<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Namita on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Namita on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@greyflak?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:13:09 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@greyflak/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Woman’ — Lost and found]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/woman-lost-and-found-7c51a5adfbf1?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7c51a5adfbf1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[womanhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lacan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 May 2021 11:10:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-27T11:10:11.043Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>‘Woman’ — Lost and found</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*rh6l9HZ4V0uMNIQO" /><figcaption>Dangerous Liasions by Rene Magritte</figcaption></figure><p>Of all the colors in the visible spectrum of light, blue does not reach us. This blue is the light that gets lost, scattered, giving the sky and the ocean its characteristic hue. Any true search for identity, of knowing and being who one is, starts with getting lost. To truly know oneself, one has to shake off the shackles that binds one to the structure, to one’s family, friends and get a taste of the unknown — to meet strangers, wander through alleys, change one’s name, fall, cry and walk back to where one started from.</p><p>In other words, any emancipatory politics begins with the loss of identity because it lays bare the veil of positive and stable identity of a conscious rational being with its pretense of sovereignty, self knowledge and self mastery. Psychoanalytic thought tries to understand ideological and psychological aspects of oppression by taking desire as the prime point of politics, by conceiving the subject as always split, divided, in relation to the world of objects. In the contemporary world rife with identity politics, where the term ‘woman’ has been conflated with all kinds of myths of female identity, whatever content to fill it up with to promote her as an empowered whole being, Lacan makes a rather provocative statement — ‘(the) Woman does not exist’.</p><p>For whatever the construction of woman is, her being is always enmeshed in relations of power structured by political economy, family and kinship systems. In the current capitalist system of production, sex/gender system can be said to exist within the relations of commodities exchange. A corollary can be drawn between oppression of women through various kinds of power-domination, discrimination by exploiting the sexual non- relation, and the fantasy of relation between use value and exchange value of commodity that gives rise to commodity fetishism.</p><p>The system exploits the non-relation in social ties and makes it profitable. The bourgeois nuclear family being the smallest viable economic unit, reproduction is tied to economics and female sexuality is controlled and regulated. Gayle Rubin, however, argues that oppression of women goes beyond the economic system, that it lies in the linguistic and kinship structures itself. Levi Strauss, a structuralist anthropologist, analysed kinship systems as a system of production based on exchange and circulation of women among men. The linguistic structure that undergirds this kinship structure makes meaning in the relation of signifiers itself, puts certain values on relations like mother, daughter, sister and so on. Therefore, subordination of women is a consequence of relationships by which sex and gender are organized and produced through language, economic oppression comes secondary.</p><p>Psychoanalysis in its Freudian — Lacanian vein deals with what happens after birth, how separation from the mother creates a duality of subject and object realized in presence and absence of mother and then through language. The child then realizes a lack, gap and splitting causing a rift with nature into the world of language and law. Sexuality then begins in infancy, as a way of encountering the self and the world. It is a concept that formulates a persisting contradiction of reality — its inherent twist. It is disruptive — constructive of identities, causes radical disorientation, operator of inhuman and essentially linked to the unconscious. As Freud says, human sexuality, even though covered in erasure and silencing is problematic because it is characterized by impossibility of full sexual satisfaction, even if all the barriers and restrictions are removed. So, there must be something else which is missing that completes it, and that point is the point of knowledge. Lacan said that the unconscious is structured like a language made of signifiers. This signifying structure has a gap, the point at which language fails, revealing its inadequacy and limit. This place of the missing signifier is where sexuality lies. Hence, sexuality is directly linked to knowledge, and as Alenka Zupancic puts it, is the point of a short circuit between ontology and epistemology. Subject is produced at the inherent limit of language and relates to the Other with ‘Objet a’ — the impossible object of enjoyment that is the missing link in the ontological signifying chain of reality and that is the objective counterpart of non-relation. He/she keeps repeating the desire for ‘Objet a’ because of the inherent deadlock of language that produces the experience of the inexperience able — that which can not be remembered or spoken.</p><p>When talking about what makes a man or a woman, Lacan doesn’t talk about any specific biological or anatomical essence that differentiates the sexes but he uses the term ‘sexual division’ to understand how the subject experiences sexuality on the level of the psyche, defining the cut in the symbolic order — two possible responses to castration. Therefore, male and female are symbolic positions as speaking beings that are castrated by the phallic function that includes language and speech. Sexuation is choosing our modes of being — getting a place in the social as sexed subjects.</p><p>This logic is very clearly stated in the diagram below -</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*7eR6nE3EboMBL003.png" /><figcaption>Logic of Sexuation</figcaption></figure><p>The left side is male and the right side is female. Both sides have to go through phallic function. The difference is the way in which they take that castration that makes them take the position of male or female.</p><p>While on the male side, all men have to go through the phallic function, and only one is exempted from it. On the female side, not all have to go through the phallic function, and there is no one who is not exempted from the phallic function. So masculinity and femininity are not positive or negative attributes but ways of being in the world with regard to language and speech. While the set of men is closed, and there is one man who escapes castration who is usually the primal father who is the source of law of castration that bears on desires of all others and not lets anyone enjoy. The set of woman on the other hand is not closed, there is no ideal of woman that gives the law of the land. Yet, there is a part of feminine jouissance that lies beyond phallic jouissance. While man’s ($) surplus jouissance is trapped by ‘Object a’ which is usually projected in the fantasy of the woman, woman (who does not exist) has two ways of desiring, either the phallic function on the male side or the signifier of the barred Other or the lack in the Other. The latter part is the supplementary jouissance that is only available on the female side. Therefore, the phrase ‘woman does not exist’ means that ‘woman’ is not an essence because a signifier for woman in the unconscious does not exist. ‘Women’ do not constitute a closure, a collective, a class. A biological female can take left side and a biological male can take the right side. Therefore, any positive identity of femininity or masculinity is fraudulent. While masculinity is a matter a of belief, an imposture, femininity a matter of pretense — masquerade. Joan Riviere describes masquerade as a play, as an attempt by a female to negotiate her subjectivity within the constraints of symbolic system, as a response to male fantasy — veiling of a lack, hiding of its nothingness, a failed attempt to match the Symbolic with the Real.</p><p>In the signifying structure of the Symbolic then, the subject of politics is always the subject of the unconscious. Any change in the symbolic system therefore has to come from the proletariat that is at the point of exploited structural negativity in touch with the Real that holds the possibility of both holding a system in place and also changing it. Any desire which seeks transformation must liberate itself from the confines of desire as structured by the market and must change alienated work to creative work. True feminist politics must then be to go beyond identity politics and create value by transforming mechanisms of production and existing social relations.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Goel, Rohit &amp; Ali, Nadia, 2019. <em>Lacan contra Foucault: Subjectivity, Sex, Politics</em>. Bloomsbury Academic Press.</p><p>Zupancic, Alenka, 2017. <em>What IS Sex?</em>. MIT Press.</p><p>Copjec, J., 2015. <em>Read my desire</em>. Cambridge: MIT Press.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7c51a5adfbf1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pandemic 2020–2021]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/pandemic-2020-2021-497688380a20?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/497688380a20</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 May 2021 10:15:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-27T11:02:56.363Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*r3LocysxhSLog66f.jpeg" /></figure><p>I.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“It’s the best possible time to be alive, when almost everything you thought you knew is wrong.” — Arcadia</em></strong></blockquote><p>Leaning on the balcony rails, gazing at the tall trees hiding behind the buildings ahead, I remember asking my mother as an eight year old, where the sky ended and the earth began. Fast forward twenty years of drifting across cities and countries, I find myself asking her the same question as we stare at the dark clouds merge into the Eastern seafront of the city.</p><p>That innocent question about the shape of the horizon to which my mother had laughed and replied with a non- sequitur has found a new meaning now as we come to the end of the year 2020 — the year that witnessed the great pandemic interspersed with regular storms, earthquakes, cyclones, forest fires and floods. While the horizon then etched the limit of my sight; with now acquired philosophical parlance, I relate it with the gap between our knowledge and reality, opening up the link between epistemology and eschatology. The question remains the same, while the horizon while teasing for a resolution reveals a severance to be mended by transformation and change perhaps in metaphysics.</p><p>I had ordered my first bunch of face masks in mid November, 2019. They arrived on time — neatly packed, nicely arranged in different colours, albeit, without any warning about what was to follow in the coming months. When asked what had made me buy them way before the global pandemic hit us, I humbly responded — my intuition and maybe on second thoughts, my ever present unconscious. There is no dearth of doomsday prophecies and fantastic end of the world scenarios, but mine was a subtle premonition — a direct experience you may say of knowing something about a future event before it occurred. As I ensconced myself in my room in the coming months, it was as unreal to me as it was to anyone, to see every human starting from the local vendors and security guards that one passes by on a daily basis to people around the world throng the streets and TV screens wearing all sorts of masks, much like the ones I had bought a year back.</p><p>I had all the symptoms before the actual ones started appearing — I had been agitating about the state of the world like a raging hysteric, making jokes about unnamed diseases, popping anti — depressants like its candy and socially isolating myself for past two years since I had returned from London having completed a stressful Master’s degree. Since dwelling in language, I had always felt that there is something absolutely fundamentally wrong about the way we live. Growing up, I had only learned how to articulate the gaps and the holes I could see. So, when it hit us, I was partially glad, if anything, it only revealed the truth about our modern global civilization — inequality, walls, isolation, alienation and digital communication and made us stare starkly at our own limitations. But, I did not imagine the scale of this. I certainly had never known what a pandemic is. This was the sort of stuff one read in history lessons and were things of the past, never to happen in this century.</p><p>Covid-19, lovingly called the Coronavirus has hit us pretty bad. Most activities are disrupted and we are confined to our homes, advised to maintain social distance from other specimens of our species — connected only through audio visual communication apps — most prominent among them Zoo(m) that allows us to interact with each other though square boxes in a grid. Resigned to peering through these digital windows of human zoos, we are facing each other with bewildered eyes and uncertain futures. We have now accepted ‘the new normal’, sitting at home, wearing masks, washing hands, using sanitizers and munching on whatever the news tells us. Time is suspended, we’re all in a limbo, nobody knows when we’ll go back to our old ways of being in the world. Science fiction enthusiasts and historians tell us that it’s not something unexpected, and to be better prepared for there’s much more to come — this is only the beginning. We are at the mercy of scientists sitting somewhere in the laboratories who might find a vaccine at some point which will be distributed across nations and its people at its own sweet time. Till then, this is our life, home-bound, staring into multiple screens, facing the biggest unknown — our own mortality.</p><p>While we are sipping on ginger tea, staring out at empty streets and following our doctor’s advice on building immunity, let’s zoom in on what the cause of this catastrophe is. In scientific parlance, it’s called a zoonotic spillover categorized as a natural disaster. Coronavirus (virus with a crown), measuring a few nanometres is non-sentient matter with no agency that when comes in contact with a living body cell, uses it as a host to multiply and propagate itself. It’s the most basic form of life — a packet of protein — genetic material (RNA) that mutates and becomes alive with a living host. Originally residing in animal species in forests who have built immunity over centuries — in this case possibly a bat or pangolin being sold in the wet market of Wuhan, China — it has now jumped to human species and has promiscuously transported itself around the globe, following the very complex and connected routes of global capitalism in its very versatile and active host — the human body. We’re confronted with this tiny matter that oscillates between life and death, and is invisible to the human eye. Something so minute holding tremendous power — enough to halt modern civilisation — ticking bomb to human arrogance and hubris.</p><p>Going through many restrictions, lockdowns and social isolation is tiring and can easily let us fall into despair. We can live in denial, move into our new normal ‘digital lives’, mark 2020 as a ‘bad year’ in our calendars, accept our fate, and sit with folded arms in wait for the vaccine OR we can use this time to look at what was wrong with us before and the world, learn and completely change the way we looks at life on this planet and the way we live in the 21st century. While this virus may look like an enemy to our individual life, but from the perspective of broader human history, I’d say it is a friend who has knocked our doors in our burning house. There was nothing normal about our society before this pandemic hit us.</p><p>Sure, we can crib about how the health care systems are not up to the mark, and complain about authoritarian governments enforcing new laws, but in all the cacophony and chatter, if we shut down and listen carefully we would hear the cracks in the engine revealing the faults in our system. There is something telling about the unpredictability of this pandemic, how it arrived without warning — but, now that it is here for good, let’s listen to its message and learn from our predicament.</p><p>Although it has affected people differently and divulged the ever widening class divide, two main things that have happened — We’re for once compelled to look into, nay acknowledge the existence of microscopic scale of matter and other things that are not visible and perceptible to the human eye and senses. The other — the collapse of the public/private space and work from home scenarios that will go on for the foreseeable future. Our lives are reduced to the basics of human survival — family, home, fire, food etc. While there are massive socio-political repercussions — recession, loss of jobs and livelihoods, war- like situations, I’d like to focus on my micro purview — things that are not in the news, not in the numbers and statistics of the counter.</p><p>Consider this lockdown static as a pause in our lives and appreciate the silence and stillness that has come with it. Now that we are working from home, and dead time has been reduced with all the online meetings, let’s once in a while look outside the window and hear song of birds who have reappeared on our horizons and window sills, notice the colour of the rising and setting sun and the changing shapes and brilliance of the moon.</p><p>The word “crisis” comes from the Greek verb “krinein,” meaning to choose, to decide between alternatives. Throughout history, pandemics have been a time for change, and we haven’t experienced this time before in recent modern history since perhaps the end of two wars in 20th century.</p><p>I propose we start from blank slate — as if we know nothing and consider my appeal for a paradigm shift in our thinking — to create possibility of creating value and meaning outside the structures that drive us — institutions that give rise to class, caste, gender inequalities that pervade oppression, violence and injustice. These structures that now govern us or that we have willingly created for ourselves are not going to last and need to dissolve and give rise to others. The transition, however must be smooth and peaceful. If we have to survive, we have to reorder, re construct and relive our futures and build new power structures, new families and new ways of working. We have to understand our situation in terms of whole systems, shift from myopic worldview and create for long term, using our imagination. It is also time to rethink the relationship between human and non-human world, human and nature while we are working on human-human connection in the digital world.</p><p>II.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“Do we really want what we say we want?” — Mark Fisher</em></strong></blockquote><p>Fisher’s last words were still ringing in my head while the doctor was diagnosing my illness. “It’s a serious case of depression. I’m afraid you wouldn’t be able to work but don’t stress, your problem is not yours alone — it’s a personal, political, planetary problem of futurity.” My professor suffered it, so are millions of young people who are stuck in this atrocious system.</p><p>It was the peak of London winter, I was still getting used to harsh winds and dark clouds in the daytime. On a cold Monday morning of the New Year, I thought I even saw snowfall and rejoiced for a bit. Before rushing for the morning lecture, I quickly checked my mail to find out that Mark Fisher, a teacher at my university whose class I had been auditing the week before had passed away. The timetable still showed that the class was on. Not sure whether I had read it correctly, I texted my friend who was equally taken aback.</p><p>The last glimpse I had of him was in a black coat and hat passing by the reception. I also vividly remember his last lecture in which I was sitting right next to him while he was reading out the names of students to mark the attendance for the day — I could see his hands and voice shivering while he struggled to pronounce my name right — that Indian girl in a yellow jumper staring hard into his sunken eyes. When I responded with an enthusiastic ‘Yes’, he smiled while throwing his fist on the table, half-joking about how the setting that day was like a scene from Kafka’s Trial. I had not known then that what I was experiencing that day was a man in his last days sincerely trying to show some direction to a bunch of young people. He had titled his seminar ‘Post-Capitalist Desire’ — instilling a ray a hope, a plea for change, in his rather bleak view of the modern world.</p><p>‘Capitalist Realism’ is a theoretical framework he had termed to understand our contemporary society and the ideology and value system that runs it — a sense that there is no alternative to this political economy and that there is no way out. With post-capitalist desire he showed us how Capital has inserted itself everywhere, it’s even in our food and bodies and everything we desire. He urged us to expand our political imagination and to yearn to desire for something beyond, and that victory could be achieved even if in the confines of current structures. He also mentioned how previous measures to engage in a counterlibido to capitalist desire failed in the 60’s and 70’s counter-culture because it didn’t think about long term plausibility. He also nudged us to stray away from Left melancholy and think that we already possess what we need to escape the confines of. His death was definitely a momentary event in my intellectual development and I was determined to find answers that I was very sure did not lie in academic institutions. What I could sense was a failure of contemporary left and protest movements for any change. Fisher suggested to dig deep in our histories to resuscitate ‘lost futures’ and make impossible happen. To create futures where there are none. He wrote — “the tiniest event can tear a hole in the grey curtain of reaction which has marked the horizons of possibility under capitalist realism. From a situation in which nothing can happen, suddenly anything is possible again.”</p><p>Can ‘value’ and ‘meaning’ be created outside this ‘reality’ matrix that we have created for ourselves? The purpose of philosophy is not just to interpret the world, but strive to change it. Any change or transformation would need patience — it’s not easy to change permanently such deep, long-lasting structures that have caused fear, misery and pain for the many.</p><p>“I want Truth, Beauty and Justice, and most of all peace and happiness.”</p><p>The doctor smiled.</p><p>III.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“Silence is the only phenomena today that is valueless. Everything else between the earth and the sky including air, water and fire have been absorbed the world of profit and utility.” — Max Picard</em></strong></blockquote><p>As I sit here isolated in the room of my suburban apartment, I can hear slow ticking of the wall clock, distant chirping of birds and the occasional sound of empty local train in the background that has stopped running for the first time in its entire history of plying from one end of the city to the other. I haven’t stepped out in months except the daily quiet morning walks. I have lost memory of the city streets, how they turned, the buildings, how they rose, the noise and clamour of commuters rushing to and from work, the colours and sounds of the bazaars and the rhythm of people in motion. For now, there is silence, the kind that allows time to reveal its mystery and power.</p><p>The current economic system that structures our global society has been posited to originate at a certain time in history. While there have been many postulations, Weber argues that the emergence of this way of working and living has a relation to religious belief and can be attributed specifically to the Protestant Reformation in England in the 16th century. This way of production went hand in hand with Enlightenment values and the rise of modern scientific and rational thought that believed in achievement of ideal human values manifested in advancement of our species through linear progress using all kinds of technology as a tool. This rational pursuit of profit for its own sake called the Protestant ethic was originally tied to pursuit of a calling and has now found home in the disenchanted atheistic materialist world by overcoming all kinds of otherwordly beliefs, rituals and practices. Through centuries of imperialism and colonization of space, time, mind and body, this western style of modernity came to dominate the entire globe and gave rise to modern myths and structures of the nation-state, corporate capitalism, mechanistic science, civil society, consumerism along with freedom, progress, fame, romance, and money.</p><p>There is no doubt that this wonderful system in which we are existing in the present and gives identity and meaning to the modern man manifests itself in hierarchical, phallocentric, and Eurocentric world views. It is based on Cartesian rationalist traditions that uses master instrumental reason as the logic of the market and public sphere that can club the whole of natural world into a single word “nature” and then claim to control its unpredictability and use its materials as “natural resources” for industrial development. Wild nature is worthless waste — an abomination in the eyes of capitalists, because it is a space of resources that has not yet been subjugated to the law of value.</p><p>‘Cartesian dualism’ is based on separation of human mind which has an independent substance from everything else that exists only in relation to it. This puts rational man at the centre of the universe, the crown of creation at the top of the chain, himself fragmented and lacking, brutally separated from and discontinuous with other species and the natural world. It justifies itself as the logic of colonisation and creates a sharply demarcated and devalued sphere of otherness that leads to oppression and domination of everything that is below this ‘reason’ — black and coloured people, women, indigenous tribes, animals etc.</p><p>This thought based on dichotomy, difference and duality creates separate categories of nature /culture, humans/animals/plants, mind/body, mind /matter, consciousness /reality, self/other, reason/emotion, public/private. Rationality of the economic system and scientific method exists by backgrounding of nature and denial on interdependence — nature is seen as setting stage in the foreground of which the drama of human civilization plays out. It is defined homogeneously and negatively with respect to humans, lacking human qualities and therefore not intelligent. A certain kind of masculine reason is valued over nature that includes the emotions, the body, physicality, sense experience, passions, animality, the primitive or uncivilized, the non- human world, as well as the sphere of irrationality, faith and madness.</p><p>This created an atomised autonomous Self existing in the realm of separation of subject and object, observer and observed, life and death, existence and non-existence, life and environment. Any damage to nature doesn’t directly affect the Self. If the origins of the modern world are religious, if work was supposed to give meaning and salvation, no wonder money is worshipped now. Even in the old organized religions like Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, Judaism that are taking new form in the far right nationalist politics — human life’s destiny is separate from other species, soul separate from nature. While this view has been going for centuries, and man seems helpless walking into his own oblivion in the face of ensuing climate disasters of which this pandemic is just a preview — the most basic of theological question is once again valid and relevant now — How do we find meaning in our work and lives? What will save us? What chances now exist for salvation in ‘end of times’?</p><p>At this moment, when science is struggling for answers to this disease and complex climate problems, is there maybe a time to look to philosophy and religion that can give our answers or help us imagine or even create a new world. Is there a metaphysics that can lead us to see and exist beyond the rationalist materialist paradigm? Is there any primordial knowledge that we posses that exists before we separate from our mothers and come into the world of language and dualism, something we already know but we are not aware of it yet that will help us face this century head on in 21st century, when we thought we had left wars and crises behind?</p><p>I found answers to my spiritual crisis in the ancient Indian philosopher — the Buddha.</p><p>IV.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“One can only stare as much at death than at the sun.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Golden morning light falls on my table as I cross another day of the calendar and prepare for the morning run to cope with the repetitive and undifferentiated days. Unnerved by news of rising cases and deaths, my mother stops me suddenly with horror writ on her face, explaining how cruel this disease is and warns me to not touch the lift buttons with bare fingers. When asked about the reason for her early morning paranoia, she goes on to explain her fear of death — the family is not even allowed to see the body of the deceased. I hug her with a knowing smile and wear my mask and gloves for her relief.</p><p>Death is public matter again — something so inherent in life and yet buried and hidden. The question of death and immortality are the starting point of any quest for knowledge. When one does not understand the biggest unknown, one lives in fear of it and that fear generates ignorance which in turn becomes the root of all evil. Reflection on mortality need not necessarily be morose and gloomy — it can be accompanied with joy and bliss and help give meaning to our lives. This knowledge of birth and death lies prior to any division, before language creates separation between subject and object and therefore, taken up by religious discourses.</p><p>When Buddha’s followers pressed him for answers to abstract, theoretical questions he refused to answer. To speculate about mere theories when there is suffering in the world, he said, is like speculating about the origin of a poison arrow while it is still lodged in one’s flesh. “First remove the arrow! Questions about origins can come later.” The teachings then dealt with the concrete reality of suffering first — that of birth, ageing, sickness and death that no sentient being can escape.</p><p>In the modern society, death is seen as an ending of human life, which is inevitable yet mysterious. It is a void, terminus, whose only meaning is that there is no meaning. Life ends when death knocks on the door, the body lies supine, the heart stops beating, and there is an end to breathing. The body that experiences pleasure and pain is decomposed, and the immortal soul is released. It is followed by mourning and loss and other rituals usually linked to tradition. This understanding separates body from soul, death from life and is discontinuous from other living beings. It leads to unconscious efforts to deny and transcend death which in turn causes the death drive to be repressed.</p><p>More life affirming account of death would be to not separate death from life. They exist together, mutually dependent and inextricable. Death happens every moment of our waking life. Creation and destruction happen together, in the cells of our body and in the universe. Here, the significance of human life lies in unity and embeddedness with nature and the universe as a whole. Death is also continuous with past and future generations and not seen as an end of individual life. One dies and arises multiple times like waking up from a sleep.</p><p>This way of thinking in a non-dual manner means to neither ‘be’, nor ‘not to be’ — implying neither of the two extremes, not denying but encompassing both and taking the middle way. To exist in a way that takes the middle path between the extremes of being and nothingness — to not cling desperately to the former and dread the latter. To transcend our instinctive desires and fears and establish ourselves in the freedom of ‘emptiness’ — between substantialism and nihilism, negation and affirmation, existence and non-existence, eternity and annihilation. Rather than existential nihility that tends towards nothingness outside of ‘being’, here ‘being’ itself constitutes emptiness. The concept of ‘sunyata’ (emptiness) which corresponds to non-substantiality means that things and phenomena do not have essence or substance in themselves but only exist in relation to the other. Everything is interdependent, impermanent and empty of substance and because everything is empty, everything is possible.</p><p>Modern science that puts rationality at its center has more in common with eastern philosophy that it would like to accept. Throughout the history of science, humans have believed in a hard solid reality and nature outside human mind and tried to understand and explain it through laws and then build technologies. 20th century’s two great physical theories, however — quantum mechanics and relativity completely dispelled this vision of reality. The findings were quite radical and changed the way we look at the world. Some of its insights were as follows —</p><p>While relativity proved that matter and energy are interchangeable. Quantum mechanics showed that the building blocks of matter — atoms are not things in themselves but observable phenomena. They form a world of potentials and possibilities rather than things and fact. Uncertainty principle confirmed that a particle can exist as a wave depending on the observer and it is not possible to determine its position and momentum at the same time.This puts forth the idea that Mind (realm of thought) and matter (realm of material world) are not completely distinct giving rise to objective reality that the mind has to comprehend. They are distinct but always connected. The mind does not end in the brain and matter is made of wave functions or vibrations. It is motile, fluid and everchanging. The solid objective reality that appears to be outside the mind that one has to deal with, does not really exist without the mind of the observer. It can change according to the change in the mind of the observer.</p><p>Humans then used the insight of these theories to create the most advanced of technology that now connects and runs the world. The information revolution that runs on data made of bits and bytes and helps us do things that were previously impossible uses the insights of quantum mechanics. We now have the most powerful nuclear weapons to show our technological prowess. However, we didn’t have to wait for German physicists in the 1920s to help us see this view of reality. Buddhist teachings have been pointing to this for centuries and rather than observing atoms splitting under the microscope, one can directly experience this truth by observing one’s own mind through meditation. Of course, one can’t make scientific tools, make long distance video calls or even build a space ship to explore the universe outside our planet by observing one’s mind. But, what is the purpose of engaging in scientific explorations and find life on other planets when we can’t even understand our own minds and help create a better civilization here in the one home we have. Isn’t it more important to create better relationships and experience the whole of life deeply rather than build things to conquer the universe in our desire for immortality.</p><p>The worldview that Buddhist teachings offer is drastically different and holistic than the Western worldview. To start with, the universe did not begin with an event called Big Bang. It operates in cycles of expansion and contraction and has no beginning and no end. The understanding of death also takes the middle way — which means neither complete annihilation such that life of an individual ends with death nor a belief in an eternal soul remaining that takes birth again and again. Rather, since life is awareness of itself, our consciousness has levels and we can perceive the same reality differently according levels of awareness. There are 4 stages of life state — birth, life, death and the intermediate state between death and birth. On our physical death, some part of consciousness that contains cause-effect relationships (karma) doesn’t end with the body and passes on in the universe for the next birth. Lives are seen as coming and going of sea waves, and the ocean is the universe.</p><p>Contrary to plain scientific view that birth happens when an ovum and sperm merge to form an egg, there is a third thing that is added and that is the work of the karma. Science can explain the mechanical working of the way nature works but it can not explain the diversity and why life works the way it does for different people. It can not answer the particularities.</p><p>Consider this stanza from one of the ancient Buddhist texts -</p><p>“Life at each moment encompasses the body and mind, and the self and the environment of all sentient beings in the Ten Worlds as well as all insentient beings in the Three thousand realms, including plants, sky, earth and even the minutest particles of dust. Life at each moment permeates the entire realm of phenomena and is revealed in all phenomena. To be awakened to this principle is itself the mutually inclusive relationship of life at each moment and all phenomena.”</p><p>This non-dual way of thinking offers continuity between human mind and the environment he lives in — between all that is human and that which appears as non-human — it reveals the wholeness of things. There is a direct link of the self (microcosmos) and the universe (macrocosmos). Of, course there is a distinction between humans and each species that exist, but it doesn’t devalue or consider human reason as superior to other forms of life. All phenomena are condensed within our life, and at the same time our life pervades the universe. The same power that moves the universe exists within our lives. Therefore, the Self can expand to contain everything else that exists as there is no unchanging, constant identity that we call the Self . The ‘I’, that we ceaselessly try to give ground to our entire life can expand to contain the entire universe.</p><p>Our fate as humans is undeniably connected with the biosphere, we are subject to universal and natural laws. Physical reality has order and follows the law of cause and effect — but this causality is not linear, meaning that an effect can not be attributed to a single cause, but there are multiple causes and conditions — cause and effect happen simultaneously or effect lies within the cause itself. This is based on the law of dependent origination that talks about the interconnectedness of all phenomena — For eg. a piece of paper in my hand contains all that phenomena that has made it reach here — the trees, the rain, the clouds, the people who carried the trunks, the factory workers et all. Fundamental reality is an interconnected process not made up of discrete things. Each part of nature interacts with the other to form a harmonious whole. All of reality is present in each of its parts, and each part reflects all other parts.</p><p>When we believe that the laws that govern nature lie outside of us, we feel succumbed to its might, to its power imposing on us, whereas if we believe that the universal law lies within us, it gives us true freedom to realise the whole of universe that we experience in our lifetimes. This makes the finite and atomized individual able to realise the infinite, for the specificity of his actual experience to assume universal meaning and to exist and work in collaboration with natural cycles and rhythms. It is already too late to think that we need to solve human problems first, and then we will think about what is happening ‘outside’ in nature. This non-anthropocentric worldview would require de conditioning of our minds and re enchantment of our dualistic world. Enlightenment lies in everyday world in this life — it is a change in perspective, another way of experiencing this world, to “take” the same things differently, to live ethically, expand our notion of Self, get rid of greed, hate and anger and to save all beings.</p><p>The goal then must be to liberate science, knowledge, time and language from the confines of capitalism, patriarchy and institutions that are structured to produce knowledge that limits us, that ties us without a rope. True freedom lies in non-duality, non-violence, wisdom and compassion for all living beings. To shift from social structures that feed on desire that is self destructive, one has to work on personal transformation as well as collective organisation to aim towards creating structures that are stable, sustainable and directed towards peace. The past and the future lie in the present moment, the eternity itself is present in every moment. To create futures is to take embodied, ego less action, to realize infinite potential that lies within us and light the path for others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/619/0*KmcmNVHANwmbRE4n.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/568/0*ql43uVXl-9uHoh21.png" /></figure><p><em>You can’t remake the world without remaking yourself</em></p><p><em>Each new era begins within</em></p><p><em>It is an inward event,</em></p><p><em>With unsuspected possibilities</em></p><p><em>For inner liberation.</em></p><p><strong><em>Ben Okri</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=497688380a20" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Representing Reality]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/representing-reality-887264d2316b?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/887264d2316b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[documentary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[global-warming]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 May 2021 10:00:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-27T10:00:32.142Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Our dilemma is like that of a plane hurtling through the fog without map or instruments.”</p><p>We march ahead, our heads held high, beating our steps to the rhythm of machines and algorithms, led by bordered notions of progress and development, leaving a trail of a phenomenon the impact of which is massively distributed in time and space across the planet. Climate change can be categorized as a ‘Hyperobject’ according to Timothy Morton alongside big words like capitalism and neoliberalism. The scale of impact is so big and vast that it is beyond human imagination.</p><p>The 21st century with its visibly glamourous cities, superfast transport has become radically interconnected, interdependent, and communicated in the formations and flow of media. We have new weapons, new satellites, and new ways of conquering space. This same world also spawns proliferating, often interpenetrating, “global crises”. From climate change to war on terror, financial meltdowns to forced migrations, pandemics to world poverty, and humanitarian disasters to the denial of human rights, these represent the dark side of our globalized planet. Their origins and outcomes are not confined behind national borders and they are best not conceived through national prisms of understanding.</p><p>Global capital acts like an invisible agent that causes havoc wherever it lays its web on. One of its most long lasting effects, climate change has become a public issue analyzed by scientists, discussed by politicians on different local, national and international levels, claimed by NGOs, supported by celebrities or contested or used a marketing tool by industrial branches and economy.</p><p>The intergovernmental Panel on Climate change (IPCC) has predicted that extreme weather events such as flooding, droughts, storms and heatwaves have increased in intensity and frequency over many land areas. To understand and approximate the level of damage that is being done, it has been constructed on the basis of physics, chemistry and big data. With increasing computing power, climate modelers have generated increasingly large simulation data sets. To represent such magnitude and scale of data related to sporadic events diffused around the earth is the challenge for the new media.</p><p>For instance, By 2050, according to an estimate based on mid- range scenarios, volume of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere will reach 500 ppm, upto 200 million people are expected to get displaced and between 15 and 37 percent of the world’s terrestrial fauna are committed to extinction. Energy Transition, in releasing urban atmospheric carbon from the use of fossil fuels, has unbalanced the global carbon cycle. Although the nature of the problem is ‘global’ and there have been inter-governmental talks and pacts like the Paris Agreement and the Kyoto protocol around the issue, it’s the less developed countries and vulnerable communities that will endure the most immediate and severe impacts even though they are the least responsible for producing greenhouse gases. Invisible to the people not directly affected by it, this is called slow violence — violence of delayed destruction that occurs gradually and out of sight. To focus on a specific region, countries like India and Bangladesh are very susceptible to droughts and floods respectively. Arundhati Roy, an activist and writer says –</p><p>“I think of globalization like a light which shines brighter and brighter on a few people and the rest are in darkness, wiped out. They simply can’t be seen. Once you get used to not seeing something, then slowly, it’s no longer possible to see it.”</p><p>Vandana Shiva, scholar and activist also commented —</p><p>“The ‘global’ in the dominant discourse is the political space in which a particular dominant local seeks global control, and frees itself of local, national and international constraints. The global does not represent the universal human interest, it represents a particular local and parochial interest which has been globalized through the scope of its reach. The seven post powerful countries — G7, dictate global affairs, but the interests that guide them remain narrow, local and parochial.”</p><p>We live in the age of ‘capitalocene’, a term coined by writer Jason W. Moore. Multi-national corporations with their immense corporate carbon footprint are blamed for the way of life they have generated for humans in the cities — ‘anthroposphere’ — a zone of urbanized living. The impact of this metabolism is complex and profound. It is a new reality which determines future of life on earth.</p><p>Media spaces are the primary symbolic and information battle grounds in which the epistemology of this condition is debated, even as the physical world changes. With digitalization, urbanization and modernization, individuals are existing in their own shell (filter bubble), stuck onto their handheld devices. Virtual world has caused people to live in a kind of mediated, hybrid reality. Emergence of a transnational public sphere (Fraser, 2007) supported by digital communication infrastructures is a key feature of social movements and formal political systems. In this context, nuclear disasters, oil spills, toxic chemicals leaks, tsunamis, earthquakes, super storms, floods, bushfires, extreme heat waves and famine function as fodder for spectacular “disruptive media events” and “disaster marathons” transmitted to distant audiences consuming online, broadcast and print media.</p><p>But the general orientation of the mass media continues to inhibit, dilute and probably confuse the clarity of understanding needed to tackle climate change. Whether based on professional awareness and culture of shared concern or the political economy of media ratings, readers and revenue, section of mainstream media now often dramatize and spectacularise climate change as an impending peril. Media representations are offered within a prevailing sea of content that sends very different messages blaming one country or another. The scale and hysterical tone of the arguments is unprecedented.</p><p>In such a hypermediated space, the question now more than ever comes up is how we as individuals and groups understand reality of the objective world around us, how we understand past, present and therefore work towards the future. Baudrillard’s theory of simulated reality caused by the powers of media is allied to the theory of the commodity in which according to Marx ‘relations between people appear in the fantastical guise of relations between objects’. In the contemporary world, the loss of ability to give meaning to reality is also the product of psychic protection, the desire of the individual not to put himself at risk by exposing himself to the stimulus of a reality he can no longer interpret. The individual is going through a kind of collective, social mechanism of splitting. The spectator self is morally disengaged, floating about in an ocean of violent images. The actor self is caught up in a reality whose violence is often morally overwhelming.</p><p>Films and documentaries</p><p>Within the visual media, the role of film (both fiction and documentary) in motivating viewers to raise awareness and lobby politicians about climate change, and to make behavioral changes to reduce their carbon emissions is noteworthy. Film has become an alternate tool for science communication, especially in this case where high stakes, diverse values, and politics intertwine with the science produced and communicated to the publics. Here ‘publics’ is used to emphasize an active audience that is heterogeneous, interpreting its messages in numerous different ways.</p><p>Historical climatology is the use of documentary evidence for the reconstruction of past climate. The trends of climatic variability may be beyond the threshold of human perception over the course of a lifetime, documentary as a form is used to record it in the best possible way. They are what they are because they make particular claims about specific sociohistorical world and explore the idea of truth in all its variable meanings. As a philosophical concept, truth can be defined as simply as agreement with facts. Legal scholar Richard Sherwin postulates the variations of factual truth, higher truth and symbolic truth. We assume that a certain reality exists prior to filmmaking process.</p><p>According to the way the reality is presented and the form it takes, the aesthetics and style of the director, documentary can be categorized into four prototypes: the authoritative, the observational, the dramatized and the poetic reflexive. (Bill Nichols (2001), Carl Plantinga (1997). Many documentaries combine elements from different prototypes, but in all of them narrative and emotional dimensions play a crucial role, even though for instance the authoritative prototype is mostly based on arguments and rhetoric, the observational on very loose and sequential structures and the poetic reflexive often on more abstract visual associations and patterns.</p><p>The rhetorical form has a story with some kind of argument inside. They seek to argue, prove, demonstrate and convince the audience about a particular point. (Nichols, 2001) We expect them to tell us something about reality that has a quality of truth and authenticity. But that said, we do know as spectators, and all theories about documentary genres confirm that documentaries use all kinds of communicative strategies and they appeal not only to reason, but also to feelings and the more sensual dimensions of our reality. Bordwell and Thomson (2001) define four basic attributes for rhetorical form documentary film: (1) It addresses the viewer openly, (2) Subject of the film is more a matter of an opinion than an issue of scientific truth, (3) Filmmaker appeals to our emotions, and (4) Film often persuades the viewer to make choices that have an effect on everyday life.</p><p>On this topic, there are two predominant schools of thought with regard to the human perceptibility. On the one side, the invisibilists assume climatic change to be undetectable to the lay observer and invisible to the naked eye. They argue that local understandings of climate change are the product of the dissemination of climatic information via scientific, technical or institutional networks (e.g. through mass media or workshops) rather than based on actual observations (Mormont and Dasnoy 1995). In contrast, the visibilists claim that the effects of anthropogenic climate change are visible and have already been reported by local people worldwide. For these scholars, climate change can be tracked based on personal experience (Howe and Leiserowitz 2013; Weber et al. 2013). Meanwhile, a third school of thought is emerging with the argument that local reports of climate change reflect a combination of both observation and reception of climate information. This third claim, coined constructive visibilism, assumes climate change not to be inherently visible or invisible, but made visible through its tangible features and/or external knowledge of it (Marin &amp; Berkes 2012).</p><p>List of films made in the recent years all over the world have been as diverse and contradictory as the topic. Some blow it up and simplify it, some deny and others have complicated wordings. For example, Franny Armstrong’s Age of the stupid, Drowned Out, An Inconvenient Truth, Before the Flood (2016), Home (2009), Chasing Ice and the big wildlife film industry — BBC, Discovery, Animal Planet, National Geographic.</p><p>All these are political in some way. BBC’s award winning series Frozen Planet, narrated by David Attenborough presents breathtaking images and the factual presentation are not aimed at a particular national body but to the world at large. This world level acts as neutral but in reality it is aimed at specific western audiences, comfortable leaning back in their living rooms in their television sets. Most transnational documentaries are an affair for the wealthy parts of the world.</p><p>But even though this is a special feature of climate documentaries that try to illustrate abstract data and scientific arguments with personal and concrete experience, the interaction between emotions, personal and everyday experience and memories are always at work.</p><p>HOME (2009)</p><p>This beautifully shot documentary made by French photographer Yann Arthus-Bertrand shows a series of events happening across the world over time. Images of changing landscapes become a sort of evidence set to the voiceover of a female narrator poetically reciting the calamities occurring as we watch the sublime natural landscapes being destroyed by human settlement and activities.</p><p>The unique vantage point and the patterns in nature shown by the film works on 3 levels: information, affect and agency.</p><p>Images</p><p>Among the first cinematographers traveled to oil fields of Azerbaijan, and shot a 30 second film of oil wells. Locally unbound — both categories of images –abstract condensates of global climate science, and the pictures of concrete climate events have entered collective memory. Iconic image of the blue planet is a popular motif in the media, used to symbolize global crises and to evoke the idea of one world under threat. Power generation — power plants symbolize the energy industry in western industrialized nations, sometimes pointing the finger at a single polluter. Long shots of bright lights and traffic jams in the US or Asian megacities depict the hypermodernity humans are living in. Big machines and cattle denote industrial meat production. Alternative energies like windmills and solar power plants are shown being built everywhere.</p><p>Affect</p><p>There is a well-documented gap between environmental attitudes (which are more amenable to change through information provision), and pro-environmental behaviour (Gatersleben et al., 2002 ; Kollmuss and Agyeman, 2002). In an attempt to effectively engage the public, visual and emotionally-based appeals are frequently employed within the environmental movement. Clearly, significant reductions must be made in individuals’ emissions and lower-carbon lifestyles must be promoted. The Age of Stupid is a film made with the stated intention “to turn 250 million viewers into climate activists”</p><p>However, not all emotions are helpful in this context. Campaigns which appeal to fear as a motivator are problematic because fear can trigger denial, apathy, repression, anger and counterproductive defensive behaviours (such as buying a ‘high-carbon’ sports utility vehicle to protect oneself against an unpredictable environment) in response (Moser and Dilling, 2004). There is a need for a positive vision to sustain people taking climate change mitigation action because results will not be seen quickly (Moser, 2006).</p><p>These studies suggest that fear appeals are more successful when the recommendations to eliminate the fear threat are perceived to be effective. Fear system — being oriented in the present and providing tangible material for contemplation. Even though fearful climate change representations focus people’s attention on the issue and produce a general sense of importance, this type of communication seems to be disempowering on a personal level, leading to disengagement from the issue.</p><p>The power of evidence and the power of persuasion is used for images showing climate change. Images present particular difficulties for our moral being, and cause guilt even if they wield a distancing force. Frozen registrations of remote calamities, we have learnt to manage our relationship of suffering. The photographic image at once exposes us to and, and insulates us from, actual suffering; it does not and cannot in and in of itself implicate us in the real and reciprocal relations necessary to sustain moral and compassionate existence. Since the dangers aren’t tangible, immediate or visible in the course of day to day life, however awesome they appear, many will sit on their hands and do nothing of a concrete nature about them. Yet waiting until they become visible and acute before being stirred to serious action will, by definition be too late.</p><p>Environmentalist advocacies of place assume that individuals’ existential encounters with nature and engagements with intimately known local places can be recuperated intact from the distortions of modernization. Within its redemption of cinema’s consciousness raising potency, further reminds us that films themselves do not possess agency. We are affected by film, but the affect hinges upon how we organize ourselves, our culture and our society refracted in these films.</p><p>What makes us human, all too human is the flux of impulses, fears and desires at the center of our being. What makes us human and civilized too is the endeavor to transform that flux (with the help of our powers to reason) for moral, creative and imaginative ends. The hope is always that images have the power to produce action and influence decisions and in so doing, to change reality.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=887264d2316b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Manikarnika Ghat]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/manikarnika-ghat-97750b544904?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/97750b544904</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[varanasi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[funerals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[burning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Sep 2020 13:15:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-28T13:15:16.211Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7cxyISRRUsSEq_vt78AGXA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Manikarnika Ghat, Varanasi, India</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=97750b544904" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is Posthumanism?]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/what-is-posthumanism-28f7c1f6278b?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28f7c1f6278b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-posthumanism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Mar 2018 15:17:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-28T15:21:19.334Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What is Posthumanism? And how can critical posthumanism develop an ethical approach in the context of technocapitalism and neoliberalism?</h3><p>Waiting for the Instagram page to load in the multiple tabs that are open in front of me, hoping to view the digital archive of the photographs I’ve taken with ‘my’ mobile phone and partially worried about the materiality of events, objects and people in that virtual world of mobile apps, tech devices, new media art and drone warfare brings me into simultaneous moments of departure and arrival.<br>Turns out that questions like “Who am I?”, “What is real?”, “What am I doing?”, “What lies in the future?” are not the banal and basic questions that I am asking alone, but are the most relevant questions of the times, when the crisis of being human is getting worse every day. What does it mean to be a human being in this epoch when so many things that we have to deal with are non-human? Is this a question somebody studying humanities should ask or should it be a concern for academics in other fields too?<br>When more than half the world’s population lives in urban centers, with a developing global consciousness fueled by media, technology and economy, it is interesting to see how the human subject develops. With growing inequality, financial crises, climate change, mass migration, rising individualism, terrorism and violence and looming uncertainty making the larger picture of our zeitgeist, we need a new way of thinking, new way of embracing change and a new way of understanding ourselves. <br>“This change constitutes a radical transformation within increasingly globalized ‘late capitalism’ from an ‘analog’ (humanist, literate, book or text — based) to a digital (posthumanist, code, data or information based) social and economic system. Techno-scientific cultures, global economic crises, looming environmental disaster, the spread of digitalisation, the rise of biomedia and the erosion of traditional demarcations between human and nonhuman all call for alternative ways of thinking about humanity and its environments.” (Herbechter, 2013)<br>The corporate colonization of our social relations and basic drives, needs and desires like hunger, sex, shelter, of our identity as humans, and of life itself is an ongoing enterprise which is ‘crisis prone’ as it affects all aspects of our existence and nature on a global scale. It degrades us, turning our most precious human qualities into commodities. Our creativity, our knowledge, our learning thus become not qualities that emancipate but resources for production of false desires of health, love and humanity. Society as a whole thus becomes laboratory of technocapitalism. (Suarez-Villa, 2009)<br>There’s a shift happening from the ‘humanist’ way of thinking which serves to promote the cohesion of all of humanity with certain universal values that have been criticized by postmodernist and poststructuralist thinkers as it presupposes a capitalist bourgeois subject who is regarded as ‘liberal’. This ideology and politics that promotes ‘tolerance’ in the face of superficial difference (like gender, race, culture, location, history) has been challenged by a form of humanism with a prefix ‘post’ which means to ‘go beyond’ and instead stresses on alternative values like ‘particularity’, ‘difference’, ‘multiplicity’ and ‘plurality’ and emphasizes the radically local and temporal context — specificity. It also criticizes the supposed transparency of mediality (realism in language, painting, media and other image-based technology) and instead emphasizes the fact that any medium has its own dynamic, its own power to construct identities and to position subjects. It points towards changeability and relativity of human nature and individuality as well as the relativity of values but turns against any idealistic form of transcendence, accentuates the inseparability of form and content, the radically determining function of context and an understanding of truth as process and insists on the ‘materiality’ of thinking and importance of ‘embodiment’ in agency. (Herbechter, pg12)<br>Posthumanism is a paradigm emerging from the challenges to humanism. It responds to anthropocentrism, speciesism and biopolitics, and informs new creative practices like bioart and electronic literature. It is an idea that covers philosophy, history, cultural studies, science and technology, new media and digital culture, environmentalism and earth sciences, bio-genetics, neuroscience and robotics, evolutionary theory, critical legal theory, primatology, animal rights and science fiction.<br>In the digital age of intelligent machines, rampant mechanisation and automation of all biological phenomena, technology is literally a body invader, penetrating consciousness, reshaping perception, circulating bodies and desire in cybernetic loops of information. Distraction is the norm in a digitally saturated world: information is everywhere, connectivity pervasive, bodies augmented, perception illuminated, truth a purely phantasmagorical effect, perception coded by media feeds, attention fully wired. Cybernetics is precisely how the language of posthuman is delivered to us.<br>We have become posthuman in the sense that subjectivity is not immanent to the laws of media, that peculiarly technological condition and object of the fully realized digital society. (Kroker, 2014) It potentially breaks the barrier of geographical distance, sexual difference, national difference, crashed boundaries, challenged frames of reference — the porous borders. It blurs the qualitative lines (male/ female, black/white, human/animal, nature/technology, local/global, present/past, dead/alive, central/ margin — in spaces that flow and connect the binaries) and reshapes the identity of humanistic practices, by stressing heteronomy and multi–faceted relationality, instead of autonomy and self–referential disciplinary purity. (Bradotti, 2013) It is a complex assemblage of human and non- human, planetary and cosmic, given and manufactured. <br>Power then as conceptualized by Foucault can be seen as restrictive (potestas) and affirmative (potentia). Figurations such as the feminist/the queer/the cyborg/ the diasporic/ native, nomadic subjects, as well as oncomouse and Dolly the sheep are no more metaphors, but signposts for specific geo political and historical locations. As such they express complex singularities, not universal claims. (Bradotti, 2013 ) The body, reconfiguring relation and ethical emergences of bodies beyond being received through representation, external and within consciousness negotiating reality through representative perception, is the foundation and the site of the event of the posthuman encounter. To add to this posthuman subject, in the nomadic theory, Braidotti explains how the process of becoming woman is always the precondition and the necessary starting point for the whole nomadic transformation. <br>With a fragmented identity living both in the virtual and physical world, the subject is a materialist and vitalist, embodied and embedded, firmly located somewhere, according to the feminist politics of location with spatio-temporal ambiguity and different planes of existence. Time itself has become condensed and speed and acceleration are the motions to be confronted with (Virilio, 1986). But what Virilio misses is the emancipatory and democratizing nature of new media and technology which can be good as well as bad depending upon the context. This point is taken up by contemporary feminist theorists under the term ‘cyberfeminism’ who see internet as a means of freedom from social constructs like gender and sex difference and machines as extension of humans. Donna Haraway’s 1985 text –“A Cyborg Manifesto” was an iconic text describing this way of being. <br>Bradotti’s claim of the posthuman becoming animal — earth — machine is supported by Luciana Parisi (2004) who says that the great advantage of vitalist monism is that it defines nature — culture as a continuum which evolves through ecology of differentiation. Development in research in biology specifically in biotechnology and nanotechnology has led to an extensive study in genomics — complete genetic makeup of the species which according to Dr. Craig Venter is going to shape the future of life on this planet. The human genome project which was started in 1990 is set to take medicine to a next level where diseases can be cured by altering the information in the DNA. The non-semiotic codes (the DNA of all genetic material) intersect with the complex assemblages of affects, embodied practices and other performances that include but are not confined to linguistic realm. Parisi strengthens this case by cross-referring to the new epistemology of Margulis and Sagan (1995), through the concept of endosymbiosis, which, autopoiesis, indicates a creative form of evolution. This means that the genetic material is exposed to processes of becoming freed from ontological foundations for difference but is not confined by social constructivism. <br>Human subjectivity has become so deeply and inextricably embedded with technology that the posthuman is born at the interstices of data and flesh. Digital devices once thought outside of ourselves, have now broken barriers of skin and mind, shaping from within the deepest recesses of consciousness, desire, perception and imagination. Ray Kurzweil’s debatable theory of singularity and artificial intelligence reaching considerable attention and acknowledgement from futurists is also a sign of technology going beyond its assumed limits.<br>Time which has always been seen as unidirectional and going forward supported by the idea of development is being thwarted by posthuman time which is a complex and non-linear system, internally fractured and multiplied over several time sequences, where affect and memory become essential elements. Memory is joyfully discontinuous as opposed to being mournfully consistent. (Bradotti, 2013) Technologies that are mobile, interpolated, fast are deeply haunted by the psychic violence against cognition, affect, and perception precipitated by recent developments in neuroscience.<br>In digital culture, the autonomous liberal humanist subject is a postmodern, multilayered individual and ‘consumer’ of cultural meaning, which in a media consumer society is always necessarily transmitted by the media. In the course of encoding and decoding cultural ‘messages’ the media subject develops specific decoding and encoding skills, which means that this subject is not the purely passive receiver of overwhelming media power, but an active consumer in search of fulfilment of his or her desires. (Herbrechter, Pg 181)<br>Here, the golden rules of our times can be developed — cartography accuracy — the use of GPS, with the corollary of ethical accountability; trans-disciplinarity; the importance of combining critique with creative figurations; the principle of non-linearity; the powers of memory and imagination and the strategy of de-familiarisation. (Bradotti, 2013)<br>As said by the visionary Marshall Mcluhan, “All media are extensions of some human faculty- psychic or physical”; in digital culture, gravity bound words and capital and power and warfare are literally launched into the weightless space of the regime of computation. Data is the currency which is being traded and codes and algorithms are the underlying mechanism of most urban activity. More data has been collected in the past two years than the entire history of humanity. Big data, distant reading and augmented reality are being used in all forms of media for entertainment, advertising, treatment of diseases and so on.</p><p>Dualistic distinction between nature- culture has collapsed and is replaced by complex systems of data — feedback, interaction and communication transfer. Data banks of biogenetic, neural and mediatic information about individuals are the true capital today, as the success of Facebook demonstrates on a more banal level. When everything can be coded in virtual capitalism and in the code of governmentality, datafication is the norm, and notions of time-space are modified, the question that needs to be asked is of work and labour and how that is supposed to change too. Digital labor and creativity are all changing with hypermobility and individuality, freelancing and project based work is more preferred with flexible working hours. Experiencing and embodying this light-time and light-space of digital reality with communication at the speed of light, we’re at the beginning of a new order of communication called ‘Liminal communication’. Social media usage averaging 44.5 hours per week, its skin barrier is being broken down by deep immersion as a circulating node within complex loops of information. When all activities of human life are archived, development of a theory for media archaeology was essential as done by Jussi Parika. <br>Arthur Kroker (2013) also talks about the new icons of power, sex, consciousness and truth and describes the current conundrum as Accelerate, Drift, Crash. <br>“Drift culture- This is the essence of the data storm that engulf us — gigantic galaxies of social, political and economic data, broken apart by the technical rewiring of everything to suit the requirements of the logic of code, here invaded by technological devices as they take root in the languages of consciousness, desire, interest, there learning to speak again in the language of social media, to see again with enhanced data perception, — bodies, metals and AI combine into new species — forms . Genetics (code drift), cosmology (history drift), distributive consciousness (archive drift), or remix media (video drift), drift culture is the ontological foundation of the posthuman axiomatic.” <br>When there’s information overload, it loses its body and consciousness itself is increasingly patterned by the language of codes which itself forms reality.<br>“Screen drift — is the eye of the future in fast motion accelerating across the deep space of media archive. That we live in a culture of proliferating screens is already a truism. Silent, but very real impact of screen culture on our psycho — geography: the psychological territory of human imagination and perception, identity and truth — saying, indeed truth — seeing. Radically altering the deepest language of human perception, shape shifting the boundaries of the real, speeding up the meaning of time itself, and transforming virtual space into artificial horizon, we are the very first explorers of the culture of screen drift.”<br>In the age of information culture, the body learns to swim in the data storm for reasons of survival. Scanned by the surveillance cameras, the signature of its iris photographed and data banked by electronic airport security, its movements through the economy electronically tracked by its own credit card history, probed by all the ubiquitous technologies associated with contemporary medicine, entertained by youtube, connected by social networking technologies, seduced by the HD screens of mass media — cinema, TV and blu ray, its ears hardwired to the sounds of ipods and eyes to the screen of Ipads, its every thought patiently recorded by the hovering satellites of the national security system, the body today is punctured, pierced, probed, and pummeled by information from all sides.<br>What religion could never fully accomplish — the unification of the world in fixed cosmological consciousness — the language of technology has set out to complete by wrapping the skin of the planet in a universal language of connectivity, thereby subordinating the heterogeneity of humanity to the steady signal of networked society. Kroker writes — <br>“Premonitory signs of the future — the digital dialectics — its virtual organs: the death of the eye associated with the appearance of the software necropolis, its synthetic physiology — Flesh Rezzing; its logic of abjection –full mind scanning; its dominant comportment — the lonely Digital Crowd: and its mythology — the rings of Saturn. Liminality is everywhere, destabilizing boundaries, undermining the logistics of perspective, challenging the binary division of life and death, light and darkness, flesh and data. What is the future of human flesh when bodies are fully wrapped within the skin of their own virtual second lives? What is the fate of privacy in the future of the fully networked ego — something to be jettisoned as extra ballast as the body blasts into the space of global communication of something very different, that is a longing for privacy as the hauntology of the lonely digital crowd?” <br>Technologies contribute actively to how humans do ethics. Technological tools are agents that can guide human decision making on normative issues. According to Bradotti, what the neoliberal forces are after and what they financially invest in, is the informational power of living matter itself. The capitalization of living matter produces a new political economy, which Melinda cooper (2008) calls ‘life as surplus’. To counter this upheaval of monetization of life, we can see emergence of the earth as a political agent.</p><p>To think beyond our species, and respecting existence of all life forms as an ethic is called deep ecology. Gaia hypothesis, a theory put forward by scientist James Lovelock posits that the organic and inorganic components of Earth have evolved together as a single living, self-regulating system. It suggests that this living system has automatically controlled global temperature, atmospheric content, ocean salinity, and other factors, that maintains its own habitability. In a phrase, “life maintains conditions suitable for its own survival.” In this respect, the living system of Earth can be thought of analogous to the workings of any individual organism that regulates body temperature, blood salinity, etc. To preserve this, we need a new form of thinking which is transdisciplinary and gets the best ideas from science, arts, humanities and social sciences to work on a sustainable future. <br>What then is the place of humanities as a scientific enterprise in this globalized network culture that no longer upholds the unity of space and time as its governing principles? In the era of citizens’ science and citizens’ journalism, what can be the role of academic research institutions? Bonta protevi (2004) talks about Deleuze’s ‘geo philosophy’ which encourages the humanities to engage with contemporary biology and physics.<br>Posthuman humanities according to Katherine Hayles (1999) can create and evolve a new set of narratives about the planetary dimension of globalized humanity; the evolutionary sources of morality; the future of our and other species; the semiotic systems of technological apparatus; the process of translation underscoring the role of gender and ethnicity as factors that index access to the posthuman predicament and the institutional implications of them all. From Gutenberg to 3D printing, media has come far in shaping human knowledge and it’s for the posthuman to use it for his survival. To conclude I’d like to quote from N Katherine Hayles (1999) — <br>“My dream is a version of the posthuman that embraces the possibilities of information technologies without being seduced by fantasies of unlimited power and disembodied immortality, that recognizes and celebrates finitude as a condition of human being, and that understands human life is embedded in a material world of great complexity, one on which we depend for our continued survival.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28f7c1f6278b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Third Cinema]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/third-cinema-9a2b0b53093b?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9a2b0b53093b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Mar 2018 14:15:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-27T14:15:50.594Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>History of mankind is wrought with the struggle for power over the other’s gender, race, land, water, energy and resources (natural or man-made). The word power has a greek origin and is defined as “the ability to act in a particular way”. This ability to do what one wants as one likes manifests in human relations in the form of hierarchy and is often accompanied with violence. A child born in a certain part of the world at a certain time is acted upon by the forces of human societies that makes him subject to power acting at different levels in the family, institutions, market, state, geography which are all linked to history. Blood has been shed, battles have been fought and statues fallen over the control of mind, body, space and time. The tool for wielding this power has historically been swords, guns, votebank. For the creative ones, the pen and in the modern times, the camera. The powerful comprise those people in society with easy access to resources, those who can exercise power without considering their actions. For the powerful, their culture seems obvious; for the powerless, on the other hand, it remains out of reach, élite and expensive.<br>Vision, space and power are often related. Development of new media and screen culture has been as drastic as the invention of the wheel and with the democratization of media tools, anyone has the right to express his or her worldview and discontent to an imaginary public. Unequal access to and distribution of material and cultural resources, and the hierarchies of legitimacies and status accorded to those differentials is what constitutes the political in media. In terms of audiovisual media where screens infiltrate modern human existence on such massive scale, politics of the moving image becomes all more important. How an image is composed, who and what is represented, what is the ideology of the filmmaker and in what time and context it was made all comment on its politics. <br>All films are political, but films are not all political in the same way. The photographic gesture is the search for viewpoints, for ideologies. The cinematic apparatus with its choice of lighting, camera angle, placement, movement, set design, acting, montage, point of view all add to the film’s politics. Not only the scene that is depicted, but also the camera’s design and the audience that watch gives the director immense power and control of filmic spacetime.</p><p>Third Cinema<br>The idea of Third Cinema was raised in the 1960s as a set of radical manifestos and low-budget experimental movies by a group of Latin American filmmakers — Fernando Solanas and Ocatavio Getino, who defined a cinema in opposition to Hollywood and European models. This new form of expression was coming largely from three different areas of the world: Asia, Africa and Latin America. At that time (during the cold war) these three zones were labelled ‘Third World’ (and in some places they sometimes still are). <br>According to Teshome Gabriel, the principle characteristic of third cinema is really not so much where it is made or even who makes it, but, rather the ideology it espouses and the consciousness it displays. In the present times, it is the cinema of the third world which stands opposed to imperialism and class oppression in all their ramifications and manifestations, challenging ivory towered paradigms within film studies, particularly Lacanian psychoanalysis, postcolonial studies and postmodernism usually associated with American mainstream and European auteur cinema. Power, direction and meaning of ideas depends on the social forces with which they are articulated. Defined by its socialist politics, third cinema may be seen as something of a holding operation in the dark times of neoliberalism’s hegemony. <br>It may relevantly result as the ‘third space’ which displaces the histories and needs that constitute it and sets up new structures of identity and political initiatives, which are inadequately understood through the current mainstream channels of production and distribution. Due to the changing multiracial and multicultural world reality, Third Cinema must reinvent itself in terms of gender, class and geographical identity and consequently in terms of narrative structure and aesthetics. It is not just about making films, it also experiments with altering the conditions of production and consumption; that is within the social microcosm that is cinema, breaking down the hierarchical divisions of labour which cinema inherited from the capitalist society.<br>Production values and content<br>Cinema has its material ecologies, which span the entire production cycle, from ecosystems and factories where minerals and plastics, silicon chips, and other resources are extracted, processed and manufactured, to locations and sets and disposal of waste products associated with film production and also its social ecologies — social relations by which films and their meanings are made, the representations of social life which they carry, and the social and cultural uptake and transformation of those meanings in contexts ranging from film festivals and cineplexes to living rooms, blogs, bodies (gestures, expressions, etc) and interpersonal relationships. By politics of production it means to locate the subject-position of the filmmaker, which is constituted by a specific colonial history. <br>In the case of third cinema, the first question arises is how does the filmmaker depict the ‘other’ and how does the audience perceive it as. The second question is what is the purpose behind making a film and who the audience is and what sort of reaction is expected from them.<br>Stuart Hall (1992) asserts, “what is ‘out there’ is, in part, constituted by how it is represented.” What happens when we confront ‘the ethnic other’ on the screen? Film makes you cognizant of the existence of the other, the other human being who you identify or disidentify with. The ‘gaze’ of the camera tells us what we are seeing and how we are seeing it. The filmic space-time is also a telling factor of the time and context it was made. While western films manipulate time more than space, third cinema emphasizes space over time. It’s very important for filmmakers to explore spaces and temporalities that are free from the colonial influence. Linguist Mikhail Bakhtin describes chronotypes as time-space articulations characteristic of a particular, historically determined conceptions of the relations between, the human, the social and the natural world i.e. ways of conceptualizing social existence<br>“They have always smelled history in the wind.” Third cinema as guardian of popular memory, is an account and record of their visual poetics; the contemporary folklore and mythology, and above all in their testimony of existence and struggle, it serves not only to rescue memories, but rather and more significantly to give history a push and popular memory a future.<br>The narrative structure, style and form of the films are also different like how western cinema is shaped by “the gauges and instruments of scientific-technological thinking” and third cinema might be enamored with ‘magic’ described as an ‘allusive, imagistic’ and ‘poetic’ style featuring “metaphors and allegories” that valorize, among other things, the “elemental terms” of “water, fire, wind, and earth,” as well as the neglected senses of “touch, smell, and taste.” Solanas and Getino developed the notion of film as a ‘detonator’ of ideas, as a pretext for gathering together in dangerous conditions. Hence the dividing of the film into discrete chapters could facilitate the film being stopped at any point and issues raised could be debated.<br>The narrative of the films is usually passionate, angry, satirical, always complex. For eg. -Mira Nair’s Salaam Bombay depicts the world of slumdwellers in Bombay, India but it doesn’t show the reasons behind it and the complex network that causes it. Third cinema would want to point the finger, it would want, in Espinosa’s words, “to show the process which generates the problems”. But to do that requires taking a position, making a commitment. It has a different epistemological foundation to Second cinema and its aim is to seek to bring cognitive and intellectual powers of the spectator into play. <br>Often these films are known to deal with poverty as a subject. Poverty is a point at which we see the critical links first and foremost between society and economy but also between politics, religion and the law and aesthetics is an appropriate way to think about poverty since it is about the critical juncture of space, experience and ideas. The speech, environment, experience, culture and behavior of workers and peasants themselves become one resource; a second resource lies in the hidden history of a country — in struggles, massacres, and victories of the past either not recorded or distorted in the schools and in history books. And a third resource lies in the aesthetic of imperfection, that is, in the idea of film still in process, reflecting a society still in formation, opposed to the complete, complacent, perfected society and form of dominant cinema. Some films end with an appeal to the audience to add further stories, letters, and ideas to the unfinished film, which is an instrument of the unfinished struggle.<br>Gunuine revolution can never be about the seizure of political power and the control of state apparatus. The socialist revolution, and the revolution which third cinema aligns itself to, calls for an extension of the political revolution into a social revolution. This means that every aspect of life must be transformed and democratized. Every microcosm of society — every organization, institution, structure — must begin the hard work of organizing its internal dynamics and practices and external relations with others on an entirely different basis than hitherto the history of humankind: on the basis that is of control being vested in the majority. The tension between militancy and entertainment, between engaging with popular culture and therefore mass audiences, while also seeking some transformation in consciousness and social reality, remain a central issue and problem for third cinema. <br>One strand is Guerrila Cinema — Solanos, Getino (1997) — indicates the conditions of production in which the filmmaking was undertaken. When filmmakers are working in conditions of political danger and state authoritarianism, when their work may be seized, censored or when they themselves might be imprisoned, the only way they can work is by using secrecy and subterfuge.<br>Full of emotions of anger, outrage, passion, desire to change the world, third cinema seeks to achieve a new synthesis between spectator’s emotional and intellectual capacities. Some of the precursors of realism maybe — Eisenenstein, Vertov, Georg Lukacs, Bertolt Brecht, Walter Benjamin.<br>According to Brecht, realistic means — discovering the causal complexes of the society/ unmasking the prevailing view of things as the view of those who are in power/ writing from the standpoint of the class which offers the broadest solutions for the pressing difficulties in which the human society is caught up/ emphasizing the element of development/ making possible the concrete, and making possible abstraction from it. Brecht’s epic theatre eliminated the Aristotelian catharsis, the purging of emotions through empathy with the stirring fate of the hero, it reduces astonishment rather than empathy, so that the spectator asks: Is this how things really are? How can things be so absurd or unjust? Epic theatre places an emphasis on the discovery of the conditions of life.<br>Third cinema also offers a critique of the individualistic conception of the artist and an alternative to the historiography premised on the individual. An account of historical change which starts from and ends with the individual is problematic because it is unable to show how the individual is formed within a broader set of social relationships and how they develop in conjunction with those relationships. Ideas, values and beliefs are internally contradictory, providing their own response or mediation of the conflicts between capital and labour. This way of thinking about history requires us to locate the actions and beliefs of individuals in their wider socio-economic context and to understand change as something that is brought about not by individuals realizing the “timeless principle” but by individuals and collectives operating within conflictual and contradictory relationships that shape what can be thought and what can be done at any particular point in time and space. <br>Sometimes, film contain representational field of conflicting voices and views that are self-reflexive — where it draws attention to its own conditions of making meanings within the medium of film. They also use rhetorical strategies of allegory and satire: An allegorical narrative is one which shrinks a larger social totality, a larger historical narrative, into a smaller story. Satire reveals the absurdity of existing shibboleths and orthodoxies and pretensions of the powerful. The spectacle must be open in the sense that it encourages the spectator to understand the world as complex and to understand that only though their participation in the world after the cinematic spectacle has finished can the inequalities and injustices of this complex world be addressed.</p><p>Distribution<br>The means of disseminating cultural products and of gaining access to audiences lies in the domination of distribution and exhibition by monopoly capital. The problem is that while monopoly capital tries to bury it by ignoring it, the state may take an unwelcome interest in an oppositional cinema. The direct or indirect influence of state on film industries is common across the world. The situation is still colonial in the sense that there is an unequal concentration of power located elsewhere: in the headquarters of financial institutions like the World Bank, the IMF, the Wall Street stock market; in the boardrooms of the multinational companies operating within the third world and the political capitals of the West like Washington.<br>The difficulty of radical filmmakers in getting their films to their audience is an enduring, structural and persistent problem. Filmmakers who accept this responsibility have two possible audiences: the middle and upper classes from which they might themselves originate, the principal consumers of film entertainment; and the workers and peasants who make up the vast majority of most of these countries. The first audience is largely urban, accustomed to foreign culture, and upwardly mobile within the local elite power structure. The second audience is more difficult to reach. It often has a firmer grasp of native culture and tradition and thus is more resistant to normal film fare and other colonizing culture. And it also has a key stake in social, economic, and political change. Both audiences are composed of spectators, and in the “continent of hunger” spectators are “cowards and traitors.” Therefore with both audiences, the filmmaker’s purpose is not to create “understanding spectators,” in Miguel Littin’s phrase, liberals who despite themselves are collaborators with the enemy, but to transform spectators into actors, or participants in the revolution. In order to bring about this transformation, filmmakers seek an original and an empowering use of language.<br>.<br>Examples<br>Third cinema in the context of India is first about self-representation, the articulation of the colonized individual, the absent subject, into history. Free from colonization of time and space — tamed temporality where past has been emptied of meaning and weight and future has been made perfect, and colonial appropriation of conceptions of geography and land, history and time, and language and hence consciousness, Indian cinema has come a long way. It exists in historical, linguistic, political situatedness — among nation-states, multinationals, diasporic communities, sub national groupings and movements.<br>Two extreme examples of third or even fourth cinema are given below:<br>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYYrPEa8ppA<br>https://vimeo.com/157416877<br>These are very stark visuals of the violence happening in the Naxal affected areas of Jharkhand, Chattisgarh and Orissa. Some of the questions that arise are “What does it mean to see figures of death and violence on screen invoking pathos” “Does everyone on this planet have an equal chance to live? And Gayatri Spivak’s “Can the subaltern speak?” In global resource wars, the environmentalism of the poor is frequently triggered when an official landscape is forcibly imposed on a vernacular one. Adivasis, Dalits and people who do not belong to the civilized society heed to riverbanks, floodplains, river dependent forests, and catchment areas that have sustained them for millennia. Such people may belong to the land but according to the Lockeian logic of private property, the land doesn’t belong to them because they are considered culturally inferior or in Annu Jalais’s terms “dispensable citizens” according to the myth of social Darwinism.<br>They respond to oppression, exploitation and exoticization. Engaging in strategies of resistance, opposition, these films are made by a filmmaker representing the oppressed community and hence deinstitutionalizing the “looking relationship” between first-world viewers and fourth-world subjects. The underlying politics of imperialism insisted that colonization was beneficial to the people being colonized. Classic colonial — post colonial discourse is repeated — territorial, economic and symbolic rape of a civilization, fixity in a deformed otherness — the pained and self conscious process of reclaiming one’s own history and traditions. <br>Exponential upsurge in indigenous resource rebellions across the globe surging the high rate of neoliberalism has resulted largely from a lash of temporal perspectives between developers — dispossessors who arrive from different time zones to impose on habitable environments unsustainable calculations about what constitutes the human gain. Change is a cultural constant but the pace of change is not. Temporal contests over how to sustain, regenerate, exhaust or obliterate the landscape as resource discount spiritual values serving webs of accumulated cultural meanings. These are the socioenvironmental fallouts of development agendas whose primary beneficiaries live elsewhere: women’s rights, minority rights, tribal rights, property rights, the right to freedom of speech and assembly and the right to enhanced economic self-sufficiency are something these people are fighting for and therefore need a voice of their own.<br> These films were screened at film festivals like Kochi Biennale, informal popular gatherings as well as in student milieu and in radical institutions.<br>One of the principles of third cinema is — insistent address to a unitary spectator who is at once disingenuous (requiring lessons in class consciousness and postcolonial development) and sophisticated (capable of appreciating an otherwise rarified oppositional aesthetics) Thus, third cinema’s critical reception and reception at film festivals should seldom be mapped onto the same experiential terrain as those of audiences at popular venues.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9a2b0b53093b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Photo essay]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/photo-essay-b9037979ba1c?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9037979ba1c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[people]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[architecture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Mar 2018 14:15:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-27T14:15:19.892Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Until recently anthropology had been concerned almost exclusively with the study of so-called primitive societies, non-literate people living in non-western worlds with a low level of technological advancement. The distinctive feature of the mode of living of man in the contemporary times is his concentration into gigantic aggregations around which cluster lesser centers and from which radiate the ideas and practices that we call civilization. The cities have an unnatural way of being, these vast metropolises exist not just objectively as financial, political and cultural hubs but also in imaginations in stories, films and photographs. It also inhabits within it multitudes of different parts and communities that inhabit the same space. The theme of this photo series was to encounter the physical space of the city and how London as the financial center of the world manifests itself in the architecture and patterns of daily life. The city suggests an immediacy of experience: the ‘this, here and now.’ It teaches us the arts, the techniques and the tactics of living in the present. What other way to represent the present moment than to photograph it. <br>Just as physical city is a palimpsest, a complex layering of architectural imaginings that are given a physical reality, destroyed and built over, so we might think of the layering of social visions in which the past remains a force in the present, and also in our present attempts to think of the future. Architecture then becomes the visual moniker of the system. Things and objects change under the gaze of photography. The stillness of a photograph makes everything before the lens a sort of specter, a duplicate version of the real. When buildings are separated from themselves in the medium of photography, they become specters of themselves. This is the condition of modernity.<br>Modernist architecture is the child of industry and engineering where form follows function. As a form of discourse, built form constructs and frames meanings. Place creation is determined by those in control of resources and is a pursuit of amenity, profit, status and political power. The built environment reflects the identities, differences and struggles of gender, class, race, culture and age. It shows the interests of people in empowerment and freedom, the interests of state in social order, and the private corporate interest in stimulating consumption. It also shapes perception and cognition. <br>Henri Lefebrvre couples a concern for social constructions of spatial ideology with the importance of lived experience. The concept of space is at once a means of production and a commodity, bot a social product and a means of social reproduction and control. Thus places are both engines of wealth and forms of wealth, we make places and are made by them. London’s architecture is a mix of both old and new, and keeping the imperial past and the modern power intact in the buildings. <br>The corporate office tower dominates the skyline of nearly all major cities — global building type for the command functions of increasingly global corporation. Tall buildings are a response to market pressure for more rentable space on a given site area. The successful corporate tower offers a distinctive image, a quest that is achieved through uniqueness of form. The ideal tower is a landmark in the literal sense of leaving a mark on the land. High tech images of reflective glass to polished facades of granite and reconstructed stone, it embodies metaphors of strength, stature and strategy, the metonym of physical prominence translating to financial domination. Lefebvre theorizes the monumental vertical built form as phallic: metaphorically it symbolizes force, male fertility, masculine violence — phallic erectility bestows a special status on the perpendicular. One building incorporates ‘a timeless façade of richly ornamented granite’. Stone is an important signifier of permanence and nature, for authentic values that do not change. Small matter that the stone has been crushed and reconstituted to achieve consistent quality across very thin sheets.<br>London’s space is full of walking arcades and gardens that have been built for flaneury. In the 1930s Benjamin recognized these arcades as the harbinger of a fundamentally new kind of space, an interior dream world of seductive commodities. In contrast to most theorists of his time, Benjamin saw modernity not as enlightenment or demystification but as new mythology. Archaic collective myths steeped in the ideas of the eternal were being replaced by a collective dream of mass culture — the fleeting and dynamic myth of commodity. In the arcades he saw a new integration in the production of space, architecture, commodity and subjectivity. With modern art coming away, photographers began taking interest in the surfaces of the world. A gleaming façade and the cracked hands that built it became the symbols of modern life.<br>London, from being the capital of the Empire to the global city of now stands tall with all its unabashed wealth and power setting an example for other cities that have developed in the recent years. Cities are from beginning capitalism in embryo. Capitalism as it is believed by many is the natural condition of humanity that confirms to the laws of nature and basic human inclinations. Capitalism is a system in which goods and services, down to the most basic necessities of life are produced for profitable exchange, where even human labor power is a commodity for sale in the market, and where, because all economic actors are dependent on the market, the requirements of competition and profit maximization are the fundamental rules of life. It is a system uniquely driven to develop the forces of production and to improve the productivity of labour by technical means. The bourgeois then act as an agent of progress. Every human action and activity then becomes tied around capital. Human bodies instead of flourishing according to their own best potential and capabilities become identical and subject to capitalist forces. Real estate becomes the function of market. This geography of and spatial outline gives the citizens of the city a sort of false sense of wellbeing and freedom. One such space is the square or the piazza:<br>The square of piazza is the epitome of open-mindedness. Here public space is surrounded by a mix of public and private buildings: government offices, museums, lecture and concert hall, churches, shops, cafes, residences.. In the square itself, people meet, walk, talk, buy, sell, argue about politics, eat lunc, sit over coffee, and wait for something to happen. They are different people, with different purposes, educated by the space they share to a civil deportment.<br>The purpose in this series was more to capture the signs and symbols, lights and shadows of the urban space of the city, than to record the life of the city. I took a rather archaeological approach where pictures of historical buildings, ornamental motifs, vernacular streetscapes become the subject — Juxtaposing, people against empty space, stressing contrast between black and white, the three dimensional and the flat, the curved and the straight, melancholic play between present and past, intangible and the real, the timeless and the transient.</p><p>Process:<br>New to the city of London, I wanted to do this project as a way to get used to the space of the city. Coming from Mumbai and Delhi, India where the space is more condensed and tight, London was not just different in spatial layout but I was also sometimes struck with dejavu of how the street corners and buildings reminded me of some areas in the Indian cities due to its colonial past. I chose the city center as the location for the project as this is where the strength and power of the city resides. Michel de Certeau, differentiates between space and place. Space is practiced place. In his chapter “Walking in the city” in the Practice of everyday life he describes the city that people inhabit as a labyrinthine reality which produces anthropological, poetic and mythic experiences of space.<br>Since the idea was to capture the city’s hard, rough concrete space and the loneliness and alienation that people face on a daily basis, I chose to just take my camera and point at what I could see on the streets.<br>Georg Simmel, a German sociologist talks about how the personality of an individual accommodates itself in the adjustments to external forces of a city. “The individual has become a mere cog in an enormous organization of things and powers which tear from his hands all progress, spirituality, and the value in order to transform them from their subjective form in to the form of a purely objective life. Here in buildings and educational institutions, in the wonders and comforts of space-conquering technology, in the formation of community life, and in the visible institutions of the state, is offered such an overwhelming fullness of crystallized and impersonalized spirit.”<br>For me, London came with a lot of freedom but also lack of pathos on the streets made the city a little distant and inaccessible. This is the uncomfortable freedom of the metropolis where individual agency is enacted within the field of possibilities realized by this real-imagined environment: its space, its population, its technologies, its symbolization. The city remained inescapably strange and opaque, often oppressive. Yet it provided the texture of our experience and the fabric of liberty.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9037979ba1c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Feminism and neoliberalism]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/feminism-and-film-f8ddf58b00c5?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8ddf58b00c5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Mar 2018 14:04:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-27T14:05:34.422Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Should I call myself feminist? Do I still need a term to describe my right to do things as I want and be what I want?”<br>Waking up with a thought like that where I question what it means to be a woman in contemporary times that are highly charged with sexual politics and neoliberal digital economics is a challenge and privilege that many face today. In a world where structure and architectures have been made by men, the question of being, becoming and existing as a woman is itself political. Simone de Beauvoir’s famous quote “one is not born but becomes a woman” proposes that stylized repetition of the acts — gestures, movements and enactments form a gendered self. Living in a hypermediated reality that has co-opted the women’s movement and made it into popular feminism where it has become an identity marker of sorts, it’s impossible to be just be without reflecting on those questions. Changing technologies that have given more agency, mobility, independence to women than ever before and have made possible to do things that were earlier inaccessible to them, have brought forth a new woman who is not afraid to experiment with sexuality, work, lifestyle and do things the way she wants. Cyberfeminism and new media has given women new ways of being with fluid identities and anonymous subjectivities. The denominators of gender, class, race, nation (intersectionality) still exist in terms of defining individual identity and determining experiences and how much this new liberalism applies. <br>The strangeness of neoliberalism is that it can converge both with fascism and emancipatory politics. Young women then become the ideal neoliberal subjects who are entrepreneurial and full of confidence and hope to create a better future for themselves by postponing child bearing and focusing on self-development. What this is really doing is turning them too into human capital by the multinational corporates. This pop-feminism that has emerged in the West is posed as an ideal form of development and progress and is then spread to other parts of the world. While there is a wide range of feminist thought and all deal with their emancipatory potential, the normalization of one form in one part of the world as opposed to exploring an alternate form is problematic. There are certain brands of feminism that women of colour, disability or working class does not identify with. Judith Butler says that feminist politics transcends identity politics. But I’d argue that the ability and freedom to find one’s identity doesn’t happen without political subjectivity. The freedom to have alternate identities like queer, LGBT and so on doesn’t exist without socio-political-economic context.<br>Media and Politics<br>Media is at the center of constructing gender relations, masculinity and femininity. Audio visuals have the most impact because of physical representation of bodies and places and high affective value. Films, advertisements, music videos, TV shows, news and now social media not only occupy time-space-identity but also create them. In a hypermediated situation that we’re living in today, John Fiske (1996) asks “Can we separate media events from non-media events, or are all events today, or at least the ones that matter, necessarily media events?” <br>Fenton (2016) explains that politics has to do with how we as individuals view our own positions in the world and how we relate to others both far and near. In dealing with differences, it has to with the difficulties of living together locally, nationally and on this planet. In a globalized world where all the nations and economies are related to each other, the power of media to create or represent events and set the agenda for the transnational publics gives its creators immense responsibility and political power. Race, gender and class positions of the creators point to the way they define the relationship between visibility, power, identity and liberation. For eg, the Russian feminist protest punk group — Pussy Riot who performed anti- Putin lyrics in front of the Orthodox church and were arrested and put to jail were in the media so often that they’ve now become celebrities who protest against Donald Trump. Their images challenge the traditional image of a woman as housewife or low status worker to the feisty, successful “girl power” icon.<br>In the case of moving image work, who makes films for whom, what the aesthetics are, the production budget, content and chronology and where it’s shown all comment on the politics of it. Since the advent of cinema hundred years ago, there have always been less women than men making films. In the recent years however, more and more women are picking up the camera and expressing their view of the world. Feminist filmmaking usually works towards a productive social change but films made by women that represent men have been rare and usually come from the West.<br>Rape<br>“Our space has strange effects. For one thing, it unleashes desire” Henri Lefebvre (1997)<br>One of the main areas in film representation is the relation between space and body. At the moment when almost 70% of the world’s population lives in urban centers and more are migrating, the body is contantly transformed, ‘citified’, urbanized as a distinctive metropolitan body. The built environment provides the context and coordinates for corporeality in most economic, social, cultural, political activities. This space inhabited by millions of people of both sexes from all walks of life and background also is rife with all sorts of crime, oppression and power relations. <br>Rape — the violation of sexual and physical integrity in public or personal space is a crime that has a pervasive effect on the workings of the community and points at gender relations and body politics. It is the entry point for feminism and because of its visual and primal nature, instantly becomes the topic for cultural debates around which narratives are formed. <br>As a case study, I’d like to critically analyze a documentary called ‘India’s Daughter’ (2015) made by Leslee Udwin on the 2012 gangrape and murder that happened in New Delhi, India. This film was very controversial when it was released and even banned by the Indian government due to the tarnished image it created of Indian society. But, it was released on social media and then went viral. (now removed) Despite this it was shown on BBC Channel 4 and in the US as part of Women’s Film Festival. The film starts with reenactment of the day’s event where Jyoti Singh (the victim) boards the bus and is followed by a series of interviews with the guiltless and shameless rapists in the prison, the girl’s parents, the family of the rapist, the girl’s friend, the lawyers and the police. It’s interesting to note how the characters were framed to create a gripping narrative contrasting intense emotions of grief from the parent’s side with careless and sexist remarks of men. There is a long take of the rapist’s comment with small shots of the protests that followed. Poverty of the rapist’s family is juxtaposed with tears of the parents and horrifying details of the crime in the rapist’s confession. Made highly affective through editing and dramatization, the fact that a British woman is trying to portray women’s sexuality in another culture through a rape narrative should be contested. Here, the political question of representation of oppressed groups (coloured women and men) by those in positions of control and power (western woman) comes into play. Her justifications that the film wants to be a part of transnational feminist movement is valid because it does show blatant attitudes of men, but the gaze of the camera and the representation reflects a similarity with other narratives created of India by the Western media. <br>Pratibha Parmar, a British filmmaker of Indian origin says, “Media representation of third world people today range from picturesque exotica, starving beggars, natives fighting each other, or as perpetual victims of calamities usually of their own making and incompetence and of spaces where poverty and under-development are a common state of affairs. While it can arouse emotions, it can also neutralize emotions and create stereotypes.” India is a very diverse and complicated society that has accepted modernity only recently and to show only one and biased aspect of it is politically not correct.<br>Although this was a documentary supposed to represent reality and show the truth, but any representation whether documented or fictionalized is manipulated and put together to show a reality that is already constructed in the director’s head. According to WJT Mitchell (1995:11), representation takes two forms: ‘aesthetic or semiotic’ (things that stand for other things) and political (persons who act for other persons) as a means of expressing ideological and political questions concerning the functioning of the body politic.<br>The title of the film “India’s daughter” defeats its own purpose by negating a woman’s identity independent of man, family or nation. The raped woman’s body is associated with the nation and the representation of the city is derived from the trope of violated femininity. In this case, her body was caught in ‘between two- deaths’ one at the time she was left on the road and the other when she passed away in a hospital. The narrative of identity, desire and death also amplifies the preconditioned perspective of a normative rape — that of woman being an innocent victim and rapists coming from a working class or low income depraved and marginalized group. It does not delve deeply into the political relationships in which people are enmeshed. There were reports that she also used some underhand unethical tactics like bribing the rapists. She also might have got access to the prison that an Indian filmmaker wouldn’t due to the postcolonial hangover that Indian people still have, thinking that white skin is better. Sure, she did it before any Indian feminists thought of doing it in true fashion of an exploring and prying independent filmmaker but she could have dealt a serious topic like this a little more sensitively. It fails to address the causes and solutions of the problem.<br>This also cannot be seen without the wider social, economic, moral and historical contexts of prostitution and pornography, bollywood movies and advertising images, where desire is built through sexualization of female bodies and commodification of land and labour. Newer mainstream cinema that’s coming out in India contain postfeminist narratives where the woman is shown as an independent young woman ready to fight and willingly deciding her sexuality while still confirming to the middle class narrative of love, heartbreak and marriage. The power relations of pornography, abortion, male violence, technology and science also make people’s opinions and behavior about gender. For eg, recently in the news, there was a minor glitch on the central station of Delhi metro where a porn clip was shown on the screens. While this might be an error, it shows the perversity and sexual repression the modern day cities are living in. Through these images femininity is constructed as locus of male desire and pleasure, and embedded in the photographed and commodified female body via a system of fetishized visual codes. It acts as an object of exchange along with other commodities like houses, TV and cars. Luce Irigaray puts it “The production of women, signs, and commodities is always referred back to men.. wives, daughters, and sisters have value only in that they serve as possibility of and in potential benefit in, relations among men.. the sexuality of men is played out through the bodies of women, matter or sign.” The woman can be a subject only by acting as a consumer, alienated from herself in her desire for commodities. Gender definitely shapes the way of looking and “the gaze” changes according to the ways of being, experiences and therefore representing the world. Laura Mulvey’s essay talks about pleasure of looking at human form and when most cameras are in the hands of straight men, the female body becomes a beautiful thing to look at, something to admire in a world full of ugliness and pain. While this normative look shared by most men has been reversed by female filmmakers, the numbers are still low.<br>Rape is a historical crime inflicted on women, men and sometimes metaphorically nations for land, labour, power and resources. Only in the recent years, has it been considered illegal and criminalized under the law. How rape is defined and how justice is acquired has historically been dependent on if the victim if married or not. In most societies, marital rape is still legal and doesn’t come under purveyance of media. Public rape however structures women’s relationship to space and agency, in dealing with love, family and the law, and to define property. While in war, it’s done for power and control, in the cities and towns it’s used to generate fear. Masculinity becomes performative and voyeuristic. Links have also been made between rape and men’s control over language and gaze through which myths are made like — women secretly fantasize about rape and that women are tempting seductresses who invite sexual encounters that they will eventually relax and enjoy, and that men have urgent sexual needs that prevent them from controlling their behavior (Berger 1986; Burt 1980).<br>In the age of mediatization, rape becomes a hypermediated spectacle. It is constantly in the news and newspapers juxtaposed with advertisements that it has become banal. Andrea Dworkin develops a causal link between representation of rape and the act of rape. For the uninitiated female spectator, watching rape is like a second hand rape of her being. Fear, agony and hatred of men run in the minds of women who watch it then. Because of its scandalous nature, rape becomes a perfect crime for films even for art cinema because its complexity and multiple truth positions and the combination of sex and violence. People watch all sorts of violence from a distance on their phone screens and even take pleasure in sharing and spreading it — mutilation, rape, torture and lynching have become such common media events that watching them on TV or social media is like watching animals fighting and killing.<br>Feminist filmmakers have a dual motive — the desire to end rape and a need to represent in order to challenge it. But for any of the films to have any real change in the society is asking for a change in the mindset and attitude towards women. What we need is a new way of looking and benign attitudes towards rape, women and people of colour.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8ddf58b00c5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘In what sense can audiovisual media be considered political?’]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/in-what-sense-can-audiovisual-media-be-considered-political-4a1ed5510f0?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a1ed5510f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[audiovisual]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Mar 2018 13:56:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-27T13:56:45.987Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>History of mankind is wrought with the struggle for power over the other’s gender, race, land, water, energy and resources (natural or man-made). The word power has a greek origin and is defined as “thse ability to act in a particular way”. This ability to do what one wants as one likes manifests in human relations in the form of hierarchy and is often accompanied with violence. A child born in a certain part of the world at a certain time is acted upon by the forces of human societies that makes him subject to power acting at different levels in the family, institutions, market, state, geography which are all linked to history. Blood has been shed, battles have been fought and statues fallen over the control of mind, body, space and time. The tool for wielding this power has historically been swords, guns, votebank. For the creative ones, the pen and in the modern times, the camera. The powerful comprise those people in society with easy access to resources, those who can exercise power without considering their actions. For the powerful, their culture seems obvious; for the powerless, on the other hand, it remains out of reach, élite and expensive.<br>Vision, space and power are often related. Development of new media and screen culture has been as drastic as the invention of the wheel and with the democratization of media tools, anyone has the right to express his or her worldview and discontent to an imaginary public. Unequal access to and distribution of material and cultural resources, and the hierarchies of legitimacies and status accorded to those differentials is what constitutes the political in media. In terms of audiovisual media where screens infiltrate modern human existence on such massive scale, politics of the moving image becomes all more important. How an image is composed, who and what is represented, what is the ideology of the filmmaker and in what time and context it was made all comment on its politics. <br>All films are political, but films are not all political in the same way. The photographic gesture is the search for viewpoints, for ideologies. The cinematic apparatus with its choice of lighting, camera angle, placement, movement, set design, acting, montage, point of view all add to the film’s politics. Not only the scene that is depicted, but also the camera’s design and the audience that watch gives the director immense power and control of filmic spacetime.</p><p>Third Cinema<br>The idea of Third Cinema was raised in the 1960s as a set of radical manifestos and low-budget experimental movies by a group of Latin American filmmakers — Fernando Solanas and Ocatavio Getino, who defined a cinema in opposition to Hollywood and European models. This new form of expression was coming largely from three different areas of the world: Asia, Africa and Latin America. At that time (during the cold war) these three zones were labelled ‘Third World’ (and in some places they sometimes still are). <br>According to Teshome Gabriel, the principle characteristic of third cinema is really not so much where it is made or even who makes it, but, rather the ideology it espouses and the consciousness it displays. In the present times, it is the cinema of the third world which stands opposed to imperialism and class oppression in all their ramifications and manifestations, challenging ivory towered paradigms within film studies, particularly Lacanian psychoanalysis, postcolonial studies and postmodernism usually associated with American mainstream and European auteur cinema. Power, direction and meaning of ideas depends on the social forces with which they are articulated. Defined by its socialist politics, third cinema may be seen as something of a holding operation in the dark times of neoliberalism’s hegemony. <br>It may relevantly result as the ‘third space’ which displaces the histories and needs that constitute it and sets up new structures of identity and political initiatives, which are inadequately understood through the current mainstream channels of production and distribution. Due to the changing multiracial and multicultural world reality, Third Cinema must reinvent itself in terms of gender, class and geographical identity and consequently in terms of narrative structure and aesthetics. It is not just about making films, it also experiments with altering the conditions of production and consumption; that is within the social microcosm that is cinema, breaking down the hierarchical divisions of labour which cinema inherited from the capitalist society.<br>Production values and content<br>Cinema has its material ecologies, which span the entire production cycle, from ecosystems and factories where minerals and plastics, silicon chips, and other resources are extracted, processed and manufactured, to locations and sets and disposal of waste products associated with film production and also its social ecologies — social relations by which films and their meanings are made, the representations of social life which they carry, and the social and cultural uptake and transformation of those meanings in contexts ranging from film festivals and cineplexes to living rooms, blogs, bodies (gestures, expressions, etc) and interpersonal relationships. By politics of production it means to locate the subject-position of the filmmaker, which is constituted by a specific colonial history. <br>In the case of third cinema, the first question arises is how does the filmmaker depict the ‘other’ and how does the audience perceive it as. The second question is what is the purpose behind making a film and who the audience is and what sort of reaction is expected from them.<br>Stuart Hall (1992) asserts, “what is ‘out there’ is, in part, constituted by how it is represented.” What happens when we confront ‘the ethnic other’ on the screen? Film makes you cognizant of the existence of the other, the other human being who you identify or disidentify with. The ‘gaze’ of the camera tells us what we are seeing and how we are seeing it. The filmic space-time is also a telling factor of the time and context it was made. While western films manipulate time more than space, third cinema emphasizes space over time. It’s very important for filmmakers to explore spaces and temporalities that are free from the colonial influence. Linguist Mikhail Bakhtin describes chronotypes as time-space articulations characteristic of a particular, historically determined conceptions of the relations between, the human, the social and the natural world i.e. ways of conceptualizing social existence<br>“They have always smelled history in the wind.” Third cinema as guardian of popular memory, is an account and record of their visual poetics; the contemporary folklore and mythology, and above all in their testimony of existence and struggle, it serves not only to rescue memories, but rather and more significantly to give history a push and popular memory a future.<br>The narrative structure, style and form of the films are also different like how western cinema is shaped by “the gauges and instruments of scientific-technological thinking” and third cinema might be enamored with ‘magic’ described as an ‘allusive, imagistic’ and ‘poetic’ style featuring “metaphors and allegories” that valorize, among other things, the “elemental terms” of “water, fire, wind, and earth,” as well as the neglected senses of “touch, smell, and taste.” Solanas and Getino developed the notion of film as a ‘detonator’ of ideas, as a pretext for gathering together in dangerous conditions. Hence the dividing of the film into discrete chapters could facilitate the film being stopped at any point and issues raised could be debated.<br>The narrative of the films is usually passionate, angry, satirical, always complex. For eg. -Mira Nair’s Salaam Bombay depicts the world of slumdwellers in Bombay, India but it doesn’t show the reasons behind it and the complex network that causes it. Third cinema would want to point the finger, it would want, in Espinosa’s words, “to show the process which generates the problems”. But to do that requires taking a position, making a commitment. It has a different epistemological foundation to Second cinema and its aim is to seek to bring cognitive and intellectual powers of the spectator into play. <br>Often these films are known to deal with poverty as a subject. Poverty is a point at which we see the critical links first and foremost between society and economy but also between politics, religion and the law and aesthetics is an appropriate way to think about poverty since it is about the critical juncture of space, experience and ideas. The speech, environment, experience, culture and behavior of workers and peasants themselves become one resource; a second resource lies in the hidden history of a country — in struggles, massacres, and victories of the past either not recorded or distorted in the schools and in history books. And a third resource lies in the aesthetic of imperfection, that is, in the idea of film still in process, reflecting a society still in formation, opposed to the complete, complacent, perfected society and form of dominant cinema. Some films end with an appeal to the audience to add further stories, letters, and ideas to the unfinished film, which is an instrument of the unfinished struggle.<br>Gunuine revolution can never be about the seizure of political power and the control of state apparatus. The socialist revolution, and the revolution which third cinema aligns itself to, calls for an extension of the political revolution into a social revolution. This means that every aspect of life must be transformed and democratized. Every microcosm of society — every organization, institution, structure — must begin the hard work of organizing its internal dynamics and practices and external relations with others on an entirely different basis than hitherto the history of humankind: on the basis that is of control being vested in the majority. The tension between militancy and entertainment, between engaging with popular culture and therefore mass audiences, while also seeking some transformation in consciousness and social reality, remain a central issue and problem for third cinema. <br>One strand is Guerrila Cinema — Solanos, Getino (1997) — indicates the conditions of production in which the filmmaking was undertaken. When filmmakers are working in conditions of political danger and state authoritarianism, when their work may be seized, censored or when they themselves might be imprisoned, the only way they can work is by using secrecy and subterfuge.<br>Full of emotions of anger, outrage, passion, desire to change the world, third cinema seeks to achieve a new synthesis between spectator’s emotional and intellectual capacities. Some of the precursors of realism maybe — Eisenenstein, Vertov, Georg Lukacs, Bertolt Brecht, Walter Benjamin.<br>According to Brecht, realistic means — discovering the causal complexes of the society/ unmasking the prevailing view of things as the view of those who are in power/ writing from the standpoint of the class which offers the broadest solutions for the pressing difficulties in which the human society is caught up/ emphasizing the element of development/ making possible the concrete, and making possible abstraction from it. Brecht’s epic theatre eliminated the Aristotelian catharsis, the purging of emotions through empathy with the stirring fate of the hero, it reduces astonishment rather than empathy, so that the spectator asks: Is this how things really are? How can things be so absurd or unjust? Epic theatre places an emphasis on the discovery of the conditions of life.<br>Third cinema also offers a critique of the individualistic conception of the artist and an alternative to the historiography premised on the individual. An account of historical change which starts from and ends with the individual is problematic because it is unable to show how the individual is formed within a broader set of social relationships and how they develop in conjunction with those relationships. Ideas, values and beliefs are internally contradictory, providing their own response or mediation of the conflicts between capital and labour. This way of thinking about history requires us to locate the actions and beliefs of individuals in their wider socio-economic context and to understand change as something that is brought about not by individuals realizing the “timeless principle” but by individuals and collectives operating within conflictual and contradictory relationships that shape what can be thought and what can be done at any particular point in time and space. <br>Sometimes, film contain representational field of conflicting voices and views that are self-reflexive — where it draws attention to its own conditions of making meanings within the medium of film. They also use rhetorical strategies of allegory and satire: An allegorical narrative is one which shrinks a larger social totality, a larger historical narrative, into a smaller story. Satire reveals the absurdity of existing shibboleths and orthodoxies and pretensions of the powerful. The spectacle must be open in the sense that it encourages the spectator to understand the world as complex and to understand that only though their participation in the world after the cinematic spectacle has finished can the inequalities and injustices of this complex world be addressed.</p><p>Distribution<br>The means of disseminating cultural products and of gaining access to audiences lies in the domination of distribution and exhibition by monopoly capital. The problem is that while monopoly capital tries to bury it by ignoring it, the state may take an unwelcome interest in an oppositional cinema. The direct or indirect influence of state on film industries is common across the world. The situation is still colonial in the sense that there is an unequal concentration of power located elsewhere: in the headquarters of financial institutions like the World Bank, the IMF, the Wall Street stock market; in the boardrooms of the multinational companies operating within the third world and the political capitals of the West like Washington.<br>The difficulty of radical filmmakers in getting their films to their audience is an enduring, structural and persistent problem. Filmmakers who accept this responsibility have two possible audiences: the middle and upper classes from which they might themselves originate, the principal consumers of film entertainment; and the workers and peasants who make up the vast majority of most of these countries. The first audience is largely urban, accustomed to foreign culture, and upwardly mobile within the local elite power structure. The second audience is more difficult to reach. It often has a firmer grasp of native culture and tradition and thus is more resistant to normal film fare and other colonizing culture. And it also has a key stake in social, economic, and political change. Both audiences are composed of spectators, and in the “continent of hunger” spectators are “cowards and traitors.” Therefore with both audiences, the filmmaker’s purpose is not to create “understanding spectators,” in Miguel Littin’s phrase, liberals who despite themselves are collaborators with the enemy, but to transform spectators into actors, or participants in the revolution. In order to bring about this transformation, filmmakers seek an original and an empowering use of language.<br>.<br>Examples<br>Third cinema in the context of India is first about self-representation, the articulation of the colonized individual, the absent subject, into history. Free from colonization of time and space — tamed temporality where past has been emptied of meaning and weight and future has been made perfect, and colonial appropriation of conceptions of geography and land, history and time, and language and hence consciousness, Indian cinema has come a long way. It exists in historical, linguistic, political situatedness — among nation-states, multinationals, diasporic communities, sub national groupings and movements.<br>Two extreme examples of third or even fourth cinema are given below:<br>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYYrPEa8ppA<br>https://vimeo.com/157416877<br>These are very stark visuals of the violence happening in the Naxal affected areas of Jharkhand, Chattisgarh and Orissa. Some of the questions that arise are “What does it mean to see figures of death and violence on screen invoking pathos” “Does everyone on this planet have an equal chance to live? And Gayatri Spivak’s “Can the subaltern speak?” In global resource wars, the environmentalism of the poor is frequently triggered when an official landscape is forcibly imposed on a vernacular one. Adivasis, Dalits and people who do not belong to the civilized society heed to riverbanks, floodplains, river dependent forests, and catchment areas that have sustained them for millennia. Such people may belong to the land but according to the Lockeian logic of private property, the land doesn’t belong to them because they are considered culturally inferior or in Annu Jalais’s terms “dispensable citizens” according to the myth of social Darwinism.<br>They respond to oppression, exploitation and exoticization. Engaging in strategies of resistance, opposition, these films are made by a filmmaker representing the oppressed community and hence deinstitutionalizing the “looking relationship” between first-world viewers and fourth-world subjects. The underlying politics of imperialism insisted that colonization was beneficial to the people being colonized. Classic colonial — post colonial discourse is repeated — territorial, economic and symbolic rape of a civilization, fixity in a deformed otherness — the pained and self conscious process of reclaiming one’s own history and traditions. <br>Exponential upsurge in indigenous resource rebellions across the globe surging the high rate of neoliberalism has resulted largely from a lash of temporal perspectives between developers — dispossessors who arrive from different time zones to impose on habitable environments unsustainable calculations about what constitutes the human gain. Change is a cultural constant but the pace of change is not. Temporal contests over how to sustain, regenerate, exhaust or obliterate the landscape as resource discount spiritual values serving webs of accumulated cultural meanings. These are the socioenvironmental fallouts of development agendas whose primary beneficiaries live elsewhere: women’s rights, minority rights, tribal rights, property rights, the right to freedom of speech and assembly and the right to enhanced economic self-sufficiency are something these people are fighting for and therefore need a voice of their own.<br> These films were screened at film festivals like Kochi Biennale, informal popular gatherings as well as in student milieu and in radical institutions.<br>One of the principles of third cinema is — insistent address to a unitary spectator who is at once disingenuous (requiring lessons in class consciousness and postcolonial development) and sophisticated (capable of appreciating an otherwise rarified oppositional aesthetics) Thus, third cinema’s critical reception and reception at film festivals should seldom be mapped onto the same experiential terrain as those of audiences at popular venues.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a1ed5510f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Film review]]></title>
            <link>https://greyflak.medium.com/film-review-701e95eeae7d?source=rss-12d2d8e3c0c3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/701e95eeae7d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Namita]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Mar 2018 13:51:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-27T13:51:17.441Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Blood of a poet (1930) — Jean Cocteau <br>https://archive.org/details/JeanCocteauLeSangDunPote1930<br>This first film by the extraordinary artist, poet, filmmaker — Jean Cocteau is a 50 minutes long sequence of surreal imagery powerfully laced together with haunting sounds. The film has no straight narrative or story structure, but things happening according to an apparent symbolic order. <br>It starts with the following text:<br>“Every poem is a coat of arms. It must be deciphered.”<br>This sets the context of the film that the following images are something to be deciphered individually by the viewer and leaves the scope for multiple interpretation. It’s divided into four parts –<br>Episode 1: The wounded hand or the poet’s scars<br>Image: It starts with a tower collapsing, artist drawing on a canvas cut to a tattoo on his scarred back, music, knocking on the door, lips start moving, rubs off the mouth, somebody comes in and jumps back off, removes the wig, washes hands, line drawing of face revolving, surprised — appear on the hand. Voice seems to be coming from the lips, goes to the window and then kisses it open eyes painted on closed eyes. Mask revolves — name of the filmmaker — being trapped in one’s own film — statue hand on mouth, veins on the hand, statue starts smiling, top shot from the ceiling, dialogue <br>Sound: Non diegetic — narrator’s voice, acousmatic sound of canons going in the background, music accompanying the movement of characters, sound of cock to show morning<br>Episode 2: Do walls have ears?<br>The statue starts talking to the artist about escaping the room through the mirror, he jumps off to the other side and swims in the darkness, enters hotel of lunacies, looks through a keyhole and sees a mexican man dying in slow motion and reverse shot of standing up straight, another hole — china’s mysteries, shadows of hands smoking, next door says flying lessons and there’s a woman scolding and beating her trapped child, next door there appears a sofa with a illusionistic wheel and shoes of a woman and man outside, looks like desperate meeting of hermaphrodites, the sign showing “mortal danger”, somebody hands a revolver and he shoots himself — “eternal glory”, comes back out of the mirror and destroys the statue, scene cuts to outside where some boys are having a snowball fight and torturing one kid.<br>Sound: clock ticking, heart beating, sighs <br>Episode four: Desecration of the host<br>The boy dies with blood oozing out of his mouth, the artist and his muse play cards on a table just beside him, the woman says ‘unless you hold the ace of hearts, you’re doomed” — Bourgeois people in the balcony above. Black man appears with wings and covers the dead boy, the screen fades and he shoots himself again, blood oozes out and people in the audience clap. In the end, the woman becomes a statue again and parades around with the globe and the harp. “The mortal weariness of immortality”</p><p>The film is essentially an exploration into the creative process of an artist full of dreams and adventures; a self-conscious exploration of the subconscious, even the unconscious. Cocteau uses symbols to narrative the myth of a poet’s trouble with life and death, his longing to create something that lasts beyond his life and desire for love, lust and immortality. The shots are a mix of what Lyotard describes as “Tableau vivant” and Epstein’s idea of close ups to get the best facial expressions of the dramatic actor in specific setting. <br>Unwilling to endure the solitude required for creativity, he attempts to pass his muse into a statue, which exacts its revenge by condemning him to a series of disconcerting adventures into his memories and dreams. The theme of suicide goes along with the theme of narcissism and applause of the audience as essential in the making of a great art work. The problem here though is the protagonist is male and the film ignores any ideas of a female poet, although there’s a shot pointing towards the androgynous nature of the artist’s perception of himself. <br>His use of mirrors, trick perspectives, reversed footage and animation to approximate the dream state is inspired and it’s tempting to disregard his anti-allegorical protestations and seek intellectual significance in the stream of narcissistic images that elongates the time it takes for a building to collapse to explore the agony and the ecstasy of creation.</p><p>The Perfect Human (1967) — Jørgen Leth<br>(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W9kls6bMkRo) <br>“Today too I experienced something I hope to understand in a few days” <br>The recurring dialogue in this slick, stylish, black &amp; white film is a comment on the nature of experience and understanding of ourselves through it, the relation of cause and effect and the creation of a self, distinct from others. It explores our obsessions with our self and the image we create for ourselves in order to reach some kind of true perfection according to social and personal systems of ideals. Anything not shown in the film like disability, other races, ugliness, and other attributes of human condition that do not abide by the this idea of perfection is left out. Human is reduced to his performance of everyday rituals and actions that<br>The camera looks at the actors in a detached manner, ‘functioning’ in a white boundless room, as though they were subjects in a zoo. This othering gaze on us which probes us to reflect on our banalities provides a sort of comical relief to our existence. Repetitive narration and slightly mismatched word/picture relations creates an atmosphere of awkward feelings. The dialogue, although brief, is heavily weighted and contributes to the characteristics of how we view man and woman, their relationship, the imperfections that contribute to a man’s perfection, things man takes for granted, and what man truly longs for.</p><p>La Faim (The hunger) (1974) — Peter Foldes<br>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vwU3UARE6yc</p><p>This animation produced by National Film board of Canada is a morality tale about greed and gluttony in the (then) modern society. It is a satire on self-indulgence in a hungry world where man has no control over his desire for sex, food, and other products where everything is commodified including his own fetishes. This is the first computer generated animation film with rapidly dissolving, reshaping images creating a stark contrast between abundance and want. The film follows a linear narrative but the scenes shift from one to another in a surreal manner. The sounds are non-diegetic with music that increases and decreases according to the action.</p><p>The exception and rule/ karen mirza-butler <br>(https://vimeo.com/15908774)<br>Mirza/Butler’s The Exception and the Rule, filmed in Pakistan and India, is a complex bricolage of formal experiments, overlapping narratives, fictional collaborators and performative quotations that explore Bertolt Brecht’s concept of Lehrstcke so as to ask the simple but urgent question, ‘what is it to make a political film?’<br>The film starts with two English people sitting on the streets, cut to news and violence scenes from Pakistani TV. The narrator mention his intent to go and film in India which was denied and therefore making this film, the shot cuts to a fast motion footage shot somewhere in Karachi with interspersed images of public spaces, There white text on black background “This film is comfortable with otherness as long as it’s not really other.” There’s a voice of a woman introducing the other filmmaker who says choosing the position of the camera means to take sides and they will shoot both on film and video. There is an interview done with a common man in the market who recites about what politics and art means from the paper. Cut to political messages on the wall and newspapers double exposure, cut to a person describing how the people are reacting to the shoot happening at a location and whatever is happening in the frame. The screen turns to black while sound still goes on (in the wings effect) bollywood, local music, background sounds that take you back to a place, woman standing in the middle of the road and clapping with her slippers. The narrator then explains that they blame intellectuals to want to make films for the working class which they themselves don’t understand. If a worker makes a film on his vacation, it is political. Because we live under the reign of private property.<br>The intermission is at the Wagah border on the border of India and Pakistan., black and white footage of nationalistic marches cut to repetitive chant of narrator — “Images I wish I should’ve made but couldn’t”</p><p>The film employs a variety of strategies in negotiating consciously political themes. Avoiding traditional documentary modes, it frames everyday activities within a period of civil unrest, incorporating performances to camera, public interventions and observation. Using film, video, found footage and photography, it throws its own site, narrative and production into question, particularly through use of direct (though unacknowledged) citations, its ambiguous application of fictional elements, and through a use of text and spoken English or Urdu.<br>The ‘rule’ implies a legal language or a directive, while the ‘exception’ evokes being ungovernable or searching for an alternative to either the state or the free market. Together, they act as both a statement that ‘the rule cannot exist without the exception, and a question as to what a state of exception might be.<br>Conclusion<br>All the films mentioned above have a common thread of questioning what it means to be an artist and a human in the different societies and times. Using different techniques of combination of images and sounds, they all provoke the viewer to question their realities without telling a story. Even though they were made in different times and different places, they all have a common theme of what art can do in the modern society and what it means to make a film in such times.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=701e95eeae7d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>