<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Emilie Poplett on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Emilie Poplett on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@emilie.poplett?source=rss-92ba3efbfed------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 15:04:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@emilie.poplett/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Spiritual abuse doesn't just happen at celebrity megachurches.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@emilie.poplett/spiritual-abuse-doesnt-just-happen-at-celebrity-megachurches-29f96abfb767?source=rss-92ba3efbfed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/29f96abfb767</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emilie Poplett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jul 2022 00:59:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-14T12:32:30.220Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Spiritual abuse doesn&#39;t just happen at celebrity megachurches. I had an everyday church horror story.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*F8i7j2FeVTaUrgYx" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@johnprice?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">John Price</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Like many Millennials, I found the church in my early 20s, in search of meaning and community. Several years later, whether I left the church or was removed from it depends on who you ask.</h4><p>Right now, stories of misconduct and abuse in the church are popular and ubiquitous. A recent documentary, “<a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt16304142/">Hillsong: A Megachurch Exposed</a>,” cast the spotlight on one of the most famous international megachurches, which at one time counted Justin Bieber, Chris Pratt, and Kourtney Kardashian among its members.</p><p>But Hillsong’s story, unfortunately, is not unique. Spiritual abuses happen every day on a smaller scale in churches across America. I know because I witnessed it. I lived it.</p><p>I didn’t grow up religious (or, rather, I extricated myself from Christianity when I was 11, after a Sunday School teacher told me my Jewish best friend was going to hell), so discovering church again at 22 came with a heavy dose of skepticism and awkwardness. But when I found Grace Church, I felt almost immediately at home. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. The sermons felt relatable and practical. The lead pastor was funny and engaging, with a self-deprecating sense of humor.</p><p>I didn’t always agree with Grace’s teachings, but I figured that was to be expected. I was a feminist and a leftist who hailed from Madison, Wisconsin, and this was the Bible Belt South. Maybe a melting pot of perspectives was healthy. Maybe we could learn from each other.</p><p>I got involved in small group Bible studies, got to know the community, and found a support system that would be crucial as I faced down some harrowing life challenges.</p><p>But then things started to go sideways.</p><p>By sideways, I mean prejudicial.</p><p>It was little things at first, and like many a Sunday school vigilante before me, I had an aspirational, change-things-from-within philosophy. Fellow churchgoers who shared my principles told me I had a calling for “standing in the gap,” which is Evangelical speak for falling on your sword to protect others. Unfortunately, the church leadership didn’t quite see it that way. They saw a troublemaker, a heretical little gnat buzzing in their ear every time they did something like, for example, invite a self-proclaimed “former lesbian” to speak to the young adult ministry about sexual depravity.</p><p>Okay, so that only happened once. (The “former lesbian” in question has since described the COVID-19 pandemic as <a href="https://www.desiringgod.org/articles/can-the-pandemic-be-an-answered-prayer">an answered prayer </a>— God’s way of canceling Pride parades — never mind that the world was approaching half a million COVID deaths at the time of this scorching hot take). But the unfailing response to any concern about diversity, equity, or social justice was that our church simply “didn’t do politics.”</p><p>That rule didn’t hold up so well during the 2016 election, when thinly veiled support for Donald Trump seemed freely welcomed from the pulpit, nor did it hold up when the church sent our financial donations to anti-choice “pregnancy resource centers<em>,” </em>which are known for <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/may/12/google-advertising-abortion-obria">giving misinformation</a> to “abortion-minded women” in an effort to coerce them into carrying unwanted pregnancies.</p><p>But anything concerning the rights and lives of people of color, the LGBTQ+ community or women? Well, we don’t do politics here.</p><h4>You Belong! (terms and conditions apply)</h4><p>It’s not like I was expecting a church in the Bible Belt to hang a rainbow flag out front or to align precisely with my personal convictions. I only expected them to be who they purported to be. When they said, “Come as you are,” when they said, “You belong,” when they said, “Diversity matters to us,” I expected them to mean it. And they didn’t.</p><p>When the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unite_the_Right_rally">white supremacist rallies in Charlottesville, Virginia</a> shook the nation in 2017, I asked a church leader if he planned to address the issue with our then-small church community. No, he wrote back, they had chosen not to address it — “for convenience” — since it happened to be the weekend of the grand opening of Grace’s building expansion.</p><p>I pushed back. Wouldn’t this be a good opportunity for us to show new attendees that we value the lives of our Black and Brown members? If not in the sermon, couldn’t we offer a prayer on social media?</p><p>In retrospect, I understand that challenging an authority member of a church is, at best, frowned upon, and that my plucky, twenty-something-year-old activism may have come across as disrespectful and pretentious. If I could do it over, I would approach it differently. I would ask to meet in person, at least. But what I knew was this: Jesus did not turn a blind eye to injustice. If we were here to be the hands and feet of Jesus, couldn’t we do better? Shouldn’t we do better?</p><p>There were other signs of trouble, too. Friends whispered about an arrogance from the pulpit that seemed to be growing by the Sunday, as more and more locals filed in to fill the new, much larger (and flashier) worship center.</p><p>In one guest sermon — a video played for us on the big screens, originating from another church — a preacher suggested that churchgoers should be all but required to tithe, and that inquiring about the final destination of your financial donations was akin to questioning God Himself.</p><p>While I was concerned with the direction the church seemed to be headed, I had found a family there. I was baptized there. There was a time when I believed that Grace Church had saved my life, and I emailed the lead pastor to let him know that and to thank him. (He later shared my very personal story, without my name attached but also without my consent, before a crowd of hundreds of church volunteers I happened to be sitting among at an evening event, but that’s another story).</p><p>Naive as I may have been, I kept looking at those signs hanging on the church’s walls and the platitudes printed in their handouts— the “Come as You Are,” the “You Belong,” the “Welcome Home”—and I still wanted to believe them. I wasn’t ready to leave.</p><h4>You Can’t Sit With Us</h4><p>Then in 2019, the church quietly rolled out a new statement of values that would exclude LGBTQ+ people and anyone having premarital sex (or otherwise engaging in a life of tawdry sin) from being members of or volunteers for the church. “The Scriptures limit the expression of human sexuality to the marital relationship of one man with one woman, which is the only legitimate and acceptable sexual relationship,” it read.</p><p>It said a lot of other bullshit stuff, too, like about how women were designed to be men’s “helpers” and how they ought to be “subject to the husband in everything.”</p><p>Essentially, all current members, volunteers, and people in leadership positions would be asked to sign in agreement with this new statement of faith if they wanted to continue as such.</p><p>At that point, I was a volunteer usher. Likely expecting some resistance, one of the staff members, a friend of mine, set up a private meeting with me to discuss the new policy and the church’s request (or requirement) that I sign it. I declined to sign.</p><p>The whole thing felt pretty un-Jesusy to me, and I was particularly concerned about what this new policy would do to LGBTQ+ members of our church community, who seemed to be particularly targeted. I pleaded with my staff member friend in an email:</p><blockquote>The cost of getting this wrong is the very lives of our LGBTQ brothers and sisters.</blockquote><p>I attached a formal letter to that email, in which I explained that my biblical study had led me to very different conclusions than the ones laid out in their new statement of faith. Signing this contract would mean checking my intellect at the door in favor of a narrow, pre-determined, and prejudicial interpretation of Scripture.</p><p>Trying to speak their language, I wrote:</p><blockquote>I struggle to imagine Jesus turning away any child of God who is eager to serve his church and his community. But [the new policy] has revealed that there are criteria I must meet in order to be truly accepted, welcomed, and loved by my church family.</blockquote><blockquote>When I signed up for [volunteer service], I signed up to serve every soul who walks through those doors on Sunday morning looking to encounter God. I signed up to serve people of every race and nationality, every gender, every sexual orientation, in every stage of life and every walk of faith. My job, as I understood it, was to make sure every person who walked through those doors felt welcome in our house of worship. To say to them, “Come with your questions, your doubts, your struggles and sins, because the ground is level at the foot of the cross.”…To tell them, “You are welcome here.”</blockquote><blockquote>It breaks my heart that I can no longer say those things — not only because I can no longer serve, but because I don’t feel that those sentiments are represented at Grace anymore.</blockquote><p>I ended the letter by welcoming further conversation in person and offering my gratitude and best wishes to the leadership of Grace.</p><p>Then I turned to the Facebook group for women in the church, a group I had prayed with, cried with, and grown with for years, to let them know I was taking a break from attending services. I did not announce that I would be leaving permanently, because I wanted to leave the door open in case I heard back from leadership and could engage in a meaningful conversation.</p><h4>Unfriended</h4><p>I did not hear back, but I was promptly removed from the Facebook group(s) associated with Grace and from the volunteer roster without any communication from the leadership team.</p><p>People I’d been good friends with for years stopped speaking to me with little to no explanation. But I understood. I was a bad influence, and they wanted me out. <em>WWJD, am I right? </em>Truthfully, the shunning was brutal. I was in the middle of a grueling diagnostic workup for what my doctors believed was lymphoma, and now I was doing it without my spiritual family, who seemed to aggressively hate me.</p><p>At that point, concluding that my letter had been received and had gone unacknowledged, I went public with a handful of the details of what had happened.</p><p>Only then did a pastor reach out, citing a “misunderstanding.” I shared my letter with him, which he ignored. He invited me to talk with him in person, but I was hesitant. I told him it seemed that the door had already been closed on me. He did not deny this.</p><p>When another staff member graciously tried to add me back into one of the Facebook groups to let me know I would always be welcome back, the pastor reached out to me again. “I saw that you requested to join the Young Adults Facebook page,” he wrote. “I was confused by that since you said you were no longer wanting to be a member of Grace. That group is for members of Grace who are looking to build community.”</p><p>He did not offer an apology.</p><p>Around the same time, other friends who did not meet Grace’s criteria for membership were also being wordlessly removed from the church Facebook groups, demoted from their leadership roles, and removed from their service teams.</p><p>Pastors spoke with people who they knew were in serious relationships or living with their partners before marriage, asking them, in so many words, whether they were having sex. From my knowledge, most of these conversations were happening between male church leaders and young female congregants. In at least one case, two older, white male church leaders held a meeting with one young, Black woman, Jasmine, who has since <a href="https://www.facebook.com/PawnoftheKing/posts/pfbid02wg158qqZ1yoYTogB9gLZNygwb5zgxoYAxez31uYy3Zjt994QNg8r1MnfowwywP3kl">shared her experience publicly</a> (and who has consented to share it here). In that meeting, they asked her if she was sleeping with the man to whom she was engaged to be married.</p><p>When she told me this, back in 2019, I was shocked. Wasn’t this the same church that once referred to sex as “tummy time” to a room full of 20- and 30-year-old women? Now they were getting women alone and outnumbered to ask them directly about their sex lives? Didn’t it go without saying that this was absolutely no one else’s business?</p><p>I was either the first or the loudest to leave the church because of the new policy, but dozens of others eventually did the same. As the months went on, more of my friends left or began to question the direction the church was headed. Every so often, someone I knew from my church days would confide in me:</p><p><em>“They broke me. How am I ever supposed to go to church again?”</em></p><p><em>“I finally left, and my best friend completely cut me off.”</em></p><p><em>“They made it clear they didn’t want me there.”</em></p><p><em>“My son was getting depressed and having nightmares and begging us to stop going. Turns out they were telling him about gay people going to hell.”</em></p><p><em>“They brainwashed me. I was brainwashed.”</em></p><p>One friend wrote to me recently, “I’m mad at myself for staying as long as I did.”</p><p>But she, like many others, was manipulated. Others would later say they felt abused. Gaslighted. Tricked.</p><p>I continued to watch from a distance as one by one, nearly everyone I knew left Grace.</p><h4>Very Fine People</h4><p>Then, on June 6, 2020, following the murder of George Floyd, I watched an <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZJLUkuM9KM">online sermon about racism</a> from a church based out of Woodstock, Georgia. Andy Stanley, the pastor from Woodstock Community Church, said:</p><blockquote>The truth is rarely found in the extremes. It’s found where the circles overlap in the middle — the messy middle… That’s where the brutal uncomfortable facts all come together, but it’s also where problems can be solved. It’s so much easier to retreat to the echo chamber of extremes.</blockquote><p>Curious to see if my former church would finally speak up about the violence against Black people in America, I checked their sermons online. In a message dated one week after the service from Woodstock appeared online, my former pastor began to deliver a message that sounded very familiar:</p><blockquote>If we really want God’s heart, if we really want wisdom, it’s often found in the middle, in the tension. It’s often found in the messy middle where circles overlap. Extremes are easy.</blockquote><p>Maybe this is a thing pastors do, borrow from one another, pass each other’s words off as their own. But I am a journalist, and we have a term for that sort of thing.</p><p>To guard against any criticism he might receive, my former pastor also spoke in that sermon about how he was “wading into a minefield” by talking about how, you know, Black people shouldn’t be shot dead in the streets, and implying that white folks in particular should not call him out and ask him to do better.</p><p>Ultimately, the message was this: We won’t all think alike, and that’s okay, because wisdom is found in the middle.</p><p>Because when we talk about white supremacists versus social justice advocates, <em>surely</em> we should all land right in the middle.</p><h4>On spiritual trauma</h4><p><em>Content warning: Sexual assault</em></p><p>As I listened to pieces of Andy Stanley’s sermon being plagiarized, I thought about saying something. Telling someone. Writing a Google review of the church, at least. I couldn’t bring myself to do it. I didn’t want to hurt anyone. I still cared for them. And I feared how they might retaliate.</p><p>I’ve talked to therapists about my church trauma for years, but there was a specific moment when I realized how deep the harm went.</p><p>It was years after I left. I had just been date raped, and I was driving home at 3:30 in the morning, crying over the steering wheel, when I thought to myself, “Grace would kick me out twice if they could.” I laughed until I was hysterical. I apologized to the Jesus I knew through the lens of Grace Church. I apologized for my own rape.</p><p>My pastors, I thought, would be so disappointed in me.</p><p><a href="https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/signs-spiritual-abuse">Spiritual abuse</a> is real, and it’s widespread. According to Web MD, “You may be experiencing religious or spiritual abuse if a religious leader has:”</p><blockquote>Used scripture or beliefs to humiliate or embarrass you</blockquote><blockquote>Coerced you into giving money or other resources that you didn’t want to give</blockquote><blockquote>Forced you to be intimate or have sex that you didn’t want</blockquote><blockquote>Made you feel pressured or obligated to do things against your will</blockquote><p>Spiritual abuse may also include “using scriptures or religious beliefs to control your clothing, behavior, sexuality, decision making, choice to have children or not, or finances.”</p><p>In my personal opinion, Grace Church’s actions meet several of these criteria.</p><p>In publishing all this, I expect to face more backlash than I already have. To lose more friends than I already have. But nothing I’ve said here is unsubstantiated. I have videos, messages, copies of the church’s policy documents over time. (The statement of faith has since been scrubbed from Grace’s website, but the internet is the internet; nothing is actually gone).</p><p>And as more and more people come to terms with what happened to them at their churches, it’s even more important to speak publicly to the wounds so many of us were left with.</p><p>Some people might say, “Why dredge all this up? Why air our dirty laundry?”</p><p>Because it’s the truth.</p><p>Because I believe it is the dirty laundry, not the airing of it, that is the problem —<em> especially</em> when the laundry belongs to an institution of power.</p><p>And because this may be the only thing I can do to protect someone else from walking into that building and walking out several years later with lifelong wounds.</p><p>No one sets out to build a church in order to hurt people. Pastoring is hard and noble work, and I still have great affection for many of the leaders and church members who meant so much to me at that time in my life. It would be dishonest for me to say that my experience with Grace Church was all bad. The pastors at Grace gave me an opportunity to explore my faith for the first time in over a decade. The small group studies were enriching and familial. At least for a while, Grace Church created an environment where I felt safe and loved. Some of my most meaningful friendships have stemmed from that time in my life, and I’m grateful to still have many of those friendships today.</p><p>I don’t think the leaders are bad people, nor do I think they hurt people intentionally. But they did hurt people, and they hurt people profoundly.</p><p>Of course, I’m not perfect either. I could have left gracefully and quietly, and maybe that’s what a Good Christian Girl would’ve done.</p><p>Or maybe a Good Christian Girl is vocal and brave in the face of injustice. Maybe a Good Christian Girl sees corruption and says, “This is wrong.” Maybe a Good Christian Girl opens the door for other people to speak the truth, like my friend Jasmine did.</p><p>This is not just about our church. This is about a thousand churches just like ours and the people on the wrong side of power.</p><p>I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again here:</p><p>I’m not sorry for what I said. I am sorry that the best you know of a woman is Pretty and Quiet.</p><p><strong>Footnote:</strong></p><p>*It appears Grace has removed references to the particular pregnancy organizations with which they were working, now citing only “Pregnancy Support Services” on their fundraising page with a goal of bringing in $4,000. As of April 2022, their partner organizations were <a href="https://pregnancysupportservices.org/">Pregnancy Support Services of Chapel Hill</a> (PSS) and <a href="https://gatewaywomens.care/">Gateway Women’s Care</a>. Gateway lists their organizational goal as “rescuing a generation from the tragedy of abortion;” PSS is a partner organization of <a href="https://www.heartbeatservices.org/about-us">Heartbeat International</a>.</p><p><strong>Recommended resource:</strong></p><p>The <a href="https://www.churchclarity.org/">Church Clarity project</a> helps decipher church stances on LGBTQ membership and women in leadership.</p><p>Their mission:</p><blockquote>Powerful institutions tend to operate in ambiguity, rather than in clarity.</blockquote><blockquote>Ambiguity enables those with power to operate without accountability and cause real harm. Many people invest years of their lives into a church community, only to later discover the truth about the church’s policies, and end up feeling betrayed, deceived and “bait-and-switched.”</blockquote><blockquote>Our mission is to increase the standard of clarity throughout the Church Industry. We are not advocating for policy changes; we are standardizing church policy disclosure, whatever the policy or type of church in question. People deserve to know the truth.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=29f96abfb767" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>