<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Guy-Philippe Goldstein on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Guy-Philippe Goldstein on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein?source=rss-c32bf97175f1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 15:03:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Seven Days Before 2018]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/seven-days-before-2018-a53da428a514?source=rss-c32bf97175f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a53da428a514</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[putin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cybersecurity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cold-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Guy-Philippe Goldstein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Dec 2017 12:37:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-26T12:38:24.882Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(aka Sept Jours Avant 2018)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_MzW26VBW3fstWwNV6JDxQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Ho Ho Ho.</p><p>As we look back at the year past and rejoice at the holidays’ festivities, we should brace ourselves to what is coming: 2018.</p><p><strong>Part 1/7–2018, the culmination of all tensions</strong></p><p>Ten years after the start of the Great Recession and the collapse of Lehman Brothers, we are now fully experiencing the social and political furor unleashed both by the Crisis and the deep imbalances built up in the decades before. As I’ve written up in a <a href="https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/the-darwin-point-4be43e130743">previous Medium post</a>, our western world has been tested — and so far we have but responded only half-way, <a href="https://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21732529-governments-skilfully-tackled-symptoms-not-underlying-disease-decade">as the Economist eloquently put it</a>. All that leading, in the heart of the Western World, to the rise of Trump that was envisioned by The Lafayette Blog as early as February 2016 and throughout the 1st semester 2016 (in French: <a href="https://thelafayetteblog.com/2016/02/11/trump-trump-trump-au-ralenti/">here</a> , <a href="https://thelafayetteblog.com/2016/02/24/trump-en-passe-de-devenir-le-candidat-des-republicains/">here</a> , <a href="https://thelafayetteblog.com/2016/05/05/trump-peut-il-devenir-president/">here</a> ) and summed up in a few slides in English: “<a href="https://thelafayetteblog.com/2016/06/29/trumpbrexitrevolutions-2016/">Revolution(s) 2016</a>”.</p><p>But there was another twist to Trump. As the Western World weakened, it invited the aggression of its enemies, starting with Russia — itself in an economic bind. <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/russias-election-meddling-is-another-american-intelligence-failure">Russia decided to directly intervene into the US elections</a> <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergei_Ivanov#Chief_of_Staff">— an operation so brash, even for Chekist standards, that it may have led in August 2016 to the demise of Sergey Ivanov, Putin’s Chief of Staff</a>. Trump was the real <a href="https://thelafayetteblog.com/2017/01/13/there-will-be-blood/">Manchurian candidate</a> — this has been now explicitly stated by <a href="http://www.businessinsider.fr/us/james-clapper-putin-trump-russia-asset-2017-12/">former DNI James Clapper in a recent CNN interview</a>. Battle lines started to be drawn. On one hand, in the populist camp — the elder, poorer, lesser educated, rural sub-sub-urban folks supported by the entrenched Old Money and Russia. On the other side — the younger, richer, better educated, urban folks supported by Digital Money and all the Western Intelligence Agencies, from the domestic 3-letter agencies to NATO allies. One year ago, I stated that on balance, if I wanted to take a side in a revolution, <a href="https://thelafayetteblog.com/2017/01/06/2017-the-year-of-the-fried-rooster/">I’d go with the young masses in the urban centers supported by Western Intelligence agencies</a>. I stand with my bet in the long run — as an Israeli friend told me last year, “in the end the good guys will win”. And surely, the political incompetence of Trump (to the difference of cunning politicians such as Orban, Erdogan or Putin) — led in no short time to his collapse in his polls toward mid-30s and to the nomination of former FBI director Robert Mueller as special counsel in May. This was to be indeed the start of the real fight. As we wrote back in May in the Lafayette Blog, “the whole western alliance will move against the one place that started this whole mess: the Kremlin. <a href="https://thelafayetteblog.com/2017/05/17/i-said-so-there-will-be-blood/">This is only but the beginning. Be ready for 2018</a>”.</p><p>Seven months later, as forces on both sides continue to coalesce, we now look at a fateful year 2018 both for the US, the Western World and possibly the stability of our planet. Indeed, Robert Mueller’s investigation may be the trigger. The Economist has laid down <a href="http://gfs.eiu.com/Article.aspx?articleType=rf&amp;articleId=1506226534&amp;secId=2">five institutional scenarios</a>. And while these scenarios make perfect sense, and are very reasonable — they may not capture the meltdown both internally and externally that is taking place. We are not living in Nixon’s slowing post-war boom, pre-1974 first oil shock. Because of our social meltdown, there’s a chance that things will get much rougher than that. And there’s a fairly high chance we go back to the times of the Cold War’s High Stake Crises.</p><p><strong><em>— -</em></strong></p><p><strong>Part 2/7 — Scenario #1:</strong> <strong>Robert Mueller completes his investigation</strong>.</p><p><strong>&gt; The investigation names Trump &amp; Putin. US retaliates against Russia</strong></p><p>Let’s go to the jugular: Robert Mueller report will state in bold letters what we already know since Ivanov was fired. Putin played again, and won “too big”. As a matter of international prestige, both for the sake of its credibility and that of its allies, the US national security apparatus will not be able to just state out loud: “ok, the Kremlin succeeded in the biggest political coup since WWII, well done guys!”. International relations are not just about international law, but also the sheer rapport-de-force between great powers in the anarchy of international relations, to restate Kenneth Waltz. The US, supported by its NATO allies, will be forced to retaliate. Because Russia’s destabilization campaign has been so vast, encompassing both the US but also the UK, France, Spain and many other democratic elections in Europe, and achieved an incredible success by putting at the head of the US one of its asset, the long term objective of the retaliation will be the demise of Vladimir Putin as president of Russia and/or a regime change after 2024.</p><p>This retaliatory campaign will be led through different avenues. Among those, some are so obvious that they are already nearly in place:</p><p>1. Increased aggressive military posture toward Russia — already started this month by the <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/23/us-officials-say-lethal-weapons-headed-to-ukraine.html">provision of lethal weapons to Ukraine</a> forces and the recent clear identification of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/19/world/europe/russia-china-america-first-doctrine.html?_r=0">Russia as a revisionist power and a threat to the US</a>;</p><p>2. Targeted sanctions further depriving the Russian economy — <a href="https://www.economist.com/news/europe/21731662-personal-sanctions-against-regime-cronies-are-especially-tough-new-sanctions-are-about">a tool that has been already been put back in place this year</a> — along with the creeping “digital” blockade against “software publishers from the Cold” such <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-cyber-kaspersky/trump-signs-into-law-u-s-government-ban-on-kaspersky-lab-software-idUSKBN1E62V4">as Kaspersky software</a>;</p><p>3. Cyber &amp; Politics: Online leaks and distribution of secure online communication tools to further help dissidents organize political, including trying to leverage the electronic fraud that is bound to happen during the 2018 Russian elections. This will be the most direct pay-in-kind action</p><p>4. Energy &amp; Economy: let large Western industrial companies continue to rapidly develop their learning curve in renewable energy — slowly but surely degrading Russia’s economy, always too dependent on fossil fuel and incapable of reforming itself and developing a market economy where private property rights would be respected.</p><p>5….and then all the “underwater” spy vs spy fight that will pop-up from time to time, and that will be in large part digital. And that is probably already raging.</p><p><strong>— -</strong></p><p><strong>Part 3/7 — Cyber Cold War 2.0 starts as a response: Be ready for high stake crises</strong></p><p>US Measures 1 &amp; 2 (aggressive military posture and targeted sanctions) have already started to be in place. This gets to show that Putin has failed to transform the “Trump asset” into a fully functioning weapon against the US National Security Establishment. But Putin will not sit idle. It will push back hard, also using weapons it has already tried and successfully tested:</p><p>1. Military threats — especially against either NATO allies or Western countries close to NATO, to increase the stakes and to conquer back Ukraine. The loss of Ukraine in 2014 was a stinging humiliation for Putin. His grand geopolitical design was to recreate something like the Soviet Union. Without Ukraine, the Union is forever dead. Indeed, Zapad 2017 Russian military exercise hinted at <a href="http://www.bild.de/politik/ausland/bild-international/zapad-2017-english-54233658.bild.html">threatening NATO and NATO-friendly countries in Baltic and Nordic countries</a>. Meanwhile, Gen. Robert Neller, Marine Corps commandant, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/checkpoint/wp/2017/12/23/theres-a-war-coming-top-marine-corps-general-tells-u-s-troops/?tid=pm_world_pop&amp;utm_term=.81a38478d898">just told 300 marines in Norway that they should be prepared for a ‘bigass fight’ to come</a>. Also this December, cease fire violations in Ukraine have accelerated, leading France and Germany on December 23, 2017 to <a href="https://www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-russia-germany-france-urge-end-cease-fire-violations-return-jccc/28934883.html">call Russia to curb violence</a> and for Russia to re-integer a joint coordination center set to stabilize the military situation. Russia withdrew from that center on December 18. Beyond the seas, Russian submarines <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/russian-submarines-are-prowling-around-vital-undersea-cables-its-making-nato-nervous/2017/12/22/d4c1f3da-e5d0-11e7-927a-e72eac1e73b6_story.html?tid=pm_world_pop&amp;utm_term=.19622197b725">are prowling undersea data cables in the North Atlantic</a>, making NATO very nervous.</p><p>2. The last threat hints to further Cyber threats — another place where the West should expect high stakes crises. It will continue to take two forms:</p><p>a. Against the universal critical infrastructure (telco, finance, energy, etc…) — a threat already illustrated in Ukraine and in the West with the <a href="https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/07/04/sbu_claims_russia_was_behind_notpetya/">NotPetya attack</a> that cost large companies such as Saint Gobain or Maersk around 200–300 million USD. Alerts on this have actually multiplied over <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-cyber-energy/u-s-warns-public-about-attacks-on-energy-industrial-firms-idUSKBN1CQ0IN">the year 2017</a>.</p><p>b. Against the “liberal democracy” critical infrastructure that are media, politicians or judges. The most obvious attack is the now well identified <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_interference_in_the_2016_United_States_elections">disinformation campaign run by Russia during the 2016 US Presidential Election</a> leading companies such as Facebook and other social media companies, <a href="http://www.journalism.org/2017/09/07/news-use-across-social-media-platforms-2017/">now providers of news for 2/3 of the American population</a>, to become unwitting agents of Russian influence. It is unfortunate that institutions such as the <a href="https://www.wired.com/story/the-state-departments-fumbled-fight-against-russian-propaganda/">State Department have been unable since the start of 2017 to do anything meaningful</a> against this cyber campaign. It is unfortunate that since the Trump administration got in power, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/kremlin-trolls-burned-across-the-internet-as-washington-debated-options/2017/12/23/e7b9dc92-e403-11e7-ab50-621fe0588340_story.html?utm_term=.e301563e18fd">no significant measures</a> have been taken to oppose Russian online disinformation campaign. Unless it is vigorously opposed, it surely is about to continue and spread.</p><p>3. This relatively low-cost leverage of the Internet is further reinforced by attack against key targets in the Western World through the semi-industrial use of kompromat or favors — towards politicians and <a href="https://www.voanews.com/a/russia-hackers-targeted-two-hundred-journalists-globally/4175088.html">journalists</a>. And it is already working in the US. Many politicians from the GOP have been quite lenient toward the Russian threat, some already fully compromised such as Dana Rohrabacher — to the point where even his <a href="http://beta.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-russia-rohrabacher-subcommittee-20171026-story.html">GOP colleagues have started to distance themselves from him</a>; but there is also the strange case of Lindsey Graham, who admitted having <a href="http://edition.cnn.com/2016/12/14/politics/lindsey-graham-hacking-russia-donald-trump/index.html">been hacked by Russia back in 2016</a>. And while he called Trump an idiot and a jackass in 2015 and 2016, he is now one of <a href="https://www.politico.com/story/2017/10/23/trump-lindsey-graham-congress-allies-244000">Trump’s best allies</a> to the point where <a href="https://www.salon.com/2017/12/11/lindsey-graham-is-now-promoting-donald-trumps-golf-club-on-his-twitter-feed/">he lavishly promotes Trump’s golf course</a>. As with Sarah Kendzior, a specialist in former USSR authoritarian states, one can wonder if Graham has been lately a <a href="https://www.rawstory.com/2017/12/authoritarianism-expert-russia-hacked-lindsey-grahams-personal-emails-so-trump-may-be-blackmailing-him/">victim of blackmail</a>. At any rate, Lindsey Graham may have already been the <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/russia-never-stopped-its-cyberattacks-on-the-united-states/2017/12/25/83076f2e-e676-11e7-a65d-1ac0fd7f097e_story.html?utm_term=.bfb3febb0b40">victim of online Russian trolls supporting Trump</a>, and this other type of blackmailing could also have forced his hand. So these are the two sticks, but there’s also the poisonous carrot: through loopholes regarding foreign financing of political campaign, created by the US Supreme Court of Justice’s <a href="https://theintercept.com/2016/08/03/citizens-united-foreign-money-us-elections/">Citizens United 2010 decision</a>, <a href="https://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/commentary/2017/12/15/putins-proxies-helped-funnel-millions-gop-campaigns">Russian money may have been able to finance GOP candidates</a>. It is more efficient to buy politicians’ wills for millions of dollars than to coerce them with armies that cost billions. And then in the wake of compromised politicians, other forces may follow. Rupert Murdoch’s FOX media empire ended up <a href="http://theweek.com/speedreads/734520/rupert-murdochs-media-empire-adopts-trump-line-russia-some-fox-news-employees-grumble">aligning itself with a large chunk of the now compromised wing of the GOP led by Trump</a>. Who <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/23/business/media/murdoch-trump-relationship.html?rref=collection%2Fsectioncollection%2Fpolitics">knows what ties, ideological or not</a>, lie behind this realignment. But as the GOP delivers one of the largest tax reform in the fiscal history of the US, to the benefits of the wealthiest Americans, and as part of the GOP becomes entangled with Russian influence and money — it looks like avenues for quid-pro-quo are multiplying.</p><p><strong>— -</strong></p><p><strong>Part 4/7 — The new dangers of Cold War 2.0</strong></p><p>None of the Cold War Redux scenarios above are particularly original. They are in the minds of many analysts and on the <a href="https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/12/22/donald-trump-vladimir-putin-cold-war-216157">cover of magazines at this year-end</a>. The Cold War Redux has even its <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_War_II">own dedicated Wikipedia page</a>. Evidently, it is disheartening to contemplate such a dangerous rise in international tensions. On the other side, the <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/kremlin-trolls-burned-across-the-internet-as-washington-debated-options/2017/12/23/e7b9dc92-e403-11e7-ab50-621fe0588340_story.html?utm_term=.e301563e18fd">US lack of reaction to Russian aggression</a> during the latter years of the Obama presidency has invited the current situation. Granted, Washington was probably under the paradigm that Russia was the post-1991 diminished Eurasian power with patriotic ambitions but no deep revisionists instincts and still an interest to find a place in our Western world. For whatever reasons beyond the scope of this current post, this may have been wrong. As mentioned above, the leniency of the US national security apparatus has led to the most successful Russian psychological operation “coup” since WWII. And now, Cold War 2.0 is nearly unescapable. Three factors will make this Cold War 2.0 different from the previous one:</p><p>(a) we are now living in an age of both nuclear and cyber threats, with potential for increased destabilization — a situation I mentioned back in <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/guy_philippe_goldstein_how_cyberattacks_threaten_real_world_peace?language=en">January 2010</a>;</p><p>(b) Russia is not Communist anymore. Instead of allying itself solely with the far-left, the Kremlin has found allies in the West with the far-right, wings of Conservative parties and very possibly some of the world’s moneyed interests (including organized crime) — reflecting the very state of Russian politics and the personal trajectory of Donald Trump. Meanwhile, the Kremlin has shrewdly maintained old left-wing/far-left ties. So now its political spectrum of actions is much wider. Besides, the compromising of moneyed interests helps the Kremlin get powerful lobbies on its side, with the promise of furthering debilitating the rules of free market competition — furthering what was already taking place in the US, as <a href="https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21695385-profits-are-too-high-america-needs-giant-dose-competition-too-much-good-thing">The Economist warned about</a>; and something evidently achieved in Russia for political reasons;</p><p>© The social dislocation in the West, already at play before 2008, and made even more painful afterwards, creates a profound vulnerability in the West. As this is communicated to the heads of the Western states through the rise of populism and political fragmentation, the West risks appearing less united, slower to react and ultimately less credible against all sorts of threats. The worst scenario would be if the head of State of the most powerful country in the world would become incompetent or look the other way; if the West was inviting and tested by many different threats away from Europe — for example a new nuclear North Korea; and if the US would plunge into a deep political and civil crisis.</p><p>— -</p><p><strong>Part 5/7 — Risks of civil unrest in the US</strong></p><p>… And civil unrest is precisely what the Kremlin is trying to achieve.</p><p>It is the only way for Russia to confuse US and NATO, and then slowly but surely re-establish preeminence in former Soviet Union republics, starting with Ukraine. The Kremlin’s objective was not to put Trump in power. It was to sow the deepest of disorders in the US. For example, the Kremlin never really hid its links with the Trump team. Only two days after Trump was elected, a top senior Russian diplomat admitted that <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2016/11/10/russian-diplomat-there-were-contacts-with-trumps-campaign.html">the Russian government was in touch with members of Trump’s team</a>. This was made to embarrass Trump, the GOP and perhaps leave traces for further internal conflicts.</p><p>So, is civil unrest in the US possible in the next 12–18 months?</p><p>Once Robert Mueller investigation report is on the table, we shall know. If there is a majority to impeach Trump — and in the same time launch reprisals against Russia — the risk of unrest will be limited. It will mean that a large enough part of the GOP will become finally fully aware of the national security danger to the US Republic. The GOP may also probably be humbled by potential losses in Congress. The victory of Democrat Doug Jones vs. Republican Roy Moore in Alabama — a state that Trump won a year ago with a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/elections/results/alabama">margin of nearly 28%</a> (!) should force any Republican to reassess strategy. Furthermore, recent polls for Congress at the generic ballot gives an <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/20/upshot/democrats-2018-congressional-elections-polling.html">average lead of 13.4% for the Democrats</a>. Never in the last 28 years has any party had such a large lead early on — an advantage that has proved in the past to be relatively stable over time till election date. Meanwhile; <a href="https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/trump-approval-ratings/?ex_cid=rrpromo">Trump approval remains stubbornly below 40%</a>. Indeed, there are grounds for GOP members to recognize that tying their hands with the Trump/Russia camp may lead to the demise of the GOP.</p><p>Unfortunately, at this stage, the GOP is further siding with the Trump/Russia camp, along with Fox News and the rest of the Murdoch media empire. The signs of impending losses may have compelled the GOP to regroup forces around the White House. To that respect, the GOP Tax reform is a brash and ultimate effort to bring in parts of Corporate America and the wealthiest of Americans into that camp. In that context, there is little chance that the GOP would accept the conclusions of Robert Mueller’s investigations: Lindsey Graham 180 degrees turn-around is an example among others that the GOP is now gravitating more and more toward the White House. Indeed, it is possible that held up by both moneyed interests and the hacking/trolling/financing Russian campaign, the fate of the GOP is now sealed. In that case, and to the difference of 1974, the US Senate will not be able to yield the 2/3 vote necessary for impeachment before or even after November 2018 mid-term elections.</p><p>…Let’s hope this last assessment is wrong and that a large part of GOP, preparing for a recovery in 2020, draws the most legitimate conclusion. Still — if at this critical juncture, the GOP remains entangled with the White House, then three scenarios remain possible:</p><p>(a) <strong>“Call to the Flag”</strong>: The national security apparatus manages to launch reprisals. It “compels” a sufficient block of the GOP to strip away as much executive powers as possible from the White House while leveraging the new Democratic majority. Nuclear powers may be shared with Congress. Congress may seize more direct authorities with regards to cyber reprisals. Power shifts from the White House to Congress. The unescapable Cold War 2.0 is then amplified by several crises. As the stakes rise, patriotic mood grows, and the weight of cyber-military complex becomes more important, fueled by the assistance of NATO allies. Trump &amp; GOP are at this stage further pressured between the antagonist forces of Russia and the National Security apparatus. Something will have to give. Most probably, it will be Trump — an incompetent political operator, and the easiest way for GOP to finally save its face. But the road will be long and potentially debilitating. As a last stand, Trump &amp; Russia may attempt a flare-up with civil unrest, supported by far-right militias. It has very few chances to succeed.</p><p>(b) <strong>“The Red House”: </strong>The national security apparatus does not manage to fully launch reprisals. The GOP blocks Democrats initiative against Trump. No major demonstrations are taking place. Basically, Trump and Russia’s influence operations are very much still in place and no legal actions are taken. But then, if no action is taken, then it is the very principle of the US governed by the rule of law that may be at stake. In that case, Russia has won. A further compromising of media/social media, GOP and the US elites is rapidly proceeding. America has become Russia. The White House is Red. Russia moves forward in Europe and the Middle-East. But Russia is still a diminished power. From a global standpoint, the situation becomes highly instable. Conflicts may flare up. Loss of US credible deterrence renders escalation much easier. And then something has to give.</p><p>© <strong>“Revolution(s)”: </strong>The national security apparatus does not manage to fully launch reprisals. The GOP blocks Democrats initiative against Trump. But now major demonstrations are taking place. They are fueled by the rising economic and political power of women in urban centers, as already demonstrated on January 21, 2017 — <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Women%27s_March">the largest-single day protest in U.S. history</a>. Russia and its online far-right allies try then to double down by sowing further disorder, fueling a climate that would lead to violent clash and domestic terrorism (and perhaps manipulation &amp; provocation). Indeed, major eruptions of violence would deter civilians to continue to demonstrate and would offer pretexts for the White House to invoke executive privileges and to impose curfews. In that context, another power group is forced to take a stand: Corporate America. On one hand, the rule of law is at stake — which means the future of US markets. Besides, core urban, early-adopter consumers &amp; talented employees — two major stakeholders, especially the female ones — are siding against Trump. Not to mention the possible influence of the national security apparatus on some parts of Corporate America. But on the other hand, there is the lure of profits from corporate tax cuts and further deregulations. Furthering the difficulties to predict the choice of Corporate America is the fact that it is very heterogenous. Tempo then may decide everything. A rapid street mobilization, associated with forceful national security &amp; allied pressures (including devastating leaks) may quickly impress parts of both Corporate America and the GOP. In that case, the situation moves to (a). Otherwise, there is further debilitation of US power. Russia achieves civil unrest in the US and legal stalemate. The situation moves to (b).</p><p>— -</p><p><strong>Part 6/7 — Scenario #2:</strong> <strong>Robert Mueller is fired before completing his investigation</strong>.</p><p>First, let’s recognize that it will be very difficult for Trump to fire Robert Mueller. As described in detail by <a href="https://www.lawfareblog.com/if-trump-fires-mueller-or-orders-his-firing">Jack Goldsmith in</a> <a href="https://www.lawfareblog.com/if-trump-fires-mueller-or-orders-his-firing">Lawfare,</a> “[…] the special counsel can be removed only (1) by the Attorney General, (2) for “misconduct, dereliction of duty, incapacity, conflict of interest, or for other good cause, including violation of Departmental policies,” and (3) in writing, which must include “the specific reason” for special counsel’s termination[…]”. The Attorney General has recused himself from the Russia investigation. The Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein has stated by mid-December that he didn’t “<a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2017/12/13/dojs-rod-rosenstein-says-he-does-not-see-a-reason-to-fire-mueller.html">see a reason to fire Robert Mueller</a>”. So then, unless replacing in the chain of command all the legal officers till one abide by Trump’s will, prospects may not be that easy. Trump could also issue a directive that abrogates or ignores the Special Counsel regulations. It is something that could be <a href="https://www.lawfareblog.com/if-trump-fires-mueller-or-orders-his-firing">constitutionally contemplated</a>. Goldsmith leads his reasoning to the fact that, ultimately, “[…] Congress would rise up quickly to stop the President, and the pressure on the cabinet would be enormous as well. If I am naive in thinking this, then we are indeed in trouble.”</p><p>Unfortunately, Congress may be as paralyzed in this scenario as in the previous ones. So let’s imagine Mueller indeed has been fired. The main difference with the abovementioned situations: the National Security Apparatus may not have had the time to fully made its case for reprisals. Leaks will then quickly multiply. Meanwhile, Democrats and urban centers will erupt in fury — but who knows how sustainable this will be?</p><p>….There’s a fair chance that the situation moves to the “<strong>Revolution(s)</strong>” scenario. Then again: if anti-Trump power quickly mobilizes, the US is destabilized but gets through and the national agenda move toward Cold War 2.0. If the anti-Trump camp does not quickly mobilize — then Russia, the GOP and a segment of moneyed interests manage to achieve victory. But this is a Pyrrhic victory for Russia: With only <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/271379/russias-share-of-global-gross-domestic-product-gdp/">3% of global GDP</a> and underlying growth problem — not to mention a reliance on old fossil fuel energy, and the absence of the rule of law — Russia is too weak to reorganize global order.</p><p>Global chaos ensues.</p><p>— —</p><p><strong>Part 7/7 — The way forward</strong></p><p>Three concluding thoughts as the scenarios are laid out.</p><p>First, the idea that the Western World, including the US, risks unrest because of a financial meltdown should not surprise anyone. In the developing world, it is a frequent occurrence — for <a href="https://econweb.rutgers.edu/rchang/polcrisisjmefinal.pdf">example</a>, “[…] in Indonesia in 1998 and Argentina 2001, economic and financial difficulties were followed by massive popular revolts, which ultimately toppled the incumbent governments.[…]”. Or, in a more general case, as demonstrated by Funke, Schularick and Trebesch in a <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014292116300587">seminal study published in 2016</a>, analyzing over 800 elections from 1870 to 2014, “[…]policy uncertainty rises strongly after financial crises as government majorities shrink and polarization rises.[…]”. Ten years after the start of a recession of the same magnitude as that of 1929, it is not surprising that 2018 echoes another fateful year — 1938. Or perhaps 1939, but with the stabilizing effect of the nuclear deterrent — provided its credibility is not dented either by new strategic cyber weapons, or by incompetent heads of state.</p><p>Second, as Cold War 2.0 sets in, it must be obvious that the struggle will not be confined to the Russia-US/NATO struggle. Other powers will try to test the vulnerabilities of the US, Russia and Western European countries as the Cold War 2.0 unravels. China, as an emerging global superpower will test both the resolve of the US in the Pacific — but also that of India, and perhaps in disguised ways, that of Russia. Regional powers and rogue states such as Iran and North Korea — perhaps assisted by Russia — may be tempted to open new fronts or reactivate old battlegrounds in the Cold War 2.0.</p><p>Finally, the ultimate objective for the Western World cannot be solely the end of Putin’s rule in Russia. The goal will also have to be a deep institutional and economic reform of the Western World, of a similar magnitude to that set up in Europe after 1945 when NHS and the Sécurité Sociale were created respectively in the United Kingdom and in France. In Europe but even more importantly in the US, two areas of reform will have to take place:</p><p>&gt; Political &amp; Institutional reforms: Social media and cable news will have to be regulated so that the spread of disinformation and hate speech that incites to violence is strictly contained. The cybersecurity of journalists, elected officials and judges &amp; lawyers will have to be elevated to that of critical infrastructure. Campaign financing should be made entirely public, with special provisions for new political movements. In the US, the current financing system, set up by the disastrous Citizens United decision of the Supreme Court of the United States, has become a conduit for corruption, both from domestic but also foreign influence. It has become a threat to the US national security and to that of its NATO allies.</p><p>&gt; Financial &amp; Economic reforms: The build-up of extreme leverage at the origin of the crisis should be addressed. As happened with the Marshall plan and then the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Agreement_on_German_External_Debts">1953 London agreement on German external debts</a>, debt refinancing and debt relief will have to take place. Meanwhile, new tighter regulations will have to be set for new debts issuance and legal penalties will have to be brought against executives responsible for the pre-2008 subprime &amp; mortgage debacles in the US and in Europe. Otherwise, moral hazard will hinder debt markets. Finally, the very imbalance at the heart of the crisis will have to be tackled. One generation later, the following observation must be made plain: The Conservative Revolution’s “Trickle-down economics” fueled by tax cuts was a fraud. It only led to income depression for the lower income brackets. Meanwhile, automatization and the start of the economy’s digitalization was not properly accompanied by a human capital effort in lifelong learning. This is a departure from previous stages of the industrial revolution that led to social investments in public education in Europe (for example in France with the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jules_Ferry_laws">Jules Ferry laws of 1881–1882</a>) or in the US, with the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_school_movement">high school movement in 1910–1940</a> or post war <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G.I._Bill">G.I bill that provided for free college education</a>. Instead of providing for the new stages of professional education post-college through tax redistribution, the middle class and the working class were offered the dream of home ownership through mortgage debt — while the upper class could gain on property speculation and tax decreases. The 2008 crisis, triggered by the massive amounts of private debt that had accumulated over the years, made plain that this dream was a fraud.</p><p>This economic and social colossal disaster should be now obvious to all. It will have to be corrected or the Cold War 2.0 will not find any solace. As long as the deep social inequalities created over the last generation are not curbed, anger and political extremism will continue to grow.</p><p>In the context of Cold War 2.0, political extremists as heads of state increase significantly the risk that our homo sapiens experience ends up in a couple of nuclear flashes. Billionaires may try to build escape plans in remote New Zealand areas or in rockets to Mars. They are delusional. No one will be able to escape nuclear holocaust. At the end of Homo Deus, Yuval Noah Harari envisions a 2-classes system between the “have” and the “have-not”, those who can accede the new digital capital and those who can’t. I fear he is deeply mistaken. As mentioned above, this will not lead to a stable equilibrium. Because of political extremism, only two types of people may exist in the not-so-distant future:</p><p>Either the representatives of a global society based on redistributive solidarity and high investments in human capital as well as technology;</p><p>Or lifeless bodies in vitrified cities turned into mass graves.</p><p>This is not a matter of choice, but of survival. The mistakes made in the last 40 years will have to be corrected so that the Cold War 2.0 is a short one, and the next 40 years turn quickly into decades of peace and prosperity.</p><p>Happy new year.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a53da428a514" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Face aux Lignes Maginots: En avant!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/face-aux-lignes-maginots-en-avant-31a1042ad7c7?source=rss-c32bf97175f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31a1042ad7c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[présidentielle-2017]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[macron]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emmanuel-macron]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[france]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[en-marche]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Guy-Philippe Goldstein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Apr 2017 17:20:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-22T12:52:12.610Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Face aux Lignes Maginots: En avant!</strong></p><p><strong>L’enjeu</strong></p><p>L’élection de ce dimanche 23 avril est la plus importante pour la France depuis 1945. Notre République court le risque, réel, d’être défait par une victoire dans l’urne de l’Extrême Droite. La zone Euro pourrait alors exploser sur les marchés — avant même qu’une décision politique ne soit prise — plongeant l’économie de notre pays, de notre zone économique naturelle et du monde dans une récession grave. Dès dimanche 24 au soir, sur les marchés asiatiques. Les banques centrales, sans marges de manœuvres aujourd’hui, ne pourront stopper le désastre. Une coordination internationale G7 sera impossible dans des délais courts pour aider un patient malade — la France — guidé par un gouvernement d’idéologues novices et obtus aux contraintes internationales. Ce ne sera pas une récession. Ce sera, cette fois, peut-être une dépression, avec les conséquences que l’histoire des hommes décrit dans ces situations : une colère sociale sans limites ; la tentation en retour d’un Etat répressif et liberticide, surtout s’il est contrôlé par l’extrême droite ; et peut-être en bout de chemin, la guerre.</p><p>Les citoyens français ne s’en rendent peut-être pas compte, mais la France aujourd’hui est un point unique de défaillance (« single point of failure ») pour l’ensemble de l’Occident et du monde.</p><p>Dans ce contexte, le mot de ‘utile’ adossé à celui de ‘vote’ n’a jamais été aussi important. S’il y a bien une fois dans sa vie où chacun de nous devra faire un vote ‘utile’, c’est le dimanche 23 avril et le dimanche 7 mai — comme cela avait déjà été le cas sous des horizons plus cléments en 2002. Mais il s’agit aussi de choisir le candidat qui (a) comprend le mieux la situation actuelle afin de l’améliorer et (b) aura la base et la légitimité pour exécuter sa politique. J’ai beaucoup d’estime et de respect pour tous ceux qui se sentent portés par les différents candidats républicains, de <strong>Mélenchon</strong> à <strong>Fillon</strong>. Mon point de vue, forcément personnel, est influencé par des réflexions indépendantes de cette élection</p><p><strong>Big picture : Crise d’inflation ou de déflation ?</strong></p><p>Notre crise est en grande partie liée à celle de l’Occident, démarrée en 2008 suite à une période de très forte spéculation immobilière, c’est-à-dire une crise de la dette privée — pas public, privé. Aux US, elle <a href="https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/the-darwin-point-4be43e130743">atteint 310% du PNB en 2008</a>, son point le plus haut depuis 1929. Les banques privées ont trop prêtées par rapport à leurs fonds propres. Leur capacité d’entraînement de l’économie s’effondre alors. Encore, une fois, la crise n’a pas été déclenchée par la dette publique. Celle-ci est certes passée de 55% du PNB en 1995 à <a href="http://www.tradingeconomics.com/france/government-debt-to-gdp">65% du PNB en 2007 à 96% aujourd’hui</a>, essentiellement pour soutenir une activité qui ne l’était plus par le privé. Mais peu d’économistes peuvent dire quel est le bon niveau de dette public : <a href="http://www.ukpublicspending.co.uk/spending_chart_1945_2010UKp_09c1li001mcn_G0t_UK_National_Debt_As_Pct_GDP">par exemple la dette du Royaume-Uni était entre 150% et 240% du PNB</a> dans l’immédiat après-guerre. Cela n’a pas empêché la forte croissance au démarrage des Trente Glorieuses. La dette publique par contre est un problème critique quand son financement concurrence celui des activités privées, et surenchérit le coût des activités privées. Le problème est magnifié en cas de forte inflation. Est-ce le cas aujourd’hui ?</p><p>On peut en douter : notre crise de la dette privée à crée un contexte de faible activité économique. Cela se voit avec l’effondrement conjoint des taux directeurs à 3 mois des banques centrales, qui constituent le cout de refinancement des banques privées : ces taux se sont effondrés. Malgré un coût très faible de refinancement, les banques privées ne veulent ou ne peuvent pas augmenter leur activité. Et cela depuis 2009 ! Nous sommes depuis 2009 sur un encéphalogramme plat de l’économie mondiale.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/407/1*NMq0KkxGfZtdseY85zlTRw.png" /></figure><p>Ce n’est pas un problème français ; pas même européen : c’est un problème mondial. Le risque n’est pas l’inflation, mais au contraire le risque de déflation. Quand Mme Thatcher s’en est pris au budget de l’Etat et aux salaires des ouvriers, c’était dans un contexte d’inflation forte <a href="http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/2647/economics/history-of-inflation-in-uk/"><strong>qui oscillait entre 10 et 20% par an au tournant des années 80</strong></a> ( !) . <strong>L’inflation en France en mars 2017 s’élevait à 1.1%.</strong></p><p>Que faire ? Dans ce contexte, les politiques d’austérité sont vouées à l’échec. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/may/27/austerity-policies-do-more-harm-than-good-imf-study-concludes">C’est ce que dit aujourd’hui le FMI</a>. The <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21721143-french-go-polls-they-are-angry-and-divided-consequential-choice-franceand">Economist, lui, prévient que la « thérapie de choc »</a> proposée par <strong>François Fillon</strong> ne pourra donner les résultats escomptés. Supprimer 500.000 fonctionnaires créera un choc d’austérité qui ne pourra pas être absorbé par le privé dans <strong>les conditions macroéconomiques actuelles qui ne sont pas celles des années 1970, 1980 ou 1990</strong>. Ici, on risque de créer 500.000 chômeurs de plus — et un effet déflationniste très dangereux dans un contexte pro-déflationniste. On comprend dès lors pourquoi The <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21721143-french-go-polls-they-are-angry-and-divided-consequential-choice-franceand">Economist ne soutient pas <strong>François Fillon</strong></a>, et pourquoi il y a <a href="http://bfmbusiness.bfmtv.com/france/presidentielle-qui-soutient-qui-chez-les-economistes-1122440.html">peu d’économistes autour de lui</a>. C’est une politique… bizarrement anachronique, je ne vois pas d’autres termes.</p><p>Le relance keynésienne aujourd’hui à elle la faveur de tous — y compris des <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21693204-central-bankers-are-running-down-their-arsenal-other-options-exist-stimulate">banques centrales, qui n’ont plus de marges de manoeuvres ( !)</a>, s’exprimant via ce parangon anarcho-syndicaliste, The Economist. Parmi les candidats qui peuvent arriver au 2nd tour, deux plans de relance sont sur la table : celui de <strong>M. Mélenchon</strong> (à 100 Milliards d’Euro) et celui de <strong>M. Macron</strong> (à 50 Milliards). <strong>M. Mélenchon</strong> demande aux investisseurs étrangers de financer une dette plus large, tout en arguant dans le même temps qu’il faudra renégocier l’ensemble de la dette. C’est vouloir le beurre et l’argent du beurre. Dans le monde réel, les marchés voteront avec leurs ordres de vente et les discours de M. Mélenchon ne feront qu’augmenter le cout de la dette finançant son programme. D’autant que nos partenaires Européens, à commencer par nos alliés Allemands, refuseront qu’on leur fasse avaler de force un plan d’une pareille ampleur. Mais qu’on quitte alors l’Europe — et au-delà du désastre commercial pour nos entreprises, notre relance fabriquera les excédents des Allemands, sans espoir de retour via des mécanismes de compensation européens. <strong>M.</strong> <strong>Macron</strong>, lui, a déjà le soutien public du pourtant très austère Ministre des Finances Allemand CDU <strong>Wolfgang Schaüble</strong>. Face à des marchés volatiles, cela ira plus vite, sera moins dangereux pour l’Europe et coutera moins cher en terme de taux d’intérêt. Allons au concret.</p><p><strong>Rien sans innovation et traitements contre les « pathologies » françaises</strong></p><p>Il y a aussi une énigme à l’inefficacité de la France. La dépense publique constitue 57% du PNB en France, comparable aux pays scandinaves. Pour autant, le « retour sur investissement » de ces services ne semblent pas là. Les études PISA montrent par exemple que le système éducatif en France <a href="http://abonnes.lemonde.fr/les-decodeurs/portfolio/2017/04/18/les-fractures-francaises-2-5-education-la-fabrique-des-inegalites_5113074_4355770.html">perpétue les inégalités sociales</a>. Les problèmes de gestion des talents, fondamentaux dans n’importe quelle grande entreprise, sont magnifiées dans des institutions bureaucratiques. Il y a trop peu de liberté d’actions dans une gestion top-down. L’avancement se fait à l’ancienneté plutôt qu’au mérite et il n’y a pas de gestion des carrières. L’évaluation elle-même peut-être très rare : tous les 3 à 5 ans par exemple pour l’inspection dans l’éducation. Aucune entreprise ne pourrait être productive si l’action individuelle n’était pas évaluée à minima tous les ans ; s’il n’y avait pas un minimum d’autonomie d’action ; s’il n’y avait pas de gestion des carrières pour les talents humains. Ce débat, je l’ai souvent eu avec de nombreux amis, dont certains hauts fonctionnaires. <strong>M. Macron</strong>, lui-même un ancien de l’IGF mais aussi du privé, est le seul à s’être exprimé sur ces problèmes fondamentaux de management de l’action public. Il demande une évaluation de l’action de la loi et l’établissement d’un vrai systèmes de gestion de carrières dans la plus grande administration de l’Etat, l’Education Nationale. Il est dommage que les autres candidats n’aient vu l’action publique que sur l’angle investissement/désinvestissement. Ce qui compte ce n’est pas uniquement où mettre l’effort d’action publique — mais aussi comment.</p><p>Cette meilleure gestion de l’action publique est nécessaire pour vaincre le chômage et préparer, s’il n’est pas trop tard, notre économie à la transformation numérique. Celle-ci est déjà en grande partie en cours : parmi les 10 plus grandes capitalisations mondiales, 5 sont des sociétés du numérique (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_public_corporations_by_market_capitalization#2017">Apple, Alphabet/Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook</a>). Associé à la robotique, elle va accélérer l’automatisation du travail. Elle va également détruire rapidement les emplois de service dans le commerce, comme c’est désormais en cours aux Etats-Unis où l’on parle de <a href="https://www.google.fr/url?sa=t&amp;rct=j&amp;q=&amp;esrc=s&amp;source=web&amp;cd=1&amp;cad=rja&amp;uact=8&amp;ved=0ahUKEwjEqKDZ6LXTAhVGVhoKHbmZAj8QFggtMAA&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theatlantic.com%2Fbusiness%2Farchive%2F2017%2F04%2Fretail-meltdown-of-2017%2F522384%2F&amp;usg=AFQjCNGV6rZJuVbzTaXpmAQOYXczTt__zw&amp;sig2=0dpAEZXhDxwUxhlr2Rqx-w">« Retail Apocalypse » en cette année 2017</a>. Ce défi économique et social doit être relevé si nous voulons mettre fin au chômage de masse. Il peut l’être si d’une part on opère un effort de formation post-éducation qui soit d’une magnitude comparable à celui connu après-guerre sur le capital humain au niveau de la santé ; et si l’on opère également un effort intelligent dans le financement des startups/PME — car l’innovation et l’emploi ne se créent pas dans les grands groupes champions nationaux mais dans les écosystèmes de startups &amp; PME, une leçon au cœur de la « Startup Nation » Israélienne dont le <a href="http://www.tradingeconomics.com/israel/unemployment-rate">taux de chômage est de 4.3%</a>. Dans les programmes, certaines propositions ressortent clairement qui vont dans ce sens, même si cela est encore insuffisant: un programme d’investissement dans la formation de 15 milliards proposé par <strong>M. Macron</strong> (parti du plan de 50 milliards), ainsi qu’une disparition de l’ISF sur l’investissement industriel mais pas sur la rente immobilière pour attirer l’épargne vers l’industrie plutôt que la rente ; un programme réservant 50% de la commande publique aux PME/PMI chez <strong>M. Hamon</strong>. Il y a également des mesures prometteuses, même si plus floues chez <strong>M. Fillon</strong> — avec un bémol : les ‘premières’ priorités listées sont dans les infrastructures, pas dans l’écosystème (humain &amp; startups). C’est un peu penser la révolution numérique comme la télématique au temps des grandes institutions d’Etat.</p><p><strong>Défendre le principe de la sécurité collective</strong></p><p>Reste les questions de défense et de diplomatie. Elles sont fondamentales car nos principes de sécurité collective sont aujourd’hui remis en question à la fois par l’Extrême gauche (qui veut sortir de l’OTAN) mais aussi par une partie de la Droite conservatrice, en rupture avec la position des partis de gouvernement depuis l’après-guerre. <a href="https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/d%C3%A9fendre-lotan-d%C3%A9fendre-la-paix-69d010241273">Comme je l’ai déjà écrit ailleurs</a>, le débat a vu émerger des positions hallucinantes, convergeant vers une conférence ‘pour la paix’ en Europe où les prises de guerre de la Russie en Crimée et en Ukraine de l’Est seraient entérinées; et où le sort des Etats Baltes, pays démocratiques membres de l’Alliance Atlantique, serait laissé à l’appréciation de son voisin Russe. C’est ce qui ressort de l’intervention de <strong>M. Mélenchon</strong> lors du Débat du 20/3/2017, soutenue en direct par <strong>M. Fillon</strong> (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VYXhy7Om0gs">voir les 8 minutes entre MM. Mélenchon et Fillon à partir de 2:36:30</a>). Revenir sur le principe d’inviolabilité des frontières en Europe, c’est inacceptable car c’est revenir sur l’un des principes garants de la paix depuis 1945. Revenir sur le principe même de la sécurité collective est inadmissible pour deux raisons : d’une part, c’est oublier que l’article V du traité de l’OTAN, qui commande l’automaticité d’une solidarité militaire envers un membre de l’Alliance, vient directement de la leçon tirée des ambiguïtés et des politiques d’<em>appeasement</em> des premiers ministres britanniques Baldwin et Chamberlain face à Hitler. D’autre part, la cyber-défense, qui est une défense en réseau, commande d’amplifier la sécurité collective. Enfin, nous avons en face de nous un nouvel ennemi, la Russie, qui voit désormais dans le prestige d’aventures extérieures un échappatoire à ses problèmes internes. La guerre en Ukraine a été déclenchée quand les Russes ont compris que l’Ukraine voulait s’accrocher à l’Union Européenne, pas à la Russie. Les accords de Minsk II ont été négociés pour l’Europe par Merkel et Hollande — pas les personnes les plus va-t-en guerre. Dire que nous sommes trop durs avec Poutine et que nous devrions avoir une politique d’accommodement, comme le sous-entend <strong>M. Fillon</strong>, c’est inciter la Russie à plus d’actions — par exemple dans les pays Baltes, cauchemar des états-majors occidentaux, et peut-être dès septembre, quand la Russie organisera ses exercices militaires <a href="http://www.ibtimes.com/russian-war-games-zapad-2017-military-drills-terrifies-nato-members-2500222">Zapad 2017</a>. Une exagération ? Non seulement la Lithuanie a rétabli le service militaire, mais la Suède également, au mois de mars, face à la menace russe. L’a-t-on évoqué dans les débats ou les programmes ? Non. La France est derrière ses lignes Maginots militaire — même si le cyber-espace ne connait aucune frontière et que la Russie a déjà démontrée qu’elle cherche à intimider via des attaques électroniques à travers l’Europe (en plus des bombardiers Tupolev interceptés de temps à autre par la chasse française). On entend aussi des « absurderies », comme quand <strong>M. Mélenchon</strong> parle de dissuasion en défense. <strong>M. Mélenchon</strong> veut renforcer la posture dissuasive de la France tout en réduisant ses armements et proposant des conférences de paix. Il faut apprécier l’audace du tribun prêt du haut de sa faconde à remettre en cause 3000 ans de littérature stratégique et de B.A.BA de la théorie des jeux. On s’en tiendra aux positions plus sérieuses à ce sujet de <strong>M. Hamon</strong> et de <strong>M. Macron</strong>.</p><p><strong>Eviter l’impéritie : voter — vraiment — utile</strong></p><p>Se pose la question de comment gouverner. Or, immédiatement, pour <strong>M. Fillon</strong>, s’il est élu, on se demande comment il pourra faire passer un programme d’austérité et d’efforts avec les affaires qu’il traîne désormais. Il y a pire : si sa femme est condamnée, alors que lui bénéficie de l’immunité présidentielle, il perdra toute légitimité pour gouverner. Il sera probablement forcé de démissionner, ouvrant une nouvelle phase électorale où les extrêmes, avec les affaires, seront renforcés. Si nous évitons l’Extreme Droite en Mai 2017, avec un Président Fillon, nous risquons très fortement de la retrouver, décuplée, 12–24 mois plus tard. Le « tous pourri » sonnera affreusement juste, en raison de la position de <strong>M. Fillon</strong>. Nous serons à nouveau au bord du précipice.</p><p>Mais nous pourrions l’être également avec <strong>M. Mélenchon</strong> : à nouveau les marchés internationaux décideraient de se méfier terriblement de la signature française. Dès lors se poserait une question politique grave pour <strong>M. Mélenchon</strong> : soit abandonner rapidement ses positions comme l’on fait Tsipras au bout de 6 mois ou Mitterand en 83, mais cette fois avec le risque d’une absence de majorité au Parlement ; soit se couper des marchés internationaux — et risquer un destin sud-américain qui semble impensable en France. Là aussi, le risque des déçus versant dans l’autre extrême, celle de droite, et assez rapidement, pourrait être rapide et brutal.</p><p>Dans cette situation, seul un vote pour <strong>M. Macron</strong> constitue un vote utile qui permet d’éloigner pour au moins cinq ans le risque d’arrivée au pouvoir d’extrême droite. D’une certaine façon, le pôle centriste social-libéral que pourrait constituer <strong>M. Macron</strong> au parlement établit un parallèle avec le pôle républicain libéral/progressiste/radical/radical-socialiste qui a bâti la IIIième République en opposition aux monarchistes. Nous en sommes là : ce pôle historique se reconstitue face à la menace anti-républicaine, incarnée désormais par l’Extrême Droite. Le gouvernement de <strong>M. Macron</strong>, s’il est élu, devra s’associer aux franges libérales de la droite et de la gauche. Ce sera un gouvernement sinon d’union nationale, en tout cas de combat.</p><p>— -</p><p>Ce combat contre l’Extrême Droite, il ne doit pas se faire résigné, mais bien au contraire dans l’audace. En 1792, face aux forces anti-républicaines menées par la Prusse et l’Autriche, sur le point d’envahir la France, Danton se précipita à l’Assemblée Nationale pour clamer que face à l’Ennemi, il fallait « De l’audace, encore de l’audace, toujours de l’audace !». 18 jours plus tard, la République remportait sa première grande victoire militaire à Valmy. Cette audace, c’est celle qui doit animer notre action de citoyens désormais et impulser celle des dirigeants politiques que nous nous choisissons. La France est dos au mur, mais elle a tous les moyens pour remporter ses combats. Ce qu’il lui faut ? Casser les lignes Maginots qui contraignent encore mentalement et spirituellement son action et qui tueront la France. Il n’y a de défense que dans l’attaque. Plutôt qu’essayer de se couper d’un Continent dont elle est le cœur, la France doit avancer avec son allié Allemand dans la création d’une Union plus forte de l’Europe. Plutôt que de se protéger des marchés mondiaux derrière des frontières virtuelles, la France doit coopérer, prendre sa part aux grands traités d’échange, et ouvrir son économie. Plutôt que thésauriser et être obnubilée par sa dette publique, qui n’est qu’une partie du problème, elle doit investir maintenant pour l’avenir et en particulier dans sa principale ressource de richesse à l’heure du digital: son talent humain. Plutôt que de croire qu’elle peut apaiser les menaces d’intimidations de la Russie en lui laissant libre cours, là-bas, dans cette « lointaine » Europe de l’Est ou du Nord, elle doit passer à l’offensive avec son allié Allemand, en particulier dans l’investissement des industries de cybersécurité. Cette audace, elle est vitale et pour la France, et pour le Monde — car si la France tombe, l’Occident sera être entraîné dans une spirale sans issue. Pour toutes les raisons exprimées plus haut, cette audace, c’est dans le programme d’Emmanuel Macron qu’elle est aujourd’hui est exprimée avec le plus de force et de raison.</p><p>Voila pourquoi ce dimanche 23 avril, je voterai Emmanuel Macron.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31a1042ad7c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Défendre L’OTAN, défendre la Paix]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/d%C3%A9fendre-lotan-d%C3%A9fendre-la-paix-69d010241273?source=rss-c32bf97175f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/69d010241273</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Guy-Philippe Goldstein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 16 Apr 2017 17:07:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-16T17:07:00.869Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A l’occasion de la campagne présidentielle en France, on découvre de nouvelles propositions pour la sécurité de la France: La sortie de l’alliance OTAN remplacée par une entrée de la France dans une alliance de pays sud-américains accompagnés de l’Iran et de la Russie (l’’Alba’ de Jean-Luc Mélenchon); La distanciation vis-à-vis de l’OTAN et une politique d’accommodement avec la Russie (Fillon); La sortie de l’OTAN et le rapprochement avec la Russie (Le Pen). Ces positions convergent vers une conférence ‘pour la paix’ en Europe où les prises de guerre de la Russie en Crimée et en Ukraine de l’Est seraient entérinées; et où le sort des Etats Baltes, pays démocratiques membres de l’Alliance Atlantique, serait laissé à l’appréciation de son voisin Russe. C’est ce qui ressort de l’intervention de M. Mélenchon lors du Débat du 20/3/2017, soutenue en direct par M. Fillon (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VYXhy7Om0gs">voir les 8 minutes entre MM. Mélenchon et Fillon à partir de 2:36:30</a>).</p><p>Ces propositions sont dangereuses. Premièrement, elles insultent la réalité et la volonté des forces en présence, marquées par une <strong>volonté du Kremlin</strong> de reconstituer la sphère soviétique et en face un <strong>outil militaire américain</strong> sans commune comparaison. Deuxièmement, sur le fond, elles remettent en cause les principes de <strong>sécurité collective</strong> qui fondent la paix en Europe depuis 1945. Elles nient la <strong>logique de la dissuasion</strong> tel que le démontre la théorie des jeux. Enfin, troisièmement, elles font l’impasse sur l’avènement d’une<strong> sécurité en réseau liée à la cyberdéfense</strong>, nouveau pilier stratégique de la défense du Continent. Appliquées, ces proposition augmenteront significativement le risque de guerre en Europe et provoqueront une rupture de la stabilité que connait le continent depuis 1945.</p><p><strong><em>La réalité des forces en Europe</em></strong></p><p>La Russie de Poutine constitue aujourd’hui un danger pour la stabilité du continent. Sur le plan intérieur, son économie a été incapable de se diversifier au-delà de la rente des énergies fossiles, qui représentaient <a href="https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=17231">2/3 de ses exports </a>avant que le cours du baril de pétrole ne perde la <a href="http://fortune.com/2015/12/22/oil-price-plunge/">moitié de sa valeur</a>. Au coeur de cette incapacité, il y a l’économie kleptocratique russe — ce que Daron Acemoglu du MIT appellerait un système économique extractif, profitant à une élite qui garde exclusivement pour elle les richesses. Cette nouvelle nomenklatura, issue de l’ex-KGB, a gérée l’économie productive comme la rente énergétique — un exemple (parmi d’autres): Pavel Durov, le créateur du Facebook russe, VKontakte, dépossédé de toutes ses actions a<a href="http://www.theverge.com/2014/1/31/5363990/how-putins-cronies-seized-control-over-russias-facebook-pavel-durov-vk">u profit d’oligarques proche du Kremlin</a>. La propriété privée n’existe pas encore vraiment dans la Russie de Poutine. En conséquences, <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21708876-political-reform-essential-prerequisite-flourishing-economy-milk-without">les investissements privés en actifs mobilisés ont baissé de 37% en 4 ans</a>. La somme de ces difficultés, c’est 3 ans de très faible croissance ou de récession; un niveau de vie qui a baissé de 10%; l<a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/they-survived-wwii-now-they-live-on-450-a-day/2016/11/07/a6fba4e4-7f71-11e6-ad0e-ab0d12c779b1_story.html?utm_term=.af7b48e38dd8">a difficulté de payer certains pensionnaires</a> — et un PNB par habitant équivalent à celui de la Grèce, pour un PNB total autour de celui de l’Espagne.</p><p>Pour protéger ce système en difficulté, le Kremlin a réagit sur le plan domestique et international. Il s’est assuré le soutien des élites de l’appareil de défense et de renseignement en faisant passer le<a href="http://www.rferl.org/a/russias-state-controlled-capitalism/28022612.html"> budget du secteur public de 35% à 70% du PNB</a> et en accordant la part belle à l’armée (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures">5.4% du PNB contre 3.3% aux USA et 2.2% ou moins en Europe</a>) et au renseignement. Il a renforcé les avantages de l’élite — ce qui classe la Russie <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_Russia">dans le bas du tableau de la corruption mondiale </a>. En même temps, il a renforcé la répression contre certains bouc-émissaires comme les homosexuels, contrôlé des élections où bourrage des urnes et <a href="http://www.rferl.org/a/russia-duma-elections-navalny-pamfilova-resignation/28007404.html">manipulation électronique des résultats restent de mise</a> — tout en laissant des supplétifs tels que des membres des forces spéciales du président Tchétchène Kadyrov supprimer des opposants tels que Boris Nemtsov (Kadyrov fut décoré par Poutine deux semaines plus tard).</p><p>A cette action interne s’est ajoutée, crucialement, une politique de prestige qui devait passer par la reconstitution d’une union eurasienne intégrant les états d’Asie centrale, du Caucase, le Bélarus et surtout l’Ukraine. Or, cette stratégie échoue à l’hiver 2013–2014 quand la rue fait partir le Président Ukrainien qui, sous la pression de Moscou, avait fini par refuser un accord d’association avec l’Union Européenne. Pour la première fois, c’est la puissance d’attraction de l’Union Européenne qui provoque une révolution à l’Est — ce qui n’a pas été beaucoup noté en Europe de l’Ouest. Le Kremlin va réagir par une action militaire en Ukraine de l’Est et en Crimée qui débouche, <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/ukraine/2016-04-18/why-putin-took-crimea">dans pas mal d’improvisation, par l’annexion de la Crimée</a>. C’est un moment de bascule au Kremlin — peut-être parce que l’on craint que les mêmes manifestations pro-UE ne reverse le régime à Moscou avec le souvenir des manifestations de 2011 dans les grands centres urbains, ou des révolutions arabes — <a href="https://warontherocks.com/2016/03/russian-hybrid-warfare-and-other-dark-arts/">ce qui est analysé de près par l’Etat major russe</a>. La Russie renforce sa politique d’intimidation contre les forces aériennes et sous-marine en Europe; elle renforce une stratégie de guerre ‘hybride’ et de désinformation contre l’Occident; et va jusqu’à tenter de directement influencer les élections américaines et européennes. Le pouvoir se cramponne: <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/09/opinion/how-do-you-get-to-be-a-governor-in-vladimir-putins-russia.html?_r=0">Poutine lui-même remplace des gouverneurs régionaux par d’anciens gardes du corps</a> et crée <a href="http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/04/12/putin-creates-enormous-praetorian-guard-puts-his-bodyguard-in-charge.html">une garde nationale quasi-prétorienne de 400.000 personnes</a>. Ne pouvant offrir de solution économique ou politique — le système étant bloqué dans sa flexibilité d’ouverture par sa nature kleptocratique, tout gage politique équivalant à la perte d’intérêts économiques parfois considérables — la seule issue reste la recherche d’une opération de prestige à l’extérieure, avec un consensus “autour du drapeau” forgé dans la mise en valeur de la menace externe. Une des cibles, ce sont les Etats Baltes dont parlaient — justement! — M. Mélenchon et qui constituent l’un des ‘canari dans la mine’ en cas d’une restauration éventuelle de l’Empire Soviétique. Avant l’Ukraine, avant la Géorgie en 2008, il y avait déjà eu ce premier test: celui de la cyber-guerilla contre l’Estonie en 2007.</p><p>Or, face à cette nouvelle agressivité russe, les pays scandinaves &amp; baltes qui prennent conscience qu’ils sont en première ligne face à la nouvelle menace russe, et qui viennent pour certains de rétablir le service militaire obligatoire (<a href="http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/sweden-military-conscription-draft-russia-balkan-threat-men-women-a7607411.html">Suède</a>, Lithuanie) — ont parfaitement conscience qu’ils ont terriblement désinvesti dans leur outil militaire. La Suède par exemple n’a aujourd’hui que <a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4033994/Sweden-warns-preparing-war-Officials-ordered-ensure-civil-defence-infrastructure-ready-fear-Russian-invasion-grows.html">20.000 militaires pour défendre son territoire</a> contre presque 10 fois plus il y a 30 ans. En réalité, tant sur le plan des questions de défense “kinétiques” que sur le plan du renseignement/défense cyber, la puissance militaire américaine demeure la premiere puissance européenne. Seule une présence américaine, accompagnée des quelques dernières puissances militaires européennes avec une capacité de projection réelle (France, Grande-Bretagne), peut permettre une capacité de dissuasion conventionnelle <em>à minima</em> face à la Russie. <em>A minima</em>, car les wargames de la RAND Corp rendus publics en 2016 ont montré que les états Baltes ne peuvent pas être défendus militairement de manière conventionnelle si la Russie décidait de les envahir: <a href="http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/nato-russia-baltic-states-overrun-in-hours-rand-corporation-report-a7384381.html">l’OTAN serait défait en 36 heures</a>. (L’installation de <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/2016/11/21/reuters-america-russia-to-deploy-s-400-and-iskander-missiles-in-kaliningrad--ria-cites-senator.html">S-400 Iskander à Kalingrad</a> n’ont probablement pas amélioré les chances de l’OTAN). La nervosité est d’autant plus grande en cet avril 2017 que la propagande russe fait entendre que, comme en Ukraine, certaines régions et villes de la Lithuanie telles que<a href="http://www.businessinsider.fr/us/russia-propaganda-in-lithuania-attack-on-the-baltics-2017-4/"> Klaipeda, la 3e ville du pays, devrait appartenir en fait à la Russie.</a></p><p>La seule solution que l’OTAN ait trouvé, c’est celle des <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21701515-ageing-alliance-hopes-russia-will-get-message-it-serious-trip-wire-deterrence">bataillons “tripwire”</a>, comme les bataillons placés au coeur de Berlin pendant la guerre froide (et dont parle Thomas Schelling dans “Arms &amp; Influence”): pas de vraies capacités défensives en tant que tel, mais s’ils étaient attaqués, alors ils déclencheraient automatiquement une riposte US. C’était l’un des coeurs de la dissuasion pendant la guerre froide et c’est pour cela qu’on le <a href="http://www.defenseone.com/ideas/2017/04/lithuania-nato-troops-adjust-life-potentially-hostile-border/137021/?oref=defenseone_today_nl">réutilise aujourd’hui en Lithuanie</a>. Ils sont au coeur d’une opération militaire de nature profondément politique: si l’OTAN ne souhaitait défendre les pays membres que sont les Etats Baltes, alors c’est toute la garantie de sécurité portée par l’Alliance Atlantique qui serait mis en défaut. Dans ce scénario, pour l’Ukraine, le message serait très clair: vous souhaitez rejoindre l’UE, mais vous n’avez pas d’autres destin qu’être dans l’orbite de la Russie. La même interprétation aurait lieu aussi en Europe de l’Est. En intervenant dans les Etats Baltes, la Russie pourrait rétablir l’influence de son ex-Empire — si l’OTAN refusait de jouer son rôle. Au moment de la crise, dans le tempo d’une action militaire pouvant se déboucler en 36 heures, avoir des dissensions fortes à l’intérieur de l’OTAN entre pays signataires pourrait mener à son impéritie. On comprend mieux dès lors<strong><em> les enjeux des élections françaises d’avril-juin et leur impact potentiel en Europe dès cet été</em></strong>.</p><p><strong><em>Les principes en jeu</em></strong></p><p>C’est dire l’importance primordiale pour la sécurité en Europe de nos principes de sécurité collective. Celle-ci vient directement des leçons tirées des années 30 et de la défaite de la dissuasion française et anglaise, très hésitante, précautionnieuse et jamais automatique à défendre la Tchécoslovaquie puis la Pologne (sans parler de la Rhénanie et de l’Autriche). La seconde guerre mondiale a été déclenchée parce qu’après Munich, Hitler s’est permis en mars 1939 d’écraser le reste de la République Tchécoslovaque. Les britanniques ont alors donné des “garanties” de sécurité à la Pologne au 31 mars 1939, mais sans envoyer de bataillons sur place. Hitler n’a pas trouvé crédibles ces garanties et a demandé à la Wehrmarcht de préparer des plans d’invasion de la Pologne <a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/wwtwo/invasion_poland_01.shtml">dès le 3 avril suivant</a>: Hitler a cru jusqu’au bout que Chamberlain ne bougerait pas si in fine il envahissait la Pologne. L’article V de la charte de l’OTAN tire les leçons de cet échec en postulant une défense automatique de tous les membres de l’Alliance si l’un des membres est attaqué.</p><p>Un front stratégique uni — avec des lignes rouges claires — est nécessaire car la Russie de Poutine, comme tous les acteurs agressifs, agit par opportunisme en cherchant les maillons faibles et en s’attaquant d’abord à des cibles ‘faciles’ qui soulignent en creux les abandons ou les manques de volonté de l’Occident. La Russie s’est réinséré en Syrie à la mi-2015 parce que les Etats-Unis l’avait abandonné en 2013. La Russie s’est attaquée militairement à la Georgie en 2008 et à l’Ukraine depuis 2014 parce que ces deux pays ne sont pas des pays OTAN. La Russie intervient directement dans des opérations non pas d’espionnage (ce que tout le monde fait) mais de provocation (ce que tout le monde évite) dirigé contres les partis politiques et les réseaux sociaux — parce que les Occidentaux n’ont jamais considéré les systèmes info des partis politiques comme ‘infrastructure vitale’ à l’égal des réseaux de distribution de l’électricité ou les télécommunications. La Russie a testé la volonté de l’Occident dans toutes ces zones géographiques ou fonctionnelles qui sont autant de ventre mou. Comme vu plus haut, les pays baltes sont un autre ventre mou militaire (difficilement défendable) doublé d’un ventre mou politique s’il y a des dissensions à l’intérieur de l’OTAN; et si un pays majeur de l’OTAN refuse de défendre l’un des pays baltes dans les premières heures de la crise militaire.</p><p>Sur le fond, remettre en cause ce principe du front uni, c’est aussi ne pas bien comprendre en théorie des jeux comment fonctionne la dissuasion. On pourrait évoquer à nouveau Thomas Schelling, mais aussi la lecture plus moderne en terme de théorie de jeux des principes de ‘Perfect Deterrence’ développée par <a href="https://books.google.fr/books/about/Perfect_Deterrence.html?id=9lWUxFvn9dMC&amp;printsec=frontcover&amp;source=kp_read_button&amp;redir_esc=y#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false">Zagare et Marc Kilgour</a>. Le risque de guerre n’est jamais aussi fort que lorsqu’il y a incertitude. La principale incertitude, c’est lorsque deux forces en puissance pensent qu’elles ont à peu près la même force. (A l’inverse, il n’y aura jamais de conflit entre Andorre et la France, par exemple — parce que l’issue serait evidente). Les principaux conflits en Europe ont eu lieu entre puissance établie et puissance montante, contestant la puissance établie: Grande-Bretagne contre France au XVIIIe et début du XIXe siècle; Allemagne contre France à la fin du XIXième siècle; Grande-Bretagne &amp; France contre Allemagne au XXième siècle. Cette règle a été magnifiée par les grands conflits du siècle, et l’opposition des deux super-grands USA vs URSS après 1945. Dans une lutte d’influence, entre deux puissances qui se pensent équivalentes, aller au conflit réduit l’inconnu informationnel. C’est pour cela que l’adage “Civis Pacem…” reste encore d’actualité. Il n’y a qu’en faisant la démonstration de sa force, tant dans la posture militaire que dans la crédibilité politique, que l’on peut maintenir sa posture défensive et éviter le conflit: ol faut que l’information soit claire. Faire l’inverse — réduire la posture militaire et réduire la crédibilité de l’OTAN en en sortant — c’est augmenter le risque de conflit au regard de toute la littérature strategique, et au regard de l’histoire. C’est pourtant ce que l’on entend dans les discours de M. Mélenchon. C’est un contresens grave.</p><p>La nécessité d’une défense collective appuyée par une posture credible sont renforcés aujourd’hui par la cybersécurité, qui fonctionne en réseau de confiance. L’avantage compétitif dans le cyberespace appartient à celui qui comprend ce qui est attaqué, avec quels objectifs, quels mode opératoires et par qui. Sans cette connaissance la défense est aveugle et condamnée à la défaite. Seul celui qui est le mieux connecté au réseau de connaissance constitué par l’échange entre instituts de recherche, sociétés de cybersécurité, Etats-Nations — seul celui-là peut pleinement défendre ses intérêts et développer son influence. A contrario, quitter ce réseau, ce n’est pas comprendre comment fonctionne l’influence et donc se construit une indépendance nationale à l’age de l’interdépendance nécessaire des réseaux. Quitter ce réseau c’est tout simplement perdre en influence — il n’y a pas de réseau équivalent d’un point de vue technique et de l’étendue et la richesse de la connaissance. La cybersécurité elle aussi obéit aux effets d’effets de réseau. Cela n’interdit pas les stratégies d’influence même de petits pays: l’exemple d’Israël montre que si on est “plus” connecté plutôt que moins on peut défendre ses intérêts de manière indépendante et souveraine par rapport aux États-Unis. Mais cela nécessite d’avoir une approche audacieuse et d’aller de l’avant par rapport à ce qui existe en étant encore plus présent au coeur du reseau. Pas de se retirer sur des lignes Maginot ou de s’inventer des alliances en pays de Cocagne qui ne sont souvent pas autre chose que des instruments diplomatiques utilisés par la Russie. Le seul pays qui à la suite de la Russie a mis son veto à l’établissement d’une commission d’enquête sur l’attaque au gaz Sarin contre des civils à Idlib en Syrie — c’est la Bolivie, pays frère de l’Alba.</p><p>On est bien loin du sérieux et de la prise de conscience nécessaire des menaces qui pèsent sur l’Europe. Car s’il y a une crise grave face à la pression russe, cette dimension Cyber sera également en jeu: l’attaque à deux reprises des systèmes électriques en Ukraine en 2015 et 2016 par des cyber-attaques russes montre qu’une attaque contre les pays baltes pourrait ne pas s’arrêter aux frontières physiques. D’autant que des intimidations russes ont deja eu lieu contre la France: TV5 Monde à été victime en 2015 de cyber-attaques visant a stopper sa diffusion. L’attaque avait ete revendiquée par le “cyber caliphat”. Les enqueteurs francais et occidentaux pensent depuis qu’il s’agissait d’une attaque russe. Une réalité devrait s’imposer à tous: il n’y a pas de frontières dans le cyberespace. De la même façon que nous devons être solidaire de tous en Europe. Ceux qui veulent abandonner les Etats Baltes ou la zone Nord/Est de l’Europe reprennent sans le savoir probablement ceux qui ne “voulaient pas mourir pour Danzig.”</p><p>Le renoncement ou l’accomodement — ce que les britanniques ont appelé l’appeasement — constitue toujours la pire des stratégies. C’est celle qui mène le plus sûrement à la guerre. La plupart des électeurs d’avril-mai et juin en France l’ignore peut-être, mais c’est l’un des enjeux cachés et graves de ce qui se joue dans les semaines qui viennent.</p><p>Cette information très peu diffusée à ma grande surprise est l’enjeu de ces quelques lignes. Il n’est pas encore trop tard.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=69d010241273" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The “Darwin Point”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@guyphilippegoldstein/the-darwin-point-4be43e130743?source=rss-c32bf97175f1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4be43e130743</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[foreign-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Guy-Philippe Goldstein]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Oct 2016 14:43:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-07T15:29:26.826Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Godwin’s law” is the famous early 1990s observation by attorney Mike Godwin that ‘<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law">As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazism or Hitler approaches 1’</a>. In France, it has been translated into the “Point Godwin”- that precise moment when indeed conversation has descended into Nazi comparison and no more civic <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/12/14/sure-call-trump-a-nazi-just-make-sure-you-know-what-youre-talking-about/?utm_term=.dd5aaa22fc29">discussion is possible</a>. When meaningful exchanges have sunk into a black-hole singularity and only hatred comes out. When cognition gives way to emotion and then to termination, the end of the exchange. This is what happens to discussion online. A similar process is today engulfing our human civilization and is endangering the Western World. Reason has given way to raw and dark emotions, taking the shape of far right populism and authoritarianism. Now, hatred is being spilled all over the Western World and beyond. The democratic dialogue is quickly losing any sense of civility, especially in the United States, the largest, most powerful democracy in the world. If that process runs to its ultimate point, then we will, as a species, reach the termination of our global conversation, i.e. of our civilization. We will reach the “Darwin Point”. We will fail the natural selection test. We will become extinct.</p><p>***</p><p><strong><em>Three lessons of the postwar world</em></strong></p><p>If we fail the natural selection test - if we reach the “Darwin Point” - it will be indeed because we did not evolve; because we did not remember the lessons of the past and then we repeated the same terminal mistakes. The crisis of 2008 is not any type of recession. As it is fully recognized now, it is a “centennial” crisis fueled not by public debt or inflation but by private debt. P<a href="http://ritholtz.com/2012/09/private-debt-is-the-main-problem/">rivate debt reached 310% of GDP in the US in 2008, the highest level since the Great Depression</a> that started 80 years ago. The best comparison for the 2008 crisis and the ensuing Great Recession is indeed with the Great Depression. There are key lessons drawn from the Great Depression that were aptly applied after 2008. One of them is that instead of reducing money supply by a third, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causes_of_the_Great_Depression">as the Fed did between 1929 and 1933</a>, money supply must be increased during banking crisis. Indeed, Fed governor Ben Bernanke, a scholar of the Great Depression, increased the monetary base five-fold, <a href="https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/11/could-ben-bernanke-have-done-more/">from $800 billion to $4 trillion</a>.</p><p>But if one major lesson of the Great Recession has been retained, four other major lessons that have become pillars of the post-WWII world have been totally forgotten since 2008:</p><p>First, the need for <strong>internal solidarity</strong>, meaning further investment in human capital and infrastructure financed by further redistribution. This was translated into the New Deal major infrastructure projects and then the establishment of the NHS in the UK and the Sécurité Sociale in France right after the WWII, along with marginal tax rates moving back to the 70%-90% level for the highest bracket following WWII - itself a de facto immense scientific and industrial government-led &amp; financed endeavor.</p><p>Second, the need for <strong>external economic solidarity</strong>, meaning maintaining and developing trade among nations, not closing borders and rising customs duties. The currency wars between the US, France and the UK in the 1930s and even more the protectionist US Smoot-Hawley tariff act of 1930 led to continuous disruption and then contraction of global trade. The rise of borders at a time of a global banking crisis led to further economic disruption and nurtured the waves of massive unemployment. This is precisely the reason why after WWII, the victors created economic solidarity institutions like the World Bank, the IMF and then initiated GATT trade negotiations, starting with the Annecy round of 1949.</p><p>Third, the need for <strong>external military solidarity </strong>in the form of a clear collective security pact. The main lesson from the security crisis of the 1930s triggered by Hitler willingness to expand his “lebensraum” was that a lack of clear red lines invites aggression; creates unpredictability both for the aggressor and the status-quo powers; and finally leads to war. After the Sudetes crisis and the invasion of Czechoslovakia in March 1939, Hitler thought that the British Empire would not defend militarily Poland. Hitler had thus not expected that Britain would declare war after Germany’s invasion of Poland. This is why, faced with Soviet threats over Europe, western allied forces created NATO. In the Article 5 of its charter lies the heart of its collective security principle: if one of its member country is attacked, then all other members must immediately come to its defense. There must be no uncertainty in the triggering of Article 5.</p><p>* * *</p><p><strong><em>Oops! — Forgetting the three lessons of the postwar world</em></strong></p><p>However, since the start of the 2008 Great Recession, we have barely applied these lessons — and now we are moving further away from them. European governments and the US Congress have both refused to relax national budget rules and invest massively in human capital and infrastructure at a time where deleveraging has rendered private banking powerless and where public long term investment can be financed at depressingly low rates. Unfortunately, politicians have shifted all the heavy work on the shoulders of central banks. And now central banks are knocking back on the door of national governments, actually asking for governments to intervene and to increase <strong>internal solidarity</strong>. This has actually brought the despair of that perennial socialist magazine — <a href="http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2016/05/economist-explains">The Economist</a>: Central banks want governments’ actions — but there aren’t any so far.</p><p>… And governments and national parliaments, instead of heading to the lessons of the Great Depression, have preferred to talk about cutting deficit and to impose austerity. The same causes have created the same effects. In Greece, the austerity measures heading back to German Chancellor Brunning’s austerity measures between 1930 and 1932, led to equivalent results: the fantastic rise of the Far-Right. In the rest of Europe and America, Right-Wing Authoritarianism has also risen. The economic plight was not as dire in Greece thanks to the Fed, the Bank of England and then the promise of intervention by ECB Chair Mario Draghi in September 2012. But all across the Western World, the personal financial collapse of working class families indebted because of the housing mirage before 2008; and the realization of declining incomes; led to the decay of the middle-class, its split in the middle — and the growing fear for the lower-educated, lesser-connected, to find oneself in the terminally wrong side of the split. There were none of the food kitchen lines of the early 1930s — but simply no special national solidarity program, only a solitary struggle to avoid an unavoidable downward social move.</p><p>Already, social inequalities had increased since the late 1970s / early 1980s.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*lM0LTR0th5NSPVekvVdftg.png" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~saez/TabFig2014prel.xls">Striking it Richer: The Evolution of Top Incomes in the United States</a>, Emmanuel Saez, June 2015</figcaption></figure><p>In the same time, the lowest quintile in the US saw their income decline relative to the rest of the population (while remaining basically flat over the last 40 years).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/631/1*Wpq1fiqPv5fREhifvEAAOw.png" /></figure><p>The effect? <strong>The wealth effect created price inflation on a very particular and critical good for any family: housing</strong>. However, this was hidden as long as credit could compensate for the lack of income.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/451/1*fpWT3FzNkY3151PwsLOODA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis (Department of Commerce) supplies the disposable income figure, and the savings rate figure, the Federal Reserve’s Flow of Funds report supplies the aggregate household debt figure. See <a href="http://greed311.rssing.com/chan-27044396/all_p3.html">http://greed311.rssing.com/chan-27044396/all_p3.html</a></figcaption></figure><p>Once the credit bubble exploded, and artificially inflated housing prices started to collapse, many middle-to-lower income households found themselves deeply indebted, stuck with negative value. People knew that their chance in one generation to create household value for their family was terminally finished. Some fell into despair, even suicide or drug consumption: <a href="http://www.pnas.org/content/112/49/15078.full.pdf">mortality rate for US white non-Hispanics 45–54 has actually increased between 2000 and 2014</a>. Many fell into anger. That translated into further political polarization and further isolationism, which had already started as social inequalities tore down the fabric of society by the early 1980s.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sDeC4vTeWkf1QFWup1fifA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Black bars: Wealth share of richest 0.01% of America’s households. Data: Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman. Red line: Distance between Republicans and Democrats in House of Representatives. Data: McCarty, Poole and Rosenthal. Source: </strong><a href="http://www.moneyandmarkets.com/worse-great-depression-76870">http://www.moneyandmarkets.com/worse-great-depression-76870</a></figcaption></figure><p>Again — the lesson from the post-war world had not been remembered. One reason for exploding social inequalities is very simple: lack of redistribution by way of taxation. A great reduction of the marginal tax rate on the highest brackets happened in 1920 in the US. It fueled in part the housing and equity speculation of the 1920s — till the Great Depression ended all that. However, by the mid-1980s, the marginal tax rate on the highest brackets had been again reduced from the 70%-90% in the 1950s-1970s (hardly a moment of economic stagnation in the US) — to actually the level of the 1920s.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*j9b67L_MVsiMUsIsLSGO5g.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Source: Tax Foundation, “U.S. Federal Individual Income Tax Rates History, 1862–2013”, 17 October 2013</em></p><p>Post-2008, anger reached terminal level. Trade and globalization have become a target. In part, it is justified. From 2000 to 2010, the US job markets lost 5.6 million in manufacturing jobs, a decline of about 30%.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*C5ZUYP5EESIYQsGWqLarAg.png" /></figure><p><a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/29/business/economy/more-wealth-more-jobs-but-not-for-everyone-what-fuels-the-backlash-on-trade.html">What the figure does not say, is that only 13% of that was related to commerce , according to the Center for Business and Economic Research at Ball State University in Indiana. In this figure, the entering of China into WTO in 2001 looms large. But the most important reason by far for this decline is the optimization of the production line, which includes in part robotization</a>.</p><p>Still, rather than fighting the robots, it is easier to have as a nemesis a foreign scapegoat. But the real human culprits are, again, governments and their lobbyists that created the (working class) losers and the (wealthy &amp; educated) winners of these modernization &amp; globalization changes. Under the financing of forces opposed to redistribution, aka higher taxes, governments have forgotten the necessity for redistribution so that there would be no losers to these changes. To redirect the anger of the losing working class, rather than to redistribute, it has become finally more convenient to blame the trade pacts and the foreign producers. Consequently, the <strong>international economic solidarity</strong>, the second lesson of the 1930s, is now being attacked.</p><p>To wit: the WTO, the follow-up organization to the GATT, started the Doha Development Round, in 2001. It collapsed in 2008. Since then, it has been impossible to revive it. As a combined result of the lack of effort on trade and the lack of national efforts on reviving growth, <a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2016/05/15/the-new-trump-order-global-trade-growth-stutters-for-first-time/">global trade growth has stalled for the first time since WWII</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/834/1*SiqL585lj-Iik_Fo1CEjYA.png" /></figure><p>The two potential replacement negotiations — the TPP between America and Asian countries, and the TTIP between America and Europe — are both stalling and have been denounced by most politicians on all sides of the oceans. The spread of protectionism has been further exacerbated by Brexit. If the UK cannot manage to reestablish some form of open trades with the EU, the UK will revert to by default WTO rules. This means an<a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/05/19/what-would-brexit-mean-for-british-trade/"> average increase of 10%-15% tariff trades with its closest economic partner, the EU</a>. <a href="http://www.economist.com/node/12798595">The infamous Smoot-Hawley tariff act of 1930 increased tariff on average by 20%</a>. Even the integrity of continental free-trade areas such as the European Union or Nafta could be at risk. If they collapse, beyond stock market shocks and stall of investment, there will be a very deep disruption and contraction of the US and European economies — and thus of the rest of the world economy. As in the early 1930s.</p><p>If borders keep closing, the cost will fall proportionally more on the same hard-hit population — the working class. <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/special-report/21707834-truth-and-myth-about-effects-openness-trade-coming-and-going">As the Economist states, quoting a study by economists from Columbia University and University of California</a>,</p><blockquote>“[…] in an average country, people on high incomes would lose 28% of their purchasing power if borders were closed to trade. But the poorest 10% of consumers would lose 63% of their spending power, because they buy relatively more imported goods.”</blockquote><p>So it’s easy to see how, without redistribution and infrastructure investment, but the closing of borders, the poorest segments of the people become ever more enraged and feed right-wing authoritarianism. And so, with the forgetting of the <strong>first</strong> <strong>lesson (internal solidarity) </strong>and <strong>second lesson</strong> <strong>(international solidarity)</strong> from the Great Depression, we have entered slowly but surely, a sort of vicious circle — let’s call that the “<strong><em>slow 1930s</em></strong>”. Initial recovery was much better than after 1929 because Central Banks did retain their lesson; but then, as detailed, Governments did not. <a href="http://www.irisheconomy.ie/index.php/2015/11/29/it-has-finally-happened/">And so, by 2015, 7 years after the start of the crisis, the global industrial production was below that of the world 7 years after 1929.</a> We are indeed in the vicious circle of the “<strong><em>slow 1930s</em></strong>” .</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/556/1*dMoUZA8_UF7h_LFdQylmcw.png" /><figcaption>Source: Barry Eichengreen/ Kevin O’Rourke (<a href="http://www.irisheconomy.ie/index.php/2015/11/29/it-has-finally-happened/">http://www.irisheconomy.ie/index.php/2015/11/29/it-has-finally-happened/</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>And as we see these two unlearned lessons unfolding, a third one is rapidly emerging: that of the collapse of collective security and the end of <strong>external military solidarity</strong>. The “<strong>slow 1930s</strong>” indeed. In France, Marine Le Pen wants to take France out of NATO. In Germany, <a href="http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/german-populists-forge-deeper-ties-with-russia-a-1089562.html">far-right populists from AfD are also extremely critical of NATO and would rather forge bonds with Russia</a>. And then, there is Trump. In an unprecedented break from bipartisan traditions heading back to World War II, Trump has rendered publicly conditional what should be the automated triggering of Article 5 of the NATO charter, the one at the very heart of the collective security principle. One of the key motto of his campaign, “<a href="http://edition.cnn.com/2016/04/27/politics/donald-trump-america-first-nationalist-history/">America First”, heads back to the America First Committee led by Charles Lindbergh</a>. Their goal was to refuse fighting Nazi Germany and basically stay out of WWII, continuing the vein of isolationism that led the US Senate to stay out of the League of Nations in 1920 — a first breach in attempt to collective security that lead to the disaster of the 1930s. If Trump becomes President, the second and the third lessons of WWII will be irremediably thrown into the dustbin. And then we will enter very, very dangerous territories.</p><p>***</p><p><strong><em>And now — Trump. Starting with the economy</em></strong></p><p>The first shock of the Trump Presidency will be an economic shock. Markets hate uncertainty. Trump is be definition unpredictable — and if left to his own devices, a political bully capable of making very uneducated guesses. He has criticized sharply Fed governor Yellen for the recent low rate decision. By doing so, <a href="http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/presidential-campaign/296294-trumps-political-dig-on-yellen-more-dictatorial-than">he’s hinting at the end of the Federal Reserve’s political independence</a>, a mainstay of modern central banks set to fight off inflation expectations. He has also proven to be a poor student of macroeconomics. He has called for “renegotiating” on US national debt to “renegotiate it” as if the AAA notation of the US national debt was not one of the pillar of our global financial system and the very foundation of the cost of debt worldwide. At any rate<a href="http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/article/2016/may/16/closer-look-donald-trumps-comments-about-refinanci/">, his comments were extremely confused and were hard to make sense of.</a> <a href="http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2015/09/trumponomics">His tax plan has been deemed a “fantasy” by The Economist</a>. So much unpredictability and amateurism will most certainly <a href="http://ww2.cfo.com/capital-markets/2016/09/will-political-uncertainty-trump-financial-markets/">augment volatility and increase the risks of crash on the markets</a>.<a href="http://www.bbc.com/news/business-35828747"> Some economists already see a Trump Presidency as an economic risk for the development of the western world and global growth</a>. <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/business/21707264-managers-need-watch-political-risk-developed-markets-well-emerging-ones-risky">The Economist stated in September 2016 that as in emerging world country, businesses should now take into account the very political risk in the western world as a new, additional cost of doing business</a>. A confidential memorandum from the German government published by Der Spiegel stresses that <a href="http://uk.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-trump-germany-idUKKCN12138F">Trump’s economic plan is a fantasy, and that the US economy could falter badly under a Trump Presidency</a>. All that could further depress the economic and social fabric of the Western World, reinforce isolationist and protectionist sentiments and feed a pro far-right feedback loop. Consequently, expecting all this and the inner protectionists sentiments of the Trump followers, part of <a href="http://money.usnews.com/investing/articles/2016-03-03/wall-street-is-terrified-of-president-trump">Wall Street may start being terrified by a Trump win</a>. Indeed, an “event study” analysis of variations of the stock market and the Mexican peso at the time of the first debate points <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/02/upshot/debate-night-message-the-markets-are-afraid-of-donald-trump.html">to a 10% average loss in the stock market if Donald Trump wins — a bit worse than 9/11</a>.</p><p>Any economic new shocks or new global recession, probable 7–10 years after the first one, will come on the background of depleted resources to stand such a shock. As mentioned earlier this year by The Economist, central banks have very limited options to use traditional rate levers to offset any macro or financial shock. A China crunch, a possibility now since private debt (again) in China is <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/acd3f2fc-084a-11e6-876d-b823056b209b">nearing unsustainable levels</a>, may also deplete available liquidity. We have very limited resources to cushion new economic shocks.</p><p><strong><em>…and then the diplomatic-military Trump shock</em></strong></p><p>The second shock will be geopolitical. In the context of the ongoing economic duress, made perhaps more dire by new economic shocks, the fabric of nations will continue to tear itself apart. 7 months after a possible Trump election, France will vote. At stake: the very existence of the European Union, one of the cornerstone of post War stability, envisioned as early as 1946 by one of the architect of the postwar World, Sir Winston Churchill. If Far-right’s Marine Le Pen wins, France moves out of Europe. The German-French alliance at its heart collapses on the spot. NATO is fatally weakened. Germany is left to its own devices — and to the rise of AfD, its own right wing authoritarian party. Today Marine le Pen is already assured to be in the run-up of the election, probably against the center-right candidate. If Trump is elected she may receive a formidable support from one of the few guys in the US who actually celebrated Brexit. Trump could invite her to the White House, giving an extraordinary political credibility to the “Front National”. Perhaps some of the NSA assets under Trump could assist Marine Le Pen in the same way that some of Russia’s national cyber assets are today assisting indirectly the Trump candidacy. Leaks at a critical juncture could emerge, damaging the center-right candidate. A manufactured scandal linked with the Muslim population could also help the “Front National”. This already happened in Germany, in January 2016, when Russian media spoke of the rape of 13 year old “Lisa F”, abused by Muslim refugees. Russian Minister of Foreign Affairs Sergei Lavrov claimed there was even a cover up by German Authorities. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2016/01/29/an-alleged-rape-sparked-tensions-between-russia-and-germany-now-police-say-it-was-fabricated/">But the whole affair seems to have been manufactured by Russian medias</a>. Nonetheless, the climate created against Muslim refugees helped far-right populist AfD trump Merkel’s CDU in the latest regional elections. <a href="http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/german-populists-forge-deeper-ties-with-russia-a-1089562.html">AfD Youth Wing is today associated with the youth wing of United Russia</a>, Putin’s party. This is a taste of what Trump’s Europe could become. Or rather Putin’s.</p><p>Then there’s Trump’s personality. As Commander in chief, as stated by many Republicans in national security circles, from <a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/09/14/colin-powell-describes-donald-trump-as-a-national-disgrace-and-r/">Colin Powell</a> to fmr. CIA head and Secretary of Defense <a href="http://www.politico.com/story/2016/09/bob-gates-donald-trump-hillary-clinton-228315">Robert Gates,</a> fmr. Secretary of Homeland Security <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/09/us/politics/national-security-gop-donald-trump.html">Michael Chertoff</a> or former director of CIA &amp; NSA Michael Hayden — he is temperamentally unfit to lead the American military, including its cyber and nuclear components. <a href="http://edition.cnn.com/videos/tv/2016/08/09/general-michael-hayden-on-trump-lead-live.cnn"><strong>Michael Hayden even stated that a Trump Presidency is a “clear and present danger” to the security of the United States</strong></a>. It is easy to understand this. An American President that would react too aggressively, without thinking of the next move, could trigger a chain of events hard to control. Especially if he has a very thin skin. One example? <a href="http://news.nationalpost.com/news/world/trump-threatens-iranian-boats-that-make-improper-gestures-to-u-s-vessels-will-be-shot-out-of-the-water">Trump threatens Iranian vessels to be sunk if Iranian crewmembers make “improper gestures”</a>. If this inviting aggression. Because if Iranian crewmembers do make improper gestures, and Trump reacts as he signals he would, then war may break out with Iran. It will be a silly, unproportioned reason for war, and America may be left alone — not a good way to start an international conflict. But if Iranian crewmembers do make improper gestures, and Trump do not sink vessels — because US officers would tell him that escalation to Iran would lead the US nowhere if started on the spot — then Trump will look like he’s making empty threats. And that will weaken America’s position.</p><p>***</p><p><strong><em>How it could unfold: Cyber Escalation</em></strong></p><p>Cyber is an additional, particular concern. Attribution of cyber-attacks is critical to understand who is behind the attack and target the right assets for reprisals. It is not an easy feat and it may require at times cooperation to quickly put all the pieces of the puzzle together; and convince your allies that you are going to hit back at the right attacker. That makes credibility paramount. That’s one of the core component of “cyberpower”. From the moment Trump becomes Commander in chief, allies of the United States may suspect President Trump is not telling the truth — at all. His domestic track record per truth telling is <a href="http://www.politifact.com/personalities/donald-trump/">already quite damming in terms of personal credibility</a> (<a href="http://www.politifact.com/personalities/donald-trump/">Politifact shows that he’s lying between 8 to 9 times out of 10</a>). Then, in the national security case of the hacks against the DNC and against the voting infrastructure in <a href="https://www.google.co.il/url?sa=t&amp;rct=j&amp;q=&amp;esrc=s&amp;source=web&amp;cd=1&amp;cad=rja&amp;uact=8&amp;ved=0ahUKEwjB3ejPtK3PAhWDLsAKHRePC2oQFggdMAA&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fworld%2Fnational-security%2Ffbi-is-investigating-foreign-hacks-of-state-election-systems%2F2016%2F08%2F29%2F6e758ff4-6e00-11e6-8365-b19e428a975e_story.html&amp;usg=AFQjCNEBeUz8ZoMoaj42lu5_Yakft5qR8w&amp;bvm=bv.133700528,d.d24">Illinois and Arizona</a>, Donald Trump stated that Russia was not behind the attacks. This offered a figment of plausible deniability to the Kremlin with cyber-attacks that many, many different private cybersecurity firms and researchers have attributed to groups belonging to Russia’s national security apparatus. The links between Donald Trump, his aides and Russia may pose grave doubts on the integrity of intelligence exchange between the US and his allies in a Trump Presidency. In Cyber, as in any other intelligence matters, this will mean a reduction and perhaps a collapse in the necessary information exchange among partners. It may even mean (a) an increased cyber in-fighting between partners and (b) de-facto a massive increase in cyber-arms race.</p><p>If there is reduced information cooperation and increase in the cyber-arms race among allies, it’s a sure thing it will increase manifold among existing neutral or antagonist countries to the US. <a href="http://www.wsj.com/articles/cyberwar-ignites-a-new-arms-race-1444611128">This comes on the backdrop of an already disturbing trend in cyberspace</a>. It may be reaching dangerous levels — as recently as September 2016, <a href="http://www.politico.com/story/2016/09/obama-russia-cyber-arms-race-227732">Pres. Obama has warned of a cyber arms-race with Russia</a> after the above mentioned hacks against the DNC &amp; Arizona/Illinois voter registration databases. These come on the heel of many other recent instances of cyber Russian intimidation against Europe. Russia is highly suspected of being behind brash cyber-attacks, sometime of a destructive nature, against <a href="http://www.reuters.com/article/us-germany-russia-cyber-idUSKCN0Y41FC">The German Bundestag</a>, <a href="https://www.wired.com/2016/03/inside-cunning-unprecedented-hack-ukraines-power-grid/">parts of Ukraine electric</a> grid, <a href="http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/russia-blamed-bringing-down-swedish-air-traffic-control-test-electronic-warfare-capabilities-1554895">the Swedish air traffic control system</a>, <a href="http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-10-14/cyberspace-becomes-second-front-in-russia-s-clash-with-nato">the French TV network TV5 Monde, the Warsaw stock exchange in Poland and perhaps even a steel plant owned by ThyssenKrupp AG in Germany</a>. In the Bundestag, Warsaw Stock Exchanges and TV5 Monde cases, the cyber-attacks were claimed by so-called Jihadists or the Cybercaliphate — fictions created by Russian secret services, and roundly denounced in a very public manner by<a href="http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-36284447"> Hans-Georg Maassen, the head of BfV, Germany Domestic Agency</a>. Evidently, as in the “Lisa F” case, the dubious claims of Jihadist/Cybercaliphate attacks can only but help the European far-right movements today allied with Russia. This background of cyber-skirmishes and cyber arms-race within an infowar creates an environment that may be conducive to real life conflicts — a point I’ve made in a now old <a href="http://www.ted.com/talks/guy_philippe_goldstein_how_cyberattacks_threaten_real_world_peace?language=en">TEDx talk</a> (<a href="http://www.inss.org.il/uploadImages/systemFiles/MASA5-2Eng6_Philippe-Goldstein.pdf">and a detailed article with INSS, an Israeli think tank, here</a>). To over-simplify the points made, let’s just recall a line by the great strategist Thomas Schelling in <strong>Arms and Influence</strong>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/830/1*4odDJcNhbTEdK-BMHURuxA.png" /></figure><p>These lines were written in 1966. We now have such weapons that can arrive virtually without warning to do decisive damages: cyber-weapons. And we could have the leaders that may think the suspense is unbearable.</p><p><strong><em>The human factors</em></strong></p><p>We could be indeed facing leaders that could find the suspense unbearable for political or even mental fit reasons — and are ready to take short-term big gambits. The first one is actually Russian Pres. Vladimr Putin. One of the best description of the Crimea invasion in 2014 <a href="https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/ukraine/2016-04-18/why-putin-took-crimea">was written recently by Daniel Treisman in Foreign Affairs</a>. To put it in a nutshell: there was no big game plan. It seems to have been an improvised gambit, operated under the pressure of events — something that even Putin may have hinted at during a reception in Sochi in 2015. The results have been a further economic isolation of Russia, as energy prices started to collapse. And so, today, Russia’s GDP in nominal term is equivalent to that of Spain (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)">according to IMF 2016 estimates figures</a>) — and its <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita">GDP per capita measured in purchasing power parity is equivalent to that of Greece</a>. Perhaps feeling additional political pressure, Putin has started to surround himself with even more loyal operatives. There is talk of recreating the <a href="http://www.vox.com/2016/9/20/12988138/vladimir-putin-kgb-intelligence-agencies-russia">old soviet-era KGB</a> — while Putin has fired three regional governors and has<a href="http://www.businessinsider.com/putin-has-2-major-problems-2016-8?IR=T"> replaced them with former bodyguards</a>. This, in a country where there are <a href="http://www.bbc.com/news/business-33814362">campaigns to bulldoze western food imports </a>— or where the <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/05/opinion/sociology-according-to-putin.html?action=click&amp;pgtype=Homepage&amp;clickSource=story-heading&amp;module=opinion-c-col-right-region&amp;region=opinion-c-col-right-region&amp;WT.nav=opinion-c-col-right-region">last independent polling institute is de facto muzzled</a>, despite the need for the political elite to understand what the people really think. Talk of a stable, rational super-power.</p><p>Or let’s talk of China’s military build-up in the South China Sea, unnerving major nations in Asia, and forcing non-traditional allies of the US such as Vietnam or India to now consider forging strong military alliances with the US.</p><p>Now add President Trump to this already difficult situation. The favorable views of Pres. Trump toward Russia will at first invite Russia to test further NATO allies while cajoling the new resident of the White House. Maybe it will be new cyber-attacks against NATO countries — or even a surprise move against, say, the Baltic states — <a href="http://www.hoover.org/research/defending-indefensible-natos-baltic-states">that may be military indefensible</a>. Putin is capable of such short-term foreign gambits if his internal political situation continues to weaken, as nationalist pride as become the de facto only ideological game in town. But then, if the humiliation feels too much like a sting, Trump may prove unpredictable. He’s already shown his extraordinary ability to do 180 about-face on the basis of very flimsy reasoning. Take Mexico: Trump threatened to build the infamous wall; then made a surprise visit to the President of Mexico where he tried to keep a diplomatic, low-profile — and then, back in the US, he blasted again against Mexican immigration. As a result, Mexican finance minister Luis Videgaray, a close ally of Mexican President Enrique Pena Nieto, and the man who arranged Trump’s visit to Mexico,<a href="http://www.politicususa.com/2016/09/07/trumps-disastrous-visit-mexicos-finance-minister-fired.html"> was finally fired</a> — <a href="http://www.latimes.com/nation/politics/trailguide/la-na-trailguide-updates-trump-points-to-mexico-trip-and-gop-1473295674-htmlstory.html">to the delight of Donald Trump</a> (!). This is unhinged diplomacy. This can only mean but one thing for foes and friends of the United States: irrational, unpredictable reactions at the top of the most powerful country in the world. This means increased nervousness for everybody, not only for the thin-skinned guy at the head of the largest military, cyber and nuclear arsenal of the world. Talk about Schelling’s unbearable suspense.</p><p><strong><em>Finally — the nuclear factor</em></strong></p><p>…And now add to all that the pinnacle of US weaponry: nuclear weapons. The “red button” is not a device that President Trump could press while in a bout of rage. Nonetheless — though <a href="http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/graphics/2016-nuclear-weapon-launch/">the senior officer in the Pentagon war room</a> is the one actually calling nuclear forces, the President has sole authority to use them. The administration could slow down or derail partly the process to the launch — <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/08/05/science/donald-trump-nuclear-codes.html?_r=0">Secretary of Defense James Schlesinger managed to create some stopping blocks during Watergate, when President Nixon was thought to be under tremendous nervous pressure</a>. But even if covert extralegal stopping blocks existed, it would be highly problematic for a President Trump to publicly control nuclear forces.</p><p>First, because Trump would still be de facto conducting “nuclear diplomacy” as the sole user of nuclear forces. To this date, nuclear forces have not been used operationally. This is part of the “nuclear taboo” — what Thomas Schelling valued as one of most critical legacy for mankind since Nagasaki in 1945. However, nuclear forces have been used politically many times, during the many crises of the Cold War and beyond. The very strength of the nuclear threat relies on the strength of the nuclear taboo. In international relations, this threat highlights the ultimate red line — usually the very defense of each country’s most critical interests. But then, Donald Trump has already started to tweak the lines. In interviews in March 2016, Donald Trump ruled out the <a href="http://fortune.com/2016/03/23/trump-nuclear-weapons-isis/">use of nuclear weapons against ISIS </a>—<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_activity_of_ISIL"> a spent military force of about 20,000 men in Syria and Iraq by 2016, hardly a major world army</a>. Back during the Cold War, there were plans to use tactical nuclear weapons against a Russian invasion of West Germany. Those plans were quickly shelved when NATO exercises showed there would be more German civilian casualties when defending Germany with tactical nuclear weapons than during WWII. Then it was revealed that during initial briefings, <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/2016/08/03/trump-asks-why-us-cant-use-nukes-msnbcs-joe-scarborough-reports.html">Candidate Trump asked three times in the course of an hour why not actually use nuclear weapons</a>. He also mentioned that he had to be “unpredictable” with the use of nuclear weapons, or that he was open to nuke parts of Europe because “Europe is big place” (see both <a href="https://thinkprogress.org/9-terrifying-things-donald-trump-has-publicly-said-about-nuclear-weapons-99f6290bc32a#.hjx4at4fb">here</a>). The very fact that all this is known is already disquieting. It surely must be very disquieting for friends and foes of the United States, especially since the United States has a nuclear “first use” policy: it can launch nuclear forces against an enemy even if it has not been attacked by an enemy nuclear forces. In matters of nuclear weapons, the words of the US President are as valuable as the use of the weapons themselves. The words of Candidate Trump are already damaging the nuclear posture of the US and are threatening international stability.</p><p>Second — proliferation. One of the key effort of the Obama administration was to limit nuclear proliferation. At the heart of this effort, is the need to restrict to the maximum the risks of nuclear terrorism. The fewer the countries with plutonium or enriched uranium, the lower the risk a terrorist group will get hold of key ingredients critical to the development of an “improvised nuclear devices”. Also, the fewer the countries with nuclear forces, the lesser the risks an international crisis will turn into full-blown nuclear war — especially if this nuclear war has been triggered by a terrorist’s “improvised nuclear device”. Let it be known that even “regional” nuclear war could have planetary consequences — a “limited” nuclear conflict between Pakistan and India may actually trigger <a href="http://www.ibtimes.com/india-pakistan-nuclear-war-would-kill-2-billion-people-end-civilization-report-1503604">a global famine and lead to hundreds of millions, perhaps billions of casualties</a>. What has been the anti-proliferation message of <a href="http://edition.cnn.com/2016/03/31/politics/trump-view-from-south-korea-japan/">Candidate Trump? In march 2016, he hinted that South Korea and Japan should develop their own nuclear forces</a> — something that both <a href="http://edition.cnn.com/2016/03/31/politics/trump-view-from-south-korea-japan/">South Korea and Japan quickly denounced</a>. He mentioned that he was <a href="https://thinkprogress.org/9-terrifying-things-donald-trump-has-publicly-said-about-nuclear-weapons-99f6290bc32a#.hjx4at4fb">ok with Saudi Arabia getting the bomb</a>. He also seems to have <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/news/archive/2016/07/trump-crimea/493280/">agreed with Russia’s invasion of Crimea in 2014</a>. Beyond the dire weakening and anxiety that such a move would cause to NATO allies if rendered official during a Trump Presidency — it would be also an additional nail in the coffin of nuclear counter-proliferation. Under the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances signed by Russia in 1994, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Security_Assurances">Russia guaranteed Ukraine territorial integrity in exchange of the nuclear forces that were positioned in Ukraine</a>. With Russia’s invasion of Crimea, Russia is in breach of the Budapest Memorandum. It is a signal sent to all the countries in the world: do not believe in international guarantees, do not abandon your nuclear program (as did <a href="http://europe.newsweek.com/nations-gave-nuclear-bombs-78661?rm=eu">South Africa, Brazil, Taiwan, Argentina, the countries targeted by the Budapest Memorandum and — yes — South Korea and Japan</a>) — a point bitterly made today by the government of Ukraine.</p><p>Third — a nuclear exchange is never impossible, especially as a result of internal errors, mistaken signals, ongoing staff’s stress and a background of deep international crisis between nuclear antagonists. In the past, there have been already about <a href="http://futureoflife.org/background/nuclear-close-calls-a-timeline/">two dozen close calls nuclear incidents that may have started accidental nuclear wars</a>. Many happened during heightened times of crisis — especially the 1962 Cuba missile crisis or the 1983 “star wars” tension. Now add the above-mentioned factors — the new cyber weapons, the ongoing tensions with Russia and China and finally Trump’s unhinged declarations and unfit temperament. This is a recipe for much increased risks and for pushing to the limits Schelling’s “unbearable suspense” among all international actors. This gives a starker interpretation to fmr. dir. of CIA &amp; NSA Michael Hayden claim that (I would repeat the line again) — <a href="http://www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2016/08/09/michael_hayden_trump_is_a_clear_and_present_danger_i_fear_for_our_future.html">Trump is a <strong>“clear and present danger”</strong> for America</a>.</p><p>This could not be more clearly stated. For America, for its allies and for the rest of the world. We have not retained the lessons of the initial catastrophe 80 years ago that led to largest massacre of human souls in the history of our species, the Second World War. And as the “<strong><em>slow 1930s</em></strong>” unfold, as we have reneged on <strong>internal solidarity through redistribution</strong>, <strong>international economic solidarity</strong> and could risk now degrading our <strong>external military solidarity</strong>, we are bound to relive these mistakes, but in a world now armed with cyber and nuclear weapons. We are back to where we started: to an increased risk of extinction — to the Darwin Point.</p><p>Faced with all these risks, how could Trump — a man who has never held office; a man who has no particular erudition or focus to ramp up that steep learning curve; a man unable to control his mouth or his temperament — how could he be elected at the top of the largest economy in the world and the most powerful military machine of the planet?</p><p>If our civilization was an IT system, a Trump Presidency may cause us a ‘fatal error’.</p><p>***</p><p><strong><em>…Back to Darwin: the fight ahead</em></strong></p><p>Still, in this “<strong><em>slow 1930s</em></strong>”, the issue goes now beyond just Trump. Trump may lose on Nov. 8 — or despite polls in favor of Candidate Clinton 33 days prior elections, we may have the same electoral surprise as <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/only-you-can-prevent-a-trump-presidency/2016/10/03/033eb90c-8996-11e6-875e-2c1bfe943b66_story.html?utm_term=.4b99464605c9">with the Brexit referendum that will lead to Britain leaving European Union, or with the recent referendum in Colombia to end the 52 years old civil war</a>. But even if both Trump is defeated in November 2016 and Marine Le Pen is defeated in May 2017 in France, both may infect conservative parties. The Republican Party is running the risk to become the “Trump” Party, veering away from pro-trade, conservative views and toward close-borders, authoritarian &amp; populist views. As The Economist predicted earlier in 2016, <a href="http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21702193-insurgent-candidates-who-win-nomination-tend-transform-their-party-even-if-they-never">the GOP may enter a very deep and very dangerous transformation</a>. In Europe, presidential elections in France will be followed by parliamentary elections. Latest polls show that <a href="http://www.linternaute.com/actualite/politique/1274309-legislatives-2017-tout-savoir-sur-la-prochaine-election-des-deputes-date-candidats-sondages-resultat/">the “Front National” may reach for the first time more than 10% of the number of the members of the National Assembly — while the Conservative alliance (LR &amp; UDI parties) could fail to reach 50%</a>. The temptation could arise of a Conservative-Far Right Populists alliance, somehow comparable to what is emerging in Eastern Europe, especially in Hungary. It will mark the de facto end of the European Union and a considerable weakening of NATO.</p><p><strong><em>Darwin and RWA — Right Wing Authoritarianism</em></strong></p><p>The enemy is here to stay. It will have to be confronted. What is his face? From Trump to Brexit or the Front National, it offers different facets for the same flaw: our old homo sapiens selves, masquerading behind the ideological allures of national identity politics. People do not vote for Trump because they are attracted by an ideology, but because they are moved by a raw emotion — anger. They are not interested by true facts, but are looking for a “forceful” champion able to convey their own anger with strength — like a good lawyer who is going to twist the truth for its own good. Trump is neither fascist nor anti-semite as was Adolf Hitler. No brown shirts saluting the Guide are marching toward Washington DC. Trump is rather an authoritarian populist. But as we try to avoid the Godwin law, let’s not neither be blind to some of the few similarities. As Michiko Kakutani from the “Books of the Times” at the New York Times, noted in thin veil while reviewing <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/28/books/hitler-ascent-volker-ullrich.html?_r=0">“Hitler: Ascent” by historian Volker Ullrich, there are a few remarkable parallels</a>.</p><blockquote>“[Hitler was] described by one eminent magazine editor in 1930 as a ‘half-insane rascal,’ a ‘pathetic dunderhead,’ a ‘nowhere fool,’ a ‘big mouth’. […]Hitler was often described as an egomaniac who ‘only loved himself’. […] A former finance minister wrote that Hitler ‘was so thoroughly untruthful that he could no longer recognize the difference between lies and truth’ […] Hitler increasingly presented himself in messianic terms, promising ‘to lead Germany to a new era of national greatness,’ though he was typically vague about his actual plans.[…]”</blockquote><p>Hitler stressed the militaristic dimension of his persona, often wearing uniforms. Trump is supposed to be the consummate businessman. But in military defeated 1930s Germany, in a country that was still run a couple of decades ago by the aristocratic class of the Prussian Junkers, and where the military was idealized since Frederick the Great, the very symbols of power had to be linked with the army. Nazism could only be but militaristic. However, the American narrative is hardly based on that of the army. It is rather founded on the pursuit of entrepreneurial success, ideally in a rags-to-riches story. The embodiment of power, success and grandeur in the US is not the General, but the Businessman. In militaristic Germany, the alpha-male had to be an exaggerated and cartoonesque version of the military man. In modern America, it may be Donald Trump.</p><p>So it’s not surprising that Trump’s behavior mimics dominant <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/trump-chimpanzee-behavior_us_57ddb84fe4b04a1497b4e512">male chimpanzees when impressing fellow apes for dominance, as stated famed anthropologist Jane Goodall</a>. Trump is here to make a show of force. But it also shows that authoritarianism and identity politics are the direct translation into our modern world of old, ingrained ape strategies. With fission-fusion primates like chimpanzees, or perhaps homo sapiens,<a href="http://www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/what-influences-the-size-of-groups-in-58068275"> the lower the opportunities for food, the lower the size of the primate group</a>. So again — when crisis strikes, and resources are depleted, the first instinct for homo sapiens may be to want to reduce the size of the group, and to expel the non-group members, a.k.a. the “foreigners”. Then — at time of dire food or mating scarcity, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3859192/">male mammals usually recourse to intra-specie violence</a>. With our chimpanzees cousins, this sometimes homicidal violence is exerted in particular against chimpanzees from other groups, from other territories — the “foreigners”. Sub-division into coherent small groups, a feature of fission-fusion societies, may actually be related to the in-group (“my kind”)/out-group (“the foreigners”) felt by human beings, and may be <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/human_evolution/2012/10/chimpanzee_wars_can_primate_aggression_teach_us_about_human_aggression.html">conducive to intra-species violence</a>.</p><p>Cue to homo sapiens: <a href="http://www.economist.com/node/16422404">this is called warfare</a>. The “economic” and “mating” causes fueling male aggression, paralleling those of our ape cousins, are troubling. When made redundant, a male has evidently lower resources but also a <a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/jobs/8588749/Unemployment-increases-risk-of-divorce-for-men.html">higher chance of being divorced by his female partner</a>. It is not surprising thus that economic crisis, yielding higher scarcity for economic and mating resources for males, would lead to a higher need for intra-specie violence. Or a need to a more “traditional” role for women — so that, for example, women would not decide to divorce on their own. To sum up, males in anger and in acute sense of vulnerability are longing for a “return” to a male-dominated, aggression-regulated, alpha-male led society. And that’s exactly what is best expressed by the vote for Trump (see below).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HKktjxx-t2tS8nhQXvc5cw.png" /></figure><p>Trump as an expression of RWA should also concentrate the anti-foreigner / “close and reduce the group” vote. It is indeed what the PPRI/The Atlantic Survey shows.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*smHhAdAuoFOGML-J9O8-sg.png" /></figure><p>Overbearing personal debt may<a href="http://www.frbsf.org/community-development/files/choi.pdf"> also bring debtors to a state of emotional stress</a>. The reaction is then “fight or flight” — and most probably fight, a.k.a. anger with testosterone-filled males. Stress is all the more understandable when your home is at risk — and when <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/anna-cuevas/high-price-of-foreclosure_b_1469060.html">home foreclosure is also correlated with divorce</a>. And probably the overall loss of status in our own fission-fusion society. Even the longing for a return to a pure “motherland” may have something to do with our primate past. When they are left alone, male chimpanzees return to the <a href="http://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(07)02283-X">old foraging territories of their mothers</a>.</p><p><strong><em>Darwin + Private Debt Crisis = Rise of RWA</em></strong></p><p>Could it be possible then that some of the key traits of Right-Wing Authoritarianism (RWA) — anger &amp; identity politics, closing of the group around an alpha-male leader, longing for the motherland and recourse to violence — be the traits of our primate past, actually triggered as a reaction to specific crises: When there is sudden shortage of resources, loss of status — and females leave the impoverished males to higher status males? There are again fascinating evolutionary links. In <a href="https://books.google.fr/books?id=V73zBwAAQBAJ&amp;pg=PA174&amp;lpg=PA174&amp;dq=violence+in+dominance+hierarchy+with+food+shortage&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=ZoGrb8JJ7U&amp;sig=gLSS08YlLFiKROAPVXlhEZSpxj4&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=0ahUKEwir55Px5cfPAhUKsxQKHeqJD2MQ6AEIJzAC#v=onepage&amp;q=violence%20in%20dominance%20hierarchy%20with%20food%20shortage&amp;f=false">Neurobiology of Aggression</a> (2003), it is noted that</p><blockquote>[…] In general, aggression intensifies when resources are scarce or limited. Among wedge-capped capuchins, for example, fighting in large groups increases when food is scarce. (p.174)</blockquote><p>But the study also shows that aggression increases when there is more provision of foods by humans in specific locations — such as farms or temples. In general, there is increase in intra-species violence in the context of competition for food (or perhaps any resources) <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3859192/">when the food sources can be monopolized</a>. The further the controllability, the higher the need for violence since the greater cost of violence is compensated by the greater “return” of a (now) controllable resource. To put it in a “human” term: there is higher risk of violence when a resource has propriety rights of access. Violence may erupt not only when one acquires those propriety rights, but also when one defends them.</p><p>For the modern homo sapiens, there is no greater good than his/her home. The owner loses the home when he/she suddenly loses income after an unemployment decision; or when the owner has acquired the propriety with private debt and either (a) cannot repay the loan because of unemployment or (b) has actually realized that the underlying value of the propriety has collapsed and is thus net worth is negative. In both cases, the debtor is bound to the creditor and is suddenly subordinated to him. Anger may now erupt.</p><p>A 2015 study by three German political scientists of elections in the western world from 1870 to 2014 (!) has clearly showed that, on average, face with a “normal” recession, far-right parties may increase by 5–10% over the next 5 years after the start of the recession; but faced with a “financial” recession (for example, triggered by ballooning private debt), far-right parties may increase by 30–35% over the next 5 years after the start of the recession.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/755/1*uXyTtWxOwnn6b-zy7umanw.png" /></figure><p>Private debt crises may also increase income inequalities. There are some hypotheses, still need exploring, that could explain it: (a) The two large private debt crisis (that of 1929 and that of 2008) were formed on the back of reduced redistribution, after a quick fall in the tax rate (resp. after 1920 and after 1980). So the debt crises hit already relatively more unequal societies. Without initial redistributive efforts at onset of the crisis, the human shock has been mechanically harder on the poorest, most vulnerable segments of the population. (b) Private debt often fuel a housing bubble — that was the case both in pre-1929 and in pre-2008. But high value housing assets may have a tendency to return to pre-crisis prices much faster than lower value / subprime assets. So the rich owners are back in the black much quicker than the poor owners. This further increases inequalities (c) The shock of 2008 comes on the edge of two revolutions: that of a service economy, and that of a digital-fueled economy requiring more educational background. Consequently, without redistributive efforts at onset of the crisis, the below college workers have been harder hit than the college educated service employees. There is an additional gender twist to this latest story since there are more females employed as employees than as blue-collar workers. Females have been relatively better sheltered from the crisis than males. This may have further fueled the anger of males.</p><p>Right-Wing Authoritarianism (RWA) is not an ideology. It’s an error. It’s the by-default, old socio-evolutionary response to a time of crisis. It may have worked when we were hunter-gatherers and needed to better coalesce, expel or kill the non-group members, and find new foraging territories and hunting grounds. When we were scattered groups of homo sapiens, the catastrophic effects of violence were by nature limited. Violence could not degenerate into world wars and its human cost did not affect the survival of the species. But the by-default RWA solution does not work today, for a modern, post-industrial economy based on trade, innovation and the need for constant update of human skills. It is unfit to a world secured by cyber and nuclear weapons linked into a global network of alliances and enmities. But still — the RWA-switch is in the back of our mind. So, we have to adapt. We have to evolve. Either we do, or we will make one last “fatal errors” in the very few years to come.</p><p>And then, we will fail at the Darwin point.</p><p>***</p><p><strong><em>Escape from the “Darwin Point”</em></strong></p><p>…but we must not, for it only means but one thing: extinction. There is no choice here. Just the need to engage into a Revolution comparable to that set up in the postwar world. This Revolution will be based on the restatement of the three old, forgotten lessons of the postwar world — <strong>internal solidarity through redistribution</strong>; <strong>international economic solidarity with trades and aid</strong>; reinforcement of our <strong>collective security mechanisms</strong>. These lessons will have to be upgraded for our new digital age. We should rebuild our hardware infrastructure but also continue to build on human capital. There are only about <a href="http://www.computerworld.com/article/2483690/it-careers/india-to-overtake-u-s--on-number-of-developers-by-2017.html">18 million software engineers in the world</a>, about 0.6% of the global workforce. We dont have the talent infrastructure for our digital age. We will also need to address the issue of the cost of housing — including zoning issues, social housing, owning vs. renting, and smart city mobility. These are hard challenges, but they are of the same magnitude than that of the creation of the NHS or the French Sécurité Sociale in postwar Europe. We may also have to do loan write-off. Is there a risk of moral hazard? Evidently. But we know now that we have to face off a survival risk. If our old primate anger takes politically over, there will be no more debtors left to pay — nor creditors there to collect.</p><p>We may dodge a bullet on November 8, 2016 in the US and on May 2017 in France. But we will still have then to confront the very cancer that is engulfing the Western World. We have now very few years ahead of us. But as a specie, we cannot have the luxury to wait for things to really go south and then rebuild. Last time around, it ended up in a world war with two atom bombs. Today, nine countries may possess around <a href="http://www.icanw.org/the-facts/nuclear-arsenals/">15,000 nuclear weapons</a>.</p><p>One month before US Election Day, this is one bottle in the ocean. I’m sure there will be many other bottles. I know that many, many different people in the US, Europe or elsewhere in the world do feel that something is terribly amiss. Many of my friends share to different levels my anxiety. I think they are absolutely correct to think so.</p><p><strong>We dont have another ten years ahead of us</strong>. As an Op-Ed from Canada’s venerable Globe and Mail just states as I was publishing this piece, <a href="http://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/hell-likely-lose---but-trump-is-the-final-warning-to-elites/article32278545/">Trump is the final warning to elites</a>.</p><p>Either we evolve now — or we may go extinct.</p><p>This is the ultimate lesson of “Trump”. Everything is possible now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4be43e130743" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>