<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Gijs Zwartsenberg on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Gijs Zwartsenberg on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@g.zwartsenberg?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 06:20:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@g.zwartsenberg/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why China’s 600 fte MSR program wants to cooperate with Delft TU and NRG in Petten]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/why-chinas-600-fte-msr-program-wants-to-cooperate-with-delft-tu-and-nrg-in-petten-7e103414a861?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e103414a861</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[thorium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[molten-salt-reactors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nuclear-power]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[clean-energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Apr 2018 19:07:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-25T07:38:14.968Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Sometimes, on rare occasions, I just love social media. One such occasion was when I discovered a very enthusiastic response that we got upon the publication of our article about the start of the SALIENT experiments. Now, we DID get a lot of response to that. But this one was special, as it apparently came from a professor at the Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics, SINAP. He told us that he and his colleagues were, I quote ‘very excited’ about the start of the experiments in Petten, Netherlands.</strong></p><p><strong>Now it’s one thing when Dutch experts tell you that Petten’s High Flux Reactor (HFR) has become a uniquely rare research facility in the world — due to, amongst other things, disappearance of nuclear research facilities in the West. It’s quite another thing if this assertion is confirmed by a spontaneous response from Shanghai on a publication one has posted just a few days before. So why are the Chinese researchers excited about a few crucibles of salt, presently irradiated in the HFR, Petten? Essentially, because they want to get their own stuff in. The HFR offers something that the Chinese at the present time do not have: the possibility to test materials in contact with salt in real life reactor conditions.</strong></p><p>A few months after this online encounter, we got word that three Chinese experts where going to visit the Netherlands. On the program were TU Delft and, of course, the Nuclear Research and Consulting Group, NRG, in Petten, that operates the HFR. For the Thorium MSR Foundation, this presented the ideal opportunity to learn more about the Chinese MSR program, and the visiting party immediately agreed to transform the proposed meeting into a Meet&amp;Greet with an audience, organized by the Thorium MSR Foundation.</p><p>As it turned out, the only evening available for Chinese delegation was December 5. As everybody in The Netherlands knows, the 5th of December is Santa Claus’ eve, which is a Big Family Thing in the Netherlands, so although we were only too happy with the visit, we were slightly concerned about our ability to present any visitors outside ourselves. We were wrong. After having dinner with our guests — in which we learned that the researchers at SINAP had been aware of the planned SALIENT experiments, as they had met Dutch researchers at conferences at ORNL in Oak Ridge, but had not been aware of the actual start of the experiments — more than thirty people showed up to hear what the three specialists in respectively nuclear fuel irradiations, materials irradiations and nuclear graphites were willing to share. The audience got three informative talks about the progress the specialist’s research in the context of the Chinese MSR program.</p><p>The first speaker presented an overview of the Chinese MSR program as a whole.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UKGNJGPgUoBYWBZB128-cQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>SINAP, and its predecessor SINR, has a long history of nuclear research for intance with the zero-power LWR, back in the early 70s</figcaption></figure><p>Already in the first slides, it becomes obvious that China has high ambitions regarding their future energy system. The Chinese government is dead serious about clean energy, the role therein of nuclear power in general and the role of molten salt reactors in particular.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Fy3VgsL4nSAg439vhgb_sQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Although I’m usually not a big fan of starting presentations with the buildings where the research takes place, in this case the picture is telling. Three modern buildings (the one on the top right is for the thermal hydraulics research where several salt loops are housed, the ones at the bottom are used as offices and materials research) are the home of the roughly 400 SINAP scientists that are working on molten salt reactors. Together with about 200 colleagues working on the same subject but in different institutions (source of these figures is World Nuclear, the Chinese government does not provide this information).</p><p>The presentation adds a nice historic perspective, that makes clear how the Chinese program was originally inspired by the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) in the US. The dates preceding the first Chinese efforts are 1954 (the Aircraft Reactor Experiment) and of course 1965 (Molten Salt Reactor Experiment). The Chinese then had their own molten salt reactor in 1970, the SINR Zero Power MSR experiment. Due to corrosion problems the Shanghai Institute of Nuclear Research gave up the program, and switched to the Light Water Reactor, in line with the worldwide developments of the time. <br> The corrosion issue is interesting, as the MSRE reported no such problems, even after 4 years of operation. The explanation may be a simple one: molten salts at high temperatures need to be kept under inert atmosphere at all times. As long as that condition is fulfilled, the salt is not very corrosive. It’s not the salt that causes the trouble, but the oxygen and any water vapor that may be in the air. The confusion about whether the salt is or is not corrosive is widespread.</p><p>Not much later, in the early 70s, China’s first Light Water Reactor was developed by SINR. For 40 years, the MSR program was suspended. Then, in 2002, the MSR was appointed as one of the concepts of Generation IV. And in 2011, China re-embarked on the MSR-quest. I remember reading a post by Kirk Sorensen around 2010, that his webmaster told him that ‘somebody in China is downloading all our documents’. No offence to the Chinese, researchers at NRG in the Netherlands have done the same thing. Kirk Sorensen’s initiative to publish the old Oak Ridge reports online will one day be in the history books of both China and the West.</p><h3>300 GW of nuclear power by 2030</h3><p>The development of the Chinese MSR needs to be placed within the context of China’s ambition to realize clean electric power on an unprecedented scale. Presently, the country is already generating 1500 GW’s of electricity (2015 figures). In 2016, the share of nuclear energy in the mix was 3,56 per cent. By 2030, China wants this percentage to be raised to 10 per cent nuclear. By that time, the total output of China’s electricity system is targeted at 3000 GW. If we recalculate this to 1GW plants, by the year 2030, 300 nuclear power plants will be spinning out clean power in China. The researcher remarks that he expects the percentage will be higher than this 10%. And although after Fukushima, the Chinese public has been doubtful about their acceptance of nuclear power, according to the presenter, this attitude has been changing a lot in favor of nuclear. For obvious reasons: the Chinese public is just fed up with having to breathe air that is brown from coal pollution. And power from sun and wind is not constant enough, is the straightforward assessment the researcher makes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pflXWmSMKvjqIpRISO2hjQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>China’s nuclear ambitions: electricity supply will go up from 1500 GW in 2015 to 3000 GW in 2030. In 2030, the share of nuclear will have grown from 3,56% in 2015 to 10%. This means that about 2/3 of China’s nuclear power plants in 2030 will be new ones, an addition of about 200 GW in just over 10 years. Using thorium is crucial, because China’s domestic reserves of uranium are limited.</figcaption></figure><p>But China has a challenge. If all those 300+ gigawatts of nuclear energy are to be produced by uranium in light water reactors, China will depend heavily on imports of huge amounts of uranium. And although China has large reserves of a wide variety of minerals, its uranium inventory is limited. The graph presented speaks clearly on China’s hunger for uranium. Here’s where the thorium comes in. A big reason for China to embark on the development of thorium molten salt reactors is to save on uranium imports. The thorium reserves of China are estimated to be above 280,000 tons. While that number may not appear to be large, a ton of natural thorium in an MSR in principle could produce 100 times the energy of a ton of natural uranium in a light water reactor. This means that thorium could really become the alternative fuel for nuclear power in China.</p><h3>Two MSR-concepts under development, one with solid, one with liquid fuel</h3><p>Starting in 2010, China is now working on two very different thorium based molten salt reactor programs. One is based on liquid fuel, the other on molten salt cooled solid fuel. Both are designed for specific application areas.</p><p>The solid fuel MSR, named ThMSR-SF, is a high temperature reactor, intended for industrial heat, hydrogen-production and electricity production. The ThMSR-SF uses fuel pebbles similar to the ones we know from the gas-cooled High Temperature Reactors. The difference is that in the ThMSR-SF the fuel pebbles are cooled by molten salt. One area of research is the optimization of the fuel elements. The pebbles are graphite spheres that contain solid fuel kernels, of which several compositions are tested, including thorium kernels.</p><p>The liquid fuel MSR, named ThMSR-LF, is optimized for the use of thorium. Key to realizing a closed fuel cycle, thus unlocking the full thorium potential, requires mastering the salt chemistry. Adequate salt cleaning is even a prerequisite for the establishment of a closed thorium fuel cycle.</p><p>The Chinese development plan for the chemistry of the salt cleaning processes has three distinctive phases. The first phase is the deployment of an online batch process. Here the fuel cycle starts with fuel loading based on low enriched uranium and thorium. There will be online refueling and removal of gaseous fission products, and after several years of operation, the whole core fuel salt will be discharged. Uranium and thorium will be extracted and reloaded to the reactor core. Fission products and minor actinides will be temporarily stored.</p><p>In the next stage, the online removal of gaseous fission products will be continued, added will be online extraction and reloading of uranium to enhance the fuel utilization ratio. Fission products and minor actinides will still be stored temporarily.</p><p>In the third stage, a fully closed fuel cycle will be realized. The researchers foresee offline extraction of transuranics, that will be reloaded to the reactor. This may evolve into a full recycling mode in which all heavy elements are recycled until they fission. Once this is realized, geologic disposal will be limited to fission products and small amounts of uranium and minor actinides, basically limited to losses in the reprocessing.</p><h3>How the future is created in China</h3><p>SINAP is investigating some remarkable techniques to realize the objectives described, like the use of fluorination for uranium recovery, combined with frozen-wall technique to mitigate corrosion, due to free fluorine (F2) during the fluorination process. The frozen wall technique basically means having some salt freeze on the reactor or piping walls, thus protecting the walls from free fluorine during periods of fluorination. Another area of interest is the demonstration of salt distillation, intended for carrier salt purification. FLiBe salt (a mixture of lithium and beryllium fluorides), especially when made from enriched Li7, is expensive, and the researchers want to demonstrate a controllable distillation device that is capable of processing several kg salt per hour, in which most neutron poisons can be reduced with a factor of hundred. Another promising technology is electrochemical separation for uranium recovery. Electro-deposition of uranium metal from the FLiBe-melt can yield a separation ratio of more than 99%.</p><h3>Introducing China’s ‘homemade’ alloy for molten salt reactors</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6nzhsCjaVZGdNuo6MBxRQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Santa Claus outcompeted by three Chinese presentations on molten salt reactors.</figcaption></figure><p>The next presenter specializes on materials irradiation. The presentation expands on how tests are conducted on alloys, graphites and composites. China has already developed what this researcher calls a ‘homemade’ version of the nickle based alloy for molten salt reactor named GH3535. All of the materials investigated are tested on aspects like strength, embrittlement, creep and swelling.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/212/1*geSMIRVzUOZFVI0dZiXqQA.png" /><figcaption>Pipes made of the Chinese ‘homemade’ nickel alloy</figcaption></figure><p>The nickel alloy is, according to the researcher, quite similar to the original Hastelloy, but there’s differences in for instance trace elements. The group has already discovered that the amount of trace elements in the composition has considerable influence on the susceptibility to corrosion. Also, in corrosion tests it became clear that the presence of certain impurities in the salt had a big influence on its corrosive behavior. The Chinese have much confidence in the quality of their material, and their ability to produce the components from it. As proof, pictures are presented of GH3535 plates, piping and tubes.</p><h3>Why the Chinese are excited about ‘Petten’</h3><p>Irradiation tests have also started for the Chinese program, but still at low doses: graphites have been irradiated at temperatures of 650C. It’s the low dose of the presented tests that explain the enthusiasm of the Shanghai researchers about the start of the experiments at the HFR in Petten. Here, the neutron flux is about 20 to 40 times higher (about 2,5*10²¹ neutrons/cm2), plus the fact that the irradiation in Petten is done in combination with actual fission.</p><p>It is clear the Chinese researchers are as passionate about creating a future of clean energy as their colleagues in the West are. The researcher expresses this by a little poem, with which the presentation is finished:</p><p>To see a world in a grain of atom<br> And a blue light in a reactor<br> Hold infinity in the palm of your hand<br> And the energy for the future.</p><h3>The ASTM paragraph on nuclear graphites</h3><p>As everybody with a more than superficial knowledge of molten salt reactors is aware of, the graphite is one of the most challenging subjects in materials development for the MSR.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/956/1*X2WWnT_72a4L_jA6aDYUZg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Nuclear graphites (right) and glove boxes at the testing facility (left)</figcaption></figure><p>The graphite is a necessary component of molten salt reactors that operate in the thermal spectrum. The operation of this type of reactor depends on the slowing down of neutrons, in the nuclear jargon these are called ‘thermal’ neutrons. In the ‘neutron economy’, many processes are counter intuitive, and this is one of them: slower neutrons are better in causing certain elements to fission. The graphite is what is called a ‘neutron moderator’: it slows them down. In many ways, graphite is an ideal material to use in combination with molten salt: it can endure incredibly high temperatures, and is virtually insensitive to the chemicals in the melt. It also has some properties that make it challenging to use. One of these is its brittleness, the other is its peculiar behavior in a neutron field: after long periods of irradiation, the graphite tends to first shrink, then swell. And although these properties can be compensated for in appropriate use — think of structural design and periodic replacement — the properties themselves also depend of the grade of graphite that is used and need to be well known.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*afS2HCGwYC0fcKWI7MiTVA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Comparing the graphite grades</figcaption></figure><p>In his presentation, the third of the three researchers mainly focusses on nuclear graphite. He immediately confirms China’s dedication to develop the first molten salt reactors: two brand new grades of nuclear graphite, simply called Graphite A and Graphite B, have already been developed for the molten salt reactor. One crucial aspect of these new graphites is their pore size: industrial graphite is porous, and the pore size matters, because the pores should be small enough to prevent any salt from entering. The Chinese researchers have discovered that to achieve this, the mean pore size should be under 0.9 micron. Both of the new Chinese graphites meet this standard: graphite A averages on 0.8 micron, graphite B on 0.7 micron. Both satisfy the size requirements; D. the graphite research team is assessing their other relevant properties, like their heat conductivity and tensile strength.</p><h3>“Presently, only NRG can do irradiation tests at high enough neutron dose with molten salt.”</h3><p>In his presentation, the researcher reveals China’s role in the nuclear world order: SINAP is rewriting the relevant chapter on nuclear graphites in ASME, and is setting new ASTM standards, for instance for testing impregnation of nuclear graphite by molten salt. ASME and ASTM are, shortly put, the worldwide reference standards describing materials properties for engineering applications. The fact that the Chinese are now adding new entries to the chapter on nuclear materials, illustrates how the center of gravity in nuclear development is shifting from the West to non-Western countries. As for the graphite for molten salt reactors, it’s not just pore size and pressure that determines how well the graphite resists the salt. It’s also the behavior of the graphite in a high neutron flux that will ultimately determine the technical lifetime of the moderator. After this presentation, the audience, aware of the challenges that the material incorporates for the design process of the liquid fuel reactor, poses many questions about the graphite. Whether the researchers think it’s possible to make the graphite strong enough, what shape it should be, and what lifetime they are counting on. The researchers agree that the material is a challenge. “It’s difficult”, says the Chinese specialist. “With a nuclear reactor, safety is an absolute necessity.” And apparently, this is exactly the reason for visiting NRG. “Presently, only NRG can do graphite irradiation tests at high enough neutron dose in combination with molten salt.”</p><p>In other words, the complex behavior of graphite can only be tested in real life reactor conditions, which means testing in a high flux materials test reactor, and in the presence of a molten salt stream that contains all the fission products that will be produced in an operating reactor. Petten’s HFR can offer all these conditions: the reactor offers a high flux, and its Pool Side Facility offers the space to place big experimental objects, like the LUMOS-loop that NRG is designing, in which molten salt reactor conditions can be integrally created. And thanks to the HFR’s high flux, a year in the test reactor can model ten years of reactor life: a feature that can save a lot of development time.</p><h3>Chinese researchers see broad cooperation possibilities between the Chinese MSR program, NRG and TUD</h3><p>At the date of the presentation, the Chinese delegation had not yet visited NRG: the Meet&amp;Greet took place on Tuesday, the visit to NRG was scheduled for Wednesday and Thursday, and the flight back home on Friday was early, so the possibility to have an after-talk was limited. But the Chinese delegation told us they see broad possibilities for cooperation between them and the Dutch research that takes place at TU Delft and NRG. But on Tuesday evening, he was not yet able to give details about specifics of this cooperation. Fortunately, for the time being, the Dutch-Chinese cooperation is already possible and relevant within the context of the SALIENT experiments. Fortunate in any case for the readers, that is, as SALIENT is funded by public money and hence everything about SALIENT is, in principle, public knowledge. Senior researcher Ralph Hania confirms that the Chinese ‘homemade’ nickle based alloy will be part of near future SALIENT experiments. As for the two new nuclear graphites, he is not yet able to confirm this, as the Chinese graphite would have to fit into a limited irradiation schedule.</p><p>Although, as an afterthought, I’m pretty confident that the Dutch researchers can’t wait to see how these graphites perform in the conditions only the HFR can offer.</p><p>And I’m pretty sure the Chinese researchers can’t wait either…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e103414a861" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/why-chinas-600-fte-msr-program-wants-to-cooperate-with-delft-tu-and-nrg-in-petten-7e103414a861">Why China’s 600 fte MSR program wants to cooperate with Delft TU and NRG in Petten</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[LUMOS, Lasers and Red Hot FLiNaK]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/lumos-lasers-and-red-hot-flinak-1fefde23b016?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1fefde23b016</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[molten-salt-reactors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thorium-msr-foundation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thorium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[copenhagen-atomics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Dec 2017 19:50:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-06T13:33:22.249Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Applause for a bucket full of salt — the LIVE world premiere of Copenhagen Atomics’ Molten Salt Loop</h3><p><strong>An uncommon combination of presentations deserves an uncommon report: we give you the highlights of an afternoon organized by the Thorium MSR Foundation that was packed with presentations, in an almost full-house in the big meeting room of The Buccaneer — a rustic former army storehouse at the center of Delft, that now serves as a meeting place for innovative green technology.</strong></p><p><strong>Judging by the audience’s response, it was quite clear that the those present agreed that the thorium-MSR option more than deserves a green label. The overall message from the audience, that included a considerable share of ‘newbies’, was very clear: let’s start DOING this!</strong></p><p><strong>Report of a vibrant Meet&amp;Greet at The Buccaneer, Delft, November 19, 2017</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v0YgOZ0ZwtmVPh-zyRZ_Mw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ralph Hania, Chief researcher of the MSR-program at the Nuclear Research and Consultancy Group (NRG) in Petten, Netherlands, discusses the hurdles to be taken</figcaption></figure><p>Since it’s impractical to fully cover all presentations, in this article we’ll focus on two contributions. The first is Ralph Hania’s (NRG) update on the SALIENT experiment. The second is live demo of two technologies by Copenhagen Atomics: LIBS detection of chemical elements and a live demonstration of their low-cost molten salt loop. As for the other presentations: Theo Wolters’ ‘Thorium for Newbies’ will be published as a video compilation. Yours truly’s presentation on the Dutch Initiative on Thorium Molten Salts (DIMOS) will be worked out in a separate article.</p><p>The statement made by liberal politician Sylvia Hosman can be read <a href="http://www.daretothink.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Statement-Sylvia-Hosman-MG-Delft-19112017.pdf">here</a>. In essence, Hosman says her party VVD, and many other politicians, are following the thorium-MSR developments with great interest.</p><h3>SALIENT update: it’s going fine, more irradiations scheduled</h3><p>SALIENT is short for a series of Salt Irradiation Experiments, and if you want to read a full scope article on this series, you can do that <a href="https://articles.thmsr.nl/petten-has-started-world-s-first-thorium-msr-specific-irradiation-experiments-in-45-years-ff8351fce5d2">here</a>. Chief researcher of the MSR-program at the Nuclear Research and Consultancy Group (NRG) in Petten, Netherlands, is Ralph Hania. The essence of his update on SALIENT-1 could be a short SMS: ‘It’s going fine’. That means, at the present time, that the temperature in the experiments shows the values that were expected.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/258/1*zqxpnK2r268ZRnWMw28Oiw.png" /><figcaption>The graph shows the expected power production within the samples, due to fission of U233, that’s been bred from thorium and can fission if it catches a neutron that comes from the HFR core (days on the horizontal axis, watts per gram on the vertical)</figcaption></figure><p>During the irradiation of SALIENT-01, only the temperature will be monitored. When the SALIENT-01 irradiation is finished, after about 2 years, the tubes will be transported to a hot cell. There, the tubes will be punctured and the gaseous fission products will be measured (expected: xenon and krypton). Next the salt, graphite, and metals will be examined with electron microscopy. In a next step the salts will be fully vaporized to get a full picture of the composition.</p><p>Hania finished his presentation with a preview of further experiments. A new element in the program is that the SALIENT experiments, that take place in the neutron flux of the HFR, will be complemented with gamma-only-irradiation of salts. These ‘SAGA’ experiments, designed to take place in the spent fuel pool of the HFR, should cast light on the radiolysis of fluor salts in gamma radiation. For these experiments, NRG will also be cooperating with Research Center Řež, located in Husinec in the Czech Republic. The next SALIENT is expected for 2019, and will focus on in-pile alloy corrosion. Hastelloy will be part of this test. Until recently, this would be Hastelloy from the Czech Republic, but since the recent visit of researchers from SINAP, Chinese Hastelloy N will be included as well. [Text continues below picture]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9t-zGDv765WxJ9nz7joPxg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Overview of the HFR pool, with the reactor on the bottom of the picture, with the Cherenkov light emanating from the core.</figcaption></figure><h3>LUMOS: modelling an MSR in a loop-type nuclear test</h3><p>However, the experiment that everybody is most eager to see happening but that is still on the drawing board is LUMOS: an in-pool loop positioned directly next to High Flux Reactor core wall. That is to say, on the Pool Side Facility.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/299/1*KJTxFyVFjjad-NSsslcrdw.png" /><figcaption>The Pool Side Facility or in short PSF is a ‘balcony’ outside the HFR core. To the left, a schematic drawing, to the right a photograph from above. The PSF allows the placement of large objects in a high neutron flux.</figcaption></figure><p>The LUMOS loop essentially allows the experimenters to mimic reactor conditions including fissioning of U233 in a moving salt stream. The LUMOS experiment mimics an MSR loop in a materials test reactor. The loop can provide data and information of flowing salt in an irradiation field, in contact with core materials. It will provide representative data including all of MSR’s complexities. This may help shortening development times, as proper data can be used to finalise designs. It could even be required to enable a successful licensing process, of course depending on the MSR design to be realised. In short, realising LUMOS will make a big difference in the development process of the molten salt reactor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/203/1*9rwZevI9ruHI8ECNZ2855w.png" /><figcaption>Schematic drawing of the LUMOS experiment, a loop-shaped molten salt flow, in which neutrons from the HFR core cause fission reactions in fissile materials in the salt. (LUMOS is short for the modest description chosen for the experiment: Learning to Use MOlten Salts. ‘Lumos’ is also the magic spell in the Harry Potter novels, used by wizzards in need of light in the darkness-GZ)</figcaption></figure><p>The SALIENT experiments provide knowledge that will help LUMOS to be succesful. Main parameters of the LUMOS experiment are:<br>•Actinide bearing FLIBE salt (~20 L)<br>•Alloy N first containment<br>•Power: 125 kW (initial)<br>•Power density: 100–180 W/cc<br>•Flow rate: ≤3 m/s<br>•ΔT: ≤100 oC<br>•5–6 operational years targeted]</p><p>With LUMOS, the experimenters aim for a setup that does not require materials qualifications that would have to be approved before the experiment is allowed by the regulator. This is the reason to design the experiment with a triple barrier (visible in the picture on the rigth), ​and to plan non-nuclear out-of-pile tests​ ​​that precede the actual experiment.</p><h3>Copenhagen Atomics flashes the LIBS laser…</h3><p>Copenhagen Atomics has been drawing quite some attention in recent years. First by presenting novel concepts for molten salt reactors like the Copenhagen Waste Burner, and later shifting their focus on partial technologies that may be key to successfully realizing full control and safety in the chemical processes of MSR’s. As a company, Copenhagen Atomics is a remarkable combination of MSR-advocacy and a young and enthusiastic high-tech startup. Most of the owners and employees have double jobs in order to be able to work on the technology of which each thinks it is of paramount importance for realizing a CO2-free energy system. Many of the team have their ‘first job’ in tech research, and have access to labs and equipment that support their MSR-research. Apparently, this allows the Copenhagen Atomics team to practice the kind of unconventional thinking that can make a difference.</p><p>An example is their Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy, LIBS in short, that got them a seat at the table of the SALIENT team. At their first presentation of the LIBS technology in Petten, in the spring of 2016, the experts at NRG immediately saw the relevance of the ability to do in-line measurement of trace elements in the melt in very low concentrations, without the need to first isolate samples. At the occasion, Thomas Steenberg showed the LIBS-graphs, in which even different isotopes of one element could be easily distinguished. The conversation immediately shifted: from whether the LIBS technology was relevant to MSR-research, to how the SALIENT experiments could benefit from the LIBS the technology.</p><p>In his presentation Thomas Steenberg, CEO of CA, chemical engineer with 20 yrs of experience with industrial R&amp;D and startups, explains that no matter how safely an MSR is build, the operator will want to know what is going on chemically inside the reactor. And the LIBS technology gives access to that knowledge, by just shooting laser pulses at sample material and reading the light that returns. The material can be liquid, such as a salt melt — or a solid. This type of sampling can be done from a safe distance, even if the sampled material is highly radioactive. Also, it does not require the collection of hazardous materials.</p><p>For the demonstration at the Buccaneer, Steenberg has brought a piece of a MoNiCr a ‘modern’ version of Hastelloy, the nickel alloy that was used in the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment in the 1960s, and that is expected to be the choice material for the first MSR’s that will be build. Steenberg only has two pairs of safety goggles for the demo, but his team has built an ingenious construction that allows the other hundred people in the room to look through the second pair of goggles…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/260/1*iuooxd1ol8J0f_LNRsEvrg.png" /><figcaption>Thomas Steenberg pointing out the detection of U235 and U238</figcaption></figure><p>Steenberg shows the result of several measurements, including one in a thorium sample. One of the remarkable features of the LIBS technology is that it can distinguish between isotopes. This provides early insight into anything that is going on inside the reactor. Any changes in composition of the melt will be detected instantly. Regardless whether the cause is corrosion, removal or addition of fissile material or just the burnup of material and the rise or fall of certain fission products, in relation to parameters like the power output of the reactor.</p><h3>…and demonstrates their salt loop, now available on Amazon.com</h3><p>It was up to Thomas Jam Pedersen of Copenhagen Atomics to introduce the spectacle piece of the afternoon: the first live public presentation of a molten salt loop.</p><p>In a foreword, Thomas Jam answered the question he is asked so often in what he calls ‘strongly antinuclear’ Denmark: why on earth is he is doing this, dedicating just about all of his free time to the development of a nuclear technology. To these people, he points out that about 80 million more people are born on this planet every year. Prosperity and education are known to bring down population growth rates, and prosperity and energy consumption are closely linked. The energy reality is that a liter of gasoline, without taxes, has about the same consumer price as that of a liter of unbranded cola.<br>[article continues below picture]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nLU6-XWM0ppQjG3R6fw1oQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Thomas Jam Pedersen: At the present time, one billion people use about half of the energy worldwide. Billions of people are eager to get to the same prosperity levels as we in the west have.</figcaption></figure><p>As billions of people are struggling to get out of poverty, and as cheap fossil energy is their only route to succeed, no government in those countries can effectively prevent continued growth of the use of fossil energy.</p><p>According to Thomas Jam Pedersen, this fact is completely ignored in the energy debates that are fiercely fought over in the west. If the world wants to move away from fossil fuels, is Pedersen’s message, we should come up with a better alternative. And the molten salt reactor may offer a road to this better alternative: clean energy that’s cheaper than coal.</p><p>To realize this vision, Copenhagen Atomics chooses the path of practical experimentation. The development of a low cost molten salt research loop, intended for investigation of salt fluid dynamics, fits CA’s overall strategy to develop partial technologies that pushes the investigation forward. The loop is intended for non-nuclear investigation of molten salt fluid thermodynamics, and it’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B077782YD6/">available on Amazon.com</a>.</p><p>The outside of the version presented at the Buccaneer consists of two stainless steel barrels, with insulated conduct on top. Inside the barrels are two heavily insulated smaller containers of 50 liters each. One of these invisible containers is loaded with salt — in the demo it is a mixture of lithium fluoride, sodium fluoride and potassium fluoride also known as FLiNaK. The melt has to be kept under argon atmosphere all the time, because at the temperatures that are used (500–700C) any oxygen in the salt makes the mixture corrosive.</p><p>This is a point that Thomas Steenberg stresses: the salt mixture itself is NOT corrosive, but only BECOMES corrosive from contaminations with oxygen, free fluorine or water. So the key to prevent corrosion is to prevent these materials from entering the salt, hence the use of argon as a protective layer.</p><h3>Behold the sound of hot, flowing liquid salt!</h3><p>Preceding the demo, Copenhagen Atomics had to send the loop by road transport from Copenhagen to Delft, and the team only had a brief time for testing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NlLDSd3iX0tuoVXSyC7C7w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Thomas Jam Pedersen of Copenhagen Atomics, filmed by Jan Leen Kloosterman and Gordon McDowell, during the test run on Friday the 17th, preceding the live demo on Sunday</figcaption></figure><p>Although the test was successful — and witnessed by TU Delft MSR researchers that were unable to attend the afternoon meeting at the Buccaneer — later that evening, a valve appeared to be stuck and a replacement part couldn’t arrive in time for the Sunday demo. All of this info would have been rather irrelevant if it wouldn’t have led to the outcome that Copenhagen Atomics’ Aslak Stubsgaard, in charge of the demo, could only move the salt once. This, however, turned out to substantially add to the attraction level of the demo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*01ApgU2bgZ-kBcdDera_hQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Aslak Stubsgaard doing the live demo on Sunday 20171119, that can be watched at: <a href="https://youtu.be/864G55az4dg">https://youtu.be/864G55az4dg</a></figcaption></figure><p>In the audience that had been told it would only get a single chance to see and actually hear the salt moving, anticipation builds up as Stubsgaard explains the setup in the big garage on the other side of the courtyard. The salt mixture, at temperature of about 500C, has a viscosity of milk, Stubsgaard explains. At 700C, the viscosity is that of water. Molten FLiNaK salt at this temperature is really fluent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/245/1*cr1X6y_melNCbQYUWkwPZA.png" /><figcaption>Still from the close-up video, filmed by Thomas Jam Pedersen: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXI82IWOm9Q&amp;feature=youtu.be">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXI82IWOm9Q&amp;feature=youtu.be</a></figcaption></figure><p>The only way to catch a glimpse of the faintly glowing liquid salt, is to look through a little window in the container. And as only one or two people could stick their head in the required position, Thomas Jam Pedersen films through one of the glass panels and screens it, so everybody can watch. After silently waiting in a darkened garage for what seems like several minutes, the audience actually hears the flowing of a liquid, accompanied by the faint red glow on a computer screen of a jet of liquid salt.</p><p>The assembled crowd cheers and applauds upon hearing it. Yes, it’s a small movement for a bucket full of FLiNak salt. But maybe one day it will be a giant leap for mankind.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1fefde23b016" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/lumos-lasers-and-red-hot-flinak-1fefde23b016">LUMOS, Lasers and Red Hot FLiNaK</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Petten’ has started world’s first 
 MSR-specific thorium fuel irradiation experiments in 45 years]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/petten-has-started-world-s-first-thorium-msr-specific-irradiation-experiments-in-45-years-ff8351fce5d2?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff8351fce5d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[thorium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[molten-salt-reactors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Aug 2017 09:20:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-25T07:32:08.799Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>On August 10, 2017, a set of concentric sealed tubes was entered into the core of the High Flux Reactor in Petten, Netherlands. In the smallest of these tubes sits an even smaller set of four graphite crucibles, containing a mixture of salts: lithium fluoride and thorium fluoride.</strong></p><p><strong>The radiation in the core will provide the heat for the salt sample in the inner tube to melt. Within the salt mixture, due to the presence of thorium in the high neutron flux, over time a fission reaction will start. And although the outer tube is in contact with the hand-warm water of the reactor basin, the concentric set of tubes provides enough insulation to let the temperature of the salt raise to about 620 degrees Celcius.</strong></p><p>This tiny set of crucibles is the world´s first molten-salt-reactor-related fission experiment in over 45 years. The experiments have been initiated by the Nuclear Research and Consulting Group (NRG) in Petten, Netherlands, and take place at the High Flux Reactor (HFR), the research reactor that NRG operates.</p><p>Sander de Groot of NRG explains that the interest for MSR’s at NRG originated while working on several large scale programs, dedicated to the High Temperature Reactor (HTR) and transmutation of long-living radioactive waste. “There was both internal and external support for our idea to start the SALIENT experiments”, he says. “This is a technology with much potential for large scale energy production. It offers the perspective of a technology suitable for a responsible energy system that is clean, affordable, reliable and safe. It is in principle the safest and most resource efficient solution in nuclear energy. The Netherlands is well positioned to contribute to international R&amp;D towards the realization of the MSR. The program also gave us the opportunity to cooperate with JRC Karlsruhe, a cooperation that we see as very important.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/1*A19AFaSlpH1eqY5yovwnFQ.png" /><figcaption>The research area in Petten, in the north-west of the Netherlands, that houses (amongst others) NRG. The bigger white dot left of the middle of the picture is the dome of the HFR. In the upper left corner the North Sea.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zx9qHW1JzwZ0TKIiWP17oA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sander de Groot (l) and Ralph Hania, neither wanting to take the credits</figcaption></figure><p>Nuclear fuels expert Ralph Hania is the lead scientists at NRG for the SALIENT experiments. For thmsr.nl he explains the experiment, that has its name derived from SALt Irradiation ExperimeNT. And because NRG is planning a series of comparable experiments, this first one is simply called <br> SALIENT-1. The next ones are on the drawing board.</p><p>GZ <em>What would you say is the importance of the SALIENT experiments?</em></p><p>RH First of all, SALIENT is a way to build up experience with the use of fission fuel in the form of a molten salt. That hasn’t been done for decades and we’re also doing it to train ourselves. It’s important to notice that SALIENT is not a single experiment but really a series, and we’ll build that up step by step. On the other hand, it is fundamental research, in which we look at the behavior of salt and the fission products that are formed in the salts.</p><p>In this project, we closely cooperate with JRC Karlsruhe. We need highly purified salts for SALIENT, and JRC is one of the very few places in the world that have the expertise to produce them. Here at NRG, we designed the irradiation part of the experiments. After the irradiation, we will send back part of the samples to JRC, and they will be doing several tests, like finding out how stable the fission products are in the salt.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/454/1*zMFfjkGiYrylFsJ3HkemLw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Filling of crucible with sample salt at JRC Karlsruhe</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/739/1*C8I8C6U9WDoTTASeMgploA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Assembly of sample holder at NRG</figcaption></figure><h3>SALIENT-1: lithium fluoride and thorium fluoride in graphite crucibles</h3><p>GZ <em>Why did you choose the lithiumfluoride/thoriumfluoride mixture as a start for your experiments?</em></p><p>RH That was the salt of choice for the Molten Salt Fast Reactor (MSFR), a European concept for a waste-burning MSR. For SALIENT-02, we will use a different mixture that will also contain beryllium, forming a mixture also known as FliBe, and uranium as the fuel. And we are already considering further experiments, that will focus more on the interaction between the salt and the containment materials. Corrosion resistance is very important for those materials: they should be mechanically strong, and able to resist chemical corrosion and intense radiation. This corrosion resistance will be the next focus of the experiments.</p><p>GZ <em>Could you describe the setup of SALIENT-01?</em></p><p>RH At the heart of salient 1 are four small crucibles that contain the LiF/ThF mixture. They are placed within a set of concentric steel tubes of about 50 cm high. At the start of the experiment, we will bring this tube in a selected radiation field of the High Flux Reactor. After a while, thorium will be transmuting to uranium and the uranium will start to fission. The salt content of the 4 crucibles is identical at the start, but within one we will place a small nickel sponge, and in another one is a nickel foil. During the fission reaction, fission products will form and a part of these are noble metals. We want to find out if these noble metals precipitate preferentially on the nickel.</p><p>GZ <em>Ah, I see. The forming of noble metals is one aspect that needs to be managed in the salt stream of MSR’s. And one proposed way to remove them is the use of nickel sponges. The idea is that the sponge with the noble metal can be replaced periodically…</em></p><p>RH Yes.</p><p>GZ <em>And the pipes themselves, what are they made of?</em></p><p>RH Well, of course they must meet all kinds of requirements, but we’ve made them out of ordinary steel. The idea is to stick to standard materials wherever possible.</p><p>GZ <em>Some of the startups are considering to use steel for their vessels. It’s interesting that you use it for the experiments.</em></p><p>RH Well, as a reactor vessel material the suitability of steel remains to be determined. Corrosion may be a problem there, and we do not yet know if we can manage that by managing the salt chemistry. The high temperatures in MSRs might also be problematic, even if the pressure inside the system is low.</p><h3>Corrosion tests, including molybdenum alloy, starting at SALIENT 3&amp;4</h3><p>GZ <em>Earlier this year I spoke with electrochemist Thomas Steenberg of Copenhagen Atomics. In his view what is needed is adequate management of the redox potential of the salt. If this is done properly, corrosiveness may not be an issue.</em></p><p>RH He may well be right about that. Even for steel, corrosion may be acceptable, but further investigation is needed. Also, for the purpose of building a reactor, different off-normal situations will have to be covered in addition to normal operation. In later SALIENT tests, the focus shifts from the salt to the interaction between the salt and possible reactor vessel materials, especially corrosion.</p><p>GZ <em>What materials will you be looking at?</em></p><p>RH For later SALIENT experiments we are planning to do irradiation tests for 316 stainless steel, Hastelloy, the nickel alloy that ORNL used in the 1960s, and TZM — the latter is a titanium/zirconium/molybdenum alloy.</p><p>GZ <em>Wow, that is going to be interesting! I’ve heard many times that molybdenum may be the ideal reactor material, but nobody has really tested it.</em></p><p>RH It’s true that we could find virtually no experimental data for molybdenum applications in the temperature range in which we intend to test. Neutronically, molybdenum looks much more attractive than nickel.</p><h3>Petten’s unique facilities</h3><p>GZ <em>One of the things I’ve been told about the SALIENT is that these experiments can presently only be done here in Petten. That is quite an amazing claim. Is this true and if so, why?</em></p><p>RH To start with, there is only a limited set of materials test reactors in the world. And only a subset of these can be used for the study of nuclear fuels. And the HFR happens to have a facility for placing larger objects in a high neutron flux zone. That is not yet relevant for the SALIENT experiments, but it will become relevant in a later stage, in which we want to place ‘loop type’ molten salt experiments that can model the dynamic system of a molten salt reactor. This is a unique facility that will offer us the chance to substantially speed up the process of developing a molten salt reactor.</p><p>The main reason that fuel experiments can be done only in a few places is the infrastructure that is needed to handle experimental nuclear fuels. In materials irradiations the neutron irradiation will change some elements, but they usually don’t create alpha-emitters. Fuels are a completely different ballgame, that requires a highly specialized additional infrastructure. The point is, once you start fission experiments, you produce fission products and alpha-emitters. Both produce lots of radiation, are hazardous and contagious, and safe handling requires specialized labs that must comply with very strict regulations. That means amongst other things that you need facilities with a wider range of ‘hot cell facilities’, that will allow you to safely handle the samples. And not only that, you also need special other cells that will allow you to completely clean and decontaminate all the materials you’ve worked with, and safely collect and ultimately deposit them. So you need to have the whole ‘train’, all the steps from start to end. And we’re fortunate enough to have all these facilities here in Petten. In the United States, France and perhaps Japan, there are National Labs with materials test reactors that also have the required infrastructure for doing SALIENT type experiments. If these countries would focus on molten salt development, they could definitely do it as well.</p><p>Another thing is that you need a regulator that has some flexibility. What we are doing here is new, it hasn’t been done before. If you have a regulator that simply says ‘this is something we don’t know, we won’t allow you to do it’, than you cannot possibly innovate. We have the good fortune of having a regulator that we can communicate with. That is not to say they’re not strict, they are! Even though we only use a couple of cm3 of salt, they checked every detail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/399/1*SvRJfrBqrdFdkh56L3Hb2A.jpeg" /><figcaption>SALIENT will take place in the High Flux Reactor in Petten, Netherlands. The drawing on the left shows the structure of the reactor building with in the center the reactor pool, containing the core.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/133/1*jiTC0UdqYuCqjfzCveGGfA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The pool, with at the bottom the Cherenkov-light that surrounds the reactor core</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*B08HZhbdfeivos6L8W3C4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>The ‘checkerboard’ displaying the topography of the reactor core, seen from above. The zones on the left of the ‘checkerboard’ form a ‘pool side facility’ that will become relevant in a next phase of experimentation. This pool side facility is a high flux region on the outside of the reactor core with enough room to accommodate a larger molten salt reactor experiment, in which a ‘salt loop’ can be tested. The intention is to fill this ‘salt loop’ with molten salt fuel. Due to the high neutron flux, a fission reaction will start and the loop will become a test scale molten salt reactor. This pool side facility of the HFR is unique. If the loop experiment proves feasible, this will give the Netherlands a head-start in molten salt reactor development.</figcaption></figure><p>GZ <em>What about the Chinese, they have been assigning several hundred millions to MSR programs…</em></p><p>RH In their case, the main question is when they are going to have a suitable materials test reactor ready for such experiments. Presently, they don’t have that.</p><h3>Waste treatment and lithium recovery</h3><p>Future MSR’s are expected to have superior waste properties. This will depend on chemical processes in which fission products can be separated from usable fuel. In molten salt reactors, fission products are the only component that can be called ‘waste’ — all the so called ‘actinides’, the heavy fissionable nuclei, can in principle be recycled back into the reactor core until they fission.</p><p>However, these reprocessing facilities need to be developed step by step and are not available at this stage of development. That also means that in the irradiation phase of the SALIENT experiments, the small amount of salt that has been tested will, after it has been carefully investigated, have to be disposed of. And in the case of nuclear waste, regulations require that even cubic centimeters of waste come with a disposal plan.</p><p>The NRG team took the opportunity to define several suitable options, and this development process already produced some valuable insights.</p><p>GZ <em>The interesting thing is that regarding the waste, SALIENT-01 already goes a significant step further than the Oak Ridge experiments in the 1960s.</em></p><p>RH Yes, by starting the SALIENT -01 irradiation, we have also committed ourselves to defining feasible waste routes. Today we cannot simply say ‘we’re not interested in the waste’. For us, this is a good driver to really sort things out.</p><p>GZ <em>And you came up with some feasible routes…</em></p><p>RH Probably. Although you have to realize that for this stage of SALIENT experiments our goals for the waste are quite modest. For this experiment, we do not yet separate the fission products from the actinides and into separate waste streams. [Separating fission products out of the fuel salt is one of the developmental goals for the MSR and is not yet practiced in this experiment — ed.] At this stage, it makes more sense to do all processing in a closed system. That being said, we have defined two routes.</p><p>The first is quite simple: we dissolve the fluoride salts in strong acid. The fluoride then will precipitate and can be removed. If we then raise the pH, turn the acid into a base, the fission products, and also the uranium and remaining thorium will precipitate as hydroxides or nitrates. That means you can then dry (calcinate) the remaining fraction that contains the actinides and the lanthanides. You have then turned your fluorides into oxides, and that is a kind of waste that everybody in the sector understands. This is quite like the familiar spent nuclear fuel (SNF) coming from many nuclear power plants. The remaining liquid waste can be cemented. You simply add cement and you let it harden. That is a quite straightforward method with which the COVRA is also quite familiar.</p><p>A promising feature of the nitric acid route is that in the process of raising the pH, and having the fission products precipitate, the lithium is likely to remain in the solution. That implies that the lithium will be recoverable. You could then simply reuse it for your next reactor.</p><p>On the other hand, this route might not be suitable for larger salt quantities because the required volumes of nitric acid are high. The second route is similar, but involves distilling off the bulk of the nitric acid solvent. This route would not allow for easy recovery of the lithium.</p><p>But again, the goal for these routes apply to the context of the experiments. After solving the waste issue for the SALIENT irradiations we will have to look into scaling up waste treatment. ”</p><p>Tiny URL for the above article: <a href="http://tinyurl.com/y7z8dyze">http://tinyurl.com/y7z8dyze</a></p><p>thoriumenergyworld’s press release and video:<br><a href="http://www.thoriumenergyworld.com/press-release/worlds-first-thorium-molten-salt-experiment-in-over-45-years">http://www.thoriumenergyworld.com/press-release/worlds-first-thorium-molten-salt-experiment-in-over-45-years</a></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FKaeSGZu_KlA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DKaeSGZu_KlA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FKaeSGZu_KlA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f04afe8a3ef40ae04dec8a049af29ebe/href">https://medium.com/media/f04afe8a3ef40ae04dec8a049af29ebe/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff8351fce5d2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/petten-has-started-world-s-first-thorium-msr-specific-irradiation-experiments-in-45-years-ff8351fce5d2">‘Petten’ has started world’s first 
 MSR-specific thorium fuel irradiation experiments in 45 years</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Our reactor will be able to compete with fossil fuel combustion”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/our-reactor-will-be-able-to-compete-with-fossil-fuel-combustion-2a1477d61247?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a1477d61247</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[thorium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nuclear]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainable-energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Oct 2016 12:49:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-11T08:20:04.095Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Terrestrial Energy’s Simon Irish:</h4><p><strong>On September 16, 2016, Simon Irish, CEO of Terrestrial Energy, visited the Netherlands to speak at the Euro Chlor 2016 General Assembly in Amsterdam. Terrestrial Energy (TE) is the Canadian molten salt reactor startup company that, according to many, holds the best cards to show the world’s first commercial molten salt reactor. Later that day, Mr. Irish gave his presentation at a ‘Meet and Greet’ at Delft, organized by the Thorium MSR Foundation. Preceding this presentation for an audience interested in MSR development, ThMSR had the opportunity to speak to Irish — who recently appeared in Myriam Tonelotto’s movie ‘</strong><a href="http://tinyurl.com/zu8k9vn"><strong>Thorium, the hidden face of nuclear’</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>(Gijs Zwartsenberg) Could you give us an update of where Terrestrial Energy stands in the development of its IMSR — the Integral Molten Salt Reactor?</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>(Simon Irish) 2016 is turning out to be an exciting year for TE. We achieved a number of important milestones recently, such as the financing of 22,5 million dollars from investors. Another development which is notable is that the IMSR development and deployment received grant support from the Canadian Sustainable Development Technology Canada program (<a href="https://www.sdtc.ca/en">SDTC</a>). We are the first fission nuclear company that has received a grant from that program, which is squarely pointed at sustainable technology.</p><p>More recently, this very week, we were pleased to announce that the US siting project to build, license and deploy the IMSR, has been invited by the Department of Energy (DOE) to submit part II of a loan guarantee application for financing between 800 million and 1.8 billion US dollars.</p><p>Third, we continue to engage our peer nuclear engineers and executives in the North American nuclear power industry, and to present to them the merits of our approach. We have, in April this year, formed what we refer to as our “corporate industrial advisory board”, a forum for us to seek input from current users of nuclear technology as we progress with IMSR engineering. Through this forum they can, early in the engineering program, give us the input that will help us deliver a reactor that is as useful as we can make it. The board represents many of the nuclear power utilities in North America. Southern Company, the second largest nuclear power utility in the US, and Ontario Power generation, the largest in Canada, joined earlier in the year. Two weeks ago Duke Energy, the largest power utility in North America, joined in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/298/1*z9QnzZQAJ0xzUBZIG4C4hQ.png" /><figcaption>Simon Irish Presenting at thmsr.nl’s Meet&amp;Greet, Delft, Netherlands, September 16, 2016</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>So you’re also discussing several site options for possible demo reactors, including US sites.</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>Yes. There are a number of site opportunities in Canada that we are pursuing, but I cannot discuss these at the moment. There is a similar program for IMSR deployment in the US. One siting that I can talk about was announced in our press release earlier this week: the Idaho National Lab as a possible site. INL has been the site for reactor development in the US for decades. They’re obviously a natural candidate to become the site of the first commercial IMSR reactor, it has many merits.</p><h3>Licensing process started in Canada and US</h3><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>You have started the Canadian licensing process, and have also started the US licensing process. Is there a synergy between the two?</em></p><p>SI Our plan is to license, construct and build the first IMSR in Canada. But we do not have to wait until we turn on our first reactor plant in Canada before we cross borders. As we reach key milestones in engineering, licensing and deployment in Canada, we envisage starting the corresponding components of siting and licensing projects in other countries. We are also interested in the UK Government’s position on SMR’s and look forward to hearing more of its path forward for advanced reactors towards the end of the year. This morning here in Amsterdam we have attended the Euro Chlor meeting, and again, perhaps there is a possibility at a future point for an IMSR siting project in Europe. That does not need to be a power production site, it could be an IMSR dedicated to delivering industrial heat. And in the case of Euro Chlor that would be in the context of chlorine related production.</p><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>In the US there have been quite some developments recently*) concerning the regulatory framework that surrounds the development of advanced nuclear reactors, is there a new wind blowing in the US regarding nuclear innovation? <br> *) </em><a href="http://www.usnews.com/opinion/articles/2016-07-11/americas-next-nuclear-power-renaissance-is-here"><em>like this one</em></a></p><p><strong>SI </strong>Absolutely! All in the advanced reactor community are monitoring developments in Washington very closely. Recent legislative developments in the US are encouraging for those seeking to develop and deploy advanced reactors in the US.</p><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>The communis opinio on the internet is that where it comes to develop and build MSR’s, the regulatory framework is the big obstacle, rather than the technology. This message has been repeated over and over again. What is your take on this?</em></p><p><strong>SI</strong> Regulation is about developing a reactor’s Safety Case to the satisfaction of the Nuclear Regulatory Authority. We think we have a strong Safety Case and we are engaged with the Canadian regulator in phase I of its Vendor Design Review, the first step in the Canada regulatory process. And we’re looking forward to presenting our reactors Safety Case to other regulators, and engage with them as early as we can.</p><h3>First IMSR expected in the 2020’s</h3><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>Another big question above the MSR market is ‘when can we see the first working one’.</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>We have gone on public record to say that we expect our first nuclear IMSR to be operating in the 2020s. We see an opportunity today to deploy an advanced reactor system by the end of the next decade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2td4LCtqcznUV7RrUJJODA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>Could you, for a lay person, explain the confidence you express with that statement?</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>It’s all about technological readiness. With the Integral Molten Salt Reactor, we are seeking to commercialize a system that has already been demonstrated and operated in a national lab. What we are seeking to do is to take that last step, the engineering and licensing step. We’re not looking to use the MSR approach to create a reactor system that requires a new fuel cycle, new moderators, new approaches. What we are seeking to do, is to take — to the greatest extend we possibly can — the existing body of knowledge, associate it with MSRs, and use that body of knowledge to support the engineering of our first commercial IMSR power plant. But remember, two IMSR’s have been build and have been operating already, this is not a blue sky technology project. That is an important point. We think that is the most appropriate approach if you want to bring the molten salt reactor to market next decade.</p><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>And that is why you insist to use Low Enriched Uranium (LEU) and not thorium.</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>You must make pragmatic business choices to support your deployment time frame and to ensure that the project can be financed — technology development risks are important to avoid if at all possible. One choice is to use as many generally used industry practices as one possibly can. We have done this. LEU is a generally accepted, well understood nuclear fuel. Another fuel would add additional complexity to the project.</p><p>Take for example the fuel supply chain. LEU can be provided by an existing industry today. Therefore it makes sense to design your reactor to incorporate that existing supply chain. If you choose to use higher enrichment levels, you would have to create a supply chain for that fuel, and surely that adds complexity to your project. We believe that other fuels are very interesting, but not for the first deployment.</p><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>And if you use the same fuel, what would you say are the main advantages of using an MSR rather than an LWR.</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>The main advantage is cost. The problem of today’s nuclear is cost. Nuclear cannot compete against natural gas. The global energy market is based on cost competition. Energy sources that are making growing contributions to the global energy market are benefitting from the investments they made in innovation 15–20 years ago. I include natural gas in that. They have done extremely well, due to innovation. On the renewable side, there have been some very impressive learning curve effects in the deployment of utility scale solar PV, those cost curves are impressive. No energy industry can advance without investments in innovation to maintain a cost competitive position.</p><h3>Terrestrial Energy’s business case</h3><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>I’m sure you have been making business cases and cost calculations. What do you think, what is your best guess if it comes to kWh-prices?</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>Our broad claim is that our IMSR reactor will be able to compete with fossil fuel combustion for the provision of heat and power to the industrial and power sectors. If you can compete on cost, compete commercially, you have harnessed one of the most powerful forces in private markets and that’s the profit motive. The industry will want to substitute and will want to adopt your technology because it reduces their cost and improves their profit position.</p><p>So this is an environmental solution which harnesses the profit motive. It doesn’t rely on national or international mandates to reduce the emission of greenhouse gasses. IMSR is a hugely scalable and dispatchable industrial heat source that promises to compete with fossil fuels on price. Remember that the industrial sector, a third of the GHG problem, is currently virtually untouched by renewables, here natural gas and coal still reign supreme, there is a good reason for that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tx89_W3F14fBqav6wv7vDg.png" /><figcaption>This LLNL diagram shows that ‘renewables’ are virtually irrelevant as an energy source for industrial heat, 24,5% of used energy in the US. According to Irish, the US Department of Energy (DOE) uses this graph to support the following two statements: <br>· Any serious discussion of energy systems for the future must begin with an understanding of the current energy systems, and the problems it creates, and how it can be transformed into a better system.<br>· Anyone who believes a massive build-up of renewable energy can clean up the energy sector lacks an understanding of the energy infrastructure of the U.S.</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>GZ </em></strong><em>So you think the IMSR can outcompete natural gas and coal.</em></p><p><strong>SI </strong>Absolutely. We have been looking at our systems ability to compete against fossil fuel energy sources in different industrial heat applications. We’re working with the national lab on that analysis, they’re expert on the type of techno economic analysis that you need to see how a nuclear reactor system can fit into industrial heat processes. The IMSR has a very diverse set of possibilities.</p><p>And the results are very encouraging.</p><p>At the moment we’re looking at our competitiveness in relation to North American natural gas prices, and as you know they are lower than in Europe. So our reference is North American coal and natural gas. Of course, if you are operating your power plant on top of the Marcellus Shale, you have access to some of the cheapest energy in the world. So we have to be a bit careful about regional variations. But generalized and on a national and global basis, we believe that the IMSR is competitive.</p><p>And when you start incorporating a carbon tax, even a very moderate carbon tax, then the case becomes very, very solid — a $50 per tonne CO2 tax adds $2.7 per MBtu to natural gas.*)</p><p><em>*) This roughly equals $80,7 million per GWyt.</em></p><p>�N�’VZ{��</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a1477d61247" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/our-reactor-will-be-able-to-compete-with-fossil-fuel-combustion-2a1477d61247">“Our reactor will be able to compete with fossil fuel combustion”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Timeline Thorium MSR Foundation / Tijdlijn Stichting Thorium MSR]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/timeline-thorium-msr-foundation-tijdlijn-stichting-thorium-msr-d6e3df3ecb5b?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6e3df3ecb5b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[molten-salt-reactors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thorium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainable-energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Jul 2016 19:13:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-30T10:50:51.055Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Bilingual page in English (En) and Dutch (Nl)</strong></p><p><strong>En: This timeline sums up events that have been relevant to the Thorium MSR Foundation and its goal: to make information available about the use of thorium in molten salt reactors.</strong></p><p><strong>* Events marked with * stand to the (co)credit of the foundation. Other events are considered relevant. Entries will be counter chronological: the latest events will appear on top. Whenever possible, we provide online resources. Entries are ISO-dated (YYYYMMDD).</strong></p><p><strong>Nl: Deze tijdlijn zet gebeurtenissen op een rij die relevant zijn voor de Stichting Thorium MSR en haar doel: informatie beschikbaar maken over het gebruik van thorium in gesmoltenzoutreactoren. <br>* Gebeurtenissen gemarkeerd met * staan mede op het conto van de stichting. Andere staan er omdat we ze als relevant beschouwen.</strong></p><p><strong>De tijdlijn is omgekeerd chronologisch: recente zaken staan bovenaan. Waar mogelijk vermelden we online bronnen. We vermelden steeds de ISO-datum (JJJJMMDD).</strong></p><h4>* 20171205 Meet &amp; Greet with researchers from SINAP</h4><p>In December, three researchers of the Chinese Center for Thorium Molten Salt Energy System of the Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics, visited Delft and Petten. They accepted an invitation by the by the Thorium MSR Foundation to give a presentation during a Meet&amp;Greet.</p><p>The researchers are Prof. Derek Tsang, who mainly focusses on nuclear graphite, Dr. Ruobing XIE has a focus on material irradiation and Jun LIN, PhD, who is doing R&amp;D of nuclear fuel.</p><p>The report of this Meet&amp;Greet is under preparation and will be published here, on articles.thmsr.nl.</p><h4>* 20171119 Meet &amp; Greet with NRG researcher Ralph Hania (NRG) and developers Thomas Jam Pedersen and Thomas Steenberg (Copenhagen Atomics)</h4><p>En: An update on the SALIENT experiments, the LUMOS plan, and a live demonstration of several techniques in development by Copenhagen Atomics.</p><p>NL: Een update van de SALIENT-experimenten, het LUMOS-plan, en een live demonstratie van enkele technieken in ontwikkeling bij Copenhagen Atomics.</p><p>The report / het verslag: <a href="https://articles.thmsr.nl/lumos-lasers-and-red-hot-flinak-1fefde23b016">https://articles.thmsr.nl/lumos-lasers-and-red-hot-flinak-1fefde23b016</a></p><h4>* 20170818 First to bring the news on the start of the SALIENT experiments</h4><p>En: We were proud to be the first to bring a full feature story on the start of the first MSR-specific thorium irradiation experiments in over 40 years, that had started a week earlier. We had agreed to wait this week, for confirmation that all was going OK. And OK it was! Our initial article was picked up worldwide, and triggered a lot of enthusiasm.</p><p>Nl: Heel trots waren we om de eerste te zijn die het nieuws brachten en een volledig achtergrondverhaal konden publiceren over het starten van de eerste specifiek op MSR gerichte bestralingsexperimenten met thorium in ruim 40 jaar, een week eerder. We hadden ermee ingestemd om die week te wachten, om eerst zeker te waten dat alles OK ging. En het ging OK! Het artikel is wereldwijd opgepikt, en leidde tot veel enthousiasme.</p><p>Hier het artikel: <a href="https://articles.thmsr.nl/petten-has-started-world-s-first-thorium-msr-specific-irradiation-experiments-in-45-years-ff8351fce5d2">https://articles.thmsr.nl/petten-has-started-world-s-first-thorium-msr-specific-irradiation-experiments-in-45-years-ff8351fce5d2</a></p><h4>* 20170623 Meet &amp; Greet with Matthew Lish (Flibe Energy), Delft</h4><p>En: Matthew Lish of Flibe Energy presented ‘Inherent safety analysis of thermal spectrum LFTR response’. Mr. Lish discussed dynamic modeling techniques, comparison of these techniques employed on model of MSRE to experimental data from MSRE, and finally results of dynamic simulation of<br>LFTR response to simulated transients and electrical load following procedure.</p><p>Matthew Lish is a graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill with a bachelor of science in chemistry, and the University of Tennessee at Knoxville with a doctorate in nuclear engineering, concentrating in system dynamics, instrumentation, and control. Dr. Lish currently works as a reactor<br>dynamicist at Flibe Energy in Hunstville, Alabama where he is developing a closed fuel cycle thorium nuclear reactor know as the liquid fluoride thorium reactor, or “lifter” (LFTR). His areas of interest include inorganic<br>separations chemistry, chemical process engineering, reactor dynamics, radiation hardened electronics for signal processing.</p><h4>* 20160916 Meet &amp; Greet with Simon Irish (TE), Delft</h4><p>En: On Friday September 16, Simon Irish of Terrestrial Energy spoke for the Eurochlor Conference in Amsterdam. That same evening, in Delft, he participated in a Meet&amp;Greet with the Thorium MSR Foundation.</p><p>Nl: Op vrijdag 16 september sprak Simon Irish van Terrestrial Energy op de Eurochlor Conferentie in Amsterdam. Diezelfde avond nam hij deel aan een Meet&amp;Greet met de Stichting Thorium MSR, te Delft.</p><p>And here’s the report: <a href="https://articles.thmsr.nl/our-reactor-will-be-able-to-compete-with-fossil-fuel-combustion-2a1477d61247#.r2imvr3zt">“Our reactor will be able to compete with fossil fuel combustion”</a>.</p><h4><strong>* 20160724 Meet &amp; Greet with Kirk Sorensen, Delft</strong></h4><p>En: This second Meet&amp;Greet with Kirk Sorensen was dedicated to the theme of nuclear ‘Waste Burners’.’</p><p>NL: Een tweede ‘Meet&amp;Greet’ Met Kirk Sorensen over zogenaamde ‘Waste Burners’,</p><h4>20160524 ‘Thorium Evening’ / Thoriumavond Provincie Overijssel</h4><p>En: A ‘Thorium Evening’ in Zwolle, an initiative of the Province of Overijssel. There has been a remarkable interest of regional governments for thorium MSR’s. Similar presentations took place in the provinces of Friesland and Zeeland. On the ‘Thorium Evening’ of Overijssel, representatatives of all (12) Dutch provinces where present.</p><p>Nl: Deze ‘Thoriumavond’ was een initiatief van de Provincie Overijssel. Onder de Provincies bestaat opmerkelijke belangstelling voor thorium MSR’s. Vergelijkbare presentaties vonden plaats in Friesland en Zeeland. In Overijssel waren vertegenwoordigers aanwezig van alle (12) provincies.</p><p>Video recording in Dutch: <a href="http://overijssel.notubiz.nl/vergadering/287242/Expertmeeting%20Thorium%2024-05-2016">Opname</a> van de presentaties van Theo Wolters, Markus Schmid en publiek debat onder leiding van Jan Medendorp, presentator RTV Oost.</p><h4>20160401 Cover article in ‘Kernvisie’</h4><p>Nl (The magazine ‘Kernvisie’ appears in Dutch only) Op 2 april plaatste Kernvisie Magazine een coverartikel over de Stichting Thorium MSR. Op pagina 4 t/m 6 staat een interview met de voorzitter. Op 8 en 9 staat een interview met Jan Leen Kloosterman, lid van de Wetenschappelijke Raad van de stichting.</p><p>Een pdf van dit magazine kan <a href="http://www.kernvisie.com/4-magazine/7-pdf-kernvisie-magazine.html">hier</a> worden gedownload, klik in de lijst op KernvisieMagazine jaargang 11 nr 2 april 2016</p><h4>* 20160522 Meet &amp; Greet with Copenhagen Atomics, Delft</h4><p>En: On May 22, 2016, Thomas Jam Pedersen, Thomas Steenberg and Aslak Stubsgaard of Copenhagen Atomics presented several innovative ideas for aspects of Molten Salt Reactors for a audience of around 50 people.</p><p>[recorded presentation to be inserted when available]</p><p>Nl: Op 22 mei 2016 presenteerden Thomas Jam Pedersen, Thomas Steenberg en Aslak Stubsgaard van Copenhagen Atomics diverse innovatieve ideeën voor aspecten van MSR’s voor een publiek van ongeveer 50 personen.</p><h4>* 20160318 Launch of the section articles.thmsr.nl on medium.com</h4><p>En. On March 18, our subdomain in medium.com was activated. Medium.com is an innovative platform for ‘longreads’, created by the makers of Twitter, who finally discover that not all can be explained in Tweets. Medium.com offers writers incredible features. One of them being that independent writers can add their content to other domains — only if both the writer and the owner of the subdomain agree to do this. Readers interested in becoming contributors need to create a medium.com-account and contact us.</p><p>Click * <a href="https://articles.thmsr.nl/">articles.thmsr.nl</a> * klik</p><p>Nl. Op 18 maart is ons subdomein in medium.com actief geworden. Medium.com is een innovatief platform voor ‘longreads’, opgericht door de bedenkers van Twitter, die er achter kwamen dat je met tweets niet alles uit kunt leggen. Medium biedt geweldige mogelijkheden. Eén daarvan is dat onafhankelijke schrijvers bijdragen kunnen leveren aan andermans publicaties zoals ons subdomein. Lezers die bijdragen zouden willen leveren dienen een account aan te maken in medium.com en contact met ons op te nemen.</p><h4>* 20160204 Meet &amp; Greet with Kirk Sorensen, Delft</h4><p>En: On February 4, 2016, Kirk Sorensen gave an introduction of his vision on Thorium Molten Salt Reactors for a non technical audience. This meeting was attended by more than 80 people.</p><p>Nl. Op 4 februari gaf Kirk Sorensen een introductie op zijn visie op thorium MSR’s voor een niet-technisch publiek. Deze meeting werd bezocht door ruim 80 mensen.</p><h4>20160205 Dutch national news covers Kirk Sorensen’s visit to NRG</h4><p>[recordings to be inserted]</p><h4>* 20160204 The Foundation’s first public appearance at Atomkraft 2.0 Kopenhagen</h4><p>A full report of the visit of Kopenhagen and the symposium can be found <a href="https://articles.thmsr.nl/atomkraft-2-0-will-molten-salt-reactors-be-the-turning-point-of-denmark-s-nuclear-story-96001035a240#.qszddmogx">here</a>.</p><p>The presentation of the Foundation by Gijs Zwartsenberg can be found <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzXIhCygmLY">here</a>.</p><h4>* 20160129 Establishment of Thorium MSR Foundation / Oprichting Stichting Thorium MSR</h4><p>The statutes of the Foundation:</p><p><a href="http://thmsr.nl/pdf/statuten-oprichtingsacte-stichting-thorium-msr-20160526.pdf">Statutes/Statuten</a></p><p>De statuten van de Stichting</p><h4>20160118 Thorium MSR’s appear in the Dutch Energy Report</h4><p>Three months after ‘motion 57’, thorium MSR appears in the Dutch Energy Report, a report in which the government presents it integral vision on future energy supply of the Netherlands.</p><p>Drie maanden na het aannemen van ‘motie 57’, verschijnt thorium MSR in het Energierapport, een rapport waarin het kabinet zijn integrale visie presenteert op de toekomstige energievoorziening van Nederland. Download <a href="https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten/rapporten/2016/01/18/energierapport-transitie-naar-duurzaam">hier</a> de pdf en zoek naar ‘thorium’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/665/0*sTeID8dwANehGvw0." /></figure><h4>20151216 Presentation for ‘Students for Sustainability’ (S4S), Delft</h4><p>With about 60 attendants this lunch presentation was of modest scale, but the enthusiasm of the young audience (mostly in their twenties) was worth noting: this generation has a fresh look and appears to have no trouble at all with the idea of a new form of nuclear power, as long as it’s safe and sustainable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/451/0*A2lo6RcLpNO_PGoC." /></figure><p>Deze presentatie had met zo’n 60 bezoekers een bescheiden omvang, maar het enthousiasme van het jonge publiek (meest twintigers) was het opmerken waard: deze generatie heeft blijkbaar geen enkel probleem met een nieuwe vorm van kernenergie, mits deze veilig en duurzaam is.</p><h4>20151105 Thorium MSR’s appear on Dutch national television</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9rYuLaCJt9a7FyHv." /></figure><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OW8OZ8P6_1c">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OW8OZ8P6_1c</a></p><h4>20151015 Dutch Parliament asks the minister to be informed about the possibilities of thorium</h4><p>Members of Parliament Bosman en Dijkgraaf issue ‘motion 57’, that asks the minister to inform the parliament about thorium MSR’s, and to inform the Parliament bout the governments findings through the Energy Report that is due for 2016.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/876/0*KRxv54cpOcMJZFXS." /></figure><h4>20150417 Thorium MSR Symposium, Delft</h4><p>En: The Thorium MSR Foundation has its roots in the Thorium MSR Symposium at Delft Technical University, April 17, 2015, which was attended by about 300 people. Lucas Pool and Jorrit Swaneveld took part in organizing this symposium, that was initiated by several others including Theo Wolters.</p><p>The Symposium featured prominent speakers, most notably Kirk Sorensen, David LeBlanc and Leslie Dewan. The full recording of this event can be watched with the link below.</p><p><a href="https://collegerama.tudelft.nl/Mediasite/Play/67f503b8e0bf41b1b870b86cb63b674a1d">Full recording of the Thorium MSR Symposium, April 17, 2015</a></p><p>Nl: De Stichting Thorium MSR heeft haar wortels in het Thorium MSR Symposium te Delft, op 17 april 2015, dat bezocht werd door zo’n 300 mensen. Lucas Pool en Jorrit Swaneveld hebben dit symposium, dat een initiatief was van een aantal mensen onder wie Theo Wolters, mede georganiseerd.</p><p>Op het symposium waren prominente sprekers, onder meer Kirk Sorensen, David LeBlanc en Leslie Dewan. De volledige opnames van dit symposium zijn te bekijken met bovenstaande link.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6e3df3ecb5b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/timeline-thorium-msr-foundation-tijdlijn-stichting-thorium-msr-d6e3df3ecb5b">Timeline Thorium MSR Foundation / Tijdlijn Stichting Thorium MSR</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SAMOFAR — Why the slow coming of a fast reactor actually speeds up the development of ‘slow’ MSR’s]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/samofar-why-the-slow-coming-of-a-fast-reactor-actually-speeds-up-the-development-of-slow-msr-s-e20b32ab3341?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e20b32ab3341</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[molten-salt-reactors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thorium]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Jul 2016 13:39:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-03T14:47:32.581Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>By Gijs Zwartsenberg</strong></p><p><strong>In the SAMOFAR project, eleven European universities and research institutes cooperate to demonstrate the safety of the Molten Salt Fast Reactor (MSFR). The MSFR will be able to efficiently ‘burn’ the existing stockpiles of plutonium, and can also use thorium to produce fuel. All fuel will be used in the form of a molten fluoride salt, in which the fissile elements are dissolved.</strong></p><p><strong>But according to many experts, the European choice to direct the efforts at developing a molten salt <em>fast</em> reactor is a remarkable one, as the fast reactor is considered to be the less ‘doable’ molten salt reactor, compared to its cousin that works with thermal or ‘slow’ neutrons.</strong></p><p><strong>Hence, the ‘fast reactor’ is expected to require a longer development time, while the ‘thermal reactor’ is expected to be a much closer target for development.</strong></p><p>There’s good reasons for this supposition: in order to safely handle high-energy neutron fluxes, researchers have to come up with new materials or very smart ideas to prevent fast neutrons from damaging structural materials. And most probably, they will have to come up with both. A thermal molten salt reactor, on the contrary, has already been successfully demonstrated by the successful Molten Salt Reactor Experiment in Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) in the 1960s. Even if we do not yet know the ultimate materials to build them from, we certainly know some good materials to start with.</p><p>Is the SAMOFAR research helping us to bring closer thermal reactors, widely considered to be the more ‘doable’ ones?</p><p>Thmsr asked this question to Jan Leen Kloosterman, professor in nuclear physics at Delft University of Technology, who is in charge of the SAMOFAR project.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/94/1*eSD9mcTnFRubj3nkWxVRyA.png" /><figcaption>Jan Leen Kloosterman</figcaption></figure><p>JLK: “At Delft we now focus on fundamental research on the behaviour of molten salts. We are presently developing software to model the salt. In order to validate the model, we are also building an experimental setup that will allow us to measure a variety of properties like viscosity and heat conductivity. We want to be able to do measurements with salt temperatures of up to 1100C. We will be using clean FLiNaK<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> salt first, but we will be able to investigate, and later model, any salt that is relevant for molten salt reactors.</p><p>In the reactor-modeling software that we develop, we will extend the neutronics with the thermohydraulics and computational fluid dynamics. With those two aspects in the model, we will be able to do safety studies. This will allow us to calculate accident scenario’s and their consequences.”</p><p><em>How many salt components do you involve in your model? We talk about quite complex mixtures once the nuclear reaction starts going…</em></p><p>JLK “In our experiment we work with the clean salts. But in a later stage, the experimental setup will be moved to ITU, our partner in Karlsruhe. They will be doing measurements in salts with fissionable components mixed in, in particular plutonium and uranium. But without the fission products.”</p><p><em>Shouldn’t these be included as well?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/165/1*aBXlSr_8gt8iWsxoDKH18g.png" /><figcaption>In the SAMOFAR project, the EVOL molten salt fast reactor is the reference design</figcaption></figure><p>JLK “Their concentrations are very low, and I don’t know if they have a large influence on the viscosity of the mixture. Anna Smith, a PhD-student in our group, is working on thermodynamics, and how it is influenced by salt mixtures of different compositions. She issued a proposal for further investigation at NWO, a Dutch organization that supports fundamental research. The better our models are, the less we need the complex measurements that we are doing now. The idea is that we need a number of measurements that serve as reference points for our models. The research of Anna Smith is directed at starting to fundamentally understand the molecular dynamics within the salt. Once we start understanding that, it will be possible to calculate most salt behaviour.”</p><p><em>Has this been done before? I guess ORNL never had this option in the 1960s, for lack of computer power.</em></p><p>JLK “True, this is really new. This is our contribution to the European project: the numeric determination of salt properties. But the experimental setup for measuring the salt properties is also new.”</p><p><em>Does the model include the interaction with reactor materials?</em></p><p>JLK “Not presently. But that is what we want to investigate with the new and upcoming project MIMOSA. Jilt Sietsma, Materials Scientist here at TU Delft, is preparing a proposal to get funding for this project, that aims at understanding the interaction between salt and structural materials. In Delft we plan to build a complete experimental molten salt loop, that will serve as a model of another loop that is to be placed in the high neutron flux of the HFR reactor in Petten.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/217/1*TzzhazHp2B8Nd27ErLJQDw.png" /><figcaption>The EVOL reactor core is placed within a safety containment</figcaption></figure><p><em>That is interesting: the European research seems directed at the MSFR. But the neutron flux in Petten is thermal, not fast. Is the salt loop not modelling a thermal molten salt reactor?</em></p><p>JLK “The loop is really part of fundamental research to understand salt behaviour in a neutron flux, at high temperatures, in contact with reactor materials. But it’s true that in this experiment this happens with thermal neutrons, in that sense this experiment is more a model for thermal reactors. But the knowledge we hope to get is equally relevant for fast reactors.”</p><p><em>Are you at Delft TU presently working on thermal molten salt reactors? And do you presently have reference designs?</em></p><p>JLK “That is something we are presently not working on. In the past, we have made designs for both single zone thermal reactors and for thermal reactors with a breeding blanket. Actually we improved the MSBR originally designed by Oak Ridge. But we haven’t been doing that type of research for a while now, because we realized that the real questions were much more on the fundamental level. Whatever reactor you design, you really need to model it. And in order to do that, you need to know all the details of the salt behaviour, including the interaction with the construction materials. These questions you really need to answer before you can even think of answering the questions a regulator is going to ask. So yes, we could come up with a better design than we have now, and then another generation of designed reactors. But your efforts will fail as long as you lack fundamental knowledge of the salts and their interactions.”</p><p><em>I guess this makes it even harder to be clear on possible timelines…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/140/1*XPIkrOiKLw-JGXw8oje6eQ.png" /><figcaption>EVOL’s safety containment, and the dump tank for the liquid core, are placed within another containment structure.</figcaption></figure><p>JLK “I think that once we have our software ready, and integrate the thermohydraulics, the fluid dynamics and the neutronics, then we are ready to think about reactor designs. We will then be able to rule out many uncertainties and reduce them.”</p><p><em>And then start experiments with much more focus…</em></p><p>JLK “Yes. Safety assessments will then be of much better quality. The error margin will be greatly reduced.”</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> A eutectic mixture of fluorides of lithium (Li), sodium (Na) and potassium (K).</p><p>‘�� �[�</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e20b32ab3341" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/samofar-why-the-slow-coming-of-a-fast-reactor-actually-speeds-up-the-development-of-slow-msr-s-e20b32ab3341">SAMOFAR — Why the slow coming of a fast reactor actually speeds up the development of ‘slow’ MSR’s</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Atomkraft 2.0 — will molten salt reactors be the turning point of Denmark’s nuclear story?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/atomkraft-2-0-will-molten-salt-reactors-be-the-turning-point-of-denmark-s-nuclear-story-96001035a240?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/96001035a240</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Mar 2016 20:28:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-18T20:28:07.887Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The largest part of the world-wide ‘molten salt reactor movement’ consists of enthusiasts who are basically exchanging information. A much smaller part is doing real research, and one of the places where this happen is Copenhagen, Denmark. Copenhagen Atomics demonstrates that, provided you have a highly motivated team that is willing to invest free time and even spare money, very meaningful research can be done at low costs. The Danish research may be able to considerably shrink the time frame that is necessary for the development of MSR’s. Challenging ideas, maybe too modestly presented – this somehow struck me as very Scandinavian. An impression of a visit to Copenhagen, on behalf of the symposium Atomkraft 2.0, organized by Danish society of engineers </strong><a href="https://universe.ida.dk/arrangement/thorium-atomkraft-version-20-hvad-hvordan-hvor-meget-317220/"><strong>IDA</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p>The reason that Lucas Pool and myself are expected in Copenhagen is the establishment, on January the 29, 2016, of the <a href="http://thmsr.nl/#/">Thorium MSR Foundation</a> in Delft, Netherlands. Our hosts have invited us to share the news of the freshly established Foundation at Atomkraft 2.0. Both the symposium and the foundation can be seen as part of an evolving worldwide movement of people who think that molten salt reactors, although presently non-existent, may present a real world solution to the worldwide overproduction of carbon dioxide, that needs to be researched and developed.</p><p>Kirk Sorensen is the undisputed initiator of this movement. It was Sorensen who, while working at NASA, stumbled upon a book called ‘Liquid Fuel Reactors’ in the office of one of his colleagues. It was Sorensen who got Oak Ridge National Laboratory to publish the meticulously made reports of the original experiments of the 1960s. I consider it no small honor to speak at the same event where Sorensen speaks, in the town where Niels Bohr grew up.</p><p>Copenhagen of 2016 does play its part in the emerging molten salt reactor movement. After a split in late 2015, the country is home to two nuclear startups: Copenhagen Atomics and Seaborg Technologies.</p><p>In the morning Lucas Pool and I are picked up by Thomas Steenberg, the new CEO of Copenhagen Atomics (CA). We have a chance to greet Copenhagen’s Little Mermaid – before we are expected at the decommissioning site of the DR3 reactor at Roskilde. CA is hoping to save the reactor site as a test site. With the old reactor removed, the reactor building would be an ideal location and a tremendous cost saving for a molten salt reactor development project.</p><p>In the meantime, as we will later learn, Kirk Sorensen is paying a visit to the farm of his ancestors (his great-grandfather owned a farm not far from Copenhagen) together with the other host of the conference, CA co-founder Thomas Jam Pedersen. At his presentation later that afternoon, Sorensen told the audience that this visit had been a moving experience, and supposed that his great-grandfather would have been stunned that his all-American great-grandson Kirk did not speak a word Danish…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/258/1*gOjN-bXjbiG8odd1Ih6-tA.png" /><figcaption>Left to right: Kirk Sorensen, Peter Szabo, Mark Holcchakier, Jiri Krepel, Thomas Steenberg, Lucas Pool, Per Holtzmann Søndergaard.</figcaption></figure><h4>Witnessing an unyielding reactor that is set for decommissioning</h4><p>At the site of the old test reactor, we join with the rest of the party, including Kirk Sorensen, Thomas Jam Pedersen, Jiri Krepel of the Paul Scherer institute who works on SAMOFAR and several others. We are received by Per Holtzmann Søndergaard who is leading the decommissioning work, and Morten Dalby. The site is still guarded, although there is no more fuel in the reactor. We clip on dosimeters when we enter the reactor area in the building.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*AyWqSqP1pKa7UTthVjPv9w.png" /><figcaption>Yours truly inspecting nuclear equipment at the DR3 reactor. To the right: a live peek at the core structure.</figcaption></figure><p>I’m impressed by how meticulously the decommissioning work is being carried out by Holtzmann Søndergaard and Morten Dalby. The old reactor was never built to ever be decommissioned, and the heavily reinforced concrete is uncooperative: special equipment had to be brought in, that peels it off layer by layer. The core structure is still intact and we get a live peek at it through several high resolution surveillance cameras that are placed within the radiation that is still there due to activated materials. But I’m sure the reactor will finally give in to the patient persistence of Holtzmann Søndergaard and Dalby.</p><h4>Full house at the symposium</h4><p>In the afternoon, back in Copenhagen, the auditory room fills up until it is packed full with about 125 curious Danes that have come to learn about molten salt reactors. And of course to see Kirk Sorensen, who has, after all, Danish ancestors.</p><p>Kirk has the kick-off presentation, but he needs to stop after a few minutes, because his voice is overruled by a persisting smoke-alarm. While we wait outside for technicians to switch the darn thing off, some whisper this could have been caused by dark anti-nuclear forces... Which would, however the hypothesis remains unconfirmed, present an ironic twist, as smoke detectors work thanks to the use of americium, a transuranic element that is made in nuclear reactors (and was first discovered by Glen Seaborg in 1945). The thousands of lives that have been saved due to the reliability of smoke detectors usually play no role in the perceptions that surround the nuclear debate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/264/1*54434O9P63FQQ4V_MdOMzg.png" /><figcaption>Kirk Sorensen presenting at Atomkraft 2.0</figcaption></figure><p>Atomkraft 2.0 is the first public presentation in Denmark dedicated to molten salt reactors, and some of the presentations have been adapted to that – Kirk Sorensen’s presentation is mostly introductory. More technical was Jiri Krepel’s presentation about The European SAMOFAR project, now headed by TU Delft professor Jan Leen Kloosterman. In his presentation Krepel explained SAMOFAR’s quest for the ideal reactor, and the possibilities to have it run on thorium or uranium 238.</p><p>In the next presentation, Thomas Jam Pedersen put the possible contribution of MSR’s to a future energy mix with high amounts of wind, water and solar energy in perspective. A relevant contribution, especially in a country that has one of the world’s highest shares of wind power worldwide. Pedersen talks about the challenges of expanding wind and solar power. A detailed graph of December 2015 shows many days that wind power provided almost 100 per cent of the electricity of Denmark, and Pedersen acknowledges this is an accomplishment. The graph however also shows a present downside of this success: even at days of 100 per cent wind power, fossil fuel plants need to keep running in order to remain on standby – they cannot simply be switched off. Pedersen expects that the Danes will keep on building windmills until they produce about 200% of the electricity that is needed. “Denmark is in the unique position of having Norway and Sweden that act as huge batteries for our grid.” The downside of course is that Denmark will then have to sell even more power at negative prices, if it’s produced at times that Sweden and Norway don’t need all this power from their windy neighbor country…</p><p>Then it’s my turn. The message that molten salt reactors present a chance to start a new conversation about nuclear energy seems to land well. As does the message that politicians have their tongue frozen when it comes to nuclear. I get quite a few questions and afterwards, a lot of people want to talk further. All in all, the response is much more positive than I’d expected in nuclear-skeptical Denmark…</p><h4>Why MSR research needs electrochemistry</h4><p>The surprise of the symposium came from Thomas Steenberg, now the CEO of Copenhagen Atomics. Earlier that day, I got a hint of Steenberg’s knowledge of electrochemistry. On our way to Copenhagen’s bronze mermaid, we discussed one of Steenberg’s passions, materials research, and I referred to a list of reactor engineer Ed Pheil, according to whom molten FliBe, the proposed mixture for MSR’s, is no more corrosive than hot water. “Oh, no”, responded Steenberg. “At those temperatures hot water is probably much more corrosive than molten FLiBe salt...”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/214/1*lN3GGHdnICQq7cFtE9cbzA.png" /><figcaption>Thomas Steenberg</figcaption></figure><p>Steenberg, who earns his living as CTO for Danish Power Systems, got his PhD in materials sciences and electrochemistry twenty years ago and has twenty years of experience as a chemical process engineer in industrial R&amp;D and startups. He and the CA team are the kind of researchers who live for experimenting, as he makes clear in his presentation. And he may be too modest about their results as well…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/143/1*HY0ynlZCQmU_I0rUaq27YQ.png" /></figure><p>In his presentation, Steenberg referred to corrosion issues that were presented by Jilt Sietsma at the symposium in Delft, in April last year. Sietsma showed microscopic pictures that revealed considerable corrosion in proposed reactor wall materials, after having been exposed to molten salt mixtures at high temperatures in strong neutron flux. Steenberg, who expresses his appreciation for the work of Sietsma, has specific ideas about the nature and of this corrosion and has ideas on how to deal with it.</p><p>During his PhD research he was part of a group, that also worked with stainless steel systems at comparable conditions (except for the neutron flux). Here the steel was exposed to fluoride salts at high temperatures (700 °C) during five years. After this period, the surface of the stainless steel was carefully examined and it showed no corrosion at all! The difference can be explained, according to Steenberg, by the presence of impurities, most notably H2O and O2. The systems that Steenberg tested at the time were continuously screened for these components, that were kept at very low levels, and no corrosion occurred.</p><p>Steenberg highlights that in MSR’s, free fluorine is another component to keep a keen eye on. This free fluorine (F2) forms at the moment of fission or decay. It has to be managed carefully, in order to prevent corrosion of the structural parts.</p><h4>“We do not need new, super duper materials – just treat the melt properly!”</h4><p>Thomas Steenberg draws a clear conclusion from his experimental observations. “We do not need new, ‘super duper’ materials in order to build MSR’s”, he says. “Hastelloy N is a good material, stainless steel is a good material. We however do have to manage that free fluorine and prevent water and oxygen from coming in. Simply said: we just have to treat the melt properly.”</p><p>Steenberg goes on to offer three more examples of how process chemistry knowledge is needed to speed up the development process of the molten salt reactor. Copenhagen Atomics has proposed a simple yet effective way to prepare spent nuclear fuel for use in a molten salt reactor. This reprocessing usually involves wet chemistry, which implies a rather complicated and cumbersome process. The CA team has a better idea. Better, faster and easier results can be obtained by fluorination of the spent nuclear fuel rods.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/322/1*2zEYx5s191PLOeOeN6xLfQ.png" /><figcaption>Fluorination in flame reactor</figcaption></figure><p>In a stream of fluorine gas, the fuel rods can be burned like wood sticks can be burned in air. This ‘fluorination’ can be safely done in a flame reactor – a very basic process chemistry device that can be bought off the shelf from Hitachi.</p><p>As for the inline re-processing of the salt mixture, the CA team has made a – as he calls it – ‘very simple setup’, that allows them to test separation and treatment procedures of different salt mixtures at different pressures (0-1 bar) and temperatures (0-900 °C) under protective atmosphere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*U-s1iz36-gws8ACu10Da9w.png" /><figcaption>Setup to test behaviour of salt mixtures</figcaption></figure><p>He and his team are actually doing such tests, mimicking the chemical conditions of different process steps of molten salt reactors. As long as these experiments are done with non-radioactive chemicals, there is no regulator interfering and much can be learned, as Steenberg and his team are demonstrating.</p><h4>Cheap laser technology checks for elements ánd isotopes</h4><p>Finally, the CA team have been testing the use of Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) as a means to screen salt mixture compositions inline. LIBS is a well-established and inexpensive measuring method. Steenberg has been working with LIBS for years and again he makes it sound simple.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/392/1*0bDBif0d0AXREGicbRKv5A.png" /><figcaption>LIBS detection determines elements ánd isotopes with resolutions below 10 ppm, based on surface measurements</figcaption></figure><p>A pulse of laser – slightly more powerful than the one you use for presentations – is used to for a plasma on the surface of the molten salt sample. The light from the plasma is analyzed and the composition of the salt can be quickly and adequately determined. Not only the chemical composition is revealed, the isotopic mixtures also show up reliably with low detection ranges (10ppm or less). This inline chemical screening allows for precise control of the MSR’s processes – both to prevent corrosion and to optimize the neutronic properties of the melt. Steenberg and his team have successfully identified elements and isotopes in fluoride melts of 700 °C. Even surface measuring of silicate melts at 1500 °C produced very accurate results. The isotopic screening may also be very relevant to future inventory tracking of fissile material – which would be a big help to design adequate safety frameworks for MSR’s for regulators.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*8CgI8EX5wfwG1eRR6yl15Q.png" /><figcaption>Measurements on Th, U and LiF samples</figcaption></figure><p>All in all, the presentation showed a remarkable next step of what has been called the ‘grass roots movement’ of enthusiasts about the development of molten salt reactors. Looking back I wonder how many times in history have we seen a group like the Copenhagen Atomics team emerging of people that invest their free time and personal savings into developing a nuclear reactor technology that they think the world desperately needs?</p><p>Steenberg makes it sound very self-evident that this happens. “We do this by funding it ourselves, using equipment of good friends and former colleagues – a lot of collaboration can make a lot of things happening for very little money.”</p><p>Gijs Zwartsenberg, 20160309</p><h4>All presentations of Atomkraft 2.0 can be found online at:</h4><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hR8PiBZPKw0">Kirk Sorensen</a> [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hR8PiBZPKw0]</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6EcMgUgufkQ">Jiri Krepel</a> [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6EcMgUgufkQ]</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyBSGpu7K-k">Thomas Jam Pedersen</a> [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyBSGpu7K-k]</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMyrMVtOqEY">Thomas Steenberg</a> [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMyrMVtOqEY]</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzXIhCygmLY">Gijs Zwartsenberg</a> [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzXIhCygmLY]</p><p>The pdf’s of the presentations can be found here, at the site of <a href="https://universe.ida.dk/arrangement/thorium-atomkraft-version-20-hvad-hvordan-hvor-meget-317220/">IDA</a>.</p><p>&quot;�aO髕</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=96001035a240" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/atomkraft-2-0-will-molten-salt-reactors-be-the-turning-point-of-denmark-s-nuclear-story-96001035a240">Atomkraft 2.0 — will molten salt reactors be the turning point of Denmark’s nuclear story?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The comeback of the molten salt reactor]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/the-comeback-of-the-molten-salt-reactor-8454c7e5330c?source=rss-c3d6a2202bcd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8454c7e5330c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[molten-salt-reactors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gijs Zwartsenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Mar 2016 15:24:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-31T21:04:56.417Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A remarkable series of experiments in National Laboratories of the United States in the 50s and 60s did not deliver the nuclear airplane that the US Airforce wanted, but it did deliver a technology that has the potential to produce clean, carbon free energy for tens of thousands of years. This ‘molten salt reactor’ demonstrated the perspective of a nuclear energy system, unparalleled in safety, controllability, resource efficiency, without generating long term waste. Political agendas sidetracked the molten salt reactor, but in recent years it’s making a remarkable comeback.</strong></p><p>Ever since Kirk Sorensen put the extensive investigation reports of the MSR program of Oak Ridge National Laboratory online in 2006, the enthusiasm about this ‘forgotten’ technology has been spreading. From a multitude of possible designs, Sorensen picked one that has become his favorite: the Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactor or LFTR in short (pronounced ‘lifter’).</p><p>On paper, the concept shows staggering numbers. As a molten salt reactor, it differs from today’s light water reactors in virtually all respects. It is inherently safe, gives access to a supply of energy that easily lasts thousands, probably tens of thousands of years. It virtually solves the long lived nuclear waste problems and produces very small amounts of waste that only needs storage for about 300 years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/653/1*7fumEMJCZFsOp-BSHeKOEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Alvin Weinberg (facing the camera), head of Oak Ridge National Laboratory at the time of the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment. In the background the reactor controls. Still from Oak Ridge documentary.</figcaption></figure><p>These numbers however do not evenly apply to all thorium options nor to all types of molten salt reactors. In the media, there has been considerable confusion on this point. The trouble is that ‘thorium’ and ‘molten salt reactors’ are separate aspects of the proposed developments. Whether or not the two are combined makes a lot of difference. A simple way to summarize this would be to say that the molten salt technology adds safety and efficiency, while the thorium adds fuel abundance and virtual elimination of long lived waste issues, provided that ‘thorium’ and ‘molten salt reactor’ are used in a single machine.</p><p>The advantage of the liquid fuel is easy to understand: liquids make it possible to remove unwanted waste products that appear during the process; you can keep the fuel in mint condition at all times. Thorium then paves the way for nuclear energy’s holy grail: a closed fuel cycle. Meaning the fuel is completely consumed, leaving behind only minimal amounts of short lived waste products while producing abundant amounts of energy. <br>In the end, it all comes down to one single word: efficiency.</p><h4>Clearing up some thorium confusion</h4><p>Some confusion has arisen from the fact that both ‘thorium’ and ‘molten salt reactors’ can be used in very different ways.</p><p>For instance, thorium can be used in solid fuel reactors. In current solid fuel reactors, thorium could be introduced to decrease uranium demand somewhat. However, this is currently not pursued, as uranium prices remain too low in the foreseeable future, hence the benefits do not outweigh the costs of significantly changing current fuel designs.</p><p>On the other hand, molten salt reactors can be run on the kind of uranium that is presently used in existing nuclear power plants. Using this enriched natural uranium in molten salt reactors , allows for a higher ‘burnup’ of the uranium in comparison to traditional reactors. This is due to the fluid form that enables online purification and optimization of the fuel, enhancing efficiency and allowing the material to stay in the reactor much longer, until virtually completely used up. These simpler molten salt reactors hence offer substantial improvements of the waste profile in comparison to traditional nuclear power plants, when using the same fuel. The improved efficiency of MSR’s also offers the possibility of burning spent nuclear fuel that is present in existing stockpiles.</p><p>But the ‘ultimate’ molten salt reactor consumes thorium. In this reactor, the thorium is first transformed into a special type of uranium (U233), an isotope that is not found in nature and that has superior ‘burning’ properties. For reasons of simplicity, this two-step process is usually summarized as ‘a thorium MSR runs on thorium’. This process is made possible due to the MSR’s high and crucial ‘neutron efficiency’, allowing both transformation of thorium, and subsequent burning. This ultimate reactor has a waste profile that makes the thorium MSR a truly sustainable option.</p><h4>One ton of thorium could prevent the release of 12 million tons of carbon dioxide</h4><p>So what could be the impact of thorium MSR’s? Let’s take a brief look at some numbers. For country-sized power plans, the Gigawatt year or GWey is a convenient unit. One GWey roughly equals the electrical energy that is needed to run a modern city of one million inhabitants for a year. To produce a GWey, the ultimate thorium MSR needs about a metric ton (1000kgs) of natural thorium. The thorium MSR uses all of its fuel. Hence it produces a waste stream of roughly 1000kgs of fission products per year, a quantity that would need storage for about 300 years — after which what is left is no more radiotoxic than regular thorium containing ore found in nature.</p><p>[A bit of math. According to the Dutch Bureau of Statistics CBS, <a href="http://[http://www.cbs.nl/nl-NL/menu/themas/industrie-energie/publicaties/artikelen/archief/2015/elektriciteitsverbruik-16-keer-hoger-dan-in-1950.htm">in 2013 the Netherlands used 119 billion kWh of electricity</a>, 14GWey in rounded country-sized numbers. If produced in molten salt reactors, this would require 14 (metric) tons of fissionable material. A coal plant requires 3.3 million tons of coal to produce one GWey. If produced in coal plants, 14GWey would require 46 million tons of coal — about 8000 km of freight train cars, each train car filled with coal. The by-product would be 169 million tons of carbon dioxide. If thorium would replace the actual Dutch energy mix that produces this 14GWey (percentages: coal 24.4, natural gas 58, oil 1.2; biofuel and renewables: 16.4) CO2 reductions would be 98 million tons.*) Application of the recent proposal of the Dutch National Bank to tax carbon emissions with €30,- per ton CO2 puts this number in perspective. Replacing fossil fuel sources with msr’s would then save the Dutch 2,9 billion euro’s per year.]</p><p>In live presentations, once the story has arrived at this point, people usually have two reactions and the two are closely interlinked.</p><p>The first is: ‘wow, this is great!’.</p><p>The second is ‘why aren’t we doing this?’</p><p>*) source: <a href="http://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/documents/PocketBook_ENERGY_2015%20PDF%20final.pdf">EC Pocketbook Energy 2015</a>.</p><h4>The thorium vision — a carbon free supplement for wind, water and solar energy</h4><p>Let’s start with the first: ‘wow, this is great!’</p><p>The vision of the thorium molten salt reactor is indeed impressive. Once it is realized, energy production becomes a whole new ballgame. This novel reactor type taps into a vast supply of carbon free energy. It promises to do so, by very efficiently using thorium, an abundant energy-dense resource, generating minimal amounts of nuclear waste that require safe storage for an overseeable period of 300 years. The energy production process of the molten salt reactor delivers safe and reliable energy at high temperatures. The heat can be used for highly efficient electricity production, but due to its high temperatures (up to 750 degrees Celsius) also as high quality industrial process heat. This allows for the production of bulk chemicals, including synthetic transport fuel for example.</p><p>Molten salt reactors can be designed in such a way that they can automatically ‘load follow’, making them ready for a future where energy is supplied by a multitude of intermittent sources like solar and wind.</p><p>Thorium is widely present on earth, and it is not a scarce resource. It is for example a byproduct from rare earth mining operations and currently stockpiled without being used. It is estimated that current mining operations each year excavate an amount of thorium that equals 40 years of worldwide energy production.</p><p>Thorium MSR’s may also offer strategic energy independence for a country. Any nation that runs on thorium MSR’s only needs very small amounts to produce its power, and a strategic supply of thorium could easily be bought. The Netherlands electricity demand would require a yearly supply of 14 tons of thorium — a quantity that easily fits in a truck. An Olympic swimming pool full of thorium, 2500 cubic meters, equals 2000 years of electric power for the Netherlands. At a price of 100 euro’s per kg, this quantity could be acquired at 200 euro’s per inhabitant. So in short, every country with thorium MSR’s could simply buy a strategic supply of thorium.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/315/1*mXA_Vwd8Az64kKzuwJbe3Q.png" /><figcaption>The dark colour of the sands of Ameland comes from monazite, a thorium mineral</figcaption></figure><p>*) For instance in the Netherlands, the dark sand on the beaches of Ameland contain high amounts of thorium. But it’s easier to buy thorium from one of the many countries with abundant mine tailings that contain large amounts of unused thorium and leave the beaches of Ameland as beautiful as they are.</p><h4>So where’s the catch?</h4><p>This inevitably leads to the next question: ‘why aren’t we doing this?’<br>There are two sets of reasons for this, one set is historic and the other one is the present day outcome of this history, a set of conditions that we need to face now if we want to see the vision of molten salt reactors realized. The easy answer to the above question is: 45 years ago, we took a wrong turn, and due to that, we are now 45 years lagging behind in research and development. But that is in hindsight, and this answer may be too easy. <br>Let’s look at some history first. In the 1950s and 1960s, the concept of the molten salt reactor emerged and was developed. These efforts resulted in the famous Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE), that had a molten salt reactor run flawlessly for more than four years, from 1965 to 1969. At first this reactor ran on uranium 235, the fissionable component of natural uranium that is also at the heart of conventional reactors. But in this reactor, the fuel was used in the form of a molten fluoride salt. Half way through the experiment, this fuel was taken out of the core and replaced by a fluoride salt of uranium 233, the uranium isotope that can only be made from thorium. And although the conversion of thorium into uranium 233 did not take place inside this reactor — this in situ conversion was planned for later experiments that were cancelled by president Nixon — the MSRE was the world’s first reactor that did run on uranium 233. The experiments were considered as a huge success by the experimenters. After the experiments some materials issues were found, but these were essentially solved by the Oak Ridge scientists not long after they became known.</p><p>In his autobiography ‘The First Nuclear Era’ Alvin Weinberg gives two reasons for the discontinuation of the MSR-program (p.130). The obvious reason is that competing fast breeder program arrived first and was therefore able to consolidate its position within the Atomic Energy Commission.</p><p>The other reason, as Weinberg states, is that the technology of the molten salt reactor was simply too different from the existing technology. And a technology too different has two hurdles to overcome: one is to demonstrate its feasibility. Another even greater one is to convince influential individuals and organizations who are intellectually and emotionally attached to a different technology.</p><p>Others see the discontinuation of the MSR-program at the time as a perfectly logical decision. At the time, there was already considerable experience with light water reactors. At the same time, the liquid metal fast reactor was already far in its development — at least, that was the widely held perception at the time. The combination of the LWR and the LMFBR together would form a closed uranium cycle. The choice for the LMFBR at the time was a logical one.</p><p>Now, more than forty years later, even an expert like Jan Leen Kloosterman said he thinks we ‘have taken a wrong turn, forty years ago’. What has happened in the meantime?</p><p>First, the program of the liquid metal fast breeder reactors, which politically outcompeted the molten salt reactor in the 1970s, in later decades turned out to be much more complex than originally thought. LMFBR’s, especially larger ones, showed to be difficult to design and operate in line with safety requirements that were justifiably enhanced and tightened over the years. This led to some of the costliest failures in the history of nuclear development. Germany’s Kalkar power plant, now famous as the theme park ‘Kernwasserwunderland’ (recommended!) is one of the more outstanding examples of politics betting on the wrong horse. And without fast reactors, light water reactors cannot create a ‘closed nuclear fuel cycle’.</p><p>In his biography, Weinberg concludes his discussion with the observation: <em>“[Molten salt] was a successful technology that was dropped because it was too different from the main lines of reactor development. But if weaknesses in other systems are eventually revealed, I hope that in a Second Nuclear Era, the molten-salt technology will be resurrected.”</em>(p.131)<br>We may extend this observation to three of our main energy technologies: fossil fuel uses the atmosphere as a waste dump, renewables are intermittent and light water reactors have a popularity problem. Now may be the perfect time to resurrect the molten-salt technology.</p><h4>The present time: technical challenges, regulatory practices that do not fit, uncertainties for investors and uncertain development times</h4><p>In essence, the molten salt reactor research needs to be picked up where it was left off in 1972. To an extent, the research of the MSRE experiments needs to be repeated as also experience needs to be rebuilt in line with current demands and standards, and present day regulators will not be satisfied with just references to the original Oak Ridge experiment reports, without the background of the people performing the tests.</p><p>Of course, there is no official list of technical challenges that are most relevant to the time frame that is needed to create the first working molten salt reactor in our age. Some scientists mention the challenge to find or develop materials that can withstand prolonged neutron flux at high temperatures. Others state that the chemical processes that need to take place within the demanding environment of a very hot reactor will need lots of research before they can be safely applied. Others claim that all of these challenges have long been solved — but within the context of other technologies. Some groups have recently come up with innovative ideas for processing aspects, like the Danish Waste Burner team, who came up with a novel idea to put existing laser sampling technology to work that allows for online screening for isotope mixtures — which may turn out to be a key ingredient in the challenge of adequate inventory tracking, a necessity for any future regulator that would be asked to license a molten salt reactor.</p><p>However, no one seriously contests that a lot of research work needs to be done. Especially because the combination of fuel and coolant creates a system in which chemistry, nuclear physics, material science and thermal-hydraulics can influence each other. As this cannot be predictively modelled in full detail, complex experiments to investigate material and salt behavior in its full complexity will be required to validate modelling and calculation tools that can reliably describe system behavior under all circumstances. This however does not mean that MSR complexity brings unsurmountable issues. So far, no show stoppers have been identified among the challenges of molten salt reactors. And the successful results of the four years of the MSRE stand firmly.</p><p>Which technical challenges will be the most relevant with regard to the development time frame, also depends on the choice of the type of reactor that is being pursued. The proposed trajectories differ widely..</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/337/1*tpW3VDPbLd_41AAcjIgBLw.png" /><figcaption>Some of the contestants in the evolving molten salt reactor race</figcaption></figure><p>The most straightforward plan is to rebuild the Oak Ridge reactor that was successfully demonstrated. This plan, issued by Thorcon Power, avoids all difficult technical issues by proposing to simply replace the whole reactor core every four to five years. At the other end of the spectrum we find what may be called the ‘ultimate thorium MSR’ — a complete power plant that runs on thorium, employs inline chemical treatment of all components in the process, and features a 45% highly efficient Brayton power conversion system. This is the plan of Kirk Sorensen’s Flibe Energy — and it is quite clear that Jan Leen Kloosterman of Delft Technical University has taken a keen interest in this version. In between we find reactor systems that are considered by its makers to be the most ‘doable’.</p><p>Terrestrial Energy’s IMSR is a case in point — they are designing a modular system that does not breed its own fuel but runs on pretty standard low enriched uranium. The IMSR however makes better use of this fuel than could be done in a light water reactor. By employing the molten salt technology, the IMSR leads to better fuel use, a better waste profile and adds the inherent safety of the reactor. TE may also be the first to show a working MSR. <a href="http://www.marketwired.com/press-release/-2100219.htm">The company recently announced their cooperation with the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission</a>, and their intention to build and operate the first commercial demonstration Integral Molten Salt Reactor plant in the 2020s.</p><h4><strong>The real challenge is to create an adequate regulatory framework, and generate the experimental data and experience to validate designs, MSR dedicated computational tools, and demonstrate MSR performance and safety</strong></h4><p>While every major technological innovation usually requires large upfront investments, innovative nuclear reactors have the extra challenge of proving their safety beforehand. With good reasons, of course: a critical nuclear system is not a toy, and should not be start up before all operational and safety features are fully known, tested and demonstrated. And while part of this testing can be done by either modelling or with non-nuclear tests, an important part will be nuclear tests. And nuclear testing almost by definition is expensive and usually takes much preparation time, because each test has to be carefully designed, discussed, redesigned and permission needs to be acquired from the regulator.</p><p>In the case of molten salt reactors, it is essential to first do an appropriate amount of experimental work, build up experience and expertise, and generate the data that will be needed for design and licensing. Those who aim to develop molten salt reactors need to acknowledge that a regulator can never beforehand give any guarantee whether they will approve a design. Safety is a first priority of a regulator, there should be no commercial pressure on the regulator.</p><p>In a recent Meet&amp;Greet’ session with the Thorium MSR Foundation in Delft, a representative of the Dutch regulatory authority explained to the audience that the essence of her task was easy to understand. The applicant needs to prove that his reactor will, under all circumstances, remain its ability to contain, cool and control its nuclear content. That requirement is the easy part.</p><p>The difficult part is to prove that it will. This demands a deep understanding of all materials and processes proposed for the design, both in normal operation and in exceptional situations. Much of this information will be design-specific for a certain reactor. The knowledge of all the various aspects will have to be built up by both the developer and the regulatory authority — a regulator can only assess what he or she understands. While the research, including all the necessary validation tests for materials and processes, will have to be payed by the developer.</p><p>And nobody, she added, can expect a regulator to build up this knowledge before there is a request to license a molten salt reactor. Also, no guarantee can be given beforehand that the design will ultimately be given its license. This would be incompatible with the regulator’s task to only license safe designs. This inevitably leads to high upfront cost for any designer of a novel reactor type.</p><p>Many see the large upfront investment and the long timeframe needed for development as an obstacle to attracting private investors in the early stage of development of MSR’s. Waiting for the market to make it happen does not seem a viable strategy. Like many breakthrough technologies before — including GPS, the Internet and the microchip — MSR’s will need a boost from government programs in order to materialize any time soon. Idealistic billionaires may offer an alternative option.</p><h4>A challenge that can be met by political will</h4><p>All of this is not to say that the challenges described cannot be met. They can be, the only requirement is the political will to meet them. There are signs that this political will is building up. The urgency of the climate change agenda has led prominent environmentalists and climate scientists to re-evaluate their previously held position on nuclear power. The vision of thorium in molten salt reactors has led others to release their previously held beliefs about the ban on all things nuclear. Along with those who already were in favor of nuclear power in the traditional form, these new pro-nuclear enthusiasts, including some that have the possibility and willingness to invest in its development, may just tip the scale. Once the political balance has shifted, molten salt reactors may be here much quicker than we now expect.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8454c7e5330c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world/the-comeback-of-the-molten-salt-reactor-8454c7e5330c">The comeback of the molten salt reactor</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thmsr-to-power-the-world">The articles section of thmsr.nl</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>