<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Andra Jatikusumo on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Andra Jatikusumo on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@guinandra?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 16:39:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Southeast Asia Geopolitics at Stanford]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guinandra/southeast-asia-geopolitics-at-stanford-382bccf2da1f?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/382bccf2da1f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 May 2025 20:18:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-26T20:18:28.285Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Quick takes on how the region is approaching U.S.-China</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i1xwv_o98rYysC35cyIxkw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Southeast Asia Conference on Prosperity and Sustainability at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University, last week. Photo taken by the author.</figcaption></figure><p>Southeast Asia was buzzing at Stanford earlier this week. I had the privilege to listen to my childhood role model, Former President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, to go on a run with Coordinating Minister Agus H. Yudhoyono (Taruna Nusantara 5), to get coffee with Former Minister Gita Wirjawan, and to have a quick chat with Ambassador Dino Patti Djalal. All of them came to campus for a Southeast Asia conference organized by Pak Gita, who’s currently a visiting scholar &amp; lecturer here.</p><p>Below are some quick takeaways from the talks, along with a few snippets from one-on-one conversations I had. <em>Caveat</em>: this is <strong>a lightly written and weakly researched post</strong> — just a snapshot of what I observe, so there will be gaps and oversimplifications. I encourage you to cross-check with more in-depth sources.</p><h4>For the U.S., it’s defense &amp; deterrence above all</h4><p>During one of the discussion sessions, I snapped this photo:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WQWAxvVetQNVyN9kzrRU2g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Zoom into Southeast Asia, and you could see differing U.S-China favorability among ASEAN nations, with the Philippines leaning towards the U.S.</figcaption></figure><p>Blue indicates countries with favorable views of the U.S., while red shows countries leaning toward China. Zoom into Southeast Asia and you’ll see a region straddling two giants. Unsurprisingly, Southeast Asia isn’t unified in its stance: countries with territorial proximity to the South China Sea or Taiwan Strait – like the Philippines – are “blue,” while those further removed – like Indonesia – tend to be “red.”</p><p>Why? I asked this directly to some of the panelists during my one-on-one interactions of them. Again, a <strong>caveat</strong>: Southeast Asia alignment is fluid and issue-specific; many states pursue “multi-vector” hedging rather than a single camp, but this color-code oversimplification helps us understand latest tensions.</p><p>Here’s what emerged:</p><p><strong>First</strong>, the U.S., under the current administration, seems to begin – and end – with defense and deterrence. Not trade, investment, or even conceptual frameworks such as promulgating democratic values. Defense. In the Philippines, the U.S. has offered strong support amid tensions with China in the South China Sea and Taiwan Strait. Their interest seems to be tightly focused on key chokepoints. Areas without immediate naval relevance – like parts of Indonesia – receive less attention. This reflects broader U.S. posture in the Indo-Pacific: trimming budgets for education and foreign affairs, while ramping up spending on jets, ships, and <a href="https://www.wsj.com/world/asia/nmesis-missile-system-us-china-pacific-ce7e1f7c?gaa_at=eafs&amp;gaa_n=ASWzDAhtx-hSpb1JFrDmmhOSlt0tP_6CJ2Qn5Vvu3VE0DHWKRsTxyTx2JKlR5aRL0W0%3D&amp;gaa_ts=6834bc33&amp;gaa_sig=YTK_V3MfS1WHiEP_rlb5W6kxr3bhL3YIpI8VOgmnvFMZLcNsm5T0t0JpxM5KdZAMAQF22-10sE2-XwMmbLVxAg%3D%3D">artilleries for military deterrence</a>. President Trump underscored this during his commencement speech at West Point this week.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MNW2GX6pR6jb7-Tb9TZV-A.png" /><figcaption>In its latest defense posture, U.S. has placed troops and artilleries at the Batanes Islands in the Philippines, a few kilometers away from the Taiwan Strait. Photo taken from the Financial Times.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Second</strong>, China’s Belt and Road Initiative plus ramp up in their economic diplomacy efforts is bearing fruit. With the possible exception of the Philippines, China remains ASEAN’s largest and most consistent trade and investment partner. Consider Indonesia: our top export and import relationships are dominated by China. Nothing new here, but thought about reiterating how important the China relationship is for us:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/847/1*Yu7Q3iYQx0RUjBA1crF07Q.png" /><figcaption>Indonesia’s top 5 trading partners — Comtrade data. U.S. remains Indonesia’s top partner, but relationship from the investment and economic fronts seem to stagnate.</figcaption></figure><p>Economic favorability follows tangible economic relationships. When I spoke with delegates in the conference, the consensus was clear: China is addressing Southeast Asia’s economic challenges in a <strong>very concrete way</strong> – offering real capital to bridge the middle-income trap, close the per capita income gap, and ease funding scarcity. China brings more checks, fewer checklists. By contrast, U.S. policies – America First, USAID withdrawals, rising tariffs, JETP revocatoins – create an economic vacuum that China has swiftly moved to fill.</p><p>And this China – Southeast Asia relationship is accelerating. Fast.</p><p>Take Indonesia: since our recent entry into BRICS, we’ve had multiple high-level exchanges with China. <a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/for-danantara-indonesias-900bn-sovereign-fund-i-choose-hope-245c8039ca7d">Danantara</a>, our newly formed sovereign wealth fund, visited Beijing last week to discuss cooperation. Soon after, Premier Li Qiang, China’s second-highest-ranking official, visited Indonesia, and <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-05-25/china-indonesia-sovereign-wealth-funds-boost-investment-ties">Bloomberg</a> pointed out that China Investment Corporation and Danantara are close to striking an agreement. To me, these are not symbolic gestures – they’re strategic realignments.</p><h4>Is the U.S. losing Southeast Asia?</h4><p>The U.S. strategy – focusing heavily on defense via the Philippines while deprioritizing broader economic or social cooperation – may make sense for now. But in the long term, I doubt it.</p><p>While Southeast Asia is <em>very serious </em>in its approach to geopolitical tension non-alignment since the World Wars, this may change if the U.S. increasing vacuum remains, intended or unintended. Countries like Indonesia already view China as their key partner. Not just because of ideology, but because of tangible, long-term investment and trade support. Unless the U.S. recalibrates its Southeast Asia playbook, it risks further ceding ground in a region that is pivotal to the future of global trade, energy, and diplomacy.</p><p>A few months ago, <a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/america-must-prioritize-indonesia-f737614b6946">I wrote about why the U.S. should prioritize Indonesia</a> – not out of charity, but for its own strategic gain. Defense-first might be the U.S. bet today. But I wonder if America First should also put economic relationships at the forefront of foreign policy, especially with its Southeast Asian allies. Quoting Singapore’s Prime Minister Lawrence Wong, during his <a href="https://www.pmo.gov.sg/Newsroom/Ministerial-Statement-by-PM-Lawrence-Wong-on-the-US-Tariffs-and-Implication">speech</a> addressing the Singaporean parliament post U.S.’ ‘Liberation Day’ (which included imposing blanket tariffs on Singapore, despite it running a trade surplus with the U.S.):</p><blockquote>“<strong>We are very disappointed by the US move (i.e. tariffs)</strong>, especially considering the deep and longstanding friendship between our two countries. <strong>These are not actions one does to a friend.</strong>“— Singapore’s Prime Minister Lawrence Wong</blockquote><h4>My latest thesis on U.S., China, and Southeast Asia</h4><p>I’m leaving Stanford soon. It’s been fun dabbling in geopolitics while studying tech, entrepreneurship, and investing at the business school over the past year. With that, let me leave here my latest thesis on Southeast Asia’s view of China and the U.S.</p><p><em>What I think most Southeast Asians see China:</em></p><ol><li>History. Admiration for its hundreds of years of civilization-building efforts and rise to power;</li><li>Economics. A committed economic partner — region’s largest trading partner and a critical source of FDI;</li><li>Policy continuity. Willingness to offer practical, concrete assistance; with or without strings attached.</li></ol><p><em>What I think most Southeast Asians see the U.S.:</em></p><ol><li>Soft power. Admiration for its innovation (i.e. silicon valley), culture (i.e. Hollywood), values tied to freedom, and higher ed (perhaps less now, given the latest drama with Harvard and international student deportations?);</li><li>Defense. Strong security partner, with national defense spend close to $900bn per year;</li><li>Policy uncertainty. Engagement with Southeast Asia seen as episodic — political-party dependent.</li></ol><p>Last point from me: some may argue the U.S. retains major economic clout or that China’s financing carries hidden costs. Both views have merit. Concerns about BRI-linked debt distress and transparency remain real. Yet the sheer velocity and top-down coordination of Chinese capital tilt the near-term balance.</p><p><strong>The question is <em>not</em> who dominates absolutely, but who is scaling influence faster — and on which fronts. To me, that dynamic tension, not a binary choice, is the region’s new normal.</strong></p><p>As always – onwards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7Cp9q_l2oZLOzwqV" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@ktabori?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Krisztian Tabori</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=382bccf2da1f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Danantara, Indonesia’s New Sovereign Fund]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guinandra/for-danantara-indonesias-900bn-sovereign-fund-i-choose-hope-245c8039ca7d?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/245c8039ca7d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sovereign-wealth-funds]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[danantara]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Apr 2025 05:49:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-14T09:28:49.428Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Achieving bold nation-building goals requires executing bold bets</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zQ2JpWXhder1_dj9nOznOw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Officiating Danantara Indonesia. Taken from Reuters.</figcaption></figure><p><em>If you don’t have time to read, here’s the TL;DR: Indonesia’s newly launched $900bn+ sovereign fund, Danantara, has sparked intense debate. While I understand the skepticism — from corruption fears to concerns about redundancy and governance — I argue that Danantara, if executed well, could be a rare and necessary bet to address Indonesia’s long-term challenges. I’m not saying it’s a silver bullet. But I am saying it’s a bet worth placing — for durable investment inflows, for income growth, and for Indonesia’s future.</em></p><p>Indonesia recently established a $900bn+ sovereign wealth fund called Danantara, and from where I’m typing this — Jakarta, where I’m spending my spring break — there’s palpable criticism behind it. One of the loudest international voices that is being forwarded around family WhatsApp groups is an article from the <a href="https://asiatimes.com/2025/03/danantara-indonesias-ticking-financial-time-bomb/">Asia Times</a>.</p><p>As an Indonesian who deeply cares about my country and its people, I feel strong sympathy for those critical voices against setting up a $900bn+ Temasek-inspired financial behemoth. I get the pessimism — corruption, authoritarian control, etc. I’m with you. At this stage, my friends at Stanford are probably tired of me raising my hand in class to (yet again) talk about Southeast Asia’s potential democratic decline, or about why I strongly feel that <a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/america-must-prioritize-indonesia-f737614b6946">Indonesian diplomats should be much more assertive</a> in establishing our relevance in a rules-based international order, as the world’s 3rd largest democracy — I repeat, 3rd largest democracy — and the largest Muslim country in the world.</p><p>My friends call me “concerned about Indonesia’s economy, but optimistic about Danantara’s mission.”</p><p>My stance on Danantara Indonesia is the following:</p><blockquote>Danantara Indonesia may not, and will not, be a panacea or a silver bullet for the economic challenges Indonesia will face in the next decade, but it is a necessary vehicle to have.</blockquote><p>Achieving bold nation-building goals requires executing bold bets.</p><h3>The long-term economic challenges we’re facing as a nation</h3><p>Indonesia has been growing steadily (5% YoY, GDP), but this may not last long if we don’t put appropriate policies in place. To try convincing you why Danantara is among the key policies Indonesia <em>must</em> adopt, let me start with what Indonesia may look like if we just keep the status quo. I don’t mean for this section to be deliberately depressing or to fearmonger. I just want to begin by stating the facts.</p><p>Let’s begin by looking at labor productivity, capital efficiency, and technological adoption, which are the drivers of long-term income growth (A + K + L).</p><h4>First, on labor (L): We’re getting older — and our education system hasn’t yet helped us become significantly more productive.</h4><p>Our median age is now around 30–31 years old, and by 2045, we’ll be around 38. That’s pretty old. If you’re reading this, chances are you’re already tired of hearing the phrase <a href="https://rsis.edu.sg/rsis-publication/idss/ip25021-avoiding-the-strategic-traps-in-indonesias-pursuit-of-high-income-status/">“middle income trap.”</a> A friend once joked that the ‘middle income trap’ is just a technical way of saying ‘old and broke’ — and while that’s an oversimplification, it captures the urgency of our situation</p><p>On average, an Indonesian adult is less productive than counterparts in many neighboring countries. Collective intelligence serves as a proxy for productivity: there’s plenty of data to back up where we stand, but let’s use PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment) scores. Our Singaporean counterparts’ <em>kiasu</em>-ness has paid off, making them good not only at counting things, but at digesting readings and communicating them in writing, which signals clarity of thought. Indonesians, meanwhile, are among the lowest quartile of PISA rankings, grouped with countries like the Philippines and Cambodia. Not only that: our average IQ is quite low, compared to Japan, Korea, and the US. These gaps are exacerbated by poor childhood nutrition, which leads to stunted physical and cognitive growth; Indonesia’s rate of stunting is around c.20%.</p><p>Here’s a slide I took from former Minister of Investment / Minister of Trade of Indonesia,<a href="https://aparc.fsi.stanford.edu/people/gita-wirjawan"> Gita Wirjawan</a>, who also happened to be a fellow at Stanford:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UcF-GwJrKEm1z28SSBp-LQ.png" /><figcaption>Not only are we getting older; we’re not getting any smarter. Taken from Gita Wirjawan’s presentation at Stanford.</figcaption></figure><h4>Second, on capital (K): capital flows to Indonesia hasn’t been productive.</h4><p>My chosen metric for this is the Incremental Capital-Output Ratio (ICOR) — basically how much investment is needed to produce one unit of additional output. Indonesia’s ICOR is around 5–6, compared to Vietnam and China at around 4. The higher the ICOR, the less efficient a country is at turning investments into growth. This simply means capitalists might think twice (or outright ignore us) when deciding where to allocate money in Southeast Asia.</p><h4>Third, on tech (A): tech transfer has been limited.</h4><p>Our entrepreneurial friends at Indonesia-born tech companies (Gojek, Tokopedia, Bukalapak) did manage to bring in global investors like GIC (my former employer) and Sequoia back when interest rates were near zero (pre-2022), introducing new tech like cloud computing and 10x software engineering. But once capital started fleeing from Indonesia as global rates rose — and some local founders faked revenues and committed fraud (e.g., <a href="https://www.techinasia.com/efishery-confirms-alleged-fraud-fti-consulting-takes">eFishery</a>, <a href="https://www.businesstimes.com.sg/international/asean/indonesias-investree-plunges-crisis-licence-revoked-amid-fraud-allegation">Investree</a>) — foreign tech investors got spooked. They seem done with us, at least for the time being. Try calling an investor friend in Singapore and ask them if their team covering Southeast Asia, particularly Indonesia, is still as active as they were in 2015–2021.</p><p>At Stanford, when we talk about AI, we talk about being agents to catapult AI forward: developing new models, building AI-native companies. In Jakarta, these conversations mostly happen among a small circle of economic and intellectual elites in places like SCBD or Senopati — leaving much of the population out of the dialogue. So, on tech transfers:</p><ul><li>Businesses: known to be highly cautious and cost-conscious in implementing new systems, barring critical needs, especially as labor is much cheaper. To illustrate, in Singapore, you see a lot of fruit vending machines. In Indonesia, they prefer to hire 3 people to run a fruit juice stall. So unless a foreign tech partner comes in and bring new technology (think Malaysia semis, Korea/Japan machineries, Vietnamese manufacturing), existing businesses are unlikely to tech-transform themselves meaningfully without a catalyst.</li><li>Consumers: forget about leading AI developments; even being an active AI consumer is challenging for the average Indonesian. Ninety percent (90%) of Indonesians earn around $200–300 per month, while ChatGPT Pro subscriptions cost $200+ a month. Nobody here is going to ditch a month’s worth of food for advanced AI tools.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LLYK1dWeHvMHHk4MGrrj1Q.png" /><figcaption>Telling an Indonesian consumer to spend $200 per month on ChatGPT pro io, that allows deep research, or even use productivity tools to help them do their work is too much of an ask if the labor base makes $250 per month. Taken from Lightspeed’s presentation, here: <a href="https://lsvp.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Southeast-Asia-Resetting-Expectations-1.pdf">https://lsvp.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Southeast-Asia-Resetting-Expectations-1.pdf</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>In sum, here’s our long-term economic challenge: we’re getting older, still not that smart, capital returns are capped, and tech progress is stalling. If you send this sentence to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solow%E2%80%93Swan_model">Robert Solow</a>, he’d likely say, “Yeah, this is a tough one.”</p><h3>Indonesia’s economy through a simplified macroeconomic lens</h3><p>Let’s see how all this translates into a simplified macro lens: consumption, investment, government spending, and net exports.</p><p><strong>Consumption. </strong>Channel News Asia has a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFW5G49eqa8">documentary</a> capturing this well. Our country isn’t just the top 1–10% who earn $thousands per month and can trade stocks at Ashta or Plaza Indonesia. We’re diverse, and a massive chunk of us spend around $150–400 per month. That’s our so-called middle class. The number of people in this bracket recently dropped from about 50 million to 45 million, meaning the majority of Indonesians are earning less, and inequality may widen. Unemployment is stable at around 5–6%, but this includes those working meager hours for low pay. The formal employment rate — often a better proxy for spending power — has been declining. If people aren’t working and getting sufficient income, it’s a stretch to rely on consumption to power the economy, unless we turn much more consumptive as a society and save less.</p><p><strong>Investment. </strong>Out of the roughly $200bn that pours into Southeast Asia, Indonesia only gets around $25–30bn, which is paltry given our population. On a per capita basis, that’s only about $100–150 per head. Many factors contribute to this, but minimal enforcement of the rule of law is a key reason. What’s more pressing is that investments into Indonesia have largely been:</p><ol><li>Hot money portfolio flows (purchases of bonds and stocks), or</li><li>Capital-intensive (not labor-intensive) natural resource projects.</li></ol><p>Relying on these status quo investments to boost the economy doesn’t seem prudent to me.</p><p><strong>Government spending. </strong>We’re capped both fiscally and monetarily.</p><ul><li><em>Fiscally:</em> We’ve kept debt-to-GDP at around 40% to maintain our investment-grade status, so we don’t pay excessive interest that outstrips tax revenues. Our tax collection is among the lowest in the world, at around 9–10% of GDP. It’s not because we apply super-conservative tax rates — our corporate tax is around 20%, personal income tax up to 35%. Rather, many businesses aren’t formal, tax evasion is prevalent, and enforcement is weak. We’re running a deficit near 3% of GDP, which is close to the legal max. Essentially, government revenues are far lower than spending. We can’t just push the government to spend more.</li><li><em>Monetarily:</em> Indonesia is at the behest of the U.S. Federal Reserve. Capital inflows and outflows aren’t durable; any shock (e.g., investors selling rupiah in favor of higher-yielding U.S. assets) can depreciate the rupiah, forcing Bank Indonesia to hike rates. A classic tit-for-tat: if the Fed hikes by X bps, Indonesia may have to hike by Y bps to prevent depreciation — often at the expense of stimulating growth.</li></ul><p><strong>Net Exports. </strong>No new news here: we mostly export commodities. Since the early days of the Republic, commodity prices (palm oil, coal, etc.) have been beyond our control and lead to volatile trade balances. While we recently ran a surplus (because of high commodity prices), it can swing back to a 1–2% deficit when those prices drop. We can’t rely on our exports to consistently boost the economy.</p><p>In summary, from a simplified macroeconomic demand side (C + I + G + NX): we don’t have much disposable income to spend; foreigners prefer easily exited asset classes to long-term bets; the government’s purse is tight; and selling palm oil or coal overseas doesn’t reliably pad the piggy bank.</p><h3>Three (3) reasons why Danantara can be Indonesia’s economic growth engine, if executed right</h3><p>I’m going to admit something here — when I see a potential fix, I tend to lean toward optimism. I’d like to think of myself as an optimistic person. My bosses and my close friends sometimes get confused or annoyed by my bursts of unnecessarily positive energy. I deliberately choose optimism because it’s the easier way to live: that optimism <a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/ai-can-lift-families-out-of-poverty-and-heres-why-12f7cec5a3c4">took me out of a plantation in North Sumatra to winning a life lottery</a> that allows me to write this blog post from a comfortable room, and with more than just a college degree. Most Indonesians typically only get up to 10th grade or high school at best. My parents taught me to hustle, and my military high school taught me not to stand idle when things are factually difficult.</p><p>So when I saw Danantara’s launch, my first instinct was: “This can work out. This could be the thing that pushes Indonesia forward.”</p><p>But I do believe my optimism rests on clear philosophical bases — it’s not blind. Here’s why I think Danantara can be a genuine engine of economic growth.</p><h4>Reason #1: A real shot at “I” in C + I + G + NX equation, which may trickle down to A + K + L.</h4><p>As mentioned, our investment inflows have been fickle. Danantara can solve that by investing billions of dollars into projects that matter. By “matter,” I mean:</p><ul><li><strong>durable, long-term investment</strong> projects that retain money despite external shocks,</li><li>real <strong>job creation in labor-intensive </strong>industries,</li><li><strong>returns</strong> at least at or above inflation,</li><li>ability to <strong>attract foreign capital </strong>to spur talent and tech transfer.</li></ul><p>A diluted, simplified example to illustrate:</p><ul><li><strong><em>Status quo</em></strong>: A short-term investor in New York spends $100m buying an Indonesian bank’s stock on the secondary market. One morning, they see a “President Trump evaluating tariffs on Southeast Asia” headline and exit the Indonesia position after holding for a year. It’s an oversimplified snapshot of how capital can flee upon any “bad” news.</li><li><strong><em>With Danantara</em></strong>: Danantara’s team, after thorough diligence, concludes that building a 100MW data center (about $1bn, assuming $10m per MW) makes financial sense over a 10-year horizon if a foreign co-investor joins. Suppose they succeed in bringing in $500m from Danantara and $500m from external partners, building it in Batam (near Singapore). The capital stays in Indonesia for 10 years (generating annual dividends), we import the know-how of advanced data center tech, and local Batam residents get employed. That beats the status quo from a long-term growth perspective.</li></ul><p>Danantara’s team explained in the media that Danantara’s trifecta mandate is: (1) make money, (2) create jobs, and (3) bring in capital that enables tech transfer. Based on publicly available info, they plan to do this across renewables (we still have the world’s largest geothermal potential), agriculture (we have so much unoptimized farmland), aquaculture (we should be a net exporter of maritime products), and more.</p><p>Goldman Sachs actually released a report outlining Indonesia’s potential competitive advantages, sectors that Danantara may consider delving deeper into:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PiW0EpPnNtoSC0rIWSK5gw.png" /><figcaption>Sectors where Indonesia may have a competitive advantage vis-a-vis other countries once they’re vertically integrated (upstream-downstream). Taken from Goldman Sachs.</figcaption></figure><p>I’m not saying Danantara’s team will succeed from day 1. Investing to make money is already tough. Investing to make money, create jobs, attract foreign partners, and facilitate tech transfer — like how Korea evolved from poverty to exporting heavy machinery, or how Japan rose from the ashes of WWII to produce advanced weapons and tanks for NATO — is even harder.</p><p>But this is exactly the bet Indonesia must make — there’s no other choice.</p><h4>Reason #2: food security for Indonesia, in a decoupling world.</h4><p>As countries rapidly decouple from one another — <a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/u-s-china-views-from-stanford-0ba7c94a2cd6">U.S. vs. China, plus weakening trade relationships across regions </a>— food security becomes paramount. During trade wars, any country should be able to feed itself, regardless of whether commodities are its competitive advantage.</p><p>Despite the folklore that Indonesia’s land is so fertile that anything grows if you toss seeds on the ground, the reality is that we’re a net importer of many daily staples. Here’s a list based on publicly available data:</p><blockquote>In 2023, Indonesia was the world’s biggest importer of <a href="https://oec.world/en/profile/hs/raw-sugar">Raw Sugar</a> ($2.85B), <a href="https://oec.world/en/profile/hs/soybean-meal">Soybean Meal</a> ($2.6B), <a href="https://oec.world/en/profile/hs/rice">Rice</a> ($1.76B)… — OEC World</blockquote><p>Sugar. Soybean. Rice. For a country extolled for its agricultural potential, this is worrisome. Many people blame corruption for this. For instance, there’s an ongoing investigation related to sugar import corruption charges. I won’t weigh in on whether this is a witch hunt or if the entire trade ministry is corrupt. What I do want to emphasize is that we don’t even produce enough sugar domestically to sweeten our own tea.</p><p>No single policy can fix this alone — it requires cross-coordination between public and private sectors. But my take is Danantara could be the most concrete conduit to start fixing it through targeted, long-term agricultural investments. When I say “long-term,” I mean 10+ years, possibly permanent capital. Danantara could buy farmland or companies that own farmland, attract foreign capital, adopt new technologies to improve yields, and employ both foreign specialists and local workers. If done well, it’s not impossible.</p><p>One might ask, “Will it make money? If private investors saw this opportunity, wouldn’t they have done it?” In theory, yes — it can be profitable, which is why we’re a massive palm oil exporter. In practice, recent private agricultural ventures messed up. For example, Tanihub (digitalizing agricultural supply chains) and eFishery (supposedly innovating in fish feed) each <a href="https://www.techinasia.com/visual-story/key-players-indonesias-agritech-map-falter-funding-falls">found themselves in trouble</a>, one due to entry into lending to farmers, the other due to revenue fraud. These incidents spooked venture capitalists, so now if you mention “agritech” in Singapore’s VC circles, maybe 1 out of 100 is willing to take a contrarian view.</p><p>So if Danantara pours money into agriculture and executes well, it not only stands to make money, create jobs, and enable tech transfer, but also signals to the world that eFishery’s fiasco was a venture risk, not a condemnation of Indonesia’s entire agricultural sector. Danantara effectively says, “Don’t conflate a single startup’s fraud with the entire country’s long-term viability.”</p><h4>Reason #3: SOE reform.</h4><p>You probably know Danantara has two holding companies under it: an investment arm (led by the CIO, financed by SOE dividends) and an operating arm (led by the COO) that consolidates SOEs under one roof.</p><p>From the news and interviews, it’s clear the operating arm’s goal is to corporatize Indonesian SOEs. Corporatizing doesn’t necessarily mean listing them publicly. It means making them run like private companies through reforms:</p><ol><li>Shutting down historically loss-making SOEs;</li><li>Restructuring SOEs with haphazard business lines;</li><li>Merging similar SOEs to extract synergies and reduce bloat;</li><li>Instituting private-sector-style governance (3–5 board members, not 15).</li></ol><p>Yes, this is painful. Danantara’s team through their interviews mention that they may close down hundreds of SOEs and reduce board memberships from around 12 per SOE to around 5. This saves real money at the expense of the political patrons who benefited from bloated boards.</p><p>Has this been done before? Yes, in Indonesia and China.</p><ul><li><em>Indonesia:</em> In the past few decades, the ministry elevated SOEs to a higher-tier status, from 2nd echelon to under the Ministry of SOE (higher echelon, with more professional management). We can do more; we still have room to improve. Danantara’s corporatization effort is the next step.</li><li><em>China: </em>I learned this from <a href="https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/faculty-research/faculty/zhiguo-he">Prof. Zhiguo He </a>last quarter, when I took his class at Stanford. Under Premier Zhu Rongji, they had “grasping the big and letting go of the small, 抓大放小” reforms in the late 1990s. About 60% of Chinese SOEs were losing money in 1998, but after a decade of painful reforms, there were fewer, more profitable SOEs. Danantara-like entities in China called SASAC and Central Huijin now holds these assets. Under President Xi Jinping, some are even partially privatized with mixed-ownership structures.</li></ul><p>If executed right, Danantara can continue Indonesia’s SOE reforms along a path somewhat parallel to China’s success story, albeit under a democracy.</p><h3>Six (6) valid concerns about Danantara, and my responses to them</h3><p>My high school debate coach would be upset if I ended my case for Danantara here without addressing potential rebuttals. So here itgoes.</p><h4>Concern #1: Corruption</h4><blockquote>“Centralizing $900bn+ directly under the President will inevitably lead to corruption and conflicts of interest. Look at 1MDB (Malaysia) and Libya’s sovereign fund.”</blockquote><p>This concern is valid — trust in government is generally low these days, and corruption is a serious issue. But calling Danantara “1MDB 2.0”, in my view, is lazy. Direct supervision by the President doesn’t automatically mean an authoritarian grip. Ministries are also “under the President,” but Danantara has a different governance structure:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/534/1*2_YVLwyJOztitEvUVkwjZw.png" /><figcaption>Danantara’s governance structure, taken from Republika.</figcaption></figure><p>To me, the official structure appears professional. There are clear demarcations of responsibilities, plus check-and-balance committees. None of the key players are from political parties. There are police and corruption eradication officials involved, but these are likely there to boost public trust because Danantara deals with state assets, and to reassure the public that the government is taking accountability very seriously.</p><p>If executed right, Danantara could function like a proper global investment firm or sovereign fund.</p><p><strong>Lets use a hypothetical case study to test this structure. Say, a politically connected person demands Danantara to invest $500m in a copper mining project:</strong></p><ol><li>The global advisory committee (Ray Dalio, Jeffrey Sachs, etc.) would raise eyebrows. <strong>These people don’t want to tarnish their reputations with nepotistic deals</strong>. They signed up to help Danantara unpaid not to get their brand damaged by political moves like these.</li><li>The supervisory committee (various ministers) and accountability committees (police, court justice, <strong>supreme audit agency, corruption eradication commission) would check for irregularities</strong>.</li><li>The private-equity-trained MDs, Directors, VPs, and associates under the Chief Investment Officer doing due diligence wouldn’t just rubber-stamp a poor investment. <strong>They left their lucrative finance careers abroad (Wall Street, Marina Bay, Hong Kong Central) to help Indonesia, not to become puppets. </strong>They might still do the deck and financial model, but begrudgingly. Knowing that their skills are used to advance political motives, I’m sure they’ll start recruiting somewhere else.</li><li><strong>Risk and portfolio committees</strong> with folks like John Prasetio (ex-General Atlantic) and Yup Kim (ex-Calpers, Alaska Permanent Fund) would also review it. They’re smart enough to not let bad portfolio construction materialize under their purview.</li><li><strong>The public would push back</strong> if Danantara made shady investments, especially given current social tensions. They will know this because Danantara has committed to be audited annually just like a public company.</li><li>The CIO, after 20+ years building a global investment career, likely wouldn’t throw it away for nepotism.</li></ol><p>So per the structure, checks and balances exist. Being “directly under the President”, to me, signals seriousness. It doesn’t guarantee no corruption ever, but at least the built-in checks are there.</p><p>Also, including <strong>three statesmen (former President Widodo and Yudhoyono) in Danantara’s highest advisory roles in my view fosters intergenerational policy continuation and support</strong>— if Danantara performs well, it becomes institutionalized and endures beyond one president’s term.</p><h4>Concern #2: Conflict of Interest</h4><blockquote>“People in Danantara will misuse their positions to benefit other institutions they’re affiliated with.”</blockquote><p>None of Danantara’s top leaders are members of a political party. The execution team (CIO, MDs, Directors, etc.) can’t hold other jobs and board memberships. They must quit their prior roles to work for Danantara full time.</p><p>Yes, CEO Rosan Roslani is also the Minister of Investment, which might raise eyebrows. But Danantara’s mission partly hinges on attracting foreign co-investors, which has historically been hindered by slow permits, overlapping regulations, and murky rule of law. Having the Minister of Investment as CEO could streamline those procedures. Abu Dhabi’s sovereign wealth ecosystem uses a similar dual-hat approach; it’s not unprecedented.</p><h4>Concern #3: Imprudent Use of State Finances</h4><blockquote>“You’re taking $5bn+ SOE dividend income per year out of the state budget, weakening government spending power even more.”</blockquote><p>Unlike Norway, Qatar, and the UAE, we don’t have excess cash from massive oil or trade surpluses. We’re running a deficit around 3% of GDP and have a narrower fiscal space given negative trade balance. Twin deficits. So setting up a sovereign fund as a country without excess reserves is a fair concern.</p><p>But consider this: Indonesia’s annual state budget historically is around $200–250bn, with maybe 2–3% of it coming from SOE dividends that is now channeling into Danantara. Would you rather:</p><ol><li>Allocate that money to repaint some regent’s official residence and fund more scholarships for Indonesians who may never return after completing their master’s abroad (if you’re an LPDP awardee thinking of staying overseas permanently and you’re reading this, yes I’m pinching you), <strong>or</strong></li><li>Give the Danantara team a chance to invest it professionally — potentially generating more returns, more jobs, and real foreign tech transfer?</li></ol><p>I’d pick the second option. We’ve had many budgeting experiments, some of which failed. I’m not saying Danantara is a panacea, but it’s at least a new shot worth taking.</p><h4>Concern #4: Redundancy with INA</h4><blockquote>“We already have the Indonesia Investment Authority (INA). Why create another sovereign wealth fund?”</blockquote><p>It’s not unusual for countries to have multiple sovereign funds, each with distinct mandates. Singapore has Temasek and GIC; the UAE has ADIA, Mubadala, G42, etc.; Malaysia has Khazanah, EPF, KWAP, PNB. China has CIC and SAFE. Saudi has PIF and NDF. Australia has Future Fund and QIC.</p><p>So by global precedent alone, having both INA and Danantara coexist is permissible. Also, based on publicly disclosed info, there’s some mandate differences between INA and Danantara:</p><ul><li><strong><em>Holding period</em></strong>: INA typically holds assets for 5–7 years, seeking an exit via IPO or a sale. Danantara can go longer (10+ years) and focus on stable cash yields.</li><li><strong><em>Deal size</em></strong>: INA’s average deal size is ~$50–150m, while Danantara can go bigger if needed. It’s a function of their different assets under management and priorities.</li><li><strong><em>Co-investments:</em></strong> INA can only underwrite their investments subject to foreign co-investors also writing theirs. Danantara is open to going it alone or syndicating.</li><li><strong><em>Talent/tech transfer</em></strong>: INA doesn’t explicitly have a “job creation” or “tech transfer” mandate; Danantara does.</li></ul><p>They serve different objectives. Hence, two separate funds can coexist.</p><h4>Concern #5: Personal Liability Risks</h4><blockquote>“In Indonesian SOEs, if a business decision fails, you can be personally liable.”</blockquote><p>True. This point is debatable, but there have been Indonesian professionals jailed because their decisions yielded negative outcomes for the SOE. Since SOEs aren’t structured like typical LLCs, personal and corporate liabilities can blur.</p><p>In theory, Danantara addresses this via a “business judgment rule” that shields executives from personal liability if decisions were made in good faith, with proper due diligence, and without fraud. <a href="https://indonesiabusinesspost.com/3705/policy-and-governance/house-passes-law-on-state-owned-enterprises">This law was passed last month</a>. So the letter and spirit of the law on this is now aligned.</p><p>In practice, this is still untested in Indonesia. But the laws and internal bylaws for Danantara are meant to create a safer environment for professionals to make legitimate business calls.</p><h4>Concern #6: Stock Market Decline</h4><blockquote>“Danantara caused the Jakarta Composite Index to fall.”</blockquote><p>Claiming a single factor caused a broad index drop is tenuous at best. It’s like saying NVIDIA’s stock fell because AMD appointed new directors. Causality is hard to pin down in stock markets — maybe it was trade-war news, maybe big investors sold for reasons unrelated to Danantara, or maybe global sentiment toward emerging markets shifted. No one knows.</p><p>Here’s also a question for those arguing this point— did Danantara cause a slide on the Thailand (SET), Philippines (PSE), and Malaysia (KLCI) stock indices as well? Or is this mainly foreign investors fleeing out of Southeast Asia, systematically? Here’s a quick chart I created, showing relative performance of these indices over the past 3 months. Indonesia, Thailand, Philippines, and Malaysia have been on the downhill:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/907/1*bQAHWRinUHyK_UObC8HyhA.png" /><figcaption>3-month performance of Indonesia (red), Thailand (green), Philippines (black), and Malaysia (blue) stock indices. All in red territory. Taken from Capital IQ.</figcaption></figure><p>What I know, however, is that Indonesia’s stock market is very shallow (average daily trading value is around $1 billion, far below India that’s double-digit billions). A few top traders can literally move the entire index.</p><h3>Cautious optimism</h3><p>I wrote this post from Jakarta and Singapore, feeling both concerned about Indonesia’s entrenched challenges and hopeful about Danantara’s potential. If you’ve made it this far, you know I don’t think a $900bn+ fund will magically solve our economic challenges. <strong>But having this sovereign fund means a new, structured approach to push capital into areas that could truly change lives — food security, high-tech industries, and job creation.</strong></p><p>On a personal note, I see Danantara as a mirror of my own optimism and deep concern for this country. There’s no shortage of reasons to be pessimistic.</p><p>Still, I’ve chosen to believe in this next leap, hoping that in five, ten, or twenty years, we’ll look back and say: “That’s when Indonesia’s next chapter began.”</p><blockquote><strong>As always, onwards.</strong></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*oJtC7Q-d7GBT76wh" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@iswanto?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Iswanto Arif</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=245c8039ca7d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[5 Insights from CoreWeave’s IPO Filing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/5-insights-from-coreweaves-ipo-filing-cc8f68aa3cf9?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc8f68aa3cf9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-center]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coreweave]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stanford]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[infrastructure]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Mar 2025 02:34:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-14T09:29:49.278Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Key Insights from Coreweave’s IPO Filing</h3><h4>Peeking into the AI datacenter’s S-1 — the first-ever U.S. AI-native company to go public</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XRS19iEBF5Uy6aiJ" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@markusspiske?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Markus Spiske</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>I’ve been writing about AI from the perspective of a student and investor at Stanford GSB. I wrote about Southeast Asia’s potential </em><a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/southeast-asia-can-make-deepseek-85d07e793bad"><em>here</em></a>,<em> and shared my AI personal story in Indonesia </em><a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/ai-can-lift-families-out-of-poverty-and-heres-why-12f7cec5a3c4"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>This weekend, most of my friends are either away on a full-weekend retreat for their <a href="https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/experience/learning/leadership/interpersonal-dynamics">Interpersonal Dynamics (aka the “Touchy Feely”)</a> class or attending/organizing the Women in Management conference. So I’ve decided to spend my Saturday nerding out a bit. While watching clips of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12ysF-2Z6UQ">Luka Dončić</a> singlehandedly boosting the Lakers’ performance, I decided to skim through <a href="https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1769628/000119312525044231/d899798ds1.htm">CoreWeave’s IPO S-1 filing</a>. Online news say that they’re rumored to raise $3.5-$4bn in at valuation of $35bn+ the next 3 months.</p><p>You may not have heard of this AI datacenter company, and that’s normal — it doesn’t sell products or services to customers like you and me. But it’s a fascinating company to watch. Unless I missed something, I don’t think any generative AI companies went public last year. Also, tech IPOs have been on a decline since 2021.</p><blockquote>Given this rarity, CoreWeave’s IPO might set a precedent for how investors evaluate AI-native companies, particularly those in AI infrastructure, moving forward.</blockquote><h4>CoreWho?</h4><p>CoreWeave is an AI datacenter company rebranding and positioning itself as an “AI Hyperscaler” (a term they’ve trademarked in their filing). At the risk of oversimplifying, a datacenter is a physical space filled with racks of servers that store and process data. Before AI took off, big tech companies like Google and Amazon dominated this space, offering cloud services like Google Cloud and AWS. These massive tech firms with extensive datacenter footprints are called hyperscalers.</p><p>Now, an AI datacenter is a specialized datacenter built specifically to train, run, and store AI models. It differs from a standard cloud datacenter in several key ways. It requires a massive number of GPUs, consumes enormous amounts of power, and needs advanced cooling systems to manage the heat generated by high-intensity AI workloads.</p><p>Here’s a screenshot from the IPO filing:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/754/1*pGFVF4Y9aKEGEPLMLZWDCQ.png" /><figcaption>Liquid cooling systems in CoreWeave’s AI datacenter, taken from CoreWeave’s S-1 filing.</figcaption></figure><p>As for CoreWeave’s origins, I haven’t done a deep dive into its history, but I do know it started as a crypto mining operation. It built datacenters to run nodes to mine and stake crypto. Since then, it has pivoted into renting out its datacenter space and computing power to companies running AI models while also expanding beyond simple infrastructure to provide full-stack AI services to clients.</p><h3>5 Key Insights from CoreWeave’s IPO Filing</h3><p>CoreWeave’s filing contains a ton of interesting data points, but if I had to boil it down to<strong> five noteworthy takeaways</strong>, here’s what stood out.</p><ol><li><strong><em>Explosive growth;</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Microsoft’s 60%+ revenue contribution as a client-cum-competitor;</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Debt-fueled expansion to U.S. ally countries;</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>NVIDIA-first;</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Ownership engineering.</em></strong></li></ol><h4>First, explosive growth.</h4><p>Unsurprisingly, CoreWeave has experienced exponential growth at the dawn of AI. Within just 2 years, its <strong>revenue skyrocketed from $16 million to $1.9billion! </strong>This aligns with the broader trend — tech giants like Alphabet and Microsoft are pouring hundreds of billions into AI development, and CoreWeave capturing $1.9 billion of that pie is impressive, even if expected. In its filing, CoreWeave cited a projection that AI will contribute $20 trillion to global GDP by 2030, representing roughly 3.5% of the total economy. The company aims to capture a portion of this market by targeting two types of customers: AI-native companies, such as research labs developing cutting-edge AI models, and large enterprises, like JPMorgan and Walmart, that are integrating AI into their operations.</p><p>Despite its impressive revenue growth, CoreWeave is currently loss-making, a reality not uncommon for companies in capital-intensive industries. Its financials reflect significant expenditures on infrastructure, alongside substantial non-cash D&amp;A expenses and losses related to fair value adjustments on bonds and warrants.</p><p>However, assessing this business solely based on net income might be misleading. Even traditional datacenter companies rely on alternative metrics that adjust for D&amp;A, capex, and asset divestments to get a more accurate picture of their financial health, typically using measures like funds from operations (FFO) and adjusted FFO (AFFO).</p><h4>Second, Microsoft is the largest client (and competitor).</h4><p>A particularly striking detail from the filing is CoreWeave’s significant customer concentration, with <strong>Microsoft as its largest client, accounting for 62% of its revenues. But what makes this even more interesting is that Microsoft is also listed as a competitor — a rare disclosure in IPO filings.</strong> This dual dynamic presents a potential long-term risk. While CoreWeave currently benefits from Microsoft’s business, the tech giant has the resources to build its own AI datacenters, potentially eliminating the need for CoreWeave’s services in the future.</p><p>Large-scale initiatives like Project Stargate suggest that hyperscalers may eventually move away from third-party infrastructure providers. Companies like Meta are already taking steps in this direction, retrofitting old cloud datacenters with NVIDIA GPUs, upgrading cooling systems from air to water-based, and using these facilities exclusively for their own AI models. Here’s a snapshot of Meta rebuilding their datacenters in-houes from scartch, taken from <a href="https://semianalysis.com/2024/10/14/datacenter-anatomy-part-1-electrical/">SemiAnalysis</a>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F4Yx3SeIWRoqFRqTw14Kvg.png" /><figcaption>Pictures from SemiAnalysis.com, showing Meta revamping its cloud-focused datacenters to purpose-build them as AI datacenters.</figcaption></figure><p>However, not every company might follow Meta’s path. While tech giants like Microsoft and Meta may develop their own AI infrastructure, enterprises lacking in-house datacenter capabilities will likely continue to rely on CoreWeave. That said, the risk is real — over half of CoreWeave’s revenue currently depends on a single customer.</p><h4><strong>Third, debt-fueled expansion to western markets only.</strong></h4><p>CoreWeave is expanding at an aggressive pace, rapidly building a footprint of 32 new datacenters with a total power capacity of 1.3 gigawatts (that’s power close to 1–2 nuclear power plants). What makes this expansion particularly noteworthy is how it’s being financed — through a significant amount of GPU-backed debt (use actual physical GPUs as collateral). As of the filing, the company holds $8 billion+ in debt, with interest payments alone reaching $360 million. Shareholder equity is negative. This level of financial leverage speaks to the scale and ambition of its growth strategy.</p><p>Geographically, CoreWeave is focusing its expansion on regions aligned with U.S. strategic interests. The new datacenters are all located in what are considered Tier-1 U.S. allies, primarily in the European Union and the United Kingdom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iyMK5ZcgHOi5o4sMyvKq6A.png" /><figcaption>Choosing the western side of the AI race; taken from CoreWeave’s S-1 filing</figcaption></figure><p>While the company doesn’t explicitly state why these regions were chosen, the rationale seems clear. Beyond the availability of power and AI talent, the geopolitical backdrop plays a crucial role. With increasing U.S.-China tensions, aligning itself with U.S. allies likely positions CoreWeave as a preferred AI infrastructure partner for Western enterprises. Given the current state of geopolitics, it’s hard to imagine CoreWeave expanding into Southeast Asia or other regions classified as Tier-2 or Tier-3 in the U.S. AI diffusion framework anytime soon:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/910/1*4Hzs1ZHQos4jjzUrFYxZRg.png" /><figcaption>CoreWeave might stick to the green Tier-1 countries: <a href="https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/perspectives/PEA3700/PEA3776-1/RAND_PEA3776-1.pdf">https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/perspectives/PEA3700/PEA3776-1/RAND_PEA3776-1.pdf</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Fourth, unfettered loyalty to Jensen Huang.</h4><p>A major factor in CoreWeave’s business model is its dependence on NVIDIA. AI datacenters require vast amounts of processing power, and right now, NVIDIA’s GPUs are the dominant choice. In the filing, CoreWeave disclosed that it has 250,000+ NVIDIA GPUs and is among the first to deploy new NVIDIA models.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/jensen-is-a-great-guy-ceo-of-amd-41c784458887">Last month, I attended a talk at Stanford by Lisa Su, where she spoke about AMD’s advancements in AI GPU technology</a>. Naturally, I ctrl+f CoreWeave’s filing for mentions of “AMD” or “Intel” to see if they were diversifying suppliers, but found nothing.</p><p>This dependence on NVIDIA poses both a risk and an advantage. On one hand, any disruption in NVIDIA’s supply chain or pricing strategy could significantly impact CoreWeave’s operations. On the other hand, as long as AI adoption continues to grow at its current pace, NVIDIA’s dominant position in the AI chip market suggests that CoreWeave will remain well-equipped to support its customers’ needs. Unless there’s an unexpected slowdown in AI adoption — which seems unlikely at this stage — CoreWeave’s reliance on NVIDIA may not be a deal-breaker.</p><h4>Fifth, ownership engineering.</h4><p>This is the fun part. CoreWeave’s founders — ex-hedge fund guys — pulled some interesting financial moves before the IPO:</p><ol><li>They sold around $500 million worth of shares at a $23billion valuation to Fidelity just months before filing, essentially turning their ownership to near single digit %; and then,</li><li>They created super shares with 10x voting power, effectively establishing a dual-class structure, with 80%+ voting power!</li></ol><p><strong>Translation: before going public, the founders cashed out big, then created special voting shares to retain control post-IPO!</strong></p><p>This is a unique founder-friendly move, but investors have historically scrutinized such setups in past tech IPOs. Will CoreWeave’s market dominance outweigh governance concerns? We’ll see.</p><p>One last interesting note — the founders admitted to past financial control problems in their filing. You don’t see that often from U.S. companies aiming for a $35 billion+ valuation.</p><h4>Caveats.</h4><p>None of this is investment advice, and I haven’t built a full thesis on how CoreWeave might perform during and after its IPO. But it’s undoubtedly a fascinating company to watch.</p><p>Wishing CoreWeave’s team — and its pre-IPO investors — the best of luck.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc8f68aa3cf9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/5-insights-from-coreweaves-ipo-filing-cc8f68aa3cf9">5 Insights from CoreWeave’s IPO Filing</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Southeast Asia Can Make DeepSeek]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/southeast-asia-can-make-deepseek-85d07e793bad?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85d07e793bad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stanford]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[silicon-valley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[southeast-asia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[deepseek]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Feb 2025 22:59:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-08T22:59:29.174Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Singapore, Malaysia, and the Philippines as an AI Tri-Force</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vt0ea6-yj6kYsueV" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@space_launch_system?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Andy Wang</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>This piece is part of my “Southeast Asia AI” series, where I study how Southeast Asia can be enablers — not just mere consumers — of the global AI boom, from Stanford University. I wrote a piece on Indonesia last month </em><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/ai-can-lift-families-out-of-poverty-and-heres-why-12f7cec5a3c4"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>When DeepSeek R1, the Chinese challenger to GPT-4 made by a hedge fund whose day job isn’t even to build AI models (I’m still amazed by this), was released two weeks ago, panic ensued. Billions of dollars in market value were wiped out overnight as U.S. AI stocks tumbled. Silicon Valley investors started questioning Stargate, the ambitious $500bn+ project initiated by U.S. hyperscalers and President Trump. Startup term sheets have reportedly been halted.</p><p>From where I’m sitting at Stanford — a campus buzzing with AI chatter — people are asking what exactly U.S. labs have been doing wrong.</p><p>Some folks now believe DeepSeek proves that AI doesn’t belong exclusively to those with deep pockets or political clout. After all, Liang Wenfeng and his genius hedge fund team at High Flyer managed to build it with only $6m, which is a fraction of the usual $100m+ thrown at large-scale AI models. I mean, just look at what DeepSeek can do with a smaller budget:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/964/1*HUVrjtA7gq1a2XUVydATeQ.png" /><figcaption>DeepSeek R1 performs in line with, if not better than, Open AI’s models. Snapshot taken from their paper, downloadable here: <a href="https://arxiv.org/pdf/2501.12948">https://arxiv.org/pdf/2501.12948</a></figcaption></figure><p>A subset of observers, including prominent investors like a16z and even some backers of OpenAI, are calling this<strong> a “Sputnik moment.”</strong> They recall how the Soviet Union’s launch of Sputnik spurred the United States into a full-blown space race, eventually culminating in landing on the Moon. In this view, DeepSeek’s emergence is a similar wake-up call: a competing superpower — China — has shown it can build formidable AI at lower cost, so everyone else must respond by doubling down on innovation.</p><p>Ironically, the panic around DeepSeek might actually heighten the demand for AI rather than tamp it down. As models become more capable, people inevitably want <strong><em>more</em></strong> of them. They’ll order more GPUs, build more data centers, and hire more AI talent. It’s a classic example of <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/planet-money/2025/02/04/g-s1-46018/ai-deepseek-economics-jevons-paradox">Jevons’ paradox:</a> when technology or resources become cheaper and more accessible, consumption can go up instead of down.</p><p>I agree with that viewpoint.</p><h3>Southeast Asia Can Join The AI Model Race, if It Chooses To</h3><p>As someone from Southeast Asia, I can’t help but wonder if we, too, can participate as a true enabler of AI — and maybe even create the next DeepSeek. <strong>My investor instincts say that the monetary incentives are obviously not there.</strong> After all, the model layer could be commoditized in the long run, with moats going to whoever has the most proprietary data — poking Open AI, who’s <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2025/01/05/openai-is-losing-money-on-its-pricey-chatgpt-pro-plan-ceo-sam-altman-says/">charging $200 a month</a> on my credit card bill monthly to charge for my use of o1-pro. Plus, a lot of the cutting-edge models end up open-sourced anyway.</p><p>But purely from a theoretical standpoint, is it <strong><em>possible</em></strong> for Southeast Asia to build its own DeepSeek?</p><p>After studying the region and talking to a few AI and Southeast Asia experts here in Silicon Valley, I’ve come to a preliminary conclusion that if Singapore, Malaysia and the Philippines want to do it, we might just have enough synergy to make it feasible. Here’s why:</p><blockquote>First, Singapore has the money<strong>;</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Second, Malaysia and Singapore have the foundation for AI <strong>infrastructure build-out;</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Third, open-source models</strong> exist to serve as a blueprint.</blockquote><blockquote>Fourth, Philippines can serve as the hub for <strong>data labeling</strong>;</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Fifth, Singapore </strong>can attract the <strong>right talent</strong> to push the research frontier.</blockquote><p>Let’s dive deeper into each.</p><h3>First, Singapore Has the Cash</h3><p>Building an AI model at DeepSeek R1’s scale isn’t cheap. Although headlines say DeepSeek cost a mere $6m to train, <a href="https://semianalysis.com/2025/01/31/deepseek-debates/"><strong>SemiAnalysis thinks the actual figure was more than $2 billion.</strong></a> Here’s their breakdown:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/880/1*-7x0zow_ARvqfuTinBjuWg.png" /><figcaption>From SemiAnalysis, who argues that the $6 million figure represents only the GPU cost for the pre-training run and does not encompass the full expenses involved in model development, such as research and development (R&amp;D) and total cost of ownership (TCO) of the hardware.</figcaption></figure><p>Regardless of the exact amount, funding matters in AI— especially when it comes from governments. The incentive for for-profit companies to build large models is limited, as these models often don’t generate direct revenue. DeepSeek, for instance, is free to use, making it difficult to justify creating a competing model that charges over $200 (like OpenAI does), particularly if Southeast Asia is starting from scratch.</p><p>Thus, I’d argue that governments play a critical role, with a KPI not to particularly make money in the short-term, but to position the country it represents as an AI knowledge center; hawker center valley, if you will.</p><p>And among all the Southeast Asian countries, <strong>Singapore is in the best position financially. </strong>Its sovereign wealth funds — GIC and Temasek — have combined assets under management of over $1 trillion, derived from trade surpluses, dividends from profitable SOEs, and other investments. That’s serious firepower. Other government entities, I believe, are flush with research and development cash too.</p><p>As an ex-GIC investor, of I’m well aware that this isn’t within a sovereign wealth fund’s mandate — but I know folks there are sharp enough to entertain the idea that maybe incubating greenfield projects or start-ups focused on doing AI research is worth exploring. Not directly by them, but by their R&amp;D sister or portfolio companies.</p><p>More importantly, <strong>Singapore is not shy about deploying capital for strategic priorities. Look at </strong><a href="https://news.microsoft.com/en-sg/2024/04/25/govtechs-launchpad-ignites-ai-innovation-across-singapores-public-sector/"><strong>GovTech initiatives or its push for AI</strong></a><strong>,</strong> biotech and fintech in years past. If Singapore’s leadership decides it wants to be an “AI epicenter” in the East, I can see them committing funds quickly — whether to build specialized data centers, subsidize GPU purchases, or stand up new R&amp;D labs.</p><p>Malaysia also has investment capabilities, albeit on a smaller scale. Still, you have major government-linked companies and funds like Khazanah Nasional that could channel substantial capital into AI ventures if there’s enough political will and a compelling ROI.</p><p>Another financial advantage — often overlooked — is that Singaporean or Malaysian entities <strong>don’t necessarily need to cough up billions in new capital to build data centers from zero </strong>— see<strong> </strong>the next section on AI Infrastructure. That’s a big cost saver and a reason to believe the region might be able to shoulder the financial burden of training a model at DeepSeek-level scale.</p><h3>Second, Malaysia and Singapore Have the Potential to Build a Robust AI Infrastructure Base</h3><p>We all know that data centers are the beating heart of AI training and inference. If you don’t have racks upon racks of GPUs (or TPUs) in well-equipped facilities, you won’t get very far. Indeed, even established cloud data centers typically require retrofitting or entirely new builds to accommodate AI’s unique demands — like advanced cooling, high-bandwidth interconnects, and robust power supplies.</p><p><strong>Among Southeast Asian countries, Singapore and Malaysia dominate when it comes to semiconductors.</strong> Their top exports <strong>are</strong> semiconductors. Jensen Huang of NVIDIA and Satya Nadella of Microsoft expressed prioritizing the two countries during their visits to Southeast Asia.</p><p>Semiconductor exports act as proxies, but the graph below shows that Singapore and Malaysia combined rank relatively high globally in data center power consumption (not on par with Virginia or Beijing, but still significant, combined). In fact, Malaysia has been approving new data center parks in Johor, Penang, and Sarawak, while Singapore recently entered a moratorium on new data center construction — albeit with efficiency guidelines.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KeM7SPlXRQSrT4kv.jpg" /><figcaption>Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia’s datacenter power consumption.</figcaption></figure><p>Also, the latest <a href="https://www.gibsondunn.com/bis-lays-groundwork-for-global-and-metered-access-to-frontier-ai-models-and-computing-power-to-train-them/"><strong>U.S. AI diffusion framework still allows Singapore and Malaysia to purchase high-end GPUs</strong></a>, as long as they comply with U.S. re-export rules (Singapore and Malaysia are both categorized under Tier 2, by the U.S. government). This is crucial because it means these countries aren’t automatically excluded from buying next-generation AI chips from the likes of NVIDIA, AMD, or Intel. Datacenters must be repurposed to allow training AI models, and access to these chips are critical. Malaysia and Singapore have the capability to build Johor, Sarawak, or Singapore-based <a href="https://www.coreweave.com/">CoreWeave</a>s or Crusoes: <a href="https://pitchbook.com/news/reports/2024-emerging-space-brief-ai-neoclouds">AI neoclouds</a> / datacenters. It’s pretty promising — you can access an article covering it <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/17/malaysia-emerges-as-asian-data-center-powerhouse-amid-booming-demand.html">here</a>.</p><p>Side note: we shouldn’t ignore that Chinese AI companies and hyperscalers sometimes host their data in Malaysian servers. It’s not impossible to imagine that the DeepSeek team might have leveraged GPU power in Johor. Cross-border tech partnerships — whether with U.S. or Chinese players — already exist here, and that can accelerate AI initiatives if the region chooses to go all-in.</p><h3>Third, Base AI Models Are Free</h3><p>This factor isn’t specific to Malaysia or Singapore, but it’s still critical: <strong>open-source AI models are readily available for anyone to tweak and build upon</strong>. You can do it yourself (assuming you own massive storage spaces that can host 685b parameters!). If you look at Hugging Face, you’ll see DeepSeek R1’s model and tokenized library available for download (though you’ll need hefty compute and storage to do more than basic inference):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EGQ2FRz06q8MipZ4aIpyzA.png" /><figcaption>Webpage SnapShot of DeepSeek-R1’s model card. Access it yourself here: <a href="https://huggingface.co/deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1">https://huggingface.co/deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-R1</a></figcaption></figure><p>This accessibility drastically lowers the barriers to entry for building new AI models. With DeepSeek R1 out in the wild, and the well-known fact that it borrowed heavily from other open-sourced models (notably from Meta’s LLAMA and OpenAI’s earlier research), a research team in Southeast Asia doesn’t need to start from scratch.</p><p>Of course, there’s a chance that as competition heats up between the U.S. and China, big players like Meta might become more guarded about open-sourcing future models. But for now, the foundation is there for anyone with sufficient compute resources and expertise.</p><h3>Fourth, Philippines Can Be the Data Labeling Engine</h3><p>While large language models (LLMs) often rely on unsupervised or self-supervised learning, data labeling is still crucial for refining and validating models to minimize hallucinations and ensure better accuracy.</p><p>Enter <strong>the Philippines, long known as the global hub for Business Process Outsourcing (BPO).</strong> There’s a growing trend of BPO workers pivoting to jobs in data labeling, which is a huge component in modern AI pipelines. Scale AI, a leading AI startup founded in 2016 and based in San Francisco, has even acknowledged how much they rely on Filipino talent for labeling and annotation work.</p><p>It’s true that some sources, including the Washington Post, have exposed rough working conditions, likening it to <strong>a </strong><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/08/28/scale-ai-remotasks-philippines-artificial-intelligence/"><strong>“digital sweatshop.”</strong></a><strong> This, is unacceptable — I wrote a piece related to fighting for dignity in the workplace a few years ago, </strong><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/dignity-co-9c1e8b05989a"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p>But imagine if Southeast Asia could collaborate to create better standards for these labeling operations — fair wages, decent working conditions, career growth. This could provide a sustainable and ethical backbone for data labeling, further fueling AI development in the region.</p><h3>Fifth, Singapore Has the Brains</h3><p>Finally, you need the human capital to design, refine, and turbocharge these models. Quite literally, Meta’s Chief AI Scientist, Yann LeCun — who shares the Turing Award (often called the “Nobel Prize” of computer science) with Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio — led the development of LLaMA. The same goes for OpenAI: Co-founder and Chief Scientist Ilya Sutskever has been instrumental in creating transformative models like GPT-4. While the Philippines has the labor force for labeling and other BPO tasks, Singapore is better positioned for high-level AI R&amp;D.</p><p><strong>Why Singapore? Statistically speaking, on average, it has the highest education levels in Southeast Asia.</strong> Check out these metrics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/925/1*p4j5cq7ri99LJYpRZrlyNw.png" /><figcaption>Singapore has the brains. I took this slide from Indonesia’s Former Minister of Invetment / Trade’s presentation last week in my class (Pak Gita Wirjawan).</figcaption></figure><p>Caveat to readers:</p><ol><li>Fellow non-Singaporeans, please don’t be offended by these generalized metrics. <strong>Indonesians and Laotians can be AI scientists too.</strong> You might be reading this as a Vietnamese who won gold medals in the International Computer Science Olympiad back in high school, or as an Thai currently teaching at a prestigious computer science department. I get it. I’m simply arguing that, on a purely probabilistic basis, Singaporeans might have a slightly higher chance.</li><li>Also, just because there are many smart people in Singapore doesn’t automatically mean they’ll become AI researchers or stay in the country. Top AI talent often migrates to the U.S. (or stay there after graduating), lured by high salaries from tech giants and Palo Alto’s heavenly weather. <strong>Brain drain is real. </strong>You can’t just tell Singaporeans to go home without real incentives.</li></ol><p>That said, Singapore is known for its meritocracy and willingness to invest heavily in talent — from paying government officials the world’s highest salaries to offering substantial grants for research. I know folks at Singapore’s EDB (Economic Development Board) are proactively working to bring top AI researchers back or attract them from abroad. Plus, I’m betting that are plenty of PhDs at NUS, NTU, and even at hedge funds around Marina Bay tinkering with AI technologies, perhaps inspired by the brilliant Chinese team that built DeepSeek.</p><h3>A Cautiously Optimistic Note</h3><p>Singapore, Malaysia, and the Philippines have obvious limits:</p><p><strong>Southeast Asian chips aren’t that advanced yet.</strong> A friend pointed out that Singapore’s semiconductor capabilities are solid but not at the bleeding edge. They can produce chips at <a href="https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/tiny-singapores-chip-hub-retains-big-punch-2024-06-21/#:~:text=The%20new%20factory%20will%20produce,developed%20some%20two%20decades%20ago.">40 nanometers</a> versus NVIDIA’s 2 nanometer designs (in collaboration with TSMC) or SMIC’s 5 nanometers in China (to those unfamiliar with chip design, essentially, the smaller the better). Then again, Singapore doesn’t necessarily need to design its own chips if it can import them from its trading partners.</p><p><strong>Southeast Asian coordination is tough. </strong>Building high-density GPU farms requires massive amounts of water for cooling and stable electricity. Any large-scale Singapore-Malaysia project might hinge on negotiating water and power deals, which is already <a href="https://thediplomat.com/2024/03/singapores-race-to-self-sufficiency-in-malaysia-water-clash/">a historically touchy subject</a>. And while the Philippines can provide data-labeling manpower, that too requires seamless cross-border data flow. We have successful precedents, however. Singapore and Indonesia, for example, are <a href="https://www.ema.gov.sg/news-events/news/media-releases/2024/singapore-indonesia-make-substantive-progress-on-electricity-imports">collaborating on electricity imports</a>, and there’s been a spillover of <a href="https://eastasiaforum.org/2024/08/14/the-singapore-malaysia-indonesia-triangle-can-be-a-data-centre-powerhouse/">Singapore-Johor data centers in SEZs</a>. So, it’s not impossible.</p><p><strong>Southeast Asia might be subject to U.S.-China export control tensions.<br></strong>As AI becomes more strategic, the U.S. might tighten export controls, or China might wall off critical technology. This could complicate procurement of GPUs or transferring massive datasets. But for the moment, Singapore and Malaysia remain relatively free to purchase the necessary hardware (under specific terms).</p><h3><strong>Closing on Hope</strong></h3><p>Despite these challenges, it’s not unimaginable that these countries could work together. ASEAN nations have cooperated before on trade, infrastructure, and education. <strong>Perhaps AI is the next big impetus for regional unity.</strong></p><blockquote>Southeast Asia can do it: (1) the money is there, (2) the infrastructure is in place, (3) open-sourced models exist, (4) the workforce for data labeling is abundant, and (5) there’s a real chance at wooing top-tier AI research talent.</blockquote><p>Does Southeast Asia <strong><em>need</em></strong> to jump headlong into the AI arms race? Of course not. But if it wants to — if it aims to build a DeepSeek-level model or at least become a critical enabler for AI, so the region doesn’t get left behind — it can.</p><p>It might be a long shot for the region to outcompete the U.S. or China at the model layer, but the fundamental pieces are present.</p><p>If PM Lawrence Wong, PM Anwar Ibrahim, and President Bongbong Marcos decide to collaborate, they could lay the groundwork for a uniquely Southeast Asian AI revolution.</p><p>As always, <strong>onwards.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*G2EX4bMiSQV5SSn0" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@raikin?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">sergey raikin</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85d07e793bad" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/southeast-asia-can-make-deepseek-85d07e793bad">Southeast Asia Can Make DeepSeek</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AI Can Lift Families Out of Poverty, and Here’s Why]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/ai-can-lift-families-out-of-poverty-and-heres-why-12f7cec5a3c4?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/12f7cec5a3c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poverty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Jan 2025 01:17:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-16T04:55:26.678Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Reflections on my childhood in a rural Sumatran palm oil plantation</h4><p>People close to me know I grew up in a rural Dutch colonial plantation in Sumatra, Indonesia. My family was low to middle class — not destitute, but we definitely struggled with basics. The place is called Marihat Ulu, which, in local slang, essentially means “Marihat in the far corner of nowhere.” Here’s a quick picture of where Marihat Ulu is:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/894/0*nItzsbhRfhtxIFuf" /></figure><p><em>(If you know Bahasa Indonesia and you’re giggling at the picture above, I understand why. Even Google Maps shows that right next to Marihat Ulu is “Jual beli kambing” (“</em><strong><em>buy and sell goats</em></strong><em>”) and “Hutan Manyangan” (“Manyangan </em><strong><em>Forest</em></strong><em>”). Feels pretty rural even by 2025 standards.)</em></p><p>Despite the slight isolation, childhood was full of adventure. After school — another legacy left by the Dutch — we’d climb a nearby hill, grab my mom’s paddy-rice shaker, and use it like a sled to race down the slope. We’d explore a spooky tombstone and old water towers on another hill–yes, more legacies left by the Dutch, chase dragonflies, and catch tadpoles in a nearby river.</p><p>Before settling in this plantation, I lived in Ames, Iowa, during my father’s PhD years at Iowa State University. After graduating, he turned down a job offer from the UN’s Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) in South Africa out of sheer patriotism — he wanted to serve his home country. I was only a preschooler then, but that short stint in Iowa left a strong impression. I realized there was a life beyond our plantation.</p><p>Once back in Sumatra, I couldn’t shake the memory of Iowa’s grocery stores and English-speaking friends. I’d pester my parents, asking how I could get “back” to that larger world. We had no internet, so my dad would share tales of Iowa whenever we’d walk to our favorite <em>clam</em>-satay stand near a literal gutter (this stuff tasted pretty good by the way — highly recommend <em>clam</em>-satay). He’d paint vivid pictures of a place so different from home. He also taught me that lack of privilege can be a source of power: he had grown up almost dirt-poor in a modest house with a dirt floor but became the first in his village to go to college and earn a PhD in America.</p><p>One day, my father saved up to buy us a massive set of green encyclopedias from a traveling Jakarta salesman — a real splurge for a family on a limited budget. I recall that time it wasn’t really a prudent thing to do, but he valued education that much. I’d read them by the faint light of a kerosene lamp because electricity was intermittent in our corner of Sumatra. Week after week, I’d emerge with a smudge of soot on my nose, but also with new knowledge fueling my curiosity.</p><p>Eventually, I left that plantation. Now, I’m writing these words from Palo Alto. It’s a long way from Iowa, and an even longer way from Marihat Ulu, but I’ve traded the Iowan cornfields for runs along Big Sur, and that’s a pretty good deal in my book.</p><h3>Why This Story, and Why AI Matters</h3><p>I’m not sharing this to brag about escaping a plantation or paying my own way at Stanford. I’m also not dismissing the severity of deep poverty, which includes stunting, lack of clean water, and people living in slums. I’m sharing this to convince you that AI can’t solve everything, but I’m sure it can help address a big piece of the puzzle that lifts individuals — and families — out of tough circumstances. In my experience, there’s a trifecta that makes all the difference, which AI can assist with:</p><blockquote>One, the right to dream big</blockquote><blockquote>Two, disambiguating the path towards that dream</blockquote><blockquote>Three, a stronger nuclear family</blockquote><p>When these three factors come together, it’s amazing what a child can achieve, especially if they’re determined to move beyond their circumstances. AI can help fill these three needs in a way that’s never been possible before.</p><p><strong>First, on the right to dream big.</strong> I was privileged to know there was a world outside the plantation because I’d lived in Iowa. But the average child in a remote village might never see any hint of life beyond their immediate surroundings. AI can bridge that gap. Picture a laptop station in the village council head’s home, connected to Starlink or some other satellite service. Its main function: a simple interface — maybe ChatGPT from Open AI, Claude from Anthropic or another large language model. Qualified volunteers or local teachers could do quarterly visits to give talks, share experiences, and help children ask the AI questions. A curious kid (assisted with someone that’s used a laptop) could type: “What is America like?” “What is Japan?”, “My classmate visited China. What is China?”. They could follow up by generating AI-created videos (i.e. Sora, Runway) or images showing these distant places. Let them iterate and repeat these questions. Suddenly, a child who’s never been outside their village is exposed to a panoramic view of the world. Not just from the movies, which are typically just one-off inspirations. This exposure might spark the same excitement I felt as a child thinking about Iowa.</p><p><strong>Second, disambiguating the path towards that dream.</strong> Back then, my “AI” was that bulky encyclopedia set my dad bought on credit (sorry Dad, still think this was an imprudent use of funds). Libraries matter, but they’re costly and limited by geography. A single laptop with AI, supported by stable internet, can do so much more. Imagine a rural kid who doesn’t speak English, has no money, but wants to travel abroad. They could ask the AI in a laptop stationed at the village council’s house: “I want to see the world. But I don’t speak English, my Mom said don’t day dream, and my family isn’t rich. What can I do?”</p><p>If you’re reading this, you know how good LLMs are these days that they could methodically provide kids with simple next steps. The AI might suggest: learning basic English with free online modules or even reading about success stories of other rural kids who made it abroad. Or any structured advice. An adult can help refine these prompts, ensuring the advice is relevant and actionable. This is how we disambiguate the “how.” AI breaks down big goals — like studying overseas — into smaller steps, whether it’s borrowing a lamp to study at night, cutting back on after-school soccer to focus to learn algebra, or trying out for a local debate competition (and even give them arguments / counterarguments so they can win the debate). Back then, my parents guided me. If these kids’ parents aren’t capable of guiding them, AI, assisted by volunteers, social workers, or village chiefs, can instead guide them.</p><p><strong>Third, a stronger nuclear family.</strong> AI can’t force families to prioritize education over short-term income. Many of my former classmates had to sell crackers or shine shoes to earn money (Pudi, if you’re reading, hello; Imam, if you’re reading this from the heavens above, I miss you man), or herd cattle instead of attending school. This third element — family support — is the hardest to “install,” but it’s not impossible.</p><p>In the long term, AI could help households financially in a lot of ways, like boosting agricultural and fishery yields and educating parents. I can go on and on. I know it seems ambiguous now, but I know a lot of folks here in Silicon Valley working day and night creating AI driven companies out of their dorm rooms, targeting specifically the underprivileged. Stanford has a class specifically to help build ventures like these: <a href="https://extreme.stanford.edu/">Design for Extreme Affordability</a>. If AI can help me proofread this blogpost and do my assignments at lightning speed (sorry, Professor!), I don’t see why it can’t also deliver educational sessions or farming tips in rural dialects. Over time, families might see tangible improvements — from a healthier harvest to broader job prospects. That might encourage them to let kids finish school or pursue opportunities they once thought impossible.</p><h3>Choosing Optimism</h3><p>AI, like any tool, isn’t a silver bullet for poverty. It can’t magically fix systemic issues such as malnutrition, slum housing, or chronically underfunded schools. Critics also warn that AI might worsen inequality, since wealthy people or areas can afford premium tools while others can’t. An Indonesian who I look up to a lot, Former Minister Gita Wirjawan, who is also a fellow here at Stanford, wrote it eloquently in his piece <a href="https://aparc.fsi.stanford.edu/publication/paradox-internet">here</a>.</p><p>Yet we’re not powerless. We can provide free or subsidized AI access in rural areas (we don’t need ChatGPT io, that’s $200 a month; the free one is enough). Train social workers or volunteers to guide students and parents. Install basic infrastructure like Starlink in isolated regions. Replace kerosene lamps with affordable, solar-powered LED lights. Keep the laptops in a community space, ensuring shared oversight.</p><p><strong>Let them dream. Let them find out how to get that dream.</strong></p><p>Yes, it’s a lot of work. But I’m optimistic it can be done without widening the gap. My father grew up in near-poverty and grew in an actual Central Javanese forest, not just a plantation, yet he found a path forward with creativity and stubborn will. We can channel the same determination to roll out AI in a way that genuinely lifts people.</p><p>I’ll admit, I’m biased toward optimism and hope. I’ve chosen to live a life that sees the possibility in every corner, no matter how “far” it seems. After Stanford, I hope to find ways to contribute by using finance/investing and AI for good, so that more kids — those who speak little English, have only basic meals, and have never seen a big city — can dare to dream of launching successful (and failed) startups in San Francisco, engaging in U.S.-China international diplomacy in Beijing, or earning a PhD from Iowa State.</p><p>Onwards.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=12f7cec5a3c4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/ai-can-lift-families-out-of-poverty-and-heres-why-12f7cec5a3c4">AI Can Lift Families Out of Poverty, and Here’s Why</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[U.S.-China: Views from Stanford]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guinandra/u-s-china-views-from-stanford-0ba7c94a2cd6?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0ba7c94a2cd6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tariffs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stanford]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[china]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-china-relations]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Dec 2024 19:08:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-14T09:29:17.796Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>U.S.-China, Views from Stanford</strong></h3><h4>Reflections on the evolving U.S.-China dynamic, shaped by a quarter of learning, debates, and insights at Stanford</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_fd5VMwMVm3qKtLzugpw7w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo taken on Democracy Day (U.S. elections) on November 5 this year, with Stanford’s Hoover Tower in the background.</figcaption></figure><p>The world moves fast. When I last wrote about <a href="https://medium.com/@guinandra/teaching-retail-investors-lessons-learned-474c2259d607">teaching retail investors</a> in July, I couldn’t have anticipated the whirlwind that awaited me this past quarter. We’ve witnessed a historic U.S. presidential election with a decisive victory and the implementation of ambitious protectionist policies that were once mere presentation slides.</p><p>Last quarter, I curated my course load to understand these global phenomena and U.S. — China dynamics, working with exceptional professors like <a href="https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/faculty-research/faculty/keith-hennessey">Keith Hennessey </a>and <a href="https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/faculty-research/faculty/zhiguo-he">Zhiguo He</a> at the GSB. While I cherish my time with b-school classmates, those who know me well understand my tendency to drift from the Knight Management Center toward Encina Hall — Stanford’s beating heart of international policy studies. It’s there that I’ve had the privilege of hosting roundtables and engaging with luminaries like <a href="https://fukuyama.stanford.edu/">Francis Fukuyama</a> and Indonesia’s <a href="https://aparc.fsi.stanford.edu/people/gita-wirjawan">Gita Wirjawan</a>.</p><p>Here’s a few insights I’ve gathered over the past quarter about the dynamic between two global superpowers — the U.S. and China — through the lens of my Stanford’s professors, fellows, and classmates.</p><h3><strong>U.S-China: Trade</strong></h3><p>For those of us who studied economics in the early 2000s like myself, tariffs seemed like relics of the past. We learned about them as pre-WWII instruments for revenue generation and infant industry protection. The post-war era championed free trade, with the U.S. leading the charge toward a rules-based international order. The WTO emerged, and free trade agreements like NAFTA and TPP flourished. In fact, global average tariff rates fell from over 40% in 1947 to just 9% in the early 2000s, marking a dramatic shift in international trade policy:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*W3ilnPxppp1z-LFZ" /></figure><p>However, this paradigm shifted dramatically when <strong>President Trump (1st term) reimagined tariffs not just as revenue generators, but as powerful negotiating tools</strong>, particularly with China — America’s largest trade deficit partner. The U.S.-China trade deficit reached a record $400bn+ in 2018, fundamentally altering the trade policy calculus. By 2023, average U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods had 20%+, compared to just 3% in 2017. President-elect Trump’s promise of broad tariffs — 10% globally and up to 60% specifically for China — materialized swiftly.</p><p>Perhaps most notably, <strong>America’s approach to China on trade has achieved rare bipartisan consensus</strong>, with clear policy continuity from Trump’s first term through the Biden administration and beyond:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/874/1*0x67nBistLiCFmJ_lG_aOw.png" /></figure><p>China, of course, <strong>responded by imposing further tariffs on the U.S.</strong>, a classic trade tit-for-tat:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/877/0*DEXEEgdkDKbGhmE7" /></figure><p>Note that the charts above exclude recent developments (i.e. banning sales of rare earth minerals).</p><p>Are these tariffs beneficial? A balanced evaluation reveals both opportunities and challenges, informed in part by insights from people I spoke to here. On one hand, tariffs provide the federal government with substantial tax revenue — customs duties surpassed $90 billion in 2023 — and may strategically benefit industries like semiconductors and defense. Structural challenges persist, however. <strong>The road to “Made in America” is challenging: the U.S. remains limited as a manufacturing base and cannot produce everything domestically. </strong>A company called Bare Botanics that produces care products <a href="https://www.wsj.com/podcasts/the-journal/how-one-business-owner-is-getting-ahead-of-trump-tariffs/7279debc-746f-413d-9edc-9d5a185397ef">couldn’t find a single company in the U.S. that sells basic intermediate products like body brushes</a>, for instance.</p><p>Experts here also emphasize significant risks to consumer welfare. They highlight how China’s role as a global supply chain hub means that <strong>most U.S. goods will, at some point, involve Chinese inputs / supply chain hubs.</strong> Higher tariffs may translate to higher prices for American consumers, contributing to inflationary pressures. In essence, while tariffs may achieve certain strategic objectives, their broader impact — including rising costs for businesses and consumers — demands a nuanced and cautious approach.</p><p>While using tariffs as leverage with China finds some support, some question the wisdom of broader tariffs on U.S. trade partners, particularly those viewed through a “China+1” lens:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/976/0*L3YdMJYmTqlr3wzh" /></figure><p>Scholars I spoke to are<strong> generally skeptical about the value of imposing tariffs on U.S.’ own allies (i.e. Canada)</strong>, or on countries like Mexico or Vietnam, where much trade has migrated. Vietnam’s exports to the U.S. have grown more than two-fold since 2018, while Mexico has become America’s largest trading partner. Historical memory might be short, but the high-tariff era wasn’t golden: consumers faced limited choices and high prices, while industries lost their competitive edge. Interestingly, a GSB professor suggested that a stronger “America First” approach might actually look more like Javier Milei’s Argentina model — Trumpist at its core but embracing free trade principles.</p><p><strong>So will the U.S. achieve its objective of reinstating a rules-based international trade order by using tariffs as a negotiation tool, without harming American consumers? Only time will tell.</strong></p><h3>U.S.-China: USD vs. CNY</h3><p>BRICS’ recent activism has reignited discussions about de-dollarization in our classrooms and policy forums. Questions about the Chinese yuan’s potential as a primary world currency have sparked debate. The expansion of BRICS to include Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE in January 2024 further fueled these discussions.</p><p>However, most experts here seem to agree that <strong>claims about the CNY overtaking the USD as the world’s reserve currency are overstated</strong>. They cite several compelling reasons:</p><ol><li>First: the U.S. dollar remains widely regarded by global trade participants as the most reliable and <strong>trusted currency</strong> for international transactions despite geopolitical shifts;</li><li>Second: despite political volatility, the <strong>U.S. economy has shown remarkable resilience</strong>, defying recession prediction, thus signaling U.S.’ strong fiscal power;</li><li>Third: China continues to face a formidable trinity of challenges — <strong>debt, deflation, and demographics</strong> (population decline) plus industrial production overcapacity;</li><li>Fourth: Russia’s (as China’s key ally) economic influence within BRICS largely reflects <strong>Soviet-era nostalgia</strong> rather than current reality, with its GDP now smaller than South Korea’s;</li><li>Fifth: investor s<strong>kepticism toward currencies controlled by non-independent central banks</strong>, particularly given historical precedents like 2015’s yuan devaluation where the PBOC prioritized industrial policy through currency manipulation.</li></ol><p>These factors help explain the minor increase, or relative stagnation, in world reserve currency composition:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YvW2XEmsCfKxkzbp" /></figure><p>The dollar still accounts for 58% of global foreign exchange reserves, while the yuan represents only 2% despite years of internationalization efforts. <strong>Barring seismic events like world wars (which, per my understanding of history, previously ended sterling’s dominance), the dollar’s position appears secure</strong>.</p><p>One clear consensus emerges: regardless of future currency dominance, centralized payment systems like SWIFT need modernization. This presents an opportunity for innovative fintech solutions from entrepreneurial minds, especially given that SWIFT still processes 89% of global cross-border payments despite its 1973 founding. I know a few of my classmates are trying to tackle this challenge.</p><h3>U.S.-China: Taiwan</h3><p>Most people here see <strong>little prospect for de-escalation in the Taiwan Strait</strong>, <strong>with reasons extending beyond semiconductors </strong>(through control over TSMC, who has 90% market share in advanced AI/defense chips). Key factors of unlikely de-escalation, in addition to ensuring dominance in chips production and design via TSMC, include: (a) national security, (b) historical imperatives, and (c) ambivalence on Taiwan’s defense strategy.</p><p>On (a) national security — I found the visual snapshot of the Taiwan Strait, South China Sea, and East China Sea I took from Google Maps, but flipped 90 degrees, a very unique way to assess the situation:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0d9Er8ElXLa_whLC" /></figure><p>This tilted map above helps illuminate China’s security concerns from a unique vantage point. Per Google, the <strong>China-controlled shallow waters (c.70 meters) limit submarine operations, creating a naval chokepoint</strong>. <strong>U.S. military presence — from Japanese to Philippine bases and Guam — shapes Chinese defensive posturing.</strong> The U.S. has increased its military presence significantly, with 375 military bases encircling China, including recent agreements with the Philippines for four new bases. Some draw parallels to Putin’s NATO expansion rhetoric regarding Ukraine. These dynamics, combined with China’s 300% increase in Taiwan Strait military exercises since 2020, make de-escalation increasingly unlikely.</p><p>On (b) historical perspective: some here think that President Xi Jinping <strong>may view Taiwan’s reunification as a cornerstone of his “national rejuvenation” vision, grounded in the belief that Taiwan has historically been an inseparable part of China. </strong>This perspective could stem from centuries of shared cultural, economic, and political ties, dating back to the Ming and Qing dynasties when Taiwan was administered as part of the Chinese empire. The current separation might be seen as a remnant of historical disruptions, particularly the “Century of Humiliation” and the Chinese Civil War, which culminated in the Republic of China government retreating to Taiwan in 1949. By tying this vision to 2049, the centennial of the People’s Republic of China, President Xi may view resolving the Taiwan question as a step toward national unity. <strong>For him, reunification might not only represent territorial integrity but also serve as a symbol of China’s historical continuity and evolving role in the global order.</strong></p><p>On (c), ambivalent / unclear stance on Taiwan: the U.S.’ longstanding policy of “strategic ambiguity” on Taiwan — opposing unilateral changes to the status quo while avoiding firm commitments to Taiwan’s defense — has become increasingly strained as China’s military capabilities grow and Taiwan’s democratic identity strengthens. While U.S. defense spending allocated for Taiwan (c.$10 billion p.a.) still exceeds China’s Taiwan-specific military budget (c.$7 billion), China’s rapid military modernization and heightened regional ambitions undermine the deterrent effect of U.S. ambiguity. Despite $690 billion in bilateral trade in 2023 underscoring economic interdependence, tensions in the Taiwan Strait persist. <strong>Experts suggest ambiguity may remain U.S. policy, causing de-escalation to be unlikely given the growing mistrust among the two superpowers.</strong></p><h3>U.S.-China: Climate Leadership</h3><p><strong>China seems to have emerged as the definitive climate leader, </strong>at least in terms of size. COP24 delegates in Baku observed global attention shifting toward Chinese initiatives. <strong>This contrasts sharply with U.S. policy volatility regarding climate</strong>:</p><ul><li>Will the U.S. pull out of the Paris Agreement, again?</li><li>Will U.S.’ game-changing Inflation Reduction Act remain relevant under President Trump’s presidency?</li><li>Will federal climate initiatives (i.e. carbon taxes, national renewable portfolio standards, limitations on fracking, nuclear energy adoption) face rollbacks amid shifting political priorities (a red house and a red senate)?</li></ul><p>China’s unified stance under President Xi, coupled with rapid advancement across climate sectors, has impressed other nations — not something I can support with data, but a sentiment shared by a few people I know who attended COP this year.</p><p>At least in EV production, China is far ahead in the race, thanks to continued implementation of China’s ambitious industrial policy. In 2023, global electric vehicle (EV) sales reached nearly 14 million units, with China accounting for approximately 60% of these sales, translating to about 8 million units sold in the country. These figures highlight China’s significant role in the EV sector:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1k6ZXcfpxnbVdu-c" /></figure><p>Chinese manufacturers also <strong>dominate the production of solar panels</strong>, producing over 80% of the world’s supply. Additionally, China is a major player in the electric vehicle battery market, <strong>producing around 75% of the world’s lithium-ion batteries</strong>.</p><h3>U.S.-China: Indonesia</h3><p>The U.S.-China dynamic continues to fascinate me, particularly as their spheres of influence increasingly intersect in Southeast Asia. As an Indonesian watching these geopolitical shifts, I find myself deeply invested in understanding how their evolving dynamic shapes my home region. The intricate balance of economic dependencies, security relationships, and cultural connections in Southeast Asia — particularly in Indonesia, the region’s largest economy — feels like a story that’s still unfolding. I’m excited to dive deeper into it next quarter.</p><p>In the meantime, I’ll leave readers with this billion-dollar question: <strong>where will countries like China, India, and Indonesia land vis-à-vis the U.S. on this chart in the next 10, 25, 50, 100 years?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/825/1*UyyeKXctcbeOJ7gMyCqN4A.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0ba7c94a2cd6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Teaching Retail Investors: Lessons Learned]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guinandra/teaching-retail-investors-lessons-learned-474c2259d607?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/474c2259d607</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nvidia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[financial-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Jul 2024 08:19:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-05T08:27:39.906Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Four things I learned as a first-time teacher of investing.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bOFoSkk2-PlD9r_PS3u3Bg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dynamic classroom: white boards, presentations, debates, and simulations.</figcaption></figure><p>Last year, I established a for-profit financial education firm, Frost-1 Academy (<a href="https://www.frost-1.com/">frost-1.com</a>), to channel my passion for learning, teaching, and creating positive communities in the realm of investing. Since then, I’ve conducted numerous masterclasses on investing in developed markets equities within frontier sectors such as artificial intelligence and diabesity, targeting retail investors as students. What began as an intellectual-cum-entrepreneurial side hustle to fund my ski trips to Aomori and Niseko (which were, unfortunately, quite pricey) turned out to be another avenue for personal growth.</p><p>After each masterclass, I solicited honest feedback from my students. A few common themes emerged, but most of them related to the unique delivery of the classes, making the weekend sessions with me, according to some of them, genuinely fulfilling. One person described it as the “funniest-yet-most intense” workshop they had ever attended (I’m still unsure how to feel about this!). Overall, the feedback was overwhelmingly positive, though I suspect dissatisfied students refrained from giving feedback to avoid hurting my feelings.</p><p>As I write this post on my flight to San Francisco, I won’t be running more masterclasses in Jakarta for a while, so I thought I’d share the lessons I learned from conducting these offline sessions, as the journey has been enlightening for me.</p><h4><strong>Lesson 1: Treating the classroom as a theatrical stage is effective.</strong></h4><p>Knowledge absorption requires focus, but our genetic makeup works against us. I recall reading that an adult’s attention span is merely 8 seconds. As an instructor, this is concerning, especially given the intensive nature of the modules I designed. Below is a snapshot of my retail investment class (around 40-50 students per cohort):</p><p><strong>Day 1: Saturday, 9 AM — 6 PM</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Module 1 — Artificial Intelligence (AI) 101</strong>: Standardizing knowledge on AI. This module is relatively theoretical, with an in-depth discussion on AI’s layers: infrastructure, large-language models, and applications.</li><li><strong>Module 2 — An Investigative Framework</strong>: Qualitative approaches adopted by investment professionals in assessing equity investment opportunities, i.e., total addressable market, moat, macro, management.</li><li><strong>Module 3 — The Math Behind</strong>: Mathematical or modeling tools professionals use to perform returns analysis and equity valuation.</li></ul><p><strong>Day 2: Sunday, 9 AM — 6 PM</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Module 4 — Equity Case Studies in AI</strong>: Applying skills acquired the previous day (Saturday), we simulated an investment committee on one stock (we chose the graphics processing unit maker, NVIDIA).</li><li><strong>Module 5 — A Lesson in Humility</strong>: A post-mortem walkthrough of a broken thesis to instill a sense of humility in investors.</li><li><strong>Module 6 — Recap</strong>: Reviewing knowledge, with discussions on emotional and logical fallacies in investing.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RLkQdUoGBrrRSUu5NFK-KQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Snapshot of the teaching materials I prepared over a few months.</figcaption></figure><p>I developed this syllabus and created hundreds of pages of content over a few months, some in between my ski runs in the Japanese Alps or after my hikes in Hong Kong (nature is a powerful brain stimulator). Any normal person would feel overwhelmed by digesting a lot of information over a weekend, especially those with limited finance or business backgrounds.</p><p>To address this, I harked back to my early college days when I was a summer theatre student (yes, I spent an entire summer at NYU Tisch rehearsing and co-writing for a musical I performed in New York and Abu Dhabi!). From my limited experience, one thing I know for sure is that theatre performers are master captors of attention, bypassing humans’ 8-second attention span limits. So, I implemented a few strategies that seemed to work:</p><ul><li><strong>Simulations</strong>: I divided the classroom into teams of about 8-10 people each. On Day 2, we simulated an actual investment committee composed of team leaders not presenting, where they got to “grill” the presenting team’s investment thesis and risks. To add some spice, I asked the simulated investment committee members to adopt a persona: one was a quantitatively-inclined member who took a red-eye flight the day before, one was a CIO who did not have much time to read the investment memo, and one was a fiery and passionate member resolved to shoot down any recommendations the deal team brought in. While typical investment committees rarely see such characters, students got to see that investors, despite their intellectual rigor, are people after all: they get cranky when they lack sleep and have biases they still try to work on.</li><li><strong>Audience participation</strong>: I set up the classroom in a business-school style, with name tags on their tables. After briefing that the classroom is a safe space to opine and voice their opinions, I encouraged everyone to participate in discussions. In certain cases where the energy level was low, I’d call out a random name for them to contribute. Investing is not an exact science, so any opinions are valid and encouraged.</li><li><strong>Show mentality</strong>: Unlike my freshman college musical, I was the sole performer. So, I took charge of the show by committing to move a lot (literally!). For the entire 9 AM-6 PM, I only sat during breaks, playfully threw my markers at the board to decide which team goes first, pushed and pulled whiteboards myself, and even instinctively pointed to the presentation with my leg (not sure how this happened — you can see this from an Instagram reels compilation made by my friend who happened to join as a student). Like theatrical performances, teaching can be quite physical if you want it to be. I thank my marathon and weightlifting sessions for helping me stay energetic and lively for an entire weekend. Before running Frost-1 Academy, I didn’t know teaching was a workout.</li></ul><h4><strong>Lesson 2: Simplifying language is crucial.</strong></h4><p>The world of investing is rife with jargon and buzzwords. The Greeks of old had sophists — public speakers and whisperers who spoke with such sophistication that even emperors were charmed; in our century, we have highly intelligent professionals within law, medicine, and finance who speak with a language that is difficult to digest for those outside of the industry.</p><p>Given the diversity of my students (their ages ranged from 20 to 55 years old, with professions from food scientists to founders), the leaders I partnered with to run my classes reminded me not to use excessive finance jargon. This was a challenge because as a trained investment professional, using jargon is unfortunately natural to me, but I was committed to using language that everyone could understand, regardless of their background, by slowly breaking down the jargon into simpler terms/phrases while trying not to lose their meanings. Here are a few examples:</p><ul><li><strong>“Parallel compute”</strong>: In Module 1 when a student said graphics-processing units (GPUs) are much more efficient for training AI data than central-processing units, I asked him to simplify the term. We settled on “the ability for a chip to calculate multiple things at once,” which was digestible for other students. We even paused to show this <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-P28LKWTzrI">video clip</a> from NVIDIA’s presentation years ago.</li><li><strong>“Transformer models”</strong>: AI reached an inflection point post-GPT launch because folks at Open AI finally figured out how to deploy transformer model principles from the Google “<a href="https://proceedings.neurips.cc/paper_files/paper/2017/file/3f5ee243547dee91fbd053c1c4a845aa-Paper.pdf">Attention is All You Need</a>” paper. For non-computer scientists, even skimming the paper requires significant brainpower. I myself wasn’t sure how to explain why transformer models are revolutionary, but a student with a technical background helped me distill it. Essentially, we used simple examples that showcase that AI models can now understand context — the Bahasa Indonesia word “Padang” can have multiple meanings depending on its position within a sentence. “<em>Saya kemarin lahap makan nasi padang dengan lauk panas</em>” is different from “<em>Padang pasir yang kemarin saya kunjungi saat makan siang panas</em>” — the first sentence refers to the word/vector “Padang” as a spicy cuisine, while the second one refers to it as a hot desert. Using these funny examples, students appreciated the contextual power of transformer models.</li><li><strong>“Thesis, Risks, Mitigants”</strong>: In Module 2, when we learned about creating an investment thesis on one page and a key concerns &amp; mitigants page on another, we collectively decided to replace the slide’s title with “Why we want to buy/sell this stock” for the thesis page and “What we are concerned about” for the risks/mitigants page. This helped non-finance students bypass the need to familiarize themselves with the terms “thesis,” “risks,” and “mitigants” on their first encounter.</li><li><strong>“Quantitative easing”</strong>: In Module 4, when a student mentioned the U.S. Federal Reserve to explain the lower-than-normal interest rate environment pre-COVID-19 and post the 2008–2009 global financial crisis during our investment committee simulation, I asked him to paraphrase it in simpler terms. After multiple iterations, we settled with “the central bank printing more money so Americans can borrow money cheaper.” Of course, this is not a precise description of QE mechanics, but this knowledge was sufficient for our purposes.</li></ul><h4><strong>Lesson 3: Repetitive trifectas enhance retention.</strong></h4><p>Months before I started teaching, one of the non-fiction books I read was Mehdi Hasan’s <em>Win Every Argument</em>. Regardless of your political viewpoint, I think everyone can agree he has a high degree of expertise in communicating to the masses. In one of his book chapters, he mentioned the power of trifectas: our brain’s hippocampus tends to process and retain information more easily if we group them into three items and repeat them multiple times. I haven’t delved deeper into scientific or psychological research to evaluate this claim, but I can relate to it in my day-to-day life.</p><p>When helping run my family’s hospitality business, I remind myself that what matters are (1) bed, (2) bath, and (3) breakfast. When preparing an impromptu speech for my farewell to my work colleagues as I leave for Stanford GSB, I memorized the outline of the speech: (1) thank them for their friendship, (2) apologize for any unintended harm, and (3) wish them good luck.</p><p>In our investment masterclass, we deployed these trifectas to aid in recalling and understanding concepts. We risked oversimplification, but we accepted this trade-off for smoother knowledge transmission and retention. It’s even better if each word starts with the same letter. Here are a few sample trifectas we used in our class:</p><blockquote><strong><em>AI (three Ls)</em></strong><em>: (1) Layer 1 — Infrastructure, (2) Layer 2 — Model, (3) Layer 3 — Applications.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>China challenges (three Ds)</em></strong><em>: (1) Debt, (2) Deflation, (3) Demography.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Qualitative framework (three Ms)</em></strong><em>: (1) Macro, (2) Market Size, (3) Moat.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Returns analysis</em></strong><em>: (1) Growth, (2) Margins, (3) Exit Multiple.</em></blockquote><p>Once we had the trifectas set and recalled, we broke them down one by one and tried to apply them to our simulation in Module 4 or the lessons learned from a broken investment thesis in Module 5.</p><p>These trifectas not only helped ensure everyone was on the same page, but weeks after the class ended, I received multiple emails saying they had forgotten most of the content, but the points that mattered and stuck the most were the trifectas.</p><h4><strong>Lesson 4: The collective mind of a diverse group is far more powerful than the mind of a single genius.</strong></h4><p>The more I practice investing, the more I realize that an investor benefits significantly from having “strong opinions, weakly held.” Investing is rarely an individual endeavor: it is difficult and treacherous path to tackle alone. “Strong opinions” means having the courage to form a stance or view on an investment opportunity by performing deep research and assessing the investor’s emotional biases and state. “Weakly held” means having the humility to hear alternative viewpoints and the courage to accept being wrong. Unfortunately, most investors (at least those my age) I know are jedi masters of the former but jedi padawans of the latter — I hope you get my Star Wars references.</p><p>During the first few seconds of my class, I asked how many people believe AI is a hype, and how many believe it is not. Quite literally, the class was polarized: 50% believed it is a hype, and 50% believed it is real. The “for” camp made strong statements such as “AI stocks are definitely in a bubble, just like crypto memecoins during COVID” to “AI is real, look at how fast everyone uses ChatGPT when it first launched — even faster than mobile app initial adoption.” The debate was intense, and I deliberately decided not to intervene.</p><p>To promote healthy discourse, I continually reinforced that the class was a safe space for everyone to express their views, as long as they committed to having an open mind and being respectful when someone else was speaking. No opinions were bad, and my role was not as a didactic instructor but rather as a facilitator and fellow student. I even reminded them that each of them paid around US$1k to spend a full weekend together — so they better make every penny worthwhile and participate. The 50+ students were aligned in building a community of investment enthusiasts which could hopefully spring into new friendships.</p><p>By the end of Sunday, in determining whether AI was a hype or not, I did not provide any answers. Instead, the classroom collectively came up with nuanced key points far more sophisticated than their initial views.</p><p><strong>Collective inputs from students: Arguments for AI</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Infrastructure readiness</strong>: Parallel compute chips, such as GPUs, are relatively novel and have only been available since 2015+.</li><li><strong>Data availability</strong>: Social media and zero paywall news sources provide free data for training.</li><li><strong>Model sophistication</strong>: Transformer models with high applicability have only been available since 2017, after the “Attention is All You Need” paper, which focuses on words/images as contextual vectors. Generative models can now also create samples similar to training data (including synthetic ones).</li><li><strong>Strong initial MVP</strong>: ChatGPT’s initial launch was speedy, positive, and widely adopted.</li><li><strong>Real market forces</strong>: Billions of dollars are being invested by cash-rich tech players (e.g., Meta, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft).</li></ol><p><strong>Collective inputs from students: Arguments against AI</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Irrational exuberance</strong>: Humanity never learns; the railway boom and internet boom were both overcapacities (one on rails, one on internet cables) resulting in poor returns on capex spending.</li><li><strong>Commodification</strong>: Business models will change, and rampant use of AI will make consumers reluctant to pay for AI services, similar to how internet access costs plummeted.</li><li><strong>Classic prisoner’s dilemma</strong>: Big tech players are simply trapped in a prisoner’s dilemma, forcing them to spend when they don’t want to (for survival reasons only).</li><li><strong>Momentum money, again</strong>: One of the students said: “a bunch of VCs not knowing what they’re doing, again!”</li></ol><p>To me personally, this exercise was heartwarming. In an increasingly polarized world, having 50+ high-powered individuals with diverse backgrounds agree to lower their egos, listen attentively to one another, engage in respectful discourse with an open mind in their ultimate pursuit of knowledge (and in real investing life, risk-adjusted returns) was deeply fulfilling. It demonstrates why being a lone-wolf and close-minded investor can be counterproductive. In the 2024 NBA basketball world, it may act as a parallel example of why the Boston Celtics (with Brown-Tatum-Porzingis-Holiday-Horford) are much greater than the sum of their parts, defeating the Dallas Mavericks carried by the genius of Luka Doncic alone!</p><p>At the very end, as a group, we were also self-aware of the limitations of the above collective inputs — we were undoubtedly missing many data points and facts (we didn’t have time to peruse analyst calls, read sector reports, and access Bloomberg terminals), but the students were more judicious in their buy/sell recommendation of NVIDIA, the subject of our case study. There was no bandwagon fallacy in play either: despite receiving similar information over the course of two days, about half of the class said to buy NVIDIA, while the other half said sell.</p><p>Running Frost-1 Academy has been fun, fulfilling, and humbling. When I first started experimenting with teaching for profit, my family and friends mentioned how it is the teacher, not the student, who learns the most. After multiple masterclasses, I wholeheartedly agree. I felt more confident delving deeper into previously foreign thematic sectors such as AI: after all, I needed to prepare hundreds of pages of materials and deliver them in a fun, engaging, and energetic way. More importantly, I learned how to build positive communities of lifelong learning in industries I respect and am passionate about: investing and business-building, knowledge I hope to continue honing as I step into the hills of Palo Alto this week.</p><p>If you happen to be Ellen (Founder &amp; CEO, Emtrade) or Claudia (Founder &amp; CEO, Pluang) — thank you for believing in me and allowing me to partner with the amazing companies and platforms you’ve built.</p><p>If you were one of my students, thank you for giving me the chance to evolve with you.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hM2Xomlk_QqGUwWtRLmzzw.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=474c2259d607" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Effective Corporate Diplomats]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guinandra/effective-corporate-diplomats-63eadfbbb7b6?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63eadfbbb7b6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[investing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[private-equity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investment-banking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diplomacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Aug 2023 01:50:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-20T01:53:24.240Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An observation of 5 key characteristics of an effective negotiator and dealmaker.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1009/1*a5gD1KwRb5_btl-E_8T50g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Midjourney (Artificial Intelligence)</figcaption></figure><p>As I navigate my daily responsibilities spearheading investment and business development efforts for my company, I regularly cross paths with individuals I like to term “corporate diplomats”. These are the chief investors, bankers, head fundraisers, and lawyers, to name a few. Their primary roles revolve around finalizing deals and ensuring that these agreements remain relevant and beneficial in the long haul.</p><p>The individuals I engage with often share common traits such as charisma and a knack for effective communication. Yet, over time, I’ve noticed distinct differences that set some apart from the rest. After jotting down my observations and seeking insights from several of my mentors and colleagues — each a seasoned corporate diplomat in their own right — I’ve identified, albeit in a somewhat clichéd manner, five key factors that define an effective corporate diplomat.</p><h4><strong>1. Values discourses over debates.</strong></h4><p>During my high school years, I was a debater. Unless debate championships have changed over the past few years, the primary goal of debate is winning. Typically, a debate team format consists of three members: the first speaker introduces the team’s case, the second speaker elaborates on it further and serves as the primary attacker of the opposing team’s statements, and the third speaker summarizes the team’s points and explains why the opposing team’s arguments are flawed. Occasionally, winning a debate involves Machiavellian tactics such as deceiving the judge by cherry-picking data that supports the team’s arguments or even launching ad-hominem attacks against an opponent’s character. By the end of the debate, a few adjudicators decide who wins and who loses.</p><p>However, I’ve observed that skilled debaters often struggle as negotiators in a corporate setting. Eloquence and the ability to present data might make someone a compelling speaker, but not necessarily a skilled deal-closer. What’s more, unlike in debate competitions, there are no judges to determine victors, and any offended parties might carry their grievances outside the meeting room.</p><p>In contrast, I’ve observed that those who successfully close deals and form partnerships are masters of compromise — they excel at creating win-win solutions. Instead of focusing on victory, they engage in collaborative problem solving, ensuring that the opposing side is not an adversary but a partner with valid concerns and objectives.</p><p>For the adept negotiator, the dynamic isn’t about “me vs. you.” It’s about establishing frameworks or environments where both parties leave feeling satisfied. In private equity investing — according to my mentor — this balance is achieved by creating investment structures agreeable to both parties; in event management, it’s realized by understanding that not everyone can have front-row seats.</p><h4><strong>2. Displays character consistency.</strong></h4><p>Effective corporate diplomats recognize that people have an innate tendency to share information, or in other words, to gossip. They understand that maintaining different personas or facades in front of various groups is not only exhausting but also counterproductive. I’ve come across tales of deals falling apart due to inconsistent portrayals of a diplomat’s character. For instance, in one meeting, a diplomat might express a disdain for tennis, but in another, he enthusiastically professes his love for it. While these might seem like minor inconsistencies, they can have larger implications. Such contradictions lead colleagues and partners to question the authenticity and truthfulness of other statements made by the diplomat in the past.</p><p>Trust is the bedrock of any successful partnership, and inconsistencies, however minor, can chip away at this foundation. When trust erodes, the collaborative essence of a partnership is jeopardized, making successful ventures more challenging to achieve. Several mentors I’ve spoken to have emphasized the importance of authenticity in corporate diplomacy. Their advice? Be genuine, open, and unapologetically confident in your beliefs and values. While appeasing individuals with sycophantic behavior might yield immediate, short-term gains during a meeting, any inconsistencies are likely to be uncovered as people compare notes. When these discrepancies come to light, they can severely damage one’s reputation and credibility, causing more harm in the long run than any short-term gains achieved through insincere flattery.</p><h4><strong>3.</strong> <strong>Avoids overselling.</strong></h4><p>A principle that often seems intuitive is this: the long-term effectiveness of a diplomat is intrinsically tied to the caliber of the company or product they represent. With today’s ease of access to experts, online information, and data, the asymmetry of information has decreased. Consequently, attempting to gloss over weaknesses or exaggerating strengths can erode trust in the diplomat over time.</p><p>From my observations and interactions with effective corporate diplomats, a common thread is their honesty and vulnerability. They don’t shy away from acknowledging the challenges faced by their companies. Instead, they transparently discuss these issues, highlighting the strategies and initiatives undertaken to address them. Moreover, if they present optimistic long-term visions akin to hockey-stick forecasts, they’re also quick to remind stakeholders that we operate in a VUCA world — Volatile, Uncertain, Complex, and Ambiguous. As such, while they hope for the best, they also recognize the inherent unpredictability of such projections.</p><p>Embracing vulnerability, though it might appear counterintuitive at first, can be a strategic strength. When vulnerability is expressed and reciprocated, it paves the way for deeper trust and credibility. It humanizes the diplomat, fostering stronger, more genuine connections with stakeholders. This authentic rapport can be the foundation for resilient partnerships and collaborations.</p><h4><strong>4.</strong> <strong>Avoids cultural stereotypes.</strong></h4><p>Effective corporate diplomats recognize and appreciate cultural nuances, but not overly dependent on it. While they understand the importance of cultural awareness, they are cautious not to stereotype or oversimplify by asserting that citizens of Country A will invariably exhibit Behavior X. This perspective, although it might seem obvious, deserves emphasis given the evolving nature of our world. With rapid globalization and the digital age, cultures no longer remain confined within geographical boundaries but intermingle and influence each other in myriad ways.</p><p>One of the most direct and insightful methods to grasp the essence of a potential partner, be it an individual or a company, is to engage them in meaningful conversation. Whether it’s over a formal meeting or a more casual “date,” spending hours discussing their views, aspirations, and values can be enlightening. What’s their backstory? How do they perceive the world? How do they define success or victory?</p><p>Just as humans have unique personalities molded by both genetics (nature) and upbringing (nurture), companies too possess distinct DNAs. Their ethos, culture, and behavior are shaped by foundational principles and their experiences over time. An adept diplomat delves deep to understand these intricacies. They exhibit empathy towards differences and similarities between their own background and that of their counterpart, and then channel this understanding to collaboratively address challenges and forge successful partnerships. In essence, diplomacy is not just about negotiation; it’s about genuine connection and comprehension.</p><h4><strong>5.</strong> <strong>Keeps personal biases in check.</strong></h4><p>Diplomats, at their core, are humans, and like all humans, they are influenced by biases and imperfections. While their primary responsibility is to champion the best interests of the company they represent, it’s a challenge to completely disentangle their personal motivations and emotions from their professional duties.</p><p>For instance, there have been instances where heads of business development bypass certain banks for their IPO processes due to personal feuds with the bankers, even if those banks have arguably better capacities to execute the IPO. Similarly, some may deliberately exclude a particular region or country when seeking potential partners because of past negative experiences or prejudices, rather than objective evaluation of the opportunity.</p><p>In my consultations with former superiors and industry peers, a recurring theme emerges: the importance of self-awareness. Recognizing one’s biases is the first step to overcoming them. It’s crucial for diplomats to prioritize the broader goals of their organization over personal inclinations. Ideally, a diplomat’s personal interests would perfectly align with those of the company. But in reality, perfect alignment is a rarity. Thus, the true measure of a diplomat’s character is their commitment to doing what’s best for the collective, even when it contradicts individual preferences. It’s about placing the mission and vision of the larger group above personal desires, ensuring the integrity of their role and fostering trust among stakeholders.</p><p>This list is by no means exhaustive and perfect: as I continue to grow personally and professionally, I’m eager to discover more traits that make a person a trustworthy and effective corporate diplomat.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63eadfbbb7b6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Menentang Investasi Bodong]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guinandra/menentang-investasi-bodong-40c8a89f8548?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40c8a89f8548</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jouska]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investasi-bodong]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investasi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indonesia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memiles]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Jul 2020 10:55:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-26T11:49:48.006Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Tameng utama dari pelaku penipuan finansial dan investasi bodong adalah pengetahuan.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2qmX-Hxhwi_LdZca38lnBQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>“Mantap nih bro, gue nemu investasi yang ngejanjiin gue bunga 10% tiap bulan. Di <em>endorse</em> si [selebgram/artis] juga btw. <em>Also</em>, liat nih profil Instagram <em>founder</em>-nya. Rumah gede, tas Celine.”</p><p>Setiap orang memiliki <em>trigger</em> yang membuat mereka agresif dalam menentang isu-isu tertentu. Sebagai seseorang yang bekerja di dunia investasi dan keuangan, <em>trigger</em> saya adalah menemukan institusi-institusi yang berkedok membantu menambah penghasilan, padahal pada dasarnya melakukan pembodohan dan penipuan — sengaja atau tidak disengaja — terhadap orang lain. Penipuan-penipuan finansial dan investasi bodong seperti ini marak di Indonesia.</p><p>MeMiles, contohnya.</p><p>Dalam kurun waktu kurang dari setahun, skema gali lubang tutup lubang MeMiles yang dikemas menarik berhasil mengumpulkan lebih dari Rp 750 milyar, dibawah klaim bisnis periklanan. Manajemen MeMiles menggaet artis-artis dan selebgram-selebgram ternama, untuk mempromosikan betapa menggiurkannya keuntungan produk bisnis dan investasi mereka ke khalayak umum. Melihat orang-orang terkenal ikut serta, tentunya, membuat beberapa orang yakin bahwa MeMiles adalah portal investasi yang legal yang menguntungkan. Sekitar 260,000 orang pun terjerumus ke skema ponzi ilegal dan merugikan. MeMiles ditutup, bosnya di penjara.</p><p>Pelaksana investasi bodong murni, layaknya MeMiles, patut untuk diberantas. Tetapi tidak semua bentuk investasi secara explisit bodong: ada beberapa yang, sengaja atau tidak disengaja, menyesatkan dan merugikan orang-orang biasa tanpa mengadopsi kebodongan murni.</p><p>Jouska, contohnya.</p><p>Terkenal di kalangan milennial seperti saya dan Gen-Z, Jouska mem-<em>branding</em> diri sebagai perusahaan yang memiliki tujuan mulia: mengedukasi masyarakat mengenai teori dan aplikasi keuangan personal melalui kurasi profil Instagram yang cetar. <em>High-quality portrait photos. Catchy captions: Bahasa with a dash of English.</em> Nasihat keuangan sehari-hari untuk mereka dibawah atau sekitar 30 tahun, yang cepat didapat via sentuhan layar <em>smartphone</em>. Pendiri Jouska muda, <em>humblebrag</em> BMW sembari memamerkan jam tangan Rolex hijau Hulk series.</p><p>Namun, awal minggu ini, hampir 750,000 pengikut Jouska di Instagram dibuat kecewa. Jouska ternyata bisnis tak berizin, yang dengan kata lain, ilegal. Satuan tugas Otoritas Jasa Keuangan (OJK) menemukan mereka hanya memegang lisensi “jasa pendidikan lainnya”, tapi Jouska beroperasi layaknya penasihat investasi dan manajer keuangan profesional. Tanpa lisensi, Jouska mengarahkan dana klien ke dua instansi ambigu lain: PT Mahesa Strategis Indonesia dan PT Amarta Investa Indonesia. Berbasis teori pasar saham naif dan ala-ala, <a href="https://www.instagram.com/aakarabyasa">Aakar Abyasa </a>— pendiri Jouska — dan timnya mengarahkan uang nasabah yang digunakan untuk membeli beberapa saham terkonsentrasi, mahal, dan tidak likuid.</p><p>Aksi Jouska tidak hanya mencoreng nama baik investor profesional dan konsultan finansial di Indonesia yang memegang sertifikasi manajemen dan penasihat keuangan legal. Aksi mereka, dalam perjalanannya mengoperasikan bisnis tanpa izin, adalah aksi yang merugikan dan membodohi publik. Jouska meng-klaim dirinya sebagai institusi yang bertujuan untuk mengedukasi masyarakat untuk berhati-hati mengenai investasi dan mengatur keuangan sehari-hari. <em>But they didn’t practice what they preached</em>: layaknya drama paradoksikal, Jouska ternyata selama ini memberikan nasihat untuk menghindari Jouska dan Jouska-Jouska lainnya.</p><p>Mungkin kalau saya Jouska, <em>defense</em> utama yang akan saya gunakan adalah menyalahkan kliennya sendiri. Walaupun Jouska dan perusahaan-perusahaan yang terafiliasi dengannya tidak berlisensi, Jouska sudah menjelaskan bahwa setiap klien berhak menolak saran investasi yang Jouska berikan. Toh, kalau tidak suka dengan saran Jouska untuk (i) memberikan mereka uang untuk diarahkan dan diatur, dan (ii) memperbolehkan Jouska untuk membeli instrumen-instrumen investasi sesuai dengan sarannya, <em>then</em> <em>feel free</em> untuk memutuskan kontrak dengan Jouska. Mantranya: <em>consent equals to a permission to act as Jouska wishes.</em></p><p><em>Defense</em> seperti ini klasik di sektor finansial dan adalah bentuk penyalahgunaan kepercayaan kritis. Lupakan permasalahan lisensi. Pertama, Jouska tidak secara holistik bertanya preferensi resiko klien mereka sendiri, di awal mula perjanjian kontrak. Semua penasihat keuangan yang menaruh kepentingan klien didepan keuntungan diri sendiri selalu memastikan bahwa membeli saham-saham terkonsentrasi dan <em>illiquid </em>tunggal adalah strategi yang cocok dengan karakteristik, keinginan, dan toleransi resiko klien. Kedua, kewajiban untuk jujur bahwa bisnis mereka tidak memiliki izin terletak pada Jouska. Fakta bahwa Jouska tidak secara gamblang mengatakan kepada klien mereka bahwa mereka tidak memegang lisensi dan sertifikasi manajemen investasi adalah salah penuh Jouska sebagai pelaku, bukan salah klien sebagai korban. <em>Perpetrators do not get to play victim</em>. Ketiga, tidak semua consent itu sama. Hanya karena klien Jouska mengatakan “oke” untuk memperbolehkan Jouska berinvestasi atas nama klien, bukan berarti kata “oke” tersebut dilayangkan di situasi yang setara. Dalam artian, dalam memberikan <em>offer</em> persetujuan ke kliennya, Jouska selalu ada di posisi yang selalu lebih menguntungkan dibandingkan kliennya sendiri. Khalayak umum, sebagai contohnya, tidak selalu memiliki kemampuan untuk bernegosiasi kontrak legal dan untuk mengakses pakar hukum untuk memastikan, melalui <em>legal due diligence</em>, bahwa Jouska tidak menipu mereka. Sementara Jouska, beserta dua institusi persekongkolannya, adalah PT yang memiliki dana dan hak-hak hukum perseroan yang melindungi mereka. Adalah hal yang wajar untuk seorang klien memberikan <em>consent</em> kepada Jouska dengan basis <em>track record</em> Jouska yang, setidaknya kepada kaum milennial dan Gen-Z, secara atraktif memberikan saran keuangan yang asyik untuk dicerna.</p><p>Kasus MeMiles dan Jouska membuat banyak orang pesimis mengenai investasi di usia muda. <em>But guess what</em>: pesimisme adalah hal yang baik dalam dunia investasi. Setiap investor baik yang saya kenal memiliki tingkat pesimisme yang tinggi, karena mereka tahu banyak aktor-aktor seperti MeMiles dan Jouska yang, karena tergiur uang, mencoba mengambil keuntungan secara tidak etis dari mereka. Di dunia investasi dan keuangan, layaknya di bidang-bidang lain, pengetahuan adalah tameng utama dari penipuan.</p><p>Memahami ciri-ciri seperti berikut membantu dalam menentukan apakah produk investasi yang ditawarkan adalah investasi bodong (seperti MeMiles), atau investasi yang sengaja atau tidak sengaja menipu kliennya sendiri (seperti Jouska):</p><ul><li><strong>Menjamin keuntungan per hari, per bulan, atau per tahun yang diluar nalar</strong>. “Kami akan menginvestasikan dana anda dalam Bitcoin, forex, saham bluechip dan memberikan keuntungan setidaknya 10% setiap bulannya.” 10% setiap bulan, secara kotor, kira-kira 120% setahun, yang berarti uang klien dua kali lebih lipat dalam setahun. 100 juta menjadi 200 juta, dalam setahun. Sementara, deposito hanya bisa menjamin bunga dibawah 10% per tahun. Menjamin 120% per tahun berarti menjamin bahwa mereka lebih pintar daripada Warren Buffet, Ray Dalio, Bill Ackman, atau investor-investor ternama dunia lainnya yang bahkan (i) tidak berani menjamin keuntungan yang mereka dapat berikan setiap bulannya kepada klien dan pemegang saham mereka, (ii) setiap harinya, bersama praktisi, akademisi, dan, <em>no joke</em>, robot <em>artificial intelligence</em> keuangan berpengalaman puluhan tahun menguras otak dan menulis algoritma agar bisa menghasilkan keuntungan lebih dibanding investor pasif pembeli indeks semata. Maka dari itu, semua investasi bodong yang menjamin keuntungan diluar nalar hampir pasti menggunakan skema ponzi, alias skema gali lubang tutup lubang. Katakan PT Bodong memiliki dua klien: Gui dan Andra. PT Bodong menjamin keuntungan dua kali lipat setiap tahunnya. Katakan, tiap klien mentransfer 100 juta dibulan berbeda. Gui di Januari 2020, Andra di Februari 2020. Januari 2021, Gui menagih 200 juta ke PT Bodong. Kebetulan, PT Bodong punya 200 juta, jadi PT Bodong memberikan 200 juta ke Gui. Lubang tergali, untuk sementara. Karena Gui senang, beberapa saat kemudian, dia menambah porsinya menjadi 1 milyar. Lubang tertutup. Februari 2021, Andra melakukan yang sama. Lubang tergali, dan tertutup kembali. Tanpa PT Bodong menginvestasikan apa-apa. Skema ponzi PT Bodong akan terus berjalan selama (i) Gui dan Andra selalu berhasil dibodohi, dan (ii) klien-klien yang tertipu bertambah. Namun, ketika mereka menarik dana hampir bersamaan, atau memilih untuk tidak menginvestasikan kembali, maka lubang yang tergalipun tidak tertutup. Skema runtuh, klien rugi, direksi PT Bodong kabur dan berfoya-foya. Ini yang terjadi di MeMiles.</li><li><strong><em>Underlying asset</em> palsu, atau halu.</strong> Untuk menjalankan bisnis ilegalnya, PT Bodong tidak perlu membeli apapun yang mereka klaim: bitcoin, emas, forex, dan/atau saham, alias <em>underlying asset</em> investasi tersebut. Yang mereka lakukan adalah manajemen ekspektasi <em>timeline</em> penggalian dan penutupan lubang. Lantas, mereka tidak dapat memberikan bukti dan menyerahkan underlying asset yang mereka beli kepada klien mereka sendiri. Dan kalaupun ada, bukti tersebut palsu. Pada dasarnya, setiap klien yang memberikan dana mereka untuk diinvestasikan memiliki hak penuh untuk secara fisik meminta <em>underlying asset</em> yang dibeli oleh asset manajer mereka. Di dunia jual-beli saham, <em>underlying asset</em> ini dipegang oleh bank kustodian legal yang klien tunjuk. Di dunia jual-beli emas, klien berhak menukar emas virtual mereka dengan emas fisik. Jika institusi-institusi tertentu menolak atau beralasan memberikan bukti pembelian legal <em>underlying asset</em> atau memberikan <em>underlying asset</em> itu sendiri, maka besar kemungkinan mereka adalah PT Bodong. Bisnis iklan MeMiles adalah contoh <em>underlying asset</em> halu.</li><li><strong>Meminta biaya keanggotaan dan memberikan komisi untuk rekrutmen.</strong> Institusi investasi legal dengan <em>corporate governance</em> yang baik menghindar dari model bisnis <em>multi level marketing</em>, alias MLM. Diluar sektor investasi dan keuangan, legalitas dan sustainabilitas model bisnis MLM, atau skema piramida, hingga detik ini masih diperdebatkan. PT Bodong mencintai model bisnis MLM: “minimal biaya keanggotaan hanya 10 juta per bulan! Rekrut 5 anggota baru, dan dapatkan bonus 20 juta.” Metode marketing keanggotaan yang, sebenarnya, hanya semakin memperkuat skema ponzi PT Bodong. Hindari.</li><li><strong>Tidak menanyakan toleransi resiko klien secara komprehensif.</strong> Setiap bentuk investasi beresiko. Di negara manapun, institusi-institusi yang menawarkan produk investasi wajib untuk secara transparan menjelaskan resiko-resiko investasi tersebut. Bahkan deposito diluar batas jaminan Lembaga Penjamin Simpanan (LPS) memiliki resiko: <em>bank panic</em> ketika ada penarikan deposito bersamaan oleh banyak nasabah, misalnya. Jika institusi yang memberikan tawaran produk investasi atau bisnis tidak secara explisit menanyakan toleransi resiko dan menjelaskan apakah produk tersebut sesuai dengan situasi keuangan calon klien, maka besar kemungkinan <em>offeror</em> investasi tersebut menipu. <em>Statement</em> institusi yang mengatakan “ya, namanya juga investasi, pasti naik turun, lah” tidak cukup. Penasihat dan manajer keuangan yang bertanggung jawab selalu meminta kejelasan hal-hal berikut dari kliennya: (i) berapa persen dari total kekayaan klienkah jumlah uang yang diinvestasikan? (ii) selama berapa bulan atau tahun klien siap untuk <em>stay invested</em>, atau tidak mencairkan investasi tersebut? (iii) apakah klien mengerti potensi fluktuasi harga instrumen tersebut setiap harinya? (iv) apakah klien yakin potensi fluktuasi ini sesuai dengan toleransi resiko klien? (v) tahukah klien bahwa investasi saham publik secara aktif (<em>market timing, stock-picking, momentum investing</em>) tidak selalu untung, dan bahkan memiliki volatilitas untung-rugi yang lebih drastis dibandingkan investasi pasif (membeli reksadana secara teratur)? Ini adalah contoh-contoh pertanyaan institusi legal dan etis selalu tanyakan kepada calon klien dan kliennya. Sepengetahuan saya, Jouska tidak melakukan ini. <em>Actually</em>, dilihat dari metode investasi asal-asalannya, Jouska sendiri juga mungkin tidak tahu cara berinvestasi saham publik.</li><li><strong>Tidak memiliki lisensi.</strong> Sebelum mendedikasikan dana sekecil apapun, cari tahu dan konfirmasi bahwa mereka sudah memiliki semua lisensi yang dibutuhkan. Jika ragu, kontak <em>call center</em> OJK, atau email <a href="/service/mailto:konsumen@ojk.go.id">konsumen@ojk.go.id</a>. OJK juga memiliki list investasi yang tidak terdaftar dan tidak dibawah pengawasan OJK di <a href="https://sikapiuangmu.ojk.go.id/">https://sikapiuangmu.ojk.go.id</a>. Hanya karena institusi mereka dibawah naungan PT, bukan berarti mereka berlisensi untuk memberikan <em>advice</em> investasi dan menjadi manajer investasi. Jouska dan <em>affiliated entities</em>-nya adalah contoh lembaga perantara efek dan manajer investasi yang tidak berlisensi, dan harus dihindari. <em>Hats off</em> kepada Satgas OJK yang secara cepat menyelesaikan kasus ini.</li><li><strong>Lain-lain.</strong> <em>Website </em>Bahasa Inggris atau Bahasa Indonesia penuh <em>typo</em>, pendiri tidak memiliki <em>background</em> sektor keuangan atau secara hyperbolis memamerkan pendidikan, pengalaman keuangan, dan kekayaan yang mungkin palsu, marketing penuh <em>gimmick</em> yang berlebihan, dan lain-lain. Untuk hal lain-lain ini, cara yang paling baik adalah memasang <em>mindset</em> pesimis dan meminta opini orang lain yang terpercaya.</li></ul><p>Sis: “Mantap nih bro, gue nemu investasi yang ngejanjiin gue bunga 10% tiap bulan. Di <em>endorse</em> si [selebgram/artis] juga btw. <em>Also</em>, liat nih profil Instagram <em>founder</em>-nya. Rumah gede, tas Celine.”</p><p>Bro: “Ah, deposito di bank gue aja cuma 5% per tahun, sis! Mana ada bisa jamin 10% per bulan. Skema ponzi itu kayaknya — kalau untung segede itu mah itu investor bule di <em>Wall Street</em> ngepercayain semua uang mereka aja ke mereka. Email atau telpon dululah sama OJK, punya izin atau nggak. Palingan Celine-nya juga minjem temennya, biasalah, bikin konten-konten marketing gitu.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40c8a89f8548" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dignity & Co.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/dignity-co-9c1e8b05989a?source=rss-d0daee035783------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c1e8b05989a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[workers-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[impact-investing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andra Jatikusumo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Aug 2019 05:43:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-02T10:28:23.165Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A call to stand up for your rights at work and to run ethical businesses.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UPh6koGlObPbnxb9tFMAHQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>My day-to-day life in private equity investing primarily revolves around screening Southeast Asian companies and start-ups our firm should invest into and partner with. The bread-and-butter activities of my type of work are relatively finance-centric: understanding industry growth, competitive landscape, supplier and customer relationships, shareholding and transaction dynamics, profitability and returns metrics, quality of management, etc.</p><p>Over the years, I’ve learned that there’s more to investing than just numbers you can model up in Excel and data you can benchmark in Bloomberg. At least at the firm I work with, core to its investment philosophy is to only support and invest in companies that are ethical in the way they conduct their businesses. There’s zero tolerance for getting entangled with companies blatantly involved in depraved activities: child trafficking, dumping of hazardous waste, selling of human organs, etc. There’s no price tags associated with them. They’re flagged as no-gos.</p><p>Increasingly, everyone — not just investment professionals — has been looking at an aspect of corporate ethics that doesn’t necessarily make headlines, as it isn’t an apparent trigger of reputational risk: the respect for employees’ rights. It’s a subset of ethics that, despite it permeating our daily lives, is unfortunately often ignored, not just by employers, but interestingly by employees, too.</p><p>I’ve met a couple of relatives and friends, asking their experience on how their rights as employees have been treated throughout the course of their careers. Instead of discussing cases on how they stood up when they felt their rights were violated, some were even surprised to understand they possessed such rights at all. Their experience — getting their resignation letters rejected by their supervisors, having their proposal for a dedicated smoking room to avoid pregnant non-smokers getting second-handed laughed at — were so embedded in their corporate culture to an extent they’re perceived as normal.</p><p>“After all, we’re just idle pawns in a life-long chess game of capitalism, right?”</p><p>No.</p><h3><strong><em>Stand up for your rights</em></strong></h3><p>Employers must respect employees’ rights and employees must hold tight onto their rights because those rights symbolize respect for human dignity. What a grandiose, fancy statement – but as pessimistic as you are reading this, you know you hate it when you’re objectified. Violating them simply means dishonoring employees’ status as human beings, who are inherently worthy. Respecting workers’ rights has nothing to do with achieving employers’ KPI targets on employee satisfaction, corporate sustainability, or legal compliance. Violating them is simply unethical.</p><p>But first, on ethics: I see ethics as a set of norms deriving from a common denominator interplay among every individual’s moral compass, often pre-agreed, but may occasionally be fluid at times. It’s relational and communal. In the context of respecting people, I believe we’ve collectively pre-agreed not to dilute a maxim that we’re worth it, in-and-of ourselves.</p><p>Such philosophy should and must apply within the corporate setting. Disrespecting employees is an unethical venture.</p><p>21st century capitalism should not advocate for lord-serf or master-servant relationships popular back when the whole world were still driven by feudals. Responsible capitalism — our form of capitalism — must be entrenched on various parties voluntarily making decisions on commerce together, both employers and employees wielding equal negotiation leverage. Yes, it’s rarely the case. But that just means we should strive towards eliminating significant power gaps between employers and employees in every key aspect affecting both.</p><p>Given the power gap, our job as employees at the least is to ensure for our rights not to be meddled with. Here’s how I see this can unfold – some based on real-life accounts of the people I spoke to.</p><ul><li><strong>Right to no harassment</strong>. Physically and mentally, directly or subtly. Say you’re a CBD warrior. On your way to the pantry, your superior starts calling you names, or worse: bro-ing his way through, performing inappropriate gestures. Or say you work for a law firm, and your partner starts smearing your name to his/her deemed equally unethical clients or partner buddies. <em>To do: report those who harassed you — or best, find a bunch of other guys / gals who’ve been harassed by the same person, and make your case. Like these </em><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/12/us/yale-fraternities.html"><em>Yale students</em></a><em>. Or the #MeToo movement.</em></li><li><strong>Right to no racism</strong>. You’re an Asian studying engineering: of course you’re an introverted math-whiz, right? Thus for a project involving a TED-talk-like presentation in front of 100+ people, your boss puts you at the backseat, in charge of swapping slides for some guy named Chad from <a href="https://www.instagram.com/litquidity/?hl=de">@litquidity</a>. <em>To do: stand up for yourself and tell your boss: just because Chad’s English isn’t ESL, it doesn’t mean he’s better than you in the intonation management department. Highlight your boss’ unconscious bias towards a particular race, professionally.</em></li><li><strong>Right to physical safety</strong>. You work 9-to-5 in a building construction department, but your employer tells you to buy your own helmet and buy your own insurance. “We’re running short of budget here.” <em>To do: gather others who are planning to join and propose to management to have your safety basics covered.</em></li><li><strong>Right to due process for promotions and terminations</strong>. It’s promotion season. You’ve been awarded “employee of the month” 12 months in a row, and last time you checked bankruptcy filings, the company you worked for wasn’t there. On a Monday morning, HR told you to clean up your desk and leave the company’s premises immediately. When you asked why, they said “just because.” <em>To do: don’t take that “just because”. Find a way to meet your supervisor at least to get an answer — never settle. You deserve to know why you’re fired.</em></li><li><strong>Right to form a bargaining group</strong>. You work for a 5-star hotel, who held your paycheck for 3 months straight with no explanations why. You formed a group — call it a union, but the hotel started firing those leading the union, on the basis of them “destabilizing the cultural integrity of the hotel chain.” <em>To do: report the hotel to relevant authorities.</em></li><li><strong>Right to quit.</strong> You’re done working because of personal reasons — enough savings to travel the world, getting ready to nurture your newlyborn daughter. You submitted your resignation letter and signed a non-compete, but your boss rejected your resignation, with a letterhead template, signed by all his fellow C-levels. <em>To do: aside from being not classy at all, that’s an illegal move from your employer’s side – at least in Singapore, the country I’m residing in. Re-assert and stand up for yourself.</em></li></ul><p>… and other rights not outlined here.</p><p>“Standing up for yourself” or “gathering others who are in the same boat to opine together” is easier said than done. It’s indisputable that employers have far more substantive bargaining power vis-a-vis their employees, simply by the nature of their size, capital, and resources. Yes, the employer-employee relationship is asymmetric, but it doesn’t mean that it’s impossible to protect your right and advance your interest.</p><p>In a worst case scenario, whereby you’re working for an unethical company and your fighting hard for your right didn’t work out, at least you should be immensely proud of yourself. It will trigger some unwanted repercussions, no doubt. But you stood up, protected your worth, and did the right thing. Even better: you defended others who haven’t had the chance or haven’t mustered the courage to speak up yet.</p><p>Better than being an “idle pawn in a life-long chess game of capitalism.”</p><h3><strong><em>Do ethical companies fare better?</em></strong></h3><p>I’m not entirely a fan of justifying acts from a pure consequentalist perspective, including when it comes to fighting for employees’ rights. Respecting others shouldn’t solely be driven by the desire for any form of expected positive reciprocation in the future, including because such act will be advantageous to the employers in the long term. It doesn’t sound genuine, it’s prone to overseeing minority rights, and it departs from the notion of respecting people for respecting people’s sake. Employee’s satisfaction and happiness shouldn’t just be a monthly KPI to target just because it’s good for the employer.</p><p>Still a supportive argument to make, nevertheless.</p><p>There’s a wide range of research on whether ethical companies thrive better, stronger, and more profitable compared to their less ethical counterparts. An easy gauge to see if they do or don’t is to check out if these companies make more money if they’re more ethical, including ethical in terms of respecting their employees’ rights.</p><p>So are they more profitable? Are their stock returns better? Questions like these gave birth to research within a segment of investing known as impact, sustainable, or responsible investing. It’s a practice of investing that believes in investments that take into account social aspects of the assets without sacrificing investment returns. Some even extend the argument by saying that ‘ethics’ in itself is a source of alpha for the stock.</p><p>However, my cursory read of articles available publicly gave me mixed answers on whether ethical companies fare better: <a href="https://www.blackrockblog.com/2019/08/08/esg-metrics-that-matter/">Blackrock said</a> companies with clearly delineated ESG policies don’t necessarily do better than others, <a href="https://justcapital.com/">JUST capital</a> returns don’t deviate much from S&amp;P 500’s, etc.</p><p>On the surface, downsides of being ethical include the need to pay for insurance, pensions, and all other tangible and intangible resources needed to facilitate an ethical work environment. But to me, it’s intuitive that in the long run, respecting your employees always works to your advantage. Some catalysts below. I leave it to full time researchers to run regressions on whether the benefits outweigh the costs:</p><ul><li><strong>Less employee turnover.</strong> Employees who are treated well and are happier stay longer. Those who aren’t happy would even quit for lower-paying jobs simply to search for places with better culture. That’s less recruiting costs for you, as the employer.</li><li><strong>Greater employee engagement.</strong> Employees who are asked to be an active part of the team and speak up will have more skin in the game and greater sense of ownership, leading to greater productivity. That’s greater volume per head for your topline P&amp;L.</li><li><strong>Stronger corporate reputation and brand equity.</strong> Gossipping is within people’s nature — those working for an ethical (or an unethical) company will tell others. Also, customers increasingly care about who made their products, how, and whether they’re ethically produced — arguably the previously unseen drivers behind <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/df314088-8b91-11e9-a24d-b42f641eca37">Beyond Meat’s pricey IP</a>O or <a href="https://www.vox.com/2018/12/17/18144250/sweetgreen-jonathan-neman-fast-food-salad-delivery-blockchain-kara-swisher-decode-podcast">Sweetgree</a>n — a salad bar — raising VC money. That’s some massive save on your marketing spend department.</li><li><strong>Fewer litigations.</strong> You don’t want to be stuck facing a prosecutor somewhere, settling triple-digit millions because of unethical conducts — you get to save these and capex them somewhere productive. That’s you avoiding getting embroiled in courtroom shenanigans.</li></ul><p>Being legally compliant checks the box, but it isn’t enough. Legal compliance isn’t the mere bedrock of business ethics. Companies must go above and beyond their fiduciary duty and answer not only to their shareholders, but also to their stakeholders, which include their employees. Existing so-called shortterm-ism — getting on analyst calls every quarter — doesn’t mean ignoring employees’ rights and reasonable demands.</p><p>At my line of work, our workstreams include performing extensive due diligence on a company on commercial, financial, tax, legal, and reputational fronts. Arguably, there’s an increasing focus on the latter. Reputational risk analysis goes beyond just screening whether anyone within the potential investee company is on the Panama papers. Potential investors formally and informally utilize all diligence tools at their disposal — including crosschecking with their competitors — on whether the potential target company conducts its business within an accepted ethical framework.</p><p>How’s management’s view on ESG? What do employees think of founders’ leadership style? We’re trained to leave no stones unturned during diligence, and I’m genuinely proud of how the investing industry has marched towards a more ethical, sustainable trajectory. Putting an optimist hat on.</p><h3><strong><em>Our duty</em></strong></h3><p>What’s left to do then?</p><p>If you’re working for someone, always ensure to stand up and speak up for yourself and your colleagues in need. If you sensed, witnessed, or experienced unethical behavior in your workplace, use all available channels provided to direct your voice. If that doesn’t work out, organize up. Guard and advance your rights as employees. You shouldn’t let your dignity be stepped on.</p><p>If you’re the employer, hats off to you if you’re actively incorporating and articulating human dignity within your company’s DNA. Thank you for paving the way towards a more ethical economy. If you haven’t consciously thought about it yet, look inward first instead of outward — there’s no need to score a moral compass medal by establishing external CSR efforts, without first setting up your house in order.</p><p>“So we should be active playmakers in a life-long ball game of capitalism?”</p><p>Yes.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c1e8b05989a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/dignity-co-9c1e8b05989a">Dignity &amp; Co.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>