<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by First.VIP on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by First.VIP on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 20:16:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@first.vip/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[First.VIP Project Analysis: ‘METAGAME’ layer Zentry]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/first-vip-project-analysis-metagame-layer-zentry-13588dcd0247?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/13588dcd0247</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Dec 2024 03:05:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-24T03:07:10.084Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_ZXxaFhS-9Adl4zYIQ-P0A.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Zentry, formerly GuildFi,</strong> announced in April 2024 its rebranding to Zentry, alongside a strategic upgrade of its brand to encompass extensive gaming infrastructure. The project is committed to constructing a Layer0 solution for its Play Economy, referred to as the Metagame Layer. Zentry has recently announced a collaboration with Beam to incubate and support the Sophon ecosystem, an entertainment-focused modular hyperchain powered by zkSync that has successfully secured $60 million through a node sale. Moreover, Zentry has launched its SocialFi platform Nexus and has outlined a strategic blueprint to reveal various product offerings: 1) Radiant, a flagship cross-platform application that is the gateway to the Zentry Metagame for gamers; 2) Zigma, an anime and gaming-inspired IP as an NFT collection; 3) Azul, a cross-world AI companion; 4) Maxion, Zentry’s flagship Web2 game publishing division tailored for game publishers. Infrastructure initiatives such as Zentry-SDK, a Social &amp; Interest Graph, and an Identity Layer are anticipated to be deployed progressively between 2024 and mid-2025.</p><h3>Executive Summary</h3><p>Zentry, formerly GuildFi, announced in April 2024 its rebranding to Zentry, alongside a comprehensive upgrade of its brand to encompass extensive gaming infrastructure. At a macro level, Zentry operates as a middle layer in the Web3 space, principally encompassing computing, gaming, and bridging functionalities across various platforms, applications, and virtual worlds. At a micro level, Zentry epitomizes a holistic provider of gaming infrastructure and ecosystem services. Zentry is “the game of games” and is pioneering a new paradigm — the Play Economy, wherein in-game accomplishments or assets can be transferred between games, extending their utility beyond the confines of the digital realm.</p><p><strong>The highlights of Zentry encompass:</strong></p><ol><li>Zentry demonstrates a robust financial foundation, with a treasury valued at $140 million and an annual revenue of $40 million in 2024. This financial stability ensures a solid runway for sustained development.</li><li>Zentry is actively engaging with the gaming blockchain Ronin Network to integrate the Beta version of its metagame gateway, Nexus. Within Nexus, creators are empowered to generate content that accentuates the Ronin ecosystem, earning incentives in the form of points and tokens for their contributions.</li><li>The team has announced a new collaboration between Zentry and Beam, two of the largest gaming ecosystems boasting a combined treasury exceeding $300 million, to incubate and support the Sophon ecosystem. Recently, Sophon successfully raised $60 million through its node sale.</li><li>During its tenure as GuildFi, Zentry amassed a considerable repository of players and project resources, providing significant support for the project’s post-upgrade advancement.</li></ol><p><strong>Nevertheless, it is imperative to acknowledge the following risks:</strong></p><ol><li>While the GameFi sector has exhibited signs of recovery, the influx of external capital and market vitality remains markedly below the levels observed in the previous bull market.</li><li>Following its recent project transition, Zentry remains in an embryonic phase, with its forthcoming infrastructure likely to encounter formidable competitive pressures.</li></ol><p>In summary, Zentry’s rebranding presents a potentially auspicious juncture for the project. Transitioning from a gaming guild to the Metagame Layer, the project now boasts an expanded narrative encompassing various domains such as GameFi, SocialFi, and AI. Furthermore, the alliance with Beam represents a formidable collaboration, and the tripartite synergy between Zentry, Beam, and Sophon will facilitate resource integration, thereby establishing a developmental edge. Nonetheless, it is crucial to recognize that, to date, the influx of new players and capital in the current cycle remains limited, necessitating vigilance regarding the future trajectory of the GameFi sector.</p><h3>1. Overview</h3><h4><strong>1.1 Project Profile</strong></h4><p>Zentry, formerly GuildFi, announced in April 2024 its rebranding to Zentry, alongside a comprehensive upgrade of its brand to encompass extensive gaming infrastructure. The project is committed to constructing a Layer0 solution for its Play Economy, referred to as the Metagame Layer, encompassing a broad spectrum of sectors, including GameFi, SocialFi, NFT, AI, and Infrastructure.</p><h4><strong>1.2 Basic Information</strong> <a href="#_ftn1"><em>[1]</em></a></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1009/1*CL5ci7_3Uq7njJMeDD_7Dw.png" /></figure><h3><strong>2. Project Details</strong></h3><h4><strong>2.1 Team</strong></h4><p>Zentry proudly maintains a cadre of over 60 professionals, whose expertise spans software engineering, product development, graphic and visual design, marketing, business development, community moderation, and event organization. Zentry, along with the majority of its employees, is headquartered in Thailand, with further employees residing in Singapore, Australia, the U.S., and Europe. The Zentry team is distinguished by its profound experience in the gaming and crypto industries, with prominent members having previously served at esteemed firms like Riot Games, CCP Games, and Playtika. Information on the core members at Zentry is delineated below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*ka6ip86BAt1RSrDNnCiVLw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Jarindr Thitadilaka</strong>, Founder &amp; Project Lead</p><p>Jarindr Thitadilaka graduated from Chulalongkorn University, Thailand, where they earned a Bachelor of Engineering in Information Communication Engineering. Boasting a decade-long tenure in the realms of blockchain technology and software development, Thitadilaka has rendered their expertise to esteemed entities including OmiseGO (OMG Network) and Bitfinex. Furthermore, they have carved a niche for themselves through extensive exploration of cutting-edge domains such as NFT tokenization on Layer2 networks, a testament to their visionary pursuits. Notably, Thitadilaka stands as the pioneering force behind the inception of the first-ever Proof-of-Concept blockchain game on the Plasma protocol, underscoring their avant-garde contributions to the technological landscape.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*4GMaOtLfPZprbkIvCw12OQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Gazinpoj Techahuasingh</strong>, Co-Founder &amp; Business Development Lead</p><p>Embarking on their journey into the realm of cryptocurrencies in 2017, Gazinpoj Techahuasingh swiftly ascended to prominence, curating a fervent community of crypto enthusiasts that burgeoned to encompass over 5 million followers. Venturing beyond conventional boundaries, Techahuasingh diversified their pursuits across multifarious domains spanning media, consultancy, fund management, and research. The culmination of their visionary endeavors materialized in the establishment of GuildFi in 2021, which has since been rebranded as Zentry. Within the echelons of Zentry, Techahuasingh assumes the role of BD Lead, orchestrating strategic partnerships and driving the expansive trajectory of business development.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*42eZiCOtVBBVIQqB4PHOJg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Ian Pieragostini</strong>, R&amp;D Lead</p><p>Ian Pieragostini boasts an illustrious career spanning over two decades within the dynamic realm of gaming. Their professional journey has traversed the corridors of industry giants including Microsoft, EA, and Riot Games. Notably, during his tenure at Riot Games, Pieragostini ascended to the esteemed role of Technical Director, orchestrating the meticulous development and fruition of multiple IPs in conjunction with his adept team.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*B9bwmqK40tmkfWmpNyt5Cw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Raymond Chng</strong>, Growth Lead</p><p>Raymond Chng is an alumnus of Singapore Management University, equipped with a decade-long tenure specializing in strategic expansion and investment advisory. Chng established REVEM in Singapore, offering real estate insights to readers through its proprietary data-driven research and in-depth consumer analytics. Furthermore, Chng serves as the founder and a distinguished contributor among the roster of writers for Embernodes, a pioneering Web3 media entity.</p><h4><strong>2.2 Financials</strong></h4><p>Throughout the GuildFi epoch, the team navigated three successive rounds of funding. Subsequently, following GuildFi’s rebranding as Zentry, an additional fundraising endeavor was conducted via the Sophon Node Sale. The cumulative disclosed capital amassed from these fundraising endeavors approximated a sum of $146 million, delineated as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mVBurlY86vKz-Rtz8ri_uA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 2–1 Zentry Financials</strong></figcaption></figure><p>According to the latest Zentry Treasury Vault Report (released on May 29, 2024)<a href="#_ftn2"><em>[2]</em></a>, the total value of the Zentry Treasury Vault is $151,367,382, up around 44% from early 2024. This is categorized into two main areas: liquid reserves and investments (as illustrated in Figure 2–1). Liquid reserves in the Zentry Treasury comprise stablecoins and major cryptocurrencies, totaling $78,105,000:</p><p>1) Stablecoins: $17,850,000, distributed among USDC and USDT, utilized in various lending and yield-generating protocols.</p><p>2) Cryptocurrencies: $60,255,000, which includes approximately 16,000 ETH staked across several protocols.</p><p>Investments in the Zentry Treasury include seed tokens, equities, liquid tokens, and NFTs, totaling $73,262,382. Moreover, the Zentry Treasury retains an approximate quantum of 1.5 billion $ZENT, with an estimated valuation of $58.6 million.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/668/1*0elaQO9GdV1VOARGyDsvzg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–1 Zentry Treasury Vault Positions</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Jarindr Thitadilaka stated in a thread on X<a href="#_ftn3"><em>[3]</em></a>, “And we are profitable. This is from Treasury management, Nodes, partnership activation, and investment from all top games/entertainment, which now generating ~$10M a year (fluctuate).” In addition, Sophon has forged a partnership with Zentry and BEAM, two of the largest gaming ecosystems boasting a combined treasury exceeding $300 million, to incubate and support the Sophon ecosystem. Sophon launched a Node Sale in April 2024 and raised over $60 million.</p><p>Overall, Zentry reveals a financial abundance from its treasury reserve, bolstered by the recent influx of $60 million from the Sophon Node Sale, thus providing substantial financial backing for future development endeavors.</p><p>In the wake of its metamorphosis from a gaming guild, Zentry has restructured its financial strategy, now officially designated as the “Four-Engine Treasury Strategy,” encompassing four distinct engines:</p><p><strong>1) Investing in Zentry’s Development — Strengthening the Core: </strong>At the heart of our Treasury Strategy is Zentry’s commitment to its development. By continuously enhancing and broadening the core of the Zentry universe, Zentry builds a robust and resilient foundation for all our endeavors. As Zentry introduces more products and experiences, the economic value within the Zentry ecosystem not only increases but also flows back to the Treasury, directly benefiting our token holders and fostering a thriving community.</p><p><strong>2) Investing in Others — Capturing Both Financial and Synergistic Value: </strong>Zentry extends its investment strategy beyond internal development and meticulously assesses potential investments for strategic alignment with its long-term vision, targeting frontier projects that integrate seamlessly with the Zentry ecosystem.<strong> </strong>These investments are chosen for their financial returns and the synergistic value they add, helping to create new experiences and enhance Zentry’s technology stack, thus keeping Zentry at the forefront of technological advancement.</p><p><strong>3) Ecosystem Incentives — Driving Rapid Expansion: </strong>Ecosystem incentives are pivotal in driving the rapid expansion of the Zentry universe. Zentry offers strategic incentives to encourage participation, collaboration, and innovation. These incentives catalyze growth by attracting new users, developers, and partners, contributing to a vibrant and dynamic community. The resulting expansion creates a network effect, exponentially increasing the value and reach of the Zentry ecosystem.</p><p><strong>4) Earning Yields — Creating Sustainable Growth: </strong>Sustainable growth is fundamental to the Zentry Treasury Strategy. Zentry generates a steady income stream by earning yields by strategically staking stablecoins, ETH, and token nodes. This revenue is strategically reinvested into the development of the Zentry ecosystem or distributed back to $ZENT holders. This approach ensures the continuous growth and enhancement of Zentry and provides tangible rewards to our community, reinforcing their trust and commitment to Zentry.</p><h4><strong>2.3 Code</strong></h4><p>At present, the Zentry codebase remains proprietary and has not been made available as open-source.</p><h4><strong>2.4 Products</strong></h4><p>The Zentry team is driven by a powerful vision: to create and nurture the Play Economy through seven strategic dimensions:</p><p><strong>1) Unified Gaming Experience:</strong> A Metagame that spans multiple games and platforms, aggregating achievements, assets, and social connections into one profile for unprecedented continuity.</p><p><strong>2) Technological Innovation:</strong> Leveraging blockchain, AI, and advanced analytics to create a robust, transparent, and fair infrastructure.</p><p><strong>3) Real-World Value Translation:</strong> In-game achievements enhance real-world experiences, unlocking discounts, job opportunities, and exclusive rewards.</p><p><strong>4) Cross-World Interactions:</strong> Breaking down barriers between game worlds, allowing assets and identities to have value across multiple platforms.</p><p><strong>5) Economic Empowerment:</strong> Establishing gaming as a legitimate economic activity where players can earn, invest, and build wealth through their gaming endeavors.</p><p><strong>6) Gamified Lifestyle:</strong> Enhancing every aspect of daily life through gamification, making every activity more engaging and rewarding.</p><p><strong>7) Inclusive Ecosystem:</strong> A world where everyone — casual gamers, professionals, investors, digital artists — can play a vital role in the Play Economy.</p><p>Within this conceptualized Play Economy, Zentry endeavors to harmonize disparate realms, including Web2 and Web3 gaming platforms, social networks, blockchain ecosystems, real-life experiences, and financial systems. Its dedication is manifest in the pursuit of the following overarching goals:</p><p><strong>1) In-Game Actions Have Real-World Impact:</strong> Completing quests or reaching levels can earn cryptocurrency or unlock real-world discounts.</p><p><strong>2) Digital Achievements Unlock Tangible Benefits:</strong> Gaming skills can lead to job opportunities or financial returns from virtual investments.</p><p><strong>3) Social Connections Span Realms:</strong> Friendships formed in games can lead to real-world collaborations, and your digital social status could influence your real-world networks and opportunities.</p><p><strong>4) Economic Activities Blur Boundaries:</strong> Trading virtual items could become as significant as traditional stock market activities, and managing a guild could be akin to running a real-world corporation.</p><p><strong>5) Gaming Goes Beyond Games:</strong> The principles of gaming extend far beyond traditional video games, permeating various industries through gamification. This involves applying game design elements to non-game contexts, transforming mundane activities into engaging and rewarding experiences.</p><p><strong>2.4.1 GuildFi</strong></p><p>Formerly recognized as GuildFi, Zentry initially operated as a prominent gaming guild in the GameFi sector. During the previous round of GameFi bull runs, driven by the success of Axie Infinity and other blockchain games, there was a significant influx of gamers seeking to capitalize on the trend. However, the high entry barriers deterred many potential participants, thus prompting the emergence of gaming guilds like GuildFi. <strong>In the last bull market, GuildFi secured nearly $150 million in funding and attained a post-money valuation of $4 billion. At its peak, GuildFi boasted a substantial user base of nearly 300,000 registered GuildFi ID users and approximately 130,000 followers on Twitter.</strong></p><p>During the GuildFi era, the project primarily operated as a gaming guild and a GameFi services provider, catering to both players and game developers. Players accrued points by completing guild tasks, redeemable for rewards and scholarships, and gained early access to partner projects of GuildFi. For game developers, GuildFi nurtured a vast and engaged player base and served as a significant marketplace for gaming assets, facilitating game promotion, asset sales, and invaluable player feedback. <strong>GuildFi disclosed in its latest post on Medium <em>“GuildFi 2023 Recap and Gearing Up for 2024”</em></strong><a href="#_ftn4"><em>[4]</em></a><em> </em><strong>(posted in January 2024), “Through year 2023 partnerships, GuildFi has brought in a total of 330,000 Partner Pre-Registrations to the aforementioned gaming titles, with the platform accruing 1,900,000 transactions and 280,000 purchases.” Throughout its trajectory of business operations, GuildFi has engaged in partnerships with prominent projects such as Memeland, Ronin, Xai, Sipher, and Pixelmon.</strong></p><p>During the GuildFi epoch, the project team cultivated an extensive network of player resources and fostered considerable relationships with various game developers. Nonetheless, the stagnation in the broader GameFi sector’s progression subsequently hindered the growth of gaming guilds. At the end of 2023, GuildFi was in pursuit of a strategic transition, which was referred to as “Project Z”. This culminated in April 2024 with the official rollout of Project Z, or Zentry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/1*JpxQt9VwWkmKFoX4bbSDAg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–2 GuildFi 2023 Recap</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>2.4.2 Zentry</strong></p><p>In April 2024, GuildFi underwent a rebranding to emerge as Zentry, a transition dubbed by the project team as “The Metagame Layer”. At a macro level, Zentry operates as a middle layer in the Web3 space. Zentry Founder Jarindr Thitadilaka stated, “Think of the Zentry as a new layer, which does the computing, gamifying, bridging, connecting and rewarding for everything that happens in other layers, permeating through various applications, platforms, and virtual worlds.”</p><p>Zentry’s Metagame emerges as a middleware, and key aspects of Zentry’s middleware role include:</p><p><strong>1) Cross-Sector Integration:</strong> Facilitate activities, assets, content, and collaborations across industries, blending play, work, and value creation.</p><p><strong>2) Universal ID:</strong> Provides universal identity and progression across ecosystems.</p><p><strong>3) Interoperability:</strong> Ensures compatibility of integration between diverse platforms, protocols, and data formats.</p><p><strong>4) Data Aggregation and Analysis:</strong> Processes vast amounts of data, enabling informed decision-making for all stakeholders.</p><p><strong>5) Value Distribution:</strong> Implements mechanisms for fair value distribution among participants.</p><p><strong>6) Sustainable Universe and Governance:</strong> Builds sustainable economic models and governance structures for the Play Economy.</p><p>Through these functions, the Metagame not only connects various elements of the Play Economy but also ensures its growth, fairness, and sustainability in the Web3 era.</p><p>At a micro level, Zentry epitomizes a holistic provider of gaming infrastructure and ecosystem services. The project team stated in a post on Medium<a href="#_ftn5"><em>[5]</em></a>, “Enter Zentry, the Metagame Layer built to bring the MMORPG experience to real life. It is ‘the game of games’.” Zentry is pioneering a new paradigm — the Play Economy, wherein in-game accomplishments or assets can be transferred between games, extending their utility beyond the confines of the digital realm. The Metagame Layer comprises three vertically integrated cores:</p><p>1) The underlying blockchain infrastructure bridging Web2 and Web3 data encompassing identity, asset, and activity;</p><p>2) A suite of targeted consumer apps designed to onboard various player segments;</p><p>3) A multiversal IP world that deepens engagement through compelling narratives and collaborative IP partnerships.</p><p>Specifically, the official delineation presents a spectrum of practical applications. For instance, players who completed gaming or real-world activities (victories in online battles, nailing 100 headshots in an FPS, or even crushing fitness goals) can earn rare items and crafting materials for Zentry, which could then be exchanged for tokens or even offer real-world rewards. Conversely, engagement in communal activities like taking three of your friends to five days of coffee runs can unlock exclusive NFTs that supercharge DeFi staking yields. With Zentry, everyone can forge a lifelong, dynamic avatar profile that evolves in status, uniqueness, and real wealth through their play across various ecosystems.</p><p>On the product front, Zentry presently harbors plans entailing a multifaceted array spanning SocialFi, GameFi, NFT, AI, and other domains:</p><p><strong>Nexus: </strong>Web3 culture’s metagame gateway, opening the doors towards the Play Economy and transforming your social interactions into an immersive, profitable gaming experience. This platform transforms social interactions, achievements, and asset ownership across digital and physical worlds into a comprehensive gaming indentity. Nexus goes beyond being a static profile, offering users an evolving digital person that mirrors their journeys across realms. Mexus as a social layer plays a crucial role in realizing Zentry’s vision of real-life MMORPG by: 1) Showcasing achievements and connecting with others; 2) Ensuring every contribution is valued, recognized, and rewarded; 3) Integrating with other platforms and networks for continuous growth; 4) Transforming passive engagement into active participation. Simply put, Nexus constitutes a bastion of SocialFi innovation, wherein users with Nexus Shards are rewarded with tangible rewards for each social interaction such as, but not limited to, likes, comments, replies, and retweets on X (although the precise nature of these tangible rewards remains undisclosed). Zentry unveiled a preliminary beta version of Nexus in May 2024. Furthermore, the official strategic blueprint outlines forthcoming endeavors to introduce a Nexus full-stack game, envisaged to encompass multifaceted social interactions, reminiscent of platforms like fantasy.top.</p><p><strong>Radiant:</strong> Gamers’ metagame gateway and Zentry’s flagship cross-platform application that turns your Web2 and Web3 gaming activities into a “rewarding adventure”. To date (as of May 30, 2024), Radiant remains poised at the threshold of launch, with conjecture veering towards a Nexus-like paradigm, wherein gamers are rewarded with points for their gaming exploits or achievements, thus precipitating a cascade of digital and tangible rewards. Radiant is Zentry’s revolutionary cross-platform metagame app that overlays both Web2 and Web3 games, creating an immersive experience where players’ actions across various games contribute to a unified profile and cohesive gameplay progression. By introducing a gamification layer over the games players already love, Radiant transforms discrete gaming sessions into chapters of a grand, personalized adventure that spans multiple worlds. For example, reaching a certain rank in an FPS game might unlock abilities in Radiant, or completing quests across two games could reveal new storylines.</p><p><strong>Zigma:</strong> An anime and gaming-inspired IP as an NFT collection. To date (as of May 30, 2024), Zigma remains absent from the Zentry ecosystem.</p><p><strong>Azul:</strong> A cross-world AI companion that elevates your gameplay, making it more fun and productive. To date (as of May 30, 2024), Zigma remains pending its official launch.</p><p><strong>Vault:</strong> The Vault of Zentry is a pivotal application within the Zentry ecosystem, offering a dynamic mechanism for token holders to actively participate in and benefit from the rise of gaming culture and the increasing value across the Zentry universe, Play Economy, and beyond. Users stake or “infuse” their $ZENT tokens into the Vault. Infused tokens generate “fragments,” a resource that reflects the user’s contribution and infusion status. The user’s infusion status, determined by their fragment count, influences their benefits and special unlocks in various applications. Fragments can be strategically burned in exchange for reward allocation (e.g., tokens). The more Fragments burned, the bigger your share of the Vault Drop rewards. A portion of Zentry’s treasury resources is earmarked for the Vault Drop reward pool, enhancing participant returns and incentivizing engagement.</p><p><strong>Maxion:</strong> Maxion is Zentry’s flagship Web2 game publishing division, enabling developers to publish games on-chain, providing players with true ownership of in-game assets, and bridging popular traditional gaming titles into the blockchain ecosystem. Maxion’s partnership with Gravity has yielded <em>Ragnarok: Landscape</em>, a Web3 adaption of the legendary Ragnarok MMORPG. In the forthcoming year, Maxion is poised to unveil an additional four game titles.</p><p>Presently, Zentry remains in its nascent phase. Among its suite of product offerings, Nexus is the sole product to have achieved a formal launch alongside a Beta integration with Ronin Network, with Nexus Beta Season 1 on Ronin Network soon to kick off. Plans for future infrastructure, including the Zentry-SDK, a Social &amp; Interest Graph, and an Identity Layer, are slated for phased rollout between 2024 and 2025.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*fbmVA1cuQy-oTqfgbgqlng.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–3 Nexus User Interface</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>2.4.3 The Metagame Stack</strong></p><p>The Metagame Stack comprises three layers: Consumer Applications, Open IP Universe, and Metagame Protocol. This vertically designed full-stack ecosystem is engineered for robustness, scalability, and adaptability to enable the seamless integration of diverse gaming experiences, social interactions, and economic activities while forming a dynamic, interconnected environment. Users primarily interact with the Consumer Applications, through which users can engage with the Open IP Universe. The Zentry ecosystem currently features a robust layer of Consumer Applications, including the aforementioned Nexus, Radiant, Zigman, and Azul.</p><p>The Open IP Universe includes:</p><p><strong>1) Zentry IP:</strong> The in-house created IPs form the core of the Zentry universe, featuring iconic characters and narratives from flagship titles like Radiant, Nexus, Azul, and more.</p><p><strong>2) Game Content:</strong> Zentry offers a rich array of gamified experiences. These experiences are continuously enriched by integrating content from Zentry’s vast network of partners, transforming Zentry into an ever-expanding content hub.</p><p><strong>3) Collaborative IPs:</strong> Zentry actively partners with other creators to bring high-quality, established IPs into its ecosystem.</p><p>The fabric of the Metagame Protocol fuses a series of modules, including:</p><p><strong>1) Zentry Universal ID:</strong> Provides a universal identity, status, and progression system through aggregated data across ecosystems.</p><p><strong>2) Off-chain Connectors:</strong> Enable intelinking of off-chain user data across integrated ecosystems.</p><p><strong>3) Gamification Engine:</strong> Transforms integrated ecosystem interactions into rewarding, game-like activities with achievements and challenges.</p><p><strong>4) Proof of Play:</strong> An activity-aggregation system that leverages blockchain to ensure fair and transparent distribution of rewards.</p><p><strong>5) Social &amp; Interest Graph:</strong> Maps user relationships and preferences, enabling personalized gameplay, tailored content, and social networking.</p><p><strong>6) Omnichain Connectors:</strong> Enable interlinking of on-chain user data across integrated ecosystems.</p><p><strong>7) Marketplace Engine:</strong> Facilitates trading of on-chain and off-chain assets both within the Zentry ecosystem and across ecosystems.</p><p><strong>8) Proof of Asset:</strong> Authenticates ownership and creation of on-chain and off-chain assets across ecosystems.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*zK-xCZ5xTNu30_j9RgNDUg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–4 The Zentry Metagame Stack</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>2.4.4 Zentry SDK</strong></p><p>To facilitate seamless integration with the Metagame Protocol, Zentry provides a powerful Software Development Kit (SDK). This tool is designed to make integration straightforward and efficient for developers and partners and equip them with the necessary resources to connect their applications, protocols, and services directly into the Zentry universe with minimal effort. Key features of the Zentry SDK are as follows:</p><p>1) Easy access to core Metagame Protocol functionalities;</p><p>2) Seamless processing and integration of essential data (e.g., user identity and play spending);</p><p>3) Tools for creating immersive, interconnected experiences within the Zentry ecosystem.</p><p><strong>2.4.5 Economic Engines</strong></p><p>Zentry’s Metagame serves as the pillar of the Play Economy, functioning as essential middleware that both facilitates and captures significant value across the ecosystem. As the Play Economy grows — fueled by the synergy between the Metagame and partner contributions — the Economic Engines gain momentum and work synergistically, funneling revenue into the Zentry Treasury for strategic allocation, including enhancing the Metagame, attracting partners, and benefiting $ZENT token holders. This reinforces long-term ecosystem growth and sustainability.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*0dFxfa9FxdlpHj_4Pw710g.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–5 Zentry’s Economic Engines and Flow of Value</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Zentry has four Core Economic Engines:</p><p><strong>1) Distribution Engine:</strong> By uniting diverse player networks, Zentry is poised to become a leading gaming distributor in the new era. Revenue streams include the Gamified Attention Platform (GAP) and Launchpad. The GAP is a novel platform that combines distribution, gamification, and advertising to offer immersive, engaging, and personalized experiences. It connects consumers and brands through Radiant and Nexus, with potential expansion to other applications. The Launchpad is a gamified modular asset distribution platform for tokens, NFTs, and digital assets from games, apps, creators, and ecosystems. It rewards active participants within the Zentry universe through a dynamic contribution model.</p><p><strong>2) Commerce Engine:</strong> As the hub of the Play Economy, Zentry captures a significant volume of commerce activities and hybrid Web2-Web3 transactions. Revenue streams include the Marketplace, In-world Spending &amp; Taxes, and IP &amp; Transmedia. The Marketplace is a market platform that seamlessly integrates Web2 and Web3 assets, enabling cross-trading and value exchange between on-chain and off-chain items from in-game assets and exclusive commodities to NFTs. Zentry’s Commerce Engine monetizes in-world spending from user interactions, quests, and achievements, including crafting materials, in-world equipment, skins, and shop items. Revenue is also shared with community creators of select digital items. The “IP &amp; Transmedia” section generates revenue through fee-sharing from collaborative IP projects. Zentry’s IP appears both within its own ecosystem and in collaboration with other IPs, while external IPs can also be integrated into the Zentry universe, driving diverse revenue streams through licensing, royalties, and transmedia storytelling across multiple platforms.</p><p><strong>3) Treasury Engine:</strong> Zentry’s Treasury Strategy focuses on growth and innovation across the ecosystem. Revenue streams include Investment, Ventures, and Staking, Yield Farming &amp; Node Operations. Investments target frontier projects that align with Zentry’s long-term vision, focusing on financial returns and synergistic value. These investments enhance Zentry’s technology stack and user experiences. Ventures are defined as companies where Zentry holds substantial stakes, such as Sophon, Maxion Labs, Zoltan, and AltF4. These ventures act as extensions of the Zentry ecosystem, contributing to its strength and resilience. Zentry monetizes from staking, yield farming, and node operation activities and generates steady income through strategic staking of assets like stablecoins, ETH, and token nodes. Revenues are reinvested into ecosystem development or distributed to token holders, ensuring continuous growth and rewards for the community.</p><p><strong>4) Infrastructure Engine:</strong> Zentry aggregates vast amounts of user data, including identities, activities, spending, and assets, making it one of the largest data mines in the gaming ecosystem. Revenue streams are derived from Protocol Fees. Zentry constructs a structured fee model for builders leveraging Zentry’s services, covering advanced data insights, developer tools, and integration services. The Zentry SDK, an easy-to-integrate toolkit, allows businesses and projects to tap into Zentry’s vast data resources and capabilities, contributing to protocol fee revenue.</p><p>Zentry’s four core engines are highly flexible and mutually supportive, creating a robust ecosystem that adapts to market shifts and seizes new opportunities. These engines work in concert, amplifying each other’s impact. For instance, data collected through the Distribution Engine informs investment decisions for the Treasury Engine, while successful projects launched via the Launchpad become potential investment targets. This interconnected system allows Zentry to maintain a stable foundation while pursuing multiple avenues for exponential growth, driving the evolution of the Play Economy.</p><p><strong>2.4.6 Growth Strategy</strong></p><p>Zentry’s growth flywheel is powered by a continuous cycle of engagement, community building, and economic activity. This self-sustaining cycle ensures that the Zentry ecosystem continues to grow, innovate, and deliver value to all its participants. The cycle begins with supporting successful launches of gamified experiences, apps, and content. These new offerings create more activities for users, fostering user growth and engagement within the Zentry universe. As the user base grows, it’s amplified by cross-game collaborations, enriching the overall user experience. This expansion leads to increased user interest, social engagement, and growth of the social graph. The larger, more engaged community drives higher economic activity within the ecosystem. This increased activity generates more value for both partners and the community through various fees and asset trading, creating a virtuous cycle of economic growth. As a result of this expanding activity, the Play Economy flourishes. It onboards new games, generates user-created content, attracts consumer brands, and expands beyond gaming into other verticals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*NIXN7dam6voFaw_O6C9A5g.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–5 The Zentry Flywheel</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The growth of the Zentry Universe is propelled by four interconnected drivers:</p><p><strong>1) Blockchains:</strong> The foundation of Zentry’s Metagame Protocol, enabling unprecedented aggregation of user data from both on-chain and off-chain sources. With the growing number of blockchains and protocols, this integration creates a unified user experience across diverse ecosystems.</p><p><strong>2) Diverse Player Networks:</strong> The Play Economy welcomes a wide spectrum of player communities, from niche to mass market. Each group can participate and play a unique, meaningful role, with rewards tailored to their level of engagement. As more communities join, the network effect amplifies, fostering a dynamic player ecosystem.</p><p><strong>3) Content &amp; IPs:</strong> The seamless incorporation of partners’ intellectual property fuels an abundance of compelling content with Zentry’s expanding universe and enriches the gaming experience.</p><p><strong>4) Cross-world Activity:</strong> Activities within the Play Economy evolve to intertwine with nearly every aspect of daily life. This lifestyle revolution ensures that every action contributes to the Play Economy’s continuous growth.</p><p><strong>2.4.7 Sophon</strong></p><p>Zentry’s strategic rebranding parallels that undertaken by Merit Circle, marking a pivotal shift from a gaming guild to a more expansive narrative. Shortly following this transformation, Zentry entered into a partnership with Beam to jointly incubate the entertainment-focused modular hyperchain, Sophon.</p><p>In April 2024, Sophon announced a partnership with Zentry and BEAM, two of the largest gaming ecosystems boasting a combined treasury exceeding $300 million, to incubate and support the Sophon ecosystem. Sophon is an emerging entertainment-focused modular hyperchain powered by zkSync, designed specifically for high-throughput applications focusing on entertainment, gaming, and artificial intelligence. At present, Sophon finds itself in the embryonic stages of development, with intricate nuances of its product architecture awaiting divulgence.</p><p>Zentry assumes a pivotal role as a gaming application layer, synergistically aligning with Beam and Sophon to propel project maturation. In this tripartite synergy, Zentry brings its extensive player network and a reputation as a forward-thinking distributor in gaming, entertainment, and lifestyle; Beam offers a robust technical blockchain infrastructure and product suite that simplifies the complexity of game development while enhancing user experiences; Sophon itself, as a modular hyperchain, is engineered for high throughput and scalability to meet the rigorous demands of next-generation applications.</p><p>On the financial front, beyond a combined reserve exceeding $300 million in Zentry and Beam treasuries, Sophon closed a funding round in early April 2024 and secured $10 million from a consortium of investors, comprising Paper Ventures, Maven11, Spartan, SevenX, OKX Ventures, and Huobi Ventures. Moreover, Sophon recently augmented its fiscal reserves to the tune of ~$60 million via its public node sale.</p><p>Beyond the purview of mere project synergy, the partnership between Zentry and Sophon features certain benefits for Zentry users:</p><p>1) Through the staking of qualified assets in an initial liquidity window hosted by Sophon, $ZENT holders will be eligible to receive a $SOPH token airdrop.</p><p>2) For the upcoming Sophon node sale, users who utilize Zentry’s code will receive not only a 10% discount but also exclusivity within the Zentry ecosystem.</p><p>3) Zentry will airdrop 5,000 $ZENT to everyone who purchases at least one node in the Sophon node public sale.</p><p>4) 10,000 $ZENT tokens will be airdropped to participating wallets that hold at least 10,000 $ZENT tokens prior to the start of the public node sale and purchases at least one node.</p><p><strong>Summary: Zentry’s rebranding closely mirrors the strategic evolution of Merit Circle, transitioning from a gaming guild to a comprehensive “Metagame Layer” with an expanded narrative aimed at fostering a sustainable Play Economy. The reimagined Zentry encompasses a diverse array of sectors, including GameFi, SocialFi, NFT, AI, and Infrastructure. Although still in its nascent stages, Zentry boasts a suite of innovative products, including Nexus, Azul, Radiant, Zigma, Vault, and Maxion. From a financial perspective, Zentry is well-capitalized, with a treasury totaling $150 million. This includes liquid reserves of $78,105,000 (in stablecoins and ETH) and investments amounting to $73,262,382 (comprising seed tokens, NFTs, and other assets). Furthermore, in a recent display of strategic acumen, the project has forged a partnership with Beam to co-incubate Sophon, successfully raising $60 million through its public node sale. In summary, while Zentry remains in its formative phase, its substantial financial reserves position it strongly for sustained growth and development.</strong></p><h3>3. Development</h3><h4><strong>3.1 Historical Overview</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J1ZAD7wcSUhFqLVqutm_nA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–1 Zentry Achieved Milestones</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Moreover, Zentry (formerly GuildFi) has engaged in a myriad of collaborations and investments across a diverse array of projects, as illustrated in Figure 3–1.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/510/1*LiMli-7dlJ614x8C369EdQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–1 Zentry: Collaborations &amp; Investments</strong></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>3.2 Current State</strong></h4><p>At the end of April, GuildFi underwent a rebranding metamorphosis to emerge as Zentry, subsequently initiating the migration of $GF tokens to $ZENT tokens a few days thereafter. Nonetheless, Zentry remains in a nascent stage, having only launched the public version of Nexus.</p><h4><strong>3.3 Future Prospects</strong></h4><p>As previously elucidated, Zentry is at the very inception of its evolutionary journey, with merely one product, i.e., Nexus, launched a month ago. The strategic blueprint of Zentry outlines expansive forays into SocialFi, GameFi, NFT, and AI, among other sectors. Imminent product launches may include a Nexus-based full-stack game, bearing resemblance to fantasy.top. Furthermore, there are ambitious plans to unveil: 1) Radiant, a flagship cross-platform application that is the gateway to the Zentry Metagame for gamers; 2) Zigma, an anime and gaming-inspired IP as an NFT collection; 3) Azul, a cross-world AI companion; 4) Zoltan, tailored for game publishers. Infrastructure initiatives such as the Zentry-SDK, a Social &amp; Interest Graph, and an Identity Layer are anticipated to be deployed progressively between 2024 and mid-2025. In the forthcoming year, Zentry’s Web3 game studio and publisher Maxion is poised to unveil an additional four game titles.</p><h3>4. Tokenomics</h3><p>On April 25, 2024, Zentry announced that GuildFi’s $GF token is migrating to $ZENT. $GF tokens will be converted to $ZENT tokens at a conversion rate of 1:10 (i.e., 1 $GF = 10 $ZENT). $ZENT serves a multi-faceted role within the Zentry ecosystem, encompassing the following applications: 1) Governance: $ZENT empowers holders with governance rights to engage in pivotal decision-making processes within the Zentry Universe, enabling them to vote on proposed amendments and policies; 2) In-world Utilities: $ZENT facilitates spending for content, progression, and features, and as Zentry expands, it will offer even more ways for holders to engage and enrich their experience; 3) Holder Privileges: $ZENT holders enjoy tiered benefits, including priority access to exclusive features, reward multipliers, and co-creation opportunities; 4) Restaking Benefits: $ZENT holders can infuse their tokens to earn a share of the Vault Drop pool.</p><p>In accordance with the $GF token distribution scheme, an extrapolation of the $ZENT distribution can be undertaken:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FqjSqmpHdP2kmIojC6CSeg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 4–1 $ZENT Token Distribution</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/451/1*iXIAEWZs_360Dyp5cVyfIw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–1 $ZENT Token Distribution</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The $ZENT token release schedule is analogous to that of $GF, as depicted in Figure 4–2. Nevertheless, in actual practice, it is plausible that a subset of users has not yet converted their $GF tokens for $ZENT. Consequently, the extant circulating supply of $ZENT may fall short of the anticipated figures.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*wjpTR0Sosg4dIhbcmbfwPQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–2 $ZENT Token Release Schedule</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Zentry’s Treasury Holdings wallets are displayed in Figure 4–3 below:</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/683/1*CudO_iQMmw4rQaHfVZV2rQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–3 Zentry’s Treasury Holdings Wallets</strong></figcaption></figure><h3>5. Sector Analysis</h3><p>Zentry belongs to the <strong>Gaming Infrastructure</strong> category under the GameFi sector.</p><h4><strong>5.1 GameFi Sector Overview</strong></h4><p>According to the data analytics fed by Footprint<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a>, the current market cap of GameFi tokens approximates $27.6 billion. Over the past three months, Bitcoin’s significant upward momentum has been accompanied by a modest increase in the market capitalization of GameFi tokens. However, this growth has lagged behind the magnitude of Bitcoin’s ascent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/567/1*JNqAHn8qoVuZPm-tLvNJ1A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–1 Market Cap: GameFi Tokens vs. BTC (Source: Footprint)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The current GameFi landscape features over 3,500 blockchain games. The lion’s share of these blockchain games resides within the BNB Chain, Ethereum, and Polygon, collectively comprising almost 60% of the total share. Of these blockchain games, ~700 maintain active status, with the BNB Chain representing about 26.7%, Polygon 12.2%, and Ethereum 20.6%.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*1pmi6GLeKjPF9o63HLh1Gg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–2 Games by Chain &amp; Games Shared by Chain (Source: Footprint)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>There is an observable upward trend in the number of active users engaging with blockchain games. At present, the number of daily active users in the GameFi sector stands at approximately 6.53 million, reflecting a marked improvement from the active user metrics observed in 2023 and exceeding the previous peak of 2 million daily active users seen during the prior bull runs in the sector. This notable increase in daily active users commenced in earnest towards the end of 2023, signifying an augmented interest and engagement within the GameFi sector.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*c8fm7cq2_neJOZDpjJBbnA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–3 Active Users &amp; Chg% (Source: Footprint)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Nevertheless, it becomes apparent that the GameFi sector in the current market cycle has yet to experience a full resurgence regarding its transaction volume. Although there has been an uptick in volume compared to 2023, it remains notably distant from the levels observed in 2022, with the monthly transaction volume currently hovering around the $1,200M mark. Furthermore, the number of monthly transactions in 2024 notably lags behind that of 2023, with the present monthly transaction count standing at 3.13 million, in stark contrast to the approximate 7 million recorded throughout 2023.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*Yj1mVu6HyGI_EMsx5r_0hQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–4 Monthly Transactions &amp; Volume (Source: Footprint)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In summary, while there has been a modest recuperation in the market cap of GameFi tokens, coupled with an augmented level of scrutiny and a marginal expansion in active user count, there exists a notable dearth in capital inflow towards the GameFi sector at present. This is underscored by the substantial disparity in transaction volume when compared to the preceding round of bull runs.</p><h4><strong>5.2 The History of Crypto Gaming Guilds</strong></h4><p>The evolution of crypto gaming guilds was predominantly catalyzed during the last bull market. At that juncture, the meteoric ascent of blockchain games exemplified by Axie Infinity instigated a frenzy among crypto gaming enthusiasts, advocating for the amalgamation of gaming endeavors with financial remuneration, or the Play-to-Earn (P2E) model. However, the pursuit of P2E opportunities often imposed prohibitive fiscal prerequisites, prompting the advent of gaming guilds heralding scholarship programs as their selling points. These venerable gaming guilds facilitated the renting of in-game assets via a judiciously structured scholarship program while providing gaming tutorials to expedite players’ acclimation to the virtual realms. Functioning as intermediaries, gaming guilds not only facilitated the monetization of P2E gameplay for crypto gamers but also engendered a burgeoning population of gamers and catalyzed a surge in demand for virtual assets.</p><p>Following the culmination of the last bull market, the trajectory of crypto gaming guilds has evinced the following defining hallmarks:</p><p><strong>1) Inherent Constraints Of Scholarship Program: </strong>At its core, the scholarship paradigm primarily caters to P2E-focused gamers within the GameFi sphere. While this community initially contributes to the augmentation of GameFi fervor and the proliferation of communal dynamics during the embryonic phases of blockchain gaming, its prolonged presence engenders palpable peril to the structural integrity of GameFi tokenomics. This predicament is particularly accentuated within the contemporary domain of blockchain gaming, where the maturation of tokenomics models remains nascent, and instances of the “death spiral” phenomenon pervade. The substantial influx of P2E-focused players can inflict severe damage on the game itself, hastening the collapse of the GameFi tokenomics.</p><p>Consequently, the sustainability of the scholarship program within individual GameFi ecosystems becomes inherently untenable. Gaming guilds must perpetually seek out profitable GameFi ventures to sustain revenue. However, during the bear market, the paucity of such projects exacerbates the vicissitudes in the revenue streams of gaming guilds, rendering them susceptible to pronounced cyclical perturbations.</p><p>Additionally, the existing scholarship paradigm adopted by most crypto gaming guilds is exclusively applicable to P2E-centric blockchain games. Yet, the P2E gaming landscape has universally entered a state of development stagnation. In the long term, the fate of the P2E model in the blockchain gaming domain remains indeterminate, oscillating precariously between perpetuation and extinction.</p><p>Moreover, as the GameFi sector navigates towards incremental maturation, a burgeoning cadre of GameFi platforms is embarking upon the implementation of bespoke renting systems, exemplified by the likes of Starshark and Pegaxy. This advent of renting systems presents a formidable impedance to the traditional scholarship program by encroaching upon its coveted user demographic. Should a greater number of players opt to embrace renting systems over revenue-sharing scholarship programs, such as those employed by Yield Guild Games, the revenue streams of gaming guilds are poised for precipitous declines.</p><p><strong>2) Regional Imbalance of Guild Distribution:</strong> At present, the majority of prominent gaming guilds are predominantly based in Southeast Asia. Notably, Yield Guild Games, the absolute leader of the GameFi sector, boasts a demographic predominantly hailing from the Philippines; GuildFi, dedicated to advancing the concept of Guild-As-a-Service (Gaas), has its principal community base in Thailand; and it’s worth highlighting the ascendance of Ancient8, Vietnam’s largest crypto gaming guild, as a pivotal force within the sector.</p><p><strong>3) A Paradigm Shift towards Institutionalization and Multifarious Diversification: </strong>Following the triumph of the scholarship program, crypto gaming guilds have embarked on a quest to fervently seek to identify the next “Axie Infinity” archetype. Consequently, contemporary gaming guilds actively partake in the NFT pre-sales hosted by early-stage, promising blockchain games, diligently amassing a corpus of NFTs in preparation for forthcoming P2F opportunities after game launches. Beyond NFT procurement, gaming guilds frequently transition into the role of early investors in myriad blockchain games, metamorphosing from NFT rental agencies and community enclaves into formidable investment institutions within the GameFi domain.</p><p>In another direction from institutionalization, gaming guilds are embarking upon a multifaceted journey of diversification, endeavoring to explore alternative developmental avenues. These include offering data, community, and traffic services to partnered projects, as well as furnishing systematic management services for their scholarship and revenue frameworks. This evolution signifies a progression towards a multifarious diversification of businesses and services.</p><p><strong>4) Significant Reliance on GameFi Sector Development:</strong> The revenue streams of crypto game guilds, whether predicated on commissions derived from the scholarship program or on the return on investments in GameFi ventures, are intricately intertwined with the progression of the GameFi sector. Currently in its nascent stages, this sector possesses substantial potential for future growth. For gaming guilds, the ability to evolve in tandem with this sector and to ensure that their investment portfolios remain consistently profitable is of paramount importance.</p><p>In the previous bull market, gaming guilds capitalized on the meteoric rise of the GameFi frenzy, securing considerable financing and revenue. Nevertheless, the limitations inherent in the scholarship paradigm gradually surfaced, and the GameFi sector has encountered systemic challenges in its trajectory of holistic progression, encompassing a dearth of real players, the ascendancy of the finance nature over the playability nature, and the tenuous sustainability of the P2E model. Consequently, the developmental trajectory of gaming guilds has become circumscribed. Confronted with this situation, myriad gaming guild projects have embarked upon trajectories of project transition.</p><p>Foremost among them was Merit Circle, which, as early as 2022, initiated a projection transition towards a DAO model extending its tentacles to various sectors. In April 2023, Merit Circle inaugurated the concept of the game-specific blockchain Beam, culminating in Beam’s debut in August of the same year. Following suit, GuildFi introduced Project Z at the end of 2023, heralding its rebranding as Zentry in April 2024. Conversely, Yield Guild Games, the leader of gaming guilds, was the latest among the major gaming guilds to commence its project transition. Yield Guilds Games disclosed its transition from a gaming guild to a protocol layer in March 2024, aspiring to metamorphose into a bastion of gaming infrastructure.</p><p>In this market cycle, major gaming guilds have collectively embarked upon a journey of diversified business model transitions, with forays into gaming infrastructure characterizing their product expansions. In response to the aforementioned adversities, a suite of strategic interventions has been orchestrated:</p><p><strong>1) Multifaceted Diversification:</strong> In recognition of the inherent constraints of the scholarship paradigm, both Merit Circle and Zentry have embarked upon trajectories of strategic business diversification, extending their reach to an array of sectors. Since March 2022, Merit Circle has been navigating towards a DAO model, emblematic of its proclivity towards a multifaceted operational landscape. This paradigm shift encompasses strategic investments in primary GameFi markets, collaborative ventures in game development, and the establishment of robust infrastructures and NFT marketplaces, orchestrating an incursion into the intricate fabrics of midstream and upstream domains in the GameFi industry chain. Meanwhile, Zentry has metamorphosed from a gaming guild formerly known as GuildFi to now a Metagame Layer, with its strategic blueprint outlining expansive forays into SocialFi, GameFi, NFT, and AI, among other sectors.</p><p>The strategic rebranding undertaken by Merit Circle and Zentry bears a resemblance, transitioning from a gaming guild that opts for the scholarship paradigm to an entity extending its tentacles into various sectors in the crypto space. This transition seeks to delve into the intricate fabrics of the GameFi industry and bolster the competitive prowess and existential longevity of their respective ventures. Nevertheless, this strategy necessitates substantial technical prowess and management acumen Typically, projects engaging with infrastructure development entail prolonged R&amp;D periods, and their future profitability is fraught with uncertainty. <strong>At present, only Merit Circle has embarked upon the nascent stages of its project transition despite Beam having launched and put into operations for merely six months. In contrast, both Zentry and Yield Guild Games have but recently initiated their rebranding endeavors, necessitating additional time for maturation.</strong></p><p><strong>2) Enhanced Regional Guild Distribution: </strong>During their nascent stages, gaming guilds were predominantly populated by denizens of Southeast Asia, thus imbuing these endeavors with a pronounced regional flavor. However, subsequent to their project transition, these ventures have transcended mere diversification of operational dimensions, catalyzing a refinement in their regional identity. Consider, for instance, the project transition of Merit Circle, traversing realms of investment, project incubation, and infrastructure. These domains have orchestrated a profound shift in the demographic, redirecting focus from mere crypto gamers to project owners and game developers. This has not only amplified the project’s global resonance but has also catalyzed interest and engagement predominantly gracing the echelons of developed countries in Europe and North America. Likewise, Zentry, post-rebranding, steers its business arc towards a panoptic vista of entertainment, thereby fostering interest and engagement, diverse not merely in roles but also geographical origination.</p><p><strong>3) Capitalization &amp; Institutionalization: </strong>In actuality, the capitalization and institutionalization of gaming guilds in the last market cycle have endowed these projects with a spectrum of revenue streams, fostering enduring resilience amidst the bear market vicissitudes. The likes of Merit Circle, Yield Guild Games, and GuildFi have since expanded their revenue channels through investments, node operation, and treasury management, among other avenues. With the waning relevance of the scholarship paradigm, these ventures might find these avenues their sole source of income. Nonetheless, projects such as Merit Circle and Yield Guild Games have previously ventured capital into myriad unpromising blockchain games, and the ROI on these ventures has fallen short of projections amid the overall lackluster performance of the GameFi sector. Conversely, Zentry’s investment portfolio gravitates towards stablecoins, Ethereum liquid staking, and node operation, thus espousing a more cautious fiscal strategy, with the fiscal health of the Zentry Treasury Vault being comparably robust at the moment.</p><p><strong>4) Mitigating Reliance on the GameFi Sector: </strong>The last market cycle witnessed gaming guilds steeped in a heavy dependence on the development of the GameFi sector. Ergo, the primary driver behind the ongoing strategic rebranding of gaming guilds is to mitigate such dependence, transitioning instead towards a pan-entertainment paradigm and comprehensive industry continuum. Notably, Zentry’s recent project transition has transcended the confines of GameFi, spanning sectors such as SocialFi, AI, and Infrastructure. The diversification of business sectors facilitates the mitigation of reliance on the GameFi sector development while simultaneously unlocking a dimension of potential growth opportunities. Nonetheless, gaming guilds cannot entirely dissociate from the developmental trajectory of GameFi, as their previously amassed player base and project resources constitute substantial advantages for prospective advancement.</p><p>Overall, the prominent gaming guilds in this cycle aspire to surmount past obstacles and pursue new avenues of growth through strategic rebranding. While the transition towards an infrastructure layer and engagement with every fabric of the GameFi industry chain present considerable challenges, posing technical and managerial pressure on its project development and business operations, Zentry’s recent foray into strategic rebranding represents a commendable endeavor, particularly in light of the current suboptimal trajectory of the GameFi sector. This endeavor offers a grandiloquent narrative and unlocks an immense dimension of growth opportunities in the time to come. Henceforth, continuous observation of Zentry’s product delivery and ecosystem ecosystem building remains imperative.</p><h4><strong>5.3 Layer 0</strong></h4><p>Amidst the evolution of public chain ecosystems, there has been a marked enhancement in the user base, user requirements, the diversity of applications, and the degree of specialization. Concurrently, the demands on network performance and blockchain specialization have escalated. Within this context, several Layer0 (L0) solutions have come to the fore. From a more expansive narrative vantage point, the Metagame Layer by Zentry can be perceived as a Layer0 solution in the GameFi sector.</p><p>At present, the majority of L0 solutions in the crypto space are well-integrated in nature, with established projects such as Cosmos and Polkadot serving as prime examples. These projects primarily delve into the realms of blockchain interoperability, scalability, message passing, and asset bridging, with a paucity of offerings directed towards entertainment, gaming, and end-user applications. Distinct from traditional L0 projects, Zentry manifests a heightened level of specialization in the domains of entertainment and gaming, thereby constituting a niche L0 solution within the GameFi sector.</p><p>In the realm of infrastructure, Zentry avails developers of a suite of tools including the Zentry SDK, Zentry ID, and Zentry Chain. Furthermore, this year, Zentry has partnered with Beam to incubate and support the Sophon ecosystem, an endeavor tailored specifically for entertainment and gaming to meet the demands for higher throughput and expedited transaction processing. Moreover, Zentry has envisioned an expansive IP universe, spanning a diverse array of products, including anime and gaming, atop its foundational infrastructure. Building upon this foundation, Zentry’s focus extends to consumer-oriented applications, which encompass a multitude of sectors such as SocialFi, GameFi, and NFTs. In sum, when juxtaposed with other ecosystems, Zentry delineates a more lucid and supportive strategy tailored for gaming and entertainment. During the GuildFi era, the project amassed a significant user base and potential user demographic within the Web3 gaming and SocialFi spheres. Should Zentry execute prudent planning and traffic redirection, it is poised to infuse its ecosystem with renewed vigor and dynamism in the ensuing periods.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/636/1*j0TnlR1JsCcMWm1RAS7zYg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–5 Zentry Product Architecture</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Zentry’s strategic planning encompasses not merely the interconnection of multiple platforms and ecosystems but also the linkage between the tangible and virtual realms, thereby amplifying the technical complexity of interoperability. Furthermore, the diversity and volume of the data involved are substantially greater, imposing elevated demands on network performance. At present, Zentry remains in its nascent stages, with pertinent technical documentation and whitepaper yet to be unveiled. Consequently, several critical points warrant close scrutiny in the forthcoming period:</p><p>1) The methodologies by which interoperability and scalability are realized;</p><p>2) The security and transparency of interactions;</p><p>3) The authentic user experience and customizability of the Zentry SDK;</p><p>4) The dispersion of liquidity across multiple ecosystems.</p><p>In summation, while Zentry faces considerable technical challenges, it will unlock a great margin of growth opportunities if successfully overcoming these challenges. As of now, no rival project exists within the Layer0 category of the GameFi sector, endowing Zentry with a distinct first-mover advantage through its strategic rebranding.</p><h3>6. Risks</h3><p><strong>Sector Risk: </strong>Despite indications of a resurgence currently in the GameFi sector, the influx of external capital and overall market vitality remain markedly inferior to those observed in the preceding bull market.</p><p><strong>Competitive Risk:</strong> Following its recent project transition, Zentry remains in an embryonic phase, with its forthcoming infrastructure likely to encounter formidable competitive pressures.</p><h4>—<strong> END</strong> —</h4><p>Website <a href="https://first.vip/"><em>First.VIP</em></a> | Twitter<em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61"><em>@firstvip61</em></a> | Wechat: gofirstvip</p><pre>Reference<br>Official Zentry Website, https://zentry.com/<br>Zentry Medium, https://medium.com/zentry</pre><pre>[1] Source: CoinGecko (as of December 18, 2024)<br>[2] https://medium.com/zentry/unlocking-zentrys-treasury-vault-6505b8516e3a<br>[3] https://x.com/jarindr/status/1791139263368847387<br>[4] https://medium.com/guildfi/guildfi-2023-recap-and-gearing-up-for-2024-c2576bc896d2<br>[5] https://medium.com/zentry/introducing-zentry-the-gaming-superlayer-60ab6c9f8c90<br>[6] https://www.footprint.network/research/gamefi/game-overview/game-market?series_date-79421=past90days</pre><p><strong>— Investment Risks and Disclaimers —</strong></p><blockquote><em>This report is only for information purposes and should not be relied upon when making any investment decision. Please do not make any investment decisions based on this report. First.vip and authors of this report are not responsible for any results of your investment.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>This report is drafted from the date indicated. As market or economic conditions may change from time to time subsequently, the content of this report may not necessarily reflect such changes. The graphs, charts and other visual aids are provided for information purposes solely, none of which should be relied upon as investment decisions. First.vip will not assist anyone in making investment decisions and no graph, chart or other visual aid can capture all of the factors and variables required to make such decisions.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Some of the statements in this report may contain First.vip’s future assumptions and other forward-looking views. With known &amp; unknown risks and uncertainties, actual results, performance or events may differ materially from the views and assumptions expressed in the statements.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Any speculations, forecasts and estimates contained in this report are speculative and are based on certain assumptions. These forward-looking statements may prove to be inaccurate and may be affected by inaccurate assumptions, known/unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors, most of which are beyond our control. It can be anticipated that some or all of these forward-looking assumptions will not be realized or will differ materially from actual results.</em></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=13588dcd0247" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[First.VIP Project Analysis: Public blockchain Aptos]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/first-vip-project-analysis-public-blockchain-aptos-84b0a1114896?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/84b0a1114896</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Nov 2024 12:35:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-14T13:14:19.260Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kzAhpk3Wyb-qNcBFiENTNg.png" /></figure><p>Founded in late 2021, <a href="https://aptosfoundation.org/">Aptos</a> is a public blockchain inheriting many of the technical innovations made by Meta in the blockchain space and is backed by an impressive lineup of investors. Since the launch of the mainnet in October 2022, Aptos has demonstrated its efficiency and reliability, establishing itself as a leader among the next-generation public blockchains. With its prosperous and engaging ecosystem, it may gain more significant growth in the future.</p><p><strong>Executive Summary</strong></p><p>Founded in late 2021, Aptos is a public blockchain.</p><p>From a team perspective, Aptos has deep ties to Diem (formerly known as Libra) and Novi, which were developed by Meta. After Meta faced regulatory pressure and was forced to abandon its blockchain endeavors, several core members of the original dev team chose to build Aptos. <strong>In a sense, Aptos can be seen as one of the heirs to Meta’s blockchain legacy. As one of the leading software development companies, Meta has a strong talent pool with excellent academic backgrounds and reliable technical development capabilities.</strong> With the continuous growth of Aptos, its development will be backed by a solid team.</p><p>In terms of funding, as of November 7, 2024, Aptos has gone through six funding rounds. Before its mainnet launch in 2022, Aptos secured $350M in funding at a valuation of $2.75B. Afterward, it closed four strategic funding rounds with undisclosed amounts. Its investors are top-tier crypto VCs such as Binance Labs, Dragonfly Capital, a16z, Multicoin Capital, Circle, and Coinbase Ventures. The latest funding round was closed on September 19, 2024. Therefore, it can be expected that the Aptos team is now rather well-funded.</p><p>From a product and technical perspective, Aptos aims to build a scalable, secure, reliable, and upgradable smart contract platform. The decentralized foundation for a secure, scalable, and upgradeable Web3 environment that Aptos uses are the Move programming language, the DiemBFT consensus algorithm, the Block-STM parallel execution engine, and an efficient node synchronization scheme. While focusing on scalability and security, Aptos has made some trade-offs in terms of decentralization. Although the number of nodes in the network is small and the entry barriers are high, posing the centralization risk, <strong>the performance advantages of Aptos are apparent.</strong> After its mainnet launch, Aptos processed more than 12,000 transactions per second and more than 300M transactions per day at its peak, with a latency of less than 1 second. Besides, it has never encountered delays or network downtime, which proves its efficiency and reliability in processing transactions. Additionally, in terms of transaction costs, Aptos has significantly reduced gas fees for users, thus offering more space for the development of DeFi and other sectors in its ecosystem.</p><p>From a project development perspective, since its inception, Aptos has been gaining momentum, especially since Q3 2024. The number of active addresses has been steadily increasing with strong user retention, and the tx count has seen significant growth. On August 15, 2024, it set a record for processing over 300M transactions in a single day, with peak transaction throughput approaching 13,000 TPS, further validating the impressive performance of the Aptos blockchain. Aptos has been sparing no effort to cultivate its ecosystem. At present, protocols running in the Aptos ecosystem cover different verticals such as DeFi, gaming, and social. At the same time, Aptos is actively maintaining strong relationships with Web2 enterprises and regulatory bodies, with collaborations with companies like Microsoft, Google, Alibaba, Amazon, South Korea’s Lotte, and SKT. Additionally, at the end of October 2024, the native USDT (Tether) officially went live on Aptos, which is expected to bring more liquidity to Aptos and unlock greater potential of the Aptos ecosystem.</p><p>From a tokenomics perspective, $APT plays a dual role in the Aptos ecosystem, providing both utility and governance capabilities. Users can use $APT tokens to participate in network consensus, vote on proposals, pay for the gas fees, and drive the growth of the Aptos ecosystem. At present, most of the initial total supply of $APT is held by the Aptos Foundation and is designated for ecosystem-related items, such as grants, incentives, and other community growth initiatives. This allocation manifests Aptos’ strong focus on the long-term growth of its ecosystem.</p><p>From the perspective of the sector, the public blockchain sector where Aptos runs has gone through several bull and bear runs, as well as the evolution of blockchain technology. The demand and understanding for public blockchains have become increasingly clear. It is evident that the consensus algorithm and performance of a public blockchain are the roots that allow its ecosystem to thrive. The prosperity of the ecosystem is the fruit that grows from these roots. To be qualified as an outstanding public blockchain, the underlying technology must be robust enough to yield good results, and at the same time, these results must be remarkable enough to gain market recognition. Currently, Aptos has laid a solid foundation for cultivating a thriving ecosystem with its well-designed technical architecture, and it has nourished the seeds through its well-designed tokenomics model and ecosystem growth plans. It now waits for the subsequent growth of ecosystem projects to produce impressive results. From a competitive landscape perspective, Ethereum and Solana are still in the top tier. Aptos, along with Sui, are orders of magnitude behind them in many respects (except for network performance). Aptos and Sui were both founded by former Meta employees and developed using the same programming language (Move), with comparable network performance. However, the two blockchains have different focuses in ecosystem development, which has caused some divergence in market perception. We believe that as Aptos continues to nurture its ecosystem and as more ecosystem projects gain traction, Aptos is expected to gain more significant growth.</p><p>1. <strong>Overview</strong></p><p><strong>1.1 Project Profile</strong></p><p>Founded in late 2021, Aptos is a public blockchain inheriting many of the technical innovations made by Meta in the blockchain space and is backed by an impressive lineup of investors. Since the launch of its mainnet in October 2022, Aptos has demonstrated its efficiency and reliability, establishing itself as a leader among the next-generation public blockchains. With its prosperous and engaging ecosystem, Aptos may gain more significant growth in the future.</p><p><strong>1.2 Basic Information<em> [1]</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7SStf5_cKPITJuC5YGlzhw.png" /></figure><p>2. <strong>Project Details</strong></p><p><strong>2.1 Team</strong></p><p>The dev team behind Aptos, Aptos Labs, is primarily located in California, North America, with employees spread across the globe. The total number of employees is estimated to be over 100, with LinkedIn showing 225 employees. According to the Aptos whitepaper, before the mainnet launch in 2022, over 350 developers had been involved in the development of Aptos. According to the official website<em>[2]</em>, Aptos’ leadership team currently includes 16 founding members and 12 department heads. Some core members are introduced as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*SXzD1zQ5pmmuwE5xcEBN6g.png" /></figure><p><strong>Mo Shaikh — Co-Founder &amp; CEO:</strong> Mo holds a BS in Accounting from Hunter College and an MBA from the University of Rochester. After graduating, he worked in real estate and private equity analysis at firms like KPMG, Blackstone, and Boston Consulting Group. In 2017, Mo founded Meridio (a blockchain-based platform for investing in and trading fractional shares of real estate with liquidity), where he also served as CEO. In May 2020, Mo joined Novi (Meta) as a Strategic Partner. In December 2021, Mo co-founded Aptos and has served as CEO ever since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*z0eiP0CmxI4Go9CCegoVIw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Avery Ching — Co-Founder &amp; CTO:</strong> Avery holds a BSc and PhD in Computer Engineering from Northwestern University. After graduating, he served as the Principal Software Engineer at Yahoo, Facebook, and Novi Financial. With over 20 years of experience in technical development, Avery has a wealth of expertise in both the traditional Internet industry and the blockchain industry. At the end of 2021, after Novi’s pilot program concluded, Avery chose to co-found Aptos with Mo and has served as CTO ever since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*qB4Vr6Kx8DoPkOGjyh23RA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Alin Tomescu — Head of Cryptography:</strong> Alin holds a BS in Computer Science from Stony Brook University and both a Master’s and Ph.D. in Computer Science from MIT. He served as a Teaching Assistant and Research Assistant at MIT’s Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science for over six years. In 2020, Alin left MIT to join VMware as a Research Scientist. In February 2022, Alin joined Aptos as a founding member and has served as the Head of Cryptography ever since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*9G5tC7MnYS3deeMUcgoYrw.png" /></figure><p><strong>David Wolinsky — Head Architect:</strong> David holds a PhD in Computer Engineering from the University of Florida. After graduating, he spent four years as a Lecturer at Yale University. In 2015, David joined Facebook as a Software Engineer and later became the Tech Lead of Web3 at Meta (Novi). In February 2022, after Novi’s pilot program concluded, David chose to join Aptos as a founding member and has served as Head Architect ever since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*Awowc7-xFvZhFyNurvi9Ow.png" /></figure><p><strong>Neil Harounian — Head of Ecosystem:</strong> Neil holds a BSc in Finance from NYU Stern School of Business. After graduating, he worked in investment banking and later joined several crypto VCs. In January 2022, Neil joined Aptos as a founding member and has served as Head of Ecosystem ever since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*oVcJCT3uOpJBrdDod-YMvg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Sasha Spiegelman — Head of Research:</strong> Sasha holds a Bachelor’s degree in Electrical Engineering from the Technion — Israel Institute of Technology and a PhD in Distributed Systems. After graduating, he joined VMware, where he worked on blockchain research. In 2020, Sasha joined Novi Financial as a Senior Blockchain Researcher. In February 2022, after Novi’s pilot program concluded, Sasha chose to join Aptos as a founding member and has served as Head of Research ever since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*xnDFnmqY-iD90VYY-Jsd_Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>Zekun Li — Head of Blockchain:</strong> Zekun holds a BSc in Computer Science from Fudan University and an MS in Computer Science from the University of Southern California. After graduating, he joined Instagram as a Software Engineer and later joined Meta (Diem) in 2018, where he worked as a Staff Software Engineer. In February 2022, after Diem and Novi’s pilot program concluded, Zekun chose to join Aptos as a founding member and has served as Head of Blockchain ever since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/113/1*_pbLs9RJIzUbn0TYI9bBWw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Asha Dakshinamoorthy — Product Lead:</strong> Asha holds a BBA in Quantitative Finance from Texas McCombs School of Business. After graduation, she worked as a Consultant at Deloitte. In 2017, Asha joined ConsenSys, the dev team behind MetaMask, where she served as Product Lead. In 2019, Asha joined AlphaPoint, a white-label software company, as Head of Product. Later that year, she transitioned to Templum Inc., a security token service provider, also as Head of Product. In June 2022, Asha joined Aptos Labs as Product Lead and has held the position ever since.</p><p>It can be seen that Aptos has deep ties to Diem (formerly known as Libra) and Novi, which were developed by Meta. After Meta faced regulatory pressure and was forced to abandon its blockchain endeavors, several core members of the original dev team chose to build Aptos. In a sense, Aptos can be seen as one of the heirs to Meta’s blockchain legacy. As one of the leading software development companies, Meta has a strong talent pool with excellent academic backgrounds and reliable technical development capabilities. With the continuous growth of Aptos, its development will be backed by a solid team.</p><p><strong>2.2 Fundraising</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/928/1*gdP0OfUy3lkAnRqELbG6ow.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 2–1 Aptos Funding Insights</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>As of November 7, 2024, Aptos has gone through six funding rounds. Before its mainnet launch in 2022, Aptos secured $350M in funding at a valuation of $2.75B. Afterward, it closed four strategic funding rounds with undisclosed amounts. Its investors are top-tier crypto VCs such as Binance Labs, Dragonfly Capital, a16z, Multicoin Capital, Circle, and Coinbase Ventures. The latest funding round was closed on September 19, 2024. Therefore, it can be expected that the Aptos team is now rather well-funded.</strong></p><p><strong>2.3 Code</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*056MpprzumS4XfkrGJm9xQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–1 # of Commits Created in Aptos’ Repositories</strong>[3]</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*Q7OXxsCAzFrfZOA-bm3Z3Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–2 # of Code Authors for Aptos</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Aptos’ source code is open-source on GitHub. Figures 2–1 and 2–2 show that there are up to ~70 active code authors (~50 now) at peak who have created a total of 40,233 commits to Aptos’ repositories. The dev activity surged in Q3 2022, Q3 2023, and Q2 2024 when the team was focused on the dev work of introducing the incentivized testnet &amp; the mainnet, the Move language &amp; a new on-chain identity solution, and a new fungible asset standard &amp; the Raptr consensus protocol, respectively. Overall, Aptos has maintained a stable development pace, without any significant signs of development stagnation. Therefore, it is expected that Aptos will continue to demonstrate strong technical development potential in the future.</strong></p><p><strong>2.4 Product &amp; Technology</strong></p><p>Aptos is a blockchain aiming to bring mainstream adoption to decentralized ecosystems by offering scalability, safety, reliability, and upgradability. The Aptos blockchain aims to bring mainstream adoption to Web3 and solve real-world problems with a decentralized ecosystem of applications. In line with its principles and vision, Aptos has made unique designs in the consensus algorithm, smart contracts, network security, performance, and decentralization.</p><p>2.4.1 <strong>Vision &amp; Technical Architecture</strong></p><p>Aptos aims to build a scalable, secure, reliable, and upgradable smart contract platform, implicitly addressing the “Blockchain Trilemma.” The “Blockchain Trilemma” was introduced by Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin, who believes that the blockchain trilemma consists of three attributes: decentralization, security, and scalability. The main idea of the blockchain trilemma is that by using so-called simple methods, a blockchain cannot be simultaneously decentralized, secure, and scalable.</p><p>For example, Ethereum and Bitcoin sacrifice decentralization in favor of scalability and security. Next-gen public blockchains such as Solana prioritize scalability while compromising on decentralization and security. In contrast, according to the Aptos whitepaper and its blog posts, it is designed with scalability, safety, reliability, and upgradeability, without specifically mentioning decentralization. Therefore, it implies that Aptos has chosen to prioritize scalability and performance at the expense of decentralization.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HmCdMFjxYt9KQKBSvBJmBg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 2–2 Aptos: Goals &amp; Technologies</strong></figcaption></figure><p>According to the Aptos whitepaper, the Aptos blockchain is built on the following core design principles: <br>1) Fast and secure execution along with simple auditability and mechanical analyzability via a new smart contract programming language, Move. <br>2) Extremely high throughput and low latency through a batched, pipelined, and parallelized approach to transaction processing. <br>3) Novel parallel transaction processing that efficiently supports atomicity with arbitrarily complex transactions through Block-STM. <br>4) Optimizations for performance and decentralization via rapid, stake-weight validator set rotation and reputation tracking. <br>5) Upgradeability and configurability as first-class design principles to embrace new use cases and the latest technology. <br>6) Modular designs that enable rigorous component-level testing along with appropriate threat modeling and seamless deployment.</p><p>We will then dive into the core technologies used by Aptos.</p><p>2.4.2 <strong>The Move Language</strong></p><p>In 2021 the Diem Engineering Team’s article <em>“Why Build Move,[4]”</em> the use of programming languages in blockchain is discussed. In any blockchain, the role of the chosen language is to provide accurate representations of state and transition. State: 1) What is the value of an asset? 2) where is the asset stored? 3) who has ownership of the asset?; Transition: 1) who can create/destroy/move assets? 2) what state transitions are allowed? 3) what are the rules for transferring assets?</p><p>Additionally, due to the inherent characteristics of blockchains, for any programming language to be suitable for blockchain use, it must be deterministic, hermetic, and metered: <br>Deterministic: A blockchain uses a state machine replication (SMR) approach, thus the programming language must ensure determinism to make sure that validators can maintain state consistency. In the case of C, for example, the lack of memory safety is untenable, while a language like Java allows for operations with undefined semantics — making either of these unsuitable for safely expressing state transitions for the SMR approach. <br>Hermetic: Due to the necessity of maintaining fidelity on the blockchain, it is vital that the inputs to transaction execution are strictly limited. In the case of a blockchain, programs must only be allowed to accept inputs from the global state or the current transaction. Any reference to an external source jeopardizes the ability to form consensus by presenting the possibility for returning differing values for different validators. <br>Metered: To ensure that the network continues to process transactions, each state transition must be assigned an upper bound on resource consumption. Without defined bounds, the network may stall in the presence of long-running or even non-terminating transactions. This is the impetus for the gas function in many blockchains, which limits the runtime of each individual program and terminates if the limit is breached. This metering functionality is almost never a built-in component of general-purpose languages, thus a specialized programming language is required to provide the metering functionality for blockchains.</p><p>To make the execution of the transactions on the Aptos blockchain retain the attributes of deterministic, hermetic, and metered, and ensure the security and reliability of the blockchain network, the Move language, inspired by languages like Rust, introduced the concepts of “resources” and “modules” in its design.</p><p>Move is a language using a “resource-based” approach. “Resources” in Move are essentially objects that have certain attributes, and any assets in Move can be represented by or stored within resource. Besides, Move emphasizes resource scarcity. Move modules define the lifetime, storage, and access pattern of every resource. This ensures that resources like Coin are not produced without appropriate credentials, cannot be double spent, and do not disappear.</p><p>Modules are libraries that define struct types along with functions that operate on these types and are defined by the account address and module name. A module in Move may either be a library or a program that can create, store, or transfer assets. Move also emphasizes “access control”. There are two types of modules in Move: private modules and public modules. Move ensures that only public module functions may be accessed by other modules. In contrast, private modules cannot be accessed by other modules and can only be mutated within the module that defines it. By distinguishing between private and public modules, the security of Move is further enhanced. In addition, modules will be grouped into a package located at the same address. An owner of this address publishes the package as a whole on-chain, including the bytecode and package metadata. The package metadata determines whether a package can be upgraded or is immutable. The owner can add new functions and resources to the package without changing the existing functions and resources, thus enhancing the programmability and upgradability of smart contracts. In addition to modules, Move also has a type of program called scripts, which accepts any number of arguments but returns nothing. Their primary purpose is to invoke public modules to make a specific global state update.</p><p>Through the design of resources and modules, Move not only makes the execution of the transactions on the Aptos blockchain retain the attributes of deterministic, hermetic, and metered but also enables efficient and secure transaction execution. Additionally, it facilitates the future updating of code.</p><p>2.4.3 <strong>DiemBFT</strong></p><p>A consensus mechanism (also known as a consensus protocol or consensus algorithm) refers to the mechanism that ensures the collaborative operation and secure record-keeping in a distributed system. It is the mechanism used to sort and confirm blocks (transactions) among a set of validators.</p><p>Different blockchains may adopt different consensus algorithms based on their goals. Bitcoin, for example, uses the Proof of Work (PoW) mechanism, where miners compete to solve a complex mathematical problem, and the first one to solve it gets to add a new block to the blockchain and receives a reward. PoW is the consensus algorithm that underpins decentralization, while the process consumes considerable computational power and energy, making it costly and resource-intensive. On the other hand, the early Proof of Stake (PoS) mechanism operates by adjusting mining difficulty based on the % and duration of tokens staked by a node operator, thus speeding up the process of finding the random number. PoS is less decentralized than PoW. However, by avoiding the computational puzzle, the PoS mechanism reduces energy consumption significantly and speeds up the transaction verification process.</p><p>Today, the Aptos blockchain leverages DiemBFT, a BFT consensus protocol. DiemBFT is a production-grade, low-latency BFT engine developed by Aptos. It is a variant of the HotStuff consensus protocol that was designed for Diem. To improve efficiency, the BFT consensus mechanism only requires a specific minimum number of nodes to function effectively. The formula to determine the minimum number of nodes needed to achieve BFT is: n ≥ 3f + 1, where f represents the maximum number of faulty nodes the system can tolerate. For example, if N = 3f+1, 1/3 of the nodes could suffer from byzantine failure, and the entire system will still operate with no issues.</p><p>Over the past few years, DiemBFT has gone through four iterations, with the following improvements: <br>1) Consensus in the common case only requires two network rounds (with round trip times typically less than 300 milliseconds worldwide). <br>2) Dynamically adjusts to faulty validators through a leader reputation mechanism. The on-chain leader reputation mechanism promotes validators that have successfully committed blocks in a window and demotes validators that are not participating.</p><p>In a BFT consensus mechanism, a leader rotation mechanism is typically used, where an elected leader proposes a block of transactions. However, many leader rotation mechanisms do not account for the leader’s state, meaning that a faulty node could be selected as the leader. If too many faulty nodes are chosen as leaders, it can negatively impact the speed and efficiency of the blockchain network.</p><p>Therefore, DiemBFT v4 introduced State Machine Replication (SMR), which takes into account the liveness and effectiveness of the nodes. Liveness means tracking the activity of nodes by analyzing the data on-chain and electing leaders from them. In the event that a leader is attacked, compromised, or becomes inactive due to network disruptions, the reputation system ensures that a new leader can be quickly and reliably selected.</p><p>Furthermore, the Aptos protocol clearly separates liveness from safety. No matter if the network is unreachable or the non-safety core is compromised in some way, the chain will not fork as long as the BFT honesty guarantees are upheld. The safety of its consensus protocol has been both audited and formally verified.</p><p>Currently, Aptos is working on the next-generation consensus protocol, and in September 2024, Alexander Spiegelman, Head of Research at Aptos Labs, announced that Aptos will soon be launching a next-gen BFT consensus protocol, Raptr, which combines the main Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) techniques to unlock high TPS while preserving Aptos’ optimal theoretical latency. It is expected that Raptr will be deployed in two phases.</p><p>2.4.4 <strong>Block-STM</strong></p><p>When we describe the performance of public blockchains, the two commonly used metrics are Throughput and Finality. Throughput refers to the number of transactions a blockchain can process per second, while Finality refers to the time measured from when a client creates and submits a transaction until another party confirms the transaction is committed.</p><p>As of November 12, 2024, after its mainnet launch, Aptos processed more than 12,000 transactions per second and more than 300M transactions per day at its peak, with a latency of less than 1 second. Besides, it has never encountered delays or network downtime. Theoretically, Aptos can achieve up to 160,000 TPS.</p><p>These impressive statistics are a direct result of Aptos’ superior transaction processing architecture: <br><strong>1) Decoupling the consensus protocol from the execution pipeline:</strong> The consensus protocol agrees on a proposed transaction ordering. In a separate protocol and outside of the critical path, validators execute the transactions and have an agreement on the final transaction ordering and execution results. By eliminating the co-dependencies that come with combining consensus and execution, higher throughput and lower latency are achieved. Aptos Labs is focusing its efforts on this decoupling for their next protocol iteration, which is on track to be integrated into testnet later this year.</p><p><strong>2) Block-STM Parallel Engine:</strong> Aptos uses a highly efficient, multi-threaded, in-memory parallel execution engine called Block-STM. STM stands for Software Transactional Memory, a new approach to engineering that supports flexible transactional programming of synchronization procedures.</p><p>On Ethereum, the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) is single-threaded, with only one core to process transactions. When there is a surge in network activity, a large number of transactions can pile up, and it takes longer to process them. To address this issue, next-gen blockchains like Solana have adopted multi-threaded parallel processing. Aptos also uses a multi-threaded parallel execution engine to process transactions. According to the current tests, under low contention, Block-STM achieves 16x speedup over sequential execution with 32 threads.</p><p>Aptos implemented Block-STM in safe Rust in the Aptos open-source codebase, relying on Rayon, Dashmap, and ArcSwap crates for concurrency. Besides, it evaluated the system with non-trivial peer-to-peer Move transactions. In Figure 2–3 below, every block contains 10k transactions and the number of accounts determines the level of conflicts and contention. Figure 2–3 shows that the transaction throughput varies with different thread counts and account numbers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*9A20k56HrOB5YtmBgtY9nw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–3 Block-STM Performance with Different Contention Levels</strong>[5]</figcaption></figure><p>As seen in the figure above, the transaction throughput for sequential execution is not affected by the number of threads, with a consistent throughput of 10,000 TPS. In contrast, Block-STM achieves 4x, 11x, and 16x speedup over sequential execution with 4, 16, and 32 threads, respectively. It can be seen that the parallel engine significantly boosts transaction speed. As the number of users increases, the advantage of using 32 threads becomes more apparent, enabling a higher transaction throughput.</p><p><strong>3) Optimized Authenticated Data Structures: </strong>One challenge is that while authenticating the ledger state (e.g., account balances, smart contracts, etc.), in-memory Merkle trees are efficient at small scale. However, writing large Merkle trees to persistent storage is a bottleneck. Aptos is designing its authenticated data structures to be database-friendly by exploring higher branching factors, access pattern-optimized caching, and careful versioning.</p><p>2.4.5 <strong>State Synchronization</strong></p><p>State sync is the protocol that allows non-validator peers to distribute, verify, and persist this blockchain data and ensures that all peers in the ecosystem are synchronized. Most blockchains today are structured hierarchically, with a set of active validators at the heart of the network. The validators grow the blockchain by executing transactions, producing blocks, and achieving consensus. The rest of the peers in the network (e.g., fullnodes and clients) replicate the blockchain data produced by the validators (e.g., blocks and transactions).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*zfg_KAwLGragxPUcab6k7w.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–4 Aptos Node Networks</strong>[6]</figcaption></figure><p>Figure 2–4 above shows that the validators are interconnected, and in addition to them, there are fullnodes, clients, and other non-validator nodes responsible for various functions. In this process, state synchronization plays a crucial role in the sound operation of the blockchain. <br><strong>1) Data correctness: </strong>State sync is responsible for verifying the correctness of all blockchain data during synchronization. This prevents malicious peers and adversaries in the network from modifying, censoring, or fabricating transaction data and presenting it as valid. <br><strong>2) User experience: </strong>When new transactions are executed by validators, state sync is responsible for propagating the data to peers and clients. If state sync is slow or unreliable, peers will perceive long transaction processing delays, artificially inflating the time to finality. <br><strong>3) Relationship with consensus: </strong>Validators that crash or fall behind the rest of the validator set rely on state sync to bring them back up to speed. If state sync cannot process transactions as quickly as they are executed by consensus, crashed validators will never be able to recover. Moreover, new validators will never be able to start participating in consensus and fullnodes will never be able to sync to the latest state. <br><strong>4) Implications on decentralization: </strong>Having a quick, efficient, and scalable state sync protocol allows for: (i) faster rotations of an active validator set, as validators can move in and out of consensus more freely; (ii) more potential validators to choose from in the network; (iii) more fullnodes to come online quickly and without having to wait long periods of time; and (iv) lower resource requirements, increasing heterogeneity. All of these factors increase decentralization in the network and help to scale the blockchain in size and geography.</p><p>To enable more efficient state synchronization, Aptos adopts the following measures: <br>1) Supporting a spectrum of different state synchronization protocols that tradeoff CPU and network bandwidth. Nodes can select the most suitable protocol based on their needs, encouraging more nodes to join the Aptos network. <br>2) In order to support inexpensive fullnodes, Aptos has a protocol that can sync transactions and their executed results signed by a quorum of validators that allows a node to skip the computation at the cost of higher networking throughput and directly update the ledger state from the executed results. <br>3) Instead of having to download a chain of blocks to get to the latest ledger as most blockchains do, a client can use the top-level transaction accumulator to get the latest committed transaction. This also allows for inexpensive pruning of previous transactions and ledger history if desired.</p><p>Through the implementation of state sync, Aptos has improved throughput by 10x and latency by 3x. Besides, peers can validate and synchronize over 10k TPS with sub-second latency in Aptos today.</p><p>2.4.6 <strong>Security Design</strong></p><p>The Aptos blockchain aims to bring mainstream adoption to Web3 and solve real-world problems with a decentralized ecosystem of applications. To reach billions of Internet users, the Web3 user experience must be safe. Given the frequent occurrences of fraud in the blockchain space, measures need to be implemented to increase the security of user transactions:</p><p><strong>1) Transaction Viability Protection</strong></p><p>Signing a transaction means that the signer authorizes the transaction to be committed and executed by the blockchain. Occasionally, users may sign transactions unintentionally or without fully considering all the ways in which their transactions might be manipulated. To mitigate this risk, the Aptos blockchain constrains the viability of every transaction and protects the signer from unbounded validity. There are currently three different protections provided by the Aptos blockchain — the sender’s sequence number, a transaction expiration time, and a designated chain identifier.</p><p>A transaction’s sequence number can only be committed exactly once for each sender’s account. As a result, senders can observe that if the current account sequence number is ≥ the sequence number of a transaction t, then either t has already been committed or t will never be committed (as the sequence number used by t has already been consumed by another transaction).</p><p>The blockchain time advances with high precision and frequency (typically sub-second), If the blockchain time exceeds the expiration time of transaction t, then similarly, either t has already been committed or t will never be committed.</p><p>Every transaction has a designated chain identifier to prevent malicious entities from replaying transactions between different blockchain environments.</p><p><strong>2) Key Rotation &amp; Hybrid Models of Custody</strong></p><p>Aptos accounts support key rotation, an important feature that can help reduce the risks associated with private key compromise, long-range attacks, and future advances that might break existing cryptographic algorithms. In addition, Aptos accounts are also flexible enough to enable new hybrid models of custody. In one such model, a user can delegate the ability to rotate the account’s private key to one or more custodians and other trusted entities. A Move module can then define a policy that empowers these trusted entities to rotate the key under specific circumstances. For example, the entities might be represented by a k-out-of-n multi-sig key held by many trusted parties and offer key recovery services to prevent user key loss. Moreover, while many wallets support various key recovery schemes, such as backing up private keys to cloud infrastructure, multi-party computation, and social recovery, they are typically implemented without blockchain support. In contrast, supporting key management functionality at the Aptos blockchain layer provides full transparency of all key-related operations.</p><p><strong>3) Pre-Signing Transaction Transparency</strong></p><p>Today, wallets provide very little transparency about the transactions they sign. As a result, users are often easily tricked into signing malicious transactions that may steal funds and have devastating consequences.</p><p>To address this, the Aptos ecosystem provides services for transaction pre-execution: a precautionary measure that describes to users (in human-readable form) the outcomes of their transactions prior to signing. In addition, Aptos also enables wallets to dictate constraints on transactions during execution. Violating these constraints will result in the transactions being aborted, to further protect users from malicious applications or social engineering attacks.</p><p>With these security designs, Aptos is able to provide users with a safer environment for using the blockchain.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>From a team perspective, Aptos has deep ties to Diem (formerly known as Libra) and Novi, which were developed by Meta. After Meta faced regulatory pressure and was forced to abandon its blockchain endeavors, several core members of the original dev team chose to build Aptos. In a sense, Aptos can be seen as one of the heirs to Meta’s blockchain legacy. As one of the leading software development companies, Meta has a strong talent pool with excellent academic backgrounds and reliable technical development capabilities. With the continuous growth of Aptos, its development will be backed by a solid team.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of funding, as of November 7, 2024, Aptos has gone through six funding rounds. Before its mainnet launch in 2022, Aptos secured $350M in funding at a valuation of $2.75B. Afterward, it closed four strategic funding rounds with undisclosed amounts. Its investors are top-tier crypto VCs such as Binance Labs, Dragonfly Capital, a16z, Multicoin Capital, Circle, and Coinbase Ventures. The latest funding round was closed on September 19, 2024. Therefore, it can be expected that the Aptos team is now rather well-funded.</strong></p><p><strong>From a product and technical perspective, Aptos aims to build a scalable, secure, reliable, and upgradable smart contract platform. The decentralized foundation for a secure, scalable, and upgradeable Web3 environment that Aptos uses are the Move programming language, the DiemBFT consensus algorithm, the Block-STM parallel execution engine, and an efficient node synchronization scheme. While focusing on scalability and security, Aptos has made some trade-offs in terms of decentralization. Although the number of nodes in the network is small and the entry barriers are high, posing the centralization risk, the performance advantages of Aptos are apparent. After its mainnet launch, Aptos processed more than 12,000 transactions per second and more than 300M transactions per day at its peak, with a latency of less than 1 second. Besides, it has never encountered delays or network downtime, which proves its efficiency and reliability in processing transactions. Additionally, in terms of transaction costs, Aptos has significantly reduced gas fees for users, thus offering more space for the development of DeFi and other sectors in its ecosystem.</strong></p><p>3. <strong>Development Trajectory</strong></p><p><strong>3.1 Accomplished Milestones</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qMJ4g6PEtZsnb5FD1Dc3GQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–1 Milestones Accomplished by Aptos</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>3.2 Current State</strong></p><p>3.2.1 <strong>Key Metrics</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*tnCqTQUZvLbCCic8YVLxvA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–1 Aptos Daily Tx Count</strong>[7]</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*JX0te9I_XCt8ISycAfWLZw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–2 Aptos Daily Active Addresses</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*gvUn7zjkeHYPz3NIxlmpBA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–3 Aptos Key Metrics — 1</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*PD2yRCz-Rk_nyW9V3qccXw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–4 Aptos Key Metrics — 2</strong></figcaption></figure><p>According to Dune Analytics, as of 10:00 AM on November 11, 2024, there are 33,671,757 active addresses and 1,909,381,503 txs on Aptos. Over the past 30 days, the number of active addresses sat at 8,184,230, accounting for ~24.30% of the total address count. Since the beginning of 2024, the number of active addresses has amounted to 25,084,036, which makes up ~74.50% of the total. This data shows that Aptos has a strong user retention rate, indicating good user engagement and active participation within its ecosystem. Aptos has shown consistent growth in network usage since its mainnet launch in October 2022. Notably, in Q4 2024, there has been a significant surge in daily active addresses, with a similar upward trend observed in the tx count. In addition, due to the popularity gained by some ecosystem projects such as Tapos (a blockchain-based game), Aptos saw two peaks in the tx count in 2024 — one in May and another in August. On August 15, 2024, the daily tx count reached 326,972,362 txs, setting a new record for the highest daily tx count on Layer 1s ever recorded by Aptos. The peak throughput was close to 13,000 TPS. <strong>Despite this massive surge in transactions, the Aptos network did not experience any delays in producing blocks,</strong> demonstrating its exceptional network performance in handling a large number of transactions in parallel.</p><p>3.2.2 <strong>Ecosystem</strong></p><p>As a Layer 1 blockchain, Aptos benefits from excellent network performance and has nurtured an engaging ecosystem.</p><p>As of November 11, 2024, there are 192 projects built on Aptos, covering 16 verticals, of which there are 49 DeFi projects, 48 infrastructure projects, 28 crypto wallets, 25 gaming projects, 18 social projects, and 16 NFT tooling projects, including several high-profile projects that have garnered significant market attention. Based on the number of projects across these sectors, the Aptos ecosystem is still in the early to mid stages of development, with a current focus on building infrastructure. As its ecosystem grows, more projects and use cases are expected to emerge, and the ecosystem will have greater potential for growth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/857/1*1v6Gn-l-xL4b2pAOUgqa7Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–2 Aptos Ecosystem Landscape</strong>[8]</figcaption></figure><p>Aptos has been actively advancing collaborations with and providing support to its ecosystem projects. It has provided new versions of the Move language, a new code compiler, a code formatter, a development suite, a new Aptos token standard, a new Wallet Adapter Standard, and more, thus helping dev teams in the Aptos ecosystem better leverage their unique advantages.</p><p>Additionally, the Aptos Foundation introduced the Aptos Grant Program and the Aptos Code Collision Hackathon. There are now four categories of the Grant Program that can be applied for: “Original Ideas”, “Idea Speakers”, “Gasless Transactions”, and “Strengthening Defense”, helping dev teams turn and monetize their ideas into blockchain projects from scratch. As of November 2024, there are more than 200 grant recipients, such as Thala Labs, Pontem Wallet, Merkle Trade, Mercato, Wapal, and Aptos Arena.</p><p>In addition to actively nurturing the ecosystem, thanks to the abundant resources earned by its core members (who are former Meta employees), Aptos has also been maintaining strong partnerships with Internet companies and Web2 enterprises around the world such as Amazon, Alibaba, Google, NBCUniversal, Microsoft, Brevan Howard, SK Telecom, Boston Consulting Group, and South Korea’s Lotte. Additionally, Aptos has fostered good relationships with U.S. regulatory bodies. In June 2024, the CFTC named Aptos co-founder and CEO Mo Shaikh to its subcommittee on digital assets.</p><p>3.2.3 <strong>Community</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gAwLlKu7z7CYHkMNsPyJgQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–3 Aptos Community</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>As of November 11, 2024, Aptos owns a large community, where its Twitter followers are rather active in liking and replying to tweets posted by Aptos; the number of members on Discord servers and Telegram is also large, and their discussions mainly revolve around the ecosystem growth and the $APT tokenomics model. The Aptos Forum also sees high levels of activity, with discussions centering around the current state of the Aptos protocol, upcoming technical upgrades, and its future direction of development.</strong></p><p><strong>3.3 Roadmap</strong></p><p>Aptos has not yet disclosed a detailed roadmap. According to responses from its team members in the community, there are no plans to release a roadmap in the near future. However, they will continue to provide real-time updates on the protocol development through community channels.</p><p>At present, the dev work of the Aptos blockchain has been largely completed. Moving forward, the focus will likely shift toward network upgrades. The primary direction for the future growth of Aptos will probably center around growing the ecosystem and strengthening partnerships.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>From a project development perspective, since its inception, Aptos has been gaining momentum, especially since Q3 2024. The number of active addresses has been steadily increasing with strong user retention, and the tx count has seen significant growth. On August 15, 2024, it set a record for processing over 300M transactions in a single day, with peak transaction throughput approaching 13,000 TPS, further validating the impressive performance of the Aptos blockchain. Aptos has been sparing no effort to cultivate its ecosystem. At present, protocols running in the Aptos ecosystem cover different verticals such as DeFi, gaming, and social. At the same time, Aptos is actively maintaining strong relationships with Web2 enterprises and regulatory bodies, with collaborations with companies like Microsoft, Google, Alibaba, Amazon, South Korea’s Lotte, and SKT. Additionally, at the end of October 2024, the native USDT (Tether) officially went live on Aptos, which is expected to bring more liquidity to Aptos and unlock greater potential of the Aptos ecosystem.</strong></p><p>4. <strong>Tokenomics</strong></p><p><strong>4.1 Supply</strong></p><p>4.1.1 <strong>$APT Allocation </strong><em>[9]</em></p><p>The native token of Aptos is $APT, which is an inflationary token and was launched on the mainnet in October 2022. The initial total supply is 1,000,000,000. Initially, the annual inflation rate for $APT is 7%, with this rate gradually decreasing over time until it reaches a minimum of 3.25% after 50 years. These newly minted tokens will be used to reward the current and future node operators and $APT stakers to maintain the sound operation of the network. As of November 11, 2024, the total supply of $APT stands at 1,125,360,719, of which 520,057,351 has been put into circulation, accounting for 46.2% of the total supply.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G0jxzn0kkcuZvdH-TH0nvA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 4–1 Initial Token Distribution</strong>[10]</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Distribution Schedule for the Community and the Aptos Foundation</strong></p><p>The Community (51.02%) and Foundation (16.5%) allocations are designated for ecosystem-related items, such as grants, incentives, and other community growth initiatives. Some of the tokens have been allocated to projects building on the Aptos protocol and will be granted upon the completion of certain milestones. A majority of these tokens (410,217,359.767) are held by the Aptos Foundation, and a smaller portion (100,000,000) are held by Aptos Labs. These tokens are anticipated to be distributed over a ten-year period: <br>1) 125,000,000 $APT available initially to support ecosystem projects, grants, and other community growth initiatives now and in the future for the Community category;<br>2) 5,000,000 $APT available initially to support the Aptos Foundation initiatives for the Foundation category;<br>3) 1/120 of the remaining tokens for the community and the Foundation are anticipated to unlock each month for the next 10 years.</p><p><strong>Distribution Schedule for Core Contributors and Investors</strong></p><p>The Core Contributor (19%) and Investor (13.48%) allocations are subject to a four-year lock-up schedule, excluding staking rewards if applicable, from mainnet launch that unlocks according to the following schedule: <br>1) No $APT available for the first twelve months;<br>2) 3/48ths of such tokens unlock on the 13th month after mainnet launch and each month thereafter up to and including the 18th month;<br>3) 1/48th of the tokens unlock each month thereafter beginning on the 19th month after mainnet launch so that all such tokens are unlocked on the four-year anniversary of mainnet launch.</p><p>It should be noted that according to the estimated $APT supply schedule, both unlocked (i.e., tokens that are available for distribution) and locked (i.e., not available for distribution) tokens can be staked. Hence, most of the tokens on the network are staked.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*PSD5s_d1RBIlhEa6_ubLgw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–1 Estimated $APT Supply Schedule</strong></figcaption></figure><p>According to Figure 4–1, more than 50% of the initial total supply goes to the community. However, most of the tokens are now still held by the Foundation to drive the growth of the ecosystem. Besides, since both locked and unlocked tokens can be staked, and $APT stakers can earn a portion of newly minted $APT tokens, the % of the community allocation to the total $APT supply will gradually decrease. Overall, $APT tokens are now distributed in a rather centralized manner (mostly held by the Foundation), which could pose challenges for the future participation of smaller token holders in the ecosystem.</p><p><strong>4.2 Utility</strong></p><p>$APT, as the utility and governance token of Aptos, has the following use cases: <br>1) The Aptos network operates on a PoS consensus algorithm where validators need to have a minimum required amount of staked $APT tokens to participate in transaction validation and earn block rewards. <br>2) As a participant in the Aptos ecosystem, once users have staked $APT tokens, they can vote on governance proposals, which include decisions related to network parameters, marketing strategies, ecosystem growth, and technical upgrades. <br>3) Users must pay transaction fees in $APT when executing transactions on the Aptos blockchain. <br>4) For rewarding ecosystem participants and community contributors.</p><p>4.2.1 <strong>Node Networks</strong></p><p>The Aptos consensus mechanism uses PoS combined with a unique BFT consensus protocol for validators to collectively process transactions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*F0_U7hnfrJnEIUxEAajq7A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–2 Aptos Node Map</strong>[11]</figcaption></figure><p>The Aptos blockchain distinguishes two types of fullnodes: validator nodes and fullnodes. While both types of nodes share the same code, they differ in their roles and responsibilities. Fullnodes replicate the entire state of the blockchain by synchronizing with upstream participants, e.g., other fullnodes or validator nodes. Besides, they connect directly to validator nodes and offer scalability alongside DDoS mitigation. However, fullnodes do not participate in consensus, and any third-party blockchain explorers, wallets, exchanges, and dApps can run a local fullnode. When a transaction is submitted to the Aptos blockchain, validator nodes run a distributed consensus protocol, execute the transaction, and store the transaction and the execution results on the blockchain. Users must stake the required minimum amount to join the validator set. Moreover, they can only stake up to the maximum stake amount. The current required minimum for staking is 1M $APT tokens and the maximum is 50M $APT tokens.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*iWbRT4qXhIz93VSm57bjMA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–3 $APT Staking Stats</strong></figcaption></figure><p>As of November 12, 2024, there are 150 validator nodes in the Aptos network, running in 47 cities in 23 countries. They have staked 909,136,163 $APT, accounting for 80.78% of the initial total supply. It can be seen that there is now still a small number of validator nodes in Aptos, which may introduce centralization risks. However, they are operated around the globe, somewhat ensuring the security of the Aptos network.</p><p>4.2.2 <strong>Delegated Staking</strong></p><p>In April 2023, Aptos introduced delegated staking, which is a new feature allowing users to reap staking rewards without requiring them to serve as validators for the blockchain’s transactions. Besides, it also enhances the decentralization and security of the network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/1*BVGyoNTUCwM37pcn5ugR4A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–4 Delegated Staking</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Participants can stake $APT in the Aptos Explorer. After opening the Validators interface (in Figure 4–4), users can click on “Delegation Nodes” to browse a dropdown list showing the active validator nodes and their detailed information such as the delegated amount, # of delegators, commission, and rewards earned. If $APT token holders click the button to the left of a staking pool address, they will be able to view more detailed information about the staking pool. This includes the compound rewards (which represent the APR that accrue on staked $APT), the amount of rewards earned by this staking pool so far, rewards performance, etc. At present, the compound rewards earned on the stakes to different staking pools are ~7% APR. $APT holders can make an informed decision about which validator node to delegate their tokens to. Once they have chosen the preferred validator, they can click the “Stake” button on the right side to proceed with the delegated staking process.</p><p>Additionally, users can choose from several staking interfaces created by Aptos’ partners (e.g., wallets, staking portals). In this way, they can receive liquid staking tokens (LSTs) to perform more DeFi operations. Aptos’ partners who have created staking interfaces include Tortuga, Ditto, Thala, and others.</p><p>4.2.3 <strong>Governance</strong></p><p>By staking $APT, Aptos community members can create and vote on proposals.</p><p>At present, to create a proposal, the required minimum for staking is 1M $APT tokens. Besides, the stake has to be locked up for 14 days and after the end of the 3-day voting period. However, any participant who stakes $APT can vote on governance proposals. Once $APT tokens are staked, the staker will receive a voter key, which represents the voting power of the token holder and can be used for voting, stored by a custodian, or delegated to other voters. Voting power is calculated based on the current epoch’s active stake of the proposer or voter’s backing stake pool.</p><p>On Aptos, a public blockchain, there are not many protocol decisions that can be made through governance and voting, mostly revolving around technical upgrades. The following describes the scope of the proposals for the Aptos on-chain governance: <br>1) Changes to the blockchain parameters, for example, the epoch duration, and the minimum required and maximum allowed validator stake. <br>2) Changes to the core blockchain code.<br>3) Upgrades to the Aptos Framework modules for fixing bugs or for adding or enhancing the Aptos blockchain functionality. <br>4) Deploying new framework modules.</p><p>As of November 12, 2024, a total of 116 governance proposals have been submitted on Aptos Governance, of which 1 proposal is currently in the voting phase, 7 proposals failed because there were not enough votes, 1 proposal was rejected (AIP-52: Automated Account Creation for Sponsored Transactions was initially rejected but was later re-submitted and passed), and 107 proposals have been passed and executed on-chain.</p><p>So far, some of the most important governance proposals on Aptos<em>[12]</em> include increasing block gas limit to account for concurrency increase, enabling the multisig prologue check, reducing stake lockup duration &amp; governance voting duration, enabling yearly reward rate decrease, enabling fee payer, enabling delegated staking, implementing decrease in staking rewards, enabling keyless accounts, and changing the storage format. It can be seen that most of the governance proposals revolve around improving the network performance of Aptos, enriching the use cases of the Aptos ecosystem, and lowering the thresholds to submit/vote on proposals.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>From a tokenomics perspective, $APT plays a dual role in the Aptos ecosystem, providing both utility and governance capabilities. Users can use $APT tokens to participate in network consensus, vote on proposals, pay for the gas fees, and drive the growth of the Aptos ecosystem. At present, most of the initial total supply of $APT is held by the Aptos Foundation and is designated for ecosystem-related items, such as grants, incentives, and other community growth initiatives. This allocation manifests Aptos’ strong focus on the long-term growth of its ecosystem.</strong></p><p>5. <strong>Sector Analysis</strong></p><p><strong>5.1 Sector Overview</strong></p><p>Aptos runs in the public blockchain sector.</p><p>Public blockchains are a core piece of infrastructure in the crypto space and boast considerable room for growth. Therefore, an increasing number of users and funds have been flowing into the sector, making the competition among public blockchains very intense. The development of public blockchains can be roughly divided into three phases: <br>Phase 1 (2008–2013): Following the release of the Bitcoin whitepaper by Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin gained significant popularity, leading to the emergence of many “altcoins” aiming to improve on Bitcoin and the first-gen public blockchains represented by Bitcoin. <br>Phase 2 (2014–2017): Ethereum was the first blockchain to support smart contracts and dApps with Turing completeness. Besides, the launch of NFT projects such as CryptoKitties allowed users to witness the use case of blockchain. Ethereum, with its strong first-mover advantage, has cultivated a prosperous ecosystem, with other public blockchains emerging during this period such as NEO, QTUM, and EOS.<br>Phase 3 (2018 — Present): Various consensus algorithms and validation mechanisms have facilitated the launch of many high-performance, low-cost public blockchains, represented by BSC, Solana, and Avalanche.</p><p><strong>In the current phase, three main trends have emerged: 1) the continuous launch of different Ethereum Layer 2 solutions; 2) the development of monolithic blockchains leveraging new technologies, such as Aptos and Sui; 3) the development of blockchains tailored for meeting specific needs, such as privacy-focused blockchains and modular blockchains.</strong></p><p>The fundamentals of a public blockchain can be analyzed from the following three perspectives: <br>1) Consensus Algorithm, which determines whether or not a blockchain is decentralized and censorship-resistant. The consensus algorithm used by a public blockchain can determine its network security. Users tend to lock their funds on blockchains they perceive to be the most secure, such as Bitcoin or Ethereum instead of Bitcoin Cash or Litecoin. How to design an efficient consensus algorithm is a significant challenge for most public blockchains, and their consensus mechanisms also determine their core competitiveness. For example, although EOS was once as popular as Ethereum, it eventually lost favor due to severe centralization among its nodes. <br>2) Technical Architecture, i.e., whether a public blockchain is able to achieve high performance. This revolves around the Blockchain Trilemma, which was proposed by Vitalik Buterin, the Founder of Ethereum. He believes that the blockchain trilemma consists of three attributes: decentralization, security, and scalability. The main idea of the blockchain trilemma is that by using so-called simple methods, a blockchain cannot be simultaneously decentralized, secure, and scalable. For example, Ethereum and Bitcoin sacrifice decentralization in favor of scalability and security. Next-gen public blockchains such as Solana prioritize scalability while compromising on decentralization and security. <br>3) Ecosystem Prosperity, whether a public blockchain can onboard a large number of developers to build and deploy protocols on the blockchain, thus nurturing an engaging ecosystem. Public blockchains are just a piece of infrastructure and need a large number of developers, ecosystem projects, and users to help them capture value. The more developers there are and the more prosperous the ecosystem, the larger the number of active users, leading to a significant increase in marginal returns.</p><p>The public blockchain sector has gone through several bull and bear runs, as well as the evolution of blockchain technology. The demand and understanding for public blockchains have become increasingly clear. It is evident that the consensus algorithm and performance of a public blockchain are the roots that allow its ecosystem to thrive. The prosperity of the ecosystem is the fruit that grows from these roots. To be qualified as an outstanding public blockchain, the underlying technology must be robust enough to yield good results, and at the same time, these results must be remarkable enough to gain market recognition.</p><p><strong>5.2 Competitor Comparison</strong></p><p>The competition among public blockchains is now rather fierce. At present, the position of Ethereum in the public blockchain sector remains unshakable. Besides, it strives to improve network efficiency and scalability through the ETH 2.0 upgrade and Layer 2 solutions. Among next-gen blockchains, Solana and BSC have also onboarded many talented dev teams to their ecosystems and boasted a large user base with their respective advantages. Additionally, among blockchains developed by former Meta employees, Sui launched its mainnet in May 2023, and Linera is still under active development. In contrast, Aptos has gained a first-mover advantage to nurture a robust ecosystem by launching its mainnet earlier than Sui and Linera.</p><p>To provide a more comprehensive view of the competitive landscape of the public blockchain sector where Aptos operates, the following three blockchains will be selected for comparison:</p><p>Ethereum: A decentralized, open-source blockchain platform allowing developers to build and deploy dApps and smart contracts. Founded in 2014, Ethereum introduced the concepts of Turing completeness and smart contracts, bringing programmability to the blockchain and enabling the development of dApps on the platform. With the largest number of developers and the most prosperous ecosystem, Ethereum is likely to remain a formidable competitor for any blockchain in the short term. Using Ethereum as a benchmark helps us better evaluate the fundamentals and the competitive landscape of Aptos in the public blockchain sector.</p><p>Solana: A high-performance blockchain that can achieve a peak throughput of up to 100,000 TPS. Founded in 2017, Solana has developed 8 key technologies: Proof of History (PoH), TowerBFT (a PoH-optimized version of PBFT), Turbine (a block propagation protocol), Gulf Stream, Sealevel (parallel smart contracts run-time), Pipelining, Cloudbreak (Horizontally-Scaled Accounts Database), and Archivers (distributed ledger storage). By leveraging these technologies, Solana significantly improves the network performance and gains a strong competitive edge over other next-gen blockchains. After recovering from a challenging bear market, Solana has proven its resilience and value, positioning it as a strong contender with the potential to rival Ethereum. Solana is one of the key competitors to Aptos.</p><p>Sui: The dev team behind Sui (Mysten Labs) was founded by key executives from Meta’s Novi Research and lead architects of the Diem blockchain and Move programming language. Besides, it is backed up by a strong lineup of VCs such as a16z, FTX Ventures, and Jump Crypto. Sui aims to build a high-performance and low-latency blockchain. Sui and Aptos share great similarities in many regards. For example, both Aptos and Sui utilize Move, a Rust-based programming language, for parallel execution. Therefore, Sui is the most direct competitor to Aptos.</p><p>In Table 5–1, we will compare these blockchains from different perspectives (e.g., team, funding, consensus, network performance, node distribution, ecosystem, and FDV).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r7HqR_-5YvGZtqrb7s7kmQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Table 5–1 Competitor Comparison</strong></figcaption></figure><p>From a team &amp; funding perspective, despite the significant technological innovations and potential of next-gen blockchains like Aptos and Sui, Ethereum and Solana have substantial advantages as early pioneers in the blockchain space.</p><p>Ethereum currently underperforms Solana, Aptos, and Sui in terms of network performance, which has been a persistent and acute issue in recent years. However, through the development of its Layer 2 solutions and sharding designs, Ethereum has gradually been able to meet the demands of some projects. Yet, it still falls far short of meeting the needs of dApps that need to process a large number of transactions with low latency. When comparing Solana with Sui and Aptos, there is no clear performance advantage among them. However, Aptos currently outshines in terms of the stability of processing many transactions in parallel, which will contribute to the growth of its ecosystem projects.</p><p>From the perspective of node distribution, after transitioning to a PoS consensus mechanism, Ethereum has seen a surge in the number of validators, with over 1M validators currently in operation, making Ethereum the most decentralized L1 blockchain. In contrast, the number of validators in Solana has significantly dropped. Moreover, the performance of leaders greatly determines whether the consensus can be successfully reached in the network, meaning that if a leader is attacked or goes offline, it could potentially compromise the security of the entire network. Both Aptos and Sui are still in the early stages of development, with a high threshold for onboarding validators, which introduces certain centralization risks.</p><p>From the perspective of the ecosystem landscape, Ethereum and Solana are leading the trends in liquid staking infrastructure and user-oriented dApp ecosystems, respectively. Aptos and Sui, in comparison, still lag significantly behind the former two in terms of ecosystem prosperity. However, when comparing Aptos and Sui, Aptos holds a certain advantage and is now focused on building infrastructure, showing potential for significant growth in the future.</p><p>In terms of FDV, when comparing Aptos and Sui, we believe that the FDV of Aptos may be somewhat undervalued. As the Aptos ecosystem continues to grow and if it can incubate projects that capture significant market attention and create hype, Aptos has significant potential for growth in the future.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>From the perspective of the sector, the public blockchain sector where Aptos runs has gone through several bull and bear runs, as well as the evolution of blockchain technology. The demand and understanding for public blockchains have become increasingly clear. It is evident that the consensus algorithm and performance of a public blockchain are the roots that allow its ecosystem to thrive. The prosperity of the ecosystem is the fruit that grows from these roots. To be qualified as an outstanding public blockchain, the underlying technology must be robust enough to yield good results, and at the same time, these results must be remarkable enough to gain market recognition. Currently, Aptos has laid a solid foundation for cultivating a thriving ecosystem with its well-designed technical architecture, and it has nourished the seeds through its well-designed tokenomics model and ecosystem growth plans. It now waits for the subsequent growth of ecosystem projects to produce impressive results. From a competitive landscape perspective, Ethereum and Solana are still in the top tier. Aptos, along with Sui, are orders of magnitude behind them in many respects (except for network performance). Aptos and Sui were both founded by former Meta employees and developed using the same programming language (Move), with comparable network performance. However, the two blockchains have different focuses in ecosystem development, which has caused some divergence in market perception. We believe that as Aptos continues to nurture its ecosystem and as more ecosystem projects gain traction, Aptos is expected to gain more significant growth.</strong></p><p>6. <strong>Risks</strong></p><p><strong>1) Competition Risk:</strong> Aptos, Sui, and Linera, which are blockchains developed by former Meta employees, share great similarities in terms of the team, technology, and investors. Therefore, the competition among them is fairly intense.</p><p><strong>2) Centralization Risk: </strong>According to the Aptos whitepaper and its blog posts, it is designed with scalability, safety, reliability, and upgradeability, without specifically mentioning decentralization. Therefore, it implies that Aptos has chosen to prioritize scalability and performance at the expense of decentralization.</p><p><strong>3) Steep Learning Curve:</strong> The Move language is a new smart contract programming language, requiring developers to invest time and resources in learning. Moreover, deploying and migrating protocols to Aptos also entails time and cost.</p><p><strong>- Investment Risks and Disclaimers -</strong></p><blockquote><em>This report is only for information purposes and should not be relied upon when making any investment decision. Please do not make any investment decisions based on this report. First.VIP and authors of this report are not responsible for any results of your investment.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>This report is drafted from the date indicated. As market or economic conditions may change from time to time, the content of this report may not necessarily reflect such changes. The graphs, charts, and other visual aids are provided for information purposes solely, none of which should be relied upon as investment decisions. First.VIP will not assist anyone in making investment decisions and no graph, chart, or other visual aid can capture all of the factors and variables required to make such decisions.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Some of the statements in this report may contain First.VIP’s future assumptions and other forward-looking views. With known &amp; unknown risks and uncertainties, actual results, performance, or events may differ materially from the views and assumptions expressed in the statements.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Any speculations, forecasts, and estimates contained in this report are speculative and are based on certain assumptions. These forward-looking statements may prove to be inaccurate and may be affected by inaccurate assumptions, known/unknown risks, uncertainties, and other factors, most of which are beyond our control. It can be anticipated that some or all of these forward-looking assumptions will not be realized or will differ materially from actual results.</em></blockquote><p><strong>References</strong></p><blockquote><em>Aptos Documentation, </em><a href="https://aptos.dev/en">https://aptos.dev/en</a></blockquote><blockquote><em>Aptos Whitepaper,</em> <a href="https://aptos.dev/assets/files/Aptos-Whitepaper-47099b4b907b432f81fc0effd34f3b6a.pdf">https://aptos.dev/assets/files/Aptos-Whitepaper-47099b4b907b432f81fc0effd34f3b6a.pdf</a></blockquote><blockquote><em>Project Analysis — Aptos,</em><a href="https://first.vip/"> First.VIP</a></blockquote><blockquote><em>Aptos Medium,</em> <a href="https://aptoslabs.medium.com/">https://aptoslabs.medium.com/</a></blockquote><p><em>[1] https://</em><a href="http://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/aptos"><em>www.coingecko.com/en/coins/aptos</em></a><em>, data as of November 12, 2024</em></p><p><em>[2] </em><a href="https://aptoslabs.com/team"><em>https://aptoslabs.com/team</em></a></p><p><em>[3] Figures 2–1 and 2–2 were captured from </em><a href="https://cauldron.io/"><em>https://cauldron.io/.</em></a></p><p><em>[4] </em><a href="https://www.diem.com/en-us/blog/why-build-move/"><em>https://www.diem.com/en-us/blog/why-build-move/</em></a></p><p><em>[5]https://medium.com/aptoslabs/block-stm-how-we-execute-over-160k-transactions-per-second-on-the-aptos-blockchain-3b003657e4ba</em></p><p><em>[6] </em><a href="https://aptos.dev/en/network/blockchain/node-networks-sync"><em>https://aptos.dev/en/network/blockchain/node-networks-sync</em></a></p><p><em>[7] </em><a href="https://dune.com/aptos/aptos-chain-metrics-overview"><em>https://dune.com/aptos/aptos-chain-metrics-overview</em></a></p><p><em>[8] </em><a href="https://aptosfoundation.org/ecosystem/projects"><em>https://aptosfoundation.org/ecosystem/projects</em></a></p><p><em>[9] </em><a href="https://aptosfoundation.org/ecosystem/projects"><em>https://aptosfoundation.org/ecosystem/projects</em></a></p><p><em>[10] </em><a href="https://aptosfoundation.org/currents/aptos-tokenomics-overview"><em>https://aptosfoundation.org/currents/aptos-tokenomics-overview</em></a></p><p><em>[11] Figures 4–2, 4–3, and 4–4 were captured from </em><a href="https://explorer.aptoslabs.com/validators?network=mainnet."><em>https://explorer.aptoslabs.com/validators?network=mainnet.</em></a></p><p><em>[12] </em><a href="https://governance.aptosfoundation.org/"><em>https://governance.aptosfoundation.org/</em></a></p><p><em>[13] CoinGecko, data as of November 12, 2024, 3:00 p.m.</em></p><p><strong>— END —</strong></p><p>Website <a href="https://first.vip/">First.VIP</a> | Twitter <a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61">@firstvip61</a> | Wechat: gofirstvip</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=84b0a1114896" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The article has been taken down……]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/first-vip-project-analysis-web3s-liquidity-layer-native-3bd23e89feca?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3bd23e89feca</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Apr 2024 08:52:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-20T15:03:10.818Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3bd23e89feca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[First.VIP Project Analysis: AAA web3 game Illuvium]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/first-vip-project-analysis-aaa-web3-game-illuvium-f1059b43f589?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f1059b43f589</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Apr 2024 10:17:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-08T08:31:53.290Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/0*SK5r1f91qGji_JSl.jpg" /></figure><p>Illuvium is a decentralized gaming world built on Immutable X and features four games with different genres developed using Unreal Engine 5. These four games share a unified worldview and are tailored to various player demographics. These games are interconnected in Illuvium’s game economy, greatly enhancing players’ gaming experiences. The project team is now on a tight schedule to develop the games with well-designed gameplay. The quality of the games in the Illuvium ecosystem has surpassed that of most blockchain games. It is anticipated that games in the Illuvium gaming ecosystem will roll out open beta in 2024. In summary, it is suggested to pay follow-up attention to this project.</p><h4>Executive Summary</h4><p>Illuvium is a decentralized gaming world built on Immutable X and features four games with different genres developed using Unreal Engine 5. These four games share a unified worldview and are tailored to various player demographics. These games are interconnected in Illuvium’s game economy, greatly enhancing players’ gaming experiences.</p><p><strong>In terms of team and fundraising, Illuvium’s dev team boasts sufficient developers who have extensive game development capabilities. Besides, Illuvium just closed a $12 million Series A funding round on March 27, 2024, and the team is now rather well-funded.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of products, Illuvium is a decentralized gaming world built on Immutable X and features four games with different genres. Specifically, Zero is an industrial building game, Overworld is a third-person adventure game, Arena is a competitive auto battler, and Beyond is a competitive collectible card game. In this gaming world, each game features unique gameplay mechanics tailored to different player demographics. However, the games are interconnected through the extraction and utilization of Resources across different games, greatly enhancing players’ gaming experiences. The project team is now on a tight schedule to develop the games. Illuvium has rolled out the open beta version of Zero (Zero Alpha) and Beyond, while Overworld and Arena are still in private beta and are expected to be launched to the public soon. From a longer-term perspective, the design of Illuvium’s gaming world presents significant challenges to the development and operational capabilities of the Illuvium team. Particularly, adjusting the production rate of in-game Resources in Illuvium Beyond and Overworld and striking a balance between P2E and play-for-fun in Illuvium Arena and Beyond are challenges the project team must overcome. Currently, Illuvium has demonstrated its development capabilities, but it still takes time to examine its operational capacity.</strong></p><p><strong>Illuvium is still in the early stages of development with Arena and Overview being in private beta. It still takes time for Illuvium to create a close-looped and engaging gaming world. However, Illuvium has gained great popularity and boasts a sizable community. It is expected that more players will be onboarded to the Illuvium gaming world after Arena and Overview are publicly launched.</strong></p><p><strong>From the perspective of tokenomics, $ILV is the governance token of the Illuvium ecosystem and is used to reward participants and drive the sustainable development of Illuvium. At present, the above-mentioned goals can basically be realized via the $ILV staking mechanism. However, this staking mechanism can only be effective and feasible when Illuvium generates lucrative revenues, and we will further observe and examine the viability of the mechanism over an extended time period.</strong></p><p><strong>Since the end of 2023, the blockchain gaming sector has experienced rapid development, with significant increases in trading volumes and user numbers. Based on data, it is expected that after the current bull run ends, the core user base of the blockchain gaming sector will be at least twice as large as before, which implies that the sector still boasts considerable room for development over a long time. In this bull run, an increasing number of games with different genres and higher quality have been emerging, which contributes to the rapid growth of the player base in the blockchain gaming sector. However, currently, many blockchain games still opt for the P2E mechanics to drive their growth with few innovations being made. Illuvium stands out as one of the few gaming projects innovating at the underlying logic of blockchain gaming. It no longer relies on monotonous gameplay to attract users but instead aims to design an effective game economy to interconnect multiple games in its ecosystem. Such a gaming ecosystem is expected to be more sustainable and vigorous than other decentralized gaming ecosystems featuring limited and repetitive gameplay.</strong></p><p><strong>In summary, it is suggested to pay follow-up attention to this project.</strong></p><p><em>Note: The final rating of [Approved]/[Rejected] by First.VIP is the result of a comprehensive analysis of the current fundamentals in accordance with project evaluation framework, rather than a prediction of the future price of the project token. There are many factors that affect token prices, and project fundamentals are not the only factor. Therefore, you should not assume that the project’s token price will definitely fall just because First.VIP assigns the rating of [Rejected] to the project. In addition, the development of blockchain projects is dynamic. Projects that we have judged as [Rejected] will likely be adjusted to [Approved] if their fundamentals change significantly and positively, and vice versa, projects that we have judged as [Approved] may be adjusted to [Rejected] if their fundamentals change significantly and viciously, and we will accordingly notify all members.</em></p><h4>1. Overview</h4><p><strong>1.1 Project Profile</strong></p><p>Illuvium is a decentralized gaming world built on Immutable X and features four games with different genres developed using Unreal Engine 5. These four games share a unified worldview and are tailored to various player demographics. These games are interconnected in Illuvium’s game economy, greatly enhancing players’ gaming experiences.</p><p><strong>1.2 Basic Information [1]</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/977/1*s4U01BXmypEPnTn2Wbzk9g.png" /></figure><h4><strong>2. Project Details</strong></h4><p><strong>2.1 Team</strong></p><p>The Illuvium team is based in Australia. The Illuvium website shows that Illuvium currently boasts 102 employees, of whom 96 have their LinkedIn profiles. The information about the core Illuvium team is shown below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*Id6qhU5baIGLuGqPo0iR5Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>Kieran Warwick — Co-Founder.</strong> Kieran Warwick, along with his brother Kain Warwick, who is the Founder of Synthetix, previously worked together in e-commerce. Kieran Warwick entered the cryptocurrency industry in 2015 and was a Sales Marketing Director at Blueshyft (an OTC exchange in Australia). In July 2016, Kieran Warwick left the cryptocurrency industry to pursue opportunities in the food industry. However, with the DeFi boom in 2020, Kieran Warwick returned to the cryptocurrency industry and co-founded Illuvium with Araon Warwick in September 2020.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*eKJmJjm3eCEfY6NDsATvbA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Aaron Warwick- Co-Founder.</strong> Aaron graduated from the University of Wollongong with a Bachelor’s degree in Computer Engineering and Physics. After graduation, he worked in the retail industry and also served as a tennis coach. In September 2020, he co-founded Illuvium with Kieran Warwick and is now involved in gameplay design and administration. Kieran, Aaron, and Kain are brothers, and they come from a family with a background in sports. The family has operated multi-million dollar retail franchises. In his spare time, Aaron owns and directs two major Australian sporting complexes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*8eycm8kXaRe3GL20KaujcQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>John Avery — CTO.</strong> John graduated from the Federation University Australia with a Bachelor’s degree in Computer Science. He has a 20-year career in both the gaming and the financial services industries. His game development career started when he began producing games for the App Store in the late 2000s, and since then, his games have reached over 1 million users. His company JNA Mobile was also one of the top Unity Asset Store publishers at the time. John joined Illuvium in December 2020 and has been serving as the CTO.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*0Vb2zjyr-pfxSDxpXILAZQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Danny Wilson — CFO</strong>. Danny has held multiple director and leadership roles in varying retail and tech-based organizations and was the Retail Franchise Director at Harvey Norman. Besides, he had a 6-year stint at Harvey Norman Business &amp; Education as Managing Director from 2013 to 2019. Between January 2016 and May 2019, Danny was the Managing Director at MAC1. Afterward, Danny has been serving as the Senior Advisor for many startups and co-founded Oracle Venture (a Web3 VC firm) in January 2022. He joined Illuvium in December 2020 and has been serving as the CFO.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*NmIIosNoUcM1szM4AEi-Tw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Benjamin Nietzsche — Head of Game Design. </strong>He has many years of career in the gaming industry. Benjamin started his career as a Co-Founder at Aequus Gaming in 2013, where he developed third-party software for League of Legends players. The most notable software developed by Aequus Gaming was LolReplay and LSI. In 2014, Benjamin worked as a 3rd-Party Consultant at Riot Games until 2016. Benjamin then joined HeadByte Studios in 2018 as a Lead Game Designer. Benjamin Nietzsche joined Illuvium in March 2021 and has been serving as the Head of Game Design.</p><p>According to the Illuvium website, among the 102 employees, there are 49 Concept Artists, Modelers, Texture Artists, Technical Artists, VFX Artists, Audio Artists, Character Artists, and Concept Artists, 15 Game Developers, 9 QA Testers, and 7 engineers who are in charge of setting up game servers. <strong>Overall, Illuvium’s core members boast extensive gaming and blockchain work experience, and the dev team demonstrates solid game development capabilities.</strong></p><p><strong>2.2 Fundraising</strong></p><p><strong>2.2.1 External Fundraising</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/985/1*Y_foA81z2uop9Jemyh13Tw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 2–1 Illuvium Funding Insights</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>As of March 27, 2024, Illuvium has externally gone through four funding rounds and secured $65 million in funding from well-known institutional-grade investors such as IOSG Ventures, Framework Ventures, Animoca Brands, Spartan Capital, Polygon Ventures, Yield Guild Games, and Delphi Digital. The latest funding round was closed on March 27, 2024. Therefore, it is suggested that the Illuvium team is now rather well-funded.</strong></p><p><strong>2.2.2 Illuvium Zero Land Sale</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/945/1*-hld3RXnUn5OOJYumSqS8g.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–1 Illuvium Zero Land Sale — 1 </strong><a href="#_ftn2"><strong>[2]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/945/1*Bq0oHqVXILoQZJS4VyQaIg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–2 Illuvium Zero Land Sale — 2</strong></figcaption></figure><p>On June 6, 2022, Illuvium announced that it closed a virtual Land sale worth more than $72.19 million. The sale distributed 19,969 Land plots out of the total supply of 100,000. There are five tiers of Illuvium Land in the sale. Higher tiers represent increasing rarity and higher Resource generation. Tier 1–4 Land plots were sold via Dutch Auction where $ETH or $sILV2 could be used to purchase Land. Tier 5 Land was sold using an English Auction format, and bidders can only use $ETH for Tier 5 auctions.</p><p>During the auctions, Land closing prices fluctuated dramatically. Tier 1 — Starting Price: 2 $ETH; Closing Price: 0.3–2 $ETH. Tier 2 — Starting Price: 6 $ETH; Closing Price: 0.97–6 $ETH. Tier 3 — Starting Price: 20 $ETH; Closing Price: 3.67–20 $ETH. Tier 4 — Starting Price: 80 $ETH; Closing Price: 13.6–76 $ETH.</p><p>The Land sale generated 4,018 $ETH and 239,388 $sILV2, of which 4,018 $ETH was swapped for $ILV and redistributed back to $ILV stakers, and the $sILV2 raised was burned, representing 2.39% of the total $sILV2 supply.</p><p><strong>2.2.3 Illuvium Beyond D1SK Sale</strong></p><p>Illuvitars are customizable NFTs on Illuvium Beyond. Illuvitars and Accessories are purchased via D1SKs, which are tradable containers that can be loaded to receive Illuvitars and Accessories. There are five types of Accessories: Head, Eyes, Skin, Body, and Props. There are two types of D1SKs to choose from: Standard D1SK and Mega D1SK. Each Standard D1SK is sold at a price of 0.005 $ETH and contains 1 random Illuvitar, 3 Accessories, and 1 Bonus Tier 0 Illuvitar. Each Mega D1SK is sold at a price of 0.025 $ETH and contains 1 random Illuvitar, 3 Accessories, and 1 rare Illuvitar.</p><p>Illuvium Beyond: Set 1, Wave One was kicked off on March 7, 2023, and the Illuvitars contained in an Alpha D1SK are marked as “Alpha”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LYJUzf14-M3WE5U6HA6crA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–3 Illuvitar D1SK Alpha Sale — 1</strong><a href="#_ftn3"><strong>[3]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/945/1*8DzGqUpc95vk3iDFVJeHvQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–4 Illuvium D1SK Alpha Sale — 2</strong><a href="#_ftn4"><strong>[4]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>Over three days, Illuvium sold 20,000 Alpha Mega D1SKs and 20,600 Standard Alpha D1SKs for 40,600 D1SKs. The total revenue generated from the sale was 47,843.51 $sILV2 and 742.39 $ETH, an incredible $4.75 million in just three days. Illuvium followed up with multiple waves of D1SK sales. Including:</p><p>On June 12, 2023, Illuvium launched the Promo D1SKs Sale with GameStop. The centerpiece of this collaboration is the Illuvium x GameStop D1SK. This special edition D1SK brings an array of exclusive Illuvitars in collector’s editions. Each Illuvium x GameStop D1SK was priced at ~$50. However, Illuvium did not disclose the sales figures for this round of D1SK sales.</p><p>On September 8, 2023, Illuvium Beyond Set 1, Wave 2 was launched. This sale featured a line-up of 25 new Illuvitars, each with its own unique characteristics and captivating designs. In the sale, each Standard D1SK was sold at 0.00301 $ETH, while the price of a Mega D1SK was dropped to 0.01801 $ETH. However, Illuvium did not disclose the sales figures for this round of D1SK sales.</p><p>On November 30, 2023, Illuvium launched the Promo D1SKs Sale with Team Liquid. These Promo D1SKs feature an exclusive assortment of pre-bonded Team Liquid Illuvitars, each uniquely designed with distinct expressions, finishes, and backgrounds. Each D1SK in this sale was sold at ~$40. However, Illuvium did not disclose the sales figures for this round of D1SK sales.</p><p><strong>As of March 27, 2024, Illuvium has externally gone through four funding rounds and secured $65 million in funding from well-known institutional-grade investors such as IOSG Ventures, Framework Ventures, Animoca Brands, Spartan Capital, Polygon Ventures, Yield Guild Games, and Delphi Digital. The latest funding round was closed on March 27, 2024. Therefore, it is suggested that the Illuvium team is now rather well-funded. Besides, Illuvium has gone through two rounds of in-game NFT sales with total sales reaching ~$76.94 million. However, most of these funds have been burned or swapped to $ILV to be redistributed to $ILV stakers. Overall, it can be said that Illuvium currently boasts healthy financial conditions to support the subsequent game development and operational work.</strong></p><p><strong>2.3 Product &amp; Technology</strong></p><p><strong>2.3.1 Overview</strong><a href="#_ftn5"><strong>[5]</strong></a></p><p>Illuvium is not a game but a gaming world made up of multiple games, each of which has its own role in this gaming world. Roughly speaking, games in the Illuvium ecosystem can be categorized into <strong>those requiring players to invest in funds to PRODUCE in-game Resources to lay the foundation for the operation of the entire gaming world</strong> (the Illuvium team can also adjust the production rate of in-game Resources to reach an economic balance) and <strong>those requiring users to</strong> leverage and <strong>CONSUME in-game Resources to fight against their opponents, </strong>and the Illuvium team needs to strike a balance between P2E and play-for-fun in games to stimulate players will join battles, thus adjusting the consumption rate of in-game Resources to reach an economic balance. <strong>According to the current game mechanics of the four games in Illuvium, Zero and Overworld are games falling within the first category, while Arena and Beyond are games falling within the second category. </strong>In addition, Illuvium has developed IlluviDex, a marketplace dedicated to trading in-game assets in the Illuvium ecosystem, where players can buy and sell in-game assets using $ETH.</p><p>From the perspective of the storyline, Illuvium casts players as a survivor from an interstellar space fleet who responds to a distress signal only to find themselves stranded on a planet in ruins. The planet’s surface is fraught with perilous weather conditions, and a vast crystal ocean covers many of its landmasses, leaving only a small fraction of the planet visible and accessible. Despite the devastation, players encounter majestic beasts called Illuvials, possessing near-godlike powers. As players traverse the world and capture these creatures using crystal Shards, they unlock Obelisks that serve as gateways to new regions. Along the way, players uncover secrets about Illuvium and rebuild their ship, the Leviathan.</p><p><strong>2.3.2 Illuvium Zero</strong></p><p>Illuvium Zero is the foundation of the Illuvium gaming world. It is an industrial building game where players take on the role of survivors struggling to survive on an alien planet. In this game, players will build up their Land, mine for Resources, scan their plots for Blueprints, and so much more.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/993/1*IkZzsyVakUr-xke-SledJg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–5 Zero</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In Zero, players can develop and manage their own complexes on top of the Land plots that they purchase or are freely provided by Illuvium (in the future) to mine Resources. Illuvium Zero can be broken down into two Resources: Elements and Fuels. The Elements players will gather are Carbon, Hydrogen, and Silicon, while the Fuel types players will produce are Crypton, Hyperion, and Solon. Elements will be used to build and upgrade buildings in Zero, Fuels will be used as an important Resource in Overworld, Crypton is a Fuel and will be the in-game travel cost to different Regions in Overworld, and Hyperion and Solon are used to craft and upgrade weapons and armor in Overworld. Besides, the Fuels that are produced are ERC-20 tokens that can be sold to Overworld players on IlluviDex.</p><p>In addition to the above-mentioned Resources, users can also create a Scanning Facility on their Land plot to scan Illuvials’ Biodata. By researching their Biodata, players can generate rare Blueprints (NFTs) that can be used to create exclusive NFT skins for other games in the Illuvium franchise. A Blueprint serves as the foundation for creating cosmetic-only skins. In Illuvium Zero, Blueprints will be utilized to design skins for Ranger and Drone Buddy, Moz4rt. Besides, Blueprints can be sold to Overworld players on IlluviDex.</p><p>There are five tiers of Illuvium Land with a total supply of 100,000, of which 19,969 Land plots have been sold in the first round of the Illuvium Zero Land Sale. Higher Land tiers represent increasing rarity and higher Resource generation. Tiers 3 and 4 Land also feature rare Landmarks that significantly boost Resource production. At present, Tier 1–4 Land can be purchased on IlluviDex, while Tier 5 Land plots can now only be purchased via auctions. In addition, due to the random distribution of Elements and Fuels in Illuvium Zero, some Land plots may face a situation of surplus in a Resource while lacking in other Resources. Therefore, players need to strategically choose Land plots where there are both Element and Fuel sites. In addition, the location of players’ Land on the map will also have a certain impact on their Land management. In the future, if players own multiple Land plots adjacent to each other, these Land plots can be interconnected to facilitate Resource exchange.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WNxKqPubFW4AhWneVLygtQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 2–2 Land Types</strong><a href="#_ftn6"><strong>[6]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LdsLvSzkz2Q5VC8lMC93Jg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 2–3 Landmark Types</strong></figcaption></figure><p>On top of Land plots, players can build and upgrade structures to mine Resources. Buildings can be categorized into 6 groups: <br> <strong>1) Basics. </strong>Nexus (along with Nexus, there are buildings that allow for upgrades or have other interesting features); Engineering Workshop (provides the infrastructure to construct basic structure types); Quantum Fabricant (provides the infrastructure required to construct advanced science and Fuel-related structures); Power Station (provides power to structures to ensure they operate with increased efficiency). <br> <strong>2) Extractors. </strong>Sediment Excavator; Mine; Hydrogen Pump; Crypton Gate, Hyperion Extractor, Solon Dredge. <br> <strong>3) Converters. </strong>Sequestrian Plant (passively converts CO2 in the atmosphere to Carbon and converts the other two Elements into Carbon); Photodisintegration Plant (passively converts oxygen in the atmosphere to Silicon and converts other two Elements into Silicon); Condenser Plant (passively converts water in the atmosphere to Hydrogen and converts other two Elements into Hydrogen); L-Crypton Collider (passively converts trace Ethereum in the material plane to Cryptons and converts other two Fuels into Crypton); Hyperion Lathe (passively converts trace Ethereum in the material plane to Hyperions and converts other two Fuels into Hyperion); Anti-Solon Inverter (passively converts trace Ethereum in the material plane to Solons and converts other two Fuels into Solon). <br> <strong>4) Storage. </strong>Carbon Matter Silo (stores aggregated Carbon nanorods); Silicon Matter Silo (stores pure metallic Silicon); Hydrogen Matter Silo (stores liquid Hydrogen); Crypton Containment Unit (stores Cryptons); Hyperion Containment Unit (stores Hyperions); Solon Containment Unit (stores Solons). <br> <strong>5) Science. </strong>Singularity Scanner (scans Illuvials in the surrounding area); Zero Point Transducer (essential for minting Blueprints); Materials Lab (provides the requisite facilitating to research Illuvium Biodata); Data Bank (improves research efficiency);<br> <strong>6) Others.</strong> Holographic Statue (displays a 3D hologram of scanned Illuvium Biodata); Marketplace (allows the purchase and sale of Resources).</p><p><strong>In addition to choosing the time to build structures and allocating Resources, players also need to consider building Paths surrounding buildings. Paths have a significant impact on Land optimization and reduce the time required for any time-based events when they are placed correctly around structures. Moreover, every adjustment made to the Paths around structures incurs substantial costs. Therefore, only when Paths are arranged sensibly and their positions are thoroughly planned can players mine Resources in the most efficient way. All of these operations will require players to be highly strategic, thus boosting the gaming experience.</strong></p><p>The role played by the Illuvium team in Illuvium Zero is primarily that of macro-level resource regulators. Since the total Fuel produced by Landowners must always represent only 5% of the overall total, the DAO consistently produces exactly 19x more Fuel than the combined Fuel produced by all Landowners. In other words, the production rate of Fuels in Illuvium Zero can be boosted up to 20x and invested in Overworld. However, the timing and amount of these produced Fuels being invested in Overworld will be controlled by the Illuvium team. Illuvium stated that when the price of Fuels fluctuates sharply, the team will adjust the supply of Fuels thus stabilizing their prices and mitigating the risk of malicious individuals manipulating the price of in-game Resources. Additionally, this mechanic implies that when 1 Fuel is minted by players, 19x more Fuel than the combined Fuel produced by all Landowners will be created, and the proceeds from selling these extra Fuels in the future will be allocated to $ILV token holders. Simply put, Landowners will receive 5% of all in-game purchases while the $ILV stakers receive the other 95%. This ratio can be modified in the future through Illuvium DAO governance to better distribute the profits generated by Illuvium to different ecosystem participants. Moreover, Illuvium, as the developer of Zero, may introduce more unique gameplay mechanics, structures, and Resources in the future to enrich players’ gaming experiences.</p><p>The game is currently in open beta and is now only available to Landowners. Blueprints minted in open beta can be retained for later use, but other in-game data will be reset when Zero is publicly launched. Besides, the game is available on both PCs (MAC, Windows) and mobile devices (Android).</p><p><strong>2.3.3 Overworld</strong></p><p>Overworld is a third-person adventure game that is intricately tied to Illuvium’s worldview. It comprises a series of Regions that players can explore at their discretion. Upon arriving at a Region, set out to explore, scouring for resources, and engaging in encounters. In Illuvium Overworld, players will take on the role of explorers on the planet, equipped with Drones to collect Resources across different regions, craft equipment, and capture Illuvials.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1018/1*e-7epzJnS0Y_Buni_BwCXQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–6 Overworld</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Illuvium Overworld is made up of 7 unique Regions and a home base known as Sanctum Mesa. Each of the Regions has completely different environments like frozen tundra, swamp, dessert, etc. Besides, there are different Resources that can be harvested in different Regions. There are four levels of Regions with different requirements of Crypton and different tiers of Resources and Illuvials that can be collected and captured. In a single run, players can harvest Resources and capture Illuvials with a limited amount of energy. The energy bar will start in full and slowly work its way to zero as players gather Resources. The run will conclude once the energy drops to 0. Hence, players need to reasonably consider their movements in the Region.</p><p>The Resources that players can collect in different Regions include Essence, Ore, Shards, Gems, and Plants. It is worth noting that Shards are the capsules that players use to capture Illuvials after defeating them in the battle. After harvesting these Resources, players can craft in-game items. These items fall into two categories. One type is used for collecting Resources or improving Resource collection efficiency. This includes Drones, Equipment, and Shards (which are similar to Pokeballs in the Pokemon games). Another type includes Augments, Armaments, and Illuvials, which are used to build a team using a mix of them in Arena. Besides, Fuels produced in Illuvium Zero such as Hyperion and Solon will be used to craft these items. Moreover, the crafted items can be sold to other players on IlluviDex.</p><p>As a third-person adventure game, Overworld has two highlights. Firstly, it offers satisfactory adventurous experiences across different Regions, allowing players to immerse themselves in the visual splendor brought by the game’s artistic design. Secondly, it emphasizes the enjoyment of collecting Resources and crafting items, uplifting the significance of these gaming mechanics. This allows players to experience a great sense of achievement in Overworld.</p><p>The game is now in private beta and requires players to email the Illuvium team to apply for an invitation code. At present, the game can be downloaded on Epic Games with some specific computer requirements.</p><p>2.3.4 Arena</p><p>Arena, as a competitive auto battler, is fundamentally different in the game genre from Zero and Overworld. In Arena, there is no need for players to collect Resources and craft items, they just need to assemble powerful teams and challenge opponents in the PvP/PvE modes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/945/1*A9thKkRksNGQ31FAAyY-QA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–7 Arena</strong></figcaption></figure><p>From the gameplay perspective, Arena does not differ much from other auto battlers. Most auto battlers including Illuvium Arena are turn-based, where players need to spend money to purchase characters and place them on a grid-shaped battlefield during a preparation phase, who then fight the opposing team’s characters without any further direct input from the player. Each character has its own unique abilities and characteristics, as well as two attributes: class and synergy. Players need to utilize these attributes to create synergies between characters, enhancing the abilities of their characters. Additionally, players can improve the abilities of characters and alter their appearance by continuously investing funds.</p><p><strong>Illuvials also come in different classes that affect their fighting style and ability to take damage: Fighter (Warrior), Guardian (Tank), Rogue (Assassin), Psion (Magic), and Empath (Support). </strong>The main difference between these Illuvial classes lies in their abilities. For example, the Fighter class is all about dealing damage through basic attacks, the Guardian class is about tanking damage instead, the Rogue class is specialized in dealing a lot of damage to the backline of the enemy board, Psion Illuvials have strong omega abilities that burst enemies down in a single shot, and the Empath class does not focus on damage but supplies the rest of the team with heals and shields. In addition, an Illuvial can possess different classes, thus providing more choices for players to build up their teams.</p><p><strong>Besides, there are 5 base affinities: Water, Earth, Fire, Nature, and Air. </strong>Through adding multiple affinities, the Illuvials can create composite affinities. It should be noted that not every Illuvial has an affinity, and it is also likely that an Illuvial possesses multiple affinities. Additionally, each Illuvial that can form composite synergies will have a dominant affinity or class. Combat units gain Hyper when their Affinity counters an Affinity that their opponents have. Illuvials with the predatory affinity do not deal more damage to their Prey. They will purely charge their Hyper meter which will eventually make them stronger. Therefore, players need to select Illuvials whose affinities counter those that their opponents have, thus increasing their chances of success in the battle.</p><p>Moreover, players can use Augments and equipment to boost the abilities of their Illuvials.</p><p>As of March 27, 2024, there are 205 Illuvials with different affinities, classes, and tiers, 87 Augments with different tiers, and 81 Legendary Augments with different abilities. After the launch of Arena open beta, Illuvials, Equipment, and Augments can be purchased on IlluviDex. Besides, players can use Augments, Armaments, and Illuvials that are crafted in Overworld to build their teams in Arena to earn rewards in the Ascendant Arena.</p><p>In Arena, the role played by the Illuvium team primarily involves overseeing operations and acting as referees for battles. Besides, the team needs to continuously release new card decks to enrich players’ gaming experience. Additionally, they must strike a balance between the abilities &amp; effects of existing cards and that of newly released cards in each version to maintain the competitiveness of the game. This places high demands on the team in terms of their ability to operate the game soundly and effectively.</p><p>Arena is still in private beta while having been launched on Epic Games with specific computer requirements. Furthermore, in the future, if players want to compete for the top players on the leaderboard and earn rewards, they need to possess a deck of at least 28 cards.</p><p><strong>2.3.5 Beyond</strong></p><p>Beyond is a collectible card game launched by Illuvium in June 2023. Strictly speaking, it is a PFP NFT collection game.</p><p>The relationship between Beyond and the other three games is relatively independent. Players can obtain Illuvitar avatars and Accessories by purchasing D1SKs. Additionally, they can customize their Illuvitar avatars by equipping them with different Accessories. Players can trade these avatars on IlluviDex while building collections to earn points and climb the leaderboard. Each week, Illuvium will take a snapshot of the leaderboard and award the top 100 collectors with bonus $ILV tokens.</p><p>In the future, these avatars will also serve as personal symbols for Illuvium players when entering this vast gaming world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/790/1*axqXwpDjjBM_rdmVyxnQnA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–8 Beyond</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>2.3.6 Conclusion</strong></p><p>As it stands, the design of the four games in Illuvium essentially aligns with the principles laid down at the inception of the gaming world. These principles entail that each game possesses distinct gameplay and mechanics tailored to different player demographics. However, through the Illuvium game economy, they are interconnected, cultivating a thriving gaming ecosystem. The project team is now on a tight schedule to develop the games. Illuvium has rolled out the open beta version of Zero and Beyond, while Overworld and Arena are still in private beta and are expected to be launched to the public soon. Looking ahead, the focus will be on bridging the technical connections among these four games. Additionally, the in-game token, $sILV2, of Illuvium will play a significant role in the gaming world, ensuring ecosystem sustainability. All of the above sets high demands on the development and operational capabilities of the Illuvium team. However, as it stands, the current business data on Illuvium is rather satisfactory.</p><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of team and fundraising, Illuvium’s dev team boasts sufficient developers who have extensive game development capabilities. Besides, Illuvium just closed a $12 million Series A funding round on March 27, 2024, and the team is now rather well-funded.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of products, Illuvium is a decentralized gaming world built on Immutable X and features four games with different genres. Specifically, Zero is an industrial building game, Overworld is a third-person adventure game, Arena is a competitive auto battler, and Beyond is a competitive collectible card game. In this gaming world, each game features unique gameplay mechanics tailored to different player demographics. However, the games are interconnected through the extraction and utilization of Resources across different games, greatly enhancing players’ gaming experiences. The project team is now on a tight schedule to develop the games. Illuvium has rolled out the open beta version of Zero (Zero Alpha) and Beyond, while Overworld and Arena are still in private beta and are expected to be launched to the public soon. From a longer-term perspective, the design of Illuvium’s gaming world presents significant challenges to the development and operational capabilities of the Illuvium team. Particularly, adjusting the production rate of in-game Resources in Illuvium Beyond and Overworld and striking a balance between P2E and play-for-fun in Illuvium Arena and Beyond are challenges the project team must overcome. Currently, Illuvium has demonstrated its development capabilities, but it still takes time to examine its operational capacity.</strong></p><h4>3. Development Trajectory</h4><p><strong>3.1 History</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d6NIbWTnoYxaBZutZ0B9vQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–1 Illuvium Timeline</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>3.2 Current Status</strong></p><p><strong>3.2.1 Operational Data</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/827/1*2-FcPYlPEp_4w76G6aeXwg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–1 Illuvium Zero Land Sale Stats</strong><a href="#_ftn7"><strong>[7]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>According to the Immutable block explorer, as of 17:00 on March 21, 2024, there have been a total of 11,392 Illuvium Land trades with a total trading volume of 10,753 $ETH. The average sale price of an Illuvium Land plot is 0.944 $ETH, its current floor price stands at 0.12 $ETH, and there are now 7,680 unique Landowners.</p><p>The operational data on other games in the Illuvium ecosystem is currently unavailable since they are still in private beta.</p><p><strong>3.2.2 Community</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*81dvImD_B7YQFEHiE3y1rA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–2 Illuvium’s Social Media Data</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>As of March 21, 2024, Illuvium boasts a sizable community where members are actively discussing issues related to gameplay mechanics and tokenomics.</strong></p><p><strong>3.3 The Future</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5CNCC2Zau_wlQ8mgcLJsgg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–2 Illuvium 2024 Roadmap</strong><a href="#_ftn8"><strong>[8]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/827/1*1K7SwakjDCSrOPrpiIQfVA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–3 Illuvium Q2 2024 Roadmap</strong></figcaption></figure><p>According to the roadmap disclosed by Illuvium, in 2024, the focus of Illuvium will still be placed on developing the games in the Illuvium ecosystem. It is expected that Illuvium Private Beta 4 will soon be rolled out. In Q2 2024, Illuvium Open Beta Testnet and Illuvium Beyond — Wave 3 will be released. In Q3 2024, a new game will be introduced. In Q4 2024, $ILV Staking V3 and Illuvium Beyond — Wave 4 are expected to be introduced. Moreover, Illuvium has announced the airdrop program after the launch of Open Beta (Mainnet). It is expected that more players will be onboarded to the Illuvium gaming world after the launch of the program.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>Illuvium is still in the early stages of development with Arena and Overview being in private beta. It still takes time for Illuvium to create a close-looped and engaging gaming world. However, Illuvium has gained great popularity and boasts a sizable community. It is expected that more players will be onboarded to the Illuvium gaming world after Arena and Overview are publicly launched.</strong></p><h4>4. Tokenomics</h4><p><strong>4.1 Supply</strong></p><p><strong>4.1.1 $ILV Allocation</strong></p><p>$ILV, Illuvium’s governance token, went live on the mainnet in February 2021 with a maximum supply of 10,000,000 $ILV. As of March 27, 2024, the total supply and the circulating supply of $ILV stand at 9,605,840<a href="#_ftn9">[9]</a> and 6,334,671, respectively.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*893Iid6p4ppvadAFYBF3uw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 4–1 $ILV Allocation (Estimated)</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/836/1*Inm6M1a78QtZVX6TvDgP4w.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–1 $ILV Allocation</strong><a href="#_ftn10"><strong>[10]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>It can be noticed that 30% of $ILV tokens were allocated to Pre-Seed, Seed, and Public investors, 30% were allocated to the Team and Treasury, and the remaining 40% were allocated to ecosystem participants as yield-farming rewards and in-game rewards. Since $ILV has been launched for a long time, most of the $ILV tokens have now been vested.</p><p><strong>Additionally, there is another token in the Illuvium ecosystem, $sILV2, which is a synthetic $ILV token and can be used as in-game currency for things like travel and shard curing. </strong>For example, $sILV2 could be used to purchase Illuvium Zero Land and D1SKs. It can be earned by staking $ILV in the protocol. Besides, it should be noted that the operation of swapping $ILV for $sILV2 is irreversible. Whenever a user mints $sILV2, he/she burns an equivalent amount of $ILV effectively decreasing the total supply of $ILV. In the long run, as the games in the Illuvium ecosystem are officially launched and more $ILV tokens are minted into $sILV2 tokens, $ILV will become a deflationary token. As of March 22, 2024, a total of 154,310 $sILV2 tokens<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a> have been minted.</p><p><strong>4.1.2 Addresses Owning $ILV</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vJBBiq92qIC3Hx9d-Hvogg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–2 Illuvium Top 100 Token Holders</strong><a href="#_ftn12"><strong>[12]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>According to Etherscan, as of March 27, 2024, there are 50,187 $ILV holders, of whom the top 10 holders collectively own 90.22% of the total supply of 8,146,998 $ILV. Among the top 20 accounts, there are 4 contract accounts that collectively own 63.41% of the current total supply of $ILV. Besides, there are 7 exchange addresses that collectively own 9.66% of the current total supply of $ILV. Altogether, these addresses own 73.07% of the current total supply of $ILV. Additionally, there are 3 addresses out of the top 20 addresses that belong to IOSG Ventures and Delphi Digital, who collectively own 1.63% of the current total supply of $ILV. <strong>Hence, deducting the % of $ILV tokens owned in these addresses, we can find that $ILV tokens are now distributed in a rather decentralized fashion.</strong></p><p><strong>4.2 Demand</strong></p><p>In addition to governance, another core function of $ILV is liquidity mining. When staking $ILV, users will share in Illuvium’s success and earn a passive income of additional $ILV, funded through in-game purchases and fees. Users can stake their $ILV to pools in the Illuvium protocol and select the lock duration from 1 to 12 months. Staking $ILV returns yield in the form of $ILV and $sILV2. If stakers want to claim their staking rewards in the form of $ILV, $ILV yield rewards are subject to a 12-month vesting period. However, if stakers want to claim their staking rewards in the form of $sILV2, $sILV2 rewards will be immediately unlocked and can be used in-game once the game is live.</p><p>There are currently two core pools in the Illuvium protocol that users can choose from, the $ILV Pool and the ILV/ETH Pool. The $ILV Pool is the pool launched by Illuvium, and users can earn farming yield rewards by simply staking $ILV to this pool. However, stakers in this pool can only share 20% of the total $ILV yield rewards distributed in the epoch. As of March 27, 2024, the TVL in this pool stands at $338,761,280, the estimated APR is 2.93%, and the estimated amount of staked $ILV is 2,219,930 (including $ILV staked in the pool, Treasury $ILV, and unlocked vesting $ILV). The ILV/ETH Pool is the pool launched by SushiSwap and Illuvium, and stakers can share 80% of the total $ILV yield rewards distributed in the epoch by staking both $ILV and $ETH to this pool. In addition, stakers in this pool can share the transaction fee incurred in this pool. At present, 291,165 $ILV has been staked into this pool, along with staked $ETH, the TVL in this pool stands at $80,519,939, and the estimated APR is 49.29%. It can therefore be roughly calculated that a total of ~2,483,757 $ILV has been staked into these two pools, accounting for ~25.86% of the current total supply of $ILV.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/961/1*4rXH25qelT0wBzSsCM2lBA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–3 $ILV Staking Pools</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/814/1*UzGkJYWPpj4O4K9flNGF0A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–4 $ILV Emission Schedule</strong><a href="#_ftn13"><strong>[13]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>There are two sources of $ILV staking yield rewards: 1) 30% of the total supply of $ILV tokens. This portion of the staking rewards will be distributed every 14 days (an epoch). At present, Illuvium has kicked off Epoch 71. As of March 27, 2024, the total estimated amount of $ILV to be distributed in this epoch is ~11,694 $ILV, of which 2,339 $ILV will be distributed to stakers in the $ILV Pool, and the remaining 9,355 $ILV will be distributed to stakers in the ILV/ETH Pool. To date, a total of ~2.92 million $ILV has been distributed as yield rewards, representing 97.33% of the total amount of $ILV set aside for stakers. It is expected that all 3,000,000 $ILV tokens will be distributed to stakers by early July 2024; 2) revenue generated from digital product sales. According to IIP-45-R<a href="#_ftn14">[14]</a>, Landowners are entitled to a 5% share of the total revenue generated from digital product sales within the Illuvium gaming ecosystem, and the remaining 95% will be swapped for $ILV and redistributed to $ILV stakers.</p><p>Assuming that the total revenue generated from a D1SK sale was 1,000 $ETH and 4,000 $sILV2, according to Illuvium’s revenue allocation schedule, 50 $ETH will be allocated to Landowners, while the remaining 950 $ETH will be swapped for $ILV and redistributed to $ILV stakers. Besides, in the future, $sILV2 used to purchase D1SKs will be distributed to $ILV stakers as revenue distribution (RevDis) rewards or be burnt to reduce the total supply of $ILV.</p><p>Overall, the philosophy of the $ILV staking mechanism adheres to the principles of fully rewarding core ecosystem participants and promoting the sustainable development of the gaming ecosystem.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>From the perspective of tokenomics, $ILV is the governance token of the Illuvium ecosystem and is used to reward participants and drive the sustainable development of Illuvium. At present, the above-mentioned goals can basically be realized via the $ILV staking mechanism. However, this staking mechanism can only be effective and feasible when Illuvium generates lucrative revenues, and we will further observe and examine the viability of the mechanism over an extended time period.</strong></p><p><strong>5. Sector Analysis</strong></p><p>Illuvium operates in the blockchain gaming sector, where there are a great number of projects with significantly different gameplay mechanics, fundamentals, tokenomics, and P2E mechanics. Therefore, in this Chapter, we will not compare them quantitatively while merely diving into the current status and prospects of the blockchain gaming sector.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wrZwbwN5KOl4It2FhmiLUw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–1 Weekly Blockchain Games Activity (Volume)</strong><a href="#_ftn15"><strong>[15]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2xHUQIHc05UYBqVBu6oKAw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–2 Active Users &amp; Chg%</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Since the end of 2023, with the onset of a new bull run, the blockchain gaming sector has experienced significant growth, emerging as one of the leading sectors driving this bull run in the blockchain industry. <strong>From the above data, it is evident that the blockchain gaming sector is currently experiencing its second rapid growth phase since the end of 2021. </strong>The number of blockchain gamers has been growing rapidly, with the peak reaching more than 3 million in a single day (active players). Besides, the trading volume placed by these gamers has also been on growth momentum. If we estimate based on the player retention rates observed during the previous bull run, it is anticipated that after the current bull run concludes, the core user base in the blockchain gaming sector will remain at over 2.5 million people. This would represent nearly 3x the number of core players at the bottom of the previous market cycle. This also suggests that the on-chain gaming sector is bound to boast considerable room for growth, and we may see the emergence of more outstanding and quality projects in this bull run.</p><p>In this bull run, we have noticed some changes in the competitive landscape of the blockchain gaming sector: <br> <strong>1) There are increasing gaming genres. </strong>Compared to the competitive landscape of the blockchain gaming sector in the last bull run where there was a great majority of RPGs, simulation, and sports games, the current bull run has seen the emergence of representative projects in more genres such as competitive and strategic multiplayer online role-playing, action, shooting, and MOBA. <br> <strong>2) The quality of blockchain games has improved significantly. </strong>On one hand, there is a shift towards utilizing popular game engines for development, leading to higher-quality games. Additionally, there is a growing emphasis on aesthetic design, moving away from the early pixelated style towards more visually appealing designs. Furthermore, gameplay mechanics are more well-designed, aligning blockchain games more closely with the standards of Web2 games in terms of playability and engagement. On the other hand, the influx of talent from the Web2 gaming industry has resulted in mainstream blockchain games adopting operational philosophies and methods that closely resemble those used in traditional online gaming. These matured operational models can still effectively drive game development and facilitate real-time communication between gaming studios and players in the short term. Therefore, these two rationales have resulted in a significant improvement in the overall fundamentals of blockchain games.</p><p><strong>However, the biggest challenge faced by blockchain games in the current bull run is that they still have not fully shaken off the influence exerted by those in the previous bull run. Strictly speaking, this current phase of rapid growth in the blockchain gaming sector has yet to see the emergence of projects that truly innovate and revolutionize the paradigm of the blockchain gaming sector. </strong>This is because the current rapid growth phase in blockchain gaming has risen not solely due to the bullish market conditions but also because developing blockchain games inherently requires a significant amount of time. Blockchain games with monotonous gameplay are easier to develop and can be quickly launched on the market to gain a first-mover advantage. However, it will take at least 2–3 years to develop games with well-designed graphics and gameplay mechanics. Additionally, these high-quality and AAA blockchain games typically involve more participants and higher costs, making their business transition more challenging. This suggests that high-quality and AAA blockchain games in the current market cycle, which were introduced late in the last bull run, will find it challenging to make significant innovations based on the experiences and lessons learned from the last bull run. Instead, they are more likely to continue to implement the P2E mechanics within their game economy.</p><p>At present, Illuvium stands out as one of the few gaming projects innovating at the underlying logic of blockchain gaming. It no longer relies on monotonous gameplay to attract users but instead aims to design an effective game economy to interconnect multiple games in its ecosystem. Such a gaming ecosystem is expected to be more sustainable and vigorous than decentralized gaming ecosystems featuring limited and repetitive gameplay.</p><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p><strong>Since the end of 2023, the blockchain gaming sector has experienced rapid development, with significant increases in trading volumes and user numbers. Based on data, it is expected that after the current bull run ends, the core user base of the blockchain gaming sector will be at least twice as large as before, which implies that the sector still boasts considerable room for development over a long time. In this bull run, an increasing number of games with different genres and higher quality have been emerging, which contributes to the rapid growth of the player base in the blockchain gaming sector. However, currently, many blockchain games still opt for the P2E mechanics to drive their growth with few innovations being made. Illuvium stands out as one of the few gaming projects innovating at the underlying logic of blockchain gaming. It no longer relies on monotonous gameplay to attract users but instead aims to design an effective game economy to interconnect multiple games in its ecosystem. Such a gaming ecosystem is expected to be more sustainable and vigorous than other decentralized gaming ecosystems featuring limited and repetitive gameplay.</strong></p><h4>6. Risks</h4><p><strong>1) Code Security Risk: </strong>Illuvium’s staking contracts have been audited several times. However, it is still likely for its contracts to be exploited by hackers as there may be undiscovered vulnerabilities. In addition, the code of games in the Illuvium ecosystem has not yet been open-sourced. Hence, it remains unknown about their security, leaving room for potential vulnerabilities and the possibility of third-party hacks in the future.</p><p><strong>2) Market Risk: </strong>At present, blockchain games are in fierce competition, and games with different genres have been emerging.</p><p><strong>3) Operational Risk: </strong>Both competitive and resource-production games impose high operational demands on the game developer.</p><p><strong>4) Token Risk:</strong> As the governance token of Illuvium, $ILV is subject to significant price fluctuations, which may negatively impact the development and operation of the project itself.</p><p><strong>5) Development Risk: </strong>The development difficulty of games in the Illuvium ecosystem is high, which lengthens the game development time. Therefore, there is a risk that Illuvium may be unable to launch its games officially and publicly on time.</p><p><strong>— END —</strong></p><p>Website <a href="https://first.vip/">First.VIP</a> | Twitter <a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61">@firstvip61</a> | Telegram @gofirstvip</p><p>References</p><blockquote>Illuvium Docs, <a href="https://docs.illuvium.io/illuvium-whitepaper">https://docs.illuvium.io/illuvium-whitepaper</a></blockquote><blockquote>Illuvium Master, <a href="https://www.illuvialmaster.com/">https://www.illuvialmaster.com/</a></blockquote><blockquote>Project Analysis — Illuvium (1st Edition), First.VIP</blockquote><blockquote>Illuvium Gameplay (Chinese), <a href="https://ilvcn.gitbook.io/ilvplay">https://ilvcn.gitbook.io/ilvplay</a></blockquote><p><a href="#_ftnref1"><em>[1]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium,"><em>https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium,</em></a><em> data was captured on March 27, 2024.</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2"><em>[2]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained"><em>https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3"><em>[3]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-set-1-wave-one-buyers-guide"><em>https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-set-1-wave-one-buyers-guide</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4"><em>[4]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-v1-1-now-live"><em>https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-v1-1-now-live</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6"><em>[6]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained"><em>https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref7"><em>[7]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://rc1-blockscout.ilv-testnet.org/mainnet/"><em>https://rc1-blockscout.ILV-testnet.org/mainnet/</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8"><em>[8]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/illuviumio/status/1772906673415262570/photo/1"><em>https://twitter.com/illuviumio/status/1772906673415262570/photo/1</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref9"><em>[9]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium"><em>https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref10"><em>[10]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium/tokenomics"><em>https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium/tokenomics</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref11"><em>[11]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://etherscan.io/token/0x7e77dcb127f99ece88230a64db8d595f31f1b068"><em>https://etherscan.io/token/0x7e77dcb127f99ece88230a64db8d595f31f1b068</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref12"><em>[12]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://etherscan.io/token/tokenholderchart/0x767fe9edc9e0df98e07454847909b5e959d7ca0e"><em>https://etherscan.io/token/tokenholderchart/0x767fe9edc9e0df98e07454847909b5e959d7ca0e</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref13"><em>[13]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://staking.illuvium.io/"><em>https://staking.illuvium.io/</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref14"><em>[14]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://snapshot.org/#/ilv-gov.eth/proposal/0xc4511bc3dadffcd3bcb617ea6b5fbeb8e0cf46c05f4805348f6fa87c601b8a0c"><em>https://snapshot.org/#/ilv-gov.eth/proposal/0xc4511bc3dadffcd3bcb617ea6b5fbeb8e0cf46c05f4805348f6fa87c601b8a0c</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref15"><em>[15]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://dappradar.com/rankings/games/charts?range=1y"><em>https://dappradar.com/rankings/games/charts?range=1y</em></a></p><p>— Investment Risks and Disclaimers —</p><p>This report is only for information purposes and should not be relied upon when making any investment decision. Please do not make any investment decisions based on this report. First.VIP and authors of this report are not responsible for any results of your investment.</p><p>This report is drafted from the date indicated. As market or economic conditions may change from time to time, the content of this report may not necessarily reflect such changes. The graphs, charts, and other visual aids are provided for information purposes solely, none of which should be relied upon as investment decisions. First.VIP will not assist anyone in making investment decisions and no graph, chart, or other visual aid can capture all of the factors and variables required to make such decisions.</p><p>Some of the statements in this report may contain First.VIP’s future assumptions and other forward-looking views. With known &amp; unknown risks and uncertainties, actual results, performance, or events may differ materially from the views and assumptions expressed in the statements.</p><p>Any speculations, forecasts, and estimates contained in this report are speculative and are based on certain assumptions. These forward-looking statements may prove to be inaccurate and may be affected by inaccurate assumptions, known/unknown risks, uncertainties, and other factors, most of which are beyond our control. It can be anticipated that some or all of these forward-looking assumptions will not be realized or will differ materially from actual results.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f1059b43f589" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[头等仓研报：区块链游戏世界Illuvium]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/%E5%A4%B4%E7%AD%89%E4%BB%93%E7%A0%94%E6%8A%A5-%E5%8C%BA%E5%9D%97%E9%93%BE%E6%B8%B8%E6%88%8F%E4%B8%96%E7%95%8Cilluvium-b1742e864fce?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1742e864fce</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Mar 2024 12:22:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-08T08:19:56.188Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*r3QoQRDUaAFZBKqI.jpg" /></figure><p>Illuvium是一个基于Immutable X，使用虚幻5引擎开发的包含了四款不同类型游戏的区块链游戏世界，这四款游戏共用一个统一的世界观，面向不同的玩家群体开发，又通过游戏世界的经济机制串联了起来，极大地丰富了玩家们的游玩体验。目前游戏开发进度良好，机制玩法设计合理，游戏品质上已经超越了目前市场大多数的区块链游戏，预计其中的主要游戏将于年内开展公测，因此我们选择关注Illuvium。</p><h4><strong>投资概要</strong></h4><p>Illuvium是一个包含了四款不同类型游戏的区块链游戏世界，这四款游戏共用一个统一的世界观，面向不同的玩家群体开发，又通过游戏世界的经济机制串联了起来，形成了一个完整的区块链游戏生态。</p><p><strong>从团队和资金来看，Illuvium的开发团队有着充足的开发经验和不错的开发能力，项目融资情况较好，于3月27日刚完成了一笔1,200万的A轮融资，因此资金面也较为充裕。</strong></p><p><strong>从产品来看Illuvium设计了一个由模拟经营类游戏Zero，开放世界冒险类游戏Overworld，自走棋形式的策略竞技类游戏Arena和NFT收集类游戏Beyond组成的庞大的游戏世界。在这个游戏世界当中，每个游戏都拥有独特的游戏玩法机制来面向不同的玩家群体，但是又通过不同游戏之间互通资源的开采和利用将这四个游戏串联了起来，使得玩家在这个游戏世界当中可以获得更加丰富的游戏体验。目前这四个游戏都已经有了不错的完成度，其中Zero和Beyond已经公测面世，而Overworld和Arena还在内测阶段，预计不久后将开始公测。从更长时间来看，Illuvium的游戏世界设计对Illuvium团队的开发能力和运营提出了非常大的考验，尤其是后期收集类游戏的产率调整和竞技类游戏的平衡性调整都将是团队必须攻克的难题，目前Illuvium已经证明了自己的开发能力，但是其运营能力还有待进一步实践的检验。</strong></p><p><strong>从项目发展来看，目前Illuvium发展仍处于初级阶段，Arena和Overworld仍然处于内测阶段，游戏世界的整体构想距离完成目前仍有一段距离。但是游戏目前已经累积了较高的人气，社区与社交媒体较为活跃，预计Arena和Overworld进入公测阶段以后Illuvium将迎来更多的玩家参与。</strong></p><p><strong>从代币经济学的角度来看，ILV代币主要作为网络的治理代币，其主要职能在于反哺游戏核心参与者以推动游戏生态的可持续发展。目前从机制设定上来讲，ILV代币通过质押机制基本可以实现以上目标，但是该机制对于游戏后续的盈利能力提出了较高的要求，有待之后的实践来给出答案。</strong></p><p><strong>从赛道的角度来看，2023年年末以来，链游赛道取得了快速地发展，交易量和用户量都有了显著的增长，从数据上来看预计本轮市场周期结束以后，链游赛道的核心用户群体将至少是原先的一倍以上，这意味着在未来的很长一段时间内，链游赛道仍将有广阔的市场空间。本轮链游赛道的发展当中呈现出了游戏类型多样化和游戏质量提升这两个特点，是本轮链游用户数量持续快速增长的主要原因。但是目前来看，本轮的链游游戏大多没有跳脱出“Play To Earn”的框架，做出的创新较少，而Illuvium是目前少数几个在区块链游戏底层逻辑上做出创新的游戏项目，其不再依靠一个单一机制和玩法的游戏来获取用户，而是试图从底层架构上建立起一套行之有效的经济模型来将多个游戏串联起来，这样的游戏生态预计将会比传统的单一区块链游戏世界更有生命力。</strong></p><p><strong>综上，Illuvium项目值得关注。</strong></p><p><em>说明：头等仓最终评定的【关注】/【不关注】，是按照头等仓项目评估框架对项目当前基本面进行综合分析的结果，而非对项目代币未来价格涨跌的预测。影响代币价格的因素众多，项目基本面并非唯一因素，因此，不可因为研报判定为【不关注】，就认为项目价格一定会跌。此外，区块链项目的发展是动态的，被我们判定为【不关注】的项目，若其基本面发生重大的积极变化，我们将有可能会调整为【关注】，同样地，被我们判定为【关注】的项目，若发生重大恶性改变，我们将会警示所有会员，并有可能会调整为【不关注】。</em></p><h4>1. <strong>基本概况</strong></h4><p><strong>1.1 项目简介</strong></p><p>Illuvium是一个基于Immutable X，使用虚幻5引擎开发的包含了四款不同类型游戏的区块链游戏世界，这四款游戏共用一个统一的世界观，面向不同的玩家群体开发，又通过游戏世界的经济机制串联了起来，形成了一个完整的区块链游戏生态。</p><p><strong>1.2 基本信息<em>[1]</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/978/1*_ucKcxPYcmjNMtTCZLE07g.jpeg" /></figure><h4>2. <strong>项目详解</strong></h4><p><strong>2.1 团队</strong></p><p>Illuvium的开发公司为Illuvium，团队位于澳大利亚，官网显示目前团队共有102人，领英上显示有96人，估计目前团队人数在100人左右，团队主要成员信息如下：</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*ZestfcUFu1GD0fS1mbkYag.png" /></figure><p><strong>Kieran Warwick — 联合创始人</strong>，Kieran 与他的兄弟 Kain Warwick（Synthetix创始人）曾一起从事电子商务工作，于 2015 年进入加密货币行业，曾在澳大利亚一家场外交易所担任市场销售总监一职。2016年7月离开加密货币行业从事食品行业，2020年随着DeFi兴起，Kieran 再次回到加密货币行业，于2020年9月创建了Illuvium。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*dhe5U4ymFiBBLsdB01nG4w.png" /></figure><p><strong>Aaron Warwick — 联合创始人</strong>，伍伦贡大学计算机科学和物理学学士学位，毕业后从事过零售行业，也担任过网球教练，2020年9月参与创建了Illuvium，并且深度参与游戏设计以及行政等工作。Kieran和Aaron，以及Synthetix的创始人Kain三人是兄弟关系，家族拥有体育背景，经营着价值数百万美元的零售特许经营权，包括澳大利亚的几个主要的体育中心。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*E4YeTZBUyNnGwb4R_dhNGg.png" /></figure><p><strong>John Avery — 首席技术官</strong>，澳大利亚联邦大学计算机科学学士学位。毕业后曾长期在游戏和金融服务行业从事软件开发工作。其很早就开始参与了App Store上的游戏开发，并且其所处的JNA Mobile公司一度是当时Unity Asset Store上重要的发行商之一，发行的游戏拥有超过100万用户。2020年12月，Avery加入Illuvium，并担任首席技术官至今。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*q3kOdXq-GKfYm94FkOA5og.png" /></figure><p><strong>Danny Wilson — 首席财务官</strong>，曾长期从事零售行业的相关工作，并曾经担任Harvey Norman的零售特许经营总监，随后担任Harvey Norman下属子公司常务董事，还参与创办了一家Apple授权服务提供商MAC1，并且担任常务董事，随后Danny在多家初创企业担任顾问一职，并且参与创立了一家Web3投资基金Oracle Venture。2020年12月，Danny加入Illuvium，担任首席财务官至今。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/114/1*MxRRVA392nBuyYKhge-ibw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Benjamin Nietzsche — 首席游戏设计师</strong>，曾长期从事游戏相关行业的开发工作。2013年参与创办了Aequus Gaming，为英雄联盟玩家开发第三方软件，包括LolReplay和LSI。2014年Nietzsche加入Riot Games担任第三方顾问。2018年，Nietzsche加入独立游戏工作室HeadByte Studios并且担任首席游戏设计师。2021年3月，Nietzsche加入Illuvium，并且担任首席游戏设计师至今。</p><p>目前根据官网资料，目前团队102人当中，有49名艺术家，负责游戏美术，模型，概念，特效等方面的设计与落地，15名工程师负责游戏本体的开发，此外还有9名负责保证游戏质量的测试人员，以及7名负责搭建游戏服务器的工程师。<strong>总的来看，目前Illuvium的核心团队均有一定的游戏行业以及区块链行业的从业和开发经验，并且游戏的开发团队较为扎实，拥有不错的游戏开发能力。</strong></p><p><strong>2.2 资金</strong></p><p>2.2.1 <strong>游戏外融资</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/982/1*q17W1ynSy_FHd2XXyv2uhg.png" /><figcaption><strong>表2–1 Illuvium融资情况</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>截至2024年3月27日，Illuvium在游戏外共完成了4轮融资，总融资额达到了6,500万美元，投资者当中包括IOSG Ventures，Framework Ventures，Animoca Brands，Spartan Capital，Polygon Ventures，Yield Guild Games，Delphi Digital等。最近一轮融资完成于2024年3月27日，因此团队目前资金能力应该较为充足。</strong></p><p>2.2.2 <strong>Illuvium Zero土地销售</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*QQrCwcFx4wFp1Z9-R1TJCw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–1 Illuvium Zero土地销售说明[2]</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*fF0TrBZ6TVtaBcIyF5aaEw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–2 Illuvium Zero土地销售结果</strong></figcaption></figure><p>2022年6月6日，Illuvium宣布通过Illuvium Zero土地的销售筹集了约7,219 万美元，共出售了10万块Illuvium Zero土地当中的19,969块土地。土地分为5个等级，不同等级的土地有不同的游戏增益，前四种等级的土地采用荷兰拍的形式进行拍卖，并且可以用ETH和sILV2来进行竞拍，最高等级的土地采用英格兰式拍卖的形式进行拍卖，只能用ETH来进行竞拍。</p><p>拍卖期间，各等级土地价格波动较为剧烈。T1等级土地起拍价为2 ETH，成交价为0.3 ETH至2 ETH。T2等级土地起拍价为6 ETH，成交价为0.97 ETH至6 ETH。T3等级土地起拍价为20 ETH，成交价为3.67 ETH至20 ETH。T4等级土地起拍价为80 ETH，成交价为13.6 ETH至76 ETH。</p><p>本轮拍卖共筹得4,018枚ETH以及239,388枚sILV2，其中4,018枚ETH将被交易为ILV代币并重新分配给ILV质押者，其余sILV2将被销毁以减少代币供应量，销毁的sILV2代币约占代币总供应量的2.39%。</p><p>2.2.3 <strong>Illuvium Beyond D1SK销售</strong></p><p>Illuvitar是Illuvium Beyond上的一种可定制肖像类NFT。玩家通过购买D1SK来获取Illuvitar和它的配件，从而搭配出专属的Illuvitar NFT，配件有五种类型，包括头饰，眼镜，皮肤，衣服与道具。D1SK有两种类型，Standard D1SK和 Mega D1SK。其中Standard D1SK包含1个Illuvitar、3个配件和1个T0等级的Illuvitar，售价为0.005 ETH。Mega D1SK则是将Standard D1SK当中的T0等级的Illuvitar替换为更稀有的Illuvitar，但是价格相比Standard D1SK会更贵，售价为0.025 ETH。</p><p>Illuvium的第一波D1SK Alpha销售于2023年3月7日开始，本轮次销售的D1SK将拥有Alpha的特殊稀有属性标注。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*WgFj_SpsQzmfQ9KnWJM0VQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–3 Illuvitar D1SK Alpha销售说明[3]</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*Oev9x2_dFI6TML5DHmtCVQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–4 Illuvium D1SK Alpha销售说明[4]</strong></figcaption></figure><p>第一轮D1SK Alpha销售共售出20,000个Alpha Mega D1SK和20,600个Standard Alpha D1SK，总收入约为47,844枚sILV2和742枚ETH，折合约475万美元。后续Illuvium又开始了多轮D1SK促销活动。包括：</p><p>2023年6月12日，Illuvium推出了与GameStop的联合D1SK促销活动。销售的每个D1SK都会包含一个独特的GameStop品牌Illuvitar，每个D1SK售价约50美元。Illuvium未公布该轮促销活动详细销售金额。</p><p>2023年9月8日，Illuvium开启了第二轮D1SK销售，推出了全新的Illuvitar，且Standard D1SK售价降低至0.00301 ETH，Mega D1SK售价将地址0.01801 ETH。Illuvium未公布该轮促销活动详细销售金额。</p><p>2023年11月30日，Illuvium推出了与Team Liquid的联合D1SK促销活动。销售的每个Promo D1SK都会包含一个独特的Team Liquid品牌Illuvitar，每个D1SK售价约40美元。Illuvium未公布该轮促销活动详细销售金额。</p><p><strong>截至2024年3月27日，Illuvium在游戏外共完成了4轮融资，总融资额达到了6,500万美元，投资者当中包括IOSG Ventures，Framework Ventures，Animoca Brands，Spartan Capital，Polygon Ventures，Yield Guild Games，Delphi Digital等。最近一轮1,200万美元A轮融资完成于2024年3月27日，因此团队目前资金能力应该较为充足。游戏内的NFT销售共完成了两轮，土地销售和D1SK销售总销售额约7,694万美元，但由于这部分游戏内销售所获得的代币主要用于销毁以及回馈给ILV质押者，因此这部分收入将不计入团队的资金部分。总的来看，目前Illuvium整体资金情况良好，应该能够支持后续的游戏开发与运营。</strong></p><p><strong>2.3 产品与技术</strong></p><p>2.3.1 <strong>游戏简介</strong></p><p>Illuvium并非是一款游戏，而是由多个游戏组成的游戏世界，在这个游戏世界当中，每一款游戏都有着各自在世界中所扮演的角色。从大的分类上，可以将Illuvium当中的游戏简单地分为<strong>供给类</strong>和<strong>需求类</strong>两类游戏，<strong>前者以投入产出为主要目的，玩家投入一定的现实资源然后产出游戏资源来为整个游戏世界的运行奠定基础</strong>，而同时Illuvium官方也可以调整游戏资源的产出量来维持整个游戏世界整体的经济平衡。<strong>后者以竞技消耗为主要目的，玩家利用获取的游戏资源来进行对抗，在对抗的过程当中消耗掉逐渐积累的游戏资源</strong>，Illuvium官方则可以通过调整竞技游戏的平衡性来激发玩家的竞技需求，从而调整游戏资源的消耗量来维持整个游戏世界整体的经济平衡。<strong>而根据官方目前的游戏机制设定，模拟经营类游戏Zero和开放世界冒险类游戏Overworld主要是作为供给类游戏而存在，自走棋形式的策略竞技类游戏Arena和NFT收集类游戏Beyond主要是作为需求类游戏而存在。</strong>除此以外Illuvium还开发了一个专门为了生态内游戏道具进行交易的市场IlluviDex，玩家可以在其中使用ETH买卖游戏道具，并且完成跨游戏的道具交互。</p><p>游戏的背景设定当中，玩家将作为星际舰队当中的幸存者，在一个疑似为文明诞生地的陌生星球上面调查一个神秘的讯号。在这个星球上有着多变的气候，复杂的地形，以及一种被称为Illuvials的野兽。这种名为Illuvials的野兽拥有一些特殊的能量，而玩家可以用从星球表面开采出来的水晶碎片来捕捉并控制这种野兽。玩家将在这个世界当中进行探索，收集，建造以及竞争等活动来揭开这个星球的神秘面纱。</p><p>2.3.2 <strong>Illuvium Zero</strong></p><p>Illuvium Zero是Illuvium游戏世界的基础，玩家将通过一款模拟经营游戏扮演在异星球求生的幸存者，开发周边的矿藏，生产相应的资源来支援未来对于这颗神秘行星的探索。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*JnaWbpODEC66j3VugrtvHw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–5 Zero游戏画面</strong></figcaption></figure><p>在Zero当中，玩家可以选择购买土地NFT或者未来在官方提供的免费土地上建造一系列的建筑，来开采和开发地块当中的资源。土地当中固有的资源包含元素矿和燃料矿，玩家可以建造建筑来开采和开发这些矿产，其中元素矿当中可以开采出Hydrogen（氢），Carbon（碳）以及 Silicon（硅）这三种元素，燃料矿当中可以开采出Crypton（绿豆）、Hyperion（彩豆） 以及Solon（黄豆）这三种燃料。其中元素将被用于在Zero当中建造和升级相应的建筑物，燃料则将作为Overworld当中重要的一种资源被使用，绿豆在Overworld当中将作为玩家进入高等级区域的消耗品，彩豆和黄豆将被用来制造和升级Overworld当中的装备皮肤以及无人机皮肤，除此之外玩家所开采出来的燃料将可以以ERC-20的形式存储在钱包里面，然后在官方市场IlluviDex出售给其他有需求的Overworld玩家。</p><p>除了固有资源以外，土地当中还有illuvial作为随机资源，玩家可以建造一个特殊建筑，来扫描随机经过土地当中的Illuvials，在获取了Illuvials的生物数据以后，玩家可以在另一个特殊建筑当中继续研究这个数据以生成一个蓝图NFT，该NFT可以用于在Overworld当中制作装备皮肤和无人机皮肤，或者同样可以在官方市场IlluviDex出售给其他有需求的Overworld玩家。</p><p>Zero的付费土地共分为5级，总量为10万个，目前第一批土地销售已售出19,969块土地。不同级别的土地代表着不同的稀有程度，越稀有的土地可以生产的资源就越多，资源的产量加成就越多，同时T3，T4和T5土地还有独特的特殊加成（Landmark地标）和功能，相应的价格也越贵，目前T1至T4等级的土地可以在IlluviDex市场进行购买，而T5级别的土地将只能通过拍卖获得。此外由于元素矿和燃料矿的数量和位置是随机分布的，有些土地可能会面临一种矿产过剩而另一种矿产不足的局面，因此玩家需要策略性地选择更均衡的土地进行购买。此外玩家在整个地图当中的位置也会对土地发展产生一定的影响，未来如果玩家同时拥有多个位置相邻的土地，那么这些土地将可以实现资源互通，并且被合并来形成规模效应。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bLBS0rj66FlbqaTj_PXRxA.png" /><figcaption><strong>表2–1 土地类型[5]</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A_IoD1eoB80bBvcB9NUIlQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>表2–2 土地详情</strong></figcaption></figure><p>在土地之上，玩家可以在有限的空间当中建造相应的建筑来开发土地当中的资源。目前可以建造的建筑有以下几种类型：<br><strong>1）基础设施。</strong>主基地（Nexus），可以决定建筑物数量上限；工程车间（Engineering Workshop），开采资源开采场和电厂的前置建筑；量子制造者（Quantum Fabricant），燃料矿场和科技建筑的前置建筑；电厂（Power Station），可以提升开采场和资源转换器的产量。<br><strong>2）开采场。</strong>泥沙挖掘机（Sediment Excavator），碳矿开采场；矿场（Mine），硅矿开采场；氢气泵（Hydrogen Pump），氢矿开采场；绿豆矿场（Crypton Gate），绿豆燃料获取池；彩豆矿场（Hyperion Extractor），彩豆燃料获取池；黄豆矿场（Solon Dredge），黄豆燃料获取池。<br><strong>3）转换器。</strong>碳转换器（Sequestrian Plant），自动生产碳元素，并且可以将其他两个元素转换为碳元素；硅转换器（Photodisintegration Plant），自动生产硅元素，并且可以将其他两个元素转换为硅元素；氢转换器（Condenser Plant），自动生产氢元素，并且可以将其他两个元素转换为氢元素；绿豆转换器（L-Crypton Collider）自动生产绿豆，并且可以将其他两种燃料转换为绿豆；彩豆转换器（Hyperion Lathe）自动生产彩豆，并且可以将其他两种燃料转换为彩豆；黄豆转换器（Anti-Solon Inverter）自动生产黄豆，并且可以将其他两种燃料转换为黄豆。<br><strong>4）仓库。</strong>碳仓库（Carbon Matter Sil）；硅仓库（Silicon Matter Silo）；氢仓库（Hydrogen Matter silo）；绿豆仓库（Crypton Containment Unit）；彩豆仓库（Hyperion Containment Unit）；黄豆仓库（Solon Containment Unit）。<br><strong>5）高科技建筑。</strong>奇点扫描仪（Singularity Scanner），用于扫描经过土地的Illuvials；零点传感器（Zero Point Transducer），制造蓝图的前置建筑；材料实验室（Materials Lab），用于研究回传过来的生物数据，生产图鉴或者蓝图，也有可能失败；数据库（Data Bank），用于提升实验室的产量和良率； <br><strong>6）其他。</strong>全息雕像（Holographic Statue），展示扫描到的Illuvials，并且增加未来再次扫描到的几率；市场（Marketplace），可以让玩家在游戏内置换所需要的资源。</p><p><strong>除了建筑的建造时间选择和资源分配选择以外，玩家还需要考虑为建筑之间安排合适的位置和路径，不同的位置和路径会对资源生产类建筑的产量有非常大的影响，并且游戏当中每一次修改建筑物的位置与路径都会产生很大的成本消耗。因此只有路径被合理安排，并且位置被充分规划的情况下，玩家才能够获得最高效的资源产出。以上这些要点都会考验玩家在策略端的投入，增加玩家参与游戏时的趣味性。</strong></p><p>除此之外Illuvium官方在游戏内扮演的角色主要是宏观资源的调控者，由于玩家生产的燃料效率是有限的，可能不能充足供给Overworld游戏的发展，因此当玩家以ERC-20的形式铸造1个的燃料豆并且进行交易时，Illuvium的财库当中就会同时铸造19个燃料豆，也就是说玩家在Zero当中的产出最多会被扩大20倍投入到Overworld当中，但是这个产出究竟什么时候以多少量投入到Overworld当中将由Illuvium官方来控制。Illuvium官方会在燃料豆价格大幅波动的时候，出手干预燃料豆的供给以稳定燃料豆的价格，以降低有人恶意控制游戏内资源价格的风险。除此之外，这样的设定也意味着玩家在收获1个燃料豆的收益的时候，整个游戏会增加20个燃料豆的收益，剩余19份燃料豆未来卖出后所获得的收益将会被财库分配给ILV代币的持有者。简单来说，在整个Zero游戏当中，5%的收益将归于土地持有者，95%的收益未来将归于Illuvium生态参与者。并且这个比例未来可以通过Illuvium DAO治理来进行修改，以更好地分配游戏所产生的利润。除此之外，Illuvium作为游戏的开发者，未来还有可能会设计出更多独特的玩法，建筑和资源来丰富玩家的游戏体验。</p><p>游戏目前已经进入公测阶段，目前仅限付费土地购买者可以参与游戏，本阶段打造的蓝图可以保留到后续使用，但是其他数据将在正式版上线后重置，游戏在PC端（MAC，Windows）和移动端（Android）皆有提供。</p><p>2.3.3 <strong>Overworld</strong></p><p>Overworld是与游戏世界观绑定最为紧密的一款开放世界冒险类游戏。其主打的就是冒险，探索和捕捉。玩家将扮演星球上的探索者，配备无人机在各个区域之中收集矿石，打造装备以及捕捉Illuvials。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*jOajYPxiaGQE_FTwMCmfEg.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–6 Overworld游戏画面</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Overworld设计有8个区域，其中1个是初始区域，其他7个为可探索区域，不同区域当中有不同的景观，对应会出现不同类型的资源和不同属性的Illuvials。区域也被设定有4个等级，不同等级所需要的绿豆燃料数量不同，产出的资源等级和Illuvials等级也不同。并且玩家在区域当中存在一个电量限制，玩家在区域内的行动都会消耗电量，并且在电量消耗完毕后就必须离开该区域，因此玩家需要在区域内合理地安排自己的行动。</p><p>玩家能够在区域当中获得的材料主要是矿石、植物和一些材料，然后玩家还可以通过Shards道具来捕捉Illuvials，然后通过在战斗空间当中与Illuvials进行卡牌战斗来收服Illuvials。在获得材料以后，玩家可以打造一些新的道具。这些道具有两种类型，一种类型可以用于搜集物资或者提升物资搜集的效率，包括无人机蓝图（Drone）、装备（Equipment）、符（Shards，相当于宝可梦游戏里面的精灵球）。另一种类型主要是用于制造Arena当中的卡牌，包括功能卡（Augments）、武器盔甲（Armaments）、战斗卡牌（Illuvials）等。此外，Overworld当中道具的制作需要消耗Zero当中产出的彩豆和黄豆，打造出来的道具也可以在IlluviDex当中出售给有需要的玩家。</p><p>Overworld作为一个开放世界冒险类游戏，其主打的两点，一点是在不同区域之间的冒险体验，感受游戏的美术设计所带来的视觉震撼。另一点在于让玩家体验到收集与制造的乐趣，在Overworld当中加大了这些机制所占的比重，从而让玩家能够拥有更多的获得感。</p><p>该游戏目前正处于内测当中，内测资格需要向官方发送邮件申请激活码，游戏本体目前可以在Epic Games商城当中下载，有一定的电脑配置要求。</p><p>2.3.4 <strong>Arena</strong></p><p>Arena作为一款策略竞技类游戏，与模拟经营游戏Zero和开放世界冒险类游戏Overworld在定位上有根本性的不同。Arena无需有繁琐的各种资源收集和制作流程，玩家仅需依托自己组建的Illuvials卡组进行PVE或者PVP的自走棋策略对战即可。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*hPTJzZyIhPMKQpsKKpPveA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–7 Arena游戏画面</strong></figcaption></figure><p>在游戏机制的核心设计上，Arena的自走棋设定与其他的自走棋没有太大的区别。游戏采用回合对战制，玩家需要每回合使用金币来购买对应的棋子并且置于场上进行对战。自走棋当中的每一个棋子都有各自的特殊能力和特点，也有职业和羁绊两种属性，玩家需要依托这两种属性来凑出相应的羁绊，提升棋子的能力，同时玩家也可以通过重复购买同一个棋子，进行合成操作，提升棋子本身的能力，改变棋子的造型。</p><p><strong>从职业来看，Arena当中的棋子主要有5种基本职业，分别是战士、守护、刺客、法师以及辅助。</strong>不同的职业主要区分的是棋子的功能，例如战士和守护主要用于置于前排承担对方棋子的伤害，刺客主要用于绕过对方前排棋子对后排棋子造成伤害，而法师和辅助则作为后排单位对对方单位进行攻击，或者为场上单位增加BUFF。除此之外同一个棋子也可以拥有多个职业，进而玩家的策略选择与阵容搭配将更为丰富。</p><p><strong>从属性来看，Arena当中的棋子主要有5种基本属性，分别是水，火，土，木，气。</strong>这五种基本属性之间呈现出相互克制的关系。每个棋子可以是无属性，也可以拥有一个或者一个以上的复合属性。当棋子拥有一个或者一个以上属性时，棋子的主属性将成为主要的克制判断依据。当两个对立的棋子之间存在属性克制时，将触发一个捕食的效果，属性克制方将获得一个激昂的Buff，并在状态栏充能完毕后获得战斗能力的加强。因此对于玩家来讲，针对不同的敌人选择不同属性克制的棋子也将是考验玩家策略能力的重要一环。</p><p>除了基础棋子之外，玩家还可以通过符文系统和装备系统来为自己的棋子增加独特的效果或者能力加成来提升某一阶段棋子阵容的能力，进而提升策略的对抗性。</p><p>截至2024年3月27日，Arena当中已经推出了205个不同属性，职业以及等级的棋子，87种不同等级和类型的符文，81种功能各异的超级符文。玩家未来将可以在市场上购买这些卡牌，或者自己在Overworld当中制作相应的卡牌来组建自己的卡组，在Arena的竞技场当中来赢得每一个赛季的天梯奖金。</p><p>Illuvium官方在Arena当中所扮演的角色主要为运营方和赛事的裁判，Illuvium官方负责推出新的卡牌来丰富玩家的游戏体验，同时也要每个版本调整旧的卡牌的平衡性来维持整个游戏的竞技性，这将对Illuvium官方的数值调整能力和运营能力提出很高的要求。</p><p>Arena目前仍然处于内测阶段，但已经在Epic Games上架，有一定的电脑配置要求。并且未来如果玩家希望能够参加天梯模式来获得天梯奖金的话，则需要至少持有一个包含28张卡牌的有效卡组。</p><p>2.3.5 <strong>Beyond</strong></p><p>Beyond是Illuvium官方于2023年6月推出的一款NFT收集类游戏，或者严格来讲是一款肖像类PFP制作类游戏。</p><p>Beyond与其他三款游戏之间的关系相对独立，玩家可以通过购买D1SK来获得Illuvitar头像以及饰品，并且可以通过装备不同的饰品来定制自己的肖像类PFP。此外玩家还可以在IlluviDex当中买卖这些NFT，然后配置出符合自己需求的头像，并且用这些头像参加官方举办的稀有度竞赛，该竞赛每周都将举办一次，排名前100的头像持有者将可获得ILV作为奖励。</p><p>未来这些头像也将成为Illuvium玩家参与这个庞大的游戏世界时的个人标志和社交媒介。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/506/1*-40e6HcP170yWn_cvrQEMw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–8 Beyond游戏画面</strong></figcaption></figure><p>2.3.6 <strong>总结</strong></p><p>目前来看，Illuvium的四款游戏的设计基本符合了其在游戏世界在构建之初就奠定的原则，即不同的游戏拥有各自独立的玩法和机制来面向不同的玩家群体，但又可以通过游戏的经济机制将这些游戏互相串联起来，形成一个繁荣的游戏生态。从完成度来看，Zero，Overworld，Arena在各自的游戏机制和品质上均已经有了不错的完成度，未来要做的是在技术上打通各个游戏之间的联系，同时Illuvium的特殊游戏代币sILV2未来也将在这个游戏世界当中发挥更重要的能力，从而保证整个生态拥有足够的可持续性。以上种种，都对Illuvium团队的开发和运营能力提出了很高的要求，但就目前来看，团队的表现还基本令玩家满意。</p><p><strong>总结</strong></p><p><strong>从团队和资金来看，Illuvium的开发团队有着充足的开发经验和不错的开发能力，项目融资情况较好，于3月27日刚完成了一笔1,200万的A轮融资，因此资金面也较为充裕。</strong></p><p><strong>从产品来看Illuvium设计了一个由模拟经营类游戏Zero，开放世界冒险类游戏Overworld，自走棋形式的策略竞技类游戏Arena和NFT收集类游戏Beyond组成的庞大的游戏世界。在这个游戏世界当中，每个游戏都拥有独特的游戏玩法机制来面向不同的玩家群体，但是又通过不同游戏之间互通资源的开采和利用将这四个游戏串联了起来，使得玩家在这个游戏世界当中可以获得更加丰富的游戏体验。目前这四个游戏都已经有了不错的完成度，其中Zero和Beyond已经公测面世，而Overworld和Arena还在内测阶段，预计不久后将开始公测。从更长时间来看，Illuvium的游戏世界设计对Illuvium团队的开发能力和运营提出了非常大的考验，尤其是后期收集类游戏的产率调整和竞技类游戏的平衡性调整都将是团队必须攻克的难题，目前Illuvium已经证明了自己的开发能力，但是其运营能力还有待进一步实践的检验。</strong></p><h4>3. <strong>发展</strong></h4><p><strong>3.1 历史</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wa-ll-pkJFitM48XWOJZlw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>表3–1 Illuvium大事件</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>3.2 现状</strong></p><p>3.2.1 <strong>运营数据</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*nc3geGJWmApydrbAT20NQA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图3–1 Illuvium Zero土地交易数据[6]</strong></figcaption></figure><p>根据Immutable X的区块浏览器，截至2024年3月21日17时，Illuvium Zero上的土地共发生了11,392笔交易，总交易额达到了10,753 ETH，平均每块土地的交易价格为0.944 ETH，当前的地板价为0.12 ETH，独立持有地址为7,680个。</p><p>其余Illuvium游戏因为还在进行内测，暂无详细运营数据。</p><p>3.2.2 <strong>社交媒体规模</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o7Aq-tZgqjwnWg-F4ejS-Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>表3–2 Illuvium社交媒体数据</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>截止2024年3月21日，Illuvium的社交媒体平台规模较大，粉丝数量较多，互动频繁，社区人数较多，活跃度较高，内容主要围绕游戏机制以及代币机制展开</strong>。</p><p><strong>3.3 未来</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*zcPWuqS6Q_s5ExKonj15Gw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图3–2 Illuvium 2024年路线图[7]</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*JeoXViNVpTdLEFPvzbA_RA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图3–3 Illuvium 2024年Q2路线图</strong></figcaption></figure><p>根据Illuvium公布的路线图，接下来2024年一整年Illuvium的主要发展方向还将集中于游戏的开发上，预计将很快推出Arena和Overworld内测的第四个版本，2024年第二季度，Illuvium计划将推出公测版本的游戏世界，并且发售Beyond的第三波D1SK，2024年第三季度，Illuvium计划公布一个新的游戏，2024年第四季度，Illuvium计划推出ILV质押的V3，并且发售Beyond的第四波D1SK。除此之外，Illuvium还公布了主网测试版本结束以后的空投计划，预计空投计划的推出将为游戏带来更多的玩家参与。</p><p><strong>总结：</strong></p><p><strong>从项目发展来看，目前Illuvium发展仍处于初级阶段，Arena和Overworld仍然处于内测阶段，游戏世界的整体构想距离完成目前仍有一段距离。但是游戏目前已经累积了较高的人气，社区与社交媒体较为活跃，预计Arena和Overworld进入公测阶段以后Illuvium将迎来更多的玩家参与。</strong></p><p>4. <strong>经济模型</strong></p><p><strong>4.1 供给</strong></p><p>4.1.1 <strong>ILV代币分配</strong></p><p>ILV作为Illuvium的治理代币，于2021年2月上线主网，总供应量为10,000,000枚，截至2024年3月27日，ILV代币的供应量为9,605,840枚[8]，流通量为6,334,671枚。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sFMRen-iGTyYQe4SdojQXQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>表4–1 预计ILV代币大致分配情况</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/454/1*mehUrBW_3UGUahkdXdAwIQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>图4–1 ILV代币分配图[9]</strong></figcaption></figure><p>从分配来看，分配给融资的代币占了代币总量的30%，分配给团队和财库的代币占了总分配的30%，剩余40%的代币将作为流动性质押奖励和游戏内奖励被分配给生态参与者。由于代币发行时间较久，目前大部分的代币均已解锁。</p><p><strong>此外ILV代币存在一种合成子代币sILV2，主要用于购买游戏当中的物品和服务</strong>，例如在Zero的土地销售和Beyond的D1SK销售中，除了支持ETH付款外，还支持用sILV2来进行付款。获取sILV2的方式只能通过质押ILV代币，且sILV2代币与ILV代币的兑换是单向且不可逆的，每一枚铸造出来的sILV2代币都会使得ILV代币的流通量减少一枚。长期来看，由于sILV2代币与ILV代币不可逆兑换的存在，随着游戏正式投入运营，更多的ILV被单向铸造为sILV2代币，ILV代币将走向通缩，截至2024年3月22日，sILV2代币共被铸造了154,310枚[10]。</p><p>4.1.2 <strong>持币地址分析</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/695/1*kpYEGzPGTghmgHueMMyPLA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图4–2 ILV持币地址分析[11]</strong></figcaption></figure><p>从上图4–2可知，据Ethereum的浏览器显示，截至2024年3月27日，ILV共有持币地址50187个，前100名持仓占比90.22%。其中前20的持币地址当中有4个合约地址，持仓占比约为63.41%，包括ILV代币的归属合约地址，财库地址以及质押池地址，7个交易所地址，持仓占比约为9.66%，上述两者总占比达到了73.07%，除此之外还有3个归属于IOSG Ventures和Delphi Digital的资本地址，持仓占比约为1.63%。<strong>因此在扣除部分上述代币以后，我们可以看到ILV代币的总体持仓较为分散。</strong></p><p><strong>4.2 需求</strong></p><p>ILV代币作为Illuvium的治理代币，其主要的职能除了参与协议的治理之外，其最重要的职能是进行质押以分享项目发展的红利。用户可以在Illuvium的质押界面，质押自己所持有的ILV代币，并且在1到12个月不等的锁定期后，取回自己的本金，以及取回质押奖励。质押奖励可以选择以ILV代币或者sILV2的形式取回，其中以ILV形式取回的话，这部分质押奖励将有12个月的归属期，以sILV2的形式取回的话，这部分奖励将即刻解锁，并且可以在游戏内的购买当中使用，这也是用户获取sILV2代币的唯一方式。</p><p>用户目前可以选择的质押池有两个，一个是ILV代币池，一个是ILV/ETH代币池。前者是Illuvium自己设定的质押池，用户仅需要质押ILV代币即可获得质押奖励，但是分得的流动性质押奖励份额较低，仅占全部质押奖励的20%，截至2024年3月27日，该流动性池总锁仓约为338,761,280 USD，预估APR为2.93%，预估代币质押量为2,219,930枚，包含了流动性质押池当中的代币，部分财库当中的代币与还未分配仍存在于归属合约当中的代币。后者是与SushiSwap合作的流动性池，用户除了需要质押ILV代币以外还需要质押ETH代币，不过该代币分得的流动性质押奖励份额较高，占全部质押奖励的80%，且除了流动性质押奖励之外，还可以获得流动性池当中交易的交易费用作为额外奖励，该流动性池当中共质押有291,165枚ILV代币，加上质押的ETH，总锁仓量约为80,519,968 USD，预估APR为49.29%，预估代币质押量为263,827枚。两个流动性池当中的质押代币相加后，预估当前ILV代币质押总量约为2,483,757枚，占当前代币供应量的约25.86%。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*bc_CQKqPM5xuGIpUPiBLnQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>图4–3 ILV流动性质押池</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/454/1*f-uaBYkWXF65wRZBAQ2Sfw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图4–4 ILV代币流动性质押奖励[12]</strong></figcaption></figure><p>ILV代币的质押收益有两个来源，一个是占ILV代币本身供应量30%的流动性质押奖励。这部分质押奖励每14天为一个Epoch进行发放，总共分78轮，目前已经进入到了第71轮Epoch。截至2024年3月27日，本轮Epoch总预估发放代币约为11,694 ILV，其中ILV流动性池将分得2,339枚ILV代币，ILV/ETH池将分得9,355枚ILV代币。已经发放的总ILV代币数量约为292万枚，已经占流动性质押奖励的97.33%，预计7月上旬所有流动性质押奖励将被发放完毕。</p><p>除了流动性质押奖励之外，ILV的质押收益还包括游戏本身的盈利。根据Illuvium治理提案IIP-45-R[13]，在扣除成本之后，游戏当中所有的营业收入当中的5%将被分配给Illuvium Zero当中土地的持有者，其余的95%将被Vault合约用于购买ILV/ETH流动性池当中的ILV代币，随后作为质押奖励分配给当轮Epoch的质押者。</p><p>这里以D1SK销售举例，假设一轮D1SK销售共获得了1000枚ETH代币以及4000枚sILV2代币，那么按照Illuvium的分配规则，本轮销售当中的50枚ETH代币将被分配给Illuvium Zero当中土地的持有者，剩下的950枚ETH代币将被Vault合约收集，并且用于购买ILV/ETH流动性池当中的ILV代币，随后于当轮Epoch分配给ILV代币的质押者。除此之外，用于购买D1SK的sILV2代币未来也会被作为RevDis（利润分配）分配给ILV代币质押者，或者销毁来降低代币的总供应量。</p><p>总的来看，ILV的质押设计秉承的原则就是充分反哺游戏核心参与者，推动游戏生态可持续发展。</p><p><strong>总结：</strong></p><p><strong>从代币经济学的角度来看，ILV代币主要作为网络的治理代币，其主要职能在于反哺游戏核心参与者以推动游戏生态的可持续发展。目前从机制设定上来讲，ILV代币通过质押机制基本可以实现以上目标，但是该机制对于游戏后续的盈利能力提出了较高的要求，有待之后的实践来给出答案。</strong></p><p>5. <strong>赛道</strong></p><p>Illuvium属于链游赛道，但因该赛道本身项目之间差异较大，无法进行定量分析，因此本节内容仅讨论赛道现状与赛道未来，而不再进行竞品分析。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*PnzO_uizj-_kwiTAKr2HbQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>图5–1 链游周活跃度以及交易量[14]</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*ZNo7aNlYc4btlaZulDR1MA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图5–2 链游活跃用户数量</strong></figcaption></figure><p>自从2023年年末，市场进入新一轮牛市以来，链游赛道取得了显著的成长，成为了本轮牛市当中领涨的主要赛道之一。<strong>从数据可以看到链游赛道正在经历2021年末以来的第二个快速成长期。</strong>链游玩家的数量增长迅速，最多时活跃用户数量已经超过了300万人，且交易活跃，市场参与热情大。如果按照上一轮快速成长期时的玩家留存率来估计的话，本轮成长期结束以后，链游的核心用户群体将维持在250万人以上，是上一轮市场底部核心玩家群体数量的接近三倍。这意味着未来整个链游赛道的体量将有非常大的增长空间，可能会涌现更多的顶级项目。</p><p>纵观本轮快速成长期，我们可以发现有一些些许的变化。<br><strong>1）链游项目类型变得更加多样化。</strong>相比于上一轮链游成长期以角色扮演类，模拟经营类和运动类为主导赛道格局来讲，本轮链游成长期当中除了以上这三个传统的链游类型以外，强调对抗性和策略性的大型多人在线角色扮演类，动作类，射击类，战棋类，战略模拟类，MOBA类等链游类型也逐渐涌现出了各自的代表项目。<br><strong>2）链游的质量有了显著提升。</strong>这个提升一方面在游戏的品质上，越来越多的游戏开始采用时下最流行的游戏引擎进行相应的开发，美术设计上也越来越讲求美观，开始逐渐抛弃了初期以廉价像素风为主流的美术风格，游戏玩法上也更加强调机制的合理性和多样性，在可玩度上与传统的游戏行业快速靠拢。另一方面也反映在了游戏的运营上，由于旧游戏行业人才的快速流入，目前几个主流链游的运营理念和方式越来越接近于传统网络游戏行业的模式，该成熟的模式短期之内仍能充分起到推动游戏发展以及即时与玩家沟通的作用。因此品质与运营两者结合，使得本轮的链游和上轮的链游在观感上有了显著的提升。</p><p><strong>但本轮快速成长期面临的最大问题在于，其仍然没有摆脱第一轮链游快速成长期对其的影响。严格来说，本轮的链游快速成长期还没有涌现出革新了链游这个赛道范式的项目。</strong>因为本质上本轮链游的快速成长期之所以会产生，除了牛市的背景以外，还因为链游的开发需要一定的时间。开发较为简单的链游能率先推出市场，占据先发优势，而需要大成本投入的链游项目则需要动辄两三年的开发时间才能真正落地，这中间的时间差决定了大型的链游项目必然是会迟于市场认知的，且大型的链游项目参与人数更多，成本较大，转型较为困难。这意味着，本轮的大型链游作为上一轮链游赛道发展的后发者，其实是很难在第一轮链游快速成长期时所积累的经验和教训的基础上做出大的创新的，只能继续深化和发展“Play To Earn”概念在游戏经济模型当中的实践。</p><p>目前来看，Illuvium是目前少数几个在区块链游戏底层逻辑上做出创新的游戏项目，其不再依靠一个单一机制和玩法的游戏来获取用户，而是试图从底层架构上建立起一套行之有效的经济模型来将多个游戏串联起来，这样的游戏生态预计将会比传统的单一区块链游戏世界更有生命力。</p><p><strong>总结</strong></p><p><strong>从赛道的角度来看，2023年年末以来，链游赛道取得了快速地发展，交易量和用户量都有了显著的增长，从数据上来看预计本轮市场周期结束以后，链游赛道的核心用户群体将至少是原先的一倍以上，这意味着在未来的很长一段时间内，链游赛道仍将有广阔的市场空间。本轮链游赛道的发展当中呈现出了游戏类型多样化和游戏质量提升这两个特点，是本轮链游用户数量持续快速增长的主要原因。但是目前来看，本轮的链游游戏大多没有跳脱出“Play To Earn”的框架，做出的创新较少，而Illuvium是目前少数几个在区块链游戏底层逻辑上做出创新的游戏项目，其不再依靠一个单一机制和玩法的游戏来获取用户，而是试图从底层架构上建立起一套行之有效的经济模型来将多个游戏串联起来，这样的游戏生态预计将会比传统的单一区块链游戏世界更有生命力。。</strong></p><p>6. <strong>风险</strong></p><p><strong>1）代码安全性风险：</strong>Illuvium的质押合约目前已经经过了多轮审计，但仍有存在代码安全性风险的可能性。此外Illuvium的各个游戏目前代码未开源，安全性未知，未来有出现相应外挂的可能性。</p><p><strong>2）市场风险：</strong>当下游戏市场竞争较为激烈，各种类型的游戏层出不穷。</p><p><strong>3）运营风险：</strong>竞技类和生产类游戏均对游戏项目方提出了较高的运营要求。</p><p><strong>4）代币风险：</strong>ILV作为项目重要的治理代币，存在代币价格大幅波动影响项目本身开发和运营的可能性。</p><p><strong>5）开发风险：</strong>游戏项目开发难度较大，开发时间较长，存在无法按时交付的风险。</p><p>推特 <a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61">@firstvip61</a> | 官网 <a href="https://first.vip/">First.VIP</a> | Telegram @gofirstvip</p><p><strong>参考资料</strong></p><blockquote><em>Illuvium文档，https://docs.illuvium.io/illuvium-whitepaper</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>社区百科，https://www.illuvialmaster.com/</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>头等仓研报《Illuvium》</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Illuvium中文游戏攻略，https://ilvcn.gitbook.io/ilvplay</em></blockquote><p>[1]https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium数据截至2024年3月27日</p><p>[2]<a href="https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained">https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained</a></p><p>[3]<a href="https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-set-1-wave-one-buyers-guide">https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-set-1-wave-one-buyers-guide</a></p><p>[4]<a href="https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-v1-1-now-live">https://illuvium.io/news/illuvium-beyond-v1-1-now-live</a></p><p>[5]<a href="https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained">https://illuvium.io/news/51-illuvium-land-sale-explained</a></p><p>[6]<a href="https://rc1-blockscout.ilv-testnet.org/mainnet/">https://rc1-blockscout.ILV-testnet.org/mainnet/</a></p><p>[7]<a href="https://twitter.com/illuviumio/status/1772906673415262570/photo/1">https://twitter.com/illuviumio/status/1772906673415262570/photo/1</a></p><p>[8]<a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium">https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium</a></p><p>[9]<a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium/tokenomics">https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/illuvium/tokenomics</a></p><p>[10]<a href="https://etherscan.io/token/0x7e77dcb127f99ece88230a64db8d595f31f1b068">https://etherscan.io/token/0x7e77dcb127f99ece88230a64db8d595f31f1b068</a></p><p>[11]<a href="https://etherscan.io/token/tokenholderchart/0x767fe9edc9e0df98e07454847909b5e959d7ca0e">https://etherscan.io/token/tokenholderchart/0x767fe9edc9e0df98e07454847909b5e959d7ca0e</a></p><p>[12]<a href="https://staking.illuvium.io/">https://staking.illuvium.io/</a></p><p>[13]<a href="https://snapshot.org/#/ilv-gov.eth/proposal/0xc4511bc3dadffcd3bcb617ea6b5fbeb8e0cf46c05f4805348f6fa87c601b8a0c">https://snapshot.org/#/ilv-gov.eth/proposal/0xc4511bc3dadffcd3bcb617ea6b5fbeb8e0cf46c05f4805348f6fa87c601b8a0c</a></p><p>[14]<a href="https://dappradar.com/rankings/games/charts?range=1y">https://dappradar.com/rankings/games/charts?range=1y</a></p><p><strong>— 投资风险与免责声明 —</strong></p><blockquote><em>以上内容分析仅提供参考信息，不作为投资决策依据，请勿基于此报告进行任何投资决策，头等仓及报告作者不对用户投资结果负责。</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>报告自所示日期起准备，由于随后的市场或经济状况可能发生变化，报告内容不一定能反映这些变化。提供的图形，图表和其他视觉辅助工具仅供参考。这些图形、图表或可视化辅助工具都不可用于制定投资决策。不代表头等仓(First.VIP)会协助任何人做出投资决定，并且任何图形、图表或其他视觉辅助工具都无法捕获做出此类决定所需的所有因素和变量。</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>本⽂中涉及的某些陈述可能是头等仓(First.VIP)对于未来预期的假设以及其他的前瞻性观点，⽽已知和未知的⻛险与不确定因素，可能导致实际结果、表现或事件与陈述中的观点和假设存在实质性差异。</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>本报告中包含的任何推测、预测和估计本质上都是推测性的，并且基于某些假设。这些前瞻性陈述可能被证明是错误的，并可能受到不正确的假设或已知或未知的风险，不确定性和其他因素的影响，而其中大多数是无法控制的。可以预料，某些或所有此类前瞻性假设将不会实现，或与实际结果有很大差距。</em></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1742e864fce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[头等仓研报：可编程的流动性层Native]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/%E5%A4%B4%E7%AD%89%E4%BB%93%E5%85%AC%E5%BC%80%E5%B0%BD%E8%B0%83%E7%A0%94%E6%8A%A5-%E5%8F%AF%E7%BC%96%E7%A8%8B%E7%9A%84%E6%B5%81%E5%8A%A8%E6%80%A7%E5%B1%82native-818e483d161a?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/818e483d161a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Mar 2024 11:28:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-14T08:00:05.407Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>-</p><p><strong>文章已下架……</strong></p><p>-</p><p>咨询微信 gofirstvip</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=818e483d161a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[First.VIP Project Analysis: cross-chain interoperability protocol Axelar]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/first-vip-project-analysis-cross-chain-interoperability-axelar-a41e38b9e43c?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a41e38b9e43c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Mar 2024 04:57:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-15T05:23:50.241Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/0*hjePzut14W7mm_DM" /></figure><p>Axelar is a cross-chain interoperability protocol, and it proposed a new concept of “Interchain Connectivity” based on cross-chain technology that prevails over existing “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts, with a mission to build a unified development environment encompassing all applications across Web3. To this end, Axelar launched the Axelar Virtual Machine (AVM) in 2024 that underpins several developer tools, transcending Axelar from an interoperability layer responsible for only message passing and asset bridging to a programmable layer capable of running complex smart-contract logic. It has been plain sailing in the development trajectory of Axelar, and the protocol is seeing sequential growth in transaction volume and user count. If Axelar can nurture a rich ecosystem of projects centering on the “Interchain Connectivity” concept in the future, it will unlock an immense dimension of growth opportunities in the sector.</p><h4>Executive Summary</h4><p><strong>Axelar is a cross-chain interoperability protocol.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Team &amp; Financials, Axelar has a team of employees coming from excellent academic backgrounds while presenting high-level development capabilities. Axelar closed multiple funding rounds and secured a disclosed amount of $113.8 million from a lineup of prestigious institutional-level investors, including Binance, Polychain Capital, Coinbase Ventures, Dragonfly Capital, Crypto.com Capital, etc. It has been plain sailing in the development trajectory of Axelar, and Axelar has seen substantial growth in both the number of commits and the number of code authors.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Products &amp; Technology, Axelar proposed a new concept of “Interchain Connectivity” based on cross-chain technology that prevails over existing “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts. The “Interchain Connectivity” concept will allow for a unified development environment encompassing all blockchains and users across Web3, capable of running smart-contract logic that spans chains. To this end, Axelar launched the Axelar Virtual Machine powered by CosmWasm in 2024 that underpins a suite of developer tools, including Interchain Amplifier and Interchain Maestro, thereby transcending Axelar from an interoperability layer responsible for only message passing and asset bridging to a programmable layer capable of running complex smart-contract logic. Axelar’s “Interchain Connectivity “ concept, in a sense, is an optimized version of the “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts, the core of which is to act as the intersection of a network of interconnected chains. At this intersection, developers can deploy their applications and then extend their reach to other chains in the interconnected network, thus significantly improving the network connectivity efficiency at the cost of developing a single connection; users can gain access to the intersection for a seamless interchain connectivity experience. Therefore, with such an “Interchain Connectivity” solution, Axelar presents an immense dimension of growth potential waiting to be unlocked in the future.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Project Development, it has been plain sailing for Axelar. Business statistics from Axelarscan show exponential growth in GMP transaction count and steady-state growth in active user count, which reflects the continuous expansion and refinement of Axelar’s cross-chain ecosystem, as well as its high-level use retention. In addition, Axelar currently supports 60 blockchain networks in its ecosystem, with over 600 interchain contracts built with Axelar via direct stacks, partnerships, and integrations. A good many leading projects in the DeFi, Layer1, and Layer2 sectors have opted to join the Axelar ecosystem. With its dynamically progressive ecosystem building, Axelar will develop and implement huge growth opportunities in the future.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Tokenomics, with a moderate design of token economy, $AXL is the utility token in Axelar Network, primarily serving the functions of network consensus, governance, ecosystem incentives, and payment. In the future, Axelar will introduce a Gas-burning mechanism to counterbalance inflation, in furtherance of maintaining robust decentralization on the network.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Sector Development, Axelar belongs to the cross-chain interoperability sector that is still garnering momentum, and with the dynamic progression of Layer1 and DeFi sectors, the cross-chain interoperability sector will usher in a wide margin of growth in the future. Axelar reveals distinction and develops an edge over scalability with its technical implementations and “Interchain Connectivity” concept in the competition against LayerZero and Wormhole. If Axelar can nurture a rich ecosystem based on this innovative concept of “Interchain Connectivity”, it will develop a powerful presence in the cross-chain interoperability sector.</strong></p><h4>1. Overview</h4><p><strong>1.1 Project Profile</strong></p><p>Axelar is a cross-chain interoperability protocol, and it proposed an innovative concept of “Interchain Connectivity” based on cross-chain technology that prevails over existing “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts, with a mission to build a unified development environment encompassing all applications across Web3. To this end, Axelar launched the Axelar Virtual Machine in 2024 that underpins a suite of developer tools, transcending Axelar from an interoperability layer responsible for only message passing and asset bridging to a programmable layer capable of running complex smart-contract logic.</p><p><strong>1.2 Basic Information</strong><a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jbEJm4-IRUhZpphfL2xAHw.png" /></figure><h4><strong>2. Project Details</strong></h4><p><strong>2.1 Team</strong></p><p>According to publicly available information, Interop Labs is the dev team behind Axelar, and based in Canada, it has a team of ~50 employees, of which 33 employees have a LinkedIn profile:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*RkvOIGs5bccwpue7bLzCTQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Sergey Gorbunov — Co-Founder:</strong> Sergey Gorbunov received their B.Sc. and M.Sc. in Computer Science from the University of Toronto. In 2015, Gorbunov received their Ph.D. from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. After graduating in 2015, Gorbunov founded StealthMine, a company providing data encryption solutions to enterprises. In 2018, Gorbunov joined Algorand and served as Chief Cryptographer. In June 2020, Gorbunov co-founded Axelar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/192/1*VWw_oHjWKllKooVG8UXU5Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>Georgios Vlachos — Co-Founder:</strong> Georgios Vlachos received their B.Sc. in Mathematics and Computer Science and a Master’s Degree in Computer Science from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. After graduation, Vlachos joined Algorand and served as Head of Mathematics. In June 2020, Vlachos co-founded Axelar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/187/1*z7pCpTZg3I_q78W-8amg5A.png" /></figure><p><strong>Christian Gorenflo — Team Lead:</strong> Christian Gorenflo received their B.Sc. in Physics from Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Germany, and a Ph.D. in Computer Science from the University of Waterloo. After graduating in 2020, Gorenflo joined Interop Labs, serving as a Blockchain Engineer, and was later promoted to Team Lead in July 2023.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/193/1*SKRMbRiKkqzfRztT4sKanQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Milap Sheth — Team Lead:</strong> Milap Sheth received their B.Sc. in Computer Science, Combinatorics, and Optimization from the University of Waterloo. After graduating in 2019, Shethe joined ISARA Corporation, a cybersecurity solutions company, and served as a part-time Researcher performing cryptanalysis of hard problems in supersingular isogeny-based cryptography. In July 2021, Sheth joined Interop Labs and has been serving as Team Lead since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/190/1*ij8aT5N6aOd8VJ8HSCvXew.png" /></figure><p><strong>Talal Ashraf — DevOps Team Lead:</strong> Talal Ashraf received their B.Sc. in Electrical and Computer Engineering from the University of Toronto. After graduating in 2015, Ashraf joined Symantec, an enterprise cloud services company, and served as a Full-Stack Backend Engineer. Later, Ashraf joined Flywheel in 2019 and Pixlee in 2020, responsible for DevOps engineering. In August 2021, Ashraf joined Interop Labs and has been serving as DevOps Team Lead since.</p><p>Overall, Axelar’s dev team members have good academic backgrounds, and the two Interop Labs Co-Founders were previously engaged in the R&amp;D of Algorand, presenting stellar development capabilities.</p><p><strong>2.2 Financials</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5sY6mBppesbeuw9Am_Kbmw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 2–1 Axelar Network Financials</strong><a href="#_ftn2"><strong>[2]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>As of March 5, 2024, Axelar has closed five funding rounds and has secured a disclosed amount of $113.8 million according to public information. In addition, Axelar received a whopping Serie B round valuation of $1 billion. Axelar is backed by a lineup of strong institutional-level investors, along the lines of Binance, Polychain Capital, Coinbase Ventures, Dragonfly Capital, and Crypto.com Capital. However, it has been nearly two years since Axelar closed its last funding round on March 10, 2022. With a lack of knowledge of Axelar’s current financial situation, we can only assume that Axelar reveals a financial abundance at the moment as the team still has managed to advance its development and business operations while maintaining a team of 50 employees.</strong></p><p><strong>2.3 Code</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c4FOqccrTDt62Ij6Y0KLzA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–1 #Commits Contributed to Axelar Repos</strong><a href="#_ftn3"><strong>[3]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1pNU19scd7bu96eaRg3Vrg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–2 #Authors Contributing to Axelar Repos</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Axelar repos are made open-source on GitHub. As of March 4, 2024, we can see from Figure 2–1 and Figure 2–2 that Axelar has been continuously making code contributions to its GitHub repos, with a total of 12,100 commits; Axelar repos once received commits from over 50 code authors, with about 50 code authors making contributions at the moment. Axelar maintains stable project development without seeing huge fluctuations in the number of commits. Since 2023, Axelar has seen sequential growth in both the number of commits and the number of code authors, indicating that the project development of Axelar is in a healthy condition.</strong></p><p>2.4 Products &amp; Technology</p><p>Axelar is a cross-chain interoperability project built based on Cosmos SDK, with a mission to offer robust cross-chain communication.</p><p><strong>2.4.1 Interoperability Layer</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eB2vYPIQgLxXEyf3A_KHEQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–3 Axelar Technology Stack </strong><a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a></figcaption></figure><p>To enable cross-chain functionality, Axelar offers an interoperability layer that is a “trinity” of Axelar Gateways, Axelar Validators, and Axelar Network. Among them:</p><p><strong>Gateways primarily enable cross-chain message passing and execution. </strong>On the source chain where the message originates, the Gateway enables initiating cross-chain message requests. On the destination chain where the message is received, the Gateway enables the message to be executed and completes the cross-chain protocol. On EVM chains, the Gateway is a smart contract address. On Cosmos and other non-EVM chains, the Gateway is an application with logic and the ability to communicate with Axelar Network. Accomplished through a multiparty cryptography scheme, the Gateway is controlled by a key that is held jointly by all Axelar Validators. Each Validator holds many key shares, and the amount of shares is dictated by the amount of $AXL tokens staked with the Validator. The Gateway can only allow actions on the external chain if the number of Validators holding key shares who authorize the action reaches a set threshold.</p><p>Once a cross-chain message is initiated by a dApp user, its first stop is to interact with an Axelar Gateway. Once a Gateway receives a message, it will generate an event. Axelar runs <strong>relayer</strong> services that observe all connected chains, pick up the event and submit it to the Axelar network for processing.</p><p><strong>Axelar Validators are mainly responsible for message verification and network consensus. </strong>Once the event sent by an external chain is received by Axelar, a poll is generated and Axelar validators vote on the poll. By querying the RPC endpoint of their source-chain node, validators can check if the submitted event was observed on their source-chain node. If the event is found, validators vote in the poll to approve the message as legitimate. These validators are then incentivized by Axelar Network’s proof-of-stake consensus model to create blocks and approve transactions.</p><p><strong>Axelar Network is primarily responsible for processing cross-chain message requests and Gas payload. </strong>Once a message is authorized, anyone can take this signed message and submit it to the destination chain for processing, and another set of relayer services monitors outgoing transaction queues containing cross-chain messages that are already approved and signed and periodically submits these transactions to the Axelar Gateway contract on the destination chain for execution. In this execution process, Axelar Network is required to use tokens of the destination chain to cover Gas costs. Axelar offers Gas and Executor services to help make this execution easier. Axelar creates and deploys a smart contract called the Gas Receiver to all connected EVM chains, allowing the user to pay for all transaction fees required throughout the entire journey of their cross-chain message without the need to acquire destination-chain tokens or any tokens supported by Axelar Network. The Gas Receiver estimates the total Gas cost required across the source chain, Axelar Network, and destination chain, charges transaction fees in a one-time payment on the source chain, and converts source-chain tokens into $AXL, destination-chain tokens, or any other required currencies. During this process, the Gas Receiver will normally charge more transaction fees than required and return the excess amount to the user’s account after the cross-chain message execution is completed.</p><p>Axelar Network, as an interoperability layer, offers advantages in many ways that present distinction from other cross-chain bridges.</p><p><strong>1) Axelar utilizes a multiparty cryptography scheme and a PoS consensus model to ensure network security. </strong>First, in the process of cross-chain message passing and execution, the Gateways can only allow actions on the external chain if the number of validators holding key shares who authorize the action reaches a set threshold. In addition, the Gateways have a rate-limiting function, putting a cap on how much of each asset can be transferred in a given time interval. Second, after all cross-chain events have been submitted to Axelar Network, their legitimacy needs to be approved by Axelar validators incentivized by the DPoS consensus model before new blocks can be produced. To prevent the concentration of voting power among a subset of nodes as a result of different $AXL amounts staked with Axelar Validators, Axelar implemented “Quadratic Voting” on its consensus layer. Quadratic voting, in general, means that to cast one vote, a validator needs to hold one share of $AXL tokens, but to cast two votes, they must hold four shares of $AXL tokens (two squared is four), and so on. Quadratic voting sets each validator’s voting power at the square root of the total delegated stake it accumulates. Quadratic voting mitigates the scenario where an oligopoly or monopoly accrues a majority of tokens or delegations and exercises censorship over transactions, thus significantly improving the degree of decentralization in Axelar Network. Therefore, the introduction of a multiparty cryptography scheme and a DPoS consensus model grants Axelar Network better security than existing cross-chain bridges in the market.</p><p><strong>2) In terms of scalability, Axelar is a public chain that can deploy and execute smart contracts. </strong>This means that Axelar enables developers to integrate their public chains or dApps into the network in an efficient and cost-effective way and can even act as “an interoperability layer” in the concept of modularity for developers to add cross-chain functionality to their applications to facilitate cross-chain execution while significantly improving the user experience. For example, developers can utilize an Axelar API to add a one-time deposit address to their application-layer dApps, and this address allows dApps to mimic the way centralized exchanges are able to receive deposits in arbitrary amounts from any chain. In addition, General Message Passing (GMP) transcends the concept of merely bridging assets, and it also empowers developers with the ability to build interchain-native applications that make cross-chain function calls and synchronize state in a way that is completely abstracted for users, which greatly improves the scalability of Axelar’s application-layer dApps.</p><p><strong>In addition, Axelar proposed a new concept of “Interchain Connectivity” that prevails over existing “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts. Interchain Connectivity will allow for a unified development environment encompassing all blockchains and users across Web3, capable of running smart-contract logic that spans chains, thereby bringing Axelar’s vision of full-stack interoperability to life. To this end, Axelar launched the Axelar Virtual Machine powered by CosmWasm in 2024 that transcends Axelar from an interoperability layer responsible for only message passing and asset bridging to a programmable layer capable of running complex smart-contract logic.</strong></p><p><strong>2.4.2 Axelar Virtual Machine (AVM)</strong></p><p>The significance of the Turing-complete AVM is not only its ability to deploy smart contracts but also the fact that it revolutionizes how dApps run logic to enable cross-chain functionality. For developers, their dApps built on the AVM inherently have cross-chain functionality enabled by the base-layer Axelar Network, without the need to integrate with other interoperability projects. This is the “Interchain Connectivity” concept proposed by Axelar, or in Axelar’s own words, <strong>“build once, run everywhere”</strong>.</p><p>More specifically, DeFi projects built with the AVM can tap into the liquidity that spans multiple blockchains to perform a variety of market activities, such as trading and lending; stablecoins projects built with the AVM can unlock a spectrum of application scenarios and allow for a seamless user experience across multiple chains; GameFi projects built with the AVM can release in-game assets or currencies across multiple chains; NFT projects built with the AVM can be integrated into GameFi projects or tap into the liquidity of marketplaces across multiple chains; crypto wallets built with the AVM can provide services to uses cross multiple chains; DAOs built with the AVM can conduct governance and enforce governance decisions across multiple chains, thus making for a convenient asset distribution experience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1019/1*XhErQTr5GElK6DI31vUbZw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2–4 AVM Architecture</strong><a href="#_ftn5"><strong>[5]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>Axelar has designed two key products for developers to deploy interchain dApps on the AVM in a way that is efficient and cost-effective, namely Interchain Amplifier and Interchain Maestro.</p><p>Interchain Amplifier is a permissionless model and service that allows developers to easily and seamlessly create a connection to Axelar Network and all of its interconnected chains at the cost of developing a single connection. Developers gain access to Axelar Network and its interconnected network of chains by paying the cost equivalent to developing only one connection. They can establish connections between new ecosystems or existing chains to add new network properties, such as improved security or better delivery and availability, hence the name Interchain Amplifier. The use cases of Interchain Amplifier include integrating various Ethereum components, such as ZK proofs, into interchain dApps built on Axelar Network</p><p>Interchain Maestro is an orchestrator that developers can use to deploy and manage their multi-chain dApp instantiations by following a simple process:</p><p>1) Specify the contracts they want to deploy, as well as the associated chains and any governance parameters.</p><p>2) Store these confirmations and initial parameters in a smart contract on the Axelar network, which will subsequently deploy them across all other networks.</p><p>3) Easily extend or clone these contracts to additional chains.</p><p>4) Upgrade their contract code with just one transaction on the Axelar Network, which will ship the upgrade to all its interconnected chains.</p><p>Developers can dramatically improve the efficiency of network connectivity and reduce the cost of dApp deployment with Interchain Maestro. Interchain Token Service, a component of Interchain Maestro, has shipped to the Axelar mainnet. Interchain Token Service automates the issuance and management of Interchain Tokens that preserve native qualities, like cross-chain fungibility and custom functionality, throughout cross-chain deployments.</p><p><strong>The launch of the AVM brings the concept of “Interchain Connectivity” proposed by Axelar to life, thus laying a solid foundation for Axelar’s ecosystem building. “Interchain Connectivity”, in a sense, is an optimized version of existing “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts, the core of which is to act as the intersection of a network of interconnected chains. At this intersection, developers deploy and manage their applications, thus significantly improving the efficiency of interchain connectivity at the cost of developing a single connection; users gain access to the intersection for a seamless interchain connectivity experience. Therefore, with its “Interchain Connectivity” solution, Axelar presents an immense dimension of growth potential waiting to be unlocked in the future.</strong></p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Team &amp; Financials, Axelar has a team of employees coming from excellent academic backgrounds while presenting high-level development capabilities. Axelar closed multiple funding rounds and secured a disclosed amount of $113.8 million from a lineup of prestigious institutional-level investors, including Binance, Polychain Capital, Coinbase Ventures, Dragonfly Capital, Crypto.com Capital, etc. It has been plain sailing in the development trajectory of Axelar, and Axelar has seen substantial growth in both the number of commits and the number of code authors.</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Products &amp; Technology, Axelar proposed a new concept of “Interchain Connectivity” based on cross-chain technology that prevails over existing “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts. The “Interchain Connectivity” concept will allow for a unified development environment encompassing all blockchains and users across Web3, capable of running smart-contract logic that spans chains. To this end, Axelar launched the Axelar Virtual Machine powered by CosmWasm in 2024 that underpins a suite of developer tools, including Interchain Amplifier and Interchain Maestro, thereby transcending Axelar from an interoperability layer responsible for only message passing and asset bridging to a programmable layer capable of running complex smart-contract logic. Axelar’s “Interchain Connectivity “ concept, in a sense, is an optimized version of the “cross-chain” and “multi-chain” concepts, the core of which is to act as the intersection of a network of interconnected chains. At this intersection, developers can deploy their applications and then extend their reach to other chains in the interconnected network, thus significantly improving the network connectivity efficiency at the cost of developing a single connection; users can gain access to the intersection for a seamless interchain connectivity experience. Therefore, with such an “Interchain Connectivity” solution, Axelar presents an immense dimension of growth potential waiting to be unlocked in the future.</strong></p><h4>3. Development</h4><p><strong>3.1 History</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uJDF4hOLIEtV5o02doF7HQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–1 Axelar Milestones</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>3.2 Current Status</strong></p><p><strong>3.2.1 Business Statistics</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oGznLr20Gzk_JNPd8NnbDg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–1 Axelar Transactions</strong><a href="#_ftn6"><strong>[6]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LTCT9UxLtl63DjHjBIQX6w.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–2 Axelar Active Users</strong></figcaption></figure><p>According to Axelarscan, as of 11:00 a.m. CST on March 11, 2024, Axelar Network has processed 1,528,445 transactions, of which 962,300 (~62.96%) were made via General Message Passing (GMP). A GMP transaction is executed to call a smart contract on the destination chain made possible by interacting with the Axelar Gateway, while an ordinary cross-chain transaction is executed to simply transfer assets from a source-chain account to a destination-chain account. The exponential increase in GMP transaction count since 2023 is an embodiment of the continuous expansion and high-level user engagement in the Axelar ecosystem. In addition, Axelar has seen a significant increase in the number of active users since 2023 and has subsequently maintained its active user count at a steady state, mirroring a good level of user retention in the Axelar ecosystem.</p><p><strong>3.2.2 Ecosystem Building</strong></p><p>As a programmable layer capable of running complex smart-contract logic, the Axelar ecosystem accommodates not only a network of interconnected chains but also dApps built on the application layer of Axelar Network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*96nK_sMEI0svGUw-smqd7w.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–3 Axelar’s Network of Interconnected Chains</strong></figcaption></figure><p>There are currently 60 blockchains connected to Axelar Network, and they are categorized into 3 tiers by activities.</p><p>Tier 1: Polygon, Osmosis, BNB Chain, Arbitrum, Avalanche, Ethereum, Fantom, Moonbeam, Celo, Terra Classic, Terra, Base, Optimism, and Kujira.</p><p>Tier 2: Kava, Sei, Mantle, Linea, Neutron, Umee, Juno, Crescent, Secret-SNIP, Cosmos, Filecoin, Evmos, Scroll, Comdex, and XPLA.</p><p>Among Tier 1 chains, ~290,330 transactions, or 19.00% of the total transactions processed by Axelar Network, were initiated from Polygon; ~189,880, or 12.42%, were initiated from BNB Chain; ~166,120 transactions, or 10.87%, were initiated from Osmosis; ~151,400 transactions, or 9.91%, were initiated from Arbitrum; ~135,840 transactions, or 8.89%, were initiated from Avalanche; and ~95,540 transactions, or 6.25%, were initiated from Ethereum. It can be perceived that Axelar’s network activities are contributed by a variety of blockchain networks, without relying on a particular chain. Overall, Axelar is currently in a healthy state of project development.</p><p>As of March 11, 2024, there are 635<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a> interchain contracts already built or ready to be built with Axelar Network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hh4TA0YPhTSYN12eSQm3cw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3–4 Leaders Built with Axelar</strong><a href="#_ftn8"><strong>[8]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>On the application layer of Axelar Network include: 1) Wallets: MetaMask, Trust Wallet, and Keplr; 2) Infrastructure: Biconomy; 3) GameFi: Decentraland; 4) DeFi: dYdX, Lido, PancakeSwap, SushiSwap, QuickSwap, and KyberSwap.</p><p>Integrations or partnerships with Axelar Network include Uniswap, Ripple, Immutable, Frax Finance, Vertex, Ondo Finance, Fantom, Band Protocol, Sommelier, Filecoin, Umee, Polygon, Sui, Circle, etc.</p><p>At present, the Axelar ecosystem is populated by DeFi projects and Layer1 blockchains, and the particular reason for this circumstance is that the interoperable nature of Axelar Network dictates its close connection with DeFi and Layer1. As Axelar continues to build and nurture a rich ecosystem of DeFi projects and Layer1 blockchains, Axelar will unlock a huge dimension of growth opportunities in the future.</p><p><strong>3.2.3 Social Sentiment</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FtrJDuLqycm9c1gk6dGcOw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 3–2 Axelar Social Media Performance</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>As of March 11, 2024, Axelar has a large presence across various social media platforms, with a huge audience but low-level community engagement. The Axelar community has extended its social reach to a large audience but still presents a subdued community atmosphere, with community discussions centering on network interaction troubles and troubleshooting. The Axelar Network Community Forum presents low-level engagement, with discussions centering on Axelar’s future technical upgrades and strategic directions.</strong></p><p><strong>3.3 The Future</strong></p><p>According to the Axelar Network Roadmap for 2024 released on January 30, 2024, the AVM will be the focal point of Axelar Network in 2024, centering on which Axelar presents its 2024 milestones, as follows:</p><p>1) Axelar Virtual Machine becomes a platform for open-source tools to enable chain-agnostic development, running on decentralized cross-chain infrastructure.</p><p>2) Permissionless connections for arbitrary chains via Interchain Amplifier, taking potential network effects out to the 100s of blockchains in the Ethereum L2verse.</p><p>3) Interchain Tokens go beyond bridges, extending native fungibility and custom functionality across all connected chains.</p><p>4) A Gas-burning mechanism is on the $AXL token governance roadmap, with the potential to turn the network deflationary, further securing Axelar Network.</p><p>5) Integrating diverse consensus approaches, including Solana, Stellar, and Move-based chains like Aptos and Sui.</p><p>6) A Gas-pricing overhaul will improve the accuracy of services that estimate cross-chain gas fees over Axelar Network.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Project Development, it has been plain sailing for Axelar. Business statistics from Axelarscan show exponential growth in GMP transaction count and steady-state growth in active user count, which reflects the continuous expansion and refinement of Axelar’s cross-chain ecosystem, as well as its high-level use retention. In addition, Axelar currently supports 60 blockchain networks in its ecosystem, with over 600 interchain contracts built with Axelar via direct stacks, partnerships, and integrations. A good many leading projects in the DeFi, Layer1, and Layer2 sectors have opted to join the Axelar ecosystem. With its dynamically progressive ecosystem building, Axelar will develop and implement huge growth opportunities in the future.</strong></p><h4>4. Tokenomics</h4><p><strong>4.1 Supply</strong></p><p><strong>4.1.1 $AXL Token Allocation</strong><a href="#_ftn9"><strong>[9]</strong></a></p><p>$AXL is Axelar’s project token and was released on the Axelar mainnet in September 2022. There was a total supply of 1 billion $AXL tokens at the Axelar genesis block, and Axelar has designed inflationary tokenomics made possible via token rewards. As of March 5, 2024, there is a maximum supply of 1,137,455,595 $AXL and a circulating supply of 587,380,415 $AXL.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mt5DX4w4FUj8guAOqJ6lHQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 4–1 $AXL Genesis Allocations And Release Schedule</strong><a href="#_ftn10"><strong>[10]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/889/1*QWnZHXA6vH5yW186FLW8hg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–1 $AXL Token Allocation at Genesis</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/881/1*7z6mBCf6NPtfx-kCDRcsiA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–2 $AXL Release Schedule</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In the allocation of the genesis supply of 1 billion $AXL tokens, about 30% went to the Company, another 30% went to Backers and the Community Sale, and 40% went to Community Programs. As of March 5, 2024, it has been nearly 17 months since the Axelar genesis block, and about 452 million $AXL<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a> of the total supply has been unlocked.</p><p>Axelar Network currently offers an inflationary tokenomics design made possible via token rewards. The inflation rate is calculated as 1% base inflation + 0.3% per externally verified chain<br> (0.75% per externally verified chain before December 5, 2023), and with 20 externally backed blockchains, Axelar Network cumulates in total inflation of 7% (14.5% before December 5, 2023).</p><p>Axelar plans to introduce a Gas-burning mechanism to counterbalance inflation, in furtherance of maintaining robust decentralization on the network. At present, it costs about 0.2 $AXL in Gas to process a message via Axelar. Assuming Axelar Network processes 100K transactions per day and a daily volume of $100M, around ~104M $AXL<a href="#_ftn12">[12]</a> in Gas fees would be collected and removed from the supply annually. This would effectively counteract an inflation rate of up to 10%, leading to a deflationary state of the network.</p><p>While the proposal was approved, the Gas-burning mechanism has yet to be deployed on the Axelar mainnet, which is one of Axelar’s milestones for 2024.</p><p><strong>4.2 Demand</strong></p><p>$AXL is the native token of Axelar Network, primarily serving the following main functions:</p><p>1) $AXL lays the foundation of Axelar’s DPoS consensus model, not only as the staking requirement of validators but also as their block rewards.</p><p>2) $AXL is the governance token of Axelar Network, allowing token holders to vote on governance proposals and have a voice in Axelar’s network parameters, marketing strategies, development strategies, and technical upgrades.</p><p>3) $AXL acts as the means of payment and will be used to settle Gas fees in the Axelar ecosystem.</p><p>4) $AXL is used to reward ecosystem participants and community contributors.</p><p><strong>4.2.1 Axelar Validators</strong></p><p>Axelar is a DPoS network powered by the Tendermint Consensus Architecture. Axelar is run by a fixed active set of 75 validators, and only those who have enough stake to get into the active set can participate in network consensus. The number of validators in the active sect can be adjusted in the future through governance.</p><p>The Axelar validator must obtain a secured and private RPC endpoint for onboarding an external EVM chain. After this is setup, the validator needs to inform Axelar about their support for this new chain and submit a command to Axelar, registering their validator as a chain maintainer for the new external EVM chain to submit the state of the EVM chain for verification. Therefore, Axelar Network poses a high threshold of entry for users to participate in network consensus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6kwlQ7RKW0j9R5JWfXaWag.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4–3 Axelar Validators by Share</strong><a href="#_ftn13"><strong>[13]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>The Axelar validator will receive block rewards for their contributions to network consensus, and Axelar offers a 5%-10% APR to its validators depending on the number of validators maintaining the EVM chain. At present, Axelar offers a ~9% APR to its validators. $AXL holders can delegate their tokens to validators for a share of block rewards. There will be a 7-day lockup period when validators and delegators unstake their $AXL tokens, and only after the lockup period expires can they withdraw their $AXL tokens.</p><p>ValidatorREX is currently the Top 1 validator by share (about 7.52%) in Axelar Network; the Top 10 Axelar validators together hold a cumulative 34.31% stake share; the Top 3 Axelar validators do not participate in network consensus. Therefore, despite a small active set of validators, Axelar Network still presents a certain degree of decentralization.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Tokenomics, with a moderate design of token economy, $AXL is the utility token in Axelar Network, primarily serving the functions of network consensus, governance, ecosystem incentives, and payment. In the future, Axelar will introduce a Gas-burning mechanism to counterbalance inflation, in furtherance of maintaining robust decentralization on the network.</strong></p><h4>5. Sector</h4><p><strong>5.1 Sector Overview</strong></p><p>Axelar, as an interoperability layer capable of message passing and asset bridging, belongs to the cross-chain interoperability sector.</p><p>The previous paradigm for the cross-chain sector was the ability to bridge assets from one chain to another, but the cross-chain sector later saw a paradigm shift to cross-chain interoperability after message-passing solutions came into the spotlight. Cross-chain interoperability, as the name suggests, aims at realizing interoperability across multiple chains. For example, a user can execute an action on Chain B without leaving Chain A, and this action is executed by cross-chain interactions to facilitate the interoperability of data, including the assets, chain state, contract calls, etc. In a way, cross-chain interoperability shares some similarities with the sidechain technique in that both emphasize achieving interoperability of assets and data between the main chain and its sidechains. However, their difference is that cross-chain interoperability projects aim to build an interoperable network of interconnected chains, granting access to all other chains with one single connection to the main network, and making all chains connected to the main network the “sidechains”.</p><p>At present, projects in the cross-chain interoperability sector follow a similar set of rules to achieve technical implementations, namely “observe — verify — pass/interact”. In essence, all cross-chain interoperability projects act as the “middleman” to fetch source-chain messages, verify the messages, and then proceed to interact with the destination chain. In this process, interoperability projects will delve into the three focal points of “how to fetch source-chain messages “, “how to verify and execute the messages”, and “how to interact with the destination chain”, to make product and technical optimizations.</p><p>The cross-chain interoperability sector is still garnering momentum at the moment without seeing a vibrant sector landscape, thus reflecting a huge margin of growth potential. We will select LayerZero and Wormhole as the two noteworthy competitors of Axelar and give a horizontal comparative analysis hereinafter.</p><p><strong>5.2 Competitors</strong></p><p><strong>5.2.1 LayerZero</strong></p><p>LayerZero is an omni-chain interoperability protocol.</p><p>In terms of Team &amp; Financials, LayerZero’s team members have extensive experience in software engineering, and they have worked together for a long time and have developed a close relationship. LayerZero has closed multiple funding rounds, cumulating in total investments of $293.3 million from a lineup of prestigious institutional-level investors, along the lines of Binance Labs, Delphi Digital, a16z, Sequoia Capital, and Coinbase Ventures.</p><p>In terms of Products &amp; Technology, LayerZero is designed for “lightweight” message passing across chains by leveraging a network of oracles and relayers. When a user submits a message to a LayerZero Endpoint on the source chain, an oracle comes into play as an off-chain entity, moving a requested block header from a source chain to a destination chain, and a relayer performs the task of fetching the transaction proof on the source chain and delivering it to the destination chain. This comes with three benefits:</p><p>1) It reduces the cost of message transmission. LayerZero eliminates the need to run its own nodes across chains and outsources the responsibility of message verification to off-chain entities; oracles perform the job of passing messages one-way from the source chain to the destination chain, thereby avoiding the cost of any interaction between oracles and LayerZero validators.</p><p>2) It ensures network security. LayerZero separates the tasks of oracles and relayers and enables the two independent entities to corroborate the validity of a transaction, thereby reducing the threat of malpractice by off-chain entities to the LayerZero network.</p><p>3) It improves network scalability. Since oracles and relayers are only responsible for message transmission and the task of message verification is done on their respective source chain and destination chain, the block speed and network throughput are entirely dependent on the performance of the source and destination chains.</p><p>LayerZero Labs launched LayerZero V2 in January 2024, introducing Permissionless Execution that separates execution from verification; Security Stack that allows developers to set their own Security Stack for message execution; and Enhanced Programmability.</p><p>In terms of Tokenomics, LayerZero Labs has not yet released its project token but has disclosed relative information from the code in its documentation. It is expected that LayerZero’s project token will serve the function of Gas payment, with more to come in the future.</p><p>In terms of Project Development, LayerZero is currently in a healthy state of project development and has ushered in a wave of significant growth in user interactions since March 2024. LayerZero currently supports a network of over 20 blockchains, of which Arbitrum, Optimism, Polygon, Avalanche, Binance, Fantom, and Ethereum have contributed the most trading volume to LayerZero. A total of 95 dApps have been built with LayerZero via integrations and partnerships, and LayerZero Labs is still actively rolling out more integrations and partnerships to facilitate ecosystem building.</p><p><strong>5.2.2 Wormhole</strong></p><p>Wormhole is a generic message-passing protocol.</p><p>In terms of Team &amp; Financials, Wormhole is the product of “the Solana and Certus.One partnership”, and it was initially designed as a cross-chain bridge only between Ethereum and Solana. Therefore, with technical support from Solana and Certus.One, Wormhole presents excellent development capabilities. In November 2023, Wormhole closed a $225M funding round, reaching a valuation of $2.5 billion, and also announced the launch of Wormhole Labs to help grow Wormhole’s cross-chain activity and development.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P5jk_C4Ua9HpcqBAuRHMkQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5–1 Wormhole Architecture</strong><a href="#_ftn14"><strong>[14]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>In terms of Products &amp; Technology, Wormhole brought its technical implementations to life in a “simple but effective” way, and the entire Wormhole architecture consists of only on-chain and off-chain components.</p><p>Wormhole’s on-chain components include the Emitter, Wormhole Core Contract, and Transaction Logs.</p><p>Some existing contracts that are Emitters: 1) xAsset Contracts (contracts that allow normal tokens to be converted to xAssets and enable these xAssets to be bridged); 2) Relay Contracts (contracts that allow cross-chain applications to send messages to a specific blockchain via the decentralized Generic Relayer network); 3) Worm Router Contracts (contracts that allow developers to make their dApp a cross-chain application that users on any Wormhole supported chain can interact with purely through client-side code). These Emitters are responsible for calling the publish message method on the Core Contract.</p><p>The Wormhole Core Contract is the contract that interacts with Wormhole’s off-chain opponents and is responsible for message verification and confirmation.</p><p>Transaction Logs are blockchain-specific logs that allow off-chain components to observe messages emitted by the core contract.</p><p>Wormhole’s off-chain components include the Guardian Network and the Generic Relayer Network.</p><p>The Guardian Network is a network of 19 validators each with a multisig which is referred to as a Verifiable Action Approval in Wormhole. Guardians need to run a full node for every single blockchain in the ecosystem and observe messages from Core Contracts across several blockchains. Once 2/3rd of the Guardians validate and sign a message, the validated message will be relayed to the target chain for execution, thus reaching finality.</p><p>Wormhole uses off-chain components to handle message verification in a way that is efficient and cost-effective, capable of passing messages across multiple chains at a very fast rate. However, Wormhole achieves fast message verification and transmission at the sacrifice of network security as it relies on a small group of validators to reach consensus, presenting a risk of centralization.</p><p>In terms of Tokenomics, $W is the native token of Wormhole and will be used primarily as economic drivers of project development and ecosystem building, as well as voting weight in protocol governance. However, the Wormhole Foundation has failed to build a strong connection between the $W token and project development as the $W token cannot fully capture the value generated as Wormhole progresses its project development nor can it bring more empower Wormhole with more application scenarios.</p><p>In terms of Project Development, Wormhole is currently in a healthy state of project development, and although Wormhole suffered from a downturn for over a year as Solana fell victim to the FTX collapse, the project has later bounced back from its low and regained vitality since mid-2023. Wormhole currently nurtures a network of over 40 interconnected chains (including Emitter-supported ones), and Ethereum, Solana, Sui, and Arbitrum are the four source chains that have contributed the most trading volume to Wormhole. Over 100 dApps have been built with Wormhole via integrations and partnerships, and Wormhole Labs is still actively rolling out more integrations and partnerships to facilitate ecosystem building.</p><p><strong>Comparative Analysis</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oKyWxfrSAerHUOG1xNco0g.png" /><figcaption><strong>Table 5–1 Competitive Analysis: Axelar vs. LayerZero vs. Wormhole</strong><a href="#_ftn15"><strong>[15]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>Comparing with LayerZero and Wormhole, we can find that Axelar underperforms LayerZero in efficiency as the Axelar architecture requires its validators to perform message verification and participate in network consensus; both LayerZero and Axelar have merits in network security: 1) LayerZero simplifies the process of cross-chain message passing while outsourcing the task of message verification to off-chain entities, and if the oracle does not conspire with the relayer to preform malpractice, cross-chain interactions will hinge on the security of the source chain and destination chain; 2) Axelar relies on its proof-of-stake network consensus to guarantee the security of cross-chain interactions. Axelar shares great similarities with Wormhole in architectural design, but compared to Wormhole, Axelar Network is maintained by more validators and hence has a higher degree of decentralization.</p><p>However, in terms of scalability, Axelar, as a programmable interoperability layer capable of running complex smart-contract logic, reveals distinction from LayerZero and Wormhole, and it proposed the concept of “Interchain Connectivity” which lays the foundation for its ecosystem building. In terms of tokenomics, Axelar has a closer bond with its project token $AXL, and after the rollout of the $AXL tokenomics overhaul, $AXL will empower Axelar Network with more application scenarios. In terms of project development, LayerZero seeks a strategic direction of interoperability across the Ethereum Layer2verse; Wormhole is prone to facilitate interoperability in Solana and Ethereum ecosystems; Axelar aims to achieve interchain connectivity in Ethereum and Cosmos ecosystems. Therefore, these three projects are in a competitive yet complementary relationship. This means that the cross-chain interoperability sector is still a blue ocean, and with the dynamic progression of Layer1 and DeFi sectors, the cross-chain interoperability sector will unlock an immense dimension of growth opportunities in the future.</p><p>On balance, we are optimistic about the prospect of Axelar in the competition against cross-chain interoperability projects.</p><p><strong>Summary:</strong></p><p><strong>In terms of Sector Development, Axelar belongs to the cross-chain interoperability sector that is still garnering momentum, and with the dynamic progression of Layer1 and DeFi sectors, the cross-chain interoperability sector will usher in a wide margin of growth in the future. Axelar reveals distinction and develops an edge over scalability with its technical implementations and “Interchain Connectivity” concept in the competition against LayerZero and Wormhole. If Axelar can nurture a rich ecosystem based on this innovative concept of “Interchain Connectivity”, it will develop a powerful presence in the cross-chain interoperability sector.</strong></p><h4><strong>6. Risks</strong></h4><p><strong>1) Code Security Risk: </strong>Although Axelar has gone through several rigorous audits, the protocol will still be exposed to systemic inadequacies and vulnerabilities. In addition, the cross-chain sector is the ground zero of hacker exploits so investors should be fully aware of the code security risk underlying Axelar before making any investment decisions.</p><p><strong>2) Competition Risk: </strong>Axelar is facing heavy competition pressure in the cross-chain interoperability sector.</p><p><strong>3) Centralization Risk:</strong> Axelar is maintained by a set of only 75 validators, which still presents a good level of centralization.</p><p><strong>— END —</strong></p><p>Website <a href="https://first.vip/">First.VIP</a> | Twitter <a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61">@firstvip61</a> | Wechat: gofirstvip</p><p>— Investment Risks and Disclaimers —</p><blockquote><em>This report is only for information purposes and should not be relied upon when making any investment decision. Please do not make any investment decisions based on this report. First.VIP and authors of this report are not responsible for any results of your investment.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>This report is drafted from the date indicated. As market or economic conditions may change from time to time, the content of this report may not necessarily reflect such changes. The graphs, charts, and other visual aids are provided for information purposes solely, none of which should be relied upon as investment decisions. First.VIP will not assist anyone in making investment decisions and no graph, chart, or other visual aid can capture all of the factors and variables required to make such decisions.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Some of the statements in this report may contain First.VIP’s future assumptions and other forward-looking views. With known &amp; unknown risks and uncertainties, actual results, performance, or events may differ materially from the views and assumptions expressed in the statements.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Any speculations, forecasts and estimates contained in this report are speculative and are based on certain assumptions. These forward-looking statements may prove to be inaccurate and may be affected by inaccurate assumptions, known/unknown risks, uncertainties, and other factors, most of which are beyond our control. It can be anticipated that some or all of these forward-looking assumptions will not be realized or will differ materially from actual results.</em></blockquote><p>Reference</p><blockquote>Axelar Docs, <a href="https://docs.axelar.dev/">https://docs.axelar.dev/</a></blockquote><blockquote>Introducing the Axelar Virtual Machine: Supercharging Interchain Development, <a href="https://axelar.network/blog/axelar-virtual-machine-future-of-interoperability">https://axelar.network/blog/axelar-virtual-machine-future-of-interoperability</a></blockquote><blockquote>Project Analysis: Axelar, First.vip</blockquote><blockquote>Project Analysis: LayerZero, First.vip</blockquote><blockquote>Wormhole Docs, <a href="https://docs.wormhole.com/">https://docs.wormhole.com/</a></blockquote><blockquote>LayerZero Docs, <a href="https://layerzero.gitbook.io/docs;">https://layerzero.gitbook.io/docs;</a> <a href="https://docs.layerzero.network/">https://docs.layerzero.network/</a></blockquote><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/Axelar">https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/Axelar</a> (as of March 12, 2024)</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> <a href="https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/axelar-a039/investor_financials">https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/axelar-a039/investor_financials</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Figure 2–1 and Figure 2–2 were captured at: <a href="https://cauldron.io/">https://cauldron.io/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> <a href="https://docs.axelar.dev/learn/network/flow">https://docs.axelar.dev/learn/network/flow</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> <a href="https://axelar.network/blog/axelar-virtual-machine-future-of-interoperability">https://axelar.network/blog/axelar-virtual-machine-future-of-interoperability</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> <a href="https://axelarscan.io/interchain">https://axelarscan.io/interchain</a> (The orange bars represent transactions via General Message Passing.)</p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> <a href="https://axelarscan.io/">https://axelarscan.io/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8">[8]</a> <a href="https://axelar.network/blog/vertex-bridge-announcement">https://axelar.network/blog/vertex-bridge-announcement</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref9">[9]</a> <a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/axelar">https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/axelar</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref10">[10]</a> <a href="https://medium.com/@axelar-foundation/an-overview-of-axl-token-economics-4dc701c9054d">https://medium.com/@axelar-foundation/an-overview-of-axl-token-economics-4dc701c9054d</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref11">[11]</a> <a href="https://token.unlocks.app/axelar">https://token.unlocks.app/axelar</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref12">[12]</a> <a href="https://community.axelar.network/t/adjusting-axelar-network-incentives-a-proposal-to-scale-to-thousands-of-chains-call-for-">https://community.axelar.network/t/adjusting-axelar-network-incentives-a-proposal-to-scale-to-thousands-of-chains-call-for-</a> comments/2515</p><p><a href="#_ftnref13">[13]</a> <a href="https://www.mintscan.io/axelar/validators">https://www.mintscan.io/axelar/validators</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref14">[14]</a> <a href="https://docs.wormhole.com/wormhole/explore-wormhole/components">https://docs.wormhole.com/wormhole/explore-wormhole/components</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref15">[15]</a> Data statistics were captured at: <a href="https://app.aevo.xyz/perpetual/w">https://app.aevo.xyz/perpetual/w</a> (as of March 12, 2024)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a41e38b9e43c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[头等仓公开尽调研报：跨链互操作协议Axelar]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/%E5%A4%B4%E7%AD%89%E4%BB%93%E5%85%AC%E5%BC%80%E5%B0%BD%E8%B0%83%E7%A0%94%E6%8A%A5-%E8%B7%A8%E9%93%BE%E4%BA%92%E6%93%8D%E4%BD%9C%E5%8D%8F%E8%AE%AEaxelar-db8040c97955?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db8040c97955</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Mar 2024 15:02:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-14T09:50:19.826Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-nyKop92AU4E0leI" /></figure><p>Axelar是一个跨链互操作性项目，以跨链技术为基础，在跨链和多链的概念之上，又提出了一个链间的概念，致力于为所有的Web3应用提供一个统一的开发环境。为此，于2024年Axelar开发了Axelar虚拟机（AVM），并且推出了多款开发工具，让Axelar从一个负责消息和资产传递的跨链层进化为了一个可以进行编程和部署智能合约执行更复杂操作的跨链层。项目目前发展情况良好，交易量和用户数稳步增长，未来如果能够依托链间的概念拓展出一整个生态系统，将在这个赛道当中拥有不错的竞争优势。</p><h4><strong>投资概要</strong></h4><p>Axelar是一个跨链互操作性项目。</p><p>从团队和资金来看，Axelar团队有不错的学术背景和开发能力，且完成了多轮融资，总融资额达到了1.138亿美元，投资人包括Binance，Polychain Capital，Coinbase Ventures，Dragonfly Capital，Crypto.com Capital等，<strong>项目目前开发情况良好，代码提交量和开发者数量都呈现出了明显上升的趋势。</strong></p><p>从产品和技术来看，Axelar以跨链技术为基础，并且在跨链（Cross-chain）和多链（Multichain）的概念之上，又提出了一个链间（Interchain）的概念，这个概念当中，所有的Web3应用将拥有一个统一的开发环境，这个开发环境将容纳多种链上不同的逻辑，并且支持来自多种链上的用户。为此，2024年，Axelar在CosmWasm的基础上开发了Axelar虚拟机（Axelar Virtual Machine（AVM）），并且推出了Interchain Amplifier和Interchain Maestro等工具，让Axelar从一个负责消息和资产传递的跨链层进化为了一个可以进行编程和部署智能合约执行更复杂操作的跨链层。<strong>从某种程度上来讲，Axelar的链间概念是对跨链，多链概念的一种升级，其核心在于利用Axelar网络的优势，将Axelar网络作为了一个多链网络当中的中心交互节点，通过在这个中心节点当中开发和部署应用程序，然后扩展至其他网络，就可以极大地提升效率，降低成本，而对用户来讲，也将有更平滑的使用体验。因此Axelar所提出的链间方案在未来拥有着非常不错的潜力。</strong></p><p>从项目发展来看，Axelar目前发展情况良好。数据方面，GMP跨链消息数量的增长，反映了跨链生态的成长与完善，同时活跃用户数量一直保持着相对的稳定，也显示了Axelar生态的用户粘性。除此之外Axelar生态版图也在不断扩大，目前已经与60个链相连，交互，合作以及集成的智能合约超过600个，其中不乏DeFi，公链，二层等赛道的龙头项目。未来随着生态相关项目的发展，Axelar也将取得一定的成绩。</p><p>从代币经济学的角度来看，AXL代币主要作为网络的应用代币使用，发挥网络共识，治理，发展，支付等方面的职能。<strong>未来AXL代币将会转为通货紧缩，届时将进一步推动网络的良性发展。</strong></p><p>从赛道的角度来看，Axelar所处于的跨链互操作性赛道仍然在成长阶段，未来随着公链赛道以及DeFi赛道的发展将有很大的成长空间。在赛道竞争当中，<strong>Axelar所提出的解决方案以及链间的概念使其在可拓展性方面有着得天独厚的优势。未来如果可以依托这个概念，吸引足够的项目来建立一个繁荣的生态，那么Axelar将拥有在这个赛道当中很大的竞争优势。</strong></p><h4><strong>1. 基本概况</strong></h4><p><strong>1.1 项目简介</strong></p><p>Axelar是一个跨链互操作性项目，以跨链技术为基础，在跨联和多链的概念之上，又提出了一个链间的概念，致力于为所有的Web3应用提供一个统一的开发环境。为此，于2024年Axelar开发了Axelar虚拟机（AVM），并且推出了多款开发工具，让Axelar从一个负责消息和资产传递的跨链层进化为了一个可以进行编程和部署智能合约执行更复杂操作的跨链层。</p><p><strong>1.2 基本信息 </strong><a href="#_ftn1"><em>[1]</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ULjnqqiCXY2lG3ucHVF0vA.png" /></figure><h4><strong>2. 项目详解</strong></h4><p><strong>2.1 团队</strong></p><p>根据当前可以获得的信息，Axelar的开发团队Interop Labs位于加拿大，总人数估计在50人左右，在领英上目前有33名雇员：</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*RkvOIGs5bccwpue7bLzCTQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Sergey Gorbunov — 联合创始人</strong>，多伦多大学计算机科学学士，硕士学位，麻省理工学院计算机科学博士学位。毕业后创办了一家帮助企业进行数据加密的公司StealthMine，2018年，Gorbunov加入Algorand担任首席密码学家。2020年6月，Gorbunov参与创办了Axelar。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*aJxN-kADfXfhH7zeeD9L8Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>Georgios Vlachos — 联合创始人</strong>，麻省理工学院计算机科学学士，硕士学位。毕业后加入Algorand，担任数学研究负责人，2020年6月，Vlachos参与创办了Axelar。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*y172oIM57Zte2XlJ6vwhVg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Christian Gorenflo — 开发团队负责人</strong>，德国卡尔斯鲁厄理工学院物理学学士学位，滑铁卢大学计算机科学博士学位。毕业后加入Axelar的开发团队Interop Labs，担任区块链工程师，2023年7月升任开发团队负责人。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*aRfzt5cK40ujx2H8fi5YZw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Milap Sheth — 工程团队负责人</strong>，滑铁卢大学计算机科学学士学位。毕业后加入了一家网络安全解决方案公司ISARA从事软件开发工作，2021年7月，Sheth加入Interop Labs，担任工程团队负责人。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/177/1*RZaGLTfDw6bdjhDChkaJoQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Talal Ashraf — DevOps团队负责人</strong>，多伦多大学电气与计算机工程学士学位。毕业后加入一家企业云服务开发公司Symantec担任全栈后端工程师，随后于2019年，2020年相继加入两家软件开发公司，Flywheel和Pixlee从事DevOps开发工作，2021年8月，Ashraf加入Interop Labs，担任DevOps团队负责人。</p><p>总的来看， Axelar项目的开发团队成员均有不错的学术背景，创始人还曾经参加过Algorand公链的研究与开发，因此项目本身拥有不错的开发能力。</p><p><strong>2.2 资金</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DapUtzaF3MWgj8n2MAOJzw.png" /><figcaption><strong>表2–1 Axelar融资情况</strong><em> </em><a href="#_ftn2"><em>[2]</em></a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>截至2024年3月5日，Axelar共完成了5轮融资，根据已经披露的融资信息，总融资额达到了1.138亿美元，B轮融资时，项目总估值已经达到了10亿美元。投资人包括Binance，Polychain Capital，Coinbase Ventures，Dragonfly Capital，Crypto.com Capital等。但是最近一轮融资完成于2022年3月10日，距今已接近两年，目前项目实际资金情况不明，但因其仍然能维持团队规模，且仍在推进开发和运营计划，因此估计项目本身资金仍然较为充裕。</strong></p><p><strong>2.3 代码</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mz7AGwG4_Gi53EhE3l-qEA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–1 Axelar代码提交情况</strong> <a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Lew59toyUdWbZ-FEPSJf7g.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–2 Axelar代码贡献者情况</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Axelar的源代码在Github上开源。截至2024年3月4日，从上图可以看出，Axelar代码在持续更新，Commits提交数共计12,110次，开发者人数最多时在50人以上，目前开发者数量约在50人左右。Axelar的开发节奏没有出现过明显的峰谷，进入2023年以来，Axelar的代码更新量和开发人员数量都呈现出稳步上升的趋势，说明目前项目开发情况良好。</strong></p><p><strong>2.4 产品与技术</strong></p><p>Axelar是一个用Cosmos SDK开发的以跨链为主要核心业务的跨链互操作性项目。</p><p><strong>2.4.1 跨链层</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/952/1*Life86vcVPsaUww9mpQziA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–3 Axelar技术堆栈 </strong><a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a></figcaption></figure><p>在跨链方案上，Axelar选择的是以网关为点，验证者为线，Axelar网络为面的“三位一体”的跨链层作为跨链解决方案。其中：</p><p><strong>网关主要负责通信和跨链执行功能。</strong>在跨链发起的源链上，网关负责发起相应的请求，而在跨链接收的目标链上，网关负责接收并执行相应的消息完成跨链操作。在EVM链上，网关以智能合约的形式存在，而在Cosmos和其他非EVM链上，网关以Dapp的形式存在，控制网关的多重签名密钥由所有验证者共同持有，每个验证者所持有的分享密钥份额由其质押的AXL代币数量来决定，只有当确认消息的验证者提交的密钥份额超过阈值时，密钥才会生效。</p><p>用户在各条链上发送的跨链消息，都会首先与网关进行交互，网关在收到消息后会在后台生成一个事件，随后由<strong>中继器</strong>拾取这些事件，并且将这些事件提交到Axelar网络进行处理。</p><p><strong>验证者主要负责消息验证与网络共识。</strong>当跨链事件被提交到Axelar网络以后，验证者节点就会开始工作，通过查询其在源链节点的RPC端口，检查是否能够观察到被提交的事件，随后再确认事件存在后，投票批准该事件为合法。随后验证者会将这些事件打包成区块，并且通过权益证明共识来确认这些区块。</p><p><strong>Axelar网络主要负责处理所有的跨链请求，并且支付相应的Gas费用。</strong>当区块打包完毕，跨链请求的消息被授权之后，另一组中继器会拾取这些消息，并定期将这些消息发送到目标链上的网关上。在这个过程中，Axelar需要使用目标链上的代币来支付Gas费用。而为了方便用户的使用，使其不用准备目标链和Axelar上的代币以支付Gas费用，Axelar创建并部署了一个名为Gas Receiver的智能合约。Gas Receiver合约会估算源链，Axelar网络和目标链上所需要的总Gas费用，向用户一次性收取源链上的原生代币作为Gas费用，随后将这些原生代币转换为AXL，目标链代币和其他需要的代币，代用户完成Gas费支付。在这个过程当中，Gas Receiver一般会收取超过实际支付数量的代币，并在交易完成后将多余的Gas费用返还到用户账户。</p><p>相比于常见的跨链桥，作为跨链层的Axelar网络在很多方面有着更多的优势。</p><p><strong>1）首先是安全性方面，Axelar的安全性由多重签名密钥和网络共识层来保证。</strong>首先在传输跨链信息和执行跨链操作时，需要达到阈值数量的验证者节点确认完消息的真实性并提交分享密钥，网关才能发挥作用，且Axelar在网关层面还添加了速率限制的功能，在给定时间间隔内每类资产进行交易的数量将存在一个上限。其次所有的跨链事件被打包完毕后，需要通过委托权益证明（DPoS）共识机制确认，才能生成新的区块。而且为了降低由于AXL质押份额不同，导致投票权集中于少数利益相关者的风险，在共识层面Axelar还引入了“平方投票”机制，即当验证者进行投票时，其获得一个份额的投票权，需要质押一个单位的AXL代币，但是如果其需要获得两个份额的投票权，则要质押二的平方，即四个单位的AXL代币，以此类推，验证者节点所拥有的代币份额，需要开完平方以后才能获得相应数量的投票权。在限制了高质押份额的验证者节点以后，网络的去中心化程度有了更大的提升。以上，两种机制的存在，保证了Axelar相较于常见的跨链桥拥有着更好的安全性。</p><p><strong>2）其次是可拓展性方面，Axelar作为一个公链，能够执行智能合约。</strong>这意味着Axelar能够更方便快捷且低成本地与其他的公链和Dapp进行集成，甚至在模块化区块链的概念当中充当他们的“跨链层”来帮助这些项目完成跨链的操作，同时也能有效地提升用户的使用体验。例如Axelar发布的一个API，可以帮助集成的Dapp生产一个一次性存款地址，这些地址可以从集成的任何链上的任何钱包当中接收任意代币的跨链资金，让用户在跨链的过程当中获得不亚于中心化交易所的交互体验。其次通过拓展通用消息传递（General Message Passing（GMP））功能，使得Axelar不光能够实现资产跨链，还能够支持复杂的跨链函数调用以及跨链状态同步，这极大地提升了与Axelar合作的Dapp的可拓展性。</p><p><strong>除此之外，在2023年，Axelar在跨链（Cross-chain）和多链（Multichain）的概念之上，又提出了一个链间（Interchain）的概念，这个概念当中，所有的Web3应用将拥有一个统一的开发环境，这个开发环境将容纳多种链上不同的逻辑，并且支持来自多种链上的用户，进一步实现Axelar的全栈互操作性的理想。为此，2024年，Axelar在CosmWasm的基础上开发了Axelar虚拟机（Axelar Virtual Machine（AVM）），让Axelar从一个负责消息和资产传递的跨链层进化为了一个可以进行编程和部署智能合约执行更复杂操作的跨链层。</strong></p><p><strong>2.4.2 Axelar Virtual Machine（AVM）</strong></p><p>AVM作为一个图灵完备的虚拟机，其意义不管是能够部署智能合约，还在于其彻底改变了传统Dapp实现跨链的逻辑。因为对于Dapp的开发人员来讲，在AVM上开发的应用程序就相当于先天拥有了跨链的功能，而无需后天再去与其他跨链项目集成，其跨链的功能则是由更底层的区块链，也就是Axelar来实现的，这就是Axelar所提出的链间（Interchain）的概念。用Axelar自己的话来讲，<strong>就是“一次构建，随处可用”（Build once, run everywhere）</strong>。</p><p>具体来讲，通过在AVM上开发Dapp，DeFi项目将能够同时使用多个链上的流动性来进行交易或者借贷；稳定币项目将能够拓展应用空间，且让用户在多个链上获得无缝的使用体验；游戏项目可以选择在多个链上发行同一个资产或者代币；NFT项目也可以集成到跨链游戏当中，或者充分地享受更高的交易流动性；钱包项目可以登陆任何一个区块链，为上面的用户提供服务；DAO项目可以跨多个链进行治理和行动，并且更轻松地分配资产。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2gPc8hBLIL4sWMRX5qPk_A.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2–4 AVM架构</strong> <a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a></figcaption></figure><p>为了帮助开发人员更有效率，更低成本地在AVM上部署自己的项目，Axelar推出了两个可供开发人员使用以构建应用程序的工具： Interchain Amplifier和Interchain Maestro。</p><p>Interchain Amplifier是一个供开发人员连接和使用Axelar网络的工具，主要用于帮助开发人员无需许可且低成本地建立起与Axelar网络的连接。开发者仅需支付加入Axelar网络的成本，就可以享受到Axelar与其他生态系统和网络之间的链接，来添加新的功能属性来提升Dapp安全性和可拓展性，因此被称为Amplifier（放大器）。其用例包括可以轻松地将以太坊上开发的一些组件，例如ZK证明组件集成到Axelar网络的Dapp当中。</p><p>Interchain Maestro是一个供开发人员部署和管理多链Dapp的工具，开发人员通过以下简单的流程就可以在多链上部署自己的合约：<br> 1）指定想部署的合约，设置合约的关键参数以及希望涉及的链。<br> 2）将参数和内容存储在Axelar的智能合约上，并且把智能合约部署在相关的链上。<br> 3）将这些合约扩展或者克隆至其他链。<br> 4）当需要升级Dapp时，开发人员仅需在Axelar上发起一笔交易升级自己的合约代码，这些代码的升级就会发送到其他连接的链上，而无需分别在其他链上进行智能合约的升级。</p><p>开发人员可以通过Interchain Maestro极大地提升Dapp部署的效率，并且降低Dapp部署的成本。其中Interchain Maestro当中的重要组件Interchain Token Service已经发布至主网，通过该功能，项目方可以轻松地发行和管理链间的代币，并且在这个跨链部署的过程当中保留代币的跨链可互换性以及一些自定义功能。</p><p><strong>通过AVM的部署，可以真正实践Axelar所提出的“链间（Interchain）”的概念，从而为Axelar生态系统的发展奠定切实的基础。从某种程度上来讲，Axelar的链间概念是对跨链，多链概念的一种升级，其核心在于相当于确立了一个多链网络当中的中心交互节点，通过在这个中心节点当中开发和部署应用程序，就可以极大地提升效率，降低成本，而对用户来讲，也将有更平滑的使用体验。因此Axelar所提出的这种方案在未来拥有不错的潜力。</strong></p><p><strong>总结</strong></p><p><strong>从团队和资金来看，Axelar团队有不错的学术背景和开发能力，且完成了多轮融资，总融资额达到了1.138亿美元，投资人包括Binance，Polychain Capital，Coinbase Ventures，Dragonfly Capital，Crypto.com Capital等，项目目前开发情况良好，代码提交量和开发者数量都呈现出了明显上升的趋势。</strong></p><p><strong>从产品和技术来看，Axelar以跨链技术为基础，并且在跨链（Cross-chain）和多链（Multichain）的概念之上，又提出了一个链间（Interchain）的概念，这个概念当中，所有的Web3应用将拥有一个统一的开发环境，这个开发环境将容纳多种链上不同的逻辑，并且支持来自多种链上的用户。为此，2024年，Axelar在CosmWasm的基础上开发了Axelar虚拟机（Axelar Virtual Machine（AVM）），并且推出了Interchain Amplifier和Interchain Maestro等工具，让Axelar从一个负责消息和资产传递的跨链层进化为了一个可以进行编程和部署智能合约执行更复杂操作的跨链层。从某种程度上来讲，Axelar的链间概念是对跨链，多链概念的一种升级，其核心在于利用Axelar网络的优势，将Axelar网络作为了一个多链网络当中的中心交互节点，通过在这个中心节点当中开发和部署应用程序，然后扩展至其他网络，就可以极大地提升效率，降低成本，而对用户来讲，也将有更平滑的使用体验。因此Axelar所提出的链间方案在未来拥有着非常不错的潜力。</strong></p><h4><strong>3. 发展</strong></h4><p><strong>3.1 历史</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EVnZIAD2xsOo6APN96qNaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>表3–1 Axelar大事件</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>3.2 现状</strong></p><p><strong>3.2.1 运营数据</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0WK1vuM1wb-RqLyeen3NVA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图3–1 Axelar交易量</strong> <a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ygsmT2QgEysbuTnaQ9JpRg.png" /><figcaption><strong>图3–1 Axelar活跃地址数</strong></figcaption></figure><p>根据Axelar的区块浏览器，截至2024年3月11日11时，Axelar上共产生了1,528,445笔交易，其中GMP（General Message Passing）交易962,300笔，占比约62.96%，GMP交易主要用于在一个链上调用凭借Axelar连接的其他链上的智能合约，其与普通跨链交易的区别在于，其指定的对象是智能合约，而普通跨链交易则仅是负责把一种资产从源链的账户转移到目标链的账户上。因此2023年以后，GMP交易数量的快速上升，反映的是Axelar跨链生态的不断完善和活跃。除此之外，自2023年以来，Axelar的活跃用户数量也出现了明显的增加，并且后续一直保持着相对的稳定，这体现了Axelar拥有着不错的用户生态粘性。</p><p><strong>3.2.2 生态项目</strong></p><p>作为一个可以进行编程和部署智能合约执行更复杂操作的跨链层，Axelar的生态系统既包含与其相连接的其他链，还包括在其之上开发的Dapp。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f7D3oN3gLWeo_E7Nz4A8Og.png" /><figcaption><strong>图3–2 Axelar跨链公链生态图</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Axelar上目前已经有60个与之相连的区块链，并且这些区块链可以按照用户以及Dapp交互的活跃等级分为3个等级。</p><p>T1等级的公链包括：Polygon，Osmosis，BNB Chain，Arbitrum，Avalanche，Ethereum，Fantom，Moonbeam，Celo，Terra Classic，Terra，Base，Optimism，Kujira。</p><p>T2级别的公链包括：Kava，Sei，Mantle，Linea，Neutron，Umee，Juno，Crescent，Secret-SNIP，Cosmos，Filecoin，Evmos，Scroll，Comdex，XPLA。</p><p>其中从Polygon发起的交易约有290,330笔，占比约19.00%，从BNB Chain发起的交易约有189,880笔，占比约12.42%，从Osmosis发起的交易约为166,120笔，占比约10.87%，从Arbitrum发起的交易约为151,400笔，占比约9.91%，从Avalanche发起的交易约为135,840笔，占比约8.89%，从Ethereum发起的交易约为95,540笔，占比约6.25%。可以看到Axelar跨链生态当中各公链的参与是相对分散的，不存在于特别依赖于某条公链的情况，整体的发展情况较为健康。</p><p>在应用程序层面，截至2024年3月11日，在Axelar上部署或者准备部署的Dapp已经达到了635<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a>个。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*veg8ESQ6zxfiGFKS5LJaKg.png" /><figcaption><strong>图3–3 Axelar生态的部分项目</strong> <a href="#_ftn8">[8]</a></figcaption></figure><p>目前已经部署的项目，包括钱包项目，例如MetaMask，Trust Wallet，Keplr；基础设施项目，例如Biconomy；游戏项目，例如Decentraland；DeFi项目，例如dYdX，Lido，PancakeSwap，SushiSwap，QuickSwap，KyberSwap。</p><p>除此之外还有一些与Axelar集成或者合作的项目，包括Uniswap，Ripple，Immutable，Frax Finance，Vertex，Ondo Finance，Fantom，Band Protocol，Sommelier，Filecoin，Umee，Polygon，Sui，Circle等。</p><p>目前来看，Axelar生态相关的项目以DeFi和公链为主，这与Axelar本身的跨链性质是分不开的，后续随着DeFi生态和公链生态的繁荣，Axelar拥有不错的发展潜力。</p><p><strong>3.2.3 社交媒体规模</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9_XlhwLlVxAL_sELd9XRNg.png" /><figcaption><strong>表3–2 Axelar社交媒体数据</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>截止2024年3月11日，Axelar的社交媒体平台规模较大，粉丝数量较多，但互动较少。社区人数较多，但活跃程度一般，交流内容主要围绕项目交互所遇到的问题。治理论坛活跃程度一般，交流内容主要围绕后续项目技术升级以及发展方向</strong>。</p><p><strong>3.3 未来</strong></p><p>根据Axelar于2024年1月30日公布的路线图，Axelar接下来的发展将围绕AVM展开，具体来讲将包括以下几个分项：</p><p>1）让AVM成为开源工具的发展平台，进行各种Dapp的开发。<br> 2）通过Interchain Amplifier来实现对任意链的无许可链接，将潜在的网络效应扩展到以太坊Layer2等数百个区块链当中。<br> 3）拓展Interchain Tokens的用例，在所有连接的链上扩展其在原生链上的可用性。<br> 4）为AXL代币添加Gas燃烧机制，从而实现通货紧缩来保护Axelar网络。<br> 5）整合不同链上的共识机制，包括Solana，Stellar和基于Move的链，如Aptos和Sui。<br> 6）改进Gas的定价机制，提高在Axelar网络上跨链Gas估算服务的准确性。</p><p><strong>总结：</strong></p><p><strong>从项目发展来看，Axelar目前发展情况良好。数据方面，GMP跨链消息数量的增长，反映了跨链生态的成长与完善，同时活跃用户数量一直保持着相对的稳定，也显示了Axelar生态的用户粘性。除此之外Axelar生态版图也在不断扩大，目前已经与60个链相连，交互，合作以及集成的智能合约超过600个，其中不乏DeFi，公链，二层等赛道的龙头项目。未来随着生态相关项目的发展，Axelar也将取得一定的成绩。</strong></p><h4><strong>4. 经济模型</strong></h4><p><strong>4.1 供给</strong></p><p><strong>4.1.1 AXL代币分配</strong><em> </em><a href="#_ftn9"><strong><em>[9]</em></strong></a></p><p>AXL是Axelar的项目代币，于2022年9月上线主网，初始供应量为1,000,000,000枚，采用通货膨胀的方式发行新的AXL代币，截至2024年3月5日，AXL代币的供应量为1,137,455,595枚，总流通量587,380,415枚。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*12wplrI5SQ7vzXFo6_rbYA.png" /><figcaption><strong>表4–1 AXL代币初次发行大致分配情况</strong><a href="#_ftn10"><strong>[10]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/765/1*YO-si6LrPHTc5Nt7j-7AWg.png" /><figcaption><strong>图4–1 AXL代币初次分配图</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/675/1*UcrOgxYflmKmiel2bPSIYQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>图4–2 AXL代币分配堆积图</strong></figcaption></figure><p>从代币分配来看，在初次分配的10亿枚AXL当中，团队和融资占比都在三成左右，社区和生态占比为四成，比例相对合理。截至2024年3月5日，距离代币首次发行已经接近17个月，在首次发行的10亿枚代币当中已解锁的代币约为4.52<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a>亿枚。</p><p>从代币的增发方式来看，目前AXL代币仍然是一种通货膨胀代币，其代币通胀率的计算公式是，1%的基础通胀率加上每个外部支持的区块链（EVM链）提供0.3%的通胀率（2023年12月5日前为0.75%），目前有20个外部支持的区块链，因此当前通胀率为7%（2023年12月5日前为14.5%）。</p><p>为了推动网络的健康发展，Axelar计划将通过实施Gas燃烧计划将AXL代币从通货膨胀代币改变为通货紧缩代币。当前Axelar处理一条跨链信息约花费0.2 AXL代币，如果以每日处理10万笔交易来计算，大约一年会收取1.04<a href="#_ftn13">[13]</a>亿AXL，通过燃烧掉这些作为Gas费用的AXL代币，Axelar将可以抵消最高10%的通货膨胀率，实现代币的通货紧缩。</p><p>目前该提案虽然已经通过，但是有关AXL作为网络Gas代币并且进行燃烧的规划还未部署在主网上，这将是接下来一年当中Axelar努力的重点之一。</p><p><strong>4.2 需求</strong></p><p>AXL代币作为Axelar网络的原生代币，主要包含以下几个职能：</p><p>1）作为DPoS的基础来进行网络共识，并且作为验证者节点所能获取的区块奖励。</p><p>2）作为治理代币，对治理提案进行投票，包含网络参数以及协议的营销，发展和技术升级。</p><p>3）支付网络上的交易费用，未来将作为Axelar网络生态上面的主要Gas费用。</p><p>4）用于奖励生态系统的参与者和社区贡献者。</p><p><strong>4.2.1 网络节点</strong></p><p>Axelar网络采用了Tendermint的共识算法，进行DPoS形式的网络共识。目前验证者节点的数量固定为75个，代币质押数量前75的节点将可以注册成为验证者，该验证者数量未来可以通过治理来进行调整。</p><p>Axelar链上的验证者需要首先在其选择的外部链上配置节点，随后将外部链的RPC端点提交给Axelar验证器节点，并且注册为这些外部链的维护者，以随时提交这些外部链的状态以供投票，因此具有一定的运营门槛。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VBJV24rQPPGBGuDGYIf5bQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>图4–3验证者节点份额</strong><a href="#_ftn14"><strong>[14]</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>各个节点将在区块共识的过程当中获得区块奖励，目前各个验证者节点区块奖励的预期APR在5%-10%之间，视其所部署在外部链上的节点数量而定，而实际的APR均在9%上下。Axelar网络用户可以通过将自己持有的AXL质押给对应的验证者节点，以分享所获得的区块奖励，此外取消质押将需要7天才能完成。</p><p>目前AXL份额占比最高的验证者节点ValidatorREX占比约为7.52%，前十验证者节点的份额占比约为34.31%，且份额前三的验证者节点几乎不参与协议的治理。因此可以看到，虽然Axelar的验证者节点数量相对较少，但是仍然有着一定的去中心化程度。</p><p><strong>总结：</strong></p><p><strong>从代币经济学的角度来看，AXL代币的设计中规中矩，主要作为网络的应用代币使用，发挥网络共识，治理，发展，支付等方面的职能。未来AXL代币将会转为通货紧缩，届时将进一步推动网络的良性发展。</strong></p><h4><strong>5. 赛道</strong></h4><p><strong>5.1 赛道综述</strong></p><p>Axelar作为一个可以进行消息跨链和资产跨链的跨链层可以被归入跨链互操作性赛道。</p><p>在过去，大众一般理解当中的跨链赛道指的都是进行资产跨链的项目，而在信息传递的方案被提出来以后，跨链互操作性赛道就应运而生。跨链互操作性顾名思义其目的是为了实现多链之间的互相操作，例如用户能在A链上完成对B链的操作，这个操作的完成依赖的是不同链上数据之间的交互，包括资产，链的状态，合约调用等信息的互通有无。从某种程度上来讲，跨链互操作性与侧链有一定的相似之处，两者都强调实现主链和侧链之间的互操作性，也就是资产和信息的共享。而不同的地方在于，跨链互操作性项目致力于实现一个互操作性的网络，当在主链上连接到这个网络以后，所有连接在网络上的其他链理论上都能成为主链的“侧链”。</p><p>目前跨链互操作性赛道当中的项目一般都遵循着类似的实现架构，就是“观察-确认-传递/交互”。因为本质上来讲，所有的跨链项目承担的都是类似“中介”的职能，它需要先获取源链的信息，确认并处理之后再与目标链进行交互，而在这个过程当中，如何获取源链的信息，如何确认和处理获得的信息以及如何与目标链交互就成为了各个跨链互操作性项目在产品和技术上竞争的重点。</p><p>目前跨链互操作性赛道当中的项目不多，赛道整体的发展仍处于成长期，未来还有较大的发展潜力。在下面的竞品对比当中，我们将选取LayerZero和Wormhole来作为Axelar的竞品，对三者的实现方案进行一定程度的比较。</p><p><strong>5.2 竞品对比</strong></p><p><strong>5.2.1 LayerZero</strong></p><p>LayerZero是一个全链互操作性协议。</p><p>从团队和资金来看，LayerZero的团队有着较为丰富的开发经验，且团队内彼此有较长时间的合作关系，磨合度高。目前已经完成了多轮融资，总融资额达到了2.933亿美元，投资者当中包括，Binance Labs，Delphi Digital，A16z，红杉资本，Coinbase Ventures等一众明星资本。</p><p>从产品和技术来看，LayerZero专注于实现“轻量化”的数据传输，因此其选择使用预言机和中继网络来完成数据的传输。当用户在LayerZero源链的端点上完成操作以后，预言机作为一个外部组件，会将源链上交易的区块头转发至目标链，同时中继会获取源链上的交易证明，并将其传输至目标链。这样做的好处有三个：<br> 1）降低了信息传输的成本。因为LayerZero无需在各个链上运行自己的节点，而将信息验证的职能外包了出去，同时预言机是单向往目标链发送信息的，也避免了与验证节点之间产生互动的成本。<br> 2）保证了安全性。将预言机和中继的职能相互分离且独立，并使得两者传输的信息可以进行互相验证，减少了预言机或者中继单独作恶对网络的威胁。<br> 3）增加了可拓展性。因为预言机和中继仅负责传输信息，所有的验证都是在各自的源链和目标链上完成的，因此交易的速度和吞吐量将完全取决于两个交易链上的属性。</p><p>2024年1月LayerZero推出了V2版本，将消息验证和执行分为了两个独立的阶段，开发人员能够视其需求，设定不同的安全配置，并且进行独立的执行，由此拥有了更多的自主权，提升了协议的可编程性。</p><p>从代币经济学来看，虽然目前LayerZero仍未发币，但是团队在其官方文档的代码当中释出了一些讯息，预计未来LayerZero的代币将承担支付Gas等职能。</p><p>从项目发展来看，目前LayerZero发展情况良好，尤其是进入2024年3月以来，用户使用量出现了显著增长。生态系统方面已经支持了超过20个链的互联，其中交易最多的源链为Arbitrum，Optimism，Polygon，Avalanche，Binance，Fantom和Ethereum。集成和合作的Dapps达到了95个，并且仍在增加当中。</p><p><strong>5.2.2 Wormhole</strong></p><p>Wormhole是一个通用消息传递协议。</p><p>从团队和资金来看，Wormhole脱胎于Solana 与 Certus.One的合作，最开始仅是为了Ethereum和Solana两个网络建立的跨链桥，因此有着较为丰富的开发经验。2023年11月Wormhole以25亿美元的估值完成了2.25亿美元的融资，并成立了新公司Wormhole Labs负责新协议的开发。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NW8l-w00yo0hU6bbLUm0Rw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图5–1 Wormhole架构</strong> <a href="#_ftn15">[15]</a></figcaption></figure><p>从产品和技术来看，Wormhole的实现方案较为“简单粗暴”，整体架构由链上组件和链下组件组成。</p><p>链上组件主要包括发射器（Emitter），Wormhole核心合约以及交易日志。</p><p>发射器当中包含xAsset合约（将普通代币转化为xAsset，并且进行桥接的智能合约），中继合约（允许跨链应用程序通过去中心化通用跨链中继网络将消息发送给特定区块链的智能合约）以及Worm Router合约（允许开发人员将Dapp打造成跨链应用程序的智能合约）等智能合约组成，负责调用核心合约进行消息发送。</p><p>Wormhole核心合约是与链下组件进行交互的合约，主要负责消息的验证与确认。</p><p>交易日志是区块链上的特定日志，允许链下组件观察核心组件发出的消息。</p><p>链下组件主要由守护者节点和消息传输网络组成。</p><p>其中守护者节点由19个守护者组成，他们持有VAA（Verifiable Action Approvals ）多重签名，其在每个连接的链上都运行一个完整的节点，专门监听来自核心合约的任何消息。当有三分之二及以上的守护者验证消息并签名以后，经过验证的消息就会被中继到目标链，在目标链中处理消息并完成跨链交易。</p><p>Wormhole采用的外部验证的解决方案，其优势在于速度较快，且成本较低，并且可以以很快的速度拓展至多个链上，但是其劣势在于牺牲了一定的安全性，需要依赖少数几个验证者节点，也存在着一定的中心化风险。</p><p>从代币经济学来看，Wormhole的代币将主要用于未来项目与生态系统的发展，并且拥有一定的治理职能。但是总的来看W代币与项目发展之间的链接不够紧密，无法充分分享到项目发展的红利也无法为项目带来更多的赋能。</p><p>从项目发展来看，目前Wormhole发展情况良好，虽然在FTX暴雷以后，被Solana生态连累出现了一年多的低潮期，但是从2023年年中开始项目又恢复了一定的活力。目前Wormhole所连接的网络（包含验证网）超过40个，从交易量来看，交易最多的源链为Ethereum，Solana，Sui，Arbitrum这四者相互之间的交易构成了Wormhole上的主要交易。目前与Wormhole集成和合作的Dapps已经超过100个，并且仍在增加当中。</p><h4><strong>竞争总结</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vnKVrwWskODyFNSgNF9nyg.png" /><figcaption><strong>表5–1 Axelar，LayerZero和Wormhole的竞争分析</strong> <a href="#_ftn16">[16]</a></figcaption></figure><p>同LayerZero以及Wormhole进行对比以后，我们可以发现，因为Axelar需要进行节点验证和网络共识，因此Axelar的架构在效率不如LayerZero，在安全性上来讲的话，LayerZero和Axelar都有可取之处，LayerZero简化了跨链信息交互的流程，本身不负责信息的验证，在预言机与中继不合谋的情况下，由源链和目标链自身来保证跨链的安全性，Axelar则是依靠网络的共识来保证跨链的安全性。Axelar在架构上与Wormhole类似，但是与Wormhole相比，Axelar的验证者节点数量更多，因此更为去中心化。</p><p>但在可拓展性方面，作为一个可以进行编程和部署智能合约执行更复杂操作的跨链层，Axelar则拥有得天独厚的优势，其提出的链间概念，也能进一步为后续生态系统的开发奠定基础。同时从代币经济学来看，AXL代币与Axelar的结合无疑更加紧密，在新的代币经济模型应用以后，能够为项目的发展带来新的赋能。而从目前具体的项目发展来看，我们可以看到LayerZero的发展的侧重点在于以太坊二层生态之间的互动，Wormhole发展的侧重点在于Solana生态与以太坊生态的互动，Axelar发展的侧重点则在于以太坊生态与Cosmos生态之间的互动，三者呈现相互竞争又相互补充的态势。这意味着当前的市场竞争环境仍处于蓝海当中，未来随着公链赛道与DeFi赛道的发展，跨链互操作性赛道将仍有更广阔的市场成长空间。</p><p>综上所述，我们看好后续Axelar在跨链互操作性赛道当中的竞争潜力。</p><p><strong>总结</strong></p><p><strong>从赛道的角度来看，Axelar所处于的跨链互操作性赛道仍然在成长阶段，未来随着公链赛道以及DeFi赛道的发展将有很大的成长空间。在赛道竞争当中，Axelar所提出的解决方案以及链间的概念使其在可拓展性方面有着得天独厚的优势。未来如果可以依托这个概念，吸引足够的项目来建立一个繁荣的生态，那么Axelar将拥有在这个赛道当中很大的竞争优势。</strong></p><h4><strong>6. 风险</strong></h4><p><strong>1）代码安全性风险：</strong>尽管完成了多次审计，Axelar仍然有存在系统风险与漏洞的可能性，同时跨链赛道作为黑客攻击的重灾区，用户需要有更高的警惕。</p><p><strong>2）市场竞争风险：</strong>目前Axelar的竞品较多，且实力不弱。</p><p><strong>3）中心化风险：</strong>目前Axelar仅有75个网络节点，仍然存在一定程度的中心化风险。</p><p><strong>— END —</strong></p><p>推特 <a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61">@firstvip61</a> | 官网 <a href="https://first.vip/">First.VIP</a> | 咨询微信 gofirstvip</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1"><em>[1]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/Axelar"><em>https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/Axelar</em></a><em> 数据截至2024年3月12日</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2"><em>[2]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/axelar-a039/investor_financials"><em>https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/axelar-a039/investor_financials</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3"><em>[3]</em></a><em> 图2–2 2–3均来自https://cauldron.io/</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4"><em>[4]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://docs.axelar.dev/learn/network/flow"><em>https://docs.axelar.dev/learn/network/flow</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref5"><em>[5]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://axelar.network/blog/axelar-virtual-machine-future-of-interoperability"><em>https://axelar.network/blog/axelar-virtual-machine-future-of-interoperability</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6"><em>[6]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://axelarscan.io/interchain"><em>https://axelarscan.io/interchain</em></a><em> 图中黄色部分的交易为GMP交易</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref7"><em>[7]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://axelarscan.io/"><em>https://axelarscan.io/</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8"><em>[8]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://axelar.network/blog/vertex-bridge-announcement"><em>https://axelar.network/blog/vertex-bridge-announcement</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref9"><em>[9]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/axelar"><em>https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/axelar</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref10"><em>[10]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://medium.com/@axelar-foundation/an-overview-of-axl-token-economics-4dc701c9054d"><em>https://medium.com/@axelar-foundation/an-overview-of-axl-token-economics-4dc701c9054d</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref11"><em>[11]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://token.unlocks.app/axelar"><em>https://token.unlocks.app/axelar</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref12"><em>[12]</em></a><a href="https://axelarscan.io/token/tokenholderchart/0x471ece3750da237f93b8e339c536989b8978a438"><em>https://Axelarscan.io/token/tokenholderchart/0x471ece3750da237f93b8e339c536989b8978a438</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref13"><em>[13]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://community.axelar.network/t/adjusting-axelar-network-incentives-a-proposal-to-scale-to-thousands-of-chains-call-for-comments/2515"><em>https://community.axelar.network/t/adjusting-axelar-network-incentives-a-proposal-to-scale-to-thousands-of-chains-call-for-comments/2515</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref14"><em>[14]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://www.mintscan.io/axelar/validators"><em>https://www.mintscan.io/axelar/validators</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref15"><em>[15]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://docs.wormhole.com/wormhole/explore-wormhole/components"><em>https://docs.wormhole.com/wormhole/explore-wormhole/components</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref16"><em>[16]</em></a><em> 数据价格截至2024年3月12日，https://app.aevo.xyz/perpetual/w</em></p><p>参考资料</p><blockquote>Axelar文档，https://docs.axelar.dev/</blockquote><blockquote>Axelar虚拟机简介：助力跨链开发，https://axelar.network/blog/axelar-virtual-machine-future-of-interoperability</blockquote><blockquote>Axelar头等仓研报</blockquote><blockquote>LayerZero头等仓研报</blockquote><blockquote>Wormhole文档，https://docs.wormhole.com/</blockquote><blockquote>LayerZero文档，https://layerzero.gitbook.io/docs <a href="https://docs.layerzero.network/">https://docs.layerzero.network/</a></blockquote><p>— 投资风险与免责声明 —</p><blockquote>以上内容分析仅提供参考信息，不作为投资决策依据，请勿基于此报告进行任何投资决策，头等仓及报告作者不对用户投资结果负责。</blockquote><blockquote>报告自所示日期起准备，由于随后的市场或经济状况可能发生变化，报告内容不一定能反映这些变化。提供的图形，图表和其他视觉辅助工具仅供参考。这些图形、图表或可视化辅助工具都不可用于制定投资决策。不代表头等仓(First.VIP)会协助任何人做出投资决定，并且任何图形、图表或其他视觉辅助工具都无法捕获做出此类决定所需的所有因素和变量。</blockquote><blockquote>本⽂中涉及的某些陈述可能是头等仓(First.VIP)对于未来预期的假设以及其他的前瞻性观点，⽽已知和未知的⻛险与不确定因素，可能导致实际结果、表现或事件与陈述中的观点和假设存在实质性差异。</blockquote><blockquote>本报告中包含的任何推测、预测和估计本质上都是推测性的，并且基于某些假设。这些前瞻性陈述可能被证明是错误的，并可能受到不正确的假设或已知或未知的风险，不确定性和其他因素的影响，而其中大多数是无法控制的。可以预料，某些或所有此类前瞻性假设将不会实现，或与实际结果有很大差距。</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db8040c97955" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[头等仓新币速递：基于ERC404代币标准的Pandora]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/%E5%A4%B4%E7%AD%89%E4%BB%93%E6%96%B0%E5%B8%81%E9%80%9F%E9%80%92-%E5%9F%BA%E4%BA%8Eerc404%E7%9A%84pandora-172c742d5fa6?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/172c742d5fa6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Feb 2024 06:44:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-07T02:39:15.268Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>头等仓新币速递：基于</strong>ERC404代币标准的<strong>Pandora</strong></p><p>注：本文于2024–02–05首发于<a href="https://first.vip/"><em>头等仓官网</em></a></p><p>本文发表时$PANDORA价格为2376</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pNV7yw0k4l66OWNhngZp-w.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>精简解读</strong></h4><p>Pandora是2月2日上线的NFT碎片化项目，其核心技术是ERC404代币标准。用户可以在Uniswap V3购买项目同名代币PANDORA以获得ERC404代币，相当于碎片化持有其NFT — — Pandora Replicants，此外也可以直接在OpenSea购买Pandora Replicants。目前PANDORA币价2,375.76美元，24小时交易量536.5万美元；Pandora Replicants的交易量48 ETH。</p><h4><strong>基本面简介</strong></h4><p><strong>团队：</strong>Pandora由匿名团队开发，团队成员数量未知。目前从公开信息能找到3名开发展Acme、ctrl和Searn。Acme是Pandora项目的GitHub<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>运营者，从他的社交账号<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>来看他是Coinbase的工程师。另一名开发者网名ctrl<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>，是Syndicate的投资人之一，他运营着自己的Web3社群。还有一位开发者Searn<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a>的公开信息较少。</p><p><strong>资金：</strong>Pandora项目并未公开融资信息。</p><p><strong>业务机制</strong></p><p><strong>碎片化机制</strong></p><p>Pandora是一个NFT碎片化的项目，其核心是ERC404代币标准，这是一种介于ERC20和ERC721之间的试验性的代币标准。ERC404代币可以在Uniswap等平台进行交易，类似于同质化代币。同时，1枚<strong>ERC404代币</strong>可以对应1枚NFT（被称为<strong>Replicant NFT</strong>）。他们之间的数学关系如下：</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/0*J6xQjfF03S_iIOdi.png" /></figure><p>其中 n<em>Replicant NFT</em> 表示 Replicant NFT 的数量，n<em>ERC404 </em>表示ERC404代币的数量，[n]表示不大于该数的最大整数。</p><p>简单来讲，凑齐一整枚代币即可持有一个NFT。例如，用户持有0.5个代币，他拥有0个NFT；用户持有1个代币，他拥有1个NFT；用户持有1.5个代币，他拥有1个NFT；用户持有2个代币，他拥有2个NFT；用户持有2.5个代币，他拥有2个NFT，以此类推。</p><p>在Pandora项目中，它的ERC404代币是PANDORA，它的Replicant NFT是Pandora Replicants。用户首先可以在Uniswap V3上使用ETH等代币兑换PANDORA代币，用户持有PANDORA代币就相当于碎片化的持有Pandora的NFT（Pandora Replicants），持有的代币数量决定了用户所拥有的NFT数量。</p><p>通过ERC404标准，Pandora实现了类似NFT碎片化的效果。在看好某个NFT系列时，用户可以选择持有一定量的代币而非完整的NFT，这对于资金配置而言更加灵活，同时也降低了参与NFT投资的金额门槛。</p><p><strong>NFT燃烧和重新铸造机制</strong></p><p>但是Replicant NFT与常见的ERC721格式的NFT不同，Replicant NFT有着燃烧和重新铸造的机制，当用户对ERC404进行转账或交易等操作时即会触发。前文提到整数的ERC404代币会与Replicant NFT绑定，因此当ERC404代币发生变动时，Replicant NFT也会发生变动。这里有两种情况：</p><p>1）当用户出售ERC404代币时，用户钱包中的Replicant NFT会被燃烧（销毁）。<br> 2）当用户转账时，Sender钱包中的Replicant NFT会被燃烧，然后在Receiver钱包重新铸造出新的Replicant NFT。</p><p>每一次重新铸造，Replicant NFT的特征都会重新刷新，稀有度也可能随之发生变化。因此，如果用户对他的NFT不满意，他可以将其不断的进行转账以刷新NFT直至获得喜欢的NFT。如果用户不想改变其Replicant NFT（不想燃烧和重新铸造）又想将其出售或者发送给别的用户，那么他可以在OpenSea上出售Replicant NFT或将其发送到另一个地址。简单而言，如果用户希望Replicant NFT产生变化，并对ERC404代币做操作；如果用户不希望Replicant NFT产生变化，则对Replicant NFT做操作。</p><p><strong>Pandora Replicants</strong><a href="#_ftn5"><strong>[5]</strong></a></p><p>Pandora Replicants是Pandora项目的Replicant NFT，是五种不同颜色的箱子，且五种颜色分别代表了不同的稀有度。官方目前并未公开每种稀有度的具体数量，但是稀有度顺序从高到低为：红、橙、紫、蓝、绿。未来箱子可能会开出新的NFT。</p><p><strong>业务数据</strong></p><p>Pandora于项目2月2日上线，目前PANDORA币价2,375.76美元，24小时交易量536.5万美元。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-qMa0uU5zTkW--J6PByirw.png" /><figcaption><strong>图1 PANDORA价格，来源：DEX Screener</strong></figcaption></figure><p>目前Pandora Replicants地板价1.2 ETH，总交易量48 ETH，有670名持有者。</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/886/1*JWvscurD6HtJ9zPQTfmVmA.png" /><figcaption><strong>图2 Pandora Replicants交易数据，来源：OpenSea</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>经济模型</strong></p><p>Pandora并没有公开经济模型，但是可以看到PANDORA代币和Pandora Replicants一样<strong>总量都是10,000枚</strong>。目前流通中的代币大概有5000枚，团队在上线初期从市场买走5000枚，用于项目运营团队奖励之类的。此外，团队保留了700个代币使用Sablier线性释放，一个月内释放完。团队在上线的第一天内使用了大概400 ETH回购了代币，团队没有锁LP主要原因是他们在Uniswap V3上不同价位分布流动性，在价格变化后需要对其LP进行调整。</p><p><strong>综合评价</strong></p><p>1. Pandora通过ERC404的形式实现了NFT碎片化的效果，其机制比较新颖。</p><p>2. ERC404代币还为NFT提供了较好的流动性，用户可以在DEX直接出售ERC404代币，而不用在NFT交易市场等待买家。</p><p><strong>— END —</strong></p><p>推特 <a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61">@firstvip61</a> | 官网 <a href="https://first.vip/">First.VIP</a> | 咨询微信 gofirstvip</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1"><em>[1]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://github.com/0xacme/ERC404"><em>https://github.com/0xacme/ERC404</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2"><em>[2]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/0xacme"><em>https://twitter.com/0xacme</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3"><em>[3]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/maybectrlfreak"><em>https://twitter.com/maybectrlfreak</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4"><em>[4]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/searnseele"><em>https://twitter.com/searnseele</em></a></p><p>投资风险与免责声明</p><blockquote>以上内容分析仅提供参考信息，不作为投资决策依据，请勿基于此报告进行任何投资决策，头等仓及报告作者不对用户投资结果负责。</blockquote><blockquote>报告自所示日期起准备，由于随后的市场或经济状况可能发生变化，报告内容不一定能反映这些变化。提供的图形，图表和其他视觉辅助工具仅供参考。这些图形、图表或可视化辅助工具都不可用于制定投资决策。不代表头等仓(First.VIP)会协助任何人做出投资决定，并且任何图形、图表或其他视觉辅助工具都无法捕获做出此类决定所需的所有因素和变量。</blockquote><blockquote>本⽂中涉及的某些陈述可能是头等仓(First.VIP)对于未来预期的假设以及其他的前瞻性观点，⽽已知和未知的⻛险与不确定因素，可能导致实际结果、表现或事件与陈述中的观点和假设存在实质性差异。</blockquote><blockquote>本报告中包含的任何推测、预测和估计本质上都是推测性的，并且基于某些假设。这些前瞻性陈述可能被证明是错误的，并可能受到不正确的假设或已知或未知的风险，不确定性和其他因素的影响，而其中大多数是无法控制的。可以预料，某些或所有此类前瞻性假设将不会实现，或与实际结果有很大差距。</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=172c742d5fa6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[First.VIP Spotlights: Pandora — The First ERC404 Implementation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@first.vip/first-vip-spotlights-pandora-the-first-erc404-implementation-d2c3b5ee599c?source=rss-e784f9242c61------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d2c3b5ee599c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[First.VIP]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Feb 2024 06:16:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-06T10:31:28.619Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>First.VIP Spotlights: Pandora — The First ERC404 Implementation</h4><p>Note: This report was debuted on the <a href="https://first.vip/"><em>First.VIP</em></a><em> </em>website on Feb 5, 2024<br>As of the publication of this report, $PANDORA is traded at $2,376</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SicjTCmX7gF8kasE8JpFEA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Abstract</h4><p>Pandora is an NFT fractionalization protocol that went live on February 2, 2024, and is the first token built on the ERC-404 token standard. Users can purchase $PANDORA tokens on Uniswap v3 to obtain ERC-404 tokens, which implies that they hold Pandora NFTs. Besides, users can directly trade the Pandora collection on OpenSea. At present, $PANDORA is traded at $2,375.76 and boasts a 24h trading volume of ~$5.365 million. Besides, the trading volume of Pandora NFTs is 48 $ETH.</p><h4><strong>Fundamentals</strong></h4><p><strong>Team:</strong> Pandora was developed by an anonymous team with an unknown number of team members. According to the disclosed information, it boasts three developers, namely Acme, ctrl, and Searn. Acme is the operator of Pandora’s GitHub page<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>, and according to his Twitter profile<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>, he is an engineer at Coinbase. Another developer, using the online alias “ctrl”<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>, is one of the investors of Syndicate and manages his own Web3 community. Besides, there is also a developer named Searn<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a> who has little information having been disclosed.</p><p><strong>Funding:</strong> The Pandora team has not yet disclosed its fundraising information.</p><p><strong>Protocol Mechanics</strong></p><p><strong>Fractionalization Mechanism</strong></p><p>Pandora is an NFT fractionalization protocol that went live on February 2, 2024, and is the first token built on the ERC-404 token standard, which is an experimental token standard combining both ERC-20 and ERC-721. ERC-404 tokens can be traded on DEXes such as Uniswap and are similar to fungible tokens. Besides, 1 <strong>ERC-404 token</strong> corresponds to 1 NFT (known as Replicants). The mathematical relationship between them is as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qt5s2498wILjYp10uvZ_TQ.png" /></figure><p>where <strong>n</strong><em>Replicant NFT</em> represents the amount of the Replicants,<strong> n</strong><em>ERC404</em> represents the amount of ERC-404 tokens, and [<strong>n</strong>] denotes the largest integer not greater than that number.</p><p>For example, if a user holds 0.5 ERC-404 tokens, he/she owns 0 NFT; if the user holds 1 ERC-404 token, he/she owns 1 NFT; if the user holds 1.5 ERC-404 tokens, he/she owns 1 NFT; if the user holds 2 ERC-404 tokens, he/she owns 2 NFTs; if the user holds 2.5 ERC-404 tokens, he/she owns 2 NFTs, and so on.</p><p>In Pandora, the ERC-404 token is $PANDORA and the Replicants are Pandora NFTs. Users can purchase $PANDORA tokens on Uniswap v3 to obtain ERC-404 tokens, which implies that they hold Pandora NFTs. Besides, users can directly trade the Pandora collection on OpenSea.</p><p>When users are bullish on a specific NFT collection, they can purchase a certain amount of ERC-404 tokens instead of buying the NFT, thus lowering the threshold for making NFT investments.</p><p><strong>NFT Burning &amp; Minting Mechanisms</strong><a href="#_ftn5"><strong>[5]</strong></a></p><p>It should be noted that Replicants are different from the common ERC-721 NFTs in that Replicants feature burning and minting mechanisms, which will be triggered when users make transactions of ERC-404 tokens. It was mentioned that the number of ERC-404 tokens (based on integer quantities) will be associated with the quantity of Replicants. Therefore, any changes to the quantity of ERC-404 tokens in a wallet will also result in corresponding changes to the quantity of Replicants. There are two cases here:</p><p>1) When a user sells ERC-404 tokens, NFTs in his/her wallet will be burnt. <br> 2) When a user transfers ERC-404 tokens, NFTs in the Sender wallet will be burnt, and new NFTs will be minted in the Receiver wallet.</p><p>The traits of NFTs will be randomized after each mint. Therefore, their rarity level may also change. If users are unsatisfied with their NFTs, they can transfer ERC-404 tokens continuously for new NFTs to be minted. However, if users do not want to burn and mint new NFTs, while they want to sell or send their NFTs to others, they can do so on OpenSea.</p><p><strong>Pandora NFT Collection</strong></p><p>Pandora is a collection of 10,000 Replicants with different colors. Pandora boxes with different colors indicate different rarities. To date, the project team has not yet disclosed the specific quantity of Replicants with different rarities, while ranked from the rarest to the least rare, red boxes are the rarest, green boxes are the least rare, and sitting between are orange, purple, and blue boxes.</p><p><strong>Operational Data</strong></p><p>Pandora went live on February 2, 2024. At present, $PANDORA is traded at $2,375.76 and boasts a 24h trading volume of ~$5.365 million.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-qMa0uU5zTkW--J6PByirw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 1 $PANDORA Price Chart (Source: DEX Screener)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The Pandora NFT collection currently has a floor price of 1.2 $ETH, a total trading volume of 48 $ETH, and 670 NFT holders.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/886/1*JWvscurD6HtJ9zPQTfmVmA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2 Pandora NFT Collection Stats (Source: OpenSea)</strong></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Tokenomics</strong></p><p>The project team has not yet disclosed the $PANDORA tokenomics, while it can be seen that <strong>the total supply of both $PANDORA and the Pandora NFT collection is 10,000 each.</strong> At present, the circulating supply of $PANDORA stands at ~5,000. The project team has bought back 5,000 $PANDORA on the market for project operations and rewards. In addition, the project team set aside 700 $PANDORA to be linearly vested within one month. On February 2, 2024, the team bought back $PANDORA by spending ~400 $ETH, The team didn’t lock liquidity pool mainly because they wanted to provide liquidity to $PANDORA on Uniswap v3 at different price ranges.</p><p><strong>Comprehensive Evaluation</strong></p><p>1. With the help of the ERC-404 token standard, Pandora allows users to purchase $PANDORA tokens on Uniswap v3 to obtain ERC-404 tokens, which implies that they hold Pandora NFTs. Besides, users can directly trade the Pandora collection on OpenSea.</p><p>2. ERC-404 tokens are able to provide sufficient liquidity to NFTs, and users can directly sell ERC-404 tokens on DEXes such as Uniswap without waiting for buyers on NFT marketplaces.</p><p><strong>— END —</strong></p><p>Website<a href="https://first.vip/"> <em>First.VIP</em></a> | Twitter<em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/firstvip61/status/1754768579457941632"><em>@firstvip61</em></a> | Wechat ID: gofirstvip</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1"><em>[1]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://github.com/0xacme/ERC404"><em>https://github.com/0xacme/ERC404</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2"><em>[2]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/0xacme"><em>https://twitter.com/0xacme</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3"><em>[3]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/maybectrlfreak"><em>https://twitter.com/maybectrlfreak</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4"><em>[4]</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://twitter.com/searnseele"><em>https://twitter.com/searnseele</em></a></p><p>Investment Risks and Disclaimers</p><blockquote>This report is only for information purposes and should not be relied upon when making any investment decision. Please do not make any investment decisions based on this report. First.VIP and authors of this report are not responsible for any results of your investment.</blockquote><blockquote>This report is drafted from the date indicated. As market or economic conditions may change from time to time, the content of this report may not necessarily reflect such changes. The graphs, charts, and other visual aids are provided for information purposes solely, none of which should be relied upon as investment decisions. First.VIP will not assist anyone in making investment decisions and no graph, chart, or other visual aid can capture all of the factors and variables required to make such decisions.</blockquote><blockquote>Some of the statements in this report may contain First.VIP’s future assumptions and other forward-looking views. With known &amp; unknown risks and uncertainties, actual results, performance, or events may differ materially from the views and assumptions expressed in the statements.</blockquote><blockquote>Any speculations, forecasts, and estimates contained in this report are speculative and are based on certain assumptions. These forward-looking statements may prove to be inaccurate and may be affected by inaccurate assumptions, known/unknown risks, uncertainties, and other factors, most of which are beyond our control. It can be anticipated that some or all of these forward-looking assumptions will not be realized or will differ materially from actual results.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d2c3b5ee599c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>