<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Gaby Swastika on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Gaby Swastika on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@gabyswastika?source=rss-80b2ba4bf9b3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 19:56:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@gabyswastika/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Manusia yang Bermain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gabyswastika/manusia-yang-bermain-fe197d691eed?source=rss-80b2ba4bf9b3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fe197d691eed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[homo-ludens]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spatial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[urban-studies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narrative]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gaby Swastika]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 May 2023 05:41:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-27T05:52:31.997Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“… and the people sat down to eat and drink and rose up to play.”</blockquote><h4>Homo Ludens</h4><p>Era globalisasi melekatkan dua atribut dalam tubuh warganya, selain menjadi warga, mereka sebagai konsumen juga (<em>citizen-consumer</em>). Atribut-atribut ini tidak bisa berdiri sendiri, jalin-menjalin antara keduanya makin erat di era globalisasi yang didorong oleh <em>creative industries</em>. Energi yang diperlukan oleh mereka, sebagai warga juga konsumen, adalah hasrat menjadi bebas dan hasrat pemenuhan rasa nyaman —<em> the desire of freedom and the desire for comfort</em> (Hartley, 2005). Hasrat terekspresikan dalam domain pemerintahan, di mana mereka terlibat dalam pencetusan dan penataan kebijakan-kebijakan pemerintah bagi publik Yogyakarta. Sebaliknya hasrat warga atas pendidikan, kesejahteraan, dan keamanan sosial patut dipenuhi; sedangkan sebagai konsumen, pemenuhan atas hiburan, media, <em>spectator tourism</em>, informasi, lebih banyak berada dalam domain ekonomi.</p><blockquote>The idea of the creative industries seeks to describe the conceptual and practical convergence of the creative arts (individual talents) with Cultural Industries (mass scale), in the context of new media technologies (ICTs) within a new knowledge economy, for the use of newly interactive citizen-consumer<em>s </em>(Hartley, 2005).</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bau4tc89Lrzl7QR3ubFzjA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Dance — Henri Matisse, 1910</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Konsep dan praktik kebudayaan di masa industri kreatif mampu bertumbuh di banyak tempat, di ruang-ruang yang bahkan jarang terpikirkan. Dalam wujud pemenuhan sebagai warga yang berdaya, baik secara individual maupun dalam kelompok, mereka memunculkan praksis dengan ide-ide kreatif. Konsep <em>Homo Ludens </em>“<em>Man the Player” </em>atau manusia bermain oleh Johan Huizinga (1990) saya bayangkan bisa dimainkan di kota-kota di Indonesia. Dengan wajah yang rupa-rupa dan akrab, dengan padu-padan budaya tradisi dan kontemporer, dengan tidak lupa atas sejarahnya dan koleksi memori untuk menuju kota hunian yang lebih baik.</p><p><em>Homo ludens </em>menampilkan aktivitas manusia bermain sebagai bagian dalam kebudayaan. Kebermainan manusia erat hubungannya dengan spontanitas, <a href="https://ceasefiremagazine.co.uk/walter-benjamin-art-aura-authenticity/">aura </a>(mengutip konsep yang ditawarkan Walter Benjamin), dan aktualisasi diri untuk menjadi manusia yang utuh — dalam konteks paragraf sebelumnya, sebagai warga yang berdaya secara utuh. Bermain mengandung aspek kegembiraan, kelegaan, penikmatan yang intensif, bebas dari kekangan atau kedukaan, berproses emansipatorik, dan semua ini hanya tercapai dalam suasana yang merdeka (Huizinga, 1990). Bermain, nyatanya, terikat pula oleh ruang dan waktu. […] <em>unique cultural context i.e.</em> <em>‘its presence in time and space’ as its ‘aura’.</em></p><p>Berkaca pada beberapa daerah yang sudah menerapkan konsep <em>homo ludens</em> dalam praksis hidupnya sebagai warga kota, seperti <em>artist</em> <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01130/full"><strong>Aldo van Eyck</strong></a><strong> </strong>yang membangun ratusan <a href="https://www.studiodmau.com/tracing-van-eyck"><em>playground</em> di Belanda</a>, muralis <a href="https://www.timeout.com/penang/art/street-art-by-ernest-zacharevic"><strong>Ernest Zacharevic</strong></a> yang menghiasi Penang dengan aksi muralnya, duo perupa <a href="https://www.mfa.org/programs/performance-art/tita-salina-and-irwan-ahmett-urban-play-playing-data"><strong>Ahmett-Salina</strong></a> yang memugar Jakarta dengan aksi permainan mereka <a href="https://rujak.org/urban-play/">“URBAN PLAY”</a>, atau para pemural yang mencatatkan <a href="https://www.instagram.com/street_art_jogja/?hl=en">arsip visual</a> mereka di tembok-tembok gang di kampung-kampung Yogyakarta. Dengan keberadaan opus ini, warga menjadi <em>citizen</em> sekaligus <em>consumer</em> atas artefak-artefak permainan yang tersebar di wilayah hunian mereka. Warga menjadi pemirsa atas aura yang ditampilkan oleh karya-karya perwujudan kebermainan para <em>artist</em>-nya.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/494/1*qPl-gmeM6k_kpBW4uOtrEw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Aldo van Eyck — Amsterdam circa 1947–1978</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*N9OEbo4jFAeQ24Bcn5ufhw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Aldo van Eyck — Amsterdam circa 1947–1978</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A-Kct-Bcxdramznq10syEw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Aldo van Eyck — Amsterdam circa 1947–1978</strong></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Space: To Consume and Be Consumed</strong></h4><p>Konsumsi seringkali dipahami secara sempit sebagai suatu proses atau aktivitas yang melibatkan pembelian dan pertukaran ekonomis, belum lagi dengan cap negatifnya, sebagai tindakan pemborosan (<em>waste</em>), <em>jor-joran</em> (<em>conspicuous</em>), atau pamer (<em>display</em>) (Budiman: 2002).</p><blockquote>To consume is to destroy. Consumption is associated with waste, with wanton dissipation, with decay. Consumptive bodies are those eaten away by disease. Fires consume. Conspicuous consumption―from the potlatch to the Polo shirt―is a waste: a public, visible, dramatic. We consume and are consumed (Silverstone, 1994).</blockquote><p>Konsumsi yang dipahami sebagai sesuatu yang negatif itu muncul karena selama ini masyarakat telah diekspansi oleh konsep ‘<em>the making</em>’ yang berada pada tataran produksi. Padahal, mode produksi turut meninggalkan jejak-jejak konsumsi atau ‘<em>the use</em>’, meski seringkali kalah pamor dengan mode produksi sehingga meninggalkan selubung dalam mode konsumsi. Dalam <em>The Practice of Everyday Life</em> disebutkan bahwa banyak―dan tidak sedikit di antaranya yang berpengaruh―kajian-kajian atas representasi masyarakat dan mode-mode tingkah laku dalam masyarakat. Analisis seperti ini pun bisa diterapkan pada penggunaan <em>urban space</em>, produk-produk yang dibeli di supermarket, cerita dan informasi-informasi yang disebarkan oleh surat kabar, dan seterusnya (Certeau, 1984).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wZfl0IO6G01tWQo4MF-PCA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Ernest Zacharevic melukiskan “Two Children on A Boat” di <em>Chew Jetty, George Town</em></strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s-m7CTjrVq4vbuFo1ioa_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Ernest Zacharevic membubuhkan opus karyanya di <em>Lebuh Armenian, George Town</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p>Kajian atas tempat (<em>place</em>) dikembangkan pada dasarnya karena hampir semua teori sosial dan budaya mengandung seluruh penjelasan atas tempat―atas relasi spasial, juga tidak lupa relasi temporal (waktu)―dengan cara-cara tersendiri. Konsep konsumsi menyebutkan bahwa konsumer seharusnya diberikan keleluasaan untuk mengindikasikan apa yang mereka gunakan atau lakukan, apa yang mereka konsumsi. Keterikatan antara aktivitas konsumsi dengan ruang tempat aktivitas ini berlangsung, dalam penjelasan John Urry (1995) disebabkan karena tempat (<em>place</em>) yang mewadahi aktivitas itu menyediakan konteks spasial (<em>spatial context</em>) yang di dalamnya benda ataupun jasa bisa digunakan, dibeli, dibandingkan, dan dievaluasi. Kondisi ini menandakan adanya restrukturasi, di mana tempat fisik telah terkontekstualisasi secara kultural sebagai ruang (<em>space</em>). Sebuah ruangan tidak berfungsi semata-mata hanya sebagai latar fisik, melainkan juga sebagai pusat-pusat konsumsi <em>(centres of consumption</em>) yang mengelilinginya. John Urry menjelaskan pemikirannya atas <em>mobile spatializations</em> dan <em>relational space</em>, yang mana keduanya melibatkan distribusi di antara agensi, tempat dan ruang, dan himpunan material.</p><p>Tak ayal George Town diakui sebagai salah satu pusat kebudayaan spasial dengan lanskap kota dan arsitektural yang khas di Malaysia. Adalah satu kawasan yang didapuk sebagai <em>UNESCO World Heritage Site</em>. Bila bicara soal Jakarta, tak habis-habis argumen kita menyoal ibukota Indonesia ini — mulai dari tata kota, sistem transportasi publik, hingga pusat kuliner miniatur Indonesia dan pusat dagang. Atau Yogyakarta, sebagai kota kelahiran penulis, persoalan kota “istimewa” ini juga tak luput dari stereotipe kota<em> klangenan, </em>namun sarat dengan isu rasisme dan kemiskinan. Beranjak dari Asia Tenggara, ada Amsterdam yang telah disebutkan di atas. Sebagai ibukota dari negeri Belanda; Amsterdam adalah kota tempat bercokol koleksi seniman-seniman dunia di museum yang tersebar di sana: Van Gogh Museum, the Rijksmuseum, atau the Stedelijk. <em>City branding</em> ‘I Amsterdam’ bercokol di kota ini dan menjadi pusat urban, meski saat ini <em>sign </em>I Amsterdam sudah dipindahkan oleh pemerintah kota.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KFQeIHJmOEFA_hAE87oZcA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Mural berlokasi di Jalan Bhayangkara, Yogyakarta (2014) — Arsip IG @street_art_jogja</strong></figcaption></figure><h4>Bermain-main dengan Kontestasi Spasial</h4><p>Permainan di kota menjadi salah satu pembacaan akan kota, sebagaimana yang ditulis oleh de Certeau (1984), “<em>A city composed of paroxysmal places in monumental reliefs.</em> <em>The spectator can read in it a universe that is constantly exploding.</em>” Dengan ledakan-ledakan permainan di kota-kota saat ini tidak akan sama dengan kondisi yang lalu dan yang akan datang. Bila melihat foto-foto di atas, foto sudah diarsipkan sejak tahunan yang lalu. Bisa jadi di area yang sama di tahun 2023, situasi berubah — permainan berubah. Warga dan pemerintah kota terlibat dalam permainan, namun dengan strategi yang tidak sama. Pemerintah berstrategi untuk menata kota sebab kuasanya sebagai aparatus, sementara warga bertaktik agar tetap hidup. Agar tak melulu susah, maka dari itu butuh bermain. Sematan <em>citizen cum consumer</em> kepada warga acapkali membuat permainan tidak selalu mulus. Selalu ada kontestasi dalam aktivitas <em>homo ludens</em> ini. Mulai dari keterbatasan lahan bermain, persoalan batas publik-privat dalam keseharian, regulasi, inter- dan dis-koneksi dari sejarah lampau dan proyeksi kecanggihan masa datang. Semuanya jalin kelindan dan terejawantahkan dalam wujud material, dalam artefak-artefak budaya yang ditemukan. <em>Playground</em>, mural, grafiti, taman, alun-alun, trotoar, museum, perpustakaan; bisa di dekat rumah, di gang kampung, di jalan utama, di bangunan publik, dan sebagainya. Permainan dalam <em>homo ludens</em> bila dipertemukan dengan konteks spasial pada akhirnya bukan hanya perkara seorang diri, melainkan sesuatu yang komunal — melibatkan pihak lain dalam level setara atau atas-bawah.</p><p>Mengembalikan lagi ujaran Johan Huizinga atas <em>homo ludens</em>:</p><blockquote>“A free activity standing quite consciously outside ‘ordinary’ life as being ‘not serious,’ but at the same time absorbing the player intensely and utterly. It is an activity connected with no material interest, and no profit can be gained by it. It proceeds within its own proper boundaries of time and space according to fixed rules and in an orderly manner. It promotes the formation of social groupings which tend to surround themselves with secrecy and to stress their difference from the common world by disguise or other means.</blockquote><p>Maka sepuluh tahun berselang sejak arsip foto mural di Yogyakarta, tahun 2024 mendatang, bisakah kita atur permainan baru atau mengambil yang pernah ada untuk menciptakan taktik baru dalam permainan? Masih terlibatkan warga dalam model permainan di tempat hunian mereka, seberapa terlibatkan mereka juga dengan penciptaan “aura” dari seniman-senimannya? Atau justru sepuluh tahun adalah waktu yang kurang untuk merefleksikan kondisi ini?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/995/1*f3u4omOTEOTqWZgrrTsyUw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Dance — Henri Matisse, 1910</strong></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fe197d691eed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From Kotabaru to Tiong Bahru: The Privy Narrative]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gabyswastika/from-kotabaru-to-tiong-bahru-the-privy-narrative-4e663e85cb15?source=rss-80b2ba4bf9b3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4e663e85cb15</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[southeast-asia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narrative]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sea]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gaby Swastika]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Feb 2022 11:01:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-09T12:28:36.420Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>This writing comes as an outcome of “(Re)constructing Southeast Asia”, a summer course program conducted by Center of Southeast Asian Social Studies UGM that I attended in 2021. Happy reading!</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jYuqyTUI7REDY2MOZy2gQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Map of Southeast Asia | Courtesy: thelancet.com/journal</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Southeast Asia at A Glance</strong></h4><p>Let’s look at Southeast Asia! SEA is a sub-region within an area of 4,545,792 km2, SEA has population of 655 million people or about 8.5% of the world’s population. SEA is the third most populous region in Asia after South Asia and East Asia. SEA is a sub-region of Asia located in the southern hemisphere. The SEA population living in urban areas reaches 50% in this 21st century era (Wikipedia, 2021). In the division of the SEA region, it consists of two kinds of geographic regions, namely: 1) mainland SEA known as the Indochinese Peninsula — or in history it is often called Indochina, consisting of Cambodia, Laos, Peninsular Malaysia, Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam. Then 2) maritime SEA which is often referred to as the Malay Archipelago or in history it bears the name of Nusantara, consisting of Brunei, East Malaysia, East Timor, Indonesia, the Philippines, and Singapore. SEA now consists of 11 countries with a diverse ethnic group, languages, and religions. In explaining SEA, we need to explain regionalism, meaning that we have an awareness of a region more than a geographical matter but an identity that is formed due to proximity, it is the proximity that encourages countries in the region to cooperate in one or more of the modes to achieve common goals, to meet common needs, and to solve multi problems, ranging from political, economic, social, cultural, defense and security aspects (Connors, Davison, &amp; Dosch, 2018).</p><p>Starting from an understanding of SEA regionalism, I compiled this essay based on two frameworks to highlight social phenomena related to SEA. Firstly, is identification of the school of thought that we can build from within the region and secondly is the continuity of doing critical, reconstructive, research work informing policy intervention as well as being incorporated into the local knowledge. In this essay I discuss what I understand in the perspective of media and cultural studies that focuses on social spaces in urban life. The two countries discussed here are Indonesia and Singapore, which are represented by two cities, namely Yogyakarta with the emergence of a social space in Kotabaru and Singapore with a social space in Tiong Bahru.</p><h4><strong>Kotabaru and Tiong Bahru</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/859/1*yBXzYEBNZrkG6weQnmz8Eg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Niuwe Wijk, the old name of Kotabaru, Yogyakarta | Courtesy: kebudayaan.jogjakota.go.id</em></figcaption></figure><p>In recent times, when the sense of sight moves in many directions and points of interest, it is possible to find various artifacts placed in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. The abundance of artifacts decorates the area called the Special Region of Yogyakarta — or more familiarly called Jogja, Yogya, or Yogyakarta. One of the quintessential areas is Malioboro, starting from its street leading to downtown, you are sure to find a lot of artworks situated on the sides of the road. Murals cannot be separated from the eye, poster art making a comeback with critical and satire messages. According to data released by Central Bureau of Statistics, Yogyakarta as the capital of the Special Region of Yogyakarta, has an area of 32 km2 and is inhabited by more than 435,000 people, while the population density is more than 12,000 people per square kilometer (BPS DIY, 2020). Yogyakarta itself is etymologically derived from the equivalent of two Sanskrit words; ‘yogya’ which means appropriate or worthy, while ‘karta’ refers to the meaning of advanced and prosperous.</p><p>In addition, Yogyakarta has architectural heritage that conceives historical and architectural value, especially Dutch colonial heritage buildings. One area that is thick with Dutch colonial-style architecture is Kotabaru. Moreover, Kotabaru has a story that is closely related to the Yogyakarta Palace. If other areas in downtown Yogyakarta are dominated by the face of the building, it is different from Kotabaru. This area is surrounded by shady trees with an airy roadside and the surrounding of Kotabaru is quite wide. At the beginning of its formation, Kotabaru was designed with the concept of garden city. The emergence of Kotabaru was initially a settlement for the Dutch colonials outside the main settlements around the Yogyakarta Palace. Kotabaru was built because at that time sugarcane plantations were widely targeted as a business for the Dutch, so they needed to reside in Yogyakarta. Cornelis Canne as resident asked Sri Sultan Hamengkubuwono VII for permission to use the land in the north of the city for a settlement for Europeans. The available land was located at the east of Code River (Sungai Code) which was eventually built as a residential area called <em>nieuwe wijk</em>. Kotabaru then became a residential area for the Dutch which was built after World War I in 1877–1921. After the independence period, striking physical changes occurred in the Kotabaru area, especially after 1997. This occurred after residential buildings began to change into other functions which mainly functioned as commercial buildings (shops and restaurants), office buildings, health buildings, and educational buildings. Various efforts have been made to protect Kotabaru so that the image of the area is maintained. These efforts include the stipulation of Kotabaru as a Cultural Conservation Area of the Special Region of Yogyakarta (Kawasan Cagar Budaya Daerah Istimewa Yogyakarta). This was stated in the Regional Regulation No. 6 of 2012 concerning the Preservation of Cultural Heritage and Cultural Conservation. It was stated in the regional regulation that the architectural guidelines for new buildings in the Kotabaru Cultural Heritage area are set using indies and colonial architectural styles. It has aimed to sustain Kotabaru, especially its physical aspects, which includes a smaller area and spatial sphere. The strong characteristic of the area lies in the radial pattern and wide green open space. When you enter Kotabaru, you will get a different atmosphere from other Yogyakarta areas, most of its surrounding and settlement are still arranged according to the cardinal directions. Large, shade, and garden trees are abundant in this area. There is a large green area in Kotabaru which is equipped with a boulevard and a wide road with trees on the left and right (DPAD Provinsi DIY, 2013).</p><p>Looking at the history of the formation of cities in Indonesia, there are two types of cities; port cities which are used as trading points and have international shipping lanes or inland cities as administrative centers located in agricultural areas. Inland cities are built on the banks of rivers, while trading cities exist as coastal cities. Indeed, the city is always new, because there are always new elements introduced in the city. The new civilization in the public space gets mediation on the highway, with the rapid growth rate of motorized vehicles, regulations are held with the function of mediator. The existence of traffic lights, road markings, horns — as instruments attached to motorized vehicles, makes it possible for citizens to be civilized on the roads. Civilization is formed from the cross-influence of a culture, which inherits and inherits all history, with new findings from that era. Therefore, being in a city or having a city is a relatively new event for the Indonesian people, which in this case is also in Yogyakarta (Raihana, 2007). The task of healthy Yogyakarta lies in structuring and maximizing the function of the highway, as well as restoring the nature of pedestrians and people with disabilities to get proper rights.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/645/1*EYfixogg1cQxFPwN1qK8Bg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Tiong Bahru in 1956 | Courtesy: Wong Kwan Collection/National Archives of Singapore</em></figcaption></figure><p>What about Tiong Bahru? Tiong Bahru today is more than three kilometers from Redhill MRT on its west end and Outram Road on its east end. For Singaporeans themselves, Tiong Bahru is not a large area, but this area has its own charm with its chic housing estate awash with good eaters and eclectic shops. However, Tiong Bahru is not only a hip area, but this area holds many historical stories, heritage trails, and its marked sites show. The art deco-style buildings in Tiong Bahru have been around since the 1930s when the area was first developed through public housing programs by the Singapore Improvement Trust (SIT) — the colonial predecessor to the Housing and Development Board (HDB). Around 50 blocks of low-rise apartments and shophouses were the first buildings to be built in this area to provide residential access apart from the increasingly crowded Chinatown area. Singaporeans used the name Tiong Bahru long before this name became legal. Tiong Bahru itself is used based on its etymology, consisting of two words ‘tiong’ which means ‘to die’ (verb) or ‘in the end’ (adverb) in the Hokkien dialect, which is embedded with ‘bahru’ which means ‘new’ in Malay language. Tiong Bahru was eventually used by residents to refer to a new area as opposed to an old cemetery (Tiong Lama). Prior to the early 20th century, Tiong Bahru was an underdeveloped area. Most of the land in this area is used for agriculture and burial areas, entering the development period this area began to be occupied by traders who built their new businesses. Merchants began to build residential houses and shopping areas along the road. SIT also engaged in building this area in the 1920s, the first major housing project was an estate of 118 semi-detached villas known as the Lavender Street Estate, following this were two large blocks of tenements with 250 rooms each in Kreta Ayer which built in 1930 (Tan, 2013).</p><p>Like the human body, the road is the pulse. The stretch that the city is alive, not dying, can be seen from the ‘health’ of the streets within. Why is that? Everyone accesses roads; roads where residents interact across settlements, as well as highways that are associated with one common interest — arriving at their destination. There are many roles within the roads in a city. In the beginning the street was also a market. Markets often give birth to downstream cities (Raihana, 2007). The era of globalization attaches two attributes to the bodies of its citizens, apart from being citizens, they are also consumers (citizen-consumers). These attributes cannot stand alone, the intertwining between the two is getting closer in the era of globalization driven by creative industries. The energy needed by them, as citizens as well as consumers, is the desire to be free and the desire to fulfill a sense of comfort — the desire of freedom and the desire for comfort. The desire for freedom is expressed in the domain of government, where they are involved in the formulation and arrangement of government policies for the Yogyakarta public. Citizens’ desires for education, welfare, and social security must be fulfilled. Meanwhile, as a consumer, the fulfillment of entertainment, media, spectator tourism, information, is mostly in the economic domain (Hartley, 2005).</p><h4>Space in SEA: Consumed and Consuming</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*J0NAegtnaHnBRw6aFOBjnA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kotabaru settlement | Courtesy: Wijaya Kusuma/KOMPAS.com</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nIZiOyGYpXKpWWT9oKQSJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Tiong Baru district | Courtesy: theculturetrip.com</figcaption></figure><p>From the illustration above, we can see how the condition of the roads that are connected to each other in the Kotabaru and Tiong Bahru. Roads in Southeast Asia are closely related to the trade sector and are filled with interactions between people from many groups and social classes. The road, therefore, can be understood as a place for displacement, the road is a place to pass, the road accommodates the movement of various forms, postures, and various human forms (Jacobs as quoted by Raihana, 2007). Life in Southeast Asian cities, in this essay represented by Kotabaru (Yogyakarta) and Tiong Bahru (Singapore) indicate a form of space that is used for the growth of trade, not only for access to motorized vehicles and pedestrians. ‘Life between buildings’ provides opportunities as well as challenges for its residents. The road is the space for the most residents found in a city, the road is also the largest in terms of area and accommodates the most interaction.</p><p>Since becoming an infrastructure, the road is no longer just an inhabited anthropological space, but also an instrumental space consumed by individuals who ride through it (Raihana, 2007). The study of place was developed basically because almost all social and cultural theories contain all explanations of place―on spatial relations, also not forgetting temporal (time) relations―in their own ways. The concept of consumption states that consumers should be given the freedom to indicate what they use or do, what they consume. The attachment between consumption activity and the space in which this activity takes place, in John Urry explanation is caused because the place that accommodates the activity provides a spatial context in which objects or services can be used, purchased, compared, and evaluated. This condition indicates the physical place has been culturally contextualized as space. A room does not function solely as a physical setting, but also as centers of consumption that surround it (Urry, 1995). A space does not function as a physical setting, but also as centers of consumption that surround it.</p><p>In Kotabaru; residents live and grow in their home environment side by side with educational and religious activities, with trade, banking, and health activities. Even though it has been built for years since the Dutch colonial government; the image of a shady, cool, spacious settlement surrounded by charming architecture remains in Kotabaru. Not to mention, the area which is in the center of Yogyakarta city makes it easy for residents to access. Kotabaru also implies a strong history as well as another Indonesian city tells the stories of postcolonialism. Postcolonialism describes the ongoing process of resistance and reconstruction in the colonized nations. Postcolonial theory investigates experiences of forms of repression, resistance, race, gender, representation, difference, displacement, and migration in relation to the west (Sardar &amp; Van Loon, 1997). <em>Post-colonialism</em> is not defined as after-colonialism, postcolonialism does not refer to a certain period, but refers to the point of view of the effects of colonialism and its practical impacts. Postcolonialism encompasses all cultures and peoples at any time in their history that were influenced by European colonialism.</p><p>Meanwhile, for Tiong Bahru, the city basically always brings out something new. New cars took control of cities in the United States in the 1950s, so both developed and developing countries are experiencing a new civilization driven by motorized transportation and technology. The new civilization in the public space in the form of crowds gets mediation such as traffic lights, signs, road markings, horns, and so on (Raihana, 2007). Tiong Bahru which was originally an underdeveloped area developed due to trade and development by the government, including new regulations for residents to live in as new settlements. Currently, Tiong Bahru is no longer known as a settlement for senior citizens but is also a classy area as a tourist and trade destination. These two areas show evidence, especially when talking about social spaces in Southeast Asia, which are free from the snares of orientalism and have developed since the colonial period.</p><p>The city is ultimately a readable text. As quoted by de Certeau, “A city composed of paroxysmal places in monumental reliefs. The spectator can read in it a universe that is constantly exploding” (de Certeau, 1984). This is where the ability to measure and assess the function of a city becomes relevant in studying the context of places we live in because urbanization occurs in one city and another with different speeds and levels. Furthermore, everyday things need to be read by urban dwellers to develop their understanding of the lived text in the form of a city. We know about our cities through direct involvement as individuals who ‘make do’ — do something in it — and reproduce it, one of which in this case is the narrative I have told from Kotabaru to Tiong Bahru. The existence of our trajectory in the city is the basis for a set of actions and operations from one point to another which is a series of events. My personal journey through the changing Southeast Asia has given a better understanding, SEA has now become a reality. Initially constructed for strategic purposes, SEA has facilitated the transformation of the concept into a reality, SEA has also led to the feeling of ‘Southeast Asianess’ among its people. SEA is now transforming its identity and taking a place of European dominance for centuries.</p><p><strong>References</strong><br> — BPS DIY. (2020, December 1). <em>Badan Pusat Statistik Provinsi D.I. Yogyakarta</em>. Retrieved December 5, 2021, from yogyakarta.bps.go.id: <a href="https://yogyakarta.bps.go.id/indicator/12/133/1/jumlah-penduduk-menurut-kabupaten-kota-di-d-i-yogyakarta-.html">https://yogyakarta.bps.go.id/indicator/12/133/1/jumlah-penduduk-menurut-kabupaten-kota-di-d-i-yogyakarta-.html</a><br> — Certeau, M. d. (1984). <em>The Practice of Everyday Life</em>. Berkeley: University of California Press.<br> — Connors, M. K., Davison, R., &amp; Dosch, J. (2018). <em>The New Global Politics of the Asia-Pacific: Conflict and Cooperation in the Asian Century (Vol. 3rd)</em>. London: Routledge.<br> — DPAD Provinsi DIY. (2013, December 28). <em>Kawasan Cagar Budaya Kotabaru Yogyakarta</em>. Retrieved December 5, 2021, from dpad.jogjaprov.go.id: <a href="http://dpad.jogjaprov.go.id/article/library/vieww/kawasan-cagar-budaya-kotabaru-yogyakarta-522">http://dpad.jogjaprov.go.id/article/library/vieww/kawasan-cagar-budaya-kotabaru-yogyakarta-522</a><br> — Hartley, J. (. (2005). <em>Creative Industries</em>. London: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.<br> — Raihana, H. (2007). <em>Negara di Persimpangan Jalan Kampusku</em>. Yogyakarta: Kanisius.<br> — Sardar, Z. S., &amp; Van Loon, B. (1997). <em>Introducing Cultural Studies</em>. UK: Totem Book.<br> — Tan, K. Y. (2013). <em>Tiong Bahru. Singapore: National Heritage Board</em>.<br> — Urry, J. (1995). <em>Consuming Places</em>. London: Routledge.<br> — Wikipedia. (2021, December 4). <em>Southeast Asia</em>. Retrieved December 5, 2021, from wikipedia.org: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southeast_Asia">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southeast_Asia</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4e663e85cb15" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Observant Club: Tasting Soto, Pursuing Body]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gabyswastika/the-observant-club-tasting-soto-pursuing-body-d845be9cfad2?source=rss-80b2ba4bf9b3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d845be9cfad2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesian-food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food-studies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gaby Swastika]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 19 Jan 2022 03:18:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-24T06:34:32.680Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*du6vBK9gd56EpQ3eGL67jg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Soto Ayam | Source: iStock</figcaption></figure><blockquote>Thank you <a href="https://www.instagram.com/_indiani_/">Mbak Indi</a> for the thorough translation. We are no longer lost. :) Since 2020 Mbak Indi has also established and arranged independent food media, called BUMBU. You can check all her publication through its <a href="https://eatymologist.com/">website.</a></blockquote><p>I was immediately interested when I first heard of its name. Appealing. The Observant Club, the club of observant people — which later I find out it was based on particular basic human need excitement towards foods. I was invited to be part of the second observation by the main hosts, <a href="https://www.instagram.com/dreamiy/">Mira</a> and <a href="https://www.instagram.com/ditoyuwono/">Dito</a>, the initiator of <a href="https://www.instagram.com/lirspace/"><strong>Lirspace</strong></a><strong> in Yogyakarta, Indonesia</strong>. I was first introduced to <a href="https://www.instagram.com/theobservantclub/"><strong>The Observant Club</strong></a> in early 2016 when they did <em>Calibrating Sense Project</em>. Hence, I was captivated for the second time in the idea of <strong>The Soto Project</strong>… for we will explore one of my favorite food: soto.</p><p>This dish served with broth, well-seasoned with spices, enhanced by <em>sambal</em> (chili sauce); all combined as my favorite dish. Other than the component ingredients, broth is the prominent key in creating a tasteful bowl of soto. In Indonesia, soto is not a rare dish, it can be found in almost every province all over Indonesia. William Wongso once said, “<em>Tak ada yang bernama makanan Indonesia. Yang ada hanyalah masakan atau makanan daerah</em>.” (“There is no such thing as Indonesian food, instead there is only typical regional food and dish.”(Tempo Magazine, 2014). It implies that we can call every typical regional dish as “Indonesian dish”, while in the other hand it is difficult to pinpoint the correlation between each dish. This disparity becomes Indonesian food’s general characteristics. I agree that it is indeed hard to identify singular so-called “Indonesian dish” amidst many cultural culinary differences; hence, it’s impossible to represent Indonesia through one or two types of dishes only.</p><p>That is why, before we start the preliminary gathering of The Observant Club, we started with a common understanding between the two hosts and three observers: during the whole program we have to be present at Lirspace to taste each different soto variant from all over Indonesia. The first gathering was on January 30th, 2016 when we tasted different variant of soto from outside Java; among those are: <strong>coto makassar, soto padang, and soto banjar.</strong> The second gathering was on February 6th when we ‘jumped’ to the eastern region of Indonesia to taste soto with East Javanese nuance, for instance: <strong>soto sulung from Madura, soto blitar, soto lamongan, and soto surabaya.</strong> The testing-activity continued by exploring the West Java and Jakarta’s typical soto at the third gathering on February 13th. At that time, we tasted four variants of soto: <strong>soto bandung, soto mie jakarta, soto betawi, and soto tangkar.</strong> The last gathering explored the soto from Central Java, such as: <strong>soto sokaraja, soto semarang, soto kudus, and tauto tegal. </strong>But then again, we have to emphasize that The Observant Club is never meant to be any kind of jury who will state which one is the best or the worst soto. We also never meant to upload the directory of soto’s vendor location nor practical information about the price.</p><p>In a discourse, specific geographical sites comprised in various component of taste, and that is the starting point of the specific characteristic and gastronomic combination. In the practice of degustation, when someone bite and chew the food in his mouth and absorbed it in one’s body; his taste bud will surely give a particular reaction of what he ate; at this point, the cultural and natural opulence merge into one. Universally, the practice of eating and drinking are distinctive process that presents the natural sphere of influence into the domain of human’s body. At this point, the mundane daily routine went beyond the function of body defense. Food is also about taste, sociality, spirituality, and aesthetic (Trubek, 2008).</p><p>All three observers were given the freedom to write whatever feedback as an observation result of this club, aside from all those points that I mentioned before. First, I would like to see it from geographical point of view, “Why the specificity of a region becomes necessary?” The location refers to the dissemination map of soto we create after every testing-session. We paste bright colorful dots on the Indonesian map to mark which region serve soto as part of their daily menu and which one of those we have tasted. The result, of course, was unbalance. The number of soto we had tasted fall far behind the abundance of soto variant available all over Indonesia. Partly, it was because not every variant of soto from each region in Indonesia were available to be sold in Yogyakarta. Furthermore, not every soto has traveled from its original location to the newest part of the disseminated location where it merge with its new region, new taste buds, new cultural atmosphere, and most importantly — the absence of the individual who has the capability to introduce them in Yogyakarta. This is where the interesting part begins. Apparently, soto manifests itself in to something that correlate people’s desire to be transported to a specific location he wanted to go. We took this occasion to go through all those locations via soto: Makassar, Semarang, Bandung, Kudus, Madura, and so on. “To have been there” was one of a goal of this degustation practice and the club’s careful observation.</p><p>Is that true? Can we actually “been there” without physically went to the specific geographical location? In some cultural studies, the concept of originality is an old concept that needs to be upgraded; especially those in the context of the culinary sphere. The destination that was anticipated by this old concept was caused by the conviction that originality is correlated with haute couture. This discourse placed the original higher than whatever considered as less-original. Based on my mere observation, it is very difficult to find authenticity and originality in the culinary sphere because of its nature that tends to merge with other influences. Hybridity, according to Homi K. Bhabha, dwell in a bowl of soto. Going through the history can be a winding and exhaustible process — thus, I will leave it out from my text.</p><p>Hybridity in a bowl of soto was originated by its various ingredients: the spices, <em>bihun</em> (rice noodle), <em>santan</em> (coconut milk) or milk, the choice of meat stuffing, or even the serving tableware. Everything merged into a new variant of soto. In that case, have we visited each region through soto? I do believe so… When someone takes the chance to taste a piece of place through food, what do we get from this? Instead of turning into blind-eyed snob who put originality in a higher position than it was supposed to be, one turn into cosmopolites: open-minded, humble, and confident. Food, after all, is not only about consuming, digesting, and survival. Food and the rite of eating are also about perception. The variant of food offered can be understood as an extension of human’s desire for “Eating is both physical necessity and a cultural site where elaborate social rituals take place” (Finkelstein &amp;Lynch, 2006).</p><p>Another aspect that was highlighted in this soto degustation project, The Soto Project, is not only limited on the physical act of biting, chewing, and<br>digesting; but also about its visual appeal. The celebration of visual fascination gets even more extravagant in this industrial era. The path started from the mode of production to consumption, showing how the mass transformed from ‘being’ to ‘having’ and moving toward ‘appearing’. That was one of the reasons why we chose to document The Soto Project through Instagram: visual, visual, visual! There were two strong contradictory statements about the visual images in our daily life performed; first, “seeing is believing”, and second, “appearances are deceptive”. How do you see soto with your eyes compared to its appearance in social media or when the image is massively reproduced through mass media, which one is more appealing? Or on the other hand, will it lessen your appetite because it might look artificial?</p><p>The visual culture itself can be described as material artifacts, physical building or images that create aesthetic end result; symbolic, ritualistic, ideological, has practical function and a purpose to create meaning in the sense of sight (Walker &amp; Chaplin, 1997). Those visual images become more and more persuasive every day, it is easy to duplicate and extended to be what Freud referred as “scopophilia” — the erotica-pleasure triggered by the activity of seeing.</p><p>We eat every day, not only as a practical way of surviving; the practice of eating is beyond survival matter. The Observant Club tries to highlight how this practice of everyday life can be presented to public in a non-trivial manner. In the practice of everyday life, what Certeau refers as a “way of operating” (de Certeau, 1984) or the practice of doing something appears as more than just dark marginalized background; and instead, the doers try to present it as a form of articulation. It includes the act of gathering, the weekly appointment to eat together, tasting the soto served on the table one by one. The portion of each soto is carefully rationed so none of us will get too stuffed before the gathering ends. The beverages served are carefully chosen to clear the palate and refresh us from the exposure of spices and herbs. Then, we make a record of each soto we taste, its ingredients, the herb and spices, the side dish, the conversations that goes along the way, and also put a colourful dot on the culinary map we made. These miniscule procedures that employ each individual need to take into account in creating a discourse. The ways if operating merge numerous sporadic practices in association with the production of individual meaning in its sociocultural context.</p><p>At this point, I want to see another point: the relation between body and consumption. Mike Featherstone (cited Miller (ed), 1995) stated how important is the body in the culture of modern consumption, not only because it is closely related to the biological process; but also because the practice of eating out is apparently stressing more on the physical image rather than biological reality. This has meant that the human body has been considered more as a medium of expression, or as an object for aesthetic contemplation, or even as the model for self-construction, than in terms of its direct connection with eating and drinking. The Observant Club tries to underline the involvement of the body in the practice of daily life, either consciously or not. There are many things I could describe in this bodily experience in each gathering: the rites of eating, talking, taking notes, face to face meeting, preparing and cleaning up the serving table, and also the presence in a specific location: Lirspace. Lirspace becomes the center of the whole practice. Do we realize that Lirspace and The Observant Club have consumed so many things? But the label of being consumptive is neither the one thing to be afraid of nor the thing I want to discuss.</p><p>Consumption is understood as a negative term because the society has been expanded with the concept of “the making” that sits on the production level. In fact, the mode of production leaves many trails of consumption or “the use”, even though it is not as well-known as the mode of production that covers the mode of consumption. Michel de Certeau explains in <em>The Practice of Everyday Life</em> (1984) that in the progressing understanding or representation of a society and more of operation, he considers consumption as an important component to determine a group or individuals. The consumer should be given the freedom to indicate what they will use or do about those products. Consumption is more than just an economic activity — the consumption of product or commodity to satisfy a material need; consumption is also about aspiration, desire, identity, and communication. The mode of consumption of a cultural product is not only represented as a private, atomic, or passive process; but also as a social, relational, and an active practice. This process has three characteristic: consumption practice which is inseparable with its spatial-temporal context; performed as a fluid, uncertain, and spontaneous practice; and it often runs without the subject’s extensive consciousness (Budiman, 2002). I wish by understanding this, the simple practice of eating soto will not stop us from exploring more complex issues. Now, I can only explore it through a certain angle while some other might see it from another perspective. The chance to explore this subject is still wide open. Eat well and have a will to know what you eat. <em>Bon appetit</em>!</p><p><strong>SOURCE<br> — </strong>Budiman, Kris, 2002, Di depan Kotak Ajaib: Menonton Televisi sebagai Praktik Konsumsi, Yogyakarta: Galang Press.<br> <strong>—</strong> de Certeau, Michel, 1984, The Practice of Everyday Life, Berkeley: University of California Press.<br><strong> — </strong>Finkelstein, Joanne &amp; Rob Lynch, 2006, “Eating out and the Appetite for Leisure” in Chris Rojek dkk (eds), A Handbook of Leisure Studies, Palgrave MacMillan.<br><strong> — </strong>Trubek, Amy B, 2008, The Taste of Place, California: University of California Press. Walker, John A. and Sarah Chaplin, 1997, Visual Culture: An Introduction, Manchester: Manchester University Press.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d845be9cfad2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Observant Club: Mencicipi Soto, Menelusuri Tubuh]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gabyswastika/the-observant-club-mencicipi-soto-menelusuri-tubuh-dfe38ef9e413?source=rss-80b2ba4bf9b3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dfe38ef9e413</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gastronomy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[food-studies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[soto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gaby Swastika]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Dec 2021 05:42:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-24T06:35:53.372Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>PS. Tulisan ini pertama kali dibuat di medio 2016 untuk kebutuhan laporan observasi, kali ini saya unggah ulang di Medium sebab dirasa masih relevan— termasuk di dalamnya terdapat beberapa pemutakhiran. Selamat membaca!</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/874/1*4PBLySTaIwKAagBFZ-Ag2g.png" /><figcaption>Salah satu varian soto, soto betawi. Sumber: unileverfoodsolutions.co.id</figcaption></figure><p>Pertama kali mendengar namanya, saya langsung menaruh minat. Menarik. <strong><em>The Observant Club</em></strong>, atau klab para pengamat — yang setelah saya ketahui berbasis pada kebutuhan manusia sekaligus kegemarannya terhadap makanan. Saya diikutsertakan dalam tim pada obervasi kedua klab ini, diajak oleh oleh dua <em>host</em>, Mira dan Dito, empunya <a href="https://www.instagram.com/lirspace/">LIR Space</a>. Kali pertama mampir ke LIR saya dijelaskan aktivitas apa yang hendak dikerjakan <em>The Observant Club </em>awal tahun 2016 ini. Alhasil, saya kepincut untuk kedua kalinya… Sebab apa yang akan kami lakukan adalah penelusuran salah satu masakan favorit saya, yaitu soto.</p><p>Masakan berkuah, dengan citarasa bumbu, terlebih bila ditambahkan sambal, adalah masakan favorit saya. Selain isian di dalam soto, kaldu menjadi kunci kenikmatan dalam semangkuk soto yang saya santap. Soto di Indonesia bukanlah barang langka, masakan ini nyaris bisa didapat di banyak provinsi di Indonesia. William Wongso pernah berujar, “Tak ada yang bernama makanan Indonesia. Yang ada hanyalah masakan atau makanan daerah” (Majalah Berita Mingguan Tempo, 2014). Artinya kita bisa menyatakan semua jenis masakan berasal dari wilayah Indonesia sebagai “masakan Indonesia”, di saat yang sama kita tidak bisa melihat benang merah darinya, dan inilah yang menjadi ciri dari masakan Indonesia secara keseluruhan. Dan saya menyepakati hal ini. Sulit memang menyebutkan satu-dua masakan yang bisa disebut masakan Indonesia, sebab saking beragam khazanah kuliner Indonesia, maka representasi atas Indonesia tidak bisa ditunjukkan melalui satu-dua jenis masakan saja.</p><p>Karena itu sebelum memasuki pertemuan <em>The Observant Club</em>, kami dibekali oleh satu pemahaman bersama, di antar dua <em>host</em> dan tiga <em>observant</em> tamu, bahwa kami perlu hadir dan mencicipi langsung satu demi satu soto di <em>Lir</em> selama beberapa kali pertemuan. Pertemuan pertama kami pada 30 Januari 2016 adalah saat mencicipi soto-soto dari Pulau Jawa, beberapa yang bisa kami dapatkan di sekitar Jogja adalah: <strong>coto makassar, soto padang, dan soto banjar</strong>. Pada pertemuan kedua, tanggal 6 Februari 2016, kami berjingkat ke arah timur Indonesia, yakni kawasan soto dengan nuansa Jawa Timur, di antaranya: <strong>soto sulung madura, soto blitar, soto lamongan, dan soto surabaya</strong>. Melanjutkan aktivitas cicip-mencicipi pada pertemuan ketiga, 13 Februari 2016, kami menyantap soto dari daerah Jawa Barat dan DKI Jakarta. Ada empat macam soto yang kami makan waktu itu: <strong>soto bandung, soto mie jakarta, soto betawi, dan soto tangkar.</strong> Pada pertemuan terakhir, 20 Februari 2016 kami menandaskan mangkuk demi mangkuk soto yang berasal dari kawasan Jawa Tengah, seperti: <strong>soto sokaraja, soto semarang, soto kudus, dan tauto tegal.</strong> Namun, kami tegaskan di sini, <em>The Observant Club</em> bukanlah para juri yang bakal menyatakan mana soto yang enak dan kurang enak. Juga tidak mengunggah sebatas direktori harga soto dan bisa dibeli di warung mana.</p><p>Dalam suatu diskursus, situs-situs tempat mengandung komponen rasa yang bermacam-macam, dan dari situlah berangkat pula karakteristik dan kombinasi gastronomis. Dalam praktik mencicipi makanan, ketika seseorang menggigit dan menguyah apa yang dia santap melalui mulut, lalu diserap tubuh, tentu setelah indera pencecap menerbitkan reaksi tertentu atas apa yang dimakan, di titik inilah budaya dan kekayaan alam menjadi satu. Secara universal, praktik makan dan minum merupakan proses yang membawa dunia alam ke dalam domain tubuh manusia. Maka peristiwa-peristiwa sehari-hari inilah mampu melampaui sekadar persoalan pertahanan tubuh. Makanan juga melibatkan perkara selera, sosialitas, spiritualitas, hingga estetika (Trubek, 2008).</p><p>Tiga pengamat, di luar <em>host</em> <a href="https://www.instagram.com/dreamiy/">Mira</a> dan <a href="https://www.instagram.com/ditoyuwono/">Dito</a>, ada <a href="https://www.instagram.com/gabyswastika/">saya</a>, <a href="https://www.instagram.com/_indiani_/">Indiani</a>, dan <a href="https://www.instagram.com/iwnprbdi/">Iwan</a> dibebaskan untuk menuliskan <em>feedback</em> dari klab ini, di luar poin-poin yang sudah disebutkan di atas tadi. Saya akan melihatnya dari pertama, “Mengapa lokasi menjadi penting?” Lokasi yang dimaksud di sini adalah pemetaan yang kami lakukan setelah sesi cicip-mencicip. Kami akan memberikan tanda-tanda pada peta Indonesia kawasan mana saja yang menyediakan kuliner soto dan dari daerah manakah soto tersebut sudah kami nikmati. Hasilnya, tentu saja, presentase yang tidak seimbang antara jumlah soto yang kami santap kalah jauh dengan kekayaan soto di Indonesia. Hal ini disebabkan karena tidak semua ragam soto dari daerah-daerah di Indonesia tersedia di Jogja. Lebih jauh lagi, tidak semua soto berpindah dari asal lokasinya ke lokasi <em>teranyar</em>, tempat soto itu berbaur dengan lokasi yang baru, lidah-lidah pencecap yang baru, atmosfer budaya yang baru, termasuk yang paling penting — kekosongan aktor yang membawa soto tersebut ke Jogja. Dan di sinilah sesuatu yang menarik mulai tercium. Nampaknya soto mewujud menjadi sesuatu yang menjembatani hasrat manusia untuk berada pada suatu lokasi spesifik yang ingin dikunjungi. Dalam peristiwa <em>The Observant Club</em>, kami mengunjungi lokasi-lokasi tersebut via soto: Makassar, Semarang, Bandung, Kudus, Madura, dan sebagainya. “<em>Having been there</em>” adalah salah satu tujuan dari praktik mencicipi soto di klab ini.</p><p>Benarkah demikian? Apakah bisa kita “<em>having been there</em>” tanpa kehadiran fisik di lokasi yang dituju. Dalam kajian-kajian budaya, konsep orisinalitas merupakan konsep usang yang perlu dirombak, orisinalitas dalam khazanah kuliner terlebih lagi. Antisipasi yang disasarkan pada konsep usang ini disebabkan paham yang mengaitkan orisinalitas dengan budaya adiluhung, keaslian adalah segalanya, yang menempatkan sesuatu yang orisinil pada tataran lebih atas dibandingkan yang tidak orisinil. Padahal dalam pengamatan saya, dalam kuliner akan sangat sulit mencari keaslian, sebab semuanya telah berbaur. Ide hibriditas yang dicetuskan oleh Homi K. Bhabha mendiami semangkuk soto. Telusur sejarahnya sendiri bisa amat panjang — saya tidak akan membahasnya di sini. Hibriditas dalam soto lahir dari rempah-rempah yang digunakan, bihun, santan, atau susu, isian daging, bahkan peralatan makannya (Budiyanto &amp; Wardhani, 2013). Semua lebur dan berbaur menjadi satu wujud yang baru. Dengan begitu, apakah berarti kita sudah mengunjungi lokasi-lokasi tersebut melalui soto? Saya rasa iya… <em>We are tasting a place through food</em>. Apa yang bisa kita dapat? Selain kita berhasil tidak menjadi “gelap mata”, di mana kita tidak menjadi <em>snob</em> yang hanya menjunjung keaslian, keuntungan kedua adalah kita tengah menjadi orang-orang kosmopolitan. Terbuka, <em>humble</em>, namun tetap percaya diri. Toh makanan pada akhirnya bukan sekadar sesuatu yang dimakan dan dicerna manusia, makanan — dan proses memakan — merupakan bagian dari kelangsungan hidup dan selera. Varian panganan (<em>comestibles</em>) yang ditawarkan bisa dipahami sebagai bentuk perpanjangan dari hasrat manusia, “<em>Eating is both physical necessity and a cultural site where elaborate social rituals take place</em>” (Finkelstein &amp; Lynch, 2006).</p><p>Semenjak persoalan mencicipi soto atau kami menyebutnya <em>The Soto Project</em> tidak lagi hanya berfokus pada apa yang kita gigit, kunyah, telan, dan cerna, daya tarik terletak pada tampilan soto yang memikat mata. Perayaan citra visual kian semarak di era industrialisasi. Alur yang dimulai dari moda produksi hingga moda konsumsi, menunjukkan bahwa massa beralih pula pada tataran <em>being</em>, kemudian <em>having</em>, dan saat ini <em>appearance</em>. Itulah mengapa salah satu dokumentasi dari The Soto Project kami lakukan via media sosial Instagram. Visual, visual, visual. Ada dua pernyataan yang sama-sama kuat tapi berlawanan atas citra visual yang menghiasi keseharian kita, pertama “<em>seeing is believing</em>”, namun di lain sisi ada pula “<em>appearances are deceptive</em>”. Bagaimana menurut kamu dari tampilan soto yang dilihat langsung oleh kedua mata, dibandingkan dengan tampilan soto saat sudah terunggah di media sosial, atau ketika direproduksi massif melalui media massa. apakah semakin membangkitkan selera makan? Atau justru menghilangkan selera karena nampak artifisial? Budaya visual itu sendiri bisa dideskripsikan sebagai artefak-artefak material, fisik bangunan maupun citra-citra yang menciptakan hasil akhir estetis, simbolik, ritualistik, ideologis, dan memiliki fungsi praktis, dengan tujuan melahirkan kebermaknaan dalam <em>the sense of sight</em> (Walker &amp; Chaplin, 1997). Citra-citra visual tersebut menjadi lebih meyakinkan dari hari ke hari, citra-citra yang dengan mudahnya berlipat ganda dan menjadi makin banyak memiliki daya perpanjangan dari peluang yang disebut “<em>scopophilia</em>”, istilah yang digunakan oleh Freud merujuk pada kenikmatan erotika dari aktivitas memandang.</p><p>Kita makan setiap hari, selain sebagai praktik untuk mempertahankan diri supaya tetap hidup, praktik menyantap makan melampaui persoalan <em>survival</em>. <em>The Observant Club </em>berupaya menunjukkan praktik sehari-hari ini supaya bisa ditunjukkan pada publik dan membuka selubung praktik sehari-hari dengan kesan remeh-temeh atau sepele. Dalam praktik sehari-hari, <em>ways of operating</em> (de Certeau, 1984) atau praktik melakukan sesuatu tidak lagi muncul sebagai latar belakang yang gelap dan terpinggirkan, justru para pelakunya perlu memunculkannya sebagai bentuk artikulasi. Bagaimana kami berkumpul di suatu tempat, di LIR, membuat janji di hari dan jam tertentu untuk bertemu lalu makan bersama-sama. Mencicipi satu demi satu soto yang disajikan dalam meja. Mencicipinya dengan porsi yang ditakar, tidak terlalu banyak, supaya tidak kekeyangan sebelum pertemuan usai, diselingi dengan minum minuman yang melegakan tenggorokan dan membersihkan lidah. Lalu kami mencatat apa-apa saja yang tersaji di setiap mangkuk soto, merekam percakapan kami, juga menandai peta kuliner. Prosedur-prosedur kecil ini (<em>miniscule procedures</em>) yang melibatkan individu-individu perlu diperhitungkan ketika hal tersebut membentuk diskursus. <em>Ways of operating</em> menyatukan praktik-praktik yang tersebar dan berjumlah amat banyak terkait dalam pembentukan makna individu-individu di konteks sosiokultural.</p><p>Masuklah saya pada poin lain yang ingin saya lihat, persoalan tubuh dan konsumsi. Mike Featherstone (sebagaimana dikutip Miller (ed), 1995) menyatakan pentingnya tubuh dalam budaya konsumsi modern, selain sebab tubuh terkait dengan proses biologis, praktik <em>eating out</em> rupanya lebih menitikberatkan pada citra tubuh dibandingkan realitas biologis, ”<em>This has meant that the human body has been considered more as a medium of expression, or as an object for aesthetic contemplation, or even as the model for self-construction, than in terms of its direct connection with eating and drinking </em>(Miller (ed), 1995: 108). Klab yang saya ikuti adalah salah satu yang mengupayakan keterlibatan tubuh dalam praktik sehari-hari, baik yang sebelumnya kita sadari maupun tidak. Banyak yang bisa saya urai perihal tubuh dalam pertemuan-pertemuan <em>The Observant Club</em>: makan-minum tentu saja, berbicara, mencatat, bertatap muka, menyiapkan dan membereskan meja saji, dan tak lupa adalah peristiwa kehadiran kita pada suatu lokasi. LIR menjadi pusat seperangkat praktik yang sudah kami langsungkan. Sadarkan kita bahwa di LIR inilah The <em>Observant Club</em> mengonsumsi banyak hal? Karenanya janganlah khawatir atau ketakutan dengan label konsumtif, bukan ini yang hendak saya tekankan.</p><p>Konsumsi yang dipahami sebagai sesuatu yang negatif itu muncul karena selama ini masyarakat telah diekspansi oleh konsep “<em>the making</em>” yang berada pada tataran produksi. Padahal, mode produksi turut meninggalkan jejak-jejak konsumsi atau “<em>the use</em>”, meski seringkali tidak setenar mode produksi sehingga meninggalkan selubung dalam mode konsumsi. Michel de Certeau menjelaskan dalam <em>The Practice of Everyday Life</em> (1984) bahwa dengan berkembangnya pemahaman atas representasi sebuah masyarakat dan mode tindakan, dia menimbang peniscayaan konsumsi menjadi penting sebagai komponen determinan dalam sebuah kelompok atau individu-individu. Konsumer seharusnya diberi keleluasaan untuk mengindikasi apa yang akan mereka gunakan atau lakukan dari produk-produk tersebut.<strong> </strong>Konsumsi tidak hanya sekedar aktivitas ekonomi — konsumsi produk atau penggunaan komoditas untuk memuaskan kebutuhan material — konsumsi juga mengenai harapan, hasrat, identitas, dan komunikasi. Mode konsumsi atas produk-produk budaya tidak lagi menjadi proses yang bersifat pribadi, atomik, dan pasif, melainkan menjadi suatu proses yang bersifat sosial, relasional, dan aktif. Proses ini sejalan dengan tiga ciri dari aktivitas yang menjadi bagian dari arena praktik, yaitu praktik konsumsi tidak terpisahkan dari konteks spasio-temporal, merupakan praktik yang memiliki sifat cair dan tidak menentu atau spontan, dan seringkali berjalan tanpa sepenuhnya disadari oleh pelaku (Budiman, 2002).</p><p>Semoga dengan memahami hal ini, praktik sederhana seperti menyantap soto tidak menghentikan kita dari penelusuran persoalan lain yang lebih kompleks. Saat ini saya baru bisa menjelajahinya melalui beberapa aspek saja, mungkin kamu bisa meniliknya dari sisi lain. Upaya untuk mengeksplorasinya masih sangat luas. <em>Happy eating</em>!</p><blockquote><strong><em>REFERENSI</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Budiyanto, Ari dan Intan Kusuma Wardhani. 2013. Menyantap Soto Melacak Jao To Merekonstruksi (Ulang) Jejak Hibriditas Budaya Kuliner Cina dan Jawa. </em>Proceeding of International Conference on Chinese-Indonesians: Chinese-Indonesians, Their Lives and Identities<em>.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Budiman, Kris. 2002. </em>Di depan Kotak Ajaib: Menonton Televisi sebagai Praktik Konsumsi. <em>Yogyakarta: Galang Press.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>de Certeau, Michel. 1984. </em>The Practice of Everyday Life. <em>Berkeley: University of California Press.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Finkelstein, Joanne and Rob Lynch. 2006. “Eating out and the Appetite for Leisure” in Chris Rojek dkk (eds). </em>A Handbook of Leisure Studies. <em>Palgrave MacMillan.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Trubek, Amy B. 2008. </em>The Taste of Place. <em>California: University of California Press.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Walker, John A. and Sarah Chaplin. 1997.<em> Visual Culture: An Introduction. </em>Manchester: Manchester University Press.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dfe38ef9e413" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Beberapa Tanggapan atas Cuitan AJI Surabaya: Memeriksa Ulang Nalar Prejudice dan Misoginis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gabyswastika/beberapa-tanggapan-atas-cuitan-aji-surabaya-memeriksa-ulang-nalar-prejudice-dan-misoginis-3279337070c4?source=rss-80b2ba4bf9b3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3279337070c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[prejudice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kekerasan-seksual]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mugs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kitaagni]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[misoginis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gaby Swastika]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Nov 2018 10:57:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-08T10:57:30.829Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Beberapa Tanggapan atas Cuitan AJI Surabaya: Memeriksa Ulang Nalar <em>Prejudice</em> dan Misoginis</strong></p><p>Hai! Tulisan ini adalah tulisan perdana saya di Medium. Tulisan yang lahir setelah saya ‘muntab’ — marah sekali dengan suatu peristiwa di hari Rabu, 7 November 2018 sekitar pukul 5 sore.</p><p>Tulisan ini sebelumnya sudah saya <em>post</em> di laman <a href="https://www.facebook.com/gabrielalaras/posts/10215747885243889">Facebook</a> kemarin. Alasan saya mengunggahnya untuk kali kedua di laman yang berbeda, tak lain adalah <em>self-archive</em>. Ya, demi mengarsipkan apa-apa yang pernah menggelisahkan saya dan tak ayal mendorong saya menghasilkan suatu artefak — berupa tulisan ini. Tulisan ini berdasarkan pendapat pribadi, tak jadi soal bila ada yang setuju ada yang tidak. Saya menuliskannya dengan harapan diskursus atas peristiwa yang dibahas menjadi kian sehat.</p><p>Berikut kegelisahan saya…</p><p>=====</p><p>Kasus pemerkosaan di wilayah KKN UGM yang kembali dibahas belakangan ini, yang ternyata kejadiannya sendiri sudah setahun yang lalu, meninggalkan perasaan campur-aduk. Sebagai perempuan, alumna studi master di UGM, sebagai orang yang pernah aktif pula di pers mahasiswa semasa S1, saya jadi ingin sedikit berbicara.</p><p>Wacana yang bergulir soal kasus ini beragam, untungnya suara-suara yang mendukung agar kasus ini diusut tuntas dan keadilan ditegakkan bagi penyintas lebih terdengar, ketimbang suara-suara buruk <em>victim blaming</em>.</p><p>Awalnya Samsara menuliskan bahwa ada <em>lho</em> cara-cara sesuai kode etik jurnalistik yang perlu dipatuhi saat menuliskan peristiwa pemerkosaan. Oke, di satu sisi saya menanyakan, “<em>Lho</em> ini yakin <em>to statement</em> ini muncul dari SAMSARA”. Oh oke (sebab saya setengah tidak percaya), bisa jadi lembaga ini memberikan ‘nasihat’ sebab mereka terlalu sering berhadapan dan menemani korban/penyintas sehingga ada rasa takut bila penyintas bakal kenapa-kenapa nantinya.</p><p><strong>NAMUN, makin lama <em>MIXED RESPONSES </em>makin berkembang,</strong> tidak hanya dari sisi bagaimana menjaga reputasi institusi pendidikan, bagaimana baiknya menjaga korban, SAMPAI DENGAN bagaimana <em>sih </em>seharusnya laporan investigasi mengenai pemerkosaan ini dituliskan, yang berakhir dengan <em>kemuntaban</em> saya.</p><p>YA, SAYA MARAH BETUL SORE INI!</p><p>Ada lembaga lain, saya tidak tahu siapa di belakang status Twitter AJI (ALIANSI JURNALIS INDEPENDEN) SURABAYA yang jelas-jelas menuliskan sebuah status <em>ngece</em> menanggapi <a href="http://www.balairungpress.com/2018/11/nalar-pincang-ugm-atas-kasus-perkosaan/">tulisan pertama Balairung Press</a> soal kasus ini. Dia bilang, “Jurnalis yg nulis koplak pisan. Detail sekali gambarkan modus pelecehan seksualnya. Korban sprti diperkosa dua kali.” (12.14 PM — 6 Nov 2018; verbatim)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/636/1*-zGYkIR5w5XdKs4L2qusYA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Woh</em>, saya marah betul!</strong></p><p>(1) Apa mereka asal <em>ngomong</em> ini tanpa mempertimbangkan bahwa teman-teman Balairung Press sudah melakukan hak jawab. Mereka <em>lho</em> sudah rilis pernyataan secara menyeluruh mengapa tulisan dengan ‘<em>angle’</em> seperti itu yang dimuat. Ini bukan investigasi sepele<em> lho</em> ya… MENGINGAT bahwa yang menulis ini adalah sesama mahasiswa, mereka inilah yang bisa dibilang sebetul-betulnya independen. Resiko akademis, TIDAK dibayar, mereka bahkan (bisa jadi) mempertaruhkan entah nilai, entah kelulusan, entah reputasi mereka di lingkaran tempat mereka kuliah. Ya itu, di lembaga yang sedang bermasalah ini.</p><p><em>Lha</em> kok bisa-bisanya dituduh sebagai <strong>penulis ‘koplak’</strong>. JAHAT SEKALI MEREKA!</p><p>(2) Dengan AJI SBY bilang ‘tulisan koplak’, mereka sendiri (saya <em>ga </em>tahu ini bisa dianggap representasi sebuah lembaga atau sekadar ketololan individu <em>netizen</em> yang kebetulan seorang jurnalis juga) sudah melakukan <strong>AGEISM</strong>, <em>prejudice</em> berdasarkan tingkat senior-junior dan umur. <em>Hah</em>, <em>dumeh</em> mereka jurnalis <em>gitu po</em>, terus Balairung ini SEKADAR PERS MAHASISWA. Terus dianggap investigasinya salah, tidak serius, dan lain-lain?</p><p>(3) Dengan menuliskan juga ‘pelecehan seksual’, bukannya ini <strong>nalar eufemistik</strong>, yang bahaya <em>lho</em> jatuhnya… <strong>Sebab mereka telah membuat seakan-akan pemerkosaan ini sekadar pelecehan seksual.</strong> Bahwa pemerkosaan Agni <em>ga</em> segitunya kok sebetulnya. LHA KOK JAHAT BANGET!</p><p>(4) Ini penyintas sudah menyatakan bahwa penulisan Balairung bersifat konsensual. Kalau saya berusaha memahami cara berpikir penyintas, <strong>Agni ini SANGAT BERANI</strong> (saya respek sekali), dia merasa bahwa dengan menceritakan kronologis pemerkosaan adalah upaya dirinya untuk <strong>bisa mengatasi trauma dan mengadvokasi dirinya sendiri.</strong> Apakah para jurnalis ini tidak punya empati dan pertimbangan akan itu?</p><p>(5) Saya tahu bahwa profesi terikat pula oleh kode etik. Meski tidak semuanya saya ingat tapi saya sendiri pernah belajar jurnalistik, saya pernah aktif selama hampir 4 tahun di pers mahasiswa FISIP UAJY, dan saya paham bahwa wacana lahir salah satunya dari bagaimana seseorang ‘berbahasa’. Meski demikian, dalam konteks ini… ya <em>mbok</em> yaa, jangan sampai kode etik ini ‘memerangkap’ dan justru <strong>menafikan prioritas — YA SI AGNI INI.</strong></p><p>Jangan seperti orang-orang masgyul yang sok-sokan ambil <em>spot</em> saat peristiwa ini terjadi. Kembali ke yang terutama, sekarang ini bagaimana supaya <em>victim blaming</em> ga terjadi, Agni bisa menerima keadilan, dan UGM sebagai sebuah lembaga yang saya hormati juga melakukan aksi nyata.</p><p><strong>#PantauUGM #SayaAGNI</strong></p><p>PS. Semoga tulisan saya di Medium tidak berhenti sampai di sini. Amin! *amor fati*</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3279337070c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>