<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Gary Borislow on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Gary Borislow on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@gary.borislow?source=rss-3539f37bfa98------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 07:49:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Harmless Delusion Theory of Humor: Responding to Questions and Objections]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/harmless-delusion-theory-of-humor-responding-to-questions-and-objections-4bc48098f2c9?source=rss-3539f37bfa98------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4bc48098f2c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cognitive-psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gary Borislow]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Mar 2023 01:30:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-30T15:06:04.959Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0fsSZcxCKSIzIzwv" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@camylla93?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Camylla Battani</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>After the initial publication of my new universal humor theory, the <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong>Harmless Delusion Theory (HDT)</strong></a>, I received many questions, arguments, and potential counterexamples. I’ve summarized and compiled them in this article along with my responses. I hope this helps clarify my theory, as well as continue to demonstrate its uniquely strong explanatory power and ability to withstand challenge.</p><p>First, here again is my theory:</p><p><strong>I propose that the essence of humor is <em>harmless delusion</em>. Humor occurs when a perceiver sees a person as holding a delusional belief and at the same time judges the situation to be harmless.</strong></p><p>I’m using delusion in its ordinary, non-clinical sense. The perceiver thinks two things about the same person at once: that the person believes something is the case, and that clear evidence to the contrary is available to the person. The delusional belief may be one the person actually holds, one they are pretending to hold, or one the perceiver imagines them holding. The person may be someone other than the perceiver or the perceiver themselves. The person may also be an animal or thing that the perceiver imagines as a person.</p><p>Harmlessness is a judgment by the perceiver that the situation is, at least to some degree, okay or acceptable to them personally. What seems delusional and what feels harmless both depend on the individual perceiver.</p><h4>1. We already have definitions of ‘funny’ and ‘humor’. Why do we need a new one?</h4><p>How is ‘funny’ or ‘humor’ defined? It is standardly defined by our reaction to it. Something that ‘makes you laugh’, ‘causes laughter’, or ‘causes amusement’. Defining something only by our reaction to it doesn’t tell us what it actually is. My purpose with my theory is to provide a much better definition of ‘funny’ or ‘humor’ by helping us understand exactly what it is.</p><h4>2. It seems like there are many things that cause or explain humor. How can you say it’s just this one concept of harmless delusion?</h4><p>I can understand this view because humor seems so varied. But I think it’s helpful to think about it alongside other things we find pleasurable, such as music, dancing, drama, paintings, drawings, sculptures, photography, architecture, fashion, design, nature, food, sports, games, puzzles, magic, sex, etc. With all these other things, the experience is just “enjoyment” or “pleasure”, but with humor it’s this unique kind of enjoyment or pleasure called “funny”. In this big picture, it seems reasonable that there is just one thing that is tipping the experience into the category of “funny”.</p><p>Also, I am not claiming that other factors don’t frequently play a part in our enjoyment of humor and the funniness we experience. As I’ve stated, I believe there are many of these enhancers. But because none of them are necessary and sufficient for humor, they cannot be the root cause of humor. And their presence does not negate the fact that there can be this set of two necessary and sufficient conditions I’ve identified.</p><h4>3. Delusion has a specific clinical meaning. Are you using the word in this way?</h4><p>No, I am not. There are two commonly used meanings of delusion: a formal clinical one and an informal nonclinical one. I’ve clarified that I’m using the latter. The clinical version is the mental illness or disorder where a person maintains a firm belief that is impervious to contrary evidence. The informal nonclinical usage of the term is for a less severe belief. Delusion in this sense is where a person believes that something is the case despite having clear evidence to the contrary available to them. Unlike clinical delusion, nonclinical delusion does not require that the person hold the belief with conviction or show strong resistance to counter-evidence.</p><h4>4. By harmless, do you mean not harmful?</h4><p>With the word harmless, I am using a precise, commonly understood meaning. The situation must feel, at least to some degree, okay or acceptable to the perceiver personally. This covers both senses of the term: situations that feel physically safe and situations that feel socially or morally acceptable.</p><h4>5. Is the delusional person us or is it another person?</h4><p>The person we perceive as having delusional belief can be either ourselves or another person. Though I think the vast majority of the time we find something funny we are perceiving delusion in a person other than ourselves. I believe this is because we very infrequently realize we were incorrect and that the counter-evidence was clear to us. And when we do, it usually doesn’t feel harmless to us (we’re annoyed or upset).</p><h4>6. What exactly does your theory say are the cognitive processes we go through?</h4><p>My theory proposes that humor occurs when a perceiver simultaneously performs two cognitive operations. The first is attributing a delusional belief to a person: the perceiver attributes to the same person both that they believe something to be the case, and that they have clear evidence to the contrary available to them. The second is appraising the situation as harmless: the perceiver judges that the situation feels, at least to some degree, okay or acceptable to them personally. Both operations are perceiver-relative, meaning the same stimulus can trigger them for one person and not another depending on how they perceive it.</p><p>The attribution of delusional belief is an instance of Theory of Mind processing, our cognitive capacity to represent and reason about others’ mental states, which we develop at a very young age and exercise continuously in social life. This capacity is what allows us to perceive what a person believes, and to recognize when that belief is held against clear evidence to the contrary. It is this perception of harmless delusional belief that directly triggers the experience of humor.</p><h4>7. Why does a joke get less funny the more you hear it?</h4><p>I account for this two ways: 1) Surprise and novelty are humor enhancers (they coexist with humor and boost it). Repeated exposure to a joke reduces the surprise or novelty, and thus the humor. Generally, we likely still perceive a person’s harmless delusional belief and find it funny, just less so. 2) Repetition could increase negative feelings like annoyance, which reduces the harmlessness and thus the humor.</p><h4>8. My neighbor reads her horoscope every day because she believes in astrology. I perceive that as a harmless delusional belief. It makes me roll my eyes, but I find no humor in it, harmless though it may be.</h4><p>Harmless means that it “feels to at least some degree okay or acceptable to us personally”. An eye-roll indicates it feels “not okay” to you, so it’s not harmless to you. This would explain why you find it unfunny. I personally see astrology as harmless delusional belief. Thus, I still find it humorous. But now it’s like an old joke I’ve heard many times. The enhancers of surprise and novelty have mostly gone away, so the humor is minimal (but still present).</p><p>Because humor is based on our perception, whether people who believe in astrology (or ESP, ghosts, flat-earth, etc.) are funny is up to each of us. To find these people funny, we must perceive them to be delusional and harmless to us. If we don’t have that perception, we won’t find them funny. This is consistent with what we see in the real world. Some people find them funny and some don’t. In fact, this is what we see in the real world with everything found funny (or not), and it’s for this precise reason.</p><h4>9. We see people make harmless mistakes every day. They miss dentist appointments because they got the day wrong, they accidentally say the wrong person’s name when talking, they take the wrong highway exit, etc. How do you account for the lack of humor there?</h4><p>Delusion is not just “mistaken belief” or “false belief”. It is mistaken or false belief <em>that is held even though what is correct or true is clear</em>. We’re unlikely to perceive the maker of a minor mistake as delusional because we’re unlikely to feel that the evidence to the contrary is clear to the person. Most of us know from experience that such minor slip-ups are easy to make because it often only takes something like a slight lack of awareness or slight misunderstanding to make them. For us to perceive delusion, we need to judge that the evidence to the contrary is so clear that there’s no justification for the mistake.</p><p>Of course, it’s also reasonable to think that someone might perceive one of these small errors as delusional belief and find it funny. For instance, my young daughters might laugh at my taking the wrong exit, because their inexperience with driving causes them to think that the correct exit was clear to me. Whether the evidence to the contrary is clear is determined by the perceiver.</p><p>In other words, the distinction between perceived false belief and perceived delusion is a matter of the extent to which a person’s false belief is judged by the perceiver to be reasonable or justified. And this judgment is made based on the evidence the belief-holder is perceived to have. Granted, it is subjective how a perceiver will judge the person, but my theory accounts for that. If the perceiver doesn’t judge that the evidence to the contrary is clear to the holder of the false belief, they won’t see them as delusional, and thus won’t find them funny.</p><h4>10. My son’s belief in the tooth fairy would be an example of harmless delusion but unfunny.</h4><p>I don’t think a child’s belief in the tooth fairy is completely humorless. I recall being mildly amused when my children fell for it. But I think mostly we don’t perceive them as delusional, because we don’t think that the truth about the tooth fairy is clear to them. They are very young and rely on us to learn about the world, so when we say it’s real, why are they wrong to believe us? We also know that we believed it ourselves.</p><h4><strong>11. By your definition, it would seem that all “make believe” is inherently humorous. Why isn’t it?</strong></h4><p>There’s no perceived delusion inherent in the action of make believe because no one is perceived as believing that an untrue thing is true. The person pretending is perceived as believing that an untrue thing is untrue (i.e., they believe that things are not real in the make-believe world). The person they might be pretending to be is perceived as believing that true things are true (i.e., they believe that things are real to them in the make-believe world).</p><h4><strong>12. Why aren’t harmless lies always funny?</strong></h4><p>There’s no perceived delusion inherent in the action of lying because no one is perceived as believing that an untrue thing is true. The liar perceives themselves as believing that an untrue thing is untrue. The hearer of the lie who doesn’t know it’s a lie perceives the liar as believing that a true thing is true. The hearer of the lie who knows it’s a lie perceives the liar as believing that an untrue thing is untrue.</p><h4>13. What about hyperbole and metaphor, which involve a person stating something clearly untrue in a literal sense? Why are these often not funny?</h4><p>Hyperbole has strong inherent potential to be found funny, and sometimes is, because by definition it involves clear overstatement or overreaction (delusional magnification), a form of delusional belief. It often <em>isn’t</em> found funny because many hyperbolic expressions are so common and familiar that they are perceived as normal statements rather than as hyperbole and exaggeration. Only the intended meaning has force. For instance, “ages” and “forever” only come across as “a long time”; “millions”, “tons”, and “an arm and a leg” only mean “a lot”; “dying to” only means “really want to”; etc. However, in cases of unconventional hyperbole, we may focus more on the literal meaning of the statement because of its novelty and creativity. This greater attention on the literal can increase the chance that the expression will be found funny because of the higher likelihood it will be perceived as delusional overstatement.</p><p>Metaphor, unlike hyperbole, is not defined by delusional belief. Thus it has much less inherent potential to be found funny. A metaphor is essentially a description based on comparison or analogy. Evidence shows that people generally understand metaphorical statements at the same speed as literal ones¹. This suggests that we typically process the intended metaphorical meaning instantly, without activating the literal meaning. Because we tend not to process the clearly untrue literal meaning, and thus don’t perceive the person making a metaphorical point as believing something untrue, the potential for humor is minimal. For example, the person using the metaphor “his words cut deeper than a knife” will tend to be perceived only as believing the true thing that the words hurt emotionally, and not at all the untrue thing that they made a physical opening. And the person using the metaphor “she has a heart of gold” will be perceived only as believing the true thing that she is kind and caring, and not at all the untrue thing that her heart is made of gold.</p><h4>14. A contradiction that isn’t funny is the following sentence: “This sentence is false.”</h4><p>Delusional contradiction is belief something is the case and isn’t the case at the same time. Paradoxes like this one can be funny if it comes across strongly that a person believes both sides without realizing it’s a contradiction (e.g., Homer Simpson’s belief that alcohol is both the cause of and solution to all life’s problems). I don’t think that’s quite the case with this paradox. Plus, if the “figuring out” of the riddle takes work, which seems to be the case with this one, that can reduce the funniness (less harmlessness). Notice how the following phrases aren’t what we normally see as funny, but when George Carlin puts a spotlight on them as oxymorons/paradoxes, the delusional contradiction of the phrase creator/communicator (and thus funniness) comes across more strongly: “jumbo shrimp”, “original copy”, and “silent alarm”.</p><h4>15. Wouldn’t the unfunniness of misdirection, magic, and optical illusions present problems for your theory?</h4><p>I think the implication here is that these things cause us, in a way, to believe things that are untrue, and that, according to my theory, we should find this delusion in ourselves funny. My theory says that we’re unlikely to perceive ourselves as delusional when we experience these things, and that this is why they are typically unfunny. We don’t perceive delusion in ourselves here because we know that we were deceived or that the evidence was ambiguous, and therefore we feel our belief was reasonable or justified. As I said above in #9 regarding the difference between mistaken/false belief and delusional belief, for us to perceive delusion we need to judge that the correct or true thing is so clear that there’s no justification for the mistake.</p><h4>16. What about breaking the fourth wall, or when an actor has a blooper? Why is this funny?</h4><p>Breaking the fourth wall is a complex thing because it plays with our suspension of disbelief (a complex thing itself), so is admittedly tricky to analyze. I think one plausible explanation is that this is delusional contradiction. When we’re viewing fiction we are suspending disbelief and imagining that the character believes they are a real person (in the make-believe world). We partially maintain this suspended disbelief when the character breaks the fourth wall and exhibits a belief that they’re not a real person. This has the effect of the character seeming to believe they’re both real and not real at the same time. Continuing to view them as the character can also make the character seem delusional in other ways. For instance, if an actor forgets their line that is an answer to a simple question, the character might seem to have delusional lack of knowledge for not knowing the answer.</p><h4>17. Why are practical jokes and pranks funny?</h4><p>In my foundational article, I showed how the target of a prank can be a source of humor by appearing to have a delusional belief (the belief a house can disappear). Sometimes in a prank, the practical joker themselves has a delusional belief — one that is pretended. This pretense is obvious to the observer but hidden from the target. The result is another source of humor, as we see in this example from <em>Candid Camera</em>:</p><p>The targets are real customers at a restaurant. The prankster poses as a fellow diner who sits extremely close to them, talks loudly on the phone, and reaches over to take their bread. The delusion we observers find funny is the prankster’s pretend belief that it’s acceptable or appropriate to do this, even though it clearly isn’t (Impropriety). We might also find the target’s delusional lack of awareness that they’re being pranked funny. It’s clear to us what’s happening, so we feel it should be clear to them.</p><p>At first, it’s usually only the observer who can experience the humor because the hidden pretense causes the target to perceive harm in the prankster’s delusional belief. But when the prank (and the pretense) is revealed, the perception of harm is reduced, and the target is now more likely to find the prankster’s pretend delusion funny. The target might also now find their own lack of awareness of the prank funny. We might laugh with the target because we can now see these things through their eyes.</p><h4>18. Why are the kinds of videos in shows like “America’s Funniest Videos” funny?</h4><p>These types of candid videos frequently consist of unintentional humor caused by a delusional lack of judgment or delusional lack of awareness. Examples of delusional lack of judgment are the father getting hit in the groin because he gets too close to his son swinging the baseball bat, the person standing up on the boat and falling in, and the person trying to walk across a sheet of ice and falling down. In each case, we find it funny because we think the evidence is clear that these actions involve poor judgment. Examples of delusional lack of awareness are the person trying to walk out of their house and crashing through the screen door, the person jumping on a bed and hitting their head on a spinning ceiling fan, and the cat knocking drinking glasses off the table. We find each of these funny because we think these obstacles were clear enough that the lapse in awareness was unjustified. With the cat, we easily personify it and think of it as a person knocking the glasses over. This type of unintentional humor is often enhanced by a large dose of schadenfreude.</p><h4>19. Do you think harmless delusion can explain humor from things like tickling, play fighting, and chasing?</h4><p>I would say that humorous tickling, play fighting, and chasing are all forms of humorous pretense. A person (or other primate) pretends to have a delusional belief, and this pretend belief is what is found funny. In this case, the delusional belief is related to the impropriety of attacking or threatening another. When we find these physical threats funny, it’s because we perceive the “attacker” as believing their behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly isn’t. That we know the threat is pretended helps us to feel it’s harmless. This explanation is basically the same as the one for insult humor in my earlier article. The main difference is that, with insults, the attack is verbal rather than physical.</p><h4>20. What about things that seem funny because they are just so obviously and clearly true?</h4><p>If you say that something is funny because it’s “obviously and clearly true”, you need to explain why everything “obviously and clearly true” isn’t funny. And why everything funny isn’t “obviously and clearly true”. The perception of “truth” merely acts to sometimes enhance humor that is caused by the perception of harmless delusion. Humor that involves truth is often about the ways we exhibit and experience others’ delusional beliefs in our everyday lives. We see and enjoy that it is true that this delusion actually does occur or seem to occur in reality.</p><p>For example, when Ellen DeGeneres points out the tiny difference between airplane reclined seats and upright seats, and how airlines seem to think of it (upright = alive, slightly reclined = dead), what we find funny is the airline’s delusional belief she draws attention to (the belief there’s a difference in safety, even though there really doesn’t seem to be). When Seinfeld points out how we think hiding our wallet in our shoe at the beach is a good idea, what we find funny is the wallet-hider’s delusional belief (the belief it’s a secure place, even though it clearly isn’t).</p><p>Or take this George Carlin line: “Have you ever noticed that anybody driving slower than you is an idiot, and anyone going faster than you is a maniac?” This draws attention to a delusional belief many of us have ourselves. Clearly everyone else isn’t stupid or crazy, but the circumstances of driving cause us to overreact and believe others are much worse than they actually are. That it’s true we sometimes have this belief acts to enhance the humor.</p><h4><strong>21. What is it we are “getting” when we view the cartoon below? The most parsimonious explanation is that “getting” the cartoon is what is making it funny, the putting together of two different and seemingly incompatible frames of reference and their associations in a playful way </strong>(Swiss Army knives and French love of wine)<strong>, rather than any delusion.</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/340/1*3kDdHChNXtulU-P8EiEh6Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>While that may be a simple explanation, it is too broad and superficial to be sufficient for humor and valuable in our understanding of it, as I’ve explained in my critique of incongruity theories. An explanation that is perhaps not as simple, but is more precise and insightful, is that the cartoon is funny because we perceive that a person believes that it’s sensible to create or own a single device with twelve of the same corkscrews, even though it clearly isn’t sensible (delusional lack of judgment). Also, the cartoon greatly exaggerates the love the French have for wine, making them seem like they believe wine is much more important than it actually is (delusional magnification). We “get” this (i.e., perceive these delusions) very quickly because of our high-powered theory of mind, which enables us to automatically associate a device with the mind of a person that would create and use it. I’d argue that my explanation describes what is noticeably at the heart of the cartoon and is therefore much more accurate and meaningful than saying it’s funny because we playfully “put together two incompatible frames of reference”.</p><h4>22. I think you are stretching your theory too much with some of your explanations.</h4><p>I admit my theory needs to be stretched. Any valid universal humor theory would need to have this flexibility in order to cover all humor. But I don’t think it ever stretches to the point of breaking. The key question to ask is if an explanation is plausible. Is it plausible that a harmless delusional belief is present and perceptible in the stimulus found funny? I contend that it always is.</p><h4>23. Isn’t your theory the same as the Benign Violation Theory (BVT)?</h4><p>I think my theory and BVT have similarities, but they are different in significant ways. The “benign” and “harmless” conditions are basically the same, however the “violation” and “delusion” conditions are <em>very</em> different. Knowing that humor is fundamentally about a person’s delusional belief is, I contend, significantly more meaningful and useful than knowing it is about, as BVT claims, something “wrong” or “not as it should be”. A multitude of things could cause something to seem wrong or not as it should be, so it ultimately doesn’t really tell us much. By knowing it’s about delusional belief, we understand specifically the root cause and true nature of humor. Plus, we can then delve further, as I have, into the different kinds of delusion in order to gain even greater insight.</p><p>I think the following comparison highlights the value of my theory in relation to BVT. Which set of terms seems to more accurately and meaningfully describe what is present in funny things?</p><ul><li>Types of Violation (BVT): Norm Violation, Bad, Incorrect, Wrong, Worse than Expected, Illogical, Physical Threat, Identity Threat.</li><li>Types of Delusion (HDT): Diminishment, Magnification, Lack of Knowledge or Judgment, Lack of Awareness, Misunderstanding, Impropriety, Contradiction, Nonsense, and Impossibility or Improbability.</li></ul><p>And, importantly, I hypothesize there are instances where HDT and BVT will make different predictions. BVT’s lack of specificity will sometimes lead to false positives. These same false positives will not occur with the more-precise HDT. Here are two classes of cases where HDT and BVT make different predictions:</p><ol><li><strong>Minor errors, such as those in speaking, typing, math, etc:</strong> BVT will incorrectly predict these errors will likely be funny, because they are cases where something is wrong or not as it should be. HDT will correctly predict humor would likely not occur because they are cases with a lack of delusion. As explained earlier, we’re unlikely to perceive the maker of a minor mistake as delusional because we’re unlikely to feel that the evidence to the contrary was clear. We know from experience that such minor slip-ups are easy to make with just a slight lack of awareness or misunderstanding.</li><li><strong>Informed choice:</strong> cases where a person acts with full knowledge and intention about what seems wrong in their situation. BVT will incorrectly predict humor because its conditions appear to be met. HDT will correctly predict humor would not occur because the person holds no belief contradicted by clear evidence to the contrary. They are fully aware of what they are doing and why, leaving nothing to attribute as delusional. Two instances of this class: eating extremely spicy food voluntarily, and deliberately breaking a minor rule. A third instance, identified by BVT researchers themselves as a case their theory struggles with, is benign masochism, where a person voluntarily seeks an unpleasant sensation for enjoyment.</li></ol><h4>24. What about the Semantic Script Theory of Humor² and the General Theory of Verbal Humor³? How is your theory an improvement?</h4><p>These more detailed incongruity theories attempt to provide more specificity to “incongruity” by saying that the opposing things need to be associated in some way or, as Victor Raskin says, “make pseudo-sense together”. But, ultimately, this overarching concept of an incongruity that is “associated”, “relevant”, “pseudo-logical”, “of a certain type” etc. is, in my view, still too imprecise to be useful in our understanding of humor itself. It might be necessary (because it’s vaguely defined), but it isn’t sufficient to explain all humor. Many situations with these qualities are non-humorous. The two counterexamples given above for BVT would also apply here.</p><p>The theorists also give a very long list of ways things might be opposed (script opposition) and techniques/processes that connect them (logical mechanism). This is essentially a list of possible elements we might find in humorous stimuli. While this may be useful in cataloging the various components of humorous instances, it has little value in helping us know what’s at the center of humor itself. The collection of script oppositions and logical mechanisms is also neither necessary nor sufficient for humor. This is evident in the theorists’ own admission that creating an exhaustive enumeration of all of them is impossible.</p><p>I maintain that the concept of delusion is superior because 1) it explains all cases of humor, not just verbal humor, 2) it more precisely, concisely, and meaningfully describes what is present and noticeable in all humor, 3) the list of nine types of delusion is an exhaustive list that focuses only on what triggers humor rather than cataloging elements found in humorous instances, 4) with the condition of harmlessness, it appears to be necessary and sufficient for humor, and 5) delusional belief is grounded in Theory of Mind research, which has known neural correlates, a documented developmental trajectory, and established measurement paradigms entirely outside humor research. This gives HDT an external anchor for validating its central construct that incongruity-based theories lack.</p><h4>25. It doesn’t matter how many examples you show. It is still cherry picking. They haven’t been randomly assembled. You, the theorist, have picked them.</h4><p>I agree all the examples are not conclusive evidence, but it’s not quantity for quantity’s sake. It’s about comprehensiveness. I’ve now illustrated how the following forms of humor can all be explained by HDT: canned jokes, cartoons, television, movies, books, standup, practical jokes, physical humor, tickling/play-fighting, first-person, third-person, unintentional, puns, malapropism, paradox, non sequitur, bathos, pretense, insult, anti-humor, analogy, anthropomorphism, hyperbole, verbal irony, situational irony, dramatic irony, parody, and satire. I feel this goes a long way to supporting the universality of my theory. Plus, I believe I’ve been able to plausibly refute all potential counterexamples presented to me by others.</p><h4>26. I have seen no evidence that delusion is sufficient (with harmlessness) to cause humor.</h4><p>The best evidence currently available that harmless delusion is sufficient for humor is that no counterexample has been successfully produced. I have subjected the theory to extensive thought experiments, including many proposed by others, and in every case a harmless delusional belief has been plausibly perceptible in stimuli that are genuinely and widely found funny. More importantly, I have yet to encounter a clear instance of harmless delusional belief that is genuinely and widely found unfunny. It is worth noting that no other prominent humor theory can make this claim about sufficiency. Incongruity, benign violation, surprise, superiority, and relief all have instances that are clearly humorless, meaning none of them are sufficient for humor.</p><p>The thought experiment approach has limitations since the theorist is involved in assessing each case. A rigorous experiment like the one I have proposed would provide more conclusive evidence, using pre-registered falsification conditions and participants who are unaware of the theory to test whether stimuli rated as containing harmless delusional belief consistently produce higher funniness ratings than matched stimuli without it.</p><h4>27. You can’t be the sole arbiter, explainer, and validator of your theory. The concept of delusion will be hard to reliably identify within the stimuli for anyone but you.</h4><p>It would be challenging to operationalize, but I think it can be done reliably. One approach is to show people a stimulus and ask them to make a binary judgment: Do you agree or disagree that [identify person in stimulus] appeared to believe [describe the belief] and that it should have been clear to this person that it was incorrect? This question avoids clinical vocabulary and maps directly onto HDT’s definition of delusional belief. Using a between-subjects design, where different groups of participants rate delusional belief and funniness separately for the same stimuli, addresses the concern about the theorist being the sole validator. Participants who know nothing about the theory are making the delusional belief judgment on their own terms, with no knowledge of how the stimulus was rated for funniness by a different group.</p><h4>28. If you know the secret to humor, why aren’t you a world famous comedian?</h4><p>While I do claim that my theory identifies the unifying core element of humor, I don’t claim it is a guaranteed formula for creating successful comedy. You could perhaps use my theory and nine types of delusion as a basic guide (e.g., let’s make this character overreact or let’s make him misunderstand or let’s make her contradict herself), but from there you’re on your own to use skill and creativity to devise the joke. My theory in no way gives a person that skill or creativity, and isn’t meant to.</p><p><em>Contact Gary at howhumorworks@gmail.com</em></p><p><em>Updated March 2026 to reflect further development of the theory</em></p><p><strong>References</strong></p><ol><li>Gibbs, R. W., Jr., &amp; Tendahl, M. (2006). Cognitive Effort and Effects in Metaphor Comprehension: Relevance Theory and Psycholinguistics.</li><li>Raskin, V. <em>Semantic mechanisms of humour</em>. New York: Springer Science &amp; Business Media, 2012.</li><li>Attardo, S., and Raskin, V. ‘Script theory revisited: Joke similarity and joke representation model’, in: <em>HUMOR: International Journal of Humor Research</em>, 4 (3–4), 1991, 293–348.</li></ol><h4>The “How Humor Works” series presenting the Harmless Delusion Theory</h4><ul><li>Part 1: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong><em>How Humor Works</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>(foundational article)</li><li>Part 2: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-jerry-seinfelds-humor-works-43315ce17182"><strong><em>How Jerry Seinfeld’s Humor Works</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 3: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-airplane-730668da627"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Airplane!’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 4: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-annie-hall-6ee2631af6ba"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Annie Hall’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 5: This article</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4bc48098f2c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Humor Works in ‘Annie Hall’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-annie-hall-6ee2631af6ba?source=rss-3539f37bfa98------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ee2631af6ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gary Borislow]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Apr 2022 11:05:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-30T15:06:00.765Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Applying the Harmless Delusion Theory of Humor</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*gNsPR3RXxWFJ6bvY3Poubg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo: MGM</figcaption></figure><p>In my first article, <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong><em>How Humor Works</em></strong></a>, I introduced my new and unique humor theory, the Harmless Delusion Theory. Using examples from many forms of humor, I explained why I contend that my theory accurately and meaningfully identifies what causes us to find things funny. I also discussed its strengths in comparison to popular ideas like surprise, incongruity, truth, and superiority. In this article, I take a deep dive into a single well-known humorous work, the movie <em>Annie Hall</em>, to further illustrate my theory’s effectiveness.</p><p>First, a quick recap of the theory:</p><p><strong>I propose that the essence of humor is <em>harmless delusion</em>. Humor occurs when a perceiver sees a person as holding a delusional belief and at the same time judges the situation to be harmless.</strong></p><p>I’m using delusion in its ordinary, non-clinical sense. The perceiver thinks two things about the same person at once: that the person believes something is the case, and that clear evidence to the contrary is available to the person. The delusional belief may be one the person actually holds, one they are pretending to hold, or one the perceiver imagines them holding. The person may be someone other than the perceiver or the perceiver themselves. The person may also be an animal or thing that the perceiver imagines as a person.</p><p>Harmlessness is a judgment by the perceiver that the situation is, at least to some degree, okay or acceptable to them personally. What seems delusional and what feels harmless both depend on the individual perceiver.</p><p>I suggest that there are nine distinct ways this delusion occurs. We experience something as funny only when we perceive that a person holds one or more of these beliefs and that the situation feels harmless to us:</p><ol><li><strong>Delusional Diminishment (e.g., underreaction, understatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much smaller in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Magnification (e.g., overreaction, overstatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment about something is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Awareness</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Misunderstanding</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impropriety</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Contradiction</strong>:<strong> </strong>1) A belief that something both is the case and is not the case at the same time. 2) A belief that two things are compatible, even though they clearly are not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Nonsense</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impossibility or Improbability</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something can be done or happen, even though it clearly cannot or almost certainly cannot.</li></ol><p>Now on to the humor in <em>Annie Hall</em>. Because the movie is fictional, the potential for the jokes to feel harmless to us is readily apparent. So, I will focus on pointing out the delusional beliefs that are the root cause of the humor. I’ve picked a number of representative examples from the movie and grouped them by the types of delusion they exhibit. I’ll conclude with a look at the key role delusion plays in the movie’s sarcastic irony.</p><h3>Delusional Magnification (e.g., overreaction, overstatement)</h3><p>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</p><p>Child Alvy is depressed and has stopped caring about anything. He tells his mother and doctor why: “The universe is expanding. The universe is everything. And if it’s expanding, someday it will break apart and that will be the end of everything.” Alvy’s mother: “What is that your business?… What has the universe got to do with it? You’re here in Brooklyn. Brooklyn is not expanding.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s belief that the significance to his life of the universe’s expansion is much larger than it clearly is. His mother, conversely, exhibits delusional diminishment (understatement<em>)</em> by referring to the universe as “business” and asking what relevance it has at all.</p><p>Alvy (Woody Allen): “I feel that life is divided up into the horrible and the miserable. Those are the two categories. The horrible would be like terminal cases. And blind and crippled. I don’t know how they get through life. It’s amazing to me. And the miserable is everyone else.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: With exaggeration, Alvy’s belief the extent of miserableness is much larger than it clearly is.</p><p>Annie (Diane Keaton): “Sometimes I ask myself how I’d stand up under torture.” Alvy: “You? You kidding? If the Gestapo would take away your Bloomingdale’s charge card, you’d tell them everything.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: With Alvy’s exaggeration, Annie’s belief that the pain of not having a credit card is much larger than it clearly is.</p><h3>Delusional Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</h3><p>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Alvy supposedly grows up in a house that sits beneath a roller coaster in Coney Island. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The family’s belief that their judgment about the house’s livability is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>[At a California health food restaurant] Alvy: “I’m gonna have the alfalfa sprouts and a plate of mashed yeast.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The restaurant’s and Alvy’s belief that their judgment about serving and eating plain yeast is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Alvy: “I don’t use any major hallucinogenics. I took a puff about five years ago at a party. I tried to take my pants off over my head.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s belief that his knowledge about how to take pants off is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Alvy: “Annie, there’s a big lobster behind the refrigerator. I can’t get it out. This thing’s heavy. Maybe if I put a little dish of butter sauce here with a nutcracker, it will run out the other side.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that his knowledge is correct that lobsters know what butter and a nutcracker mean, even though it clearly is not. An example of <strong>humorous pretense</strong>, where a person creates humor to amuse others in their reality by overtly pretending to have a delusional belief.</p><h3>Delusional Lack of Awareness</h3><p>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Alvy, in a flashback, is wondering what his childhood classmates are like as adults. We then see the children as they state what they are doing in the future as adults: “I run a profitable dress company.” “I’m President of the Pinkus Plumbing Company.” “I sell tallises.” “I used to be a heroin addict. Now I’m a methadone addict.” “I’m into leather.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The children seem to think they are adults. They have a belief their awareness of who they are is correct, even though it clearly is not. This is also absurdity (extreme lack of awareness).</p><h3>Delusional Misunderstanding</h3><p>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</p><p>Alvy’s date brings him to see a yogi speak. Alvy’s date: “He’s got millions of followers who would crawl all the way across the world just to touch the hem of his garment.” Alvy: “Really? It must be a tremendous hem.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that his date means the followers like the yogi’s hem, even though she clearly means they like the yogi.</p><p>Alvy has killed spiders at Annie’s apartment. Alvy: “I did it. I killed them both. [Annie is crying] What’s the matter? What are you sad about? What did you want me to do? Capture them and rehabilitate them?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that Annie’s crying means she’s sad about the spiders, even though it clearly means she’s sad about something else.</p><p>Alvy: “I was having lunch with some guys from NBC. So I said, ‘Did you eat yet or what?’ And Tom Christie said, ‘No. D’you?’ Not ‘Did you’. ‘D’you eat?’ ‘D’you?’ Not ‘Did you eat?’ but ‘D’you eat?’ ‘Jew?’ You get it? ‘Jew eat?’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s belief that Tom means “Jew”, even though he clearly means “did you”. This is also delusional magnification (overstatement).</p><h3>Delusional Impropriety</h3><p>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Annie and Alvy have just met for the first time a few hours earlier. Annie: “This tie is a present from Grammy Hall.” Alvy: “Your Grammy? My Grammy never gave gifts. She was too busy getting raped by Cossacks.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief it’s appropriate to make such a comment in a casual conversation with someone he just met, even though it clearly is not. This is also delusional magnification (overstatement).</p><p>Soon after they begin dating, Alvy and Annie are in a bookstore and Alvy brings her books on death: “I’m going to buy you these books because I think you should read them instead of that cat book. Because, you know, I’m obsessed with death, I think. Big subject with me. I have a very pessimistic view of life. You should know this about me if we’re going to go out.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s belief that it’s appropriate, at this point in their relationship, to urge her to read the books, even though it clearly is not.</p><h3>Delusional Contradiction</h3><p>A belief that something both is the case and isn’t the case at the same time.</p><p>Alvy telling a joke: “Two elderly women are at a Catskill mountain resort. One of them says, ‘Boy, the food at this place is really terrible.’ The other one says, ‘Yeah I know, and such small portions.’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The woman’s belief she both doesn’t like the food and does like the food (she wants more of it).</p><p>Alvy approaches a man and woman on a street: “Here, you look like a very happy couple, are you?” Woman: “Yeah.” Alvy: “Yeah? So, how do you account for it?” Woman: “Uh, I’m very shallow and empty and I have no ideas and nothing interesting to say.” Man: “And I’m exactly the same way.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The couple appear and sound happy and confident, yet their words express unhappiness and lack of confidence. Also, the delusional norm violation of volunteering this to a stranger.</p><h3>Delusional Nonsense</h3><p>A belief that something has meaning, even though it clearly doesn’t.</p><p>Annie (to Alvy): “Oh, God, what a dumb thing to say, right? I mean, you say ‘you play well’ and then right away I have to say ‘you play well’. Oh, oh, God, Annie. Well, oh well, la-di-da, la-di-da, la-la. Yeah.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Annie’s belief “la-di-da” has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</p><h3>Delusional Impossibility</h3><p>A belief that something can be done or happen, even though it clearly cannot or almost certainly cannot.</p><p>Alvy telling a joke: “I was thrown out of NYU my freshman year for cheating on my metaphysics final. I looked within the soul of the boy sitting next to me.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that it’s possible to cheat on an exam by looking into someone else’s soul, even though is clearly is not. Also, the school has the same belief.</p><p>Alvy telling a joke: “This guy goes to a psychiatrist and says, ‘Doc, my brother’s crazy. He thinks he’s a chicken.’ And the doctor says, ‘Well, why don’t you turn him in?’ And the guy says, ‘I would, but I need the eggs.’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The guy’s belief that it’s possible for his brother to lay eggs, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>[In California] Annie: “It’s so clean out here.” Alvy: “That’s because they don’t throw their garbage away, they make it into television shows.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that it’s possible to make a television show out of waste, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Alvy: “There’s a spider in your bathroom the size of a Buick.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: With exaggeration, Alvy’s pretend belief that it’s possible the spider is as large as a car, even though it clearly is not.</p><h3>Sarcastic Verbal Irony</h3><p>I maintain that all humor flows from the nine types of delusional belief, and the humor found in verbal irony is no exception. Verbal irony occurs when a person overtly pretends to have a belief with the intention of implying their attitude about something or someone. Sarcastic verbal irony is when this attitude is a negative evaluation meant to criticize, insult, or ridicule someone. Like with humorous pretense, we find the pretend belief in verbal irony funny when we view it as delusional.</p><p>Alvy (to Annie, who has just parked the car they were in): “That’s OK. We can walk to the curb from here.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that the distance to the curb is much larger than it clearly is (Magnification).</p><p>Alvy (to Annie): “Grammy Hall? What, did you grow up in a Norman Rockwell painting?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that it’s possible Annie grew up in a painting, even though it clearly is not (Impossibility).</p><p>Alvy (to Annie, who has arrived late): “Jesus! What did you do? Come by way of the Panama Canal?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Alvy’s pretend belief that it’s possible Annie took that route, even though it clearly is not (Impossibility or Improbability).</p><p><em>Contact Gary at howhumorworks@gmail.com</em></p><p><em>Updated March 2026 to reflect further development of the theory</em></p><h3>The “How Humor Works” series presenting the Harmless Delusion Theory</h3><ul><li>Part 1: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong><em>How Humor Works</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>(foundational article)</li><li>Part 2: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-jerry-seinfelds-humor-works-43315ce17182"><strong><em>How Jerry Seinfeld’s Humor Works</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 3: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-airplane-730668da627"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Airplane!’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 4: This article</li><li>Part 5: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/harmless-delusion-theory-of-humor-responding-to-questions-and-objections-4bc48098f2c9"><strong><em>Responding to Questions and Objections</em></strong></a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ee2631af6ba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Humor Works in ‘Airplane!’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-airplane-730668da627?source=rss-3539f37bfa98------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/730668da627</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gary Borislow]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Mar 2022 17:12:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-30T15:05:56.049Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Applying the Harmless Delusion Theory of Humor</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZUj0PsTD1EqzZ2XB6AkXig.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo: Paramount Pictures</figcaption></figure><p>In my first article, <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong><em>How Humor Works</em></strong></a>, I introduced my new and unique humor theory, the Harmless Delusion Theory. Using examples from many forms of humor, I explained why I contend that my theory accurately and meaningfully identifies what causes us to find things funny. I also discussed its strengths in comparison to popular ideas like surprise, incongruity, truth, and superiority. In this article, I take a deep dive into a single well-known humorous work, the movie <em>Airplane!</em>, to further illustrate the effectiveness of my theory.</p><p>First, a quick recap of the theory:</p><p><strong>I propose that the essence of humor is <em>harmless delusion</em>. Humor occurs when a perceiver sees a person as holding a delusional belief and at the same time judges the situation to be harmless.</strong></p><p>I’m using delusion in its ordinary, non-clinical sense. The perceiver thinks two things about the same person at once: that the person believes something is the case, and that clear evidence to the contrary is available to the person. The delusional belief may be one the person actually holds, one they are pretending to hold, or one the perceiver imagines them holding. The person may be someone other than the perceiver or the perceiver themselves. The person may also be an animal or thing that the perceiver imagines as a person.</p><p>Harmlessness is a judgment by the perceiver that the situation is, at least to some degree, okay or acceptable to them personally. What seems delusional and what feels harmless both depend on the individual perceiver.</p><p>I suggest that there are nine distinct ways this delusion occurs. We experience something as funny only when we perceive that a person holds one or more of these beliefs and that the situation feels harmless to us:</p><ol><li><strong>Delusional Diminishment (e.g., underreaction, understatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much smaller in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Magnification (e.g., overreaction, overstatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment about something is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Awareness</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Misunderstanding</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impropriety</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Contradiction</strong>:<strong> </strong>1) A belief that something both is the case and is not the case at the same time. 2) A belief that two things are compatible, even though they clearly are not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Nonsense</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impossibility or Improbability</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something can be done or happen, even though it clearly cannot or almost certainly cannot.</li></ol><p>Now on to the humor in <em>Airplane!</em>. Because the movie is fictional, the potential for the jokes to feel harmless to us is readily apparent. So, I will focus on pointing out the delusional beliefs that are the root cause of the humor. I’ve picked a number of representative examples from the movie and grouped them by the types of delusion they exhibit.</p><h3>Delusional Diminishment (e.g., underreaction, understatement)</h3><p>A belief that something is much smaller in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</p><p>[Reading newspaper headlines] Kramer: “Passengers certain to die!” McCroskey: “Airline negligent!” Johnny: “There’s a sale at Penney’s!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Johnny’s belief the seriousness or danger of the situation with the plane is much smaller than it clearly is. He maintains this belief throughout the movie.</p><h3>Delusional Magnification (e.g., overreaction, overstatement)</h3><p>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</p><p>McCroskey wrongly thinks the plane is heading for the tower he’s in (“It’s coming right at us!”) and jumps out the window. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: McCroskey’s belief the danger to him is much larger than it clearly is.</p><p>In a gag repeated throughout the film, Ted tells stories of his life to fellow passengers. As he finishes, each fellow passenger kills (or has killed) themselves. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The fellow passengers’ belief that the pain of listening to the story is much larger than it clearly is.</p><h3>Delusional Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</h3><p>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>A sign in the plane reads, “NO SMOKING. EL NO A YOU SMOKO. FASTEN SEATBELTS. PUTANA DA SEATBELTZ.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The airline’s belief that their knowledge about the translation is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Rumack: “What was it we had for dinner tonight?” Elaine: “Well, we had a choice of steak or fish.” Rumack: “Yes, yes, I remember, I had lasagna.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Rumack’s belief that his knowledge about what he ate is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Controller: “Maybe we oughta turn on the searchlights now.” Kramer (who is helping them guide the plane): “No. That’s just what they’ll be expecting us to do.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Kramer’s belief that his knowledge is correct that the plane is suddenly the enemy, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Elaine makes an announcement: “Ladies and gentleman, this is your stewardess speaking. We regret any inconvenience the sudden cabin movement might have caused. This is due to periodic air pockets we encountered. There’s no reason to be alarmed and we hope you enjoy the rest of your flight. By the way, is there anyone on board who knows how to fly a plane?” [Passengers erupt in panic] <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Elaine’s belief that her judgment about making such an announcement is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><h3>Delusional Lack of Awareness</h3><p>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Randy, the flight attendant, borrows a guitar from a passenger to play a song to a sick passenger. On the way down the aisle she bangs passengers on the head with the guitar yet keeps walking. While playing, she knocks the sick girl’s IV tube out with the guitar yet keeps going. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Randy’s belief her awareness of what’s happening with the guitar is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>The flight attendants conspicuously drag the plane’s unconscious pilot and copilot down the aisle without the passengers noticing. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The passengers’ belief their awareness of what’s happening on the plane is correct, even though it clearly is not. (Also, the flight attendants’ delusional lack of judgment in thinking this wouldn’t be noticed.)</p><p>Rumack enters the cockpit to say, “I just want to tell you both good luck. We’re all counting on you.” He does this before, during, and after the emergency landing. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Rumack’s belief his awareness of what’s happening and what he’s doing is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><h3>Delusional Misunderstanding</h3><p>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</p><p>Rumack: “Can you fly this plane and land it?” Striker: “Surely you can’t be serious.” Rumack: “I am serious, and don’t call me Shirley.”</p><p>Rumack: “Captain, how soon can you land?” Oveur: “I can’t tell.” Rumack: “You can tell me, I’m a doctor.” Oveur: “No, I mean I’m just not sure.” Rumack: “Well, can’t you take a guess?” Oveur: “Well, not for another two hours.” Rumack: “You can’t take a guess for another two hours?”</p><p>Rumack: “You’d better tell the Captain we’ve got to land as soon as we can. This woman has to be gotten to a hospital.” Elaine: “A hospital? What is it?” Rumack: “It’s a big building with patients, but that’s not important right now.”</p><p><strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: In all three exchanges, Rumack’s belief the other person’s words have a particular meaning, even though they clearly mean something else.</p><p>McCroskey: “Johnny, what can you make out of this? [Hands him the weather briefing] Johnny: “This? Why, I can make a hat or a brooch or a pterodactyl…” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Johnny’s belief McCroskey is asking what he can turn the piece of paper into, even though he’s clearly asking what Johnny thinks about it.</p><p>Captain Oveur and Roger Murdock both mistake the radio messages “Over” and “Roger” as someone calling their names. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Their belief the words mean their names, even though they clearly mean the radio message terms.</p><p>In a flashback, a man Elaine is dancing with gets stabbed in the back and begins motioning to his back. Elaine thinks he’s still dancing and mimics his moves. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Elaine’s belief the man’s movements mean he’s dancing, even though they clearly mean he needs help.</p><p>When a flight attendant tells the passenger’s to get into crash positions, the passengers get into positions that look like it is after they crashed. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The passengers’ belief the words mean one thing, even though they clearly mean something else.</p><h3>Delusional Impropriety</h3><p>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Captain Oveur asks a little boy visiting the cockpit questions such as, “Ever seen a grown man naked?” and “Have you ever been in a Turkish prison?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Oveur’s belief that his questions are appropriate, even though they clearly are not.</p><p>After a passenger starts panicking and is slapped by several people to try to calm her down, other passengers line up with boxing gloves, a wrench, a gun, etc. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The passengers’ belief that their behavior is appropriate, even though it clearly is not.</p><h3>Delusional Contradiction</h3><p>A belief that something both is the case and isn’t the case at the same time.</p><p>Ted: “My orders came through. My squadron ships out tomorrow, we’re bombing the storage depots at Daiquiri at 18:00 hours. We’re coming in from the North, below their radar.” Elaine: “When will you be back?” Ted: “I can’t tell you that. It’s classified.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Ted’s belief he both can and can’t reveal details about the mission.</p><h3>Absurdity</h3><p>When any of the nine types is taken to an extreme degree, the result is absurdity. Much of the humor in <em>Airplane! </em>could likely be classified here.</p><p><em>Contact Gary at howhumorworks@gmail.com</em></p><p><em>Updated March 2026 to reflect further development of the theory</em></p><h4>The “How Humor Works” series presenting the Harmless Delusion Theory</h4><ul><li>Part 1: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong><em>How Humor Works</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>(foundational article)</li><li>Part 2: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-jerry-seinfelds-humor-works-43315ce17182"><strong><em>How Jerry Seinfeld’s Humor Works</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 3: This article</li><li>Part 4: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-annie-hall-6ee2631af6ba"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Annie Hall’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 5: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/harmless-delusion-theory-of-humor-responding-to-questions-and-objections-4bc48098f2c9"><strong><em>Responding to Questions and Objections</em></strong></a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=730668da627" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Jerry Seinfeld’s Humor Works]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-jerry-seinfelds-humor-works-43315ce17182?source=rss-3539f37bfa98------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/43315ce17182</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jerry-seinfeld]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gary Borislow]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Mar 2022 12:42:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-30T15:05:51.140Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Applying the Harmless Delusion Theory of Humor</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*UFkpGZza2Kjy7nB4Wj9Mxw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/thomashawk/">Thomas Hawk</a></figcaption></figure><p>In my first article, <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong><em>How Humor Works</em></strong></a>, I introduced my new and unique humor theory, the Harmless Delusion Theory. Using examples from many forms of humor, I explained why I contend that my theory accurately and meaningfully identifies what causes us to find things funny. I also discussed its strengths in comparison to popular ideas like surprise, incongruity, truth, and superiority. In this article, I take a deep dive into the work of a single well-known comedian, Jerry Seinfeld, to further illustrate the effectiveness of my theory.</p><p>First, a quick recap of the theory:</p><p><strong>I propose that the essence of humor is <em>harmless delusion</em>. Humor occurs when a perceiver sees a person as holding a delusional belief and at the same time judges the situation to be harmless.</strong></p><p>I’m using delusion in its ordinary, non-clinical sense. The perceiver thinks two things about the same person at once: that the person believes something is the case, and that clear evidence to the contrary is available to the person. The delusional belief may be one the person actually holds, one they are pretending to hold, or one the perceiver imagines them holding. The person may be someone other than the perceiver or the perceiver themselves. The person may also be an animal or thing that the perceiver imagines as a person.</p><p>Harmlessness is a judgment by the perceiver that the situation is, at least to some degree, okay or acceptable to them personally. What seems delusional and what feels harmless both depend on the individual perceiver.</p><p>I suggest that there are nine distinct ways this delusion occurs. We experience something as funny only when we perceive that a person holds one or more of these beliefs and that the situation feels harmless to us:</p><ol><li><strong>Delusional Diminishment (e.g., underreaction, understatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much smaller in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Magnification (e.g., overreaction, overstatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment about something is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Awareness</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Misunderstanding</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impropriety</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Contradiction</strong>:<strong> </strong>1) A belief that something both is the case and is not the case at the same time. 2) A belief that two things are compatible, even though they clearly are not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Nonsense</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impossibility or Improbability</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something can be done or happen, even though it clearly cannot or almost certainly cannot.</li></ol><p>Now on to the observational humor of Jerry Seinfeld’s stand-up comedy. Stand-up is an artificial environment that creates a certain degree of safety and distance for the audience. This and the fact that Seinfeld largely sticks to innocuous topics make his comedy’s potential to feel harmless to us readily apparent. So, I will focus on pointing out the delusional beliefs that are the root cause of the humor. I’ve picked a variety of jokes from throughout his career and grouped them by the ten types of delusion they exhibit. I’ll conclude with a look at the key role delusion plays in one of his favorite techniques: sarcastic irony.</p><h3><strong>1. Delusional Diminishment (e.g., underreaction, understatement)</strong></h3><p>A belief that something is much smaller in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</p><p>On illusionists who appear to catch a bullet between their teeth: “How do you even know that you would be good at this? Do they throw it at you a few times first? Really hard. Put it in the gun and go, ‘Okay, Bill… this one’s going to be coming a little bit faster now.’ <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The shooter’s belief that the speed of the bullet is much slower than it clearly is.</p><h3><strong>2. Delusional Magnification (e.g., overreaction, overstatement)</strong></h3><p>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</p><p>“They’re always showing you how detergents get out bloodstains. Kind of a violent image, isn’t it? I think if you have a T-shirt with bloodstains all over it, maybe laundry isn’t your biggest problem right now.” Seinfeld creates an image of a person in a serious predicament, but stopping to do laundry. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The person’s belief that the importance of the laundry is much larger than it clearl is.</p><p>“When I was a kid, and they invented the Pop-Tart, the back of my head blew right off. We couldn’t comprehend it. It was too advanced. When we saw the Pop-Tart in the supermarket, it was like an alien spaceship. And we were just chimps in the dirt playing with sticks.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: With the help of exaggeration, the kids’ belief the significance of the Pop-Tart is much larger than it clearly is.</p><h3>3. <strong>Delusional </strong>Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</h3><p>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment about something is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>“You ever see a guy with a mattress on the roof of his car, driving down the highway? Without fail, he’s got his hand out the window, holding the mattress… This moron believes that if the wind catches this huge rectangle at 70 mph, ‘I got it. I got it… I am using MY ARM.’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The driver’s belief that his knowledge or judgment is correct that he can hold the mattress to the car, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>“When you buy socks they always come on a tiny hanger. Does anybody have a tiny sock closet to hang them up? Tiny doors. Go through them to pick out what you’re wearing that day.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Seinfeld’s pretend belief that his knowledge is correct that the hangers for socks are meant to be used at home, even though it clearly is not. An example of <strong>humorous pretense</strong>, where a person creates humor to amuse others in their reality by overtly pretending to have a delusional belief.</p><h3>4. <strong>Delusional </strong>Lack of Awareness</h3><p>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>On the elderly drivers in Florida: “I just can’t drive around there. Old people drive slow, they sit low…. And the left turn signal, on from when they left the house that morning. That’s a legal turn in Florida, by the way. It’s called an Eventual Left. You can signal this week, then turn any following year of your life.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: With the help of exaggeration, the drivers’ belief their awareness of the car and their ability to drive is correct, even though it clearly is not. (Also the delusional lack of judgment in the fictional Florida law.)</p><p>“So apparently there was some sort of moose problem. And they had to move these moose by helicopter. They’d put one in a harness and then they moved him, hanging from cables underneath the helicopter. Here is an animal that’s been on the ground for thousands of years as a species. Suddenly he’s hundreds of feet in the air. And the look on his face was so funny. He was looking around like, ‘Well, I guess I can fly now… I must have eaten some kind of a weird berry or something.’” With anthropomorphism, we attribute humanlike qualities to nonhumans. In effect, we imagine them as people. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The humanlike moose’s belief their awareness of their ability to fly is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><h3>5. <strong>Delusional </strong>Misunderstanding</h3><p>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</p><p>“I’m wearing contact lenses now but I wore glasses at the age of 10. I thought I had to get glasses because I couldn’t tell what my parents looked like. I’d ask my mother for money and she’d always say, ‘What do I look like, a bank?’ ‘Do I look like I’m made of money to you?’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Child Jerry’s belief his mother’s words mean she thinks Jerry doesn’t know what she looks like, even though they clearly mean something else.</p><p>“If aliens are watching this through telescopes, they’re going to think the dogs are the leaders of the planet. If you see two life forms, one of them takes a crap, and the other one’s carrying it for him… Who would you assume is in charge of that society?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The imagined alien’s belief that our picking up after dogs means they are in charge, even though (to us) it clearly means something else. Because it’s clear to us, we feel it should be clear to anyone observing.</p><h3>6. <strong>Delusional </strong>Impropriety</h3><p>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>“That’s what happens when you’re a kid. There’s a level of boredom where you cannot support your body weight. My parents would take me to the bank and I would just liquefy. I’d walk in, ‘Oh, I can’t handle this…’ The legs just give out. They’d turn around from the teller’s window and I would be flat on my back in the middle of the floor.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The child’s belief that it’s appropriate to behave like that in a bank, even though it clearly is not. An example of how we can perceive a child as delusional when we think of an adult behaving like the child. In effect, we imagine the child as a delusional adult. (Also the delusional magnification by the child.)</p><p>“I think if you jump out of a plane, and that chute doesn’t open, the helmet is now wearing you for protection. Later on, the helmet’s talking with the other helmets going, ‘It’s a good thing he was there or I would’ve hit the ground directly. You never jump out of a plane unless you have got a human being strapped underneath you. That’s basic safety.’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The humanlike helmet’s belief it’s acceptable to wear a person and land on them, even though (for humans) it clearly is not. With anthropomorphism, we see the helmet as a delusional person.</p><h3>7. <strong>Delusional </strong>Contradiction</h3><p>A belief that something both is the case and isn’t the case at the same time.</p><p>On wearing a Superman Halloween costume as a child: “Plus my mother makes me wear my winter coat over the costume anyway. I don’t recall Superman wearing a jacket… ‘Boy, I’m Superman but it is a little chilly out today. I’m glad I’ve got this cheap little ten-year-old-kid’s jacket.’ Seinfeld gives us the image of a Superman who needs a jacket. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Superman’s belief he both is and is not extremely strong.</p><p>“Let’s get one thing straight about dry cleaning right now. It doesn’t exist. There’s no such thing as dry cleaning. My first question is, ‘What the hell is dry cleaning fluid?’ There’s no dry fluids.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The dry cleaner’s belief that their cleaning method both is and is not dry.</p><h3>8. <strong>Delusional </strong>Nonsense</h3><p>A belief that something has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</p><p>“I’m sure some idiot said it to you today. You can’t get through a day without someone going, ‘Well… it is what it is…’ Why are you alive? To just say air words that fill the room with meaningless sounds? I’d rather someone just blew clear air in my face than said, ‘It is what it is,’ to me one more time. Just come up to me and go, ‘Pppppphhhhhhh. I get the same data from that.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: With the help of exaggeration, the person’s belief that what they’re saying has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</p><h3>9. <strong>Delusional </strong>Impossibility</h3><p>A belief that something can be done or happen, even though it clearly cannot or almost certainly cannot.</p><p>“Old men can take tremendous amounts of heat. Steam rooms, saunas, hot tubs, Jacuzzis. They love heat. I’m sure if they ever try to land a man on the sun, one of these old retired guys will be able to do it. No space suit. Just a terry-cloth jacket and a pair of flip-flops. He’ll sit there with a towel on his head going, ‘Close the door. In or out? Come on. You’re letting all the heat off the sun.’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Through exaggeration, Seinfeld’s pretend belief that it’s possible for a person to sit on the sun, even though it clearly is not.</p><h3>Absurdity</h3><p>When any of the nine types is taken to an extreme degree, the result is absurdity.</p><p>In the previous example, the man sitting on the sun. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Extreme Diminishment (underreaction). His belief that the severity of the conditions is much smaller than it clearly is.</p><p>On buying too much milk: “Now, it’s a race against the clock with the expiration date. You’re eating giant punch bowls of cereal. Three meals a day. You’re washing your face with milk. Bringing cats in from all over the neighborhood. ‘Hurry up and drink it! Come on, it’s almost time!’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Extreme Magnification (overreaction). The milk owner’s belief that the problem with the milk’s expiration is much larger than it clearly is.</p><h3>Sarcastic Verbal Irony</h3><p>I maintain that all humor flows from the nine types of delusional belief, and the humor found in verbal irony is no exception. Verbal irony occurs when a person overtly pretends to have a belief with the intention of implying their attitude about something or someone. Sarcastic verbal irony is when this attitude is a negative evaluation meant to criticize, insult, or ridicule someone. Like with humorous pretense, we find the pretend belief in verbal irony funny when we view it as delusional. Sarcasm can also point to and magnify delusion in the target’s real belief.</p><p>“We go to the beach, go in the water, put your wallet in the sneaker. Who’s going to know? What criminal mind could penetrate this Fortress of Security?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Seinfeld’s pretend belief that his own knowledge about the effectiveness of the hiding technique is correct, even though it clearly is not. Also, the wallet-hider’s similar real belief, which is alluded to and, through exaggeration, magnified by Seinfeld (Lack of Knowledge).</p><p>“I love the Lane Experts. Constantly revising and updating their lane choice. Always got the hand out the window. ‘Can I get in there? Can I get ahead of you? Can I be part of your lane? Ohh, you’re in such a great lane.’ ‘Yeah, come on in, pal… We’re zooming over here. This is the Secret Lane nobody knows about it. I’m letting you in, don’t tell any of the other cars.’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Seinfeld’s pretend belief that his own knowledge and awareness about the specialness of the lane is correct, even though it clearly is not. Also, the lane-switcher’s similar real belief, which is alluded to and, through exaggeration, magnified by Seinfeld (Lack of Knowledge and Awareness).</p><p>“And I’m sure this stupid Dual Zone thing totally works too. To keep different-temperature air molecules from co-mingling inside a three-foot-wide closed compartment of an automobile. Because when I go to my coffee place in the morning, I like to get my coffee black on the left side of the cup, cream and sugar on the right.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Seinfeld’s pretend belief that it’s possible to have coffee this way, even though it clearly is not. Also, the Dual Zone inventor’s similar real belief, which Seinfeld alludes to through analogy (Impossibility).</p><p><em>Contact Gary at howhumorworks@gmail.com</em></p><p><em>Updated March 2026 to reflect further development of the theory</em></p><h4><strong>References</strong></h4><p>Seinfeld, Jerry, 2020. Is This Anything? Simon &amp; Schuster.</p><h3>The “How Humor Works” series presenting the Harmless Delusion Theory</h3><ul><li>Part 1: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce"><strong><em>How Humor Works</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>(foundational article)</li><li>Part 2: This article</li><li>Part 3: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-airplane-730668da627"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Airplane!’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 4: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-annie-hall-6ee2631af6ba"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Annie Hall’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 5: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/harmless-delusion-theory-of-humor-responding-to-questions-and-objections-4bc48098f2c9"><strong><em>Responding to Questions and Objections</em></strong></a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=43315ce17182" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Humor Works]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-487018554fce?source=rss-3539f37bfa98------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/487018554fce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cognitive-psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gary Borislow]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Mar 2022 12:54:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-30T15:05:46.329Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Solving the mystery of what makes something funny</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W3sr1P942W1V9a0xXMFUVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Illustration by Sasha Borislow</figcaption></figure><p>Humor is a significant part of my life. Not a day goes by that I don’t consume or (try to) produce something funny. A few years ago, I developed an intense curiosity about how it worked. What exactly is it that causes us to find something funny? Many things that we find enjoyable don’t provoke a “that’s funny” response in us, so what makes humor unique? I initially assumed it would be easy to find the answer but was amazed to learn that a definitive one doesn’t exist.</p><p>It turns out that none of the standard theories are widely accepted. Evidently this is because most of them only apply to some types of humor or describe something that only accompanies humor, and the rest are too broad or vague to be meaningful. This was highly intriguing to me. How could there be such a gap in knowledge about something so ubiquitous in all our lives and essential to who we are? I’m not an academic, but I felt compelled to take matters into my own hands and search for the solution. And after extensive reading, research, observation, and discussion, I think I might have found it.</p><p>How will we know if we’ve successfully located the precise thing that triggers “funny”? We’ll know it if we can conclusively say that humor always has this thing, and this thing always has humor (i.e., the thing is both necessary and sufficient for humor to happen). Before presenting my theory, I’ll briefly discuss some of the leading explanations and why they are unsuccessful in identifying this thing we instinctively recognize as funny.</p><p>One fact that is well established is that humor happens in our minds. We experience it as a result of perceiving (mentally interpreting) something a certain way. Many people claim that what we find funny is something we perceive as surprising. This is easily refuted, though, because clearly there are examples of things we find surprising but not at all funny, and things we find funny but not at all surprising. Regarding the latter, which may not be as obvious as the former, we can all probably think of times we’ve laughed at a movie or TV show we’ve seen before, even when we knew the joke was coming. If we’re still laughing in the absence of surprise, there must be something else provoking it.</p><p>Surprise is actually one of many humor enhancers, which are things that can boost our enjoyment of humor but are not essential to it. They are the feelings, emotions, and qualities that coexist with humor. Because they accompany it and are frequently prominent, enhancers are often mistaken for humor itself. Other common ones besides surprise are superiority, relief, admiration, schadenfreude, profanity, obscenity, cleverness, truth, relevance, relatability, novelty, misdirection, delivery, and timing. We can see that none of these are the essential ingredient for humor because, like with surprise, it’s easy to think of examples of the enhancer that have a complete absence of humor, or examples of humor that have a complete absence of the enhancer.</p><p>Also popular are incongruity theories, which say that humor occurs when we perceive the juxtaposition of incompatible or contradictory things, and that these things are associated in some way. This overly broad concept suffers from the same problem as the others above in that it’s easy to imagine incongruous things with zero humor. An offshoot of the theory states that we laugh when the incongruity is resolved, but this is also insufficient for humor and mostly just pertains to the structure of a certain kind of verbal joke that has ambiguity.</p><p>A newer theory that has gained some traction helpfully provides more specificity to incongruity by suggesting that humor arises when we perceive something as wrong or not as it should be, but at the same time feel it is acceptable or okay (a benign violation)¹. This is on the right track but still unsatisfying because it ultimately doesn’t really tell us much. It’s evident from the pleasure of it that finding something funny, to at least some degree, feels acceptable or okay. So we’re left with this inexact and insufficient idea of “wrongness” to describe humor that is far too imprecise to be valuable in our understanding of it.</p><p>I’ve developed a much more specific and illuminating yet still comprehensive theory that explains exactly what this wrongness is. I contend that my theory identifies the only qualities shared by all humor and, therefore, defines humor’s fundamental nature.</p><h3><strong>The Harmless Delusion Theory</strong></h3><p><strong>I propose that the essence of humor is <em>harmless delusion</em>. Humor occurs when a perceiver sees a person as holding a delusional belief and at the same time judges the situation to be harmless.</strong></p><p>I’m using delusion in its ordinary, non-clinical sense. The perceiver thinks two things about the same person at once: that the person believes something is the case, and that clear evidence to the contrary is available to the person. The delusional belief may be one the person actually holds, one they are pretending to hold, or one the perceiver imagines them holding. The person may be someone other than the perceiver or the perceiver themselves. The person may also be an animal or thing that the perceiver imagines as a person.</p><p>Harmlessness is a judgment by the perceiver that the situation is, at least to some degree, okay or acceptable to them personally. What seems delusional and what feels harmless both depend on the individual perceiver.</p><h3><strong>The 9 Categories of Delusion</strong></h3><p>I’ve identified nine distinct ways this delusion occurs. I suggest that these nine types of delusional beliefs are at the very heart of humor. We experience something as funny only when we perceive that a person holds one or more of these beliefs and the situation feels harmless to us personally. This exhaustive list begins with types that are delusional versions of basic errors and moves toward kinds that are more inherently delusional.</p><ol><li><strong>Delusional Diminishment (e.g., underreaction, understatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much smaller in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Magnification (e.g., overreaction, overstatement)</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment about something is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Lack of Awareness</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Misunderstanding</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impropriety</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Contradiction</strong>:<strong> </strong>1) A belief that something both is the case and is not the case at the same time. 2) A belief that two things are compatible, even though they clearly are not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Nonsense</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</li><li><strong>Delusional Impossibility or Improbability</strong>:<strong> </strong>A belief that something can be done or happen, even though it clearly cannot or almost certainly cannot.</li></ol><p><em>Note: Any of the above categories can reach an absurd degree, meaning the delusional belief is presented in such an extreme form that the evidence to the contrary is impossible to miss. Absurdity in humor is one of the nine types taken to this extreme.</em></p><h3><strong>Observational Evidence</strong></h3><p>The following is an extensive list of diversified and detailed examples (83 to be exact) offered as evidence for this theory’s strength in accurately explaining the many different types of humor experiences (i.e., that harmless delusion is necessary for humor). Most of the examples are from works popular globally and already well known to be funny. Many of them also involve fictional contexts, making their potential to feel harmless to us readily apparent. So, I will concentrate mainly on pointing out the delusional belief that sparks the humor. With real-life cases, I’ll also address the perception of harmlessness.</p><p>First, we’ll look at each of the nine delusion types one by one using relatively straightforward kinds of humor. Then, we’ll examine the presence of delusion in more complex varieties. Before we jump in, here’s a technique for spotting the delusional belief in the thing found funny. Look for a person, or something that might cause us to think of a person, who acts on the belief and thus could be viewed as making an unjustified mistake. The mistake is unjustified because the person has clear evidence to the contrary available to them.</p><h4><strong>1. Delusional Diminishment</strong></h4><p>A belief that something is much smaller in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</p><p><em>Willy Wonka &amp; the Chocolate Factory</em>: Willy Wonka (Gene Wilder) reacts nonchalantly to children expanding, shrinking, falling down chutes, etc.: “It happens every time. They all become blueberries. Oh well, I’ll get it right in the end.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Wonka’s belief that the severity of the children’s condition is smaller than it clearly is.</p><p><em>The Big Lebowski</em>: The Dude (Jeff Bridges) has his house broken into and is assaulted, but his biggest worry is that his rug that “really tied the room together” is damaged. When being grabbed and thrown into a waiting car, he’s only concerned about spilling the drink he’s holding: “Careful man, there’s a beverage here.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The Dude’s belief that the danger of his situation is smaller than it clearly is.</p><p><em>Airplane 2: The Sequel</em>: Elaine (Julie Hagerty) is a flight attendant on a space shuttle and is making an announcement to passengers: “We’ve been thrown off course just a tad…In space terms, that’s about half a million miles.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Elaine’s belief that the distance they are off course is smaller than it clearly is.</p><h4><strong>2.</strong> Delusional <strong>Magnification</strong></h4><p>A belief that something is much larger in amount, degree, or significance than it clearly is.</p><p><em>The Jerk</em>:<em> </em>Navin (Steve Martin) jumps for joy when the new phone directory with his name in it is delivered: “The new phone book’s here! The new phone book’s here! I’m somebody now! Millions of people look at this book every day!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Navin’s belief that the significance of his name in the phone book is larger than it clearly is.</p><p>In a standup routine, Eddie Murphy imitates a child when first hearing the bell of an ice cream truck, excitedly yelling at the top of his lungs: “Ice cream! Ice cream! The ice cream man is coming! The ice cream man is coming! Ma! Throw down some money!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The child’s belief that the significance of the ice cream is larger than it clearly is. This is an example of how we can perceive a child as delusional when we think of an adult behaving like the child. In effect, we imagine the child as a delusional adult. This shift in perception is made easier here by an adult doing the imitation.</p><p><em>This Is Spinal Tap</em>:<em> </em>Nigel (Christopher Guest), the rock musician, is in his dressing room complaining about the tiny bread and olive with missing pimento on his food tray. Throwing the olive down, he says, “It’s a complete catastrophe!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Nigel’s belief that the problem with his food is larger than it clearly is.</p><p>In a Jerry Seinfeld standup joke, he helps us imagine a possible discussion between the people who came up with the name for Life breakfast cereal. One person says, “Why don’t we call it Oaties or Squaries?” Another one replies, “Oh, no. This is much bigger than that. This is life I tell you! It’s life!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The cereal-namer’s belief that the significance of the cereal is larger than it clearly is.</p><h4><strong>3.</strong> Delusional <strong>Lack of Knowledge or Judgment</strong></h4><p>A belief that one’s knowledge or judgment about something is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>The Office (American)</em>: Michael (Steve Carell) says, “I’m not superstitious, but I am a little stitious.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Michael’s belief that his knowledge about the word is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>The Simpsons</em>: Homer Simpson quotes: “Operator, give me the number for 911!” “I’ll make the money by selling one of my livers. I can get by with one.” “English? Who needs that? I’m never going to England.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Homer’s belief that his knowledge about these things is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>The Jerk</em>: Navin, in a fancy restaurant, orders the freshest wine (“The freshest you’ve got!”) and complains about the escargot (“You would think that in a fancy restaurant at these prices you could keep the snails off the food!”) <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Navin’s belief that his knowledge about wine and snails is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>Big</em>: Josh (Tom Hanks) is a 12-year-old in an adult body. At a party, he eats baby corn like regular corn on the cob. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Josh’s belief that his knowledge or judgment about how to eat the baby corn is correct, even though it clearly is not (especially for an adult, which is how we view him).</p><h4><strong>4.</strong> Delusional <strong>Lack of Awareness</strong></h4><p>A belief that one’s awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Canned joke: A man is driving on the highway. His wife calls him and in a worried voice says, “Honey, be careful! I just heard on the news that there was a madman driving the wrong way on the highway!” The man replies, “Not just one, there are hundreds!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The man’s belief that his awareness of what is happening on the highway is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>City Lights</em>: A Tramp (Charlie Chaplin) is eating spaghetti at a party and a paper streamer still attached to the ceiling lands in it. He eats the spaghetti and then begins eating the streamer, including standing up to do so. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: A Tramp’s belief that his awareness of what he’s eating is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>The General</em>: Johnnie (Buster Keaton) sits on the side rod of an old locomotive. As it starts moving, he goes up and down with it, but doesn’t realize it until ten seconds pass. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Johnnie’s belief that his awareness of what is happening around him is correct, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>Seinfeld</em>: Elaine (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) is at a wedding and dancing very badly (flailing thumbs, arms, and legs). The people around her just stand and stare, looking confused and annoyed. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Elaine’s belief that her awareness of her dancing ability and how others feel about her dancing is correct, even though it clearly is not. This is an example of humorous lack of self-awareness.</p><p>A hypothetical common situation that we sometimes find funny: We are alone and looking everywhere for our eyeglasses, only to eventually find them on top of our head. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Our belief that our awareness of what is on our body is correct, even though it clearly is not. This is an example of how we can find ourselves funny by perceiving our own delusion in hindsight.</p><h4><strong>5.</strong> Delusional <strong>Misunderstanding</strong></h4><p>A belief that something has a particular meaning, even though it clearly means something else.</p><p>Puns and similar wordplay contain words with double meaning. When we see or hear a statement that makes use of double meaning, we can feel enjoyment from the cleverness of its design and our own cleverness or insight in figuring out the two meanings (like the feeling of solving a problem or puzzle). But the pleasure from perceiving something as clever (i.e., intelligent, creative, skillful, quick) is <em>not the same as</em> the pleasure of amusement from humor (Aha! vs. Haha!). Not only do the two experiences feel different, but research shows that the regions of the brain they activate differ². Cleverness can only enhance our enjoyment of humor; it is not humor itself. Hence the silence or groan that typically greets an intended joke that relies on double meaning alone.</p><p>When looking at decidedly humorous things that have double meaning, we can see that there is always the presence of delusion too. One way this happens (but not the only way, as I’ll show later) is through the misunderstanding that can result from the ambiguity in double meaning. To see what I mean, watch how in the following cases, puns that are all homophones (same pronunciation, different meaning) have noticeably more humor with the incremental addition of delusional misunderstanding.</p><p>First, we have these puns in corporate slogans and taglines: “The Citi Never Sleeps” (Citibank), “Nothing runs like a Deere” (John Deere), and “The Company You Keep” (New York Life Insurance). <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: None to really speak of, and so no real humor to speak of, either. The double meaning and its cleverness are the focus, which is likely the company’s intention.</p><p>Next, we have the same kind of pun, from <em>Airplane!</em>: Rumack (Leslie Nielsen): “Can you fly this plane and land it?” Striker (Robert Hays): “Surely you can’t be serious.” Rumack: “I am serious, and don’t call me Shirley.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: We now have a prominent delusional belief based on misunderstanding, and with it, discernible humor: Rumack’s belief that the word means the woman’s name, even though it clearly means that Striker is emphasizing he thinks something is true.</p><p>And last, in a sketch from <em>Saturday Night Live, </em>the news commentator Emily Litella (Gilda Radner): “What’s all this fuss I keep hearing about violins on television? Why don’t parents want their children to see violins on television? If they only show violins after 10 o’clock at night, the little babies will all be asleep and they won’t learn any music appreciation! I say there should be more violins on television!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Still revolving around a homophonic pun (violins/violence), delusion and humor are in full bloom in this emphatic argument caused by Emily’s belief that the word means the musical instrument, even though it clearly means the negative behavior.</p><p>A bonus supercharged homophonic pun joke is the famous Abbott and Costello routine, <em>Who’s on First?</em>:<em> </em>Bud Abbott is identifying the players on a baseball team for Lou Costello, but they have names like “Who” and “What,” causing Costello to think Abbott is asking him questions. Abbott: “Who is on first base.” Costello: “What are you asking me for?” And so on. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Costello’s belief that Abbott’s words mean he is asking questions, even though they clearly mean he is saying the players’ names.</p><p>Here’s an example of delusional misunderstanding due to ambiguity of not just a single word but a sequence of words:</p><p>This joke won an online contest as the funniest joke among 40,000 rated. Two hunters are in the woods when one of them collapses and stops breathing. His friend calls 911 and tells the operator, “My friend collapsed while we were hunting and I’m afraid he might be dead.” The operator says, “Stay calm. First, let’s make sure he’s dead.” There is a pause on the other end of the line, followed by the sound of a gunshot. “All right,” says the man to the operator, “now what?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The hunter’s belief that the words “make sure he’s dead” mean “shoot him to make sure he’s dead,” even though they clearly mean “check him to make sure you’re right that he’s dead.”</p><p>Moving on from ambiguity, in <em>All in the Family</em>,<em> </em>Archie Bunker (Carroll O’Connor) uses malapropisms such as “detergent to crime,” “invading the issue,” and “last will and tentacle.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Archie’s belief that the words he’s using have a particular meaning, even though they clearly mean something else.</p><p>The misunderstanding doesn’t have to be word-based at all, as this example illustrates:</p><p><em>Hannah and Her Sisters</em>: Gail (Julie Cavner), telling Mickey (Woody Allen) he shouldn’t worry so much: “Two months ago you thought you had a malignant melanoma.” Mickey: “Naturally. I had the sudden appearance of a black spot on my back.” Gail: “It was on your shirt!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Mickey’s belief that the spot on his back means cancer, even though it clearly means he has a spot on the back of his shirt.</p><h4><strong>6.</strong> Delusional <strong>Impropriety</strong></h4><p>A belief that a behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</p><p>Henny Youngman: “Women are crazy today. Take my wife — please!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Here’s an example of double meaning made funny by delusion that doesn’t involve misunderstanding. Instead, we have Youngman’s belief that it’s appropriate or acceptable to make a request to take his wife away, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>Seinfeld</em>: The series brought us the person who stands extremely close to the person they’re speaking to (close talker), the person who dips the same chip in dip twice (double dipper), and the soup restaurateur who refuses service to customers who don’t follow his stringent rules (“No soup for you!”). <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The characters’ belief that their behavior is appropriate or acceptable, even though it clearly is not.</p><p><em>The Far Side</em>: The comic strip by Gary Larson portrays a chicken wearing glasses and an apron, serving a bowl of soup to a smaller chicken in bed, with the caption, “Quit complaining and eat it! Number one, chicken soup is good for the flu — and number two, it’s nobody we know.” With anthropomorphism, we attribute humanlike qualities and mental states to nonhumans. In effect, we imagine them as people. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The humanlike mother character’s belief that cannibalism is appropriate or acceptable, even though (for humans) it clearly is not.</p><h4><strong>7.</strong> Delusional <strong>Contradiction</strong></h4><p>(1) Based on the formal logical definition of contradiction: A belief that something both is the case and isn’t the case at the same time. This is sometimes called self-contradiction or situational irony. (2) Based on the informal definition of contradiction: A belief that two things are compatible, even though they clearly are not.</p><p><strong>Examples of the first definition of the term:</strong></p><p>These actions: A person posts on social media that social media is a waste of time; a sign says, “Want to learn to read? Call us today.”; and a psychic cancels a performance because of “unforeseen circumstances.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The person’s belief that social media both is and is not a waste of time; the sign maker’s belief that you both can and cannot read; and the psychic’s belief that they both can and can’t see the future. All are examples of unintentional humor.</p><p>Quote attributed to Yogi Berra: “Nobody goes there anymore. It’s too crowded.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Berra’s belief that both nobody goes there and many people go there.</p><p><em>The Simpsons</em>: Homer makes a toast, “To alcohol! The cause of, and solution to, all of life’s problems.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Homer’s belief that alcohol both causes a problem and gets rid of it. This example and the one before are paradoxes; as a whole, they have a bit of truth but are still mostly perceived as contradictory.</p><p><em>The Office (British)</em>: David Brent (Ricky Gervais) says, “You’ve seen how I react to people, make them feel good, make them think that anything’s possible… And I don’t do it so they turn round and go, ‘Thank you, David, for the opportunity, thank you for the wisdom, thank you for the laughs.’ I do it so, one day, someone will go ‘There goes David Brent. I must remember to thank him.’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: David’s belief that he both does not and does want to be thanked.</p><p><em>Monty Python</em> has the refined matrons of the Batley Townswomen’s Guild (the Pythons in drag) reenacting the Attack on Pearl Harbor by hitting each other with their handbags and wrestling each other to the muddy ground. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The women’s belief that they both are and aren’t kind, polite, sophisticated, etc. This is an example of how self-contradiction can go even deeper, to the point where a person acts in a way contrary to a central characteristic of who they are or how we know them.</p><p><strong>Examples of the second definition of the term (a belief that two clearly incompatible things are compatible):</strong></p><p><em>The Simpsons</em>: Lisa: “Hey Ralph, want to come with me and Allison to play Anagrams?” Allison: “We take proper names and rearrange the letters to form a description of that person.” Ralph: “My cat’s breath smells like cat food.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Ralph’s belief that his statement is consistent with what the girls just said, even though it clearly is not. This is an example of a non sequitur (does not logically follow from what preceded it).</p><p><em>The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy</em>: Douglas Adams, as narrator, asks, “Why are people born? Why do they die? Why do they want to spend so much of the intervening time wearing digital watches?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Adams’s belief that questions about human existence and watches belong together, even though they clearly do not. This is an example of bathos (a sudden shift from serious or important to trivial or ordinary).</p><p>With the explanations in this section, the weakness of the incongruity theory becomes more apparent. <strong>It’s not incongruity itself we find funny; it’s the belief there’s no incongruity, even though there clearly is.</strong></p><h4><strong>8.</strong> Delusional <strong>Nonsense</strong></h4><p>A belief that something has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</p><p><em>Monty Python and the Holy Grail</em>: The knights who say “Ni.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The knights’ belief that the word has meaning, even though it clearly does not.</p><p>The Swedish Chef, the Muppet character, speaks gibberish that sounds Swedish but isn’t. His best-known phrase is “Bork, bork, bork!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The Chef’s belief that his words have meaning, even though they clearly do not.</p><p><em>Groundhog Day</em>: Phil (Bill Murray), who is repeating the same day over and over, says, “Well, what if there is no tomorrow? There wasn’t one today.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Because we know the character’s situation, we understand what he means. But when looking at his comment from the perspective of the unknowing person he’s speaking to, we see Phil’s belief that his statement has meaning, even though it clearly does not. This is an example of humor made possible by dramatic irony (we observers have knowledge that an observee does not have).</p><h4><strong>9.</strong> Delusional <strong>Impossibility or Improbability</strong></h4><p>A belief that something can be done or happen, even though it clearly cannot or almost certainly cannot.</p><p>Groucho Marx: “One morning I shot an elephant in my pajamas. How he got in my pajamas, I don’t know.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: After figuring out the double meaning, which we enjoy mainly as clever, not funny, we see Groucho’s belief that it’s possible for an elephant to wear his pajamas, even though it’s clearly impossible.</p><p>A practical joker can intentionally cause a target to have a delusional belief. For example, in a <em>Candid Camera</em> prank, a person is asked to deliver a package to a building and return to the building fifteen minutes later. In between, a false building front is removed, making it appear that the building disappeared. When returning, the target says things like, “It’s pretty amazing, because the building was just here.” and “I think I’m going crazy.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The target’s belief that it’s possible the building could disappear in fifteen minutes, even though it clearly is not. This is another example of humor enabled by dramatic irony.</p><h4><strong>Absurdity</strong></h4><p>When any of the nine types is taken to an extreme degree, the result is absurdity. The evidence to the contrary becomes impossible to miss.</p><p><em>Monty Python and the Holy Grail</em>: Black Knight (John Cleese) has his limbs severed in a sword fight while calmly stating things like “Tis but a scratch.” and “Tis a flesh wound.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Extreme Diminishment (underreaction, understatement). The Black Knight’s belief that the severity of his injuries is smaller than it clearly is.</p><p><em>Monty Python’s Flying Circus</em>: A customer at a restaurant asks his waiter for a new fork because his is dirty, which ultimately leads to the restaurant’s manager intentionally impaling himself with the fork because he’s so distraught about the error. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Extreme Magnification (overreaction). The restaurant manager’s belief that the significance of the error is larger than it clearly is.</p><h4><strong>Multiple Delusions</strong></h4><p>A single funny thing doesn’t have to be limited to just one of the nine; it can simultaneously contain multiple types of delusion. I believe this can potentially act as another enhancer to strengthen the humor.</p><p><em>New Yorker</em> cartoon by Bob Mankoff: A businessman is speaking on the phone to someone while looking and pointing at his appointment book. The caption reads, “No, Thursday’s out. How about never — is never good for you?” <strong>DELUSIONS WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The businessman’s belief that he can be both rude and polite at the same time (Contradiction) and that it’s appropriate to say he never wants to meet, even though it clearly is not (Impropriety).</p><p>Rodney Dangerfield: “My psychiatrist told me I was going crazy and I said I’d like a second opinion. He said, alright, you’re ugly too.” <strong>DELUSIONS WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The doctor’s belief that Rodney wants the doctor to give another opinion, even though Rodney clearly does not (Misunderstanding), and the doctor’s belief his insult is appropriate, even though it clearly is not (Impropriety).</p><p><em>Take the Money and Run</em>: Virgil (Woody Allen) is holding up a bank and hands the teller a note that says he has a gun. The teller calmly insists that the note says ‘gub’ not ‘gun’. <strong>DELUSIONS WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The teller’s belief the note means ‘gub,’ even though it clearly means ‘gun’ (Nonsense, Misunderstanding) and that the danger is smaller than it clearly is (Diminishment).</p><p>I maintain that all humor flows from delusional belief, expressed through one or more of the nine types, including the humor found in pretense, verbal irony, parody, and satire.</p><h4><strong>Pretense and Verbal Irony</strong></h4><p><strong><em>Humorous pretense</em></strong> occurs when, for the purpose of creating humor, a person <em>pretends</em> to have a delusional belief. The pretend belief is what we find funny. Note that this kind of humor involves a person communicating as themselves and pretending for the amusement of others in that person’s reality. It differs from examples given earlier that involve a person pretending (acting) as a fictional character for the amusement of others outside the character’s world (i.e., the audience). A person using humorous pretense is typically motivated to make it obvious that they are pretending. Otherwise, they might be seen as actually delusional and thus not harmless.</p><p>Humorous pretense generally takes shape in two ways: 1) We create it ourselves, often impromptu, when conversing with our family, friends, and others in our life. We do this when we kid or joke with others. 2) An artist or performer creates it when communicating as themselves directly with their audience.</p><p><strong>Examples of the first way are a challenge to document because they happen spontaneously in real life. To show how it works, I will list a few I’ve created or observed:</strong></p><p>In a standard dad joke, my daughter says to me, “I’m hungry.” I reply, “Hi Hungry, I’m Gary.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: My pretend belief that I don’t recognize my daughter and that the word means my daughter’s name, even though it’s clearly my daughter and it means her need for food (Lack of Awareness, Misunderstanding).</p><p>In my house, we try to trap insects we find inside and then release them outside. After doing so and coming back inside, I’ll sometimes announce, “Nobody answer the door if the doorbell rings.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: My pretend belief that it’s possible the insect will try to get back inside by ringing the doorbell, even though it’s clearly not (Impossibility).</p><p>My wife’s social media post on the day we turned the clocks forward an hour: “I actually lost three hours this morning. But then I found a couple behind the couch.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Her pretend belief that it’s possible to find hours behind the couch, even though it’s clearly not (Impossibility).</p><p>When asked in a <em>60 Minutes</em> interview if his parents were funny too, Jerry Seinfeld said yes and gave an example of how, if a fly would land on your soup and you tried to shoo it away, his father would say to you, “How much could he eat?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: His father’s pretend belief that shooing the fly away means you don’t want it to eat all your soup, even though it clearly means you don’t want a fly to touch your soup (Misunderstanding).</p><p><strong>Examples of the second way pretense is used (an artist or performer communicating as themselves):</strong></p><p>Steven Wright standup jokes: “I spilled spot remover on my dog and now he’s gone.” “I was once arrested for walking in someone else’s sleep.” “I just lost a buttonhole.” “One of my grandfathers died when he was a little boy.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Wright’s pretend belief that these things are possible, even though they clearly are not (Impossibility). Bonus points if you spotted the pun + delusion.</p><p>Ellen DeGeneres standup joke: “A friend of mine was at my house, and I told him: ‘I’m going to do standup again.’ And he said: ‘Really?’ And I said: ‘Yes, why?’ And he said: ‘Well, do you think you’re still relatable?’ And I said: ‘Yes, I do think I’m still relatable. I’m a human being.’ He said: ‘Well, I mean, your life has changed so much.’ And I said: ‘I know, but I still think I’m relatable.’ And anyway, just then, Batu, my butler, stepped into the library and announced that my breakfast was ready.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: DeGeneres momentarily creates a pretend version of herself who believes that her awareness of her relatability is correct, even though it clearly is not (Lack of Awareness).</p><p>Insult comedy, including the roast, involves subjecting a person to insulting jokes at their expense. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The comedian’s pretend belief it’s appropriate or acceptable to gratuitously insult someone else, even though it clearly is not (Impropriety). Because it’s in the context of joking, this type of humor is generally seen as harmless. But as it often has real people as the butt of the joke, unpleasant feelings and emotions might arise and thus diminish the humor experience, particularly for the target.</p><p>A person who tells a joke that is intentionally unfunny (sometimes labeled anti-humor): One example is a joke called a “shaggy dog story,” which involves telling a long joke that ends without a punchline. Another is a joke with an obvious answer as the punchline, like: “Why did the chicken cross the road? To get to the other side.” A third is Norm MacDonald roasting Bob Saget with mild, corny jokes. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The joke teller’s pretend belief that their awareness of the joke’s funniness is correct, even though it clearly is not (Lack of Awareness).</p><p>Besides using pretense solely to be funny, a person might also do so to produce <strong><em>verbal irony</em></strong>. Verbal irony occurs when a person overtly pretends to have a belief with the intention of implying their attitude about something or someone. Sarcastic verbal irony is when this attitude is a negative evaluation meant to criticize, insult, or ridicule someone. Like with non-ironic pretense, we find the pretend belief funny when we view it as delusional.</p><p>First, two conventional examples of non-sarcastic verbal irony: A person says, “What lovely weather we’re having!” when it’s pouring rain. A driver who gets a flat tire says, “Great, this is just what I needed today!” Statements like these have become such a common way people express displeasure with a situation that they have lost most of their humor power, but the elements are still there. <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The speaker’s pretend belief that their awareness of what is present or happening is correct, even though it clearly is not (Lack of Awareness).</p><p>Sarcastic verbal irony typically packs a more humorous punch. This is likely because the act of being sarcastic, like insult humor discussed earlier, can be perceived as having a belief that’s delusionally inappropriate (Impropriety). Additionally, the pretend belief can point to and magnify a real belief held by the target of the irony, resulting in the target being found funny as well. In effect, a delusional belief can be projected onto the target. Sarcasm’s sting has the potential to introduce feelings of unpleasantness and harm into the picture, which might diminish the experience of humor, especially for the target. The following are examples of different varieties of humorous sarcastic verbal irony:</p><p><em>Saturday Night Live</em>: Roseanne Roseannadanna (Gilda Radner) is a news commentator reading a letter from a viewer named Richard Feder, which says, “Dear Roseanne Roseannadanna. Last Thursday, I quit smoking. Now, I’m depressed, I gained weight, my face broke out, I’m nauseous, I’m constipated, my feet swelled, my gums are bleeding, my sinuses are clogged, I got heartburn, I’m cranky, and I have gas. What should I do?” She replies, “Mr. Feder, you sound like a real attractive guy.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Roseanne’s pretend belief that her awareness of Mr. Feder’s attractiveness is correct, even though it clearly is not (Lack of Awareness).</p><p>In a hypothetical to illustrate a typical remark, a man and woman are waiting for an elevator. The button has already been pressed and is lit, but the woman impatiently presses the button again a few quick times in a row. The man says, “Good idea, keep pressing the button. That should make it get here faster.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The man’s pretend belief that his knowledge is correct that repeatedly pressing the button makes it arrive faster, even though it clearly is not. Also, the woman’s real belief, which the man has echoed and drawn attention to (Lack of Knowledge).</p><p>Another hypothetical, this time a cliché: A man says something which a woman finds flawed, so she replies, “What planet are you from?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The woman’s pretend belief that it’s possible the man is from another planet, even though it clearly is not. Also, the man’s real belief, which is alluded to and, through exaggeration, magnified by the woman (Impossibility).</p><p><em>Friends</em>: Chandler (Matthew Perry): “I got her machine.” Joey (Matt LeBlanc): “Her answering machine?” Chandler: “No, interestingly enough, her leaf-blower picked up.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Chandler’s pretend belief that the leaf blower answered the phone, even though it’s clearly impossible or highly improbable. Also, Joey’s real belief, which is alluded to by Chandler (Impossibility/ Improbability).</p><p><em>Friends</em>: Joey: “Hey, Chandler, when you see Frankie, tell him Joey Tribiani says hello. He’ll know what I mean.” Chandler: “Are you sure he’s going to be able to crack that code?” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Chandler’s pretend belief that his own knowledge about the message “hello” is correct, even though it clearly is not. Also, Joey’s real belief, which is echoed and, through exaggeration, magnified by Chandler (Lack of Knowledge).</p><p><em>When Harry Met Sally</em>: A group of friends is playing a game where people must guess what a person is drawing, and the clue is that it’s ‘a saying’. Jess (Bruno Kirby) shouts out the guess, “baby fish mouth.” When finding out the answer is ‘baby talk,’ Jess says, “What’s that? That’s not a saying.” Harry (Billy Crystal) replies, “Oh, but baby fish mouth is sweeping the nation.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Harry’s pretend belief that his own knowledge about the phrase is correct, even though it clearly is not. Also, Jess’s real belief, which is echoed and, through exaggeration, magnified by Harry (Lack of Knowledge).</p><h4><strong>Parody</strong></h4><p>Parody is simply humorous imitation. To imitate someone or something in a humorous way is to imitate with an enhancement or addition of one or more of the nine delusional beliefs.</p><p>A frequent technique in parody is to exaggerate a person’s style, mannerism, or eccentricity, to the point where the person appears delusional. Two impersonation examples:</p><p>Joe Piscopo and Phil Hartman heighten Frank Sinatra’s swaggering, tough guy persona by having him insult other celebrities, such as calling Stevie Wonder “blind as a bat,” Sinead O’Connor “cue ball,” and Bono “Bozo.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The pretend Sinatra’s belief his behavior is acceptable, even though it clearly is not (Impropriety).</p><p>Jim Carrey takes Jimmy Stewart’s trademark optimism to extremes by having him enthusiastically and cheerfully say, “Well, I guess we’re gonna have ourselves a nuclear holocaust!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The pretend Stewart’s belief the danger is smaller than it clearly is (Diminishment).</p><p>Parody can also work in the other direction and generate humor by diminishing an already elevated or exaggerated person, as it does in these examples:</p><p><em>Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery</em>: Dr. Evil, a parody of a movie villain, talking to his son: “Scott, that hurts Daddy when you say that, honestly. Could I have a hug? Give me a hug. Come here and give your father a hug.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Dr. Evil’s belief that he both is and is not evil (Contradiction).</p><p>In a standup routine, Eddie Izzard imitates Darth Vader standing in line for lunch at the Death Star cafeteria and arguing with the server about the need for a tray. He finally relents when told it’s because the food is hot. “Oh, I see, the food is hot. I’m sorry, I did not realize. Ha-ha.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The pretend Vader’s belief that he both is and is not powerful and merciless (Contradiction). With both the Vader and Dr. Evil parodies, we perceive the characters as maintaining their defining qualities while at the same time acting in a way that’s opposite to them.</p><p>In many cases, parody primarily serves as a serious framework that conveniently provides a sharp contrast for funny content. Several examples provided earlier in this article were from parodies of serious genres (e.g., <em>Airplane!, This is Spinal Tap, Monty Python, </em>and<em> The Office</em>).</p><h4><strong>Satire</strong></h4><p>Satire is a form of creative work that exposes, comments on, or criticizes aspects of people or society. It sometimes uses humor, via all the elements and techniques highlighted here so far, as a way of doing this.</p><p>An impersonation can go beyond style to satirically focus on a perceived flaw of a person. Tina Fey highlights Sarah Palin’s inexperience by impersonating her saying this about visiting the United Nations: “It was just amazing. So many interesting people. Though, I have to say I was disheartened by how many of them were foreigners. I promise that when Senator McCain and I are elected, we’re gonna get those jobs back in American hands.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: The pretend Palin’s belief that her knowledge of the U.N. is correct, even though it clearly is not (Lack of Knowledge). And, by association, the real Sarah Palin’s beliefs.</p><p>Jerry Seinfeld uses an analogy to comment on the high price of movie-theater candy. In a standup routine, he makes a comparison between the candy and jewelry that relies on the fact that both are in a glass case: “I go up to the guy, ‘I’d like to see something in a Milk Dud if I could. Nothing too garish, of course.’ Sometimes I will take out one Milk Dud and put it on the black velvet. ‘Oh, boy, that’s a beauty. Honey, what do you think?’” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Seinfeld momentarily creates a pretend version of himself who believes the worth of the candy is larger than it clearly is (Magnification). And, by association, the beliefs of the people running movie theaters.</p><p><em>A Modest Proposal</em>, by Jonathan Swift, is an iconic example of humorous satire. In his essay, to implicitly expose and criticize the treatment of the Irish, Swift proposes that the Irish poor sell their children as food to the rich: “A young, healthy child well nursed, is, at a year old, a most delicious nourishing and wholesome food, whether stewed, roasted, baked, or boiled; and I make no doubt that it will equally serve in a fricassee, or a ragout.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Swift’s pretend belief that it’s appropriate or acceptable to treat children this way, even though it clearly is not (Impropriety). And, by association, the beliefs of the rich and the British government.</p><p><em>Dr. Strangelove</em> criticizes Cold War ideologies by ridiculing the people in power. President Muffley (Peter Sellers): “Gentlemen, you can’t fight in here! This is the War Room!” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Muffley’s belief that you both cannot and can fight in the room (Contradiction). General Turgidson (George C. Scott): “Mr. President, I’m not saying we wouldn’t get our hair mussed. But I do say no more than ten to twenty million killed, tops. Uh, depending on the breaks.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Turgidson’s belief that the extent of casualties is smaller than it clearly is (Diminishment). And, by association, the beliefs of the real people in power.</p><p>Final example:</p><p><em>Being There </em>takes aim at politics and media culture, with the character Chance (Peter Sellers), who we see is really a simple-minded gardener, being mistaken for a thoughtful, wise businessman and becoming a media figure and political advisor to the President of the United States. Chance: “As long as the roots are not severed, all is well. And all will be well in the garden. In the garden, growth has its season. First comes spring and summer, but then we have fall and winter. And then we get spring and summer again.” Ben Rand (Melvyn Douglas): “I think what our insightful young friend is saying is that we welcome the inevitable seasons of nature, but we’re upset by the seasons of our economy.” President Bobby (Jack Warden): “Well, Mr. Gardiner, I must admit, that is one of the most refreshing and optimistic statements I’ve heard in a very, very long time.” <strong>DELUSION WE FIND FUNNY</strong>: Rand’s and President Bobby’s belief that Chance’s words mean he is giving advice about the economy, even though they clearly mean he is talking about gardening (Misunderstanding). And, by association, the beliefs of real politicians and others in power. This is one more example of humor driven by dramatic irony. Because the truth is clear to us, we feel it should be clear to the characters.</p><p>These are just a tiny fraction of the many cases I’ve scrutinized. For each of the above, countless others in a similar vein exhibit the same kind of harmless delusional belief.</p><h3><strong>Necessary and Sufficient Conditions</strong></h3><p>As I indicated upfront, a theory that correctly defines humor’s essence will specify what is both necessary and sufficient for humor to occur. This means that the harmless delusion theory passes muster if, generally speaking, all things we find funny have harmless delusion (necessary), and all things we perceive as harmless delusion have humor (sufficient). Let’s look at each of these individually.</p><p><strong>All things we find funny have harmless delusion.</strong> I think I’ve supplied abundant supporting evidence in this essay that my theory is very likely to pass this test. With a wide-ranging list of examples covering many of humor’s forms, I’ve methodically shown how harmless delusion can be found in each one. Though it may not always be the most prominent feature, harmless delusional belief, I claim, is always perceptible in decidedly funny things. Never is it implausible that such a belief is present and noticeable.</p><p>To further investigate, an experiment could be conducted with a representative sample of people. Participants can be asked to rate various stimuli in terms of the degree of funniness and the degree to which the stimulus feels okay or acceptable to the participant (harmlessness). Separately, participants can make a binary judgment on whether a person in the stimulus appears to hold a belief despite clear evidence to the contrary available to them (delusional belief), with no humor framing. Other positive qualities, including cleverness, should be measured as well to disguise that the study is about humor and properly evaluate puns and double meaning. Effort should also be made to control for enhancers. Generally, if people who rate stimuli as funny also rate them as harmless and as containing a delusional belief, then the theory passes the “necessary” test.</p><p>Two classes of cases provide additional support for necessity by showing where existing theories produce false positives that HDT correctly handles. The first is minor errors: cases where something is clearly wrong, yet humor does not follow because the mistake is too common or easy to make. When a mistake is easy to make, the perceiver does not attribute clear evidence to the contrary available to the person, and delusional belief is not perceived. The second is informed choice: cases where a person acts with full knowledge and intention about what seems wrong in their situation, such as voluntarily eating extremely spicy food or deliberately breaking a minor rule. Here too, no delusional belief is attributable, because the person holds no belief contradicted by clear evidence to the contrary. Existing theories struggle with both classes; HDT handles them through the same principled mechanism.</p><p><strong>All things we perceive as harmless delusion have humor.</strong> I contend that harmless delusion is intuitively humorous. It seems impossible to imagine a completely humorless instance of a person who harmlessly holds a belief that something is the case despite clear evidence to the contrary being available to them. So we can see without an experiment that it’s very unlikely the theory will fail this test. But a study like the one I just outlined above could be done here as well, only with manipulation of whether delusional belief is present or absent and whether harmlessness varies, to test whether these conditions jointly predict humor. Generally, if people give higher funniness scores to stimuli they rate as containing harmless delusion than they do to stimuli they rate as lacking harmless delusion, then the theory passes the “sufficient” test.</p><p>Note that, because humor is subjective at the individual level, it requires more than just a single person finding a single thing unfunny or funny to refute or support the theory. We must perform a more scientific assessment of each case by looking at how people, in general, tend to perceive it. That’s why I’ve emphasized examples already widely regarded as funny and proposed additional research among representative samples of people.</p><h3><strong>Conclusion</strong></h3><p>A few closing thoughts:</p><ul><li>That we need to perceive something as both harmless and a delusion to find it funny would help explain the subjectivity of humor and why the same thing can be funny to one person and unfunny to another. People have different cultures, values, experiences, circumstances, relationships, personalities, tastes, moods, etc. All of these factors can affect how each of us interprets something and thus the extent to which it feels negative or unacceptable to us, and a person seems to have a belief that’s obviously wrong or false. In other words, at least in part, humor is subjective <em>because</em> it is the perception of harmless delusion. Also playing a role is the variable effect of humor enhancers.</li><li>It should not be too surprising that humor — which is essentially a social phenomenon — is based on our ability to perceive others’ beliefs. The delusional belief attribution at the heart of HDT is a specific instance of Theory of Mind processing — our cognitive capacity to represent and reason about others’ mental states. We see a person as holding a belief despite having clear evidence to the contrary available to them. We develop Theory of Mind at a very young age and continuously exercise it to understand others and successfully engage in social interactions. It has known neural correlates, a documented developmental trajectory, and established measurement paradigms that exist entirely outside humor research. This gives HDT an external anchor for validating its central construct that other humor theories lack. In further support, research has found that humor appreciation involves some of the same regions of the brain that are also involved in Theory of Mind³.</li><li>This is not the only humor theory to focus on belief. Other ones do so, too, that are not widely known. However, they are centered around concepts such as self-deception⁴ or discovering one’s own wrong belief⁵ and thus differ substantially from what I’ve presented here.</li><li>This theory places a potentially valuable new tool in the hands of people seeking to create humor. Not only that, non-people have something to gain as well. To date, we’ve been mostly unsuccessful in our attempt to design machines and artificial intelligence (AI) that can understand and generate humor. Possibly this is because of the lack of an accurate explanation of what humor actually is. With the harmless delusion theory now at our disposal, maybe we can teach the robots a few new tricks.</li><li>While the purpose of this theory is not to explain why we humans evolved to have this kind of response to harmless delusion, I will briefly suggest an idea. The response of amusement and laughter could have evolved as a beneficial way for us to signal to people that harmless delusion is present so they are aware of it and can correct it. A more harmful delusion requires a more forceful signal, like pain.</li><li>My goal with this article is twofold. One, to help everyone better understand humor by presenting my theory in a thorough yet accessible way. Two, to pique the interest of academia, who hopefully will see the same power I see in my hypothesis and want to further explore and test it.</li></ul><p>Now that you know this about humor, you might be thinking, “Great, Gary! Thank you so much for ruining humor for me!” (Sarcastic verbal irony). My response is that it absolutely <em>doesn’t</em> ruin it. Experiencing and appreciating humor is very different than thinking about how it works. It’s easy to keep the two separate. Even when I was in analysis mode while researching comedy for this article, I was immensely enjoying all the funniness.</p><p>So don’t worry. You can resume your laughter, but now with a greater understanding of what’s so funny.</p><p><em>Updated March 2026 to reflect further development of the theory</em></p><p><em>Contact Gary at howhumorworks@gmail.com</em></p><p><strong>References</strong></p><ol><li>McGraw, A.P., &amp; Warner, J., 2014. The Humor Code: A Global Search for What Makes Things Funny.</li><li>Amir, O., Biederman, I., Wang, Z., Xu, X., 2013. Ha Ha! Versus Aha! A Direct Comparison of Humor to Nonhumorous Insight for Determining the Neural Correlates of Mirth.</li><li>Iidaka, T., 2016. Humor Appreciation Involves Parametric and Synchronized Activity in the Medial Prefrontal Cortex and Hippocampus.</li><li>Gontar, C., 2018. So the Essence of Humour is Self-Deception? Who Are You Kidding? The Philosopher, Volume CVI №1.</li><li>Hurley, M. M., Dennett, D. C., Adams Jr, R. B., &amp; Adams, R. B., 2011. Inside Jokes: Using Humor to Reverse-Engineer the Mind.</li></ol><h4>The “How Humor Works” series presenting the Harmless Delusion Theory</h4><ul><li>Part 1: This article (Foundational article)</li><li>Part 2: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-jerry-seinfelds-humor-works-43315ce17182"><strong><em>How Jerry Seinfeld’s Humor Works</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 3: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-airplane-730668da627"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Airplane!’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 4: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/how-humor-works-in-annie-hall-6ee2631af6ba"><strong><em>How Humor Works in ‘Annie Hall’</em></strong></a></li><li>Part 5: <a href="https://medium.com/@gary.borislow/harmless-delusion-theory-of-humor-responding-to-questions-and-objections-4bc48098f2c9"><strong><em>Responding to Questions and Objections</em></strong></a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=487018554fce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>