<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Eryk Sawicki on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Eryk Sawicki on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@eryk.sawicki?source=rss-557bca14fb9f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 19:26:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@eryk.sawicki/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“FAILURES OF THE WORLD, UNITE!”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eryk.sawicki/failures-of-the-world-unite-fc1def0c6056?source=rss-557bca14fb9f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc1def0c6056</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rpg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ttrpgs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disco-elysium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eryk Sawicki]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 Oct 2021 22:43:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-19T22:43:00.282Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4St67E1I1gqDWwywxlMh3A.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Towards a broader understanding of failure in Disco Elysium and roleplaying games.</h3><h3>Abstract</h3><p>By calling on the works of Karl Marx, Raewyn Connell, Jesper Juul, and Judith Halberstam, this dissertation defines three frameworks within which failure becomes possible, and which we can examine the notions of failure in video roleplaying games. Then, using Halberstam’s work on The Queer Art of Failure, I explain how these frameworks create an unhealthy and unattainable notion of success. By applying these frameworks and subversive, queer notions of failure to roleplaying games, I able to examine systems which encourage and reward failure. Then, I look at Studio ZA/UM’s Disco Elysium as an example of a roleplaying game which similarly critiques contemporary frameworks for success and failure. By analysing its narrative and mechanics, I come to find an interesting critique of neoliberalism; one that takes the player’s assumed knowledge of roleplaying game mechanics (like pursuit of self-improvement) and subverts it to state that no ideology is flawless. Overall, I find that adopting Halberstam’s idea of seeing failure as a “speedbump to mastery” is a key part to self-actualisation and rejecting capitalist notions of success.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Metal Gear Solid’s (1998) GAME OVER screen has become a gaming icon; “It’s video game’s iconic scream.” (Kotzer, 2017) The devastated exclamations of Solid Snake’s team echoing against a black screen overlaid with neon, futuristic lettering is proof of one thing: the player had failed, and Snake had died. Snake had died because the player failed. Considering failure and success as a life-or-death situation seems reductive, an equivocation entirely unrelatable to most people who pick up a game controller. But adhering to these black &amp; white, good &amp; bad definitions of failure is commonplace in videogames. Where we would balk at them in real-life, they do not appear out of place in games. This is the aim of the essay; to reframe this reductive notion of failure and ask, what happens when we begin to look at failure as a state of different degrees? When we question the systems which enable success and failure? Most importantly, what happens when we recontextualise failure as appealing? I will answer these questions during this essay to ultimately offer a contrasting notion of what it means to fail. “There’s another kind of pleasure in that”, says Jack Halberstam, “You rewrite the game, and in the process you accept what we call failure.” (Shaw and Ruberg, 2017, p.202) I aim to redefine failure and, by extension, success purely because our current notions of success seem unattainable; I graduate with debt, unable to purchase property, with a Master’s degree in a subject which is first in line for sneering remarks from the public. I am a failure by all accounts, and all that remains is to reject the game I was born into and find my own definitions of success. This is also the reason why I chose to research failure and Disco Elysium in particular: it is a game made by a group of people whose lives followed a similar trajectory to mine. Lead designer Robert Kurvitz was a novelist, an artist, a communist activist (EGX, 2018) and struggled with alcoholism. It was, ironically, only once he embraced the capitalist notion of success that he and the rest of the team were given an opportunity to create Disco Elysium. Exploring and embracing failure as a creative is freeing, though the potential for self-annihilation is overwhelming. By researching failure, I aim to self-reflect and create a personal philosophy I can follow for the rest of my life.</p><p>It is only fitting for an essay about failure (and queer failure, no less) to begin with a disclaimer: I am cis-gendered, white, and heterosexual. I am disclosing this now rather than later to frame the words I type; I will be looking at the Estonian-made Disco Elysium through a queer lens shaped by my own heteronormative experiences. To begin in earnest: Disco Elysium is a roleplaying video game developed and published by the Estonian studio ZA/UM, released in 2019. The game revolves around a washed-up, self-destructive police detective named Harrier Du Bois (Harry). Harry serves the Revachol Citizens’ Militia (RCM), a fragmented, volunteer-driven peace corps trying its hardest to preserve order. More importantly, the RCM is a remnant of the Mazovian Revolution (Kraz Mazov is, of course, a Karl Marx-parallel). The city of Revachol and Disco Elysium’s wider world are a eulogy to communism and failure, its team thanking Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels at awards ceremonies (EGX, 2018); marks of war pepper the city’s buildings, and its people yearn for change but are instead met by the slowly-encroaching “Pale” — a featureless force of nature which swallows all in its path. A recent labour dispute in Revachol’s district of Martinaise culminated in a man murdered and hung from a tree. It is the job of Harry and his partner — tall, professional, and dry — Kim Kitsuragi to solve the murder. What follows is a journey of self-discovery: Harry wakes face down, naked, amnesiac, and hungover. The person he becomes is, the game posits, up to the player.</p><p>While the field of possibility of “the person Harry Du Bois becomes” is vastly interesting, I am focusing on something this possibility permits: failure. I write about failure because failure is, to me, the defining zeitgeist of the 21st century; failure to address mass economic inequality (Hobbs, 2021), failure to address fascism (Hammar, 2020), climate change (BBC News, 2021a), racism (BBC News, 2021b), and so on. Capitalism, using Karl Marx’s definition of a system where “profit is ultimately derived from the exploitation of the worker” (Wolff and Leopold, 2021), permits accumulation of wealth, and so where some have, others have not. Someone, of course, is making untold amounts of money off this “failure”, and with that bringing the question of “what does it mean to fail?” Exploring the ontology of failure will allow me to build a framework with which I can approach a close reading of Disco Elysium. Failure is often clear-cut in videogames: the player fails at some test of skill and is placed back at the start or before said test of skill. These failures have been well explored in academia and they are mostly irrelevant to Disco Elysium. What happens when the player has no choice but to live with their mistake? And is it really a mistake if the game’s narrative continues as intended regardless of the mistakes made? These are questions that few games concern themselves with, and they are the reason I picked Disco Elysium as the focal point of this dissertation. I aim to answer these questions by calling upon work in the field of game studies which explores failure in games; importantly, this work is prohibitive as it focuses only on singular, normative definitions of failure, and so I will have to venture outside of videogames and look towards academics of queer theory such as Bonnie Ruberg, Jack Halberstam, Adrienne Shaw, and Jordan Youngblood who try to redefine failure as a positive. It is Halberstam’s definition that I will be aligning closely with, an encouragement to “to fail, to make a mess, to fuck shit up, to be loud, unruly, impolite … to disrupt, assassinate, shock, and annihilate.” (Halberstam, 2011, p.110). Failure is merely a speed-bump to mastery, claims Halberstam. These multitudinous definitions of failure are key to this dissertation; they will not only help guide my assertions and, by extension, the reader’s understanding of Disco Elysium, but also point the reader towards an understanding of failure as a socio-political concept which can be a rich ground for identity-making and radical self-love.</p><p>It is also important to make my intentions clear: this dissertation is a close, conceptual analysis of key philosophical concepts and a particular videogame. I will explore failure as a broad concept and explore how failure relates to the game’s mechanics and its narrative. When speaking of “mechanics”, I want to interrogate the dice-rolling system which makes up the heft of Disco Elysium’s gameplay. Conversely, “narrative” concerns the themes of failure present in Revachol, Harry’s life, and the socioeconomic state of the world the two inhabit. Where one knows that reading a book entails reading from left to right (in English, at least), from top to bottom, and flipping one page to the next, analysing videogames requires, in parts, dry descriptions of what the player sees on-screen and how they interact with the game due to the affective elements of both. These might be uninteresting to anyone familiar with videogames, but nonetheless a necessary exercise in accessibility. With several disclaimers out of the way, only one remains and, to quote Jesper Juul: “Needless to say, any remaining failures of this [essay] are entirely my responsibility.” (Juul, 2013, preface)</p><p>The first chapter of this dissertation will briefly historicise and define failure in video games with the aim of informing and framing the second chapter. Using the research of Óliver Pérez-Latorre and Mercè Oliva as a groundwork, I will make the argument that games replicate the features of neoliberalism (Pérez-Latorre and Oliva, 2019) and define neoliberalism as one of the frameworks which enables failure. Digging deeper, I will also refer to Raewyn Connell’s Masculinities (2005) to establish parallels between neoliberalism and the social organisation of masculinity. These two frameworks will be my main tools in establishing a broad, philosophical definition of failure. With that definition in mind, I will look towards Judith Halberstam’s The Queer Art of Failure (2011) for a radical critique of what it means to fail and the first step of recontextualising failure as a positive. Looking at videogames as a framework which allows the player to fail also, by definition, requires the player to have some agency to enact that failure, especially when we consider neoliberalism. Looking at broad theories of agency and chance written by postmodern French philosopher Gilles Deleuze (2005) will aid me in creating a critical framework through which we can assess failure in videogames and begin approaching roleplaying games, namely Disco Elysium (ZA/UM, 2019) in the second chapter.</p><p>Following on from this, chapter 2 will be a close reading of Disco Elysium. While my intention is not to create a list of recommendations for developers to implement a broader understanding of failure in their games as it would be entirely unattainable for indie developers, I want to explore a game about failure, and a game which does it well. For that reason, I will talk about Disco Elysium’s narrative and the failure that permeates it. These will be contextualised by the definitions I establish in Chapter 1. Its plentiful characters experience failure in a multitude of ways; a Novelty Dicemaker battles the free market, and eventually finds a home catering to a steady supply of regular customers; a game studio aims too high and runs out of funding. These characters approach failure according to frameworks I set up in Chapter 1. Because of that, using those frameworks to reflect on the situations these characters are in can be a productive exercise in dialectics, ie. “a method of philosophical argument that involves some sort of contradictory process between opposing sides.” (Maybee, 2020)</p><p>Finally, before I start the essay proper, it would be worthwhile to define some terms I will be referencing and, while I find genre classifications tedious and limiting (the specifics of which are well beyond the scope of this essay), I will call on several well-known genres to facilitate a smoother conversation. “Roleplaying games” is a broad genre, and one that also needs context. A somewhat old-fashioned term, “roleplaying” was mostly attributed to tabletop roleplaying games (TTRPGs) like Dungeons &amp; Dragons (D&amp;D) (Gygax and Arneson, 1974) wherein players would sit around a table armed with dice, pencils, and hastily-scrawled maps, and crawl through dungeons narrated by a “Dungeon Master”, all while playing the role of some treasure- and glory-seeking adventurer. “Dungeon Master” is a trademarked term and has fallen out of grace in the greater contemporary TTRPG community, and so I will instead use “Game Master” (GM) from here onwards. D&amp;D rulesets made the jump to computers, thusly called computer roleplaying games (cRPGs), with Baldur’s Gate (Interplay Entertainment, 1998) using a modified version of D&amp;D’s 2nd edition rules. While Baldur’s Gate was by no means the first cRPG on the market, its popularity and rippling effect on the videogame industry leaves it a good reference point when talking about cRPGs. These definitions are important to get out of the way: Disco Elysium’s TTRPG roots are clear and its developers don’t shy away from them (Wiltshire, 2020). When defining failure, I will look to cRPGs like Disco Elysium and, indeed, even TTRPGs for guidance. John Harper’s Blades in the Dark (2017) will be my main point of reference in tabletop roleplaying games due to its interesting framing of failure as a point of improvement. Calling on pieces of media like TTRPGs and cRPGs is an intentional departure from the academic work on these subjects; Halberstam writes of “Low Theory”, a mixing of “low brow” and pop culture texts with academic work in an attempt to avoid being “snared by the hooks of hegemony” (Halberstam, 2011, p.2). The independent TTRPG scene is heavily populated by designers on all ends of the queer spectrum, and so I would rather draw inspiration from their work rather than the works of established brands like Hasbro’s D&amp;D. Likewise, easy access to the indie TTRPG scene means the community is rife with radical approaches to game design, self-identity, and community building.</p><h3>Chapter 1: Defining Failure</h3><p>This chapter will focus on theories of failure as part of a process of creating a framework for approaching failure critically. This will be the foundation of the rest of the essay; work mentioned here will be key in further discussion. Firstly, I will briefly historicise the broad concept of failure in videogames to show how failure has developed with the medium’s maturity, and so that the reader can see where this analysis of failure fits in with contemporary videogames. This history will also leave behind threads of ideas I wish to explore further, and these threads will be highlighted as such.</p><p>In platforming (games where the main challenge stems from navigating through an environment) and puzzle games like Portal 2 (Valve, 2011), failure is clear and well-defined. When the player fails to make a jump and falls into a bottomless pit, the end-state is obvious. You must try again. Likewise, if the player does not find the one, correct solution to the puzzle, they cannot proceed. They must try again. In action games like Uncharted 4 (Naughty Dog, 2016), Nathan Drake can get shot and subsequently die or he can, again, fall into a bottomless pit. Failure is clear. Failure in videogames is death. Failure outside of videogames is death, too. Death as failing to live, and death as un-life. Luckily, in videogames that failure is often not final. The concept of re-trying has roots in arcade games; they were means for arcade machines to separate players from any spare change they had. For extra money, the player could try again and keep going. There was little narrative, nor an endpoint. If the player finished one game of Pac-Man (Namco, 1980), they would simply be placed back at the start, their score rolled over and ready to climb higher and higher. Here, failure served two purposes: it made their failing in a specific set of circumstances into a personal failing, one that encouraged them to try again and keep trying until they were better and held mastery over the game’s systems and controls. It would test the player’s stamina, their skill against increasing odds and, of course, their pockets. For this reason, Jesper Juul says of these games that they are “pleasure spiked with pain” (Juul, 2013, p.9), that they set up a framework for us to fail. The feeling of failing in a videogame is not cathartic and, unlike other arts, it is more than a simple release and remediation of these negative feelings. When we fail in a videogame, we are the ones responsible. We are the ones who feel those negative feelings of personal failure directly, where in a film or a book we would simply be witness to someone else’s failure. This all makes sense, and Juul’s essay goes to great lengths to examine the pain of playing video games. The industry moved away from this, though, with a heightened focus on narrative play. When consoles moved to the home, arcades couldn’t rely on pennies to keep games going and players were introduced to “save” mechanics; save the game, turn the console off, eat your tea, and return, the game ready to go from exactly where you paused it. “Checkpoints”, likewise, made death toothless. The player, post-death, was placed before their point of failure and asked to try again. There are no stakes in this approach. In response, there has been a contemporary renaissance of “roguelike” and “roguelite” games (the name itself a reference to Rogue, a dungeon-crawler published by Epyx in 1980), games which are disinterested in narrative (though not always, of course) and games which deny players the continuity afforded by “saving”. Roguelite games, again, focus on that final definition of death as failure. The player must start again, their progress and gear reset.</p><p>Looking at death as the only means of failure is prohibitive, however. In the Western epic Red Dead Redemption 2 (Rockstar Games, 2018), the narrative culminates in death. It is the sole and undeniable end which the game makes clear from its midpoint: down this path only death lies. The player character, Arthur Morgan, is a frontiersman and the player’s actions early in the game leave him unknowingly infected with tuberculosis during a money shakedown. His father figure and gang leader, Dutch van der Linde, slowly succumbs to paranoia and the pressures of endless pursuit from the law. By the end, Dutch betrays Arthur and leaves him for dead. Here, we see that death-as-failure is prohibitive: the player followed the game’s orders and succeeded in fulfilling them, yet Arthur still dies. Juul calls this a “tragic ending”, “where the player is happy to have successfully overcome failure and played the game to completion, but where (this being a tragedy) the protagonist is correspondingly unhappy.” (Juul, 2013, p.93) And, though speaking about Red Dead Redemption 1 (Rockstar Games, 2010), Juul highlights a definition of tragedy here that calls for the protagonist’s death as “[necessary] and [inevitable]”. It is also worth noting that, while Arthur’s ultimate death cannot be stopped, the player does have some agency over the means of Arthur’s death. Following the game’s simplistic morality meter, a righteous Arthur will die peacefully atop a mountain overlooking a sunrise. A dishonourable Arthur is shot through the head on that same mountain by one of the game’s antagonists. Later, I will refer to this reading of failure as tragic and tragedy as failure. I will further discuss this idea of multiple endings later on in the context of living with one’s mistakes. This also creates a dissonance between who is defining failure: failure and success as defined by players, and failure and success as defined by developers can take on different meanings. Success as defined by the individual, and success as defined by a ruling system can lead to dissonant, opposing definitions. This is one of the ideas our approach towards failure with Queer theory addresses. While this dissonance is a key aim of this dissertation, developer intent is beyond the purpose of this essay. Instead, it is failure and success as experienced by the players and the affective experiences resultant of these systems that will take centre stage. Death-as-failure is an unfortunate by-product of a videogame landscape which prioritises life-and-death combat as its main mode of interaction; so much so that games console controllers have buttons named and shaped after gun triggers. So… what happens when failure becomes ill-defined? When there is no GAME OVER screen to look at, nor a high score to beat? When death is not part of the game’s structure? To answer these questions, I will first interrogate three ideologies which form a structure for failure and success: neoliberalism, hegemonic masculinity, and capitalism. These are some of the ideologies taking centre stage in Disco Elysium; the game is highly critical of capitalism and neoliberalism, saying that these people “… don’t really have beliefs. Sometimes they stumble on one, like on a child’s toy left on the carpet.” (ZA/UM, 2019). One of the game’s first dice rolls is during a conversation with Klaasje, a woman who becomes one of your investigation’s main suspects. The check prompts: “Try *The Expression* on her — let her know you want her. Physically.” (ZA/UM, 2019) The success rate shown by the game tells the player that they have less than a 50% chance of success. It is a ridiculous, nigh-impossible check which (mostly) ends in utter embarrassment. Pure, unadulterated, masculine confidence is embarrassing, and goes to show the player that failing a skill check in Disco Elyisum is not the finality they have come to expect from other games.</p><h4>Failure in a Neoliberal Context</h4><blockquote>Kim Kitsuragi: “It’s worrying. Especially considering his political views. Detective Du Bois is — as you may know — a Mazovian socio-economist. He wants to liquidate the ruling class. Which — again — for a police officer… is a little odd.” (ZA/UM, 2019)</blockquote><p>Óliver Pérez-Latorre and Mercè Oliva approach the game of Bioshock through the lens of neoliberal ideology, defining neoliberalism as follows:</p><blockquote>“Free choice and individualism are at the core of neoliberal governmentality. Collective well-being should be achieved through the sum of the actions (free and autonomous) of individuals and companies who try to maximize their own wellbeing. Neoliberalism is based on placing the responsibility on individuals, who must look after themselves, while it also advocates the dismantling of public policies. In other words, in neoliberal societies, individuals are expected to govern themselves according to certain objectives. Thus, in neoliberalism, power is not absent but rather internalized by citizens.” (Pérez-Latorre and Oliva, 2019, p.790)</blockquote><p>This is worth drawing attention to as a baseline for approaching a definition of failure; failure does not exist without context, and to define failure we must also define the parameters of success. The genre of roleplaying games overlays with neoliberal politics very neatly: both are concerned with self-governance (Bioshock), self-improvement (Path of Exile), and are usually highly individualistic (The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim). And so, by extrapolating from those win conditions, I claim that failure through a neoliberal lens entails subservience, subjugation, and subordination. Likewise, at the opposite end of the spectrum to self-improvement is decay, entropy, and laziness. Individualism becomes collectivism. I’d like to draw attention to the social and power dynamics of these terms as they set up the next chapter on masculinities. Overall, this gives us a broad, philosophical definition of what it means to fail and one that we can apply to Disco Elysium.</p><p>A lesser point I’d like to make in the context of Disco Elysium is the “Thought Cabinet” mechanic. Completing tasks, reaching milestones, and certain conversation prompts grant the player “thoughts”. The player can then “internalise” the thoughts to consider its implications over a set period of in-game time; the thoughts ranging from theories of self-identity to political affiliations, to personal philosophies. Internalising the thoughts has certain effects on Harry’s skills. A notable example is the “Advanced Race Theory” thought triggered by a man aptly named “Measurehead”. Measurehead’s phrenology, if pursued, gives Harry a -1 to any Drama-related skill checks, saying that he is “Fooled by the absurdity” (ZA/UM, 2019). The Thought Cabinet is an interesting renunciation of the neoliberal self-improvement typical to RPGs; these skills make Harry worse, and they make a succinct statement. Phrenology is absurd, and believing it makes Harry worse at fooling others. How can he fool anyone if he’s been fooled so easily himself? The Thought Cabinet also allows for incongruent, unique combinations: the player can choose to pursue “Mazovian Socio-economics”, the in-world analogue to Communism, despite being a serving policeman. Not only does Disco Elysium put failure front-and-centre in its worldbuilding, it also allows the player to explore interesting consequences thereof: is communism and state-led policing compatible? Is phrenology and police work compatible? Exploring Mazovian socio-economics leads Harry to finally realize:</p><blockquote>“0.000% of Communism has been built. Evil child-murdering billionaires still rule the world with a shit-eating grin. All he has managed to do is make himself *sad*. He is starting to suspect Kras Mazov *fucked him over* personally with his socio-economic theory. It has, however, made him into a very, very smart boy with something like a university degree in Truth. Instead of building Communism, he now builds a precise model of this grotesque, duplicitous world.” (ZA/UM, 2019)</blockquote><p>Similarly, exploring Moralism:</p><blockquote>“The Kingdom of Conscience will be exactly as it is now. Moralists don’t really *have* beliefs. Sometimes they stumble on one, like on a child’s toy left on the carpet. The toy must be put away immediately. And the child reprimanded. Centrism isn’t change — not even incremental change. It is *control*. Over yourself and the world. Exercise it. Look up at the sky, at the dark shapes of Coalition airships hanging there. Ask yourself: is there something sinister in moralism? And then answer: no. God is in his heaven. Everything is normal on Earth.” (ZA/UM, 2019)</blockquote><p>These explorations of ideologies become renunciations of ideology; every political affiliation the player can pursue ends up unsatisfactory, bitter, and cynical. The affective properties of playing with the game’s systems of self-improvement, and neoliberalism, lead the player towards a realisation that self-improvement is flawed. The system, in this case Disco Elysium, tells the player to expand their ideological horizons by presenting them with the Thought Cabinet. When the player reaches the end goal the game instead shows that there is no happy ending: the game is set against them. Ideology is altogether flawed. I’d like to tie this back to the wider point of this dissertation: the systems which frame whether we fail or succeed are rigged against us. It is, overall, an interesting subversion of the systems we come to expect of roleplaying games.</p><p>In the context of Disco Elysium, two of its characters embody neoliberalism in notable ways. Harry’s partner, Kim Kitsuragi, is open about his affiliation with “Moralism” and so Kim acts as a solid sounding board for the player’s various, possible political affiliations. Likewise, one of the main tasks the player is given is to “get a reality lowdown” — find a rich person and ask them to tell you about the world. This rich person is Joyce Messier, the Wild Pines Group’s representative and negotiator with the Dockworker’s Union. She describes herself as an “ultraliberal” and, interestingly, acknowledges her own class consciousness. Messier is aware of her wealth, and of the unsavoury relationship her wealth has to union busting, corporate espionage, and the status quo. She acknowledges the human cost of her wealth but is comfortable enough in her life not to change anything. Messier is an interesting antithesis to the central statement of this dissertation: I propose recontextualising and redefining failure as success seems unattainable, but those whose success came easily have a vested interested in the continuation of the status quo. This antithesis becomes a moral question, then: why should I make life easier for others? Unfortunately, I do not have an answer to this question. Regardless, the sentiment of this dissertation is one of collectivism; of working for the betterment of the community.</p><h4>Failure in a Masculinist Context</h4><p>Digging further into neoliberalism, I want to explore masculinity as it is organised in a neoliberal society. This is a broad definition of masculinity, calling on the sociological organisation of masculinity and also of the cultural and marketing ideas of who plays video games and how they play video games. Raewyn Connell’s Masculinities (2005) defines masculinity as a relational concept; it does not exist independently. It is, rather, always contrasted to femininity, and is composed of four interplaying masculinities: hegemony, subordination, complicity, and marginalization (Connell, 2005, p.76). In short, though, Connell writes:</p><blockquote>“an unmasculine person would behave differently: being peaceable rather than violent, conciliatory rather than dominating, hardly able to kick a football, uninterested in sexual conquest, and so forth.” (Connell, 2005, p.67)</blockquote><p>To find a counterpoint to these notions of failure, it is not enough to find the opposites of their prescribed notions of success. Masculinity, as per Connell’s writing, organises itself according to certain values. Removing those values and reversing them doesn’t leave us with a “positive masculinity”, because masculinity does not and cannot exist without those component parts. Instead, we must look for a more radical approach; one which does not try to work within these current restraints, and one which establishes an alternative system. For that reason, work of academics of queer theory will be my main reference point for building a rebuttal to these notions of failure. Before I approach that, however, it would make the most structural sense to also discuss the effects of Capitalism as a system within which we live, and the implied system of the world of Disco Elysium.</p><p>I would also like to call on Shira Chess’ work in Ready Player Two (2017). Chess writes about “Player Two”, the designed identity which acts as a counterpart to “Player One”. Player One is the masculine ideal of who should play videogames: “white, cis- , heterosexual, young, abled, and middleclass male” (Chess, 2017, p.171). Chess expands on this, writing that “The designed identity of Player Two, like Player One, is a fiction, an amalgamation of many hybridized images of who should play, how they should play, and what that play looks like.” (Chess, 2017, p.6) If we were to look at Disco Elysium through the lens of Chess’ work, formulating the identity of the person this game was made for seems somewhat difficult. This is not a game which demands mastery, it is critical of the middle classes, and is thoroughly unviolent. To make this point more cogent, I’d also like to call on Donna Haraway’s concept of the “cyborg”. Haraway writes of the cyborg as “creatures simultaneously animal and machine, who populate worlds ambiguously natural and crafted.” (Haraway and Wolfe, 2016, p.6) Haraway’s work is deeply rooted in feminist theory, and so an apt critique of a heteronormative society in which masculinity is a dominant component. With this in mind, I propose an image of the player as one who exists between the game-world and the real-world.</p><h4>Failure in a Capitalist Context</h4><p>To cohesively discuss failure in Disco Elysium we also have to consider the procedures which make up its mechanics. Using Ian Bogost’s idea of procedural rhetoric, that is embracing that “video games are not just stages that facilitate cultural, social, or political practices; they are also media where cultural values themselves can be represented — for critique, satire, education, or commentary.” (Bogost, 2008, p.119) We can then interpret game mechanics and processes as specific statements about the world. Because Disco Elysium always displays a count of the player’s money (Réal), we can interpret that as a sign that the player’s capital worth plays a big role in the game’s world. When Harry meets the Mega Rich Light-Bending Guy, merely approaching him makes the Réal count rocket up to nigh infinity.</p><blockquote>Harrier Du Bois: “Are you telling me that you are so rich that light literally bends around your face?”</blockquote><blockquote>Mega Rich Light-Bending Guy: “Among other things… but calm down, I’m but a lowly single-digit billionaire.”</blockquote><blockquote>Harrier Du Bois: “Really?”</blockquote><blockquote>Mega Rich Light-Bending Guy: “No, not really. There are actually quite many digits.”</blockquote><blockquote>Suggestion: “A man this *chill* is at least a triple digit billionaire.” (ZA/UM, 2019)</blockquote><p>The game makes a simple, satirical statement: rich people bend the reality around them, and merely being in the presence of someone so unbelievably rich opens opportunities; to social status, to wealth, to business, and so on. Wealth attracts wealth. Later, the Mega Rich Light-Bending Guy introduces Harry to the “Weiss-Wiesemann” a fictional, highly complex mathematical formula which measures the difference between the net-worth of all individuals in a room. Once you approach the peak of 1, or 100%, the laws of physics have been observed to bend around the high net-worth individual. Asking Kim for a second opinion reveals that he doesn’t see the light-bending, suggesting he is considerably wealthier than Harry. The notable thing here is that the game does not glorify the riches of the Mega Rich Light-Bending Guy; his status and wealth are satirised and clear out of the reach of most people. There is no “hustle porn” to be seen here, and the meeting is a total rejection of neoliberal self-improvement. The system does not permit the people to reach this level of wealth without the connection and contact to someone else of that status. Wealth attracts wealth, and so on.</p><p>So, how do we define capitalist success? By virtue of using the works of Karl Marx to discuss capitalism, capitalist success is inextricable from the moral judgements that go alongside them: “Marx argued that all capitalist profit is ultimately derived from the exploitation of the worker.” (Wolff and Leopold, 2021) It is difficult to extract a definition of capitalist success from the works of Marx who, for obvious reasons, was more preoccupied with defining a human emancipation from capitalism, making the state of capitalism a failure in itself. For this reason, and what may sound somewhat contrived, our definition of capitalist failure is Marxist success. We’re disinterested in the capitalist success of accumulation of wealth, and so can make the simple rhetorical leap to say that capitalist failure would be failure to accumulate capital. This is a simplistic reduction of capitalism at large, but appropriate for a conversation concerning the mechanics of Disco Elysium.</p><p>I acknowledge that these frameworks for success and failure as broadly philosophical and mostly applicable to our lived reality, and less so to videogames. This essay is an exploration of what it means to fail in videogames, acknowledging that most games do not permit the scale of failure discussed here. This is my reasoning for choosing to discuss Disco Elysium first and foremost; Disco Elysium provides ample room to discuss these topics and stands as a good example of redefining failure in videogames according to these principles. Likewise, this is not a call for videogames to start introducing multicursal narratives (using Espen Aarseth’s definition of “aspects, such as repetition, interlaced narrative threads, prolepsis,…” (Aarseth, 1997, p.7)) which permit the kinds of rippling effects failure has on a narrative. This would be financially impossible for studios to implement. Nonetheless, embracing failure from this perspective becomes a philosophical shift I ask for players to go through: the narrative peaks of Mass Effect 1 and 2 are successes, but they ultimately do not stop the catastrophic events which take place in Mass Effect 3. This has led to many online discussion forum threads eager to call the narrative of Mass Effect 2 “pointless” (metroidman92, 2011; Dreamboum, 2018; bobbythecat17, 2018). This viewpoint extends past videogames too, with Rian Johnson’s Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017) seeing similar complaints (lockpick4862, 2017; SavageHoliday, 2018; Carro, 2019; Rossi, n.d.). The topmost point of Halberstam’s Queer Art of Failure establishes that queer lives are, to some extent, defined by their failure to conform to heteronormative standards. By rejecting the heteronormative framework for failure and success, these stories become stories of camaraderie, courage, and learning. Player choice in the build-up to Mass Effect 2’s Suicide Mission (an impassioned charge into dark space with low chances of survival) enables the possibility of losing crew members who the player has built up a relationship with. Those crew members, obviously, do not reappear in Mass Effect 3. Instead, this failure in saving their lives manifests as the ultimate sacrifice: those crew members committed their lives to saving the universe in Mass Effect 3. The main takeaway here should be that failure is a learning process. Success, as defined by neoliberalism and masculinity is oft unattainable. The value of failing does not only lie in learning, but in standing against unreasonable standards and finding a self-defined meaning of success.</p><p>It goes without saying that some would respond to this by asking what the issue is with aligning to current ideas of success. Marx would call this ideology: “… a “worldview” providing the members of a group with a sense of meaning and identity” (Wolff and Leopold, 2021), and would even write about “seeking to liberate individuals from certain false and misleading forms of understanding” (Wolff and Leopold, 2021). The question of: “what is wrong with aligning with contemporary frameworks of success and failure?” is one based in a firm ideology. There is a benefit to interrogating our ideologies for we might come to learn surprising things about our assumptions and what we deem “common sense”. The answer, then, is “There is nothing wrong with that.” with the caveat that the wrong question is being asked. Rather, the question should be: “What is the benefit of these contemporary frameworks for success and failure?”. Bringing this back to previous analyses of neoliberalism and capitalism, by interrogating our ideology we might find that these frameworks push us to “internalise power” (Pérez-Latorre and Oliva, 2019, p.790) and strive to self-improve. And we ask, “With what benefit?”, and “With benefit to whom?” Using the example of the “carbon footprint”, a means of measuring an individual’s contribution of CO2 to the atmosphere and consequently to climate change (Anon, n.d.), the oil giant BP pushed everyday people to be more conscious of their impact on climate change. Of course, this push for individual responsibility and “internalised power” was a convenient diversion tactic: BP to this day produces 3.8 million barrels of oil a day (Kaufman, 2020). Sorting one’s recycling pales in comparison to the systematic changes required to stop just 100 corporations creating 71% of the world’s pollution (Riley, 2017). And so, by interrogating just one small aspect of our ideology we have found that the notion of paying attention to our carbon footprint, of self-improvement, does more to push the blame from multinational corporations to individuals.</p><h4>Queer Art of Failure</h4><p>The neoliberal, capitalist, and masculinist approaches to failure outlined previously place the player in opposition to the game systems; the player is expected to persevere, grow, improve, and triumph over the game’s challenges. When we look at Disco Elysium, we know that this is not a game requiring dexterity or other forms of player skill; it is slow and prose heavy. Brendan Keogh writes:</p><blockquote>“… videogames produced beyond the confines of the high-budget blockbuster industry are instead phenomenological — explicitly that of situated navigation rather than godlike configuration, a corporeal engagement of the senses rather than an intellectual engagement of systems — and they require an integrated and cooperative relationship between the human and the computer.” (Keogh, 2018, p.184)</blockquote><p>Phenomenology is a philosophical school of thought, widely agreed to have been founded in the late 20th century by Edmund Husserl. A succinct definition can be found in the Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy from David Smith:</p><blockquote>“phenomenology is the study of “phenomena”: appearances of things, or things as they appear in our experience, or the ways we experience things, thus the meanings things have in our experience. Phenomenology studies conscious experience as experienced from the subjective or first person point of view.” (Smith, 2018)</blockquote><p>This is a key concept for considering videogames, especially roleplaying games, where the player is tasked with inserting themselves, or a character of their making, into the game’s world. Roleplaying games, above all, are concerned with the idea of “immersion” or “flow”, with the two terms often used interchangeably. The key aspects of a state of flow are the loss of perception of time, a balance between game challenge and player skill, and unbroken concentration (Michailidis et al., 2018). Taken in the context of Disco Elysium especially, the game presents the player with a breakdown of every aspect of Harry’s personality. These 24 aspects break down the barrier between Harry’s phenomenological experience and the player’s. Some of these aspects, like “Endurance”, “Pain Threshold”, “Encyclopaedia”, “Rhetoric”, and “Empathy” are self-explanatory. Others, like “Inland Empire” and “Electro-chemistry” are more abstract and instead make a statement about the kind of person Harry is/was. “Inland Empire” is described in-game as:</p><blockquote>“Hunches and gut feelings. Dreams in waking life.” (ZA/UM, 2019)</blockquote><p>To bring this back to Keogh’s initial point, I’d like to make a connection to Donna Haraway’s idea of the “cyborg” as “creatures simultaneously animal and machine, who populate worlds ambiguously natural and crafted.” (Haraway and Wolfe, 2016, p.6) If the neoliberal approach is to dominate the system and the game then, conversely, I want to apply the idea of the cyborg to a gamer who integrates with the game systems.</p><p>This “cyborg-gamer” Keogh outlines is a more apt lens for me to approach Disco Elysium with. Disco makes clear the factors which affect the player’s rolls. If the player, for example, maintains an amicable relationship with Kim Kitsuragi, the interface indicating a dice roll during a pivotal narrative beat will display the following disclaimer: “+1 — Kim trusts you”. If the player develops a friendship with Lt. Kitsuragi, the game will also show: “+1 — Kim *really* trusts you”. While the game relies on dice and chance to randomise outcomes, it also offers the player assistance. To turn down the game’s assistance and instead “savescum” is “To abolish chance by holding it in the grip of causality and finality, to count on the repetition of throws rather than affirming chance, to anticipate a result instead of affirming necessity — these are all the operations of a bad player.” (Deleuze, 2005, p.27). Thusly, the cyborg-player is one who denies the hegemonic dominance required of neoliberal and masculinist approaches to failure, and one who aims to integrate with the game’s systems. This leads me neatly to the next, key piece of theory. To integrate with the game’s systems is one thing but lacks purpose independently. Why should the player integrate with the game’s system and stop trying to dominate it?</p><p>A key text of this dissertation is Judith Halberstam’s The Queer Art of Failure (2011). I would like to note that the author goes by both Judith and Jack and uses he/him and she/her pronouns interchangeably. With respect to the published work, here I will use the author’s published name Judith, with the pronouns she/her. Halberstam sets up the following argument:</p><blockquote>“Heteronormative common sense leads to the equation of success with advancement, capital accumulation, family, ethical conduct, and hope. Other subordinate, queer, or counterhegemonic modes of common sense lead to the association of failure with nonconformity, anticapitalist practices, nonreproductive life styles, negativity, and critique.” (Halberstam, 2011, p.89)</blockquote><p>Later, in a moderated conversation between Jack Halberstam and Jesper Juul, as transcribed in Queer Game Studies (2017), Halberstam expands on this, saying:</p><blockquote>“[Queer people] fail in their socially prescribed role. There are two responses you can have to that. One is to try and play the game as it’s been written, to say, “I’m sorry, I didn’t realize. I will now get married and have children, and then maybe you will accept me as a success on your terms.” Or you refuse the game. You say, “Actually, that outcome is not what I desire.” You rewrite the game, and in the process you accept what we call failure. So, that acceptance in failure, that investment in failure, that excitement about failure, is the queer art of failure.” (Shaw and Ruberg, 2017, p.202)</blockquote><p>And so, the central statement of this dissertation is based on the above quote: we should embrace this queer art of failure when playing roleplaying games. Indeed, outside of them too, but that is beyond the scope of this essay. By willingly failing, we reject the terms of success established by another and instead we establish our own boundaries, facing a moment of self-actualization: defining our own terms for success. As I have discussed before, the terms of success in videogames with point-scoring systems or competitive systems are clear. In roleplaying games, these terms are less clear. For that reason, I’d like to reference the input of an audience member in that same conversation. Kathryn Boyd Stockton refers to it as an “accumulation of anti-capital” (Shaw and Ruberg, 2017, p.208). It is this accumulation that builds up value over time, and it is these failings that feel awful in the moment but yield greater benefits over time. While this feels like success-with-added-steps, in a capitalist society that moment-to-moment failure can have devastating consequences especially for those who identify as part of the precariat. Isabel Lorey defines the precariat as a low-income people who live their life according to a relationship with precariousness; the precarity of health insurance tied to employment, to housing and food related to employment, and so on (Lorey et al., 2015, paraphrased). And so encouraging the accumulation of anti-capital comes up against its main barrier: a literal situation of life and death. Succeed, or face loss of earnings. Encouraging failure when livelihood is at stake seems a privileged, out of touch position to take. This is a rebuttal I unfortunately do not have an answer for; but the question is quite broad and does not require a black-and-white approach. If failure puts the reader at a potential loss of housing or sustenance, it makes sense to confront the reality of the system we live in and seek out capital.</p><p>When many games present players with “morality” meters; multiple choices, some of which are presented as “good” and “bad”; or scoring systems, the reflex to succeed can be tough to overcome. Finishing Mass Effect 2’s (BioWare, 2010) “Suicide Mission” with a full squad of loyal, alive teammates can be a satisfying reward for time spent investing time into exploring the game’s many missions, systems, and narrative arcs. But heading into Mass Effect 3 (BioWare, 2012) with a squad which is mourning, a squad personally affected by loss can be an indulgently cathartic experience. Overcoming our want to succeed is a direct stand against the neoliberal ideology Western readers will most likely relate to. And so, we come to another interesting question: if deliberate failure and accumulation of anti-capital is our aim, we’re not only coming to a moment of self-actualization through establishing boundaries, but also reflecting on a way of life that is default. If we accept failure as the goal, are we rejecting the aims of the videogames we play and the terms of the world we live in? This way, as Halberstam explains, failure becomes an anti-capitalist, revolutionary act. Bringing up neoliberal ideology in this context isn’t without intention; placing the wellbeing of the community in the hands of individuals and companies by means of self-governance and responsibility is a central dynamic in most roleplaying videogames (Pérez-Latorre and Oliva, 2019). Overcoming obstacles, defeating enemies, and other shows of prowess rewards the player with experience points they can spend on improving their characters more, with an expectation that players will build the most optimal character for approaching the game’s systems. This focus on self-improvement places every character on an even playing field of even opportunities and prescribes any failure as a personal failure rather than a systemic one.</p><p>Synthesising the definitions of failure outlined by neoliberalism and masculinity gives us a philosophical framework. However, by bringing in the lessons from The Queer Art of Failure, we can begin questioning this framework. The notion that the opposite of masculinity is femininity, and so the failure of masculinity is to be feminine is a clearly sexist idea.</p><h3>Chapter 2 — Disco Elysium and Dice</h3><p>For this academic reading of Disco Elysium, the player is… me. This is important; my experiences are inseparable from this reading. And so, I will try to outline my own attitudes and perspectives and their bearing on this reading. Sarah Ahmed speaks of “orientation” as beyond the commonly understood sexual orientation: “Orientations shape not only how we inhabit space, but how we apprehend this world of shared inhabitance, as well as “who” or “what” we direct our energy and attention towards.” (Ahmed, 2006, p.3) Orientation is an idea I will return to regularly, comparing and contrasting my orientations against Disco Elysium. I am a Polish immigrant to England; my parents and extended family are manual laborers from a post-Communist era. My political orientation leans, nay, sits firmly left. After an extended conversation with my partner, we both settled on the idea that we identify as male and female, respectively, because that is what we are used to. Being referred to as a man does not feel wrong, and so the label stuck for the past 24 years. I am heterosexual so far — my lived experience has been privileged by the lack of fear that feels so common to queer lived experience — but I cannot say this with full certainty. My creative work has always focused on ideas of masculinity because, despite me identifying as a man, I do not identify with masculinity. It has been defined as “toxic”, “unhealthy”, and so on, and so my aim has always been to find something which does not feel fit those criterions. Something that could help other men in the same situation find their path. Adrienne Shaw and Bonnie Ruberg say that “Queerness, as its heart, can be defined as the desire to live life otherwise, by questioning and living outside of normative boundaries.” (Shaw and Ruberg, 2017, p.x-Introduction). Having lived my entire life happily benefitting from passing as a heterosexual man, it approaches stolen valour to say that I identify with queerness. The queer experience is not, of course, defined by suffering. So far, there is little to contrast; if the player pursues centrism and neoliberalism (referred to as “Moralism” in-universe), the game says:</p><blockquote>“Moralists don’t really have beliefs. Sometimes they stumble on one, like on a child’s toy left on the carpet. The toy must be put away immediately. And the child reprimanded. Centrism isn’t change — not even incremental change. It is control. Over yourself and the world. Exercise it. Look up at the sky, at the dark shapes of Coalition airships hanging there. Ask yourself: is there something sinister in moralism? And then answer: no. God is in his heaven. Everything is normal on Earth.” (ZA/UM, 2019)</blockquote><p>Having grown up surrounded by video games, they became my main hobby and outlet. This is a relatively heteronormative journey, and quite stereotypical. My ideological journey, however, was one of a slow lean towards pacifism and a rejection of authority, of “getting yours”, and of individualism. A common sentiment throughout my family went as follows (translation mine):</p><blockquote>“Communism was great. We had lots of money but there was no food on the shelves, under Capitalism we have no money but there’s lots of food on the shelves … it was only terrible if you had a problem with authority.”</blockquote><p>This, largely, spells out disaster for me and this dissertation. Challenging authority and the status quo is an underlying tenet of this whole piece. Taken outside of the context of the Communist states, however, we can apply this to the notions of failure I set up earlier in the essay.</p><p>This close reading will approach two main aspects of Disco Elysium. I want to talk about Disco’s mechanics and its narrative. Of course, the two are interlinked and separating them is merely for structural neatness and not a statement for or against the specific approaches of narratology and ludology.</p><p>Disco Elysium is a prose-heavy game. Its key gameplay mechanic is the textbox; every interaction, be it with a person or inanimate object, is framed by a textbox. Every interaction is made livelier by the constant chatter of Harry’s 24 “skills” chiming in and adding their observations. Sometimes, these skills will argue between themselves, riff off one another, and even sway each other. The player’s role is to arbitrate them and pick their next course of action. Of course, 24 voices get chaotic, and so the game presents a simple mechanic to filter them out: the player can spend progression points to improve these skills, drawing out their voice out of the crowd of others. Any time there is something to be said, the game rolls two 6-sided dice in the background, and whichever skill scores the highest gets to speak. During most conversations these die rolls stay in the background, though the player can hover over most dialogues to see the rolled number compared against a target value. At key moments and narrative beats, the player is explicitly asked to trigger a die roll, its dark-orange coloration showing that there is no retrying here; whatever happens, happens. Other dice rolls, the ones coloured White, can be tried and, if failed, retried on the condition the player chooses to spend a progression point to improve its constituent skill. This distinction between what can be retried and what cannot be retried is mainly one of timing; these Dark-Orange checks happen mid-conversation, while the White ones are mostly triggered by objection interactions in the world. The reasoning for this distinction is “logical” and follows a common-sense understanding of conversation — we can’t keep saying different things until we get the desirable outcome — so I will not explore this reasoning further. What is interesting, is the distinction itself. The game makes it clear that anything happening after this point is final and cannot be retried.</p><p>When it comes to dice systems and games which approach failure with nuance, John Harper’s Blades in the Dark (BitD)(2017) is a great example. BitD is a tabletop roleplaying game which primarily uses pools of 6-sided dice to adjudicate outcomes, based on whether the player’s actions are deemed Controlled, Risky, or Desperate. For brevity, I will only quote the rules to Risky actions below.</p><blockquote><strong>RISKY</strong></blockquote><blockquote>You go head to head. You act under fire. You take a chance.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Critical:</strong> You do it with<strong> increased effect</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>6</strong>: You do it.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>4/5</strong>: You do it, but there’s a consequence: you suffer <strong>harm</strong>, a <strong>complication </strong>occurs, you have <strong>reduced effect</strong>, you end up in a <strong>desperate </strong>position.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>1–3</strong>: Things go badly. You suffer <strong>harm</strong>, a <strong>complication</strong> occurs, you end up in a <strong>desperate </strong>position, you <strong>lose this opportunity</strong>. (Harper, 2017, p.23)</blockquote><p>My reason for using BitD rules as an example here is simple: it offers a much more nuanced framework for considering failure, both in TTRPGs and in cRPGs. At no point does the game stop if the player rolls badly; rolling the lowest possible results of 1–3 results in complications, but at no point is the player blocked from progressing. Notably, I claim that the rules support leaning into the accumulation of anti-capital mentioned earlier in the essay. Pure success is only possible on a roll of 6, every other result leads to some complication. The rules push the players into uncomfortable positions, with each roll leading to a frantic, improvisational game of actions and consequences. Regardless of the risk of each roll, be it Controlled, Risky, or Desperate, the threshold for success is the same. Making Desperate rolls is encouraged, too, with the game noting that players attempting desperate actions be rewarded with experience points regardless of if they succeed or not. Here, the mechanical incentives for players and game masters alike are clear: drama resulting from attempting Desperate manoeuvres is good; failure is encouraged, and failure drives you forward. Applying this to cRPGs can be a naïve endeavour; videogames are limited to their code and offer predetermined choices. There is no Game Master to give improvised situations and outcomes. Nonetheless, we can read this through the lens of queer failure which Halberstam established; failure is merely a “speed bump toward mastery” (Shaw and Ruberg, 2017, p.214).</p><p>Disco Elysium’s dice rolls use two six-sided dice to adjudicate outcomes. However, in videogames we come up against the problem of savescumming. “Savescumming” — though a somewhat crass term — is the practice of saving the player’s progress and reloading, allowing the player to retry from that point until the player reaches a desirable outcome. In the context of Disco Elysium, if a certain die roll doesn’t go their way, the player can simply load the game at the start of a conversation and try again and again until they succeed. During the game’s countless conversations, the meanings of “success” and “failure” become defined by outside forces; by the developers themselves. The interesting question I aim to answer: should the definitions of these successes and failures concern thematic cohesion, narrative “flow”, “common sense”, affective or satisfactory outcomes, or something else? Harking back to the example of Red Dead Redemption 2: the player overcoming Arthur’s tuberculosis would be a satisfactory outcome, surely, but one that would nullify his redemption arc.</p><p>There is nothing stopping the player from savescumming, though referring back to my previous mention of Deleuze, we approach a philosophical juncture. As he writes, ““To abolish chance by holding it in the grip of causality and finality, to count on the repetition of throws rather than affirming chance, to anticipate a result instead of affirming necessity — these are all the operations of a bad player.” (Deleuze, 2005, p.27). By savescumming, the player is acting in bad faith; they take full advantage of the uncertainty of repeated die rolls, and they disrespect the finality of chance. There are two approaches to this: the first is a concerted effort to reclaim agency. The player feels they are owed a certain result, be It due to creating their character in a way where their failure feels unearned, or due to a narrative turn they feel was likewise unearned. This is the neoliberal approach; the player is met with a system with a clear end goal and will take advantage of this system to achieve their optimal result. The reasons for taking advantage of the system are multitudinous; going back to the idea of the “cyborg-gamer”, the player has no reason not to savescum, but the practice is generally frowned upon (hence the name). The other option is a straightforward acceptance of their failure; this most aligns with the queer art of failure I have mentioned before. But this is also at odds with the idea of Player One: where these masculine hyper-gamers would be proud of mastering the game’s systems and overcoming its challenges without resorting to lowly savescumming, to say that their approach can be queered and turned into a story of self-actualisation seems unfounded. Their aim to complete the game without savescumming is the masculine, societal pressure of self-improvement. The difference, then, must lie in changing how we play videogames. Where the pride of completing a game without savescumming is a celebration of one’s ability to dominate the game’s systems, and thus a thoroughly masculine approach, the queer approach is to accept the failure that comes of our inability to finish the game. The approach of failure as a “speedbump to mastery” doesn’t go far enough in this case: it is accepting that the game has bested us that matters.</p><p>Deriving fun from the game’s systems in ways other than completion is also something to consider: Aubrey Anable writes that “video games offer us ways of being with and feeling machines.” (Anable, 2018, p.39) This is a natural next step in the idea of the cyborg-gamer as it closes in on the devices which facilitate this connection. While Anable writes of the affective properties of the touchscreen, we can expand her work to the controller:</p><blockquote>“Being touched, in the sense of being moved emotionally, signals the very real experience of something immaterial pressing itself on our emotional state and changing it, and the capacity for us to touch someone or something else in a similar way.” (Anable, 2018, p.39)</blockquote><p>Playing videogames in this way poses a different notion of success which savescumming has no bearing on. Playing for the emotional resonance of a game introduces a whole spectrum of approaches that would be, by the dominant approach, a failure of playing the game. This way, the game stops being a system to be dominated, and a system to be embraced and lived within; a vehicle for emotional connection, the medium of which being a remediation of the game’s world and the game’s controls. This requires further research as it opens up a broad avenue for approach; Bo Ruberg writes about this, calling it “playing games queerly” (Ruberg, 2019, paraphrased). Here, completing the game is no longer the sole aim; rather, to play games queerly is to play with the aim of losing, the aim of spending time in the game’s environments, the aim of not getting better.</p><p>Going back to the topic of savescumming, to exemplify savescumming in the context of Disco Elysium, I will use the late-game example of Kim Kitsuragi being shot during a standoff with a mercenary group. As previously mentioned, the player can get several bonuses during this conversation for building a friendship with Kim. At one point, when Kim’s back is turned, the player is given the option to warn Kim of the gun pointed at his back. After spending several hours talking to Kim and exploring Kim and Harry’s relationship, a rogue roll of the dice, despite the bonuses, could mean that Kim does not react in time and gets shot. If the dice roll is successful, Kim is only grazed. In the moment there is no way to tell if Kim is dead (luckily, Kim is only severely injured by the gunshot) and so the player can immediately action a solution: reload their save and try to warn Kim again. This is a strong counterargument to the Queer Art of Failure. Where I would pontificate about the value of accumulating anti-capital, about learning from your mistakes, and accepting failure, the player would ask: But why should I? The failure here isn’t skill-based, and the player has mitigated their risk of failure as much as possible by building a friendship with Kim. There is no learning experience here, other than the one that even when a system is tipped in your favour it might not always act favourably. A sobering message, but a message nonetheless. Overall, the arguments not to savescum are quite weak — it is only natural to seek the best outcome (or so my ideology would say).</p><p>Disco Elysium takes place in a fictional, unnamed world. More specifically: a tiny district of the city of Revachol (Re-va-shol), Martinaise (Martin-ay). Martinaise has all the marks of a city ravaged by war; its buildings stand in disrepair, walls and bridges pockmarked by bullet holes, and its people abandoned by a government not set on supporting them. Martinaise’s most relevant landmarks are the Whirling-in-Rags, a hostel cafeteria and the meeting place of the Hardie Boys, a muscle-unit of the Dockworkers’ Union who work nearby. Opposite the Whirling-in-Rags is the East Delta Commercial Centre, though it more commonly goes by the superstitious moniker “Doomed Commercial Area”. The people of Martinaise call it so because every business which moves into the office block mysteriously fails within a few months. Is it a curse cast upon the building, or is it the inevitable destiny of capitalism running its course? One of the building’s largest offices was occupied by a game studio, now abandoned, whose project ballooned out of scope. In the notes the player can find scattered amongst the office’s debris and defunct radiocomputers is a story paralleling that of ZA/UM themselves. A group of friends, young and ambitious with little direction, gathering to make something great. In their ambition they refused to settle for anything but perfection and, one by one, their friendships broke, and the team drifted apart. There is a self-aware rebellion here: the team at ZA/UM knew that they could succumb to that same fate their characters did. This is a studio which, unfortunately, did not stand up to the test of capitalism. The fact that the studio had to close is an indictment of capitalist success: gathering a group of creatives under a common cause, ready to create something enriching but unable to fund it is a sad state of events. But it comes up against another rebuttal to the central thesis of this essay: it is easy enough to say No! to the system we live in, but that does not change the fact that we are part of that system regardless of our opinion on it. Saying “we embrace failure” is rather meaningless when that embrace puts a stop to our work, our livelihood, and puts us in a position of precarity. This unfortunately mirrors an earlier rebuttal: brandishing failure as a weapon against unattainable notions of success doesn’t change the reality that without work, we put our lives at risk.</p><p>Deep within the Doomed Commercial Area, past its offices and maintenance tunnels, by a window overlooking Revachol and next to a now-defunct chimney stack sits a Novelty Dicemaker. She doesn’t have a name; the Novelty Dicemaker is one of the few characters defined by their labour. She runs, right now, the only successful business operating out of the Doomed Commercial Area. She laughs the “curse” off as mere superstition but acknowledges that the chimney stack is technically outside of the building. It’s important to note that the Novelty Dicemaker is the only one who seems to have staved off labour alienation, using Marx’s definition of a worker who has been separated from the product of their labour (Marx et al., 1988, paraphrased), and instead works independently, creating a product which she herself sells to a local community she is part of. The Dicemaker is, by capitalist definitions, a failure. She lives by herself, in a property which doesn’t belong to her, and she does not accumulate wealth. Nonetheless, this highlights that the neoliberal use of “self-improvement” isn’t an inherent negative and shouldn’t be looked at as such. Growing one’s skills isn’t a malicious scheme to extract profit and alienate workers from their labour. At least… not always. The difference here is between self-actualisation and labour alienation; the Dicemaker has reached a point of equilibrium. Her skills provide for her lifestyle, and nothing more. There is no flagrant display of wealth here.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Using work on neoliberalism, capitalism, and masculinity, I have defined a broad concept of failure that includes lack of accumulation of wealth, lack of self-improvement, and collectivism. These concepts of failure were unsatisfactory, and so I used the work of academics who study queer theory to create a subversive notion of failure which places those very things at the forefront. Bringing in the work of Karl Marx, I posit that collectivism is the thing we should be striving for. This brings with it a critique of ideology, also inspired by the work of Karl Marx, that takes us dangerously far from the intended topic of discussing failure in videogames. Nonetheless, the two are inextricably linked and so the essay criticised capitalist ideology for a narrow spectrum of success which is unattainable to most. Finally, I discussed how these theories apply to Disco Elysium. By calling on the work of John Harper in Blades in the Dark, I looked at a gameplay system which encourages failure and gives the players a reason to attempt high-risk manoeuvres. While the possibilities and wide permutations tabletop roleplaying games permit fit the central thesis of the dissertation almost perfectly, I ultimately arrived at the point that this would be unsustainable for game developers. Instead, I found that Disco Elysium offers a similar solution: it offers a more linear narrative that gives the illusion of open-endedness thanks to the 24 skills which make up Harry’s psyche. By allowing the player to prioritise certain skills, those skills shape the perspective through which the player interacts with Disco’s world, though the narrative beats remain largely unchanged. Even that in itself is a tough ask: a throwaway Tweet claims Disco Elysium’s script contains over one million words (Disco Elysium — The Final Cut, 2020). This is, likewise, quite unattainable for small studios. Unfortunately, the barriers to an expanded understanding of failure are, by all accounts, quite boring: it is a matter of scope and budget. The takeaway isn’t that developers should focus on expanding the fail states their games contain. Rather, that the successes these games contain perpetuate an unhealthy status quo. If, like Disco Elysium, we instead focus on the failures and make those the key goal of our art we can avoid the scope bloat — the goal of games then turns into collective action, mutual aid, and charity (as opposed to accumulation of wealth). Going beyond roleplaying games, if we look at the 4X genre (abbreviation of eXplore, eXpand, eXploit, eXterminate) and its colonialist mechanics (as clearly evidenced by the name), the notion of success is a flawed one. Often, there are no means by which the player can restore, protect, and share, which means playing with those goals in mind is to fail the game. The to-be-released game Terra Nil instead reverses those goals, “[presenting] players with the task of environmental rejuvenation” (Anon, n.d.).</p><p>To conclude, by interrogating contemporary sociology and political ways of thought I have created a definition of failure in videogames that goes beyond the simplistic dichotomy of life and death. By approaching failure from the perspectives of neoliberal thought and hegemonic masculinity, I have also defined parameters of success, enabling a holistic outlook on what it means to fail both in video games and in a neoliberal, capitalist society. I posed a brave proposition at the start of this essay: that this understanding of failure can be a rich ground for identity-making and radical self-love. By rejecting the systems we’re born into we can begin to carve our own, non-conformist, definition of success and interrogate the ideologies we take for granted. Using Disco Elysium as a key text, I have explored how game mechanics promote failure and how its characters do the very thing this essay has been about: the characters reject success and strive to find their own meaning. This isn’t to say that the thesis is watertight; there are strong rebuttals to the rejection of ideology. Losing a job is a speedbump in one’s life, but it can also have devastating effects to one’s ability to secure shelter or food. In that case, encouraging people to embrace this kind of failure is irresponsible. On the other hand, to put up with poor working conditions rather than unionising due to the potential of job-loss is likewise to embrace exploitation. It is a nuanced conversation, and one this essay only scratches the surface of. Bringing in the work of Aubrey Anable has opened up another potential avenue for explorations of failure, however, and one that Bo Ruberg’s “Videogames Have Always Been Queer” (2019) explores. By applying queer readings to games, we can form other, non-hegemonic definitions of play itself. Playing not to finish the game, but to spend time in its space, to score the lowest score, or to play in ways unsupported by the game’s systems are all means of queer play which would be treated as “failure” by the frameworks I have established throughout. I would have to further research these theories as part of a PhD; combining theories of socioeconomics, gender, and video game theory was an ambitious task, and one that would benefit from a much-expanded scope. Nonetheless, it has been the sole purpose of this essay to explore the cases which do not lie at the extremes of precariousness; the cases in which embracing failure is a vehicle to explore our ideologies and to learn about the side of our psyche which vehemently steers away from.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>Aarseth, E.J. 1997. Cybertext: perspectives on ergodic literature. Baltimore, Md: Johns Hopkins University Press.</p><p>Ahmed, S. 2006. Queer Phenomenology: Orientations, Objects, Others [Online]. Duke University Press. [Accessed 10 March 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv125jk6w.">http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv125jk6w.</a></p><p>Anable, A. 2018. Playing with Feelings: Video Games and Affect [Online]. University of Minnesota Press. [Accessed 10 March 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctt20mvgwg.">http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctt20mvgwg.</a></p><p>Anon n.d. Terra Nil on Steam. [Accessed 31 August 2021a]. Available from: <a href="https://store.steampowered.com/app/1593030/Terra_Nil/">https://store.steampowered.com/app/1593030/Terra_Nil/.</a></p><p>Anon n.d. What is your carbon footprint? The Nature Conservancy. [Online]. [Accessed 26 August 2021b]. Available from: <a href="https://www.nature.org/en-us/get-involved/how-to-help/carbon-footprint-calculator/">https://www.nature.org/en-us/get-involved/how-to-help/carbon-footprint-calculator/.</a></p><p>BBC News 2021a. Greece wildfires spread, causing mass evacuations. BBC News. [Online]. [Accessed 20 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-58124129.">https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-58124129.</a></p><p>BBC News 2021b. Marcus Rashford mural defaced after England Euro 2020 defeat. BBC News. [Online]. [Accessed 20 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-manchester-57803161.">https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-manchester-57803161.</a></p><p>Mass Effect 2. 2010. PC [Game]. BioWare.</p><p>Mass Effect 3. 2012. PC [Game]. BioWare.</p><p>bobbythecat17 2018. Why does Mass Effect 2 feel pointless? r/masseffect. [Online]. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.reddit.com/r/masseffect/comments/93v9fc/why_does_mass_effect_2_feel_pointless/">www.reddit.com/r/masseffect/comments/93v9fc/why_does_mass_effect_2_feel_pointless/.</a></p><p>Bogost, I. 2008. The Rhetoric of Video Games In:, pp.117–139.</p><p>Carro, J. 2019. The Last Jedi Makes Star Wars Pointless | Away With Words. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://awaywithwordsjc.com/2019/01/09/the-last-jedi-makes-star-wars-pointless/">https://awaywithwordsjc.com/2019/01/09/the-last-jedi-makes-star-wars-pointless/.</a></p><p>Chess, S. 2017. Ready Player Two: Women Gamers and Designed Identity. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.</p><p>Connell, R. 2005. Masculinities Second Edition. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.</p><p>Deleuze, G. 2005. Nietzsche and philosophy. London: Continuum.</p><p>Disco Elysium — The Final Cut 2020. @DJLoff Hey there, thanks for the question, we have over a million words in the game!</p><p>􀚴􀚵􀚶. @discoelysium. [Online]. [Accessed 31 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://twitter.com/discoelysium/status/1215597783509610497.">https://twitter.com/discoelysium/status/1215597783509610497.</a></p><p>Dreamboum 2018. Mass Effect 2 always felt like a disappointing sequel to me. ResetEra. [Online]. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.resetera.com/threads/mass-effect-2-always-felt-like-a-disappointing-sequel-to-me.35201/">https://www.resetera.com/threads/mass-effect-2-always-felt-like-a-disappointing-sequel-to-me.35201/.</a></p><p>EGX 2018. Disco Elysium — What happens when you’re aiming to create the best RPG of all time [Online]. [Accessed 19 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iMsgs5viEbg.">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iMsgs5viEbg.</a></p><p>Gygax, G. and Arneson, D. 1974. Dungeons &amp; Dragons Basic. Tactical Studies Rules, Inc.</p><p>Halberstam, J. 2011. The Queer Art of Failure [Online]. Duke University Press. [Accessed 29 March 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv11sn283.">http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv11sn283.</a></p><p>Hammar, E. 2020. Imperialism and fascism intertwined. A materialist analysis of the games industry and reactionary gamers. gamevironments.</p><p>Haraway, D.J. and Wolfe, C. 2016. Manifestly Haraway [Online]. University of Minnesota Press. [Accessed 23 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctt1b7x5f6.">http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctt1b7x5f6.</a></p><p>Harper, J. 2017. Blades in the Dark. Evil Hat Games.</p><p>Hobbs, A. 2021. Economic inequality and recovery.</p><p>Baldur’s Gate. 1998. PC [Game]. Interplay Entertainment.</p><p>Juul, J. 2013. The Art of Failure: An essay on the pain of playing video games. The MIT Press.</p><p>Kaufman, M. 2020. BP created ‘carbon footprint’ as a devious, manipulative PR tactic. Mashable. [Online]. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sham.">https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sham.</a></p><p>Keogh, B. 2018. A Play of Bodies: How We Perceive Videogames. Cambridge: The MIT Press.</p><p>Kotzer, Z. 2017. 20 Game Over Screens Worth Dying For. Vice. [Online]. [Accessed 19 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.vice.com/en/article/3dynbb/20-game-over-screens-worth-dying-for.">https://www.vice.com/en/article/3dynbb/20-game-over-screens-worth-dying-for.</a></p><p>lockpick4862 2017. [Spoilers]TLJ Feels A Little… Pointless? r/StarWars. [Online]. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.reddit.com/r/StarWars/comments/7kk124/spoilerstlj_feels_a_little_pointless/">www.reddit.com/r/StarWars/comments/7kk124/spoilerstlj_feels_a_little_pointless/.</a></p><p>Lorey, Isabell., Derieg, Aileen. and Butler, J. 2015. State of insecurity : government of the precarious. London: Verso.</p><p>Marx, K., Engels, F. and Milligan, Martin. 1988. Economic and philosophic manuscripts of 1844. Amherst, N.Y: Prometheus Books.</p><p>Maybee, J.E. 2020. Hegel’s Dialectics In: E. N. Zalta, ed. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy [Online]. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. [Accessed 27 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2020/entries/hegel-dialectics/">https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2020/entries/hegel-dialectics/.</a></p><p>metroidman92 2011. So Arrival completely made ME2 pointless? *spoilers* — Mass Effect 2. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/944907-mass-effect-2/58647264.">https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/944907-mass-effect-2/58647264.</a></p><p>Michailidis, L., Balaguer-Ballester, E. and He, X. 2018. Flow and Immersion in Video Games: The Aftermath of a Conceptual Challenge. Frontiers in Psychology. 9, p.1682.</p><p>Pac-Man. 1980. Arcade [Game] Namco.</p><p>Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End. 2016. PS4 [Game]. Naughty Dog.</p><p>Pérez-Latorre, Ó. and Oliva, M. 2019. Video Games, Dystopia, and Neoliberalism: The Case of BioShock Infinite. Games and Culture. 14(7–8), pp.781–800.</p><p>Rian Johnson 2017. Star Wars: The Last Jedi. Walt Disney Studios.</p><p>Riley, T. 2017. Just 100 companies responsible for 71% of global emissions, study says. the Guardian. [Online]. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/jul/10/100-fossil-fuel-companies-investors-responsible-71-global-emissions-cdp-study-climate-change.">http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2017/jul/10/100-fossil-fuel-companies-investors-responsible-71-global-emissions-cdp-study-climate-change.</a></p><p>Red Dead Redemption. 2010. PS3 [Game]. Rockstar Games.</p><p>Red Dead Redemption 2. 2018. PS4 [Game]. Rockstar Games.</p><p>Rossi, J. n.d. What was the most pointless part of Star Wars: The Last Jedi? — Quora. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-most-pointless-part-of-Star-Wars-The-Last-Jedi.">https://www.quora.com/What-was-the-most-pointless-part-of-Star-Wars-The-Last-Jedi.</a></p><p>Ruberg, B. 2019. Video games have always been queer. New York: New York University Press.</p><p>SavageHoliday 2018. Finn’s mission in the last Jedi is stupid. r/StarWars. [Online]. [Accessed 26 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.reddit.com/r/StarWars/comments/8674qd/finns_mission_in_the_last_jedi_is_stupid/">www.reddit.com/r/StarWars/comments/8674qd/finns_mission_in_the_last_jedi_is_stupid/.</a></p><p>Shaw, A. and Ruberg, B. 2017. Queer Game Studies [Online]. University of Minnesota Press. [Accessed 19 March 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctt1mtz7kr.">http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctt1mtz7kr.</a></p><p>Smith, D.W. 2018. Phenomenology In: E. N. Zalta, ed. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy [Online]. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. [Accessed 25 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2018/entries/phenomenology/">https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2018/entries/phenomenology/.</a></p><p>Portal 2. 2011. PC [Game]. Valve.</p><p>Wiltshire, A. 2020. The making of Disco Elysium: How ZA/UM created one of the most original RPGs of the decade. gamesradar. [Online]. [Accessed 7 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.gamesradar.com/uk/the-making-of-disco-elysium-how-zaum-created-one-of-the-most-original-rpgs-of-the-decade/">https://www.gamesradar.com/uk/the-making-of-disco-elysium-how-zaum-created-one-of-the-most-original-rpgs-of-the-decade/.</a></p><p>Wolff, J. and Leopold, D. 2021. Karl Marx In: E. N. Zalta, ed. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy [Online]. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. [Accessed 19 August 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2021/entries/marx/">https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2021/entries/marx/.</a></p><p>Disco Elysium. 2019. PC [Game]. ZA/UM.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc1def0c6056" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Male Domain, Masculinity, and Kentucky Route Zero]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eryk.sawicki/the-male-domain-masculinity-and-kentucky-route-zero-fcccb3f89771?source=rss-557bca14fb9f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fcccb3f89771</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[masculinity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neoliberalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kentucky-route-zero]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eryk Sawicki]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Aug 2021 13:26:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-06T13:26:37.033Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xe67dwyk2nRLu3wS5M6EIA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kentucky Route Zero, 2013.</figcaption></figure><p>In trying to answer the question posed by this essay, I will explore Cardboard Computer’s <em>Kentucky Route Zero </em>(Annapurna Interactive, 2013) as a site challenging “masculine play”. I will begin by assessing the claims that videogames are a “male domain” and the effect this assessment has on our reading of Kentucky Route Zero (KRO). Developed and released episodically over the course of 9 years (Cardboard Computer launched their Kickstarter campaign in 2011 so it is likely the concept stage started earlier, and the final episode was released in 2020), KRO holds a unique context in that its development began in the leadup to Gamergate (GG) and finished years after Gamergate’s peak. The fallout of Gamergate has been far-reaching in the industry (Chess and Shaw, 2015), and so it will be interesting to see if we can draw parallels between GG and KRO. KRO is a fascinating remediation of several “traditional” arts (McLuhan, 2001); its narrative structure follows that of a stage play, divided into acts and scenes; and its interludes turn museum exhibits, stage plays, and performance art into possibility spaces (Bogost, 2008). These elements in synthesis make KRO a rich site for exploration.</p><p>The first section of this essay will focus on the second part of the question. That is, I will examine the consequences of considering videogames as a male domain by historicising the videogame industry and focusing on several key milestones; namely early video game advertising, followed by the growth of the gamer identity, how that identity led to Gamergate, and ending with the violent storming of the Capitol Building. The second section of the essay, then, will focus on Kentucky Route Zero as a piece of work which was partly developed pre-Gamergate, and partly developed post-Gamergate. Though “masculinity” or explorations <em>of </em>masculinity are not prominent themes in KRO, I will explore how its mode of play challenges dominant ideas of masculine play. By historicising the gamer identity in the first section, I aim to build a stable foundation for interpreting Kentucky Route Zero as a game which does not reproduce masculinity in the second section.</p><h3><strong>THE DEMESNE OF MEN</strong></h3><p>To talk about the consequences of considering videogames as a “male domain”, I will first examine and explore the meaning of the term. Carly A. Kocurek’s <em>Coin-operated Americans </em>(2015) is a historical and economic analysis of the growth of a new male identity, one predicated on prowess at the unlikeliest of arenas: the arcade. As Kocurek explains,</p><blockquote>“Compared with mid-century visions of manhood, competitive video gaming is closer parallel to a post-industrial, heavily individualized labor market … one that celebrates the skills and victories of individual achievements, where workers fulfill work roles as consultants, contractor, and freelancer”. (Kocurek, 2015)</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fksxYVvNyJD4fZV6_g578w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mattel Electronics’ Intellivision advert</figcaption></figure><p>I want to point to the clear parallel with neoliberalism here, one that I will explore later in the essay. This slow growth of the male gamer identity can be traced as far back as the early days of video games marketing of the 1980s, with recurring themes occurring even today. I will use the example of an advert for Mattel Electronics’ <em>Intellivision</em> system featuring George Plimpton, suited and booted, surrounded by bold serif typography which speaks of action, control, and challenge. Raewyn Connell’s <em>Masculinities </em>(2005) breaks down the organisation of masculinity into four parts: hegemony, subordination, complicity, and marginalization. I claim that these advertising methods are appeals to hegemonic masculinity which were merely the start of advertising predicated on masculinity. Kocurek uses a photograph taken by Enrico Ferorelli, featured in a 1982 issue of <em>Life </em>magazine, to illustrate a conscious rebranding effort coming from arcade owners. The boys pictured did not fit the negative stereotype of the “gamer”, they were “bright, clean-cut boys and young men … At their worst, the boys were harmless troublemakers, at their best, they were entrepreneurs and innovators on the rise.” (Kocurek, 2015). Kocurek claims that this was the first step — an attempt to stave off the moral panic of the games-obsessed teen by rehabilitating their image and pushing for a “tech-masculinity”. With that came an identity which broke rules, took pride in being anti-establishment, and possessed a mastery over technology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*6AKjSYlbvsYEhU4F221ZHA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Life Magazine, 1982. Photograph by Enrico Ferorelli.</figcaption></figure><p>As that identity took hold, gaming became an insular hobby and, by extension, created a division of “us” vs. “them”. In <em>Ready Player Two</em> (Chess, 2017), Shira Chess establishes a definition for Player Two (P2) — the “casual” games audience — based on the inverse of Player One (P1). Chess explains, calling on Jesper Juul’s <em>A Casual Revolution</em>:</p><blockquote>“the stereotype of the hardcore player is one ‘who has preference for science fiction, zombies, and fantasy fictions, has played a large number of video games, will invest large amounts of time and resources toward playing video games, and enjoys difficult games.’ The casual player stereotype, on the other hand, ‘is the inverted image of the hardcore player,’ one who likes ‘positive and pleasant fictions,’ has not played many games, and is willing to invest only minimal time.” (Chess, 2017)</blockquote><p>Player Two, then, is not an accurate reflection of the industry or market, but instead a designed identity, much like the masculinist image of Player One: the male gamer. For the purposes of this essay, P1 and P2 are handy, broad-stroke stand-ins for the male, hardcore gamer identity and its inverse, the casual gamer identity. Critical reflections of the gamer identity were seen as attacks by people whose identities were tied up in the media they consumed, going as far as subjecting the authors of the critical reflections to threats of violence, death, and rape. (Jennifer deWinter and Carly Kocurek, 2012) In 2014, these threats escalated to their peak and came to be known as #Gamergate. Developer Zoe Quinn was accused of having sex with a Kotaku journalist in exchange for positive reviews of her game, <em>Depression Quest. </em>Calling back to the concepts of P1 and P2, <em>Depression Quest</em> was a game aimed at Player Two — it did not require gaming prowess, it was relatively short, and focused entirely on the affective aspects of its narrative. As this was not a game for Player One, “Those in the GamerGate movement [alleged] that there is corruption in video games journalism and that feminists are actively working to undermine the video game industry.” (Chess and Shaw, 2015)</p><p>All of this, Alina Kim argues, was a leadup to the storming of the Capitol Building by alt-right supporters who had been empowered by years of corporate pandering to their fragile identities (Kim, 2021). A photograph of a man taking part in the invasion went viral, its standout feature a symbol tattooed on the man’s left hand (Rising serpent 🇺🇸, 2021). The symbol was tied to game series <em>Dishonored</em> and, claims Alina Kim, “is not the first time toxic gaming culture has made a cameo in a mainstream demonstration of violence.” (Kim, 2021) A report written by the Anti-defamation League found over 200 accounts on the games platform Steam spewing neo-Nazi rhetoric (Anon, n.d.), and so, as Kim claims, “through Internet platforms, extremists have found a path to realize violent desires that were previously channeled solely through video game action”. (Kim, 2021) It is important not to conflate these arguments with the moral panics which claim video games cause violence; playing video games was not what made these men violent, but video games were and are part of a society which supports and rewards displays of hegemonic masculinity. Kim’s most important highlights that:</p><blockquote>“… dark video game ‘memes’ can desensitize, brainwash, and eventually, convert. After all, white supremacist humor is built on such bigoted imagery; … In the glorification of historical killers and racists and accumulated frustration toward modern feminism, young players can be exposed casually to alt-right propagations, with enthusiastic imitators later escorted into the hateful world.” (Kim, 2021)</blockquote><p>As Adrienne Shaw and Shira Chess correctly point out, the language of academia is opaque and only lends itself to misconstruction (Chess and Shaw, 2015). The growing Player Two identity coupled with hard-to-parse Feminist cultural theory can add to the alienation of Player One. Alienation which, without proper support, can turn violent.</p><h3>KENTUCKY ROUTE ZERO</h3><p>In this chapter, I will use Cardboard Computer’s Kentucky Route Zero (KRO) to explore the negative space between the “us” and “them” of Gamergate discourse. As mentioned in the introduction, KRO was released episodically over the course of 7 years. The narrative follows Conway, an older antiques delivery driver, as he tries to complete one final delivery to 5 Dogwood Drive. On his journey through the weird-Americana landscape, Conway meets TV repairwoman Shannon Marquez, android musicians Junebug and Johnny and, finally, the young boy Ezra and his eagle brother Julian. The game is split into five acts, with interludes taking place between each act. The player starts in control of Conway, choosing dialogue options as Conway interacts with the other members of the group. Throughout the other acts, however, the player is sometimes given control of the other characters, choosing dialogue options for <em>both or more</em> characters involved in the conversation. This shift of perspective is important to note for a further point on the decentralisation of power later in the essay.</p><p>KRO’s themes are too multitudinous to mention, though I will give a brief summary of its relevant themes to give the essay a sense of thematic cohesion. It is also worth briefly noting my own biases and orientation here as they are key to my interpretation of the game. Sara Ahmed explains that, “To be orientated is also to be turned toward certain objects, those that help us to find our way.” (Ahmed, 2006) and so my touchstones will be inextricably linked to my experience as a Polish immigrant in England; as a cisgendered, heterosexual man; as Player One; and as someone who’s family life and relationship with masculinity is complicated. It goes without saying that Conway’s found family, his falling back on alcohol, and being lost to work and medical debt are themes which resonate the most with me. An interesting aspect of KRO’s critique of capitalism is the Hard Times Distillery, a whiskey distillery which seems to entirely employ skeletons. Conway becomes indebted to the Distillery by accident, his body turning skeletal bit by bit until he is finally taken away into the night to work off his debt. Here, the game reproduces masculinity and I call on Connell’s <em>Masculinities </em>again to back up my claim. Connell explains that complicity is one of the aspects of masculinity. Very few men actually fit the standard of hegemonic masculinity, but the majority of men benefit from its subordination of women; “Marriage, fatherhood and community life often involve extensive compromises with women rather than naked domination or an uncontested display of authority.</p><p>Kentucky Route Zero is, widely, part of the “walking simulator” genre often at the target of Gamergate-aligned attacks, a genre reserved for Chess’ concept of Player Two. “Walking simulator” is a derisive and mocking title, suggesting that the game is mechanically simplistic, without challenge, and not even a <em>game</em>. This again calls into view the tribalism of Player One versus Player Two; Chess explains that denigrating casual games as “feminine” creates a power hierarchy where the masculine is superior and the feminine is inferior. We can likewise link this to another of Connell’s aspects of masculinity: marginalization, that is, “The interplay of gender with other structures such as class and race.”. Any game which challenges masculinity is therefore deemed lesser, inferior, a walking simulator. This leaves an interesting space, however, as we begin to classify KRO as a game for Player One or Player Two. It is not an action game, it does not ask for time commitment, or for grand displays of skill. But… KRO is not a “positive and pleasant fiction”, and it definitely does not fall in line with Chess’ examples like “Kim Kardashian: Hollywood”, or “Hungry Babes Mania” (Chess, 2017). In that case, I ask, who is KRO <em>for? </em>Considering both P1 and P2 are designed identities, they are not fully representative of the people they claim to represent. It is nonetheless interesting to ask who the development team saw as their target demographic when neither demographic seems a natural fit.</p><p>This is where my analysis of KRO as a game challenging the male domain begins. That KRO is not easily classifiable as for Player One or Player Two seems a conscious decision in a post-Gamergate world, rejecting the notion that games should be either-or. Where we can posit that most video games are affirmative of heterosexuality, that they rely on the player’s prowess and invite the player to exert control over their mechanics, I want to use dramaturgical theories of identity to make the claim that KRO actively challenges those assumptions. Erving Goffman opens with the statement that “… there is the popular view that the individual offers his performance and puts on his show ‘for the benefit of other people.” (Goffman, 1959) and this is certainly reflected in one of the first dialogue choices the player can make. Conway needs to access a computer so that he may find directions to 5 Dogwood Drive, though things are never so simple. The computer’s owner, Joseph, can’t remember the password and instead tells us to “feel it out”; tells us that it’s “something poetic”. When accessing the computer, the player is presented with three choices:</p><blockquote><strong>CONWAY</strong>: <em>(Typing.)</em> Wheels slide loose.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>CONWAY</strong>: <em>(Typing.)</em> The stars drop away.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>CONWAY</strong>: <em>(Typing.) </em>I talk and listen to him talking.” (Annapurna Interactive, 2013)</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pp3OBhVUylQT07BS7-iBuA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kentucky Route Zero, 2013.</figcaption></figure><p>These are, of course, purely for show and purely for the benefit of the player. Any one of the three choices takes the player to the next screen. This is an interesting reflection on masculine play; if masculine play is about exerting control, the game gives it up freely. It engages in a moment of co-authorship with the player, appeasing them as one would a child. Calling back to the link between the gamer identity and neoliberalism, I ask: If neoliberalism is about personal achievement, can you attribute a systemic success to the individual?</p><p>The fifth and final act of KRO asks the player to relinquish control of the characters the player has been in control of up until this point. Where GG called into question the masculinist tendencies of the industry, I suggest that GG’s fallout had a clear, noticeable effect on KRO’s structure considering the fifth act came out a significant period of time after GG’s peak. If one key aspect of masculinity is hegemony, that is, “the successful claim to authority, more than direct violence, … (though violence often underpins or supports authority)” (Connell, 2005), then the games industry’s focus on violent conflict resolution and modes of engagement <em>is </em>hegemonic as players spend the majority of their time inflicting violence. Non-violent modes of play <em>do</em> exist, but they do not have the successful claim to authority that violence does. I would also like to call on Jesper Juul’s <em>The Art of Failure</em>, in which he makes the claim that playing video games is “pain spiked with pleasure” (Juul, 2013). Juul makes this statement about games with a fail-state and games which the player can get better at. Again, this is an innocuous prerequisite considering the state of the industry and further cements KRO as a game challenging hegemony. It does not have a fail state. There are no scores. There are no means of getting better. We must consider what failure means in this case — I do not want to quickly disregard Juul’s argument as parts of his core paradox ring true in the case of KRO:</p><blockquote>“This is the paradox of failure in games. It can be stated like this:</blockquote><blockquote>1. We generally avoid failure.</blockquote><blockquote>2. We experience failure when playing games.</blockquote><blockquote>3. We seek out games, although we will experience something that we normally avoid.” (Juul, 2013)</blockquote><p>Coming back to the question of my orientation towards KRO, it certainly feels appropriate to say that I would generally avoid situations which draw attention to a man’s body being claimed by vice and unjust employment.</p><p>A question I would like to consider but not necessarily have the answer to, is one concerning agency. If an aspect of masculine play is exerting one’s will over the game and making the game satisfy one’s demands, KRO is already challenging those expectations. There are no game-changing choices to be made, nor is there any potential to change the flow of the game’s narrative. What does agency really mean if the players choices are already pre-written and expected? A definition used by Daniel Muriel and Garry Crawford explains that “… agency is defined as what transforms reality one way or another, and, politically, as what … operates within the framework outlined by … neoliberalism.” (Muriel and Crawford, 2020) There is a link to be made here between neoliberalism and the “tech-masculinity” explained earlier in the essay — mastery over a system, personal responsibility and achievement, and control. KRO indeed offers dialogue choices to make, thus allowing the player to transform the game’s reality and appeasing the neoliberal tendencies of masculine play. The choices have no greater effect on the narrative, however, and so the “agency” feels superficial. This could be said of most games until procedural generation technology allows for true expressions of agency. It is an interesting tangent to consider in this essay regarding masculine play.</p><p>By Act 5, Conway has been tragically enveloped by debt and alcoholism. His last job, the goal the player has been pursuing for the game’s length, is taken over by the friends Conway made along the way. When the group finally arrive at 5 Dogwood Drive they find it flooded and destroyed, only a handful of survivors left to pick their lives back up. The player’s view is affixed high above the village and they have no choice but to relinquish control over the characters’ lives. What follows is a slow and thoughtful rebuilding of the village in memoriam of the people who are no longer there. Vignettes play throughout the village and we’re left with no choice but to watch. This direct wrangling of control from the player is not only a direct statement against hegemony but could also be extended to a greater statement in opposition of neoliberalism. 5 Dogwood Drive is not rebuilt by a singular agent acting out their self-determination while everyone stands by. The work the player has put in getting the group to this point is reflected on by the game’s insistence on letting the player rest. The community grows and rebuilds, together, unguided. Where the player has guided them before, the group no longer needs guidance as they self-actualise and break free from self-interest and instead act in the interest of the community.</p><h3>CONCLUSION</h3><p>Throughout the essay I have drawn a thread connecting the initial creation of the gamer identity, its unsavoury connotations, the shocking events of Gamergate, and how those events led up to the attack on the Capitol Building. I then tried to apply this masculine, neoliberal identity to Kentucky Route Zero to find points of contention. There, it turned out that Kentucky Route Zero was largely incompatible with the gamer identity, going as far as to fully shed any association with it by the very end. Trying to analyse a game which does not directly address masculinity was a difficult task, one which resulted in some slightly contrived arguments which needed a lot of set up. Nonetheless, we can extrapolate many of these findings and apply them to the “walking simulator” genre at large — games which try to challenge masculine notions of play, notions of control, and notions of mastery. It is also worth ending on the note that what this game did in reacting to the events of Gamergate would simply be impossible in games of larger teams and budgets. Independent publishing allows for experimentation but is ultimately (and unfortunately) ineffectual in challenging hegemony and authority. Profit lies in the expected and cements its successful claim to authority. In terms of answering both parts of the question, I explored how masculinity is <em>not </em>reproduced in Kentucky Route Zero, it instead choosing to challenge the neoliberal assumptions that underlie theories of masculinity. As a result, I also uncovered further questions of agency and control, ones that would be a good fit for a future dissertation project. Likewise, I also explored a brief history of gamer identity-making and how those appeals to masculinity could be argued to have had violent consequences. The combination of the two, I claim, lead to Kentucky Route Zero, a game which seems to wholeheartedly reject common conceptions of masculine play.</p><h3>BIBLIOGRAPHY</h3><p>Ahmed, S. 2006. <em>Queer Phenomenology: Orientations, Objects, Others</em> [Online]. Duke University Press. [Accessed 10 March 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv125jk6w.">http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv125jk6w.</a></p><p>Annapurna Interactive 2013. <em>Kentucky Route Zero</em>.</p><p>Anon n.d. This is Not a Game: How Steam Harbors Extremists. <em>Anti-Defamation League</em>. [Online]. [Accessed 16 July 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.adl.org/steamextremism.">https://www.adl.org/steamextremism.</a></p><p>Bogost, I. 2008. The Rhetoric of Video Games <em>In</em>:, pp.117–139.</p><p>Chess, S. 2017. <em>Ready Player Two: Women Gamers and Designed Identity</em>. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.</p><p>Chess, S. and Shaw, A. 2015. A Conspiracy of Fishes, or, How We Learned to Stop Worrying About #GamerGate and Embrace Hegemonic Masculinity. <em>Journal of Broadcasting &amp; Electronic Media</em>. <strong>59</strong>(1), pp.208–220.</p><p>Connell, R. 2005. <em>Masculinities</em> Second Edition. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.</p><p>Goffman, E. 1959. <em>The presentation of self in everyday life</em>. New York: Anchor Books.</p><p>Jennifer deWinter and Carly Kocurek 2012. Rescuing Anita: Games, Gamers, and the Battle of the Sexes. [Accessed 16 July 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://www.flowjournal.org/2012/12/rescuing-anita/">https://www.flowjournal.org/2012/12/rescuing-anita/.</a></p><p>Juul, J. 2013. <em>The Art of Failure: An essay on the pain of playing video games</em>. The MIT Press.</p><p>Kim, A. 2021. Gamifying Terror — the Alt-Right’s Video Game Infiltration. [Accessed 13 July 2021]. Available from: <a href="http://uchicagogate.com/articles/2021/2/25/gamifying-terror-alt-rights-video-game-infiltration/">http://uchicagogate.com/articles/2021/2/25/gamifying-terror-alt-rights-video-game-infiltration/.</a></p><p>Kocurek, C.A. 2015. <em>Coin-Operated Americans: Rebooting Boyhood at the Video Game Arcade</em>. Minnesota: University of Minnesota Press.</p><p>McLuhan, M. 2001. <em>Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man</em>. London: Routledge.</p><p>Muriel, D. and Crawford, G. 2020. Video Games and Agency in Contemporary Society. <em>Games and Culture</em>. <strong>15</strong>, p.1555412017750448.</p><p>Rising serpent 🇺🇸 2021. What symbol is that? <a href="https://t.co/BE1nkaRiOk.">https://t.co/BE1nkaRiOk.</a> <em>@rising_serpent</em>. [Online]. [Accessed 16 July 2021]. Available from: <a href="https://twitter.com/rising_serpent/status/1346911882108522499.">https://twitter.com/rising_serpent/status/1346911882108522499.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fcccb3f89771" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hope for the future: a critical assessment of the Peace Journalism project]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eryk.sawicki/hope-for-the-future-a-critical-assessment-of-the-peace-journalism-project-dd27528a9acf?source=rss-557bca14fb9f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd27528a9acf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pacifism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conflict]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eryk Sawicki]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Jan 2021 13:04:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-22T23:56:58.598Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My reason for choosing to write about Peace Journalism was twofold: firstly, a personal conviction and slow lean towards pacifism and the rejection of violence as a whole. Secondly, the dissonance that arises from accepting violence as the last-resort tool of the politically repressed and unrepresented; be it the French Revolution, the Civil Rights Movement, or Pride. What better way to combat this dissonance than by delving into the first step of Peace Research: the way we talk about war and peace. There are two ways of approaching the question of Peace Journalism: the normative question asks whether journalists <em>should </em>try to stop war, and the empirical question which asks<em> if</em> journalists can stop war. This critical evaluation of the Peace Journalism project will take four parts: firstly, I will set the background and give context around the project and introduce the prominent voices on the subject. Then, I will explore the application of Peace Journalism as an analytical framework by taking aspects from Robert Entman’s Framing Theory. By using Seow Ting Lee and Crispin Maslog’s work in developing Peace and War journalism “frames” one can devise a framework through which to analyse journalism posthumously. This will attempt to answer the empirical question. Of course, Peace Journalism is not without its fair share of criticism; thus, I will spend the third section of this essay responding to critics who argue that Peace Journalism is simply “good journalism”. The final chapter will be an attempt at using Thomas Hanitzsch’s work to place peace journalism within the realm of public communications and making it <em>feasible</em>. That is, addressing structural concerns of journalists worried about implementing it in their work, and a brief overview of contemporary peace journalism regarding civil issues like the Black Lives Matter movement. This will attempt to answer the normative question.</p><h4>A History of Peace Journalism</h4><p>The seed of Peace Journalism was first brought to light by Johan Galtung in a 1965 paper coauthored with Mari Holmboe Ruge. They ask: “…how do events become news?” (Galtung and Ruge, 1965), and speak of “…collective perception, where perception is made on behalf of others to be relayed to these others later…” (Galtung and Ruge, 1965). These ideas and questions were then developed, outlined, and interrogated through the years. Jake Lynch and Annabel McGoldrick put to paper the tenets of peace journalism in 2001, and that will be the base document for this essay. The key takeaway being that Peace Journalism (PJ) is a departure from the commonly held belief that journalists just report the facts; rather, PJ is the push for journalists to stop reporting <em>reactively </em>on the narrative established by government or military sources. Instead, PJ encourages journalists to step back and always ask: “what is the best method of achieving peace?”. The authors state that “facts do not crop up innocently, waiting for journalists to discover and report them” (McGoldrick and Lynch, 2001); it is a call for more nuanced and accurate discourse, calling on the author’s holistic understanding of the conflict at hand. It is a call for journalists to interrogate the sources they get information from and understand the benefits (not necessarily to the journalists themselves) of pushing the official government party line. As previously mentioned, PJ is by all means a <em>normative </em>theory (and so has attracted a variety of criticisms) — it is mostly concerned with the ethical and moral values expected of journalists and posits that journalists should <em>try </em>to stop war.</p><p>Amongst behaviours that Peace Journalists should strive for is a mindset shift away from framing conflicts as us-vs-them, or as black-and-white. The framing should divide conflict participants into smaller groups all wanting their own outcomes, opening the way for more creative reporting. To aid this, journalists are advised to avoid othering language, and language which demonizes or victimizes certain peoples. When reporting violence, journalists should avoid concentrating on the visible effects (like body counts), and instead focus on the longlasting damage (like psychological trauma, or economic and sociological effects). Moreover, violence should not be reported in a vacuum — if all we see is violence, the sensible assumption to make would be that violence is always in reaction to previous acts of violence, or that violence is an acceptable retort. Most importantly, the journalist should pick up and assess peace initiatives regardless of where they come from and put them forward to officials; be they from grassroot organisations or civilians, and even if the ideas go against the established narrative. All that is not to say that the journalist should not take sides — “I am willing to humanize all sides but I’m not willing to legitimize all goals.” (Galtung, 2000) — I argue that journalists <em>should </em>take sides and <em>should </em>use their platforms for the prevention of war. To say that journalists should remain detached from the things they report denies them humanity; it leaves them unfeeling and dispassionate. Criticisms pointed at PJ often target this very idea; where this (admittedly, civilly minded) author would posit journalism as a means of war prevention a noble application of one’s skills and the example of citizenry, critics oft argue that the role of journalists is simply to portray facts and let their readers make an opinion. These criticisms will be addressed later on.</p><blockquote>“I am willing to humanize all sides but I’m not willing to legitimize all goals.” (Galtung, 2000)</blockquote><h4>Peace Journalism as an Analytical Framework</h4><p>A key point of required background for this section of the essay is Entman’s “Framing Theory”, devised in 1993. The theory states that “to frame is to select some aspects of a perceived reality and make them more salient in a communicating text” (Entman, 1993). Taking this idea, Jake Lynch and Annabel McGoldrick devised War Journalism and Peace Journalism frames that they could then use to conduct research with; the same event portrayed with both frames to several groups of research participants. This way, Lynch and McGoldrick were able to capture people’s reactions to both portrayals of the same event and quantify the emotional impact of both. There is, of course, an assumption that a simple dyadic split can capture all the intricacies and ideological differences between journalists and their chosen way of framing their reporting.</p><p>The research found that viewers of war journalism “showed significantly higher increases in feelings of astonishment, revulsion, contempt, distaste, anger, disdain, scorn, and downheartedness…” (McGoldrick and Lynch, 2001). While an encouraging finding, the research was not able to tell what effect the audience’s understanding of the situation had on their want for a peaceful outcome. For example, one would find it difficult to say if the research participants would still support the pulling out of Western troops from Afghanistan if they knew that this would leave the repressive Taliban in charge. There is an interesting sidenote to make here: Galtung defined a difference between the pursuit of Peace and the pursuit of Justice. He claims that “[our purpose] in #peacepractice is to solve societal conundrums non-violently. Theirs is to identify &amp; assign guilt &amp; punishment.” (Galtung, 2021a) While the fault of the research here lies in a lack of conclusion (the point of PJ is to report events in their context, and so the research participants should have been briefed), arguably that is beyond the work of PJ. Pulling out Western troops from Afghanistan would be the non-violent end that PJ strives for; ensuring the needs of the Taliban and the Afghans are met would be the work of restorative justice. Galtung argues that “if we MUST decide on chronology, it is NEEDS first then RIGHTS.” (Galtung, 2021b) This is indeed backed up by the research: Lynch and McGoldrick found that explanations of context and background led to audiences defining problems in <em>structures </em>rather than any one actor, and seeking <em>justice </em>rather than deterrence or punishment.</p><p>Lee and Maslog’s paper titled “War or Peace Journalism?” takes the idea of PJ as an analytical framework further and serves as the base for other academics going forward. Their closing statement concludes that studies around Framing Theory so far have “neglected to explore framing as a conscious act by journalists.” (Lee and Maslog, 2005) This raises questions that have likewise been asked by academics: what are the systemic blocks stopping salaried journalists from applying these frames despite being aware of them? Taken further, are these <em>systemic </em>blocks, or is PJ simply unattractive to journalists? Is PJ’s analytical background confusing journalists and proving to be an inaccessible way of framing their reporting? Follow-up research conducted by Shahira Fahmy and Britain Eakin used the frames established by Lee and Maslog to compare reporting on the Mavi Marmara incident. For context, the incident saw a sea vessel belonging to the Free Gaza Movement boarded by the Israeli Defence Force (IDF). Reports are largely conflicting; the IDF claims they opened fire in self-defence whereas the passengers and official investigations suggest a different series of events. The main sources they analysed were The New York Times, The Guardian, and the Israeli Haaretz. The surprising finding was that the Haaretz employed both peace and war journalism frames more than its non-Israeli counterparts (Fahmy and Eakin, 2014). However, this could be interpreted as accidental: while the reporting fell into war and peace journalism frames, there was little of the solution-seeking that Peace Journalism suggests. Framing Theory is, after all, focused on the unconscious and these studies are assigning war and peace frames “posthumously”. The authors acknowledge that “…framing studies have neglected to explore framing as a conscious act by journalists.” One could infer from these findings that the locality of each paper plays a part in its journalist’s reporting: the Haaretz was building on a base of historical context it would expect its readership to have, whereas the Guardian and the New York Times would both have to pick its frames carefully to construct a story someone unacquainted with the Palestine/Israel situation would find engaging. It is the paper’s final statement that the categories borrowed from Lee and Maslog’s research need adapting to specific conflicts.</p><h4>Peace Journalism as “Good Journalism”</h4><p>These previous pieces of research have a common thread running through them: that Peace Journalism is simply “Good Journalism”. That is, the frames and tenets of Peace Journalism are ones that all journalists should be following. While that may sound complementary at first glance, some academics use that as a point of criticism, dismissing the extraneous cognitive load from their already stressful jobs. There is a school of thought which argues for journalism being an “objective” vocation — though the journalist David Loyn in an online article published 2003, argues that presenting each conflict as a network of past events would “have every viewer or listener reaching for the off button.” (Loyn, 2003) This feels an unfair assessment to make, however, as surely every person seeking out such news would appreciate the extra context over a watered-down, simplified version of events. Indeed, Lynch challenges those who try to champion ideas of “truth” and “objectivity” against PJ. Peace Journalism is, in no way, against those principles. He attacks Loyn directly by claiming that simply gathering two accounts of an event does not make an “objective” story (Lynch, 2007). Every piece of reporting has a process of framing that is “inevitable in journalism — some facts are allowed through the gate, others kept out.” (Lynch, 2007) Lynch likewise makes a jab at opponents of PJ by claiming they “dislike the critical self-awareness of journalistic structure and agency inscribed in peace journalism analysis and methods” (Lynch, 2007). Indeed, it is curious the attitude Loyn’s statement betrays towards his work: are journalists in the business of people-pleasing, or sharing the news in their most comprehensive forms? Loyn’s criticisms seem misguided; taking us back to Galtung’s quote “I am willing to humanize all sides but I’m not willing to legitimize all goals.” (Galtung, 2000), which shows us that the core intent of PJ is not to editorialise or conceal, it is simply to avoid violence and seek peaceful resolutions to conflicts so that the needs of the people can be met, and justice established.</p><p>Loyn rebukes many of these criticisms in a follow-up article stating that “it is the responsibility of journalism to reflect the voices of the powerless, but on their own merits… not because the reporter takes a position promoting their views.” (Loyn, 2007) This is a fair argument to make — but it supposes that PJ asks journalists to pick a point, any point, and run with it. At risk of overusing, it is worth looking back to the Galtung quote: Peace Journalism does not ask journalists to promote <em>any </em>view, but the view of those who are powerless and helping them change the world. It seems fallacious to suggest that those who have merit are capable of changing their world or, at least, their own situation. It is, possibly, a naïve position to think that the world benefits those who already have merit, and it is the role of journalists, amongst others, to make the world better for those who do not have merit (whatever it may be) by shining a light towards their situations. Loyn likewise argues that he wants to give people the materials to make peace, rather than make peace. It is unclear what the difference between the two is in his mind; he claims that the “only USP of conventional ‘mainstream media’ is impartiality, and we kick out the props from under us if we lose that.” Lynch’s previous reply seems apt here again — it seems that Loyn is averse to self-awareness, and to reading about the very theory he is arguing against. How could one stay impartial in the face of radical hatred? Is silence not a form of complicity? Loyn seemingly rejects framing theory and refuses to accept his work as anything less than impartial.</p><h4>Making Peace Journalism Feasible</h4><p>To figure out a way of making PJ feasible, we first have to look at the bigger picture of public communications to see where it fits. Not only that, but journalists themselves need to figure out where they want their work to fall. Luckily, Thomas Hanitszch has already laid the groundwork for this classification. He divides public communication into a 4-axis matrix of fact vs fiction, and internal vs external leaving us with four distinct areas: journalism, public relations, entertainment, and advertising (Hanitzsch, 2007). The y axis of fact vs fiction represents the primary information value of the piece, whereas the x axis of internal vs external represents the communication goals. For example, a piece classified as “external” and “factual” would fall under Public Relations, an “external” and “fictional” piece is Advertising, and “internal” and “factual” is Journalism. Hanitszch goes on to say that “Journalists select and judge information which produces an inevitably contingent media reality.” (Hanitzsch, 2007) For clarity, “contingent” in this context relates to the philosophical and rhetorical concept of contingent statements; that is, statements that could be true or false depending on the state of the world. I could say that the sun will rise tomorrow, but that is entirely contingent on the sun existing <em>to rise</em>. Hanitszch explains that there are two approaches to PJ: those who hark back to the idea of Peace Journalism as “Good Journalism”, and those who believe in interventionist peace journalism. In this case, the interventionist school of thought is much closer to Public Relations on his matrix and might even cross the line when choosing to engage in conflict resolution. Journalists willing to embrace the PJ project have to decide where their work lands on this spectrum. The spectrum in itself is not prescriptive, but it does serve as a good guide for selfawareness, allowing journalists to easily reference the matrix and ask themselves “Who benefits from this?” Rather disappointingly, Hanitzsch ends his piece by asking, “what kind of society do we live in that allows and creates a sort of journalism that has no sense of peace?” (Hanitzsch, 2007) Looking at this statement from the perspective of interventionist PJ, criticising society for being disaffected with a system our form of journalism is trying to combat seems self-defeatist. Empirically speaking, Peace Journalism may not be able to single-handedly stop war, but society is a self-propagating meme; every cog has an effect on its mechanism, no matter how small.</p><p>There are, of course, structural problems that hold back journalists from diving in headfirst into conflict-preventative methods. Using the media landscape of the UK as example, tabloid print would be unlikely to ever be interested in appropriating the methods of PJ. The people within the company who might be interested likewise would lack any significant sway required to change the system structurally. Likewise, even if certain parties were willing to entertain adopting the frames of PJ, it is undoubtedly a less cost-effective means of reporting. Journalists will have to be more experienced, more knowledgeable, and more specialised than before. This, of course, is more expensive. The question then becomes: how do we support journalism? Website paywalls are the easiest option but limiting access to information is ethically unsound when we consider that this information is crucial to maintaining peace. Pricing out the poor (those who are, unfortunately, the most likely to be affected by the information within) is a direct form of violence.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Overall, the attitudes towards Peace Journalism held by critics are surprising; they often fail to address points that proponents have already argued against and lack certain good faith in their arguments. There is a difference in ethics at the core of the Peace Journalism debate: that journalists should <em>try </em>to stop war, that they should <em>try </em>to lift up the unheard and the unnoticed, that they should <em>try </em>to seek peace, above all. Opponents of Peace Journalism seem to take issue with this central tenet rather than the ideas posited by Galtung, Lynch, McGoldrick, or any of the others that have since added to the debate. When Lynch and McGoldrick’s research found that those exposed to Peace Journalism found their spirits lifted, imbued with hope, and seeking systemic reform over punishment, one wonders what ground opponents have to stand on. Indeed, Peace Journalism might feel at first glance (as it did to me) a display of conviction-less bothsidesism, though it is clear that that is not the case. Peace Journalism is merely a piece of the puzzle of Peace Research — it is the beginning step that leads on to restorative justice and equity. Those who argue against Peace Journalism as simply “Good Journalism” likewise seem unable to put forward unconvincing arguments. If PJ is just simply good journalism, why is there so much opposition to the term? It seems that some opponents take issue with the semantics of calling it Peace Journalism and take offense at acknowledging their own framing processes. An exercise in posturing, keen to hold up a veneer of “objectivity”. This is understandable in some ways; Peace Journalism asks journalists to be acutely aware <em>and </em>critical of their own biases, ways of working, and corporate allegiances.</p><h4>Bibliography</h4><p>Entman, R.M. 1993. Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm. Journal of Communication. 43(4), pp.51–58.</p><p>Fahmy, S. and Eakin, B. 2014. High drama on the high seas:Peace versus war journalism framing of an Israeli/Palestinian-related incident. International Communication Gazette. 76(1), pp.86–105.</p><p>Galtung, J. 2000. The Task of Peace Journalism. Ethical Perspectives. 7, pp.162–164.</p><p>Galtung, J. 2021a. An essential difference between Peace work &amp; Justice work:…. <a href="https://twitter.com/JohanGaltung/status/1345711959145132034?s=20.">https://twitter.com/JohanGaltung/status/1345711959145132034?s=20.</a> 03/01/2021. [Twitter]. [Accessed 03/01/2020].</p><p>Galtung, J. 2021b. Ha. You know my answer. BOTH-AND. At the same time. But if we MUST decide on chronology, it is…. <a href="https://twitter.com/JohanGaltung/status/1345716254229856257?s=20.">https://twitter.com/JohanGaltung/status/1345716254229856257?s=20.</a> 03/01/2021. [Twitter]. [Accessed 03/01/2021].</p><p>Galtung, J. and Ruge, M.H. 1965. The Structure of Foreign News:The Presentation of the Congo, Cuba and Cyprus Crises in Four Norwegian Newspapers. Journal of Peace Research. 2(1), pp.64–90.</p><p>Hanitzsch, T. 2007. Situating peace journalism in journalism studies: A critical appraisal. Conflict &amp; communication online. 6(2), pp.1–9.</p><p>Lee, S.T. and Maslog, C.C. 2005. War or Peace Journalism? Asian Newspaper Coverage of Conflicts. Journal of Communication. 55(2), pp.311–329.</p><p>Loyn, D. 2003. Witnessing the Truth. [Online]. Available from: <a href="https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/article_993jsp/">https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/article_993jsp/</a></p><p>Loyn, D. 2007. Good journalism or peace journalism? Conflict &amp; communication online. 6(2), pp.1–10.</p><p>Lynch, J. 2007. Peace Journalism and its discontents. Conflict &amp; communication online. 6(2), pp.1- 13.</p><p>McGoldrick, A. and Lynch, J. 2001. What is Peace Journalism? Activate. (Winter 2001)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd27528a9acf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[July round-up: gaming’s interesting stories]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eryk.sawicki/july-round-up-gamings-interesting-stories-c1ec2dc68b56?source=rss-557bca14fb9f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c1ec2dc68b56</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[video-games-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heterotopia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roundup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-news]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eryk Sawicki]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Jul 2020 17:45:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-29T17:45:36.124Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>July round-up: gaming’s most interesting stories</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rnAI5FKXHhl2BUMzz6Lpbg.png" /></figure><p>July has flown past: I returned to work from furlough. <a href="http://rollwithit.events/">Roll With It</a> saw its first booking, and then two more. I applied for an MA on a whim. A very passionate, this-is-what-I-want-to-do kind of whim.</p><p>Writing this round-up is part of a process: I’m trying to find my <em>thing. </em>As far as voice is concerned, I’m on alright terms with mine. It’s a bit rough and my sentences sometimes get really fucking unwieldy and don’t roll off the tongue as well as they could but I’m getting there. My partner is a fantastic editor.</p><p>There’s pieces I’ve read over the past month that really have a <em>thing</em> pinned down. A closer examination of the political scenario surrounding Palestine, Israel, and how it influenced Last of Us 2 director Neil Druckmann is an enlightening read.</p><p><a href="https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/bv8da4/the-not-so-hidden-israeli-politics-of-the-last-of-us-part-ii?fbclid=IwAR2_-oxuqvcdatNqf2qAUetQvPr_nal2McMhy9OeGtK8q93Px8sf38TRIFE">The Not So Hidden Israeli Politics of &#39;The Last of Us Part II&#39;</a></p><p>The Last of Us 2 tries its hand at some odd bothsidesism. Its two factions — the militant, self-sustaining Wolves and religious, self-sustaining Scars — are embroiled in a conflict the game’s insurmountably nihilistic worldview deems necessary. The Wolf leader, Isaac, tortures a man and whispers on the grapevine speak of the Wolves killing a child. The Scars… hang people, rip out their intestines, and make flowery euphemisms about it all.</p><p>Maiberg’s article draws an important comparison: Druckmann’s experiences of growing up in Israel have unsubtly informed his reading of conflict as a part of human nature, and of the way he’s written about the Scars and Wolves.</p><p>Another piece goes into the architectural inspiration of Kane &amp; Lynch 2’s Shanghai.</p><p><a href="http://www.heterotopiaszine.com/">Heterotopias | games + architecture</a></p><p>Heterotopias — coming from Foucault’s writing on worlds within worlds; spaces that disturb, reflect, and contradict — is a fascinating exploration of digital spaces, and a zine committed to paying its contributors (!).</p><p>Issue 001 might contain one of the only favourable readings of Kane &amp; Lynch 2: Dog Days out there. An interview with Rasmus Poulsen, Art Director, sheds light on the development team’s scouting trip to Shanghai — complete with reference photos — while zine editor Gareth Damian Martin complements the piece with 35mm photos taken of the game on his screen. It sounds a little pretentious, and it kinda is.</p><p>Dog Days opens with a strong image: an unfocused shot of a camcorder pointed at Kane &amp; Lynch getting the absolute daylights beaten out of them. Another harsh, nihilistic view of violence. It makes sense, then, for Martin to follow the logic of Dog Days’ presentation and record a recording of a recording.</p><p>Another piece of work — this time a video essay — continues the streak of reflections on violence (and, unintentionally, also talking about Kane &amp; Lynch).</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FW4TNu0oBtKs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DW4TNu0oBtKs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FW4TNu0oBtKs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/429d06ab0788b57f63621e0ac9826477/href">https://medium.com/media/429d06ab0788b57f63621e0ac9826477/href</a></iframe><p>Jacob Geller views Max Payne 3 and the two installments of Kane &amp; Lynch through the lens of Artaud’s “Theatre of Cruelty” — a form of theatre designed to shock the senses. With its intention to upset, Kane &amp; Lynch is an undeniably successful piece of work that paid the price. Sales-wise it was a failure. Max Payne 3 saw the opposite result; its ugliness was polished but it was never enough to fully jolt its audience.</p><p>So far, these articles have covered architecture, theatre, and politics. All items to cross off my list of <em>things. </em>It’s cool: I wouldn’t have known where to start with them anyway. The search continues.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fembed%2Fplaylist%2F3Bb0c8ShzoKC1966nuYWul&amp;display_name=Spotify&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fplaylist%2F3Bb0c8ShzoKC1966nuYWul&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmosaic.scdn.co%2F300%2Fab67616d0000b273580ffe579b32f1e6a93ac225ab67616d0000b273d900c117313f845f61dd629bab67616d0000b273e6e7036545c528f7396273baab67616d0000b273eaf51925f9dde8f871647b24&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=spotify" width="300" height="380" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f70eac0aa7f95adc6d42fd8f12b629ca/href">https://medium.com/media/f70eac0aa7f95adc6d42fd8f12b629ca/href</a></iframe><h3>This month’s round-up was written to…</h3><p>Cassius’ pop electronica album Ibifornia is just so <em>fun. </em>The 9-minute <em>Go Up </em>rises to heights the descent from which is a straight up certified bop.</p><p>The deep bass of Flower and Be Again reflects those sweat-soaked firefights in this month’s titles’ dark alleyways.</p><p>Feel Like Me, Comeback Kid, and Hiroshima are more triumphant, then, as I hope next month’s reading moves away from the violent, male-oriented stories.</p><p>Let me know in the comments about your favourite articles from this month!</p><figure><a href="https://ko-fi.com/eryksawicki"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5b19Qv14UKOi8DykQNq3bQ@2x.png" /></a></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c1ec2dc68b56" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Boring Games]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@eryk.sawicki/boring-games-e8c4ffdc3b58?source=rss-557bca14fb9f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e8c4ffdc3b58</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[disco-elysium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-games-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[outer-wilds]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eryk Sawicki]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Jun 2020 11:33:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-02T15:01:03.587Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Non-violent games and why you should play them: Part 1</h3><p>When people look over my shoulder while I’m playing a video game I feel a slight tinge of embarrassment. It’s an odd, reflexive impulse that probably stems back to my parents. The impulse is irrelevant: the games industry is the largest media industry worldwide. Gaming is <em>cool</em>. Or, at least, it’s part of the zeitgeist.</p><p>During lockdown I’ve had a lot of time to catch up on the games I’ve missed. My partner will look over my shoulder and ask: “what’s this one about?”. I’ve saved the galaxy in Mass Effect, did a bit of father-son bonding in God of War, and some father-daughter bonding in The Last of Us. I became Outer Wilds Ventures’ newest recruit.</p><p>I took over the Federal Bureau of Control in… Control.</p><p>I enjoyed Control — it threw me back to reading the SCP Foundation in high school. Spooky copy-pastas and amateurish horror stories; baby’s-first-photoshop and baby’s-first-audacity projects.</p><p>Control’s team threw themselves into a supernatural America and realised it perfectly. Their redacted reports of a ███████ in ████ were uncomfortably prescient. This was, clearly, baby’s-<em>thousandth</em>.</p><p>Its tightly designed. It feeds into your fear of the Men in Black. The game pitches you against fast, flying enemies and pushes you to keep moving with a quickly depleting health bar and health <em>drops</em> dropping aplenty.</p><p>With my friends I played Killing Floor. Killing Floor is a fever dream: you’re locked in carnival grounds, abandoned hospitals, mines, and tunnels, and heavy metal blasts at volumes deserving of an occupational hazard advance. It’s by design though: it’s <em>numbing</em>. You shoot enemies in the head with <em>style</em> and in <em>slow-motion </em>— this was baby’s-thousandth — and a Black lady with an oh-so-British accent encourages you to buy more *lovely big guns*. “It’s satire!” the crowds shout. <em>Sure.</em></p><p>I had a good time with God of War too. I remember some mild outrage at the time — we (the royal we, <em>gamers</em>) were <em>very</em> mad that the titular God of War was no longer God of Shagging Owt That Moves. He was a dad now. He’d grown up.</p><h3></h3><p></p><p>With him, the games industry had grown up too. <em>Kind of</em>. We don’t tell stories of the inordinate shag now, you see, we tell stories about absent fathers. Mothers? 🤷‍♂️ They were there, probably, but we’d missed the door slamming for the ideal of working in the industry — an industry notoriously unkind to its 28% female-identifying workers(UK Games Industry Census — understanding diversity in the UK games industry workforce | Ukie, 2020).</p><p>God of War is tightly designed, too. The camera punches in when you behead and carve flesh asunder — this was baby’s thousandth — and your axe<em>,</em> <em>lovely big axe,</em> freezes the poor soul on the receiving end. It’s all very glorious.</p><p>In the 18 years I’ve been playing video games, most haven’t changed. Their verbs are mostly the same: shooting, running, climbing, and so on. If you play nothing but the biggest releases, you’d be led to believe that anything short of masterpiece is not worth playing; that that’s all there is to gaming. It’s a monopoly, and we have to be wary of it.</p><p>The recent <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8apW-UFhGZg">PS5 reveal event</a> featured a staggering 65% of games that were based on violence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*c3gUAMfcen-fcg48" /></figure><p>The non-violent section is made up of Sackboy: A Big Adventure, the latest NBA entry, Astro’s Playroom, and Gran Turismo. In the “Hard to tell” section is Pragmata, which I would imagine will be violent but it’s… <em>hard to tell</em> from the trailer shown. We’ll see how Stray, Goodbye Volcano High, Jett: The Far Shore, and Bugsnax turn out.</p><p>The non-violent games are either sports, autosports, or platforming games with a younger target audience in mind.</p><p><em>Enough,</em> I thought, <em>I have been adequately masculated (?)</em> <em>and my girlfriend doesn’t like the loud noises.</em></p><p>So, I went and sought out the most conventionally <em>boring</em> and different games. This is part of a mindset change for me — instead of calling out the things I don’t like (ie. violence), I’ll try and sell you on these gems.</p><p>I don’t like the term “walking simulator”: it’s one I wish would leave and never return to games discourse. It’s reductive, inappropriate, and kinda old-fashioned. I’m inclined to believe anyone earnestly using that term carries around change for the arcade. And yet, here I am using “boring” as a descriptor. They’re not boring — I wouldn’t be playing them if they were! But they’ve niche appeal, low(er) budgets, and the freedom to experiment. This is where the real gold of video games is!</p><p>Thanks to itch.io’s Racial Justice bundle my library is 1,700 games stronger. This is going to be a hefty article (series?).</p><h3>Euro Truck Simulator 2</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/622/1*zBV7XQiVOVXAXKsPkYDhnA.jpeg" /></figure><p>At Gamescom 2018 I queued for nearly three hours to have a go in a hydraulic cockpit playing Euro Truck. I unironically love this game.</p><p>It’s as exciting as it sounds. You take the role of a freelance truck driver hauling freight over Europe. You start off taking contract jobs until you can afford to buy your own truck (all trucks are lovingly recreated, with most real-life manufacturers providing true-to-life models of their trucks). From there, you buy a garage, maybe another truck, maybe one of those Hula-dress figurines to go on your dashboard.</p><p>Maybe you get enough money to hire a trucker and start your own freight empire.</p><p>ETS’ Europe is massively scaled down (God forbid we got a prettier Desert Bus) — driving from Germany to Italy took me the best part of 2 hours. You’ll have to sleep, turn your blinkers on, fuel up, and slow down for toll booths. If you’re out of road, there’s downloadable expansions to add Italy, Eastern Europe, and Scandinavia to the map.</p><h4>10–8 to drain the dragon</h4><p>The true appeal of ETS, to me, comes from its customisability. If you’re dedicated to the craft, airbrakes are there. If you’re not, and you just fancy a ride down the M32 at 90mph freight-free make sure to disable traffic offences. Red light? Never met her. Fancy a bit of Jeremy Vine at 6pm? Stick on BBC Radio Two from the game’s internet radio selection.</p><p>On a job in Czechia? Plenty of country-specific radio stations too.</p><p>Nothing beats driving through the night and rain, snuggled in the soft, constant hums of your truck’s engine, and the soft glow of dashboard lights. Bonus points if you get to experience this in VR.</p><p>Out of all the games I’d played in front of my partner so far, this was the one that caught her attention the most. Did I turn the map off so she could navigate for me? <em>Possibly</em>.</p><h3>Outer Wilds</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YBVCyv6mu7Y65AETi63lPA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Outer Wilds’ opening shot is what you see when you lie in the grass and look at a clear sky. Imagine the stars overhead, and imagine yourself on a rock hurtling through space. Imagine the <em>other</em> rocks hurtling through space: home, maybe, to a kind stranger grilling a marshmallow over a campfire.</p><p>Outer Wilds is a tiny, toyish solar system bound by Newtonian physics. To appreciate Outer Wilds, you have to come to appreciate some really wild concepts at the base of space travel. The Sun at the center of Outer Wilds exerts a gravitational pull on everything — your small, cobbled-together spaceship will get flung about, victim to imperceptible galactic forces. Speed up in your spaceship and you’ll keep going. There’s no friction in space.</p><p>At its core is a compelling mechanic to keep you playing: every 20-or-so minutes, something happens to jolt you back to the start. I won’t say what it is to preserve some of the magic, but it’s grand and terrifying the first time it happens. You’ll spend the rest of your playthrough trying to stop said event, all while navigating planets that change over time. They might fall apart under their own weight, or gravity from nearby planets might change their layout.</p><h4>Roasted Marshmallows</h4><p>It’s a beautiful, eulogistic world, where other fellow astronauts settle on their planets and just… sit down for a little while. Sit by their campfire and play a little tune. You’ll approach them and tell them of their impending doom and they accept it, offering up some roasted marshmallows. There’s no fear of the future in Outer Wilds, and there’s no shame in lying in the grass to look at a clear sky.</p><p>But, despite this pull to slow down, I always felt like the game was rushing me. The Sun will fly across the horizon, throwing you into ultra-short day-night cycles, and the planets hurtle through space at dizzying speeds. Slowing down came with the guilt that I could be doing <em>more</em>, that there was always another piece of the puzzle to be found.</p><p>I’m not sure if my approach was the right one: each run I’d get distracted and fly to a new planet to find something new, rather than exhaust each planet for their clues. In the end I was left with a time sensitive task that left me waiting several minutes, and a misstep would lead to a quick death. Trying this again became somewhat of a chore. If I had something to do instead of waiting, I’m sure my endgame experience would have been kinder.</p><p>There’s a lot of humour here; the people you meet talk to you with a zany deference. <em>You </em>are the latest astronaut to leave Timber Hearth, and kids tell you they want to grow up like you. Your ship is prone to breakage. The notes you find left behind by a lost race of scientist-aliens are eager, earnest, enthusiastic, and they don’t fail to poke fun at the youngest two using an intergalactic Slack to flirt.</p><h3>Disco Elysium</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jAVtIW_eTJJOJs2zSdi58g.jpeg" /></figure><p>I find talking about Disco Elysium difficult. It’s a game so unabashedly political, so broad in the topics it broaches, and so deep in its worldbuilding that I struggle to keep up with this point-and-click-turned-visual-novel. Nonetheless, every moment I spent with Disco Elysium was an absolute joy. It embodies the best part of modern RPG design; both video game <em>and</em> tabletop. The dice rolling in the background, the ones that keep ticking everything over, always keep the action moving so failing is <em>truly</em> as satisfying as succeeding. It’s consistently made me laugh more than any game in the past ever has.</p><p>Disco Elysium’s skill system represents every dirty, creative, authoritarian, communist, and Christ-I-wish-I-had-a-cig-right-now part of your character’s mind. They’ll battle it out with one another mid-conversation, and spur tangents of thought inside your head. These thoughts go into the Thought Cabinet so you can mull them over properly and, maybe, internalise them.</p><p>In a world of RPGs that define characters by the force they can exert on the world around them, Disco Elysium allows to become the Communist Cop, or the Sorry Cop. There’s no combat in Disco Elysium, and it doesn’t try to convince you that violence is necessary for a gritty story. Its post-mortem scene was written with such scientific precision it made me gag.</p><figure><a href="http://ko-fi.com/eryksawicki"><img alt="Support me on Ko-Fi" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5b19Qv14UKOi8DykQNq3bQ@2x.png" /></a></figure><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>Ukie.org.uk. 2020. <em>UK Games Industry Census — Understanding Diversity In The UK Games Industry Workforce | Ukie</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://ukie.org.uk/UK-games-industry-census-2020&gt; [Accessed 17 June 2020].</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e8c4ffdc3b58" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Storytelling in games as compared to film]]></title>
            <link>https://uxdesign.cc/storytelling-in-games-as-compared-to-film-how-cinematography-interaction-and-narrative-design-f8280ba2b309?source=rss-557bca14fb9f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8280ba2b309</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-experience]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Eryk Sawicki]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jun 2020 17:11:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-16T16:45:06.935Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Inspired by cinema, game developers take this understood medium and apply its learnings to a vast, unmapped frontier. They are faced by a new set of challenges: giving players control over narratives, introducing them to systems and ways of play that aren’t immediately intuitive, and letting go of authorial intent. This dissertation will explore and understand the ways the principles of cinema apply to games, and how games are developing those principles to create cinematic experiences for the new age.</p><p>The three keywords of this dissertation should be defined so that no confusion may arise from their application. <em>Image</em> will be used to talk about the visuals the player is shown, and the key tenet of cinema: visual grammar. <em>Story</em>, then, will be in relation to the narrative design (a concept unique to games; the way a player is fed narrative through ways other than image) and structure of narrative. Finally, <em>experience</em>, will be used in relation to the emotions invoked through control schemes, decision making, and other aspects of interactivity and gameplay games provide to shape the player’s experience.</p><h3>Chapter 1 — The Cinematic</h3><p>Interaction is what sets games apart. This doesn’t, however, mean that games are separate from other artforms. Cutscenes take control away from the player and follow the conventions of cinema. With the progression of technology, cutscenes can be performed by professional actors, motion captured and animated. Developers can choose to use advanced lighting simulations, mimic the imperfections of cameras, and even record motion capture footage with virtual cameras.</p><p>This chapter will explore a brief history of cinematography in gaming: how modern developers take inspirations from the medium of cinema and apply it to interactive medium of gaming.</p><h4>Additional Nomenclature</h4><p>To talk about image in video games, I first must outline and explain the ways image is presented to the player. Three terms I will use from here onwards are:</p><p>Cutscene — “any non-interactive storytelling or scene-setting element of a game” (Hancock, 2002).</p><p>Third Person Perspective — Follows the player character during gameplay. Much like a film camera, these can tilt, pan, and zoom.</p><p>First Person Perspective — The player assumes control of the character from the character’s perspective.</p><h4>Influence of Cinema on Games</h4><p>Hideo Kojima, director of the hugely successful <em>Metal Gear Solid</em> series, doesn’t hide the influence cinema has had on his work. If anything, he embraces it, his Twitter profile proudly stating: “70% of my body is made of movies.” (Kojima, 2010). His 2004 release, <em>Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater </em>opens on a clear pastiche of <em>James Bond </em>— a title sequence directed by Kyle Cooper (<em>Rogue One, mother!, Seven)</em>, no less. The main theme? A haunting tribute to <em>Bond’s </em>female vocals, performed by Cynthia Harrell (Hibino, 2004).</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FMx76RGHbfms%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DMx76RGHbfms&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FMx76RGHbfms%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e3c2b909a308085032593b636a02177d/href">https://medium.com/media/e3c2b909a308085032593b636a02177d/href</a></iframe><p>Kojima cites Hitchcock’s <em>North by Northwest </em>as a huge influence on <em>Metal Gear Solid </em>(1998), stating “It is Hitchcock’s use of this first-person view that resembles one of the key features in MGS.” (Kojima, 2003). He notes that, due to the player being able to freely switch between first and third-person (bird’s eye view) perspectives “it was difficult to direct certain scenes as [he] would have wished” (Kojima, 2003). <em>Metal Gear Solid </em>employs another perspective, however, dependent on the player’s context. If the character leans against a wall, the camera swings down to the character’s level, providing a clearer view of what lies around the corner. Kojima goes on to say that “…it is by limiting on-screen information with these three cameras that helps create a feel of menace.” (Kojima, 2003).</p><h4>Filmmakers without Cameras</h4><p>Dori Arazi, during a talk about his time as Director of Photography on Sony’s 2018 game <em>God of War</em> spoke of the challenges he encountered (Arazi, 2017). Coming from a film background, Arazi says a knowledge of optics was crucial to his success. As all his work was virtual, he and his team first had to teach their software to interpret the data their virtual camera recorded. This required them to understand how each lens distorted the image, and how different lens worked under varying lighting conditions. His team was able to craft a 15–85mm zoom lens with a 1.8f aperture, something not yet possible with any lens on the professional market. While this is any cinematographer’s dream — allowing for huge freedom in framing — Arazi mentioned that the PS4’s computational power is a limiting factor when it comes to lighting. With each extra light added, the processor’s load is multiplied exponentially, and so Arazi had to use each light as effectively as possible.</p><p>The benefit of a virtual camera is that heavy equipment isn’t necessary for intricate camera moves. The animation department can take over from the virtual camera under Arazi’s supervision. Dollies, tracks, jibs, and even shots that would require use of a drone can all be easily animated after the fact. Arazi made sure to highlight the fact that a virtual camera is not actually a camera — it is simply a way of recording motion data that can then be manipulated in post-production. Camera shakes could be eliminated, missteps in the actors’ blocking, or even whole actions could be altered and hand animated. One could claim that this is where the uncanny valley comes into play as characters actions become <em>too </em>perfect, or too rehearsed. This, though, is an unfair criticism to make; an incapable or inexperienced animator <em>would</em> commit these mistakes, but an incapable or inexperienced actor would <em>also</em> make the same mistakes.</p><p>Games give Directors of Photography (DP) greater control over the finished product. Much as a film DP would need to location scout, Arazi had to collaborate with level designers and concept artists to create the virtual world the camera would inhabit. This does, however, require a wider skillset: Arazi quoted his history in animation and design as a help — knowing how an animator works and communicating his needs was easier as a result. Rather than finding inspiration through location scouts, Arazi had to inspire: creating sets that the Designers were happy with — ones that could accommodate battle segments, puzzles, or whatever other gameplay mechanics they wanted to implement — but also ones that enabled the Director to lead the action in cutscenes.</p><p>Coverage (a film term for capturing action from several angles) is never a problem. As motion capture studios capture data from tens of angles, the placement of the camera becomes something the developers can change during production. With the ability to seamlessly merge takes or hand-animate minor details, the team can easily pull out the best performances without having to worry about hiding cuts, or editing in general.</p><p>Arazi cites the game’s interactive camera his main challenge: it was difficult for him to give up his authorial intent. Working with designers and animators they decided that, though the player has ultimate control over the game’s third-person perspective, there were animations and combat scenes that the team wanted to make sure players experienced. When <em>Kratos</em> goes in for a brutal killing blow, the camera punches in on the action as seen below in Figure 2, then goes back to its neutral position for the player to keep going.</p><figure><img alt="Closeup of God of War protagonist Kratos cleaving an enemy in half with a greataxe." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/578/0*XuwoBAPtAD17qmaP" /><figcaption><em>Figure 2 — God of War (2018)</em></figcaption></figure><p>These techniques combine the interaction granted by the medium as well as cinematographic principles, mixing gameplay with a dynamic camera that reacts to the players inputs, while still producing an image that emphasises the action and has intent behind it. It’s a display of the unique workflow of the games industry: the DoP has control over the image while working closely with the animators and designers and having a grasp of all departments.</p><h4>Cinematics as Loading Screens</h4><p>With the advancement of technology, cutscenes can fulfil more than one function. A cutscene is a perfect time to flush the computer’s short-term RAM (random access memory) of the previous level and use it to load the assets needed for the next area. This rids games of loading screens which notoriously grind pacing to a halt. Naughty Dog takes these up a notch though. <em>Uncharted 4 </em>(2016) combines cutscenes and gameplay during moments of tension to slow the pace, mask loading of assets, and trick the player into believing they have the ability to affect the outcome of the situation. Take the scene in Figure 2 (below): following a lengthy car chase during which the player is jumping between cars and tearing through Madagascan countryside, the player’s car crashes and the main character, Nathan Drake, becomes trapped underneath its flaming wreck.</p><p>This is, in fact, the midpoint of the sequence. The player controls Drake’s arms as he’s trying to pull himself out of the vehicle (Figure 3 — notice the two bars to his left and right that both have red tape wrung around them — intended to draw the player’s eye). As stakes are high, the player will try to be as quick as possible, but Drake’s animation cycle and the rate at which the car sets aflame is well-timed. Despite the player’s actions, the scene plays out at <em>exactly</em> the same pace every time. The timing not only sets up tension, but also allows enough time for behind-the-scenes processing to load the next scene’s assets and allow the player to keep playing uninterrupted.</p><figure><img alt="Uncharted protagonist Nathan Drake trapped in a burning vehicle, reaching out for the door handle." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SoexIl8WzZHMNdZl" /><figcaption><em>Figure 3 — Uncharted 4 (2016)</em></figcaption></figure><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FFqSbj_hIO-I%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DFqSbj_hIO-I&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FFqSbj_hIO-I%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4b2a679107a2a5ea8de1195be9c7f13c/href">https://medium.com/media/4b2a679107a2a5ea8de1195be9c7f13c/href</a></iframe><p>It’s a clear aspiration to be more filmic — a short breather in an action-packed sequence, only to be thrust right back into the action.</p><h4>Why not make films instead?</h4><p>Criticisms levied towards Kojima and others of his philosophy place them as unsuccessful filmmakers making do with second best. <em>Metal Gear Solid 4</em> is infamous for its ~8 hours of cutscenes, holding two Guinness World Records: “Longest end sequence in a video game” at 1 hour 9 minutes and “Longest cutscene in a video game” at 27 minutes (Guinness World Records Limited, 2018).</p><p>This opens an interesting debate: are purely gameplay-driven games a la <em>Half-Life 2 </em>(2004) which feature no cutscenes more deserving of the “video game” title than ones like <em>Metal Gear Solid</em> <em>4</em>, which, as mentioned, contain almost 8 hours of cinematics? Davey Wreden’s <em>The Stanley Parable </em>(2013)<em> </em>and <em>The Beginner’s Guide </em>(2015) are derogatorily labelled as “walking simulators”. They feature no cutscenes, nor do they have involved gameplay mechanics: the player simply navigates the environment, taking in the narrative delivered through text, environment, or narration. Without a fail state, can these pieces of work also be called games?</p><p>This is an old-fashioned train of thought: avoiding the fail-state was the player’s objective in arcade games like <em>Pac-Man </em>(1980)<em> </em>or <em>Donkey Kong </em>(1981)<em>. </em>The maturing of games as a medium has led to new sensibilities: the objective of “walking simulators” is narrative, and <em>Dear Esther </em>(2012) developer Dan Pinchbeck feels critics think that “games have to be defended from innovation” (Pinchbeck, 2016), and that their criticism often “starts coming apart at the seams” (Pinchbeck, 2016).</p><p>This is a positive to most: games as a medium are still a young frontier. Developers can freely experiment with structures and storytelling methods.</p><h4>Procedural Camera Systems</h4><p>CD Projekt Red’s <em>The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt </em>(2015) is a huge game: its 450,000 word script (Stein, 2015) rivals most novels — Tolkien’s <em>Lord of the Rings</em> trilogy totals 455,000 words — and to animate the game’s dialogue was a gargantuan task. As <em>The Witcher </em>is an open world game — players are free to explore and interact as they wish, and in whichever order they wish — the team decided to automate this process. Cutscenes for the main story were all hand crafted, but side content was mostly created through a ‘procedural’ camera. The team created a template: the player character, <em>Geralt</em>, and the people he talks to have a pool of animations the system would randomly select from, ranging from simple hand gestures to body movements and expressions. Alongside a camera system that would select the best of pre-made angles (with criteria like: is the lens free of obstructions?) the team could quickly animate thousands of conversations between <em>Geralt</em> and other characters. They could then go in and quickly polish the scenes, work out kinks that came up — no automated process is perfect, after all — and save massive amounts of time.</p><figure><img alt="Medium shot of Witcher 3: Wild Hunt protagonist Geralt mid conversation." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SlsX1lUZuZ05kkvz" /><figcaption><em>Figure 4 — The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (2015)</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Chapter 2 — Interaction</h3><p>Interactivity is the key differential between video games and cinema. Through interaction, the player can affect <em>image, story,</em> and their <em>experience</em>.</p><h4>Half-Life 2’s Invisible Tutorials (Brown, 2015)</h4><p>Valve Corporation’s <em>Half-Life 2</em> (2004), a “first-person shooter” game, uses all three keywords to immerse the player in its world.</p><p>Analysis by essayist Mark Brown explains a scenario in Ravenholm, an abandoned village, the player comes across. As the player enters a house, their eye is drawn towards the grotesque scene on the back wall (Figure 1) directly opposite the entrance (Brown, 2015). A zombie corpse has been split in two with a saw-blade. There are two conclusions to draw from this: the cause of Ravenholm’s abandonment is made apparent (story), and the player is shown that the most effective way to fight the creatures is through use of saw-blades (experience and gameplay).</p><figure><img alt="Half-Life 2 zombie is cut in half with a giant saw blade." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8GgQP84DYv6Z6w2r" /><figcaption><em>Figure 5 — Half-Life 2 — Valve Corporation, 2004</em></figcaption></figure><p>The only way forward is through the door blocked by the table on the left of Figure 1. As the player approaches and uses their Gravity Gun to pick up a saw-blade, a zombie is revealed (as shown in Figure 2). The only way out, then, is to use the saw-blade as a projectile weapon. And so, without using dialogue, text, or cutscenes, but instead using cinematic principles like leading lines and colour theory (note the generous swathes of blood in Figure 1 and bright light in Figure 2), Half-Life 2 tells a story and teaches the player a core gameplay mechanic.</p><figure><img alt="The player has picked up a saw blade, and an enemy has appeared in their line of sight." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WG4QuMv31v6-lDjH" /><figcaption><em>Figure 6 — Half-Life 2 — Valve Corporation, 2004</em></figcaption></figure><p>This kind of environmental and visual storytelling is an interesting field, venturing even into psychology as Naughty Dog developer Emilia Schatz claims: “You need to figure out what your environment is telling the player, and figure out how you can give the player as much information as possible so they feel very informed — but at the same time influence their decision to be the right one.” (Schatz, 2014). It is not fully unique to gaming, however: this technique is reminiscent of the Kuleshov effect — the idea that two sequential shots can alter the viewer’s perception of emotion portrayed by an actor — through subtle environmental clues the designer is able to influence the conclusion a player will reach.</p><h4>Empathy through Gameplay</h4><p>Naughty Dog’s <em>The Last of Us </em>(2013) is a great example of a game that uses its mechanics to create a bond between player and character. The narrative is set 20 years after a global cataclysm. The characters struggle to survive in a hostile world, scavenging for supplies. This translates to gameplay: the player will go into combat armed with scraps; a splintered baseball bat or 3 rounds of ammunition. Faced with large groups of enemies, the player must make real-time, desperate decisions on how to use their limited supplies. Using them now means they won’t be available later — who knows what lies in wait just around the corner? The player, then, is thrust into the same position as the characters, as a single mistake could spell disaster.</p><p>Conversely, Red Hook Studio’s Lovecraft-inspired <em>Darkest Dungeon </em>(2016) uses this desperation to make the player the villain of the situation.</p><p>The game places the player in the shoes of a baron of an abandoned estate. To rebuild, whatever cosmic horrors lie within must first be purged. The player recruits adventurers, using them only as a means to an end. We are presented with two main statistics of each adventurer: <em>Health</em> and <em>Stress. </em>As the player sends adventurers out on successive missions, their <em>stress</em> value rises and the likelier they are to suffer <em>Afflictions</em>, such as ‘Paranoid’, ‘Hopeless’, and ‘Masochistic’. After suffering an <em>Affliction</em>, characters that suffer more stress have a chance of being struck by a heart attack and dying permanently.</p><figure><img alt="Side view of Darkest Dungeon — four heroes face off against four eldritch creatrures." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*6sOi_TYR-_J6KqA8" /><figcaption><em>Figure 7 — Darkest Dungeon — Red Hook Studios, 2016</em></figcaption></figure><p>Characters suffering <em>Afflictions</em> might lash out against the player. These subversions are usually harmful: a <em>Masochistic</em> character might hurt one of their fellow party members, while a <em>Hopeless </em>character might run to the back, ruining the party’s tactical composition and disabling certain choices for the player. The game, at this point, takes control from the player. Instead of using cutscenes, though, characters act on their own, pushing the idea that they are independent and rebelling from their commander.</p><p>Another essay by Mark Brown calls this “Morality in the Mechanics” (Brown, 2016): the player is encouraged to push adventurers to point of extreme stress, of mental illness, and then discard them once they are no longer of use. The aim of the game, ultimately, is to use others for personal gain — shedding humanity in favour of greed. The game does not explicitly ask you to make a black and white moral decision, but the most efficient way of playing is by throwing away tired adventurers, bringing on new ones, and repeating the cycle. Healing broken characters takes time and money — it’s up to the player if they can spare any.</p><p>It’s also important to note the camera perspective of <em>Darkest Dungeon</em>. It is neither first nor third-person, but seen side-on, as illustrated in Figure 3. There’s a further separation from your adventurers — a side view is impersonal, and places them on the same level as enemies they encounter. The player has constant view over their statistics: <em>Health </em>and <em>Stress. </em>It’s dehumanising — the adventurers are just pawns in a game.</p><figure><img alt="Papers Please shows a citizen’s passport and biometric information. The player has denied them entry." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*N-YQLGQeTMVuytBx" /><figcaption><em>Figure 8 — Papers, Please (2013)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Lucas Pope’s indie hit <em>Papers, Please </em>(2013) takes a different approach: the player takes the role of a border crossing immigration officer, wherein the gameplay revolves around granting or denying people access to the fictional country of Arstotzka. The player is given different objectives each day, and more complex ones with each passing day — if a neighbouring country declares war on Arstotzka, the player is not allowed to grant access to the citizens of that country. Deadlines get tighter each day. Bribes, sob stories, and threats all come flying towards the player, and only the player can make the decision on their course of action. At the end of the day the player earns money for their work, spends it on rent and medicine (if needed) and continues on. It is up to the player to decide how corrupt they want to be, and how far they will go to feed their family.</p><figure><img alt="End screen of Papers Please, several members of the player’s family are shown as dead and they are struggling to pay rent." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*f_ukXMBz6nYs5sCT" /><figcaption><em>Figure 9 — Papers, Please (2013) — End of Day screen</em></figcaption></figure><p>Film grants us the ability to empathise with characters through the actors and their expressions. As social creatures, we react empathically to the feelings of those around us. The filmmakers take us on this journey, however, while the mechanics of the aforementioned games push the player into the role of the arbiter and catalyst rather than a mere observer.</p><h3>Chapter 3 — Narrative Design in Linear and Non-Linear Worlds</h3><p>The focus of this chapter will be on comparing the ways narrative can be communicated to players in both linear (wherein the narrative progresses in a set order as the player does, and is most film-like) and non-linear games (wherein the player is granted some degree of freedom and agency in approaching the narrative), as compared to that of films.</p><h4>Ludonarrative Dissonance</h4><p>Clint Hocking, former creative director at LucasArts and Ubisoft, coined the phrase <em>“Ludonarrative Dissonance” </em>while discussing <em>Bioshock </em>(2007). He claims that “By throwing the narrative and ludic elements of the work into opposition, the game seems to openly mock the player for having believed in the fiction of the game at all.” (Hocking, 2007). Going back to <em>Uncharted 4</em>, the protagonist Nathan Drake is portrayed as an everyday man: his adventures are punishing and tiring, firefights leave him stressed, and he’ll often joke and quip at his situation. The dissonance, then, comes from the fact that by the end of the first game of the (at time of writing) 4-game series, Drake has shot, maimed, and injured more people than a trained Marine would in their lifetime. Drake’s constant portrayal as a next-door-bloke becomes dissonant when, by the fourth game, Drake is handling full-automatic weaponry and fighting off hordes of paramilitary forces.</p><p>This is an important definition: it’s a criticism unique to video games arisen through combining gameplay and interaction. Films don’t experience this kind of problem: theme is shown through narrative and imagery, while the pursuit of “fun” is a key principle in the design of games.</p><p>Campo Santo’s <em>Firewatch </em>(2016) is a good example of a game that overcomes this dissonance. The story follows Henry, a man escaping the tragic reality of his ill wife and dissolving marriage as he ventures out into the American wilderness as a fire lookout. The gameplay revolves entirely around exploring the wilderness and interacting with Delilah — a fellow fire lookout whom we never see — over a walkie-talkie Henry carries everywhere with him. The story takes a turn toward thriller as mysterious figures seem to haunt the two over months. This is eventually resolved quite anti-climatically, a commentary on the horrors the mind fabricates when in isolation for extended periods.</p><h4>Narrative Structures</h4><p>Tom Abernathy of Riot Games and Richard Rouse of Microsoft Game Studios conducted a talk at the 2014 Game Developers Conference named “Death to the Three Act Structure!”, decrying the application of the classic Artistotelian three act structure (protasis, epitasis, catastrophe — ie. setup, confrontation, resolution). They note that the structure can be <em>almost</em> applied to a cutscene and narrative-heavy game like <em>Uncharted 2</em>, but that the serialised TV drama (à la <em>The Sopranos </em>(1999), <em>Breaking Bad </em>(2008), and <em>Game of Thrones </em>(2011)) narrative structure is a lot more convenient for games: “…showrunners have [to think about] structure on every level of magnification: … structure of scenes, about the sequences that scenes make up, the acts between ad breaks, half or even full season arcs…”.</p><figure><img alt="Slide plotting Toy Story onto a three act structure graph." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*M3iIXuAUhTTOdlz6" /><figcaption><em>Figure 10 — Plotting Toy Story (1996) as a Three Act Structure</em></figcaption></figure><p>A good example of this is Telltale Games’ <em>The Walking Dead </em>(2012). The game was released episodically; episodes would come roughly two months apart, with five making a whole season. This meant that designers had to deliver a satisfying narrative within each 2–3 hour episode that players could ruminate upon between episodes, but also push forward the narrative that spans across the whole season. While this is fine for a game with an episodic release window, the two then talked about Naughty Dog’s <em>The Last of Us</em> (2013). The game is quite neatly divided into chapters — each named after the season during which the year-long narrative takes place — and each chapter has self-contained arcs with characters that appear and disappear, as well as arcs that span the whole game.</p><p>But how does this apply to open world games?</p><figure><img alt="Slide showing Fallout 3’s narrative structure as a mess of lines with a big question mark in the middle." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bqrbjDMf-iTPS1gc" /><figcaption><em>Figure 11 — “Death to the Three Act Structure!”, presentation slide</em></figcaption></figure><p>Josh Sawyer’s talk on narrative design in <em>Fallout: New Vegas </em>(2010) focuses on the arcs of characters within quests and player agency. Players want the feeling of agency upon the world and of their character being unique, and this was more important than structure. For this, the team at Obsidian Entertainment had to make dialogue options according to a set of guidelines they made: providing tactical and strategic choices, forecasting the consequences of their choices, and validating all options to avoid “win” or “loss” choices (Sawyer, 2012). The latter was most important to them — having choices that were clearly the best would punish players that weren’t playing according to that arbitrary standard. However, validating all choices was a huge amount of work, and so the studio created a “Reputation” system that would keep track of the player’s attitude towards all factions. This meant that forecasting the consequences was a lot easier — they could use the player’s reputation to write further encounters.</p><p>The conclusion of Abernathy and Rouse’s talk is a direct counterpoint to someone they quoted at the very beginning of their talk: “Screenplays ARE structure.” — William Goldman, and propose that “Game stories are NOT structure” (Abernathy &amp; Rouse, 2014). There is no globally applicable structure for games.</p><figure><img alt="Slide of a Microsoft User Research Study showing findings of their studies." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pgSe5aLm4XbsAiWZ" /><figcaption><em>Figure 12 — Deborah Henderson’s summary of findings</em></figcaption></figure><p>The two quote research conducted by Deborah Henderson of Microsoft, stating that gamers find it a lot harder to retell the narratives of their favourite games, but consistently remember characters and their characterisation, not necessarily their role in plot (Henderson, n.d.). For this reason, they conclude that game narratives should instead focus on character first, aligning character motivations with player motivations. This is another unique challenge for games: artists, writers, and designers can concentrate on providing memorable and interesting companions that join the player on their journey, and can be a vehicle for interaction, exposition and narrative. Combining narrative, level design, and gameplay mechanics, leads to a structure that is custom-made for the game and its requirements. If this leads to a three-act structure, fine, but developers get a lot more freedom in structuring their story.</p><h4>Diegetic Worldbuilding</h4><p>Designer Jurie Horneman explores the design of narratives outside of cutscenes. In his 2015 Game Developers Conference talk, he defines two important terms for games: “story” — that which is pre-authored, about something happening to someone, and “fictional” — related to things the game is asking you to pretend are true (Horneman, 2015). He explains that the mechanics of games are abstract: health points, failure states, player character deaths are all abstractions the player accepts to understand the game. However, that what is fictional, then, is also that which is meaningful. Every game design element can be seen from the mechanical and the fictional side.</p><p>It is the narrative designer’s job, then, to explain to the player mechanics in a diegetic way, thus diegetic worldbuilding. Most games solve death with a checkpoint system: the player simply resumes from an earlier point and attempts the challenge again. Horneman’s example of <em>Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time </em>(2003), explains this with a framing device: the titular Prince and player character, is retelling the events of what happened, and any mistakes the player makes are framed as a mistake in his story, lapses in memory. Health points are a game staple, and <em>Half-Life 2 </em>(2004) uses the player character’s exo-suit as an explanation for his physical wellbeing being numerically quantified. Removing a staple such as this, though, like <em>Ico </em>(2001) is a statement in itself, and redefines the gameplay in that game. The fail state of <em>Ico</em> isn’t the player character’s death, but the capture of his love interest by shadowy creatures. The creatures are not bothered by the player character, they simply slow him down. With minimal changes <em>Ico </em>recontextualises the game’s objective: do whatever it takes to keep the companion away from danger.</p><p>Ultimately, little can be said on the narrative design of games as compared to cinema. The games that feature cinematics heavily take inspiration from cinema and, in majority, tell linear stories that do not need to adapt to the player’s actions. In this, developers have to be wary of ludonarrative dissonance and structuring: it is best to structure their narratives in ways reminiscent of serialised dramas — short narrative arcs that are best suited for shorter play times, with overarching arcs that can engage players for a time much longer than the length of a feature film. In other cases, games venture too far from the realm of cinema to apply the same principles.</p><p>This dissertation began on a faulty premise: that games bear likeness to cinema, and that this likeness is sought after by developers. The research undertaken has, however, shown that the most cinematic of games are made only by studios with the highest funding; and that games as a medium have a bevy of challenges and considerations unique to them that are not relevant to cinema. It has been an interesting foray into storytelling nonetheless, and one that has shown the most creative, most novel ideas come from the developers experimenting in this vast frontier. While cinematic games hold stories well told — influenced by cinema — it is the ones that utilise the strength of the medium that make the standout experiences: playing <em>Uncharted </em>and watching <em>Indiana Jones </em>evoke similar feelings, but there is nothing quite like the guilt of sending a party of afflicted, crushed adventurers into the <em>Darkest Dungeon</em>.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>Abernathy, T. &amp; Rouse, R., 2014. <em>Death to the Three Act Structure! Toward a Unique Structure for Game Narratives. </em>[Online video] <br>Available at: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m6Hjfu0-oZY">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m6Hjfu0-oZY</a><br>[Accessed 4 April 2018].</p><p>Arazi, D., 2017. <em>God of War and Cinematography in Games. </em>Bydgoszcz, Camerimage.</p><p>Brown, M., 2015. <em>Half-Life 2’s Invisible Tutorial | Game Maker’s Toolkit. </em>[Online video] <br>Available at: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMggqenxuZc&amp;">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMggqenxuZc&amp;</a><br>[Accessed 2 April 2018].</p><p>Brown, M., 2016. <em>Morality in the Mechanics | Game Maker’s Toolkit. </em>[Online video] <br>Available at: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RHH7M4siPM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RHH7M4siPM</a><br>[Accessed 28 March 2018].</p><p>Guinness World Records Limited, 2018. <em>Record Application Search. </em>[Online] <br>Available at: <a href="http://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/search/applicationrecordsearch?term=longest+cutscene&amp;contentType=record">http://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/search/applicationrecordsearch?term=longest+cutscene&amp;contentType=record</a><br>[Accessed 2 April 2018].</p><p>Hancock, H., 2002. <em>Better Game Design Through Cutscenes. </em>[Online] <br>Available at: <a href="https://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/131410/better_game_design_through_.php">https://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/131410/better_game_design_through_.php</a></p><p>Henderson, D., n.d. <em>Microsoft User Research Study. </em>s.l., Studios User Research.</p><p>Hibino, N., 2004. <em>Snake Eater. </em>s.l.: Kojima Productions.</p><p>Hocking, C., 2007. <em>Ludonarrative Dissonance in Bioshock. </em>[Online] <br>Available at: <a href="http://clicknothing.typepad.com/click_nothing/2007/10/ludonarrative-d.html">http://clicknothing.typepad.com/click_nothing/2007/10/ludonarrative-d.html</a><br>[Accessed 6 April 2018].</p><p>Horneman, J., 2015. <em>The Design in Narrative Design. </em>[Online video] <br>Available at: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8VIlfTtypg">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8VIlfTtypg</a><br>[Accessed 4 April 2018].</p><p>Kojima, H., 2003. Hideo Kojima at the Movies: Hitchcock Films. <em>Official Playstation 2 Magazine</em>, 1 August.</p><p>Kojima, H., 2010. <em>HIDEO_KOJIMA (@HIDEO_KOJIMA_EN) | Twitter. </em>[Online] <br>Available at: <a href="https://twitter.com/HIDEO_KOJIMA_EN">https://twitter.com/HIDEO_KOJIMA_EN</a><br>[Accessed 2 April 2018].</p><p>Konami Digital Entertainment, 2017. <em>Metal Gear in Concert. </em>[Online] <br>Available at: <a href="http://metalgearinconcert.com/">http://metalgearinconcert.com/</a><br>[Accessed 2 April 2018].</p><p>Pinchbeck, D., 2016. <em>The problem with ‘walking sims’ </em>[Interview] (28 September 2016).</p><p>Sawyer, J., 2012. <em>Choice Architecture, Player Expression, and Narrative Design in Fallout: New Vegas. </em>[Online video] <br>Available at: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LR4OxNfzTvU">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LR4OxNfzTvU</a><br>[Accessed 7 April 2018].</p><p>Schatz, E., 2014. <em>From Uncharted to The Last of Us: An Hour with Emilia Schatz, Pt. I </em>[Interview] (29 July 2014).</p><p>Stein, Z., 2015. <em>This is how big the script was for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. </em>[Online] <br>Available at: <a href="http://uk.ign.com/articles/2015/05/29/this-is-how-big-the-script-was-for-the-witcher-3-wild-hunt">http://uk.ign.com/articles/2015/05/29/this-is-how-big-the-script-was-for-the-witcher-3-wild-hunt</a><br>[Accessed 4 April 2018].</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/76/0*-ojSgM9_au5w6G46" /><figcaption>The UX Collective donates US$1 for each article published in our platform. This story contributed to <a href="https://medium.com/uxmpretas">UX Para Minas Pretas</a> (UX For Black Women), a Brazilian organization focused on promoting equity of Black women in the tech industry through initiatives of action, empowerment, and knowledge sharing. Silence against systemic racism is not an option. Build the design community you believe in.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8280ba2b309" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://uxdesign.cc/storytelling-in-games-as-compared-to-film-how-cinematography-interaction-and-narrative-design-f8280ba2b309">Storytelling in games as compared to film</a> was originally published in <a href="https://uxdesign.cc/">UX Collective</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>