<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@gendercc?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 01:16:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@gendercc/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Map of false solutions in Latin America and the Caribbean]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/the-map-of-false-solutions-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean-caa6139308dd?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/caa6139308dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-6]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[false-solution]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Nov 2026 06:16:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-14T06:54:56.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This contribution is authored by members of the Critical Geography Collective of Ecuador: Melissa Moreano Venegas, Amanda Yépez, Mónica Brito, Karolien van Teijlingen, Humberto Freire, Daniela Escobar, Diana Vela Almeida.</em></p><p>Since 2021, the <a href="https://plataformajusticiaclimatica.org/">Latin American and Caribbean Platform for Climate Justice</a> (PLAC-JC) and the <a href="https://demandclimatejustice.org/">Global Campaign to Demand Climate Justice</a> (DCJ) have been building <a href="https://www.mapafalsassoluciones.com/articulos/guia-de-metodologias-de-educacion-popular-para-la-justicia-climatica/">educational materials</a> (in various languages) on false solutions to climate change. One the materials is an <a href="https://www.mapafalsassoluciones.com/">interactive map</a> and the associated database of false solutions projects (only in Spanish) designed and maintained by the <a href="https://geografiacriticaecuador.org/">Critical Geography Collective of Ecuador</a>.</p><p>Last September 30th we hosted a webinar to present this initiative with the support of Not without us! project. You can find the recording <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1VtaSOwv9Cp8OOZcVt5pjBzvYH7wTs2gL/view">here </a>(only in Spanish for now. We are working on the Portuguese and English versions).</p><p>But what exactly are false solutions to climate change, and why map them?</p><p>Firstly, we defined several criteria for defining a false solution to climate change, which aid for investigating how an intervention works and what it causes. We map them because we acknowledge the power of a map to condense vast amounts of information into a single image or, when interactive, a single tool. Also, because this information can subsequently be downloaded and cross-referenced for deeper analysis. And because we love maps! The criteria are not a checklist that every project or initiative must meet, but a guidance. Let’s review them:</p><p>1- For mapping false solutions, we need them to be territorialized: they occupy a place. A location reveals who participates, where funding comes from, and whether historically marginalized communities, and their land uses, rights, and relationships with ecosystems, are affected.</p><p>2- They maintain the status quo and concentrate power and wealth. An initiative may seem novel and ambitious yet preserve the structure of domination that creates “winners” and “losers.” If elites keep the decisions and profits while local communities bear the consequences, inequalities are likely reproduced.</p><p>3- They are techno-optimist: excessive faith that innovation alone will solve the problem, ignoring the material conditions that reproduce inequality. Focusing on the device or market while overlooking who controls the process and who is affected hides essential dimensions of the crisis.</p><p>4- They are driven mainly by corporations and/or financial institutions. Their presence alone does not make a project a false solution, but their interests, responsibilities, and influence over design and execution should be investigated.</p><p>5- The provoke socio-ecological impacts: large-scale emission reductions, mining of “critical” minerals” or adaptation projects should not be assessed without considering local harm they may cause.</p><p>6- They offset without effective reduction. Offsets can sustain emitting activities while declaring their impacts neutralized through credits. The central question is whether the activity truly cuts emissions at the source or shifts responsibility to other territories and projects.</p><p>Together, these criteria offer a political and territorial lens. They ask not only whether a solution looks ecological, but whether it transforms the structural causes of the problem or merely contributes to rights violations and the concentration of decision-making power.</p><h3><strong>Findings up to 2026</strong></h3><p><strong><em>Geographic and temporal scope</em></strong></p><p>The database records 219 projects in 26 countries or territories. It is not an exhaustive inventory. It draws on reports from member organizations of PLAC-JC and DCJ, and it serves to recognize patterns, not to measure the region in absolute terms. Ecuador (37 cases), Chile (32) and Peru (31) concentrate 100 cases, followed by Brazil and Honduras (14 each) and Guatemala (13). These figures reflect documentation capacity. Fewer records do not mean fewer projects or lesser impacts.</p><p>Most cases date from as recent as 2010. This suggests consolidation, not a passing wave. Projects accumulate, diversify and remain active amid expanding climate policy and new financial mechanisms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/683/1*aWVc54VkyfVT9KzEaFRAiw.png" /></figure><p>Carbon and conservation projects are the largest category (99), followed by “green” energy (85). Adaptation (17), mining or inputs (16) and geoengineering (2) complete the picture, so the phenomenon spans many sectors. A sector label alone cannot determine whether an intervention is a false solution. Financing, design and consequences must be examined.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/772/1*P1-TLer544z8afq-N8wmLw.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>A public-private financing architecture</em></strong></p><p>Funding is a network of public and private actors. Private funds appear in 168 cases (almost three in four), international financial institutions in 54, public funds in 50, bilateral financing in 30, multilateral financing in 27, the UN system in 17 and NGOs or conservation bodies in 15. These categories overlap.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/851/1*bGVuAwtYkQB27-yeMrrQSQ.png" /></figure><p>Expansion is therefore neither simple privatization nor isolated state policy. It is an “institutional buffet” of companies, states, banks, carbon funds and multilateral bodies, one that materializes in real forests, watersheds, mining zones and coasts.</p><p><strong>It remains to be explored whether, within this framework, the governments of the Global South possess any decision-making power vis-à-vis corporate power.</strong> Responsibility depends not only on who owns a project but on who provides credit, assumes risk, sets rules and profits. When objectives, indicators or contracts are defined outside the territory, communities have limited capacity to decide.</p><p><strong><em>Transnational climate capital and north-south links</em></strong></p><p>Of 148 cases with documented origin, 117 involve identifiable foreign participation (98 foreign, 19 mixed). Only 17 are national and 13 international or supranational. Projects operate locally while capital and decisions are spread across countries, which complicates accountability.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/670/1*AvRQsBmINRQRR3jE5VQcpw.png" /></figure><p>Europe is slinked to 59 projects, the United States and Canada together to 58 (48 only the US), and Latin America and the Caribbean in 41 <strong>(mainly public investments??).</strong> Within Europe, Germany and Spain are linked to 12 cases each, and Norway, France and Switzerland to 8. The US is especially tied to Ecuador, Guatemala, Peru, Panama and Brazil. The US, Germany and Norway lean toward carbon and conservation, Spain, Chile and China toward “green” energy, and Canada toward mining and transition inputs.</p><p>It remains unclear whether <strong>the region is merely a passive recipient</strong>, as well as the question of how decision-making power and benefits are distributed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/748/1*PoAB3M74oa6tbZBz3ywBSw.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Territory, use rights and resistance</em></strong></p><p>As the “solutions” increase, so does the resistance and contestation to them. The database reports 110 cases of some type of resistance, showing that communities organize against changes in land use, limits on rights or unjust distribution of benefits. Land use rights are central because community ties to territory exceed formal property, and interventions can affect collective uses and traditional practices even without displacement.</p><p>Indigenous peoples (129 cases) and peasants (105) most often bear territorial costs, followed by urban neighbourhoods (47), local governments (32), fishers (31), landless peasants (29) and informal workers (14). Benefits may be counted nationally and internationally, while costs fall on those who live in daily contact with land, water and forests.</p><p>This is a question of justice: it matters who receives the benefits and who absorbs the harms. It also challenges simplified ideas of “public interest,” since a policy may benefit the global climate while producing highly unequal local effects.</p><h3><strong>False solutions, genuine climate concern and territorial power</strong></h3><p>The conclusion holds that genuine climate concern can become a resource for exploitation when capital appropriates territories to reorganize them and finance technologies, even at the expense of rights. The core issue is territorial governance, not technology.</p><p>The findings fall into three dimensions. The first is a repeated regional repertoire of patterns across countries and sectors. The second is transnational climate capital, meaning networks that exceed the receiving state. The third is conflict over territorial autonomy and use. They reinforce one another: shared instruments and funding repeat patterns, transnational capital shapes priorities, and local implementation reorders rights and provokes resistance.</p><p>Climate policy should therefore be judged by the relations it establishes: who defines objectives, who controls resources, who bears risks, and how communities can intervene. Not every climate action is false, but some may reproduce the model causing the crisis, hide costs behind a green image, or endanger territorial autonomy.</p><p><strong>Remember…</strong></p><p>False solutions are private or state initiatives that promise to mitigate climate change or support adaptation but in practice sustain and reproduce the very capitalist system that drives the crisis. Instead of challenging capitalism, they give it a green makeover.</p><p>Our critique goes beyond the type of technology. A project may use solar panels, protect forests, or claim to promote adaptation, yet it must be judged by the power relations behind it: who funds it, who decides, who profits, and whose life deteriorates. What matters is who controls the means of production: the technology, the land where the project is located, the financing, and ends up taking all the decisions. And those relations are usually gendered.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=caa6139308dd" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/the-map-of-false-solutions-in-latin-america-and-the-caribbean-caa6139308dd">The Map of false solutions in Latin America and the Caribbean</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Not Without Us! Project Journey Since 2017: Bridging Communities and Global Climate Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/my-not-without-us-project-journey-since-2017-bridging-communities-and-global-climate-politics-1022e9c3c9f8?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1022e9c3c9f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unfccc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 09:23:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-04T09:23:15.172Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>By Ndivile Gugushe</strong></p><p><strong><em>Between hope, frustration and the unfinished struggle for climate justice</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="circle of people during a workshop" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*jX2A4YHtoDV0nhOGRmi5RQ.png" /></figure><p>Since its inception in 2017, the <em>Not Without Us!</em> project has sought to advance gender justice in international climate policy and local climate action. My journey with the project has been bitter-sweet marked by learning, growth, solidarity and empowerment, but also by frustration at the persistent gap between international climate commitments and the lived realities of the communities we represent.</p><p>Over the years, I have deepened my understanding of international climate negotiations and strengthened my skills in advocacy, policy analysis, facilitation, training and movement building. The project has enabled me to build relationships and partnerships while connecting local struggles with global climate justice movements. One of its most valuable contributions has been the opportunity to translate complex international policy discussions into knowledge that communities can understand and use, while bringing their experiences, priorities and demands into global decision-making spaces.</p><p>This knowledge exchange must work both ways. Communities are not merely recipients of information; they possess valuable lived experiences, Indigenous and local knowledge, and practical solutions that should shape climate policy. Bridging communities and the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) must therefore go beyond representation. It must challenge unequal power relations, ensure community priorities influence decisions and strengthen people’s ability to hold governments accountable.</p><p>Yet the other side of this journey is difficult to reconcile. Upon participating in negotiations and advocating for climate justice, I often return to communities without tangible results to show for the promises made. People continue to experience climate impacts that threaten their livelihoods, food security, water access and well-being. They face losses that extend beyond financial calculations, including homes, ancestral lands, cultural heritage, ecosystems and, sometimes, loved ones.</p><p>For developing countries with limited resources and inadequate social protection, these impacts deepen poverty and inequality and undermine progress in health, education and development. The contradiction is clear: while international negotiations produce declarations, frameworks and mechanisms, communities continue to bear the consequences of a crisis they have contributed comparatively little to causing.</p><p>This raises a difficult but necessary question: <strong><em>What is the value of our participation in global climate processes if the communities we represent continue to suffer while promises remain unfulfilled?</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="Ndivile giving a workshop" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*Ra2m841bv-RZt57iM2OxzQ.png" /></figure><p>This is not a rejection of international advocacy. The UNFCCC and the Paris Agreement remain important platforms for cooperation and accountability. However, their credibility depends on implementation, adequate climate finance and meaningful support for developing countries. Ambitious commitments mean little if political and economic interests repeatedly delay the urgent action required. The distance between global promises and local realities continues to raise questions about political will and the economic systems that place profit and growth above human and ecological well-being.</p><p>My experience with <em>Not Without Us!</em> has reinforced my belief that participation alone cannot deliver climate justice. We need meaningful pathways through which community priorities shape policy; resources reach local actors and institutions are held accountable for their commitments. This requires sustained investment in grassroots organising, feminist leadership, community knowledge and movement building. Climate finance must be adequate, predictable, accessible and provided without adding unsustainable debt burdens, particularly for women-led organisations and community initiatives. Adaptation and resilience must also be rooted in local realities and address the structural inequalities that deepen vulnerability.</p><p>We must also question the economic assumptions underpinning climate action. Can a system that prioritises endless accumulation, competition and profit deliver the rapid and equitable transformation needed to protect people and the planet? Incremental reforms have value, but they may not be enough if the structures that reproduce inequality and ecological destruction remain unchanged.</p><p>Perhaps what is needed is a deeper social transformation — one that redefines our values, power relations and economic priorities. Such transformation must place care, solidarity, ecological integrity and human dignity at its centre. It must be democratic, inclusive and driven by communities themselves, connecting local struggles to broader movements capable of challenging injustice and advancing viable alternatives.</p><p>Looking back to 2017, I recognise how much this journey has contributed to my personal and professional growth. I remain committed to learning, sharing knowledge, building partnerships and ensuring that marginalised voices are heard. At the same time, I carry the discomfort of knowing that our efforts have yet to produce the scale of change communities urgently need. Rather than allowing this frustration to become discouragement, we must use it to question existing approaches and strengthen our collective struggle.</p><p>The future of <em>Not Without Us!</em> must therefore be about more than preserving knowledge or maintaining participation in international negotiations. It must ensure that knowledge travels, communities gain power, advocacy leads to material change, and global commitments translate into safer livelihoods, stronger resilience and greater equality.</p><p>Ultimately, success should not be measured only by our presence in negotiation rooms, the interventions we deliver or the networks we build. It should be measured by whether our work contributes to a more just future for the communities whose struggles give meaning to it.</p><figure><img alt="8 people in front of the venue of SB64 in Bonn" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*SB7Io0Apk7MxkB7Is1Lwkw.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>The question is no longer whether communities deserve to be heard, but whether the global systems making decisions in their name are prepared to act on what they have heard.</em></strong></p><p>I remain committed to this journey because silence, exclusion and acceptance of the status quo are not options. But commitment must go hand in hand with honesty, accountability and stronger movements capable of challenging structural injustice and turning the promise of climate justice into reality.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1022e9c3c9f8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/my-not-without-us-project-journey-since-2017-bridging-communities-and-global-climate-politics-1022e9c3c9f8">My Not Without Us! Project Journey Since 2017: Bridging Communities and Global Climate Politics</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Green Transition Is Becoming a Security Project]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/the-green-transition-is-becoming-a-security-project-217fa84d004f?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/217fa84d004f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[energy-transition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-litigation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[just-transition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Aug 2026 12:17:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-11T12:19:13.685Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>What years of climate litigation in Indonesia taught me about democracy, militarisation, and justice.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b29oXZcdYpI0XGrmTO3flg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>by Renie Aryandani*</em></p><p>The first time I challenged Indonesia’s national electricity plan in court, I thought the case would be about energy. I expected to spend months debating coal phase-out timelines, renewable energy targets, emissions trajectories, and legal obligations under climate commitments. As an environmental lawyer, these were the questions I had prepared myself to answer. Instead, I found myself confronting something much bigger. The deeper question was never energy.</p><p>It was power, not electrical power, but political power.</p><p>Over the past two years, I have come to realise that the greatest challenge to a just energy transition in Indonesia is not only our continued dependence on fossil fuels. It is that the transition is unfolding within an increasingly securitised model of governance.<br>Climate change is not militarising Indonesia. Rather, Indonesia’s expanding security state is reshaping how the country responds to climate change. That distinction matters.</p><p>I have worked on strategic litigation challenging Indonesia’s national electricity planning. These cases question policies that determine how the country will generate electricity for decades to come and whether its transition away from coal will genuinely happen.<br>At first, I believed the greatest obstacle to a just energy transition was political unwillingness. Today, I think the challenge runs deeper. It is about governance. Increasingly, I find myself asking not only whether Indonesia is pursuing a green transition, but also what kind of institutions are carrying it out.</p><p>Across the world, climate change is increasingly discussed through the language of security. Governments speak of energy security, food security, critical mineral security, and climate security. The risks are real. Climate change threatens food production, energy systems, and social stability. But in Indonesia, another shift is unfolding alongside these conversations. The state’s response to multiple national priorities increasingly relies on expanding the role of military institutions in civilian life.<br>The government’s flagship programmes now place military institutions in roles that extend well beyond defence: from territorial development battalions and food production initiatives to environmental governance, forest management, social welfare programmes, state asset recovery, and other strategic national priorities. These initiatives differ in purpose, but together they reveal a broader transformation.</p><p>The military is no longer operating only as a defence institution. It is increasingly becoming an institution of governance. I began to understand what this transformation looked like not from reading government policy, but from accompanying communities to court. One of those communities is Rancapinang, a farming village where residents are challenging the government’s decision to allocate their land for military use. Their lawsuit is not a climate case. It is an administrative law dispute over land rights.<br>Yet spending time with the community changed how I understood climate justice. After court hearings, villagers did not speak about legal doctrines. They spoke about losing farmland, uncertainty over the next planting season, and whether their children would inherit the livelihoods that had sustained generations before them.</p><p><strong>Women worried about something even more immediate.</strong><br>If access to farmland changes, household food production changes. Care work becomes harder. Community support networks become more fragile. The burden of adapting to uncertainty quietly shifts into women’s everyday lives. None of these experiences appear in government planning documents. Yet they are precisely what determine whether development is experienced as justice or dispossession.<br>Moving between courtrooms challenging national electricity planning and villages confronting military expansion, I began noticing an uncomfortable pattern. The issues appeared different. The governance looked remarkably similar. Major decisions were made far from the communities most affected. Participation became procedural rather than meaningful. Urgency justified limited consultation. Implementation mattered more than democratic deliberation.<br>Whether discussing electricity planning, food security, territorial development, or environmental governance, the same question continued to emerge:</p><p><strong>Who gets to participate before decisions are made?</strong><br>This is why I have become increasingly uneasy with the growing popularity of the term climate security. Much of the global conversation asks how climate change threatens national security. My experience has led me to ask the opposite question:</p><p><strong>What happens when national security begins shaping climate governance?</strong><br>What happens when resilience becomes associated with command rather than participation?<br>What happens when urgency becomes a justification for concentrating state power instead of strengthening democratic institutions?<br>These questions matter because climate justice has never been only about replacing fossil fuels with renewable energy. It is about transforming the way decisions are made. A transition cannot be called just if communities remain excluded. It cannot be feminist if women continue bearing the greatest burdens while having the least influence over planning. And it cannot be democratic if participation is treated as an obstacle to implementation.<br>One of the climate cases I worked on was dismissed before the court even examined whether Indonesia’s electricity planning complied with its climate commitments. Legally, we lost, for now. But politically, something important happened. Communities entered spaces where they had long been absent. Government planning became open to public scrutiny. Energy policy was no longer viewed as merely technical; it became visible as a question of democracy. We have appealed the decision and will seek review before Indonesia’s Supreme Court.</p><p>That experience taught me something I did not expect when I first became a climate lawyer. The green transition is not only a technological transformation. It is a political one. As governments accelerate climate action, we should pay as much attention to the institutions implementing the transition as to the transition itself. Because the greatest danger is not simply that the transition will be too slow. It is that the transition will succeed in reducing emissions while simultaneously normalising increasingly militarised forms of governance.<br>A just transition requires more than renewable energy. It requires democratic institutions capable of ensuring that those most affected have the power to shape the future itself. Without that, the transition may become greener. But it will never become just.</p><p><em>*Renie Aryandani is an Indonesian environmental lawyer working at the intersection of climate justice, gender, democracy, and state power. Her work focuses on strategic litigation challenging exclusionary energy governance and supporting communities defending their rights in the face of environmental and development conflicts.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=217fa84d004f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/the-green-transition-is-becoming-a-security-project-217fa84d004f">The Green Transition Is Becoming a Security Project</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conserving forests as global reproductive labour: A radical feminist critique of the Tropical…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/conserving-forests-as-global-reproductive-labour-a-radical-feminist-critique-of-the-tropical-e2b1cc384728?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e2b1cc384728</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminist-critique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tfff]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Jul 2026 16:49:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-21T16:49:49.030Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Conserving forests as global reproductive labour: A radical feminist critique of the Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF)</strong></h3><p>by Melissa Moreano Venegas</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5wIKDGBFQO-wPwXO3Tccag.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>This is the english translation of the article in spanish found </em><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/conservar-los-bosques-como-trabajo-reproductivo-global-una-lectura-feminista-de-la-tropical-forest-adb7caf05e3c"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>The Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF) is presented as “an innovative financing mechanism to incentivize long-term, large-scale forest conservation” (<a href="https://tfff.earth/feedback/">TFFF Concept Note, 2025</a>). The mechanism was introduced by Brazil at COP30 as a novel initiative. First, it was conceived by a country of the Global South. Second, it proposes to mobilize substantial, global, stable, and permanent financing without duplicating existing programs, but rather addressing a key gap in environmental finance: remuneration for the maintenance and restoration of forest cover, still largely absent from the global financial architecture. Third, from the outset it establishes that a significant proportion of the resources will be directed to those who protect and restore forests, particularly Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities (IPLCs). Fourth, unlike REDD+, the TFFF focuses on rewarding forest conservation and recovery without reducing forests to carbon sinks: the mechanism values the entirety of standing tropical rainforests, whether primary, secondary, or under restoration. In what follows, I offer a feminist critique of the mechanism.</p><p><strong>1. The unequal incorporation of reproductive labour into global circuits of capital</strong></p><p>Silvia Federici tells us that capitalism is sustained not only through the theft of workers’ productive labour, but also through the systematic expropriation of reproductive labour: the labour that sustains life, bodies, territories, and the material conditions of existence -the work of feeding, caring for, cleaning, emotionally supporting workers; attending neighborhood or community assemblies; cooking during communal labour; collective caring for children and elders; caring for seeds, water, forests; preserving local knowledge. It is labour that has been historically invisibilized, racialized, and feminized. The TFFF did not “discovered” this labour: it belatedly incorporated it into the global financial architecture without altering the structural power relations that have exploited it freely for centuries.</p><p>But why are initiatives that recognizes the reproductive labour of forests and communities multiplying now? Because, as Nancy Fraser warns us, contemporary capitalism is a regime that systematically externalizes its conditions of possibility -nature, care, reproductive labour- conditions indispensable to its continued functioning, which it exploits to unsustainable limits. To address these crises, capitalism knows no other response than to incorporate them into circuits of value production for accumulation, through conservation payments such as those proposed by the TFFF.</p><p>The mechanism will pay around USD 4 per hectare of conserved forest, adjusted for inflation and depending on deforestation and degradation rates. Previous conservation payment programs have recognized much higher values (Ecuador’s Socio Bosque Program, for example, pays between USD 15 and USD 50 per hectare, an amount that barely competes with cattle ranching in the Amazon). The result is that these payments are unlikely to compete with what global trade pays for beef, minerals, soy, palm oil, and pulp, commodities that are primarily responsible for tropical forest degradation.</p><p>This difference is not technical: it expresses a systematic devaluation of care labour, consistent with capitalism’s patriarchal logic, which does not pay-or pays less for-the labour that sustains life, to the point of producing a new exclusion: the eco-precariat, about which I have previously <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/eco-precariat-reproductive-labour-and-climate-justice-44f052ac9bec">written</a>.</p><p>In addition, the TFFF explicitly acknowledges that if leverage ratios shift or markets fluctuate, per-hectare payments may be temporarily reduced. <em>If the financial situation improves</em>, compensatory payments would then be made. This clause concentrates the entire structural violence of the scheme: financial risk is transferred to those performing reproductive labour, not to those capturing value. In other words, care is paid only if markets allow it. Federici would put it bluntly: capitalism still does not pay for reproduction; it merely subsidizes it when it needs it to survive.</p><p>The TFFF reproduces North-South inequality and persistent coloniality: the benefits are global, but conservation obligations fall locally. It is countries with tropical forests-and within them, Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities-that must guarantee the planet’s ecological reproduction under schemes of monitoring, conditionality, and surveillance: payments are subject to satellite remote sensing systems, global indicators, and severe penalties for deforestation or degradation, even when caused by fires. From a feminist ethics of care, this implies unilateral responsibilization: those with the least control over structural dynamics (markets, extractivism, climate change) assume the greatest financial risks.</p><p><strong>2. Those who design the mechanism define who truly benefits: persitent coloniality and debt</strong></p><p>The TFFF reproduces relations of subordination of the so-called Global South countries to financial structures designed and commanded by the so-called Global North. As mentioned, the mechanism was designed under Brazil’s leadership, but with decisive support from the UK Government (UK PACT), the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, and the PROGREEN alliance. Multiple global NGOs, philanthropic foundations, and international financial actors participated. The resulting structure of the TFFF is a blended finance fund that combines:</p><ol><li>Funds from sovereign states, referred to as “sponsors,” and eventually from philanthropic investors. Approximately USD 25 billion is expected from this so-called “junior debt.”</li><li>Funds from institutional investors (large organizations such as pension funds, insurance companies, or sovereign wealth funds) that invest in specialized financial markets. Up to USD 100 billion is projected in this so-called “senior debt.” <em>Senior</em> means these lenders have priority in repayment if the fund encounters financial problems, above other creditors (such as sponsor countries or forest countries).</li></ol><p>Here is a key point: the initial capital will be gradually repaid over time, generally in regular installments that <em>include interest</em>, after a ten-year grace period. During this first decade, the initial capital is expected to generate income (through investments in various sectors except fossil fuels) to begin repaying lenders. In other words, the TFFF will not receive donations; rather, it is a debt-receiving mechanism whose borrowed funds will be invested to generate returns for sponsors (states of the Global North), lending institutions, and financial markets, which are the primary beneficiaries. The payment hierarchy makes this clear: after ten years, the fund will first repay senior debt, then junior debt, and only afterward, if there is a surplus, will forest incentives be paid to forest countries. The good news is that of that final amount, at least 20% must reach Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities.</p><p>We are witnessing a form of expansion of global financial authority, operating through technical, legal, and seemingly neutral instruments that displace sovereignty from states and territories toward transnational financial circuits. All of this is presented as a mechanism designed from the Global South, yet it reflects a persistent coloniality. Following Tithi Bhattacharya’s assertion that social reproduction is not a separate “sector,” but the material foundation of capitalist production, we can argue that the TFFF converts that reproductive base -the forest, the territory, life- into a source of stability for financial accumulation, guaranteeing return flows to institutional investors. The TFFF internalizes global ecological reproduction within the logic of capital valorization, without altering the absolute priority of payment to markets.</p><p>The mechanism’s financial, rather than socio-ecological justice, orientation is also reflected in its architecture. The TFFF will be legally housed as a Financial Intermediary Fund (FIF) within a Multilateral Development Bank, presumably the World Bank. This bank would act as trustee, secretariat, and coordinator among the mechanism’s various bodies. Here lies a complicated issue: according to the mechanism’s documents, the World Bank will serve as the secretariat accountable to the Facility’s Board of Directors… which is the World Bank itself.</p><p>In sum, the TFFF is presented as a “payment for conservation.” But from a radical feminist framework, the question is different: is this a wage for caring for planetary life, or a disciplinary incentive to secure global financial stability? The amount, the conditionalities, the financial intermediation, and the payment hierarchy suggest the latter. We are not facing a reparation of ecological debt, but its reconfiguration as an investment opportunity.</p><p>The TFFF can be read as an attempt to resolve a structural contradiction of contemporary capitalism: we urgently need to conserve forests, but without relinquishing the primacy of financial capital. The proposed solution is to incorporate conservation into a global trust, managed by the World Bank and bond markets.</p><p>From a feminist perspective, this leaves open questions that cannot be technically resolved:</p><ul><li>Is the historical labour of care by Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities being recognized, or simply integrated into financial accumulation?</li><li>Who controls timelines, risks, and decisions?</li><li>Is this a response to the ecological crisis, or a strategy to stabilize financial capitalism in crisis?</li></ul><p>The TFFF is not simply “good” or “bad.” It is a terrain of struggle. But it can only be transformed if it is analyzed, named, and confronted from a theory that places the reproduction of life, rather than the reproduction of capital, at the center.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e2b1cc384728" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/conserving-forests-as-global-reproductive-labour-a-radical-feminist-critique-of-the-tropical-e2b1cc384728">Conserving forests as global reproductive labour: A radical feminist critique of the Tropical…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conservar los bosques como trabajo reproductivo global: una lectura feminista de la Tropical Forest…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/conservar-los-bosques-como-trabajo-reproductivo-global-una-lectura-feminista-de-la-tropical-forest-adb7caf05e3c?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/adb7caf05e3c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[feminist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tropical-forest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Jul 2026 14:25:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-21T16:50:34.368Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Conservar los bosques como trabajo reproductivo global: una lectura feminista de la Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF)</strong></h3><p>Melissa Moreano Venegas</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5wIKDGBFQO-wPwXO3Tccag.jpeg" /></figure><p>La Tropical Forest Forever Facility (TFFF) se presenta como “un mecanismo de financiación innovador para incentivar la conservación de los bosques a largo plazo y a gran escala” (<a href="https://tfff.earth/es/feedback/">Nota conceptual del TFFF, 2025</a>). El mecanismo fue presentado por Brasil en la COP30 como una iniciativa novedosa. En primer lugar, fue concebida por un país del sur global. En segundo lugar, propone movilizar financiamiento sustancial, global, estable y permanente sin duplicar los programas existentes sino respondiendo a una laguna clave del financiamiento ambiental: la remuneración por el mantenimiento y la restauración de la cobertura forestal, aun ampliamente ausente en la arquitectura financiera mundial. En tercer lugar, establece desde el inicio que una proporción significativa de los recursos se destinará a quienes protegen y restauran los bosques, en particular a los Pueblos Indígenas y las Comunidades Locales (IPLCs). En cuarto lugar, a diferencia de REDD+, el TFFF se centra en recompensar la conservación y la recuperación de los bosques, sin reducirlos a sumideros de carbono: el mecanismo valora el conjunto de los bosques tropicales húmedos en pie, ya sean primarios, secundarios o en proceso de restauración. En lo que sigue, haré una crítica feminista al mecanismo.</p><p><strong>1. La incorporación desigual del trabajo reproductivo de cuidar los bosques en los circuitos globales del capital</strong></p><p>Silvia Federici nos dice que el capitalismo se sostiene en el robo del trabajo productivo de las trabajadoras, pero también en la expropiación sistemática del trabajo reproductivo: aquel que mantiene la vida, los cuerpos, los territorios y las condiciones materiales de existencia, el trabajo de alimentar, cuidar, asear, sostener emocionalmente a lxs trabajadorxs; de asistir a asambleas barriales o comunitarias, cocinar para los trabajos comunitarios, de cuidar colectivamente a niños y ancianos; el trabajo de cuidar las semillas, el agua, los bosques, de preservar el conocimiento local. Es un trabajo históricamente invisibilizado, racializado y feminizado. El TFFF no “descubre” este trabajo: lo incorpora tardíamente a la arquitectura financiera global, sin alterar las relaciones estructurales de poder que lo han explotado gratuitamente durante siglos.</p><p>Pero, ¿por qué ahora se multiplican las iniciativas que proponen reconocer el trabajo reproductivo de bosques y comunidades? Porque, como nos advierte Nancy Fraser, el capitalismo contemporáneo es un régimen que externaliza sistemáticamente sus condiciones de posibilidad, que le son indispensables para seguir funcionando: naturaleza, cuidados, trabajo reproductivo, a los cuales explota hasta límites insostenibles. Para enfrentar esas crisis, el capitalismo no sabe hacer otra cosa que incorporarlos en el circuito de producción de valor para su acumulación, a través de pagos por conservación como el que propone el TFFF.</p><p>El mecanismo pagará a alrededor de 4 USD por hectárea de bosque conservado, ajustados por inflación y en función de la deforestación y la degradación. Programas anteriores de pagos por conservación han reconocido valores mucho mayores (el Programa Socio Bosque en Ecuador, por ejemplo, paga entre 15 USD y 50 USD por hectárea, monto que apenas logra competir con la ganadería de carne en la Amazonía). El resultado es que es probable que esos montos no sean competitivos con los que paga el comercio global de carne, minerales, soya, palma y pulpa de papel, mercancías que son las principales responsables de la degradación de los bosques tropicales.</p><p>Esta diferencia no es técnica: expresa una devaluación sistemática del trabajo de cuidado, coherente con la lógica patriarcal del capitalismo, que no paga o paga menos el trabajo que sostiene la vida, al punto de producir una nueva exclusión, el ecoprecariado, del que ya escribí con <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/eco-precariat-reproductive-labour-and-climate-justice-44f052ac9bec">anterioridad</a>.</p><p>De manera adicional, el TFFF reconoce explícitamente que, si las ratios de apalancamiento se alteran o los mercados fluctúan, los pagos por hectárea podrán reducirse temporalmente. Luego, <em>si mejora la situación financiera</em>, se harían pagos compensatorios. Esta cláusula concentra toda la violencia estructural del esquema: el riesgo financiero se traslada a quienes realizan el trabajo reproductivo, no a quienes capturan el valor. Es decir, el cuidado se paga solo si los mercados lo permiten. Federici lo diría sin rodeos: el capitalismo sigue sin pagar la reproducción; apenas la subsidia cuando la necesita para sobrevivir.</p><p>Aquí TFFF reproduce la desigualdad Norte-Sur y la persistente colonialidad: los beneficios son globales, pero las obligaciones de conservación recaen localmente. Son los países con bosques tropicales y dentro de ellos, los pueblos indígenas y comunidades locales, quienes deben garantizar la reproducción ecológica del planeta, bajo esquemas de monitoreo, condicionalidad y vigilancia: los pagos están sujetos a sistemas de teledetección satelital, indicadores globales y penalizaciones severas por deforestación o degradación, incluso cuando estas son causadas por incendios. Desde una ética feminista del cuidado, esto implica una responsabilización unilateral: quienes menos control tienen sobre las dinámicas estructurales (mercados, extractivismo, cambio climático) asumen los mayores riesgos financieros.</p><p><strong>2. Quien diseña el mecanismo define a quién beneficia realmente: Colonialidad financiera y deuda</strong></p><p>El mecanismo reproduce relaciones de subordinación de los países llamados del Sur global a las estructuras financieras diseñadas y comandadas por el llamado Norte global. Como mencionamos, el TFFF fue diseñado bajo el liderazgo de Brasil, pero con apoyo decisivo del Gobierno del Reino Unido (UK PACT), el Rockefeller Brothers Fund y la alianza PROGREEN. Participaron múltiples ONG globales, fundaciones filantrópicas y actores financieros internacionales. La estructura resultante del TFFF es un fondo de financiamiento mixto (blended finance), que combina:</p><p>1- Fondos que provienen de estados soberanos, llamados “patrocinadores” y, eventualmente, de inversionistas filantrópicos. Se espera obtener alrededor de 25 mil millones USD de esta llamada “deuda junior”.</p><p>2- Fondos de inversionistas institucionales (grandes organizaciones como fondos de pensiones, compañías de seguros o fondos soberanos) que invierten dinero en mercados financieros especializados. Se prevé hasta 100 mil millones USD en esta llamada “deuda senior”. “Senior” significa que estos prestamistas tienen prioridad en el pago si el fondo tuviera problemas financieros, por encima de otros acreedores (como los países patrocinadores o los países con bosque).</p><p>Aquí viene algo clave: el capital inicial será devuelto gradualmente a lo largo del tiempo, generalmente en cuotas regulares, que <em>incluirán intereses</em>,<strong> </strong>tras un período de gracia de diez años. Durante esta primera década se espera que el capital inicial y genere ingresos (gracias a inversiones diversos sectores excepto en combustibles fósiles) para comenzar a devolver el dinero a los prestamistas. En otras palabras, el TFFF no recibirá donaciones, sino que es un mecanismo de recepción de préstamos (deuda) que será invertida para generar ganancias para los patrocinadores (estados del Norte Global), las instituciones prestamistas y los mercados financieros, que son los primeros beneficiarios. La jerarquía de pagos lo deja claro: al cabo de los 10 años, el fondo pagará primero la deuda senior, luego pagará la deuda junior y solo después, si hay excedente, se pagarán los incentivos forestales a los países con bosques. La buena noticia es que, de ese último monto, al menos un 20% deberá llegar a los Pueblos indígenas y comunidades locales.</p><p>Estamos ante una forma de expansión de la autoridad financiera global, que opera mediante instrumentos técnicos, jurídicos y aparentemente neutrales, pero que desplazan soberanía desde los Estados y los territorios hacia circuitos financieros transnacionales. Todo ello mientras se presenta como un mecanismo diseñado desde el Sur global pero que refleja una persistente colonialidad. Siguiendo a Tithi Bhattacharya y su afirmación de que la reproducción social no es un “sector” separado, sino el fundamento material de la producción capitalista, podemos argumentar que el TFFF convierte esa base reproductiva -el bosque, el territorio, la vida- en una fuente de estabilidad para la acumulación financiera, garantizando flujos de retorno a inversionistas institucionales. El TFFF internaliza la reproducción ecológica global dentro de la lógica de valorización del capital, sin alterar la prioridad absoluta del pago a los mercados.</p><p>La orientación financiera -y no de justicia socioecológica- del mecanismo se plasma también en su arquitectura. El TFFF se alojará jurídicamente como un Fondo Intermedio Financiero (FIF) dentro de un Banco Multilateral de Desarrollo, previsiblemente el Banco Mundial. Este banco actuaría como fiduciario, secretariado y coordinador entre las distintas instancias del mecanismo. Aquí viene la cuestión complicada: según los documentos del mecanismo, el Banco Mundial será el secretariado que debe rendir cuentas al Consejo de Administración de la Facility que es… el mismo Banco Mundial.</p><p>En suma, el TFFF se presenta como un “pago por conservación”. Pero desde un marco feminista radical, la pregunta es otra: ¿esto es un salario por el cuidado de la vida planetaria, o un incentivo disciplinario para asegurar estabilidad financiera global? El monto, la condicionalidad, la intermediación financiera y la jerarquía de pagos sugieren lo segundo. No estamos ante una reparación de la deuda ecológica, sino ante su reconfiguración como oportunidad de inversión.</p><p>El TFFF puede ser leído como un intento de resolver una contradicción estructural del capitalismo contemporáneo: necesitamos urgentemente conservar los bosques, pero sin renunciar a la primacía del capital financiero. La solución propuesta es incorporar la conservación dentro de un fideicomiso global, gestionado por el Banco Mundial y los mercados de bonos.</p><p>Desde una perspectiva feminista, esto deja abiertas preguntas que no pueden clausurarse técnicamente:</p><p>· ¿Se está reconociendo el trabajo histórico de cuidado de los pueblos indígenas y comunidades locales, o simplemente se lo está integrando a la acumulación financiera?</p><p>· ¿Quién controla los tiempos, los riesgos y las decisiones?</p><p>· ¿Es esto una respuesta a la crisis ecológica, o una estrategia para estabilizar el capitalismo financiero en crisis?</p><p>El TFFF no es simplemente “bueno” o “malo”. Es un campo de disputa. Pero solo podrá ser transformado si se lo analiza, nombra y confronta desde una teoría que ponga en el centro la reproducción de la vida, y no la reproducción del capital.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=adb7caf05e3c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/conservar-los-bosques-como-trabajo-reproductivo-global-una-lectura-feminista-de-la-tropical-forest-adb7caf05e3c">Conservar los bosques como trabajo reproductivo global: una lectura feminista de la Tropical Forest…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Energy Planning Without Us:
Why Legal Challenges Matter for Gender and Climate Justice]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/energy-planning-without-us-why-legal-challenges-matter-for-gender-and-climate-justice-d695c48d0686?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d695c48d0686</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[just-transition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy-justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Jul 2026 14:13:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-20T14:13:38.852Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>by Renie Aryandani*</p><p>Energy planning is often treated as a technical exercise — numbers, projections, and policy targets discussed behind closed doors. Documents such as national electricity plans are presented as neutral roadmaps, shaped by experts and institutions presumed to act in the public interest. But in reality, these plans determine whose lands are used, whose livelihoods are disrupted, and whose voices are excluded.<br>As a lawyer involved in litigation challenging energy planning in Indonesia, I have followed closely how these decisions are defended in court. What becomes clear is that documents often described as “non-binding” or “merely indicative” are, in practice, used to justify concrete actions: the approval of projects, the allocation of resources, and the continuation of energy pathways that have long-term social and environmental consequences.<br>This raises a fundamental question: if these planning documents shape real decisions, why are they so difficult to challenge?<br>Legal systems, including in Indonesia, have traditionally drawn a line between “decisions” and “policies.” Only the former — concrete, individual, and final — are typically open to judicial review. Planning documents, by contrast, are often placed in a grey area, considered too abstract or too early in the decision-making chain to be tested in court.<br>However, this distinction no longer reflects reality. Energy planning is not a neutral or preliminary step; it is where key choices are made. It is where governments decide which energy sources to prioritize, which regions will host infrastructure, and how risks and benefits will be distributed. By the time a “final” decision is issued, many of these choices are already locked in.<br>From a climate justice perspective, this matters deeply. Across different contexts, energy projects disproportionately affect communities that are already marginalized. Women, in particular, often bear the indirect impacts of energy development — through displacement, loss of access to natural resources, and increased care burdens — while remaining excluded from formal decision-making processes.<br>Yet their absence is not accidental; it is structured into how planning itself is conducted. Public participation mechanisms, when they exist, are frequently procedural rather than meaningful. Technical language, limited access to information, and unequal power dynamics all contribute to silencing those most affected.<br>This is why legal challenges to energy planning are not merely technical disputes — they are part of a broader struggle for inclusion and accountability.<br>Courts can play a crucial role in this process. By recognizing that planning documents have real legal and social consequences, they can open space for earlier intervention — before projects are approved and impacts become irreversible. Judicial review, in this sense, becomes not only a tool to correct administrative errors, but also a mechanism to question whose knowledge counts, whose interests are prioritized, and whose voices are heard.<br>Globally, there is a growing recognition that climate governance must be accountable, inclusive, and responsive to those on the frontlines. Legal strategies are increasingly being used to challenge not only specific projects, but also the policies and plans that enable them. These efforts reflect a broader shift: from reacting to harm, to contesting the structures that produce it.<br>Bringing energy planning into legal scrutiny is part of this shift. It is about acknowledging that decisions affecting people’s lives do not begin with permits or contracts — they begin much earlier, in documents that are often shielded from public debate.<br>For gender and climate justice advocates, this opens an important pathway. Engaging with legal processes — even those that may seem distant or technical — can help expose the gaps between formal commitments to participation and the realities on the ground. It can also help reframe planning not as a closed, expert-driven domain, but as a space where justice must be actively negotiated.<br>The challenge, of course, is that legal processes alone are not enough. Courts operate within constraints, and litigation can only go so far. But when combined with broader advocacy and community engagement, legal action can amplify voices that are otherwise excluded — and create pressure for more inclusive forms of decision-making.<br>At its core, the issue is simple: energy planning shapes our collective future. It determines not only how we generate electricity, but also how we distribute power — both literally and politically.Ensuring that this process is not conducted “without us” requires more than technical reforms. It requires opening up the structures of decision-making, questioning long-held assumptions about expertise and authority, and insisting that those most affected are not treated as an afterthought.</p><p>Legal challenges are one way to begin that process.</p><p><em>*Renie Aryandani is a legal and advocacy practitioner working at the intersection of climate issues, gender justice, and state power. She has been involved in several strategic litigation efforts challenging exclusionary energy planning, while critically examining legal structures that often silence the voices of affected communities.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d695c48d0686" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/energy-planning-without-us-why-legal-challenges-matter-for-gender-and-climate-justice-d695c48d0686">Energy Planning Without Us:
Why Legal Challenges Matter for Gender and Climate Justice</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Perempuan Memimpin Jalan Menuju Dekarbonisasi]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/perempuan-memimpin-jalan-menuju-dekarbonisasi-2719cbfb8e08?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2719cbfb8e08</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[just-transition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decarbonisation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Nov 2025 16:29:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-18T16:29:57.628Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JogOBIq7H4Wpb0WsLtYpJw.jpeg" /></figure><h4><em>Marhaini Nasution<br>Aksi! for gender, social, and ecological justice</em></h4><blockquote>“Kami belajar lihat sendiri masalah kami, pikir sama-sama, terus jalan sama-sama. Dari situ kami sadar, perubahan itu tidak datang dari orang luar. Tapi dari kami sendiri, dari tangan perempuan yang berani lawan ketidakadilan.” — <em>Diana Leiwakabessy, perempuan nelayan Latuhalat, Ambon.</em></blockquote><p>Di tengah meningkatnya tekanan global untuk menurunkan emisi karbon, perempuan petani dan nelayan di Indonesia menunjukkan bahwa transisi menuju masa depan rendah karbon tidak harus datang dari proyek raksasa. Di Ambon, Makassar, dan Yogyakarta, mereka melahirkan solusi berdasarkan i kebutuhan hidup sehari-hari: menjaga keberadaan air, menjamin ketersediaan pangan, dan melanjutkan kehidupan dengan cara yang berkelanjutan.</p><p>Melalui program kerja sama Aksi! for gender, social, and ecological justice (Aksi!) dan LIFE, dengan dukungan International Climate Initiative (IKI), perempuan di tiga wilayah ini memperlihatkan bahwa dekarbonisasi yang berkeadilan gender bisa tumbuh dari komunitas. Inisiatif ini merupakan bagian dari program Gender Transformative Decarbonization (GetDecarb) — sebuah upaya memperkuat kepemimpinan perempuan dalam membangun masa depan rendah karbon yang adil dan demokratis.</p><p><strong>Krisis Iklim dan Ketidakadilan yang Dihadapi Perempuan</strong></p><p>Perubahan iklim semakin terasa nyata oleh komunitas. Perempuan nelayan di Desa Latuhalat dan Seilale, di Ambon, menghadapi kemarau panjang, banjir rob, dan cuaca yang tidak menentu. Saat angin kencang, para nelayan tidak bisa melaut. Perubahan suhu laut menyebabkan hasil tangkapan berkurang dan ikan berpindah ke wilayah yang lebih jauh. Selain itu, naiknya volume air laut menyebabkan pengikisan di pesisir. Dampaknya sangat terasa bagi warga pesisir Latuhalat. Air sumur menjadi payau dan sebagian rumah mulai terendam air laut, membuat akses terhadap air bersih semakin sulit. Kondisi ini menambah beban perempuan yang setiap hari harus mencari air untuk kebutuhan rumah tangga.</p><p>Lain halnya dengan Negeri Seilale. Letaknya yang lebih tinggi membuat warga sulit mendapatkan air bersih karena aliran air yang masuk ke kampung tidak mencukupi kebutuhan seluruh warga, terutama saat musim kemarau tiba. Banyak keluarga harus membeli air untuk kebutuhan harian mereka.</p><blockquote>“Kalau musim kemarau datang, kami harus beli air Rp150.000 per tangki. Itu berat sekali,” <em>ujar Ibu Ina, perempuan nelayan dari Seilale, Ambon.</em></blockquote><p>Situasi serupa juga terlihat di Makassar. Perempuan pesisir di Tallo dan Cambayya hidup di antara air asin yang merembes masuk ke sumur, banjir rob, dan musim kemarau yang berkepanjangan. Di Yogyakarta, kekeringan semakin sering terjadi dan diperparah oleh pembangunan hotel-hotel besar dan atraksi turisme lainnya yang menguras air tanah serta mempersempit ruang hijau.</p><p>Bagi perempuan, krisis air bukan sekadar persoalan lingkungan dan iklim, tetapi juga beban sosial dan ekonomi. Mereka harus berjalan lebih jauh mencari air, mengeluarkan biaya tambahan untuk membeli air bersih, dan menanggung stres berlapis baik secara psikis maupun fisik — karena tetap harus memasak, mencuci, serta mengurus keluarga.</p><blockquote>“Apa-apa yang pusing pasti perempuan,” <em>ujar Diana, perempuan nelayan dari Latuhalat, Ambon.</em></blockquote><p><strong>FPAR: Perempuan sebagai Peneliti dan Penggerak Perubahan</strong></p><p>Menghadapi situasi yang semakin berat akibat krisis iklim, perempuan di Ambon, Makassar, dan Yogyakarta mulai berkumpul, saling bercerita, dan mencari jalan keluar bersama. Dari obrolan sehari-hari tentang air, laut, dan pangan, tumbuh kesadaran bahwa persoalan yang mereka alami bukan sekadar urusan rumah tangga, tetapi bagian dari ketimpangan yang lebih besar. Mereka mulai memahami bahwa perubahan tidak akan datang dari luar, melainkan harus dimulai dari diri mereka sendiri dan komunitas di sekitar mereka. Dari sinilah proses perubahan atau transformasi bermula.</p><p>Transformasi yang terjadi di tiga wilayah ini tidak muncul begitu saja. Melalui pendekatan Feminist Participatory Action Research (FPAR) yang difasilitasi oleh Aksi!, perempuan yang terlibat program ini belajar mengenali dan menganalisis masalah mereka sendiri, mengidentifikasi akar ketimpangan yang mereka alami, dan membangun strategi kolektif untuk mengatasinya.</p><p>FPAR menempatkan perempuan sebagai peneliti dan ahli atas kehidupan mereka sendiri, bukan sekadar penerima dampak. Dalam proses ini perempuan mengkritisi relasi kuasa yang menindas, baik di rumah, di masyarakat, maupun dalam kebijakan publik.<br>Mereka memetakan bentuk ketidakadilan yang dialami, mulai dari beban kerja ganda hingga keterbatasan akses terhadap sumber daya seperti air, tanah, dan laut.</p><p>Prinsip FPAR juga memperkuat aksi kolektif dan solidaritas antarperempuan. Diskusi-diskusi yang berawal dari pengalaman sehari-hari, seperti kesulitan air atau hasil tangkapan ikan yang menurun, berkembang menjadi gerakan bersama untuk perubahan struktural.<br>Seperti disampaikan oleh salah satu Perempuan Nelayan di Makassar:</p><blockquote>“Dulu perempuan merasa tidak bisa bicara soal kebijakan. Sekarang mereka bukan hanya bicara, tapi juga punya data, analisis, dan solusi.” <em>— Saenab, perempuan nelayan kampung Tallo, Makassar.</em></blockquote><p>Melalui proses ini, FPAR tidak hanya menghasilkan pengetahuan, tetapi juga membangun kekuatan politik perempuan untuk menghadapi relasi kuasa yang timpang antara komunitasnya dan negara, dan memperjuangkan dekarbonisasi yang adil gender dan transformatif.</p><p><strong>Dari Krisis ke Solusi: Inisiatif Perempuan dalam Transisi Energi dan Pangan</strong></p><p>Melalui hasil analisis kolektif FPAR, perempuan di tiga wilayah mulai merumuskan inisiatif energi bersih dan pengelolaan sumber daya alam berbasis komunitas.<br>Gagasan seperti pembangunan jaringan air bersih tenaga surya skala rumah tangga di Ambon dan Makassar, muncul dari proses FPAR sebagai reaksi atas kekeringan dan mahalnya air bersih. Di Yogyakarta perempuan petani kota mengembangkan gagasan menanam secara kolektif untuk menjaga ketahanan pangan di tengah krisis air dan panas ekstrem.</p><p>Walau masih dalam tahap awal, gagasan dan inisiatif mereka ini menunjukkan arah baru kepemimpinan perempuan dalam dekarbonisasi, menghubungkan adaptasi terhadap krisis iklim dengan mitigasi emisi melalui energi terbarukan skala kecil.</p><blockquote>“Perempuan telah membuktikan bahwa dia bisa melakukan usaha dekarbonisasi dalam bentuk sederhana,” <em>kata Winarni, fasilitator FPAR Yogyakarta.</em></blockquote><p>Selain urusan energi, perempuan di Ambon juga menginisiasi penanaman pohon pisang, rambutan, dan sukun di pesisir pantai. Tujuannya, untuk mencegah banjir dan abrasi, sekaligus memperkuat ekonomi keluarga. Dari hasil panenmereka membuat produk olahan pisang seperti keripik dan sale. Mereka juga mengembangkan bibit rambutan dan sukun untuk dijual atau dibagikan ke komunitas lain.</p><p>Langkah ini menjadi contoh nyata bahwa aksi iklim perempuan menghasilkan co-benefit, memperbaiki ekosistem sekaligus membuka sumber pendapatan baru.</p><p><strong>Tantangan Akses terhadap Pendanaan Iklim</strong></p><p>Meskipun penuh inovasi, inisiatif perempuan di akar rumput ini masih menghadapi tantangan besar yaitu sulitnya mengakses dana iklim. Prosedur administrasi yang rumit, bahasa teknis yang sulit dimengerti, dan minimnya pengakuan atas kerja komunitas membuat kelompok perempuan terpinggirkan dari mekanisme pendanaan.</p><blockquote>“Kami bisa menanam mangrove, membuat biokompos, atau membangun sistem air tenaga surya kecil, tapi kalau tidak ada dukungan dana, semua berhenti di tengah jalan,” — <em>Anggi, fasilitator FPAR Makassar.</em></blockquote><p>Padahal, dana kecil yang langsung menyasar kelompok perempuan terbukti berdampak besar pada ketahanan komunitas. Akses ke pendanaan iklim yang adil bukan hanya soal uang, tapi soal pengakuan terhadap peran dan pengetahuan perempuan dalam menjaga alam.</p><p><strong>Suara dari Akar Rumput: Dari Kampung ke Ruang Kebijakan</strong></p><p>Program GetDecarb bertujuan memastikan agar pemerintah lokal dan nasional mengakui dan memasukkan perspektif gender dalam kebijakan dekarbonisasi, mitigasi, dan ketahanan iklim.</p><p>Melalui proyek ini, enam kelompok perempuan akar rumput di Ambon, Makassar, dan Yogyakarta kini lebih percaya diri mengekspresikan aspirasi politik mereka, serta berjejaring untuk menyuarakan keadilan iklim, agar dekarbonisasi Indonesia mengakui perempuan dan komunitas mereka sebagai pemangku kepentingan utama menuju masyarakat yang berkeadilan gender, demokratis, dan berkelanjutan secara ekologis.</p><p><strong>Pesan Menuju COP 30: Dekarbonisasi yang Adil dan Feminis</strong></p><p>Di COP30 di Belem, Brasil, Aksi! dan LIFE akan membawa suara perempuan dari Ambon, Makassar, dan Yogyakarta ke ruang global.</p><p>Melalui sesi dan pertemuan di COP30, perwakilan Aksi! dan Life akan menegaskan bahwa solusi berbasis komunitas perempuan, mulai dari pertanian berbasis lokal, energi skala kecil, hingga pengelolaan pesisir — penanaman pohon di pesisir (pisang, sukun, rambutan) untuk cegah abrasi dan banjir, pengelolaan air bersih tenaga surya skala rumah tangga, atau pengolahan hasil laut seperti ikan asap dan abon ikan sebagai bentuk adaptasi ekonomi — , harus diakui sebagai bagian integral dari strategi global menuju dekarbonisasi yang transformatif.</p><p><strong>Harapan dari GetDecarb</strong></p><p>Inisiatif GetDecarb menegaskan bahwa transisi rendah karbon harus memasukkan keadilan gender, sosial dan ekologi. COP30 menjadi momen penting untuk menunjukkan bahwa perempuan di komunitas akar rumput bukan hanya korban krisis iklim, tetapi adalah pemimpin mengatasi krisis iklim dan menuju transformasi menuju tatanan yang lebih adil. .</p><p>Dari pesisir Ambon, dari lorong-lorong hijau Yogyakarta, hingga tepian pantai Makassar, perempuan Indonesia telah memulai langkah nyata menuju masa depan rendah karbon.<br>Mereka belum memiliki semua sumber daya, tapi mereka memiliki visi, pengetahuan, dan solidaritas. Dan dari sinilah, dari tangan-tangan mereka, dekarbonisasi yang adil bisa benar-benar dimulai.</p><p>Jakarta, 7 November 2025</p><h3>Community Women’s Leadership for Decarbonisation</h3><h4><em>Marhaini Nasution<br>Aksi! for gender, social, and ecological justice</em></h4><blockquote>‘We learned to see our problems by ourselves, think together, and move forward together. From there, we realised that changes do not come from other people. They come from us, from the hands of women who dare to fight injustice.” — <em>Diana Leiwakabessy, fisherwoman from Latuhalat, Ambon.</em></blockquote><p>Amidst increasing global pressure to reduce carbon emissions, women farmers and fisherwomen in Indonesia are demonstrating that the transition to a low-carbon future does not require massive-scale projects. In areas such as Ambon, Makassar, and Yogyakarta in Indonesia, they create climate solutions tailored to their daily needs, including preserving water, ensuring food security, and maintaining a sustainable way of life.</p><p>Through a collaborative programme between the Indonesian Aksi! for gender, social, and ecological justice (Aksi!) and the German LIFE, with support from the International Climate Initiative (IKI), a German government program supporting climate and biodiversity projects in developing countries, women in these three regions demonstrate that gender-just decarbonisation can grow from within communities. This initiative is part of the Gender Transformative Decarbonisation (GetDecarb) programme — an effort to strengthen women’s leadership in building a fair and democratic low-carbon future.</p><p><strong>The climate crisis and the Injustice faced by community women</strong></p><p>Despite the relentless onslaught of climate change on their communities, the women of Latuhalat and Seilale in Ambon stand firm. They confront prolonged droughts, tidal flooding, and erratic weather, yet they persist in adapting and finding solutions. When the winds are fierce, the fisherman can’t venture out to sea. Changes in sea temperature have led to reduced catches as fish migrate to more distant waters. Moreover, sea level rise contributes to coastal abrasion, with the coastal villagers of Latuhalat bearing the brunt of it. Well water has turned brackish, and the seawater is slowly submerging some houses, making access to clean water increasingly challenging. This situation adds to the burden on women who must fetch water for their daily household needs.</p><p>The situation is different in Seilale. Its higher elevation makes it difficult for the villagers to obtain clean water because the water flow into the village is insufficient to meet the needs of all villagers, especially during the dry season. Many families have to buy water for their daily needs.</p><blockquote>‘When the dry season comes, we have to buy water for IDR 150.000 per tank. That’s very costly,” <em>said Mrs Ina, a fisherwoman from Seilale, Ambon.</em></blockquote><p>A similar situation can be seen in Makassar. Women from the coastal areas of Tallo and Cambayya must contend with saltwater seeping into their wells, face tidal flooding, and prolonged drought. In Yogyakarta, droughts are becoming more frequent and are exacerbated by the construction of hotels and other tourist attractions that drain groundwater and reduce green spaces.</p><p>For women, the water crisis is not just an environmental and climate issue, but also a social and economic burden. They have to walk further to find water, often spending hours each day, incur additional costs to purchase clean water, and bear multiple layers of stress, both psychological and physical, as they still need to cook, wash, and care for their families. The lack of clean water not only affects their health but also their ability to engage in income-generating activities, further exacerbating their economic vulnerability.</p><blockquote>“Whatever is troubling, it is always the woman’s burden,” <em>said Diana, a fisherwoman from Latuhalat, Ambon.</em></blockquote><p><strong>FPAR: Women as Researchers and Agents of Change</strong></p><p>Faced with increasingly difficult situations due to the climate crisis, women in Ambon, Makassar, and Yogyakarta began to gather, share stories, and seek solutions together. From everyday conversations about water, the sea, and food, they have become aware that the problems they face are not merely household matters, but part of a larger issue of inequality. They have begun to understand that change will not come from outside, but must start from themselves and their communities. This is where the process of change or transformation begins.</p><p>The transformation that took place in these three regions did not happen overnight. Through the Feminist Participatory Action Research (FPAR) approach facilitated by Aksi!, the women involved in this programme experienced a profound shift. They learned to recognise and analyse their own problems, identify the root causes of the inequalities they encountered, and develop collective strategies to overcome them. This process not only empowered them to become advocates for change in their communities but also instilled in them a sense of agency and influence.</p><p>FPAR positions women as researchers and experts on their own lives, not merely as recipients of impact. In this process, women critique oppressive power relations, whether at home, in the community, or in public policy.</p><p>Women had identified the forms of injustice they experience, from the double burden of care work at home to the limited access to resources such as water, land, and the sea.</p><p>The FPAR principle also strengthens collective action and solidarity among women. Discussions that began with everyday experiences, such as water shortages or declining fish catches, evolved into a joint movement for structural change. As expressed by one of the fisherwomen in Makassar:</p><blockquote>“In the past, women felt they couldn’t talk about policy. Now they not only talk about it, but also have data, analysis and solutions.” <em>— Saenab, fisherwoman from Tallo village, Makassar.</em></blockquote><p>This FPAR process not only generates knowledge but also builds women’s political power to confront the unequal power dynamics between their communities and the state, and to advocate for gender-just and transformative decarbonisation.</p><p><strong>From crisis to solution: community women’s Initiatives in energy and food in decarbonisation</strong></p><p>Through FPAR’s collective analysis, women in three regions began to formulate and lead the implementation of community-based initiatives for clean energy and natural resource management. Ideas such as the development of household-scale solar-powered clean water systems in Ambon and Makassar, spearheaded by women’s groups, emerged as a response to drought and the high cost of clean water. In Yogyakarta, urban women farmers have developed the concept of collective farming to ensure food security amid water crises and extreme heat, demonstrating their proactive role in addressing the impacts of climate change.</p><p>Although still in the early stages, these ideas and initiatives point to a new direction for women’s leadership in decarbonisation, linking adaptation to the climate crisis with emission mitigation through small-scale renewable energy.</p><blockquote>“Women have proven that they can undertake decarbonisation efforts in simple ways,” <em>said Winarni, FPAR facilitator in Yogyakarta.</em></blockquote><p>Beyond energy matters, women in Ambon have also initiated the planting of banana, rambutan, and breadfruit trees along the coastline. The aim is to prevent flooding and abrasion while strengthening family economies. From their harvests, they produce banana-based products, including chips, and sell them. They also develop rambutan and breadfruit seedlings for sale or distribution to other communities.</p><p>This step is a clear example that women’s climate actions produce co-benefits, improve ecosystems, and open up new sources of income.</p><p><strong>The challenge of access to climate finance</strong></p><p>Despite those innovations, these grassroots women’s initiatives still face significant challenges, such as the difficulty in accessing climate finance. Complex administrative procedures, difficult technical language, and a lack of recognition for community work have marginalised women’s groups from financing mechanisms.</p><blockquote>“We can plant mangroves, make bio-compost, or build small solar water systems, but without financial support, everything sticks halfway,” <em>said Anggi, a facilitator at FPAR Makassar.</em></blockquote><p>In fact, small funds that directly target women’s groups would have proven to have a significant impact on community resilience. Access to fair climate finance is not just about money, but also about recognising women’s roles and knowledge in protecting natural resources.</p><p>Voices from the grassroots: from the village to the global policy spaces</p><p>The GetDecarb programme aims to ensure that local and national governments recognise and incorporate gender perspectives into decarbonisation, mitigation and climate resilience policies and actions.</p><p>Through this project, six grassroots women’s groups in Ambon, Makassar, and Yogyakarta are now more confident in expressing their political aspirations and network with others to voice their concerns about climate and gender justice, so that Indonesia’s decarbonisation recognises women and their communities as key stakeholders towards a gender-just, democratic, and ecologically sustainable society.</p><p>Message to COP 30: Fair and Feminist Decarbonisation</p><p>At COP30 in Belém, Brazil, Aksi! and LIFE will bring the voices of communjity women from Ambon, Makassar, and Yogyakarta to the global stage.</p><p>Through sessions and meetings at COP30, representatives from Aksi! and LIFE will emphasise that women-led community-based solutions, ranging from local agriculture, small-scale energy, to coastal management — planting trees along the coast like bananas, breadfruit, rambutan to prevent abrasion and flooding, household-scale solar-powered clean water management, or processing marine products such as smoked fish and fish flakes as a form of economic adaptation — must be recognised as an integral part of the global strategy towards transformative decarbonisation.</p><p><strong>Expectations from GetDecarb</strong></p><p>The GetDecarb initiative emphasises that the low-carbon transition must incorporate gender, social and ecological justice. COP30 is a crucial moment to demonstrate that women in grassroots communities are not only victims of the climate crisis but also leaders in overcoming it and moving towards a more just transformation.</p><p>From the shores of Ambon, through the green alleys of Yogyakarta, to the coastlines of Makassar, Indonesian community women have already taken concrete steps towards a low-carbon future. They may not have all the resources, but they possess vision, knowledge, and a sense of solidarity. And it is from here, from their hands, that fair decarbonisation can truly begin.</p><p>Jakarta, 7 November 2025</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2719cbfb8e08" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/perempuan-memimpin-jalan-menuju-dekarbonisasi-2719cbfb8e08">Perempuan Memimpin Jalan Menuju Dekarbonisasi</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Indonesia’s Democracy Is Bleeding: A Call for Global Solidarity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/indonesias-democracy-is-bleeding-a-call-for-global-solidarity-ef41ad52f7a2?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef41ad52f7a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solidarity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Sep 2025 07:55:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-11T07:55:28.773Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>By Renie Aryandani</em></p><p>I write from Indonesia, a country often hailed in global conferences as a “democracy in transition.” But beneath that glittering label, we live under an authoritarian(-style) government that rules with violence, corruption, and impunity. Our daily reality is not freedom — it is fear.<br>On the streets, police brutality has become routine. Just days ago, a 21-year-old ride-hailing driver, Affan Kurniawan, was crushed to death by a police tactical vehicle during protests in Jakarta. His name will not appear in glossy government reports, but for us, it is carved into our conscience as yet another life stolen by state violence.<br>Meanwhile, inside parliament halls, the ruling class enriches itself. Members of the House of Representatives enjoy massive salaries, allowances, and luxury housing benefits — while millions of citizens struggle with the cost of rice, fuel, and school fees. To cover fiscal gaps, local governments hike property taxes (PBB) by 250% to 1,000% in cities like Pati and Cirebon, sparking protests from farmers and workers who simply cannot pay. Instead of protecting its people, the state burdens them.<br>Worse, the law — which should be a shield for justice — has been bent into a weapon. Courts criminalize peasants who defend their land from extractive projects. Survivors of human rights violations are silenced, while perpetrators walk free in ministerial offices. Those who expose corruption or environmental crimes face harassment and lawsuits. Our so-called democracy is managed by a cartel of oligarchs who treat law as their private playground.<br>And when the people resist? The regime ensures their voices are muffled. Just this week, Jakarta’s Broadcasting Commission (KPID) urged media to “avoid provocation” in reporting protests. This language sounds harmless, even noble. But in practice, it pressures journalists to downplay the truth: the beatings, the arrests, the blood spilled on our streets. When media are told to “be calming,” what they are really told is to look away.</p><p>This is an authoritarian(-style) government not only in its raw violence, but also in its silences. An authoritarianism that kills young drivers, that raises taxes while officials flaunt wealth, that bends laws to protect criminals in power, and that asks the press to wash away our pain.<br>Yet amid this darkness, resistance grows. Women lead the marches against land grabs. Students risk arrest to call out oligarchy. Queer youth organize safe spaces to imagine freer futures. Families of victims of state violence refuse to forget.</p><p>But we cannot survive this fight alone. To our sisters, comrades, and allies in feminist, queer, climate, and justice movements around the world: we need your solidarity. Speak our names in your networks. Challenge the complicity of international institutions that continue to legitimize our rulers while ignoring their crimes. Hold accountable the corporations that profit from our oppression.<br>Our struggle in Indonesia is not isolated. It is part of the global pattern where authoritarian regimes, patriarchal violence, and climate destruction intertwine. We resist because our lives depend on it. We reach out because our survival is bound together.<br>Another world is not only possible — it is urgent. Stand with us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef41ad52f7a2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/indonesias-democracy-is-bleeding-a-call-for-global-solidarity-ef41ad52f7a2">Indonesia’s Democracy Is Bleeding: A Call for Global Solidarity</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Feminist Climate Justice: “The power to prioritize what is essential for the reproduction of life”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/feminist-climate-justice-the-power-to-prioritize-what-is-essential-for-the-reproduction-of-life-9c342a05614e?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c342a05614e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Aug 2025 15:16:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-21T15:16:46.452Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b29oXZcdYpI0XGrmTO3flg.jpeg" /></figure><p>This text is the result of a conversation between Ivonne Yánez, Liliana Buitrago, Carmen Aliaga, Melissa Moreano and María Gabriela Merlinsky as part of the Diploma in Gender and Climate Change of the Latin American Council of Social Sciences, CLACSO. The dialogue was transcribed by Daniela Escobar and edited by Melissa Moreano.</p><h4><strong>The Climate Crisis from Dominant and Hegemonic Discourses</strong></h4><p>Ivonne is a member and co-founder of <a href="https://www.accionecologica.org/">Acción Ecológica</a> in Ecuador, and the global network <a href="https://www.oilwatch.org/">OilWatch</a>. She is an environmentalist and feminist, a biologist, and a science fiction enthusiast. She has been working on climate change issues for more than 30 years, and has seen how hegemonic discourses over the past few decades have become increasingly sophisticated in evading, distracting, and avoiding decisions that could restrict access to the energy required for capitalist production and consumption. In other words, decisions that prevent people from talking about the real cause of climate change, which is the extraction and burning of fossil fuels. To this end, a series of mechanisms have been invented, some within the United Nations and its Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), associated with carbon offsets. Ivonne, along with others, denounces that these mechanisms allow the implementation, mainly in countries of the South, of a series of projects/programs which <em>supposedly</em> capture CO2, <em>supposedly</em> retain CO2 in vegetation, and which <em>supposedly</em> reduce emissions occurring elsewhere in the world, in this case, in the industrialized countries of the North. However, it has already been demonstrated that the offset system is not addressing the problem, because since the climate change negotiations began, emissions have continued to grow. Also, it is clear now that the hegemonic discourse seeks to evade the discussion about the urgent need to transform capitalism to end dependence on fossil fuels. This latter is being done by incorporating a new discourse: that of the <strong>energy transition</strong> that use resources again from the South, primarily the so-called “critical” minerals for the transition, while also continue using fossil fuels.</p><p>From this perspective, the emergence of false solutions reveals that the UNFCCC is designed to evade, to avoid, to distract from <strong>real solutions</strong>. <strong>False solutions are not the result of the UNFCCC’s malfunctioning, but its ultimate goal</strong>. And in this context, a real solution is to leave fossil fuels in the ground, as in the pioneering case in Ecuador of not extracting oil from a national park, the Yasuni-ITT Initiative.</p><h4><strong>Critique of False Solutions from Latin American Feminisms</strong></h4><p>Faced with the proliferation of false solutions to the climate crisis, for Liliana, a mother, ecofeminist, researcher, and <em>artivist</em> in the <a href="https://ecopoliticavenezuela.org/">Observatory of Political Ecology of Venezuela</a> and the <a href="https://www.instagram.com/mujerescuerposyterritorios/">Collective Women, Bodies, and Territories</a>, we need to reimagine everything: from patriarchal politics to the ways we relate to territories, including personal, family, and couple relationships. We are at a time when what feminists say — that “everything must be transformed” — implies seeking solutions to global, geopolitical, and national problems, and to <strong>what is understood as politics</strong>. In this sense, territorial ecofeminisms in Latin America have proposed rethinking the links with nature, coming up with notions such as <strong>the body-territory or the healing of the earth</strong>, which aim to rebuild the fabric of life. We are experiencing a kind of cognitive decoupling that should help us uncover the links between one problem and another. For example, between the violence people suffer due to climate change — eco-territorial violence — and gender violence. And vice versa. This unveiling can lead to imagining and building new forms of government, more democratic forms of <strong>climate democracy</strong>, where we can consult the people, as has happened with the Yasuní-ITT Initiative in Ecuador, where actions can be taken from below so that we can multiply the real solutions to the climate crisis.</p><p>But hegemonic politics devalues ​​alternatives conceived by the people by <strong>feminizing the spaces where those alternatives occur</strong>, labelling them as minor, private, individual initiatives that cannot be generalized or replicated. But what really happens is that these are alternatives that cannot be appropriated by capital, that cannot be commodified and presented as The Great Solution. These are what the <a href="https://futurosindigenas.org/">Indigenous Futures collective</a> calls “<strong>living solutions to the climate crisis</strong>”, which go with ancestral knowledge, practices of building the fabric of life, of re-imagining, where the humanity-nature divide is repaired, healed, as a political action. It is these political practices that green colonialism transforms into a <strong>feminized otherness</strong>, because it disregards everything caring, feminine, everything associated with the body, as invalid in the face of the climate crisis. However, these are actually struggles for the recomposition of the living fabric and against bio-precarity.</p><p>Liliana, who is also a member of the <a href="https://pactoecosocialdelsur.com/">Ecosocial and Intercultural Pact of the South</a> and the <a href="https://plataformajusticiaclimatica.org/">Latin American and Caribbean Platform for Climate Justice</a>, raises the urgency of <a href="https://www.mapafalsassoluciones.com/">mapping false solutions</a> to visualize them from a multi-critical perspective that dismantles <strong>the absurd idea that biotic carbon is equivalent to the carbon emitted by an extractive industry</strong>. And not only in its chemical dimension, but also in its social dimension: that the carbon that circulates, which is part of all living beings, would be equivalent to the pollution, the inequalities and the violence produced by extractivism. Let us be clear: <strong>false solutions are only possible because the precariousness of life</strong> is exacerbated by the current crisis of capitalism — inherent to the system itself — which is now in its most cruel phase. The precariousness produced by the same system of dispossession leads people to normalize violence and causes ruptures in community ties. <strong>Without this precariousness of life, green capitalist projects could not be established in the territories.</strong> A pending task is then to deromanticize the green economy and its enchanting function that makes people believe they are fighting against the climate crisis when accepting false solutions.</p><h4><strong>The Pledge of Latin American Feminisms: The Collective and Life at the Center</strong></h4><p>Carmen has been fighting against mining extractivism alongside the <a href="https://www.redlatinoamericanademujeres.org/">Latin American Network of Women Defenders of Social and Environmental Rights</a> for almost 20 years. For some time now, the Network has added up to their journey some efforts to articulate and strengthen <strong>the perspective of care and the reproduction of life, of the everyday life of women</strong>, which is blurred and kept hidden when production, trading and what generates “wealth” is prioritize. Reviewing the path taken, Carmen suggests that, as a Network, they arrived later both to the feminist struggle and to the struggle for climate justice. But this “slow but steady approach” has allowed them to build fundamental principles to confront the new colonialism, now painted in green, the bearer of solutions to the climate crisis. Their sharpened perspective has allowed them to identify that, beyond the raw materials they seek to extract, the enactors of green capitalism are <strong>faithful operators of the patriarchal pact that seeks to disrupt the living fabric of the community</strong>. Thus, they do not seek out the community, or the assembly, or any collective decision-making space, but rather leaders, generally men, who have already had some disagreement with the community, with whom they negotiate and through whom they enter local decision-making spaces. The women’s sharpened perspective has allowed them to identify that “green” companies employ the same strategies as the former mining companies, but with a renewed capacity to appropriate the narratives of struggle: “This is sustainable for Mother Earth”, they say.</p><p>After their sharpened perspective has come radicalism: from Latin American feminisms, from women’s struggles, other ways of living are being proposed. Peasant, ejidatarian, and indigenous women’s organizations say: “We are no longer negotiating whether they give us a little compensation or if the process is a little less contaminated. <strong>What we are disputing is that they let us live as we are accustomed to living</strong>”. There is no negotiation of any kind here, but rather <strong>a radical assertion that there is a way of life absolutely opposed to the capitalist, colonial, and patriarchal dynamics of expropriation</strong> that seek to exploit life on the land and strip peoples of their political capacities to articulate the community. This is the feminine power of positions like the territory-body from our comrades in Guatemala, which is nothing more than the clamour for <strong>another way of understanding, living, and managing the territory</strong>. The response, of course, is violent. The dispossession projects now focus on damaging the image of women leaders, discrediting them, through sexist mechanisms.</p><p>Faced with this, there is a need to build <strong>other forms of politics</strong>, ones that are anti-patriarchal and built on care. For Carmen, who is also a researcher at the <a href="https://colectivocasa.org.bo/">Socio-Environmental Coordination Collective (CASA)</a> in Bolivia, we must transcend the separation between feminisms and environmentalisms or the hierarchy between different struggles: climate, social, economic, and gender struggles for equality, for emancipation, for freedom, for the right to enjoyment. <strong>We must transcend the myth that feminist emancipation can be postponed, that it can be done later, that it is not urgent</strong>. And even worse, in a global scenario in which we live in a situation of permanent war on different scales. The starkest is the genocide in Palestine, but there are also multi-sited wars, which lead the social movement not to be on the offensive but on the defensive, in survival mode. In this situation, women are almost always left behind, because in our struggles <strong>we also reproduce the injustice in the distribution of care work, now in the organization and mobilization, which falls disproportionately into the hands of women</strong>.</p><p>And also, to acknowledge that <strong>the triumph of the war associated with the climate crisis is the triumph of patriarchy and colonialism.</strong> That patriarchy and colonialism strengthen capitalism, and that if we don’t see, name, and dismantle this triad, we will not win. We know that it is difficult to name what appears minimal, local, of the everyday, or domestic, because we have inherited the dichotomies between the public and the private, between nature and society, between emotion and reason. Here, feminisms have given us the possibility of <strong>politicizing emotions, not as a means of revictimization, but of empowering political subjects</strong>. From there, from the contestation of concepts, from the production of meanings, we have begun to talk about <strong>reparation</strong>. We want to think and act not only from dispossession but also from reparation.</p><p>We are men and women, developing <strong>reparative theories</strong> not as individuals but as mixed collectivities, recognizing the defence of life as a priority over the hegemony of production, commodification, consumption, and dispossession. We are defending the river, life, community, carnival, joy, coming together, and having time: time for joy, for gathering, for nurturing, for enjoying, time to reproduce life. <strong>The power to prioritize what is essential for the reproduction of life is the strongest and most useful tool of struggle we have</strong>.</p><p>In a future text, we will share the visions of Latin American feminisms for COP30, the Latin American COP.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c342a05614e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/feminist-climate-justice-the-power-to-prioritize-what-is-essential-for-the-reproduction-of-life-9c342a05614e">Feminist Climate Justice: “The power to prioritize what is essential for the reproduction of life”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Justicia climática feminista: “la potencia de priorizar lo que es esencial para la reproducción de…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/notwithoutus/justicia-clim%C3%A1tica-feminista-la-potencia-de-priorizar-lo-que-es-esencial-para-la-reproducci%C3%B3n-de-2cc2df49e4a1?source=rss-c4193a40019c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2cc2df49e4a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[articles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[GenderCC - Women for Climate Justice]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Aug 2025 15:10:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-21T15:17:21.859Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b29oXZcdYpI0XGrmTO3flg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Justicia climática feminista: “la potencia de priorizar lo que es esencial para la reproducción de la vida”</h3><p>English version : <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/feminist-climate-justice-the-power-to-prioritize-what-is-essential-for-the-reproduction-of-life-9c342a05614e">https://medium.com/notwithoutus/feminist-climate-justice-the-power-to-prioritize-what-is-essential-for-the-reproduction-of-life-9c342a05614e</a></p><p>Este texto es fruto de la conversación entre Ivonne Yánez, Liliana Buitrago, Carmen Aliaga, Melissa Moreano y María Gabriela Merlinsky como parte del diplomado superior en Género y Cambio Climático del Consejo Latinoamericano de Ciencias Sociales, CLACSO. El diálogo fue transcrito por Daniela Escobar y editado por Melissa Moreano.</p><h4><strong>La crisis climática desde los discursos dominantes y hegemónicos</strong></h4><p>Ivonne es miembra y co-fundadora de <a href="https://www.accionecologica.org/">Acción Ecológica</a>, Ecuador, y de la Red <a href="https://www.oilwatch.org/">OilWatch</a>, es ecologista y feminista, bióloga y aficionada a la ciencia ficción. Lleva trabajando en temas de cambio climático más de 30 años, y ha visto cómo los discursos hegemónicos a lo largo de estas últimas décadas se han vuelto cada vez más sofisticados para evadir, distraer y evitar tomar decisiones que puedan restringir el acceso a la energía que necesitan los procesos de producción y de consumo capitalistas. Es decir, que no se hable sobre cuál es la verdadera causa del cambio climático, que es la extracción y quema de combustibles fósiles. Para eso se ha inventado una serie de mecanismos, algunos en el seno de las Naciones Unidas y su Convención Marco sobre Cambio Climático, asociados a las compensaciones de emisiones de carbono. Ivonne, junto a otrxs, han denunciado que estos mecanismos permiten ejecutar proyectos/programas, principalmente en los países del sur, que <em>supuestamente</em> captan CO2, <em>supuestamente</em> mantienen CO2 en la vegetación, y que <em>supuestamente</em> estarían reduciendo las emisiones que se realizan en otra parte del mundo, en este caso, en los países industrializados del norte. Sin embargo, se ha demostrado ya que el sistema de compensaciones no está enfrentando el problema, porque a lo largo de los años desde que empezaron las negociaciones de cambio climático las emisiones no han dejado de crecer <em>porque sencillamente el sistema no fue inventado para eso</em>. En segundo lugar, lo que se busca desde el discurso hegemónico es evadir la discusión sobre la necesidad urgente de transformar el capitalismo para terminar con la dependencia de los combustibles fósiles. Esto último se está haciendo a través de incorporar un nuevo discurso: el de la <strong>transición energética</strong>, que sigue utilizando recursos del sur, principalmente los minerales llamados “críticos” para la transición, mientras sigue utilizando combustibles fósiles.</p><p>En esa perspectiva, <strong>la emergencia de falsas solucione</strong>s revela que la CMNUCC está hecha para evadir, para evitar, para distraer de las verdaderas soluciones. <strong>Las falsas soluciones no son el resultado del mal funcionamiento de la CMNUCC, sino su objetivo</strong>. Y en ese marco, una verdadera solución es dejar los combustibles fósiles bajo tierra, como en el caso pionero en el Ecuador, de no extraer petróleo de un parque nacional, la <a href="https://www.yasunidos.org/">Iniciativa Yasuni-ITT</a>.</p><h4><strong>La crítica a las falsas soluciones desde los feminismos latinoamericanos</strong></h4><p>Frente a la proliferación de falsas soluciones a la crisis climática, para Liliana, mamá, ecofeminista, investigadora y artivista del <a href="https://ecopoliticavenezuela.org/">Observatorio de Ecología Política de Venezuela</a> y la <a href="https://www.instagram.com/mujerescuerposyterritorios/">Colectiva Mujeres, Cuerpos y Territorios</a>, tenemos que re-imaginarnos todo, desde la política patriarcal hasta las maneras de relacionarnos con los territorios, pasando por las relaciones personales, familiares, de pareja, etc. Estamos en un momento en donde esto que dicen los feminismos de que “hay que transformarlo todo”, implica también buscar las soluciones a los problemas globales, geopolíticos, nacionales, <strong>de lo que se entiende por política</strong>. En ese sentido, los eco-feminismos territoriales en Latinoamérica han propuesto re-pensar los vínculos con la naturaleza con nociones como el <em>cuerpo-territorio</em> o <em>la cura de la tierra</em>, que apuntan a la reconstrucción del tejido de la vida. Estamos atravesando una especie de desacoplamiento cognitivo que nos debe ayudar a develar los vínculos entre un problema y otro. Por ejemplo, entre las violencias que sufren las personas por el cambio climático -las violencias eco-territoriales- y las violencias de género. Y viceversa. Ese develamiento puede apuntar a imaginar y construir nuevas formas de gobierno, formas más democráticas, de democracia climática, en donde podamos consultar al pueblo, como ha ocurrido con la Iniciativa Yasuní-ITT en Ecuador, donde se pueden tomar acciones desde abajo, para que logremos que las soluciones reales a la crisis climática se multipliquen.</p><p>Pero desde la política hegemónica se desvaloriza las alternativas pensadas desde los pueblos a través de<strong> feminizar los espacios donde ocurren, </strong>tachándolas de iniciativas menores, privadas, particulares, que no pueden generalizarse o replicarse. Pero lo que ocurre en realidad es que son alternativas que no pueden ser apropiadas por el capital, que no pueden ser mercantilizadas y presentadas como La Gran Solución. Es lo que el <a href="https://futurosindigenas.org/#:~:text=Futuros%20Ind%C3%ADgenas%20es%20una%20red,aportaci%C3%B3n%20en%20nuestro%20ko-fi.">colectivo de Futuros Indígenas</a> llama “<strong>las soluciones vivas a la crisis climática</strong>”, que vienen acompañadas de saberes ancestrales, prácticas de construcción del tejido vivo, de re-imaginación, donde la escisión humanidad-naturaleza trata de ser reparada, sanada, como acción política. Es a estas prácticas políticas a las que el colonialismo verde transforma en una <strong>otredad feminizada</strong>, porque menosprecia todo lo que sea cuidado, femenino, todo lo que está asociado al cuerpo, como no válido ante la crisis climática, pero que en realidad son luchas por la recomposición del tejido de lo vivo y contra la bio precariedad.</p><p>Liliana, quien también es integrante del <a href="https://pactoecosocialdelsur.com/">Pacto Ecosocial e Intercultural del Sur</a> y de la <a href="https://plataformajusticiaclimatica.org/">Plataforma Latinoamericana y del Caribe por la Justicia Climática</a>, plantea la urgencia de <a href="https://www.mapafalsassoluciones.com/">mapear las falsas soluciones</a> para visualizarlas desde una perspectiva multi crítica que desmonte <strong>la idea absurda de que el carbono biótico es equivalente al carbono que emite la industria extractiva</strong>. Y no solo en su dimensión química, sino social: que el carbono que circula, que hace parte de todos los seres vivos es equivalente a la contaminación, las desigualdades y las violencias que producen los extractivismos. Debemos estar clarxs de que las falsas soluciones <strong>solo son posibles porque la precariedad de la vida está exacerbada por la crisis actual del capitalismo</strong> -que es inherente al propio sistema- que está ahora en su fase más cruel. La precariedad producida por el mismo sistema de despojo lleva a las personas a normalizar las violencias y ocasiona rupturas en los vínculos comunitarios. Sin esa precariedad de la vida, no se pudiesen instalar los proyectos del capitalismo verde en los territorios. Una tarea pendiente es entonces desromantizar la economía verde y su función de encantamiento que hace creer a las personas que están contribuyendo en la lucha contra la crisis climática embarcándose en las falsas soluciones.</p><h4><strong>La apuesta de los feminismos latinoamericanos: lo colectivo y la vida en el centro</strong></h4><p>Con esas perspectivas coincide Carmen, que viene de las luchas contra los extractivismos mineros junto a la <a href="https://www.redlatinoamericanademujeres.org/">Red Latinoamericana de mujeres defensoras de derechos sociales y ambientales</a> por casi 20 años. A ese caminar, desde ya algún tiempo, han sumado el esfuerzo por articular y fortalecer la perspectiva de los cuidados, de la reproducción de la vida, desde la realidad de las mujeres y de la cotidianidad de que se mantiene desdibujada, ocultada, cuando se prioriza lo mercantil, lo que se vende, lo que genera “riqueza”. Revisando el camino recorrido, Carmen plantea que como Red llegaron más tarde, tanto a la disputa desde los feminismos como a la disputa por la justicia climática. Pero ese “llegar despacito, pero seguras” les ha permitido construir unos principios fundamentales para enfrentar el nuevo colonialismo ahora pintado de verde, portador de las <strong>soluciones a la crisis climática</strong>.</p><p>La mirada agudizada les ha permitido identificar que, más allá de la materia prima que buscan extraer, son operadores fieles al <strong>pacto patriarcal que busca romper el tejido vivo comunitario</strong>. Así, no buscan a la comunidad, o a la asamblea, ni a ningún espacio colectivo de decisión, sino a dirigentes, generalmente varones, que ya hayan tenido alguna diferencia con la comunidad, con quienes negocian y a través de quienes se introducen en los espacios de decisión local. La mirada aguda de las mujeres les ha permitido identificar en las empresas “verdes” emplean las mismas estrategias de las antiguas mineras, pero con una capacidad renovada de apropiación de las narrativas de lucha: “Esto es sostenible con la madre tierra”, dicen.</p><p>Tras la mirada aguda ha venido la radicalidad: desde los feminismos latinoamericanos, desde las luchas de las mujeres, se están planteando, <strong>otras formas de vivir</strong>. Las organizaciones de mujeres campesinas, ejidatarias, indígenas dicen: “ya no estamos negociando si nos dan un poquito más de resarcimiento o si el proceso es un poquito menos contaminado. Lo que nosotras estamos disputando es <strong>que nos dejen vivir como nosotras estamos acostumbradas a vivir</strong>”. No hay ningún tipo de negociación ahí, sino una radicalidad de decir que hay una forma de vida absolutamente opuesta a las dinámicas de expropiación capitalistas, coloniales, patriarcales, que buscan explotar la vida en la tierra y despojar a los pueblos de sus capacidades políticas de articulación de la comunidad. Esa es la <strong>potencia femenina</strong> de posicionamientos como el territorio-cuerpo desde compañeras de Guatemala, que no es otra cosa que el clamor <strong>de otra forma de leer, vivir y gestionar el territorio</strong>. La respuesta, por supuesto, está siendo violenta. Los proyectos de despojo ahora se enfocan en dañar la imagen de las dirigentas, desprestigiarlas, a través de mecanismos machistas.</p><p>Frente a ello, surge la necesidad de construir otras formas de hacer política, antipatriarcal y construida desde los cuidados. Para Carmen, quien también es<strong> </strong>investigadora del <a href="https://colectivocasa.org.bo/">Colectivo de coordinación Socio Ambiental, CASA</a>, de Bolivia, debemos trascender la separación entre feminismos y ecologismos o la jerarquía entre las distintas luchas: climática, social, económica y las luchas de género por igualdad, por emancipación, por libertad, por derecho al goce. <strong>Trascender la fábula de que la emancipación feminista se puede postergar</strong>, que se puede hacer después, que no es urgente. Y peor aún, en un escenario global en que vivimos en una situación de guerra permanente y en diferentes escalas. La más descarnada es la que podemos ver en Palestina, pero también están guerras multisituadas, que llevan a que el movimiento social no esté a la ofensiva sino a la defensiva, en supervivencia. En esta situación, casi siempre se posterga a las mujeres, <strong>porque en las luchas también reproducimos la injusticia en la repartición del trabajo de cuidados</strong> ahora de la organización, de la movilización, que cae de manera desproporcionada en las manos de las mujeres.</p><p>Y también nombrar que el <strong>triunfo de la guerra</strong> que va asociada a la crisis climática es el triunfo del patriarcado y del colonialismo. Que <strong>el patriarcado y el colonialismo fortalecen al capitalismo</strong>, y que, si no vemos, nombramos y desmontamos esa tríada no vamos a vencer. Sabemos que es difícil nombrar lo que aparece como mínimo, local, cotidiano o doméstico, porque hemos heredado las dicotomías entre lo público y lo privado, entre naturaleza y sociedad, entre emoción y razón. Aquí, los feminismos nos han dado la posibilidad de politizar las emociones, no como vía de revictimización, sino de <strong>habilitación de sujetas políticas</strong>. Desde ahí, desde la disputa de conceptos, de la producción de sentidos, hemos empezado a hablar de <strong>reparación</strong>, no solamente queremos pensar y actuar desde el despojo sino también desde la reparación.</p><p><strong>Hacer teorías reparadoras</strong> no como individuos sino como colectividades mixtas, somos hombres y mujeres reconociendo la defensa de la vida como prioridad por sobre la hegemonía de lo productivo, de lo mercantil, del consumo, del despojo. <strong>La defensa del río, de la vida, de la comunidad, del carnaval, de la alegría, del juntarnos, del tener tiempo</strong>: tiempo de goce, de juntarse, de criar, de disfrutar, tiempo para reproducir la vida. La<strong> potencia de priorizar lo que es esencial para la reproducción de la vida</strong> es la herramienta de lucha más fuerte y más útil que tenemos.</p><p>En una próxima entrega compartiremos las visiones desde los feminismos latinoamericanos hacia la COP30, la COP latinoamericana.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2cc2df49e4a1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus/justicia-clim%C3%A1tica-feminista-la-potencia-de-priorizar-lo-que-es-esencial-para-la-reproducci%C3%B3n-de-2cc2df49e4a1">Justicia climática feminista: “la potencia de priorizar lo que es esencial para la reproducción de…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/notwithoutus">Not Without Us!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>