<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Carmiel Frutkoff on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Carmiel Frutkoff on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@frutkoff?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 15:48:20 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@frutkoff/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bubbies Cookies –]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/bubbies-cookies-9fe5ec05fa89?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9fe5ec05fa89</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 06:06:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-04T06:06:24.175Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Bubbies Cookies</strong></p><p>When food brings back amazing memories</p><p>“Look what I found,” My brother said, coming up from the basement. We had been cleaning my grandparent’s house out for the last month, so his statement was not out of the ordinary. Every few hours or so, one would find something that they thought the other would find interesting. Prints to a project my Grandfather had worked on as an engineer many years ago, 8mm films of family outings that dated back to the ‘60s, war memorabilia from one of the world wars a family member had brought home with them. The finds were not only intellectually stimulating but also and rather emotionally moving. With every discovery, we would learn something new about our Grandparents lives and our family.</p><p>In the spring of 2010, my Grandmother passed away, leaving the home she had shared with my Grandfather for a significant part of their 65-year marriage. For the first time, 24 Glen Ave felt empty. It was an odd feeling, and I noted it to my brother after the Shivah was over and everyone had finally left. This home had never been empty before, I mentioned to him on the morning we began cleaning. Even when the family went away, there was always a dog (or two) and a litter of kittens to keep it company. Even now, with them all gone, here we were, the two of us in the house, but we were to be the last. When we finally cleaned it out, this home would go on the market and would most likely be gutted away, memories and all, to make way for a newer house and new memories.</p><p>I had brought books down to the Livingroom when he came up from the basement with a big bowl in his hand. “What is that?” I asked, my hands too full to come over and see for myself. Amishar grinned but did not say a word; he did this often whenever he wanted someone to experience the discovery for themselves. I put the books down on the old electric organ and came in to see what it was he was going on about. I must have been staring blankly for a while because after not getting the reaction he expected, my brother nudged me along “do you get what this is?” he asked.</p><p>“dough?” I replied, not wholly impressed. “It’s cookie dough” his eyes were looking at me as if waiting for the coin to fall, “Bubbies cookie dough”, he tried again, impatient at the time it took me to understand the gravity of his find. “Bubbies chocolate chip cookie dough,” he said, walking me through to the find and its conclusion. “Is it still good?” I asked. “Yea”, he replied, “I found it in the deep freeze.”</p><p>My Grandparents were a product of the Great Depression, a time in their life they made sure would go on to live in the memory of their children and grandchildren. While we all grew up enjoying far better times than they knew in their younger years, they made a point to share with us the reality of other times, to proverbially nail in the stories, less we forget how fortunate we were. While the stories had a romantic feel to them and an important moral, I can hardly say that we took them to be any more than they were – stories. But for Bubbie and Grampy, the Great Depression was a life event that would be a part of their lives till the day they died. They had two deep freezers down in the basement and a pantry that could feed a small army for many weeks. My brother and I ate from this food for a better part of 4 months and only had to visit the supermarket for perishables.</p><p>They hid things everywhere, which became part of the excitement of cleaning up their house. On the day we began sorting and cleaning, my brother asked just how closely we should examine things before throwing them out. I picked up a random book from the bookcase, flipped through it, and a 100$ bill fell to the floor. We both stared at it for a moment, “that close”, I replied.</p><p>The deep freeze was my Grandmother’s delight; she would spend the mornings sitting at the kitchen table cutting coupons out of the supermarket flyers. She would do so with intent, biting the tip of her tongue as she vigilantly cut along the lines, never missing a dash. She would then head over to the supermarket to purchase everything that was on sale. It did not matter if they were out of flour or sugar; if it was on sale and she had a coupon, she bought it. “Someone would need it”, she would say to me. If not, she had two huge deep freezers in her basement. She would spend the rest of the afternoon cooking and baking, much more than the house occupants could ever hope to devour. She was a Jewish Bubbie through and through; not even a mouse would go hungry in her house.</p><p>It was pretty typical for her to make a massive batch of cookies but then freeze half the dough for another time, and as it just so happened, she would never make that second batch, but we would!</p><p>We immediately put aside everything we were working on and began preparations to bake my Grandmother’s cookies; pre-heating the oven, buttering down the pans; we even took out a rack for the cookies to cool off. If Bubbie were watching us from above, she would have been proud.</p><p>We found her cookbook above the stove and made sure we knew how long to leave the cookies in for. 20 min later, the first tray was ready, bringing back for the first time in a while the divine smell of baked goods to a kitchen that genuinely craved it.</p><p>Once the first round had cooled off, we sat down and bit into our first cookie over a glass of milk. Immediately I was overwhelmed by both flavour and emotion. The cookies were exactly as I remembered them; perfectly crunchy on the outside, with a sweet, chocolaty chewiness on the inside that melted in your mouth. I looked away towards the counter so as not to betray my tears.</p><p>On that counter, Grampy first taught me how to make a mayo, cheese and tomato sandwich. I must have been twelve, and we were watching a Red Sox game. Then between innings, with the Red Sox down a few points, my Grandfather heavily got out of his armchair and walked over to the kitchen; he emerged a few minutes later with a delicious looking sandwich and a cup of ice tea. “That looks good”, I pointed out, so I got up to make my own. Grampy followed me into the kitchen. He showed me how to make the sandwich with an incredible eye for detail. God was in the details; he used to say – to ignore them was to ignore God. We cut the bread with precision; the tomatoes were chosen carefully and cut with the correct serrated edge knife that was not too long or too short. Lettuce was a necessity; it made sure that the ever so slightly toasted bread would not grow wet from the tomatoes. It also did something with the cheese in your stomach, but I couldn’t understand what that was about since in the background, this whole time, my Grandmother was telling us both off. She was worried that we would not be hungry for dinner, but more importantly, the kitchen was her temple, and my Bubbie was the high priest. Nothing was allowed to happen there without her blessing.</p><p>The second cookie was just as good; I couldn’t imagine ever growing tired of them. Deep inside, I knew that the batch would come to an end, but for the time being, I chose to ignore that reality and immersed myself once again in my Bubbies delicious baking.</p><p>Following the day my Grandfather had shown me how to make sandwiches, I would tiptoe into the kitchen, and in my Bubbies absence – make myself delicious sandwiches that I often enjoyed far away from her prying eyes. Bubbie was not fooled one bit, I would get caught from time to time, and while she would tell me off for snacking before dinner, she would do so lovingly. One afternoon, I came into the kitchen to find a pan of mini pizza’s, freshly baked, sitting where I would usually make my sandwiches. Bubbie entered the kitchen and, seeing that I noticed the delicious looking pizza, eyed me with a little grin. She then walked over to a cupboard, took out a paper plate, and handed me a pizza on it. I devoured it, but when I. reached over to take another, she hit my hand. “NO,” she said sternly, “not before dinner”. “And no sandwiches either!”</p><p>We stood in silence for a moment; my 12yr old self had forgotten what it was like to be scolded. Was she serious?</p><p>I looked up slowly and was met with a smile. Bubbie put a few more pizza’s on my plate, swore me to silence and ordered me out of the room. My sister and I discovered with delight just how delicious my grandmother mini pizzas were from that day forth. We would ask her to make them again and again, to mixed responses on her part. At times she would do so with such happiness, delighted that we loved her baking. While at other times, she would scold us for asking for a pre-dinner snack. Having not grown up with her, we were slow on picking up her mood changes.</p><p>We all remember in amusement that time when my Grandmother grew tired of our presence in her kitchen and ordered us all out. I was making a sandwich, but my sister was trying to be helpful, cutting up vegetables for dinner. “Everyone out!” she yelled, and we all complied. Walking back up the stairs, we overheard her complain to my Grandfather, “No one is helping me!” to which he noted that my sister was just there helping her and that she sent her away none the less. “You can’t have it both ways”, he concluded, “Yes, I can”, she snapped back. I recalled the story to Amishar as we dove in for another cookie and washed it down with milk.</p><p>“Yea, she was a character”, he remembered in amusement.</p><p>“Do you remember how every night she would pick up the bread from the local bakery?” he recalled.</p><p>I nodded, remembering how many times, especially in later years, she would insist that I come along to carry the heavy bags. We would wait until closing and then pick up the leftover bread from the bakery, filling the car with packages filled to the brim.</p><p>At times, when it was not enough to her liking, she would stop by the local supermarket and, ignoring her famous coupon rule, would purchase everything she felt was missing.</p><p>Back at home, together with my Grandfather, we would organize it, fairly dividing the donations between the packages. Then, during my Grandmothers morning supermarket run, she would drop off the bags at the local pantry and with families in need.</p><p>One time she used me for such an errand. We went to visit a “friend”, as we arrived she pointed to a bag and said, take that in, leave it in the kitchen and then come say hello. It was clear by her tone that this was to executed discreetly.</p><p>As we arrived, she stepped out of the car and went to greet her friend, taking her attention off me, just long enough for me to drop off the parcel of food in the kitchen and then join them in the living room. Later on the ride home, she explained, “some people are too proud to come to the pantry, too embarrassed to ask when they are in need”, She said as we pulled into the driveway and parked the car. “It’s up to us to notice when someone in our community is in need and never take no for an answer,” she said into the silence of the extinguished engine and a moment later, stepped out of the car and started heading towards the house. I just sat there for a while, enjoying the silence and watched her admiringly as she wobbled heavily up the stairs of the back porch. A fiery woman, whose blaze burned from the purest of places, and whose embers like the memories of her, would keep us warm long after she was gone.</p><p>A few days and many memories later, my brother and I ceremonially ate the last cookie. We had finished cleaning out the house, the stories of old all packed neatly into the caveats of our mind. The smells and sights tucked into the closets of our hearts. The pickup truck had come and gone; the last precious parcels were packed into Uncle Howie’s car. Standing in the unfurnished dimly lit kitchen, I picked up the last cookie, broke it in half and handed over what seemed the larger piece to my brother. We savoured the chewy, chocolaty baked good in a grave silence. The bare and unfurnished kitchen stood out in its starkness; the chairs and table gone – a silent monument to our Bubbie. For in a gesture that would indeed honour her memory, we had given everything away to those who needed it more.</p><p>If you knew Roz Frutkoff and want to relive a memory, or you just like yummy chocolate chip cookies – try the following recipe.</p><p>Bubbies Cookies:</p><p>2 1/4 whole grain (I use a mix of spelt and flour)</p><p>1 tsp Baking powder</p><p>100 gr butter</p><p>3/4 cup of brown sugar</p><p>2 eggs</p><p>2 tsp of vanilla extract</p><p>1 cup chopped walnuts</p><p>1 cup of chocolate chips</p><p>Preheat oven to 175c</p><p>In the first bowl, blend butter, sugar and eggs till fluffy – then add the vanilla extract.</p><p>In the second bowl, mix all dry ingredients. Add the wet bowl to the dry bowl and mix well.</p><p>Then add walnuts and chocolate chips.</p><p>The mix should become quite sticky.</p><p>Place small balls of dough on a well-oiled pan and bake for 9–11 minutes.</p><p>Makes about 24 cookies.</p><p>Enjoy while rereading this story!</p><p>If you liked this story – give a clap, and if you really liked it – You can share along with a picture of your cookies :)</p><p>Food is a great medium to spark memories of loved ones – I would love your stories in the comments below.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9fe5ec05fa89" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Avi Goldberg: A tribute to my childhood friend]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/avi-goldberg-a-tribute-to-my-childhood-friend-0259fc1851a1?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0259fc1851a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[friendship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eulogy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Nov 2024 10:06:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-01T11:40:49.449Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/1*z8_oENCwXuA2_o62qkb86A.jpeg" /></figure><p>I am not entirely sure how to write these words. How does one say goodbye to their very first friend?</p><p>These are words I mostly expected to write in our old age. Perhaps if it had come to it, you would have written them about me. Who knows what could have been? Writing these words, mid-life holds with it a special kind of pain and sadness that, unfortunately, has become commonplace this past year.</p><p>This morning, I received the news that my childhood friend, Avi Goldberg, was killed in action last night in Lebanon. I am generally good with words, but none can truly encapsulate the shock and the sorrow of your absence. I have been sitting here in front of my computer for hours, watching the cursor blink on a mostly empty screen as spells of grief flow through me like an electric current.</p><p>Avi, you and I go back to a time before either of us can truly remember; we met at the age of two, back when we lived in Kaminitz, Neve Ya’akov. Together, we navigated the first few years of our lives. Some so early on, they were captured in old photographs and became memories only later on. Our families were close as well — so close that my grandmother, may her memory be a blessing, once told me that she considered you another grandchild. In fact, in later years, when we grew out of touch, Grandma became the keeper of updates. Every visit would begin with her sharing what all the cousins were up to, and you were always among them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uQ8ckiqz1EkZt5Hzjo9dfg.jpeg" /><figcaption>My Grandfather&#39;s 90th. Avi is on the Left, and I am on the right with my guitar.</figcaption></figure><p>One of my earliest memories is of you. Having arrived in Israel as a young child, I was immersed in a world of English speakers — my family, our friends, our neighbours, and even many in our synagogue all spoke English. But at Gan (pre-school), I was surrounded by Hebrew, a language I barely understood. I can still picture the scene: a teacher towering over me, speaking in sounds I couldn’t decipher. And then, there was you, who stepped in and became my translator. We were no older than three or four, but you saw I was upset and intimidated by the situation, so you came running over and stood by my side. You became my first friend, and this moment — my first memory of friendship.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/710/1*Ii7CXKQQgNeblMziu9hd6g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hanukkah 1985 (4 years old), From Left — Meir, Avi and myself.</figcaption></figure><p>Your ability to see people this way reminds me of your original namesake, our Father, Abraham. In the Parsha of Vayera, he encounters three figures who we, the omniscient readers, often recognize as angels:</p><p>“And God was seen (וירא) by him (Abraham) at the trees of Mamre, and he was sitting at the entrance of the tent as the day grew hot. And he raised his eyes and saw (וירא) three figures standing near him, and he saw (וירא), and he ran from the entrance of the tent to greet them” [Bereshit 18:1–2]</p><p>The Rabbinic commentators stand perplexed by this encounter. Why does the text mention twice that Abraham sees the people? Isn’t once enough?</p><p>It is well known that there are no superfluous words in the Bible, leading many commentators to the conclusion that these two mentions allude to two different kinds of seeing.</p><p>The first is physical — Abraham sees three people in the heat of the day.</p><p>The second sight is more profound. Abraham sees that they are tired from their journey and concludes that they must be hungry and thirsty. The second sight drives him to action — “And he saw, and he ran…” When one sees another in such a manner, they are compelled to action.</p><p>That is how I remember you, Avi. A kind and gentle soul who could see people like Abraham. It compelled you to action in so many areas of your life. Indeed, It often seemed that you were born without a selfish bone in your body — always looking out for other people.</p><p>The last time I saw you was a few months ago. We met by chance at Ben Zackai St. We had just made it back to Israel, and while we found being stuck in the US while Israel was at war challenging, you had been that entire time in the reserves. It was a brief encounter, and most of it was spent on you wanting to hear about me. Then, just as we prepared to part ways, you gave me your winning smile and referred to the challenges of our people, saying — “… at least we have one another”.</p><p>These last few years have often left me doubting this Jewish fraternity you spoke of. But I walked away encouraged. We fall apart when we fail to see the other’s humanity; we come together when we aspire to see people with our hearts rather than our eyes, and you were always an example of that from childhood and throughout adulthood.</p><p>Rest in peace, dear friend, and thank you for teaching me friendship.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0259fc1851a1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Silence Fuels Radicalism: The Tragic Cost of Not Speaking Out”]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/when-silence-fuels-radicalism-the-tragic-cost-of-not-speaking-out-f95312d535b3?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f95312d535b3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[radicalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tisha-bav]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[discourse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Aug 2024 20:05:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-01T10:56:13.006Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MYQcwW1mGG0wpONE" /><figcaption>photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@tinaflour?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Kristina Flour</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>Was it Sin’at Hinam that destroyed Jerusalem, or perhaps the culprit lies elsewhere?</em></p><p>Under the Hasmonean Kingdom, two voices emerged from the Jewish people — the Pharisees (1) and the Sadducees (2). These were days when kings wore the robes of the High Priest, and the Sadducees held both the crown and the sacred flame. Their power spoke to the rulers and the elite, while the Pharisees, with their devotion to learning and interpretation, found their place among the scholars and the common people.</p><p>When Queen Salome [שלומציון המלכה] — The Peace of Zion — passed, the fragile peace she had nurtured shattered. Civil war erupted, leaving the land scarred and its people divided. Herod rose from the ruins, a king in name but a servant of Rome.</p><p>Herod’s rule was one of iron and blood. He silenced the leaders of both Sadducees and Pharisees, but the strife between them did not die. Even weakened, they continued to tear at one another until the Great Rebellion rained down upon them, washing away the Priesthood and the last remnants of Jewish royalty into the seas of time.</p><p>In the aftermath of the destruction, the Rabbis attempted to create a narrative that would end the hostilities and bring the people together. To do so, they shifted the blame from the Romans over to the Jewish People.</p><p>In this new storyline, the Romans were a tool of God, not the perpetrator of death, rape and the enslavement of loved ones. As such, their role was believed to highlight our people’s divisive nature and the need for them to come together as one under God. The takeaway is one we recite every year on Tish’a B’av: Sin’at Hinam, hating the other for no reason, brought the downfall of the Jewish People.</p><p>This story, with its enduring morals, holds a value that time cannot erode. Yet, the truth it carries remains clouded by inaccuracies.</p><p>To believe that the unification of these two factions could have altered the course of history is not only misguided but ignores the overwhelming reality they faced.</p><p>Even united, the Jewish people would have stood before Vespasian, the architect of Rome’s might at its peak. No nation could withstand the force of Rome in its prime — least of all, our own.</p><p>The outcome was never in doubt. Even together, we would have fallen.</p><p>This leads us to the true culprit of our destruction — the zealots. Unable to fathom the power structures of their time, they led the people on a suicide mission. The flames of zealously led our people into darkness. Our leaders’ failure was not that they couldn’t speak to one another but that they failed to reign in the “crazies” who ran amok in their communities.</p><p>The Rabbis, and to some extent, the Priests, did not see the dangers of unbridled fanaticism. They downplayed it as overenthusiasm and, at times, even praised it as religious patriotism.</p><p>Then, the tables turned. The leaders understood. But it was too late. It is mirrored in the texts that no longer distinguish between Pharisees and Sadducees once the rebellion begins but rather between the “Moderates” and the “Zealots”. The leadership’s most significant flaw was that they did not see this coming and recognised this distinction too late.</p><p>When Vespasian confronted <strong><em>Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai</em></strong>, questioning why he hadn’t come sooner, Ben Zakkai pointed to the zealots. When he pleaded with his nephew, the leader of the zealots, to restrain his men, Abba Sikkara’s response was chilling: ‘If I try, they will kill me.’ By then, madness reigned, and the leadership had lost control — but it wasn’t always so.</p><p>The rise of the zealots did not go unanswered. The Romans retaliated, executing ten members of the Pharisee leadership, including Raban Shimon ben Gamliel the Elder. A descendant of King David and Hillel the Elder, Raban Shimon was not only the leader of the Pharisees but also the Nasi, the Prince of the Jewish people. His title and lineage made him a messianic figure in the eyes of the zealots, but his execution sent a clear warning. Why he was chosen for execution remains unclear — perhaps the Romans sought to quash any potential rebellion. Josephus suggests in his <em>Vita</em> that Raban Shimon may have tacitly supported the zealots’ acts or, at the very least, remained silent. His silence was a choice, one that spoke volumes to the people. He could have denounced the zealots, but he did not.</p><p>Yehoshua Ben Gamla and later Natan Ben Natan, the High Priests and leaders of the Sadducees, also failed to act. Raban Shimon’s execution should have been a stark warning of the chaos to come if the zealots were not restrained. They, too, had the chance to speak out, to take a stand — but they remained silent.</p><p>The cost of that silence was their lives. When the zealots seized Jerusalem, they murdered the two High Priests, desecrating their bodies in a final act of violence. Only then did Rabbi Yochanan Ben Zakkai act, turning to the Romans to save what little remained.</p><p>In the well-known story, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai asks Vespasian for three things: the lives of Rabbi Zadok, the priest; Raban Gamliel, the Prince; and the city of Yavne with its scholars. By securing these, he preserves the Priesthood, the Davidic lineage, and Jewish scholarship, hoping to rebuild the Jewish people.</p><p>However, a lesser-known part of the story offers a deeper insight into this request. Vespasian shares a parable with the rabbi:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“ If there is a barrel of honey and a snake [derakon] is wrapped around it, wouldn’t they break the barrel in order to kill the snake? Similarly, I am forced to destroy the city of Jerusalem in order to kill the zealots barricaded within it.<br>Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai was silent and did not answer.” <br>[Bavli Gitin 56:1]</em></strong></blockquote><p>His silence speaks volumes; it acknowledges the bitter truth: the moderates had lost their battle against the zealots. He realises that the true enemy was never those with differing opinions but those who refused to compromise. A community thrives on opposing views — it is not only acceptable to disagree; it is essential. But there is no place for radicalism and violence, whether verbal or physical, even under the guise of tolerance and pluralism. This violence, even when it supports your worldview, devastates the community. When people disagree, a zealot will always emerge, someone whose truth is more important to them than the community as a whole. Sometimes, these zealots lean right; other times, they lean left.</p><p>The political centre is not merely a middle ground between right and left but a firm stance against zealotry. The centre’s core belief is that contradictory ideas hold value as long as they are expressed peacefully, contributing to a narrative that builds rather than tears down. When either side accuses the centre of being their adversary, it is a chilling sign that zealots are at work.</p><p>Zealots, like weeds, must be regularly uprooted. Failure to do so risks losing the entire garden — or, in our case, the “pot of honey.” Once this happens, there is no going back; we must find our Yavne and start anew.</p><p>As I spend the day fasting and contemplating, I find myself attuned to the silence in our Talmudic story. In Rabban Yochanan’s silence, I hear the great, enduring tragedy of our people: the times we elevated our proverbial Pinchas instead of restraining him, our failure to define the boundaries of discourse, and, most of all, those moments when our need to be right silenced the call to curb extremism simply because it aligned, however slightly, with our own point of view.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bCl9TbPli1woiXq0" /></figure><ul><li>Pharisees [פרושים], from the root P.R.S. [פ.ר.ש] 1. to break away [from the Mainstream] 2. interpretation — the central value of their Jewish outlook.<br>The Pharisees, led by Rabbis [Teachers], believed in the power of the written word and the revolutionary idea of interpretation — that how humans chose to read the biblical word of God was of greater importance than a so-called “God’s Will” as claimed by prophets or those in power.</li><li>Sadducees [צדוקים] from the root S.D.C [צ.ד.ק] — Justice. The origin of their name is unclear. One suggestion is that they are named after Shimon Ha’zadik, Simon the Righteous, a high priest known for his kindness.<br>The Sadducees, led by Priests, believed in worshipping God through Avoda, Temple work. As they cared little for the written word, the sources available to us today are scarce. From the little we know of them — they believed that the soul dissipated upon death. As such, they did not care for the idea of Messiah, Divine Providence, or the ideas of reward and punishment.</li><li>While the Sadducees and Pharisees accounted for the lion’s share of the people, there were other sects, which historians group as the Essenes. Essens [איסיים] is a modern identity term not recognised by those labelled by it, nor would these sects ever see themselves as one entity. The Essenes is a collective term which includes both groups like the Sikarim — a violent religious sect known for their “terror” attacks on both Roman and Jewish civilian populations alongside “Hippie-like” sects, which were vegan and would not harm a fly.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f95312d535b3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How scared are you to make a phone call?]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/how-scared-are-you-to-make-a-phone-call-5619137b70a2?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5619137b70a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anxiety-and-depression]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parsha]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ptsd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[overcome-fear]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Dec 2021 19:56:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-29T19:56:46.617Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>God walks Moses through his fear of communicating</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*54VYreY9wrdEYeiI" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@dankapeter?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Danka &amp; Peter</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The phone rang, and even before I could see the name on the screen, a wave of fear swept through my body. As I look over, my fears are realized as the writing across the screen ominously reads, “Don’t Answer!”. The input I placed instead of my commander’s name. It was in humour, but at that moment I couldn’t remember why it was funny. I take a deep breath to calm my nerves. “What is the worst thing it can be?” I rationalize, “That he calls me back to base?” No reason to fret there. I hit the answer call button and lift the phone to my ear — “Hi Daniel, Ma Nishma?” I say, with as much swag as I can muster, hoping the anxiety doesn’t show through my words.</p><p>I got my first mobile phone in September 2000. The second Intifada broke out, my unit was sent to the northern front, and the Army needed a way to get in touch with me in a more immediate fashion. One time, there was an attack; we were all called in. The Army called my parents landline, but I was out with friends. Arriving late, I was scolded for not being available. I didn’t want it, nor did I feel I needed it, but my commanding officers insisted that I either get a phone or check in every two hours. The latter sounded terrible — so I bought a cellphone.</p><p>I didn’t use it much. Being the lone wolf, I was not big on communication, especially not the kind that took place away from visual social cues. When using landlines, I would keep it short and only call when I felt it was needed. I never understood my sister. Growing up one year behind me, she was more social and seemed to take incredible pleasure from communicating with her friends. She would spend all day with them and then come home only to call them and talk more. This did not change when we went mobile. My sister would always use up her minutes while I would barely scratch the surface of my plan. Once, the phone company charged me for NOT using my phone enough!</p><p>As it was rarely used for social communication, I guess it shouldn’t come as such a surprise that I was averse to my phone from the get-go.</p><p>After the Army, the relationship with my mobile phone would fluctuate. Often months would go by, and it wouldn’t bother me at all. I could leave the ringer on, answer calls without thinking twice. But at other times, it would create such anxiety, I would feel that even knowing it was ringing would send me down the rabbit hole.</p><p>Often I would wonder why I was paying for this increased stress in my life. But people “needed” to reach me, so I conformed. To this day, when my phone rings or, worse — buzzes, I freeze. Sometimes it’s a slight apprehension that I can overcome; other times, it’s a crippling fear. Because it is not constant, it has often had a devastating effect on my relationships. I can be friendly and outgoing one moment, and then suddenly — I drop off the face of the planet. Some friends and family know that I don’t answer my phone and won’t take it personally. But others have been burnt by it and have stopped talking to me altogether because of it.</p><p>As you can imagine, this has also been devastating to my working relationships. My field of work requires a lot of communication with others — partners, group leaders, colleagues etc. Working up the courage to share this handicap with them is not always something I can muster. We all want to be competent at our jobs. Finding that you can’t even make a simple call to a client has lasting effects long after the anxiety subsides. Feelings of failure that you are sub-par are augmented with the knowledge of how good you could have done your job if you could only conquer your fear.</p><p>Moses, according to many commentators, was no stranger to social anxiety. In our Parsha, Moses mentions twice that he is of “uncircumcised lips”, once in the context of Pharaoh and later when ordered to talk to Israel. <br>[Exodus 6:12,30]</p><p>The Rabbis wonder about this use of words, and many concluded that it is in reference to Moses’s fear of communicating. Based on Talmudic sources, Rashi claims that Moses fear came from his stutter.</p><p>Rabenu Bechayeh would continue to share how Moses was full of fear — not only about speaking before Pharaoh (an understandable fear) but also when standing before the children of Israel, his followers. Rabenu Bechayeh will continue this theme in the following Parsha, sharing the distinction between positive fear that can help us grow vs negative fears that can harm us if left untreated.</p><p>Haran (Rabbi Nissim Geronidi, Spain c1350) — shares that Moses, the Father of all Prophets, had to have the ultimate weakness — a crippling fear of speaking so that we could all relate to him. A prophet who fears speech is like a driver scared of driving. In this story, Moses must overcome his fear to fulfil his mission and, in doing so — teaches us an essential lesson in conquering our own fears and flaws. [Derashot Haran 5:5].</p><p>Rather than cure Moses’ speech flaw, or grant him the “spirit of God” that would fill him with courage. God instead answers as a seasoned teacher and father figure — essentially saying, Don’t worry, I am right here! Then, when that is not enough, he sends Aharon — his brother, to physically stand by his side. This, too, is a teachable moment. One that shies away from a simple miracle fix to our challenges and encourages us to face them on our own or fall back on loved ones — when needed.</p><p>A few years ago, I asked my friend Eyal how he gets himself up every morning to run. Most people just talk about it, but he actually did it. He shared that instead of seeing running as a vitamin that could help improve his life, he decided to see it as an anti-biotic he couldn’t live without. Many skip their vitamins, but it’s rare for someone to skip out on taking their anti-biotic.</p><p>I found this notion inspiring, and it helped me recognize my fears, follow through on treatment and, develop my coping mechanisms. I plan my calls in advance, always look for privacy before making a phone call, screen calls and reply by text when possible, anything to help lower my anxiety. I also go to therapy, run a lot, and generally try to spend as much time outdoors. Unfortunately, it’s not a perfect fix, and I still often find myself falling down into the chasm of anxiety, fear and depression. When I do, I think back to this Parsha to find the inspiration to get up again.</p><p>It has taken me a very long time to deal with my <a href="https://frutkoff.medium.com/not-all-wounds-are-visible-cb354cb6fc5">military-related trauma</a> and fears. For a very long time, I thought I could ignore it or wish it away. I felt that it was a phase, and every time it would subside, I thought it was for good. Until I internalized the lesson that God was teaching Moses in our Parsha. There is no easy fix. One needs to face their flaws, face their fears — otherwise, they will never be able to overcome them. You can fall back on friends and family; you can find inspiration in faith — but regardless of the source — only you can muster the courage to overcome your fears and flaws.</p><p>P.S. If you want to reach out, text me ;)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5619137b70a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Once upon an Ice Cream Truck]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/once-upon-an-ice-cream-truck-f2dd2c647979?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f2dd2c647979</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ice-cream]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boycottisrael]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Sep 2021 09:40:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-25T06:18:26.339Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How Ice Cream can change the Middle East</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*iW1FzQWpvftY03z35Lzamw.jpeg" /><figcaption>My adorable niece enjoying the best food in the world</figcaption></figure><p>When the dust settled, I could finally see myself. Sitting on a sidewalk downtown Jenin, not quite sure what had just happened. Armed forces in Hummers and Tanks dotted a landscape of half-ruined buildings like a child’s plaything, left scattered around the room at the promise of a more exciting venture.</p><p>A muffled silence picture framed the moment — a well-known phenomenon among Merkava Tank drivers who sit with their right ear against a 1600 horsepower motor. Muffled gunshots, inaudible voices of the soldiers around me slowly come into hearing range. A child is sitting next to me, a boy, maybe eight years old. He studies me curiously, and I give him a friendly nod. He doesn’t seem a bit scared, his boyish fascination of everything military outweighing the knowledge that, in many ways — I am the enemy. There are other children around us. In later operations, I would get used to it. The lack of fear Palestinian children demonstrated, who at a battle’s end (and at times, during the action itself) would wander out nonchalantly, in between the bullets to play, tend to their families cattle or run an errand for one of the elders in their family.</p><p>The battle lasted for days. There were a couple of near-death experiences that I brushed off the way one would pat down their pants before walking into the house from the garden. There was a birthday too. I turned 21 during the battle. I celebrated by clearing away bodies of a Nahal reserve unit caught in an ambush not far from the Qasava. There was no excessive drinking on my 21st, but my crew did sing happy birthday, and my Gunner gave me a crumpled up magazine cutting of Bar Refaeli that had kept him company during the long hours of guard duty at the checkpoints.</p><p>The child eyed my rifle, an Israeli version of an AK47. I pulled it aside so that it no longer sat between us and tried to make conversation with the boy. But, unfortunately, he did not speak any Hebrew or English, and my Arabic was abysmal despite my many years studying it. So we sat in silence and watched the trucks, jeeps, and armoured vehicles drive around chaotically while the IDF secured the city’s downtown.</p><p>In the distance, I noticed the dust of a convoy making its way towards us. Who would it be this time? The child also noticed the dust on the horizon, perking his head to the side as he listened and then watched the convoy come into view. — Yaser Arafat, attempting to gain a few political points at the end of the battle, stepped out of the first convoy. The people wouldn’t have it. They had lost enough and had no patience for him. He left as fast as he came so as not to be swallowed by the angry crowds.</p><p>The second convoy was of a very different nature. Following the lead Jeep were two Ben&amp;Jerry’s ice cream trucks.</p><p>They were so out of place that at first, I assumed they were special forces camouflaged as ice cream trucks. But moments later, the two trucks opened their side windows and began giving out Ice Cream. In a matter of moments, Israeli soldiers and Palestinian children lined up in front of the trucks as they would anywhere else in the world. Only, this had just been a war zone. We lost thirteen of our men. The Palestinians lost close to fifty, some of which were still lying in between the ruins of buildings. The boy looked at me unsure but then followed the signal of my hand, motioning him to come with me. I let him step in front of me, and before long, we both returned to the sidewalk with ice cream. We didn’t get to choose flavours; one just took what they handed out. I got cookies and cream, the boy — Dulce de leche, lucky him.</p><p>We sit and watch others line up for ice cream as we enjoy our own. It was one of the most surrealistic moments of my life — Israeli Soldiers, Palestinian children and two ice cream trucks that would bring them together for a brief moment.</p><p>Years later, staffing Kids4Peace, it seemed obvious that our events would always feature Ben&amp;Jerry’s Ice Cream. Someone once mentioned that Jerry was connected somehow to the Brattleboro graduates of our Peacebuilding program. Others said he was on the board, while some in the office said it was a local connection — and that their choice to support peace communities had nothing to do with Jerry’s activism. Whatever it was — Ben&amp;Jerry’s became a staple of every peacebuilding event we had in the city. Food has the incredible power of bringing people together, ice cream — even more so. It may seem trivial, but B&amp;J’s played an essential role in bringing our children together.</p><p>Food also has the power to separate. Our religious practices generally include food items that we are not allowed to eat. It is rarely your daily pees, carrots or some random vegetable on the no-no list. Alcohol, coffee and meat — staples of a meal that symbolise encounter and bring people together are far more common. I thank God that Ice Cream did not exist at the time our religions took shape. Food that we share can end conflicts.</p><p>When Abraham came to Jerusalem, King Malki Tzedek greeted him with wine, bread and meat. They ate, and an alliance was born. Many years later, B&amp;J did the same for our Jerusalem interfaith community.</p><p>As you can imagine, I was disappointed by the recent B&amp;J statement that they will no longer sell ice cream in the West Bank. The company claimed they adopted this decision to help the peace movement -but I can’t imagine how not serving ice cream helps anyone. Rather than make statements and decisions on where and who they WON’T be selling their ice cream to, B&amp;J could have focused on who they ARE selling their ice cream to — interfaith and peacebuilding communities like Kids4Peace, Seeds of Peace, the YMCA etc. If they wanted to send a clear message supporting peace, wouldn’t focusing on their positive action make for a more vital message? Instead, they decided to punish rather than build.</p><p>In his book Community, Peter Block shares two kinds of communities; A Community of Problems and a Community of Possibilities. The first is far more common. We often focus on our problems and define our reality through the speculum of everything that is not working. Unfortunately, this mindset doesn’t leave many possibilities for a better future. If we only see the ‘IS’ that is negative and focus on the faults of our community, we will never create anything better. This neo-realist approach that saw ‘conflict’ as default has led us to believe that we must focus on war reduction to see peace. It may have had its place in the 20th century, but it is doing a disservice today. Instead, imagine a community-building approach to conflict. One that recognises struggle as an integral part of the growth process that all communities go through. If we can Change The We (#Changethewe) and reimagine our conflict, not as one happening between TWO peoples but one taking place in ONE community — we may suddenly find that we have a wealth of tools and strategies to overcome adversity. Community building and overcoming the struggles of conflict in our communities are not new phenomena. But before we can lean on our knowledge in this area, we must do the work in shifting the way we think — so that we may realise that we are indeed one community.</p><p>A community of possibilities is one that, rather than focus on what is not working, chooses to explore what they can create together. It’s a community that encourages creativity and supports the dreams and aspirations of its individuals. The defining question of this community is</p><p>— <strong>What can we build together?</strong></p><p>At Kids4Peace, rather than only meet the other (contact theory), we worked on creating our community using six steps I will expand upon in a future piece. Community events that included food were central to our process and often highlighted by our members as something they would never forget.</p><p>Rabbi Soloveitchik’s “Kol Dodi Dofek” is a Jewish reflection of the mindset above. In this book, Soloveitchik shares that how we see ourselves and others — as subjects or objects, will be central in defining our behaviours.</p><blockquote>“Against your will, you are born, and against ‎your will, you ‎die” (M. Avot 4:22), but by your free will, you live. Man is born as an object, dies as ‎an object, but ‎can live as a “subject” — a creator and innovator who ‎impresses his ‎imprimatur on his life and breaks out of a life of instinctive, automatic ‎behaviour into one ‎of creative activity. Jewish texts tell us that a man’s mission in this world is to turn ‎fate into destiny — ‎an existence that is passive and influenced into an existence that is active and ‎influential; an ‎existence of compulsion, perplexity, and speechlessness into an existence full of ‎will, vision, and ‎initiative.”</blockquote><p>While Conflict Resolution is preoccupied with understanding peace through the empirical study of war, that is to say in ‘negative’ terms by which peace is only achieved through prevention of war. Peacebuilding, on the contrary, attempts to look for a new understanding of human interaction, encouraging a proactive approach of ‘peace creation’ rather than the reactive ‘war reduction’.</p><p>Rabbi Soloveitchik goes on to talk about people of fate and people of destiny.</p><p><em>People of Fate</em> are defined by their problems, by the challenges that they involuntary react to. They ask — Why does this always happen to me!?</p><p><em>People of Destiny</em> endure the same challenges and tragedies, but rather than be victims, they survive. They ask — how can I grow from this. How can I build something new?</p><p>This is our challenge as individuals and communities — to be people of destiny and communities of possibilities. This is where B&amp;J failed in their recent new policy.</p><p>There is an alternative ice cream that focuses on the positive. It’s called Buza (Ice Cream in Arabic). A few years ago, an Israeli and a Palestinian began to dream — what can we create together?<br><strong>What has the power to build communities?</strong></p><p>Alcohol was a no — it is a dietary restriction for more than half the population, and children can not consume coffee.</p><p>Then it dawned on them — Ice Cream!!</p><p>Today they are ranked by many as the best Ice Cream in the Middle East. But, don’t take my word for it — <a href="https://buzaisrael.co.il/%d7%90%d7%95%d7%93%d7%95%d7%aa/">check them ou</a>t.</p><p>If, like me, you want to support an Ice cream that aspires to dreaming a better middle east rather than boycotting those who don’t think like them — then Buza is your new favourite place.</p><p>I pray that Ben&amp;Jerry’s once again aspire to be the ice cream that makes all children happy and not only those who fit the company’s political agenda, but if not — We have no shortage of good ice cream brands to take their place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f2dd2c647979" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ki Tavo — When you believe…]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/ki-tavo-when-you-believe-87f025dbf9e6?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/87f025dbf9e6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dvar-torah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ki-tavó]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[miracles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Aug 2021 14:40:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-29T14:40:47.961Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Ki Tavo — When you believe…</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SzvtfC_GAB3T_oLn" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@alexradelich?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Alex Radelich</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote>ט֗וֹב לְהֹד֥וֹת לַיהֹוָ֑ה וּלְזַמֵּ֖ר לְשִׁמְךָ֣ עֶלְיֽוֹן׃</blockquote><blockquote>It is good to praise the LORD, to sing hymns to Your name, O Most High,</blockquote><blockquote>לְהַגִּ֣יד בַּבֹּ֣קֶר חַסְדֶּ֑ךָ וֶ֝אֱמ֥וּנָתְךָ֗ בַּלֵּילֽוֹת׃</blockquote><blockquote>To proclaim Your steadfast love at daybreak, Your faithfulness each night.</blockquote><p>My teacher, Even Leader, once gave a Drash on psalms 92 saying that the juxtaposition of daybreak and love, faithfulness and night was not without meaning.</p><p>When the day is bright and new, when there is light for us to see for miles, it is not hard to see God’s kindness in the world and for us to proclaim our love. But at days end, when the night is long when darkness surrounds us, and no end seems to be in sight — that is when we must fall back on our faith to get by. Faith is a powerful tool; it allows us to move mountains that we could not move. It enables us to face fears that we had no chance of overcoming. When you believe, you can overcome anything the world throws at you.</p><p>Our Parsha, Ki Tavo — ends with interesting introversion on faith. Moses speaks to the new generation, to those who are about to enter the Holy Land. He reflects upon them the actions of their parent’s generation and says on to them:</p><blockquote>וְלֹא־נָתַן֩ יְהֹוָ֨ה לָכֶ֥ם לֵב֙ לָדַ֔עַת וְעֵינַ֥יִם לִרְא֖וֹת וְאׇזְנַ֣יִם לִשְׁמֹ֑עַ עַ֖ד הַיּ֥וֹם הַזֶּֽה׃</blockquote><blockquote>Yet to this day, the LORD has not given you the heart to understand, eyes to see, or ears to hear.</blockquote><p>The commentators reflect on this odd choice of words to teach a lesson about faith. So often, we rationalise that those who witness miracles would be of great faith. Yet the Desert Generation saw some of the greatest miracles and was of very little faith despite seeing them. Furthermore, we have seen that our people had great faith in some of our darkest times.</p><p>At the end of his journey, Moses comes to teach us that the relationship between faith and miracles is not as we may have thought. Rather than faith stemming from miracles, it is when you have faith that miracles are everywhere to be seen.</p><p>Yehuda Amichai — in his book “Miracles” shares a similar mind to Rashi in his comments on this verse:</p><blockquote><em>ֵמרָחוֹק כָּל דָּבָר נִרְאֶה נֵס</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>אֲבָל מִקָּרוֹב גַם נֵס לֹא נִרְאֶה כָּךְ.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>אֲפִילוּ מִי שֶעָבַר בְּיַם-סוּף בִּבְקִיעַת הַיָּם</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>רָאָה רַק אֶת הַגַּב הַמֵּזִיעַ</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>שֶל ההוֹלֵך לְפָנָיו ואת נוע ירכיו הגדולות...”</em></blockquote><blockquote>“From afar, everything seems like a miracle. But from up close, it does not appear that way. Even those crossing the Red Sea saw only the sweating back of the person before them and the movement of their big thighs.”</blockquote><p>In verse above, Moses tells the new generation that not only will their faith be great despite not seeing the same magnitude of miracles, but that their miracles may seem small only because they are close to them. Distance obscures our miracles, and it is only by our choice in faith to see them for what they are.</p><p>We live today in very uncertain times. In many ways, we are deep within the night, and for many of us our future is uncertain. We are also at summers end; the days are getting shorter, the nights longer. This is a time when we must turn to faith. When I say faith, I don’t mean religion; the two are different but are often confused with one another. Religion may be a tool that one turns to in search of faith — but it is not a purpose onto itself, and it is not the only option. It doesn’t matter if one finds faith in God, Tao, Chi, E = mc2 or in other people. But it is important that when times are uncertain, they turn to faith; for if not, they give way to their fears — and these can consume all that is beautiful in our world.</p><p>In a related story. I once walked Grandma to a park near her home. We were hardly halfway there when she commanded me to stop. <em>“Do you see that bench? Yes, that one, let’s sit there,”</em> she said, pointing towards a bench halfway up the hill.</p><p>I tried to protest, reminding her that the park was just a few more minutes up the hill and that it is much nicer. <em>“We will sit here for a few minutes, and then we can continue,”</em> She said decisively. When my grandmother made a decision, not even the Queen of England could change her mind.</p><p><em>“Come help me out”</em>, she commanded, <em>“and make sure to sit next to my good ear so that I can hear you.”</em></p><p>I helped her out and sat beside her.</p><p>Grandma closed her eyes, and took a deep breath of the cool air and let it out with a sigh of relief. Then she opened her eyes slowly and looked around till a group of young trees across the path caught her gaze.</p><p><em>“Aren’t they nice?”</em> She said, pointing to them. <br><em>“It’s so beautiful here, don’t you think?”</em></p><p>I followed her gaze across the path and looked at the pitiful sad excuse of the sidewalk shrubbery before us. The trees were small, bent over and from the looks of it, half dead. I hesitated a moment before replying but then took her hand and smiled.</p><p><em>“Yes, Grandma, it is a beautiful place”</em> — because when you are young, sometimes you need older people who see life from a distance, to open your eyes to the miracles and remind you that the world is indeed a beautiful place.</p><p>This week, my Brother <a href="https://medium.com/u/4a3711fb99c0">Amishar</a> married the one who has been his home almost since the day he met her. In the spirit of this Parsha — I want to take this moment to bless them both.</p><p>Amishar and Chelsea,</p><p>I pray you two always find a way to hold on to your faith. The faith you have in one another, the faith you have in your community and the faith you have in God and our world. All relationships require a lot of work and constant up-keeping. Sometimes you two will stand in happiness in the mornings of your life, the world as a whole at your feet — Everything will seem bright and new — and you will feel gratitude and give thanks almost intuitively. But relationships are not always easy. At times they will wade through dark times; sometimes, the future will seem vague and bleak. I pray that at these moments are few and that when they visit — that you hold steady in your faith, that you don’t lose the capacity to see miracles, that you recognise the beauty that exists between you two and much like the Israelite&#39;s standing at the doorsteps of the Holy Land, build your new home with it.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F9QI3b_pA-M4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D9QI3b_pA-M4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F9QI3b_pA-M4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7a4ed9e5b19da243363be6a920cc3dd0/href">https://medium.com/media/7a4ed9e5b19da243363be6a920cc3dd0/href</a></iframe><p>Our Parsha teaches us that miracles and beauty exist everywhere. Left, right and centre of the joint path you both walk on. If you make the choice to see, hear and know in your heart — No obstacle will ever be a challenge for you two.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=87f025dbf9e6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Atlas]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/the-atlas-327e7ad489f8?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/327e7ad489f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tribalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[occupation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Dec 2020 22:44:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-29T22:44:56.377Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*DMbKHLWKFVKUtqNn" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@britishlibrary?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">British Library</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Eighty years ago, the Jewish people experienced a traumatizing event in which we lost half of our people. Hurt and scared, our wounds still bleeding, we came together and created the State of Israel. We infused into this country many dreams, and hopes alongside the pain and fear we inherited from the Shoah.</p><p>Some came to Israel with the lesson of self-preservation, they said:</p><p><strong>“This can never happen again to us!”</strong>.</p><p>These people set forth to make Israel strong and resilient. An entity that can stand up for Jews, where ever they may be threatened or in danger.</p><p>Others came to Israel with the lesson of universal compassion, they said<strong>:</strong></p><p><strong>“This can never happen again, period”</strong>.</p><p>These people see our State as a stepping stone for a better humanity.</p><p>These two statements, these two mindsets; tribalistic and the universal — echo through every issue that Israel has ever contended with. They mark the borders of our Israeli identity, most of us falling somewhere in that spectrum.</p><p>Often, when I share with people how my family’s experiences of the Shoah led me to be sensitive to another’s plight, some of whom we are oppressing, I see them cringe.</p><p><em>“How dare you compare!”</em> they shoot back at me defensively.</p><p>Little do they understand that I am not comparing. I am moved and compelled to action by human atrocities of the past. Our grandparents suffering, I argue — does not give us a free pass to hurt others. Even when, and especially when the political realities are complicated.</p><p>The following story is based on incidents that took place during the summer of 2002. For the sake of the story and some of its real-life characters’ anonymity, I took the liberty to make some fictional changes. Overall, the story is factual, but more importantly, it depicts some of the thoughts and feelings I was having at the time and how they play into my life today.</p><h3>The Atlas</h3><p>When I was six, in anticipation of my first day of school, my parents bought me my first Atlas. Of all my newly acquired books at that time, it was the most exciting of them all. It was so big that it did not fit on any bookshelf and demanded it’s own place of honour on my desk. When I would sit down and read it, it would reach out far beyond my lap, and it took an entire arm’s length to turn each page. But most intriguing about it was that rather than words, it was filled with pictures that sparked this child’s imagination and sent me miles away to countries and cultures I would never see in person. Stories of past and future, some historical, others imagined would fill my head as my little hands turned those pages. Many a time, I would dream myself a captain of a ship or some other character in a Kipling story sailing seas and exploring these foreign lands. These stories were just about as spectacular and fantastic as ever could be told, since a child’s imagination knows no limit.</p><p>However, most of these stories have since gone and faded from memory as the sight of land from a ship set sail, while it voyaged on towards my adulthood.</p><p>All, but one story.</p><p>It was told to me by Grandpa may his soul and memory be blessed, on a rainy November day not long after school had begun. My grandfather saw the Atlas sitting on my desk; boasting its throne to all that cared to notice, and nonchalantly, picked it up and told me that he personally knew the editor. He pointed to his name on the bright red cover as he sat down on my sister’s bed and opened it to a random page. I crawled up next to him and waited in anticipation to hear more, The fact that MY Grandpa knew the editor of my favourite school book thrilled me to no end. Maybe he could tell me stories that I had missed. And boy, could he!</p><p>As we flipped through the pages, my grandfather proved to be the best history teacher I would have, pointing to different lands and telling me their stories. Grampa met every question with another detailed account of what had happened and how ‘this and that’ took place. That afternoon empires rose and fell as the raindrops on my window, withering away with only the occasional thunder to remind us of their once great distant past.</p><p>I must have been daydreaming when I suddenly noticed that Grandpa had not spoken in a while. His moist eyes staring hard at the map shared with me that he too was somewhere else, somewhere that pained him. I followed his gaze down to the opened Atlas and tried to read the name of the country we were about to explore, breaking the word into syllables as my Mummy had taught me.</p><p><em>“Pooh — laaaand”</em> I read carefully.</p><p>Then with a little more confidence, I repeated it.</p><p><em>“Po-land… Poland. Grandpa, it says Poland.”</em></p><p><em>“Yes, it does..”</em> he said sadly. <em>“that’s where I am, sorry — was from”</em></p><p><em>“Oh”</em> — I replied, looking at the green outlined country sitting in the centre of the page yet explored. My heart was conflicted at addressing his sadness, all while wanting to continue on our exciting voyage.</p><p><em>“Do you miss it?”</em> I asked him hesitantly.</p><p><em>“Miss it?”</em> He repeated my question as if to reiterate, but never answered it.</p><p>Instead, he began with a shaky voice to tell me a story, his story, a story of a little boy in Tarnow and of the war that would annihilate everything he knew. His voice choked as he told of the last time he saw his mother, of his brothers and sisters that were incinerated to ash. Of Gentiles who stood idly by and watched in silence. Of a world that didn’t care.</p><p>To this day, I don’t know how much I understood of his stories. Many of them would be repeated, details filled throughout years to come, to the extent that I could never differentiate when I was told what.</p><p>Two things, though, did stand out on that occasion. I remember my Grandpa crying, his tears staining the pages of my newly bought Atlas. From that day forth, whenever my Atlas was opened to Europe, I could see the place where they fell and would remember the moment. The other was of the moment after, he wiped his tears and said that it would never happen again. Not now, when we have our own country. <em>“One day you will grow up and go to the army,” </em>He stated<em> — “and you, along with many other Jewish boys and girls, will make sure of that, It will never happen again!”</em></p><p>I swallowed his words eagerly, every one of them imprinting itself upon my heart. I reiterated them when I rose, and when I slept, in my home and along the road, my life was to take me on. I looked forward to the day of my conscription with passion, every moment of my teenaged life seemed to be in preparation for it. Finally, the day came, and on a sunny morning in March I arose tenaciously to mission, uniform to the nines, gun at hand <em>“It would never happen again!”</em></p><p>It was only once I was in the army that my determination wavered. I began to look at the world around me with the naive yet beautiful sense of justice that only the young can procure. Terrible things were happening, and my people were no exception in bringing harm to others. My Grandpa said that it would never happen again and on that rainy day in November, so many years ago, I believed him. Yet the people in Cambodia, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, Serbia and many other distant lands seemed to counter this notion. My Grandpa spoke of our army in idealistic terms; how it stood proud for a people who longed for freedom and self-determination. Yet it would seem that dreams; pink and lofty when first conceived, tend to turn grey come reality. How could one really rid the world of pain with more fighting and killing?</p><p>Then one day, my narrative shattered, and I got lost in my Tank in search of the meaning of it all. It was a Tuesday morning, I had just arrived at the base after a vacation at home. My comrades were excited to see me, I was early, which meant that they could go home earlier.</p><p><em>“We have a patrol in half an hour,”</em> one of them told me, <em>“switch to work uniforms, you could take my place, and I could go home.”</em></p><p>I assured him I would do my best, but the base commander thought otherwise.</p><p><em>“You don’t know the area yet,”</em> He declared,</p><p><em>“Once you are in work uniform come to the war room for a briefing.”</em></p><p>I was to be part of the secondary patrol that would follow, half an hour behind the leading party.</p><p>My briefing was cut short by a distant explosion, and machine-gun fire of a 0.5 browning. The radios in the room immediately came alive with chatter, and along with my crew, I ran to our Merkava Tank, knowing that someone would surely need our help. The command came moments later, the patrol Tank was hit by an IED — Go secure the area so that medical and mechanical crews can safely reach the bombarded Merkava.</p><p>We take our position, and the rest of the crews move in. We scan the area for further threats, and the gunner notes that it is oddly quiet for a supposed battle zone.</p><p><em>“The Tank looks fine too,”</em> He says.</p><p>We drive closer to the other Tank and call out to the team on board, they stick their heads out and wave back. Their Merkava had lost it’s left caterpillar but otherwise was relatively intact, the crew seemed fine too.</p><p><em>“Where are they going?”</em> my commander asks, pointing to the medical crew walking away from the scene into a nearby field.</p><p><em>“We killed the terrorists!”</em> They all tried to answer at once.</p><p><em>“We saw them hiding low in the field after the explosion”</em>, <em>“We opened fire!” “They stopped moving!”</em></p><p>We grab our guns and follow the medics, they might need back up. Up ahead of us the Medics suddenly stop short, frozen in place they stare at the ground from a few feet away. One first-responder turns around and vomits while the rest seemed bewildered by some terrifying sight. As we advance, the horror becomes clear to us as well.</p><p>A little girl, (later we would learn she was nine years of age) was lying on the ground, her white dress stained with dirt and grime, her head was nowhere to be seen… at her side, an older woman, (her mother) lay still, a hole the size of a tennis ball pierced through her chest. There is a baby in her arms. One of the Medics lifts the child from her lifeless arms. The baby whimpers, a shiver runs through me, he’s alive!</p><p>The Medic stares at us and then back at the baby wide-eyed. We stand in deafening silence.</p><p>The stillness is disturbed by a grunt from a nearby bush, a quick search finds a young boy a few feet away, the brother of the headless girl. The Medic quickly hands the baby over to one of the fighters and runs over to check him. The boy is no more than twelve years of age. He is missing his right arm and is losing a lot of blood. The Medic stops the bleeding and patches him up, we signal one of the ambulances to approach. While we lift him into the ambulance, the boy is blabbering incoherently in Arabic.</p><p><em>“What is he saying?”</em> my commander asks.</p><p>One of the soldiers translates: <em>“We heard the explosion, we were scared, we hid in the bushes, but then they started shooting at us, why were they shooting at us?”</em></p><p>The Medic wipes the blood away from his hands, shaking his head fervently.</p><p><em>“He lost too much blood”</em> he mumbles, <em>“he won’t make it.”</em></p><p>He was right, he didn’t.</p><p>We head back to base with the baby, others go to the nearby village to locate the family, or rather the father who shy of his little boy no longer had a family. The scene is sombre and tense, we sit around in silence, Skynews blasting in the background — we wonder if they will pick up on the story. The other Tank commander curses to himself as if a conversation just took place in his head, then he fumbles to light a cigarette, his hands are shaking. The gunner turned killer lifts the baby in his arms and gazes into his eyes in disbelief,</p><p><em>“I can’t believe I killed his family, we were sure it was the terrorists who attacked us”</em> he mumbles as he looks into the babies eyes. Then the tragic irony hits me; the gunner himself also lost his mother to a violent attack when he was a child, now he just made this child an orphan to his mother. Is this what they call the cycle of violence? It usually sounds so dry. I put my hand on his shoulder and try to comfort him as he begins to sob. <em>“It’s okay”</em> I hear myself say, <em>“It’s okay”</em>, but it’s not okay. Why the fuck would I say it’s okay?</p><p>He buries his head into the baby’s tummy, the latter finds this amusing and giggles, unaware of the tragic moment.</p><p><em>“He will never remember this”</em>, I think to myself. <em>“He will grow up learning how an IDF patrol killed his family, but he will never remember how the man who pulled the trigger, cried in his arms.”</em></p><p><em>“He will grow up to be a terrorist,”</em> says another soldier as if to counter my thought process. The commander curses again and spits on the ground. I turn around irritated and silence him, but deep down, I know he might be right. It is the circle of violence, after all.</p><p>Emotion overwhelms me, and I sit down by his side and join the gunner in his tears. I’m confused and not really sure how or what I should be feeling. This is what happens when you give kids uniforms and guns and tell them to make the world a better place. This was us, making sure it would never happen again.</p><p>Two weeks later, back at home, I come across my old Atlas, it’s cover barely holding fast. I open the book and flip through it, stopping short as I come across Eastern Europe. I run my fingers across the map that saw my Grandpa’s tears fall so many years ago. His voice echos in my mind across space and time as if suddenly he was sitting once again by six years old me.</p><p>“…it will never happen again.”</p><p>My heart begins to race fast.</p><p>Every story has a moral, but had I jumped to conclusions? What was he trying to say to me?</p><p><em>“…it will never happen again”</em>, was it only to ourselves that we owed this?</p><p>My thoughts wander back to the two orphaned boys, one in uniform, the other in diapers, and I am taken by emotion. With a fit of rage, I send my Atlas hurtling across the room. Its cover comes apart, and some pages fall to the ground as it hits the wall of my childhood room. A thought comes to mind. How when telling a country’s history, we tend to look at the coloured parts of the map when, in fact, it’s the black lines between them that actually tell the story. Every line representing thousands of human beings dead, killed, murdered because someone thought that the coloured part was worth dying and killing for.</p><p>Descartes once said that the first man to put up a border and say, ‘this land is mine’, was the greatest sinner of mankind. So many have followed on this path, so many sinners, and I was now among them.</p><p><em>“…it will never happen again”,</em></p><p>the narrative no longer worked for me. Not if it was solely focused on us. Not if spoken from the mouths of victims who can not see the pain of others. I must write a new story, I must listen to my heart, I can no longer live old narratives in silence as the world once did us.</p><p>For let us be honest, let us speak plainly — <strong>it will happen again!</strong></p><p>It will happen again for the simple reason that we are human, and in our times of weakness, we forget who we are and hurt others.</p><p>It will happen again because time after time, we fail to embrace the weak before they learn to hate.</p><p>It will happen again because we refuse to face our own depravity and choose to blame religion, nationalism, or other economic and political movements rather than own up to what we, humanity, have done. We systematically disassociate ourselves from the “offender” and fail to realize that all the finger-pointing in the world will never remove the mirrors in which our fingers are pointed right back at us…</p><p>It <em>will</em> happen again.</p><p>Only this time, I won’t be silent.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=327e7ad489f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Painter]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/the-painter-129144b2ad36?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/129144b2ad36</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Dec 2020 07:23:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-22T07:37:50.440Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Revolution does not know nuance, <br>Nuance does not allow change.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WKkgTYY4EWFj6vty" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@yannispap?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Yannis Papanastasopoulos</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I once met a painter while walking through a Jerusalem Market. She was dreaming a world of colours mixed in such harmony, that I; who have always wished to mix people of different shapes and colours in such a manner, stopped — to find inspiration for a while.</p><p>She paused and looked up.<br> <em>“Are you a Rembrandt or a Picasso?”</em> She asked me.<br>I wasn’t quite sure, so she painted me a picture of words.</p><p><em>Picasso was a Revolutionist, Rembrandt, a conformist.</em></p><p>Picasso broke the rules, he was loud and flamboyant and never painted beyond the surface.<br>Rembrandt longed for harmony and order. He was methodical and disciplined. He would paint with a two haired brush, <br>layer upon layer upon layer upon layer. <br>He lived in poverty in a time of peace, whereas Picasso lived in affluence during a time of war.</p><p>People are generally one or the other. Which are you?<br>I admired both painters… and could not decide.<br>Some days I’m Rembrandt, other days I’m Picasso.<br>I’m sure you could pick for me,<br> it is easy to define the other and place them in a box.</p><p>But I don’t know who I am, <br> and I think I may never know.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=129144b2ad36" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ki Tavo — Who are you not seeing?]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/ki-tavo-who-are-you-not-seeing-e72f2bfcd5cb?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e72f2bfcd5cb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dvar-torah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[invisible-people]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Sep 2020 14:42:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-04T10:55:04.709Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Ki Tavo — Who are you not seeing?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*d7q9r7TGEsowMY5f" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@greystorm?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Ian</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Last week I spoke about those we see and those we don’t. This weeks Parsha seems to continue this theme with a very relevant and significant statement on our lives today. The focal point of this weeks portion is the somewhat odd ceremony that the Israelites enact upon their arrival in the holy land. It’s a coming of age ceremony for the nomadic Israelites that warns them of the dos and don’ts in their new land.</p><p>Commentators recognized a theme; the warnings seem to all regard transgressions that one does “Be’se-ter” — in hiding. But Iben Ezra a commentator of the 11th-century golden era of Spain challenges this notion. He noticed that the punishments only seem to parallel some of the commandments, not all of them. More importantly, these commandments can not be described as being done in hiding. How can it be that leading the blind astray, being dishonest to the stranger, or being unjust with the widow and orphan, be “In hiding”? They all involve another person.</p><p>Armed with this knowledge, he goes back to the text to see if these commandments have something else in common. Iben Ezra then teaches that “In hiding” is used in the greater context of the word, and includes those who are hidden from society. “She’ein lahem ozer” — that they do not have someone to help them.</p><p>If a judge were to rule unjustly in a case between two civilians of privilege, her transgression would soon be publicly known. But when a judge rules unjustly with an orphan or widow, or in terms of my social circles — A person of colour, a Palestinian, or any other minority — no one would care enough to make a big deal out of it. Iben Ezra then concludes that because humanity may not care for those who are not seen, God assures us that she cares and will seek their justice.</p><p>This is not a new, a few weeks ago, we came across a similar notion. Deuteronomy 24:14 warns us not to oppress the poor and the strangers that dwell in our lands. God continues, and warns that if this ever were to come to past, and they were to cry out at night, the merciful one would hear that cry, sin would be placed on our heads and God would claim their vengeance and justice.</p><p>When I first started my way in the interfaith world, I had a very warped sense of what our justice system was like. I had a lot of trust in the various branches of government, I knew they were not perfect, but I assumed that the imperfections were the exception to the rule.</p><p>At one point I started working with youth, and my teen staff included several Palestinian boys who taught me more about the conflict in the first few months of working with them, then I had learned my entire life. Of this, they say — ומתלמידי יותר מכולם — I have learned most from my students.</p><p>One day, Yusef (not his real name) was late for a program, I called to see what was going on.</p><p>“I can’t talk,” He said almost in a whisper — “The police are integrating me.”</p><p>“Put me on with them,” I asked.</p><p>At first, he refused; he was nervous and didn’t want me to make things worse. I promised that I would be thinking only of him and was not going to try and make a point — a widespread phenomenon among left-wing activists. Often, they don’t think of the individual Palestinian’s best interest and argue with the law Israeli to Israeli. It rarely has the intended effects and only serves to make the situation worse for the Palestinian individual involved. After much coaxing, he agreed and passed on the phone.</p><p>“Hi, this is Carmiel, I am Yusef’s group leader” — I said in the most Israeli fashion possible. “Can you tell me why you stopped him?</p><p>“Are you Israeli?” The policeman asked,</p><p>“You mean Jewish? Yes, I am.”</p><p>“Oh” — I could hear him relax a bit.</p><p>“Listen, brother; I need him here with me,” I spoke with familiarity. “He is supposed to run a program — why did you stop him?”</p><p>“Because he was running towards the train.”</p><p>I held my breath to control my emotions. Then in the calmest voice, I could procure,</p><p>“That’s because he is late for the program and should have been here half an hour ago!”</p><p>“Fine, we’re letting him go.” Came the reply on the other side.</p><p>“Thank you brother, Take my number down if you need to follow up.”</p><p>“No need.”</p><p>After the program, I pulled Yusef aside to see how he was doing. He laughed at my genuine concern.</p><p><em>“Carmiel, this happens to me almost every time I leave the house.”</em></p><p>I thought he was exaggerating, but as the year went on, I began to realize that his statement ran true. If you are a young Arab man in Jerusalem, then you are going to get pulled over and frisked by the police at least two to three times a week. It doesn’t matter if you are the kindest, most peace-loving soul ever.</p><p>As time went by, and I began to comprehend just how bad it was, I also started noticing it more around me. It’s an odd thing, sometimes something can be right in front of you, and you never see it. Then it’s brought to your attention, and you can’t stop seeing it. Suddenly I noticed how often the police detained the Arab population around me, and it started to irk me.</p><p>On a few accounts, I walked over and playing stupid — handed them my id card. When they would ask why, I would say innocently, “Oh, I thought you were stopping everyone”, and this would lead into a conversation about racial profiling, while the entire time I pretend to be clueless. But more often, I stop nearby, make eye contact with the police, and make clear that I am watching their interactions with the young man, my phone ready at hand. I can not share in words how angry these ‘stop and frisks’ make me. They don’t play any security role of note; they exist to serve as a reminder to the Arab public — Don’t forget who is Master and who is Slave. If I ever became Mayor of this city, this ugly practice would be the first thing out the door.</p><p>Over the last few weeks, I couldn’t help think of the many who don’t find justice in our justice system, not necessarily due to malintent, but rather for the social blindness that plagues us all. This Parsha foresaw a reality like this for as previously mentioned, every generation’s ethical standing is challenged by those they can not see. Therefore, on mount Gerizim, just outside of Nablus, God warns us — Even when others don’t see you act or don’t care for your transgression, it doesn’t mean you are not guilty!</p><p>Let us be thankful for those we can now see. I don’t know if it was Corona that made us more aware of others or just a general sentiment from a growing number of citizens sick and tired of their leaders racist and dividing rhetoric. But as I read through this Parsha, I find myself praying that the coming new Jewish Year, be one of seeing. One where we can finally open our hearts to others, to the strangers among us. And I pray that we all go to the voting booth this year, and make it happen. Words of Torah are admirable, but they are meaningless if not put to action. When you go and vote, I pray you vote for kindness, for compassion and for a nationwide community of communities that do not fear the hard work of learning how to see others.<br>Shabbat Shalom.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e72f2bfcd5cb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Yavne or Jerusalem?]]></title>
            <link>https://frutkoff.medium.com/yavne-or-jerusalem-d3ad33e3973a?source=rss-d96bf13c7a28------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3ad33e3973a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tisha-bav]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jerusalem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coexistence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interfaith]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Carmiel Frutkoff]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Jul 2020 10:35:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-20T14:43:48.937Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“What is your Jerusalem?”</em></p><p>I asked my group one morning, on an old city Jerusalem rooftop. It was a Friday in July, and we had been working on similar questions all morning. The group pondered the question for a while, and then one participant, a Muslim Palestinian teen decided to take a go at it. She spoke of her core tenets of faith. Of the role of religion in her life and of those elements that are ‘make or break’ for her. She was not off-topic, for the question was not asked superficially, but rather, Jerusalem was a metaphor for what they could never give up. The core of their very being, their redline. I was leading an interfaith group of Israelis, Palestinians and Americans on an educational journey, through the streets of our city, to that place that has no answers.</p><p>I wanted them to speak of the space where their Jerusalem’s collide — to that space in which our beliefs contradict the very essence of the other who is our neighbour.</p><p>The teens worked on it for a while, and I didn’t go easy on them; challenging each answer as they made their way into our circle. I wanted to enter that uncomfortable space where tolerance no longer informed our actions, a sphere beyond the borders of pluralism that challenges the peacemaker in every one of us. To create moments of cognitive dissonance that leave us confused and wondering about our true “ism’s” in life. When all is said and done, I wanted to know — what hierarchy of values will drive your action, what will come first? Will we follow the doctrines of our faith, or will co-existence triumph?</p><p>I was hoping to bring our conversation from the educational theory to our physical reality, to really talk about Jerusalem. But the sun was pounding down on us, and the gurgling of someone’s stomach reminded me that despite my own Spartan ways, the group needed to eat. So I let it be, and the question was left on a Jerusalem rooftop, while the rest of us went to eat lunch in the Muslim Quarter.</p><p>One thousand nine hundred fifty years ago Yohanan Ben Zakai took leave of Jerusalem. The story in the Talmud tells how he made his way out of the besieged city by faking his death and presented himself to Vespasian; the general soon to be emperor. When asked by Vespasian for his will, Ben Zakai turned his back on Jerusalem and asked for three things; the city of Yavne and her sages, the ensured survival of Rabbi Gamliel’s line and the guaranteed survival of the High Priest and his line. By doing so, the Talmudic narrative claims that he saved the Jewish people from annihilation. <br>Rabbi Akiva though disagrees and states that even the wisest of people can lose their wit at times, leading the claim along with others that Ben Zakai should not have given up on Jerusalem.</p><p>The two opinions reflet one of the great rhetorical questions; When should one persist and follow through and when should one recognize failure, cut their losses, and begin again?</p><p>While Ben Zakai chose to give up on Jerusalem and start a new, Rabbi Akiva would burn on the stake after spiritually leading the second rebellion for Jerusalem. Some applauded R. Akiva for his bravery and tenacity; others admonished him for the irresponsible exploit of leading the Jewish people; who had no significant military might, against the Roman Empire. A perhaps brave, but foolish action that led to far greater destruction and one that would put the very existence of the Jewish people at stake.</p><p>Ben Zakai, on his part, may have cut his loses. But then, led the Jewish people through one of the most significant theological reforms Judaism has ever seen — shifting the focal point of Judaism from the Temple to one focused on the study Torah, prayer and community. Words would take the place of sacrifice; Rabbis would take the place of Priests. The change would not be superficial, to say the least — It would completely change the core tenets of the faith, but many would argue that in doing so, Ben Zakai saved Judaism.</p><p>While there is much to say for compromise, one can’t help but wonder; who would we be as a nation if we always gave up on Jerusalem? Are there not times when one must stick it out and fight for what they believe in? <br>Radical compromise can often be just as devastating and also lead to Jewish demise. The Ben Zakai mindset had Jews bow their heads for the last 2000 years while suffering massacres, pogroms and the holocaust. It was the ‘Rabbi Akivas’ who blew wind into our sails and gave our people direction. It was the ‘Rabbi Akivas’ who gave shape to our redemption and led the Jewish people out of the Diaspora to a State of their own.</p><p>Ben Zakai acknowledges this possibility. Giving up on Jerusalem plagued him his entire life. It is told that on his deathbed he shared this with his disciples, pondering his actions and their consequences and concludes: <em>“Furthermore there are two roads [before me], one of Gan Eden the other of Gehenna and I do not know down which one I will be led”</em> [Berachot: 28b].</p><p>The final words to leave his lips being -</p><p><em>“Sanctify the vessels from their impurity and prepare the seat for Hezekaiya — the King of Judah who has come”.</em></p><p>While somewhat cryptic, it is clear that in his dying breath Ben Zakai was not satisfied that his compromise was warranted. Should he have fought for Jerusalem?</p><p>With his death, the Talmudic question remains open to inspire generations to come.</p><p>Yet despite his uncertainty, one would be wise to remember that we are the decedents of the ‘Ben Zakai’s’ of this world. While the ‘Rabbi Akivas’ fight and perish, it is the Ben Zakais who survive and continue the legacy.</p><p>Now it is left to me to take inspiration from Both Rabbi Akiva and Ben Zakai, to share in the uncertainty.</p><p>I am a peacemaker; I teach compromise at every turn. But I deeply believe that this process must begin by clearly defining ones Jerusalem. Only when we know who we are, understand our red lines, what we can’t compromise on, what we are willing to die for — can we begin the process of compromise and creating the reality that we want to live for.</p><p>It goes deeper still. Those who know themselves, know their borders and feel secure in them tend to be more peaceful people. In my work, I have often found that when people don’t have a base to stand on, they grow fearful, which in turn can lead to hatred and violence. We must spend the time to get to know ourselves, get to know our values, get to know our limits and limitations — we must recognize when we can’t coexist so that we might coexist.</p><p>It may sound like a contradiction, but a peacemaker must always contend with the ultimate Tisha B’av question; When do they compromise on Yavne and when do they fight for Jerusalem?</p><p>Only then, can we come together to begin rebuilding the City of Peace.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3ad33e3973a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>