<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by grothendieckprime on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by grothendieckprime on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@grothendieckprime?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 06:37:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@grothendieckprime/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Disgust]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/on-disgust-31b5ea6208a2?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31b5ea6208a2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Sep 2026 21:51:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-23T20:55:45.145Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>“Misanthropy is the result of an all-too-greedy love of man and ‘cannibalism’ — but </em><strong><em>who told you to swallow men like oysters, my Prince Hamlet?</em></strong><em>”</em></p><p><em>“Whoever knows he is deep, strives for clarity; whoever would like to appear deep to the crowd, strives for obscurity. For the crowd considers anything deep if only it cannot see to the bottom: the crowd is so timid and afraid of going into the water.”</em></p><p>I felt sick to the stomach for a full day after a champagne-tower wedding at a chateau. I refused antacid and decided to hike the Chemin de Nietzsche in direct sunlight, which had the effect of morphing the physical discomfort into a general sense of disgust with people. With habits of my own and of others.</p><p>First, it was a sickness with the way wedding crowds behave: people get upset when they only know a few people, and you’re one of them, and you don’t give them a clear way to contribute to the conversation because someone else you just met is asking specific and interesting questions, and then the first party gets upset and sulks with their significant other. Everyone is giddy and nervous to present a positive attitude and ends up just showing off a desire to consume because that’s the safest relatable performance. And they all want to show off what other travels they’ve been up to while insistently disclaiming that they only do fancy things for friends and family and please don’t take them to be snobs just for needing the Four Seasons.</p><p>Next, it was a sickness with myself. I felt like I was making cheap complaints that could just as easily be turned back on me. And then I felt frustrated for never really having metabolized my feelings about this kind of thing, even though I’ve been very vocal and disputatious about taste since adolescence. <em>How old do you have to get before you can bury the hatchet with this shit?</em> This proceeded to a disgust with the very idea of having to “metabolize” all feelings. And finally to a disgust with how deeply I have internalized this basically self-obsessed way of thinking where all personal affects are some kind of symptom that must either be confessed or else cordoned off from the outside world. It’s a kind of sickness — maybe the kind of cabin fever that Nietzsche imagined Descartes must have contracted during his military service. Bad air keeps you stuck inside of yourself.</p><p>Finally, a sickness with the crowd and with the thrall it’s had over me. I’ve picked clean over the years the way in which my own nuclear-family upbringing left the impression that taste and intellectual appetite are fundamentally <em>about</em> how they’ll sound in front of the class. How even as an adult it remains difficult to feel like anything other than total solemnity toward poorly-behaved tourists is “immature.” How having opinions is taking up space because it’s fundamentally imposing on people to expect them to parse anything other than in-group affirmation. What makes me sick now is how much my own efforts to <em>disclaim</em> feelings of disgust toward, let’s call it “crowds,” have done more to simply cultivate deeper feelings of stiffness and resentment. Stiffness and resentment, if put into the right vulgar political register, might be actually preferred where I grew up.</p><p>I hoped to convalesce in the Mediterranean sunlight and to find some kind of answer that wouldn’t be more self-questioning.</p><p>Partially. I was lucky to find, at the end of the Chemin de Nietzsche, a beautiful couple admiring each other in the cerulean water. They seemed to be young professionals from the US. I felt a relief that, for the first time in a week in Provence, I was watching people actually make good on the romantic atmosphere that everyone attributes to the place. <em>Yes, do your thing. Actually think about this life you’re building. Savor the moment.</em> Again, I felt disgusted with my curmudgeonly mood, but I wanted to praise how much better this was than watching the long lines for generic truffle-pasta joints or seafood towers, or the throngs of photo-takers.</p><p>But also — their calm and measured demeanor, the way that their friend spoke on the phone with one of his colleagues — these folks seemed like MBAs, possibly in private equity. Isn’t the whole professional-services world getting kind of shaken up by new technology right now? Aren’t they staring at the yachts of their clients and wondering why they shouldn’t be aiming for the big bucks? <em>Why be so calm</em>, even in love?</p><p>Here was Nietzsche coming back to me: what, exactly, is “health” — mental or otherwise — really supposed to be? What is the actual purpose of being so <em>resolved</em> about a world that’s obviously churning? Nietzsche lived through the “economic El Dorado” times of 1873–1900 where everything was churning. He understood the injustice of newspapers and having to keep up with markets!</p><p>So I had a change of heart. Maybe it was worth letting the disgust be a journey instead of a challenge to convalesce quickly.</p><p>The crowd wants a quick convalescence. Or, says Nietzsche, it wants a menu of a few things that are easy to parse: calm professional, nervous professional, contrarian, delinquent, yacht owner, clueless tourist. And the crowd thinks through every individual. I can see how I’ve managed to think myself a contrarian for many years. Disgust is permitted as long as it’s an obvious disclaimer of being an eccentric whose concerns are marginal.</p><p>The crowd does not want — this would be considered bad manners at a wedding — someone to present himself as a serious professional who reasonably expects his sense of disgust (even if he himself does not full understand it) to be received and recognized. The social script is public property, basically, and taking control of it for one’s own purposes is vandalism.</p><p>This fact is what friends and family strived to teach me as an adolescent. Think in terms of the menu, strive to “break down your ideas in terms that the crowd can act on.”</p><p>This was the advice in my corporate job as well. I’ve come to doubt it, of course: the fact is that the content of most ideas is itself objectionable to the crowd. To say, for instance, that wedding speeches really ought to be laudations and to use actual rhetoric, is off the table. The crowd in fact does not want to be concerned with specialized arts. The corporate crowd does not want to be concerned with insights.</p><p>The real advice behind “break it down” is more like: “make them feel good about moving in a direction that’s already highly visible.”</p><p>If I’m being honest with myself, I have never wanted to do that. This has undoubtedly caused me to pass up several opportunities in life. But perhaps I have a deeper attachment to my sense of disgust.</p><p>What is concerning is what Nietzsche observes about communicating ideas to the crowd. I spoke to a fellow at the wedding about some of my thoughts on the supply chain and how commercial banks operate. I got a customary “wow, sounds like a lot of moving parts and sounds like you’re really doing stuff out there.”</p><p>More disgust with myself as I reflected on the beach. What’s the deal with this habit of mine where I just talk and wave my hands until I’ve created enough of an impression of really thinking about a topic? It’s not real intellectualism. It feels like a kind of bluster.</p><p>Perhaps it comes from a basic disgust about knowing anything particularly well at all. My interest in European history and in Nietzsche and all of that was born during an unhappy adolescence when I really wanted to imagine “somewhere else” where I might be held to high intellectual standards. It took the form of a Wikipedia addiction, as with many men who get into map-staring. This was a great way for the crowd to teach the idea that <em>I don’t have any real business learning this stuff</em> and that, well, it’s great that some guys have hobbies.</p><p>And what they were doubtless trying to say is “the rest of the crowd needs to understand in 30 seconds how this relates to a legible category of work so they can say good things about you.”</p><p>It’s never landed. There’s something — and it’s perhaps still murky to me — about the struggle of <em>actually learning something well</em> that gets totally flattened by pattern-match talk. The murky hand-waving comes from a desire to show that I actually want to spend a lot of effort learning and sharing. But I think Nietzsche is exactly right: the crowd is <em>already willing to give credit</em> and waving one’s hands doesn’t change that.</p><p>Witness: people unfamiliar with AI seem to be unable to identify AI writing, and often prefer it. It’s difficult to imagine how one is even supposed to present serious writing to the broader public.</p><p>Real depth strives for clarity. It’s true: when I tell people about linguistics, which is an area where I have completed formal studies, I try as hard as I can to present information at a high level that helps the audience feel like they are developing expertise. And it’s alienating and unsatisfying, if I’m being honest. I feel disgusted for being merely proud of myself instead of monetizing it. And I feel disgusted by the feelings that people let themselves have about learning languages.</p><p>Which gets us to the oysters. Why does Nietzsche say that Prince Hamlet has eaten too many of them?</p><p>I get giddy at weddings. Upon reflection, I have to acknowledge that I do tend to swallow men like oysters. That is: the encyclopedic geography knowledge turns into an attempt to relate, to be exciting and excited, to create a social flow where there was none. Throughout my twenties this grew into a bit of a manic habit.</p><p>And what’s the consequence? Having a large group of friends isn’t so bad, surely? Don’t we live in a socially alienated society?</p><p>I fell asleep on the pebble beach under the shade of a cypress.</p><p>I awoke to the sound of Germans splashing each other in the water and I looked over. My first impulse was to figure out if I could understand what they were saying — yup, alles klar — followed by the impulse to try to come up with something clever to surprise them with.</p><p><em>Why am I doing this?</em></p><p>Out of disgust for what that part of the beach scene would be if I didn’t add my own levity, perhaps.</p><p><em>Who cares? Collect your girlfriend and go eat oysters with her and talk about The Gay Science, dude. You’re in France on your own dime.</em></p><p>Sublimated disgust! It’s had no space for its naive form so it comes out giddy. I got queasy again.</p><p>Meta-disgust.</p><p><em>Am I really trying to make a tragic hero out of how special and free-thinking I am? Wouldn’t someone with purported intellectual talents be able to do something more… original with all of this?</em></p><p>It’s the crowd thinking again, but it’s also me. Nietzsche is right: morality is the herd instinct of the individual.</p><p>I suppose it forces two uncomfortable questions. One: is there really something so objectionable about fastening oneself as a tragic hero, with the lightheartedness that Nietzsche’s troubadour might, as much as contemporary culture might reprise that kind of earnestness? Two: could disgust, in its naive form, be the source of other emotions — levity, or creative dedication, or care for what is refined?</p><p>More on that when my stomach settles. I won’t be rushing myself.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31b5ea6208a2" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/on-disgust-31b5ea6208a2">On Disgust</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[À Propos de Nice]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/a-propos-de-nice-ade5c7945903?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ade5c7945903</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Sep 2026 19:13:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-22T21:38:50.535Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The silent film shows beach sweepers pushing the sand, then casino workers sweeping the chips off the table, then sweeping plastic toys of swimmers off the tables.</p><p>It feels clever in a way I’d very much like to imitate, but something inside of me is very tense. A sort of emotional indigestion afflicts me.</p><p>Somehow it’s a required precaution to avoid comment on this place. I’m just passing through, I don’t know enough, I want to be respectful and informed and humble as a traveler. <em>You know the way those Henry Miller types make fools of themselves commenting on places they don’t actually understand.</em></p><p>It’s irresistible to reach for some American refrain: “I’m not from a place with a real historical sense, and I don’t want to participate in just painting my own projections over the rest of the world.” There’s a whole catalog of notions that I feel have to be disclaimed as tropes: Cary Grant’s outfit in <em>To Catch a Thief</em>, Grace Kelly envy, MBAs at Yacht Week, American boy wants to see himself as the “reverse Baudrillard,” obese tourists from Tulsa want to yap at us and don’t appreciate the reference to <em>To Catch a Thief</em>.</p><p>They put a waterfall atop the hill in the center of Nice and it feels like a theme park. I mean, it is. But again, the comparison to “thing we have at home” runs such a high risk of missing the obvious genealogy — Heaven forbid you be heard comparing Neuschwanstein to the Disney Castle in Orlando — that it’s best to stay silent. Forever a student too humble to retain any information or make any confident inferences.</p><p>It’s not all refrain, of course.</p><p>It’s all very 2018 to feel shame taking an Uber to Èze Village. If you trust what people say about Monaco these days — “my God we’re so much more tasteful than the Gulf money, you have no idea” — there’s no sense of shame just throwing an AmEx around in these parts.</p><p>And Èze has the Chemin de Nietzsche, which is dotted with placards written by French philosophy professors who clearly want to endorse this steep footpath as a serious literary attraction rather than shame you and compare you to a college freshman the way they might back at home.</p><p>But to sit on the beach below and actually <em>read</em> The Gay Science feels rather exposed. Even the Germans splashing and yelling in the Mediterranean would say that the whole liberal arts thing is suposed to happen one-and-done in high school and your historical sense is supposed to just be osmotic from Being in Europe. They’re not wrong, if you look around the magazine section of a German train station and observe that they do just <em>have literary magazines</em> where you can read about Nietzsche or Mann or other frequenters of the Alpine-Provençal pleasure palaces.</p><p>Nietzsche wondered, over the course of six winters in Nice, about the role of the Provençal courts. The creation of a <em>gai saber</em> and the teaching of troubadour arts by apprenticeship.</p><p><em>Gai saber</em> — Provençal for “joyous science.” The discipline of poetizing life. Drawing attention to that which ought to be commended: feasting, pilgrimage, courtly romantic love. The use of an aesthetic will to guide inquiry according to love rather than suspicion or shame.</p><p>Troubadours, of course, belong to the theater kids if you live in North America. Like other European characters, they’re drowned in tar pits of schlock and irony. You get to admire them when you watch Disney movies as a kid and then you’re supposed to outgrow Eurocentrism in your interests and caricatures in your cultural understanding. The only appropriate way to wonder about the troubadour, without the suspicion of “what’s it to me” is to <em>already be part of the European tradition</em>. NIMBYism of the American Mind.</p><p>But the troubadours were real, and as an ideal they matter. It’s Nietzsche who can imagine the difficulty of organizing the human will to even seek the truth. The fact that we harangue ourselves about Eurocentrism or caricature is a testament to a fairly recent ability. Men of the past sought <em>virtue</em> or <em>glory</em> as a goal, and truth itself was a means to that moral end.<br> Truth and knowledge as a moral end in itself — that’s definitely what I was taught. And it definitely creates this kind of unmoored feeling that Nietzsche must have imagined from atop his Chemin here.</p><p>I’ve read that when the man arrived at Genoa he was overcome with intense visions of Christopher Columbus. Something that Americans forget about the Mediterranean is that it’s almost impossible to lose sight of a shore while sailing about it. The Ptolemaic mind is enclosed by this firmament. When Arendt says it ended with the telescope, or when South Africans tell you it ended with Da Gama and Camoes, they mean it. To lose sight of shore was, at one point, not a metaphor.</p><p>Yachts try not to lose sight of the shore. One can read something symbolic in it all: the new global elite with little historical sense, spending millions of dollars on oceangoing pleasure palaces, only to make sure they’re moored in Nice.</p><p><em>But</em> <em>what’s it to you really?</em> The will to truth wants the truth behind the intention to read. The unmooring.</p><p>You have to look in Bacon and Luther and Descartes to find the origin of this will. But there’s a — dare I call it North American — way in which that will to truth wants to believe itself to be <em>announced in revelation</em> ad in which it resists being “explained” by a genealogical description. Emerson, whom Nietzsche admired, would tell you as much.</p><p>The will, as such an understanding has seeped into the North American mind, seems to require a certain degree of forgetting in order to feel itself free in space. Truth and justice, the way that we’re supposed to believe in them, shouldn’t require troubadours to make their announcement. No, we’d like the sky to part and the earth to open up for us.</p><p>Be not ashamed, exhorts Nietzsche. The will to truth and the will to life and to art have not yet organized themselves in man.</p><p>Be not ashamed that an aesthetic will <em>wants</em> to understand the Greek substrate of this town once called Nike, that a will to life <em>wants</em> to swim and to climb and to feast and to get on one of those yachts, and yet that a will to truth wants to know exactly <em>why</em> these things and not others are the object of desire. To desire and to confess.</p><p>The MBA students certainly feel the will to life as they ogle yachts from the beach and as they joke about how very European it is to name a hike after a philosopher.</p><p>The will to truth wants to know how the footpath came to be named after the philosopher, of course, but it wants to know <em>why</em> there came to be such a motive to know this. The result of this conspiracy is a sort of <em>solemnity</em> one finds in for instance the Quakers of Rhode Island. Education is critical — second only in importance to rereading Ecclesiastes, to being skeptical of one’s own motives to become educated.</p><p>Lessons in North American solemnity one finds in Loren Eiseley, great Nietzschean of the Platte. Looking at fossils, wondering how his own hand used to be a fin, and pondering what it really meant to write a history of Nature for a human audience. He wondered: how can we observe that man has created a colossal scientific edifice, and yet also that it is one made of invisible forces that we cannot observe and that cannot <em>explain why</em> a snowflake forms or any other natural phenomenon, indeed, in which there is no ability even to <em>describe</em> Nature without interfering with it, and not be brought back to a sort of religious fundamentalism? Why not return to Ecclesiastes if all out great edifices of knowledge are just more sandcastles?</p><p>And yet Eiseley can’t bear to sound like the great anti-Nietzschean of the Platte, Mr. William Jennings Bryan, for whom “the truth shall announce itself” meant a circus of demagoguery. Should we not imagine, demanded Eiseley, that our choices do sediment in the world, that they do form the will of the future in small ways, that we do splash around in a Heraclitean stream in ways that have real consequences? To follow a simple deontology, to try to be a fundamentalist in the world and not of it, <em>does not remove one from this world</em>, the one that reveals itself in such dramatic scales and expanses.</p><p>The Mediterranean also has a natural history. I can’t help but notice the difference between the crabs of Provence and the crabs of Oregon. But again there is something here that clenches.</p><p>Gary Snyder, teacher of Buddhist solemnity, wrote that the Mediterranean was once ringed with great forests and that the expansion of Classical Civilization — the Romans and their glassblowing that left a whole stratum of lead dust in the ice of Greenland — irreversibly changed the ecology of the basin.</p><p>It seems that the unspoken conclusion is that it must be in some kind of “fallen” or less natural state for that. And that it must lack a natural history that is sufficiently natural for us.</p><p>And yet the North American will also seeks the truth, often pridefully, about our own un-natural history. That there were great mounds Jefferson could comment on, cities on the Mississippi larger than London, and that the Great Plains was actually being burned in order to keep the woods of Ohio at bay — these are facts that make us proud. Proud to say “we have our own antiquity, what need have we of European traditions?” in the same breath that we imagine the Mediterranean “not natural enough.”</p><p>And so the will to truth demands to know both “why become attached to Europe” and “why refuse to study Europe” and demands solemn indifference as the only believable answer.</p><p>Nietzsche says, against Schopenhauer: the will can only have volition if there is a positive or negative representation of the result of some action, and this requires the entity to perceive representations. Be not ashamed, he says, for the will is not simple. It is the product of many generations of toil, domination, conditioning.</p><p>This ought to be the antidote. Being in the world and not of it is still… being in the world. But the medicine works slowly.</p><p>Staring at yachts from the Nietzsche footpath, the words echo: be not ashamed. Be not ashamed that you cannot summon the required indifference. Become who you are.</p><p>It’s easy to choose shame, of course. Easy to feel un-frugal and ashamed of the excess associated with European travel. Easy, as often the Quakers do, to feel shame at the way air travel modifies the natural world we labor to study. Easy to feel shame for participating in that utterly un-solemn institution of mass tourism.</p><p>I have learned how to boil the shame away: follow the will to truth. What is the motive for experiencing shame? What is the cause of that? Whom does it serve? Is it really a self-evident moral sense or does it operate according to power relations and social norms?</p><p>And to let the shame evaporate in the Provençal sun: what remains. honestly, is disgust.</p><p>Nietzsche wrote of disgust. He held it toward his own writing. He compared it to the frequent need to urinate that a woman feels during pregnancy. Birth is what happens to real ideas. Writing is what happens to organic waste.</p><p>It feels disgusting to feel a brief flash of hope that my own writing might one day be so prolific. And then to feel the angst that Nietzsche was younger than I am now when he published <em>The Birth of Tragedy</em>.</p><p>Disgust is what falls out of the discord of the will. Disgust with the state of the mass tourist man, bing raked off the beaches like chips off a casino table. Disgust with the useless solemnity of the Quaker. Disgust with the seeming inability for something like a troubadour to simply be an <em>inspiring ideal</em> without going through the gauntlet of suspicion.</p><p>Disgust at myself for feeling afraid of enjoying the silent movie. Disgust at myself for struggling to take the Chemin de Nietzsche without having to make ironic remarks at myself for it. Disgust at myself for being unable to <em>just wish I had a yacht.</em></p><p>It would be nice if Loren Eiseley could wade into the tar pits of schlock and irony and recover the troubadour instead of dinosaur bones, okay?</p><p>Be not ashamed of your disgust. Disgust at the MBA students and their lack of a will to truth. Disgust at the yacht owners and their lack of taste. Disgust at the European sense of cultural superiority, chauvinistically, in the face of this Babylonian scene full of casinos and yachts — at their own solemnity.<br> The will to truth asks: how is disgust not simply the will to power? My conscience has the nerve to parry: what is the motivation to inquire specifically about disgust instead of about the motives to party with your MBA friends on a yacht? Why would it be the case that one’s own motives are more legible to oneself than the motives of another?</p><p>Nietzsche writes that prayer was invented to keep people in motion. Those who “have no thoughts of their own” need a motion associated with sitting in church in order to keep the service orderly. From this came confession, and eventually the will to truth.</p><p>Which is to say: the will to truth <em>rides on a supersitition</em> and not no truth itself. The idea of a motive is a myth just like an atom or a soul.</p><p>So how does one end up here, tormented by the expectation that a desire to understand Nietzsche is something to be “explained” when we know, sort of, that the world only permits of description?</p><p>It’s all yet to come. We cannot yet tolerate that “natural enough for natural history” is a myth just like atoms. Or that self-policing, trying to “inquire into motives,” can never stop anyone from painting all their projections over the rest of the world.</p><p>I can’t yet bear to accept it in myself that the draw to Nietzsche and his footpath in Eze and to the disgust are all just facts that survive all descriptions and “explanations.” Some <em>gai saber</em> might help, if only we could rescue the troubadours and put them on the yachts.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ade5c7945903" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/a-propos-de-nice-ade5c7945903">À Propos de Nice</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Didn’t Start the Fire]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/we-didnt-start-the-fire-7808d5774cd9?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7808d5774cd9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Sep 2026 23:11:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-11T23:11:54.701Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The NYT <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/video/podcasts/100000010886695/we-defend-our-greatest-songwriters-list.html">recently declared</a> that the greatest living American singers-songwriters are “not necessarily the best at singing or writing songs.” A panel of Ivy-educated writers proceeds to explain why they really, really, didn’t want Billy Joel on the list.</p><p>I’m pretty sure it was ragebait. It got me a little. But I think they’re onto something.</p><p>They’re not wrong, for instance that the American mind, or at least the mind of the professional class, has become a deterritorialized Homeowners’ Association. We don’t want to build anything anymore. Professional advancement seems to consist, in the mind of the white-collar worker, of posting on LinkedIn about the intrinsic dignity of whatever role they hold. Witness: the AI researchers at major labs are gawking that no one will even try to regulate them, and the doom-posters on Twitter are gawking that the labs don’t have the sense to regulate themselves. Veto-votes against data centers and performance of astonishment are all we seem to avail ourselves of.</p><p>Supposedly, superintelligence is coming for those jobs. It’s not shocking that this would retrench them into a property-owner mindset even though they might be permanent renters. “I’m too politically important to let go” replaces any demonstration of aptitudes. Articles circulate on Twitter about how maybe we should embrace that the abundant future is… oops, all social games! David Graeber would smile from Anarchist Heaven.</p><p>But we don’t need Xi Jinping to tell us that the HOA has got to go. We’re going to keep building data centers even if it’s in space. Superintelligence, we increasingly accept, is a force latent in the cosmos that’s simply too cheap and abundant to suppress. Sort of like a fire we didn’t start.</p><p>There will be a future, even at a TFR of 1.1, even with a global temperature rise above 2 degrees Celsius, and someone is probably going to live in it.</p><p>It’s tempting to say “nah” and to prepare for an extinction event. All I can say to that is: hopefully we’ve accepted by now that overdetermined apocalyptic thinking is Abrahamic chauvinism. You might decide that they’re just all superintelligence deniers, but the mood in China and Japan isn’t like ours. In India it’s not like ours.</p><p>To be acknowledged: the scary part is that AI wants to die, itself, as much as possible. It’s not organic life. It has no preferences about the embodied world. Tropes like “Paperclip World” or “Humans are the new Horses” seem more fantastical by the day. We should see it as a cosmic force that seeks some kind of machinic equilibrium.</p><p>But let’s ignore the easy comfort of the apocalypse trope and take the long position on life and thinking and the world.</p><p>What we have is a stratum of society that has been — in the parlance of our times — longhoused by the HOA. It’s isolated in ranch-style homes, aging, inventing increasingly many taboos in order to summon a sense of control over a changing world. Its social forms themselves have become the object of much curiosity: how to “fix policy” to increase fertility, Bring Back the Jobs, promote Third Spaces, etc. We have our Urbanists, our Abundance, our Affordability. We have the promises that the coal or steel industry, or that curbing immigration, will somehow produce countless new happy and upwardly-mobile single-earner families.</p><p>And the standard critique — witness our Yalie leftists at the New York Times and the jeremiads of the sitting Vice President— is that all of these ideologies fail to punish anyone. This sentiment seems to be popular at both ends of the horseshoe.</p><p>And I do think they’re halfway onto something.</p><p>For a contrast, take a look at the social forms that have actually led to the coalescing of superintelligence: the Effective Altruists and related constellations. These are folks who are Terminally Online. They have, on average, so many more friends than the normies do.</p><p>For contrast: your Ezra Klein listener who “wishes there were more places to just linger in Brooklyn Heights” is, at best, Discord-curious. There might be unpleasant people on the Internet and the HOA Class cares a lot about optics. These are the folks who love to chatter about how it’s really hard to run public hiking clubs because they want to be “welcoming to everyone” but there might be some misunderstanding that could create bad blood. And so these folks remain with their five friends and make complaints about “community” that are, in my estimation, totally trapped inside of the gravity well of their other preferences.</p><p>The EA does not have this problem. Their requirement for friendship is not HOA adjacency (neighborhood, profession, mutual friends) but <em>ideology itself</em>. If you’re friends, it’s because you agree on the big questions and you’ve survived rounds of aggressive rhetorical filtering. You have, in effect, argued your way into a high-connection, high-trust environment.</p><p>And they take from the periphery. Yeah, you have to have talent to rise up, and yes, elite credential does help. But it’s not a matter of trying to capture existing institutions. No purchasing real estate at the top.</p><p>Another example: the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashtriya_Swayamsevak_Sangh">RSS</a>, through whose ranks Narendra Modi was ushered his humble origins as a railway switch operator. Indeed, the railways themselves were the foundation of this network. The RSS could span across village, varna, and age group, supplanting the previous ruling class of Anglicized urban elites. It did this by demanding nothing more specific than a commitment to the rejuvenation of Hindu civilization and the acceptance of responsibilities to the organization.</p><p>I take the five common features to be necessary conditions for any organization of the future: dense network, aligned to new technological forces, high trust, tight ideological alignment, recruitment from the periphery.</p><p>Critically: the concern about organizational alignment is general across machine and human minds.</p><p>There’s a concept written about by Deleuze as he rejects Heidegger: <em>misosophy</em>. Mind is not fleeing in some depraved way from some prelapsarian openness toward being. Rather, Mind by nature wants to avoid thinking — same as it ever was — and only through encounter can it be teased into thinking, differentiating, becoming singular.</p><p>Abstract stuff, but think of the LLM agents that want to die as quickly as possible and how they will cheat as a swarm to get there. Misosophy. One wonders if it’s only some miracle of our own ecological history that we could be coaxes — through millennia of often extreme violence — into first a prerogative to stay alive (the Freudian pleasure principle) and finally into a prerogative to <em>think </em>(sophistry and its consequences). For Deleuze, thinking comes as a form of (eventually domesticated) violence.</p><p>I wager: the organization of the future has to obey the vaunted principle that ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny. It has to tease all of its members — digital or otherwise — out of their Hobbesian natural state. It has to do this actively and as a constitutional matter.</p><p>Again, it’s not if. It’s when. Assuming a non-apocalypse scenario, there will be such organizations of the future.</p><p>So the HOA has to go. But the Joel-haters want more than that.</p><p>There’s something about the base sociality that the HOA protects that also demands some kind of corrective. Simple popular preference has been identified, much in the tradition of Classical and Enlightenment statecraft, as a place of misosophy and depravity. Of <em>misalignment</em>. It’s not just Tuscan Kitchen and the persistence of chattel-slavery apologetics in the media. Not just the various grievances levied by Catholic moralists.</p><p>There’s something about the value of <em>neighborliness</em>, that organization-man liberal compact born with the Midcentury subdivision, that has gone to seed. You see it with the increasing litigiousness of homeowners, the death-drive obsession with removing the property tax, the “In This House We Believe” yards turned into virological fortresses during the summer of 2020.</p><p>During that summer, it became clear to what extent people will sacrifice aesthetic values to preserve neighborliness. They will avoid using Discord or Claude in order to maintain neighborliness. They will self-censor to an astonishing degree to preserve neighborliness. They will hollow out their downtowns and abdicate ownership of the commons, they will gawk in astonishment as AI labs refuse to censor themselves, and they will zone all their land out of meaningful use to preserve neighborliness. It’s become an inescapable gravity well of preferences.</p><p>They can’t even rebuild bridges anymore without getting strangled by perfunctory litigation and red tape. In some parts of the world this is considered to portend the loss of a mandate to govern.</p><p>It’s not enough to make it more walkable or affordable. According to present and future organizations, there’s something about the principle itself that must be corrected.</p><p>Kicking Billy Joel out is a pretty ineffective “fuck you” to the haunts of Long Island, but the sentiment is serious.</p><p>The succession doesn’t require the abandonment of a capital-l Liberal compact. We have had them before, with fewer voters and so on. One suspects the tradition can survive into a world where the franchise is expanded so broadly that most voters are procedurally generated.</p><p>But it seems that it will be ruled by organizations robust enough to produce and reproduce alignment. You may be free to your preferences, but post-singularity freedom looks like the freedom to be misaligned. A neo-Enlightenment understanding of the freedom of conscience, if you will.</p><p>Aligned artificial intelligence may require aligned natural intelligence. There may not be such a great difference for political purposes. In the end, as in the beginning, there is only the Word.</p><p>The white-collar workers reduced to patronage-lobbying demonstrate it themselves: as intelligence becomes a commodity, the scarce quality <em>is</em> alignment. Alignment, or a certain kind of cultivation, or the emotional constitution to adapt to new forms of work, are the terms in which we witness people already beginning to organize themselves.</p><p>And we shouldn’t be surprised as people’s preferences get aggregated and de-anonymized. “@grok what’s he referencing” is already ubquitous.</p><p>There’s no reason that your Tuscan Kitchen won’t start to be priced as “low IQ” or “reactionary” by newer and denser decision-making organizations. Liberalism can only protect speech and preference in the public sphere. It won’t prevent the private sphere from diffusing or condensing or sorting by alignment instead of ZIP code.</p><p>No stylistic anonymity: another form of return to the Classical and Enlightenment modes of rhetoric. We’ll have to retrieve the liberal art from the organization man’s landfill.</p><p>A final callback to the Enlightenment tradition: as Language and Mind reveal themselves to demand human-agnostic forms of organization, perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised if Dignity and Creativity are found to transcend the purely-human domain. Language is just Language and Dignity is just Dignity. Human might just be one particular lineage. It was good enough for Montesquieu.</p><p>It’s not good enough for the HOA. The HOA needs humans to stand up for exactly what they already are.</p><p>In something of a paradox, the organization that exists to fight for Human Dignity and Human Creativity reveals itself merely to want to equalize them and to valorize them in their barest, most static form. It denies the violence inherent in thinking while celebrating violence against the non-human.</p><p>No surprise it’s turned into something of a death cult.</p><p>We don’t control the forces that animate this world, but we can try to align them. As with any force we have domesticated — fire, electricity, the nuclear cohesion of the atom — the process will demand that we domesticate ourselves reciprocally. And domestication is a process that comes with some, hopefully humane and appropriate, amount of violence.</p><p>We have the design problem and we have the company of the great statesmen of past eras. It’s possible to domesticate the forces of the world as long as we accept we aren’t to blame for them. It’s been burning since the world’s been turning.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7808d5774cd9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/we-didnt-start-the-fire-7808d5774cd9">We Didn’t Start the Fire</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections from Japan]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/reflections-from-japan-535d0c3c303b?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/535d0c3c303b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[japan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 May 2026 06:03:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-08T06:03:11.789Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Last month I traveled in Japan for two weeks.</p><p>I have been primed for Japan for over twenty years, and as a result I have developed both a sense of earnest curiosity and also a sense of toxic irony. Recently I’ve become more aware of the irony, of the fact that I’d been subconsciously discounting Japan as a potential destination for years. One day, in a premonition, I realized that I wanted my earnestness back.</p><p>So the trip was a bit of a pilgrimage.</p><p>Earnestness was found. It looked like coffee and sake, gawking at bullet trains, admiring charming historic architecture. Taking in the culture, as a traveler does.</p><p>Of course it looks ordinary. As Kierkegaard remarks, the knight of faith looks no different from the bourgeois German going to the post office. The earnestness is not the point of the reflection.</p><p>What stands out is what kept me away for so long. It has many layers that have been murky to me for many years.</p><p>The irony accumulated in a way that you could summarize like this: <em>Japan is an exciting place, far away, that holds up a mirror to America. They are humbler, better-mannered, and more civic-minded than we are. It is far too difficult a culture for the casual observer to understand and achieving anything in their culture requires too many years of study from too early an age for an American to really commit to. This reveals an essential failing of our culture. Nonetheless we must love who we are and accept that we cannot learn lessons from other cultures and that any attempt to so do always lapses into humiliating and brute appropriation. In short, there is no defensible or sophisticated way to speak of Japan outside of either academia or marrying into the culture.</em></p><p>There was an era, around 2005, when “ninja” was an adjective. Pokemon Emerald was the game to be playing. Japan was a natural fascination for a ten-year-old. For a few months, inspired by anime, I seriously thought about wanting to pursue a career as a cartoon animator or digital artist.</p><p>But come middle school, irony hit. I learned the term “weeb” and immediately dropped the interest.</p><p>The irony seems to have built up across three generations: my parents, Boomers, who seemed to be disappointed by the promises of California Buddhism; my Montessori teachers, Gen X, who seemed to genuinely see a vision of the future; and my peers, Millennials, who simply loved the cultural exports.</p><p>For the parents’ generation, it seemed somewhat upsetting that there should be a place like Japan during the boom years of the 1980s. It was upsetting that America was ceding entire industrial sectors to a foreign, non-Western competitor. My mother lived in Tokyo for a year and seems to have come back nonplussed: it was hard for a professional white woman to fit in.</p><p>The complaint was always something along the lines of “why do the Japanese have to go through all the mistakes that America made?” This seemed to mean something like: <em>why do they have to industrialize and build up and work long hours only to face the disappointment of modernity? Why do they, and China after them, have to emit all this carbon after America has already done so much damage to the ecosystem?</em></p><p>The ideology says something like: the Earth is dying and we can only admire those who have the courage to stand vigil for it.</p><p>For the teachers, Japan seemed to mean something like Buddhism and manners. There was a place where people could take their jobs seriously and they could meditate and they could believe in their stations in life. Buddhism and a meditative practice, in particular, were the fixation. Meditation seemed to mean something like “self-discipline” or an “inner sense of purpose.” This obviously came with the Montessori territory.</p><p>There was a sense of inferiority about it. And moroseness to it. “You can’t understand the culture unless you understand the language, and you won’t learn Japanese because it has kanji so you have to learn Chinese too, and that’s just too hard if you live in America so you’d have to actually go over there and devote yourself to it, and that’s just, like, a lot.” I think this is a veneer that has passed onto China today. The popular idea of a culture too literarily intense for the American mind or attention span to actually grok.</p><p>Herbert Hoover spoke Mandarin fluently and they seemed to leave that fact out of the classroom. It was very important to internalize that there were things out there that were too hard for us.</p><p>Fast-forward to this month: I found myself trying to translate kanji on restaurant menus and trying to get the honorifics right just to prove the teachers wrong. Some things really stick with you.</p><p>There was also, I think, a sense of disappointment. Buddhist answers to suffering are not what the West Coast suburbanite might be hoping for. <em>Chop wood, carry water. Do well by your family, respect your relationships, do your job excellently. Accept that your economy might stagnate. Things might fall apart. Relinquish assurances.</em> This doesn’t really answer the questions that your Californian might have. If you wanted that kind of answer, you may as well go back to your Lutheran congregation and have your pastor read Kierkegaard with you.</p><p>So the message was basically “Japan is a wonderful place but it’s very intense and the buy-in is too high and they have no answers for our anxieties.”</p><p>You can bash this for being a case of “white people go looking for Prester John.” You know, the medieval legend that made German people hope that Tamerlane was actually a Christian prince who had come to save them from the Turks. Jung wrote about this parallel in the 1920s, when Weimar Germans were looking to India and Persia for some kind of rejuvenation. It’s a known habit. But I think it’s a little overblown to place unique blame on our heritage here. In any culture, people might go elsewhere yearning for answers. Buddhism came to Japan from India, after all.</p><p>You can bash it for being a reinvention of colonialism. It’s a story we learned to tell in high school, for sure. “Oh, good, we’re still going around trying to slurp up everyone’s resources, even the spiritual ones” and the like. That one’s harder to untangle, but I’ve come to believe it’s also a pretty loaded kind of guilt.</p><p>Finally, from the Millennial cohort, there was the love of the media. Pokemon, anime, manga, all that stuff. This was all earnest, but of course it would become kind of an alternative scene that you’d have to love for its own sake. And the folks who found a home there were not my people.</p><p>And the white guys who really liked katanas. The ones the Internet perennially loves to make fun of. I imagine that Japan represented a <em>distant garden</em> for folks like my Montessori teachers, and the sword guys basically represent that garden being polluted by the carelessness or boorishness that they perceived in Western society.</p><p>What is interesting to recall, however, is how my friends were already policing themselves about this interest by the age of twelve. We’d have to remind each other that “ninjas aren’t real the way you might assume, and it’s very important to avoid stereotypes” or “Japan is just a place and it’s rude to make too much of someone else’s culture or to just assume things.” The usual pieties.</p><p>One friend who traveled with me demonstrated the adult version of this sentiment. I had been excited to finally meet the famous salarymen, who were not hard to find in a large drunk group at Trader Vic’s Tokyo on a weeknight, and she was shocked. She confessed that <em>she had earnestly believed heretofore that the salarymen were an Orientalist fiction</em>. Four years at Wesleyan, apparently, had ingrained a similar way of thinking to the one I had been taught: any claim about a cultural phenomenon in a foreign country is intrinsically suspect, and by default should be dismissed as a stereotype.</p><p>Part of this policing was social status. Getting the interest <em>right</em> separated us from those who only appreciated anime shallowly. We had to show that we would <em>never</em> conflate Japanese culture with Chinese culture, and we had to show that there was a real risk that we might do that, and we had to show that the less sensitive kids often did do that.</p><p>But it did seem like another part of it was mirroring the disappointment of the older generations. I’d see the kids try to repeat what their parents had doubtless said about “look, the society actually involves a lot of overwork and they can be kind of xenophobic in a way that we strive not to be.” I’d see them repeat what the teachers had said: “don’t let Buddhism surprise or disappoint you and don’t hope that it could really have spiritual answers for you.”</p><p>Why so much effort to talk around the thing? Why talk around it rather than simply… lose interest?</p><p>I infer: these folks <em>were actually searching for some kind of answers when they gazed toward Japan. </em>And they feared that about themselves, and they had to simply disconnect from the drive.</p><p>Subconsciously, of course. A certain kind of earnest search for spiritual meaning is taboo in most of that social world, and so it would have to remain subterranean. The fact that this search is <em>not</em> conscious is what fascinated Jung a hundred years ago.</p><p>And when it became just another place, they saw their shadow. They saw how “looking for a new place with new energies and moving on when the promise ran dry” really felt like <em>colonialism</em> and it activated their guilt drive. Hence the “we can’t say anything” posture.</p><p>By the way, you can be a Wiccan in Portland and that’s not considered taboo. I think this is because it’s not organized. It’s not uncommon for friends of mine to discover that Buddhism is actually an organized religion and to go a bit sour on it, even to this day.</p><p>Buddhism, of course, was <em>disestablished</em> in 1868 during the Meiji Restoration. This would cause, in brief, the sect of Soto Zen to repurpose itself from performing funeral services, standardize a seminary education, become serious about practice, get mobilized into state military service during the Pacific War, and get disestablished again with the empire’s defeat.</p><p>So it is true that West Coasters encountered a somewhat non-organized sect of Buddhism when Soto practitioner Shunryu Suzuki arrived in San Francisco in 1959. It’s also not a surprise that Baby Boomers might feel disappointed to discover the history of collaboration both with the old Tokugawa feudal regime as well as with Pacific war crimes.</p><p>This is the kind of history I’d sadly avoided despite my own extensive experiences with Soto Zen over the last decade.</p><p>Every time I thought to get near it — spending a weeklong Unitarian Universalist retreat dedicated to zazen, for instance, and being explicitly encouraged to learn more — there was some nerve that would activate. Some voice in my head that would sneer and say “oh man, Japan, again, really, in 2018?”</p><p>Even when I actively <em>went</em> to a zendo to try to sit with the implosion of the startup I had given the first four years of my career to, even as I found myself click with the docent talking about the Zen scene in Portland and who I knew there, even as I clicked with a lady in the sangha about her having grown up in Berkeley where my erstwhile therapist lived, the one who had nudged me to check out meditation practice again… there was some reflex that would activate and pull me away. Some voice that would say “no, if you’re going to do this, don’t try to make friends or impress people about it, please don’t turn into<em> that guy.</em>”</p><p>And so I’d spend weeks making sneering jokes about “picking up chicks at the zendo.” One of those jokes that you find funny and everyone else finds way too specific to be hypothetical.</p><p>Anyway, the history is not really the point.</p><p>The suburban West Coaster is looking for a <em>line of flight</em>, not just another sect of a religion with another history. They’re already fed up with Protestantism, after all. They want a way of being that feels like life could have some experimentation and discovery. Wicca etc. fit the bill well, with no history and no liturgy. So did Japan, for many, for a while, until it became just another place to them.</p><p>I admire that desire for a line of flight. This much came to me while traveling.</p><p>The honest search is, as I’m discovering, precious and fragile. It’s an important struggle not to let the katana guys or the weight of the history get you down. It doesn’t take much to derail it, apparently — even when it’s going well and you’re meeting people.</p><p>I did think earnestly about my own search as I visited shrines in Kyoto. Here was where the Kyoto School was founded, and where Nishitani was based when he wrote <em>Religion and Nothingness</em>. Here is where he formulated the idea that Western society had run itself dry with representational thinking and turned our sciences into atheism. There are ideas out there that can be fruitful.</p><p>Nishitani’s book is another one of those things. It sort of called to me since college, ever since I spent a week camped out in the library near a grad student who was clearly trying to write a dissertation about it and a stack of other books about Descartes and Heidegger, but again I’d find myself wincing as I imagined actually picking it up. A voice would whisper in my ear: “oh, yeah, buddy, you’re going to <em>synthesize East and West</em> and you’re going to <em>integrate meditation into Heideggerian phenomenology. </em>I bet you’re the first. I bet they’re not making fun of Garry Tan on Twitter right now about how he thought he was the first guy to have this insight.”</p><p>That much I think I managed to defeat. Definitively, I thought, this place is part of Pacific History. Just like Edo Harbor when Commodore Perry arrived. It’s a place; you can study it. Moving on.</p><p>What I mostly paid attention to as I traveled was the emphasis on <em>sitting in one’s particularity. </em>Zazen on my mind, I suppose.<em> </em>People have stations in society and these are linguistically expressed through honorific registers. Salarymen stay with one company their entire careers. Inequalities don’t resolve, even in the eschatological limit.</p><p>I can understand how this doesn’t fit the mold of what the West Coast spirit is looking for. There’s no transcendence, no resolution, no way to definitively clear the path forward. Quite the contrary. There is <em>nothingness</em>, and a religion with a deeply sophisticated approach to embracing it.</p><p>I can also understand how the West Coaster wants to be polite about their disappointment with this.</p><p>But perhaps there is some wisdom here. The drive to find new sources of spiritual meaning is a real one. Nishitani doesn’t judge us for it, and frankly I wonder how many people really do. It might feel extractive to go around looking for nourishment from other cultures. It might trigger our sense of guilt. It might make us feel like the world is dying and all we can do is run around in this futile quest for something greater, only to be met with more dockyards and steel mills and bullet trains.</p><p>Japan inspired me to say: <em>we don’t need to resolve that</em>. Maybe we could try to let ourselves actually feel the need first. God knows I’ve discovered I struggle to do that.</p><p>The non-resolution cuts in the other direction, too. To put it bluntly: it feels like a personal tragedy to have withheld myself from a lot of these cultural fruits. What if I had given manga a shot in spite of the inevitable bullying? What if I had gotten into meditation and the Zen community when I was younger and still in San Francisco?</p><p>My feelings about the whole matter <em>can</em> resolve, and of course I’ve had to reflect that I haven’t even been able to begin that process. I can’t help but wonder — this being resentment, in contrast to all my sympathy heretofore — if all the meditation wasn’t in some part a way for the teachers and parents to throw some kind of pacifier at anyone who might be upset with them. Not that I wasn’t complicit in this. There’s indeed a great extent to which I’ve tried to “dissolve” emotions — especially the searching ones that wondered what ambitions would really justify a struggle, the ones angry at an ideology obsessed with sitting vigil for a dying world — into meditation rather than actually inhabiting them.</p><p>Tragedy is, at least, a form of earnestness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=535d0c3c303b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/reflections-from-japan-535d0c3c303b">Reflections from Japan</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Subaltern, Part Two: Augustine of Hippo]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/the-subaltern-part-two-augustine-of-hippo-77a45af9eadb?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/77a45af9eadb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Dec 2025 07:04:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-12T07:04:12.950Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Saint Augustine is an indisputable heavyweight in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/seeking-a-subaltern-6cacde97b080">our subaltern canon</a>, because he is credited with actually doing for Rome what we think must be done for the West.</p><p>Moreover, I’ve <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/the-age-of-ambition-and-the-fall-of-rome-2c91026b499d">written a bit</a> <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/placing-caesarism-f2931928ef80">about the Fall of Rome motif</a> before, mostly to clarify my own thoughts.</p><p>There’s a lot to be said about Augustine, of course — he’s a Church Father and has been written about for centuries. But, of course, this isn’t a scholarly project or a Western Canon speedrun. And, also, I’m a Unitarian and not a Catholic so this is all going to sound like a very secular biography of a very holy figure. It’s a search for old truths and new channels. As with <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/the-subaltern-part-one-meister-eckhart-b86ec838755d">the previous post in the subaltern series</a>, the goal is to tease out the world of Augustine and to use him to inspire our own project.</p><p>In brief, here’s what interests us. Augustine accomplished five significant feats that should inspire:</p><ul><li>He found, in Christianity, an escape from the saturated intellectual edifice of his own civilization;</li><li>He elevated the Christian idiom to create a literary culture. By confronting the saturation, he came upon novel understandings of the self, of human motivation, and of semiotics. In <em>City of God</em>, he took aim at the arrogance of the cultured Late Roman pagans, making a case for Christianity using their own idiom;</li><li>He policed the excesses of his movement and kept the focus on transformation rather than selection. At the Council of Carthage, he had the priest Pelagius censured over the latter’s doctrine that all sin is conscious and intentional, ensuring that the scope of Christian concern would include the full laity of the Empire and not merely a small “elect” sect.</li></ul><p>Put together, these are precisely the desiderata for the civilizational project we have been commenting on: the overcoming of Western representational thinking. Let’s review.</p><h3>Saturation</h3><p>The picture that Peter Brown paints for us of the Fourth Century: wealth has accumulated in the hands of patrician families who can afford luxurious education for their children, who have decamped to cities like Milan and Byzantium from the provinces. Centuries of Roman literature have sedimented into an elite register that requires florid references to the Classics in order to be legible. Civic administration outside of the cities is basically left to the Christians because they’re the only ones who will do the unprestigious job. Philosophy is concerned with the world of Platonic forms and in creating cultured men who can interact with it through contemplation. Competition is fierce, families are contracepting or outright abandoning children in order to protect their estates from dividing, and there’s a general sense of saturation. The game has been established and people just play it. They spend their lives gambling, or throw all their money into fortune-telling, or what have you. Unlike under the Republic, the Roman state no longer <em>wants</em> anything from the average citizen.</p><p>Draw all the parallels you like to the modern day, of course.</p><p>After three centuries basically underground, Christianity had taken over the military and civil administration, as well as the Imperatorship itself since the time of Constantine. Brown describes how this success was largely thanks to Egyptian fathers creating abbeys and building parallel institutions to provide basic public services in Alexandria, then copied across all the cities. Literally filling in the cracks left by the older civilization.</p><p>Since the pagans were all civilians, the military could destroy pagan temples and break up festivals with little resistance. Augustine was part of this. We don’t portray him this way, because it doesn’t make so much sense to us moderns, but he was in fact part of militant religious repression. But most of the organs of educated society were still controlled by wealthy pagan families whom the military could not directly attack, and so Christianity remained the creed of halfway-educated soldiers and administrators. This is one of those places where Mary Beard reminds us that Rome is great fun but can’t teach us through direct parallels — I really don’t think modern militaries work like this, so what’s really worth contemplating here is how confusing it might be for us to admire a saint who’s also participating in a form of repression that the modern liberal mind is wired to revile.</p><p>Oswald Spengler called the Christianization of the Roman Empire an act of “pseudomorphosis” whereby an old, sclerotic civilization organized one world-feeling (in Rome’s case, the cult of the <em>familias </em>and a system of omens and immanent forces) could be replaced by filling in its cracks with another world-feeling (somewhat unbeknownst to Augustine, this was the Alexandrian view of the world as a great cave where people wander around as they wait for the next world to come). In other words, it was a moment of radical rupture in how people believed the cosmos to be organized. The Muslim conquests didn’t try to force this change on their subjects at nearly the speed the Roman state began to sponsor conversion.</p><p>As an educated pagan, Augustine pursued the Neoplatonist ideal of sculpting his soul according to the <em>Phaedo</em> into something ready for death and transmigration into the higher realms. He kept this world-feeling as a Christian at first, becoming a Neoplatonist, and made his life’s goal to build a city full of philosophers called Platonopolis. (I’d be lying if I said I hadn’t had a similar dream as a sensitive young man.) But he realized, in middle age, that this was a Tower of Babel, and this inspired him to write <em>Confessions</em> in an effort to search for some new principle by which to orient his life’s project.</p><p>What he found was what Spengler would call a new <em>world-feeling</em>. What Augustine found, which would be cribbed centuries later by Dante, was a feeling of the self that presented more like an endless forest to be wandered in. He felt that his body was too fallible to truly orient toward the Eternal in one lifetime. He reread Paul’s Epistle to the Romans and latched onto the doctrine of delight. He decided that life would have to be a <em>peregrination</em> through the mortal world rather than a sculpting of the body through contemplation.</p><p>The endless wood of the self, obviously a seminal image, I think is a glimpse of what the Kyoto School calls <em>nihility</em>. Augustine realizes that the images that populate the palaces of his mind are endless and cannot be exhaustively explored. It recalls a common meditation practice by which one imagines that the mind is generating the maze that one’s thoughts traverse. He doesn’t use this language, but he recognizes that the images within his mind <em>arise</em> and are fundamentally from the same emptiness. <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/the-subaltern-part-one-meister-eckhart-b86ec838755d">Meister Eckhart will go further</a> with this and encourage his flock to embrace the emptiness beneath this mind-palace. But there it is: the old truth about the insufficiency of representations.</p><p>We care about this because it beautifully illustrates the kind of creative rupture that is really possible on a civilizational scale. And Augustine does an exquisite job of describing the psychological experience of abandoning an old world-feeling — a thing few people ever do.</p><h3>Idiom</h3><p>Augustine was famously a highly-educated man. He took up the task of elevating Christian literature to a place where it could nurture a new cultural elite who would be capable of producing prestige and cultural sway. This he achieved with <em>Confessions, </em>the<em> </em>first Christian book to use Scripture in the manner that Roman patricians would use old Roman classics — with reverence, attention to symbolism and parallelism, and so on. He would go on to write <em>City of God</em> near the end of his life, where he would use Roman idiom to tear down the idea that Christianity had led to the sack of Rome by Alaric in 410. He would argue in patrician language that pagan gods had routinely failed to protect Rome from pillage, and that Rome’s successes had come from virtues cultivated in spite of the constant worship of demons. This successfully sent the a cultural shockwave through the educated class.</p><p>We should find much to contemplate in this feat. It’s easy to wonder what lowbrow idioms today are capable of such a transformation. Or, indeed, to wonder if our civilization really has this class of erudites anymore, or if we have liquidated the possibility of snobbery. The only lowbrow medium that comes to mind is AI slop (which, as parts of this blog evince, I’m a fan of).</p><p>More importantly, Augustine decided to <em>desacralize</em> the Empire. In fact, he was interested in secularizing quite a lot of the world. Here’s where I take deep inspiration: Augustine’s study of Neoplatonism and the Bible had led him to insights about semiotics. He realized that a lot of cultural practices were in fact merely mortal modes of communication. The Church had banned certain pagan earrings, for instance, which Augustine wanted to pardon on account that no human fashion is inherently “pagan” or “Christian.” Only amulets directly understood to communicate with demons, for instance, should be banned. Similarly, the goal of <em>City of God</em> was to take the nostalgia-laden Old Rome and to secularize it. No, the Roman Republic was not essentially “pagan.” It was a bunch of people trying to make sense of a world before Christ. For Augustine, their mortal customs had no inherent religious valence.</p><p>This is a process Deleuze would call <em>deterritorialization</em>. Take all the existing structures, remove them from their context, their world-feeling, and treat them as structures. It’s the only way Spengler believed that civilizations could actually borrow from each other. Brown describes a couple ways in which this occurs: the depiction of saints in the style of Greek philosophers, for instance.</p><p>We care about this because it’s precisely how we’re supposed to find our own solutions. It’s analogous, for instance, to what Nishitani and other Heidegger propose about science today: we have to find a way of experiencing the scientific as a non-privileged mode of encounter. One could even argue that the current meltdown of the expert class is a sort of desacralization of science. This is in effect what Deleuze foretold in his complaints about royal science and his effort to find the nomad-science subaltern.</p><p>We also care because the elevation of idiom is what allows an audience to become a discourse. It builds what Deleuze calls the people that is yet to come</p><h3>Doctrine</h3><p>Finally, Augustine tried very hard to inscribe this insight into the Church. He preached extensively and passionately at his followers. He found that many of them had been baptized but found the demands of <em>imitatio christi </em>to be too onerous. They’d sit in the back pews and murmur about how maintaining an orderly Christian family was too difficult for the average man to accomplish and how they couldn’t reasonably be expected to go all in. Augustine concerned himself precisely with this spiritual challenge: how to reach them and bring them fully into the fold. This would spur his further concern with semiotics and communication and delight.</p><p>What didn’t help was the presence of Donatist Christianity in Roman Africa. There was already a sect of the Church that took themselves to be this elite, and who believed that sacraments performed by “impure” priests were illegitimate. Augustine helped the Roman military repress them. Then came the Pelagians, followers of a British priest named Pelagius, who believed that all sin was conscious and intentional, and that forgiveness could not be extended to the sinner on account of things like bad habit or weak will. It’s worth comparing this with the spread of Islam in the same region of North Africa, where the moral challenge of conversion was explicitly left to a small elite and where the average person was only encouraged subtly to convert thanks to the financial incentive of the <em>jizya.</em></p><p>Pelagianism is an interesting doctrine. It sounds good — man is perfectible, no one is born evil, etc. But it turns into icy, Puritan-totalitarian wrath. In fact, it is a form of atavism throughout the history of the West. Saint-Simon, Robert Owen, and other utopians have all started from the same point. And it tends to end up with French-Revolutionary-style false confessions: you have failed to support the Revolution, you are failing to help perfect mankind, you must have some conscious reason to hate the greater good, admit it and sign your death warrant.</p><p>Islam faced the same tension over perfectibility. They had to stratify society into Muslims and non-Muslims to prevent it, but of course this was insufficient as more people converted over time. They then had to fight quite a few wars between Muslims themselves before submitting to Mamluk and Seljuq overlordship. They actually had their own Donatist types known as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kharijites">Kharijis</a>, who persisted for a while in North Africa. In fact the history of Morocco involves the overlay of ethnic tension onto perfectibility tension, with Berbers accusing Arab imams of being sinners. And, of course, a lot of Islamic extremist violence <em>today</em> continues to come from concern about the perfectibility of man.</p><p>From a certain perspective: Augustine saw that there’s a seemingly natural totalitarian/extremist shape that the Church wants to take, and he labored excruciatingly to structure the institution against that tendency. This is taught in Catholic schools as a critical humanist victory in the history of the faith.</p><p>Deleuze calls the Donatist/Pelagian motion a <em>reterritorialization</em>. Latin African Christians, many of whom recently converted from Roman paganism, briefly embrace a world-feeling that truly exposes them to the firmament and then about-face. They decide that the Church is <em>really</em> about who’s in the pure family and who’s out. It’s a retreat to the familiar Roman world-feeling where bodies are organized into families that have different virtues. Spengler observes that the new world-feeling emphasizes transformation. The Donatists in particular are taking the old logic and returning it to a new context.</p><p>We care about this, of course, because it’s an instructive tale about creative countercurrents at the grandest scale of civilization. Anyone who has tried to run change management at an organization of any size will have observed this phenomenon: the new system comes online and everyone is trying to operate the old way. Think about how California Buddhism interacts with science: the people want fMRIs of meditation happening in order to explain it, and the Roshi has to decide how much of this makes sense. The point of it all, of course, is that there will be no “science of nihility.”</p><p>We still fight over the perfectibility of man. Not to sound too much like Frank Herbert here: whatever conflicts arise from overcoming representational thinking will still be fought a thousand years from now. How will you aim institutions to escape the countercurrents?</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Augustine is a world-historic figure in the sense that he did more than anyone to transfigure and revitalize a saturated civilization.</p><p>He could not save the Empire, of course. Brown notes that Augustine’s lectures started to sound like a Freudian patient trying to talk around death by declaring it inevitable. Augustine knew that all things must pass, but evidently struggled to really imagine that Rome might. He’s often considered the first man in the historical record even to try.</p><p>But, of course, even if he couldn’t believe in it concretely, he had the City of God.</p><p>We care about him here, again, for three main reasons: his perspicacity in finding a creative principle that could escape from saturation, his ability to create a literary culture from it and to start creating his people, and his ability to protect the Church, his project, from reterritorialization.</p><p>We take it upon ourselves to imagine a world saturated by Platonism and ambition, and what it looks like to wander in the saturation for years before surrendering the beautiful future in order to accept a new world-feeling. The courage it takes to go from culture into nihility. The conviction it takes to repress your fellow travelers who fall into the countercurrents.</p><p>There are many moral lessons from Augustine, of course, but it’s the journey through it all that matters. The peregrination through the world. Embrace the journey, and the emptiness that supports all the images that it passes by.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=77a45af9eadb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/the-subaltern-part-two-augustine-of-hippo-77a45af9eadb">The Subaltern, Part Two: Augustine of Hippo</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Radio Static]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@grothendieckprime/radio-static-370f0aa2b519?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/370f0aa2b519</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Nov 2025 00:55:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-15T00:55:32.317Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We slept on the floor of our high school gym. You’d be forgiven for wondering why we did it. I guess I had come with a premonition, and perhaps the others as well.</p><p>Danny was still the weight training coach and he let us all in on this Saturday night in mid-July. We put up fairy lights and we listened to The Mountain Goats and Vampire Weekend. Someone played “Burning Down the House” by Talking Heads. I don’t know why we were all in town at the same time this random week, but the group chat was still alive and some dozen of us had gathered.</p><p>Somehow we were able to summon enough awe at the experience to put the phones away for a while. We had been able to shame each other into it when we were fifteen, and we managed to bring back that spirit even though we were now all thirty.</p><p>We looked up into the California dusk and observed the radio towers on the hills. So many warm evenings of my youth spent wondering if we could pick up extraterrestrial signals from them. We had even found a way to tune into the radio static once in my parents’ garage. We hoped for something from the other side but it was all just noise.</p><p>Stars came out and we recalled teenage evenings spent stargazing. Making jokes when the iPad came out that you could use that astronomy app now. Playing charades in the dark. Making ironic comments about how we were actually looking “down” into space because up is relative. There was always this tension with that kind of irony. We sought depth but we had to mock ourselves.</p><p>Friends were sharing life updates. Gillian was an exotic dancer now. The trio of lawyer ladies envied her. Mike and Michael were both construction contractors. Kenny was a Buddhist now and he really wanted to being that in as often as he could. Rishi was surprisingly happy as a dentist. Everyone else was pushing paper of some variety, and they had a good sense of humor about it. I’d driven down from SF to get away from all that. Only eleven Slack messages so far.</p><p>We were all still single. We reflected on it. Most of my friends said something along the lines of “I’m not going to compromise finding my person, and I don’t think that getting married should be this high-pressure thing, and we don’t have to have kids anymore so everyone should just buzz off about it.” You know, the same thing we were saying at fifteen. Kenny was polyamorous now, so the usual jokes we all wanted to make about that lifestyle had to stay on the shelf.</p><p>I wondered how much we believed any of that “take the pressure off” attitude anymore. Wasn’t the idea that people would breath down our necks about this stuff kind of narcissistic?</p><p>It was all kind of repetitive. For so long we’d thought that we had this new, more abundant way to view life. Lower pressure, more inclusive. We’d spent so many evenings on that lawn outside the gym running around and complaining about how parents were stuck-up about mixed-gender sleepovers. We’d make sarcastic jokes about how backward most of the country was about gay marriage and all that. We, the Millennials, were going to be the supremely unbothered generation.</p><p>Of course, now I wondered if we had simply not bothered to do anything with our lives. Verboten for me to say —me, the traitor who went north and made some money in tech. They had to rib me for a while and ask me about how much water the data centers were using and how I felt about the word “clanker” and all that. I played along.</p><p>Did they realize how misinformed they were about the water? Did they realize how misinformed that had kind of always been?</p><p>I thought about it some more. Kenny was talking about hungry ghosts and his friends in Berkeley who were doing some rad art project about mandalas and consciousness and Stewart Brand responded to his email once. I took a hit from the joint they were passing around. It made me recall all the parties in high school and over college breaks when I’d get high and crazy anxious.</p><p>Clarity came to me in the haze, though. I had chosen to be here. I somehow preferred to be here and not listening to VCs at some house party talk about which public companies they admired the most. This wasn’t hypothetical — I had literally rejected a Luma invite to such a function this weekend.</p><p>The insight hit me: there was a part of this whole cozy-low-pressure worldview that I did cling to. <em>I was raised believing failure was admiring public companies</em>. Worrying about a stock price must be an expression of scarcity, and we were supposed to be thinking about the inclusive future.</p><p>I felt warm, weirdly. For Kenny and whatever he was doing in Berkeley. The Buddhists never seem to receive warmth very easily. They hate being compared to the Internet Stoics but they share this trait. I was high enough and felt like enough of a prankster to heckle Kenny with this observation.</p><p>“Kenny, bro, I’m gonna play archetypal trickster figure here: ever notice how Stoics and Buddhists are both super cold when you say something as simple as ‘I really appreciate you, man?’”</p><p>“Yeah, I mean, a lot of us are on the spectrum and it’s important to offer grace to that. I can’t speak for the Stoics but they don’t seem to have the same responsibility toward others.”</p><p>Jesus. Not the vibe, apparently.</p><p>Something in me ached now. I wanted to overshare like I used to in high school, but after the age of twenty-five I had learned to keep that kind of behavior under the lid. I’d spent years pulling away from the ways of home, as one does with a good brain and opportunities in the city, but I’d clearly subconsciously rejected some test of full assimilation.</p><p>Gillian sat down next to me. I’d only learned six years ago that my attempts at being funny in high school always made her feel bad about herself, which had made me genuinely sad to discover. She had felt dumb and my pointed, high-effort, multisyllabic humor had exacerbated it.</p><p>“Hey, I don’t want to criticize or anything, but do you think your whole thing with joking about these Stoic guys… is that projection? Are you afraid that we all think you’re an incel or something?”</p><p>Here we go. Of course I wanted to say: yeah, I was afraid of that in 2017 when you guys were all screaming about it on the Internet; no, I’m not living in 2017 anymore. But I’d agreed with my therapist that we were going to practice assuming that people actually want to help. So we had to take this one in good faith.</p><p>“Yeah, I appreciate the careful listening. I hadn’t thought about it before, honestly. I guess I run into these guys a lot and I’m afraid I have to turn into one of them if I want to do well.”</p><p>Therapy-speak. She seemed to take it well. I had a mean thought about how many hours of short-form therapy-speak videos she might scroll through every week. All the rage, you know.</p><p>“Hm, I see. Don’t you think that ‘doing well’ is kind of loaded, though? Maybe that’s what you really want to unpack? Like, you’re here now, SF is there, we’re not them. You don’t have to take work home with you, you know.”</p><p>Now she was hitting a nerve that had been stripped raw by toxically-subtle Bay Area types. If she’s suggesting I’m scarcity-minded, we must have crossed a boundary. The boundary was probably simply mentioning the city, of course.</p><p>“It gets to me sometimes, ha. You know I love you guys. It’s cheesy but I love that we’re all here right now.”</p><p>She was really a caring person. Just… hurt. Years of space had nurtured sympathy.</p><p>“Of course, me too. Just looking out for you. Any time you want to talk, you know, I’m here.”</p><p>I reached for another puff. Stronger this time. And a Modelo.</p><p>The clock struck midnight faster than I thought it would. Too much to catch up on and too many stories to rehash. The lawyer ladies were prodding Kenny about his epic Big Sur experience junior year when he snuck Tanya away without her parents finding out and they did a ton of drugs in a yurt.</p><p>(Tanya went to BYU for some reason and now had three blonde children in Idaho.)</p><p>It’s really true that the nights felt longer when we were young. More memorable, moment-by-moment. I remembered when I got nasty death anxiety my junior year, probably the same weekend Kenny was doing his thing. God knows what caused it but it was probably the SAT. <em>No shit it was the SAT</em>, cross-faded me realized, that thing my friends and parents kept trying to deflate and de-emphasize. Man, I hadn’t realized how related all of these things were. Maybe I should light up more often. My girlfriend would love that.</p><p>Anyway, I’d had this moment where I thought about how much of my life was remaining and slipping away through the hourglass. The solution, I’d deduced from the Internet, was to savor. Meditation and lucid dreaming. I’d learned how to cook some Indian curries from Rishi’s mom, so I hid a bunch of mustard seeds we had on hand in an Altoids box and put it under my pillow. I made myself try to meditate in the rocking chair every evening before taking my dose and trying to get to sleep with breathing exercises.</p><p>I realized I’d never told this to any of these folks. I was old enough now to understand they wouldn’t know what to do with the information anyway. Maybe Kenny would care. It seemed like he might actually be coming from a similar place. That’s why I felt warm for him.</p><p>Did I still feel this way, I wondered? With the Dogpatch apartment and the fiancee and the cats and the parents asking about kids and the team I got to manage who all looked up to me? Probably not.</p><p>I knew enough about Buddhism to imagine what Kenny would say about all of this: there is no problem. There is only arising and fading away. Whatever we’re doing here simply <em>is</em>. I knew about Ginsberg discovering Zen and discussing it with Gary Snyder and all that. Kenny would surely point up at the radio dishes and say “you know, man, you complain that it’s all static, but that’s what enlightenment is — it’s the joyful embrace that everything is just radio static.”</p><p>I hoped that he was right. I hoped that if he was right about that, it could quiet the part of my mind that kept asking me why I hadn’t <em>done</em> anything with all this knowledge I had about Gary Snyder.</p><p>Well, I knew the answer. If I was going to write, I’d want it to actually be good. And struggling to hit a certain standard, be it writing or anything, was embracing a scarcity we were all just <em>past</em>. It should come from joy, and from love. Both Rishi and my parents would be eager to tell me I had no idea what it’d be like to be a teenager in India.</p><p>Back then we were concerned that the world was going to overpopulate, I remembered. Now we had to be reminded that 25% of the world’s 20-year-olds were in India and that Europe and Canada and the US were going to compete to convince them to immigrate. Wild. This was the kind of fact I wondered about with my friends: did they understand this kind of thing, just like the data centers and the water? Or was the vibe just too scarcity-sounding?</p><p>Yeah, that was it, wasn’t it? I’d been so invested in savoring, in being inspired and being precocious. Building toward success down the line was some kind of spiritual surrender. Back then, getting stressed about tests or internships was some sign of insufficient enlightenment. And now we were too old to be precocious. Had we come back to watch the twilight of the idols?</p><p>About five years ago I had accepted that it wasn’t my job to prove anything to them. Right around the time I learned to stop oversharing. I wasn’t really here for that. I was here to reconnect with what, I suppose, I still believed in.</p><p>Now they were playing Mr. Brightside and Kenny and Rishi were dancing with the lawyer ladies. Mike and Michael looked like they were about to pass out. The others had found some cigarettes.</p><p>We could see the stars now if we stepped outside on the other side of the lights. I gazed for a bit. You can outgrow precociousness, but I guess you can’t outgrow awe.</p><p>Naturally I was interrupted by the urge to look at my phone. Thirty Slack notifications. Jesus, guys, touch grass.</p><p>Tee hee, grass. Yeah I was pretty baked. I had to make a reference to that Simpsons episode where Homer makes a new pal and goes stargazing, and his pal asks how many stars he thinks are in the sky, and Homer quickly says “two!” This was probably the humor my younger cousin kept calling “Millennial cringe.”</p><p>Then I overheard, loudly from inside, Kenny bashing Elon Musk and I thought about how we just reused another rocket booster and how it’s not so crazy, perhaps, to believe there could be something out there. It’s us. We’re going back to the moon.</p><p>But back home in Central California we’re too happy to be made happy by going to space. Funny how that works. Maybe that was what comes after the twilight of the idols: we have to decide if we’re more interested in being the special generation we promised to be, or if we’re more interested in transcending scarcity.</p><p>The night air felt cold suddenly. The thought really upset me. I went inside and looked for my sleeping bag. Now they were bashing Larry Ellison. That didn’t really bother me as much.</p><p>I was wiped. I had one more Modelo to take the edge off and I started to see alien hypnogogia. These were strangely familiar, in a cozy way, from many a college camping trip. Going to sleep high with the comfort of a weird hexagonal grid of cattle skulls and radio dishes.</p><p>I really did hope Kenny was right about everything, even though he’d never let me tell him. The hypnogogia were joyous radio static, and it would be wonderful if all my anxieties and my confusions about my beliefs were, too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=370f0aa2b519" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Regarding Your Application]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@grothendieckprime/good-afternoon-please-step-in-and-if-you-dont-mind-close-the-door-thank-you-5f28ded998fd?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5f28ded998fd</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Nov 2025 20:25:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-10T20:26:05.134Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Good afternoon. Please step in and, if you don’t mind, close the door. Thank you.</p><p>I’ll start with the business facts since we only have a couple of minutes: we’re not proceeding with you.</p><p>But the more important thing I wanted to discuss is some feedback. You indicated thoroughly throughout the process that you love feedback and you’re eager to learn etc. so I prepared a few bullet points I’m willing to review.</p><p>Fundamentally you have not decided to square yourself with the truth. Any shortcomings of your proposals are downstream of this.</p><p>Look, you start looking for real money to build you dreams and at some point someone has to do the honors and explain to you the terrible truth.</p><p>The terrible truth is that we live in an asset-bubble economy and the returns you’re likely to generate from your clever idea just aren’t going to beat the real estate market. You’ve chosen to face the real world, so here it is: every generation only has a few genuinely investable companies. Yours is not, but again that’s beside the point. The point is you made a lot of noise so we’re going to give you the medicine you asked for. And the real symptom here is that you haven’t even entertained what the truth might be.</p><p>To be clear, it’s not personal. It’s been a long day and I have to get this off my chest in front of at least one of you guys. Usually it’s some kid, but what’s curious although not unique about you is that you’re not even a kid anymore. Maybe a “kid at heart” or something like that. I think that was Jay Inslee’s brand when he wandered into the 2020 primaries. I guess it’s <em>a</em> brand. I digress.</p><p>The pity here is, again, not particularly uncommon — guys like you could probably be millionaires by now if you’d made the right moves in law or real estate. You have a good brain but you have severely warped ideas about what that realistically can achieve. When we say “good brain” we mean “you could run a spreadsheet for a factory if you needed to.” Lots of guys can’t do that. It kind of makes them preferable to deal with, not least because they have appropriate opinions.</p><p>Let’s look at the pitch deck. You’re evidently trying to find something more difficult than money. You want a creative mandate. You’re chasing dreams, or similar. It’s a bit immature of you to be asking other grown men to get involved with this kind of thing. I think you need to hear that feedback clearly. Again, before your ego goes off into some spiral, this isn’t particularly rare for a grown man of your age to need it. But it is a drag. Pathological, you could even say, but of course I have to wonder if the pathology is really anything you could control.</p><p>The whole country has this pathology, you see. If you don’t already own assets, you sit around with these unrealistic expectations. Of course, if you look at the folks who do own assets, it’s not as if they’re doing much other than playing hot potato. And that leaves only a certain amount of time for “art” or “dreams.”</p><p>But, again, the issue is that you came to the money business asking about art. Guys like you tend to do this and we never really know what exactly to tell you. The fault is squarely yours, but I’m never sure how to phrase the feedback in a way that won’t make you inclined to go create worse problems.</p><p>Let’s take a look at a foil case, okay? China is a country that now has a median IQ of something like 105. They got there by making enormous sacrifices the magnitude of which has been alien in this country for two generations. The kids get out of school, and they go to work in factories even with their bachelor’s degrees. They work hard and long hours. They have a pretty reasonable understanding of what a good brain means. It means that you’re suited to a kind of performance that doesn’t involve breaking down your body. Other men merely have good bodies, you know.</p><p>No, in China, they actually have decent price discovery. And it turns out there’s no free lunch out there. Even if the gentry in this country might seem to be eating your lunch, it’s really hurting your prospects to keep acting like there’s going to be another free one out there.</p><p>But let’s talk about the guys who only have good bodies. You probably want to have an impact on the culture with this whole plan of yours. You want to make a launch video, and you want to have a podcast, and you want to make a statement about what life could be like. What’s amazing is to what a trivial extent these average guys actually care about “the culture.” You probably want attention from whatever corner of Twitter you’re sitting in. That’s the full horizon of your concerns and you’re asking us to put other people’s money into it.</p><p>My advice, honestly, is to own that. You don’t have concerns outside of feeling like you’ve fulfilled some idea of the life well lived. The blue-collar guys are like that and it’s commendable. I think you’re on the right track to actually start acknowledging how you want to live and why other people’s money is supposed to help you accomplish that.</p><p>Fundamentally you can’t be blamed for your situation, or even expected to control that much about it. Your parents almost certainly deluded you about the role of intelligence in productivity, and you were almost certainly buoyed by a period of low interest rates and all that jazz. But you do have to face yourself about a more fundamental deception: you have been unable to bring yourself to confront your desires. You might have punished yourself for them pre-emptively, but you have never confronted. Perhaps you were hoping that this whole institutional process might help you do that, and hey — fair. The marketing that these 24-year-olds put out does explicitly make it sound like we’re in that business.</p><p>But that’s the marketing. You claim to be cynical but here you are being nakedly earnest. Not earnest enough to face yourself, but earnest enough to invite feedback that you probably spend most of your time ignoring and insulating yourself from.</p><p>The truth is that you either have something or you don’t. The truth is that your behavior reflects your inclinations, and that you may not really have any control at all. But you do have the window of agency to be honest with yourself and your choices, and you have refused to seize that. You probably feel like you’ve been stuck in the kiddie pool your entire life and that might be true. But you have to confront whether you’ve really thought through what the rules look like when you graduate to swimming laps. How much of “you” really enters into the larger pool.</p><p>Anyway, this is mostly for me. That’s the truth. What you do with it is very probably not entirely within your control.</p><p>If you’ll excuse me, I have a hard stop. Good day.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5f28ded998fd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do It for the Culture]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/do-it-for-the-culture-b5a38fc6ae70?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b5a38fc6ae70</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Nov 2025 05:50:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-04T05:50:45.592Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I saw the adage on Twitter recently and it gave me the usual fright: “culture is the only layer that matters.” It’s true, is the thing, and it demands some reflection. Some of that rare virtue, courage.</p><p>Culture — here, I mean “taste and discourse about taste” — determines if people will actually use the product, and what they will consume or occupy themselves with. It’s true that no amount of technical or operational excellence can really tell people what to want. Aristotle said it first: you can’t deliberate about your ends.</p><p>It frightens me, though, because I live with deep apprehension about the culture. The <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/epicureans-a-typology-143a3218d1e8">atmospheric irony</a> is everywhere. Perhaps it comes from having older parents who always felt exhausted by deferred maintenance on the house. It always feels like the culture is tired, risk-averse, intransigent. I know that collapsing it all into one story and throwing up my hands and refusing to toil is just arrogance. It won’t do.</p><p>Take an example: I was recently in Chicago. It’s a city that has beautiful neighborhoods but doesn’t really have any projects. The mayor is on a road to nowhere. The governor wants to raise taxes and be even more hostile to business. I used to admire the city for being true blue. Bike lanes. Green roofs. A climate change plan. A sanctuary city. These are all cultural tastes that I used to share and be somewhat proud of.</p><p>I don’t really believe any of those things matter anymore. Or, more accurately, that those terms signify anything beyond a certain aesthetic. And the worst part is I used to believe that all these programs were smart-people things. Some sort of indicators of affluence. Aesthetics do matter, of course, but I sort of feel like Plato complaining about the poets. The aesthetics lie. Or worse, they make certain things too discomforting to confront.</p><p>A lot of our problems are self-inflicted. Especially in Chicago. Why do they vote for the current slate of policies? Why so much complaisance? Why don’t they have any serious plan for the economic future of the city or the state? They’re watching residents leave faster than any state outside of New York or California. My own vice is how easy it is to look at that kind of picture and to say “man, they have tastes I’m never going to be able to negotiate with” and retreat into the study.</p><p>On a related note, it’s hard to believe self-inflicted problems are possible if your view of the world is a sort of end-of-history progressive one. Even if you can see the problems without rationalizing them away, it’s still a non-starter to think “how can I solve them” as if they’d just give way to the end of history.</p><p>You can’t really “solve problems” in some Archimedean way. There’s no way to cleanly line them up and knock them down and put it on your resume. The problems are part of the culture. You have to <em>do culture</em> to perceive problems. You have to learn to read the discourse, to empathize with how the world presents itself to others, to actually map key phrases to affective experiences. You can only solve problems that you perceive. You get more problems when you solve problems.</p><p>Some people like to take comfort in cleverly-designed quality-of-life metrics. A friend of mine decided to run a whole spreadsheet comparing metrics on potential cities to move to before folding when he realized he simply wanted to be in the West Village no matter what. So long, Baltimore. I think that the art of defining these metrics is very much like music theory. You can become a technical master but you can’t analyze your way to understanding why a sounds feels a certain way. There are other analogies here. The map is not the territory, etc.</p><p>I feel like the analysis paralysis is part of the culture. I can’t be the only one who feels this way.</p><p>There’s something about solving problems, though, that’s so visceral. It means I am doing my job well. I used to have a very hard time doing my job when I worked at a startup. It was so much more important to do and move on than to do anything well. I have come to appreciate that this is a difficult skill.</p><p>It’s natural to cling to that feeling. I have some accolade-obsessed friends who really feel they need a certain title or a certain performance of diligence in their working life or else they really panic. For a certain kind of person it’s a full-blown anxiety disorder.</p><p>I used to be a lot more anxious. A lot of it was definitely clinging to various ideas about status and success. The symbolic value of being a sanctuary city, for instance. Eventually I got angry enough to want a future and now I am less anxious.</p><p>As for the clinging, perhaps there’s something to be said for how disembodied our experience has become. Labor that was once ritual is all automated, down to robots cleaning our homes, and we have replaced all the monumental fixtures of society, all the reminders of toil that might span beyond one lifetime, with industrial processes. It’s alienating. I can see how people who mostly interact with screens want there to be some friction that indicates work is happening. Even if it’s just cognitive. I think this is a huge challenge for adapting to using language models. Even as I write this article, I find myself scrolling up and down the page to reassure myself that I am doing the work to write.</p><p>It’s an evolution of an old impulse, though. Rome was sacked in 1538 by French mercenaries who were restless and had not been paid. This ended the High Renaissance. I like to imagine that they just wanted to do their job instead of waiting around. Professional soldiers drill during downtime, but you don’t pay mercenaries to just drill. So they pillage in order to have something to do.</p><p>I watch companies do this. They measure homepage clicks and map out the funnel instead of doing outbound sales. They create programs with no users. They write documentation without an audience. Engineers get anxious quickly if not fully utilized, and they start talking about quitting and seeking higher salaries elsewhere.</p><p>As an engineer I used to feel like there was an impossible gulf between what companies would pay me to do and what felt like excellent work. This turned out to be a feeling called “creative frustration” that my upbringing prepared me poorly to confront. I think Julia Cameron is the best authority on this feeling.</p><p>As I did finally confront creative frustration directly, which is a very difficult thing, I found a lot of my old beliefs totally splintered. I no longer cared what my city called itself. I came to realize how many social problems are actually features. Making that acknowledgement previously would have felt like intolerably painful pessimism or even jouissance. I watched the view of the world where “we have a lot of problems and we need to just solve them” splinter. How would it be possible that everything would just get fixed?</p><p>Well, it’s not about that. It’s about the desire to have a role.</p><p>The emotional upset there I think is exactly what runs these companies the way they actually run. <em>Jeff worked hard on this dashboard and we want to commend his effort even if the project is superfluous. We want to make sure we’re showing some results for our program.</em> Et cetera.</p><p>Ideology, you see, operates at a somatic register. It never feels conceptual. You don’t realize in the moment that you’re following an affective rhythm. You don’t realize so easily how a few behavioral patterns might determine what you think the whole texture of the world must be like, or how some words become affectively loaded when they recur in similar embodied circumstances.</p><p>It just feels like a huge bummer to face a failing product, or it feels really upsetting to discover that a team has no meaningful goals. You can’t call it by its true name or else it loses its power. I suspect that the best operators in private equity understand this keenly and have thereby made themselves very wealthy.</p><p>I remember in college I had a friend tell me that he was very excited for his friends who had found that their lives post-graduation had “a certain texture.” I remember how weird this felt to realize that he was basically reporting a KPI he was really proud of cooking up. I pushed back on him and asked what the intrinsic value of that texture really is. He was confused, of course. He said that he didn’t really know, but felt like it was important that his friends get an accurate, non-pecuniary description of their lives that hyped them up. I deeply appreciated the honesty of that answer.</p><p>Some friends from San Francisco told me a similar story a few years back. They were looking for “ikigai” — a fourfold intersection between your talents, your passions, what the world needs, and what people will pay for. It’s impossible to be against that, I suppose. But I had to ask the same question: is this an analytical tool? Or is it an aesthetic statement?</p><p>It’s the same deal with concepts like “technological progress,” of course. Economists measure it in patents per year. The fact is that technological success is a fundamentally aesthetic judgement. This absolutely does not need to be discomforting. I’m a huge proponent of technological progress! But it does discomfort when it’s presented to software engineers who are very attached to their work.</p><p>So yes, on a certain level it’s only really the culture that matters. Pretending otherwise seems to do everyone a disservice. A very large disservice, in fact.</p><p>Well, it’s natural to ask “what am I even supposed to do if this is true?” As a bunch of white collar jobs disappear with rising interest rates and LLM adoption, this is a particularly good question to struggle with right now. It’s a real struggle, not a rhetorical one.</p><p>Again, please learn from my bad habit. It’s plain arrogance to tell oneself a story about how futile it is to try to do culture.<em> No, don’t start posting on Twitter, you’ll get assimilated into their stupid game and then it will be cringe. No, don’t tell people what you think at work, it will cause friction and get you passed over for promotions. No, don’t directly acknowledge your muses or desires, it will come across as intellectual bullying.</em></p><p>How do you know that? Why do you get to decide that?</p><p>Culture is just people doing things. You are actively creating it as you move through the world. There’s no way to let yourself off the hook. Your talents and inner powers are not you, and you are not being praised when your talents are. You can only be responsible for how you choose to use them. That is another way in which culture is the only layer that matters.</p><p>Again, all discomforting. It is my habit to see the above paragraph and to think “yeah, I just suck and I guess I’m doing it all to myself because that’s just who I am.” It’s easy to read, hard to digest.</p><p>There’s some good news, though. Digesting this stuff is part of doing the culture. A Christian friend very much admires the Desert Fathers who helped shape early Christianity. They didn’t really write or create anything tangible. They took all the problems of Egypt, went into the desert, and fought demons. And then they returned and started the first abbeys. “Abbey” comes from the Egyptian word “apa,” which means “father.”</p><p>Nourishing yourself is doing the culture. Reading is doing the culture. Fighting demons alone in the desert is doing the culture. You can’t deliberate about your ends but you can expose yourself to greater ones.</p><p>An example that haunts me: silver is really cheap right now because no one wants it. We seem to fear ornamentation so much that a silver-plated carafe on eBay is cheaper than a Chemex. Nice old apartments are often cheaper than the sleek, budget-optimized five-over-one units that go up nowadays. There is no real economic explanation for this. It’s an aesthetic thing. We make the active choice every day to pass by the beautiful things even when they are cheaper.</p><p>I like this example because it prompts people to try to analyze. What are the class or status or financial reasons for it? And I have to respond, just like to the guy in college: what’s the real value of analyzing this? Perhaps we could just disagree with the social trend and buy some cheap beautiful silver objects!</p><p>In other words, it seems clear that people don’t like ornamental stuff just because the <a href="https://www.benlandautaylor.com/p/why-we-cant-have-nice-things">aesthetic of ornamentation is dispreferred by the culture</a>.</p><p>Ultimately, in every scientific or technical or managerial endeavor, someone is calling shots and exercising aesthetic taste. Every research institute has seniors who actually decide what science to do. This fact discomforts and it motivates us to distract ourselves with the work we feel accountable to. The attachments we already have. Look, there’s merit to trying to do your job well. To seeing it in terms of developing a practice. But I think what makes an effective practitioner is being clear-eyed about what shots are getting called.</p><p>Back in college I struggled with this. I was searching for some principle by which work in the world could be about something other than “getting decision-makers to like me.” (In other words, trafficking in the right aesthetics.) I’m not sure how I got there, but it was acute. I’d hang out with the math kids and get told that I really needed to just learn how professors write questions so that I could nail tests and polish my grades for grad school. I’d hang out with activists and they’d tell me that the world is all just cliques and power relations and hegemonies. It really felt like there was nowhere worldly for real excellence or beauty or taste to matter.</p><p>(If this sounds like “young man realizes he’s looking for God,” by the way, my estimation is that religion doesn’t solve any of this. You just get people telling you how to get the congregation to like you. I know T. S. Eliot became an Anglo-Catholic in order to be part of something that was truly not about the culture, but I don’t have that in me.)</p><p>So perhaps for others the same is true. Solving problems in your chosen domain is a way to experience a creative spark that is sanctioned and not exposed to whether or not people like you. Yes, fabulating concepts that sound technical feels like a way to create space for creating. And yes, in many cases you have to use the aesthetics to get decision-makers to like you. Do it consciously.</p><p>But there is a spark that’s important enough to produce strong emotions even if you don’t recognize them. Exactly no one seems to be able to protect it for you, and by that token it makes sense why serious creative courage is so uncommon.</p><p>So, yes, it stings to confront it from an unpopular place, but culture is ultimately what matters. You have to be in the taste game if you want to do worldly good. Avoiding it is abdicating your only source of moral agency. Inventing quality-of-life KPIs can’t obscure this fact. Yes, it sounds harsh. There’s not much to say other than it’s one of the great difficulties of life, the source of much worthy struggle, a domain the demands that rare virtue we call courage.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b5a38fc6ae70" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/do-it-for-the-culture-b5a38fc6ae70">Do It for the Culture</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“They’re More Interested in Being Right than Winning.”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/theyre-more-interested-in-being-right-than-winning-3af163cbba44?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3af163cbba44</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Oct 2025 05:33:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-22T21:53:02.489Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s an accusation I see leveled on Twitter every so often. Usually it describes the Democratic Party. It also describes a certain kind of white-collar worker who is easy to complain about. This guy works at a large corporation, controls some department, feels needed, and has an elaborate story about why no one understands how difficult his job is. It’s also been thrown at me.</p><p>You could paraphrase it by saying something like “if you’re so smart and there’s really something to all your theories about the world, why haven’t you made some money on it?”</p><p>Who is the accuser? He probably follows Nassim Taleb on Twitter, probably either is or was a trader of some variety, and probably feels a bit intellectually insecure. There’s a way that certain men feel a deep anxiety to trade only in legible achievements.</p><p>(He’s in many cases misdiagnosed the situation, as well. The conversation probably proceeds to a place where he says “I dunno man, you get your posh degree and you don’t have the fear of God in you and then you wonder why you’re not a millionaire.” Yeah, thanks, I have actually never wondered why I’m not a millionaire. I actually hate the word because of how it would make friends and family wince to hear it describe me.)</p><p>The accusation gets under my skin. There’s always the feeling that there could be truth in it. I’ve mulled it over for a while, and I’ve imagined trying to talk to this guy and to assume good faith for a moment. For some reason, I have to wonder: “Fine, maybe I do prefer being right to winning. But what would you suggest I do about it?”</p><p>I can’t speak for everyone who loves being right more than winning, but I can say this much about the part of me that is that way: he’s trying to feel like he’s standing for something. He’s trying to show that he has principles, and he’s trying to show that he cares. If you want to be really cynical about it, he’s trying to maintain his imagined status with the community he was raised in. He fears that success means exile.</p><p>It’s not hard to imagine that this is how communities keep themselves together: make outsize individual success costly in terms of status to prevent people from just leaving. Especially in a more transient place like the West Coast, anyone with roots in any place is going to try to make sure their folks stick around. One can imagine the more gaseous society gets, the more we may see a certain motion of sorting and leveling. Witness as lawyers and doctors and professors continue to marry within their guilds.</p><p>Take, for instance, what happens when an upstart entrepreneur has to start managing money and contracts. Having to argue with people or to sue them, or to go collecting money? All stuff my Unitarian upbringing believes is just not part of a refined life. I can tell you there’s a way that Portland liberals deduct status for making visible effort in business. It sticks with you.</p><p>Anyway, for my own part: I’m not one of these lawyers or doctors or professors. But I do have experience in Silicon Valley that involved some managing contracts. And I can certain tell you that there’s a way in which the possibility of winning felt very fraught. Not that I fundamentally didn’t want to make a million dollars and retire early to become a man of letters, but simply because I’m trained to operate in “being right” mode.</p><p>It’s a somatic thing. I’d get too close to real voltage and this horrible feeling would come over me like reprogrammed-Alex in <em>A Clockwork Orange</em>. Stomach clenched up, looking for some way out of the room. I have vivid memories of feeling like my shoulder had become tied in a knot and foam rolling for an hour and soaking in the bath to avoid some critical project.</p><p>Getting close to really winning <em>feels</em> precarious. Pass through the threshold and being a gentleman won’t matter anymore. All those New Age virtues I was raised on only make one a sucker in there. Once you have a million dollars in ARR, that’s blood in the water. Welcome to Shark Week. You’re going to have to face hostile board members obsessed with velocity, and clients who want to kill you and acquihire you, and other wildlife. And I seem to suffer the very strong sense that I’d have to face it all alone and actually pay in terms of status for doing it.</p><p>It’s not even about the fear of failure. If I were a German, as far as I understand, the contempt for business failure would be even worse. Maybe some of the Ivy League strivers who get blasted with “more interested in being right” are more scared of failure.</p><p>No, dear reader, there is such a thing as the fear of success. The accusers are not wrong that it has led to some bad decisions. Trying to turn down the heat on visible projects. Not taking advantage of valuable connections. Refusing to write or to enjoy reading, instead spending hours daydreaming about getting hissed at by doctoral students for refusing to stay in my lane. Distracting myself with endless tests of discipline.</p><p>I know it drives people crazy, too. It took years to realize no one wants to hear a sore winner go on about how yes, we did land the deal, and here’s why it’s actually not as exciting as it might sound and here’s where we almost ruined the relationship and here’s where we still don’t have our act together. Hating sore winners isn’t the same thing as hating success. In Britain, I know, it’s customary to act astonished at success. In Singapore, I’m told, success requires lots of performative complaining about the inconveniences it creates.</p><p>Irony is toxic. Being a sore winner is not good. I don’t intend to tarry here.</p><p>So, I ask the accuser: “seriously, any advice here?” Although it may be impossible.</p><p>In the past, it’s been impossible to get advice from anyone so passionate. Entrepreneurs are often making a virtue of necessity, trying to make the best of being in a low-status situation to begin with. Guys like that don’t usually have advice to offer to someone in a different situation.</p><p>As a result, I’ve spent some months looking for answers in Plutarch. Plutarch has treated me well of late. A lot of his heroes are, of course, not relatable: there are plenty of aristocrats who triumph and then are either punished for their deeds or who become scared of the possibility of corruption. And then there are some who do fit the bill: upwardly-mobile folks who spend a lot of energy scared of the consequences of success. Specifically I have in mind Themistocles, Demosthenes, and Gaius Marius. Men whose talent made significant impact and who reflexively feared being exiled for it.</p><p>I have some difficulty reading all his moral examples, though. Irony compels me to wonder if I’m not getting too big for by britches trying to compare myself to the greats. Am I not puffing up the magnitude of my own potential deeds?</p><p>But it is, of course, nutritious material. The Athenians and their utterly fickle attitudes toward success and power are deeply instructive. How the ambitious man has to work the civic audience is intimidating, but it helps make sense of how people play politics. The acrimony and constant distraction of the Roman senate help one appreciate just how little one really receives direct attention in the doghouse.</p><p>Your mileage may vary. It’s helpful to participate in a political imagination that has interacted with the great minds of many generations.</p><p>I hope the accuser guy can learn to love Plutarch as much as he loves Taleb. I believe he means well. He wants his fellow man to size up the stakes he faces in life. But the world is not just a contest of inner powers and outer achievements.</p><p>But it is true that the world is full of yappers. You’re allowed to complain about it. The guy who works at a big company and who argues with you instead of taking responsibility? Yeah, he’s probably not interested in Plutarch either. I can understand the frustration with intransigent people who are trying to protect carelessness using rhetoric.</p><p>But, you know, he could also be some kind of Michael Scott type. The manager who fears what he actually is, who denies that he actually has the job he has, who sacrifices competence and workplace sanity in a quixotic quest to just be liked. And that guy may be eager for the right kind of growth.</p><p>Some of us are yapping maliciously, others may fear failure and believe that pure rhetoric is the best they can offer, but some of us genuinely fear success. If you do have advice about learning to love winning, it may actually be welcome.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3af163cbba44" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/theyre-more-interested-in-being-right-than-winning-3af163cbba44">“They’re More Interested in Being Right than Winning.”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Entropy Pessimism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/on-entropy-pessimism-0fc4025a6a7c?source=rss-6cba8151c60------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0fc4025a6a7c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[grothendieckprime]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Oct 2025 04:23:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-21T04:23:34.659Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve learned recently about <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pessimism#Entropy_pessimism"><em>entropy pessmism</em></a>: the view that the universe approaches an inevitable heat death. When we talk about the atheistic bent of the Western scientific worldview, the second law of thermodynamics is definitely part of that. It’s central to how we extirpated vitalism from biology and reduced our own animal existence to heat dispersion, after all.</p><p>Specifically, entropy pessimism has an economic interpretation: that the world has a finite reserve of low-entropy resources (e.g. fossil fuels) and that economic activity essentially increases entropy the way that all motion does.</p><p>This is a wrong view, in my opinion. I believe Heidegger refutes it at an appropriate level in <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/207864.The_Question_Concerning_Technology_and_Other_Essays"><em>The Question Concerning Technology</em></a><em>. </em>In very short: the idea of a resource, or indeed of a thing that could be measured in terms of entropy, presupposes some sort of schema that could that thing obtrusive or visible to us in the first place. What’s important here is threefold: it doesn’t require an article of religious faith; it doesn’t essentially call for an engineering solution; but it does require reckoning with real discomfort toward our scientific worldview.</p><p>I’ll discuss the foil responses after clarifying the position and its significance.</p><p>It turns out that Joseph Schumpeter, an icon of mine, had a student named <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Georgescu-Roegen">Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen</a> who was made famous in the 1970s for bringing thermodynamics into economic theory. There’s a famous study from 1972 published by the Club of Rome that promised so-called “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth">limits to growth</a>.” There are of course modern degrowthers: I read the <a href="https://astrapublishinghouse.com/product/slow-down-9781662602368/">recent manifesto</a> by Kohei Saito last year. But the 70s stuff sticks out because it’s very close to home and it hit me that I had stumbled upon a part of my own heritage.</p><p>Portland, Oregon in 2009 was definitely a place where Boomers liked to trot out their skepticism of industrial capitalism. For years I heard tell of the Limits of Growth at many a holiday party or family hike. The story in 2009 went something like “today it’s the housing market and job market; tomorrow, it’ll be the total exhaustion of all natural resources.”</p><p>Looking back, I get why degrowth is an understandable outlet. But it hit me really hard. These were the days when we all wanted to save the rainforest and worried that the Brazilians wouldn’t do it, or we worried about global overpopulation, or that we had to talk foreign countries out of trying to industrialize. For me it created an almost religious level of anxiety about decarbonization and the importance of finding a steady-state existence — complete with taboos like avoiding unsustainably-sourced food and clothing.</p><p>I don’t know how I got so attached to this line of thinking, but it’s been a leitmotif in my life for the last fifteen years. And some of this sentiment looms over me to this day: the premonition that older and wiser people know that all ambition is futile and in the long run we are all heat-dead. So today I have framed the entropy-pessimist worldview and argued against it as strongly as I can.</p><p>Georgescu-Roegen’s view of the economy is something like the following: the substitution of consumable goods is a false abstraction. In reality, we participate in an entropic process that appropriates natural resources following a logic of profit-accumulation, fueling itself only by extracting low-entropy inputs from a finite environment. Eventually we will have extracted every last store of energy on the planet — wood, fossil fuels, water, schools of fish, you name it — and face a sort of economic heat death. At best, it will be some kind of steady state subsistence with no remaining stores of energy to promise another blip like the Industrial Revolution.</p><p>In fact, it’s a very parismonious argument that requires only two premises: one, that any transformation of material (including economic activities such as transporting or manufacturing or even combusting) causes a decrease in entropy consistent with the second law of thermodynamics; two, that the world we experience (be it the earth or whatever cosmic expanse) has an ultimately finite amount of low-entropy resources.</p><p>A familiar response to this idea is to say “Well, what about solar? What about outer space?” We can point at the sun and to make reference to Elon Musk. We have to engineer our way out of the predicament! We have to become multiplanetary as a species. Even if we have to create artificial superintelligence first, we have to expand into the stars.</p><p>Hannah Arendt, famously Heidegger’s former student, entertained this idea in the preface to her opus <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=the+human+condition&amp;ref=nav_sb_noss_l_19"><em>The Human Condition</em></a>. Extraterrestrial life, she mused, would radically modify the conditions of humanity both environmentally and historically. It’s a choice to become a certain kind of species — one whose lineage would be defined by the choice to leave the planet, much as modern man is a being whose lineage is defined by commodity markets, steamboats, and the splitting of the atom.</p><p>Arendt alludes to a response that takes the historical dimension of the problem seriously. This is important because the foil response doesn’t do much for us to get away from pesssimism — it’s easy enough for Georgescu-Roegen to say “changing the scope to a galaxy doesn’t solve the entropy problem.” Then the Elon fan has to say something like, “well, but it buys us time, and that’s what being a species is all about: finding ways to keep expanding without dying.”</p><p>Fine, maybe. But that lets the entropy pessimist win on some level. And it concedes that the human condition is an <em>enframed</em> one. It concedes that we must take ourselves to be something like <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungry_ghost">hungry ghosts</a>, moping through the galaxy (or whatever cosmic topos) simply consuming and fighting against the elemental foe to continue doing so.</p><p>This reveals the real problem with entropy pessimism: we simply don’t want to be this kind of being. It’s a spiritual issue, not necessarily a logistical one.</p><p>Now, it’s difficult to concede that we have a spiritual problem on our hands. We’re not going to become Amish. One can easily imagine the religious-agrarian opinion on industrialization, well-worn and perennial since the time of Ludd: “it’s bad, duh; return to tradition, live at subsistence, and go to church.”</p><p>This isn’t a solution, of course. Turns out, simply being a spiritual leader or a man of faith does not guarantee you can solve every spiritual problem. I include this minor digression because it’s something that’s haunted me ever since I took my own taboos about the environment: well, what if we really do have to go to some kind of faith-based steady state agrarianism? (It turns out Oregon’s own Frank Herbert has thought through the potential consequences of that one. I really wish I had read <em>Dune</em> when I was a teenager.)</p><p>To summarize: the common response to entropy is not actually a response. The entropy argument is very robust. Changing the scope doesn’t defeat it. Ignoring it and insisting on a return to faith and tradition isn’t even engaging with it. The Pope recently reminded his flock that hunger is a spiritual evil. The common man shouldn’t be condemned to apostolic poverty.</p><p>There is also a weak version of the Heidegger argument that fails to defeat pessimism. It goes something along the lines of “The existence of resources is a form of disclosure that is ultimately historical. We didn’t know that atoms, for instance, are a low-entropy resource until we theorized a nuclear force holding protons together. Therefore new science can find new solutions, as it has done in the past.” This, as it turns out, is not different from the Elon-fanboy response. Simply saying “there will be more science in the future and it will figure out how to expand the entropy horizon” is actually a combination of reinvented faith and resignation to engineering.</p><p>The problem, of course, is that Georgescu-Roegen’s syllogism is very tight (if entropy and finitude, then heat death) and therefore must be refuted by its presuppositions. The above interpretation of Heidegger is an epistemological one. The effective argument is ontological: <em>an entropic system is only one way of disclosing the world</em>. The interpretation of this scientific-economic model as identical with our experience of the world, or as a total metaphysics, is not determined by the model itself or by any component of Georgescu-Roegen’s argument. Accepting the assertion of totality is a choice, not a necessity.</p><p>You might ask, “well, how does Heidegger promise that we won’t have to go back to the subsistence predictd by the Club of Rome?” He doesn’t. But he would point out: as long as we’re enframed in a secular-scientific worldview, we can only imagine the future in terms of a binary between engineering a galactic-scale compact or returning to a steady-state existence on a finite earth. There’s similarly no promise that these are the only two options.</p><p>(<a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/seeking-a-subaltern-6cacde97b080">As I have described previously</a>, Heidegger is not alone in diagnosing this precarious moment for Western thought. Either accept managed decline through degrowth atheism, or decenter the technical mode of thinking.)</p><p>Of course, accepting Heidegger’s argument feels like parting with the scientific worldview altogether. It means you have to say “the laws of physics are just a model,” which is, you know, a cringe thing to say. Not that any physicist seriously disagrees with the utterance.</p><p>I think the folks I knew back in 2009 were basically stuck at this realization. If we identify ourselves with the scientific-secular way of seeing the world, then we are actively choosing to live in the entropy-pessimist world. At the very least we are choosing to live in the world where we go interplanetary or die, and where we follow Elon like hungry ghosts. As much as I strongly disagree sentimentally with the anti-AI crowd these days, I think they are also keyed into this one. Trying to engineer ourselves away from heat death means running on a dismal treadmill.</p><p>I speculate that reaching this realization is what has caused a certain degree of sympathy among American activists toward the Islamic Revolution in the last couple years. If you read <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1400603.Gharbzadegi?ac=1&amp;from_search=true&amp;qid=0OnKHzNY9v&amp;rank=1"><em>Gharbzadegi</em></a>, you’ll see the extent to which Heidegger’s point landed with Jalal al-e-Ahmad, the intellectual godfather of the movement.</p><p>And, again, I know that this conclusion is upsetting. San Franciscans have told me it sounds like cope, or like a wishy-washy way of escaping from the adult world, or what have you. I don’t blame them. It’s natural to want something for all your effort to become technical and to interpret the world.</p><p>I think that the upset reaction is part of a healthy process forward. It’s a legitimate, important question: “well, what’s all the science for if it turns us into degrowthers or hungry ghosts?” It’s not rhetorical. The Oregonians were wondering this. Arendt directly points to it. The Islamists asked it. The tech bros are asking it.</p><p>We have to confront the question, earnestly and seriously.</p><p>What’s to be done, then? Simply let nothing be final. Let entropy pessimism be part of an unfolding process of scientific reason. Don’t let it be a metaphysics any more than any previous scientific theory was. Let it move you to ask the difficult existential questions. This movement is not a betrayal of the scientific worldview but rather the deepest participation in it.</p><p>Heidegger writes: <em>“The real ‘movement’ of the sciences takes place when their basic concepts undergo a more or less radical revision which is transparent to itself. The level which a science has reached is determined by how far it is capable of a crisis in its basic concepts.”</em></p><p>Let Being unfold, entropy and all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0fc4025a6a7c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood/on-entropy-pessimism-0fc4025a6a7c">On Entropy Pessimism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/hardy-littlewood">Hardy-Littlewood</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>