<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Faye Calloway on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Faye Calloway on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:53:32 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Affair Opens a Marriage]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/an-affair-opens-a-marriage-b9a0a41bd844?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9a0a41bd844</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[open-marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[infidelity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[therapy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 Dec 2018 03:19:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-11T13:44:32.607Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Our couples counselor might be dismayed to learn how we’re using the skills he taught us.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8VQyVQKFjQEXlskYIelM3w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Nita via Pexels</figcaption></figure><p>Long before I became an unfaithful woman myself, I studied the condition. I read fiction, nonfiction, scientific works, personal narratives, accounts by therapists, and journalistic reports. I analyzed these readings from angles both moral and practical, noting the prevalence of tragedy, and the way that the rare happy ending tends to be heavily qualified.</p><p>Classically, if a woman commits adultery, the explanations are: 1) She is bad, 2) Her husband/marriage is bad, or 3) Both. The story can end tragically, the woman’s immorality punished with discovery, exposure, murder, suicide, or a life lived out in loneliness and poverty (<em>Anna Karenina, Madame Bovary, The Scarlet Letter</em>), or happily, the obstructing spouse blamelessly removed so the adulterous lovers can live legitimately ever after (<em>Middlemarch,</em> <em>Jane Eyre, </em>the<em> Outlander </em>series). Even in these happy examples, however, the legitimized relationships are paid for in poverty, blindness, and guilt/grief/a twenty year separation, respectively.</p><p>Recently, we’ve begun to notice that reasonably decent women with pretty okay marriages sometimes have affairs, too, and not always with men they prefer to their husbands. This change in the accepted order of things has provoked confusion. Even the women having the affairs can’t seem to explain themselves. Questions abound. Is infidelity more innate to our biology than previously admitted? Is cheating hardwired into our novelty- and diversity-seeking genes? Is cheating an expression of female empowerment, women owning for themselves what has long been the prerogative of men? Is it the action of entitled women with unrealistic expectations of marriage seeking to “have it all?” Is it nothing more than the natural consequence of reliable birth control? Is it an act of creative self-expression, women rebelliously seeking to experience aspects of themselves that they have long suppressed in order to be “good girls?”</p><p>And regardless of the explanation, what is to be done? No matter how legitimate the reason for an affair, we can’t approve of the affair itself. Perhaps marriage itself is the problem, and we also find reports by people who are subverting the institution through swinging, polyamory, or “seeing other people.” These stories are hard to relate to, though. If we’re not forsaking all others, do we even have a marriage? If we do away with the center pole of monogamy, won’t the whole structure collapse around our heads? The people willing to risk it seem like fools. Most of us would rather live in a flawed house than no house at all.</p><p>When I became an unfaithful woman myself, I found that my research was useless. The literature failed, in nearly every respect, to inform my actual experience. My story is not a tragic drama, a morality tale, a sweeping romance, or a pornographic work. I suppose it’s mostly a portrait of a marriage, another area in which the literature has been of very little practical use to me.</p><p>So, here is a true and hopefully useful account of my journey from infidelity to open marriage, via marriage counseling. It’s a story I wish a big sister or a wise friend or even my mother could have told me before, or as, I lived it myself. I would have appreciated the company. It’s also long. The three acts are <em>The Affair</em>, <em>The Marriage Counseling</em>, and <em>The Open Marriage</em>, for those who prefer to cut to the chase.</p><h4><strong>The Affair</strong></h4><p>I never intended to have an affair. Quite the opposite. A successful marriage was high on my list of personal ambitions, and by nearly any standard, an affair represents a failure to live up to the ideals of the institution. But fourteen years in, my husband and I were struggling. Kids had caused a strain by generating a lot of new responsibilities that my husband and I had trouble allocating in a fashion that we both agreed was fair. We fought a lot about our marital job descriptions, and we both felt overworked and under-appreciated. We still had sex two or three times a week but my husband complained that it wasn’t good sex. It didn’t bring us closer to each other. And he was right. If I turned him down for sex, he sank into a terrible funk, so I tried not to turn him down. I experienced sex as an obligation, a chore, something I had to do to keep the house of my marriage habitable. My passion, which was no longer consulted in the matter, vanished without a trace, like a once-flowing stream gone underground.</p><p>My husband viewed the problem of my missing desire as my fault, a case of mismanagement. This was his biggest complaint about our marriage, and the most common reason we fought. I had complaints of my own, but voicing them only seemed to make things worse. A hunt for my lost libido sounded like more fun than fighting with my husband over my right to not be in the mood for sex every time he was, or the fact that he never thought it should be his turn to stay home with sick kids. Maybe I would even find my missing mojo and we really would be happier. I accepted the responsibility.</p><p>I explored sexy books, sexy movies, stories I wrote myself, fantasies I wove. Sometimes I struck a spark, which I would attempt to shelter and feed and bring to my husband. This felt a little like cheating. He wanted to be the one to generate the spark, and fuel the flame. I wanted that, too, but I couldn’t make it happen any more than he could. Foraged desire seemed the best I could manage.</p><p>Enter a man from my past, rediscovered on Facebook. He was a classic “one who got away,” someone with whom I’d shared an intense physical and emotional attraction at a time when we were not free to pursue it. Because we’d known each other in the days before the Internet or even email, we’d lost touch completely when life separated us. We began corresponding, and found all the unexpended desire between us as combustible as ever. He was not happy in his marriage, but he was committed to it.</p><p>What to do? As foraged desire went, my correspondence with Adam (as I’ve called him <a href="https://bullshit.ist/monogamy-an-evolution-a-revelation-and-an-attempted-revolt-8a8f72287a57">elsewhere</a>), was a rich harvest. I brought it to bed and fed my husband with it. And this feast was served up only from imagined gleanings. Where was the harm in that? A real affair, with real sex, would be unacceptable to my husband, but an imaginary one would benefit him. And Adam was not a threat to my marriage, as I saw it. He was as embedded in his own marriage/family/place/career as I was in mine, and neither of us wanted to destroy what we had. But the underground stream, the one I hadn’t seen in years, bubbled up and fountained for Adam, and I was so thirsty! It was such a relief to discover that this part of me wasn’t dead after all, and so heartbreaking to imagine that it was closed off and forbidden to me forever unless I took a wrecking ball to the life my husband and I had built, and the future we looked forward to together.</p><p>I had a firm rule for myself that governed my interactions with other men. If I could tell my husband in good conscience, I was on the right side of the line. Anything I would have to hide from him or lie about was out of bounds. Applying this rule to the Adam problem, I took the dilemma to my husband, along with a proposal: an epistolary affair, which I would share with him. He could read the letters himself, or I could relay them — whichever he preferred. We would both reap the benefits.</p><p>To give my husband credit, he tried. And for a week or so, the letters Adam and I wrote sparked some of the hottest sex my husband and I had had in years, and some wonderfully intimate conversations. But jealousy and mistrust got the better of him. The fantasy was too real. He felt as though I were having a real affair, and he felt like a chump. I offered him the freedom to make a similar arrangement for himself. Not being a writer, he didn’t see the appeal of an epistolary affair. “Have a real one, then,” I offered. He said, “But then you would do the same, and I don’t want that.” He didn’t feel that anyone would want to date a middle-aged, married man. (I pointed out that Adam was a middle-aged, married man, to no effect.) If we agreed to see other people, he assumed that I would have plenty of options and he would have none. In his mind, I was already fucking Adam, or would be doing so behind his back as soon as possible. I had opened our marriage without his consent. He demanded that I close it, that I stop writing to Adam, maybe not forever, but for some indefinite amount of time, until and unless he could become comfortable with the idea.</p><p>I felt that I had slammed into a wall. On the one hand, my husband’s reaction was only what anyone might have expected. It was the culturally sanctioned response to a proposal that many people would feel was a completely unsupportable violation of the marriage contract. My husband insisted that his reaction was beyond his control, it might even be in his biology, and he was helpless to respond in any other way. On the other hand, I, too, felt that my husband had violated the terms of our marriage, by laying down the law and forcing me to concede by fiat. We had agreed, as I saw it, that the status quo was not working for either of us. I had proposed a solution in good faith, and my husband had not only rejected it, but had shut down all further discussion and now insisted that we adhere to the status quo more firmly than ever. Worse than that, my bid for the honesty and openness and communication and trust I aspired to in our marriage had led to the opposite. My husband’s trust in me, which had always been provisional despite my best efforts to deserve it, was now completely withdrawn.</p><p>I experienced something of an epiphany. Up to this point, I had on some level earnestly believed that I could make my husband happy, and that I could make him trust me. If I loved him enough, were faithful and honest and considerate and empathetic, if I made sure that the kids were not fighting and the house was tidy when he got home, if I were supportive of his work and his relationships with friends and family, if I made sure that he got enough time to do things he enjoyed, if we had frequent enough sex, if I conducted myself with other men precisely as I would if he were watching, if he were free at any time to go through my billfold or my email or the files on my computer, then, logically, he would have full confidence in me and we would have a happy marriage. But none of this was working. I’d made a hundred well-intentioned rules for myself and followed them to the letter, and all for nothing. My husband was unhappy to the point of depression, our marriage was not a pleasure, and he didn’t trust me worth a damn.</p><p>I’d been trying to control my husband’s feelings with my actions. This was no covert manipulation on my part — my husband held me fully responsible for his feelings. And now, in turn, my husband was seeking to control his feelings by controlling my actions, by insisting I cut off all contact with Adam. I could see now that this did not work, had never worked, was never going to work, but I couldn’t make him see it. There was a bitter freedom in this discovery. I have always been a little too ready to sacrifice my own desires in order to maintain harmony with the people I love. But in this case, I could not restore harmony by sacrificing. I could give Adam up, as I had given up every other attraction I’d felt to other men since committing to my husband, but I would not receive my husband’s trust, relief, gratitude and appreciation in return. I couldn’t buy the marriage I wanted with this coin. I would gain nothing except the resentment and bitterness that come of payment for services not rendered.</p><p>I couldn’t afford it. I could not afford to resent my husband any more than I already did. And whether he knew it or not, he couldn’t afford it, either. I told him I was ending the correspondence with Adam, but I moved it to a secret email account and continued it.</p><p>I struggled with my conscience, of course. Most of what passes for morality in humans comes down to what we can justify to our friends and loved ones. There was no one to whom I could justify my relationship with Adam. I’d failed to convince my husband, and I had no friends who would sanction my lying to him — except Adam himself, who was engaged in a corresponding deception with his wife. I understood that I was in dangerous territory, casting myself loose from both convention and the constraining good sense of my friends. It wasn’t what I wanted. But the rules had failed me. If no one I knew was willing to help me figure out a better way, I would work on the puzzle alone.</p><p>These were my thoughts:</p><ol><li>I wanted Adam desperately — not in place of my husband or any aspect of our marriage, including sex, but in addition. I had not simply revived a physical passion I’d feared was gone forever, I had also fallen in love. Contrary to everything I’d been led to believe, neither the passion nor the being in love made me want Adam instead of my husband. I still loved my husband very much — not just the life we had made together and our family, but the company of the man himself. I was under no illusions that marriage to Adam, or to anyone else, would be better or easier than the marriage I already had. But my feelings for Adam keenly reminded me that the joy, the beauty, the aliveness, the extremity that we call <em>being in love</em> is perhaps the most exhilarating aspect of the human experience. To deny those feelings after I’d been lucky enough to stumble into them seemed almost an act of self-hatred, like cutting off my own limb. Was my marriage a trap I should suffer, or maim myself to escape? Why, simply because I had once experienced this glorious rush of feeling for my husband, and married him, and continued to love and maintain my commitment to him, should I renounce the possibility of ever feeling it again? There is no use pretending that the love married people feel for one another after a decade or two, no matter how good in its own right, is the same giddy feeling one has with a new love. How did it make any sense that I would be immediately free to feel this if my husband died or divorced me, but otherwise, the exact same feeling was a disastrous betrayal, a moral failing: Forbidden?</li><li>I wanted my husband to have access to this fever and spark himself. He is an attractive man, and a skillful lover, and he deserved to be wanted as I had wanted him in the beginning of our relationship — as I now wanted Adam. I felt burned out and exhausted by his disappointment that I could not desire him. If another woman could — let her! We would all be happier. I trusted that he, too, would want that desire, not instead of our marriage, but in addition to it.</li><li>Nothing in my experience of love, in any of its forms, supported the idea that love is a zero sum commodity. You do not have to withdraw it from one person to give it to another. I didn’t love my husband less when our first daughter was born, or my first child less when my second daughter was born. I have several very close women friends whom I love and confide in. When I begin to love a new friend, I do not have to love an existing friend less. I didn’t see why sex should change that equation. The limiting factor in any form of intimacy is not the human heart, but time. The true betrayal of my husband would be to steal my time and attention from him and give them to another man. If I conducted my relationship with Adam on my own time, I took nothing from my husband that belonged to him.</li><li>My correspondence with Adam — or even a real affair with actual sex — was not a betrayal of my husband, or of anyone else. It would take nothing from my husband, and it would not hurt him. The proof of this was in keeping the secret. As long as he didn’t know, he suffered no loss, betrayal, or shame. Only<em> knowledge </em>of the affair would hurt him — and not even knowledge itself, but his feelings about that knowledge. Yes, the secret was dangerous because of the damage it would inflict if discovered. That meant my true moral responsibility was not to avoid the affair, which caused no harm, but to avoid <em>discovery</em>. If I could conduct the affair in such a way that it would remain absolutely secret, I would not hurt my husband.</li><li>Lying to my husband was a problem, but the greater problem was not being free to be myself in my marriage. I had been married before, very briefly, and had ended that marriage when I realized I was protecting my first husband from so many facts he was unwilling to accept about who I really was and what I really thought that <em>I couldn’t write</em>, because I would betray myself. It is one thing to end a marriage in its first year, before kids, before joint property, when even the wedding gifts are easily divvied up according to whose friend the giver was. It’s another thing entirely when you hold everything most dear in common, including two daughters and a lovely home and nearly two decades of love and mutual reliance and comfort and shared community, history, and habit. I could end my marriage for a principle that felt a little abstract, even to me — <em>the freedom to be myself</em> — or I could build a little privacy wall, and make a secret cabin for the part of myself that wasn’t fitting in, and keep the ship of our marriage afloat and sailing. I could do that for a while, at least, and see.</li></ol><p>Adam’s and my correspondence turned into an actual affair, of sorts. Because we lived hours apart and had full lives and were both dedicated to the necessity of not being discovered, we saw each other exceedingly rarely, when I was passing through his town for other reasons, and then only for an hour at a time, in locations that would not look suspicious if my husband used my phone to track my location. A parking garage stairwell. The back of my minivan, parked at a trailhead. Otherwise, we exchanged erotic letters about once every three weeks, on average.</p><p>In one way, my marriage improved. My husband and I stopped fighting about sex. My desire quotient increased considerably, thanks to Adam, and I had lots of fodder for fantasy which I used to enliven sex with my husband. In every other way, we made no progress, and our marriage remained mired in lack of trust, misunderstanding, and resentment. We fought frequently and bitterly. No matter how I tried to bridge the gap between us, my husband seemed to hear every word out of my mouth as a criticism or an insult. I felt unloved, unmet, misunderstood, and very lonely.</p><p>Finally, I proposed marriage counseling, and my husband agreed.</p><h4><strong>The Marriage Counseling</strong></h4><p>I was skeptical of marriage counseling. My parents went, when I was in high school, and they say it saved their marriage, but from what I could gather from my mother’s account, it didn’t solve their problems so much as sort out who to blame for them — my dad’s family in a suspicious majority of cases. More than one couple among my close friends had spent a decade in marriage counseling, only to divorce. <em>What did you learn?</em> I would ask them, and they couldn’t seem to say. I also didn’t believe a therapist would understand our problems better than I understood them myself. The real issue, I thought, was that my husband <em>couldn’t hear me</em>. I didn’t want to pay a therapist just to tell me I was right if nothing changed, and I couldn’t believe a professional stranger would get through to my husband when I — compulsive communicator and love of his life — could not.</p><p>But I’d been reading about John and Julie Gottman’s research on marriage for years, and found it illuminating. Then I stumbled on the Gottman Institute’s blog, and recognized my marriage in a number of the articles. Furthermore, the articles didn’t merely describe familiar problems, but hinted at practical solutions. A Gottman relationship coach offered free consultation via Skype. We could get marriage counseling in the comfort of our own living room, with no commute. It seemed worth a try.</p><p>We met with our coach in two-hour sessions once a week over Skype for several months. He was a miracle worker, and I would praise him by name if I were sure he would want to be associated with this story. As it is, I will say that he deserves tremendous credit for helping us, and no blame for what my husband and I have done with the skills he taught us. I did not disclose, in the counseling, that I was having an affair. We did discuss at length, however, my attempted epistolary affair, and the fallout, which meant that we received affair recovery counseling. In every other way, I engaged honestly in the process, because I really wanted it to work. Fortunately, so did my husband.</p><p>We learned how to have a “connecting conversation” — how to listen and reflect back what the other was saying until we reached an understanding, rather than immediately disagreeing and defending our own positions. We used this skill to untangle the knots of all our worst misunderstandings and accumulated hurts. We use it still, when discussion between us starts getting tense, to back down and understand each other so we can get on the same side of the problem. The ability to do this is a revelation. I was astonished to discover that listening and understanding are skills that can be taught — and even more astonished to discover that I was as bad at them as my husband. In fact, being the better debater of the two of us, I may have been worse. I think it’s practically a national crime that these communication skills exist and we don’t teach them in elementary school. Instead we’re taught rules for avoiding conflict, and when those rules fail us, as my rules for avoiding conflict in my marriage failed me, we have no idea what to do other than draw weapons and fire shots.</p><p>In therapy, we also located the source of my husband’s mistrust of me. Interestingly enough, it lay outside our marriage, in the attitudes of his parents. Both of them were mistrustful people who had not trusted me, and their attitude had insidiously infected my husband. Once he realized he was carrying a burden that didn’t even belong to him, he gladly set it down.</p><p>Our therapist also helped my husband learn to take responsibility for his emotions. This was the most transformative change of all. At last, my husband understood what I had already discovered: My actions affected, but did not control, his feelings. He stopped blaming me for his unhappiness and learned instead to confide his feelings and seek my understanding, my empathy, and my help. My relief at this change was overwhelming. I’d been carrying the weight of my husband’s entire emotional world on my shoulders. When women complain about emotional labor, this is what they mean. They mean that every negative emotion experienced by someone in the family is their fault and/or their problem to solve. My husband learned to do his own emotional problem-solving. It took him about three months, once he saw that such a thing was possible, and understood the need. Other than our children, this might be the best thing that has ever happened in our marriage.</p><p>Our therapist told us that the way to improve sex is to improve emotional connection. My husband’s complaints about sex were actually complaints that he didn’t feel close to me. Sex was the primary way he knew to seek connection, and his frustration with sex reflected his sense that it no longer worked to draw us together. So learning to listen to each other, understanding each other better, finding new ways to enjoy and appreciate each other <em>did</em> take pressure off of sex, which was no longer the only fastener in our tool kit. Sex did become less of an obligation for me, and therefore more enjoyable. But improving our overall state of intimacy didn’t restore the rush and thrill my husband and I had felt when our relationship was new, and that I now felt with Adam — my body pulsing with desire at no more than the thought of touching him. I doubt any reasonable person would have expected it to.</p><p>We concluded the marriage counseling, declared it a resounding success, and, over the next year and a half, continued to reap the benefits. My relationship with Adam remained a secret, but my husband and I began to amicably discuss the possibility of sex with other people. His jealousy and tendency to guard and question me about my interactions with other men subsided dramatically, and his confidence and willingness to flirt with other women increased. We were able to discuss without acrimony my attempt to correspond openly with Adam, and he apologized for having reacted so fearfully and intolerantly. He said that if he were to face the same situation again, he would respond differently. I wasn’t sure, though, so I kept my secret.</p><p>Then, something remarkable happened. My husband confessed to a friend of his, a woman I had been certain for years harbored feelings for him, that he was theoretically free to see other people. The friend confessed her attraction, and then kissed my husband. My husband brought the story to me. Did I mean it? he wanted to know. Was he free to pursue this?</p><p>I told him yes. And I confessed my ongoing relationship with Adam. Just like that, we had what I’d been pressing for: An open marriage.</p><h4><strong>The Open Marriage</strong></h4><p>So what is it like?</p><p>Let me first say what it isn’t. It’s not a list of rules. It’s not a contract signed in blood describing what will and won’t be tolerated, anticipating every eventuality, and listing consequences for a breach. Instead, it contains a few articles of faith — not rules but first principles — which have to be true or the whole thing falls apart. 1) We put each other, our marriage, our family first. 2) We trust and confide in one another: No lies and no secrets. 3) We resolve conflict through communication.</p><p>Our open marriage is a fairly new development. For both of us, the lure has been the opportunity to experience the physical desire, both given and received, that we’ve lost in our marriage, even as we’ve gained the other considerable riches that marriage confers. We have both located that physical desire with other people we love, trust, and feel emotionally close to, and neither of us can quite envision the appeal of Tindr or anonymous hookups. Of course, we don’t know what the future holds. My husband might meet an attractive woman at a conference who only wants a one-night-stand with him. My lover might someday leave his wife. My husband’s lover might grow to want a more full-time relationship than she prefers at the moment. Change is the only certainty, and we both accept that. We’ll talk our way through it as it comes. There’s still a lot we don’t know, but here are some issues we have navigated so far.</p><p><em>Really and truly, am I fine staying home with the kids on a Friday night while my husband and his lover are on a hot date?</em> This one is a little difficult, I won’t lie. Since we became parents, the issue of one person getting to go out and have fun while the other stays home with the kids has been one of our most contentious issues. We’ve gotten much better at it over the years, mostly by assuring ourselves that we are both equally supported by the other in getting to do things that we enjoy. I resented the heck out of my husband’s weekly guys’ night out when he guilt-tripped me for every weekend appointment, book club meeting, or birthday dinner with friends. These days we make a point of supporting each other. My husband gets his weekly guys’ night — and once a month, he spends that evening with his lover instead. Sometimes I run away for days at a time to write — and see Adam while I’m gone.</p><p>Meanwhile, whether I enjoy my Friday night with the kids is not my husband’s responsibility, it’s mine.</p><p><em>Is there jealousy?</em> Less than you’d expect. Jealousy comes from the fear that someone has taken or will take something that you want, or that already belongs to you, and leave you the poorer. Both my husband and I feel richer, not poorer. I’m so grateful, after years of keeping secrets, for the freedom to be honest, to be fully myself in my marriage without recrimination, and to have more time with Adam. My husband is so grateful to experience the delight of falling in love, of being with a woman who can’t get enough of him, without losing any of the good things he has with me. The trust and freedom to pursue these connections with other people feel like gifts my husband and I give each other, rather than thefts by our respective lovers.</p><p>We also see jealousy differently, since the marriage counseling. The simple logic of jealousy is that it’s an injury caused by another person’s actions and is remedied when those actions change or cease. According to this logic, if my husband sees his lover on my birthday weekend and I feel jealous, the solution is for my husband to apologize and never see his lover on my birthday weekend again. But now we are both better at understanding jealousy as masking a fear, or a sense of loss. My birthday weekend jealousy wasn’t caused by my husband spending a few hours with his lover after we’d already completed all the family celebrations we had planned. Instead, it was a sign that I didn’t feel special or celebrated enough during the time we did spend. The solution is not for my husband to spend less time with his lover — it’s for him to spend more thoughtfulness and attention on my birthday. I don’t need to punish my husband for my jealousy by taking something away from him — I need his help addressing the fear or the lack that my jealousy has highlighted.</p><p><em>Do my husband and I still have sex with each other?</em> We do. And we appreciate it more. The reality of sex with a new partner, even when it’s very hot, also tends to be complicated, especially as we all get older. The very simplicity and lack of surprise that can make married sex seem boring when it’s the only option make it a welcome comfort amidst the inevitable doubts and wrinkles one encounters with a less familiar partner. And when I’m less focused on what sex with my husband is not — something I absolutely must have <em>now now now,</em> as it was at the beginning — I can better appreciate everything that it still is, and the closeness it fosters between us.</p><p><em>Am I worried that my husband will like his new lover better, and that his freedom to stray will ultimately lead to his leaving me?</em> No. <em>My husband doesn’t have to choose.</em> Neither do I. That is the whole point. We get to keep our marriage, home, trust, commitment, companionship, security, mutual reliance, shared history, shared experience of parenthood, dreams for the future, and community, <em>and</em> we get to have other lovers. No other woman in the world could offer my husband that, and no other man could give it to me. Why on earth would we leave each other now? We have everything we could want, right here in our marriage.</p><p><em>Do our relationships with other people cause fights between us?</em> They do, from time to time. (So does the cat litter box.) But we fight differently since the marriage counseling, too. Our fights used to drive wedges between us that we didn’t know how to remove. Now, more often, conflict between us is an opportunity to understand each other better. I was angry about my birthday weekend. My husband and I fought about it. But ultimately, we were able to communicate the fears and disappointments that led to the fight, and we felt closer to each other afterward.</p><p><em>Would I recommend an open marriage for everyone?</em> I would not. A friend once told me that children don’t break marriages, but they find all the existing cracks and widen them — and then pile on the pressure. Opening a marriage does the same, but more so. When I first proposed my erotic correspondence with Adam to my husband, our marriage wasn’t strong enough to handle it. We didn’t trust each other, we couldn’t communicate well, we were stingy and angry with one another because we weren’t meeting each other’s needs, we harbored lasting blame and resentment, and we competed with each other instead of cooperating. In this state, our marriage nearly collapsed at the mere suggestion of openness. Only after we learned how to repair all those cracks, and did so, was our foundation strong enough to withstand the added weight. So, in the first place, I wouldn’t recommend open marriage to any couple who doesn’t already have stellar communications skills, and the ability to resolve conflict with empathy and understanding. In the second place, many couples who have marriages strong enough to handle openness won’t want to rock the boat. An open marriage represents an adventure and a challenge, the kind of thing that breaks novices, disturbs the comfortable, and makes those stronger whom it doesn’t kill. I suspect it’s better suited to the middle-aged, who’ve had a decade or two to develop trust and commitment in their relationship, are no longer struggling under the demands of new parenthood or fresh careers, and need something else to keep them alive and curious and challenged.</p><p>One other caveat bears mentioning. We all like validation, and the accomplishments achieved while successfully navigating an open marriage are singularly unsuitable for boasting about on Facebook. An open marriage is often not discussable even with close friends. When your spouse is your only trusted confidante, sharing the secret of an open marriage can make for intense marital bonding. But for people who like to share with a wider audience, marathon-running or cross-country RV trips are probably a better choice for mid-life enlivenment.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9a0a41bd844" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Weinstein in the Wardrobe]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/the-weinstein-in-the-wardrobe-c1b05a6d8473?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c1b05a6d8473</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[adultery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metoo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[harvey-weinstein]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Dec 2017 18:45:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-21T15:50:45.200Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Or, What To Do About #MeToo</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/755/1*_fG04tSdqUM5aBNHd7tY9A.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the wake of Weinstein and Louis CK and Franken and the others, in the current reality of Trump, in the flood of #MeToo stories ranging from the uncomfortable to the horrific, a great many injustices which we have all been ignoring for years finally stand revealed. The closet we chucked them into stands wide open, and we are confronting the appalling consequences of our long policy of cleaning up by tossing in everything we didn’t want to see, and slamming the door.</p><p>The horrors in the closet run the gamut from empty wrapper trash to molding swimsuits to roaches and rodents all the way up to the monster itself. They range from harassing comments to pornographic images in the workplace to groping, to violent rape and career-destroying media smear campaigns punishing the famous victims. On one end of the spectrum is really bad manners. On the other is violent crime. The only true commonality, besides the sexual nature of the messes themselves, is the fact of their concealment.</p><p>No problem can be addressed until we have named it and gained a sense of its scope. The #MeToo movement has done a very effective job of naming and showing the size of this particular problem, and the campaign’s inclusiveness has been critical to its success. Only the storyteller determines whether a story is worthy of sharing as #MeToo. That’s as it should be. Where concealment, silencing, looking away, denial, and punishment are the norm, we can’t trust any of our usual methods for determining the worth or seriousness of an account. We must be willing to hear all the voices.</p><p>But <em>describing</em> a problem and <em>addressing</em> a problem are two separate processes. When <em>describing</em> a problem, we must be inclusive. When <em>addressing</em> a problem, we need to be analytical and discriminating.</p><p>Right now, we are being neither analytical nor discriminating — and we are not addressing the problem. Right now we are channelling our fury into mob violence and witch hunting. We are rampaging through the town smashing shop windows because we’re angry and we need an outlet — with no reference to the fact that few of the shop keepers have harmed us, and our true enemies are barricaded away in fortresses behind moats and battlements and yard-thick walls. Weinstein but not Trump. Al Franken but not Roy Moore. Louis CK but not Woody Allen. Garrison Keillor, for heaven’s sake! It doesn’t take much analysis to see that men are not being punished by guilt so much as by accessibility. Democratic politicians and men with jobs from which they can be fired are vulnerable. Republican politicians and men with no boss but themselves are not.</p><p>Mob violence, in this case and every other, is not a path to justice.</p><p>I hope we come to our senses soon, because we have some important analysis to do, and it cannot be done by an angry mob. #MeToo has made us aware of much that we have previously ignored, and has raised a very important question: <em>Why</em> are we so determined not to look at the ugly misuse of sex? <em>How</em> have we all been so complicit in ignoring, dismissing, covering up to the tune of millions of dollars, even punishing the victims of sexual crimes?</p><p>We need to understand this, and we need to understand it properly, because getting the answer wrong is only going to lead to more of the ugliness we have now — fury and mistrust in all directions, brutal punishment of the accessible, and no checks on the worst offenders. And we could all be facing this prospect, not only on the national news, but in our communities, in our workplaces, in our families.</p><p>A popular scapegoat for the question of why we ignore bad sexual behavior is the patriarchy, and the culture of toxic masculinity it has engendered. Women, even if we have no innate moral superiority over men when it comes to using sex for power, are invariably the losers of any war between the sexes, because men possess the nuclear option: Rape. If women are complicit in keeping silent, it’s because we are victims, we fear reprisal, we have been gaslighted until we doubt our own perceptions, we have Stockholm Syndrome — a twisted love for our oppressors born of our dependence upon them. Our culture, our expectations, our laws, our workplaces, our society at large, appear gross and poisoned beyond all livability, and the culprits have been identified: Men.</p><p>Let’s take a moment to appreciate that blaming a problem on half of humanity (not a half from which we can extricate ourselves, either) <em>and</em> the entire history of our civilization is not a promising approach if we are interested in <em>solving</em> the problem. It is a great justification for mob violence, though, since according to this view, anyone with a penis is guilty and deserves to be punished.</p><p>Men are not the only ignorers of bad sexual behavior. A great many women voted for the self-confessed pussy-grabber in the White House. When a woman I know was raped as a young teenager by the quarterback of her high school football team, her closest girlfriend insisted she was mistaken, and her second-closest girlfriend went on to date the guy. Were these women voters gaslighted? Were the girls who refused to believe their friend victims of Stockholm Syndrome?</p><p>Of course not. In gas lighting and Stockholm Syndrome, the victims are confused into empathizing with and defending their abusers. Make no mistake: The ignoring girls are not the confused victims of their friend’s rape. The girl who was raped, after all, is perfectly clear on the matter. The women Trump has mishandled were not tricked or intimidated by the experience into campaigning for him. The #MeToo movement has invoked a fine feeling of female solidarity, and that’s a good thing. But there is no dimension of female solidarity that will stretch to justify female ignoring as shared victimhood, while male ignoring is guilt by association.</p><p>I would like to propose a different explanation for our averted gazes — one that applies to women as well as men, and to the best of sex as well as the worst.</p><p>We do not only turn our faces away from the violent, the ugly, the coercive, and the criminal manifestations of sex. We turn our faces away from <em>all</em> sex that doesn’t directly involve us. If two colleagues develop a certain vibe, we take to avoiding the break room when they’re in there flirting at the coffee machine. Being the third wheel on a date is a misery. We excuse ourselves, mortified, if we accidentally blunder in on someone else’s intimacy. We consider public displays of affection, whether our parents hugging in the kitchen or teenagers making out by their lockers at school, to be in poor taste. “Get a room!” we tell them, meaning, <em>We don’t want to see this.</em> <em>Don’t involve us.</em></p><p>If we were completely honest — though we won’t be — we could generate a positive #MeToo campaign, matching every story of a time when we were silent about something negative and sexual with a story of a time when we were silent about something positive and sexual. I could tell about the time my married co-worker, who was walking with me to a meeting, said my name and stopped in the middle of the sidewalk. I stopped, too, and turned as if he’d yanked me around by a string tied to my stomach. We stared at each other for a suspended moment, a world of unspoken, un-acted-upon attraction shimmering between us. Then he bent to tie his shoe. We laughed the rest of the way to the meeting, in the shaky way of people coming down from a jolt of adrenaline, without ever quite acknowledging what was funny. Or I could tell about the time I hugged my college professor — the one I and all the other girls had a huge crush on — and he kissed my neck and told me he could feel my heart beating. It was wildly inappropriate and I will remember the moment fondly for the rest of my life. Or I could tell about the time when one of the men interviewing me for a job advocated hiring me because he thought I was cute. I know this because he confessed it later, somewhere along the way to becoming my husband. In addition to introducing me to my mate, the job also launched me on a career in IT, which was a lucky break for a recently-graduated English major with no previous experience.</p><p>There are excellent reasons why humans have learned to look away when sex is in the offing.</p><p>Sex is, and always has been, a destabilizing force in human society, because sex is incredibly anti-egalitarian. I don’t mean that it’s unequal between men and women, though goodness knows, pregnancy, childbirth, and motherhood <em>don’t</em> stack up fairly to a forgettable, deniable, moment of gratification. Instead, I mean that in any mutually dependent group of people — from a small band of ancient hunter-gatherers to the employees of a modern company — sexual attraction skews the equation, strengthening the connection between two people at the expense of their connections to others. Sex is exclusive: As much as it draws two people together, it leaves everyone else out. Sex is unfair, self-centered, and jealousy-provoking. It is the very essence of favoritism.</p><p>The tendency of sex to disrupt social dynamics is the primary reason that we dislike — even in situations involving consenting adults — sexual liaisons or even marriages between teachers and students, employees and supervisors, soldiers in a unit, ship’s companies, or really in any group of people working together in a mutually dependent fashion, particularly where power structures are involved. In these enlightened times, we sometimes worry that the person in power might force unwanted advances on a dependent. In <em>all</em> times — even very benighted ones — we really hate the idea of anyone gaining an unfair advantage by sleeping with the boss. And where there’s work to be done, we resent the way that sex prioritizes itself over everything else — at least when <em>we</em> are working, and someone else is enjoying the sex.</p><p>Long before we developed culture and rules for regulating the antisocial power of sex, we have been managing its disruption in a more instinctive way: via secrecy and lies. We engage in sex, nearly always, where other people can’t see us. We lie to one lover about our desire for another, or the existence of another. Lust is so intrinsically linked to an urge to hide that, “I want to be alone with you,” is a clear declaration of it.</p><p>Hiding sex, lying about sex, and denying sex are old, deep patterns of human behavior — patterns that are largely pro-social in their origins. We humans need each other to survive. We need, not just a single mate, but a whole, extended community to keep us safe and sheltered and fed and healthy and happy. We can’t afford to fight or be disliked by those we depend upon, so we tuck the difficult things about ourselves out of sight. Sex, for better and for worse, is one of those difficult things. We don’t ask. We don’t tell. Or if we do, we mostly lie, and assume that anyone else who’s talking is probably lying, too.</p><p>We keep both the clean and the dirty laundry of sex in the wardrobes of our psyches — the ballgowns and lingerie, the stained underwear and smelly socks. Sometimes it’s the entrance to Narnia. Sometimes it’s where the monsters hide. (Never is it a good place for a person to spend significant time, let alone an entire population of LGBTQ folks. Yes, it’s the same closet.)</p><p>Of course, to point out that the closet serves a valuable and positive purpose, and that much of what it conceals is also good, is not to dismiss the nastiness that can lurk there. #MeToo has provided us with a thick and disturbing catalog of that nastiness, and without question, something needs to be done. But what?</p><p>When we humans get scared of things we can’t see, we are inclined to take a militant approach. We like to draw up zero tolerance policies and send in the police to keep order. A lot of frustrated women seem to be dreaming right now of workplaces where nothing sexual would be permitted, ever, in any circumstances, under pain of firing. But the idea of what our workplaces would be like under such policies is truly frightening. Those of us who met our spouses at the office know that not all workplace flirtation is unwelcome. The lines between the acceptable and the unacceptable are thin and moveable and context-dependent. Yes, plenty of things are clearly bad, but the gray area is enormous. When we are forced to follow rules that run counter to our instincts, that are so vague and arbitrary that we are all sooner or later on the wrong side of them, that have very stiff consequences for infraction; when the mere accusation is tantamount to a sentence — this is a police state. No police state in the history of ever has fostered the trust and open communication needed to achieve a more enlightened citizenry. Police states lead to lies, hiding, fear, spies and informants, punishment of the vulnerable, and rewards for the sadistic. More policing of sex in our workplaces is the very opposite of what we need.</p><p>The true problem is not that we don’t know how to treat one another. We learn those rules in elementary school. Don’t hurt other people, either physically or with words. Don’t frighten, intimidate, or bully. Don’t touch people in ways they don’t want to be touched. If someone is being mean, ask him to stop, and if he won’t, tell the teacher. Don’t lie. Don’t spread ugly rumors.</p><p>We also have a reasonable sense of what to do when people break these rules — who to ask for help, what kinds of infractions warrant a black mark on an HR record, and what kinds warrant prison time. Most bad behavior involving sex fits into our existing understanding of what’s okay and what is not, and what to do about it. So the problem is not that we need new rules and consequences for behaviors involving sex.</p><p>What we need is a better security system for detecting infractions. Rather, we need a way to compensate for the fact that our existing security systems are culturally and evolutionarily buggy when operating in the presence of sex. Even a whiff is enough to confuse them. The cameras lose focus. They swivel away. When the diamond goes missing the tapes are curiously unable to confirm that a theft has taken place. Perhaps the cleaning crew removed it for dusting. Maybe a mouse knocked it off and carried it away. We just can’t be sure.</p><p>Our instincts will always whisper to us to look away and not involve ourselves. They will remind us that people hide sex and lie about it and we can’t trust what they say. Our most primitive impulses will assert that the best strategy for dealing with monsters in the closet is to firmly shut the door and hide under the covers.</p><p>Refusing to look is an excellent strategy for dealing with an imaginary problem. It is a highly counterproductive approach to a real one. Sex, like our closets, is subject to both kinds of problem — while also encompassing much that is merely correctly put away. Thus, the grownup’s guide to closet hygiene provides a good metaphorical strategy for detecting Weinsteins in the wardrobe. Here is a summary for those unfamiliar with the method:</p><p>1. Keep the closet door shut whenever you are not directly engaging in closet business. This simple precaution will, in the vast majority of cases, maintain tidiness and neutralize closet monsters. If the door stays shut and all remains quiet, no further action is needed. Hysterical speculation that something terrible is hiding within is unproductive and counter indicated.</p><p>2. Monitor the exterior of the closet. Keep in mind that problems requiring attention are nearly always detectable from outside the closet. Signs include but are not limited to: a door that will not close or remain closed, or conversely, will not open; a bad smell; insects; leaks or spills issuing from beneath the door; cries for help or other sounds of distress; expressions of disgust or concern by person or persons accessing the closet; a bad reputation of the closet; a tendency of vulnerable populations to avoid the closet or suffer harm in its vicinity.</p><p>3. Investigate the above signs — and any others eliciting unease — with courage and resolve. We may find ourselves tempted to shirk this step, with the excuse that discretion is a virtue. But to ignore, or — worse — cover up any of these concerning symptoms is not discretion, it is sloth.</p><p>And sloth, as we all know, is a deadly sin.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c1b05a6d8473" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Plan for Surviving the Future: Join the Club]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/plan-for-surviving-the-future-join-the-club-b1460161bab4?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1460161bab4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[discrimination]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Nov 2016 16:49:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-29T15:39:47.964Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yy-30nKfYTwjjmsFE06ACQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Since the election of Donald Trump, my social media news feed has strongly resembled a disturbed hornet’s nest, full of upset and conflicting suggestions about the best way to cope for the next four years. <em>We have to fight! We have to be kind. Put on a safety pin! Safety pins are useless. Blame the working class! Reach out to the working class. The electoral college should be abolished! Have faith in the electoral college. Trump supporters are racist bigots! Trump supporters are people, too.</em></p><p>Scrolling through my news feed — which represents a bubble like any other, of course, but a rather bigger bubble than I used to occupy before social media — I feel like an upset hornet, too, flying around in a frenzy, unable to decide where to land, and who, if anyone, to sting. But one post in particular got me flying a little higher, considering the bigger picture.</p><p>The Facebook post was by a college classmate, a passionate social justice activist. I don’t know her well but have admired (with occasional clicks of the Like button) her commitment to bettering the world and helping the downtrodden. In her post, she declared her intention to help privileged white people newly politicized by the election understand how they might fight against racism in ways more effective than simply donning a safety pin. She announced that she would not shame safety pin wearers for their naivety or for the racist mistakes they constantly make, however unconsciously, by existing as privileged white people within a racist culture. She would get to know them, direct them to protests and actions, educate them. She expressed her guilt and shame for her own unconscious role in perpetuating racism, as hard as she works every day to overcome her blind spots. And she assured people of color, who have already suffered enough, that it is not their job to educate these newly politicized white people — that burden falls to her and to other white, privileged activists.</p><p>Her post gave me an odd feeling. Shouldn’t all of this have gone without saying? Why wouldn’t an anti-racism activist welcome greater general concern about racism? Why should anyone be shamed for wearing a safety pin? Why would my Facebook friend need to lecture herself (and the rest of us) on her duty to accept these well-intentioned safety pin wearers kindly? Why was speaking with people who made no demands, but only indicated a willingness to listen, a burden to be lifted from people of color?</p><p>My odd feeling was a familiar one. I have it every time I show up for a conversation about race, prejudice, bigotry or discrimination and my “Tell me more,” is met with, “You could not possibly understand because you’re blinded by white privilege.” Or my, “Who are you?” is met with, “Don’t ask me to represent my people. We’re all individuals, just like you.”</p><p>My Facebook friend’s post clarified something I have long sensed but struggled to express: Social justice activism is a club, and it has some unwritten bylaws. Its values are as much about embracing the guilt and shame of racism as they are about breaking down the barriers of prejudice. The struggle is not only to stand up against discrimination, but also to kneel down in confession and atonement. My Facebook friend’s statements about her failures to confront racism in her own life, and her willingness to lift the burden of education from the victims of racism, were a demonstration of her credentials. They proved her membership.</p><p>Your average privileged white person newly concerned about racism is interested in constructive action. Guilt, confession and atonement — not so much. A well-meaning safety pin wearer walking into the social justice pharmacy has come in search of practical remedies — an ointment, or perhaps a purgative. A treatment plan. Instead, she gets a lecture: <em>You have a nasty, contagious STI. Do you know how you got a nasty, contagious STI? By doing nasty things with other nasty people—or being born to them. It’s too late now. You’re infected for life. Even if you try not to, you’re going to spread it to other innocent victims. I can help you treat the symptoms — although you deserve to suffer from them — but first I’d like to hear you say that you are very, very sorry for contributing to the spread of an epidemic that was already a huge problem before you added to it with your existence.</em></p><p>Some people see justice in this lecture and apologize for their existence in order to receive the medicine. But most people stay the heck away from the pharmacy after hearing that lecture a time or two. And this is a shame, because social justice activists know some really good treatments for racism, prejudice, bigotry and discrimination. The irony is massive and concerning. <em>How on earth can we halt an epidemic of discrimination if we discriminate when handing out the remedies?</em></p><p>The fact is, we are all tribal creatures. We all like our own people best — the ones with whom we feel safe and comfortable just being ourselves. We all have our own ways of recognizing our people — by the color of their skin, by their safety pins, by certain conversational rituals. Our tribalism is instinctive, inherent. It will always be a part of us. But certain manifestations of tribalism — such as racism, prejudice, discrimination and bigotry — are deeply destructive. These destructive forms are ascendent right now. Trump’s election has, overnight, slammed up walls that people like my activist Facebook friend have spent years trying to take down, and have caused many of us to take shelter behind divisions we’d barely recognized until now. The career social justice warrior and the newly politicized safety pin wearer used to occupy the same Facebook bubble without conflict. Now they see their differences as reason for concern.</p><p>In times of threat, it is natural to take shelter among those with whom we feel the safest. And Trump, being the ultimate tribalist, represents a threat to everyone who is not a member of his tribe. Alas, that’s all of us. Trump occupies a tribe of one.</p><p>Our fear causes us to splinter into smaller and smaller groups, eyeing each other mistrustfully and subjecting each other to stringent tests of belonging. <em>What’s the secret password? Show me your ID.</em> Our fear misleads us, though. It is precisely in small groups that we are most vulnerable. In small groups we are readily rounded up and persecuted. The instinct to seek safety in division is precisely the one that the most fearful among us must resist at all costs.</p><p>My Facebook friend recognized this need to overcome division when she resolved to reach out to safety pin wearers despite her instinct that they are not members of her tribe. I honor her for this. I honor those who counsel listening, communication, safety pin wearing, reaching beyond our bubbles and comfort zones, and acknowledging the grievances of those who voted for Trump. In our hearts, whether we are people of color, activists, safety pin wearers or Trump supporters, we are all tribal creatures who like our own people best. But we also live in a country dedicated at its most fundamental level to uniting and including <em>anyone who wants to be a part of it</em>. We are all home here, in this house with lots of walls, and lots of doors.</p><p>We need to stop concerning ourselves with red state values, blue state values, and minority rights. We need to concern ourselves instead with <em>American</em> values, and <em>human</em> rights.</p><p>We can’t remove the doors of tribalism. They are structural. But like any other door, they have two functions. They close against outsiders. And they open to welcome and include. We don’t have to bolt them and hide from every knock. We can instead stand in our doorways and ask each other, <em>How do you belong? Would you like to come in?</em></p><p>And we can write new scripts for the pharmacists among us. <em>Oh, honey, you have humanity. It’s epidemic, and chronic. There’s no cure. You’ll die with it, and so will we all. But with lifestyle changes, you can expect to live a long, healthy life and keep the symptoms from flaring up too often. New treatments are discovered all the time — the best way to find out about them is to ask other sufferers. Even if you don’t learn anything new, commiseration is therapeutic. Oh — and although the symptoms may look different on the surface, there is only one strain of humanity. When you think the other patients have a different disease, it only means you haven’t understood them yet.</em></p><p>From up here above the swarm, I notice a number of hornets have stopped buzzing and gotten to work expanding the hive, recruiting new members, poking holes in the interior walls. I think I’ll join them. Because if someone comes along to knock over this big hornet’s nest of an American democracy — this house with lots of walls and lots of doors where everyone is welcome and we all have rights — we’re going to need all the stingers we can get.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1460161bab4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Seeking Eden]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/seeking-eden-42ad0f00871c?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/42ad0f00871c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[monogamy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love-and-sex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[polyamory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Nov 2016 16:12:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-08T17:46:38.845Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Eve offered Adam paternity in exchange for monogamy. And Adam, the fool, accepted. We’re still paying the price of this bad bargain.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0z5sEjKrSt3vV_pHEjcMEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Garden of Eden by Adrian Hillman, via <a href="http://stock.adobe.com/">Adobe Stock</a></figcaption></figure><p>Lately, I’m obsessed with the sex lives of our primitive ancestors. My obsession with prehistoric sex is related to my obsession with the German concept of <em>Zeitgeist</em>. The <em>Zeitgeist</em> is woven from cultural assumptions so basic and unquestioned that they remain invisible to us, even as they give shape to everything we think we understand. Imagining an invisible zeitgeist hanging across my view, concealing everything it also reveals, makes me itch to draw aside the curtain and steal a glimpse backstage. Sex, above all other aspects of our humanity, is shrouded in a hundred layers of culturally-derived <em>shoulds</em> and <em>mustn’ts</em>. How better to see it clearly than to study it before we hung the curtain?</p><p>Of course we can’t see clearly. Human civilization arose too long ago, and the fossil record preserves nothing of genitals, let alone love. Culture comprises the very lenses of our understanding. We can’t know. We can only guess. Since I am a storyteller, not a scientist, the lack of facts doesn’t trouble me much. Long before we invented science to make sense and meaning of the world around us, we conceived fiction.</p><p>Here is the story I imagine: a play, framed by the parted zeitgeist.</p><p>Once upon a time, some clever, ground-dwelling apes began to become more clever. The clever ones lived longer and had more surviving, clever children. The cleverer they became, the bigger their brains, the larger their heads at birth, and the more helpless and slow to develop their offspring. These slow-to-mature infants were more work than any poor single mother — the standard kind of mother among apes — could manage on her own. One trait above all others made the burden of these children bearable, and aided their survival to adulthood: their capacity to love and be loved <em>for a very long time.</em> The love of their mothers was not enough — these children were too much. They needed all the love they could get, from anyone who might notice them lying in a puddle of their own feces, blithely sucking their toes, and snatch them out of the path of an approaching lion.</p><p>This critical human capacity for attachment must have evolved in lock-step with our enlarging brains, and been reinforced at every stride. No wonder if the attachment capacity, along with the intelligence it supported, began to generalize. We attached to our mothers, to our children, to other members of our tribe, to our mates, to other species, to things, to places, even to ideas. And where we attached, we stayed constant. Our love did not evolve to end in a day, a season, a year. Our love intended to see a human child through the long years to adulthood. We loved to last.</p><p>A creature who loves to last, and who needs help from others to raise children, has a peculiar feature: It never outgrows its family. Many of the world’s animals strike out on their own at sexual maturity, but not humans. No sooner do we become mature and independent enough to seek a mate, but our burdensome offspring render us dependent on those who love us once again. The need for a surrounding family to ensure the survival of self and children is crucially more feminine than masculine. Women give birth, nurse infants, and are inescapably the stewards of their own genetic legacies. A man may be nine months away in any direction by the time his child is born, and his purely genetic interest may be to move on quickly from a pregnant mate to ensure another. Women cannot so readily escape. No wonder modern studies show women’s brains more heavily wired for communication and building emotional connection than those of men. The survival of the species has disproportionately depended upon women’s ability to generate and maintain tribe.</p><p>Men are just as subject as women to the broadly human need to attach and love for a long time. The difficulty for men is that this need for intimate attachment conflicts with mating far more directly than it does for women. To meet the purely pragmatic goal of ensuring the largest number of healthy, surviving offspring, mating requirements are simple — if slightly different — for human males and females. Males should mate as often as possible with as many females as possible. Females should mate every three to five years between surviving children, and each time with a different male for maximum genetic diversity. Females are born and raised within a tribe that remains theirs when they need help with their own infants. An ideal mate would be a genetic stranger, not a family member, but the requirement for a mate is infrequent and brief. For females, mating represents no threat to tribal bonds. The situation is very different for males. Once a male reaches sexual maturity, his genetic imperative is to mate as often as possible for the rest of his life. Naturally, he should not mate with the members of his birth tribe, because they are likely close relatives. He should become a lone wanderer, perhaps, moving always on the peripheries of tribes of females, forming brief liaisons and then moving on. This is all very well for a creature with no family feeling. But human men form long, strong attachments to their tribes of origins, which they must leave in order to mate. And they get attached to their mates. And they have all the associations of safety, comfort, acceptance and belonging that women do with being a member of a tribe.</p><p>Here, in a nutshell, is the original problem with human sex. Our first and simplest sexual imperatives are directly at odds with our later-evolved requirements of love and long-standing attachment. Sex drives us from our tribes; the need for love, belonging, and childcare draws us back. Everything we know about human sex results from the attempt to forge a compromise between these two imperatives — the attempt to co-locate sex and tribe.</p><p>To facilitate the compromise, both males and females have made concessions. Males go to lengths to make themselves uniquely appealing to females who might select them, not simply as sexual partners, but as tribe members. Males offer protection, food, material goods, childcare and nearly anything else a woman might want. Females have obligingly uncoupled sex from fertility in order to accommodate males who would certainly not stick around for the long term where sex was available only every few years.</p><p>It’s tempting to construct an idyllic, Garden-of-Eden portrait of the past in which the compromise worked perfectly. We can conjure a scenario in which males, upon reaching sexual maturity, left their tribes of origin and, after a period of wandering and proving themselves, were initiated into new tribes full of unrelated females who were viable sexual partners. Men gained access to home, comfort, acceptance, belonging <em>and</em> plenty of sex, women gained valuable tribe members who offered physical protection, material goods, sex as needed, and good genes for their children. Everyone was satisfied and life was good.</p><p>But if this is Eden, we must look for a snake, and the serpent is easy to spot. Where we find love and attachment, we inevitably find possessiveness and jealousy. Possession is, to our primate minds, the proof of love. Anything worth possessing is worth possessing exclusively. From the moment humans developed the capacity for long-term love, we have also suffered the pangs of jealousy.</p><p>Did jealousy destroy Eden from within? Did the need to exclusively possess our mates fray the bonds of tribe? Did sister fight sister for the most desirable man; did brother fight brother for the exclusive sexual favor of the prettiest girl? Did the winners build little huts with a single door which they barred against one another’s suitors? I doubt it.</p><p>Even in modern times we see evidence that men don’t suffer possessive jealousy when sharing a mate within a tribal context. Wife-swapping is more benevolently regarded on military bases than elsewhere, the members of elite sports teams often share sexual partners without jealousy, and the famous promiscuity of gay men can also be understood as a lack of sexual jealousy within a tribal context. In Eden, male sexual jealousy must have been more guard dog than snake, patrolling the perimeter of tribe, distinguishing between outsider males who came to steal, and those who came to share.</p><p>Female jealousy must have served a different purpose, tied to female desire. In the bargain between men and women, men receive tribal belonging in exchange for good genes and valuable citizenship. The currency in this exchange is sex, and a man’s value is set by female desire.</p><p>Women experience two kinds of desire. The first is ancient, procreative, hormonally-driven, spontaneous desire. This type of desire is linked to fertility, and would have been much more rare in ancient women — who were pregnant or lactating most of the time — than in modern women who are frequently fertile. Procreational desire will make do with whoever is around, but is particularly responsive to novel males who do not smell like family. Within a tribal context, this type of desire serves as an initial indicator that an outsider male might make a valuable tribe member (and even if not, procures his desirable genes for the tribe). Procreative desire grants an outsider male a hearing for a bid to join the tribe. The second type of desire is the more recently evolved love-and-attachment-promoting desire which nourishes and maintains emotional connection. Women experience the second type of desire for men they wish to keep as tribe members. This attachment-promoting desire serves as a barometer of a man’s security in his adopted tribe. The sexual desire of the women of the tribe is both signal that a man is wanted and motivation for him to stay. A lack of female sexual desire is both signal and motivation for him to seek a different tribe.</p><p>But wait! Surely fickle female desire was the agent of our expulsion from Eden? As many disillusioned modern men can testify, sheer value — being a good provider, a good father, a responsible, caring citizen — is no guarantee of female desire. Once a woman becomes complacent in a man’s attachment to her tribe, she takes his contribution for granted. Even an entire antelope is more likely to elicit a fond hug than a blow job. Eve does not uphold her end of the bargain! And Eden fades from our grasp.</p><p>Again, I don’t think so. In Eden, male value didn’t ignite the fire of female desire, either. Jealousy did. A man valuable enough to keep as tribe would be equally welcome elsewhere. No spur to female attachment-promoting desire is more effective than awareness of a man’s invitation from the sexy ladies across the way, and of his freedom to accept that invitation. Jealousy doubtless played a role within the tribe as well, competition between sisters for a man’s preference frequently stirring the embers of a feminine desire otherwise prone to dormancy during near-chronic pregnancy and lactation.</p><p>If neither jealousy nor fickle female desire engineered our banishment from Eden, what drove us out of the garden? Why did we give up our loving, generous tribes and our sexual freedom, and take up cramped monogamy? What strange, new fruit fanged the snake of jealousy and cast female desire in the villain’s role? What knowledge was the primate psyche so unsuited to bear?</p><p>Humans were long spared an understanding of the link between sex and childbirth. Infants were the constant, unquestioned accessories of womanhood, children were tribe-members in training, and men were free to pursue their social and sexual agendas unfettered by any burdensome concept of paternity. Imagine the havoc wreaked on the psyche of a loving, jealous primate by the notion of fatherhood! Suddenly children, who had only ever been the possessions of women, became the possessions of men. If an apple of knowledge drove us out of Eden, knowledge of paternity was surely that apple. And <em>female</em> jealousy alone was the serpent, Eve’s wish to possess Adam more fully than her sisters satisfied in a bargain Adam could not resist — possession of his <em>own </em>children in exchange for his sexual exclusivity.</p><p>With possession comes possessiveness. The guard dog of male jealousy left the perimeter of the camp and came to stand at his mistresses’ bedroom door. Adam’s faithfulness to Eve required her faithfulness in return, a price her envy surely failed to measure. Adam sought to secure his new possessions by possessing Eve as well, systematically removing every support enabling her to care for his children without him. From the wrenching discovery of paternity has flowed God the jealous Father, the wresting of women from their maternal tribes, monogamy, misogyny, the subjugation of women, the nuclear family, in short: our fall from Eden.</p><p>The Ten Commandments outline the rules for the post-Eden world order. A jealous, possessive Father who admits no rival deities (certainly not a maternal counterpart) reigns supreme. Tribe is redefined in the narrowest possible terms with the injunction to honor father and mother. The right to individual property — foreign to tribal people who survived by sharing — is codified with admonitions not to take the lives, wives, or stuff of others. The commandments against coveting and lying close loopholes: Don’t even think about taking lives, wives or stuff; and don’t do it and then lie about it, either.</p><p>Another new concept came into being: Sin. Certain aspects of our basic natures — which had previously served as healthy regulators of tribal life — became troublemakers under the new rules. Lust, Pride, Envy, Gluttony and Greed, ugly names for the old, useful inducements to female desire, made the list. Sloth, the condition of a well-provisioned tribe ripe for expansion, and Wrath, indicator and punisher of behaviors that disrupted tribal harmony, also made the list of seven deadlies. Male jealous possessiveness, however, remained free from censure — no sin, but rather a God-given, God-possessed right. Its privilege has turned the old, loyal border-patroller into a dog in the manger, lunging and snarling at seekers after the feminine desire which — now a faithless snake and not a warming ember — no longer benefits the dog.</p><p>On stage, framed by the zeitgeist curtain, many years have passed since Adam and Eve left Eden and got their own place. In tedious scenes, Eve has nursed babies, reprimanded toddlers, and complained of headaches, while Adam has checked door and window locks, then tiptoed out to the whorehouse. Now, Adam and Eve argue in the modern kitchen of their suburban home. Eve has a career. Adam has had a vasectomy. The kids are at soccer and piano lessons.</p><p>ADAM: I work my ass off around here doing things for you. I put in long hours at the office, and then I come home and do chores. I bought you this nice house. I joined the school board. Is a simple sexual favor every once in a while too much to ask?</p><p>EVE: Oh, honey. I do appreciate you, I really do. And I love our family. But I work just as hard as you do and I don’t feel like having sex anymore. I don’t know why.</p><p>ADAM: (snarls) You feel like having sex with Rod from book group. I see the way you look at him.</p><p>EVE: Well, that’s true. I know! How about I fuck Rod, and you fuck someone else, too. Wouldn’t that be fun? We could spice things up a bit.</p><p>ADAM: <em>NO.</em></p><p>EVE: Sweetie, be reasonable. I don’t want Rod to move in. I don’t want his babies. I just want to fuck someone I actually desire, for a change. Wouldn’t you like to be desired, too?</p><p>ADAM: Yes. I mean, <em>NO!</em> Because then you would fuck Rod, and that would make me jealous.</p><p>EVE: Jealous? Really? Even if Stella from yoga were giving you blow jobs?</p><p>ADAM: Let me explain something to you. You are a woman. If you want to have sex with Rod, all you have to do is say so and it’s practically a done deal. I, however, am a man, and a middle-aged one at that. Stella from yoga doesn’t want me for my gorgeous bod. I’d have to offer her something else — my time, my attention, my money, a nice house, a ring, kids — something like that. Do I have any of those things to give her? No! Because I already gave them to you!</p><p>EVE: Are you saying you want a divorce?</p><p>ADAM: No! Because you’ll take half my stuff, I’ll never see the kids, everyone will think I’m a scumbag for abandoning my family, and Stella STILL won’t want to fuck me! Also, I’d be lonely and I’d miss you. What I WANT is your desire! Why can’t you just hand it over?</p><p>EVE: I guess because you can’t leave.</p><p>ADAM: Well, that sucks.</p><p>EVE: Have you ASKED Stella if she would fuck you?</p><p>ADAM: Have you READ the sexual harassment policy?</p><p>[End Scene]</p><p>Applauding half-heartedly, we are appalled by the state of the curtain that swishes closed before us. The velvet is stained, torn, raveling at the hems, ripping at the seams — even burnt in a few places.</p><p>Why don’t we get a new one?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=42ad0f00871c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Monogamy: An Evolution, A Revelation, and an Attempted Revolt]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bullshit-ist/monogamy-an-evolution-a-revelation-and-an-attempted-revolt-8a8f72287a57?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a8f72287a57</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[infidelity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love-and-sex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Sep 2016 14:10:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-06T22:02:39.332Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dSaRizS1MTAiqC-Oh2rcaA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Recently, a rather dry, scientific article introduced me to a motive for monogamy in early humans that I could actually relate to. It was as though a giant light bulb had switched on inside my mind. Suddenly our modern sexual predicament — and my own sexual history — made sense to me in a whole new way.</p><p>The fashionable way to explain monogamy is that it’s the best way to bring up babies: Since human infants are so helpless for so long, we’re more likely to grow up to pass on our father’s genes if he helps raise us. Given the frequency throughout recorded history with which humans have survived to pass on genes despite completely absent fathers, this theory has never caused so much as a Christmas tree light to twinkle in my brain. Here is the puzzle. Human males are obviously capable of having, and seem often inclined to pursue, as much sex as possible with as many females as possible. This would appear a foolproof strategy for achieving the ultimate goal of all biological creatures — the maximum number of offspring in a lifetime. Meanwhile, females routinely enlist the assistance of family and friends to ensure the survival of those offspring, whether males stick around or not. What possible benefit could there be to human males in giving up promiscuity and chaining themselves to one mate for life? It doesn’t make sense.</p><p>In “<a href="http://www.nature.com/articles/srep32472">The Evolution of Monogamy In Response to Partner Scarcity</a>,” published in <em>Nature</em>, Ryan Schacht investigates a different possibility: Humans did not evolve long-term monogamy, but rather a short-term form of monogamy called mate-guarding. At times when fertile females are more scarce than virile males (the norm for humans, since males and females occur in roughly equal numbers, but females are infertile for long intervals due to pregnancy and lactation), the most successful mating strategy for males is not to have sex once with a fertile female and dash off in search of another, nor is it to settle down with one mate for life. Instead, it is to mate-guard, or obsessively spend every waking and sleeping moment with a mate and have lots and lots of sex with her while fighting off any other males who come near her — for a finite period, sufficient to get her pregnant.</p><p>Sound familiar? In fact, an evolved penchant for mate-guarding would account for nearly everything that we associate with <em>falling in love</em>: relentless sexual desire, obsessiveness, suffering when parted from our lover, jealousy, and a strong impulse to neglect all other tasks and relationships in order to be alone<em> </em>with our lover. It would also explain a human feature that is unusual among primates — our preference for sex in private. Helen Fisher’s research has shown that this in-love state, which is also called <em>limerence</em>, has very distinct and consistent physiological and neurochemical characteristics, which is exactly what you would expect of traits that are evolved, rather than culturally dictated. In fact, fMRI studies of people in this stage of love reveal that their brains closely resemble those of addicts high on opiates. Fisher’s research also reveals that this stage is brief, lasting, at the very outside, two years. And tragically, from our modern romantic standpoint, it never returns. Not with the same lover, anyway. Instead, it gives way to the long-term affection and intimacy that we generally associate with family.</p><p>Long-term monogamy, in contrast, seems to go against many of our instincts. Not only do we regularly fail at it, we tend to describe it as “work,” which is pretty much the opposite of anything innate, irresistible, built-in. What does long-term monogamy do for us? Well, it’s an excellent way of making sure that our biological children inherit our stuff. As soon as we stopped roaming around in tiny, familial bands and settled down with farms and property, inheritance became more than our genes — it became our belongings. Union was not merely sexual, it was material. And because we are social apes who maintain lasting social ties, we are <em>capable</em> of long-term monogamy as a cultural adaptation, particularly if it’s enforced through our dominance hierarchy and leverages our fear of social ostracization. It is interesting to note that the enforcements of long-term monogamy—religion, secular law, the investment of family and community — kick in right around the time that limerence typically ends. Once you look at it, it’s perfectly clear that short-term monogamy may be innate, but long-term monogamy is cultural all the way.</p><p>What would we expect of creatures who instinctively prefer short-term monogamy with a series of partners but, for cultural reasons, have adopted a practice of life-long monogamy with one partner? Struggle, that’s what. A constant, nagging sense that one’s basic nature is at odds with the moral framework of cultural expectation. Punitive legal, religious, and social machinery designed to enlist the rational mind in a permanent war against the unruly body. We might also expect to find a longing for, and a faith-based belief in, a perfect love — one that, contrary to all experience, will sustain the ecstatic intensity of limerence over a lifetime or an eternity. In other words, we’d expect to find Romance and God.</p><p>Really, it’s delightful how much sense the history of human civilization makes when we start with highly social, clever, greedy, lazy apes who practice mate-guarding. First, we invent tools for obtaining food and protecting ourselves. Then we want to keep our tools, but carrying them everywhere becomes a problem. (Our need for pockets almost certainly drove the invention of clothing, and not the other way around.) Ingeniously, we find ways to get our food to stay in one place, and settle down — inevitably acquiring a lot more stuff in the process. And this stuff is valuable! We only want to share it with a few people who are important to us and will look after it when we die! Like our kids! Well, easy for a woman — she knows who her kids are — but what about men’s stuff? Men need to know which kids are theirs! Enter long-term monogamy. That works from a pragmatic standpoint, but as animals, we don’t like it. We need a way to enforce it. Enter government and religion — tools for making individuals do things even when they don’t want to because it’s good for society as a whole. (The Ten Commandments are all about establishing the dominance hierarchy, defining tribe in terms of fathers and mothers, and safe-guarding private property — wives in particular.) Now we have technology and civilization, but we’re unhappy because we live under a set of rules that force us to act in opposition to a very basic aspect of our animal nature — our sexual instinct. Still, we have other animal instincts keeping us in check — our social natures leading us to tend our bonds to other members of our tribe, our innate reliance on a dominance hierarchy to establish our place in that tribe. What to do? Use our creativity to forge order and meaning from our conflicting realities, of course — and transcend those realities in pleasurable ways. Enter art! And here we are.</p><p>What does all of this have to do with <em>my</em> sexual history?</p><p>A while back, a man from my past reentered my life. He and I had experienced an intense, secret attraction when I was in high school and he in college. In those pre-email, pre-social media days, he vanished utterly from my life when he graduated. Naturally, it was Facebook that brought us back in contact, twenty-five years later. We began exchanging messages, and over a few months they became increasingly erotically charged. I wrote him this:</p><p><em>The key elements of temptation are: desire, the moral code that forbids acting on that desire, and the opportunity to act on it. Any two of these without the third aren’t in conflict, but add the third and you have a problem. The sinner accepts opportunity and breaks the moral code, the saint accepts the moral code and suffers desire, the iconoclast accepts desire and denies the validity of the moral code. (Or you could call them the adulterer, the faithful spouse, and the polyamorist. I seem to be thinking allegorically, in terms of apples and snakes.) Then there is the artist, who might be any of the others, too, but who ultimately accepts the </em>problem<em>, and illuminates it by turning it into art.</em></p><p>The specific type of art that I had in mind was an exchange of audience-specific erotica. Since we were both married and wished to stay that way, we wouldn’t meet in person. Our affair would be entirely imaginary. He — let’s call him Adam — accepted my proposal, and elected not to tell his wife. I, however, trusting that I could demonstrate that the arrangement was not in conflict with my marriage, told my husband.</p><p>At first, my husband expressed a cautious willingness to go along. My interest in sex had flagged well behind his for years, and we had discussed before the role that fantasy might play in reigniting my libido. My correspondence with Adam had already worked wonders in this department. Also, my husband was flattered by and grateful for my trust, as I was by his. For a couple of weeks, all seemed well. Inspired by Adam’s letters, my husband and I were communicating more openly and honestly about sex than we had in years, we were having lots of it, and we felt quite clever and proud of ourselves. Then, trouble struck. My husband’s confidence crashed. The idea that I was having sex with him while thinking about Adam troubled him in ways that were directly counterproductive to sex itself. He read some of my letters and declared them “too real.” He could not shake his certainty that sooner or later I would stop being content with the fantasy, or Adam would. He felt jealous, humiliated, and impotent. Worst of all, he sensed me falling in love with Adam. He felt he was losing me.</p><p>In vain I explained that I was tremendously happy and grateful to be married to him, I loved our life together, and I had no desire whatsoever to be married to Adam instead. I did have bright, buzzy, obsessive feelings about Adam and was quite engrossed by our sexy correspondence, but I wanted to <em>share</em> all that excitement with my husband, not exclude him. I didn’t want to change a single thing about our life together except the one thing my husband also wanted to change — stagnation in the bedroom. And of course, fair was fair. If I could have an imaginary affair, my husband was free to do the same.</p><p>None of this helped. My husband is not a writer. An affair by correspondence would never work for him, and if he engaged in the real thing — a possibility I was open to — he’d have to grant me permission to have real sex with Adam, too. And sex, in my husband’s and my experience, is glue. The two of us began quite casually, as friends with benefits, and look what’s come of it: a loving, interdependent family with two kids and a lot of shared stuff. We are well aware that plenty of sex with someone you like can lead to lasting love. If my husband and I started having sex with other people, how could we be sure we wouldn’t end up wanting to remake our families with those new people instead?</p><p>Instinctively, I felt that I would never wish to leave my husband for Adam, that this danger did not exist. But given my husband’s and my love story, and the great weight of evidence that affairs — even when they’re called polyamory or open relationships — lead to divorce all the time, I couldn’t reassure him. I couldn’t even fully reassure myself.</p><p>In the end, I wrote to Adam that I had to stop. I expected a brief response letting me know that he understood and regretted it, but, for reasons I can only guess at, he never wrote me back. I missed him like hell, but I was also hurt and angry. It may have been an imaginary affair, but the breakup felt real enough. I won’t lie: Things were bad in my marriage for a while. But it’s been over a year since the correspondence ended, and my husband and I are better able to discuss it analytically these days. Or maybe I should say that my husband is better able to tolerate my attempts to make sense of the whole thing, though he’d really prefer that I stopped talking about it.</p><p>This is the point in the story where the theory of mate-guarding sheds its illuminating light. The moment I saw myself as a primitive ape responding to a sexual instinct shaped by an evolutionary history of mate-guarding, I saw that I had been right that I would never have wanted to leave my husband for Adam. My husband and kids are my tribe, my family, my home. The mating instinct — mercifully thwartable in its original aims by modern birth control — might draw me for an obsessive interval to a novel, outsider male, but that obsession would inevitably wane for both of us. As nature intended the matter, I would soon be pregnant. My pheromone-fueled attraction to the novel male would diminish, and I’d be drawn instead back to the safe, familiar-smelling men of my family, where my tribe would help with the exhausting work of raising my big-brained, slow-to-mature infant. And if I didn’t get pregnant? Limerence would wear off anyway, and free us both to seek more productive mates. Because that’s what limerence does.</p><p>But wait. Limerence wears off, yes. According to Fisher’s research, though, it doesn’t vanish utterly — it transmutes into lasting affection and intimacy. In a thoroughly logical manner, limerence is a complex biochemical process for generating offspring and, along the way, converting genetic strangers into members of the tribe. So would I have wanted to move Adam into the spare bedroom around the time that my sexual obsession with him started to subside?</p><p>Once I could see limerence, not as the first, error-prone step in the process of identifying a mate-for-life, but as a cycle which humans instinctively seek to complete multiple times in our lives, I realized that it’s no mystery to me what happens after limerence runs its course. I have never had a true affair — the kind with actual sex — but twice since my husband and I have been married, I’ve been through limerence with other men. The first time was before our children were born, the second when our youngest was a toddler. Both men were co-workers and office mates, which meant I spent a great deal of time with them. Both times I was intensely attracted, enthralled, prone to lurid erotic dreams and fantasies. Both times I am viscerally certain the feeling was returned, though in neither case were confessions made or actions taken. Both times my husband sensed my feelings and we discussed them. He was jealous and brooding, but ultimately able to trust me not to act on my desire. And what happened? Gradually, the obsession and the fantasizing faded. In their place was a warm, deep fondness that I retain for both men to this day. Since we no longer work together, I go months or even years without seeing either of them, and to the extent that I stay in touch with them it’s largely through their wives. I am deeply happy to see them when I do, yet not unhappy when I don’t. If I imagine having sex with either of them now, I feel about it roughly the way I feel — this is terrible to say — about married sex: If we were both there and no obstacles presented themselves, it would probably be pleasant, but there is nothing driving it.</p><p>When I view my erotic correspondence with Adam in terms of limerence, some answers seem quite clear, but others remain mysteries. In my experience, limerence requires physical presence — even if not physical intimacy — to run its course. If contact is severed midway through, as it was with Adam when I was a teenager, it may go latent but remains revivable, even a quarter of a century later. (This is the reason that the plot of every romance novel depends on keeping the lovers apart for as long as possible — it’s the one reliable way to extend limerence.) If he and I had had a physical affair, I feel quite certain it would eventually have run its course, leaving us with a lasting fondness for one another, but a much reduced critical urgency to get naked together. What of the correspondence, though? Of that, I’m genuinely unsure. One obvious possibility is that Adam was already fading out of limerence by the time I called things off. He might have been ready to remember me fondly but occasionally from a safe distance, might have welcomed the guilt-free opportunity to do just that. Since this possibility hurts me in my Romantic sensibility, I prefer to imagine that he barred the door out of fear that my freaked-out husband would vengefully contact his wife, but that he missed me like hell, too. When I framed the idea of our correspondence as art, I was not simply attempting to disguise something unacceptable beneath a pretty label. I was proposing a classic act of sublimation — using creativity and imagination to transform the unacceptable into the acceptable, to convert raw sexual energy into story. Written words are far more lasting than touch, regardless of whether they’re deemed to have lasting value. I aimed to transform the ephemeral into the permanent, something capable of long outlasting its generating spirit. But in the process I admit I hoped to prolong the generating spirit, too. Who knows how long limerence can last, sustained by the imagination and not dissipated through presence? Indefinitely, I hoped. Primitive ape I might be, but I am also a complex product of my Romance-obsessed culture.</p><p>It’s really no wonder that in the end I was unable to convince my husband to go along with my experiment. In essence, I proposed to sacrifice the unacceptable act of sex in hopes of indefinitely prolonging a desire that my husband also found unacceptable. We ran smack up against another intractable relic of our primitive past: Jealousy. My husband and I may be long past the mate-guarding jealousy of limerence, but don’t forget the other force that powerfully motivated our greedy, social ancestors — the need to defend family and belongings against threatening outsiders. I don’t doubt that on some level of my husband’s brain, far deeper than he can help, I am both family member and prized possession, and thus doubly worthy of defense. Undermine either sense, and I might escape his jealousy only to find that my position in his tribe has grown tenuous. Our primitive apes are at an impasse — mine bent on pursuit of limerence, his bent on stopping me. For now, I see no option but the one our ancestors signed up for so long ago: Long-term monogamy, and chafing.</p><p>But I also possess the highest consolation of my rich culture — and the time-honored pastime of those left to recover from limerence on their own — the ability to illuminate the problem through art.</p><h3>bullshitist on Twitter</h3><p>It&#39;s all https://t.co/yKNTCvJnJW Why not signup for our newsletter? https://t.co/zLCRrFFEKt</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a8f72287a57" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bullshit-ist/monogamy-an-evolution-a-revelation-and-an-attempted-revolt-8a8f72287a57">Monogamy: An Evolution, A Revelation, and an Attempted Revolt</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bullshit-ist">Bullshit.IST</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Sex, Anthony Weiner, and Treating the Midlife Crisis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/on-sex-anthony-weiner-and-treating-the-midlife-crisis-bbbf22285683?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bbbf22285683</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[infidelity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[midlife]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love-and-sex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[divorce]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Sep 2016 14:48:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-17T03:25:07.506Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LJohhkaWZTaJYzHpNWKKGw.jpeg" /></figure><p>A few years ago, when my husband was nearing his mid-forties and I was still in my late thirties, we began to have a recurring fight of a new and particularly demoralizing flavor. It began with his perception that he’d been sexually rejected. I would apologize and explain that I had just been exhausted/in a bad mood/distracted (we had two small children when this fight first materialized), and hadn’t intended to hurt him. He would generalize the incident into an indictment of our marriage, informing me that I obviously didn’t love him anymore and only insisted on keeping him around because he was useful. My efforts to counter this accusation while feeling furious and wronged never sounded very convincing. He would descend into a mood that almost visibly surrounded him as a heavy, black fog, and stay there for a couple of days until we managed to overcome our respective resentments enough to have sex. Then we’d return to functionality until the next time.</p><p>After a while, I noticed that this fight happened very predictably when we’d gone a while — maybe five days to a week — without having sex, and that sex was the only thing that ever cleared the post-fight funk. Even exceedingly unfriendly sex, the kind in which foreplay came down to my saying, “Look, damnit, let’s just get this over so you’ll stop being an asshole,” still functioned to noticeably improve my husband’s mood. The situation began to remind me of something.</p><p>When I was nineteen, I spent a semester in the Italian Alps. It wasn’t a perfect four months — I’d left my boyfriend behind and I was cold a lot — but on the whole, it was pretty idyllic. Everywhere I looked was stunning beauty. I became quite close to the other students in my program. I traveled to Florence and Venice, saw amazing things, met fascinating people, and learned a lot. It was, in many ways, a peak experience. So I was at a loss to explain why I frequently plunged into deep, dark wells of sadness. I cried often, for reasons I felt helpless to identify. Clearly I was deeply distressed about something, but what? I missed my boyfriend, but not unbearably. Being cold and having an itchy scalp (there wasn’t enough hot water for daily showers) was irritating, but hardly a source of bottomless grief. The only explanation I could think of involved the decision I had made not to go home that summer, but to live with friends in the city where my boyfriend lived. I had also decided to graduate a year early, which meant I might never live at home again. Could I, unbeknownst to my conscious mind, be grieving about this? The explanation didn’t feel quite right, but it was the best I could do. Having to grow up and strike out on my own seemed a plausible excuse for existential sadness, and if I couldn’t manage to feel consciously terrible about it — well, the mind has mysterious ways. The bouts of sadness continued over the summer after I left Italy, and several months into the fall semester. It was my last year of college and my boyfriend and I were applying to grad schools, so my grieving-over-growing-up theory still fit. Kind of. Finally, in a phone conversation, my mother asked, “Do you think it could be your birth control pills?” Our family physician, when consulted, thought indeed it could and switched me to a different pill. Like magic, the profound, mysterious sadness vanished from my life.</p><p>Since then, I have retained a deep respect for the power of body chemistry to affect or even generate mood. Even more importantly, I’ve become aware that not all internal states have an external cause, let alone an external cause of corresponding significance. That semester in Italy, the pensiveness I could detect at the thought of leaving home was truly all I felt. I convinced myself that a blameless fact of my life was a large problem, because I was certain that I could not feel so terrible unless something equally terrible was happening to me. It was an understandable mistake, but it was also a massive misconception.</p><p>I believed my husband was making a similar mistake. I’m the kind of finicky introvert who quickly snaps when asked to pay attention to multiple things at once. Consequently, snuggling me suggestively from behind while I’m trying to cook dinner (especially if underfoot children are making the case that they will <em>die on the spot</em> if not given a snack) is an excellent way to get shrugged off, possibly without my even noticing that I have been so rude. It’s not a charming trait, but it’s well established. My husband — who, tragically, loves nothing better than to snuggle me from behind while I am cooking — knows it well. In kinder and more rational eras of our marriage, my husband snuggles, I shrug, he says, unrepentantly, “Sorry — I can’t help it,” and life sails on. But at the time of the fight, my husband experienced this quirk as damning evidence that my love for him was dead and gone. He seemed to elicit it on purpose to provoke the fight. He felt terrible, he incorrectly identified my shrugging as the cause, then magnified its significance to something terrible enough to explain how awful he felt. Meanwhile, all the evidence pointed to his unhappiness being bodily, chemical — the fact that his mood crashed when we neglected sex, and that only sex seemed to have the power to lift it.</p><p>My husband didn’t dismiss my theory, but it didn’t help us much. The solution still looked like a matter of more frequent sex. But we had jobs, small children, busy schedules, sleep deprived nights, and little privacy. My dread that he would turn into a raging asshole if I didn’t put out was not — strangely enough — an aid to my flagging libido.</p><p>What eventually did help was an article in <em>The Atlantic</em> that a friend pointed out to me: “<a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/12/the-real-roots-of-midlife-crisis/382235/">The Real Roots of Midlife Crisis</a>,” by Jonathan Rauch. According to this article, many longitudinal studies measuring happiness over a lifespan show a U-shaped curve, with general life satisfaction declining gradually for participants beginning in their 20s, reaching the lowest point during their 40s, and beginning to climb again in their early to mid 50s. This finding appears in disciplines from anthropology to psychology to economics, and even in studies of non-human primates. Midlife unhappiness appears without reference to life events, often when people are at the peaks of their careers and have stable families, secure finances, and tragedy-free lives. In other words, people in their 40s are often unhappy for reasons seemingly not of circumstance but of biology. They are unhappy, not because of their lives, but because of their bodies.</p><p>The article made a real difference to my husband for two reasons. The first was the excellent news that mid-life unhappiness is temporary. Make it into your 50s, and satisfaction swings up again, on average continuing to increase into old age and generally exceeding the previous highs of early adulthood. The second reason was that he felt, in a real and important way, absolved of blame. His malaise was normal. It wasn’t his fault, my fault, our children’s fault, his job’s fault. It was not a sign that his life was badly flawed or that he was doing anything wrong. No dramatic response — such as quitting his job, his family, his marriage, or his country — was called for. He was just going through a normal slump, and it would get better by itself. This understanding improved my husband’s point of view considerably. If he felt a bit down, that was normal. No need to cast about for a reason. Instead, he began to focus on things he enjoys, and to make more room for them in his life: going to the gym, cooking, a regular night with guy friends, obsessing about cars. The sex situation improved, too, with less pressure.</p><p>It’s been quite a while since my husband and I had the fight. I had all but forgotten about it until Anthony Weiner’s third sexting scandal reminded me. “Sex addiction; very sad; it’s an illness with him,” went the predictable responses, but <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/close-and-personal/201609/anthony-weiner-is-not-sex-addict-neither-is-anyone-else-0">as Joye Swan noted in <em>Psychology Today</em></a><em>,</em> sex addiction does not exist. Pleasure in sex does not wain into physical dependency — the hallmark of addiction — but rather just keeps right on being a pleasure. That Anthony Weiner is strongly compelled to engage in activities that make his dick hard is no evidence of illness. The oddity in Weiner’s case is not the impulse but the apparent inability to control it. Still, how much must Anthony Weiner’s life have sucked recently? He’s a public laughingstock with a botched career, staying home with the kid while his wife advises an even-more-historic-than-usual presidential campaign. Add a touch of midlife crisis, and in all compassion — who is more in need of some alleviating pleasure?</p><p>Put all these things together and shake: the old fight with my husband, Anthony Weiner’s risky extramarital sexting, mid-life malaise, the mood-lifting power of sex. This is what emerges. In our forties, we are prone to a mysterious, interior unhappiness that has no external cause. We seek outside ourselves for justification and, tragically often, locate a spouse to blame. Where our unhappiness is wide and deep, we mound our spouse’s crimes correspondingly high, a pile of dirt large enough to explain such a crater. At the same time, we are desperate to lift our low moods. The small pleasures haven’t been cutting it lately — we need something big, transformative. We remember that long ago and far away we used to flirt with strangers, have exciting new sex with exciting new people, fall madly, crazily in love. We need this now. And since we are married — to a spouse we already blame for the whole situation! — we are not allowed to have it.</p><p>Oh, what to do? Now that I, too, have reached my 40s, I look around and everyone I see is struggling. There is the divorcing friend whose wife cheated, the divorcing friend whose husband sexted, the friend who bandages the wounds caused by her blaming husband with the flirty kindness of other handsome men. There is the friend whose wife accommodates his taste for swinging because novel, exciting sex is the one relief he’s known from what he only recently learned is manic depression. There is the friend whose husband left because he came to find her inexplicably unbearable; she was sure, <em>sure</em> he was cheating, but then again, maybe he left so he wouldn’t.</p><p>And me? I wouldn’t say I’m depressed. But when I think about it, perhaps a sense that life is slightly flatter than usual explains my recent interest in extra specially sexy sex. Mostly, I channel it by writing erotica. But to be honest, I also tried to convince my husband that an explicit correspondence with an old flame would be harmless. He didn’t agree.</p><p>I can’t blame him. I can’t think of a single story from art or life that would reassure him of something I believe in my heart to be true, that a little extra specially sexy sex on the side, if you’re in a bit of a slump, can make everyone involved feel better, even the spouse to whom you come home in a good mood, for once. What if we lived in a world where Anthony Weiner sexted and nobody cared? What if stay-at-home parents improved their attitudes with flirty texts to people who weren’t appraised of the toddler snot on their pajamas or the Cheerio powder on the bottoms of their socks — and it didn’t make them lying, cheating sleaze-balls or rotten parents? What if office workers — married but not to each other — sometimes slipped off to empty conference rooms and swept away the Monday blues with an orgasm or two, and no one considered it grounds for divorce? I’m pretty sure the first halves of these scenarios are common enough among people who, far from wanting out of their marriages, hide and lie precisely in order to preserve them. Certainly not everyone does it — the price for getting caught is very high, and plenty of us have better impulse control than Anthony Weiner. But consider this possibility: The people who pull it off without getting caught really are happier and better adjusted, more content in their marriages and kinder to their families, less inclined to walk around in a black mood in search of someone to blame. Consider the possibility that a little extra specially sexy sex can do all this <em>as long as nobody knows</em>.</p><p>I can think of no better example of the way that belief shapes our reality. If something is harmless or even beneficial if it’s a secret protected by a lie, but a tragic betrayal if it comes to light, is the thing itself at fault, or our belief about it? What do we have to gain from clinging to this belief? When I look around at the wreckage of my friends’ marriages — the blame, the fury, the hurt, the betrayal, the dismal finances and the grieving children — what we have to lose seems abundantly clear.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bbbf22285683" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why You Won’t Necessarily Marry the Wrong Person]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/why-you-wont-necessarily-marry-the-wrong-person-d254c07ea306?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d254c07ea306</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[love-and-sex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[romance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Aug 2016 18:00:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-28T23:17:54.299Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*rIfb8rNrVcjIbg8EBv6JdA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Recently, <em>The New York Times</em> published a wonderfully provocative piece by Alain de Botton, titled “<a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/29/opinion/sunday/why-you-will-marry-the-wrong-person.html?_r=2">Why You Will Marry the Wrong Person</a>.” The article is a brief encapsulation of some of the illuminating insights in de Botton’s new book, <em>The Course of Love</em>, which I cannot recommend highly enough to anyone interested in better understanding the frustrations and emotional contradictions of married life. In the article, de Botton calls for rejection of the Romantic philosophy of marriage to which Western culture has subscribed for the last 250 years, the notion that “a perfect being exists who can meet all our needs and satisfy our every yearning.” He recommends replacing it with a philosophy of pessimism: “We should learn to accommodate ourselves to “wrongness,” striving always to adopt a more forgiving, humorous and kindly perspective on its multiple examples in ourselves and in our partners.”</p><p>De Botton’s clear-eyed analysis of the dynamics of married life is downright revelatory, but the notion that our marriages break down because our partners “fail to meet all our needs and satisfy our every yearning,” doesn’t ring true to me. I’ve had front-row seats for a few divorces now, and I have yet to see one caused by someone’s failure to live up to an impossible Romantic standard. When I see that dynamic, it tends to be in my single friends, whose idealistic ideas about marriage keep them constantly searching for a better partner instead of choosing one for better or worse and settling down. Far from being Romantic idealists, my divorcing friends have generally lowered their standards down to the ground in an attempt to save their marriages before finally giving up in despair. Also, if we’re all wrong for each other from the start, and we can address this wrongness by adjusting our expectations and attitude, then it would seem to follow that it doesn’t matter much whom we marry. In my heart I can’t believe this is true. It seems clear that some marriages are much happier than others, with the worst leading to emotional starvation and misery that no amount of forgiveness, humor, and kindly perspective on either side can remedy. If into every marriage some wrongness must fall, that wrongness lands along a broad continuum, ranging from tolerable to wildly unbearable. Some people appear much wronger for each other than others.</p><p>So if Romanticism isn’t the fatal flaw, the worm in the apple of marriage — what is? How else can we explain our sense that happy marriages are about as common as unicorns — and, as with unicorns, if you <em>do</em> spot one, it’s bound to be a hoax?</p><p>Here is my theory. We don’t marry our partners because we expect they will meet all our needs and satisfy our every yearning. We marry our partners because we expect they will do exactly one thing better than anyone else: Love us the way we most need to be loved. If they meet that one expectation, they can flunk pretty much all the others and we’ll still end up with a marriage that feels more happy than wrong. The people who make us feel deeply accepted and at peace and contented inside our own skins do not have to be perfectly beautiful, perfectly good at keeping the house, perfectly patient with the children, perfectly wealthy, well-groomed, fit, present, responsible, or interested in our favorite hobby. Those people can get away with any number of egregious failures, and, as long as they continue to make us feel loved, we will pour forgiveness and kindly perspective over them by the bucketful and never trouble them with a sense that we’re holding a reproachful measuring stick of expectation against their efforts in the world.</p><p>I think most marriages begin in this blissful state. We’re so deliriously full of passion and gratitude and delight that we are profligate spendthrifts with our love. We throw open the doors of the storerooms and shower our partners with all the goods inside — and because we give each other everything, we can hardly fail to give the one, key thing. Then, inevitably, the blockbuster giveaway comes to an end. The marriage settles into a more sustainable economy. We give and get, get and give. Since most of us have no idea what our key thing is, we don’t ask for it directly. If it’s a freely traded commodity in our marriage, we may never have to ask, or even know how much we need it. If not, the pain of missing it will help us understand our need, and we will ask to have it met. At that point, we’re very likely to hear from our beloved partner that the key item is on indefinite backorder. We’re told it’s overrated anyway, and we’d be happier with something else.</p><p>In other words, we have two problems. 1) We don’t know what we need in order to feel loved. 2) When we figure it out, our partners don’t believe us.</p><p>This all makes more sense with an example. Take me. I’m forty-one years old; I’ve been married for fifteen years; I’m a mother of two; I’m a writer of love stories. Up until a month or so ago, it had never occurred to me to wonder what I most need in order to feel loved, or what my husband needs. Asked point-blank, neither of us knew. It took some teasing out.</p><p>I asked myself, what kinds of interactions seem to untangle a knot inside me, smooth me out, make me put down all my defenses, trust someone completely, and feel so grateful I’d do almost anything for the person who made me feel that way? What makes me feel <em>un</em>loved? When a man desires me, what aspects of myself is it most important to me that he find sexy?</p><p>Here are my answers. I want to be admired for my mind, my insight, my articulateness, my wit. If someone wants to be my friend, I want it to be for those qualities. If a man desires me, I want it to be because he found me sexy in light of our conversation, not solely because he liked the look of my boobs from across the room. I feel most unloved when I lay out one of my newest and shiniest insights and the response is indifference or dismissal.</p><p>It was obvious to me the moment I thought about it that my husband does not need his mind, his ideas, his insight, admired in order to feel loved. I had no idea what he did need, though. Neither did he. I batted it around in my head for a few days.</p><p>“Something about physical presence?” I guessed. “Something about someone purely and simply wanting you around?”</p><p>“Don’t forget about sex,” he replied. “Sex is really important.”</p><p>My first reaction was to shrug sex away. Sex couldn’t be the actual thing he needed in order to feel loved. For me, sex is secondary — a thing that feeling loved makes me want. So what does it take to make my husband want to have sex?</p><p>Well…hardly anything, really. I mean, he’s a man.</p><p>I reframed the question. What does it take to make sex darned near impossible for my husband to resist?</p><p>A woman he desires, ready and willing to have sex with him.</p><p>At this point, a great many fights and fraught conversations that my husband and I have had around sex came flooding back to me in a new light. When we had breastfeeding infants and I was touched out and exhausted, he told me he needed, <em>needed</em> to have sex with me in order to feel loved, valued, connected to me. Over and over he’s told me that as long as we’re having sex — the kind I participate in with enthusiasm, not the grudging, getting-the-chores-done kind we have when I’m not in the mood — there is almost nothing I can do wrong in his eyes. The one thing that would end our marriage on the spot, he has said, is my telling him I will never have sex with him again.</p><p>He had been telling me for years what he needed to feel loved, and I hadn’t believed him. <em>Why?</em></p><p>Two reasons. The first is that he needs something so different from what I need that I didn’t know how to believe him. The second is that I always heard him telling me he needed my <em>desire</em> in order to feel loved. And the only response I could give was despair, because my desire is a fickle diva on whom I cannot rely. I have never loved or helplessly depended upon my husband more than when our children were newborns, have never needed more to make him know how much I love him. I have also never been as alienated from desire as I was then. If that’s what it took to convince him, we were all doomed, the game was rigged against me, and it was fucking unfair.</p><p>Once I laid down my defenses and gave the issue some compassionate thought, I realized that my husband does not actually need my desire in order to feel loved. In some situations, he might even experience my proactive, take-me-now lust as unwelcome pressure. What he needs is my generosity and good-will, my pleasure in his pleasure, my desire, not so much for his body, but for his body’s satisfaction. When I feel truly well-loved by my husband, I don’t even have to reach to give him these things, which remain well within my grasp when full-on, selfish desire is beyond me.</p><p>What about my need, then? Had I ever asked him to meet it?</p><p>I had. Frequently, the outcome had been fights in which I’d been reduced to weeping, screaming, fleeing-the-room-or-the-house hurt and fury because no matter how many times I told him what I needed, what he needed, what our marriage needed — no matter how much intelligence and insight and articulateness I brought to bear on the problem at hand — he simply <em>wouldn’t hear me. </em>The only thing in the world I had wanted was for him to look at me and see a compassionate, wise, intelligent woman who loved him well enough to burrow deep into both our psyches and find honest answers to the recurring question of how we could make each other happy. I wanted him to understand me, thank me, and love me for helping. Instead, he’d all but hated me for being critical, and for asking him to say things he couldn’t for the life of him feel to be true.</p><p>I need something so different from what he needs that he didn’t know how to believe me, either. And he also felt despair because, no matter what I said, he couldn’t see me trying to help, trying to be loved for the very best thing I have to offer. He only heard me telling him he was wrong, and demanding that he thank me for it.</p><p>When I made this discovery I felt further despair, because this is precisely the sort of insight I hardly ever manage to sneak past my husband’s defenses. But the alternative was resigning myself to the marriage we had without hope of improvement, and that seemed like a poor option. My husband will tell you that he understood me just fine the first time I expressed myself clearly, and that he assimilated the information successfully within an hour or two. I could tell you a much longer and more dramatic story, but suffice to say it ends the same way: Glory hallelujah, he heard me! He really did! And then he actually started trying to do it. He has admired me in words more often in the last two weeks than in the last two years of our marriage, and I feel <em>so much better</em>.</p><p>The insidiously difficult thing about this give and get economy of love is that reciprocity is not built in. I can be incredibly generous to my husband with sex, and he can feel very happy and well-loved by me, and it might never cross his mind to compliment my wisdom and intelligence. Instead, he might try to reward me with more sex, and end up quite hurt by my <em>it’s never enough with you</em> response. He might pour words of admiration and praise all over me, and in my gratitude I might return the favor and wonder why he’s only getting sulkier the longer I talk. The golden rule is not just ineffective in this situation, it’s destructive. When we apply it, we’re likely to pave our way straight to marital hell on golden cobblestones of good intention. The golden rule assumes a single currency, but the marital economy has two. I have to love my husband in the coin of his realm. He has to love me in the coin of mine.</p><p>I’m sure that other people’s marriages look quite different from mine in their particulars. But here are some ideas that I believe apply generally:</p><ul><li>Different people need different things in order to feel loved.</li><li>The things we need in order to feel loved are probably much simpler than we expect, given the sheer number of different things we’re capable of holding against our partners. Most of our grudges are red herrings. We can be angry for a hundred reasons at someone who doesn’t make us feel loved, ninety-nine of which we would forgive a person who does.</li><li>For a man, even if it doesn’t come down to sex, the need may often lie in the realm of physical pleasure and comfort. Men in our culture tend to lose access to all but the most limited forms of physical affection beyond little-boyhood, and are only able to regain it as adults in their most intimate relationships. And the love shown to boys as they get older often takes the form of attention to their physical comfort — food, laundry, transportation, housekeeping. When the men I know complain about their marriages, it often sounds like this: “She never wants to have sex.” “She’s home all day while I’m at work, but the house is always a wreck.” “She’s so picky about the decor that I don’t feel at home in my own house.” “She’s never around. She’s always off meeting her own needs and never home taking care of mine.” As a woman, I have tended to assume these were inarticulate expressions of a deeper-lying emotional need. But what if, as in my husband’s case, these are perfectly articulate expressions of the true complaint after all? <em>When you don’t look after my physical pleasure and the comfort of my surroundings, I feel that you don’t love me.</em></li><li>For a woman, the need is more likely to be emotional than physical. It’s generally going to involve being admired for, desired for, supported in the pursuit of her best thing — the thing that sets her apart from other women — and that best thing is not likely to be her female anatomy. Nor is that thing likely to be her ability to keep a clean, comfortable house. When women say that they’d be willing to have more sex with their husbands if only those husbands did a little more housework, this probably <em>is</em> an inarticulate expression of a deeper-lying emotional need — namely the need to demonstrate and be admired for traits more uniquely their own, and more valued in our culture, than the skills of a competent housemaid.</li><li>A modern American woman is likely to possess a sense that catering to a man’s physical comfort and pleasure is not her job. A modern American man is likely to possess a sense that catering to the emotional needs of a woman is not his job. He may, in fact, have been led to believe that women’s emotional needs are a form of insanity, or, as my husband succinctly summarized from the zeitgeist when I ran this point by him, “Bitches be crazy, yo.” (He was lovingly validating my insight, not expressing his own opinion!) None of this helps.</li><li>When a marriage becomes unendurable, it’s likely that the partners need mutually incompatible things in order to feel loved. She needs to be desired for her ability to create beauty, but her aesthetic makes him feel uncomfortable in his own house. Or she needs to be loved for being a party girl who always knows how to bring the fun, but once they have a kid, her free-spirited impulsivity results in a lack of routine and a surrounding chaos that make him feel profoundly unloved and resentful of her best thing.</li><li>An affair — or the temptation to have one, even if resisted — is usually the consequence of a need to feel loved going unmet in the marriage. Men may be drawn to affairs with women who prioritize their physical pleasure. Women may to be drawn to affairs with men who admire them for virtues their husbands are unable to appreciate.</li></ul><p>De Botton writes, “Compatibility is an achievement of love; it must not be its precondition.” When I look around me at the new territory my husband and I have discovered in the last month, this observation strikes me viscerally with its truth. Don’t get me wrong — I still sometimes offend my husband with my insight and shrug off his advances; he still sometimes annoys me by appreciating me with sex instead of words. But now, when we injure each other out of old habit, we’re more likely to skirt around the defensiveness and blame that used to derail us every time, and move straight to the apology and try-again. Compared to where we’ve been living, this looks like happily-ever-after. I don’t want to overstate the victory, though. Lately I’ve been thinking a lot about Philip Pullman’s <em>His Dark Materials</em> trilogy, in which the protagonist loses a rare and once-instinctive magical ability and in order to regain it must painstakingly rebuild through years of study and practice what she once possessed through grace. When I read the series in my twenties, I knew this was a metaphor for some heavy lesson of life, but I couldn’t puzzle out which one. Now it seems abundantly clear. Some days the work of love — the tricky diplomacy and delicate conversations resulting in improved but still noticeably flawed outcomes — seems a lot to ask for something that used to be such easy magic.</p><p>Nevertheless, I feel lucky to have a marriage that, upon examination, reveals itself as capable of compatibility. It might have gone another way. He might have said, “But I don’t love your mind. I’ve never respected your ideas, and I think your obsession with writing them down is a self-indulgent waste of time. I loved you for your passion but now it never seems to be focused on me.” I might have said, “I’m not attracted to you anymore. I don’t think I will ever be again.” If this had happened, we would have had two options: divorce, or hunker down for the long haul in a loveless marriage.</p><p>This is where the true meaning of Romanticism comes clear, and I see that de Botton is right: Romanticism <em>is</em> the reason we get divorced. But his definition is wrong. Romanticism is not the notion that a perfect being exists who can meet all our needs and satisfy our every yearning. It’s the conviction that the purpose of marriage is to love and be loved; that a marriage without love is no marriage at all.</p><p>Perhaps if we threw out Romanticism we’d get divorced less often. But avoiding divorce is not the goal. The goal, which de Botton’s writing beautifully seeks to facilitate, is to be happier in our marriages. And the way to do <em>that</em> is to take Romanticism for granted, and focus instead on learning how to better love, and be loved.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d254c07ea306" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Do We Fall Out of Love?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/why-do-we-fall-out-of-love-5e18f91cf159?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e18f91cf159</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[divorce]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[breakups]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[friendship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[toxic-friendships]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Aug 2016 18:40:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-09T20:35:23.817Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/798/1*jP2FVy2vRwzqaKmW2qGBrQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I have reached the age of divorce. It’s a terrible age. Unlike the ages of graduations, weddings, and births which preceded it (and will no doubt follow, not for us but for our children), the age of divorce is not marked by parties. Instead, it is punctuated by long, unhappy conversations with my now-single friends, both male and female, and with my husband. We have so many things to figure out. Is this really happening? Is it justified? Whose fault is it? Could it have been avoided? My husband and I want to know, will it happen to us? Really, it all boils down to one question.</p><p>Why do we fall out of love?</p><p>Until recently, my own experience cast little light on the subject. The few times other people have definitively parted ways with me, they have not explained themselves, leaving me mystified as well as heartbroken. The few times I’d (agonizingly) ended relationships myself, I’d still <em>liked</em> the person I was breaking up with, just not enough for the relationship we’d moved into. The vast majority of dear, close friends I have had in my life are still my friends, even though sometimes distance and circumstance render those relationships dormant for long periods. My longest friendships have nearly all gone through rough spots, but they have also smoothed out again. I made it through my first forty years without learning how it felt to stop loving someone I’d previously adored.</p><p>Then, just over a year ago, I ended a friendship with a woman who, for fifteen years, had been one of my closest friends. I used to love her. I saw her several times a week, felt incomplete when something important happened to me and she didn’t know about it, discussed all my problems with her, shared all my secrets, knew all of hers. I considered her, and she considered herself, a member of my family. But gradually, over a number of years, our friendship changed. She seemed to continue to love me dearly and regard me as one of the most important people in her life, but she became inconsiderate of me in ways that made me feel deeply unloved. I found myself complaining about her behind her back, not just a little, but a lot, to anyone who would listen. I dreaded picking up the phone when she called. I disapproved of things about her that I used to easily forgive. I was angry at her, not only for the things she did, but for who she was. When she walked into my house, a cloud of resentment settled on me. I could barely stand to look at her.</p><p>I had not simply stopped loving her. I had gone to the other extreme. From loving her, I’d traveled to something that was nearly hate. I had fallen out of love.</p><p>This is how bad it got: I looked up the clinical definition of narcissistic personality disorder and discovered that my friend met every single one of the criteria. That should have made it clear and simple — who wants to be friends with a narcissist? But it didn’t. Lacking that ugly label, I had long been aware that she was selfish, inconsiderate, jealous, thin-skinned, insecure, and sometimes positively immoral. In full awareness of these flaws, I used to love her anyway. She had a great many good qualities to balance them out. When I still loved her, it would never have occurred to me to armchair diagnose her with a serious personality disorder. The fact that I had done so seemed more a symptom of my lack of love than the reason for it.</p><p>So what had changed?</p><p>The closest I could come to an explanation was a sense that she took and took from me and gave nothing back. But even this was hard to pin down. Yes, she asked a lot from me, but very little of it was onerous. She wanted my company and my attention and my approval, things I had once given her more than willingly, things that would seem to be the natural consequence of friendship, not the too-high cost of it.</p><p>The epiphany came, as is so often the case, when I was thinking about another question: What does it mean to fall in love? To fall in love, whether with a child, a pet, a friend, or a lover, is to experience the answer, in the form of another being, to one or more of our own deeply held needs. In a successful relationship, whether it be a love affair or a friendship, each person is meeting at least one need of the other, and the more fundamental the need, the more intense the relationship.</p><p>When we fall out of love, it came to me, the inverse is true. We fall out of love, not when our needs are not met — we are hopeful creatures — but when we understand that our needs will not <em>be</em> met, when we see that our loved ones no longer can or will or want to.</p><p>In marriage, the needs are many and they change as the largest features of our lives change — children, employment, health, community. Our spouses may cease to meet the needs that made us love them in the first place, only to meet new needs that develop along the way. In marriage we may fall in and out of love multiple times, hate our spouses on the one hand and love them all the more on the other. In marriage, it’s complicated. With my friend, it was simpler.</p><p>All my life I have sought out conversations in which I can hash out my own problems or someone else’s problems or the problems of the world in search of shared insight. It sounds small, probably, but it isn’t for me. I’ve had this need as long as I can remember. It’s the thing that makes me a writer, which is the most enduring and long-standing of my identities, predating paid employment, marriage, motherhood. This is the need that my friend met beautifully when I first knew her. She’s highly intelligent, has a memory like an elephant, is intensely analytical, is deeply interested in people, and, like me, considers a good conversation to be among the greatest pleasures in life.</p><p>We became friends when we were twenty-five, when we had similar pasts and similar future prospects which, as it happens, were not borne out. At each of the big forks in the road — marriage, children, education, career — we took different turns. As our lives diverged, I remained curious and empathetic about her experience, but she lost sympathy for mine. Her life was difficult and disappointing; she was jealous of me and found my problems petty compared with hers. Over time, I stopped discussing my own concerns. We analyzed her life instead, but she sought only my validation, not my insight. Our conversational connection, the search for shared understanding which had formed the basis of our friendship on my side, went dead.</p><p>It was not simply the dead connection that killed our friendship, though. Out of love, then good will, then habit; out of an understanding that my friend needed a lot from me but would give back to me when she could, I operated our friendship at a deficit for nearly a decade. Honestly, I would have continued to do so. The true cause of death was not my unmet need itself, but the realization that my friend had become someone who couldn’t meet it and no longer wanted to. If at the same time she had needed me less herself, we might have drifted apart without much pain or rancor. But instead she clung to me all the more tightly, feeling entitled to rely upon me to meet a great, growing crop of her own needs — of the sort that someone else might have spread over a spouse, family, other friends, babysitters — world without end.</p><p>We speak of love as selfless, generous, bottomless. When we crash into its limits we feel flawed and terrible. But we misunderstand the nature of love. Yes, love can be selfless, but not indefinitely. We give love to those we need, and when our need is met, our love feels limitless, capable of any acceptance, any forgiveness, any gift in our power. Need is the engine of love. But the process by which this engine is fueled often escapes our notice entirely, because when all is working well, we meet the needs of those who love us without any effort at all, simply, as it seems, by existing. When our lives were similar, my friend met my very large need for a particular sort of conversation with no effort at all, by doing something she, too, found pleasurable. As long as she met that need of mine, the time I spent in her company was nothing but a pleasure for me, and if by spending that time I also met her own very large need for more family, it cost me nothing at all. When she stopped meeting my need, the engine of my love for her gradually lost power, and the ever-growing burden of her own needs finally burned it out completely.</p><p>There is an additional point to be made. When love dies, the need from which it sprang will endure. Sooner or later, that need in us will manifest another love: That’s how it works, and it is no one’s fault. This is no less true in marriage than in friendship. The difference is, in marriage there is shame, betrayal, guilt in the inevitable moving on, if it begins when the marriage has not reached an official end: In friendship, we’re allowed. My former friend must be replacing me with new friends by now, and I wish her well. As for me, I started replacing her a decade ago. By the time I finally said goodbye to her, I hadn’t needed her in years.</p><p>I know because I didn’t miss her. I only felt relief.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e18f91cf159" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Life Changing Magic of Fighting by Text]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/the-life-changing-magic-of-fighting-by-text-d6b82ec0c957?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6b82ec0c957</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Apr 2016 12:31:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-27T20:31:21.728Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*taXjLLZWayA2w95InEd1ag.jpeg" /></figure><p>My husband and I have been together for eighteen years, married for fourteen of those, and consequently we have our share of disagreements, misunderstandings, and fundamental incompatibilities. Plenty of these we resolve (or live with) more or less amicably, but sometimes they turn into fights. A fight can begin over anything, but it always ends in one or both of two ugly places.</p><h4><em>Ugly Place #1</em></h4><p>Me: [Explicates grievance with a clarity, insight, fairness to both sides, and basic wisdom that would surely inspire any marriage counselor to send us home without charging us because there was nothing left to add.]</p><p>Him: I can’t hear a word you’re saying because of your tone.</p><p>Me: My tone is like this because I’ve said the same thing fifteen times and you still haven’t heard me and I’m really, really frustrated!</p><p>Him: Well, when you sound like that I just don’t feel like doing anything for you, or even being around you.</p><h4><em>Ugly Place #2</em></h4><p>Him: You want me to apologize? Fine. I’m sorry. Happy now?</p><p>Me: No, because [attempts yet again to explicate grievance with clarity, insight, fairness to both sides, etc.]</p><p>Him: See? Apologizing to you never works. You just use it as an excuse to double down.</p><p>Me: That’s because I don’t want you to apologize! I want you to <em>hear</em> me!</p><p>Once we’ve arrived in either of these places, all hope of resolving the original conflict is long gone. If we’re lucky, it has become very late at night and we’re too tired to keep fighting so we go to bed mad. If we’re unlucky, nothing intervenes and…the best that can be said is that we’ve never physically injured each other. Maybe I’ll leave it at that.</p><p>Over time, we have learned all the fastest routes to the ugly places. Our efficiency is a wonder to behold.</p><p>Me: [Gazes out the window with an unhappy expression.]</p><p>Him: I <em>know</em> the grass needs mowing — could you get off my case?</p><p>Me: I wasn’t even <em>looking </em>at the grass —</p><p>Him: I can’t hear a word you’re saying when you take that tone.</p><p>Not long ago, I listened to a therapist explaining a rather obvious point to my daughter. “It’s hard to find a good solution to a problem when you’re upset. The trick is to calm down first.” I say it’s an obvious point, but if it had occurred to me to teach my daughter this, I wouldn’t have been paying the therapist. It’s possible that I have never in my life calmed down before attempting to solve a problem that’s upsetting me. Instead, I deduce the problem from the upset and solve it in order to calm down. Hey, it works for me. But it doesn’t work for my daughter. As soon as I thought about it, I realized it doesn’t work for my husband, either. I began to consider our fights from a radical new perspective. What if my husband was not an unreasonable asshole? What if the anger in my tone really did upset him so much that he couldn’t solve the problem we were fighting about?</p><p>I wasn’t sure what to do with this insight. I doubted that my husband would notice if I managed to fix my tone, since he’d intuit my anger from the expression on my face. And there is nothing to be done about my face. Some people are born poker failures, and I am one of them.</p><p>I would like to tell you that I arrived at a brilliant solution by the application of logic, but instead it happened by chance. My husband and I had a fight. It went roughly like this:</p><p>Me: [Had day that, for reasons having nothing to do with my husband, began being horrible before I got out of bed and proceeded from there.]</p><p>Him: [Came home from work still mad because I was bitchy in the morning; became even madder because I still looked grumpy when he walked in the door.]</p><p>Me: Could you pass the wine?</p><p>Him: I don’t feel like doing anything for you when you take that tone. Get it yourself.</p><p>Me: You used to be nice to me when I was upset. Now when I have a bad day you take it personally when it has nothing to do with you and you’re mean to me. I feel like you’re only nice to me when I’m already fine, and when I most need to feel loved you don’t even like me.</p><p>Him: You want me to apologize? Fine. I’m sorry. Happy now?</p><p>It was a going to bed still mad kind of night.</p><p>The next morning we were chilly to each other until he left for work, and later he texted me.</p><p>Him: What was wrong with you last night? Your rage seemed completely disproportionate to the situation.</p><p>Me: It was not disproportionate. I feel like I came home with a scrape and instead of giving me a hug you poked me with a sharp stick. I think my rage was fully proportionate.</p><p>Him: I didn’t mean to dismiss your feelings. But you were rude to me and I reacted badly. I will try to be nicer if you will.</p><p>Me: You interpreted me as being rude to you, but it wasn’t my intention. I had a really shitty day. I didn’t get anything done that I needed to because there was a sick kid. We had to hang out at the germy doctor’s office during flu season, which freaks me out. I got screamed at a lot because the sick kid wanted to be doing something more fun than staying home sick. At the grocery store I accidentally crashed my cart into some guy’s cart and my fervent apology was met with a wordless snarl and I barely got checked out without bursting into tears. Then you were mean to me all evening.</p><p>This is when the miracle happened.</p><p>Him: Wow. I didn’t know about the guy at the grocery store. That kind of thing really bugs me. I’m sorry for my part in your bad day. I didn’t deal with you kindly, and I let us both down. I wish I’d been more aware of what was going on with you. I’ll try to do a better job in the future.</p><p>I was utterly gobsmacked. Was this even my husband? Had he outsourced this conversation to some helpful, emotionally sensitive person at his office? I would have been sure of it, except that for years I had been telling him what I needed to hear, and he had just repeated it back to me, nearly verbatim. <em>I don’t want you to say you’re sorry. I want you to say you understand why I’m mad, and that you weren’t trying to make me furious and miserable, and that, in the future, you will try to avoid doing the thing that made me feel this way, now that I have explained to you what it was. </em>This was the first evidence in a decade that, despite my tone, he’d heard me after all.</p><p>A couple of weeks later, it happened again. I was inadvertently rude to him. He took offense. Instead of apologizing, I got defensive. He dredged up a previous rudeness of mine which I had completely forgotten and demanded that I account for the troubling pattern he saw emerging. I slammed out of the house in a fury because it was time to take a child to a music lesson.</p><p>A few minutes into the music lesson, a text from him. A total of five messages later, we had it cleared up. He was sorry, I was sorry, we had both acted like jerks but not out of malice. By the time I got home an hour later, we were friends again.</p><p>Ever since I got my first email account, I’ve been warned that an email message is a poor choice for sensitive communication because, unlike voice, it doesn’t accurately convey tone. I’ve always been a little skeptical of this advice because writing a letter is considered a good way to communicate when you have something difficult to say and need to convey it carefully. The difference between a letter and an email is not lack of tone, it’s speed. Email is easy to fire off in the heat of the moment, whereas writing a letter forces you to slow down and be more deliberate. Isn’t the implication that email conveys tone — or at least mood — all too accurately? And if this is true of email, how much more true is it of texting, the fastest and least deliberate form of written communication yet developed?</p><p>According to all my previous notions, fighting by text is a terrible idea. But it was working like magic. Why? <em>Because text doesn’t accurately convey tone.</em> It conveys words. If you’re too angry to form coherent sentences, texting won’t do a thing to help. I’m almost never too angry to form coherent sentences. But for some reason, my husband has never been able to appreciate the cogency of my statements when I yell them with tears of hurt and fury streaming down my face. I guess we all have our limitations.</p><p>Fortunately, these days we also have instant messaging. From now on when tempers are on the rise, I plan to walk out the door with texting device in hand, and fight with my words instead of my voice so my husband can hear me. Maybe from now on, our lucky fights can be the ones where we <em>don’t</em> go to bed still mad.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6b82ec0c957" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Search of Lost Libido]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@faye.calloway/in-search-of-lost-libido-b532dd904c80?source=rss-3fb247851d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b532dd904c80</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marriage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love-and-sex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Faye Calloway]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 19 Mar 2016 23:56:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-19T23:56:24.563Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KhDJOW_rM_3oSnrS3YzRpg.jpeg" /></figure><p>When sex is going well between me and my husband, there is very little I can do wrong in his eyes. If the kids stomp on my last frayed nerve and I screech at them like a harpy to drive them out of my presence he might say, “Little jerks. Here, let me pour you another glass of wine.” (This is a certain stage of marriage at its finest — insulting your shared offspring and abetting one another’s substance abuse. The important thing is to do this <em>together</em>, without judgement.) However, when my husband does not feel well laid, I can shriek at the kids in the morning and he’ll come home that evening still displeased with me and my shrewish temper, and maintain that displeasure no matter what display of family peace and harmony greets him when he walks in the door.</p><p>It’s not just me he dislikes when he’s in this state. When he feels sexually deprived, he, too, is irritable and impatient with the kids. He lacks all enthusiasm for his job. He feels the joy has been sucked out of his life and he has nothing to look forward to but years of drudgery in the service of his ungrateful family. He cannot be enticed by proposals of movie-watching, dinner in nice restaurants, time away from the rest of us, or any of the things he usually enjoys. He is immune to any acts of kindness on my part — except a rewarding round of intercourse, which, not surprisingly, is difficult to pull off in these circumstances.</p><p>More than one long-married couple among my friends report a similar dynamic. As problems go, this one seems easy to solve:</p><blockquote>Do something we both enjoy, together and frequently. Simple, right?</blockquote><p>Well, no.</p><p>My husband’s libido and mine are two completely different animals. His is a large cat. It sleeps lightly and is easily roused both day and night. Mine is a bear, subject to lengthy periods of hibernation and irritable when poked awake by, say, a bored cat wanting to play. It seems laughably obvious that these two animals do not belong together. How could they ever make each other happy?</p><blockquote>But my libido wasn’t always a bear. It used to be a cat, too.</blockquote><p>When my husband and I were first together, we wanted each other so badly that we’d get it on in the kitchen because the bedroom was too far away, or we’d park just short of our destination on car trips and climb into the back seat because we’d been feeling each other up the whole way and were on the verge of spontaneous combustion. But this wildcat kind of desire disappeared for me early in our marriage. A year or two in I tried switching up my birth control pills because I thought the hormones were wrecking my sex drive. Later I thought I’d deliberately squelched this part of myself for fear I would cheat on my husband. I was so afraid I would, because the only times I felt that easy, quick attraction he used to spark, it was for someone else. If I had sexy dreams and woke up so turned on I had to wake him up to do something about it, those dreams were not about him. Later still, I blamed the kids, the hormonal changes of pregnancy and breastfeeding, intimacy overload, exhaustion.</p><p>My husband felt betrayed and suspicious. “I know this is part of you,” he would say. “I remember it clearly! It didn’t just evaporate. It’s there somewhere. It’s bound to be up to something, but no matter what I do, I can’t get to it!” I couldn’t get to it either. I imagined a river vanished underground, perhaps eroding a giant sinkhole beneath the foundations of our marriage.</p><p>So I went looking for it. I’ve been looking for years now, and although I haven’t found a magic spell to turn my libido back into a cat, I have found a few things, here and there, that make it feel less like a bear. They don’t last long, but I don’t need them to. They’re like glamours I carry around in the pockets of my mind. I pull them out when my playful cat of a husband tries to wake my hibernating bear and we’re headed straight for the kind of fight that can make the cat sulk for days.</p><blockquote>What are these magic things? They’re stories.</blockquote><p>I find them:</p><ul><li><strong>In books.</strong><em> </em>A romance industry that nets a billion dollars a year (in the U.S. alone) is a giveaway that I’m not the first person to stumble on this solution. And yet, though I have dabbled in reading romance, and have indeed found some very hot sex and been turned on by it, I haven’t tended to find stories that really work for me in romance novels. What kinds of stories really work? Ones that connect me to my own experience of desire. I have been madly in love. I have felt desire that made me so wild and wanton I barely recognized myself. I want stories that make me remember how it feels. In the romance novel plots of good girls who learn to be bad, bad girls who learn to be good, Cinderellas rescued from empty lives by wealth, hot sex, and true love (in that order): Where am I? Nowhere I can see. I’m the little match girl looking in the windows at someone else’s food and warmth. I tend to find what I’m looking for in books that tell bigger stories, of which desire is a part. Diana Gabaldon’s <em>Outlander</em> series is my favorite. Madeline Miller’s <em>Song of Achilles</em> is another. Neither bears any resemblance to my life, but when the characters fall madly in love, madly in lust, I remember perfectly how it feels.</li><li><a href="http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=sr_fapo?rh=n%3A283155%2Cp_27%3AFaye+Calloway&amp;sort=relevance&amp;ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1458429274&amp;fap=1"><strong>In my writing.</strong></a> Stories that connect me to my own experience of desire are not easy to find. I can think of various reasons for this, but they all pretty much boil down to: Shame. Sex is as many different things as food is. It can be transcendent in a way we’ll remember all our lives. It can poison us. It can be utterly mundane, a responsibility, a chore. But though we don’t mind admitting this about food, we don’t generally allow the same sort of honesty around sex. We bandy about packaged versions of it — airbrushed girls in swimsuits draped over sports cars, the dukes and billionaires of romance novels — that bear as much resemblance to the sex we <em>have</em> as a McDonald’s hamburger advertisement bears to a home-cooked meal. Somehow we believe in this packaged version, and think, when it looks like nothing we know, that there’s something wrong with <em>us</em>. So we talk about it even less. When literary writers say <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/06/books/review/the-naughty-bits.html?pagewanted=all&amp;_r=0">it’s impossible to write well about sex</a>, I think it must be this packaged version they’re talking about. Slapping the slick, consumer idea of sex into a novel that is otherwise concerned with getting at honest truths about human existence would be a little like hanging a McDonald’s ad in the Louvre. Because we’re ashamed of sex, we have turned it into something false, and because it’s false, the kinds of writers and publishers and readers who value the real shy away from it. And yet — we yearn for the experience itself. Not the fake, but the real thing at its best. At least, I do. So, in the time honored tradition of writers short on the stories they want to read, <a href="http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=sr_fapo?rh=n%3A283155%2Cp_27%3AFaye+Calloway&amp;sort=relevance&amp;ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1458429274&amp;fap=1">I make my own</a>.</li><li><strong>In flirtations with other men.</strong><em> </em>These are often much more than stories, and I could devote an entire essay to the role of the “work husband,” the gym crush, the old flame rediscovered on Facebook who corresponds enthrallingly from afar. These “emotional affairs” get a terrible rap. <em>Just as bad as a physical affair</em>, countless click-bait articles scold, as if there’s no meaningful distinction to be made between thinking and doing. (Taken to its logical extension, this line of reasoning would mandate locking up murder mystery writers.) When handled in ways that skirt the jealousy issue, I have known these relationships to improve marriages at least as often as they damage them, in the same way that any close friendship can. They meet emotional needs our poor, overtaxed marriages can’t handle. They can make us happier, more fulfilled, less resentful of our spouses for not being everything we need at every moment. Happier people make for happier marriages. The jealousy issue is difficult to skirt without wading into dishonesty, though, and that’s no small problem. This is where stories come in. I transform blameless interactions with men I’m attracted to into lurid, fantasy affairs in the privacy of my mind. I admit this is risky. It is impossible to want a man who is not my husband without, well, <em>wanting</em> him. But wanting and having are not the same, and so far I have managed to remember that the goal of this game is to <em>want</em>. I’ve got the having covered. Jealousy is still a problem sometimes. My husband is attuned to me closely enough to be aware of what I’m doing and we’ve had quite a few fights about it. But we’ve had better sex, too.</li></ul><blockquote>What do these stories do for me? I think they simulate the ready passion of a new love affair.</blockquote><p>Emily Nagoski writes in her illuminating book <a href="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00LD1ORBI/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?ie=UTF8&amp;btkr=1"><em>Come as You Are: The Surprising New Science that Will Transform Your Sex Life</em></a>, that the highest intensity kind of desire tends to occur at the beginnings of love affairs when the security of the attachment between the lovers is uncertain. This explains why I was a cat when my husband and I first met, but have been a bear ever since. Nagoski wisely points out that the sex isn’t always good just because the wanting is high-intensity. What I mostly experience is the inverse of this. The sex my husband and I have when we both want it is excellent. But I don’t always want the sex just because it’s good.</p><blockquote>And there’s no surer way to turn good sex bad than not to want it.</blockquote><p>These stories, these glamours that make me want what I already have, are not a perfect solution. Because of course they don’t make me want precisely what I have. The obvious flaw, particularly as my husband sees it, is that my stories are not about <em>him</em>. He wants me looking in his eyes, seeing him, wanting <em>him</em>, not drifting on a fantasy of my imaginary characters or, even worse, some non-imaginary man. I’d like that, too. But how?</p><p>Emily Nagoski would advise me, I think, to reframe my goal. Why would I want that anxious, insecure-attachment kind of sex when the possibility of something much deeper and more meaningful exists with my husband? She would tell me that what I have is already perfect, if only I would stop buying into the notion that my desire should be the spontaneous kind more often experienced by men. Most women experience contextual desire — the kind that kicks in once we’ve been hanging out for a while in a sexy situation, rather than the kind that flares up at the least provocation and propels us nearly against our wills <em>into</em> the sexy situation. I think she would tell me: You are a bear, not a cat. Bears are marvelous when you find the right way to wake them up. Love being a bear! I think she would tell my husband: Don’t poke the bear. Wake her nicely, don’t stress her out, and she will make you happy. She would tell him: The little monitor in your brain that pushes you off the cliff of despair when you don’t get laid is adjustable. Sex is not a drive, like hunger, like thirst. No one has ever suffered tissue damage for lack of it.</p><p>I’m pretty sure Emily Nagoski is right. I’m going to experiment with her advice. But I doubt I will stop reading sexy stories, writing sexy stories, engaging — opportunity permitting — in the odd fantasy affair. I doubt I will give up falling passionately in love in my imagination. Because waking the bear up nicely under stress-free conditions frankly sounds like a lot of work. It smacks of planning, childcare, reservations and expense. It doesn’t sound like the kind of thing that would fit into ten minutes before the alarm clock goes off on a weekday, the last chance at armistice in the face of looming interspecies war.</p><p>Sometimes I just need to feel like a cat.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b532dd904c80" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>