<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Gil Shafir on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Gil Shafir on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@gilshafir?source=rss-32f3c0ea2de1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 17:28:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@gilshafir/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Future Unfolding]]></title>
            <link>https://gilshafir.medium.com/future-unfolding-e8a226331be8?source=rss-32f3c0ea2de1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e8a226331be8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[futurism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gil Shafir]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Feb 2021 20:20:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-18T00:27:17.915Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Evolutionary Look at a Virtualized Future</h4><p>This post originally grew from an interest in the cypherpunk writings of the late 1990s. Writers such as John Perry Barlow and Timothy May prophesied that the internet would liberate the people of the world from the censorship power of the nation state and allow total freedom and autonomy. I was curious whether those ideas still seemed hopelessly naive in the post-Bitcoin world or whether, like many technological predictions, they were simply too optimistic with their timeline.</p><p>Consider the mechanisms governments use to control what people do online (the financial system, local laws, the Domain Name System (DNS), firewall blacklists, etc.) and how the decentralized architecture of blockchains undermines all of them. None of these controls can be enforced on a distributed autonomous organization transacting in Bitcoin and using a namespace secured on a distributed ledger. But, technical feasibility is a necessary but not sufficient condition for widespread usage; economic and geopolitical factors will ultimately determine whether people choose to circumvent these controls at scale. That realization caused me to greatly expand the scope of my analysis.</p><p>As information technology continues its exponential rise, society seems to be turning in a more dystopian and populist direction. On the flip side, many credible technologists are arguing that exponential growth in technology will lead to a post-scarcity world of abundance. Davidson and Rees-Mogg’s 1997 book <em>The Sovereign Individual</em> helped shape my thinking on how to reconcile these competing ideas. Their central thesis is that political shifts can be predicted by how dominant technologies alter the logic of violence. They argue that the industrial revolution caused massive increases to the returns on violence, resulting in the behemoth nation states we have today, but that information technology, specifically the internet, reverses this trend.</p><p>Applying ideas from evolutionary theory provided the framework for me to evaluate Davidson and Rees-Mogg’s technological-determinist approach. Working on Wall Street during the 2008 financial crisis, I saw firsthand how mainstream economics failed to predict the crash. Around that time, Eric Binhocker’s <em>The Origin of Wealth</em> introduced me to evolutionary economics and the application of complexity theory in economics. Rather than seeing the economy as a mathematically precise system transitioning between states of equilibrium, evolutionary economics treats it as a chaotic system characterized by continuous bouts of creative destruction. This framework is introduced below and ultimately developed to predict the form of our information technology driven future.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Imagine all possible states of existence as a fitness landscape, a multidimensional surface consisting of peaks and valleys across a nearly unlimited possibility space. Each peak represents a local maxima of fitness with valleys representing the opposite. If we were to constrain our thinking to biology, evolution is the obvious mechanism for movement in this landscape. Now remove this constraint, and imagine that an evolutionary process is responsible for progress along this landscape in all domains. Under this framework, biological evolution is just a subtype of a general purpose algorithm. I hope to show that rather than just a simple thought experiment, treating evolution as a universal algorithm provides the best framework for making sense of the world and predicting its future state.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RkyykrK7IUUVFWa2" /></figure><p>An evolutionary algorithm requires three components: (1) a mechanism for introducing variance (generating function), (2) a competitive process that selects for variants with increased fitness (competition function) and (3) spreading of higher fitness variants (propagation function). In biological evolution, random genetic mutations compete through survival of the fittest and spread through sexual reproduction. In the economy, market participants invent new technologies which capitalism determines the fitness of through economic competition. Winning technologies propagate by growing startups, bankrupting competitors and being adopted by surviving incumbents.</p><p>Moving evolution past biology was enabled by the development of sufficiently complex minds. Instead of relying on behavior preprogrammed through DNA, evolutionary advantage moved to animals with complex enough networks of neurons to support novel decision making. This complexity birthed language and with it, abstract thought and the ability to transmit ideas or memes to others. Unique to humans, these memes also include methods of social organization that can be viewed as a type of technology. Coevolving with memes came the first tools, physical technologies that increased their creator’s fitness past biological limitations. In order to separate these concepts, I will use the convention of splitting technology into two categories: social technologies (methods of organizing people for productive ends: culture, laws, religion, scientific method, political systems, etc.) and physical technologies (tools, farming, machinery, computers, etc.).</p><p>Evolution typically climbs slowly towards the tops of fitness peaks, but can sometimes make leaps to entirely different fitness peaks that offer better or worse maximal fitness. In biological evolution, we witness these leaps as mass speciation and extinction events. In technological evolution, we find developments such as agriculture or industrial manufacturing so large, that they result in a wholesale shift in social technologies and complete societal upheaval.</p><p>Advances in computation and communication have brought us into the information era, but we are still operating with the social technologies of the industrial era. The internet connects every person on earth through ever-increasing bandwidth, making new problems global and connecting us with like-minded friends across the planet rather than those coincidentally living in the same borders. With the importance of physical location diminishing, a new dominant social technology will need to be global in its scope, suggesting either an internationalist approach of a world government or a libertarian approach of decentralized governance. The new technology of blockchain and cryptocurrencies radically shifts evolutionary advantage in the decentralized direction, enabling governance structures based on voluntary association and instantiated in cryptographically secure smart contracts. In the following sections I will explore how the technologies of the internet, artificial intelligence, virtual reality and cryptocurrencies will remake society through the lens of our evolutionary framework.</p><h3>Table of Contents:</h3><p>Part I: Evolutionary Capitalism – Lays the foundation for how to think about progress as the coevolution of physical and social technologies. How the economy operates on the same algorithm as biological evolution, but has replaced violence with economic competition. Why mainstream economics has failed, and how to think of wealth creation in evolutionary terms.</p><p>Part II: Technologically-Driven Growth — Expands on the evolutionary framework to explain the primacy of technological progress. How information technology has come to dominate other types of physical technology and how it differs from industrial technology. Discusses centralized vs. decentralized computing architectures and the potential of blockchain technology.</p><p>Part III: Technology and the Evolution of Modern Government — Uses the technology-centric view of growth to explain how modern government evolved as a consequence of industrial era technologies. Why our current system is breaking down as growth in industrial technology has stalled and progress has been limited to information technology.</p><p>Part IV: Future Unfolding — Outlines four potential futures trajectories based on the relative rates of growth of industrial and information technologies. Focusing on our current trajectory, explores the longer-term societal and cultural implications of an information technology driven world.</p><h3>Part I: Evolutionary Capitalism</h3><p>Humans are unique among animals in our ability to cooperate in groups. Evolution genetically programmed humans with the social instincts necessary to survive our many millennia of hunter-gatherer existence. These instincts towards cooperation and reciprocal altruism increased group fitness, but only evolved to operate at the tribal level. New social technologies were required for these instincts to scale beyond the tribal level, facilitating the cooperation of progressively larger networks of people through positive sum interactions.</p><p>Most of human history consisted of small tribes of hunter-gatherers working with simple tools and spreading over a sparsely populated world. In that context, advantages in social and physical technologies could only confer limited advantages. Agriculture was the first physical technology to change this paradigm, massively increasing the number of calories a single person could produce. This technological shift enabled higher population densities and freed some labor from food production. Agriculture also created assets tied to a fixed location whose protection led to the first professional soldiers and governments. Since this shift, humanity’s progress has been governed by the coevolution of physical and social technologies.</p><p>Violence or the threat of violence generally results in zero sum interactions while voluntary exchanges are positive sum. Historically, the powerful became wealthy through the expropriation of goods and resources. The social technology of free market capitalism, in combination with functioning institutions to maintain the rule of law and property rights, unlocked evolutionary economic competition by safeguarding the free exchange of goods and services from the threat of violence. The incentives for technological progress increase radically when people are safe to profit from their ingenuity. While we can find many moral arguments justifying capitalism through ideas such as natural rights, the better way to understand its success is that it is the most accurate social-technology polymorphism of biological evolution, extending the originally biological methods to the economic.</p><p>Mainstream economics focuses on how scarce resources are allocated through the market behavior of rational actors. Simplifying assumptions allow the creation of mathematically beautiful but often <a href="https://paulromer.net/trouble-with-macroeconomics-update/WP-Trouble.pdf">wrong models</a>. In reality, economic equations contain too many variables to have closed form expressions and therefore cannot be solved mathematically. Economics borrowed its mathematical precision from physics in the 19th century, but instead of adapting as physics did — with its discoveries of the laws of thermodynamics and complexity theory — economics continued down an independent and blinkered intellectual path. The economy displays all the hallmarks of a complex adaptive system. Market participants compete in various networks as agents in a dynamic non-equilibrium system. In this context, macro behaviors are best understood as an emergent phenomenon arising from millions of micro level decisions. Unfortunately, such a complex and chaotic system can not be modeled accurately. Predictions made with the tools of mainstream economics miss <em>black swan</em> events with sometimes catastrophic results.</p><p>The move of the competition method of the evolutionary algorithm from a violence to an economic-based method was facilitated by granting government a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly_on_violence">monopoly on violence</a>. Specifically, a third party was required in order to safeguard property rights, enforce contracts and provide protection from outside threats. Over time, governments increased their scope to address apparent failures of the algorithm to produce efficient or just outcomes. Some examples of perceived market failures include externalities, monopolies and economic inequality. By providing methods for reaching consensus without a trusted third party, blockchain networks provide a blueprint for how some of these traditional governmental roles could be disintermediated by technology.</p><p>Money developed as a social technology to lubricate the exchange of goods and services by acting as a unit of account, medium of exchange and a store of value. Sound money, or money that maintains its value over time, is hugely beneficial for the smooth functioning of an economy. Gold coins or gold-linked paper currencies fulfilled that role well historically due to gold’s scarcity and high stock to flow ratio. Today, governments have monopolies on the printing of fiat currencies. Some of the worst economic collapses have been precipitated by excess governmental printing of currency to pay debts. Bitcoin provides some of the same benefits of gold through its algorithmically limited supply, but also allows nearly free and instantaneous transfer anywhere in the world, something only possible with a digital asset.</p><p>Changes in biological evolution become hardcoded into DNA and are not easily reversible. Changes in social technology that come from the propagation of new ideas can happen much more quickly, but do not have the same permanence. This mutability can be looked at as both a feature and bug as it results in much greater dynamism but also greater fragility. History contains many cautionary tales of groups that have seemingly made the shift into productive economic competition only to collapse into violence. Granting the government a monopoly on violence, including the initiation of force, comes with the risk that government power could be subverted or appropriated towards private ends. Often this is done under the guise of correcting the unjust results of the market economy, but always makes society worse off when prosecuted to the extreme.</p><p>Wealth creation is best understood as movement along our fitness landscape towards greater peaks of utility. The faster the evolutionary algorithm of capitalism operates, the more wealth can be created. Red tape and bureaucracy slow this movement while technologies that facilitate permissionless innovation can speed up this process. Regulations often trap our progress at a local maxima of fitness, increasing the costs to explore a new peak. Entrepreneurship is the most effective mechanism for exploring new peaks of fitness, a topic I will discuss in more detail in the next section. Redistributive schemes may appear to reach more Pareto optimal outcomes on paper, but can reduce risk taking and require a static view of wealth rather than one that embraces the dynamic and chaotic process of creative destruction that is responsible for its growth.</p><h3>Part II: Technologically-Driven Growth</h3><p>Economic growth has traditionally come from a combination of sources including building economies of scale, exploiting natural resources, developing capital markets, the comparative advantage of wage and input price arbitrage and inventing new emerging technologies. While many of these sources provided rapid initial growth, they can only move us to a local maxima in our fitness landscape resulting in decreasing marginal utility. Only emerging technologies allow us to explore completely new peaks in our fitness landscape. As a result, economic growth will increasingly be driven by new technologies.</p><p>Biological evolution optimizes fitness parsimoniously with prior structures being reused and repurposed through minute genetic mutations. Physical technologies also generally develop similarly through incremental improvements from prior generations. Breakthrough technologies invent entire new categories and may be extremely innovative, but are always unique combinations of components and innovations from prior technologies. In this way, <a href="https://www.nyas.org/magazines/winter-2010/what-is-technology-and-how-does-it-evolve/">technological evolution is best described as combinatorial</a>. At their lowest level, physical technologies are composed of base technologies that harness a natural phenomenon for productive means — such as the ability of silicon to act as a semiconductor. The organization of science itself as a collective enterprise is the social technology responsible for the creation of new base technologies. While it is possible to invent a new technology in isolation, the systematic sharing and critical review of experimental results turns the process into one of recursive self-improvement. Without continuous advances in physics or another of the hard sciences, sustainable technological growth is impossible to maintain.</p><p>New technologies do not immediately move us to a new point on the fitness landscape. Emerging technologies inspire competing narratives of how they will affect that frontier. Competing technologies may go through similar hype cycles and only some will actually get widely adopted. It is only after a technology moves through its <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_Revolutions_and_Financial_Capital">deployment phase</a> that we really can see its overall effect. By that time, there will already be multiple new emerging technologies competing for mindshare. We may not move to a slightly better place on the fitness landscape if the switching costs are too high relative to the efficiency benefits. New technologies must often be an order of magnitude better to cause a shift.</p><p>The question of whether a new technology will be successful is often a function of timing rather than the feasibility of the idea itself. Financial viability is determined by where component technologies are on their cost/performance trajectory. For this reason, it is common to see many startups pursuing the same objective all emerge at the same time. Even in science, simultaneous coinvention is the rule rather than the exception. This phenomena indicates that most scientific discovery emerges from the current zeitgeist rather than from individual works of genius. However, iconoclast scientists and entrepreneurs are sometimes able to influence the direction of technology. Businesses that explicitly go after novel hard problems are able to monopolize the best talent in that area and impact the direction of progress as shown by Elon Musk’s companies Tesla and SpaceX.</p><p>The invention of computation-based information technology unlocked a new peak of fitness where <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424053111903480904576512250915629460">innovation could happen through software</a> rather than hardware. General purpose computation allows any physical technology to be emulated by software. Software, unlike other physical technologies, does not require new physics advancements for breakthroughs. Exponential increases in the cost-to-performance ratio of general purpose computation, captured by Moore’s Law, allow more and more physical technologies to be replaced by software. Innovation with electrons through digital information is fundamentally more efficient than through atoms. Digital information can be copied with nearly zero marginal cost enabling rapid prototyping and iteration. The price and speed asymmetries between hardware and software innovation mean that any technology that can become software will become software.</p><p>The shift to an information technology driven economy is characterized in accounting terms by a move from tangible investments (machinery, natural resources, etc.) to intangible investments (software, R&amp;D, etc.). In contrast to tangible investments, <a href="https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691175034/capitalism-without-capital">intangible investments are (1) sunk costs or generally more company-specific and harder to sell, (2) have more spillover effects or benefits to others besides the company making them, (3) are much cheaper to scale and (4) have more synergies or additional value in the right combinations</a>.</p><ul><li>The scalability of intangible assets has led to somewhat paradoxical results. Coase’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm">Theory of the Firm</a> tells us that company formation occurs because transaction costs make it cheaper to internalize specific jobs functions into a corporate hierarchy. Based on this theory, as technology reduces transaction costs firm sizes should shrink. Instead, we are seeing one or two massive companies dominate each information technology vertical. The scalability of intangible assets explains this phenomenon. When minute improvements to an algorithm can result in millions of dollars of extra revenue, transaction costs are a negligible consideration compared with the potential upside of internalizing those job functions. Data scale advantages realized through machine learning and network effects bolster the scalability effect. There is no reason to use the second best product when the best product is just a click away. Open source projects and emerging blockchain technologies may provide an alternative path for capturing intangible scalability effects without concentrating the rewards in a small number of firms.</li><li>Spillover effects are observable in the market anytime a company releases a novel feature that is immediately copied by its competitors or an employee takes a job with a competitor. Knowledge and ideas are non-rival, meaning that use by one party does not prevent another party from exploiting them. Intangible or knowledge spillover effects also occur between people. As social creatures, technical knowledge is transferred between people either explicitly through conferences and whitepapers or more implicitly through social interaction and observation. These spillovers confer a benefit to living in proximity to other people and businesses at the cutting edge of a specific field and results in the geographic concentrations of certain industries. Silicon Valley is the best example of this. Top engineers know their knowledge and earning power will increase faster if they move to Silicon Valley. As talent concentrates in these locuses of knowledge businesses follow suit, resulting in a self-reinforcing loop. This trend is likely to continue concentrating talent and expertise until virtual social interaction rivals that of the physical world. COVID-19 lockdowns have already accelerated this timeline.</li><li>The combinatorial nature of technology means assets are more valuable when combined with each other in novel ways rather than in isolation. This synergy value occurs between tangible assets but is even stronger between intangibles given their scalability and non-rival characteristics. This effect means the first entity to come up with a new technology may not be the one to reap the benefits. Instead the benefits will go to whomever figures out how to combine it with other technologies in the most synergistic way. Patents, particularly those for software or other technologies built primarily from intangible assets, are not needed to encourage innovation given this dynamic. The costs of originally implementing an idea in software are small compared with those of deploying it at scale. Attempting to reduce intangible spillover effects through the legal system is a significant waste of resources.</li></ul><p>Information technology periodically sees new architectural paradigms that radically reorganize how computation is carried out. These shifts have often been between more centralized and decentralized architectures. Some examples include the shift from mainframe computers to personal computers (decentralizing) and the shift from desktop applications to cloud computing (centralizing). Blockchain technology, starting with Bitcoin, emerged as a new architectural paradigm pushing us in the decentralized direction.</p><ul><li>The internet consists of a set of core protocols such as TCP/IP and DNS that allow disparate hardware and software systems to communicate with each other in a decentralized manner. Missing from this protocol suite was a way to transfer value. Bitcoin emerged in 2008 to fill this gap with a novel solution to the Byzantine Generals Problem, a longstanding problem in distributed systems on how to reach consensus in a network without trusting all nodes. The brilliance of the solution is that it combines a <a href="https://www.gwern.net/Bitcoin-is-Worse-is-Better">unique combination of concepts</a> from cryptography and distributed systems with a set of supporting economic incentives.</li><li>Bitcoin transactions are small scripts which cryptographically sign ownership of Bitcoin from one address to another. Blockchain scripts can also be used for more complex financial contracts. There is no technical reason why distributed ledger systems could not handle all types of financial transactions including complex derivatives. We are already seeing growth in some of these applications on the Ethereum blockchain through the DeFi movement. Disintermediation of financial services by blockchains would eliminate the exorbitant fees paid to firms for simply acting as intermediaries between those seeking to invest capital and those seeking to raise capital, thereby massively reducing the friction introduced into the economy by financial firms extracting rent as gatekeepers.</li><li>Smart contracts are contracts written in code on a distributed blockchain which facilitate algorithmic executability. When terms of the contract are met, execution occurs without any third party involvement. In effect, code can be turned into law. Potential third party arbitration can also be written directly into a contract through a multi-signature transaction.</li><li>Initial coin offerings (ICOs) provide a decentralized funding mechanism and, unlike traditional IPOs, the tokens issued can be used transactionally. This structure has the benefit of aligning the incentives of all business stakeholders as all parties benefit from appreciation in the underlying token. If popularized, we could see the next generation of internet companies running as decentralized protocols. This shift would be the most significant social technology breakthrough since the limited liability joint stock corporation, a structure that first allowed concentrated risk taking with a diversified investor base who could buy and sell their shares at a market clearing price.</li><li>Ethereum greatly expanded the scope of blockchains to include distributed computation featuring a Turing complete programming language. This expansion enables nearly limitless use of blockchains, although the additional overhead of running computations this way currently limits its usefulness to areas where censorship resistance is more important than efficiency. A potential use case of this technology is distributed autonomous organizations, truly decentralized organizations governed by rules coded in smart contracts.</li></ul><h3>Part III: Technology and the Evolution of Modern Government</h3><p>All government systems are social technologies subject to evolutionary pressures, but are more resistant to change given the centrality of violence to their operation. Governmental power and legitimacy is derived from the threat or application of violence, making it risky to challenge. Sufficient pressure to radically change government generally comes from either prolonged stagnation or regression along the fitness frontier and/or a highly disruptive new technology. Drawing heavily from Davidson and Rees-Mogg, three types of technological change are most relevant to consider in this context:</p><ul><li>Technology of violence — The dispersal of weaponry in the population and the balance of power between offensive and defensive weapons directly influence the potential size and scope of government. The concentration of all effective weaponry in the hands of the state enables a more totalitarian government. When the balance of power is tipped towards offensive weapons, larger states who can direct more economic resources to the machinery of war are at a significant advantage. When defensive weapons become more powerful on balance, states can operate at a smaller scale while still ensuring the security of their citizens.</li><li>Technology of governance — Information technologies from writing systems and accounting ledgers in prior eras to computer networks today are essential to run governments. In prior eras, how dispersed these technologies were in the economy determined the superiority of governmental capabilities relative to private enterprises. Today, many private corporations have significantly better technical capabilities than most governments. As information technology has become the most dominant technology, the advantages of centralized vs. decentralized computing architectures directly influences the relative effectiveness of large central governments vs. more dispersed governance structures.</li><li>Dominant technology driving wealth creation — Governments, including their coevolved social technologies, are adapted to the dominant technological paradigm at the time of their creation. A change in the dominant technology can necessitate a radical evolution in government. Failure to evolve to new realities eventually leads to stagnation and decline, corrupting obsolete institutions in the process. The economies of scale of the dominant technology, particularly with respect to labor, also influence the ideal size of government. The technology of the internet is both global in scale and decentralized by design, leading opposing groups to contradictory conclusions about its effect.</li></ul><p>Human cooperation within any political system is facilitated by certain shared truths. As Yuval Noah Harari argues in his book <em>Sapiens</em>, we internalize these stories about religion or political ideology to such a degree that we are willing to die for them, unable to see their arbitrariness. He refers to these stories as myths or imagined realities, but they can also be explained in our evolutionary framework as examples of coevolved social technologies. While within any historical period we view these myths as unchangeable, divine or natural laws, they are in fact always subject to change.</p><p>The nation state developed as the dominant social technology in response to the physical technology of the industrial age. The inventions of the printing press and gunpowder weapons created the conditions necessary for the Industrial Revolution and with it a radical evolution in government. The printing press allowed for the mass production and decentralized distribution of knowledge, altering the technology of governance by breaking the Church’s monopoly on knowledge distribution. Gunpowder democratized force by shifting the balance of power from armored knights to minimally trained soldiers carrying guns, significantly altering the technology of violence. Suddenly, military supremacy went to whomever could marshall the greatest amount of economic resources into building armies. The military imperative to expand economic output paired with scientific advancements enabled by the printing press led to the development and rapid rise of industrial technologies. Industrial production replaced agriculture as the dominant source of wealth creation, rewarding the larger-scale political arrangements of nation states capable of organizing vastly more labor and capital into centralized commercial and legal frameworks.</p><p>Coevolving with the nation state came the social technologies of mass democracy and nationalism. Previously unaffiliated lands combined under a manufactured national identity generally anchored by a shared language. Just as chivalric oaths were responsible for compelling an armed knight onto the battlefield in support of his king, nationalism is responsible for motivating millions to lay down their lives in support of the abstract notion of a nation. In this context it is easy to see why efforts like nation building rarely work. Successfully adopting mass democracy requires the coevolution of a suite of complementary social technologies. National identity must supersede any tribal or religious identities.</p><p>Mass democracy provides a check against tyranny of the worst kind, but also provides a justification for the confiscation of private wealth for the state. When combined with a capitalist economy, this feature/bug results in a competitive advantage in a world where military supremacy is a function of the quantity of resources spent on weapons and soldiers, but carries some long-term risks. Mass democracies are particularly susceptible to the failure case of populism where the tyranny of the majority is abused at increasing levels to advantage some groups at the expense of others. A large middle class reduces the risk of this failure scenario by aligning the incentives of more voters with respect to tax and transfer payment policies. The growth of the middle class occurred as a direct consequence of industrial era physical technology that required large amounts of semi-skilled human labor to scale, a dynamic that may not continue in the information era.</p><p>With the development of nuclear weapons, large nation states gained the ability to destroy the world many times over. Past this point, pouring more and more resources into military expenditures makes less economic sense as the doctrine of mutually assured destruction limits the scale of war. Terrorism subsequently emerged as the larger threat. As the theater of conflict parallels technology’s movement from the physical to digital world, cybersecurity will become the bigger concern. Knowledge and intangible assets can not be easily appropriated through armed conflict. This characteristic reduces the incentives for physical warfare, but increases those for cyber-warfare and corporate espionage. Given these shifts in the technology of violence, governments no longer need to operate at the same scale to provide their most fundamental product, that of protection.</p><p>Democratic governments often grow rapidly during crisis periods and tend to maintain much of that size when the crises are over. Groups benefiting from new programs fight to keep them and there is less of an incentive for the rest of the population to rally against them given their dispersed costs. Politicians are only held accountable to the next election cycle, making it someone else’s responsibility to pay the future liabilities from debts incurred today. However, the tendency to achieve political compromise by spending more money is only sustainable in a rapidly expanding economy. Beginning in the 1970s, economic growth driven by industrial era technology slowed, but instead of adjusting our expectations to the new reality we have continued to borrow and spend a nonexistent surplus. Without that surplus, political battles have become more zero sum and increasingly partisan and acrimonious.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*aCWkPxXfCdEZ0okh" /></figure><p>Tyler Cowen writes in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Stagnation"><em>The Great Stagnation</em></a>: “We have been living off low-hanging fruit for at least three hundred years. We have built social and economic institutions on the expectation of a lot of low-hanging fruit, but that fruit is mostly gone.” It is of course possible that a new source of significant growth is just on the horizon with some potential sources including cheap fusion energy, genetic engineering, asteroid mining based natural resource extraction and nanotechnology. However, in the absence of such a technical breakthrough, there is a real sense in which our <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nM9f0W2KD5s">growth has slowed either from exhausting the sources of easily exploitable ideas from science or a cultural shift that makes us less willing to take risks</a>. It is this mismatch between economic growth and institutional and societal expectations that is most responsible for the widespread feeling that something is fundamentally broken in our system.</p><p>It may seem strange to suggest stagnation along our fitness frontier when company valuations are increasing and we have shiny new gadgets every year. However, in examining the areas where GDP growth has come in the West, the growing backlash against financial elites makes more sense.</p><ul><li>More debt increases the leverage of businesses and thereby their returns to equity holders, but only at increased risk of default. Increases in leverage across the economy, encouraged by the deductibility of interest expense, creates systemic risk and more potential for large financial crises. When companies are bailed out and management not held financially responsible, we create a significant moral hazard problem amounting to a type of social welfare for the rich.</li><li>Globalization enables cheaper goods through labor cost arbitrage, but abundant cheap human labor slows technological progress by reducing the return on investment of automation. Its benefits are also more limited in the outsourcing country if comparable jobs are not available for displaced workers. Productivity growth slowed as job growth moved to the services sector where efficiencies are harder to achieve through technology. The jobs that have been automated are generally more routine middle-income jobs. Both high-paying creative jobs and low-paying complex physical labor jobs have been less affected leading to an increase in inequality.</li><li>Exponential technological progress has been limited to fitting more transistors on a wafer of silicon and similar processes. Software continues to disintermediate existing industries as a result, but simply does not require as much labor as legacy industries. The winner-take-all dynamic in information technology industries results in fewer employers, with each enjoying monopoly level profits. Even in industrial and non-IT sectors, an increasing percentage of growth is coming from the use of software and other intangibles assets requiring less incremental labor. Finally, many of the greatest benefits of information technologies are non-material and don’t show up in GDP statistics. Even the cheapest smartphone now grants instant access to the world’s information and nearly free global communication. This progress has improved people’s lives on many qualitative dimensions, but not always their economic prospects.</li></ul><p>While slowing growth in industrial technologies is leading to stagnation along our fitness frontier, some of the core coevolved social technologies of the nation state are also losing relevance. Information technologies are leading directly to an erosion of national identity.</p><ul><li>Spending most of our time online and in VR loosens the bonds with our physical relationships and allows us to form new virtual communities with people with shared interests globally. Group affiliations like national identity have exploited the natural human tendency towards tribalism to build the manufactured allegiance of nationalism based on the accident of historical locality. While it was possible for this myth to operate when we were still generally siloed in our local communities, it is harder to maintain on a globally networked planet.</li><li>Identity politics and intersectionality separate people into categories of privilege and oppression instead of encouraging notions of common humanity. The popularity of this more recent flavor of social justice, in contrast to prior movements, erodes rather than strengthens the conditions necessary to maintain a shared national identity. On the left, a crusade against politically incorrect ideas is stifling free speech, shrinking the Overton window and causing many to fear they will be <em>cancelled</em> for saying the wrong thing. On the right, identity politics is playing into the fears of economically declining rural white voters resulting in the reemergence of racially tinged populism. Both sides have seen honest debate turn into performative virtue signaling toward the ideological purity of their respective tribe. While not directly related to information technology, the prosecution of these ideas has been facilitated and accelerated by the internet and especially social media.</li><li>A real or imagined common enemy has often been required to get diverse nation states to operate cooperatively. Some of the periods of greatest unity have been after foreign attacks or during wartime. Without a mythical ‘other’ to act as a foil for internal problems, such as the Soviet Union did for the US during the Cold War, societal cohesiveness is harder to maintain. Instead, internal factions are left with no one to blame except each other. China’s meteoric rise coupled with its explicit rejection of liberal norms may lead to it emerging as a new common enemy, but only at significant cost due to high levels of economic interdependence.</li><li><a href="https://medium.com/deep-code/understanding-the-blue-church-e4781b2bd9b5">Mass media acted as part of the government apparatus by constructing a common narrative that supported social coherence</a>. The internet has shattered that common narrative by providing a platform to thousands of dissenting voices. As our sense making institutions moved from an oligopoly of media conglomerates to social media platforms, there has been an increase in extremist views, political partisanship and mob outrage. With declining economic prospects, traditional news media outlets have embraced an activist mindset previously restrained by the need to appeal to a broad audience.</li></ul><p>We are now at an inflection point where the evolutionary pressures from gunpowder and industrialization that led to the nation state becoming the dominant form of government have shifted. Continuation along our information technology led growth trajectory necessitates new social technologies including new forms of government.</p><ul><li>Investments are increasingly intangible, work is increasingly digital and business is increasingly transacted through the internet. These trends reduce the need to live under the laws and taxation schemes of western democracies.</li><li>It is hard for mass democracy to function in an environment with a small middle class given the incentive to use the coercive power of government to extract and redistribute private resources.</li><li>Political infighting, brought about by the mismatch between stagnating productivity and the high growth assumptions implicit in the structure of most institutions, will only increase without new breakthrough technologies outside of information technology.</li><li>The extreme functional incompetence of politics-obsessed governments and supranational organizations has been laid bare by the COVID-19 pandemic.</li><li>National identity based on the accident of physical locality is breaking down thanks to the internet. People are less willing to sacrifice financially for their government as a result.</li><li>Governments no longer need to operate at the same scale to provide physical protection for their citizens.</li><li>Younger generations are being forced to pay into unsustainable redistributive schemes for prior generations while facing worse economic prospects. They are both the most disadvantaged by the current system and the most familiar with the information technologies necessary to circumvent it.</li><li>Bitcoin and other crypto assets provide a way to secure wealth from confiscation putting pressure on traditional fiat currencies.</li><li>Increasing debt and deficits make society prone to financial crises each of which has been addressed by massive increases to the money supply and public sector debt. These responses increase the risk that a future crisis will snowball into a full blown currency crisis leading to a devaluation of fiat currency. Such a scenario would pose an existential risk to the legacy political system.</li></ul><h3>Part IV: Future Unfolding</h3><p>Given the primacy of technological growth in our model, it is possible to sort our possible futures into four potential trajectories based on the rates of growth in industrial and information technologies. While our current trajectory of accelerating information technology is likely to continue, all scenarios are explored below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-tOB7isEqCA-_gYIDGi9Eg.png" /></figure><h3>Stagnation → Authoritarianism</h3><p>Broad technological stagnation is a nightmare scenario for liberal democracies. While the economic benefits of information technology growth have not been evenly shared, they still provide a desperately needed source of wealth creation. Exponential information technology growth driven by smaller transistors is a few generations away from running into the <a href="https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4567410">limits of quantum physics</a>. If we are unable to continue this process through another architectural paradigm, we could face the prospect of decelerating growth in both information and industrial technologies, stalling progress along the fitness frontier. This scenario would cause major societal problems and likely lead to violence and populist authoritarian rule.</p><h3>Resuscitation → Status Quo</h3><p>Part III outlined how industrialization led to the modern nation state and how the shift to information technology is radically altering those conditions. Although most people recognize that our political system is increasingly dysfunctional, debate is stuck over how to use government power to turn back the clock and make the present look more like the past. However, the internet and information technologies are only becoming more central to our lives. Any attempt to maintain the status quo in perpetuity requires reverting progress to a lower point on the fitness landscape and unacceptably high levels of coercion.</p><ul><li>Increasing barriers to trade reduces the ROI of outsourcing and could return some middle-income manufacturing jobs. However, attempting to re-industrialize through trade policy makes goods more expensive for everyone, reallocates capital toward lower growth industries and hurts people in other countries trying to climb out of poverty.</li><li>Passing laws barring misinformation on social networks sounds like an easy way to combat extremist views, but is based on a fundamentally incorrect assumption. This assumption is that increased divisiveness is the work of bad actors who can be censored out of existence. Instead, the reason it is so easy for the internet to increase tribalism and social division is that national identity was always a tenuous social construction. There is only one model for how the internet can be prevented from allowing dissenting voices to distribute their messages. That model is China, and the example it provides is a dark and dystopian one. Using liberal governmental power to attempt to control what messages are disseminated online will be no more effective than the Church attempting to censor the output of the printing press by banning certain books.</li><li>Greatly increasing income redistribution through more progressive taxation could decrease income inequality, but is an unsustainable solution at current growth rates. &lt;1% productivity growth simply does not provide the surplus wealth necessary to support wide scale income transfer payment schemes such as Universal Basic Income. Using governmental power to enforce equality of outcome also reduces the incentives that make capitalism work and provides a strong incentive for productive people to escape from the jurisdictions of governments pursuing that agenda.</li><li>The globalizing effect of information technologies has led some to argue that the world would benefit from a single unified government. There were significant advantages to larger scale in political arrangements in the industrial era. More labor and capital operating in a single market under a consistent legal, regulatory and monetary framework helped achieve greater economies of scale and reduce transaction costs. However, this approach doubles down on a failing social technology. The same problems now affecting democratic nation states would apply to any world government, simply magnified to an even greater scale.</li></ul><p>If nation states can not return to the past economically and can not rebuild a shared national identity that leaves only one productive option: growth. While it is not clear growth in industrial and other non-information technologies can reach its previous levels, there are cultural and policy changes that could increase it. Although this post has focused on what will happen rather what should happen, it is at least worth mentioning some actions a theoretically competent nation state could pursue.</p><ul><li>Regulations and bureaucratic red tape significantly limit innovation. Too many scientific advancements never make it out of the laboratory due to the regulatory costs of deploying them at scale. Governments could radically reduce red tape in areas like healthcare and biotech to allow permissionless innovation similar to what has worked so well for information technologies.</li><li>Too much human capital is currently wasted on zero sum activities. We could disincentivize, either through tax policy or social pressures, the wasting of vast amounts of human capital on zero or minimal sum activities. Think less public market investing and advertising optimization and more high risk/reward greenfield scientific research.</li><li>More smart people should pursue the sciences and engineering. The social status of scientists and inventors could be higher to reflect the enormous value accrued from emerging technologies. Science fiction and media could promote more optimistic visions of the future including new speculative technologies.</li><li>Human capital should be liberated from dysfunctional political and economic environments. Immigration could be massively expanded for technically trained individuals.</li><li>More capital should be allocated towards technology entrepreneurship. Capital gains taxes could be eliminated for venture capital and legal avenues opened for startup crowdfunding and token sales.</li><li>Large companies should spend more of their cash reserves on emerging technology research and development. The tax deductibility of interest expense could be removed and replaced with an incentive for R&amp;D spending.</li><li>Resources should go into large scale scientific projects. We could launch multiple Manhattan Project level initiatives in areas like fusion energy, quantum computing and biomedicine.</li></ul><p>In the longer-term, it is not a question of whether a new social technology will replace the nation state, but what that social technology will be. Even with faster economic growth, the behemoth nation states of the industrial era make little sense in an information technology driven world. However, its replacement could come about in two very different ways. If it comes through slowing technology growth, the result will be the chaos and decline of the Stagnation scenario. If change comes through competition from a new social technology, particulary amid a backdrop of accelerating technological growth, the result will contain the progress of the Virtualization or Realization scenarios.</p><h3>Virtualization → Decentralized Governance</h3><p>Continuing down our current path of exponential information technology growth with a slowdown in industrial era technology is the most likely and interesting scenario. Some implications of orders of magnitude improvements in computation include more industries being replaced by software, artificial intelligence algorithms playing a much bigger role in the economy and virtual reality at levels of visual fidelity matching the real world. As people’s digital lives overtake their physical lives in importance, blockchain-based governance structures have the potential to replace many legacy forms of government. On the cultural side, our social norms around work and how to find meaning in life will also change.</p><p>Experimentation with novel social technologies, including new forms of government, is necessary to identify new peaks of fitness in an information technology dominated world. In a free market economy, when a business no longer meets the needs of its customers, competitors emerge to meet shifting demand. Within the sphere of nation states, switching costs, including financial, legal and emotional, are prohibitively high for most people. As nation states are geographic monopolies and all land is already claimed, the question of how to inject competition into this realm is a difficult one. The best opportunities for a new physical frontier of experimentation can only come through competition between jurisdictions. However, purely digital experimentation through virtual communities is already possible. As the costs of citizenship increase relative to their benefits, there is an increasing incentive to simply opt-out of participation in legacy institutions by <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOubCHLXT6A">exiting virtually</a>. While this option was not previously feasible, the emergence of cryptocurrencies and blockchain technology makes it a realistic option.</p><ul><li>Access to the financial system has been used as a weapon against undesirable businesses with governments <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/money/2014/mar/23/operation-choke-point-payday-lenders-issa-banks">putting pressure on banks and payment processors</a> to cancel certain accounts. Transacting in Bitcoin negates this ability, although controls can still be implemented between crypto payments and the legacy financial system. Complete autonomy will become possible as the crypto ecosystem develops past the point where it ever becomes necessary to transfer value back into legacy fiat currencies.</li><li>While internet businesses operate globally, they can be forced to comply with local laws in any jurisdiction they hold sufficient assets to be used as leverage. Purely digital business transacting in cryptocurrency could be domiciled anywhere or nowhere and would remain immune from local laws or shakedowns. Although only a small number of businesses fit this description today, this number will only increase as cryptocurrency adoption grows and software disrupts more industries. Additionally, distributed protocol alternatives to centralized internet businesses are immune to government control by design. The more intrusive the regulatory burdens and censorship demands are on legacy internet businesses, the more attractive decentralized alternatives become.</li><li>DNS is the internet protocol responsible for linking domain names with IP addresses. The protocol is semi-distributed, but still relies on root servers to act as the ultimate source of truth. Control of the root servers has allowed the United States government to confiscate domain names of offending organizations. Blockchains can provide a completely decentralized alternative to DNS — originally demonstrated by Namecoin and now Ethereum. If governments continue to abuse their control over the internet’s namespaces there will be a move to fully decentralized censorship resistant alternatives.</li><li>Some governments use firewalls at the internet service provider level to block certain websites from their citizens. Proxy servers can be used to circumvent these controls and protocols such as Tor make it nearly impossible for governments to see or control what people do online. Should sufficient desire exist, there is nothing short of destroying internet infrastructure governments can do to prevent use of Bitcoin and other blockchain networks.</li></ul><p>Distributed autonomous organizations with internal governance mechanisms and smart contract based constitutions are already being implemented on Ethereum and other blockchains. So far, these governance structures are primarily used to control monetary policies, but could be expanded to come to consensus on other policy questions. The United States pioneered the social technology of constitutionally limited government with a system of checks and balances to attempt to stem the natural tendency of governments towards tyranny. The US Constitution attempts to use a natural language social contract to limit government power to only those specifically enumerated. Disputes over constitutionality are litigated through the courts system with the Supreme Court acting as the ultimate arbitrator. Through blockchain smart contracts this <em>ex post</em> system of checks and balances could be replaced with <em>ex ante</em> protections. In effect, the governing entity would literally be unable to act outside of specifically preprogrammed capabilities. This functionality allows experimentation with an entirely new class of governance social technologies that may be better adapted to the information era.</p><p>While democratic voting could be an implementation option in blockchain governance systems, decision making will likely occur either in proportion to asset holdings (proof-of-stake) or contributions to the network (proof-of-work). Consensus through either of these methods aligns the goals of the network with those most economically invested in it. If implemented in a traditional political system, these consensus methods create the potential for those with economic power to alter the rules of the system, benefiting themselves through rent seeking activity. Open-source blockchain systems mitigate this risk in three ways, virtual systems are easy to exit from, their code can be forked into a competing chain and all parties are economically incentivized toward the same Schelling point — an increase in the value of the underlying cryptocurrency or token. These strengths are not to suggest that blockchain networks are immune from organizational failure, most can and will fail, but through the evolutionary process of trial and error successful models will emerge.</p><p>The relatively stable club of nation states and their geographic monopolies have so far largely limited competition for the most valuable asset, smart people and their accumulated knowledge and entrepreneurial drives. Once competition for these people begins in earnest, rapid change is possible. Although it is impossible to predict the exact form of this change, the increasingly digital nature of economic activity will limit the ability of bad actors to use violence to achieve their goals. Governance structures based on voluntary association must treat people as customers rather than revenue generating assets to have any chance of success in a competitive marketplace. Mature blockchain networks where users are already transacting, entering into contracts and participating in governance will be the obvious choice to run information technology focused societies. While governments will likely operate at a smaller scale, distributed protocols will link everyone globally into interoperable financial and communication networks. Some of these networks may pivot into also providing physical security to their users, or that may be provided by separate entities offering their services to competing blockchain social contract networks.</p><p>In addition to changes in governance, an information technology based society will develop new cultural norms. Mass manufacturing relied on machinery and businesses processes that enabled people of various skill levels to produce a consistent product. With information technology this normal distribution of employee output moved to a power law distribution. Some employees, particularly engineers, are able to produce 10x more output than other colleagues. This phenomena makes sense given that technology acts as a multiplier on a person’s productivity. As technology advances, that multiplier increases as well, but so do the cognitive requirements of leveraging it. Not everyone has the intelligence or desire to exercise that level of cognitive ability, and we will be forced to accept that we can not simply retrain everyone to become productive engineers.</p><p>Advances in artificial intelligence will lead to more job losses. Machine learning, a subset of AI, uses statistical algorithms on data to enable computers to make probabilistic inferences without needing preprogrammed rulesets. It has recently made significant leaps through neural network algorithms running on specialized hardware. Although most of the popular machine learning algorithms have been around for a number of decades, it is only recently that the <a href="https://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.com/en//pubs/archive/35179.pdf">quantity of data</a> and computational power have made these advances possible. So far, these advances have been limited to predefined problems in limited domains (e.g., games, speech/image recognition). However, even with these limitations, machine learning is achieving above human level performance in an increasing number of tasks making it a better substitute for human labor.</p><p>Our social norms were developed in an era when personal industriousness and labor force participation were the main drivers of growth. We have internalized the Protestant work ethic to such a degree that people now gain their self worth from their job success. While work is a meaningful intellectual challenge for some people, for most a 9–5 job is pure drudgery that makes them miserable. However, given the societal pressures to work, many people fall into depression when they are unemployed. Ultimately, people need a creative outlet and often the ability to triumph in some type of struggle in order to be happy. Artisanal crafts and hobbies with enthusiast communities can provide this outlet. Video games, especially VR, will become the mainstream way of fulfilling this need.</p><p>Meditation and the Buddhist idea of freeing ourselves from the cycle of constant desire is also an effective way of bringing contentment to people. Psychedelic drugs in the right setting can have similar, albeit temporary, brain effects to dedicated meditation and are a great way to open people up to its potential. Even drugs as demonized as opiods can be used safely and it is their illegality that has caused the vast majority of the societal damage. We should realize that many people can use these substances without becoming addicted. Even choosing to <em>opt-out</em> into a permanent state of chemical induced ecstasy should be socially acceptable. Society can provide treatment options for people trying to get clean, but should also remove the stigma around using mind-altering substances. The idea that all people have to work to be productive members of society will fade as a social norm.</p><p>Living a digital existence will erode the importance of location. Real estate continues to be a source of wealth inequality. Housing appreciation has been most significant in urban areas with high concentrations of intangible-heavy businesses. The fact that so many people want to move to San Francisco given its exorbitant rent, homelessness and human waste problems speaks to the power of intangible spillover effects. In urban areas with tight housing markets much of the <a href="https://qz.com/169767/the-century-old-solution-to-end-san-franciscos-class-warfare/">economic surplus ends up being transferred to landlords</a>. Although the beginning of the information era has seen an increase in the amount of real estate driven inequality, it will decrease it in the long term as more interactions become virtual, reducing the importance of physical location.</p><p>Privacy will become impossible to enforce necessitating new culture norms. Data is becoming cheaper and easier to collect and we have become better at applying the right machine learning algorithms to it to extract meaningful insights. While it is easy to denounce governments spying on their own citizens and large internet companies engaging in surveillance capitalism, in the long run it will become impossible to maintain an expectation of privacy as information technology improves past a certain level. Even a radical rearchitecting of the internet with personal data stored encrypted under pseudonymous digital certificates would not make people immune from having statistical inferences made about them. Any attempts at effectual bans would amount to making statistical analysis on certain types of data illegal. Instead, culture will have to adapt to the point where people realize that everyone engages in certain behaviors society considers deviant and ethical judgements of victimless crimes are abandoned.</p><p>Free, high quality education will become the norm. Education has turned into a massively expensive credentialing service. College education outside of the sciences simply indicates someone has jumped through a number of hoops and is motivated to be an obedient employee rather than qualified for anything in particular. The internet is making access to information and learning free and will cause the bubble in higher education to burst. This shift will help level out the equality of opportunity by giving all people access to the same educational options at near zero cost.</p><p>Poverty will be eliminated in terms of being able to afford the necessities of life, although not necessarily on current income-based formulations. We will think about quality of life in very different terms as a result. While inequality gets the bulk of media attention, the greater cause of human suffering is poverty. In alleviating the consequences of poverty, technological progress has been an unquestionable success, making food and goods available at vastly cheaper costs. Through cheap bioengineered nutrition, free virtual education, the decreased importance of location and the nearly limitless possibilities offered by virtual reality, information technologies will provide a base level quality of life better on many dimensions than can even be purchased by the wealthy today.</p><p>Although not the post-scarcity world promised by some futurists, virtual reality grants everyone the ability to transcend the limits of the physical world. While the internet began the process of moving our lives into the digital realm, virtual reality will supercharge that process. The human brain has no direct sensory capability, instead it constructs our reality from electrical signals transferred into the brain from our sensory organs. While VR still looks like a toy technology limited to games and entertainment, it will eventually be able to construct a <a href="https://www.seedmagazine.com/content/article/why_we_havent_met_any_aliens/">reality of our choosing</a>. Display technology at or above the level of the human eye, rich 3D gasound and full body tracking will all be commonplace in a few more generations of the technology. Realistic haptics, stimulation of the vestibular system and complex olfactory experiences will eventually emerge as well. As this technology improves, both its productive uses and escapist appeal will rapidly increase. After all, while the real world may have great visual fidelity, its storylines are often bland and the gameplay boring and repetitive.</p><p>Artificial neural networks simulate hierarchical networks of neurons digitally. Based on current levels of technological progress we should expect neural networks with more simulated neurons than the human brain in the 2030s. What tasks these networks will actually perform above human levels remains to be seen. However, the success of projects such as DeepMind and GPT-3 at computational levels orders of magnitude below this threshold should make us optimistic about potential future capabilities. The holy grail of the field is artificial general intelligence (AGI). AGI refers to human-level generalized intelligence that is able to make accurate inferences after only a few training examples. The speed by which artificial intelligence can move from narrow applications to generalized intelligence is the primary variable for predicting future employment. Artificial general intelligence would in effect be the last invention humanity would ever need to make as above human level AGI would be able to make better versions of itself and take over the progression of the evolutionary fitness function.</p><h3>Realization → Singularity</h3><p>Should we be able to both continue our growth in information technology and restart growth in industrial technology there is the potential for a type of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-scarcity_economy">post-scarcity world</a> described by Peter Diamandis and others. Due to the combinatorial nature of technology development, accelerating growth in multiple scientific fields and categories of technology can result in a positive feedback loop of exponential progress. While it is theoretically possible to enter this scenario directly from our current circumstances, it is more likely to emerge from the Virtualization scenario after the development of artificial general intelligence. This future would make the labor of most people unnecessary, but would grant humanity god-like power and massive amounts of surplus wealth.</p><p>Existential risks are brought up by some philosophers as reasons to be wary of rapid technological progress. Commonly mentioned risks include global warming, nuclear weapons, synthetic bioweapons, self replicating nanotechnology and artificial intelligence. <a href="https://nickbostrom.com/papers/vulnerable.pdf">Nick Bostrom frames the problem through his concept of the ‘Urn of Invention’ — a metaphorical urn containing a ball for each possible invention in which there are some number of black balls that if picked would end human existence.</a> Interestingly, all of these risks with the exception of AI, are a function of our fragile physical existence and are significantly mitigated by a move to a more virtual existence. Technology that transfers human consciousnesses onto an electronic substrate could eliminate most of these risks entirely. As for superhuman AGI, when viewed through an evolutionary lens that holds progress as the ultimate good, it is hard to view it as an existential risk rather than a desirable next step.</p><p>Human existential despair is reasonable. We are conscious and sentient beings, but only smart enough to grasp our insignificance in the universe. Only through greater intelligence will we truly be able to address the fundamental scientific and philosophical questions of existence. Therefore, developing technologies that enhance our own intelligence or building artificial intelligence capable of tackling these questions should be our highest goal. Just as biological evolution gave rise to human-driven technological evolution, our destiny increasingly appears to be to unlock the next phase of evolutionary progress by breaking down the limitations of biologically constructed minds and bodies through artificial intelligence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-Bj3zxYk4SQrD27A5v0g-A.png" /></figure><p>Thanks to Gavin Wolf, Phillip Jen and Pablockchain Serrato for their help on previous drafts of this post.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e8a226331be8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>