<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Fattah Fathun Karim on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Fattah Fathun Karim on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@fathunkarim?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 17:34:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@fathunkarim/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Systems & Ideologies]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/systems-ideologies-86470ed3c267?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86470ed3c267</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ideology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[statecraft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Nov 2021 17:30:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-14T11:26:04.780Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SMiGYKv7SZ4RChVu.jpg" /><figcaption>Niccolò Machiavelli</figcaption></figure><p>This blog might seem like an anomaly, as it may contain some level of political bias. However, man is a political animal, so keeping that in mind, I hope I would be pardoned. Rhetoric aside, my aim is not political at all. This is not a defense piece in favor of any particular political party or ideology in any part of the world. Instead, it is an investigation into what contributes to the sociopolitical stability of a country and binds its institutions together against numerous odds, helping it maintain a stable power landscape.</p><p>Most of the time, when I used to engage in political discussions, I would receive alarmist feedback in return. It’s not surprising to see people getting frustrated and pessimistic over a long-standing establishment, especially if the establishment has been inefficient in addressing people’s concerns. As time progresses, the popularity of an establishment is bound to wane, particularly in a democratic setting where people are conditioned to expect change. Additionally, there is anti-establishment propaganda, which does not necessarily have to be a lie but rather a twisted, filtered narrative fed to the people for political gains. Both the establishment and anti-establishment forces propagate propaganda according to their vision and ideals. However, generally speaking, anti-establishment hyperbole catches people’s attention the most, as it caters to the powerless, who constitute the majority of the population. Another reason is that such narratives are sensational, dramatic, intellectually striking, adrenaline-inducing, and morally vindicating. In a divisive society, this trend is most pronounced, as seen in the United States of America.</p><p>In China, on the other hand, there is effectively no anti-establishment propaganda present due to government censorship, which suppresses any potential divisiveness. In fact, divisive tendencies are seen as a vice, and whatever the Chinese Communist Party decides is expected to be obeyed. This is why I mentioned a democratic setting as a fundamental prerequisite for such a sociopolitical dynamic to materialize. A country might lack democracy, but it might have a democratic setting. For example, in most third world countries, a democratic setting can be found as a consequence of colonial influence, but on the contrary, few unbiased elections can be found.</p><p>On the other hand, the only people who subscribe to pro-establishment propaganda are usually ideologically aligned activists, party loyalists, or associated beneficiaries. This is rarely a spontaneous phenomenon but rather arises out of an existential need. A practical example of the influence of both types of propaganda can be found in literature and the entertainment industry. Anti-establishment rhetoric sells the most, while nuances sell little. You have to have a villain in your story and a hero as well. The hero will conquer the villain and bring eternal justice and peace. However, in real life, revolutions occur repeatedly, and myths remain as myths. Only the elites get to switch positions of power.</p><p>On the other hand, if you write a nuanced narrative, neither antagonizing nor idolizing any particular figure, party, or ideology, it will be comparatively harder to reach the masses. The balance will always lean towards the sensational storyteller and not the nuanced observer. Unlike anti-establishment rhetoric, which easily attracts people, the establishment contrives its own ways to bring people back under its influence. This is achieved through patriotism, identity politics, religion, cultural conservatism, etc., which are naturally integrated into the human mind. Thus, ideologies make their entrance into political landscapes, playing a vital role in determining the power equilibrium among stakeholders.</p><p>The anti-establishment bloc always has leverage in this game due to people’s proclivity towards its cause. Additionally, they can solely focus on creating anti-establishment propaganda and invest more time into crafting it. On the other hand, the establishment bloc has less time to invest in such trivial matters since they have bigger responsibilities, namely the governance of the whole country, on their shoulders. If the establishment is efficient enough in governing the country, their propaganda does not yield the expected outcome. In contrast, the inefficiency of a government inadvertently benefits the anti-establishment campaign, strengthening propaganda with little effort from their part. The efficiency of a government relieves it from the necessity of creating a strong propaganda network since actions speak louder than words. When this happens, the burden to create anti-establishment agitation becomes heavier on the anti-establishment bloc. Even the slightest anomalies have to be capitalized and sensationalized to level up their game against the efficient rule of the establishment.</p><p>Ordinary people do not tend to think about political nuances in this way. Each party presents itself as genuine to their cause, making it justifiably hard for a regular person to decipher the real intentions behind propagandist activism. As I stated earlier, propaganda does not necessarily have to be lies but rather carefully crafted filtered narratives to woo people into a cause. So when specific bits of propaganda strike a chord with an ordinary person, they will definitely embrace it, especially if they lack political consciousness. The political battleground should be seen as a sport. The parties are players, and the people are the tools, while the goal is to ascend towards state power. In this battle, while anti-establishment forces enjoy leverage on the propaganda front, the establishment, on the other hand, has leverage in a far stronger factor, which is the state apparatus. Now, this might sound like an over-generalized word, but it is vital to understanding the course of power dynamics in a society.</p><p>At this point, I feel obliged to describe what can be construed as a “system”. A system, as we have been taught in our signals and systems course, is a process that takes inputs and produces an output. This is a purely engineering definition of physical systems. However, in this context, we will be using “systems” interchangeably with “services.” Since we are discussing state mechanisms, we will primarily focus on state services, but we will also touch upon some private realms to gain a more holistic picture.</p><p>We must understand that a state does not exist in isolation; it must also prioritize its private sectors. After all, in a free-market economy, it is the private sector that is responsible for generating wealth and resources. The state relies on the revenues collected from this generated wealth, which are obtained through taxes or other mechanisms. Additionally, the private sector ensures mass employment, so ignoring it would mean disregarding a significant and influential political factor</p><p>So, Let&#39;s start with employment.</p><p>Employment is one of the key factors for political stability. Unemployment has a deep psychological impact on a population, especially the young. It generates despair, frustration, uncertainty, and increases the tendency to take risks. It is also deeply responsible for recruiting militias, which consequently escalates domestic violence, political flare-ups, and organized crime.</p><p>To provide a small-scale local example, Brahmanbaria, a district in Bangladesh, serves as a good illustration. The people of this district are mostly seasonal farmers. They plant crops during specific seasons, harvest them at the end, and sell them for a living. However, for the rest of the year, they lay idle due to the floodplains being submerged underwater, which they usually use as farmlands in the summers. The water level rises so high that when the rivers are full, it drowns the road connections, isolating the whole region from the mainland. This works as a major deterrent for big industries to set up their firms in this region. Consequently, people have to rely mostly on agriculture and farming and have literally nothing to do when the water overflows from the rivers.</p><p>During these idle times, young men in Brahmanbaria spend most of their time at local tea stalls engaging in politics, playing cards, gambling on petty games, and gossiping about trivial family affairs, etc. They are full of youthful energy but have nowhere to spend it. Indolence combined with youthful energy is a recipe for disaster, which gets channeled into violence. Brahmanbaria is the living proof of this. The frequency of violent infighting between Brahmanbaria’s village clans is unparalleled in this country. The same can be seen in Char areas (alluvial lands), which suffer from a big scarcity of work, contributing to loaded uncertainties for its residents. Char areas, especially in off seasons (flood seasons), become extremely violent. A similar trend can be observed in border areas, flood-prone regions, steep mountain areas, and deep dense jungles. The lack of work is bound to translate into political instability. The Sundarbans have pirates, the mountains have Arakan Bahini and Shantibahini, char areas have scattered militias, flood-prone regions are filled with land grabbers and dacoits.</p><p><a href="https://www.tbsnews.net/bangladesh/crime/spiteful-spears-brahmanbaria-193879">Spiteful spears of Brahmanbaria</a></p><p>A state’s pledge is to ensure work for all its constituents. However, theoretically, it cannot enforce this, as it is ultimately an individual’s liberty to choose whether to work or not and to select their preferred line of work. The government cannot infringe upon this personal right. What it can do, however, is create an environment where work opportunities are available. It must ensure that workplaces are free from gender, racial, and religious discrimination and that work is accessible to all who wish to pursue it and possess the necessary qualifications. To equip its people with the required skills, the state must provide adequate education and training facilities.</p><p>To achieve these goals, the government must design a system. It invests time, money, and logistics, drafts or amends laws, and takes measures to promote employment opportunities while also considering other interests of the state. The objective is to maximize employment within the boundaries defined by the state. In communist countries such as North Korea or Cuba, the demarcation line is designed to ensure maximum state ownership. All enterprises in these countries are state-owned, with capital controlled and shared by the state bureaucracy. However, the fixed nature of the state bureaucracy limits its creative potential. Decisions made by the government are translated into the market through a restrictive, linear approach that hampers market growth and expansion, consequently curtailing economic growth. This is a shortcoming that free-market economies do not have. They foster an open market where anyone can participate and profit, encouraging innovative ideas and versatile enterprises, thereby accelerating market scope and diversification. Enterprises engage the state’s constituents, thereby passively serving the state’s initial goal of providing employment opportunities while ensuring a versatile economy.</p><p>To understand the importance of versatility, we need not look further than Venezuela. The country heavily relies on oil, which accounts for 80% of its GDP. Although Venezuela used to have minor agricultural and manufacturing exports, poor economic policies and over-reliance on oil caused these sectors to suffer. When struck by US sanctions, they could no longer sell oil elsewhere, leading to hyperinflation and a total collapse of their poorly managed economy. Similar circumstances can be observed in Iran as well. While Iran does not solely rely on oil, its economy had the potential to rival that of its neighboring Middle Eastern countries. However, Iranian oil also faced US sanctions. When an entire economy is based on one pillar, the collapse of that pillar affects the entire economy. Therefore, diversification is crucial for a secure economic future. Middle Eastern countries that heavily rely on oil, such as Saudi Arabia, UAE, and Qatar, are gradually realizing the importance of market diversification and reducing their dependence on oil. They are liberalizing their systems, attracting investors to build economic zones and infrastructures, and adapting to ensure a prosperous future regardless of geopolitical conditions. These countries are transforming their conservative cultures by boosting tourism, opening bars, nightclubs, holiday resorts, investing in cinemas, promoting sports, establishing Westernized universities, increasing female participation in the economy, creating self-sustaining digital ecosystems, and more. Although the shift is still underway and will take time to solidify, it is necessary for their long-term stability.</p><p>On the other hand, consider countries like the United States of America. The entrepreneurial craze has resulted in a bloom of technologies and services. They have created resources out of thin air, which they sold to the whole world. To ensure their creative supply chain, they have brought in the world’s finest minds as immigrants by selling them the American dream. A collective effort invested by these intelligent individuals has gifted America with an invaluable set of knowledge, skills, and novel innovations. America’s precious resources that it had engineered have put it up as an uncontested hegemon for decades. This would not have been possible in a communist country that approaches linearly through state-controlled entrepreneurial decisions, like North Korea or Cuba. I am not invoking countries like China, Vietnam, Laos, Peru, etc. because despite being run by a communist party their markets have some degree of free-market characteristics. China, when it was at the peak of its cultural revolution (communist revolution) under Mao Zedong, suffered from such a problem. But after Den Xiaoping opened up its market, and embraced the free-market economy, the Chinese market exploded and is still expanding to this day. Chinese Communist party even had to admit that the cultural revolution was a mistake and should have been directed differently. Same with Vietnam. After the communist takeover by the North Vietnamese army, the country was not going anywhere, but shortly after the ruling regime opened up its market (not to the extent of china but still ), the country is going on a fast track economic development. Both China and Vietnam had violent phases when their economy was poor, especially during the period of their communist revolution. We can see the same with the soviet union too. Shortly After receiving a massive economic shock from the cold war and also the war in Afghanistan, the USSR model was proving to be unsustainable. The USSR command economy was proving to be extremely inefficient to match with other emerging global markets, like that of America and Japan. America and Japan were pacing at a burgeoning pace, whereas the Soviet economy stagnated so bad that they had to rely on only oil export at that moment. Such a tense moment can be realized through soviet premier Alexei Kosygin’s anxious exchange with the head of oil and gas production of the soviet union at that time.</p><blockquote>things are bad with bread. Give me 3 million tons [of oil] over the plan</blockquote><p>After Mikhail Gorbachev assumed power, he started to transform the soviet union’s command economy into a market economy. The soviet union had to be gradually dissolved in order to materialize these administrative and economic reforms. Thus, the Russian federation along with other post-soviet countries like Lithuania, Estonia, Ukraine was born. A whole country dissolved because the command economy failed to meet the global market reality. This alone should be enough to demonstrate the huge political repercussions that economic systems can entail.</p><p>But laissez-faire or absolutely free markets are not desirable either since they tend to centralize entrepreneurial versatility by creating monopolistic corporate power and intricate legal mazes. There is also a fear of cross-border capitalist aggression and corporate imperialism. This is something the Chinese State has managed to balance effectively. It has hindered foreign monopolies from operating within its borders and instead fostered similar copycat infrastructures that incentivize its own pool of entrepreneurs. Consequently, this approach has led to the creation of thousands of job openings and the advantage of keeping tech revenues within Chinese borders. Allowing Facebook, Google, Twitter, YouTube, etc., to operate in China instead of platforms like Weibo, Baidu, WeChat, Sina Weibo, Youku, etc., would result in offshored revenues with no tangible employment opportunities for Chinese mainland citizens. Furthermore, it would impose a political toll on the Chinese state, as American companies tend to operate independently according to their own set of rules rather than those of the states in which they operate. The Chinese system has proven successful, whereas countries that did not (or could not) emulate the Chinese approach have suffered in these aspects.</p><p>In Bangladesh, for example, the government effectively has no control over social media and other Silicon Valley tech giants. These companies generate billions of dollars through their advertising schemes in the country. While it can be argued that the Silicon Valley giants have boosted the local SME scheme, the outflow of billions of dollars is far from an ideal situation, despite our limited influence. Unlike China, we lack the technical expertise to build our own infrastructure, so we must accept certain trade-offs. However, these trade-offs have not only economic but also political implications. As a country, we have not yet reached the technological maturity of first-world countries. Fake news is rampant on online platforms, and its impact extends beyond harmless propaganda. Rumors and political propaganda disseminated through these platforms have amplified communalism among the people, generated political tensions, increased sexism, racism, domestic violence, and led to political conflicts, among other issues. The communal violence witnessed over the last 6–7 years can be directly attributed to the misuse of social media platforms. The government struggles to control this situation because Facebook prioritizes user privacy, while its algorithm continues to fuel the spread of sensational fake news posts. The government attempted to introduce the Digital Security Act to curb online criminal activities, although the success of this act remains debatable. Many claim that the act was introduced to silence journalists, a notion I disagree with. If an omnipotent government truly wanted to silence journalists, it wouldn’t need a law to do so. Furthermore, the massive market growth of news and print media, evident in the recent issuance of licenses by the government, contradicts the idea of an adverse journalistic atmosphere. During this government’s tenure, there has been a significant increase in the number of dailies and news channels, far surpassing previous regimes’ figures. Previously, the count wasn’t even a fraction of what it is today. The DSA act was formulated to catch miscreants in the virtual world. Although journalist unions want us to believe that all journalists are innocent, in practical life, we can observe that many of them are not as blameless as they claim to be. An investigative report produced by Mazhar Milon of Maasranga TV exposed such journalistic malpractice. Additionally, if you were to ask politicians, businessmen, and public service officials directly, you would see that such journalistic malpractices are, in fact, quite endemic</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FRbSi_PPdLFE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DRbSi_PPdLFE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FRbSi_PPdLFE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/11a1f4472ae75037c79bda10c8a38384/href">https://medium.com/media/11a1f4472ae75037c79bda10c8a38384/href</a></iframe><p>Although not much studies have been done exploring the success of DSA in achieving its goals, but at least the government offered a system against the populist sentiment to hold such people culpable. Previously there had been no such systems for digital platforms, hence adding this does not give out a sinister vibe if anyone gives a more nuanced thought into it.</p><p>The country saw many large protests thanks to social media activism. Shahbagh Protests, Quota Reform movement, Road safety protests, Anti-Rape protests, etc. to name a few that have emerged out of social media activism. But this could have been made possible due to a democratic setting of the country where the government allows freedom of speech to some extent to preserve its democratic outlook. Many would disagree with this notion but it can be easily cross-checked through some hours of browsing online. Opposing forces are quite vocal on online platforms, blasting the government for every action they take, every move they make. They can also be seen to hold rallies, protests on Paltan, Shahbagh, and other key places with regular media coverage. Talk shows invite dissident voices regularly and in fact more than supporting voices, since dissidence has a bigger sense of valor, yielding more PR value for the concerned media. But it would be an out-and-out lie to claim that the country has turned into free-speech heaven. Some levels of intimidation do occur on local levels since we are yet to outgrow the culture of muscle power at provincial levels, but on national policymaking levels, such practices are barely observed.</p><p>Although the westernized notion of free speech doesn&#39;t exist here, just like western secularism, which also doesn&#39;t exist in its actual shape and form despite the constitution having secularism as one of its core pillars. There are some parts of our country’s history which the ruling party has demarcated and sanctified, granting them immunity from criticism. For example, Bangladesh’s liberation war, the concept of the Father of the nation, Bangladesh’s national anthem, and Bengali nationalism. Once a journalist named David Bergman called in question about the actual toll of the liberation war of Bangladesh. He was brought under contempt of court for distorting the liberation war’s history and was also castigated for whitewashing war crimes and war criminals of that period. Now, this can be construed as an attack on the free press, but from a greater political point of view, it is not. You cannot get away with doing revisionism on the holocaust narrative in first-world countries as well, especially European ones which still carry the taint of the holocaust. You cant even get away with doing such revisionist practices in the United States without having to face dire consequences. You can’t be a James Watson, a Flannery O’ Connor, or an H.P Lovecraft making frequent racist tropes, without being canceled by your peers. People like Alex jones whose fake news campaign ends up causing the Sandy Hook massacre eventually get charged too. So even in the land of the free, journalism is not completely immune. It&#39;s all about striking a balance at the end of the day so that minimal damage follows. Would you allow fake news and rumors to run rampant and threaten national security for the sake of free journalism or would you put a leash into it to avert grave social explosions? Also, weakening the nationalistic fervor of a country has sinister repercussions too. It prompts divisiveness even more and creates a recipe for a civil war based on identity politics. In the absence of a nationalistic glue, identity politics grabs a hold. It is unavoidable unless the country has an extreme libertarian, selfish, Reagnite, Thatcherite, Ayn Rand culture integrated into it. A third-world country, due to the absence of such a subculture, needs a strong unifying identity to propel itself forward than have a faulty foundation that carries the potential to drop it into a deep identity crisis and then to endless chaos. This is especially true for countries with strong familial relationships and clan cultures. This is true for Bangabandhu’s Bangladesh, Mao’s china, Ataturk’s turkey, Lenin’s Russia, Mahathir’s Malaysia, Singapore&#39;s Lee Kuan Yew. None of these founding fathers are absolutely flawless, but the identical base must not be separated for the sake of the country’s identical cohesion. If not someone can easily sow the seeds of divisiveness and change the political landscape of the whole nation.</p><h4>The rise of the middle class…</h4><p>The political climate in Bangladesh had never been stable after its emergence as an independent and sovereign nation. The country used to be mired with political violence, political assassinations, military coup, countrywide Hartals, strikes, arsons, and vandalism. It is only fairly recently that the country is enjoying a greater degree of political stability unlike any other time before. One key reason behind this is that the government had drastically reduced poverty. Millions were lifted above extreme poverty and a near elimination was projected to be by end of 2021, which unfortunately got impeded due to the Covid crisis. The ruling party worked with a goal in mind, which is to reduce extreme poverty at any cost. The reason is simple. People who have nothing on their plate are easy political recruits. They are easy to agitate and cheap to maintain. Political oppositions usually exploit the desperation of these borderline poor young people to exert their muscle power for political gains. The government, after assuming power, barely needs them since they have far better tools at their disposal in order to exert their muscle, especially the administrative services and the armed forces which are under their command. The difference between the current regime with its predecessors is that it has greatly developed and incentivized the civil and military services, politicized them, and has brought them under a certain amount of discipline. It has made public services stronger than ever before, thus providing its muscle with more substance. It has increased the salary of public officials to a staggering 100% and in some cases even more. It has increased other associated facilities like housing, medicare, educational, advanced training and deputation opportunities, bundles of allowances, and what not. Military officials have also been bestowed with enormous facilities. All these have a political aspect to them. It has been done to keep the sensitive government bodies under control. In the previous administration, the government had comparatively little control over the administrative bodies. These places were highly inefficient, unimaginably corrupted, and had very little accountability. These places also had a deeply divisive political atmosphere. There were pro-government groups, anti-government groups among the civil and military servants. For example, in 1996, a group of public officials created “Jonotar Moncho” to oppose the incumbent government that they felt to be illegal and morally bankrupt. The government understood that they had lost their grip on the public service officials and after pressures being mounted upon them from both the general public and public service cadre, the BNP government was forced to resign at that time. The ruling party took lessons from that and hence revamped the whole public service so that agitations cannot breed within the system and no similar “Jonotar Moncho” can form. The ruling party indeed has succeeded in this project. They have successfully tamed a beast that is now under full control of the government. But the bigger beast that they had tamed is the military service. Bangladesh had a history of coups and counter-coups. The first coup started with the assassination of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman after which a lot of subsequent coups followed. There were more than 10 coups within the 50 years of the country. Some were successful while some ended up in waste. Whenever a tense political power crisis brewed in the country, armies used to take an attempt to grab state power. The recent coup attempts were in 2009 and in 2011. The current regime took power in 2009. Although many would say that the 2009 BDR mutiny was not a direct coup attempt but an outburst of legitimate grievance of BDR soldiers. It’s apparently true since this is what actually happened but the political aim behind it was to create a tensed atmosphere where the army would be forced to intervene due to the failure of the government to protect military lives, where aggrieved BDR soldiers were to be used as pawns. Once the military would get to intervene it would have shifted the state power towards them since the civil government would appear to be weak and ineffective in handling state affairs, thus nullifying the government. But the government steered through this crisis pretty intelligently. It managed the whole thing politically instead of invoking the military. This event was a wake-up call for the government that it can be ousted at any time through a potential military crisis. The next such signal came through 2011’s coup attempt, which is not much discussed in pop culture because the attempt was neutralized before any damage could have been done. Due to a lack of sensational display, it went beneath the radar. But these subsequent coup attempts, along with all the experiences from the past shaped the ruling party Awami league’s military approach. Through countless incentives, deputations, business opportunities the government tamed the military pool. Also, it heavily politicized the army, picking mostly party loyalists for sensitive posts and blocking potential troublemakers from availing those posts. This also comes from a lesson gathered from the assassination of Sheikh Mujib. A lot of Pakistani loyalists remained in the country and retained their positions in the military after the country achieved its independence. Therefore the military was politically divided with both pro-Bangladesh and anti-Bangladesh forces possessing substantial influence. The chief of staff General Shafiullah once expressed his regret that had the detective chiefs of DGFI (known as DFI back then), NSI, and military intelligence cooperated with him and provided him with substantial intelligence reports the assassination could have been prevented. These agencies blocked valuable intels from reaching the chief of staff in order to smoothen the road of Mujib’s assassination. Their complicity in this assassination came as no surprise. Back then, the chief of these intelligence agencies were the leftovers of the military faction who were loyal to Pakistan and played a questionable role in the liberation war in 1971 led by Sheikh Mujib. Although the country once liberated cannot be reverted back, but nonetheless, if the Sheikh Mujib factor could be eliminated from the political scene, it would have been easier to revert back to the old Pakistani ideals which were greatly damaged due to the liberation war. Such ideological commitment, therefore, prompted these detective chiefs to ensure the success of these operations which is why they colluded with the assassins by blocking their agencies&#39; intel from reaching the ears of senior officials like the chief of staff and other key politicians. Taking lessons from such pasts, the ruling party, therefore, politicized all the sensitive military positions so that such crises do not reappear. It was in fact about to reappear through the 2011 coup attempt. The chief belligerent of this operation major Syed Muhammad Ziaul Haque was inspired by Hizbut Tahrir and had envisioned establishing an Islamic state by overthrowing prime minister Sheikh Hasina. But as soon as major Ziaul Haque tried to convince the upper officials to join his coup project, his plan quickly got foiled because the senior officials did not agree to comply. If the military at that period had been in a disorderly shape like its predecessors, the coup attempt might have taken off. But with a military kept in line, materializing such a conspiracy is bound to be extremely difficult.</p><p>With the two big state apparatus under full political command, the ruling party faces very little threat to their state power. It had addressed all the mistakes that its predecessors have done and thus got to further tighten its grip on state power. The grip is so strong that the party has been ruling for 13 years straight without even stumbling a bit. They have already outlined a vision 2041, implying that the next 20 years of state power will be on their hands as well. Such confidence can only emerge from the fact that they have mastered in bringing the Civil and Military administration under a certain political discipline. But taming the population is even more challenging. The country hosts around 200 million people with a population density of over a thousand and with a per capita GDP of around 2500 dollars as of today. The per capita GDP was around 400 dollars 13 years back when the current regime took over state power. Although many experts criticize GDP as a growth indicator, it is an undeniable fact that the country’s wealth has increased drastically and its economy is booming. Its total GDP rose from 79 million to 310 million with a 6.4% annual growth within these 13 years. The state budget used to be around 40–50 thousand crores previously which have now scaled up to more than half a million crores as of today. Extreme poverty had been widely reduced, giving rise to a large landscape of the middle class.</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/10/opinion/biden-child-poverty-bangladesh.html">Opinion | What Can Biden&#39;s Plan Do for Poverty? Look to Bangladesh.</a></p><p>As stated earlier, a poor economy coupled with unemployment is a recipe for a political disaster, since a poor man has very little to lose. Whereas, a middle-class man has a lot of things to think about. He can lose his job, his livelihood, his home, his career, his savings, his family security, his social reputation, and a lot of other things. Very few middle-class households would be willing to risk all that, since most of them would prefer financial and social security to carry on with their lives. They would prefer to stay busy with their career and families than spend countless lazy hours on the local tea stalls gossiping and discussing politics with others. Revolutions foment through such lazy hours. Marx could never build up a following had he been busy doing a round hour job. Engels bailed him out, paid for all his expenses including his family’s so that Marx could focus on creating his line of thought. It&#39;s not like Engels was a career-focused guy either. He inherited all his wealth from his industrialist father. A similar case can be observed for Che Guevara too. He was a regular medical student with a focus on building a good medical career. But in the final cycle of his academic year, when he went on a motorbike trip throughout the whole of Latin America with his friend meeting lots of poor oppressed Latinas and other revolutionaries, is only when he became thoroughly indoctrinated with revolutionary zeal. The point is, you need to have time at your disposal, engage with people, exchange ideas, rhetorics in order to bring about a revolution. You need people who would spare their time too. Let&#39;s look over a local case. Recently the government had spiked the price of diesel to a staggering 27%. Social media erupted over such a hasty decision and was unanimously condemned. But the condemnation stuck to the virtual world. It did not get out of the social media cocoon. No one came down on the streets except for one or two political parties with a handful of protesters which won&#39;t even exceed 20–30 people in a country of around 200 million. Had it been 20 to 30 years back, the situation could have been different. Back at those times, the oppositions could easily gather thousands of people on Sohrawardi Uddyan or in the corners of Paltan. They could easily gather thousands of people within hours since the supply of such protestors was abundant. In 2004, for example, there was a huge protest led by the Awami League and its allies protesting the diesel and kerosene price hike. 50 were injured, hundreds were picked up by police. Now that the awami league is in power and had done the same thing, not a fraction of such protest can be seen in the streets, let alone protestors getting injured or picked up by the Police.</p><p><a href="https://www.voabangla.com/a/a-16-2004-12-26-voa2-94357349/1386325.html">50 hurt during General Strike in Bangladesh</a></p><p>When organizing such political protests, organizers used to hand out some 200 to 500 taka per attendee back at those times. In some cases, they were provided with foods and beverages (a craved food item in this country ) instead of hard cash. These days finding such destitute people who would join massive political rallies for such a meager amount of money or a packet of biriani is quite challenging. People do not want to risk getting caught or injured for such a poor reward. Even a poor rickshaw puller earns around a thousand taka each day. Political consciousness has also dwindled down among the masses, reducing the charm of attending political rallies. Most people now view such processions as a gathering of a bunch of jobless goons. Therefore, such a shortage of freelance destitute political pawns has made the work of the opposition parties even harder.</p><p>What’s more interesting is that the funds required to organize such big political processions are largely paid by businessmen with political affiliations. But imagine if you wanted to gather around thousands of people in the streets of Shahbagh, whereas previously some couple of lacs would do, it can now cost more than millions of takas. Businessmen don&#39;t want to scale up their donations so high and hamper their business which makes arranging the funds for such showdowns even more challenging. They would rather donate to the ruling party-led processions and stay under their favorable eyes. In fact, the government had wooed the business leaders into their cause. Although the ruling party had communism as its constitutional tenet, it has drifted far away from it. The markets have been completely liberalized by the government granting giant subsidies, loans, tax havens to incentivize investments and production. A fully focused free-market production-based economic policy had helped the government to pursue its financial targets. In order to ensure the growth of the private sector, the government’s primary focus had been on revamping the electrical infrastructure. When the government took power in 2009, it had inherited a power sector with a generational capacity of 3500MW. The capacity had since been escalated to a staggering 26,000MW as of today. The turning point was the decision of incentivizing quick rental power plants. The government enacted a controversial law, “Quick Enhancement of Electricity and Energy Supply (Special Provision) Act 2010” to fast track the energy sector in order to bring about a solution to the extant crisis. The law allowed energy investors to do unsolicited negotiations with the government in order to set up their power plants. The government planned to subsidize them even if they remained idle, paying them for their capacitive charge. Also, no tendering process would need to be followed and the whole business would not be allowed to be brought into court.</p><blockquote>“All acts done or purported to have been done, actions taken or orders made under this law shall not be called in question in any court” — a part of the provision of the bill</blockquote><p>This law was heavily opposed by every other political party, including civil society. Transparency international demanded an immediate withdraw of the bill. Local and international bodies viewed this as a tool for corruption and condemned it unanimously. But the idea behind it was to facilitate an already famished sector at the fastest pace possible. The only way to do that was to remove all barriers towards investments.</p><p><strong><em>And the idea worked.</em></strong></p><p>Today the country has a capacity of 26MW power with daily load peaking at 12–15MW each day. The uninterrupted power supply is being supplied to industries, corporations, and households. Places, where there are still interruptions, are due to faulty transmission infrastructure or some failure at the distribution end. But we have excess stock of electric energy today, which was unimaginable previously for such a small economy. And all this has only been possible due to the enactment of the “Quick Enhancement of Electricity and Energy Supply (Special Provision) Act 2010”. Through such incentives, many local and international players flocked inside the country to invest in the power sector because it appeared to be a relaxed and conducive business deal. And after that, a cumulative effect ensued. With energy sufficiency and free-market policies comes the industrial boom. Within these thirteen years, an insane industrial boom occurred. Without ensuring adequate electricity, it would have otherwise been impossible. We wouldn&#39;t even be able to enter the digital era had we not earned energy sufficiency. The country has now over 88 economic zones and a lot more are on the way. The country which used to have only one chief export, namely the garments industry, now managed to produce another promising competitor, which is the light engineering sector. This particular sector is heavily energy-intensive. We have also entered the car manufacturing era and smartphone manufacturing era. Previously Samsung once thought of investing in the country, but the electrical and political infrastructure was not in favor of their business which is why they had to shift their R&amp;D project to Vietnam. We also had Ford’s attention but due to a lack of electrical infrastructure, they never showed any further interest. There was also a time when we had to reject a Fiber Optic cable network through our country, lagging us ages behind from the modern world. Had that to happen, our country would have been digitalized a decade ago. This was the sad reality of Bangladesh previously at the core of which was poor electrical infrastructure. Those who opposed the quick rental bill at that time never had this political vision in mind which the ruling party had. At the end of the day, the ruling party had been proved to be correct with its timely policy, and not its staunch critics who accused it of corruption. It&#39;s not to say there had been no corruption and it’s not an attempt at whitewashing corruption either. But a political party needs to work with long-term visions and not shallow ones. It has to determine whether it should show zero tolerance and continue having a fragile electrical infrastructure, or risk some level of corruption to achieve energy sufficiency. Such a crucial decision against a populist idealistic bubble requires some degree of strategical which civil bodies rarely possess but experienced politicians do.</p><p><a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/10/bangladesh-climate-change/620224/?fbclid=IwAR2jpE5_Y_TBNj7PJMpgtVlc1dr337pgmCwk8giHayuxI-ZAMCo4zlrnmHU">Bangladesh Really Is a Climate Success Story</a></p><p>With energy secured, the road to economic empowerment became a lot smoother. The threat to power from economic factors has been largely reduced. Another factor that could be a threat to the ruling party’s power base is the universities. Students had been at the forefront of many national movements, starting from the language movement, liberation war to the movement against the military dictatorship and a lot of others. The military regime of Hussain Muhammad Ershad could have been toppled largely thanks to student activists occupying the streets with political slogans. Ershad banned student politics from all universities, thus fueling the fire even more. This is an agitation that Mr. Kazi Firoz Rashid, presidium member of the Jatiya Party, believed to have contributed to General Ershad’s fall. According to Mr. Rashid, he advised General Ershad not to put a ban on student politics, but he did it anyway. And the result was catastrophic for Mr. Ershad. The universities were historically at the forefront of political thought and political leader production. Launching an assault over such a rooted tradition with a hasty executive order is highly impractical. And that it was. General Ershad soon lost all control over the students, who were coming out in droves in the streets under the banner of different political parties. This is a reason why, despite numerous criticisms, no political parties after that ever took an attempt at banning student politics from university campuses despite student politics polluting the academic environment. Student politics is at the root of many problems in university campuses but banning this practice would mean losing control. And an uncontrolled campus can be turned into a recipe for political disaster, which opposition parties can successfully exploit. For example, if the ruling party proceeds to ban all sorts of student politics on university campuses, it might contain major political groups inside the campuses but it cannot make the ban effective for Islamist politics from creeping in, since it can be easily camouflaged within a spate of religious activism. And it’s not only Bangladesh who feels a sense of threat from universities. For example, the United States of America shaped its universities in such a way so that no such disaster can brew. A growing political consciousness coupled with postmodernism created a deeply political atmosphere inside American campuses in the early 60s. There were fewer pressures on the students as well since Nixon hadn&#39;t yet come forward with his ambitious student loan policies and Sallie Mae hadn’t yet been established. Among the universities, UC Berkeley used to be at the forefront of political activisms which culminated in the 1960s Berkeley protests. This was largely thanks to the rising impact of postmodernism, counterculture, and the hippie movement as a response to the World war, Vietnam war, and other warring foreign policies of the United States.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QsYqoN-mD3aE21W-.jpg" /><figcaption>Berkeley protests: Free Speech Movement in the year 1964–65</figcaption></figure><p>To subdue the threat coming out of university campuses the American government tried everything at its disposal to address these situations. They threatened to stop educational subsidies, cutting research grants and halting student loans to anyone engaging in campus rioting. Following the severity of politicization of American campuses in the 60s and 70s many local levels, state level, federal level bills were passed and appropriated just to be able to address the heightening political unrest in American campuses. After Nixon’s enactment of student loan policies and the through the establishment of Sallie Mae, campus unrest dwindled down a lot. Students required student loans, financial aids. research grants to pursue higher education. The subsequent legal system made it tougher for anyone with a trace of such activities to face immense hurdles in accessing such facilities. Also, the burgeoning student loans made sure that the students stick to academic affairs than engage in political activities since the latter would cost them more and more if their academic calendar is jeopardized. For example, the state of Tennesse enacted a law which includes,</p><blockquote>Any part-time or full-time student who is convicted of any criminal offense growing out of any student riot, protest, or disturbance shall forfeit any further right to any student loan or financial assistance supported by state funds</blockquote><p>The government thus, disincentivized such political movements coming out of universities with a good deal of success. To quote the president of Yale University Kingman Brewster, the new mood on campuses resembled an “eerie tranquility”. Another commentator is heard saying, “After six years of mounting campus turmoil, students seem suddenly to have reverted to a quiet, private style of life”. A Gallup poll soon afterward found that college students slowly started to reject all kinds of radical politics.</p><p><a href="https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/caselrev/vol22/iss3/6/">Governmental Response to Campus Unrest</a></p><p>All this had been possible only because America has a very strong state apparatus with an even stronger legal system and does not have much of a historical context. In Bangladesh, it is not possible because the state is not as strong as it purports to be. The state also cannot impose financial leashes because the economy of the country isn&#39;t even a tenth of that of the United States. The state, therefore, is bound to provide financial assistance in higher education, which the students take for granted. In private universities, however, a different picture is observed. Student politics are non-existent in private universities because there are financial backlashes that might follow. The costs of studying in these universities are too high and hampering the academic activities only bleed the individual student’s pockets even more. If banning student politics in public campuses indeed had been possible, then General Ershad would have been able to do it, but he miserably failed. This is why local context is very important to be considered before fantasizing about the American system. To contrive an effective system locally, local contexts must be present in the system’s discourse.</p><h4>Moving on…</h4><p>After public services, military, and administrative bodies have been thoroughly appropriated, the next check comes through the election commission and the judiciary. Although the judiciary is purported to be independent, it is still a highly political place. Despite the judiciary being declared independent, most of the judge recruitments still are sanctioned through law ministry, since it lacks an independent secretariat. Supreme court judges are selected by the president who is a stakeholder in the ruling party. Therefore, the system contains some degree of political signature. The recent debacle against chief justice Surendra Kumar Sinha for example. His appointment to chief justice was a political decision and so was his eventual resignation. There are other supreme court judges who also have been brought under corruption charges relieving them of their duty. Their association with the opposition political parties and their verdicts which didn&#39;t fall in line with the governments expectation are widely rumored to have contributed to their downfall. But this is not the first time the judiciary has been politicized. The previous administrations had an even stronger grasp on the judiciary. The previous BNP government even amended the constitution to change the age limit of the chief justice so that Justice K.M Hasan can legally take over the responsibility of the chief of the caretaker government. The underlying strategy for such a decision was that, since he was loyal to the party, he would assist them in getting re-elected. But a coup by General Moin U Ahmed, thwarted this plan and pushed him out of the scene. There came many other judges before who had a direct affiliation with BNP and Jamaat e Islam. For example, Justice Mozammel Haque, after retirement, was nominated by BNP to contest in the National elections. Then there was Justice Rouf, Justice Syed Modasser who later went to become Jamaat e Islam&#39;s political advisors after going to retirement. The politicization of the judiciary has become integral in our political culture. No ruling party ever spared their grip on the judiciary because otherwise, their political will becomes very tough to prevail.</p><p>Election commissions have never been independent in this country as well. Voting in this country had always been an showdown of muscle power with the election commission having very little control over the nominees. In 1996’s election the election commission allegedly created fake voter lists to make sure the BNP nominee wins some specific seats like that in Magura and some other constituencies. After news of this broke out, the opposing parties including Jamaat e Islam rioted in the streets, came under one banner with demands to establish a caretaker government for ensuring a free and fair election. When political escalation rose up even higher, the BNP government was forced to amend the constitution and resign from power. Caretaker governments rarely come at an advantage of the ruling party. Hence whenever a caretaker governments comes into power a transfer in power follows. To eliminate this possibility BNP tried to put their preferred candidate, Justice Sayem, in the power of caretaker government through amending the constitution. But General Moin U Uddin Ahmed’s coup foiled that. After the caretaker government of General Moin U Ahmed relinquished their power, threw national elections through which Awami League got elected, they became busy erasing the threat of the caretaker government decree which eventually would have once again shifted the state power once their term ends. Hence they used the judiciary to rule the caretaker government system illegal and then erased the caretaker government amendment from the constitution. The biggest blunder of BNP was boycotting the parliament. Because despite losing the national election, they had a sizable representation in the parliament through whom they could take an attempt to block the bill against the caretaker government, but their absence in parliament gave the bill an uncontested majority. Now, with the caretaker government out of sight, the elections got institutionalized to be under the ruling party’s supervision. Although the government says it plays no influence over the whole election process since all the responsibility falls over the election commission due to it being free, but then again the election commission is as free as the judiciary is. Like the judiciary, the election commission is also elected by the ruling party. There was supposed to be a law for the selection of election commissioner but no government till now had taken an attempt in formulating one. If legislation is made, then parties cannot select people out of their whim. If the law is made to favor the ruling party, they can never make a comeback when they go out of power. If the law is made to make the election commission completely independent, then the threat of power becomes even more pronounced. Hence the line is always kept blurred so that the ruling party can act as they please. The current election commissioner for example. He was alleged to be a member of “Janatar Moncho” by the BNP establishment, but he outright denied such claims. He was also made OSD (Officer on Special Duty) as a punishment when the BNP government assumed power in 2001. And now with the Awami League government back in power, he was rewarded with the responsibility of assuming the position of the chief of the election commission. Hence, despite how much the ruling party justifies, it would be very hard to convince anyone that the election commissioner is politically unbiased and neutral.</p><h4>Foreign policies…</h4><p>The last threat that remains for the government comes from foreign powers. The difference between the current administration and the previous ones is that the current administration has a more inclusive foreign policy approach than its predecessors who had a blinkered approach towards their foreign policy. When Sheikh Mujib formed the government in 1972, the country was inclined towards the India-Soviet Union block. Soon after the country was liberated, the severe divisiveness and mismanagement forced Sheikh Mujib to think of an alternate plan. He took inspiration from communist countries and tried to form a one-party state under the name Bakshal (Bangladesh Krishok Sromik Awami league). Zafrullah Chowdhury, a war veteran and trustee of Gonoshastho Kendra who is now a politician on the opposition front, once recounted an incident to the media where Sheikh Mujib invited him to join bakshal. According to his testimony, Sheikh Mujib drew inspiration from communist countries to create bakshal in order to bring the whole country under a political discipline. The post-1971 era was rife with political divisions among the military, Awami league leaders, Jashod, NAP, Rakkhibahini, etc. The increased political escalations were making the country extremely challenging to govern. Sheikh Mujib is said to have famously quoted that he inherited a “mine of thieves” referring to the corrupt politicians who were busy looting public funds and foreign donations. He expressed his concerns to Zafrullah Chowdhury and asked him to join Bakshal, but Mr. Zafruallah declined. Despite being an ardent communist himself, he told Sheikh Mujib that it would be an unwise decision for Mr. Mujib to pursue that path. He feared that Sheikh Mujib, being an ever-evolving politician, would not realize communism at its purest form and that it&#39;s better left to be exercised by theory totting communists who spend day and night memorizing Lenin, Marx, Engels, Mao, Castro, Guevara, etc. Mr. Mujib assured him that he had done his math and came to conclude that this was the only way to solve the existing political crisis, but Zafrullah remained unconvinced. Right after that day, Zafrullah Chowdhury flew to London to pursue his medical studies and soon as he dropped at the airport, he got the news that Sheikh Mujib has been assassinated by a rogue military faction. Although local military personnel was responsible for his death, it is widely alleged that there were international backers behind this assassination, namely the American-ISI establishment in order to eliminate the soviet-communist influence from South Asia&#39;s backyard. Indian detectives had that intel and tried to warn Sheikh Mujib and his wife, but both of them ignored the alarm believing that his own countrymen can never even think of doing such a thing. Given the track record of the CIA and ISI, it comes as no surprise for them to exploit the domestic in order to carry out their agenda. After killing Sheikh Mujib the country reverted back to it’s Pakistani ideals. Bengali nationalism was tried to be erased from the constitution since Pakistanis used to conflate Bengali with Hindu identity. Bangladesh Betar was renamed to Radio Pakistan and the country started to rapidly Islamize. Khandaker Mushtaq, the incumbent prime minister used to idolize Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Pakistan&#39;s founder, in all manner possible including his attires. Before the birth of Bangladesh, he even tried to oppose Bangladesh’s liberation and thought of building a federation state with Pakistan like today’s Russian federation. He was even set out to take this proposal to the united nations but after his plan got exposed, Sheikh Mujib barred him from going to the UN. It was Sheikh Mujibs’ worst decision to keep him as his political colleague despite him doing such subversive actions. When asked, why he kept him close despite not being a trustworthy guy, he famously said, “Keep your enemies closer so that they have troubles committing much mischief”. After he got the opportunity to assume premiership due to Sheikh Mujib’s assassination, he instantly grabbed it, and started to manifest his Jinnah vision and turn the country into another Pakistan proxy. Since then the country started to fall into the Islamist rabbit hole. The subsequent military governments amended the constitution to make it more Islamic. They erased “Secularism” from the constitution which was one of the constitutional pillars of our newborn nation. They added “Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim” as a preamble to the constitution, which was a big blow to the secularist nature of the constitution that the intellectuals formed. They also repealed the constitutional law which banned religion-based political parties, thus clearing the way for Jamaat e Islam, a Pakistan-based Islamist political party that openly opposed liberation war and was accused of war crimes to conduct their political activities in Bangladesh. The country started to become institutionally communal. The governments engineered such a system that would push the country towards a Pakistani system of thought, weakening the Bengali identity. Anything that had a Bengali signature was considered to be remnants of Hindu culture and therefore, were disincentivized or vehemently opposed. For example, Rabindranath’s creations were a popular target, and so was the national anthem which they deemed to have animist Hindu influence. Bengali traditions like Pahela Baisakh, Jatrabala, Musicals, Lalon Mela, local seasonal festivals, etc. were constantly being pushed under the rug for being in conflict with the state-sanctioned identity. “Joy Bangla” slogan was banned for having similarities with “jay hind” and was subsequently replaced with “Bangladesh Zindabad” in accordance with “Pakistan Zindabad”. Instead of incentivizing Bengali traditions and cultures, the country started to bulk import Saudi Wahabism through madrasas and through labor exchange programs with the middle east. The educational vacuum of the rural areas was quickly replaced by madrasa facilitated systems, slowly changing the whole cultural demography. The government at those periods, for their allegiance to the pan Islamist philosophy, largely ignored the cultural shift that was happening across the whole country, and in some cases, they even abetted them since this ideological shift would benefit their vote banks. Such changes culminated when the Afghan war happened. Many Bangladeshi people went to Afghanistan to fight against infidel Soviets alongside the mujahideen to liberate Afghanistan. After the war, many of the trained jihadi militants came back to Bangladesh and started campaigning locally for an Islamic state. Many Islamist NGOs propped up recruiting thousand into their cause. Many of these hardline Islamists even ended up representing in the parliament, through forming alliances with the major parties. It&#39;s only when militant activities were rampaging the whole country, that the governments started to pay attention to the elephant in the room. But they were largely unsuccessful since they never had a counterbalancing strategy against the system that had been carefully brewed by the Islamists. One of the afghan returnee militants, Mufti Hannan, formed Huji (Harkat-Ul-Jihad) with the sponsorship of IIF (International Islamic Front). They were responsible for carrying out the largest grenade attack in 2004, against the opposition party at that time which was Awami League. According to the confessions of Mufti Hannan, the threat to Islamism was the primary motive for militants to plot and carry out this attack. Although it had political patronage, the militants were primarily stimulated with Islamist propaganda. Then there was the rise of Bangla Bhai, Shaykh Abdur Rahman, and the emergence of Jamatul Mujahedeen Bangladesh. Initially, they received heavy state patronage but after their militant activities spiraled out of control, the government started to take brute force action. To contain islamist militancy and also to contain political terrorism, the BNP government at that time, introduced a new police division under the name Rapid Action Battalion. Through RAB the culture of crossfire which is just a euphemism for extrajudicial killings got established. One such notorious operation by RAB was operation cleanheart which was its earliest operation in history. But operations like these were alleged to have been used by the people in power to stifle political oppositions and eradicate their influence than actually combating militant leaders and terrorists. In fact this very extrajudicial killing of the govt at that time was the selling point of Awami League in its next elections. It pledged to people that it would stop the culture of extrajudicial killing once it assumes power. But such promise never saw the light of the day. The party, soon after assuming power, kept the system as it was. Although the party reduced extrajudicial killings, they never dismantled the culture completely for its own expediency. Hence militant threat was never curbed out but instead got even more amplified. Huji had been responsible for collaborating in another bone-chilling attack that had shaken up the whole nation. In 2005, JMB was responsible for carrying out a series of grenade attacks throughout all the districts (63 out of 64) of Bangladesh in order to shake the political establishments with Huji as its collaborator. Numerous attempts had been made to assassinate Sheikh Hasina, organized mostly by fundamentalist forces who feared a secular reemergence through her party. Many literary activists, cultural activists like Humayun Azad, Shamsur Rahman were attacked. Pahela Baishakh ceremony at Ramna Batamul was bombed which caused a number of deaths. The liberation war history was gradually being distorted and slowly being erased against which a blogger pushback emerged. Many bloggers were hacked to death by Islamists due to looming allegations of blasphemy on them. Another incident to note was the 10-truck arms haul case. Bangladesh was being used as a transit for arms smuggling into the border states like Assam and Tripura to aid the separatism movement there. More interestingly, the state minister of home affairs, Lutfuzzaman Babar, along with the detective chiefs was found out to be directly involved in this matter. After BNP lost power, they got convicted and tried with life imprisonment. The country soon earned an image of becoming a terrorist hub throughout the whole world. Coupled with this, the heightening political and economic crisis and rampant state corruption got the country labeled as a failing state. A leaked envoy from the US state department stated that the country was being run by a kleptocratic government with the leadership being injurious to US interests. Very few foreign investments were coming in and the country was gradually losing grip on foreign diplomacy too. All of these contributed to the caretaker government crisis. It is largely rumored that the coup had international patronage and that General Moeen did not take such a bold attempt out of his own accord. The international brokers are rumored to have wanted Professor Yunus, a novel laureate from Bangladesh to get on board but he declined the offer unless offered the position for 10 years straight. Fakhruddin Ahmed was later brought in instead of him. The interim government was welcomed by the Awami league but strongly opposed by BNP. But, soon after the caretaker government launched legal assaults against all dominant parties using Anti Corruption Commission, it lost all domestic political support. Meanwhile, Awami league held frequent meetings with a number of foreign diplomats and tried to ensure that international support sways on their side. General Moeen U Ahmed wanted to sit for an even longer period of time but eventually, he was forced to call elections and concede the state power to a domestic political party. Due to a surge in popularity of the Awami League at that time because of the institutional failure of the BNP government, and also because of the party&#39;s diplomatic advantage along with conducive settlements with the interim government, Awami League swept into state power after the interim government disintegrated. The political settlements between Awami League and the interim government of General Moeen U Ahmed can be found in Pranab Mukherjee’s book where he expressed his concerns about General and his team’s safe exist, urging the ruling party to ensure a safe passage out for this group. And it in fact happened. The general along with his associates like Fakhruddin Ahmed got a safe passage out without the government trying to meddle into it. As a party Awami league matured a lot. In its previous tenures, it did not have a wisely crafted foreign diplomacy. Sheikh Hasina herself admits that she did not play by the rules of foreign players with regards to international diplomacy, and hence lost international support when she contested in 2001 national elections. It is even rumored that the station chief of Indian intelligence, who was at a local function with other diplomats and civil servants was heavily elated when he heard Awami league had lost in the national elections in 2001. The NSA adviser of the Indian Government Brajesh Mishra set up his connections to the BNP establishment through station chief Tony Mathur. Although the Vajpayee government fell out of favor with Sheikh Hasina for favoring her opposition, the other political elites in India were still in favor of Sheikh Hasina, especially from West Bengal and Congress. Even some senior BJP leaders did not take it lightly. Tathagata Roy, for example, publicly castigated Mishra for causing such a huge political blunder. The concerns were not at all exaggerated, which would be later proven by the heightened militant activities and security breaches through the Indian borders. Nevertheless, the BJP never completely cut its ties with the BNP establishment. When BJP took over state power once again in 2014 defeating Congress, BNP leaders threw parties and distributed sweets across their Paltan office as a celebration. They considered it as a major win for themselves since they might have a shot at getting diplomatic leverage over the Awami League government who had historically been close with congress. But despite Awami League’s bitter past with the BJP government, they slowly appropriated the BJP government into their cause, by proving themselves to be better security, strategic, and business partner than all of its predecessors.</p><p><a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/op-ed/politics/behind-the-raw-tirade-1377514">Behind the &quot;RAW&quot; tirade</a></p><p>The big game that Awami League played here is shaping its policy to “Friendship to all, Malice to None.” It purported itself as the least belligerent party which would be able to provide better regional stability while also ensuring a stable business partnership. Other major political parties had a belligerent approach in their foreign policy vision. Jamaat e Islam for example was aligned with the ISI-Arab establishment, which was antagonistic towards Indians and the secular forces. BNP, due to its alliance with Jamaat e Islam had to lean towards their policy. They also used to have American support in their favor as a remnant from the ISI establishment, but after a surge of militancy, that support too started to wane. Awami league grabbed this opportunity and made anti-militancy at the core of their campaign. It showed itself as the only secularist party capable of combating militancy. BNP could not integrate secularism in its system due to its major stakeholder being jamaat e Islam, an Islamist party. Thus, the party could not but capitulate to Awami League on diplomatic grounds. Since assuming state power, Awami League has employed its foreign diplomats very sensitively. Gawher Rizvee, Dipu Moni, A K Abdul Momen, Shahriar Alam all have a fairly clean and commendable record compared to other ministers and advisors. But its not like it was all rainbow and sunshine for the foreign department. For example, when the war criminal trials were fomenting, the ISI-Arab bloc which included America severely pressured the government to withdraw these trials. But the government did not budge considering local political scenario. Support for the trials was skyhigh and it was Awami League’s one of the most popular election manifesto to bring war criminals under trial. Also it was vital towards earning them an ideological point over the others. Things went so bad that turkey called back its ambassador. Qatar, Saudi Arabia, HRW all stood staunchly against the trials. Pakistan and Bangladesh went to a diplomatic row as well, since the Pakistani establishment vigorously defended the accused and branded them as martyrs for Islam. But the party quickly recouped its diplomatic presence in the international arena. From calling back its ambassador, Turkey has now entered into making arms deals with Bangladesh which usually do not happen unless strong diplomatic relations are present. Arab states also have warmed up their relations, through broadening business ties and intensifying labor exchange programs. The success of Awami League’s diplomatic efforts can be realized through observing the foreign powers’ reactions to the Bangladeshi election. Despite wide allegations of voter fraud, no foreign powers ever cared to pay any attention to these allegations. Although things are now starting to change due to US-China power struggle, nevertheless the party has tried its best to balance out its strategical position. Balancing strategy is advantageous for another reason. It frees a country from monopolistic influence from other foreign powers. This provides it with earning a bargaining power. Pakistan, North Korea, Mayanmar for example, has a full reliance on china, and hence they can&#39;t afford to have much bargaining power over their patron. India, Australia has a full reliance on USA, hence they can&#39;t say much here either. The AUKUS deal, for example, was coerced by US and Australia had to oblige. Australia&#39;s diplomatic relations with European countries bled heavily due to this deal. Same with the Huawei debacle over privacy concerns. Following US influence, Australia kicked out Huawei, strained its relation with China and continued prolonging the feud. In the end, it was Australian economy that bled out, and Americans did not come forward to pay the damage. Same unilateral monopolies can be found throughout other foreign powers, for example, Russia-Syria, Iran-lebanon, Iran-Iraq, Afghanistan-Pakistan, Israel-USA, Russia-Belarus, Turkey-Russia, etc. Many would claim that such a monopolistic dichotomy exists in the case of India-Bangladesh too. But it does not. Bangladesh has more trade deficit with China than it has with India. JICA is one of the leading partners in the developments of Bangladesh along with WB and ADB. And if we talk about political clout, then it falls flat too. While it is true that the Awami league government gets to enjoy more support from India, but that&#39;s because India has a stake in it. It is the only party that is friendly towards India, and the only party that could provide a better security in the region. All of the other political parties fuel their politics with anti-Indian xenophobic rhetorics in order to earn populist support, which is of course seen as a political threat inside the Indian establishment. Although rhetorics, but the fear of manifestations lies there. And it’s not the opposing powers that use xenophobic antagonisms. Every party chooses a villain in their story. Since India borders 98% of our country, therefore, we get to interact with India more than any other regional neighbor. Almost all of the rivers in Bangladesh come through the Indian borders except for shangu and matamuhuri which come through mayanmar. There had been long time water disputes, border disputes, maritime disputes, enclave disputes, smuggling disputes and many other disputes between the two countries. Such unresolved conflicts were a legitimate cause for fueling Bangladeshi grievances. There is also a post-partition and pro-pakistani influence in the country (since the country was previously east Pakistan) which helps the opposition to politically capitalize on these sentiments. But the biggest irony is, the parties who championed themselves as the hero against Indian oppression were the least successful in mediating deals with India. The enclave disputes have been solved by pro-india party Awami league. The maritime dispute has been solved by Awami league too. When BNP was in power, the BGB and BSF were frequently locked in violent clashes, border breaches and illegal migrations were rampant, all of which pushed the Indian government to order shoot on sight and also to fence the borders. The fence did not exist before, but due to non-cooperation and volatile border situation, it had to be instated. Another interesting thing is that the water treaties were also mediated by Pro-Indian party, and the not the oppositions. Teesta water treaty, which has been a long-time bone of contention between the two countries is being tried to solved through the financial and technical assistance of China, India’s arch-enemy, by setting up an 80 billion dollar comprehensive management and restoration project on teesta’s banks inside the Bangladeshi border. For a Pro-Indian party to invite India’s arch-enemy in its border territory obviously raises eyebrows. But that&#39;s strategical planning. The other governments experimented with belligerence, non-cooperation but could achieve nothing. As a party with experience, the current government cooperated, showed friendliness in order to come to mutual resolutions, and only when the approaches weren’t being reciprocated from the other side, is when they decide to invite third parties while simultaneously not appearing belligerent to avoid diplomatic tensions.</p><p>So in a sense, the opposite is true. India needs Awami League for greater regional security and regional cooperation. Now with most other regional countries like Nepal, Afghanistan, Sri Lanka, Tibet, Pakistan out of its orbit, it needs a reliable local partner like Bangladesh more than ever before. Through this foreign policy mechanism, Awami League had effectively thwarted away threats from foreign powers from all over. There is of course one Achilles heel in Bangladesh’s foreign policy that has the potential to wreak havoc in Bangladesh’s political atmosphere. And that is the Rohingya crisis. Refugee crisis has changed the course of political discourse in the European world, giving birth to massive right-wing xenophobic populism in places where these would have been previously unimaginable. For example, the rise of the AFD party in Germany. To think that the refugee crisis won&#39;t affect Bangladesh on such a grander scale would be a naive thing to think. But for a small power like Bangladesh, no matter how good the diplomatic efforts are, it is quite impossible to solve this crisis unless the superpowers come forward in good faith. If they continue fuelling the crisis, which they do since they all have a major stake in it, then repatriation efforts would obviously fall flat. Only a geopolitical miracle can solve this crisis which for a small economy country like Bangladesh is pretty tough to engineer.</p><p><strong>Ideologies…</strong></p><p>To quote stuart hall,</p><blockquote>The problem of ideology, therefore, concerns the ways in which ideas of different kinds grip the minds of masses, and thereby become a `material force’. In this, more politicized, perspective, the theory of ideology helps us to analyse how a particular set of ideas comes to dominate the social thinking of a historical bloc, in Gramsci’s sense; and, thus, helps to unite such a bloc from the inside, and maintain its dominance and leadership over society as a whole. It has especially to do with the concepts and the languages of practical thought which stabilize a particular form of power and domination; or which reconcile and accommodate the mass of the people to their subordinate place in the social formation. It has also to do with the processes by which new forms of consciousness, new conceptions of the world, arise, which move the masses of the people into historical action against the prevailing system.</blockquote><p>Ideology has always riddled philosophers since it has been coined by De Tracy, a french philosopher who was associated with the French Revolution. De Tracy wrote a book called <em>Eléments d’idéologie, </em>in which, he explores ideas that shape people’s minds and reality. De Tracy tried to formulate ideology as a “Science of Ideas” but it soon got detached from a “scientific methodology” to the ideas themselves. Most of the credit goes to Napoleon Bonaparte who viewed ideology as a sinister term and branding anyone ideologues whom he thought to be a threat to his power, especially to De Tracy&#39;s liberal, republican followers. Since then it has been used synonymously with just “ideas” in political science. Marx and Engels took on De Tracy’s work and tried to formulate what constitutes ideology to explain the system around them. The book “ The German Ideology” is a result of such inquiry.</p><blockquote>Morality, religion, metaphysics, all the rest of ideology and their corresponding forms of consciousness no longer retain the semblance of independence; they have no history and no development; but men, developing their material production and their material intercourse, alter, along with their real existence, their thinking and the products of their collective thinking.- Marx &amp; Engels</blockquote><p>But their work was inconclusive. Some Marxists Scholars interpreted that economic and materialistic conditions fueled capitalist class structures. But other Marxists like Althusser differed in such Marxist interpretations. Althusser’s book “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses” is a counter interpretation to such Marxist narratives. He contended that material conditions are not enough to explain why masses act against their self-interest and successful revolutions are not born. He opined that there are two categories of power that hold a capitalist system firm to its ground. One is fear and another is ideology. Fear is a euphemism for repressive state apparatuses, for example, police, military, courtrooms militias, etc. Ideological state apparatuses are institutions that shape minds and lures subjects to conform within a system. Universities, Churches, Seminars, Convocations Rallies etc. to name some. The power of ideology was comprehended by Gramsci too. He wrote on hegemony, taking ideologies one step further. Gramsci contended that political parties come up with an ideology; a set of ideals to attract people. Once someone gets enticed and harmonized with it, then he submits his loyalty to the party either consciously or subconsciously. Then the party gets to make decisions on behalf of him which they know would be met with little opposition due to their follower’s loyalty. Thus they get to create a hegemony based on a set of ideologies. Gramsci understood that hegemonical loyalty is key to keeping the system going and suppressing rebellions. Loyalty works better to control than fear because fear can sometimes cause eruption whereas loyalty would ensure order. Gramsci, Althusser, and other Marxists propounded their theories to explain what keeps a capitalist system functioning, not exactly for a particular political party. For example, in the US there are two chief political parties, the republicans and the democrats. Powers exchange hands once in 5 years but the systems remain the same. Althusser and Gramsci tried to theorize what keeps the system, the capitalist system stable against a potential worker revolution. But their theory can be extended to any political party and their grip on power too. Loyalty and institutional conditioning can keep one party in power while suppressing the others. It does not necessarily have to wander into the dichotomy of capitalism and communism. Since the American system has large checks and balances, therefore, parties cannot build absolute hegemony. But in China, Russia, for example, absolute hegemony is possible and it did in fact, happen. Chinese hegemony is unparalleled unless we count North Korea. The same hegemonical approach was observed in Singapore, in Vietnam, in Rwanda and many would say Bangladesh would satisfy such criteria as well. But i would contend that Bangladesh although had been able to build up a hegemony but its hegemony was powered by Repressive State Apparatuses rather than Ideological State Apparatuses, following Althusser’s theory. The party’s ideological foothold has decayed tremendously whereas global Islamism is slowly replacing it as its alternative. The party focused so much on infrastructures that it forgot to take care of the Ideological formation of the nation. It wanted to force its ideology on people but that only backfired. What it should have done instead is that it should have made its core ideology more appealing which it failed to do miserably. The country fell in war before because of an identical conflict that might reappear again someday soon due to increasing ideological and cultural polarisations. This reminds me of Samuel P Huntington’s book, “The clash of civilizations”. Although many prominent activists and thinkers dismiss the book as deeply problematic and racist, we know most of what he said is true. Huntington predicted that future clashes would be based on cultural identity rather than any other tangible one. Many say such theories simplify conflicts and promulgate racism against certain cultures. But it does not. In India for example, the country has fallen under deep conflict surrounding Hindutva and the Islamic identity. In Bangladesh, communal tensions had risen up as well since people are getting conscious regarding their religious identity. In Myanmar, a similar case can be observed with Rohingya Muslims, ethnic Burmese, and mainland citizens. In Afghanistan, the Taliban was in conflict with the westernized government of Ashraf Ghani. Iraq faces tensions between Sunnis and Shias, Lebanon faces problems within Shias, Sunnis, and Christians. Yemen faces tensions between the Saudi-backed Sunni government vs the Iran-backed Shia(Houthi) rebels. Syria had conflicts between Sunnis and Alawites. Rwanda faced genocide due to a conflict between Hutus and Tutsis. Ethiopia is at a war now between Abiy Ahmed-led Amharas and Tigray Rebels. South Africa is getting increasingly hostile towards South Asians. Racial tensions are getting more and more pronounced in America. Therefore, to ignore such instances is to live under a rock. But for many academics and social activists, admitting such factors is not politically correct and therefore can be detrimental to their career. The conventional wisdom is cultures and races cannot be vilified since they might propagate racism. Conflicts happen not for cultural or racial differences but for systemic discrimination. What they usually miss is that ideological differences have a cryptic power that can translate into material reality. Being aware of such potential is better than twisting it, since it can help in finding solutions. Slavoj Zizek for example once contested Mehdi from Al Jazeera on this.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FqkdPZ-UmrSw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DqkdPZ-UmrSw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FqkdPZ-UmrSw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6f12c965623f995347ec2c149edfc0cd/href">https://medium.com/media/6f12c965623f995347ec2c149edfc0cd/href</a></iframe><p>Social activists contend that ideas do not pose problems but material conditions. Such a materialistic view might be true in some cases but the power of ideologies should not be underestimated. Ideas and beliefs can move mountains. Every people act on their beliefs. Even Marx and Engels, who were peak materialists, could not imagine people out of the realm of ideology. If someone is corrupt and greedy, that springs from a self-centric, Ayn Rand style viewpoint, the core of which is “a focus on the self”. If someone is patriotic, philanthropic then that springs from a collectivist viewpoint. Many give up their lives out of nationalistic fervor, fighting imperialism. Many on the other hand propagate imperialism out of nationalistic fervor. Similarly, we can find communist zealots, right-wing zealots, cult maniacs, tribal supremacists, etc. And let&#39;s not forget religious zealotry. Without religious zealotry, the Taliban resurgence cannot be explained. The Taliban fighters only lived on bread and water against heavily-armed US and Nato forces and also the Afghan army. But in the end, they ended up victorious over the rest, and all of it is thanks to the sheer force of their ideology which indoctrinated their minds. Ideologies also have the power to blind people from common sense since context can shape minds without even them being aware. To quote Barbara J. fields…</p><blockquote>Ideas about color, like ideas about anything else, derive their importance, indeed their very definition, from their context. They can no more be the unmediated reflex of psychic impressions than can any other ideas. It is ideological context that tells people which details to notice, which to ignore, which to take for granted in translating the world around them into ideas about the world.</blockquote><p>Different cultures shape people’s reality differently which is the very essence of clash of civilizations. Although I highly doubt Barbara J. Fields would agree with Samuel P. Huntington, nonetheless, her proposition that reality is shaped according to contexts coincides with Huntington’s assumption that different ideologies can create different conception of reality which may end up in collision once tensions starts to brew.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RWV-SsUv35B9eFDoYj4KvQ.png" /><figcaption>Two contrasting nationalist propaganda centering the middle east.</figcaption></figure><p>Politics is largely dependent on ideologies. Ideologies calibrate people within a cause, empowering those who are the vendors. Those who can effectively sell ideologies can climb up the ladder of power much efficiently than those whose ideologies are weak. Ideologies captivate people, shape their minds and drive them towards taking action. While it is true that ideologies aren’t going to grow crops on your farm and neither it is going to light up the bulb in your room, but sometimes a mere slip in effective policymaking can get shrouded out by ideological blows. For example, Afghanistan had a more or less functioning government despite how much corrupted it was. It was more experienced in modern state governance than the Taliban ever had. But for the lack of a cohesive ideology, their hegemony was soon overhauled by the Taliban&#39;s strong ideology. After the Taliban’s ascendancy, the country has been suffering extremely on economic and infrastructural grounds but there are no contesting ideologies that can drive people out on the streets against them. Actually, there are far better ideologies out in the world that can contest the Taliban’s ideology but to galvanize these into people’s minds you need an equally powerful political party to promulgate and dissipate these ideas. Extreme ideologies can plant vigor into people which can make them act selflessly. Nationalism, religion are the biggest examples. Wars that had been waged in the name of nationalist or religious ideology sustained more deaths than wars that had little ideological drive. Taliban’s ideology falls under such extreme. According to senior Taliban officials, many of their workers spent day and night on only bread and water but never showed disloyalty. No matter what happens, even if people starve, ideologies will drive them forward. Turkey, for example, is now in a deep economic crisis after Erdogan’s poor economic policies. Inflations are at an all-time high, banks are failing and so is its regional stability. But the only thing that&#39;s keeping him in power, is his populistic nationalist and religious rhetoric. Although his days are numbered because, unlike Afghanistan, turkey has some level of ideological competitors. The chief competitor being the secular Ataturkian philosophy which is still quite powerful than Erdogan&#39;s neo-Islamist policies. Afghanistan sadly had none. Taliban’s philosophy is so strong that no other local ideologies can ever dream of challenging its hegemony. The Ghani government was void at its core. He was seen by the local people as a western puppet holding power to serve western interests. Despite their efforts and everything, they were always considered as a placeholder for foreigners. Their political blunders and human right violations along with the US and Nato forces only exacerbated their local image and fueled xenophobia. A government cannot be bulletproof, it is bound to have some mistakes. And mistakes it did, a lot of it. The governments were massively corrupted, many public officials and military servicemen were unpaid for months due to rampant corruption of senior officials and politicians, gross human rights violations were being perpetrated in the name of combating the Taliban, and no local political context was built up leaving a big ideological vacuum. The leaders were in fact, imported from the Afghan diaspora who dwelled outside most of their lives. For a diaspora living abroad for most of their lives, connecting with locals can be very challenging. Also, most of the developments were Kabul centric whereas other parts of the country were greatly overlooked and in many cases ravaged in the name of combating the Taliban. Many innocent people lost their lives, which the Nato and US forces justified as collateral damages. But all this brutality and destruction pushed people towards siding up with the Taliban. The Taliban capitalized on their grievances and showed them a way out. They filled up their moral void, gave them purpose, and filled them with ideological fervor. The Ghani government was working with long-term goals and strategies but such things do not directly talk to people. Regular afghanis wouldn&#39;t comprehend or be fascinated with Ashraf Ghani&#39;s Ted talks but rather would have been enchanted by a leader with charismatic rhetorics and moral hyperboles. Taliban provided exactly that, easily comprehensible religious rhetorics and voluntary services. For example, Taliban ran a justice system of their own in parallel to the Afghan Justice system. It was hugely famous for conveying swift justice, whereas the Afghan government’s justice processes were largely lengthy. One reason was that the Afghan government modeled the justice system according to the lengthy foreign justice system similar to that of the French with some elements of shariah law. Modern justice processes are by default supposed to be lengthy since there are multiple steps to be completed for a fair justice. As it is said, justice hurried is justice buried. But people want instant justice, especially people of third world countries where people have a hard time understanding nuances. Another reason was that the courts were highly corrupted. Without bribes, very few cases saw the light of the day. Many came out of the courts with unjust verdicts even after offering bribes. The Taliban showed people that man-made law is bound to fail and that Islam offers salvage. Taliban’s first advantage was that in a place mired with regressive ideals, people are generally weak towards religion and do not question the authority of it. Adding to that, the failure of the hybrid justice system only reaffirmed to the afghans the need for a theocratic justice system, thus surging the popularity of Taliban.</p><p>For a establishment, slips would be made here and there, and these slips, no matter how minor or major, are amplified by opposing powers. Opposing powers sell people a dream of a utopian land that is being stunted due to the mismanagement of the immoral ruling power. The success of such opposing power depends on two things. Firstly, the ruling power has to fail in holding the systems from collapsing, and secondly, the ideology of the opposition has to be easily digestible, full of slogans and rhetorics, morally validating, comprehensible to everyone, and also should seem utopian. Ideological strengths depend on the strength of its narratives. A perfect utopian government can be toppled through a strong ideology. All it needs to do is find some loopholes in the system and magnify it to the extreme so that people get panicked. People eat up sensational stories easily, which easily explains the popularity of cinemas, fiction, artworks, etc. In a mature democracy with a functioning system along with a good enough educational base, extreme ideologies like that of the Taliban, would have faced a tough time getting ground. Because then people would understand and care about nuances, can be able to comprehend complexities which as a result can make them rely less on rhetorics. Therefore, most extreme ideologies can be seen to proliferate in underdeveloped or developing countries. Developing countries are the worst hurt since developmental works come up with a lot of holes that can be easily manipulated and ideologically exploited. Bangladesh, Maldives, Indonesia, India, Pakistan, Philippines, Cambodia, Mexico, etc. for example. Extreme ideologies are populistic and rhetorical in nature but lack nuances. Be it hardline communist ideologies or Islamist ideologies, despite both of them playing on people’s frustrations, they do not offer practical solutions for a 21st-century state. This is why such endeavors always fail. There is effectively no communist state in existence today apart from North Korea, which again, is a pariah state. A highly ambitious Islamic state was formed in Syria but it too failed within a couple of years. Such models might work in very small-scale isolated domains, for example, what Al Shabab does in much of Somalia or what the Taliban did in many discreet parts of rural Afghanistan before coming into power. But when they rise to state power, all of their policies start to fail much like what’s happening in Afghanistan right now.</p><p>Symbols are important too. They cement ideologies into a culture. This is why statues are built, roads are named after people and movements, national holidays are observed, national emblems are declared, etc. This is also why statues are targeted, emblems are overturned, roads and bridges are renamed once the power gets to change hands. Such crude political stunts happen especially in those countries where the fundamental identical issues are not dealt with, for example, what would define a country or a nation who are residing in it. Which historical narrative would work as the anchor. Without such an anchor a country can fall into chaos. Everyone will want to establish their narrative creating a massive fuss, which would only fuel divisiveness and push towards further conflicts. This happens especially in countries with multi-ethnicity and multi-religious demography. For example, the ethnic divide in Ethiopia, which is fueling the Ethiopian crisis. The Rwandan genocide was a fight between the two major ethnic groups Hutu and Tutsi over power. Similar things can be seen in most parts of Africa and in many parts of the middle east. Afghanistan is a land mired by ethnic conflicts which made it impossible for anyone including the world’s two biggest superpowers (Soviet and the USA) to fix. As for religious tensions, look no further than Lebanon. The country was in a civil war due to a power crisis between the Shia population, Sunni population, and Christian population. After a power-sharing treaty was proposed, the civil war stopped, but the tensions didn&#39;t. Whenever a crisis appeared, so did old wounds. The recent economic crisis in Lebanon had escalated identity conflicts even further down and it wouldn&#39;t come as a surprise if another civil war brews. In Syria, Iraq, Yemen similar cases can be observed. All it requires is an issue and it can trigger large-scale sectarian or ethnic violence all over a country. To solidify the narrative of one ethnic group over the other, one religious group over the other, symbols are used. When ISIS took over in Syria, it destroyed every statue and remnants of Syria’s historical past including those in the museums to purify their land. Same with Afghanistan. When the Taliban previously took over they destroyed statues, shrines, temples, and artifacts in order to establish a religiously homogenized country. One such famous sensation was the destruction of the Bamiyan Buddha. Whenever the Taliban threat loomed around the corner, museum curators and others used to channel the precious artifacts through the black markets which diplomats used to collect in order to preserve. The go-to place for these diplomats to collect these ancient gems were the local wet markets and vegetable traders. The traders used to collect these from curators, conceal them within their vegetables and sell them to diplomats for a very good price. Another way to collect them was through Pakistan, which used to be the smuggling corridor for these ancient artifacts.</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/04/magazine/ghazni-panels-afghanistan-art.html?smid=fb-share&amp;fbclid=IwAR0sS4H6-P1SiJjvN7geAbfkuyHUhxTzrgfdycQ5spZtf423lMjf38fcqII">How One Looted Artifact Tells the Story of Modern Afghanistan</a></p><p>In Australia recently a Gandhi statue got vandalized, in Balochistan Jinnah statues got vandalized, in Bangladesh Sheikh Mujib&#39;s mural got vandalized. Churchills statue was defaced in London. Queen victoria’s and Queen Elizabeth’s statue was defaced in Canada. Saddam Hussain’s statue was pulled down after his fall. All of these had been done out of ideological fervor. But it’s not just underdeveloped or developing countries where attacks on symbols happen. In the US for example, at the peak of the BLM movement, many statues of American founding fathers and other such luminaries were vandalized. Christopher Columbus was turned into a villain by campaigners who further demanded to change America&#39;s historical narrative. The reason given behind all these vandalisms was these historical people were directly or indirectly associated with racism and slavery and hence their emblems must not exist. In fact, this is the core of leftist political discourse in western countries. It follows a guilt-based model which views the western establishment as inherently guilty for every problem like racism, sexism, colonialism, slavery, homophobia, xenophobia, islamophobia, capitalist dystopia, etc. The root lies in the western establishment as they tend to believe and hence contend that such symbolic presence of western historical individuals needs to be erased and villainized in order to create a more inclusive and tolerant society. It&#39;s not just the BLM activists only, even people from the opposite aisle are equally guilty of defacing and destroying symbolic sculptures like that of George Floyd, Modeste Testas, and others. All of these remind me of one quote from the character Joker in the movie Batman: the dark night where he burns up his looted cash stack and says “It’s not about the money, but about sending a message”. Statue destruction has similar goals. It&#39;s about attacking the hegemony of an ideology and sending a message. A statue or a symbol does not have much of a physical value, but it can act as an ideological benchmark, consolidating a country&#39;s national and historical identity. Every country thus creates its own anchor point. Pakistan anchors Jinnah at the root of their existence, and hence Jinnah’s statues and symbols are engraved within the Pakistani culture. India does the same with Gandhi and Nehru. Turkey does it with Ataturk, Malaysia does it with Mahathir, Singapore does it with Lee Kuan Yew, China does it with Mao, Cuba with Che Guevara and Fidel Castro, Russia does it with Lenin, etc. It&#39;s not about the people either, but about the thought and the identity surrounding them, about the systems they preached, based on which their whole country’s existence relies. Had they not been an anchor the country’s ideological vacuum would have been filled up with other anchors. For example, many communist parties of Bangladesh like CPB idolize Che Guevara and Fidel Castro. Some idolize Lenin, some idolize Mao despite these figures having not originating from their local land. In the absence of local idols, people import idols from foreign nations. Again to reiterate, through the term “idol” I am trying to imply the whole body of thought, not the person in its physical sense. When conflicts between ideological factions arise, symbols are attacked first in order to champion one ideology’s hegemonical supremacy over the other.</p><p><a href="https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2021/08/19/shia-zealots-try-to-cancel-a-statue-of-baghdads-founder">Shia zealots try to cancel a statue of Baghdad&#39;s founder</a></p><p>Speaking from my local context, we always had two such idols upon whom our existences were shaped throughout the times. One is Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and another one is Ziaur Rahman. When BNP assumes power they erase everything related to Sheikh Mujib, from renaming roads and infrastructures to editing books and tele-contents. After Mujib’s assassination, every attempt was taken to erase his influence from public minds. History was rewritten to suit the politics of the BNP-Jamaat establishment. When Awami League came back in power they too treaded down a similar line, removing every symbol of Ziaur Rahman, weakening his influence from every sector possible. Many of the symbols were reverted back, erasing Ziaur Rahman’s trace from them. For example, the airport was renamed Hazrat Shahjalal international airport from Zia international airport. Many other infrastructures faced a similar fate. The latest attack of Ziaur Rahman’s symbol is the campaign to remove his grave. It is an open secret that Ziaur Rahman’s dead body is not in the grave that we currently know of. The site selection for this grave had a political goal. When president Ziaur Rahman was killed, his body is widely rumored to have been desecrated and thrown down in the Karnafuli river, while his accomplices’ dead bodies were buried in some hills in Rangunia. Upon the acting president’s order, these graves were exhumed and one particular body was flown back to Dhaka calling it the late president’s dead body. The coffin was never opened and the dead body was never revealed to the public, and neither was it revealed to his family members. The dead body was buried in the vicinity of the national parliament to make a permanent symbolic presence in Bangladeshi politics, which was aimed at consolidating BNP’s ideological presence. Now that power has been shifted to Awami League, BNP’s ideological presence inside the parliament&#39;s vicinity has become a major irritant for them. Not just Ziaur Rahman’s grave but there are multiple other graves inside the national parliament who were famous for their pro-Pakistan and anti-Bangladesh viewpoint. Due to making alliances with such power for political leverage, BNP willingly or unwillingly integrated their symbolic presence inside the Bangladeshi political landscape alongside Ziaur Rahman. How much of it was BNP’s original plan and how much of it was the manipulation of Pakistani loyalist forces like Jamaat e Islam can be up to debate. But the goal was clear: to slowly revert the damage of the liberation war and re-establish the Pakistani way of thought through a symbolic push. This is why Awami league leaders, mostly freedom fighters, get so hyped up when talking about these. The first attempt Awami League took to diminish the symbols was that it reverted back Zia Uddyan’s (where the late president’s mausoleum lies) name to its original, Chandrima Uddyan. But they couldn’t yet touch Ziaur Rahman’s grave since they consider it as the final symbolic assault which might require immense effort and can also create nationwide political unrest.</p><p>And it&#39;s not just curriculums, pictures, murals, or mere statues which possess emblematic potential but infrastructures can as well. Padma bridge is a good example of this. Padma Bridge was the most ambitious manifesto of the Sheikh Hasina government. Building up this bridge has got to be the most dramatic construction project in Bangladesh&#39;s history. The project was initially supposed to be funded by the World Bank. But soon after the tendering process was passed with SNC-Lavalin getting the project’s contract, World Bank brought allegations of graft and halted all the funding. They demanded a unilateral investigation to probe the whole fiasco, while the Bangladeshi Government wanted the inclusion of their representatives. Upon pressures from the World Bank, the Bangladeshi government arrested the secretary of Bridges divisions, Mosharraf Hossain Bhuiyan without any prior investigation. It removed minister Syed Abul Hossain from his ministerial post without any prior probe too. Bangladesh administrative service association, which was then led by Abu Alam Shahid Khan released a public statement opposing such a hasty apprehension of secretary Mosharrof Hossain citing the apprehension unlawful. World Bank eventually released a statement saying they have substantial evidence to charge Bangladeshi officials and hence lodged a case in a Canadian court against the Bangladeshi government and SNC-Lavalin on allegation of graft, stopping the project funding completely. Bangladesh tried to assuage World Bank through diplomatic channels and a lot of efforts were made but no solution was reached. In any other part of the world, such a crisis would have dissuaded a government from further pursuing such a messy project, since the burden would have been better laid off in order to keep the international donor bodies happy and also to focus on different attainable projects. But Sheikh Hasina was adamant about implementing it. She rebelled against the world bank and decided to fund the project completely through the country’s own funds. It was such an ambitious project that many opposed this decision, from oppositions to civil bodies, citing that it is unnecessary and govt should focus more on containing grafts than wasting public resources. Many even said that the project would never get to see the day of light and even if it did, it would be filled with multitudes of defects which would make it unusable. The point is people never thought such an ambitious project could ever be pursued due to rampant corruption in the public sector and among politicians. But she carried on with her decision anyway. Later in the year 2015, the Canadian court issued its verdict. It found no proof of allegations against Bangladeshi officials and neither did it find any credible corruption evidence on the part of SNC-Lavalin. Mashiur Rahman, the prime minister’s economic advisor accused rival contractors who didn&#39;t get the contract of conspiring against the project. The finance minister at that time, ABM Abdul Muhith on the other hand accused World Bank chief Robert Zoellick of incompetency and dishonesty which led to this crisis. Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina accused Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus of lobbying against this project due to their existing political rivalry. Although all of these are mere allegations, nonetheless, the whole corruption drama was indeed proven to be a mere hype (“hearsay” as the Canadian court retort) than anything. If Sheikh Hasina had not taken the bold decision to go on with the project regardless of all the obstacles, it would have taken an even longer period for the project to get materialized. Overcoming all the uncertainties, the bridge has finally taken shape and is now waiting to be inaugurated at the start of 2022. There is a reason behind such adamancy on the prime minister’s part. Padma Bridge acts as her emblematic success. The bridge’s success is intertwined with her identity which cements her achievements even further. Padma Bridge has transformed the whole economy of the southern regions. This bridge marks a political victory, has a story associated with it, something which her loyalists can use as a political point for years to come. Every inch of this bridge evinces her political supremacy and solidifies her political victory both inside the country and outside of it. Only an experienced politician has the capability of taking such a risk for implementing his/her broader vision. This cannot be comprehended by idealists or activists whose vision is narrow, confined within their realms, easily coerced by foreign influence and also, far detached from ground reality.</p><p>Sheikh Hasina pulled out such unwavering moves in other places too, mostly in the power sector. For example, the quick rental issue, the Rampal issue, the nuclear power plant issue. There had been big opposition against the Metro rail from experts and activists. Regular processions were being held at DU advocating to change its route plan. Also, the recent case of fuel price hike was largely met with opposition but had to be done due to a timely necessity. All these should be seen with a broader economic and strategic vision rather than a shallow one. The country needs to develop, for which it needs electricity. It also needs a good public transport system all of which require the implementation of courageous megaprojects. Megaprojects would obviously cause some level of public suffering but this is a cost people have to endure for a time being, because in a place with such a dense population few alternatives remain. Flyovers, Bridges, BRT, Subways, Metro rail, Expressways, Elevated expressways, etc. need to be built to meet future demands if the country is to develop. And this can’t be done without some degree of public inconvenience. Unfortunately, whereas such endeavors should be appreciated and should be pushed to be made more fast and efficient, many groups politicize it saying these are scheme for corruption and promulgate it to the outside world as such. For example a transportation expert from BUET, professor Shamsul Haque believes that the Bangladeshi government undertakes such transportation projects due to corporate lobbying. This is also the view of many Civil Societies like Shushanoer Jonno Nagorik and others. It is not to say that there is no corruption. The country was never corruption-free. But to say that such projects are done to just fill up pockets of corporates and politicians is far from reality. If I learned anything from observing my seniors in the government offices, the purposes behind big projects are always noble, which are aimed at solving problems for the constituencies, having bundles and bundles of feasibility tests done by industrial experts before going into implementation. The corruptions that happen midway are basically through over-estimations or taking commissions from contractors. The politicians pitch such ideas to please its constituency, parliamentary body channels it to relevant ministries who evaluate its merit, then independent industrial experts throw in designs, assess their feasibility, after which relevant govt agencies are assigned to implement it. So to say throw in such naive allegations disregards reality completely. Blaming the government is easy but understanding the nuances is where the real challenge lies. Apart from transportation, the Industries need to be energized, and so needs corporations and residential houses. A country with almost no free land, insufficient solar irradiance, weak wind speed, few to no suitable places for river dams, can barely produce even a fraction of the power demand with renewables. But it is constantly criticized for not treading down the renewable line like Germany or the USA. The US has around 320 million people with a size of around 9.8 million square kilometers, whereas Bangladesh has around 200 million people with a place of 147,570 square kilometers. Despite such immense disparity, America is the second-largest emitter of greenhouse gases, while Bangladesh ranks 48th. To have similar expectations from both of them on the grounds of greenhouse emission would be quite bizarre. But despite that, the Bangladeshi government gets bulldozed by representatives of the developed world to obey their orders. For example, Al gore once grilled Sheikh Hasina on the world economic forum about the Rampal issue and asked it to be halted. He never cared to think about the economic and political repercussions of doing so. He never cared to think that our poverty is directly related to our poor industrial infrastructure, which would require large-scale domestic electric supply to be energized. Without an industrial boom, our economy will keep faltering. He also never cared to visit the Rampal site as Sheikh Hasina asked her to. Neither did he offer Sheikh Hasina an economically and strategically viable alternative to Rampal which would match its production capacity (around 1.2 GW) with minimal land and capital requirement. Most of the anti-Rampal activism is alarmist propaganda played by some of the international bodies whose job it is to raise alarm on every issue without even giving a second thought about local contexts. For example, the dominant propaganda against Rampal is that it is being established inside Sundarban which is absolutely false. It is being made miles away from Sundarbans demarcation area, and nearly 70–90 miles from the forest’s sanctuary. Most of the land that had been appropriated for this plant used to be shrimp farms previously. These farms on other hand pollute the ecosystem even more with toxic fertilizers being dumped into them regularly in order to maximize production. No forestland has been cleared, as many activists would like others to believe. But such nuances are of no interest to Al gore. He just needs to raise alarms and project his westernized vision on people who are less fortunate. This is the level of detachment that activists have with ground reality and they expect their idealistic visions to be adopted by people of less fortunate lands with equally less fortunate economies. One alternative, however, could be nuclear-fueled power plants, which we are already in the process of making. But the capital for this is so gigantically high that getting investors becomes even more challenging. Al gore or other influential activists would never lobby to bring such projects inside Bangladesh. In fact, if anything, he would oppose it, considering his long legacy of anti-nuclear stance in order to tackle climate change.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fohx14rDJUnY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dohx14rDJUnY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fohx14rDJUnY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/011d5ab947236146f98185e0351573e2/href">https://medium.com/media/011d5ab947236146f98185e0351573e2/href</a></iframe><p>This is why sometimes leaders have to take Machiavellian decisions overriding populist ones. Populist sentiments might come with enormous political and economic costs. But few would have the acumen to realize them, if not politicians. You can take decisions and make academics and activists happy, but that might create a bigger plight for your countrymen in the longer run. Activists and academics won&#39;t necessarily assess them since their domain of their expertise is limited. To state one example, Bangladesh has a long feud with Digital Security Act. A notable academic, Professor Dr. Ali Riaz assessed all the cases and categorized the people charged within this law. He found that journalists are the main target of this particular law, hence concluding that DSA has been implemented to silence journalists. But his inference is based on national dailies which he takes biblically and also fueled by his anti-establishment bias. The problem with this is that national dailies often overlook nuances in order to provide sensational content for their readers to engage. They indeed showed nearly correct statistics of such persecutions but did not care to do further investigations which might be behind such apprehensions, leaving the inference part upon the reader. Professor Riaz construed it as an attack on the free press, but this thought never occurred to him that, some deeper nuances can lie underneath. For example, many journalists are associated with small-scale to large-scale criminal activities. Many of them blackmail people for money and public contracts, many are guilty of extortion, many are accused of drug trading and smuggling, many are accused of character assassinating, land grabbing and other such mischiefs. Some journalists are even used by a particular group to carry out their agenda, smear the reputation of their opponents for financial or political gains. With the proliferation of social media, spreading manipulated news has become a lot easier. One such manipulative news update on the digital platforms can instantly crush someone&#39;s long-earned reputation, harm businesses, spread communal riots, halt projects, and do other unrecoverable damages. DSA offers a mechanism to bring under accountability before they can be able to cause irreparable damage. Such legal mechanisms did not exist before which, after the proliferation of social media, became a timely necessity. But Mr. Riaz overlooks such motives and generalizes it all to fit his narrative. This reminds me of a popular saying, “ There are lies, damned lies, and then there are statistics”. An academic’s interest lies no further than producing exciting literature. Same with activists too whose main fuel is sensational storytelling. For example, reporters without borders brought allegations against DSA too, citing that journalists are being silenced. The case study they put forward in support of their argument were two people who were incarcerated due to DSA, one of whom died in jail. But neither of them were journalists, both were online activists, both having their own personal businesses. One was a freelance cartoonist and the other was a crocodile farmer. Not only that, the case was lodged by a private citizen who filed the case against them both for smearing his reputation online. It was not the government who had charged them. But reporters without borders never cared to look into the issue. All they needed to do is pick up a sensational story, never minding to verify its authenticity and then hastily coming to an equally sensational conclusion. Both activists and academics like Ali Riaz adopt an anchor point where they presume that everyone is being oppressed. Their research takes on from that point. But there are all sides to a story for which a deeper dive is required. Another notable example is amnesty and human rights watch. They take their data from social media and other reactionary activists and bring it forward to the whole world who take these biblically. Amnesty, for example, brought allegations of “forced disappearance” by the ruling party of Bangladesh. While some handful of cases might have happened, but to the scale that they show it certainly does not happen. Many of the enforced disappearances have later turned out to be voluntary. Many such people fled to India or other parts of the country to evade their lenders. Many fled from their areas where they have criminal charges looming on their head, only to reappear years and years later hoping those charges would fade away. Many are disappeared by relatives or business rivals due to financial feuds family feuds, or property-related feuds. One very sensational case was the disappearance of Ilias Ali. When he disappeared it was widely advocated that the government disappeared him. But a senior party member, Mirza Abbas, from his own party once leaked to the media that Ilias Ali was disappeared by his own political rival from his very own party. Local Sylhetis of his constituency also know it to be an open secret. But due to political expediency, they charge the government with this as a political point to attack the ruling party. For a ruling power, it is quite inconvenient to forcefully disappear someone, since they have all the state apparatus, from military to police and detectives to capitulate anyone they consider as a threat. Most of the forcefully disappeared people do not match the political might of the ruling power as to be purported as a threat. The big threat that actually comes is from the central leadership of their opponents which every party tried to neutralize through their own methods. BNP and its alliance for example carried out the August 21 grenade attack in order to eliminate the leadership of their opponent. Many of the highly influential local leaders were eliminated too, but they were done mostly by Islamists that BNP condoned and harbored. Islamists tried to assassinate Sheikh Hasina multiple times, especially Huji. The BNP establishment, instead of creating a distance with them, sheltered them in order to enjoy a leaderless opposition. Much of these vengeful schemes are inspired by the ISI strategies of Pakistan. ISI uses the Islamists as a vehicle to carry out movements or attacks for political gains. For example the assassination of Benazir Bhutto. She was killed for representing a political party as a woman which is considered sacrilegious by Islamist standards. Pakistani military wanted her out as well, and it is widely rumored that general Parvez Musharraf made the way for her to be assassinated, relaxing her state given security when the assassin came. August grenade attack happened similarly. Huji, an Islamist group plotted the attack, Bangladeshi detective agencies abetted it upon getting a green signal from party seniors.</p><p><a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news-detail-111469">It was Hawa Bhaban plot</a></p><p>Previously Sheikh Mujib and his whole family were assassinated for the same reason, which is to create a leaderless situation and to weaken a particular political power. Sheikh Mujib&#39;s assassins were all rewarded later, with the BNP establishment granting them indemnity, employing them in top diplomatic posts, and bringing them in the national parliament. But it is not only the BNP establishment who understood the benefits of a leaderless opposition. The caretaker government of 1/11 incarcerated both party leaders upon corruption charges. When Sheikh Hasina was handed over state power, the high court acquitted her but kept the charges against Khaleda Zia, the ex-prime minister. She was later convicted and sent to 5 years in jail. The government suspended her sentence on humanitarian grounds. But here lies an interesting political factor too. Her sentence is suspended, not pardoned, which means it can again revive upon the government’s will, which would incarcerate her for even more years. Tarique Rahman faced the same fate too. He was convicted for seven years and is now remaining in exile. Awami league thus enjoyed the benefits of a leaderless political opposition as well. In a mature democracy, leaders shouldn&#39;t have mattered but policies and ideologies should have. For example, in Israel, people are conditioned towards policies, not leaders. Hence, despite many of its leaders being incarcerated, it barely affects the partys’ political activities. But to expect such mature behavior in the developing world or the underdeveloped world still remains a fantasy.</p><p>It’s not like that the ruling party has won its ideological battle and could shape its systems to the finest. The systems they inherited were bad enough, and the way things are moving does not generate much hope either. Corruption is still endemic, public services are still lackluster, legal systems are still thoroughly polluted and so are the law enforcing agencies. Extortions, Human rights violations, political mischief, project lag, service lag, poor health, poor educational infrastructure are still a grim reality. But things are developing slowly thanks to political stability which this country lacked for long. But for a party that has been straight 13 years in power, people are justified in having higher expectations. The delays in developments frustrate people and fume further distaste towards the establishment. If the system bleeds, the ideology holding that system bleeds too. If you let it bleed for long, people will justifiably lean towards the other available ideologies. Unfortunately, the party pushed its focus so heavily on infrastructure and material grounds that it forgot to shape people’s minds. The party’s ideology which focuses on Bengali Nationalism and Secularism at its core, now mostly exists among a handful of people. Failure to meet up people’s demands is one of the many factors that had been degrading down the appeal of Bengali culture and heritage. The country embraced globalism but did not concentrate on creating a perfect cultural barrier to protect the Bengali identity. People now identify secularism and Bengali identity with the ruling party Awami League, hence the failure of the government and its bodies translate into the failure of secularism and Bengali identity. Since this is the only party that claims to preserve liberation war values which are in a sense true, hence people are even losing their connection to liberation war, because the party could not make the essence of liberation war ubiquitous. The recent fiasco over flying the Pakistani flag inside Bangladeshi soil by Bengalis themselves reflects this growing tension even more. Of course, there has to be a political consensus on the issue of identity and ideology but it has never been reached. BNP for its alliance with Jamaat e Islam had embraced semi-Islamist narratives whereas jamaat e Islam is fully Islamist. Other political parties which have a substantial following like Gono-Odhikar Porishod also capitalize on Islamist rhetorics. One parallel secular force did in fact pop up, under the leadership of Dr. Kamal Hossain and under the name Juktofront. They even gained some parliamentary seats allying with BNP. But their infighting broke them apart and pushed them out of the scene. I am not including communist parties in this discussion since they never managed to gather a sizable following to even be able to block a road. Most of such parties are usually a one-man show, for example, Mujaihidul Selim’s CPB and Jonayed Saki’s Bhashani Moncho. The other communist parties like Jashod and Workers party have integrated with the ruling party, hence they don’t count either. To sum things up, The ideological fight today is between Awami league’s secular Bengali identity vs Islamist ideologies of jamaat e Islam and Hefazot e Islam. BNP as a party acts as a carrier of Islamist ideology since the party has no fundamental ideology of its own, also since it helps to expand their voter and power base. Since Awami League is the only major party that promotes secularism, hence minorities of Bangladesh historically had been a fixed voter base of this party. Minorities had in fact been synonymous with the existence of the Awami League. Hence the failure of the Awami league government creates more plight among Bangladeshi minorities since the majority starts vilifying the minorities in return. If secularism was adopted by other political parties, such communal tendencies could not have gained momentum since it could have been separated from Awami League’s identity and integrated into everyone’s life. The same is true for Bengali identity, Our liberation war values, and everything. No other parties ever came in good faith to recognize these ideological issues, hence making way for Pakistani and Arab Islamism to creep in. Thanks to social media, such tendencies are getting even more amplified. People would definitely be attracted to strong immunized ideologies with a moral appeal. Due to the populace not being mature enough they easily fall prey to rhetorical and superficial ideologies. The ruling party had indeed created massive infrastructural and material development but it forgot to look into the cultural aspect of the country. Many among the ruling party themselves are devoid of the ideology that their party hold, frequently spouting communal narratives and even sponsoring them from time to time to increase their foothold. There are tons of such party activists who regularly finance waaz mahfils and attend them as chief guests whereas such functions promulgate values that are completely antithetical to the party’s core ideology. But nonetheless, they do it because they themselves do politics for power, and not for ideology. And this is how Awami League’s ideology is decaying day by day.</p><p>To state an example, the student wing of the ruling party, Bangladesh Chatro League become increasingly notorious on university campuses. They have lost all of their former glory and turned into a repressive apparatus for the state. Due to the party remaining in state power for so long, they have become more and more ruthless. Chatro league was once associated with tons of national movements and student protests. It was also a center for intellectual exercise and promulgating the Bengali identity alongside Chatro union which too was a very popular student organization at that time. But all of those faded away and today the whole institution had turned into a party of beneficiaries than a party of ideologues. The power that the government had consigned them made them ruthless in turn. The government had one goal, to keep the universities in control through these political units. And therefore, they bestowed them with a sinister muscle with which they end up terrorizing general students and teachers. When you give confer power to someone who barely has any political consciousness, then he treats this as a tool to exert dominance and flex his muscle. In lord of the rings, for example, the ring of power corrupts anyone who comes across it. Similarly, when someone who was a nerd all their life, all of a sudden gets absolute power, it becomes tough for him to appreciate it and act responsibly. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Given the impunity that he receives, it becomes even tougher for him to control his muscular desires and flex his power over others. Power exercise is a natural urge, and without proper grooming, it is bound to be abused. Unfortunately, there are no grooms, unlike in lord of the rings where there were multiple.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QV0ZD6DhEq_OUBww.jpg" /><figcaption>Frodo with the one ring — Lord of the rings</figcaption></figure><p>Most, if not all the student political activists are politically unconscious who engage in politics either out of pressure or for enjoying short-term campus benefits. The ruling party also made way for them to reap profits out of the system. Most of the student leaders are engaged in extortion, monopoly control on hall room allocations, tender control, dining control, 3rd-grade recruitment control, etc. They also enjoy preferential treatments when applying for public service. Also, there lie options to influence teachers to get unfair advantages in their classrooms. Students are first ragged, tortured, and then lured into these advantages by seniors when they enter universities, thus perpetuating the political culture. These mechanisms or ‘Systems’, assist to unleash the inner beast of the young students and convert them into the muscle of the political parties. Most of their misbehaviors are given impunity. When they beat up their fellow students or harass their teachers, most of such cases are shoved below the rugs. One such senior on my campus was Mr. Zaman Ibrahim who used to harass girls openly without any fear. He used to threaten our alumni that he will lynch them whenever they put their foot on campus. Once he touted guns out in the open to terrorize a student. But no actions were taken against him because he had political backups. The girls whom he used to tease never got justice for what they received. My roommate (Pial ’15) was beaten up once for criticizing the student leaders (Tamim ECE’15) who stole money from the dining funds. I too was harassed by the same political faction (led by Faisal IEM ’15) for boarding up that my provost (Professor Bazlar sir) assigned to me. And what disturbed me, even more, was to see my friend (Shubhro ’15) among the harassers. And he had just joined politics some few days ago. Another friend of mine (Rafi EEE’15) along with another student from URP (Rafid UPR ’15) were heavily beaten up by a political senior and a political batchmate from their own hall (Nibir BME’14, Ritu ECE ‘14) regarding the exact same issue. They were beaten up for boarding a room that the hall provost allotted for him without the political goon’s permission. My teacher professor Dr. Selim Hossain, with whom I co-authored my first conference paper got harassed to death over an election feud between two factions of chatroleague (Sezan panel vs Rudronil panel) where one party wanted him to favor them over the other. I saw many seniors, batchmates and juniors downplay his death just because they were engaged with active politics. One of my senior brothers (Arafat CSE’13) along with many others, was once beaten up mercilessly with blunt tools in the guest room of Bangabandhu hall upon allegations that he might be associated with a different political ideology. Another senior of mine who just lived next to my room (Mubin CSE’14) was also beaten up by the same goons in front of my room. He was arguing with them for breaching his room and throwing his belongings out of his room to make room for political juniors. What was more harrowing that the lead of that incident was given by a political batchmate of mine (Faisal ’15) and a junior from my department (Abir ‘16). I tried to help break the fight, but my arms broke doing that. Thankfully Mubin bhai’s political friends came down hearing the scuffle and drove them away. The junior I mentioned before was also a convict in the famous incident of beating up a referee in the hall tournament. Alleging partiality, the referee, who was a pretty old man, was beaten up mercilessly by political goons from my hall. He had to be taken to ICU and very few believed that he would survive. But thankfully he did, but that unrest caused the campus to be closed indefinitely. These are just some parts of the story which the ruling party’s student faction caused on the general students, general people, and the teachers in my campus that I personally experienced. Others have bigger and far traumatic stories to tell. And this is just one university. There are numerous other public universities where the pictures are even bleaker.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F6iEW9MHq6Lw%3Fstart%3D578%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D578&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D6iEW9MHq6Lw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F6iEW9MHq6Lw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/57dd74736d7ce9309f25fed1b6acc879/href">https://medium.com/media/57dd74736d7ce9309f25fed1b6acc879/href</a></iframe><p>It&#39;s not like actions like these are centrally endorsed. In fact, there are Some good men among the living. For example, Zia Bhai from batch ’13 once saved my friend Jayed Amin despite when local people were hunting him down for some personal issues. I too was once offered refuge by Anup Bhai, batch 14 when I was facing militant threats through Facebook. But these are very scant incidents that get shrouded out by the larger scenario where terrorism reigns. And these are more pronounced, get more visibility and therefore put bigger impact on everyone’s minds. And as i said, when people grows distate towards an individual or organization they end up growing distate for everything they embody, including their ideals. Such terrorisms drove people to be more sympathetic towards opposing powers making them side with their cause. The student parties claim that they have to exist to combat fundamentalist forces. But their actions had instead eased the work of fundamentalist forces. Just like how the Taliban received growing silent support who were being oppressed by Ghani govt and western military, in a similar manner, the terrorist actions of Chatroleague inadvertently grew the support base for fundamentalist forces. Since the Chatroleague politicians do politics for benefits and not for ideology, hence the ideology could never seep inside the university boundaries rather faded away before even entering the system. The government wanted to control universities through these loyal student factions, and they achieved their goal. But they had to sacrifice ideological hegemony doing that, which they had knowingly or unknowingly overlooked. The systems have been built with negligible accountability in order to grant maximum muscle, and as a result, it had been breeding beasts after beasts for years. What the system could never achieve is that it could never produce quality politicians. Politicians were bred, but those were at the times of the liberation war and some decades after that. The country at that time was submerged in peak ideological fervors with universities being their proliferation zone and Chatro league, Chatro Union being their purveyor. The political signups were voluntary and ideological. Such a picture does not exist any longer. Politics have been handed over to opportunists than actual ideologues. It&#39;s not Awami league that devised this system, but BNP and Jamat-e-Islam are equally to blame for perpetuating the exact same culture with their student faction Chatro Dol and Islami Chatro Shibir, when they were in power.</p><p>But ideologies should be prioritized and opportunism should be discouraged. If opportunism is incentivized instead, then the moral legitimacy of a political party evaporates. For example, in Local UP elections, the candidates always ran independently without having to run under the symbol of any particular political party. Therefore, there was room for many candidates of the same party to fight parallelly for an electoral position in local UP elections. But in the recent election, a change has been incorporated into the election process where the candidates would have to require party nominations and run for elections under their corresponding party symbol. The parties were asked to nominate one candidate out of all their applicants and put him up for elections. The motive was to select the finest apple from the base in order to preserve the party image before letting them run in the elections. What it has done instead is that it created a big room for corruption. Many nominees were selected by the party officials, not because of their political vision or ideology but due to the sheer force of their wealth and muscle. Such practice alienated a lot of loyal and potential candidates. Many grassroots supporters alleged that senior officials were vouching for and nominating candidates in exchange for a large sum of bribes. Such messages swept across the whole country with frequent protests erupting here and there. Many rejected candidates rebelled against party decisions and stood for the elections by themselves. And ironically, a huge amount of rebel candidates have won in their respective constituencies defeating the party-nominated ones, proving that many of the allegations brought up by aggrieved rebels were in fact true. The party did fail to select candidates with popular acceptance among their constituencies because it failed to cater to politicians and brought in traders instead. Awami league went as far as to banning them from their party for going against party decision, thus pushing away its support base even further. The lesson from such systemic discrimination had shattered the political mindset of many dedicated and lifelong supporters. Many started to feel that the party which was supposed to have ideals at its core, do not talk to them anymore. The ethical foundation that the ruling party had eroded since they came in power, and the erosion purports to be big since the party has been in power for 13 years long, the longest time any single party held power in Bangladesh. There had been tons of allegations of corruption, suppression, violence, and injustice. Adding to that when the party started to discriminate among its own supporter base, it started losing legitimacy among its own loyalists too. All of these happened because money and muscle were prioritized, and politicians were not. Those with large sums of money could buy off their ticket to the ruling party whereas ideological adherents were ignored. These seasonal leaders are not carriers of ideology but their main target is to expand their business empire and make money. The recently sacked Mayor of Gazipur, Mr. Zahangir Alam, is one of such instances. He was sacked for denigrating the values of liberation war and also for insulting the father of the nation. But such ideals are core to his party’s existence, which he should have internalized once he had signed up for the party. There was no reason to nominate Mr. Zahangir while ignoring other experienced senior politicians of Gazipur. But since Mr. Zahangir had a pile of cash he got his ticket in, whereas others couldn&#39;t. Another mayor, Mr. Abbas Ali of Katakhali was sacked just some days later for the same reason. He went against party ideals. Despite being part of a secular party, Mr. Abbas was touting fundamentalists rhetoric to his followers, saying that setting up murals of the father of the nation is anti-Islamic hence should not be allowed in his municipality. Such a remark goes completely against the fundamental secular principles of Awami league. There are more such activists in Awami league who could not yet internalize Aawmi Secularism or its other nationalistic ideals. But such people who are completely oblivious to party ideology get in the party bandwagon with the sheer force of money. There are tons of such politicians who are oblivious to ideals but are open to business. They treat it as a business endeavor rather than a place to manifest visions. Incorporating such questionable practices weakens a party’s ideological hegemony among the people while on the other hand provides an advantage to the opposing powers who have a better moral cohesion and also a greater ideological commitment. The party has lost a big range of public support due to failing the fight on the ideological front. It has, for example, completely lost on the ideological battle online where it has very few scopes to exercise its muscle. The only things that are keeping them alive are the state apparatuses. The party has entrenched its influence on these particular systems which has still kept them in the positions of power, but it lost the popularity among its constituency which it once had.</p><p><a href="https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/election/2021/11/15/awami-league-its-own-worst-enemy-at-union-parishad-polls">Awami League its own worst enemy at Union Parishad polls</a></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FGn_ml_XFONE%3Flist%3DPLpo3zv9jSp3gGMps4dIRRA2O6GW82lthr&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DGn_ml_XFONE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FGn_ml_XFONE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5b9fc8a30e98ecc891b19526478b533b/href">https://medium.com/media/5b9fc8a30e98ecc891b19526478b533b/href</a></iframe><p>Neither Amnesty nor Human rights watch or any other international elite body would come to any help when a political crisis brews. In the end, a country depends on its populace. They live in it, live through its weals and ordeals. They get to select the political discourse, rebel if things don&#39;t fall in line. The ruling party has kept the systems functioning no matter how faulty. If the systems collapse or get back to their previous ineffective phase, people will oust them out as well. This is why oppositions daydream about toppling the government every night and day but see no fruit to it, while the ruling power teases them constantly saying that they lost the support of the populace. By support, they mean muscle power that carries the potential to corner the government into meeting up with their demands. Such muscle power was displayed by Hefazot e Islam in 2013 and in 2021, under Allama Shafi, Mamunul, and Babunagari. BNP could not even show a fraction of such power. Even the spontaneous movements, for example, the quota reform movement, road safety movement, Shahbagh movement all had a substantial muscle, whereas major political oppositions failed to show any such muscle power within recent years. This is partly due to the failure and negligence of the deputy leadership of the BNP establishment in the absence of their party chief. And also due to the ruling party keeping the systems effectively functioning. As soon as the systems start to crumble down, structures start to disintegrate, people will come down on the streets in droves. There would be no backup since the party does not have ideological hegemony anymore, hence negligible loyalty among the masses. Unless that is to happen, people will be disgruntled but privately, which wouldn&#39;t be much of a threat to the party’s power. They are better off seeing people disgruntled in their private spheres, ranting on social media, than coming down and blocking the streets. Social media rants will eventually vanish, but street protests can spiral out of control, forcing them to capitulate. They know it better since they had been long on the opposition and used the exact same tactic to rise into power. And they don&#39;t want their own tactic to be used against them. This is why they focus a lot on material infrastructure and keeping the system intact, rather than giving even a fraction of that attention towards developing the cultural landscape and cementing ideologies. This is a short-term solution, in the long run when all the people will realign themselves with the opposing ideologies, the party would have to count their days.</p><h4>Concluding…</h4><p>To sum things up, Politics in developing and underdeveloped countries have to be managed strategically and based on local context. To emulate a first-world system into a third world is no less than a fantasy. The failure to recognize local context is largely responsible for the political failure and systemic catastrophes in most of these countries. Only local experienced leadership can be capable of navigating through this since they can directly engage with the people, know their psyche and their maturity. This is an advantage that foreign bodies do not hold, no matter how much theoretically they are educated about an issue. Even if foreign powers are comparatively successful in thoroughly managing a country, at the end of the day, they will always be looked as looters, oppressors, and colonizers regardless of their intent. It didn’t work in India, Bangladesh, Lebanon, Algeria, Afghanistan, and it won’t work in Somalia, Mali, or the other African countries which are still under Western political influence. Political and infrastructural systems can be imported from outside, just like we do for physical commodities. But, the drive for this must emerge spontaneously and not be imposed upon, with a wide degree of local engagement. Whatever the system is, at the end of the day, and it has to work. If it fails to do that, it will eventually be replaced. We should always keep in mind that there are no cookie-cutter solutions, only context-based solutions. What may be true for one part of the world may fail miserably in another part of the world. The focus, therefore, should be always concentrated on the fitness of the systems and also on cementing ideologies. Just material developments cannot ensure hegemony, but ideologies must be given priorities too. Both of these factors should be constantly monitored to see if they are functioning properly or bleeding. In the absence of neatly functioning systems, muscle power grows up and anarchy ensues. Both the ruling powers and the oppositions should focus on systems. Ruling powers have a stake in protecting the systems whereas oppositions have a stake in seeing it bleed. Even if power exchanges hands, at the end of the day, a functional system is what all the powers should aim for instead of getting locked up in endless polarisations and infighting. But at first, some fundamental ideologies should be set upon which the state’s identity would stand upon. Thus ideological conflicts would get minimized and focus can be directed on state systems. While I agree that absolute ideological adherence cannot work for the better and that everything needs to adapt considering ground reality. But nonetheless, there must be a balance to it all. If ideology is compromised, identity gets compromised too which is a recipe for polarisations and disaster. Hence even if slight modifications need to be introduced into the ideological narrative it must be done cautiously so as to not lose moral validation from the constituency. Once moral validation is lost, a state is left with repressive state power to maintain a society. This is short term solution and can never last long. It also opens up a pathway to a dystopian, bleak society and sooner or later is destined to end up in conflicts, because you cant accumulate exponential grievances for long.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86470ed3c267" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Satires and who are afraid of them?]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/on-satires-and-who-are-afraid-of-them-6f1c6e1fd269?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6f1c6e1fd269</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 May 2021 19:35:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-14T18:34:12.167Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vYqcjygdY2dMZLRv" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@sonance?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Viktor Forgacs</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Honestly speaking, everyone is.</strong></p><p><em>(P.S: The cartoons and caricatures used in this blog do not reflect my views or my advocacy of any sort. All of the contents used here are for documentation purposes only and are not intended towards causing any communal incitations but rather to get to know the contexts better. Just like to understand the human anatomy one must confront a naked human body, similarly to understand the contexts and historic progression behind any particular subject, one should remain open minded and be prepared to confront any displeasing contents that may come across for the sake of a better understanding of the whole thing. If you are still comfortable with being displeased by some of the cartoons and events that might unfold, please do not continue. This is a study on cartoons and caricatures and their influence on social dynamics. To reiterate, it is not in any way meant to provoke any individual or any particular group or any particular faith. If you are still interested in the study, please continue otherwise please don’t. Hope to see you in my upcoming blog entries.)</em></p><p>By everyone I don’t necessarily mean every single individual on the planet. Although, it might not be completely untrue if their turn comes up, but nevertheless, anyone a cartoon targets is obviously to get somewhat, if not massively, unsettled. Satires are a mode of expression which are concerned with poking at people’s feelings. But before we judge satires for playing with people’s feelings we should at least know that every mode of expression tends to do the same, that is to evoke some particular feeling or sensation within the audience. Satires can come in different forms under a wide variety of mediums. A musical piece can be a satire, so can be a drama. A literature can be a satire, so can be a poetry. Caricatures are usually satires. They are basically a form of portrait which uses some unique features of the subject and exaggerate them to the point where it becomes humorous. When a subtle criticism of something or someone is pushed forward, but in an exaggerated or humorous way, then a satire is born. A satire wraps up a sociopolitical message within it’s carefully crafted humorous structure. But unlike the usual, non-satirical modes of entertainment, for example in the case of the avaerage music, or painting, or drama, or poetry, or novels etc., satires are mostly divisive. It contains a “target” who/which gets satirized (be it an idea or a people) and an “audience” who gets entertained. In case of non satirical modes of entertainments, there are scopes for everyone to be simultaneously entertained without anyone getting offended. But for satirical modes, someone is bound to get unhappy, angry, agitated or vengeful even, whereas on the other side of the spectrum there can be seen bursts of cathartic sneers and bloated laughter.</p><h4>Anatomy of a laughter…</h4><p>It is this particular nature of satire which makes it so controversial. People usually don’t take to be charged or attacked, be it verbally of physically. In most if not all of the cases, they elicit some sort of resistance. How to appropriately react to cartoons of oneself and how to put a leash on vigilante satirists, is a topic which no one in the planet could ever agree upon. People want to be immune from criticisms or any kind of satirization of themselves. But then again, they want to laugh their hearts out at the same time too, be it at the expense of others. While there certainly are more benign sources of laughter out there, but laughters derived from the misery of others, has a wider appeal. Starting from our childhood, consider the time when we were in the kindergarten or in our early school, we used to instinctively laugh at someone who is the “weird one out”. The socially awkward kid used to be always bullied and laughed at. The kid who asks some stupid question or replies with some stupid answers were always a laughing stock. If you go back in time a little more, a time when we were toddlers barely being able to stand on our feet, you would notice a similar pattern. Kids get really amused seeing others fall in an embarrassing situation. This specific psychological aspect of the toddlers are often exploited by the elders to entertain the children with silly, frivolous and mindless tricks. If a child cannot comprehend a situation, he/she wouldn’t find it funny. Awkward romantic jokes aren’t ever gonna make them laugh or even smile, but randomly stumbling upon a wall or cracking an egg upon your head might. Take for example, Tom and Jerry, a very popular children’s cartoon. what is the cartoon actually about? It’s just about a cat chasing a mouse incessantly and failing each of the time quite miserably. It doesn’t actually have a plot (although in some episodes there seems to be a little story narrative but those are targeted to serve the adult audiences). The children are glued onto the screen just to watch tom getting smacked each time. Every time Tom/Jerry gets hit by something or runs into an awkward situation, the children crack up. But take Looney Tunes for example. Looney Tunes follows the similar pattern of hit and run comedy too. But they seem to be less appealing to a child but rather more appealing to an adult. The reason being that, looney tunes actually entails some plot within it, apart from the mindless slapstick fillers each of its episodes contain. Now this can easily bore out the children, since they are there for watching the embarrassment of the poor bunnies or the coyote or the Tasmanian devil or the ducks or the pigs or whatever other slapstick thrill looney tunes have to offer. But adults can comprehend the subtle pinches and the plot’s comedic references, granting them to be able to enjoy the full package of humor. As for the children, they cannot comprehend the language nor the narrative references, making it less appealing to them compared to the tom and jerry show, which is mostly mute and hence an easy fodder for a toddler.</p><p>Its not just tom and jerry or looney tunes, most children’s cartoons are based on the mindless slapstick model. Classic cartoons were filled with it, although modern cartoons might have reached a balance, but nonetheless they are still prevalent in most of them. Its not children’s cartoons which laid the inception of slapstick comedies, but in fact it’s inception started with adult comedic strips which introduced such kind of comedies to the general people. It goes back as early as in Greek and Roman periods where clowns entertained audience through exchanging quips and beatings among themselves. In the middle ages, slapsticks can be found to be used in Shakespeare&#39;s plays. Shakespeare included chase and beating scenes in his play “the comedy of errors”. In the 20th century with the boom of television comedy, came a host of slapstick comedies. Charlie Chaplin being one of the most notable ones of such genre. Along with them were the keystone cops, laurel and hardy, marx brothers, the three stooges. These all were comedy strips targeted to audiences of all range. So, be it cartoons or films in general, such characteristics had a timeless presence throughout the history of the comedy genre.</p><p>Now why does mindless awkward violence or people’s random embarrassments make us laugh? There are multiple theories for this of course and none can be disregarded. Children respond to slapstick humors because that’s the best thing their minds can process. As we get older, our slapstick response dwindles out, since we develop more and more self-awareness, our cognition develops and so does our ability to assess situations. Hence the amount of bullies we get to see in our pre-school tend to gradually drop as we ascend towards higher educational levels and in case of graduate levels or post graduate levels they become close to being non-existent. Although it would be wrong to say there aren’t any, but even if so, those cases are more nuanced, have more complicated social factors behind them and are usually driven with an agenda rather than being driven out of mere fun or instinct. Basically we get a better hold onto our instincts as we grow older and start to express sophisticated social manners. Our empathy grows even better and we learn to socialize more effectively due to our cognitive developments. But still, our childlike self doesn’t completely go away. To show an example to illustrate this point lets take a look at the following video. A a viral video from a metal band called Syskill from East Germany, where they try to jump on an ice pool to prove how brutal they are as a way to promote their band, shows a classic example of slapstick humor.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fzd7c5tQCs1I%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dzd7c5tQCs1I&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fzd7c5tQCs1I%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/470047a2947a458d41f5b3a710feb85c/href">https://medium.com/media/470047a2947a458d41f5b3a710feb85c/href</a></iframe><p>The man in the video jumps in the pool, gets hurt but immediately is followed by laughter from his friend. After whining in pain for a while he too bursts out in laughter and it reinforces the laughter in the whole group even more, making them go hysterical. This is where the theory of socialization comes in. Laughter has evolved as an emotional cue to bond with our peers throughout our human history. Robert Provine in his book states that we are more likely to laugh while we are around our friends and peers rather than when we are alone. Social cues are important to generate intuitive laughter. Laughter is a cathartic release of energy from the body which is associated with reducing the overall stress of the body’s system. And it is contagious too. When an awkward situation appears and we laugh it away, we send out a signal towards others that it is nothing much to worry about. If we fall and break a leg or shatter a bone, no one is going to laugh but rather try to contact every available emergency hotlines of nearby hospitals. But if a little pain is all that occurs, then we laugh it away intutively to reduce the stress of the whole situation, and it all happens quite automatically. But then again, the chance of laughing things out happens mostly among close kins. Among strangers we don’t usually evoke such an emotion, or even if such emotions appear intuitively, the general tendency is to suppress the feeling to avoid tension. Laughter and its intensity here signals the strength of the emotional bond among a group of people. Laughter is contagious for this reason — to have an in-group feeling. The bigger the laughter, the bigger the heart they say; which actually translates to having a better social skill. Sophie Scott, a British Neuroscientist, has a very interesting Ted talk based upon where she shares the social aspects of laughter and how tightens up our bond among our kins.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FUxLRv0FEndM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DUxLRv0FEndM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FUxLRv0FEndM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/953db81a897c8623302a080e0df1bb44/href">https://medium.com/media/953db81a897c8623302a080e0df1bb44/href</a></iframe><p>That laughter is contagious, is an idea which is quite often exploited by sitcoms. For example when watching “Seinfield” or the “big bang theory” or “two and a half man” or “Friends” or “How i met your mother” or sitcoms alike, we encounter a laughing audience, but we should better realize that those were deliberately put there to mimic a live audience. Laugh tracks were developed by Charles Douglas, a sound engineer in CBS, in order to fix the inconsistency of laughter of the in-house crowd in order to be properly aired for the radio and television channels. He saw that the crowd was not reacting with the expected intensity at the expected moments, which posed a problem for the airing the show or engraving them into the record tapes perfectly. At times they laughed too loud and for a prolonged moment, and at times they didn’t laugh quite as much when the punchlines appeared. So to bridge this inconsistency, Charley Douglas came with a scheme, a sweetening method in which he engineers the laughter of the crowd to the production team’s will. When needed he tones the laughter down, and when needed he amplifies it up. Thus creating the perfectly engineered, transmittable version of the whole show. Soon he developed the whole thing into artificial laugh tracks and after the production costs of live sessions soared, the demands for laugh tracks started to skyrocket. Comedian Milton Berle once talked of a joke which didn’t receive adequate laughter response from the in-house crowd, but after Douglas added the laugh track, Milton reportedly rejoiced, and told everyone, “See, i told you it was funny”. Although the efficiency of laughter tracks to make a show more funny is still debated but nonetheless it has been giving punchline cues to viewers since the inception of its usage by Douglas and the sitcom producers. Today, most laughter tracks can be seen ingrained in the most of the sitcoms. Even most late night talk shows use sweetening for the audience laughters. Late night shows by Steven Colbert or Jimmy Fallon, or John Stewart, John Oliver, Bill Maher are to name the few. Oh and how did i forget about Saturday Night Live. All of the sound of audience laughter are very well captured, well engineered, sweetened or de-sweetened and then aired. All of these are done to amplify the appeal of the whole show and provide an intricately engineered program to the consumers in expense of a tiny delay in live airing. It is just too risky to keep your hands off from sweetening. But unlike sitcoms which use pre recorded laugh track, late night talk shows don not usually use pre-recorded laugh tracks, since they are aired live. They just sweeten them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/560/0*LrpEJAyBgIAhsM2c.jpg" /><figcaption>Courtesy: Nymag</figcaption></figure><p>Now is laughter just to enhance emotional bond or to reduce the overall stress factor in the air? Unfortunately no. There are other aspects to laughter too. “Schadenfreude effect” for example, which means to get a sense of joy at other’s misfortune, explains some of the cases of laughter where humans revel in when they see others fall in embarrassing situations. This gives a passive sense of superiority over other people who are the subject of ridicule. It may be voluntary or involuntary. While voluntary schadenfreude might translate to an outcome of jealousy, the involuntary ones are mostly unconscious and less passionate. But schadenfreude is ingrained in most if not all of our genes. Then, there is the theory of incongruity which explains why incongruous situations, are occasionally perceived as humor. The brain not being able to decipher the outcome of situation uses laughter as an escape mechanism. This is why unpredictable jokes are the funniest. Jokes that are easily predictable don’t work that good. But for jokes to be funny, the incongruity needs to be easy to comprehend as well. For example, I once recommended “South park” to a friend of mine. He didn’t enjoy the show as much as i did. The reason being that, south park is a narrative centric cartoon with full of pop culture references. My friend wasn’t aware of the pop culture references, hence the incongruity in the narratives weren’t apparent to him. It’s not just south park but if i had given him Saturday night live, he would have felt the same. But he would have definitely enjoyed Mr. Bean, Scary Movie, The dictators or other such comedy films which don’t require much context or pop culture references to be comprehended. The theory of incongruity explains slapstick humors too. When someone trips down or gets smacked in the head with a pan, we perceive that as a deviance from the norm. It all happens so randomly that it comes to us as unexpected, mostly as a shock. Although theory of incongruity explains slapstick humors partially since there are obviously other factors at play here too, but nonetheless the significance cannot be overruled. Laughters are complex and intricate neurological processes. And like many other neurological processes, it is so intertwined, that a single factor cannot be attributed to it. And hence the interest and researches into this field seems to be never ending too. Many of the theories i have referenced here have been borrowed here from scientific american. I am linking the whole article below for a better read, in case anyone wants to dive a bit more deep.</p><p><a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/whats-so-funny-the-science-of-why-we-laugh/">What&#39;s So Funny? The Science of Why We Laugh</a></p><p>Laughters are biological processes that have been evolutionary selected throughout the great course of time. It obviously serves a purpose, otherwise this process would have long been eliminated. Freud theorized that laughter is a venting mechanism for suppressed emotions. It is a cathartic release of “tensed energies” he says. To elaborate, when we are calculating billions of calculations in our minds each day within the realm of reality it stresses our neurons out. We have a set perception of reality and when it gets shaken but in a playful, apparently harmless way, it helps our neurons get a momentary relaxation. Concepts which are more stress inducing, for example socially taboo topics make the joke even more interesting, make them even more funnier. When sensitive topics appear, we tend to invest a good lot of neural energy to calculate the perfect way to react. So, when such tense moments appear in front of us, our brain subconsciously picks up the cue but just as the incongruity appears, it realizes the punchline and calms itself down. It’s like pulling a lever up and then abruptly releasing it down, freeing up the energy invested. And in the case of neural calculations, it releases them as laughter. This made Freud understand why jokes with scatological and sexually undertones so easily amuse us. Its not just these specific category of jokes, but take any taboo for example. Take for an instance, racial issues. Racial and jokes about ethnicity are predominant in every societies. Race is a sensitive topic to talk about since it has always played a role in breeding war and division. But with the rise of sensitivity in a topic, rises the potential of it to be joked about. Gender relations too, a conflicting topic but a breeder of an ocean of joke. Race, Gender, Power, Politics, Religion, Drugs, take any sensitive topic you can find, and you will see an abundant of jokes surrounding them. But you would surely have a hard time finding any joke regarding electric transformers, or like water cycle of the planet, or the layers of atmosphere above the earth. But even a non sensitive, benign issue may have a tons of jokes surrounding it, considering how well it has been publicly sensationalized. In millennial terms, if a topic gets trending in layman conversations, (or say in twitter) it is bound to be followed by a barrage of jokes. Politicians and celebrities are always centerpieces of jokes since they are always sensationalized, and have the highest exposures.</p><p>Although, juxtapositioning of mismatched incidents, slapstick humors, household humors, dad jokes or in plain bangla “Mirakkel” jokes may seem perfectly benign forms of humor but nonetheless, these are not powerful sociological tool and hence don’t stand out. They can be contain cultural emblems and portray daily lives of average individuals, but they cannot mobilize society as a group, neither do they possess transitioning power. These are soft versions of satires without much complicated thoughts being invested into them. On the other hand, strong satires, acerbic criticisms have always been an interesting area to explore. An abundance of studies have been done on them and they seem to have larger imprint on the contemporary minds of people since their strength can mobilize and bring revolutionary changes. These are also more emotionally appealing since they integrate many intricate social thoughts and factors. Such satires usually portray a larger collective and their mindsets. Hence the imprints last longer on the people despite it’s success on social mobilizing. Usually political satires falls under this category but other satires can come up with such socially mobilizing power too. For example, satires targeting the absurdity of certain conventional social customs and practices. And its the sheer power of satires which nakedly can point out loopholes in systems is what makes the sociopolitical orders tremble. Also it makes it even more relatable and funnier.</p><p>Check out the clip from Seth Mcfarlene’s “Cavalcade of Cartoon Comedy” below, where the animators present a transition from an apparent slapstick humor to a critique of alienation and evangelical Christianity. They used one of my favorite looney tunes cartoons, “Wiley E. Coyote and the Road Runner” and exaggerated the slapstick to fit into a modern setting, providing it with a narrative.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FOQhOcDFbflQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DOQhOcDFbflQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FOQhOcDFbflQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/14e3d40a04d64e8ea8f992bebd255e40/href">https://medium.com/media/14e3d40a04d64e8ea8f992bebd255e40/href</a></iframe><p>People usually seek out for narratives as they grow older. Silly acrobatics start to lost their appeals. Or in other words, people start to prefer content rich skits, contents that are derived from everyday incidents starting from family matters to workplace affairs to celebrity gossips, to local and international politics and other everyday affairs that they can relate to. Although children tend to be more prone to the schadenfreude effect, but those are in more of a primitive form, within the domain of a nascent brain’s processing capability. But for adults the case is a little different. People cant shed off the schadenfreude effect completely, since it comes with the genes. But we become good at suppressing it. Through developing more social experience, building empathy, learning appropriate etiquette, and through other social and neurological development, we get to learn to behave and not make ourselves look like a completely insensitive person in front of others. But still the schadenfreude remains, and ironically, gives birth to the strongest satires and comedic sketches of all time. Now, it may feel like a sinister thing is gaining traction here. The fact that people consciously or subconsciously reveling in other people’s misery, showing utter disregard to humanity and benignancy which differentiates us from wild animals, might seem anything but noble.</p><p><strong>But only if things were that simple.</strong></p><p>When trying to understand the schadenfreude effect present in people and their taste in humors, we cannot boil it down too simplistically as we do for juveniles. Adults are more complicated and require a deeper thought to understand their thought processes. One such important factor is class tensions and power dynamics among people.</p><p>Power is a basic human craving which is very much unevenly distributed in the society. Social class, hierarchy, wealth and the political system often determine how much power and influence a person can hold. It can lead to immense frustrations among people. The working class or the people in the lower hierarchy are always at the mercy of the policymakers and of the administrators at the top. Politicians Businessmen dictate their life from all the way around. Now dissents can come at a cost. To go against the establishment is a very arduous job. You need an enormous manpower first of all. Be it through forming mass public opinion and mobilizing grassroots activism or through funneling enormous sums of money for recruiting and managing mercenaries from among the common public. An interesting way to form public opinion are through mass media contents. In ancient times, the voice of the people were poetry. Then came other forms of literature which had a substantial reflection of public opinions. The newspapers industry became even a bigger media which contained an amalgamation of thought of the general public. To quote Mahfuz Anam, from The Daily Star, Print media are the medium through which a government gets to have a close look into the minds of their constituency. In recent times, Digital media are playing a parallel role with the Print media for holding and expressing public opinion. Now, these opinions are from the people without any substantial power of influence. Such distributions of opinions influence others in forming their own, and thus giant public interests are formed. In a democratic society these interests are expected to be manifested through the voting system with mass, undisturbed public participation.</p><p>But what’s an effective tool for forming and mobilizing public opinion? News reports Op-eds are effective but boring. What works good is stoking public emotions and those are created by narratives. Through propaganda pieces, rhetorical showdowns, flashy posters, manifestos, etc. Now these all can be satirical or non satirical in nature. Satires are just another mode of dissent. Anything can be satire as long as it combines two fundamental things. It has to contain humor and a critique. If it doesn’t contain a humor, then it would only be counted as a critique. If it contains humor and not a critique, then it would be a simple comedy piece. Combine the two, and you get a satire. Satires can come in the form of literature, or in the form of imagery, or in the form of poetry, in propaganda posters or in pamphlets, etc. Among all the other forms of satires, cartoons seem to be drawing the most controversies, because of its potential power stored within it.</p><p>It however suffers from a little ambivalence. The nature of cartoons are unpredictable. It’s really tough to understand the course of a cartoon, if it would be powerful enough to mobilize the public. One reason is cartoons or satires have the power to tone down the intensity of a matter. But due to its entertaining value it sticks very well among the public. Cartoons are visual art. Unlike articles or protest manifestos written in words, cartoons come with a visual message. It is easier for humans to process visual imagery than a bunch of words jumbled together. It sticks for long too. That’s why children prefer pictorial educations, adults prefer infographics and graphical illustrations over tedious reports and mathematical jargons, consumers get driven towards creatively illustrated marketings strategies, newscasters like vox, nytimes, bloomberg quicktake, Al Jazeera, use animation tactics for fancy reportings and entice more audience etc. Compared with other forms of satires, cartoons have this advantage over its audience. It presents a visual imagery with an integrated critique to its viewers. It gives people an easy puzzle to solve. The image being the puzzle, and the narrative being the solution. Deciphering the message of the cartoon gives a sense of achievement, sends out a dopamine rush in the body. Although the sense may come consciously or unconsciously, but nevertheless it gives out a sense of intellectual pride, insinuating that you are smart enough to understand subtelties. Getting to understand the joke piles up on that sense of pleasure, inducing the humor, bringing about the smile or the laughter. This is true for every cartoon pieces, but the satirical cartoons are the ones deserving of some extra attention, due to their sheer strength stored in them.</p><p>Cartoons have always been a matter of controversy since their very inception in mass media. Cartoons have acted as a strong dissenting medium since generations. And lets be honest, powerful and influential people were never in favour of dissents. But for political check and balances they have to act like they are in favour or at least condone some level of dissents. To trace back the origins of caricatures, lets go to 19th century france, where King Louis Philippe just lifted censorship over the newspapers and has granted them considerable amount of freedom to exercise their freedom of speech. The french revolution consisting of working class people had led the pathway for king louis to ascend into power. Hence he was a little sympathetic to the public press. But the freedom he granted to the press backfired against him, after a satirist Honoré Daumier, who was a vocal critic of the monarchy, started doing caricatures on the king and publishing them in popular satirical dailies. Daumier’s first cartoon that caught him a lot of heat was Gargantua. Gargantua was a depiction of the the king which showed him taking food offerings from bureaucrats, elites, dignitaries while simultaneously defecating titles, honoraries, rewards for them in return. Daumier was persecuted for this drawing and was sentenced to six months in jail (the sentence was later suspended). Despite the persecution, he kept on continuing his caricatures in popular left wing dailies of those times. His cartoons got insanely notorious in the public spheres, gaining him an ever growing fanbase. The reason why I am calling him of having an ever growing fanbase? Well look at me, here I am, two centuries later, writing a blog noting his works down, oceans away from where Daumier or his journals were born.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Cy4LdWolmk1mxeSk.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Gargantua: Daumier</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The place Daumier initially worked for, La caricature was even more infamous. Its editor, Charles Philipon was an active participant of the French revolution. After the revolution, he started the publication but with a negative editorial attitude towards the monarchy. Most left wing publishers of that time believed that despite the working class bringing louis philippe to power, the revolution’s cause totally hijacked by the elites and the bureaucrats, and the king was acting as a chief patronizer for them. Philipon came up with a famous caricature of king louis philippe in his satirical weekly, named “Les Poires” or ‘The Pears”. It depicted the gradual descension of the king’s face into a pear in four steps.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*V_LC0eYMW9smX_sH.jpg" /><figcaption>“Les Poires” published in La Caricature.</figcaption></figure><p>This particular imagery has a great lot of significance. It agitated the monarchy a lot. They prosecuted Phillipon 6 times with 3 convictions, had him jailed for a year, seized all his journals and made him pay thousands of franc worth of fine. But the suppression only added fuel to the fire. As historians noted, this particular imagery spread like wildfire in the streets of Paris. Hundreds of festoons appeared in the corners of Paris all of which contains references to “The Pear”. It became so endemic that it was becoming increasinly tough to take the king seriously, since the thought of him alone gave people instant flashbacks of a silly looking pear. It toned down the king’s weight turning him into a laughing stock. Phillipon is considered to be one of the major influences in the world of freedom loving caricaturists who prefer dissents over conformity at any cost. In fact philippon can be credited with the first bold caricaturists who stood so hard against the tides. Dissenting cartoons don’t have a long past. The first caricaturist credit is given to William Hogwarth who drew inspirations from Italian and French paintings but incorporated his paintings in satirical ways, earning him the credit. Francisco Goya was a somewhat benign caricaturist too, but did not have such an acerbic style. It was basically after the development of lithography in 1790, after when print media saw a boom, that the wave of satirical caricatures started to gain traction, and began to draw public attention. And the spearhead was launched by none other than Phillipon. Who else would have taken this risk, unless a revolutionary from the core of his heart?</p><p>France has a rich legacy of political cartooning. It didn&#39;t come off so easy. Inherited from Greek-Roman traditions, French kings used to invite buffons to entertain them with humorous plays. They were even granted some freedom to poke fun at the king. Then buffons started to get replaced by literary geniuses who created more sophisticated satires and parodies. Jean de la Fontaine for example. In times of the French revolution, the proletariats used satires and mockery against the ruling monarchy, especially Marie Antoinette. the last queen of France before the French revolution, whom the people blamed for France’s financial crisis because of her carefree, extravagant lifestyle. She was popularly mocked with the title “Madame Deficit” for her lavish expenditures. It is noted that during the period of the French revolution, from 1789 to 1792, 1500 satirical illustrations were produced prompting the revolution to grow even stronger. After the French revolution, just at the time when lithography and print media started to see a boom, caricaturists, cartoonists, satirists saw a boon in their career with satirical dailies, weeklies being published regularly. I have mentioned of some popular French satirists above, like Daumier and Phillipon. Though the aftermath of French revolution gave rise to a wider press freedom by the king, the scenario quickly changed after the king was being frequently targeted by the press and the satirists. The freedom was scrapped from them and censorship was reinstated. But in 1881, the censorship law was revoked again bringing back the long cherished press freedom. This paved the way for cartoons to proliferate again. One famous cartoon of that time was Caran d’Ache’s famous cartoon, “They spoke about it”. The cartoon’s context was a famous political scandal of that time, the Dreyfus affair, which created massive political division in France at that time. It shows a family having a gleeful moment at the dinner table while all on a sudden breaking out in a huge conflict after the “Dreyfus Affair” gets brought up at the table. The Dreyfus affair centered around Alfred Dreyfus, a military personnel of jewish descent, who was falsely accused with treason against the French military. The affair divided the French population into two parties, the Dreyfusards and the anti Dreyfusards. The anti Dreyfusards were largely driven by anti semitism, whereas the Dreyfusards were motivated by republican values and individual rights. The Dreyfusards were little in number at first, but as the conspiracy by french military gradually started to unfold, a conspiracy which tried to falsely indict Dreyfus, their faction grew in number and in strength. The affair lasted for 12 years, and serves as an example of injustice and anti semitism prevalent at those periods. Despite that, this incident greatly reduced the clerical influence in the French republic and further corroborated the need of a free press. The peak outcome of the Dreyfus affair was the formal declaration of the “Separation of Church and State” in 1905, which firmly established the principle of “Laïcité”, or Secularism into the French Republic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*EgQR5ecNxjZei5tQ.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Drawing by <em>Caran d’Ache</em> in <em>Le Figaro: “They spoke about it”</em></strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*f-yjW2FOm4ko257U.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>A caricature of Jean-Baptiste Bienvenu-Martin, Minister of Public Instruction, forcing the separation between the church and the state, published in Le Rire in 1905.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Cartoonists in France thrived well in the following periods, from playing big roles in Stavisky affair, in both of the world wars, waging public opinion against the fifth president of the republic Charles De Gaulle, fighting against imperialism, capitalism and state control of the media in 1968 and in all throughout the 20th century. It became integrated into French culture so much to that it became completely inseparable. Cartoons have become so normalized that no matter how horrendous, it’s status was protected just as preciously as any other democratic rights of the republic. French satirists produced an abundance of propaganda cartoons on world war 1 which were so abundant in numbers that they are still a topic of interest for many researchers to study wartime psychologies.</p><p><strong>World War 1: French Cartoons</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*RCKzkj6FIVqR65cg" /><figcaption><strong>French cartoon showing germans failing to break into Russia through Northeastern Poland. The wolf here symbolizing russian troops.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/811/0*MU1cApAOBHAWhXmt.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Cartoon depicting French soldiers fighting against German soldiers drawn as bugs.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/0*uxWCKRA4CpkkIZj1.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>French soldiers throwing germans off their border. Germans were popularly caricatured as pigs, because in pre world war period, pigs were associated with good omen in german culture.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/816/0*2Gg8K_Z0meI_XI5T.jpg" /><figcaption>A pig protesting for being compared with the kaiser ( German emperor)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/820/0*iaG4rXomTiEJMeaX.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Cartoon depicting kaiser meeting gruesome fate in pursuit of his imperialist ambitions.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/816/0*M-9qYPRIbLRF5_Nk.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Cartoon showing senegalese soldiers kicking germans away into their border. It tried to insinuate that even africans, who were thought of to be inferior ( brrom on the hand instead of a bayonet for example) fight against this kind of german barabarity.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/509/0*KkaUv8rpDzbZLWAZ.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Cartoon showing kaiser turning into a serpent, constricting Marianne (personification for the French Republic), and a young french soldier fighting kaiser to free her.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/523/0*LIsXqyg6wfK2TzXI.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Cartoon showing a german soldier evolving into a monstrous ogre, becoming completely devoid of humanity</strong></figcaption></figure><p>World War 2: French Cartoons:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*dfW7ulPGov_8CaJN.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Anti Hitler Postcard in france.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*uOJfDMoTDDretUzV.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Cartoon showing hitler turning into a minotaur trying to devour the world map.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*NveaKSaDRXOfHtSd" /><figcaption><strong>“His last claim” by french caricaturist paul barbier. The signs from left to right say austria, czechoslovakia, poland and all the words adjacent to the feet translates to “His last claim”</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/503/1*j5wfoGtjMLI3Di6NQYoQqg.png" /><figcaption>Anti nazi propaganda postcard by French Artist Paul Barbier.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*oA8pmH2aiJbVrZ1r" /><figcaption><strong>German leader and his confession: Paul Barbier. It shows Jesus saying “Love each other” and hitler saying “ If he doesnt shut up i am gonna throw him in a concentration camp”.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*GWJVQjqTanpuuARa" /><figcaption><strong>Caricature of three prominent Nazi Leader.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Cartoons thrived and survived in 20th century without having less to fear about any monumental repercussions. There were one or two isolated incidents, like when a satirical magazine “Hari Kiri” was banned for publishing cartoons on the then deceased French president Charles de gaulle, but the ban was later lifted and the magazine went operational again.</p><p>But then 21st century happened.</p><p>It was in the 21st century that things started to take a graver turn. Although, not by the government which used to be the usual case throughout history, but rather through terrorist factions with their hardline ideological adherence. The repercussions didn’t befall the cartoonists in the form of petty boycotts or court battles but rather through straight on massacres and homicides.</p><p><strong>Enter Charlie Hebdo era…</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*B32CTn5FbiPFcJTn" /></figure><p>In the year 2011, a bomb went off in the office building of Charlie hebdo, a French satirical magazine publishing satires on trending issues around the globe. The bomb was a response to cartoons made by Charlie hebdo mocking the islamic faith. Prior to the incident Charlie Hebdo brought out an edition titled Chariah Hebdo (Shariah Hebdo), with the caricature of Prophet Muhammad (depicted as the guest editor of the edition) at the front cover with a quote saying, “100 lashes if you don’t die laughing”. The cartoon was a made as a response to the introduction of Shariah Law in libya and victory of the islamist party “Ennahada” in Tunisia. The cartoon triggered extremist muslims so bad that they were prompted to carry out a bomb raid on the magazine’s office. The event shook the whole nation sending shockwaves throughout every corners. The attack was akin to an attack on France’s republican values, and it’s deeply rooted values of freedom of speech. France’s then prime minister Filon, interior minister Guéant all voiced their support for Charlie hebdo. In 2012, Charlie hebdo made even more cartoons on Islamic extremism as a form of retaliation after violent protests erupted in the Islamic world as a reaction to a recently aired film “Innocence of Muslims”. Around 50 people were dead all over the Islamic world while leaving hundreds injured. Charlie targeted and mocked the extremism with their cartoons, gaining them even more notoriety. Though they were asked not to fuel the fire by the Foreign Minister of France, they stood firm on their free speech grounds. Then in 2015, another raid happened on Charlie Hebdo’s Office. Two Islamist gunmen forced into the office and conducted a mass shooting, leaving 12 staff cartoonist dead, including “Charb” who was in charge of the whole magazine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TyZW7hlBxBfR-r8o.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>“Charb”, director of Charlie Hebdo, one of the many who were assasinated in the 2015 terror attack.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>What happened after that was an avalanche of support for Charlie Hebdo. French Prime Minister François Hollande described it as a terrorist attack of utmost barbarity in french soil. The demand for the magazine skyrocketed, pushing them to print millions of copies to meet up with the demand. French government granted them 1 million euro to support the magazine. A google affiliated group donated 250,000 euro, guardian media group donated 100,000 euro. In the streets of the western world and in the internet protestors espoused the slogan “Je Suis Charlie” or “I am Charlie” as a way to show solidarity with the magazine and its causes. The survivors who were left alive in the magazine’s office pledged to continue publishing their works and not bow down to terrorist threats.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*NukzYZAgIrRQKivg.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Procession in support of Charlie Hebdo</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In the Islamic world, however the scenario were completely different. Massive protests against Charlie hebdo followed, demanding an all out ban on the magazine. Violent protests erupted in Niger, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Algeria, Jordan, Chechnya and many other places around the world leaving dozens dead and many more injured. A UK based islamist group gave charlie hebdo the “islamohphobe of the year” award as a way to insult. As a retaliation to the islamist group, another UK based NGO awarded Charlie hebdo with “Secularist of the year” award. The magazine authorities later donated the reward moneys from the award to the family of the murdered cartoonists.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cn7Ck0qsZN8whNBU.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1Oy9H4bJpIwVlnPa" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/0*W2XhGdINQg6Kro4q" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/0*4UIRl29Lvfnaza4R.jpg" /><figcaption>2015 Anti Charlie Hebdo Processions throughout the world.</figcaption></figure><p>Fast forward to 5 years, and history repeats again. On september 2020, Charlie Hebdo announced that it would reprint the prophet muhammad cartoons marking the 5th year anniversary that led to the violent mass shooting in their office. They announced it as a gesture to honor the dead artists on the occasion of the trial hearing of the murderers that was just a month away. This announcement was not taken lightly by the islamic world. Again a wave of protests broke out. Weeks after the publication, a pakistani immigrant carried out a knife attack injuring two people at Charlie Hebdo’s previous office location. The attacker didn’t know that the magazine office changed their location. But he admitted to have been driven by vengeance against the magazine for reprinting the caricatures of muhammad. French government backed Charlie Hebdo up and retorted that the enemies of the republic will never win, pledging to stand against islamist terrorism at any cost. Emmanuel Macron, French PM backed the rights of the caricatures to be published. Then just after a month, another terrorist attack shook the whole french world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/932/0*o0p9myWdiCyffJj3.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Samuel paty, a french teacher, decapitated in the streets of France by one of his students</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Samuel paty was a middle school teacher teaching geography, history and civics at the Collège Bois-d’Aulne. In a class on the topic of Freedom of Expression as a part of the “Civic Education course”, he showed his class a caricature of prophet Muhammad from an edition of the Charlie hebdo magazine. Prior to showing the photo he warned the class and asked them to close their eyes if they had issues with such cartoons. A series of online smear campaign and confrontation followed from one of the Muslim student of that class and her father. The father furthered corroborated the campaign with the help of a local extremist imam and strengthened the voice of condemnation. The online campaign spread throughout Islamic communities like wildfire. The incident prompted an 18 year old Islamist immigrant from Chechen, Abdoullakh Abouyedovich Anzarov, to take matters into his own hands and punish Paty for his misdeeds against his religion. Anzarov followed and decapitated him publicly in the streets before getting encountered by the French Police who shot the assailant to death.</p><p>This incident sent shockwaves again. Macron went even much more harder against the islamists, closing down mosques and NGOs with radical islamist ties, banning and deporting extremist preachers, and bringing social media extremist activities under police radar. He held a national tribute for Mr. Paty and posthumously awarded him the Legion of honor (Highest french order of merit). Charlie Hebdo cartoons were projected on govt buildings as a homage to Samuel paty, standing in straight defiance to the extremist demands. People brought down rallies in support of the murdered professor, paid their fair share of tributes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QT7xNuAKQlRUl5i7.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EpUIplCI5a7MkvQk.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/0*9lzalJrjayUUaO_Q" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bGACEPWrUhmxbADK" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/813/0*d1g3R4jyWauxXIXv" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/992/0*qOXhAAXU87xWoXbV" /></figure><p>But all of this, especially the projection of charlie hebdo cartoon on national building as a homage to Samuel Paty came with a serious backlash from the muslim world. Accompanied with Macron’s statement “Islam is in a crisis”, and his pledge to battle radical and political islam at any cost, it put France into a huge diplomatic crisis. Most of the loudest voices were heard from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Bangladeshi islamist groups brought out rallies to beseige French embassy and demand cutting diplomatic ties with France. Pakistani Islamists group were doing the same. But in a more louder way. Unlike Bangladeshi govt who tackled this problem very wisely, bowing down to no islamist demands, Pakistani prime minster could not do that. He had to condemn French government as per the islamist demand with all his might to appease to the Islamists of his country. But that alone wasnt enough. Pakistani radical Islamist group “Tehrik e Labbaik Pakistan” started to create more grassroot mobilization and finally in 2021 came out in large number besieging the streets of Lahore to demand the expulsion of french ambassador of Pakistan. It created massive problems for Pakistan, amounting to several deaths of policemen and protesters. Imran khan tried to lobby the Muslim world into pressurizing the European countries to introduce blasphemy laws in their respected constitutions. Apart from Imran khan among the other Muslim nations, Erdogan was a key player in anti French campaign. He called macron a mentally deranged person and that he needed mental treatment. Macron recalled his French ambassador to Turkey as a retaliation for such remarks. Erdogan asked for other countries to boycott French products despite keeping Turkey’s trade ties well alive with the French. The boycott never succeeded. No govt responded to that, rather it were just mere individuals boycotting French products from their personal positions. But that didn’t quite have any significant effect on French trade. Iran asked the international community to put tough sanctions on France for disrespecting Islam, but that too never saw the light of the day.</p><p>The reason I have so focused and elaborated on France because France is the only country who was most hard bent on the issue of protecting their rights to satirize despite massive global pressure. The practice of caricaturing is so mired within their history that it has become integral to French identity. The vigor with which French society defended their rights to freedom of speech and the rights to satirize any social issues they feel like, is unparalleled. Its not like that other countries do not have such passionate cartoonists. They do, but stirring up global tensions on such mass scale and striving for the rights of cartooning despite diplomatic backlashes were only seen from the part of the French Republic. Like France, Denmark too had their fair share of cartoon related diplomatic troubles. The Jyllands-Posten Muhammad cartoons controversy for example. The Danish magazine Jyllands-Posten posted 12 cartoons on prophet Muhammad which were met intense backlashes. Massive riots followed globally leaving hundreds of people dead. Embassies were attacked, ambassadors were recalled, massive boycotts and assassination attempts were followed. Whereas on the other hand, many publishers of other western countries decided to reprint the cartoons as a retaliation to the hostility that erupted throughout the whole world. The countries included France, Norway, Sweden, Ukraine, Netherlands, Germany, Spain, USA, UK etc. The diplomatic tensions grew so severe that the Danish Prime Minister compared the diplomatic crisis with the one that followed after the second world war broke out. The events were so huge that summing them up would require a whole new article. I am therefore dropping the link down below for anyone who is interested in knowing the full timeline of the whole crisis.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_Jyllands-Posten_Muhammad_cartoons_controversy">Timeline of the Jyllands-Posten Muhammad cartoons controversy - Wikipedia</a></p><p><strong>Keep in mind, all of this happened just because of a bunch of cartoons, 12 to be precise.</strong></p><p>Another such diplomatic furor occurred way back in the times of second world war. The spark was caused by a UK based caricaturist David Low. Low used to specialize in creating political cartoons. He published a lot of cartoons on Austrian civil war, Spanish civil war, Italian invasion of Ethiopia and many other political events prior to second world war. Low specially rose in fame for his acerbic caricatures on Hitler, Mussolini and Stalin in times of second world war. But it was Hitler who took particular issues with Low’s caricatures on him. Low’s cartoons were banned in Germany and in Italy. But Hitler could never move on from Low’s stinging depiction of his. According to British Foreign minster of that time, Lord Helifax, the German officials used to go crazy as soon as any copy of the Evening Standard reached them. After getting their hands on the paper, phones used to buzz, everyone’s tempers flared up, fevers mounted, and the whole system used to go in a frenzy. Germans banned the paper, but the officials used to get some copies to understand whats happening in the UK. And the relentless cartoons from Low irritated them a lot. It irritate them to so much that Helifax had to request Low to go a little easy on Hitler and the Nazis. Because the cartoons were impeding the peace process between Germany and the UK. Low hesitantly had to agree, since he didnt want to be escalate the world war tensions. Hitler on the other hand was plotting a different plan with his foreign press secretary, Ernst Putzi. Since he couldnt just silence the Evening Standard and David Low, so he sought out other damage control methods. It was Putzi’s idea that they bring out a paper debunking all the gross allegations made by the antagonizing cartoons. And that they did. They published Hitler in der Karikatur der Welt: Tat gegen Tinte (Hitler in the World’s Cartoons: Facts Versus Ink). You can compare it with modern day fact check. They used to pick up cartoons and fact checked it. Like when a Cartoon depicting Hitler as the grim reaper in the paper “The Nation” suggested that Hitler was a warmonger, Putzi added the facts that Hitler was on the contrary trying to make his ambassadors sign up peace agreements (The four powers pact) in order to establish peace between France, Germany, Italy and the UK. But verbal response to visual cartoons were doomed to fail and that it did. People don&#39;t get enticed into checking snopes just as much as they are enticed at seeing silly memes and ‘The Onion” articles. Same thing happened there. The cartoons were always triumphant over fact checking by the Nazis. No one liked to read big essays debunking a cartoon. The project failed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/351/0*nlh5f4nO7RBsKSYO.png" /><figcaption><strong>Georges, “The Grim Reaper,” The Nation (1933)</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/774/0*qFUFXdBgBPL_IjXV.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>David Low and the Dicators. The cartoon expressing that Hitler and Mussolini are scared to tears at the ink of David low.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>It was not only cartoonists like Low who created wartime propaganda but satirists from all aspects did. Low specialized in creating still images. But there were motion pictures, animations which took a hit at the rival countries too. An abundance of propaganda animated cartoons were created, with Walt Disney, Warner Bros leading the industry at that time. The propagandas were made to manufacture public consents for war, for helping out the military into getting more recruits for war. These cartoons, animations all served as driving forces for people joining in the military. One of the most notable propaganda cartoon has to be the Ductators of Looney tunes where it takes a hit on Hitler, Mussolini and Hideki Tojo.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FrVtB6afVg9A%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DrVtB6afVg9A&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FrVtB6afVg9A%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/50876abc6b7600164b720fd7cb78a464/href">https://medium.com/media/50876abc6b7600164b720fd7cb78a464/href</a></iframe><p>It would be unfair not to include Walt Disney propaganda too. The time when Donald Duck becomes a Nazi in his dreams. Pure classic!</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FL90smU0SOcQ%3Fstart%3D78%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D78&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DL90smU0SOcQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FL90smU0SOcQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/813cbd7a1a01da1d14b7494f0899354b/href">https://medium.com/media/813cbd7a1a01da1d14b7494f0899354b/href</a></iframe><p>There were propaganda from the soviets against the Americans too but none matched the strength and comedy wit of the American industries. Also it can be attributed to the fact that anti Nazi alliances had more freer and less restrictive environment for cultural practices.</p><p>But it was not only Hitler who used to get a fit looking at cartoons. This paranoia about cartoons are universal. But some system are good at suppressing them, whereas some aren’t. Thomas Nast for example, took a hit on Boss Tweed and his cronies. Nast pointed out with his cartoons how cunningly tweed and his allies were stealing from the public fund. Nast’s savage depiction exposed his corruption under broad daylight. Tweed understood the power of Nast’s pen. And he instinctively tried to do everything possible from his part to stop Nast. He anguishly asked the papers to stop Nast from publishing his cartoons. “ Stop them damn pictures”, he famously said, “ I don&#39;t care a straw about your newspaper articles, my constituents cannot read. But they can’t help seeing at those pictures”. Nast was even offered an art scholarship worth 500,000$ to stop targeting Tweed an his gangs with his cartoons, which Nast respectfully refused. Tweed’s fear ultimately came to be true. Nast’s cartoons mobilized public opinion so much that even people from far and beyond got to know who tweed and his gang were despite having to do nothing with them. Tweed and his gang were eventually thrown out of the office, stripped off their roles, were charged with swindling money and were awaiting trial. Tweed escaped in Spain, living there as an exile, as a seamen in a ship. But a Spanish customs official recognized him from one of Nast’s drawings. Tweed was recaptured and brought back to justice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*QZ1xZr3l1Jkrs4Nf.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Boss Tweed, depicted as so greedy of an individual, that a sack of money replaced his head</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/711/1*MH4gfEKNQUp75grNYJucrA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Nast on the Tweed ring. Each of the ring blaming each other for the theft of public fund</strong></figcaption></figure><p>That&#39;s the power of cartoons that every powerful people fear. It possesses the power to strip them naked under broad daylight, that otherwise might not have been possible. It can mobilize public opinion so much that it works as a purveyor of political change.</p><p>Although it would be wrong to think all these times the establishment were in completely good terms with cartoonists, since they helped spread their version of propaganda in wars and other efforts against the enemy. There were times when cartoonists took a stance against their own nations doings. The masses were such a magazine spearheaded by Art Young. There were many other contributors like Robert Minor, Carl Sandberg, Amy Lowell etc. But the themes was what was important. The masses was anti war and in most cases, anti capitalist. The cartoons of the publication were greeted with great public appreciation. But it was met with hostility from the establishment. Art young and the Masses along with Eastmen were charged with sedition and espionage. The court asked if they tried to undermine war efforts and create hurt the recruitment process by swaying people’s sentiment away from the war? Young wasn&#39;t ashamed into admitting that he was anti-war. Though the jury couldn&#39;t come up with a verdict, but nonetheless the publication had to stop functioning any longer. Young was a hero to the public, so despite the masses being short lived, his imprint remained fresh till this day, as a pioneering anti war figure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/549/1*bnyGPZVgxjecou77I9GCpw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Art young’s caricature on jesus published at The Masses. The cartoon was aimed at criticizing the government for persecuting anyone who preached peace and stood against the war efforts.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Dissenting Cartoons were prevalent in Germany too. From George Grosz to Kathe Kollowitz to John Heartfield all were some of the dissenting voices of that time. But all of them were suppressed with the rise of fascism. These cartoonists had some communist leanings and were anti war. Hence they fell under the radar of the Nazi government. Grosz fled the country sensing a rise of fascism taking place, while heartfield was forced into exile. Heartfield’s office was vandalized and all cartoons were destroyed prior to that. The Nazi government on the other hand, had one or two propaganda cartoon publication too. Der sturmer for example. It alone outchampioned all the other publications thank to govt patronizing and suppressing dissenters. The paper spread hatred on the jews, capitalists and communists and helped the Nazis rise to power. All the left leaning anti war publications couldn&#39;t match up with its might and could not prevent the Nazis from rising to power. The paper mostly targeted at Jews, blaming them for all the world’s problems.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/595/1*tR8dQd9ATvJz8aSpUEcqkg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Der stumer cartoon portryaing a greedy jew with both capitalist and communist leanings pressing his butt against the globe.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>It was one of the biggest and the most successful purveyor of antisemitism in Nazi Germany. It showed Jewish ritual murders, Jewish criminality, Jewish connection with devils and demons, Jewish goal of global domination, Jewish conspiracy against the whole world and what not. It also showed Jewish as filthy communists, rapists, greedy capitalists, seducer of Aryan women, and portrayed the Jewish intellectuals as untrustworthy, dishonest, secretive, disloyal. All of those were instrumental into building public opinion against the Jews which eventually paved the way for mass Jewish persecution in Nazi Germany. The publisher of Der Sturmer, Julius Streicher, earned millions selling the anti semitic propaganda. Streicher regularly authorized articles and cartoons demanding the extermination of the Jewish race in Der Sturmer. Nazi politicians of that time had this to say about Der Sturmer,</p><blockquote>With pleasure, I say that the <em>Stürmer</em>, more than any other daily or weekly newspaper, has made clear to the people in simple ways the danger of Jewry. Without Julius Streicher and his <em>Stürmer</em>, the importance of a solution to the Jewish question would not be seen to be as critical as it actually is by many citizens. It is therefore to be hoped that those who want to learn the unvarnished truth about the Jewish question will read the <em>Stürmer</em></blockquote><p>Streicher’s ambition of a global annihilation of the Jews didn’t go unpunished. After the fall of Hitler, at the Nuremberg trials, Streicher was put to justice. He was found guilty of war crimes and hanged to death.</p><p>But Der Sturmer raises an interesting question. On free speech grounds, should Der Sturmer have been spared? Cartoons demonize and stereotype their targets all the time. It attacks politicians, ideologies, socio-political movements, communities, cultural niches, and any other thing that exists in the society. If cartoons need to be free, it should be free for all. Thus creating a legit paradox. The paradox of tolerance. Even France, the country which protects the freedom of expression of it’s satirical publications like a hawk protecting its chicks, banned cartoons on the holocaust. It also restricts cartoons from antagonizing certain groups of people. Even the French agree that absolute freedom cannot be granted, lest a Der Sturmer case reappers. But on the legality of the rights of Charlie Hebdo and Jylland-Posten, the argument was that, cartoons should free to attack any ideologies. No individual ideology should be singled out and given special rights over the other. Since religion is a ideology, hence it falls under such category. If cartoons on Christianity, Buddhism, Judaism etc. can be accepted then singling out Islam would be an unfair thing to do. And not only the big Abrahamic religions but any religion can be made fun of, since at the end of the day these are just mere ideologies like any other. Ideologies aren’t just restricted to religion, but there are many others. Political and Social ideologies are abundant. Feminism, Communism, Liberalism, Neoliberalism, Libertarianism, Conservatism, Secularism, Environmentalism, Fascism, Ecofascism, Nationalism, Anarchism, Syndicalism, Transhumanism are just one of the many. To grant one group immunity from criticism over the others would be showing inconsitency and appeasing to a portion of demography over the other. Macron says ideologies politicians all should be subject to criticism for the better good of mankind. That&#39;s how problems are exposed, talked about while mobilizing the society towards a change. But revisiting history such as the holocaust are banned because the trauma are still fresh on the genocide survivors. The genocides are not a concept but rather an actual happening in human history. In most cases, the genocide denials or mockery are done with political motives. For example, in Bangladesh the ones downplaying the genocides of 1971 are done by the anti liberation forces or Pakistan loyalists. Same with the holocaust deniers. Usually people who are Nazi sympathizers, or just basic antisemites espouse such views on the holocausts. The neo Nazis of the west for example. And then there are the orthodox Muslims and hardline Christians who are at odds with the Jews for their orthodox religious views. Iran for example, are notorious to poke at the authenticity of the holocaust. President Ahmadinejad was constantly on somewhat denial when pressed by the journalists on the holocaust issue. The new president Hassan Rouhani takes a softer line but nonetheless the prevalence existed for ages in Iran. Apart from religious reasons, another reason here is political. Iran and Israel both are the mightiest in terms of nuclear power on the middle east. And both of them are arch enemies, which dates back to the Arab-Israel war. Hence any tragedies of Israeli Jews are bound to be undermined by Iranians because the misery of the enemy is always an advantage (Remember Schadenfreude?). Hence other Muslim nations, especially the ones with whom Israel aren’t at odds with acknowledge the authenticity of the holocaust for as it is without any hesitation, except for Iran, who are still at somewhat denial coming from their national level officials. When the Danish cartoon incident happened, Iran was one of the fiercest opponents. Iran held International Holocaust Cartoon Contest in 2006 as a response to jylland-posten. The reward for the best cartoons were 5000$-12000$ for the top 3 winner while 3 gold coins for each 9 that followed. The organizers sought out to continue this initiative for as long as Israel does not cease to exist. But it didn’t get continued. Instead the 2nd International Holocaust Cartoon Competition occurred after the Charlie Hebdo attack in 2016. Such politics of genocide denials which affect its survivors and their lineage is what makes them abhorrent in the eyes of the international community. Denying other genocides or making cartoons on them are equally prohibited in most countries. In Bangladesh, 1971 genocide denial or revisiting history will land one in jail with maximum prison term let alone making cartoons on them. This is to honor the genocide survivors and halt the anti liberation war politics led by the Pakistani loyalist blocks. Genocide archives and repertoires are usually well substantiated. Most of the denials don&#39;t spring out from goodwill rather to distort the truth for political ambitions. Hence Iranians aren&#39;t practicing free speech when organizing International Holocaust Cartoon Competition but poking through the fresh wounds that the Nazi genocide survivors still have in them, for sadistic and political purposes. Its not only holocaust survivors but hate speech against any communities are not greeted well. Its one thing to criticize an ideology and another thing to go full on Der Sturmer. Most people confuse between these two. They conflate ideological criticism with mindless bullying and nefariously curated ethnic demonizing. But to think like this is perfectly normal, since understanding the nuances would require understanding the contexts which might seem daunting. Charlie Hebdo when asked, asserted that they published cartoons as per their policy. They pushed criticisms through cartoons, attacking ideologies from all ends. They didn’t agree to singling out Islam whereas they regularly published cartoons on Christianity Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism and others. It would be unfair, they claim, to give one community immunity under the pressure and threat of terrorism while blasting all the rest. They delineated free speech from hate speech and ethnic demonizing. Macron uttered the same thing when he sat for an interview with al jazeera with regards to this specific issue.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FT_rSzeweybM%3Fstart%3D1282%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D1282&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DT_rSzeweybM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FT_rSzeweybM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5db43cbc633881805442031314ec6437/href">https://medium.com/media/5db43cbc633881805442031314ec6437/href</a></iframe><p>Another notable diplomatic row happened in the eighties when Margaret thatcher was in power of the UK. The incident occurred with the assassination of a Palestinian cartoonist Naji al Ali. Naji al ali was born in Palestine but had to move into exile into Lebanon after the Palestinian war. He grew up in many parts of Lebanon but afterwards he moved to Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and then finally to London for the shifting nature of his career and jobs. He was deeply entrenched in the Arab nationalist movements and portrayed a lot of layman Arab opinions through his cartoons. His cartoons were so genuinely reflecting of the average Arab voice that the guardian labelled him as “the nearest thing there is to an Arab Public Opinion”. Naji al ali was famous for his iconic cartoon “Handala”. It is the symbol of Palestinian defiance against the oppression pressed upon them. Handala has a rich legacy. It has been so widely adopted that Palestinian streets are filled with this symbol. Walls, buildings poles and what not. Handala can be seen in jewelry motifs too. It also served as a mascot for boycotts, divestment and sanction (BDS) movement, and also as a mascot for Iranian green movement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/244/0*xtiBpwt8s3HyeHUR.gif" /><figcaption>Handala</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Sot9V58EZgCIpc7h.jpg" /><figcaption>Handala graffiti in palestinian streets</figcaption></figure><p>Naji al ali was a critic of both Israeli and Arab politicians earning him disfavor from both sides. But thats not Naji al ali. That was reflective of the whole arab population living in the west bank, gaza and palestinian refugee camps. Everybody were fed up with the arab leadership for failing them as well as remaining harshly bitter to the israeli occupation. But acting as the representative of such critical opinion concentrated the wrath of the politicians on Naji al ali specifically. He was working for international newspapers which posed a threat the arab-israeli leadership’s political image. In 1987, Naji al ali was assasinated under broad daylights outside the office of the Kuwaiti Newspaper Al Qabas where he worked for. It is still unclear who commissioned his assasination but it is widely believed that PLO was responsible for his death. Although many hands point to Force 17 who worked for Yasser Arafat. But the troubles arose after involvement of Mossad was exposed. After the capture of some suspected assailants, it was found that they were working as double agents. Despite being on the hit team working for the PLO, they confessed to collaborating with the Mossad too. It was then revealed that Mossad knew beforehand about the assisnation project that was to be carried out against Naji al ali. But they chose not to intervene. British intelligence were heavily displeased with this. Mossad’s decision to remain uncooperative on this matter with their british counterparts by not sharing information prior to the assasination attempt, paved the way to the gruesome death of Naji al Ali. British govt expelled three israeli diplomats as a retaliation. Margaret Thatcher was extremely infuriated and ordered the closure of the Mossad’s Base in London.</p><p>To note a positive aftermath of diplomatic conflagrations caused by cartoons, libya comes in mind first. Gaddafi and his regime falsely accused 5 buglarian nurses and a palestinian medical intern of conspiring to inject 400+ children in a hospital at Benghazi with the HIV Virus. They tortured and forced confessions out of them. After spending 8 years in jail and trials after trials, they were sentenced to death by firing squads by the libyan high court. Novinar, a bulgarian daily, chose to print some cartoons as a criticism to Danish government for not pressuring libyan government enough to rescue their citizens. It antagnoized and demonized Gaddafi while critiquing Bulgarian government. The cartoons caused immense uproar, mobilized public opinion all around. Gaddafi could realize the potential it was gaining. Libyan foreign minister summoned bulgarian ambassador and asked that the cartoons were hurting libyan image and they would like it to be stopped. The embassy ensured that they distanced from the cartoons and are in no way endorsing them. But the damage had been already done. The cartoons were phenomenal and an instant sensation. It stripped gaddafi and his regime naked to the public eye. Upon pressures from all around, gaddafi agreed to extradite the prisoners to bulgaria where afterwards the bulgarian president proceeded to pardon them . Had it not been Novinar, an alternate reality might have easily occured. Oh and by the way, did I forget to mention that Novinar was the first and only paper who had reprinted all the 12 danish cartoons in defiance to the response of the islamic communities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/1*mOhMMIULy7jL_bAJZFJpmQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Gaddafi, writing thank you for your quiet diplomacy to bulgaria, while 5 gallows dedicated to the bulgarians lurk behind. Published in Novinar</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Diplomatic tensions are big incidents, hence make the breaking news. But an abundance of domestic tensions arise due to cartoonists picking up domestic targets and satirizing them. Churchill for example ordered an investigation into Daily Mirror to look out for cartoonists who were hurting national interests by publishing demoralizing cartoons. The cartoonist on target was Philip Zec who published a cartoon critical of Churchill administration for jeopardizing human lives in their pursuit of war over oil. Churchill’s home secretary summoned the daily mirror’s chairman, editors to talk over this issue. He compared the cartoons to Nazi era propaganda. The matter even went into the parliament inducing there a heated debate. The paper was threatened to be closed down but after the govt got too invested in the war, the issue was thrown under the rug. Zec went back to his drawing board. Bill Maudlin was another anti war caricaturist who exposed the grim reality of the war. He was too pressurized to tone down his caricatures because it was hurting wartime recruitment processes. Maudlin’s anti war, anti propaganda rhetorics through his cartoons were swaying people away from joining the war. Censorships weighed in from the editors too. Out of 246 cartoon submission of his in the post war period, 40 were weeded out. Editors unjustly erased off his cartoons, alleged him for red baiting politicians and having communist ties. Another Cartoonists Herblock was also a significant force against the prevalent red scare of that period. Herblock was one of the originators who came up with the term McCarthyism. McCarthyism referred to persecution of people based upon unfounded, unsubstantiated, suspected allegation of cooperating with the communists to subvert national interests. It mainly targeted govt and federal employees, labor union leaders, academics etc. charging hundreds and leaving them jobless or imprisoned. The allegations were mostly false and fabricated and serves as an historical case of paranoia over communism in the modern US. Maudlin caricatured this paranoia to show how absurd it was. He also bitterly depicted Richard Nixon when his Watergate scandal broke out. Nixon, upon seeing the cartoon, cancelled subscription of the Washington post out of his sheer outrage. Maudlin even got his name enlisted into the infamous “enemies list” of Richard Nixon, which was a list of his assumed political enemies whom he later targeted to destroy. Cartoonists getting into hit lists arent anything new. Before Maudlin, David low was one of the cartoonists to get into the hit list of Nazis. Naji al ali got into the hit list of Palestine Liberation Organization. Sri Lankan cartoonist Jifry Yoonos was stabbed, beaten and terrorized for caricaturing then president of Sri Lanka Renaisighe Primadas. Iranian Cartoonist Manouchehr Karimzadeh was sentenced to 50 lashes, ten years in prison and a hefty for caricaturing creating a cartoon resembling the young ayatollah khameini.Argenitian cartoonist Cristian Dwoznik was kidnapped, robbed and threatened not to satirize the president through his cartoons. Cameroonian cartoonist popoli was dragged out of his car by security forces, beaten up mercilessly and jailed for caricaturing the first lady of cameroo. Sri lankan cartoonist, Pragneeth Eknaligoda was forcefully disappeared. Syrian cartoonist Ali fezrat was abducted, fingers cracked in retaliation over his cartoons on Bashar al Assad by Syrian forces. Another Iranian cartoonist was Mahmoud Shokraye was sentenced to twenty five lashes for creating cartoon on an member of parliament of Iran. A Belarusian cartoonist oreg minich was forced to choose between serving 5 years in prison or permanent exile. Such are the examples which only further illustrate the power of cartoons.</p><p>Apart from getting into hit lists or enemies lists, there are multiple occasions where cartoonists were persecuted by leaders. French far right political leader Marine le Pen for example sued Charlie Hebdo for cartooning her. South African president Jacob Zuma sued a cartoonist in court, who depicted him as a rapist raping lady justice. The cartoon insinuated that Jacob Zuma was manipulating and destroying the sanctity of the justice system. Same thing happened with the prime minister of UK, John Major. There was a gossip in the press about Major that he was having an affair with his caterer Clare Latimer. Platt, an editor of new statesman published a cartoon on this gossip under the headline, “The Curious Case of John Major’s ‘Mistress’ ”. Major sued the new statesman, which pushed the new statesman towards bankruptcy, and got platt fired from his job. Although Major had the upper hand in the case because there were no concrete proof of major’s affair at that time, but 10 years later it was revealed that indeed he had. When Platt was asked to reflect on the past about his cartoon on the Major he says,</p><blockquote>I should have realized that no one protests so loudly as the crook who is rightly accused, but can claim innocence in particular circumstances</blockquote><p>Truly, only the paranoids have the loudest voices.</p><p>The tradition of chasing down cartoonists by prime ministers, presidents or presidential candidates are still alive till this day. When Barry blitt published his new yorker cartoon on the Obamas, Obama had to pause his campaign works and address the issue regarding the cartoon. Usually pausing down an election campaigns to address an specific issue, when other pressing things are at hand to be dealt with, insinuates that its a major thing that cannot go unaddressed. That&#39;s how cartoons even shake the chair of the mightiest. But the Barry blitt’s cartoon in new yorker wasn’t understood in context, which gave rise to the problem. The cartoon showed Obama fistbumping Michell Obama while wearing jihadist clothes. This was considered racial stereotyping and straight on demonizing. It was harmful for Obama’s campaign too since it fueled the suspense and conspiracy theories around him. Hence Obama took the time to pause his campaign and denounce the cartoon. But the cartoon, on the other hand, was intended to satirize the right wing viewpoint of Obama at that time. Right wing supporters viewed Obama as a covert islamist agent set to destroy the west, for his name “Barack Hossain Obama”. But the context was misunderstood and hence severe backlashes followed. President trump also tried to pin down a cartoonist for satirizing him. Trump’s legal team tried to take off a cartoon from the internet by exploiting IP rights. The cartoon showed trump fooling his followers with pseudoscientific cures for covid, like kool aid, hydroxychloroquine and Clorox. The followers were shown to have wore MAGA hats. Trump campaign’s legal team used the “MAGA” hat part of the cartoon and cleverly exploited it for legal persecution. They claimed it to be intellectual property of trump campaign and hence to be immediately removed from the internet. It was the time before the 2020 election so it can be easily presumed why the paranoia could’ve been triggered in the trump campaign.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/890/0*hdPXVj9IXgknz6fh" /></figure><p>The world have advanced a lot. Abduction and forced disappearances or assassinations aren’t a wise way to respond to cartoons if you are in powerful position. These could be obviously weapon of the vigilantes but powerful people can’t afford doing unlawful things to take personal revenge. What they instead do is resort to the law. Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan once was jailed for 4 months for reciting a satirical inflammatory poem. He was seen to be the beacon of free speech, but after assuming office, he became the very thing he wanted to destroy. He sued a cartoonist and the publication Cumhuriyet for portraying him as a cat entangled in a ball of wool. He then sued another newspaper Sakarya for reprinting the cartoons. Another time he took another paper Evrensel to court for portraying him as a horse. For animal loving Turkish people, Erdogan does seem to be deviating a lot. He once charged and led to the arrest of 4 Turkish students for portraying him alongside animals which Erdogan resembled in a graduation ceremony. There was a time he even sued a doctor for sharing a meme on the internet which compared him to the fictional character “Gollum” from Lord of the rings.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*EShRd4AybsrBlA_C.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/395/0*b6Ab6PDLKA6zwtks.png" /><figcaption><strong>Erdogan as a cat entangled in a ball of wool on the right, and as gollum from the lord of the rings at the right.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Erdogan didn’t keep his persecution spree domestic only. He went international with his suing strategy. He once sued A Dutch Far right politician for portraying him as a terrorist. Then he pledged strict lawsuits against Charlie Hebdo for defaming him through their cartoons. Erdogan’s intolerance for cartoons only earned him more criticism since he was once viewed as a champion of free speech and human rights when he was an active advocate of those while not in power. But getting power changes the equation. Intolerance arises. As they say, a free press is an opponent’s dream but an incumbent’s nightmare. Indian minister’s have their fair share too in this case. Recently on the course of West Bengal election a BJP worker was arrested for sharing a meme on Mamta Banerjee which morphed her face into Priyanka chopra’s face, with an intent to mock. She was later released but it raised a countrywide furor over the attack of freedom of speech. But it was not the first time for Mamta Banerjee’s party to sue others for ridiculing Mamta Banerjee. Before this 2021 election, in 2012 a professor from Jadavpur university, Ambikesh Mahapatra was too jailed for sharing a cartoon on Mamta Banerjee. But what&#39;s funny is, the opposition party, BJP, who blamed Mamta for intolerance, took a cartoonist to court for caricaturing their leader Narendra Modi. In 2011, Harish Yadav was sued in court for a cartoon on Narendra Modi where it shows him refusing a skull cap from a Muslim cleric. This is the 21st century way of dealing with hurtful cartoons, i.e take people to courts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*AhqAWfL-3_82tqI7.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Mamata Banerjee’s meme that caused the furor</strong></figcaption></figure><p>But to blame politicians only and spare the community would be wrong too. Sometimes community acts as a force to pressurize cartoonists from depicting things they value. Sometimes a politicians stake is carried out by his/her over-enthusiastic supporters. Sometimes when ideologies or groups are satirized, collective actions follow. For example when David Levine drew Henry Kissinger screwing the world, he got severe backlashes from his co workers alleging the cartoon to be sexist. David Levine was working for the Nation at the time. When majority of the Nation’s staff revolted the only strong supporter of the cartoon remained was Christopher Hitchens who too was a contributor of the Nations. The letter signed by The Nation’s stuff wrote,</p><blockquote>As workers at The Nation, we protest the publication of David Levine’s cartoon in the February 25 issue. The problem is not that the drawing is sexually frank; it is that a progressive magazine has no business using rape jokes and sexist imagery (he screws, she is screwed) to make the point that Kissinger revels in international dominance. Kissinger is a man, but the globe is not a woman. The artist’s intention may have been to dramatize the confusion between sex and power in the mind of a powerful white, middle-aged man. But the publication of his drawing shows that The Nation itself is imbued with that mentality. No wonder seven out of ten of our subscribers are men</blockquote><p>to which Christopher Hitchens wrote,</p><blockquote>How depressing that so many Nation colleagues should confuse the use of a stereotype, even as an artistic satire, with the reinforcement of a stereotype. The only safeguard against such a literal mentality would be the adoption of the Islamic code which, in order to be on the safe side, forbids all depictions of the human body as profane. The last sentence of their letter is just silly</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*TuDO5FuEqAyk_h4t" /><figcaption><strong>“Henry Kissinger, screwing the world”, by David Levine</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Then there was a time when Art Spiegelman, a cartoonist inspired by David Levine, drew a cartoon mocking policemen who fired fourty one bullets at an unarmed New Guinea immigrant. From the mayor to the governor, all denounced it. Hundred of police officers revolted, picketing the new yorker’s (the publisher of the cartoons) office. They even went as far as publishing an op-ed in new york post as a response to the cartoons saying,</p><blockquote>If you’re burglarized or your family is menaced by thugs, you should be consistent. Call Al Sharpton instead of 911. See where that gets you, Spiegelman, you creep.</blockquote><p>Then there was a time when “The Nation” was heavily lampooned for a cartoon made on Abraham Lincoln by Robert Grossman. The cartoon was “Babe Lincoln” which portrayed Abraham Lincoln as a cross dresser, based on the rumors around his sexuality. It was denounced as homophobic garbage and was alleged to fuel up the tensions and violence against the homosexuals. But it was actually just putting rumors into context as per Grossman and the meaning was completely upto the audience to decipher. Another cartoonist Raymond Jackson was a target of the mob too. He was a popular target because he didn&#39;t used to target individuals but rather groups. That&#39;s how he managed to offend so many numbers of people. One time he caricatured power workers who were protesting for meeting up with their demands. It led to such fury that they threatened to shut down the Evening Standards through blocking power supply to the press. He even satirized Irish people when IRA had bombed in London killing 8 people. It drew heavy backlashes from the Irish diaspora. It also gave rise to debates on the thin line between and non racism when it came to the rights of cartooning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/694/1*-VXDOdVIaV9PfbNnK_8awg.png" /></figure><p>To mention something from the recent times, Patrick Chappatte’s parting away with the nytimes comes to mind. Patrick Chappatte was a cartoonist from the nytimes who were had a rich legacy of covering cartoons from conflict ridden areas. Nytimes once published a cartoon from a famous Portuguese cartoonist about a blind trump administration being guided by the Israeli administration. Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu was portrayed as a dog with an Israeli locket hanging from it’s neck. And a blind Donald trump was portrayed as being guided the dog (Israeli PM). The cartoon sever backlashes from all over, with nytimes being charged with antisemitism. There had to be a lot of damage control being done by the nytimes. Nytimes didn’t even have a meeting with its cartoonists or other editors, but rather decided on to go with banning all political cartoons from then on. Under public pressure Nytimes had to stop a cartoon critical on the relationship of US-Israeli relationship. In stark contrast to the power of cartoons, an angry mob outweighs it all. On the brighter side, it paved the way for a wonderful TED talk by Patrick Chappatte. It was one of my early inspiration to dig deeper into the world of cartoons. Had nytimes not fired Patrick Chappatte i would have never got to see such an illuminating TED talk (thanks nytimes, i guess). Chappette perfectly explains how mob culture suppresses the cartoons and cancels the artists if they don&#39;t see it fit. In other words, he explains the tyranny of the majority pretty well.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FMIGtyaVb2Xc%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DMIGtyaVb2Xc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FMIGtyaVb2Xc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c01b00a97b40acc62922330f25a2425d/href">https://medium.com/media/c01b00a97b40acc62922330f25a2425d/href</a></iframe><p>The article by Patrick Chappette, in his blog, was a wonderful read too.</p><p><a href="https://www.chappatte.com/en/the-end-of-political-cartoons-at-the-new-york-times/">The end of political cartoons at The New York Times | Chappatte.com</a></p><p>There was also a case where a group of policemen were under fire for sharing a George Floyd cartoon in their group chat. George Floyd case was a sensitive case in the US where a black man named George Floyd was killed under a police knee-on-neck restraint. The incident of sharing a meme on George Floyd was leaked and the officer who shared the meme in the police group chat was fired. There are countless such scattered cases where people got “canceled out” for their questionable sense of humor which others deemed inappropriate, especially in the United States. Its not a bad thing per se, to hold people accountable for being menacing views, but nevertheless, it is definitely a form of censoring through social pressures.</p><p>But keep it in mind that, all of these instances are coming from very much liberal countries. Lets not talk about the conservative countries all over the world where cartoonist enjoy even less and less freedom. When it comes to Bangladesh, the biggest incident to happen was in 2007. The newspaper prothom alo published an editorial cartoon in its satirical magazine Alpin’s 431st edition. The cartoon was drawn by a 20 year cartoonist Arifur Rahman, under the title “Naam”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/601/0*ADHA_wLLhuVWcXyx.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Arifur Rahman</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/185/0*PMV9G-6dceE3GS9p.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Alpin Cartoon that gave rise to the 2007 cartoon controversy in Bangladesh. First frame: the elderly person asks the boy his name and the boy replies “my name is babu”. Second frame: The elderly person instructs the boy to say “muhammad” before saying someone’s name. Third frame: The elderly person asks what is the boy’s father’s name to which the boy replies, Mohammad Abu. Fourth frame: The elderly person asks the boy what is the creature in his lap to which the boy replies, “ Mohammad Biral”</strong></figcaption></figure><p>This cartoon created massive riots across Bangladesh. Clerics met with the highest government bodies asking for the revocation of the license of prothom alo. They demanded the arrest of Prothom Alo’s editor Matiur Rahman and the editor of Daily star Mahfuz anam. The cartoonist was arrested under emergency laws and dhaka court sentenced him to imprisonment for hurting religious sentiments. After two months of rigorous imprisonment he was let free on bail. Arifur Rhaman later was granted political asylum by Norway and he continues to live there in exile. Alpin stopped circulation, the editor of prothom alo apologized and launched a new satirical magazine roshalo following the closure of Alpin.</p><p>Bangladeshi cartoonists always had to work in an environment of fear. Since the country has very poor police and legal framework and are filled with conservative and political hardliners it is very tough to maneuver and publish cartoons. Although there were a rich culture of caricaturing in our country but it slowly saw a sharp drop. Each newspaper used to be filled with editorial cartoons but with the introduction of draconian laws and constant attack on the free press, it became tougher and tougher to continue the political caricaturing culture. There was a cartoonist Shishir Bhattacharjee who used to create political caricatures regularly on notable leaders in the leading dailies. Now they seem to be non existent. Previously the laws weren&#39;t so draconian but with the recent implementation of the digital security act (DSA) the culture of fear grew even more stronger. Now political cartoons are on life support. Even if someone tries to draw something they have to be very careful as not to wake up the lion. Cartoonists have to self censor a lot of things in order to avoid troubles or just basically draw things that are benign, non political, non religious. Satirizing religion have been completely banned, so that part remains untouched. Its understandable, since a country full of hooligans cannot be kept calm without the introduction of some sort of draconian laws. With the boom of internet and better connectivity, justification behind the laws become more apparent because a simple agitation can create instant ripple effects and result in devastating riots. But although it could put a huge leash on the cartoonist’s hands, and could halt further 2007 Alpin controversies from happening, it restricted cartoonist’s freedom even more. Anyone can use DSA if their feelings get hurt to lock up cartoonists. Satirizing the prime minister have been completely banned. Even MPs sue cartoonists for hurting their feelings. A famous case, the wounds of which are still sharp, is the case of Ahmed kishore and Mushtaq Ahmed. Kishore used to draw cartoons critical of the government. especially the handling of the covid crisis, loan defaulting etc. Mushtaq was a writer and an online activist. They both were charged with sedition and spreading propaganda. After immense tortures in the jail, writer mushtaq died in prison. the whole world broke out in criticism of the bangladeshi government for attacking freedom of speech and stifling dissenting voices. From Amnesty to HRW to all the human rights think tank, everyone condemned this move. After the death of mushtaq, upon enormous local and foreign pressure, cartoonist kishore was freed on bail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*Bj1y0DxwSsmKw2JL.png" /><figcaption>Cartoonist kishore (left), Writer Mushtaq (right).</figcaption></figure><p>The washington post even published a full page ad from the CPJ advocating for the release of cartoonist kishore.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/0*UsfNlSQLzBH7mSt2" /></figure><p>Now this is not something that suddenly happened. It was the result of a decade old attack on the freedom of press and the implementation of the draconian law that is the Digital Security Act. One of the leading magazine in Bangladesh is Unmad led by Ahsan Habib. Unmad had been here since the dawn of the eighties, 1978 to be precise. The magazine was hugely inspired by “Mad Magazine”. Unmad used to feature a lot of political cartoons too. But slowly that tradition dwindled out, because as per Ahsan Habib, they wanted to play things safe. The magazine still publishes a lot of great stuffs but its domain have been curbed to a lot. Without being granted a substantial amount of freedom, cartooning loses its value. Hence we don&#39;t have a sorel or a levine or a david low. all we have are benign soldiers. And that&#39;s exactly what the establishment always wanted. To avoid unnecessary troubles by the likes of strong caricature vigilantes like Thomas Nast, whose cartoons propelled the downfall of Boss tweed and his cronies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qKcOKB5o4oLsIwvn.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Unmad making political covers, but only the ones that wont get them sued.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>But its not a sudden incident that just took place. The culture of persecution and intimidation piled up for generations. This is just the result of it all. In a talk popular talk show “Ajker Bangladesh”, the host of the talk show Khaled Mohiuddin aired an episode on Political Cartoons. He invited notable cartoonist Shishir bhattacharjee and Ahsan Habib along with professor Golam Rahman and journalist Abed Khan for a discussion over the culture of caricature in our country. The guests revealed how they sweeten down cartoons and captions to avoid making unnecessary agitation and spare themselves the troubles. Shishir Bhattacharjee mentions how they avoid making cartoons on the highest political figures of the country (except for when emergency cases, when massive mobilization are present in the streets). Golam Rahman elaborates on the culture of political intolerance of our country as well as of our neighboring country which is a root cause of intolerance towards cartoons. Ahsan Habib explains how he sweetens cartoons according to the country’s tolerance atmosphere. They also discuss on the trajectory of the whole cartooning culture in Bangladesh, its present and its future scenario. They also chuckle on the fact that they have so many libel cases against them amounting to crores that it makes them burst out in laughter that someone at least thought of them of being millionaires. But shishir bhattacharjee mentions an interesting thing. The caricature of expediency, i.e. caricaturing after risk assessing. This is a vital to every cartoonist in the world for their own protection. But it only gives a measure of how “free” a society actually is.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FiEzHL0tR4Ik%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DiEzHL0tR4Ik&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FiEzHL0tR4Ik%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/10fc978ffe93795cdd708846462a8029/href">https://medium.com/media/10fc978ffe93795cdd708846462a8029/href</a></iframe><p>Shishir Bhattacharjee mentions another instance from his memory which I thought should be included to add some more context to a statement previously made, that a free press is a weapon for the oppositions, but a threat to the incumbents. He recalls a time when Saifur rahman newly appointed economist minister, a person who liked his cartoons once turned against him because he took issue with a particular critical of him. He threatened shishir with punitive actions. Shishir later came up with a rejoinder expressing his deep apologies to do damage control. Good thing that he didn’t hold the grudge, otherwise god knows what could have happened — shishir says. He only highlighted how tough it was becoming day by day to caricature our democratically elected leaders and hold them accountable. Saifur rahman even tried to stop the circulation of a newspaper “Bhorer kagoj” by intervening with the printing process of the press which printed the paper. So the attack on cartoons and free press is nothing new. It dates way back. Its just because of the increased connectivity and increased exposure, that the control mechanism on the press have been further intensified.</p><p>But despite the love and hate relationship between the politicians and the press, it does serve the politicians a lot. If you are a subject of being cartooned constantly, it implies that you are getting a good amount of public attention and a matter of public priority. This induces a sense of supremacy in oneself. Even if the cartoons are bad , being depicted on a frequent basis means that you are occupying a huge share of public’s attention. Ralph Steadman understood this psychology and so once he pulled out a manifesto as response to politicians complaining too much.</p><blockquote>I urged all cartoonists in the world to stop drawing. I considered that if all cartoonists did that, even for one year, politicians as we know them would change. If we denied them the benefit of our attention, insight, and wit, they would suʃer withdrawal symptoms of such withering magnitude that the eʃect on their egos could only be guessed at. Not even a tyrant can survive the whiplash of indiʃerenc</blockquote><p>Steadman halted from doing political cartoons for 23 years but after some months later he broke his abstinence by drawing three cartoons on Margaret thatcher.</p><p>Cartoons serve politicians in a different way too. For example, in the 2016 US election, Donald Trump’s election victory is believed to have been largely influenced by online memes exploding on his behalf. There were domestic and internationally conducted meme campaigns on social media. Specially Russian trolls, who were found to be operating from Moscow through fake Facebook and twitter handles, spreading propaganda memes with popular conservative tropes. Their target were the average churchgoing Christians, military veterans, working class white people and most of those who were the center of trump campaign’s target voters. The memes included Christian and Jesus trites, Clinton depicted as Satan with budding horns, hypernationalism, rampant islamophobia, communist paranoia, xenophobia, guns &amp; beers and freedoms, American dream and uncle sam references, and all other textbook republican selling points. Although trolling are just a part of the bigger picture. Trolls alone cannot bring one to power, but can merely cement an already existing sentiment. After all the point of cartoons and caricatures is to take some elements from the real word, amplify it and induce within it some sense of humor. “We memed a president into existence” was a popular talking point of memers and trolls of that time, raging from 4chan to twitter to Facebook. One of the most trending memes of those times were “Pepe the frog”. A children’s cartoon character, Pepe the frog, created by Matt furie, was gradually adopted by the internet as a meme character. Prior to 2016 elections, it started to get appropriated by the right wing circles. Donald trump tweeted a meme showing a version of pepe the frog personifying him, quoting, “You Can’t Stump the Trump”. Internet broke down with creative right wing pepe meme from then on. It turned into such a frenzy that it quickly got adopted as being the mascot meme for the right wing political diaspora. Merches were being sold like crazy, for example Alex jones who benefitted a lot out of the pepe hysteria. Matt furie, the creator wasn’t fascinated with this of course. He despised the fact that his creation was appropriated by people who ideology he felt to be despicable. he didn’t want to see his creation get further polluted in the mainstream. So, he sued alex jones over copyright claim. The case was closed after backdoor settlement worth 15k was made and Alex jones pledged never to use Pepe the frog in his works again in his political advocacies and merch sells. There is a whole documentary based on this whole “Pepe” fiasco. The documentary is named “Feels good man”, and can be accessed through Amazon Prime.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FZEiqZWw5vYs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DZEiqZWw5vYs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FZEiqZWw5vYs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b85360137f90d3054fdb5b949c6f89f0/href">https://medium.com/media/b85360137f90d3054fdb5b949c6f89f0/href</a></iframe><p>To know further, on how satires can influential elections, check the article below which clearly articulates the dynamics of satires and their influences on the 2016 election.</p><p><a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/01/23/how-jokes-won-the-election?utm_source=twitter&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_campaign=onsite-share&amp;utm_brand=the-new-yorker&amp;utm_social-type=earned">How Jokes Won the 2016 Election</a></p><p>But its not just that Donald trump only benefitted from freelance trolls working on behalf of him. His later years in office were stained with counter trolls who were constantly making fun of him on social media. But this time not just trolls, but whole media ganged up on him. All the popular talk show hosts, comedians, cartoonists all ganged up on Donald trump. Although there were some fair share of satirists from the republican aisle, but that&#39;s was too insignificant to counter the satire wave against Donald trump in mainstream media. Saturday night live used to hold at least some episode each season mocking Donald trump. Alec Baldwin became a household name for doing Donald Trump impressions. SNL overdid the sketches so much that Donald trump started to become indistinguishable from alex baldwin doing his impression. Now as i said earlier, politicians always had a love and hate relationship with satirists. So did Donald. He once even hosted Saturday night live. His monologue can be still found on YouTube. But after SNL targeted him, he became too salty about SNL.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/797/0*b8rRiMPBO-5m-NSg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/896/0*WxEIFmMb5R8s9Vh-.jpg" /></figure><p>After so many coordinated attacks from mainstream media outlets like nytimes, economist, newyorker, washingtonpost etc. and through constant satirizations through late night talk shows, comedy shows, caricatures, online memes etc., public opinion gradually started to skew towards the democratic aisle. It became a “cool” and “trendy” trait to satirizie trump. Although the satires were well deserving since Donald Trump is actually a living joke, but dehumazining him so much was more of a manufactured dominno effect or a hysteria you can say, rather than a natural progression of events. This gave Joe Biden an edge and rose him to power eventually. Donald trump’s blunders were so much in his career, that right wing satirists were getting cornered by conscience and communal pressures. It was being increasingly tough to create right wing political cartoons without being deemed as an associate of stupidity. But cartoons and satires were always targeted towards the intelligent, who can calculate out the humor. This vaccuum of right wing cartoonists were easily filled in democrat leaning cartoonists who had conscience to back them up. Right wing cartoonists had to defend, while their opponents had to attack. And attack is the basis of high impact cartoons. Remember “Schadenfreude?’ Thus history flipped for Donald trump in the 2020 elections and he was eventually thrown out of the office. And lets not forget the impact “South park” had towards a relatively young audience. Although south park takes a centrist approach in every issue, but when they went for trump they could do anything but be centrist. Because of course, the reality was so absurd, and every action of trump demanded a joke. How could they tilt towards his side, when Donald trump was supplying them with incessant pool of contents. South park turned their long running character Mr. Garrison into a personification of Donald Trump and it was in anything but approving of him.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fi-fNKErt1PU&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Di-fNKErt1PU&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fi-fNKErt1PU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/38d33810ba97c478c34ba43520e0e3f2/href">https://medium.com/media/38d33810ba97c478c34ba43520e0e3f2/href</a></iframe><p>Like south park another great centrist satire group were the onion, who targeted both of the sides. The onion was and still is a widely acknowledged sensation. It lives on the absurdity of events which regularly unfold into American politics. Onion shows absurdity in such a trustable way, that even the most naive people and even politicians get baited into believing it. Onion articles, videos contain layers and layers of irony. Onion format of ironical humor have been adopted widely by other parts of the world too. To name one such, Earki from Bangladesh comes in mind. The online satire portal is directly influenced by Onion’s ironical humor style. Although Onion propagates no views of their own, Earki injects their views at intervals of their humors. Onion on the other hand remains completely ironical 24/7 with no clear, unironical messages to it’s audience. For example take a look at this onion video satirizing conspiracy theorist of the Al qayeda terror attack. Check the layers of irony working in this place.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FQ_OIXfkXEj0%3Flist%3DPLE4B9FD1BE4772DE3&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DQ_OIXfkXEj0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FQ_OIXfkXEj0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/dcf20dce02408ccd33ffb0eafbe2dc86/href">https://medium.com/media/dcf20dce02408ccd33ffb0eafbe2dc86/href</a></iframe><p>The ironies are so hard to catch that it fooled a lot of people including donald trump, us congressmen, fifa executives and who not.</p><p><a href="https://abcnews.go.com/International/times-people-fooled-onion/story?id=31444478">All the Times People Were Fooled by The Onion</a></p><p>Thus a free press converges to a point of check and balance by itself, through each sides constantly satirizing the other sides exposing their absurdities. It is an evolution towards a condition where less absurdity remains, because the more absurd something/someone gets, the more vulnerable target it would become for satriziations. Because the fuel for satires is the absurd and no one wants to supply the other side with a generous amount of fuel. But this can be only done in a healthy democracy. In autocratic countries, there are no check and balances. There is always a leash that the powerful and the influentials put onto the cartoonists, who are dictated at their every move, their every penstroke. There are no checks and balances of narratives here. On the other hand, there are linearization of narratives. The evolution towards less absurdity therefore don&#39;t get mobilized. hence making way for an ocean of absurdities to stay alive. Autocrats are the most memed/caricatured in everywhere but their country. The more resistance they show the more they are made fun of. Xi jinping is famously parodied to be Winnie the pooh. This got so widespread, that the Chinese authority cracked down on social media sites. The Chinese social media completely blacklisted any references to winne the pooh. Kim Jong Un is even mocked by world leaders, “Rocket Man” as trump mentioned of him in the United Nations. Cartoons are a resistance towards autocratic suppressions. They are symbol of the people’s will. Thats why they say “The freedom of cartoons and satires in a country is the measurement of it’s democracy”. No wonder cartoonists in autocratic nations suffer more than any other representative democratic countries. This reminds me of the cartoon of General Yahya Khan in the liberation war of Bangladesh. The cartoon was drawn by ‘Patua’ Quamrul Hassan showing Yahya khan as a beast. This became an emblem of Bangladeshi defiance against pakistani aggression.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/456/0*o88SIT6WBK0nFLW_.jpg" /><figcaption>Caricature of Pakistani despot Yahya Khan in times of Bangladeshi Liberation War.</figcaption></figure><p>The demise of caricatures is always a grim signal towards a dying democracy. In Egypt for example, Bassem youssef, a satirist who drew inspirations from Jon Stewart, launched a late night talk show in Egypt. The talk show was basically designed to be a copy of Jon stewart’s talk show but for Egyptian people circling around Egyptian affairs. But Egypt was not a democracy. Despite Muslim Brotherhood gaining power through a democratic process, most of their actions were in a sense anti-democratic but merely populist. Bassem Yousuf’s studio was vandalized, he was prosecuted and arrested and later pushed into exile. Iranian show “Parazit”, which too was influenced by he “Daily show” in America faced the same fate too. It was launched before the presidential election and was basically a comedic political commentary like the daily shows. The show lasted for 3 years until it had to be packed up following domestic pressures. The daily show format had appealed not only to Americans but towards the whole world. In Russia, Navalny, the political opponent to Vladimir Putin launched a similar thing. He made youtube videos in the style of daily shows, exposing the corruption of the putin government. And as autocrat nations go, it too did not go well for navalny. He was poisoned with a deadly nerve agent Novichok by the Russian authorities while he was in a flight, and was left in a critical condition. He survived but it only increased his domestic approval even more. Navalny had been a global sensation after this, earning him a huge amount of domestic and international political clout.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FhrORwk_RZLM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DhrORwk_RZLM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FhrORwk_RZLM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/66c4ce5245e57498ab35ad1cdaf14faa/href">https://medium.com/media/66c4ce5245e57498ab35ad1cdaf14faa/href</a></iframe><p>And then there are Bangladeshi satirists like Naveed Mabub. Although he modeled his comedy talk show following the model of late night talk shows in America, but his satire serves very little purpose. The comedy is stale and benign, mostly dad jokes. The jokes are non offensive so that he may stay on the safe side without falling out of favor with his hosts. Without the “schadenfreude”, it is obvious that the show would not be much funny. Satires need to be bold, not cowardly and catering to the powerful. And submitting to fear never gave rise to a good comedy. Naveed Mahbub’s show fails from all aspects. Then there are people who export the late night talk show culture into other countries. Pilot Media intiatives were such a team who had undertaken such a project in Nigeria. The whole journey was such challenging, to train the Nigerians and to manage everything perfectly for airing the first episodes, that it deserved a story of it’s own. The result of the project was “The other news” hosted by Okey Bakassi. It too was a comedic commentary on Nigerian politics. The show was an instant hit among nigerians. Okey Bakassi even aimed at running for president in 2019 elections being so hyped with his indulgment in Nigerian politics. Satire, thus was used to cement Nigerian democracy. All these satirists take elements from the regular public and create satires along with that to earn maximum public approval. Thus further cementing democracy of theire corresponding regions.</p><p>Now although it may feel mean to make satires on others or the beliefs they hold. My friend Mrinmoy voiced the same concern to me. But that will only leave us with comedies like Tom and Jerry. The satires with socio-political components are bound to be preserved. They keep our democracy in check, gives the voiceless a voice, makes the powerful and influential accountable. It also gives a cathartic release to the people derived of power. If you can’t do anything or take actions against something unfair, unjust or just plainly absurd, the best you can do is expose all its absurdity and laugh your hearts out. When others share the same feeling with you, your laughter increases thousandfold, because of the group sentiments you all share of course. Like agitation, laughter is contagious. And unlike agitation it actually keeps the mind and body healthy. Many government even prefer that. By giving somewhat freedom to cartoons they give a sense of free press. Political unrests follow whenever people take it to the streets, get agitated that is. But letting the agitation turn into cathartic laughter you can easily deter people from coming out. If you let people just laugh at their homes, tone down their adrenaline with dopamines, you can control riots from breaking out in the streets. This is something cartoonist Dwayne Booth agrees to as well. “ he government wants you inside the house, laughing at petty jokes”, as he says. But nonetheless political cartoons are important. Against a powerful person or a powerful ideology one might feel himself helpless, but a cartoon can help him vent away his frustration. Also it helps mobilizing public opinion and cementing the already rebellious sentiments among a bunch of agitated people. But It acts more like fueling the fire than instigating the fire. If the fire is already there, the fuel only puff up it’s flames. Steadman famously said, “The only things of value is the things you cant say. thats why drawing is so important, it gives you a way to express what cannot be put into words”. Steadman also corroborates the claim that cartoons help in venting frustrations or disappointments. He once aspired to assassinate Ronald Reagan, the 40th president of the United States. But after getting to caricature him, his willpower vanished.</p><blockquote>“It’s a form of assassination”, he says, “What you want to do is to cause that person damage. But not lethal, physical damage. If you can psychologically damage someone then you are really doing something. I’m all for that. It’s the story of every serious satirist.” — Ralph Steadman</blockquote><p>Who knew our inner schadenfreude feature would evolve us into making such humors and satires which would navigate us towards cementing our democracy and channeling our suppressed emotions, giving voice to the voiceless, to the powerless. It holds the mighty and the powerful accountable, mobilizes social opinions and glues the commonfolks even more rigidly. This sheer impact of political cartoons and their potential of social transformation is what makes it the strongest of all forms of painting. This is why despite the risks, political cartoons yet have not relinquished. Even if it they go relinquished in mainstream platforms, there will always be vigilante platforms through which they will find their way out. Facebook for example. Most of the dissenting voices can be seen on facebook which dont make their way to the mainstream publication. Social media like Facebook, Twitter, Reddit with their liberal policies gave host to more dissenting voices than any government could grant it’s citizens. Arab Spring was an outcome of massive social media mobilizations too. Also, it was a breeder of immense cartoons against tyranny and dictatorship in the age of Arab spring. Satires and Caricatures would always find their ways our and be immoral.</p><p>But if you ask my stance on censorship, I have somewhat ambivalent views. I do acknowledge the fact that anti semitism or islamophobia, racism, homophobia or sexism is blatantly wrong. But I also acknowledge the fact that these tropes have been really unfairly used to silence cartoonists from making cartoons even a bit critical of their ideology or their group. For example Patrick Chappatte and his cartoon department at nytimes who were accused to be antisemite were shut down, or the Charlie hebdo magazine whose staffs got gruesomely murdered amidst gross accusation of islamophobia, or the Cartoon by David levine which got backlashes for sexism, or the Babe lincoln cartoon which was branded as homophobic, or the Irish cartoon by Raymand Jackson which was accused to be racial stereotyping, or Kishore’s cartoon which were deemed to be seditious landing him in torture cell of the government. What we need is to understand the context before jumping to conclusion when speaking of satires. Many times the contexts are overlooked which creates big misunderstandings. We also should show some bits of tolerance so that caricaturists get the the maximum freedom to exhibit their creativity, while paraelly keeping close watch so that no new Der sturmer case may reappaer which would lead towards another holocaust like event.</p><p>But tolerance is something which apparently is a lot to ask for.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6f1c6e1fd269" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Template ideologies]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/template-ideologies-9dc7aeb9f0f?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dc7aeb9f0f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2020 07:38:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-17T16:53:39.194Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*or0KJMTL20Go5Wdy.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong>“Everything is Ideology”</strong></blockquote><p><strong>- </strong>Slavoj Zizek, Slovenian Political Philosopher and Cultural Critic</p><p>And I cannot agree more.</p><p>After all, what is a man but a collection of ideas embodied in a biological body?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FPk8ibrfXvpQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DPk8ibrfXvpQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FPk8ibrfXvpQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/90ab715925c67861e4883561d2b084d2/href">https://medium.com/media/90ab715925c67861e4883561d2b084d2/href</a></iframe><p>When someone says that he is free from any sort of ideological bounds, he is either delusional or lying. To be a human is to have a set of ideals that propels one through the course of life. Our code of conducts don’t spring out of the blue. Like most of our animal neighbors, we too are learning species. Despite our genetic markups which define our instincts and biological traits, our social constructs are completely influenced by the data that we feed into our minds regularly. Our brain takes in the data, computes them, analyzes them, contextualizes them with a frame of reference and provides us with an injunction- to adopt it or to abandon it? or maybe embrace some parts of it?</p><p>Ideologies are just a bunch of concepts, or a set of social constructs to be more precise. Animals who don’t live in solitary have to abide by some code of conducts so as not to delve into chaos with it’s fellow species. Being animals, one of the genetic attribute is to fight each other over the right to mate, access to resources and asserting territorial dominance. The more social an animal species become, the more they need to come out of primitivity in order to keep their social structures stable. Lion prides, Ant colony, Wolf Packs, Chimp Societies etc. all show certain social behavioral patterns through which they glue their societies. Such ideological patterns help them cooperate in groups with stunning efficiency. After all, cooperation is the key to conquer. Humans are nothing but advanced monkeys. So, if anything, such ideological social constructs should be even more pronounced in human societies.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FTud_giDF2Zg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DTud_giDF2Zg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FTud_giDF2Zg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/23897663372e29719102d7b11c1ca094/href">https://medium.com/media/23897663372e29719102d7b11c1ca094/href</a></iframe><p>The documentary series Animals Like Us (embedded above^) cements this argument. The documentary series created by wildlife filmmaker Guillaume Poyet highlights the fact that we are not as unique as we deem ourselves to be. We are just an extension to what already exists in the animal kingdom. This particular episode shows the viewers how animals structure their political hierarchy and how eerily that resembles with our diverse dominant political systems. To quote the narrator,</p><blockquote>Well Before Humans developed the political ideologies of Hitler, Gandhi or Kennedy, animals developed an array of strategy to make their communities work and impose their will on others.</blockquote><p>From Formica ant making federalist Supercolonies, to colonizing Polyergus ants raiding Formica ant colonies and turning them into slaves, to misogynistic Baboon tyrants, to hyperliberal bonobo societies, to nepotistic/opportunist chimps lobbying and forming syndicates to stage coup to replace their clan leaders, to democratic Red Deers, the filmmakers dive deep into the political frameworks of the animal kingdom. There is another interesting fact into this episode. A comment on the episode shows people’s conspicuous ideological bias even while watching innocent animal videos. There are in total 11 episodes of this series, all of which tries to draw parallel between animal and humans in terms of emotions, culture, language, trade, business, etc. But none of them contain such an exemplary feedback from its viewers which fits perfectly to the essence of this article.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DRYobXrIaocasoKLHZmdug.png" /></figure><p>What’s evident through this is that people put on their ideological lenses before their eyes before proceeding on to perceive anything. The force of the ideology (which is feminism in this case) is so strong that it drives the commentator to aggressively react to the video, and dismissing it on the go. While the video is certainly not about feminism but rather animal behavior, the commentator decides to stop watching it since it conflicts with the ideology that she holds dear to her. It’s not to argue that feminism is bad or anything. But what gets vivid from this is the nature of adherence to ideology. Again, it is not to say that feminism is a bad ideology or something. I myself associate with the feminist cause. But that was never the core substance of the film, in fact it was just one sentence spanning for some seconds in the 50 minutes long film. To criticize this particular sentence, you certainly don’t need to boycott the whole body of work. But that’s what happens when ideology gets the good of you. Now, its not imply that we ourselves/the tolerating bunch are any different. Maybe we can neutrally analyze this situation because we do not have such strict emotional adherence to feminism. But what if we saw the narrator glorify pedophilia in a sentence? What if instead “a male’s paradise”, he told “a child enthusiast’s paradise”? Would we not react the same aggressive way? Many might say being a male isn’t a crime but a pedophilia is, so both should not be held under the same standards of judgement. True. But what’s more true is the fact that, in both cases, the substance of the film doesn’t change. So judging the film by a split of second strips away its central motive, which is to educate people about a portion of animal behavior.</p><p><em>(Although I tend to side with the narrator here, since projecting human moral standards and ethical values to animals is not a wise thing to do. The narrator simply narrated the incidents in reference to animal kingdom, not in reference to human societies. So blaming him for misogyny would be inadvertently blaming nature for misogyny.)</em></p><p>Now that’s one instance of strict ideological adherence. You can see examples such strict adherence everywhere. From Communists, to Religious fanatics to Animal rights activists, to New age atheists, to Gender right activists etc. Every ideological spectrum will have its fair share of fundies. Their adherence is so impassioned that it blinds them from seeing any nuances.</p><p>What you won’t see on the other hand is the instance of a person without any ideological attachment, unless he lives in the jungle, all by himself. If a person thinks workers should enjoy particular rights, he supports the worker’s rights cause. If he doesn’t approve of that, he would support the stakeholder’s cause. If a person thinks women should enjoy equal rights as men, he already believes in the feminist cause. If he doesn’t believe that, then he lines up with the traditional gender role cause. There are many people who thinks they don’t have any political ideologies. It couldn’t be any more wrong. A person cannot live outside of the realms of politics. Everything is politics, including your clothes” — a popular saying goes. Those who brag on not having opinions on any political affairs, inadvertently submits to the status quo. It may look like he is ignorant and unaware, but he is unaware because he doesn’t feel the necessity to ponder upon the status quo system that he is a part of. He is subconsciously playing along with the status quo as his preferred political system. If someone thinks that sth is wrong with the current political system that he is a part of he must have an opinion in his mind on how he wants to see things. Human rights/Dehumanization, Feminism/Anti-feminism, Communism/Capitalism, Nationalism/Globalism we all tend to align ourselves with a particular ideological direction. Sometimes our ideological association may be parts of this aisle and parts of that. For example, someone may oppose mass immigration, while advocating for free global market. Such amalgam of sentiments stemming from opposing ideological angles are usually the dominant ones. But nonetheless, you can’t find anyone with zero ideological attachments. Those keeping silent/indifferent are basically submitters to the status quo.</p><p>So, ideologically speaking, a man can be categorized as such,</p><ol><li>Strict Adherents</li><li>Strict Opposers</li><li>Partial Adherents/Partial Opposers.</li><li>Indifferent/Unconscious Perpetuators</li></ol><p>Take any ideology or socio-economic concept out of the random, and you will are sure to fall under one of this four categories.</p><h4><strong>Template Ideologies</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/626/0*_7b1ZEGw58Z07Qlb" /></figure><p>Ideologies are integral portion of societies. We are evolutionary driven to associate ourselves with a variant of socio-ideologies. Because, as the authors of the animals like us documentary say, we want to see our visions and wills to be manifested in the society that we live in. We all want things to go our way. From the religious fanatics to the liberal communists all want to live in a world with their visions manifested in all the corners of the society.</p><p>Template ideologies are for people who want to associate themselves with ideological movements but do not have much time at their disposal to understand their nuances. Therefore, they rely on others feeding it to them in small, shallow, digestable chunks which they will promulgate through their platforms. Most people are template ideologists, including myself. It’s not possible to get an overall nuanced view of all the ideologies that we tend to adhere to, in such a busy scheduled life. Our lifespan is limited, and we’ve got work to do in order to feed ourselves. Hence to make the best utilization of time, we try to surf around the surface and adopt what’s convenient and easily comprehensible to build up our identities and personalities. We want to fall under groups, get a sense of belonging and be a part of the big waves, not like aimless, lonely isolated ripples.</p><p>These things are kind of like Wordpress templates. Providing people with numerous templates to build their websites upon and sparing them off the burden from having to code, Wordpress saves their time and energy. Like most of the Wordpress websites looking the same and consisting of similar features and limited functionalities , most template ideologies look and work the same way too. But just like Wordpress, template ideologies have large user and propagation base.</p><p>Template humanism for example, is to quote one or two quotes from Rumi, Mandela, Gandhi, Lenon, Dalai lama or other similar people. Or share theatrical humanitarian works by humanitarian agencies/charity donors/rich philanthropists/rich celebrities. To be a template feminist is to spew out highly overused clichés about women empowerment and share one or two feminist quotes from glittery blogs, women CEOs or popular celebrities. To be a template atheist is to quote Dawkins, Harris, Hitchens, Stephen fry, Carl Sagan etc. despite not caring to read any of their works. To be a template religious one needs to share one or two religious quotes out of context that fits his narrative and throw it to the world to see. He doesn’t necessarily need to understand religious nuances in order to express his belief and identity to others. He just needs to make other’s aware of his personalities through shallow materials. To be a template communist, one needs to put up a Che Guevara tee shirt despite not caring to know Che’s life’s trajectory, his influences, his visions, his wars. A template libertarian on the other hand will just utter the word “Freedom” like a broken record, and occasionally quote one or two Ayn rand quotes. Template art enthusiast is to know one and one artist only, who ironically would be Vincent Van Gogh and to reduce more, just one of his painting, Starry Night.</p><p>Now are template ideologies bad? I wouldn’t say so. Template ideologies work as great memes. I mean not the edgy memes on social media, but memes as a cultural unit. Memes are ideas that are spread socially, like genes which are spread biologically. Like genes, more reproduction increases the chances of survival. The more a genetic host reproduces, the more chances of that genome to flourish and dominate. Of course, keeping into account that, the offsprings need to be strong and immune. Memes work as no different. It’s the strongest and the most reproductive of the memes that stick till the end of the day. Ideologies are after all conceptual cultural units too.</p><p>It wouldn’t have been possible to bring people under the umbrella of war without spreading nationalistic, tribalistic ideologies. The idea of nationalism has been around for generations, since the birth of State from Ancient Greek Periods. States formed under nationalistic banners and nationalism was vital to wage wars towards other tribes/empires and expand the already existing territory. The usefulness of this ideology was so successful that it continues till this day. Every country puts nationalism on it’s forefront to glue its nation together and to bring them under a common cause. With the recent deterrence from war, and global free trade, Globalization started gaining more popularity than nationalism. Although at the same time, populist politicians are trying to bring people’s nationalist sentiments by scouring out globalism’s flaws to secure their vote bank, but that’s another topic for another day.</p><p>So it should be celebrated right?</p><p>Umm… Yes and No.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Yes because it helps the ideology to proliferate. There are no alternatives for an ideology to manifest without an abundance of template hosts who will voluntarily reproduce them. Although there is one alternative which is forcing the ideology onto others, but that’s unsustainable. Nothing is more efficient than an ocean of template hosts spreading an idea like a plague.</p><p>The problem on the other hand is to fall victim to the unwanted consequences of such ideologies that hide in plain sight and comes as a package with the rest. While most template ideologies are just petty swanks from the individual’s perspective, the trouble arises when it turns political, i.e. influencing policy making and implementations. For example, template nationalism may work to glue a nation together and drive them to strive amidst turbulent times. It on the other hand, can also can give rise to xenophobia, racism, migration crisis etc.</p><h4>Template Atheism</h4><p>Template atheism, similarly, have been observed to harbor racist, xenophobic, ethnocentric undertones within its tenets. Though many might argue atheism do not have anything to do with any particular tenets which is true, but you don’t need biblical books to create template tenets for atheism. By template tenets, we mean new atheist clichés promulgated throughout pop culture.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIn5yTyLS_mg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIn5yTyLS_mg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIn5yTyLS_mg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/42b315525e58cb563659a07c176bb727/href">https://medium.com/media/42b315525e58cb563659a07c176bb727/href</a></iframe><p>In this video Olly reflects on what he learnt from the new atheists and how he grew over those since through growing up and learning more socio-political and academic nuances he started to get wider visions about the things the new atheists talked about. I too once was a template atheist when I first started out, quoting Harris, Dawkins here and there indiscriminately. But I rarely delved into the deep, just scratched the surface to scour for bits of wisdom to satisfy my confirmation bias. It hit me when I was gifted with a Sam Harris Book “The End of Faith” by a close senior of mine from my university, Tahnia apu . I had high hopes of the book since it came from a person that I completely looked forward to during my transitional phase. But reading the book, I started to realize, maybe Harris’s critics were not entirely wrong. The first few pages were riddled with demonization. Though yes, religion isn’t a race, but when billions of people are demonized in such a shallow, thoughtless , stereotypical way, it gives way to fundies from the other ends with an extra edge. It can justify wars, invasions, and total obliteration of relatively peaceful communities. Indian fanatic Hindus for example, use new atheist’s demonizing rhetorics to justify pouncing on Muslim communities and turning their lives into hell. Noam Chomsky says when the nuances are irresponsibly ignored and emotions are rallied, it shrouds out the bigger picture and takes people nowhere except towards more fights and chaos.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fm_i3479FgKc%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dm_i3479FgKc&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fm_i3479FgKc%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/64422422b6c7bca6685f8d6ded523995/href">https://medium.com/media/64422422b6c7bca6685f8d6ded523995/href</a></iframe><p>Seeing this one may feel the need to repudiate the new atheism movement completely. But as easy as it is to criticize the movement for it’s flaws, its not so easy as to completely disregard it. Chomsky or Zizek or Olly might not comprehend the magnitude of the wave it created throughout other parts of the world, since their view too in a way Eurocentric. In Islamic countries the new atheists had a huge impact in deradicalization of the youth. I can attest to it, since I was an output of that project along with most of my atheist friends and acquaintances. Our religious blindfolds got completely decimated by the new atheism wave. But just like Olly I too started to grow up from my shallow, template form and started to explore the nuances even more. I tried to look for more detailed deconstructions of such complex issues keeping raging reactionary sentiments aside. Under Olly’s YouTube video Idriz Saferi echoes just the sentiments as me but in a more articulate manner.</p><blockquote>Hi Olly, I decided to comment on your video regarding some of the things you mentioned, as I happen to disagree, quite strongly with your position. I am a PhD student in Biophysical Chemistry and I really shouldn’t be wasting my time, but this is a topic that I find very interesting and that is personal to me. I used to be an islamic fundamentalist from a third-world muslim-majority country and, at least for me, Dawkins’ approach worked. He made me feel very stupid, not because he said insulting things, but because those insults were supported by clear arguments and evidence. I truly hated him as a religious person, so far as to pray for his death, but I could not refute his arguments. It is because of him that I decided to read on the theory of evolution and it is because of him that I am now an atheist. I will be forever thankful to him for his insults. Now, that was a personal account and you’d probably be right to say that his approach worked for me because I happen to be a scientifically minded person and that it fails to work for the vast majority of people. That’s probably right, but you are not considering the indirect influence he is having/has had: mobilizing people who already happen to not believe in god, or are just empathetic to the idea of it. It is not a coincidence that so many of todays atheists regard him as a primary influence. While his aggressive approach is unlikely to convert religious people, it is stimulating other atheist to fight against religious bullshit. Regarding Dawkins’ arguments against god’s existence. You criticized his book The God Delusion and mentioned that you have grown out of it. Well, of course you have. You are a philosopher and he is not. Of course by now you should have a deeper understanding of philosophical issues than Dawkins. Why would you expect to still learn from that book, and why would you think that the book was written with you as a target audience? It’s a scientist attempt at explaining the arguments against god’s existence. I am pretty sure that for all of his arguments in the God Delusion, you have multiple counter-arguments from theologians, and then you have counter-counter-arguments from non-believers and philosophers and so it goes. The God Delusion is not a book to be read by philosophers so they can learn “fresh &amp; new” arguments against god. Nothing Dawkins says in it is novel. The book is meant to reach people who have no idea of any argument for or against god, it is meant to be read by people like I used to be: people who believe in a crazy god without knowing any arguments against it. And in light of recent developments in the world, I think that we need books like that more than ever. You also cite Eagletons book as superior, and I certainly would hope so. What would that say about Eagleton, if that wasn’t the case? That would be just like him writing a book on evolution and it being better than anything Dawkins has written on the subject. But how many people did Eagleton’s book reach? And what level of understanding of philosophy did you have to had to understand it completely? I hope you get my point: to write a book on god from an academic point of view, you would have to restrict yourself to only one particular argument and then explain how that argument was understood by just one or a few philosophers. Clearly that wasn’t Dawkins goal. He didn’t want to add fuel to a fire (i.e. debate) that has been going on between philosophers for thousands of years. Then you went on to talk about their politics and their positions on various social issues. This was very disappointing to hear. Why should any of this matter? Dawkins, as far as I know, has not written books promoting sexism or racism or whatever (e.g. Dawkins said this or that about being an MP, etc), and even if he had, that still wouldn’t invalidate his position on religion. This part of your talk made me think that for you to respect someone’s position on an issue and defend it, you have to agree with them on everything. I can’t help noticing the similarity in this line of thinking with the Atheism+ people. But anyway, I am just mentioning that this is how you gave the impression of thinking, I am not saying that you do. As an example, Hitchens was of course an asshole and everyone knows that, even atheists, and his position on Iraq was of course wrong, but why should I not defend him in places where he was right? Because he left his trotskyan phase? I have actually a friend who opposes Hitchens on everything because of his political shift. You also mentioned Sam Harris as a worst case. Again, I strongly disagree. I have never seen someone who understands islamic fundamentalism the way he does. When I read his work, I get the feeling that he knows me and is just describing the way I used to be. I follow his work very closely and I can see the injustice he is getting by leftist ideologues, and getting his work misinterpreted and being labeled with whatever you can think of, to silence him. But anyway, I will conclude my comment by mentioning two more things. (1) I I am happy to hear that you will give away their books; this way they can get to the audience they were written for. They do not belong on the bookshelf of a professional philosopher, same as Dawkins books on evolution do not belong in the bookshelf of an evolutionary biologist. And (2), I am writing this extremely tired at <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=In5yTyLS_mg&amp;t=330s">5:30</a> am. I am not even proof reading what I wrote but I know that my text is not coherent and I am sure it is quite accusatory and rude, but please believe me that that is not my intention. I hope you’ll take it as what I meant it to be: a critique of your position. I unfortunately lack the time, effort and even sophistication in articulating my thoughts clearly in the English language to edit the text so that is does not sound rude. Finally, since this is my first comment, I would like to tell you that I enjoy your videos immensely and I hope you continue posting more. They always make me think. I also hope you will do videos on the philosophy of science sometime in the future. Cheers, bIs</blockquote><p>This would resonate with most of the people in Asian, African and other conservative countries where conservatism/fanaticism is state sanctioned and little to no counterbalance are allowed to exist. For example in Bangladesh all kinds of contents that might hurt religious sentiments are banned under the ICT Act. Hence fundamentalist books can become best sellers while critics of them get jailtime. In such scenario academic books would never fare off well, wont ever reach people’s ears. To reach out to the wider mass and seed in the deradicalizing triggers rooted deep into their brainwashed minds, dawkins, hitchens, harris have better opportunity than for example, Eagelton or John Gray or other academics. Template ideologues, though shallow, have higher chances of spreading out and sowing their ideas into the mainstream. But so as not to fall into the rabbit hole of harmful far right stereotypical ideologies, one needs to start to develop to the critical phase, and grow out of the naïve template phases.</p><h4>Template Science</h4><p>Template Science is another problem. By template science, I mean pop science clichés. Pop Science are great way to transmit scientific ideas across the lay population. Pop Science writers, infographic creators, youtubers, bloggers all are excellent communicators, no doubt. But to transmit bits of scientific wisdom to the non professional lay people requires science to be broken down into digestible pieces. Throughout this process a lot of nuances get shrouded away. Pop Science is emotional, entertaining, awe generating. So it has to be coated with emotional appeal to cater to a large number of people. The simplification process of the complex scientific ideas hence slowly go on to be oversimplified. Oversimplification of scientific data leads to distortions, or outright misinformation. To do actual “Science” is to lack emotional approach in the scientific procedure, be highly data driven, fact based, experimental and bring out reproducible results. Pop Science just needs a fancy headline, measure the emotional appeal of the topic, summarize the whole topic through that emotional lens and produce an infotainment. Also it needs to use overused clichés as it’s opening title, best if written in bold/italicized manner, like “ Scientists found out that”, “Researches conclude”, “A team of scientist found out that”, “Science says” etc. The problem with this is that, people being the gullible species that they are, take the infotainment as authoritative information through the charm these magical phrases. But in many of the cases, the oversimplification gets a lot of the “science” wrong.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F0Rnq1NpHdmw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D0Rnq1NpHdmw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F0Rnq1NpHdmw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/cace2ca3d71521036fe6944fe0829c21/href">https://medium.com/media/cace2ca3d71521036fe6944fe0829c21/href</a></iframe><p>While “A new study shows that your cat might actually wanna kill you”, can seem comical and not to be troubled about, that’s where we would get things wrong too. Things as usual turns troubling when it becomes widespread and start to influence political scenario. For example MMR vaccine and autism. A 1998 research paper by a UK doctor suggesting a possible link of MMR vaccine to autism was picked up by UK’s dailies in a frenzy. Despite expert virologists and microbiological scientists (who are more authorized in this issue than a doctor) debunking the paranoia, and giving widespread support to vaccines, the dailies did not retract the negative media coverage partly to the fact that they wanted to decimate the image of government, who were in support of vaccination programs. Their intent to taint negative image of the government distorted science to public reality. And as a consequence, the vaccine debate traces to this day still, along with other scientific topics that has been politicized. For example, climate change, sex and gender, GMOs, Renewable Energy, Covid-19 pandemic etc. In Bangladesh fake and pop science run without a leash in national dailies and online tabloids. People drown into an ocean of misinformation owing to the fact that Bangladesh doesn’t have quality pop science portals, neither quality journalism. So anyone can get away with reporting anything. The Ganashasthya Kendra testing kits for example, which were proven to be highly prone to produce erroneous results, were promulgated in the eyes of Bangladeshi people as legitimate science by the news agencies’ cheap emotional campaigns, just as in the case of MMR vaccines and the UK newspapers. GMOs are another such example which lost its nuances into the public eye due to pop science and politicization. The list only goes on and on and on…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/0*VdSdgyEUIEukOS6R" /></figure><p>But then again my aim is not to disregard the importance of pop/template science, but rather to highlight the problem that might come along if we are not careful enough. While Joe Rogan retweeting futurism from their blog ,“Scientists say we are made of start stuff”, feel like a cliché that has been so overused to the point that it seems pretentious and comical at this point and shouldn’t be much of a concern too, we equally should be aware of the bigger drawbacks that might come along with putting pop science to such exalted heights. The politicization of renewable energy is another example. Campaigns pushing for renewable energy to replace fossil fuel fail to address the fact that its nearly impossible to replace fossil fuel with the existing renewable technology. Also they hide out other forms through which renewables may pose harms. Like winds posing threats to bird population, solar farms taking mass land footprints, river dams requiring massive land footprint, and hampering native ecosystem as well, or offshore windfarms, tidal farms hampering fish life etc. Yeah i agree that the magnitude of these problems do not remotely equate to the damage by fossil burnings. But then again you have to take into account the fact that renewables do not produce one percentile of the energy that can be produced by non renewables. The only replaceable alternative to fossil fuels are nuclear energy who have high energy yield and fewer environmental concerns. But for renewable company lobbying and politicization of nuclear, a viable option got hindered in most of the country. Greta, the template activist for example opposes nuclear energy despite being a climate activist. This doesn’t make sense remotely. Template demands wont ever be able to meet up with the energy demand, not even within the one percentile, so how is that helping!</p><h4>Template Humanism</h4><p>As for template humanism, things get even worse. Humanism is completely a political issue. Who gets to have complete human rights and who doesn’t has been an unresolvable issue since long. If victims get their desired justice, perpetrators might not get theirs. If govt mercenaries get justice, rebels/terrorists might not get theirs. If you oppose archaic/medieval cultures you might get branded as a colonizer. If they are not opposed, you would get branded cultural relativist/postmodernist. Take for example, the Syrian dilemma. Whose right to support and whose to not? what started out as a product of Arab spring, slowly delved into Syria vs ISIS. The westerners and the Sunni world supported the human rights for rebel soldiers. The Shia world, and Russians on the other hand supported the Assad loyalists. Most of the media sensations concerning Assad’s brutality were basically the manipulations of white helmets or the rebel factions who themselves are also responsible for carrying out massive human rights abuses in Syria. ISIS for example, aren’t much known to respect human rights either when conquering targeted territories. Consider this famous case of a Syrian boy who had been the profile picture of all the Muslim and western world for years, especially of those who were against the Assad Regime.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*W0VfeMURPzIVtzZu" /></figure><p>It went viral throughout all social media as a symbol of the massive human right abuse of the Assad Regime. All the template humanists took this picture for granted and set it up as their temporary/permanent profile picture.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FPJOzBRy7dWs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DPJOzBRy7dWs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FPJOzBRy7dWs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0b1eee38a7802903de1e22ce0804ede4/href">https://medium.com/media/0b1eee38a7802903de1e22ce0804ede4/href</a></iframe><p>But little did they know this was meticulously fabricated by Syrian White helmets and the kid’s dad is actually an Assad loyalist. When interviewed later on, the dad says he is grateful to Assad for setting up his locality free from the occupation of rebel factions. Apparently the father left his previous home in another Syrian state which got occupied by rebel factions, to western Aleppo to settle down under Assad’s control. When the tensions escalated between govt. force and insurgents as insurgents took over Al-Qaterji neighborhood in Aleppo , a Russian air strike on the rebel held land got Omar and his family injured. All were looking for shelter and soon afterwards rescue teams appeared to take them to the hospitals. He got severely pissed off at insurgents for exploiting his child’s image amidst this turbulent times for their political aims. In fact, the photojournalist who took the photo of the child in the ambulance, was Mahmoud Raslan, a loyalist of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harakat_Nour_al-Din_al-Zenki"><strong>Harakat Nour al-Din al-Zinki group</strong></a><strong> </strong>, an active insurgent opposition group of Syria. The group who rallied the propaganda of Omar Danqeesh as a symbol human rights abuse beheaded a 12 year old child for allegedly being a soldier for Assad’s regime.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJBrXEtnNNms%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJBrXEtnNNms&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJBrXEtnNNms%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/48519a9526a032f3c8a09cea8a73024c/href">https://medium.com/media/48519a9526a032f3c8a09cea8a73024c/href</a></iframe><p>I am not asserting the fact that Assad is a saint. Of course, there is no smoke without fire. But his oppositions aren’t saints either. So when people support one group thinking they are championing or advocating for human rights, I feel pity at their delusion. Wars are not pretty. Collateral damages happen on both sides, and neutral civilians always needs to pay the price. To learn if life under opposition factions like ISIS is any better, check the VICE documentary below which takes the viewers into the heart of ISIS controlled territories, documented by ISIS themselves.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAUjHb4C7b94%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAUjHb4C7b94&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAUjHb4C7b94%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/2d244d9498e8c83652d022ef9ece3ea7/href">https://medium.com/media/2d244d9498e8c83652d022ef9ece3ea7/href</a></iframe><p>Now between two opposing groups with such extreme war measures and manipulative political strategies, who should template humanists support to show their humanism and moral high grounds? Not that much of them give a nuanced thought about this, of course, it wouldn’t be template humanism otherwise. So the thing they do is rally on with the herd mentality. The mob is always right!</p><p>In our country recently, template humanism advocated to drive poor people into the homes, most of the people in support for strict unlimited lockdowns were privileged upper class or upper middle class youths who had never had to taste poverty in their entire life and most probably never have to in the future. What they failed to realize is that if such a thing was to happen, millions would have to starved to death or fall down in the lowest pit of poverty. In such case the challenge for governments are to take balanced approaches so as to not drive poor people to verge of extreme poverty and also parallelly ensuring public safety to the extent that’s possible. This was a WHO official David Nabarro’s statement two days back. But such a thought is nuanced and doesn’t fall under a sensational template. A middle ground is never a utopian chase. So how can it be adopted by the wishy washy masses?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/702/1*Ip8vMBo2sOcIM1a89KY-5Q.png" /></figure><p>Usually countries with Eurocentric viewpoints doesn’t much concentrate to understand third world dynamics. Poverty is a driving factor in these countries, so the equation in Bangladesh or India, or Nepal or Pakistan wouldn’t necessarily be the same as that in US, Germany, Canada etc. first world countries. Most template humanists are exposed to Eurocentric narratives which make them blind towards the complexities of third world societies.</p><p>To keep on talking about such template ideologies would be to proceeding towards writing a book. I think these above examples are quite enough to provide the gist that I am trying to convey. So let’s end the topic focusing one particular template ideology that inspired me to the write up the whole thing.</p><h4>Template feminism</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ICv1G_O6RFY8YA8q.jpg" /></figure><p>Feminism has many different definitions depending on who you ask. But in general, it refers to women fighting to achieve equal status as men in their society. Its a fight for achieving equal socio-economic freedom, equal opportunities and equal civil rights as their male counterparts in their respective societies. Throughout mankind’s defining history most of the time the society was patriarchal. Although there were matriarchal liberal societies, the mentions of which we can find in Fredrich Engel’s book, patriarchy shaped human societies more than matriarchy ever did. With the concept of property inheritance, the transfer and concentration of social power gradually shifted to males, and it’s that point of history where Engels says the history of female oppression started to begin.</p><p>To amend the damage done, slowly lighting up from the 18th century, to gaining pace at 19th century, to escalating even further in the twentieth century, the history of women’s emancipation begun. They started to fight for equality, a thing that they have been stripped off for thousands of years. While massive development followed in establishing equal rights for women, the fight is to anywhere but an end. There are things yet left to be fixed, from first wave feminism to second wave, to third wave, now we’ve reached the fourth wave and yet still many things remain left to be discussed and to be fixed. But the fruits of all these waves are mostly enjoyed by first world women. Feminism hasn’t so remarkably hit the third world countries as it did to the first world. The struggles of women in such poor countries are still a substance of fascination to many western white women born and bred under privilege that their predecessors have earned for them. While they buy empowering “ Girl Power, Proud Slut” tee shirt, some third world worker woman under the poorest pay and poorest working condition possible for as much as 73$ wage per month.</p><p>In conservative underdeveloped countries, while women empowerment are subtly injected by governments to improve their image into the world and ameliorate their human rights index, the population are equally resistant to such development measures. Most people still hold the conservative viewpoint that women are property and should be subject to a man’s will. To fight these prejudices the battles remain to be a never ending struggle. State does little to educate people on this issue out of the fear of a conservative retaliation. Hence the young generations either adopt the status quo conservative viewpoints or on the contrary espouse feminist ideas springing from the west, since they are mostly exposed to western media outlets. Therefore struggle for emancipation hence comes from within the youths through west-centric forms. Whereas the govt. has to tread very carefully to keep the conservative sentiments in check and thereby missing out on many vital aspects of feminism, the gullible, progressive youth on the other hand espouses feminism as rendered by western pop media outlets. The problem with taking in the full package of either end is to bring in additional troubles which come in as a camouflage with the rest.</p><p>Now it’s not to exalt local conservative cultures over feminist narratives of the west. I am not trying to put up a cultural relativist/postmodernist argument here since I believe morality shouldn’t be subject to geographical locations only. What I am trying to do, on the other hand, is explore the nuances of the ideology that we are importing through a careful revision of the whole thing.</p><p>Pop feminism can be seen through many forms. Feminism was intended to liberate women from all the shackles of life, but now as the progress marched forward corporations appropriated the movement to their own benefit. Corporations are mindless entities with a sole target to increase profit. Hence, it should not be a big of a wonder when we see big corporations championing feminist narratives and woman emancipations all over the world. The reason being that, it increases company image to the public eye. And also if such cultural shockwave can be passed on and established it will grant companies with tons of skilled and obedient workers. If companies did care so much, then there should not have been the constant debate of gender wage gap across the world. Companies aren’t just much interested in uplifting women from oppression than they are at marketing their pro feminist image for their own cause. Because of course, removing gender wage gap barrier wont serve them as much as a positive marketing and a supply of cheap female labor would do. So it should come of no surprise as to what these companies actually try to advocate for.</p><p>The disparity between Men and Women lies in society in terms of the freedom that they can exercise. Historically girls were stripped out of that freedom, and males enjoyed the sole right to exercise them. Therefore when girls started emancipating themselves holding the men as benchmarks. Its like, “Men do this thing, why cant we? GIRLPOWER!”. It was a battle for reducing the gap between two sexes, where males held higher socio-economic positions and freedom but females didn’t. Once Simone De Beauvoir was told by Sartre that she used to amaze him by her intellectual charm. He deemed her intellect to be as equal to as that of a male’s. The sentiment behind this echoes vivid patriarchy. There is a standard, which is inherently male, and that women can only try to reach it. Whereas trying to bridge the gap serve as an initial purpose which is to mobilize the fight for equality, the activism should try to ascend further up to see a wider picture of the whole hustle. Most pop feminist brandings do not come from books or essays or hourlong nuanced discussions, but rather from chunks of entertainment pieces and from MNC advertisements. MNCs are mindless and do not of course support feminism because it’s the right thing to do, but would support anything that might add to their stock value. Hence they provide the consumers with a shallow version of feminism. These superficial templates gets memed like crazy by template activists since they have wishful appeals, digestable charms and in the meanwhile putting little to no stress at the brain. Such shallow version of feminism, while worthwhile to spread the idea to the larger mass, ends up distorting the original idea of feminism, which was initially to set the women free.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.slideshare.net%2Fslideshow%2Fembed_code%2Fkey%2FG7plPL6EhK6TVs&amp;display_name=SlideShare&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.slideshare.net%2FKMartell1%2Fthe-hypocrisy-of-femvertising&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fcdn.slidesharecdn.com%2Fss_thumbnails%2Ffemvertising-slideshare-171204064435-thumbnail-4.jpg%3Fcb%3D1569603386&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=slideshare" width="600" height="500" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/458425dffe272f768f5db8a55472dbc2/href">https://medium.com/media/458425dffe272f768f5db8a55472dbc2/href</a></iframe><p>Lmao! Hilarious, isn’t it.</p><p>Corporations have long trapped men into corporate wagecuckery. But that was not under the pretense of men’s right movement or meninism or sth like that. It was under the pretense of “success”. To be successful is to be a CEO, or an Alibaba entrepreneur or a NASA astronaut etc. Its easy to delude men with the story of success, which they are most insecure about. For women the corporations just add in some more extra woke points with the already existing ones. And that is feminism. Integrating woke points to sell shoes, bags, softwares etc. are just modern trends of marketing. With the changing social viewpoints companies adjust themselves to make sure they earn the maximum social and economic capital. For example, Bethesda, the gaming company. In some parts of the world they are pro LGBT, in some parts they are not so much.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*Q9_WaD8vxvTjB0bA.jpg" /></figure><p>So when corporations tell women that feminism means becoming Google CEO, or NASA astronaut, or President of New Zealand, they blur out the bigger picture. Yes of course, a girl should be free to chase the Google CEO dream, the same way she should be free to just live her life anyway she wants. If a girl thinks of spending her life rescuing injured animals, and spending her life with them would fill her life’s purpose, would she be considered a “good feminist”? If a girl feels like taking entrepreneurial risks with friends and not choosing stability over entrepreneurial dreams and be broke most of the time, would she be considered a “good feminist”? Of course, if she wins her dream she might be featured in vogue of forbes as a woman’s right champion but what if she fails? Is a girl choosing to pursue a postdoctorate more feminist than a girl who is just an accountant or runs a day care? But populist notion is that the more successful a girl becomes, that is the more she bridges the gap with a male, the more feminist she is. Such notion doesn’t take into account the question of freedom. Like how free a person actually is, comparing to the males. A male might choose to earn a PhD, or take financial risks for entrepreneurial dreams, or just get a regular job and play video games all day long, or engage into politics, or be a broke conservationist, or be a drug dealer (jk, no need to freak out) without having to face any gender based prejudices. In their decision makings, the males are mostly free from gender issues. For females on the other hand they have to win things like man, be wagecucks like a man, be successful corporate slaves like a man. Hence even though feminism have been around for long, the changemakers among women are relatively few. As Adam Atler put into his book, to be original is to think out of the box. Prodigies do not think out of the box, hence they do not become changemakers. Prodigies are not risktakers. They are not in truer sense free. Whereas, on the other hand, broke college kids, college dropouts go on creating Starbucks, oracle etc. JK Rowling herself was a single mother on welfare before becoming hit with Harry Potter. Was the broke Rowling more feminist than the successful Rowling? Has feminism index increased for her?</p><p>But sadly most women are fed with wishful glittery versions of feminism as promulgated by the celebrity media, by the multinational corporations and by pop magazines. This might bridge some gap but from a wider perspect, the shackles are still there. The men don’t have a benchmark to pursue, the women still are holding to that, i.e. keeping men as benchmarks and trying to level up with them. If you go to LinkedIn or other such social media, there are tons of examples of pop feminism running amok for you to see.</p><p>Template feminism doesn’t just delude women into corporate wagecuckery. But just like other template activism, it too gets entangled with politics sooner or later. And when matters start to get politicized, all hell’s break loose.</p><p>To give an example on how template feminism hurts women’s cause lets look no further than the recent debates around rape in our country.</p><h4>Rape, Sexual Violence and Legal troubles</h4><p>Rape has been growing up a pressing issue in our country. With the number of rape incidents rising drastically, the concerns are getting much more pronounced. The rape incident counts in 2018 were 732 while in 2019 the incident count was 1413 according to Ain O Salish Kendra. Its hard to tell if rape statistics actually increased or if rape reportings increased, because of the sheer nature of the crime. The human rights agencies presume that the numbers should be much much higher, but the culture of reporting in a conservative country like Bangladesh is yet to take root. So if rape on average is increasing or if more are coming out is yet to be known. Rising numbers of rape pose a dilemma. It can be either deciphered as a good sign considering stigma and fear regarding rape reporting is slowly being removed or it can be considered a bad sign considering the alarming number of rapes that still exists in society. But if you watch the news, observe the populist sentiments, pop personalities and pop-activism, you will immediately get the notion that Bangladesh is slowly turning into a rape haven. But this is just emotional rallying. If the numbers of rape reports were too low, like that of Mozambique with 0.2 , Or Egypt with 0.1, or Yemen with or 0.8, per 100,000 people, would that have been better? To put things into context, Mozambique has a serious rape crisis, where rape against school children are pretty common and open. In Yemen, Houthi rebels and militiamen use rape as a tool of war. In Egypt rape witnesses go to be arrested by law agencies for violating “morality” let alone the victim hoping for any justice. Hence Rape statistics actually give out equivocal, inconclusive message. It might mean that either police are not taking cases of rape victims or that women themselves aren’t reporting cases to the authority out of intimidation, frustration or harassments. The reality of the issue is just too hard to figure out.</p><p>Pop feminism is fueled by emotions. It’s not tough to understand why they would freak out at such statistics and view this as an imminent rapist takeover of the whole nation. But this sentiment slowly starts to get politicized and the template feminist inadvertently get used as political pawns. To spread panic and frenzy among the people is an extremely effective and political tool to mobilize the overthrow of a government. Therefore such moments are meticulously utilized by oppositions to further their own cause. On the other hand, as a retaliation, government underplays the problem and tries to cover it up by throwing in obnoxious comments or going on the path of denial regarding the crisis. Thus a legitimate issue becomes a political feud between two parties, and in the meanwhile, the central essence of the issue gets washed away.</p><p>Rape evokes such mass outrage for some reasons. One reason being that rape victims live on with the trauma for life and live to tell the tale. The another reason is patriarchy. In patriarchal societies, like that in Bangladesh, women are considered to be the property of the men. A woman belongs to her father, or her brother or her husband. She is not just an individual person. When a girl is raped the outrages come worded like this, especially if coming from men — “She could be someone’s daughter, or sister or husband. How could these beasts do such a gruesome thing”. See how subconsciously the ownership over the female is pronounced and the patriarchal mind expresses itself out?</p><p>Such sentiment is of course not endemic to Bangladesh. In every patriarchal country, women are considered to be nothing more than properties. And rape in itself is considered to be an attack on the husband, or the father or the brother of the victim. Many countries, including Bangladesh consider stranger rape to be rape only. Bangladesh do not have any law regarding marital rape. Neither does Egypt, Sri Lanka, China, Afghanistan or other patriarchal countries. In fact such laws forming out of patriarchal notions of rape fails to address rapes of males too. Rapes of young boys are also an epidemic in most countries. In the confinement of mosques, churches thousands of such cases occur without getting noticed or brought under the law. There was a book called “Bishfora” which investigated into the child rape in madrasas. But the book was immediately banned by high court after an appeal for hurting religious sentiments.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*u5rJI31QkgcFTSZA.jpg" /></figure><p>The patriarchal outrage is not a sensible outrage either. It too, like template feminism, is driven by mindless emotion. But the rage is even stronger here, because of course males tend to be more aggressive and would seek out aggressive vengeance as a retaliation to their property damage. Therefore most emotionally driven patriarchs shout out the demands for public crossfires, or shariah laws like beheading, stoning or chopping off the genitals etc. Girls too, start to mimic them and echo such extreme reactions to empathize more with the cause and not be misunderstood to be girly, easygoing and impractical.</p><p>In February 2019, a case emerged where a vigilante under the pseudonym “Hercules” went on a rampage against rapists, murdering them and leaving a signature note of his on the murder spot along with the deceased. It was largely applauded by template activists because finally rapists were getting their due punishment, which govt. had failed to provide them. But soon it turned out that it was just Govt’s law enforcing agencies carrying out political attacks on targeted political people. The rapists were found to be not guilty of rape afterwards by medical examination. The govt. agencies successfully utilized pop sentiments to their own advantage.</p><p><a href="https://en.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/Search-for-%E2%80%98Hercules%E2%80%99-leads-to-govt-vehicle">Search for &#39;Hercules&#39; leads to govt vehicle</a></p><p>Such is the drawback of pop activism. It leads to unintended consequences which manifest through the gullibility of pop activists and their shallow vision.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*yYnALByRdz-5CWPy.jpg" /></figure><p>With the rape cases rising drastically, and template activism exploding in similar proportion through social media, people started to mass campaign against rape. Many girls started to change their profile picture black. This drew criticism from edgy internet critics that black profile pictures do not contribute to the cause at all and that the girls were just dumb, emotionally driven and impractical. Funny thing is our “practical” edgelords are pro death penalty or pro-stoning too, which are even less practical, and to be precise, detrimental. While it’s true that a black profile picture will not be able to change anything, a non black picture wont be able to change anything either. But the thing which a black profile picture can do is spreading a “meme”, or a shockwave. It’s like twitter hashtags, which are just a word with a tag, but in a broader sense, it’s a collective mode of expression to send out a message. If Black profile picture is useless so is putting profile picture frames, like “go nuclear”, “save climate”, “BLM”, “stand against corruption” or putting up a temporary black ribbon as profile picture when some prominent individual dies, or putting up LGBT filters in pride month. All these are intended to create public awareness, and express mass solidarity, not to magically solve the issues.</p><p>Now the reactions weren’t just confined within the realms of Facebook only. The revolts started to escalate so high that people started to hit on the streets, block roads in demands for exemplary punishments for the perpetrators. The problem with this of course is that the base was too weak. Maximum protestors did not know what they were fighting for. The protest is branded “protest against rape”. Are they protesting against individual rapists? Like they care about guys marching with placards asking them to stop. You can protest against fee increase, tax increase, bill increase to an authority who might listen to your appeal. But would rapists submit to your appeal? “Protest against rape” would imply catering to an authority who is consciously raping women on day to day basis, and that the protestors want it to be stopped. Many activists might say its a protest against government govt and that protest against rape would imply government is indirectly assisting rapists to get free. In that sense, it kinda makes sense. Hence, what’s followed is a conspicuous display of contempt towards the government for going easy on the rapists and harboring a culture of impunity. So from rapists the focus shifted towards the criticism of government. Fair enough, the movement now is going somewhere, it might actually have a shot at pushing the government to revisit its stance on rape. But the problem is what they are accusing the government of, and what they are putting on their demand list. Most of these demands were unrealistic. For example, government should introduce capital punishment to deter rape incidents.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/976/0*DxB0hLG-dpWYy7lt.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/0*5aF8iZH4Ge0ILVfm.gif" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*kdiJigNi__aq_-g0.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*-lceU2z5eyxQiNar" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uiV6wx9O8Eq29Dk5.jpg" /></figure><p>This is of course the milder offline version with the hardline capital punishments like crossfire, public lynching, castration, beheading being among the popular ones thriving in online spheres. With the increasing pressure from template activism, the government bowed down to populist demands and revisited the law. Just yesterday, on Monday 12th, Bangladeshi Cabinet passed the law of death penalty in accordance with the popular public demand.</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/12/world/asia/bangladesh-death-penalty-rape.html">Bangladesh to Allow Death Penalty for Rape Convictions</a></p><p>This marks as a major win for the activists. But for the rape victims? Not so much. Death penalties, no matter how brutal in form (beheadings, hangings, stonings) never helped to curb out sexual violence. It always backflips and worsens out the situation. Rape is the most underreported crime in the world. Mostly due to the fact that, rapes rarely occur through the hands of a stranger. Around 80% of the rapes are committed by perpetrators that the rapists personally know. They can be family members, acquaintances, friends, boyfriends etc. If the punishment for rape equates to death penalty victims often feel reluctant to report the crime since it would end up with a death penalty for the perpetrators the victims know. The family of the victim also blocks reporting to save their relative from the death grip. It doesn’t end in just that, in courts, death sentences are considered to be very sensitive issues, hence judges have to very cautiously tread to prove someone worthy of a death sentence, and that an innocent might have not been framed. If one is condemned to death sentence it moves from lower court to supreme court to high court, with additional optional of reappeal creating unnecessary delays and eventually getting them pardoned. The pardoning also happens due to an absence of victims from the court. The lengthy court process makes the victims reluctant to pursue the case further. They sometimes falls prey to intimidation or persuasion for out of court settlement, eventually pushing them to drop the case. Police also don’t want to take such cases, considering the extreme toll of such cases and instead urge them to opt for out of court settlements. This happens especially in gang rape incidents where multiple people risk the fate of a death sentence. Bangladesh, in fact, had death sentence for rape, as legislated in 1995 and enacted under the BNP government. But then after the Shukur Ali case, where a minor was condemned to death penalty, BLAST along with other organizations challenged the legality of the death penalty. The case was disputed and death penalty was finally rescinded after five years of being enacted.</p><p><a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/opinion/perspective/news/why-crossfire-will-not-solve-our-rape-problem-1855024">Why crossfire will not solve our rape problem</a></p><p>Another issue with the death penalty is that, it doesn’t leave the perpetrator with an incentive to leave his victim alive after rape. When a rapist would view rape and rape after murder equivalently, since both would end up handing him the death sentence, there will be little convenience left to him to leave his victim alive. Instead he would just kill, try to conceal the body and abscond himself. In case of milder sexual assaults, the victims risk being murdered too. Therefore while its definitely a victory for template feminist activists, it certainly might not mean the same for rape victims.</p><p>What solution should be provided then? What is justice? That is something which is upto the court to dispute and settle, through rigorous case studies, thorough analysis and evidence driven debates . That they have been influenced to give in to populist demands is alarming. It shows the government’s unwillingness to care about victim justice rather than trying to comply with populist demands. Complying with such sentiments will lessen down the conviction rate even further, if we are to pay heed to legal experts and their analyses.</p><p><a href="https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/law-rights/2017/07/09/less-1-ever-gets-punished-rape">Less than 1% ever gets punished for rape</a></p><p>The reason rape gets so little conviction is because the absence of witnesses in court, lack of evidence, out of court settlements and intimidation from the perpetrator’s family and aides which only gets worse through the court’s procedural delays. The justice system is so archaic that its not only rape but all kinds of crimes face such fate be it homicide, large scale corruption, drug smuggling, human trafficking etc. Adding to the fact that Bangladeshi legal system still runs on archaic models with archaic system losses through its each step, the condition even further worsens due to a shortage of judges and tribunal courts. Millions of cases are yet to be examined with only a handful of judges at disposal. Settling them fast therefore proves to be a mammoth’s task. Unless the broken justice system is fixed and modernized, the lag will keep on being continued. And of course justice delayed is justice not served. Although there is a special tribunal, <em>Nari o Shishu Nirjaton daman tribunal</em> which specifically deals with these cases. But then again in this intricate ecosystem, an abundant of factors lie intertwined. A fast track court might increase the risk of falsely convicting someone, or quickly acquitting someone for the lack of evidence. Whereas, false accusations to settle legal disputes, perpetuation of equivocal colonial law which clearly do not define rape, intimidation by perpetrator’s family, social stigmatization, out of court settlement in the form of family salish, dysfunctional conservative patriarchal police force, lack of adequate number of judges to handle such huge number of cases aid to the backlogs of such cases.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/745/1*WKD28iSMcl2cM5sC4arhfg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/754/1*zHGsi3fWkVcEEPuwL-lQQA.png" /></figure><p>The above screenshots were taken from BLAST’s conference report on Rape Law Reform in Bangladesh. The conference report highlights all the major issues regarding the legal hurdles of such cases.</p><iframe src="https://drive.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=https%3A//www.blast.org.bd/content/publications/BLAST-RLR-Conference-Report.pdf&amp;embedded=true" width="600" height="780" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f8f1fca20675415ad94ec2da487a66f8/href">https://medium.com/media/f8f1fca20675415ad94ec2da487a66f8/href</a></iframe><p>The protesters, ignited by the wrath of rape incidents, while could design their movements well so to keep it apolitical and push the government to focus on tangible issues, instead sidetracked, pushed for radical impractical demands, and turned themselves into political pawns for the opposing parties without them even noticing. Most are unaware of the Bangladeshi legal structures and where the reforms might actually be needed. The biggest hurdle to justice is societal rather than technical. Conservatism, Patriarchy, Stigmatizing sexuality, political power exercise, Out of court settlement practices etc. These issues need social reform which need public awareness. Protesters instead were more busy with being pissed off at the government than addressing primary societal factors which mostly contributes to the problem.</p><p>Its not to say that the protestors did nothing to address to the social factors. They did, but that too in a shallow thoughtless way. Slowly the problem started to delve into a cultural war. On one side there were hyperliberal western narratives, on the other side there were patriarchal religious mindsets. Both fighting each other to decide on what causes rape, what should be the punishment. Both agree that rape is bad, but their analysis differs. Lets deconstruct both party’s analysis one by one.</p><p>The patriarch religious say its because of lack of decency, free intermingling of both sexes, pornography, and western media exposure that rape culture is getting sowed into society. Some of them go on blaming clothing choices of women partially for rape. One of the influential Bangladeshi Superstar, Ananta Jalil for example, sent out a video messages blaming victims for their clothing practices which he claims contributed to increasing rape incidents. Some of my classmates in fact fall in line with Mr. Jalil, despite having studied at one of the topmost engineering institution of Bangladesh. And their claims could not be any further away from reality. There are no data to support their claims. But not they care much except for trying to bring society back to conservatism.</p><p>There are no conclusive scientific studies which show non aggressive pornography correlated with escalated sexual violence. Instead there are studies which show there zero or in fact negative correlation between soft core, non aggressive pornography.</p><p><a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01639625.1994.9967974">Pornography and sexual aggression: Associations of violent and nonviolent depictions with rape and rape proclivity</a></p><p>Rape is a product of aggression. It’s an exertion of power by the strong to the weak. If we are to accept the fact that nonviolent sensual pornographies incite rapes then Gaming should cause terrorism too. Or watching money heist or Ocean’s 13 should cause bank robberies. Or watching Breaking Bad should cause people to open up meth labs in their houses. Of course I am not arguing for violent pornographic materials since they have been proven to have positive correlation towards sexual aggression. One reason gamers do not turn terrorists is because they do not have the platform to practice their aggression or robbers because of not having proper gears and courage. But porn consumers have the option to engage with a female where they have the option to exercise their aggression, so violent porn should be kept out of the question. Softcore erotica pornographies wont necessarily send out message of aggression to the consumer that they would try to mimic, which evidently would make sexual aggression increase. In fact UK banned violent pornographies of any sort based on such assumptions.</p><p>When people say indecent clothings incite rape, they too are quite off base with such extreme remark. Although this sentiment is mostly promulgated by religious conservatives but for the rest it’s toxic masculinity that contributes to such mentality. It’s true that the appearance of a female might be stimulating to a male. But then again, stimulants vary from man to man. Some can get turned on by a mere glimpse at a woman, let she be she covered up in the blackest of burqas or not. People fantasize and fetishizes girls in burqas too, that’s nothing new. Even Burqas can’t save women from men fantasizing them. Hell, they even go as far as writing songs on women dressed in burqas, “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0V2PwCj2sI"><em>Burqa pora meye pagol koreche</em></a>” for example. Whereas, on the other hand, many males may not even get turned on even though while visiting nude beaches. You can search for nude beaches online and check how many guys are turned on in those places, which should be apparent by their state of erection. you will find very few. But getting turned on doesn’t mean getting aggressive. Aggression stems from power and entitlement. Rape is a product of aggression. So getting turned on isn’t a good explanation towards rape either. Although these may give biological overviews of the instincts, it doesn’t justify such actions. As Randy Thornhill says, to consider sth natural, and therefore justified is to commit a naturalistic fallacy. We are not saying that pouncing upon someone because biology told him so is okay. It is definitely not okay. Aggression is natural, but that doesn’t legitimize homicide. Jealousy is natural, but that doesn’t legitimize burning someone’s house down. Greed is natural, but that doesn’t validate corruption, Kleptomania might be natural for someone, but petty theft cannot be justified either. Similarly in a free society, one’s problem should not be other’s burden. A girl has the right to exercise all freedom she wants just like men do. If men have a problem with themselves, it should be taken care of by themselves too. Women should not have to pay the cost for men’s troubles. Like similarly, a black man shouldn’t hide himself from the streets because some old white racist guy who instinctively thinks that blacks are criminals. If someone’s instinct turns someone on merely at the sight of a burqa or a bikini, its upto the guy to learn to control himself and behave, not upto the girl to adjust her lifestyle in accordance with the troubled guy’s need.</p><p>The common tactic of the conservative religious or the borderline patriarchs is to promulgate a biological basis for rape. The goal is to commit naturalistic fallacy in order to bend women according to their will. Most template feminists, upon gullibility and good faith, start to fall down the conservative rabbit hole. But that’s just the antithesis of feminism. In the course of advocating for shallow feminism, many end up lining up with the traditional approach in sexual violence which is through surrendering their socio-economic and sexual freedom, because of course that’s how “Nature” intended. On one hand you have basic conservative viewpoints, and on the other hand you have femvertisers narrowing women down into objects or corporate slaves. To be shallow in ideological approaches is to give room to be easily trapped between one of these two extremes.</p><p>One of my friend confessed to me about having hardcore sexual fantasies and justified the fantasies using evolutionary biology. Thornhill and Palmer investigates this issue deeply and theorizes two possibilities. One that rape might be adaptive or might be a byproduct of other adaptations. The adaptation strategy tells us that rape evolved as strategical tools for lesser males to pass on their genes. Those who could reproduce more were rewarded in the evolutionary chain, be that through force or through consent. But the authors do acknowledge the fact that societal conditions evolved to put tolls on such chaotic behavior which might have worked as a counterbalance. Rapes occurred when the benefits outweighed the risks. Hence, in war zones we see an overabundance of rapes and in stable societies we see very few compared to that. The reason is that war zones lack accountability. So the benefits always outweighed the risks. But social and legal constraints in a civil society always worked in reverse. The risks associated with such acts worked as deterrents.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*DY5lNa1yVwocDAa6" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/0*QbjiqXJI3Ad0zqJ_.jpg" /><figcaption>A natural history rape book cover and Randy Thornhill, the author.</figcaption></figure><p>Thornhill and Palmer criticized social theories of rape by feminist authors like Brownmiller, Kate Millett, Germain Greer and others. Their main criticism was that the feminist theorists completely ignored the biological basis for rape, which is unfair to a neutral scientific approach to unveiling the cause of a problem, and mostly are emotionally driven. To put matters into context, The dominant theory of rape comes from Brownmiller and other similar feminist authors who view rape as not as a sexual tool but a political weapon of the patriarchy. Brownmiller’s views have given new perspective to rape’s roots. It says rape is a conscious psychological drive of the perpetrators to assert power and dominance over the weaker sex to keep them under intimidation. She uses wars as her examples, and rapes by political or community leaders or anyone with a concentration of power. Brownmiller rejects the theory that rape is about sex assuming that rapes do not occur in animal species.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*cSmZpPB-VTlhzwuB" /><figcaption>Brownmiller with her revolutionary book</figcaption></figure><p>Both Brownmiller and Thornhill have their fair share of criticisms. To start with Thornhill, many critics say that Thornhill’s argument fall apart for cases where the victims are male, transgenders, underage or old. Also that, evolution might not have given an edge to rapists since parental investment would have been deterred by such acts. Considering physical and mental injury to the victim, and the offspring’s fatherless/callous father state, the reduced parental investments should have reduced the chances of survival. But personally, I think, the criticisms don’t hold much ground. Particularly because I think the monogamous parental state is fairly a new trait among humans. And since human societies stayed in groups, the chances of survival for rape offsprings should not necessarily have required dedicated biological father figures in order to survive. Also that, when raids and conquests of tribes happened, the offsprings would have inevitably fallen under the responsibility of the invading clans. Also such criticism fail to take into account the byproduct of other adaptation theory. Like Aggression. Aggression did not evolve as a sexual strategy but as a territorial, political, and survival (against hunters) strategy. Brownmiller’s biggest criticism is her discrediting biology as a factor. She says rape has no sexual motive, despite all sexual violence having sexual acts common in them. She says animals are not known to rape their own kind, which is false too. Chimps, dolphins, mallard ducks, rats and bundle of other species show such behaviors and they are quite well documented.</p><p>Holding the biological basis with some degree of credibility, many courts adopt chemical castrations as a strategy to curb out repeated sexual offenses by sexual offenders. Depo Provera is an FDA approved drug which has been in use for long in some American states for chemical castration purpose. It reduces blood’s testosterone level to milder standards and aims to stabilize uncontrollable sexual desires of the male perpetrators. It worked in many cases to reduce repeat offenses. But human rights agencies claim using this is unfair and inhumane since, it comes along with numerous side effects to the subject’s health. Also the fact that it needs to be continued for life, but are administered by the state for as long as they are on parole. Hence after the parole ends it jumps back again. They also claim that it strips someone of their sexual agency and freedom, which has been debunked since it just lowers down the level of aggression. The This fact proves the adaptive strategy of Thornhill and Palmer, that rape might have been a byproduct of aggressive adaptive features.</p><p>The topic of rape and sexual violence is extremely complicated. The definition for example and the subjectivity only creates more conflicts among narratives. Conservatives tend to brush off marital rape, male on male rape, transgender as trivial. Whereas on the opposite side of the spectrum, reactionary feminists may claim that a bad date is in fact a rape too. For example, when Aziz Ansari was accused of sexual assault by his date with whom he believed that he had consensual sex, but later on got got himself entangled with a metoo case.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FteBlqboyxbw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DteBlqboyxbw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FteBlqboyxbw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ae4ffca6d6aed3b6429046f43919274a/href">https://medium.com/media/ae4ffca6d6aed3b6429046f43919274a/href</a></iframe><p>The case of Aziz Ansari popped up in a girl’s forum where a girl Abby Neirman posted her metoo story about Aziz Ansari. It was at the time when metoo movement was in vogue. To become a part of a huge ideological wave by faking stories is nothing new. Lets check the case of Mindy from Princeton, who faked her story to get a sense of belonging in the “Take Back the Night Movement”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*-B0zZ-zhyT1bAdB_BtjG4w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/527/1*GoFQqMYYN1cOvwUNZ1dlEg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/519/1*4rcKomW4E1vrbaiF8VPmiQ.png" /></figure><p>The ambiguity around rape befuddles feminist as well. Germaine Greer for example, is known for her controversies surrounding rape. She says, rape is so generalized and uniformly penalized that many rape ends up being trivialized and therefore not reported. she argues for laws to be formulated keeping the wider recipients of assault victims in head, and that not everyone goes through equal trauma, which therefore requires flexible penalties in order to provide rooms for all victims to come forward and seek justice. Most of the criticisms hurled toward Greer are that she trivializes rape and her callousness to provide data to bolster her arguments. But nonetheless, her points do raise some important questions. How to define consent, how to penalize non-stranger rape, and if implementing extreme measures for all helps in any way.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FzKSKLrDB9iI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DzKSKLrDB9iI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FzKSKLrDB9iI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/8d18a162a0b6f79a6e1934e719d519db/href">https://medium.com/media/8d18a162a0b6f79a6e1934e719d519db/href</a></iframe><p>Any measures, whatever you may think of, might follow up with unintended blowbacks. So jumping on the thoughtless populist bandwagon might not help, and if escalated might end up hurting the cause. The book Sexual Violence: Opposing Viewpoints is a must read in this case. The book takes in points put forward by experts from all sides of the spectrums and combines them for the readers to be able to get a wider view of the whole situation. It might end up without providing the reader a conclusive statement, but would certainly show the reader the complexity of the whole situation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*yOFn7oL-D5IkgZ4h.jpg" /></figure><p>The book contains many thing apart from the death penalty issue. Mostly because, regarding rape, death penalty issue have been settled down and rescinded away from court procedures way long ago for being counterproductive and in violation with human rights . Other than that the book addresses other points regarding cause, justice, prevalence surrounding rape perfectly well.</p><p>There is also a popular notion that only Bangladesh has lowest conviction rates. But no. In fact Germaine Greer wrote her book On Rape to address UK’s remarkably low conviction rates, which is around 4.9%. She argues that understanding rape in its truest sense, keeping emotions aside, and formulating laws accordingly may help addressing the situation. As per RAINN, in the USA, out of 1000 cases, 5 leads to conviction. Bangladesh has 3% conviction rates as per reported by Women and Children Repression Prevention tribunal from five districts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kUl66ChKyNOLMZWL-62GJw.png" /></figure><p>So to brand Dhaka as Rape Capital or to brand Bangladesh as A rapist nation isn’t going to much help the victims other than it will benefit political parties to further their political goals. The protesters should instead formulate their arguments better, ask for modernization and reformation of legal procedures, demand for police’s accountability, and to remove political impunities. Govt’s vigilante wings mostly enjoy unfettered in return of loyalty to the government. When such impunity is established, according to rape theory, the benefit will outweigh the risk, and rapes/sexual assaults as a power assertion will keep on being continued. But its highly unlikely that govt would strip them off their power since these vigilante teams ensure their shrines. And this is a problem not only for rape, but for other crimes too. Vigilante wings are notorious for massive human right violations in public colleges, universities, localities etc. They are known for extortions, intimidations, lynchings, violence along with other such heinous crimes. What fuels them is the impunity they enjoy from the local politicians and the police. Without addressing this unfettered and unchecked power, it would be impossible to reduce the amount of rape in any way. The only one that will get punished would be the ones that get viral in social media. Others will get covered under the blanket.</p><p>And most importantly, its not possible for us to study and research about the billions of available social theories and ideologies. Its okay, useful and perfectly fine to remain in the realm of template activism at some points in life. But when things escalate and go political, we’ve got to be aware so that our heightened, shallow emotions may not end up making the movement running in circles or hurt the initial cause eventually. We should always stay alert to hidden slippery slopes laying around while making big decisions. To share once or twice “ Science says we are made of starstuff” is harmless but spreading “Science says there is no gay gene” turns into political drama/cultural clash, ends up in human rights abuses. Now I am not saying that citizens should shut themselves up and don’t congregate under a cause. They obviously should have a right to that. But before instigating such high impact shockwaves, we should try to understand the nuances pf the issue first and form sensible arguments, while keeping the emotions aside. It will save everyone’s time and help in focusing on tangible/realistic aspects of the issue, instead of beating about the bush, or advocating for counterproductive strategies like speedy trials, death penalties for rape.</p><p>Also, only channeling the anger towards the government will take people nowhere. Because the root problem lies in the agelong normalized rape culture within the society. Female sexuality being tabooed and frowned upon, victim blaming, slut shaming, judging women for their economic and sexual freedom and treating them as properties of the males, perpetuation of religious, obedient tradwife stereotypes etc. Society must put an end to viewing women’s affairs from a male’s perspective. To repeat John Berger, a woman’s worth is judged by how the male gaze views her. To practice real feminism, this shackle has to be broken at first, that is, to be actually free and without any constraints of such arbitrary moral expectations put forth by religion or the patriarchal society. So I guess, the protest slogans would have been more fruitful if they were directed to the conservative societal practices, rather than the already struggling befuddled authoritarian government. At least through template activism, and mass memeing, we might try to engineer and change society’s perspectives towards traditional gender roles and bring in desired reforms. This might at least have some shot at making things better. Asking govt to step down, or to cut their vigilante teams off power, or to invest billions of dollars for justice and police reform is likely not going to happen until Bangladesh enters into the high economy zone. So fighting this fight might turn out to be futile, and in no way come to of any help towards the victims. It might escalate political tensions, but if that’s the intent of the protestors, then yes this movement is a success. But seeing my friends and the gullible mob, I would like to believe that they were propelled by an impassioned concern for making the lives of the womenfolk better. I therefore believe that the protestors should focus on tangible tactical protests aimed at reformation of society, rather engaging in fruitless endeavor which results in political tensions, and ends up with counterproductive outcomes.</p><p>But it is not to say that I do not say that I do not support mass political protests, which I do. Every democratic nation should have the absolute right to stage political protests and send out political waves through the masses. But then again, we’ve got to set our grounds first. Are we in for a political protest? Or to achieve some certain goals which are supposed to make a victim’s life better. Both are justified, but we just have to choose which path we are gonna tread on. The political one? Or the victim rights activism one? Because of course, both would require different sets of strategies to come up with some substantial outputs. Fighting with the strategy set of one path while believing to be fighting for the other would not be only delusional but might also bring about unintended outcomes.</p><p>We should always stay alert in such sensitive situations and take calculative approaches, because of course, as the great philosopher George Floyd said, “The truth is always somewhere in the middle…”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/706/0*KPSP5m0bSBABF11v" /></figure><p>For further readings:</p><ol><li><a href="https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/32000/ior530012011en.pdf">https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/32000/ior530012011en.pdf</a></li><li><a href="https://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/violence/global_campaign/en/chap6.pdf?ua=1">https://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/violence/global_campaign/en/chap6.pdf?ua=1</a></li><li><a href="https://digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4363&amp;context=lalrev">https://digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4363&amp;context=lalrev</a></li><li><a href="https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7279&amp;context=jclc">https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7279&amp;context=jclc</a></li><li><a href="https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/race/race-rape-and-the-death-penalty">https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/policy-issues/race/race-rape-and-the-death-penalty</a></li><li><a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/program/the-stream/2020/10/10/why-are-women-raped-with-impunity-in-bangladesh/">https://www.aljazeera.com/program/the-stream/2020/10/10/why-are-women-raped-with-impunity-in-bangladesh/</a></li><li><a href="https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/law-rights/2017/07/09/less-1-ever-gets-punished-rape">https://www.dhakatribune.com/bangladesh/law-rights/2017/07/09/less-1-ever-gets-punished-rape</a></li><li><a href="https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/rape-statistics-by-country">https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/rape-statistics-by-country</a></li><li><a href="https://youtu.be/mEE1hVeMU_U">https://youtu.be/mEE1hVeMU_U</a></li><li><a href="https://youtu.be/48R3sh8I2T8">https://youtu.be/48R3sh8I2T8</a></li><li><a href="https://www.blast.org.bd/content/publications/BLAST-RLR-Conference-Report.pdf">https://www.blast.org.bd/content/publications/BLAST-RLR-Conference-Report.pdf</a></li><li><a href="https://www.rainn.org/statistics/criminal-justice-system">https://www.rainn.org/statistics/criminal-justice-system</a></li><li><a href="https://online.ucpress.edu/nclr/article-abstract/4/2/917/68959/Is-the-Death-Penalty-Good-for-Women?redirectedFrom=PDF">https://online.ucpress.edu/nclr/article-abstract/4/2/917/68959/Is-the-Death-Penalty-Good-for-Women?redirectedFrom=PDF</a></li><li><a href="https://www.dhakatribune.com/opinion/2018/09/14/questioning-the-death-penalty">https://www.dhakatribune.com/opinion/2018/09/14/questioning-the-death-penalty</a></li><li><a href="https://www.dhakatribune.com/opinion/2018/09/14/questioning-the-death-penalty">https://www.dhakatribune.com/opinion/2018/09/14/questioning-the-death-penalty</a></li><li><a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/law-our-rights/law-interview/news/death-penalty-rape-the-severity-punishment-has-nothing-do-impunity-1977109">https://www.thedailystar.net/law-our-rights/law-interview/news/death-penalty-rape-the-severity-punishment-has-nothing-do-impunity-1977109</a></li><li><a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/law-our-rights/law-interview/news/death-penalty-rape-the-severity-punishment-has-nothing-do-impunity-1977109">https://www.thedailystar.net/law-our-rights/law-interview/news/death-penalty-rape-the-severity-punishment-has-nothing-do-impunity-1977109</a></li><li><a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-44922084">https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-44922084</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@gracelapointe/dont-be-an-ellen-jamesian-c2a1b423c7e3">https://medium.com/@gracelapointe/dont-be-an-ellen-jamesian-c2a1b423c7e3</a></li><li><a href="https://tbsnews.net/world/countries-least-number-rape-cases-reported-144178">https://tbsnews.net/world/countries-least-number-rape-cases-reported-144178</a></li><li><a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/opinion/perspective/news/why-crossfire-will-not-solve-our-rape-problem-1855024">https://www.thedailystar.net/opinion/perspective/news/why-crossfire-will-not-solve-our-rape-problem-1855024</a></li><li><a href="http://www.avoiceformalestudents.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/The-Daily-Princetonian.pdf">http://www.avoiceformalestudents.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/The-Daily-Princetonian.pdf</a></li><li><a href="https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/faculty_scholarship/110/">https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/faculty_scholarship/110/</a></li><li><a href="https://www.academia.edu/27227484/Rape_and_evolution_A_Reply_to_our_critics">https://www.academia.edu/27227484/Rape_and_evolution_A_Reply_to_our_critics</a></li><li><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/dec/01/sheryl-sandberg-lean-out-corporate-feminism">https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/dec/01/sheryl-sandberg-lean-out-corporate-feminism</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dc7aeb9f0f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Productivity and Ivyphilia]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/productivity-and-ivyphilia-fc21f482aa30?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc21f482aa30</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rat-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motivational-speaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[toxic-productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hustle-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fake-guru]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Sep 2020 17:36:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-21T22:12:22.550Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*PvPBaWc4kXgdXUNU.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2020/04/03/826015780/when-the-hustle-isnt-enough">Hustle Culture’s black roots, by <em>Dani Pendergast for NPR</em></a></figcaption></figure><p>The fascination towards Ivy leagues and similarly reputed colleges abroad like MIT is nothing new for us Bangladeshis and Indians. Pretty much every student have had the fantasy of studying in these highly esteemed institutions at some point of their lives. No matter how far fetched these fantasies might seem to be for the individuals, but hey, let’s be honest, who at some point of their lives, didn’t keep their rational thoughts aside and fantasize for some brief moment about walking down the aisles of MIT or Harvard? Or vicariously imagining oneself in the positions of others who have already scored the dream; through seeing all their fancy videos from youtube, their social media presence, and gorging into reddit forums to learn their experiences. When we fantasize about something so tangible but yet so far beyond our reach, we start to expose ourselves to a wide range of scammers. And that is of course, the fundamental basics of scamenomics. When scamming someone, it should always be the topmost priority to make sure that the individual being targeted has a shrouded inner craving, as well as sheer ignorance on the subject matter.</p><h3>Section 1:</h3><p>(This section is just for context. I tried to dig in the roots of hustle culture and toxic productivity in general. You can skip this section if you are more keen to read on scammer profiles which i will be discussing on section 2)</p><p><strong><em>Toxic Productivity</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*PIAy7_EpsrPhDlEY.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://hbr.org/2017/12/productivity-tips-for-people-who-hate-productivity-tips">Source: Harvard Business Review</a></figcaption></figure><p>Capitalism has pushed the world into a rat race. Productivity, Career-centrism, tenacious workloads, all are celebrated with one goal in mind, which is to become the maximum profit yielding asset for a corporation. With the rise of the productivity culture, along surges up the levels of anxieties in an individual as well. Keeping in mind that these people face severe insecurities regarding their jobs and career ascensions, there emerges services which promise people to get them on the right track. These services may include productivity apps, self help gurus, motivational speakers, self-help productivity booster books and tons of other similarly related stuffs which are supposed to program ourselves to the best, so that our accelerated output growth catches up to the expectation of our employers, or pushes us to the summit of our corporate ladder. For example, Let’s take into account a popular social networking site, LinkedIn. Linkedin is a professional networking social media website which aims at connecting employers and employees from all over the world. It’s just a marketplace for corporations to scour around for potential employees and also for individuals to find suitable jobs. It would have been great if it was just that, but no. LinkedIn is a for profit company which has been acquired by microsoft for 26 billions dollars. A company offering just a networking facility for employee and employers do not amount to such a gigantic net worth. It has to hook up its customers and engage them as much as possible to the platform. LinkedIn capitalizes on the insecurities of people, insecurities about job, career growth, productivity and self development. It designed its news feed section just like facebook and twitter, with infinite scrolling feature to update feed. The infinite scrolling feature is a popular social media trick to keep its users hooked. While in facebook and twitter you are engaging in fun yielding hooks, news, memes, songs, stupid cat videos, or political discussion forums, in linkedIn the hooks are a bit different. You are constantly bombarded with the success stories of your peers and others. You are constantly fed bright and glistering industry profiles, success stories and reminded each moment that you are not enough, and that you are missing out. The fear of lagging behind generates stress, anxieties and eventually pushes one to a state of depression. You get driven to do something only to realize upon finishing it, that there lies another checkpoint ahead completed by others which you need to follow. And this cycle never ends. LinkedIn thus promotes corporate rat race to the extreme, at the cost psychological distress of its users. linkedIn even offers you ways to get around your inferiority complex. They offer you courses through LinkedIn learning, which shows up right under the drop down option “<strong>Work</strong>”.</p><p>Crazy right? How linkedIn makes you feel lazy and keeps a hook named “Work” so that you click on it driven by the insecurities that has been rattling from your insides through frantically browsing your linkedIn feed. The reason i categorize linkedIn just as any other social media platform is because the way it is designed actually resembles other addictive social media platform to an uncanny level. Its layout is just like facebook, with three columns where the feed section is in the middle. Its feed is just like facebook. LinkedIn’s color palette is just like facebook and twitter, that is blue. The reason for using blue color palette is to make the experience more eye soothing so that users don’t get stressed away by spending too much time on these social platforms. Because of course, the more time invested, the more the stock rise for these companies. Like facebook, linkedIn introduced post reaction button replacing the like button to offer users with more options to express themselves. This feature introduction followed 3 years after facebook introduced its reaction feature. Facebook’s like, or reaction feature is a well known hooking technique which engages users more with their platform and keeps them hooked into the platform even more. Now why would linkedIn follow the psychologically manipulative hack that Facebook introduced, and implement on their very own platform if linkedIn actually don’t want people to waste their time on linkedIn but to actually “<strong>Work</strong>”. LinkedIn’s addictive platform design matches so well with facebook that at a time it just feels like a big ripoff. And additionally, since linkedIn has insecure users who come here looking for opportunities, they can use other means of manipulative tricks which facebook or twitter cannot. For example, “invitation to connect” through one’s email inbox, “see who viewed your profile” in ones profile feed, etc. which are in psychological terms, known as social reciprocity hacks. The amplification of personal insecurities and unhealthy thrust to becoming increasingly competitive makes me conclude that linkedIn is in fact worse than other social media platforms. It’s billion dollar existence depends upon psychologically stressing out its user base through pushing the toxic productivity culture even further, and also without offering an end point. And it’s not just that, such heightened anxieties push people towards deceptive measures as well. No matter how much engaging other social media platforms maybe, people are at least genuine in those places, but in linkedIn people always put up on an ersatz appearance, and hide their genuine self so that employers don’t get deflected away. In an article by techcrunch, it highlighted an applicant survey by ADP, which states that around 44% applicant lie about their work histories, 41% about their education, 23% use fake credentials and licenses.</p><p><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22335544/">The effect of Linkedin on deception in resumes - PubMed</a></p><p>This fraudulence, phoniness and the inauthentic practices with a goal to score some personality points for certain gains (employment, social credits) reminds me of a popular episode from Black Mirror, “Nosedive”. In this hypothetical realm, everyone has to feign their persona in order to win and maintain adequate social credits to thrive within their surroundings.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FR32qWdOWrTo&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DR32qWdOWrTo&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FR32qWdOWrTo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/179147c30563810ebdcbca40a7afe7ca/href">https://medium.com/media/179147c30563810ebdcbca40a7afe7ca/href</a></iframe><p>But is this productivity craze actually worth it? While yes, laziness is never the answer but stressing yourself out to the extent that your anxiety hits its the ceiling is also not worth it. To make farm animals more productive, we engineered their life out of them. Most animals in factory farming are just miserable meatbags for whom being born itself is a curse. Now do we want to be just like that? Do we want to be alive or just breathing? Do we need to chase the productivity illusion so bad that we need to sacrifice our psychological well being along with all that makes a life worth living? Recently the corona pandemic highlighted this issue in a more exemplary way. Everyone being confined to their household started to feel like they are missing out something and falling behind the race. With countrywide lockdowns increasing internet traffic and social media activities, people are falling prey to these psychological manipulations even more. Added to that, the soaring unemployment and job insecurity inadvertently grows the people more anxious and thus productivity schemers start to profit off their vulnerabilities.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fr-rht7kCASo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dr-rht7kCASo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fr-rht7kCASo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e564f9724dbf85d432cf8e330aba65fc/href">https://medium.com/media/e564f9724dbf85d432cf8e330aba65fc/href</a></iframe><p>The productivity craze also lures us into programs which claims to save our time, and thus stretch our hands into a multitude of productive works. Speed reading for example. Speed reading trainer apps and speed reading trainers would tell you that by doubling or quadrupling your reading speed you can quickly consume the content of a book while saving your precious times which can invested into wide array of other productive works or read more books with the power of extra speed.</p><p>But what the trainers won’t tell you is that, speed read comes at a cost, it costs you your comprehensibility. Reading at a faster pace brings your comprehension level to a drastic low. The only way to read speedily is by mastering the language that the book is written into and through cultivating a habit of reading. All those tracker apps and WPM ( words per minute ) training apps are bullcrap if you really want to comprehend and understand what you would be reading. And not just update your social feed to let others know that you’ve just read a book.</p><p>Check what Elizabeth Schotter and her research team found out on this particular issue which is to me, the last nail in the coffin for speed reading gurus.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FYo5HfJcvtgs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DYo5HfJcvtgs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FYo5HfJcvtgs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/460c06fb6d2ed534ea79cbe00055363b/href">https://medium.com/media/460c06fb6d2ed534ea79cbe00055363b/href</a></iframe><p>How did speed reading craze soar so high in demand?</p><p>Of course for the race to be hyperproductive.</p><p>But if you feel this to sinister wait till you see people enjoying movies in 2.5x speed.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FSfmHGmIbfvs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DSfmHGmIbfvs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FSfmHGmIbfvs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e0da6532723848c2cd6f667e9c6cf912/href">https://medium.com/media/e0da6532723848c2cd6f667e9c6cf912/href</a></iframe><p>I just can’t wait until a guru comes to save me from wasting time sleeping and teaches me the art to sleep in 5x speed.</p><p>To understand productivity craze let’s watch the market dominance of productivity enhancing tools. According to market research, the net worth of productivity enhancing softwares is to boost upto 96.36 billions of dollars by the end of 2025, whereas in 2018 it was just valued at 33 billion USD. The 16.5% drastic growth has can be partly contributed to the Covid-19 pandemic which steered many people into seeking productivity enhancer tools due to increasing anxieties and insecurities. And the most dominant market for such products will be the United States with 60.7% of the total market share. The rest 39.3% would be consist of China, Japan, south and central america, southeast asia, india and the rest of the world. Now this should come of no surprise. Because US work culture is pinnacle of rat race olympics, where you just need to keep on working harder and harder and keep on climbing up the corporate ladder till you reach the position of the apex predator. Even then you won’t be paid in millions. So you have to work even harder to join the million dollar clubs. But then again, there would be billionaires ahead that you would need to beat. So you gotta work hard to reach the billionaire club. After that you need to work even harder to reach to the level of the world’s richest man. And if you are in fact the world’s richest man, you have to work hard to retain that position, and keep a watch so that no one topples you any time soon. The work culture never teaches you to be satisfied. This is the american dream basically. Anyone can find success if they work hard enough. Its a free land, anyone can become a billionaire like Bill gates, or zuckerberg or Musk Or Bezos. People like Oprah are celebrated and idolized for being the perfect embodiment of the American Dream, that is the self made billionaire. What’s the secret to their success? Work hard, harder, more hard, neah! still not hard enough, you are not giving your 100%, invest your full energy, give it, give it now, don’t take washroom breaks you fool (<a href="https://www.theverge.com/2018/4/16/17243026/amazon-warehouse-jobs-worker-conditions-bathroom-breaks"><em>amazon’s obsession with keeping workers productive</em></a>), don’t give excuses of illness or the pandemic, even if your local government wants to stay home for your safety (<a href="https://news.sky.com/story/coronavirus-tesla-boss-elon-musk-defies-state-rules-to-open-california-plant-11986820"><em>musk defies state’s pandemic measures to reopen california plant</em></a>). American rat race is like a happy gulag. Everyone works round the hour to chase a deer that only keeps on moving and moving. You chase and chase, complete checkpoints after checkpoints only to never know when to relax, because there is no time left, and the next checkpoint looks so close. It’s like a voluntary gulag where you are self motivated instead of being forced. But actually the self motivation stems from worshipping money. Money is undeniably necessary but the celebration of grotesque greed is only possible through selling neoliberal capitalist stories, like the american dream. But this is not true, as in the book “Animal Farm” the character Boxer, who keeps on working and working in hopes of a better future only ends up feeding the pigs to monstrous obesity. The amazon retail workers can never reach the level of Bezos. But the american dream says so. Every american is given the same opportunity, and through working hard and smart anyone can become an oprah or a bezos. But sadly this is just bollocks. Success requires merit, and hard work, true. But it requires luck and environment too. And having a rich family who can invest your ventures like Bill gates’ parents helps too. Having a degree from ivy leagues help too. Or winning an accidental lawsuit of 250 million dollars like <a href="https://www.bostonherald.com/2020/07/24/washington-post-settles-250m-lawsuit-with-teen-in-a-maga-hat/">Nicholas Sandmann</a>. Or having a rich husband like the world’s richest woman, Mackenzie Bezos. Success is measured through riches, so yes even though she earned her fortune from her divorce, but theoretically speaking she is the most successful woman on the planet now. Not the people who are working 24/7 in amazon with little break and little vacation period.</p><p><a href="https://aeon.co/ideas/a-belief-in-meritocracy-is-not-only-false-its-bad-for-you">A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it&#39;s bad for you - Clifton Mark | Aeon Ideas</a></p><p>Thus the infatuation of chasing an elusive success point, makes the rat run the wheels even faster until he is completely enervated. And in the meanwhile, many meaningful facet of life is lost without the rat even noticing. For example, meaningful friendships, relationships, personal space and a sane psyche. Anxieties, Depression replaces all those major aspects of a meaningful life. To understand this phenomena better i can suggest you Sam Polk’s biographical book on this. Sam Polk was an Wall Street Hedge Fund trader who rose up the ladder up to the millionaire club but could never reach the point of satisfaction. His pursuit of moneymaking resonates with many young people who turn their success pursuit into an addiction, with shifting their goals further and further as they start finishing one after another milestones. For Sam, getting into Wall Street was supposed to be the fulfillment of his dreams. But soon started to lose track of that satisfaction. He started to realize his toxic obsession with moneymaking when he was offered 3.25 million dollars in bonus and yet it could not satisfy him at all but rather infuriated him for the sum being too, which in fact it wasn’t. He realized that his pursuit of the elusive success checkpoints cost him his relationships with his life-partners, friends, families. It eventually drowned him into states of depression, overeating, bulimia, alcohol and drug abuse. He then quit wall street, his pursuit of greed, and returned back to a relatively normal, stable, and a healthy family life.</p><p><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/27274419-for-the-love-of-money">For the Love of Money</a></p><p>I had a review of the thing written back in 2018, attaching it here, if you don’t have much time to go through the book.</p><p><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2378963914?book_show_action=true&amp;from_review_page=1">Fattah Fathun Karim&#39;s review of For the Love of Money</a></p><p>Also this blogpiece was a good read which i recommend, which echoes similar sentiments on how toxic productivity strips you away from all that’s good.</p><p><a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/melodywilding/2016/08/08/6-signs-your-obsession-with-productivity-is-destroying-you/#40530e7d7265">6 Signs Your Obsession With Productivity Is Hurting You</a></p><p>Thus we can pretty much realize why america would be the biggest market for productivity enhancing softwares and apps. Most americans are systemically fed the insecurities about earning success to become extremely competitive and milk the best out of them. But they never get to be aware of what constitutes success in the first place. Hence they keep on running the never ending rat race. To keep them from not enervating and keeping the wheel running, they need energy and performance boosters. And productivity services thrive based on their voluntarily heightened anxieties. And along with them thrives motivational coaches and gurus, and performance enhancing drugs.</p><p>The other places of the world lag a little behind than the americans but american productivity craze has started to reach those parts of the world too. And this is due to the globalization of the anxiety market.</p><p>Now reading all of this, one might come to conclude that i am trying to put up a case against productivity in general. But actually i am not, just to stay clear. Anxiety and distress are our vital evolutionary trait. If we don’t get anxious, we won’t be motivated to work and without work we won’t be able to grow or collect resources to live on. But then again, we need to eat to live too, but does that mean we need to keep on binging ourselves on food? What happens if we actually do? Does our physical and psychological health ameliorate or deteriorate? This is just the case when we ride on the hyperproductivity trend. WIth the active and passive promotion of hyperproductivity culture being promulgated through social media, workplace culture and productivity monitoring, floods of advertises luring towards of maximizing productivity, and through other dystopian ways the system keeps our anxiety and stress level up making us feel that we are always lagging behind. All these cumulatively motivates us to consume more productivity enhancing tools (thus creating a 92 billion industry), and also helps us into turning ourselves into farm chickens stripped off a normal life to maximize meat output at the cost of destruction of the self, the psyche. In an article published in the citizen, Bhabani shankar nayak articulately explains how unfettered capitalism drove competitive productive hysteria into our minds with the aid of social media, and how it decimated our “self” to alarming extent. She argues that unfettered capitalism taught us that idleness is a sin, time is money, and productivity maximization is our only hopes to salvation. While blatantly ignoring our working conditions, mental healths, family, friendships and other meaningful aspects of life. The author draws parallel between workplace hustle culture with ancient wartime economics which rewards alertness, prudence, fecundity, constant vibrancy and in the meanwhile vilifying any sort of frivolity. But wartime strategies should not be our benchmark to follow which would drive our anxieties like that of a military general or a field marshal. We do not have countries to liberate nor tribes to conquer. So, why the bustle and for whom and for what?</p><p><a href="https://www.thecitizen.in/index.php/en/NewsDetail/index/15/18807/The-Capitalist-Battle-of-Productiveness">The Capitalist Battle of Productiveness</a></p><p>Now, the american dream would like to tell us that to better our socio-economic condition we need to work our hearts out and make ourselves useful. What it forgets to mention that people in fact do work hard. Some people faint out working hard in their workplace just to make ends meet. How is fainting out while catering to customers in a burger shop going to help one reach the level of silicon valley entrepreneurs whose motivational life stories are the fuel of every motivational channels that you will come across online. An article run by Nytimes highlights the overloaded work culture in the US and and how people’s lives are shaped surrounding it. It brings up the story of of a hospital food service worker Alexander Cutler, who worked extra shift to make her ends meet. She faints down while overworking and is sent to bedrest for weeks without being compensated at all. It mentions of a guy named Julion Payes who used to work 80 hours a week at Mcdonalds and Aerotek. To keep him up awake and energetic he used to binge on coffees and sodas. His town paid him even less of a minimum wage than Cutler’s town which was barely enough for a person to make his ends meet. Such low pay prompts the workers to work extra shifts or take multiple jobs just to earn a square living. But the huge chunk of time invested onto this, takes away their life away from them. Payes too fainted out at grocery stores, had little time for his family and friends. It shows an instance where his little brother emotionally begs Payes to spend some time with him saying, “How much for one hour to play with me”. But little did he know Payes was just on the virtuous mission of exhausting himself to the brink of becoming a saint in the eyes of employers.</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/02/21/magazine/minimum-wage-saving-lives.html">The $15 Minimum Wage Doesn&#39;t Just Improve Lives. It Saves Them.</a></p><p>Such productivity crazed work culture is nothing new. It roots back to american history of slavery. With the boom in cotton industry american demand for slave trade only increased in order to meet up with the rising cotton demand which brought down the price of apparels to a drastical low. To increase productivity americans confiscated and conquered native american lands to expand their plantations, and push their slaves to work to the verge of breakdowns. To keep productivity in check they devised monitoring schemes to watch over their slave’s productivity. Each slave was supposed to yield a minimum threshold of crops, and if that didn’t match the overseer’s expectation, severe whippings befell upon them as punishment to bring them back on the productivity track. Being more productive was a drawback for a slave too, because once a slave yielded more than expected the bar for him got set up even higher which would eventually require him to keep that consistency all throughout the following days. The slaves often fainted out only to vomit again when waking up, then got back to work and return to being broken by the end of the day. The plantation owners never saw them as human beings but as tools of productivity. And they did succeed. The american cotton industry boomed to 500 millions of dollars worth in a short period of time. America was responsible for yielding half of the world’s net cotton production. And they couldn’t but afford but exploit every inch of their slaves to keep the consistency of the production or to expand them in fact. To quote the article,</p><blockquote>Like today’s titans of industry, planters understood that their profits climbed when they extracted maximum effort out of each worker. So they paid close attention to inputs and outputs by developing precise systems of record-keeping. Meticulous bookkeepers and overseers were just as important to the productivity of a slave-labor camp as field hands</blockquote><p>With the plantation owners devising spreadsheets like that of Thomas Affleck’s “<strong>Plantation Record and Account Book</strong>”, superior supervision and accounting techniques and hierarchical work management, the plantations grew increasingly efficient and individual worker yield grew up to 400% within the span of 60 years which is astonishingly huge and pretty insidious too once you start to think what might have went through the workers to have reached that bar. But it did accelerate innovation and paved the way towards industrial revolution. Modern era workplace management, supervision, accounting, hierarchical reporting, banking system, etc can be attributed to those plantations. But just because it yielded excessive production, brought innovations, accelerated world economy (which eventually fell apart for production overflow; crashing slave market and cotton market along with it), can we justify slavery and worker exploitation? As historian Edward Baptist said, quoting from the article,</p><blockquote>Before the civil wars, lived in an economy whose bottom gear was torture.</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/08/14/magazine/slavery-capitalism.html">American Capitalism Is Brutal. You Can Trace That to the Plantation. (Published 2019)</a></p><p>While the slaves were forced into work, many supposedly “free” workers before and after force upon themselves the hideous workloads voluntarily just out of the virtuous notion that exhausting oneself to work is the pinnacle of human virtue. Bertrand Russell ponders upon the cause and effect of such enervating work culture in his essay “In praise of idleness”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/387/0*5GWLxdtKoxFcGHWm" /></figure><p>According to Russell, since long idleness was perceived to be a vice and overwork as a virtue. Such sentiments were basis of wartime economics of the past. Leisure was allotted for only some privileged fractions only. It was deemed blasphemous to ask a king to work, just like it was blasphemous to call a peasant to rest. Overwork was glorified and applauded for exploiting the labors of the bottom line through generations after generations with the help of fables, scriptures, mandates and what not. And all of this just to maintain the status quo, just to keep the idle faction immerse themselves into eternal hedonistic idleness and the drive the rest towards an exhausting culture of productivity to lift the civilization up.</p><p>Russell argues that intensive labor does more harm than good. While we moved far ahead from wartime economics, nevertheless we carried away with us the glorification of overworking and restlessness from our past battlegrounds. Russell argues that leisure is mandatory. Because it was the small leisured class who could afford thinking things out of the box. Because they did not have to worry about exhausting their asses out to make out a living. He says, these particular class, for being granted freedom in pursuing their interest could bring paradigm shifts in science, politics, philosophies, arts and other frivolous endeavors which did not necessarily generate much of a wealth considering the time and resource investment behind them. In this essay he proposes a 4 hour workday which would grant an individual to explore his interests, be free in his creative endeavors and have time of his own to indulge into things that make a life meaningful and not like a farm chicken or the life of “Boxer” from the book Animal Farm. It’s not just Russell though, John Maynard Keynes predicted that with technological revolution the world would enjoy 15 hours work week. But russell argued that if that happened, the companies would then lay off half of their workers and overwork others to save employee costs rather allow them 15 hour workweek.</p><p>Russell wrote the book in 1935. While it was written nearly a century ago, the idea still holds true to date. With productivity being the buzzword of 21st century, and the hyper productive farm life being glorified everywhere, our psyche and self are getting destroyed. We lost the person residing in the middle and replaced it with the person that a LinkedIn professional would find useful for his company. The race to enriching resumes with meaningless certifications, most of it which are done just for the sake of something other (to show off to employers mostly and generating a productive farm chicken image of the self ), the gist of those which one will eventually come to forget later on, are stripping us off from a life that we can actually claim an ownership on and be satisfied with.</p><p>Russell claims, “ The modern man thinks that everything ought to be done for the sake of something else, and never for its own sake”. So what do you think? Should we be Russell’s modern man and spend your whole life behind pot boilers only to realize later on that this is an endless and an elusive pursuit that we are pursuing?</p><p>And at least the workers having been mentioned above get paid. Alexandria Cutler of the previously mentioned nytimes article got 12.32$ hourly wage. Payes was paid low but after minimum wage reformation in his town he started to get 15$ per hour. Considering he does 80 hours a week as per mentioned in the article, he should get 62,400 dollars a year. Considering vacation leaves and others, lets consider the worst case scenario. let’s presume payes works 33 weeks in total and earns 40,000$ a year. Even then, thats double of what a graduate student gets from his professor. But academic exploitations are always overlooked since in most cases these are not considered to be jobs. Since the student status retains, professors can get away with exploiting their student’s labour to built up their research project while paying them negligible sum of money. The workloads of a grad student is enormous, just like any other professional employee in any industry or in some cases even more. Since it’s still technically a learning phase, and a degree earning phase, they don’t get to have employee benefits as per labour acts. And it creates room for massive labour exploitation. The extensive workloads breed extensive stress and anxieties. In a report published by the guardian, it shows that around 30% phd students develop psychiatry conditions which is by the far the highest of any profession including the most stressful ones like in emergency response units or people working in defence.</p><p><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/higher-education-network/2018/may/18/academia-exploitation-university-mental-health-professors-plagiarism">Academia is built on exploitation. We must break this vicious circle | Anonymous academic</a></p><p>Ignoring grad students’ conditions is not a new topic in town. The exploitative professors were once exploited students themselves. It’s just a cycle that keeps on being repeated over and over again.</p><p>In an article by the economist, “The disposable academic” the author takes the criticism even much further by analyzing the potentials of PhD degrees over career prospects and weighing it against the years and years of low paid, overworked, overstressed academic journey to see if it yields much of a value. Of course, he concludes, that in most of the cases it doesn’t yield as much value as is to be expected out of it. The author highlights the cases of foreign students too. He shows how professors searching for cheap labour turn their cheeks towards international students who are easier to exploit at the cheapest possible rate and burdening them with extensive workloads without getting whined at is an easy shot too. Most of these foreign students come with a hope of permanent residency and therefore the professor’s offer seems to them like a dream come true. Thus, they themselve create the room for the professors to push them into conformism. Most of the students pursuing higher studies do not have much awareness about worker rights, minimum wage and healthy work schedules. Most of them view conformism and subserviency as the only path to salvation, that is a good career in later life and a permanent residency. But this is unfair if we consider human rights to be same for everyone. And the reason the professors can get away with it, is because PhD students are not considered workers but rather learners or apprentices. The unionization of grad students is a rare sight too. Many universities even actively detest and try to drive away unionisation attempts. And even if they do acknowledge grad students unionizing themselves, they neglect or stop negotiating with them afterwards, like that which happened in New York University. Most student work so restlessly with the notion that they are working for something greater than them. The only way to prove your worth in such a highly revered field, to be acknowledged as an expert, a brainiac and a part of the fringest talent pool, is to enervate yourself as per your professor’s will. And all in the meanwhile, putting a blindfold to the ways your professor and the university is benefitting themselves from exploiting you.</p><p><a href="https://www.economist.com/christmas-specials/2010/12/16/the-disposable-academic">The disposable academic</a></p><p>This particular article threw the academic world in a tantrum. It even generated cult followings. Many forums followed and continued the discussion. Many follow ups got written by academics sharing their personal experiences. For example huffingtonpost ran an article following the economist one under the title, “I am a Disposable Academic” which encompasses around the writer’s own experience as an academic.. Psychologytoday also has an article from psychologist Michael W Kraus sharing his own experience. Both are attached below for you to read. While they mostly agree with the economist article, but kraus takes a backflip at the end, saying that doing phds are intellectual pursuits. The thrill of overcoming challenges should be the reward, not the money. Well yes exactly! That’s what many other defender of the status quo has in their mind too. Although kraus doesn’t go on completely defending the status quo, he does express that he could use a little more money while he was in grad school. But nevertheless, he believes that the intellectual pursuit and overcoming intellectual challenges are worth the long hours and low pay. This is an instance of stockholm syndrome in my opinion. Since you have to justify your noble pursuit in one way or the other, you start to twist reality. Plus you might become a professor soon enough after your slavery clause ends, only to turn yourself into slave owner. So you can’t but keep some potholes and have some defense on your side.</p><p>Plus selling stories is the most easy way to keep people content and contained when you are running out of palpable values to offer. It worked selling nationalistic stories to wage wars. It worked selling religious stories to suppress women and minorities. It worked selling abrahamic stories to displace a nation and create a never ending crisis in the middle east. It worked selling stories of a superior aryan race to germans for uniting them under hitler and wage world war. It worked selling stories of caste to keep the social division in check, and keep a perpetual labour supply for dead end jobs. On a more relatable side, MLM companies, ponzi schemes, pyramid schemes all operate on the basis of selling dreams to marginal or middle class families. Stories have the power do wonders.</p><p>Coming back to the context of higher education, how else can you convince an indian or a bangladeshi or a taiwanese to work long hours for you, provided with the slightest pay, other than selling the glorified story of academia. The story of Green Card and a prosperous career after the doctoral program, would that come to your assistance? Realistically speaking, can a doctoral program which earns one 2–3% more than a Masters degree entice an individual? Umm Idk, maybe! But what if they decide to unionize to better their condition due to a lack of delusional lenses in front of their eyes? How else can you prompt them to work like workaholics with the least of benefits provided?</p><p><a href="https://www.huffpost.com/entry/disposable-academic_b_4178524">I Am a Disposable Academic</a></p><p>While the stories might indeed seem to be quite fascinating which the universities or the professors sell to students, but then again, most of these stories are illusions too. I can’t help but quote the Unabomber’s Manifesto on this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/907/0*Mht1kW2Df-dOfDzI.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ExEqsts1QeML0_XM.jpg" /><figcaption>Unabomber Manifesto along with the Unabomber</figcaption></figure><p>It might seem weird that i am referring to a anarchist terrorist to make my point. But let’s not kid ourselves. He was one of the brightest minds of his time after all, who advanced faster than any of his peers. His contribution towards mathematics is fairly noted as well. Since Ted was immersed into academia, he got to know the ins and outs of it’s research culture. He claims that most research works are basically surrogate activity of professors. They have little do with real world impact but mostly to keep oneself busy with or to showcase his intellectual exercise for advancing his career. In the chapter, “The motives of scientists” Kaczynski claims, researchers are not merely driven by curiosity and a goal to ameliorate mankind, but they rather engage into them as surrogate activities, as a part of the “<strong>power process</strong>”. By surrogate activity, kaczynski means those activities which are directed towards artificial goals that people create themselves in order to just have a goal to look forward to and get fulfilment out of them. By power process he means, 1. to have a goal (a scientific problem to solve), 2. to make an effort (a research), 3. to attain the goal (get solution to the problem). Thus kaczynski claims that researchers engage mostly in surrogate activities which are not much driven by the motive of benefiting mankind or mere curiosity as they claim but just out of feeling a sense of fulfilment and conquer.</p><blockquote>Science and technology provide the most important examples of surrogate activities. Some scientists claim that they are motivated by “curiosity” or by a desire to “benefit humanity.” But it is easy to see that neither of these can be the principal motive of most scientists. As for “curiosity,” that notion is simply absurd. Most scientists work on highly specialized problems that are not the object of any normal curiosity. For example, is an astronomer, a mathematician or an entomologist curious about the properties of isopropyltrimethylmethane? Of course not. Only a chemist is curious about such a thing, and he is curious about it only because chemistry is his surrogate activity. Is the chemist curious about the appropriate classification of a new species of beetle? No. That question is of interest only to the entomologist, and he is interested in it only because entomology is his surrogate activity. If the chemist and the entomologist had to exert themselves seriously to obtain the physical necessities, and if that effort exercised their abilities in an interesting way but in some nonscientific pursuit, then they wouldn’t give a damn about isopropyltrimethylmethane or the classification of beetles. Suppose that lack of funds for postgraduate education had led the chemist to become an insurance broker instead of a chemist. In that case he would have been very interested 10 in insurance matters but would have cared nothing about isopropyltrimethylmethane. In any case it is not normal to put into the satisfaction of mere curiosity the amount of time and effort that scientists put into their work. The “curiosity” explanation for the scientists’ motive just doesn’t stand up. — ( Industrial Society and its future: para 87)</blockquote><p>Kaczynski then goes on to conclude the section “ The motives of scientists” using this striking paragraph,</p><blockquote>Thus science marches on blindly, without regard to the real welfare of the human race or to any other standard, obedient only to the psychological needs of the scientists and of the government officials and corporation executives who provide the funds for research. — (Industrial Society and its future: para 92)</blockquote><p>While many thing here may be debatable, for example, that the modern academic culture is different-It is more of a job, rather an surrogate activity, that tenureship depends on publication counts, and its either publish or perish for which professors are forced to conduct frivolous researches. Also that many industrial collaboration happen within academic sphere which aim towards real life utility of projects and seek out results for industrial benefits. But lets kid ourselves not. Most of the academic papers are so specialised that they have little to no impact due to lack of readers who would actually go on translating those knowledge into real life applications. Kaczynski’s period in Academia was in the sixties (1962–1969), a time when the publication hysteria hadn’t much hit academia like it has today. The focus and pressure on publications paved way towards trivial scientific pursuits and trivial knowledge addition in already saturated fields. Such expansion of insignificant contributions, no matter how noble they may seem, are not much more than a dog chasing his tail. Both are trivial means to keep oneself busy. But this trivial contribution culture costs universities more. In an article by Richard Vedder, a Distinguished Professor of Economics at Ohio University analyzes the additional costs that universities have to go through for research emphasis. He explains that unlike the sixties, in modern era research emphasis have pushed faculties to recruit more teachers to balance the abated course-loads of tenured academics. Thus in places where 12 tenured professor would have done the job, now requires 18 to cover up the overall shortfall. And this amounts to 600,000$ additional investment from the university administrations. But the output of papers from all these faculties don’t amount much more than 33,000$. Added to that, the output gets read by roughly 100 people in honest sincerity, that too considering the maximum. So the author wonders if investing so much money into research hysteria actually worth it where the outputs are not significant enough.</p><blockquote>The point, however, is that lower teaching loads over the past half-century have come at a cost. In part that cost is met by moving away from using expensive tenure-track faculty to teach, going to more part-time adjunct faculty (some would argue with a loss in instructional quality). The emphasis on research, however, is expensive and leads often to a trivial addition to the stock of knowledge. Diminishing returns set into research. The 100th paper on the impact of gerrymandering, interpretation of John Rawls’ veil of ignorance, or the effects of climate change on the mating habits of insects no doubt is typically less consequential than the first or second paper. Moreover, while research sometimes complements teaching and leads to more insightful instruction, a publish or perish environment can lead to student neglect, perfunctory teaching, and a decline in mentoring of young persons that helps them navigate the transition from adolescence to adulthood.</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/richardvedder/2018/07/12/33000-academic-journal-articles-that-almost-no-one-reads/#e5f0bd35756a">$33,000 Academic Journal Articles That Almost No One Reads</a></p><p>The fact that most scientific academic journals often go without being read or any value being churned out of them has been a part of an ongoing discussion on how to reform academic publishing practices. Smithsonian magazine ran an article on how many people actually do read academic papers. They argue that apart from authors, editors and referees, reviewers the readerbase of such specialised academic journals is practically non existent. Although the report showed some skepticism about the actual metrics but nevertheless it does acknowledge the fact that most of these rigorous works often go unnoticed because of their lack of real life utility. And as times are passing by with more publishers coming on board the problem is only increasing. Trivial scientific pursuits with redundant researches are thriving rampant, because of the notion that it’s better to publish anything rather than nothing.</p><p><a href="https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/half-academic-studies-are-never-read-more-three-people-180950222/">Academics Write Papers Arguing Over How Many People Read (And Cite) Their Papers</a></p><p>So the point is,</p><p>Is making a grad student reach the verge of psychological breakdowns for such insignificant pursuits worth it? And also, is selling daydreams to graduate students ethical? Most foreign PhD students are usually in their mid twenties or thirties. In such age groups you need a living wage to survive, since you start to become independent from your families, and your financial needs are just like your counterparts who are working in industries. But despite working more arduously than your friends in the industry, doing 10 hours weeklong work schedules with very little pay and living on instant noodles and free pizzas (ref. Economist),is satisfying the trivial scientific pursuit of your professor and the university reputation actually worth it? Or are you actually getting ripped off and your labour not being properly evaluated nor even properly rewarded? Do you think the Napoleons are just exploiting Boxers like you for your cheap and dedicated labour, in exchange of an elusive dream? (Animal Farm ref.)</p><h3>Section 2</h3><p><strong><em>Ivyphilia</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*rLb0KoxsCHAHgoG-.jpg" /></figure><p>Apparently the reverence of doctorate degrees and academic research culture stretch far and beyond. A PhD is still a matter of great social prestige be it the united states or in other countries. The title “Dr.” is very lucrative one , just like the title “Alhaj” in a person’s name. The reason being that both titles are generative of deep admiration and social points. Although having a doctorate degree would also offer you the image of being one of the smartest fews on the planet, overlooking the actual intellectual contribution that the degree yields. But nonetheless the social recognition is enough for grad students to live under minimum wage working with demanding professors for 5 years or more, The glittery outward appearance blinds people to the overworked, overstressed, underpaid living condition of poor grad students.</p><p>Now the fascination with grad schools and graduate degrees have opened scopes for impostors to seep in, especially in underdeveloped and developing countries where people worship grad schools like crazy. Being one of the most advanced, intelligent species is like being among the 1% of the whole nation. Its like ascending from ghettos and turning yourself into a prophetic figure. Having a doctorate multiplies the credibility of your words to a thousandfold, since you start to be considered among the highly intelligent 1% of the population. A claim seems suspicious? No worries, just attach the words PhD behind it, it won’t be anymore.</p><p>“Vaccines are a hoax. They cause autism and evolution is a lie.” — Random Joe</p><p>“Vaccines are carefully crafted lies that is part of a colonial project through which the west tries to dominate the third world. The racist and unfounded theory of evolution is promulgated to support the theory of vaccinations and bolsters the sales of big pharmaceutical companies.” — Random Joe (PhD in xxxxxx)</p><p>The random joe might be discarded at an instant by branding him stupid and insane. But can you call the random joe with a PhD insane? And what if the random joe with a PhD is from Oxford, Cambridge or Harvard?</p><p>And i am not even kidding. There are multiple people with PhDs with extremely idiotic viewpoints. Although i came up with the example above on the go just to demonstrate how a statement’s credibility increase with the help of a doctorate degree. But if you search online you will find numerous such PhD holders with dumbfounded views about the world.</p><p>Geez, who could’ve thought!!! That working on the 100th paper measuring the bond lengths of isopropyltrimethylmethane or the 100th paper on the effect of gerrymandering about might not necessarily land one among the intellectual saints.</p><p>This enormous power of credibility that doctorate degrees hold did not go unnoticed in the eyes of the shrewds and scammers. Many scammers will try to either fake certificates, invitations or amplify their tenuous relations with reputed universities (non degree, execed or online programs), to garner public attention. Sometimes they may be done for business purpose which many motivational self help gurus do, sometimes they can be done to establish a business, sometimes they might be done get contracts from governments of NGOs and sometimes just out of pure narcissistic inner drive.</p><p>Let’s take some case studies for example.</p><h4><strong>Case 1. Clint Arthur</strong></h4><p>Clint Arthur is a celebrity entrepreneur and a personal branding expert who helps financial advisers stand out of the crowd and flourish in their business. His website states,</p><blockquote>Clint Arthur is one of America’s most sought-after Motivational, Inspirational, and Entrepreneurial Speakers, and The World’s Top Expert on Creating Celebrity Positioning for Authors, Speakers, Coaches, and Entrepreneurs</blockquote><p>There’s just so much buzzwords in that one sentence, that it starts to feel like to have been overstated, aggrandized.</p><p>It feels like that because it actually is.</p><p>In an article by Wall Street Journal the journalist Jason Zweig dives into arthur’s whole business mechanism. Arthur, a once cab driver turned motivational guru trains businesspeople, including dozens of financial gurus, most of them are fake too. So, he is technically a fake guru of fake gurus, as a youtuber coffezilla puts. WSJ reveals that the what Arthur does is that he basically charges a hefty sum of money (5000$ to 25000$) from financial advisers and motivational gurus through his courses, arranges them a speech in Harvard or US Military Academy at west point and thus helps them flourish in their business. Now what’s the motivation behind doing that? As Arthur says,</p><blockquote>In order for a person to give you a lot of money,” Mr. Arthur said in an interview, “they must admire you, like you and trust you.</blockquote><p>And i’ve already state before how an affiliation with reputed institution instantly swells up your credibility to people. So Mr. Arthur is just reaffirming my previous argument.</p><p>But the funny thing Arthur is not affiliated with Harvard neither the US military. Apparently just “believe in yourself, do it now!” is not much of an attractive feat. for Harvard administrators that they will invite a person over it. So how does he accomplish that? Arthur sponsors an independently run HBS Students club with a huge chunk of money and they invite him over as a courtesy. Arthur brings in with him his clients to render speeches in the event. And thus his clients get to tag themselves with the “Harvard” image which is so vital for their business scheme, that is to earn client’s trust.</p><p>Upon knowing the fact Mr Arthur is using HBS students club as a means of personal gain and helping scammers, the club closed their ties with him. Arthur hires Faculty clubs at harvard or west point which anyone can hire given the designated fee. Arthur claims they were all sanctioned by harvard and west point authorities, where in fact upon contacting them WSJ found out that none of them were sanctioned by any of those aforementioned authorities. In fact west point released statements saying that they do not support Mr Arthur’s deceptive ventures.</p><p>but Arthur has a fanbase, of course why wouldn’t he. He just let people earn the credibility they wouldn’t have found otherwise. As <strong>Ms. West</strong>, a client of Arthur says,</p><blockquote>Ms. West said in an interview that “there shouldn’t be any confusion” over whether these are school-sponsored events: “We spoke at Harvard.” She called mentioning the Harvard name “dropping the H-bomb” and said it brings “instant credibility” with clients. “It’s like, ‘If I’m good enough for Harvard, I’m probably good enough for you.’</blockquote><p>People’s tendency to not question any harvard affiliate with their degree of intelligence is what makes these fake gurus thrive online and offline and its them themselves admitting it.</p><p>The Wall Street Journal article can be found here,</p><p><a href="https://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2018/02/16/meet-the-guy-who-gets-financial-advisers-into-harvard-and-west-point/">Meet the Guy Who Gets Financial Advisers Appearances at Harvard and West Point</a></p><p>There are multiple instances of such motivational deceptive gurus that can be found online who sell people platitudes in disguise of something wise. Coffeezilla did a whole episode exposing clint arthur and explaining his deceptive mechanism. You can find it following this link below,</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FUwftRRc7EbI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DUwftRRc7EbI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FUwftRRc7EbI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e94df11b9ec1fb8184f72a70499f5dfe/href">https://medium.com/media/e94df11b9ec1fb8184f72a70499f5dfe/href</a></iframe><p>The funny thing is Arthur uses the wall street journal’s scathing review to his advantage while it is basically a scathing review of his works. But Arthur is just one guy. The fake motivational guru industry is even much more wide. All of them have have one thing in common, selling unfounded dreams, to be more precise, “The American Dream” and promoting hustle culture with bundles of cliches wrapped as something extremely thoughtful.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FL9Gpr7PEnbs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DL9Gpr7PEnbs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FL9Gpr7PEnbs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0892d0ef40fab113160ee87fc7ad94af/href">https://medium.com/media/0892d0ef40fab113160ee87fc7ad94af/href</a></iframe><p>In this article by Larissa Faw in the Forbes Magazine, she highlights such overused niche culture that are rampant in these fake guru services which are thriving in the west.</p><p><a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/larissafaw/2018/03/02/the-scam-of-millennial-motivational-coaches/#6c729e9bd14e">The Scam Of Millennial Motivational Coaches</a></p><p>The funny thing is that, what rises in the west eventually follows to the east too.</p><p>In my country, motivational guru business wasn’t a big thing until a guy solaiman shukhon came and changed it all.</p><h4>Case 2: Solaiman Shukhon</h4><p>Solaiman shukhon is an ex navy lieutenant turned marketing guru. He was in banglalink, amra network and now currently work at marketing department of Nagad.</p><p>It was the year 2018 at the month of July. Mr. Solaiman Shukhon drops a bomb to his followers that he has been invited by the Cambridge university to give a speech at a event organized by the Department of Engineering under the banner, “International Branding and Inspiration”. The combo of these two seemed to be extremely fishy and very unlikely. Considering his past bragging, plagiarising foreign contents some of us friends thought of diving into the issue. We found out that it was just the exact replication of the scheme of Mr. Clint Arthur. The WSJ article exposed Arthur in february and solaiman shukhon’s case appeared July. In Cambridge, the authority knew nothing about such a person being invited. Instead it was a found out that a bangladeshi graduate student named Bahauddin invited him in a personal program that he was about to arrange through renting the uni clubs.</p><p>But just like Clint Arthur, Mr. Solaiman showed this off as an invitation by harvard authorities and claimed that his hard work was being monitored by people all over the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*NIjMg1IKSr0z_qB0.jpeg" /></figure><p>But every scammer leaves a trace. It just needs to be digged. To know the detail of the scam you might try giving a read to shakil ahmed’s medium note on this. The article was first published in his facebook id but after being reported by solaiman shukhon and his team it quickly got taken down.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@shakil.istikal/solaiman-sukhons-tour-of-cambridge-4c537b59c9fb">Solaiman Sukhon’s Tour of Cambridge</a></p><p>Solaiman shukhon has a multitude number of other issues that has been exposed by a bundle of other people, but let’s not dive into those issues since it would require a whole new other article.</p><p>but it didn’t just end up with solaiman shukhon.</p><h4><strong>Case 3: Upoma Ahmed</strong></h4><p>Upoma Ahmed a lecturer at Canadian International university who claims to have earned recognition from harvard university. She runs an organization named Evolution 360 which god knows what they are good for apart from highly adorned facebook branding with cliche NGO terms which never gets materialized. Her whole CV is exaggeration or amplification of cliches. she claims to be global goodwill ambassador of UN whereas such a thing doesn’t even exist. UN and GGA are different entities. But hey, the UN tag is a pricy thing right? What’s funny is that she isn’t even recognized by GGA too. Her forged braggings caught the eye of content derived Bangladeshi news portals and she was turned into an overnight celebrity persona.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pI9RuMnn65QVAQ9b" /></figure><p>It didn’t end in just that, she later on devised her ways to take her credibilities to an extra level. She tried to affiliate herself with harvard, because as Ms. West have previously mentioned, “Mentioning the H-bomb gains you an immediate trust of people”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*um5j3Z-rHRZNYEKy" /></figure><p>The smiley used to hide the “X” in HarvardX was clever and it in fact worked. Journalists took notice and her name were on papers after papers as a groundbreaking achievement of a Bangladeshi Individual. Why? Because of course, it is harvard, and also because bangladeshi journalists can’t fact check.</p><p>You won’t much find the articles in the portals now, since after her getting exposed by Manas Nag, a senior from her own university, the papers pulled the articles down. Apparently medium is not letting me embed facebook post, so you can navigate through clicking on <a href="https://www.facebook.com/manas.nag/posts/4135720126470211">here</a>.</p><p>No one knows what her motives were. Only she can tell. Maybe just to feed narcissistic ego or to establish her organization. But the takeaway from this incident that i want to bring out to you is the UN, Harvard and western institution craze that we suffer from.</p><p>Now, let me tell you the story of a guy from my own university.</p><h4>Case 4: Shahinur Alam Jony</h4><p>Shahinur Alam Jony is an ex kuetian from the Dpartment of EEE, now working at Ericsson as a tech solutions senior manager. So far so good, but what’s problematic in his profile is when he claims to be have graduated from harvard. He too is a motivational guru just like Clint arthur whose business is through selling hopes. Though i don’t claim to be aware of his motives, unlike Arthur’s whose motive is totally business driven. My guess is that these are mostly narcissistic pursuits of his and a way to amend his academic shortfalls while he was pursuing his undergraduate at KUET.</p><p>It all started when a junior knocked me saying that he wants to invite Mr. Jony to host a session on higher studies at ivy leagues and other similarly reputed institutions, since he is the only kuetian to have earned the honour of graduating from Harvard and MIT. I knew of Mr. Jony before, since such a celebrity figure from my own university would be pretty hard to get by unnoticed. But i had my suspicions from the beginning, since his social media activities were not much convincing. His english usage, pronunciations were pretty poor for a Harvard or an MIT grad, and his insights were full of overused cliches and hackneyed phrases mostly used by motivational gurus. Also when i saw him celebrating the fact that Nikola Tesla was the founder of Alternating Current, while he himself being a EEE graduate, i couldn’t just take him seriously. But these were just merely personal hunches. I had no proof with me with which i could deter my juniors away from him. So i started to investigate and test my hunches. I started knocking Bangladeshi alumni at both unis only to find out that they have no clue of such a person in their database. I had another friend on board with me, my IEEE partner Pritom Mojumder who used his own channels to verify his presence at HBS graduate directory. But he too found nothing substantial. No one knew of such a graduate student. I started knocking registrars at MIT, HBS, MIT Sloan to check if they have their name in his directory. After countless mailing they affirmed me that a person with such a name did enrol in their programs but under non degree executive education course. He is in fact an alumni of MIT Sloan and HBS but not a graduate of the schools. Hence his name is not in the graduate or the ex-student directory.</p><p>Now Mr. Jony is just like any other motivational guru. He comes at local campuses, gives speeches, motivates students saying “ স্বপ্ন দেখ,চেষ্টা চালিয়ে যাও, হাল ছেড়ো না, কাজে নেমে যাও, আমি পেরেছি, তুমিও পারবে”, which basically translates to - if i can do it, so can you, you just have to give your 100%. No matter how much motivational it may seem, these are just bunch of overused cliches that motivational gurus use. When he was invited in our campus by the department of ECE, my friends who attended there told me how he snobbishly ridiculed our faculties claiming that their intensive academic dedication in undergraduate level couldn’t take them anywhere near to the level where Mr. Jony reached today. Mr. Jony had backlogs, used to read our teachers notes to pass exams. He says, “ And now now look at us. I am an Harvard and MIT grad working at ericsson and you are still stuck at the boundaries of KUET”. From this i previously concluded that his motive might be redemption and an ego drive. Something he could never find in kuet, but is trying hard to do so get. (<em>Or maybe he is just trying to establish his organization youthcarnival as a credible organization, who can tell</em>)</p><p>But getting into Harvard is not easy, at least it wasn’t for him. So what could be done! Because after all, to earn everyone’s reverence you need the H-bomb. To have this tag, Mr. Jony resorted to executive education program in Harvard Business School. Executive programs are not degree programs. They are non degree programs often online based, which are open enrolment programs where anyone with the right amount of admission fees and executive experiences can join. The programs can last from less than a week to several weeks. The programs are hugely expensive too ranging within thousands of dollars. Now given that it is a non degree program why should anyone join? Whats the takeaway? Execed providers like MIT Sloan or HBS will claim that it enhances a professional’s skills and boosts his career even further, whereas the real driving cause here is actually moneymaking. Execed courses are targeted towards industry professionals who are full with cash. Through execed courses the universities charge them a humongous sum of money in exchange of little insights and bragging rights. Most industry professionals and celebrities enrol in such programs to get the prestigious institution’s tag behind their back. Maria Sharapova, Ciara, Channing Tatum, Ll Cool, Ratan Tata, Julia Bishop etc wealth magnets are one of the target people whom Harvard tries to attract towards it’s execed program. And why not, as per BBC execed program brings harvard millions of dollars in revenue per year (132 million dollars which accounts to 14% of Harvard’s total revenue). Since the programs are relaxing, are okay with fragile commitment , lack rigour while generating such humongous chunks of money in the middle, no wonder universities jumped into selling their Brand name for a hefty price. It’s not just rich celebrities and industrial magnets that are attracted to it. The corporate elites are increasingly coming into these courses for networking purpose and career enhancement (or maybe just for showing off like sharapova, depending on the person). While it’s good to have certificate of completion from harvard to show off to people and flex on the alumni status that has been just granted to you, it might not be as useful to an employer on basis of utility. While the world might not know how easy it is get into executive program given you have a good executive work experience, unlike into degree programs where the acceptance rate is around 4.7% — an employer would not so easily be fooled. Sometimes employers fund or endorse such programs for its employees so that they can harness employee loyalty more than before and also brag on having harvard or MIT certified professional in their team.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20160725-smart-ways-to-get-harvard-on-your-cv?">Smart ways to get Harvard on your CV</a></p><p>Now looking at Mr. Jony’s linkedIn profile you can see that he has completed General Management Program, something that he and Sharapova both have gotten themselves enrolled into. Looking at the program you will see it is an expensive one, requiring 65,000$ for virtual and 73000$ for blended or on campus lessons, covering a total 10–15 weeks.</p><p>The only difference between Sharapova and Mr. Jony is that, Sharapova does not claim herself to be a Harvard Graduate, Mr. Jony does.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/738/1*vy9ggmfDvH6vqvGftUv61w.png" /></figure><p>Technically speaking, you cannot claim to be a graduate after completing a non degree, alumni status granting executive education course. It provides one with a certificate of completion, which is not equivalent to a degree and to claim yourself a graduate you need to have a degree from that institution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V5DG2vTTzVnsrFipVIC1HA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/763/1*xgp3Yx-eXwxbLQwINIM-oA.png" /></figure><p>When i was mailing through registrar offices, Mr Jony got aware of us that we were trying to verify him. MIT Sloan forwarded a mail to him asking for his permission if they could cooperate with us. Since then he has been claiming this to be unexpected and outrageous to our teachers, the people who he have been scamming all along. He claims that he never have claimed graduation from neither Harvard nor MIT. But if that was true, how was everyone deluded to believe that he was when his seminar took place at our campus premises? Most importantly, why does his facebook page still have the post of him claiming to have graduated from Harvard Business School, and even more astonishingly why is such a huge mistake his pinned post?</p><p>It’s not just the pinned post of him though. His whole facebook page is filled up with him selling his Harvard and MIT image.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/626/1*8KZwp9r1si6ClBptlUlfoA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/877/1*KXMgFbG1-JW04M1c6eUATg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/739/1*-aro8jUugr8DZDz70PqeYA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/738/1*C2djXFxrOgGm9pN_JXCeew.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/738/1*6C6MrdlfVLFZTZBNbPhY_w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/746/1*_lZuoMK229vdAP_L3qZsag.png" /></figure><p>Can you really blame people like my juniors for thinking him as an MIT and a Harvard graduate while he himself promulgates this through his social media channels?</p><p>Mr. Jony loves to present himself as a conqueror. He conquered MIT and Harvard both, a rare opportunity that very few Bangladeshis are bestowed with. But did he conquer tho?</p><p>Open enrollment executive education programs require nothing but money, and a good track record of executive work experience. So what was conquered here actually?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/628/1*UQQ9jtcBOoyzWkIWgMI0tw.png" /></figure><p>While there are actually a good number of Bangladeshis who in fact did conquer MIT and Harvard, navigated themselves through the challenges and got selected to pursue their degrees despite the rigorous selection process and 4.7% acceptance rate, Mr. Jony’s voice seem to be the loudest although he is not one of the actual “conqueror” bangladeshis. Doing executive education is not conquering neither challenging, but rather pursuing an ivy league fascination. Okay, so now you may argue, this is a news outlet who might have used unnecessary hyperboles to attract readers. But did they? Without his consent?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*Dc_mYdq0Agh-Yexi3gq1Kg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/626/1*AvLFpV0Un9rOl1L2tX3kjg.png" /></figure><p>It feels like this is a fantasy he himself prefers to dwell within rather than silly exaggeration by local journalists.</p><p>In Mr. Jony’s linkedIn Id, under his education section, it shows his affiliation with Harvard, Stanford, MIT, University of Michigan, University of California, Irvine, University of Melbourne, Copenhagen Business School. But in none of these universities did he undergo any degree program. LinkedIn has options to integrate non degree certifications underneath its education feature. The education part are supposed to be fully exclusive to degree programs only. Otherwise it confuses people. If an actual MIT Graduate integrates his MIT affiliation under his education section and so does Mr. Jony, how would you be able to differentiate?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KhkvuVt0kUGgwzG70g54vQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CgPiw_o1H7jRFn4QyxYgsg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ixxOHIC2D_3io7jBalfYRA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WcFkZlXD8RMu_eTRJgS_Sg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iZ7c8Ho_o4m2SVCmggGEig.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/981/1*b7p-ewEUX9-Y9cPh8pIfPg.png" /></figure><p>These are all collected from his linkedIn profile.</p><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jony-shahinur-alam-mit-and-harvard-alum-pmp-a023a09/">JONY SHAHINUR ALAM, MIT and Harvard Alum, PMP - Tech Solutions Snr Manager / Program Director - Ericsson | LinkedIn</a></p><p>Not just that look at his facebook bio.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/468/1*0jTYZnIcPwxhtyGvaAEtgw.png" /></figure><p>Imagine yourself doing a CS50 course from HarvardX and after completion you put in your bio that you studied at Harvard. It’s so easy right?</p><p>Sadly you can’t do that either. Harvard, MIT both explicitly state that while a non degree course can certainly grant you alumni status, it is in no way equivalent to any degree courses that are offered. Hence, no execed enroller can claim themselves to Harvard or MIT Graduates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gK_Q43Dp9D7fhq8_5VxCBg.png" /></figure><p>Gee i wonder why they would give the alumni rights though! Definitely not to use people like sharapova, ratan tata, charlie tatum in their alumni directory, right? Or give a tangible reward for the hideously large amount of money they are paying to the execed authorities, right? Or is it so?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*El05KAGwvhRTy-hLBdTazA.png" /></figure><p>Remember Julie Bishop? The Australian foreign minister who enrolled in an execed program? This is how Harvard uses its execed programs to affiliate themselves with rich industrialists, politicians, celebrities by granting them alumnus status apart from earning the millions of dollars coming along the way. It’s a win win situation. Harvard wins by earning affiliation of influential people. The influential people also get to be a part of the ivy league intellectuals. Or why else would they pay?</p><p>Now moving back to Mr. Jony, either he wants to deceive people which, apparently, he is pretty bad at, since the bundles of university affiliations already makes his educational section look pretty disingenuous or he is just blatantly ignorant and blinded by narcissism. Looking at his motivational videos, his hysteric repetitive posts, egotist and conquering image of the self it make me feel like that he is trying redeem himself from his not so successful past. He wants the validation from others which he craved for but never got. He wants applause from all that surpassed him in his school, college or in his university. He wants to display his worth so loudly that it doesn’t go unnoticed to those who were on the lead in his past life. Hence, as the MIT registrar told me, it’s not abnormal to see people amplifying their tenuous relationship with MIT. And it’s understandable since it earns them quick social points, deceive their employers or fit some other agenda</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tkbnelr-nFUzqA_Wu6os0w.png" /></figure><p>It might also be that he is trying to establish his organization youthcarnival as a motivational guru hub just as any other motivational guru does. But i don’t think that Mr. Jony is a bad guy, rather someone who just went psychotic in search for validation. Or maybe i am wrong, maybe he has other plans, which only he can say.</p><p>The prime example of insanity has to be Rashidul Bari from Bari Science Lab.</p><h4>Case no. 5: Rashidul Bari</h4><p>Rashidul Bari is an adjunct lecturer at Bronx Community College in the Mathematics department. His unhealthy obsession with academia had led him to lead a delusional life. He derides his countrymen, disparages them with an exalted view of dwelling in the intelligent west. Mr. Bari is not of the intelligent 1%. And therefore out of that grudge, he tries to push his little son, Soborno Isaac to the limit. He wants to achieve his intellectual validation from others through his son. His obsession with showing the world that his son is nothing short of a genius is extremely unhealthy and abusive towards the child. But Mr. Bari too lives in fantasy land. He adopts deception, amplifies polite gestures of high profile figures to fool his countrymen into believing that his 6 year old son got recognition from all of those highly respected figures.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F_20X96fdMWfytOe4YIX9g.png" /></figure><p>Reading above, anyone with a brain can easily infer that it is not Soborno, rather his father, who is trying to echo the ivy league fascination through his son’s name.</p><p>As for all the presidents, prime ministers, college professors, nobel laureates loving him, that should come of as no surprise. Anyone with a bit of empathy in them would show affection towards a child. And when a child does something out of the box (like puking up every symbols and equations his dad forced him to remember) anyone would cheer for him to inspire him even further, and that’s no big deal. No one, and definitely not Prime ministers or nobel laureates would try to be rational and destroy a child’s spirit saying things like, “You suck as shit kid, go play with your nintendo and let the big guys handle this”. On the other hand what happens is that, sometimes while many such important figures do reciprocate to maintain their courteous public image, some do not do that. And that’s when Mr. Bari gets frighteningly furious.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FtDo2AMnJMJQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DtDo2AMnJMJQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FtDo2AMnJMJQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/64430b5199795e53738ae35b23a21eef/href">https://medium.com/media/64430b5199795e53738ae35b23a21eef/href</a></iframe><p>This is what happens when a psycho doesn’t get the validation that he tries to scheme out or force out of other people. For them reciprocation and validation is the only craved thing, than actually doing it out of the love for it. So when that backfires, when people see through the scam, they get fired up. They get really really fired up. For example when he pestered NY Bengali Community with his son’s youtube video “I am muslim and i love america”, claiming it to be the best anti terrorism movie ever to be made, the community did not reciprocate much. His response was that Bangladeshi community is a taxi driver community, for which they weren’t able to recognize his son’s accomplishments.</p><p>Just check his breakdown.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FLkERhdWZPCE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DLkERhdWZPCE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FLkERhdWZPCE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/55f077e5a80f3f2828e7064cf206cb46/href">https://medium.com/media/55f077e5a80f3f2828e7064cf206cb46/href</a></iframe><p>In another of his meltdown video, he freaks out over the fact that someone somewhere had undermined his son’s genius (or in other words, Mr. Bari’s carefully crafted genius image of his son). It sucks to see you life’s work get ridiculed like that, doesn’t it?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FFm9VUBOjsqA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DFm9VUBOjsqA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FFm9VUBOjsqA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/eb3b6a52a3ff463fb2d991938dda26b5/href">https://medium.com/media/eb3b6a52a3ff463fb2d991938dda26b5/href</a></iframe><p>In another video, Rashidul Bari, upon knowing that he and his son has son has been turned into a subject of meme in Bangladeshi cyberspace, he goes into explosive rants against Bangladeshi youngsters whom he asks to leave degeneracy and pick up the pen. He asks them to level up and follow his 6 year old son’s footsteps to achieve intellectual sainthood and be a worthy human. He probably deleted the video after the video got them memed even more. If i stumble upon it sooner or later i will attach it below. I am just too tired of stalking the person at this point.</p><p>Rashidul Bari is a product of the hyperproductive craze of the current world. He doesn’t understand the nuances, but nevertheless wants to be a part of it. He wants to be among the 1%, he believes in the american dream. He believes that through working, working and working he can reach the level of nobel laureates someday. Well, but he is aging. So i guess his son can follow his father’s dreams. But a child isn’t born with such ambitious projects in mind. It has to be inserted in, and of course by who else, other than people like Mr. Rashidul Bari.</p><p>Below is a video of his son which claims that he loves to study at spare times.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F5xuU1qnWat4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D5xuU1qnWat4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F5xuU1qnWat4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e08b6d526637b1f95434100257ef06dc/href">https://medium.com/media/e08b6d526637b1f95434100257ef06dc/href</a></iframe><p>Not just that, he loves to solve maths while in the middle of eid prayers too…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*uepXwBuWzlkEIZgx.jpg" /></figure><p>This is not normal. This is child abuse. Unless these are camera stunts of course. But i would like to think that these are in fact Rashidul Bari’s carefully crafted dramas to show his family as hyperproductive and as a global asset.</p><p>What’s even more funny is that, Bari take his brilliance craze to a next level. In every video on his channel, he includes “Sponsored by Brilliant”, which is in fact, a lie. The reason to include brilliant is that, it heightens up his credibility. Brilliant is an app to develop mathematical aptitude. The company sponsors it’s app through many scientific and educational channel. I was surprised to see brilliant sponsoring a psychopath with no substance in his channel. But then i found out, it was just Mr. Bari making things on the go.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mv7g82ieS1U_flBrBkif5w.png" /></figure><p>Hmm, seems suspicious that brilliant would sponsor a channel who can’t even get their url right.</p><p>This is brilliant’s website in case you were wondering→</p><p><a href="https://brilliant.org/">Brilliant | Learn by doing</a></p><p>And this is how an actual brilliant sponsorship looks like under a channel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uccrAgRPQKDQm5NjpN79QA.png" /></figure><p>This is so stupid, it legit cracked me up when i first saw this. But Mr. Bari has the desire to appropriate every single brainiac thing to fit his genius narrative.</p><p>But what caught my interest is that Rashidul Bari plays the Ms. West’s H-Bomb (Harvard Bomb) technique too. But unlike Ms. west who just faked her harvard speech by the help of motivational guru Clint Arthur, Rashidul Bari faked Harvard recognition by a courteous reply from Harvard’s 28th president Drew Gilpin Faust. You can get one for you offspring too, by exaggerating their credentials and asking for validation through mail. No one, and definitely not a harvard president would be so rude as to not give a courteous reply to a highly aspiring and desperate validation seeker. Same thing happened with Obama, who too gave a courteous inspiring feedback to his son’s works. But Mr. Bari used them to portray as they were recognition letters.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F9LZASY8opp8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D9LZASY8opp8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F9LZASY8opp8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b641563258d3f1bf6e61e8c824df5a53/href">https://medium.com/media/b641563258d3f1bf6e61e8c824df5a53/href</a></iframe><p>Rashidul bari worked as a security guard for 15 years. He then earned a shot at being a college teacher in his locality (which is pretty impressive, gotta admit). He too has motivational videos like Mr Shahinur Alam Jony who too had not so much of a successful past. Both have videos with egoistic captions. These inflating ego makes them blind, gives them a sense of meritocracy and to part of the meritocracy, often time they fool, mislead or delude people, just to feed in their ego.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FBYVb-6z9jEM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DBYVb-6z9jEM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FBYVb-6z9jEM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b83d24cb0fbbb63640372536ed32d957/href">https://medium.com/media/b83d24cb0fbbb63640372536ed32d957/href</a></iframe><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F_RH4_esPzCA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D_RH4_esPzCA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F_RH4_esPzCA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/37d8eb51bf61a1312fc3627862a14561/href">https://medium.com/media/37d8eb51bf61a1312fc3627862a14561/href</a></iframe><p>Don’t both of these two videos, from two different have have a strikingly eerie resemblance?</p><p>Yes, both are vendors of glittery dreams and are on an inflated ego drive. Both feel that they have been done injustice to and now they have won. They have won, and the fact that they did win at the end, has to be validated. They need loud acclamations from their peers, something they never had the privilege to have before. To me, it’s just their insecurities and a crave for long-wanted attention that makes them act like this.</p><p>Mr. Bari is not a professor. He is an mathematics teacher. But his clickbaity title does imply otherwise. He loves to claim his son is youngest american professor, a visiting professor per se, which is an equally delusional claim. He desperately wants to portray his child as a child prodigy, which for a fact, he is not. A child prodigy won’t be able to earn professorship at the age of 6 years let alone solve PhD problems. Best they can do is skip some grades for being a little more advanced than others. It’s easy to understand why Mr. Bari’s 6 year old son is not a prodigy. Having a child prodigy is not a desirable thing for parents. Most parents with prodigy children want their children to become normal just like other kids. Because maintaining a child prodigy is extremely hard. They suffer from severe psychological and cognitive issues. Most are socially awkward, and don’t get along with people very well. They are also a subject to jealousy for other parents — a reason for which the parents of prodigy children often try to hide the fact their child is in fact quite advanced than others. In an article by the Economist, “ The curse of genius”, the author articulately explains why having a genius child is sometimes an extremely burdensome thing.</p><p><a href="https://www.economist.com/1843/2019/04/29/the-curse-of-genius">The curse of genius</a></p><p>It’s just the insecure ones like Mr. Bari who try to feed their insecurities by exaggerating or confabulating their children’s image towards others.</p><p>Fun fact: the Unabomber/ Ted Kaczynski was a child prodigy too.</p><p>The obsessive belief in meritocracy is one of the driving factor for people like Mr. Jony and Mr. Bari to go crazy. Mr Bari has severe disdain for people who are in the low profile, low educated demography although he himself was a part of it for 15 years. He believes in an utterly meritocratic world, looking down upon the poor and unfortunate. His endless rants against bangladeshis whom he remark as “Taxi driver community”, his rants against hero alam, memers and countless other endless rants only prove his stick adherence to meritocracy. But this unhealthy obsession with meritocracy is not only delusional but also problematic. First of all meritocracy is myth. A lot of privilege factors work in building a meritocratic individual. Luck, Environment, Nurture, Race, Affirmative actions, Family and Friends, acquaintances etc. which are not equally distributed among every individual. But a person who strictly adheres to the concept of meritocracy tends to overlook these nuances and feel like others are lazy compared to him for which he is more deserving than others. This endorses them to uphold the status quo even if it might be wrong and exploitative. This also kills empathies and makes people more selfish, discriminatory, scornful, less cooperative, less willing to share or even pull others to success. Clifton Mark highlights this issue even more briefly.</p><p><a href="https://aeon.co/ideas/a-belief-in-meritocracy-is-not-only-false-its-bad-for-you">A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it&#39;s bad for you - Clifton Mark | Aeon Ideas</a></p><p>Neither Bari or the aforementioned people know such nuances. Hence they live in their fantasies and try to bring others along the way to clap and live in their fantasy stories.</p><p>So what’s the takeaway from all of this? Am i presenting a case against academia? or against productivity?</p><p>No, i am not trying to deter anyone from pursuing either. In fact i am keen on pursuing a PhD myself sooner or later on a specialised topic in my field. And i know that being a lazy sloth wouldn’t definitely get me there. I am in fact trying to plan out ways so that i may have some financial backups before pursuing them so that i don’t have to completely depend upon the professor and get some independence on my hand. (<em>also so that i don’t need to worry about living on noodles and pizzas, lol</em>).</p><p>Through this article, I am just trying to put up case against hyperproductive hustle culture and how people unconsciously stress themselves out over things which are harmful for their psyche and their lifestyle. It’s good to be productive but it equally helps to keep your psyche in check and make time for families and friends. When we are in family programs, or hanging with friends if we are constantly riddled with the thoughts that we are not being productive it doesn’t help more than it does harm. While anxiety does help, it sometimes backfires. A state of constant anxiety and stress reduces performance level and kills cognitive ability. It also hampers any other trivial creative pursuits, as <em>Russell </em>says, and shortens our domain to a confined boundary. Burn out phases aren’t helpful and we need to stop glorifying burnout culture. We also need to stop passively shaming ourselves which eventually others vicariously follow for not being stressed and anxious enough. A balance between work and life can be achieved without having to face insidious repercussions. Because ultimately , hyperproductivity, best employee culture is just for the corporation’s benefit and for the sake of unfettered capitalism. It has very little to do with you. Just learn to know that you are being exploited.</p><p>We need to stop our obsessive adherence to meritocracy too and blind worship culture. A ticket to MIT or Harvard is not a ticket to sainthood. We need to focus on the substance and individual provides than his fancy tags. Because ignoring substance over fancy tags is how the world plunges into mediocrity. It creates room for scammers, fake gurus, narcissists, trolls, abusive parents and who not. In the end what matters is what you actually learned, and how are you implementing them, and not the embellishments that adorn you.</p><p>Oh and how could i forget!</p><p>Fuck linkedIn and other rat race, phoniness, inauthenticity, promoters. It would really suck to see the world turning into a real life nosedive episode from black mirror.</p><p>AND TO THOSE DROPPING H-BOMBS…</p><p>STOP BEING A FAKE A FRAUD!</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIyee5Xm20WA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIyee5Xm20WA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIyee5Xm20WA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6a4cce4a31aa2f24cdac72f76f7723cf/href">https://medium.com/media/6a4cce4a31aa2f24cdac72f76f7723cf/href</a></iframe><p><em>Thank you for your patience.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc21f482aa30" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tree Lives Matter: A systematic study on the impact of long term quarantine on human intelligence]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/tree-lives-matter-a-systematic-study-on-the-impact-of-long-term-quarantine-on-human-intelligence-eb2552aed823?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eb2552aed823</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Aug 2020 21:21:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-31T06:27:26.085Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A satirical investigation jointly authored by: Fathun Karim &amp; Taif Bin Ahmed Anim</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*C6RpFr8v7lb78GDp.jpg" /><figcaption>Source: Bdnews24.com</figcaption></figure><h4>Abstract</h4><p>Even amidst the global pandemic protests seem to be in the air . The death of George Floyd has sparked massive outrage and rioting in the United States but today we will not be looking at that, we will be looking at a protest that is much closer to our beloved soil. The protesters in the US resurrected the Black Lives Matter movement once again in the light of recent police brutality and here in our country we too are not willing to be left behind. But racism was never an issue for our country, in fact being racist was considered to be healthy and normal, so a Black Lives Matter would only generate confusing stares from the masses, so a local approach had to be taken. Upon knowing this, the CEO of outrage got into immediate action and ordered his employees to bring back an issue from the past; A protest which died years ago but rose once again from the ashes like a phoenix . Yes, if you are already guessing you would be guessing right, we are talking about the Metro Rail protest .The protest began in 2016 but took a backseat after other issues were brought up . But the Academy of TSC went into a hiatus after the scholars of TSC got tempted into tons of other side projects and also in the starvation Olympics. But with the quarantine happening and lack of recreational chemicals all over the academy, the ghost of the past came back to haunt once again. In this article we hope to dive into the world of the TSC Scholars and analyze the dynamics of the resurrected movement as a whole.</p><h4>Introduction</h4><p>First of all, The Trees: If you have mistakenly wandered off to the heart of the Oxford of east uncommonly known as Dhaka University, you probably visited this legendary area named TSC. Apparently this place is supposed to be Teachers’ and Students’ Center but there are hardly ever any teachers seen in this place. This place is most suited for probably enjoying some time with someone you are surely going to dump in the next month and to purchase herbal remedies and pharmaceutical items. The most common thing to see here is probably humans wearing huge sniper targets on their head. If our reports were correct most of these humans were female. Anyways, if you can divert your attention from all the great sources of interesting human behavior around then you will get to notice there are so many trees in the proximity. These are not just great but most of these trees are old too. The trees mark the age old saga happening around DU all over the year. They are the witness of decades of chaos, riots and friendly fights among the wide variant of scholarly groups of the TSC Academia. If the trees are indeed chopped off, the essence of all these commotions, the monuments of the valiant/scholarly spirits will be uprooted along with the physical trees themselves.</p><p>At this point, you may be wondering why we are bringing up trees and what’s the point of writing this. Don’t get us wrong we love our stationary chlorophyll containing friends. After all, it may be beyond the comprehension of our general readers, but from the findings from the last TSC Proceedings, we came to learn that trees produce Di Oxygen Mono Nothing. It was a remarkable discovery indeed which is yet to cross the border and illuminate the west, but the news has already broken out among the local peers. Another vital study from the proceedings found out that trees can assist with sanitary facilities. Human urine and feces are filled with the vital nutrients for trees. The trees at TSC have therefore evolved to attract humans to pee and defecate on them, which in turn also benefits the human, how you may ask. Well, again a group of TSC scholars dived into the issue and found out that holding your urine may cause bladder damage, urinary tract infection and also can lead to kidney stone formation.</p><p>After the proceeding was published the TSC servers were reported to be overflowed with traffic. The people were illuminated, especially the local scientific peers. Multiple counts of people hugging and cuddling trees at TSC for hours long were spotted and reported in the national dailies. Many were reported to have performed some novel physical rituals with the trees. The Academy have categorized these new specimens as “ Homo Sheikhmujibi Ecosexualis”. But recent development at metro rail has put the novel species under threat of extinction due to their shrinking habitats. The over aware local crowds and scholars therefore came forward to protest the cutting down of trees and preserving the local ecosystem of the TSC area. Thus the last issue of the TSC proceedings helped in shaping public awareness, and instigated a massive movement against the metro rail project of the government</p><h4><strong>The Scholarly Commandments</strong></h4><p>After months of surveys, a research team accumulated the most prominent arguments against the project and published the data in TSC Open Access. Analyzing the sentiments we find out the reasons for protests as such:</p><ol><li>The trees!!!!!!!!!!!!</li></ol><p>2. Sound Pollution from the Metro Rail.</p><p>3. Vibrations</p><p>4. Massive crowding.</p><p>7. Overflowing DMC patients</p><p>8. Indifference to alternate route selection/station selection</p><p>9. Damage to cultural heritage.</p><p>10. No other uni in any part of the world would have allowed such a structure to go above them.</p><p>11. The Air Force didn’t allow a route near their borders, why should DU?</p><p>12. Invasive gang weeder species which may pose a threat to the local ecosystem.</p><p>13. Price hike of cancer curing medicines, due to escalated demand.</p><p>14. Less public coochies.</p><p>For the points number 12,13 and 14 we can share nothing but sympathies for our notable scholars. This touches us all, and if you fail to feel any empathy, please reconsider your humanity.</p><p>For the rest of the points though, let’s take a deep dive into the issues presented by our notable scholars and check the amount of veggies required to produce such ephemeral wisdom.</p><p><strong>Note: Most of the issues raised here are addressed by using the official reports.If further info is required contact NKDM ,who conducted the EIA surveys .</strong></p><p>Point Number 1:</p><p>Though how bad of a news it may strike to the heart of Team Greta, to our notable scholars of TSC, and also lets not forget the local birds, chopping trees might prove to be necessary for a project to be completed. If a tree gets into the way of a construction site, it’s quite normal to get rid of it. During road construction, building construction, railway constructions even, trees need to be cleared. If you want to create a civil construction, you have to sacrifice some trees that come in the way. We cannot expect to preserve the amazon while willing to create a Manhattan within its perimeter. Unless we can go to a cyberpunk future, with elevated skyscrapers and elevated roadways, which can leave the rain forests stay at their place underneath in peace. We do not Know if that could be turned into a reality, since the trees would die out anyway due to low sunlight but hey who am I to presume the course of science.</p><p>But since we are not living in such a Utopian commune, we are required to come to terms with the basic facts of civil construction, that it requires some trees in the construction site to be sacrificed. But the annoying thing is that our scholars are very choosy when picking up the trees to fight for. The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA Report) of the project has already mentioned the number of trees to be cut in total, along with every minute detail of all of them. The categorizations have been done too. Every tree was analyzed, categorized and presented in the report along with their size, location in the Right of Way, scientific name, local name, common name, types (if they are fruit yielding, timber yielding, ornamental, medicinal or other) etc. The owners of the trees are also noted, who are PWD, DCC and The parliament house. Here is a quick summary on the number of trees, collected from the “<a href="https://dmtcl.portal.gov.bd/sites/default/files/files/dmtcl.portal.gov.bd/page/138715e9_9963_4a57_8618_a4409055260f/RAP-II-Complete-Document.pdf"><strong>RESETTLEMENT ACTION PLAN-II (RAP-II) FOR MRT LINE-6 EXCEPT DEPOT AREA</strong></a>” report.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*4wt73lyZM4FUwt-Q" /></figure><p>For further intricate details on the trees, you can check the original survey from the <a href="https://dmtcl.portal.gov.bd/sites/default/files/files/dmtcl.portal.gov.bd/page/1420da79_44dd_4209_80d2_49f4d41f22e2/Final%20EIA_20160121.pdf">EIA reports</a> which lays out all the information in a a far detailed way. A glimpse of the descriptive survey is hereby presented,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*pDpWgmQSrWeFCn0_" /></figure><p>We are mentioning all this just to prove the point that the project officials have done their homework and assessed all possible impacts on the vegetation to carry out the gigantic project. These fall under unavoidable losses of the whole project. Not just the trees, the company NKDM had assessed flora and fauna populations both, which may be hampered due to the project. The birds, the aquatic animals, the amphibians, and ecosystem as a whole. They did not find the metro project to be conflicting or disrupting any protected ecological place, plant or animal species or others. Most bird populations that might get affected, are expected to migrate into nearby vegetation sites. Mitigation to ecological damage also has been proposed in the report, which includes re-plantation near the project sites. The trees that would suit best for re-plantation purpose have also been researched and cataloged.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*-BUNCXm1YN7HJ0_Z" /></figure><p>A lot of work went towards assessing the damage and probable mitigating measles for them. Developing a sustainable project model is a vital aspect for a project and for the Metro Rail Project it had already been done years and years ago. But our scholars haven’t done their homework, so we can’t blame them well enough. For once, they don’t know anything about unavoidable ecological losses in a mega-project, neither do they know about the mitigating measures which are proposed for damage control. But somehow, in the mind of our scholars, trimming the handful of trees that are hanging over the project site is more destructive than opposing a billion dollar mega-project which would serve a wider purpose for the millions of city dwellers.</p><p>In fact, the alternate routes that have been pondered by the project officials include even much more trees, vegetation which are also protected under the environmental act of Bangladesh. One of the driving factors for not choosing the alternative was the ecological consequences that might have followed. So are our notable scholars pro-environment or actually anti-environment? We can bet that they don’t know any of the consequences of their demand as well. Or maybe they are just acting in self interest. So why should the government care about the interest of fringe people over the interest of the nation as a whole? The alternate route and it’s probable consequences can also be found in the EIA report.</p><p>So we can safely assume that the weed is strong on this one.</p><p><strong>Moving on — → Noise:</strong></p><p>This could be a legit concern because a non interrupting environment is indeed needed for a sound educational atmosphere. But, to the dismay of our fellow scholars, the EIA report already has worked that out too. The report extensively highlights the problems that might be associated with the noise generating from site construction to railway operation. It includes the models followed to determine noise levels and the necessary mathematics to quantify the problem as a whole. It also proposes mitigation plans to sort out the problems that may arise. The team first took the ambient noise measurements of the areas. Then they proceeded towards calculating the probable noise generation due to operation. They compared it to the ambient noise and the standard ambient noise. If they didn’t match, they moved towards mitigatory measures. As DoE didn’t have the detail particulars, the company adopted MoE, which is the Japanese standard for noise regulations in railway operations. Now the funny thing is, the MoE indicates that the equivalent continuous sound pressure level should be around 60 dB during day time and 55 during night time. But the existing noise levels near Bangla Academy, which is 78 dB at daytime and 68 at night time already surpasses the standard condition to a considerable amount. We assume, thats something our scholars are unaware of since we never saw them go on mass processions to keep the noise level in check before like we are doing now. But to give them a benefit let’s assume that the metro rail will cause the noise level to rise astronomically high. But then again, such an assumption falls to the ground once the report is gone through. The calculations to predict the noise level clearly indicates that the additional noise contribution from the metro to the surroundings would not be significant. The Du region would see 0.5% increase in peak ambience conditions near public library and TSC areas. The reason for considering peak increase in ambience is to imagine the worst case scenario, at times when activity is the most and the ambience remains at highest value(7 am to 7 pm). Now the 0.5% to the already existing noise level isn’t something to make such a huge fuss about, otherwise, we would have seen larger protests regarding the existing problem before. Now to add to the inconvenience of our respectable researchers, the company had laid out plans to even curb out the noise impact that might follow the rail operation. Here’s a flowchart taken from the report,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*dBJCBC9Tt0EDXhoO" /></figure><p>If you take a further read on the report you can find more mathematical and statistical detail upon which they draw their conclusions from. Jumping into section 5 you will see a brief picture of the ambient noise scenario, and in section 6 a detailed picture of combined noise prediction through metro operation and construction operation. Now we encourage our readers to look up to the report, so we won’t be going through the details, but just the highlights.</p><p>On another interesting note, our fellow researchers held an online meeting on 7th June, from their journal’s official Facebook page. One of the academics pointed out that in the proximity of 20 meter radius of the railway track lie the most prolific research labs of DU, coming up with scientific breakthroughs now and then. From her perspective, being in a 20 meter radius made it very dangerous for the labs to operate so productively as it is doing now and implying that a lab renovation would not be possible, since it wasn’t constructed keeping renovations in mind. But she threw a boomerang at the project if you check closely which is only to hit her back. The MoE standards lay out the safe distance from the rail tract to noise receptors at a 12.5 meter distance. So when our honorable academic argued that 20 meters is an alarming distance she is either discarding engineering standards or she is just ignorant. But as a rule of thumb we know TSC Scholars can never be ignorant, so we are assuming that a groundbreaking engineering discovery awaits us all, which would destroy all traditional engineering standards like a tropical cyclone.</p><p>Then the report also provides compensating propositions. The principle mitigation measure includes the usage of Vibration proof track (MSS cushions) and noise barriers. A total of 5868 meters of MSS is to be installed among which Dhaka University will get its fair share, as per the report. For further noise reduction, noise barriers are to be provided alongside the entire alignment. The report indicates a total of 138 meters of parapet noise barrier of 1.5 height to be installed at the university area. The measures are taken as per the industrial standards along with some extra steps for further remedial purposes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*ywxJ-A4i6gs2Eq78" /></figure><p>So, let’s analyze, The weed here is quite cheap which is deteriorating our scholar’s reading comprehensibility.</p><p><strong>Moving on — → Vibration:</strong></p><p>Again the report intensively studies this problem. The logic was that vibrations arising from the transit operations would meddle with the scientific research and can cause property damage. Let’s analyze this claim.</p><p>The transit operations are supposed to have significant vibrational problems compared to viaduct construction. So keeping this in mind, the report further progresses to quantify the impact and to address it in full. The Japanese method established by TOEI has been adopted to study the vibrational phenomena that might be incorporated with transit operations. Among all the country standards, the Japanese standard for vibration regulation is taken into account to act as the standardization index for designing the routes of the railway track. The reasoning behind it is that the Japanese criteria is the most strict than any other, and the company is trying to design the routes according to the strictest measures as possible, to keep the plan out of any probable loophole. The Japanese criteria even comes in two categories, among which the even more stricter one is taken into account which is 60 VdB or in other words, approximately 1.4 mm/sec of peak particle velocity.</p><p>The curvatures create the larger vibrations, hence 200m curves, and 400m curves were separately studied and appropriate measures have been suggested with respect to the VdB levels that would be accompanied. The critical distance of 12.5 m was taken into consideration as per the Japanese standard. And it was found that not a significant increase in VdB would be observed than the standard one. In the pier face, it was found to be a little bit exceeding but let’s face it, there is no structure which lie in the pier face. In fact most of the structures are situated beyond the standard distance that is 12.5 meter, lying in around 20m or 30m at distance. The VdB already meets the standard, which is 57.5 for ballast less track, 49.9 for Vibration proof track in case of 200m radius; 60.8 VdB for ballast less and 53.2 for vibration proof track in case of 400m radius; 59.4 VdB for ballast less and 51.8 VdB for vibration proof track. Now as we see, the strictest standards are met, in terms of vibration for 12.5 distance from the piers. But, on the brighter side, not a single structure in the university area lies within such a little distance, the closest one was Dhaka Gate which lies at 14.5m distance, but still that crosses the standard threshold. The rest lie at 24 to 55m distance which far exceeds the standard one. So we can easily assume the vibration won’t affect our scholars’ privacy at any cost. In fact Dhaka Gate was treated as a special case, and to protect it’s fragile structure, the piers have been modified to be installed at no less than 15m of distance and also the plan includes Vibration proof (MSS cushion) tract to further decrease the VdB below the standard VdB level.</p><p>Now, the engineers and planners have done their homework, but our scholars were too busy in discovering scientific breakthroughs in their pollution free labs, and getting pissed at the thought of metro rail demolishing down their research environment through vibration (Just Like our former minister, who accused the opposition party to have demolished Rana Plaza by shaking and vibrating the structure). They were so busy with scientific concerns and the bleak future that they forgot to take a look at what they were raising questions about. It’s understandable, doing science and experiments really takes a toll on now, something planners and engineers have never done and therefore, would never understand. Our utmost sympathies!!!</p><p>The weed here is diagnosed to be cheap too. It is having similar adverse effects like it did in case of noise.</p><p><strong>Moving on — → Overcrowding.</strong></p><p>Now, the university area never ran out of crowds. TSC is one of the most crowded places of Dhaka University. Almost all the roads are open to public usage, except for heavy vehicles like buses and trucks. But the scholars have decided that any existing crowding condition can be tolerated, considered a part of DU heritage, but additional crowds due to metro operations can in no way be tolerated. The logic behind this is diverse. Firstly, the crowd would spoil the beautiful ambient environment of DU. Then there would be many non local crowds who would only come looking for trouble, harass the students, rob them in streets, tease the girls in public and practice all sorts of criminal behavior alike. Also, littering would increase. Another crowd that the students raised their concerns are on the hawkers and cart vendors. Now DU already has a good share of its hawkers and cart businesses in it’s roadsides and recreational zones. And it is not seen as too big of a deal. And a station wouldn’t bring a wave of hundreds of new hawkers and cart sellers in that area because of the already existing market conditions. Sneaking in and thriving into an already existing market is quite a tough challenge unless adequate business scopes are present. The existing cart vendors could grab the market due to leisure spending of the students and consequentially, a demand on their take away products. But the transit users are commuters. They would be on the move, and won’t intuitively spend an hour or a half for recreational purposes in the campus area. The place where the vendors can actually have a chance with the commuters is where they would gather up, that is on the station platform where they would wait a few times for the train to arrive. But the stations are elevated and are far above the ground. So how can it pose threat to the streets, like turning the footpaths into mini markets? Therefore, the commuters vs vendors scenario at the campus roads is actually debatable. Or else we would have observed overcrowded itinerant vendors in all public stoppages. Markets can’t just grow out of the blue unless a favourable condition exists. Also, upon request adequate traffic policing can repel the sellers out of the station platform. So, controlling this part of the problem is actually a solvable administrative problem. Also most of the students who would use the station would be DU students. So technically ‘extra’ people should not astronomically concern anyone. In the report, it does assert that some pedestrians may increase in the station proximities. But the study did not find the project to fail to accommodate them. Also plans to renovate the streets, footpaths have been submitted to DMTC for better pedestrian management. But considering the fact that no student wing went into massive protests to dispel out the temporary businesses at TSC and nearby areas especially, and also in other DU corners speaks volume and indicates how artificial of an outrage it is.</p><p>Then another concern raised was that the extra “crowds” would be aggressors. They would sexually harass the female students of DU and rob the innocent children on the streets. Now this is a really far fetched tin foil hat claim. It assumes that commuters are usually robbers, hijackers and sexual aggressors. But in the end, the students themselves are commuters too. Would they like to share the tag of aggressors as well? And also, why would aggressors and snatchers need to travel so long from their locality to the campus area to safely practice their criminal activities. It just doesn’t make any sense. If it really was the case, then they wouldn’t require metro rail to do that. The commutation options are already open for everyone through the campus. Therefore, how metro rail can play such a big magic in commuting new waves of robbers and aggressors whereas ground commutation can’t is open to scholarly debate.</p><p><strong>Moving on — -&gt; Overflowing DMC Patients.</strong></p><p>Though we used this here satirically, based on the concern raised by one of our fellow correspondents. But this is actually something which even further solidifies the ground of the metro project. Transporting patients needs to be fast and immediate. Or people can die. So, a country’s government can’t just prioritize the sentiment of salty university students over the average citizen’s health condition, can they?</p><p><strong>Moving on — → Alternate routes:</strong></p><p>Hate to break it to you pal, but this has been assessed far before the scholars even raised their concerns. It’s not like the company gets paid for nothing. They did “No Build “surveys, tested alternative routings economically, socially, environmentally and technically. The optimum design that was selected is what our scholars are bitching about at the present. Now changing the route would have brought more inconvenience to the project. The optimization cannot be achieved in other routes. Now if some of our radical scholars say that “down with metro rail”, which one of them actually did in one of the journal’s forums, that would be pointless as well. Because, a “No build” alternative has been assessed too. It was found out that the traffic speed would decrease on average 2.8 km/hr by the year 2025. But with the metro project up and running, the average speed would rise up to 7.6 km/hr. Also the traffic demand forecast indicates that the traffic would increase 3 times in the metropolitan with respect to 2009 when the survey was conducted. This requires a strategic structure to manage. Therefore the “No Build” alternative was counted out. <a href="https://libportal.jica.go.jp/library/Data/DocforEnvironment/Reports/EastAsia-SouthwesternAsian/DhakaMRT/DhakaMRTReport.pdf">Click </a>to navigate to the source.</p><p>Now for alternate routes, the study found out that it would have required depot installation in the city park area. This would have led to a great irreparable damage to Shishu Park. The park area would be drastically reduced and a great deal of trees would be needed to chop down. Now, Shishu Park is a national concern unlike DU, where the students themselves are divided. So, damaging a nationally protected children’s recreational center which has been around for ages, could generate national contempt. Also technically this was a poor choice, since the usable land area for the depot installation at the Shishu Park is very little compared to Suhrawardy Udyan where it is located now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*uvCZCvGr2CdBLX4D" /></figure><p>Just like rousting which are selected on the basis on traffic demography and technical, economical, environmental optimization, station locations are selected on the optimization scale too. Station locations are based on focal city activities, traffic nodes, physical conditions (elevated road, geology, groundwater, etc.), accessibility protection from flooding and escape in an emergency. <a href="http://jica.go.jp/english/our_work/social_environmental/id/asia/south/bangladesh/c8h0vm0000bs3qxe-att/c8h0vm0000bs3r0e.pdf">Source</a></p><p>Also, minimizing traffic congestion is another concern. Putting a station in a heavily busy Shahbag intersection could cause traffic disruption below the tracts due to increased pedestrian movements. The alternative could be to push some steps forward within the technical limit, which it did, to the next traffic node, that is TSC arena. There could be a good lot of other reasons too, which the planners would know better. But the consultancy firm from which our scholars collect their data and gather their spirits from are from the humanities department of different local universities. Never were they seen to interview or discuss the issues with the planners and engineers who were the brain behind all of these. But we understand their sentiment, you gotta be aware of your peers. How can the east’s oxford grads pay heed to stupid engineers who couldn’t even fight and win their chance to study at DU. Plebs shouldn’t be paid attention to in any way.</p><p>So, bottom line, don’t ask for the boof from the wrong group of people. Know thy commie peers!!!</p><p><strong>Moving on — →Heritage destruction:</strong></p><p>She also went on highlighting the fact that DU is a living museum of our country’s liberation and therefore, a very important cultural heritage whose landscape is illegal to alter. While it is true that some of the structures are officially protected as cultural heritage sites, it’s equally true that the project is imposing no threat to them. As per the law, (on par to the UNESCO standard) rural or suburban heritage should have 0.5 miles radius free from any structure or construction. But, for metropolitan areas, the rule is to keep the buffer zone free from any construction which is at least 3 meters in width from the structure in consideration. Now our honorable scholar mentions the buffer zone to be 200 square meters which is outright wrong. Her data is low with respect to suburban heritage structure, and too big for urban heritage structures. You can fact check the data by clicking on this <a href="https://law.resource.org/pub/bd/bnbc.2012/gov.bd.bnbc.2012.09.03.pdf">link</a> (para 3.4.6.4). For the hundred heritage sites that are protected you can follow up daily star’s <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news-detail-74498">article </a>on this and check if actually any of the heritage sites fall under the 3 meter buffer zone. It doesn’t. The report exclusively states the fact that upon surveying, the current route was found not to lie in conflict with any historical heritage sites of Dhaka and was completely clean on that.</p><p><strong>Moving on — -&gt; Comparison to foreign universities.</strong></p><p>There are lots of universities which have metro operations around them. And also if there is no instance of any university hampering development works for national cause if the necessary guidelines are followed. As, the project report clearly specifies that all the guidelines are maintained and well satisfied, then on what basis can the opposition come from. In no way any well reputed foreign university would be so dumb to fight that, but even if they did they would be wrong and legally lose.</p><p><strong>Moving on — — → The case surrounding Air Force</strong></p><p>Most of our honourable scholars are pretty mad over the fact that the government does not treat them and the military equally. In this century of globalisation, where celebrities like John lenon advocated for a “no border, no countries” sentiment, what is the use of militaries? Militaries bring forth war, violence and million dollar budget war films. But our notable scholars ask for peace and prosperity. Clearly both are not on the same level. So, if the Military gets one tenth of a pie, the rest portion of course mathematically should go to DU.</p><p>But our government is turning their back on DU grads. As one scholar put out, the air chief had pressured the PM and administrative authorities of metro rail to change the route of the metro project despite the former plan being more convenient than the current one, the changed one. So, if the government acknowledged the troubling request of the Air Force, why can’t they listen to the sensible request of the university students! The reasoning of our scholar was that the route was chosen to satisfy the needs of political leaders. So that they can conveniently gather in suhrawardy udyan for their political assemblies. They would be needing to park their cars comfortably in Shishu Park Arena, and also travel from Uttara to Shahbag via metro. Also they need their children to play in Shishu Park while they are attending the political assemblies in Suhrawardy Udyan. Our honourable scholar termed this political selfishness as “DSS” or “Digital Singapore Syndrome”. And due to DSS, the route had to be reconstructed to the current one, although the current one is far more inconvenient.</p><p>But the DSS Theory also doesn’t hold any coherence as our reporters have found out. The problem with this theory starts with the Air Force. No matter how much pissed off our scholars may be for not receiving the same privilege as of the militaries, but the journal of commonsense states that, highly experienced military administratives would be far more knowledgeable on military affairs than a young adolescent angry university student. Or else there would be no barriers between a university fresher with an age old experienced air force official with regards to aircraft handling, flight operations, VIP, VVIP transportation, relief transportation operations etc. It is true that the route had to be changed, but the necessity of the change as outlined by the Air Force Staff were more than just an angry kid being mindlessly stubborn for more candies.</p><p>As the officials have pointed out, the chief obstruction of this project is purely technical. As per the Civil Aviation Act the height of the metro rail structure doesn’t satisfy the allowable standard. The allowable height of any structure on that distance from the funnel runway is 14 feet as per the CAR-84 regulatory measurement. But the MRT Line-6 was to be 62 feet high which is more than 4 times the allowable height. It would shrink the runaway to an alarming extent which may intrude the flight operations. Also it posed a wall obstruction for which the flight would be left with no room for lateral maneuver and also it would require the flights to change the approach angle to 8 degrees than the usual 2.5–3 degrees which would pose risks to landings and takeoffs. Now the place harbors around 10000 flight hours by BAF alone, apart from the VIP, VVIP, relief and emergency goods transportation which increases the flight hours even further up. It’s no wonder the military officials wouldn’t want more damage to their carriers or damage to their pilots, passengers and goods. If you want to view the full press briefing of the justification from the Air Force Staff regarding the issue, follow this <a href="https://www.thedailystar.net/news-detail-205680">link</a>.</p><p>Now for the rest of the part of our scholar’s arguments, which is concerning the engineering design, is utterly laughable. She only takes into account one aspect, the” radius” of the track to justify her claims, but sadly civil engineering isn’t that easy. There are tons of engineering and non-engineering considerations that are needed to be taken before adopting a route. Some of the non engineering considerations have been discussed on the EIA report in the alternate route considerations. A screenshot on why it is not recommended have been provided at section 8. But that’s just the EIA assessment. There are tons of other engineering assessments which dictated the map of the route alignment. Speaking of maps, have a look at these two pictures. This is to show the contrast of civil constructional plans done by a biochem fresher in parallel with professional engineering firms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/467/0*IIzEhZEuyJfUey6k" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/787/0*AMpl__VvXB9ktjpM" /><figcaption>Figure: Railway engineering as done by a biochem fresher(Left) , Figure: Railway engineering as done by professional engineers(right)</figcaption></figure><p>It is also fun to see the 200m radius argument since it appears to be her comparing one part to a distant part of the route. These are not alternate options. The reason the Khamarbari route was selected is because the alternative Bijoy Sharani plan was rejected by the air force on technical grounds. The reason Matsha Bhaban is not selected since it did not meet the technical design evaluations and EIA assessments, compared to the route through the university area. Also another fun fact is that the curvatures are all around 200m in radius in the farmgate area, which absolves it of any risk, but our fellow scholars are sure that this track doesn’t meet the criteria and is very much risky. Also they are stating that the Matsha Bhaban radius is far more flexible. Now this is doubtful, because all their surveys were done in Google Map satellite view and not through any due process or survey reports.</p><p>Now to learn which factors actually affect design plans, resort to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_engineering#Railroad_engineering">Transportation engineering</a> to start understanding what level of intricacies goes in designing a highway or railways. Navigate through the sources and you would understand why just a google map and a digital marker isn’t enough to derive a solid railway route design.</p><p>But another thing should be kept in mind that, adjustments can be made of course. But the trade-offs should be kept in mind. If viable, better alternate routes are present they should be adopted without a doubt. The economic, environmental, technological trade offs of course would have to be far low for the Matsha bhaban route, that it had to be discarded by the metro authorities. To understand the inconveniences one does not simply ask “The political leaders”, but the “Planners and Engineers” of the company.</p><p><strong>Results and Discussion:</strong></p><p>The project follows all the necessary technical and environmental guidelines and is clean on all accounts. There would be some subtle damages, inconveniences and disruptions while constructing the whole thing which is perfectly reasonable for a mega-project like this, but the trade off outweighs the problems once it goes operational. It was found that our scholars at the TSC corners preferred “emotional” method, instead of any pragmatic methods. They also rely on vegetation more than technical reports to dictate their decisions. If they took a slight attempt to read, they would have seen that all of the concerns have been addressed and there is no substantial grounds to fight on. Searching for cheap loopholes would now only mean fighting for fighting’s sake, which would end up in nothing but an utter waste of time for all.</p><p>If our scholars walked down the streets with an open eye for the last few years they would have observed the progress in the constructional works. The depot has been installed, the soils have been prepared, the pillars have been erected, viaducts are being formed etc. The bottom line of which is that millions of dollars of investments have already been channeled towards its progress, which includes the survey, planning, manufacture, installation apart from some other costs.</p><p>Now just to protect the fragile baseless sentiments of some absolutely uniformed student group, should the government sacrifice millions of dollars of taxpayer money and adopt inconvenient planning and technical design. Should the government serve national interest or the sentiment of just a handful of students?</p><p>On an interesting note: The Managing Director of the Metro Project is a DU graduate. Feels funny to see an alumni going against their own doesn’t it? Or may it be that he isn’t? Maybe he is just doing his job as it should be done instead of purposefully trying to destroy his own alma mater? Has this idea ever come across our notable scholars’ mind? That’s a question we are leaving to God to figure out.</p><p>Our proposition would be for our scholars, to learn how to read. There are tons of reports publicly available. Many are kept confidential for legal reasons. But you can request access to those. Also if reading doesn’t help, or if you are heavily against reading, you can always reach out to the engineering and consultancy firms that are dealing with this. Stop taking commie bhai brothers as a valid source of information.</p><h3>Reference</h3><p>In this section we present the data that was used to formulate our theories .The Scholars of TSC and the dominant species of the land of Shahbag is highly territorial as seen with the pictures below :</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/0*woJAzAlljvfO7Zoq" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/0*SbuTMZYAbiGNHa1m" /></figure><p>Fortunately, for our reporters their underdeveloped neocortex makes them susceptible to camouflage . Our reporters were able to bypass their measures and observe them in their natural habitat .</p><p>The most common thing we observed was their immense love of trees. That is showcased below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/0*zlyo4GSEc1B-C0hW" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*iqi-bQwCsIPMjsv2" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/508/0*Qt_SLdrmY9huH4nO" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/526/0*qPQDkwQhZJWlC77j" /></figure><p>Outsiders causing problems is also one of the fears of the native species.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/501/0*I5Qt-r4lKHOijWA8" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/856/1*dMs7l_c_va0BEEPBOr8tLQ.png" /></figure><p>This fear is so prevailing that the scholars are comparing the outsiders to a certain political party and of course most commuters are molesters !!</p><p>Moving away from the obviously retarded comparison .There’s also the culture and poribesh . TSC is the Silicon Valley of culture and a true architectural marvel and such projects would destroy the beauty .</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/713/0*r2OEQifNODMcidck" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/0*RTjM9ZNtr4RFTIkJ" /></figure><p>The movement has also attracted commies and people harboring commie ideas who want to stop the project through more revolutionary means . They have a more simpler plan than the other scholars , if the protest does not work they will just smash the pillars .To that we tip our fedoras and hope their affairs are in order .</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/499/0*I4P270jOaSszu4mL" /></figure><p>Another group is what we have classified as the clout chasers . The scholars in this group can barely be even called scholars . The clout chasers are the bottom feeders of every movement .They need not be pondered on but we felt that we needed to include them to be as concise as possible .So, we decided to include one .To them we say, “hope she reads this ,bro”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*UXm1V_lIKDIrPAqb" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*uq2MQWVWlDwM0X4k.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/0*9CETm9e1go6r8tJt.png" /></figure><p>The live session from Bangladesh Student Union has also been an indispensable source of lolz and insight . Anyone interested should take a look.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JAwk8mQ8NKUASJF4scE3kg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/626/1*K8zZJfNtPtXfRU4vbggrUg.png" /></figure><p>This video also talks about the Rampal issue which is something we will cover in the future . Here’s the link for the live- <a href="https://www.facebook.com/bsu.du1952/videos/297262751393385/"><strong>https://www.facebook.com/bsu.du1952/videos/297262751393385/</strong></a></p><p>Now we could not leave out the various engineers who studied at the University of Google and published their findings by firing up Ms paint.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/501/0*i95p7alaNkPQd-Zn.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*5Ht1pjGcQKHaygg5" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*Dmt1E2q7DsVIxFuQ" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*S7mknGqLRvo4_Ftp" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*kC0aD0G_xryDaCD3" /></figure><p>Now, we are almost at the end of of our paper . We want to end things on a lighter note . We have found a section of the scholars that seem to have a knack for generating humor. We found these people funnier than Pickle Rick.We want to want to highlight them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/632/0*iah5UZUOwKY4bbGx.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/513/0*0aOzzqWw_dmDllXF.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/493/0*RL2jDCqpSbE8FUgA.png" /></figure><p>With that we have come to the end of this proceeding. Thank you for reading through all this . Join us as we tackle other issues .</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eb2552aed823" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Balance of Nature]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/on-the-balance-of-nature-82c4a615a5d2?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82c4a615a5d2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Aug 2020 08:52:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-23T08:52:30.260Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*c4ob61AkToRt2cUf" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@dainisgraveris?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Dainis Graveris</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>How many men are there to women?</p><p>Depends on who you ask.</p><p>If you ask hardline religious people like Dr. Zakir Naik, you will find the answer that females greatly outnumber males in nature everywhere, except for places where female infanticide is practiced like india, china etc. They outnumber males so greatly, that men has to practice polygamy, which is taking more wives for oneself, to ensure that the surplus women don’t become public properties. This is a very obnoxious thing to say, but as professor Zakir have put, this is the most sophisticated word he could say to explain the scenario. The overabundance of women in the wedding market, inevitably turns them into public properties or put in another way, a sexual object for the masses to enjoy.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FaxOIgrL4M_s%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DaxOIgrL4M_s&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FaxOIgrL4M_s%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/54f2306d936f69c14113d7735dce6ddd/href">https://medium.com/media/54f2306d936f69c14113d7735dce6ddd/href</a></iframe><p>But why am i quoting a preacher with regards to a scientific inquiry? Seems odd, and inappropriate. I know. I get your concerns. But the fact is that, such opinions are ingrained in the minds of millions of people, given the state of such preacher’s influences. Also it provides the lustful men a justification to take in more brides in terms of religion, since religion is deemed to be the highest moral authority by the most.</p><p>If you take a little time and bother yourself to check the statistics, you will see a completely different picture. The male to female population ratio is fairly balanced with approximately 1:1 ratio. Its not precisely balance, like exactly equal in number. But the ratio is fairly balanced with a rounded 1:1 ratio in terms of single digit. According to world bank’s report, the number of males in the world was reported to be 3.867 billions whereas the number of females in the world was reported to be 3.803 billions as of the year 2019. The global average of male to female thus tend to converge falling into a 50.416:49.584 ratio. Although the distribution is not the same in terms of age, country, race, ethnicity, subcultures, religion etc, but the tendency to reach towards an equilibrium state is quite evident, so evident that it starts to feel uncanny. It feels like some invisible hand is making sure the balance is kept intact.</p><p>But is there actually any need for a conscious control so that the sex ratio stays balanced among humans? Not just humans, but in most of the animal species similar characteristic is observed, that is, a balanced sex ratio. So what could be actually dictating the direction of this process?</p><p>Allow me to introduce you to our forever ignored friend in the nature department, Maths!!!!!</p><p>We’ve all heard about probability at some part of our life. Toss a coin, what do you get? You get either a head, or a tail, and what’s the probability of each of this options to occur? Its a 50–50 chance. a 50% probability for head, a 50% probability for tail. the formula went like this,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/882/1*PkkZcpgM0j80nGk4Hp5lNw.png" /></figure><p>Now, lets start tossing coins. For this i will take the help of the following website, and their interactive coin toss simulation service.</p><p><a href="http://www.shodor.org/interactivate/activities/Coin/">Coin Toss</a></p><p>In my first toss, i got a tail. The service lets you see list of cumulative results, ratios which would soon come to our use.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/932/1*cXCoTmyeNI6CIWFWkmxUuQ.png" /><figcaption>1st test toss</figcaption></figure><p>We got a tail, making the ratio of tail to head 100:1</p><p>Let’s start to increase our toss count. let’s make it 4.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/929/1*UtSzoWfR1mWi0RZecZ3Ukw.png" /><figcaption>2nd test toss. total 4 toss</figcaption></figure><p>the ratio dropped to 75:25 for tail to head.</p><p>Lets increase more.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/936/1*_12BOiXp8hWxRqEAhaulCA.png" /><figcaption>3rd test, 10 tosses in total</figcaption></figure><p>the ratio came to 70:30. both sides seemingly are trying to come forth each other.</p><p>Now, for 100 toss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*XeSC58MTLE0eKjtuN4dNnA.png" /><figcaption>4th test. 100 toss</figcaption></figure><p>check how both of the numbers are slowly moving towards each other with the increasing number of tosses.</p><p>Now for a 1000 toss,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/931/1*8tiIPd4TloJ_ufSa_woICw.png" /><figcaption>5th test, 1000 toss.</figcaption></figure><p>For 10000 toss,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/911/1*dGR-vdSkqzsAFFkj_p8ZbA.png" /><figcaption>6th test, 10000 toss</figcaption></figure><p>For 1001000 test, (pardon the extra 1000, the application doesn’t allow erasure of accidental tosses ).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*YEnwDmeyC6yl5QwJ9VF7oQ.png" /><figcaption>7th test, 1001000 toss</figcaption></figure><p>We can notice a trend from these tests, that the results start to converge with the increasing count of tests. This is what happens when large number of samples or iterations are incorporated in an event having totally random results. This is a popular phenomena in probabilistic theory, known as LLN or Laws of Large Numbers.According to the law, the average result of a large number of trials should come close to the expected value, and come even closer as the trials are increased. Expected value here intuitively signifies the generalization of weighted average, or the arithmetic mean of the large dataset.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/509/0*EtWc5p25y0Il_wJ5.png" /><figcaption>LLN visualization</figcaption></figure><p>Now considering two biological sexes, that is two possible outcome of childbirth, male and female. We can bring the coin toss analogy to the nature department. Notice how just one-tenth of a million dataset took us towards the expected value in the coin toss tests. Although practically speaking it doesn’t even need that much. in 1000 coin toss we in fact started to reach converging point. Looking at the LLN graph, it shows less than 100 can even yield results close to expected value. If that is the case, imagine how the results would behave for 7.674 billions of data, which is the global population count as of 2019. It will undoubtedly come to converge.</p><p>Therefore, even in other species, apart from homo sapiens, we see similar LLN trends. And see a balance in their numbers. Therefore it really doesn’t require an overseer to steer things into balance, but just simple unconscious mathematics.</p><p>Apart from mathematics, there are some biological drives towards equilibrium as well. Evolutionary stable strategy being one of them. This strategy is basically an appropriation of Nash equilibrium from Game Theory, which states that in a non-cooperative game individual players always adopt the strategies which works the best in response to their opponents moves (assuming each player are aware of their opponent’s strategies), and changing strategies until their opponent changes theirs won’t aid them in increasing their own payoffs. In nature, once a trait is adopted by a certain population, it would remain the same since against natural selection it fared the best so far for the population’s existence. Natural selection would eliminate all mutative strategies thereby, keeping an equilibrium state for the whole population. The balanced sex ratio is the evolutionary stable strategy as well for most of the animal species. To understand why so, we got to understand Fisher’s principle. In his 1930’s book “The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection”, Ronald Fisher argues that an approximate sex ratio of 1:1 is the evolutionary stable strategy for most animals. W.D Hamilton who outlines the process in a more concise manner,</p><blockquote>Suppose male births are less common than female.</blockquote><blockquote>A newborn male then has better mating prospects than a newborn female, and therefore can expect to have more offspring.</blockquote><blockquote>Therefore parents genetically disposed to produce males tend to have more than average numbers of grandchildren born to them.</blockquote><blockquote>Therefore the genes for male-producing tendencies spread, and male births become more common.</blockquote><blockquote>As the 1:1 sex ratio is approached, the advantage associated with producing males dies away.</blockquote><blockquote>The same reasoning holds if females are substituted for males throughout. Therefore 1:1 is the equilibrium ratio.</blockquote><p>Following Fisher’s theories, came MacArthur who proposed to look into this issue from the perspective of Game Theory. W.D Hamilton picked it up from there and termed the equilibrium point as “unbeatable strategy”. From then on John Smith and George Price coined ESS, or Evolutionary Stable Strategy which lays out the point that, for a given population, invading mutations don’t sustain against natural selection, unless they had some greater advantage to offer. Fisher was aware of one fact that male births tended to be higher. He reasoned it like this — Higher frequency of males die at infancy or before reaching the ability to mate or procreate, which eventually cancels out the surplus male births and reducing the passing of the genes favoring male births.</p><p>But wait, weren’t our births random coin toss occurrence, where the results (head or tail) are completely independent from each other?</p><p>This is true only if the other factors aren’t in play. If there are other factors in play, then there would be extra parameters in the equation, the calculations would not be totally independent, as what LLN requires. For LLN theory to work, it requires complete independence. But sadly, sex ratio is not a completely random occurrence, or in other words, it isn’t actually totally independent. We already saw how fisher’s theory, and ESS influences sex selection in childbirth. in coin toss there are no such ESS factors which influence head or tail occurrences. There are a good bunch of other factors which influence the sex ratio as a whole. In case childbirth, the ratio is more inclined more to males offsprings than females. Not a single column in the wiki entry shows a ratio below 1 for childbirth cases. Through the link below you can navigate to the whole stat as presented in wikipedia.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_sex_ratio">List of countries by sex ratio</a></p><p>The reasons for this may vary. Climate for example is one of those reasons. A study carried out by catalano, bruckner and smith found out that ambient temperature plays some role in determining sex selection. Their team found out that a degree rise in temperature causes 1 extra male birth per 1000. Other researches, for example, a study conducted by Helle, Samuli and others found that warm periods and excessive stressful periods like in world war situations, male births peaked compared to female births. Although unclear, gestational environments are also reported to have influences on sex selection of the child. Like gestational stress, or maternal malnutrition might be a cause to increased death of male fetuses which lower down the sex ratio eventually. Chemicals like dioxins are reported to have influenced increased female proportions, along with other chemicals like PCB and DDT, which are well known endocrine disruptors, causing abnormally low sex ratio in some villages of greenland and canada. Although environmental factors are highly debated in academia and also vaguely understood but nonetheless, some aberrations in the sex ratio is quite apparent from places to places.</p><p>Researches looked into age factors as well. A research by Bernstein et. al concludes that the higher birth ratio might be a result of males procreating at a younger age. The studies didn’t find any correlation between females who conceive early and sex ratio, but they concluded that the father’s might play a certain role in sex selection of the baby. Statistically older fathers tend to breed females more than their younger counterparts. Another interesting biological fact is the order of the offsprings. In a <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/194308b0">study</a> published in 1962, Renkonen, Raimo and Mäkelä found out that the order of the offspring’s sex tends to favour one sex over the other.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*1TtQFPp86P8MURp_JiKu8w.png" /><figcaption>influence of childbirth order on sex selection- Renkoren, Raimo</figcaption></figure><p>Other than natural causes, there are man made social factors too. For example, sex selective abortions and infanticide. Such practices eventually increase male proportion in the ratio. For example in china and india where male births are more preferred than female births. In china the one child policy only exacerbated the scenario. More sex selective abortions started to surface for couples to get their desired male offspring. In china the ratio went as high as 1.181 as per 2011 survey, which is pretty abnormal ratio and traces its roots at sex selective abortions. In india female fetus abortions have been a long occurring problem too, although things are improving through constant awareness and govt. initiatives. In countries where the general people prefer male births more like Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan the ratio eventually ends up favouring men as well, which is quite evident given their abnormally high sex ratio (between 1.11 and 1.2).</p><p>Economic factors also weirdly play a role here. In a study on east germany’s and west germany’s population who have identical genetic footprint, Catalan et al. found out that the economy of those regions had a significant role to play in the existing sex ratio of that region. According to gestational stress as we saw before, the sex ratio should decline. In 1991 when East germany’s economy collapsed, and the sex ratio dropped compared to it’s previous years. Whereas, the sex ratio at west germany remained the same, which didnt face such gigantic economic collapse like the east. This observation only corroborated the population stressor theory, concluding the fact that economical conditions play a significant role in sex ratio of a given population.</p><p>Now, recall that i used approximately 1:1 sex ratio for most of the animals, not all. Animals who abide by the Fisher’s law are called Fisherian animals and animals who defy the law are called non fisher animals. Reptiles are a good example for this. Usually birds and mammals have balanced fisherian sex ratio. But for reptiles whose sex selection is temperature dependent, like that of turtles, alligators, lizards etc. the scenario is different. There are two category of sex determination in offsprings. One is GSD which is Genetic Sex Determination (based on chromosomal inheritance) and the other is ESD, or Environmental Sex Determination (Based on environmental conditions). ESD is also known as TSD, or Temperature Based Sex Determination. Alligator females are hatched if the eggs are incubated between 27.7 to 30 degree celsius and males are hatched if the temperature is kept 32.2 to 33.8 degree celsius. For turtles, the case is different. Turtles hatch female hatchlings at higher temperatures and male hatchlings at lower temperatures. Below 27.7 degrees celsius, males are hatched and above 30 degrees celsius females are hatched. Based on this difference TSD are categorized into two patterns, Pattern I and Pattern II. Pattern I is divided into two categories, Pattern IA and Pattern IB. Most turtles are of Pattern IA type, who produce females at higher temp. range and male at lower. The remaining turtles are Pattern II type along with crocodiles, lizards etc, who produce females at extreme highs or extreme lows, and produce males in between. Tautara reptiles are of category IB type who produce males at higher temperature and females at lowers, just the opposite of turtles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/698/0*i67xzk9OJGCmQ7mI.png" /></figure><p>So, we can see that there is no random occurrence in sex selection for these particular species. The environment gets to decide what to come out of the brood. Hence, the Laws of Large Number doesn’t fit here, like it does in higher level species, for example, mammals, birds etc. <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/49645?seq=1">The reason for this is fitness adaptation</a>. With the variance of climate and temperature in the atmosphere, one particular sex would get to have advantage over the other in terms of survival. Hence before hatching, the sex determination inside the shell happens in such a way that the fittest sex is hatched out, in order to cope up with the existing environment outside the shell. Thus they achieve an optimum evolutionary strategy, which makes sure that their species don’t go extinct in any given environmental condition. In fact sometimes this poses a problem. For example, in turtle species, climate change have driven them to produce 99% female offsprings in the span of twenty years. Whereas it used to be 1:6 sex ratio, now it rose up to 1:116 sex ratio. This rose concerns among researchers that if the turtles might go extinct at some point, due to overabundance of female turtles and negligible males.</p><p><a href="https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/2019/04/sea-turtle-sex-ratio-crisis-from-climate-change-has-hope/">Sea turtles are being born mostly female due to warming-will they survive?</a></p><p>What can be said for sea turtles can be said for other TSD species as well. Would rising global warming threat their existence and vanish them out of the wild?</p><p>At this point, it might feel great to know that we don’t have to worry since we are higher level GSD species following Fisher’s principles and maintain LLN balance to the full. But as we pointed out earlier, we aren’t actually completely immunized from this thing. Superstitious stereotypes, fundamentalist ideas and cultures and medieval perspect on gender roles tend to do a disservice towards female birth. Also wars and violence claim a lot of male lives. Thus regional aberrations occur, which breeds conflicts. Gender imbalance can generate serious troubles. It can cause the excess males at the lower status level to congregate and get violent. A scarcity of female partners may drive a large portion of the population go crazy, eventually creating huge social unrest. Also an excess of such young, agitated angry males may ease the way for terrorist organization to recruit more people in their team. They also might get absorbed into militaristic political factions as disposable foot soldiers. There are ample evidences that where a group of single, agitated, hyperactive young males congregate, violence and organized aggression becomes more apparent. <a href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/bare-branches">Hudson et Al. </a>even went further to consider such particular problem as a potential regional threat. In india and china many homicidal cases and violence against women could be largely attributed to their rising anomalous sex ratio. Kidnapping and trafficking also increases as a result, since the shortage of women expands the sex industry. In fact, in the Middle East , where sex ratio is pretty high up ( Qatar 2.84, UAE 2.73 ), many girls from asian countries are illegally trafficked for sexual slavery. Its not just the sex ratio behind this, but polygamy is another contributing factor behind this, which only worsens the crisis. But middle easterners being the richie rich of the region can afford buying women from poorer nations to stave off their crisis, unlike south sudanese where polygamy eventually breeds civil war.</p><p><a href="https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2018/03/19/why-polygamy-breeds-civil-war">Why polygamy breeds civil war</a></p><p>The south sudanese exhibit the exact findings of Hudson et Al. If you want a more rigorous look into the findings of the correlation between sex ratio and violence especially in the context of china and india, you can refer to this paper from NCBI for further queries.</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1569153/#__sec4title">Abnormal sex ratios in human populations: Causes and consequences</a></p><p>Therefore, in conclusion it is always wise to resort to expert opinions from relevant fields to understand the overall nuances of a particular matter. When some know it all preacher enters the stage and sells you the lucrative justifications for polygamy to uphold his belief systems in high regards, take his words with a grain of salt. Just keep in mind that his job is to sell an ideological system to you, not exactly hard sciences. Hence he has to act like a jack of all to entice you, has to manipulate, fabricate or distort scientific truth so that you are not left dissatisfied with his version of truth. Scientific nuances won’t come to his assistance so he has to cover them up, cover the parts that conflicts his interests. Although i am pretty sure Dr. Zakir never went through one single study regarding this field. And of course, why would he, it won’t help his preaching business at all. He has to brand unmarried women as “public property” and condemn them to justify his polygamous worldview. But if he had to undergo the scientific nuances, if anyone really had to be branded “public property”, it would have to be men, the sex that is inherent to his identity. And as we all patriarchal torchbearers know well enough, its the women who are our property, not vice versa, right?</p><p>Okay since we are at the end of our article, let me confuse you a little more. Is a coin toss actually a completely random occurrence? Or is there some kind of extremely intricate mathematics behind this, which dictates which side is to fall? As my respected teacher Professor Hashem used to once say, “There is nothing random in Computer Science, everything follows rules.” I would like to extend that from computer science to the whole universe.</p><p>I would say that the whole universe is just a manifestation of mathematics. Its just a bunch of mathematical processes getting intertwined with each other, directing the dynamics and the course of the universe. Nothing is random. It just looks random to us since we are either too lazy or unable to calculate the faintest mathematical relations and prefer to look on generalized, bigger, comprehensible mathematical relations instead, counting the rest as just stochastic and random phenomena.</p><p>We be livin’ inside a mathematical simulation for real!</p><p>Quick Mafs!</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FM3ujv8xdK2w%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DM3ujv8xdK2w&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FM3ujv8xdK2w%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/45223cce12ab3a86e1143ce5b48a061b/href">https://medium.com/media/45223cce12ab3a86e1143ce5b48a061b/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82c4a615a5d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Idealistic Transitions]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/on-idealistic-transitions-adfccb7b4668?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/adfccb7b4668</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Jul 2020 19:08:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-22T04:33:12.041Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>On Ideological Transitions</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*76XWRC6CtUdIPMt0.jpg" /></figure><p>Once a popular economist, John Maynard Keynes is said to have quoted,</p><blockquote>When the Facts Change, I Change My Mind. What Do You Do, Sir?</blockquote><p>The substance of this quote is absolutely unarguable. In pursuit of the truth, intellectual honesty is a must. True reality cannot be perceived unless our actions are dictated by facts, and not through emotions or agenda of any kind. This is something almost if not all of the readers here can agree upon. But a fundamental flaw in us human beings is that, we are story telling species. We unified ourselves through the means of stories. It is in fact the ability to imagine and construct a story, along with the capability of convincing others into it, which made large scale human collaboration possible. And the large scale flexible human collaboration is what shaped us as the most advanced, dominating animal species, and helped create the modern world as we see it is today.</p><p>But its ironic of me to quote Keynes as the opening of this article. The reason i started it with a quote of Keynes in this case, is because it’s fake. Many of you took the quote to be granted, because its the first time you are coming across this without having any prior knowledge regarding Keynes or other economic histories, and also because you have some level of trust in me, the author whose article you thought would be worth a read. So did i, i too fell for the similar trap, when i first saw the short documentary on Keynesian economics in The School of Life channel on YouTube. But, little did i know, they got the facts wrong. When i searched for the quote (for some reason i cant specifically remember), only then i came to know that i had been the wrong thing. There has been no trace found anywhere of John Keynes enunciating such a expression. But the traces can be tracked down to another person Paul Samuelson, who was asked why did he continuously change his position in his subjects, with newer edited version of the truth with each new edition of his book. To which he answered, “ When the events change, i change my mind, what do you do?”. Now that i presented you with an alternate reality. A more fact driven one, investigated one, would you still stick to my initial proposition? Speaking from common sense, no one would want to be that much stupid and dogmatic as to hold on a wrong worldview, unless he/she overly adheres to some conflicting agenda. Despite that, the Denial Olympics is rather pretty common. That’s why its so complicated to establish a standard version of reality, trumpeting over a diverse definition of truth , because people find it tough to cut off the emotional tie from their deeply cherished stories, face the facts, and adjust their worldviews accordingly. The power of stories in shaping the world is a core thesis of Harari’s books. If you want to learn more about them, you might as well check the book.</p><p>The world is full of stories. State, Religion, Money, Empires, Families, Human Rights, gazillions of ideologies etc. all are stories. A story does not need to be about a fictional world with kings, queens, heroes and villains. It can be more abstract, act kind of as a tool, for example: money. Money does not have any concrete value. It is just a piece of paper. But we assign a meaning to this particular piece of paper. I have to believe that a 10$ note is worth 10$ worth of someone’s labor and that they are exchangeable. Similarly my trader has to be believe in the same story, that he is being offered a piece of paper which represents a significant portion of his labor, that can be traded. Thus the whole global trade system operates, based on a shared imagination, or in other words a shared story. Thus works empires, religions, families and all the other stories. Based on an imaginary narrative, we design our lives, our social structures, institutions, systems, hierarchies and interactions. Stories are vital to problem solving and social engineering.</p><p>One such a story that is fundamental to understanding modern social structures is the idea of feminism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/564/0*rQlk5O6ZGQ-vmcwk.jpg" /><figcaption>Source: nastywomancosmetics instagram</figcaption></figure><h4>Exploring the roots</h4><p>Feminism is basically an extension of the idea of human rights, but projected onto the female demography. Feminist theories started to emerge from the 17th centuries but the traces are scanty and no such label was introduced. In fact due to this lack of label and an organized structure, many sociologists prefer to call the earlier movements regarding women’s rights as protofeminism. It was after the renaissance, at the age of enlightenment that organized feminist sentiments started to gain its grassroots. When reformist social structures came to eventuate the exclusion of women from reformist policies, it disturbed a lot of contemporary female intellectuals, who later went on publishing playwrights, novels, articles etc. to challenge the male centric notion on womanhood. One of such a prominent literary work was of Mary Wollstonecraft. Her book “ A vindication of the rights of women” is a protofeminist literature which was pivotal towards influencing the first wave feminist theories and accelerating first wave feminist movements. Wollstonecraft wrote the book as a response to Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord who presented a report to French National Assembly arguing that women should only receive domestic education. Wollstonecraft was then impelled to write a rebuttal which came along as the rights of women. She argued that men and women were ordained with equal natural rights by god and to reject that notion would be a grave sin and unjust.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1020/0*ftPoXEkWsheeqD-j.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9Wm5a9vuKYY4DkZA.jpg" /><figcaption>Mary Wollstonecraft and her book “ A vindication of the rights of women”</figcaption></figure><p>Following Wollstonecraft’s legacy, discussions regarding women’s rights started to flash up in public arena. In the mid 19th century, at Seneca Falls, the women’s suffrage movement started to gain traction. It took the sentiment of the abolition movement which was happening at the same time, and utilized the emotional sentiment towards its own purpose. This marks the inception of the first wave feminism, when women organized themselves and fought for their rights to vote. Although the struggle was highly turbulent with it slowly getting faded away but then it got revived back again. There were divisions among feminist activists who had difference in approaches and in some sense, had conflicting ideals. For example, although it was ignited by the concept of enlightenment and equal natural rights, after eastern europeans started to flood in the united states, the suffragist leaders started to use racist and nativist rhetorics to justify their cause. Carrie Chapman, for example, argued that the votes of american born, literate, middle class women would counterbalance the votes of foreigners. Such classist remarks drove many working class poor women into trade unionist movements, and away from the feminist suffrage movements. But later on after more radical feminist voices started to appear like that of anarchist Emma Goldman, Charlotte Perkins Gilman who signified the women’s issues as a whole, only then things started to escalate rapidly. Then more radical violent dissident groups came along after the polite method wasn’t working out. Emmeline Pankhurst and her dissident team led boycotts, picketings, bombings to pressurize British into accepting their plea, and they did succeed into prompting British govt to allow the rights to vote in 1918. Following the british’s successes, american suffragists went on hardline too, leading boycotts and violent confrontations with police and state which prompted american govt. to permit women the rights to vote in 1920 in the forms of nineteenth amendment. The french and the egyptians caught up with suffrage grant in the mid 20th centuries, along with syria, pakistan, indonesia etc. Saudi Arabia was the last one to catch up, granting women the right to vote and right to run for parliament in 2011. While the timeline may vary, it indicates how a ripple in one end of the world might create domino effect in all part of the world, sooner or later. Stories, if proven effective, spreads like wildfire.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HAWkqgu-6kVJAxfr.jpg" /><figcaption>Source: The New Yorker</figcaption></figure><p>You can easily notice how stories emerge, get built up on the base of other stories and expand themselves throughout societies. How the stories regarding god, nature, justice gave birth to the stories of abolitionism, and consequently giving rise to feminism. And thus came waves after waves, modified, refurbished, enhanced in a more fancy and nuanced wrapper. While Jane Austen, Mary Wollstonecraft, Aphra Behn etc protofeminist authors influenced the world into first wave feminism, first wave feminist authors like Virginia Woolf , Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Charlotte Perkins Gilman etc influenced the way towards second wave feminism.</p><p>Second wave feminism started with “The feminist Mystique”, a literary work by Betty Friedan. Although Simone de Beauvoir and some other notable authors are also credited with igniting second wave despite having published their work earlier, but feminist mystique is considered the tipping point. Personally i can relate to simone de beauvoir since i spent more time with her books and got most influenced by her compared to others in my views.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*nru75oukap1_Dncg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/929/0*O4lEk9wmMwz4BcIZ.jpg" /><figcaption>Simone de beauvoir and her book “ The second</figcaption></figure><p>Second wave feminism attacked the dominant social structure and justified women being angry since they were getting ripped off in all social aspects. It talked about issues without labels. How societies’ narrative towards women and their roles in society contribute to the wider misfortunes of women. They argued that women’s rights didn’t stop at earning suffrage, but there were lot other unnoticed places where it may seem individualist discrimination but on the contrary accumulates to a wider discriminatory scenario. They identified the patriarchy inside social institutions and critiqued it. They targeted notions of sexuality, domestic roles, reproductive rights, systemic inequalities, domestic violence, custody laws etc. Carol hanisch popularized the term “The person is political” implying that, even though an individual woman’s problem seem individualistic and frivolous, it may be a part of a less apparent widespread systemic discrimination which shadows the rights of women as a whole. In the meantime Kate Millett brought her book “ Sexual Politics” and Germaine Greer wrote “The female eunuch” which solidified the individualistic but yet collectivist struggle of second wave feminists. The triumph of this movement was marked by legislative changes in those times, for example the equal pay act, reproductive freedom and access to birth controls, eradication of educational inequalities, support shelters for rape and domestic abuse victims, and taking sexual harassments in workplaces into consideration. Second wave mainly worked on to change how society viewed a “woman” as, and strived to change the notion that women are merely decorative, stripping them off their personal agency.</p><p>The success of second wave feminism gave rise to the third wave. With increasing participation and ascension of woman’s career in workplaces, the voices became more strong and more issues were put forward towards the discussion table. The term third wave is credited to Rebecca Hall, who wrote an article titled “Becoming the third wave” in Ms. magazine. The article was directed as a response to the nomination of Clarence Thomas in the Supreme Court of United States, who was accused to have harassed Anita Hill, an american lawyer who was under Thomas’s supervision at the Department of Education and the EEOC. Anita publicly testified against Clarence Thomas in front of an all male, all white judiciary committee which was an eyesore to many. Hence Rebecca wrote the article to address this whole issue where she quotes,</p><blockquote>So I write this as a plea to all women, especially women of my generation: Let Thomas’ confirmation serve to remind you, as it did me, that the fight is far from over. Let this dismissal of a woman’s experience move you to anger. Turn that outrage into political power. Do not vote for them unless they work for us. Do not have sex with them, do not break bread with them, do not nurture them if they don’t prioritize our freedom to control our bodies and our lives. I am not a post-feminism feminist. I am the Third Wave</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/670/0*D9U3vXzjyYqYKtx1" /><figcaption>Rebecca Hall</figcaption></figure><p>Third wave feminism brought gender, class and racial issues onto the table. They directed their focus onto understanding racial dynamics which they believe to have been absent in the second wave feminist movements. The biggest criticism to second wave feminist movement was its lack of inclusivity. The movement was accused to be elitist, overly homogenized and saturated with the issues of white middle class cisgender women. It barely included dialogues on the struggles of women from other races, lesbians or transgender woman. The historical narratives on which the movement pivoted itself upon, were also accused to be whitewashed, ignoring the condition and contribution of working class women and also of women from different racial backgrounds. Kimberlé Crenshaw, a lawyer and a civil rights advocate, coined the term “intersectionality” in 1989 as a critical response to the white centric second wave feminism.</p><p>Third wavers embraced intersectionality, lgbt issues and post-structuralism but somewhat at the cost of of frownings from second wavers with some legit criticisms and also some bigoted criticisms getting hurled towards them. The generational gap was highlighted by feminist author in her essay “Generations, Academic feminists in dialogue” through the quote,</p><blockquote>This problem manifests itself when senior feminists insist that junior feminists be good daughters, defending the same kind of feminism their mothers advocated. Questions and criticisms are allowed, but only if they proceed from the approved brand of feminism. Daughters are not allowed to invent new ways of thinking and doing feminism for themselves; feminists’ politics should take the same shape that it has always assumed</blockquote><p>The success of the third wave lied in integrating a wider range of allies from different races, classes. It challenged heteronormativity, gender stereotypes and femininity as viewed by society. Naomi Wolf wrote “The Beauty Myth”, critiquing how society puts unrealistic beauty standards onto women and how women are driven towards an unhealthy lifestyle as a result of trying to cope up with societal beauty standards. The book addresses sexist stereotyping of women advocated and influenced through the means of media objectification and commercial cultural influence, which is often overlooked but has a significant impact in turning women vulnerable and yielding room to exploit. The third wave also tried to reclaim derogatory terminologies that had been often used to undermine women, such as, sluts, spinster, bitch, whore, cunt etc. The single, “All women are bitches” by Fifth Column, and the “Toronto Slutwalk”, a protest movement against a Toronto police officer who claimed that women should stop dressing like sluts in order not to be victimized, were part of such causes. The third wavers actively advocated for child care, single mother welfare, reproductive rights and widened access, sexual liberations and de-stigmatizing and bunch of other causes to fill up the gap of the second wave. But unlike second wave, which was shaped by wars, civil rights, workplace and academic segregations, third wave was shaped by pop media, for example Riot Grrrl, feminist punk subcultures, Ms. Magazine and other online e-magazines and also through the internet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VSaqHfvg5g8JJa1E.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*SwiYz2lcetjiDheo.jpg" /><figcaption>Riot grrrl, Ms. Magazine</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Wy34I-6CSsjHh7CJ.jpg" /><figcaption>Slutwalk</figcaption></figure><p>After a year of slutwalk, in 2012, with Alissa Quart coining the term “Hipster Sexism” to address subtle, ironic acceptable forms of media objectifications, Jimmy Savile sexual abuses coming into light, the international outrage concerning 2012 Delhi gang rape and murder, and related movements galvanized the fourth wave feminism. Although some activists like Jennifer baumgardner dates the wave back to 2008 with the rise of twitter’s popularity among the 19–28 age group of women, who steered the whole fourth wave all the way up to today. Fourth wave is marked with the explosion of social media and utilizing its full potential for feminist causes. The metoo movement for example, originating in Myspace in 2006 by sexual harassment survivor Tarana Burke, is one of the prominent instances of the fourth wave.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pixQ8JG5yyuWxGuq.jpg" /><figcaption>metoo illustration</figcaption></figure><p>Metoo rose to prominence when Ronan Farrow wrote an investigative report on The New Yorker exposing prominent producer Harvey Weinstein and his predatory past. Following this, actress and activist Alyssa Milano wrote up a blog post encouraging women who have been likewise victimized by weinstein and others, to come forward with the hashtag metoo in their social media platform for people to realize the magnitude of the problem. Alyssa’s siren broke out of proportion in twitter, facebook and other social media platforms, with big shot celebrities and even commonfolks coming out with their buried experiences of abuse. Metoo exposed many high-level prominent figures for their predatory nature and highlighted the weight of the problem in media and workplace, pressuring corporations to redesign their workplace culture to create a less toxic environment for women to work in. This would have been unattainable through any other means, and since spoke to a lot of women from its core and gave the vulnerable a platform, a voice, it wasn’t confined within a region, instead spread like wildfire throughout most part of the world. The whole metoo wave is quite intricately documented in wiki, which i am willing to skip, since it is too big and would be quite of an infodump.</p><p>This should have the implication that internet has been the best thing women could ever have have; which would in fact be really really wrong. On one hand internet brought feminism to the masses, gave the vulnerable a voice, allowed them to congregate and forward their causes, and on the other hand, it created niches for cyberbullies, stalkers, defamers, doxxers etc. Internet added new dimensions of problems which were virtually nonexistent before. Gamergate for example, was a coordinated harassment campaign again female game developers and feminist media critics who voiced against of sexist stereotyping in the video game productions. The targeted harassment went so out hands that some activists like Anita Sarkeesian started getting rape, death threats and had to shift homes after getting her home addresses leaked online. A gamergate associate anonymously threatened to carry out a massacre against the attendees who would attend Anita Sarkeesian’s public appearance in Utah State University, as a result of which the public event had to be cancelled. The intimidator cite Montreal Massacre of 1989 as an inspiration, which was a mass shooting in École Polytechnique, an engineering school affiliated with Université de Montréal, by an assailant named Marc Lépine, killing 14 female engineering students as an attack against feminism. Lépine considered himself to be a rational person and reckoned that feminism was destroying society, favouring women at the expense of men. He thought to cleanse society of its illness, and hence planned and executed the attack. Now similarly, the gamergate forces also worked on the same rationale, they too considered feminism as a cancer to society, which has been sabotaging the gaming culture and on a mission to eliminate their invigorating gaming experiences. But what makes it worse and even more threatening was that, Lépine was a lone wolf, gamergate affiliates were not, they were a collection of potential infuriated Lépines.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/631/0*qmas6tmoUGAqTg39.jpg" /><figcaption>Victims of Montreal Massacre</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9AnuzOUU2gu1hPHN.jpg" /><figcaption>Two primary targets of gamergate. Zoe quinn and Anita Sarkeesian</figcaption></figure><p>Cyber harassments has been a wider part of discussion since the explosion of internet, and monitoring, regulating cyber harassments have proven to be a constant challenge for tech companies. Extreme regulations go against free speech policies which is a fundamental human right. But then again targeted harassments pose more threat to a stable society and can cause disastrous effects. So drawing the thin line between free speech and hate speech have been a topic of intense debate which continues till this day. While some improvements have been made, but still loopholes exist for the predators to prey on. And also it came at the cost of free speech, which many argue has linearized the internet experience. It is kind of like a double edged sword. One one hand companies need to restrict free speech, and on the other hand they need to ensure free speech. Inclining on one side automatically effects the other. And most importantly, the speech regulation are seen by the perpetrators as a violation to their fundamental human rights, which in turn infuriates them even more. An important thing to note is that, the perpetrators don’t see them as doing something ignoble. In their version of story, they are the good eyes, while women, or the feminists are the villain. So when the good guys are censored by society, their anger grows more, and the retaliations become more galvanized.</p><p>Now i don’t know if you realize but the stories i have been narrating to you above is also in a sense whitewashed. I have barely touched the struggles of women outside of the west. Not even fully western, but mostly american and then somewhat british. There are some reasons to it of course, firstly because of english being our second language after bangla, we are still mostly under british and american influence than of any other country. Also, west being the hegemony, the media of the west also dominates the internet, or the air in general, making it more easily accessible towards people across the west. English becoming the global language, gave the west an edge as well. Combined with excellent academic culture, most impactful literary analysis, socio critical theories can be traced back to the west too. Judging most recent popular movements, be it communism, capitalism, feminism, secularism, democratization, freedom and liberty are fairly western phenomena than anything else. Therefore when external societies get a taste of the ripple, it is seen as an attempt in westernization. And westernization is a far reaching phenomena, than for example sinicization, or russification, or arabization, or indianization. But this is in no way to discredit the struggle of the iranian women protesting forced hijabs, the arab women fighting for driving rights, african women fighting against genital mutilations, or the egyptian feminists fighting against sexual harassments and unjust islamic impositions, or the russian pussy riot groups fighting against orthodoxy and dictatorship, or even the feminist pioneers from our subcontinent who constantly fought for the rights of women. But it’s not possible for an individual like me to cover the whole feminist movement around the globe in one little article unless i pursued some considerable academic years trying to realize and summarize the whole thing in a global scenario. I tried to learn from the most credible, impactful and accessible resources i could find, and reflected on those that i could gather in such short time.</p><p>One native documentary that really struck me was of bratto amin’s 36 24 36. The documentary talks about the post colonial notion of beauty and how it aids to the passive exploitation of women into fitting a certain beauty narrative. It also highlights the intensity of media objectification, effects of neoliberalism in shaping children’s mind in their infancies with beauty products, barbie dolls etc, which on its way lineralizes their notion of beauty. It also shows how society adapted to such narratives and women are pushed into conforming into such narratives. it was available to watch on youtube but for some reason it got removed. But dailymotion still hosts the full documentary which i am embedding below.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.dailymotion.com%2Fembed%2Fvideo%2Fx3jn1lf&amp;display_name=Dailymotion&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.dailymotion.com%2Fvideo%2Fx3jn1lf&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fs2.dmcdn.net%2Fv%2FCnqRJ1V6waZ7Ku2dn%2Fx240&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=dailymotion" width="480" height="269" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/bfefb0eb4acba178e8679d7ee7585932/href">https://medium.com/media/bfefb0eb4acba178e8679d7ee7585932/href</a></iframe><h4>Idealistic transitions</h4><p>In my past life i had been an utter misogynist brat. I chuckle and cringe at how retarded my views were at the past. And it’s no wonder that it had been that way. I was little and influenced heavily by my surroundings. And we live in a patriarchal surrounding. Sometimes i felt contradicting intuitions, but brushed it off thinking how silly those were. In school, prank calls gained quite notoriety since trolling others was always fun and it was the pre internet age. The only way to troll were to ring calling bells and run away or do prank calls and befuddle the person on the receiving end. Pranking girls were funnier because of course, of the sole reason that they were girls. Then came the age of internet. No need to waste money on phone calls, or risk getting beaten up, if you can have the option to troll people for free, which we did and laughed victoriously after one after one successful trollings. It seemed all fun and games, until we all grew up and realized how idiotic and harmful those were. We had no one idea at that point, no one was there to point to us that it was all wrong. It was like aesop’s fable about the boys and the frogs. The boys throw stones at vulnerable frogs without fear of repercussions or the conscience that it is wrong. What seems fun and cool, maybe exonerating and even traumatic for others.</p><p>After moving to college, and eventually getting busy with the fight for getting into a good enough university, things started to wane out. We started to get matured. I started reading non fiction books, started to learn about liberalism, progressivism, liberal western ideas. Started exploring online forums, blogs and my eyes started to open on how wrong i was at my past, and under how intense ill influence i was under. My college time inadvertently made me change my social circles which i realized was the best thing to happen to me. I have to admit, i was a conservative religious fundie at that point of life as well. After i explored the liberal ideologies, and understood that the extreme i was in at that point was wrong, i started to transition my set of ideals, and moved to the other end of the extremes. Most of the people go through such a phase. After their status quo world gets shattered away, they become obsessed. Or as per the popular internet language, they become redpilled. Redpill phases are blood boiling, since the rebel inside awakens and breaks the shackles with such a strong force that it drives the person to the extreme. The negative exposure takes a hideous toll on the person’s psyche, just like it took on mine. Soon i got to realize it was no big deal and i am no che guevara or jesus christ. I cant change things alone, but that it is all a gradual and incidental process, which will find it’s route automatically. I realized that what i have been immersing myself into is a sea of negativity which is doing no one no good, instead hurting my psyche, hampering my regular life. I slowly started to move to more benign positions and trained myself to become less angry. I didn’t ditch my progressive ideals though, i just started to become less angry, and engaged more what i could practically achieve.</p><p>Among all of the liberal socio political stories, i will be sticking to the story of feminism only for this article. Getting to wear the glasses of truth like from the movie “They live”, i started to see the systemic discriminations and sexism running rampant. It all used to bother me a lot when my idealistic transition happened. Because like the Gamergate soldiers or Marc Lepine , i too was convinced that a force was dismantling the fabric of society, but unlike them i sided with the feminists and rallied against the conservatives. After transitioning into a more benign position after realizing the outrage was disproportionate and more emotion driven than logistics, i just observed and took notes on what’s happening. I tried to influence the people surrounding, but that’s the maximum i did, because it was the most pragmatic approach i could afford, without boiling up my brain for insignificant results. I saw how unfairly the society around me treated it’s womankind. How stereotypical attitudes shaped their lives not for the good but for a life of confinement and conformity. How harassment incidents went unnoticed or suppressed to protect chastity and innocence. I noticed favouritism, segregation, and power exertion on a structural basis. My peers held archaic perspectives regarding the roles of women and the rights they ought to possess. They frown on their dresses, their lifestyles, their choices, their voices. I remember once in my special machine presentation class, a friend of mine opened up to me. He couldn’t bear that girls are pursuing engineering education. We had a female teacher who was assessing our presentation and he didn’t like that. Although she was modestly dressed with hijabs on, but still couldn’t earn his approval. Why? Because she was grabbing the position of a guy who could pursue engineering and earn a living for his family. But instead our “Mam” is wrongfully holding that position depriving a potential guy from a living. I asked him, why shouldn’t our “mam” be able to earn a living? He tells me, because it’s not the duty of the girl to earn a living but to take care of the child and her husband. He says, just look at your female peers, dressing in sarees and salwar kameez, or worse - western dresses, giving the options for the males to gaze, while they themselves stray away from their moral responsibilities.</p><p>Now this is not a new sentiment that he just came up with. This is the sentiment that has been for ages since women started to get integrated into the workplace. Meanwhile at that period, i was in the middle of reading Simone De Beauvoir. In her book she echoes to have experienced similar sentiments from her contemporary men. She says of a guy who was pissed when women were integrating in workforces. The reason behind his wrath was that the women were robbing the men of their jobs, and its therefore doing society a disservice. The men has to be the breadwinner and it does not help when women come up and rob them off of the opportunity that had been already saturated. Simone wrote the book long ago, but the instance she highlighted till today. I was astonished to see how extremely accurate this was till this day. But one difference i saw was that, most of the conservative mindsets had religious wrappings around it. Most of the misogynist remarks thrown by my peers had religious coatings around it to make it further invincible. And not any religion in particular, but all in fact. Every misogynist had religion as a shield to defend themselves against criticisms. Because of course, if someone does, he would then inadvertently be criticizing religion, which would be a risky business. You wouldn’t want to unintentionally earn the wrath of God, and risk your faith, hence people even back themselves out from critical thinking, just to play it safe. Simone also mentioned another instance. She was a close friend of Sartre, a highly regarded existential philosopher till this day. Once sartre told her, simone was different, she was intelligent, too close of that of a man’s. This particular remark hurt her, thinking that society always held men as the standard of intelligence while the women as always below them by default. A woman’s intellect is judged with respect to that of a man, and not independently. The underestimation of woman’s intellect holds true to this day. Hence female participation in STEM fields are far low than of fancy subjects like home economics.</p><p>In our campus, girls were not allowed to be Class representatives (CR). Since it is inconvenient for a girl to be one. Why because of course she is a girl. A CR has to keep connection to all of the students and teachers as well, to plan and execute perfect schedules for classes and tests and other related academic stuffs. Now the justification is that, the girls will be open towards vulnerability, and they could be easily exploited. Okay sure, for security concerns, makes perfect sense. But what does this imply? That our campus authority have failed to ensure a secure environment for our girls. It’s not the girl’s fault that she has been stripped off the opportunity to ride up to a leadership position. Its the failure of the system which couldn’t ensure such an opportunity for it’s female students. Girls can exercise very limited freedom compared to the boys, mainly because of security issues. While it is true, that in a suburban area security insurance is an utopian ambition, and i am not blaming KUET here, but i am trying to highlight just this, that as a society we haven’t progressed much to ensure a safe space for our girls, and that much work needs to be done to achieve the western standard for equal rights and opportunities. It’s not just CR, but girls weren’t allowed to General Secretary (GS) or Assistant General Secretary (AGS) of departmental associations and were stripped off from many leadership positions in curricular and extra curricular affairs. I had a female friend from another department who shared her grief with me on her departmental experience. She says it sucked to see them not having the similar privileges and opportunities as her male peers and their voices ignored. Her male peers may have acted on good faith, but you gotta realize, it comes at the cost of their independent agency. One junior once told me, she wished she was a boy, she would thus have the opportunity to fully explore herself, and not get stuck into confinement. A very close senior of mine once briefed me how systematically exploited all the girls in her department have been, which went barely noticed. Most decisions came from the boys who used to assert dominance in all meetings and gatherings. Their voice were frivolous compared to the strength of their male peers. Hence many didn’t even continue to bother. Thus the voices from the girls’ end keeps getting suppressed and everyone gets used to it, the boys and the girls too. The girls get busy with just studies and other trivia while the boys engage fully in the major departmental issues. Now this is nothing unique to that particular department, but rather it portrays a glimpse of the wider scenario. It’s the tendency of the boys to act like valiant princes who are on a mission to either safeguard or rescue their princess who don’t have much agency of their own. That men are defenders and decision makers, while women are homemakers and beneficiaries, have been perpetuated by society for so long that it started getting ingrained into our DNA. Hence whenever major issues were to be resolved, for example in tours, or in departmental fests or mass protests, or cultural programs, or other departmental non departmental functions, the boys usually used to override the steering wheel, always with an elusive notion that by birthright, they have been assigned superior analytic and decision making capability and hence society had put them on upper hierarchies to decide things for themselves as well as others. Nature turned them into guardians, and while some flexibility can be granted to women, to satisfy the social progress bar, its always wise to obey nature and override them whenever felt convenient. The basic arguments are all the same, “ ‘They are girls, they wont understand the intricate things which vitalize and mobilize “these” issues’ or ‘A girl isn’t suited mentally or physically for such “manly” organizational works’ or that ‘It requires mature supervision, they wont be able to contribute much’.” While in some cases, it is true that many of the organization works might be tough for women to execute since the social structure doesn’t provide them with adequate security and options, but in most other cases these are excuses to segregate a part of the class to ease the dominance of others under the pretense of conveniences. Also the lack of security for which girls cannot properly exercise leadership and decision making roles, explicitly highlights, how as a society and as a leading educational institution we failed our women. There are thousands of similar griefs you will find once you start to get to talk to the girls and come to know their experiences. Some may make sense, while some may feel to be mindlessly, emotionally driven, but the core sentiment is real. That society failed to ensure an equal flourishing ground for women. Also how this inadvertently bolsters the dominant “male guardianship” sentiment of the boys, which only solidifies through time.</p><p>Again i am not blaming KUET at all. I understand their shortcomings. KUET cannot drastically change society’s mindsets in a night. The best it can do is to restrict some options of the girls and impose certain limitations in their movements and participations to ensure nothing unexpected happens. But the trouble arises when it becomes the norm. Many students, including the teachers take this to be the default moral scenario and forget that the policies are there in the first place out of desperation. Hence when a girl just chooses to overstep, she is frowned upon, castigated and morally questioned. The moral policing sometimes end up in unnecessary harassments. For example vigilante parties trying to keep decency in check by harassing couples in their privacy, sometime doxxing them sometimes not. Interestingly, it’s not the guys only who are in the raiding team. There was one particular instance where one senior year couple doxxed another junior year couple since they caught them getting intimate in the departmental building close to where they themselves were dating. Now, while it is really inappropriate to get intimate in a public place, it certainly isn’t such a heinous crime that requires doxxing. Why you may ask? Let me explain you the aftermath and you will realize. When the doxxing happened and everyone got to know, it was all over for the girl. She was publicly shamed, her ex boyfriend viraled her nudes to everyone, her whole faculty got to know, she got expelled from her hall, publicly shamed like a witch and eventually she had to cancel her studentship and leave the place to escape the trauma. And what happened to the guy? Nothing. He was saved by his seniors, no one made such a big deal out of it and the next day his departmental seniors took him out for a treat for working in their departmental program. You can easily notice the disproportionate reactions to different sexes, and the disproportionate impacts too. Is this fair? Is it so big a crime that one has to get tarnished for life and discontinue her hard earned engineering program? This was sth that bothered me and a friend of mine a lot, and we discussed on the possible rationale behind this. It’s understandable when guys go after girls, its their intuition to act as such but why would a girl aid in making another girl’s life miserable. I came across a term by then, which was “internalized misogyny”. It perfectly explains what happened. Internalized misogyny basically refers to misogynist ideas held by women which they learn and internalize from patriarchal societal system. They too cannot be blamed since they themselves do not realize the internalized misogyny in them. Once a friend told me about some more internalized misogyny which was that his female buddies slut shamed others many of the times. Now while it may look benign and not too big of a deal but it certainly aids to the misogynistic culture that pertains around that place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*ADW26CHG7sPrlmhb.jpg" /><figcaption>Internalised misogyny illustration</figcaption></figure><p>There was one incident where a female buddy of mine came out in her social media account against an harassment issue that she faced from her departmental senior. The senior she accused was apparently a very popular figure in the department. He was a wholesome guy to everyone, had excellent results, cared for his friends and juniors, and was a free source for study related notes. When he got accused of using derogatory remarks in his social against the girl, everyone got shocked. The girl had very few people beside her while most other guys went out on a public smearing campaign. Many girls too sided with the senior guy for they had an ideal image of him. She was being repeatedly slutshamed, her characters getting brought into questions along with other character assassinating claims. Now, after very few people believed her, and that it was going nowhere, one friend side with her and came forward with a bunch of screenshots, where she got publicly sexualized and objectified without her consent by her peers, showing the magnitude of the problem and the culture that persists. The accused senior was just a continuation of that culture, no matter how benign and accidental it seemed. Now the later developments of the case made people realize what they had been overlooking all the time, many of those who opposed the girl stopped shouting since now the attention shifted to another classmate and some allies of his who were central to the latter screenshots. The guy was asked to apologize which he did but pretty reluctantly, which infuriated the girls even further. Then a raid was carried against the girl and her boyfriend, by vigilante moral police teams as i have mentioned earlier, which was utilized by the perpetrator as a weapon for another smear campaign and reclaim his glory. This received mixed response. Some said he never realized that he was wrong, while some say that he was right all along, she had it coming. This propelled the matter further. Apparently the guy in question was running for General Secretary post of our departmental association, and the girls all rioted against that decision. They asked our teachers to reconsider. But amazingly, their voices were ignored. Their voices weren’t paid any attention to by a single teacher and the majority of the classmates. He won the GS election and retained his power with the help of faculties and classmates, although allegations against were solidly proven. At that time i still wasn’t done reading Simone De Beauvoir. My blood was boiled, i along with my friends stood up and tried to side with her, since we knew no one else would have, but of course to no avail.</p><p>Now what’s the big deal of this? Many of the students asked. They implied that such a public drama was unnecessary. What they didn’t realize is that, the toxic culture has been always present and ignored. I had a departmental who once told me, that one of his friend grabbed a female classmate’s buttocks to her surprise and came back to his friends with a victorious grin. He knew she wouldn’t tell anyone or make a big deal out of it since no one wants to invite troubles in their shoulders. Also it would have been more awkward to bring up the allegation that her friend grabbed her buttocks without her consent. It was better to brush it away. A friend of mine once commented on a friend’s body to her boyfriend, urging him to cover her girlfriend up since it agitates him. This is a clear intimidation which should have been unacceptable in any recognized institution. But it is only fairly recently that a sexual harassment monitoring unit was formed comprising of faculties and administratives. It did not have any existence. And despite existing it could not bypass the status quo culture and take effective regulatory steps. One such incident happened fairly recently. A female alumni was sexually harassed by some students on facebook which got leaked. This is what happens when actions do not have repercussions. Things get normalized, and normalized it has. When the alumni threatened to take actions some, out of fear, apologized. While the main perpetrator deactivated and launched his army to smear campaign against her allies and turn it into a political issue, so that he can get political protections. Religion and Politics, two of the biggest hideouts for misogynists like him. If one fails to serve, opt for the other.</p><p>A culture of impunity encourages people into wrong behaviour. Once when at rag day, Jubba issue appeared to surface and ekattor television aired a program concerning this issue, all hell broke loose. We had all the support from everywhere, since here we were right track and ekattor television were just fear mongering. The problem which people seemed to miss is that, the anchor who aired the program was being repeatedly harassed by our classmates. Although she isn’t the writer, neither the reporter, but just a mere host, which many of the kuetians failed to realize. Days after days her public profile and her online shopping facebook page was smeared by an army of Kuetians poking at her dress, slutshaming, and with other derogatory remarks. It continued for days and days and days. A pop-youtuber Natalie Wynn coined the term “Morbid Cringe” to describe this effect. Morbid Cringe is when a person or a group of people get overly obsessed and contemptuously fascinated with a particular person or a certain group, or an idea. Just that happened with my fellow classmates. They got morbidly cringed out at the ekattor tv host and carried out an extensive harassment campaign without being conscious about the fact that it was a wrong thing to do. They can’t be blamed because they were immersed in a culture of impunity and negligent towards progressive social issues.</p><p>One parallel i noticed here is that, the defamation tactics are eternal. Remember the protofeminist that i talked of earlier? Mary Wollstonecraft. She was smeared against due to her erratic lifestyle and less for the substance of her work. A woman’s worth is reduced to the modesty standards she abides by. I found it in John Berger’s book “Ways of Seeing”. John says,</p><blockquote>A man’s presence suggests what he is capable of doing to you or for you. By contrast, a woman’s presence . . . defines what can and cannot be done to her</blockquote><p>He adds,</p><blockquote>One might simplify this by saying : men act and women appear. Men look at women. Women watch themselves being looked at. This determines not only most relations between men and women but also the relation of women to themselves. The surveyor of woman in herself is male: the surveyed female. Thus she turns herself into an object — and most particularly an object of vision: a sight.</blockquote><p>To extrapolate Berger’s wisdom in my timeline, i would like highlight another issue. Recently there had been a debacle on what constitutes the identity of a Kuetian. A girl doxxed an ex-kuetian masters student who did not continue his masters for some reason, for faking his kuetian identity. Personally i did not like the doxxing, because without being confirmed of anything it’s wrong to move on to a smear campaign. Many shared similar sentiments with me. Some asked her to apologize, which she says she did. But the problem arose, when some guy came forward to defame her following a past scandal which was absolutely unrelated to the issue that were being discussed upon. The girl was accused to have been intimate with a senior of her’s in a departmental building, which was later proved to be fake. But this issue was pulled up from the grave just to use as a weapon against her. What the girl did was highlight an issue on what constitutes a kuetian identity. instead she was attacked with ad hominems regarding her sexual scandals. A girl’s chastity is hence extremely important for her voices to be heard. Although the allegations against her, and the rumours were fake, but no one seemed to care, because her opponents have mastered the art of war and know how to obliterate their opponents.</p><p>The girl of my department that i talked about who opened up about her sexual harassment issue was also targeted with similar ad hominem tactics. Its easy to character assassinate a girl rather of a boy. A girl’s purity is like the social security card which ensures her voice will be heard. But the concept of purity, chastity itself is flawed. This is a classic distraction that people fall prey to due to the hidden layers of misogyny in his society which shapes the idea of a woman and their worth inside his mind. When i went to a meeting where the students were trying to come up with a solution i was charged by another friend on why i had been reacting. I told him it was a case of sexual harassment and there should be some repercussions or else the culture of impunity would only persist, and we would be to blame. He asks me why was i uttering this word “sexual harassment” and what does it even mean. I was dumbfounded and realized it was pointless to argue from then on. Another friend of mine says, she has a questionable character, and is notorious for using and exploiting guys and also living an erratic life. Now , considering the fact that such astronomical claims could in fact be true, which i or neither my pals could care the slightest bit about, we failed to realize how does that impact the assessment of the current issue. Their justification was that, based on past history we can overlook what happened and give the perpetrators a pass and close the case. I was feeling nauseated and got out of the room. The alumni i talked earlier about? She too was attacked for her dress up choice as an attempt to divert the attention from the perpetrator to her character and morale.</p><p>Do i blame them? No. Once i was like them too. I saw just my childhood reflection in those guys, where i was a dumb prankster. But soon i got to learn a thing a thing or two from the media and literature that i consumed. I would like to give the benefit of the doubt to my friends that they haven’t. After that incident i talked with a lot of those buddies of mine. we revisited what happened. And even though i wont claim i could change their minds i could at least say i could make them listen and ponder upon the facts. Had they been immersed into socio-political issues like i have been, they could easily realize those too. But is it their duty to do so? I do not think so. One reason being that, i voluntarily came across such facts, at the expense of my academic studies. My friends kept their academics intact, hence had less time to explore these topics. I strayed away from my mission and had to struggle later on. It should have been the duty of the institution to formally create an environment which promotes progressivism and aligns itself with liberal values. It was the duty of the institution to teach formally and in an structured way to students about progressive socio-cultural issues. We had social studies course but barely were such issues touched. Reading books were never inspired, case studies weren’t done neither studied, but a culture of slides and grade pursuits were followed which exacerbated the situation, because the students became more reluctant to these issues after such a boring course. Hence i don’t blame the ignorant. I blame the system that harboured their ignorance without trying to eradicate them.</p><h4>Re-examining my transitioned ideals</h4><p>Its all fun and games until contradictory reality hits. I was never into rap music but an epiphany hit me, when i stumbled upon a song by Doja Cat, “Juicy”.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FYIALlhlyqO4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DYIALlhlyqO4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FYIALlhlyqO4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3de55164ae4bdc247cf8ba83604b9b19/href">https://medium.com/media/3de55164ae4bdc247cf8ba83604b9b19/href</a></iframe><p>The song has some explicit imagery of the models, including Doja, portrayed as water-melons, cherries and some other luscious fruits. The reason it striked me is because, the allegations which sparked the metoo wave at kuet was that, some guys were inappropriately objectifying their female peer in their social media platform by comparing her to water melon, sandwich and other food items. It seemed absolutely justified to get triggered at such inappropriate behaviour from your peers. No one deserves to be denigrated so low, especially from the people they know and trust. But how can you expect much, when media objectification have normalized such concepts? Doja Cat’s song is one out of the many. And interestingly, i found no backlash for this particular song and its sexist portrayal too. When blurred lines by Robin Thicke came out, it created a huge amount of controversy. Although, blurred line does not have such explicit blatantly sexist portrayal, it received disproportionate backlash compared to Juicy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/0*avj3qyv_xKQEPg-q.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*r4IO5MmVKaooYc4A" /><figcaption>Protests against blurred lines.</figcaption></figure><p>Critics say blurred lines trivializes sexual consent and promotes rape culture, which caused the massive outrage. Some pointed out to the objectification element to it too. But if trivializing sexual consent is something to be so enraged about, then why shouldn’t objectification be the subject to similar outrage? Hip Hop music and many pop songs constantly promotes objectification in the name of art and women empowerment. After sex positivism started getting mainstream, in parallel so did media objectification. While sex positivism is a fine thing to achieve, on the other hand media objectification should be objectionable. If a culture endorses and glorifies objectification and then slams its men for objectifying it’s women, then this just shows a blatant hypocrisy. A popular narrative surrounding this is that, when women objectify themselves, then it is empowerment, but when others do it for them, like men, only then it is predatory. It denotes the power transfer from one group of people to another group of people from whom it had been stripped away. Hence many do not view it as objectionable, but something to celebrate. While the power transfer may make sense, but in my opinion, it’s just a cheap justification for capitalism. The capitalist media corporations use this cheap justification tactic to keep the supply chain alive. It might sound like a conspiracy at this point but i don’t think it is totally off base. When the discussions surrounding media objectifications were running rampant, the activists saw a future where objectifications would be close to being eradicated. But as a great anonymous person once said, “Sex Sells”. Hence the objectifications never goes away but instead comes under a different fancy wrapper, which is the term “empowerment”. Music, Advertisements, films etc are rampant with such sexist elements. I got to admit i was a little confused on this, since it seemed to me like advocating for a conservative viewpoint. It was usually conservatives who despised women coming on screens and always acted as a moral police to keep women away from media presentation, citing God and their holy scriptures. Now, just to oppose the God Brigade to break the shackles of women, we have inadvertently pushed them towards corporations who passively exploit their body and sexuality for financial profits. These are two extreme opposites of a spectrum, and the girls just oscillate from one end to another akin to tennis balls in a tennis court.</p><p>Now, you may argue that what if the perpetrators did not immerse themselves in sexist hip hop musics like Doja Cat’s Juicy or Tekashi69’s trollz or similar other media contents. I won’t claim that they do. Because in my 4 years of living in a boys hall, i have never seen them play any of these category of western musics aloud. But i did see them consuming media, local , hindi , and some pop stuffs from the west which were no less sexist or objectionable. In our departmental nights, many such music were danced to, played on the stage without anyone realizing what it was normalizing. It was all fun and games, rainbow and sunshine. But while these could be acted on good faith, the subtle normalization leads to the vile acts by the perpetrators which they consciously or subconsciously get engaged in. And the fun fact is that, in the race to consuming sexist media, girls and boys both go hand in hand. A feature of popular music is that it caters to both male and female audience . I can’t remember the names of the hyped media contents back then, since i never had the delicacy for them and didn’t much engage in them either, but trust me on this, there were, and there were a lot of such elements. People usually prefer party songs to celebrate an occasion with bass boosted linear, simple but high tempo beats and occasional bass drops. We were no different. In cultural nights, campfires, rag days, departmental fests or celebration of any kinds, the most popular songs were such high tempo bass boosted party songs. While the songs themselves are no problem, but what i want to highlight is that the trend in media consumption. Most of the popular party songs come from pop and hip hop artists, or DJ mixes. And the culture associated with such music scenes are mostly hypersexualized and objectified. I won’t say all are, but i can safely remark that most are. These media contents could be safely consumed had there been awareness among the students. But the problem is most of them are not aware of what they consume, they don’t realize the border between appropriateness and inappropriateness, and hence the influence from these media gets the better hold of their psyche. There is a reason why explicit media contents come up with an age restriction. Its assumed that, adults can be composed enough to just extract the entertainment value out of the piece of work instead getting mindlessly influenced which juveniles may be driven to. Its assumed that adults already have had the socialization, education and mental growth to learn to differentiate between right and wrong, appropriate and inappropriate. But the problem is, being a conservative country we have made the discussions regarding sexuality and social dynamics such a taboo, that people barely get the option to learn. The highest form of training that we get are from social circles, and peer influences. Hence the better the peers, the better the maturity, and on the contrary, the worse the peers, the more dominant are juvenile tendencies. But this was not supposed to happen. It should have been the duty of the state to ensure a formal training through which the juveniles can learn appropriate social dynamics and become mature functioning adults of societies. Party songs or Item songs couldn’t have had much effect that way. Although personally i am a little skeptic on how much a pre-awareness program actually is effective to completely shield from negatively getting influenced, but i can safely assume that it would have certainly ameliorated things, and help people realize the thin line between right and wrong.</p><p>Adding to normalization of objectionable and objectifying media contents, the ignorance of socio-cultural dynamics and the culture of impunity &amp; negligence exacerbates the status quo. So how much can the guys who engage inappropriately can be actually blamed? While this is definitely wrong, but aren’t they just a product of their environment and atmosphere?</p><p>Also the narratives surrounding objectifications vary as well depending on context and the economics behind it. There was a popular joke, while it itself is sexist, but is not quite off base.</p><blockquote>Churchill: “Madam, would you sleep with me for five million pounds?” <br>Socialite: “Well, I suppose… we would have to discuss terms, of course… “ Churchill: “Would you sleep with me for five pounds?” <br>Socialite: “Mr. Churchill, what kind of woman do you think I am?!” <br>Churchill: “Madam, we’ve already established that. Now we are haggling about the price”</blockquote><p>Now why i am quoting this, and saying this is not totally off base, check this video by Time, where they cite a study claiming how women become okay with objectification when the associated product is expensive, and not cheap.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fha97-2Bbz0g%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dha97-2Bbz0g&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fha97-2Bbz0g%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5d9763a5b3b0be624de1d1fdc0ffe678/href">https://medium.com/media/5d9763a5b3b0be624de1d1fdc0ffe678/href</a></iframe><p>Does sending such mixed signals help or does it further deteriorate an already existing objectified culture? I don’t know. Maybe a more intensive analysis needs to be done.</p><p>Let me present to you another case study. It’s about Neo-Burlesque. neo Burlesque is the revival of american burlesque culture which comprises of various acts such as stripteases, modern dance, theatrical mini dramas etc. Now the burlesque act is justified to be empowering to women, because women have the power to themselves and they are celebrating their bodies for fun and recreational purposes. Now if you feel this to be some corporate voodoo talk, you will be on the same side as me. But let me present you two sides of the story through this report attached below.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FPMo7X_feEyg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DPMo7X_feEyg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FPMo7X_feEyg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4208dc8fbf406abe7896f58ce9ac152c/href">https://medium.com/media/4208dc8fbf406abe7896f58ce9ac152c/href</a></iframe><p>While the video presents mostly justification by burlesque dancers and less criticisms from the feminist critics, it also unconsciously draws the parallel between the Time’s report and the burlesque culture. How glamour and money can drastically change and adjust narratives regarding female objectification. This also indicates how popular pop music and hip hop songs get away with objectifying women and denigrating them to sexual playtools. It’s the money behind which always decides for the women what is okay, and what is not okay.</p><p>When Anita Sarkeesian and others pointed out the unnecessary sexist portrayals lying subtly hidden in video games, for example hypersexualization of female characters to please the overly dominant male audience of video games, they were not received well either. Gamergate happened as a response to that. Most who defended the gaming industry defended on the grounds that, if it is normal for media to exploit the image of a female body to please their audience why shouldn’t it be normal for gaming industry to follow the same route. It’s not like that it doesn’t make sense at all. Guys would want to protect male gazes, corporations would want to protect their revenues, and feminists would adjust themselves under the guise of individual empowerment to reap some of the benefits off the capitalist system. And thus, the perpetuation of such sexist objectified culture by all sides, inadvertently assists in deteriorating the image of women which some feminists have been fighting to improve for decades. The recent feminist movements have been more individualistic, hijacked by neoliberalism, which deteriorated the already existing hostile environment for women, but now bolstered with corporate aid. Below is a article from Megan Murphy who highlights this particular problem in more detail.</p><p><a href="https://www.feministcurrent.com/2011/02/04/burlesque-they-tell-me-its-just-for-fun-except-im-not-having-any/">Burlesque: They tell me it&#39;s just for fun...Except I&#39;m not having any.</a></p><p>it’s quite crazy, how money and capitalism can sabotage a whole movement in the matter of seconds!</p><p>So how much are the guys to actually blame? When such a normalized, and glorified culture persists? When the dominant social narratives pushes all to objectify women to keep the cycle of the consumerism running.</p><p>But this too comes with a contradiction. Such levels of moral policing comes along with a rabbit hole towards hardline conservatism. What constitutes objectification? How much artistic freedom could be practiced? Such questions might inadvertently turn a culture more regressive than expected. For example just two days ago, egypt sentenced several women were condemned to 2 years of prison over some silly tiktok videos, citing the videos as indecent and immoral. Now, egypt’s such decision stem from religious conservatism rather than feminism which are conflicting in some sense, but the conservative moral forces sometimes utilize feminist causes to oppress women even more and send them back to their confined niches.</p><p><a href="https://time.com/5872610/egypt-women-prison-tiktok-videos/">Egyptian Women Get 2 Years in Prison for &#39;Indecent&#39; TikTok Dance Videos</a></p><p>In iran an 18 year old teenage girl named Maedeh Hojabri was arrested for posting a dancing video of hers in her instagram, upon the claims that the videos were emanating indecency.</p><p><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jul/08/iran-woman-arrested-instagram-video-dancing">Woman arrested in Iran over Instagram video of her dancing</a></p><p>Now it was not the first time iran launched a war on its women. 4 years earlier several others were also detained on similar charges, since they appeared to have danced on pharrell williams’s song “Happy” on their social media platform, which was a very popular trend at that time globally.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-29272732">Iran Happy dancers given 91 lashes</a></p><p>Moral policing in fact plagues most conservative islamic societies around the middle east which bars women from exercising their socio-economic freedom in those societies and creates a culture of segregation. Moral police is in fact a structured, well established, state sponsored dedicated group who actively monitor moral violations in countries like saudi arabia, sudan, malaysia etc.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-36101150#:~:text=SAUDI%20ARABIA,-AFP%20Public%20socialising&amp;text=Who%20they%20are%3A%20Formed%20in,covering%20all%20but%20their%20eyes.">Who are Islamic &#39;morality police&#39;?</a></p><p>Now, what do these instances imply to us? Should we move out from neoliberal objectifying culture to a more regressive, segregative and oppressing culture? i can’t tell for sure as to where to draw the line. Although context does matter, but i am just trying to show you how feminist causes can be hijacked and help fundamentalist conservative sentiments to mobilize. And those who are on the liberal aisle, sometimes as a response or retaliation inadvertently end up advocating for neoliberalism, which perpetuates the objectification and hypersexualization of women.</p><p>I remember the time when a friend of mine said to me, “Do you consider everything that a girl says to be true?” I was then on believe all women team. It was the pinnacle of metoo movement at that time and this was the most dominant and popular narrative. The narrative was endorsed by Nytimes after Kavanaugh assault cases started to surface. Though after Joe Biden sexual assault cases started to appear, nytimes crew and all the supporters of this campaign took a backflip. Then the discussion went into more trivial semantic debates, like it was never “believe all women” but “believe women” which drastically changes the narrative. The conservative media outlets criticized it claiming such narratives were always political instead of actual virtue, and hence showing liberal hypocrisy.</p><p>Were they totally off base? i do not think so.</p><p>Metoo campaigns can easily be exploited for political purpose and to take someone down. Since it relies on mob justice, and gaslights anyone who disagrees, it can be used as a perfect tool to bring someone down or achieve political goals, and in some cases reap some personal benefits or in fact revenge. It happened with democrats hijacking metoo for smearing kavanaugh, it happened with republicans hijacking metoo for smearing biden. When trump was elected, it was deemed to be a defeat for the women, since trump was accused to one of the most vilest misogynist. Women’s march took place as a protest to his rise to presidency.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AT0m-Z8Xuh4YDlmj.jpg" /><figcaption>Women’s March</figcaption></figure><p>While the accusation against trump are not astronomical rather idiotic locker room talks and some bits of conservative denigrating viewpoints on women, it was not deserving of such disproportionate reaction. But the fueling was astronomical due to liberal leaning media endorsements, which helps less to woman’s actual causes but aids a political party over another, in my opinion.</p><p>In January 2018, comedian Aziz Ansari was accused to have sexually abused a women with whom he hooked up for a night. The claim took a toll on Aziz’s career since when such a stigma comes towards a person it propels others to dissociate with the person in order to save their image or their business. Later although the mob shifted towards supporting Aziz, but the toll he had to take were disproportionate without any repercussions on the accusers side. What happened to be a bad sex, was turned into a sexual abuse.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FteBlqboyxbw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DteBlqboyxbw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FteBlqboyxbw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ae4ffca6d6aed3b6429046f43919274a/href">https://medium.com/media/ae4ffca6d6aed3b6429046f43919274a/href</a></iframe><p>What started as a voice for vulnerable women to voice their sexual harassing experiences has become so wide and ambiguous that it started to divide women themselves, on the effectiveness of the whole thing. Tarana burke who is credited to have coined the term metoo in 2006 has told the atlantic that the movement started to encompass all ideas under one umbrella while this was not the initial purpose, and hence its losing its grounds. In fact check the video below where atlantic writer caitlin flanagan discusses the problems associated with the movement. Here she too can be seen to echo the similar sentiment as how measuring trivial problems within the same scale as the horrifying ones ultimately started to nullify the cause of metoo.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FMsCtfr6Dfa0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DMsCtfr6Dfa0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FMsCtfr6Dfa0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/fa35f6b82b15740208c51c979498a0d3/href">https://medium.com/media/fa35f6b82b15740208c51c979498a0d3/href</a></iframe><p>Since Metoo relied on mob justice and ignored due process, it opened up room for false allegations. Since the potential impact of false or exaggerated allegations have been overlooked by many activists, many potential allies who happened to be men, have sided away to not risk themselves. For example, Aziz Ansari himself was a metoo ally but then the boomerang hit him, and it hit him bad. In fact women themselves have expressed concerns over the possible dismantle of the whole movement due to misappropriating the whole thing. Check the survey by Vox below where women were asked how much concerned on these issues.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qTtg264w5Q2DO6DR.jpg" /></figure><p>Also, this was a good read too, from Harvard Business Review, which shows how the gross sweeping generalizations and mob justice culture started to backfire the whole movement. How company officials are backing away from recruiting women to play safe, how interactions, co-operations were being affected out of paranoia of the mob culture and etc.</p><p><a href="https://hbr.org/2019/09/the-metoo-backlash">The #MeToo Backlash</a></p><p>Germaine Greer, author of the female eunuch, and a second wave feminism pioneer echoes a similar sentiment. Though citing a controversial person like Greer is not a wise choice, but given her experience on feminism, and her herself being a feminist pioneer of the second wave, it would be even more unwise to leave her out of the discussion. And seeing her views i do feel like she is not totally off base while many of the new age feminist would disagree. I first came across greer’s views in Al jazeera’s Head to Head segment with Mehdi Hasan. If you are interested you might give it a shot and check the whole 1 and a half hour segment out. But Mehdi’s belligerence might annoy you hence i am attaching another video of her views where she is allowed to express herself more clearly without getting interrupted.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FL1UmEVW4eUo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DL1UmEVW4eUo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FL1UmEVW4eUo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/99e969c83d57ef6a10fb7d6fd809cbfa/href">https://medium.com/media/99e969c83d57ef6a10fb7d6fd809cbfa/href</a></iframe><p>Many second wave feminist are on greer’s side, citing the negligence of due process and privileged women utilizing it for monetary, political or vengeful gains, which might inadvertently hurt women’s cause. Margaret Atwood for example has also received major backlash for questioning the integrity of metoo movement when a colleague of her’s was accused of sexual misconduct. While it might feel like she was acting on favouritism, but the substance of Atwood’s arguments make no less sense. She argues that a to hold every woman as angelic would be unconsciously stripping them off their moral agency. A woman is capable of making good or bad moral choices, and hence everyone deserves a due process before facing any social or institutional repercussion. Below is the link to the Op-ed for which Margaret Atwood had a storm of backlash against her.</p><p><a href="https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/am-i-a-bad-feminist/article37591823/">Opinion: Am I a bad feminist?</a></p><p>With the rise of trans acceptance and sex positivism, more divisions of feminism had been created. Swerf for example, are referred to those who support radical feminism but does not support sex work since they consider it to be dehumanizing to women. They accuse liberal feminists of being so individual centric, that they ignore feminist histories where women were only subjected to the servitude of men, and how sex work, pornography are just a perpetuation of the past. They feel that neoliberal feminist is wrong in the sense that it considers the individual to be above all, and that having the option to “choose” is the most feminist issue there could be, ignoring the fact it may contribute to the wider discrimination to marginalized women or women of poor underprivileged class, since it normalizes objectification.</p><p><a href="https://www.feministcurrent.com/2015/11/04/shit-liberal-feminists-say-swerf/">Shit liberal feminists say: SWERF</a></p><p>Then comes Twerfs, another group of radical feminists who are opposed to transgender activist and who else to cite on this other than the great J.K Rowling. J.K Rowling and her allies fear that transgender activism have overshadowed actual feminist causes, smearing women’s safe spaces. They fear that the years of accumulated progress to ameliorate woman’s condition in society is being systematically destroyed by trying to obfuscate gender identities. Also rowling argues that such ambiguity surrounding gender identity does huge disservice to the children’s psyche. Rowling’s full view can be found in her blogpost from June 10 in her personal website.</p><p><a href="https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-her-reasons-for-speaking-out-on-sex-and-gender-issues/">J.K. Rowling Writes about Her Reasons for Speaking out on Sex and Gender Issues - J.K. Rowling</a></p><p>Now seeing all these feminist divisiveness, and tons and tons of contradictions i have started to move towards a more benign and skeptical position. I understood that there is not a linear narrative and that all ends can have fair logics on their side. To wholly side with one group would do a disservice to the other. And this was one of the tipping point. What if i myself got a fake allegation hanging on my head? In Bangladesh, when the privileged english medium children brought metoo in social media sphere, it was massively celebrated, as a step forward towards bettering women’s lives in bangladesh. While it itself was more of a privileged class echo chamber rather than a marginal voice, but soon it too started to break apart. I saw germaine greer’s sentiments coming into action, that metoo will evidently fail, for a lack of structure.</p><p>There was a Bangladeshi group in facebook, “Healthy minds” who championed girls coming forward with their abuse stories. While the success of the group was to destigmatize women coming out with their abuse experiences, it parallely endorsed mob justice and as a consequence, ate itself up. Numerous fake allegations and exaggerated claims started popping up, which eventually turned people against the whole thing. Once a popular blogger imtiaz mahmood was metooed as well. Imtiaz Mahmood was accused to have sent indecent messages to a woman and eventually for having exploited her. But later it was revealed to be a baseless smear attempt too. Thus, the absence of due process started to undermine the whole movement, and it again started to unfold in front of my eyes.</p><p>What metoo fails to realize is that it opens up the option for people to be falsely tried. In the court of public opinion, the justice narrative that, “innocent until proven guilty” have shifted towards the narrative “Guilty until proven innocent”. Many activists argued that, the small amount of falsely accused can be expendable because large proportion of women are getting justice. But they fail to realize that being wrongfully tried is a worse situation to fall in, and to ignore these particular victims is to attack one of the foundation of the justice system, which is the Blackstone’s Ratio. Blackstone’s ration states that,</p><blockquote>It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer</blockquote><p>Now this have been the foundation to establish the notion of innocent until proven guilty. But in the court of the mob, you are guilty until proven innocent. Hence, the structurelessness of the whole is the root of it getting slowly exploited and decimated, and even turning potential allies against the thing out of paranoia.</p><p>Check Bari Weiss, an Nytimes contributor discuss this issue on Bill Maher show.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FE6lCPvwiIqo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DE6lCPvwiIqo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FE6lCPvwiIqo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d19c1b2c11ed986200a4769e1956b2f4/href">https://medium.com/media/d19c1b2c11ed986200a4769e1956b2f4/href</a></iframe><p>So have i too looked over the fact if the backlash which our departmental senior received when he was metooed was disproportionate or not? Now after two years of it happening, I tend to think so. What he did, was relatively mild compared to the smear he received. But was it necessary for the girl to speak out? Yes, otherwise the issue would never have come up. Someone had to speak out to break the ignorance of others about such issues, to take the blindfold off their eyes. What she did was bold and necessary to highlight the abusive culture that predominates at Kuet. But it did come at a cost, at a cost of disproportionate backlash, along with the cost of psychological stress of some of her allies who were acting as mediators. They were trying to diplomatically handle the situation, since in a political atmosphere and a impunity dominant culture won’t let you get away with the highest forms of justice, and so diplomacy was to be resorted to. But it was a double edged sword for the mediators, since they tried to bring out the optimum result but at the cost of being not able to satisfy the victim and also earning the wrath of the guy brigade. At those times i was virtually not taking any of the side hustles into considerations. Now that i realize, i feel bad for ignoring the struggle some of the guys had to go through.</p><p>Also guillotining someone and fully ostracizing is not an option either. Since the perpetrators are too a product of society which endorses objectification and harbours the culture of sexual harassment, so ostracizing them like murder assailants feels far stretched at this point. It could have been done, if they understood the weight of the whole thing, and still violated it, but as one friend of mine asked of me, “ what do you mean by ‘sexual harassment’, what does it even mean”. So is it justifiable to expect them to act like saints to whom the revelation had not reached yet?</p><p>I maybe wrong on a lot of stances that i discussed here , but i am happy to be proven wrong. If convincing counter arguments, evidences come forth i would happily align myself accordingly. Because ofc, we are learners, we constantly learn.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=adfccb7b4668" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Post Modern Truth]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/post-modern-truth-ee9a7092167e?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee9a7092167e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Jul 2020 15:23:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-07T19:15:03.504Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*A2ZNB4L1Yg67YNT-.png" /></figure><p>GRE Prep (B+C):</p><p>Social media has burgeoned social tensions like never before. it has divided people, sensationalized even the most banal and trivial things. The giant multinational companies which bolstered facebook’s existence with billions of dollars of advertisements, are gradually on the route of boycotting the platform. Already Mr. Zuckerberg has lost around 7 billions and if all the companies continue their boycott it would cost upto 70 billions for facebook. It all started after bombastic claims of facebook condoning racist, boorish, hateful contents started to surface online. A non profit organization, Stop Profit for Hate called for a massive boycott, where companies after companies responded and buttressed the cause. Zuckerberg and his team tried to burnish their corroded image through talking with the activists at the NGO, revisiting and reconsidering their policies, but sadly to no avail. Facebook is starting to lose its ground as a socially beneficent tool rather picking up the image of a socially destructive and divisive one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OO6zFfrcRC5TE1jI.jpg" /></figure><p>But, this raises a question. Is castigation of such a magnitude is actually justifiable? Social dynamics, especially when occurring online are capricious in nature, and policing them is a double edged sword. If you stand up for free speech, you cant go on censoring everything that might go against your views or opinions. On the other hand, if you let free speech free speech loose, it can cause catastrophic damage in the form of fake news, mass bullying, doxing, gaslighting, cancelling etc which may have devastating socio-political impacts or may push an individual towards destruction. This is a confounded issue to to solve, with no black and white answer to it. To be complaisant to each customer is not practically possible. It all started to go downhill for facebook after twitter factchecked Donald Trump on a series of tweets on mail in ballots, the source of which was of course, CNN. This little incident acted as the catalyst to facebook’s downfall. Trump admonished twitter for factchecking him, accusing them of censoring his free speech. Twitter denied to step back from factchecking misleading contents even if those are from big shots like the president himself. Trump threatened twitter with litigation, but to no avail. When facebook was asked if they would follow twitter in converging towards a safe space in the internet, zuckerberg said no. He advocated for free speech. Things started to get a lot of escalated from that point on. Facebook’s stance was not conciliatory with facebook’s progressive public outlook, which advocates for diversities and safe space. To remain compliant with the current social status quo, zuckerberg had to side with the progressives. But in my opnion, zuckerberg may have made the move not to go against progressives but to avoid contention with the govt. which were already accusing facebook of allowing election meddling by russian online troll armies. The cambridge analytica compendium was a severe blow to facebook’s reputation, losing them many of their customers and causing them face show-cause in senate. While seeing twitter getting a political blowback, facebook clearly wanted to avoid the contention with the government based on their past learning. Facebook therefore played a craven move here to stay on the safe side in this drama. But were the wrong at maths, this instead hit them harder than ever. The drama so convoluted and facebook inadverdently got so intertwined with it, that within the matter of 2 hours facebook lost 7 billions. The conundrum of online social dynamics is hard to crack. One miscalculated step may end up your career, or collapse an entire industry. No matter how much contrite you might become afterwards, it might not be enough to undo the damage Compliant with the public will is a must. But what needs to be measured, is the loudness of the groups and the shift in public opinions. Companies are unconscious entities which have one goal in mind, to profit. The companies joining stop hate for profit campaign also joined the cause as a business move, because at the end public image translates into money too, hence they seem to compliant along with the shifting and popular opinion of their target demographic. One needs to realize, there is no absolute truth. In a post modern world, truth is subjective and depends on the loudness of a group and the political backups behind them. Every field of academia, which once was thought to be independent are too somehow depended on corporation money, public funding and money from local and international students. whenever money dependency comes in, so comes constraints. Their outputs therefore somehow align to the status quo mostly if not always, reinforcing ideas which are gaining momentum among a significant demographic. The linearization of ideas has not yet reached an alarming state, true. Most chicaneries sweep in the fields of social science, where objective experimentation is tough to model, hence sometimes wrong codas get brought out by the authors which may or may not be shaped by their bias. The caustic issues of todays, like the trans issue debate, or the race debate, or the diversity debates, immigration debates rarely get opposing and critical viewpoints published out of fear of backlash. Even Nytimes, which is a coagulation of leftist ideas, published an article yesterday how their stance on Covid-19 spread trajectory got influenced by the question of racial gatherings. The inconsistency of these scientific stances clearly depicts a fear of incommensurate public backlash and the fear of getting cancelled out. We are having a group connoisseurs from all public spheres who apparently claim to have monopoly on the truth, despite not being a practitioner of nuances, whose loud voice is cogent enough for the public discourse to get lineralized, and academia along with corporations to act along with their sideline. Because ultimately strength in numbers, or to be more precise, the dominant numbers. In my honest opinion, we should at least spare the academia, and keep it free from the fear of backlash, because we cannot afford losing trust on this side, unless we are prepared to face a growing substantiated distrust in this sector which would have long lasting ill impact on every aspect of lives. Fuck the industries, they can eat shit for all i care.</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/06/us/Epidemiologists-coronavirus-protests-quarantine.html?referringSource=articleShare">https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/06/us/Epidemiologists-coronavirus-protests-quarantine.html?referringSource=articleShare</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee9a7092167e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Blinded by Diplomacy]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/blinded-by-diplomacy-439a4a2afbf6?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/439a4a2afbf6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Jul 2020 15:44:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-13T07:30:47.184Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*3Y8IozAXKEhuBMmi.jpg" /><figcaption>War Criminal Portrayal of Henry Kissinger.</figcaption></figure><p>GRE Prep “A”:</p><p>Abated are the actions of the charismatic leaders and policy makers, which resulted in loss of millions for nationalistic and personal profits. Every nation in the world engages in bloody wars, every political leaders get their hands dirty but the winners always get a free pass, and the losers end up in jail unless of course, they run away in abscondence. The ones who are spared are the ones harboring power in all sector of the government and the judiciary, and continue on with their legacy of human rights violation, aggregating pages after pages of blood-soaked woes of the innocents. How to alleviate the miseries of the unheard voices? No abeyance of justice and moving straight to trial? Seek justice from who? The ones who pull the strings from behind? You know nothing Jon Snow. The aesthetics of diplomacy and the aberrance from moral guidance in policy making are one of the greatest, devilish display of statesmanship. Its all a game. Those making the right moves wins. Adulteration of documents, distractions, murders, kidnap, genocide all are allowed till it falls under the best interest of the nation. Those making the right move at right time wins and the their criminal charges alleviated, destroyed and thrown into ambiguity. The austerity of the statesmen are stunning, when carrying on genocides, or when straight on denying them. The antipathy to justice and human life is not the way of diplomacy. Its a chess game and the winner gets to decide who is to consider human and who is not, what is justice and what is not. The media presentation is also confusing, hard to determine. The amalgamation of heroic and villainy representation, or just heroic, or just straight on demonic portrayals. Public opinion is shaped by media. So they try to shape media portrayal too, as they feel fit. Like Kissinger who was one of the celebrity media figures. But behind that celebrity persona, ran a sinister rodent inside the head of this vile diplomat.<br>In the name of amelioration of the people who are being either tortured by dictators or anachronistic communist rebels, Kissinger sanctioned wars on innocents. But the likes of Kissinger are very crafty, like an abstemious super model, they will keep their genocidal counts in check, not binging on them like Hitler or Stalin and the likes of them did. They will advocate for peace and show a state of anarchy in the state they are willing to attack, to reinstate peace of course. What happens instead of peace is a state of more anomaly, violence and famine. But its all justified of course, because they are fighting the greater evil and some level of apathy if therefore justified. As Kissinger told in one of his interviews, in statesmanship morality doesn’t work, you’ve got to choose between two evils. This artless acknowledgement is enough to understand the ascetic indifference they hold for the lives of the layman. Kissinger was very cynic in his deals, and calculative. He didn’t need approbations to devise his policies, because he was authorized to be the highest policy maker by the likes Nixons and Fords, due to his history as a great analyst and a nerdy persona. Nixon came in power with a pledge to assuage the wars in Vietnam, instead he amplified it once taking power, of course under the influence of one person, Kissinger. Genocides after genocides were sanctioned, rather being attenuated as was the pledge. And what was the reward? A NOBEL PRIZE of course.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/307/0*B7gG0W_WfM7WO4Va.jpg" /><figcaption>Kissinger in his Nobel prize ceremony</figcaption></figure><p>it has been proven over and over again, that what better way to score a Nobel peace prize other than committing or consenting to mass genocides. Now this is a rhetoric here that i am using of course. But nonetheless genocidal maniacs getting Nobel peace prizes would always hold to be true. The autonomous government of Cambodia who were neither on south or north Vietnamese’s side were bombed and massacred through Kissinger’s orders to instigate fear and pressure on the region and make the US presence known. The way these killers and their bootlickers aver their Nobel motives in doing so is utterly sickening. This is where we need Bernie Sanders who can aver the truth about these mass murders in public debate, where the likes of hillary can just dodge. Hitchens was a hero, for he through his arduous and assiduous investigation busted Kissinger for who he was, a war criminal. When apprised with Hitchen’s investigation findings, of course Kissinger being the cunning diplomats, denies all allegation by appropriating one of Hitchens investigations on Mother Teresa. “ Anyone vilifying a saint like Mother Teresa cannot be taken seriously”, Kissinger says. The alacritous lionizing by the media of a crafty diplomat therefore needs a Hitchens checkpoint to filter out the hyperbole and bring out the truth to the public. And the only way the innocent dead souls can be appeased is to revoke the Nobel peace prize of these genocidal warlords and bring them to trial, just like the loser leaders who were tried for war crimes, and so should Kissinger, Haig, and allies. Please, read the fantastic book “ The trial of Henry Kissinger “ By Hitchens to realize the war crimes of Kissinger in full. Hitchens and the likes comes and goes, admonishing us of the evil of sacredizing warlords, yet we keep on praising them and of course keep on awarding them Nobel Prize for peace.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=439a4a2afbf6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Art and Beauty]]></title>
            <link>https://fathunkarim.medium.com/on-art-and-beauty-bcfde4d66ab?source=rss-7b8513959c2b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bcfde4d66ab</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fattah Fathun Karim]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 May 2020 13:15:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-22T18:36:40.640Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>An objective look into the subjective</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4y9bD4Eti5vS5F6K" /><figcaption>“Paris abducting Helen”, Artist — Gavin Hamilton</figcaption></figure><p>Oh god not this debate again!</p><p>Back at the end of my uni days, i engaged in a lot of surrogate activities with my long term partner Mrinmoy and many other friends. We had a lot of taste in common, in the field of entertainments mostly, but apart from that we had another thing in common, an aptitude for debates. There were a lot of other friends with whom i used to discuss interesting issues for nights long, but those could never reach the heights of adrenaline rush as it was with Mrinmoy. It was mostly due to his adamancy that others lacked, and it also pointed out to me that i need to organize my thoughts more and gather around adequate amount of concrete evidence to come forth with a convincing argument. Not that i couldn’t convince the guy, i could in most of the times, but some of the invested time and energy could have been spared had my opinions been more organized. And what better ways are there to satisfy this need other than writing and noting things down… well i for once can’t think of any, so i came here running in just to do that.</p><p>Dream Theater or Opeth? Nights and nights went debating but yet no concluding answers. I always opted for DT and Mrinmoy took Opeth. The reasoning of him was that Opeth could convey more emotions in him but DT could not which evidently makes Opeth better musicians than the DT. I disagreed and prefered DT to be better musicians than Opeth. My reasoning was, relatively speaking, that DT was technically more sophisticated, had more structured songwriting and the members had more command on their instruments while playing live. Also, DT has speed, techniques, melodies, harmonies and can render intense emotions. Opeth works on a certain mood mostly while DT’s ones are experimental and have mood switches in between which many people fail to keep track of. Both bands have signature tonality and comparing the emotions of their songs would be like comparing sweet and sour. But the bottom line i wanted to bring out is that, while feelings can be subjective, we can at least judge the quality of the musicians by the technical engineering of the song. How much intellect were invested and how much skills have had to be mastered for coming up with something like this. We can at least seek out some objective criteria like this to judge the quality of an artwork, at least that was my opinion back then.</p><p>I further laid my case by bringing up examples of beethoven, bach, mozart and the pioneering classical musicians. My buddy used to be a fan of Hans Zimmer and he used to think that Zimmer was better musician than the likes of Beethoven and others, since the feelings rendered by them were not remotely close to Zimmer’s, he used to say. But does that make Zimmer good? I mean, many people like many things, but without a sound reasoning should we accept anyone’s version of criticism of such artistic expressions? In that case, many girls who like Taylor Swift can say that too, “ I am touched and moved by break-up songs (mind you, the woman made up 76% of her songs on breakup from what i could find in google). So just because the breakup songs touched more young girls, does that make Taylor swift a superior musician than the likes of Beethoven, Bach or others? Or Hans Zimmer? You can see the parallels in lots of other musicians. Kanye or Steven Wilson? Ed Sheeran or Vangelis? Drake or Josh? (pardon the pun: i meant Joshua from queens of stone age, of course). Now before you accuse me of comparing two different subset of people with two completely different musical genre, well that was initial point too, its not possible to compare the “feelings” rendered by two different genre, but at least we can compare the content that lies underneath them, the musical intricacies, the richness and diversity of the whole sound etc. At least that was my point so far back then.</p><p>But soon it kicked me, i maybe am just comparing someone’s technical skills, grammar sense and intellectual capacities, not the beauty of the thing. I read in Harari’s book about the concept of beauty first, that is, modern notion of beauty is that “Beauty is in the eye of the beholder”. The term was coined by Margaret Wolfe Hungerford, in the year 1878 and it gained traction since then. But similar sentiment before were echoed in Shakespeare&#39;s works, in Hume’s Works and of some other writers. But the term got its momentum after Hungerford coining it up and has remained like that since. This is the first argument you will see when you would come to analyze art and artistic substances. It is often a popular escape tactic which works by drawing a quick conclusion. The notion that art is subjective is both a good argument and also an escape route. In one hand it is an intellectually lazy position to take, and on the other hand it does have some legitimacy into it.</p><p>But, Beauty was not always in the eyes of the beholder. The subjective notion of art is quite recent as i expressed in my last passage. So what were the standard of beauty at the past? the aesthetics of art? the standard through which people judged creativity of others and drowned into an ocean of elitism? Lets take the help of history on how our perceptions of beauty and appreciation of artworks evolved through time.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FiEy1BxMVUzk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DiEy1BxMVUzk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FiEy1BxMVUzk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/be88bcb962eb19afff42af25824d245e/href">https://medium.com/media/be88bcb962eb19afff42af25824d245e/href</a></iframe><h3>A brief glance on the evolutionary timeline:</h3><p>The Greeks defined beauty on many levels. Some Greek philosophers thought that beauty was to be associated with anything good, virtuous, noble. Anything that did not fit in that category was in fact not to be considered “beautiful”. Thus beauty got itself entangled with divinity, hypermasculinity and things alike. Greeks did not practice abstract beauty, instead emulated reality at its finest, even the notions of divinity were to be seen as hypermasculine, exalted reflection of reality. Heraclitus of Ephesus said,</p><blockquote><em>To God all things are beautiful, good, right.</em></blockquote><p>The reflection of all the noble standards of beauty are quite evident in the embodiment of the Greek gods, the Olympians, the pantheons and the overall sculptural representation of the gods and godly affairs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*MhZTPAPwdDyWhobj.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Zeus</strong></figcaption></figure><p>As for the hedonist Greeks, happiness was the ultimate beauty, happiness being considered to be the ultimate pursuit by them. Theognis, a Greek poet, for example said,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/964/0*UQXM_aLXjZnxgJo0.png" /><figcaption><strong>Theognis</strong></figcaption></figure><blockquote>Beauty is all that pleases.</blockquote><p>Socrates categorized beauty into three parts, the ideal beauty, the spiritual beauty and the functional beauty. The ideal beauty reflected nature, spiritual beauty was reflected through the eyes, and useful beauty had functional value. Plato considered beauty to be an extension of Pythagorean principle, that is harmony and proportion, added with splendour. Plato proposed the thought of inner beauty. Plato’s teacher Socrates was deemed to be hideously ugly by the standard of that time, so it’s no wonder that his devoted disciple would come up with such a concept. Plato told that the soul lies within the frame of the earthly body and therefore the beauty of the thing cannot be comprehended by all. So he said, beauty is a matter of intellectual insights and realization which requires intense philosophical wisdom. Plato therefore proposed to ban art in the contemporary schools which he thought was morally degrading to the youth since they were pursuing a delusional concept of beauty in those places. He instead proposed to stick to geometrical beauty, which was the Pythagorean school of thought on beauty.</p><p>Pythagoreans figured out that beauty was associated with mathematics. Pythagoras used to have a firm notion that all things had origin in numbers. Everything exists because they are ordered, and they are ordered because that’s how mathematical laws governed them to be. Through this mathematics springs up the conditions for beauty and existence. Pythagoreans assigned number to everything. And in fact every number had a certain physical or metaphysical representation. 1 was the number of reason, 2 was the number for females and opinions, 3 was the number for males and harmony, 4 was the number of justice, 5 meant marriage, 6 meant creation etc. One of the most interesting instance of pythagorean’s numerical notions was the Tetraktys.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/0*XCt5SF7vuWynmPs3.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/373/0*82eCE0StguNB0XNC.jpg" /><figcaption>Tetraktys in pythagorean periods</figcaption></figure><p>A Tetraktys has four points on each sides. Four thus represented strength, justice and solidity. The total points of the tetraktys’ sides, counted individually sums up to be 10. With the first 10 digits, all number can be represented. As number was considered to be the essence of everything, so Tetraktys was the representation of the condensation of universal wisdom, which held all the numerical marvel and numerical operations in within. <br>Pythagoreans analyzed music in terms of mathematics, they laid out the mathematical foundation of music with notational proportions, ratios, inventing musical scales, modes etc. The knowledge of the proportional principle was then later on manifested into greek architectures. The structures were built along to similar proportions that dictated the grammars of music.</p><p>Moving on to the medieval period, we start to see more evolved version of the concept of beauty. Thomas Aquinas laid out the idea that, for beauty to exist, not only does it need proportion, but also integrity. The thing should have a wholeness to it and all parts of its original self should be intact. Considering which, an amputated person or an animal would be ugly, for they lack the wholeness to them. Or a guitar without a pair of strings would be ugly, because its not in its absolute form. Aquinas gave some other conditions for something to be beautiful too. He added splendour and clarity to his already existing points too. He put an emphasis on colours. He implied that an object’s physical form should manifest at its purest to be considered beautiful and the radiance of the object is therefore as important as the structural part. But medieval transition to the concept was mostly steered by christian theological influences. Before Aquinas, St. Augustine addressed the matter of beauty along with being, as both being rooted in the Creator of the Universe. It is the creator through whom comes goodness, virtue and beauty. Through a rational understanding of all God’s creation can we earn divinity and purification. And also the concept of light being an integral component of beauty gained pace too. Since, god is associated with light and demons are associated with darkness, hence light is beauty and darkness, irradiance is not.</p><p>With the dwindling romance with christianity and god, the thinkers of the later age scrutinized the concept even deeper, and with a more ungodly but materialistic viewpoint. In the fifteenth and sixteenth century, beauty was seemingly an affair between invention and imitation. An artist could imitate the reality of nature for as it is, keeping them scientifically accurate. They were also granted the freedom to imagine and create non existing artifacts, keeping logical coherence to the whole thing. The revival of neoplatonic ideas, and new art techniques, perspectives, flanders etc guided the path of the understanding of beauty in such times. Leonardo Da Vinci was from this age. He said, imitation is a study of nature while inventiveness remains faithful to nature while picking up elements from nature itself, to create something new and unique, keeping consistency with logical coherence. To him, inventiveness breeds technical innovations as well, like sfumato technique which was developed by Da Vinci. Sfumato technique was used to blur the borders whereas previously the painters used to paint clear outlines on the subjects to give more realistic, sharp outlook. But vinci blurred the outlines giving his paintings a more gleamy, dreamy, glow in the middle image.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/0*O-1fx80HUPksjHU_" /><figcaption>(left) crop of Sandro Botticelli’s “Birth of Venus”, (right) crop of Leonardo da Vinci’s “Mona Lisa”</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/0*T2sSzi5JV8eiFuEF" /><figcaption>Flying machine by Leonardo Da Vinci</figcaption></figure><p>To quote Vinci here,</p><blockquote>The painter is master of all the things that may come to man’s mind, and so if he wishes to see beauties of which he may become enamored he has the power to make them, and if he wishes to see monstrous things that terrify him. or clownish and comical things, or truly pitiful things, he is the lord and creator of them.</blockquote><p>As the renaissance movement was moving forward, lots of experimenting could be seen in the artists with more nuances getting integrated in. The period took the “Grand Theory” or proportional theory towards more precise heights. It perfected the concepts of proportions and then moved onto the next stages. As exists in academia, the period was categorized into classicism, mannerism and baroque. All these are styles of arts that were in hype between the artists of this period. Classicism was the remnants of the “classic” age which were the concepts of the greeks, the roman principles etc. Mannerism was distinguished by the intellectual sophistry that was put into the artwork, the architecture as opposed to early renaissance artworks with relatively simpler approach. Mannerism exaggerated the conventional balance and proportional techniques into sophisticated asymmetries, artificial and unnatural elegances. Soon Mannerism was replaced by Baroque styles of art. This artwork had the characteristics of contrasts, movement, exuberant detail, deep colour, grandeur and surprise, the combined aim of which were to generate wonder in the viewer’s eyes. This style emerged to provoke more intense emotion towards a person than anything else.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Ni5ZJ6IC7ozQZVvy.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/0*BUQ_fhFEGAWS3Evz.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qT3ZpcqVID95Ajyq" /><figcaption>Oath of the Horatii (Classicism), Deploration of Christ (Mannerism), Triumph of the Immaculate (Baroque)</figcaption></figure><p>Moving on towards the eighteenth century, Eco Umberto tells us to see the events of that time as stanley kubrick portrayed in his film Barry Lyndon which was a parallel existence between the commendable and the condemnable. This age was marked as the blooming age for logic and reasoning. From Hume to Kant to Hegel, all had investigated into the concept of the beauty and came up with their versions of studies. The dialectic of beauty were steered by an adherence to monarchy or bourgeois fantasies with a melancholic, dark, disturbing line of artworks, theatrics working in parallel. The likes of Immanuel Kant vs the Likes of François de Sade, as if two complementary sides of beauty working side by side in their own realms, but with the same appeal. Now to state an interesting fact, David Hume was the first to see beauty in a subjective way. On the subjectivity of beauty Hume had this to say,</p><blockquote>Beauty is no quality in things themselves: It exists merely in the mind which contemplates them; and each mind perceives a different beauty. One person may even perceive deformity, where another is sensible beauty; and every individual ought to acquiesce in his own sentiment, without pretending to regulate those of others. To seek the real beauty, or real deformity, is as fruitless an enquiry, as to pretend to ascertain the real sweet or real bitter.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*dn6s_kOTGHoZLVvs.jpg" /></figure><p>Hume’s idea echoed the Galilean sentiment that hot and cold is a subjective experience depending upon the subject who experiences the thing. Also the subjectivity of bodily taste, like the bitter and sweet experiences of certain foods influenced hume’s ideas in a way. He took the idea of this and stretched it to spiritual sense, or the discerning of beauty by men. Hume explains this in more details in his book on the standard of taste. It was not just him but such sentiment was picked up and echoed by other philosophers too. In his book, “ Critique of judgment” , Kant says,</p><blockquote>The judgment of taste is therefore not a judgment of cognition, and is consequently not logical but aesthetical, by which we understand that whose determining ground can be <em>no other than subjective</em>. Every reference of representations, even that of sensations, may be objective (and then it signifies the real [element] of an empirical representation), save only the reference to the feeling of pleasure and pain, by which nothing in the object is signified, but through which there is a feeling in the subject as it is affected by the representation.</blockquote><p>It was during these times, that the concept of the sublime started to gain traction. Though originating in the classical era through the likes of Longinus who explained the sublime as something awestrucking in the human soul, the idea started to gain grounds on the eighteenth century. John Dennis and Joseph Addison were two such British Writers who explained some essence of the sublime which they got to experience from travelling through the Alps Mountains. The expedition, in their words, was a feast to the eye for them, a pleasure to the sights but the experience of this beauty was not full of delight but intertwined with horror and grandeur. They reckoned that this has to be something more than beauty itself. They didnt coin the term sublime, didnt use any such nomenclature but their experience was further extrapolated by Edmund Burke who wrote “A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful” to illustrate the new concept of beauty, “The Sublime” into rigorous detail to define such experiences. To understand the Sublime, this BBC short cane be referred to, which presents the idea in a short and comprehensible, introductory way</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Ft0fHjIPpR-Q%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dt0fHjIPpR-Q&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Ft0fHjIPpR-Q%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b53920de3667d5ffd0b37886a10b4836/href">https://medium.com/media/b53920de3667d5ffd0b37886a10b4836/href</a></iframe><p>Thus beauty got a new dimension. Lets be real for a moment, we don’t enjoy anything unpleasant or harmful, but yet we do. We enjoy horror films, we enjoy frightening artworks, we enjoy looking at nature at its wildest appearance. But why? Burke explains, terror and fear is only beautiful if they are stripped of the harm it can cause. He retorts, pain and terror are parts of the sublime, but only when they are detached from the harmful impact on the subjects that view it as the sublime. Same was with beauty previously. It could be please one without inducing any need for possession or desire. The indifference towards the object of art is what connected beauty and the sublime. Both could be just sensed for pleasure through the eyes or the ears, without a potential to have an effect or a desire to possess. As for Kant, he says, beauty is disinterested pleasure, universality without concept and regularity without law. It’s kind of like two different dimension working in parallel, with a invisible partition that separates each other from being able to interact, thus creating an indifference. And this indifference yields out the experience of the beauty, for both the beauty and the sublime.</p><p>At this point of age, we reach the inception of romanticism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SuqgqBiBqAkXSFZG.jpg" /><figcaption>Lord Byron on the shore of the Hellenic Sea</figcaption></figure><p>Romanticism was a set of ideas which driven the world of art, literature, architecture towards a new direction, starting from the mid eighteenth century. Romanticism was a reactionary movement. It was for one, a reaction towards the enlightenment, and the rationalisation of everything. It was the time when industrialization was taking offset. A whole new different world was forming and at a very faster pace than could be fathomed. Railways were connecting places, easing commutation of labour and fueling industries. Scientists were inventing patents after patents, leading to the expansion of these industries and even making way for new ones. Businesses began to boom, so did the materialist civilization all across the europe. This is when some writers, poets, artists, novelists started to move away from society and listen to their heart. the idea rejected the preconceived notion of the academy which acclaimed historical or mythological artwork. Or that art has to follow certain set of rules. The romantics instead focused on the mind, projecting the feeling of the artist towards into the art. The romantics moved towards nature for inspiration, portrayed highly of whatever they found around them. the romantic visual art started off as painting landscapes. Soon, human subjects started to emerge into the artwork, and their feelings were emphasized before rationality, by the artists. The positive emotions, wonder, mystery leaping out of the ordinary were enhanced and the were embellished by visual hyperboles and perspects. Thus appreciation for nature and surroundings came into being.</p><p>Stemming out from the opposition to classicism, enlightenment,romanticism another art style came into being, which was Realism. Realism was the portrayal of the ordinary life just as it is. Whereas, romanticism underlies the same theme dealing in portraying reality, the difference lies in the emotional appeals. Romanticism is usually positivity inducing and takes an optimistic approach at reality, nature and the past. It is an appreciation of the human feeling a whole. It can work with something bigger, greater than the person or the subject of the art. It can contain mystery, heroism, innocence, unnatural events, or exciting expeditions, adventures, or in another word, a look into the deep dungeons of the sublime but with an exaggeration to fit the artist’s emotional narrative. On the other hand, realism portrayed the surroundings just as they were. There were no ornamenting or sugarcoating anything, just a simple presentation on what the simple eyes can see. It was a reaction against art requiring to be imaginative and reality enhancing. While romanticism offered the room to distort or exaggerate reality and create emotional overdrives, realism challenged it and portrayed reality in a more truthful and honest manner. The realists point of view was that reality need not be soothing and pleasing, it often can be just the opposite and it deserves to be preserved for the public to view just for what it is. The realists thought, there were much more than to just running away from the dystopian industrial and urbanized world, milking the imagination. And that’s why they took the step to portray life just as it was, without any optimist amplification. One effect of realism was that, it paved the way towards a lot of revolutionary movements, since it portrayed the regular life miseries in a non idealized manner, but with an actual portrayal. It highlighted the problems, miseries, exploitations within society and addressed them. Through these arts and literature, people drew inspiration for rallying against the system.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kGAYgHoP_6Brbh8-.jpg" /><figcaption>The Third-Class Carriage — Honoré Daumier</figcaption></figure><p>The third class carriage was one of such a realist painting which was a portrayal of working class parisians in the mid nineteenth century. The painter Daumier took an interest into the lives of the lower level, working class people who couldn’t afford first class or second class tickets. The overcrowded, smelly third class compartments were anything but pleasant. the painting and its abysmal aura captures this pretty well.</p><p>But can ugliness, melancholic times be beautiful? Let’s get back to the theory of sublime. If the misery cannot be touched or physically felt, if we are just a spectator detached from the reality of the painting then yes, it indeed can.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FiilzRF_5EL8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DiilzRF_5EL8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FiilzRF_5EL8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ec4ade2add230de3e5984a1d658bc5ea/href">https://medium.com/media/ec4ade2add230de3e5984a1d658bc5ea/href</a></iframe><p>Then in the middle of nineteenth century another wave of artists start to pop up, the Impressionists.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*noXEd_5Bz_xbeYC0.jpg" /><figcaption>Impression, Sunrise — Claude Monet</figcaption></figure><p>Named after the famous painting of Claude Monet, “Impression, Sunrise”, the art movement didn’t start off good. It was not well received by the critics when it popped into the scene. Impressionist style was associated with small, thin, often abrupt visible brush strokes to create a light transitioning effect and blurry portrayal of a scene focusing on the subject and the emotions of the moment, and not on the details. It focused on capturing the light’s motion effects of a particular moment as impressionists thought that light impacts our mood and sends certain sensations. Since, detail and clear lifelike outlines were ignored, this particular artistic style were heavily criticized by art critics of that time for being lazy and incomplete. many even went on to claim that, this style of art was at best a sketch. But soon the style was picked up by other artists, like Sisley, Morisot, Pissarro, Édouard Manet, Renoir etc. These artists defied the academia and spearheaded the impressionist style into a style that have brought revolution in the art world, leading to the creation of immortal artworks like those of Van Gogh’s, Gustave’s and others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-3V_caGa1PAvi1Qo.jpg" /><figcaption>Cafe Terrace at night — Van Gogh</figcaption></figure><p>As a reaction to all these conventional artworks which deals with logical reality, a counter style evolved which saw things in a different way. Some idea from the romantic period, like mysticism, spirituality started to get revived. Symbolists believed that art should represent the absolute truths in an indirect manner. Thus one of the pioneers in this field Jean Moreas wrote a manifesto, “ They Symbolist Manifesto” noting popular big shots like Charles Baudelaire, Paul verine etc. But this symbolism was only the revival of some imaginary elements from the romantic period. It was not analogous to emblem, which denotes to allegorical representations representing a certain idea.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/0*4X1Z2nPEGbRjauG4.jpg" /><figcaption>Death and the Grave Digger — Carlos Schwabe</figcaption></figure><p>Moving on, in the early twentieth century, inspired from Dada movement, which was a reaction towards the world war, Surrealism started to get a cult following. Surrealist outlets, Surrealist bureaus, Surrealist manifesto and lots of other similar things started to surface. Surrealism was an antithesis to reality as in the sense of the logical physical world. It entailed the juxtaposition of nonsensical objects or random shapes to create a nonsensical artwork, often with a meaning to point out to the absurdity of the institutions which brings forth the catastrophes like those of world war I. Surrealists were influenced by Freud’s work, like Breton, who thought that we repress our unconscious minds by our conscious one, which is driven by or restrained by logic and reason. Unleashing the unconscious in the art was one of the surrealist’s goal. A popular practice was to record dreams and trance-like events. Some surrealists integrated texts to their artworks, giving art a new perspective. Rene Magritte was the one who showed how linguistics can shape art and its perception through his groundbreaking artwork, “The treachery of images”. Surrealists altered our notion reality and provoked our thoughts through nonsensical paintings.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/378/0*S9GzQdSkFOuOOqvu.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*vsAToJmroFkyU5tC.jpg" /><figcaption>From left; Treachery of images by Rene Magritte and The persistence of memory by Salvador Dali</figcaption></figure><p>In the middle of twentieth century the world of art took another steep turn, entering the world of Abstract Expressionism. spearheaded by Jackson Pollock, Willem de Kooning, Franz Kline, Mark Rothko and others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4TVpYKjbJ5EeVFLD.jpg" /><figcaption>Convergence— Jackson Pollock</figcaption></figure><p>Before Pollock, Klint, Kandinsky and others contributed to the development of Abstract Art but, Pollock’s work was what strengthened the genre of abstract art and solidified its base. Now with Kandinsky and precursors of Pollock there were at least some distinguishable lines and objects (even if they are real or not). But with Pollock all barriers broke down and there were nothing but a random motion of colours and abstract expressions. This is why many attribute abstract expressionism to Pollock’s, though the idea came good long before Pollock entering the scene. Now many can cast doubts on pollock’s works. like how can this be art? In fact Pollock’s floor of his workstation was infamously claimed to be more artistic than pollock’s abstract artworks. But to a layman it’s normal to feel like that, but considering history of the development of art, the context of the artwork and the emotion it renders, Pollock’s artwork is no less than that of a genius. To understand the timeline of the development of art from classical to Pollock in a more visually comprehensible way, i recommend this short video essay by nerdwriter which is a very brief but a precise case study.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FQ1irNBh2qg8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DQ1irNBh2qg8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FQ1irNBh2qg8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/88400e1c32ed97e67bd3a44b6b0fa962/href">https://medium.com/media/88400e1c32ed97e67bd3a44b6b0fa962/href</a></iframe><p>kandinsky used to say, abstraction is not an antithesis to realism, it is realism. There are many things real that we cannot see through our eyes, for example, the consciousness and the emotions. Abstraction is a lens to view or experience those intense feelings within us. This is why abstract artists don’t use any objects from the real life but instead resort to random shapes, lines contours, textures to come up with their visual aesthetic.</p><p>Now let me tell you a story of a banana.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NC2qzjeh7f4s4bqu.jpg" /><figcaption>A woman satirically posing before “Comedian”, an artwork by Maurizio Cattelan in the year 2019</figcaption></figure><p>Comedian was a artwork which generated a storm in the world of art. The reason is understandable. It is just a banana taped to a wall, and displayed as an artwork one of the most prestigious galleries of the world. It might feel as a joke, which it actually did to almost everyone visiting it. And thus it became talk of the town. Tons of people gathered around to see the absurdity for themselves, took satirical selfies, made it go viral online, all over the world. It became the headlines for many news outlets, thousands of memes, twitter jokes, reddit threads started to burst out. Now, lets check back the name of the artwork, shall we? What was the name again of the banana? Oh yes “ The Comedian”. Whats the purpose of a comedian again? to make people laugh. And was he a good comedian? could it make people laugh? well, apart from all any other artwork presented there, i would say comedian lived up to its name. In fact, not just the gallery visitors, but it made the whole world laugh and made it laugh for days. The banana was just a part of the art. It was the whole world who turned the comedian into “The Comedian”. To learn more on the banana, you can check the video from the Art Assignment.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fso8sB25IL4o%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dso8sB25IL4o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fso8sB25IL4o%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7346fb7fc5899bbcb870696b8ef61825/href">https://medium.com/media/7346fb7fc5899bbcb870696b8ef61825/href</a></iframe><p>Comedian was a Conceptual art. And conceptual artwork are really notorious for creating controversies. Conceptual artworks can be traced back to Michael Duchamp who put on an infamous artwork as a display for an exhibition of the Society of Independent Artists. The fountain was regarded as the most influential and pioneering work in this field. Conceptual art was in a sense a critique to formalism, which implies the practice of studying art through analyzing its style and form. Although there are some valid criticisms here, for example, if we apply enough mental gymnastics we can turn anything into a work of art. One fine example is Pierre Brassau.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/465/0*d2Fo5EWd3Q3PLo0f.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*ZmJCrXI7utkq_oGJ.jpg" /><figcaption>Left: Peter ( Pierre Brassau ) in 1964, Right: One of the four original pieces of Pierre Brassau (Peter) chosen for exhibition by axelsson.</figcaption></figure><p>Swedish journalist Åke Axelsson to fool art critics. Axelsson wanted to test if art critics could really differentiate modern art from a random stroke of brush that even a monkey can come up with it. He contacted Borås Djurpark zoo for this reason and convinced the zookeeper to use Peter, a 4 year old chimpanzee for his cause. The chimp was given a set of brush and a paintbox. The chimp created multiple artworks which axelsson publicized as the artwork for Pierre Brassau, a forgotten painter from the past. Most critics couldn’t realize the scam, but one who implied that the work seems to have been made by an ape. So this puts forth the question, is it even an art if a monkey can do it? or even i can do that? Well technically no, since the monkey art was a scam mostly but most modern artwork are not. These have context, efforts and thoughts ingrained with it that only the artist can create and render through his artwork. In fact, for Cattelan to come up with the “Comedian” it took him a year. He wanted it to be a sculpture of banana, but later, went on with an actual banana. Also the monkey does not have an artistic intuition, knowledge nor experience, making his work totally a product of the unconscious. But conceptual artists make their things consciously, with investing in it months and months if not years of thoughts. Most of the conceptual artists are in fact highly regarded professionals of their field with years of experience. The art assignment has a good case defense of conceptual art as a whole.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FVHLs76HLon4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DVHLs76HLon4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FVHLs76HLon4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c18c7163133641d83b44466a7c2aff5a/href">https://medium.com/media/c18c7163133641d83b44466a7c2aff5a/href</a></iframe><p>So, i think we have dived enough into the history and development of artworld. Pardon me for i skipped many other important artistic movement, especially Suprematism, Cubism, Constructivism, De stijl or Neoplasticism, Photorealism, Fauvism, Geometric Abstraction etc, because the article already is turning out to be hideously big, and it could easily reach the length of a mini book if i continued to do so. But one interesting book that i was taking most of the reference from was “On beauty” by Umberto Eco. The book is a magnificent read and i recommend it to everyone who is interested in knowing about the history of beauty in further details.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/342/0*DKaNfPPPSFrRXY56.jpg" /></figure><p>But what i wanted to show is that, the trend of beauty was shifting to the minds and thoughts. The world of art have got more broad, independent and versatile. Previously when academia defined art in terms of the overall construction of the art, the styles used, the processes it underwent, the theme it stood upon, and some other objective physical criteria, art slowly transitioned to its status today as a thing which provokes certain emotions and thoughts in the mind of the spectator. Something that pleases the visuals or the olfactories or triggers our notions, fires up our thoughts, makes us perceive reality in a different way. Therefore , art has become so broadly defined that disregarding a certain branch of artwork would be just straight on ignorant. Thus, evolutionary timeline only added dimensions, without dismissing any particular one.</p><p>Now though art has become more generous and broadly defined, many if not most of the people cling to some version of art while dismissing others, In the world of visual arts, modern art gets the most heat. When the world transitions to a new state of art, people have a hard time grasping it, and it reflects on their hour long rant on how we moved on from our glorious past to a dull, abysmal present, and towards a dystopian future. People put their rational self to work and connect many dots, makes theories as how there is a wide on conspiracy by handful to kill everything that is beautiful and wonderful. Just a quick youtube search would give you hours of video essays/rants on why modern art sucks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/731/1*1GZrLTys_zpuyJeGjAmfLg.png" /></figure><p>Now you may complain why i included adam ruins everything here, for he does make some valid points, but lets be honest, his discontent with modern or contemporary art is super obvious in the collegehumor video. While its true that art market does have some loopholes and questionable business practices, but it definitely does not negate the art itself. Artnet produced a wonderful aticle explaining where Adam Conover gets art wrong and where he gets it right.</p><p><a href="https://news.artnet.com/art-world/comedian-adam-conover-art-market-scam-1047887">Comedian Adam Conover Says the Art Market Is a Scam. Here&#39;s What He Gets Right-and Wrong. | artnet News</a></p><p>And adam is not even a conservative. Usually most of resistance against modern art is spearheaded by people from the conservative end of the political spectrum. Conservatives usually are the first ones who put up a resistance against any new forms or styles of art. Since Conservatism upholds traditional values and traditional social institutions, concepts hence the idea can be seen to extrapolated in all sorts of life, even in the world of art and lifestyles. For example lets check the conservative youtube commentator Paul Joseph Watson,</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/455/1*FhEo-1qPSnpEC2ZJWHnT7w.png" /></figure><p>Now you may say, why i am using a youtuber as a representative for most conservative. Well, PJW is a quite popular among young conservatives and his videos hit millions. He echoes most of the conservative notion regarding anything moder, from visual art to architecture to music to almost everything. While there are more sophisticated, intelligent, educated conservative politicians or people out there, PJW represents and echoes the sentiments of the masses. Therefore i picked PJW as a representative figure for the commoners, who still dwells in the glorious past. Though many may like on or two aspects of modern cultural movements, but still the clinging to the past always stays somewhere beneath. The fact that most of this people miss out is that, they think art as something rigid and not expandable. They think that modern culture is devoid of intelligence of any sort, be it music or art or anything. But it is not. Most contemporary artists are experts in the art scenario. Many pop musical artists have a solid understanding on musical theories and its dynamics. Modern architects too are one of the professional experts who had to go through a rigorous learning process to become an artists. So that these people would engage in something hollow and unintelligent is a preposterous claim and also outright wrong. Despite being the more intelligent than the rest, these people show remarkably little understanding of any of the modern arts, be it visual art, music, architecture, fashion or anything. While they accuse them of being dumb and retarded, ironically it is actually these people who appear to be intellectually lazy. They don’t check the context of the what they criticize let alone understand the meaning they try to convey.</p><p>As much as modern art gets the heat, so does modern music. Modern music too have been more generous overtime. But likewise, the listeners hadn’t been. Most people usually subscribe to some certain genre of music while not being able to tolerate others. While Art gallery may not be filled with spectators from all over the world, music on the other hand is on everyone’s footsteps. Therefore the brawl regarding the music industry is more vivid than the art industry. A popular youtuber Thoughty2 uploaded a 20 minute long video about why pop music is bad, and he analyzed it using “SCIENCE”. So it has to be legit right? Because “SCEINCE!!!!!!!!”</p><p>Despite the video being filled with loopholes, it garnered a serious amount of popularity over the decade and the essence of the video was echoed by tons of other people and content creators on social media. It is a quite popular tactic for conservatives to use science as a tool to discredit their opponents because traditionally it was the counter culture activists who exalted science and targeted conservative notions using science. So conservatives use the weapon of their enemies against them. Although the science used in this particular video was taken out of context to fit a narrative, overlooking the outright misinformation about the musical industry, the video does put forward an interesting issue to ponder upon. Can a music be good enough if it is not crammed with sophisticated musical intricacies and instead have a simple or linear approach? The answer to this is of course quite simple. Music is a way to convey emotions to the audience, its an audible sensation. It can be composed in many different styles using as many or as little instrument as the artist want, or in fact no instruments at all. Though instrumentalists might get disappointed at this, but that’s just how it is. Only vocals can convey create an emotional audible sensation too. Is bird’s chirping music? well undeniably yes. Are fountain noises, leaves clamouring in the woods, or gushing of wind musical? Hard to disagree when there are tons of romantic poets romanticizing on nature’s audio harmonies. A traditional viewpoint for music was that, music requires harmonies, melodies, rhythms, rich timbre, dynamics. But that notion faltered down, with a lot of musical styles emerging out which excluded some aspect of these criteria, but were equally popular to the listeners. There are musics without discernible rhythms, or any particular beat arrangement, like the Gregorian Chant which has no particular time signature.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FDlr90NLDp-0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DDlr90NLDp-0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FDlr90NLDp-0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ac60ab390e9a95c4ca75ac9d5c695cde/href">https://medium.com/media/ac60ab390e9a95c4ca75ac9d5c695cde/href</a></iframe><p>Then there are music without any particular melodies. Especially the ambient music genres, which people use as relaxing therapeutic tones to listen to while working. Melodies are a sequence of notes which form a tune, and these musical pieces are random undisciplined notes coming to the ear. Many of the Baroque Preludes are told to be devoid of melodies, since they are basically arpeggiated notes played over and over for a prelude. Bach’s Prelude #1 in C is also one of such an example. Lets check a work which has very little distinguishable melody in it, relying heavily on simple chord progressions.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FDKejfYzB3ak%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DDKejfYzB3ak&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FDKejfYzB3ak%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0f9302769827b6e97365798453c133ea/href">https://medium.com/media/0f9302769827b6e97365798453c133ea/href</a></iframe><p>Then there are music which can lack any harmony (harmony implying multiple notes played simultaneously to create texture of a song, or in other words chords). Music without harmony are generally known as monophonic music. Plainchant like Gregorian Chant, Armenian Chant, Byzantine Chant etc were monophonics. One popular monophonic was Erik Satie’s The four ogives, which was inspired by gregorian chant.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FSWdOeu61sVI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DSWdOeu61sVI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FSWdOeu61sVI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/86d6b9c0744f208230ed1606e6baff22/href">https://medium.com/media/86d6b9c0744f208230ed1606e6baff22/href</a></iframe><p>About Timbre, there are old classical country music which use a single instrument for the whole song, yet they are legendary even till today. Like those of Hank Williams for example. The songs focus mostly on the vocals and little on the music which only fill add textures of the song. Lets check another song for example which uses only a harmonica but equally wonderful to listen till this day.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FK-PhBryFuIM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DK-PhBryFuIM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FK-PhBryFuIM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6f78147ce58f1e249b7e0d204866c89c/href">https://medium.com/media/6f78147ce58f1e249b7e0d204866c89c/href</a></iframe><p>So music couldn’t be restrained to a particular set of definition, instead had to be extended far beyond. So many proposed that music should be called a set of organized sound. But then again, many organized sounds like human speech, industrial machinery noises are not considered to be music. Then again, there are music which defy an ordered arrangement of sound, like noise music and musique concrete.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FZpH-ZAfJ7Rg%3Fstart%3D1181%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D1181&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DZpH-ZAfJ7Rg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FZpH-ZAfJ7Rg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d2ea2f3c5f63defd422b48ec57adc3ad/href">https://medium.com/media/d2ea2f3c5f63defd422b48ec57adc3ad/href</a></iframe><p>Noise music may seem to be deranged modern day product but it actually predates world war. With the new waves of artists questioning the status quo of art styles and opening room for new ones, the musical world wasn’t left too. Luigi Russolo, an italian futurist painter wrote a manifesto called “ The art of noises” in which he lays his case that technology will lead the way of music of the future, creating options for new sounds and a varied stream of timbre. Later on Arseny Avra Amov, Edgar Varese and others started to contribute to the cause. Another notable name in this field was Pierre Schaeffer who came up with the concept of musique concrete, which meant to abstract concrete sounds into a musical composition. A good introductory video on this was published by BBC in a documentary titled, “The new sound of music” in 1979, presented by Michael Rodd.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fc4ea0sBrw6M%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dc4ea0sBrw6M&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fc4ea0sBrw6M%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/40c5f7124d6c0138a6b1b5e1ca443a70/href">https://medium.com/media/40c5f7124d6c0138a6b1b5e1ca443a70/href</a></iframe><p>Slowly the world started to turn more experimental. The music definition industry was really being worked on and on. And then we found Silence. Silence got its way into being a musical piece too.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJTEFKFiXSx4%3Fstart%3D393%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D393&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJTEFKFiXSx4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJTEFKFiXSx4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f8ae8fcc29a5dc4fee277b762d9aea66/href">https://medium.com/media/f8ae8fcc29a5dc4fee277b762d9aea66/href</a></iframe><p>This may feel like a prank to many. But thats one of the pioneering musical piece considered till today. The art is the ambience that the player creates with his gestures. He gestures the opening, makes some gestures in between the score and uses an end gesture. The audience focuses on the player and his gestures. Everyone in the room together creates an ambience, which is the music. Cage’s point was to show that anything could be music. He drew influences from many places for this particular musical score of his. He took inspiration from Zen Buddhism, his visit in an anechoic chamber at Harvard, his friend Robert Rauschenberg’s series of white paintings and some earlier composition of his where moments of silence were parts of the scores. Thus the world got to see that even silence/ambience could be music.</p><p>In the late nineteenth century when EDM started to developed it just provided dancing beats to party with. With popular synthesizers entering the scene, electronic music started to soar in popularity. Finally Russolo’s prophecy was coming true. The future indeed started to see a transition in technology driven sounds. Samplers were analog before, but soon with the development of computers, it started to transition into the digital realms and become more widely available. Indie musicians popped on the scene. Let me introduce to vaporwave. Vaporwave music is slowed down repurposed music. It samples any particular and changes its tempo, adds effect to create some more dreamy, bubbly vibe to the music. It seems like a completely different musical piece. So can plagiarism be counted as a individual musical score? As i told earlier, musical world and art world is generous with room for any any to join. But of course with a valid set of reasoning. So what is the reasoning for vaporwave to be counted as music? Well, if sampling or repurposed musical bits can create something unique then the world shouldn’t be left of the charm that easily, should it be? Adam Neely lays a solid case in defense of vaporwave, which i recommend is a must check if you are interested into learning more.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FQdVEez20X_s%3Fstart%3D571%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D571&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DQdVEez20X_s&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FQdVEez20X_s%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/175c85c68ef9e74ad388be12d736879d/href">https://medium.com/media/175c85c68ef9e74ad388be12d736879d/href</a></iframe><p>Soon music started to get political. Rap music evolved in the African American communities as a hip hop culture (hip hop being a broader term including other cultural elements like breakdancing, graffiti painting etc. ). Now since the practice emerged from the marginal black and latino people, it was always a target for the white people. Most rap songs echoed the marginal sentiments and had anti oppression, fulminating lyrical contents. And consequently, it became a target for racists and white nationalists. But on the contrary, the popularity of rap music only grew far and wide, and became a voice for the people at the ghetto. Rap artists started to get neat records and major hits on the billboards, and its an irony that this genre was discredited for not being musical enough. Not just that the critics were clueless about what can be perceived as music, but for some of them, their were instances of subtle racism. Take a look at this research which highlights some of the racist undertones of rap critics.</p><p><a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/3180978?read-now=1&amp;seq=3#page_scan_tab_contents">Rap and Race: It&#39;s Got a Nice Beat, but What about the Message?</a></p><p>If we talk about Rap and don’t mention Ben Shapiro, a political commentator, creator and host of the daily wire, it would be a grave sin. Here’s a link to his rant on rap music being gibberish nonsense and not music. Now he is a guy who isn’t worth paying attention to, but the reason i am using this is because he echoes similar sentiments, as he puts, apart from a musical case perspective, a cultural case too. That rap music doesn’t send out a positive family friendly message across its listeners. Now he says the same thing for rock genre, where he brings down the genre for being simply constructed, and quite sure, he condemns it for the cultural side too, because like rap, rock music too gained its popularity as an anti-establishment culture. So the cultural warriors, or the conservatives, take a heat on music in the guise of musical complexities but actually taking a beef with them for the cultural atrocities. John lennon’s “Imagine” was a target too for political commentators like them, because of the morally degrading “message” it sends across. Here’s a wonderful video essay that might be worth your attention.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FoV_yhvaU6Vk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DoV_yhvaU6Vk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FoV_yhvaU6Vk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/37b0f9cab43f0d1d3d0b3fe1a36bf855/href">https://medium.com/media/37b0f9cab43f0d1d3d0b3fe1a36bf855/href</a></iframe><p>Now, to not discuss about rock and metal music in terms of politics would be a far graver sin, since it was the most notorious music scene than any other could be.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xb9PfYOY-qTDjt4o.jpg" /></figure><p>There were multiple instances when rock and metal artists were sued to courts and even banned from performing. PMRC (Parental Music Resource Center) was such a name who struggled to take matters to the court and clean the music industry so that the children do not fall into the trap of degeneracy. Black Sabbath was one of the pioneering rock bands who were barred from performing in many places, like for instance, in England, because their tone allegedly resonated with the tone of the devil. Many churches took an active stance to boycott such “satanic” music. But things only got more extreme. From rock came heavy metal, and then on came thrash metal, death metal, black metal and what not. Now there are about hundreds of such derivatives of metal music altogether. The ones who cherished the new wave of music back then are the one now protesting against the avant garde music. The accusations are the same like any other. The new waves of musics are lazy, simple and repetitive. Also, some claim to be pure noise, nothing else. Lets hear this guy go on a rant against metal subgenres that he doesn’t deem to be music, because they are simple and incomprehensible. I don’t know if that may feel like an oxymoron, but yeah to simply summarize the whole video, that’s basically it.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fgi3qC_zQ4Po%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dgi3qC_zQ4Po&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fgi3qC_zQ4Po%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/62d2cf9fa0f3ad1361130fbd714fa253/href">https://medium.com/media/62d2cf9fa0f3ad1361130fbd714fa253/href</a></iframe><p>So, avant garde music always took the biggest heat by the contemporary people and its nothing new. It is a practice that we humans have been doing overtime. Pop musics are now the scapegoat for public heat, while previously it was rock and metal music, long before that it was jazz music which got the heat, and before that classical pieces too. Beethoven was criticized for being indiscernible noises rather than actual music. Even Frank sinatra’s musics were discredited as being sung, played by some cretinous goons.</p><p>But what these people, or “critics” miss out is that, music is something that should invoke emotional response from within us. It’s not a circus show where you just show your mad skills and get some appreciation in return. The artistic skill set should convey some feeling towards the person enjoying that. If that can’t happen then it would be a mindless action. Maybe the work is simple and can resonate among the billions of people, maybe it can resonate with millions of people, maybe thousands, maybe hundreds but in the end it is a gateway towards exploring one’s feelings and drowning in an ocean of emotions. If this criteria can be met, then in my opinion things should be granted the rank of art or music.</p><h3>Personal take</h3><p>My personal takeaway from analyzing all the artistic trends is that, we cannot dismiss one over the other for it will be too shallow. We can judge artistic by their capability and the intellectual content they put to the work, but we cannot judge people’s reception which is totally subjective. Enjoying pop music is equally fine and respectable as enjoying technical death metal music. Both resonates to different group of people and it boils down to how these music trigger neurochemical activity in the brain.</p><p>Now i am not arguing that emotional responses don’t follow any trend, like they governed by some invisible force, well of course not. If that happened, then there would be no mathematical modeling for music. It would stop making sense, since all will be fell under the realm of subjective appreciation. but still, there is some subjective element to it, and apart from mathematics, our memories and environments, cultures, personalities govern a lot of emotional dynamics within us, so a matter of subjectivity tends to arise and sometimes surpasses the objective realm of our taste.</p><p>But we can at least judge a person’s dedication, merit and skills which do not need to be subjective. these are quantifiable and can be measured to judge the potential worth of a musician. Knowledge of the overall thing and able to implement them in real life i think can be a good comparing criteria, which is something i stick to personally. This is why many may accuse me of being an elitist while i am not actually disregarding or disrespecting a particular style of art or music, but rather putting some certain artistic expressions over the others for their impact and intellectual content within them.</p><p>(So yes Dream Theater is obviously better, DUH!!!!)</p><p>You can easily tell, given enough knowledge at your hand, if a work of art is intellectually driven or is it totally a random production without any talent investment. This is why we leave criticism to the specialists, check their reports and then come to a conclusions of ours. In my opinion it is better to leave the judgemental responsibilities to experts and as for layman like us, to just enjoy the show, and keep an open mind. Learning new perspectives can broaden our view of the world, and can enhance our creative self. Also kill our snobbish self while appreciating the efforts of others. It also helps us in another way, by not making us look like a whiny fool before a crowd of well-informed people.</p><p>I am not saying everything you see is a fine piece art, tons of them are totally rubbish actually but we should be more careful when putting our judgements, look at the contexts, and meanings of whatever art, music or forms of entertainment we come across. We should not be totally out of touch with the world just as the likes of Ben Shapiro, Paul Joseph Watson are. And enjoy whatever our feelings respond to, after all its a free world.</p><p>I for one am a fan of conceptual art. I love anything that provokes the mind, makes you think deeply over something and derive a meaning. The works that are visually splendid but lacks substantial thoughts are something i do enjoy but don’t blow me away or linger in my thoughts for days. To me, agitation of thoughts generate more emotional response than mindless acrobatics. For music it’s totally different. I am kind of an omnivorous in this field, but i prefer intricacies over simplicities. They just kick my neurons even harder.</p><p>Think my brothers, think!!!!!!</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><h3>The end</h3><p>(Oh i forgot to add another reference, my bad fellas. Do check one of the videos that inspired me a lot to look more deep into the matter. The concept of the ideal critic is pretty interesting. Do have a check).</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FG1UsGWxDPKA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DG1UsGWxDPKA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FG1UsGWxDPKA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/04200f9bea724aefbfcec4bcfa11216b/href">https://medium.com/media/04200f9bea724aefbfcec4bcfa11216b/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bcfde4d66ab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>