<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Greyson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Greyson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses?source=rss-7320d913ac7c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 16:19:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Bæddels Took Them]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/when-b%C3%A6ddels-took-them-d75d9e1688d6?source=rss-7320d913ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d75d9e1688d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[baeddelism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tumblr]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Greyson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Mar 2022 02:00:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-12T02:06:43.825Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An interview and reflection on the Bæddelism movement</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xXRFmDYV6_ZYPny25aEuuw.png" /></figure><h4>How did you first learn about <a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/lets-talk-about-b%C3%A6ddels-a-comprehensive-retrospective-a59784bf311b">Baeddelism?</a></h4><h4>Vera:</h4><p>I started dating a trans woman I’d been hanging out with who was relatively cool at first, was also relatively popular on Tumblr, but started to get into very anti-men rhetoric.</p><p>This trans woman took advantage, I feel, of my actual, legit trauma of cisgender men, and she started wording that in a way to suggest that trans men were also dangerous. While there were some issues that I had with a few trans men, I don’t feel that anyone- regardless of gender- is inherently good or evil.</p><p>Then I saw this person’s friends start referring to themselves as “Baeddels”- or some sort of quippy parody of the word.</p><h4><strong>How did you first come into contact with the trans women that introduced you to Baeddelism?</strong></h4><p>I met them in anarcho-feminist, radical marxist, radical communist spaces. Very heavily influenced by academia, and very white-dominated academic spaces.</p><h4><strong>What was your experience with Baeddels, and with Baeddel ideology as a whole, like?</strong></h4><p>A lot of word salad [laughs]. A lot of confusion, a lot of rewriting history and my own experiences. And what I mean by that is that they were rewriting my experiences, and taking ownership of them from me- like, they would explain my own experiences to me.</p><h4><strong>So sort of co-opting your experiences and narrative?</strong></h4><p>Yeah. Well, the co-opting didn’t come until I started talking about intersex stuff, but they would definitely use my experiences of being antagonized as a kid, or the misogyny and sexism I experienced, to further their own narrative that they were inherently separate from.</p><p>What these Baeddels seemed to be saying was that <strong>women couldn’t be sexist, and that men were</strong>; it’s this idea that they have, this, “I’m a woman, so I can’t be hurtful to you”. Any Feminist theorist will tell you that you don’t need to be a man to enact misogyny.</p><h4><strong>Did you have more experience with Baeddels in person, or online?</strong></h4><p>I knew probably four Baeddels in real life, but most were online.</p><p>Online they were more willing to say things that were, for lack of a better word, <em>stupid</em>. They would say things that lacked any kind of logical sense. But in person, they would go into this kind of toxic femininity- this <strong>weaponization of weakness</strong>. And I think that’s because online they were often in these echochambers, but in person they had to rely on much more subtle manipulation.</p><h4><strong>You mentioned that the trans women you interacted with were very often separatists- how did that manifest?</strong></h4><p>There was a time when I had predominantly been around men my entire life- and I enjoy dating men- and the first time I dated a trans woman, she told me that “there’s no greater pleasure than a trans woman dating a trans woman”. And I had never even really identified as a trans woman, I was just always seen as a really butch cis woman. She saw me as- and this is going to sound really self-absorbed- someone she really wanted to be. She was very tall, and I was very short, and she envied that kind of thing about me.</p><p>[The same woman] was dating a trans man, and she got really upset when he kissed me one time. He was her meal ticket at the time; he was working and she wasn’t, he was cleaning for and driving her, and when I came in I started doing some of that cleaning for them. And they both took advantage of that, but I think she- and I see a lot of Baeddels do this, actually- <strong>they’ll have one trans man they can date, or that the group can date, and they’ll really use him, so very much, to do all the labor, the emotional labor, the cooking, and working to support them, because it’s “safer to be a trans man than to be a trans woman”.</strong> Which isn’t true.</p><p>I think when he kissed me, she got really threatened by that- and that’s when she started doing things like accusing me of making up an eating disorder. She called me out on Tumblr, which like, she convinced me to be on Tumblr in the first place because she wanted us to be like “hot Tumblr dykes”- like some sort of internet power couple.</p><p>And I could talk at length about this, and <strong>the triggering my eating disorder, and trying to get me to be thinner, and thinner, and thinner</strong>. And that goes back to the intersex thing, because I know a lot of fat distribution is dependant on hormones. A lot of trans women- especially the thin ones- want everyone to look like them, like very skinny.</p><blockquote>“I felt really lonely there, and stupid all the time. I felt like I was being a bad trans person.”</blockquote><p>I’ve actually been told by a Baeddel that <strong>the fat positivity movement is inherently transphobic</strong>, because it talked about curves and body fat, and not all women have curves. And while there’s room to speak about how exclusionary that can be to trans women, I was told that I was being transphobic for engaging in fat positivity because of that. Which is ridiculous.</p><p>It was very isolating. <strong>I didn’t see my friends for a while, I was kind of just living with them, cooking and cleaning for them, starving myself, and slowly growing crazy.</strong> I was just being consumed by this weird academia and theory that had no basis, because everything was online and Tumblr-based.</p><p>I think I was coming from a place of being harmed by everyone in my life, and I needed a place to relate to someone; so any time I shared my experiences, they would go, “I relate to that!”, or “I experienced that!”</p><p>And I really hate to say this, but I don’t think they experienced everything they said they experienced. I know one of the Baeddels had said that <strong>she had grown up a privileged white straight man, and now she’s a lesbian, and that’s the most oppressed thing.</strong> And I asked, “what do you mean that’s the most oppressed thing?” And they said, “well, the cis gay men”- and well, what do you mean “the cis gay men”? That’s very conditional between race, class, and so many other factors. I don’t know if they had ever been to the deep South, but I really don’t know if a feminine cis gay man would have some kind of privilege like that.</p><p>Any time I asked questions there would be this very lengthy response, and the woman I was dating would use these big words she knew I didn’t understand, and it was very hard to keep up with her privileged white woman academia. That’s what I see a lot of them doing through academic terms, even though they don’t read theory at all- they just write their own theory. Which is, in my opinion, pretty dangerous.</p><p>It came to me at a point where I was very quick to weaponize anything anyone told me about their experiences, because I was always a fighter. <strong>I’ve been an activist for a long time, you know, and when these trans women would come to me with their experiences I would believe them. I wanted to.</strong> But the way they acted didn’t add up when compared to what they were saying.</p><p>I felt really lonely there, and stupid all the time. I felt like I was being a bad trans person.</p><h4><strong>Where do you think those problems within Baeddelism come from?</strong></h4><p>It’s difficult to say, because this was happening in the deep South, where I was at. And while I do think there’s a lot of TERF ideology that provoked this response, I also think a lot of people espousing this were people that were from big, progressive cities- like Portland- who came in and took over these spaces I was in at the time.</p><p>I honestly think a lot of these ideas came from a need to <em>prove</em> that their existence is valid; <strong>like they needed to prove that they were women, feminists, and even survivors.</strong></p><p>I think it comes from a place of insecurity, which leads them to feel that testosterone is evil, which leads them to really want to rid themselves of it, so they believe they must terrorize others for having it. <strong>They internalize this idea that testosterone itself is “bad”. </strong>They’re trying to separate themselves from all forms of masculinity, and manhood, and testosterone- so they demonize it. It’s very black-and-white thinking.</p><blockquote>“They would take in little bits of information and twist them to strengthen their claim to oppression.”</blockquote><p>I found that a lot of Baeddels will identify very proudly as autogynephiles- and that’s fine, but <strong>it was an aspect of how they would separate themselves from any kind of responsibility for their actions.</strong> If they hurt someone, they didn’t want it to be seen as a “man thing”. Because we’ve been taught that “men hurt people, but women never hurt people. Women are kind and nurturing, and they have eating disorders, and obsess over makeup, and all of these things. They never hurt each other.” Where that comes from is another story, but I think a lot of these Baeddels try to separate themselves from any responsibility for causing harm- because if they cause harm, that will link them to manhood. And that’s not an excuse, but that’s just kind of my theory.</p><h4><strong>Do you think that’s driven by their own dysphoria?</strong></h4><p>Yes, absolutely.</p><h4><strong>Are there any specific examples of how Baeddels or their ideology was harmful to you that you would like to share?</strong></h4><p>One time I admitted to a trans woman lesbian seperatist that I had taken testosterone when I was in my 20’s. She, because I was “assigned male”, got really upset- and she would say, <strong>“how could you put something so evil into your body, testosterone is <em>gross”</em>.</strong> Which is so incredibly harmful; no one should be criticized for the hormones they put into their body. Especially intersex people, who have been mutilated and coerced into binary genders for the entirety of history. She made me feel like I was evil for using testosterone.</p><p>Another time, a trans woman said that<strong> I was privileged for being fat as a kid. </strong>Which is just… <em>“fat privilege”</em> is not a thing.</p><p>There was a lot of online bullying about my being short, because I had “short privilege”- and that I shouldn’t take up so much space in conversations, because even though I’m “ugly” I “pass better” because of my height.</p><p>One time I had a Baeddel tell me that <strong>“intersex people take up too much space in conversations about these issues”</strong> when Baeddels would try to reclaim “hermaphrodite”. I’d seen a lot of non-intersex people try to reclaim “hermaphrodite”- I don’t know if that happens so much anymore, but that was a big thing when I was starting to notice Baeddelism and the ways of thinking around it.</p><h4><strong>Could you share more about how they co-opted or spoke over intersex experiences?</strong></h4><p>When I was younger I developed a condition- Gynecomastia- which causes breast tissue growth. Baeddels would say things like, “oh, you must be so lucky,” and imply that <strong>I and even non-intersex fat trans women have some kind of <em>privilege </em>for having more breast tissue.</strong> They would weaponize this to silence certain people, saying they had “fat trans woman privilege”, or even “intersex privilege”- founded in this misconception that intersex people have these beautiful, androgynous, idealistic bodies. As if being intersex means to look like the opposite sex of what they were assigned at birth, which isn’t what intersex is at all. It’s a serious medical condition. I had serious learning and communication issues growing up because of my condition.</p><p>I would tell them a story about a male peer of mine grabbing my breast tissue, and they would respond, “oh, that happened to me; I was given a ‘titty twister’”. And that is a violation of consent, but it isn’t the same thing. Having someone grabbing my chest tissue because it looked different from my cis peers’ bodies was not the same as a ‘titty twister’, but they would say this was an example of me experiencing misogyny from an early age.</p><blockquote>“These people are co-opting the experiences of Intersex people and saying that the root of all oppression is transmisogyny.”</blockquote><p>As an intersex person I was socialized with a micropenis, and I was expressing one time that it was used when I was a young sex worker- when I was 16- that it was a very scary thing because a lot of my johns were getting off on fucking me because I had like, tiny genitalia. So at one time I was criticizing this phenomenon of a lot of white trans women “liking tiny girldick” because I felt it was creepy and uncomfortable. <strong>And a lot of Baeddels at the time called me transmisogynistic, because “what’s wrong with wanting a cute little girly dick?”</strong></p><p>All I have to say is that as someone who was a sex worker at 16, an intersex person, and a CSA survivor- and they all knew this- this is a real experience that a lot of real people have, growing up with these things. <strong>And it’s seen as a fetish and a disability, but they’re trying to make this a cutesy feminine thing. </strong>Not a lot of intersex people will agree with that, it’s very harmful. But they would just try to shut me down and call me transmisogynistic, and try to say that I was like, saying all trans women are pedophiles. And that’s not what I’m saying, I’m just saying that it’s something that makes me feel weird.</p><p>I think the same person who told me that intersex people took up too much space in these conversations told me, while I was talking about genital mutilation and the hormones and steroids forced on intersex people, that I needed to be <em>careful</em> because I might do harm to the trans community trying to get people access to hormones.</p><p>I was talking about how intersex puberties can be delayed, and I was trying to relate those experiences of being alienated by my peers as being harmful, and she would try to make me sound like I was saying that kids shouldn’t have hormones or puberty blockers- but you know, there are only two hospitals in the country who have said they won’t do these invasive surgeries on intersex people.</p><p>They would talk about how the gay community was always forgetting about the trans community, and I’d point out that non-intersex trans people were constantly forgetting about intersex people. That’s a really dangerous rhetoric to have- <strong>if you don’t have intersex people talking to you, you’re not going to understand those experiences.</strong></p><p>There was one trans woman- I don’t know if she was a Baeddel herself, but she was definitely around them- and she said, “I just got my hormones checked, and I have a tiny bit more estrogen than the average AMAB person has! I’m intersex!” And like, the intersex experience is definitely different than just finding out later in life that you have slightly different hormones, y’know, completely undetected until that point.</p><p>But she’d come into these conversations and say, “as an intersex person…” <strong>Which is something Baeddels would often do, using their identities to shut down anyone who had any kind of criticism of them</strong>; it was this identity politics thing- and so many people talk about identity politics without having ever read Kimberlé Crenshaw and just totally shit on her work.</p><p>There were a lot of situations like that.</p><h4><strong>Could you describe how you witnessed them using associations with masculinity or manhood against people?</strong></h4><p>I’m from a very rural public school where women fight- and I think that’s something that a lot of rich Baeddels don’t understand, is that women fight each other; especially in lower-class areas. And I remember one time I was in a heated debate with one of them; I don’t remember what she was saying, but it had gotten to the point where I was like ready to take my earrings off and fight, and she was like, “no no no, fighting is a masculine thing.” Like she was trying to invoke dysphoria to make me not want to kick her ass.</p><p>And I was like, “have you ever been to public school?” <strong>Violence is not a masculine thing, women have been doing it forever.</strong> I think that was one of the ways they tried to demonize masculinity.</p><p>There was another time where this white trans woman was taking up space in a black neighborhood, and it was very dark, after a show- and it was a big group of people, men and women, trans and cis people, all just kind of hanging out. A black man walked up and said, “hey guys, what’s up?” And this one white trans woman started screaming at him very aggressively, accusing him of transphobia for saying “guys”. And I was like, that’s not transphobia, that’s just colloquialism. It was just a weird thing for her to do, especially in a black neighborhood.</p><p>The same woman had some nazi language, and she would call us to defend it, saying, “it’s reclamation!” or whatever. And Jewish and rRoma people would tell her, like, “that’s weird” but she’d just go “I’m reclaiming it,” because, y’know, trans women. I remember Baeddels trying to reclaim the black triangle as well, trying to claim it was for lesbians, but that was also a rRoma thing.</p><p>The way they adopt people into these movements is kind of shitty too- they would do it under this allure of “safety”, and they would usually have their trans men lackeys on, <strong>so paralyzed in fear that they can’t say anything, they “have to protect the trans women”.</strong> It’s so weird to me to see these, like, 6’2’’ trans women with their long arm spans put these super short trans men in front of their bodies, using them like these meat shields, almost. They’d say “you should be protecting us!” and like, I’m 5’3’’! I’d love to be that tall, I’d feel so much safer. It’s like they don’t know how bodies work in the world.</p><p>I’ve seen them use these young trans men’s (or transmascs’) own dysphoria agains them, weaponize it against them, and say, <strong>“don’t you want to be masculine? Don’t you need this? You should fight for us and do this work- that’s what men do.”</strong> They’d tell them to take out the trash for them because “that’s what men do,” and it’s like, you’re my roommate! Take out the fucking trash, It’s your turn! [Laughs]</p><p>And it’s so backwards, like, this is supposed to be gender liberating- but this isn’t gender liberating. <strong>This is the same bullshit that the cis people teach us; we should be better than this.</strong> They’d use this academia to weaponize it against other trans people- even trans women, especially if they didn’t match the ideal.</p><p>I knew this straight trans woman who was very open about this, that she liked dating men, and she didn’t identify as queer. And she’s also a street worker, right? But these trans women would say <strong>she’s privileged because she likes men</strong>- and I mean, <em>what?</em> She’s a street worker. They were trying to hold her to the same standard that they hold straight cis people; this woman who was non-passing. And she was very open about this; she would recognize her experiences as different from other trans women’s.</p><p>Trans identity is so fluid, so different, even depending on race, region- you can’t tell any trans person how to navigate their own experiences. It was like trying to say this woman had some sort of privilege, like she shouldn’t talk about her own experiences because she wasn’t a trans dyke or something.</p><h4><strong>Could you talk about the trans women- especially the young trans women- who would get sucked into this ideology?</strong></h4><p>I hope this isn’t going to sound awful, and it isn’t something I’m afraid of because the Baeddel movement has more of this grooming issue than anything else- what happened to me is I tried to live with one of these Baeddels, and she asked me out. And it was this slow decline where she’d try to use transfeminism as a dating mechanism, which is just weird.</p><p><strong>It’s a grooming tool,</strong> to find people who are coming from a place of hurt and be like, “no no, come here, we’ve got you-” if you’re pretty, if you’re white, if you follow our rules, <em>if you date us</em>. The number of times I’ve seen trans women who are attracted to men get told by these women that like T4T trans dykes is the way to go, and like, that’s trying to change someone’s sexuality. That’s not cool.</p><h4><strong>Could you tell me more about your feminist beliefs?</strong></h4><p>I mean that has a lot to do with my experiences with sex work, and it doesn’t have a lot to do with my experiences with being trans. It’s about marginalized genders- and I say that to refer to people who’s genders have caused them to be pushed into these places where they have to fight to survive. My feminism is based in capitalism, and classism, or marginalized income through capitalism.</p><p>Baeddels will say that trans men, even the ones who haven’t transitioned, have some sort of male privilege- which is a weird thing to put on someone else’s experiences. They’ll be super academic, use big words, and confuse people- especially people from lower-class areas who don’t have access to the same education they do. <strong>So this trans man who hasn’t transitioned, has been groomed to think he has some kind of magical male privilege in the world- <em>that can get him killed!</em></strong> And that’s fucking scary, I don’t want that to happen. I would hope no one would want that to happen.</p><p>Privilege is not inherently based in class, gender, income- it’s so varied.</p><p>I try to take radical feminism and add my own understanding onto that. I try to read even the anti-trans radical feminists and understand that some of it does have good points, and try to understand how they came to that conclusion in order to dissect that.</p><p>It seems like Baeddels don’t live in that kind of reality. They tell short people who are beat up because they’re short that they have some kind of “short privilege”- or that society hates tall women, which is based in transmisogyny; but they see short women as cute or adorable.</p><p>But that’s not true; society sees short people as weak and easy to beat up, that’s something you’d know if you’d ever lived as one. I’m not saying short people are oppressed, but it’s very clear if you’ve ever been a short person at a bar or at a concert that how they treat you is different from how they treat other people.</p><p>A lot of this is really based on Tumblr “social justice warrior” stuff circa 2011, which is fine, but if you live in an echochamber online you’re going to start seeing all these patterns that just aren’t there.<strong> It’s kind of a conspiracy theory, honestly, this Baeddelism,</strong> “trans women are the most oppressed”, “transmisogyny is the basis of all oppression”. It’s very Euro-centric, trans communities being seen as kind of a white thing.</p><h4><strong>How do you feel about there being a resurgence of Baeddel ideology? Like, you’re on Twitter; you’re seeing this yourself.</strong></h4><p>It’s terrifying. Trans people have a lot more exposure now, the community is growing, and I’m scared that a younger trans woman might think it’s the “hip” thing to do to identify as a Baeddel- instead of understanding that there is no inherently good or bad gender, and that we need to raise people and shape society in such a way that people are taught to be good to each other.</p><p>I think it’s really important to share these kind of stories, because I think that not a lot of people have run into these kinds of things in real life- <strong>have met Baeddels, and been able to recognize them</strong>. It’s so much more subtle- it’s a manipulation you don’t see online.</p><p>It’s very scary to me to see this “Baeddelism 2.0” or whatever you want to call it- <strong>trans women becoming the TERFs of the trans community</strong>. Like, they see what TERFs do and they just re-enact TERF behavior. I see these Baeddel trans women kind of becoming what they hate the most, and replicating systems of abuse they’ve been subjected to themselves.</p><p>It’s not doing activism any service, it’s not helping anybody. It’s not even helping cis people- it’s helping no one. <strong>The root of abuse cannot be a hormone or a chromosome</strong>, and saying, for example, that trans men have “mind phalluses”- that’s an absurd thing to say. I don’t understand how no one around them calls that out for how absurd it is.</p><p>It’s getting kind of scary in a way that, well, I would be afraid if a politician- for example- was on the fence about trans people and stumbled onto these conversations, and the reaction they would have to seeing this kind of rhetoric. I don’t feel like we have to be kind to our oppressors or whatever, but at the same time, we’re a very marginalized group with so many intersecting identities. To say that being a trans woman is inherently more oppressed than being Jewish is quite absurd, and it’s a dangerous ideology to fall into.</p><h4><strong>Is there anything else you would like to share?</strong></h4><p>I don’t agree with Baeddelism. While I do recognize that there is misogyny and sexism in the world, I also believe there is a lot of intersexism that happens in non-intersex trans communities, and I think the voices of intersex people are really important.</p><p><strong>I have a theory that the reason Baeddels tend to push down the voices of intersex people is because our experiences throw a wrench into that black-and-white thinking</strong>. The root of all oppression is not that of being a pure trans woman, in my opinion; we could talk about what the root of all oppression is all day long, but it’s not that.</p><p>Read the rest of the story:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/lets-talk-about-b%C3%A6ddels-a-comprehensive-retrospective-a59784bf311b">Let’s Talk About Bæddels</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/brushes-with-b%C3%A6ddels-23faff43f0b1">Brushes with Bæddels</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d75d9e1688d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Brushes with Bæddels]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/brushes-with-b%C3%A6ddels-23faff43f0b1?source=rss-7320d913ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/23faff43f0b1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tumblr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baeddelism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Greyson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Mar 2022 01:39:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-12T02:07:28.275Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Recalling the Bæddel movement</h4><h4>Author’s Note</h4><p>As we look back on the Baeddel movement almost a decade later, it’s important to remember not only the ideas they popularized, but the reality of the movement itself. Was this just a proposed ideology that ultimately fizzled out and disappeared- or was it something more?</p><p>Those looking back on their own experiences with Baeddel movement recall not only the ideology itself, but the actions and attitudes manifested by it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZBhXsOAfKrGy2zqzvmwuPw.png" /></figure><h3>Anonymous</h3><p><strong>Content Warning: Sexual assault</strong></p><p><strong><em>AN:</em></strong><em> This user requested to remain anonymous when their story was posted, stressing that they have not shared this information elsewhere on the internet.</em></p><p>When I was a sophomore in college, <strong>a cisgender man sexually assaulted me</strong> in a rather serious way that lasted several minutes. (we’ll call him Jeff)</p><p>He knew I was dysphoric and that I was, at the time, identifying as a nonbinary trans man. The part of my body that the assault focused on was a particularly feminine part of my body, and thus a particularly dysphoria-inducing part.</p><p>I had trans friends on campus, but we’d had a recent falling-out over a drug dealer they were friends with who made me extremely uncomfortable (we’ll call him Brian). The root of the discomfort I had with Brian stemmed from an event the year before in which he’d allegedly either choked a trans woman, or grabbed her and held her up by the shirt in a fit of anger.</p><p>Because I’d seen how they responded to that situation and how quickly they’d sided with Brian, and because they were also friends with Jeff, I didn’t feel like I could talk to those friends about what had happened to me.</p><p>I was in several trans Facebook groups at the time, which felt like the only place I could really talk about what had happened and how it had affected me.</p><p>I posted about how the assault was <strong>painful in a very trans-specific way;</strong> how when it happened, it felt like I was disappearing into statistics about girls in college, and how it was focused on a very dysphoric part of my body.</p><p><strong>I was a man, but I was a victim of a very specific type of misogyny that centered around my body, and I didn’t know how to process it.</strong> I knew that’s what it was, though, and I was angry and hurting.</p><p>This was at the height of the first wave of Baeddelism, and most of the trans groups I was in had a rule that we would always, in every discussion, prioritize the voices of trans women.</p><p>A trans woman who identified as a Baeddel took issue with the fact that I said I’d experienced misogyny, stating that, in her opinion, trans men cannot possibly, ever, be victims of misogyny. If we experience misogyny, it’s misdirected, and <strong>we aren’t the “real” targets.</strong></p><p>Obviously, this was a pretty upsetting thing to hear within days of the most traumatic night of my life so far. I got mad and argued that no, I <em>was</em> the direct target of an assault by a man whom I’d known had been attracted to me for some time leading up to it, and whether I wanted it to or not, misogyny had played a role in how it played out and why it happened in the first place.</p><p>I was banned from the group by her and her friends.</p><p>She had a ton of social capital in trans Facebook, and this was at a time when I saw Baeddels in the very groups this all went down in unironically arguing that trans women deserved trans woman-exclusive spaces, but <strong>trans men couldn’t be trusted to have those spaces</strong>- because they were too transmisogynistic.</p><blockquote>“She seemed to find a lot of joy in how much it hurt me.”</blockquote><p>I made a post in another trans group about listening to survivors and not denying their experiences, and then I went to dinner.</p><p>Within the half hour I was at dinner, <strong>the Baeddel and her friends got me banned from every single trans Facebook group I was in; </strong>except for two AFAB-specific ones. I left one of those shortly afterwards because it was full of transmisogynists and transmedicalists.</p><p>I ended up with pretty much no one to talk to about the experience at a time when I was already really, really struggling, and it’s one of several factors that led to me dropping out.</p><p>The Baeddel who got me banned also messaged me directly at some point during all of this, and I tried to get her to understand the pain she was causing me. <strong>She basically laughed it off</strong> <strong>and said it was my fault.</strong> She seemed to find a lot of joy in how much it hurt me, and blocked me soon after.</p><h3>Luke</h3><p><strong>Content Warning: Suicide, consent violation</strong></p><h4><strong>Q: How did you get involved with baeddels, or how did they get involved with you?</strong></h4><p>I used to run a <a href="https://aesthetics.fandom.com/wiki/Trendercore">trendercore</a> blog on Tumblr; trendercore was set up largely by transmascs who had been hard done by other transmascs with transmedicalist beliefs. The gatekeeping of feminine and nondysphoric transmascs was the instigator for why trendercore came about; it started off as a transmasc reclamation of nondysphoric and feminine pride.</p><p>Baeddel ideology was becoming more widespread at the time, and one blogger (@purgatorianpricess, or “Vice”) decided that a movement by and for transmascs was inherently exclusionary of transfems. I shouldn’t need to say this wasn’t the case; non-transmasc trans people were very welcome, they were just not part of that initial wave because the thing trendercore was rebelling against was, largely, other transmascs reinforcing gendered stereotypes on feminine transmascs.</p><p><strong>Vice began a harassment campaign</strong> against many transmasc trendercore blogs, accusing them of transmisogyny and sending their followers to harass and suicide bait people.</p><blockquote>“If I was a real man, I’d match cis male suicide statistics.”</blockquote><p>The antagonism toward me started after I reblogged a chain with Vice in it, where an adult trans woman was yelling at me (then a minor) very threateningly. I called her out on this and said I felt scared because of how aggressive they were being.</p><p>Vice and a few other Baeddel minors in her circle took this as an example of ‘transmisogyny’- as apparently calling any trans woman aggressive in any context is playing into the TERF idea that trans women are just aggressive men. This is patently terrible, and<strong> links into the “trans women can do no wrong” rhetoric Baeddels championed.</strong></p><blockquote><strong>“… Transmascs could be ‘redeemed’, like we were all knee-deep in some kind of religious sin.”</strong></blockquote><p>So what happened next? I get overwhelmed with threatening asks, messages, and harassment: often being told to kill myself because “if I was a real man, I’d match cis male suicide statistics”, and <strong>getting sent percentages of male suicide stats.</strong></p><p>I reiterated my stance: that maybe there aren’t many transfem trendercore blogs because it originated in transmasc culture, and needed more than, like, 3 months to permeate other trans circles. I was sent more pressuring asks and messages, until I caved and spent money on some online software that scours social media for the words ‘transfem’ and ‘trendercore’ together- so I could compile <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1pultPlX64bDbDO29nYYYL-d0PCGbMRA6he-qhRoNgpg/edit?usp=sharing">a list of non transmasc trendercore social medias</a> in an attempt to get the suicide baiting and violent anons off my back.</p><p>This did work to a small extent; suddenly they were parroting <strong>this idea that transmascs could be ‘redeemed’, like we were all knee-deep in some kind of religious sin.</strong> But the harassment kept on coming.</p><p>TME/TMA (TransMisogyny Exempt / TransMisogyny Affected) language was also a big, big part of the harassment. Like, a <em>big </em>part of it. “TMEs” was used then as it often is today- <strong>as a shorthand for “transmasc”.</strong></p><p>There was this one transfem blogger who was against the whole purgatorian-princess thing; she <a href="https://sunnybunnyferalmode.tumblr.com/post/186063428027/hello-everyone">made a post</a> about how “calling a trans woman aggressive is not inherently transmisogynistic”. When I say she was like the only transfem defending transmascs, I mean she was the <em>only one</em> doing that.</p><p><a href="https://sunnybunnyferalmode.tumblr.com/post/190285923957/heres-a-couple-things-that-ive-been-meaning-to">I sent this ask to her years ago</a>, and you can start to see “transmisandry” pick up steam as a term. I think- and it’s just a theory- but the fallout around the Baeddels would actually become the foundations for later discussions of “transandrophobia”.</p><p>When it finally calmed down, it was like, November 2019. By which point I had begun to change my main blog into what it is today- I started by posting about what I faced as a trans man, initially using the word “transmisandry” to describe transmasc oppression. Then “transandrophobia” started picking up steam as a term (coined by <a href="https://medium.com/u/a22c41d86623">Saint Dionysus</a> <a href="https://nothorses.tumblr.com/post/636563851582767104/you-have-a-very-interesting-viewpoint-on-certain">in 2016</a>), and I was able to connect to other transmasc bloggers.</p><p>In January of this year, I spoke with a Baeddel who commented on one of my posts to ask where it first started using Baeddel. It replied,</p><blockquote>“Well years back I saw posts that were like, “bæddel” is the origin of the word “bad” and means “hermaphrodite or effeminite man” and “hermaphrodite meant someone with breasts and a penis”, and were making the connection that some people referred to by this word probably experienced gender similarly to how we did; what we currently call being a trans woman. <strong>It resonated with me with how hated trans women are by our society, so this etymology seemed reasonable.</strong> A lot of people I knew on here were starting to identify with bæddel and other old words for people like us, such as scritta and wæpnedwif, and I did as well.”<br>@thebaedlingdykefag on Tumblr</blockquote><h4><strong>Q: If you had to guess- where do you think problems within Baeddelism came from?</strong></h4><p>The problems came from the ideology, which was informed by the identity of the group. The belief that transmascs were inherently transmisogynistic (like some kind of Original Sin) meant that <strong>basically anything a transmasc did could be reinterpreted as malicious, even when it wasn’t.</strong></p><p>e.g. Transmascs being afraid of forced pregnancy is actually, secretly, somehow “rubbing it in” for transfems who want to be pregnant but can’t.</p><h4><strong>Q: If you had to describe Baeddel ideology, what would be the core tenants?</strong></h4><p>Baeddels believed that <strong>the perpetrators of transmisogyny have been misindentified as cis,</strong> so Baeddels identify the source as trans- specifically transmasc. Baeddels believe in a kind of either Trans Women Separatism, or Transfem Lesbian Separatism, depending on the individual Baeddel.</p><p>There was some mistrust of bisexual and straight trans women who were a part of the movement, as <strong>some lesbian Baeddels believed that their attraction to men made them a threat</strong>. So there was a lot of biphobia and ostracisation for having anything to do with maleness- which is a hallmark of the original <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feminist_separatism">Lesbian Separatist</a> ideology, too.</p><p>Baeddels also borrow a lot from cisgender radical feminists, because they are radical feminists as well; or TIRFS (Trans-Inclusive Radical Feminists).</p><p>Other bits of ideology include:</p><ul><li>Transmascs have male privilege</li><li>The trans community shouldn’t include transmascs</li><li>Transmascs pose a threat to transfems</li></ul><p>Baeddels also espoused some “kill all men” rhetoric, and encouraged those telling trans men to kill themselves. And, generally, they believe in an ahistorical narrative of continuous oppression from the age of Old English.</p><p><a href="https://transgentleman-luke.tumblr.com/post/669913655526195201/why-baeddelism-is-intersexist-and-ahistorical-and">I have mentioned before</a> that the etymology of “bad” is heavily debated by scholars. Even if it was linked, its to do with intersex people and the line of succession. Trans women are likely incidental.</p><p>Which is interesting when you see that they project that onto transmascs; telling transmascs that they’re just collateral damage and not the “main target”. Hypocritically, they will claim intersex history as their own, despite, by their own logic, not being the main target.</p><h4><strong>Q: How would you feel about a new “Baeddelism 2.0” movement?</strong></h4><p>Baedelism 2.0 really worries me, but at the same time, I think it will probably fizzle out again. It isn’t a coherent, unified movement- it’s lots of little friend groups who have differing ideas to each other or other groups. <a href="https://medium.com/p/a59784bf311b">The last wave of Baeddelism fell apart because of a breach of trust and a violation of someone’s consent.</a></p><p>My theory is that the Baeddelism 2.0 movement may even make it as far as a commune again, but inevitably, it <em>will </em>fall apart. Either because there’s bisexual transfems there and the lesbian transfems want to cut off all avenues towards any men, or via assault, disagreement, or falling out.</p><blockquote>“It is very hard to for victims to make valid assault accusations against their trans woman abusers without being misconstrued as ‘transmisogynistic’ by Baeddels and those who sympathize with them.”</blockquote><p>A friend of mine got sucked into Baeddel ideology on twitter. This was last year, so when the second wave was building again. She was someone I had talked to a lot about Anarchism and left wing politics in general, so her inclinations towards Baeddelism make sense. She suddenly started identifying as a lesbian, making an exception for my friend- before turning to universal man-hate and other Baeddel behaviour.</p><p><strong>That same person had previously been fetish-mining me</strong> for her mommy kink. I was freshly estranged from my own mum, and she stepped in to be like, “I’m your new mum now,” and would pester me to call her “mum” in Welsh- as at that point she was going by a Welsh name. I played along, but it transpired that she was basically using that to get off, and she had a thing for infantilising transmascs and being this mum/mom figure.</p><p>I mention all of this because I believe Baeddelism as a whole just attracts the worst of the transfem community. <strong>Yes, they’re hurting and yes, their pain with transmisogyny is valid.</strong> But it doesn’t excuse the repeated instances of boundary violation online and offline, or <strong>the toxic ideology that only causes harm to transmascs and transfems alike.</strong></p><p>You know how you get transphobic cis gays calling themselves mean gays to excuse their shitty behaviour towards other minorities? Baeddels are like that (hell, @baedlingdykefag calls herself a “mean transfem” in her messages to me) — <strong>they excuse shitty behavior by disguising it as liberationary politics</strong> and actively cause harm to others for ideological gain. The fact that sexual assault and harassment is a big part of this, at least for me personally, makes me believe that Baeddelism just attracts the worst people.</p><p><strong>Their actions are not representative of transfems as a whole.</strong> But it is very hard to for victims to make valid assault accusations against their trans woman abusers without being misconstrued as “transmisogynistic” by Baeddels and those who sympathize with them.</p><h3>Others</h3><p>The following are shorter segments from a couple of experiences that were shared with me in relation to Baeddelism.</p><h4>Anonymous</h4><blockquote>“I had one [Baeddel] directly tell me that I’m beneath her as a trans man, and that <strong>I should “Shut my smelly cooch up” and only use my voice to uplift trans women. I was a minor at the time.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>“She then sicced her followers on me, and they bombarded me with messages telling me I’d “never be a real man”, that I needed to “sit on the side and allow them to have the spotlight”, and even telling me to kill myself- because I was inherently toxic to them. I was 16 years old, pre everything, and I couldn’t even pass at the time. They didn’t seem to care that I was a minor, or a newly hatched egg.”</blockquote><h4>Kirin</h4><blockquote>“In 2020, Georgia was in a Discord server that I was an admin in. Shey got into arguments with server members mutliple times, and ultimately were banned over one of these arguments.</blockquote><blockquote>“There was a discussion about lateral aggression in trans communities- “transandrophobia” wasn’t a term that I knew about at the time, but it was basically a convo about transandrophobia in the trans community. The conversation was mostly between transmascs talking about our own experiences, and shey basically came in and said, “you’re all being transmisogynistic for saying trans women are mean to you!”</blockquote><blockquote>“Shey were denying that trans women could be transphobic, and <strong>upon me saying I had been correctively raped by a trans woman, said shey “didn’t have time for this,” and told me to “stop being transmisogynistic”.</strong> [Paraphrased]</blockquote><blockquote>“[When I encountered shem on Tumblr later,] I was blocked by Georgia and put on a blacklist shey had made. Shey have since reblogged posts accusing me of racefaking, harassing <em>Shem</em>, and a multitude of other things- from bloggers who threatened to physically harm me.</blockquote><blockquote>“I do firmly believe that shey still thinks that way, especially now that Shey openly talk to and reblog from Baeddels.I think shey always held their ideals, but all the recent discourse, and all of the people speaking out against transmasculine people, really pushed shem into being more blatant about it.</blockquote><blockquote>“Also, I do think that “transfems can do no wrong” rape denial thing is associated with Baeddelism.”</blockquote><p>There are, of course, a vast number of other experiences to be recounted, and voices to be heard. These represent only a handful of stories shared with me, which I have been given permission to make public.</p><p>As we look back on the history of this once-thriving movement, and as we argue over whether or not it should be revitalized, it’s the individual experiences with this movement that are the most important to seek out and listen to.</p><p>Read the rest of the story:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/lets-talk-about-b%C3%A6ddels-a-comprehensive-retrospective-a59784bf311b">Let’s Talk About Bæddels</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/when-b%C3%A6ddels-took-them-d75d9e1688d6">When Bæddels Took Them</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=23faff43f0b1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Let’s Talk About Bæddels]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/lets-talk-about-b%C3%A6ddels-a-comprehensive-retrospective-a59784bf311b?source=rss-7320d913ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a59784bf311b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[radical-feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transfeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baeddelism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Greyson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Feb 2022 23:31:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-23T18:49:48.799Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A comperehensive retrospective on Tumblr’s movement to make gender essentialism “trans-friendly”.</h4><h3>Disclaimer</h3><p><strong>Transmisogyny is real, and requires much more acknowledgement than it currently receives.</strong> The trans community is very much capable of transmisogyny, and often does enact or enable it; likewise, trans people also often enact and enable transphobia against other parts of the trans community. Trans women suffer at least as much as the rest of us, and trans women — as a class — are not privileged, and do not hold the power to oppress anyone else.</p><p>If you take only one thing away from this post, take this:</p><h4>Trans people all need to work on being better allies to each other. None of us can gain anything without the rest of us.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yIw18gORHnXs50EwhwUmBQ.png" /></figure><h3>Setting the Stage for Baeddelism</h3><p>We can’t talk about Baeddelism without talking about Tumblr user <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20140625080113/http://monetizeyourcat.tumblr.com/">@monetizeyourcat</a> (“Cat”), and the ideology she popularized on the website in the early 2010’s.</p><p>Cat was a loud voice with a huge blog in the early days of Tumblr. Most of her popular content was humor-based, but she also championed an ideology that synthesized certain aspects of feminism, transfeminism, and communist ideals. The ideology Cat popularized is better explained <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20231103051309/https://www.tumblr.com/werewolfchoir/625914652405137408/i-know-were-all-over-this-moment-but-boy-oh-boy">here</a>, but <strong>this is the foundation</strong>:</p><ol><li><strong>Manhood is inherently oppressive, and cannot exist outside the context of oppression</strong>.</li><li><strong>Being a man is, therefore, </strong><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025244/https://flarebossmalva.tumblr.com/post/171547254715/2014-era-trans-politics-really-fucked-up-my-self"><strong>ethically harmful and wrong</strong>;</a> particularly if you are giving up womanhood in order to be a man.</li><li><strong>Being a woman is, therefore, ethically correct</strong>; <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20190211130758/https://eternalgaylord.tumblr.com/post/105638515556/if-its-not-intrusive-would-you-mind-relaying-what">particularly if you are giving up manhood in order to be a woman.</a></li></ol><p><em>(</em><strong><em>Note: </em></strong><em>this is an understanding of Cat’s ideology as filtered through those who witnessed and were impacted by it. Cat’s blog only exists in archives, and original posts are difficult or impossible to track down at this point.)</em></p><p>You may recognize some of the ideas here as <strong>a version of </strong><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radical_feminism"><strong>Radical Feminism</strong></a>: in this context, referring to the version currently popular online that centers around the idea that men are <em>inherently</em> oppressors, and that women are <em>inherently</em> victims.</p><p>All Cat really did was map Radical Feminism onto the trans community: if manhood is Bad, and womanhood is Good, then trans men — who reject womanhood in favor of becoming men — are Immoral. Likewise, <strong>trans women — who reject manhood in favor of womanhood — are The Most Moral.</strong></p><p>The idea that trans women experience more oppression than any other group of trans people was (and still is) commonly taken for granted by trans people and trans allies, and this narrow understanding of how trans people are perceived by society at large certainly <em>feels</em> correct, in that context: trans women are punished the most by immoral society because they are, in reality, the most moral.</p><p><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20140625111044/http://monetizeyourcat.tumblr.com/about">Cat herself understood her gender to be a sort of choice</a>, and while she did allow that this was not a universal experience for all trans people, it is apparent in her ideology that choosing to be a woman is always <em>possible</em>. And if being a woman is inherently more moral than being a man, it stands to reason that choosing womanhood is, is many ways, <em>the right choice</em>. Trans men in particular were <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220725062743/https://werewolfchoir.tumblr.com/post/678651832926633984/i-noticed-that-old-posts-i-made-on-here-about?is_related_post=1#notes">indirectly pressured to detransition</a>, following the same logic that cis radical feminists apply: trans men are “betraying womanhood”, even damaging feminism itself, and it is morally correct for them to live as women — whatever the personal cost.</p><p>Nonbinary people who were AMAB (Assigned Male at Birth), were often viewed as “basically trans women”; a still-not-uncommon form of bigotry against nonbinary people that erases personal autonomy, and forces conformity to a binary.</p><figure><img alt="A screenshot from monetizeyourcat’s tumblr blog, reading: “i tend to use “trans girl” or “trans lady” or “trans woman” cladistically to include nb amab people including people who have very “masculine” aesthetics or looks and i think this is a good idea in general. i mean if you want me to not think of you that way i’d be happy not to but it’s just generally that this is a cohort i belong to more fully than any specific subgroup of it” (Posted 06/23/2014)" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1013/1*LgIcDQFXHv0ove0eVXegUw.png" /><figcaption><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20140708234029/http://monetizeyourcat.tumblr.com/post/89697932482/i-tend-to-use-trans-girl-or-trans-lady-or">[Link to the original post]</a></figcaption></figure><p>It’s unclear whether Cat ever identified as a Baeddel, and she certainly didn’t begin the movement herself. Members of the online trans community have, however, <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025302/https://werewolfchoir.tumblr.com/post/625917223807123456/at-the-height-of-the-myc-era-i-experienced-one-of">spoken to her influence on dominant ideologies in those spaces</a>.</p><figure><img alt="A Tumblr post by @blackmetalbaeddel: “Don’t call yourself a misandrist if you are not opposed to trans men as much as cis men. Under patriarchy all men are the enemy.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*d1LkD71v40a5DV5_.png" /></figure><h3>Establishing an Ideology</h3><p><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025303/https://defendtranswomen.tumblr.com/post/110578832542/just-sayin">The first post on Baeddelism</a> was by Tumblr user @unobject, on October 2nd, 2013:</p><figure><img alt="A screenshot of a Tumblr post. Tumblr user unobject posts an image of Google’s description of the word “Bad”, noting that the origin is “OLD ENGLISH”, and originates from the word “Baeddel”- defined here as “hermaphrodite, womanish man”. Unobject captions the image “just sayin’”, and the date stamp shows that the post was uploaded October 2nd, 2013." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/0*CJD-SkYRxvPM24is" /><figcaption><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211128202024/https://twitter.com/AcesArosEnbies/status/1464740033123037196">Credit to @AcesArosandEnbies</a></figcaption></figure><p><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211128202024/https://twitter.com/AcesArosEnbies/status/1464740033123037196">The post was quickly liked by @lezzyharpy</a>, also one of the first to call themselves “Baeddels”.</p><p>This post first provided the name and defining ideology of the Baeddel movement. The implication of the post was, essentially, that because the root of the word “bad” was “baeddel”, and because “baeddel” referred to intersex people and “womanish men”, this old English slur was proof that transmisogyny was the worst form of bigotry; and even, perhaps, the root of all bigotry. (It’s worth noting that <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220301223131/https://transgentleman-luke.tumblr.com/post/669913655526195201/why-baeddelism-is-intersexist-and-ahistorical-and">this interpretation of the etymology has been problematized</a>.)</p><p>While @unobject was the first person to make this connection, @autogynephile (“Eve”) eventually became, in essence, the figurehead of the movement. Of the other Baeddels, some of them were explicitly aware and supportive of the ideology behind Baeddelism, some of them were young or newly-out trans women seduced by the personalities involved, and some of them were tangential enough to the movement that their understanding of it was wholly different from the understanding those at the core of the movement held and promoted. Baeddelism was a sort of trend, for a time, and many participants wore the name without entirely knowing what it meant.</p><p>It’s important to acknowledge that as much as there <em>were</em> dedicated members of Baeddelism, and as much as there <em>was</em> a unified ideology behind it, there were also individual Baeddels who did not understand — let alone support — the ideology.</p><h3>The Ideology</h3><p>Baeddels essentially built upon the foundation of @monetizeyourcat’s ideology that had been gaining traction on Tumblr in the years prior, with some additions that ultimately defined their movement:</p><ol><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220207161348/https://ancientson.tumblr.com/post/669862456061001728/hi-i-cant-find-whats-wrong-with-urls-like-born-to"><strong>Transmisogyny is the form of oppression from which all (or most) other forms of oppression stem.</strong></a></li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220207161345/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/668882135310073856/genuine-question-whats-a-baeddel-im-seeing-it-a"><strong>Privilege is granted on the basis of assigned sex</strong></a><strong>.</strong> <em>(“AFAB” or “Assigned Female at Birth” vs. “AMAB” or “Assigned Male at Birth”)</em></li></ol><p>These fundamentals of Baeddelism were essentially <strong>a rebranded form of Radical Feminism</strong>, much like Cat’s ideology. In particular, they drew from <strong>the Radical Feminist idea that misogyny was the “primary” form of oppression</strong>; that which all other oppression stemmed from. Baeddels only tweaked this idea to replace “misogyny” with “transmisogyny”, which led to the rest of the conclusions Baeddels drew:</p><h4><a href="https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1bijYQ2KRGUkAJal46S6KaalGAijhbiw6?usp=drive_link"><strong>There is no “transphobia”</strong></a></h4><p>All “transphobia” stems from transmisogyny first, and transphobia as it impacts non-trans-women (or, sometimes, non-transfeminine people) is incidental.</p><figure><img alt="Anon asks: “So are you saying trans men’s male privilege cancels out the cissexism they face?” @unobject answers: “the argument is two-fold: 1. the two are completely unrelated- trans men are men and are structurally and interpersonaly in a position of power in relation to woman generally, regardless of “cissexism” and 2. that nearly all of “cissexism” is actually based in and enacted through trans/misogyny, as are the ways trans men have access to navigating through it.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/852/1*EZHXlBAEyWj1JzVBqNph0A.png" /></figure><h4>There is no “Trans”</h4><p>If “transphobia” isn’t real, what else is left of the transgender identity?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*nxru25DbzJtCiYcW9pP6xQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/514/1*OdAxFDpV34egSjjqqgFHWw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*5CdJxqPfAFMM1uoP7J06qg.jpeg" /></figure><p>While this is by no means the dominant understanding of transgender identity or community, the equivocation of oppression to identity is, in many ways, core to Baeddel ideology (<a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211007100921/https://nothorses.tumblr.com/post/634888542304305152/yeah-people-should-be-using-tmatme-as-a-way-to">and we see the lasting impact of this in still-widely-used “TME/TMA” termingology</a>). By this logic, if transphobia doesn’t exist, neither does trans identity or trans community (though they obviously believed that transmisogyny, and subsequently trans women, do). Therefore, there are no “trans men”, and belief in the existence of “nonbinary people” is highly contingent on whether an individual believes in the oppression of nonbinary people.</p><figure><img alt="A Tumblr post by @weapinwifebunny: “can we just ban cafabs from claiming to be ~~trans~~ please #men can’t be trans #they can only be men”. Comments by @autogynephile and @baeddelaire read: “cosigned”, and “cosigned, pinned to the top of my blog, etc”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/477/1*rk-lc0fSEWs3khAl2YhyHg.png" /></figure><h4><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211129212020/https://actual-mandible-garrus-labeouf.tumblr.com/post/179125307377/baeddel-ladyisak-corkysdebt-ladyisak-i"><strong>“AFAB</strong></a><strong> </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@kainiezgoda/assigned-sex-and-the-privilege-binary-71f88bcb0abe"><strong>Privilege”</strong></a></h4><p>The idea that within the queer and/or trans community, people who were AFAB/CAFAB (Assigned Female At Birth) receive unique privilege and positions of power that people who were AMAB/CAMAB (Assigned Male at Birth, a counterpart to “AFAB” and “CAFAB”) do not.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*bE0SLo8dwm6KxeARFOking.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>Trans Lesbian Separatism</strong></h4><p>… was what the movement was ultimately defined by, as the logical conclusion of their other beliefs (much like <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lesbian_feminism">Lesbian Separatism</a> was the logical conclusion of Radical Feminist beliefs).</p><p><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20181227050105/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/152271598940/hey-as-a-young-trans-girl-can-i-ask-you-what">Baeddels believed that only trans women can understand, or be truly safe for, other trans women;</a> therefore, contact with anyone who was not a trans woman was deemed “dangerous” and highly discouraged.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/521/1*FEZk4bxCKYNleLXCidX1dw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="Screenshot of a post by Tumblr user @autogynephile: “FELLOW TRANS WOMEN: Never ever EVER make the mistake of aligning yourself with trans men or their political interests. Do not participate in “queer,” “LGBT,” or “trans community” branded spaces, be very wary of “feminist” branded ones. Do not fill your head with trans men’s words or ideas. Do not date trans men. If you are isolated and suffering now, the introduction of trans men into your life will make it worse.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*RDC7jsH9UdoEcgAz481gYQ.png" /></figure><h4><strong>Trans Men</strong></h4><p>… also played an important role in Baeddel ideology, and the resulting treatment of trans men is what is often remembered today. Baeddels generally believed the following, either explicitly or implictly:</p><ul><li>Trans men <strong>are not oppressed, </strong>or experience so little oppression that it hardly matters.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*7YINkpJdn6ldX9JDVV1j2A.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Trans men <strong>do not experience misogyny</strong>, even prior to transition.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*Wk5z5KJcmra-vVb9bAPYmg.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li><strong>Trans men have access to male privilege</strong>, or trans men have an easier time passing, and frequently go “stealth”; thus benefiting from male privilege <em>as well as cis privilege.</em></li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*ozwpLXQu5LM9cCvc3agjgA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Trans men are often (or always) misogynistic and transmisogynistic, and <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211010130417/https://actual-mandible-garrus-labeouf.tumblr.com/post/179125307377/baeddel-ladyisak-corkysdebt-ladyisak-i">are not held accountable for this.</a></li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nMcCX4e1KuJAhh8WvRfz2w.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211010130417/https://actual-mandible-garrus-labeouf.tumblr.com/post/179125307377/baeddel-ladyisak-corkysdebt-ladyisak-i"><strong>Trans men oppress cis women.</strong></a></li><li><strong>Trans women enacting violence on trans men is “punching up” </strong>at oppressors, and therefore not only permitted, but encouraged.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*BjG44tAfz5m7XdKZoKeNHA.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li><strong>Trans men are inherently violent</strong>, or become aggressive and violent when they go on testosterone HRT (Hormone Replacement Therapy)</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*N--qWPTLS_U6_wv1CiX_Pw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The impact of this ideology is often discussed among transmasculine people because of the depth of harm it caused, directly and indirectly — and it was very much intended to. Harm caused to transmascs was not only permitted or excused, it was often actively celebrated.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*r1fQm4mAiTHad1HLy-GOeg.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong>Nonbinary People</strong></h4><p>… are often overlooked when summarizing Baeddelism, but Baeddels did have plenty to say about them. Baeddel ideology relied on the idea that privilege was granted on the bases of assigned sex, and nonbinary people’s genders were thus treated as irrelevent; they essentially did not believe nonbinary people truly existed.</p><ol><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025255/https://earlgraytay.tumblr.com/post/621207532428509184/if-you-have-a-the-timespoons-could-you-elaborate">CAFAB nonbinary people are either trans men attempting to invade women’s spaces, or cis women pretending to be trans.</a></li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025255/https://earlgraytay.tumblr.com/post/621207532428509184/if-you-have-a-the-timespoons-could-you-elaborate">CAMAB nonbinary people are actually just trans women who haven’t accepted it yet</a>. They must transition, or they are transmisogynistic.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/826/1*g3v2tSBob1pLS4iUYYFSFg.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Intersex People</h4><p>Intersex experiences, and intersex history, were often co-opted and erased by Baeddelism. This was often more a byproduct of their beliefs than an overtly-stated idea, but most notably, the term “Baeddel” itself is likely more applicable- if not exclusively applicable- to intersex people, rather than trans women. Making their reclamation of it as a “transmisogynistic slur”, or their claim that the word’s existence means that “transmisogyny is the root of all oppression”, incredibly ignorant- if not <em>actively harmful</em> misinformation.</p><p>Notably, Baeddels also believed that intersex people- being “more androgynous” (a harmful misonception)- were able to pass more easily as the opposite assigned sex, and that <strong>intersex people (even within transfemme spaces) had “intersex privilege”.</strong> Some even believed, and openly claimed, that intersex people were “hermaphroditic”; a slur against intersex people, and typically implying that the individual has both sets of reproductive systems simultaneously.</p><h4><strong>Trans Women</strong></h4><p>… did not receive universally positive treatment, either. Baeddelism was very much a cult-like group built around the firmly-held conviction that they were absolutely correct, and that anyone who disagreed with them was The Enemy. <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220207161348/https://ancientson.tumblr.com/post/669862456061001728/hi-i-cant-find-whats-wrong-with-urls-like-born-to">Trans women who disagreed with them were generally seen as brainwashed and self-hating,</a> and <strong>trans women who <em>did</em> agree with them were expected to subjugate themselves to the ringleaders of the movement.</strong></p><p>Within Baeddel circles, trans women were most frequently victimized by the abusers allowed to run rampant because “trans women do not, and cannot, harm anyone else.” — including, apparently, each other.</p><blockquote>“They were also bad shitty abusive people in general.</blockquote><blockquote>“… a bunch of them passed around a pile of smear campaigns and false rumors about virtually any trans woman that they had a even the slightest animosity for. Including the victim of the kinkster rapist. They’ve done other fucked stuff, like chased two twoc off this site for trying to make a zine, but yeah. That’s like, just some of it. I’m not up for going over the messy details of the whole shitparade.</blockquote><blockquote>“Full disclosure, I made a lot of excuses for these sacks of crap, even while they were out there spreading false crap about me […] I wasn’t aware of the worst shit they were doing until much much later.”<br><a href="https://rejectedbaeddeldiscourse.tumblr.com/post/139925257925/what-does-baeddel-mean-i-associated-that-with">- @punlich</a></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/479/1*RHQ0Fn7ZibgdN6Z6PbL89g.png" /></figure><h3>Inside the Movement</h3><p>Though individual Baeddels often existed in vastly different social circles from each other- particularly offline- those who lived through the movement highlight commonalities in their experiences.</p><p>One interviewee recounts the manipulation present in their initial involvement with the movement:</p><blockquote>“It came to me at a point where I was very quick to weaponize anything anyone told me about their experiences, because I was always a fighter. I’ve been an activist for a long time, you know, and when these trans women would come to me with their experiences I would believe them. I wanted to. But the way they acted didn’t add up when compared to what they were saying. <strong>I felt really lonely there, and stupid all the time. I felt like I was being a bad trans person.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>[…] “Online they were more willing to say things that were, for lack of a better word, stupid. They would say things that lacked any kind of logical sense. But in person, they would go into this kind of toxic femininity- this <strong>weaponization of weakness.</strong> And I think that’s because online they were often in these echochambers, but<strong> in person they had to rely on much more subtle manipulation.”</strong><br>- Vera</blockquote><p>It seems at points that the environment created within this movement- and the social circles that composed it- was almost cult-like in nature and in need for control.</p><blockquote>“It was very isolating. <strong>I didn’t see my friends for a while, I was kind of just living with them, cooking and cleaning for them, starving myself, and slowly growing crazy.</strong> I was just being consumed by this weird academia and theory that had no basis, because everything was online and Tumblr-based.”<br>- Vera</blockquote><p><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/when-b%C3%A6ddels-took-them-d75d9e1688d6">When Bæddels Took Them</a></p><p>Perhaps most chilling, however,<strong> are the patterns in their attitudes toward sexual assault.</strong> One interviewer recounts being subject to sexual assault, and upon posting about their experience to a Facebook group, being met with hostility from Baeddels present in the group- who quickly used their social influence to have them banned from some of their only support systems at the time.</p><blockquote>“I ended up with pretty much no one to talk to about the experience at a time when I was already really, really struggling, and it’s one of several factors that led to me dropping out.</blockquote><blockquote>“The Baeddel who got me banned also messaged me directly at some point during all of this, and I tried to get her to understand the pain she was causing me. <strong>She basically laughed it off</strong> <strong>and said it was my fault.</strong> She seemed to find a lot of joy in how much it hurt me, and blocked me soon after.”<br>- Anonymous</blockquote><p>Another recounts sexual consent violations from a friend-turned-Baeddel:</p><blockquote>“[My ex-friend] had previously been fetish-mining me for her mommy kink. I was freshly estranged from my own mum, and she stepped in to be like, “I’m your new mum now,” and would pester me to call her “mum” in Welsh- as at that point she was going by a Welsh name. <strong>I played along, but it transpired that she was basically using that to get off,</strong> and she had a thing for infantilising transmascs and being this mum/mom figure.”<br>- Luke</blockquote><p>And yet another interviewee discusses verbal sexual harassment during interactions with another Baeddel:</p><blockquote>“I had one [Baeddel] directly tell me that I’m beneath her as a trans man, and that <strong>I should “Shut my smelly cooch up” and only use my voice to uplift trans women. I was a minor at the time.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>“She then sicced her followers on me, and they bombarded me with messages telling me I’d “never be a real man”, that I needed to “sit on the side and allow them to have the spotlight”, and even telling me to kill myself- because I was inherently toxic to them. I was 16 years old, pre everything, and I couldn’t even pass at the time. They didn’t seem to care that I was a minor, or a newly hatched egg.”<br>- Anonymous</blockquote><p><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/brushes-with-b%C3%A6ddels-23faff43f0b1">Brushes with Bæddels</a></p><p>While Baeddel ideology itself does not explicitly condone or excuse sexual assault, it’s striking how common these stories are; especially considering how small in numbers actual Baeddels were.</p><p>It was, in fact, this exact problem that would eventually cause the movement to dissolve.</p><h3>The Downfall of Baeddelism</h3><p>Sometime between the group’s formation in 2013 and their downfall near the end of 2014, @autogynephile (also “Eve”), the defacto “ringleader” of the Baeddel movement, <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220317025247/https://twitter.com/gothmyths/status/1489823721732730882?s=20&amp;t=mTqXIP2ykn6QL-mL1h_Vkw">began what Baeddels referred to as a “transbian safehouse”.</a></p><p>This was apparently intended as a place for unhoused trans woman lesbians and trans women who, in general, had sworn off contact with men; the ultimate goal of the lesbian separatist ideology at the core of the Baeddel movement. It was thus also <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211010130417/https://actual-mandible-garrus-labeouf.tumblr.com/post/179125307377/baeddel-ladyisak-corkysdebt-ladyisak-i">referred to as a “commune” by some</a>, and <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025253/https://ancientson.tumblr.com/post/673946058730192896/im-glad-people-are-talking-about-the-harm">as a “cult” by others.</a></p><p>One occupant of the “safehouse”- Elle- later <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20150515082522/http://zeroambit.tumblr.com:80/post/93824290085/facts">posted to Tumblr that they had been raped by Eve</a> during their stay, and detailed their experiences.</p><h4>The Baeddels, rather than believing the victim and ousting the rapist from their movement, <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20181227050108/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/152271017285/this-is-why-im-not-really-following-this-new-wave">chose to close ranks</a> <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211006120149/https://rejectedbaeddeldiscourse.tumblr.com/post/153479429090/tw-rape-sexual-assault-victim-blaming">around Eve</a> instead.</h4><figure><img alt="A Tumblr post by @opiumhug: “I stand with Eve […] firmly, unequivocably, unapologetically. If you have a problem with this, get away from me, my blog, and my personal space. you are my enemy.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/848/1*gos0OTMFwfnUw2YZrvkG4Q.png" /></figure><p>Various reasons were given for this:</p><ol><li>The victim must be lying</li><li>The victim- and anyone who believed them- was simply transmisogynistic.</li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025247/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/183880416115/this-is-why-like-6-years-ago-when-half-of-the">Anyone who disagrees with the Baeddels is an Enemy Of The Movement,</a> a “carceral thinker”, and a danger to trans women as a whole.</li><li><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20150325073821/https://baeddelmoonabuse.tumblr.com/post/114285117233/bagelmoon-i-refuse-to-ever-throw-any-of-my">Trans women are incapable of sexually abusing anyone.</a></li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20240221234126/https://baeddel.tumblr.com/post/114590028242/i-stand-with-eve">“Standing with Eve” was the ultimate sign of loyalty</a> to the movement, and <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20240221235522/https://www.tumblr.com/baeddelmoonabuse/114285117233/bagelmoon-i-refuse-to-ever-throw-any-of-my">thus a mark of pride and honor.</a></li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20201002160203/https://weepingwitch.tumblr.com/post/152469473504/what-does-baeddel-mean-i-cant-really-find-a-good">It was okay to keep being a Baeddel no matter what, because Rape Accusations Should Be A Personal Matter.</a></li></ol><p>(You can read more about Eve’s own denial of these events <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220314192823/https://gnoll-queen.tumblr.com/post/100543132039/autogynephile-raped-elle-moved-her-community">here</a> and <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220314192336/https://valeriekeefe.tumblr.com/post/119432136361/facts/amp">here</a>.)</p><p>Years later, even people involved in the initial group have spoken out against the movement and actions of those involved:</p><blockquote>“I was in ~the Baeddels~ for years and like… we straight up did horrible shit.</blockquote><blockquote>“We harassed anyone that disagreed for any reason, our politics were terrible, our isolationism made an environmental ripe for abuse that I have firsthand experience of, there is nothing in that group worth salvaging or defending.</blockquote><blockquote>“Also acting like people are just bringing this up out of the blue is silly like… it’s being brought up because people are still trying to defend the shit we did instead of fucking recognizing that it was wrong.</blockquote><blockquote>“Creating this myth that hate on the Baeddels is just a way of keeping trans women in line is a tacit defense of the horrid shit we did.”</blockquote><blockquote><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211128202024/https://twitter.com/AcesArosEnbies/status/1464740033123037196">- @lezzyharpy</a></blockquote><blockquote>“like I’m sorry but I served my time in shitty awful Baeddel group in early mid 2012s and it fucking sucked ass.”</blockquote><blockquote>“… Like it’s straight up cult-like the way you build this self-reinforcing network wherein ayone on the outside looking in with any criticism is unsafe, not to be trusted, only there to hurt trans women, and the only people you can trust is this self-selected group of trans women.”</blockquote><blockquote><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20211009120414/https://lezzyharpy.tumblr.com/post/664269936418586624/like-im-sorry-but-i-served-my-time-in-shitty-awful">- @lezzyharpy</a></blockquote><h4><strong>This was not the only instance of abuse by people associated with Baeddelism.</strong></h4><p>Elle posted their statement on August 4th, 2014; between that time and September of the same year, another user by the name of Quinn <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20140920203417/http://quinnharley.co.vu/post/96317865095/mobile">posted about her own experiences with abuse at the hands of @monetizeyourcat</a>. <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20150501162602/http://www.homumado.biz/post/96508378695/mobile">Cat’s roommates in Seattle posted about their experiences with Cat shortly after Quinn did</a>. <strong>Both parties alleged that Cat had been a manipulative and abusive </strong><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20150501162557/http://www.homumado.biz/post/96532906665/mobile"><strong>roommate</strong></a><strong>, friend, and partner.</strong></p><p>Cat first attempted to argue the accusations, then later admitted that they were true and left the site. <a href="https://monetizeyourcat-blog.tumblr.com/">Her blog still contains her parting message</a>. It has been <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025308/https://justaquickquestion.tumblr.com/post/96342361895">pointed out</a> that this is not necessarily an action taken in good faith and desire for growth.</p><p>The reception of her abuse allegations followed a similar pattern to Eve’s: people who ascribed to her ideology, Baeddels included, <strong>believed that Cat was not and <em>could not have been</em> abusive, as a trans woman</strong>. <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025257/https://mayflyslacktivist.tumblr.com/post/96916689820/it-is-both-horrifying-and-kinda-of-perversely-funny">Others ignored warnings about her past and potential future actions</a>, citing transmisogyny as the reason she must have been accused at all.</p><p>It has also been pointed out that Cat’s ideology (and, relatedly, Baeddel ideology) <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025304/https://foxmccloud.tumblr.com/post/96337091101/you-know-something-that-im-thinking-about-re-the">was extremely conducive to abuse- if not <em>entirely constructed</em> in order to allow abuse.</a></p><h3>Why It Matters, and Why Baeddelism Never Really Fell</h3><p>Baeddelism itself has seen <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025252/https://nothorses.tumblr.com/post/675944324121477120/just-as-an-update-on-this-whole-mess-shocking">multiple</a> <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025259/https://nothorses.tumblr.com/post/676089751032496129/re-your-recent-update-with-baeddellism-links">attempts</a> at <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20181227050108/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/152271017285/this-is-why-im-not-really-following-this-new-wave">resurgences</a> by <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025305/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/667783224280465408/whats-even-funnier-is-that-theres-a-really-long">various individuals</a>, including <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220317025302/https://transgentleman-luke.tumblr.com/post/676380343532650496/i-just-want-to-thank-you-for-posting-about">documented experiences with self-proclaimed Baeddels as recently as 2018</a>- well after the movement first “fell” in 2014.</p><p>Most proponents of “Baeddelism 2.0”, a revival of the original movement, argue that the abuse that occurred within the original movement was either completely fabricated by detractors (sound familiar?) or, at minimum, not actually inherent to the ideology.</p><p>And, of course, there are some <a href="https://baeddel.tumblr.com/">original Baeddels</a> <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220317025250/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/183880440820/several-of-the-baeddel-crew-people-are-actually">still active on Tumblr today.</a></p><h4><strong>Baeddelism never actually went away.</strong></h4><p>“Baeddelism” was only one name for a set of beliefs that existed long before the specific term did, and hasn’t gone anywhere since the original Baeddel movement died down.</p><p>What the Baeddels did was put a name to the ideology @monetizeyourcat was cultivating before them, and what Cat did was popularize, centralize, and justify a way of thinking that had existed before she ever made her blog.</p><h4>This ideology has since been referred to, loosely, as “TIRF-ism”: Trans-Inclusive Radical Feminism.</h4><p>It is rare that anyone actually refers to themselves as a “TIRF”, and there is no real centralized TIRF movement; rather, a loose collection of radical feminist beliefs circulates various transgender spaces. The validity of these beliefs is generally taken for granted: of course (trans) women are The Most Oppressed People; of course (trans) women are Inherently and Unequivocally Victims In All Situations; of course (trans) men are Inherently Oppressors; of course (trans) men are Dangerous and Evil… and so on.</p><p>Like Radical Feminism, and subsequently <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TERF">Trans-Exlcusive Radical Feminism (TERF-ism)</a>, <strong>those ideas are fundamentally dangerous.</strong></p><p>The defining tenants of radical feminism are that misogyny is the root of all oppression, and that rather than misogyny being an issue of power and control on a society-wide level, it is instead, or also, a matter of oppression and privilege on an individual level: men are always oppressors, and women are always victims.</p><h4><strong>These beliefs fundamentally exclude and erase the experiences of other marginalized people.</strong></h4><p>Namely, people of color and indigenous people, who’s experiences with and concepts of gender do not fall within the strict and rigid lines that white, western, colonialist people’s do.</p><p><strong>Radical feminism is not a redeemable ideology. </strong>It cannot be reshaped into something good. It is fundamentally broken, and the movements born from it- lesbian separatism, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_lesbianism">political lesbianism</a>, TERF-ism, TIRF-ism, and Baeddelism- are proof enough of that. <strong>They each promote only surface-level variations of what is fundamentally cult-like thinking</strong>: only the in-group can be victimized. Only the in-group is safe; the out-group is inherently and universally dangerous. Only the in-group understands you. All members of the in-group are, fundamentally, <em>incapable</em> of abuse.</p><p>We cannot allow these ideas to be perpetuated within <em>or</em> without the trans community.</p><h3>Learn the Signs &amp; Prevent Harm</h3><figure><img alt="A Tumblr post by @birlinterrupted: “I have to wonder what the entire like… point I guess is of like reintroducing the sort of bogeyman of the ‘baeddel’ […]” Response by @insurrectionarycompassion: “You’re only saying this because you’re not an ex member who has to see these people consistently sanitize their coverup of numerous internal abuses. […]”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/483/1*wj4cam_d-bZ-mNdlM5ysuA.png" /></figure><p>Here’s what we can do to prevent this from happening again:</p><ol><li><strong>Learn what Baeddel ideology and TIRFism look like,</strong> even detached from the name.</li><li><strong>Learn what radical feminism looks like,</strong> even detached from the name. Even from people who claim to oppose radical feminism.</li><li>Act on dogwhistles. Call them what they are.</li><li><strong>Do not allow people to downplay the harm all forms of Radical Feminism have caused</strong>. Remind each other that Radical Feminism is not a redeemable ideology, and seek out other branches of feminism instead.</li><li><strong>Remember the harm that <em>has</em> been caused</strong>. Remember that it will be caused again if these things are allowed to go unchecked.</li><li>Listen to and uplift marginalized people. Allow them to speak to their own experiences, identify their own needs, and name their own oppression.</li><li><strong>Remember who the real oppressors are</strong>, and do not pit marginalized people against each other. The people perpetuating and benefiting from transphobia are cis people- and more specifically, cis people in power.</li><li><strong>Build solidarity with other marginalized people</strong>. One group of trans people cannot gain liberation without liberating all trans people, and one group of trans people cannot be targeted without the rest of us suffering as well.</li><li>Remember that there is no group or identity incapable of enacting abuse, violence, harassment, or other harm against another. <strong>Victimhood should not be determined based solely on an individual’s identity.</strong></li><li><strong>Remember that there are no acceptable targets</strong> for violence, cruelty, harassment, and abuse.</li></ol><h4>Red Flags to watch out for:</h4><ul><li>Using, or interacting with people who use, “Baeddel” anywhere in their usernames, blog descriptions, “about” blurbs, or other forms of self-identification.</li><li>Downplaying the harm original Baeddels did: calling them “misled”, their actions “mistakes”, but otherwise supporting or making apologies for their ideology.</li><li>Obfuscating, ignoring, or erasing the abuse and rape allegations against members of the Baeddel movement. (Especially if they claim those were made only with transmisogynistic intent, and/or erase the transfemme identity of the victims).</li><li>Obfuscating, ignoring, or erasing the harm done to other transfemmes by Baeddels.</li><li>Claiming TERFs only target, harm, or have ill will for trans women/transfemmes. Using “TWERF” or “TWEF” instead of “TERF”.</li><li>Claiming transmasculine people should not have any say in conversations about misogyny, transphobia, and/or TERFs.</li><li>Talking about “AFAB Privilege”, or otherwise implying that AFAB people share any universal quality or disposition aside from being assigned female at birth.</li><li>Referring to trans people by AGAB, TME/TMA distinction, or even transfemme/transmasc frequently or exclusively; actively erasing or not allowing room for nonbinary and intersex experiences that do not fall within those binaries.</li><li>Implying men- cis or trans- would be better if they were made into women instead.</li><li>Implying attraction to men, or being a man, is somehow a “curse” or a “burden”, or otherwise unfortunate.</li><li>Implying a fear of men, including trauma-induced phobias, should never be healed from or sought treatment for. Implying men, cis or trans, cannot also experience trauma around men.</li><li>Treating trans men or transmasculine people as “acceptable targets” in any way; for harassment, for abuse, for misgendering, for inducing dysphoria, etc.</li><li>Implying transmasc dysphoria is “toxic masculinity”</li><li>Characterizing transmascs as hysterical, whiny, delusional, crazy, or otherwise using feminine stereotypes.</li><li>Implying it is femininity, specifically, that is targeted by the patriarchy; that feminine people are targeted more than masculine people, that transfemmes are the most targeted for their rejection of masculinity in favor of femininity, or the implication that masculinity is only ever looked down upon by feminists.</li><li>Dismissing, erasing, punishing/ostracizing, disavowing, or treating with suspicion transfeminine people who do not agree with Baeddel or radfem ideology. Insisting all or most transfemmes agree with Baeddel or radfem ideas.</li><li>Using “listen to transfemmes” to silence other groups of trans people, and otherwise implying transfemmes are a monolith who happen to agree with you.</li><li><strong>In general</strong>: espousing the ideas, fundamental or otherwise, that defined the Baeddel movement. (including TIRF and radical feminist ideology)</li></ul><p>This list is not comprehensive, nor is any one thing on this list 100% certain to indicate that someone is a Baeddel- or if they are, that they are necessarily dangerous. It’s important to keep in mind how many people are groomed into this movement and abused within it; some of those who espouse Baeddel rhetoric may themselves be victimized by others.</p><p>But until we recognize these ideas for what they are and where they’ve come from, history can only repeat itself.</p><h3>Educate Yourself and Others</h3><p>It would take a long, long time and a lot more space to detail all of the damage done, the people hurt, and the dangers of continuing to allow these ideas to be perpetuated. Instead, I have compiled some resources and references.</p><p>I urge you to check these out, bookmark them for later, or whatever else works for you! (They’re also all much, much shorter reads than this has been.)</p><ul><li><a href="https://baeddel-txt.tumblr.com/">@baeddel-txt</a> and <a href="https://rejectedbaeddeldiscourse.tumblr.com/post/139322260755">@rejectedbaeddeldiscourse</a>, two blogs dedicated to documenting various posts and beliefs held by original Baeddels.</li><li><a href="https://defendtranswomen.tumblr.com/tagged/baeddel">Another blog’s tag for Baeddel history.</a></li><li><a href="https://baeddel.net/tag/baeddel/">Baeddel.net</a>, another archive of Baeddelism.</li><li><a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20211128202024/https://twitter.com/AcesArosEnbies/status/1464740033123037196">@AcesArosEnbies</a> thread, and <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20220317025247/https://twitter.com/gothmyths/status/1489823721732730882?s=20&amp;t=mTqXIP2ykn6QL-mL1h_Vkw">@gothmyths</a> thread, on Baeddelism.</li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20220207161345/https://quinndolyns.tumblr.com/post/668882135310073856/genuine-question-whats-a-baeddel-im-seeing-it-a">@quinndolyn’s recount of Baeddelism.</a></li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20240106012923/https://nothorses.tumblr.com/post/652585288262139904/do-you-know-where-i-can-learn-about-baeddels-from">My own post on the origins of the Baeddel movement.</a></li><li><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20221116221400/https://nothorses.tumblr.com/post/628844771472965632/thegreenmeridian-nothorses-so-i-wanted-to-put">My own post including posts from Baeddels (and others) as recently as 2018.</a></li><li><a href="https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1FjymFcoxeLwxGxO-qqFAH7nNz5IgF6k-?usp=sharing">An archive of assorted Baeddel posts</a>.</li></ul><p>Read the rest of the story:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/when-b%C3%A6ddels-took-them-d75d9e1688d6">When Bæddels Took Them</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@greyson.not.horses/brushes-with-b%C3%A6ddels-23faff43f0b1">Brushes with Bæddels</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a59784bf311b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>