white. Obviously, you have no way of catching the error (unless the subject happens to inexplicably come up in your conversation with the Original). Now, imagine instead that you remember your cab looking like a cartoonish Disney car with Donald Duck at the wheel. This time, you will probably start your Martian tenure by teleconferencing a psychiatrist.</p><p>If this scenario sounds too extreme, let’s soften it. Imagine feeling perfectly fine during your first day on Mars. Suddenly, you have a vivid memory of enjoying a romantic candlelight dinner with your best friend’s spouse. Struck by this unlikely occurrence, you also recall the two of you holding hands on the edge of the Grand Canyon. (No worries, the plot will remain family-friendly.) While you have never been to the Grand Canyon, you recall your friend telling you about their recent trip… In an instant, your bewilderment gives way to an incredible realization. You rush to the bathroom and stare at yourself in the mirror, only to discover that your dark brown eyes have turned steely gray… just like those of your friend.</p><p>What’s going on here? Let me admit to having secretly added a “morphing” device (the Blender) next to the Scanner. The evil scientist has obtained the scans from both you and your friend, with the intent of morphing one into the other. To reduce the shock, the Blender was initially set to 99% of “you.” Now, let’s start turning the dial down. At 98%, to your genuine surprise, you recall a few Norwegian words. At 90%, you are perplexed to find out that you no longer need a step stool to reach the lightbulb. Meanwhile, the dial keeps turning.…</p><p>Before you are thrown into complete disarray, let’s add an option to the Blender — the Smoother. When selected, the Smoother ensures that the blending creates no dissonance. As the dial continues to turn, your changes occur “in batches” to keep your “memories” internally consistent. The resulting life story is now assured to remain coherent at every step of the transformation. For example, at the first appearance of your friend’s spouse, all memories of your own spouse are erased. The same goes for your hairstyle, caffeine addiction, and fondness for YouTube science channels.</p><p>The dial has turned all the way down to zero and stopped. Now, you <em>are</em> your friend. No physical device or psychological test could possibly distinguish between the two of you. Are you still “you”? Or do you and your friend now share the same self? Otherwise, have you disappeared somewhere along the way? Where? And how would you know if you did?</p><p>It appears that for as long as you are alive, your self is impossible to get away from. It may hide when you aren’t looking (akin to Schrödinger’s cat), but otherwise, it follows you like a shadow. It reappears at every moment of self-consciousness despite the drastic changes that your body and mind continuously undergo throughout your life. It comes back after dreamless sleep, loss of consciousness, general anesthesia, and out-of-body experience. It survives teleportation, merging, splitting, and morphing. Are you doomed to identify with this endlessly tenacious ghost traveling through your life?</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>The Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/25-the-end-of-becoming-breaking-the-spell-of-enduring-852dec1257c3"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3bc267ba8737" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/24-at-one-with-everything-the-paradoxes-of-teleportation-3bc267ba8737">At One with Everything: The Paradoxes of Teleportation</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Barriers to Love: Dropping Every Mask]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/23-the-barriers-to-love-dropping-every-mask-efadf864cf0b?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/efadf864cf0b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[empathy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[acting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[compassion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 19:17:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-14T02:29:21.786Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rAtykhpmkMhbqWxSSQoWWg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Your task is not to seek for love, but merely to seek and find all the barriers within yourself that you have built against it. (Rumi)</em></p><p>If you look into my eyes, you will see another person like yourself. However, that would be just a projection. If you were to open my skull, you wouldn’t find any traces of my awareness within a walnut-shaped spongy object. How do you know I am not a philosophical zombie, a biological robot, a mere sentient look-alike? Is it only because of the similarities in our anatomy and behavior that you expect my experience of you to resemble your experience of me?</p><p>~~~</p><p>In the past, neurologists who tackled particularly difficult cases of untreatable epilepsy often had no choice but to sever the connection between the two brain hemispheres. The “split-brain” patients appeared unchanged from the outside and did not report feeling in any way peculiar. The first clues of the two separate minds came from observing the brain halves exhibiting conflicting intentions. For example, a split-brain man trying to undress could be pulling his pants down with one hand while pulling them up with the other hand. Similarly, a split-brain supermarket shopper could be seen picking items off a shelf with one hand while putting them back on the shelf with the other one. Some ingenious experiments carefully routed images to separated hemispheres that could no longer communicate with each other. As a result, when was shown a funny image, a patient insisted that she didn’t see anything — while giggling and making up confabulations when asked to explain her amusement.</p><p>What could be going on here? Split hemispheres still share the brainstem, one of the oldest structures we inherited from reptiles, which regulates physiological functions such as arousal, breathing, and heartbeat. We often get away with making little use of our evolutionarily recent frontal lobes, but once the brain stem shuts down, we are dead. Yet the entire self cannot reside in the brain stem, for otherwise we would arrive at a peculiar conclusion that most of the brain plays no role in the workings of the self (and even worse, that reptiles may be no different from us). Could it be that each patient’s self was genuinely split into two separate ones, living side by side yet unaware of each other’s existence?</p><p>On the other hand, perhaps it is not the unusual splintering of the self that requires explaining but the routine fusion of our experience into a unified whole? The question extends beyond our skulls. What would happen if instead of connecting the two <em>hemispheres</em>, we were to connect two <em>brains</em> into a super-brain? The mind spanning these four hemispheres would see with four eyes, hear with four ears, speak with two mouths, and share autobiographical memories of two lives. The next logical step, surmises <a href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/feeling-life-itself">Christof Koch</a>, would be “brain bridging” — a futuristic neurotechnology that safely links two brains in a similar way that the two hemispheres of our brains are normally linked. The brain bridge would engage gradually, starting with just a handful of neurons and then cranking up. As more and more neurons are interconnected, there must come a point when both persons’ conscious experiences of the world vanish, their individual selves cease to exist, and “a new amalgamated or blended mind” emerges in their place.</p><p>What if instead of a surgical fusion, the blending unfolds “bottom-up,” through the sensory channels? Imagine that you and your friend are simultaneously touching an apple. Presumably, both of you have a similar feeling of a smooth, cool surface. Now, move your fingers closer, until you are touching it at almost the same spot. If you think “almost” is not enough, imagine your fingers merging (as if you were turning into conjoined twins). Both of you are now feeling the same spot on the apple. As the merging spreads, the sensory signal travels up the same nerve in your shared hand. The elbows have merged, the shoulders, the necks. You are now sharing the spinal cord. If your fused finger was pricked, both of you would reflexively withdraw the shared hand, but your conscious experiences of the touch (residing in the brain) would still be unique.</p><p>Finally, your brains are fully merged. What does the apple feel like now? And which one of you is feeling it? And, by the way, what has just happened to your boundary?</p><p>~~~</p><p>If a full brain fusion sounds far-fetched, imagine instead a device that allows couples to directly experience their partner’s physiological parameters such as breathing rate, temperature, galvanic skin response — or any other measure that would provide them with a visceral window into each other’s emotional states. Would it have the potential of unlocking a new depth of mutual understanding, wonders <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/217866/livewired-by-david-eagleman/">David Eagleman</a>? After all, such technology appears quite feasible in the foreseeable future. “Brain-to-brain interfaces” are already capable of establishing connections between brains to transfer motor control signals (albeit, still rather basic). It even allows a human to move a rat’s tail with a mental command (which may not be the most technically advanced, but certainly the coolest).</p><p>Do we really need a physical interface between two brains to share another person’s experience? Although we may not know what it is like to be someone else, we project intentions, perceptions, and beliefs into each other’s minds routinely and effortlessly (if not always accurately). The ability to peek into the physical and emotional states of others must have conferred obvious social advantages. Some highly sensitive people spontaneously resonate with the perceived feelings of others. (Unsurprisingly, the condition is called “mirror-touch synesthesia.”) In a sense, they become “human chameleons.” Such people may try to avoid being around angry or stressed-out people, and when they must stay in a large group, they often find relief by focusing on a comfortable-looking person.</p><p>How can human chameleons come about? According to one popular theory, evolution has sidestepped the inconvenience of merging nerves by opting for a wireless option. “Mirror neurons” respond in a similar way whether one is performing an action or observing it being performed by another person. (Instead of dedicated neurons specialized in mind reading, there might be a general capacity to simulate the observed states of another person — but the term still sounds like a good shorthand.) <a href="https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393340624">V.S. Ramachandran</a> called mirror neurons the “nature’s own virtual-reality simulations of the intentions of other beings” that “blur the boundary between self and others … the closest thing to telepathy that nature was able to endow us with.” Even an amputee watching someone fondle an ice cube may feel the cold in his phantom fingers. Where do “his body, his phantom body, and a stranger’s body meld in his mind”?</p><p>~~~</p><p>On the surface, the theory of natural selection seems to imply that living creatures should be selfish. The time you spend caring for others is the time you could have spent promoting the survival of your genes. However, that’s not what we observe in the organisms that have evolved in close dependence on each other, both within their groups and across their ecosystem. Evolution may have predisposed us to care not only for our children but for all children of the tribe (you know, just in case). Apparently, a community of individuals who are prepared to sacrifice themselves for the welfare of others may be less likely to go extinct than rivals who always place their selfish interests first.</p><p>Communities are interdependent systems. According to the theory of group selection, the world is largely inhabited by the species that may choose to care for others at the detriment of their own interests. This evolved propensity may be experienced as <em>compassion</em>. Yet despite our noble intentions, blind compassion may lead to unwanted (and often, mutually frustrating) interference in the lives of others. The missing ingredient is <em>empathy</em>, the ability to understand and share others’ feelings. Needless to say, empathy involves no mind-reading, as we can only “model” the minds of others based on our own experiences, assumptions, interpretations, and sometimes, wishful thinking.</p><p>Operating on its own, empathy is likely to produce a bully or a sleazy manipulator. But even combined with compassion, it may occasionally get in the way of helpful action. Our brain needs to perform a delicate balancing act of preserving empathy while preventing over-empathy. (Just imagine being operated on by a teary-eyed over-empathic surgeon.) If unchecked, empathy may erase our boundaries altogether, not only making us “one with everything” but also forcing us to feel everyone else’s pain. Is this what we have bargained for? Perhaps, suggests <a href="http://alisongopnik.com/ThePhilosophicalBaby.htm">Alison Gopnik</a>, the real secret of altruism is trying to allay the pain of others even when you don’t feel it yourself? Meanwhile, if you are offered an empathy enhancer, don’t rush to consume it in a single gulp.</p><p>~~~</p><p>We start learning to understand “other minds” early on. Just as kittens spend their days mock-fighting and mock-hunting, young children enjoy role-playing and “make-believe” games. Hardwired from birth to learn by imitation, observes <a href="https://www.northatlanticbooks.com/shop/the-book-of-not-knowing/">Peter Ralston</a>, both kittens and children are preparing for the respective challenges of their adult lives. We don’t have to be children (at least, by age) to adopt virtual identities. We do so routinely while interacting with our bosses, parents, partners, friends, and kids, picturing ourselves as our favorite book and movie characters, or stepping into virtual worlds as online avatars. As we experience unyielding social pressures to imitate our role models, it becomes natural for us to internalize their influences.</p><p>Some of us are drawn to stage performances and even go on to become professional actors, apparently unable to resist the appeal of stepping into imaginary lives. Convincing acting requires that we suspend both our disbelief in the reality of the fictitious plot and our belief in the reality of our own life story. Nevertheless, we can take advantage of our life experiences to go deeper into the lives of our characters. It may be harder to go the other way, though, approaching our everyday existence as a theatrical performance, playing our part in the comedy of life without identifying with our role.</p><p>Imagine yourself as an actor capable of perfectly reproducing your friend’s state of mind in every minute detail. You start by learning to mimic her idiosyncratic movements, gestures, reactions, facial expressions, tone of voice, and so on, until you appear to behave just like her. Then you assume her beliefs, preferences, and thinking style until you can imitate her responses in every situation. Finally, with the help of the necessary sci-fi props, you internalize her unique patterns of experience, gradually reducing the difference between your brain states until you can impersonate her feelings and emotions. Soon, you completely adopt her physical and mental habits. Now, what distinguishes you from your friend?</p><p>~~~</p><p>The “allegory of the long spoons,” encountered in multiple ancient cultures, describes two versions of a banquet: one in heaven and the other in hell. In both scenarios, the diners have long spoons attached tightly to their arms. People in hell are starving, as they cannot lift the food to their mouths without dropping it. In contrast, people in heaven are thriving, as they feed each other across the table.</p><p>Sharing our eyes to help each other gain insight into our blind spots is the closest that our minds can get to feeding each other with long spoons. We can inquire into our everyday experience through open listening — to a bird, to the wind, to ourselves and others. Listening without having to defend our opinions, promote our agendas, boost our self-esteem, or placate our anxiety. Peering through the layers of masks that we have grown in response to social pressures and seeing each other without images and expectations, as if for the first time, and becoming aware of our deep similarities. Looking through the mirror of each other’s eyes and recognizing our private selves as impersonal reflections of our shared condition.</p><p>As our protective boundaries dissolve, our minds may someday reach across the metaphysical divide to merge into a greater, wiser whole.</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/3bc267ba8737"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=efadf864cf0b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/23-the-barriers-to-love-dropping-every-mask-efadf864cf0b">The Barriers to Love: Dropping Every Mask</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Forget the Self: Exploring the Boundaries of the Mind]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/22-to-forget-the-self-exploring-the-boundaries-of-the-mind-6e5b5b577a0c?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e5b5b577a0c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nonduality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[embodiment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 18:05:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-13T20:13:35.434Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kWPD1uhU9YI9VFd4n17ruQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>“To study the Way is to study the self.</em></p><p><em>To study the self is to forget the self.</em></p><p><em>To forget the self is to be enlightened by all things.</em></p><p><em>To be enlightened by all things is to remove the barriers between one’s self and others.”</em></p><p><em>(</em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%C5%8Dgen"><em>Dōgen Zenji</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>“I have a report,” said Porcupine. “This morning when the birds woke me up, I realized that my quills and my skin don’t delineate me.” “What delineates you?” asked Raven. “You always blink when you ask a hard question,” said Porcupine. Raven said, “You are very observant.” (<a href="https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Zen-Master-Raven/Robert-Aitken/9781614293842">Robert Aitken</a>)</p><p>~~~</p><p>What delineates your embodied self? What separates you from your surroundings? How do you distinguish yourself from the chair you sit in, the clothes you wear, the space you occupy, and the people you meet? In other words, where is your <em>boundary</em>?</p><p>The boundary separates the entities that are inside the system from those that are outside of it. This common-sense definition is not only circular but vague, since the boundary is in the eye of the beholder, and deciding where to draw it may be far from obvious. Is the light switch inside or outside an electric circuit? If the walls, the foundation, and the roof delineate a house, are water lines inside or outside of it? Once you have flushed the toilet, how long does the sewage remain inside your house? (You may ask a similar question about your body.) What about your mind? Is this question inside or outside of it?</p><p>The boundary is not a physical container but a mental model used for convenience. Drawing different boundaries will lead to different mental models, which will lead to different physical outcomes. To make sense of a system’s behavior, it often helps to expand its perceived boundary — or quite literally, “think outside the box.” For example, to understand the forest ecosystem, we may need to go from seeing each tree as being enclosed within the physical boundaries of the bark to considering its symbiotic relationships with other trees (such as in aspen colonies) and forest inhabitants, both plants and animals — or, to use another idiom, to “see the forest for the trees.” Closer to home, viewing the gut microbiota as an integral part of our organism may affect our approach to diet and treatment.</p><p>The boundary process of living organisms evolved with the development of cell membranes and the immune system to protect the cells from intruders. When the earliest single-cell organisms established boundaries between themselves and the outside world, they laid the foundation for the separation between self and non-self. However, any physical interface that represents the boundary of a living system — a membrane, cell wall, or skin — is only a convenient means of describing an otherwise purely dynamic distinction, observes <a href="https://wwnorton.com/books/Incomplete-Nature/">Terrence Deacon</a>. Living organisms are open systems that exchange energy with their environment. When the exchange stops, the system closes down and dies.</p><p>Each emerging level of organization becomes a new “self,” simultaneously creating the “other,” which includes everything that doesn’t belong to it. By identifying the environment as being on the “outside”, the boundary reciprocally locates the organism as being on the “inside” (looking out). We may still compare brains to cellular membranes that mediate their interactions with the outside world. In contrast with fixed cellular interfaces, however, our self continuously changes its boundaries. There is no place within our brain for the homunculus to hide.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Besides altering their environments by erecting physical shelters and barriers within their biological niches, animals (from ants to birds to beavers) also construct “cognitive niches” — essentially, creating affordances, such as tools — that enhance their ability to solve survival problems. Similarly, we use tools and language to make our physical and social worlds friendlier for the brains like ours. Consider a child solving an arithmetic problem in a notebook. The loop through pen and paper, observes <a href="https://global.oup.com/academic/product/supersizing-the-mind-9780195333213?cc=us&amp;lang=en&amp;">Andy Clark</a>, helps to shape the flow of thoughts in her brain. Since she could choose to solve the problem either internally (in her mind) or externally (using her fingers, paper, or a calculator), how important is the difference between the “internal” mind and its external props?</p><p>The mere fact that a routinely used prop happens to be external to the physical brain doesn’t stop it from being a part of the mind. Clark invites us to imagine three people playing Tetris. The first one performs physical rotations using key presses, as in the classic computer game. The second one rotates the shapes in her mind to determine the fit as if performing a mental rotation exercise on an aptitude test. The third one executes the rotation with the benefit of a neuroprosthetic that has augmented (or even replaced) her brain areas originally responsible for mental rotation, making it just as easy as using the rotate button. How essential is the difference between these ways of playing? If in doubt, consider an alien player, which has evolved the cognitive equipment required for a mental rotation that functions just like the brain implant used by the third player. Would you still hesitate to classify this brain function as part of the alien mind?</p><p>Numerous sensory and cognitive feedback loops already crisscross the boundaries of the brain, the body, and the world, quite literally extending our mind beyond the body. These self-defining processes, suggests <a href="https://www.degruyter.com/columbia/view/title/515460">Evan Thompson</a>, support an <em>interoceptive</em> sense of self — a feeling of our body from within that connects our embodied self to the world. As cyborgs are stepping off the sci-fi pages into everyday life, the evolution of high-tech adaptations may eventually obviate the distinction, relegating it to the archive of ancient superstitions.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Can your self actually escape its physical boundary? Apparently, it can. The “out-of-body experience” (OBE) is a vivid disembodied sensation described as seeing the world from a perspective other than your physical location. During an OBE, the self “separates” from its body and identifies with something else. It could be experienced while one is falling asleep and suddenly having a distinct feeling of floating up to the ceiling and looking back down at their body in bed. While floating up, recounts <a href="https://www.oliversacks.com/books-by-oliver-sacks/hallucinations/">Oliver Sacks</a>, one may have their senses “unusually sharp,” feel “a wonderful peaceful bliss,” and find it difficult to believe they are experiencing a hallucination. In rare OBE cases called “doppelgänger,” a full-body analog of the phantom limb, the brain may end up creating two body images instead of one and then feel another body of theirs nearby. A still spookier type of doppelgänger, “autoscopy” (the Greek for “self-watcher”), even allows one to interact with their double.</p><p>Our holistic sense of embodied self is not immune to scientific exploration under carefully controlled experimental conditions. According to <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/306248/the-spiritual-doorway-in-the-brain-by-kevin-nelson/">Kevin Nelson</a>, applying electric current to a particular brain area can reliably trigger an OBE experience “with the mechanical predictability of turning on a light switch.” One may feel lightness and “float” several feet above the body whenever the current is turned on, promptly “returning” into the body when it is turned off as if being summoned by the press of an elevator button.</p><p>An OBE can also be induced without direct manipulation of the brain. A trick similar to the rubber hand illusion may work for the entire self. Imagine wearing a pair of special goggles connected to a video camera. A partner walks a few feet behind you with the camera (so that you could continuously see yourself from the same external perspective), repeatedly touching your back with a stick. You feel the stroking of your back while also seeing the stick touching the back of your “virtual” body in the video. Eventually, you may start feeling yourself inside your virtual body strolling several feet ahead of your physical one.</p><p>OBEs aren’t experiences of disembodiment but rather of altered embodiment, suggests Thompson. OBEs reveal that your sense of who you are and where you’re located goes with your self-as-subject and not your body-as-object.</p><p>~~~</p><p>What can be more familiar than the sense of being grounded in our body? Yet the boundaries of our minds are even more permeable than those of our bodies. Some stroke victims may fail to clearly discern where they begin and end, no longer capable of perceiving themselves as an integrated entity separate from everything else. Instead, in the words of <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/304515/my-stroke-of-insight-by-jill-bolte-taylor/">Jill Taylor</a>, they may feel “blended in with the space and flow” around them, with their physical boundaries no longer limited to where their skin meets air, as “a genie liberated from its bottle.”</p><p>Our boundary is not a place but an experience. As we grow up, we learn to think of ourselves as separate individuals encapsulated inside our bodies, “looking out” at the world from behind our eyes. And yet, this separation is conceptual. The brain reconstructs our body image every waking moment based on sensory feedback. To anchor the self to the body, it must combine numerous internal and external sensations.</p><p>Your embodied self is a bandage wrapped around an “invisible man.” What would happen to your sense of separation if the bandage was removed, and you experienced your imaginary boundary as a ceaseless flow of sensations rather than a solid container? Where would you begin and end? What would separate you, the experiencer, from the experience itself?</p><p>When internalized deeply, this perspective may irreversibly change our relationship with the world. Experiencing our personal boundaries as the figments of our imagination may dissolve the claustrophobic bubble of separation, revealing that we are a lot less insulated than we had realized. Without the solid ground of a fixed identity under our feet, the human condition may still feel like a tasteless cosmic prank — but not a tragic one. And some of us may find this realization eminently satisfying.</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>The Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/23-the-barriers-to-love-dropping-every-mask-efadf864cf0b"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e5b5b577a0c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/22-to-forget-the-self-exploring-the-boundaries-of-the-mind-6e5b5b577a0c">To Forget the Self: Exploring the Boundaries of the Mind</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Edges of the Self: Proprioception, Neuroprosthetics, and Expanding Beyond]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/21-the-edges-of-the-self-proprioception-neuroprosthetics-and-expanding-beyond-a4c9217e1503?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a4c9217e1503</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-mind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transhumanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[illusion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 17:08:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-13T16:42:05.014Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b8QeBh-KJ5_6Gma81yUNdg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>It’s all a matter of making friends with the Malkovich body. Rather than being an enemy that must be pounded into submission, I began imagining it as a really expensive suit I enjoy wearing. (</em><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Being_John_Malkovich"><em>Being John Malkovich</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>Imagine being asked to touch your nose with your right index finger (a standard neurological test). As you do it, the neurologist gently vibrates your biceps tendon. Unbeknownst to you, the vibration stimulates muscle spindles in the biceps that would normally be stimulated by the muscle’s stretching, creating a kinesthetic illusion that the arm is moving away from the face. However, the touch sensation on the nose tells the brain that the hand is not moving. But the nose is also not moving… The only way your brain can make sense of these conflicting inputs is to create an experience of the tip of your nose moving toward your finger — that is, growing longer. Fortunately, once the vibration stops, the nose rapidly returns to its normal length. This phenomenon was aptly named the “Pinocchio illusion.”</p><p>~~~</p><p>Poetically described by <a href="https://www.oliversacks.com/books-by-oliver-sacks/hallucinations/">Oliver Sacks</a> as “the eyes of the body,” <em>proprioception</em> anchors you to your physical self. It never occurs to you that your hand may not belong to you. This is fortunate because you wouldn’t get far without recognizing yourself as the owner of your hand. But your seamless experience of being-in-the-body is not something that you just carry around. Rather, it is sustained by real-time feedback from the host of receptors in your skin, muscles, joints, and tendons. These receptors support your proprioception by continuously informing the brain of your limbs’ position and movement in space.</p><p>Proprioception not only serves as the foundation of the embodied self but also teams up with other senses to help define its outer limits. As you observe your arms and legs moving with respect to one another and external objects, the visual and proprioceptive feedback support each other in creating the immersive experience. When you look down at your hands and recognize them as your own, observes <a href="https://www.degruyter.com/columbia/view/title/515460">Evan Thompson</a>, your awareness includes your experience of seeing and feeling them. In a somewhat circular way, you are aware of your perception as your own experience. To close the loop, bring your index finger and the tip of your nose together and see if you can distinguish the sensations of “the nose being touched by the finger” and “the finger being touched by the nose.”</p><p>While the brain does its best to correlate all senses, the visual input usually overrides the tactile one, which in turn trumps proprioception. Even the senses of proprioception and touch combined may be unable to correct a visual interpretation, however absurd. A vivid demonstration of poking a hole in the seemingly introspection-proof experience of the embodied self is the “rubber hand illusion.” In this setup, your hand is hidden out of sight under a table (or otherwise made invisible to you by an opaque screen), while a somewhat realistic rubber hand is placed in front of you. You are asked to fix your eyes on the fake hand while both your hidden one and the look-alike are simultaneously stroked with a brush. Eventually, you may start experiencing a convincing illusion that the rubber hand is yours and that the sensation of being stroked is located in this inanimate object. Moreover, you may feel a full-blown “virtual arm” connecting your shoulder to the rubber hand on the table in front of you. The sense of embodiment could be so vivid that you would retract your (real) hand with a start if the fake one was suddenly smashed with a hammer.</p><p>As with any other perceptual puzzle, your brain has to guess what belongs to its body by combining its expectations with the available sensory data. When it erroneously integrates misleading visual inputs with the real sensation of touch, it can easily mistake a rubber hand for a real one. Your brain’s ability to incorporate an inanimate object into its body illustrates the fragility of the embodied self.</p><p>~~~</p><p>If you can “own” something inanimate, can you also own something that doesn’t exist? Apparently, you can. People who have lost an arm or a leg often continue sensing its presence for years after the amputation. This “phantom limb” can often be experienced as moving, either involuntarily (as if the stump is being pushed around) or voluntarily (when the amputee tries to move it). For example, a phantom arm may closely resemble the lost physical one in size and shape and even “wear” a wristwatch if the real arm did. Apparently, suggests <a href="https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393340624">V.S. Ramachandran</a>, even though the limb is missing, the corresponding brain map continues to represent it.</p><p>The phantom is likely to disappear the moment a prosthesis is put on the stump, merging seamlessly with it. The artificial limb becomes part of one’s body image, just as a blind person’s cane becomes an extension of their arm. This isn’t just a convenient metaphor. In an experiment described by <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/217866/livewired-by-david-eagleman/">David Eagleman</a>, when a monkey was repeatedly forced to reach for its food with a rake, its brain maps became reorganized to include the length of the tool, making the rake literally a part of the body (from the brain’s perspective).</p><p>Similarly, an artificial leg can often respond to minute irregularities of the ground almost as well as the original one. Nevertheless, walking with a regular prosthetic leg remains difficult. A real leg continuously streams information to the brain, such as its position, the bend in the knee, the pressure on the ankle, and the tilt of the foot. None of this information is provided by the prosthetic. To complicate things further, hand prostheses require a much more refined gamut of tactile sensations to enable recognition by touch.</p><p>The challenge can be partly addressed by <em>neuroprosthetics</em>. An ideal neuroprosthetic would send signals through outgoing nerves (the same ones that previously controlled the lost muscles) and deliver the sensation of touch and movement to the incoming nerves. Such a device would be experienced as mentally “transparent,” in the same sense as the background software is transparent to you when you drag an icon across the desktop. Once the sensations migrate to the neuroprosthetic (just as they did to the rubber hand), the artificial limb is treated by the brain as if it were the real one. As with any activity that involves closed loops with external objects (whether canes or joysticks), neuroprosthetics extend our agency beyond the body.</p><p>~~~</p><p><em>Afferent</em> neuroprosthetics bypass damaged nerves and communicate with the brain directly by converting signals into patterns of electrical stimulation. (The oldest example is the cochlear implant used to restore hearing.) However, integrating artificial and natural sensory systems has proven challenging. Implanting electrodes directly into thousands of nerves to create complex sensations (as done by Neuralink) could be very complicated and dangerous. And tweaking the brain to make it receive the signals to the correct areas could result in unforeseen consequences.</p><p>Fortunately, given the flexibility of brain maps, routing the signal to the original areas may not be necessary to restore function. For example, according to Eagleman, blind people can learn to use a device (such as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brainport">BrainPort</a>) that converts light into electrical impulses and stimulates other sensitive parts of their body, such as the tongue, instead of the retina. As a result, the users may feel that the scenes experienced through the device have “openness” and “depth,” and that objects were “out there” (rather than a faint projection on their skin).</p><p><em>Efferent</em> neuroprosthetics read information out of the brain to control an external device (such as a robotic arm) by mere thought. Simply imagining an action can activate some of the brain areas responsible for performing it. A missing ingredient to complete the action control loop is sensory feedback from the muscles (since no physical movement is happening). Even though the visual feedback from observing one’s own movement can be used in place of the missing tactile cues, efferent neuroprosthetics are still experienced as disembodied robots.</p><p>~~~</p><p>The neuroprosthetic research has been primarily motivated by the need to recover the lost function (due to wartime wounds, traumatic accidents, or congenital disabilities). However, the interest has been also fueled by our natural desire to transcend human limitations in ways that used to be confined to the boldest sci-fi writings. A global intellectual movement dubbed <em>transhumanism</em> has focused on using sophisticated emerging technologies to enhance our intelligence, anatomy, and physiology. AI-enabled brain implants that augment our senses and boost our cognitive processes appear destined to move human abilities as a species to a qualitatively new level. What if, wonders Eagleman, we could augment our <em>interception </em>to become capable of directly experiencing the states of our body that are presently unconscious, such as blood pressure and the state of the microbiome?</p><p>Let’s bypass technological evolution and imagine yourself as a disembodied “brain in a vat” that operates a full-body neuroprosthetic that is controlled by thought and supports all the sensory feedback to your brain. Such a device would feel no different from having a real (albeit augmented) body. Now, imagine the neuroprosthetic slowly encroaching onto your brain, with your biological neural net being gradually taken over by an artificial one. Eventually, your entire brain is replaced. Are you still there?</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>The Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/22-to-forget-the-self-exploring-the-boundaries-of-the-mind-6e5b5b577a0c"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a4c9217e1503" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/21-the-edges-of-the-self-proprioception-neuroprosthetics-and-expanding-beyond-a4c9217e1503">The Edges of the Self: Proprioception, Neuroprosthetics, and Expanding Beyond</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Ghost in the Machine: Mental Maps and the Fragile Unity of the Mind]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/20-the-ghost-in-the-machine-mental-maps-and-the-fragile-unity-of-the-mind-9b39066c9475?source=rss-524a23d8dd72------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9b39066c9475</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[synesthesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neuroscience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[integration]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[emer gentway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jul 2021 15:42:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-13T16:23:43.289Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g8PGDAESeSv7N-LiY9Hk1w.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>What dissolves the imaginary problem is seeing through both the problem and the one who seems to have it. (</em><a href="https://www.newharbinger.com/nothing-grasp"><em>Joan Tollifson</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>Imagine yourself as an alien scientist trying to gain insight into my subjective experience by exploring me as a biological organism. As I am laying in a high-resolution fMRI machine, you are getting a clear, unobstructed, dynamic view of my neural firings and hearing a flat electronic voice transcribing my speech. But no amount of information about me as a system would suffice to catch a glimpse of my awareness. You would still have no idea what it would feel like to be me — living in my private world of which I am the center. Both perspectives on me are valid and complementary, but your perception of me as a complex system is vastly different from my experience of myself as a sentient being, an intentional agent, and an autonomous self.</p><p>~~~</p><p>Our brain is the most complex system in the known universe. It is also the one we have been interacting with most often. Given our challenges with understanding complex systems, our most deeply ingrained — and most consequential — misconceptions must be about ourselves.</p><p>Nowadays, it seems natural to assume that our self is intimately dependent on the brain. It has long been observed that damages to particular brain areas reliably predict declines in the corresponding mental functions. Neurosurgery has further confirmed these observations. Modern science has developed refined non-invasive procedures for analyzing this dependency by systematically mapping the activity in well-defined brain areas to specific behaviors and experiences. We now have compelling evidence that sensations, perceptions, thoughts, and feelings are all caused by the patterns of neural activity. Mind somehow emerges from the interaction of loosely arranged basic cells that follow simple rules of interaction.</p><p>Upon reflection, however, a conclusion that a physical brain can produce an intangible mind is not at all intuitive. It may be easy to see the heart as a pump, the stomach as a container, and the kidney as a filter. But why would a small bundle of wrinkly gray matter house the seemingly immaterial substrate? Indeed, the self was traditionally equated with the “soul” and believed to reside in the heart, alongside reason, emotion, and other mental faculties. The first mummification step in ancient Egypt, according to <a href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/feeling-life-itself">Christof Koch</a>, was “to scoop out the brain and discard it” while “the heart, the liver, and other internal organs were carefully extracted and preserved so that the Pharaoh had access to everything he needed in his afterlife.” Even Aristotle viewed the heart as the home of intelligence, and the brain — as a blood-cooling device. (As a careful observer, Aristotle noticed that the blood exiting the brain was considerably cooler than the blood entering it — which we now see as the outcome of the brain’s intense energy consumption.)</p><p>It was not until the 2nd century A.D. that a physician Galen first argued that “the vital spirit” animating humans flows up through the body into the head, where it “becomes purified into thought, sensation, and movement.” Even in Galen’s mind, however, the brain’s mushy gray matter served merely as a filter and a pump. Later cultures viewed the mind through the lens of whatever technology they were most familiar with, metaphorically likening the brain to a mechanical clockwork, a telephone switchboard, a computer, the internet, and nowadays, to convolutional neural networks.</p><p>Mental breakdowns and brain disorders are “cracks in the façade of the self” (in the words of <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/314197/the-man-who-wasnt-there-by-anil-ananthaswamy/">Anil Ananthaswamy</a>) that let us examine neural processes that are mostly impenetrable otherwise. The very same abnormal experience may appear terrifying to a psychiatric patient, amusing to a psychedelic explorer, inspirational to a meditator, insightful to a philosopher, and informative to a neuroscientist. Looking under the hood of our brain may help us not only gain a deeper understanding of our mind but also become more accepting of ourselves at the human, personal level. Rather than “deconstructing” or eliminating the self, we may gain a more holistic understanding of the magic glue that holds it together and makes it struggle to preserve its current shape.</p><p>~~~</p><p>To make the navigation of our environment more efficient, our brain directs visual, auditory, and proprioceptive sensory inputs to the adjacent clusters of neurons. Neuroscientists capture this spatial coherence in the form of <em>brain maps</em>. Just as the country borders, brain maps come about by happenstance and continue being shaped by active inputs from the body, points out <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/217866/livewired-by-david-eagleman/">David Eagleman</a>. The notion of a map as a discrete entity is merely a helpful abstraction, agrees <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/196548/self-comes-to-mind-by-antonio-damasio/">Antonio Damasio</a>, as our mental states always involve multiple brain regions. Nor does the deterioration of specific mental functions due to the damage to certain brain areas imply that those functions are somehow “located” there. (London Bridge’s falling down would have led to significant economic disruptions, yet the economy of medieval England was by no means located on the bridge.) Nevertheless, the notion of brain maps may help rule out implausible conjectures, suggest intriguing hypotheses, and provide useful insights.</p><p>Well-defined maps support our ability to detect progressively smaller sensory differences. Due to the poor differentiation across infants’ brain maps, their chaotic and awkward movements engage many muscles at once. However, as they mature and become aware of subtle distinctions in their sensations, the movements become more economic and precise. Since sensory data can be corrupted by noise, the brain must figure out how to use the incoming information for updating the maps. One approach is to rely on consistency over time: If a change is lasting, the map is worth updating. For example, if you grew up with scoliosis and got your spine aligned as an adult, you would initially feel tilted while walking straight. Until your brain has adjusted, tilting your spine back into the habitual curve would “feel right.”</p><p>~~~</p><p>The boundaries of brain maps are not fixed. Though somewhat delineated, their outlines are often “porous,” as a map may “slide” onto an adjacent one. While we tend to think of neurons as cooperating happily, like ants in a colony, points out Eagleman, they could be more accurately viewed as fiercely competing for resources to stay alive. This is why the “homunculus” in medical textbooks looks so strange: The body areas that send more sensory information to the brain (such as fingers and lips as opposed to torso and thighs) win more of the brain real estate. Even if you merely tie two of your fingers together and let them operate as a unit for some time, their maps will eventually merge into a single area.</p><p>According to Eagleman, any patch of the cortex is pluripotent, meaning that it can develop a variety of functions depending on what inputs are plugged into it. (The term “pluripotent” was originally used to describe differentiated cells that can sometimes be reprogrammed in adulthood.) For example, when an animal’s visual inputs are experimentally “redirected” to the part of the brain normally involved in hearing, the “rewired” animal appears to “see” with its auditory cortex. Apparently, its brain interprets hearing as normal vision. Similarly, observes Eagleman, the visual cortex of those who were born blind is completely taken over by other senses such as smell and taste. Even when people with normal vision are blindfolded for as little as an hour, their visual cortex temporarily becomes active when they perform tasks with their fingers or when they listen to sounds. The auditory cortex of deaf people also becomes employed for vision and other perceptual tasks unrelated to hearing.</p><p>Similarly, when an amputated hand stops being a source of continuous sensory inputs, its original brain map is encroached upon by the surrounding areas. Those greedy neighbors happily move in to take over the abandoned land where the hand used to be. Since the map of the face happens to be located next to the map of the hand (rather than that of the neck, as one would expect), a map of the hand (with distinct fingers) may be felt on the face, and a map of the face may appear on the palm. What if a brain area such as the “visual” cortex is only visual because of the data it receives, wonders Eagleman?</p><p>~~~</p><p>Brain maps that are naturally assembled in unusual ways may produce remarkable sensory experiences. <em>Synesthesia</em> describes surreal abilities to taste colors, see music, hear shapes, or touch emotions in various combinations. “The sound of colors,” wrote <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wassily_Kandinsky">Wassily Kandinsky</a>, “is so definite that it would be hard to find anyone who would express bright yellow with bass, or dark lake with the treble.” Similarly, people with color-number synesthesia associate numbers with colors, imbuing each number with its unique “personality.” It turns out that the brain maps for colors and numbers share borders. Synesthesia may thus be caused by a “crosstalk” between these normally separated areas. (A complementary hypothesis, suggested by Eagleman, blames synesthesia on our reduced ability to modify an association once it has been set. For example, once a child associates a letter with its color on a letter block, the association sticks.) Incidentally, our language is a special case of synesthesia, which combines concepts and images with otherwise meaningless noises.</p><p>Across the animal kingdom, we find all kinds of strange peripheral devices. As random mutations introduce new sensors, the brains simply figure out how to exploit them based on a few general principles. But for the new sensor to become operational, the adaptation doesn’t have to take multiple generations. Just as you don’t need to buy a new computer for each new hardware component, your brain doesn’t need an upgrade to support a new sensor. For example, when an extra eye is transplanted on one side of a tadpole, the two eyes on that side split control over the original brain map, enabling full vision in the new eye.</p><p>Our brain weaves together sensory inputs to create a holistic perception. From a distance, an impressionist painting may look like a woman holding a child in front of their house. When you zoom in, however, you may notice that each one is painted with just a few brushstrokes (which you initially saw as pieces of clothing and faces). Outside of the context created by the entire painting, the patches of color would remain meaningless. Combining shapes with colors — to see green as going with a frog — also requires a binding step. When you look at your friend, your brain combines parts of the face (eyes, nose, and mouth) into a single recognizable image. When you hear a person talking, your brain further merges the face and the movements of her mouth with the sounds coming out of it to create a seamless multimedia experience.</p><p>The same is true of our perception of ourselves. Only in anatomy textbooks and sci-fi thrillers is the brain isolated from the body and confined to the head. In reality, it is always attached to the senses, and through them, to the world outside. Despite the moment-to-moment sensory flux, our body usually feels like a single whole. Yet the only reason why the hand you see coincides with the hand you feel, observed <a href="http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/57628">William James</a> over a century ago, is that “the original sensations… coalesced together into one and the same space.” The sensations from your entire body are fused. There is unity in everything you are at any moment. Your <em>embodied self</em> — an intangible sentient entity behind your eyes that appears to animate your body and mind — is continuously constructed from the real-time coordination of your senses.</p><p>~~~</p><p>The brain’s representation of the body can be confused by scrambling the inputs from different senses. When our body image doesn’t match up with the sensory inputs, our inner harmony is disrupted. It may be impossible for most of us to imagine what it would feel like to become incapable of combining the features of a perceived object (such as its color and texture) into a single entity. Yet there is no single place in the brain where the incoming information is being integrated to create a complete perception. Though we may routinely take it for granted, the apparent unity of consciousness is one of the most significant achievements of evolution. In this regard, we are like our alien friend, the octopus.</p><p>However, the similarity ends there. The octopus’s body is not a unified entity controlled by the brain, observes <a href="https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374207946">Peter Godfrey-Smith</a>. Rather, its brain is spread throughout its body. Most of the octopus’s neurons are in its arms, equipped with their own sensors and controllers, which enjoy considerable independence. Besides the sense of touch, the arms can also smell and taste chemicals. Even an arm that has been surgically removed can perform basic motions like reaching and grasping. The octopus may not even track the location of its arms. To some extent, the central brain guides its arms, but otherwise, it just watches them go. They sense and respond independently, only briefly losing autonomy when the octopus “pulls itself together” and imposes central control. An entire bee has only a million neurons, while each octopus’ arm has tens of millions of them. Could the arms have their own experiences?</p><p>An uncontrolled movement of an object is usually a sign that it isn’t part of our self — but for the octopus, this distinction must be blurred. Its arms are partly “self,” directed and used to manipulate things, and partly “non-self,” roaming freely as agents of their own. The octopus’ brain is like a jazz conductor, orchestrating creative artists who are willing to accept only so much direction. Despite feeling unified, our self may also be an elaborate performance by an enormous ensemble of non-sentient players rather than a lonely ghost lurking in the guts of the neural machine.</p><p><em>This story is best enjoyed as part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present"><em>The Uncharted Present</em></a><em> publication, starting with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/0-zen-for-nerds-an-intro-to-the-uncharted-present-18d45bff0b1"><em>intro</em></a><em>. If that’s how you got here, please continue to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@emergentway/21-the-edges-of-the-self-proprioception-neuroprosthetics-and-expanding-beyond-a4c9217e1503"><em>next one</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9b39066c9475" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present/20-the-ghost-in-the-machine-mental-maps-and-the-fragile-unity-of-the-mind-9b39066c9475">The Ghost in the Machine: Mental Maps and the Fragile Unity of the Mind</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-uncharted-present">The Uncharted Present</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>