<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Henri Cotard on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Henri Cotard on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@henricotard?source=rss-18d904b42931------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 15:33:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@henricotard/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Proposing a new project to Yvon Chouinard: Patagonia Home]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@henricotard/proposing-a-new-project-to-yvon-chouinard-patagonia-home-9c7a302d08c1?source=rss-18d904b42931------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c7a302d08c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patagonia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henri Cotard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Apr 2020 20:59:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-10T08:34:55.459Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Proposing a new project to Yvon Chouinard: Patagonia Home</strong></p><p>By Louis Cassiani-Ingoni; Henri Cotard; Tommaso Fantin; Sharon McKay, April 2020</p><p>As a group of four students, we propose to founder Yvon Chouinard to extend Patagonia’s scope with Patagonia Home; an Architectural Boutique that conveys the same message of sustainability that the brand tries to communicate with every one of their products.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*m_HKoN12aKhSFqtK.jpeg" /></figure><p>Outward Focus Analysis</p><p>1.Problem</p><p>Living in today’s society comes with a great cost to our planet. Building materials, energy provision, furnishment, all contribute to the waste that is being produced on a daily basis. There are more than 138.45 million housing units that incur almost to 12% of the total Greenhouse gas emission (GHG) in the US (US EPA, 2020). The emission comes mostly from heating, waste management, poor quality materials and fossil fuel consumption. Indirectly, we can trace all of the emissions related to an item’s supply chain inside the house, from the sofa to the kitchen.</p><p>Patagonia’s mission statement is to be “in business to save our home planet.” A bold and courageous statement that goes well beyond their core business. In compliance with their mission, Patagonia provides their customers with a sustainable alternative to dress and, as of more recently with their launching of Patagonia Provisions, to eat as well. What if Patagonia were to provide the first alternative to live sustainably in a 360° manner? Dressing, eating, and now living with as little negative impact on the planet as possible.</p><p>2. Solution</p><p>Our solution is Patagonia Home , an Architectural Boutique that conveys the same message of sustainability that the brand tries to communicate with every one of their products. Practicality, beautiful design, high technology, and most importantly, sustainability, are at the core of Patagonia Home. Patagonia Home is a corporate venture that will act as a codependent business unit with roots in Ventura, California, and will be formed by 3 departments:</p><p>1. The Architecture Studio, run initially by five experienced sustainable architects and BIM experts, will provide scalable and modular blueprints for different types of housing.</p><p>2. Real Estate Department, which will manage some of the projects constructed and deployed near the best recreational parks in the US and rented for vacation purposes.</p><p>3. Interior Design department, that will leverage the already known expertise in design and material research of Patagonia, to design beautiful and sustainable homes with appropriate furnishings. With the waste of production of textiles, together with the machine already used to produce clothes, we believe it will be possible to rethink the production and design of some home products like pillows, sofas, armchairs, curtains and let the imagination flow.</p><p>Patagonia’s high end customer base, will have two options:</p><p>1. Rent online and/or buy an already built cookie-cutter home in strategic locations, for example in the wilderness of Jackson Hole Mountain resort.</p><p>2. Meet with an expert in any of the Patagonia flagship stores deployed around the country and design their dream sustainable home from start to finish.</p><p>For the rent alternative, homes will already be stocked with Patagonia clothing and gear relevant to the location, as well as select Patagonia Provisions snacks in order for customers to experience a full brand experience. This will also be a way to showcase new products, have direct A/B testing of new gear prototypes and direct marketing with the customer base.</p><p>3. Customers</p><p>We are targeting a niche taking advantage of the already established high end Patagonia’s customer segment. Our target segment will be high purchasing power individuals that are already close to the outdoor clothing industry in values and habits. We believe we can increase the customer lifetime value (CLV), create more attachment to the brand for the already established clients, and attract more “outsider” people who are not directly interested in the outdoor clothing industry and sustainable food.</p><p>According to Ibisworld which has defined Patagonia’s customer persona, the customer is between 18 to 40 years old, a conscious buyer that values quality products, has a disposable income and advocates sustainability and environmental issues. If we take the total number of consumers in the outdoor clothing market, which nowadays is valued at about $4bn, the 30% of the consumers represent people earning from 40.000 to 69.999 dollar a year (“Consumer Profile”, 2014). In addition 24.7% represent consumers that earn more than $70k a year.</p><p>Patagonia Home’s total suitable market will be the sum of these two sections, so 54,7% of the total number of clients of the outdoor clothing industry. This assumption lies in the fact that a person that earns more than $40k a year, and he/she already knows the brand, can afford to access a loan for a house. The total obtainable market is far narrower. According to our forecast, we assume that Patagonia, in the next five years, would reach only 0,1–0,2% of those customers, selling a total of 138 architectural projects and building 44 facilities for renting purposes around the US.</p><p>4. Market Analysis</p><p>Patagonia Home will be positioned in two markets: the green building market and the homestay market.</p><p>In 2019, the global green building market represented a $264 billion industry, most of it in developed areas, such as North America and Europe. With a forecasted 10,12% compound annual growth rate from 2017 to 2022, the market size is expected to reach more than $364 billion by 2022 (Research Market Future, 2018). This projected growth can be explained by several factors.</p><p>First of all, the global construction market, which the global green building market is a part of, is also forecasted to grow exponentially in value, with a 9% CAGR until 2021 ( Research Market Future, 2019) .</p><p>Secondly, the global growing concern is leading the whole industry to change, as the energy consumption of homes represents a significant part of the total energy consumption. This growing concern raises the demand for solutions minimizing energy consumption and carbon footprint. It also leads to an increasing awareness regarding the benefits of living in a green house or apartment. Beyond the ecological impact, people are beginning to realise that owning a sustainable property could save them money in the long run, with a cut in energy costs, and potential high margin at resale.</p><p>Finally, linked to the growing concern of global warming, governments are increasing regulations and incentives to encourage a shift from traditional buildings to green buildings. Incentives not only refer to CO2 credits but also tax breaks given to small and medium enterprises for reducing their environmental impact (The Energy Saving Promotion Scheme 2019).</p><p>The key players of the global green building market include: Alumasc Group Plc (UK), Amvik Systems (Canada), BASF SE (Germany), Bauder Limited (UK), Binderholz GmbH (Germany), E. I. duPont de Nemours and Company (U.S.), Forbo International SA (Switzerland), Interface Inc. (U.S.), Kingspan Group plc (Ireland), and Owens Corning (U.S.). Saint Gobain S.A. (Germany), SGS (Switzerland), NATiVE (U.S.), Green Building Store (U.K.), Green Build Products (I) Pvt Ltd (India), Bauder Limited (U.K.), Wienerberger AG (Austria), Ginkgo Sustainability (Canada). They can be either indirect competitors or partners. Regarding direct competitors, Patagonia Home will be in direct competition with architectural agencies focused on sustainable projects, such as Studio 3A (Portugal), Studio Green (U.S.) and Hewitt Studios (U.K.).</p><p>Regarding the homestay market, Patagonia Home will also be in an industry that is consistently growing due to the increase of tourism and of market shares over hotels. The market is led by two main actors: Airbnb and HomeAway (by Expedia) representing respectively 27% and 18% (The Rise of Home Sharing Platforms: Friend, Foe or Frenemy?, DBS Group Research, 2019) of the market. Airbnb would be the main competitor of Patagonia Home, as it offers more similar possibilities than any other company on the market and as it is, by far, the biggest homestay provider company with $3.6 billion of revenue in 2018 (Fees, 2020).</p><p>Regarding sustainable housing itself, the trend is stable (Research Market Future, 2019). People are looking for clean alternatives and other sources of energy to supply their homes. According to the same report, it is forecasted that from 2018 to 2021 the levels of new green building activity worldwide will increase from 27% to 47%. Almost 50% of new houses will introduce green building standards. According to the World Green Building trends 2018 report, the top five environmental reasons for building green are reducing energy consumption, protecting natural resources, reducing water consumption, lower GHG emissions and indoor air quality. The first cause, that counts up to 34% of the cases, that triggers the construction of green buildings are not the environmental regulations but the client demand. Despite fixed costs dropping from 76% in 2012 to only 49% in 2018, the construction costs for green buildings are still the biggest top barrier. In the US therefore, it is not surprising that the top barriers are higher fixed costs and concerns about affordability.</p><p>5. Sales Channels</p><p>Patagonia’s current sales channels include selling through retailers and wholesalers. Clearly, Patagonia Home provides challenges in the current business model, as these same retailers will not be interested in selling homes or real estate. For this reason, we have come up with two main channels in order to reach customers in the most effective way.</p><p>Rental Solution: Patagonia Home will launch its very own website for its rental solution. Similar to Aribnb’s website, customers will be able to discover available houses in different locations and book them for a set period of time ranging from a daily, monthly, or yearly basis.</p><p>Designing/Buying Solution: Patagonia Home’s website will also include a section for those interested in designing their own home and/or acquiring an already-built home, and will be provided with a contact number and email to set up a meeting. These clients will also be able to visit any Patagonia flagship store around the US to meet with a sales associate, who will show them all the different alternatives from designing to ready-made solutions. If the clients wish to proceed, they will be invited to work together with our architects and interior designers to customize their project following Patagonia’s sustainable values. According to research, engaging with clients in the early stage of the design process “helps them to demonstrate the value of the choices being made and how they will impact final building performances” ( Research Market Future, 2019) .</p><p>6. Unique Value Proposition</p><p>By extending its offer to homes, Patagonia would create a unique opportunity for its customers: being fully sustainable.</p><p>Indeed, for now, high-class individuals wanting to have a smaller impact on the environment, while still using products of good quality, are buying organic food from one company, sustainable clothes from another and other environmental-friendly products from other companies. Until now, Patagonia has managed to create a web of sustainable products (clothes, food, hiking equipment) that are generally bought by the same customer base. With Patagonia Home, these high-class individuals, that want to reduce their impact on the environment, will finally have the possibility to turn to the same company for most of their needs. This opportunity would create value in ways that competitors don’t, because now, you can eat, dress and live 100% sustainably with Patagonia.</p><p>On one side, people will be able to buy or build their new sustainable house with Patagonia and, on the other, people will be able to rent a sustainable house when they travel, so that they can always stay at an environmentally-friendly place. The latter goes beyond ‘housing’ per se. Customers renting a Patagonia house will not only enjoy the experience of sleeping in a Patagonia Home, but, as will be explained in more detail further in the report, will also be able to enjoy the experience of trying Patagonia clothes and food, as they will have access to it during their stay.</p><p>7. Unfair Advantage</p><p>The barriers to entry to both the green building market and the homestay market are high on the initial investment part, as Patagonia will have to build most of the homes first. Thankfully, as a corporate entrepreneurial project within a firm such as Patagonia, we have a significant financial power to back us. Therefore, the important investments required to launch Patagonia Home does not represent a significant issue.</p><p>Another significant barrier to entry that new entrants face regards the reputation and the level of trust customers need to have before buying/renting a house/apartment. Indeed, potential customers need to trust a company before staying at one of their premises, for safety reasons, but also to know that they will get what they paid for. This is even more the case when buying or building a house. The fact that Patagonia is already a renowned brand, known for the quality of its products as well as for its social vocation, will be very helpful for Patagonia Home to deal with this barrier. Moreover, current Patagonia customers, who have an existing bond with the company, will trust it when renting or purchasing one of its sustainable premises. To face the industries’ barriers to entry, both Patagonia’s existing strong financial structure and its reputation represent significant advantages on other new entrants of the market.</p><p>Regarding the competition, Patagonia Home has a significant unfair advantage, as it already has Patagonia’s customer base as potential customers. Indeed, Patagonia’s customer base is made of a lot of high-class individuals looking forward to living sustainably 100%. Patagonia Home is a feature of Patagonia that already has a customer base waiting for it to exist. This represents a competitive advantage, inimitable by competitors, that will facilitate Patagonia Home’s launch and success.</p><p>Inward Focus Analysis:</p><p>8. Fit within the Firm</p><p>Founded in 1973 as a clothing company specialised in mountain climbing gear, Patagonia has become a billion-dollar global brand selling not only clothes, but a lifestyle centred around environmental activism. Since 2009, Patagonia has introduced Patagonia Provisions , a line attempting to fix a “broken food chain,” that sells only locally grown foods which address environmental concerns. In other words, Patagonia offers their customers the possibility to not only dress sustainably, but eat sustainably as well. In order to dive even deeper into Patagonia’s philosophy of sustainable living, we believe that Patagonia Home would offer customers the unique opportunity to live sustainably 24/7. This horizontal integration allows Patagonia to widen its product range, whilst at the same time deepen the pursuit for a sustainable lifestyle. Patagonia Home is a “good fit” for the company itself due to reasons that are both cultural and strategic.</p><p>8.1 Fit within the firm — Culture</p><p>Patagonia’s culture of environmentalism, sustainability, and entrepreneurship is deeply entrenched in the company’s roots, even before its creation. Patagonia’s story begins in 1965 when its founder, Yvon Chouinard — an avid mountain climber, and his partner Tom Frost founded Chouinard Equipment. By 1970, Chouinard Equipment became the largest supplier of mountain gear in the US. However, the duo soon realised that their gear was actually harming the mountains, mainly due to the repeated hammering of pitons in the mountain’s cracks. For this reason, Chouinard and Frost decided to discontinue their most sought after product, and instead came up with an innovative alternative which could be wedged by hand instead of being hammered in: aluminum chocks. The product was a huge hit, and more importantly, Choinard and Frost were able to find a sustainable solution to continue doing the sport they loved.</p><p>Patagonia was created three years afterwards as a clothing company, and it also carries the same sustainable mission. This is evident through its environmental ethics which it has implemented since the early ’70s, these include: supporting employees in any environmentally active endeavours, organising environmental campaigns, donations to small grassroots organisations (rather than large NGOs), donating 10% of profits or 1% of sales (whichever is larger) every year, using only environmentally friendly and non-toxic materials and fabrics such as organic cotton, and consistently evolving its operations to minimise any negative impact on the planet (“History of Patagonia”, 2020). Patagonia Home is genuinely aligned with the company’s culture of sustainability. Patagonia considers itself an ‘activist company’, and Patagonia Home is aligned with these values as it would enable customers to live under sustainable walls and live a sustainable lifestyle through green energy and environmentally friendly furniture.</p><p>8.2 Fit within the firm — Strategy</p><p>As of less than two years ago, Patagonia launched a new mission statement: “Patagonia is in business to save our home planet.” We immediately saw a great metaphor with building homes to enable the protection of our home planet. Our idea fits Patagonia’s visionary strategy as a whole as it corresponds to today’s customers and most importantly to those of tomorrow. Customers are willing to pay a premium price for Patagonia products, not only because of their high-quality and environmentally-friendly products, but because of the pride in being a part of a group that is actively taking steps into saving the environment we live in. Marshal Cohen, chief industry analyst with NPD Group even describes them as the “Rolls Royce of their product category” (Margolin, 2017).</p><p>Moreover, the ongoing trend of sustainable products has been growing since the 20th century (Fowler, 2007) and is yet still increasing and making money: “I know it sounds crazy, but every time I have made a decision that is best for the planet, I have made money” according to Patagonia’s CEO (Chouinard, 2016). Reports conducted by the World Economic Forum suggest that less and less cars will be owned by individuals in the future; in fact customers will rent cars for particular journeys (WEF, 2018). As houses are the most important ownership in modern society, we are convinced that sustainable houses will correspond to the demand of customers. This approach follows Patagonia’s strategy every time they open a new line of products. For instance, in clothing: “ Lately, we’ve been working on a sustainability index. For instance, it takes 185 gallons of water to grow the cotton to make a T-shirt. And it makes a difference where the water comes from. Is it from a dam that has displaced lots of people and destroyed a river? Once we determine that, we try to buy cotton from areas where it rains. Then we publish all of that information on our website. It’s called the Footprint Chronicles” (Chouinard, 2016). I t is also the case with Patagonia Provisions: “I’ve been interested in food for 40 or 50 years, and I’m just now focusing my attention on it. I want to change the way people are eating” (Chouinard, 2011).</p><p>To conclude, Patagonia Home fits the company’s cultural and strategic heritage whilst nurturing its futuristic vision that has characterised the brand since 1973.</p><p>9. Synergies</p><p>Patagonia Home will result in the opening of two new main departments within the Patagonia Brand: an Architecture Studio and an Interior Design Studio. The aim of Patagonia Home is twofold: one is to construct cookie cutter sustainable houses in strategic, nature-filled locations that customers can either rent or acquire on the spot. The second is to accompany high-class customers on their journey to design and build a house in a location of their choice. These two new departments will be able to act synergistically within the company in a multitude of ways.</p><p>Designers already working for Patagonia have experience and competencies in the production of textiles, thus Patagonia Home would be able to use those same designers in certain aspects of their interior design team to help with the selection of materials needed for specific furniture. Besides, the machinery used to produce clothing can also be used to produce certain types of furniture such as pillows and curtains and ensure that there is no production waste. Not only will this reduce initial costs needed to launch Patagonia Home, but will also allow different sectors of the brand to feel involved in this new “project,” thus collapsing the barriers between sectors and consequently increasing the core strength of Patagonia employees.</p><p>Patagonia’s for-rent cookie cutter homes will also be stocked with select Patagonia gear and clothing relevant to the location of the home and the season. For example, a Patagonia Home in the Swiss Alps in the winter, will already include Ski and Snowboard jackets and trousers. There is also a possibility to partner with Black Diamond Equipment, ex Chouinard company, for mountain gear, like ropes, harnesses, skis and avalanche safety equipment. Moreover it could be possible to organize outdoor activities and workshops depending on the. location of the house: climbing and surf camps, fishing and meditation spots or skiing and snowboarding. Similar to Airbnb experience, but more adventurous. Going a step further, the homes can also be stocked with samples of Patagonia Provisions, allowing the Patagonia customer to indulge in the brand in a 360 degree manner, thus increasing the customer lifetime value of every client.</p><p>This corporate venture will further synergise Patagonia’s different departments and provide an omnichannel experience to the customer.</p><p>10. Investment</p><p>In terms of investment, we have created an Excel sheet with all of the associated costs, which you can find from Appendix 4 to 6. We estimate that to launch Patagonia Home, it will be necessary to hire 19 people in the first year, and an additional 14 people during the upcoming 5 years.</p><p>The whole business unit will be managed by a project manager, which will have the last say and the responsibility for the whole project. Under him, the team will be divided between 4 managers, each one responsible for a different department. The Arch Studio Blueprints director, the Arch Studio Custom project director, the Interior Design director and finally the Real Estate director.</p><p>In the first year, part of the management team will be made up of 4 architects, 3 designers, 2 sales and account managers and 5 part-time people for cleaning and maintenance of the rental house, that will be outsourced depending on the location of the home. We’ve estimated a total cost of €1.660.500 for the whole team, considering contributions at 35%, and insurance and benefits. This will increase up to € 2.930.500 in the 5th year, when the team will reach 33 people.</p><p>Other costs to take into consideration are online marketing, google adwords, event sponsorship, fairs, training course, team building and influencers, which could be done by Patagonia athletes already under contract. Moreover we estimate a cost for PR agencies to write blogs and articles, and UX design studio to integrate the booking system in the website. Additional costs include web developer, data analytics, server &amp; maintenance. The breakdown of the costs is visible in the appendix. Current assets to run the business, like computers, printers and office expenses won’t be very high, considering that we want to keep the main operations in the current headquarter in Ventura.</p><p>We want to take inspiration from the most classic business models of architecture studios around the world. Thanks to a fund that will work as a guarantee for the bank, we will have access to loans to buy the land and pay the outsource construction companies. The operation will conclude when the apartments will be sold, and the loan will be given back keeping the capital gain as a revenue. We compared the price in the US with the average construction prices in Europe and we estimated that for a “small“ house, this will be around €250,000, for the Luxury €500,000 and for the platinum around €600,000, land excluded. The construction costs are justified by the green sustainable technologies, which have dramatically decreased in the past 10 years. These technologies include: solar panels, insulating glass, water saving shower head, roof insulation, cavity wall insulation, floor insulation, balance ventilation, heat pump, solar boiler, waste heat recovery for wastewater in shower.</p><p>The first year we plan to sell 15 ready-made “small” houses and 5 “luxury” in all of the US. Furthermore, we plan to start the construction of 10 “small” houses, 1 “Luxury” and 1 “Platinum” for renting purposes. Considering the construction time, the total weeks of rental for the first year will be only around 10 full weeks, that we will use to pivot and experiment the demand.</p><p>From a financial point of view, the total cost that Patagonia will incur in the first year will be around €13 million. We estimate that Patagonia would have to invest, to be cash positive, a total of €13.330.000 which we have deduced should be divided 75% in loan, around €10 million, and the rest, almost €3.330.000 million, invested in cash by Patagonia.</p><p>We believe this 3.330.000 million investment to be an appropriate amount because, since Rose Marcario joined Patagonia as CFO in 2008, the company has increased dramatically the scale of operations and tripled its profits, reaching $600 million in revenues in 2013. After that she became CEO in 2013. So we think they have the availability to engage this kind of investment.</p><p>11. Scope &amp; Diversification Strategy</p><p>Patagonia’s diversification strategy is characterized as a single business organization in the sense that more than 95% of their total sales are derived all from a single industry. Instead of managing operations in multiple areas, they specialize in outdoor sports apparel and adventure gear. Patagonia’s diversification is limited to their product line, however many environmental initiatives are undertaken, such as donations and raising money for Grassroots efforts (Chouinard, 2013).</p><p>Items characteristic of a diversification strategy are visible on the website as well as their blog. On the one hand, their blog is full of live videos and virtual galleries that show how their products are being used, how the production of those products directly benefits the environment as well as employees and customers’ feedback. On the other hand, on</p><p>Patagonia’s website, not only can you shop for clothes and gear, but you can also listen to Patagonia music, connect with the group’s community and watch live videos of world travels (Patagonia, 2020). Patagonia is a pioneer in environmental affairs and a relevant example of that is when Patagonia switched to organic cotton. If it was an important risk at the time, they quickly found out the positives of it. Firstly, it led to diversification in their Textile Exchange program. Indeed, the (TEP) unites product brands, retailers, farmers and stakeholders to learn about the social and environmental benefits of environmentally conscious textiles. In 2002, Patagonia helped fund this group as the goal was to boost global sales of organic cotton apparel and home textile products (Chouinard, 2016).</p><p>Conversely, Patagonia undertook an anti-growth strategy: “It’s something we worked hard for. In ’89, ’90, we were growing too quickly. Our bank was in trouble, we couldn’t get loans, and it was a mess. I wanted to grow at a rate where I could eventually be free from the banks, even if I was holding growth back purposely. And that’s what we did. I believe there is a certain right size for every endeavor, whether it’s a business or even a religion. You exceed that after a while, and then you’re no longer valid. I’m always questioning what the right size is for our company” that was crucial in the company’s first successes (Chouinard, 2016).</p><p>Understanding their low diversification is key when releasing Patagonia Home. Patagonia Home would be a premium product sold at a premium price for premium customers, in line with the group’s historical and successful strategy. Our idea is not to banalise our offer and rather stick to the group’s core strategy: “In our catalogues, we are going to tell people not to over-consume. Buy what you need and hopefully it will be a Patagonia product.” This was important to understand before launching our product and when deciding how many houses would be produced.</p><p>12. Entrepreneurship/Innovation Strategy &amp; Culture</p><p>There are not many more entrepreneurial firms than Patagonia and not many people more characteristic of an entrepreneur than founder Yvon Chouinard. Answering the question about his entrepreneurial traits, Chouinard described his DNA as risk-taking and sees Patagonia as a risk seeking entrepreneurial firm: “ I am the entrepreneur who comes up with the wild and crazy idea and then dumps it on people to let them figure it out ” (Wang, 2010). Still today, Patagonia takes risk to answer new demands from the customers’ side: “These types of things (discussing the new Patagonia national Park) are actually why I have this company, to use the profits and take risks that public companies can’t take” (Wang, 2010).</p><p>Strategically, Patagonia is entrepreneurial in their approach to nature and sustainability but also in their construction of a new state park down at the tip of South America, about 800,000 acres of peat bogs and swamps and 200,000 acres of sea, that sequesters more carbon than almost anywhere in the world. As a rock climber and adventurer, Chouinard would always be the first one to experience new routes. Whether it is when ascending Yosemite’s Valley Muir Wall in California with unsecured ropes and hand-forged pitons, when he surfs in Baja or when he descends Clarks Fork River in Yellowstone National Park, Chouinard is always the first one to do so.</p><p>Besides its entrepreneurship traits, CEO Rose Marcario drives innovative initiatives daily that can be described as sustainable innovation (O’Rourke, 2017). Three years ago, Patagonia launched its website ‘Worn Wear’, a marketplace selling merchandise that is in good condition and is returned to Patagonia for new merchandising credits to be cleaned and repaired and sold again which shows a great market innovation as none of their competitors do that. Besides ‘Worn Wear’, 1 Percent to the planet was also a great innovation at the time making Patagonia a profitable NGO mixing entrepreneurship and innovation: “We give away 1 percent of our annual sales to 650 environmental organizations through our 1% for the Planet program. Craig Mathews, the owner of Blue Ribbon Flies, and I came up with the idea in 2001. Today, more than 1,800 companies have joined. Investing in the well-being of our planet makes good business sense.” To date, the pledge has brought $175 million to environmental and conservation efforts. At Patagonia, innovation is so deeply anchored in their culture that resistance to change does not impact innovation. Chouinard said he believes that “entrepreneurs are like juvenile delinquents who say, “This sucks. I’ll do it my own way. I’m an innovator because I see things and think I can make it better. So I will try it. That’s what entrepreneurs do.” Patagonia is so innovative that its opposition to resistance is swallowed by its core desire to change. For instance, when Patagonia was an alpine company, Chouinard wanted to start swim and surf lines, “the whole company was trying to reject it. It took us years to inculcate our surf business.” Today, the same can be said for their national park. Finally, Patagonia is an industry leader in technological innovation investing three million dollars annually in research and development, besides developing new fabrics like synchilla (recycled polyester fleece), capilene (moisture-w icking polyester fabric) and most recently a wetsuit lined with chlorine-free wool for increased isolation (Chouinard, 2016). To conclude, not only does the firm have an entrepreneurial and innovation strategy but they are the core of the ecosystem.</p><p>13. Mission &amp; Vision</p><p>Founder Yvon Chouinard is a great entrepreneur, and has been from his teenage years to his 81 years today. Besides his laidback clothing requirements, and open space in the office, Chouinard is a huge advocate for entrepreneurial values and vision. When asked if leadership can come from anyone at any level, Choiunard replied “ Yes, that’s what we would expect. At any point, anyone can speak up and challenge what’s happening, even challenge the mountain ,” (Margolin, 2017).</p><p>Chouinard has a very entrepreneurial life philosophy that revolves around autonomy and practicality. As an avid rock-climber Chouinard is totally self-learned; he made his own climbing tools by teaching himself how to blacksmith. Patagonia was born as a result of Chouinard’s own entrepreneurial mindset, when he decided to use and then sell Scotland rugby shirts as climbing shirts because the collars would keep the climbing sling from hurting his neck. Patagonia is originally all about being able to live autonomously and adapt to the environment rapidly. These values correspond to Patagonia Home, a brand that pushes living in autonomy to its extreme as food, clothes and housing are the three only necessities to live in nature. The pragmatic aspect is illustrated in Patagonia’s reaction to climate change that has been a rising issue in the past 10 years and Patagonia Home would be a fundamental revolution in the market and in our lives.</p><p>Patagonia is known for having a flat network within the firm, where communication can flow from any given direction, regardless of one’s position. In fact, Patagonia loves to break the boundaries as “often, the best ideas aren’t from the manager; they’re from the person whose hands are dirty doing the real work. If one person’s doing the work, you don’t need their manager, their manager’s manager, and so on, to get things done; you just need the right person,” (Margolin, 2017). Entrepreneurial ideas are supported and encouraged from any employee at Patagonia, as long as they follow the company’s core values and mission.</p><p>Patagonia’s mission statement in 2012 was “ to make the best product, but do it with no unnecessary harm and use business to implement solutions to the environmental crisis” (Carus, 2012). More recently, this changed to “Patagonia is in business to save our home planet,” thus moving from a more subdued approach to a more activist one. The company’s values and missions set an entrepreneurial focus in the company, as they urge any employee to come up with valuable ideas that can help save our home planet.</p><p>This is evident in Patagonia’s launching of Patagonia Provisions, an organic food line that sells only organic and locally grown food. This is an attempt to fix the “broken food-chain” which has resulted from the mass production of food using chemical pesticides and GMOS (Margolin, 2017). This horizontal integration stays true to the company’s mission and values, and gives their customers a further option to follow a sustainable lifestyle. Clearly Patagonia values an entrepreneurial mindset and encourages employees to innovate, so as long as the ideas are relevant to the true mission of the company.</p><p>14. HR Policies</p><p>It is important to note that Patagonia is very employee centered. Besides historically being the industry’s first employee-owned company as it was sold to employees in 1989, its current employee benefits are extraordinary such as ‘surf flextime’ with employees going surfing when the waves are out in front of the amazing HQ building: “When the surf comes in, all the surfers are out of here. But I’ve never seen an instance when anyone’s taken advantage.” Taking this into account, HR policies are crucial and have to be effectively managed.</p><p>HR policies are already in place to support intrapreneurship such as its flat structure to promote initiatives from any employee to the CEO Yvon Chouinard, as opposed to traditional hierarchies. Also, the talent acquisition process is particularly oriented towards entrepreneurial and independant mindsets and the process takes time to make sure the talent is the right fit for the firm: “ Hiring right is half the battle. We hire slowly and we hire hard. It’s not unusual to have a position open for over a year before we find the right person, even at the senior level. Then we have substantial orientation and onboarding in the first year, giving new hires significant time with th e senior team” (Wang, 2010).</p><p>Top management establishes leadership management. The leader picks the right manager and team, and sets the right vision. They pick the “mountain”, involving a healthy debate with the crowd about it. The manager states who will be the different “climbers” and “athletes”, attributing clear goals to every person involved. The idea is to coach rather than supervise simply giving a context and an objective, and then every employee decides how to get to the top of the mountain in their own way.</p><p>Patagonia”s culture bible ‘Let my people go surfing’ also dictates that meetings and professional relationships should be dynamic : “The worst managers try to manage behind a desk. The only way to manage is to walk around and talk to people. As long as you get the work done, there’s a lot of flexibility in scheduling. People are encouraged to live the lives they want and do what they need to do, whether that’s horseback riding, surfing, or seeing their kid’s play. If we’re hiring independent people who care about the environment and the outdoors, we certainly can’t have a culture that doesn’t allow them to do those things” (Chouinard, 2011).</p><p>Therefore, the current HR policies implemented at Patagonia are already effective; yet they could be deepened. For example, with ‘startup competitions’ within the firm to promote innovation or bigger partnerships in terms of sponsoring and marketing with sport clubs and federations to encourage professionals to use Patagonia more.</p><p>15. Comparison to other Entrepreneurial firms — 3M</p><p>In many ways, Patagonia’s entrepreneurial spirit is similar to that of 3M’s. Both companies were founded from true entrepreneurs that came up with an innovative and modest solution to bring to the market, and they have the same flat-network structure that promotes a friendly environment where all employees can share their ideas. Patagonia has the potential to grow into a truly diverse company by using sustained regeneration to enter new markets within the environmentally sustainable industry, just as 3M is in the technological one. Although Patagonia already has an extremely entrepreneurial environment, it can learn from some of the policies and procedures that 3M uses in order to promote innovation. Some of these include creating a 15% rule where employees must spend up to 15% of their time on non-program related activities that are related to innovative ideas for the company; or the objective to have 25% of sales come from products introduced within the last five years. By undergoing an organizational rejuvenation with the introduction of new policies related to entrepreneurial objectives, Patagonia has the potential to really break down the boundaries of what they can create and sell under their umbrella of sustainability. Patagonia Home is just the first of many other corporate ventures Patagonia can launch to further their mission to save the planet.</p><p>16 . Risks</p><p>As seen in the investment portion of the report, Patagonia Home is a large investment in terms of finance, human capital, and technology. This could be a potential problem for Patagonia, as the company is adamant about having controlled growth since the recession in 1991 that forced them to lay off 20% of their workforce (“History of Patagonia”, 2020). In the 80’s, Patagonia was growing at a very fast pace which was fuelled by revolving bank loans; but once the recession hit in 1991, their sales halted, and bankers called back their loans. This resulted in Patagonia having to make drastic cuts in both production and human capital — many of whom were friends. Since this moment, Patagonia has kept their “growth and borrowing to a modest scale,” (“History of Patagonia”, 2020). With the recent launch of Patagonia Provisions, and now Patagonia Home, employees in the company may be fearful that Patagonia is growing too quickly and that they may fall into the same trap of ’91, risking their jobs.</p><p>17. Risk Mitigation Strategy</p><p>Patagonia is no longer the company it was 30 years ago; in 2015, their total revenue was $750 million, and, thanks to Trump’s tax cut which reduced corporate tax from 35% to 21%, the company received an additional $10 million in profits in 2018 (Au-Yeung, 2018). This extra money was donated to “grassroot groups fighting climate change, i ncluding organizations that work in regenerative organic agriculture to help reverse global warming” (Au-Yeung, 2018) . In 2021, Chouinard could use that money to launch Patagonia Home, and further his brand’s tools to help the environment. In order to mitigate risk and calm any nerves within the company, Patagonia Home will rely less on loans and more on in-house resources. By re-investing its own available cash and taking only a portion of the investment needed from bank loans, Patagonia will be stronger in fighting cut-backs during a next possible recession.</p><p>Bibliography</p><p>2014. Consumer Profile . [online] Available at: https://patagoniabrandaudit.weebly.com/consumer-profile.html. [Accessed 22 March 2020].</p><p>Carus, F., 2012. Patagonia: A Values-Led Business From The Start . [online] the Guardian.</p><p>Available at: <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/patagonia-values-led-business-benefit-cor">https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/patagonia-values-led-business-benefit-cor</a> p. [Accessed 12 March 2020].</p><p>Chouinard, Yvon, Jib Ellison, and Rick Ridgeway. “The sustainable economy.” Harvard Business review 89.10 (2011): 52–62.</p><p>Chouinard, Yvon, and Vincent Stanley. The responsible company: What we’ve learned from Patagonia’s first 40 years . Patagonia, 2013.</p><p>Chouinard, Yvon. Let My People Go Surfing: The Education of a Reluctant Businessman — Including 10 More Years of Business Unusual . Penguin, 2016.</p><p>DBC Group Research. The Rise of Home Sharing Platforms: Friend, Foe or Frenemy? 12 August 2019.</p><p>Eu.patagonia.com. 2020. History Of Patagonia — A Company Created By Yvon Chouinard . [online] Available at: <a href="https://eu.patagonia.com/gb/en/company-history.html.">https://eu.patagonia.com/gb/en/company-history.html.</a> [Accessed 19 March 2020].</p><p>Fees, A, M., Locks, S., Protectors, S., Heaters, E., Heaters, G., Rights, S., Deposits, S., Agreements, L., Lease, B., Rentals, V. and Bills, E., 2020. Airbnb Statistics [2020]: User &amp; Market Growth Data . [online] iPropertyManagement.com. Available at: https://ipropertymanagement.com/research/airbnb-statistics. [Accessed 20 March 2020].</p><p>Fowler, Stephen J., and C. Hope. “Incorporating sustainable business practices into company strategy.” Business strategy and the Environment 16.1 (2007): 26–38.</p><p>MacKinnon, J., 2015. Patagonia’S Anti-Growth Strategy . [online] The New Yorker. Available at: <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/patagonias-anti-growth-strategy.">https://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/patagonias-anti-growth-strategy.</a> [Accessed 21 March 2015].</p><p>Margolin, K., 2017. How Patagonia’S Unique Leadership Structure Enabled Them To Thrive . [online] Virgin. Available at: <a href="https://www.virgin.com/entrepreneur/how-patagonias-unique-leadership-structure-enabled-th">https://www.virgin.com/entrepreneur/how-patagonias-unique-leadership-structure-enabled-th</a> em-thrive. [Accessed 15 March 2020].</p><p>O’Rourke, Dara, and Robert Strand. “Patagonia: Driving sustainable innovation by embracing tensions.” California Management Review 60.1 (2017): 102–125.</p><p>Research Market Future, 2018. Green Building Market Overview, Industry Top Manufactures, Market Size, Industry Growth Analysis &amp; Forecast To 2023.</p><p>MarketWatch. Available at: <a href="https://www.marketwatch.com/press-release/green-building-market-overview-industry-top-m">https://www.marketwatch.com/press-release/green-building-market-overview-industry-top-m</a>anufactures-market-size-industry-growth-analysis-forecast-to-2023-2018-08-20. [Accessed 22 March 2020].</p><p>Research Market Future, 2018. Green Building Market Research Report — Forecast To 2023. MRFR . [online] Marketresearchfuture.com. Available at: <a href="https://www.marketresearchfuture.com/reports/green-building-market-4982.">https://www.marketresearchfuture.com/reports/green-building-market-4982.</a> [Accessed 11 March 2020].</p><p>Research Market Future, 2019. Green Building Market 2019: Global Industry Overview By Historical Analysis, Comprehensive Research Study, Opportunities, Competitive Landscape And Regional Trends By Forecast To 2023 . [online] GlobeNewswire NewsRoom. Available at: <a href="https://www.globenewswire.com/news">https://www.globenewswire.com/news</a>release/2019/06/12/1867490/0/en/Green-Building-Ma rket-2019-Global-Industry-Overview-By-Historical-Analysis-Comprehensive-Research-Stud y-Opportunities-Competitive-Landscape-and-Regional-Trends-by-Forecast-to-2023.html. [Accessed 22 March 2020].</p><p>Segran, E., 2020. The Future Of Clothes: These 3 Startups Help You Rent Or Resell Everyday Items . [online] Fast Company. Available at: <a href="https://www.fastcompany.com/90457489/caastle-thredup-trove-most-innovative-companies-2">https://www.fastcompany.com/90457489/caastle-thredup-trove-most-innovative-companies-2</a> 020. [Accessed 10 March 2020].</p><p>The Business Research Company, 2012. Global Construction Market Trend 2019 : Major Drives, Key Players And Scope . [online] MarketWatch. Available at: <a href="https://www.marketwatch.com/press-release/global-construction-market-trend-2019-major-dr">https://www.marketwatch.com/press-release/global-construction-market-trend-2019-major-dr</a>ives-key-players-and-scope-2019-07-17?mod=mw_quote_news. [Accessed 22 March 2020].</p><p>US EPA. 2020. Sources Of Greenhouse Gas Emissions | US EPA . [online] Available at: <a href="https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions.">https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions.</a> [Accessed 19 March 2020].</p><p>Wang, J., 2010. Patagonia, From The Ground Up . [online] Entrepreneur. Available at: <a href="https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/206536.">https://www.entrepreneur.com/article/206536.</a> [Accessed 12 March 2020].</p><p>Welch, L., 2013. The Way I Work: Yvon Chouinard, Patagonia . [online] Inc.com. Available at: <a href="https://www.inc.com/magazine/201303/liz-welch/the-way-i-work-yvon-chouinard-patagonia.">https://www.inc.com/magazine/201303/liz-welch/the-way-i-work-yvon-chouinard-patagonia.</a> html. [Accessed 22 March 2020]. Consumer Profile.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c7a302d08c1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The impact of globalisation on CSR in football]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@henricotard/the-impact-of-globalisation-on-csr-in-football-46f2393f6d1f?source=rss-18d904b42931------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46f2393f6d1f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[csr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[globalisation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[football]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henri Cotard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Apr 2020 10:10:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-24T19:56:18.340Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The impact of globalisation on CSR in football</strong></p><p>By Henri Cotard, April 2018</p><p>This study seeks to get behind the spin and explore different perspectives of CSR from the 1990s until today in elite European football authorities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*X9dQjGPluZPO3eTrqyr2Hg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Table of contents</strong></p><p>Introduction</p><p>I — Research on globalisation and CSR</p><p>I.1 Forms and definition of globalisation</p><p>I.2 Historical construction and evolution of CSR</p><p>I.3 Why study the causal effect in football?</p><p>II — Globalisation’s positive impact on football’s CSR</p><p>II.1 Converging towards a model</p><p>II.2 Football as a value creator</p><p>II.3 Football’s philanthropic activities</p><p>III — Globalisation’s negative impact on football’s CSR and the limitations of our study</p><p>III.1 Some authorities remain shareholder minded</p><p>III.2 More global concerns about CSR have been worsened or neglected</p><p>III.3 Limitations of our analysis</p><p>Discussion — Football and CSR as ideal partners in the future</p><p>Conclusion</p><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>Over the last 30 years in the corporate world[1], globalisation has engaged public concern over the role of business in society and is now substantial (Walter et al., 2011). In parallel since 1995[2], the football industry has strongly developed and has become a major economic and political sphere in business. Paradoxically, if globalisation has genuinely impacted Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), it is only very recently that CSR has been analysed in the context of football. If this paradox has been qualified by Green (2006) as “unsurprising given the widespread understanding of sport as being a hobby, and as a quasi per definition, contributing to the benefit of society due to policies drawing on the inclusiveness of sports”, this paper will attempt to overcome this paradox and discover the impact of globalisation on CSR in football. This study seeks to get behind the spin and explore different perspectives of real substance from the 1990s until today in elite European football authorities.</p><p>A first part will address the nature and evolution of globalisation and CSR. Then, we will focus on the positive causal effects of globalisation on CSR in football. In contrast, our third discussion will outline its negative impact and the limitations of our analysis. Our conclusion will attempt to show that CSR must be incorporated into football clubs’ strategies tomorrow as football and CSR provide an ideal fit.</p><p><strong>I — Research on globalisation and CSR</strong></p><p><strong>I.1 Forms and definition of globalisation</strong></p><p><strong>Globalisation</strong></p><p>There is no broader meaning than the one of globalisation. Considered by many to be the dominant force in business, globalisation is a holistic phenomenon of intensification of fluxes that shape our society as a whole (Kercher, 2007). Scherer and Palazzo (2008) propose that globalisation is defined as a process of amplification and acceleration of social activities and economic cooperation across areas and countries. This process makes multinational corporates gain more free space and flexibility to employ international business and trade but new global problems and challenges are produced during this process, such as climate change, distribution of income and welfare and terrorism (Scherer and Palazzo, 2008).</p><p><strong>Globalisation in football</strong></p><p>Football globalisation was triggered by the intensification of business globalisation. The ‘Bosman ruling’ marks the start of free circulation of players and the rise of a globalised football. When players would only play for clubs of their country before the 1990s, the winning of Bosman’s case and the release of what has now become Article 45 (1) of the Treaty on the functioning of the European Union, has enabled freedom of movement for workers and freedom of association.</p><p>Today, football is one of the most globalised industries with a single game viewed in more than 55 countries, by more than 500 million people and broadcasted by more than 75 television channels (Scherrer, 2017). In the English football league, almost 70% of players and 65% of coaches are not English. If the numbers are mind-blowing, globalisation in football is only at its start with emerging markets like the United States, China and India starting to attract players and investors worldwide. Two institutions regulate football globalisation: Federation of International Football Associations (FIFA) in the world and, Union of European Football Associations (UEFA) in Europe.</p><p><strong>I.2 Historical construction and evolution of CSR (lecture 1, 41)</strong></p><p><strong>History of Corporate Social Responsibility</strong></p><p>A single globally accepted definition of CSR does not exist, as the concept is still evolving. Until the 1950s, discourse on CSR was limited. The publication of T<em>he Social Responsibilities of the Businessman</em> by Howard Bowen in 1953 is widely regarded to be the starting point of the debate about the role of business in society.</p><p><strong>Definition of Corporate Social Responsibility</strong></p><p>This has led to an emphasis on linking CSR with corporate financial performance; CSR is increasingly seen as a way to add value to the business (Fernandez, 2016). The most widely accepted definition is Carroll and Buchholtz’s, stating CSR comprises “economic, legal, ethical, and philanthropic expectations placed on organisations by society at a given point in time” (2009:44).</p><p><strong>I.3 Why study the causal effect in football?</strong></p><p><strong>Football as a mirror of society</strong></p><p>Analysing the impact of globalisation on CSR in the world of business would have been thoroughly interesting; albeit rather very general and vague. I have decided to concentrate on the football sphere not because I am passionate about the sport but because I believe that football is a mirror of society and has a core duty of promoting CSR, perhaps more importantly than other businesses.</p><p>Indeed, the border between a football stadium and a social manifestation is very unclear (Testa, 2009). In his novel <em>L’éloge de l’esquive</em> (2014), author Olivier Guez flies back to the XVIth century to explain that dribbles were a way for black slaves to avoid contact with white players in the case that they would be scraped at the end of the game. Invented by Capoeira dancers, Neymar’s favourite dribble is not only an aesthetic movement but also reflects the profound origins of Brazilian society and history. As French anthropologist Christian Bromberger assesses, a football game brings together the fundamental values of society being one of the deepest symbolic representation of our time (Bromberger, 1995: 377). Also, in the stands, supporters have the opportunity of last resort for political and social expression where it is usually never freely permitted anywhere else (Njororai, 2009: 872).</p><p>Moreover, football clubs are the reflect of modern business corporations. The president is the CEO of the club and marketing directors, recruitment staff, managers and players are the employees. Supporters can be considered as consumers. Studies reveal a significantly high degree of similarity between the management of a football club and the one of a medium-sized company.</p><p><strong>Football, more than just a sport</strong></p><p>Because of football’s high visibility and mass communication, globalisation has given football a larger role than one of an activity or entertainment, whether it is when Zinédine Zidane addresses a headbutt to Marco Materazzi during the 2006 World Cup final, it is seen immediately on social media and negatively influences children, or when Dani Alves eats a banana that is thrown at him on the pitch, his image makes headlines and is followed by anti-racism campaigns from many players.</p><p>Today, if less than 2.65 billion people in the world have access to social media, 2.65 billion people do play football. From the poorest and richest countries, all political orientations, of both sexes and all ethnicities, football has understood, alike most corporate businesses, that it owes a duty to promote socially responsible behaviours through CSR initiatives.</p><p><strong>II — Globalisation’s positive impact on football’s CSR</strong></p><p><strong>II.1 Converging towards a model</strong></p><p>It is only very recently that football clubs have integrated CSR to their strategies. Sports organisations and particularly football clubs have recognised their “expanding economic, social and even political significance” which also includes “dealing with matters outside their immediate sporting sphere of activity” (ILO, 2003). Research at club level has confirmed the increasing need of stakeholder management in order to demonstrate sound governance and strategic management (Szymanski, 1998). The Stakeholder Theory (Freeman, 1984) means firms’ obligations go beyond those prescribed by law and extend to integral groups in society. Juventus FC was the first club to adopt this attitude and release its annual CSR report last year[3]. The Italian club [4] has inspired elite clubs to positively impact society, following four initiatives.</p><p>Firstly, as globalisation has spread, the number of supporters and audience has significantly enlarged. Alike consumers in multinationals, football clubs have continuously engaged in promoting a sustainable relationship with its supporters by organising trips for away games, coordinating travel itineraries and booking hotels. For home games, most elite clubs[5]have built new stadiums that are more comfortable, allow the public to appreciate a pleasant view from every seat and offers Wi-Fi, drinks and food. The increasing number of memberships and visibility has helped football institutions understand that supporters constantly nurtured their social life surrounding their passion for football and it is clubs’ responsibility to respond to their expectations.</p><p>Secondly, globalisation has increased the level of competitiveness between clubs and especially between players. As a consequence, football bodies have placed their employees, the players, at the heart of their business model by strengthening their player formation programs. For example, a club like FC Barcelona has created <em>La Masia</em>, a “city-club” that attracts very young players from the start of their teenage years and builds a dream environment making them feel comfortable, allowing them to go to school and offering them a social life.</p><p>Our third argument focuses on how globalisation has enlarged football’s impact on its area and local community. Consulting firm Deloitte (2005) has recommended that clubs integrate CSR management to ensure healthy relationships with their communities supporting the idea that football clubs have a role of corporate citizenship, taking responsibilities within society (Matten &amp; Crane, 2005). Former French champion, AJ Auxerre has always invested in new infrastructures at the heart of the small town and recently decided to install training camps in the suburbs to develop the region. Thus, football has become a social actor with the redevelopment of urban areas and local campaigns.</p><p>Finally, football clubs are businesses and seek to do business responsibly, beginning with its own governance and financial management, because sustainability in football means first achieving long-term success, even in difficult times. Juventus President Andrea Agnelli participated to create the European Club Association (ECA) that represents the interests of football clubs. ECA’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mission_statement">mission statement</a> is “to create a new, more democratic governance model that truly reflects the key role of the clubs”.</p><p>Therefore, these four reasons explain how globalisation has enabled football clubs to recently integrate CSR initiatives into their strategies at a club level, but we will know investigate football’s role towards promoting CSR at a macro level.</p><p><strong>II.2 Football as a value creator</strong></p><p>Integrating CSR in football clubs’ business models gives the opportunity to create value for society. In the long-term, football clubs create value for their external stakeholders and position themselves as highly relevant and influential social, economic and political agents.</p><p>Firstly, globalisation has enabled football to create human values to increase quality of life. This can be seen in the advertisement of supra-national entities or global causes. Most famous examples would be the sponsoring partnership between FC Barcelona and the United Nations (UN) to fight against poor childhood through UNICEF. Hence publically advertising the brand on every shirt, the football club has been offering two million euros per year to the cause since 2011. Not only football benefits society humanly but also economically.</p><p>Indeed, football has become a business agent creating financial value for other industries such as broadcasting, sports industries and the clothing industries. 38% of Nike’s market share is based on football, equal to 1.4 billion euros. The organisation of a national or international event also accelerates the economy macro-economically with the creation of stadiums, constructions, the creation of jobs and social initiatives. Football also accelerates micro-economies with the hosting of national games in smaller towns.</p><p>Thirdly, football has become a social agent fostering cultural value. Cultural identity is very strong in rural cities like Athletic Bilbao that is one of the most nationalist clubs in Europe as only one non-Basque player has joined the club since its creation[6]. If this argument may seem flawed for international and multicultural cities, football builds a cultural identity in smaller clubs and regions.</p><p>Fourthly, football creates reassurance values and connects commercial or political actors with people through social marketing campaigns. Football connects people from different backgrounds and nationalities. A famous example is the winning French football team of World Cup 1998, “Black-Blanc-Beur”[7] symbolising three cultures and connecting the country politically. If it is not necessarily football’s objective, emotions procured during a game have the power to unite people and make them cry, of happiness.</p><p>Thus, we have analysed how globalisation has enabled football to become a value creator. According to the theory, Corporate Social Performance (CSP), corporations have a responsibility in undertaking CSR practices since business and society are two interpenetrating systems (Wood, 1991).</p><p><strong>II.3 Football’s philanthropic activities</strong></p><p>Carroll’s (1979) <em>Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibilities’</em> the most commonly accepted model of CSR, concentrates on what society expects over and above economic and legal obligations. In the context of football, we see evidence of some corporations being <em>truly</em> responsible for players or football clubs creating their own discretionary activities. Arsenal, Real Madrid, Juventus have all created foundations using the power of football to support people having difficulties or who find themselves in situations of precarity. Indirectly, those clubs have enabled players such as Zidane, Ronaldo or Beckham to do the same, supporting research against cancer, autism or diabetes.</p><p>Thus, the concerns for transparency and accountability evident within the corporate world have transferred to football. This has led some to suggest that football organisations cannot ignore CSR and that they have to implement it. However, globalisation has not always impacted positively CSR in football and these damages constitute the next part of this paper.</p><p><strong>III — Globalisation’s negative impact on football’s CSR and the limitations of our study</strong></p><p><strong>III.1 Some authorities remain shareholder minded</strong></p><p>Despite having improved football’s impact on society in certain aspects, the intensification of economic and cultural fluxes has nevertheless damaged some aspects of corporate social responsibility. Such behaviours can be explained by the reasoning of Shareholder Value Theory that is a direct opposite to Stakeholder theory; Shareholder Value Theory underlines the relationship between corporations and their various stakeholders. It is less demanding toward businesses and their societal implications in the long-term, stating that the only social responsibility is to make profits and increase the economic value of the company for its shareholders (Friedman, 1970).</p><p>Almost every week, a political scandal makes the headlines of newspapers though the most publically dispersed current affair was revealed by the American justice and concerned ex-President Sepp Blatter. Involved in corruption around the organisation of 2018 and 2022 world cups, his re-elections since 1998 and personal fiscal evasion of not less than 50 million dollars, Sepp Blatter eventually had to abdicate from his functions (FIFA, 2016)[8]. Scandals have not only concerned political misbehaviours but also economic and legal frauds.</p><p>Any engagement or entering into the political arena in order to solve political problems is or should be either for lobbying their profit interests (Hillman-Keim, 2004) or as voluntary acts of discretionary philanthropy (Carroll, 1979) that equally serve strategic aims (Porter &amp; Kramer, 2002). Globalisation has increased economic disparity between the elite league and amateur leagues and has caused some teams to disappear such as Wimbledon, Portsmouth and Coventry in England. Moreover, tickets’ price has increased exponentially in certain clubs. Corporate social responsibility also creates a duty for football bodies to be responsible for the manufacturing of their equipment but it does not seem to be the case as shirts and balls are produced in the poorest region of South-East Asia , Sialkot (Pinsker, 2008). Additionally, to the product itself, the marketing of certain football clubs is promoting harmful goods or companies. For example, Liverpool has long advertised for Carlsberg beers and Zenith Saint-Petersburg currently advertises for Gazprom.</p><p>From a legal point of view, globalisation has unified European countries with the creation of the European Union. However, in football, laws have not been unified in every country. Panama Papers have revealed a true misappropriation of rules concerning fiscal niches from very famous and newsworthy players like Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo. These arguments reveal that globalisation has also contributed to individuals making profit.</p><p><strong>III.2 More global concerns about CSR have been worsened or neglected</strong></p><p>From a social point of view, football should have followed the trends of society and placed women at an equal stand to men. When companies create more and more quotas or restrictions to employ as many women as men and verify that salaries are of the same order, masculine football is still years ahead of feminine football. Also, the attitude towards the referee is often disgraceful as football pitches are the host of daily homophobic abuses.</p><p>Eventually, we could argue that globalisation has culturally embraced all cultures and led to a homogenisation of the ways football teams play or a loss of identity in national teams as players play in leagues abroad. Ex-coach Arrigo Sacchi dresses this conclusion as well as questioning nationalities of players that are formed in a host country from their childhood.</p><p>The environment is an interesting point because, in the world of business, it represents one of the main issues of CSR. Considered by the Global Economic Forum to be the main issue for tomorrow, football has not yet been aware or raised awareness towards its community. In 2022 will be held the twenty-first world cup in Qatar and, because of temperatures, the current idea is to air-condition all stadiums and vaporise seats on a 24-hour basis. Obvious to say that the impact on climate would be inconsiderable.</p><p>Thus, our second part has shown that globalisation has weakened the implementation of CSR practices in football, in six distinct spheres: politically, economically, legally, socially, culturally and environmentally.</p><p><strong>III.3 Limitations of our analysis</strong></p><p>Before drawing any conclusions on globalisation’s impact on CSR in football, it is necessary to put in perspective our analysis.</p><p>On a global level, the world governing body FIFA has created a CSR unit, even so the general moral integrity of the organisation and a number of its ‘‘goodwill’’ activities remain doubtful (Jenkins, 2006), which links to occasional scepticism about the general idea of CSR and its application. Additionally, writing CRS strategies is an important step but implementing them can be a different story as the good intentions do not always come into practice as planned. This leads to some organisation viewing CSR as an image or a brand image rather than a philanthropic or honest act, especially in football that is a very branded industry.</p><p>Hence, a limit to the study of CSR in football is that business companies have always searched for profit and, some, now develop the search for social responsibility, in opposition to football clubs who have never perceived profit as their only objective. The main goal for a football club is to win titles, the second one to attract supporters and the third one to make a profit. Extremely rare are investors who have won money through football. Moreover, because football’s objective is winning trophies, this has resulted in very short-term objectives and it remains very complicated to install CSR strategies, that must be long-term.</p><p><strong>Discussion — Football and CSR as ideal partners in the future</strong></p><p>This paper has demonstrated the positive and negative impact of globalisation on CSR in football. The industry is only at the beginning of its awareness and CSR practices have only been recently incorporated in clubs’ strategies. Based on a recent academic paper (Breitbarth et al., 2016) and previously seen arguments, we can argue that football organisations offer a particularly appropriate context for CSR.</p><p>Firstly, the popularity of football ensures mass media distribution and communication power ensuring to promote CSR activities to a wide audience. Secondly, football is largely viewed by children and teenagers who are more likely to engage in a CSR programme if it is attached to a football organisation or personality. Thirdly, the authors argue that football CSR would invariably involve group participation and therefore aid social interaction, therefore leading to improving cultural understanding and integration. Whether or not football institutions currently benefit society, it is only by engaging in socially responsible activities that those will develop a better understanding of CSR.</p><p>These arguments make it clear that the potential for football clubs to engage effectively in CSR is strong. Some academic commentators have gone so far as to state that CSR and football are ideal partners (Walters et al., 2011).</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Thus, the football industry has been witnessing an intensification of fluxes since the 1990s and, in parallel, the emergence of more socially responsible strategies. This paper has discussed the impact of globalisation on CSR raising several questions on the effectiveness of CSR in the long-term and the actual willingness of football clubs to follow this path. If CSR in football has been only rarely approached in books, it is mainly because those strategies are relatively recent and their potential is still to be explored. Indeed, what Eisenberg describes today as one of the most capitalistic sports (2006) could become, in tomorrow’s world, a core asset toward society as a whole, as we have argued that CSR and football are ideal partners. But it is the duty of football institutions and their actors to incorporate this opportunity to sustainable business models.</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>Breitbarth, T., Harris, P. (2008°. The role of corporate social responsibility in the football business: towards the development of a conceptual model. European Sport Management Quarterly 8(2) DOI. 10.1080/16184740802024484.</p><p>Bromberger, C. (1995). Le match de football. Ethnologie d’une passion partisane à Marseille, Naples et Turin. Paris : Editions de la Maison des sciences de l’homme.</p><p>Carroll, A.B. (2008). A history of corporate social responsibility: concepts and practices. In A. Crane, A. McWilliams, D. Matten, J. Moon and D. Siegel (eds.), The Oxford handbook of corporate social responsibility: 19–46. Oxford: Oxford University Press.</p><p>Carroll, A.B., Buchholtz, A.K. (2009). Business and society: ethics and stakeholder management (7th edition.). Cincinnati: South-Western.</p><p>Crane, A., Matten, D., and Spence, L.J. (2013). Corporate social responsibility in a global context. Chapter in: Crane, A., Matten, D., and Spence, LJ, Corporate Social Responsibility: Readings and Cases in a Global Context, 2, 3–26.</p><p>Deloitte and Touche. (2005, quoted in Holt, Michie, Oughton, Tacon &amp; Walters, 2005).</p><p>Eisenberg, C. (2006).”Le football comme phénomène mondial”. In Football, sport mondial et sociétés locales (Eds, Compagnon, O and Dietschy, P). Paris: Alternatives Économiques. 8- 23.</p><p>Fernandez, M. (2016). Social responsibility and financial performance. The role of good corporate governance.</p><p>Green, M. (2006). From ‘sport for all’ to not about ‘sport’ at all? Interrogating sport policy interventions in the United Kingdom. European Sport Management Quarterly, 6(3), 217238.</p><p>Guez, O. (2014). L’éloge de l’esquive. Montpellier: Ed. Gabelire.</p><p>Friedman, M. (1970). The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits. New York Times Magazine, 13 Sept.: 32–3, 122, 126.</p><p>Freeman, R.E. (1984). Strategic management: A stakeholder approach. Pitman, Boston.</p><p>Hillman, A.J., Keim, G.D., and Schuler, D. (2004). Corporate Political Activity: A Review and Research Agenda. Journal of Management, 30: 837–857.</p><p>Holt, M., Michie, J., Oughton, C., Tacon, R., &amp; Walters, G. (2005). The state of the game: The corporate governance of football clubs. Research paper, Football Governance Research Centre of Birkbeck University of London, 3.</p><p>Jenkins, H (2004) ‘A Critique of Conventional CSR Theory: An SME Perspective, Journal of General Management, 9(4): 55–75.</p><p>Jenkins, H (2006) Small Business Champions for Corporate Social Responsibility, Journal of Business Ethics, 67(3): 241–256.</p><p>Kercher, K. (2007). Corporate Social Responsibility: Impact of globalisation and international business. Faculty of Law.</p><p>Matten, D., and Crane, A. (2005). Corporate Citizenship: Towards an Extended Theoretical Conceptualization. Academy of Management Review, 30(1): 166–79.</p><p>Melé, D. (2008). Corporate Social Responsibility Theories. Oxford Handbooks.</p><p>Njororai, S. (2009). Colonial legacy, minorities and association football in Kenya. Soccer &amp; Society, 10 (6): 866–882.</p><p>Porter, M.E., and Kramer, M.R. (2002). The Competitive Advantage of Corporate Philanthropy. Harvard Business Review, December: 57–68.</p><p>Pinkser, J. (2014). One city in Pakistan makes nearly half of the world’s soccer balls. The Atlantic. Available at: <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/07/one-city-in-pakistan-produces-nearly-half-of-the-worlds-soccer-balls/373802">https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/07/one-city-in-pakistan-produces-nearly-half-of-the-worlds-soccer-balls/373802</a>. [Accessed 5 March. 2018].</p><p>Scherer, A.G., Palazzo, G., and Baumann, D. (2006). Global Rules and Private Actors. Towards a New Role of the Transnational Corporation in Global Governance. Business Ethics Quarterly, 16: 505–532.</p><p>Scherrer, G. (2017). Barça-Real : Les chiffres qui montrent que le Clasico n’est pas un match comme les autres. [online] Available at: <a href="https://sport.francetvinfo.fr/football/espagne/barca-real-les-chiffres-qui-montrent-que-le-clasico-nest-pas-un-match-comme-les-autres.">https://sport.francetvinfo.fr/football/espagne/barca-real-les-chiffres-qui-montrent-que-le-clasico-nest-pas-un-match-comme-les-autres.</a> [Accessed 2 March 2018].</p><p>Szymanski, S. (1998). Why is Manchester United so successful? Business Strategy Review, 9(4), 4755. Tacon, R. (2005). Football and social inclusion: Evaluating social policy. Research paper, Football.</p><p>Walters, G., Tacon, R. (2011). Corporate Social Responsibility in European Football: A report funded by the UEFA Research Grant Programme. LO. (2003). FIFA and ILO team up on worldwide campaign to fight child labour. Press release, February 13.</p><p>Wood, D.J. (1991). Corporate Social Performance Revisited, Academy of Management Review, 16: 691–718.</p><p>[1] Widely considered to start its third expansion phase in 1989, resulting from the fall of the Berlin Wall.</p><p>[2] Bosman ruling on December 15th 1995.</p><p>[3] Available at: http://www.juventus.com/en/club/investor-relations/csr/index.php.</p><p>[4] For which the Agnelli family also directs multination Fiat.</p><p>[5] Juventus, Arsenal, Bayern Munich, Atletico Madrid, Olympique Lyonnais.</p><p>[6] Iñaki Williams in 2012.</p><p>[7] Black-White-Muslim.</p><p>[8] He was followed by Michel Platini and Jerome Valcke a few months later.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46f2393f6d1f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>