<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Hassan Vawda on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Hassan Vawda on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@hassanevawda?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:34:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@hassanevawda/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Incorporating 'change' as data during a Collaborative Museum PhD]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/incorporating-change-as-data-during-a-collaborative-museum-phd-dcd7259b9c38?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dcd7259b9c38</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[museums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[methodology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autoethnography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 10:06:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-24T10:06:29.997Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Researcher Is Not Static: What Changes During a Collaborative Museum PhD?</h3><p>A few months ago, returning <a href="https://www.gold.ac.uk/our-people/profile-hub/stacs/pgr/hassan-vawda/">to my PhD </a>after an extended period away from study, I found myself reopening chapters I had not looked at for some time. I expected the familiar challenges of writing up: revising arguments, tightening analysis, checking references, and recovering the thread of a project that has occupied much of my life over the last five years. What I did not expect was the feeling that I was entering into a conversation with a former version of myself.</p><p>Revisiting my literature review, methodology and reflective notes, especially those authored in the first few years, felt less like editing and more like an encounter with a researcher shaped by different assumptions, experiences, emotions and ambitions. The questions I was asking, the examples I found significant, and even the way I understood my own position within the research all reflected a particular moment in time. Reading those chapters again was a reminder that a doctorate is not only a process of producing knowledge. It is also a process through which the researcher is continually reshaped.</p><p>Perhaps many doctoral researchers experience this. We often talk about a PhD as a journey but rarely pause to consider quite how much changes during that journey. This feels particularly true for those of us studying part-time. A doctorate can stretch across five, six, seven or more years. Years in which careers evolve, institutions change, relationships deepen, families grow, and the wider world shifts around us. The person who begins a PhD and the person who submits it are rarely the same.</p><p>I wanted to share this reflection not only with those beginning a doctorate, but also with those in the middle of one: navigating fieldwork, spending months in archives, working through analysis, returning after interruptions, or staring at draft chapters wondering why they no longer sound quite like the person writing them today. That feeling can be unsettling, but it may not be a sign that something has gone wrong. It may be evidence that something important has happened.</p><p>For many researchers in the <a href="https://www.ahrc-cdp.org/">AHRC’s Collaborative Doctoral Partnership programme</a>, which I have been fortunate to be part of, this experience is perhaps even more pronounced. Our projects are often embedded and partnered within museums, galleries, libraries and archives alongside our university. We spend years engaging not only with collections and records, but also with institutions, professionals, communities, policies and organisational cultures. Some of us start as practitioners. Others arrive as researchers. Many occupy a shifting space somewhere in between. Over time, our relationship to these institutions evolves, just as they evolve themselves.</p><p>The museum, archive or heritage organisation that first inspired our research may look very different several years later. Staff move on. Teams are restructured. Priorities shift. New opportunities and challenges emerge. At the same time, our own understanding develops. We acquire professional experience, encounter new perspectives, and deepen our engagement with the subject. Often, the questions that first motivated the project begin to take on different meanings.</p><p>For those undertaking collaborative doctoral research, this can be particularly pronounced. The institution that helped shape a project proposal at the outset may not be the same institution that exists by the time the thesis is submitted. In my own experience, many of the individuals involved in conceiving and supporting the project in its early stages are no longer within the organisation. Over the course of the doctorate, staff moved on, organisational structures changed, and whole areas of institutional activity were reconfigured through restructuring and wider sector pressures. Looking back, I realise that I have not simply been researching a cultural institution; I have also been witnessing its evolution in real time.</p><p>This creates an interesting challenge for those of us working in partnership with museums, galleries, libraries and archives. We often begin our studies thinking of the institution as a relatively stable context for the research. Yet over the lifespan of a part-time PhD, institutions can transform significantly. Relationships built at the proposal stage may no longer exist. Departments may disappear, merge, or be reimagined. Strategic priorities can shift. By the point of writing up, we may find ourselves reflecting on an organisation that is recognisably connected to the one we started with, but by no means identical.</p><p>It is not only researchers and institutions that change during a long doctoral project. The wider political, social and professional landscapes change too. One of the realities of undertaking a PhD over many years is that the context in which your research sits may look very different by the time you complete it.</p><p>In my own case, when I began researching religion and belief within art museums and the policy landscape of the wider cultural sector in 2019–2020, there were relatively few visible examples of formal policy interventions, strategic frameworks or sector-wide initiatives engaging with these questions. Now, writing up in 2026, I find a slightly different landscape. New conversations have emerged. Organisations have begun developing resources, programmes and interventions that engage more directly with religion, belief and worldviews. Questions that once felt peripheral within the sector have become more visible and more established. The field itself has moved.</p><p>Returning to my writing recently, I realised how many of my own positionalities had shifted since the PhD began. Professional experiences had broadened my understanding of the cultural sector. Personal experiences had reshaped how I think about participation, belonging, care and public culture. The institutional context surrounding the research had evolved. Even my emotional relationship to the topic had changed. Looking back at earlier chapters, I could recognise a researcher writing from a very different moment in their life, with different forms of knowledge and different ways of seeing. Yet that earlier researcher was still me.</p><p>I think there can be a temptation within doctoral research to treat reflexivity as something completed at the beginning. We write a positionality statement, acknowledge our standpoint, and then continue as though that standpoint remains fixed. But positionality is not static. The longer we spend researching museums, archives and heritage organisations, the more our understanding tends to deepen and complicate. We notice things we previously overlooked. We develop greater appreciation for institutional realities whilst often becoming more aware of their limitations. We become more attentive to complexity.</p><p>For researchers working with qualitative, ethnographic or reflexive methodologies, this is not simply a personal observation. It may also have methodological significance. One of the most surprising realisations during writing up has been that the distance between where I began and where I stand now feels meaningful. Not merely as background context to the research, but as something worthy of reflection and interrogation.</p><p>This is where approaches such as autoethnography can be particularly valuable. Autoethnographic methods invite us to take seriously the movement of the researcher through the research process. They remind us that our changing experiences, assumptions and relationships to the field do not simply accompany the research; they shape how we interpret it. In that sense, the researcher is not external to the project but part of its ongoing story.</p><p>For those researching museums and archives, this raises an interesting possibility. The reflective notes, field journals, supervision records and methodological memos that accumulate across a doctorate may be doing more than documenting a research process. They may reveal how our understanding of institutions, collections, heritage, public engagement and even wider social debates evolves over time. In some cases, that evolution may itself become a valuable source of insight. Not because reflection replaces interviews, archival research or analysis, but because it helps us understand the lens through which those materials are being interpreted.</p><p>For those at the beginning of their doctorate, my encouragement is simple: keep those reflections. Record moments of uncertainty, excitement, frustration and discovery. Write about the first time you encounter an unexpected archival record, gain access to a collection, conduct an interview, present your research publicly, or realise that your original questions are beginning to shift. You may later discover that these reflections are doing more work than you realised.</p><p>And for those further along the journey, particularly those returning to projects after significant periods away, perhaps allow yourself a moment to acknowledge what has happened in the meantime. You are not simply finishing a project about a museum, archive, collection or institution. You are also encountering the accumulated versions of yourself that helped produce that research.</p><p>For me, writing up has become less about returning to unfinished work and more about reintroducing myself to the researcher who began it. The conversation is sometimes uncomfortable, sometimes surprising, and occasionally affirming. But it has reminded me of something that feels particularly important for doctoral researchers to hear.</p><p>The researcher is never static.</p><p>Over the lifespan of a doctorate, the researcher changes, the institution changes, the field changes, and the wider world changes too. Sometimes those shifts remain in the background. Sometimes they become visible within the analysis. And sometimes, particularly through reflexive and autoethnographic approaches, they become part of the knowledge the research itself produces.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*okzN61unm9j4eoxg8JoYkQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dcd7259b9c38" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Muddled in a Time‑Capsule of Diversity? The National Trust and Its Trapped Potential]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/muddled-in-a-time-capsule-of-diversity-the-national-trust-and-its-trapped-potential-ee1a2bc59a66?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ee1a2bc59a66</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-heritage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accessibility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diversity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[national-trust]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 May 2026 22:06:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-11T22:06:54.365Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The National Trust is at an inflection point. Publicly, in 2025 it committed itself to one of the most <a href="https://docs.nationaltrust.org.uk/strategy-2025/p/1">ambitious equity agendas in its history</a>: to end unequal access to nature, beauty and history within a generation. Strategically, this marks a significant shift. Access, belonging and representation are no longer positioned as peripheral concerns, but as central to the Trust’s future purpose, central to its business plan.</p><p>In many ways, this is a return to the Trust’s founding impulse. When Octavia Hill, Sir Robert Hunter and Hardwicke Rawnsley established the first iteration of what eventually became the National Trust at the end of the nineteenth century, the project was <em>radical</em>. Staking claim to spaces of beauty that had long been the preserve of the privileged and to place them, <em>inalienably</em>, in trust for the public. The Trust was founded on the principle that access to landscape, heritage and respite should not be determined by class or ownership, but by collective stewardship. It was an early articulation of cultural and environmental equity, long before such language entered public policy.</p><p>The challenge now is that the inequalities the Trust confronts today are deeper, more relational and more intersectional than those its founders could have imagined. Contemporary Britain is marked not only by class stratification, but by the compounded effects of race, migration, religion, disability, geography and environmental injustice. And navigating this all in a time of intense polarisation and brutal public and political rhetoric where the complexity struggles to get through.</p><p>Against this backdrop, the Trust’s commitment to ending unequal access is both necessary and urgent. And yet, ambition and capacity are not the same thing. Across the Trust’s vast organisational landscape, a growing tension is emerging between what the institution wants to <em>be</em> and what its internal structures currently allow it to <em>do</em>.</p><p>I return to the National Trust here having written about it before, as both an object of analysis and encounter. <a href="https://www.roots-routes.org/%D8%AC%D8%A7-%D9%85%D9%90is-wineglass-the-national-trusts-powis-castle-and-the-clive-of-india-collection-by-hassan-vawda/">In earlier autoethnographic work on Powis Castle and the Clive of India collection, I explored how heritage is not simply displayed but <em>felt</em></a>: how historic places choreograph, with intent or circumstance, encounters with nationhood, belief and belonging. The Trust’s sites welcome, unsettle, include and exclude. Their poignancy lies in the fact that they often do all these things at the same time.</p><p>Now, reflecting on the organisational architecture behind that experience, a different question emerges. What happens when an institution as vast and consequential as the National Trust recognises that access is unequal, embeds that recognition into its core strategy, yet continues to operate through inherited structures, conceptual, procedural and attitudinal, that were not designed to address those inequalities? What happens when corporate processes, role design and decision‑making frameworks begin, inadvertently, to blunt the radical equity the Trust was originally founded to pursue?</p><p>It is this disjunction, between founding vision and contemporary delivery, between recognition and reconfiguration, that places the National Trust at its current crossroads.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P9xa2ATgvoCDth3qYiCpLw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Ambition first, Organisational Architecture second?<br> </strong>Few organisations hold assets as powerful as the National Trust’s. Its combined stewardship of landscapes, historic houses, collections and archives gives it unparalleled capacity to shape contemporary understandings of British identity, ecology and care. At a time of deep political polarisation, when questions of belonging, inheritance and environmental responsibility are increasingly contested, those resources matter profoundly.</p><p>But ambition without architecture is fragile.</p><p>The Trust’s access commitments, articulated through its ten‑year strategy and programmes such as <em>Everyone Welcome</em>, are filtered through an organisation composed of hundreds of semi‑autonomous places, regional teams and disciplinary silos. This organisational form, historically effective for conservation and estate‑based stewardship, was not designed to deliver large‑scale social change around access, equity and representation. The result is a growing mismatch between the scale of the Trust’s public commitments and the internal conditions required to meet them.</p><p>Research across public administration and cultural policy has long identified this structural problem. When institutions adopt progressive or redistributive goals without corresponding changes to governance, workforce composition, role design and decision‑making authority, delivery becomes uneven and easily stalled. Policy scholars describe this as an <em>implementation gap</em>, the space between strategic intention and operational reality, where responsibility is devolved, but power, clarity and resource remain centralised or diffuse. This gap is not incidental; it is most pronounced where ambitions involve disrupting entrenched power relations or reducing structural inequality.</p><p>Within the National Trust, this dynamic is particularly acute. Access work, especially where it involves challenging inherited narratives, redistributing authority, or engaging with communities historically marginalised from heritage, often sits <em>alongside</em> rather than <em>within</em> core organisational systems. Governance models, commissioning processes and recruitment frameworks frequently lag behind the radicalism of stated ambition, leaving individual roles or teams to absorb a disproportionate share of institutional expectation without equivalent authority or support.</p><p>Sector evidence reflects this pattern more broadly. Workforce data and research consistently highlight skills gaps, role compression and recruitment pressure across the heritage sector, particularly in posts that combine public engagement, project delivery and strategic leadership responsibility. Such roles are frequently asked to act as sites of organisational transformation without the structural leverage to effect it. The effect is cumulative: access becomes labour‑intensive, high‑risk work, carried by individuals rather than embedded institutionally.</p><p>This challenge is compounded by the Trust’s vast and fragmented organisational landscape. Semi‑autonomous properties, regionally distinct cultures, and long‑established corporate leadership structures have created stable systems for conservation and visitor management. Yet these same systems can become resistant to forms of change that require reflexivity, redistribution, and a re‑working of power. In this context, even well‑resourced access initiatives risk being contained, flattened into delivery functions, rather than allowed to reshape organisational norms.</p><p><strong>Coming Late to the Conversation or Arriving at the Right Moment?<br> </strong>One of the most striking aspects of the National Trust’s current engagement with diversity and access is that, for an organisation of its scale and influence, it has come to this conversation comparatively late. While many cultural and heritage institutions began embedding inclusion strategies in the early 2000s, and had them firmly “oven‑ready” within organisational strategy by the 2010s, the Trust appears only now to be fully waking up to the implications of access, belonging and representation as core questions of institutional purpose.</p><p>This lateness is not merely chronological; it is conceptual. Much of the cultural sector has already lived through a full cycle of diversity‑led policy making: from early commitments to representation and participation, through measurable improvements in programme reach and workforce diversity, to a more recent moment of reflection in which many organisations are acknowledging the limits of those earlier approaches. What once felt progressive, embedding diversity into deliverables, targets and outcomes, has in some cases hardened into what critics describe as a digitised or procedural inclusion: diversity that is visible, reportable, and insufficiently transformative.</p><p>Scholars of multiculturalism and cultural policy have described this phenomenon as a form of institutional afterlife: approaches that persist long after their political and social context has shifted. What was shaped in an earlier moment, often under New Labour’s emphasis on recognition, cohesion and managed plurality, now circulates in near‑<em>zombie</em> form: still animated yet increasingly disconnected from the conditions it seeks to address. Diversity remains affirmed rhetorically, but its capacity to unsettle organisational norms or redistribute power is diminished.</p><p>The risk for the National Trust is clear. In arriving late to the diversity agenda, it may default to these ready‑made frameworks, borrowing approaches that delivered real gains in earlier decades, but are now struggling to respond to a hyper‑diverse, hyper‑polarised Britain in which questions of identity, heritage and belonging are intensely contested. In such a context, inclusion cannot be sustained as a technical problem or delivery challenge alone; it is a cultural and political condition.</p><p>And yet, this lateness also presents an opportunity.</p><p>The Trust’s delay means it is not locked into a single legacy model of diversity practice. It arrives at the table at a moment when the sector is beginning to ask more searching questions about power, participation and institutional reflexivity. Unlike other organisations, the Trust holds vast and diverse assets, physical, symbolic and national, capable of anchoring a more ambitious re‑imagining of access: one that moves beyond representation toward shared authority, beyond participation toward belonging.</p><p>In this sense, the National Trust stands at a choice‑point. It can lean into inherited diversity and access models, useful, tested, but increasingly strained, or it can treat its late arrival as a chance to develop approaches attuned to the most urgent conversations shaping Britain today: about race and environment, faith and heritage, mobility and land, memory and nationhood. Few organisations are better placed to host, mediate and materially ground those debates.</p><p>Whether the Trust emerges as a follower of established inclusion practice, or as a leader in the next phase of opening public cultural and heritage spaces to those not currently present, will depend not on the strength of its commitments alone, but on its willingness to recognise that diversity today demands something more radical than delivery: it demands re‑configuration.</p><p><strong>Where Ambition Meets Its Limits</strong></p><p>If this mismatch between ambition and structure is visible anywhere, it is in London.</p><p>London is one of the most diverse cities in the world. It is also one of the most unequal, and one of the places where access to nature, leisure time, transport and heritage is most unevenly distributed. National access‑to‑nature data consistently shows that Black and Asian communities are significantly less likely to access green and blue spaces regularly, despite standing to benefit disproportionately in terms of wellbeing, physical health and stress reduction. These disparities are not the result of lack of interest. They are the cumulative outcome of structural barriers shaped by planning decisions, travel time, cost, cultural signalling and long histories of exclusion.</p><p>The National Trust recognises this context. Ending unequal access is central to its strategic vision. Yet in London, the Trust remains curiously peripheral to the city’s cultural and heritage ecologies. While there are meaningful local impacts at individual sites in the capital, the organisation is notably absent as a convenor or galvaniser of the extraordinary diversity, talent and global cultural innovation that London holds. Its heritage, art and landscapes have the potential to be lived, felt and re‑imagined through the city- but too rarely are they positioned to cascade into the wider cultural life of the capital.</p><p>As a Londoner, I often experience Trust sites within a short geographic orbit of the city as feeling like distant worlds, disconnected from London’s lived pluralism. Engagement is more frequently framed through outreach than presence; through invitation rather than co‑ownership.</p><p>This represents a significant missed opportunity. Nowhere else do heritage, landscape and urban proximity intersect so sharply. Nowhere else does the National Trust hold greater potential to mediate contested ideas of Britishness, belonging and environmental responsibility at a moment of profound social polarisation. To become genuinely influential within London’s cultural ecology, to be looked to as a pioneering institution in addressing access and mobilising heritage in inclusive ways, would position the Trust to lead nationally.</p><p>If, however, it continues to remain peripheral in the capital, it risks following the residual echo of established EDI approaches within the sector rather than shaping, challenging or innovating beyond them.</p><p><strong>Who the Trust Reaches and Who It Still Doesn’t<br> </strong>The National Trust’s scale is frequently cited as evidence of success. With millions of members and tens of millions of visits annually, it is one of the most influential cultural and environmental organisations in the UK. Yet scale is not the same as representativeness.</p><p>While the Trust has successfully grown younger membership in recent years, it does not routinely publish detailed ethnicity or socio‑economic data for its membership or visitor base. That absence matters. Without granular insight into who converts from visitor to member, and who remains on the margins, commitments to ending unequal access risk remaining aspirational rather than measurable. In a context where national datasets consistently show unequal access to nature and heritage along racial and socio‑economic lines, the lack of disaggregated membership data limits the Trust’s ability to evaluate progress meaningfully.</p><p>Workforce data offers partial insight into this gap. The Trust has acknowledged that its staff and leadership demographics do not yet reflect the communities it seeks to serve, particularly at senior levels. This imbalance is not incidental. Representation shapes how risk is understood, how roles are designed, and whose perspectives inform strategic decisions. It influences whether access is treated as a core organisational concern or as a specialist function delegated elsewhere.</p><p>Access, then, cannot be reduced to opening gates or increasing footfall. It is about who is visible within an organisation, who is trusted to lead, and who feels entitled to occupy its spaces, physically, culturally and symbolically. Until the Trust is able to account more fully for who it reaches, who it does not, and why, the gap between ambition and impact will remain difficult to close.</p><p><strong>Beyond Programmes: Toward Institutional Reflexivity<br> </strong>None of this is to dismiss the seriousness of the National Trust’s intent. There is genuine commitment, substantial investment and thoughtful work underway. But access cannot be resolved through programmes alone, nor sustained through delivery mechanisms that leave underlying systems untouched.</p><p>What is required now is institutional reflexivity: a willingness to examine how decisions are made, how authority is distributed, and whose knowledge is allowed to shape organisational change. Equity cannot remain concentrated within engagement teams or specialist roles while governance, commissioning and leadership norms elsewhere operate as if unchanged.</p><p>Access is not something the National Trust can simply <em>deliver</em>. It is something the organisation must learn how to hold differently, through recruitment that values relational expertise, commissioning that redistributes authority, governance that is porous rather than defensive, and evaluation that measures belonging as well as reach.</p><p><strong>Care, Critique and the Long View<br> </strong>I write this not in opposition to the National Trust. As a member, and as someone whose encounters with Trust places have been shaped by both alienation and solace, I remain convinced of its potential.</p><p>Few institutions are better placed to offer spaces of encounter: between people and nature, between past and present, between inherited narratives and emerging identities. But holding that space requires more than intention. It requires alignment, between strategy and structure, between rhetoric and labour, between who is invited to participate and who is trusted to lead.</p><p>The Trust holds the keys. The question now is whether it is willing to place them in hands beyond the familiar, those not historically present at its thresholds, but essential to shaping its future relevance.</p><p><strong>A Note on Positionality<br> </strong>I write this piece as both a researcher and a post‑pandemic National Trust member. My engagement with the National Trust is shaped by professional experience across large public cultural institutions and grassroots organisations, as well as by lived experience entering heritage spaces as someone from a minority background. The reflections offered here are intended as constructive critique, grounded in care for an institution whose future relevance matters profoundly to the cultural and environmental life of the UK. As a professional in the sector, the National Trust is paradoxically both the organisation I engage with most as a visitor, and the one in which I most acutely experience a sense of being out of place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ASKEojUH2BtUb3Bq3QmWyQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ee1a2bc59a66" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Learnings for today from ‘Religion in Secular Society’ (1966)]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/learnings-for-today-from-religion-in-a-secular-society-1966-4515d72a393c?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4515d72a393c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[secularism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[post-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[britain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[museums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Dec 2025 17:11:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-21T17:19:07.909Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As I come close to completing my PhD looking at religion and belief in modern and contemporary art museums in Britain <a href="https://www.museumsassociation.org/museums-journal/opinion/2024/07/we-need-open-dialogue-about-belief-and-religion/">(click here for more on that)</a>, I have found myself returning to the books and texts that anchored my thinking along the way. Bryan R. Wilson’s <em>Religion in Secular Society</em> (1966) is one such text.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1XcvtEcd29GfK-Ua-jnxBg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Wilson was one of the most influential British sociologists of religion in the post-war period, a key figure in the development of secularisation theory in the UK. Writing from within the intellectual optimism of mid-twentieth-century sociology, he sought to describe what he understood as religion’s structural retreat from public life under conditions of modernity, particularly as he put it within ‘Western societies’. His work helped to normalise an assumption that religion, often used interchangeably with Christianity, in the context of secularisation that Wilson was speaking in, was no longer a central organising force.</p><p>Reading Wilson today is a curious experience. The book feels both anchored to its moment and quietly operative in our own. It is of its time in the confidence with which it assumes religion’s decline to be orderly, progressive and, within Britain, largely settled. Yet it remains strikingly present in how those assumptions continue to organise the common sense of many professional and cultural institutions. The 2021 Census, with its headline significant increase of ‘No Religion’ to 37.2%, might seem to confirm Wilson’s thesis. Yet, the persistence, reconfiguration and politicisation of belief in public life suggests something more complex at work: not the disappearance of religion, but its diffusion, mutation and continued presence in new social, cultural, political and ideological forms.</p><p>Wilson’s argument is not aggressively anti-religious. There is a great care and respect to religion and belief within his work. He distinguishes between belief, practice, and social power, arguing that even where belief persists in modern life, religion loses its capacity to shape collective norms, authority, and public meaning. Religion, in his account, becomes privatised, residual, increasingly marginal to the tangible work of governing society and the communities within it.</p><p>This tension is where Wilson becomes most useful for me — not as a guide to the present, but as a way of understanding the intellectual climate in which many of our institutions were formed and the disposition of many of the intellectual classes who shaped it. His work helps explain why religion is so often treated as something people privately <em>have</em>, but which should not meaningfully structure public life. Why faith is welcomed as heritage, or as community engagement, or as a diversity category, yet remains peripheral to the intellectual core of cultural production.</p><p>In the museum sector, this logic is particularly legible. Religion is rendered safe when it is worshiped for its aesthetics, historical significance or to engage a diverse community. It becomes awkward when it is lived, contested or in control. These dispositions did not emerge accidentally. They were shaped by decades of scholarship that framed secularisation not as one possible account of social change, but as its inevitable trajectory.</p><p>Yet Britain today does not resemble the society Wilson imagined would emerge. Christianity has not simply faded into irrelevance; it has fragmented into a multitude of ways people and communities hold meaning and look to guidence from it — from cultural Christianity to liberal theology, traditional idealisms to charismatic revivalism, and, more recently, increasingly assertive forms of Christian ethnonationalism. At the same time, Islam has come to occupy a disproportionate symbolic role in public and political discourse — frequently treated as the terrain upon the successes or failures of multicultural Britain are fought out.</p><p>Here, the limits of secularisation theory become particularly visible. Islam is routinely discussed not as a lived, internally diverse set of beliefs and practices, but as a problem to be managed, a threat to cohesion, or a test case for national values. This is not the language of religion’s retreat from public life, but of its hypervisibility — filtered through nationalism, race, migration, security and empire.</p><p>Wilson’s framework offers little help in navigating this terrain. If religion is assumed to be receding, institutions do not develop the literacy to engage it when it returns in new forms. If belief is imagined as successfully domesticated into private life, there is little preparation for its reappearance in public — as care and solidarity, but also as exclusion and power.</p><p>For me, <em>Religion in Secular Society</em> remains valuable precisely because of these blind spots. It reveals the intellectual weather in which many of our current institutional anxieties were formed. It helps explain why secularism is often treated as neutral rather than ideological; why belief is framed as risk rather than resource; and why cultural institutions struggle to hold religion as a living, contemporary force rather than a historical residue.</p><p>In my research, I’ve come to see secularisation less as a settled fact than as a governing assumption — one that continues to shape policy, funding and curatorial culture even as the social reality it claims to describe becomes increasingly unstable. Wilson gives us a map of that assumption’s origins.</p><p>And that matters now. At a moment when religion is central to public debates (even if not explicit) — around identity, belonging, migration and power — understanding belief in Britain requires more than reacting to its loudest expressions. It requires tracing the intellectual traditions that taught us to stop listening in the first place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4515d72a393c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Apprehending and Apprehensions of the Sacred: Hamad Butt: Apprehensions at Whitechapel Gallery…]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/apprehending-and-apprehensions-of-the-sacred-hamad-butt-apprehensions-at-whitechapel-gallery-72630f4e27fe?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/72630f4e27fe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[london]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[whitechapelgallery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Oct 2025 08:56:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-26T08:56:32.703Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Apprehending and Apprehensions of the Sacred: Hamad Butt: Apprehensions at Whitechapel Gallery, 2025</h2><p>Originally published by the Foundation for Spirituality in the Arts: https://fsa.art/inspirations/hamad-butt-apprehensions/</p><p>There’s a drip-fed tension amongst the contemplation in the first major survey of Hamad Butt’s (1962 – 1994) work. The trio of installations, Familiars, is what you step into – initially a cold choreography of elements and materials suited to the laboratory. Cold, but clinical in its certainty. Through this work, especially seen alongside his other installations, early works, and experiments, Butt’s practice opens into something more spiritual: not belief as doctrine, but as condition and as chemical – a heightened apprehension of what can be known but not fully seen.</p><p>This isn’t simply metaphor. One of the reasons to visit this show is to feel the typography of belief – of ritual, of inherited sacred forms – that reverberate across Butt’s practice. It’s there in the careful placement of Qur’an stands, in the lexicon of light, in the invocation of djinn and the invocation of alchemy. His installations embody a powerful tension between scientific precision and metaphysical inquiry, between inherited forms and artistic risk. You sense the mizan, the balance. One part tradition, one part criticality, one part sheer speculative daring.</p><p>Orbiting questions about transmission, truth, and how to survive in a world where certain lives, certain ways of knowing, are made invisible. In the 1990 work Transmission, on loan from Tate, Butt stages a meditation on belief and danger in the unseen. Glass books etched with imagery of Triffids – fictional, mutant plants from post- apocalyptic literature – are placed on Qur’anic rehal, raised into a luminous circle. The installation is irradiated by ultraviolet light. Visitors must wear protective lenses to view it. It’s a ritual of risk. Where ideas are either sent from heaven or grown in the test tube. The references – Islamic, Christian, scientific, Queer – accumulate without ever collapsing into a single meaning. Blind faith becomes both metaphor and material: questioning what is passed on, textually, virally, spiritually.</p><p>It matters that this exhibition is at Whitechapel Gallery. Situated in one of the most demographically complex areas of London, the gallery occupies a space shaped by waves of migration, economic inequality, and cultural resilience. According to the most recent census, over 40% of Tower Hamlets residents identify as Muslim – one of the highest proportions in the UK – and the borough has one of the youngest populations in the country. Whitechapel is</p><p>marked by a visible religiosity, with mosques, churches, gurdwaras, synagogues, and street-side shrines occupying the same civic terrain. It is also an area that has undergone rapid gentrification, where long-standing communities navigate the pressures of displacement and cultural erasure.</p><p>In this environment, questions of belief, inheritance, and visibility – so central to Butt’s work —take on an immediate and grounded relevance. His installations do not just speak metaphorically to the unseen, but to the lived experiences of residents negotiating multiple, often competing, frameworks of meaning in their everyday lives. What this show does well is to not over-interpret, not over-mediate. There is an atmosphere of deep attentiveness: to Butt’s aesthetic, yes, but also to his apprehensions. Alongside the key installations, it is the inclusion of early experiments and archival fragments – process drawings, prototypes, letters – that give the exhibition a rare intimacy. They show an artist not only responding to the crises of his time, but actively thinking, shaping, adjusting, trying. These aren’t just background materials – they echo with their own frequency. They reveal Butt as a kind of transistor, receptive to multiple, often invisible, signals; a channel between the bodily and the esoteric, the scientific and the sacred, the seen and the intuited.</p><p>And yet, one is left wondering: does the exhibition fully lean into this potential for resonance with its local surroundings? Can the spiritual and intellectual generosity of Butt’s work be more than just contemplated – could it be activated? In a neighbourhood where living traditions of belief, particularly Islam, remain highly visible, could Butt’s work have opened space for convening dialogue – not just about aesthetics, but about ethics, loss, devotion, vulnerability?</p><p>One imagines what it would mean to programme a conversation not just about Butt, but through him – bringing together those who carry faith and those who carry care, those who live with religion and those who live with HIV. Could the mizan that Butt held – that balance between light and harm, faith and uncertainty – have offered a model for collective meaning- making?</p><p>There is rich possibility here. Whitechapel Gallery could draw from the spiritual and civic infrastructure surrounding it. Could it have collaborated collectively with neighbours such as the East London Mosque and Positive East – to activate Butt’s work not only as historical object but as civic catalyst? A public programme shaped by interfaith dialogue, Queer theology, health activism, and spiritual philosophy could have transformed the exhibition into a platform for pluralistic conversation. Such gatherings might not resolve tensions, but in the spirit of Butt’s art, they could hold them – with care, with risk, with radiance. But leaning into networks of religion and belief, and civic infrastructure, comes with significant resource-heavy endeavours and particular skillsets that perhaps the sector is still working to value – in resource</p><p>and focus.</p><p>Returning to the exhibition itself, it is a real blessing to have Butt’s practice foregrounded and spaciously exhibited as it has been. To apprehend is not just to perceive – it is also to arrest, to stop, and to hold. This exhibition does just that. It arrests time, allowing the afterlife of Butt’s work to continue radiating in its language of chemical belief and scientific spirituality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tYF3ldcX8L0jeWjnTLu_yw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=72630f4e27fe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Playing the Sacred and Profane in INDIKA]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/playing-the-sacred-and-profane-in-indika-ae2df5a75b91?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ae2df5a75b91</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion-and-spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indika]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Oct 2025 09:48:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-03T12:15:37.523Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>INDIKA, </em>the 2024 video game by developer Odd Meter, is one of faith, dissent, and interior fracture. Its central character is a nun journeying through a world where God is absent, ritual is fragile, and the boundary between sacred and profane trembles. Dmitry Svetlov, the game’s writer-director, describes growing up within the Russian Orthodox tradition and later rejecting it — calling the creative act of <em>INDIKA</em> “like taking a shovel to your brain” as one fights inherited faith in a world of fear and hypocrisy.¹</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*veth6s_QYR65gbAwYDPMTA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Playing it in Britain on a traditionally rainy day on my PlayStation 5— it becomes a milieu distinct in its religious history but resonant with religious transformation — <em>INDIKA</em> becomes legible as more than an Orthodox allegory. It probes questions of faith in a secular age: what does it mean to believe when belief no longer commands social legitimacy? How does one maintain spiritual desire when sacred grammar has been unravelled? As a British player, these themes did not feel foreign. They echoed Britain’s own post-secular condition: Christianity diminished in institutional power, yet persistent in moral infrastructure and cultural memory.²</p><p>Mircea Eliade’s <em>The Sacred and the Profane</em> (1957) offers a useful conceptual frame. Eliade frames religion as a universe structured by <strong>ruptures</strong> — moments when the sacred breaks into the mundane, giving orientation, myth, and meaning.³ The profane is the background hum, the everyday. In <em>INDIKA</em>, the convent, the prayers, the icons stand as attempts to carve sacred space. But the game constantly unsettles them: puzzle elements, grotesque figures, mocking voices of doubt. That sacred order is never stable, never wholesale. Instead it fractures, leaks, distorts — and in those fissures we see the profane pressing in.</p><p>This mirrors the condition of faith in many contexts today: the sacred has lost dominance but refuses disappearance. Religion is reconfigured, haunted, contested.</p><p>The classical secularisation thesis forecasted the erosion of religion as modernity advanced — in Britain, the decline of church attendance and the repositioning of the Church of England from moral authority to cultural institution.⁴ Yet, as <em>INDIKA</em> suggests, the story is more complex. Religion does not vanish; it transforms.</p><p>José Casanova argued that religion re-enters public spaces in new forms.⁵ Habermas, meanwhile, describes our era as “post-secular,” where secular and religious discourses must learn translation and mutual respect.⁶ In this light, <em>INDIKA</em> captures a world not beyond God, but after God’s easy signification. Faith now resides in paradox, in absence, in yearning.</p><p>Christianity in Britain is less an institutional centre, more a subtle presence: in architecture, in the moral language of welfare, in moments of communal ritual. It is quiet but not extinguished. The game’s instability — its ruptures of sacred space — feel like the contemporary condition of disbelief and devotion entangled.</p><p>The <em>Guardian</em> interview with Svetlov deepens the interpretive frame. He openly frames <em>INDIKA</em> as critique of the institutional Orthodox Church — pointing to clergy as propagandists and to religious obeisance as enmeshed in political power.¹ But the game doesn’t simplify the critique. It does not demonise faith itself. Instead it dramatizes the psychic cost of a faith under strain. Svetlov’s own journey — from participation to rejection — echoes in Indika’s internal struggle.</p><p>The choice to build puzzles that break the protagonist’s world as her mind fractures is a design logic: the world is unsteady because belief is unsteady. The game’s aesthetic — chilling, baroque, uncanny — insists that the sacred and profane cannot simply be bracketed.</p><p>Why does this matter? Because video games are becoming one of the most vital expressive media of our time. In their interactivity, their player-as-agent logic, they can enact existential tension rather than merely describe it. A novel or film might narrate doubt; a game makes you live it. And with the increasingly opening of independent developers to be able to generate auteur works that wide audiences can consume — the journeys of induvidual and collective faith may be increasingly explored.</p><p>In <em>INDIKA</em>, you inhabit the tension: you traverse corridors of prayer, memory, sin. You toggle between realms, puzzle through chaotic architecture, converse with doubt incarnate. The game does not preach doctrine. It demands reflection. It invites wonder and unmooring.</p><p>In that sense, <em>INDIKA</em> is not theology. It is theology’s critical echo — a spiritual experiment in art. It rehearses how we live in relation to what surpasses us, what haunts us, what we refuse and yet cannot leave behind.</p><p><em>INDIKA</em> is not a celebration of religious certainty, but a meditation on religious rupture. It assists us in seeing that the sacred, though deprived of dominance, still lingers — faint, unstable, potent.</p><p>For Britain, for myself as a player here, it became a mirror to ask: how do we live in a space where Christianity has lost centralized authority but remains inscribed in our ethics, our memory, our institutions? What remains of the sacred when the profane is ever present?</p><p>Eliade once noted that a “wholly profane world” would be a recent and rare achievement of the human spirit.³ <em>INDIKA</em> suggests that achieving it might be harder than we imagine — and perhaps unappealing. Because behind the cracks of rationality, the yearning for transcendence still lingers.</p><ol><li>Keith Stuart, “Russian Orthodox church meets fairytale: the making of Indika,” <em>The Guardian</em>, 2 May 2024. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/games/2024/may/02/indika-russian-orthodox-church-fairytale-game-dmitry-svetlov-interview?utm_source=chatgpt.com">Link</a>.</li><li>Grace Davie, <em>Religion in Britain: A Persistent Paradox</em> (London: Routledge, 2015).</li><li>Mircea Eliade, <em>The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion</em> (New York: Harcourt, 1957).</li><li>Callum G. Brown, <em>The Death of Christian Britain: Understanding Secularisation 1800–2000</em> (London: Routledge, 2001).</li><li>José Casanova, <em>Public Religions in the Modern World</em> (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994).</li><li>Jürgen Habermas, “Notes on Post-Secular Society,” <em>New Perspectives Quarterly</em>, 25(4), 2008, pp. 17–29.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ae2df5a75b91" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Great British Publication: ‘Islam and the Muslim Prayer’, 1914]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/a-great-british-publication-islam-and-the-muslim-prayer-1914-335db1189cd8?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/335db1189cd8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[united-kingdom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[british-muslims]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[britain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Jan 2025 22:28:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-09T22:40:27.744Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In a library within a Buddhist monastery in rural England, I came across this brightly coloured copy of ‘Islam and the Muslim Prayer’ by Khawja Kamal-ud-Din. A scholar and missionary in the Ahmadiyya tradition, whose role in reviving the Shah Jahan mosque and founding the Woking Muslim Mission in 1913 marks a significant contribution to the early institutionalisation of Islam in Britain. The publication ‘Islam and the Muslim Prayer’, first printed in 1914 was one of the earliest efforts to explain and guide the act of Muslim prayer to a native British audience. Its pages are filled with striking photographs of British converts, reverently demonstrating the stages and postures of Islamic prayer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LizirJQxPO-fLdKdckesoQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Flicking through the book, I think of the ever-reoccurring conversations and regularly flaring up narratives about Islam being incompatible with British values or being this unruly presence in the coded and intangible ‘Judeo-Christian culture’ we live in. Something that has always shadowed my formative years as a British-born Muslim under the ‘War-on-terror’ discourse cloud of world order. But does this book give me a sense of the rootedness of Islam in Britain? Over 100 years old, full of well-dressed quintessentially ‘British’ aristocrats, academics and politicians hoping to teach Islamic prayer to British audiences.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eew_jD3P33XsECPtOYat0w.jpeg" /></figure><p>The early 20th century in Britain was still in a windfall of rapid industrialisation, modernisation and global expansion that not just altered the governance and economic aspects of the country but rapidly adjusted it social fabric, while the creeping twilight of the British Empire brought a sense of introspection. Christian traditions and beliefs that once dominated British life were rapidly shifting.</p><p>Amidst this period of transformation, there emerged individuals — often from elite or well-travelled backgrounds — who fell within a sympathetic disposition to the orientalist idea of the European West as the pinnacle of modernity, with the East portrayed as trapped in an uncivilised, unruly, and traditional past. Yet, these individuals inverted this negative framing, seeing in the East — and particularly in Islam — a positive embodiment of values they felt were eroding in Britain. To them, the East represented a haven of traditionalism, spiritual reflection, and connection to God that starkly contrasted with the perceived disenchantment of modern, industrialised Britain.</p><p>This orientalist fascination often stemmed from a longing for something deeper and more authentic than the relentless materialism and rapid societal shifts of their own culture. In Islam, some found a form of spiritual continuity and rootedness that resonated with their disillusionment — a compelling counter-narrative to their own world’s disarray. A repository of tradition, faith, and connection to the divine, qualities they believed were fading from Western life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nfxRCanhCqwYP7DsThyWfA.jpeg" /></figure><p>So when I see Lord Headley looking back at me from the pages of this book, sitting in this monastery library 110 years later, demonstrating how one holds their hands in their daily prayer to Allah, will he be looking back at me as a corrupted Brit or corrupted Muslim?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5eAcIyKbs39H_RnfBppfXQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4x7O0u5DP_5Ui9VIJRH8yA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=335db1189cd8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Post-Secular Elegy: Reflecting on Theaster Gates’ ‘Afro-Mingei’ (Mori Art Museum, Tokyo…]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/a-post-secular-elegy-reflecting-on-theaster-gates-afro-mingei-mori-art-museum-tokyo-538fe564e36c?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/538fe564e36c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mingei]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tokyo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theaster-gates]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mori-art-museum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contemporary-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Dec 2024 20:27:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-20T20:27:16.842Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Post-Secular Elegy: Reflecting on Theaster Gates’ ‘Afro-Mingei’ (Mori Art Museum, Tokyo, April-September 2024)</h3><p>Ascending into the skies of Roppongi, the 54th floor of the Mori Art Museum became the latest site consecrated in Theaster Gates’ ever-expanding practice of giving aesthetic, cultural, and political language to spirituality and sacredness through his vision as an artist. His work intersects with movements, communities, and cultures that resonate with his soul. In <em>Afro-Mingei</em>, Gates’ visual, material, and textual language feels momentous in its hyphenation. As I stepped into the show’s first section, titled <em>SHRINE</em>, the post-secular was fully present, even if not consciously articulated in Gates’ practice or within the curators’, Tokuyama Hirokazu and Kataoka Mami, framing. The post-secular is not explicitly referenced in the text within or accompanying the show, yet for me, it was the concept through which I entered and exited the exhibition with.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DmxqjBCpPIqUFNE96j2HwQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Afro-Mingei</em> is an elegy in the notes of hyphenation or ‘hybridity’, not merely as a post-colonial lingua franca<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>, but as a totem of contemporary art and spiritual tradition. <em>Afro-Mingei</em> places the art museum in full relief as a temple hosting the divinities and philosophies of diverse, remixed sacredness — an art museum as a temple of the post-secular. It is where the outcomes of modernity do not signal religion’s retreat, but rather where reconfigurations and differences in belief multiply — especially within the <em>hyphen</em>.</p><p>The exhibition’s hyphenation also bridges the personal and the global. Definitions of <em>Mingei</em> — as an early 20th-century codified movement of craft and belief — intersect with the historiographies of cultural, spiritual, and collective resistance in the African American Civil Rights Movement. This bridge is connected through Gates’ perspective as an artist and crafter — holding the constellations of what has propelled much of his practice into a journey of digesting <em>Mingei</em>. He embraces it with a solidarity of sweet resistance while seeking ways to mitigate the bitterness of its interconnectedness with Imperial Japan and its colonial legacies.</p><p>The resistance within Gates’ view of <em>Mingei</em> lies in the power of cultural identity blessed within everyday objects crafted by nameless artisans, where the object and the craft that created it become a vanguard against national and industrial cultural erasure. Speaking of the renowned codifiers of <em>Mingei</em> — Kawai Kanjiro, Hamada Shoji, and perhaps most notably, Yanagi Soetsu — Gates speaks of their importance in using “craft to establish a political and social stance; they created magazines, journals, working groups, study groups, and tea gatherings”<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> to make the intangible tangible. This codification of everyday craft and culture into a philosophy through communal exchange and knowledge production resonates with a sweetness of solidarity found in cultural activations like <em>Black is Beautiful</em> and other acts of creation within African American cultural histories.</p><p>In the first section, <em>SHRINE</em>, Gates conjures an explicitly altar-like atmosphere. Organ drones from his installation <em>A Heavenly Chord </em>(2022) reverberate, mapping out the space, between objects of art, craft, and devotion. Marked by a refusal to explicitly label anything as religious, the objects are instead left open to the atmosphere of devotion — a weaving together of Christian traditions, Shinto practices, and Buddhist meditations, without collapsing them into a single narrative. This refusal to simplify the spiritual complexity of his work is where the post-secular reading is resonant. Gates invites the viewer into a space that is neither fully religious nor entirely secular, but something in between — where spirituality is fluid, dynamic, and constantly being redefined by differences of beliefs engaging more. But what is mediating the difference?</p><p>The most prominent philosopher of <em>Mingei</em>, Yanagi Soetsu, was himself a scholar of religion. For Yanagi, <em>Mingei</em> was an extension of a path towards divinity, and as curator Hirokazu puts it, <em>Mingei</em> represented the pure essence of Buddha<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>. It is a recognition of craft without ego, of an object without a named creator — a celebration of the creation, whose existence in the world renders the creator divine. Gates embraces this sentiment, presenting works of exemplary craft, but takes a step towards disorienting the purity of <em>Mingei</em> by placing two works signed by their creators. A scroll by the poet, potter and Bhuddist nun, Otagaki Rengetsu (1868–1912) and a stoneware vessel by the formerly enslaved potter from Edgefield, South Carolina, David Drake (c.1801–1874). From one perspective, this could be seen as a desecration of <em>Mingei</em>’s purity philosophy of <em>art without heroes</em>, but from another, it is the consecration of <em>Afro-Mingei</em>.</p><p>Moving beyond <em>SHRINE</em>, the exhibition’s second chapter, <em>BLACKNESS</em>, delves into cultural production as both a spiritual and political act. Gates’ emphasis on framing the cultural productions of Blackness as craft, particularly those born out of resistance to oppression, adds another layer to the exhibition’s post-secular echoes. In works that reference the labour of African American artisans and the ceramic traditions of where Gate’s locates the birth of his ceramic practice, Tokoname in Japan’s Aichi Prefecture, he elevates craft as a form of sacred labour. The spiritual weight of this work is not tied to any one belief but emerges from the act of creation itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JtarbhWUXGV-UKScGpMf_w.jpeg" /></figure><p>In Gates’ hands, the act of making becomes a devotional practice. His ceramics, tar paintings, and architectural interventions all evoke the spiritual power of manual labour. This is particularly poignant when considering the historical context of Black craftsmanship in America, which has often been marginalised or erased. Gates reclaims this history, imbuing it with a spiritual significance that transcends the secular realm of artmaking. The result is a body of work that speaks to the endurance of Black cultural and spiritual traditions in the face of systemic oppression.</p><p>A central feature of this phase of <em>Afro-Mingei</em> is the <em>Black Library</em>, a space filled with thousands of books on Black history, art, and culture. The library functions as both a physical archive and a metaphorical temple — a space where knowledge itself is sacralised. The books lining the shelves are not merely objects of study; they are texts imbued with the weight of cultural memory and spiritual significance. Gates positions the library as a space for communal reflection, a place where the past and future of Black thought can be contemplated and reimagined. This is further drawn upon by Gates’ own interjection into this philosophy, with a chamber in the library specifically reflecting on the various socially engaged projects he has undertaken throughout his career. Perhaps this is Gate’s visioning himself as Yangai, as a codifier through knowledge exchange and spiritual quest in defining the craft of Blackness in America.</p><p>In the final chapter of the show, prefaced by an overlapped timeline depicting the histography of Mingei, of key moments of the <em>Black History in America, </em>Theaster Gate’s biographical points of reference, key moments in the history of Tokonome, Aichi and finally a biographical timeline of speculative fiction, <em>The Yamaguchi Institute</em>. The latter is an iterative project building a narrative around a character called Yamaguchi Shoji, a potter who migrates from Japan to Mississippi and marries an African American woman. A vision of a life that prescribes an experience to the hyphen between <em>Mingei</em> and <em>Blackness</em>, of the global narratives and the personal experience of the artist. A precursor to the final room, where in all its worshipful spirit, AFRO-MINGEI is presented as a living experience. A Shinto-Pentecostal celebration of the real-life labour, craft and legacy of Tokoname potter, Koide Yoshihiro (1941–2022).</p><p>What is then the post-secular reading? European and North American philosophers Peter Berger, Jürgen Habermas, and Charles Taylor have been central in defining post-secularism in its conventional frame. Berger originally was a preacher of the ‘secularisation thesis’<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a> of the 1960’s, suggesting that modernity would lead to the decline of religion, but later revised his views, acknowledging that religious belief persists robustly even in modern contexts<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a>. Habermas extended this, arguing that modernity necessitates a dialogue between secular and religious worldviews<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a>, while Charles Taylor’s concept of the ‘immanent frame’ presents modernity as a space where belief and unbelief coexist, allowing for a plurality of spiritual perspectives<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a>. Post-secularism, then, reflects not the eradication of belief, but rather the emergence of a diverse field of beliefs coexisting within modernity — a condition where no single belief system dominates outright, but differences are constantly mediated.</p><p>Yet, just as <em>Mingei,</em> this mediation is not without its critiques. Post-secularism often assumes a dominant belief system that frames the conversation and within readings of modernity as Western colonial hegemony, it is often seen as pluralism and diversity of belief having to be mediated through dominant forms of Christianity and/or secularism. The expectation that all differences of belief must negotiate with a primary worldview framework quiet the liberatory potential of spiritual diversity.</p><p>Within <em>Afro-Mingei</em>, Gates does not allow any single belief system — whether Christian, Buddhist, or Shinto — to dominate. Instead, he embraces the difference of beliefs, using the materiality of craft and the process of creation as a liberatory mode of mediating these spiritual differences. Through art, craft, and the hybridity of his practice, Gates perhaps enacts a kind of post-secularism that resists being mediated through dominant cultures. He finds in the physical act of making an alternative, where diverse spiritual traditions can coexist in modes of liberation and resistance. Not under the shadow of a singular dominant belief, but through the shared act of creation, honouring both the spiritual and the material in equal measure.</p><p>It is in this context, that I bared witness to <em>Afro-Mingei</em> as post-secular elegy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*njKVL0s40Dkgty0hDJYcqg.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Homi K. Bhabha’s ideas of <em>hybridity</em> and the <em>Third Space</em> explore how cultural identities are fluid, formed through interaction between cultures. Hybridity disrupts colonial power by creating new, mixed identities, while the <em>Third Space</em> is where these identities emerge and transform cultural meaning. <em>The Location of Culture</em>, Homi K. Bhabha, 1994</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Extract from ‘Theaster Gates in Conversation with Kataoka Mami’, <em>Afro-Mingei, </em>2024</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> ‘The Trajectory of the Potter Theastre Gates, Tokuyama Hirokazu, <em>Afro-Mingei, </em>2024</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> <em>The Sacred Canopy: Elements of A Sociological Theory of Religion</em>, Peter Berger, 1969</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> ‘Further Thoughts on Religion and Modernity’, <em>Society</em>, 49(4), pp. 313–316, Peter Berger, 2012</p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a><em>An Awareness of What is Missing: Faith and Reason in a Post-Secular Age</em>, Jürgen Habermas, 2010</p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> <em>A Secular Age</em>, Charles Taylor, 2007</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=538fe564e36c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[جا مِ is wineglass: the National Trust’s Powis Castle
and the Clive of India Collection]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/%D8%AC%D8%A7-%D9%85%D9%90-is-wineglass-the-national-trusts-powis-castle-and-the-clive-of-india-collection-89d4098df319?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89d4098df319</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[british-india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[museums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[national-trust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Apr 2024 17:07:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-17T17:07:14.945Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(first published in roots&amp;routes journal Year XII, n°39, May — August 2022<br>‘RETURN, HEAL, REDISTRIBUTE’, curated by Domenico Sergi, Nur Sobers-Khan, Anna Chiara Cimoli and Giulia Grechi — <a href="https://www.roots-routes.org/%D8%AC%D8%A7-%D9%85%D9%90is-wineglass-the-national-trusts-powis-castle-and-the-clive-of-india-collection-by-hassan-vawda/">https://www.roots-routes.org/%D8%AC%D8%A7-%D9%85%D9%90is-wineglass-the-national-trusts-powis-castle-and-the-clive-of-india-collection-by-hassan-vawda/</a>)</p><p>The unethical histories that created collections or the institutions they sit within has been a prime discursive space within the administrators, curators and researchers that care for those collections. Often finding light in the odd curated exhibition, public programme but mostly taking place in closed research. Conference after conference of those speaking <em>museumese</em> are interspersed with a keynote on decolonising the collections, on restitution, on authority of knowledge. There is a lot of energy in the discussion but how is this manifesting in practice in museum functions? From discussions about reinterpreting an object to removing the object altogether. From talking about community voices shaping the interpretation of collections to letting in effect communities hold, touch, and claim some sort of mediated ownership of the objects and materials. Does this hyperactivity of discussions and research have any impact on the day-to-day experience of museum visits? This paper reflects on one research activity I was part of in the form of an autoethnography of a study day looking in the ‘Clive Collection’, in the care of the National Trust, to rethink how the collection can engage with its histories going forward. A study organised as part of a wider research project coordinated between Tate, National Trust and UAL. Yet, although this very paper emerged from this institutionally-sponsored research, it found itself in a purgatory of institutional (in)visibility. The experience of being part of this study day raised a tension on the purpose of research in relation to this work — and what impact do these types of initiatives have on the actual day-to-day functionality of these spaces.</p><p>I submitted this paper initially to the National Trust — with a request to publish. The representative of the National Trust that I was liaising with, along with the wider research project team that was delivering this research, highlighted that the National Trust wouldn’t publish my writing for public consumption but was willing to share the paper as an internal only document. I then asked Tate if it was possible to publish the paper with them. The associated research team working on the project highlighted that the article was too critical of the National Trust, which would make it difficult for Tate to publish it. So, the paper found itself in a no man’s land.</p><p>August 14th2021, was the formal acknowledgment of یوم آزادی‎,the day celebrating the 74th year since Pakistan’s independence. The following day is the official acknowledgment of India’s independence from British rule, also in its 74th year. A weekend that marked an independence from centuries of resource syphoning rule by a British private company com state enterprise. The weekend is a mark of independence, but also a mark of the final symbolic legacy of total administrative control — the drawing lines and motions of partition. The carving of a map led by the <em>Viscount </em>Radcliffe, who despite never stepping foot in India, drew new national borders which caused the largest migration in history — with the consequences visible across countless lives, generations, and untold traumas.</p><p>That very weekend I also found myself driving to ‘Powis Castle and Garden’ with my mum and my sister. A National Trust site in Wales, which is acutely framed as an attraction that ‘reflects the changing ambitions of the Herbert family, who occupied the Castle from the 1570s’ (2021). Yet, there is peculiarity to this castle that prompted to travel to it. That is, Lady Henrietta Herbert who wedded Edward Clive in 1784, the son of <em>Major-General</em> Robert Clive. The <em>great</em> ‘Clive of India’ as his statue, that still stands tall outside the foreign office today, symbolises. A statue that was erected 140 years after his death, and championed by <em>Lord</em> Curzon in a zeal to recognise or, rather re-interpret, Britain’s control of India as statecraft rather than the exploitative and extractive capitalist enterprise that it was. A significant attitude shift to memorialise ‘Clive of India’ as a public servant to his royal highness, considering that he still rests in an unmarked grave. The public opinion even in his own lifetime was more serpent than servant, labelling him as a ruthless a-moral brute whose flaunting of wealth was derided. Yet, this man, who walked into a Mughal treasury and returned as one of the wealthiest men in Europe, is to this day memorialised as a statue of dignity and civility in the heart of Britain’s capital. With all the PR-driven culture war politics being churned, and the current Conservative fan(fiction) of history and hollow claims of museums being ‘bullied by the woke nihilistic left’ (Dowden, 2021). What is the actual story that wants to be told about the ‘Clive of India’ statue in their ‘retain and explain?’</p><p>Beyond the monument that sits amongst the institutions of Governance in London — the public memorialisation that also bears his name in Britain, is the hidden (but not really) ‘Clive Collection’ that sits in a couple of rooms in Powis Castle. This is not really hidden because it is part of a National Trust property, whose very principle was to create access to the history and beauty once locked into the fiefdom of aristocracy. This is still hidden however, because nobody I have spoken to in my immediate networks knows it exists. Even museum people, interested in unerathing histories of Britain’s rule in India, ignore its existence. I didn’t even know it existed until 2020, when I sat in a virtual conference organised by Paul Mellon British Art Centre on Arts and Empire in India. Me and a colleague, also of South Asian heritage, also studying museum practice around wider perspectives, were surprised to hear that there is a public ‘Clive Collection’ display that has been open to the public since 1987 . The presentation, I recall, was framed around the research being done since 2018 on the ‘Clive Collection’, with the aim to re-think how such a space could be presented to the public and bring new perspectives on the objects and artefacts in the collection. From meaning and understanding to how the object entered the collection — loot or purchase. The strongest memory of listening to this presentation was the unsurprised nihilism that I felt in my heart when it was emphasised that the majority of ‘objects’ in the collection had received little attention of provenance, and even with research — most objects are ultimately categorised as ‘unknown’ in relation to their acquisition. I remember speaking to a colleague after the session about the purpose of this research? Who was thisfor and what was this hoping to achieve?</p><p>This 2018 research kickstarted by the 70th anniversary of India’s independence, is part of the recent awakening within the National Trust to the wider heightened investigations, pressures and internal reorientations of thinking around which stories are included and excluded in museums. And most importantly, whose voices are present in the production of knowledge in these spaces and what type of cultural histories do the audience have access to? A notable turn is symbolised by the an interim report released in September 2020 about research being carried out on the links between colonialism and slavery in National Trust properties. A report which drew the irk of the voices of worry from static eyed visions of Britain’s history that the National Trust has gone ‘woke’ and even drew complaints and an investigation from the Charity Commission (Adams, 2021). The response, to a report that is hardly <em>radical</em>, and when I read it, simply provides facts that are expected in relation to how it feels to think of representation in these spaces. It speaks volumes to the status of the National Trust regarding which parts of the public feel most ownership with it. The dominant culture that feels best served by the National Trust as an institution. The culture that the trust in the National Trust supposedly needs to be restored too.</p><p>It is in this context that I was driving to Powis Castle — following an invitation to engage with the collection as a researcher. A researcher, who draws deeply upon my personal and emotional self in relation to navigating public spaces of cultural value, worth and historical storytelling in Britain. These emotional responses are vital (and perhaps more important) of the historical narratives that are often framed as facts — considering how little is often included and how much it is excluded. The invitation was a strand coming out of a cross-collaboration between the University of the Arts London’s Decolonising Arts Institute, Tate Galleries, Imperial War Museums and the National Trust. The project is titled <a href="https://www.tate.org.uk/about-us/projects/provisional-semantics"><em>Provisional Semantics</em></a>. In this specific output, researchers within the field of art history, heritage and museum studies were convened for a proposed ‘close reading of the display and interpretation of a book of poetry by Hafiz, currently on display at the Clive Museum, Powis Castle’. For me, this reading resides in how I experienced the space, physically. By taking a trip to see the object and drawing on what can be defined as an autoethnography of sorts, this paper represents my ‘close reading’ of the object, reflecting on the observations, experiences and emotional impacts that are present in the space .</p><p>I am unsure if it is a coincidence or a planned conscious intervention, that it just so happened that the visit fell in the weekend that also marked Pakistan and India’s independence. I also invited my mother and my sister to join me. The invitation of my mother, who I see as a source of safety and strength, particularly in relation to the unfamiliarity I find myself in when working within museums. My mother, who seldom visits any museum or art historical space, unless when accompanied by me. Often, commenting on how attending these spaces with me makes her feel welcome, when in fact her presence makes it more welcoming for me. I feel familiar in these spaces yet simultaneously broken-hearted by them. To visit a National Trust site which houses a space called the ‘Clive Collection’ made me anxious. With my experiences of working within the field, I had a presumption of an uncritical space, in which my presence would feel like a hyper-minority — where publics would visit for a day of leisure, having tea and scones with a flavour of passive nostalgia for the Empire. I asked my mother if she would like to join me to give that sense of comfort that she brings, offsetting any authorities of dominant culture in these spaces. She had never heard of Powis Castle and Gardens and did not know there was even such a display called the ‘Clive Collection’ in Britain. I told her it held items lauded as treasures and trophies collected by ‘Clive of India’, as well as items collected by his son (who also served as Governor of Madras) and his wife, Lady Henrietta, whose castle was her family’s estate.</p><p>As we left London on the morning of the 14th August, my mum shared the latest song being played on the Pakistani radio stations and channels marking independence. I wondered whether there will be any acknowledgment of the independence at Powis Castle and Gardens, or even in the ‘Clive Collection’. Perhaps a specially curated public programme taking place across the weekend?Verbalising it, both my mum and sister laughed at me — and yes, I did think such expectation was futile — but then again it had been three years since the research on re-energising the collection began. Maybe my expectations on the fate of research in cultural institutions are too high. Of course, turning up on the day, there was not a single reference to independence — there was no public programme, there was not even a peep on the social media channels of Powis Castle and Gardens. This made me think of Emily Pringle’s (2019) interrogation on the place of research in art museums, or museums and collections in general — with competing discourses that govern the space. The role of research itself is both ever present in museum spaces, and also can be at times disconnected and scattered across the organisation. Being split through the different corridors of the museum, for instance, the research on collections or learning, often most challenging and critical, is detached from discourses on audience development or financial stability. This is how I make sense of the reason why the research at Powis Castle is taking place. For many, attending Powis Castle and Garden over this weekend, having their scones and tea with a side of peacock flaunting, their knowledge of Britain’s role in India can be reduced to complete passivity locked in a timeline far from the now. Detached from their daily life. Without a second thought of the impact it has had on their life. The ‘it’s in the past’ choir.</p><p>As we crossed into Wales, my mum recalls a memory triggered by our laments on the consequences of the British Empire. Me and my sister reflect on our schooling in London and the lack of reference points on the reality of the British Empire. My mum grew up in a working-class neighbourhood in Karachi, Pakistan. She recalls that whilst independence was of course celebrated, thinking to herself as a child, there was a passiveness in discussing Britain’s rule. The true extent of the impact was not a critical presence but an everyday one. She recalls a moment when she applied for a job as a teaching assistant in a well-regarded school in Karachi, aged 18. She was rejected after the interview for not having the right proficiency in English. She recalls this memory with the emphasis on the legacy of Britain’s everyday presence that forever lingers. As a young person who had never been to England, being rejected for a school assistant role in Karachi, for not being versed enough in English. It’s a tangible reality of one of the entrenched echoes that postcolonial nations found themselves in the grip of. The language of English and the ‘power’ and ‘politics’ that are coded into the presence and access the language still holds within the country (Kachru, 1986). More specific to Pakistan, Firasat Jabeen (2019) calls the presence of the English language the ‘perpetuation of colonial legacy’. Not its presence as a language as it cannot be detached from being a global language, but its presence in structuring society. In how it manifests and is used as a tool for status, class, economic and acutely educational access. A domain of elite Pakistani society represented in an educational system that gifts those who have access to English. There is a sadness in my heart that I am not proficient in Urdu. The heart of Mustafa from Tayib Saleh’s 1960’s novel ‘Migration to the North’ — the broken heart of the colonial/post-colonial subject who masters the cannons of knowledge production and language of ‘the West’. I have a degree in English Literature. I have an acute experience of working in art museums and cultural institutions, spaces in which I feel a hyper minority within. I research these spaces often as someone who felt and still feels excluded, and my research touches on why experiences like mine, and communities I feel associated with are <em>invisible</em> from these spaces. The native, the insider and the outsider. But I think about Abu-Lughod’s (1991) point of the <em>halfie</em> — the researcher in the field of Western academia, who are from and researching communities who were historically the researched, historically ‘othered’, that they are more recognisable as ‘researchers’ within those communities than ‘Americans who study Americans’. Or in this case, those with the attributes and affiliations of the dominant culture that has been canonised as the cultural memory in British art institutions, and overpopulated in the literal presence of its audiences, staff, and knowledge producers. I wonder why I was invited to this study day to inform the framing of the ‘Clive Collection’ and not someone with the experiences and insight of my mum?</p><p>The study day on the Hafiz poems displayed in the ‘Clive Collection’ was framed as a ‘a collective close reading of the object itself, its display and its past and current interpretation’. The <em>reading</em> in this context is stretched beyond the pages of the book. I assumed this was a museological reading in the first place — rather than a collective reflection on the poetry of Hafiz. I do so because I have no linguistic expertise on Persian manuscripts, nor an expertise of the work of Hafiz. When I think of Hafiz as a poet, as a historical figure, he lives in my consciousness through his timeless referential space in the collective imaginary of (translated) Urdu poetry of the 20th century. Particularly, in the biographical and poetic works that have elevated the great Iqbal to hold the timeless status he has in South Asian consciousness, and particularly Pakistani Muslim consciousness. I have read of how Iqbal had held Hafiz as a portal to a transcendent space in his formative years studying in London, and how his verses allowed him to traverse time and space as narrated by Atiya Begum Fyzee-Rahamin (1947). A transcendence I feel from Iqbal, when listening in Urdu or reading (with English translation) his verse. Liberating transcendence. Priya Satia (2020) in her reflection on the construct of history and time in relation to European colonial realities, administration and memory emphasises the power of the poetic to ‘enable a truer reckoning with the legacies of empire’ (2020:272). Emphasising the role of liberation dialectics of poetic-philosophers, like Iqbal, in the independence of India and formation of India/Pakistan, Satia speaks to poetry as a way of reclaiming the very ‘truth telling’ that has been held in the discipline on history. To buckle the locked narrative of history that frames the developed and underdeveloped civilization universal narratives- the ultimate moral justification of colonial control and power. This collection of Hafiz poetry, that sits caged in a collection of other looted objects in a venue which is presented largely as a passive <em>nice day out</em> for National Trust members, gained a heighted symbolic status on the anniversary of Pakistan’s independence.</p><p>We entered the grounds, driving through the long road of the estate into a large, overcrowded car park sat just below the castle. Walking into the castle courtyard, I feel an ashamed privilege that I always feel in my stomach when walking into public cultural and heritage organisations. A quite extraordinary reality of what was once a space of restricted elitism, is now functioning as a mediated public space. Yet, just like all cultural and heritage public institutions, the radical optimism that is embedded in these spaces of public education, is also locked into that dominant culture that formed it and reproduces around it. Consistently, arts and cultural spaces have a disparity in their visitor base, particularly in class and race, even in the recent decades of diversity confidence. Data specifically on the National Trust’s demographic base is not easily available in the open space of public reporting, yet, looking to one of the few sources I have come across, a 2008 survey on its membership base, it highlighted that 99% was white (National Trust, 2009). A statistic that was felt to be present across the National Trust, including staff and volunteers, as reflected on by Naomi Harflett (2014) in their ethnographic doctoral thesis on volunteer profiles in the National Trust. The research highlighted an extraordinary disparity, even in relation to the wider sector’s general consistency of lack of participation and inclusion in the category of ethnicity. The National Trust’s current vision till 2025 is titled ‘For everyone, for ever’ — with a strong commitment to diversity that recognizes ‘we have a long way to go, but we’re determined to be for everyone, for ever’ (2021). Part of this vision is an expanding research-led interrogating of the legacies of colonialism and slavery in many of its properties.And my being in this space as a visitor and researcher is a slipstream of this vision. Yet, standing in the courtyard of the castle, I didn’t feel any welcoming enthusiasm, an enthusiasm ‘for everyone’. I stood there with my family and looked at this packed visitor attraction, across the various tables and chairs with tea and scones being blissfully consumed with peacocks striding across the garden. I stood in this courtyard feeling a hyper minority, like we were the only racialised experience in that space, the 1% of its 99% membership. Like I thought I would feel. My mum wondered as to how many people there today even knew the symbolic nature of the date — there was no reference to independence, just a pasteurised sense of passive Empire nostalgia.</p><p>I spoke to a very welcoming front of house volunteer to register my attendance for the appointment to see this book of Hafiz poetry. I asked if today felt like a <em>normal</em> Saturday, looking at the visitor numbers, and they confirmed yes — it feels like a <em>normal</em> Saturday afternoon in the summer period as if it were pre-covid. We were guided to the former servant quarters of the castle by the deputy collections manager, where a space was prepared to hold and inspect the object that had brought me here, the book of Hafiz poems. This was the first time in my mum’s life she had been in the back of house of a museum, let alone holding a museum object: the book, a small pocket-sized volume. I had no reference point to the physicality of the book as, surprisingly, there is not a single photographic listing of it and no listing whatsoever of a Hafiz book of poetry in the National Trust digital database. I asked the staff member present about the missing presence of the book in the digital database, and they informed me that it was only recently that the very listing of the object has been corrected. At times in its history, it had been acknowledged as ‘Tipu’s prayer book’. The prayer book of the defeated Muslim sultan who stands as a symbol of conquering might equals right, or a valiant spirit of anti-European resistance. Whose defeat and death fell inthe same period when Edward Clive became Governor of Madras, 1798–99. Opening the book, touching its pages I felt an overwhelming sense of consequence — of objects and peoples dispersed across Britain, and taking roots within its national and linguistic boundaries meandering without plan to where it is now. A space that has navigated the presence of difference firmly rooted in its ‘motherland’ as an unplanned consequence of its history. We open the first page, the colours and format familiar to me, echoing Quran and other holy books of Arabic script I learnt to read in madrassas in Northeast London. My mum looks at the Persian script, and through her tongue of Urdu can pick up the odd line, the odd word — fragments. The first word she points to is جامِ, <em>jaam </em>— and says it symbolises the wineglass. جامِ is wineglass. We turn from page to page, with the fragments of Persian via Urdu via English coming to me. My mum opened the book just past the halfway mark and there, to the surprise of the staff member, within the pages was a delicate, hand cut paper bookmark. It turns out this bookmark had not been catalogued before. I’d like to think that in her brief interaction with a museum object my mum has instantly contributed to its documentation. The staff member present, who themselves knew the collection and premises having been there for over a decade, said the bookmark was likely Lady Henrietta’s — who was versed in Persian and was known for her papercuts. Was this bookmark where she had read up to or perhaps her favourite of the poems?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*pGtc_PXykD1c2E6p" /></figure><p>In the biography of Lady Henrietta through her letters titled ‘Birds of a Passage’, Nancy K. Shields (2009) emphasises the immersion Lady Henrietta found herself when moving to India when her husband took the post of Governor of Madras. It tells of her travels, particularly to Mysore and engagements directly with the relics and remnants of Tipu’s kingdom. She took residence in Tipu’s now abandoned Bangalore palace, and was arranged for Tipu’s مُنشی to be her personal tutor in Persian. Shields goes on to narrate that she was even encouraged by her new tutor to take the poetry of Hafiz as a translation exercise — a poet whom she became more and more intimately affiliated with. Ultimately contributing a series of scattered translations of verses.</p><p>‘The mystery of love, hid behind the veil; search<br>For it amidst the intoxicated drinkers of Wine<br>For such things belong not to religious men of eminent degree.’<br>– Hafiz, translated from Persian by Lady Henrietta Clive</p><p>I think to myself of what it means for Lady Henriatta Clive to have a linguistic and intimate connection to Hafiz as a poet — in contrast to the reality of her being at the centre of a violent syphoning and pillaging of a peoples and culture through Britain’s presence and administration of India. Whilst at the same time, the poetry of Hafiz being timeless staples that inspired the liberation verse of independence poets.</p><p>We put the book down and move through the back of house corridors into the <em>ballroom</em>, where the ‘Clive Collection’ is housed — starting with the empty space where the book I was just holding is usually placed. Sat behind glass, crammed amongst other objects, and displayed as a closed book. There is no interpretation, information, or insight into what is in the book or any details of the books context in the collection. The book is also displayed back to front<em>, </em>an overlook given that Persian is read right to left. I stepped back and looked at the whole room. It is a museum of a museum. The collection has largely remained unchanged from its 1980’s installation, in which it is cased in kitsch orientalist we learnt from a volunteer host. The welcoming staff member who had facilitated access to the book, said how the space is in desperate need for revitalization — for access, for context and for wider audiences. There is a lack of coherence in the displays, with objects seemingly put together for no other reason than an aesthetic choice. The lighting is so dim, you can’t even see the colours and gems on many of the objects on display. I was told that there have even been collection materials that have had to be taken off display as the conditions in the display room are not to standard. I look to this dimly lit space with such sadness, a prison, a tomb of euthanised historical context, a graveyard that no flower of poetics can grow in. It makes me feel that just holding the book of Hafiz, with my mum, outside this context was a liberatory moment. Maybe we should have not put it back in its box, which feels like a coffin. Even the sacred materials are present but reduced to ornaments — with the most striking image I have been left with, that of a portrait of Clive set above a shelf of Hindu Gods and Goddesses. Sickening.</p><p>I noticed a set of interpretation panels just outside the room. These are newly installed, a material consequence of the hope held by researchers to reframe the collection. It profiles the characters involved, Clive, his son and Henrietta. It references Clive as someone to some was an ‘imperial hero’ and to others a ‘greedy bully’. It introduces the ‘Clive Collection’ as ‘one of the most important collections of South Asian artefacts in Europe’. I overheard a comment from a visitor who didn’t look out of place walking around saying ‘this Clive doesn’t sound like a pleasant man’. Is this a positive effect? Is this really what this collection could be doing to visitors, on the anniversary weekend of Pakistan independence? My mum and my sister both feel the same as I do, we desperately want to leave this place. Outside, I ask my mum and my sister if they want anything from the café or the shop, my mum replies, ‘I don’t want to give a penny more of OURS to this place’. As I looked over the courtyard, still seeing all the tables and chairs full, with scones, tea and peacocks roaming — it made me think of the Harflett (2014) who observed that the National Trust is conflicted between its presumed financial base and that of its vision to address its diversity at all levels. It’s a perfectly working model for a <em>normal</em> summertime Saturday. An enshrined dominant culture — it’s the crux I have observed and experienced across many public cultural institutions, particularly those that have a remit to explicitly be custodians of British art history and heritage. Their functional day to day resting on an unconscious gratification of the dominant culture. Diversity must find pockets around this — in research, in curatorial, in meetings and trainings — but not in the daily functional bread and butter. What would the National Trust identify as the reason(s) for Powis Castle and Gardens to not do anything to acknowledge independence — considering it bills itself as hosting one of the ‘most important’ collections of South Asia in Europe?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*rrLf8x3A3xHSQhtf" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*HOWz77b__5j9tzoo" /></figure><p>Reflecting on this trip, I wondered how impactful this study day on a Hafiz book really was? Perhaps the time, energy and expertise may have been better used to curate, programme, and resource a programme of Powis Castle and Gardens for the 2022 anniversaries of Pakistani and Indian independence. 2022 marks the 75th anniversary of independence, of partition, will there be an acknowledgement of that at Powis Castle? The study day came and went. Its discussions amongst those invited will be drawn into data contributing to the <em>Provision Semantics</em> research project. There will be papers, reports, and maybe even agenda items to discuss findings at some institutional meetings — but then what? If I visit the castle in 2022 on 14th August, will I have a different experience?</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p><strong>Abu-Lughod L</strong>., <em>Writing Against Culture</em>, in Fox, R. G. (ed.) <em>Recapturing Anthropology: Working in the Present</em>. Santa Fe: School of American Research Press, 1991, pp. 137–162.<br><strong>Adams G. K., </strong><em>National Trust slavery report did not breach charity law — Museums Association</em>, <em>Museums Association,</em> 2021, Available <a href="https://www.museumsassociation.org/museums-journal/news/2021/03/national-trust-slavery-report-did-not-breach-charity-law/">HERE</a> (Accessed: 7 September 2021).<br><strong>Clive H., &amp; Shields Nancy K., </strong><em>Birds of Passage: Henrietta Clive’s Travels in South India 1798–1801,</em> edited by Nancy K. Shields. London: Eland, 2009.<br><strong>Dowden O., </strong><em>History Matters Conference | Policy Exchange</em>, in «Policy Exchange» 2021. Available <a href="https://policyexchange.org.uk/history-matters-conference/">HERE</a> (Accessed: 7 September 2021).<br><strong><em>Dowden O., </em></strong><em>For Everyone, For Ever: Our Strategy to 2025, </em>in «National Trust» 2021, Available <a href="https://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/features/for-everyone-for-ever-our-strategy-to-2025">HERE</a> (Accessed: 7 September 2021).<br><strong>Fyzee Rahamin A. B.,</strong> <em>Iqbal</em>. Bombay: Bombay Academy of Islam, 1947.<br><strong>Harflett N.,</strong><em> For Ever, For Everyone?: Patterns of Volunteering: The Case of the National Trust</em>, University of Southampton, Faculty of Social and Human Sciences, PhD Thesis, 2014.<br><strong>Jabeen F.,</strong><em> The Perpetuation of Colonial Legacy: Uncovering Internal Orientalism in the Form of English Supremacy in Pakistan,</em> in «Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development», 41(5), 2019, pp. 432–443.<br><strong>Kachru Braj B.,</strong><em> The Power and Politics of English</em>, World Englishes 5 (2/3), 1986, pp. 121–140.<br><strong>National Trust</strong>, Membership Survey 2008, Swindon, National Trust, 2009.<br><strong><em>Powis Castle and Garden | National Trust</em></strong> (2021). Available <a href="https://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/powis-castle-and-garden">HERE</a> (Accessed: 7 September 2021).<br><strong>Pringle E., </strong><em>Rethinking Research in the Art Museum</em>, <em>Rethinking Research in the Art Museum</em>. Routledge, 2019.<br><strong>Ṣāliḥ, al-Ṭayyib.</strong><em> Season of Migration to the North</em>. Portsmouth, NH, Heinemann, 1976.<br><strong>Satia P.,</strong> <em>Time’s Monster</em>. Harvard University Press, 2020.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89d4098df319" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A.Sivanandan’s 1971 Reading List for Teachers on Race and Immigration in Britain.]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/a-sivanandans-1971-reading-list-for-teachers-to-race-and-immigration-in-britain-9b8e9212a4ff?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9b8e9212a4ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[multiculturalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[british-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diversity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Aug 2023 09:48:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-06T10:02:11.690Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SyG6vjglvwGcbnF7dBfG5A.jpeg" /></figure><p>I recently picked up to read ‘The Multi-Racial School’, a 1971 volume of essays and reflections published by Penguin. Edited by Julia McNeal and Margaret Rodgers, it presents texts by schoolteachers, academics and policymakers, presenting observations, case studies and suggested best practices on how British schools can better adapt to a ‘multi-racial’ society.</p><p>In the opening text by Dipak Nandy, it lays out the school is one of the many institutional and policy areas that need to play catch up as a result of the unplanned increase in ethnic diversity, the ‘absence of mind’ of ‘acquiring a coloured population’ through the ’50s and ’60s but with no considered plan in supporting what this means beyond a speculative ‘generous liberalism’.</p><p>I enjoyed reading the volume, always important to give a reminder of the steady, deep policy work that has historically happened. Draw the chains of learning around this deep work to connect them to policy and practice today that looks to address the same structural inequalities. So often things feel fragmented and the new report, the new initiative or the new commission attempting to deal with structural inequalities always feel like they are starting fresh rather than building on from what has happened.</p><p>In relation to this book, I also enjoyed the vivid picture of schooling for immigrant children from post-colonial families across England, particularly the case studies of schooling in London. My dad came to England aged 7 and it gave a strong picture of the education system he would have had to navigate, experience and understand — and the experiences of teachers who were adapting and including or resisting and attempting to assimilate experiences like his.</p><p>The book concludes with a speculative reading list for teachers to open their perspectives to better understand the experiences of the children of immigrants that were now in their classrooms….much of which is incredibly still relevant, and significant and would enhance anyone’s understanding of race in Britain today:</p><p>The Lords of Human Kind: European Attitudes in the Imperial Age, 1969, V.G. Kiernan</p><p>Black Skin, White Masks, 1952, Frantz Fanon</p><p>Death at an Early Age, 1968, Jonathan Kozol</p><p>The Me Nobody Knows: Children’s Voices from the Ghetto, 1969, ed. Stephen M. Joseph</p><p>The Autobiography of Malcolm X, 1965, ed. Alex Haley</p><p>Race in the Inner City: A report from Handsworth, Birmingham, 1970, John Augustine, Runnymede Trust</p><p>Journey to an Illusion: The West Indian in Britain, 1966, Donald Hinds</p><p>Jamaican Migrant, 1965, Wallace Collin</p><p>Any selection of novels by Samuel Selvon and Andrew Salkey</p><p>Vicious Circle, 1968, Wilfred Wood and John Downing</p><p>Violence in the Toilets: The Experiences of a Black Teacher in Brent Schools, 1969, Marina Maxwell in Race Today</p><p>Land of Five Rivers: Stories from the Punjab, 1965, Kushwant Singh</p><p>Selected Stories from Gujarat, 1961, Sarla Jagmohan</p><p>Tales from Indian Classics, 1965, Orion Ghosh</p><p>East comes West: A Background to some Asian Faiths, 1970, Peggy Holroyde et al.</p><p>Racial Discrimination in England, 1968, W.W. Daniel</p><p>Immigration and Race in British Politics, 1965, Paul Foot</p><p>Colour and Citizenship: A Report of British Race Relations, 1969, E.J.B Rose et al</p><p>Colour, Citizenship and British Society, 1970, Nicholas Deakin et al.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3P-NLlJemBJdkyG9Aa0NhA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9b8e9212a4ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Assalamualaikum Documenta Fifteen]]></title>
            <link>https://hassanevawda.medium.com/assalamualaikum-documenta-fifteen-4755243098f6?source=rss-58872ee7bb2f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4755243098f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contemporary-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[documenta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[germany]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hassan Vawda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Sep 2022 11:35:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-10T12:22:47.625Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Visiting <a href="https://documenta-fifteen.de/en/">Documenta Fifteen</a> was the best Documenta we have been to. It also felt like the most inclusive environment we have ever experienced in an established, large scale European contemporary art institution. Opening the guide, the first words are, ‘Assalamualaikum reader’. Walaikumusalaam Documenta Fifteen.</p><p>It is no joke. What Ruangrupa has attempted to achieve in their radical re-orientation of Documenta is resounding. It is a success in every sense of its bravery and boldness in attempting to overlay and re-organise the purpose and power that is held within the Eurocentric elite art infrastructures. Exemplified here by Documenta as an institution and the <a href="https://hassanevawda.medium.com/westernese-curatese-942ff965d3ef">westernese curatese</a> hegemonic community in its orbit. It is crucial to start any conversation on Documenta Fifteen with this reminder. Its overshadowing critiques and accusations dominating the headlines of that very nexus. The initial superficial glance that generated flat headlines seldom went beyond defining Documenta Fifteen as ‘controversial’. It is re-orientating, reconsidering and experimenting with the boundaries of using the infrastructure to see how far an echo of anti-colonial solidarity and communal, global joy of the marginalised can be platformed, achieved and shared with equity. In its critique, it is now in a power of narrative control, with increasingly numerous essays and articles, bringing nuance to the world it opens and to the hostilities it has received. Equally, a bombastic, populist consensus narrative is rife, sucking the nuance and change of meaningful exchange. This is just the strong side of a circle of angles that has aimed to delegitimize Documenta Fifteen from the start. Documenta Fifteen is left out of the shade by the dominant culture who find themselves bewildered in a space they would expect to flourish in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ezVxNXSKDgjGr36wiRhR_A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Harvest by ‘Gudskul’, Documenta 15</figcaption></figure><p>‘It’s actually a good thing, the real problem is the over-professionalism of the arts — curators to artists’. The participating artist and writer Hamja Ahsan said in response to a comment from one of the (relatively few) institutional chieftains present during the opening weekend of Documenta Fifteen. He was responding to a comment that there has been a discursive impression in certain circles that there is an ‘amateurish’ feel to it. This framing of ‘amateur’ doesn’t reflect the reality but is more the bewilderment of the art world nexus with Documenta Fifteen — the struggle to find the safety of that reference point that their precious Venice or Art Basel gives them. Be it in the tools of interpretation, the clarity of its relation to the art market or the reality that the minorities are always the minorities. The intimidating ‘amateur’ to their safe ‘professional’. The collective to their ego-ripened artists. The warmth of community to their champagne driven art markets. The enchanted to their disenchanted. The Non-Aligned to their NATO. The anti-colonial to their colonial. The Assalamualaikum to their VIP welcome. The anti-oppressive global solidarity to their multicultural global hegemony.</p><p>Ruangrupa themselves define the institutional ecosystem of these large-scale art world holy spaces and biennale circuits as ‘exploitative’ and ‘extractive’. They also reflect on the reality of attempting to flip the binary of the values in these spaces, with and within the infrastructure of an institution that works for the artworld taste buds. The last line of Ruangrupa’s opening reflection of their process in the programme states, ‘negotiation becomes the name of the game’. Ruangrupa have articulated their curatorial vision in the concept of <em>lumbung</em> — a collective rice harvest for when times are tough. In the context they draw it into — the harvest at Documenta are snippets of methodology, practice, artwork and conversation by the artists, collectives, and community movements, selected through networks and values in an iterative and evolving discursive process. The production budgets, each selected artist or collective, could be used within their own localities or within Documenta itself. The results are a programme full of successes, failures and experiments but all are in the same procession of thought processes to re-centre the world on the side of justice. A justice kept on the outer circle of the West dictated multicultural hegemony.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SpLsqlXC24oQCXocRObQpg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Aboriginal Tent Embassy, Richard Bell, Documenta 15</figcaption></figure><p>It is this sense of justice which has exposed the limits of institutional mechanisms of the euro-infused contemporary art infrastructure, the limits in giving legitimacy to this justice. Contemporary art institutions exist to give legitimacy to the artists asking questions, challenging, and establishing values and pushing ideas and concepts. The entire infrastructure of Documenta is to give legitimacy to the curatorial visions and artist expressions they hold. The infrastructure just about held to give legitimacy to the dominant culture detractors who viewed this Documenta with a bewilderment in its detachment to the art market, its centering of experiences of the global south and its aesthetic of a lumbung. But the limits were tested, and the immediate fissures started emerging after <a href="https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/documenta-15-vandalism-artists-respond-hito-steyerl-1234630786/">the venue hosting ‘A Question of Funding’ was broken into, vandalised and death threats sprayed on to the wall</a>. A collective whose harvest was speculating ‘alternative economic structures that can resist the physical and geographical boundaries and restrictions in Palestine and, hopefully, beyond it’. There was no institutional weight to respond to this, to respond to the duty of care the organisation has to the artists and artistic team.</p><p>The opening weekend of Documenta was a privilege to be part of. Joyful even if intoxicated by the hedonism of extrovert post-secularity. Parties, gatherings and picnics sprouting all over the city to the tunes of anti-champagne art market classes. During this weekend, speaking to a regular Documenta attendee — they proclaimed that the lack of the ‘art basel’ crowd will impact the next Documenta. The curatorial lead would be a close heartbeat to the comfort of that crowd. Richard Bell spoke of bracing for the ‘white revenge’ that exists around every corner of radical liberation activity and theologies. We guess opening Documenta with Assalamualaykum results in the vitriol and institutional lava that has consumed Documenta Fifteen since its opening weekend. From the <a href="https://documenta-fifteen.de/en/news/statement-by-taring-padi-on-dismantling-peoples-justice/">removal of Taring Padi’s mural</a> ‘The Peoples Justice’ to the ‘organisational reviews’ of artworks <a href="https://www.e-flux.com/notes/481665/censorship-must-be-refused-letter-from-lumbung-community">without the support of the artists or artistic team</a>. A review to decide what is legitimate and what is not dictated by a lens of pressure that falls to the populist right harmonising with a liberal professionalism within the arts whose values are consciously or unconsciously grounded in a post-Christian secular civilising mission. Which is why opening Documenta with Assalamulaykum is profoundly radical and that is why the echo of that greeting in the programme has struggled to be supported by the infrastructure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eExg4wD2MrArikKtejQL6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>section of ‘The Peoples Justice’, Taring Padi, Documenta 15</figcaption></figure><p>Whilst Taring Padi’s artwork that was exploring the power structures, violence and elusive empathy in relation to the 1965–66 Indonesian genocide and the following legacy of Suharto’s military dictatorship was literally removed, in a programme full of collectives, the targeting never became personal. Artist Hamja Ahsan was the first artist to be personally targeted, with racist and Islamaphobic trolling amplified by populist right political figures in Germany. Hamja, whose harvest at Documenta overlays <a href="https://www.middleeasteye.net/discover/british-muslim-hamja-ahsan-artist-fried-chicken-shop">a world of fictionalised Halal Chicken shop signage across Kassel</a>. Comments calling Hamja a ‘terrorist’ or needing to be ‘forcibly replaced’ became common place, with Hamja reacting and responding with vitriol and heartbreak to the trolls and attacks. He has since been banned from any public programming from Documenta due to calling the Chancellor of Germany a ‘fascist pig’ in a pithy statement on his personal Facebook in response to the constant trolling. A strange choice to ban artists at Documenta on but it was a response to a call to arms by odious amounts of trolls on twitter on this specific line. Documenta reacted to this pressure to drop Hamja, but the mechanisms failed to react or respond or offer the necessary support to the Islamaphobia and constant threats he faced. Hamja Ahsan became the shaheed of Documenta, a martyr making visible the harmonisation of the populist right wing and the liberal elite cultures of the art world. The harmonisation that a presence of a Muslim beyond politically passive, fabulous and wine-drinking is seen as the stranger, the other, the danger.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JwqBecUwn38buwuWJYYVnw.jpeg" /><figcaption>harvest part of the ‘Atis Rezistans/Ghetto Biennale’, Documenta 15</figcaption></figure><p>Ironically, I (Hassan) was invited by Hamja to speak in one of his public programme conversations. I was going to speak for the first time in depth about my research, particularly, the access of Muslims in the contemporary art space. This has been cancelled due to Hamja insulting the German Chancellor. Yet, Hamja’s artworks are still on display. Taring Padi still has a significant presence in the programme. The collectives, individuals and futures of anti-oppressive world building that Ruangrupa has convened are still there. Egg on the face of the detractors and downright racists. As the last weeks and days of Documenta Fifteen roll on, looked on with relief from the delegitimisers and the staff whose energy has been sapped in the cross-fire (many of whom are good hearted). A countdown of the days for the mechanisms of re-address kicks in, the ‘white revenge’ as Richard Bell told us may not just be round the corner in response to the programme of Documenta Fifteen. It is already here.</p><p>This is a call to all those working and navigating within the spaces of the art world — particularly those with decision making power. Documenta Fifteen is not finishing in September, the solidarity that is necessary for all those who have participated and to Ruangrupa who have convened is now of the utmost importance. This solidarity is beyond the social media tweet or the soft statement, whilst important, solidarity now is ensuring all those who have participated in Documenta have the resonance that is associated. That their reputation travels through the various networks and resources of the cultural landscape across the world. For all those in the spaces of influence, in your organisation and networks, ensure the narrative of Documenta Fifteen is authentic. That it is:</p><p>· The best Documenta that many have ever been too.</p><p>· A radical experiment in restructuring the possibilities of the contemporary art ekosystem.</p><p>· The failure of institutional processes of the contemporary art cultures to <strong>act</strong> on Islamophobia, racism and antisemitism in anti-oppressive ways.</p><p>If you can attend in these last weeks, we urge all to make the pilgrimage to Kassel, to show support and solidarity by seeing the harvests of the programme. If you are unable too, reach out and speak to artists involved — follow their work and advocate for them in the networks you are adjoined too. Documenta Fifteen may be coming to an end, but the fight for its legitimacy will continue and its legacy needs to be safeguarded. The ‘White Revenge’ will not win.</p><p>Walaikumusalaam Documenta Fifteen,<br>Hassan and Khaled</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aZYB9R-tuQEfPkQ-TIJitQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>‘Birds of Paradise, Jannah Chicken’, Hamja Ahsan, Documenta 15</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4755243098f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>