<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Erik on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Erik on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@eriksitter?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 14:53:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@eriksitter/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dear colleague, I’ve rejected your Design Challenge, and here’s why.]]></title>
            <link>https://eriksitter.medium.com/dear-colleague-ive-rejected-your-design-challenge-and-here-s-why-a279ac71ae4a?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a279ac71ae4a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[product-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[recruiting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ui-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Apr 2026 11:41:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-14T11:41:55.851Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="UX designer sitting at a desk with wireframes and sketches, raising a hand to refuse a design challenge shown on a laptop screen with a “Rejected” stamp." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uR8QURD3pKCNEl3KFxMVQA.png" /></figure><p>This is a matter of <strong>power dynamics</strong>. The company, and more specifically the colleague who decides to introduce a design challenge into the hiring process, holds all the leverage.</p><p>If you’re unemployed or actively looking for a job, you often don’t really have a choice. Your only option is to comply and go through a test that, in most cases, is poorly written, badly designed, ethically questionable, and unpaid. On top of that, these challenges often have little to no scientific or methodological validity when it comes to actually assessing a candidate’s skills or potential within a profession that has his roots in Science and not Graphic Design.</p><p>I’ve already written about this problem in more detail in another article <a href="https://medium.com/ux-planet/design-challenges-designers-demand-reform-as-unfair-tasks-miss-the-mark-part-i-2a69ea62fb94">here</a>.</p><p>Personally, I’m lucky enough to be in a position where I can refuse this kind of design challenges. And I strongly believe that anyone who already has a job and some degree of security has a responsibility to push back against practices like these. If people who <em>can</em> say no keep accepting them, the system will never change.</p><p>As a result, poorly designed challenges keep being produced, colleagues keep convincing themselves that they are “improving the hiring process” and “bringing value to the company,” while in reality they’re doing the opposite.</p><p>Along the way, strong and qualified candidates are lost, filtered out by a <strong>broken evaluation system</strong>, yet criticized by many, included Peter Merholz from Adaptive Path.</p><h3>The Job Advertise</h3><p>Recently I’ve applied for a Product Design job for a specific reason, in the description they were stating:</p><blockquote>While we have a strong foundation in visual design and design systems, we are specifically looking for a professional who excels in User Experience (UX), Information Architecture, and User Research.</blockquote><p>In the country where I currently live, Greece, it is extremely difficult to find a <em>true</em> UX designer position. In most companies, “UX design” is still largely interpreted as web design. Much more so than in other countries I’ve worked in.</p><p>This is precisely why this job description caught my attention.</p><p>That kind of framing is rare here, and it aligned with the kind of work I actually want to do. I had no interest in going back to doing pure web design, otherwise, I might as well have stayed in web design in the year 2000.</p><p>There were, however, some immediate red flags.</p><p>The job posting did not include any information about salary or even a salary range, which is something required by European regulations, nor during my call with the HR manager salary details were shared, and at the same time I was informed that the hiring process included a design challenge.</p><p>At that point, I could have refused right away as my portfolio should be enough covering 12 cases, Product Management, UX Design, Visual Design, Organizational Design, System Thinking and Research included statistic. Instead, I chose to say yes, at least to take a look at the challenge, knowing that I might decide to reject it afterward.</p><h3>The Design Challenge</h3><p>Assignment duration: 6–10 Hours | Deadline: Within 7 days</p><h4><strong>Context</strong></h4><p>Finding a home (notice: <em>the company is a web app listing homes</em>) isn’t a one-day task; it is a project. Users often browse for months, save dozens of listings, call various agents, and attend multiple viewings. Currently, users often struggle to track their own progress, asking themselves: “Did I call this agent yet?” or “Which one was the apartment with the nice balcony?”</p><h4><strong>Challenge</strong></h4><p>Design a “My Search” management tool that transforms “Saved Ads” into an active workspace.</p><h4><strong>Goals</strong></h4><p>The feature is specifically aimed at increasing the number of messages sent to listing owners per user by reducing the organizational overhead of a complex search. The goal is to create a high-utility experience that also improves return rate of users, ensuring they rely on the dashboard as their primary command center throughout their journey.</p><h4><strong>Deliverables</strong></h4><p>Please submit a PDF presentation or a Figma link containing the following:</p><p><strong>1. The discovery (research plan)</strong></p><p>● Format: 3–5 Bullet points.</p><p>● Task: If you could interview a property seeker before starting this design, what are the top 3 questions you would ask them to uncover their true struggles with the current process?</p><p><strong>2. The logic (information architecture &amp; states)</strong></p><p>● Format: Sketches, flowcharts, or a bulleted list.</p><p>● Task: Map out the property states a user cares about (e.g., “Saved”, “Contacted”, etc). How does a property move from one state to another? What data is crucial at each stage?</p><p><strong>3. The visuals (one key screen)</strong></p><p>● Format: High-fidelity design.</p><p>● Task: Choose ONE key view to design in high fidelity (e.g., the main “Active list” view) for a platform of your choice (Desktop, Mobile Web, or Native App). Show us your best UI skills here. Do not design the entire flow</p><p><strong>4. Bonus (if time allows): The system (one component)</strong></p><p>● Format: Figma component.</p><p>● Task: Build the main “Property Card” component. Show how it handles at least 3 different states (e.g., “New Listing” vs. “Contacted” vs. “Deactivated”).</p><p><strong>5. The rationale (short text)</strong></p><p>● Format: A brief summary (approx. 200 words).</p><p>● Task: Explain one key trade-off you made. Why did you prioritize X over Y?</p><p><strong>6. Self-evaluation (short text)</strong></p><p>● Format: A brief summary (up to 200 words), or a bulleted list.</p><p>● Task: Task: How do you rate overall your deliverables? Are there things that you couldn’t deliver to the level that you would like? Why? Was it due to time, experience, etc?</p><h3>What is wrong with it and so why I rejected it</h3><p><strong>Unethical design challenge</strong><br>Design challenges that ask the candidate to design something related to company products, are known as unethical challenges because the company gets material that can be recycled for internal purpose, this is typically a red flag.</p><p><strong>Free work disguised as “evaluation”</strong><br>This is essentially free product design work for a real product feature (“My Search” dashboard for <a href="http://xe.gr/">t</a>he company). Even if the company don’t ship the candidate exact design, they are generating strategic product thinking, IA, UI, and component systems.<br>This is unethical and flawed because the work has direct business value, candidates are asked to solve a real roadmap problem instead of a fictional scenario of a fictional product. If the company do it, it’s normally a paid challenge.</p><p><strong>No IP or NDA clarity whatsoever<br></strong>Candidates are never told what happens to their submitted work. Does <a href="http://xe.gr/">t</a>he company own it? Can they use it? This should be explicit, and the fact that it isn’t, on a challenge solving a real live product problem, is a serious omission.</p><p><strong>The brief optimizes for company KPIs, not user ethics<br></strong>The stated product goal is:</p><p><em>“increasing the number of messages sent to listing owners per user”</em></p><p>This is a growth metric framed as UX success.<br>This is ethically sketchy because you nudge candidates toward designing behavior-manipulation patterns (some are forbidden by EU law). It also conflates user value with platform conversion goals.<br>Ethical candidates might actually push back on this framing and be penalized for it.<br>It’s a bad signal because the “right” answer may be one that optimizes engagement, not user well-being which is an antithesis with UX Design basics.<br>Moreover this solution does not answer to the user questions they stated:</p><p><em>“Did I call this agent yet?”<br>“Which one was the apartment with the nice balcony?”</em></p><p>So the user need is more oriented towards:</p><p><em>“Better organization, memory support, sensemaking, and progress tracking.”</em></p><p>However, the business goal they state is:</p><p><em>“Increasing the number of messages sent to listing owners per user.”</em></p><p>Those two things are not the same problem. They’re only loosely correlated.</p><p><strong>The platform choice is inconsistent.</strong><br>Letting candidates pick between desktop, mobile web, and native app makes cross-candidate evaluation meaningless. <br>The company is not comparing like for like. Please bear in mind that what we are doing here it’s a user interview and in order to evaluate candidates correctly, it has to be structured and this is not.</p><p><strong>“We Encourage AI” creates a hidden evaluation trap</strong><br>The company say AI use is encouraged, but they also expect candidates to “own” the work. This is problematic because there’s no clear evaluation standard.<br>How much AI is “too much”?<br>Will candidates be judged for being transparent?<br>People who disclose AI use may be subconsciously penalized vs those who don’t or vice versa.</p><p><strong>Self-evaluation requirement is psychologically biased<br></strong>Asking candidates to critique themselves introduces biases because confident candidates may sound arrogant. <br>Thoughtful candidates may undersell themselves while neurodivergent candidates often struggle with self-promotion framing.<br>This evaluates communication style, cultural norms, confidence performance but not design competence.<br>It is also ethically questionable. Whatever candidates admit to, can and will be used against them in evaluation or salary negotiation.</p><p><strong>No evaluation information</strong><br>Dear colleague, if you implement a design challenge you must state how the work will be evaluated. <br>Candidates have no idea how they’ll be judged. What weight goes to the IA vs the UI? What does “good” look like? Withholding evaluation criteria isn’t rigorous, it’s just opaque.</p><p><strong>No salary mentions and speculative work<br></strong>There’s no salary information provided in the job advertise or during the first call, yet the company is asking to conduct an unpaid unethical design challenge, not inclusive and that will not objectively assess them. This is not fair.</p><p><strong>The bonus task<br></strong>There cannot be a bonus task. <br>It’s like dropping a bomb in the quality of the evaluation criteria and the consequent output.</p><blockquote>In a competitive hiring process nothing is truly optional.</blockquote><p>Candidates who are unemployed, have no caregiving responsibilities, or simply had a lighter week will produce the bonus component. <br>If completing the bonus task will not give them extra points, they will have worked for nothing, if it will give extra points, it will penalize the other candidates who didn’t do the bonus task, creating a biased evaluation process.</p><p><strong>This is not an inclusive hiring process</strong><br>At the bottom of the job advertisement there were these words:</p><p><em>“[…]and focus on creating a diverse and inclusive workplace.”</em></p><p>Whoever crafted this design challenge has wrongly assumed that all the end users are identical, but it’s wrong and some of them will be penalized.<br>Parents and caregivers, disproportionately women, cannot casually absorb a 6–10 hour unpaid task on top of their current job and home responsibilities.</p><p>Candidates with disabilities, cognitive, physical, or mental health related, may require more time to complete the same work. The fixed time framing implicitly penalizes them with no accommodation mechanism mentioned anywhere.</p><p>Candidates from lower socioeconomic backgrounds who are working multiple jobs or cannot afford to spend 10 hours on speculative unpaid work are filtered out, not by skill, but by financial precarity.</p><p><strong>A fundamental misalignment</strong><br>The way in which the challenge was crafted, underlines a misalignment between what the role claims to value and what the evaluation system actually measures, as well as the already mentioned methodological concerns about the hiring approach itself.</p><p>From a skills-assessment perspective, the design challenge places disproportionate emphasis on:</p><ul><li>High-fidelity visual design</li><li>UI polish</li><li>Figma execution and component construction</li></ul><p>While these are legitimate skills, they are not the core competencies highlighted in the job advertisement.<br>Also, pick an HR Manager, put it in front of Figma full time for one month and after a month she/he will be good to go.</p><p>The challenge does not meaningfully assess several of the central capabilities the role claims to prioritize, including:</p><ul><li><strong>User Research in practice</strong>: The task does not evaluate research design, recruitment, synthesis of insights, or how research findings inform product decisions. It tests familiarity with UX language rather than real research competence.</li><li><strong>UX leadership and discovery</strong>: There is no assessment of problem framing, hypothesis formation, collaboration with Product Managers during discovery, or how design decisions are shaped by learning and uncertainty.</li><li><strong>Information Architecture under real-world constraints</strong>: Although the task touches on states and flows, it lacks technical, organizational, and product constraints that define real IA work.</li><li><strong>Dummy content is missing</strong>. Web Designers operate by guessing, UX Designers instead need data from research, design challenges crafted well, includes fake user interviews from which the UX Designer can code the data that will lead the design, without this, again it’s Web Design.</li></ul><p>As a result, the process primarily filters for visual/UI production skills, while under-evaluating UX strategy, research maturity, and systems-level thinking. It favors designers who already use Figma daily and have polished visual skills <em>(what about those still using AdobeXd or other software?).</em></p><p>In practice, <strong>this tends to select visual designers operating under the label of UX designers,</strong> rather than UX professionals whose primary value lies in research-driven decision-making and product-level judgment.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a279ac71ae4a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Design Challenges: Designers Demand Reform as Unfair Tasks Miss the Mark (part II)]]></title>
            <link>https://uxplanet.org/design-challenges-designers-demand-reform-as-unfair-tasks-miss-the-mark-part-ii-07659a11254d?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/07659a11254d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-centered-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spec-work]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Feb 2024 18:49:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-26T11:34:46.167Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Examining the ethical, psychological, and practical concerns surrounding design challenges, and advocating for a more inclusive, human centered and effective approach to evaluating designers.</h4><figure><img alt="Ornamental image of a desk with pencils, pens and mouse carefully positioned about a book with a sci-fi illustration as a cover. The cover showcase a laptop with cyber human-hands texting on the keyboard, while on the display we see data chart in blue and turquoise colors with a human head at the center projecting sci-fi and cyberpunk feelings" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*V2IWpAeN0672ZUPc" /></figure><p><strong>Table of contents (part I) </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@eriksitter/design-challenges-designers-demand-reform-as-unfair-tasks-miss-the-mark-part-i-2a69ea62fb94">To read the first part of the article click here</a><br>1. Background context<br>2. Methodology<br>3. Findings<br>4. Objective and/or Scientific Foundations of Designers Complaints<br>5. Negative Impacts for Businesses<br>6. What designers wants?</p><p><strong>Table of contents (part II) click here for the second part</strong></p><p>7. What motivates designers to promote design challenges?<br>8. Why do designers who advocate for design challenges continue to insist?<br>9. But what about whiteboard challenges?<br>10. I’m still going to ask for a design challenge<br>11. Conclusions</p><h3>What motivates designers to promote design challenges?</h3><p>Over the years, colleagues who promote design challenges, as well as whiteboard challenges, have given various reasons, and, personal perception, have changed slightly over time.</p><p>It used to be common to hear “because I need to evaluate how you work under pressure” but at least in Europe, you hear less of that and more of “I need to see how you think” or, more recently, almost as if feeling cornered, “how else can I evaluate you?”.</p><p>In reality, none of the reasons that promote this practice have any scientific basis, in the sense that no one has ever bothered to conduct a study to determine whether speculative work is a valid system for evaluating a candidate.</p><p>Below are some of the most common reasons designers says they ask their colleagues to conduct a challenge:</p><p><strong>— Demonstrates a designer’s problem-solving skills<br></strong>While it’s true that design challenges could provide a snapshot of a candidate’s problem-solving abilities, the limited scope and artificial environment of these challenges may not fully capture a designer’s ability to tackle complex, real-world problems.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment stating that if your process require a design exercise to evaluate someone, you need to redesign your interview process" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/787/1*aP21WCCOmSpCEwQXJbsLhw.png" /></figure><p>As highlighted in this article, design work is multifaceted and often requires considering various aspects.</p><p>A design challenge focused on a specific task or scenario may oversimplify the design process and fail to assess the broader skills required by the profession.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment that complaint about the fact that a statement like “we want to see your process” it’s a nosense has you will never get it out from a 4-hour time limit task." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/777/1*7b_9QFOUV9uUEUHtiecoiQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s worth to mention, that often design challenges do not present a problem, they present you the solution:</p><p>“Design an app that does this and that”</p><p>and on top of this, a portfolio typically already showcase the designer problem-solving skills.</p><p><strong>— A glimpse into a candidate’s design process<br></strong>Design challenges can indeed give some insight into a candidate’s design process. <br>However, without adequate feedback or dialogue, candidates may not have the opportunity to fully explain their thought process or the rationale behind their design decisions.</p><p>Furthermore, the time constraints and high-pressure nature of design challenges may not accurately reflect a candidate’s typical design process.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment promoting the rejection of design challenges and suggesting that those asking for them they don’t know what they are looking for" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/774/1*vSK8KgFdeOV6OHwYFZax6Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>— Offers an opportunity for designers to showcase their skills<br></strong>This is really the most classical inherent motivation of a speculative work but in reality a portfolio already showcase skills.</p><p><strong>— I have 1000 candidates I cannot go through all their portfolios<br></strong>I cannot verify the validity of this comment, perhaps it is so in the United States or perhaps is true for large businesses or very desired one, for example I kinda remember that NNGroup gets around that amount or more when they open a position.</p><p>If I have to give an evaluation based on personal experiences, here in Europe we are full of small and medium-sized companies and when during the first call I ask among how many I have been selected, the answers generally always revolve around these numbers:</p><p>“100–80–50 applications” and 10 selections of which then about half is the one that passes to the design challenge stage.</p><p><strong>— I receive many applications from candidates who have done a bootcamp and their portfolios are full of not real projects</strong><br>Just because someone’s portfolio contains projects completed during a bootcamp doesn’t diminish the quality or relevance of their work.</p><p>Students of the four main online bootcamps actually interview real people for their course projects, thus making these portfolios projects more realistic than the fake prompt design challenges without dummy content that designer evaluators assign to the candidates.</p><p>Motivations like “because I need to evaluate how you work under pressure”, “I need to see how you think” and “how I evaluate you” have all been indirectly addressed above in this article.</p><p><strong>— A designer it’s a cost, we need to de-risk the chances to pick the wrong designers<br></strong>I don’t have research data that could specifically object to this comment, I could explain it on a psychological level, but I think it’s not necessary considering what has already been written so far.</p><p>Designers could easily argue that all employees have a cost.</p><p>Depending on the company, country and city, some employees cost more than a designer and yet they don’t have to do a design challenge with no data and which requires hours of work.</p><p>Don’t make the mistake of thinking that in every country, even in Europe, a UX Designer or a Developer is always paid more than, for example, a Recruiter, a Marketing Manager or a Customer Support Team Leader, because this is not always the case. That is perhaps more of an American, German and some Northern European countries reality.</p><p>Some designer (<em>and they do</em>) might say that doctors are not asked to perform a test surgery on a dead body, nurses are not asked to sew an orange to see if they know how to stitch, paramedics are not asked to drive the ambulance from the point A to point B as quickly as possible and pharmacists are not asked to guess the correct drug based on the person’s symptoms or make a preparation in the laboratory.<br>At least, on a personal level, I’m sure of it because I come from a family of doctors.</p><p><strong>— Yes but doctors have a certificte, a degree etc<br></strong>Architects and Graphic Designers too, yet before internet they were among the first ones to experiment speculative work. <br>Plumbers may have a diploma, yet when they enter into a firm, I doubt they are asked to perform work for free as part of the hiring process.</p><h3>Why do designers who advocate for design challenges continue to insist?</h3><p>Let’s set aside strictly personal reasons like:</p><ul><li>Someone might seek a candidate primarily engaged in crafting without the need of knowing UX Design, an know-how by osmosis may be considered ok</li><li>Business reasons (<em>eg I’m the CEO I decide</em>)</li></ul><p>Despite detractors of this practice having solid and valid grounds to oppose it, in a field like UX Design (<em>when practiced correctly</em>), where decision revolves around data research, why do proponents of design challenges or whiteboard challenges persist with this practice?</p><p>Personally, I think that the motivation are simply psychological and social.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot oflinkedin comment stating that company follow the herd and that they expect to solve a task in 2–3 days when they take 3–6 months to solve the problem" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/775/1*d-Dkwt4zgIiQhiADWvK2oQ.png" /></figure><p>For example, designers has already clarified that they do not want to work for free and that a portfolio walkthrough and a peer to peer interview are they way to go, so why a design challenge promoter should reply with:</p><p>“What is the alternative?” when designers has already presented the alternative.</p><p>Perhaps D. Norman would reply by saying that this is the symptom, not the problem.</p><p>At this point you should apply <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_thinking">critical thinking</a> to the data that now you know and a bit of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metacognition">metacognition </a>and then ask yourself key questions like:</p><ol><li>Why do I still feel the need of an alternative different by the one manifested by my colleagues, some with 5, 10, 15, 20+ years of experience?</li><li>Why other businesses do not ask for a design challenge and still their design teams succeed?</li><li>Are my motivations backed by data?</li><li>Am I victim of a bias?</li><li>etc etc</li></ol><h4>Psychological and Social Motivations Behind the Design Challenge Promotion</h4><figure><img alt="Ornamental image. Digital Illustration of hand puppeting a human brain on a blue, light blue background with geometrical sci-fi lines, charts and graphs" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*feMzpAjDRdkrS0TqBuRsPQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you ask me, as I previously said, there are probably psychological factors that are playing here, for example:</p><p><strong>— Status Quo Bias</strong><br><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Status_quo_bias">This is a tendency</a> for people to prefer things to stay the same unless there is a compelling reason to change. <br>Someone may see a design challenge as a standard practice in the industry, regardless of its validity, and so hesitate to deviate from this norm without clear evidence of a better alternative.</p><p>But even with a clear evidence and better alternative, designers don’t see them because they may end to experience resistance to change.</p><p><strong>— Resistance to change</strong><br><a href="https://medium.com/ux-planet/if-stakeholders-dont-buy-it-it-s-not-necessarily-a-uxer-or-product-manager-lack-of-skills-but-a-5689930b1f89">I talk about it in these article</a>, you can skip the top part and scroll down till when I talk about the emotional cycle of the psychiatrists Kubler-Ross.</p><p>Imagine your child has a favorite toy that he/she play with every day. One day, you tell her/him that you are going to replace it with a new toy.</p><p>Your child might feel upset or worried because she/he loves her/his old toy and he/she don’t know if they will like the new one. This feeling is what is called “resistance to change”.</p><p>It’s when we feel nervous or scared about something new because we are comfortable with the way things are. Just like your child might miss the old toy, adults can feel the same way when something changes in their life.</p><p>Eh, you think it’s easy, but it’s not, because this psychological phenomen can be a very bumpy ride when we have a strong ego or when we have spent years with the same convinctions and built our personality and who we are on it, something that does not happen consciously.</p><p>RTC can causes in people experiencing an emotional anxiety caused by the prospect of a transformation or change that is taking place and this trigger another amazing thing called cognitive dissonance.</p><p><strong>— Cognitive dissonance</strong><br>I also talk about it in the same article I mentioned above. Here is what it is:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of the article mentioned above and that says: “A mental distress experienced by a person who simultaneously holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas or values. Discomfort is triggered by a situation where a person’s beliefs collide with new evidence presented to that person.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_zri6uacJlA_Pr_p7Ex-OQ.png" /></figure><p>This can then trigger a series of other interesting circumstances such as defensive attitude, difficulty accepting change, confirmation bias, fear of the unknow</p><p><strong>— Defensive Attitude</strong><br>Some designers may adopt a defensive attitude when their practices are questioned or criticized. Asking for alternative way of evaluation, could be a way to deflect criticism and maintain the status quo without seriously considering the feedback provided.</p><p><strong>— Confirmation Bias</strong><br>Designers may be biased towards their existing beliefs or practices and may overlook or dismiss alternative suggestions that challenge their current approach. <br>They may only consider alternatives that align with<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias#:~:text=12%20External%20links-,Definition%20and%20context,difficult%20to%20dislodge%20once%20affirmed."> their preconceived notions </a>of effective hiring practices.</p><p><strong>— Fear of the Unknown</strong><br>There may be uncertainty or skepticism about the effectiveness or reliability of alternative assessment methods, particularly if they deviate from familiar practices. Designers may be hesitant to adopt new methods without clear evidence of their efficacy.</p><p>Ultimately we can also try to call in <em>Swidler, A. Culture in action: symbols and strategies (1986)</em> and quoting:</p><blockquote>culture influences action not by providing the ultimate values toward which action is oriented but by shaping a repertoire or ‘tool-kit’ of habits, skills, and styles.</blockquote><p>In the field of design hiring practices, the “culture” could be the established norms and practices within the industry or a particular company. This includes the use of design and whiteboard challenges in the hiring process.</p><p>Despite the lack of empirical data supporting the effectiveness of design challenges, and the numerous criticisms of this practice, it continues to be used.</p><p>This could be because it is part of the “tool-kit” that designers involved in the hiring process have inherited from their predecessors.</p><p>It’s a familiar practice, something they themselves might have gone through when they were job candidates. As such, it becomes a habit, a known method of assessing candidates, and is perpetuated in the hiring process.</p><p>The use of design challenges could also be seen as a “style” of hiring — a way for companies to present themselves as rigorous and thorough in their hiring practices. <br>Even if the effectiveness of design challenges is questionable, the very act of having a design challenge could be seen as a signal of a company’s commitment to hiring the best talent.</p><h4>Why focused on crafting?</h4><p>I have to take the long journey, so following for some paragraph.</p><p>Another motivations to why some designer still push on design challenges, could be due to a lack of understanding of UX Design and its poor penetration as an official job, from the physical market, into the digital market, which was already occupied by other professions before NNGroup went online.</p><p>From 1999 NNGroup started to promote the usability weeks and the user experiences weeks. <br>These were 1 and 2 days seminaries (<em>perhaps there was a 3rd not sure</em>) that were mainly talking about usability on different aspects of a website and it tooks a couple of years before seeing on their website the combined words “UX Design”.</p><p>Indeed first they were using the words “user experience”, then “UED” and then “UX Design” and I always wondered if Nielsen and Norman implemented “Design” in place of “Architect” to follow a market trend.</p><p>Bottomline, things from the USA to the rest of the world didn’t spread fast and neither in an homogeneous manner.</p><p>One of the leading usability websites in Italy, active I think already in 1999, wrote an article in 2011 about how people didn’t understand what UX Design was, suggesting that perhaps was because it lacked the scientific basis that Usability Engineering had:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a paragraph of the italian article to which refers the above paragraph refer and that is then translated below in english" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/919/1*ORFuxYMXsxsqhF2CIVkpfg.png" /></figure><p>Translated means:</p><blockquote>The feeling is that User Experience is a happy label, but that it is not clear even to all its practitioners what it is. Strengthening the sensation is the consideration that it is not a discipline with (<em>missing word</em>) brought by scientific research (unlike usability engineering, which boasts lines of research in Human-Computer Interaction), nor with ad hoc design practices ( as is true for information architecture, which has an arsenal of choice in card sorting, content inventory, construction of controlled dictionaries and more).</blockquote><p><strong>By coincidence, in a </strong><a href="https://jakobnielsenphd.substack.com/p/ux-vocabulary-inflation"><strong>recent article</strong></a><strong>, Jakob Nielsen reminds us that this field was originally called “usability engineering”.</strong></p><p>This was in Italy (<em>at that time 4th richest country in EU</em>), site of reference to promote usability, most important books from D. Norman were already published, perhaps translated in Italian and we are at the end of 2011, precisely 2 years before the first bootcamp launched a course in UX Design that was not instructed by a Usability Specialist, a UI Architect a UX Architect or someone with a degree in Psychologist, but graduated in Art and Graphics.</p><p>This shows us that things don’t always evolve as we expect and in spite several indications that UX Design was not an upskilling but an interdisciplinary job profession the scientific disciplines we saw in the previous part of this article.</p><p>If you remember Don Norman’s books and his words, he has repeatedly emphasized the multidisciplinarity of this profession, including its scientific basis and well, requirement to apply them.</p><p>When I was a teenager in Italy, around 1997, I used to design interfaces for browser games and sell them under the table. I naturally called myself a UI Designer because I didn’t design websites and these were UIs, like the ones we have once we log into a SaaS with the side menu and the data at the center of the screen.</p><p>I didn’t design websites for banks, e-commerce, etc. Back then, professions like Web Designer, UI Designer, Visual Designer, and Graphic Designer already existed.</p><p>When I started working as a Web Designer around 2000–2001, I worked exactly like everyone else in that time, with a “project mindset,” so there was no upfront research, I didn’t design anything based on data except the data coming from my common sense, what I had absorbed from other sites and what the client wanted.</p><p>We would do sketches, slice out the home page from Photoshop, create user flows, and make changes based on user feedback once online (<em>if we were working with a regular client</em>).</p><p>Otherwise, it would happen just like in the design challenge prompts that everyone hates.<br>A client would come with a list of what they wanted or would tell you to make a website that does this or that. You would execute the order, change something according to the client and that’s all.</p><p>In some cases, especially with graphic designers, they would ask you for a free draft of the project and then decide after choosing from other potential designers.</p><p>Furthermore, jobs like Web Designer, UI Designer and Visual Designer in USA were already into the online digital market before NNGroup lauch and between 2000 and 2006 we have traces of job titles such as “UI/UX Design” that many today blame but that in that time, was just the UI Designer job title evolving to accomodate this new thing called UX, regardless the fact that UX artifacts typically comes before wireframes.</p><p>The fact that most job postings in Germany (<em>I lived here</em>), Spain (<em>did interviews there</em>), Italy (<em>I lived here</em>), and Greece (<em>I’m living here</em>) are all oriented towards crafting, makes me think that UX Design has perhaps penetrated as a general upskill, Nielsen’s heuristics have become “common sense”, and the whole scientific part has never been received if not as example of good design founded on such scientific subjects.</p><p>This could explain why design challenges continue to be crafted without dummy content.</p><p>Here are some additional points to consider:</p><ul><li><strong>The lack of scientific understanding </strong>of UX Design can lead to a focus on aesthetics and superficial features over user needs and usability. <br>Typically these design challenge prompt lack of user needs, user goals, pain points, the data/dummy content UX Design need to perform the job.</li><li><strong>The emphasis on crafting</strong> and visual design can lead to a neglect of the research and problem-solving aspects of UX Design.<br>Often these challenges do not give time for user research (but many would not spent time for free on that) nor give you fake user interview answers to analyze and, the prompt it’s not a problem, it’s already the solution.</li><li><strong>The use of design challenges</strong> can be a way to assess a candidate’s visual design skills, but it does not necessarily measure their ability to conduct research, understand user needs, and design effective solutions.<br>After all, nobody really cared about this things in Web Design.</li></ul><h3>But what about whiteboard challenges?</h3><p>Even though I have collected about 45 comments specifically about the whiteboard challenges, I have not included them in the analysis. This is because I originally intended to write a separate article on whiteboard challenges where I was involving interviews with different Psychologists.</p><p>However, the vast majority of the reasons that designers have raised against design challenges also apply to whiteboard challenges which are not inclusive, present the same problems of lack of dummy content and they also have a version where the candidate it’s not informed in advance about what will be the context.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of linkedin comment. The author is dyslexic and he would prefer design challenges rather than whitboard challenges, pointing out in this way a lack of inclusivity" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/767/1*zM_u6e6w1h4srNz3CaAJ5A.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment saying: “a whiteboard challenge will show you who’s good at being creative very quickly under a lof of pressure. That’s just now how everyones’s brain work. I think allowgin someone to collaborate on a problem with a team is a great compromise. Interviewers shoul always offer accomodations instead of creating an unrealistic pressure cooker.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/691/1*XbTyxV-qAAao7SJfFgasVQ.png" /></figure><h3>I’m Still going to Ask for a Design Challenge</h3><figure><img alt="Ornamental image. The image depict a fantasy illustration of a devil with laughing and whosing many sharps teeth. He’s skin is red, big horns, long earswith earrings and a grey short beard." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ecpl8X_Z9FZczkx9" /></figure><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment saying that a portfolio exist for a purpose and test taking is for school. If a company wants to test someone theyn can pay by hiring the candidate as freelancer. The probation time exist for a purpose and such types of challenges are not taken by accountants and marketers" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/766/1*vus7C5SIjrP5tbcKz9ZA7w.png" /></figure><p>If in spite of this 2 parts article, included the potential consequences for you, your design team and the business you are working for, you still want to implement a (<em>paid is honest</em>) design challenge then…</p><h4>Try to implement it in a fair way</h4><p><strong>1.If the candidate has a portfolio,</strong> explain him/her why the portfolio it’s not enough, what you didn’t find in it, at least it’s a feedback in order to improve the portfolio and a respectful thing to do.</p><p><strong>2. Offer the candidate these two options,</strong> better with the third one:</p><ul><li>Design challenge.</li><li>Whiteboard challenge.</li><li>Audit of a chosen site.</li></ul><p><strong>3. Craft an ethical design/whiteboard challenge</strong></p><ul><li>Do not ask to redesign something of your product.</li><li>Do not ask to design something of a product that align with your product (<em>eg you work for an eCommerce and you ask to design a cart page</em>).</li><li>Do not ask for the source file.</li></ul><p><strong>4. Craft a realistic design/whiteboard challenge</strong></p><ul><li>Provide dummy content (<em>eg user needs, user goals, paint point, user flows, the answers of the user interviews, empathy map etc</em>).</li><li>For whiteboard challenges, provide the context in advance, before the actual interview/call.</li><li>If you need, use the AI to craft user interview answers, paint points etc (<em>I mean fake for fake, as you just care about the process</em>).</li><li>Do not offer the solution, let the candidate analyze the dummy content and come out with the solution that he/she thinks.</li><li>Provide the solution “Design an app that does this and this and that” only if you work in a feature team, an agency on project mindset, or you do not care about UX because you need a bricklayer.</li></ul><p><strong>5. Clearly specify what are the deliverables</strong></p><ul><li>Sketches</li><li>Wireframe mid, high fidelity</li><li>User flows</li><li>Canvas maps</li><li>Empathy map</li><li>User Journey</li><li>Customer journey</li><li>etc</li></ul><p>All these things require time, if they are not listed, the candidate is free to do not provide them to you.</p><p><strong>6. Specify what are the criteria of evaluation</strong></p><ul><li>Write them in a clear way.</li><li>Do not let ambiguity of judgment.</li><li>Craft the instruction to avoid a final “assumption VS assumption” but you wanna win because you have the knife in your hand.</li></ul><p>One of the best design challenges I saw was coming from an international business, an LMS, that was clearly stating “we will not judge your assumptions”.</p><p>They were not stupid, they knew that even if they had provided some dummy content, it was still too open to various assumptions all valid without a validation.</p><p><strong>7. The candidate is the end user</strong>, when you craft the challenge do it using plain language, use bullet points, manage white spaces and avoid lexical ambiguity. <br>(<em>Do not bother to my IA, I am bound to medium freepaid options (pff</em>)</p><p><strong>8. Give enough time</strong> which means at least 7 days, but expect that some candidate may have even less than 8 hours to dedicate them. <br>Best ones are open ended.</p><p><strong>9. Provide feedback after you have evaluated the challenge</strong>, if you do it via email, avoid templates as it’s not respectful. You are all paid handsomely, to hand write a response.</p><p><strong>10. Remember to indicate in the job advertise,</strong> that if the portfolio is lacking of what you need (<em>state what you need</em>) a design challenge will be required.</p><p><strong>11. Describe also how many steps the interview last.</strong></p><p><strong>12. Write the salary or the salary range in the job ad</strong>, if you are in <a href="https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/pay-transparency/#:~:text=Under%20the%20new%20rules%2C%20EU,employers%20who%20break%20the%20rules.">Europe is mandatory by law</a>.</p><blockquote>The new rules will make it compulsory for employers to inform job seekers about the <strong>starting salary or pay range</strong> of advertised positions, whether in the vacancy notice or ahead of the interview.</blockquote><blockquote>Employers will also be prevented from asking candidates about their <strong>pay history</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>Once in the role, workers will be entitled to ask their employers for information about:</blockquote><blockquote><strong>average pay levels</strong>, broken down by sex, for categories of employees doing the same work or work of equal value</blockquote><blockquote>the <strong>criteria</strong> used to determine pay and career progression, which must be objective and gender neutral</blockquote><figure><img alt="Screenshot from the EU law page stating:“The new rules will make it compulsory for employers to inform job seekers about the starting salary or pay range of advertised positions, whether in the vacancy notice or ahead of the interview. Employers will also be prevented from asking candidates about their pay history. Once in the role, workers will be entitled to ask their employers for information about the average pay levels, broken down by sex, for categories of employees doing the same work or" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GQHSLgHgLaW1vrFMsupYMA.png" /></figure><p>Once hired, the employee is now entitled to ask what is the salary of the other employees performing the same job and you must provide the data.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment saying that if a hiring manager cannot see your process through your portfolio and questioning you, that you don’t want to work there. A design challenge is about assumptions. UX is about real data" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/776/1*I89iasBdPSjW3rbYmdwpXw.png" /></figure><h4>Some example of bad design challenges</h4><p>This was an unethical one required by a founder of a stealth startup, once I read it and I also saw that his neo UX Consultant had recently changed title from Art Director just to look as UX Consultat and didn’t have any experience in UX, I’ve dropped out from the process.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a real design challenge, unethical, not paid asking the candidate do redesign part of a product and upload the design on the server of the company together with those of other candidates" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r5T_EgHjqXPYGSGy2-_zqg.png" /></figure><p>This other one was also unethic and asked by a Director of a famous automotive agency in Germany</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a real bad design challenge, unethical, not paid asking for UX audit of one of their website and also how to improve the design in order to sell their suitcase in a faster way" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5GzIo7TaCvcFp-hTXIU0Xw.png" /></figure><p>This other also unethic and with several flaw addressed in this article, was proposed by a Head of UX which is also a point of reference for an important online platform in the design field</p><figure><img alt="Another screenshot of an unethical design challenge asking to redesing the flow in order that their client can order in a faster way" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/996/1*dhlhvTD7pS0HSnCAE-As2A.png" /></figure><h4>Ultima Ratio</h4><p>Perhaps designers promoting the design challenge, can still change approach in another way.</p><p>When designers are interviewing other designers, they are simply conducting user interviews. <br>If you know how to conduct user interviews, that you can conduct one with your colleague candidates.</p><p>You can keep the portfolio walkthrough and integrate the step with a set of questions, or just use questions. <br>Prepare the research plan like you would normally do and decide between structured and unstructured interviews and for each question assign a value to the answer.</p><p>Obviously this will present all of a series of problems like biases that you need to learn to tackle, how to get common consens between interviewer about the value between each number etc, but at least you may produce data for an analysis of this evaluation.</p><p><a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/author/evan-sunwall/">Evan Sunwall</a> from NNGroup is promoting a <a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/structured-hiring-interviews/">structured interview here at this page. </a><br>However, while I have some questions about it, I do not see it as an easy approach for designers who are mainly involved in crafting and lack the necessary selfanalysis to conduce unbiased research, beside the fact it may take times for them. Yet it could be a last resort.</p><h3><strong>Conclusions</strong></h3><p>While this article is not exhaustive, research process was heavily synthetized and does not address in detail specific situations such as a candidate who only needs to work on the design system of a product or simply produce the UI, it still provide several points of think about it.</p><p>The current state of design challenges in the hiring process raises critical questions about fairness, effectiveness, and respect for design expertise.</p><p>While they may offer some insights into specific technical skills, the limitations exposed throughout this article are undeniable. Unrealistic expectations, ethical concerns about unpaid work, and a lack of alignment with real-world design work, all call for a fundamental shift in how we assess design talent.</p><p>The lanscape is made by a complex interplay of historical legacies, cultural influences, and individual motivations. Despite the evolution of UX design from its scientific roots, there remains a significant gap in understanding and implementing scientific principles within the industry.</p><p>This gap manifests in hiring practices that prioritize crafting over human-centric problem-solving, perpetuating traditional assessment methods that fail to capture the essence of UX Design as a working profession rather than a field from which pick something.</p><p>The persistence of design challenges can be attributed to a myriad of factors, including status quo bias, resistance to change, and cognitive dissonance among industry professionals.</p><p>These psychological barriers, compounded by a lack of scientific understanding and standardized evaluation criteria, contribute to the perpetuation of outdated practices that undermine the profession’s integrity.</p><p>However, amidst these challenges lies an opportunity for transformation.</p><p>By embracing ethical considerations, promoting inclusivity, and adopting alternative assessment methods such a portfolio walkthough, collaborative talking, the UX design community can chart a path towards a more equitable and professional hiring process.</p><p>The conclusions drawn from this article underscore the need for collective action and introspection within the UX design community.</p><p>Challenging entrenched norms, advocating for change, and cultivating a deeper understanding of the profession’s core principles, designers can enter in a new stage of professionalism, integrity, and inclusivity in UX design hiring practices.</p><p><strong>For further investigation,</strong> it might be interesting to explore through a more accurate and by the book research the whole topic and:</p><ul><li>The perspectives of hiring managers and why they choose to use design tasks</li><li>The effectiveness of design tasks in predicting job performance</li><li>The impact of these hiring practices on diversity and inclusion</li></ul><p><a href="https://medium.com/@eriksitter/design-challenges-designers-demand-reform-as-unfair-tasks-miss-the-mark-part-i-2a69ea62fb94">To read the first part of the article click here</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=07659a11254d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxplanet.org/design-challenges-designers-demand-reform-as-unfair-tasks-miss-the-mark-part-ii-07659a11254d">Design Challenges: Designers Demand Reform as Unfair Tasks Miss the Mark (part II)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxplanet.org/">UX Planet</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Design Challenges: Designers Demand Reform as Unfair Tasks Miss the Mark (part I)]]></title>
            <link>https://uxplanet.org/design-challenges-designers-demand-reform-as-unfair-tasks-miss-the-mark-part-i-2a69ea62fb94?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a69ea62fb94</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spec-work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Feb 2024 18:47:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-26T11:33:49.153Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Examining the ethical, psychological, and practical concerns surrounding design challenges, and advocating for a more inclusive, human centered and effective approach to evaluating designers.</h4><figure><img alt="Ornamental image. Top view of a wooden desk with pencils and pens. At the center a book. The cover of the book has modern designs depicting skyscrapers on the right side of the cover and on the left side a series of circles and spheres similar to planets" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yo6tJTdmP_PAMEg-8OGAQQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Abstract</strong><br>Since over 10 years and inheritated from the speculative work of the “physical world”, design challenges are a mainstay in the design hiring process of many businesses of any size. They faced and are facing a growing chorus of dissent from designers who find them unfair, disrespectful, and ineffective.</p><p>This analysis examines 186 comments in order to try to understand the psychological and practical reasons behind this discontent, uncovering concerns about unrealistic time expectations, lack of respect for expertise, limited skill assessment and ethical considerations surrounding unpaid work.</p><p>Largely picking up from the voices of designers themselves, the article amplifies their call for reform, advocating for a more human-centered and ethical approach to design talent evaluation.</p><p>Alternative assessment methods, such as portfolio reviews, collaborative discussions are presented as more promising avenues for assess the candidate and promoting inclusivity in the hiring process.</p><p>This article not only highlight the pitfalls of design challenges but also charts a path toward a more respectful and successful way to find and grow candidates.</p><p><strong>Table of contents (part I)</strong><br>1. Background context<br>2. Methodology<br>3. Findings<br>4. Objective and/or Scientific Foundations of Designers Complaints<br>5. Negative Impacts for Businesses<br>6. What designers wants?</p><p><strong>Table of contents (part II) </strong><a href="https://eriksitter.medium.com/07659a11254d"><strong>click here for the second part</strong></a></p><p>7. What motivates designers to promote design challenges?<br>8. Why do designers who advocate for design challenges continue to insist?<br>9. But what about whiteboard challenges?<br>10. I’m still going to ask for a design challenge<br>11. Conclusions</p><h3><strong>Background Context</strong></h3><h4><strong>Overview of Hiring Practices</strong></h4><p>Some digital companies, during the recruitment process to fill positions like:</p><ul><li>UX Designer</li><li>UX/UI — UI/UX Designer</li><li>Product Designer</li><li>Lead</li><li>Head of</li><li>Director of</li><li>UX Researcher*</li></ul><p>usually require a challenge at the second step, other times as first step.</p><p><em>*designers are the most involved, but the challenge can also be requested from UX Researchers, sometimes (and this happened to me) presented as a request to design something.</em></p><p>The design challenge also called a task or take-home assignment, usually consists of one of these requests:</p><p><strong>A.</strong> Conducting an audit of a web app or a mobile app (<em>generally an heuristic analysis</em>)</p><p><strong>B.</strong> Following a prompt that requires producing a certain type of deliverables/artifacts generally related to the design or redesign of a web app or a mobile app.</p><p>When the request directly concern the companye’s product or a client’s product, or when the work concerns a similar product, for example, an eCommerce company that requests a design challenge in the eCommerce sector albeit different in the type of product sold, then these challenges are called unethical and, when they require for the source file of the work, are considered the worst ever.</p><p>These challenges are considered unethical as the ideas, designs, and/or consultancy of the candidate could be used by the company to their advantage and without paying the candidate.</p><p>Another type of challenge is called “whiteboard challenge”, which, in addition to potentially falling into the above unethical categories, involves inviting the candidate to the office and asking them to solve a prompt at the whiteboard while members of the evaluation team observe the candidates and/or interact with them.</p><p>This latter is divided between whiteboard challenges that inform the candidates in advance of the prompt that will be given, thus providing context, and those that do not inform them.</p><p>In the digital age and post-Covid, this practice has been transferred to a video call, for example on Miro, FigJam, and other digital products capable of simulating a whiteboard.</p><p><strong>Personal notes</strong></p><p>The use of this practices does not seem to be confined to a specific industry, company size or country. In my personal experience I rarelly found whiteboard challenges here in Europe <em>(DE, IT , ES, GR mainly)</em></p><p>However, there could be a correlation between exposure to digital innovation/expansion and its practices (<em>resulting in a kind of spillover</em>), as well as the age of the company’s employees and their ability and interest in staying current.</p><p>For instance, individuals who are active on the internet and conduct research related to their profession, could become aware of this practices and subsequently introduce them to their company.</p><p>On the other hand, more mature individuals, aged 50+, could transpose it from the physical world (<em>such as architecture, graphic design</em>) to the digital one.</p><p>Furthermore, a candidate who had to complete a design challenge to secure a job, could emulate this practice to the next candidate if they ever find themselves in the position of being the interviewer.</p><p>Even at a contractual level, the context varies. For example, as a freelancer, I have never been asked to do a design challenge, possibly due to the fear of being invoiced, but I have been asked to do so as an employee.</p><h4><strong>Emergence of Design Challenges</strong></h4><p>Tracing the exact starting point of design challenges as a hiring practice proves tricky. Here’s why:</p><ul><li><strong>Global Variations:</strong> The timing could differ significantly across countries and continents. What might have emerged in one region years ago could be a newer trend elsewhere.</li><li><strong>Language Barriers:</strong> Exploring this topic across various languages adds another layer of complexity. For example, translating “design challenge” into Italian, my native language, it’s weird and probably I would have called it “lavoro gratis” (<em>free work</em>)<br>Someone more sophisticated, again in Italy, would have called it “lavoro speculativo” (<em>speculative work or spec work</em>) like in US.</li></ul><figure><img alt="Artificial illustrtion with just ornament purposes. It depicts people with 17th-18th century clothes and design of projects of that time" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-9WORbWpmYD7Firxknbo9A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The practice of unsolicited design work to prove your skills in order to get the job or the project, likely stretches further back 2000, especially in fields like graphic design and architecture, when it was and still it is called “spec work” or “speculative work”.</p><p>I found a trace of the term “spec work” in this pdf produced by <a href="https://irp-cdn.multiscreensite.com/1c74f035/files/uploaded/SYO%20Graphic%20Design%20compiled.pdf">Entrepreneur Inc dated 2004</a> with this word used by a Graphic Designer.</p><figure><img alt="The image it’s a screenshot of the following text: “Working on “spec,” is an area of contention among graphic designers. Some refuse to work on “pitches” or do graphic designs on speculation. “I do not participate in spec-work or pitches. It’s bad for graphic designers to take part in this type of business development strategy,” says Los Angeles-based Pertrula Vrontikis. “The graphic design industry doesn’t pitch for million-dollar accounts like an agency, or for assignments that last three…" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/933/0*XlBPm8ZMUpkv8ywJ" /></figure><p>Against this practice several sources emerged, like <a href="https://www.nospec.com/articles">nospec</a> (<em>a site that also offer articles against it</em>), a page on <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speculative_work">wikipedia</a></p><blockquote><strong>Speculative work</strong>, also known as spec work, is any kind of creative work that has been completed or submitted by volunteer designers to prospective clients, under the circumstances that a fair or reasonable fee has not been agreed upon in writing. Designers are required to invest time and resources to contest with each other to win a contract. — Wikipedia</blockquote><p>and this youtube video uploaded in 2011</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FDsstOs-K7gk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DDsstOs-K7gk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FDsstOs-K7gk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e80bbf98fe4b981a15c52c272edcb5d1/href">https://medium.com/media/e80bbf98fe4b981a15c52c272edcb5d1/href</a></iframe><p>The term “design challenge” is simply the evolution/adaptation of the term “spec work” applied to the digital context.</p><p>We have mention of it in a Twitter by <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jmspool/">Jared Spool</a> in 2006 (<em>I can’t find the screenshot</em>) and trace of the term on <a href="https://www.quora.com/Are-spec-work-exercises-in-design-job-interviews-good-or-bad/log">Quora in December 2010</a></p><figure><img alt="A Designer (possibly) asking on Quora in 2010 if spec work exercies in design job interviews are yes or a no" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/593/0*rMsDnd8kfn82vANe" /></figure><h4>Who is Behind Them</h4><p>I don’t have data on this specifically, but based on observations, when a company lacks dedicated designers or product managers, someone exposed to design challenges might implement them within the hiring process. In companies with product managers or owners, they often introduce them.</p><p>It’s worth noting that unless they have a background in UX design or behavioral sciences, none of the individuals mentioned above typically possess the complete knowledge to fully assess design candidates. Therefore, some companies opt to hire freelance designers for evaluation.</p><p>However, if a company has someone with a design title, they’re the most likely candidate to introduce the design challenge.</p><p>Unfortunately, in many cases, this practice is carried out by a fellow designer who often receives free rein from the company. Because the company itself lacks expertise in this area, they rely heavily on the designer’s judgment, even if the designer themselves may not have the complete knowledge required to effectively assess a candidate</p><h4><strong>Criticisms and Concerns</strong></h4><p>There is a general division among those who promote this practice:</p><ul><li>Those who consider it effective and indispensable for evaluating a candidate</li><li>Those who declare they <a href="https://orgdesignfordesignorgs.com/2018/05/15/design-exercises-are-a-bad-interviewing-practice/">have never used it</a>, such as <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/petermerholz/">Peter Merholz</a>, former co-founder at <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/adaptive-path/about/">AdaptivePath</a>, and those who strongly criticize it (Peter Merholz too)</li></ul><figure><img alt="A screenshot of part of the article availble at the above link associated with the firm “Adaptive Path”. It calls out that design challenges are not effective and does not help you in evaluate a candidate" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NIPd_jUMxt4ORu6e" /></figure><p>Concerns have been raised about their fairness, as they may favor candidates with more free time or resources.</p><p>Questions have also been raised about their effectiveness in accurately predicting job performance.</p><p>Additionally, there are concerns about inclusivity, as these challenges may inadvertently exclude talented candidates who are unable to participate due to various personal circumstances.</p><h4><strong>Purpose of the Article</strong></h4><p>The purpose of this study is to investigate into these criticisms by analyzing comments on LinkedIn related to design challenges.</p><p>The goal is to understand:</p><ul><li>Why designers dislike design challenges?</li><li>Are their motivations objective and/or science based?</li><li>Do they offer alternatives?</li></ul><p>By doing so, I aim to identify potential drawbacks of this hiring practice and explore alternative assessment methods that could lead to a more equitable and effective hiring process.</p><h3><strong>Methodology</strong></h3><h4>Data Collection</h4><p>The data for this research was collected from LinkedIn, a professional networking platform. A total of 9 threads were selected for analysis. These threads varied in nature — some expressed opinions about design challenges, others questioned their validity as an evaluation method, and some promoted collaborative methods as an alternative to take-home challenges.</p><h4>Data Analysis Approach</h4><p>A research was conducted on 186 comments selected from these threads. The selection was based on the relevance of the comments to the research questions:</p><p>“Why do people dislike design challenges?”</p><p>“Do they offer an alternative?”</p><p>12 themes were identified, some could be further merged, but I’ve decided to keep it a bit granular for a more nuanced understanding of the sentiments and perspectives expressed in the comments.</p><h4>Selection Criteria for Comments</h4><p>The selection of comments was based on their contribution to the research questions. Comments that were too short or did not contribute to the discussion were excluded. All selected comments were in English.</p><p>The vast majority of comments were from designers who criticized the use of design challenges, some included whiteboard challenges as well.</p><p>In contrast, there were fewer comments from designers who openly declared they were adopting design challenges in their hiring process. A small number of commenters implied they were using this method, but did not explicitly state so.</p><h4>Demographics</h4><p>The demographics of those who left a comment were diverse. They were mainly based in the USA, with a few from the EU and the Middle East.</p><p>They held various titles such as UX Researcher, UX Designer, CX Designer, Director of Design or UX, Product Designer, UX/UI Designer, Lead Designer, etc.</p><p>Their experience in the field ranged widely, with some having over 20 years of experience. They represented a broad spectrum of company sizes, from freelancers to employees of FANG companies.</p><p>This broad demographic and experiential range provided a rich and varied dataset for the research, offering insights from different perspectives and contexts within the design industry.</p><h3>Findings</h3><figure><img alt="Chart bar of the numbers of comments per theme. The numbers of comments associated with their specific theme, are written right after the Theme name in the following of the article" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/1*mvg5MRk6wH5j2qJ7FTmuxw.png" /></figure><h4>Themes</h4><p><strong>1.Distrust and Ineffectiveness in Hiring Process (135)</strong></p><p>The comments under this theme reveal a deep-seated skepticism about the efficacy of design challenges in providing an accurate measure of a candidate’s abilities.</p><p>They highlight concerns about the arbitrary nature of such assessments, a pervasive lack of trust in the hiring process, and the perceived inadequacy of interviews in fully capturing a candidate’s skills and fit for a role.</p><p>These comments not only question the effectiveness of design challenges but also express frustration and a reluctance to participate in such tasks, underscoring a broader distrust in the hiring process.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment with over 1000 reactions of a Designer complaining of a design challenge required in spite of a portfolio with 15 projects. I asked for another option and it was denied. The author is questioning “if my portfolio was satisfied you, then why give me a task to do again?”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/881/1*NJHXNhgVesFurHVkxKl4uw.png" /></figure><p><strong>2. Lack of Respect — Time Factor (85)</strong></p><p>The comments under this theme express a strong dissatisfaction with the perceived lack of respect for candidates’ time but also their expertise as designers with previous working experience should not be asked to perform homework.</p><p>These comments highlight concerns about the insufficient time allocated for task completion and the unrealistic requests and expectations set by design challenges.</p><p>There is a clear preference for assessment methods that do not demand excessive time investment from candidates (<em>eg portfolio walkthrough</em>).</p><p>They encompass expressions of frustration with the hiring process’s disregard for candidates’ efforts and a call for more transparent and respectful practices.</p><p><strong>3. Lack of Respect — Realism in Assessment (48)</strong></p><p>These comments highlight the inherent lack of realism in tasks due to missing data and other information which upset designers that perceive it as a lack of respect towards them and their profession.</p><figure><img alt="A likedin comment that complain about a company that asked for a design challenge, a user journey, without providing data forcing the UX Designer to invent things. The author then wonder “is this how they work in the company?” by guessing rather than by using data to devise solutions?" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/784/1*UAWVmlxhRJf3C1wzjKOPJQ.png" /></figure><p>The comments underscore the importance of respecting candidates and the need for creating realistic assessment scenarios. There is a clear preference for assessment that accurately reflect the challenges and dynamics of real-world design projects.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author complain that those asking for a design challenge aspect a solution in few hours but in reality the work take several hours. The author point out that hiring managers reply “we care about your questions” but the author reply “how can I have questions if I have never researched before the problem” referring thus to the lack of dummy content and realism of the challenge" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/762/1*1yeup_SXmWJ6jH8i6jNUvA.png" /></figure><p>They advocate for more realistic evaluation practices that take into account the candidate’s work processes and experiences.</p><p>Furthermore, these comments critique the lack of insight into candidates’ processes in take-home challenges.</p><p>Designers suggest that discussing case studies from their career provides a deeper and more meaningful insight into their work and enthusiasm for the field.</p><p><strong>4. Rejection and Avoidance of Design Tasks (65)</strong></p><p>This theme contains comments where individuals express their outright refusal to participate in design challenges.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author states he always refuse these challenges because he has a portfolio and point out he would prefer a live design collaboration." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/757/1*WMc7ZLZJO6jDm0me6KmDMg.png" /></figure><p>It includes instances where candidates decided to abandon the hiring process due to the presence of such task, or expressed an intention to avoid companies that require challenges in the future.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author says that he/she reject any sort of design challenge" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/870/1*L7m5vGbixdA1DfRRdhlz0w.png" /></figure><p>This theme highlight the strong negative reactions and proactive measures taken by some candidates in response to design challenges.</p><p><strong>5. Alternative Assessment Methods (55)</strong></p><p>The comments analyzed suggest a variety of alternative assessment methods that are seen as more inclusive and reflective of a candidate’s actual abilities, thus providing a fairer evaluation process.</p><ul><li><strong>Portfolio Reviews</strong><br>This is the most frequently suggested alternative. The designer responsible for the hiring, reviews the portfolio candidate on its own.</li></ul><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author says that portfolio reviews are more respectful and achieve better results" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/748/1*ZmQhZzfTf80PSs_6KUDlsg.png" /></figure><ul><li><strong>Collaborative Discussions</strong><br>Soft skill interview to understand how people work. The focus is trying to understand how it could be work together, a way for both, candidate and future colleague to see if there’s a fit.</li><li><strong>Portfolio Walkthrough</strong><br>This method provide insights into candidates’ thinking processes and collaborative abilities. It’s seen as more respectful of candidates’ time and expertise as they do not require speculative work.</li><li><strong>Tailored Tasks for Senior Roles</strong><br>Some comments suggest creating tasks that specifically test differentiating skills for senior roles, indicating a need for more tailored evaluation methods.</li><li><strong>Choice between Design or Whiteboard Challenge</strong><br>If the challenge is mandatory, a few comments suggest giving candidates the option to choose between a design challenge or a whiteboard challenge</li><li><strong>Whiteboard challenge</strong><br>One/two designers were preferring this method as they stated they could not perform well with design challenges.</li></ul><p>The overarching theme is a call for assessment methods that are more realistic, respectful, and reflective of the actual work designers do.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author is making an hironic comment. If the company feels it has to de-risk a candidate by asking a design challenge, then the author would like to ask a design challenge to the company so to de-risk him/he from ending in a company with poor management" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/783/1*hr4_rpL6UiH7OOGi_plFaA.png" /></figure><p><strong>6. Unpaid design challenge (49)</strong></p><p>In these comments designers express frustration with the expectation to complete design tasks without compensation, questioning the fairness and efficacy of such assessments.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin post. The author complain of an unethical challenge he did and was rejected without any feedback. He says he will never do again design challenges." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/710/1*Z429OYIZz2uoLa5J0u_Cmw.png" /></figure><p>There is a consensus that portfolios, resumes, and interviews should suffice for evaluating candidates, and the use of design tasks is viewed as outdated, unfair, and potentially exploitative.</p><p>These last aspects seem to play as an aggravating factor in front of the fact that the design challenge it’s not compensated.</p><p><strong>7. Ethical and Legal Concerns (47)</strong></p><p>This theme encompasses comments that underscore ethical and legal concerns associated with uncompensated design challenges.</p><p>Designers bring to light issues of fairness and legality, discussing the potential exploitation of a candidate’s work and expertise. They also raise concerns about adherence to fair labor practices.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author point out the possible legal consequences for businesses asking spec work without compensation." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/783/1*hsDgkmZBU1x-QgcbF7weEA.png" /></figure><p>Furthermore, these comments discuss various ethical dilemmas linked to design challenges. They highlight issues such as the lack of compensation, the potential exploitation of candidates’ time and ideas, and the exclusionary nature of these tasks.</p><p>Additionally, they express apprehensions about the fairness and transparency of the hiring process. There is a need for a more ethical and legally sound approach to design challenges in the hiring process.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. General comments that describe this practice as ineffective, borderline, unethical and inhumane stating that those asking for it prey on the power dynamics that a hiring company has over candidates and pointing out that these practices are not good at predicting if the candidate is qualified" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/776/1*kDsHQ2urr001FQc100hpwQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>8. Challenges with Portfolio not Being Valued (45)</strong></p><p>This theme includes comments from designers expressing frustration when their portfolios are not sufficiently evaluated or credited during the evaluation process.</p><p>These designers advocate for portfolios as the primary means of evaluation, as they believe these collections of work accurately represent their skills and experience.</p><p>Frustration is especially pronounced when design challenges require tasks identical to those already presented in their portfolios. These fictitious design challenges without dummy content are useless when a portfolio contains real scenarios or more detailed design challenges that instead included dummy content.</p><p>Design challenges are seen as redundant and dismissive of the effort and skills already demonstrated in their portfolios.</p><p>In summary, there’s a desire for a hiring process that recognizes and respects the value of candidate portfolios and avoids unnecessary duplication of the work already presented in them.</p><p><strong>9. Risk Mitigation and Fairness (43)</strong></p><p>In these comments, designers specifically call for compensation for candidates who invest their time in completing design challenges.</p><p>They argue that this would not only be a fairer practice but also a form of risk mitigation for both parties involved.</p><p>The comments highlight that if the attitude of those asking for the design challenge is to mitigate the risk of hiring an unsuitable designer, then the candidates should also be allowed to mitigate their own risks.</p><p>They point out that the not paid time invested in a design challenge could be used for another design challenge, paid or better crafted, preparing for an interview process that does not require a design challenge, applying to other jobs, and so on.</p><p>Designers emphasize the importance of creating a level playing field for all candidates, where their time and effort are respected and compensated.</p><p><strong>10. Lack of Human Centered Design (26)</strong></p><p>This theme contains comments that critique the hiring process for not adhering to human-centered design principles. The comments underscore the need for fair treatment and consideration of candidates’ time, skills, and unique ways of processing information.</p><p>They highlight that the hiring process often fails to consider the individuality of candidates, their diverse ways of processing information, and their other commitments.</p><p>The comments also advocate for a more human-centered approach to interviews. They emphasize the importance of empathy towards candidates and the need for meaningful discussions about the job and how candidates can contribute.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author point out that these challenges are not inclusive. If the candidate is working or it has children or other activities, there will be less time available compared to other candidates." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/778/1*379RcAYf5B4dM5pJKfQovQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. This comment enforce the previous one calling for a more human centered approach as this practice it’s not inclusive" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/754/1*EPEW3mDiNysJ9rIepzly1Q.png" /></figure><p>They critique interviewers who adopt a grill-style or test-like approach, calling for more empathetic and inclusive interview processes.</p><p><strong>11. Collaboration and Communication Assessment (8)</strong></p><p>This comments emphasize the importance of assessing candidates’ ability to collaborate and communicate effectively. Designers argue that these important aspects are often overlooked in design challenges, which may focus too heavily on technical skills or crafting abilities.</p><p>They advocate for observing how candidates articulate their thoughts, respond to feedback, and engage in constructive dialogue.</p><p>Designers commenting here are seeking for a 50–50 relationship with their colleagues engaged in evaluating, this is another type of “collaboration” they are looking for, suggesting that interview exercises should not feel like exams or performances but rather opportunities for mutual learning and understanding.</p><p>These comments also stress the importance of collaboration in design-based roles and suggest that design challenges may signal a lack of value for collaboration within a company, this because the design challenge happens in a siloed context and the whiteboard challenges are too short and often, like take at home challenges, badly designed.</p><p><strong>12. Inclusivity and Bias Concerns (6)</strong></p><p>This theme captures comments that address concerns related to inclusivity and potential biases in the hiring process.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment stating that they are not realistic, not inclusive, that do not assess the the collaborative skills and that the author of the comment has hired successful designers without asking for a take at home task" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/754/1*h-R2W98Y2l6FcXnaD0WN4g.png" /></figure><p>The comments point out how design challenges may disadvantage certain groups of candidates, such as neurodivergent individuals or those with limited time availability due to other responsibilities (<em>eg parenthood, caregiving, etc</em>).</p><p>They underscore how these challenges could perpetuate inequality in the hiring process by not accommodating the diverse needs and circumstances of all candidates.</p><p>These concerns persist, with designers asking for a more inclusive and equitable approach to design challenges in the hiring process.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author point out that design challenges are full of biases and that sound as incredibily lazy." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/779/1*U9jxF3b8qZvuAt8fY56-Aw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author point out the lack of inclusivity suggesting that companies in this way are excluding the groups of candidates with diverse perspectives that the company needs and stating that it assumes that everyone play by the rule adding the potential legal risk for the business asking for unpaid work." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/737/1*mf7gU2CFb4CZH-hyC32PKg.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Objective and/or Scientific Foundations of Designers Complaints</strong></h3><p>Designers through these comments has rised up many topics and problematics about design challenges, let’s see some of them.</p><h4>Lack of UX Design knowledge and so Human Centered Design</h4><p>User Experience (UX) Design is rooted in the scientific research method, drawing from fields such as behavioral and cognitive psychology, anthropology, sociology and human-computer interaction.</p><p>These disciplines provide the foundation for our research, educating us about cognitive heuristics and biases, and guiding us on how to mitigate them beside helping us to deconstruct interactions and not just between man and machine.</p><p>Moreover, these fields enable us to understand the human brain as a computer, with diverse processes that can vary from individual to individual. <br>This understanding can then leads us to the discovery of neurodivergent processes, for instance.</p><p>Among other things, this set of knowledge is what allows a UX Designer to work on a SaaS as well as an eCommerce without having previously worked on a SaaS or an eCommerce.</p><p>Part of this, it’s also because UX Design discover problems and devise solutions based on data coming from research, not on guessing, and this is why people called for “realism in design challenges”, because often are just prompts without dummy content, data.</p><blockquote>The one thing I can predict with certainty is that the principles of human psychology will remain the same, which means that the design principles here, based on psychology, on the nature of human cognition, emotion, action, and interaction with the world, will remain unchanged. — D.Norman (The Design of Everyday Things</blockquote><p>All along his book (<em>first published in 1988</em>) <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/donnorman/">Don Norman</a> reminds us of the connection with Psychology, not just with Technology and its importancy. At least other two times he has reiterated this, here when he complains of the lack of knowledge in designers in <a href="https://www.core77.com/posts/17993/why-design-education-must-change-17993">2010</a></p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a paragraph of the Don Norman essay presented in the link above and in which the connection of UX Design with sciences is made" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xG25RJN4yHyznU2Q83kt-w.png" /></figure><p>while here always in 2010 he underline the importancy of these scientific knowledges</p><figure><img alt="In this screenshot Don Norman complaints that students in design are not trained in behavioral sciences and to not anderstand the importancy of research to lead the design decisions" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XfWuZWzZ5JLN_EHHIgCwwQ.png" /></figure><p>again here in <a href="https://jnd.org/state-of-design-how-design-education-must-change/">2014</a></p><figure><img alt="In this screenshot Don Norman again reiterate that UX Design comes from sociology, cognitive science, anthropology" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OF9ZHT1FDPa4b2mWSPxaJw.png" /></figure><p>and Don Norman continue to call for this in the next years, also in 2016 when he point out that design became just craft.<br>It is no coincidence that perhaps all of the design challenges are just crafting, like in the job advertises: “wireframes, user flow, figma” no science required.</p><p>Yet in the end, scientific disciplines equip us with the ability to understand and effectively apply Human-Centered Design. <br>Once we internalize these principles, they can be utilized to identify issues in any form of interaction even human-to-human.</p><p>This understanding becomes so pervasive that it’s hard to pretend that our application of knowledge should be limited to the interaction between the customer and the product or service we’re working on.</p><p>Consequently, any objections to design challenges become transparent and self-evident.</p><h4>Limited Scope</h4><p>Design challenges frequently concentrate on particular tasks or scenarios, which might not adequately represent the full range of a designer’s abilities and experiences.</p><p>Candidates often perceive these challenges as an oversimplification of the design process, failing to evaluate their capacity to address intricate problems.</p><p>This refers to the fact that these challenges often focus solely on the crafting aspect, neglecting considerations such as user needs, usability, accessibility, research analysis or, the focus, may be exclusively on a single aspect.</p><p>This limited scope combined with a lack of realism, make often looks design challenges as ceremonies rather than evaluative processes.</p><p>Books likes “The Design of Everyday Things”, “Emotional Design: Why We Love (or Hate) Everyday Things”, the snapshots of Don Norman essays or article like this one about <a href="https://www.hci.org.uk/article/the-role-of-emotional-design-in-user-experience-a-comprehensive-analysis/">emotional design</a>, highlight the complexity and breadth of design work, suggesting that design challenges focusing narrowly on specific tasks or scenarios may indeed not fully capture a designer’s skills and experience.</p><h4>Artificial Environment &amp; Realism (lack of dummy content)</h4><p>Design challenges are conducted in artificial or isolated environments, disconnected from real-world design scenarios.</p><p>Designers argue that this, artificiality hinders their ability to showcase their true capabilities and problem-solving skills.<br>I think we can back up with science some of the elements that were part of the above themes:</p><p><strong>— Lack of User Interaction and Feedback<br></strong><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Influence:_Science_and_Practice">Social proof </a>and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring_effect">anchoring</a> (just to mention two) are psychological concepts that play significant roles in user behavior and decision-making process not just for a person using a product or a service, but for everyone, the candidate too.</p><p>Social proof is the tendency we have to conform to the actions or behaviors of others especially when we are uncertain. <br>Anchoring refers to the cognitive bias we have when we relies too heavily on an initial piece of information when making decisions.</p><p>These concepts aren’t inherently negative and they can be leveraged to guide user behavior and improve user experience.</p><p>For example, in a design challenge, in absence of user feedback, a candidate could leverage the principles of social proof by use existing data as a form of social proof.</p><p>Anchoring instead, could be used to make strategic design decisions. If the design brief mentions specific user expectations or industry standards, these can serve as ‘anchors’ that guide the process and the candidate can then design solutions that meet or exceed these anchored expectations.</p><p>However, in the typical design challenge scenario (<em>as well whiteboard</em>), the lack of dummy content (<em>fake user interviews, personas, empathy maps etc</em>), place this evaluative method into a limbo of everything and nothing that make it challenging for designers to effectively apply these concepts.</p><p>Without dummy content, designers may struggle to evaluate the effectiveness of their solutions and may lack confidence in their work.</p><p>This can undermine their ability to showcase their true capabilities and problem-solving skills, as they are unable to demonstrate how their designs would perform in real-world scenarios or how they would respond to user feedback and iterate on their designs accordingly.</p><p>— <strong>Artificial Pressure<br></strong>Many design challenges, in addition to not taking into account the candidate’s available time, often have extremely tight delivery times (<em>for example 48 hours</em>) which make this evaluation method further ineffective.</p><p>Stress and pressure can impair cognitive function and decision-making.</p><p>High levels of anxiety or stress can reduce the efficiency of cognitive processing and often lead to impaired performance, moreover also time pressure can negatively contribute as it can influence decision-making and task performance.</p><blockquote>Indeed, working memory, attention, response inhibition and cognitive flexibility have all been found to be impaired by stress (Girotti et al., 2017). At work, impairments in these domains translate to a reduced ability to concentrate, control our impulses, remember and plan. — <a href="https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3610068">Cambridge Cognition</a></blockquote><p><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-07901-1">This study on Nature</a> called “Time pressure changes how people explore and respond to uncertainty” studied the way in which time pressure affect our decision making and help to sustain “spec work detractors” motivations.</p><p><strong>— Emphasis on Style over Substance<br></strong>Spec challenges lacking of dummy content, often end up to emphasize visual outputs, potentially overlooking a candidate’s critical thinking, research skills, and ability to adapt to real-world constraints.</p><p>Psychology again explain this through cognitive heuristics, social belives and the way in which our brain works and form quick irrational decisions.</p><h4>Time Constrain</h4><p>While the unjustified time constrains posed by design challenges can negatively impact the quality of the final output of the challenge in any candidate, neurodivergent individuals, such as those with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), dyslexia, and other neurocognitive conditions, may require more time to process information, organize their thoughts, and complete task.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author complaint about time constraint stating that 5 days are never enough to complete the task and calling out for a lack of inclusivity for those who has other activities (eg childcaring)" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/774/1*NB_8l8_0qmam8cHWzVvgNA.png" /></figure><p>The strict time constraints of design challenges can be particularly challenging for them, as they may struggle to work effectively under pressure within the allotted time frame, thus penalizing them over the other candidates but yet being perfectly able to perform the job within the company and, in some exceed in analysis over more traditional individuals.</p><p>Furthermore, this study titled <a href="https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3610068">“How Time Pressure in Different Phases of Decision-Making Influences Human-AI Collaboration”</a> (<em>very interesting to read for the take on AI) </em>found that human cognitive and decision-making abilities depreciate under pressure.</p><p>This conclusion is also supported by the studies from RA Barkley (<em>note: in some there are also children in the demography</em>), <a href="https://dyslexia.yale.edu/comments-by-drs-sally-bennett-shaywtiz-on-dyslexia-adaaa/">Bennett Shaywtiz</a> on Dyslexia and this other <a href="https://healthmanagement.co.uk/our-insights/articles/dyslexia-awareness/#:~:text=People%20with%20dyslexia%20may%20experience,follow%20a%20list%20of%20instructions.">article</a>.</p><figure><img alt="A statement from the above research that says time constrains are administrative convenience and does not help to evaluate intelligence or potential" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gE28AZsBPeGfyjgUI2HXqQ.png" /></figure><p>Lastly, while not specifically highlight in the comments, assessments for any candidate, must abide by equal employment opportunity laws to avoid any discrimination or adverse impact on candidates.</p><h4><strong>Subjectivity in evaluation</strong></h4><p>Although we are well aware that the evaluation of a candidate is a process highly subjective rather than objective, design challenges are often created with such a high level of approximation that they become even more subjective and therefore poorly effective in their evaluation.</p><p>As we have seen above, there is a latent lack of basic knowledge of the scientific principles that govern the fundamentals of UX and HCI that instead could help in improving the process.</p><p>This is compounded by the fact that design challenges are often created without any care; they often seem thrown together by our potential future colleague, as if to say:</p><p>“Here’s the design challenge, I’ve done it, now I’m done.”</p><p>Sometimes they are presented on PDFs without paying attention to:</p><ul><li>information architecture and white space management</li><li>without clearly specifying what the deliverables are</li><li>without clearly indicating what will be evaluated and what will not</li><li>and without dummy content</li></ul><p>All this laxity opens up all possible scenarios, and without reference points. For example, the candidate may say one thing and the designer responsible for the evaluation may say the exact opposite and be convinced they are right without any supporting data.</p><p><strong>— Lack of Standardized Evaluation Criteria<br></strong>One of the key issues contributing to subjectivity in evaluation is the absence of standardized evaluation criteria for design challenges.</p><p>Without clear guidelines on what constitutes successful performance, designers in charge of the evaluation may rely on personal preferences or biases when assessing candidates’ work.</p><p>In many cases, design challenges are evaluated in an unstructured manner, with the designer evaluator providing feedback based on their individual impressions rather than following a systematic evaluation process.</p><p>It can be considered somewhat paradoxical as we are talking about conducting user interviews... <br>The role of a designer typically involves things like understanding, empathy, research, critical thinking, metacognition etc</p><p>However, when it comes to evaluating candidates in a hiring process, especially through design challenges, the criteria for assessment may not always be as clear or standardized as one might expect.</p><p>This lack of standardized evaluation criteria can lead to discrepancies and unfair treatment of candidates.</p><p><strong>— Variability in Evaluator Expertise</strong><br>Another factor contributing to subjectivity in evaluation is the variability in evaluator expertise and experience.</p><p>Design challenges may be evaluated by designers with differing levels of familiarity with design principles, industry standards, and best practices.</p><p>Evaluator expertise can impact the reliability and validity of assessment outcomes, with less experienced evaluators exhibiting higher levels of subjectivity and inconsistency in their judgments.</p><p>Without adequate training and calibration among evaluators, there is a risk of biased or unreliable evaluations that may disadvantage certain candidates.<br>Which is another reason for not implementing this practice, which should not be implement because:</p><ul><li>“I feel powerful”</li><li>“I feel proud”</li><li>“Wow I am responsible for the evaluation, such prestige”</li><li>“I’m feeling cool”</li><li>“This makes look me/us professional/s”</li></ul><p>There’s nothing wrong in saying:</p><p>“I can’t do it”</p><p>and this is indeed is also another problem, some of us grow in the field with the wrong colleagues around, often ready to grill us and thus increasing social pressure.</p><p>The following was a comment about lack of training:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author point out it must be recognized that sometime designers involved in the hiring process, just end up to be involved in it without having any type of training, thus opting for a design challenge." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/695/1*ACG1egcmbKPU5ufDtwo9uA.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Negative Impacts for Businesses</strong></h3><p>Here we try to draw some conclusions about the possible negative consequences for businesses insisting with this practice.</p><p><strong>— Limited Insight<br></strong>Design challenges may not provide a comprehensive understanding of a candidate’s abilities (<em>interdisciplinarity of the profession</em>).<br>If a company’s hiring process doesn’t accurately assess a designer’s skills, it could lead to hiring individuals who aren’t the best fit for the team or the work, potentially affecting the quality of the team’s output.</p><p>— <strong>Restricted Talent Acquisition<br>A.</strong> Businesses or Designers evaluators that mandate unpaid design tasks, risk alienating skilled candidates who respect their time and abilities, and who might be willing to undertake a paid design challenge.</p><p><strong>B. </strong>Experienced professionals and candidates who perceive the challenge as poorly constructed or lacking necessary data, may choose to bypass it entirely.</p><p><strong>C.</strong> Designers whose portfolios already extensively demonstrate their interdisciplinary skills, may decline challenges that necessitate redundant replication of existing portfolio content.</p><p><strong>D.</strong> Candidates with time constraints and those with neurodivergent conditions, might opt out of participation due to concerns about being evaluated based on the final work, which could be adversely affected by limited time availability or unique information processing methods.</p><p>These factors could lead to a narrowed candidate pool, potentially resulting in missed opportunities to recruit a diverse and highly competent design team.</p><p><strong>— Lack of Diversity</strong><br>A hiring process that is not accommodating of diverse needs and circumstances could lead to a lack of diversity in the workforce. This could limit the range of perspectives and ideas within the company and negatively impact innovation and problem-solving.</p><p><strong>— Reputation Damage<br></strong>If word gets out that a company is essentially asking for free work during the hiring process, or worst an unethical design challenge, it could harm their reputation in the industry and limit the talent pool.</p><p><strong>— Human-Centered Design Principles Perception</strong><br><strong>A. </strong>By ignoring the principles of human-centered design, companies may be showing a lack of empathy for their candidates. <br>This could be a red flag for designers who value empathy and human-centerd thinking and may be as well a red flag of the way in which the design team or the design evaluator work.</p><p><strong>B. </strong>Without considering the emotions and psychology of candidates, companies may not be getting a full understanding of a candidate’s problem-solving abilities, creativity, and design thinking.</p><p>— <strong>Lack of Critical Thinking<br></strong>Persisting with poorly crafted design challenges, despite evidence suggesting their ineffectiveness, may indicate a lack of critical thinking or metacognition in the hiring process.</p><h3>What designers wants?</h3><p>Designers are calling for a more human-centered approach to the hiring process, one that prioritizes fairness, inclusivity, one that respect their time, expertise, accurately reflect the realities of the job and consider their individual circumstances and needs.</p><p>This includes a shift away from design challenges that are seen as unrealistic, time-consuming, and potentially exploitative, towards alternative assessment methods that provide a fairer and more comprehensive evaluation of their skills and abilities.</p><p>They seek reforms that address the shortcomings of traditional design challenges and align with the principles of human-centered design.</p><p>This includes incorporating realism, authenticity, and comprehensive assessment methods, as well as accommodating the needs of neurodivergent individuals.</p><p>They aim to create a recruitment process that fosters a positive candidate experience.</p><h4><strong>Their 5 points</strong></h4><p><strong>1.Comprehensive Assessment</strong><br>Designers seek assessments that encompass the full spectrum of their skills and experiences, rather than focusing narrowly on specific tasks or scenarios.</p><p>This involves evaluating critical thinking, research skills, adaptability, and collaboration, in addition to visual design abilities.<br>They want this to be done through their portfolio as it provide projects and case studies based on data.</p><p>They want peer to peer interviews with their future colleagues, so to test soft skills, explore how both parties thinks and see how they could work together, this may involve developers too.<br>The understand that the lack of a portfolio, may trigger the request of a task.</p><p><strong>2. Realism and Authenticity</strong><br>If the designer evaluator insist with a design challenge (<em>whiteboard too</em>) designers want it closely mimic real-world design scenarios, allowing them to showcase their true capabilities and problem-solving skills.</p><p>This involves incorporating dummy content like interviews answers to analyze, personas, user journeys and so on.</p><p><strong>3. Objective Evaluation Criteria</strong><br>Designers advocate for the establishment of standardized evaluation criteria to ensure fairness and consistency in the assessment process.</p><p>Clear guidelines on what constitutes successful performance can help mitigate subjectivity and bias in evaluations.</p><p>In case of a design challenge, this also means clearly state what are the aspected deliverables (<em>sketches, mid/high wireframes, prototypes, task analysis, interviews, user journey etc</em>) and what is going to be evaluated and what not.</p><p><strong>4. Inclusivity and Support for Neurodiversity<br></strong>Designers emphasize the importance of accommodating neurodivergent individuals, such as those with ADHD, ASD, or dyslexia, who may require additional time and support to demonstrate their skills effectively.</p><p>Flexible time constraints and alternative assessment methods can help level the playing field for all candidates.</p><p><strong>5. Professional Development Opportunities</strong><br>Designers value opportunities for learning and growth throughout the recruitment process.</p><p>Constructive feedback regardless of the outcome of the assessment it’s desired but in case of design challenges, is strongly demanded.</p><h4>Their Atlernatives</h4><p><strong>1. Portfolio Walkthrough </strong><br>Portfolios contain work that designers have completed in real-world scenarios, often for actual clients.</p><p>They argued that portfolios offer a more holistic view of their capabilities compared to a single design challenge, which may not capture the breadth and depth of their expertise.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin comment. The author states that the same can be achieved with a portfolio walkthrough." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*8csQ1TKIZJqaRORCkHwAOg.png" /></figure><p>Portfolios often include projects that detail the designer’s process from start to finish, providing insight into their problem-solving approach, decision-making process, and ability to handle feedback and revisions.</p><p>This gives a more accurate representation of their skills and how they apply them in practice.</p><p><em>Personal note:<br></em>It’s indeed bizarre that some designers reject entry levels and junior portfolios for containing design challenges or case studies (<em>notice that a case study is based on data</em>) calling them not real, and then in their place, they propose design and whiteboard challenges that are not real and without data.</p><p><strong>2. Peer to Peer Interview</strong><br>This format involves informal discussions or “chit-chat” sessions that go beyond technical assessments and delve into soft skills, collaboration dynamics, and work styles.</p><p>In these interviews candidates have the opportunity to interact with team members who they would likely collaborate with closely if hired (typically designers, then developers and the product managers). This allows both candidates and interviewers to see if there’s a “vibe” but also to understand they works.</p><p><a href="https://eriksitter.medium.com/07659a11254d">To read the second part of the article click here</a></p><p><strong>Link sources<br></strong><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7046177700062842880/">Linkedin 1</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/jmspool_ive-been-saying-for-years-that-whiteboarding-activity-6975973628576153600-4d87/?originalSubdomain=fr">Linkedin 2</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6975829705887207425/">Linkedin 3</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/glorialo94_how-to-solve-a-product-design-challenge-activity-6863247579778572288-LluV/?trk=public_profile_like_view&amp;originalSubdomain=au">Linkedin 4</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/michael-olamide-0a544a202_yesterday-i-declined-a-design-task-or-test-activity-6955110868665679872-9ChJ/?trk=public_profile_like_view&amp;originalSubdomain=gh">Linkedin 5</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/cameronmoll_hiresmarter-interviewtips-interviewing-activity-6912014304292556800-Lsza/">Linkedin 6</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/zanderwhitehurst_ux-ui-career-activity-7119652215446716416-PxgB/?trk=public_profile_share_view">Linkedin 7</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/sam-bowring-185a76172_ux-designchallenges-homework-activity-7094860859549626368-Lc3l/">Linkedin 8</a><br><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7157070258917326848/">Linkedin 9</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a69ea62fb94" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxplanet.org/design-challenges-designers-demand-reform-as-unfair-tasks-miss-the-mark-part-i-2a69ea62fb94">Design Challenges: Designers Demand Reform as Unfair Tasks Miss the Mark (part I)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxplanet.org/">UX Planet</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Striking the Balance: The Intersection of Common Sense and User Research in UX Design]]></title>
            <link>https://uxplanet.org/striking-the-balance-the-intersection-of-common-sense-and-user-research-in-ux-design-8efd21a70276?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8efd21a70276</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[common-sense]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Aug 2023 18:07:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-14T18:07:56.776Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Vector draw with pastel colors, mainly cold ones as blue, light blue, violet and some pink. At the center an ipad with a diagram, on the left side of the viewere, the draw of a man half the size of the ipad, standing upon two books, wearing a blue shirt, yellow trousers and a magnifier pointing at the ipad screen, on the right side of the viewer a man with blue trouser a violent shirt, a blue paper in his left hand and the right hand point the ipad" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XBZcBg-HfKpzfZ8Vdvkbnw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/businessmen-with-magnifier-looking-business-process-flow-chart-business-rules-regulation-main-company-policy-it-business-analysis-concept_10780482.htm#page=3&amp;query=intersection%20research%20illustration&amp;position=8&amp;from_view=search&amp;track=ais%22">Image by vectorjuice</a></figcaption></figure><p>In this essay I’ll be exploring a thought-provoking statement that touches on the fine balance between intuition and empirical data in the world of UX design.</p><p>While I was online I stumbled in a statement that incorporated:</p><ul><li>Design Patterns</li><li>Common Sense</li><li>Research</li></ul><p>If you are a researcher, you probably already know where we are going, it’s just that when you read “common sense” and “research” together, you have that shiver down your spine isn’t it? You damn rare beast of these dark days!</p><p>That statement, with thousands of likes, that in line of principle I found correct but that in practice, I personally find over generic, was saying:</p><blockquote>You don’t need to validate every small design choice to get the confidence to proceed with it.<br>You don’t need a usability study to test straightforward functionality like basic forms.<em><br></em>If you use software intentionally and develop a good general understanding of how people interact with software, you should be able to design universal interactions without asking users if they make sense.<br>Research is complex and expensive. Keep research for challenging systemic problems.<br>Don’t waste your effort and time on testing stuff that should be obvious to design if you have ever used any popular piece of software.<br>Use your common sense and avoid over-complicating interactions.<br>There are consumer apps serving millions of users effectively, and they do it with well-established interaction patterns. Emulate those. Don’t reinvent the wheel.</blockquote><p>There was also a funny comment from a Senior Product Designer that I wanted to recall because I found it quiet symbolic, it was saying:</p><figure><img alt="line drawing, black and white, stylized humanoid figure, without hair, with a proud and fearless gaze, often used as a “meme”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/266/0*0zBW7PiR3Pol39XF" /></figure><blockquote>The opinion you hold will get you a lot of hate from <strong>ux purists</strong>. I’m not one of them.</blockquote><p>What is a UX purist? It made me imagine these hate filled purists living in Gilead and keeping poor Product Designers and UI Designers as servants while preaching them the Bible of Usability 😅</p><p>But then, what would be a non purist UX? the one that skip research and simply follows common sense for basic things? (<em>which basically was me in 2000 doing web design 😁</em>) and who/what define what are small things? and straightforward? and what is common sense?</p><p>Because normally, striking the right balance between thorough research and practical implementation is often one of the keys to succeed and often… balance is missing within us.</p><p>That’s why I recalled that comment and decided to include it. Besides the fact that it has that vintage clichéd flavor where UX Designers are labeled as purists, with a negative connotation, as soon as they try to express a “<strong>UXerly Thinking</strong>.”😅</p><p>Now let’s go back to the statement I was referring:</p><blockquote><strong>1.</strong> “You don’t need to validate every small design choice to get the confidence to proceed with it.”</blockquote><p>What is a small design? in what context? is it small for you, for me, for us or for them? <br>Ok, yes in line of principle is true, I mean there’s a validity to some extent, but how many, would actually understand it as a line of principle? and how many kidnapped by confirmation bias would fall for it without first thinking at 360°?</p><p>It is true that not every small design choice requires validation, especially if it aligns with established design patterns and best practices. However, some level of validation and user feedback is still essential to ensure that the design meets the specific needs and preferences of the target users.</p><p>Not only, we are not machines and we are not infallible, testing, design critique etc serve as a litmus test.</p><p>Incorporating user feedback and validation, even for seemingly minor design elements, can lead to valuable insights that help refine the overall user experience.</p><p>Moreover, user behavior and preferences can vary significantly across different contexts and user groups and what might seem like a minor design decision to a us, could have a substantial impact on the user’s experience.</p><blockquote><strong>2.</strong> “You don’t need a usability study to test straightforward functionality like basic forms.”</blockquote><p>Ok, in line of principle is true, but there is the usual “it depends” which doesn’t make this sentence valid, but partially valid.<br>Basic forms may seem straightforward, but they can still impact the user experience significantly. <br>This statement also assume that on the other side there’s “someone” who knows what he is doing, which is not necessarily true.</p><p><em>“Ah Erik what the hell, come on, if someone is working in the field he/she certainly know how to implement a straightforward functionality like a basic form”</em></p><p>Well no, not necessary. I may simply mention the fact that from the early 2002–2003 more or less, UX, which started as a “terminology extension/evolution” of usability, has been progressively engulfed by professions that were already established in that time, like Web Designers, UI Designers, Product Designers and Visual Designers.</p><p>Furthermore, from the year 2013 starting with General Assembly, all major Bootcamps, and some master I saw, have built “UX” around a web design core, totally neglecting psychology (<em>eg name a Bootcamp that explain the stages of cognition or cognitive heuristics or in vivo coding in qualitative research) </em>and minimizing usability teachings, rather than build UX around a psychology/usability core which would have anyway naturally led to including web design aspects.</p><p>The reality is that the ability to design and implement a user-friendly form is not always a given, even for experienced designers.</p><p>Designing a seemingly simple form that meets user expectations and is easy to use requires one of these three things:</p><ul><li><strong>A</strong>. You didn’t study but you have absorbed this knowledge by osmosis, being exposed to forms that were correctly crafted, being exposed to colleagues that passed you the correct information.</li><li><strong>B</strong>. You have studied and you understand various usability principles, best practices, and the psychological aspects of user behavior.</li><li><strong>C</strong>. None of the above, but you are proactive, you understand that everything on the screen should be there for a reason, crafted in a certain way, so you have questions and you do some quick secondary research.</li></ul><p>Objectively, the validity of the statement depends on the individual designer’s expertise. While experienced designers might have a better intuition about form design, it doesn’t eliminate the need for usability testing.</p><p>Some example?<br>Well there are a lot of forms that continue to use a label as placeholder, not accessible forms and forms that let the user guess what fields are mandatories or does not clearly communicate the mistakes the user made while filling up the form itself.</p><p>Even straightforward functionality like basic forms can have usability challenges that might not be immediately apparent and even if in principle usability studies might not be necessary for simple forms, conducting some level of usability testing or user feedback is beneficial to identify any potential issues.</p><p>Let’s see some example of forms that I guess, would be defined as straightforward:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a sign in form with usability mistakes described in the body text of the article" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/1*dn0CgAXL63itzQap_Ehqug.png" /></figure><p>The first thing you see here, is a label used as placeholder. We already know that this is not recommended and we know it thanks to… well research! 😁 and if you personally didn’t do that specific research, there’s still NNgroup that inform you about this.</p><p>Labels should be placed outside of the placeholder, because when you type in the text field, the label disappears and the memory aid function is lost, furthermore some users could get confused and think that the field is already filled in.</p><p>In this case though the form uses a floating label, which is an alternative, but this is typically a mobile design solution. We use a floating label because we need to save room on mobile viewports and mobile app, here I was on a desktop.</p><p>Once the floating label is triggered, I have two problem now, the characters are too small and the contrast ratio is too low.</p><p>Let’s move on, do you see anything else? Well there’s a bit of work around the hyperlinks, isn’t?</p><p>Best, would be to underline hyperlinks, this indicate people that they can click on them, instead of guessing they can, which would also be an heuristic mistake. <br>Of course, hovering over the hyperlink and displaying the underline:</p><figure><img alt="Bottom portion of the sign in form that evidence how on mouse hover the link “need help” becomes underlined" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/374/1*8pzSiAxlTeb9R0XKDINJRA.png" /></figure><p>it’s an acceptable alternative, but the hyperlink should also be different from the body text which is not</p><figure><img alt="Bottom portion of the sign in form that evidence how there are three hyperlinks all designed in a different way, one in grey without being underlined, one in white against a grey body text, and one in blue against a grey body text" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/338/1*hc62af5AM_538TCVbqtWLQ.png" /></figure><p>and when you click on “Need Help” you get this:</p><figure><img alt="Image that shows a form of the same site, where the hyperlink “learn more” is designed in grey and underlined, instead of blue and without being underlined, pointing out a design lack of coherence" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/510/1*X6hDOsOVNsCneW0-y6aTBA.png" /></figure><p>where you can see that the hyperlink part of the body text is actually underlined, while “need help” wasn’t.</p><p>However if we go back we see that we have an hyperlink indicated in white (sign up) one without indication (need help) and one “learn more” which however it’s not in blue, but in grey and also underlined, pointing out there’s also a certain lack of congruence.</p><p>Last but not least, people who cannot perceive color differences cannot identify links.</p><p>But there’s something more, if you click on “learn more” in the first form, you get this:</p><figure><img alt="bottom of the sign in form, showing that once the user click on the hyper link “learn more” instead of going on another page, the text “learn more” disappear and unfold 5 line of text related with privacy policy and terms of service" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/361/1*H1XuFg3O4QTaVDIm6tuMNw.png" /></figure><p>“learn more” disappear and a new text unfold below. This can be confusing for the user, and doesn’t really look as a common pattern in response to an hyperlink.</p><p>Here instead there’s another problem and a heuristic breach:</p><figure><img alt="again the same sign in form, this time the screenshot highlight that there are conditions for the password, as exaplained in the text of the article" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/449/1*3hthG-OTT0X4CWIL6atQgg.png" /></figure><p>You only know there’s a rule for the password (between 4 and 60 characters), only once you make a mistake, instead we should be informed in advance.</p><p><em>“Don’t set users up for failure with secret rules” — Kathryn Whitenton, NNGroup</em></p><p>This is another form with similar problems:</p><figure><img alt="Contact form from another business where mandatory fields are not indicated, except when you skip them" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/599/1*cMajqnswkzMujrovqTxEhQ.png" /></figure><p>mandatory fields are not indicated, moreover it seems that only the red fields are mandatory, yet when you fill them up and you click on the CTA button, this is what you get:</p><figure><img alt="Same contact form from the previous company, highlighting that there are mandatory fields that appear as such only in a second moment, when the previous one are filled and you try to submit the form" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/1*efOtVEAYWQebybu5Zyqd_A.png" /></figure><p>Aha! so also the telephone/mobile fields were mandatory, but we only found it later. So I fill up the missing fields and I click the CTA and this is what happens:</p><figure><img alt="Same contact form that highlight that in spite of having filled the input field (except the message box, which by the way was the only non mandatory field” the user receive e generic message saying try again" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*hFNk9U0sB_2d_vsB7HHetw.png" /></figure><p>I simply got this error message telling me “please try again” but what’s the problem? <br>It doesn’t help me to correct any mistake I may have done and because I cannot find a work around, it’s a high level heuristic error.</p><p>You may think that it’s because I didn’t type in anything in the message box, but it’s not the case, also because this form when I’ve took the screenshot was able to send a message without actually writing something in the text box, after all, it’s not a mandatory field.</p><blockquote><strong>3. </strong>“If you use software intentionally and develop a good general understanding of how people interact with software, you should be able to design universal interactions without asking users if they make sense.”</blockquote><p>How far does this sentence go? are we in the MVP realm?<br>I mean, if I was still a web designer yeah, go for it, but as UXer, to me it doesn’t look entirely true.<br>Having a good understanding of user behavior is important, but it doesn’t replace the need for user research and usability testing.</p><p>Users might have diverse needs and preferences, and designing without involving them can lead to assumptions that may not hold true in practice. Also, can research be synthetized in simply asking users if the interactions make sense?</p><p>Designing universal interactions that cater to a broad range of users is undoubtedly a “cool” goal, however, and it seem so by what I’m understanding, assuming that a good general understanding of how people interact with software is enough to achieve this without involving users in the design process can be risky.</p><p>This because it’s the same cognitive psychology that teaches us that individuals process information differently based on their experiences, backgrounds, and cognitive abilities and so accommodating this diversity can only be achieved through direct involvement and feedback from users.</p><p>Are we here still in the realm of skipping research under the above so far stated situations? Can research be skipped by simply using established design patterns? :/</p><blockquote><strong>4</strong>. “Research is complex and expensive. Keep research for challenging systemic problems.”</blockquote><p>“Research is complex and expensive” well… first a moment of silence for those UX Researchers that may have landed here and now crying in a corner.</p><p>Most of the times I’ve heard that research is complex and expensive, was from people opting for qualitative research, writing questions that could potentially trigger bias and getting away with the final results without calculating the statistic value of such data: “yeah! let’s do surveys they are cheap🥰”…😒</p><p>Also, doesn’t sound like one of those clichéd and hackneyed phrases born in the past and repeated over time like a justifying mantra that no longer finds correspondence with reality?</p><p>All in all, yes, general speaking it is true that some research efforts can be complex and expensive, but it’s essential to recognize that user research is not a one-size-fits-all approach. The level of complexity and resource allocation for research should be tailored to the specific project’s needs and objectives, moreover it’s 2023 and with advancements in technology and research methodologies, user research doesn’t always have to be prohibitively expensive.</p><p>I saw managers crying at the idea of just 10 user interviews saying ”it would take too long”, I heard a CEO telling me “so what do you want? that I allow you to do research? and then what? bringing me the results in three years?” and I saw managers allocating one month of generative research for an MVP and getting a high quality result with dozens of interviews and qualitative data analysis annexed.</p><blockquote><strong>5.</strong>“Don’t waste your effort and time on testing stuff that should be obvious to design if you have ever used any popular piece of software.”</blockquote><p>Eh, ok sure again, generally speaking yes, do not waste effort and time, but:<br>Who says what should be obvious?<br>What is obvious? <br>Obvious for who? for us? for business people that may read this sentence in a dogmatic way and victim of confirmation bias get back in their offices and start to cut on research? ’cause actually it often happen in this way😅</p><p>This sentence raises an essential point about not assuming that what is obvious to a designer will also be evident to users.</p><p>I had to cancel an advertise in FB marketplace in order to republish it. I did it and FB without informing me, deleted all the conversations I had in my messenger with the buyers that asked me about the deleted product I was giving away. <br>Beside failing an heuristic audit, it has also broken a mental model, the one for which the messages in my messenger stays there, unless I do not go to delete that messages, and I didn’t.</p><p>Was for the well paid super expert design team in FB an obvious action to take without inform the end user? Well was not obvious for me.</p><p>Curiously, if the delete process you indicate the item was given away through FB marketplace, you will get a pop up informing you that the user messages you received, will be deleted.</p><p>Even if certain design choices seem obvious to us, they might not align with the mental models or behaviors of the actual users. Users come from diverse backgrounds and have varying levels of digital literacy, so we cannot assume that everyone will approach the product in the same way.</p><p>Hence, relying solely on personal assumptions about what is obvious in design can be a pitfall.</p><p>While we may have a deep understanding of popular software and common interaction patterns, it’s important to remember that each product or application has its unique context and user base.</p><p><strong>Any popular piece of software, may be popular, but still have a wrong design either because everybody copied everybody, or because nobody did research.</strong><br>Relying solely on personal assumptions can lead to blind spots in the design, and user testing is there right to uncover issues that we may not have anticipated, leading to a more refined and user/human-centered product, or in another scenario, service.</p><blockquote><strong>6.</strong>”Use your common sense and avoid over-complicating interactions.”</blockquote><p>Has common sense to be used in general? <br>Has to be used to identify the obvious “stuff” mentioned in the sentence 5, or it has to be used to avoid over-complicating interactions?</p><p>In line of principle it’s valid, but the above forms example were designed by businesses with more than a designer and as well with a director/head, yet the design had basic problems.</p><p>This because common sense is:</p><ul><li><strong>Subjective</strong><br>Our thought processes, cognitive biases, and mental models all influence how we interpret and make sense of the world around us. These factors can affect our perceptions, decision-making, and understanding of various situations, including user interactions with digital interfaces.</li><li><strong>Knowledge based</strong><br>Besides the lines in the previous point, common sense it’s also knowledge based. Our capability to assess a situation using common sense rely on what we know, and what we know does not necessary match the seniority of our job title, even when it’s just about basics things.</li><li><strong>Also intuition based<br></strong>Common sense is also based on our intuition. <br>If we design relying only on common sense for what we think are basic things, beside being at risk of bias, we are also saying that we assume about people behavior, in another terms how people will behave interacting with the system we have designed.<br>Intuition about people behavior, often turns wrongs, and that’s why science does not rely on it, and that’s why all we know today about usability, it comes from scientific research methods.</li></ul><p>So while common sense has its place in design, it should be complemented by research to ensure the design choices.</p><blockquote><strong>7. </strong>“There are consumer apps serving millions of users effectively,</blockquote><p>This is partially valid, we have all around example of consumer app serving millions of users, yet they have basic mistakes.<br>Do they serve them effectively? according to who?</p><ul><li>The person with a motor impairment that struggle to click on the CTA because it’s too small or too close to another one?</li><li>The color blind person for which you have designed a dashboard that uses colors that makes the chart bars unreadable?</li><li>The one unaware of having a cognitive disorder for which you have designed a page overwhelmed by extraneous cognitive elements and that now think to be too stupid because can’t sort it out?</li></ul><blockquote>and they do it with well-established interaction patterns. Emulate those. Don’t reinvent the wheel.”</blockquote><p>Well, in 2005 Amazon was not someone anymore someone to emulate according to this article on <a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/amazon-no-e-commerce-role-model/">NNGroup</a></p><p>While well-established interaction patterns can serve as valuable guidelines, blindly copying them without considering the unique context and user needs of a specific product can lead to missed opportunities for innovation and customization. User research plays a vital role in understanding the target audience and their specific preferences, behaviors, and pain points.</p><p>Moreover, cognitive psychology teaches us that user behavior is influenced by factors beyond just familiarity. Factors like cognitive load, visual hierarchy, and the user’s mental state also impact how users interact with interfaces. Therefore, while emulating established patterns is a solid starting point, designers should also consider the underlying psychological principles that drive effective user interactions.</p><p><strong>In conclusion<br></strong>Even if in principle and pour parler many part of the statement can make sense, once analyzed with a critical spirit, we realize that there is a sea between saying and doing and that they cannot be applied in a 100% safe way without having some research backed up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8efd21a70276" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxplanet.org/striking-the-balance-the-intersection-of-common-sense-and-user-research-in-ux-design-8efd21a70276">Striking the Balance: The Intersection of Common Sense and User Research in UX Design</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxplanet.org/">UX Planet</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is the Imposter Syndrome and its implications]]></title>
            <link>https://eriksitter.medium.com/what-is-the-imposter-syndrome-and-its-implications-7f20323203ed?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7f20323203ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[working-environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[studying]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[imposter-syndrome]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenthood]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Dec 2022 17:37:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-30T17:37:27.857Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A woman seated, elbows on the table, hands joined at face level, eyes closed, worried atmosphere" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5hbCBeDRF0Lk_8Su" /></figure><h3>Intro</h3><p>If you are completing a Bootcamp or especially if you use LinkedIn, you may have read posts about the “Imposter Syndrome” in your feed.</p><p>Most of these posts are not written by psychologists, psychotherapists or psychiatrists but by ordinary people like me, sometimes unfortunately even some life coaches, who instead of dedicating time to research, he/she decides to publish succinct definitions of this syndrome, accompanied by advice on how to fight it and that, however, never include an invitation to contact a professional.</p><p>Some of these posts degenerate into dubious utterances like this:</p><figure><img alt="Linkedin User screenshot saying: “just because you have imposter syndrome, doesn’t mean that you are not incompetent :) — internet wisdom”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/653/0*PNBARGQUmgd6p8I0" /></figure><p>Written by someone who forgot to perform discovery before making a joke on a psychological problem, or they degenerate into terrifying articles like this:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of an article published on Medium stating: “you have imposter syndrome because you’re an imposter” and “Imposter syndrome means you have more to learn”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/0*vszdsqQYirHU9fJP" /></figure><p>Published on Medium where unfortunately it has obtained thousands of claps, and shared on LinkedIn by a well-known medium-publisher called “UX Collective”, and fortunately has also been strongly criticized.</p><p>This article review, based on research and articles by psychologists, psychotherapists and psychiatrists, arises from the need and the attempt to clarify in a network of clickbait posts and superficiality.</p><p>If you are a founder, a manager, a life coach but especially a father or a mother and you want to understand what is and how deep the Imposter Syndrome is and what the dramatic consequences it can lead to, I invite you to invest the necessary time in reading this article.</p><h3><strong>Table of contents</strong></h3><ul><li>What is the Imposter’s Syndrome</li><li>1978: The year of the Imposter’s Syndrome</li><li>Does Imposter Syndrome mainly affect high-achieving women?</li><li>Is there any job profession most affected by the imposter syndrome?</li><li>The Imposter’s Syndrome, a root of cultural and social development</li><li>Imposter Syndrome vs Self Doubt</li><li>Is the Imposter Syndrome a mental disorder?</li><li>Psychological characteristics, comorbidities and suicidal tendencies</li><li>How to overcome it?</li></ul><h3>What is the Imposter’s Syndrome</h3><p>There are several definitions that may vary slightly from one another, it depends on the opinion of the writer and also on the year in which they were written.</p><p>In an article reviewed by the World Mental Healthcare Association, we can read the following definition:</p><p><em>“Imposter syndrome is a psychological phenomenon involving intense feelings of self-doubt. The condition is linked with perfectionism, intelligence, accomplishments and social status. It can affect a person’s professional and personal life and make them skeptical of their success.”(8)</em></p><p>Audrey Ervin, psychologist and academic director of the graduate program in Counseling Psychology at Delaware Valley University, describe it as:</p><p><em>“Characterized by chronic feelings of inadequacy, incompetence, and fraudulence despite objective success. It’s hard to internalize success and genuinely hold the belief that you’re competent and capable”(6)</em></p><p>Those who suffer from it, therefore, are convinced that they have reached certain goals by pure chance or even by mistake.</p><p>This perception of inadequacy is experienced not only in the professional sphere, but involves any role one finds oneself covering in life. The imposter syndrome, in fact, can make us feel distracted by parents, incompetent professionals or indifferent partners. Those who suffer from it think that the esteem and appreciation of others derive from their ability to pretend. The feeling is that of deceiving those around us and, consequently, fear that sooner or later we will be unmasked.(9)</p><h3>1978: The year of the Imposter’s Syndrome</h3><p>It was the psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes, who 44 years ago spoke for the first time about this syndrome, in the publication of their:</p><p><em>“The imposter phenomenon in high achieving women: Dynamics and therapeutic intervention.”</em></p><p>A 5-year research in which the psychologists have worked in individual psychotherapy, theme-centered interaction groups, and college classes with over 150 highly successful women — women who have earned Ph.D.’s in various specialties, who are respected professionals in their fields, or who are students recognized for their academic excellence.</p><p>Despite their success, their patients were displaying the symptoms of what Clance&amp;Imes then called “Imposter Syndrome”.</p><h3>Does Imposter Syndrome mainly affect high-achieving women?</h3><p>The short answer is no, it doesn’t mainly affect high-achieving women.</p><p>How many times, in different posts on linkedin and articles written by random dudes, we have read a sentence like this:</p><p><em>“The </em><strong><em>Imposter Phenomenon</em></strong><em> (IP) has been found mainly in high-achieving women in academic and career fields.”</em></p><p>This is a reference from the findings of Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes, but 44 years have passed since then, don’t you think maybe other research has been done?</p><p>The simple fact that the findings of P.C. &amp; S.I. pointed out how the parent-daughter relationship had negatively affected their clients, shouldn’t it legitimately make you question that perhaps the same thing could happen with anyone who has experienced a parenting relationship like the one described?</p><p>And that perhaps the cultural and social environment in which, at this point, children grow up, could have influences that do not exclude those who have not studied at Harvard, who have not completed a master’s degree or who have not become head of a department?</p><p>The same Clance and Imes in a 1993 publication, write that the imposter phenomenon was originally thought to be particularly pervasive among females but surveys of several populations, however, have found no differences between the sexes in the degree to which they experience imposter feelings (7).</p><p>Not only, studies of college students (Harvey, 1981; Bussotti, 1990; Langford, 1990), college professors (Topping, 1983), and successful professionals (Dingman, 1987) have all failed, however, to reveal any sex differences in imposter feelings, suggesting that males in these populations are just as likely as females to have low expectations of success and to make attributions to non-ability related factors(7).</p><p>It is clear that Imposter Syndrome affects both men and women (although 16 articles found greater symptoms of imposter syndrome among women and 17 articles found no gender effect). Additionally, this syndrome affects individuals across the age spectrum (two studies reported that increased age was associated with decreased imposter feelings while three studies found no age effect). (12)</p><h3>Is there any job profession most affected by the Imposter Syndrome?</h3><p>These are just some of the posts we can see popping around on LinkedIn, none of them reporting a research as reference or being published by someone in the mental health sector:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin user post stating: “imposter syndrome is one of the most prominent things in the IT and marketing world”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/656/0*dVe5C-UIa-ESeDVF" /></figure><p>I didn’t find any research confirming this statement.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin user post stating: “imposter syndrome torment creative people”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/674/0*0TdKJPruMKvo1VLi" /></figure><p>And I could not find any research confirming that Imposter Syndrome “torments” creative people or that men and women in this job sector are most affected nor I could find any research that analyzes all the jobs in the world to determine which one it’s more affected by this syndrome.</p><p>All these types of posts seem to do two things, dramatically confusing self-doubt with Imposter Syndrome and trying to use a mental problem to drag attention on a specific job category.</p><p>The published literature on Imposter Syndrome consists exclusively of evaluations of cohorts to assess the prevalence of imposter syndrome and describe their psychiatric and psychological co-morbidities.</p><p>The prevalence of this syndrome varies widely from 9% to 82%, largely depending on the recruitment strategy for the study (e.g., population-based evaluations, studies of students), screening tool used (e.g., Clance Imposter Phenomenon Scale, Harvey Imposter Phenomenon Scale) and cutoff used to assess symptoms. (12)</p><p>The literature on the prevalence of imposter syndrome may be subject to publication bias (i.e., the tendency of journals to publish studies with positive findings rather than negative findings) since all of the peer-reviewed studies reported some participants endorsing imposter feelings. (12)</p><h3>The Imposter’s Syndrome, a root of cultural and social development</h3><p>Within the research by Clance &amp; Imes, published in 1978, we can read how the family environment of their patients was important for the development of this syndrome.</p><p>P.C. and S.I. observed that their patients could be typically divided in two groups with a different type of family:</p><p>The first family(1) in which the smartest person among brothers and sisters was not her but always someone else who, in reality, always had lesser success and recognition than hers.</p><p>The second family(1) in which she herself was the most intelligent, capable, beautiful person of all the others, whose parents said she could achieve anything, so at the first thing not achieved she collapsed.</p><p>The different types of family experiences lead to the same result, with the difference that in the first case, in women there is still the desire to succeed, despite knowing that they are never enough for their goal.</p><p>In the second case, however, women will always feel unable to do so and always on the verge of collapse and of being discovered.</p><p>One of P.Clance and S. Imes’ clients who had trouble with spelling, remembers that she pretended to be “sick” for three consecutive Fridays when spelling bees were held.</p><p><em>She could not bear the thought of her parents finding out she could not win the spelling contest(1).</em></p><p>We can therefore say that the results of C. &amp; I. <strong>suggest that this syndrome begins to be cultivated when the patients are still children</strong>, and that there is a <strong>strong social component</strong>, the attitude of the parents.</p><p>Margaret Mead (1947) notes that a successful and independent woman is seen as “a hostile and dangerous force within society”. Martina Horner’s (1972) studies, which support Margaret Mead’s findings and observations, see the fact that success for a woman is a source of fear and discomfort. Her studies suggest that, often, for fear of being rejected by society and considered less feminine, they don’t even try.</p><p>Men, probably, are faced with the implication of the same stereotype. Where it is the man who must carry on the patriarchal culture, always be infallible and show no sign of abating, it is evident that, at the first inevitable creak that happens to everyone in life, the doubt begins to instill himself that he does not have the qualities to be where he is.</p><p>Similarly, ethnic minorities have the same problem. In fact, they are seen on the basis of the stereotype of the same minority, which cannot hold certain important positions or obtain important results (2).</p><p>Eleven studies evaluated Imposter Syndrome among minority student populations. These studies found that Imposter Syndrome is common among African-, Asian-, and Latino/a-American college students and that imposter feelings are significantly negatively associated with poor psychological well-being, depression, and anxiety.</p><p>Interestingly, one study found that <strong>imposter feelings were stronger predictors of impaired mental health than the stress of the individual’s minority status</strong>.(14) (12)</p><p>This is particularly significant given that research on ethnic minority populations tends to focus on their minority status and presumed experiences of discrimination, rather than the individual differences within a minority group such as the presence or absence of imposter feelings. (12)</p><p><em>The syndrome is deeply rooted within our cultures and that we begin to internalize around 7/10 years of age(2).</em></p><p>That is the moment in which we are taught what role we play in our society, in which we learn what a woman must do and what a man must do, in which we learn that those who are different from us must be treated differently(2).</p><p>The disparities take root within us and teach us that we must approach a cultural standard that is imposed on us otherwise we will never be real men and real women (2).</p><p>Finally, social psychological research suggests that how people are treated by self-relevant others is an important precursor to imposter feelings. This is because individuals’ everyday interactions are laced with important social evaluative cues, conveying whether others see them as a person of value and worth (Smith et al., 1998; Huo and Binning, 2008).</p><h3>Imposter Syndrome vs Self Doubt</h3><p>The Imposter Syndrome is part of what in Neuro-Linguistic Programming we would call ‘limiting belief’, a deeply rooted belief in us that does not allow us to grow and enjoy our life.</p><p>It is a situation that can not only prevent you from achieving your result and goal but also, once achieved, prevent you from enjoying the fruits.</p><p><strong>Those who suffer from it do not feel that sense of ‘purpose in life’ that we should be able to achieve instead. (2)</strong></p><p><em>The Imposter Syndrome, rather than being the classic “Self Doubt” that sometimes grips us, is instead a form of the latter (3), a pattern.</em></p><p>Sufferers are chronically afraid that they will not be able to maintain their success (4), the feelings persist even in the face of information, which indicates the person’s validity and successes (5).</p><p>The Imposter Syndrome has one of its traits in chronicity/longevity and pervasiveness, Self Doubt does not.</p><p>There’s nothing wrong with occasional Self-Doubt. The key, most experts agree, is frequency.</p><p>Most people feel like an imposter at some point in their lives, especially in intimidating scenarios, whether they’re on a blind date, at a new job, or speaking in front of a large crowd(6) or questioning themselves if they are going to be good parents.</p><p>Adolescence, for example, is a time characterized by self-doubt, the important questions to ask yourself are:</p><p><em>“Is your self-doubt developmentally appropriate? Is it a persistent, nagging, ongoing experience? Or is it a temporary, situational experience?”</em>(6)</p><p>This distinction between Self-Doubt and Imposter Syndrome is very important, because most of the times when someone on LinkedIn or in Bootcamps talks about the Imposter Syndrome, they are actually dealing with it as if it were a normal Self-Doubt.</p><p>This in turn, in combination with advice like “study harder”, leads me to think about when people mistakenly think that depression and <strong>Depression Disorder</strong> are the same thing, and they go out of their way with advice like “Try to get out, make new friends, be happy ”, advice that in reality are far-fetched and the result of which ends up worsening an already painful situation.</p><h3>Is the Imposter Syndrome a mental disorder?</h3><p>Someone could say that informally, Imposter Syndrome is a mental disorder, but formally it is not, and perhaps it is for this reason that on LinkedIn, everyone feels ready to give psychotherapy advice on it, without ever suggesting instead, to contact a psychotherapist.</p><p><em>Half of the 62 peer-reviewed publications on Imposter Syndrome were published in the last seven years underscoring the recent recognition of Imposter Syndrome as an important clinical phenomenon.(12)</em></p><p>Despite this the syndrome is not featured in the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual 5th Edition (DSM-5, published in May 2013) nor in the International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision (ICD-11, published in Jan 2022).</p><h3>Psychological characteristics, comorbidities and suicidal tendencies</h3><p>The imposter syndrome has been associated with psychological characteristics such as:</p><ul><li>Introversion (Lawler; 1984)</li><li>Trait anxiety (Topping; 1983)</li><li>Low self-esteem (Snyder; 1972)</li><li>A tendency to shame (Khout; 1984)</li><li>Conflicting family experiences with little emotional support (Bussotti; 1990).</li></ul><p>Two personality characteristics typical of this syndrome are:</p><ol><li>Low self-esteem</li><li>High self-control, or the tendency to monitor and modify the presentation of oneself according to the social signals present in the situation (Snyder; 1972, 1974).(10)</li></ol><p>Another characteristic aspect is being motivated mainly by the desire to demonstrate one’s intelligence: when this fails because a mistake has been made, one feels helplessness, avoidance of the task, a sense of guilt towards oneself, anxiety and shame. (Dweck; 1986).(10)</p><p>People who experience this syndrome could* (editor’s note) come from families in which there were conflicts and a lack of emotional support during childhood and in which communication and behavior are regulated by rigid and implicit rules. (10)</p><p><em>* ”can” was changed with “could” as we have researches that point out also to ethnic discrimination as trigger actor</em></p><p>In these families the child in order to feel accepted has had to create a “false self”, which growing up has brought insecurity about his own identity and successes (Bussotti, 1990), therefore to compensate for self-doubts, the person cultivates his own self-esteem trying to always live up to his idealized image.(10)</p><p>This phenomenon is often accompanied by excessive worries, depression and anxiety that derive from the stress to which the person undergoes in order to always live up to his own image of success and avoid being labeled as unworthy or incompetent.(10)</p><p>Other causes could be due to the society we live in, a devaluing or overly pretentious workplace, colleagues, friends or relatives who need to prove they are better by devaluing or manipulating, and more.(11)</p><h3>Comorbidities</h3><p>Imposter syndrome often co-exists with already present <a href="https://psychiatry.org/patients-families/depression/what-is-depression">depression disorder</a>, <a href="https://psychiatry.org/Patients-Families/Anxiety-Disorders">anxiety disorder</a>, somatic symptoms, social dysfunction or can lead to one of them, included <a href="https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/burnout-symptoms-signs#:~:text=Burnout%20is%20a%20form%20of,up%20with%20life&#39;s%20incessant%20demands.">burnout</a> and suicidal tendencies.</p><h3>Suicidal tendencies</h3><p>In the study: “Maladaptive Perfectionism, Imposter Phenomenon, and Suicidal Ideation Among Medical Students” published in 2021, conclusions evidence that medical students who exhibit maladaptive perfectionism are at increased risk for feelings of imposter phenomenon, which translates into increased risk for suicide.</p><p>The results in the study suggest that an intervention targeted at reducing feelings of imposter phenomenon among maladaptive perfectionists may be effective in reducing their higher risk for suicide.</p><p>However, interventions promoting individual resilience are not sufficient; systemic change is needed to address medicine’s “culture of perfection.”(13)</p><h3>How to overcome it?</h3><p>At this point, it should be clear to any reasonable person and human being caring for others, that Self-Doubt and Imposter Syndrome are two similar but different aspects and that posts like the followings, are not only often useless but in some cases demonstrate ignorance and are far from being helpful:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin user post stating: “it’s a passing effect that you (might) feel from time to time” or “Imposter Syndrome is a natural effect of all the success you have experienced”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/0*E6O2KB7q8PHzvMPM" /></figure><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin user post stating: “it’s simply doubt, we all have doubts at one time or another”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/656/0*dNWapF2rCumvf1IJ" /></figure><p>The following one instead underline the lack of knowledge on the topic and no previous research on the topic:</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a linkedin user post stating: “imposter syndrome is always a lie. What is actually happening is the natural consequence of learning a new skill”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/670/0*PRFphtHhitNVxiZz" /></figure><p>This last one was associated with a video in which one of the “help” factors, was the fact that the person suffering from Imposter Syndrome would have done more to prove his/her value, and so exceeding the expectation and being rewarded but those around him/her…</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot from a linkedin user post stating: “don’t believe the myth that says imposter syndrome hurts you. Find out 3 ways imposter syndrome actually helps you in your career in my video”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/668/0*wXVf4CMoESurT7tg" /></figure><p>If you feel or think to have the Imposter Syndrome,<strong> the best way to overcome it, it’s to approach a Psychotherapist and certainly avoid to read Imposter Syndrome posts on LinkedIn</strong>, as they could harm you more than help you.</p><p>Resources:</p><p>(1) <a href="https://www.paulineroseclance.com/pdf/ip_high_achieving_women.pdf">Psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes: The Imposter Phenomenon in High Achieving Women: Dynamics and Therapeutic Intervention</a></p><p>(2) <a href="https://www.psicologiadellavoro.org/tag/burnout">Psychologist and Psychotherapist Andrea Castello</a></p><p>(3) <a href="https://www.ajpe.org/content/82/2/6990">American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education: Intellectual Self-doubt and How to Get Out of It</a></p><p>(4)(8) <a href="https://mind.help/topic/imposter-syndrome/">World Mental Healthcare Association</a></p><p>(5) <a href="https://caps.umich.edu/article/graduate-students-imposter-syndrome">University of Michigan Counseling and psychological services</a></p><p>(6) <a href="https://www.psycom.net/imposter-syndrome">Psychologist Audrey Ervin</a></p><p>(7) <a href="https://paulineroseclance.com/pdf/-Langford.pdf">Langford &amp; Clance: The imposter phenomenon: recent research findings regarding dynamics, personality and family patterns and their implications for treatment (1993)</a></p><p>(9) <a href="https://www.psichemilano.com/sindrome-dellimpostore/">Psychologist and Psychotherapist Alessandra Marazzani Visconti</a></p><p>(10) <a href="https://istitutosantachiara.it/la-sindrome-dellimpostore/">Psychologist and Psychotherapist Enrica Montanari</a></p><p>(11) <a href="https://www.pamelabusonero.it/sindrome-dellimpostore/">Psychologist and Psychotherapist Pamela Busonero</a></p><p>(12) <a href="https://www.mentalhealthjournal.org/articles/commentary-prevalence-predictors-and-treatment-of-imposter-syndrome-a-systematic-review.html#:~:text=The%20published%20literature%20on%20imposter%20syndrome%20is%20comprised%20exclusively%20of,and%20psychological%20co%2Dmorbidities1.">Prevalence, Predictors, and Treatment of Imposter Syndrome: A Systematic Review, Dena M. Bravata, Divya K. Madhusudhan, Michael Boroff, Kevin O. Cokley</a></p><p>(13) <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34350548/">Maladaptive Perfectionism, Imposter Phenomenon, and Suicidal Ideation Among Medical Students</a></p><p>(14) <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/264471310_An_Examination_of_the_Impact_of_Minority_Status_Stress_and_Impostor_Feelings_on_the_Mental_Health_of_Diverse_Ethnic_Minority_College_Students">Cokley K, McClain S, Enciso A, et al. An examination of the impact of minority status stress and imposter feelings on the mental health of diverse ethnic minority college students. J Multicult Couns Dev. 2013; 41(2): 82–95.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7f20323203ed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[If stakeholders don’t buy it, it’s not necessarily a UXer or Product Manager lack of skills, but a…]]></title>
            <link>https://uxplanet.org/if-stakeholders-dont-buy-it-it-s-not-necessarily-a-uxer-or-product-manager-lack-of-skills-but-a-5689930b1f89?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5689930b1f89</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stakeholder-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cognitive-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Sep 2022 23:25:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-20T11:56:34.617Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>If stakeholders don’t buy it, it’s not necessarily a UXer or Product Manager lack of skills, but a stakeholder problem.</h3><figure><img alt="Photo of a business woman holding money in her hands and with a serious and fixed gaze towards. On the right side a business man with open arms and palms turned up with the arrogant gaze turned up to his right" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4K6rmUZ-HSZ2VTfWAyuAoA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Depositphotos, Author: Andrew Lozovyi</figcaption></figure><h3>Premise</h3><p>Since I am a UXer, and this article could be read by those who do not know this profession or think they know it (eg “oh yes, you do wireframes, flows and pretty things), like many other UXers I feel the need to reiterate that our discipline was not born to exclusively serve the digital world, indeed initially in the 90s at most, it had the title of UX Architect (<em>User Experience Architect’s Office in Apple, cit. D. Norman</em>) then after the 2000s people progressively started to misuse the term to say “UX Design”, “I/you design apps” etc and relegating it to the digital world, often confusing it with Web Design and Graphic Design.</p><p>I also want to reiterate that UX applies to the end user, whether it is the user of a digital product, physical product, the candidate of a recruitment process or the same employee within a company or a citizen who uses a service, like the public transport or the medical service in a hospital. <br>UX is not limited to wireframes and certainly does not simply deal with graphic aesthetics, for that, there is the Graphic Designer.</p><p>In its past, we speak of the 50s, there are roots in cognitive psychology and in the scientific research method, from these, the discipline has evolved over time into what Don Norman then called User Experience when he worked for Apple in the mid 1990s (although the term, per se, had already been used decades earlier).</p><p>The following article specifically refers to “stakeholders” where the terms can be changed with “people/humans beings” and it assumes that UXers and PMs are doing a data driven work or anyway backed up by decades of knowledge in their sector.</p><p><strong>Table of contents</strong></p><ul><li>Intro</li><li>Stakeholders and fear of change</li><li>Stakeholders and resistance to change</li><li>Stakeholders and cognitive dissonance</li><li>Stakeholders and confirmation bias</li><li>Consequences for UXers</li><li>Resources</li></ul><h4>Intro</h4><p>Several bootcamps and articles on the web focus on how important it is that UXers and Product Managers are able to convince stakeholders, to the point that if they can’t, UXers and Product Managers should bet blamed.</p><p>This same conviction then seems to bounce from one recruitment process to another, in which recruiters or other people involved in the hiring process ask questions in order to find out how the candidate managed to convince the stakeholders and, if he/she did not succeed, then it’s a bad candidate.</p><p>However a good amount of the people involved in the recruiting process are victims of biases that reduce their ability to be impartial, moreover, it is easier to blame others than to recognize our own limitations or mistakes.</p><p>A sentence like this:</p><p><em>“To garner their support, make sure your stakeholders clearly understand the issue, the solution, and the ways in which it will benefit them.”</em></p><p>It is extremely simplistic and ignores human nature, indeed the example above, can only succeed when certain circumstances within the stakeholder cognitive and behavioral processes are met, otherwise it’s not going to happen, no matter how good a Product Manager or a UXer is in selling their work.</p><p>Stakeholders, whoever they are, CEO, CTO, Head of Departments etc (and sometimes also Product Managers), are human beings and as such, subject to cognitive bias and the inability to accept change and, especially UXers, they can be carriers of very radical changes.</p><blockquote><em>“Before you heal someone, ask him if he’s willing to give up the things that make him sick” — Hippocrates</em></blockquote><h4>Stakeholders and fear of change</h4><p>True motivation to change depends, first and foremost, on the ability of stakeholders to notice the negative aspects of the condition in which the product, company or employees working for the company find themselves.</p><p>Stakeholders are human beings, and as such their minds keep track of the words that gratified them and the criticisms that hurt them, the situations they experienced, the times when, despite obstacles, they acted and those when the fear of failure paralyzed them.</p><p>It keeps track of the decisions they made, their successes and defeats. Their self draws on these memories.</p><p>The self, their sense of identity, is a kind of “container” of self-descriptions:</p><ul><li>Physical</li><li>Psychological</li><li>Biographical</li><li>Relational</li><li>Social</li></ul><p>and is based, for the most part, on beliefs and ways of feeling. Ultimately, it is not what they really are, but rather is the result of how they are accustomed to thinking about themselves.</p><p>Possessing a stable self is calming; it makes us feel like individuals with continuity over time. But it comes at a price:</p><p>It requires consistency, that is, that we act, in the present, similarly to how we have done in the past.</p><p>For this reason, people, and thus also stakeholders seek out experiences familiar to them and are averse to new ways of thinking.</p><p>Thus, however, they end up locked into a limited view of themselves and the world.</p><p>In a past experience, I extracted data from Microsoft Power BI, merged 3 years of research performed by two different UXers and in which, users were always complaining about the same problem that went unheard for years, as result they were registering their account to never log again after just 24 hours.</p><p>When I calculated that in the last 3 years the business was burning €1M per year due to the user cost of acquisition/churn rate, precisely because the user problem was ignored, the CEO surprised by the amount of money loss, replied with a “lol”, literally.</p><p>Recently in a company that did not know what product discovery was, nor the difference between Product Manager and Project Manager, nor the creation of a product as a solution to a user problem, in order to help myself and the business itself, I quoted Don Norman, Jakob Nielsen, Joe Natoli, Debbie Levitt, referenced specific researches to corroborate what I was saying and supporting my own researches.</p><p>I have quoted Teresa Torres, Don Norman again, William Hudson and reported examples of companies that have failed to innovate, closed for bankruptcy or burned huge amounts of money because <em>“we know what our customers want”</em> the answer they gave me was that they had to speed up and that they didn’t want anymore to conduct interviews and surveys, they could be done later on, to adjust the product so far built without research.</p><p>There is nothing UXers can do in these situations, if the change does not arise first in the company itself. Nobody can help those who doesn’t want to be helped and UXers are not like other professions, they are equipped like doctors and if the doctor is telling you that you are going to get a liver cirrhosis if you don’t stop drinking and you keep drinking, the doctor can’t help it, but the barman (the Web Designer) can help you, ’cause he/she doesn’t care as he/she doesn’t need, so he/she will be happy to make the pretty graphic/serves you another beer.</p><blockquote><em>“UX without research, it’s not UX and UI without UX it’s not UI, it’s Web Design.”</em></blockquote><h4>Stakeholders and resistance to change</h4><p>Resistance to change, in this specific case, typically a resistance to change product strategy, adopting a new type of management, a new organizational chart etc it causes in people experiencing an emotional anxiety caused by the prospect of a transformation or change that is taking place.</p><p>If we use the emotional cycle proposed by the psychiatrist Kubler-Ross, and we adapt the context to the one we have in a business, more or less this is what happening in stakeholders:</p><p><strong>1. Shock phase.</strong> It is the state of paralysis or initial block when stakeholders are exposed to the perspective of change, for example adopting “Product Discovery”, removing “Dark Design Patterns” etc.</p><p>In this state stakeholders usually do not react, there’s is silence, low reaction or apparent compliance, so that UXers or Product Managers may think that stakeholders have willingly accepted the transformation, but in reality what is happening is that stakeholder emotional system has “frozen.” Their rational mind has not yet processed the change and what it means.</p><p><strong>2. Negative phase.</strong> At this stage stakeholders deny the change, this implies closing their eyes in front of reality and any evidence that transformation is necessary or is occurring.</p><p>Normally stakeholders continue with their processes, actions, works etc as if nothing had happened, with the naive claim that the need to change disappears. This is because, by grasping to their everyday routines, they recover the feeling of control.</p><p><strong>3. Phase of wrath</strong>. When stakeholder can no longer deny change, the most common thing is to react with anger, frustration, and rage. In this phase, all the feelings repressed during the previous phases emerge.</p><p>At this stage stakeholders often try to back up each others, they try to make team, rise up a shield and point a finger against the Product Manager or the UXer. This is a defensive reaction, at his core there’s an attempt to maintain the status quo, because it’s comfortable, secure, produce a feeling of control, stability, certainty.</p><p>Product Managers or UXers are seen as distruptive and unpleasant elements. It is not the wrong past strategies and methodologies that have led to this moment, but the PMs and/or the UXers that do not conform to the status quo, actually wrong (remember we are talking about denying the evidence, not hypothesis), of the stakeholders.</p><p><strong>4. Phase of negotiation</strong>. It is a phase in which stakeholders will try to find a way out, although it is usually useless because stakeholders are still struggling to change. At this stage they have not yet accepted the change, but they try to find the “way” to avoid it.</p><p>Here is usually when different type of cognitive biases show up. If stakeholders are unable to accept the change and recognize past mistakes, this is also where usually everything end.</p><p>Product Managers and/or UXers get frustrated, their profession it’s not recognized, evidence it’s ignored and they have two options, start to look for a new job or continue to work by producing low quality deliverables, giving up on their professionality and/or years of studies who taught them the correct way to perform their profession.</p><p><strong>5. Phase of depression</strong>. At this point, usually after the umpteenth meeting in which there’s again a clash of world view, more or less intense, stakeholders finally accept that change is inevitable, but they do not accept it, they can react getting depressed or irritated because things are not going as they wanted.</p><p><strong>6. Phase of the test</strong>. It is a phase where resistance to change is finally disappearing because stakeholders realize that they have to react. This is happening when:</p><ul><li>They start to give importance in the values and objectives that PMs and UXers says. Taking responsibility is central: values and objectives can be encouraged, but not induced from outside by PMs and UXers. On the contrary, they must be “built” in a conscious and deliberate way inside the stakeholders.</li><li>Stakeholders gain the ability to predict the long-term consequences of one’s actions, not to repeat old habits. In a word, a change requires self-control to accomplish. Impulsiveness is the tendency to act on the spot without considering that the expected results, in this way, may not occur; it is difficult for a person without a minimum of self-control to keep at bay that part of himself that pushes him towards the usual behaviors.</li><li>Cognitive flexibility is achieved. The ability to accept even those conditions that are different from how one would like them, to modify one’s thoughts according to reality and to assume the perspective of those who have different ideas.</li></ul><p>At this point stakeholders start looking for realistic solutions and new coping models that fit the reality. They begin small experiments that bring them closer to change and allow them to observe it in a new perspective.</p><p><strong>7. Phase of acceptance.</strong> It is the last stage in which stakeholders return to find the balance that was lost with the change. They find and implement new models of adaptive behavior that help them to rebuild their identity in new circumstances.</p><blockquote><em>“The motivation for change depends on the ability to fully realize the negative aspects of the condition in which one is”</em></blockquote><h4>Stakeholders and Cognitive Dissonance</h4><p>Why do many stakeholders firmly defend their views and beliefs even in the face of overwhelming evidence that their ideas and views are totally wrong?</p><p>One explanation is what in psychology is called cognitive dissonance.</p><p>A mental distress experienced by a person who simultaneously holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas or values. Discomfort is triggered by a situation where a person’s beliefs collide with new evidence presented to that person.</p><p>Stakeholders suffering from cognitive dissonance will vigorously defend, justify and maintain their glorious beliefs even when faced with irrefutable evidence that they are wrong.</p><p>A classic example:</p><p><strong>- UXer / Product Manager:</strong> <em>“A product / service is created to solve the problem of one or more people, not because someone one day decides to do it to maybe copy the competition. Here is a pile of decades of studies that proof the effectiveness and all the benefits of this process and the downsides when it is not applied. At the bottom you will find the signatures of Thor, Batman and all the Olympian Gods.”</em></p><p><strong>- Stakeholder:</strong> <em>“I disagree and you are a rookie in this company and just a bad person who wants to dictate how to live my business life, now I cry, go away.”</em></p><p>To reduce psychological distress, stakeholders will have to change their mind or behavior in order to resolve the inconsistency or contradiction, thus restoring mental balance and emotional harmony, or otherwise known as cognitive consonance (yes the opposite of dissonance).</p><p>There are several ways human beings and so stakeholders reduce their mental tension when their behavior and available information collide.</p><p>A stakeholder experiencing cognitive dissonance will try to reduce mental tension in several ways, for example:</p><p><strong>A</strong>. At best they will change their behavior or beliefs to be congruent with the new information:</p><p><em>“Okay, let’s proceed with the research. It will allow us to understand the behavior of our users, to study their process, to understand what problems they experience, to innovate, get a leverage on our competitors and this will also reduce the risk for us of creating a failing product, of burning money for nothing and of reduce or avoid retrofit costs etc”</em></p><p><strong>B</strong>. They will justify their behavior or beliefs by modifying conflicting cognition:</p><p><em>“We know our customers, we know what they want even if we have never done research, for this time we can avoid doing it and proceed with product development, for once we can do it”</em></p><p><strong>C</strong>. They will justify their behavior or beliefs by adding new cognition:</p><p><em>“We have millions in profits, we know what we are doing” </em>or<em> “We will do more research later on to adjust the product” </em>or<em> “We will invest more in new customer acquisition to compensate the loss due to a lack of research”</em></p><p><strong>D</strong>. They will ignore or deny information that conflicts with their existing beliefs:</p><p><em>“Product discovery it’s not really necessary, a business can decide to start simply for business decisions, not because there’s a problem to solve” </em>or <em>“This is not a startup business, we have our own processes” </em>or<em> “There’s no need to do maintenance on this machine, it’s perfectly working and we never had problems”</em></p><p>Many stakeholders are unwilling to change their vision of things to account for new information that contradicts their beliefs, instead, they reduce cognitive dissonance by justifying their way of viewing things rather than by changing their minds or behaviors.</p><p>If science worked in the same way, there would be no progress nor a whole series of inventions.</p><h4>Stakeholders and Confirmation Bias</h4><p>Confirmation bias, it’s the tendency to process information by looking for, or interpreting, information that is consistent with one’s existing beliefs.</p><p>Human decision making and information processing are often biased because stakeholders simply interpret information from their own point of view.</p><p>Stakeholders need to process information quickly to protect themselves from harm. It is adaptive to rely on instinctive and automatic reflexes that keep them out of danger, in this case the change is seen as a danger, a danger that travels carried by the aforementioned cognitive dissonance.</p><p>Another reason stakeholders display confirmation bias is to protect their self-esteem. People like to feel good about themselves and discovering that the belief that they are of great value is incorrect causes stakeholders to feel bad about themselves.</p><p>Therefore, stakeholders will look for information that supports their existing beliefs. Another reason is accuracy. Stakeholders want to feel smart, and information that suggests they have an inaccurate belief or make a bad decision suggests them lack intelligence.</p><blockquote><em>When we seek only what confirms our beliefs (</em><strong><em>confirmation bias)</em></strong><em>, we only side with what is most comfortable (</em><strong><em>cognitive dissonanc</em></strong><em>e) and we do not examine contrary ideas (motivated reasoning), we impede social, economic and academic progress. — Sam McInerne</em></blockquote><p>If PMs or UXers are highlighting with, for example data research, the bad consequences or the poor results of a decision operated by a stakeholder (sales, marketing, growth etc), this information that conflicts with stakeholders decision, may cause discomfort and is therefore ignored or given little consideration.</p><p>In the context of decision making, once an individual makes a decision, he or she will look for information that supports it.</p><p>Confirmation bias also surfaces in people’s tendency to look for positive instances. When seeking information to support their hypotheses or expectations, people tend to look for positive evidence that confirms that a hypothesis is true rather than information that would prove the view is false if it is false.</p><p>Confirmation bias also operates in impression formation. If people are told what to expect from a person they are about to meet, such as that the person is warm, friendly, and outgoing, people will look for information that supports their expectations.</p><p>Banal example, if a stakeholder explain to his colleagues that UXers are engaged in the digital product by doing wireframes and UI, they will expect this, not a profession with roots in cognitive psychology, not a profession that does research and work in an iterative process along all the lifespan of a product, not a profession that applies to any type of end-user, and so employees as well as users of a physical product.</p><p>If a Senior Recruiter will explain to a Junior that a UXer needs to know HTML and JS to be as such (false) the Junior Recruiter will seek for this, falling victim of a confirmation bias and with the risk of leave behind good or even excellent candidates that don’t know HTML or JS.</p><p>Confirmation bias is important because it can lead stakeholders to stick firmly to false beliefs or give more weight to information that supports their beliefs than is warranted by the evidence.</p><p>Stakeholders may be too confident in their beliefs because they have accumulated supporting evidence, when in fact a lot of evidence that refutes their beliefs has been overlooked or ignored, evidence that, when considered, would lead to less confidence in their beliefs.</p><blockquote><em>People experience genuine pleasure — a rush of dopamine — when processing information that supports their beliefs. “It feels good to ‘stick to our guns’ even if we are wrong,”</em></blockquote><p>These factors can lead to risky decisions and cause stakeholders to overlook warning signs and other important information.</p><h4>Consequences for UXers</h4><p>When stakeholders refuse to acknowledge the evidence, often one of the typical situations that UXers (but why not, PMs as well) encounter is that of finding themselves in situations in which a dichotomy is created:</p><ul><li><strong>A</strong>. Leaving the business to be able to continue working professionally somewhere else, to be able to enrich oneself in an environment that embraces change and that foster personal growth and allows them to do quality work.</li><li><strong>B</strong>. Continue to work for the same business, producing mediocre work, skipping steps in established processes, ignoring the end user and sometime producing only graphics (UI without UX).</li></ul><p>Since changing job it’s not an easy option, except perhaps for those with enough savings to quit and go back to looking for a new job, option B is the most common.</p><p>It therefore happens that by treating someone according to expectations (I expect that you do not do research, that you ignore the research results, that you only do the UI and maybe you go directly in deployment with good peace of QA and devs), that UXer may unintentionally change his or her behavior to conform to the expectations, thereby providing further support for the perceiver’s confirmation bias.</p><p>This situation then has a major consequence of reducing the professional quality of the UXer and of “polluting” the ecosystem by producing and dispersing in other businesses “modified” UXers to support the confirmation bias of stakeholders.</p><h4><strong>Resources</strong></h4><p><a href="https://positivepsychology.com/cognitive-distortions/">Positive Psychology</a><br><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/think-well/201812/why-many-people-stubbornly-refuse-change-their-minds">Psychology Today</a><br><a href="https://psychology-spot.com/resistance-to-change/">Psychology Spot</a><br><a href="https://www.britannica.com/science/confirmation-bias">Britannica Science</a><br><a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Denying-Grave-Ignore-Facts-that/dp/0199396604">“Denying to the Grave: Why We Ignore the Facts That Will Save Us”, by Sara Gorman, Ph.D., MPH, and Jack M. Gorman, MD</a><br><a href="http://www.psicologo-parma-reggioemilia.com/">Dr. Gabriele Calderone and Giovanni Bortologgi Psychologists and Psychotherapists</a><br><a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/100-years-ux/">A 100-Year View of User Experience, by Jakob Nielsen</a><br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9BdtGjoIN4E">The Term UX, by Don Norman</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5689930b1f89" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxplanet.org/if-stakeholders-dont-buy-it-it-s-not-necessarily-a-uxer-or-product-manager-lack-of-skills-but-a-5689930b1f89">If stakeholders don’t buy it, it’s not necessarily a UXer or Product Manager lack of skills, but a…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxplanet.org/">UX Planet</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is UX Design a Career and Study Change Path?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/is-ux-design-a-career-and-study-change-path-10a341b98dd1?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10a341b98dd1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jobs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ui]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[careers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Jan 2022 19:28:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-12T19:28:00.047Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><em>An explorative research of English speakers candidates and remote/hybrid job offers, within the German market.</em></h3><figure><img alt="Three young women and two men sitting during a team meeting" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*_QtXhHY1LpkJRlN3" /><figcaption>Team meeting</figcaption></figure><h3>Abstract</h3><p>This research within the German labour market, analyses job offers addressed to English speakers in the UX Design field, offering a remote or hybrid working solution. <br>The study collected 183 job advertisements on LinkedIn from Feb 2021 to October 2021, analysed 125 jobs advertisements among the businesses that hired and not hired for the role and analysed the study and career profiles of 79 hired candidates.<br>78.57% of the businesses required previous experience and no qualification. 63.20% of businesses hired a candidate within 8 months, while 36.80% did not hire anyone by the average hiring time, nor by the end of the year 2021.<br>The research showed that more than half of the hires identify a candidate of foreign nationality with a predominance of female, who has made a direct change of profession, i.e. without a course of study during the transition to the new profession (39.24%) or who has changed profession after a course of study (34.18%) which introduced him/her to the new career.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><ul><li>How relevant is a university degree in UX Design (when one exists available to the candidate)?</li><li>Is a professional degree enough? and a diploma from a private school?</li><li>Is a degree really important?</li><li>How much previous experience is crucial to getting the job and is it really essential?</li></ul><p><em>The purpose of this research, limited to the German labour market, is therefore to open a window in this direction.</em></p><p>This research explores:</p><ul><li>What is the most popular job title in the field?</li><li>If and which studies, do companies require.</li><li>How much experience is required and if it is required.</li><li>How long it takes companies before hiring a designer.</li><li>If there is a higher incidence among candidates of one gender rather than another.</li><li>Which studies the candidates possess.</li><li>Which industry hired the candidates.</li><li>What path candidates took to work in this field.</li></ul><p>A wider similar research but with a different method and target was conducted by <em>Maria Rosala</em> and <em>Rachel Krause</em> for <a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/ux-career-advice/">Norman Nielsen Group in 2019</a> and was based on responses from 722 UX professionals around the world.</p><h3>Method</h3><p>This research used LinkedIn as a data resource to collect job advertisements, analyse business profiles and hired candidate profiles.</p><p>Data were collected from February 1, 2021 to October 31, 2021.</p><p>All the job advertisements available on LinkedIn with the following characteristics were collected:</p><ul><li>Job titles as UX Designer, UI Designer, UX/UI Designer, UI/UX Designer, UX Researcher and Product Designer.</li><li>They were offered as remote or hybrid jobs.</li><li>They could be performed in English, German was not a requirement.</li></ul><p>This led to the collection of 183 job advertisements.</p><p>Once the average hiring time was determined, as the most recent job advertisements would have led to hires after the year 2021, the number of total job advertisements was reduced to 125 and a final check was done on December 31, 2021.<br>Furthermore the last part of the research, continues by focusing on the 79 candidates that were hired.</p><ul><li>Job description analysis were focused on two specific requirements, study requirements and years of previous experience.</li><li>LinkedIn business profiles were used to know when business hired for the position sought.</li><li>Where the businesses were asking for a field pertinent study, in alternative to a university degree, data were clustered under the item “diploma” meaning high school diploma and online diploma*.</li></ul><p><em>*Some countries have professional high schools that teach design, others have online diplomas recognized by the ministry of education, but not comparable to high school diplomas and almost everywhere there are private schools that teach the subject.</em></p><ul><li>Candidate profiles were used to retrieve information about their past working experience and studies.</li><li>As qualifications/studies, I had to include the item “<em>Certificates (few hours)</em>” to designate those courses up to 200 hours available on websites like Udemy, Coursera, LinkedIn and so on.</li><li>At the same time, the item “<em>Online Course Bootcamp</em>”, designates online courses of +400 hours or courses on-site.</li><li>When has been the moment to organise in a chart the title of studies (<em>Fig.22</em>), only the last study before landing a job into the field, was taken in consideration. <br>This means that candidates with a “M<em>aster</em>” were not counted also in the “<em>Bachelor segmen</em>t”, as well candidates with an “<em>Online Course Bootcamp</em>” but also owning a master or bachelor degree, were not included in such segments.</li><li>As past experiences, only direct past experiences in the role were taken in consideration to determine if the candidate had or not previous experience with the job.</li></ul><p><em>For example, candidates that were working as Frontend Developers, Graphic Designers, Web Designers, Marketing Designers and so on and then suddenly became UX Designers, UI Designers, Product Designers or Researchers without an upgrade in their studies, were considered having no direct past experience in the role.</em></p><p>This was a controversial aspect led by the fact that there may be two different type of people involved in the hiring process, those who look for a direct past experience and those that make a connection with the role based on an idea rather than on facts, an example those hiring managers that think a Graphic Designer it’s also a UX Designer and similar.</p><p>It was necessary to set a line and I decided for a straight one.</p><p><strong>Downsides:</strong></p><p>In using LinkedIn as a resource, it is necessary to keep in mind some issues that may not make LinkedIn a particularly reliable resource:</p><ul><li>The study path of a candidate is closely related to what the candidate reports within his or her LinkedIn profile.</li><li>The previous working experience is related to what the candidate decides to write in their profile.</li><li>Even though I started tracking ads from January to make sure the February ads were new, I can’t 100% rule out that some of the ads posted in February are no older than February, which would lengthen the hiring time.</li><li>Some jobs may be fake job ads.</li><li>Some candidates may not have a LinkedIn profile, hence the job may result as unfilled due to the lack of a match in the company’s LinkedIn profile.</li><li>Not filled roles may also be the result of an administrative change of the business.</li></ul><h3>Figures</h3><p><em>(Figure title is placed below the image)</em></p><figure><img alt="Chart bar, in order of popularity: Product Designer, UX/UI Designer, UX Designer, UI/UX Designer, UI Designer, UX Researcher" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_uyi94b8iA4u9vh--dKcSg.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 1.</em></strong><em> Segmentation of 183 job advertisements over 9 months within the German job market.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Donut chart. Almost 80% of job ads only require working experience. Only 8.73% require a degree or experience." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*taV3STq1JtveSa3JFwW88Q.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 2.</em></strong><em> Segmentation of study and job experience requirements within 125 job ads.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Donut chart: 35.20% businesses do not specify how many years of experience are required but 28% of businesses require 3 or more years of previous working experience and 19.20% require 2 or more years of experience" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mhCjS00a5dluV1lkHyrwTQ.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 3.</em></strong><em> This pie chart shows businesses </em>that ask for work experience and specify or not the number of years required (similar years have been merged, eg “3–4” added to the “3 or more” cluster).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Pie chart: 63.20% of businesses filled the role, 36.80% didn’t." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xztNjRVbUmTBqeb8M3blcQ.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 4 A.</em></strong><em> Percentage of jobs filled and not filled within a timeframe from Feb 2021 to December 2021 and based on 125 job ads.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Cloud Words Map: Fintech, Cloud Soft. Services, HR Software, Education and Web Agency are the most popular industries that hired in this research" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fShdDp6cXlNLkPOKRYcMMQ.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 4 B.</em></strong><em> Type of businesses that hired the candidates.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Table: The average hiring time is 2.7 months, the longest 8 months the fastest within 1 month" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DMcsqY5eyOcd8brICJjDtw.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 5.</em></strong><em> Number of months required to hire a candidate.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Treemap: 10 jobs were still vacant after 10 months, 6 after 9 months, 3 after 6 months, 11 after 5 months, 11 after 4 months and 5 after 3 months" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WNS6HmMacAKQWfbkJ20RNw.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 6.</em></strong><em> Breakdown of 46 not filled job positions between Feb 2021 and Dec 2021.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Pie chart: 56.96% of the hired candidates are women and 43.04% men" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RGT_6h8aHkd2d9v1xatBRg.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 7.</em></strong><em> Gender distribution among 79 hired candidates.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Population Pyramid Chart: Female candidates are the majority for Product Designer, UX/UI Designer, UI/UX Designer, UX Designer, UX Researcher and UI Designer with higher ratio for the UX Designer job position" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nawm7jG10Hp3MNb11mHUdw.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 8.</em></strong><em> Gender distribution of 79 hired candidates job title based.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Pie chart: 77.22% of hired candidates is foreigner while 22.78% is German." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sU29MlwO5HYVKVbK1xqdVg.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 9.</em></strong><em> 79 hired candidates living in Germany with a German or foreign nationality.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Bar chart: Germans are the higher number of hired candidates, followed by Americans, Spanish, Chinese and Indians. 54.10% of 77.22% foreigners, have a nationality outside of Economic European Union." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DconUIzol-go2YjCRjyNRA.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 10.</em></strong><em> Breakdown of nationalities among 79 hired candidates.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Bar chart: Of 79 hired candidates, 17 without experience are the highest cluster, followed buy 12 with 3 years of experience and 10 with 2 years of experience" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Oxc4c2t7VHo_58cxN3wCVA.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 11 A.</em></strong><em> Hired candidates grouped by years of experience.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Pie chart: 63.3% of hired candidates had an experience between zero and 3 years" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JDMApEn2BtBHP6-sTQaPtQ.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 11 B.</em></strong><em> Cluster One encompass: candidates without experience, with less than 1 year and with 1,5 years of experience. Cluster Two encompass: candidates with 3, 2 and 2,5 years of experience.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="2 different pie chart. On the left 60.38% of businesses hired a candidate that matched the required experience while in 39.62% had less than required. On the right chart of businesses that required experience without specify how many years, 68.18% hired people with experience while 31.82% didn’t." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8IxwPN8fvowobJoJobNU9Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 12. </strong>On the left: Businesses that hired candidates matching the years of experience required and businesses that hired candidates with less experience than what was required. On the right: A segmentation of candidates with and without working experience, hired by businesses that required experience but didn’t specify how many years.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Tornado chart. Businesses that required from 1 up to 2.5 years of experience are the most that hired candidates without experience." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cMVYSoDHaOIQ9PqYyj11Pg.png" /><figcaption><strong><em>Figure 13. </em></strong><em>This diagram showcase the cluster of businesses that hired candidates with less experience than what the business was asking for. A lack of a light blue bar indicates a candidate with 0 experience.</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 17 hired candidates without experience. Last qualification achieved: 1 Master, 3 Bachelor and 13 Online Courses" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NZHXQS4UMpg83XhlWTVgJg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 14</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study paths of the 17 people hired without direct experience in the role.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 8 hired candidates with 1.5 years of experience. Last qualification achieved: 3 Masters, 1 Bachelor and 4 Online Courses" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MgON1ujaKqDBuv7FcWPN9A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 15</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study paths of 8 hired candidates up to 1.5 years of experience.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 13 hired candidates with 2 and 2.5 years of experience. Last qualification achieved: 5 Masters, 5 Bachelors, 3 Online Courses and 1 Certificate of few hours" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YHXtTZDTjOj8wGi82ta_Rg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 16</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study paths of 13 hired candidates between 2 and 2.5 years of experience.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 12 hired candidates with 3 years of experience. Last qualification achieved: 4 Bachelors, 3 Masters, 2 Highschool Diploma, 1 Online Course Bootcamp, 1 Certificates of few hours" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2aNoR9zy56fZGDRYxadQXw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 17</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study paths of 12 hired candidates with 3 years of experience.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 7 hired candidates with 4 years of experience. Last qualification achieved: 2 Masters, 4 Bachelors and 1 Online Course Bootcamp" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JXiJttC55xlQmEWNjITfgQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 18</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study paths of 7 hired candidates with 4 years of experience.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 5 hired candidates with 5 years of experience and 5 candidates with 6 years of experience. Last qualification achieved: 5 Masters, 4 Bachelors and 1 Associates Degree." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uU1UB-tvHOU0BngeuKei6A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 19</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study paths of 5 hired candidates with 5 years of experience (A) and 6 years of experience (B).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 5 hired candidates with 7 years of experience and 4 candidates with 8 years of experience. Last qualification achieved: 2 Highschool Diploma, 3 Bachelors, 2 Masters, 2 Online Course Bootcamp." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AqP4W9BgMqKdavcpvQMUVg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 20</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study paths of 5 hired candidates with 7 years of experience (A) and 4 candidates with 8 years of experience (B).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Graphic map. Study paths of 1 hired candidates with 9 years of experience and 2 candidates with 12 years of experience. Last qualification achieved: 2 Bachelors and 1 Master" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*STWjrUYRfC5bFN6uBz8q9Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 21</strong>. This map represent a breakdown of the study path of 1 hired candidate with 9 years of experience (A) and 2 candidates with 12 years of experience (B).</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Pie chart. Bachelor degree is the last type of study achieved before jump into the UX segment 34.21%, followed by a Master degree 28.95%  and an Online Course Bootcamp 26.32%." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HTKbSxdwHNeHjzQ0GjrWfA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 22</strong>. This pie showcase what is the last type of study achieved before jumping into the UX design segment.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Cloud words chart: Industrial Design and Industrial Product Design are the most popular Bachelor degrees among a large variety of degrees not necessary related with UX Design." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PVVrf94Q3q8NSCvkR0UVIw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 23</strong>. This cloud highlight what is the most popular bachelor degree among the hired candidates.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Cloud Words Chart: Integrated Design and Digital Experience Design are the most frequent Master degrees in a scenario not particularly reach of this type of study and not necessarily related with UX Design." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TifbFaFqtLk6sqJBystCcA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 24</strong>. This cloud highlight what is the most popular master among the hired candidates.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Cloud words chart: This chart highlight that if we take in consideration all type of studies hired candidates achieved, an online course bootcamp in UX Design, with 720–960 hours of study, is the most popular above a bachelor in Industrial Design followed by one in Industrial Product Design" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BP5Jc8BcW82gC_j9tgH1wg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 25. </strong>This cloud highlight what is the most popular type of study among hired candidates.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Pie chart" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZR59nyPd8qZsBn6TbsHorQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 26.</strong> This pie chart segments 79 designers, dividing among those who started working as UX, UI, PD, UX Researcher immediately after their studies (17,72%), those who have passed from a different profession without first having studied the subject in some way (39,24%), those who studied before changing profession (34,18%) and those who studied after changing profession (8,86%).</figcaption></figure><h3>Discussion</h3><h4><strong>Job Titles (Fig.1)</strong></h4><p>According to the collected data, the most sought-after profession in Germany within the UX segment is the Product Designer (30.05%), followed by UX/UI Designer (26.23%), UX Designer (19.13%), UI/UX Designer (17.75%), UI Designer (4.92%) and UX Researcher (4.92%).</p><p>There is currently no global agreement on what the duties of each of these job titles are, a teacher could teach what the duties and roles of a UX Designer are and then a candidate finds themselves in an application process where the business is convinced that the candidate should know how to use After Effects.</p><p>Generally, positions starting with “UX/UI” and with “UI/UX” have created a mental model where the former, description of the job advertisements in hand, indicate a greater focus on the UX part and the latter on the UI part.</p><p>However, this is not always the case, and some people drafting the job advertisement break this mental model, writing for example “UX/UI” in the job title and then in the description writing “UI/UX”, sometimes by inserting requests outside of this profession and creating some confusion.</p><p>The same can be applied to the position of Product Designer, where we find traditional UX Designer or UI Designer tasks or both, but with a different name.</p><p>At the same time, some companies that use the title of “Product Designer” expect a purely development role of the UI gutted of the research and UX part.</p><p>Therefore, since there is no clear line of demarcations, job titles should be taken for what they are, titles and nothing more, except for the role of UX Researcher, a rather rare position in this study, and that is limited to research.</p><h4>Studies and working experience (Fig.2 and 3)</h4><p><em>78.57%</em> of the analysed ads required previous work experience.<br>The remainder is divided between those requiring:</p><ul><li>A degree (<em>degree/professional diploma</em>) or previous experience.</li><li>A degree (<em>degree/professional diploma</em>) and experience.</li><li>Those that do not specify anything.</li></ul><p>If almost <em>80%</em> of businesses ask only for previous work experience, this opens the debate to various issues.</p><ul><li>Who determines whether previous experience is relevant in a job segment where the same businesses have difficulty understanding the difference between one role and another?</li><li>The vast majority of office jobs can be learned by practising and studying on your own such as via online resources.<br>The alternative is the university, which although it is first of all a privilege (not everyone has the opportunity, something many seems to forget to often) is still one of the two alternatives, and as such should be considered, otherwise why should parents spend money for the university?</li><li>The classic worldwide known paradox: How can previous experience be achieved if businesses require previous working experience?.</li></ul><p>If we only take in consideration businesses that were asking for both, a degree and a previous work experience, <em>53%</em> did not hire a candidate and while this research does not explain the reason, it may be a significant result for businesses in search of a candidate.</p><p>The research also shows that <em>35.20%</em> of businesses do not specify how many years of experience the candidate must have, but <em>28%</em> and <em>19.20%</em> ask for 3+ and 2+ years respectively, much more than any internship, while only <em>9.6%</em> ask for at least 1 year or more of previous work experience.</p><p>In any case, a profession is like a product for sale in the market, the customer decides if it is valid and if he/she needs it.<br>According to the results, most of the German businesses are clear, they are not interested in studies but only to previous work experience.</p><p>Going further into speculation, at the cost of being uncomfortable, I might speculate that the reason is that we are faced with one of those “<em>manual laborers</em>”, in case “<em>digital manual laborers</em>”, where businesses and so people, think the qualification does not matter so much as practical skills, because on one hand it’s one of those jobs that can be learned by doing it, on the other, it is not one of those complex jobs that as much as a doctor or a civil engineer, requires a bachelor degree.</p><p>If businesses are interested in requiring work experience and not any qualification, I might also assume that they believe that the work experience is a certificate of evaluation and validation of the candidate (eg a replacement for school and university certificates).</p><p><em>At this point, however, people involved in the hiring process should no longer ask the candidate to participate in a case study (design challenge) in order to evaluate him/her, as the latter has already been evaluated and validated by the previous businesses where the candidate worked.</em></p><h4>Filled/not filled roles and industry (Fig.4, 5 and 6)</h4><p><em>63.20%</em> of companies hired a candidate with an average timeframe of 2.7 months and the longest of 8 months, while <em>36.20%</em> did not hire any candidate in a time window of 3 + at 10 months.</p><p>The major industries that have hired, are found in the <em>Fintech</em>,<em> Cloud Software Services</em>, <em>Education</em>, <em>Human Resources Software </em>and <em>Healthcare Software</em> sectors.</p><p>This research does not reveal what are the variables that can speed up, delay the hiring process of a candidate or lead to non-hiring, however I can list some factors:</p><ul><li>In Germany many businesses ask for 3 months’ notice, if there is an urgency they will try to hire a new designer within 3 months.</li><li>Too stringent requests could penalise the business making it more difficult to find someone.</li><li>The successful candidate withdrew at the last moment.</li><li>The business may have changed its strategy and suspended the recruiting process, or it was a fake advertisement.</li></ul><p><em>Given that some businesses took up to 8 months before hiring a candidate, students and career changers should feel encouraged to apply even to ads that are a few months old.</em></p><h4>Candidate gender (Fig.7 and 8)</h4><p><em>56.96%</em> of the hired candidates are women while <em>43.04%</em> are men, with a clear predominance of women hired as UX Designers.</p><p>The research does not explain whether the labour market offers more female candidates than male, whether this is just a coincidence, a preference for female candidates or whether females are more skilled.</p><p>For example, anyone who has tried to hire a woman Backend Developer will have found themselves faced with a certain shortage of applications compared to men, perhaps the situation in this context is similar.</p><p>A brief analysis of the teams that hired for the UX Designer position, the one with the highest female ration, highlights that 3 teams probably hired to maintain a 50–50 gender quota while others continued to increase women’s quotas while continuing an imbalance.</p><p>The most bizarre example is perhaps that of an institution neither a business, in the education sector, with an exclusively female team of 10 designers including UX, UI and Product Designer and that in the whole 2021 continued to hire only women.</p><h4>Nationality (Fig.9 and 10)</h4><p>Although the research analysed German job offers that required the English language and not the German one, some premises must be made:</p><ul><li>In Germany, almost all German companies that have a digital product or digital service on the internet, adopt English as their working language in their offices.<br>In cases where this does not happen, usually, those who work in the technical department are not required to speak the German language.<br>In this industry, it is most frequently requested when the job involves contact with German clients not able to speak English.</li><li>Although it is perfectly possible to find a 25-year-old German who cannot speak English, it is still the second language most spoken by European citizens and allows them to communicate with each other.</li></ul><p>We would therefore expect a certain balance in the hired nationalities, perhaps even with a majority of candidates of German nationality, on the contrary the research has shown that <em>77.22%</em> of candidates hired are foreign nationals and that 54.10% are from outside Europe.</p><p>Further research should be conducted to understand the reason for such a large gap, but I can still make some hypotheses:</p><ul><li>The number of Germans able to speak English is lower than their European counterparts, or Germans, being able to work with their own language, prefer not to embark on English language work.</li><li>Foreign candidates are on average more skilled.</li><li>Digital German businesses have long been internationalised, especially in large cities, hiring candidates from all over Europe and even beyond.<br>An international environment and the promotion of diversity are generally considered strengths and therefore promoted.</li><li>Using the English language in the office, allows businesses to expand the pool of candidates from which to draw, this can lead to a greater chance of finding the best candidate.</li></ul><h4>Years of experience (Fig. 3, 11A-B, 12 and 13)</h4><p>We have seen that most businesses require previous work experience, if we return to take a quick look at <strong>Fig. 3</strong> we will notice that the top three is divided between:</p><ul><li><em>35.20%</em> does not specify how many years of previous experience the candidate must have.</li><li><em>28%</em> ask for 3 or more years of experience.</li><li><em>19.20%</em> ask for 2 or more years of experience.</li></ul><p>If we look at <strong>Fig.11 A</strong> and temporarily exclude the column of hired without experience, we can see that all in all the results are confirmed, having the highest number of hiring for candidates with 3 and 2 years of experience, which count for <em>35,48%</em> of hires, followed by <em>11.29%</em> with 4 years of experience and <em>8.06%</em> with 7 years of experience.</p><p>Now, let’s go back to observing the first column of <strong>Fig.11 A</strong>.</p><p>In a context in which almost 80% of the job advertisements analyzed require previous experience in the role, it is positively striking that the greater number of hires occurred among candidates with no previous experience in the role.</p><p>If we now create two clusters as in <strong>Fig.11 B</strong>, we obtain a percentage of <em>31.65%</em> for both clusters, which when added together reaches <em>63.3%</em>.</p><p>This suggests that <em>63.3%</em> of companies hired designers with relatively young experience (from 0 to 3 years) while the remainder, hired candidates from 4 years of experience onwards.</p><p>Among the businesses that specified the years of experience, however, there is <em>39.62%</em> that hired candidates with less experience than required (<strong>Fig. 12</strong>).</p><p>Of the 17 businesses that hired candidates without experience, only 10 specified the years of experience required (from 1 to 5+), with an average of 2.3 years of experience. <br>Among them, two required either a qualification (degree/diploma) or previous experience.</p><p>In conclusion, I can assume one of the following hypotheses:</p><ul><li>Some businesses are forced to hire less experienced candidates due to a lack of availability among more experienced candidates.</li></ul><p><em>For example, considering the German labour market compared to the Italian one where I lived and worked for years, this could be because regardless of whether it is a startup or a long-standing business, generally, permanent contracts in the tech field are routine, so we could have employees who spend more time in a business, consequently less availability on the market, than other positions that typically have a 1 or 2 year contract.</em></p><ul><li>Companies may prefer relatively young* candidates in terms of experience (0 to 3 years).</li></ul><p><em>*Seniority is heavily subjective. Here in Germany I have seen candidates being hired as a junior because they are actually junior, and after just 6–12 months being promoted to the role of senior, and I have seen candidates with 8 years of experience being hired below the seniors in the business, despite having more work experience in the role.</em></p><ul><li>Years of experience required are relative and perhaps added only as a sort of pro forma.</li><li>In contrast to the first point and in common with the second point, candidates from 4 years of experience upwards could have a strong competition and have more difficulties.</li></ul><h4>Online Course Bootcamps — a force to be reckoned with (Fig.14)</h4><p>The map in this figure is astounding, out of 17 candidates hired with no experience, 13 come from Online Course Bootcamps (<em>+400h</em>) and Online Courses (<em>up to 200h</em>).</p><p>Some might argue that perhaps the 17 businesses that hired them, did not require particular experience or university education for the type of job and although 7 of these did not specify how many years of previous experience was needed, the other 10 required between 1 and 7+ years and did not require a mandatory qualification.</p><p><em>What should make us think is that these 79 hired designers have looked for a job in the same country and in the same period of time, this means that 13 candidates have been probably preferred to more qualified candidates and/or more experienced.</em></p><p>By looking at the maps from <strong>Fig.14</strong> to <strong>Fig.21</strong>, it seems as the candidates’ years of experience increase, the number of candidates who have chosen to attend an Online Course Bootcamp decreases.</p><p>This could be due to one or more factors:</p><ul><li>By chance, there was a large group of candidates with this type of study in the cluster of 17 inexperienced hires.</li><li>In the past, there were no Online Course Bootcamps. <br><em>Currently in Germany, there are two major businesses offering UX and UI Design courses, the most popular and dominant in this country, started around nine years ago and a certain amount of years must be considered to achieve a level of notoriety among future designers and popularity among businesses in the digital sector.</em></li><li>The pandemic, the better salary than other jobs, the cost significantly lower than that of many masters and which, among other things, for the unemployed can be supported by the German Employment Agency, could have made this choice very popular.</li></ul><p>Finally, for 13 designers who have attended an Online Course Bootcamp, for 10 of them the Bootcamp is always the same (<em>I have deliberately omitted the name</em>).</p><p>This could indicate one, but not limited, of the following hypotheses:</p><ul><li>Businesses prefer Online Course Bootcamps that have more than 600 hours. This could be either from hearsay, or from the popularity of the course, or because, less likely, they have read the program.</li><li>Students prefer courses from this specific Online Course Bootcamp, or feel that less than 600 hours are not enough to learn the practical basics of the profession.</li></ul><h4>Candidate University Study Path (Fig.14 up to 25)</h4><p>Based on the collected data (<em>Fig. 23 and 24</em>), the most frequent bachelors are:</p><p><em>Industrial Product Design</em><br><em>Industrial Design</em></p><p>And the most frequent masters:</p><p><em>Integrated Design<br>Digital Experience</em></p><p>Based on the collected data (<em>Fig. 25</em>) the top ten of the most frequent studies (any type):</p><ol><li>UX Design Course 720–960h</li><li>Bachelor Industrial Design</li><li>Bachelor Industrial and Product Design</li><li>Master Integrated Design</li><li>UI Design Course 600–800h</li><li>Bachelor Communication Design</li><li>Bachelor Advertising</li><li>Bachelor Advertising and Design</li><li>Bachelor Graphic Design</li><li>UX/UI Design Course 480h</li></ol><p><em>If we were to group people with a high school diploma and professional high school diploma, regardless of the type of study, without a degree and without an online UX or UI design course, then the high school diploma would go to third place tied with the bachelor in industrial and product design. <br>This and the data displayed in the maps, seems to highlight that the UX field, it’s a job sector open to anyone, regardless of the type and level of study.</em></p><p>Among all the bachelors and masters detected in this research it would be interesting to know which are the most relevant for the UX, UI, Digital Product Designer and UX Researcher profession.</p><p><em>Unfortunately the only way would be to be able to read the program of each bachelor/master, since a title is just a title.</em></p><p>Many of the businesses requiring a university degree do so without realising that without reading the content of the program, they are only asking for a title, not necessarily the knowledge to which they aim for, and this <a href="https://www.cmswire.com/digital-experience/the-dirty-little-secret-about-ux-masters-degrees/">article</a> from <a href="https://www.cmswire.com/author/debbie-levitt/">Debbie Levitt</a> provides an idea of the problem.</p><p>For example, “<em>Industrial Product Design</em>” is a university degree that often appears in job requirements, but some university courses with this title, do not address the digital market.</p><p>Rather, they focus instead on the world of physical design, so much so that in one of the programs that I have read, the same university, in recommending career outcomes, never mentions UX or UI and when it mentions Product Design it does so by referring to the physical product, not the digital one.</p><p>On the other hand, most likely to keep up with the market, another university introduced “<em>Industrial Product Design and Digital Media</em>” which indeed tackled also the digital field.</p><p>One of the university masters present in this research, is called “<em>Master in Design</em>”, by the mouth of the same candidate, the master does not address UX Design at all and not even UI Design, it addresses the topic of research in different sectors of the industry.<br>Paradoxically, an 800 hour Online Course provides the basics to start off in UX Design, that that master in object did not provide. Will people involved in the hiring process be aware of this?</p><p>Another master I had the chance to read the program of, is called “<em>Master in Integrated Design</em>”, there are around 600 hours of lessons (excluding the hours of study) in 3 semesters.</p><p>120 hours are dedicated to the English and German terminologies in the field and 180 hours are broad, talking about lights, sound, installations and physical design.<br>This reduces the number of hours fully applicable to digital design to just about 300.</p><p>Within the masters found in this research, there is one that costs €14k and another that costs €30k.</p><p>If based on our personal experiences or our network, we can probably assume that those actively looking for a job, send hundreds of resumes, and if we look at the results of this research, most likely, candidates with expensive masters or prestigious universities, were rejected in favour of candidates who attended a cheaper Online Course Bootcamp of over 400 hours (26.32%) or even a few hours course (up to 200h).</p><p>When it’s about Online Course Bootcamps and Certificates, the same attention to the program should be paid. <br>In recent years, UI Design has separated enough from UX to create a profession of its own.<br>The 720–960 hour UX Design Online Course Bootcamp that emerged from this research, focuses on UX not UI, conversely the 600–800 hour UI Design Online Course Bootcamp focuses on UI not UX, therefore businesses should know what to expect from each one of them especially considering the rampant climb these courses are doing in the education market.</p><p>Students and “<em>returning to study</em>”, should carefully evaluate the study program they intend to pursue, be it university, professional school or online course and if particularly expensive, ask themselves if the knowledge transmitted is so unique and rare as to be worth the cost, otherwise consider investing that money differently.<br>Conversely, if too cheap, they should ask themselves if the cost does not reflect a low level and low quantity of knowledge transmitted.</p><h4>Career and Study Change Path (Fig.25)</h4><p>In an attempt to understand how many started this profession after their studies and how many did not, this pie chart analyzes the 79 hired candidates, by clustering them in four segments:</p><ul><li><strong>Transitioned by job </strong>(<em>39,24%</em>)<br><em>In this group there are all candidates who at some point in their career, have left the previous profession for the profession of UX, UX / UI, UI, UI / UX, Product Designer and UX Researcher without studying or updating themselves first.<br>This includes both, those from opposite professions and studies (eg Account Manager, Sales / BA Business Administration etc) and those from jobs and studies that have or could have a fraction of a relationship (Graphic Designer, Frontend Developer / BA Brand Management etc) with the profession in object.</em></li><li><strong>Transitioned by study</strong> (<em>34,18%</em>)<br><em>In this group there are all the candidates who at some point in their career, have chosen to leave their previous profession and study UX or UI through a master, school or an Online Course/Bootcamp and then start a profession such as UX, UX/UI , UI, UI/UX, Product Designer and UX Researcher.</em></li><li><strong>Direct</strong> (<em>17,72%</em>)<br><em>In this group there are all the candidates who, after having attended a degree course, a master’s degree or a professional school, have started their career directly as UX, UX / UI, UI, UI / UX, Product Designer and UX Researcher.<br>In most cases these are candidates who have obtained a qualification such as Industrial Product Designer, Interface Designer, Industrial Engineering and similar. <br>Only one had a disconnected qualification as Foreign Languages and another a parallel qualification in Art Direction plus Plastic Arts and Electronic Media.</em></li><li><strong>Transitioned by job and study </strong><em>(8,86%)<br>In this are those who left their previous profession (like the “transitioned by job”) started a new job as UX, UX / UI, UI, UI / UX, Product Designer and UX Researcher.<br>Then, after this they took the decision of updating themselves with a master a school or an Online Course/Bootcamp.</em></li></ul><p>If we add up the data of the “<em>Transitioned</em>”, we obtain that 82.28% of the hired people started with a different type of profession.</p><p>This research is unable to determine with absolute certainty what is the key element that allowed people, who had a different job, to start a career as a UX, UI, Product Designer or Researcher without having had previous experience in the role or without having studies in UX Design.</p><p>I can only speculate some possibilities:</p><ul><li>Random factor</li></ul><p><em>Even without this explorative research, it should be clear by now that the recruitment processes have nothing meritocratic and nothing objective.<br>We grow up with the idea that a qualification or previous experience gives us a preference path towards those who do not have it, but in fact this is not the case.<br>The evaluations are therefore completely personal.</em></p><ul><li>Luck</li></ul><p><em>Luck is part of life, we shouldn’t be ashamed to admit it. Be there, apply to the right job, in the right business at the right time.</em></p><ul><li>For whatever reason, the business decided to invest in the candidate</li></ul><p><em>It takes more skills to read a person and courage to invest in him/her, than to buy someone in which another business had previously invested.</em></p><ul><li>Self-taught candidate or incomplete LinkedIn profile.</li></ul><p><em>People could study the profession on their own, practising, reading articles or books, and in the process of recruiting they have convinced the business.<br>Although the percentage of “Transitioned by job” is quite high and therefore less likely that all these candidates have not added a course or study in the field in their LinkedIn profile, it is still a possibility.</em></p><ul><li>A sort of cognitive distortion of those involved in the recruitment process.</li></ul><p><em>The mind confirms the pre-established image that a person has of reality, by means of cognitive distortions.<br>For example, a Graphic Designer or even a Photographer, can be hired as UX Designer or a UI Designer because there is a graphic component or because there is the word designer. <br>Consequently a Frontend Developer is hired as UI Designer/Product Designer because there’s an association between the “Frontend” and the fact that a User Interface shows up in front of a user.<br>A Brand Designer is hired as UI Designer/Product Designer because being brand associated with a design such as for example a logo it’s also again associated with the user interface and the word “designer” present in both titles strengthen this reasoning.<br>A Data Analyst, since analyzes data then he/she will also automatically be a UX Researcher, a degree at Academy of Fine Arts means being a UI Designer because of the graphic/visual component, a degree in Psychology a UX Designer because UX Design partially draws on some aspects of psychology.</em></p><p><em>In cognitive distortions, for the mind it is not truth but coherence that is important, if our mind believes that our thinking is coherent, then it is valid even if in fact it is not or is only minimally so.</em></p><h3>Conclusions</h3><p>Based on the methodology used, the most frequently hired candidate is of foreign nationality and female.<br>German business seems to greatly approach an international working environment and they adapted by turning English as the main working language in their offices, most likely to accommodate foreigners and have a greater pool of candidates to attract. <br>Further research could be conducted to understand the reasons for higher female employment in the field, in order to understand if gender quota were randomised, women more skilled or if somehow UX Design it’s a field that appeals more to women than men.</p><p>The study path is various, data displays a profession that at its base consists of some people with a high school diploma, people with different bachelors, not necessarily related to the UX field, university masters in the field of design that change the direction of a previous type of bachelor, and an extreme popularity of UX Design courses over 480h.<br>Further research could be conducted to understand if the hiring of candidates with a UX Design course is growing in Germany and in other countries where the same identical online courses are available.</p><p>From the point of view of the demand, the known trend of businesses in which previous work experience is required continues, in this case at levels that, taken only in this context, are worrying.<br>However they are dampened by businesses, it seems, forced to hire people with less experience than required, in some cases even five years less.</p><p>The complete absence of a request for a study qualification in 78.57% of cases, on the one hand, can be seen as encouraging, if we take into account that for one reason or another not everyone may have the opportunity to attend university.<br>This would give a job opportunity to people with different study paths and the businesses to discover excellent candidates even outside the university path.</p><p>However, a lack of any type of level of study/certification or an update before and during the same design career of the candidate, in order to acquire the theory and keep the candidate updated (almost all German businesses offers a study budget between €500–€1500 or more), may be counter productive for the business, the candidate and the whole design ecosystem itself.</p><p>On the other hand, the fact that this aspect is coupled with the request for previous work experience is instead discouraging, on the one hand because obviously if all businesses reasoned this way, the same ones would not exist, on the other because it represents a sort of destabilisation of a system that is made to teach a job as an alternative, when possible, to direct learning in the field.<br>Therefore, requiring a previous experience is a bit of a denial of the very existence of the university or the vocational school.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10a341b98dd1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/is-ux-design-a-career-and-study-change-path-10a341b98dd1">Is UX Design a Career and Study Change Path?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp">Bootcamp</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Accessibility and public administration healthcare websites, in Germany, Italy, Spain and United…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/accessibility-and-public-administration-healthcare-websites-in-germany-italy-spain-and-united-dd8734f273b2?source=rss-97b4e4bd317b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd8734f273b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[web-accessibility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accessibility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universal-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Erik]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Feb 2021 11:39:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-24T11:18:02.179Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Accessibility and public administration healthcare websites, in Germany, Italy, Spain and United Kingdom</h3><h3><strong>Abstract</strong></h3><p>20 years have passed since the introduction of WCAG 1.0 and a little less since in the early 2000s European countries began to use them as a reference by incorporating them into local laws on web accessibility.</p><p>On October 26, 2016, the European Directive 2102 established that European countries, by September 23, 2018, must integrate WCAG 2.1 into local laws on internet accessibility and that by September 22, 2020, all the websites of the institutions of the public sector must be accessible and <strong>at least once a year</strong> must publish an accessibility statement.</p><p>Starting from the assumption that the entire public sector should have long since reached WCAG accessibility level A, this audit, which is not intended to be exhaustive, has the main objective of examining the homepage of 40 websites related to the health sector of the top four European economies, obtaining indications regarding the current state of implementation of WCAG 2.1 level AA.</p><p>The research was conducted using seven automation tools and manual techniques, the data were collected taking into account the failed and partially failed checkpoints and the number of errors generated (redundancy included).</p><p>The audit also analyzed compliance with the publication of the accessibility statement and the technological stack of the websites. None of the 40 sites were found to fully comply with WCAG 2.1.</p><p>The data also highlighted basic problems, such as the failure or incorrect use of HTML headers (19 sites), but also obsolete technological choices such as the use of dated markup (11 sites).</p><p>The results have also generated the perception that the accessibility statement represents an uncomfortable homework task, once performed, in several cases there seems no improvements, not to mention that in some cases the statements are older than a year, while the EU Directive asks to publish at least one statement per year.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>If WCAG 1.0 was introduced in 1999, there is another important milestone and it is represented by the adoption in 2006 of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), an important document signed by 164 countries including the European Union and which in article 9 states:</p><blockquote><em>To enable persons with disabilities to live independently and participate fully in all aspects of life, States Parties shall take appropriate measures to ensure to persons with disabilities access, on an equal basis with others, to the physical environment, to transportation, to information and communications, including information and communications technologies and systems, and to other facilities and services open or provided to the public, both in urban and in rural areas.</em></blockquote><p>Point number 2 letter G of the same article specifies:</p><blockquote><em>States Parties shall also take appropriate measures: To promote access for persons with disabilities to new information and communications technologies and systems, including the Internet;</em></blockquote><p>Disabilities are generally divided into 4 main categories, visual, auditory, motor and cognitive. The latter, perhaps less well known, include dyslexia, short-term memory deficit, people who require consistent design, simplified language and people who experience an educational or cultural disability.</p><p>To this it should be added that the disability does not necessarily have to be permanent, it can also be a temporary disability, just think of a fractured hand or someone who recently went through some surgery that affects the interaction with the environment.</p><p>The definition of the term “disability” according to the CRPD is as follows:</p><blockquote><em>Persons with disabilities include those who have long-term physical, mental, intellectual or sensory impairments which in interaction with various barriers may hinder their full and effective participation in society on an equal basis with others.</em></blockquote><p>The last part of this statement is important, as it is in the impossibility of interacting with the surrounding environment due to its barriers, that society itself becomes disabled and not the disabled person itself.</p><p>There are 80 million people with more or less severe disabilities living in Europe, and while the development of a site accessible to all should be a question of humanity rather than a legal obligation, public administrations (PAs) should understand that citizens being the main contributors to the services offered by the PAs themselves, the latter should not make any differences and indeed should offer equal accessibility without distinction.</p><p>Countries with the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_the_European_Union">highest nominal GDP</a> were chosen. <br>The main European economies in this sense are Germany, the United Kingdom, France and Italy.</p><p>Even if there was Brexit, the UK was kept both for language reasons (manual technique it’s easier) and because their legislation refers to WCAG 2.1.</p><p>France was excluded due to lack of knowledge of the language, and Spain included (fifth largest economy in Europe).</p><p>Health sector was chosen because it represents an important intersection point between people and the internet, sooner or later in fact, we all have to interact with this sector.</p><p>The websites were selected based on the number of people they are called to serve.</p><p>For Germany, which has an insurance-based health system, the <a href="https://www.krankenkassen.de/krankenkassen-vergleich/statistik/versicherte/aktuell/">top 10 insurances </a>by number of members were chosen, among those that citizens are obliged to choose by law.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.mscbs.gob.es/organizacion/ccaa/directorio/home.htm">Spanish</a> health system, similar to the Italian one, serves its citizens through websites located in each of the 17 autonomous communities that make up Spain. Here the websites of the 10 most populous communities were chosen.</p><p>The United Kingdom offered five forced choices, having one national site, one for Wales, one for England, one for Scotland and one for Northern Ireland.</p><p>Still five websites connected to the national health system were missing, the choice fell <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/504252/leading-busy-hospitals-ranked-by-number-of-admissions-england-uk/">on hospitals</a>, in this case based on the number of patients served.</p><p>The Italian health system serves citizens locally through “local health units” also called ASL / USL / AUSL (have changed name several times), each has a website and there can be more than one within the same city .</p><p>For example, the city of Rome is divided into 15 municipalities and citizens visit the website of the “local health unit” responsible for their municipality of residence.</p><p>The healthcare websites of <a href="https://www.tuttitalia.it/citta/popolazione/">the cities with the highest population</a> were chosen (Turin excluded).</p><p>For each site, only the homepage was analyzed.</p><p>The audit used a combination of manual techniques and the use of seven different automation systems.</p><p>WCAGs are made up of “checkpoints” categorized into levels A, AA and AAA.</p><p>The European Directive encourages the implementation of level AAA but does not require it, it is at the discretion of European countries to include it in their legislation.</p><p>All sites were tested against WCAG 2.1 and failed checkpoints were categorized in ARIA, Color, Content, Form, HTML, Image, Link, Media, Responsive, Table, Other.</p><p>The audit started on January 27th and ended with the writing of this report on February 22th.</p><h3>How to read data</h3><p>The numbers represented in the graphs should not and cannot be used to make comparisons between one site and another, in the same way a reduced number of non-respected checkpoints is not an indication of a site with better accessibility.</p><p>Although it may not be an excuse, but it is still a fact, in a homepage with 20,000 lines of code, it is easier to find even distracting errors than a homepage with 5,000 lines of code.</p><p>A homepage can fail checkpoints 1.4.3 (color contrast), 1.4.5 (image of text) and 1.4.1 (use of color) but if another homepage fails only one checkpoint, for example 2.1.1 (keyboard) and keyboard navigation is not possible, the latter is potentially in a more serious situation.</p><p>Checkpoints data include both completely failed and partially failed. Also, failing some checkpoints can cause a cascade effect that automatically impacts other checkpoints, these are also included in the overall count.<br>For this reason, it must therefore be taken into account that by conforming to the checkpoint that triggered the cascade effect, it potentially also conforms the other affected checkpoints..</p><p>According to the type of error, checkpoints were divided into the categories Aria, Color, Content, Form, HTML, Image, Link, Media, Responsive, Table, Other.<br>The number of errors does not necessarily represent single errors but redundancy, this is because every time the same type of error is repeated on the page, it represents a potential obstacle for the user.</p><p>The “HTML” category includes both errors strictly connected with the respect of the WCAGs, and errors and missed best practices of the W3C.</p><p>The “Table” category is present only for Italian sites, as they are the only ones to have errors of this type.</p><h3>Overall results</h3><h4>Language accessibility</h4><blockquote><strong>What is really ICT accessibility?</strong> Basically stands for access for all or for everyone. So this could include people with disabilities, it could include individuals who are aging that may be losing their sight and may be losing their hearing, and it could include English as a second language in addition. <br>So again, accessibility is access for all. — Christopher Lee, <a href="https://g3ict.org/">G3ICT</a></blockquote><p>This is a very underestimated aspect of accessibility and which, unfortunately, not being an obligation, will find little implementation by those PAs that need laws that dictate what to do and sometimes, even those are not enough.</p><p>Across Europe, <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/04/09/most-european-students-learn-english-in-school/">91% of students</a> in primary and secondary school were studying English in 2017, but it has been part of the school education system since before the 90s and its introduction into the school system is long-standing (<a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/english-in-the-germanspeaking-world/history-of-english-instruction-in-the-germanspeaking-world/964C5BCA04BD8FBA41EE6EE590E7BDEE#:~:text=The%20second%20time%20span%20includes,to%20be%20established%20at%20universities.">1895, Prussia</a>).</p><p>Today English is the second most spoken language in the world and the most popular in <a href="https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/94456/most-common-second-languages-spoken-around-world">55 countries</a>.</p><p>Since the European borders have been opened to European citizens, moving to another country is much easier and thanks to the spread of the internet, digital companies and remote work, it is very easy to start a new life abroad without first, need to learn the local language.</p><p>In multi-cultural cities like Berlin where <a href="https://www.businesslocationcenter.de/en/business-location/berlin-at-a-glance/demographic-data/#:~:text=Foreign%20population%20of%20Berlin,-People%20from%20more&amp;text=Around%20777%2C345%20foreigners%20were%20registered,Turkey%2C%20Poland%2C%20and%20Syria.">21% of the population is foreign</a>, the English language has since become the official language in the offices of practically all companies in the digital sector.</p><ul><li>11.2 million foreigners live in <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/890277/foreigner-numbers-by-country-of-origin-germany/#:~:text=As%20of%202019%2C%20approximately%201.47,million%20foreigners%20lived%20in%20Germany.">Germany</a></li><li>9.5 million foreigners live in the <a href="https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/migrants-in-the-uk-an-overview/">UK</a></li><li>5.9 million foreigners live in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Spain#:~:text=According%20to%20the%20United%20Nations,%2C%20World%20Disasters%20Report%202006">Spain</a></li><li>5.3 million foreigners in <a href="https://www.infomigrants.net/en/post/19852/italy-has-third-largest-migrant-population-in-europe-report">Italy</a></li></ul><p>Let’s see which countries are at the forefront of this aspect of accessibility by offering healthcare websites accessible in a second language.</p><p><strong>Germany:</strong></p><ul><li>3 websites out of 10 use English as second language</li><li>5 websites out of 10 use multiple languages such as English, Chinese, Turkish, Polish, Spanish, Arabic, Croatian, Romanian, French, Greek, Italian, Magyar, Portuguese, Croatian, Russian and without integrating Google translate.</li><li>2 websites out of 10 do not use any second language</li></ul><p><strong>United Kingdom:</strong></p><ul><li>2 websites out of 10 integrate Google Translate to offer more than 50 languages</li><li>8 websites out 10 do not offer accessibility in any second language.</li></ul><p><strong>Spain:</strong></p><ul><li>1 website out of 10 integrate Google Translate to offer English and French</li><li>9 websites out 10 do not offer accessibility in any second language except for their own languages such as for example Basque and Catalan</li></ul><p><strong>Italy:</strong></p><ul><li>1 website out of 10 integrate Google Translate to offer more than 45 languages</li><li>9 websites out 10 do not offer accessibility in any second language. One website may offer the English language, but the icon is there without being linked to a translated page</li></ul><p>It is worth remembering that in countries like Italy,<a href="https://www.agi.it/fact-checking/immigrati_pil_italia-5648357/news/2019-06-13"> foreigners produce 9%</a> of the gross domestic product, about 139 billion euros.<br>If there’s no budget for a translation in English and its maintenance, integrating Google translate takes just few minutes.</p><h4>Websites stack</h4><p><strong>CMS</strong></p><ul><li>24 websites out of 40 use a CMS.</li><li>8 Italian sites out of 10 use Joomla, Liferay, DNN, Plone and NQContent. Joomla is the most used.</li><li>6 German sites out of 10 use TYPO3, Magnolia, AEM and GSB (a government CMS). TYPO3 is the most used.</li><li>5 UK sites out of 10 use Wordpress and Wagtail. Wordpress is the most used.</li><li>5 Spanish sites out of 10 use Drupal, OpenCMS and Sharepoint. Drupal is the most used.</li></ul><p><strong>JS Framework</strong></p><p>10 websites out of 40 use a Javascript framework such as Vue, React, Angular, Prototype, Mootools and AlloyUI.</p><p>Germans and United Kingdom sites use the most popular such as React and Angular where Germans sites are the ones that do the larger use of JS framework while in opposite Spain sites the lesser usage.</p><p><strong>UI Framework</strong></p><p>20 websites out of 20 use a UI framework such as Bootstrap, Foundation and UIKit.</p><p>German sites are the only ones using both Bootstrap and Foundation while Italian sites are the ones that do the largest use of a UI framework with 7 out of 10 using it.</p><p><strong>HTML</strong></p><ul><li>29 websites out of 40 use HTML5.</li><li>All German sites use HTML5</li><li>9 UK sites use HTML5 and one use XHTML 1.0</li><li>6 Spanish sites use HTML5, one uses HTML strict 4.01, one uses HTML 4 transitional combined with XHTML transitional, another two use XHTML 1.0 transitional.</li><li>4 Italian sites use HTML5, one use HTML 4.01 transitional, one use HTML 4 transitional, one use XHTML 1.1 strict and three use XHTML 1.0 transitional.</li></ul><h4><strong>Overall Failed checkpoints</strong></h4><p>The following image lists the 40 websites analyzed, starting with the website with the least number of failed checkpoints and showing for each site the number of levels A and AA failed checkpoints</p><p><strong>Site DE_5:</strong> 15 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 6 Level AA<br>Site DE_10: 15 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 6 Level AA<br><strong>Site ES_5:</strong> 15 Failed checkpoint / 10 Level A / 5 Level AA</p><p>Site UK_1: 16 Failed checkpoint / 7 Level A / 9 Level AA<br><strong>Site IT_9:</strong> 16 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 7 Level AA<br>Site IT_10: 16 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 7 Level AA</p><p><strong>Site ES_1:</strong> 17 Failed checkpoint / 6 Level A / 11 Level AA<br>Site ES_4: 17 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 8 Level AA<br><strong>Site ES_9:</strong> 17 Failed checkpoint / 8 Level A / 9 Level AA</p><p>Site DE_4: 18 Failed checkpoint / 13 Level A / 5 Level AA<br><strong>Site UK_2:</strong> 18 Failed checkpoint / 7 Level A / 8 Level AA<br>Site UK_5: 18 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 9 Level AA<br><strong>Site ES_7:</strong> 18 Failed checkpoint / 7 Level A / 11 Level AA</p><p>Site DE_2: 19 Failed checkpoint / 8 Level A / 11 Level AA<br><strong>Site DE_7:</strong> 19 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 10 Level AA<br>Site UK_7: 19 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A /10 Level AA<br><strong>Site UK_8:</strong> 19 Failed checkpoint / 8 Level A / 11 Level AA<br>Site ES_10: 19 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 10 Level AA<br><strong>Site IT_5:</strong> 19 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A / 10 Level AA</p><p>Site DE_1: 20 Failed checkpoint / 11 Level A / 9 Level AA<br><strong>Site DE_3:</strong> 20 Failed checkpoint / 11 Level A / 9 Level AA<br>Site DE_9: 20 Failed checkpoint / 11 Level A / 9 Level AA<br><strong>Site UK_3:</strong> 20 Failed checkpoint / 9 Level A /11 Level AA<br>Site ES_6: 20 Failed checkpoint / 10 Level A / 10 Level AA<br><strong>Site ES_8:</strong> 20 Failed checkpoint / 11 Level A / 9 Level AA<br>Site IT_3: 20 Failed checkpoint / 12 Level A / 8 Level AA<br><strong>Site IT_4:</strong> 20 Failed checkpoint / 10 Level A / 10 Level AA</p><p>Site UK_9: 21 Failed checkpoint / 10 Level A / 11 Level AA<br><strong>Site UK_10:</strong> 21 Failed checkpoint / 12 Level A / 9 Level AA</p><p>Site UK_4: 22 Failed checkpoint / 11 Level A / 11 Level AA<br><strong>Site IT_6:</strong> 22 Failed checkpoint / 12 Level A / 10 Level AA</p><p>Site DE_6: 23 Failed checkpoint / 12 Level A / 11 Level AA<br><strong>Site UK_6:</strong> 23 Failed checkpoint / 12 Level A / 11 Level AA<br>Site ES_2: 23 Failed checkpoint / 11 Level A / 12 Level AA<br><strong>Site IT_1:</strong> 23 Failed checkpoint / 14 Level A / 9 Level AA</p><p>Site IT_2: 24 Failed checkpoint / 14 Level A / 10 Level AA</p><p><strong>Site IT_8:</strong> 24 Failed checkpoint / 13 Level A / 11 Level AA</p><p>Site IT_7: 25 Failed checkpoint / 14 Level A / 11 Level AA</p><p><strong>Site DE_8:</strong> 26 Failed checkpoint / 14 Level A / 12 Level AA<br>Site ES_3: 26 Failed checkpoint / 17 Level A / 9 Level AA</p><figure><img alt="Image of graphic bars reporting the overall failed checkpoints (green), failed level A (red) and failed level AA (yellow)" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mnmDk5Vp2IzMqJSoS8qTkQ.png" /><figcaption>Overall failed checkpoints in green, failed level A in red, failed level AA in yellow</figcaption></figure><p>We can see that the best performers are two German sites while the worst performers are a Spanish site and a German site.<br>However, the numbers are relative for the reasons already explained in the introduction, it‘s not simply a matter of non-compliant checkpoints but of what kind of checkpoints, their severity.<br>For example, the Italian site ranked fifth, in terms of accessibility and usability is dramatic.<br>This graphic simply fulfills the main scope of this audit, to highlight if the analyzed sites are compliant with WCAG 2.1.</p><h4>Shared failed checkpoints</h4><p>The highest failed checkpoints shared by Germany, Italy, United Kingdom and Spain are the followings:</p><ul><li>1.1.1 Non-text Content (Level A)</li><li>1.3.1 Info and Relationships (Level A)</li></ul><p>United Kingdom and Spain also shared a failure in the checkpoint:</p><ul><li>1.3.4 Orientation (Level AA)</li></ul><p>Italy and United Kingdom also shared a failure in the checkpoint:</p><ul><li>1.4.5 Images of text (Level AA)</li></ul><p>Italy, United Kingdom and Spain also shared a failure in the checkpoint:</p><ul><li>1.4.10 Reflow (Level AA)</li></ul><p>Germany and United Kingdom also share a failure in the checkpoint:</p><ul><li>4.1.2 Name, Role, Value (Level A)</li></ul><p>Germany and Italy also share a failure in the checkpoint:</p><ul><li>2.4.4 Link purpose in context (Level A)</li></ul><h4>Overall WCAG errors</h4><p>The following image lists the 40 websites analyzed, starting with the website with the least number of errors.<br>Such errors include redundancy and represent the sum of the errors of each category: ARIA, Color, Content, Form, HTML, Image, Link, Media, Responsive, Table, Other.</p><p><strong>DE_10:</strong> 115 errors<br>ES_10: 151 errors<br><strong>ES_5:</strong> 154 errors<br>UK_10: 202 errors<br><strong>IT_9:</strong> 262 errors<br>DE_4: 276 errors<br><strong>UK_1:</strong> 310 errors<br>UK_4: 327 errors<br><strong>ES_3:</strong> 334 errors<br>UK_5: 375 errors<br><strong>UK_2:</strong> 409 errors<br>IT_7: 421 errors<br><strong>IT_10:</strong> 426 errors<br>ES_9: 467 errors<br><strong>UK_7:</strong> 474 errors<br>UK_8: 474 errors<br><strong>DE_3:</strong> 491 errors<br>ES_4: 494 errors<br><strong>IT_6:</strong> 601 errors<br>ES_7: 630 errors<br><strong>ES_1:</strong> 731 errors<br>UK_3: 788 errors<br><strong>DE_6:</strong> 884 errors<br>DE_5: 978 errors<br><strong>IT_3:</strong> 998 errors<br>DE_1: 1050 errors<br><strong>ES_8:</strong> 1055 errors<br>ES_6: 1096 errors<br><strong>DE_2:</strong> 1130 errors<br>UK_6: 1188 errors<br><strong>IT_5:</strong> 1243 errors<br>DE_9: 1328 errors<br><strong>UK_9:</strong> 1353 errors<br>ES_2: 1522 errors<br><strong>IT_2:</strong> 1640 errors<br>IT_4: 1902 errors<br><strong>IT_1:</strong> 2113 errors<br>DE_7: 2193 errors<br><strong>IT_8:</strong> 3318 errors<br>DE_8: 3633 errors</p><figure><img alt="Image of graphic bars reporting the overall errors for all 40 websites" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M7p28N7nC_25jSLki9z9dg.png" /><figcaption>Overall errors</figcaption></figure><p>Also in this case the number of errors is relative in itself. In counting errors, it is necessary to take into account that the more lines of code there are, the more likely it is to find errors.</p><p>Moreover, the number of them is not in itself a factor that determines how accessible a site is and how much not, but they helps to give an overview of the general diligence applied in the development of the site and allows to understand if these sites have errors in common.</p><p>For example, only 8 out of 40 sites analyzed make perfect use of headings, all the others had several mistakes such as multiple and only headers 1 or skipped headings, missing headings, headings used to hack space and paragraph titles that should instead be headings.</p><p>In these terms, the Italian sites are among the worst followed by the German sites.<br>The Italian and Spanish sites and some English sites, are those with the oldest design, however the obsolescence of these and in some case what seems a patched up practice of updating, does not seem to be the cause, as the German sites that instead turn out to be the most modern, have more errors in the headings than the Spanish sites do, thus suggesting that at the base there is a problem of accessibility know-how or in any case of best practices.</p><h4>Overall category errors</h4><p>The following graphic adds up all the errors of all the 40 healthcare websites analyzed.</p><figure><img alt="Image of graphic bars reporting the overall category errors of the 40 websites" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/987/1*KiSx71l6y8IfxNXJz9osBA.png" /><figcaption>Overall category errors</figcaption></figure><p>Dividing them into categories we obtain the following results:</p><ul><li><strong>Media and table</strong>, 16 and 36 errors respectively.<br>These are the categories with less errors, however very few websites use videos and only Italian websites had table errors, when used.</li><li><strong>Link and image</strong>, 755 and 773 errors respectively.<br>The “link” category refers to broken links, absence of link text describing the purpose of the link for an anchor element or link text without an attribute title.<br>The “image” category refers to the non-use of alt attributes, the use of text alternatives such as filenames / placeholder, the use of image text to convey a message or the non-use of alternative attributes on image elements, area elements or input elements of type image.</li><li><strong>Form and other</strong>, 1006 and 1047 errors respectively.<br>While “others” refers to any problem that did not fit into the other categories, the “form” category refers to any kind of problem related to this element, for example form control without an accessible name, lack of label element to explicitly associate a form control with a label or lack of a highly visible focus indicator in place of the default browser indicator.</li><li><strong>Color and ARIA</strong>, 1563 and 2686 errors respectively.<br>The “color” category refers to any problem related with the contrast ratio, while “ARIA” category refers to problems with the ARIA markup, for example lack of use of role=status attribute in order to notify the assistive technologies, lack of attributes to expose the state of a component or for example lack of use of aria-labeledby for link purpose.</li><li><strong>HTML and responsive</strong>, 3784 and 7122 errors.<br>The “HTML” category refers to problems such for example the wrong use of h1-h6 to identify headings, commonly skipped headings, wrong hierarchy structure or headings used to hack space. <br>Other examples may be the absence of unique ID attributes within the page, the absence of language attributes or the lack of separate information and structure from presentation to enable different presentations.<br>Refers to situations where size and position do not scales with text size, columns do not reflow, content restrict its view and operation to a single display orientation for no specific reason or CSS is not used in a way that allows users to view content in such a way that line length can average 80 characters or less.</li><li><strong>Content</strong>, 18748 errors.<br>This category mainly refers to two problems, using absolute font units instead of relative units such as percent, em units or named font sizes in order to avoid zoom problems, and not specifying line spacing in CSS. <br>As many people with cognitive disabilities have trouble tracking lines of text when a block of text is single spaced. Providing spacing between 1.5 to 2 allows them to start a new line more easily once they have finished the previous one.</li></ul><h4><strong>Design problems</strong></h4><p>There are certain design choices that, regardless of what the WCAG requires or not, are notoriously wrong or require careful use.</p><p><strong>Font size</strong></p><p>Even if the WCAGs do not set the minimum font size or a user can zoom in with assistive technologies.<br>Websites should do what is in their powers to improve the accessibility without constantly rely on assistive technologies to improve aspects that can be improved without break the website design/layout.<br>There is no reason to use 8pt / 10.6px for the menu headers and 9pt / 12px for the body text. <br>The use of small or microscopic fonts was a trend of the past that was carried out with the idea that the design was slick.</p><p>An example:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/805/1*L6WiLxgUtieRP6Ykg4FKIg.png" /><figcaption>Image of a text at 12px and low visibility</figcaption></figure><p>Same text enlarged at 18px and black color:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/807/1*6iyVEwmF8_F2xPqr1TJdzQ.png" /><figcaption>Image of a text at 18px and good visibility</figcaption></figure><p>The most modern websites of this audit, mostly use fonts in the body text between 16px and 20px usually Germany and some UK website, while the less modern sites use fonts that are just too small even for people like me that wear a pair of glasses but do not belong to the canonical group of people with disabilities.</p><blockquote>Choose a font that’s at least <strong>16 pixels</strong>, or 12 points. If many of your users are older adults, consider using an even larger font size — <strong>19 pixels </strong>or 14 points.6,24 A small font size is more difficult to read, especially for users with limited literacy skills and older adults. — <a href="https://health.gov/healthliteracyonline/display/section-3-3/">Health.gov</a></blockquote><p>Some of the sites analyzed were rich in textual content:</p><blockquote>These findings provide evidence that text-heavy websites should use <strong>fonts of size 18 </strong>or larger and use default line spacing when the goal is to make a web page easy to read and comprehend. — <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/301935601_Make_It_Big_The_Effect_of_Font_Size_and_Line_Spacing_on_Online_Readability">Luz Rello, Mari-Carmen Marcos, Martin Pielot</a></blockquote><p>Fonts that are too small are not good not only for healthy people, but for dyslexic people either:</p><blockquote>Font size should be 12–14 point or equivalent (e.g. 1–1.2em / <strong>16–19 px</strong>). Some dyslexic readers may request a larger font. — <a href="https://www.bdadyslexia.org.uk/advice/employers/creating-a-dyslexia-friendly-workplace/dyslexia-friendly-style-guide">Bdadyslexia</a></blockquote><p><strong>Justified text</strong></p><p>The justification of the text is another custom of the past and it was found in the oldest sites analyzed.</p><blockquote>Use left-aligned text<strong>.</strong> A consistent left margin makes reading easier. — <a href="https://accessibility.huit.harvard.edu/design-readability#:~:text=A%20value%20of%201.3%20to,sometimes%20known%20as%20%22rivers%22.">Harvard University</a></blockquote><p>Full justification often makes reading more difficult because sometimes there is:</p><blockquote>Extra space between words that makes it difficult to follow along on one line.</blockquote><blockquote>Less space between some words that makes it difficult to distinguish words.<br>inconsistent letter spacing that makes it harder to distinguish letters and words.</blockquote><blockquote>Spacing that causes “rivers of white” and disrupts tracking.</blockquote><blockquote>The problems with full justification are usually much worse when users increase the text size (and text reflows as it should per Success Criterion 1.4.10: Reflow).</blockquote><blockquote>Centered text is also more difficult for most people to read, when there are multiple lines of text. It is harder to find the beginning of the next line of text and keep a smooth reading flow for comprehension. Additionally, screen magnification users might miss some centered text. -<a href="https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/low-vision-a11y-tf/wiki/Supplemental_Guidance:_Text_Justification#:~:text=With%20full%20justification%2C%20text%20is,sometimes%20adjusted%20space%20between%20letters.&amp;text=for%20left%2Dto%2Dright%20scripts%2C%20left%20justified,text%20is%20easier%20to%20read">W3.org</a></blockquote><p><strong>Capitalization</strong></p><p>Four Spanish sites and eight Italian sites use capitalization in headings, titles or even in small paragraphs, this too is a legacy of the past, more atavistic than small fonts.</p><p>Here we have some examples:</p><figure><img alt="Image of a body text with yellow capitalize letters on a black background" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/979/1*wqnacBctqJWNj7TMrRS68g.png" /><figcaption>Image of capitalization in the “contrast site version”</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Image of another example of a long title using capitalized letters in a small box area" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/698/1*RPq067eSam73u5iRN8OnIA.png" /><figcaption>Image of capitalization used in the news title</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Image of capitalized letters used in a sentence within a very small box" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/402/1*gLybI13wzvCWx3UCANKiXg.png" /><figcaption>Image of capitalization used in the news title within a too small font size text context</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Image of capitalization used for the name of the headers menu" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/1*DF_vbuB86e4DmFDgD4tR_A.png" /><figcaption>Image of capitalization used in the menu headers</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="Image of another example of capitalization used in the headers menu" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/446/1*FPbXpQmQQr_c-8sV66i90g.png" /><figcaption>Image of capitalization used in the menu headers</figcaption></figure><p>There are two problems with capitalized text in links:</p><blockquote>Firstly, some screen readers read capitalized text letter-by-letter. And this occasionally even occurs when the HTML is in sentence-case and the CSS forces the capitalization.</blockquote><blockquote>The second problem is that capital letters are harder to read (for everyone, but especially people with reading disabilities).</blockquote><blockquote>Capitalized text has no difference in shape: all the words are just one big rectangle. Sentence capitals have differentiated shapes based on the letters used.</blockquote><blockquote>The general rule when it comes to reading is: if it’s more difficult to the general public then it will be almost impossible for a person with a cognitive disability to read. — <a href="https://www.sitepoint.com/15-rules-making-accessible-links/">Sitepoint</a></blockquote><p>The use of All Caps can reduce the readability of your text:</p><blockquote>Usability expert Jakob Nielsen has found that reading on screen can be around 25% slower than reading from paper<a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/why-web-users-scan-instead-reading/">1</a>, and reading All Caps can be a further 10% slower<a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/weblog-usability-top-ten-mistakes/">2</a>.</blockquote><blockquote>When we read, we don’t actually look at every letter in a sentence, but actually the shapes of the words. When text is in All Caps, the height of every letter is identical making every word an even rectangular shape, forcing us to read letter-by-letter, reducing our reading speed. Take a look at the shapes made by the two words below. — <a href="https://www.mity.com.au/blog/writing-readable-content-and-why-all-caps-is-so-hard-to-read">Mity</a></blockquote><p><strong>Carousels/Sliders</strong></p><p>Almost all the sites tested that use it, have a common peculiarity, 90% are unable to implement a carousel without making it inaccessible or difficult to access.</p><p>The carousels are not accessible via tab navigation, for a variety of reasons some or all of these listed here:</p><ul><li>Pause, stop, play controls are missing</li><li>Text is written on the background image without considering the contrast ratio, so depending on the image, portions of text are not legible</li><li>Auto mode is enabled without stop control, using sliders to convey too long messages which, in an average of 5–6 seconds, are unreadable</li><li>The owl dots are often invisible due to a contrast ratio problem</li><li>The navigation arrows are not very visible due to the discard contrast ratio</li><li>The focus is not visible or is too little visible</li><li>The navigation tab first scrolls within the images that make up the carousel without these scrolling in front of the user, so it is impossible to understand where the focus is.</li><li>Once the navigation tab has gone through all the sliders, it suddenly reappears on one of the navigation arrows, maybe.</li><li>The carousel breaks during tab navigation</li></ul><p>An example of a bugged carousel where the right arrows appears almost in the middle:</p><figure><img alt="Image of a bugged carousel with the right arrow stuck in the middle" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s7uVAo9ghUV5WOUGBM2hzA.png" /><figcaption>Image of a bugged carousel</figcaption></figure><p>Below there’s another example of bad carousel, where the left arrow is undetectable due to bad contrast. Arrows are visible only because of mouse interactions, otherwise the carousel was also not accessible via tab navigation.</p><figure><img alt="Image of a non accessible carousel via tab navigation and arrows control with poor contrast" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*29kdMX8HZ8r5WugJcaoq5w.png" /><figcaption>Image of an inaccessible carousel</figcaption></figure><p>The Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI), <a href="https://www.w3.org/WAI/tutorials/carousels/working-example/">on a page published in 2015</a>, that is 5 years before PAs had to align with WCAG 2.1, provides an example of a carousel as it should be to be accessible.</p><blockquote>According to <a href="https://erikrunyon.com/2013/07/carousel-interaction-stats/">tests run by Erik Runyon</a>, a Technical Developer at Notre Dame University, only about 1% of visitors actually clicked on a slide, and of that 1% in a 5-slide carousel, the first slide was clicked 89% of the time. — <a href="https://www.dgtlnk.com/blog/website-carousel/">Digital Ink</a></blockquote><p>and NNG came to the same conclusion</p><blockquote>Auto-Forwarding Carousels and Accordions Annoy Users and Reduce Visibility — <a href="https://www.nngroup.com/articles/auto-forwarding/">Nielsen Norman Group</a></blockquote><p><strong>Focus visible</strong></p><p>Another frequent problem beyond a tab navigation that is not always accessible regardless of the carousels, is the focus of the tab navigation which serves the user to understand where he is.</p><p>Sometimes the navigation tab starts with a visible focus, then disappears, then reappears, other times it is a low quality focus, which is barely seen.</p><p>Some example of nice focus:</p><figure><img alt="Image of a series of links with tab focus visible" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*Jjoo1Z7iRcUasT5UP7a02w.png" /><figcaption>Image of a series of links with tab focus visible</figcaption></figure><p>Some example of bad focus:</p><figure><img alt="Image of a series of bad implemented tab focus" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*34rwZdlYFd_gdrgCG12ggg.png" /><figcaption>Image of a series of bad implemented tab focus</figcaption></figure><p>Visibility is not only about making the tab focus visible, but also maintaining the visibility of the text that in some cases disappears in others it becomes difficult to read for people with cognitive difficulties or suffering from dyslexia, as the border of the focus does not have a merging between the letters and the edge itself, creating a sort of capitalization effect.</p><h4>Accessibility statement</h4><p>The <a href="https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:32018D1523&amp;from=ES">accessibility statement</a> is an important part of this audit because it gives some clues on how the PAs relates to the law and also allows to hypothesize what problems the statement itself presents.</p><blockquote>(1) Directive (EU) 2016/2102 establishes common accessibility requirements […]<br>(2) Member States <strong>should ensure </strong>that public sector bodies provide accessibility statements using a model accessibility statement established by the Commission.<br>(3) Member States <strong>are encouraged to ensure</strong> that public sector bodies review and <strong>update</strong> their accessibility statements regularly, and <strong>at least annually</strong>.</blockquote><p>Article 1 of the directive then specifies</p><blockquote>1. <strong>Member States shall ensure</strong> that the declarations made in the statement, as regards compliance with the requirements set out in Directive (EU) 2016/2102 are accurate and based on one of the following:</blockquote><blockquote>(a) an actual evaluation of the website’s or mobile application’s compliance with the requirements of Directive(EU) 2016/2102, such as:</blockquote><blockquote>— a self-assessment done by the public sector body,</blockquote><blockquote>— an <a href="https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32016L2102">assessment</a> carried out by a third party, for example a certification;</blockquote><blockquote>(b) any other measures, as deemed appropriate by the Member States, which provide equal assurance that the declarations made in the statement are accurate.</blockquote><blockquote>2. The statement shall indicate the method used as referred to in paragraph 1</blockquote><p>Therefore, governments are in charge to ensure the application of the directive, which establishes that the website audit can be based on external consultancy or on self-assessment, the statement must be published compulsorily, on a regular basis, at least once a year.</p><p>The accessibility statement must also use the directive template, which requires PAs to specify the statement date of publication, the date of the last revision, the assessment method used and indicate whether the site is compliant, partially compliant or non-compliant with, in this case, the WCAGs having been commonly adopted .</p><p><strong>If the site is not compliant or partially compliant, PAs must:</strong></p><ul><li>List the non-compliance (s) of the website (s) / mobile application (s), and / or, describe which section (s) / content / function (s) are not yet compliant.</li><li>List non-accessible section (s) / content / function (s) for which the disproportionate burden exemption, within the meaning of Article 5 of Directive (EU) 2016/2102 is being temporarily invoked.</li><li>List non-accessible section (s) / content / function (s) which is / are out of scope of the applicable legislation.</li></ul><p>The following image table summarizes the situation regarding the accessibility statement of the 40 websites analyzed.<br>Older websites (published before September 23, 2018) were supposed to be compliant with the new directive starting by September 23, 2020.</p><p>As a result, it was reasonable to expect all selected sites to have a statement updated to at least 2020, being now just in early 2021.</p><figure><img alt="Image of a 4 column table that list: website, accessibility statement publication date, self or external assessment and if the statement is conform to the EU directive." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/851/1*aAlj0aTFSYN2woCHe8-4AA.png" /><figcaption>Accessibility Statement Table: publication, type of audit, informative compliance or not</figcaption></figure><p>2 websites out of 40 have an accessibility statement published in 2021</p><p>16 websites out 40 have an accessibility statement published in 2020 of which however, the healthcare website of the city of Florence and suburbs “<strong>Azienda Usl Toscana centro</strong>” does not clearly publish the date, it is possible retrieve it by the W3C badge in the footer which refer to the WCAG 2.0.</p><p>4 websites have an accessibility statement published in 2019</p><p>2 have an accessibility statement published in 2018 of which one refers to WCAG 1.0 and one to WCAG 2.0</p><p>1 website have an accessibility statement published in 2015</p><p>1 website have an accessibility statement published in 2006, date estimated based on the browser versions mentioned as compatible as the date itself was missing</p><p>1 website have an accessibility statement published between 2005 and 2010, date estimated based on the browser versions mentioned as compatible as the date itself was missing</p><p>5 websites have an accessibility statement but there’s no date nor there was a way to estimate it.</p><p>8 websites do not have any accessibility statement.</p><p>By taking in consideration only the websites with a statement published in 2020 and 2021, only 10 websites mention if the audit was self assessed or carried by an external agency and correctly states why the website it’s not compliant.</p><h3>Conclusions</h3><p>The websites of the healthcare sector that have been analyzed belong to four European countries that are anything but unrelated to the WCAGs.</p><p><strong>In 2002</strong> in Germany, the “Barrierefreie-Informationstechnik-Verordnung” regulation (BITV 1.0 and subsequent<a href="https://www.bitvtest.de/infothek/artikel/lesen/bitv-20.html"> BITV 2.0</a>) came into force.<br>It was based on WCAG 1.0 and obliged public sector websites to comply with the guidelines by 2005, a regulation which over time it has been updated up to WCAG 2.1.</p><p><strong>In 2004</strong> in Italy the “Legge Stanca” (Stanca Act) came into force and as the German BITV initially referred to WCAG 1.0 then updated to version 2.0 and 2.1.</p><p><strong>In 2003</strong> Spain followed the same path with “Ley 51/2003” (Law 51/2003) then updated to the current “Real Decreto 1112/2018” (Royal Decree 1112/2018) and always updating from WCAG 1.0 to WCAG 2.1.</p><p><strong>In 1999</strong> United Kingdom was already trying to regulate the accessibility of websites through the “Code of Practice” of section III of the Disability Discrimination Act (DDA) which came into effect in 2002 up to the Equality Act 2010 and consequent WCAG 2.0 and WCAG 2.1 implementations.</p><p>Surprisingly, the results are disappointing.</p><p>Regardless of the number of non-compliant checkpoints, none of the 40 sites were fully compliant even at level A of the WCAGs.<br>Beyond the non-compliance with WCAG 2.1, it emerges that not even the accessibility statement is respected, either because it is not published, or because it is incomplete.</p><p>At the same time, <strong>the results also suggest that the expectations of the European Union, where it calls on Member States to encourage PAs to apply the directive, are misplaced.</strong></p><p>Websites reporting WCAG 1.0 compliance were clearly never reached by relevant State organizations even during the period in which WCAG 2.0 was in effect.</p><p>If 7 out of 10 German healthcare sites have an accessibility statement published close to September 2020 (EU Directive deadline), it can be assumed that either the State has encouraged the PAs, or the latter has followed the law independently.</p><p>If only 2 out of 10 Italian healthcare sites have an accessibility statement published in the summer of 2020, one of which refers to WCAG 2.0 instead of WCAG 2.1, it can be assumed that the State is absent and the PA that manages the websites has no interest to follow the law.</p><p><strong>Many accessibility statements seem to be patched up</strong>, like if they were originally made several years ago and then updated only in certain paragraphs, creating as consequence, controversial situations.</p><p>For example the statement of the <strong>healthcare website of the Canary Islands</strong>, declares the was prepared on May 7, 2019 (WCAG 2.0 were active) and revised in May 2020 (after the end of September was supposed to be compliant with WCAG 2.1)</p><p>The website, lists the failed checkpoints, which are part of the WCAG 2.0, it does not list the failed WCAG 2.1 checkpoints, assuming it was tested against WCAG 2.0.</p><p>Yet the same accessibility statement mentions among the measures adopted:</p><ul><li>XHTML 1.0</li><li>CSS 2 grammar</li><li>Accessibility guidelines for web content WCAG level AA.</li></ul><p>However, while XHTML 1.0 was released in the year 2000 and W3C in 2014 started to recommend <a href="https://www.w3.org/blog/news/archives/4167#:~:text=The%20HTML%20Working%20Group%20today,of%20the%20Open%20Web%20Platform">HTML5</a>, the website does not use XHTML 1.0 rather HTML strict 4.0.1.<br><a href="https://www.w3.org/Press/1998/CSS2-REC">CSS 2</a> was released by W3C in 1998 and in 1999 the first drafts of the new version, CSS3, organized in modules, began.<br>Among the failed checkpoints listed by the public body, there are 1.4.3 and 3.2.3 which are both level AA checkpoints.</p><p>In the same accessibility statement it’s also possible to read:</p><p><strong>“The design and layout of the portal has been developed taking into<br>account the Accessibility Guidelines for Web Content (WCAG 1.0)[…])”</strong></p><p>Suggesting that a website online since the early 2000s, was tested against WCAG 2.0 regardless of the fact that it was originally developed to comply with WCAG 1.0, and highlighting at the same time how the State was absent in encouraging the development of a new site to meet the requirements of the EU Directive within September 23, 2020.</p><p>Controversial statements like this one, can also be found in some UK and Italian websites.</p><p>Another evidence that emerges is that often, the accessibility statement is not followed by an improvement of the site or the implementation of practices to guarantee its accessibility.</p><p>In fact, it is possible to find accessibility statements published 2, 5, 10 years ago that list problems still present today.</p><p>As if the PA not only postponed the revisions to every year simply because the directive establishes an annual minimum, but it performed the accessibility test on a website with past errors dragged over the course of one or more years.</p><p>In an audit performed by <a href="https://www.un.org/esa/socdev/enable/gawanomensa.htm">Nomensa</a> on behalf of the United Nations in 2006, it was noticed how many errors were trivial and easy to resolve, the same applies today.<br>For example, adjust the contrast ratio, implement the focus of the tab navigation, use the headers appropriately and alternative text descriptions for images, do not require months of work or expensive budgets.</p><p>The results of this research cannot help but trigger a number of questions which are then listed below together with opinions and hypotheses for answers.</p><p><strong>-Is there a lack of financial resources?</strong></p><p>The websites analyzed in this audit belong to the top 4 European economies (5 if we include France). <br>If there is an economic problem, then it is questionable how other European countries will align with WCAG 2.1.<br>Spain has a smaller economy than Italy, yet in some ways the sites analyzed were better than the Italian ones.</p><p>The EEA (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Accessibility_Act">European Accessibility Act</a>) foresees that from <a href="https://www.agendadigitale.eu/cittadinanza-digitale/accessibilita-ora-tocca-anche-ai-privati-le-novita-e-i-punti-critici/">2025 </a>also the private sector must adapt, among the sectors mentioned we read the <a href="https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=1202">eCommerce</a>.</p><p>Although I was unable to find further specifications on possible exemptions, if the PA does not have the financial resources to implement the directive on web accessibility, we must ask ourselves how the private sector of eCommerce, which also counts the craftsman who buys a template on Shopify and invoice € 25,000 per year can find the financial resources to adjust.</p><p><strong>-Is there a lack of controls?</strong></p><p>It is quite evident that although Germany, United Kingdom, Spain and Italy have internal organizations with the task of monitoring the application of accessibility laws, these fail in their task, it is sufficient to note all the unpublished or published accessibility statements that do not comply with the format provided in the EU Directive.</p><p>Requiring all public sites to use a centralized system to publish accessibility statements would allow for faster checking, something that seems to happen in Italy where AGID (<a href="https://www.agid.gov.it/">Agency for Digital Italy</a>) hosts on its platform such statements, yet only 1 Italian healthcare website out of 10 was publishing there.</p><p>A Belgium association, and probably many others, seems also to suggest towards a <strong>centralized control system</strong>:</p><blockquote>“Statements are often incomplete or poorly drafted. To overcome this problem, the <a href="https://cawab.be/">CAWaB</a> recommends that accessibility statements be submitted to the control body for validation before publication. — <a href="https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12537-Review-of-the-application-of-the-Web-Accessibility-Directive-/F1303759">CAWaB</a>”</blockquote><p><strong>Centralization</strong> seems also to be the Italian way to solve the current “website problems”. While completing this research I found the Italian site of an agency called “<a href="https://designers.italia.it/">Designers Italia</a>”.<br>It is my understanding that this is a team of web developers, designers and copywriters working in the dependency of the government agency AGID.</p><p>On the site it’s possible find the presence of two kits, two website templates designed for schools and municipalities, which PAs can use if they wish so.<br>Perhaps, Italy (which like Spain and England has a state health system), should through Designers Italia, oblige the use of these templates for all PA websites (possibly not by using Wordpress due to security problems), and manage them at a technical level by Designers Italia, this would probably guarantee uniformity, better control and better results.</p><p><strong>-How is actually used the feedback mechanism?</strong></p><p>The European Directive provides that in the accessibility statement there is a link to a form so that the citizen can complain about the lack of access to the site, and a link to an arbitration board that will eventually have the task of mediating between the parties.</p><p>Speculating, it seems that the administrations of the websites analyzed either ignore the directive, or that they have no interest in respecting it because they feel safe, or because of a lack of financial / administrative sanctions or because since there is the feedback link, if there’s a problem, the citizen will contact the administration.</p><blockquote>The lack of sanction is also a major problem. As no sanction is provided for by the Directive, public bodies are not obliged to follow it, which calls into question its application and effectiveness and above all, still deprives many people with disabilities of having access to accessible websites. — <a href="https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12537-Review-of-the-application-of-the-Web-Accessibility-Directive-/F1303759">CAWaB</a></blockquote><p>The latter, however, seems to be a transfer of responsibility, from the PA to the private citizen, while instead it should be the extrema ratio, to use when in good faith the PA is certain of being in compliance.</p><p>If I were a disabled citizen, knowing the law, I would rely on my government for it to be applied, I cannot imagine connecting to a PA site and then having to do a control police job, because if I don’t do it, the site administration will not solve the problem.</p><p><strong>-Self-assessment or External assessment?</strong></p><p>Self-assessment means that the controlled is also the controller, an aspect in itself controversial, furthermore for a self-assessment it is assumed that the site administration has the knowledge to be able to carry out a self-assessment.</p><p>Some PAs that have carried on a self-assessment have stated that they have done so using an automation software, but without mentioning the software.</p><p>Others, on the other hand, have updated the accessibility statement, leaving the self-assessment as an evaluation method, and the names of two automation tools that ceased to exist 10 years.</p><p>The accessibility statement seems to represent an uncomfortable homework task, once performed, in several cases there seems no improvements neither immediately, correcting small errors, nor in the long term.</p><p>A type of problem noticed also abroad and that I bring in this quote:</p><blockquote>Web accessibility is too often perceived as a technical problem, while in reality it is first and foremost an organizational matter. — <a href="https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12537-Review-of-the-application-of-the-Web-Accessibility-Directive-/F1422850">Raph de Rooij, Ministry of the Interior and Kingdom Relations</a></blockquote><p>Lack of knowledge about the accessibility it’s also a problem as mentioned in this other quote:</p><blockquote>Now some people think of “accessibility” as just a checklist, it’s just about meeting legal or project requirements.<br>Accessibility is not about a checklist it’s about people,<strong> it’s about the user experience</strong>.<br>The first step is understanding how people with disabilities use the web,<br>the standards do have an important role, yet they’re not the first step.<br>They come later. — Shawn Henry, W3C</blockquote><p>The results of this research shows also that an accessibility statement can be made today, errors are highlighted but these are not solved, because the European directive establishes the minimum of one statement per year and because Member States do not encourage frequent reviews, nothing is fixed until the next year.</p><p>In practice it is as if today February 2021, we paid for the public transport ticket, we got on the vehicle and realized that all the seats are broken and that we cannot sit. Then, posted inside the bus we find a message that tells us:</p><p><strong>“This bus does not have accessible seats as they are broken, we are doing our best to fix it, date: February 2018. <br>If you cannot access the seats of this bus you can send us feedback”</strong></p><p>However, it is not the site administrator of a hospital or health insurance that deals with the development or design of a website but a group of developers and designers, who are the first to have knowledge of accessibility, accessibility which, however, it still looks like a niche concept today.</p><blockquote>“Finally, special attention must also be paid to the training of web designers, webmasters, content writers, etc. in digital accessibility so that the content published on public websites is also accessible — <a href="https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12537-Review-of-the-application-of-the-Web-Accessibility-Directive-/F1303759">CAWab</a>”</blockquote><p>Accessibility is the basis of UX Design but if we do a quick search among the job advertisements, or in the various online development and design courses, we will find that companies take longer to ask to know what Lean, Agile and Scrum mean (working methodologies that many throughout their lives, apply without even knowing that someone one day gave them a name), rather than asking to know what WCAGs or accessibility are, a problem that the private sector will face when the directive will also become mandatory for them in 2025.</p><p>In conclusion, it‘s possible to make a list of the main factors that to varying degrees depending on the country, cause the problems highlighted:</p><ul><li>Absence of controls and sanctions by the Member States</li><li>Little interest from the public administrations</li><li>Lack of knowledge of ICT accessibility at administrative level</li><li>Lack of a group of developers and designers who apply the basic steps to develop a product, such as but not limited to usability tests and accessibility techniques</li></ul><p><em>Report on </em><a href="https://www.behance.net/gallery/113985359/UX-Report-Healthcare-Website-Accessibility"><em>Behance</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd8734f273b2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/accessibility-and-public-administration-healthcare-websites-in-germany-italy-spain-and-united-dd8734f273b2">Accessibility and public administration healthcare websites, in Germany, Italy, Spain and United…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp">Bootcamp</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>