<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Fish Yang on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Fish Yang on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@fishyang?source=rss-815e12c13c35------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 15:31:22 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@fishyang/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[China’s Growing Influence and its Weakness]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@fishyang/chinas-growing-influence-and-its-weakness-32077cd9f3c2?source=rss-815e12c13c35------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32077cd9f3c2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bicycles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[china]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[market-research-reports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supply-chain-management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Fish Yang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Nov 2024 02:22:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-17T02:22:33.094Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It seems like it’s not just the bicycle industry that’s trying to navigate through the long cold winter that is the post-pandemic — also the automobile industry, especially long storied brands, is facing its share of troubles.</p><p>The rise of Chinese EV manufacturers like BYD, NIO, and Xpeng have posed significant competitive challenges to the traditional European automobile industry, quickly reshaping market dynamics and putting a lot of pressure on the companies to adjust operations, product, and strategies.</p><p>Volkswagen (VW) is closing multiple German plants and cutting jobs to manage decreasing demand and intense price competition. BMW, fighting with rising costs and very disappointing Q3 2024 results, has also announced workforce reductions. At the same time, Bosch, the world’s largest auto parts supplier, plans to cut 7,000 jobs globally as EVs require fewer mechanical components, decreasing demand for its core products. These developments show how Chinese EV brands, with their affordability and advanced technology, are rewriting the competitive landscape, forcing European automakers into a race for survival in the electrification of the industry.</p><ul><li><a href="https://www.welt.de/253317996?utm_source=chatgpt.com">VW: Autobauer verschärft Sparkurs — Werksschließungen und Entlassungen möglich — WELT</a></li><li><a href="https://www.bild.de/politik/inland/bmw-ruft-in-der-auto-krise-1-5-mio-fahrzeuge-zurueck-66e02ab5fd0c4e5b099280d3?utm_source=chatgpt.com">BMW ruft in der Auto-Krise 1,5 Mio. Fahrzeuge zurück | Politik | BILD.de</a></li></ul><p>It’s of course not only in the car industry that Chinese companies are reshaping the landscape — there are many examples:</p><p><strong>Shein</strong> in the fast-fashion clothing industry, putting H&amp;M and Zara under pressure; <strong>Temu</strong> challenging Amazon and all other e-Commerce platforms; <strong>Tiktok</strong> swapped the young generation’s social media, <strong>DJI</strong> dominating the drone industry, <strong>Insta360</strong> outcompeting GoPro. More and more Chinese products, brands, and apps are coming into our life, fueling consumption.</p><p><strong>But how about the bicycle industry ?</strong></p><p>I have observed over the last few years how Chinese companies are expanding themselves, and I could see how they also apply the same logic and approach toward to bicycle markets, expanding reach, building product, and utilizing social media to garner attention,</p><p>Firstly, we should keep in mind that China is the world’s largest hub for smelting and refining minerals. After being extracted in other countries, a significant portion of minerals undergoes the refining process in China. This is because these industries are highly polluting, and local governments in China often turn a blind eye to any environmental concerns.During the Russia-Ukraine war, while the rest of the world sanctioned Russian crude oil, China was able to purchase it at discounted prices paying with RMB. So to speak, they have a good advantage on raw material cost. Furthermore, China’s vast domestic market provides a substantial internal demand, which helps reduce production costs.</p><p>When it comes to consumer goods and consumer electronics, without tariff, China’s manufacturing capabilities are arguably the most competitive in the world.</p><p>The strategies are simple:</p><ul><li><strong>Great Value for Money — Product and Marketing Strategy</strong></li></ul><p><strong>Shein</strong> might be the best example that’s seen in the wider public. In the bike industry, taking Aventon and Tenway as an example:</p><ol><li>They invested millions to buy online ads and get on top of search engines. Quickly, they gained the consumers’ eyeballs and built up the brand awareness — both companies got supported by significant capital</li><li>They have the most competitive prices. Both feature hub motor bikes at only USD1599, and 1399, going down to 899 and below.<br>Surprisingly, they also have good designs. Usually their designs are heavily “inspired” by other popular brands. You could see Aventon had been “inspired” by Radpower; Tenway also offered “tribute” to Coboc, Riese &amp; Muller, and Vanmoof.</li><li>They have a strong supply chain to support them. The founder of Aventon is the second generation of a Chinese bike assembly factory called JaHong. Similarly, the founder of Tenway is also the second generation of Trinx, an assembly and bicycle group in Shenzhen. .They knew how to make frames, they knew all their suppliers, they knew the rule of games unlike a lots other startup companies from USA/Europe, <br>Plus, for E-kits they only work with Chinese suppliers (well, Chinese suppliers already dominate the hub motor category) Aventon’s mid motor is from Gobao. The brand probably doesn’t mean anything to most people, but they are the biggest controller manufacturer for 2-wheels in China. Their annual production is about 15~20 million units per year, and they just started entering the complete E-bike drive unit system with Aventon being their first customer.<br>The new Aventon mid-motor bike MSRP is USD2599. Needless to say, Bafang, Amanda, and ShengYi are all Chinese E-kit companies and I have worked with them all — super competitive prices, and all of them all have good experience in the market for many years so at least there are some guarantees for support.</li></ol><p>I have been talking to some Taiwanese drive unit companies, and even though TW is also known for electronics manufacturing, most new Taiwanese players from electronic companies, no matter how big their mother companies are,<strong> THEY DON’T GET IT.</strong> Take an example, few years ago I used to have a chance to have an afternoon tea with the President of Sinbon Electronics, Mr. Wang. He is a very successful businessman and no doubt that his story from a school teacher to a NTD20billions Company President was amazing. At the time they just invested in Vanmoof and developed their own E Drive Unit system. He was proudly talking about their new product and how fast they had been developing for Vanmoof while Vanmoof moved away from Darfon Electronics. Also he had compared their new drive unit with Bosch. He was very confident that he could make it very competitive against Bosch. I then asked him a question: do you have a service network? He looked at me with confusion : why should we need to have that? Customers will take care of the service. I then politely said : maybe that was why Bosch is more expensive.</p><p>Quick summary for Chinese companies successful formula: Big capital investment into marketing; Good design tribute (homage?) to other trendy brands; Super competitive pricing; and good supply chain management to support them.</p><p>Sounds familiar, right? Compared to Shein and some other globally successful Chinese companies, this is exactly what they do. And, let’s face it — who doesn’t like products with great value for money?</p><ul><li><strong>Acquisition</strong></li></ul><p>The Chinese bicycle industry has recently acquired a lot of European companies, ranging from bike assembly factories, distributors, and, eventually, even brands.</p><p>Just to name a few, GoldenWheel from TienJing acquired some Eastern European assembly factories; Keeway acquired Mifa and its brands. Cycle Union was acquired by the Chinese (although the boss moved to Singapore and became Singaporean). United Wheel acquired Huffy a long time ago; the major shareholder of Kent International is also from China.</p><p>The list goes on. If Chinese can acquire football clubs, why not bicycle companies? In fact just these two years many big brands were in acquisition talks with Chinese companies. I had also received few “ads” and sending around in Chinese list the companies who were looking for sales(no name referring to, but very easy to guess)</p><ul><li><strong>China is trying to make its own Bicycle Supply Ecosystem</strong></li></ul><p>Every time when I explained China to people from the Western world, I always had to remind them that China is arguably the most capitalistic society in the world. However, unlike the United States, it operates without the rule of law. Think other countries are the “Wild Wild West”? Look at the Chinese market — that’s the real Wild Wild West. Yet, at the same time, China is an authoritarian state, where many business policies are dictated by the government.</p><p>This may sound contradictory, but if you understand China’s history, it aligns perfectly with the logic of its commercial activities and government interventions dating back to thousand years ago, the Song, Yuan, Ming, and Qing dynasties. Understanding the government’s direction and mindset is crucial. Often, you won’t learn about China’s policies directly from newspapers or official statements. You need to “read between the lines,” listen, observe, and sometimes even sense what’s in the air. Let me give you a hint: Xi Jinping’s speeches can be a valuable guide.</p><p>Currently, in China, the most critical factor is what Xi Jinping likes and supports. He has the power to dismantle an entire industry, like the private education sector, overnight, while simultaneously championing the growth of solar panels and electric vehicles. Fortunately, Xi Jinping likes bicycles(or people believe he likes bicycles), as they align with his vision of “health/sport “ and “green mobility.” This might explain why, despite having so many more lucrative opportunities, DJI chose to enter the bicycle drive unit market.</p><p>The core philosophy of China’s industrial policy is straightforward: “Self-reliance in manufacturing, free from reliance on foreign brands.”</p><p>I believe China is working to establish its own bicycle ecosystem. They aim to cultivate domestic manufacturers to replace Shimano, SRAM, and even Bosch. In some cases, so-called “leading enterprises” are expected to shoulder the responsibility of supporting and developing the entire supply chain ecosystem. I recall someone mentioning that these leading companies often have government backing, but one of their key performance indicators is the ability to drive growth among related upstream component manufacturers.</p><p>Of course, industrial protection policies are not unique to China. However, the level of execution, determination, and resources available to support these policies is unmatched by most other countries (let’s not forget that their policies can remain consistent over a long period because they don’t have to care about people). I see XDS as the most successful representative of this strategy.</p><p>In OEM manufacturing, they are virtually unbeatable. They outperformed Giant to secure Trek as a key client and are now Trek’s most important partner. I’ve also heard that several North American and European brands are collaborating with XDS. Frame wise : Colnago, Ridley, Trek, Cube,Norco,Pivot, In recent years, with the rise of China’s domestic market, XDS quickly became the top-selling brand in the country. They strongly support local component brands, such as Li-twoo — China’s answer to Shimano — which has worked closely with XDS during this wave of growth.</p><p>Recently, XDS invested in acquiring the Astana Team. The rumor said the money was supported by government. On the branding side, they have adopted a strategy similar to Specialized and its S-Works line: mid-to-low-end bikes are still sold under the XDS name, while high-end models are branded as X-Lab. They also sponsor the Chinese national team.</p><p>The industry is now speculating — what’s XDS’s next move? They’ve started expanding to international markets. Given their capabilities, I believe they can easily enter any market. Check below website: <a href="https://www.probike.com.sg/">Pro Bike Singapore</a></p><p><strong>Weakness of Chinese Brands :</strong></p><p>We could see in general, the advantages of Chinese brands are : low price, homage product(You should go take a look at Xiaomi household appliances shopping mall : their strategy is simple, never be the first one but copy the best one and make it very cheap.When observing industries dominated by Chinese brands or the fields they excel in — such as fast fashion, various consumer electronics, EVs, and mobility solutions — you’ll notice they tend to focus on fast-moving products that require little cultural depth. Many are disposable or lack any significant connection to the consumer. Emerging categories, such as power banks or rapidly replaceable smartphone and laptop components, often fall squarely into the domain of fiercely competitive Chinese brands.</p><p>However, brands like Prada, Patagonia, Apple, Uniqlo, and Pinarello hold a permanent place in consumers’ hearts. These brands create connections beyond the product itself — through storytelling, spirit, long-period of time promise and the consumer’s sense of identity with the brand. This intangible quality is what we call “soul.”</p><p>Most rapidly rising Chinese brands lack this “soul.” Even when they attempt to tell compelling stories, they are often exposed for shortcomings in other areas. For example, Shein has faced backlash for its use of Xinjiang cotton, exploitative factories, and carcinogenic materials. Despite investing heavily in influencer campaigns to enhance its brand image, the controversies surrounding it remain unresolved. Similarly, Temu has been accused by Chinese suppliers of maliciously delaying payments and has been criticized for allowing untested, unsafe products to flood the U.S. market.</p><p>Regrettably, under China’s current authoritarian regime and strict censorship, no brand can truly possess a soul.</p><p>Also, China’s society harbors many dark aspects, which have inevitably become the “original sin” of every Chinese company. Under strict censorship, every Chinese entrepreneur has drawn their own invisible “red line” — a boundary they dare not cross. Everyone treads cautiously, taking detours around sensitive issues. Even when they speak of ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance), they can never truly embody it in the way Patagonia does. Their polished marketing rhetoric often fails the test of time.</p><p>I know you might argue that Western companies have similar issues. But I would clarify: in other countries, as a business owner, you can at least choose to “stay small and true to yourself.” In China, no matter your size, you can never truly be yourself. Of course, there are those who, like Eichmann (a mid-level Nazi bureaucrat responsible for orchestrating the logistics of transporting Jews to concentration camps and later tried in Jerusalem), completely integrate themselves into the system. But that is outside the scope of this discussion.</p><p>Nearly every wealthy Chinese person I know has a second passport (or their children hold foreign citizenship), along with second or third contingency plans. I’ll never forget an incident two years ago at Eurobike. A prominent Chinese component manufacturer’s CEO, sitting in his meeting room, cautiously turned off his phone and said to me, “Now I can ask you about your thoughts on the future of Chinese companies.” This unseen yet very real anxiety, in my view, is one of the greatest weaknesses of Chinese enterprises. While it may appear that everyone is forging ahead, they have already mapped out an exit strategy. Even the two heirs of XDS possess American citizenship.</p><p>There’s a famous saying in China: *”Businesspeople are like crabs — when they turn red, they die.”* In Chinese, “turning red” carries a double meaning. It can signify gaining status, fame, and wealth. But when a crab turns red, it is dead and ready to be eaten. This phrase vividly illustrates the entangled relationship between entrepreneurs and the authoritarian government in China. Even Jack Ma, with all his fame, wealth, and influence, could not escape this fate. It is now an open secret that Alibaba has effectively been taken over by Xi Jinping’s government.</p><p>But what does this mean in practical terms? Consider this year’s unprecedented failure during China’s Singles’ Day shopping festival: Alipay’s massive outage. It serves as a chilling reminder of the vulnerabilities that even the most prominent players face under such a system.</p><p>I personally resonate deeply with one of the arguments in *Why Nations Fail*: that the rule of law and democracy are the foundational pillars for a society’s upward progress. If China cannot fundamentally shift away from its system of rule by man and authoritarian governance over the long term, its seemingly robust structure will gradually be hollowed out. We might witness many companies rise and fall, but perhaps in the end, the only enduring “brand” will be “China” itself.</p><p>However, before that day arrives, we should focus on the immediate challenge — the competition with Chinese companies that lies ahead.</p><p>Of course, the Chinese are very smart.<strong> “If I can’t create a soul, how about I just buy one?”</strong></p><p>Anta Sports acquired Amer Sports, which owns numerous premium sports brands such as Arc’teryx, Salomon, Wilson, and Suunto. We also know that China’s Geely Holding Group acquired Volvo, not to mention that the British luxury sports car brand Lotus is now also owned by a Chinese company.As I mentioned before, China is, in fact, the most capitalist country. They are highly adept at leveraging the power of capital to expand their influence. If one day Accell were to be acquired by a Chinese company, I wouldn’t be surprised. After all, KKR has invested in numerous Chinese enterprises already.</p><p>Overall, it is not a bad thing for consumers. Consumers will have more choices and also, they could buy cheaper.</p><p>However, for those of us already working in the bicycle industry, it raises important questions about what the impact will be on us?</p><p>The bicycle industry stands at a critical juncture, as Chinese suppliers continue to exert mounting pressure on their Taiwanese counterparts, from assembly lines to individual components. In the past, many in Taiwan believed that superior quality and service would secure their edge. However, that belief is becoming increasingly difficult to maintain, save for a few exceptional cases like FSA, Tektro, and KMC, which have successfully built protective “moats” around their operations. For most others, the outlook is uncertain.</p><p>Take saddles and grips, for instance. Chinese manufacturers are now producing products of impressive quality at highly competitive prices. A recent example involves a Merida saddle purchased by my cousin in China and delivered to Kunshan. It bore a striking resemblance to the Specialized Power Comp saddle in both appearance and quality. Perhaps most surprising was the price — RMB 45 (roughly USD 6.25), which included dealer margins, Merida’s margin, shipping, and VAT. This price is significantly below what Velo charges for OEM saddles. To put it in perspective, the same Specialized Power Comp saddle sells for USD 139 online in the United States.</p><p>To be clear, the comparison is not entirely fair. Companies like Velo and Specialized invest heavily in R&amp;D, while Chinese manufacturers can often bypass these costs through imitation, without bearing the expense of trial and error. However, it does raise an important question: if I, as a brand owner, have in-house design capabilities and simply need a contract manufacturer, should I consider working with these Chinese suppliers? The answer seems increasingly evident.</p><p>Interestingly, this dynamic isn’t limited to saddles. In the case of suspension components, we have identified lesser-known Chinese suppliers who deliver comparable quality at roughly half the cost of suppliers that many industry veterans are accustomed to using.</p><p>These examples illustrate a broader point: the relationship between brands and Chinese manufacturers must be viewed through a strategic lens, depending on one’s position in the value chain. For brands, the rapid turnaround and cost efficiency of Chinese suppliers can be an advantage, particularly when mold costs are involved. However, for Taiwanese contract manufacturers, survival hinges on finding and defining their true value beyond the comfort zones of the past.</p><p>Bicycle brands must stay innovative, continuing to create unique designs rather than relying on off-the-shelf frames. Cost control and intelligent sourcing are essential — and the sourcing team must be open to exploring new suppliers to remain competitive. I encourage senior managers to deconstruct their supply chain costs and bring in true experts — not the type swayed by kickbacks, but those who genuinely understand supply chains and cost dynamics. Savings should be reinvested in product development and brand storytelling.</p><p>One of the advantages of the bicycle industry is that brands often have distinct personalities, which foster deeper consumer connections. While companies like Shein may pose a threat to mainstream fast fashion, they won’t obliterate every unique brand — unlike clothes, bicycles have an intrinsic identity that customers connect with on a different level.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32077cd9f3c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>