<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Gareth Bentley on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Gareth Bentley on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@garethbentley?source=rss-73adc2b09638------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 02:48:09 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@garethbentley/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Schrodinger’s foreign correspondent]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@garethbentley/schrodingers-foreign-correspondent-76e64afa70a1?source=rss-73adc2b09638------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/76e64afa70a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[post-truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-transformation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gareth Bentley]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Jan 2017 11:24:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-27T13:13:42.929Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Jeremy Bowen, foreign correspondent and Middle East Editor for the BBC, in June seven years ago (2010), accepted the <em>British Journalism Review</em>’s Charles Wheeler award for an outstanding contribution to broadcast journalism. In his acceptance speech, he made the statement that one of his peers, John Pilger, who is also accustomed to garnering awards for outstanding journalism, had emailed him to say:</p><p>‘I was a weasel, a disgrace to journalism- because I was trying to report impartially.’</p><p>This remark powerfully illustrates the salience of different and conflicting individual emotional attachments to issues such as impartiality in the British field of foreign correspondence. It exemplifies a profound difference in approaches between two of the most celebrated living exponents of the craft. John Pilger’s 2010 documentary, ‘The War You Don’t See’, is an investigation into this phenomenon of alienation within British and American mainstream journalism. He calls it, ‘holding up a mirror’ to British and American ‘stenographers of power’. The rise of Wikileaks also exacerbates this ‘war’ or split between institutional and independent journalism, between television and press journalism, a point that is certainly not lost on Pilger, in his journalism.</p><p>Jon Snow, Channel Four news presenter and foreign correspondent, an interviewee for this research, made the following observations on political history in a published interview with David Edwards:</p><p>DE: ‘He [Mark Curtis] argues that there’s a pattern to post-1945 British and US interventions, basically defending profits and installing people like the Shah in Iran…’</p><p>JS: ‘Oh this is bollocks! Total bollocks!’</p><p>DE: ‘Do you think so?’</p><p>JS: ‘Utter bollocks!’’ (Edwards, D. &amp; Cromwell, D., 2009: 1)</p><p>This, I would argue, is a similar but more ideologically framed manifestation of different journalistic emotional and political attachments to historical truth, impartiality, objectivity. What I would note from such a polarized dialogue is two human agents arguing for a fixed historical truth that subsumes human agency into hegemony and counter-hegemony. In other words, as journalists, what they have in common, is a top-down position. The understanding of this writing is that any objective or political approach that claims to track hegemonic or counter-hegemonic historical narratives is a human ideal and so, by virtue of its humanity, ‘cracked’, imperfect. What Snow and Edwards are arguing about depends on their internalization of Anglo-American national discourse.</p><p>Foreign correspondence, or international journalism, is constructed on a ‘them’ versus ‘us’ basis, an alienation. This powerful delineation is the product of the rise of nation-states and national media systems. According to Williams (2011, 23):</p><p>‘Print and broadcast journalism has grown within the framework of the nation-state: newspapers, radio and television have been organised on a national basis serving the informational needs of the state, commerce and civil society.’</p><p>I want to interrogate British journalistic ‘places to stand’ (McLuhan, 1964) through the prism of emotion which acts as a conduit for internalization and externalization of Otherness. Tuchman (1991) refers to an ‘Archimedean point’ as one that the professions of law and journalism require to ‘pin down’ objectivity and garner popular trust. An Archimedean point is a scientific metaphor for a theoretical position, a view, that encapsulates totality, all reality, a rather tall order for an international journalist.</p><p>I want to investigate the objectivity hypothesis with application to British foreign correspondents’ use(s) of emotion in reporting conflict and trauma, in order to inquire whether or not this point is perceived to exist or whether the point is rather an articulation or multiple articulations inscribed in the practice of individual, journalistic agents.</p><p>‘Truth isn’t outside power or lacking in power…truth isn’t the reward of free spirits, the child of protracted solitude, nor the privilege of those who have succeeded in liberating themselves. Truth is a thing of this world: it is produced only by virtue of multiple forms of constraint. And it induces regular forms of power…it is produced and transmitted under the control, dominant if not exclusive, of a few great political and economic apparatuses (university, army, writing, media)’…. (Foucault, 1984:73)</p><p>Foucault’s argument suggests that all so-called objective truth is partial. One way to investigate partiality is by examining the sets of constraints that give rise to partial truth. This research project is interested in a particular set of constraints and partiality, that of emotion and human agency. The proposed object of study is the practice of British foreign correspondents reporting international conflict and trauma. The project’s analytic framework is the journalist as subject, as human complex agent. It is assumed that without individual journalists, there is no news, so this project begins its enquiry with the human individual. It will examine temporal constraints on journalist practice as well as emotional constraints from the point of view of the journalist him/herself.</p><p>Objectivity emerged as a scientific ideal out of the historical process of modernity, Enlightenment, as an attempt to awake reason in mankind. But there has arguably always remained a flaw in the project:</p><p>‘For is it not the case that modernity’s mode of reason- for all its worth- cannot bring reason under its own critique? Is not the Achilles heel of reason precisely the fact that it cannot be deployed against itself? This is because if you fold reason back against itself, it panics.’ (Zizek, 2009: 10)</p><p>Here Zizek evokes reason as a kind of double-edged sword, good for instrumental deployment in the external, ‘objective’ world; dangerous, in his view, when employed as a self-reflective tool. This, of course, is the therapeutic turn, taken up by psychoanalysis and psychotherapy. Such a turn was an attempt by a therapist to act as an ‘objective’ instrument to reflect back indirectly on the analysand in order to address the analysand’s trauma more obliquely through the voice of the therapist. Is journalistic trauma a manifestation of a flaw in the application of objectivity, a source of panic and internal conflict between the learnt routine practice of objectivity being flooded by the rising up of emotional trauma or biological affect? Trauma, from an objective perspective, is a medical and biological phenomenon, a recognizable set of mental and physical symptoms and does not account for the individual, subjective experience of trauma. Nor does it account for the object of trauma. In other words, what traumatizes one foreign correspondent, be it traumatic objects such as atrocity, rape, extreme suffering, mass slaughter, child killing, does not necessarily traumatize another. Surely trauma is not only an objective phenomenon; it is a subjective as well as emotional one. On that basis, what then separates the objective truthiness of one journalist’s trauma from another?</p><p>Emotion (and affect) is a subject that seems to be percolating into the cracks of Western popular discourse. One of the main currents of this rise of emotional discourse is ‘therapeutic culture’ and its psychoanalytic association with ‘the talking cure’ (Furedi, 2004; Lupton, 1998; Nicholson, 1999; Pantti, 2010).</p><p>In Britain, there has been an emotionalization of the public sphere, a public mass mediated space for orchestration and display of emotion, especially since the death of Princess Diana in 1997 and the events of 9/11/01, ‘9/11’ (Blackman and Walkerdine, 2001; Dalrymple, 2010). Emotion also seems to have entered popular discourse through the door of individualization and the cult of the self (Curtis, 2002; Beck, 2003), which can be traced back further to 1960s counter-culture. In books, self-help guides for gaining personal happiness and quasi-confessional autobiographies have made their mark, shoring up consumer-cultural notions of the self.</p><p>In television culture, commercial interest in emotion as a device to maximize audiences has produced ‘infotainment’ (Delli Carpini and Williams, 2001, 167):</p><p>‘In short the new media [cable and satellite TV and the Internet] are creating an environment that is increasingly incompatible with the structures and practices that maintained the news-entertainment distinction for most of this century. As these walls crumble, the form and content of news entertainment come to resemble each other more closely, laying bare what has always been a socially constructed distinction. What is clear is that this new media environment presents a direct challenge to the authority of elites- journalists, policy experts, public officials, acacdemics, and the like- who served as gatekeepers under the old system.’</p><p>Examples of infotainment programmes are reality television, talk shows, three HBO series of ‘In Treatment’, all adding to the arrival and presence of the discourse of emotion in mass mediated culture. Recent buzzwords that allude to this cultural change affecting news culture are breaking ‘live’ news, immediacy, ‘therapy’ news and ‘conscious’ journalism. The ‘emotional’ turn has produced a whole raft of satirical news shows such as Charlie Brooker’s ‘Newswipe’, Jon Stewart’s ‘The Daily Show’, ‘Mock the Week, ‘Have I Got News for You?’ and more.</p><p>The media theorization of this recent phenomenon tends to build on the large historically established body of political economic theory. But the central nodes of the sociological literature on emotional discourse are anger/rage (Sloterdijk, 2010), fear (Robin, 2004; Bourke, 2005; Furedi, 2002), compassion, empathy and altruism, a conspicuous shift from the outmoded catch-all emotional classifier, ‘love’, all of which arguably go together (Gilbert, 2005; Harman, 2010, Scott and Seglow, 2007; de Waal, 2009). Compassion, altruism and empathy are all conceptually related to self/other, I/thou dynamics. Trust (Fukuyama, 1995; Kohn, 2009) and respect (Sennett, 2003; Honneth, 2007; McNay, 2007) arguably fit the same social dynamic. Trauma (Kalsched, 1996; Herman, 1997; Alexander et al, 2004; Bernstein, 2005; Leys, 2000), denial (Cohen, 2001) and happiness (Ricard, 2003, Haidt, 2006) are current emotional topics that focus more on the pyschological ‘self’ pole than the ‘other’ pole.</p><p>Other more generic books discuss the meaning of emotion, different typologies of emotion and its relationship with science (Greco &amp; Stenner (Eds.), 2008; Nussbaum, 2004, Solomon (Ed.), 2003, 2007; Oatley and Jenkins, 1996; Fisher (2002), Lupton (1998); Boruah (1988) and Evans (2001)). There is also an expanding scientific body of research on emotion, human and animal, notably Le Doux (1998), McGilchrist (2009) and Damasio (1994, 2000, 2004). There is also an emergent body of literature on affect. Studies on affect attempt to bridge the cultural and historical divide by focusing on the role of the body and its affective emanations (Deleuze, 1988; Green, 1999; <em>Body and Society</em> special issue, 2010, Despret, 2004, 2008, Latour, 2004).</p><p>In the news analytic literature, emotion is argued by some to have become a news value (Tumber and Prentoulis, 2003: 228). The clustering of emotional discourse around compassion and trauma is also reflected in journalism scholarship: compassion (Moeller, 1999; Boltanski, 1999; Tester, 2001) and trauma (Meek, 2010). My work is designed to test journalists’ discourse on compassion and trauma against this body of emerging media analytic literature, as well as to investigate how foreign correspondents understand their relationship between emotion and self.</p><p>The relationship between emotion and self is a complex one. For example, is emotion exclusively a subjective experience? Surely the emotional connection between a journalist and traumatized sufferers is a dynamic flow between human-beings? Is it possible to distinguish between what Gitlin calls ‘media for disposable emotion’ (2002: 41) and mediated emotion that is more valuable? Does emotion have to be instinctual and unconscious to be real? Is self-reflexive, self-conscious emotion, therefore, false? This dilemma or conflict is also framed by media analysts as being between the inner and outer world, inner and outer emotion (Gitlin: ibid.).</p><p>Muhlmann frames this conflict or war within journalism as different understandings of conflict centred either inside or outside journalistic agency. Unifying journalism , according to her, was a ‘requirement of the ‘popular’ press of the nineteenth century to provide true information, accurate and ‘objective’ facts’ in order to ‘bring together readers who might well have different opinions on a subject, and hence reach the common denominator of an increasingly large readership’ (2008: 6). This is how she theorizes the role of the reporter reporting conflict:</p><p>‘Unifying journalisms are not necessarily strangers to conflict, therefore, they often base themselves on it, and then construct the ‘centre’ of the community by means of a conflict shown through the gaze of the reporter. Nevertheless, we are entitled to remain sceptical about the nature of the conflicts which this journalistic process is capable of revealing and exposing. They are, by definition, conflicts which lead back to the centre,make their readers feel the identity of a ‘we’.’ (Muhlmann, 2008: 28)</p><p>Muhlmann, therefore, distinguishes between centring and decentring journalism. The former is broadly mainstream and conservative; the latter broadly polemical, political.</p><p>Carl Jung, writing in 1959, produced a psychoanalytical analysis of what is arguably the same phenomenon but applied to all humanity:</p><p>‘Today humanity is split, as never before, into two apparently irreconcilable halves. The psychological rule says that when an inner situation is not made conscious, it happens outside, as fate. That is to say, when the individual remains undivided and does not become conscious of his inner contradictions, the world must perforce act out the conflict and be torn into opposite halves.’ (1959: para. 126)</p><p>It must be stated at the outset that the purpose of this writing is not a psychological inquiry, but borrowing Jung’s notion of ‘inner’ and ‘outer’ contradiction is a good starting place. When foreign correspondents report conflict, are they conscious of any inner conflict? Does objective journalism allow for any such self-reflexivity? Is inner conflict documented in any of their autobiographies? Is Pilger any more reflexive than Bowen or vice versa? Is Edwards more reflexive than Snow? Are press journalists more reflexive than television ones? Are there institutional differences between the BBC, Channel Four and CNN? Journalistic agency and emotion are very little theorized in the media academic field, especially the academic field of journalism studies.</p><p>McLuhan took an ideological political economic line when claiming that conflict is propagated by the commercial interest of mass media:</p><p>‘Archimedes once said, “Give me a place to stand and I will move the world.” Today he would have pointed to our electric media and said, “I will stand on your eyes, your ears, your nerves, and your brain, and the world will move in any tempo or pattern I choose.” We have leased these “places to stand” to private corporations.’ (McLuhan, 1964)</p><p>Would he have said with regard to the ‘electric’ media, ‘And emotion will stand on your ears, your nerves, and your brain’?</p><p>Most research on journalistic reporting constraints has taken two foci. One is newsroom ethnographies looking at political economy approaches (concerned with propaganda, ideology, ownership and control). The second focus has been institutional/organizational approaches looking at the categorization of professional routine practices, such as news values, gate-keeping, the news net, agenda-setting and objectivity. Other documented constraints are linguistic, temporal, cultural and technological. And yet, as in any area of social activity, perhaps there remains an excess, a residual of journalistic agency which these theories cannot explain. Has the new era of technology brought to us by satellite and heralded by 24-hour news altered journalistic agency? In the Arab world, it has provided a broader range of information, but in Britain and America, it has led to less fact, analysis and context (Lewis and Cushion, Eds., 2010).</p><p>Perhaps there are moments, when journalistic norms do not function as usual, that have to do with some kind of international ‘crisis’ (the 9/11 Trade Tower attacks, the Asian Tsunami of 2004, the 7/7 London bombings in 2005), a collapse of the ruling interpretative frame, that is potentially both ontological and epistemological. Perhaps this different kind of coverage has to do with an excess of temporal constraint, a demand for ‘liveness’, of ongoing 24-hour coverage? Do these moments allow for a more emotional, personal voice and style than is usual from journalists; moments that demand more of the journalist him or herself and break open the mould of diurnal routine news coverage; moments, perhaps, of ‘heroism’ and performance? Take the example of Jonathan Miller, foreign correspondent for Channel Four News, when he made the following remark on BBC Radio Four’s <em>The Media Show </em>(30/3/11) in the context of a widely reported news story in Libya about Iman Al-Obaidi:</p><p>‘Reporting from Libya has tested my professional impartiality and objectivity to the very limit. We’re journalists, but we are also human-beings. And when you see the repression and the violence with which ordinary people are treated, it sort of shakes you. Although all my journalistic training, the objectivity, the impartiality in which I’m schooled to be a reporter, to be detached, that was lost in the case of Iman Al-Obaidi, I must confess.’</p><p>It is in moments such as these that a different journalistic discourse emerges, a more emotional human one, often affected with trauma and compassion.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=76e64afa70a1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>