<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Eric Santosa on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Eric Santosa on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@eric.santosa?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 01:54:11 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@eric.santosa/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Activity and Narrative as Building-block of Human Experience]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eric.santosa/activity-and-narrative-as-building-block-of-human-experience-4297e627438a?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4297e627438a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Mar 2024 23:11:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-07T23:11:54.941Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NpjcA6H-AhZe5g75" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@daria_kraplak?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Daria Kraplak</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>In my cultural psychology course I usually make use of two important concepts to elucidate the cultural contexts that enable human to experience the world, to understand self and make him or herself intelligible in the world: activity and narrative.</p><p>The first concept I derive from marxist psychology of Vygotsky and his followers which roots back to Hegel and Feuerbach. There are two articles of mine on this topic (one on the story of Vygotsky, and the other on Leontiev&#39;s and Engestrom&#39;s cultural historical activity theory) which can be found in my blog. The second, I owe it from Jerome Bruner&#39;s cultural psychology, literary theory of Roland Barthes and semiotics of Saussure and Peirce.</p><h4>Activity System</h4><p>Alexei N. Leontiev which may be said as the main theorist that develops Vygotsky’s ideas considers activity as the appropriate unit of analysis that Vygotsky has searched for before his death of Tuberculosis. Leontiev defines activity as:</p><blockquote>“..the non-additive, molar unit of life for material, corporeal subject…. It is the unit of life that is mediated by mental reflection. The real function of this unit is to orient the subject in the world of objects. In other words, activity is not reaction or aggregate of reactions, but a system with its own structure, its own internal transformations, and its own development.” (Leontiev, 1981: p.46)</blockquote><p>This definition may be difficult for more western-influenced readers to digest. To put it in more simple way activity is a system that functions as the building block of meaningful human life that orients how people interprets and responds to him or herself or other minds. For example, the classroom teaching activity is a system that allows the act of raising hand to become intelligible. Cultural scripts that direct how people respond to the act are also made possible through the activity as a system. Even human self is determined as well by the roles they play in those activities. Participations in classroom activities would define the teacher&#39;s and the students&#39; self concept and esteem.</p><p>It&#39;s not that the activity as a molar unit cannot be broken down, but if we would like to construct meaningful social life any smaller elements should be organized in activity contexts. To elucidate this, Leontiev make use of levels of unit of analysis as in figure below.</p><p>In our example of the act of raising hand in classroom, the activity is the classroom activity whose motive is teaching and learning. The operation is the tangible gesture of raising hand by the participant which is determined by the condition. For example when the participant is a disabled who does not have hands he would not be able to make the gesture. The action is what is understood of the intentions behind the raising-hand, for example to ask a question or to make comments on what is being talked about in the classroom. The action is driven by the participant&#39;s goal. The operation of raising hand would be meaningless if it is decontextualized from the activity of classroom teaching. The reading of other people&#39;s mind is possible only when the gestures are understood within their contexts.</p><p>Similarly the billboard is a gesture like the raising hand in the classroom. Billboard as a gesture becomes an act of showing or telling something in the context of brand promotion activities. In the first version of the mosquito repellent billboard where there are no visual cues other than the picture and the name of the product the audience will use the promotion activity as the context to figure out the meaning of the gesture. It&#39;s like a salesman is trying to offer the audience a mosquito repellent. Unless the product is really innovative and disrupting what people know about mosquito repellent the billboard will not get any attention from the audience.</p><p>In the billboard with the two additional set of visual cues the audience is given another layer of contexts. The context of promotion activity will be pushed to sub-consciousness as background. In these two alternative versions the audience is presented with a mother doing care-giving activities, and the other a mother doing fighting activities like a warrior. These layers of context then are positioned in the foreground at discursive consciousness level. These activity contexts are presented through two different sets of meaningfully interrelated gestures which include the act of the mother, the setting of bedrooms and cultural artifacts such as nightgown and bed, or army-look apparel and hand-gun. The existence of the mosquito repellent brand will be meaningful differently in these two different contexts although its function to kill the mosquitoes maybe exactly the same. In marketing communication jargons these two activity contexts communicate similar functional benefit, but they will induce different emotional benefits to the audience.</p><h4>Narrative Mode of Experience</h4><p>To deliver such emotional benefit however the presented activity contexts should be able to induce relevant and appealing narratives in the mind of the audience. Narrative is simply a meaningful sequence of activities or events. Jerome Bruner explains narrative as follows:</p><blockquote>“a narrative is composed of a unique sequence of events, mental states, happenings involving human beings as characters or actors. These are its constituents. But these constituents do not, as it were, have a life or meaning of their own. Their meaning is given by their place in the overall configuration of the sequence as a whole-its plot or fabula.” Bruner (1990: 43)</blockquote><p>These constituents are elements of the dramatic quality, what in Kenneth Burke&#39;s dramatism is termed as the narrative pentad which consists of actors, action, intention, instrument and scene. Just like gestures and visual cues in activity contexts, this dramatic pentad would be meaningless when they are not put into certain narrative contexts. Narrative with its timeless fabula and timely sjuzet functions to glue the pentad in various activities together into a sequence that delivers meaningful experience. Like cultural scripts it dictates what the actors and interlocutors anticipate, their inter-subjective experience, the kind of worlds possible for them and how they would respond to each other in a given situation.</p><p>For example in the first set of visual cues the image of a young mother making her kids asleep comfortably may induce the audience to reconstruct a narrative of a mother who has problems with her nagging kids who could not fall asleep because of mosquitoes. Killing mosquitoes with the repellent tube becomes the solution to her problem which at the end allows her to restore her paradise of being a good mother.</p><p>In this example, being a good mother is the fabula, the timeless subject of the story that helps to make sense of the timely organizational plot of the sequence (sjuzet) and the pentad which is present in the image. The second set of visual cues in the billboard offers yet another dramatic pentad, another fabula and sjuzet, that is, being a courageous warrior which dictates another kind of meaningful sequence of activities.</p><p>These two sets of visual cues with their own narratives will deliver different emotional benefit to different audience. Which of the two narratives is relevant and appealing will depend on its fit with the psychography of the target audience.</p><p>How can those sets of visual cues or gestures be able to induce certain kinds of narratives? Here Peirce’s semiotic is very much of help to explicate the workings of how visual or verbal cues or gestures may become signs that dictate people’s awareness of certain narratives, and at the end inducing emotional benefits to the audience. The visual cues are the signifier or in Peirce’s term, the representamen; and the narratives induced in the audience’s mind are the signified. In Peircean triadic scheme the signified has two elements, that is, the interpretant (the sense that comes from interpretation process) in the audience mind, and the object or referent. In this triadic scheme the narrative with its fabula and sjuzet is the interpretant, the sense while its dramatic pentad elements are the referents.</p><p>For Peirce interpretation is an on-going process where interpretants can function as representamen that induce another more advance interpretants. This iterative interpretation process can go ad infinitum to construct or reconstruct newer sense. Narrative as interpretant must be a result of more advance and complex iterations. I shall have to say more on this topic in other article since it’s a complex subject that cannot be put in one or two paragraphs. Here I just would like to point on one important merit of semiotic. It is that Peircean triadic scheme can help us to be aware of our own interpretations, our relations (or conflicts) with other minds and to reconstruct a targeted communication that is able to induce emotional benefits to our audience in more strategic way. The backward process is important as well. It enables us to deconstruct our own interpretation and communication process, to evaluate the impacts for our social worlds.</p><h4>The Interplay between Activity System and Narrative Mode</h4><p>Let’s go back to how activity system and narrative becomes the building block of human lives. In everyday life narrative plays a very important role of helping people to make sense of themselves and their world. Activity system alone as context is not sufficient to help people orient themselves in the world. From the point of view of activity system human self is determined by timely experience delivered in certain concrete activity. It is as if human self would change from one activity to the other, oblivious of the past activities he or she has got involved in, and ignorant of the future possible activities that he or she may involve him or herself.</p><p>In reality people have a sense of continuity that define the timeless self and determine how he or she will experience current activities and their sequence. Narrative as context with its timeless fabula and timely sjuzet helps people to experience their various activities as meaningful part of their self. Using Bruner’s term, narrative with its fabula, sjuzet and the dramatic pentad allows people to have narrative mode of experience while activity system a paradigmatic one.</p><p>Let&#39;s take a look back to our classroom. There we find a young woman in her mid twenty who acts as a teacher, and some kids who sit in circles circling some tables. It&#39;s in the morning around nine AM. They are in a classroom in a kindergarten that is located in Pondok Indah, a place where many more upscale middle class of Jakarta live. Indah, her name, has worked there as kindergarten teacher since her graduation from a well-known university in Jakarta three years ago.</p><p>Eleven AM the class is dismissed. Behind the door there’s a good-looking young woman around her age waiting. She is the mother of Raka, one of Indah’s pupils, asking to have a talk with her. After having a seat in the empty classroom Indah asks her how she can help. Martha, the young mother starts to tell her story how she got divorced with her husband after three years of marriage, not long after her second baby was born; and how she has difficulties now raising two kids as a single parent while she’s got to work full-time. Raka, her elder of the two, now five years old is refusing to go to school the last three days. Martha is asking Indah for help.</p><p>Two hours has passed. Indah suddenly realize that she has missed a lunch appointment with her close friend at Pondok Indah Mall. The story of Martha is absorbing her very much. Looking at her Blackberry there are three missed calls and pings already from her friend. She hurry herself, answering her friend&#39;s pings, calling her chauffeur to take her car to school lobby.</p><p>Inside the car on the way to the mall her eyes are wandering for a moment before a billboard catches her attention. The billboard pictures a young mother wearing a nightgown in her kids bedroom holding a mosquito repellent tube. Before she can recognize the brand name the car has passed the billboard. The picture reminds her of the paradise at home when she is with her two-years old.These simple scenes may be found in our cheap local TV series, but it serves us here to illustrate how human experience a glimpse of their life, and at the same time show us the kind of life forms human may possibly have.</p><p>From paradigmatic mode point of view the activity systems which Indah may get involved in her life are: work activity in an early education institution where her role is teaching; domestic activity in a middle class family where she acts as mother; and social-leisure activity where she can find a rather loosely-defined role as a friend. This paradigmatic mode helps her to manage her life in more strategic ways into several fields of life. Each activity systems may have their own rules. Together they may compete with each other in using up resources, like time, energy and money available for Indah.</p><p>From narrative mode point of view these activity systems are experienced seamlessly as part of Indah&#39;s self whose main motive or fabula is being a good caregiver. Fabula is the key element that defines how Indah may experience herself. She may conceive of herself mainly as a caregiver who strive to become a good one. In family setting it fits perfectly well with her role as a mother of a two years old. Similarly it may fit with her role as kindergarten teacher in her work activity as well.</p><p>Listening to the story of Martha she may interpret it as a paradise-lost sjuzet where divorce prevents Martha from realizing her own paradise as a mother. Listening to the story of Martha, it&#39;s like she is presented with the kind of world she may possibly experience in the future, which may be the main reason why the story is quite absorbing for her. The picture of a young mother in nightgown on the billboard may reminds her of the paradise she may possibly be prevented from as well.</p><p>Martha on the other hand may not experience her own life the way Indah understands it as a story. Martha may have experienced a paradise-lost plot when the divorce happened several years ago. Now since she has been able to deal with it she may understand herself and her situation more like a female warrior who feel challenged to survive and overcome the problems. From narrative point of view her fabula is being warrior whose paradise is when she could strategically beat the enemies. She may see herself as undergoing transformations from a nice but fragile little girl who feel hurt because of the divorce into becoming a tough single mother who could stand the pain. That may be her sjuzet. If she were presented with the two alternative billboards, she might see the second set of visual cues more interesting than the first.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4297e627438a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Pleasant Surprise: tribute to friends and students]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eric.santosa/a-pleasant-surprise-tribute-to-friends-and-students-343af2ea9b8?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/343af2ea9b8</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 May 2023 08:55:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-01T20:35:10.593Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Pleasant Surprise: tribute to friends and students</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/1*fPYq1eOKotXc5LWVZ3rSJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Thursday, may 12 2011 at Mercure Surabaya I had breakfast with Reza, a philosopher-friend of mine who teach at Widya Mandala University. Yes, you guess it right. We had a very philosophical conversation people would find too serious and boring. Suddenly he said, &quot;by the way, I heard your students at Atma Jaya (Jakarta) plan to have a farewell party on 18. And they plan to write a book for you. They told me not to inform you about this hahaha..&quot;</p><p>A farewell party on 18? Oh I remember that my dean asked me to come to the faculty on 18. It maybe true that they plan to have a surprise party. But a book written by students for me?? It could not be true. First of all I&#39;m not the kind of popular guy that deserves such an honor. Secondly, I&#39;m not an old guru on his 70th birthday and not planning to die very soon to deserve such an obituary-like speech or article. Thirdly, as far as I know majority of my students do not like to write anything like that. I considered the idea of the book as whimsical. It couldn&#39;t be serious.</p><p>The next day I was in Kuta Bali I received an email from Reza with an article titled &quot;Saya dan Cermin&quot; attached. He said it will become one of the articles for the book. Reading it is like hearing comforting voices from an angel, saying &quot;You&#39;re not alone, Eric. You&#39;ll never alone.&quot; Reading the last line there in a dark hotel room I did not realize that my eyes were filled with tears. Tired after long hours of interview I fell asleep with my IPad still on my lap.</p><p>Bali is indeed the kind of place where people may easily forget themselves. Me included. Lucky for me that what brought me there is an ethnographic work that allows me simultaneously to observe and to enjoy life-style centers. I visited cafes, bars, restaurants, shopping malls and of course the beach. The idea of obituary-like book vanished from my mind.</p><p>Back home in Jakarta there were works waiting for me. Busy. Hectic. I didn&#39;t remember the date 18 until I received a blackberry message from my dean, reminding me to come at lunch time. I was working in the morning at my office in Pakubuwono. Coming a bit late, approaching the faculty meeting room I saw many colleagues and students.</p><p>I must admit that I was a bit awkward when I entered the room. I didn&#39;t know what to say since the way I see it I&#39;m not really going anywhere. Many students asked me where I&#39;m going after resigning from Atma Jaya. And I said to them, &quot; Hey. I&#39;m not going anywhere. I still have my class tomorrow. And from my side, if heaven allows me to, I don&#39;t intend to stop teaching. I keep doing what I&#39;ve been doing all this time. It&#39;s just that I&#39;m not in their payroll anymore.&quot; True. I now have different priority since I gotta invest more time in business. But stop teaching is far from what I imagine myself doing.</p><p>Listening to the speech at the party made me feel like I were in heaven with the blessed dead standing in front of my eyes. &quot;Thank you&quot; was all that I could say in response to those obituary-like speech. Except one. When Okki Sutanto, a student of mine started his speech holding a graphically well-designed book students and friends have written in just a week long, my heart was filled with guilty feeling. He opened his saying, &quot;I hope Mas Eric does not take this as rubbish, a waste of paper...&quot; Before he finished his sentence I didn&#39;t realize myself uttering my subconsciousness, &quot;anything that comes from loving hands will not be rubbish.&quot; I guess this was a kind of defense mechanism for repressing my guilt.</p><p>This is my confession. Yes. I often despise the students, saying that they&#39;re a bunch of zombies, that their work are piles of rubbish, waste of papers. With cynical gesture I often say, &quot;You think yourself worthy since you are students of a renowned university. Do you know how much your price is out there in labor market?? Not much more than minimum regional wage!&quot; Heaven, forgive me for saying such bad things to those youngsters. They&#39;re just victims of an oppressing education practice from a rotten society.</p><p>With this guilt still in my subconscious mind, I had mixed feelings when I first read the title &quot;King&#39;s Lecture&quot; of a book written for me. It&#39;s very easy for a nobody like me to fly into the sky of self boast. After a moment I found myself back on the ground what I saw was like a poor peasant who suddenly being crowned as a king. I laughed at myself.</p><p>Curious, after the party I read through the book. It looks like the greatest paradox of all. The book is a crown awarded to a fool who does not fit as a king at all. It is a love letter written by the abused juniors to their abusive senior who despises them. The writers are people who consider themselves garbage while in fact from their loving hands readers may find precious diamonds. Yes. The students are indeed diamonds buried deep inside the ground.</p><p>The book is for me a reward more than anything. It&#39;s priceless. Thank you guys!</p><p>For downloading the book <a href="https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/8419923608886670411/2035492651775909299#">click here</a>. To see the blog go to <a href="https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/8419923608886670411/2035492651775909299#">http://a-tribute-to-eric.blogspot.com/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=343af2ea9b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cultural Psychology: an approach to understand human experience]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eric.santosa/cultural-psychology-an-approach-to-understand-human-experience-d28886985ecf?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d28886985ecf</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 May 2023 08:18:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-01T20:56:49.885Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fULOhHuXcDQSLT8V" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@darylbydesign?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Daryl Han</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Cultural psychology has been delivered in Cultural Psychology course at the Faculty of Psychology Atma Jaya Catholic University Jakarta for several years since 2004. Starting the year 2012 the course is not offered to the students anymore because of the change in psychology curriculum at the faculty. This article is a response for those who asked and still want to have material and discussions on the topic. Here I would like to make a brief sketch about what cultural psychology is which previously has been discussed in the course.</p><p>Note: This article was writen in 2012 when social media and digital tech diruptions was still early. I hope the approach and concepts from my cultural psychology lectures may still be relevant now in 2023. I would be very glad to have critical responses that may be useful to make it more relevan.</p><h4>Why Cultural Psychology?</h4><p>I am often asked what my cultural psychology is about, why I am quite passionate on this topic. Let me illustrate with a case. If you belong to middle class segment living in big cities like Jakarta chances are that you may have visited and bought a cup of coffee at Starbucks which may cost around thirty thousand rupiah or more. Certainly Starbucks is not the only place you can find quality coffee. There are more other places you can find coffee with similar quality with cheaper price. The question is why people keep buying coffee at Starbucks despite higher price? Assuming that human can make rational decisions, what is it that people buy beyond coffee products at Starbucks? To answer those questions cultural psychology will direct our discussions into the concept of human experience. What is it that people buy? It is certain experience which is offered intentionally or not at Starbucks. This experience maybe delivered through brand communications, the products, packaging, design interiors or others that when coordinated and managed well are able to deliver certain unique experience that people may find only at Starbucks.</p><p>Cultural psychology is about understanding human experience and things that may work for delivering certain experiences for them. It is first of all about how humans understand themselves and their world, how they reason their mind and behavior, how they may be able to make themselves intelligible for other minds, and how they may change their mind and behavior.</p><p>Students will have a better understanding if they get also involved with three other courses: interpretive-qualitative research method; cultural change strategy and management; media and persuasions. Cultural psychology course consist of discussions on the approach and basic concepts, while the other three are discussions on research method and applications of cultural psychology. I plan to write articles on these topics as well if it have time.</p><p>Cultural psychology as an approach is not new. Its root can be traced back to the time when Wilhelm Wundt founded his laboratory in Leipzig in 1879. Wundt himself around the same period has written several volumes of Völkerpsychologie in which he offered an approach, quite different from experimental psychology, to study human cultures. To have complete pictures of human phenomenon one must use both approach. They should not be considered as conflicting with each other.</p><p>Later on in early twentieth century Vygotsky has raised similar concerns about psychology as science and profession. His works were aimed to build a unified general psychology that offer a more integrated approach to understand human mind and behavior. In his times already psychology has been segregated into several schools of thought that have not only their own approach but also their own object of study. His work focused on finding a more appropriate unit of analysis as an object of psychology.</p><p>In times where psychology and social science as scientific study are still dominated by positivist and experimental approach, a more interpretive approach to study human mind and behavior is needed to balance and enrich the way we understand ourselves and our contemporary world.<br>In fact in people’s daily life the way we understand ourselves and people around us is heavily interpretive. We understand our social life more through interpreting other people’s behaviors rather than through comparing and testing them in laboratory or psychological test settings. Professional counselors does not seem to have difficulties to understand her clients without applying psychological tests. The term empathy for example which is heavily discussed and become a basic concept in many counseling courses is basically an interpretive and phenomenological process. Despite that, very little we have discussions on how we can understand ourselves and other people’s mind and experience.</p><p>I write this article with the hope that the discussions will continue. I do not expect myself to cover all the material to properly understand cultural psychology in this article. What I write is the kind of cultural psychology that I usually discussed in my courses. My thinking in this area is very much influenced by three broad sources:</p><ol><li>Jerome Bruner’s cultural psychology, John Searle’s philosophy of mind, speech-act theory, semiotics of Charles Sanders Peirce and Ferdinand de Saussure, and literary theory of Roland Barthes;</li><li>Marxist psychology with Vygotsky, A.N. Leontiev, Evald Ilyenkov and Ÿro Engeström’s cultural historical activity theory; and</li><li>Comparative mythology of Joseph Campbell and Jungian psychology.</li></ol><p>I’m also very much influenced by discussions with friends, colleagues and clients, both brand owners and professionals in marketing communications industry who have stimulated my thinking through posing me many interesting and challenging problems from business point of view. Together with people in public sectors, to my eyes they are in a real business of managing strategic cultural and behavioral change in our civil society.</p><p>I would be satisfied when this article can move more people to ask questions and to explore more on the topic. It’s still a long way to make what I’m presenting in this article more useful and workable for managing cultural change both in the context of marketing communications or in public sectors. I prefer to see the journey as a collective enterprise with a common vision: for us both in private and public sectors to be able to manage our civil society in more strategic ways.</p><h4>What is cultural psychology?</h4><p>Cultural psychology is an approach to understand human mind and behavior through studying the social cultural contexts in which it occurs. Even further it is claimed that it is impossible to understand them without considering its cultural and historical contexts.</p><p>This assertion is not limited to cultural psychology. Ecological and social psychology in general have quite similar assertions that human behaviors are influenced by their social context. Cultural psychology in contrast asserts that human mind and behavior, is not only influenced, but more fundamentally constituted by their social cultural contexts. This means that they exist and intelligible only when they are treated as texts and put in their contexts.</p><p>Let me give a very simple example: the act of raising hand in a classroom. Anybody who is born and grew up in modern world would understand what it means when somebody sitting in a chair among a group of people in a classroom raises his hand. It means he intends to ask questions or make comments. The question is how is it possible that everybody understand this action? The very same act of raising hand, when it is put in other contexts would mean differently. For example at the bus stop when a man raises hand that would mean that he intends to stop a bus or taxi. The driver who never previously talked to him would know what he means and will pull over his taxi.</p><p>In the language of mainstream positivist social psychology the behavior of the taxi driver of pulling over his taxi is influenced by the man’s behavior. The man’s behavior becomes the stimulus and the driver’s the response. In contrast cultural psychology would say that first of all the act of the man’s raising hand is intelligible for the taxi driver and others nearby since the act comes up in the context of commuting activity. In itself the raising hand when it is decontextualized would be meaningless.</p><p>Furthermore the act of the taxi driver that follows after the man’s raising hand is in accordance with a kind of subconscious cultural scripts such that when they are disrupted everybody else nearby would have questions in their mind. Such subconscious cultural scripts are things that people take for granted, and will not get their attention unless they are disrupted. For example when the driver does not pull over his taxi, the man will have a question and demand an explanation why he does not do so. When nobody provides him with enough explanations, he will try to reconstruct in his mind for himself many possible stories to explain the driver’s act. It maybe the taxi is heading home to its taxi pool; or that since it’s late at night and the road is empty the driver fears of crime. The function of these stories are basically providing possible contexts that will help for mitigating the disruption the taxi driver’s action has induced.</p><p>Take another example from marketing communication industry. A mosquito repellent brand is showing a picture of a mosquito repellent tube and its brand name on a big billboard with white background across the street. No other visual cues are there on the billboard. Like the act of raising hand in classroom the act of the brand owner putting the picture on the billboard will induce expectations among the audience. People who grew up in urban setting and happen to see the billboard will know that this is an ad, and that means the brand is trying to tell something to its audience. Seeing an ad people would expect that the brand would tell something new, something they don’t know, or something that may disrupt their taken-for-granted experience.</p><p>Unlike the act of raising hand at the bus stop however there are no cultural scripts that dictate how the audience should respond to the ad. Depending on what the brand owner would like to achieve the ad should provide more cues for the audience to reconstruct possible stories in their mind that enable them to get meaningful take-outs from the ad. If the target the brand owner would like to achieve is to get the audience interested to buy the product, the billboard certainly would not be able to do it. Among so many billboards near the mosquito repellent ad it will not be able even to get the attention of the audience. The most that this ad can achieve is to get the audience aware that the product exists.</p><p>To help the audience reconstruct a meaningful story in their mind, let’s consider to provide two alternative sets of visual cues by utilizing cultural contexts which are available and recognizable in modern people’s life. The first alternative set is adding a picture of a young mother in nightgown with two of her kids lying asleep on the bed as background. The picture shows the mother holding a repellent tube trying to kill mosquitoes in the bedroom. These additional visual cues will help the audience to reconstruct a familiar story of a mother’s efforts to make her kids more comfortable sleeping. The second alternative set is a picture of a young mother dress up with a GI army-look apparel trying to protect her two kids who stand behind her from something dangerous. She is combating against mosquitoes which attack her like a squad of fighter aircrafts. She has two repellent tubes. One she holds on her belt like a hand gun, and the other she is using to repel the mosquitoes. Similarly these second set of visual cues will help the audience to reconstruct a story of a young mother’s effort to protect her kids from harm.</p><p>Which of the two alternative stories is more effective to get the audience attention or even further to induce the audience to buy the product, it is still debatable and will need more research to decide. The second set of visual cue may get more attention compared to the first since it contains disruptions from familiar scene of a mother taking care of her kids, though it will depend on its fit with the psychography of the target audience. The point we are going to make here is that by providing visual cues that help the audience reconstruct cultural contexts in their mind the ad is becoming more meaningful and enable the brand owners to get the respond that become its targets.</p><p>In real life settings people make use of such visual and verbal cues which are available in their environments to understand themselves and the world. Going back to our Starbucks case, it is the context which exists at Starbuck that help the guests having certain unique experience when they visit the place. The context is maybe delivered through brand communications, products, packagings, services, design interior, the kind of people doing the operations and also the kind of people visiting the place.</p><p>Question that remains for us to discuss is what makes the difference between the experience people may have when they visit Starbucks compared for example Angkringan in Jogjakarta. The kind of concrete activities people are doing at Starbucks and Angkringan maybe similar, that is drinking coffee, having chats with acquaintances etc, but the experience maybe quite different. We will keep this question in mind for our next discussions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d28886985ecf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Menyoal Ilmu Psikologi Positivistik]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eric.santosa/menyoal-ilmu-psikologi-positivistik-1570161d1d81?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1570161d1d81</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Aug 2022 22:53:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-30T22:53:21.152Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Oleh Eric Santosa</p><p>Psikologi sebagai ilmu yang berkiblat ke fisika ala newton dan mencari hukum ‘alam’ universal (ahistoris) akan selalu bertegangan dengan kesadaran manusia yang memungkinkan adanya pilihan-pilihan bebas dalam konteks sejarah (historis). Tulisan ini bertutur mengenai tegangan-tegangan ini.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*SeEi_ilwjMMvsM-n" /></figure><p><strong>1. Pengantar</strong></p><p>Alkisah di Leipzig tahun 1879, Wilhelm Wundt mendirikan laboratorium psikologi pertama. Itulah tanda kelahiran psikologi sebagai ilmu pengetahuan empiris. Begitu kira-kira cerita yang sering dituturkan di dalam kuliah-kuliah sejarah psikologi. Sebagai ilmu pengetahuan empiris, psikologi mendeklarasikan dirinya sebagai studi ilmiah tentang perilaku dan proses-proses mental. Misi yang diembannya kurang lebih adalah: menggambarkan, secara objektif, perilaku dan proses-proses mental dengan menggunakan pengamatan yang hati-hati dan sistematis; menjelaskan mengapa perilaku dan proses mental itu terjadi; dan meramalkan apa yang seseorang akan lakukan di masa depan, berdasarkan peristiwa yang sudah lalu.</p><p>Deklarasi seperti ini cukup untuk mengindikasikan bahwa ilmu psikologi menganggap dirinya sebagai bagian dari ilmu positivistik yang mengadopsi premis-premis tertentu tentang kenyataan yang menjadi objek studi (tataran ontologis), dan bagaimana memperoleh pengetahuan tentang kenyataan tersebut (tataran epistemologis).</p><p>Pada intinya, premis ini mengatakan bahwa ada suatu kenyataan objektif berupa substansi yang memiliki esensi terlepas dari lingkungan sekitarnya, dan bahwa substansi tersebut merupakan sebuah sistem yang diatur oleh suatu hukum tertentu. Tentu substansi itu mungkin saja dipengaruhi oleh lingkungannya, akan tetapi esensinya sudah diasumsikan terlebih dulu ada terlepas dari lingkungannya. Kita akan menyebut premis ini sebagai premis esensialis, karena mengasumsikan esensi objektif dari kenyataan yang sedang diamati.</p><p>Premis berikutnya yang sangat erat kaitannya adalah premis representasionis dan verifikasionis. Premis-premis ini berbicara mengetahui pengetahuan. Di luar kenyataanobjektif diasumsikan ada subjek pengamat yang berkesadaran. Pengetahuan merupakan implikasi logis dari kesadaran subjek pengamat.</p><p>Premis representasionis mengatakan bahwa pengetahuan dapat diumpamakan sebagai gambar yang mewakili (to represent) kenyataan objektif. Implikasinya lebih jauh adalah bahwa secara prinsipil hanya ada satu gambar saja yang benar, yaitu yang benar-benar tepat menggambarkan kenyataan objektif tersebut.</p><p>Disinilah premis verifikasionis memainkan perannya. Premis ini mengatakanbahwa pengetahuan mesti dibuktikan (verified) kebenarannya. Pengetahuan yang benar adalah yang memiliki korespondensi dengan kenyataan objektif (bebas nilai). Metode eksperimental dianggap sebagai model ideal cara memperoleh pengetahuan objektif. Berdasarkan pengetahuan yang objektif ini, maka sang subyek pengamat akan mampu meramalkan apa yang akan terjadi pada objek studinya di masa depan.</p><p>Mudah ditebak, bahwa premis-premis ini mengikuti premis ilmu alam ala Newton yang mengandaikan alam semesta itu bagai sebuah mesin besar yang secara prinsip dapat 100% diramalkan tindak tanduknya, baik di masa depan (to predict) maupun di masa lalu (to retrodict), apabila manusia mengetahui hukum yang mengaturnya.</p><p>Tentu saja tidak semua aliran pemikiran di psikologi menganut metode eksperimental. Akan tetapi dapat dikatakan bahwa mayoritas menerima premis esensialis dengan memperlakukan kenyataan psikis sebagai substansi objektif (relatif terhadap peneliti sebagai subyek pengamat) yang diatur oleh suatu hukum universal seperti hukum alam. Tujuan utama berbagai aliran psikologi tersebut adalah untuk menemukan ‘hukum alam’ tersebut. Pandangan seperti ini dapat ditemui mulai dari psikologi Freudian, behavioristik, humanistik sampai dengan psikologi kognitif yang mutakhir.</p><p>Tulisan berikut ini bermaksud mempersoalkan premis-premis di atas. Ini dilakukan dengan menunjukkan bahwa ketika pendekatan positivistik dipakai untuk mengerti kenyataan psikis dan sosial, ia akan berbenturan dengan premis penting lainnya, yang juga diterima secara parsial oleh pendekatan positivistik, yaitu premis kesadaran manusia. Benturan ini secara logis menimbulkan masalah baik pada tataran teoretis maupun etis.</p><p>Untuk mencapai maksud di atas, tulisan ini dibagi menjadi beberapa bagian. Sebagai ilustrasi bagaimana ilmu positivistik memahami objek studinya, di bagian kedua akan digambarkan secara sederhana bagaimana ilmu fisika ala Newton memahami gejala spektrum cahaya. Ilustrasi ini kemudian akan digunakan di bagian ketiga untuk menggambarkan bagaimana psikologi positivistik mencoba mengerti manusia. Di bagian keempat akan dibahas masalah-masalah pada tataran teoretis dan etis bila pendekatan positivistik dipakai untuk memahami perilaku manusia.</p><p><strong>2. Ilustrasi Cara Kerja Ilmu Positivistik</strong></p><p>Di bangku sekolah menengah, kita belajar bahwa bila cahaya matahari masuk ke sebuah prisma, ia akan keluar kembali dalam bentuk spektrum cahaya. Cahaya matahari adalah cahaya putih yang sebenarnya merupakan kombinasi berbagai cahaya yang dapat diamati melalui cahaya yang keluar dari prisma tersebut. Spektrum cahaya matahari adalah spektrum yang paling lengkap, terdiri dari tujuh warna yang dapat dilihat mata manusia yaitu merah, jingga, kuning, hijau, biru, nila, dan ungu, dan dua yang tidak dapat dilihat mata manusia, yaitu infra merah dan ultraviolet. Itu adalah spektrum cahaya matahari.</p><p>Akan tetapi tidak semua cahaya menghasilkan spektrum yang lengkap seperti cahaya matahari. Cahaya yang berasal dari zat-zat kimia tertentu menghasilkan spektrum yang tidak lengkap. Zat tersebut memancarkan cahaya bila diberi energi tambahan dengan cara memanaskannya. Sodium, misalnya, bila diberi energi akan memancarkan cahaya kuning. Bila cahaya ini memasuki prisma, maka spektrum yang akan keluar adalah dua garis cahaya kuning tipis. Sebaliknya sodium juga akan menyerap energi yang dipancarkan oleh cahaya.</p><p>Apabila cahaya matahari yang berspektrum lengkap diarahkan menembus uap sodium, cahaya yang keluar akan berspektrum lengkap minus dua cahaya kuning di atas. Ini berarti sodium menyerap sebagian energi cahaya matahari yang masuk. Dapat dikatakan bahwa pancaran atau penyerapan cahaya kuning merupakan sifat zat sodium. Zat-zat lainnya memiliki berbagai sifat yang berbeda sehingga secara prinsip pengamat dapat mengenali suatu zat melalui sifatnya.</p><p>Para fisikawan kemudian bertanya: mengapa zat kimia memiliki sifat-sifat seperti itu? Penjelasannya mesti terletak di partikel-partikel terkecil yang membentuk zat tersebut, yaitu atom. Di tahun 1913 seorang fisikawan Denmark bernama Niels Bohr memberi penjelasan dengan menggunakan model sistem solar yang diciptakan dua tahun sebelumnya oleh Ernst Rutherford. Atom digambarkan berisi nukleus yang menjadi pusat berbagai orbit dimana elektron-elektron bergerak mengelilinginya. Tiap jenis atom memiliki jumlah elektron yang berbeda-beda. Energi yang diterima oleh atom akan menyebabkan elektron tertentu lompat keluar orbitnya. Dalam perjalanannya kembali ke orbit mereka akan memancarkan energi. Inilah yang menyebabkan sodium memancarkan cahaya berspektrum kuning ketika dipanaskan.</p><p>Pelajaran apa yang dapat ditarik lewat ilustrasi di atas mengenai cara ilmu positivistik memahami objek studinya? Pertama-tama para ilmuwan mesti memperhatikan variasi dan konstansi dari gejala yang menarik perhatiannya. Sodium secara konstan memancarkan dan menyerap cahaya kuning. Zat lainnya memancarkan dan menyerap spektrum cahaya yang berbeda. Kedua, mereka mencari esensi dari substansi untuk menjelaskan variasi dan konstansi gejala.</p><p>Penjelasan seperti ini dapat digambarkan lewat skema stimulus-organ-response (S-O-R). Sodium adalah substansi atau organ yang esensinya mengada terlepas dari lingkungannya. Ia menerima stimulus berupa energi yang menyebabkannya berrespons dengan memancarkan spektrum cahaya tertentu. Yang menjadi pertanyaan bagi para fisikawan adalah apa yang membuat sodium (O) memancarkan spectrum kuning (R) apabila diberi tambahan energi (S). Mereka berpikir jawabannya mesti terdapat di dalam esensi dari sodium. Ini adalah premis esensialis.</p><p>Ketiga, para ilmuwan kemudian membuat berbagai hipotesis untuk menjelaskan apa yang terjadi di dalam sodium. Model atom sistem solar merupakan salah satu penjelasan apa yang terjadi di dalam sodium sehingga ia “berperilaku” seperti itu. Diterima atau tidaknya penjelasan di atas sebagai pengetahuan objektif yang universal bergantung pada korespondensinya dengan perilaku objektif sodium yang bisa diamati melintasi ruang-waktu. Ini adalah premis representasionis-verifikasionis.</p><p><strong>3. Cara Kerja Ilmu Psikologi Positivistik</strong></p><p>Cara psikologi sebagai ilmu positivistik memahami perilaku manusia mirip dengan cara ilmu fisika ala newton memahami “perilaku” sodium di atas. Ini bisa diamati lewat penelitian-penelitian yang dilakukan untuk memahami perilaku manusia. Salah satu contoh yang kurang lebih tipikal adalah penelitian persepsi sosial yang dilakukan oleh Duncan (1976).</p><p>Di dalam penelitian ini dua kelompok mahasiswa kulit putih menonton sebuah film yang berisi situasi dimana seseorang mendorong seorang lainnya. Kelompok pertama menonton situasi dimana sang pelaku adalah orang kulit putih, sedangkan yang kedua orang kulit hitam. Kedua kelompok kemudian diminta untuk mengkategorisasi situasi itu sebagai “main-main” atau sebagai “perilaku agresif.”</p><p>Duncan menemukan bahwa peserta penelitian cenderung mengkategorisasi situasi tsb sebagai “perilaku agresif” bila sang pelaku berkulit hitam, dan sebagai “main-main” bila sang pelaku berkulit putih. Hasil penelitian ini dijelaskan dengan mengatakan bahwa kategorisasi tersebut terjadi karena peserta penelitian yang berkulit putih memiliki stereotipi dan prasangka negatif (prejudice) terhadap orang berkulit hitam.</p><p>Penelitian Duncan ini dilakukan berdasarkan premis-premis ilmu positivistik yang sama dengan ilmu fisika ala newton. Skema S-O-R yang sama dapat diterapkan dalam penelitian ini. Film yang berisi interaksi dua aktor di atas merupakan informasi (S) yang kemudian diproses sedemikian oleh peserta penelitian (O) sehingga menghasilkan respons (R) Berupa kategorisasi “main-main” atau “perilaku agresif.” Skema S-O-R ini mengantar peneliti pada dugaan bahwa mesti ada sesuatu yang terjadi di dalam diri subjek penelitian (O) yang membuat variasi stimulus sejajar dengan variasi respons. Ini adalah premis esensialis.</p><p>Penelitian yang mutakhir mengenai perubahan sikap tetap menganut premis-premis positivistik yang sama. Ini dapat dilihat lewat penelitian yang dilakukan oleh Dasgupta dan Greenwald (2001). Tujuan dari penelitian mereka adalah mencari cara untuk mengurangi prasangka negatif otomatis terhadap orang berkulit hitam.</p><p>Penelitian ini dilakukan dengan mengikuti skema S-O-R. Peserta penelitian (O) dibagi menjadi tiga kelompok: dua kelompok eksperimen, dan satu kelompok kontrol. Peserta di dua kelompok eksperimen diberi tugas yang mengharuskan mereka melihat dan mengenali berbagai tokoh publik berkulit hitam dan putih, baik yang dikagumi maupun yang tidak disukai. Kelompok eksperimen pertama memperoleh gambar (S1) orang kulit hitam yang dikagumi dan kulit putih yang tidak disukai (gambar pro kulit hitam).</p><p>Kelompok eksperimen kedua memperoleh gambar (S2) orang kulit hitam yang tidak disukai dan kulit putih yang dikagumi (gambar pro kulit putih). Kelompok kontrol memperoleh tugas mengenali gambar (S3) serangga dan bunga. Setelah melihat berbagai gambar orang kulit putih dan hitam, peserta penelitian kemudian diminta untuk mengerjakan dua macam tes (R) yang bertujuan mengukur sikap rasial otomatis (Implicit Association Test) dan sikap eksplisit. Hasil penelitian ini menunjukkan bahwa peserta penelitian (O) di kelompok eksperimen pertama yang memperoleh gambar (S1) pro kulit hitam mengalami perubahan sikap rasial otomatis (R) menjadi lebih pro kulit hitam.</p><p>Berbagai teori tentang persepsi sosial dan perubahan sikap umumnya berusaha menjelaskan apa yang ada dan terjadi di dalam organ (O) sehingga ia berperilaku tertentu. Sama seperti para fisikawan yang menggambarkan esensi dari berbagai zat kimia dengan mengandaikan keberadaan proton, neutron dan elektron, para ahli psikologi menggambarkan esensi kenyataan psikis manusia dengan mengandaikan keberadaan berbagai instansi mental. Fiske dan Taylor (1991) misalnya mengandaikan adanya dua instansi mental dasar yang ada di dalam diri manusia: kognisi dan motivasi. Ini adalah premis esensialis.</p><p>Pengandaian yang mirip juga dapat dilihat melalui teori McGuire (1969) tentang perubahan sikap. Ia mengandaikan adanya dua proses mental yang mengantar seseorang ke perubahan sikap yaitu reception dan yielding. Reception adalah proses kognitif dimana seseorang mencerna suatu pesan hingga sampai ke pemahaman, sedangkan yielding adalah proses motivasional dimana seseorang menerima pesan sebagai positif sehingga bersedia berperilaku sesuai dengan pemahaman tersebut. Diterima atau tidaknya penjelasan Fiske dan Taylor (1991) dan McGuire (1969) di atas sebagai pengetahuan bergantung pada korespondensinya dengan perilaku manusia yang objektif.</p><p><strong>4. Menyoal Ilmu Psikologi Positivistik</strong></p><p>Premis esensialis dan verifikasionis menjadi bermasalah bila dipakai untuk memahami perilaku manusia. Masalahnya datang dari premis lain yang sebenarnya penting bagi, dan diterima oleh pendekatan positivistik, yaitu premis kesadaran manusia.</p><p>Dalam pendekatan positivistik, pemisahan antara subjek dan objek merupakan faktor penting yang menentukan kebenaran suatu pengetahuan. Kesadaran diterima secara parsial hanya sebagai karakteristik subjek pengamat, dan bukan karakteristik objek. Lebih jauh lagi dapat dikatakan bahwa objek mesti diasumsikan tidak sadar sehingga perilakunya ditentukan sepenuhnya oleh hukum sebab akibat alamiah.</p><p>Tujuan ilmu positivistik adalah menemukan hukum tersebut. Ketika pendekatan ini diterapkan untuk memahami perilaku manusia, ia menjadi tidak konsisten karena premis kesadaran manusia diterima hanya secara parsial. Di satu pihak sang manusia pengamat dianggap berkesadaran sehingga mampu memiliki pengetahuan yang benar. Di lain pihak sang manusia yang diamati dianggap tak berkesadaran, dan perilakunya dikendalikan oleh berbagai kekuatan alamiah yang tidak bisa dikendalikannya. Kalaupun ia dianggap berkesadaran, perilakunya dipandang dikendalikan oleh sebab-sebab yang berada di luar kesadarannya.</p><p>Penerimaan premis kesadaran manusia secara parsial menuntun ilmu positivistik untuk memperlakukan manusia sebagai objek belaka. Ini menimbulkan permasalahan baik di tataran teoretis maupun etis. Di tataran teoretis, permasalahannya berawal dari ambisi ilmu positivistik untuk menemukan hukum alamiah universal yang secara tak terelakan mengatur perilaku manusia mengatasi ruang dan waktu.</p><p>Ini adalah cita-cita ideal ilmu fisika ala newton yang secara prinsipil dapat dicapai melalui metode eksperimental. Citacita ini tidak bisa hidup berdampingan dengan premis kesadaran manusia. Ketika metode ini diterapkan untuk mencari sebab musabab perilaku manusia, ia boleh jadi menghasilkan pengetahuan tentang faktor-faktor penyebab perilaku yang berada di luar kesadaran manusia yang diamati.</p><p>Akan tetapi, begitu pengetahuan tersebut menjadi wacana di luar komunitas peneliti dan menjadi bagian dari kesadaran manusia secara umum, maka secara prinsipil juga hukum sebab-akibat di atas menjadi tidak tak-terhindarkan. Artinya, seseorang kemudian mampu memutuskan apakah ia akan mengikuti atau tidak mengikuti, dan bahkan bila ia memiliki cukup kekuasaan ia dapat mengubah hukum tersebut.</p><p>Dengan perkataan lain, hukum itu sendiri menjadi tidak universal, tetapi menjadi bagian dari sejarah manusia yang terikat di dalam ruang dan waktu (Gergen, 1973). Dengan demikian, cita-cita ilmu positivistik untuk menemukan hukum yang mengatur perilaku manusia mengatasi ruang dan waktu secara prinsipil tidak dapat dicapai.</p><p>Argumen di atas bukan bermaksud mengatakan bahwa tidak ada hukum, universal ataupun bukan, yang mengatur perilaku manusia. Yang hendak dikatakan adalah bahwaperilaku manusia tidak diatur oleh hukum alamiah yang tak-terelakkan dan mengatasi sejarah. Oleh karena itu kita harus membedakan hukum yang mengatur gejala alamiah objektif dan gejala kemanusiaan.</p><p>Gejala objektif adalah segala macam gejala yang keberadaannya dapat dirasakan oleh kelima indera manusia. Hukum yang mengaturnya adalah hukum sebab-akibat alamiah yang tak terhindarkan dan mengatasi ruang dan waktu. Sebuah bola basket misalnya, yang dilempar ke atas dengan sudut tertentu oleh Reza, akan mengikuti hukum Newton mengenai gaya gravitasi, dan akan kembali mendarat di atas tanah. Ini adalah gejala alamiah objektif yang bisa dirasakan oleh indera manusia, dan yang perilakunya diatur oleh hukum yang tak terhindarkan oleh bola tersebut.</p><p>Sama halnya bila bola itu, setelah dilemparkan oleh Reza, mengenai Adri hingga mengakibatkan memar di wajahnya. Ini juga terjadi mengikuti mekanisme fisiologis yang tak terhindarkan bila badan manusia terbentur benda dengan kecepatan tinggi.</p><p>Sekarang bayangkan, setelah terbentur bola basket itu, Adri menjadi marah, berlari mengejar Reza dan memukulnya. Apakah ada hubungan sebab-akibat alamiah objektif antara perilaku Reza melempar bola dan kemarahan Adri terhadap Reza? Kedua gejala tersebut tentu saja melibatkan gejala objektif yang dapat dirasakan oleh indera manusia. Akan tetapi gejala objektif tersebut tidak menentukan hubungan keduanya.</p><p>Sulit dibayangkan bagaimana ada hubungan sebab-akibat alamiah yang niscaya antara keduanya. Kalaupun ada hokum yang mengatur hubungan keduanya, ia kurang lebih dapat dirumuskan sebagai berikut: “bila seseorang disakiti ia akan marah dan membalas orang yang menyakitinya.” Tidak ada sesuatu yang salah dari rumusan hukum ini kecuali bila ia diperlakukan sebagai hukum alamiah yang tak terhindarkan dan mengatasi sejarah.</p><p>Di tataran etis permasalahannya adalah: premis kesadaran manusia secara parsial, menuntun orang untuk memonopoli kebenaran pengetahuan dan lebih jauh, menindas hak sesamanya untuk mengemukakan pendapat. Ini didasari oleh anggapan bahwa sesamanya tidak mampu untuk memiliki pengetahuan yang benar (incapable of knowledge), dan perilakunya berada di luar kesadaran.</p><p>Dalam interaksi sosial konkrit, hubungan subjek objek yang menindas ini dapat dilihat wujudnya di dalam, misalnya, beberapa bentuk interaksi dokter-pasien, psikolog dan kliennya, peneliti psikologi dan peserta penelitiannya. Apabila sikap seperti ini dianut oleh pihak yang berkuasa atas banyak orang, maka yang akan terjadi adalah proses pembisuan kesadaran publik. Suara publik jadinya kemudian hanya membeo apa yang dikatakan oleh pihak penguasa.</p><p>Situasi seperti ini dapat dilihat wujudnya dalam, misalnya, praktek pendidikan dimana guru menjadi pihak yang berkuasa atas muridnya. Dalam bentuk hubungan seperti ini, guru adalah pemegang kebenaran mutlak sehingga murid tinggal membeo kata-kata sang guru. Lebih jauh, guru juga bisa dipandang sebagai pihak yang kesadarannya dibelenggu oleh ideologi tertentu yang dianut oleh penguasa birokrasi pendidikan.</p><p>Masih di tataran etis, permasalahan lainnya berawal dari premis esensialis yang diterapkan pada sesama manusia. Premis ini mendorong orang untuk memperlakukan sesamanya sebagai objek yang memiliki esensi mutlak yang tak terelakan dan mengatasi sejarah.</p><p>Permasalahan ini bisa dilihat biasanya lewat pernyataan-pernyataan stereotipikal mengenai orang atau kelompok tertentu: “Andi memang dasarnya pemarah,” “Seks bebas adalah kultur barat,” “Pada dasarnya orang Indonesia itu ramah,” “Cara kerja orang Indonesia tidak sistematis,” “Kaum homoseks senang gonta ganti pasangan.” Itu adalah beberapa contoh pernyataan tentang orang atau kultur tertentu yang sering dilontarkan oleh orang awam.</p><p>Akan tetapi para ahli perilaku manusia juga memiliki sikap seperti itu, bahkan dengan lebih arogan mengatakan bahwa pernyataan mereka di dasarkan pada penelitian yang objektif. Ini bisa dilihat misalnya lewat teori Individualism-Collectivism (Triandis, 1972; Hofstede, 1980). Manusia, menurut kulturnya, digolongkan ke dalam salah satu kategori: individualis atau kolektivis. Digambarkan bahwa masing-masing kategori itu memiliki perilaku yang khas.</p><p>Teori seperti ini, ketika dibawa ke kehidupan sehari-hari, menutup mata sang pengamat terhadap dinamika dan variasi di dalam sebuah masyarakat. Lebih jauh sikap ini bila dianut oleh pihak yang berkuasa atas kesadaran publik berpotensi mendorong marginalisasi orang/ kelompok tertentu yang dianggap berperilaku menyimpang dari kategori normatif.</p><p><strong>5. Penutup</strong></p><p>Tulisan ini tidak bermaksud mengatakan bahwa pendekatan positivistik harus dicampakkan begitu saja dalam memahami gejala kemanusiaan. Yang hendak dikatakan adalah bahwa bila pendekatan ini akan diterapkan, ini mesti dilakukan secara kritis. Ia boleh jadi dapat diterapkan untuk meneliti berbagai perilaku manusia yang berada di luar kontrol kesadaran pelakunya.</p><p>Akan tetapi, pendekatan ini terutama bermasalah dalam usaha memahami kenyataan psikis dan sosial yang melibatkan kesadaran manusia. Pendekatan apa yang lebih tepat dalam memahami kenyataan psikis dan sosial seperti ini? Ini adalah pertanyaan yang masih terbuka bagi diskusi selanjutnya.</p><p>DAFTAR PUSTAKA</p><p>Duncan, B. L. (1976). <em>Differential Social Perception and Attribution of Intergroup Violence: Testing the Lower Limits of Stereotyping of Blacks.</em> Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 34: 590–8.</p><p>Dasgupta, N. &amp; Greenwald, A. G. (2001). <em>On the Malleability of Automatic Attitudes: Combating Automatic Prejudice With Images of Admired and Disliked Individuals.</em> Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81: 800–814.</p><p>Fiske, S. T. &amp; Taylor, S. E. (1991). <em>Social Cognition.</em> McGraw-Hill, Singapore.</p><p>Gergen, Kenneth J. (1973). <em>Social Psychology as History. </em>Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 26: 309–20.</p><p>McGuire, W. J. (1969). <em>The nature of attitudes and attitude change.</em> In G. Lindzey &amp; E. Aronson (Eds.), Handbook of social psychology (2nd ed., Vol. 3, pp. 136–314). Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.</p><p>Triandis, H. C. (1972). <em>The Analysis of Subjective Culture.</em> John Wiley, New York.</p><p>Hofstede, G. (1980). <em>Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values.</em> Sage, Beverly Hills CA.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1570161d1d81" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How consumer insight can benefit us, consumers]]></title>
            <link>https://uxdesign.cc/how-consumer-insight-can-benefit-us-consumers-cc9868757b8b?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc9868757b8b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[customer-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethnography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consumer-insights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brand-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-growth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Dec 2019 06:36:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-23T01:26:26.104Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Consumer insight is an explanation of how and why consumers adopt particular products. It helps producer’s brand to increase likelihood of happy adoption by target personas. I will argue that it can help us, consumers, as well. Two things it can benefit us: to raise awareness on life situation, and to grow self more systematically.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ouSXsVrKCDUGU8SI" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@markusspiske?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Markus Spiske</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>The analytical tool</h3><p>Consumer insight helps brand to be aware of consumer’s motives and painpoints in using products. It helps to tell whether consumer is happy or not with the brand. Insight is delivered by systematically observing personas and product use cases in consumer’s ecosystem. The output is thick descriptions of how and why consumers do or do not adopt the products.</p><p>There are numerous analytical tools that may guide to deliver consumer insight for brands. In this article we will use ethnographic zoom-lens as shown below. It is used for identifying product elements that may be appealing, relevant and fit the identity of consumer personas. Using this analytical tool I will show how consumer insight can benefit us, consumers, as well.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/754/1*W1QgqE9T0d3Q8gyVOsW2wA.png" /></figure><p>To illustrate how we use this analytical tool, consider these two thick descriptions:</p><p>A young single (trait, level 4) mom (role, level 3) is working in an advertising agency (community, level 3) as account manager (role, level 3). After divorce with her ex (trait, level 4), she has to finance and manage a household (role, level 3) with two elementary school age kids by herself. Their education is her financial plan priority (persona motive, level 2). She is using an investing app that allows her to buy ETF in small amounts (levels 0–1). When she is buying ETF she definitely has motive of profit (use motive, level 2). However, she might not take bigger risk for bigger profit. She would perceive the app more as a saving rather than an investing app (app use case, levels 0–2).</p><p>Compare with second case: a young male startup entrepreneur (persona, levels 3 — 4) whose motive (persona motive, level 2) is winning business competitions. He might be willing to take more risk for gaining bigger profits. An investing app which allows to buy ETF (Exchange Traded Funds) with small amounts might not fit to serve his motive to get bigger profit with bigger risks (use case, levels 0 — 2).</p><p>These two cases illustrate how we can use ethnographic zoom-lens for helping brand to understand consumer’s motives and painpoints. For more about ethnographic zoom-lens read <a href="https://link.medium.com/kKTdQzGrh2">this article</a>.</p><h3>Raise self-awareness as consumer</h3><p>Living in modern urban ecosystems we are surrounded by brands which are competing to occupy our awareness, to win our interests, and to get us use their products. Brands who have good insights understand how and why consumers use products more than what the consumers realize about themselves. They can serve target personas better than competitions. However, this can also put us, consumers, in vulnerable positions. We can guard our vulnerabilities by raising self-awareness as consumer on our life situations.</p><p>We can do this by curating both sides of the zoom-lens: the cultural ecosystems we are in, and our identities as consumer. On the ecosystem side, we can guide ourselves to be aware of two things: the product offered and used, and our social circles in urban life. Awareness is a habit that can be cultivated by training ourselves to observe touchpoints in the ecosystems. Touchpoints are social occasions where we can observe flows and exchange of products, money, people and discourses. Brands are represented in touchpoints through products and people.</p><p>On the self-as-consumer side we can curate our own persona and product use cases. We can ask ourselves: what traits or values that we do or do not share with tribes and communities? What are the roles we may play in relevant communities? What are the products that we are willing to repeat buying and using? How and why? What are the touchpoints that we often find ourselves in? With whom? What are our pain points in those touchpoints? Pain points can be related with products, money, people or discourses both in conversations and in media. By observing our own persona, use cases and pain points we can raise self-awareness. It helps us to realize what may be relevant, appealing and fit our identity. This is so that our decisions to adopt whatever offered to us in the ecosystem are less impulsive and more enlightened.</p><h3>Grow your self as producer</h3><p>Consumer insight helps brand to grow by increasing the likelihood and scale-up the number of happy adoptions by personas. This is done by having empathy on persona motives and pain points, and then identifying potential elements of appeal, relevance and identity (ARI) in touchpoints. Accordingly, products and brand stories are designed so that those elements maybe present in consumers’ life. Their objective is doing service to help overcome the pain points consumers experience in particular touchpoints.</p><p>This brand-consumer relation can be described using engagement model below. It consists of two positions: the left one represents self as producer; while the right one others as consumers. In between the two is the ecosystems where both producer and consumer may find themselves in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/708/1*3AfGgfcgMCY0vqWjSA-P0w.png" /></figure><p>What this producer-consumer engagement model is saying is that if we would like to grow, we need to go beyond being passive consumer, and develop self as a producer-brand that serve other people in the ecosystems. Empathy is the first step for doing this. The analytical tool can guide us to do empathy, design the service for others and grow more systematically. Positive regards from social circles and willingness to pay by personas are the feedback we get when we are so good at delivering the services that people are happy to repeat using them.</p><p>This engagement model can be applied for personal self developments both in careers or in running startup initiatives. Being producer in the ecosystem starts with empathy on other people’s pain points. These are brand’s opportunities to contribute with services that may help overcome the pain points. In career at a company, this means doing service for co-workers, superordinates and subordinates. In startup enterprise, this means doing services for customers based on our core competence. Growth both in revenues and reputations is by-products of doing empathy and services consistently based on what we are really good at.</p><p>For further discussion about this topic, you can reach me through eric.santosa@gmail.com</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc9868757b8b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxdesign.cc/how-consumer-insight-can-benefit-us-consumers-cc9868757b8b">How consumer insight can benefit us, consumers</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxdesign.cc/">UX Collective</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Understanding brand and UX jargon using object-oriented ethnography]]></title>
            <link>https://uxdesign.cc/understanding-brand-and-ux-jargon-using-object-oriented-ethnography-6d87cdea05a0?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d87cdea05a0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[semiotics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethnography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brand-strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Dec 2019 00:45:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-15T10:34:38.891Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Jargon has created many confusions, but at the same time it is something we cannot live without. This is especially true when we read briefs in brand strategy, product development, UX design or consumer insight projects. I’ve been using object-oriented ethnography and thick descriptions to help myself understand the jargon in project briefs. Here’s how I understand them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8uRJU8xDu_oyg34p" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@clemono2?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Clem Onojeghuo</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I’ve been working to deliver consumer insights for variety of brand, product or service categories. I’m truly a horizontal jack of all trades in this sense. Despite this variety my task is always the same: to identify elements in brands, products or services that may help to improve the quality and scale-up happy adoptions by consumers, users or customers. And, the analytical tool that I use is always the same as well.</p><p>Working with one category to the other, the challenge for me is to understand the jargon that is used in project briefs by various brand owners, advertising, or design agencies. To avoid misunderstanding the briefs I would translate them into my analytical tool. Here it is and how we can use it.</p><h3>Thick description and semiotic zoom-lens</h3><p>Object-oriented ethnography is a discipline for observing how and why consumers experience particular objects in their ecosystem. It aims to explain product experience: the total content of appearance of products from first-person point of view. The task is to help outsiders to see how the products appear from insider’s point of view using <strong>thick descriptions of product use</strong>.</p><p>The thickness of product use descriptions should help to explain how and why consumers do or do not adopt particular products. This insider’s explanation is constructed by providing background contexts from consumer ecosystems. A thick description can be constructed using five levels (0–4) semiotic zoom-lens below.</p><p>Note: Consumers, user and customer are terms that are used interchangeably in this article for referring to person who adopt brands or products.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CKarB6azdNliPKcOlDrL7Q.png" /><figcaption>Thick descriptions of UX personas and use cases using semiotic zoom-lens</figcaption></figure><p>We can find tangible products at the lowest zoom-in (level 0). They are objects that consumers use as tools; while scripts are mental representations in consumers’ awareness of how they may operate them. The tools are used to conduct actions with certain intentions in mind (level 1). Product use descriptions (levels 0–1) are constructed using these two lowest levels.</p><p>An Example of product use (levels 0–1). In a mobile app we could find this product use instruction: “tap the plus-button, and then tap the amount or type the number (product-script, level 0) to put your small change in the virtual piggy-bank (action-intention, level 1); and then if the piggy-bank balance has reached a minimum of 5 dollar, tap the invest-now-button (level 0) to buy the ETF (level 1).”</p><p>This product use description is thin. To be more meaningful thick description of product use should be embedded into relevant context of ecosystems. The mobile app is a tool (level 0) prepared by provider to deliver a service (levels 1–2): helping customers to do investing activity with motive of profits (use motive, level 2). These levels 0–2 (product use + use motive) define the mobile app category: an investing app. To construct a use case, however, we still need to enrich the touchpoint (level 2) with background persona motives.</p><p>Two product use case example (desc 0–2):</p><p>First case: A young (trait, level 4) mom (role, level 3) is working in advertising industry (tribe, level 4). When she is using the investing app, she definitely has the motive of profits (use motive, level 2). However, she also may have background motive (persona motive, level 2) of caregiving with plans for the finance of education for her two kids. When she uses the investing app (levels 0–1) she might not be willing to take more risk for gaining bigger profits. She might perceive the action of buying ETF more like saving, rather than investing (perceived positioning of product).</p><p>Compare with second case: a young male startup entrepreneur (persona, levels 3–4) whose motive (level 2) is winning business competitions. He might be willing to take more risk for gaining bigger profits. An investing app which allows customer to buy ETF (Exchange Traded Funds) with small amounts might not fit to serve his motive to get bigger profit with bigger risks. These two cases illustrate two different thick use cases (desc 0 — 2) of the same product.</p><p>As shown above a well-formed thick description is constructed by embedding product use (levels 0 — 1) further up the levels to involve use-motives (level 2), personas (levels 3–4) and persona-motives (level 2). Elements in level 3 and 4 (tribe-trait, community-role) can be used as spectrums for constructing different personas. Going back down the zoom-lens levels, these spectrums help to generate various possible persona-motives that may serve to enrich the touchpoints (level 2) as backgrounds for use-motive in use case description (desc 0–2). More examples of how we can use thick description of product use can be read <a href="https://link.medium.com/raUCUwIP61">here</a>.</p><h3>Social semiotic zoom-lens</h3><p>Above we have used semiotic zoom-lens as analytical tool to understand two terms in UX design jargon: persona and use cases. Persona is a model user, more or less representing one target psychographic segment; while use cases are possible ways the product maybe used by the persona. In consumer research, use case more or less represents certain pattern of usage habits and attitudes toward certain products.</p><p>For further understanding brand and UX jargon I would need another analytical tool: <strong>social</strong> semiotic zoom-lens. This represents two interacting zoom-lenses: one on the left represents <strong>producer</strong>, the other on the right <strong>consumer</strong>. As is shown in the scheme below, in-between the two there is an <strong>ecosystem</strong> where both producer and consumer may be co-present. It consists of both tangible and intangible objects that may enable or constraint product design and use cases.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IqbRVOqoMN6_gn7ilPMI_g.png" /><figcaption>Brand strategy jargon in social semiotic zoom-lens</figcaption></figure><p>In the ecosystem we could find touchpoint at level 2. It is a battle arena where producer may face competitions in serving and winning consumers’ attention, adoption and loyalty. This arena is social occasion where brand communications and products may be presented as <strong>stimulus</strong> for certain target personas. Presence in the touchpoint is a real test for the brand, how far the stimulus, for example, taglines, visuals or products really work to produce consumer’s <strong>actual</strong> <strong>response</strong> as intended by the producer.</p><p>Brand strategy description is a formulation of <strong>intended responses</strong> (levels 3–4) by the producer. It consists of brand <strong>personality</strong>, a cluster of traits that producer wants target consumers perceive from the brand; and brand <strong>positioning</strong>, a statement of what the brand is about, and how, whom and why it is able to serve them with certain emotional and functional benefits.</p><p>To make a<strong> thick description of brand strategy </strong>we<strong> </strong>would need to go further down the zoom-lens levels to involve <strong>theme </strong>(level 2) and <strong>product design</strong> (levels 0–2). Theme is a thematic platform for organizing various stimulus that a brand may exploit to embody its personality and positioning in the touchpoint. This is for the purpose of both brand communication and product design. The thickness of brand strategy should help both brand team and product designers to understand which elements should be present in the stimulus for embodying the brand. More about brand strategy jargon can be read in this article by <a href="https://link.medium.com/27o1xZpR61">Paramita Mohamad</a>.</p><h3>UX design jargon</h3><p>A well-formed thick description of brand strategy should align with product design. This is to make sure all important elements that embody the brand are present in the product. The real test for product design is when it is present as stimulus in user’s touchpoint: how far it is appealing, relevant and fit the identity of target persona.</p><p>UX design jargon provides us with conceptual tools for building a design that could connect with persona. The concepts below are jargon adopted from Don Norman’s fundamental principles of interaction. For more, read Don’s book: The Design of Everyday Things (2013). This is how we can understand them using social semiotic zoom-lens.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tr_G8TWUWEqDh--7mKAR7g.png" /><figcaption>UX design jargon in social semiotic zoom-lens</figcaption></figure><p>Conceptual model is a simplified explanation of how and why something works. It can be found in product manuals, product campaigns or other form of stimulus in potential touchpoints. Conceptual model is a thematic platform (level 2) both for designing and communicating the product for target persona.</p><p>For brand communication purposes the challenge is how the target personas could form mental model of the product that is inline with brand strategy. In UX design conceptual model helps to guide decisions on which features or functionalities (level 1) should be included in priority list. It also guides the use of affordances, signifiers and constraints (level 0) in design process.</p><p>For further discussion about this topic, you can reach me through eric@mcinsights.co</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d87cdea05a0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxdesign.cc/understanding-brand-and-ux-jargon-using-object-oriented-ethnography-6d87cdea05a0">Understanding brand and UX jargon using object-oriented ethnography</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxdesign.cc/">UX Collective</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A learning from object-oriented ethnography to help guiding UX design]]></title>
            <link>https://uxdesign.cc/a-learning-from-object-oriented-ethnography-to-help-guiding-ux-design-e5dfa324a282?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e5dfa324a282</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[product-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thick-description]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethnography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Nov 2019 04:41:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-16T05:05:34.725Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As ethnographer working with products, I use object-oriented thick descriptions of product use for identifying UX personas and use cases. The thickness helps to explain how and why users do or do not adopt particular products. Here’s how they can be useful for guiding product design process.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*rIswjYIBKDhUzTo6" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@kerensa1?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Kerensa Pickett</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I am an ethnographer helping clients with consumer insights for improving products. I don’t consider myself a UX designer or researcher. However, when I receive briefs on product research from clients, I believe, my first response is similar to that of UX designers. The first question that I have in mind is which possible model consumers or personas would be happy to use the product. As object-oriented ethnographer my task is to provide consumer insights by identifying possible painpoints and elements of appeal, relevance and identity to increase the likelihood of happy adoption of the products. This is to help fine-tuning product concepts or prototypes.</p><p>I may say that I’m a product experience generalist. I have worked almost two decades with wide variety of product categories, ranging from consumer goods, banking, telco, hospital, public facilities, movies, education, and lately, digital apps. In spite of this variety the analytical tools I use for helping client fine-tuning product concepts or prototypes is always the same; and constructing personas and use cases has been an essential part of my work.</p><p>Note: in this article consumers, users or customers are terms that I used interchangeably depending on the contexts and cases of product categories being discussed. Similarly the term user experience (UX), customer experience (CX) or product experience are used interchangeably. For example, in case of mobile apps I would use the term user, while in banking service contexts the term customer. Consumer is general term that encompass both.</p><h3>A very brief introduction to object-oriented ethnography and thick descriptions</h3><p>Object-oriented ethnography (OOE) is a discipline for observing how communities of consumers experience particular objects in their ecosystem. It aims to explain product experience: total content of appearance of a product from consumer’s first-person or community-insider’s point of view. The main task of OOE is to help outsiders to see how objects appear from insider’s point of view through constructing <em>thick descriptions</em> of product use.</p><p>Thick description is an insider’s meaningful explanation of products use by providing contexts of the ecosystem. The thickness helps to explain how and why consumers do or do not adopt particular products. It can be illustrated using five (0–4) vertical levels of semiotic zoom lens below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jMlMeWArrz9dZ3DhhhhUXw.png" /><figcaption>Semiotic zoom lens for constructing thick descriptions of product use Involving all five levels (0–4)</figcaption></figure><p>We can find tangible product at the lowest zoom-in (level 0). It is part of consumers ecosystem that is operated as tools or materials for undertaking actions; while scripts are consumers’ mental representations of how they may operate the products in particular contexts. Different products may have similar use (action-intention, level 1) but different operations (product-script, level 0). For example the use of three chairs below are for sitting. All variants of chair afford sitting. However the way we operate them maybe different. Other than sitting, each product variant has different variety of affordances.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cHwpeLKIgN_baIE7dwQWmA.png" /><figcaption>Three chairs with similar product uses (for sitting) but different operations and affordances</figcaption></figure><p>Using the Victorian chair (A) we can rest our arms on both sides. The other two variants have different affordances. Unlike the Victorian, we cannot rest our arms at the stackable or the bean-bag chair. However, the bean-bag (C) may allow us to sit in a more relax postures, while the stackable (B) can be stacked with one another when not in use.</p><p>We can find product use description (desc 0–1) in digital apps as well. For example in one app we may find use instruction as follows: “tap the plus-button, and then tap the amount or type the number to put your small change in the virtual piggy-bank; and then if the piggy-bank balance has reached a minimum of 5 dollar, tap the invest-now-button to buy the ETF.” Another similar app which does not have virtual piggy-bank may have different operations, and may not allow users to accumulate small change before buying ETF.</p><p>This use instruction involves both product-scripts (level 0) and action-intentions (level 1). We can see that for product-use instruction to be meaningful for users it has to involve action-intentions such as “to put small change in virtual piggy bank”, or “to buy the ETF (exchange-traded funds).” If otherwise the action-intention contexts are stripped off, the use instructions would be meaningless.</p><p>Product use description is thin (desc 0–1). It does not help to explain why and how users adopt the product. To make it thicker we would need to add context of activity and its motive (level 2). The above use instruction example is how user may operate an app to undertake action of buying an ETF in an investing activity. General motive of this activity is profit.</p><p>In user’s ecosystem there are many other background motives that may add different nuances to this product use motive. These can be observed through possible inter-connected activities in user’s ecosystem. A young mom (family community-role, level 3) using the investment app definitely has motive (level 2) of profits. However, she also may have another motive (level 2) of caregiving with plans for the finance of education for her two kids. When she uses the investing app she might not be willing to take more risk for gaining bigger profits. She might perceive the action of buying ETF more like saving, rather than investing. Compare for example with a young male startup entrepreneur whose motive is winning business competitions. He might be willing to take more risk for gaining bigger profits. These two cases illustrate two different thicker descriptions or use cases (description 0–2) of the same product.</p><h3>A well-formed thick description of product use</h3><p>We can describe use case (desc 0 — 2) when we embed thin product use (desc 0 — 1) within certain product use motives (level 2). This defines the category of the product. To construct a well-formed thick description we need to embed the use case further up the levels to involve personas. Elements in level 3 and 4 can be used as spectrums for constructing personas. A ‘young mom living in Jakarta’ for example may be a good start to describe one persona. This description (desc 3-4) involves a mom (family community-role, level 3), who is young (trait, level 4), living in Jakarta (social group, level 4).</p><p>This is still thin. To be useful for design process it should be thicker involving persona motives (level 2) as well. This persona motives work as background contexts for product use motive. We could add one word ‘working’ to the persona description to involve activity-motive: ‘young working mom living in Jakarta’ (desc 2–4). This indicates an activity whose motive is productivity. The word mom also indicates at least one other relevant activity besides working, ie. caregiving (level 2) whose motive may be love. Combining both persona (desc 2 — 4) and use case (desc 0–2) descriptions as shown below constitutes a well-formed thick description.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*34rY4YInilPK-GEjMlIoBg.png" /><figcaption>Well-formed thick description involving possible personas, product use cases &amp; touchpoints</figcaption></figure><p>We could see that descriptions of personas (desc 2 — 4) and product use cases (desc 0 — 2) have overlaps or touchpoints at level 2. Touchpoints are social occasions in the ecosystem where product and persona motives may interact. Within touchpoints we could identify various use cases with background persona motives. The three chair variants (A) Victorian, (B) stackable, and (C) bean-bag below maybe relevant for persona X, Y and Z. Possible touchpoint X-A for example could be in the office where X has certain roles in a big company. Within this touchpoint we could observe &amp; identify possible use cases (X-A-1, X-A-2…., X-A-n).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RS3naWPsofVxeVaDWCymYw.png" /><figcaption>Three chair-variants possible product use cases and touchpoints for three different personas</figcaption></figure><p>The aim of using OOE at this stage of design process is to find elements of relevance, appeal and identity of the product that may be present in the touchpoints and may increase the likelihood of happy product adoptions by the persona. These elements may vary for different personas. The Victorian chair variant (A) for example may have elements of identity that fit for persona X (man in tuxedo) to state his identity that he is not a regular guy in the office (persona motive). Possible use cases might be in touchpoints where he receives guests. The same elements however may not fit the identity of persona Y (young working mom) and Z (young man in casual wear) who may be present in the same office.</p><h3>Using thick descriptions for service design</h3><p>We may use thick descriptions not only for product but also for service design. For this we need first to understand where service use is ‘located’ in the semiotic zoom-lens. Service is cluster of inter-connected actions (level 1) offered by providers to help customers in doing their activities (level 2). Service use descriptions (levels 1–2) would need to involve tangible products that are used by providers and/or customers as tools (levels 0–1) for conducting the actions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7DuPTjDs89v9Lgg-kVJ2Dg.png" /><figcaption>Thick description of use cases involving service use, tool use, and background ecosystem of personas</figcaption></figure><p>Consider for example bank account services. Saving account service consists of inter-connected actions offered by bank to help customers saving their money with certain background motives (levels 1–2). To make the saving account service works it would need tools like a passbook which records the customers deposits and withdrawals (levels 0–1). The passbook (level 0) will be needed each time customers make cash deposits or withdrawals (level 1). The on-ground touchpoint (level 2) of saving account service using passbook is at branch office counters where customers meet bank tellers.</p><p>The availability of new technology in customers ecosystem may create more touchpoints and extend the scope of the service. Electronic data technology for example makes it possible for banks to extend the touchpoints of saving account service by providing debit cards (level 0). For customers this tool allows new service affordances to make cash deposits, withdrawals, transfers or other actions (level 1) at ATMs outside bank office touchpoints (level 2).</p><p>The technology also allows banks to extend its service to include cashless payments using EDC machines at merchant counters. For customers debit card may afford easier payments. Here we need to realize that there are two interrelated service categories (levels 0–2) involving debit card as tool: saving and payments, each with different set of possible use touchpoints.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9kE1MPE19pt_823GQISVxg.png" /><figcaption>On-ground and on-mind touchpoints of debit cards for three personas</figcaption></figure><p>Although these descriptions of service &amp; tool use involve levels 0–2, they are not thick enough. To make a useful service use case description we would need to construct persona description using spectrums in levels 3 and 4. An example of use case: a young working mom (persona Y) withdraws cash to fill her wallet (Y-A-1-Card) using debit card (service A) at the ATM in a convenience store (<strong>on-ground</strong> touchpoint Y-A). She shops in the store but chooses to pay cash, not cashless using debit card (Y-A-2-No-Card).</p><p>To explain why the debit card is not used for payment we would need to observe the <strong>on-mind </strong>touchpoint (Y-A). On-mind touchpoint is ‘social ocassion’ in customer’s awareness which consists of persona motives and their ecosystem that serve as background contexts for debit card use. The young working mom chooses not to swipe debit card at the EDC to pay for her daily shop in the store (Y-A-2-No-Card). This is to allocate and limit spending to make sure she still has money until next paycheck in upcoming month (background persona motives). She only has one saving account where she receives her monthly salary. Her debit card is connected to this saving account (digital ecosystem). For her, ‘easier payments’ with EDC affords painpoint experience: failure to manage her money until next paycheck. This prevents Y from using cashless payment with debit card.</p><h3>Using thick descriptions for mobile app UX design</h3><p>We could locate mobile app in the semiotic zoom-lens at level 0 as a tool used (desc 0–1) for delivering services (desc 1–2). Unlike debit cards and passbooks, digital mobile apps in smartphone allow more service affordances depending how they are designed. In this case we need to consider that this technology has created online digital ecosystems. A mobile app is like a building architecture inside of which many more features or functions can be found.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OUsALeJsg3nNdaaZ4UoZmg.png" /><figcaption>On-mind touchpoints and elements of relevance of e-wallets</figcaption></figure><p>Digital touchpoint is the occasion in the ecosystem where users face the screen and use apps installed inside a smartphone in particular on-ground touchpoint. An app use motive in a digital touchpoint (level 2) defines the category of service the app affords. For example an e-wallet app may afford use motives of small fund allocations and payments at small merchants using QR codes. To make a well-formed thick description of e-wallet use we need to construct persona using spectrums from levels 3–4. To explain why and how the persona use e-wallet we also need to identify on-mind touchpoint in users awareness in which some persona motives (level 2) may work as backgrounds for e-walllet use.</p><p>Observing this on-mind touchpoint is important for finding app feature that may serve as elements of relevance, appeal and identity for certain personas. The young working mom from the above example maybe happy to use e-wallet app for cashless payment at merchant counters. We could explain this adoption since e-wallet affords allocations of fund that may allow more control on spending. The e-wallet balance becomes the element of relevance that serves as smaller saving accounts in which she could allocate some portions of her salary for certain objectives.</p><p>For further discussion about this topic, you can reach me through eric@mcinsights.co</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e5dfa324a282" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxdesign.cc/a-learning-from-object-oriented-ethnography-to-help-guiding-ux-design-e5dfa324a282">A learning from object-oriented ethnography to help guiding UX design</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxdesign.cc/">UX Collective</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Good UX designs require three things to achieve]]></title>
            <link>https://uxdesign.cc/good-ux-designs-require-three-things-to-achieve-a447f10e813d?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a447f10e813d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[semiotics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[experience-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 May 2019 12:33:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-16T05:06:01.934Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>This is what I, as a new comer, learned from UX clichés and UX 101.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*2luI5A-epS886_WA8MJgCg@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Can you figure out how the above objects can possibly be used? (Downloaded from<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lydia"> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lydi</a>a)</figcaption></figure><p>I was struggling to get myself understand conversations in UX. As a newcomer, I read articles of various UX publications in Medium and Don Norman’s book, “The design of everyday things,” as my UX 101. The question that stuck in my mind in learning UX was this: what do good UX designs require to achieve? I found there was no simple answer to it.</p><p>In my previous years researching how people experience consumer goods and other non-digital products I have found semiotics useful for understanding what good product designs need to achieve. What I would like to share here is my re-reading on Don’s principles of interaction using Peircean Semiotics as analytical tool for helping me clarify what good UX is like. A very brief introduction to semiotics can be read in my article: “<a href="https://link.medium.com/2ub8Oxrk1W">On deconstructing experience</a>.”</p><h4>What makes good experience?</h4><p>Three concepts from Don’s principles of interaction help to define good experience:</p><ul><li>Affordance</li><li>Feedback</li><li>System images</li></ul><p>To understand why and how they are important we will start from the concept of experience in Peircean Semiotics.</p><p>Experience is the total content of <em>appearances</em> of an object from user’s first-person point of views. It is indeed subjective but not impossible to understand and to design if we use appropriate analytical tools. Peircean Semiotics tells us that there are two important facets of this appearance when a user or consumer encounters an object: the <em>firsts</em>, the possible attributes of the attended object, and the <em>seconds</em>, the reactions from real encounters with it.</p><p><em>Firsts</em> (1sts) is the equivalent of what Don calls <em>affordance</em>. It is how the object could possibly used, the actions that the attended object affords for a user. However, the concept of firsts encompasses not only <em>actions</em>, but also <em>senses</em>. When we encounter a cake for example it affords us actions like “eating” and also senses like “sweet, sour, bitter, etc.” In short, it is a universe of all possible attributes, sense-actions of the attended object, taken for granted as “true facts” from user’s first-person point of view.</p><p><em>Seconds</em> (2nds) is the equivalent of what Don calls <em>feedbacks</em>. It is the reactions we receive from real encounters with objects <em>as brute facts</em>. Seconds may <em>seamlessly flow</em> with the firsts, as we really taste the sweet-sourness when we bite the cake. Or it may <em>disrupt</em> our cake‘s affordances such as “eating” when it turns out to be a hard, not-eatable object.</p><p>In semiotics both firsts and seconds are called the <em>unmediated</em> experience since they result from immediate encounters with an object. Greater portion of the total content of these unmediated appearance cannot be captured into human awareness or be made intelligible by using words, visuals, voices or any other <em>signifiers</em>. Most of them are fleeting into either <em>subconsciousness</em> or <em>unconsciousness</em>.</p><p>This reminds me of what I learned from Fabricio’s <a href="https://link.medium.com/tgmg4xdm0W">list of UX clichés</a> about good UX:</p><blockquote>“A user interface is like a joke; if you have to explain it, it’s not that good”</blockquote><p>This expression is very true indeed. Minimum requirements for Good UX is when the attended object can deliver <em>seamless flow</em> of affordances and feedbacks, even when users <em>do not have words to explain it</em>. Words may freeze and break the flow of experience. A well-designed object would look natural, intuitive, and do not need any explanations.</p><h4>Representations of well-designed object</h4><p>To achieve this seamless flow of experience, however, we would need to consider one other facet of experience: the <em>thirds</em>. This is the equivalent of Don’s <em>system images</em>. It is the appearance of an object <em>mediated</em> by signifiers: symbols, index, and icons.</p><p>The signifiers work to capture the fleeting experience into human awareness by forming <em>representations</em> of the attended object in user’s mind. System image is the content of this representation. It is a subjective mental imagery represented in user’s mind that allows learning and habituations in using the object.</p><p>A well-designed object would enable users through its signifiers to form relevant representations, the system images. Good experience happens when the representations can establish<em> relevance</em> with user’s previous experience, and at the same time deliver some rewarding <em>novelties</em>.</p><p>It is important to observe spontaneous representations formed in user’s first-person point of views since it would influence <em>possible range of affordances</em> when the user encounters the object. These representations <em>can be different for different user segments.</em> For example, consider the picture above at the beginning of this article. What affordances may appear in user’s mind? Modern users in general may say that it is a coin that might be useful for exchange, but it may not give feedbacks as real money that we could use in modern day reality.</p><p>A Game of Thrones fan may say that it maybe a fictional coin of House Stark of Winterfell, since the symbols is similar to Stark’s sigil. For her, this coin may not induce any affordances other than for imaginations. However, a numismatist (who study and collect coins) may recognize this as something invaluable: it is a gold coin from 6th century BCE Kingdom of Lydia of western Anatolia in Asia Minor. For a numismatist this coin may afford many possible sense-actions like collecting, valuable, auctions, etc.</p><p>The three things that make good experience can be described in a scheme like below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*he2PqTKsOvN3KRMmufgbZA.png" /><figcaption>Seamless flow of experience, involving unmediated firsts, seconds, and mediated thirds</figcaption></figure><p>One important process that makes the thirds possible is signification. The question is how could a symbol or an icon function as signifier for an object? Signification consists of <em>frequent pairings of an icon and a feedback </em>in users’ previous experience. Take for example the now-ubiquitous hamburger button. Almost in any apps we can find this button. It signifies the toggling (collapsed-displayed) of a menu or navigation bar. By itself this icon is meaningless. It acquires its status as signifier because every time users tap this icon it gives feedback by displaying or collapsing menus.</p><p>This signification only works with those who have previous experience of using mobile apps or internet browsers frequently. It is important to understand this previous presence and pairings of icon-feedback in user’s life conditions. This understanding can only be achieved through systematic observations on relevant significations that are already taken for granted as “true” in certain cultures.</p><h4>How can good experience be designed?</h4><p>Good UX requires these three things to achieve seamless flows: affordances, feedbacks, and system images. The question now is how can it be designed? User experience can be designed through reconstructing the signifiers in a graphical user interface to help users forming <em>intended </em>representations or system images.</p><p>Before doing the reconstructions we need to make decisions on the intended representations. It is a business decision that is important for connecting the planned app with potential target users.</p><p>Here are the three steps we need to follow for reconstructing signifiers:</p><ol><li>Choose symbols or icons that may already function as signifiers from users’ previous experience. If we are not sure we need to conduct research to observe the significations in target users’ life;</li><li>Prototype the app by using the chosen icons, symbols in the user interface to signify intended affordances and feedbacks. We need to compose the chosen signifiers to help users form the intended representations. We can prepare several alternative routes of prototype for testing;</li><li>Test the prototypes to see if the intended representations emerge in users’ mind by observing <em>spontaneous </em>responses when they encounter the UI.</li></ol><p>Let’s take an example to illustrate how these steps can be done. Consider the UI of an investing app below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zF3HppAL0uppLQlGD3F9Fw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Piggy-bank as metaphor, the intended representations or system image of an investing app</figcaption></figure><p>The intended representation of this app is piggy-bank. It serves as metaphor that guide the reconstruction of signifiers that can be found in the UI. The app aims to help users to collect small amount of money each time they make transactions in merchant’s point of sales. This small amount is a round-up of total amount of purchase by the user.</p><p>These round-ups can be collected into a virtual piggy-bank. This is represented by a circle in which a collected amount is shown. Putting this circle in the UI was a conscious decision. It is meant to mimic the rounded form of real piggy-bank that users maybe already familiar with.</p><p>Just like in real piggy-bank, users can add the amount by tapping the plus button at the right-bottom of the UI. After reaching the minimum amount of $5 the piggy-bank can be emptied by tapping the invest-now button, and the amount will be invested. Total amount of money a user has invested from this piggy-bank is shown in the number at the upper side of the UI.</p><p>This investing app has been active in several markets like the US, Europe and Australia. When it was first tested in Indonesia, the respondents spontaneously remarked that this app is an online <em>celengan</em>. <em>Celengan</em> is piggy-bank in Indonesian language. This proved that potential users in Indonesia may experience the virtual piggy-bank seamlessly.</p><p>That is all I learned about what makes a good UX from cliches and 101. Hope this helps UX communities to have further productive discussions.</p><p>For further discussion about this topic, you can reach me through eric@mcinsights.co</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a447f10e813d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxdesign.cc/good-ux-designs-require-three-things-to-achieve-a447f10e813d">Good UX designs require three things to achieve</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxdesign.cc/">UX Collective</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to avoid making more UX clichés]]></title>
            <link>https://uxdesign.cc/how-to-avoid-making-more-ux-clich%C3%A9s-2b32314f886f?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b32314f886f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[user-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[semiotics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research-method]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 May 2019 06:10:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-16T05:06:32.771Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>An expression becomes cliché since it is quite often used, yet lacking clarity. To avoid making more UX clichés we need to ‘unpack’ the X part of the UX and learn how the concept can be useful to deliver novelty.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4rBR97JreFhdu15m" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@edhoradic?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Edho Pratama</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I’m a new comer in UX. I have spent my previous years more in qualitative consumer research. Reading Fabricio Teixeira’s “<a href="https://link.medium.com/iNolV9y3yW">A comprehensive (and honest) list of UX clichés</a>” (and all the responses) it makes me wonder why they become clichés.</p><p>After reading through all the list I come to realize that most of them, directly or indirectly, have to do with lack of clarity on the concept of experience. In UX the word seems too elusive despite its very common usage. I will share my point of view about some of the clichés in the list, borrowing from semiotics, the analytical tools that I use in analyzing how people experience consumer goods.</p><h4>#1 cliché, that struck me most: on designing subjective experience</h4><blockquote>“You can’t design an experience; <strong><em>experiences are too subjective</em></strong> to be designed”</blockquote><blockquote>An argument used by coworkers who are running out of things to say but somehow still want to sound smart.</blockquote><p>Fabricio‘s coworkers who say this argument must be non designers, since it betrays a UX designer’s work. Similar expressions can be found in Donald Norman’s book, The Design of Everyday Things (2013):</p><blockquote>“Engineers tend not to like it; <strong><em>it (experience) is too subjective</em></strong>. But when I ask them about their favorite automobile…they will smile delightedly as they discuss… the sensation of power during acceleration, their ease of control while shifting or steering, or the wonderful feel of the knobs and switches on the instrument. <strong><em>Those are experiences</em></strong>.” (Norman, 2013: 26 — 27; emphasize, mine).</blockquote><p>A quick search in Don’s book produces quite many: 114 mentions of the word ‘experience.’ Compare with <a href="https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=experience%2Cresearch%2Cdesign%2Cuser%2Ctechnology&amp;year_start=1700&amp;year_end=2008&amp;corpus=15&amp;smoothing=3&amp;share=&amp;direct_url=t1%3B%2Cexperience%3B%2Cc0%3B.t1%3B%2Cresearch%3B%2Cc0%3B.t1%3B%2Cdesign%3B%2Cc0%3B.t1%3B%2Cuser%3B%2Cc0%3B.t1%3B%2Ctechnology%3B%2Cc0">Google book corpus here</a>. Unfortunately for us we cannot find any systematic or adequate discussions on ‘experience’ in this book.</p><p>An expression would become cliché when it is quite often used, yet lacking clarity and fail to deliver novelty. The word ‘experience’ is like a black box that cannot be opened. We cannot see what’s inside, yet cannot avoid using it.</p><p>To avoid making more UX clichés we need to ‘unpack’ the X part of the UX and learn how the concept can be useful. I have written how we can do this in two of my articles: “<a href="https://link.medium.com/KMFgmhjFBW">What we really mean by ‘experience’ in UX</a>”, and “<a href="https://link.medium.com/S6JPExnFBW">How Semiotics Can Help Building Better UX</a>.”</p><p>Experience is the <strong>total content of appearance of an object </strong>from<strong> user’s first-person point of view</strong>. It is indeed subjective but not too subjective so that we cannot learn how things are like from user’s first-person point of views.</p><p><strong>Subjective experience can be designed</strong> if we have appropriate approach and analytical tools. For example, semiotics can be useful for designing user experience through reconstructing signifiers. Successful signifier reconstructions would help users to form what Don Norman called a system image.</p><p>Regardless which approach we adopt, to do this we need to open our mind and <strong>put ourselves in user’s position in relations to the attended object</strong>. In other words, what we need to do here is <strong>empathy</strong>. It is a non-negotiable requirement for any ergonomic design.</p><h4>#2 cliché: on lack of empathy</h4><blockquote>“You are not your user”</blockquote><blockquote>A reminder that you are not designing the product for people like yourself. Often used as a way to encourage more user research in a project.</blockquote><p>I don’t really understand why this expression has become a cliché. If it is, it would only mean that, like experience, empathy has lost its meaning for UX designers. This expression need to be used more often with clarity how empathy can be done and useful.</p><p>Research is indeed essential for delivering quality UX. However, to do empathy we don’t need to wait until a costly research is conducted. Empathy is required even before we think of doing research. What we can expect from UX research, if conducted properly, is fine-tuning our empathy using systematic observations.</p><p>“You are not your user” is for us to become good designer, not to encourage more UX research. It’s a waste of money to do research without empathy.</p><p>The surest way to waste money in bad UX research with no empathy is to ask what they want.</p><h4>#3 cliché: on bad UX research</h4><blockquote>“If Henry Ford had asked people what they wanted, they would have told him faster horses”</blockquote><blockquote>Used as a counter-argument to the previous statement, when you start to realize you won’t have time or money to do enough user research.</blockquote><p>This expression is very true but cannot be useful. It should be used only as reminder of bad UX research.</p><p>Good UX research would try to avoid asking user’s opinion <em>about</em>, what they want <em>from</em> the object being attended to. It would also avoid relying too much on user’s verbal report on her own experiences with it.</p><p>To avoid bad UX research, we need to learn a bit further about ‘experience’ as content of appearance of an object. Of the total content of appearance only very small portions can be captured consciously in human perceptual field. Larger portions of what we experience are fleeting into unconsciousness or oblivion in split seconds the moment after the encounter between users mind and the attended object.</p><p>When we bite a cake, for example, how it appears to us consumers is much more than the sum of those that can be captured by words like sweet, sour, bitter or any other signifiers. These signifiers help to capture the fleeting experiences into awareness, make them intelligible to ourselves and other people who share similar significations.</p><p>However, the imageries or discourses represented in user’s awareness using these signifiers are not identical to the real experience itself. Users may not have adequate vocabularies to make their experience with objects intelligible. It is the task of researchers and designers, not users, to observe and probe how they experience the object.</p><p>Asking users their opinions will only yield what they know and rationalize, not what they experience or what they want. It’s not that users are stupid. It’s because they are human. UX research which relies more on asking user’s opinions would yield misleading results.</p><h4>#4 Cliché: on indecisive UX design</h4><blockquote>“Let the users decide”</blockquote><blockquote>None of us is going to win this endless argument, so we should take this to c̶o̶u̶r̶t̶ user testing. But I’m still going to prove you wrong at the end.</blockquote><p>Let’s be clear on what we could NOT expect from UX research. Any research, even a good one, can never cure indecisiveness. It can only be cured by strategic thinking and leadership.</p><p>This expression “let users decide” is not useful at all. It only indicates misunderstandings on what is a good UX research, and how it can be useful for delivering a winning design.</p><p>UX research is not the same as opinion polls where users are asked to decide which candidate is better. Like the Henry Ford apocrypha, opinion polls will only yield “better horse” responses.</p><p>A good UX research would include setting-up experimental conditions and stimulus that allow users to perform spontaneous responses. It would also allow researchers to observe and collect the responses. Quality data in UX research consists of signifiers spontaneously used and practices spontaneously performed by users when an object is presented to them.</p><p>What we could expect from UX research with quality data is insights on how far a UX design is relevant and appealing for potential users. This is achieved through analysis by comparing data from various set of responses.</p><p>A winning UX design can be concluded from this, only if there are clear strategic decisions on the priorities to achieve. Conducting UX research for curing indecisiveness will only lead into more confusions.</p><p>For further discussion about this topic, you can reach me through eric@mcinsights.co</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b32314f886f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxdesign.cc/how-to-avoid-making-more-ux-clich%C3%A9s-2b32314f886f">How to avoid making more UX clichés</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxdesign.cc/">UX Collective</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Semiotics Can Help Building Better UX: On Deconstructing Experience]]></title>
            <link>https://blog.prototypr.io/how-semiotics-can-help-us-in-ux-on-deconstructing-experience-eaf3e55fb0e1?source=rss-747da965b43e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eaf3e55fb0e1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[experience-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[semiotics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[financial-app]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eric Santosa]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Apr 2019 13:25:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-16T05:07:06.113Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xYcsxgy4SKX23I8k" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@alex_andrews?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Alexander Andrews</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Experience is the stuff that both researchers and designers need to attend to. A designer must really understand how intended users might experience her design. Whatever it is, at the end of the day, she would want the outcome to be <em>relevant</em> and <em>appealing </em>experience, to <em>engage</em> with whoever audience she has in mind.</p><p>The same is true, I believe, for researchers. A UX researcher would want the knowledge, the outcome of her research to be useful and insightful for design process. To achieve this, she would need <em>analytical tools</em>, sharp enough to observe and <em>deconstruct</em> the experience people have with digital apps to find relevance and potential appeal from user’s first-person point of views.</p><p>In my years as qualitative consumer researcher, and a newbie in UX, semiotics has been quite useful analytical tool for deconstructing and reconstructing people’s experience with products. It’s not only limited to experience with tangible consumer goods but also with intangibles such as movies, education, telco, banking or insurance products.</p><p>Semiotics helps me first to ask the right questions for study, to direct what to observe, and to find relevance and potential appeal for consumers or users. My intention here is to share how it can also be useful for deconstructing user’s experience with digital apps.</p><h4>A Very Brief Introduction to Semiotics and Experience</h4><p>Semiotics is the study of signs (from the Greek <em>sēmeîon</em>, ‘sign’). It is relations in which an object ‘stands for’ or <em>signifies</em> another object. The word ‘tree’ signifies a tree. Here, ‘tree’ works as <em>signifier</em> to signify a material <em>referent</em>, an attended object. However ‘tree’ can also signify ‘Baum’, a German word for tree. Object in this case is not necessarily material referents, but can also be non-material: imaginations, ideas, or social objects.</p><p>This process of <em>signification</em> helps an interpreting agent to <em>represent</em> the tree, to form non-material interpretant, ideas or mental imageries of the attended object in her mind. It allows human agents to learn, to form habits, to take actions on external reality. In brief, semiotics is the study of how human mind makes sense of its <em>experience</em> in the world of objects (Tap here for more on <a href="https://link.medium.com/zOmVxz67lW">the concept of ‘experience</a>’).</p><p>Semiotics tells us that <em>semiosis </em>(from Greek <em>sēmeîōsis: </em>observation of signs)<em>, </em>the sense-making is always <em>mediated</em> by signifiers. We can say that they are <em>tools</em> for making sense of human <em>experience</em> in her world. It is something we cannot live without for making reality intelligible for ourselves and other people who <em>shared</em> similar significations.</p><p>The structure of experience <em>mediated</em> by signifiers can be schematically described as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZB2DGsONqckf3knDT1GZJQ.png" /><figcaption>Triadic (3rds) Experience — Mediated by Signifiers</figcaption></figure><p>This is what CS Peirce, the founder of semiotics, called the triadic experience, or the thirds (3rds). This facet of experience is essential for human <em>learning</em>, <em>habit</em> forming and <em>communication</em>. The triadic happens the moments we name the attended objects using words and make the experience <em>intelligible</em> for ourselves or friends.</p><p>There are two other facets of experience, the <em>unmediateds</em>: the firsts (1sts) or monadic, and the seconds or dyadic experience. The firsts is the facet that allows us to <em>recognize</em> the <em>possible</em> <em>qualities </em>for sense and action on objects. When we see a tree we somehow ‘know’ it is a hard object, something that you could lean yourself on. This is an equivalent of what Donald Norman called <em>affordances</em>.</p><p>The seconds (2nds) is the facet when our five senses encounter actual objects in the world. This actuality allows <em>reactions</em>, <em>feedbacks</em> from the objects. You would get feedbacks and be surprised when the tree turns out to be void, so that you could not lean yourselves on it.</p><p>The thing about this unmediated experience is that it’s fleeting. It happens in split seconds in streams of experience. Signifiers allow us to capture and represent it to our mind. The moment we name or capture the experience with words, it stops being unmediated. It would then mediated by signifiers, words or images that we use for making the experience intelligible for both ourselves and other people.</p><h4>Experiencing Tangible vs Intangible Objects</h4><p>For doing semiotic deconstructions it is important to notice the different nature between experiencing intangible objects like digital apps, and tangibles such as consumer goods. When we bite a cake, for example, almost all its possible qualities for sense-actions (the 1sts) are immediately actualized. This actuality provides reactions and feedbacks (2nds) for us consumers through all the sensations in our mouth. This is not the case with intangible objects.</p><p>When a user gaze at the front UI of an app on her smartphone screen, she may ‘know’ all possible qualities for sense-actions of the app (1sts). However, unless properly designed, these possible qualities will not be immediately actualized to give her reactions, feedbacks (2nds). The app, the attended object will remain hidden.</p><p>A digital app is more like a universe hidden inside a museum building. The front UI is like a front door of the building. The app is a <em>gestalt</em> that is more than the sum of all the UIs. To really experience the universe, a guest must enter and interact with objects in the building.</p><p>At the front door we may put a signifier ‘history of middle-age Europe’ to help potential guests to imagine possible qualities they may experience in the museum. Inside the building there may be more signifiers to help people to experience various elements of the universe. The challenge of UX then is to design signifiers and tools both <em>inside</em> and <em>outside</em> the building to help guests to experience various elements of the universe.</p><h4>Deconstructing UX</h4><p>The purpose of semiotic deconstructions is to make ourselves aware of our own and other people’s experience from first-person point of views. In the context of UX, it is to identify relevant significations and representations of various elements of an app that results from users previous learning and habits in their familiar ecosystems.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*AMLJ46l4SNU_qyQTBVanEA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Front UI as Initial Signifier</figcaption></figure><p>Let’s start a tiny case of app experience deconstruction. Consider now an app with front UI like the above picture. Imagine we present it to potential users, and ask what words or images come spontaneously into their mind. The resulting responses are all possible categories: objects, actions and senses that it may signify for the users.</p><p>The front UI signifies the app as a <em>gestalt</em>. It works as <em>initial</em> signifier that open the access for us to understand the experience they may have in the app. Users may respond like: money, saving, investing, ‘grow your money’, wallet, shopping, high-risk, short-term profit, big money, etc. These are <em>relevant significations</em> associated with the front UI that result from users’ previous learnings, habits in life ecosystems as they know it.</p><p>We can analyze these responses using <em>semiotic zoom lens </em>below by putting individual responses, either as attended objects, signifiers, or sense-actions. In this illustration, there are two pairs of signification: one inside-app involving micro object [front-UI— {sign} — investment-app], and one outside-app involving macro object [investment-app— {sign} —money ].</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eDyv6DprsexZXKCzc06WJg.png" /><figcaption>Semiotic Zoom-Lens for Deconstructing Inside- and Outside-App Experience</figcaption></figure><p>All other responses may be put as either micro or macro sense-actions. Micro sense-actions are those qualities that can be immediately actualized by interacting with UIs inside the app; while macros are those that investing money ‘affords’ or potentially can actualize outside the app.</p><p>Comparing these macro and micro sense-actions we can identify potential disruptions that the investing app may be able to deliver in users investing activities. For example we may find ‘investment’ in macro signifies: [user — {exp: high-risk, bankrupt, big-money, short-term-profit} — money]. These are sense-actions that users have experienced {exp} from outside-app previous learning in their life ecosystems.</p><p>In contrast the micro may be <em>contradicting</em> the macro. The front-UI signifies [user — {exp: risk, small-money, long-term-gain, ease-of-buy-sell-stock} — investing-app]. The app may potentially disrupt what users have learnt about investment from their previous experience. This contradictions of sense-action may become the app’s main appeal for certain user segments.</p><h4>Zooming-Out of the App: Archetypes Represented</h4><p>The macro sense-actions are important for identifying <em>representations</em> of what is relevant, what habits have been formed regarding money, and what users have learnt about investing from their familiar life ecosystems. All these outside-app categories: objects and sense-actions, can be analyzed into clusters like below to learn in a broader perspective what <em>archetypes</em> are represented in users mind about investment [user — {rep} — investment].</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yOZ3-DOC3VvZGXufawtXpg.png" /><figcaption>Clusters of Outside-App Signification Around Money</figcaption></figure><p>Archetype is <em>thematic</em> complexes of life discourse and practices that is represented through images and words. In semiotics, archetype is the interpretant, the mental imageries in users mind that is represented by signifiers. The above clusters are generated from spontaneous word-associations around three verbal signifiers of three money activities: buying-selling stock, investing, and saving. The result of these word associations may represent the kind of archetypes around money that are active in users mind.</p><p>We can see from the clusters that the word ‘investment’ may represent two contradicting archetypes: the left side (big profit, big money, stock, enterprise) represent archetype of business [user — {rep: business} — investment-stock], while the right side more an archetype of family or community (<em>arisan</em>, future, money). This archetype is more associated with ‘saving’ [user — {rep: family, community} — investment-saving] which emphasize safety and small money rather than big profit.</p><p>In the middle are keywords that represent current practices of investing from user’s perspective. Here we can also observe contradiction between ‘investment’ and ‘stock’. The word ‘investment’ represent more of long-term happiness, while ‘stock’ of a ‘darker’ short-term gains.</p><h4>Deconstructing Usability</h4><p>The above deconstructions focus more on app-<em>gestalt</em>, and to identify its <em>utility</em>: what and how it helps users to navigate and do things in life. Semiotics can also be used for deconstructing <em>usability</em> of an app by zooming-in further with semiotic lens into inside-app experience.</p><p>Here the focus is on the UIs and functionalities: what and how they help users to navigate and familiar herself with universe inside an app. The inside-app signifiers can be said to perform well if they are able to signify possible sense-actions (<em>monadic</em>), to engage, to give <em>immediate</em> feedbacks (<em>dyadic</em>), and to form user’s habits and understanding (<em>triadic</em>).</p><p>In the illustration below there are two micro pairs of signification: one micro UI-level involving the [front-UI — {sign} — investment-app] sign relation, and one micro functionality-level involving the [plus-button — {sign} — front-UI] sign relation. The UI-level signification is how various UIs may signify the app-gestalt; while the functionality-level is how certain UI-elements, like plus-button, graph, or bar icon, may signify one UI-gestalt.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3PqAv8kiM9dozV5pqktxNQ.png" /><figcaption>Zooming Inside the App: From Pages to Components</figcaption></figure><p>The UI level signification is similar to our previous outside-app deconstruction. The difference is we are now focusing on <em>sense-operations</em>, not sense-actions. The <em>same action</em>, like buying stock, can have many <em>different operations</em> depending on the conditions given by the UI. This is the monadic experience, the possibility for operations when users are facing certain UIs.</p><p>Consider these two UIs below. Both may have similar sense-actions: buy-stock, or investing, but they have different sense-operations. On the left-side, the Home UI, the action of investing is conducted by operating the plus-button at the right-bottom corner. On the right-side Round-Ups UI, similar action of investing is conducted by operating the ‘invest-now’ button. Similar plus-button at the right-bottom corner of this UI affords different action.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-TInTsGgbsaZTgclSTZ44g.png" /><figcaption>Two different UIs with similar sense-action: investing, but different sense-operations</figcaption></figure><p>To deconstruct inside-app experience the challenge is that typical users may not have adequate verbal signifiers to make their experience intelligible. We will have to closely observe how users operate the UI the first time it is given to them. We need to directly observe which UI elements are tapped and how spontaneously they are tapped. Good usable UIs are those that are able to quickly deliver all three: monadic, dyadic and triadic facet of experience.</p><p>For example, how quickly users can recognize tappable plus-button (monadic), provide immediate feedback the moment it is tapped (dyadic), and able to understand what it is doing (triadic). In the Home UI, users can quickly recognize that operating the plus-button by tapping signifies the action of investing. It gives immediate feedback by popping-up the amounts (5, 10, 20) to invest.</p><p>In the Round-Ups UI users may first misunderstand what action the plus-button affords. There are many more tappable elements that may distract users from tapping the plus-button. This UI may be less usable than Home-UI. However, the moment users tap the plus-button, it gives immediate feedback by adding the amount of money inside the circle.</p><p>This feedback allows users to ‘know’ what it affords. Users respond by spontaneously remarking that the circle is like a piggy-bank; and tapping the plus-button is like putting a coin into it. This metaphor is <em>cognitive representation</em>, a mental model, or using Don Norman’s term the <em>system image</em> of the Round-Ups UI. Users spontaneously call this UI an online Piggy-bank. This cognitive representation helps users further to intuitively ‘know’ what the ‘invest-now’ button affords. Tapping it is like emptying the piggy-bank for buying stock.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6k5g6nnt6Bl2ZbWf2xCIpw.png" /><figcaption>Piggy-bank as Metaphor, or Cognitive Representation of the Round-Ups UI</figcaption></figure><p>Based on this observations we can say that this UI has good usability and is able very well to deliver all three facets of experience. The piggy-bank metaphor has helped users to understand what operations can be done to conduct the action of investing in this UI.</p><p>I hope this tiny case of app experience deconstruction may illustrate how semiotics can help us building better UX.</p><p>For further discussion about this topic, you can reach me through eric@mcinsights.co</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eaf3e55fb0e1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://blog.prototypr.io/how-semiotics-can-help-us-in-ux-on-deconstructing-experience-eaf3e55fb0e1">How Semiotics Can Help Building Better UX: On Deconstructing Experience</a> was originally published in <a href="https://blog.prototypr.io/">Prototypr</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>