<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Fifth Estate Republic on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Fifth Estate Republic on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@fifthestaterepublic?source=rss-349f70762a7a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:00:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@fifthestaterepublic/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Background Power of the Clintons]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@fifthestaterepublic/the-background-power-of-the-clintons-89ea8376cd03?source=rss-349f70762a7a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89ea8376cd03</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hillary-clinton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[department-of-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doj]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democratic-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fifth Estate Republic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Sep 2018 01:19:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-24T01:19:42.076Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Is J. Edgar Hoover the model for the Clintons?</em></p><p>Hillary Clinton funded the Steele dossier when she was ahead in the polls and looked like she would be the next President of the United States.</p><p>Just like Nixon at Watergate, she didn’t need the dossier to help her win the election. The media led us to believe this was a foregone conclusion. Yet, she did it anyway, paying a small fortune for it. Why would she do this?</p><p><strong>Habit</strong></p><p>My answer is she did this out of habit. The arrogance of power continuously and surreptitiously exercised.</p><p>Consider — Clinton bailed out the financially struggling Democratic Party during the last election. For this support, she insisted on absolute control of the Democratic Party’s campaign finances. Note: it was Democratic Party money that funded Steele’s dossier. Now note how the money was paid to Steele in a way to mask Clinton’s role. Money was paid to a [WHO], a D.C. attorney, who then paid it to [WHO], a lobbying firm, which in turn paid Steele. Such facile maneuvering makes it unlikely this is the first time she created or acquired a file containing both actual and false, salacious information on an opponent. So having done this before, she knew its value. And it being her chance to be President, she would not want to leave anything she might control to chance. She would want to do what’s worked for her in the past. Even if she didn’t need it. Habit.</p><p>And here’s where the comparison to Watergate takes a different turn. Nixon did the break-in to find his opponent’s campaign plans in case he needed to react. Clinton did this not to react, but for a more insidious purpose. She wanted to proactively destroy her opponent’s image and campaign.</p><p><strong>How does Clinton think she can get away with this?</strong></p><p>Among many things, this episode brings out another chorus of “how do the Clintons keep getting away with things?”</p><p>Since it’s unlikely that this was Clinton’s first “black op”, it begs the question — how many other “dossiers” has she gathered but not yet weaponized?</p><p>This is not such a far-fetched idea. FBI Director J Edgar Hoover was reputed to have files on many prominent people and politicians. For this, he was a much-feared man. If Clinton is willing to spend millions for a dossier she really didn’t need, she probably has many more on others, just in case. Who might these other people be? Is it anyone who has ever been in a position to harm Clinton? This could be a lot of prominent people. Does this explain why the Justice Department or the FBI hasn’t raided her house and seized her files? Is it because of political motives (Peter Strozk and Lisa Page)? Or money (Bruce and Nellie Ohr)? Or the threat of ruination (are there many who would like to see these files confidentially purged, as if they wouldn’t see the light of day)?</p><p>Imagine if the evidence that has been the basis for a Special Prosecutor is found to have been purposefully created by a political opponent and advanced by a biased Judicial Department. In ordinary legal circumstances, when the evidential basis is found false, all subsequent legal proceedings are considered biased (“the fruit of the tree”), and the case is dismissed. After two years of investigation, how likely is that to happen? With the animus towards Trump, how likely is that to happen?</p><p><strong>What’s next?</strong></p><p>In the unlikely ending of the investigation, how likely is it that the light will now shine on Clinton’s manipulation? Hasn’t this already been handled by a Judicial review finding her legally compliant? Wasn’t she already essentially found innocent in the private email investigation? Wouldn’t any further investigation make her into a martyr?</p><p>And that’s how it’s done.</p><p>There’s something wrong with the United States political system when the Department of Justice and the Congressional Senate collectively meet with outside organizations to bias an election.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89ea8376cd03" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Trials of Judge Roy Moore]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic/the-trials-of-judge-roy-moore-3c9482f42b99?source=rss-349f70762a7a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c9482f42b99</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[breitbart]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[senate]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fifth Estate Republic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Nov 2017 00:22:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-18T01:10:31.919Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The fires of outrage grow almost out of control. The rush to judgment has been so swift I can feel the wind fanning the fire.</em></p><p><strong>The Washington Post has turned the Alabama Senate race on its head. The media and politicians from both sides of the aisle have found Judge Roy Moore’s behavior with a 14-year-old as reprehensible. Who could argue else-wise? In fact, to argue else-wise is to bring condemnation upon oneself.</strong></p><p>However, this is America. Americans are supposed to presume the defendant (Judge Moore) is innocent until proven guilty. Who will stand up for Moore and provide a defense? I thought you and I could become dispassionate devil’s advocates, and do this together. This does not mean we support nor oppose the Judge. It does mean that we will assume the role of his defense. Let’s start by thinking through what we have been told so far.</p><p>This is not easy. This story is unfolding in the media at a quickening pace. It has captured the attention of most Americans. Two days ago, we were told the facts are irrefutable of an older man taking advantage of two young girls and trying to date three teenagers when he was 32 years-old. The media and most politicians are calling for him to resign his nomination for the Alabama Senate race.</p><p>The Judge has a big decision to make. So far, he shows no interest in withdrawing.</p><p><strong>1. What is the issue with Judge Moore?</strong></p><p><strong>2. Who gains by forcing the Judge out of the election?</strong></p><p><strong>3. Is there really a scandal?</strong></p><p><strong>4. What do the women victims allege?</strong></p><p><strong>5. How inappropriate would it have been in the late 70s for a 32 year-old Alabama man to date an 18 year-old?</strong></p><p><strong>6. What is the fourth victim’s, Leigh Corfman, allegation of sexual misconduct when she was a 14 year-old?</strong></p><p><strong>7. What is Corfman’s evidence?</strong></p><p><strong>8. Why did Corfman, or her mother, Wells, withhold reporting the 1979 assault until now?</strong></p><p><strong>9. The Process to Destroy an Opponent (Reminder: we are still doing devil’s advocate work!)</strong></p><p><strong>10. Closing Thoughts</strong></p><p><strong>1. What is the issue with Judge Moore?</strong></p><p>Left-leaning CNN has described Judge Moore as a pariah, noting he has been suspended from the bench twice for his activist views on same-sex marriage and fighting to allow a sculpture of the Ten Commandments on government property. Of course, much of his constituencies admire his stance on the same issues.</p><p>After a close primary election, Judge Moore won the Republican nomination for U.S. Senator from Alabama, filling the vacated seat of Attorney General Jeff Sessions. Alabama is a predominantly Republican state, and Moore was expected to win handily in an election in four weeks. That is, until two weeks ago when the Washington Post story upset the upcoming Senate race. It ran a story with four older women alleging Judge Moore had an inappropriate relationship with each of them almost forty years ago when they were minors.</p><p>Obviously, the timing so close to the election raised red flags. The reporters provided little details of the unacceptable behavior, but still generated a great uproar. Among those calling for Moore to quit the race were the Republican National Committee and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell. Senior Senator John McCain led other political forces, saying Moore would not be seated if he won the election. Former Presidential candidate Mitt Romney went further. He said that the constitutional right to be presumed innocent does not apply in politics. The loudest voices are saying that even if Moore wins his senate race, he will be ejected. The fires of outrage grow almost out of control. The rush to judgment has been so swift I can feel the wind fanning the fire.</p><p><strong>2. Who gains by forcing the Judge out of the election?</strong></p><p>· The Democrats win either way. They can take a Senate seat long-held by Republicans. This is of enormous consequence where the Republican majority is so thin. Also, with the 2018 elections around the corner, the Democrats will enjoy the distraction to the Republicans, believing this will improve Democrat chances in 2018.</p><p>· The Republican Establishment, some of which were Never-Trumpers during the presidential campaign, will see an opportunity to obstruct the Trump populist agenda. They also believe this will improve the likelihood of their reelection. Their concern is for Steve Bannon’s progress towards replacing establishment congressmen with politicians who support the Trump agenda.</p><p>· Special interest groups and their lobbyists will be able to return to the status quo before Trump was elected. They will be able to continue operating throughout the upheaval of the Moore scandal, no matter how long it takes to resolve.</p><p>· The media is already winning big ratings running the salacious story that has taken hold of the national interest. The more the scandal spreads, the more money is made.</p><p>· In America, the sea change of feminist awareness and power will continue as women change the status quo of sexual harassment and sexual assault in all industries. The voices to protect our children from harm will also be appropriately heard loud and clear. Ivanka Trump has already weighed in here.</p><p>· Notably absent is the President. He wins either way. If the Judge is elected, he has one more supporter of his agenda. If the Judge doesn’t get elected, the President can point to his supporting Moore’s Republican primary opponent.</p><p><strong>3. Is there really a scandal?</strong></p><p>A scandal is driven by its own forces of righteous indignation. A manufactured scandal is driven by something else. It is a powerful, inexpensive, and risky political tool wielded by amoral political foes possessing great resources. Consider that the 2016 presidential race raised a billion dollars for the Trump and Clinton campaigns. One side lost. How much would their substantial donors be willing to pay to gain or keep control of what legislation gets passed? In the Senate, where the Republican majority is a slim two votes, clearly, the stakes are enormously high. Is it possible that complex scandals can be constructed? The answer is — how conspiratorial are you? Remember the adage, “just because you’re paranoid, doesn’t mean they’re not after you.”</p><p><strong>4. What do the women victims allege?</strong></p><p>Let’s look at the first four victims to come forward. The allegations of three of the women are essentially the same.</p><p>A 16 and a 17 year-old allege the Judge had a brief date with each, although both agree no sexual contact was solicited nor given. The Judge denies these allegations.</p><p>The third woman claims that when she was an 18 year-old, she briefly dated the Judge. She noted there was no sexual aspect to their few dates. Today, their 14 year age gap is considered unacceptable. The Judge, who was 32 at the time, now says he is uncertain if he dated her, but acknowledges he may have, and that he dated women younger than himself.</p><p><strong>5. How inappropriate would it have been in the late 70s for a 32 year-old Alabama man to date an 18 year-old?</strong></p><p>Consider the prominent movie “To Have and Have Not” that was made not too long before the incident we are looking at. The lead actress during filming was 18-year-old Lauren Bacall who played a steamy role opposite 43 year-old Humphrey Bogart. Although a 21 year age difference, their real-life affair led to marriage the year following the film’s release. The point is that we shouldn’t make judgments about an age difference at a time when the culture in Alabama was different than today. Even today, many Alabamans are not shocked by the issue of age with this third victim. There were laws then for an adult courter who dated a girl who was below the age of majority, and above the age for consensual sex. (For historical context, in 1979, when the date was alleged to have taken place, the age of consent was 14 for most states, and age 10 in Delaware). Moore would have been required to ask the parents if he could see their daughter. But it was not required. She was not a minor. Were that the case, Moore would have been complying with the law. (In fact, both history and literature are replete with examples of wealthy, older men marrying younger women. It was not seen as unusual and unacceptable to the same degree as it is today.) This unnecessary action with the parents was probably the reason the Judge was hesitant in recalling the events.</p><p>Why were the times different forty years ago? Perhaps it was that people seemed to mature earlier in those days. My evidence today comes from looking at how many offspring still live at home well after college graduation.</p><p>Lest we forget, the woman acknowledged there were no sexual relations with the Judge.</p><p><strong>6. What is the fourth victim’s, Leigh Corfman, allegation of sexual misconduct when she was a 14 year-old?</strong></p><p>At age 53, Corfman alleges that in 1979, at age 14, the Judge took her to a private place where he undressed both of them down to their underwear, began touching her, and forcing her to touch him on top of his underwear. Anyone at any time in history would find this behavior reprehensible and illegal.</p><p>However, if not true, these accusations themselves are reprehensible. And if they were promoted by a third party as an intentional attempt to derail the Judge’s Senate run, criminal.</p><p><strong>7. What is Corfman’s evidence?</strong></p><p>At the time, she says she told a couple of her friends that she was seeing an older man. Secondly, as already mentioned, her deposition was quite detailed, indicating a vivid memory of a traumatic event.</p><p><em>There are four counter arguments:</em></p><p><em>First, according to the Post reports, Corfman never identified the older man to her friends</em>.</p><p><em>Second, memory by itself is not enough to evidence an assault, no matter how traumatic.</em> For example, most people know that eyewitness testimony is not reliable in most courtroom circumstances. The Supreme Court has upheld challenges to eyewitness testimony. There are biological and psychological underpinnings that affect memory recall. Since it is relevant in this case, a 30 minute Google search on adolescent memory and the effects of time, yielded credible and valid scientific reports done by the most eminent researchers. Their bottom line — as time progresses, even as little as two months, memory details fade, are forgotten, or altered in our mind. This is true even when the events are traumatic.</p><p>Over time, victims come to believe these altered memories actually occurred. Also, they feel real. In short, Corfman’s memory after 38 years is unlikely to have remained unchanged.</p><p>As evidence, we know this is true because her mother, Nancy Wells, says there are inconsistencies with her daughter’s recollection. Detailed stories by Corfman about frequent and long telephone conversations from her bedroom with Moore are a central part of Corfman’s story. However, her mother says there was no bedroom phone. This is the first instance where we see Corfman not telling the truth.</p><p><em>Third, Corfman acknowledges that as a teenager she had a troubled life</em> — drinking alcohol, using drugs, having multiple boyfriends, and attempting suicide at 16. Meanwhile, aside from the current allegations and Moore’s past political controversies, the Judge has led an exemplary life in the public eye for forty years.</p><p><em>Fourth, given the pedophile nature of the accusations</em>, there should be other similar allegations of Moore’s deviant behavior. However, in the last forty years there is no evidence of this type of deviant behavior. This is very unusual for a pedophile. Consider Anthony Weiner, who couldn’t control his compulsive behavior. Or Harvey Weinstein, where lots of people knew of his sexual behavior. Yet no one has heard of any aberrant sexual behavior of the Judge.</p><p><strong>8. Why did Corfman, or her mother, Wells, withhold reporting the 1979 assault until now?</strong></p><p><em>How did the Post reporters know</em> to find Corfman in the first place if, according the what the news report implies, she only told her mother and friend? Obviously, she told others; maybe more than a few. If true, where in the news reports is the corroboration presented? Where are the other witness testimonies? And if the Post reporters were pressing Corfman for information is true, is it because the reporters were on a timetable, and willing to cut corners? In either case, the lack of details is grossly unacceptable for such serious allegations.</p><p><em>Corfman waited nineteen years to tell her mother.</em> It is accepted that traumatic sexual assault cases create fear and embarrassment. It prevents victims from coming forward to tell their story until many years after the assault happened, if at all. For Corfman, it took nineteen years to tell her mother. She then waits another 12 years to tell a male friend in 2009. We can understand why she might not want the world to know what happened to her. But because we do know at least two others were told about what had happened to her, we now have two witnesses to look to for corroboration. We want to know if, by 2017, any of her memories can really be trusted. We don’t hear the Post reporters describing any inconsistencies in the stories of her confidants.</p><p>Again, Corfman provides a credible reason for her waiting. She wanted to wait until her children were grown. She knew her allegation would raise a maelstrom. But now her story has changed. She blames the Washington Post reporters who sought her out and pressed her for information. Consequently, she blames the reporters for the timing of her story. Really? She had to know the story would cause an enormous political impact, ruining a man at the pinnacle moment of his political career. She is old enough to understand and accept this action. Does she still harbor such ill will towards Moore that she was willing on her own volition, to tell the whole world her story, however inaccurate it may be and whatever the blowback that would likely occur? It’s hard to believe a woman who has lived such a life as hers, would put herself in such a position without getting something substantial in return.</p><p>Corfman’s concern for revealing the 1979 incident to her children before they were out of the house is a totally different story. They would have had a good idea of Corfman’s troubled years after seeing her marrying and divorcing three times, filing bankruptcy three times, having a failed business, and owing $139,689 in back taxes and other bills. In all, this is a picture of a family living under on-going stress. It’s hard to believe her family would be further scarred to learn of her teenage assault. This is the second instance where we see Corfman is likely not telling the truth.</p><p><strong>9. The Process to Destroy an Opponent (Reminder: we are still doing devil’s advocate work!)</strong></p><p><em>How do you construct a scandal?</em> Find a vulnerability of the target, Judge Moore. If one isn’t readily available, research deeper and create one. The Washington Post reporters may have done this. In order for his enemies to destroy Moore’s credibility, his enemies will introduce a flood of new “victims” to get the scandal started. Introduce a few credible victims initially. Most all of these victims will have legitimate stories to tell.<em> </em>Then manage the process by introducing them onto the scene when it is most damaging to Moore.</p><p>The way the process works is for Moore to spend time defending himself against the allegations of the fourth woman, Corfman. While doing this, in order to maintain a fast pace at the beginning of this scandal, a fifth victim, Beverly Young Nelson, appears. The Judge must now cut short his defense against Corfman and begin assessing the new charges and defending himself against the fifth accuser. On the surface, her allegations are thought by many to be the death bullet for Judge Moore. She alleges that, also in the late 1970s, when she was 16, the Judge’s outrageous behavior while driving her home made her fear she would be raped. Her evidence she knew the Judge is a signed high school yearbook entry by him. She is being represented by high profile attorney Gloria Allred, who had to have been contacted very shortly after the story first broke.</p><p>Then, and this is important, keep drip, drip, dripping more empathetic “victims” out every other day or so, with increasingly more repugnant stories. Many, even most, of the victims will believe they have real stories to tell. To the degree possible, the objective is to control the pace and put Moore on the defensive. In this case, he can’t be allowed to satisfactorily address each accuser before the next accuser appears. This keeps the story in the public mind, and creates pressure to denounce Moore. The opposing side, which has unlimited resources, can use those resources against Moore, whose supporters will begin to bail out.</p><p>Before long, the Judge will be unable to satisfactorily respond to each allegation. They will also use their power to dissuade Moore’s supporters by saying the fight against Moore will continue even if he is elected. The idea is to suppress the vote for Moore.</p><p>The Judge is challenged in the media for not providing a credible rebuttal to Corfman. The Judge has his attorney challenge on TV the fifth victim, asserting a handwriting analysis will disprove Nelson’s allegations, two new victims appear. But the arrival of a sixth and seventh accuser drown out the potential rebuttal to the charges brought by Nelson.</p><p>During this process, those who benefit the most by getting Moore out of the race will be the first and loudest voices of contempt. These are often the most powerful and respected opponents. They also have the most to lose as they are seen as the Establishment during a time the electorate is voting for the Populist. Next will be people with an agenda to push. The snow ball of the scandal no longer needs the forces which started it.</p><p><strong>10. Closing Thoughts</strong></p><p><em>First, the complicit media keeps the story before the public. </em>The investigation becomes increasingly tawdry. It presents a more evil picture of Moore. The predominantly liberal media see a temporary end to the Alabama Republican Party’s hold on the Senate seat for this election cycle.</p><p><em>Second, when it comes to the timing of the announcements to the election</em>, it is unlikely Corfman would have known the voting rules. The Judge’s name cannot be removed from the ballot in time for the Republicans to replace it with another candidate. And if the reporters knew, it would explain why Corfman sensed the time pressure the Post reporters were placing on her.</p><p><em>Third, the financial implication to some moneyed interests is so enormous; </em>it is not beyond belief that someone is pulling the strings.<em> </em>If so, there will not be sufficient attorney resources to defend Moore? This is not a paranoid or conspiratorial thought. The fact is the importance of a Senate seat in a divided body is worth a considerable amount of money and power to many people.</p><p><em>Fourth, we haven’t heard if there is an investigation by the appropriate authorities underway?</em> It is a serious crime to undermine a federal election. How can congress support an investigation of Moore without supporting an investigation of his accusers and the Washington Post? Again, given that there is a senatorial election involved, is there an investigation to determine if there is anything untoward happening behind the scenes? Since the Establishment Senators control what investigations are undertaken, it seems unlikely one will occur in this instance.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c9482f42b99" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic/the-trials-of-judge-roy-moore-3c9482f42b99">The Trials of Judge Roy Moore</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic">The Fifth Estate Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Trials of Judge Roy Moore]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@fifthestaterepublic/the-trials-of-judge-roy-moore-9bf9c4c2ba4c?source=rss-349f70762a7a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9bf9c4c2ba4c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[breitbart]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[senate]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fifth Estate Republic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Nov 2017 20:15:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-17T00:16:43.918Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The fires of outrage grow almost out of control. The rush to judgment has been so swift I can feel the wind fanning the fire.</em></p><p><strong>The Washington Post has turned the Atlanta Senate race on its head. The media and politicians from both sides of the aisle have found Judge Roy Moore’s behavior with a 14-year-old as reprehensible. Who could argue elsewise? In fact, to argue elsewise is to bring condemnation upon oneself.</strong></p><p>However, this is America. Americans are supposed to presume the defendant (Judge Moore) is innocent until proven guilty. Who will stand up for Moore and provide a defense? I thought you and I could become devil’s advocates, and do this together. Let’s start by thinking through what we have been told so far.</p><p>This is not easy. This story is unfolding in the media at a quickening pace. It has captured the attention of most Americans. Two days ago, we were told the facts are irrefutable of an older man taking advantage of two young girls and trying to date three teenagers when he was 32 years-old. The media and most politicians are calling for him to resign his nomination for the Alabama Senate race.</p><p>The Judge has a big decision to make. So far, he shows no interest in withdrawing.</p><p><strong>1. What is the issue with Judge Moore?</strong></p><p><strong>2. Who gains by forcing the Judge out of the election?</strong></p><p><strong>3. Is there really a scandal?</strong></p><p><strong>4. What do the women victims allege?</strong></p><p><strong>5. How inappropriate would it have been in the late 70s for a 32 year-old Alabama man to date an 18 year-old?</strong></p><p><strong>6. What is the fourth victim’s, Leigh Corfman, allegation of sexual misconduct when she was a 14 year-old?</strong></p><p><strong>7. What is Corfman’s evidence?</strong></p><p><strong>8. Why did Corfman, or her mother, Wells, withhold reporting the 1979 assault until now?</strong></p><p><strong>9. The Process to Destroy an Opponent (Reminder: we are still doing devil’s advocate work!)</strong></p><p><strong>10. Closing Thoughts</strong></p><p><strong>1. What is the issue with Judge Moore?</strong></p><p>Left-leaning CNN has described Judge Moore as a pariah, noting he has been suspended from the bench twice for his activist views on same-sex marriage and fighting to allow a sculpture of the Ten Commandments on government property. Of course, much of his constituencies admire his stance on the same issues.</p><p>After a close primary election, Judge Moore won the Republican nomination for U.S. Senator from Alabama, filling the vacated seat of Attorney General Jeff Sessions. Alabama is a predominantly Republican state, and Moore was expected to win handily in an election in four weeks. That is, until two weeks ago when the Washington Post story upset the upcoming Senate race. It ran a story with four older women alleging Judge Moore had an inappropriate relationship with each of them almost forty years ago when they were minors.</p><p>Obviously, the timing so close to the election raised red flags. The reporters provided little details of the unacceptable behavior, but still generated a great uproar. Among those calling for Moore to quit the race were the Republican National Committee and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell. Senior Senator John McCain led other political forces, saying Moore would not be seated if he won the election. Former Presidential candidate Mitt Romney went further. He said that the constitutional right to be presumed innocent does not apply in politics. The loudest voices are saying that even if Moore wins his senate race, he will be ejected. The fires of outrage grow almost out of control. The rush to judgment has been so swift I can feel the wind fanning the fire.</p><p><strong>2. Who gains by forcing the Judge out of the election?</strong></p><p>· The Democrats win either way. They can take a Senate seat long-held by Republicans. This is of enormous consequence where the Republican majority is so thin. Also, with the 2018 elections around the corner, the Democrats will enjoy the distraction to the Republicans, believing this will improve Democrat chances in 2018.</p><p>· The Republican Establishment, some of which were Never-Trumpers during the presidential campaign, will see an opportunity to obstruct the Trump populist agenda. They also believe this will improve the likelihood of their reelection. Their concern is for Steve Bannon’s progress towards replacing establishment congressmen with politicians who support the Trump agenda.</p><p>· Special interest groups and their lobbyists will be able to return to the status quo before Trump was elected. They will be able to continue operating throughout the upheaval of the Moore scandal, no matter how long it takes to resolve.</p><p>· The media is already winning big ratings running the salacious story that has taken hold of the national interest. The more the scandal spreads, the more money is made.</p><p>· In America, the sea change of feminist awareness and power will continue as women change the status quo of sexual harassment and sexual assault in all industries. The voices to protect our children from harm will also be appropriately heard loud and clear. Ivanka Trump has already weighed in here.</p><p>· Notably absent is the President. He wins either way. If the Judge is elected, he has one more supporter of his agenda. If the Judge doesn’t get elected, the President can point to his supporting Moore’s Republican primary opponent.</p><p><strong>3. Is there really a scandal?</strong></p><p>A scandal is driven by its own forces of righteous indignation. A manufactured scandal is driven by something else. It is a powerful, inexpensive, and risky political tool wielded by amoral political foes possessing great resources. Consider that the 2016 presidential race raised a billion dollars for the Trump and Clinton campaigns. One side lost. How much would their substantial donors be willing to pay to gain or keep control of what legislation gets passed? In the Senate, where the Republican majority is a slim two votes, clearly, the stakes are enormously high. Is it possible that complex scandals can be constructed? The answer is — how conspiratorial are you? Remember the adage, “just because you’re paranoid, doesn’t mean they’re not after you.”</p><p><strong>4. What do the women victims allege?</strong></p><p>Let’s look at the first four victims to come forward. The allegations of three of the women are essentially the same.</p><p>A 16 and a 17 year-old allege the Judge had a brief date with each, although both agree no sexual contact was solicited nor given. The Judge denies these allegations.</p><p>The third woman claims that when she was an 18 year-old, she briefly dated the Judge. She noted there was no sexual aspect to their few dates. Today, their 14 year age gap is considered unacceptable. The Judge, who was 32 at the time, now says he is uncertain if he dated her, but acknowledges he may have, and that he dated women younger than himself.</p><p><strong>5. How inappropriate would it have been in the late 70s for a 32 year-old Alabama man to date an 18 year-old?</strong></p><p>Consider the prominent movie “To Have and Have Not” that was made not too long before the incident we are looking at. The lead actress during filming was 18-year-old Lauren Bacall who played a steamy role opposite 43 year-old Humphrey Bogart. Although a 21 year age difference, their real-life affair led to marriage the year following the film’s release. The point is that we shouldn’t make judgments about an age difference at a time when the culture in Alabama was different than today. Even today, many Alabamans are not shocked by the issue of age with this third victim. There were laws then for an adult courter who dated a girl who was below the age of majority, and above the age for consensual sex. (For historical context, in 1979, when the date was alleged to have taken place, the age of consent was 14 for most states, and age 10 in Delaware). Moore would have been required to ask the parents if he could see their daughter. But it was not required. She was not a minor. Were that the case, Moore would have been complying with the law. (In fact, both history and literature are replete with examples of wealthy, older men marrying younger women. It was not seen as unusual and unacceptable to the same degree as it is today.) This unnecessary action with the parents was probably the reason the Judge was hesitant in recalling the events.</p><p>Why were the times different forty years ago? Perhaps it was that people seemed to mature earlier in those days. My evidence today comes from looking at how many offspring still live at home well after college graduation.</p><p>Lest we forget, the woman acknowledged there were no sexual relations with the Judge.</p><p><strong>6. What is the fourth victim’s, Leigh Corfman, allegation of sexual misconduct when she was a 14 year-old?</strong></p><p>At age 53, Corfman alleges that in 1979, at age 14, the Judge took her to a private place where he undressed both of them down to their underwear, began touching her, and forcing her to touch him on top of his underwear. Anyone at any time in history would find this behavior reprehensible and illegal.</p><p>However, if not true, these accusations themselves are reprehensible. And if they were promoted by a third party as an intentional attempt to derail the Judge’s Senate run, criminal.</p><p><strong>7. What is Corfman’s evidence?</strong></p><p>At the time, she says she told a couple of her friends that she was seeing an older man. Secondly, as already mentioned, her deposition was quite detailed, indicating a vivid memory of a traumatic event.</p><p><em>There are four counter arguments:</em></p><p><em>First, according to the Post reports, Corfman never identified the older man to her friends</em>.</p><p><em>Second, memory by itself is not enough to evidence an assault, no matter how traumatic.</em> For example, most people know that eyewitness testimony is not reliable in most courtroom circumstances. The Supreme Court has upheld challenges to eyewitness testimony. There are biological and psychological underpinnings that affect memory recall. Since it is relevant in this case, a 30 minute Google search on adolescent memory and the effects of time, yielded credible and valid scientific reports done by the most eminent researchers. Their bottom line — as time progresses, even as little as two months, memory details fade, are forgotten, or altered in our mind. This is true even when the events are traumatic.</p><p>Over time, victims come to believe these altered memories actually occurred. Also, they feel real. In short, Corfman’s memory after 38 years is unlikely to have remained unchanged.</p><p>As evidence, we know this is true because her mother, Nancy Wells, says there are inconsistencies with her daughter’s recollection. Detailed stories by Corfman about frequent and long telephone conversations from her bedroom with Moore are a central part of Corfman’s story. However, her mother says there was no bedroom phone. This is the first instance where we see Corfman not telling the truth.</p><p><em>Third, Corfman acknowledges that as a teenager she had a troubled life</em> — drinking alcohol, using drugs, having multiple boyfriends, and attempting suicide at 16. Meanwhile, aside from the current allegations and Moore’s past political controversies, the Judge has led an exemplary life in the public eye for forty years.</p><p><em>Fourth, given the pedophile nature of the accusations</em>, there should be other similar allegations of Moore’s deviant behavior. However, in the last forty years there is no evidence of this type of deviant behavior. This is very unusual for a pedophile. Consider Anthony Weiner, who couldn’t control his compulsive behavior. Or Harvey Weinstein, where lots of people knew of his sexual behavior. Yet no one has heard of any aberrant sexual behavior of the Judge.</p><p><strong>8. Why did Corfman, or her mother, Wells, withhold reporting the 1979 assault until now?</strong></p><p><em>How did the Post reporters know</em> to find Corfman in the first place if, according the what the news report implies, she only told her mother and friend? Obviously, she told others; maybe more than a few. If true, where in the news reports is the corroboration presented? Where are the other witness testimonies? And if the Post reporters were pressing Corfman for information is true, is it because the reporters were on a timetable, and willing to cut corners? In either case, the lack of details is grossly unacceptable for such serious allegations.</p><p><em>Corfman waited nineteen years to tell her mother.</em> It is accepted that traumatic sexual assault cases create fear and embarrassment. It prevents victims from coming forward to tell their story until many years after the assault happened, if at all. For Corfman, it took nineteen years to tell her mother. She then waits another 12 years to tell a male friend in 2009. We can understand why she might not want the world to know what happened to her. But because we do know at least two others were told about what had happened to her, we now have two witnesses to look to for corroboration. We want to know if, by 2017, any of her memories can really be trusted. We don’t hear the Post reporters describing any inconsistencies in the stories of her confidants.</p><p>Again, Corfman provides a credible reason for her waiting. She wanted to wait until her children were grown. She knew her allegation would raise a maelstrom. But now her story has changed. She blames the Washington Post reporters who sought her out and pressed her for information. Consequently, she blames the reporters for the timing of her story. Really? She had to know the story would cause an enormous political impact, ruining a man at the pinnacle moment of his political career. She is old enough to understand and accept this action. Does she still harbor such ill will towards Moore that she was willing on her own volition, to tell the whole world her story, however inaccurate it may be and whatever the blowback that would likely occur? It’s hard to believe a woman who has lived such a life as hers, would put herself in such a position without getting something substantial in return.</p><p>Corfman’s concern for revealing the 1979 incident to her children before they were out of the house is a totally different story. They would have had a good idea of Corfman’s troubled years after seeing her marrying and divorcing three times, filing bankruptcy three times, having a failed business, and owing $139,689 in back taxes and other bills. In all, this is a picture of a family living under on-going stress. It’s hard to believe her family would be further scarred to learn of her teenage assault. This is the second instance where we see Corfman is likely not telling the truth.</p><p><strong>9. The Process to Destroy an Opponent (Reminder: we are still doing devil’s advocate work!)</strong></p><p><em>How do you construct a scandal?</em> Find a vulnerability of the target, Judge Moore. If one isn’t readily available, research deeper and create one. The Washington Post reporters may have done this. In order for his enemies to destroy Moore’s credibility, his enemies will introduce a flood of new “victims” to get the scandal started. Introduce a few credible victims initially. Most all of these victims will have legitimate stories to tell.<em> </em>Then manage the process by introducing them onto the scene when it is most damaging to Moore.</p><p>The way the process works is for Moore to spend time defending himself against the allegations of the fourth woman, Corfman. While doing this, in order to maintain a fast pace at the beginning of this scandal, a fifth victim, Beverly Young Nelson, appears. The Judge must now cut short his defense against Corfman and begin assessing the new charges and defending himself against the fifth accuser. On the surface, her allegations are thought by many to be the death bullet for Judge Moore. She alleges that, also in the late 1970s, when she was 16, the Judge’s outrageous behavior while driving her home made her fear she would be raped. Her evidence she knew the Judge is a signed high school yearbook entry by him. She is being represented by high profile attorney Gloria Allred, who had to have been contacted very shortly after the story first broke.</p><p>Then, and this is important, keep drip, drip, dripping more empathetic “victims” out every other day or so, with increasingly more repugnant stories. Many, even most, of the victims will believe they have real stories to tell. To the degree possible, the objective is to control the pace and put Moore on the defensive. In this case, he can’t be allowed to satisfactorily address each accuser before the next accuser appears. This keeps the story in the public mind, and creates pressure to denounce Moore. The opposing side, which has unlimited resources, can use those resources against Moore, whose supporters will begin to bail out.</p><p>Before long, the Judge will be unable to satisfactorily respond to each allegation. They will also use their power to dissuade Moore’s supporters by saying the fight against Moore will continue even if he is elected. The idea is to suppress the vote for Moore.</p><p>The Judge is challenged in the media for not providing a credible rebuttal to Corfman. The Judge has his attorney challenge on TV the fifth victim, asserting a handwriting analysis will disprove Nelson’s allegations, two new victims appear. But the arrival of a sixth and seventh accuser drown out the potential rebuttal to the charges brought by Nelson.</p><p>During this process, those who benefit the most by getting Moore out of the race will be the first and loudest voices of contempt. These are often the most powerful and respected opponents. They also have the most to lose as they are seen as the Establishment during a time the electorate is voting for the Populist. Next will be people with an agenda to push. The snow ball of the scandal no longer needs the forces which started it.</p><p><strong>10. Closing Thoughts</strong></p><p><em>First, the complicit media keeps the story before the public. </em>The investigation becomes increasingly tawdry. It presents a more evil picture of Moore. The predominantly liberal media see a temporary end to the Alabama Republican Party’s hold on the Senate seat for this election cycle.</p><p><em>Second, when it comes to the timing of the announcements to the election</em>, it is unlikely Corfman would have known the voting rules. The Judge’s name cannot be removed from the ballot in time for the Republicans to replace it with another candidate. And if the reporters knew, it would explain why Corfman sensed the time pressure the Post reporters were placing on her.</p><p><em>Third, the financial implication to some moneyed interests is so enormous; </em>it is not beyond belief that someone is pulling the strings.<em> </em>If so, there will not be sufficient attorney resources to defend Moore? This is not a paranoid or conspiratorial thought. The fact is the importance of a Senate seat in a divided body is worth a considerable amount of money and power to many people.</p><p><em>Fourth, we haven’t heard if there is an investigation by the appropriate authorities underway?</em> It is a serious crime to undermine a federal election. How can congress support an investigation of Moore without supporting an investigation of his accusers and the Washington Post? Again, given that there is a senatorial election involved, is there an investigation to determine if there is anything untoward happening behind the scenes? Since the Establishment Senators control what investigations are undertaken, it seems unlikely one will occur in this instance.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9bf9c4c2ba4c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Corporate Tax Plan — Who’s Pulling the Strings?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic/the-corporate-tax-plan-whos-pulling-the-strings-cb8610b06f14?source=rss-349f70762a7a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb8610b06f14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taxes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump-administration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[small-business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[congress]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fifth Estate Republic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Nov 2017 22:10:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-04T22:10:55.796Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Some facts:</em></p><ul><li>At 39.5%, the U.S. corporate tax rate is the third highest of all the world’s countries.</li><li>U.S. corporations have moved their headquarters overseas, particularly to Ireland where the corporate tax rate is 11.8%.</li><li>The average European corporate tax rate is 18.8%.</li><li>Corporations have a responsibility to shareholders to maximize profits. This means seeking out countries with low tax rates.</li><li>Vital to U.S. interests, the tax rate proposed by then-candidate Trump was 15%.</li><li>The Congressional tax plan is being negotiated at a rate of 20%.</li></ul><p><strong><em>Why is Congress proposing a tax rate higher than the average European country?</em></strong></p><p>This rate is a big time loser. It provides little inducement to move HQ’s back to the states. So why is Congress proposing a rate that will have little or no impact to the U.S.? Obviously, it doesn’t want the low rate. But why?</p><p>Think of the options why Congress isn’t pulling the strings to pass the tax legislation in a bipartisan way. Congress doesn’t want to give Trump a win. Congress believes a 20% rate will work sufficiently well. Congress is incompetent, and doesn’t realize the history of prior tax reduction plans. None of these positions have merit. So maybe we’re looking in the wrong direction. Maybe it’s big business that doesn’t want the pressure to relocate. After all, like Ireland, 11.8% has a lot of green.</p><p>If big business wanted the tax rate lower than 20%, it could afford a massive lobbying effort. They know they’re not going to get the rate to 15% or lower, so they’ll leave well enough alone. They’re mindful of the America First populism sweeping the country. Evidence for this position? There hasn’t been an outcry from business for a 15% rate. Even Trump has given up on the large corporate tax reduction. In this regard, his support of a 20% tax rate is strictly a political maneuver.</p><p><strong><em>Overseas retained earnings — Not gonna happen</em></strong></p><p><em>More facts:</em></p><ul><li>Major corporations have parked trillions of dollars of retained earnings overseas.</li><li>If these trillions of dollars were in the U.S., there would be an enormous amount of capital available to fund economic growth.</li><li>The tax plan’s proposal is to charge a one-time fee of 10% to move these monies to the U.S.</li></ul><p>If the corporation’s headquarters are not going to return to the states, why repatriate all that money. Besides, why would a company want to pay a 10% tax to return money that’s already been taxed? Since most of the HQ’s are not going to move, the repatriation idea makes no sense.</p><p><strong><em>Small Business Rules</em></strong></p><p>There’s more to the business tax cut than just for major corporations. Much of the future growth in America is in small business, especially with an appreciable tax rate drop. Small businesses are 99.7% of American firms, 49.2% of employment, and 64% of new jobs. The headquarters of small businesses are U.S. based. There is no issue of relocation. There is no effective competition by low tax rates of foreign governments. And since pre-tax profits of small business firms pass through to the owners, the tax rate will be appreciably lower under the proposed plan. Higher profits will more likely translate into more rapid reinvestment and employment than big business could attain. Small business tax reduction will be a big win for the President.</p><p>When you combine the advantages to small business with the personal income tax plan to the middle class, the overall result of the tax plan will be a winner for him. When the time is right, a focused corporate tax plan can always be brought up in Congress again. Meanwhile, we are also likely to hear demands from small business for reductions in regulations.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb8610b06f14" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic/the-corporate-tax-plan-whos-pulling-the-strings-cb8610b06f14">The Corporate Tax Plan — Who’s Pulling the Strings?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic">The Fifth Estate Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tax Reduction for Whom?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic/tax-reduction-for-whom-9d826f92731?source=rss-349f70762a7a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d826f92731</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tax-reduction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tax-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fifth Estate Republic]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Oct 2017 17:09:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-29T17:09:50.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Tax Reduction and Reform Bill — Purposeful complication</strong></p><p>How can the average middle class family know whether or not r to support the proposed tax legislation? Politicians spout the income benefits that support their political position, clouding the debate with jumbled, incomplete data, claiming various outcomes. The administration said the average middle class family earning $90,000 a year, will see a $1,000 tax reduction. Others say it could be $7,000. Since no one has shown where these numbers come from, I thought it worthwhile to take on that challenge, and, in so doing, allow those same citizens to decide for themselves if they can support this legislation.</p><p>This is not going to be easy. We are going to need to look at the numbers to get to the truth. This requires patience and a slow read as keys to mastering the proposed tax plan. For both you and me, I’ll try to keep it simple.</p><p>What we want to know is who will get a tax cut, and how much? Everyone wants to know what this means to their family.</p><p>To start, we need to establish key facts.</p><p>· The 2018 budget forecast is $3.9 trillion. Since the percentages of various revenue sources have not really changed since 2015, we’ll use this as a base year.</p><p>· In 2015, 47% of the budget was funded with personal income taxes, or, in 2018 terms, $1.833 trillion.</p><p>· The top 1% earners will pay about 50%, or $953 billion. The bottom 60% will pay about 2% (that’s right — 2 %!), or $37 billion. <em>The president told us that these groups will not see a change in their tax payment rates.</em></p><p>· This leaves 39% of income earners who will pay 48% of the nation’s$1.833 trillion of personal income taxes, or $880 billion. You are probably in this grouping. No worries; the president told us that this group will see a real tax reduction. <em>(Ahem.)</em></p><p>So, how much are we going to get? Let’s look at three different views that, depending on the party affiliation, politicians can use (there are undoubtedly more views!).</p><p><strong>1.</strong> <strong>Top-Down View</strong></p><p>The CBO tells us that this proposed income tax cut from all sources of income could cost the country $10 trillion over 10 years. If we present value this amount, it is $7.4 trillion in today’s dollars. Assuming one-tenth of this income revenue cut occurs in the first year, it amounts to a $740 billion cut. Other estimates say a combined first year cut of $1 trillion will occur. Let’s use the lower amount, $740 billion. Without tax reduction, $880 billion in taxes would otherwise have been paid. Since the tax situation for the top and bottom earners won’t change, this means the 39% of the middle class households will get the full benefit of 47% of planned tax reductions — a $348 billion tax cut from the $880 billion in planned budget reduction. Remember, the lowest 60% and the top 1% pays the rest of the taxes, but our focus is only on the middle class.</p><p>There are 125 million households in the USA. We said 39% of the households constitute the middle class that pays 48% of the nation’s personal income taxes. 39% of 125 million households are about 49 million households. On average, each of the 49 million households will share equally in the $348 billion tax savings, seeing a tax reduction of $7,714. So far, so good.</p><p><strong>2.</strong> <strong>Bottom-Up View</strong></p><p>Let’s compare a 2015 tax form with the proposed tax form. We’ll do it the simple way and, again, only focus on the middle class. So far, we’re told deductions for the home mortgage, charitable deductions, child care, and college credits will not change, so let’s not include them in the calculations. Nor should we include some deductions that may change, such as eliminating deductions for a home office; a 401(k); and state and local taxes. Otherwise, what’s the big change? The standard deduction. It’s going from $12,600 to $30,000 for spouses filing jointly, or a reduction of taxable income of $17,400. At a tax rate of 25%, a family could expect a $4,350 tax reduction with this legislation.</p><p><strong>3.</strong> <strong>The President’s View</strong></p><p>In an early speech that covered the tax cut, among other topics, the President said that a middle class family earning $90,000 will save $1,000 in taxes, and there will be no change for low income and the top 1%. This means that 49 million households in this group will have a total tax cut effect of $49 billion. (By the way, the President said this was a terrific and significant tax reduction. Big Whoop. This could buy you a new phone, and with a little left over, buy some ice cream).</p><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>These numbers were hard to follow, weren’t they? The politicians count on this obfuscation. The media complicates the information further, depending on their editorial perspective and the capability of the reporter. How can we make an independent judgment? We have to be able to decide for ourselves where we stand on the important issues of the day. But without the data on which we can agree, this is not possible. In order to make sense of the imperfect information we have, we need to use our critical thinking skills to create multiple perspectives, and then decide what makes the most sense to us.</p><p><strong>Critical Thinking</strong></p><p>Can we trust any of these economic numbers? Without understanding the source of the data, we can’t determine our confidence in them. This will make political horse trading difficult. Consider:</p><p>· How is it possible to have such a variance of outcomes? Usually, assessments start with the CBO. When the numbers don’t fit the desired narrative, the sources used will vary depending on the end game. With the numerous think tanks in D.C., each of which has its own focus, it’s not hard to find data to support a political position.</p><p>· Will the forecast tax reductions allow for bilateral agreement?</p><p>· The forecast tax revenue predictions can change. On Friday, the President announced that middle class tax reduction will likely be $5,000, the prediction of the Bottom-Up View. Is he saying this to create a groundswell of citizen support for the tax bill, and in so doing, is he removing some of the negotiating room for both parties, making it harder to pass the bill he so desires?</p><p>· Meanwhile, the Top-Down View noted a forecast personal income tax reduction of $348 billion. If the President’s original $1,000 plan will only reduce revenues by $90 billion, what happens to the other $258 billion in proposed tax reduction? Was the purpose of this earlier amount to facilitate political trading to get a bill passed?</p><p>· Or is the plan purposefully designed to use unused budgeted tax revenue cuts for other purposes, such as building the southern wall?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d826f92731" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic/tax-reduction-for-whom-9d826f92731">Tax Reduction for Whom?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-fifth-estate-republic">The Fifth Estate Republic</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>