<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Félix de Rosen on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Félix de Rosen on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@felixderosen?source=rss-bf7b029baedc------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 14:22:44 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@felixderosen/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thoughts on Collapse & Holding My Breath Underwater]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@felixderosen/thoughts-on-collapse-holding-my-breath-underwater-9f62768ea726?source=rss-bf7b029baedc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f62768ea726</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[polycrisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meta-crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freediving]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collapse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Félix de Rosen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Mar 2024 22:48:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-04T22:48:20.540Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AVX0kjT8k3HpFzD9k_BJBg.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><em>“A world full of billions of people who understand their eco-distress as super-fuel, and who have allowed their feelings to meaningfully reshape the deepest parts of themselves, is health by another name.”</em></blockquote><blockquote>-Britt Wray<em>, Generation Dread</em></blockquote><p>Sixty feet underwater and with only the air in my lungs sustaining me, I opened my eyes to a golden ray of light flowing down serpent-like, diagonally through the deep azure around me. Immersed in this vast blue body of water, I received an inkling of insight as to the origins of my attention to the subject of collapse.</p><p>Morbid fascination with death or decay? No. A hunch as to how things were going to turn out? I wish, but no. It was something simpler and more elusive. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it, but knew it had to do with curiosity. Curiosity about our planet and its current state and direction. Curiosity about my own cognitive biases. The curiosity of not knowing the future has in store and the accompanying sense of wonder for the present.</p><p>Because to think about collapse, as I do when I swim deep underwater, is to contemplate the unknown without needing to resolve into something known. The French philosopher Albert Camus wrote, with typical French existentialist gravitas, that “there is but one truly serious philosophical problem and that is suicide.” For Camus, contemplating suicide and death was a responsibility we owed to life: how can you fully appreciate the gifts of life if you haven’t imagine its end?</p><p>In a similar vein, the writer David Foster Wallace, in a speech to the 2005 graduating class of Kenyon College, tells the story of two young fish who meet an older fish that says “Morning, boys. How’s the water?” The young fish swim on for a bit, until one of them looks at the other and says “What the hell is water?”</p><p>The story is short. The metaphor is simple: we often don’t appreciate what we are immersed in. This is why we often don’t think about the air we breathe, even though we inhale over 20,000 times per day. My underwater insight was that feeling into the breakdown of our social-ecological systems was a way to reconnect with the beauty, complexity, and mystery of life on Earth. Diving underwater, holding my breath for minutes at a time, paradoxically brought a breath of fresh air to my world.</p><p>I had come to the Yucatan Peninsula, that bit of Mexico that juts out into the Caribbean Sea, to train how to dive underwater using only my breath, a practice known as freediving. Flying into Cancun Airport, the landscape below looked like a moist, shaggy carpet of greenish-gray trees, interrupted here and there by communication towers, sliced through by highways, and punctuated by low-rise settlements. The Yucatan Peninsula is a vast limestone plain that connects southeastern Mexico, northern Guatemala, and Belize. That limestone is a key reason why the area is such a mecca for divers of all kinds, both the scuba divers who rely on bottled air and the freedivers who work only with their breath.</p><p>Limestone is composed primarily of calcium carbonate, the primary ingredient in the shells of eggs, snails, shellfish, and many other natural materials such as pearls and chalk. Limestone is partially soluble in water. As it is exposed to water — whether in the form of rain, waves, or rivers — it erodes over time, creating stunning cliff edges, deep ravines, and caves. Most cave systems across the planet are formed as water wears away at underground weak spots in the limestone, gradually creating larger and larger cavities and channels.</p><p>From the plane, I can’t spot any rivers in the landscape because the Yucatan has no rivers. Instead of running on the surface and collecting into streams and rivers, the rainwater here percolates into the limestone bedrock and gathers into the world’s most extensive underground network of caves, with one cave measured at over 347 kilometers in length.</p><p>Sometimes, the roof of these caves collapses, and the water within is exposed to the air above, forming deep open-sky wells known as cenotes. The cenotes of the Yucatan attract divers from all over the world because their waters are calm and deeply transparent. Sunken beneath the surrounding forest, wind doesn’t disturb the surface. Because cenote water is filtered through the limestone, it contains little suspended particulate matter. Good visibility and stable conditions. In other words, a diver’s dream.</p><p>One sunny morning, I walk through a quiet, leafy residential neighborhood in the seaside resort city of Playa del Carmen and find the building I’m looking for. I push through the creaky gate and enter <em>Pranamaya,</em> the local freediving school, to start a three day intro course to freediving. My freediving instructor, Claudio, is an Argentine who spends the warm season running a freediving school on the other side of Mexico, in Baja California, and the rest of the year teaching in Yucatan. He is tall, thin, and muscular, and has the weather-worn calm of a man who spends a good chunk of his life under the sun and in the ocean. He seems friendly and genuinely excited in introducing me and the other two students to freediving.</p><p>Freediving is an ancient practice. Across the world, people living by the sea have learned to hunt and forage underwater for sustenance. Pearl hunting, performed by freedivers, was a core part of the economy of diverse cultures, from Japan to the Philippines and the Persian Gulf. Because of the prominence of freediving in their lives, some people have even evolved special genetic adaptations. A 2018 study showed that the spleens of the Bajau people of southeast Asia are 50 per cent larger than those of a neighboring land-based group. When the spleen contracts underwater, it releases more oxygen-rich blood allowing the Bajau to dive longer underwater.</p><p>But as a recreational practice in the West, freediving is still relatively new. The sport has exploded in popularity since the 2010s, aided by a slew of books and movies. The goal of our beginner’s course is to understand the basic physiological principles that allow us to hold our breath, dive underwater, and re-emerge safely. If everything went well, we would finish the course capable of comfortably swimming to a depth of 12 meters (40 feet), or roughly the length of a 4 story building. “That sounds impossible,” I told Claudio. “Don’t worry,” he said, “it’s not a race. We’ll go one step at a time.”</p><p>I was first drawn to freediving through dazzling cinematic Youtube videos of freedivers moving underwater, seemingly unperturbed by gravity. Yes, it’s true; the internet brought me. The minimalism of those videos appealed to me: solitary bodies floating in what seemed like infinity, and with little to no equipment necessary, only a wetsuit, eye mask, and fins. Freediving appeared, at least from the slickly produced videos I watched, to offer a unique combination of freedom of motion, physical challenge, and direct, unmediated immersion in nature. I was hooked.</p><p>But I was also terrified. I would watch the videos — like most people- holding my breath, in a mixture of fear and awe, never thinking I would try it. The very idea of being underwater and not able to breath gave me mild panic attacks. It brought me back to childhood nightmares of drowning in dark, uncaring waters, suffocated by stormy seas, lost and tragically forgotten. Eventually, my curiosity got the upper hand. The freedivers I saw online raved about the sense of calm they felt underwater. Perhaps a way to understand my fear was quite literally to immerse myself in it… Instead of getting rid of my fear, could I engage it, even befriend it?</p><p>For something that we do on average over 20,000 times per day, one would think we would have a better understanding of how breathing actually works. But fear seems to thrive on ignorance, and we take the most common things for granted. Thankfully, on day one of the course, Claudio, with his charismatic calm, went a long way in dispelling my fears. Standing in front of a white board in the dimly lit living room of the diving school, he shared the four stages of a freediver’s breath hold. Each stage corresponds to a different, protective instinct of the body. “If you understand and respect the natural responses of your body to not breathing,” he emphasized, “you’ll have no problem freediving.”</p><p>Upon inhaling a lungful of air, you don’t feel the desire to breathe for some moment; this is the comfort phase. When the desire emerges is the beginning of the second, or negotiation, phase. From a physiological perspective, you aren’t in danger; you aren’t low on oxygen. Your body simply responds to increasing levels of carbon dioxide in the blood with the urge to breathe. It’s called the negotiation phase because you can be in conversation with your mind, negotiating with it, to remind it that there is no real emergency.</p><p>Gradually, carbon dioxide levels in the blood continue to rise, amplifying the urge to breathe, and oxygen levels in the blood lower enough that the abdominal area starts to spasm in small contractions. It’s the body’s next instinctual layer of defense, trying to force air out of the lungs so that fresh air can come back in. It’s called the “fight” phase because you still aren’t in danger at this point: by learning to relax the body, the onset of the contractions can be significantly delayed and you can learn to tolerate them more easily. If you start having contractions underwater at depth, it’s time to make your way back to the surface.</p><p>If one keeps pushing through the contractions, the body eventually blacks out. This is the fourth stage, and yet another instinctual, protective response of the body. During a black out, the body stops breathing and shuts down all functions that aren’t immediately needed for survival. After a few minutes of blackout, the body will try its final protective mechanism: a forced exhale and an inhalation. If you’re underwater, that can mean drowning. If you’re above the surface, it means another breath.</p><p>Later, Claudio leads us to the sunny roof of the school, where we splay out on yoga mats for a bit of stretching and relaxation exercises. Claudio likes to incorporate yogic exercises into his freediving training; it’s a way of relaxing the body and preparing ourselves for holding our breaths. With dogs barking, palm trees rustling, and reggaeton music playing in the background, we start with a simple breath-hold to see how long we can comfortably last. The goal is not to set a record, but to familiarize ourselves with our limits and the experience of withholding breathing.</p><p>“Ok, 3, 2, 1, go!” says Claudio. The first 20 seconds fly by like a breeze. When I feel a desire to breathe, I try to simply relax and scan my body for tension as instructed by Claudio. I have to remind myself that the desire to breathe at this point is just that, a desire, not an actual need. After a minute or so of this internal dialogue, the contractions start. These are harder to negotiate with as the urge to breathe becomes increasingly intenses, increasingly unbearable. Trying to relax in these conditions feels impossible, like a mind-bending paradox. For a few seconds, I wonder what I am doing torturing myself with a self-imposed suffocation ritual on a yoga mat in Mexico. Eventually, I remember this isn’t a competition, and just over two minutes into the experience, I exhale and breathe in the fresh air. I’m still there, in one piece. Phew.</p><p>Later that day, we repeat the experience face down in a shallow pool, with pool toys to help us float comfortably in the water so we can fully relax our bodies. We go one at a time, with Claudio standing at our sides, guardian angel-style, encouraging us to relax, testing our limbs to see if we are holding tension or not: “Let go of your neck…let go of your jaw…let go of your legs…there, you got it, just let go…”</p><p>Doing the exercise in water feels completely different than on our yoga mats. When cool water touches the human face, the heart rate lowers, blood is circulated away from our limbs towards the vital organs, and the spleen releases oxygen-rich blood cells. It’s called the mammalian dive response. Amazingly, we share this instinct with all marine mammals, such as dolphins, whales, and sea lions. When they dive deep into the ocean, these same mechanisms become activated, but to a much greater extent.</p><p>With the floaters supporting me, it’s easier to relax and allow my mind and body to wander. This time around, I last a full minute longer than on land. The same challenges emerge as on land, but I start to familiarize myself with the peculiar feeling of rising carbon dioxide levels in the body and with relaxing into the rising tension that a breathhold entails. “It’s a mental game,” says Claudio. “Yes, eventually you do need to breath, but until you reach that point, you have to simply relax.”</p><p>The next day, we meet at the school, pack our wetsuits, fins, and snorkel masks, and pack into the school’s white pickup truck. With mediocre house music playing through the truck’s ratty speakers, we drive through Playa del Carmen to a nearby cenote to begin our first dive. There are thousands of cenotes in the Yucatan Peninsula, with varying range of depth and width. They carry different names — Maravilla, el Pit, Angelita<em> </em>— to reflect their unique characteristics. Because the cenotes provided easy access to clean freshwater in an area without rivers, they have played a central role in the practical and ceremonial lives of the Maya people, the predominant indigenous people of the Yucatan.</p><p>Important Maya settlements, such as the famous Chichen Itza, were built around these natural wells. The Maya also traditionally consider the cenotes as entrances to Xibalba, the realm of the afterlife and home to the rain god Chaac. As I walk towards the cenote, it’s not hard to understand why. From the parking lot, I walk through the dense forest barefoot on a gravel path broken up by tree roots and ant routes. The path reaches the edge of a cliff, where I can see below me a perfectly round pool of water, the color of lapis lazuli, about 30 meters wide, marks a clear break from the surrounding vegetation. Trees, from the very edge of the cliff, lean over the water; some have partially fallen in. The contrast between the pool and forest looks like a minimalist painting: blue circle, gray-green line, blue sky. It does feel like a portal. Out of precaution, I ask Chaac for safe passage through this underworld.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*21fn6kJJ0PAz8m3y6Qh9hw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Claudio waits for us in the middle of the cenote by a buoy. Ten kilos of weights attached to a rope hang down in the water from the buoy, creating an underwater vertical axis onto which we can lower and raise ourselves during our exercises. We start off gently, each student lowering themselves down the rope, head up, to 5 meters depth. At that depth, we start to learn how to equalize our ears: underwater, the pressure from the water compresses the air in the ear canal, so we pinch our noses and blow into our ears to bring the pressure back to normal.</p><p>For our next dives, Claudio has us go down head first, using the rope to pull ourselves down. Before each dive, we take a minute or two to float by the buoy, relax our bodies, and declutter our minds. After this period of rest, we take a big breath and go down.</p><p>During my first dives, I am so focused on doing the exercise right that I forget Claudio’s #1 rule: relax and enjoy yourself. I find it hard to relax when I’m also learning to hold my breath, habituate myself to pressure, and calm my mind simultaneously. But Claudio’s insistence on relaxation is not just a good vibe check. It’s an essential requirement of good freediving. A fearful or anxious mind causes tension in the body, which uses up more energy and oxygen, and thus reduces time spent underwater. It’s common for free beginning freedivers to obsess about how deep they can go, at the expense of how responsibly and enjoyably they dive. My freediving manual says it simply in bold letters: “Dive relaxed, or do not dive.” It’s not the most encouraging instruction, but it gets the point across.</p><p>Over the course of the day, and the next, we slowly increase our comfort with depth until we reach the 12 meter goal. After each dive, the sensation of panic and anxiety dissipates and is replaced by calm and wonder. Pulling slowly down the rope, my entire attention is focused on the points of tension in my body that emerge as I go deeper and deeper. With the rope guiding me, I do some descents eyes closed. Everything disappears during that time as I concentrate on the sensations in my body: the feeling of the cold water on my skin, the increasing pressure on my ears, the sounds made by the aquatic life around me, my heart beating, as well as my own internal voices occasionally freaking out.</p><p>And, sooner than expected, my hand touches the stopper at the end of the rope, I fold forward to turn 180 degrees, and open my eyes. Beside me, a few small fish and Claudio, making sure I’m doing things right. Below me, deeper, darker waters. Above, light filtering through the speckled surface. Suspended in this watery cathedral, I feel weightless, as does my awareness, which stretches out into the waters of the cenote, following the water’s journey backwards through the labyrinthic underground rivers, up into the porous limestone bedrock, through the tangled tropical forests, into rainfall, and back into cloud. For a few seconds, I indulge in that peaceful expansiveness until, shit, the contractions kick in, I remember where I am, and I swim back up.</p><p>The French professional freediver Guillaume Nery, who dives to depths of over 120 meters, has some interesting thoughts about freediving. “Today,” he says, “we’re under so much pressure. Our minds are overworked, we think at a million miles an hour, we’re always stressed. Being able to freedive lets you, just for a moment, relax your mind.”</p><p>I’m curious about this parallel Guillaume draws between the pressure of our lives and the pressure underwater. When we feel pressure on land, we tend to either ignore, relieve, or release it. But what happens when a pressure is too powerful for any of those options? What do we do when we can’t get rid of the pressure? In describing the experience of being 80 meters underwater, Guillaume says: “I let the water crush me. I accept the pressure and go with it… I relinquish all control, and relax completely. The pressure starts crushing me, and it doesn’t feel bad at all. I even feel like I’m in a cocoon, protected.” I’m relieved when I first hear Guillaume speaking at a TEDx talk online. Relieved to hear someone speak about the benefits of surrendering to pressure.</p><p>“Nature and the elements are stronger than you,” says Guillaume. During my time in Yucatan, these words echo in my mind. If modernity is an experience of rising pressures coming from multiple predicaments, what does a healthy surrender look like? Not a surrender that gives up, but rather a surrender that accepts.</p><p>What I find so interesting about freediving is how exposed one is to the watery surroundings. Without all the gear that scuba divers are forced to carry, freedivers have no choice but to practice humility in the water. That humility, ironically, requires training, as freedivers learn to habituate their bodies to the new pressure, turning discomfort into comfort, so that they have the freedom underwater to enjoy the moment.</p><p>As I continued to train after the course, I would reach a limit, a depth that I couldn’t go beyond. Usually, it was because I couldn’t equalize my ears, or because my mind started playing games with me. Every freediver reaches a limit: it’s the point at which your body and mind are not capable of enduring the stress. Whether in freediving or in life on land, going beyond that limit requires accepting the stress, feeling it in, and then acting appropriately.</p><p>This training process is not a switch that suddenly turns on. It’s a muscle that we strengthen through practices of paying attention to what our bodies are telling us and being skeptical of the biased narratives we tell about ourselves. During my dives, I would occasionally have contractions on my way, early enough that it was clearly a result of stress rather than a need to breath. I needed time to understand the difference between what my mind was saying was real and what my body was speaking. Over time, I started relaxing more deeply and the contractions disappeared.</p><p>My training also underscored how important basic safety protocols are in this learning process. Without the morning relaxation exercises, without an understanding of how to respond in case of an emergency, without Claudio by my side during my dives, I would have felt lonely and incapable of diving. The parallels with collapse are worth spelling out: we need safe containers to explore difficult, challenging, and potentially traumatizing territory. These containers are physical, social, and virtual spaces where no one is shamed into any direction, places where we can let go of our guard and understand that we are not alone in our feelings, so that we can go deeper, together, and develop a practice of resilience.</p><p>Developing resilience is a lifelong process because collapse is a predicament that we learn to live with and engage. And yet, we live in a culture that prioritizes simple narratives and quick-fixes, where it’s hard to fully comprehend the simple idea that some narratives are complex and some problems don’t have easy solutions. Some situations require care, not problem solving. The unexpected gift of freediving, for me, was to enter an uncanny place where tension and relaxation, comfort and discomfort,could coexist. An ambiguous realm beyond my control but in which I nonetheless had the freedom to act.</p><p>In her book, <em>Dread Generation</em>, the ecopsychologist Britt Wray emphasizes how often we forget the emotional aspect of the climate crisis, and why we need to give voice to more challenging emotions such as grief, shame, and anxiety: “As emotions get bulldozed by world events and scientific predictions, the ability to create a more just and healthy world depends largely on how these difficult feelings are tended to.” To develop resilience in the face of an increasingly challenging world ironically requires a capacity to <em>feel</em> that world. It’s counterintuitive, but simple: you cannot change what you cannot feel.</p><p>Human beings, with our sensorial bodies, are always in direct connection with that world. We don’t just sense the obvious power of floods, droughts, and hurricanes. We also sense the slower, yet equally deadly, power of toxicity in our air, our water, and our political and media culture. We can feel in our bodies the modern obsession that pushes us to achieve more and more, turning us into what Gabor Mate calls “hungry ghosts.” Humans -it’s worth reminding ourselves over and over again — have evolved in relationship to the planet. We have always been porous to our surroundings, part of the Earth’s breathing skin.</p><p>The ecophilosopher David Abram is one of the most eloquent writers on humanity’s deep embeddedness into the living, breathing fabric of the planet. “Humans,” he says, “are tuned for relationship. The eyes, the skin, the tongue, ears, and nostrils — all are gates where our body receives the nourishment of otherness.” Modernity, however, is predicated on understanding humans as separate from nature, as a category apart. If we are to really feel into the depth of our planetary predicaments, then a first step is to remember that, like divers, we are totally immersed in the Earth; not on it, but within it and part of it. Our bodies can sense all that the Earth holds: both the enjoyable — fresh air, clean water, joy, wonder — and the painful — the pollution, the anxiety, ecocide, and the fear.</p><p>If freediving provides an apt metaphor for how to respond to collapse, it’s in large part because collapse, like water, is something we are fully immersed in, part of, and oftentimes complicit in. It’s easy to externalize our great crisis as a form of chaos in the world “out there”. We love to identify and find connection with the positive attributes of the world — beauty, love, honor — but shy away from recognizing our entanglement with the shadier sides of our nature.</p><p>And yet, mythologies from the world are proof that humans have always dived into the metaphorical waters and emerged strengthened. Across all continents, we find myths and stories of primordial bodies of water from which the world originates, as well as floods sent on land as divine retribution or purification. The Christian Bible itself starts with an image of a divine wind sweeping over the faces of primordial waters. In our nighttime dreams, large bodies of water such as oceans, lakes, and pools, frequently represent the unconscious, that part of reality that exists but that we are not aware of on a day to day level.</p><p>This symbology makes sense: the ocean is vast, impossible to fully grasp and understand. It is mysterious because we cannot see well below its surface. It is alien because we cannot breathe in it. Yet at the same time, water literally composes our bodies: our blood is over 85% water. Water is the great common denominator between all forms of life, and the ocean, and specifically photosynthetic algae, produce over 70% of the oxygen in the atmosphere.</p><p>Diving into water and exploring its depths — physically or metaphorically constitutes a plunge into the wider landscape of life. The dive connects us with what we love and cherish — with sunflight flowing into cenotes, with lush tropical forests, and brilliant tapestry of life. But it also connects with the ugly that we so easily push away: the devastated ecosystems, the species rendered extinct, the communities displaced for mining concessions that power our “connected” lifestyles, the rich cosmovisions replaced by a hopeless consumerism. Modern culture hides away this shadow in the name of staying open for business.</p><p>To face collapse is not an easy dive, but as Britt Wray says, “…the torment comes bearing gifts. If you explore its depths, you’ll find a valve somewhere inside you that taps into the most existential part of yourself.” Diving into these difficult waters is intensely difficult at first. We have to take it slowly, habituating ourselves to increasingly widening circles of understanding and empathy. Our bodies start numb and stiff. And then, little by little, we start to swim.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f62768ea726" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Search of Climate Politics’ Radical Center]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@felixderosen/cultivating-the-radical-center-1e65a936ac83?source=rss-bf7b029baedc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e65a936ac83</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[regeneration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-action]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ecology-and-environment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Félix de Rosen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Aug 2023 16:58:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-24T18:33:44.949Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Why inclusive visions are crucial to our ability to respond to the ecological crisis.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1olE0KM-6gS147cJVR1fgA.jpeg" /></figure><p>If the climate movement has taught us anything over the past decades, it’s that although it’s necessary to communicate the symptoms of the planetary crisis, such as atmospheric CO2 levels or global income inequality, statistics rarely sway hearts unless they are tied to compelling storytelling of a better future. There are many reasons why stories catalyze change. Here’s one: we all need a compelling reason to let go of the familiar and embrace the unknown. To address the interconnected crises afflicting our planet today — crises of climate, biodiversity, democracy, technology — we need visions for the future that are tangible enough to inspire us to reshape the way we look at the world. And for these visions to gather traction, their reach must stretch beyond their cultural, political, and class bubbles.</p><p>If climate doomism remains so appealing today, it’s in part because we don’t speak enough about all that we have to gain: about clean air, waters to swim in, farms that nourish us and the ecosystem, more free time, and healthier, more meaningful lives. It’s also because the visions of the future that receive the most air time — those of politicians and business — are focused on narrow audiences. They rarely have the courage to reach across the divide.</p><p>The environmentalist-rancher Bill MacDonald coined the term “radical center” to describe the coalition of ranchers, environmentalists, and government agencies that worked together beginning in the 90s to preserve rural livelihoods and local ecosystems in southern New Mexico and Arizona. This work of creating working partnerships that put aside their differences for a common good takes time. A decade ago, psychedelics were taboo in the US mainstream because of their association with hard drugs and the radical politics of the 1960s. In 2013, the Multidisciplinary Association for Psychedelic Studies (MAPS) started the long and arduous process of gaining FDA approval for MDMA assisted psychotherapy. Their initial work focused on treatment for US war veterans, firefighters, and police officers with PTSD. In the press conversations that followed, conservatives staunchly opposed to drugs were given a reason to change their minds when they saw their own cultural icons tell their stories of healing. MAPS has been crucial in shifting the tide of public opinion around psychedelics.</p><p>To cultivate the radical center and build consensus around climate initiatives, we need to speak to the values of our audience. Like MAPS’s work with veterans, we can speak to core values that animate human beings across the cultural spectrum. The climate scientist Katharine Hayhoe, for example, is also an evangelical Christian; much of her work involves forging alliances between Christian groups and climate advocates based on the shared values of stewarding the planet. We need this sort of diplomacy that makes it worth it for others to join the conversations we need to have. In the words of marine scientist Ayana Elizabeth Johnson, “Show me this is worth the effort. Show me examples of where this is already happening. Show me that there’s a place for me in the future, after all this change.”</p><p><em>Show me there’s a place for me in the future</em>. I’ve often asked myself whether we really need to do this, whether nurturing popular support for system change matters. Doesn’t most change happen from the top-down, or through a small elite of change-makers? Why go through the trouble of rallying “the masses”? These are valid questions: a recent Harvard <a href="https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190513-it-only-takes-35-of-people-to-change-the-world">study</a> confirms that only 3.5% of a population protesting nonviolently is necessary for serious political change. But this perspective is akin to being in a theater, focusing on the brightly lit actors on the stage, and forgetting about all that is happening backstage and beyond that enables the performance. The activist and author Rebecca Solnit describes this process, using the example of the US Supreme Court’s 2003 ruling that struck down the last laws criminalizing homosexuality: “The conventional narrative would have it that the power rests in the hands of the nine robed ones; a more radical model would mention the gay Texas couple who chose to turn their lives inside out over many years to press the lawsuit; but a sort of cultural ecology would measure what made the nation rethink its homophobia, creating the societal change that the Supreme Court only assented to: they all count.”</p><p><em>Show me there’s a place for me in the future</em>. The words ring in my mind as I watch videos of the UK’s Just Stop Oil protestors peacefully blockading London traffic to demand the government halt all new fossil fuel licenses. The movement draws on a rich tradition of raising awareness through disruption and spectacle. I also envision a fossil-fuel free future, yet I can’t help but identify what feels like a missing piece in Just Stop Oil’s strategy. The disruption of the lives of the working class makes headlines, but does it offer a deeper collective vision of a future without oil? The movement has so far garnered neither <a href="https://www.bristol.ac.uk/psychology/news/2023/116.html">popular support</a> nor <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jul/31/rishi-sunak-approval-100-new-north-sea-oil-and-gas-licences-fossil-fuel-climate-crisis">government action</a>. But there is a <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jul/07/disruptive-protest-helps-not-hinders-activists-cause-experts-say">longer-term view</a> in which unpopular disruption is necessary to bring issues to the public limelight. So whilst inclusivity is core to any political strategy, we can also recognize its many nuances: we don’t have to bring everybody on board all the time; we can be intentional and strategic.</p><p>There is, nonethless, a <em>particular</em> power to including a broad public in our visions. This power emerges from our intuitive understanding that the public is the legitimate and just bedrock on which our institutions stand. In the theater metaphor, the audience is powerful because they offer their precious attention to the performers. In political revolutions, there’s always a key moment when the status quo which had felt so entrenched and immutable suddenly loses its grip on us and we wake up to a totally unfamiliar landscape. We’ve all felt this in positive and negative ways in our personal lives — when we emerge from a sickness finally able to feel good again, when we wake up from a nightmare, or when we come to terms with false beliefs that had kept a relationship afloat. Collectively, we don’t control when that liberating moment of rupture comes, when the seemingly infinite power of big business and opportunistic politicians crashes; sometimes, it never comes, or it comes in a way we don’t expect. But we can always prepare for it.</p><p>Climate doomsters may critique this viewpoint as too rosy, offering a false sense of hope (“hopium”). Is it not naive to speak of system change amidst firestorms, mass extinction, and the continued, state-sponsored granting of new oil and gas leases? Have we need not irreversibly overshot our planetary boundaries? Is it not simply too late? Having read enough disturbing climate statistics and seen enough destruction to throw my arms up in abandon, I empathize with this perspective. But believing in our collective capacity for positive change is not to deny how deep in crisis we are. It is instead to make an informed bet, with no certainty of winning, on a shared, thriving future in this deeply interconnected planet. We can accept the state of the world today and still agree that, in Solnit’s words, “when we fight we sometimes win; and that we are deciding the future now.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e65a936ac83" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>