<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Logan Taylor on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Logan Taylor on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 16:27:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Games for our Grandchildren: Thoughts on Sony Ending Physical Disks for Playstation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/games-for-our-grandchildren-thoughts-on-sony-ending-physical-disks-for-playstation-06cef27bb199?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/06cef27bb199</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 Jul 2026 17:46:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-07T21:22:46.123Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*38Ytck0yNoVMmVNDTBGDXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>There are many wolves inside me.</p><p>Business Wolf: This makes perfect sense. Digital videogame sales have been outselling physical for almost a decade now. Steam changed the market forever. Microsoft has been pushing more and more toward digital and Sony saw the writing on the wall. Why sell a product that only generates <em>some</em> of its revenue as profit when you could sell a digital version and incur none of the same manufacturing and distribution costs? It just makes sense.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*r6361y7Ph14QmNiBCYhjcg.jpeg" /><figcaption>All wolf images in this article are from Zero Parades: For Dead Spies. Good game!</figcaption></figure><p>Physical Media Wolf: *a long, low howl* Lament! Lament the loss of the disc, that fair and fine device on which one can find untold — — hang on, what? I have to install the game anyway, even if I have the disc? Well, once it’s installed, I just <em>own</em> it, right? So I could play it even if the world ended and I had to generate the electricity by running on a big wheel? What do you mean “not always?” Whatever, that’s not the only reason to own the physical thing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/386/1*nDUl31ENsM9Fp7kvIIYTdw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Other Reasons to Own the Physical Thing Wolf: Culture is material. It is only in the last twenty-odd years that humans have generated culture that is as ethereal as the internet. I won’t claim that the stuff that happens on the internet isn’t “real;” it obviously is. Society only exists because of social interaction, and social interaction happens online as much as it does in reality. But <em>culture</em>, art and music and things we make, cannot only be in the mind or online. It loses critical dimension. Objects like games signify realness and serve as proof of the experiences and memories contained in them, triggered by them, passed from one person to another, stored and revered and appreciated. Objects hold meaning more easily than 1s and 0s. I would rather show my grandchildren <em>Super Metroid</em> on a cartridge than an emulator.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/386/1*XVoZuB0kKeG8czMHs1SOMA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Indie Game Wolf: Digital games have been a godsend for independent developers who do not have the capital necessary to manufacture and distribute physical games. As game development has become more and more accessible, more artists can make games and distribute them without having to go through gatekeepers and find a publisher to front those costs for them. This particular decision from Sony doesn’t matter much, except that it marks the continued shift online that we see taking place at every corner of society.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*Vjz7P_SLQz8pft6wgmJVAw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anarchist Wolf: That shift, overall, is bad. The internet democratized quite a lot of media and culture at first, but Sony ending discs is another step in a long line of the old gatekeepers of media and capital moving back in and monopolizing power in digital spaces. Sony puts more money into digital, and because money simply is power in our global capitalist system, they wield more power there too. If they control storefronts and licensing, then they define the concept of ownership for their consumer base. They enforce a hierarchy with them at the top. While it is rare for consumers to completely lose access to digital goods, it is much <em>less</em> rare than someone from Sony coming to your house to physically repossess your copy of <em>Grand Theft Auto 5</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/386/1*_wFxsPZyJxw49X1QP87J8A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Summation Wolf: The disappearance of physical games media is not, in and of itself, the problem. It merely exposes the real problem: The severe lack of consumer protections in the digital world. There is a layer of protection inherent to physical ownership. You bought the thing and you literally have it. If the company that made it wants it back, they have to come and take it from you. This layer of protection has historically been taken for granted. Similar shifts have happened, like in the world of stock trading where the distance between the stock owner and the actual stock they own has become greater over the last 150 years or so, but typically, if you buy something, you have it.</p><p>This layer of protection does not exist for digital games, and so it must be manufactured. But who will manufacture it? It is not in the interest of companies like Sony to do so. The more control they have over their product, the better. Is it in the interest of the governments of the world? That depends on the current makeup of any given government and how much or little they will kowtow to corporate greed (spoiler alert: Most of them will. A lot.) One thing is without doubt: Consumer protections are in the interest of the consumer, and usually, the consumers must take them. What that looks like for digital ownership of media, I do not know. But if you haven’t already, take this as a call. It’s time to wake up and start looking.</p><p><em>If you liked this, please head over to </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em>my profile</em></a><em> and give me a follow. Also, games preservation is important. Check out </em><a href="https://www.stopkillinggames.com/en"><em>Stop Killing Games</em></a><em> if you’re interested in learning more or supporting videogame preservation efforts.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=06cef27bb199" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Grappling with the Past: Resident Evil Requiem and the Legacy of Terror]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/grappling-with-the-past-resident-evil-requiem-and-the-legacy-of-terror-06ee1f3d13d8?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/06ee1f3d13d8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Jul 2026 17:24:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-03T17:24:25.201Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nU5W53pH9IfBadVYNEz-iw.avif" /></figure><p>The past is an infection. Trauma lives in the blood, dormant sometimes for years, sometimes for decades, before it resurges with a vengeance, often with horrible consequences. It can even leave its impact on generations to come, fixing itself in the genetic memory of people plagued by famine and disease and passed down to the children who come after, who bear scars from wounds they themselves never suffered.</p><p>This is what motivates the plot of <em>Requiem</em>, the ninth main series entry in the <em>Resident Evil</em> franchise. I, personally, was not particularly excited for this game. We are at the point in the <em>Resident Evil</em> life cycle where it’s time for Capcom to shit the bed and eradicate the good will built up by a successful franchise reinvention with a poorly-handled slop fest that forces another round of reinvention. It happened with <em>Code Veronica</em> giving way to <em>Resident Evil 4</em>, and it happened with <em>Resident Evil 6</em> giving way to <em>Resident Evil 7: Biohazard</em>. I checked my watch; <em>Requiem</em> had a long, dark legacy to overcome.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/616/1*MG1wMd4DyNuz-2kbZ_BvZg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The true horror the series needed to overcome</figcaption></figure><p>Imagine my surprise when the game was good. Maybe I’m too much of a pessimist, but the trailers promising the return of Leon S. Kennedy said to me that the life cycle was coming to an end. The game’s opening is as melodramatic as I expected, setting the stage for my doubts to be confirmed. But the flashback to newcomer protagonist Grace’s mother’s murder was tense and mysterious, new villain Doctor Gideon is exactly the right kind of visually interesting freak, and Leon is as quippy as ever, but with a desperate edge.</p><p>It’s this last thing that I want to discuss in detail here. Leon’s infection, a lingering effect of T-Virus exposure from his time in Raccoon city during the events of <em>Resident Evil 2</em>, is what gives the narrative of <em>Requiem</em> its real weight. Leon was changed by the events that took place in Raccoon City. They have left their mark on him, literally. He is dying. He must go back to the place where it all began, though his goal is not explicitly to find a cure. It’s to do what he’s always done: Stop the greedy, powerful pricks of the world from creating worse and worse bioweapons to use on the innocent citizens of every nation.</p><p>On the face of it, this is pretty basic symbolism. He has a literal infection from the traumatic horror he experienced, which is a one-to-one relationship of sign (infection) and referent (guilt and trauma). Leon expresses that he carries guilt over the fact that he wasn’t able to make a difference in Raccoon City, wasn’t able to stop the events of <em>Resident Evil 2</em> from happening, or save more people, or just do <em>something</em> other than the bare minimum of survival that he got away with. Forget that this is an impossible demand. Trauma is not always logical. There is nothing else he could have done, but he feels guilty anyway.</p><p>But this symbol gives us the key to unlocking the true meaning of the game, which in turn allows us to understand <em>Requiem</em>’s relationship to the games that came before it.</p><p>Here’s my thesis: <em>Requiem</em> signifies the <em>Resident Evil</em> series’ first successful shift away from the B horror genre that it was founded on toward the A horror that its rival series, <em>Silent Hill</em>, has always excelled at much more. It is not fully successful, but it gave me feelings I have never had while playing a <em>Resident Evil </em>game, feelings that this was not just tight, exciting horror storytelling, but that it had real symbolic weight and meaning beyond anything else the series has ever done.</p><p>B horror is not worse than A-horror. You have almost certainly heard a movie described as a “B movie” before. The term comes from the golden age of Hollywood, when cinema was the most popular form of entertainment around. Movies were usually shown as double-features: The “A movie” was the headliner, the popular, well-known film that people wanted to see, and the “B movie” was usually a cheaply-produced genre film, like a western, science fiction, or horror film. This allowed studios to cheaply turn a profit on audiences who were already there in the theater, and to give untested talent a place to work where it wouldn’t cost the studio too much money.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*ltxFXsekKOE09guDv0ak0Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>A poster for one of the most famous B-Movies of all time</figcaption></figure><p>This tradition persisted but morphed when television became more popular. Producing movies cheaply for TV became the new home of B movies, especially B horror movies. Even though the circumstances change, the content of B movies rarely does: Produced for cheap, shot with inexperienced actors, demanding creativity from production and director in order to squeeze the maximum possible value out of every moment of production time, and often not succeeding.</p><p>B horror is not less valuable than A horror. It simply offers something different, an experience often devoid of taste or sensibility but that is nonetheless art. The transgressive work of John Waters, along with films like Alfred Hitchcock’s <em>Psycho</em> and the Italian <em>gialli</em> films, have all been hugely influential on art and the world at large. It doesn’t have to be high-brow to be good art.</p><p><em>Resident Evil</em> has always been B horror. The genuinely horrible voice acting that the first game is famous for, along with the ridiculous, monster-laden melodrama of nearly every game’s plot, do not really allow space for “serious” narrative storytelling devices like figurative language, symbolism, subtle characterization, and psychological drama. Even the more serious games, like <em>Resident Evil VII: Biohazard</em> and <em>Resident Evil VIII: Village,</em> never stray too far away from hillbilly grindcore and medieval fantasy horror, respectively. The game that seems the most dedicated to maintaining a “dramatic” feeling is, ironically, also the worst game in the series: <em>Resident Evil 6</em>.</p><p>But then we have <em>Requiem</em>. We have Leon making quips after every defeated bad guy, just like <em>Resident Evil 4</em>, but balanced with the clear understanding that this is a defense mechanism for him. The return to the Racoon City police station in the ruins of that metropolis cements this. This is where it all started and ended for Leon. This is where his globe-trotting, monster-filled life began, and his old life, the one with any hope for a normal future, died.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vkh2K89yNBbaL-hP93u8GQ.avif" /><figcaption>The ruins of Raccoon City</figcaption></figure><p>But crucially, Leon is not here to cure himself. He is here because he’s following the trail of a new bad guy trying to make use of the last invention of Oswald Spenser, the brain behind the T-Virus infection that started it all. This new bioweapon, Elpis, promises universal mind control, ultimate power, yadda yadda. You’ve heard it all before. The new system is built in the bones of the old. There’s a new freak, a new clone of fan-favorite villain Albert Wesker, and a new protagonist to inherit the never-ending war against the powerful who seek to control the masses.</p><p>Leon is prepared to kill and die for this war. The only thing he isn’t prepared to do is forgive.</p><p>You see, the twist of the game is that Spenser, as an old man, regretted the horror he released onto the world. His final invention, Elpis, was not a weapon, but a cure. The elusive cure for the T-Virus, something that has never existed up to this point in the series. Spenser has moved past the dichotomy, and he did it so many years before <em>Requiem</em> takes place. So many years of this war, of fighting and killing, of people chasing Spenser’s “legacy,” missing his final, crucial twist.</p><p>Of course, we cannot fully absolve him. We probably can’t even absolve him a little bit, and the narrative of <em>Requiem</em> doesn’t try. Spenser may not have created the paradigm — the “strong” have always sought whatever weapons they could to oppress the “weak,” after all — but he mutated it for all time. His regret is too little, too late.</p><p>But it might be enough to pave a path for Leon. He gets the injection of Elpis. He is cured. If the symbol holds, if the metaphor leaves its indelible mark on the world of <em>Resident Evil</em>, then he can take the path Spenser did. Not a path of forgetting, but a path of healing.</p><p>Maybe he can finally leave Raccoon City behind.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MBIk8hSudiY1nbCBIS9QPw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Our boy just needs some rest</figcaption></figure><p>The way this is all done in the game is… not perfect. I don’t think the balance is right; one of the sequences in the game is in contention for the most ridiculous thing I have ever seen in <em>Resident Evil</em>, and when we go too far in that direction, it can make the rest of it ring a little hollow. In addition, I don’t think Grace and her journey fits perfectly into this story. There are a lot of distractions, diversions, and detours on the way to this symbolic healing. It’s not buried, exactly, but it’s far from the only thing the game has going on.</p><p>But to me, it’s the most fascinating. It’s like the series is struggling against the bindings of its B horror roots and finally making some headway. Every earnest attempt at drama in the series thus far has either fallen flat or been so overblown that it’s B horror <em>unintentionally</em>, the earnest failure of storytellers not quite good enough to pull off their goals. So it’s almost surreal to see them succeed here, at least partially.</p><p><em>Resident Evil 2</em> was one of the first games I ever beat as a kid. It’s been an important part of my gaming journey since the beginning, and I’ve played it more times than I can count. The reinterpretation of Leon in the remake of that game, as well as the remake of <em>RE4</em>, always felt like a retread, for obvious reasons. And the journey of Ethan Winters, the protagonist of <em>VII</em> and <em>VIII</em>, was all brand new ground, creating all new subplots that only tangentially relate to the main series.</p><p>But here we have forward motion, in narrative and symbolic terms. Is it the most well-rendered, heavily symbolic psychodrama I’ve ever witnessed? No, not by a long shot. In the world of videogames, it might not even rank. But it’s a sign of growth. It’s an indication that not only can Leon learn from the past, but maybe we all can. We can all reinterpret the traumas of the past and break new ground. And that’s a message that I’m happy for a game to have right now.</p><p>I just didn’t expect it in <em>Resident Evil</em> of all places. And that pleasant surprise might be the best part.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! If you liked this, please</em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em> head on over to my profile </em></a><em>and give me a follow. And if you want more right away, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/animal-well-is-a-perfect-metroidvania-a-screen-by-screen-breakdown-bb969ba57261"><em>click here</em></a><em> to see an article I’m proud of.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=06ee1f3d13d8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Things I Love In Games: The SA-X]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/things-i-love-in-games-the-sa-x-9c22ef540318?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c22ef540318</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jun 2026 19:01:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-18T19:01:00.934Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VHjN5rj4uAUgMdu2FcXfBA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Helplessness is a terrifying thing. The removal of power and the ability to affect our own destinies, drive meaningful change, or even protect ourselves, is the source of both deeply upsetting and deeply cathartic fiction, especially horror.</p><p>Horror gaming really hit upon helplessness as a game design tool with <em>Amnesia: the Dark Descent</em> in 2010. As the frail Daniel, you stand no chance against the monsters in the game, so your only option is to run and hide. You can’t do damage, can barely hinder them in any way. They outmatch you. You must escape.</p><p><em>Amnesia</em> was largely praised for this design choice, and with good reason. Design by subtraction, by removing options from the player rather than granting them, is a hard thing to get right. Players often resent lacking things that they have in other games. But now this type of design is a staple of the horror genre. The <em>Outlast</em> games in particular take this concept and run with it. But my first interaction with the horror of helplessness in games goes back much further than <em>Amnesia</em>.</p><p>In 2002, as a wee six-year-old boy, I played <em>Metroid Fusion</em> and met the SA-X.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UblHs6ODMJFrEJMKyuR4nQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Gross dangerous man hunts harmless lantern boy in Amnesia</figcaption></figure><p><em>Metroid Fusion</em> takes place fourth in the main series of <em>Metroid</em> games. In the first game, as galactic bounty hunter Samus Aran, you break up a gang of space pirates who seek to use the titular metroid organism, a type of dangerous, parasitic alien, to wreak havoc on the galaxy. In the sequel, <em>Metroid II: Return of Samus</em>, Samus is tasked with going to the metroid home world and exterminating every single one. They are too dangerous to be left alive.</p><p>But Samus has a change of heart right at the end of the game. A metroid baby, the last of its kind, hatches from an egg in front of her and imprints on Samus as though she were its mother. She does not kill it, instead leaving the planet with the baby in tow. Eventually that metroid grows up and saves Samus’ life in <em>Super Metroid</em>, and again at the beginning of <em>Fusion</em> when Samus is infected by the natural prey of the metroid, the X-parasite, which are running rampant thanks to Samus’ campaign of genocide against the metroids. She is only saved by an injection of the metroid DNA that clears the X-parasite from her system. The infected remains of her signature power suit are sent to a research facility in space.</p><p>I tell you all of this because it’s important to understand the context. Later in <em>Fusion</em>, the player will encounter those remains of Samus’ power suit, now animated by the X-parasite that infected it. The X-parasites imitate organisms, absorbing their DNA and copying them. This new being, dubbed the SA-X, is a doppelganger, an exact copy of Samus at her full power.</p><p>And it is hunting you.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G_TOOkCKFf_qwZj2iakWNg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Extended screenshot of Metroid II</figcaption></figure><p>The <em>Metroid</em> games are generally light in terms of story. It’s not that they have no plot; there are plenty of pre-game text dumps and narrative backfills that string the games along, but those aren’t really the point. The <em>Metroid</em> games carry their plots and themes using mood. The eerie music, the desolate, hostile environments, and the facts of the situation in a given game do much more to communicate with the player than simple text.</p><p>This is the level on which the SA-X operates. It is a predator; Samus is the prey. It represents Samus at full power, most notably equipped with the ability to fire an ice beam from its arm cannon. Metroids are vulnerable to the cold. In <em>Metroid II</em>, when Samus was exterminating them, she used the ice beam to do it. Now that same weapon has been turned against her.</p><p>It is as if a phantom of the past has come to punish Samus. She is part metroid now, placed in the same position she placed the original metroids in all those years ago. You cannot fight the SA-X. You must simply run from it. Any attempt to stand against it will end in death, just as the metroids who stood against Samus all died. The game never makes a point about this. No NPC comes in and says, “Gee, that’s ironic, huh, Samus?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*G1dIEfWO79wgM96SJNms9w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The SA-X (right) hunting for Samus (left)</figcaption></figure><p>In fact, Samus does not recognize herself in the creature. She questions whether it is capable of reason only to dismiss the idea and judge it a “killing machine.” This is never confronted or addressed in the text of the narrative, and the game allows this tension to go on until the end. The Galactic Federation (it’s always a federation, eh?) wants to capture the SA-X to “study” it (i.e. use it as a weapon). Samus interrupts, claiming the plan to be a bad one even as she herself has been deployed by that same Federation as a weapon over and over again.</p><p>And if you don’t think the creators of the <em>Metroid</em> series know what they’re doing here, I strongly recommend <a href="https://www.gamedeveloper.com/audio/a-maze-of-murderscapes-metroid-ii">S.R. Holiwell’s “A Maze of Murderscapes: Metroid II.”</a> It’s one of my favorite pieces of game writing ever, and this quote in particular always sticks with me: “Games about killing should probably make you uncomfortable. They shouldn’t be carefully crafted to be pleasant.”</p><p>I don’t know if <em>Metroid Fusion</em> is comfortable, or even <em>too</em> comfortable, with being about killing. It probably is, given Samus’ appraisal of the SA-X. But there seems to be, for the careful player, a lesson in that lack of self-reflection. A lesson communicated across games, through unpleasant emotions like helplessness. A lesson about the helplessness of the powerful and how they understand the world and their position in it.</p><p>Let’s just hope we’re all listening for it.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! If you liked this, make sure to </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em>follow me here on Medium.</em></a><em> And if you want to read more, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/filthy-save-scum-what-a-fun-little-ninja-game-taught-me-about-videogame-save-systems-03695107b4c5"><em>click here</em></a><em> to see an article I’m proud of.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c22ef540318" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lost in the Fog: Silent Hill F and the Failures of Symbolism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/lost-in-the-fog-silent-hill-f-and-the-failures-of-symbolism-e7ec024089c4?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e7ec024089c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Jun 2026 19:01:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-11T19:01:00.710Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8hBpGpz0xi7xYQGCqvHGJw.avif" /></figure><p><em>This article contains major spoilers for Silent Hill F.</em></p><p>M. Night Shyamalan and his twist endings have done irreparable damage to the world of storytelling. Not because twist endings are bad, but because it’s so easy to do them poorly that they are often deployed by less skilled storytellers without an understanding of how they should be used. Too commonly, they lead to a <em>reversal</em> of stakes when they should lead to a <em>reinterpretation</em> of stakes. This is often the problem with “it was all a dream/hallucination” plots.</p><p>I’ve discussed this before when writing about <em>Prey</em> (2017), so I won’t rehash the entire thing here, but I’ll sum up: If I believe that the decisions I’m making as a player of a game have weight for a specific reason, and a last-minute twist in the narrative makes it so that none of the reasons I had for making those decisions actually mattered, or they mattered for completely different reasons that I could not have hoped to figure out, I’m going to be pissed.</p><p>This is the reason that exactly half of <em>Silent Hill F</em> pisses me off.</p><p>If you aren’t familiar with the series, most of the <em>Silent Hill</em> games employ a similar two-tiered structure: There is the “fog world,” which is recognizable as our own but covered in a dense layer of choking fog that hides strange monsters, and the “otherworld,” which is a more bizarre, disjointed, and impossible space covered in red rust and filled with deep holes that go nowhere. The first half of each level is spent in the fog world, where things are spooky and eerie, but at least nominally familiar to the player as “real.” Then, after a certain narrative point is crossed, things transition to the otherworld, where the monsters are deadlier and more numerous and the puzzles become more surreal, solved through symbolic associations rather than coherent logic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5QEwhx7N5qKcPAnhmw7U-A.jpeg" /><figcaption>The “fog world” in the Silent Hill 2 Remake</figcaption></figure><p>As a structure, it generally works well. The player is given time to familiarize themself with a level in a less threatening circumstance before things get flipped on their heads. It allows a portion set in a hospital, for example, to include real patient files in the fog world and then surreal nightmare files in the otherworld that tell the story of doctors attempting to “cure” patients of their sanity by endlessly tormenting them.</p><p><em>Silent Hill F</em>, the most recent entry in the series, generally preserves this structure despite its transplanting of the setting and time period from 1990s-ish USA to Japan in the 1960s. In <em>SHF</em>, you play as Hinako, a teenage girl with an emotionally and physically abusive father and a mother who feels she has no choice but to defend him. She’s basically right, given the abysmal state of women’s rights in Japan in this period, and this lays a lot of the thematic groundwork for the game. Documents spread throughout the game include suicide notes from abused women and notes detailing women’s plans to escape from the town and flee their circumstance, taking their chances elsewhere. This is the “fog world”: Hinako’s hometown seemingly abandoned by everyone except her and a few friends, choked by dense mist and roaming monsters.</p><p>But <em>SHF</em>’s “otherworld” deserves special mention. Whenever Hinako passes out or sleeps in the fog world, she wakes up in a place called the Dark Shrine, a surreal landscape of endless black populated only by traditional Japanese religious shrines and a single man with white hair and a fox mask who guides her. A Dark Shrine section follows each fog world section, offering a semblance of the back-and-forth balance found in the older <em>Silent Hill</em> games.</p><p>Despite my initial misgivings about it, the Dark Shrine ends up really working. As you venture further into the main shrine itself, a small doll that Hinako used to have as a child warns you via cryptic writing to not trust the man in the fox mask. But where else can you go? You follow him deeper and deeper, and it becomes clear that the Dark Shrine is a stand-in for the institution of marriage. Every step Hinako takes is another step into entrapment; every bond of friendship she sacrifices to the shrine is symbolic of the isolation she experiences moving into her adult life with her new husband. Eventually Hinako, having been thoroughly broken, submits to physical mutilation, cutting off her own arm to be replaced with a grotesque fox arm and allowing her back to be painfully branded with a religious symbol.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cVOaVmdjwsVpRXpN5vps6Q.avif" /><figcaption>An early Dark Shrine section in Silent Hill F</figcaption></figure><p>This <em>really</em> works. The symbolic weight of these sequences is powerful and moving. My initial reaction of, “You <em>really</em> should not be doing that” was tempered by the followup: What real choice does she have? She is isolated in a place she cannot escape from, at the mercy of this man who promises her that she only has to do this one extra thing, only has to change herself a <em>little </em>bit more to be good enough, until she is unrecognizable to herself and the player. Each mutilation carries a gameplay benefit, a bump in power to the player’s combat capabilities, but this subversion deepens the horror. I do not <em>want</em> to be more powerful if this is what it costs Hinako.</p><p>So the Dark Shrine sections work. What about the other half of the game?</p><p>Oh. <em>Oh</em>. Oh no. Please don’t tell me it was all a dream. Please, I’ll do <em>anything</em>. I’ll play <em>Silent Hill Homecoming</em> again. Just… anything but that.</p><p>The fog world portions of the game are, gameplay-wise, fine. Puzzles are overall pretty simple, the weapon durability adds some tension, a few of the compact sections, like the doctor’s house, really work. But the fog world fails <em>completely</em> on the level of narrative, character, and symbolism, and it’s much more painful to experience in comparison to the strong Dark Shrine sections.</p><p>In the real world, Hinako mostly travels with her friends Shu, a boy and childhood friend of Hinako whom she is not interested in romantically, and Rinko, who <em>is</em> interested in Shu romantically and is jealous of the bond he and Hinako share. This could be a source of real dramatic tension, except that they never talk about it, even after Rinko <em>pushes Hinako down a flight of stairs</em>. Instead, every time Rinko and Shu get separated from Hinako, Hinako can overhear them talking about how she is actually dead and how Shu needs to accept this and move on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EFH9GxKxl4In5CoDd-2Vtg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hinako’s hometown shrouded in fog</figcaption></figure><p>As far as I can tell, this is never really elaborated on. The game ends with the fog world version of Hinako confronting the Dark Shrine version of herself, who has fully submitted to the idea of marriage. The fight is only doable because of some red pills that Hinako has been taking throughout the narrative (they serve as your primary healing item). Shu, the son of the local pharmacist, gave them to her for her stress because of her horrible home life. It becomes clear after the last boss fight that Hinako is addicted to the pills and the fog world events of the game have actually been a delusion caused by an overdose; Hinako is in her early twenties, not seventeen, overdosed on the pills at her wedding, suffered a psychotic break, killed several people, and is still at large with the police searching for her.</p><p>None of this, <em>absolutely none of it</em>, fits in with the rest of the fog world portions of the game. Hinako apparently (but apparently not) being dead the whole time, the conflict between her, Rinko, and Shu, the ending of the conflict with her parents where they’re killed by the fox version of her, none of this stuff really adds up to the ending of the game. Are these memories? Are they distorted hallucinations caused by the overdose? Is Hinako supposed to be actually wandering through her home town but seeing a completely different reality because of the drugs? I don’t know, and I don’t find any of these options satisfying.</p><p>And before anyone corrects me, yes, I know that there are more endings, but those are <em>only</em> available on NG+ playthroughs, and I cannot imagine being so jazzed about the last act of this game that I would ever want to play it again.</p><p>Symbolism is a tricky thing to get right. The concept of “meaning” in art is extraordinarily difficult to unravel, but at its base level, it works similarly to how language works: through the concept of “signs.” A sign is something that conveys meaning. The word “chair” is a sign that conveys the meaning of a separate seat for one person, usually with four legs and a back (thanks, dictionary). You have a sign, which can really be anything, and then the thing that a person interpreting that sign is supposed to understand from it, which is the meaning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kjW9VW5QitrpMOIwpkTClQ.avif" /><figcaption>Hinako post-mutilation in the Dark Shrine</figcaption></figure><p>We can scale this up to any level of complexity. Hinako’s self-mutilation in the Dark Shrine is a sign. It signifies to me, as a specific interpreter, that I am not meant to understand this act of replacing her human arm with a fox arm as literal. Instead, I am meant to understand it as symbolic. It is a metaphor. It is an act or emotion that is explained through its connection to another act or emotion. It “signifies” to me that Hinako has become complicit in her own entrapment, and is being pressured into it by the people around her (the Fox Mask and the shrine maidens assisting in the ritual). If I were to interpret this completely literally, it would be grotesque, but inert. I would just be watching someone chop off their arm. But because of the complex ways the human brain can interpret and understand meaning, instead we get a weighty scene dripping with emotional intensity and meaning that rings far beyond what I’m actually seeing.</p><p>This doesn’t happen in the fog world. There are some documents and some puzzles that communicate some extra meaning, but by and large, the signs do not signify anything. We get disconnected information from documents that implies a lot of backstory that barely ever ends up being relevant. There is no meaning for me to interpret. This could be a failing on my part, but I don’t believe it is. In the face of the ending and its implication of a psychotic break caused by a drug overdose, I look back on the conversations that Shu and Rinko had with Hinako in the fog world, all of the journeying and puzzle-solving and fighting I did, and it just feels meaningless. Like filler. Like I had to go and do stuff because this is a game so I need stuff to go and do.</p><p>Which is a shame. The Dark Shrine sections are so good, so bursting with the psychodrama and powerful symbolism of the old <em>Silent Hill</em> games, that the ball being dropped on the rest of the game is a real disappointment. But Konami has shown that they at least retain <em>some</em> of their chops; the ritual sequences in the Dark Shrine are some of the best horror I’ve played in a game all year.</p><p>I just hope they can stick the landing next time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e7ec024089c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Things I Love in Games: The Fierce Deity Mask]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/things-i-love-in-games-the-fierce-deity-mask-db3ea8420700?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db3ea8420700</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Jun 2026 19:01:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-04T19:01:00.658Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zIgHX_ZBGgvDr6qHljDRSA.avif" /></figure><p>What is the meaning of sacrifice?</p><p>You have to give something up, of course, but not every time you do that is a sacrifice. A sacrifice requires giving up something important to you, something that you may have once seen as essential, for a greater purpose. Parents may sacrifice things they once desired for their children; ambitious people may sacrifice opportunities or friendships that were important to them in order to achieve some overarching goal; people may sacrifice their time and money for a charitable cause, believing that it is worth it to improve society with their own precious resources.</p><p>One thing I often write about is how videogames offer a kind of realism that is wholly unique to them as a medium. I call this <em>experiential</em> realism. Videogames allow the people playing them to not only witness a situation, but to experience what it might be like to actually have it happen to them. Feelings like guilt and pride are difficult for films, books, and paintings to express because they are reflexive emotions felt about oneself, unlike feelings such as joy, sadness, or fear. Guilt and pride usually require actions, something done <em>by</em> someone that then prompts the feeling in a self-reflective way. Interactive media, like videogames, are well suited to this purpose. This is especially true when it comes to sacrifice.</p><p>In <em>The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask</em>, the primary collectibles in the game are masks (duh). They provide a variety of powers, from making you invisible to enemies, to allowing you to talk to mummies, to literally blowing you up (shoutout to the Blast Mask). There are a few plot-essential masks that allow you to transform into the various magical races of Hyrule, like rock people or fish people, but most of the effects are minor, the masks optional collectibles for performing small tasks, or in some cases long, esoteric side quests. Importantly, you almost always get them for helping someone. Including the transformation masks, there are twenty-three in total.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cIQru_giSWR-gpTCtQpHhg.png" /><figcaption>Screenshot of all the masks in the inventory</figcaption></figure><p>Well… twenty-four, really.</p><p>At the end of the game you travel into the moon and inside is a meadow dominated by a single large tree. It’s meant to be surreal and strange. This is where you have to go to battle the titular Majora’s Mask, the mind-controlling mask driving the game’s villain to destroy the kingdom. Dancing around the tree are four children, each one wearing the mask of one of the game’s bosses. Each child prompts you to trade in five of your non-transformation masks in order to play a little minigame. If you trade away all twenty of the optional masks, a fifth child, wearing the Majora’s Mask, will give you the final mask in the game: the Fierce Deity Mask.</p><p>The Fierce Deity Mask allows a fourth transformation. It can only be used during boss battles and changes you into a towering, adult version of yourself, with completely white eyes, warrior face paint, and a large double-helix sword that can shoot out beams of energy. Basically, it turns any boss into easy mode as you melt them with your implacable warrior power.</p><p>There’s something about the whole situation that feels off to me. Even when I played <em>Majora’s Mask</em> as a kid, I didn’t like the idea of giving up all of the masks I’d worked so hard to collect. The Fierce Deity mask seems like it should be a reward, but you have to trade away all of these other masks, each one with a story, in order to get it. It feels like a sacrifice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yS_-EpE_RtZ4B-SEVVa4Tw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The surreal world inside the moon</figcaption></figure><p>But really, what do you need them for? The game is ending. The <em>world</em> is ending. What enemies do you have to hide from? What mummies do you have to talk to? You have one job: Kill the final, most powerful enemy. Take the Fierce Deity mask. Become a true warrior. Sacrifice everything you’ve worked for. Destroy. Destroy. Destroy.</p><p>You may have caught earlier that I mentioned that the Fierce Deity Mask transforms you into an adult version of yourself. Up until this point, you have played as a child. This is your final transformation.</p><p>Videogames are always about power. You, the player, are typically the only being with true agency in the narrative because the rest of the characters are little computer puppet people. Some games subvert this, but most are happy heaping more and more and more cool, shiny ways to fight and kill on the player. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with this; I like feeling powerful.</p><p>But sometimes a game can make you uneasy about power. It can show the exchange that power demands, the sacrifice of meaningful tokens and symbols of the places we’ve been, the things we’ve done, and the people we’ve helped. For this kind of power? The power to destroy? The power of the Fierce Deity?</p><p>You may have to give up everything.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! If you liked this, you can follow me </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em>here on Medium.</em></a><em> You can also check out another article that I’m proud of </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/the-revolutionary-mind-disco-elysium-as-scale-model-of-human-thought-08ca910fc051"><em>here.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db3ea8420700" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Heart in Dishonored]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/the-heart-in-dishonored-398206b2d769?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/398206b2d769</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Feb 2026 00:43:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-02T03:25:32.765Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Things I Love in Games: The Heart in <em>Dishonored</em></h3><p><em>This is “Things I love in games,” a simple series where I highlight… things I love in games. Imagine that.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*EtV3_ExONFHbt9nam1ojbQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Information wins games. Without knowing the positioning of your opponent’s defenses, the weakness of a particularly powerful boss monster, or the cravings of a VIP client coming to your sushi restaurant, you will be hard-pressed to find victory. Thinking on your feet is great and all, but how often to people beat a boss in <em>Elden Ring</em> without ever having fought it before? Without the opportunity to study its moves and learn its patterns?</p><p>Enter <em>Dishonored</em>, the landmark 2012 immersive sim stealth-action game that coined — and as far as I know exclusively uses — the term “whalepunk.” In <em>Dishonored</em>, while controlling disgraced royal bodyguard Corvo Attano as he hunts down the greedy pricks who assassinated your Empress, Jessamine Kaldwin, there are a lot of ways to gather information. You can spy on people from shadowy rafters above their heads, scurry through rodent holes while possessing a rat, or eavesdrop from a balcony.</p><p>Or you can use the Heart.</p><p>The Heart is an item gifted to you by the mysterious Outsider, the extra-dimensional asshole who gives you your powers. It is a literal human heart that you equip and hold in your left hand, the hand that usually wields a mystical power or a gun. Its main function is to guide you to hidden charms that make you more powerful; while holding it, you can see them through walls, and it beats faster and faster as you close in on the collectibles. But it also does something much, <em>much</em> more interesting.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*ujLQ5imBwnLlMxxJjF7GwA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit to Radiator Design Blog</figcaption></figure><p>The heart speaks to you. Press the left trigger while holding it and an ethereal, feminine voice will say something, doubled with echo as if from phones pressed to each ear, telling you secrets about the level you are traversing or the person you are looking at. Not useful secrets; the useful part is seeing the charms through walls. But <em>juicy</em> secrets. <em>Melancholy</em> secrets. Secrets which, after you learn them, you wish you had left well enough alone.</p><p>In the brothel: <em>“They thought they would be working in a factory. By the time they arrive it’s much too late.”</em></p><p>Near a bridge on the waterfront: <em>“Many seek the bridge for solace. Ruined men, abandoned women, and plague victims have all leapt from here.”</em></p><p>When looking at a member of a street gang: <em>“His mother’s dying words to him were: ‘Give us a whiskey, darling.’”</em></p><p>A city guard: <em>“This one has kept a lock of hair from everyone he’s ever killed.”</em></p><p>Another: <em>“When not at his post, he searches for his sister, missing a week now.”</em></p><p>A religious zealot: <em>“They are experts at extracting confessions, even from the innocent.”</em></p><p>Another: <em>“He was asked to perform a wedding. So few lately. It lifted his heavy heart.”</em></p><p>Everywhere: <em>“Can you hear them too? Crying out in the dark?”</em></p><p>Everywhere: <em>“I can feel a great age ending.”</em></p><p>Everywhere: <em>“What have they done to me?”</em></p><p>You can learn, through strategic use of the Heart in certain environments and on certain characters, that it is the heart of the Empress, Jessamine Kaldwin. The Empress your character, Corvo, failed to protect. The Outsider has fashioned it for you. A friendly, grim gesture from an alien being? A twisted joke? Who’s to say.</p><p>As far as I’m concerned, the Heart is the greatest worldbuilding tool ever put in a game. The visceral, uncompromising bluntness of the writing, combined with excellent vocal effects and voice acting, lend so much character to the world of <em>Dishonored</em> that would simply not be there otherwise. There are more than 250 of these lines throughout the game, a genuinely staggering number of poetic lines to write and record, and their effect is intense and evocative.</p><p>The Heart reinforces the theme and mood of the setting, Dunwall, and the unbearable misery of the people who live there. It gives you a reason to seek these people out and see them as people, not vision cones with swords. It humanizes the setting at a variable rate determined by the player; if you want a little more, all you have to do is pull the Heart out and squeeze.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! If you liked this, please consider heading over to </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em>my page</em></a><em> and giving me a follow. And if you want to read more, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/filthy-save-scum-what-a-fun-little-ninja-game-taught-me-about-videogame-save-systems-03695107b4c5"><em>here’s an article I’m proud of.</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=398206b2d769" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ranking Every Videogame I Played in 2025]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/ranking-every-videogame-i-played-in-2025-cbb036512d96?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cbb036512d96</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Dec 2025 01:05:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-25T01:05:32.778Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This article contains minor spoilers for each game discussed. Reader beware.</em></p><p>Three years ago, I set myself a New Year’s resolution: each month, I would play a game I had never played before. I wanted to consume games more critically and with more intent, and it worked; I played 15 new games that year (“new” here just meaning that I had never played them). I began keeping internal track of my “game of the year,” but counted the candidates as any game that was new to me, rather than games that actually released that year.</p><p>So, I thought it would be fun to collate some of the thoughts I’ve had on the games I’ve played this year and crown my personal game of the year (I know, I know, I’m a genius for being the first ever guy to think of this). This will be especially useful for the games I found interesting, but maybe not quite interesting enough to write a whole article for.</p><p>Without further ado, here is my ranking of the thirteen “new to me” games I played this year:</p><p><strong>13. Mini Mini Golf Golf</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*mxkEe8WHNxcGRLm2_vx4bA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This game should have been my jam. A person trapped on a space station that controls an underwater machine creating artificial tectonic plates in order to combat climate change? Communicating with your computer, who it turns out is a human brain transformed into an operating system, as they realize that the human brain that was turned into the tectonic plate machine is someone they used to <em>date</em>? And to top it all off, you unlock buried traumatic memories of the people the sentient computers used to be by beating levels of a mini golf computer game?</p><p>Unfortunately, none of these elements really come to fruition. The narrative backstory of the computers is compelling in some places but painfully dull in others. The “found footage” of live-action actors in a cable-TV program about how videogames can transform people’s lives is great in theory, but each segment goes on for far too long. And most devastating is how boring the mini golf levels themselves are. You play the same handful over and over and over again, a mind-numbing monotony. I respect the narrative ambition, but it is done a massive disservice by the underwhelming “game” parts of the game.</p><p><strong>12. Twelve Minutes</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/616/1*jG0A28TsZzpQScKzpRt4RA.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you’re a frequent reader of this blog, you’ll know that I have a searing hatred for “it was all a dream” plots. Any narrative that is fully symbolic, or occurs entirely in the mind of only a single character, etc. is hard-pressed to win any points from me. This is for a simple reason: an inversion of stakes. I build connection to a narrative by investing myself in what’s at stake. To then pull the curtain back and say, “Get bent, loser. Those stakes? Nope! Invest yourself in these <em>new</em> stakes in the last ten minutes of the narrative! Aren’t I a genius?”</p><p>Anyway, <em>Twelve Minutes</em> is a time loop game where your everyman hero repeats the same twelve minutes after getting home from work. In these twelve minutes, a police officer arrives at your house, attempts to arrest your wife for murder, and kills you. Then you reset. You have to figure out what he wants and how to keep yourself and your wife safe while breaking the loop. Some clunky movement mechanics make repeated loops with a string of complex actions kind of tedious, and the final reveal is, frankly, kind of stupid. But it kept me moving through it until the end, and Willem Dafoe gives an interesting performance as the villain.</p><p><strong>11. Silent Hill f</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*P1zMWaZOQDHqNgY_yp8PYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’m working on a whole article about <em>Silent Hill f</em>, so consider this a little preview: Half of this game is <em>really</em> good, and the other half is not. The portion that takes place in this version of the <em>Silent Hill</em> series’ “otherworld,” the Dark Shrine, is an effective symbolic journey across a psychological landscape warped by the painful sociological circumstances of women in 1960s Japan. The way the Dark Shrine stands as an allegory for the journey of a girl into “womanhood” and the responsibilities placed on her by her culture is pitch-perfect.</p><p>The real world sections of the game are… not that. On an individual level, most of the segments are fine. The puzzles all work, the enemy placement is sometimes frighteningly effective, etc. But the narrative momentum is effectively absent and the symbolic language is confused. The ending, especially, is a nightmarish miniboss rush mired in <em>huge</em> amounts of required, crowded arena battles with enemies that spawn more enemies. The lackluster third act, unfortunately, sours all of the great work done by the Dark Shrine. It’s a shame, because Akira Yamaoka’s music has never been better. Portions of this game are literally saved by the score. The rest I could take or leave, and I won’t be playing it again to unlock more endings.</p><p><strong>10. Unfair Flips</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*mw5PuJOqNUYvrrQBiBfJOw.jpeg" /></figure><p>What is there to say about <em>Unfair Flips</em>? Quite a lot, perhaps. It’s a game in which you have to flip a coin to land on head ten times in a row, but you start with only a 20% chance to land on heads. Each heads gives you money, with consecutive heads results multiplying that money. You use the money to buy upgrades, the most important of which is increasing the chance that you land on heads.</p><p>That’s it. That’s the game. It’s an exercise in simplicity. Humans will turn anything into a game on their own. <em>Unfair Flips</em> weaponizes this impulse against its audience. What are you doing? Just flipping a coin? Just because it plays a musical note that ascends a major scale every time you land on heads? Just because it told you to? Just because you have nothing better to do?</p><p>I think these are interesting questions for a game to be asking. It’s not very much fun, though.</p><p><strong>9. Marvel Rivals</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dRArfuQTB5Kjcgxf0TTtFQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s <em>Marvel Rivals</em>. I got a new PC this year and decided to play <em>Marvel Rivals</em> with friends. We mostly played casual mode. I played Invisible Woman until Emma Frost came out, and then I played Emma Frost. It’s a competent hero shooter, it feels good to play, it’s well-balanced, and it defines a “middle of the list” game. I probably won’t play it anymore.</p><p><strong>8. Faith: The Unholy Trinity</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tSAp37WGXG4h9rdaEtYd9w.avif" /></figure><p>Now we’re into the weird stuff. <em>Faith</em> is the answer to the burning question at the core of each of our beings: What if the satanic panic had been real, and there really were satanists staffing abortion clinics and summoning demons in the sewers? More importantly, what if there was a videogame about it that looked like it came out on the Atari 2600?</p><p><em>Faith</em> sees you playing a priest in the 1980s, disgraced after a botched exorcism and haunted by his failure, pressed into service by an older priest in order to stop a satanic cult that has taken deep, <em>deep</em> root in your suburban community. It makes great use of its simplicity. Your only weapon is your cross and it performs every function, so what if you have to throw it away to solve a puzzle? It also betrays its modern origins by including some of the most frightening rotoscoped animation I’ve ever seen in a segment where your only light is the flash from an unreliable polaroid camera. Eugh.</p><p><strong>7. Who’s Lila?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*K-pRBi6-bcsgJiJozuogoA.jpeg" /></figure><p>At first, it seems like <em>Who’s Lila?</em> is just a game with a great gimmick: Your player character has trouble feeling emotions, so he practices facial expressions in the mirror. It’s a point-and-click adventure where a third of the screen is taken up by your own character’s face, which you manipulate in tense social situations to try to wear the expression that serves you best. Do you smirk at the bully to goad him into hitting you? Or look scared so he thinks he’s won?</p><p>But it’s deeper than that. It’s not often that a videogame goes to such great lengths to be in conversation with the works of David Lynch, but <em>Who’s Lila?</em> is one of those games. It is Lynchian in the purest sense of that word: Characters speak in veiled references to events that you have little way of learning about, several scenes exist independent of the narrative, which itself repeats, changing what is true depending on actions you take. To top it all off, the plot concerns the actions of a metaphysical cult and the thought construct (or tulpa) they’ve created with the power of their collective imagination. Wild stuff. If you are into that kind of thing (like I am), you will probably like it despite the tedium of trying to unlock every ending to fully understand the story.</p><p><strong>6. Vampire Survivors</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b6oAKUiHAr1XSrtaLupwTQ.avif" /></figure><p>Everyone who has ever said this game is awesome is right. If it’s not the progenitor of the “bullet heaven” genre (the opposite of bullet hell, where the level is full of enemies and you produce thousands of projectiles to defeat them), then it certainly made it popular. The various characters are just different enough from each other to provide near-infinite variety, the strict time limits on each level mean you know exactly how long a run will take (if you survive to the end), and you will always, <em>always</em> unlock something after a run.</p><p>There are so many unlocks, guys. So, so many. The only reason it’s not higher is because roguelikes rarely resonate enough with me to truly capture my heart.</p><p><strong>5. Clair Obscur: Expedition 33</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EJOpZ0Pk1RKR2XP_sgwxbQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ve played most of the <em>Final Fantasy</em> series, along with many other classic JRPGs. They always struggle with a simple question: How do you make turn-based combat not boring? Each one tries to solve this problem in a different way, but I really respect how <em>Clair Obscur</em> does it. I think of it as maximalist design. You want active battle systems? How about two different kinds of parries, two different kinds of dodges, and timed button presses on every attack? You like abilities? How about 200 of them that can be spread across any character in any combination?</p><p>This would be fine enough on its own, but it’s combined with a story that takes what should be a stupid JRPG “save the world” narrative and grounds it in the kind of humanity-on-the-brink story most often found in post-apocalyptic fiction. Characters feel real grief for this dying world. I only have one gripe, but it is <em>major</em>. The story takes a turn in the third act that I believe is to the serious detriment of the narrative as a whole, and it really sours the whole thing for me. I won’t spoil it, but man, I just don’t know why they made the choices they did.</p><p><strong>4. Silent Hill 2 (2024)</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*evV9IffwxBbaaOcPgStXMQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Damn this game is good. It updates the clunky combat from the original, which I understand has its own thematic resonance with the “everyman” nature of the story, but the new combat system feels so chunky and visceral despite its simplicity. The intense, choking fog and darkness, explored from a new over-the-shoulder camera, made my skin crawl even when I was unfortunately overloaded with healing items (if you play third-person action games at all, play this one on hard mode).</p><p>Most importantly, the updates to the voice acting are excellent. They emphasize different things than the original, but gone are James Sunderland’s horribly awkward, exclamatory statements about pizza. The game nails exactly what makes <em>Silent Hill</em> special. The town is not a dream, but a real place that is warped beyond recognition by the psychological traumas of the characters. It’s important that it is not a dream, but that instead it is a living place that hates you. The game leverages the arbitrary nature of most video game puzzles, abstracting them into psychological questions that you provide answers to, always digging deeper into the trap.</p><p>It’s a little too long, and some sequences can be a bit dull, but it always picks back up again. If you’ve never played a <em>Silent Hill</em> game and like horror, start here.</p><p><strong>3. Hollow Knight: Silksong</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*ZJ2JMFxAk7V9Z6Q0sWUcmQ.png" /></figure><p>I’ve always maintained that <em>Hollow Knight</em> is actually just the game <em>Dark Souls</em>. I don’t mean this in a snarky internet-critic way, but as an appreciation. It’s rare that a game achieves the same balance of symbolic storytelling, visceral gameplay, and player self-determination.</p><p><em>Silksong</em> has different priorities. It’s faster, less forgiving, and more difficult overall. It emphasizes more coherent NPC storylines and a protagonist that truly inhabits the world. In my opinion, there is very little to criticize in <em>Silksong</em>, and that’s partially my problem with it. This feels stupid to say, but it’s perfect in a way that doesn’t sing for me. I played it to 100% completion and enjoyed nearly every second, but it slips through my memory like water. I like everything about it; I’m not sure I <em>love</em> anything about it. But I respect the immense care it shows toward crafting every element of a game’s systems and world, and I also love hitting things with a big drill.</p><p><strong>2. Pentiment</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YehSK1CzoSDKCDn3TUM6FA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ve encountered the sentiment online that there are a few games that have truly attempted to inherit the ethos of <em>Disco Elysium</em>, which I would describe thus: Games that are as interested in thinking as mainstream gaming has been interested, for decades, in violence.</p><p><em>Pentiment</em> is the game that has come closest for me. You play as Andreas Maler, a young apprentice artist attempting to create a masterpiece illuminated manuscript (the medieval/Renaissance religious texts with all the weird animals in the margins) when a visiting baron is stabbed to death in the abbey where you are studying. It falls to you to investigate the murder and exonerate the prime suspect: your elderly, sweet-tempered mentor.</p><p><em>Pentiment’s</em> strength is in its narrative writing and thematic integrity. Every interaction with the peasants, craftsmen, monks, and nuns in this town reveals a new shade of their lives, and the complex politics of where to place your loyalties is always informing scenes. Most importantly, the game is about belief: You cannot prove, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that any particular person committed the murder. You have to judge, and be judged in turn.</p><p><strong>1. Blue Prince</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*ra7YG9rhccKK1c89t5GK1A.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Blue Prince</em> is everything I want in a game. The idea is novel, the execution is immaculate, and even though that would be enough to make the game great, the creator’s intense love for the concept of puzzles and enigmas motivated him to craft an enchanting puzzle box that far, <em>far</em> exceeds any and all expectations I had for the game.</p><p>The game is, essentially, a house-building puzzle roguelike (I don’t actually like referring to it as a roguelike, but it will do here). You’ve inherited a manor from your deceased uncle on the condition that you can make it from the entrance to the secret 46th room on the other side. Every time you open a door, you “draft” what room is on the other side from three options, trying to form a path to the opposite side. Every morning, the manor resets. But hidden underneath this ingenious, endlessly fun base structure are dozens, if not hundreds, of other puzzles. Some are contained entirely within a specific room; others require you to pull information from other rooms to solve.</p><p>Every time you believe you have found everything in a room, you are wrong. Every time you think you’ve solved the last puzzle, you are wrong. The creator, Tonda Ros, deserves to be mentioned with the master puzzle makers like Torquemada, Hempuli, and Will Shortz. <em>Blue Prince</em> is a masterpiece of game design, a magnificent puzzle, and a labor of intense love that can be felt in every inch of the game. It’s my game of the year, and it’s not a particularly close race.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! What did you play this year? Be sure to subscribe to </em><a href="http://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em>my page</em></a><em> here on Medium if you want to read more, and check out an article I’m proud of </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/the-revolutionary-mind-disco-elysium-as-scale-model-of-human-thought-08ca910fc051?source=user_profile_page---------19-------------df3bb25947a9----------------------"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cbb036512d96" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Children in Videogames, Part 4: Fantasy Racism, Objectification, and the Social History of Monsters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/children-in-videogames-part-4-fantasy-racism-objectification-and-the-social-history-of-monsters-085f10fafd86?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/085f10fafd86</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Sep 2025 23:32:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-22T23:32:18.800Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Pmq36hnAo-QFMIOXRTBZ2A.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Question: Why can you kill the goblin children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>?</strong></p><p>Answer: Who cares? They’re just goblins.</p><p>In the summer of 2020, amidst global protests of racially-motivated police brutality, including but certainly not limited to the murders of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, every corporation was scrambling to put together a statement on “diversity” to signal that they were on the right side of history. Wizards of the Coast, the company that owns and publishes <em>Dungeons &amp; Dragons</em>, was no exception. On June 7th, <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20200618091802/https://dnd.wizards.com/articles/features/diversity-and-dnd">they put out a statement as well</a>. They, of course, affirmed their commitment to diversity, and more importantly for our purposes here, distanced themselves from <em>D&amp;D</em>’s past depictions of certain races as inherently monstrous and evil.</p><p>Here, “races” are roughly equivalent to “species,” which is the term that <em>D&amp;D</em> has now adopted as canon. Think elves, dwarves, orcs, and humans. I will be using the word “race” throughout this article to reflect the language used in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>.</p><p>The statement only specifically refers to orcs and drow, also known as dark elves, but cites them only as the “prime examples.” I think it’s reasonable to include goblins in this group, especially given the followup in the statement about how these groups have been depicted “using descriptions that are painfully reminiscent of how real-world ethnic groups have been and continue to be denigrated.” Even in the modern era, goblins have been used as stand-ins for a lower class of people (in Terry Pratchett’s <em>Discworld</em>) or have come under fire for perceived alignment with real-world antisemitic stereotypes (the goblins in <em>Harry Potter</em> being greedy bankers with large noses).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/681/1*meTHx-UZ0iCaS1ibcubzug.jpeg" /><figcaption>Yeah, kind of like that</figcaption></figure><p>Four months after Wizards of the Coast published this statement, <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em> released in early access, including the majority of the content found in the game’s first act. This first act is where most of the content surrounding the goblins is focused, including the scene in which your player character (PC) can choose to rescue Halsin and kill the goblin children.</p><p>This all leads to a fascinating dichotomy, especially where the goblin children are concerned. On the one hand, we have Wizards of the Coast, the official parent company and long-time publisher of <em>Dungeons &amp; Dragons</em>, stating that they want to distance the new material they produce from stereotypical depictions of races as inherently evil or monstrous. On the other hand, we have <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>, in which goblins are depicted as… inherently evil and monstrous. Womp womp.</p><p>The depiction of goblins in <em>BG3</em> is not exactly in line with the oldest <em>D&amp;D</em> tradition, where goblins were (like pretty much all monsters) bags of loot to be slaughtered. It’s more like the middle era that WotC is distancing themselves from, where they have a culture and a god, Maglubiyet, in whose name they commit many terrible acts. In <em>BG3</em>, they’ve traded Maglubiyet for the Absolute, a new god that serves as the primary antagonist for the game. The goblins serve as willing low-level fodder for the cult of the Absolute, who control them by promising divine rewards for their service that will never actually materialize. The leaders of the cult of the Absolute look down on the goblins and treat them like dirt to be walked on.</p><p>This could be compelling, right? A warlike race driven to a mad fervor by the manipulations of a clever god to do its bidding. And this wholesale cultural manipulation might have thematic weight if it were in contrast to something, but it is specifically <em>not</em> in contrast to anything, on purpose. You can meet a goblin named Brakkal in the goblins’ home base who has been imprisoned for refusing to follow the Absolute and instead adhering to Maglubiyet’s old tenets. The new goblin way under the Absolute is to kill basically anyone who isn’t in the cult, which they do so with glee, often eating the members of sentient races that they kill (if you are in good with the goblins, they will offer you some roast dwarf at a party). But then, what is the <em>old </em>goblin way under Maglubiyet that this brave martyr is so dedicated to following?</p><p>Well, it’s killing anyone who isn’t a goblin. And eating them. But you shout “Maglubiyet!” instead of “For the Absolute!” while you do it. Truly a well-rounded depiction of a culture.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9r61UTVyVDphOSv9s8Udpg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Brakkal in question</figcaption></figure><p><strong>This is Starting to Sound like Politics</strong></p><p>There are a lot of questions people ask, sometimes in bad faith, about videogames and the content therein. Once such question is covered in Jacob Geller’s phenomenal video essay <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FtCV421T52s&amp;t=699s">“Does <em>Call of Duty</em> Believe in Anything?”</a> In short, how can videogames avoid being labelled as “political?” How can we make our games just escapism with having to bring up anything complicated or challenging?</p><p>Short of arcade shooters like <em>Galaga</em> and pure puzzle games like <em>Baba is You</em>, all games are political. We live in a political world; every depiction of a person or group of people is influenced by the politics of the moment, the unconscious encoding of messages and bias by the creator, and the context of the medium. Games are art. And art, like all communication, is fundamentally unable to be disentangled from politics. Everything in the entire world is influenced by politics. We are all born into social machines beyond our full understanding or control that were set in motion hundreds of years before we were born and which control every aspect of our lives. That <em>is</em> politics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HkEuAQVaDVU3lUKzEbIK_w.png" /><figcaption>Careful with the incendiary rhetoric there, bud</figcaption></figure><p>What videogames depict as good or bad, and what they incentivize in play, is worth examining. Gamers cannot expect videogames to be taken seriously as an art form and also expect them to be free from analysis, political or otherwise. I hope that the work I’ve done in this series, and the work Jacob Geller does in the linked video above, help make that clear.</p><p><strong>The Role-Playing Conundrum</strong></p><p>There is a tension inherent to the role-playing game. Like videogames, table-top RPGs always have to balance the game parts with the narrative parts. The things in the game are not real. Anything you encounter is, in some sense, an object, whether that object is formed of sound and light on a screen or only exists in the shared imaginary mind space of the players around the table. The fun comes from getting to pretend that it <em>is</em> real, that the weird NPC you’ve just encountered has an inner world and motivations and exists as part of an imagined landscape of a sort of “fantasy reality” that you can invest yourself in.</p><p>But when players of a TTRPG like <em>Dungeons &amp; Dragons</em> are invested in something, they usually want to know more about it. As time has gone on, many of the official <em>D&amp;D</em> monsters have morphed from purely mechanical challenges, maybe with interesting lairs or powers, to things approaching people. Many players feel that it makes the world of the game, the <em>fiction</em>, richer and more rewarding to have different races and species that have their own ecology and, eventually, culture. This, in my opinion, is clearly reflected in WotC’s statement from 2020. The game has changed. Times have changed. We have a better understanding of how art shapes society, attitudes, culture, and the political landscape. Things that used to just be monsters have become people, with aspects of both.</p><p>All of this leads to <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>, which exists in a painful, awkward middle ground. In the game, you can infiltrate the goblin camp and speak to many of the goblins there. Overall, the depiction is ugly and vile. There is a human character named Volo who is at least nominally interested in learning about the goblins and is instead captured and tormented by them, kept as a slave and forced to sing under threat of harm or death. The game, in effect, treats this as a joke. Most of the dialogue in the encounter is geared toward making fun of Volo and putting him in danger, as if to say, “How foolish can you be? Why try to understand them? They’re horrible little monsters.” In the eyes of the game, Volo’s attempt to learn about or understand the goblins is obvious folly. There is nothing to learn. There is nothing to understand. They are goblins.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7TMMfJAWr07E2u-A8XAk4A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Volo in the scene in question</figcaption></figure><p>And yet, there <em>are</em> things to learn about them. Some of them are trying to learn how to read. One found a book of poetry and likes it but is ashamed of that fact and doesn’t want anyone else to know. The one that “owns” Volo seems to genuinely want him to sing a song that she can appreciate even as she threatens his life. These are not flattering depictions, and they even fall short of showing any real depth of thought or robust internal landscape, but their presence in the game at all complicates the overall message of the game’s first act: The best outcome, if you are even remotely interested in doing good, is to eradicate every single goblin you see.</p><p>They cannot be redeemed. Not a single one can be good, even by accident. They have thoughts and wants and desires, but this does not stop them from being, to a one, evil, putrid little monsters.</p><p><strong>But Goblins Aren’t Real</strong></p><p>Trust me, we’re getting there.</p><p>The word “objectification” became a sort of gaming buzzword in the 2010s, long after its introduction into actual philosophical and political discourse, due in large part to a critic named Anita Sarkeesian. She, one of the main targets of the reactionary “Gamergate” movement, made a wonderful series of videos called <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X6p5AZp7r_Q">“Tropes vs Women in Video Games”</a> where she breaks down popular games and their depictions of women through a feminist lens. She makes use of the feminist scholar Martha Nusbaum’s work on defining and breaking down the term “objectification.” Nusbaum defines objectification fairly simply: it is “treating <em>as an object</em> what is really not an object, what is, in fact, a human being.”</p><p>But how can this relate to videogames? <em>No</em> NPC is a human being. As I said above, all of the characters you encounter <em>are</em> objects. They are not real. How can objectification be an issue? Nusbaum tackles this sort of problem in her discussion of <em>Playboy</em> magazine, and in particular a revealing photo of a woman in a tennis outfit with the caption “Why we love tennis.” She writes, “…the characteristic <em>Playboy</em> generalizing approach… strongly suggests that real-life women relevantly similar to the tennis-player can easily be cast in the roles in which <em>Playboy</em> casts its chosen few. In that way it constructs for its reader a fantasy objectification of a class of real women.” If an object (in this case a photograph) serves as a representation that is similar to a real-life counterpart, and the audience is strongly encouraged to treat that representation <em>as</em> an object, then this can create a “fantasy objectification” where the object and the real-life group it is similar to become tied together in the audience’s head. This is one of the main reasons that harmful stereotypes even exist; when art and media encourage an audience to think of a group of people as only one thing, or only a handful of things, then that will happen. The media-created image will come to stand in for the group.</p><p>The depictions of the goblins in the game — head-dresses, simple clothing and tools, and weapons decorated with bones — is not dissimilar from depictions of tribal peoples, almost always indigenous, the world over (and especially in North America). The goblins have shamans and priestesses that read as “primitive.” They erect totems and engage in the sacrifice and cannibalism of other sentient races. These are the some of the depictions that, in the words of WotC, are “painfully reminiscent of how real-world ethnic groups have been and continue to be denigrated.” It is never stated that goblins are evil <em>because</em> they are tribal and primitive, but they <em>are</em> evil <em>while being</em> tribal and primitive, and are the only race depicted as such in the game.</p><p>Goblins are monsters, and monsters always mean something. Through their long history, unable to be divorced from the arc of the human storytelling impulse that has been present for as long as we have, monsters have always represented a facet of human fear, doubt, uncertainty, or anxiety. <em>Frankenstein</em> depicts a monster that, rejected by its creator, becomes wicked and must ultimately be destroyed, reflecting anxieties about parenthood and humanity’s supposed existence as a reflection of a divine creator. Bram Stoker’s <em>Dracula</em> shows a monster from a distant, shadowy country that invades and pollutes a major metropolitan bastion in an act of “reverse colonialism,” which is just one among many themes. <em>Godzilla</em> reflects Japan’s cultural anxiety about the consequences of the nuclear bombs that were dropped on the country. Even in the world of TTRPGs monsters mean something; the podcast <a href="https://scintilla.studio/monster/"><em>Making a Monster</em></a> consists of insightful interviews with game designers about their favorite monster they’ve ever created and what it means for players to encounter it (it’s a great podcast, you should check it out).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*Jto_Pgee_eywreLjL6ujOQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>It’s a REALLY good podcast</figcaption></figure><p>So what do the goblins in <em>BG3</em> mean? They mean that there are simple, tribal people who have culture but are incapable of empathy or goodness. The best outcome, really, is to kill them all, because all they ever do is kill and eat other people. And worst of all, where there are goblins, there are goblin children, which are just beasts, really. I mean, they’ll grow up to be goblins, which we have already established is quite a bad thing. And it’s not like the goblins care; I mean, they don’t even give the children <em>names</em>, just numbers. Better to take care of them now. One less goblin child is one less goblin.</p><p>In light of the real-life history of horrific treatment of tribal people, including forced sterilization of indigenous women in Canada and the US, and <em>especially </em>the treatment of indigenous children, including forced adoption into the genocidal white society that eradicated their families and their pasts, this depiction of goblins not only as primitive monsters but as beings whose children are worth killing, rubs me the wrong way.</p><p>And this kind of thinking is not exclusively the domain of the past. There is a genocide being perpetrated in Palestine, especially in Gaza, by the country of Israel. Earlier this year, a former member of Israel’s parliament named Moshe Feiglin was quoted saying, “Every child in Gaza is the enemy. We need to occupy Gaza and settle it, and no Gazan child will be left there. There is no other victory.” Nissim Vaturi, deputy speaker of the Knesset (Israel’s parliament) was quoted in February as saying that every child born in Gaza is “already a terrorist, from the moment of his birth.” Dehumanization of a group of people inevitably extends to children.</p><p>The depiction of goblins in <em>BG3</em> is not a mortal sin. I don’t think that Larian should be brought up on charges or boycotted or anything like that. In the grand scheme of things, maybe it’s not a huge deal. But it is <em>some</em> kind of deal. I don’t care if goblins aren’t real and this is just a videogame. The message of “primitive peoples have weird gods and are evil cannibals and deserve to be eradicated” <em>is</em> real, and present. The existence of a race of people against whom it is not only allowed but encouraged by the game’s incentive structure to kill their children <em>is</em> some kind of deal. Art reflects reality. This is a part of reality I would rather not be reflected in such a cold, uncaring way.</p><p>Question: Why can you kill the goblin children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>?</p><p>Answer: Who cares? They’re just goblins.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! If you liked this, make sure to go to my profile and follow me so you can read my next article when it comes out. That’s also where you can find my other work.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=085f10fafd86" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Children in Videogames, Part 3: Immersion and Agency]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/children-in-videogames-part-3-immersion-and-agency-43afdc0813b1?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/43afdc0813b1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 May 2025 15:56:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-21T15:56:00.809Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5Ak2qo0-UisAX9TKC77thQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This is Part 3 in a series of articles discussing the presence of children in videogames. You can start at the beginning with Part 1 </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/children-in-videogames-part-1-why-can-you-kill-the-goblin-children-in-baldurs-gate-3-4489cf3a9182"><em>here.</em></a></p><p><em>Content warning: This article discusses violence against children. It also features screenshots of Gamers on forums saying horrible shit. You have been warned.</em></p><p>Question: Why can you kill the goblin children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>?</p><p>Answer: Because I’m the player and it would break my immersion to not be able to.</p><p>Answer: Because I’m the player and I don’t like being told no.</p><p>Answer: Who cares? It’s not real.</p><p>In Part 2, I discussed the concept of “mechanical morality,” which is when game developers restrict players from engaging in certain acts in their videogames not out of a technical constraint or a game design decision, but because of a behind-the-scenes moral judgment. There is no good reason within the worlds of <em>Skyrim</em> and <em>Fallout 3</em> why you can shoot children with arrows and rocket launchers and they will just never take damage or die. The reason you can’t do it is because the developers don’t want you to be able to.</p><p>So, when we consider the question of why you can kill the goblin children and not the tiefling children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>, we encounter another difficulty that has little to do with mechanical morality: Who cares? Literally who cares if you can kill one type of child or the other? Or if you can kill children at all?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Hii4aAFM65AM8Gi78V9_Lw.avif" /><figcaption>Who cares if you can kill this child?</figcaption></figure><p>Well, obviously <em>some</em> people care. Developers make these choices for a reason, and whether that reason is because they don’t want to depict things that are horrible or because they want to be able to sell their games everywhere worldwide, it is clear that someone, somewhere, cares. It could be the developers or it could be legislative bodies governing art and “good taste.”</p><p>And Gamers care. That’s Gamers with a capital G. The kinds of people you find when you dredge internet forums on this topic, or who chime in when women in games have a visible muscle, or who come out of the woodwork when Yasuke, a real Black guy from history, is Black. They offer battle cries of “realism” and “immersion” and “player freedom” to bolster their credibility.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/961/1*zeP2TIllhVvwQJbS9sB5ug.png" /><figcaption>Yeah, like that.</figcaption></figure><p>So, let’s take them at their word (at least on the “killing children” stuff). We lose nothing, critically, by taking these concerns seriously for a bit.</p><p>There are two main camps of Gamers that you will encounter online when it comes to killing children, and for simplicity’s sake, I’ll call them the Immersion Gamers and the Freedom Gamers.</p><p>The Immersion Gamers argue that not being able to kill children is immersion-breaking. What this means is that when a game’s systems are affected by mechanical morality, when there is no reason beyond the developer’s sensibilities that you cannot kill children in the game, it makes the player too aware that they are playing a videogame. It shatters the illusion. If I stab this adult with a sword that sets them on fire, they will bleed and burn and die. If I stab their son with the same sword, he will just run away. The chain of cause and effect is shattered.</p><p>On one hand, I’m sympathetic to this argument. Game developers walk a gnarly tightrope when it comes to player immersion; every videogame, no matter how photorealistic or abstract, is just a sound-and-light show designed to fool the brain into taking it seriously for a while. This can be done to a greater or lesser degree of skill and thereby create a greater or lesser degree of immersion. Anyone who has played games for a decent amount of time knows what it is like to try something that <em>looks</em> possible, find out it’s <em>not</em> possible, and feel themself pull back from the game a little bit. It’s not always devastating to immersion, but it can definitely drag the play experience down.</p><p>Some games overcome this by simply not having children present in the world at all. Even some <em>Bethesda</em> games, like <em>The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind</em> and <em>The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion</em> go this route, as well as Rockstar’s <em>Grand Theft Auto</em> titles. This helps preserve immersion, a bit, because the immersion-breaking part (the fact that there are no children visible in these worlds) is front-loaded. It might be something you realize and then dismiss as strange, but it is not as present in the real-time gameplay experience as attacking a child and having them be invincible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5ska-erO8Te2rIJGC04-eg.avif" /><figcaption>Honestly, it’s probably for the best that there are no children in Oblivion if they would look like this.</figcaption></figure><p>This seems like it may be an irresolvable tension. If a game developer is creating an open-world game that is meant to represent a real society, even a fantasy society, if that world is meant to be at all analogous to ours and feature biological entities that reproduce sexually, then children would be a part of that world. But in giving players freedom to act against NPCs in that world, the developer must lessen immersion in one of two ways if they do not wish to depict children being killed: Leave them out, or make them invincible. For the time being, let’s set this aside. We will return to it later when we discuss the history of children in games.</p><p>Onto the Freedom Gamers.</p><p>The Freedom Gamers argue that it is an infringement on player freedom to disallow a game’s systems from applying to things it should obviously apply to. “Player freedom” is a difficult concept to discuss, partially because it’s so slippery. Pinning down what any individual person means by “player freedom” or “player agency” in videogames (and the terms are often used interchangeably) is difficult, so agreeing on a standard definition proves nearly impossible. For our purposes here, “player freedom” will refer simply to the player’s ability to take a variety of mechanical and narrative approaches to solving the problems that a game presents. “Immersive Sim” games like <em>Deus Ex</em> and <em>Prey</em> (2017) feature a high amount of player freedom, while games like <em>The Last of Us</em> feature a much lower amount of player freedom.</p><p>It should be said, rather than just implied, that calls for the privileging of player freedom often arise in opposition to mechanical morality. Similar to the experience of the Immersion Gamers, there is a strong reaction by Freedom Gamers against being told “no” for no other reason than that they are being told “no.” Sometimes when Gamers discuss the matter of player agency in online forums, they are not referring to the freedom <em>to act</em>, but freedom <em>from judgment</em>. There is a prevailing sense on some forum posts that Freedom Gamers feel that they are being judged for their desires and resent that fact.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S61snvyltDAht_p6DRA4dQ.png" /><figcaption>Yeah, like that.</figcaption></figure><p>But even despite this, there may be legitimate criticisms to be levied at developers, depending on the degree to which the presence of mechanical morality restricts a player’s agency. Imagine someone playing <em>Fallout 3</em> is roleplaying as a psychopath who, when asked to do quests on people’s behalf, shoots them with a gun for being impertinent. When they come upon Little Lamplight, a cave society inhabited exclusively by children, their go-to strategy will fail them. The children of Little Lamplight cannot be killed, and thus the player’s preferred problem-solving tool has been taken off the table and they are forced to do something they don’t want to do in the middle of a play experience that, for them, could be all about feeling powerful and having agency.</p><p>There has been much spilled ink on how videogames often serve as fantasies of power and agency for people who, especially under a capitalist system, have had nearly all their power and agency ground away to nothing. Some people use videogames as escapism, or as the adult version of having their He-Man action figure beat up their Vegeta action figure. This is not an illegitimate way to engage with games, but the desire for this unfettered freedom, either from consequence or judgment, is incompatible with the concept of mechanical morality.</p><p>So what’s going on here? Is this fair? Do game developers have any obligation to create an internally consistent world that always follows the rules of realism and believability that they themselves set down? Need they honor the twin gods of immersion and player freedom?</p><p>Again, we might be able to find some help in answering these questions by turning to the history of children in videogames. I’ve put it off long enough, so let’s dive in.</p><p>Children have essentially always been in videogames. We can roll it back to 1996 for <em>Pokemon Red/Green</em>, in which your character is ten years old, to 1994 for <em>Earthbound</em>, in which you play as children who have to go on a quest to save the world (and beat up some other children to boot), to 1990 for id Software’s <em>Commander Keen</em> games or a year earlier for <em>A Boy and His Blob</em>. And in many of these games, children are in peril; they fight, get attacked, and “die” (or at least get a Game Over) with plenty of frequency. As I mentioned, there are kids who are enemies in <em>Earthbound</em>, though in that game you don’t “kill” your enemies, you just beat them up until whatever force is brainwashing them goes away and they “return to normal.” There are even more modern examples where you play as children in horror games, like <em>Among the Sleep</em> and <em>Little Nightmares</em>, and some that can be quite disturbing, like <em>The Binding of Isaac</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/256/1*qhri81oM29LtmB29UN6cGw.png" /><figcaption>A “Cave Boy” enemy in Earthbound</figcaption></figure><p>But what do all of these games have in common? Well, you play <em>as</em> the child. They are the protagonist. They fit fairly neatly into a familiar genre of dark adventure films and novels in which child protagonists are placed in peril. Structuring the child as the protagonist makes them easy to root for, and so even though the images may be frightening or disturbing in some way, the audience understands that harm befalling the child is bad.</p><p>So the real problem comes when children are NPCs in videogames and the player character isn’t. And it’s only <em>really</em> a potential problem when the children are placed in the same position that other NPCs are in respect to the player: The position of objects upon which the player is meant to inflict their will. Those are the types of games we are going to examine, and they are most common in the genre of western computer role playing games (or CRPGs) like <em>Fallout</em> and <em>Baldur’s Gate</em>.</p><p>If you’ve only come to the <em>Fallout</em> franchise since Bethesda’s tenure (beginning with <em>Fallout 3</em>) you might not realize that not only are there children in <em>Fallout</em> and <em>Fallout 2</em>, but you can attack and kill them. Doing so more than, say, once, will earn you a special character reputation called Childkiller. This reputation makes it so that anytime you talk to an NPC, good or evil, their attitude toward you will be 30 points lower than if you didn’t have Childkiller, which can be genuinely devastating to a playthrough. It also spawns bounty hunters who hunt you in the overworld map, adding to your potential pool of difficult encounters. Basically, if you behave in a way that is antisocial, you will be treated like an antisocial freak.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/763/1*wPnQPE9blQDdl0X4EiK63Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rejected image for the Childkiller trait for Fallout 2 (yes, really)</figcaption></figure><p>We have a potential solution to the problems of Immersion and Freedom, here, don’t we? Allow the player to kill children, but punish them for it in a way that makes sense in the world of the game. We already have games in which players are punished for crimes by being attacked or arrested, so why should that structure fail when it comes to this specific act? Well, here is where our story runs aground in reality.</p><p>In many places in Europe, including Germany, children had to be removed entirely from <em>Fallout</em> and <em>Fallout 2</em> in order for the games to be sold there at all. Regardless of what any one individual might think, there is a clear difference in the minds of policy-makers (and I would argue most people) between killing an adult and killing a child, even in a videogame. We cannot ignore the fact that for some game developers this is not an issue of morality, immersion, or player freedom at all. It’s a matter of money.</p><p>But why should these boards and legislatures care? Why should <em>anyone</em> care? Videogames are, as many, <em>many</em> gamers are quick to point out, not real. They are entirely fictional. Does it make any kind of philosophical sense to make moral judgments about their content?</p><p>Videogames are, as I’m sure you’re aware, interactive. The simplest way to define this I’ve found comes from philosopher Dominic Lopes’ book <a href="https://www.routledge.com/A-Philosophy-of-Computer-Art/Lopes/p/book/9780415547628?srsltid=AfmBOooStiaclkz3ryCjT0JbrLn9W5KGVuGZXH0xTF15rfwxkycJCP9p"><em>A Philosophy of Computer Art</em></a>: “a work of art is interactive just in case it prescribes that the actions of its users help generate its display.” Simple enough to grasp. You, the player, help generate the content in a game. There is no chance that, while watching the first episode of the <em>Fallout</em> TV show, you will see Walton Goggins’ character shoot a little girl. But there is <em>some</em> chance, in playing <em>Fallout</em>, that you <em>will</em> see someone shoot a little girl (and if you do, that someone will probably be you). So the exact level of heinous shit in the game is often up to the player.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lwFtrd3seb5AM2vYQPnoOg.avif" /><figcaption>Probably not pointing his gun at a little girl.</figcaption></figure><p>This interactivity is the reason for so much of the cultural outcry surrounding videogames over the years, as it leads to several of what philosophers like to call “special moral problems.” To fully unravel the sense in which the player’s actions are “real” is beyond the scope of what I’m doing here, but if you’re interested in a full treatment, you can read <a href="https://philarchive.org/rec/CARMAM-14">this article that I co-wrote</a>. The short version is that videogames are “self-involving interactive fictions,” or SIIFs, which is a term that comes from philosophers Jon Robson and Aaron Meskin. All this means is that videogames make certain things true about their player in the playing of them; when you say “I just shot that guy,” you didn’t, really, because you’re sitting on your couch or at your desk pressing buttons on a controller, but there is still a sense in which that phrase is true. It is generally accepted that this form of first-person self-description is normal and acceptable when playing a videogame, but of course, it gives rise to concerns when a gamer can accurately say things like “I just killed that kid.”</p><p>This is not <em>literally</em> true, but in the words of philosopher Kendall Walton, it is <em>fictionally</em> true. We are meant to believe it to be true in the world of the game and, because videogames are SIIFs, it becomes fictionally true of us as players as well. The gap between the real world and the fictional world of a videogame is, in some sense, narrower than the gap between the real world and the fictional world of, say, a film. Yes, I did not kill a <em>real</em> child, but that does not make the statement untrue.</p><p>How seriously to take this is up to each individual person, and clearly many countries in the world have found videogames’ special interactive relationship concerning when it comes to violence. It is worth taking these concerns seriously, up to a point, because art does not exist in a social vacuum. It represents, reinforces, and subverts dominant cultural narratives through its very construction. Art <em>is</em> real, even if the things that it depicts aren’t. And in the special case of videogames, this does not only come down to what they <em>show</em>, but what they <em>allow</em>.</p><p>Let’s bring it back to the matter at hand and return to <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>. It would be immersion-breaking, in a game that prioritizes immersion over many other factors, to disallow the killing of children when adults can be killed just fine. Hence, you can kill the goblin children. The goblin children are mean and cruel and, the greatest sin of all, rude to the player character, so the player may really <em>want</em> to kill them. Hence, you can kill the goblin children. And killing the goblin children must not have raised much of a cultural fuss with ratings boards the world over, or else the player wouldn’t be permitted to do it. The problem has been solved: Larian prioritizes immersion and player freedom in their games and the ratings agencies of the world didn’t care, so it’s fine.</p><p>Hang on, there’s something else written down here in my notes. “You still haven’t explained the tiefling children.” Oh yeah.</p><p>Question: Why can you kill the goblin children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>?</p><p>Answer: Who cares? They’re just goblins.</p><p>Oh, boy. Here we go.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! If you liked this, make sure to go to </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em>my profile </em></a><em>and follow me so you can read Part 4 when it comes out. That’s also where you can find my other work.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=43afdc0813b1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Children in Videogames, Part 2: Skyrim, Fallout 3, and Mechanical Morality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gatherer286/children-in-videogames-part-2-skyrim-fallout-3-and-mechanical-morality-17b20eeaa56a?source=rss-df3bb25947a9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17b20eeaa56a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Logan Taylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Apr 2025 15:54:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-08T15:54:44.960Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PsSApBw24s6qoWBRAoQ1nQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This is Part 2 in a series of articles discussing the presence of children in videogames. You can find Part 1 </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286/children-in-videogames-part-1-why-can-you-kill-the-goblin-children-in-baldurs-gate-3-4489cf3a9182"><em>here</em></a><em>. Content warning: This article discusses violence against children.</em></p><p>Question: Why can you kill the goblin children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>?</p><p>Answer: Because the game was designed that way.</p><p>This seems, on the face of it, like the most sarcastic answer to the question. But if we dig a little deeper, we’ll find that the reasoning underneath this answer leads us to fascinating places.</p><p>At their core, games are pretty much just rules that every player of the game agrees to in order for the game to function. In real life, when a player violates a rule, the other players (or an official referee) can call them out for it, stop the game, and figure out what to do next.</p><p>In videogames, that’s not possible. Instead, because the world of a videogame is usually constructed as a physical place, the rules are enforced by the game itself, typically as a result of the limits of its programming. When you’re playing <em>Call of Duty</em>, no referee tells you that you can’t climb over the easily-traversed barbed wire that blocks off the edges of the level. You just can’t do it.</p><p>Simple enough. We, as players, accept that there are things that are impossible to program. There are limits to how robust a videogame can be. Of course I can’t travel south out of the map in <em>Skyrim</em> and explore the rest of Tamriel. That would be fucking crazy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d0zqWMbgZ1yrU7z95FDEsg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The “You cannot go that way” message in the top left when you hit the edge of the map in Skyrim</figcaption></figure><p>There are also things that seem like they <em>should</em> be possible based on a game’s systems, but aren’t. They are disallowed by the developers. Often, this is still a technical constraint. While it seems possible in the systems of <em>Prey</em> (2017) for me to, say, short-circuit a door’s electronic controls with my stun gun to disable it and prevent an enemy on the other side from following me, I can’t. Again, reasonable. The level of mechanical robustness that would be required to accommodate every player’s wildest ideas would necessitate a level of detail approaching reality.</p><p>And yet, this is <em>exactly</em> the level of mechanical complexity that <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em><strong><em> </em></strong>became well-known for. If you can think of a way to manipulate the game’s systems into allowing something that doesn’t at first seem plausible, if it is <em>possible</em>, then it is likely that you can do it. This level of complexity affords a great deal of freedom to players, but is usually reserved for games with robust, real-time physics and lots of loose objects, like <em>Skyrim</em> (just look at players using the Telekinesis spell to pick up and throw bear traps at enemies in that game).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/703/1*NzLJKKtwLny6K7J8kIZcJg.png" /><figcaption>Nothing to see here, folks</figcaption></figure><p>But <em>Skyrim</em> is a good example of another important concept, what I call “mechanical morality.” Mechanical morality is the idea that something that should theoretically be allowed by a game’s systems is instead disallowed by a behind-the-scenes moral judgment from the developers. In an interview ahead of <em>Fallout 3</em>’s release, Todd Howard fielded the question of whether or not children would be killable in the game, saying, “You will not be able to be a child killer. There are several reasons for this… like we wouldn’t be able to sell the game, anywhere to anyone… We never wanted the game to offer any incentive or desire to be blowing kids away… we just knew it was going to be a big no-no.” After demoing <em>Fallout 3</em> at a press event in 2007, a member of the gaming press asked if the player could kill children in the game. Todd Howard responded with, “Do you want to be able to?” These answers, presumably, also apply to <em>Skyrim</em>’s unkillable children.</p><p>Let’s break this down. In <em>Skyrim</em>, the player has a huge amount of mechanical freedom. They can interact with countless physics objects in the world, including famously putting a basket over an NPC’s head to block their vision and steal their stuff right in front of them. Is that realistic? No. But is it a fun result of a number of complex systems interacting with one another? Definitely.</p><p>But notice I said <em>steal</em> their stuff. Within the world of <em>Skyrim</em>, there is society, government, and laws that the player character can be arrested or attacked for breaking. If you commit theft, assault, or murder, you will be chased by guards and given the opportunity to either pay off your bounty in gold (the amount of which depends on the number and severity of crimes committed), go to jail and serve your sentence (which incurs mechanical penalties to the amount of experience points your character has accumulated), or fight back and risk being killed outright. This is a construction that makes intuitive sense based on the shared real-world history of humanity and of societies with their own laws and customs, all of which have/had behaviors that they would simply not tolerate. It is the “reality” of the fictional world of <em>Skyrim</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/775/1*01hITUU_qesWipQ3uMK4IA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dealing with the fuzz in Skyrim</figcaption></figure><p>But we can also examine this construction from the perspective of mechanical game design. Game design is most often about incentivizing certain behaviors and punishing others in order to guide players to strategies and decision-making patterns. This is a gross oversimplification, of course, but it will serve our purposes here. Imagine a game in which a player must try to score as many points as possible by destroying small tokens of two different colors, say, blue and green. The blue tokens are worth 1 point and the green tokens are worth 5 points. What will the player’s priority be? Presumably, they would want to design a strategy that allows them to destroy as many green tokens as possible.</p><p>Now, suppose that instead of destroying tokens, the players are killing humanoid figures. Instead of blue tokens we have representations of men, and instead of green tokens we have representations of women. The mechanical reality of the game has not changed in any appreciable way (destroy more of one thing than the other to win), but the whole affair seems to take on a moral quality. In the fiction of the game, the goal is no longer to destroy as many green tokens as possible, but to kill as many women (or virtual representations of women) as possible.</p><p>There are two ways to react to this, and both are quite common: (1) Who cares? None of this is real. There is no difference between virtual men and virtual women and none of them are alive, so killing them has no moral value at all, or (2) Incentivizing players of games to commit harm (even virtual harm) against virtual beings that are representations of real-world groups or individuals is (in some way too complex to dig all the way into here) bad.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S61snvyltDAht_p6DRA4dQ.png" /><figcaption>A very sane example of viewpoint number 1</figcaption></figure><p>I, personally, am in the second camp, but I’ll explore that more in a future part of this series. What’s important is that the developers of these games are often in that camp as well. This is where we get Todd Howard’s straightforward answers to the question of why children aren’t killable in <em>Fallout 3</em>: Uh, they just aren’t, bro. We didn’t even want that. That’s whack.</p><p>This leads to the most extreme form of mechanical morality: Total disallowment. There are things that the developers simply do not want to depict in their games, or at the very least want to discourage, so it doesn’t matter how much the mechanics of the game should make it possible. This is the part of the <em>Call of Duty: Modern Warfare</em> mission “Clean House” where if you shoot an innocent woman and her baby, you are forced to restart from a checkpoint, and if you do it enough times, the game kicks you back to the main menu, asking, “Are you serious?” This is “desynchronizing” in <em>Assassin’s Creed</em> for killing enough civilians, essentially getting a game over for engaging in extreme antisocial behavior. This goes beyond breaking the law in games like <em>Skyrim</em>, which serves as a risk to balance out the mechanical reward of killing everyone you meet in order to take all of their cool stuff and ruin the game’s difficulty curve. The ultimate level of mechanical morality is game developers forbidding certain actions simply because those actions represent behaviors that would be abhorrent in real life.</p><p>As much as some gamers don’t want it to be true, this is the game developers’ right. They do not have to depict anything in their art that they don’t want to.</p><p>So, with this frame in mind: Why can you kill the goblin children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>? Perhaps more relevant to mechanical morality: Why <em>can’t</em> you kill the tiefling children in <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>?</p><p>This is the real crux of the issue. If no children were killable in the game, it could be filed under the same category as <em>Skyrim</em> and <em>Fallout 3</em>, conforming to the conventions that Bethesda established nearly 20 years ago. The reasons why a developer might not want the player to be able to kill <em>any</em> children are, on the face of them, obvious. Depictions of dead bodies are upsetting, but most cultures rightfully view the deaths of children as <em>more</em> upsetting, <em>more</em> tragic, due in part to their perceived innocence and inherent vulnerability. There are many societal mechanisms oriented around protecting and providing for children. Todd Howard has outright admitted that these are the reasons motivating <em>Fallout 3</em>’s system of mechanical morality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*o1ezM88_N_W4DV4vWcOR-Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>A quest in Ghost of Tsushima in which you track down a man’s missing family and find his dead wife, but only a toy to represent the dead child</figcaption></figure><p>But if you can kill some children and not others, the equation changes. Larian, the developers of <em>Baldur’s Gate 3</em>, seem to not want to depict the player attacking and killing tiefling children. This sems unusual; nearly every side quest and secondary story in the game can be ruined by a player’s decision to kill certain characters, and everyone else in the tiefling grove is able to be killed by the player. The tiefling children <em>are</em> able to die, and in fact <em>do</em> die if the player chooses to raid the druid grove where the tieflings are sheltered. They are just killed offscreen. This embargo on personal violence against them is not born out of a desire to preserve narrative continuity or a sense of cohesive worldbuilding; the narrative continuity is clearly unimportant and it actually damages worldbuilding cohesion to have this obviously artificial limitation placed on the player. It reveals the artifice behind the scenes of the game.</p><p>On the other hand, the player is mechanically incentivized to kill the goblin children in the scene with the caged Halsin. The encounter becomes more difficult if they are allowed to escape. If the player knocks them unconscious, Halsin will kill them. The game seems determined to have the player, or someone allied with the player, kill them onscreen.</p><p>So, in examining the question in the frame of mechanical morality, we have our answer: Because it would be, in some way perhaps only available in the minds of the developers at Larian, especially distasteful to allow the player to attack and kill tiefling children onscreen but not goblin children. Because as soon as games depict situations that are analogous to real life, mechanics take on an inherent morality, and Larian decided to establish a system of mechanical morality in which killing goblin children and killing tiefling children have different weights and values. The mechanics tell the story by their mere facts: Killing goblin children is not bad, and killing tiefling children is.</p><p>But there is more to this story, and to get to it, we will need to discuss that most elusive and unsightly beast: player agency.</p><p><em>Continued in Part 3. If you liked reading this, click </em><a href="https://medium.com/@gatherer286"><em>here</em></a><em> to check out some of my other work and follow me to keep up with the series.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17b20eeaa56a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>