<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by From the Platform on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by From the Platform on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@fromtheplatform?source=rss-d12d96608ca6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:16:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@fromtheplatform/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Podcast Episode 6 Listening]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@fromtheplatform/podcast-episode-6-listening-f30d4115c02c?source=rss-d12d96608ca6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f30d4115c02c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christadelphians]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[listening-skills]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[From the Platform]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Apr 2019 08:50:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-12T08:50:59.207Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Podcast Episode 6 Listening</strong></p><p>In these podcasts we have stressed the importance of listening when encountering challenging topics.</p><p>Our community is online, technology has made its impact in several ways, and like many communities have found, they’re both positive and negative.</p><p>This episode will look at how to listen to others in an internet age where members have, for some time, had access to an abundance of new information. Our members are listening to a wider variety of opinions and information through online videos, discussions and podcasts than ever before. This understandably generates more questions and ideas which we need to listen to, to understand and help disseminate.</p><p>There are new ideas about how challenging passages can be translated, interpreted and applied. Verses that talk about the role of women and sexuality spring to mind.</p><p>Some are very compelling and talk about these issues in an open manner that is a shock for some and to others is a breath of fresh air.</p><p>This content is being listened to, there are no barriers to its access and, if it were your inclination to, you cannot possibly shut it down.</p><p>It simply cannot be ignored, so how do we then engage with the conversation and enable our members to parse out fact from fiction in a way that opens up the conversation in the manner we have been talking about through this podcast series?</p><p>Hopefully the previous episodes have provided you with some of the necessary tools already — today we will talk about creating a forum in which to undertake the following listening technique:</p><p>Partner one begins by airing their view</p><p>Partner two repeats this back and asks ‘is that right?’</p><p>If no, repeat until clarified, partner one can add detail.</p><p>Partner two asks: What’s concerning you the most about what you’ve just told me?</p><p>Partner two repeats this back.</p><p>Partner two: is there anything you/me/we could do about it?</p><p>Partner two listens and reflects back.</p><p>Finally partner two asks, is there anything else you would like to say.</p><p>The listening technique presented here is from the Alpha marriage course and you can find in a link on the podcast page.</p><p>Now I’d like to roleplay this as with a CYC member, as that is a forum most ecclesias provide where questions are encouraged.</p><p>But then we will move on to think about the forum available for adults to ask questions.</p><p>So you might get the question: “Why don’t women speak at the meeting? that doesn’t seem fair to me.”</p><p>Validate the question and repeat it back to them:</p><p>“That is a really interesting question. Why don’t you feel it is fair that women don’t speak at the meeting?”</p><p>“It doesn’t seem fair to treat women differently to a man, just because they’re women”</p><p>“OK so just so I’m sure, you don’t think it’s fair to treat women differently because of their sex? Is that right?”</p><p>“Yeah, I guess, it seems they could be just as good at teaching than men, if not better in some cases”</p><p>“I see, so you feel women are just as able to lead and teach as men?”</p><p>“Yes”</p><p>“Is there anything else that concerns you about this?”</p><p>“Um, well, I guess if God is supposed to be all loving and fair I don’t see how this fits in.”</p><p>“OK so, you’re concerned that this doesn’t fit with the impression you have of a loving and fair God?”</p><p>“I dunno, I guess so”</p><p>“Is there anything else you’d like to say about this?”</p><p>“Hmm, I don’t think so”</p><p>“OK, well this is really important. Do you think you could tell me what concerns you most about this?”</p><p>“Ummm, what concerns me most..? I guess, that, you know, this is like, what we base our lives on…so it should be fair and it doesn’t seem fair.”</p><p>“So fairness is the most important part of this for you?”</p><p>“Yeah”</p><p>“So what do you think you or I or the ecclesia could do about this?”</p><p>“Uuurm…make it…more fair?”</p><p>“And what would that look like?”</p><p>“Well, I guess we should let women lead and speak?”</p><p>OK let’s pause there for a second. This conversation highlights a few things that I feel are really important before we move on.</p><p>First, it might seem repetitive but the young person is being listened to and engaged with, the issue is clarified so we know we’re definitely not talking at cross purposes.</p><p>We also get to the nub of the issue, in this case fairness within a social group. It could just as easily be the question about God’s judgement and most likely that will come up again, so don’t be frustrated when the young person, or any person, backs up on the argument and goes down another route.</p><p>By asking what can be done about this you are engaging that young person in a future responsibility, they probably haven’t considered what can be done about it so it’s an important avenue to open up in our young people. The realisation that the future is in their hands is so important in keeping them within the community.</p><p>Let’s continue our conversation bringing in some of the other moral foundations having listened to their concern, aware that this may take place over several different conversations.</p><p>“So by letting women teach and speak you’re going to have to change some of the traditional ways in which things are done in the ecclesia… and some of those things are based on passages like 1 Timothy 2:8–15.</p><p>Now as a community we place paramount importance on what the Bible says, so we can’t just dismiss it because of what we think might be fair or unfair. We ultimately believe God has presented a better understanding of what is right and wrong in the Bible for us to follow.”</p><p>OK let’s pause again. We have moved the argument from the fairness foundation to the authority and loyalty foundations and so it’s probably a good point to get the young person’s perspective on this, especially if they’ve touched on it before, so you’re building on a solid mutual understanding. You’ll need to park the women’s roles discussion for now and establish the young person’s thoughts on the authority of the word of God, as one leads on from the other. Again this is going to take multiple conversations which should be expected and is part of our duty.</p><p>Listening helps us move from one moral foundation to another and develop and get to the heart of the issue at hand and, in some cases, establishes a person’s concerns about the underlying structures those issues are built on that need cementing first.</p><p>There is no point having a discussion about what the Bible says about women’s roles when you don’t a agree on what the Bible even is.</p><p>Remember though, we can’t just make the jump without listening to the other person, we have to put the effort in. If someone comes to us to say “Why don’t women give prayers” and we reply “Well, do you believe that the bible is God’s word?” it misses the need to listen.</p><p>It might be saving time by addressing an underlying issue and getting straight to the point, but we have gone straight from Care and Fairness to Authority and Loyalty in a jolt that will seem abrupt and inconsiderate putting the other person on the back foot.</p><p>You can then if you wish open up the conversation about the strength of translation debates within that passage (we’ll deal with these in the next episode) so the young person is prepared with all the information needed to have a clear understanding about that passage.</p><p>Now young people are likely to ask questions in this manner, they are inquisitive &amp; encouraged to ask questions through formats like sunday school and CYC. Youth weekends, camps and conferences continue the work with engaging talks and discussion, for those who attend them, and remember not everyone does.</p><p>The support system we do have for our young people is to be celebrated and encouraged, hundreds hours of work go into these events and it made a massive difference to my childhood, for which I am eternally grateful.</p><p>It is less common for us as adults to be so forthright however. Honest conversations and questions generally become harder as we become far more aware of social taboos as well as more fearful of provocation or confrontation (see episode 2). We may also think we will be overwhelmed and/or underprepared. The frustrations and splits these discussions have caused in the past make it seem like its not worth the effort.</p><p>I’d suggest they highlight a lack in the communities space for debate and a lack in its intellectual virtues that make thinking and learning about these issues constructive.</p><p><strong>“Intellectual virtues” are the deep personal qualities or character strengths required for good thinking and learning.</strong></p><p><strong>Consider: What do we tend to associate with good thinking and learning?</strong></p><p><strong>K<em>nowledge. </em>Good thinkers often know a lot; at a minimum, they aren’t ignorant. Raw cognitive <em>ability. </em>Good thinkers also tend to be intelligent or to have a reasonably high IQ.</strong></p><p><strong>However, a person can have both while also being intellectually hasty, lazy, dishonest, arrogant, servile, distracted, superficial, careless, or closed-minded. These latter qualities prevent a person from thinking or learning well. And they are “characterological” in nature. They are cultivated dispositions to act, think, and feel in particular ways.</strong></p><p><strong>These considerations underscore the fact that good thinking and learning have a character-based dimension. They require the practice of qualities like intellectual carefulness, perseverance, honesty, humility, attentiveness, and thoroughness. These are intellectual virtues. </strong><a href="https://intellectualvirtues.org/what-are-intellectual-virtues/"><strong>https://intellectualvirtues.org/what-are-intellectual-virtues/</strong></a></p><p><strong>Intellectual Virtues Getting Started</strong></p><p><strong>1.<em> Curiosity</em></strong>: a disposition to wonder, ponder, and ask why. A thirst for understanding and a desire to explore. <strong>Slogan</strong>: Ask questions!</p><p><strong>2. <em>Intellectual humility</em></strong>: a willingness to own up to one’s intellectual limitations and mistakes. Unconcerned with intellectual status or prestige. <strong>Slogan</strong>: Admit what you don’t know!</p><p><strong>3. <em>Intellectual autonomy</em></strong>: a capacity for active, self-directed thinking. An ability to think and reason for oneself. <strong>Slogan</strong>: Think for yourself!</p><p><strong>Executing Well</strong></p><p><strong>4.<em> Attentiveness</em></strong>: a readiness to be “personally present” in the learning process. Keeps distractions at bay. Strives to be mindful and engaged. <strong>Slogan</strong>: Look and listen!</p><p><strong>5. <em>Intellectual carefulness</em></strong>: a disposition to notice and avoid intellectual pitfalls and mistakes. Strives for accuracy. <strong>Slogan</strong>: Avoid errors!</p><p><strong>6. <em>Intellectual thoroughness</em></strong>: a disposition to seek and provide explanations. Unsatisfied with mere appearances or easy answers. Probes for deeper meaning and understanding. <strong>Slogan</strong>: Go deep! <a href="http://www.ivalongbeach.org/academics/master-virtues">http://www.ivalongbeach.org/academics/master-virtues</a></p><p>It’s like we need a new sort of CYC — this time for adults.</p><p>Currently concerns within the community are suppressed for one reason or another, I find as an elder I hear many concerns second hand and thereby have no idea how wide spread those concerns are or who holds them, is this one or two people that I need to sit down with or a group of 5–10 that warrants a bible class or study day on the topic?</p><p>A concern is unlikely to be as explicit as someone coming directly to me and saying: “I’ve got real concerns about the translation, interpretation and/or application of 1 Timothy 2:8–15” if it is then great, you can engage in that immediately with the listening technique.</p><p>Concerns are more likely to be raised within smaller friendship groups where there are similar ideas and a basis of trust. But these often stay within these groups, subtly generating an us and them mentality.</p><p>But when we come together concern is more likely to be displayed in a passive comment, perhaps with a knowing look, or perhaps it is shown in non-attendance. These are much harder to turn into an engaging conversation as the person can become defensive, quickly hiding behind the mask their comment was veiled under in the first place or the excuse of a busy lifestyle.</p><p>As I have said the first thing that needs to be in place as a part of ecclesial infrastructure is a method for dealing with concerns so that a healthy listening process can be started in faith. The environment needs to change, ecclesias need a time and space devoted to inputting new ideas and tackling them one by one prayerfully trusting God in the process.</p><p>As it stands I can see 4 compiling issues with the lack of conversation within ecclesias:</p><p>1 Stagnation. Perhaps an ecclesia has had all these debates and the older generation feel like its going over old ground again. This leads to things people once adhered to through a thorough understanding become adhered to due to tradition thinking “we’ve been through all this once not we can lay it to rest.” This combined with a fear of letting our adherence to the scriptures slip and losing respectability with in the community means ecclesias remove discussion, debate and the ability to question.This leads to:</p><p>2 Apathy. Many people have a concern but are not wanting to bother with it. Previous experiences were stressful or discussions were closed down immediately, are caught up in a long AB’s process, or care and fairness concerns are met rashly with authority and loyalty answers and visa versa. People either leave or, if able, go to a different ecclesia that suits their style. This leads to:</p><p>3 Half baked ideas. Some people know there is an alternative translation/interpretation of 1 Timothy 2 perhaps having listened to one convincing podcast or talk but having not studied it enough personally isn’t able to present the argument fully.</p><p>It has the danger of going unchecked and simply confirms a bias as there is no place within the ecclesia to draw out the full argument and inspect it thoroughly. This could be because you’ve joined an ecclesia that simply confirms your bias, you all lean the same way, there is no disconfirmation bias and it just sits as “this interesting thing I once heard” that can simply just become part of what that person believes. Which leads to</p><p>4 Polarisation. A downward spiral into a fractured community, typical of what the internet has done the world over in communities large and small.</p><p>The Big Conversation Event was a great idea but it lacked the structure of a listening technique we could all engage in, unfortunately, brothers and sisters from all parts of the spectrum were put together to confirm how wrong the opposite side really was.</p><p>If you don’t have a system in place in your ecclesia my suggestion would be to present your concern, or the concern you know others to have along with a framework or structure based on the listening technique, so people know exactly how the conversation will go, removing the need for others to fear an undermining of the ecclesial community.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f30d4115c02c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From The Platform Ep2 Notes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@fromtheplatform/from-the-platform-ep2-notes-5962d468f1ec?source=rss-d12d96608ca6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5962d468f1ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christadelphians]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[From the Platform]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Nov 2018 13:34:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-07T13:34:58.525Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Fear of the Unknown</p><p>[These are the notes from the From The Platform Podcast: <a href="https://soundcloud.com/fromtheplatform">https://soundcloud.com/fromtheplatform</a>]</p><p>This episode will look into the claim that fear is innate at an instinctive level, hard wired into the part of the brain known as the amygdala and this affects our response to anything new that enters our environment.</p><p>When dealing with challenging topics or even traditional topics in a group, parts of that group will feel comfortable exploring the issue, probably having already looked into it themselves. There will, more inevitably however, be some part of the group that become quite fearful and worried about where this exploration might go. There are many things to fear — how this could change the group morals and where it gets its authority, there is the often the silent fear of not getting it when it appears everyone else does. There is the fear of having been wrong.</p><p>What do we do about it? Can we alleviate it? Should we alleviate it? Perhaps that fear instinct is there for a good reason and needs to be listened to..?</p><p>So firstly how do we know fear is an innate hard wired instinct?</p><p>We’ve all see the youtube videos of domesticated cats reacting to cucumbers right? They’re born and brought up in a home but when the cat sees a cucumber it reacts to it as if it has seen a snake, this happens even if the cat has never encountered a real snake in its life.</p><p>The cat has not learnt fear. It has in fact had its previously learnt understanding about the world and it environment reduced to a kind of chaos where everything it thought was safe is now to be approached with caution. What was once known and explored territory is now unknown and unexplored and that has happened through an innate and instinctive fear for long tubular green things.</p><p>Here is an excerpt from <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief </em>by Jordan B. Peterson, here he is talking about an experiment with a rat in a cage that is administered electric shocks through the floor of its cage when a light bulb flashes on:</p><blockquote>“Such experiments first imply that fear in any given situation is necessarily something learned. Second they imply that fear exists as a consequence of exposure to punishment, and only because of that exposure. A problem with this interpretation is that the rat was inevitably afraid as soon as he was placed in the new experimental environment, even though nothing terrible has yet happened there. After he’s allowed to explore, he calms down. It is only then that he is regarded as normal. The experimenter then jars the rat out of his acquired normalcy by presenting him with something unexpected and painful… He then “learns” to be afraid. Really what has happened is that the unexpected occurrence forces the rat to reattain the state he was in (or that same state in an exaggerated manner) when he first entered the cage. The fact of the electric shock, in conjunction with the light, indicates to the rat (reminds the rat) that he is, once again, in unexplored territory. His fear in unexplored territory, is just as normal as his complacency in environments that he has mapped and that hold no danger. We regard the calm rat as the real rat because we project our misinterpretations of our own habitual nature onto our experimental animals.”</blockquote><blockquote>B. Peterson, J., 2002. <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief</em>. Routledge. p58–59</blockquote><p>How does this work with humans then?</p><p>Imagine you have an unexpected call into the manager’s office whilst going about your predictable work day you know the feeling. The first thing you think before anything else is “uh-oh what have I done?” it induces an initial innate fear followed by curiosity. It could be at worst the worst thing you could possibly imagine or at best the best thing you could possibly imagine. She could fire you, you could get a promotion, she could pull out a gun and shoot you for no apparent reason… the possibilities are endless because the reason for being called into the office is unknown. It is a shock, on what was considered to be a safe and predictable space on a very normal day, something with unknown potential has happened and part of us reacts to it like a cat to a cucumber — humans however are able to explore a novelty such as this in an abstract way, thinking through possibilities based on previous experiences that we can explore in our heads.</p><p>A loud knock at the door around 10am in previous experience has been a postman in a rush, a loud knock at the door at 10pm is an altogether different novelty that we will approach with far more caution.</p><blockquote>“If you can’t tell what something means, because you don’t know what it is, what then does it mean? It is not nothing — we are in fact frequently and predictably upset by the unexpected. Rather, it could be anything, and that is precisely the crux of the problem. Unpredictable things are not irrelevant, prior to the determination of their specific meaning. Things we have not yet explored have significance, prior to our adaptation to them, prior to our classification of their relevance, prior to our determination of their implication for behavior. Things not predicted, not desired, that occur while we are carrying out our carefully designed plans — such things come loaded, a priori , with meaning, both positive and negative. The appearance of unexpected things or situations indicates, at least, that our plans are in error, at some stage of their design — in some trivial way, if we are lucky; in some manner that might be devastating to our hopes and wishes, to our self-regard, if we are not.</blockquote><blockquote>Unexpected or unpredictable things — novel things, more exactly (the class of novel things, most particularly) — have a potentially infinite, unbounded range of significance. What does something that might be anything mean?”</blockquote><blockquote>B. Peterson, J., 2002. <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief</em>. Routledge. p42–43</blockquote><p>The very fact that new situations that hold a spectrum of potential good or bad outcomes cause us fear and anxiety show us fear is innate.</p><p>You might be thinking where is this going? What is the meaning of this podcast and of its tip toeing around the unknown? What will be the implications? Does it scare you or are you curious?</p><p>Imagine the boss calls you in and says that she has received numerous complaints about how you have dealt with certain situations, you’re clearly not cut out for the job and your contract has been terminated with immediate effect. This is a complete surprise to you, your known experience, that you thought was predictable has now become unknown and unexplored territory not only for the future but for the past as well — who had been making complaints? I thought I got on so well with everyone…you suddenly begin to question your social abilities, your personality traits, your like-ability, your skill set. You need to re-examine/explore yourself. There is now a huge paradox between your career goals and the fact that you have just lost your job. You must redraw your map and reestablish your goals.</p><p>One year later you find yourself in a better job doing something you love and the result of reorienting of yourself has proved to be better than the previous situation you were in before. In hindsight the thing you feared and perceived as a huge threat has transformed you and put you on a better path.</p><p>So what happens when we meet a “novelty” that opposes our previously mapped out Christadelphian beliefs?</p><p>Either we are curious and embark cautiously on an exploration of the unknown and make modifications risking coming up against something that could possibly unravel our entire world view and all that is attached to it…</p><p>Or we are fearful, resist modification and stick firmly within the known.</p><blockquote>“The dilemma of contradictory simultaneous meanings can be solved in only two related ways (although it can be avoided in many others). We can alter our behaviours , in the difficult situation, so that those behaviors no longer produce consequences we do not desire or cannot interpret. Alternatively, we can reframe our contexts of evaluation (our goals and our interpretations of the present), so that they no longer produce paradoxical implications, with regard to the significance of a given situation.”</blockquote><blockquote>B. Peterson, J., 2002. <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief</em>. Routledge. P41</blockquote><p>Let’s take evolutionary creation as an example of something that can generate fear and anxieties about moving away from “The Truth” for the literal 7 day creationist. And to balance it we will see how fear of being ridiculed by other groups also influences the decisions made by the evolutionary creationist.</p><p>Rejection or adaption. Retaining traditional interpretations or re-understanding. Both make choices based on fears and authorities</p><p>The debate has, of course, many sides to it comprised of Young Earth creationists, Old earth creationists, evolutionary creationists and possibly more, all with nuanced opinions.</p><p>Here I am going to put forward a broadly stereotypical view of a Young Earth Literal 7 day creationist for the purpose of showing how this idea of innate fear can work at this level when challenged by evolutionary creationism, I don’t intend to belittle the idea only show where fear takes place, remember we’re going to look at how this works from the other angle too, later on. So:</p><p>The world is full of unknowns. Fear reigns as we are destined for death. Sickness, social exclusion or even war could break into our realities at any moment. In contrast the Bible is the divine word from God it is a map that provides meaning to the meaningless, we can find comfort in it, knowing what happens after the great unknown of death. It also satisfies the unknown of what happened before our birth, it contains a beautiful creation account that sets us in the image of God and the world as good.</p><p>The Genesis account documents Eden’s paradise pointing forward to a paradise to which we can attain through Jesus, it documents the fall of the first man Adam into the unknown and the beginnings of God’s promises that lead to Jesus, the second Adam, our guide through the unknown back into a relationship with God through his atoning sacrifice, undoing the consequence of Adam’s sin that we are all born into. It depends on Adam being the literal first man whose sin was a historical event.</p><p>Additionally this belief provides us with a community in which we find ritual and tradition, these help us map out how we should act socially, giving us purpose and fulfilment. Creation echos the beauty of God and his word, just as the world is perfect and good so is God’s word.</p><p>Evolution and the notion of a world that is Billions of years old and humans are millions of year old reduces this person’s worldview back to the unknown and to the chaos they found the Bible took them away from, not only for themselves but for the community they depend on. It cannot be true. If true they stand to lose everything. Fear is a natural, instinctive, protective and understandable response.</p><p>They will appeal to the authority foundation of Scripture as God’s word but also to creationist scientists or scientific evidence that seems to point to a young earth in order to be protected from the unknown.</p><p>Evening lectures and magazine articles systematically pick apart the theory of evolution — even if there are no interested visitors it serves as a protection for their current world view.</p><blockquote>“Unprotected exposure to unexplored territory produces fear. The individual is protected from such fear as a consequence of ritual imitation… — as a consequence of the adoption of group identity, which restricts the meaning of things, and confers predictability on social interactions.”</blockquote><blockquote>B. Peterson, J., 2002. <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief</em>. Routledge. p18</blockquote><p>When we have an authoritative moral foundation based on a particular biblical interpretation that deems it inerent, literal and unchanged it means that all that we know is all that we have to know. The unknown is not allowed to either exist or otherwise be explored. It also becomes very easy for the challenging topics to “produce fear” and for this fear to tighten control on group identity retreating back into and strengthening traditions.</p><p>When everything has to be controlled in these areas however and there is no room to even begin exploring the unknown, people either get aggravated or leave. Discussing it or exploring it outside of the restrictive Christadelphian norms is off limits and this can cause a social aggravation.</p><blockquote>“When identification with the group is made absolute, however — when everything has to be controlled, when the unknown is no longer allowed to exist — the creative exploratory process that updates the group can no longer manifest itself.”</blockquote><blockquote>B. Peterson, J., 2002. <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief</em>. Routledge. P18</blockquote><p>After all to modify this interpretation about the bible to much, too quickly, or even at all would destabilize the community and inevitably cause rifts. <br>A literal creationists conservative response could be: have faith, be satisfied with, and obedient to, the word of God. The word of God has been<em> </em>refined — trust it. God has mapped it all out for us, perhaps in some areas He hasn’t explicitly shown us the exact logical scientific route from A to B but we must trust in B nonetheless because it is from God and he sees things we cannot.</p><p>What we see here is an appeal to the Authority, Loyalty and Sanctity foundations we spoke about in the previous podcast. The 3 foundations that balance the foundations of Care, Fairness and Liberty to create a conservative mindset.</p><p>They would argue, and quite convincingly from scripture, that we should not modify. We are the faithful few, we are like the 3 friends approaching the furnace. What is wrong with the simplicity of the world view of the the literal 7 day creationist Christadelphian?</p><p>If you appeal to the liberal mindset based on the first 3 moral foundations you will hear: It is oppressive, harmful and unfair.</p><p>Oppressive because there is no individual liberty to explore and grow spiritually, harmful because the rest of the world mocks us, and unfair because an oversimplified approach doesn’t take onboard everyone’s opinions and legitimate concerns.</p><p>For the evolutionary creationist innate fear is still a very real motivation but the fear comes from a different source as we will discuss later.</p><p>For some reason the evolutionary creationist has encountered evolutionary theory, explored it, wrestled with it and has been able to adapt their beliefs to incorporate both God and evolutionary theory. It is worth noting that some have gone through this and have not been able to keep both in check resulting in a rejection of either God or Evolutionary theory. Showing us that yes, the danger is real if, as we do, we feel a relationship with God is paramount.</p><p>On that point: should we use the fact that those who are vulnerable to losing their faith can and do when tackling challenging topics like evolution, should we protect them and hide them from it therefore?</p><p>Clearly in today’s world this is an impossibility, hiding people from areas that need exploring just delays and arguably compounds the impact when eventual exposure does occur. Young people are likely to become resentful to having things such as this hidden from them. “Protecting the children” interestingly was one reason the Israelites gave as a reason for not entering the promised land.</p><p>So let’s look at the evolutionary creationist. What has happened in order for them to have taken the second option and assimilated evolution into their world view without it becoming catastrophic for their faith?</p><p>Stereotypically this can happen for a combination of the following reasons:</p><ol><li>A legitimate belief in evolution through an exposure to, and an understanding of it.</li><li>Not wanting friends or colleagues to think they are backward. Leading to a desire to have a faith compatible with scientific and broadly accepted thinking.</li></ol><p>They then either adapt to:</p><ol><li>A parabolic understanding of Genesis 1–3 and an understanding of the atonement that is not mechanical or</li><li>An old earth pre-existing before Genesis 1:3</li></ol><p>The evolutionary creationist is convinced due to studying the theory of evolution and seeing how it can fit alongside the bible but there is undeniably an element of the other groups that person belongs to seeing the literal 7 day creation as invalid that will influence them.</p><p>The evolutionary creationist has another “group” colleges, friends or family to which creationism is “the cucumber” and that elicits the same fear that evolution does in the literal creationist Christadelphian group. That group is more than likely important for maintaining work, social status and friends — but don’t get me wrong they are also legitimately compelled by the evidence presented by the theory of evolution it’s not just pandering to a group — in the same way the literal 7 day creationist is legitimately compelled by their theories.</p><p>The evolutionary creationist therefore take steps to reconcile their faith with their understanding and what that means socially. One view becomes the scientific, actual origin of the universe the other a spiritual parable with a cultural context that aids their spiritual understanding and journey.</p><blockquote>“We act to transform “where we are” into “where we would like to be.” When our attempts to transform the present work as planned, we remain firmly positioned in the <em>domain of the known</em> (metaphorically speaking). When our behaviours produce results that we did not want, however — that is when we err — we move into the <em>domain of the unknown, </em>where more primordial emotional forces rule. “Small-scale” errors force us to reconstruct our plans, but allow us to retain our goals and our conceptualisations of present conditions. Catastrophic errors, by contrast, force us not only to re-evaluate our means, but our starting points and our ends. Such revaluation necessarily involves extreme emotional dysregulation.”</blockquote><blockquote>B. Peterson, J., 2002. <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief</em>. Routledge. p43–44</blockquote><p>So where we end up is back at the conservative/liberal spectrum established by Moral Foundations Theory. Literal creationists are shocked by the evolutionary creationists liberal disregard for group loyalty by being influenced by other, authority of the literal interpretation (and for some, the grounds of atonement,) and the sanctity of simple Bible truth. To them their assimilation of evolution constitutes a catastrophic error due to the exposure of worldly influences.</p><p>To the evolutionary creationist however, their previously held beliefs contained a small-scale error that a adaption of category from literal to symbolic has solved. Literal creationists, especially ones that take a particularly hard line in trying to control what others think could be construed by some as dogmatic, insular and oppressive in regards to control over group identity which in turn harms individual members in their liberty to explore and draw their own conclusions as well as the whole group as it is ridiculed by the outside world.</p><p>An evolutionary creationists liberal response could be: have faith when entering into this particular unknown and explore — it is here that we grow spiritually and learn more. We will not be saved from the storm or the refiners fire, but what is left is what is built on a sure foundation.</p><p>Remember a literal creationists conservative response could be: have faith, be satisfied with, and obedient to, the word of God. The word of God has been<em> </em>refined — trust it. God has mapped it all out for us, perhaps in some areas He hasn’t explicitly shown us the exact logical scientific route from A to B but we must trust in B nonetheless because it is from God and he sees things we cannot.</p><p>Essentially the liberal wants to refine themselves but the conservative depends on the refined word. One requires the exploration of new territory and the other requires strengthening the old.</p><p>The liberal takes this view because they depend less on Loyalty, Authority and Sanctity more on inclusion and liberty. The conservative requires less liberty and more loyalty and authority.</p><p>Arguably the remapping of traditional ideas is something the community has done with the very literal description of the Devil we find in our English translations — we expect anyone who would wish to join us to remap their ideas of a fallen angel and explore a new idea that suggests the Satan is a purely spiritual reflection of man’s own heart and/or the office of an adversary.</p><p>We pin that mainly on a translation issue but it has a lot to do with stripping away the cultural layers of Greek and medieval influence to find what It meant to those the words were originally written to.</p><p>The problem is you can easily construct both narratives from the principles in the scriptures in ways that sound compelling both backed up with some degree of science.</p><p>So again what do we do!?</p><p>It is evident that our young people are exploring these unknowns in other arenas outside of the Christadelphian community and are coming to conclusions without us — finding comfort in a new normal that has a compelling care foundation and leaving the community, or at least silently disagreeing — the very danger sometimes presented as a reason for not discussing these issues become the actual reality when issues are left as unknowns or met with unsatisfactory answers. Information is at their fingertips if we do not provide it.</p><blockquote>“When we are in the domain of the known, so to speak, there is no reason for fear. Outside that domain, panic reigns. It is for this reason that we dislike having our plans disrupted, and cling to what we understand. This conservative strategy does not always work, however, because what we understand about the present is not necessarily sufficient to deal with the future. This means that we have to be able to modify what we understand, even though to do so is to risk our own undoing. The trick, of course, is to modify and yet to remain secure. This is not so simple. Too much modification brings chaos. Too little modification brings stagnation (and then, when the future we are unprepared for appears — chaos).</blockquote><blockquote>Involuntary exposure to chaos means accidental encounter with the forces that undermine the known world. The affective consequences of such encounter can be literally overwhelming. It is for this reason that individuals are highly motivated to avoid sudden manifestations of the unknown. And this is why individuals will go to almost any length to ensure that their protective cultural “stories” remain intact.”</blockquote><blockquote>B. Peterson, J., 2002. <em>Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief</em>. Routledge. P18</blockquote><p>When this unknown is approached the first intuitive response will be fear — of Chaos and an undoing of our current reality. One tactic is to force a situation into utter chaos as quick way of showing it is unfeasible and provides a justification in directing the group back to the safety of the known — you see this with disruptive children in class it is easier to engage in disruptive play — because they know how to do this over the unknown of sitting quietly and absorbing information.</p><p>However you find an appeal to the authority of John Thomas compelling then he prints these word James Foreman wrote to him:</p><blockquote>“Never be afraid of results to which you may be driven by your investigations, as this will inevitably bias your mind and disqualify you to arrive at ultimate truth.</blockquote><blockquote>Investigate everything you believe: if it is the truth, it cannot be injured thereby; if error, the sooner it is corrected the better.” Herald of the Kingdom and Age to Come (1859, vol. 9, no. 8), 179–180.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5962d468f1ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From The Platform Ep 1 Notes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@fromtheplatform/from-the-platform-ep-1-notes-977a9b8319fb?source=rss-d12d96608ca6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/977a9b8319fb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[moral-foundations-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christadelphain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[From the Platform]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Nov 2018 13:25:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-07T13:27:59.050Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>How we talk about what we talk about:</strong></p><p>[These are the notes from the From The Platform Podcast: <a href="https://soundcloud.com/fromtheplatform">https://soundcloud.com/fromtheplatform</a>]</p><p>“The principle of charity” is all about taking your interlocutor (person with whom you are discoursing) seriously. Don’t misrepresent them- this is called “straw-manning” — arguing against a caricature of their argument, rather than their actual argument.</p><p>Don’t just disagree with them, try to find out why they hold such and such a belief. What is their motivation for holding that belief? What other data does that belief explain? Don’t assume they have made a silly mistake. If you feel your interlocutor has made a silly mistake, find the best possible version of what they might mean, not the worst. Their idea often comes from a legitimate place, it is better to try and understand where the idea comes from than to react against it. Be a good listener first then present your ideas as a personal opinion to be considered and reflected on. -</p><p><strong>How to talk about the spectrum of ideas:</strong></p><p>Any challenging topic we face is going to generate a spectrum of responses. Many political and social sciences categorise these responses as liberal/conservative or left/right wing, but is this the best way to deal with labelling the responses to issues within the community?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/239/0*W8u7ApwQouiIKqHx" /></figure><p>There are concerns that it leads to labelling people rather than responses and potentially polarising the community as it seems to do with party politics.</p><p>First let’s take a step back and remember context is always king in these situations:</p><p>“Conservative” and “Liberal” are generalisations that don’t mean anything specific when used without qualification, they mean different things to different people in different contexts and so don’t fully convey the nature of the specific topic being discussed.</p><p>It is important to only label the responses to a specific topic and not the people holding those views on that specific topic.</p><p>We need to make that clear when starting any conversation. A real problem arises when people use the words in a loaded way, “don’t listen to her, she’s one of those liberals”, which doesn’t lend itself to fruitful conversation.</p><p>Remember:</p><p>Many people take a conservative view with respect to X and yet a liberal view on Y.</p><p>Something viewed as conservative by one society may be viewed as liberal by another.</p><p>I’d suggest that liberal/conservative language is already being used colloquially and it may be important to reclaim the definitions so as to use in its proper contextual sense.</p><p>Used in the right way it is very useful as it lets us understand more about what a certain perspective is founded on in general terms. Rather than using it to polarise and create opposing “tribes” it can be used to understand the background and foundation of another person’s perspective and therefore understand what is important to them as explored below in the Moral Matrix section.</p><p><strong>Understanding the “Moral Matrices” different perspectives are founded on.</strong></p><p>This section is based on “Moral Foundations Theory” as described in the book “The Righteous Mind — Why Good People are Divided by Religion and Politics” by Jonathan Haidt. It is a useful theory to help understand how we can have such a spectrum of perspectives in our community and why those perspectives find homes more comfortably in some ecclesias rather than others.</p><p>Now this may sound quite foreign to many of you but I’d like to reassure you it’s quite simple and if you bear with me we will get round to how it works alongside bible teaching quite neatly.</p><p>Essentially it is a new tool to talk about ideas we are already familiar with. New tools are used all the time by our community whether it be concordances, online bibles or other ways of reframing bible topics to help a new audience understand and apply fresh thinking to those already well informed.</p><p>One way to understand where a perspective comes from is to understand what moral “taste bud(s)” it touches on.</p><p>It has been shown that we have 6 moral “taste buds” and we use some or all of these 6 moral foundations, whether we realise it or not, to inform our reactions to certain topics. These reactions are instinctive and immediate when triggered, we then construct an ad-hoc rational to back up our gut feeling and will latch onto information that confirms our first thoughts — known as confirmation bias. Many things such as upbringing, life experience, education, location and culture shape how we react to different topics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qR2F55HfobD-amG03f32Rw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It can be argued that:</p><p>The liberal moral matrix is based on the core value of care for victims of oppression &amp; less (if at all) on loyalty to a group, authority (e.g., of a scriptural interpretation) and sanctity (e.g., of tradition.) See Figure 12.2</p><p>The conservative moral matrix is based on preserving institutions and traditions to sustain a moral community, meaning you’re more likely to balance all 6 foundations in order to preserve the community over helping the individual/minority. See figure 12.4</p><p>Main point: An individual’s moral matrix around a particular topic is intuitive, based on upbringing, life events and at what stage they are in life, it is also continually confirmed by their group. Similar to tastebuds it is extremely unlikely that you can change another person’s moral matrix by force feeding them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rPTmFRsStmCVF0_cpuHBQw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*AznjRtt9IFJ70XXpasaCUQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 5. Scores on the Moral Foundations Questions, from 132,000 subjects, in 2011. Data from YourMorals.org</figcaption></figure><p>These figures show the moral make up of conservative &amp; liberal Americans regarding a broad range of views, including religion, by social psychologists at <a href="http://yourmorals.org/">yourmorals.org</a>. Taken from “The Righteous Mind” by Jonathan Haidt.</p><p>It is important to understand how these moral matrices affect the discussions we have around a subject like sexuality, for example, because it can trigger the “sacred” values of both groups resulting in a moral a “disgust” it is hard for either party to get past.</p><p><strong>So what do liberal and conservative moral matrices look like in Christadelphia?</strong></p><p>Remember we can only approach this question stereotypically which means the picture painted is crude and shows the extremes of a spectrum, it is important not to use this to label people or ecclesias based on your assumptions about them.</p><p>It’s one thing to be OK with a different matrix existing, it is another to try and understand why other matrices exist. We often think of the ecclesia as a training ground for the Kingdom, a place where we learn love and gentleness amongst a group brought together by God in order to get along — yet if we polarise and create bubbles the healthy tension between left and right is lost along with the practice of convivial discussion which gets outsourced to the internet where anonymity and facelessness breeds bitterness and anger.</p><p>The table below sets out my own view on how the conservative/liberal view of scripture and the ecclesia fit under each of the Moral Foundations. It is important to note that these things are intended to reflect intuitions triggered by a topic — they are written here for readers to being to understand, not challenge, the makeup of others. It has been shown that an individual will only change through personal reflection after non-confrontational and gentle dialogue with people they feel safe with and who have listened to and understood them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Pi0Q-EOjYGcfdwYUt9Gg5g.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sExwmRZ-jqXRKrmqC53QZg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>So how does this work in practice?</strong></p><p>What often happens is one side appeals to a foundation that the other either does not hold in high regard or uses but balances with other instincts.</p><p>E.g. Imagine the following scenario someone with a strong Care/Harm &amp; Liberty/Oppression foundation may start a debate about homosexuality with someone that has a more balanced intuition across all 6 moral foundations in this way:</p><p>Person A: “Homosexuals are marginalised and oppressed by the community and it harms them.”</p><p>Person B: “But God’s word clearly states Homosexuality is an abomination to God.”</p><p>It is not that Person B has no Care/Harm foundation to appeal to, it is that they are appealing to the Authority/Subversion foundation that balances their own personal view.</p><p>What Person B does however, is shift the argument away from the Care/Harm foundation to the Authority/Subversion &amp; Loyalty/Betrayal foundation, foundations that Person A is likely to have less dependence on or be persuaded by. In fact Person A will most likely begin to now question the authority of Person B’s traditional interpretation of scripture leading to Person B feeling as though Person A is undermining the entire moral makeup of the Bible and the community. Still Person A’s issue around the Care/Harm foundation has still not been addressed.</p><p>Quite quickly both sides have denigrated the most sacred core values held by the other. Person A feels that Person B has zero care for victims of oppression and Person B feels that Person A has no intention of preserving the institution and tradition of the community to sustain moral cohesion.</p><p><strong>So what should we do?</strong></p><p>Personally I feel first we need to understand the moral foundation that the person starting the debate is appealing to, we need to listen and validate that persons concern and how important it is to them and discuss it on those terms first. We are then able to open up the discussion to consider the other moral foundations, foundations that we are equally going to have to understand that person’s perspective on. Remember be aware as to why you have entered into this debate, are you hoping to correct someone or understand their perspective? Are you able to consider you might learn something new?</p><p><strong>What does Jesus do?</strong></p><p>I’d like to appeal to how Jesus handles two situations: one on the road to Emmaus and one in the Temple. I am aware that my perspective on these passages has a particular leaning/bias so please take that into account. Interestingly having shared this idea with my friends I have already been shown where my perspective has blinded me to some of the realities of the text and the following is edited to hopefully be more balanced (a case in point of how these principles can aid a working document like this).</p><p>Two disciples are heading away from Jerusalem on the 3rd day after the crucifixion and Jesus appears to them but they don’t perceive who he is, he travels by their side away from Jerusalem (the “wrong direction.”) He listens to their concerns and admittedly calls them fools and slow of heart and then shows them that all these things had to happen from the scriptures. He then shares in fellowship with them and reveals himself as Jesus. Without telling them what they must do they get up and of their own volition return to where they should be. We are prone to see ourselves in the role of Jesus in our own situations but we have to be aware we could also be living out the role of the two disciples.</p><p>Now we might well say that Jesus got very angry at points when refuting others and look to Jesus’ turning of the tables in the Temple as a mandate to sharply chastise and rebuke one another.</p><p>One way to interpret Jesus’ actions in the Temple by NT Wright however is that were done to pass judgement on a corrupted, bureaucratic system, and he passed that judgement in a way that signified clearly in the cultural context, his Kingship, and his subsequent establishment of a new Temple. — See NT Wright: The Challenge of Jesus. Intervarsity Press 1999 p62–67<br>If correct it follows that if we think we can do likewise, then we are claiming a Kingship that is not ours to reach out and grasp, we end up setting ourselves up as Kings over one another, something only Jesus had the right and power to do.</p><p>The rest of his ministry goes on to show us that our King wishes us to become servants and serve one another in order to claim a place in that kingdom.</p><p>It is true that Jesus spent considerable time provoking his religious opponents. He told them plainly that they’d completely missed the point of the scriptures they thought they followed (John 5:39). He gave them a really hard time, usually doing so in public. It often feels like Jesus was actively winding them up. Let’s not whitewash those aspects of Christ in the text. They’re there, so they matter. That doesn’t mean that we should be liberally provoking each other — far from it. But it does mean that Christ treated the recalcitrants and belligerents differently to how he treated the ordinary people who wanted to hear what he had to say.</p><p>And none of this should be any surprise — we’re all different and have different modes of communication we naturally employ, however, our high calling is to “love one another as I have loved you”. If we kept that in mind we would spend more time listening, more time understanding, more time finding common ground.</p><p><strong>Selection of quotes from</strong> <strong>Jonathan Haidt, </strong><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/16252969"><strong>The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion</strong></a></p><p>“We should not expect individuals to produce good, open-minded, truth-seeking reasoning, particularly when self-interest or reputational concerns are in play. But if you put individuals together in the right way, such that some individuals can use their reasoning powers to disconfirm the claims of others, and all individuals feel some common bond or shared fate that allows them to interact civilly, you can create a group that ends up producing good reasoning as an emergent property of the social system. This is why it’s so important to have intellectual and ideological diversity within any group or institution whose goal is to find truth…”</p><p>“Loyalty, respect for authority and some degree of sanctification create a more binding social order that places some limits on individualism and egoism.”</p><p>“It is clear that each party to this dispute — as to all that persist through long periods of time — is partly right and partly wrong. Social cohesion is a necessity, and mankind has never yet succeeded in enforcing cohesion by merely rational arguments. Every community is exposed to two opposite dangers: ossification through too much discipline and reverence for tradition, on the one hand; on the other hand, dissolution, or subjection to foreign conquest, through the growth of an individualism and personal independence that makes cooperation impossible.”</p><p>“Sacredness binds people together, and then blinds them to the arbitrariness of the practice.”</p><p>“Innate does not mean unmalleable; it means organised in advance of experience. The genes guide the construction of the brain in the uterus, but that’s only the first draft, so to speak. The draft gets revised by childhood experiences. To understand the origins of ideology you have to take a developmental perspective, starting with the genes and ending with an adult voting for a particular candidate or joining a political protest.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=977a9b8319fb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>