<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Emmanuel on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Emmanuel on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@emmanuel6?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 12:00:40 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@emmanuel6/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Famous Art Gallery Just Crossed a Line — and Nobody Is Talking About It]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/famous-photo-gallery-yellowkorner-now-sells-horrendous-ai-images-instead-of-real-art-photos-075f4321b502?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/075f4321b502</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-ai-tools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[photography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yellowkorner]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Dec 2025 10:57:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-04T13:07:57.819Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Known around the world for curating real photographic art, this institution is now making a choice that raises serious questions about ethics, art, and trust.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GdzTzBR3LwBHj5g_7iSJ-w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photos taken by author, depicting AI images made by artist Fabien Novarino, sold at YellowKorner shop in Passy in Paris, France.</figcaption></figure><p>Even though my job is in illustration, I always enjoyed and respected photography as an art. I always loved to visit YellowKorner shops to admire interesting and huge beautiful photos. But yesterday, while walking by their gallery in Passy in Paris, I was immediately struck by the “photos” displayed in the storefront windows. Take a look at the pictures above.</p><p>If you have any experience with AI images, those “photos” (with the slightly misleading label “silver gelatin print” underneath them, as if real photos), are instantly identifiable as AI productions. The nonsensical logo on the shoulder, the glass helmet visor that doesn’t connect properly to the helmet, but above all else… those horrible artifacts that you can see on the zoomed in photo on the right.</p><p>I couldn’t believe it. I always assumed YellowKorner was a high end… photography gallery. Not a “generalist” art gallery. Not a kitsch and cheesy “<a href="https://medium.com/@emmanuel6/what-is-fast-art-837f67673c7b">fast art</a>” gallery (you know, the ones with the cheap pop art imitations of Warhol style paintings, the Mickey Mouse showing the middle finger and other balloon dogs…).</p><p>So obviously, I entered the gallery, to see for myself if I was mistaken, or if indeed I was witnessing the death of a renowned art institution.</p><p>This is what I saw inside:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VIGD6lZURroY1B7K_LRbgw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by author, depicting AI image made by artist duo Electric Dreams, at YellowKorner shop in Passy in Paris, France.</figcaption></figure><p>Take a closer look at the signs on the shops. Yeah. Nonsensical text. Here is a closer look below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1dzS8Qz_ue-kA07sOegTww.png" /></figure><p>Another photo:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p13f1dA2k4oMRB9L0n2nxg.png" /><figcaption>Ai image by artist Alexandre Fauve.</figcaption></figure><p>Take a look at the price and label:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5lGQEduVBgG1BgFPlgHOoA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo taken by author at YellowKorner shop in Passy in Paris, France.</figcaption></figure><p>$2.000 for a giant… AI image. Notice that AI is not mentioned anywhere on the label. To be fair, it is indeed mentioned on their website, but deeply buried in the specs details. When I asked the owner of the gallery about it, he didn’t lie at all. But I wonder if older and uninformed clients are really made aware of what they are buying honestly.</p><p>And let me tell you, at this scale (2x1 meters, or 6.6x3 feet), you cannot miss the horribles artifacts, right in front of your face. I mean, take a look at this close up on the trees in the middle of the image:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VE_8DLvXcbTgAs_6Ar1z-w.png" /><figcaption>Ai image by artist Alexandre Fauve close-up.</figcaption></figure><p>I asked the owner about all those AI images in the gallery. After saying some nonsense about the fact that photographs can’t make photos with animals anymore because of animal protection laws (which is completely false, they have been selling real photos with all kinds of animals before…), and even though most of the AI images don’t contain any animals… he then said that we have to embrace modernity and stuff like this.</p><p>I mean, ok… you can probably defend that position if you want. But wasn’t the whole purpose of this gallery to sell, you know, photos? I mean they even state that on their communication material. They don’t sell paintings, drawings, sculptures. Just photos. How is an AI image considered a photo now? And more importantly, how can they sell those alongside real photos? I really don’t get it.</p><p>It’s a bit like if you went to a kids’ toy shop, and they sold toys for dogs. Don’t get me wrong, I have nothing against people who buy toys for their dog. But wouldn’t that be weird and misleading to sell dog toys in the middle of kids’ toys, without explicitly mentioning the difference?</p><h4>But the misleading aspect is not even the main issue for me here.</h4><p>The main issue for me is simply the quality of the product. I’m absolutely sure most clients would not even notice the issue by looking at the images. You need a little bit of knowledge about technology and those tools to notice the difference. My parents or my grand parents would never notice it, I’m sure of it. Moreover, YellowKorner is a very established and respected institution. I doubt anybody not very familiar with art and AI would even suspect that they could sell anything other than real photographs taken by real photographers.</p><p>But the issue of quality is not about the fact that most people wouldn’t notice the difference. Exactly like most people wouldn’t notice the difference between a cheap or expensive bottle of wine in a high end restaurant.</p><p>That simply doesn’t change the fact that people are still implicitly expecting quality in those institutions. That’s why they are ready to pay the big bucks. It doesn’t matter that they “enjoy” the quality in those venues more for the psychological effect than for the real “understanding” of it. If a high end restaurant sold a $20 wine bottle, that they bought at the supermarket, for $1500 dollars, letting people believe it was a grand cru, it would be very misleading and dishonest. Even though most people would not notice the difference. There is a tacit understanding in luxury establishments, that the products are (normally) of high quality, certified as such by experts and gourmets who know a lot more than us. Vetted by critics etc… It doesn’t matter if they mention somewhere in the menu that the wine is actually just a cheap bottle. We would feel betrayed.</p><p>It’s the same here. I assume most people who are not familiar with art and/or new tools would simply buy the images because they look nice on a superficial level, and they would assume that for $2.000 they are buying an exclusive photo, by a high end photographer. Imagine if after two months, when an art enthusiast friend of theirs came to visit their house, they said to them: “oh you buy AI art now?”. How would they react? I mean I hope YellowKorner is indeed warning their clients that they are buying AI images. But what if they are not explicitly warning them? I don’t know for sure, but I feel there is something disingenuous about the whole thing. I could be wrong though. Maybe all clients are well aware of what’s happening. I would need to do more research to be sure. But it could be very tempting to simply not mention it. After all, they keep saying on the labels “silver gelatin print”, and still present the “artists” as “collage photographer using the latest AI tools” or something…</p><p><strong>But here is the problem: the quality is NOT there.</strong></p><p>There are artifacts on those images. A lot. They don’t survive a 20 seconds scrutiny by any trained eye. Things are just not connecting properly. Eyes of humans and animals have all the problems of AI images. Everything feels cheap and fake. I mean, if at least they modified the images to make them look “good”, I would at least admit there is some work being done here. It’s not even that hard to do for anyone familiar with photoshop and similar softwares. But it’s not the case. It just looks like it was printed straight out of the generative tools. Maybe upscaled to get good definition, but that’s all.</p><p>How can you sell thousand of dollars images that are literally just giant prints of generative tools? Isn’t that… weird? How can that not hurt them in the long run? Even if they stoped after some backlash (which I’m almost certain will happen at some point), wouldn’t they have created a dangerous doubt for customers?</p><h4>The psychological effects of art</h4><p>You see, for me, and for many art enthusiasts, luxury clothes enthusiast, gourmets etc… the psychological effect of art is extremely important. I would even say that it is one of the main aspects of art. We don’t like or buy an image just for its superficial aesthetic qualities. We buy it for what it represent and means at a deeper level. We might be amazed by a photo, not just because it looks nice, but also because we know that the thing it depicts actually exists somewhere. That’s part of the beauty of photography.</p><p>We admire a luxury brand not just because its clothes look nice, but because we know it was crafted by hand by some experienced tailors, following a century old tradition. Even if we can’t all tell the difference.</p><p>How would you feel if you paid $6.000 for a famous couturier suit (let’s imagine we could actually afford those…), thinking it was done by hand by great tailors in Italy, only to discover that it was done in factories in Bangladesh, with cheap fabric, and that the real cost of the piece was $50?</p><p>Yeah, maybe the suit still looks nice (I mean it’s doubtful honestly, but let’s imagine). But it’s not the same.</p><p>How would you feel if you bought an expensive painting, only to discover it was not from the artist you believed it was, but by a counterfeiter? Maybe the painting still looks nice on your wall, but it’s not the same.</p><p>I know what you think: those are rich people problems. And you’re right. But still, think about all the people working in those luxury industries, and all those artists who get hurt in the process. I know you don’t feel sorry for rich people getting scammed. I don’t that much either. But I feel sorry for the real artists and craftsmen whose work gets devalued by all those cheap rip-offs.</p><p>Tell me in the comments if you had any knowledge about those AI images being sold there, and/or if you know anyone who got fooled by it, I would love to learn more about this whole thing.</p><p>Have a good day.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=075f4321b502" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2 years later, Midjourney still hasn’t taken over my job as an illustrator and storyboard artist]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/2-years-later-midjourney-still-hasnt-taken-over-my-job-as-an-illustrator-and-storyboard-artist-4558f6b321a6?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4558f6b321a6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[illustration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[midjourney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Jul 2024 09:21:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-24T09:21:51.465Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>I was right so far, but why exactly? A deep analysis and comparison of human vs AI art skills. And a test for you to try, if you still don’t believe me ;)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BnGGh9-OG0A9yoDPCn8_PA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by author (like <strong>really</strong> by author, not with AI but by painting it haha)</figcaption></figure><p>A lot of people feared AI will replace artists. I feared too, as an artist. But as soon as I tested the AI, I understood I was “safe”. I even wrote an article two years ago about it, that got some “success”: <a href="https://medium.com/@emmanuel6/why-dall-e-will-not-steal-my-job-6a1e2943cb82?source=your_stories_page-------------------------------------">Why Dall-E will not steal my job</a>.</p><p>Around me, most other artists were not so worried. It’s generally people not working as artists who jumped to crazy conclusions. And I think there are two main reasons for that misunderstanding:</p><p>The first reason is actually pretty simple: non-artists overestimate the time it takes for a professional artist to create a simple art piece (like a storyboard frame), and (vastly) underestimate the time it takes to get a decent art piece out of a generative AI model. More on that after.</p><p>The second reason is that non artists have never really tried to create something for a real client with an AI model. We artists have obviously tried (to see if we could go faster, cheat our way out of working, or simply see if we will get replaced). And we all had to revert back (thankfully), to really, hum, making art. That’s the most critical point. I’m going to expand more about it now.</p><h4>Making real “new” things is impossible with AI models</h4><p>I know that’s the most controversial statement. And you will test my words later in this article. But as an artist who has tried those models for a few years now, I can absolutely tell you with certainty that AI models can’t really “create” like an human, EVEN if they really, really, look like they do to non-artists (and even to some artists who haven’t fully tried it yet).</p><p>You see, for people outside of the “artistic jobs” (and even for us sometimes to be fully honest), it can be very difficult to see the nuanced differences between creation and remixing. We can only see it when we are actually trying to create something original with the AI (when we don’t have the choice). In that regard, I am thankful to AI, not only because it’s useful for some small things in my workflow, but also because it allowed me to understand better the concept of creation itself.</p><p>Let’s give an example that everybody can understand better. If I create an art piece representing a Disney princess in the style of Tim Burton, I really look like I am actually creating something new. After all, that image/concept didn’t exist before, and now it exists. But in reality, I am remixing existing things. And to be fair, to a certain extent, all art is a little bit remixing what came before. But, it’s a little bit more complicated. Let me go further before judging.</p><p>If you ask an AI model to remix, it will do it reasonably well, and generally faster than a human. It’s really good for that.</p><p>That’s why the successful AI art pieces online generally look like the crossover of familiar concepts, like Marvel superheroes as babies, Star Wars characters in Wes Anderson style, Disney characters as zombies, Countries as knights, Religions as knights, knights in the desert, futuristic knights, superheroes dressed in old renaissance style etc…</p><p>That’s what it’s made for, and it produces actually fun and enjoyable images that way. It still takes time to get good images like that, but it does it well.</p><p>The problem arises as soon as you don’t remix clear existing things. Or you don’t use an existing (and famous) style. Ask it to make a generic character in Pixar style, mostly fine. Ask it a very precise character (not random), that looks like something you or your client have in mind, that wasn’t already done before, and the results are just impossible to get. Like really. I tried.</p><p>Still don’t believe me don’t you? I see… Then don’t take my words for it, just try it for your yourself :) Here is a test for you to see:</p><h4>The DIY test to see if I’m crazy</h4><p>Try to reproduce this storyboard I made for a client (or even just one or two frames as a test if you want), with any AI tool you like, without (obviously) putting my images in the software (that would be absurd, the idea is to try to create something “new” without an actual exact reference, the point of my job). I trust you will try for real as there is nothing to win haha, and it’s for science ;). You can use other images found online as references though, of course, as long as it’s not the ones below. I’m going to give you the same “rules” I got from my client underneath (like a simplified script if you will):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2fnLl55ealEQvg15wl2DMg.png" /><figcaption>Storyboard for Valvena by author</figcaption></figure><h4>The rules:</h4><p>You need 6 images (or one or two if you don’t have the patience, but ideally six). It’s mobile format (vertical). The two characters are two young men (two travel influencers), one is white, the other one is black. They have shorts, t-shirts, and a backpack for the white guy. They need to remain the same (or relatively consistent) in all the frames, obviously. They are live streaming while in front of some beautiful landscape and old maya ruins (like the Machu Pichu kind of ruins). In the first two images, the black man is holding the phone, we see his face in the foreground. White man in the background. Then they switch, white guy holds the phone. They look happy at first, then they start to freak out when the profile pictures of the people watching their livestream change to mosquitoes profile pictures (it’s for a mosquito repellent product).</p><p>You have the right to add the livestream profile pictures of people and mosquitoes, and the likes heart icons, in “post-prod” in photoshop or similar softwares if you know how to do it, if it’s easier. But there HAVE to be some indications that people are liking their livestream, and that their profile pictures are changing to mosquitoes, otherwise the all concept doesn’t work for this particular advertising.</p><p>If you manage to create something decent, please post it in the comments, and please add the time it took you. But what will happen most likely, if you don’t cheat and use my images as reference, is that you will have great difficulty to create even a single image conforming to the brief. You’ll see. Believe me, I tried.</p><p>Why exactly?</p><p>Simply because there are no other images on the all internet of two young influencers, one white and the other one black, live streaming in this exact configuration (with the black guy holding the phone in front of his face, and the white guy in the background with the Machu Pichu or similar mountain behind him). There just isn’t. It’s not super original when you think about it, I admit, but it’s not <em>generic enough </em>for the software. It’s too “particular”. You can find an image of a man taking a selfie, sure. You can find an image of a backpacker, sure. You can find an image of the Machu Pichu, sure. But combining the three in a way relatively similar of this storyboard is, first, very long and difficult to describe properly to the software. But also it’s too “specific”. You will get super weird results.</p><p>As you will see, while it’s pretty “easy” (still takes time and effort but it’s ok) to get a good image of a woman having a coffee, or smiling, or a man walking in the street (because it’s generic, looks like other similar images online), it’s actually extremely difficult to get an image of something too… not generic let’s say haha.</p><p>Now if you add the livestream “effects” (profile pictures, like heart icons, mosquitoes profile pics), it’s just absolutely impossible to get that exact image. You will have to at least add it “manually”. Which is okay by the way, but still requires a little bit of “graphic design work”, if not directly drawing it.</p><h4>Time</h4><p>Also, as you will discover, getting a decent image using those AI models takes time. You generally don’t get a good image on the first try. From my experience, and feedbacks I read online, it takes around 15 minutes for a generic image, 30 minutes for a more specific one, and up to a few hours to get something really “great” (that people like and share on social medias, like babies superheroes…).</p><p>For an artist, it takes 5 to 10 mins to get a decent sketch, 30mins to get a decent black and white frame, 1 hour to 1:30 hour to get a finished colored frame like the ones above (a little bit more if there are a lot of feedbacks). So, for a way more accurate result, you actually don’t really take THAT much more time than an AI model. The only real advantage of the AI model is the complexity of the rendering (you can get a fully rendered image way faster than what it would take for a human, but it’s generally never really necessary for professional works to get fully realistic renderings anyway…). And the workflow is generally easier if you provide a good black and white drawing made by an artist.</p><p>By the way, the best results are generally obtained by people uploading ready made images from real artists that they found online. That’s how the best AI images are made. Not from prompts directly, but from a mix of prompts and uploading and remixing images found on Pinterest.</p><p>So real artists actually still have an advantage, as they can provide those images themselves. Which leads to the last point.</p><h4>Last nail in the proverbial coffin</h4><p>Now to the very last nail in the proverbial coffin, something often overlooked:</p><p>We artists also can use the AI models everybody can use.</p><p>I know, it seems obvious, but nobody seems to have given real thoughts about it :)</p><p>The fact that anybody can create “art” using the AI models actually includes… us artists.</p><p>So even if the models become very good, someone who can draw, paint, use graphic design softwares, AND use the AI model, will still have an enormous advantage on someone only using the AI models.</p><p>Think about it: if you can hire someone who can use a good AI model, but can only do that, and hire someone who can use the AI model AND can draw and paint, thus being able to modify or improve at will the AI results, who would you rather hire? Who would make the best concept arts for video games instance?</p><p>Cars are getting better everyday, but everyday people <em>and</em> great pilots can both drive those. So the great pilots still have an advantage on the random joe in a race.</p><p>Great chess computers can be used by everyday people <em>and</em> chess masters. So chess masters still have an advantage in using those to learn on random players. Sure you can beat the great players with the computer, but would you hire a random joe with a computer to teach your kids chess, or would you hire a professional grand master? Go try to cheat at chess online on Lichess.org or Chess.com, you will soon get kicked out of the servers. It’s surprisingly easy to spot cheaters at chess online. Computers simply don’t play like humans. You can win a few games, then you’ll get spotted. Any intermediate player can spot the difference. Algorithms too.</p><p>More and more of my clients are sending me briefs with AI images that they created as references. But they are still contacting me because they simply can’t get the precise results they want from the softwares. It still looks too generic, and weird.</p><p>Don’t get me wrong, you can produce super cool and beautiful images from the softwares. But everybody else can. And in those everybody there are also artists. Who can modify at will those images. What makes you think it will be easy for anybody to compete, if everybody has the same AI models?</p><p>The overall level might increase (or more accurately, the <em>speed </em>will increase, not the level, as the level is of course limited by the data, thus by the best artists in those datas). But so will the level (or speed) of the people at the “top” of the pyramid.</p><p>Don’t hesitate to post your results in the comments, I would love to see it, and I will be happy to see if I’m missing something :)</p><p>Have a good day!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4558f6b321a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is “Fast Art”?]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/what-is-fast-art-837f67673c7b?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/837f67673c7b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gallery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artist]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 May 2024 09:44:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-30T14:12:56.880Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>It’s exactly like a fast food, but for art. An analysis of bad Pop Art and AI “art”.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*otUjgoDKf1u9OaC2aHMeVg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A random “bad art gallery”, the same in every city.</figcaption></figure><p>Audrey Hepburn, Mickey Mouse, Superman, Marilyn Monroe, Spiderman, Mr Monopoly... What do all of those “names” have in common? They are all the stars of the “Fast Art” movement, represented by all the “bad art galleries” of the world.</p><p>In every city in the world, in every neighborhood, from New York to New Delhi, from Paris to Mexico, there is a “bad art gallery”. We all walked by their store window. We all know their “art”. We all saw the same ideas repeated over and over.</p><p>If you are a kid, or a teenager, or someone who never entered a museum before, and it’s the very first time you come by such a gallery, you might stop in wonder. “Wow, it’s so cool” you might say.</p><p>But after encountering twenty almost identical galleries in many different cities, or simply after entering any good museum, you will want to puke anytime you come by those generic and bland “pieces”.</p><p>They represent a famous person (from the past generally but not always), an athlete, a singer, or a famous comic book character, or an animation character, and they “subvert” it.</p><p>Subvert here simply means they represent it in a graffiti style, or doing something uncommon for them. For instance:</p><p>Mickey Mouse showing his middle finger. Superman being obese.</p><p>Sometimes they just represent the person, with some funny colors (a bad imitation of Warhol). The stars here are Audrey Hepburn and Marylin Monroe.</p><p>It is always very hollow.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Because the “idea” is always the same, very superficial: to mix two opposing styles, or genres, or famous characters. A Disney princess in Tim Burton style, a superhero out of shape/old/evil…</p><p>50% of the time, they simply represent something famous in a graffiti style. Spiderman graffiti, Mr Monopoly graffiti, Mickey Mouse (again, I know, exhausting) graffiti…</p><p>It’s an art of “surfing” on other people’s art.</p><p>It used to say something, a critic, about the society of consumption. Now it just became another product of mass consumption.</p><p>It’s not creating anything new, just using the prestige of famous intellectual properties, changing a little detail, and selling it as “new”.</p><p>It’s not an act of creation, but of parasitism.</p><p>And worse for any art: it has already been done a million times before.</p><p>Why would you want to play (again) with a Campbell soup tin can, if it has been already done by Warhol, and done again, parodied, by millions of people since the 50&#39;s?</p><h4>What’s the point?</h4><p>To create something easy and fast, that looks good to the inexperienced person, to sell stuff without thinking. It’s exactly like a fast food.</p><p>It’s the Fast Art.</p><h4>“AI art” is Fast Art made easier.</h4><p>The Fast Art is also my main concern with AI Art. Because Ai art is just Fast Art made easier. The most successful “AI art” is generally precisely the mixing of existing characters or style.</p><p>It’s (almost) never creating something new, but making famous Marvel characters as babies/zombies/unicorn/whatever… or Disney Princesses as Tim burton characters, or as a portrait of someone in someone else’s style.</p><p>It’s always, like the Fast Art, funny, cool, good for a BuzzFeed article that you read in the morning while going to work. But’ it’s never, never, “new”, groundbreaking, or deep.</p><p>It says absolutely nothing.</p><p>And even when it does say something, it generally was already done a million times.</p><p>The first time, as a teenager, I saw Mickey Mouse showing his middle finger, I thought “oh cool”. Then when you saw the same kind of images a million times, you wonder “what’s the point exactly?”.</p><p>It doesn’t matter that the “ai artists” are using a machine to make art. The problem would be exactly the same if they used their brushes on a canvas.</p><p>It’s just that mixing two famous things does not make you someone creative. The concept of “mixing” already existed long before you were born. And the stuff you are mixing was already created by far more creative people.</p><p>Disney characters, like their princesses, or Mickey Mouse, Pluto, Dingo… look good, because they are amazing character designs made by creative geniuses. So of course your “art” is going to look superficially “cool” if you use them on a canvas.</p><p>It doesn’t mean that there is anything really creative in simply copying those already existing intellectual properties on your canvas, and adding some grunge graffiti effects around them.</p><p>The best way to see Fast Art for what it is, a gimmick, is to see a lot of it. When you will have seen a hundred similar bad pop art pieces, you will grow so bored of it. Exactly like if you eat at a fast food everyday.</p><p>And it’s as bad for your soul as a fast food is for your health.</p><p>Thank you, have a good day :)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=837f67673c7b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why there will always be inequalities in the world]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/why-there-will-always-be-inequalities-in-the-world-8fff0b8322a2?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8fff0b8322a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[polític]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Feb 2023 20:07:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-23T00:14:35.752Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The “let’s give 1 million dollars to everybody” thought experiment</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/971/1*L2AMR7lMLBIgnEwAmALAPw.jpeg" /></figure><p>A lot of people, intellectuals or “everyday people”, have amazing ideas to solve the insane amount of inequality in society. We should abolish private property (communism), or let the free market solve all problems by raising the living standards of everybody (capitalism), or let a powerful ruler choose the best path (most monarchies, dictatorships…), or get rid of any form of governments (anarchy)…</p><p>But, unfortunately, experience as shown that no human society, anywhere, under any ideology, since the beginning of history, has ever been equal. You can argue all you want about the various “levels of inequalities” (there is disparity between systems, it’s true), but the reality is that a few percentile of the population always ends up with the majority of the resources and power.</p><p>I should stress out that I’m not happy about that fact. But there is an economic reason for that, impossible to escape in the real world. A reason that cannot be ignored without running into false utopian dreams, which often lead to nightmares. Economy is complex, difficult, and often seems mysterious. That’s why it’s easy to lure people with false and dangerous promises. I thought it could be helpful to explain some basics, with some telling and more intuitive examples.</p><p>To explain it, I’m going to start with a thought experiment. Let’s imagine that your government suddenly decides to give every citizen 1 million dollars. In pure economic theory, it is possible, since the government can “produce” money. You probably already know that huge creation of money leads to inflation, but it’s important to really understand why, to really get to the deep reasons of inequalities.</p><h4>The “let’s give 1 million dollars to everybody” thought experiment</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zqJ4chSNKLPV998R-dZrKA.jpeg" /></figure><p>A new president is elected on a simple promise to solve all problems: he or she will award 1 million dollars to every citizen. It’s a promise impossible to resist. So the president is elected with a huge margin.</p><p>Through debt, printing of money and issuing of treasury bonds, the government manages to raise 340 trillion dollars (340 million of American citizens, by 1 million, equals 340 trillion). The actual debt of the US government is roughly 30 trillion. So that’s a huge increase (more than 11 times).</p><p>Many things will likely happen to the economy after that. The most important being inflation, or devaluation of the dollar as a money. Let’s start with an example of how it could impact the price of a single item, to understand why exactly inflation would appear. Then we will take an example of a salary impacted by inflation.</p><h4>The Ferrari example</h4><p>We are going to take a Ferrari F 458 as an example of a good that would be impacted by the new measure, to explain how inflation works.</p><p>The Ferrari F 458 costs roughly 200 000 dollars today. Let’s imagine that 10% of US citizen are fans of Ferrari, and dreamed of buying one since a long time. There are roughly 2.500 to 3.000 Ferrari F 458 sold every year. Now, 34 million of people want and can afford a Ferrari F 458. That’s twice the total number of cars sold in the USA every year (roughly 17 million).</p><p>To meet the demand, Ferrari would need to increase its production of F 458 from 2500 to 34 million units. That means an increase by 13.600. That would probably be physically impossible to do. That would mean producing as much Ferrari as twice the total of cars sold on the US market last year. They would never manage to get enough raw material (steel, plastic, man power…) to create enough cars. They could not simply buy all the other car factories, because other cars companies would probably face the same increase in demand (probably other people would prefer to buy a Porsche, a Ford, a Lamborghini etc…). There would be too much competition on the market to buy all the materials needed to increase the production of Ferrari on our finite planet. Moreover, the price of raw material would probably increase due to the high manufacturers demand.</p><p>So what would happen is that, as the demand would exponentially exceed the offer, the price of a F 458 Ferrari would rise exponentially. The Ferrari would not cost 200 000 dollars anymore, but 13.600x200.000=2.720.000.000 dollars (13600 is the increase in demand we calculated roughly earlier). Or more than 2 billion dollars if you want. It’s a very loose calculus, just to give an idea of the scales we are talking about.</p><p>But wait a minute you may say. Who could buy a 2 billion car? Simply the same people who can buy a 200.000 dollars Ferrari today. But how and why? We need now to get into the impact of inflation on salaries to understand further, but it’s all linked:</p><h4>The cleaning person example</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WUX2w0rtcjPKrBuhPWamJQ.png" /></figure><p>Let’s take the example of a cleaning lady or man. Being a cleaner is a very difficult, exhausting, little valued job, with a poor salary. When cleaning ladies and men will be awarded 1 million dollars, most of them will probably want to stop working. Either to find a better and more interesting job, or simply to go on vacation for an extended period of time.</p><p>But the cleaning still has to be done by someone. So companies will have to buy extremely expensive robots to clean. And if they can’t find one (because of price and/or too much demand), they inevitably will have to increase exponentially the salary of cleaning persons, to keep hiring ones.</p><p>But how do you convince someone who has 1 million on their bank account to come clean your company floor? By offering them extremely more money as salary, to convince them to come back to work. The same will probably happen for most jobs. How could a company afford to pay people 1 million or more a month? Simply by charging customers exponentially more for their services. They won’t have the choice, or nobody will be working anymore (at least in difficult jobs). They either increase the salaries and costs exponentially, or they shut down entirely.</p><p>But how could people still afford the services or products of companies which pay their employees hundreds of thousand, or millions of dollars a month, and then ask them hundreds of thousand, or millions of dollars for their services? It’s simple, everybody now has more buying power (1 million dollar), so people can afford to pay way more for basic necessities.</p><p>Then, higher paying jobs will naturally increase too. So, if the cleaning person is now paid 100.000.000 a year (10.000 times the actual real salary or something like that, very rough just to explain), then a lawyer will be paid 10.000x100.000 dollars a year (if they currently earn one hundred thousand a year for instance). That means a lawyer will earn 1.000.000.000 a year. That means the Ferrari will cost the lawyer two years of salary, roughly the same amount as of today.</p><p>Now let’s dive into the core of the problem: the finite ressources problem. Let’s take another example to explain it, that will be even more intuitive to understand than cars:</p><h4>The trip to a luxury destination example</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PbscfAKxR2XzqNlsS4PvGA.png" /></figure><p>Let’s imagine that most Americans want to go on holidays, in an exotic and foreign place. They all want to buy first class plane tickets to Hawai, or Paris, for instance. Unfortunately, there is not enough available place on the airlines for everybody. And not enough hotels to accommodate everybody. You can’t simply build million more planes and hotels. There is not enough place and material to build that. You can’t expand a city like Paris, or an island like Hawai, indefinitely. You can’t increase exponentially and suddenly the number of planes in circulation. I think it’s very intuitive to understand.</p><p>Millions of people now are trying to buy a few thousand plane tickets. Millions of people are trying to get to the presidential suite in the Ritz or other luxury hotels around the world. So what are airlines companies going to do? What are hotels going to do? You guessed it, they will dramatically increase the cost of their services. Who will be able to buy those plane tickets and those luxury hotel rooms? The same people who can afford it now.</p><h4>So why most people can’t be “rich”, economically speaking?</h4><p>To understand it further, we have to define what that really means to be “rich”. It’s not just having a lot of money, because money is an abstract and relative concept. Being rich simply means being able to buy a lot of resources, or assets. But where do those assets come from? They come from material, and man/woman power. And there is simply not enough of those things in the world for everybody to be “rich”.</p><p>In other words, not everybody can have an expensive sport car, or go to the Ritz in Paris, simply because there is a small finite amount of expensive sport cars made every year, and only 71 rooms in the Ritz in Paris. You can’t fit 7 billion people in 71 rooms. So not everybody can come to the Ritz in Paris. They simply can’t, no matter how much money you create out of thin air, and no matter what politicians can promise.</p><p>Moreover, even if there was an infinite quantity of material in the world (which is not the case), you would still need people to build the Ferrari in the factories, and people to build hotels, and to serve you and work in the Ritz for instance. Otherwise, a Ferrari not built is just steel and plastic (you even need people to make plastic). And an hotel without staff is not really an hotel. Just walls and furnitures who take dust. You can’t build a Ferrari by yourself. You can’t enjoy a palace without employees.</p><p>But who would be those workers serving you? If everybody is rich, why would some people decide to build you a Ferrari, or serve you the breakfast and clean your room in the Ritz?</p><p>To make an even more obvious point, there is 4.571 employees working for Ferrari today. There is probably even more subcontractors for a varity of their pieces. You also need outside contractors to build the factories, to run electric plant to provide you with electricity, I can’t even imagine how many workers to build the roads, convey the cars around the world, thousand of people extracting and refining the oil to make it work, etc…</p><p>There are probably millions of people necessary to build and allow a system to work properly to build around 2500 Ferrai F458 a year. You simply need way more people to build Ferrari than the number of Ferrari you can produce, sell or give each year. You simply can’t give a Ferrari to all the people who helped build one.</p><p>The same is true for the Ritz in Paris. There are 524 employees for the Ritz in Paris. Twice the number of the clients the hotel host (71 rooms, so if every room has a family of 4 that’s 284 people total). Even if we counted only the employees, you could not create a functioning turnover to allow every employee to enjoy the hotel fully, even taking turns like in a Kibbutz communist society. And I’m not even counting the workers necessary to build the place, to make electricity, water etc…</p><p>A “lavish” lifestyle, which means with abundant means and man power, is simply not possible to expand to the majority of people. It is by definition the accumulation of resources and man power into the hands of a few persons. This accumulation is possible only if many are working, and a few enjoying. The other alternative? Nobody is working, and everybody is poor. As soon as there is creation, there is accumulation by some. Yes, even in communist countries. Why? Because not everybody can do the same job. You need a lot of people doing difficult jobs, and just a few doing the lead, the “elite”. You can’t technically have a lot in the elite, and nobody doing the difficult jobs. Otherwise there is simply nothing made, and nothing to enjoy.</p><h4>Last note about the “value” of money</h4><p>Before concluding, I just wanted to add some precision about how money and the economy works (yeah just that haha). Very briefly I promise, to help clarify.</p><p>You probably already know that money is an abstract human concept, that has no inherent value. But something that people often miss, is also how much money is bound by the limits of the “real”, material world. You see, the way money value works is (very roughly), by comparing the amount of money in circulation in a country (producing that money), to the amount of value of its economy. That’s why the dollar has more value than the CFA Franc from Gabon (600 times more value). Because the country creating the dollar, the USA, has more material and “people” resources to “offer” in exchange of its dollar, than the Gabon against its CFA Franc. That simply means with dollars you can buy more “stuff” (everything produced in the USA to make it simple), than with the Franc CFA (everything produced in Gabon). Money is not backed by gold (gold has no inherent value either by the way), but it is backed by the value of a country economic power, and also the trust that people have in that economic power.</p><p>It’s more complicated in real life, but it’s the general idea. To explain it in another way, let’s try this: no matter how much money you have, you will not be able to buy even an ounce of Vibranium. Why? Because it is a fictitious metal, that only exists in the superhero universe of Marvel company. You can only buy what exist, what is produced. You can create how much money you want out of thin air, but you can’t create “stuff” out of thin air. That’s how money lose its value when a government produce too much of it.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>I want to stress out that I am absolutely not happy by the fact that there are inequalities. I also hope they will decrease. Too much inequalities are bad for the stability of societies, and destroy lives. I was just trying to explain to the best of my understanding of economy, why there will probably never be an utopian society without inequalities. Even if we were to remove organized societies entirely, and go back to the state of nature, there will always be stronger people who will organize to steal and use weaker people.</p><p>The goal should be to try to help the poor and the weak, and to limit the indecency of extreme inequalities. But I wrote this article to warn against the false utopian promises of some fool, who tell you that the solution is to get rid entirely of the system, or of society values. Because there is simply no societies without inequalities, and there will never be. The goal is simply to help the ones at the bottom, and to make the game as fair as humanly possible.</p><p>Have a good day.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8fff0b8322a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why you should not participate in any unpaid graphic design contests]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/why-you-should-not-participate-in-any-unpaid-graphic-design-contests-ce9e821a2a3b?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ce9e821a2a3b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[unpaid]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[graphic-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contests]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motion-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Dec 2022 12:14:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-21T12:14:09.970Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>It’s not (only) because it hurts the market, it’s just totally useless for you</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V2fh4NWkofAWNnjonfSpUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Nicola Barts on Pexels</figcaption></figure><p>There are a lot of freelancing websites, like 99 designs, that work on the concept of unpaid contests for freelancers. Whether you are a graphic designer, a motion designer, or an illustrator, I strongly recommend you never participate in unpaid contest to win a client or a project.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Simply because it is a totally unreliable way of working. On any website that promotes that way of working, there are at least tens of people participating in each contest, if not hundreds. The clients select people based on their “feelings” on each project, which means it is usually totally random.</p><p>Even if they selected on talent or actual quality of work (which is absolutely not the case most of the time, because they are not professionals in this field), you probably have the same level than a lot of other graphic designers, illustrators or motion designers. Which means that even if you produce very good work, you still rely on chance to earn money. It’s like playing in a casino.</p><p>Moreover, even if you win once in a while, your ratio work/rates is impossible to sustain to live.</p><p>If you work one week on each contest, and you win a quarter of those contest (which would be an EXTREMELY good ratio of win, very unlikely to happen), you would still work entire months, for the price of a single week. But most often than not, you’ll win less than 10% of your contests. Than means you’ll work the entire year, for less than a month salary. How long do you think you can do that?</p><p>When you just finished school, and are desperately trying to have some new clients, it can be very tempting. Because you don’t really need to earn a lot of money (you are still living with your parents, or you are working another part time job, and/or you don’t have many expenses), but you can’t sustain a real life with contests. So why bother in the first place?</p><p>To make a “name” for yourself? To expand your portfolio?</p><p>That will not happen. The quality of the work you will produce will be very low, even if you are good. Because you simply don’t have the time to work properly, and you will lose your motivation very fast as the rates are very low anyway. After losing a few contests, you will give up. The problem is that there will always be new “juniors” to replace you.</p><p>Moreover, the clients who hire people in those contests usually are more interested in cheap over quality. They are not “big brand names” like Coca Cola. They are unknown “little people”. And they will often choose poor designs, or ask you to make your design “uglier” (my wife likes purple, can you do the logo purple, and add some yellow in it, and some pink…” those kind of feedbacks). So even if you win, chances are your portfolio will not improve that much.</p><p>Sometimes, the contests are simply canceled after every participants send their work.</p><p>I know it’s hard to not have work when you start. But trust me, those contest will only give you the false impression that you are working. But it’s fake. You are not really working if you are not paid.</p><p>What those contests are actually doing, is to provide a service for free for clients. That service is called “brainstorming”. It is actually the most important part of your design process. But instead of having just a few different ideas proposed by a single person, as is the case with any graphic designer or illustrator job, the client can choose between hundreds of propositions.</p><p>The problem? those propositions take time and effort to produce, by a lot of people. And almost none of them are paid.</p><p>To make an analogy, it’s exactly like if someone hired workers to build them a house, let’s say, a hundred workers (masons, electricians, plumbers, painters etc…). But they said they would only pay ONE of the workers, at the end. The one who did “the best job” of all.</p><p>Keep in mind that ALL the workers helped to build the house. They all worked hard, and participated in the success of the house. But at the end, only one tiler would get paid for his work, because he was the favorite worker of the client. And worse, he would be paid the price of a single worker, not even the price of the full house.</p><p>It’s not even a good deal for the winner. At least the winner should be paid the price of one hundred workers. That would be a little bit more “fair”. Like if you play the lottery, you don’t win the price of a single ticket, you win the price of ALL the tickets sold. That’s why people want to win the lottery. Only one winner, but who wins enough for a lifetime. Not just enough to finish the month.</p><p>In the end, the client had the work of one hundred people, for the price of one.</p><p>That’s exactly the same in those graphic design contests. The client has one hundred ideas for their logo, their videos, their packaging, but they pay only one. It’s absurdly unfair.</p><p>But I want to stress out that the problem is not a “moral” problem. I don’t really care about that. If people want to work for free, it’s their problem, and their “right”. Really. If you want to clean the house of your neighbor for free, who am I to stop you. But they should at least know that they are working for free.</p><p>That’s why I’m writing this article. To explain the “real” deal of those contests.</p><p>To conclude, be aware that there are absolutely NO reason to participate in unpaid contests. It’s not “just” killing the profession, I know you don’t really care about that when you are desperately trying to work, but it’s also killing you.</p><p>It will have EXACTLY the same impact on your career than to simply create your own personal projects to expand your portfolio. Honestly, take the time to do that instead. Then try to register with real “agents”, or websites that don’t work on the basis of unpaid contests.</p><p>Thank you, have a good day :)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ce9e821a2a3b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The limits of logical reasoning]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/the-limits-of-logical-reasoning-417631f66b8f?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/417631f66b8f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[phylosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abortion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logical-reasoning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gun-control]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Nov 2022 13:05:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-28T13:05:36.110Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Especially on difficult political issues, like abortion and guns rights…</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DLIVcsPGzy3PiilItIvAMA.png" /><figcaption>The thinker by Rodin, model 1880, cast 1901</figcaption></figure><p>There is a big flaw in political reasoning and debates, which I believe is the “real”, deep reason, of political misunderstandings and political conflicts between citizens. I believe we are mislead by thinking that “echo chambers”, or “polarization”, are the main causes. They play a role, for sure. But the real problem is the misunderstanding of the limits of “logical reasoning”, as envisioned and explained first by philosopher Kant in his <em>Critique of Pure Reason </em>(even if it was applied on metaphysics, I believe it applies also on political debates).</p><p>I’m going to take two “hot” political issues, as examples in this article, to try to demonstrate that you can completely, fairly, legitimately, reasonably, justify very opposite views on different topics, even with the same datas. A little bit like Kant “proved” the existence, AND then the lack of reality, of God in his famous book, to demonstrate the limits of reasoning. I’m going to try to do the same with those hot and polarizing political topics that are <strong>abortion</strong>, and <strong>gun laws</strong>.</p><p>My goal here is to give for each of those two issues, two opposite “in favor” and “against” arguments. My goal is to give “extremely” convincing arguments (at least for most “reasonable people”), that would reasonably convince almost anyone of their validity, no matter their personal political sides.</p><p>My goal, if I succeed, is to put you in the position where you don’t change your mind, but realize that there was more to the question than you thought initially. No matter where you stand for. I will obviously try to abstain from giving you arguments that you already heard, the “classical arguments”. We will go deeper, I hope. We will take “new perspectives”.</p><p>My goal is obviously not to convince you to take one or the other side, but precisely to show that you can’t convince someone on those issues using only “logical arguments”. I believe, I hope, that realization could help to reduce tensions in society, if better understood. I’m going, in conclusion, to give more “useful” way to try “answering” those difficult questions.</p><h4>Abortion, against and in favor arguments.</h4><h4>1-The case against abortion</h4><p>There is one particularly convincing logical argument against abortion. It is exemplified by the legal turmoils of “third party fetus homicide” laws, that arise as soon as abortion laws are enacted in any country. <a href="https://repository.uchastings.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1656&amp;context=hastings_constitutional_law_quaterly">This great legal review article</a>, from the respected Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly (article written by Californian defense lawyer Alison Tao), exemplify the problem.</p><p>To explain it very simply, to allow abortion, the general legal propositions are to consider that a fetus is not a person until a certain amount of time, generally the first trimester of the pregnancy, because it is not yet sufficiently “formed”.</p><p>No matter if this proposition is reasonable or not, it creates a difficult legal (and even philosophical) question, the question of third party fetus homicide.</p><p>To explain it with a little context: Imagine a pregnant woman, during her first semester of pregnancy. This woman and her husband had great difficulty conceiving a child. They finally succeeded thanks to medical help, but the doctors warn that if this attempt finally fail, they are not sure they could succeed the next time, as can happen in certain difficult pregnancies.</p><p>Now imagine that this woman is attacked by a stranger in the street, who pushes her on the ground, to rob her of her purse. During this attack, the fragile fetus unfortunately dies in the shock. The woman “herself” suffers minor bruises.</p><p>The legal question is: should the attacker be prosecuted under the definition of “simple assault” (shoving or slapping a person that results in bruising may be charged, generally, as simple assault), or involuntary fetus homicide?</p><p>It seems like a simple question, but it is actually not. To be characterized as an homicide, the victim must be considered legally a person. You can’t legally “murder” a chair.</p><p>Some states simply added an aggravating circumstance in the case of assault on pregnant women.</p><p>Assaulting a pregnant woman seems like an obviously terrible action, so let’s look at other, more complicated legal scenarios.</p><p>What if the same woman was pushed, not by an attacker, but by accident, simply by someone running to catch a bus?</p><p>In this case, the hurried passer-by can face no charges on the one hand (it’s legally an innocuous accident to accidentally push someone on the ground, if no serious injuries result), or, on the other hand, face reckless homicide charges, which are extremely more severe (and can be up to 15 years or more in prison, depending on the circumstances and the states), if the fetus is a “person”.</p><p>The difference is huge for the persons involved.</p><p>Now imagine a last scenario: What if the husband, or boyfriend, of a pregnant woman, decides he doesn’t want to become a father anymore. His partner refuse to abort. So he slips an abortive pile in the drink of his wife. The fetus dies, but no “harm” (at least physical) is done to the pregnant woman.</p><p>Can this be considered an assault? Is this “so bad” legally, if only a fetus, as a non-person, was harmed? Probably yes, because it was non consensual, but how to classify it? Is it really like slipping an innocuous vitamin in someone else’s drink? Is it a little more severe? How severe? What is the loss? The loss of a minor organ, or the loss of a life?</p><p>And more importantly, how would the pregnant woman perceive those situations? It could be argued that from her perspective, even if she was still in her first semester, her loss is comparable to the loss of a “real human being”. After all, if the actions of the third party had not taken place, she would have had a full child, who would have lived a full life. She indeed could rightly feel that her “child” was taken away from her, and would probably want her loss to be recognized by the justice and society.</p><p>To conclude, if we consider that a first trimester fetus is not a person, then a third party killing this fetus should (or could<em> in theory</em>) have no more legal and moral consequences than cutting someone’s hair or fingernails.</p><p>But we all intuitively feel that is not really the case, at least I believe, based precisely on the “third party fetus homicide laws” enacted in most states.</p><p>I feel the counter argument coming. But the problem is not that “someone” is “killed” for pro-choice defender, but that the pregnant woman suffered a loss in her own body, without her consent. So the problem is the problem of consent.</p><p>It can be simply answered that yes, the consent is the problem. But once again, no matter the lack of consent, the issue is of the value of the loss. You can’t legally of morally blame someone who made you loss a small part of a fingernail. So we have to agree that a fetus is of more value than a fingernail (as most states and people do). So we have to wonder what value. And for most people who would suffer such a loss, the value is of course the value of a “future life”.</p><p>We can reasonably add that ANY action, by third party or not, who ends a viable pregnancy at any term, is indeed jeopardizing a life. So it can be “reasonably” defended that a fetus is, <em>at least</em>, a “future person”, or citizen, or human being. So an abortion can be argued reasonably to be, <em>at least</em>, a preemptive or actual form of “murder”.</p><p>Now, let’s see an equally reasonable and logical argument in favor of abortion.</p><h4>2-The case for abortion</h4><p>Even if we were to admit (we don’t really have too, but for the sake of thinking) the conclusion of the first argument, that a fetus is a person, there is a very good argument to be made in favor of abortion. A moral and legal one at the same time.</p><p>Let’s admit that a fetus is a person. We have to realize that it is nevertheless a person in a very unique situation, in that its life, its very existence, is entirely, completely, dependent on another person body (the mother, or pregnant woman, how you like to call her).</p><p>A fetus is indeed the only human who lives inside another human being.</p><p>It cannot survive, especially in the beginning, outside of the body of the pregnant woman.</p><p>That raises a big legal and moral problem. But before explaining that problem, I’m going to give another similar legal and moral question, that will help exemplify the situation.</p><p>If you have a terrible kidney failure, and you need a kidney donor to save your life, you are in a relatively “similar” legal and moral situation of a fetus. I know it seems far stretched, but you are going to see that it is not THAT far stretched actually.</p><p>Imagine the only donor available is one of your siblings, or even your mother for instance (I’m sure you see where I am going). If they give you one of their kidneys, they will save your life. If they refuse, you will die. They are indeed somehow “killing you”, in a sense, if they refuse.</p><p>But the problem is that, as it is considered in almost every democratic country, it is legally impossible to force someone to give you their kidney. They have to do it voluntarily. There are two reasons for that. First, obviously, because they risk their health themselves by doing so. It is generally a safe procedure, but they can still die during the operation. And they can also have a small risk of having their only remaining kidney fail them at a later stage of their own life. It is just a little bit less safe to have only one kidney than two for this reason.</p><p>It is also considered by most democratic countries that a person’s body is “sacred”, and belongs only to themselves. We can’t force someone to use part of their body for someone else, even for saving a life.</p><p>A pregnant woman is in exactly the same situation as a potential organ donor. Because, even if the health risks of pregnancies have become less and less prevalent, they still exist. A woman still have a small risk of dying during pregnancy or childbirth. Moreover, she is supposed, as any citizen, to possess full property, autonomy and choices regarding her own body.</p><p>It is therefore absolutely immoral, and illegal, to force a woman to have a pregnancy against her will, even if the fetus is a person.</p><p>-</p><p>I hope, with those two arguments, that I managed to convince you, not that abortion is good or bad, but that very strong logical arguments can be made on the two opposite sides of this debate.</p><p>What is more important? The right to live of the fetus as a futur person, or the rights of bodily autonomy of a woman? Those are “competing rights”, very valid competing rights. The solution is NOT obvious, I hope I managed to show that complexity. It is not easy to decide only based on “logic”. We have to use our personal “gut feelings” at some point (or personal preferences, opinions if you will), to choose a side. There is probably no “right or wrong” answer.</p><p>That’s why finding a “middle ground”, or consensus, is probably a good idea. But we will talk about that in the conclusion.</p><p>Let’s try the same exercice with gun laws, this other hot political debate.</p><h4>The right to buy guns, against and in favor arguments.</h4><h4>1-The case for guns</h4><p>There is one big argument in favor of laws, in my opinion, allowing citizens to purchase firearms. It is that the number of people actually dying from gun violence (homicides I mean, not suicides) is <em>relatively</em> low, even in a country like the USA (which have very lax gun laws), compared to other “mundane” causes of deaths. There is around <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/195325/murder-victims-in-the-us-by-weapon-used/">12 000 homicides</a> by firearms, every year, in the USA, compared with more than <a href="https://www.forbes.com/advisor/legal/auto-accident/car-accident-deaths/#:~:text=In%20the%20United%20States%2C%20the,Fatality%20Analysis%20Reporting%20System&#39;s%20history.">40 000 deaths by car accident</a>, or even <a href="https://nida.nih.gov/research-topics/trends-statistics/overdose-death-rates#:~:text=Nearly%2092%2C000%20persons%20in%20the,drug%20from%201999%20to%202020.">92 000 death by drug overdose</a>.</p><p>In this regard, it can be argued that preventing citizens from buying firearms, for personal defense, for fun, or any other reason, is not very “reasonable” considering that almost everybody is able to buy a car. People drive recklessly, under the influence of various substances, everyday. Nobody thinks of banning cars. Sure, you need a driver license, but a firearm permit can be implemented in the same way.</p><p>For instance, if the government makes sure that any gun purchaser has no criminal record, and why not also regularly checks that they have no dangerous mental health issues (every 10 years for instance), it could be reasonably argued that guns are finally not really more dangerous than cars.</p><p>Moreover, some countries, like Switzerland, have a lot of gun ownership, around <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/switzerland-gun-laws-rates-of-gun-deaths-2018-2?r=US&amp;IR=T">28% of the population possesses a firearm</a> there, compared to <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/249740/percentage-of-households-in-the-united-states-owning-a-firearm/">42% in the USA.</a> But their rate of homicides is extremely low, <a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/VC.IHR.PSRC.P5?locations=CH">1 per 100 000 people compared to 7 per 100 000 people in the USA</a>.</p><p>So maybe the reason of gun violence is not <em>only</em> related to gun ownership, but to other factors. It is possible (just speculations), that the difficult access to health practitioners, health insurance, low safety and social net protections, extreme capitalist functioning of the USA (where winners take all, and “losers” are left dangerously alone and vulnerable), are a dangerous “mix”, that <em>combined </em>with high gun ownership, creates this unusual high level (relatively to other countries I mean) of gun violence that we see in the USA, with all their mass shootings, school shootings, and day to day violence. There could be many factors. It is not absolutely sure that the prevalence of guns is in itself a guarantee of violence.</p><p>Guns didn’t exist before around at least the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun">13th century</a>, but societies where infinitely more violent before that. Societies were even more violents before the invention of modern firearms, one or two centuries ago. I’m sure most people would prefer to live in America today, with all their guns, that in medieval Europe with all their swords. I’m not even talking about health concerns, but really you had more chances to be killed by a sword in medieval Paris, in France, than in modern day Chicago with all their guns and gangs.</p><h4>2-The case against guns</h4><p>Let’s admit that guns are not <em>that</em> dangerous for society, compared to other more “mundane” risks like car accidents. Let’s admit guns are not even the <em>main</em> reason of violence in a society, but just participating in the mix of other social problems. There is still the question to know: are the benefices really worth the cost, or the risk, to society? Is it worth it, even if the risks are low?</p><p>We all understand the benefices of cars. They are huge for society in terms of mobility and economic life.</p><p>But what are really the benefices of guns ownership? To protect oneself against dangerous people, or a tyrannical government, mainly (as explained by the supporters of the second amendment).</p><p>We are not going to discuss about the leisure activities like hunting or just collecting guns. I feel it’s not really a benefice that could be weighed favorably against innocent lives lost. Nobody will argue in favor of drunk driving, because it’s “fun” to get drunk at parties for instance (even if it IS fun, one could argue, it’s not a reason to risk innocent people lives).</p><p>So we are going to talk about the benefices of guns, to protect oneself against dangerous people, or a tyrannical government.</p><p><strong>— Let’s start with the tyrannical government.</strong></p><p>A population with firearms can effectively better defend themselves against a dictator. But let’s push the logical argument a little bit “too much”, at absurdum as we say, just for the pleasure to think.</p><p>The American government possesses Nuclear weapons. If an evil dictator really came to power in this country, and effectively had the support of the army (like any serious dictator would need), he could possibly (in theory) threaten his own population with nuclear retaliation. The USA are a big country after all, so he could realistically threaten to unleash one or two nuclear warheads on a few cities, like Chicago, Dallas or Los Angeles, to deter rebellion, and to keep everybody “in line”, without destroying the whole country.</p><p>It would of course be impossible in a small country like Israel, Japan, or Switzerland, because those countries are too small to target only one part of their territory without damaging too much of the whole country. But in the USA, it is absolutely possible.</p><p>So are guns really a viable option of defense against a dictator? Probably not, at least not <em>certainly</em>. The best defense being probably having strong democratic values in the general population, in the army, and having strong counter-powers like the judiciary, the press and the parliament (congress).</p><p>Moreover, contrary to popular beliefs, dictators rarely stay in power <em>only</em> with the support of their army. <a href="https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/dictatorships-often-survive-local-support">They generally need the support of a substantial part of their population</a>. And, when they lose it, they generally lose their power, as we have seen during the Arab springs for instance.</p><p>Of course a big part of their population always suffer, but they still need a substantial support of their population to stay in power. That was the case in Nazi Germany, in Argentina, in Soviet USSR, in Irak, in Syria, and in most dictatorships. There is always a part of the population who supports the dictator, for ideological reasons, or because they benefit from it, or both.</p><p>So a dictator in the USA will likely not only have the support of the army, but also of a part of their population. Which is armed precisely to oppose him in theory, but would side with him. Canceling the benefices expected from an armed population, or leading to civil war.</p><p>The only historically proven, reliable way to fight a dictator (or any government), is simply to have enough of the population “fed up” with him, and “falling” into the opposition. A population is infinitely greater in numbers than their army, in any country (<a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/232330/us-military-force-numbers-by-service-branch-and-reserve-component/">1 300 000 people in the US army</a>, against 340 000 000 citizens). The sheer numbers are generally sufficient to disrupt and change governance. Most populations in countries of the Arab springs, like Tunisia, succeeded in their revolution without an armed population. Whereas in some countries it can fail, even with an armed rebellion (think of the Farcs in Colombia), simply because there are not “enough” of rebels, even if they are armed.</p><p><strong>— What about protecting against other dangerous people?</strong></p><p>This is the classical “arms race” game theory problem. Of course, if everybody has a gun, it’s better to have one yourself. But the idea is precisely to prevent everybody from having a gun, so you don’t need one, and the tensions decrease.</p><p>Then, of course, only criminals have guns, not honest people. That is the case in most European countries for instance. But the reality is that real armed criminals (organized crime) rarely use their weapons on regular citizens, even less so in public areas like a school or a mall (they are not, generally, “mad men” living in their mother’s basements, but more sort of illegal “business people”, trying to avoid confrontation with the police as much as possible). They usually use guns to kill other criminals.</p><p>Moreover, the arms race often creates its own vicious circles. For instance, if a burglar breaks into a house in France, he likely won’t expect armed resistance (except in some parts of the countryside). So he will probably not take a gun with him, as he is generally just trying to steal a TV or money. The judiciary cost of breaking into a house WITH a gun is exponentially worse, if you get caught by the police, than breaking into a house without any weapons (armed robbery is way worse than simple robbery).</p><p>There is no reason for him to bring a gun. He doesn’t generally fear for his life. And guns are a real liability in a country like France. As it is never authorized, if you get caught with one, the problems are very big, no matter the infraction.</p><p>And even if he takes a gun with him, he is far less likely to use it against the people in the house. Why? Because, once again, he doesn’t fear for his life. His gun gives him the confidence that he is “safe”. He will generally use it to scare people, not shoot them.</p><p>What about serial killers? Those people are really a rarity in the criminal world. And they will have the advantage of “surprise”. They generally don’t kill with guns anyway.</p><p>Whereas, in a country like the USA, a burglar really can expect armed resistance while breaking into a house. Does that stop him from breaking in? Not really, that just convinces him to take a gun with him. As everybody is expecting the other party to be armed and fears for their own life, the tensions are really high, and the result is fear, not feelings of safety.</p><p>The police officers job is often more difficult and dangerous in countries where citizens are armed. Which of course makes them more prone to make mistakes, and “shoot first and ask questions later” because of fear (“I thought he had a gun”). That’s probably one of the reasons the US police kills so much more than any democratic police in the world.</p><p>Lastly, even in the cases of a “good guy” with a gun, stoping a bad guy with a gun, it is very difficult for the police (or even bystanders) to understand who is the good guy. That’s why <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/no-charges-colorado-officer-who-killed-hero-who-stopped-mass-n1283532">heroes get accidentally killed in a lot of mass shootings</a>. The police officers simply don’t understand why a civil, someone dressed in normal clothes, not in uniform, is shooting someone else in the streets, in a mall, or anywhere else. They arrive on the scene a little bit late, they don’t have the time to correctly assess the situation. All they know is that an active shooter is killing people, and all they see is a “regular guy” with a gun, standing next to a corpse, or even actively shooting at someone.</p><p>They can’t reasonably ask: “Are you the baddy? Or the hero?”. Moreover, if they don’t take a shot fast, they can themselves get killed.</p><p>That’s why it’s generally safer for everybody to let people in clear uniforms (police officers or army…), do the “good guys with guns”.</p><p>Imagine the confusion if everybody draws a gun, during a terrorist attack. Who is with who?</p><p>-</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Once again, I was not trying to convince you that you should be against or in favor of abortion. Or against or in favor of guns. I’m not even saying that my arguments are completely decisive. Just that they are based on <em>some </em>reasonable logic.</p><p>I was just trying to show you, that logical reasoning is ultimately limited, in finding a solution to some difficult political questions.</p><p>A lot of good, logical arguments can be made in various different perspectives.</p><p>So, why do people choose one side or the other?</p><p>It can be for various reasons, education, social environments… But ultimately, I believe that the real reason is simply “gut feelings”.</p><p>What do I mean? I simply mean that people have different priorities, that’s all.</p><p>Some women are more worried about the loss of their bodily autonomy, which is understandable. Some people, for religious reasons or any other reasons, are more worried about the life of a fetus. That doesn’t mean that anyone of them is more “wrong” in an absolute moral sense. Those are both valid, logical concerns.</p><p>Some people are more worried about their liberty to defend themselves against potential aggressors, knowing that the police takes a lot of time to come to the rescue in case of danger, so they want to have the right to buy a gun. Some other people are more worried about the societal climate of fear that lax guns laws can create in a country. And the ability for crazy people to do mass shootings. Those are valid, logical concerns. Nobody is really “wrong” about their concerns.</p><p>What are the solutions?</p><p>It’s obviously <strong>consensus</strong>. It has always been the ideal solution in democratic countries.</p><p>It’s never a good idea, when people strongly disagree, to only favor one side (except if a consensus is absolutely impossible, like with the question of ending slavery, but it’s rarely the case, and that often leads to civil wars).</p><p>How to reach consensus? By admitting that nobody can be totally “satisfied” with the solution. The role of the debate should be to place the “cursor” somewhere. Not to definitely put in on one side or the other. Otherwise it creates too much political instability.</p><p>More generally, the goal is to consider that your opponents oppose you in “good faith”. Because that is actually generally the case. It’s a little bit preposterous to imagine that one side is composed only of “stupid or crazy radical people”. That can happen, of course. But it’s not a very “useful” or practical way to think. Especially if you can demonstrate that logical and reasonable arguments can be made on both sides.</p><p>Sometimes, when the disagreement is really strong, it’s just more healthy to say, like Ali G: “Let’s agree to disagree”.</p><p>Thank you, have a good day :)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=417631f66b8f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[No no no, AI “art” is not Art. If you think it is, you don’t understand Art]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/no-no-no-ai-art-is-not-art-if-you-think-it-is-you-dont-understand-art-365c0476aae9?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/365c0476aae9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[midjourney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dalles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Oct 2022 14:31:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-31T14:31:47.218Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Let‘s finally explain what Art is, and most importantly, what it is not…</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YEQTSnVMWh4d798AKCNHEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Illustrations by author, showing a human “process of creation”: no randomness, everything intended and struggled for.</figcaption></figure><p>I just read this <a href="https://medium.com/mlearning-ai/how-to-make-money-with-ai-art-ed223d55cb89">article</a> by Stella Sky, here on Medium, where she explains that she creates art, using Midjourney. Under “her” pictures, the little words “made by Stella Sky”, made me cringe a lot. I feel a lot of people are confused about what art really is. It’s normal, it’s a vague concept, that can cover a lot of things, for different people and different times. But I still believe we can try to define it. And especially define what it is not.</p><p>I’m going, after, to explain why AI artists are not artists (as an artist myself), even if they can “imitate” artists. There is a big difference, that I am going to try to explain. And then, why AI art is not Art.</p><h4>What is Art, in the end?</h4><p>Originally, the word “art” comes from the latin <em>ars</em>, which means “skill, trade, technical knowledge”.</p><p><strong>Modern definition:</strong></p><blockquote>To put it simply, art is a human activity that requires practical skill, and theoretical knowledge, to create a product or activity that appeals to senses, emotions, intuitions and intellect.</blockquote><h4>What art is not?</h4><p>Art is different from nature, because art is a human activity, it needs human intent. Art is different from science, because its goal is not pure knowledge. Its “goal” is centered around producing<strong> emotions</strong>, at least<strong> </strong>mainly. “Making you think” is a good but finally secondary and “optional” byproduct of a good art piece.</p><p>An art piece that would ONLY make you think (without trying to produce any emotions linked to aesthetics in any form), would probably not be pure art, but closer to philosophy. But, conversely, a philosophy book that intends to produce mainly emotions, rather than to simply explain (like <em>Thus spoke Zarathustra, </em>by Nietzsche) is closer to art than to philosophy, in my opinion.</p><p>Those concepts are of course subject to a little bit of personal interpretation, I admit. But the most important thing to understand is that…</p><h4>Art is NOT an idea.</h4><p>Now the most important thing to understand: ART IS NOT AN IDEA.</p><p>I’m going to say it again: an artist is not (just) someone who has ideas.</p><p>ANYBODY has ideas. Having ideas is one of the most simple thing in the world. And yes, good ideas too are not that difficult to get.</p><p>It’s not ideas that make the world, it’s their execution. So…</p><h4>Art is about EXECUTION.</h4><p>I’m sure you know at least one person who once told you that they have an amazing idea, to create the next big startup, or to write the next big novel… Maybe you’re the one who had one of those great ideas. I’m SURE they do. Most people actually do have amazing and crazy and creative ideas. Just look at your dreams. You ARE creative. Being creative doesn’t automatically makes you an artist though. Scientists can be incredibly creative people. But they are not necessarily artists.</p><p>What makes a good art product or activity, though, is not JUST the idea. It’s mainly the execution.</p><p><strong>An idea is only as good as its execution.</strong></p><p>It’s true for most human activity by the way. Sure you can have the idea to connect friends on internet, but that doesn’t mean you are going to create something as successful as Facebook.</p><p>You can have the idea of a story with a scary clown, terrorizing and killing children. That doesn’t mean you are going to write a good book. While a good writer like Stephen King can write “It”, and it becomes a masterpiece, not many people could write a masterpiece with the same idea. Stephen King is a good writer not just because he has a lot of original ideas, but mainly because he can write in a very skilled way. His writing abilities are the main ingredient for his books, it’s those who give life to his ideas.</p><p>You can have the idea of a lot of things, as long as you can’t execute those ideas, they have no value.</p><p>And it’s not the idea that people love, it’s the final execution. That’s why some Batman movies are good, and some are really bad.</p><p>It’s exactly the same “idea”, of a superhero dressed as a bat fighting bad guys, but executed very poorly or very well, depending on the movie director (and the movie team, and actors…).</p><h4>So, why AI “artists” are not artists?</h4><p>Because they lack “creative control”. AI is an “art” of “accident”. It is not “reliable”, or consistent. That’s why it doesn’t really have a “style”. I mean it does have a style actually, we can immediately recognize the style of Midjourney compared to Dall-E for instance. But it’s not the style of the person who creates the “prompts”. It’s the style of the software.</p><p>If you look at Stella Sky images for instance, you could tell they are from Midjourney if you know the software. But you could NEVER tell they are from Stella Sky in particular, compared to all the other images produced with the same software by other people.</p><p>It’s impossible to tell which person wrote which prompt, by looking at the final picture.</p><p>When people type prompts, and think they “create” art, they are extremely wrong.</p><p>They just <strong>ORDER</strong> “art”. Like they would if they hired an illustrator.</p><p>If you hire an illustrator, and you tell them what to draw (the prompt is like the brief), then you are a <strong>CLIENT </strong>of an artist, not an artist!</p><p>If you hire a music composer, and tell him to produce a “sad, melancholic music, to listen to at night when you are alone”, and he creates a masterpiece like Chopin’s mazurkas, you can’t say that YOU created this music. It’s not because you give the order, that you are the artist.</p><h4>Finally, why AI art is not art?</h4><p>What AI do is to randomly, but with a pattern recognition, put pixels on a screen to look <strong>like </strong>a picture made by an artist<strong>. But it has no intent, and doesn’t understand what it is producing.</strong></p><p>The person who writes the prompts is a client. The prompts are not art, like would be a poem, because they are not the “final product”. We don’t read the prompts, we look at the pictures that the <strong>software</strong> made.</p><p>The AI is a machine, a random generator of pixels.</p><p>There is no artists involved in this process (other than the ones who produced the billions of pictures stolen to be used in the softwares data base, with no regard for copyright claims by the way).</p><p>It produces something that can <strong>look like </strong>art. That doesn’t mean it’s art.</p><p>It’s like saying that a word generator is an artist.</p><h4>But it creates beautiful pictures!</h4><p>Yes, Ai can create beautiful, moving pictures. Not a lot to be honest, but I have seen a few online, that really made me stop and admire.</p><p>Exactly like a real life sunset is beautiful, moving, but not art (it is made by nature, with no human intent or skills involved), Ai pieces can be beautiful and moving without being art.</p><h4>Infinite monkey theorem analogy</h4><p>Basically, to make an analogy that will illustrate the difference, let’s think about the “Infinite monkey theorem”.</p><p>The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infinite_monkey_theorem"><strong>infinite monkey theorem</strong></a> states that a monkey hitting keys at random on a typewriter keyboard for an infinite amount of time will almost surely type any given text, such as the complete works of William Shakespeare.</p><p>Ok. Great. Does that mean that the monkey is an artist? No. Why? Because he didn’t write Hamlet with INTENT. And he doesn’t understand it either. He did it by ACCIDENT. It is not reliable.</p><p>It’s exactly the same with the AI art generator. You can type the same prompt over and over again, it will produce different outputs. Moreover, a lot of them are totally useless.</p><p>When it does product good pictures, it is totally by randomness, not by intentional planning. It’s US, humans, who realize “oh this one looks nice”. The AI doesn’t make any difference between a good and bad picture. For the AI, they are all just PIXELS.</p><p>The AI doesn’t try to communicate something with its productions.</p><p>The AI doesn’t know what a tree is. It never saw a real tree. Never. It is not “moved” by a beautiful tree. It just knows that “pictures of trees”, in its database, tend to have the pixels of this color, right there in the picture, on average. So if you ask it to produce a picture of a tree, it will randomly put the pixels, according to the patterns of millions of tree images, to produce something random that has more chances to look as a tree, than if you type the prompt “apple” for instance.</p><p>Some of those trees images will look terrible, and some of them will look fantastic. The AI will not know why, or which one. It is random.</p><h4>But some “real art” is also just about concept.</h4><p>Yeah, I know, some modern, contemporary art is also just about “the idea”.</p><p>Like Malevitch “white square on white background”, or Duchamp’s Fontaine etc…</p><p>The difference is obviously that they have intent, contrary to the machine.</p><p>But it’s like writing prompts you may say, the person writing prompts have intent…</p><p>But precisely, all my point here is to show that most “average” people don’t understand, nor like, those “conceptual art pieces”, exactly for the reason that those artists give too much importance to “ideas”, over execution.</p><p>I’m not going to enter into the debate about if contemporary art is art or not. What I just want to show, though, is that when art is just about the concept, it becomes very controversial, almost “dubious”.</p><p>It is totally evident, obvious, for almost anybody, that Raphael, Caravaggio, Michel Ange, Leonardo Da Vinci, are artists. It is way more confusing for contemporary conceptual artists, that you see in the Miam Art Basel for instance (one of those who put pizza boxes on the floor, selling it for millions of dollars, I saw it, I promise…). The formers are admired since centuries, the later… I’m not even sure if they are even admired today, or just speculated on honestly...</p><h4>But why execution is more valued than concept?</h4><p>Because the “traditional” artists show a mastery of <strong>technical abilities</strong>. And art was originally about technical abilities, not just ideas (artists were sought to “imitate” nature in antiquity, not create). While the new “conceptual artists”… only show that they have original or shocking ideas, not always “technical abilities” of any sort.</p><p>While most people realize they could never acquire the technical abilities of a Leonardo Da Vinci, most people assume (probably rightfully) that they could have crazy and shocking ideas, like any contemporary artist, fairly easily, if they really wanted to. I’m not saying they are right or wrong. But, let’s admit it, it’s more “impressive” to see a Vermeer than an abstract painting (even if I promise that I really love Kandinsky or Rothko), or even a <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2014/oct/20/paul-mccarthy-butt-plug-sculpture-paris-rightwing-backlash">giant green butt plug by Paul Mc Carthy.</a></p><p>I’m not saying figurative art is “better”, or that abstraction is bad. I’m just saying we intuitively <strong>respect</strong> more something that takes decades to master and create, that something that can be technically done in a few hours. It’s natural. We do the same for any human activity.</p><p>If a monochromatic white (or Klein blue) abstract painting is destroyed, we feel bad, of course. Like if a giant green butt plug is vandalized, sure, it’s bad, it’s not normal to destroy art pieces. But if a Géricault painting was to be destroyed, I’m sure we would feel the loss as more severe, even if we don’t want to admit it.</p><p>Just because we can easily recreate a new monochromatic white or Klein blue abstract painting, or a giant green butt plug, given the minimum instructions about the canvas and the paint, or the material and dimensions of the plug. While it would be extremely difficult to create “Le radeau de la méduse” again, even with the best instructions, and the best painters.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Obviously art is subject to interpretation.</p><p>Some people will assume that a beautiful picture is art. Some will say that anything is art. Some will think that everybody is an artist. You can think what you want of course. We can think that giving a trophy to everyone makes everyone an athlete. Or we can think that an athlete is not just a question of trophy, not just “someone who does sport”. But someone who devoted their life to sport, and attained human technical excellence in their domaine of expertise.</p><p>It’s the latter view that I personally chose to adopt for art.</p><p>In my opinion, making pictures in 2 minutes by typing words in a software, with no knowledge of any art theory or history, no knowledge of anatomy, colors, or even on how to correctly hold a pencil, doesn’t make you an artist any more than playing a song on Spotify makes me a musician.</p><p>Because, at the end of the day, if electricity goes down, my internet connection is lost, or my computer broken, I can always draw on a piece of paper. The skills are there, with or without the technology. Like a good serious pianist without a piano still possesses all the technical, theoretical, musical abilities to create music differently, a good artist doesn’t need his wacom cintiq to draw.</p><p>An Ai artist is totally dependent on so many other people and things to do his “art”. On the engineers who built the software. The servers to store the billions images of the database used by the AI (stolen to real artists without respecting copyrights by the way). On the electricity workers. On the computers factory, etc…</p><p>What can an AI “artist” produce without their AI software?</p><p>Nothing.</p><p>Thank you, have a good day, don’t hesitate to contradict me in the comments, it’s an open debate ;)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=365c0476aae9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Should you go to Art School?]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/should-you-go-to-art-school-f34420f7edd2?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f34420f7edd2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-school]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[online-courses]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Oct 2022 12:01:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-29T12:01:37.742Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>And what are the alternatives?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/790/1*igU9CNhkU8wt_QLw8TZwTw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Life model by David Shrigley</figcaption></figure><p>There is a big debate nowadays, about the question to know if art schools are worth it. It’s a very important question, because art schools are very expensive, and our field is difficult, especially at the beginning.</p><p>Before I explain what I think about art schools, I’m going to explain very briefly why I believe I can give you some useful informations.</p><h4>Who am I to say?</h4><p>I know art schools, both in Europe and in the USA, because I was a student at some of those institutions. I did 4 years of graphic design school in Paris, in France, at Penninghen and Maryse Eloy. And two years at the Miami Ad School in Miami. Those three schools are considered very good, among the best graphic design/art schools.</p><p>I also know the field. I work since a little bit more than 9 years, as a professional artist. Four years as an art director at the ad agency Publicis, and after that since 6 years as a freelance storyboard artist and motion designer. You can check my <a href="https://www.emmanuelazouvi.com/storyboard">website</a>, if you want to see my professional works in this field, or my <a href="https://www.instagram.com/eazouvi/">Instagram</a>.</p><h4>What are my thoughts about art schools?</h4><p>I’m going to say it very simply, so you don’t lose time, then I’m going to explain more deeply. So if you’re interested in the subject you can continue reading after that, but at least you have the main infos here:</p><blockquote>Art schools are not really worth the money for the <strong>technical abilities</strong> they will teach you. You can learn way more, for way cheaper, online or in books (I’m going to explain how after). But, art schools are super cool for the <strong>social life</strong> you will get, and the <strong>network </strong>it will provide, if you can afford it (if money is really not a worry for you). It’s very cool also to get feedbacks from the teachers, but it’s not an absolute necessity. It’s also easier to organize your curriculum, in a school, as precisely you don’t have to create it yourself from scratch.</blockquote><p>There, I said it, in four sentences haha. Now I’m going to expand a little bit.</p><h3>The good about art schools</h3><h4>1-Social life</h4><p>There is, in my opinion, one big positive thing about art schools. And it’s not really related to the job. At least not directly. It’s simply the social life. Being in school with a lot of other people, who are passionate about the same field as you, is really nice. You will meet a lot of friends, lovers, you will party and have a lot of fun.</p><h4>2-Networking</h4><p>On a more practical level, you will also expand your network. It’s also very motivating to work with other students. The teachers you meet will sometimes even help you get internships and a job.</p><p>So that’s something. It’s NOT like it’s a total scam. For some people, studying in a school is the only way they will stay motivated.</p><h4>3-You don’t have to think too much</h4><p>If you want to be a professional artist, but you know nothing about art, graphic design, animation… the “easiest” way is to go to art school. Because you won’t have to worry about the classes you should take, about the level you are supposed to get, how to make a portfolio etc… Everything will be well organized and given to you. You’ll just have to do your homeworks and listen the teachers.</p><p>Whereas, if you learn by yourself, you’ll have to create your own curriculum. And you’ll have to learn to evaluate your level yourself (it’s quite difficult actually). Learning by yourself is intellectually way more challenging than going to school. It demands a good organization, and a strong motivation.</p><h3>The bad about art schools</h3><h4>1-Too expensive</h4><p>Art schools are super, super, expensive. You can really learn the same stuff, that you will get after 4 years of art college, online or in books, for like 500 dollars total honestly (a lot of online tutorial or books about anatomy, photoshop, blender, illustrator, after effects, color theory, perspective… are either free or cost around 20 dollars).</p><h4>2-Too long</h4><p>It’s also super long for no “real” reason. I remember, in schools, we had like around 2 or 3 hours of each classe every week. 2 or 3 hours of photoshop, after effects, anatomy etc…</p><p>That means in 1 months, you get around 8 to 12 hours of a class. But most of that time is not spent learning. It is spent with the teachers calling the names of the students, talking about various things unrelated to class, about the students interrupting the class, about the teacher helping that one student whose computer is not working, or who has great difficulties to understand the course etc…</p><p>But, if you buy a good class of drawing anatomy, photoshop (or any other software) on Udemy, 21 Draw, Skillshare, you get usually around 15 hours of class. And it’s really JUST learning time. Contrary to a school where a lot of the time is spent on other things.</p><p>Also, if you are motivated, you can totally watch those 15 or more hours of video, and do the assignment, in 2 or 3 days honestly. I once finished a 30 hours course about digital painting, on Udemy (<a href="https://www.udemy.com/course/the-ultimate-digital-painting-course-beginner-to-advanced/">fundamentals of digital painting from beginner to advanced</a>, I’m not sponsored by the way), in one week, because I liked the course.</p><p>So, instead of spending 3 months on photoshop classes in art schools, you can learn the same stuff in one week online. The same is true for most subjects.</p><p>You can totally get the same amount of knowledge, that you would get in 4 years of art school, in 6 months to one year studying online. I am NOT saying you will be an expert after 1 year, be careful: I am saying you will get the same knowledge as someone who just finished art school, because graduates from art school are not experts. I know, I was once a graduate.</p><h4>3-The teachers “quality” varies greatly</h4><p>In Art Schools, there are some amazing teachers, some average teachers, and unfortunately also some bad teachers. Some are good at their job, but don’t know how to teach. Some are not even good at their job. It’s the lottery. You will get some amazing teachers who will help you improve a lot, and give you enthusiasm. And you will get teachers who will bore you to death.</p><p>Whereas online, you can have access to the very best teachers, if you want to. I mean you can buy animation, or character design classes, from some legend Disney animators like Aaron Blaise or Tom Bancroft, for 25 dollars. Can you imagine the value that represents? Those guys created some of the most famous Disney characters. Not only the best, but you can also choose the one whose style and personality fits you the most.</p><p>You can always preview some of their free videos, to see if you like how they talk and teach, if they are funny, interesting etc…</p><p>You can also check their online portfolios, to be sure they are good.</p><p>And you can of course read the reviews of the other students.</p><p>That means, for around 20 dollars, you can get some teachers who are “legendary”, so much better that most teachers you will get in a 50 000 dollars art school.</p><h3>But, where will you find all the infos, to study outside of Art Schools?</h3><p>Very good question, my fellow artists! That’s THE question. If you know where to find, everything will fall into place.</p><p>So, the best advice I can give is this one: Find the regular, traditional Art Schools you wanted to study at. Look on their website, they all have a “curriculum” section, where they explain ALL the classes they will give you each year. Simply write down all those classes, and try to find a cheap equivalent online, on a few websites I will give you :)</p><p>For instance, if they will give you anatomy, photoshop, after effects, typography, “how to build a portfolio” classes, etc… , then just find the same classes online, and check the prices.</p><p>It’s a good way to start. Then you can simply add new stuff that you find interesting, and think could be usefull</p><h4>The places where you can look for quality content</h4><h4>Online courses</h4><p><a href="https://www.21-draw.com/">21 Draw.com</a>: Price 25 dollars per class.<br>For drawing, character design, and animation. Not a lot of classes (I mean compared to other platforms), but very Good quality classes, from top instructors. I love the interface.</p><p><a href="https://www.udemy.com/">Udemy.com</a>: Price around 15 dollars per class (with promotion, but they always have promotion ;) )<br>For ANYTHING (softwares, drawing, comic book, even yoga or cooking if you want haha) They have a lot of classes for anything you can think of. The interface is really good. But the quality of classes varies greatly, be aware! Some courses are amazing, some others not so much, read reviews and check instructor portfolio. Don’t worry if you bought a class that was not good, I think you generally can ask your money back if you are not satisfied.</p><p><a href="https://www.skillshare.com/">Skillshare.com</a>: I never tried Skillshare, but I’ve heard it’s very similar to Udemy. I’m sure they have good content there too.</p><p><a href="https://gumroad.com/">https://gumroad.com/</a>: Very good tutorials there.</p><p><a href="https://cubebrush.co/">https://cubebrush.co/</a>: Never tried it but they have a lot of art courses. I think the online art school by Marc Brunet, on this website, is good also. It’s more expensive, around 1000 dollars. But it’s like a complete art program. I never tried it, but he has a lot of free youtube tutorial that are really good.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKtu_JtQCY0yryIy6zK4ZCg">Marc Brunet</a>: The artist I was talking about in the former paragraph. He has a youtube channel with a lot of free content, that are really good.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/SamDoesArts">Samdoesart</a>: He has a youtube channel with a lot of free content, that are really good. You can also buy his <a href="https://samdoesarts.gumroad.com/">tutorials</a> on Gumroad, I did some and they are really good.</p><p><a href="https://creatureartteacher.com/">Aaron Blaise:</a> Amazing veteran animator from Disney. He has free content on his youtube channel also. I bought some of his tutorial, it’s juste amazing, love it. Great artist, and very great teacher.</p><p><a href="https://www.proko.com/">Proko</a>: THE teacher online, for anatomy. Really. Every aspiring artist should buy his anatomy classes. It’s more expensive than most online tutorials (300 dollars if I remember correctly), but it’s totally worth it. Hours and hours of anatomy lesson, exercices, just amazing. You will know everything about the human body, and how to draw it. He has a lot of free content on youtube if you want to check.</p><h4>Books</h4><p><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Figure-Drawing-All-Its-Worth/dp/0857680986">Andrew Loomis</a>: Amazing illustrator of the 50’s. His books should become your bible :)</p><p><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Constructive-Anatomy-Dover-Artists/dp/0486211045/ref=sr_1_1?crid=8Y8U8V2TX3NZ&amp;keywords=bridgeman+anatomy&amp;qid=1667043294&amp;qu=eyJxc2MiOiIyLjMzIiwicXNhIjoiMS45NiIsInFzcCI6IjEuOTkifQ%3D%3D&amp;s=books&amp;sprefix=bridgeman+anatomy%2Cstripbooks-intl-ship%2C135&amp;sr=1-1">George B. Bridgeman</a>: Amazing books on anatomy.</p><p>There is so much more, I probably forget a lot, I’ll add later, but that gives you some starting points :)</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>I hope that article could help you a little bit. I know how scary and confusing the world of higher education can seem to young people. Especially if you have nobody in your close family who can help you navigate it. It’s easier to become an artist if your parents are also artists. Like it’s easier to become a doctor if your parents are doctors. But if nobody in your close social circles knows art, it’s almost impossible to know how to make the difference between the good and the bad.</p><p>I know it’s also scary to spend a lot of money on a school. Especially if you are not certain that you will get a good education, and if you will be able to really get a job after that.</p><p>But I know it’s also very scary to try to educate yourself, outside of an institution. Famous institutions, like art schools, are reassuring. They give you the feeling that you are doing something “serious”. While studying at home, from online tutorials, can seem not serious (especially to your parents, who really want you to have a “diploma”, an official degree).</p><p>But the reality is that in art, nobody really pays attention to your degree. They just check your portfolio.</p><p>Now, if you or your parents are really scared of you not going to a “real” school, or if you really want the social life of a school, here is my last advice:</p><h4>Last advice</h4><p>If you or your parents really want you to go to an Art School, I would highly recommend that you start by studying by yourself for a few months before that. It can be during your high school. Or during holidays. Or, why not, by taking one year off after high school.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Because then you will take way more from your art school. You will already know some basics, so you won’t struggle too much, you will be ahead of other students, and you will be able to focus on what’s important in art school: <strong>building a good portfolio</strong>, not learning the basics of photoshop!!</p><p>So many students go to art schools to learn everything from scratch. That’s REALLY not the good way in my opinion. It’s better to go there with some solid knowledge of the basics (at least some knowledge of the main softwares, and some anatomy basics), so you can really let the good teachers elevate you to the next level.</p><p>You will also benefit the most from the networking effect of the school, if your level is already somewhat ok. The teachers will notice you, and give you more opportunities.</p><p>I really hope that helped you, don’t hesitate to ask questions in the comment section if you want, I’ll try to answer (I mean I don’t have SO much followers so I should be able to do it haha)</p><p>Have a good day :)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f34420f7edd2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How men became Gods to one another]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/how-men-became-gods-to-one-another-b6dc9c51fcec?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6dc9c51fcec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[debunked]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[desire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Sep 2022 11:49:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-27T23:04:57.028Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Or how a french philosopher demystified love and desire</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*huZgUo0FSGrDpiZURpsc4g.png" /><figcaption>Julius Kronberg — Romeo och Julia</figcaption></figure><p>I am a big fan of René Girard, a french philosopher from the 20th century. He is not one of the most famous philosopher, especially outside of philosophy circles, but he is definitely my favourite one. He changed my life and my understanding of the world (yeah, nothing less haha). Especially on this such important concept of love.</p><p>He wrote a lot about religions, the sacred, and the scapegoat phenomenons. But to be honest, I don’t really care about those subjects (not that much I mean). For me, his most important works are about love and desire. For me, he is THE philosopher who really understands how love and desire work. Far from the very naive, romantic, or even sexist and uninformed views that a lot of his colleagues often have about those subjects.</p><p>He wrote one book particularly, that really changed my understanding of love and life generally. That book is titled in english “DECEIT, DESIRE AND THE NOVEL”. It’s a bad traduction of the original title. A more “literal” traduction of the french title would be something like: “Romantic Lie and Novelistic Truth”.</p><p>Basically, his (great) idea in this book, is to try to understand desire and love, by analysing a few great works of fiction, by the best novelists in the world. He selected particularly Don Quixote by Cervantes, Proust, Stendhal, Dostoyevsky. But why is this a good idea, to examine desire and love through fiction? Because, as he explains, great novelists often have an intuitive understanding of how human psychology works. For anyone who read some great books, it is obvious that our great writers have some amazing “mind reading” abilities. They not only help us understand how we think, they help us understand how other people think and feel. Reading Dostoyevsky or Proust, is a little bit like taking 4 years of psychology college.</p><h4>So what exactly will you learn from René Girard book?</h4><p>I will try to summarize the most important points , for me, from Girard book here. I will not really give you <em>all</em> the explanations needed for each point, because that would literally take me an entire book to write, and it’s better to read it directly from Girard of course. I will just give you a few of his insights, as food for thoughts, to get you interested in the subject.</p><h4>1-The mimetic desire</h4><p>This is THE theory of René Girard. The one he is the most famous for. René Girard thinks (it has been supported by some recent studies on children and animals), that desire works by mimicking other people desires. That’s the basis for learning (think mirror neurons), as for driving goals, and conformity and acceptance in society. It is the reason for the seemingly randomness of fashion trends. It is also the reason for the attraction for famous people, and for “popular” kids in high school.</p><p>It is also the explanation for the “rival” phenomenon, or the “love triangle”. Such phenomenons are extremely common in novels, make for good storytelling, because they are a very common drive for desire in real life.</p><p>Basically (to make it super simple, but it’s more complicated of course), the reason you desire someone, is because that person is desired by other people. To be more specific, you desire that person because they are desired either by a lot of other people, OR because they are desired by a person that you admire (the rival).</p><p>Of course, beauty and personality plays a role. In the same sense that gold was probably originally desired for its “beauty” and material qualities. But what reinforces the desire, is the fact that a lot of people also desire it.</p><p>In most great books of fiction, the romantic interests are sought after by more than one person. They are considered attractive by “common” standards.</p><h4>2-Rivalry, or how men became Gods for one another</h4><p>This leads to the second point, rivalry. In most great books of fiction, love exist because rivalry exist. Not always, we are going to talk about another possibility just after. But rivalry is a central theme in love stories. Why? Because, through the person we think we desire, what we really desire is actually our rival. The person we admire. It’s a hidden desire, but it’s the “real” desire. Without rivalry, the desire is weak. It doesn’t need to be a rivalry with someone we know: it can be with a famous person, like Don Quixote who admires famous knight of the past Amadis de Gaule, who drives his desire to become a knight himself (even though Amadis is dead since a long time). But, as Girard explains, the closest the rival, the strongest the desire.</p><p>Your rival, in a sense, is a God to you. But an “evil” God, if I may say. A god who tortures you, making you feel so small in comparison to its “greatness”. A God that you want to overthrown, by getting what they desire the most. This concept of other fellow humans becoming Gods will be addressed again in another point later. Girard explains that since we live in democratic societies, the concept of “outside Gods” have vanished. Before, the King, or the God, was the sacred, the divine to look up to. All of us were simple mortals. But since the relative disappearance of monarchy and religion, everybody became equals, so we had to turn to one another to find “greater than life” personas.</p><p>In a very narcissistic sense, what we ultimately desire is ourselves. But a greater version of ourselves. This greater version is often found in the rival. The rival is by definition someone like us, our doppelganger, only a better version of ourselves. He is us, if we had the quality we think we should have. He is the person we desire. The person we desire to be, and more importantly, the person we would like to desire us. We want to elicit in our rival, the same sentiments they elicit in us. That would mean we have surpassed them. And the person we “desire”, our love interest, is a “transitional object”. A means to prove to ourselves that we are better than our rival, by seducing those that our rivals desire.</p><p>That’s why love can vanish, when “left alone”. I’m sure you have already felt that. That’s the reason why men seem to bond so strongly around the idea of “chasing women”. It’s not for the women solely, but the place in the group they will get, the respect they will earn from their rivals, by seducing beautiful women. It’s the reason women watch more closely other women, at a party, than the men, comparing themselves.</p><p>Thus, Girard explains, jealousy is the fuel of desire. If someone likes you, and you like them back, a tender, sweet love can appear, for a little while. But their desire can dissipate over time. But, if you show them that you love someone else, you just transformed a little crush into a terrible obsession, that can last extremely longer than any “real” love. Sometimes an entire life. Thus, jealousy is the weapon of choice of any machiavellian seducer. It is the fuel of most great love stories, think Proust or even Flaubert’s Emma Bovary. In Proust masterpiece “In Search for Lost Time”, the character Swann is literally obsessed with Odette de Crécy, during almost all 7 books. He is dying of jealousy for her, and she plays with that. Then, he realized at the end of his life, that he almost died for a woman that was not even really his style, that he is not even really sure to have really loved. And Emma Bovary, whose love for Leon is the strongest when she can’t have him, and dissipates afterwards when she gets him. Who, all the time, is looking outside for happiness, and never seems to get it when her desire is resolved.</p><p>If your partner lost interest in you, and you talk long enough with someone else at a party, chances are their desire could come back very quickly, like a little demon who awakens after a long nap.</p><h4>3-Masters and slaves</h4><p>But sometimes, rivals are not present. At least, not in the sense of another person. Sometimes the God is not a rival, but the actual love interest. This leads to the ever present theme of “Master and slave”, that exist in almost every great love story, as in real life.</p><p>Here Girard explains something that we probably all know very intuitively, but in a more profound way: A love relationship is not balanced.</p><p>The roles can, and will sometimes change, but there is almost always someone who desire more than the other at any given point. Love, or more precisely desire, can’t be equal. Why? Because we can’t desire what we have.</p><p>Look at your wrist. Do you have a watch? If yes, do you desire this exact watch? No, of course. You can enjoy having it, sure. But you can’t <em>desire</em> it (in the burning sense). Because it’s already yours. Now look at the Rolex website online, and there you will see many watches that you can desire (if that’s your taste of course, otherwise look something else haha). By definition, desire is “a strong feeling of wanting to have something”. You can’t want to have something... that you have.</p><p>That’s of course the reason why men desire so much during courtship, and way less after having sex. Or why women are so full of desire in the early stages of the relationship, and less after getting married for instance (yeah very cliché sorry).</p><p>There are many logical reasons for this. But one insight that Girard gives, very interesting, is that we have generally (most people), a low opinion of ourselves. Without always realizing it, but it’s very common to have insecurities, to not feel “enough”. So we instinctively believe that anyone who loves us is not really… interesting. How could they love us, if we are not desirable? If they do, that means they are even less desirable than ourselves, so we lose interest. That’s the famous quote from Marx: “I refuse to join any club that would have me for a member”.</p><p>That’s one of the reasons people desire so much the ones who don’t desire them back, and the things they can’t have. If they are out of reach, outside, that means they must be valuable.</p><p>The problem is that as soon as we show too much affection for someone, we automatically fall in the “slave” category of the relationship. And it’s a vicious circle. Because if we fall in that category, our love interest will desire us even less. And what happens if that person desires us less? You guessed it: we desire them even more. Thus reinforcing the circle.</p><p>That’s why love often seems like a “war”. A war where concealment and secrets are the main weapons. Almost every teenager learns that intuitively very early on: if you want to seduce someone, conceal your desire. Like in poker, show your hand, and you’ll lose the game. Love is a game won best by tricksters.</p><p>The great seducers of the past, like Casanova, always looked with a sorry sympathy, almost pity, at the people who “refused” the rules of the game. The naive ones, the clueless children, who wants to “not play games”, and be loved for themselves “naturally”, without any effort. What they don’t realize, is that there is nothing natural in being loved by those you desire so much. The opposite is actually true. More often than not, it’s precisely your desire for someone that will dissipate theirs, if you’re not careful.</p><p>But wait, is there no rival here then? There is actually still a rival in this relationship, but not in the sense that we usually think about rivals. Here the rival is so close, it blends with our love interest.</p><p>The rival IS our love interest in this Master/Slave relationship. Or more precisely, our love interest splits in two distincts persons: a subject and an object. A subject, a rival. And an object, the object of desire. And those two rivals actually desire the same person. Yes, you read that correctly. In the master/slave situation, our love interest desire… themselves. And as this self obsessed seducer is so much in love with themselves, they manage to elicit in us this mimetic desire to love them too, exactly like an outside rival could do it. By winning them over, we subconsciously want to prove ourselves that we are “better” than them (again like with the outside rival).</p><p>That’s the basis for the fuckboy, seductor, fatal woman, or “coquette” phenomenons (how you like to call it).</p><p>The fuckboy, like the “coquette”, or the fatal women, are the most desirable love interests, because they desire no one. But not exactly. They actually desire someone. They desire themselves. They are in love with their own bodies, their own image, their own superiority.</p><p>The indifferent, in love, is always the master. So the seducers are always winning, because they are indifferent to others. They are, in a sense, very similar to the people who desire them, because they all desire the same thing: the seducers themselves.</p><p>The love triangle, with its mimetic desire, still exist here. But with only two persons. One of them splitting into two different persons. If you love a seducer, you are actually in a rivalry with them, to win them over. But it’s a rivalry you cannot win. And as you cannot win it, their indifferent attitude confirms you that they are indeed “sacred”. They are the indifferent God that you are looking for. They have the key (apparently), to the end of the “metaphysical” desire (the desire outside of yourself). It’s an illusion of course. The metaphysical desire can’t cease. We can only desire what is outside of ourselves. But the illusion is strong.</p><p>From the point of view of the seducer, unfortunately, the desire is dead. That’s both the reason of their romantic success, but also the reason of their vital despair. They are desired by other people, but they feel “empty” and bored, because of course they can’t satisfy themselves. That’s the character Stavrogin in Dostoyevsky Demons, who is the love and desire interest of everybody, but ends up by killing himself. Life is unbearable for such a person, at the extreme end of metaphysical desire, for they have nothing left to want, which is of course a definition of depression.</p><h4>4-No love without obstacles</h4><p>And what about characters who are equally in love, and equally in desire of each others, like Romeo and Juliet?</p><p>Girard explains here, following his reasoning on desire, that if nothing in the relationship itself is an obstacle, the obstacle has to be exterior. For desire needs not to be satisfied to exist and flourish. That’s why every “real romantic couples” in fiction (like Romeo and Juliet, Tristan and Yseult, Lancelot and Guenievre), need very strong obstacles to their love, to maintain the “illusion” that they are in love. Death is often the most extreme and “useful” obstacle, to allow the romance to live forever.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>There is so much more to learn from Girard great book. I’m barely scratching the surface of his deep mind. But I wanted to share some of his thoughts, as a preamble, for anyone interested in those subjects. At the end of his book, he points toward some “solutions” outside of the metaphysical desire, to feel a more profound and meaningful sense of love, but I’ll let you discover by yourself haha.</p><p>Thank you, have a good day!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6dc9c51fcec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Dall-E will not steal my job]]></title>
            <link>https://emmanuel6.medium.com/why-dall-e-will-not-steal-my-job-6a1e2943cb82?source=rss-d2c34efc6161------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6a1e2943cb82</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[illustration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storyboard]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Emmanuel]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Aug 2022 12:02:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-13T12:25:58.894Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Why Dall-E will not steal my job as an illustrator</h3><h4>I finally was able to try it. And I can assure you it’s impossible to create professional and useful images from a text description. Here are my tests trying to create art with Dall-E.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*syf2qY1PXnJYeSA4vmSb0w.png" /><figcaption>Image by author</figcaption></figure><p>I am a professional illustrator and storyboard artist since 10 years. I work mainly for advertising, and a little bit for cinema. When I started to read all those articles about Dall-E and Midjourney, saying that AI will steal my job as an illustrator, I was very scared. Then I became more skeptical when I understood how it worked. So I registered on their waiting list, and I finally got the opportunity to try it this morning, to see if I could recreate something similar to what I do for a living, on it.</p><p>I simply tried to recreate professional images that I had to do for a client, especially a simple storyboard frame for Citroën car company. I totally randomly choose that frame, that was made for an instagram ad (that’s why it’s vertical). Here is the original frame:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dyxSwemMjXt0MgC64zcscQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Storyboard frame made by the author</figcaption></figure><p>As you can see, it seems very “easy” to describe. It’s a man and a woman, in a Citroen Ami car, front view. I don’t even mind that the car is colored in blue and the characters are white. I just wanted to see if I could get something similar with Dall-E. The results are better than I expected, but really far from being useful for my client. Here a a few of the results I got with different descriptions:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4x-WnYEx5CkhCXC5ewx__Q.png" /><figcaption>Dall-E interpretation of my description-1</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vqLSwxKQQKB8bMiQzb6GyQ.png" /><figcaption>Dall-E interpretation of my description-2</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*isxXZDb_hIxCeCvMpuiQwQ.png" /><figcaption>Dall-E interpretation of my description-3</figcaption></figure><p>The software didn’t know the exact model of the car (because it’s new probably). The characters are ok but not so realistic. And getting the same composition was almost impossible. I also realized that I forgot to mention so many details that seemed intuitive for me, like having the characters smile, looking in front of them, having the woman driving, the characters having their seatbelts on etc…</p><p>So all of that to say that it’s very, like very, difficult to describe an image with words. There are so many things that an illustrator will instinctively know how to do, that the machine would need to be told to do. Even if it was possible, it would take a very long time to get a description coherent and satisfying for a client, and many more time to try many tests, to get something right. It took me maybe 10 to 15mins to generate all those images (thinking about the correct descriptions but also generating the images took a few minutes). None of them are really usable, in a professional presentation I mean. And it took me something like 30mins to draw it myself, including the sketch to validate with my client the correct angle and composition, and correcting with their feedbacks.</p><p>Now imagine having to do this process again and again, and again, to finally get a coherent storyboard of 12 images like this one, with the same characters and cars in different angles:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B2A2G_BLl8yPZiSG6lSGsw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Storyboard for Citroen by author</figcaption></figure><p>So yes I have big doubts that those softwares, even vastly improved, will really help my clients in a professional mindset. It could help maybe to create fast moodboards. But I doubt they would want to save some money to get something like that. They need the drawings to be good, to be precise, to look professionals and to communicate exactly what they want. They are doing extremely expensive advertising campaigns (in the range of a few hundred thousand dollars, even millions when it’s for TV), so I doubt they would want to save a few hundreds (or even thousand) dollars by replacing their storyboard artist with a software. They need everything to be professional and “on point”. To explain the idea correctly to their boss, their clients, the movie director, the camera team, the special effects department etc…</p><p>A storyboard is a professional tool, to have a coherent vision of a project. It can’t be imprecise, approximate. And I’m not even talking about having the same characters with different and strong expressions, like on this storyboard I did for Brico Depot:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F8YIHBpjXtsp2QfFwU9snQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Storyboard for Brico Depot by author</figcaption></figure><p>It’s a little bit like when camera became cheap, and everybody had a good camera on their phones, people assumed it would be the death of professional photographers. But it was not. People still hire professional photographers for their wedding (like my sister recently), because it looks so much better when done by a pro. And advertising agencies and Fashion brand companies still pay large sum of money to professional photographers to shoot their campaign. I doubt any serious company will just say “let’s just buy a good camera and shoot the campaign ourselves, it will be cheaper than hiring a real photographer!”. A tool is just a tool. You still need someone specialized in using it, and with a good artistic sense.</p><p>I actually took some photography classes during my studies. I had a very good camera. And I can assure you, taking good photos is very very difficult. I admit I’m a bad photographer. It’s just not my art field. If I had to make professional photos, I’ll hire a real photographer. It’s not because you have a good tool that you are a good artist.</p><p>We could say the same thing with painters. When photography was invented, people assumed paintings were dead. They are not. When digital art was invented, traditional art continued to strive. Those are just different art forms, with their own specialists.</p><p>Talking about art forms, how Dall-E is doing with purely “artistic drawings”? I tried to recreate an illustration I did, not in a professional context, but just for myself. Because then there is less incentives to be “precise” (as it’s not professional). I just wanted to see if Dall-E was better for art than for professional storyboards. So here is the image I had made myself (I’m a big fan of Vaporwave and lofi aestethics, I do a lot of those kind of 80’s images for my instagram, then I animate them):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*syf2qY1PXnJYeSA4vmSb0w.png" /><figcaption>Image by author</figcaption></figure><p>And here are the images that Dall-E made, with my description of this image:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s5Iw4MvKg2xObX1f_zKvRg.png" /><figcaption>Dall-E interpretation of my description-1</figcaption></figure><p>It’s like, I don’t really know. It’s just not what I had in mind. Of course, because it’s almost impossible to explain a mental image with words. Also, evidently, it’s not my “style”. It totally lacks personality. But I mean, to be fair, it’s still impressive for a machine. It probably will get better over time. But do you understand what I mean, when I say that we still have many many years before people can create interesting art using those tools?</p><p>Then I tried something different. I uploaded my image (above), and asked Dall-E to create variations of this image, just to see. Here are the results:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0I75TLxaegM_OLVpLsTg2A.png" /><figcaption>Dall-E variations of my illustration</figcaption></figure><p>Yeah… Take a closer look to one of them:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GntSXrjeQRZB1C8il-iyMA.png" /></figure><p>I think you see the problem haha.</p><p>And what if the softwares become way better in the futur you may ask?</p><p>As I said on a previous article, even chess survived the success of AI tools. When Deep Blue beat Garry Kasparov in 1997, everybody assumed chess was dead. But more and more people are learning and playing the game today than before. So many youtube and twitch channels dedicated to chess have millions of subscribers. And the world champions like Magnus Carlsen are still making millions of dollars.</p><p>At the same time, no human player is able to compete with the computers. They actually use the computer to learn and better understand the game.</p><p>So why chess is not dead? Because in sport like in art, humans are more impressed and interested by humans abilities, even when they are no match for other machines or animals. Almost nobody watches matches between chess computers, it’s a little bit boring.</p><p>Also, today, with a gun, you can kill the strongest fighter man on earth in one second. The most trained martial artist, who spent 30 years crafting his art, can be defeated by a child who found a gun. We could assume that martial art should be dead. It’s “useless” compared with technology. But we still love to watch fights as a sport, between opponents fighting with their hands. Because it’s not the ultimate result (being stronger or beating your opponent) that is important, it’s the human excellence that people love to watch and admire. It’s not impressive to kill someone with a gun. Very much more to watch someone doing it with their hands, against an equally trained fighter.</p><p>A machine can lift a house, but people still love to participate in and watch the strongmen competitions.</p><p>A car, or even a cheetah, can easily outrun Usain Bolt, but we are still impressed by him, because he is the fastest human. We don’t care if any average Joe is faster on his motorbike. We are impressed that a man can RUN faster that anybody else. Not that he IS faster than anybody or anything.</p><p>So yeah, even if Ai becomes better at creating illustrations than humans (and I still have some doubts, I’m not saying it’s impossible, I’m just skeptical), I still believe my field will survive, like chess.</p><p>The cool thing will maybe not anymore to see the final results, but to see people in the act of drawing. A little bit like today, some automated pianos can play anything, but people still love to see real humans play piano. It’s more fulfilling to see humans do and create things, than to see a machine doing it.</p><p>So to all the people talking about the end of illustration and animation, or even art, be aware that art cannot die. It’s an idea. Ideas don’t die as V said. Moreover, it’s an idea central to human life since the beginning of times. Since a guy, in a cave, 50 000 years ago, realized he could put a print of his hand on the cave wall, using dirt, blood or anything. Or that he or she could sing, dance, tell stories…</p><p>Ai is a tool. What makes art is not a tool, it’s the will to make art. A machine doesn’t have will. A tool can transform art, improve it, expand it, not erase it. I’m very excited to see what those tools will bring to futur artists. I’m not worried they will steal our jobs. I mean ok, maybe just a little bit deep down haha, but not in the short or mid term at least, that I’m sure of :)</p><p>Have a good day!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6a1e2943cb82" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>