<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by orangefizz on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by orangefizz on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@emlynaddison?source=rss-cdf87bbcb0ef------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 19:49:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@emlynaddison/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Is In Control Of Providence Public Schools?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@emlynaddison/who-is-in-control-of-providence-public-schools-eafb26dae952?source=rss-cdf87bbcb0ef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eafb26dae952</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rhode-island]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[providence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[orangefizz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jul 2019 14:51:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-19T14:51:22.242Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*402-rKYVCv7tkMOMH8mdLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo: Luke Walden</figcaption></figure><p>In a <em>Rollingstone</em> article titled “The Pentagon’s Bottomless Money Pit” (<a href="https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/pentagon-budget-mystery-807276/">https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/pentagon-budget-mystery-807276/</a>), journalist Matt Taibbi catalogues the U.S. Department Of Defense’s repeated unsuccessful attempts to audit itself. After its final attempt to accomplish this task again failed, says Taibbi, auditors’ only defense was that the military’s spending system “was too illogical to penetrate”.</p><p>They might just as well have been describing Providence’s educational system. <em>Who is in control?</em></p><p>Let me start by saying that I know almost nothing about how a school system works, much less city/state budget policy or administrative operations, and so it’s very possible that I’m dead wrong about some of my conclusions. But as a parent of a Providence public school student who has read the Johns Hopkins University’s PPSD Review, there are no dumb questions when ninety percent of our kids are failing English and math.</p><p><strong><em>NINETY PERCENT</em></strong><em> OF OUR KIDS ARE FAILING ENGLISH AND MATH.</em></p><p>The PPSD Review is appalling and infuriating, and reveals a deep injustice inflicted on our children. It raises serious questions about ethics and competence and should anger every resident of this city.</p><p>Following the PPSD Review, the RI Department of Education set up public education forums — ostensibly to show that, if all parties simply make a show of coming together and demonstrating that they’re committed to change and “healing”, it can change! we can heal! This is foolish, naïve, and ineffective; it’s window dressing. How do I know this? Because we’ve been here before: in 1993 the city’s schools received almost exactly the same report (<a href="https://www.golocalprov.com/news/25-years-ago-a-there-was-a-major-study-of-providence-schools">https://www.golocalprov.com/news/25-years-ago-a-there-was-a-major-study-of-providence-schools</a>).</p><p>Why are we here again. Were parents in 1993 not angry enough? Were teachers and elected leaders not committed enough to demanding change? Of course they were. Nothing changed because the problem is deeply systemic.</p><p>I don’t much care whose ire I earn from writing this letter (but I’ll wager that their kids aren’t in the PPSD system). This PPSD Review puts us way, way beyond forums, meetings, post-mortems, and community-building; this is a reckoning. Parents aren’t bake sale volunteers; we’re working taxpayers who have a right to confront each individual, group, and organization — whether paid or unpaid, elected or unelected — at every point in a system that is charged with the education of our children. Nobody will be spared this time. I don’t care what agreements have been struck, what promises have been made, or what contracts have been signed. All bets are off.</p><p><strong><em>NINETY PERCENT</em></strong><em> OF OUR KIDS ARE FAILING ENGLISH AND MATH.</em></p><p>Where to begin? An alarming refrain throughout the PPSD Review is a lack of centralized control of the school system: no authority, no solid plan, no priorities, too many cooks in the kitchen, too many hands in the cookie jar, too many masters, et cetera. Is the Providence Mayor’s authority over schools too broad or too subject to political pressures? Is the PPSD Superintendent too beholden to the Mayor’s office and/or the city council and does the position lack sufficient authority? Does the PPSD lack sufficient staff, organizational capability, transparency, and political impartiality to do its job effectively? Does the Providence school board lack sufficient authority to be an effective governing structure? Does the Providence city council lack a prescribed charter to make it more effective in supporting schools? Do school principals lack sufficient authority to make decisions that they are best equipped to make at the school level? Do teachers have too much or too little authority to decide curricula and is their efficacy being whitewashed by the Collective Bargaining Agreement? Does the Rhode Island Department of Education have too much authority to dictate limits on disciplinary action by principals and professional development for teachers? Does the Providence Teachers Union have too much latitude in dictating contract terms and insulating teachers at the expense of students and educational integrity?</p><p>Too much control where it doesn’t belong and too little control where it does. The buck doesn’t stop anywhere. If this was a private business venture it would have failed. Design-by-committee doesn’t work; you need centralized decision-making — leadership that has teeth. There is no structure or policy in place for authority to be assigned effectively — and so the system has putrified: pathetic grades, unchallenged students, ineffective and demoralized teachers and principals, draconian budget and procurement processes, a curricular focus at the expense of instructional focus, crumbling facilities, poor school culture and lack of consequential discipline, racism and sexism, and parental disenfranchisement. And all attempts at proaction are suffocated by labyrinthine power structures and administrative hell, persistent political favoritism, and contractual fabrications that are routinely championed as benefitting the many when in fact they benefit a scant few.</p><p>Where are the kids in all this?</p><p><strong><em>NINETY PERCENT</em></strong><em> OF OUR KIDS ARE FAILING ENGLISH AND MATH.</em></p><p>At one of the RIDE forums I observed a teacher — long known among the school’s parents as a repeat no-show — sitting and clapping in approval to the speakers. Demoralized or not, not showing up to teach when a classroom of failing students are counting on you is unacceptable. Teachers can play hooky because they know they’re protected by the union: there are no consequences. Tell me I’m wrong.</p><p>The Mayor has been acting as if he was a mere witness to this carnage. He was elected on a platform of improving schools yet the PPSD Review shows that his negotiation of the cataclysmically wrong-headed Collective Bargaining Agreement and his office’s massive overreach are possibly two of the most serious failures. The Mayor may have entered office believing that he could fix schools with proactive-sounding initiatives like more technology and summer classes, but it’s counteracted by his bad decision-making when it really counts. He says “The buck stops with me” but do parents honestly trust that so much authority over schooling is left to an elected individual with no background in education in a city that made its name on political favoritism?</p><p>And does anyone still believe that more technology in the classroom — so-called “personalized learning” — is working? This is not educating, this is phoning it in.</p><p>Many parents feel that the RIDE forums, though well-intentioned, are largely designed to placate the public: the PPSD Review highlights how RIDE’s priorities, bureaucracy, and mandates — like pressuring schools to artificially lower suspension rates — are serious contributing factors to both teacher morale and student culture, exacerbating the vacuum of leadership on the ground. But have a coffee and a donut on us and let’s have a conversation about your school problems. Was 25 years not long enough to start addressing this?</p><p>The Providence public school district, charged with the education of Providence’s ~24,000 students, is, judging by the PPSD Review, incapable of recognizing its own complicity or of identifying its own failures, much less able (or willing) to correct them. A protectionist and politically protected institution in Providence? Say it ain’t so! This is how jaded we’ve become, but it’s not funny anymore. To the few brave souls in the district who may actually belong there and who really do put in the work, remind yourselves that the PPSD’s incompetence is screwing with our children’s future. Call out the weak links; blow the whistle. Because parents are now fed up enough to want to stage a wholesale takeover of Providence schools. One can imagine that an immediate and permanent halt to all paychecks in the district would have a wonderful laxative effect on this defunct and irresponsible system. Would students be any <em>WORSE</em> off?</p><p><strong><em>NINETY PERCENT</em></strong><em> OF OUR KIDS ARE FAILING ENGLISH AND MATH.</em></p><p>On the Providence city council, the PPSD Review presents a body that is political, bullish, and bureaucratic, yet parents know so little about the organizational structure of Providence’s educational system (does anyone?) that we can’t even form an opinion about whether they’re necessary for Providence schools, let alone effective. The procurement process is self-evidently ridiculous and, by their own admission, they over-complicate things. Some would like to see the reins passed to the school board, where these responsibilities should belong.</p><p>The Providence school board seems best equipped to properly manage school-related policy, though, per the PPSD Review, members seem rightly alarmed that they’re unaware of how school curricula are selected, how the board’s policies actually work in practice, and how to more effectively communicate with the Providence city council — to say nothing of communication between the city council, PPSD, the Mayor’s office, the Superintendent, and RIDE. It’s enough to make your head spin.</p><p>Then there’s the Providence Teachers Union; an albatross around the district’s neck. And I write that as a bright-eyed socialist. Whatever noble purpose this outfit may once have served in supporting teachers, it has been convincingly vaporized by its perfectly distorted priorities: protect the teachers and their pay, and to hell with the students and their learning. At all costs, keep the teachers employed. The union persists because, in the venerable mythology of American labor, A Union Can Do No Wrong, therefore its critics are either misinformed or intentionally dishonest. They have made the calculation that nobody will ever succeed in calling them to account because the opposing side’s kids keep aging out of school; soon enough it becomes somebody else’s problem, and the can gets kicked down the road. So the paychecks keep getting sent, the grades keep falling, and the buck gets passed: it’s not our fault; don’t blame us; blame them, or them, or them…</p><p>My father-in-law was a New York high school principal for over 25 years. When I mentioned that teacher hiring in Providence is based on seniority, not merit, and that underperforming or absentee teachers are not permitted to be disciplined or fired by principals because their employment is protected by their union, he was appalled. The first thing he asked was “Who negotiated that contract? Start there.” He’s right: why does the Providence Teachers Union have the power to dictate this in the first place? What made the Mayor feel obliged to gift this absurdity to the union’s members — at the expense of our kids? Whoever OK’d this contract knew that it would give the union the power to keep substandard teachers in circulation and that it would limit professional development opportunities for others. Literally the <em>ONLY</em> outcome of these is that it <em>HURTS STUDENTS</em>. The teachers get paid either way. How is this logical?</p><p>Parents know that most teachers are well-intentioned, committed, and hardworking, and that they’re laboring under impossible conditions. But, like any profession, there are bad apples and this district has more than a few. You can fully expect parents to start naming names; it’s time to clean house. Private enterprise doesn’t survive underperformance, and neither does education. Yet, per the PPSD Review, underperforming teachers are routinely shuffled around, and guaranteed a teaching post from year to year (on our dollar). No business would tolerate this. No sensible person would tolerate this.</p><p><strong><em>NINETY PERCENT</em></strong><em> OF OUR KIDS ARE FAILING ENGLISH AND MATH.</em></p><p>As if the nightmare of the district’s administrative dysfunction wasn’t bad enough, even the most elementary part of a school education — the classroom — is broken here. Students are unchallenged or outright ignored, discipline is virtually non-existent, curricula are vague and random and insufficient, homework is a joke, facilities and materials are deficient, and the culture of learning is completely bankrupt. School in Providence has become a kind of super-funded daycare. No wonder so many are moving away. No wonder so many are sending their kids to private schools — for those who can afford it. And no wonder the charter school evangelists are crowing louder than ever: this only legitimizes their existence. But the charter school model is the classic American non-solution: forget about that tired, broken system and feast your eyes on this Shiny New One! What they’ve done is argue for the construction of a second set of train tracks beside the existing one, never mind that it only serves a lucky few, is not scalable (not even close), and sucks teachers, money, community investment, and attention away from public schools where approximately 90% of the city’s kids are still hoping like hell to get an education too. Charter schools are a diversion from the difficult job of actually <em>fixing</em> something. It’s irresponsible, unfair, and it’s unforgivably shortsighted.</p><p>My wife and I had, until this PPSD Review, steadfastly refused to consider bailing out of the public school system in Providence. We were both educated in public schools, we both have graduate degrees, and we both believe that public schooling is the best way for a citizenry to cultivate a sense of shared experience and community. Public schools are where most of our countrymen start; it’s where we learn to be responsible, fair, empathetic, constructive, co-dependent, and emboldened for the future by our collective power.</p><p>Now take away great teachers, effective discipline, principals with meaningful authority, proven curricula, responsive funding, sound buildings, sports and art, morale and meaning, and watch what happens to that future. It’s shameful.</p><p><strong><em>NINETY PERCENT</em></strong><em> OF OUR KIDS ARE FAILING ENGLISH AND MATH.</em></p><p>There are no dumb questions.</p><p><strong>Teachers</strong>: Do <em>YOU</em> think that the Union contract’s hiring/firing requirements are good for students and education? Are <em>YOU</em> outraged by it? The time has come to speak up.</p><p><strong>Principals</strong>: What do <em>YOU</em> need to be more effective at the school level? What obstacles are preventing proper curricula from being taught, teachers being adequately trained, discipline being meaningful, and school facilities being maintained?</p><p><strong>School board</strong>: Do <em>YOU</em> want the authority to govern PPSD school policy and contract negotiations? What is obstructing effective policymaking and administration in Providence?</p><p><strong>City council</strong>: Do <em>YOU</em> think you’re an effective body for serving the district’s schools? Are you part of the solution or part of the problem?</p><p><strong>Superintendent</strong>: Do YOU think you could be more effective with more authority? Or is that authority best assigned elsewhere? What is NOT WORKING and why?</p><p><strong>Mayor</strong>: Do <em>YOU</em> think your approach to Providence schools is working? Do <em>YOU</em> think the CBA needs to be gutted and renegotiated immediately? Nobody is waiting until 2020; students are failing <em>NOW</em>.</p><p><strong>RIDE</strong>: Do <em>YOU</em> think your pressure on the district’s schools is helping or hurting? Do <em>YOU</em> think you’re being responsive enough in ensuring that the needs of the largest school district in the state are being met?</p><p><strong>PPSD</strong>: Do <em>YOU</em> think you’re getting it done? Do you even <em>KNOW</em> what needs to be done? <em>HOW</em> you are going to change how you operate to give Providence schools what they need to turn around?</p><p><strong>Providence Teachers Union</strong>: Would <em>YOU</em> send your kids to Providence schools?</p><p><strong>To all parties</strong>: <em>WHO</em> should be in control of the district’s educational system? Can you agree?</p><p><strong><em>NINETY PERCENT</em></strong><em> OF OUR KIDS ARE FAILING ENGLISH AND MATH. WHAT PERCENTAGE OF THOSE WHO WE PAY TO PREVENT THAT ARE RESPONSIBLE?</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eafb26dae952" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>