<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Güneş Ünüvar on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Güneş Ünüvar on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@gunuvar?source=rss-faff44324895------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 08:52:44 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@gunuvar/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chapter I: The Dust]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gunuvar/chapter-i-the-dust-e1e83124abfa?source=rss-faff44324895------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e1e83124abfa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fantasy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Güneş Ünüvar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 Feb 2026 16:34:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-21T16:34:55.287Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2cQMeBGcL9cJQUZ5woGWIA.png" /></figure><p><em>Barracks of Seinrock-upon-Deathwall, the Channel of Khàras</em></p><p>The night was too quiet.</p><p>The Channel of Khàras is never quiet. Not if you’ve lived here long enough to know what the Channel looks like when it decides to eat men alive. And I, Kharlyn, have been on this cliff long enough.</p><p>Most nights you hear <em>something</em>: the groan of timber from ships leaning into the current, the distant barks of orders over the water, the wind clawing at the cliff face, the wheeze of some poor bastard trying to breathe through broken ribs in the infirmary below. Tonight there was only the wind.</p><p>Even the Channel sounded like it was holding its breath.</p><p>I stood at the upper outpost on the cliff edge, staring down into the dark cut we called the Deathwall. That wasn’t a poetic name. If you slip, you’re gone. If the kheron, the war-crazed people on the other side of the Channel hellbent on invading our lands, charge the cliff and push you over, you’re gone. If your mind cracks and you decide you’ve had enough and step forward…</p><p>You’re gone.</p><p>“<em>Sir?</em>”</p><p>The voice pulled me out of my thoughts. I turned to my right and found the boy who shared this post with me. He was trying to look older than he was — jaw clenched, shoulders square, eyes a little too wide.</p><p>“It’s almost midnight,” he said.</p><p>He was right. The sky above the Channel was a strange, pale blue instead of the usual hard, suffocating black. An odd kind of brightness that made everything look washed-out and sick.</p><p>“Yes,” I said. “Almost.”</p><p>He glanced down towards the lower outpost a long way below, where the shore met the dark water.</p><p>“Should I signal?” he asked. “To the lower outpost, I mean.”</p><p>I watched him for a moment. He was gripping his sword too tightly. The knuckles on his fingers were white.</p><p>“Do you want the honest answer?” I asked.</p><p>He swallowed. “Yes, sir.”</p><p>“We’ve delayed as long as we can,” I said. “If we wait any longer, the tide changes, and with it our chance.”</p><p>He nodded, clearly not reassured, then looked at me as though hoping I might still change my mind. I didn’t.</p><p>“Light it,” I said. “Let’s see if tonight wants to kill us quickly or slowly.”</p><p>He ran out to the beacon, unhooked the lantern, and touched the flame to the tarred wood. The signal torch caught on the first try, a bright orange wound cut into the pale blue dark.</p><p>For a few heartbeats nothing moved.</p><p>Then shadows separated themselves from the cliff base far below. One by one, boats pushed out from under the overhang where we’d hidden them from kheron eyes. First ten, then twenty, then rows and rows — little black shapes gliding out into the Channel in perfect silence.</p><p>The vanguard.</p><p>I felt the usual lurch in my stomach. You plan the thing for weeks… You calculate the current, the wind, the moonlight, the visibility from the watchtowers on the eastern side. You argue with your lieutenants and send messengers to the Crimsonhold to reassure commanders who have never seen Khàras in their lives. It all feels abstract, lines on a map.</p><p>Then the first boat leaves shore and suddenly it’s real.</p><p>“If this works,” I said under my breath, mostly to myself, “half of us might live long enough to go home.”</p><p>The boy heard me anyway. His mouth twitched into a nervous smile.</p><p>“I’ll head down,” I told him. “Watch the Channel till dawn. If we’re lucky you’ll see our banners on the far side.”</p><p>“And if we’re not, sir?” he asked.</p><p>“Then you’ll see the banners of the enemy instead. Either way, someone will be there by morning.”</p><p>He didn’t laugh.</p><p>The path from the upper outpost down to the lower one was steep and slick with old spray. We’d hacked crude steps into the rock over the years, but the cliff still liked to remind you who was master here. I took my time, boots finding the familiar notches, hand sliding along the rough, damp rope we’d strung as a railing.</p><p>Halfway down, the smell of the sea hit me properly: salt, tar, and that copper tang that never really left the Channel, no matter how long it had been since the last good slaughter. Thirty years of war had soaked this coast so thoroughly that I sometimes thought if you wrung out the rocks, they’d bleed.</p><p>By the time I reached the lower outpost, the vanguard boats were already halfway across the Channel — black dots in a silver-gray strip of water. Behind me, Seinrock-upon-Deathwall huddled against the cliff like it was afraid the wind might tear it off and throw it into the sea, a fear firmly embedded within its history.</p><p>My lieutenants were waiting near the shoreline.</p><p>“Sir,” said Wynd Redscar, giving me the formal salute — hands crossed over chest, head dipped — before relaxing into something closer to how he actually spoke to me. We’d grown up together in Aìmon; years of campaigns hadn’t knocked that out of him yet.</p><p>“Commander,” said Farran Bayforth, younger, sharper, helm tucked under his arm. Clever eyes, a little too fast for his own good.</p><p>Behind them loomed Galvor Valòras, or the ‘Bear’, as the soldiers called him. He didn’t bother with formalities beyond a short nod. When you have killed as many men as Galvor has, and survived as many fronts, you earn certain privileges.</p><p>“Report,” I said.</p><p>“Vanguard away, no losses,” Wynd said. “Winds are on our side for once. If they hold, they’ll make the far shore in four hours, give or take.”</p><p>“Unless the kheron decides to come visiting,” Farran added. “Assuming they’re actually asleep and not waiting for us behind every rock and tree.”</p><p>“Always a joy to hear your optimism,” I said.</p><p>“My caution is learned,” he said. “A little bit of paranoia. Which is why I am still alive.”</p><p>He wasn’t wrong.</p><p>We boarded one of the larger boats — the kind we usually reserved for supply runs. Tonight it carried me, Wynd, Farran and a dozen more soldiers. Another big boat behind us was stacked with crates of spare weapons and equipment. Smaller craft packed with infantry bobbed in our wake.</p><p>“Cast off,” I said.</p><p>The ropes were slipped free. Oars dipped into the Channel with soft, practiced motions. No shouted cadence, no drums; this was supposed to be a ghost crossing.</p><p>The current took us.</p><p>If I’ve learned anything from war, it’s that quiet can be more terrifying than battle.</p><p>In a fight, there’s noise, movement, something to push back against. In silence, all you have are your thoughts. And the longer you stare at the dark horizon, the more your mind fills it with things.</p><p>Half an hour into the crossing, Farran shifted beside me on the bench.</p><p>“Look at the sky, sir,” he muttered.</p><p>I already had. The colour was wrong — it has been for the entire night, but now it was beyond doubt. The dawn should have been a faint band of grey over the eastern cliffs, but instead the whole sky above the far shore glowed with a thin, icy blue — like light seen through thick ice. It didn’t strengthen or fade with time. It just…hung there.</p><p>“Unusual weather,” I said carefully.</p><p>“It gives me chills,” Farran replied. “And not the pleasant kind.”</p><p>I didn’t answer. I was supposed to be the one who didn’t spook. Commanders don’t get to admit they’re unnerved by the colour of the sky, or the way the air tastes, or the feeling in their bones when the Channel is too calm. You start doing that, your men will happily follow you right over the edge of the Deathwall.</p><p>I glanced back. Galvor’s boat was keeping pace behind ours. Even from this distance I could see him standing at the prow, huge arms folded, gaze locked on the glowing horizon as if he might wrestle it into telling him its secrets.</p><p>We reached the opposite shore roughly four hours later, just as Wynd had predicted. The landing point was a narrow strip of shingle squeezed between steep, pine-clad slopes and the Channel’s cold water. The vanguard had already arrived. Boats lay pulled halfway up the shore; men were stacking crates, checking gear, stamping their feet to get feeling back into them.</p><p>The air on this side of the Channel felt different.</p><p>Colder, yes. Khàras is no tropical haven. But this cold had a bite to it, like breathing in ice dust. And that same pale blue haze hung above the trees, thicker now, curling along the ground in thin tendrils.</p><p>Galvor strode over as soon as my boots hit the shingle.</p><p>“Landing secure,” he said, voice like gravel. “No sign of kheron patrols. No fires inland. No watchers on the ridge. Nothing.”</p><p>“Nothing at all?” I asked.</p><p>He shook his head. “Too quiet.”</p><p>“You too?” Wynd said under his breath. “Starting to sound like Farran.”</p><p>“I’ve fought kherons longer than you’ve held a sword, boy,” Galvor rumbled without looking at him. “They don’t leave a defensive shore like this unscreened by accident. Something’s going on.”</p><p>Farran stepped in, unable to leave it alone. “Which is exactly why I suggested we should assume an ambush. With respect, sir, this entire landing feels wrong. They’re proud, not stupid.”</p><p>“Ambush isn’t their style,” I said. “You know that. Zealous convictions define their strategy — usually to their disadvantage.”</p><p>“I know what they <em>used to do</em>,” Farran answered. “I don’t know what they do now. None of us has fought a war that dragged out like this one before. We’ve been trying to gain a foothold on this side of the Channel for five years — or is it six? This is too easy — too good to be true.”</p><p>He had a point, and it irritated me.</p><p>“Fine.” I exhaled sharply. “We’ll adapt. We establish a foothold here, then send scouts inland before we move the main force.”</p><p>I turned back to the shore, gesturing to the half-finished camp.</p><p>“This place needs a name,” I said. “If we survive, history will ask where we crossed.”</p><p>“Blue Landing,” Wynd said immediately, nodding up at the unnatural sky.</p><p>“That’ll do,” I said. “Galvor, throw up a perimeter. Twelve tents and a central marquee for command. I want wood for barricades. Nothing fancy, just enough that if kherons decide to finally show up they can’t roll straight through us in one push.”</p><p>“You heard the Commander!” Galvor roared at his vanguard. “Move! You want to live to see breakfast, you build!”</p><p>Men scattered, shouting to each other as they dragged logs and planks from the treeline. Fires took, sputtering weakly in the damp air. A small pocket of familiar activity grew on the alien shore.</p><p>It didn’t help.</p><p>No birds. That was what bothered me most. On this side you always had gulls, crows, those irritating little cliff-swallows that liked to shit on armour. Here? Nothing. No calls, no rustle of wings, not even the buzz of insects.</p><p>“Have you noticed,” Wynd said quietly at my shoulder as if he’d read my mind, “that it’s <em>too</em> quiet? Where are the birds?”</p><p>“I’m aware,” I replied. “Don’t start sounding like a poet. It doesn’t suit you.”</p><p>“Just saying,” he murmured. “I’ve never seen a forest this still at dawn.”</p><p>I looked up at the haze again. It wasn’t just hanging there; it was rising, thin threads streaming upward from somewhere beyond the ridge, as if the land itself were exhaling blue smoke.</p><p>We were losing time. We’d planned to hit the kheron town of Tyxan before full daylight — strike fast, burn supply caches, pull back to the Channel and meet the second force. The longer we lingered, the more likely someone on this side would notice our little armada and send word up the chain.</p><p>“Farran,” I said, turning to him. “Pick five of your sharpest men. Lightly armoured. You’ll scout ahead — no further than the first rise. You look for tracks, encampments, fresh fires, anything. If it looks untouched, you send one runner back to report and then push on towards Tyxan. If it doesn’t look untouched, you run back yourself and tell me why.”</p><p>“Yes, sir,” he said. “And if we <em>do</em> find evidence of them falling back?”</p><p>“Then we thank the Elder Gods for a small mercy and follow the plan,” I said.</p><p>He gave me a thin smile and jogged off, calling for volunteers.</p><p>Wynd waited until he was out of earshot, then said quietly, “You didn’t answer him.”</p><p>“I answered him perfectly well,” I replied.</p><p>“You didn’t answer the <em>important</em> bit,” Wynd persisted. “What if this isn’t them falling back? What if this is something else?”</p><p>I looked at him for a long moment.</p><p>“I don’t know,” I said at last. “Which is why we’re sending scouts and not the entire damned army.”</p><p>Galvor rejoined us about an hour later. The camp was in as good a shape as you could hope to get on an enemy shore before breakfast.</p><p>“Perimeter set,” he said. “Half of Watchers of Death will remain here to hold the Landing. Other half are ready to march with you.”</p><p>“And Farran?” I asked.</p><p>“Still out,” Galvor replied. “Too long for my liking.”</p><p>Mine too.</p><p>We left the Blue Landing with two hundred and fifty infantry and sixty elite forces at our back, moving into the trees in a long, loose column. The forest closed around us quickly — dark trunks, thick undergrowth; and a persistent, deafening silence.</p><p>The further we went, the thicker the blue haze became. It coiled low to the ground, then curled higher, turning the trees into shadows and smudging the world into layers of grey and pale turquoise.</p><p>“Spread out,” I ordered. “No one loses sight of more than two men to either side. If you can’t see them, you’re too far.”</p><p>We advanced in fits and starts. Every few dozen paces, the chief navigator would stop, squint into the murk, and adjust our course.</p><p>“Never seen fog like this,” he muttered once, not quite under his breath. “It’s not coming in from the Channel. It’s…rising.”</p><p>I heard it too: not the words, but the thin strain in his voice. Old men from Seinrock do not spook easily. They’ve spent their lives on the edge of the Deathwall. When they start talking about strange fog, you listen.</p><p>“Is Tyxan close?” I asked him.</p><p>“Should be,” he said. “If this damned mist would get out of the way, I could tell you for sure. We’re on the right line. The trees thin about a quarter-mile ahead. After that, it’s all slope down to the shore.”</p><p>He was right about one thing: the trees did start to thin.</p><p>He was wrong about it helping.</p><p>As the trunks spread out, the haze thickened, turning from stray threads into a proper blanket. My vision sank down to a few yards. The soldiers nearest to me were pale shapes with darker blobs where their faces were. Beyond that, just shadows and that relentless blue glow, like we were marching inside a dead man’s dream.</p><p>Somewhere ahead, a man screamed.</p><p>Not the sharp cry of someone startled. The long, breaking howl of someone genuinely terrified.</p><p>I pushed forward, elbowing through my own front line. Galvor and Wynd closed in at my heels.</p><p>The scream cut off.</p><p>“Where?” I called.</p><p>“Here, sir!” Another voice, strained, off to the left.</p><p>Shapes parted, and I saw one of my soldiers half-fallen, one leg twisted as though caught in a trap. He was clawing at his boot, trying to tear himself free.</p><p>“Get back,” I snapped, grabbing his shoulder and dragging him away.</p><p>Something lay on the ground where his foot had been.</p><p>For a heartbeat, it was just a shape in the haze — a dark mass, larger than any human, armour broken and twisted. Then the mist shifted, and I saw grey skin, thick cords of muscle, and a hand the size of a small child’s torso, fingers still curled where they’d gripped the boy’s ankle.</p><p>A kheron.</p><p>I’ve killed more kherons than I care to remember. I have seen them angry, screaming, dying, laughing as they bled, dragging men down with them as they fell. I have never seen one like this.</p><p>He was shaking. Not with rage — with fear. His eyes found mine. They were wide and glassy, white rimmed around dark irises. His chest hitched, struggling for air.</p><p>I dropped into a crouch, ignoring the way the cold seeped through the plates of my armour, and switched to kherae, hoping I remembered enough of the language to be understood.</p><p>“Who are you?” I asked in his language. “What happened here?”</p><p>His lips cracked as he tried to speak. The sound that came out was a croak, dry and broken.</p><p>“Plague,” he whispered in our language. “Run.”</p><p>The word rasped in his throat, thick with an accent I hadn’t heard in years, but I understood it well enough.</p><p>“What plague?” I demanded, switching back to my native tongue. “From where?”</p><p>He coughed, wheezed, and forced the next word out like it cost him everything.</p><p>“Tyxan. The Capital.”</p><p>His hand spasmed, clutch slipping on the rocks.</p><p>“Speak,” I snapped. “What is in Tyxan? What did this?”</p><p>He tried. I saw the effort in the cords of his neck, in the tension in his jaw. He got as far as “Run — ” again.</p><p>Then he came apart.</p><p>There’s no better way to describe it. One moment there was a kheron soldier at my knees, armour dented and filthy, breath frosting in the cold air. The next, the flesh and bone of him just…unwove. His body collapsed inward silently, collapsing into a drift — a cloud — of fine, glittering dust, pale blue and faintly luminous. It rose.</p><p>The dust poured upward as if the air were water and something above us was drawing it in. It twisted once, twice, then streamed into the haze overhead and was gone.</p><p>Only his battered armour remained, clattering empty onto the stones.</p><p>Behind me, someone swore. Someone else whispered a prayer. I heard the sound of steel scraping on scabbard leather, the rasp of men tightening grips on weapons that, suddenly, looked very small.</p><p>I stood slowly.</p><p>All around us, other little fountains of blue dust were rising in the fog — here and there, in ones and twos, farther off by the slope where Tyxan should be. Each one marked a place where somebody had died in a way no mortal should.</p><p>Wynd stepped up beside me, voice low.</p><p>“Qarlynn,” he said. “What in all the Elder Gods’ names was that?”</p><p>I looked past him, towards where the land fell away. Through the thickening glow, I could just make out the vague shapes of buildings, a cluster of darker blocks in the mist.</p><p>Tyxan. Or what was left of it.</p><p>For thirty years I had lived with the certainty that war was the worst thing the world could throw at me. Watching those dust-clouds rise, feeling that wrong, icy light prick at my skin, I realized I was wrong. War was just what mortals did to one another.</p><p>This was something else entirely.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e1e83124abfa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Teaching Space Law to Younger Generations]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei/teaching-space-law-to-younger-generations-8d129e994e49?source=rss-faff44324895------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d129e994e49</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[space-exploration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-mining]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-debris]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[outer-space]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Güneş Ünüvar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 May 2024 15:34:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-20T17:08:41.274Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Dr. Güneş Ünüvar</em></p><p><em>Editor-in-Chief,</em><strong><em> Pulsar Blog</em></strong></p><p><em>Postdoctoral Researcher, </em><strong><em>Luxembourg Centre for European Law (LCEL), University of Luxembourg</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JcNZQdcnniAT3qW3H7kYvg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>DIMAS (<em>Diplôme d’initiation aux métiers aéronautiques et spatiaux) </em>and Space Law</strong></p><p>On May 17th, 2024, I had the distinct pleasure of visiting Lënster Lycée International School (LLIS) in Junglinster, Luxembourg to engage with high school students and to talk about space law and policy. I was invited to LLIS in the context of the <a href="https://lpem.lu/offre-scolaire/diplome-dinitiation-aux-metiers-aeronautiques-et-spatiaux-dimas/">DIMAS</a> programme (<em>Diplôme d’initiation aux métiers aéronautiques et spatiaux</em>), a collaborative project between several Luxembourgish schools which offers secondary education and vocational training students an introduction to various aeronautical and space professions. This involves providing them with training prior to higher studies in aeronautics and aerospace. The coordinator and one of the teachers of the programme at LLIS, Damir Dodić, has a master’s degree in aeronautical engineering. It is also important to note that all participants, teachers and students alike, do this in addition to their curricular work. They voluntarily stay at school every Friday afternoon just for these lectures since October 2023. The sacrifice and determination it takes to voluntarily stay at school at the end of each week for months is no joke.</p><p>Even as a scholar and lawyer with plenty of experience in teaching and public speaking at academic conferences, as well as other forms of public outreach (including media interviews), the preparation for this one-day visit was not straightforward. I had the impression that my particular experience and teaching style would not apply to a group of high schoolers. Everything I had taught or presented up until that point was either to peers (professors, practicing lawyers, or PhD candidates) or to master’s and bachelor’s level students at various universities. One can assume that all of these groups above have a certain degree of knowledge in (international or national) law, so a lot of things could be presumed to be known. Space law is a technical, specialized, ‘niche’ subject even for those specialized in international law. If I had a euro for each time I heard the phrase “I didn’t even know there was a space law!” from a fellow lawyer, I could easily afford my own spaceship.</p><p><strong>Space and Our Innate Curiosity</strong></p><p>How, then, was I supposed to make this relatable to high school students? For me, this was completely new territory — and while it was somewhat daunting, it was equally exciting. Explaining something complicated or technical in simpler terms, they say, is a good indicator that one knows the subject well. With this in heart, I began preparing my classes. I focused on the fundamentals, building bottom-up: what are some of the key issues to which anyone could relate about outer space? Everybody likes to think about the stars. Everybody, at some point in their lives, looked up to the skies and stars and wondered why they are the way they are. I decided to start with this innate curiosity we have about space and what is above us. I wanted to give them a quick recount of why space is part and parcel of every culture — and how our fascination with the Sun and the Moon and the stars probably gave us our first spiritual experiences as the human civilization.</p><p>In the morning, this is how I started teaching to a class of 13 to 15 year-old students. After having established that space is not only for sci-fi geeks and that we are all predisposed to be curious about it, I talked about what kinds of activities we are currently engaged with in space: satellite operations, exploring the Moon and Mars and eventually beyond. Then, I asked them whether they think laws and lawyers had any place in outer space. This question surprised some of them. “Do you mean, like, Murphy’s law, or laws of physics?” one student asked me. When you are a lawyer trapped in your legal echo chamber, a question like this can surprise you to no end. “I mean legal rules and legislation, or perhaps international laws,” I clarified.</p><p>One student, for example, wrote that “there should be law in space if humans are in space, as anywhere humans go law needs to follow.” Another observed that “since the beginning, humans have always felt the need of owning something they discover or find. Wars over the centuries prove this. That is why it would be very positive for laws to be established.” Another passionately noted that “it can easily become an extravagant display of disgusting wealth very quickly… although i think it could be necessary”, while one student observed that there should indeed be laws, “or else people would start to claim land and there would be no peaceful space exploration. Also, people can come together to create more technology and can go further.” One student brought up the issue of ‘colonization’. Finally, one student succinctly concluded that “it barely [made] sense.”</p><p>Having avoided mentioning any policy-related issue before asking the question on whether law or lawyers should exist in outer space, I can assure the readers that these reactions are pure observations by the students themselves. Anyone with even the most superficial knowledge of the state of policy and legal affairs in space law will immediately see the parallels between these reactions and the current state of affairs and discussions in multilateral fora, such as the UN COPUOS.</p><p><strong>Colonizing Space?</strong></p><p>I lead the discussion with the term ‘colonization’. What does it mean to colonize a place, as opposed to, for example, ‘using’ or ‘exploring’ that place? Students quickly contextualized what colonization means, noting that on Earth, it had very negative and exploitative connotations. When I asked them to elaborate, they noted that colonization occurs when a group goes to a country with a native population there, and subjugates and harms that native population. The colonizer then uses the natural resources and the native population gets nothing out of that interaction — only harm and suffering. I pushed a bit more: “So, can we colonize space? As far as we know, there are no populations there.” One student responded that “we can still harm the environment in space — that can also be colonization.”</p><p>This observation inevitably conjures up images of reckless and ruthless destruction of environment by colonizing powers. Indeed, the destruction wrought upon a territory by colonization is so multi-faceted that we often forget what it does to environment. It reminded me how the British literally blew up a ridge in Guatavita, Colombia to drain a lagoon so that they could pillage the gold that was reportedly at the bottom. They could not find anything, but the effects of the environmental catastrophe that followed still resonate to this day. It is not farfetched to imagine a mining company in space blowing up hills and ridges or craters in hopes of finding valuable subsurface resources or extracting water ice.</p><p>The class eventually contended that we could indeed colonize space, if we go there to exploit and destroy — and if we act irresponsibly and with no regard to the consequences of our actions. As this debate was continuing (between the students, with little or no intervention on my side), I had realized that I dramatically underestimated my audience. I felt very happy about how sophisticated and nuanced the debate had become. Even though I had prepared multiple other topics to discuss, this first question (out of nine questions I had prepared for discussion) took up all of our allocated time, and we had to conclude.</p><p>The second group I taught in the afternoon was older: 16 to 18 year-old students. The first question I posed was the same as my morning group: do we need law and lawyers in space? The answers were similar: “it is crucial to establish legal frameworks to govern activities such as resource extraction, territorial claims, and even potential conflicts”, or that “yes, or else there will be no consequences to immoral actions committed in space and there will be no limits to our actions.”</p><p><strong>Space Mining and Owning Space</strong></p><p>We then turned our attention to the specifics of space mining. By this point, I had told them that there were some international agreements that set the ground rules in outer space — you are free to use and explore outer space, but only peacefully and cooperatively. In addition, you are not allowed to ‘claim’ any territory in outer space, and no celestial object can be owned by any state or non-state entity.</p><p>Then, I asked them what they thought about owning a part of a celestial object. “What if you mine the Moon and extract chunks of it — can you own that?” The overwhelming majority said that yes, you could; or you should be able to as long as the celestial object remained intact. “But what is intact?” I pushed back. “If you remove half of a comet made mostly of water ice, would you say the comet is intact?” This intrigued them, and as they scrambled to find an answer to this question, I assured them that nobody knew the answer to it as it was not clear at all. What is the boundary between mining an asteroid and ‘appropriating’ it? There is indeed no magical answer.</p><p>Both classes were very concerned by the encroaching influence of the hyper rich (the “one percent”, one called them), and thought that allowing them to act without rules in space can only be bad news. Unsurprisingly, Elon Musk’s name came up multiple times, mostly with negative connotations. Most students disapproved of his aspirations to ‘colonize’ Mars, and contended that whatever he wanted to do there, it had to be done in accordance with a space law. I assured them that Mars was not a lawless place — that international space law applied to it, and that Elon Musk could not seize it without breaking an international law rule or two.</p><p>“But how do we enforce this law?” one student asked. If you are an international lawyer reading this, you must be smiling bitterly. “There is no police force to enforce it,” I said. “International law is a system based on good faith and the conviction that if you agree to something, you will comply with it. If not, there are international courts and other tribunals. Otherwise, there are more ‘informal’ ways of enforcing, such as economic sanctions. But it is very, very complicated,” was all I could say. They weren’t impressed.</p><p><strong>Space Debris (and How to Fix It)</strong></p><p>The final topic we covered was the Earth orbit and space debris. The week before, I was told, they had visited <a href="https://www.ses.com/fr">SES</a>, one of the biggest satellite operators in the world. It is headquartered in Betzdorf, Luxembourg, a fifteen-minute drive from LLIS. I asked them what they learned there. They told me about the expansive uses and functions of satellites, how we depend on their functionality to use applications like Google Maps. They also pointed out that space debris is an important issue, and that when a satellite is no longer functional, it tends to stick around the orbit a while longer and sometimes it is removed to a higher orbit, called a ‘graveyard orbit’.</p><p>I asked them if they knew how much space debris currently orbited Earth. When you tell a group of students “tens or hundreds of thousands, depending on their size,” that is one thing. It is another thing entirely when you <em>show</em> them. I quickly opened the internet browser and showed them the eye-opening, real-life visualization of space debris provided by <a href="https://wayfinder.privateer.com/">Wayfinder</a>. They collectively gasped when I told them all pink dots they saw on the live map represented defunct satellites or pieces thereof: space junk. They served no purpose, and the more space junk there is, the more likely that they will slam into something that is functional and create even more debris.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7EqJB3OxDeDj03271Dt9IQ.png" /><figcaption>Privateer Wayfinder. Source: <a href="https://wayfinder.privateer.com/">https://wayfinder.privateer.com/</a></figcaption></figure><p>They immediately started thinking about ways to prevent it. “Can we clean up or recycle them?” one asked insightfully. “That is the plan,” I answered, and noted that there are many companies and projects trying to find a feasible way of doing just that. “It is expensive, though,” I added, “each pink dot you see on the map costs millions of US dollars to clean up. Multiplied by a couple of hundreds of thousands, you’ll get a rough idea.”</p><p><strong>“What Can I Do?”</strong></p><p>Something remarkable happened at the end of the class: something that has never happened to me before after a university course. A student came up to me and told me that he wanted to ask a question. “Go ahead,” I told him, expecting something related to law or the facts that we had discussed. “What can I do?” he asked eagerly. I was a bit taken aback, and asked him what he meant. “About the space debris, for example,” he clarified. “This is my future,” he said passionately. “I don’t want the orbital debris to block us out of outer space. This is my future, and they are ruining it.” he repeated. This was easily the most meaningful question that was asked all day, and served to prove that what I intended to achieve that day was achieved.</p><p>This brief experience at a high school taught me many things, but one thing stands out. Education and awareness about space activities, the legal and political framework governing their future, is not something that should be confined to any particular level of education. It should start as early as possible. This is indeed their future. Today’s decision-makers may see some of the destructive effects of impending global catastrophies such as climate change or an irredeemably polluted Earth orbit, but his generation <em>will</em> feel the brunt of both if we do not start acting responsibly. I had expected to speak about the basics of outer space activities and what kinds of rules and principles are in place today to a group of high schoolers, but I ended up doing much more. They are extremely smart, insightful, and most importantly — they are ready to act.</p><p>It is our responsibility to share what we know with them as peers and fellow Earthlings — not to patronize them, but to show them what <em>can</em> be done now and how they can help prevent their parents messing it all up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d129e994e49" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei/teaching-space-law-to-younger-generations-8d129e994e49">Teaching Space Law to Younger Generations</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei">Pulsar — A Space Law and Governance Blog</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is There Space for Everyone?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei/is-there-space-for-everyone-900b9852eb6c?source=rss-faff44324895------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/900b9852eb6c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[moon]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Güneş Ünüvar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Jul 2023 10:27:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-06T10:27:36.574Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Is There Space for Everyone? Younger Generations and Multi-Stakeholder Engagement in International Space Law and Policy</strong></h3><p><strong><em>A Conversation with Dr. Antonino Salmeri</em></strong></p><p><strong>Dr. Güneş Ünüvar<br></strong><em>Editor-in-Chief<br>Pulsar</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*E2Brthpj4QTQGc7qLbvXrQ.png" /></figure><p>For the first edition of what will hopefully become a long-standing series of conversations with space law and policy experts, I would be hard-pressed to talk to someone more fitting than Dr. Antonino Salmeri. First of all, he is easily one of the most prominent rising stars in international space law, having already achieved an impressive professional career. Currently, he is one of the Co-Chairs of the <a href="https://spacegeneration.org/">Space Generation Advisory Council</a> (SGAC); has recently completed a highly innovative PhD thesis on Lunar governance (which has been published as a well-received book pretty much <em>as is</em> — a feat impressive in itself) at the University of Luxembourg; and has been involved in a myriad of policy initiatives, among them the ongoing Lunar Policy Platform Initiative funded by the <a href="https://www.openlunar.org/">Open Lunar Foundation</a>, as well as the SGAC’s <a href="https://spacegeneration.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/EAGLE-Report.pdf">2021 EAGLE Report</a>.</p><p>Beyond his impressive credentials — which he somehow managed to cram into a little more than seven years — there is a more personal reason why Dr. Salmeri was the natural choice for this first edition. My introduction to <em>Alpha Persei</em>, therefore the process leading up to the establishment of the <em>Pulsar Blog</em>, dates back to a networking event he organized in Luxembourg, sometime in early 2022. Barely a few months into my decision to start a research project on international space law, I found myself at a “Space Café” at the Mousel Brewery in Clausen, down by the Alzette River, at the centre of Luxembourg. It was my first time among the brilliant engineers, entrepreneurs, officials, researchers, and policy-makers active in Luxembourg’s vibrant space sector. That is when I met Harry Ghillemyn, one of the co-founders of Alpha Persei and the driving force behind it. Shortly after, I started conceptualizing what has now culminated into this very blog. Dr. Salmeri’s drive for bringing people together, which also reflects in his professional work, is quite literally the starting point of it all.</p><p>Below are the highlights of our very insightful conversation in May 2023 in Limpertsberg where we discuss making a tangible, impactful difference in international space law and policy, the importance of multi-stakeholder engagement, as well as the future of space activities on the Moon and beyond.</p><p>**</p><p>Dr. Salmeri began his legal training at the University of Catania, in Italy, where his dissertation focused on constitutional law and general theory of law. “<strong>I have always been very passionate about governance systems and political systems, how they are designed, and how institutions play a role</strong>”, he notes. After doing his first LLM on European Union law in Rome, he quickly realized that EU law was a highly saturated field: “<strong>EU law is quite inflated and it would have taken me a very long time to have a meaningful impact, and I really like to make a practical difference.</strong>” This principle, namely making a difference, seems to have driven his every move from then on.</p><p>It was around this time, in late 2016, that he was introduced to the universe of space law through a presentation by Elon Musk. “<strong>He was devising this plan to establish a colony on Mars — I was fascinated,”</strong> he recalls. However, he quickly adds that he does not endorse Mr. Musk’s more recent trajectory: “<strong>At the time, he was different.</strong>” Then, the urge to make an impact, to instigate a change, kicked in. “<strong>I have always been passionate about astrophysics and engineering. When I found out about Musk’s plan, I started thinking: in order to have a colony on Mars, you need laws. Someone will need to rule this colony. There will need to be sovereignty and jurisdiction. How do we answer these questions?</strong>” He quickly discovered the so-called <a href="https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/introouterspacetreaty.html">Outer Space Treaty</a> (OST) and the <a href="https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/intromoon-agreement.html">Moon Agreement</a>. Reading about the non-appropriation principle enshrined under Article 2 of the OST, which prohibits national appropriation of outer space by claim of sovereignty or any other means, he immediately realized the unique characteristics of the field. “<strong>No sovereignty? It was incredible. Overall, it also matched my interest in governance systems,</strong>” he recalls.</p><p>The first breaking point was his decision to study space law in Leiden back in 2017, under the supervision of Prof. Tania Masson-Zwaan. “<strong>That changed my life forever,</strong>” he says. “<strong>I wanted to write a dissertation on a possible constitution for Mars, but Prof. Masson-Zwaan encouraged me to focus on something more practical — namely, space resources.</strong>” Barely two years after the promulgation of <a href="https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/2262/text">the US Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act</a>, coupled with <a href="https://space-agency.public.lu/en/agency/legal-framework/law_space_resources_english_translation.html">the then-brand-new 2017 law in Luxembourg</a>, the timing seemed impeccable. Ultimately, he wrote a thesis on the interpretation of ambiguous provisions through national legislation, which was published in <a href="https://airandspacelaw.olemiss.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/full-issue-43.1.pdf">the Journal of Space Law</a>.</p><p>Despite distancing himself from more traditional reiterations of constitutional law, it is evident that his foundations firmly grounded in this field has had an impact on his work on space regulation. It wouldn’t be too farfetched to argue that the OST provides a constitutional framework (it is often called the ‘Magna Carta’ of space law) for the regulation of space activities. It is broad in scope, assertive in its aspirations — but like many constitutions, general in its language and often lacks further specification. It is through national frameworks that this general framework trickles down. His work on space law gives a novel twist to this constitutionalist approach.</p><p>Shortly after, and with the emergence of the Artemis Programme, his interest in space resources zoomed in on the Moon. A myriad of issues remained unresolved. “<strong>You need to find a site, you need to land on the site, you need to establish infrastructure, get power, get transportation, and then you need to find the resources, and then you need to start mining it, then processing, storing, and transporting. None of this will happen in a safe and sustainable manner if you don’t have appropriate governance mechanisms in place.</strong>” These considerations eventually prompted him to start his PhD research, which he now completed and published as <a href="https://law-store.wolterskluwer.com/s/product/the-multilevel-governance-of-space-mining/01t4R00000P3nDnQAJ">a book</a>, on the multi-level governance of space mining on the Moon.</p><p>**</p><p>In addition to his academic work, Dr. Salmeri is deeply involved in the work of several non-governmental organizations (NGOs). In general, NGOs are embedded within different layers of international law and policy-making. They provide key expertise on matters of importance, they help identify priorities for future policymaking, and give direction to how current points of contention can be addressed in a way that takes different stakeholders’ perspectives into account. International space law happens to be one of these domains where NGOs and other non-state entities substantially contribute to this process of policy-making, which is something that became clear to Dr. Salmeri during his PhD. He began to actively collaborate with the SGAC, a reputable global NGO and a professional network which places a great emphasis on the cross-generational dialogue and the representation of younger generations on matters concerning space. It was this cross-generational perspective that caught his attention, as it elevated the voices of the future generations. “<strong>When you are saying something on behalf of the young generation, it starts to have a more practical value as well. So I transformed my research into policy positions that could be advocated by the young generation.</strong>”</p><p>Continuously driven by making a tangible and practical impact, he founded the so-called <a href="https://spacegeneration.org/eagle">Effective and Adaptive Governance for a Lunar Ecosystem (EAGLE) Project</a> under the auspices of SGAC, which eventually culminated in the EAGLE Report, prepared by a team of 14 young experts across different disciplines. The Report proposes the adopting of a Lunar Charter to give a regulatory foundation to the future Lunar activities. In June 2021, it was presented during the 60th Session of the Legal Subcommittee of the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (<a href="https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/copuos/index.html">UNCOPUOS</a>). “<strong>It offered me the opportunity to start getting involved in the discussion with more actionable proposals,</strong>” Dr. Salmeri says, emphasizing that this was the beginning of his focus on the broader civil society beyond the generational layers. “<strong>That’s when I started working with the Open Lunar Foundation. As a policy analyst, I was helping them to understand the policy implications of their mission, which is to promote the cooperative and peaceful development of the moon. And then towards the end of [2022], I realized that I wanted to start something dedicated specifically to lunar policy and the applicable standards of behavior.</strong>” He proposed, and received funding for, the Lunar Policy Platform Initiative — a project primarily focused on establishing and maintaining multi-stakeholder communication on safe and sustainable lunar development. “<strong>The goal is to develop some predictability into how we conduct activities on the Moon, formalizing expectations of behavior and understanding, for example, if you want to establish a landing site on the Moon, the processes that you need to go through. If you have finally established a landing site, how do you manage it, and how do you handle your relationship with others active on the surface? The idea was that we needed an actor who connects all other actors.</strong>”</p><p>Dr. Salmeri believes that this high involvement of NGOs and other non-state actors in international space law and policy was an incremental process, but it certainly comes with the territory. “<strong>Space law is 70 or 80 per cent international law. Because of that, it remains in the hands of states. The law-making is done through international treaties and soft law instruments. However, because of the increased role that space plays in the global scene, the complexities that the private sector and NewSpace involvement brings, as well as the increased difficulty in governing space, the involvement of non-governmental entities has increased.</strong>” In addition to the SGAC and Open Lunar, in which he is directly involved, he quickly names the International Institute for Space Law, Secure World Foundation, and For All Moonkind as other examples.</p><p>As of 2023, <a href="https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/copuos/members/copuos-observers.html">49 NGOs, academic institutions, and other non-governmental entities</a> hold permanent observer status at the UNCOPUOS, the primary global multilateral forum where international space law and policy is regularly discussed. <strong>“[All of the NGOs above] are observers at the UNCOPUOS,</strong>” he notes. “<strong>Because of the intergovernmental nature of UNCOPUOS, they are not entitled to take any decision or contribute to any decision-making. Even though observers get the opportunity to speak, and sometimes their contributions are invited, primary inputs are provided by States — who hold the control of the process. They have the discretion to do what they want with the information provided by the observers. This is a bit different than the </strong><a href="https://www.itu.int/en/Pages/default.aspx"><strong>International Telecommunications Union</strong></a><strong> (ITU) system, which incorporates a sector membership for NGOs and private organizations. Even sector membership does not provide the right to vote, but it gives private actors an autonomous channel to provide their input.</strong>” However, despite this limited role NGOs might seem to have on paper, the reality is more complex. “<strong>In practice, the relevance of NGOs comes from the unique expertise and perspective they can provide, because States know very well that they do not have all the answers to the questions that we need to address.</strong>”</p><p>An important layer to NGO and civil society participation is that it boosts the systemic legitimacy, where different perspectives of different layers of society are heard and, to the extent possible, incorporated into the law and policy-making — both substantially and procedurally. “<strong>On a substantive level, if we are talking about how to keep the skies clean and free from debris </strong>[in reference to the <a href="https://www.iau.org/public/darkskiesawareness/">Dark and Quiet Skies Initiative</a>]<strong>, therefore usable by generations for observation of the stars, or if you are thinking about what to do and how to do it on the Moon, non-state engagement becomes critical. Even though, and legally speaking, the Moon is not the heritage of humankind except for the Moon Agreement parties, it is still culturally very relevant and important to all of us. Spiritually, it is considered to be sacred by many cultures around the world. When you include the input of young generations, indigenous organizations, scientists, and companies, you will see an important difference.</strong>”</p><p>In addition, non-state participation in these processes can elevate the legitimacy of the process, beyond the substance itself. The process, however, is inherently state-centric in the sense that it does not have a structural preconceptualization of how non-state actors ought to participate in the process. “<strong>The world is much more complex than that. We cannot grasp everything through legally binding instruments or even soft law instruments. There is a whole realm of norms of behavior and practical considerations that will not be developed by states, either because they don’t have the capacity, or because they don’t have the interest. And that is where NGOs can play an increasingly important role. The problem is that there are no structures or processes to navigate this realm, and create content. It happens pretty much randomly, based on the initiative that one or two actors have. It is not systematic, regularized, or holistic. So there is room for NGOs to come in and give a framework to these processes to make sure that on top of international law, or at the bottom of international law and everything, we also have coordinated development of policies and standards of behavior. This is also what the Lunar Policy Platform is set out to do — providing a space, and institutionalized processes, for discussing about policies and standards of behavior and increase predictability in the system.</strong>”</p><p>**</p><p>In the course of our conversation, I found myself fascinated by, and constantly going back to, the work conducted by the SGAC and the demography it asserts to represent. Coming from an international economic law background, the notion of a non-governmental institution acting on behalf of ‘young generations’ is as novel as it is ingenious to me. My experience in observer participation in multilateral law and policy-making initiatives, among them the United National Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) Working Group III (WGIII) on Investor-State Dispute Settlement, is relatively bland. As of 2023, around 40 observers regularly attend UNCITRAL WGIII. The overwhelming majority of the non-governmental observers are either arbitration centers or academic institutions. There are those who explicitly favor the <em>status quo </em>and attend the meetings to voice the concerns of foreign investors, and others who are vehemently critical of the current state of affairs and emphasize a broader societal engagement in addressing the reform process; but none expressly seek, for example, to ensure that the international foreign investment protection regime should take the concerns and perspective of future generations into account. International space law is, to my knowledge (as was also concurred by Dr. Salmeri), the only field of international law where such cross-generational platform is provided.</p><p>Dr. Salmeri is certainly aware of this void in other fields. “<strong>Even though in climate change there are some small groups, there is nothing like SGAC, at least not as large,” </strong>he observes.<strong> </strong>While he sees this as a problem, he is hopeful about the future. “<strong>The United Nations Secretary-General is proposing the development of an intergovernmental forum for youth engagement and providing the opinion of the young generation at the UN level. This is part of the plan for the UN Summit of the Future that will take place in 2024. So I think, if anything, [SGAC] is actually a blueprint for other sectors to start doing the same in their own area.</strong>”</p><p>It is admittedly a professional deformation on my end, but I need things defined when they can be. What exactly is meant by ‘younger generations’? “<strong>Based on our statutes and bylaws, anyone between the ages 18 and 35,</strong>” Dr. Salmeri clarifies. (<em>Editor’s note: I still have about half a year before I fall outside the scope of SGAC</em>). And what does representing an entire generation –or multiple layers of different generations- look like? Younger generations, just like previous generations, harbour a multitude of diverging and clashing opinions — our societies are defined not only through shared feats but also our social, political, economic frictions. How does the SGAC address these differences? Has there been any pushback, any denouncement by the members of this so-called younger generations? “<strong>SGAC has existed for over 20 years right now. We have representation in 165 countries. We have about 25,000 members all around the world, and we have a number of different sections, or pillars, as we call them, in SGAC. There is a whole structure that substantiates this claim or assertion of representing the young generation.</strong> <strong>We have never received any pushback — nobody ever said, ‘You don’t represent us’,</strong>” he notes. Despite any divergence the younger generations will have, his emphasis rested on the undeniable fact that they would share a fraction of time and space on our Earth’s lifespan, during which decisions taken in the past would unleash their consequences on them.</p><p>He maintains that this perspective was surprisingly missing from the SGAC’s <em>modus operandi</em> when he first got involved. “<strong>I was witnessing the community coming together, at least states, to decide what to do with, say, the Moon. Companies were trying to come up with their own ideas as well, in line with their goals. I was seeing that the voice of the youth was missing in that process. No one was saying, you know, ‘The Moon belongs to us. Whatever you decide today, we will bear the consequences of it in 30, 40, 50 years. You should consult us if anyone else, we should have a say in this, or at least should provide our opinion.’ That there was no one providing that voice, no one providing that viewpoint, no one saying this is what the youth wants. I wanted to change this.</strong>”</p><p><strong>**</strong></p><p>By this point, I was very eager to hear what Dr. Salmeri had in store for the future. “<strong>I want to dedicate the best of my energies to the Lunar Policy Platform,</strong>” he responds. “<strong>I want to establish, coordinate, and manage this dedicated platform for the identification of lunar policy priorities and the development of standards of behavior for safe, predictable, and sustainable lunar activities. I am in the process of gathering partners, contributors, advisors, and sponsors to make sure that this proceeds in the right direction. We are actually starting a pilot in [June 2023], and in November, we will present the results of this pilot at the </strong><a href="https://parispeaceforum.org/en/"><strong>Paris Peace Forum</strong></a><strong>, which is a global, high-level, diplomatic forum that takes place every year. At that event, we will have a roundtable to introduce our first Lunar Priorities Report. We will outline and explain what the community undergirding the lunar ecosystem thinks are the priorities to be addressed. Once we have done that, we will start working on these priorities, item by item.</strong>”</p><p>As also evidenced by his existing work, he seeks to deliver impactful, tangible outputs and contribute to how humanity will engage with the rest of the universe. He does not outright exclude a return to academia, but he remains resolute about the impact factor. “<strong>I don’t know if I will go back to academia. I mean, some research every now and then, I like it and I think it is important, but I want to dedicate my energies to deliver practical impact. Between now and April 2025, I am in the leadership of SGAC, so I have that responsibility towards the organization. I will carry it forward to the best of my abilities, and the priority for me in that area is to bring SGAC to contribute to key global processes such as the </strong><a href="https://www.un.org/en/common-agenda/summit-of-the-future"><strong>UN Summit of the Future</strong></a><strong> or the </strong><a href="https://www.royal.uk/news-and-activity/2023-06-28/the-king-unveils-the-astra-carta-seal-at-a-space-sustainability"><strong>Astra Carta</strong></a><strong>.</strong>”</p><p>**</p><p>My conversation with Dr. Salmeri lasted less than an hour, but it was nothing short of a well-informed, multi-layered lecture in its own right. The work conducted by NGOs, like SGAC and Open Lunar, are potentially paradigm-altering. International space law and the intense engagement by the NGOs in it is a living, breathing example of how non-state actors can contribute to the making of international legal and political orders through expertise and valuable policy work. They can provide immense support on how to set our priorities straight. It shakes the traditional dominance of (and perhaps the overreliance on) states over the creation and maintenance of the international legal order in ways not possible in many other legal fields today. What is even more heartening is that as non-state actors are willing to participate, states appear to be willing to allow them. It is seen as a way to democratize and legitimize the way international law is made, and as Dr. Salmeri also notes, international space law could serve as a blueprint in other fields of international law.</p><p>There is no question that the multitude of perspectives from all layers of our society enriches our engagement with outer space. One cannot help but hope that, as humanity ventures farther into space, the lopsided interests dominating our planet, the senseless destruction we have wrought on our home, the mistakes we have committed down here, are a little less likely to repeat themselves. Ultimately, I believe, this is what the struggle is for.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=900b9852eb6c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei/is-there-space-for-everyone-900b9852eb6c">Is There Space for Everyone?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei">Pulsar — A Space Law and Governance Blog</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pulsar: A ‘Cosmic Lighthouse’ for Space Law and Governance]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei/pulsar-a-cosmic-lighthouse-for-space-law-and-governance-c6ecbc658ae0?source=rss-faff44324895------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c6ecbc658ae0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[space-mining]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space-policy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Güneş Ünüvar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Jul 2023 10:17:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-06T10:17:28.417Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Dr. Güneş Ünüvar<br>Harry Lars Ghillemyn</strong><br><em>Editors-in-Chief<br>Pulsar</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8ZliNsK6POWcmBFbew93fg.png" /></figure><p>Welcome to Pulsar, a blog dedicated to the fascinating and dynamic realm of space law, investment and governance.</p><p>As humanity continues to push the boundaries of space exploration, the need for a comprehensive legal and regulatory framework has never been more crucial. This blog aims to provide a platform for inter- and trans-disciplinary discussions, critical analysis, and thought-provoking insights on this rapidly developing field.</p><p>As we embark on this journey to explore the legal and governance aspects of outer space, Pulsar will feature a diverse array of content, including:</p><p><strong>Analyses</strong> are mid-length, peer reviewed articles (2000 to 4000 words) focusing on cutting-edge research, legal and interdisciplinary theories, and innovative solutions to address the challenges posed by the growing commercialization and militarization of space. Articles will also explore topics such as property rights in space, liability for space debris, and the regulation of commercial space activities from the perspective of international and national legal spheres.</p><p><strong>Blogposts</strong> are short, peer-reviewed articles (no more than 2000 words) which provide concise, engaging, and informative posts on the latest news and trends in the world of space law and governance. Our blog posts will cover a wide range of topics, from new legislation and treaties to emerging challenges and controversies.</p><p><strong>Interviews</strong> provide exclusive insights from leading experts, policymakers, and industry professionals, as they share their perspectives and experiences on the most pressing issues in space law and governance. Our interviews will shed light on the challenges, opportunities, and future trajectories of this burgeoning field.</p><p>**</p><p><strong>Pulsars</strong> are neutron stars, rotating with incredible speed and mind-boggling precision — they are dubbed “cosmic lighthouses”. This is why we call our platform Pulsar, in the hope that it provides guidance to those who seek to understand and navigate the legal and policy aspects of this vast, fast-paced and ever-expanding new frontier. We recognize that regulation, use, and exploration of outer space is an intricate web of legal, political, economic, and technological considerations. As we reach for the stars, the need to establish a robust, ethical, and equitable system of laws and norms becomes increasingly critical. Pulsar will serve as a hub for the exchange of ideas and knowledge, fostering a vibrant community of individuals passionate about the future of space exploration and the legal frameworks that will shape it.</p><p>We are very excited to embark upon this journey, and we encourage you to be a part of it. You can submit your contributions via gunes.unuvar@alphapersei.com, and reach out for any inquiries regarding the blog — and be sure to keep an eye on this space.</p><p><em>Sic itur ad astra.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c6ecbc658ae0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei/pulsar-a-cosmic-lighthouse-for-space-law-and-governance-c6ecbc658ae0">Pulsar: A ‘Cosmic Lighthouse’ for Space Law and Governance</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/pulsar-by-alpha-persei">Pulsar — A Space Law and Governance Blog</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Kahve]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@gunuvar/kahve-511d09772b22?source=rss-faff44324895------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/511d09772b22</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Güneş Ünüvar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Nov 2022 17:34:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-09T17:40:25.764Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5oZQcP8DP7xCdu5N1bh2hA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Kokuların, diğer duyulara oranla insanın geçmişine giden en kestirme yol olduğunu düşündüm hep. İnsan bir kere gördüğü şeyi tekrar göremiyor, duyduğu sesi bire bir tekrar duyamıyor, dokunduğuna dokunamıyormuş, bir kere baktığı manzarayı tekrar göremiyormuş gibi gelir bana kendimi bildim bileli. Koku duyusu hep biraz farklıydı benim için. Her duyu kendince farklı, kendine has olsa da, bir kere kokladığım hiçbir şeyi tekrar koklayamadığımı içten içe bilsem de, bu gerçeği hep yok saydım. İnsan hiçbir zaman aynı kahveyi nasıl tadamıyorsa, koklayamıyor da. Yine de adını koyamadığım bir zamansızlık, bir devamlılık hissi saklıymış gibi gelir bana kokularda. Eski bir tanıdığın, bir sevgilinin parfümünü sokaktan geçerken başkasının üzerinde duyduğum an, o kişinin yanına gidiveririm. Mangalda pişen tavuğun, kızaran patlıcanın, biberin kokusu hep çocukluğumdaki pikniklere götürür. Tüpten gelen gaz kokusu hep aynı paniği salar tüm benliğime. Çam kokusu mutlu eder, mor sümbül kokusu hala anlamsız yere midemi kaldırır. Hepsi, ama hepsi, mutlaka geçmişteki bir anı kafamın içinde tekrar tekrar yaşatır, kısa ama hep aynı videoları kafamda döndürür. Islak köpek kokusu mesela, gençken evladım gibi baktığım köpeğimi getirir aklıma, sanki yanı başımdaymış, kafamı çeviriversem bana doğru koştuğunu görecekmişim gibi beni o andan söküp alır — akan zamanı yarım saniyeliğine unuttuğum o an geçip gittiğinde de beni yine zamanın akışına acımasızca bırakır. Hep de düşerim bu tuzağa. Bu sefer farklı olacakmış, bu sefer zamanın kör karanlık, dolambaçlı koridorlarından bir çıkış bulmuşum gibi. Elbette hiçbir zaman bulamam. Kimse bulamadı.</p><p>O eski sevgilinin elli tane resmini görsem, saatlerce kayıttan sesini dinlesem, o bir nefeslik sürede yaşadığım zaman yolcuğunun yerini hiçbir zaman tutamaz. Çocukluğumdan beri kaç kere ızgara tavuk, yoğurtlu patlıcan kızartma yemişimdir; kaç kere çam ormanına kaçmış, kazara Datça’da, Bodrum’da, Foça’da bir apartman girişini insafsızca saran sümbüllere bakıp yolumu değiştirmişimdir; kaç tane yıllar önce ölen köpeğime benzer köpek görmüşümdür, bilmiyorum. Onlarca, yüzlerce belki. Hiçbir görsel, işitsel ve tensel temas, beni kokuların etkilediği kadar etkilemedi.</p><p>Bunları ve bunun gibi ne başı ne sonu olan bir sürü konuyu teker teker kafamda döndürdüğüm gri ve soğuk bir pazartesi sabahı, Kopenhag’daki Nørrebro İstasyonu’nda, şehrin kuzeyindeki Klampenborg adlı bir sahil kasabasına gidecek treni bekliyordum. Sabah sanırım sekiz civarıydı. Tren, Avrupa’nın birçok başkentinde olduğu gibi Kopenhag’da da çok sık kullanılan bir toplu taşıma aracı olageldi. Şehrin birçok yerinden bu istasyona gelip, buradan metroya, bazen otobüse aktarma yapıp, işine gücüne koşturan insanların yanımdan geçip gidişlerini biraz kayıtsız, biraz anlamsız bir hüzünle izledim. Bu şehre ilk taşındığım zamanlarda, insanların hemen hepsinin gözüme ne kadar güzel, değişik geldiğini hatırlıyorum. Aklıma birkaç kere kendimi Danimarkalı kadınlara bön bön bakarken yakaladığım, sonra utanıp günlerce sokakta -yanlış anlaşılmasın diye- kafamı kaldırmaya utandığım günler geldi. Şimdi belki yine güzeller, ama herkes aynıymış gibi geliyor. Yine kafamı kaldırmıyorum, yine pek insanların yüzüne bakmıyorum; ama utandığımdan falan değil. Mecalim yok, ilgim de kalmadı. Arada sırada bakışıp karşılıklı hafifçe gülümsediğimiz tonton yaşlı nine ve dedeler dışında tanımadığım insanlara yaklaşımım biraz bu ülkenin insanlarınınkini andırır hale geldi. Danimarka’da insanlar pek tanımadıkları insanlarla konuşmaz, muhatap olmazlar. Yer yol sorarsanız elbette sizi terslemezler, ama bir bağlam, bir sebep, bir zaruret ya da keyfiyet yoksa, kimse kimsenin neyle ilgilendiğini, durduk yere halini hatırını sormaz. Bununla beraber, öyle bir toplum bilinci var ki, eğer bir kuralı çiğnediğinizi gören olursa derhal müdahale eder ve sizi uyarırlar. Bir kere hatırlıyorum, annem bizi ziyarete gelmişti. Ne Danca ne de başka bir yabancı dil konuşmadığı için, benim olmadığım zamanlarda dışarıya çıkması gerektiğinde vücut dili ve çat pat İngilizcesi ile kelime kelime anlaşmaya çalışırdı. İşte olduğum bir saatte köpeğimi gezdirirken, hayvanın iki kere büyük tuvalet yapacağı tutmuş. Birincisini elbette elindeki poşetle toplamış, ama ikinciyi yapınca poşeti kalmadığı için onu alamamış. Hayvancağız da zaten köşede bir çimenliğin oraya yapınca, annem de nasılsa kimse üzerine basmaz diye hiç almaya yeltenmemiş. O sırada koşu yapan Danimarkalı bir kadın, annemi biraz çatık kaşlı ve sert bir şekilde uyarmış. Annem durumu anlatmaya çalışmış, ama tabii ki anlatamamış. Kadın da üsteledikçe üstelemiş. En sonunda annem ‘Eeh, yürü git be!’ diye kadının üzerine yürüyünce, o atletik kadıncağız ne olduğunu anlayamayıp derhal toz olmuş.</p><p>Değişik kadındı annem. Ufak tefek vücuduna, ucu bucağı olmayan o ruhunu hiç sığdıramadı. Neye isyan ettiğini bilmeden, ama isyanını da hiç kesmeden, kavgayla, gürültüyle, kahkahayla, çığlıkla yaşadı gitti öylece. Keşke burada olsaydı.</p><p>Tam kendi kendime bu köpek hikayesine (belki üç yüzüncü kere) gülümserken, trenin ışıkları yavaş yavaş tünelin ucundan belirdi. S-Tog dedikleri banliyö trenlerinden birisi. Benimle beraber kalabalık bir grup yolcu da trenin gelmekte olduğunu fark edip, hafifçe peronun ortasından ucuna doğru hareketlendi, neredeyse bir metronom düzenindeki adımlarıyla, yerde güvenli mesafeyi belirten sarı çizgiye kadar yekpare yürüyüp durduk. Trenler sinir bozucu derecede dakiktir Danimarka’da. Toplu taşımaya yönelik hiçbir şeyin geç kalmasından, gelmemesinden, eski olmasından yana bir romantizm mümkün değildir. Anadolu’da, mesela, gelmeyen, geç gelen, ya da kafasına göre gelen, gelip gelmeyeceği meçhul trenler üzerine yazılmış ne kadar da çok şarkı, türkü, hikâye vardır, bilinmez. Bu tip güzellemeler, romantik betimlemeler, bir atomik saat dakikliğinde çalışan sistemlerde pek işe yaramaz. Belki de bu Cermen halklarındaki romantizm yoksunluğu, toplumların saat gibi işlemesinden kaynaklanıyordur. İşin paradoksal yanı da şu ki, saat, zamanı temsil eder. Zamandan daha romantik bir şey düşünemiyorum. Ama demek ki, zamanın içine işlemiş olan o melankoli, zamanı taklit ya da temsil eden şeylere sirayet edemiyor. Tıpkı yapay bitkilerin sıkıcılığı -kokusuzluğu- gibi.</p><p>Tren en sonunda yavaşladı ve kapıları tam da peronun yerlerine işaretlenen kapı kısımlarına denk gelecek şekilde durdu. Kapılar yavaşça açıldı, Nørreport’ta inecekler sakin sakin trenden inip peronun çıkışına yollandılar. Herkesin indiğinden emin olduktan sonra, peronda trene binmek için bekleyen yolcular, ben dahil olmak üzere, hiç acele etmeden trene bindik. Yirmi yıldır yaşadığım bu şehirde bir kere bile trene paldır küldür binmedim, hiç gerek olmadı. Her zaman oturacak ya da insanlarla sıkış tıkış olmaya gerek kalmayacak bir köşe bulabildim. Güney şehirlerinde (Atina olsun, İstanbul olsun, Roma olsun, Ankara olsun) o trene binme yarışları, buradaki insanları dehşete düşüregelmiştir. Bir noktada, güneyli olmama rağmen, bana da tuhaf gelmeye başladı bu. Fakat sonra bunun bizim kanımıza işlemiş bir kalıtsal çakallık olmasından ziyade, toplumsal güvensizlikten kaynaklandığını fark edince çok üzülmüştüm. Üzülecek başka şey kalmamışçasına, böyle ufak tefek şeylere üzülür olmuştum üstüne üstlük. Fakat bu ufak tefek şeyler bir toplumu toplum yapıyormuş. Sanıyorum en çok da bunu fark ettiğimde üzülmüştüm. İnsanlardaki bu dinginlik, bu arkayı sürekli kontrol etmeye gerek olmaması hali, bir kayıtsızlığa, sıkıcılığa sebep oluyor, tamam. Ama günbegün romantikleştirdiğimiz her şeyin -ama her şeyin- acıdan, eksiklikten ve yokluktan doğduğunu fark etmem de çok zaman almadı. Keşke kimsenin fedakârlık yapmasına, acı çekmesine, kendisini başkasının yerine bir kuyuya bırakmasına gerek olmasaydı, benim doğduğum yerlerde de. İnsan bunu istemese de düşünüyor.</p><p>Trenin kapısından geçip, sola dönüp, otomatik kompartıman kapısını elimin tembel ve rastgele bir hareketiyle (hala tam olarak sensörlerinin nerede olduğunu bilmiyorum) açtıktan sonra, trenin gideceği istikametin tersi bir koltuğa oturdum. Karşımda, yirmili yaşlarında, koyu sarı saçlı, okula ya da bir kursa gittiği belli, genç bir kadın oturuyordu. Tüm dikkatini önündeki tablete vermiş, bir şeyler okuyordu. Bacak bacak üstüne atmış, sağ dirseğini camın eşiğine yerleştirmiş, ritmik bir şekilde sol ayağını bileğinden hafif hafif sallıyordu. Yanındaki bez çantaya gözüm takıldı. ARKEN Kunst. Şehrin biraz dışındaki bir modern sanat müzesinden. Bez çantaların burada yıllar içinde nasıl popülerleştiği ve pahalı, şaşalı çantaların yerini aldığını da sessiz bir hayret ve hayranlıkla izledim. Bez çantaların artan popülerliği, bana biraz yıllar içerisinde dünyanın lüks ve parıltıyı bırakıp, kendini mat bir rahatlığa bırakışının ufak bir temsili gibi geldi hep. Takım elbiseden daha rahat kıyafetlere geçiş gibi biraz, ofis yaşantısından evde çalışmaya giden yol gibi. ‘Siz’in yerini ‘sen’e bırakması, her yeni nesilde ritüellerin biraz daha terk edilişi gibi. Bir süre bez çanta bile topladım, sanıyorum Ankara’daki evimde bir yerlerde. Bu çantanın aynısından bende de olsa gerek.</p><p>Bu genç kız, ne benim gelip karşısına oturduğumu ne de yanına gelip oturan orta yaşlı hanımefendiyi fark etmişe benziyordu. Danimarka’daki bir başka durum da budur: insanların sizin varlığınızı fark etmemesiyle, sizi görmezden gelmesi arasındaki farkı anlamanız neredeyse imkansızdır. Başlarda kişisel algıladığım bu durumu da yıllar içerisinde önce yok saymayı, sonra içselleştirmeyi ve nihayet özümsemeyi başarmış olmak, benim üzerimden ağır bir yük aldı. Hatta bir noktada imitasyona başladım. Şu an birini yok sayma konusundaki acımasız yeterliliğimi Danimarka’daki yıllarıma borçluyum.</p><p>Nørreport’tan yaklaşık on dakika mesafedeki Østerport istasyonuna kadar trenler yer altından gider. Yıllardır böyledir. Ben de bu süreyi benimsemiş olacağım ki, tren yer üstüne çıkana dek içinden geçtiğimiz o karanlığı hiçbir zaman garipsememişimdir. Østerport’a gelmeden yüz-yüz elli metre önce tren yerin altından çıkar ve sağlı sollu taş duvarları olan, tepesi açık bir aralıktan geçerek istasyona girer. Sonrası Nordhavn, Hellerup, Charlottenlund diye devam eder ve en sonunda ağaçlık bir yoldan yirmi dakikalık bir yolculuğun sonunda Klampenborg’a varılır. Aslında denize çok yakın olmasına rağmen, trenle giderken deniz görünmez. Ya ağaçlar ya binalar o görüş açısına müsaade etmez. Klampenborg’a vardığınızda denize en yakınsınızdır. Bu trenin son durağıdır aynı zamanda. Gelir bir köşe taşına, orada durur. İnenler iner, binenler biner, sonra gerisin geriye güneye, Kastrup Havaalanı’na kadar gider.</p><p>Ben de trenin durmasına yakın ayaklandım (tren durmadan ayağa kalkmazsam, sanki inemeyecekmişim gibi bir his içimden hiç eksik olmadı). Trene girdiğim kapıdan değil de az ilerideki bir başka kapıdan inmek için biraz yürüyüp, kompartımanın otomatik kapısını yine tuhaf el hareketleriyle açtım. Kapı açılınca, hafta sonundan kalma olduğu her halinden belli bir bira kokusu burnumu istila etti. Bu koku da, objektif iğrençliğine rağmen, bende hep iyi ve mutlu anılarla bütünleşik olduğundan, kokuyu almamla istemsiz bir gülümsemenin yüzüme yayılması bir saniye kadar sürdü. Başkalarının hafta sonu eğlencesini, hiç tanımadığım insanların hiç görmediğim mutluluklarını, artık zar zor anımsadığım (ve anımsadıklarımın aslında ne kadarının yıllar içerisinde kurguladığım alternatif gerçeklikler olduğunu merak ederek) gençliğimin o taze gürültüsünü kafamda canlandırarak, trenden indim. Bunların hepsi üç saniye kadar sürdü. Trenden indiğim an, unuttum.</p><p>Danimarka’ya ilk geldiğim yıllarda, buraya Geyik Parkı denen, zamane Danimarka krallarının avlandığı genişçe bir ormanı (ben geldiğimde kamuya açık bir park haline gelmişti) gezmeye gelirdik. Her gidişimde farklı bir patika bulur, değişik bir taşa rastlar, yıldırım düştüğü her halinden belli ürkütücü bir ağaç kütüğüne bakıp yıldırımın düştüğü anı gözümde canlandırmaya çalışırdım. Hayatımda ilk defa burada geyik görmüştüm. Hem de bir tane, iki tane değil; maaile. Baba, anne, teyze, amca, çocuklar, hepsi. Genişçe bir açıklık, bu geyiklerin çiftleşmesine ayrılırdı. Yılın belli dönemlerinde bu açıklığa iki yüz metreden fazla yaklaşmak tehlikeli ve yasaktı. Kaç yıldır, kim bilir kaç nesil geyik ailesi burayı yuvası bellemişti, hiçbir zaman bilemeyeceğiz. Zaten ben de bu sefer Klampenborg’a geyik görmeye gelmemiştim. Yine tren istasyonuna yarım saat yürüme mesafesindeki Taarbæk adlı, denizle orman arasına belki yüz metrelik bir alana sıkışmış, sessiz ve dingin balıkçı kasabasına gelmiştim. Yavaş yavaş aydınlanmaya başlamış, fakat griliğinden hiçbir şey kaybetmemiş tanıdık Øresund göğünün altında ağır ağır yürümeye koyuldum. Bir an, bisikleti de getirse miydim, diye de düşündüm. Sonra üç gün önce çalındığını hatırladım. Tekrar canım sıkıldı.</p><p>İstasyonun yanındaki arabalar ve bisikletler için ayrılmış park alanını geçip, dar bir kaldırımdan sahile doğru yürümeye koyuldum. İki şeritli bir şehirlerarası yoldan (yıllar içerisinde bu yolda artan tek trafik bisiklet trafiği oldu), etrafta hiç araba olmamasına rağmen koşarak geçip, genişçe bir çimenlik alana, oradan da Taarbæk’e inen patikaya daldım. Sağımdaki geniş çimlik alan, hafif bir eğime kendini bırakıp, kumsalla buluşup, denize açılıyordu. Tam kumsalla çimlerin birleştiği yerde, yıllardır taşı bile değişmemiş olan küçücük, barakayı andıran eski bir ev vardı. Yıllar önce çok meşhur bir lokanta olduğunu, insanların burada yemek yiyebilmek için aylarca rezervasyon sırası beklediğini hayal meyal hatırlıyorum. Ne durumda olduğunu tam bilmemekle beraber, bu barakanın artık bir lokanta olmadığını varsayarak ve ara ara denize bakarak Taarbæk’e inen patikanın dibine ulaştım. Burada yol, denizden kuzeye doğru kıvrılıyordu. Solumda geniş bir ağaçlık, sağımda tek tük denize bitişik evler diziliydi. Gündüz olduğu için evlerin içlerinde pek ışık yanmıyordu. Noel’den bir hafta öncesi olması dolayısıyla (gelenek olduğu üzere) bazı camlarda cılız ışıklarıyla mumlar gördüm. Bu mumlar, Yahudilerin menora ya da yedi kollu şamdan dedikleri mumluklara benzer mumluklarda olurdu, ama bu benzerliğin tesadüf mü yoksa bilinçli mi olduğu sorusuna hiçbir zaman bir cevap (muhtemelen hiç araştırmadığımdan) bulamamıştım. Dikkat edenler, Kopenhag’ın dört bir yanındaki kutu kiliselerde de Davud’un Yıldızı’nı görebilirler. Bu benzerliğin de tesadüf olup olmadığı benim için hala bir muammadır.</p><p>Taarbæk, güneyden kuzeye yaklaşık on beş dakika içinde boydan boya yürünebilir. Ben de yaklaşık on dakika ana caddede yürüdükten sonra, kasabanın neredeyse kasabanın kendisi kadar geniş marinasının hemen bitişiğindeki taş okulun arka tarafında bulunan, ana caddeden görünmeyen ama marina tarafından bakıldığında güzelliğiyle başka bir yere bakılmasına mâni olan turuncu, iki katlı bir evin kapısına geldim. Yavaşça kapıyı üç kere çaldım. Her çalışımda kalbim daha da hızlı atmaya başladı.</p><p>Kapıyı genç bir kadın açtı. Gözlerinin etrafında (gülümsemekten mi ağlamaktan mı olduğunu bilemediğim) belirmiş kırışıklıklara bakılacak olursa otuzlu yaşlarında, incecik ve sağlıklı görünen, ortalama bir Türk kadınından bir kafa kadar uzun, kumral, yeşil gözlü, ince dudaklı, çıkık elmacık kemikli, gözlerinin içi gülen bir kadın. Tüm bu kuzeyli özelliklerinin aksine, babasının genlerini esmer teni ele veriyordu. Çocukluğundan beri aşina olduğum gülümsemesini görünce, ben de gülümseyiverdim. Gülümsemesinin ardındaki yorgunluğu saklamayı beceremiyordu ama, bu onun beceriksizliği miydi, yoksa benim onun içini bilmemle mi alakalıydı, bilemiyorum.</p><p>‘Hoş geldin amca,’ dedi aksansız Türkçesi ile, sesini çok yükseltmeden, ama beni görmüş olmanın mutluluğunu da dizginlemeksizin.</p><p>‘Hoş bulduk, Denizciğim,’ dedim. Elimde tuttuğum poşeti uzattım. ‘Baban nasıl oldu?’</p><p>‘İyice,’ dedi, kendi de pek ikna olmamışçasına. Torbanın içindeki tereyağlı bisküvi kutusuna baktı. ‘Hiç zahmet etmeseydin, önceki getirdiklerin de hala duruyor.’</p><p>‘Sen yersin, incecik kalmışsın,’ dedim, gülümseyerek. ‘Yemesin zaten. Ben sana getiriyorum bunları. Onun bisküvi yiyecek hali mi kalmış?’</p><p>Sessizce dudaklarının kenarlarını yukarı büzdü.</p><p>‘Yukarıda mı?’</p><p>‘Evet. Şimdi uyuyor, dilersen biraz salona geç, az sonra yemek için uyandıracağım zaten. Kahve içer misin?’</p><p>‘İçmez miyim?’</p><p>‘Tamam,’ dedi, müşfik bir gülümsemeyle. ‘Filtre? Espresso? Türk?’</p><p>‘En kolayı neyse, o olsun,’ dedim.</p><p>‘Peki,’ dedi, mutfağa daldı. Paltomu çıkartıp astıktan sonra yavaşça salona geçtim.</p><p>Genişçe, beyaz duvarlı, duvarlarında onlarca eski harita asılı, siyah koltuklarının üzerinde memleketin neresinden olduğunu kestiremediğim örtülerin olduğu, yıllar öncesinde Ankara’da çekilmiş olduğunu hemen anlayıverdiğim çerçeveli fotoğrafların dizili olduğu camlı bir dolabın yanında üç yüz kadar kitabın düzenli bir şekilde dizili olduğu, tıpkı sahibi gibi dopdolu ama bakınca insana fenalık verecek kadar tıkış tıkış bir salondu bu. Hiç öyle misafir ağırlamaya falan debelenmeyen, sadece sahibine konuşan bir salon. Salonun girişine bitişik, bir çalışma odasına açılan bir kapı daha vardı. Çalışma odasının tam ortasında, karargahlarda üzerine büyükçe haritaların serildiği masaları andıran kocaman bir çalışma masası, tepesinde de sorgu odalarından fırlamış zümrüt yeşili bir lamba, masayı aydınlatıyordu. Şehir tasarımları, el çizimi haritalar (hem gerçek hem kurgusal coğrafyalar), manzara eskizleri her yana saçılmıştı.</p><p>Deniz mutfakta sessizce kahvemi hazırlarken, kahvenin kendisinden önce kokusu salona geldi. Kahve kokusu, hayatımın her döneminde, her yerde, her daim bana eşlik eden birkaç kokudan biri olageldi. Avukatlığa başladığım dönemde, stajımı yaparken beni içine oturttukları beş metrekarelik odamın yanındaki mutfaktan gelirdi aynı koku her sabah. Kahve kokusu, o dönemin iç bunaltıcılığıyla bağdaşacağına, o dönemi çekilir kılmıştı. Yüksek lisans yıllarında, Belçika’da, evimin mutfağından gelen Türk kahvesi kokusu beni alır memlekete götürürdü, yağmuru dur durak bilmeyen, güneşsiz Brüksel günlerinde. Yine o günlerin karanlığına yapışacağına, o karanlığı aydınlatırdı, acı acı. Gezi Parkı’nda direnirken, yaşarmış gözlerimizle, içimizdeki umudun aroması oluvermişti her akşam sığıntı gibi tıkıştığımız evlerde, ertesi günkü kapışmaları beklerken. Bir arkadaşımın gözüne polisin attığı gaz kutusu isabet ettiğinde, hastanede, ruh gibi bekleşirken de elimize kahve tutuşturmuştu birileri. Doktoraya kabul aldığımın akşamına da kutlamak için içtiğimiz ardı arkası kesilmeyen rakının üzerine de sağlamından sade birer kahve patlatmıştık babamla mesela. Doktora tezini yazarken, mürekkepten daha önemliydi kahve. Her sabah, çölde su arar gibi kahve aradığım günleri dün gibi hatırlıyorum. Her yerde, her halde, her duyguda bir yerlerde saklıydı kahve kokusu.</p><p>Ölmek üzere olduğunu çok iyi bildiğim kardeşimin kuzeyin en kuzeyindeki evinin salonunda otururken de, kızı, yeğenim, bana kahve hazırlamaktaydı. Burnuma geldiği an, bana öncelikle neyi hatırlattığına karar veremediğim kahve kokusu da en az benim kadar şaşkın, benim kadar hareketsiz, benim kadar çaresizdi.</p><p>Sonra gözüm dışarıdaki gri denize takıldı. Yıllardır burada yaşıyor olmama rağmen, buranın denizini de hiç ciddiye alamadım. Kuzey Denizi’ni Baltık Denizi’ne bağlayan Øresund kanalı bana daima ruhsuz bir gölü anımsatmıştır. İzmit Körfezi’nin, Marmara’nın, Ege’nin, Karadeniz’in dibinde büyümüş olan bize, böyle denizler inandırıcı gelmez. Dalgası dalga, rengi renk, kumu kum gibi değildir. Balığının tadı tuhaftır, yosunu bile gönülsüzdür. Ama her denizin olduğu gibi, buranın da bir sevdalısı bulunur. Yelkenlisi, gemisi boldur buraların, her mevsim. Sadece benim sevdam bambaşka yerlerdedir. ‘Allah sahibine bağışlasın, denizini bilemem ama, ülke pek müreffeh. Denizi de çirkin oluversin,’ diyemedim bir gün bile. Deniz dediğin deniz gibi olacak arkadaş. Baktın mı için ferahlayacak. Seni içine çekecek. Burası öyle değil.</p><p>Belki de buranın denizi hasta etti kardeşimi. Belki ondan kızına Deniz adını koydu, özlediği ama hiç özlediğini itiraf edemediği denizleri her gün anmak için. Soramazdın böyle şeyleri ona. Önce ‘ha siktir’ der, sonra güler, şakayla karışık başından savardı. Ama ben başka bir açıklaması olduğunu sanmıyorum.</p><p>Deniz, elinde kahveyle geldi sonra. Türk kahvesi. Gelmeden kokusundan anlamıştım tabii, Türk kahvesi getireceğini. Yaldızlı, bizim oralardan olduğu belli, eski bir fincanda getirdi.</p><p>‘Uyandı babam, amca,’ dedi, şevkli bir kibarlıkla. ‘İstersen kahveni iç, sonra çıkarsın. Acele etme, bakıcı tuvalete götürdü, bir on dakika sonra belki kendi iner. Ben senin geldiğini söyledim.’</p><p>‘Tamam kızım, acelesi yok, işine baksın,’ dedim. ‘Yardım edebileceğim bir şey varsa söylersin.’</p><p>‘Ben bir bakayım, geleceğim birazdan,’ dedi, sonra salondan çıktı. Bir anda derin bir sessizlik çöktü. Sonra daha önce farkına varmadığım bir saat sesini fark ettim. Kafamı kaldırdım. Tanıdık bir saat. Ağır aksak, bir saniyesi bir saniyesini tutmayan, sanki saati göstersin diye değil de, zamanı anımsatsın diye salona asılmış bir saat. Sonradan hatırladım, babaannemden kalma bir saat. Hala çalışıyor olmasına da kardeşimin evinde olmasına da hiç ama hiç şaşırmadım. Bende olsa elli kere bozulmuş, atılmış, belki de çalınmıştı. Arşivciydi zaten benim kardeşim. Geçmişe dair görsel, işitsel, bizden ne vardıysa hep o sakladı diye vardı.</p><p>Bana da bir tek kokular kaldı işte.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=511d09772b22" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>