<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Henry Prince on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Henry Prince on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@henryprince?source=rss-d9a16d80944b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 14:02:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@henryprince/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Problem With Copyright In The Digital Age]]></title>
            <link>https://henryprince.medium.com/the-problem-with-copyright-in-the-digital-age-38b41d274bde?source=rss-d9a16d80944b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38b41d274bde</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henry Prince]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Feb 2022 19:42:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-10T19:42:42.776Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This essay focusses on copyright which, as we’ll see, is intrinsically linked to capital. The aim is to discuss the ways which copyright policy and jurisprudence are stuck- they’re outdated. Copyright is a tool used by big businesses to suppress innovative and useful information technologies. Copyright has been used as a weapon and tool for control by big businesses to secure their economic positions and ensure growth for decades, and centuries even. As laissez-fair economics have taken hold in the 20th century, copyright policy has become led by corporate needs. Along with influencing policy, big business has pushed forward its conception of ‘creativity’ as the magical act of conceiving original ideas from thin air and claiming ownership over them for life and beyond. This essay traces back the origins of copyright — how it came into existence and under what circumstances, discusses copyright’s modern evolutions as well as contemporary movements, and questions its validity in the digital age arguing that copyright is the transference of collective expression into private individual ownership.</p><h3>1. Copyright — an origins story</h3><p>Only a small subsection of people could read and write when the printing press was brought to Europe. The religious and political class used writing to enshrine doctrine and the educated, letter-writing elite wrote out of leisure. A laborious method of reproducing texts using wood blocks existed, imported from China, but the written word had a long way to go before becoming commodified. In 1440, Johannes Gutenberg developed the European iteration of the printing press which enabled Venetian merchant capitalists to lay the groundwork for the transformation of the book trade along capitalistic lines. At the inception of the book trade, book manufacturers were awarded exclusive printing privileges (patents) by state authorities as a way of stimulating economic growth, in exchange for political loyalty. Of course, at this point in history, writing wasn’t a profession or leisure activity as it is today. In fact, relatively few people were engaged in writing and this new business focussed on the production of ancient works by Greek and Latin authors. This here marks the beginning of the private appropriation of intellectual creativity, made possible by intellectual property laws as agreed by the state and merchant class.</p><p>In England, the early book trade was characterised by a monopoly awarded to the Stationers Company (circa 1476). The Stationers Company kept a registry of every publisher and title printed, and as a result was able to control what was manufactured. In other words, censorship emerged with primitive copyright laws. It’s worth mentioning at this point that these early copyright laws were very different from today’s. The growing economic rewards from the trade flowed only to publishers, printers and booksellers. Authors’ rights weren’t recognised until publishers started reaching the limits of classic and medieval works in the proverbial public domain. Having encouraged the expansion of the reading public (aka proved a market off the back of stolen works and created demand), they began looking to new authors and original works to stimulate growth. Fast forward to the end of the 17th century and being an author became an activity to pursue for personal recognition and financial gain. In this same period, the printing monopoly was gradually dismantled, and copyright evolved to endow authors with a <em>natural right</em> to their works, as the fruits of their own labour (<em>natural right</em> meaning a perpetual right beyond the authority of any government; impossible to repeal by human law— a universal, inalienable right). In response, and to safeguard its exclusive control over valuable literary works, the copyright industry reasoned that; individuals must be free to alienate their property rights since these rights are not only to be enjoyed and used, but also to be disposed of, exchanged and alienated. The publishing monopoly accommodated authors’ natural rights into its modus operandi but managed to avoid any significant damage to the industry by arguing authors must transfer their rights in perpetuity in order to be published and commercialised. Legal challenges in civil courts were unsuccessful.</p><p>In 1710, almost three centuries into book printing, the first modern copyright law was passed: The Statute of Queen Anne. Existing titles would be copyright protected for periods of 21 years, while new ones for an initial period of 14 years, renewable for a further 14 years. (today, most copyrights last for 70 years after the death of the author, or in the case of multiple authors, the death of the last living author). The Statute of Queen Anne also only concerned the right to copy and had the effect of protecting against piracy.</p><p>By the late 1700s, 12 out of the 13 original states of the United States of America passed copyright laws based on the Statute of Queen Anne. Their iterations of intellectual property laws emphasised the need for <em>legal security of the fruits of learned and ingenious persons’ study and industry</em>. Americans cemented the idea that human beings require economic reward to be intellectually or artistically creative. Amazingly, five states went even further in democratising access to knowledge and, in order to avoid a copyright monopoly, set a “just price” clause. This clause allowed courts to set reasonable prices for books where copyright owners overcharged. Also, if a copyright owner tried to limit the supply of a work, the court could grant a license to publish it to another party. In sum, this era of copyright continued to be a publisher’s economic right regulated in service of the public, without any rights for authors. In 1790 the United States’ copyright laws went federal.</p><h3>2. Copyright — Modern iteration of the law in England and Wales</h3><p>Copyright today has long expanded from just books to include a great number of types of works like film scripts, typefaces, sculptures, industrial designs, software and so on. It is largely an automatic right meaning that once a work is ‘fixed’ in tangible form, no registration is needed. It is fleshed out across many international and regional agreements, and of course national legislatures.</p><p>In England, copyright law makes up over 200 pages of the <em>Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988</em> and is complemented by many EU copyright policy updates. So what does copyright give you the exclusive right to do as an author?</p><p>In England, and broadly in the western world, copyright gives you the author the exclusive right to: <strong>make copies of your work, distribute copies, rent or lend copies, perform or play your work in public, and make adaptations</strong>. This refers to the entirety of any piece of work, or a substantial part at least. Any third party must obtain permission from the rightful copyright owner before exploiting works in the above mentioned ways. If not, you are a pirate and copyright infringer.</p><p>Any lawyer worth their salt will tell you quickly that copyright law and capital are intertwined. In practice, the reason intellectual property protection exists is so that individuals or companies can monetise by entering into business agreements, or suing others for infringing your rights. It’s important at this point to insert a caveat to say that within the capitalist paradigm copyright does have some positive uses and the intention is to critique modern copyright law, not to advocate a dismantling of the entire copyright industrial complex. Exclusive rights exist to enable authors to exploit the fruits of their labor commercially — to sustainably earn a living from their inventions, and to exclude others from gaining financially from work that is not their own. They’re like bargaining chips that they can choose to exchange with members of the mercantile class, like distributors or manufacturers. Copyright operates as a support system so that creatives, especially ones engaged in time consuming production (like scriptwriting) are able to dedicate sufficient time to it. Without the ability to earn a living from creative work, creation would be reserved for a wealthy elite and 9–5 workers creating micro-content in their lunch breaks and weekends.</p><h3>3. Copyright as a means to suppress disruptive information technology.</h3><p>Technology moves fast and it often reveals new ways of distributing, consuming and copying content. For example; in the 80s the VCR enabled individuals to record televised content and make copies of VHS tapes at home. Before the VCR, in the tightly controlled and highly commercial TV industry, people could only access content from TV broadcasts or by physically going to the cinema. Each content <em>access point</em> was monetised either by advertising or tickets at the box office. So when the VCR came along and people could own and watch tapes on demand after only paying the initial purchase price, the copyright industrial complex mounted a fight. In legal terms, the VCR allowed people to make copies of copyrighted films and programmes at home. As we saw above, making copies of works without permission is copyright infringement, so a huge debate was sparked over whether the millions of people using VCRs were breaking the law or not. The same thing happened with MP3s and p2p file sharing — more on that later.</p><p>The dilemma lies where these new technologies are not designed with the law in mind, but only to improve access to information. As law-making is a slow process it is often reactive to change and isn’t able to adapt quickly to new technologies. In this chapter I’m going to discuss three important Dutch cases that went to the highest court in the EU, which tried to clarify how the law can protect against new technological means of access to information - means that exploited blind spots in the pre-existing legal framework.</p><h4>The Pirate Bay Case</h4><p>The Pirate Bay (TPB) is interesting because technically none of it’s functionality constitutes copyright infringement. TPB are not making copies or distributing, broadcasting or renting any works at all. TPB is a decentralised platform that links up uploaders (”seeders”) with downloaders (“leechers”); hence ‘peer to peer’ (p2p). It’s a bit like a telephone exchange. With TPB it is the file sharers themselves that are committing the offences by distributing songs or films without permission. So what could the content industries do? A few countries have seen cases against individual pirates, hoping to scare the rest of us into stopping but that hasn’t really worked. The only hope of blocking access to this platform was to go to court and try and persuade a judge to interpret the law so it applied to TPB, kind of like bending the rules. And that’s what happened in the Court of Justice of the European Union.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38b41d274bde" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making a Living from Live Streaming? A Beginner’s Guide to Monetisation Features]]></title>
            <link>https://henryprince.medium.com/making-a-living-from-live-streaming-a-beginners-guide-to-monetisation-features-bea0fe000754?source=rss-d9a16d80944b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bea0fe000754</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henry Prince]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Oct 2020 07:42:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-29T14:55:52.771Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An analysis of the biggest platforms’ monetisation features for the artists, managers and more, turning to live streaming for a new income stream.</h4><p>This post was written by <a href="https://medium.com/@henryprince">Henry Prince</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@jeremiejoubert">Jeremie Joubert</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-LEtdvymOONDOgslVHrCWg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by<a href="https://unsplash.com/@luismorerat?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText"> Luis Morera</a> on<a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/stage-camera?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText"> Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Eight months into the pandemic it feels somewhat trite to begin by stating the unprecedented ascendance of the live streaming format in music. Yet artists who relied massively on touring income are still struggling terribly, and many have already turned to live streaming or have felt pressured to do so, wondering how it could work for them. According to a Bandsintown <a href="https://artists.bandsintown.com/support/blog/bandsintown-releases-data-report-on-live-streaming-attitudes-amongst-fans-artists">data report</a>, 70% of artists are hoping to increase the frequency of their live streams — but is this medium viable? What tools exist at the disposal of artists to earn money from live streaming? Show business is as much show as it is business, so how can the latter thrive via this new form of entertainment?</p><p>Overall we find that there are two facets to generating revenue through live streaming. Creators can utilise <strong>in-platform</strong>, native features among which memberships and paywalls present interesting prospects. We are more reserved on the advertising model, let alone the digital goods model. Alternatively, creators can leverage their traffic <strong>off-platform</strong>, that is by redirecting viewers to third-party websites to capture data, generate merchandise sales or music streams. The native, in-platform features are complex yet interesting and will make the primary focus of this article. We will however touch on the off-platform features towards the end of this piece.</p><p>This article provides artists with a beginner’s guide to the monetisation features available from live streaming platforms such as Twitch, YouTube, TikTok and Twitter. It aims to guide artists and their managers in unlocking revenue streams while engaging with their fans. The native features under review are <strong>advertising</strong>, <strong>digital goods</strong>, <strong>memberships</strong>, and <strong>ticketing</strong>. We will cover how artists can access the tiers (or “Programs”) which unlock these features, how they work, which platforms make them available and offer our view on the pros and cons along the way. Leveraging live stream traffic off-platform involves embedding links in-stream, in the video descriptions and in the creators’ profiles, which can be achieved with varying degrees of creativity and freedom.</p><h3>Native, In-Platform Monetisation Features</h3><p>A few things set live streaming apart from conventional on-demand streaming. Firstly, as an artist or manager, while you may be used to receiving royalties through an intermediary like a collection society, a label or a distributor, the dominant model in live streaming is for the streamers to be paid directly by the platforms. This is particularly true since the royalties that are paid by the video platforms are at best constrained, when not subject to <a href="https://www.billboard.com/articles/business/9431760/jeff-bezos-twitch-music-royalties-artist-rights-alliance-letter">controversy</a> anyway. Secondly, the sources of revenue available for streamers are more diverse and can be convoluted. We will discuss, for instance, the introduction of virtual currencies (aka digital goods) which bring a whole new world of monetary exchanges.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/973/0*axohOf6gzWuamREP" /></figure><p>The table above summarises the availability of monetisation features offered by the main streaming platforms. Before we dive into each of those, it is worth noting that not all features are accessible to all creators. Most platforms have introduced streamer tiers, and let us first see who can unlock those.</p><p>As live streaming platforms foster direct relationships with their talent, they employ incentive schemes to encourage streamers to produce content. Consequently, features allowing streamers to earn money are always presented as a reward for creating quality content and growing an audience.</p><p>Let’s first look at Twitch to illustrate this. On Twitch, creators ascend through three levels: <em>Streamer</em>, <em>Affiliate </em>and <em>Partner</em>. To move up the levels, creators have to achieve certain thresholds of usage and audience building. You begin your journey as a <em>Streamer</em>. To become an <em>Affiliate </em>and unlock monetisation features, you need to broadcast for a minimum of 8 hours over at least 7 unique days in the last month, have at least 3 viewers per stream on average and gain 50+ followers. The thresholds increase to unlock <em>Partner </em>status (<a href="https://www.twitch.tv/creatorcamp/en/learn-the-basics/twitch-101/">see Twitch 101</a>).</p><p>Similarly, on Twitter, you must be onboarded to the <a href="https://media.twitter.com/en_us/articles/products/2018/in-stream-video-ads-for-publishers.html"><em>Amplify Pre-Roll Program</em></a> to unlock monetisation via ads. This requires your account to be verified and for you to publish around 5 videos per week in the last month. On YouTube, you must be a Partner to start monetising your content. To be eligible, you need to live in a qualifying country, have gained more than 4,000 watch hours in the last 12 months as well as 1000 subscribers and have a linked AdSense account (<a href="https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/72851?hl=en-GB">see this page</a> for up to date eligibility criteria).</p><h3>Ad-Breaks: Unlikely To Break The Bank.</h3><p>As you start broadcasting, the platform may introduce advertising in and around your content and send you a share of that income. Your earnings will depend on where and how often ads are shown, how many viewers saw the ad, and where the viewers are. They will also depend on the pool of advertiser revenue.</p><p>This model was not particularly rewarding for creators pre-pandemic. In 2020, it has become even less so since advertisers have pulled their ads in droves reducing the demand for ad space and in turn impacting the payouts. On average, it was generally accepted that YouTube paid out somewhere in the region of $1,000 for 1 million streams, yet this estimate might get even lower with the impact of Covid-19 (for a more detailed breakdown see <a href="https://onezero.medium.com/this-is-how-much-youtube-paid-me-for-my-1-000-000-viewed-video-1453cad73847">this article</a>).</p><p>As we saw above, to activate this revenue stream you will need to access specific programs or streamer tiers such as the YouTube Partner Program. The cut of the money that YouTube pays out to the creator comes to <a href="https://influencermarketinghub.com/youtube-money-calculator/">55%</a> of the cost per thousand impressions (CPM) billed to the advertiser (yes, they retain 45%), which itself varies on a country-by-country basis. In other words, one million views in India will earn you less than one million views in the United States, since India-based advertisers typically pay less.</p><p>Twitch pays out the creator on a fixed CPM basis or up to 75% of net ad revenue, depending on the country in which the end-user views the ad (Source: <a href="https://www.twitch.tv/p/legal/affiliate-agreement/">Twitch Affiliate Agreement</a>). And if you get access to Twitter’s Amplify Pre-Roll Program you keep <a href="https://digiday.com/media/twitter-now-offering-30-second-skippable-pre-roll-ads/">70%</a> of the revenue from ads, except if Twitter helps drive traffic to your content, then the table turns, you only keep 30% and Twitter keeps 70%.</p><p>In our view, the ad-supported model is a good add-on to make some extra cash from live streaming but the earning potential will only reward those artists able to attract viewers in large, absolute numbers. For this reason, this does not feel like the most compelling way to earn money from live streaming and should certainly not be your main driver unless you are confident you can drive audiences in the tens of millions.</p><h3>Digital Goods: An Innovative Model With Some Maturing To Do</h3><p>The digital goods model involves viewers actively and directly giving streamers money in the form of virtual gifts, tips, or fiat currency. It is more complex because many platforms require their users to first acquire some virtual currency before spending it. The nature of the digital goods that users will spend their virtual cash on also varies.</p><p>To demonstrate how this model works, we will focus on YouTube and TikTok. Instagram does not have a digital goods model at the time of writing and only video-game streamers are eligible to earn “Stars” on Facebook.</p><p>YouTube digital items are <a href="https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7288782?hl=en-GB">“Super Stickers” and “Super Chat”</a>. Super Chat is a service where a user pays for their comment or question to be pinned at the top of the chatbox, next to your stream. A common use case for this is an artist Q&amp;A: if many questions are flooding the chatbox, viewers will be enticed to buy a Super Chat to highlight their question to the artist or streamer. YouTube’s Super Stickers inhabit the chat much like Facebook stickers in Messenger and are the cousins of emojis. They offer a way for fans to support their favourite streamers while getting a token gift in return. The viewer’s name and the amount spent appear next to the sticker so that you can give them a shout out. As a live streamer you earn revenue from your viewers spending these items: you keep <a href="https://videoadnews.com/2019/11/06/youtube-helps-creators-diversify-beyond-ad-revenue-with-super-stickers/">70%</a> of the gross revenue, However, to access this scheme you also need to be in YouTube’s Partner Programme.</p><p>TikTok’s digital goods gifting model rests on what is essentially a digital currency, whereby viewers can purchase ‘coins’ to reward streamers. This model is not unique: Twitter and Reddit also have ‘coins’, Twitch has ‘Bits’, and Facebook has ‘Stars’.</p><p>Going back to TikTok, once a viewer has purchased Coins in their wallet, they can then purchase gifts or “virtual items” which can be bestowed upon their favourite live streamers or artists. As with YouTube’s Super Stickers, these gifts are a proxy for showing support and the gifter’s name, user ID and the amount of the gift appear for all to see in the stream so that the streamer can give the gifter a shout out. Once a gift lands in the streamer’s account it may be converted into Diamonds (“virtual credits”) and it is these diamonds alone that can be converted into hard cash and withdrawn using Paypal or other payment channels.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ffQAXNDsl8NfzzUS" /></figure><p>So how much is a Diamond worth in US dollars? On their <a href="https://www.tiktok.com/legal/virtual-items?lang=en">website</a>, TikTok states “<em>The applicable monetary compensation will be calculated by us based on various factors including the number of Diamonds a user has accrued</em>”. In practice, a diamond is worth <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V64KxRV5TQo">$0.005</a> but the vagueness of TikTok’s policy suggests this is subject to change at their discretion. As a streamer you must withdraw at least $50 at a time and since TikTok takes 50% of your earnings that means you must accrue $100 (ie 20,000 Diamonds) to cash out. How many gifts do you need to accrue 20k diamonds? The diamonds equal the coin value of the gift, for instance, if you receive 500 coin gifts, you earn 500 diamonds. A package of 500 coins currently retails at $6.49. So, for you to get your first whiff of cash ($50) from live streaming on TikTok, you need fans to collectively give you $270.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/0*AcXBc5U7_7sqMBbd" /><figcaption>Examples of TikTok virtual items or ‘gifts’ available in the store. Link to “Buy Coins” bottom right.</figcaption></figure><p>To receive money under this scheme you must be 16 or older and onboarded into the TikTok Live Stream Program. The eligibility criteria include your number of followers, engagement and frequency of posting. TikTok says you must be “selected by TikTok” which sounds like they are operating a tight curation, however, we understand it to be largely automated.</p><p>Elsewhere, Twitch streamers receive <a href="https://www.uktech.news/how-to-make-money-on-twitch-a-beginners-guide#:~:text=Each%20Twitch%20Bit%20is%20worth,thousands%20of%20Bits%20at%20once.">$0.01</a> per Bit gifted to them and Twitter pays out <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2017/06/21/periscope-super-hearts/">70%</a> of the cash value paid by fans for the Super Hearts (Twitter’s version of TikTok’s virtual gifts).</p><p>As a streamer, the amount you will receive will ultimately depend on the generosity of your audience, which will reward for good quality content and possibly a high level of interaction. Some streamers have also decided to openly prompt their viewers to tip them.</p><p>Our view is that this model should not be your primary focus as an artist. Each transaction generates very little net revenue and the model does not facilitate repeat payments. Digital Goods could be a nice add-on for those artists driving large audiences to their streams, but still: why should they bother?</p><h3>Membership: A Promising And Flexible Model</h3><p>The membership remuneration type is based on your viewers paying a monthly subscription to your streaming channel, in exchange for recognition, access, or other perks you can mobilise. Twitch and YouTube are the main proponents of memberships.</p><p>On Twitch you must be an Affiliate to add a subscription button to your profile and the set 3-tier pricing structure which starts at £4.99/month for your fans can go up to £9.99/month and £24.99/month. The creator keeps <a href="https://www.twitch.tv/p/legal/affiliate-agreement/">50%</a> of the revenue from channel memberships or, in other words, Twitch keeps a lion share of 50%. <a href="https://www.twitch.tv/thessfischer/">Thess Fischer</a> is a notable model and House DJ who has appeared for 3 years running in Top 100 Female DJ lists from DJane Mag and DJaneTop. She live streams DJ sets on Twitch three times a week. Thess has a very well crafted Twitch profile, with clear links to her social media channels, Discord server, donate button and more. She monetises her channel by offering three membership tiers. Tier 1 removes ads, gives you access to the chat in subscriber-only mode, as well as subscriber-only streams — it also unlocks a “Sub Badge”. Tiers 2 and 3 offer exclusive emotes on top. According to some speculative calculations, if 10% of her 11,432 Twitch followers subscribed to the first tier (£4.99), Thess would generate £5703 each month from her members and take home £2851 after Twitch’s cut.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/778/0*iKUFjVsWohjomQ2I" /></figure><p>YouTube also offers “Channel Memberships”, which can be priced anywhere from £0.99/month up to £49.99/month (or equivalent in local currencies). Each tier can be set to unlock new perks such as ad-free viewing, loyalty badges, custom emojis, members-only chat and more. At the time of writing, YouTube offers a private live stream feature in beta mode, which could quickly become a smarter way to monetise your live appearances. For a YouTube channel to start offering memberships, YouTube does set a barrier to entry at 30,000 subscribers or more (eligibility detailed <a href="https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7636690?hl=en">here</a>) and will keep a 30% cut to manage the subscriptions and take payments on you behalf.</p><p>Patreon deserves an honourable mention here and it seems to us that it is the direct-to-fan subscription platform par excellence. Straight from inside the Patreon feed, patrons can engage with their audience and offer many different kinds of content such as posts, images, videos, audio files and even exclusive live streams via integrations with YouTube and Crowdcast.</p><p>In our opinion, the membership model is one of the most promising options. It is an excellent way to engage with your core fans and reward them. As a creator, it also forces you to become more focussed on your core audience. Fans are billed automatically, at regular intervals, so artists get regular income. The amounts per transaction are higher than with digital goods.</p><p>For a more detailed discussion on subscription and membership models see <a href="https://medium.com/swlh/exploring-subscription-models-in-live-music-172ae91ca298">this article</a> from one of the authors of this piece.</p><h3>Paywalls Instead of Concert Halls? Ticketed Live Streaming Models</h3><p>The pay-per-view or ticketed model entails charging audiences for access to your live stream. In other words, paywalling your live stream. We have seen recent examples — experimentations, really — from artists successfully promoting and selling tickets to live events however the jury is still out regarding whether the ticketing model will thrive, and if it does whether it will continue to exist beyond the pandemic. Audiences are used to accessing live streams for free, so one question lurks over the model: as a fan what added value am I getting from a paid stream? Why should I pay for access when there is already so much content to watch for free or within my existing subscriptions?</p><p>Before looking to address those questions we need to go through the basics. This monetisation model consists of selling tickets to live stream events, be it performances, film premieres, chats, Q&amp;As etc.. There may also be secondary sources of revenue should you make the event available on-demand afterwards — think merchandising, or royalties, more pay-per-view access or royalties.</p><p>Currently, you can set up a paywalled event on Facebook from an artist or label Page but officially Facebook does not permit ticketed virtual events in which sound recordings or songs are performed. This means that if reported they may take down your event(s) or remove your access to other features. Other global platforms such as YouTube and Instagram do not make ticketing available for music-based events yet but are understood to be working the issue.</p><p>For now, we need to look outside of big tech giants. There are two ways to organise a ticketed digital show. Artists and their managers can use a ticket seller such as Dice who then links the fans to a third-party hosting platform (and that could be a private YouTube link). Alternatively, there are plenty of integrated services who will take care of the entire event, from ticketing to streaming, and allow the artist to control the experience. Both models allow artists to control ticket prices. We will look at these two models by analysing examples of their use.</p><h4>Ticket Gateway: Dice</h4><p>In July 2020, Nick Cave teamed up with a film making team to shoot his solo performance inside Alexandra Palace. The video recording was broadcast via a paywalled live stream and cost £16 (or equivalent). The event page said, “<em>The film will be streamed as a live experience, and will not be available to view online following the event (…) When the show’s about to start, the link to join will appear on your ticket, or you can access the stream link that [Dice will] email you on the day.“.</em></p><p>Dice has been until now an innovative, if conventional in its business model, ticket selling portal. When it comes to live stream events, on the night, Dice sends the fans a link to the stream hosted on a third-party website such as Vimeo, Zoom etc.</p><p>The familiarity and excellence in user experience design of both Dice and, say, Vimeo, make this model an attractive option but it must be noted that this approach requires many clicks for the end-user, navigating from an app to a video hosting service via a confirmation email if you want to view on desktop. The requirement to download an app, to begin with, may even prove too cumbersome to some who may not already have it. On the other hand, Dice does have an established audience, which likely enjoys the curation of the platform, and can be reached through promotions and notifications</p><p>This model allows the creator to choose whether to broadcast, behind the paywall, either an actual live performance or a pre-recorded one (which was the case for Nick Cave’s). Dice’s back end is also attractive, as it allows creators to conveniently edit the event page and provides customer data such as average age, gender, the number of “saves” in the app, how many fans are on the “waiting list”. Dice also provides each buyer’s name and email, although, strangely, Dice specifies that this customer data is not to be used for remarketing. There is no initial set up fee and Dice retains a generous <a href="https://support.dice.fm/article/353-fees-payments-and-reporting">10%</a> of the ticket sales.</p><h4>All-In-One Integrated Services: High-Spec to Basic</h4><p>Tech and music journalist and researcher Cherie Hue <a href="https://www.patreon.com/posts/what-will-happen-41057050">recently observed</a> that not a week goes by where she doesn’t hear a new live streaming platform. The spectrum is wide and ranges from the high spec, versatile and expensive to the cheap and cheerful. We will review two services on either end of that scale; Maestro as a premium, full-service platform, and Veeps on the more accessible end.</p><p>MAESTRO: High-End and Versatile</p><p>Maestro is a modular, high-spec, integrated solution which allows artists to create highly customised live streaming events nested inside a branded webpage, complete with interactive features. Adapted for access via mobile and browsers, Maestro offers a custom URL for each event. Further links to sell tickets, merch can be added. Interactive features such a chat, shout outs, fan polls, a donate button, social media feeds, Spotify profile can also be added. In short, Maestro offers a complete turnkey solution, and since it does not require fans to sign-in or download an app, access is rather frictionless.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TmAjIBbrI-Ci9qS6" /><figcaption>Branded Maestro landing page example with live stream player in the centre, a sidebar showing social feeds, Spotify, competitions, polls and more, and links along the top and bottom.</figcaption></figure><p>On the artist’s side, the experience of using Maestro is also frictionless as many tools required are integrated into the service — justifying Maestro’s premium price point. Services provided include website hosting, the livestream player, of course, analytics and data export. The service boasts strong bandwidth for delivering the video feed to fans and provides billing services for the paywall, collecting donations or ticket purchases. Maestro’s business model is based on thresholds for usage charge, on top of a $500 set up fee. 5,000 views cost $500 and each hour of live stream viewed is charged 8 cents per viewer, Maestro keeps 12% of the revenue from the paywall and donations and retains $0.65 per ticket sold. On the whole, according to Maestro, this adds up to approximately 18% of overall income for most projects. Of course, with this service you can freely set the price your fans will need to pay to access the livestream. Erykah Badu is a notable artist to have used this service. She priced access to her first live stream at $1, the second at $2 and the third at $3. With over <a href="https://variety.com/2020/music/news/erykah-badu-quarantine-concert-livestreams-business-1234582892/">100,000 viewers</a>, Badu will have grossed upwards of $100,000.</p><p>VEEPS: Simple and Accessible</p><p>Veeps offers a similar service to Maestro but much simpler and more accessible. There is no initial set up fee. Artists must create “artist accounts” on the website and have them verified before creating a paywalled event. Ticket prices are set by the artists and cannot go below <a href="https://veeps.com/faq">$3</a>. The transactions are artist-friendly since Veeps add a 15% service fee onto the ticket prices and it is the fans who bear the entire cost: there are no setup fees or deductions from the artists’ revenue. A key different with Maestro is Veeps presents as a hub or community, displaying upcoming shows on the homepage and locking fans into their ecosystem whereas Maestro is a faceless backend.</p><p>Using Veeps, artists can decide whether their live streams are made available on-demand after the event. Artists can either make them available for free on their usual channels or continue monetising access as paywalled on-demand streams via Veeps’ website.</p><p>As an example, L.A. Priest used Veeps in May to perform to fans “<a href="https://www.facebook.com/trulylapriest/videos/298209668247189">Live from the Shed</a>”. He charged £5 for advance tickets and £7.50 for tickets bought on the day of the show. L.A. Priest chose to upload the video <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YThgfn2adSw">recordings</a> of the live performance to his Facebook and YouTube pages straight after.</p><p>In our view, artists must, however, be mindful when doing this since they are making available for free something which other fans paid for, and it’s not clear what benefits the ticket holders got over the free viewers in the end. Fans may be happy to know that the performance is live at the time, but ultimately the video content is the same. Uploading live streams for free after the event sets a risky precedent and fans may be dissuaded from buying tickets to future live streams. Lastly, with modest budgets, live streams may not be super productions, so when made available on-demand afterwards (“out of context” in a way) alongside the rest of the internet’s on-demand videos, your video might lose the edge it had from being an exclusive, time-limited, paywalled live stream.</p><p>One of the disadvantages of Veeps’ is that fans must create fan accounts and watch the live streams via the Veeps website (whether on mobile or desktop). This means Veeps cannot send those all-important notifications to fans alerting them of the start of the event. The discoverability value-added is low too. With no app, they cannot send notifications recommending events you might like. No doubt Veeps will have mailing lists and social media presence but realistically as an artist, even your fans have to do the work and you will need to do all the heavy lifting when it comes to promoting your show and selling your tickets.</p><p>To conclude this section on the paywall model for making money from live streaming, we find that this is a more recommendable approach as the earning potential is higher relative to digital goods on ad-revenue. Artists can set their prices, can have more control over the experience, and collect data. However, the downside is that unlike a live tour in which artists could replicate the same show 20 times to new audiences, a show live-streamed is immediately expired. Some artists, such as Gorillaz for their <a href="https://gorillazlivenow.com/">December 2020 virtual shows</a> will arrange multiple performances over a short period to cover different time zones, but the life span is still not several months. We recommend getting creative and innovating on your current live set. How can you deconstruct or remix your live show to spin off different versions? In our opinion, Nick Cave’s “Idiot Prayer” was inspired because he offered fans alternate versions of songs “<a href="https://www.nickcave.com/news/idiot-prayer-nick-cave-alone-at-alexandra-palace/">from across the breadth of Cave’s career</a>”. In the topical, isolation-themed performance he reworked both songs and concert setting to convey new meaning.</p><h3>Other Features For Leveraging Your traffic: Linking Out</h3><p>We have now reviewed at lengths the in-platform, native monetisation features, However, as an artist or streamer, you may also leverage your audience and generate value, if not direct revenue, by directing fans to other sites or platforms in your ecosystem, such as your merch store or a music streaming service.</p><p>Perhaps, for some, capturing fan data may even become a strategic priority and the very reason why you would engage with your audience through the live stream medium. It will then become a necessity to send fans to a website you own and control.</p><p>We will discuss strategic issues around how a live stream project can and should live in your music marketing plan in a further article, however since this piece focuses on the features offered by the platforms themselves, let us explore those, with a focus on YouTube. The other platforms can be used to drive traffic through a simple URL in the stream description, the chatbox or your profile.</p><h3>Promoting concerts and other events</h3><p>You may already have concerts or festivals planned for the Summer or Fall of 2021. Through its <a href="https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7570245?hl=en-GB">‘Concert tickets on YouTube’</a> feature, YouTube allows artists to list upcoming live shows above video descriptions, and link out to ticket sellers. The viewer’s nearest concert is listed first, followed by the complete list of tour dates. You have to be selling tickets through one of only four YouTube-approved ticket vendors and the list of supported countries is not long (6 countries). Should you, however, at some point, sell tickets to a paywalled live stream event through a conventional ticketing platform, this feature may become particularly handy.</p><h3>Linking from your live stream</h3><p>Chances are, before considering streaming, you will have already uploaded a bunch of videos on YouTube, so you may already be aware of the importance of dropping the right link in your description. This will be your number one stop to drive traffic from your live stream event to your desired, off-platform website.</p><p>You may also be familiar with YouTube’s “Cards”. Simply put, they are overlays that appear at the top right corner of your videos at moments you chose in your videos, driving traffic to crowdfunds or merch purchase points on 3rd party sites or retailers approved by Youtube. You can add those cards to live streams too, and they will appear at regular intervals; when they don’t, a clickable tooltip, “(i)” will appear in the top right corner of your video, allowing your viewers to find out more.</p><h3>Linking out to your merchandise site</h3><p>YouTube also offers a specific “Merch shelf”, displaying official merch products for sale below your video. For music channels, the products can be automatically picked up from merchandise marketplace <a href="https://www.merchbar.com/">Merchbar</a> so your starting point is to ensure either your products are listed through one of Merchbar’s partners. Note that this feature is only available for members of Youtube’s Partner Program, access to which we’ve covered above.</p><h3>Making a Living From Live Streaming? A Modest Living Until a Winning Business Model Emerges</h3><p>There is no one-size-fits-all way of monetising when it comes to earning a crust while keeping those fans engaged via live streaming platforms. There is not one proven, valid, monetisation model although selling tickets and memberships seem the most promising.</p><p>Here is a summary chart of the features, platforms and rates paid by the platforms to help guide you towards the most suitable one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/944/0*RwPGRSbcCPoZdjo3" /><figcaption>Rates paid by live streaming platforms (including Dice as a live streaming <em>ticket seller</em>)</figcaption></figure><p>The four native monetisation features offered by the top global platforms, as they exist today, do not all show the same potentials. The membership model seems appealing on paper and could be a great way to convert fans into paying subscribers. Will they take you up on it? Will you, as an artist, find sufficient content to release regularly? The second-best model in our opinion is the paywall or ticketed model. Many in the industry will find comfort in the familiarity with this business model, but do not be fooled: online viewers have high expectations, and you will not lure them to simply pay what they can get for free elsewhere.</p><p>Among the other two models, the ad-support is a turnkey solution that will pay you, but this will only be viable for those artists who will count viewers in the five or six digits. Lastly, digital goods as they exist today may offer some rewards to popular streamers, but artists and their management will find it difficult to budget and plan around those unless, or until, this model matures.</p><p>All in all, how you as an artist will make use of monetisation features will also be determined by how you chose to engage with fans and the content of your live streams. Live streaming is a new format rather than a new channel through which to funnel old formats, and we will expand on this in a future article. Nick Cave was a trailblazer in this regard because his show seemingly took inspiration from the loneliness of lockdown. He reworked his performance to provide a unique take, which fans would otherwise not have seen. Hopefully, he will inspire many in devising appealing and unique live stream productions, rather than replicas of actual concerts.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bea0fe000754" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The real significance of Jon Hopkins “Singing bowl”]]></title>
            <link>https://henryprince.medium.com/the-real-significance-of-jon-hopkins-singing-bowl-fbc7698573f?source=rss-d9a16d80944b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbc7698573f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[isolation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ambient-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jon-hopkins]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henry Prince]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 May 2020 11:26:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-10T12:16:17.373Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The real significance of Jon Hopkins “Singing bowl (Ascension)”</h3><p>Jon Hopkins popped up in my Google News ‘suggested articles’ this morning. He has released a new ambient track called “Singing Bowl (Ascension)”. The black and white photo of him floating in a pool with his shirt on, looking numb and calmly staring upwards at nothing resonated with me. This was the first sign that JH was tapping into a collective state of mind. I scrolled through his twitter a bit and read through the NME article and the Clash article. Nowadays, music journalists are so used to commodifying musicians and their work that it doesn’t occur to them anymore to draw parallels and interpret their work as giving a voice to a collective consciousness. They missed an opportunity to remind us of the role of art in reflecting life back at us.</p><p>His tweets almost intentionally leave a trail of breadcrumbs to a commentary on isolation and self-exploration. It was an opportunity to write an elegant article describing how “Singing Bowl” and the creative process behind it, is a metaphor for the quietening of life and ongoing collective personal development. It’s not particularly interesting to know that the instrument he used is a 100 year old singing bowl from Delhi. The interesting part is where he describes it as ‘pure’ and ‘liberating’ to use a single sound source and pare back his creative process. This is a beautiful illustration of a wider social awakening.</p><p>Quarantine has made us all adapt our lives and find alternatives for old habits. We’ve all conjured up solutions to carry on activities that are important to us which depended on leaving the house like connecting with family members. In a shutdown world we’ve also had to pare back our lives significantly and live with less choice. In a mundane way, going to the supermarket and buying whatever is there because the usual shelves are bare and you impulsively buy whatever you can because <em>what if everything goes to shit and next time the shops are closed?</em> In a literal sense our world has been forcibly reduced to our neighbourhoods, the walk to the shops and the route we take in our daily quota of exercise. When there’s nothing to plan to do or regret not doing, no friends or places to see, no FOMO, we’re pushed to look more intently to our immediate surroundings for alternatives. Our lives are stripped back and we’re made to look inwards, relearn what we like and who we really are. We realise that we actually enjoy solitude. The illusion of endless choice as a necessary component for the <em>pursuit of happiness</em> (itself nothing but code for material gain and fulfilment of one’s consumer self) is broken and in reality, we can find freedom and contentment in simpler ways of living and being. If we’re lucky they might be beautiful, pure and liberating too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbc7698573f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I gave a talk at ORGCON19 about my new project on the information environment in the Web2.0 era.]]></title>
            <link>https://henryprince.medium.com/i-gave-a-talk-at-orgcon19-about-my-new-project-on-the-information-environment-in-the-web2-0-era-711f597186b9?source=rss-d9a16d80944b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/711f597186b9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[installation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-visualization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henry Prince]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jul 2019 06:42:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-15T14:45:23.714Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*X_d0iTKuFA49hNNweFbNEQ.png" /></figure><p>On Saturday 13th July <strong>Open Rights Group</strong> hosted their annual conference ORGCON. I’ve known the people at ORG for a few years as a volunteer and this year I was glad to give a talk about a project I’m working on.</p><p>FACT: In the space of a single decade, the most valuable companies (globally) by market cap went from being energy companies mostly selling oil, to only technology companies. Not only have tech companies totally displaced the energy companies, where the energy companies were worth between 200 and 300 billion dollars, the tech companies have gone far beyond, doubling these valuations (Facebook is currently valued at just shy of 600 billion dollars).</p><p>This is important because the WAY these companies have accumulated this wealth is by capturing information about our private lives and identities, and using it to influence our decisions to vote a certain way, or to buy a certain product.</p><p>Before moving forward I’d like to present myself. I’m Henry Prince. I’m an ORG volunteer, a law student and I work in music where I negotiate license agreements with music streaming companies, hardware manufactures and telcos to make our music catalogue available on their services. This means I have a good understanding of the commercial arrangements, and the flows of revenue and data from digital music consumption to labels and artists. Moreover, since 2014 I’ve run <strong>Not Like That</strong>, a record label and digital art production company in which I work closely with music, video and graphic artists to produce immersive A/V shows. My work with <strong>Not Like That</strong> has made me understand the power of immersive media as a means of conveying ideas in a profound, lasting way. I have found that the most effective way of communicating ideas is to appeal to both people’s intellect and also their emotions. Attaching the logic of an idea to an emotional state makes a much longer lasting impression.</p><p>This experience with Not Like That coupled with my legal studies led me to apply what I’d learnt to A/V installations addressing human and digital rights issues that I think need to be more broadly known and understood.</p><p>I will go into the details of the project I’m working on (which is the point of this post) but before, I want to open a bracket and talk about my personal history that made me interested to pursue this project. I grew up in a fairly middle class family, quite a modern household with an openness to new technologies. Certainly not luddites by any stretch. My parents have adopted smartphones with ease, they got on the social media train and have basically replaced TV with youtube on their tablets which is something I thought mainly millennials and up did. In spite of this, they have continually refused to take seriously my warnings regarding tech companies’ collection, storage and use of their data to influence their behaviours. It goes as far as them completely ignoring my pleas to stop tagging me on facebook when they check into locations or post group photos or selfies. My family insists on low-key doxing me whenever we hang out and they think I’m a <em>prima donna </em>for making a fuss about it. They tell me “why the hell would facebook care where I go or what I’m doing?” and “get over yourself”. Paradoxically, the times when I’m actually able to explain to them my concerns, their responses tend to swing between nihilism “what does it matter” and fatalism “we’re all fucked anyway”. Is this their way of humouring me by acknowledging the issues but disregarding their importance?</p><p>The truth is I suspect their behaviour is replicated across many many families and unfortunately even the Cambridge Analytica scandal hasn’t broken their spell of nihilism and fatalism.</p><p>The big idea behind my project is to highlight the contrast between what I call the individualised reality and the shared reality, in the context of the information environment. The shared reality is broadly how I characterise traditional media, which is to say media that is published in one set form that anyone can choose to engage with. Some newspapers or TV broadcasts, for example, might have certain political leanings but there is one limited spectrum of information being released into the world. The individualised reality is where each person’s newsfeed is crowded, different and curated to reflect them, so no two people have the same set of facts. The fact that the type of content facebook pushes to the fore is memes, which present complex issues in a grossly simplified, binary way leaving out any nuances that might give rise to necessary discussion, adds to the communication breakdown and pits people against each other.</p><p>My last installation/music performance hybrid in Feb 2019 had 6 projectors covering each wall in a room with visuals, creating what I liked to think of as a shared experience of a VR headset. The whole crowd was essentially standing in a 360 VR digital world. Recycling this idea, I thought it would be cool to illustrate the contrast between the shared and individualised realities by placing VR headsets inside this room. The outer screens would project a single but incomplete content feed and inside the headsets, participants would be faced with different images. In order to complete the picture in the shared reality, participants have to work together to solve a puzzle in the headsets. My reason for gamifying the installation is to simultaneously trigger an emotional response (pleasure - sense of achievement) and intellectual reaction in people when they realise that through their collaborative work in their individual visions, they managed to reveal the message or image outside. This game mechanic not only reinforces the message by tying positive emotion to action, but also reclaims a principle used by facebook (and the others) to make their apps addictive. It’s the principle of feedback loops and variable rewards that keep users coming back for more. When a user posts a photo for example, and gets a like or a comment, this triggers a small dopamine release in the brain which induces happiness. This leads the user to keep posting content and engaging with others to repeatedly trigger that reward. However, in order for this to work, facebook has to make sure users do not get linear rewards. They must get variable rewards. Sometimes likes, sometimes no likes. In the end, I want to encourage participants in my project to reflect on a question like “How is the way we access information affecting our citizenship?”, or “Do algorithms shaping our individualised realities have a knock-on effect on our perception of our common shared reality?”.</p><p>As you can imagine, this is a large scale project idea. Not feasible without decent funding and a dedicated team. So Ivan Isakov and I have devised a pared-back first iteration to gather feedback and spot challenges. The first iteration is an interactive web-app which aims to simulate the experience of a social media platform and highlights the way our personal data is taken as well as the effects of the processing of this data. The participant is drawn into a fake world where they are users of a new AI-assisted social media platform named Big Brother (working title). Where Apple has Siri and Amazon has Alexa, Big Brother has <em>bb, </em>the AI assistant. As participants scroll through the feed, <em>bb</em> will repeatedly interrupt them in a way not unlike Microsoft’s annoying <a href="https://www.google.com/search?q=clippy&amp;source=lnms&amp;tbm=isch&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=0ahUKEwjq6dCox7LjAhWhTxUIHf84C2oQ_AUIECgB&amp;biw=1278&amp;bih=662">Clippy</a>, prompting choices like selecting a song to listen to on Spotify, Google searching something or engaging with content on Twitter. <em>bb</em> uses creepy language revealing how much it knows about you (like your heart rate and blood pressure from a FitBit) and records all your choices, forming an image of who you are. For context, facebook and google do this — they call the information about you psychographic data and they use it to target content at you and to help third parties target ads at you. The 5 minute journey through the fake social network ends with all content in the newsfeed reflecting you.</p><p>I am always looking to scheme with artists and collaborate on projects. If you’d like to get involved in this project or have an idea for a new one, you can reach me at henryjnprince (at) gmail (dot) com. You can visit my website too at <a href="http://www.notlikethatmusic.com/">notlikethatmusic.com</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=711f597186b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Thinking Through Law and Code” — Lawrence Lessig lecture notes and thoughts.]]></title>
            <link>https://henryprince.medium.com/thinking-through-law-and-code-lawrence-lessig-lecture-notes-and-thoughts-5edfe99b2e84?source=rss-d9a16d80944b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5edfe99b2e84</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henry Prince]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Mar 2018 08:24:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-18T21:40:49.517Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In 1999 Lawrence Lessig published his book “Code: And Other Laws of Cyberspace” in which he argued <em>code is law,</em> inviting us to reflect on the forces that regulate our behaviours, and how the law affects those forces. For him it is necessary to go over the relationship between machine code and law once more. The advent of blockchain encourages him to tread old ground, remind us of how right his predictions had been regarding the internet, and warn us not to make the same mistakes again. Indeed, a parallel exists between the early days of the internet and these early days of blockchain, both in their philosophies of decentralisation, and potential.</p><h4>Lawrence Lessig explains the modalities that influence people’s behaviour.</h4><p>1.<strong> Law</strong>: Laws are <em>ex-ante</em> rules that govern our behaviours. They can determine <em>a priori</em> which actions are out of the question, and which are permissible. For example, the law tells us we cannot kill another or steal. Rules like this align themselves with fundamental morals and we all follow this code without needing to try first.</p><p>2. <strong>Norms</strong>: Norms are community codes — unwritten rules so to speak, which we all, more or less, live by. They aren’t written in law but rather form the foundation of our social interactions in that they signal to us the nature of situations in which we find ourselves. Take speech norms for instance; on a daily basis people auto-adjust their language based on the situations they are in, choosing perhaps to use colloquial language in social situations and formal language at work. Gender is also a carrier of many norms such as male/female dress codes and codes of conduct.</p><p>3. <strong>Market</strong>: The market impacts our behaviour in that different prices or costs orient our decisions.</p><p>4. <strong>Architecture</strong>: Lastly and perhaps most importantly in the online world, architecture affects our behaviour. Our physical environment such as fences and roads determine where we can and can’t go. Doors indicate entrances, and bridges routes over water. Architecture in software is the limitations imposed by user interfaces. Our behaviours are steered by which menu options we find, and which buttons are clickable.</p><p>→ In the end, the law actually impacts all three other modalities. Let’s look at smoking as an example. (1) The law regulates who can and can’t buy cigarettes. (2) Governments persuade people smoking is antisocial and harmful with advertising campaigns. They manipulate public opinion to alter norms so smoking begins to be seen negatively. (3) The State makes nicotine products extremely expensive, driving people away from the habit. (4) Finally, the State can impose rules on the composition of tobacco products such as the amount of nicotine in each cigarette. The effect here reducing people’s appetite for nicotine.</p><p>In the digital world, architecture affects the environment that enables or disables privacy, for example. Lessig challenges the 1990s notion that cyberspace is not regulable because of it’s immaterial nature; a place where free speech and privacy are protected. This early (libertarian) conception of the internet, notably voiced by EFF co-founder John Perry Barlow, considered that the traditional principles of property and identity were not relevant online. Lawrence Lessig points to an underlying confusion; legal concepts are applied to us not because we are existing in tangible space, but as a result of the architecture we are in, and limited to. The freedom of the early internet made possible by it’s architecture, could therefore be curtailed by actors (business/governments) seeking to police and monitor it, by turning it into an architecture of control. Of course, this has very much happened (cc Snowden revelations). In the 2000s, this original idealistic view of the internet was compromised, resulting in less privacy and security, and more control.</p><h4>Blockchain: The technology to bring about the next wave of paradigm shifts?</h4><p>Many mistakes were made in the 2000s which affected the development of the internet. How can those mistakes be avoided with the development and implementation of blockchains? Blockchain code is unique because it has two-fold potential. On the one hand technical (decentralised, transparent, immutable, automated) and on the other political - with the potential to improve governance and bridge the gap between behaviour and governments’ ability to regulate behaviour.</p><p>Blockchain is an architecture designed not to have a regulator in the middle, but blockchain evading the law is a libertarian fallacy. The law will not go away and will use it’s courts and other tools to intervene, however crudely. One striking and close-to-home example of this is the recent Court of Justice of European Union’s (CJEU) ruling in the Dutch Pirate Bay case. Here, the CJEU boldly expanded the legal notion of ‘communication to the public’ (essential in determining copyright infringement) to apply to The Pirate Bay that simply hosts and indexes trackers uploaded by users. Liability was confirmed (in spite of safe harbour laws protecting online intermediaries) and a web blocking injunction was handed down. (<a href="https://www.technollama.co.uk/european-court-rules-on-legal-nature-of-torrent-links-in-pirate-bay-case">ref</a>)</p><h4>In Lawrence Lessig’s view, there is a fundamental need for reciprocal understanding of machine code and law.</h4><p>Lawyers must grasp the radical efficiency brought in by blockchain code. It could be a great benefit to the most disadvantaged people, eliminating the need for trust in order to participate in economic (and other) transactions globally. Software developers must in turn understand three important aspects of the law; 1) imperfections are not always weaknesses, 2) it’s not possible to be above the law, and 3) escaping the law is often plain wrong.</p><p>1. <strong>A lack of clarity in law can be a feature!</strong> Ambiguous laws can help apply abstract legal principles to situations which may not have been originally envisioned. The <a href="https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/1651">All Writs Act</a>, a United States Federal Statute dating from 1789 for instance, allows Federal Courts to “issue all writs necessary or appropriate in aid of their respective jurisdictions and agreeable to usages and principles of law”. Following a shooting in San Bernardino, California in 2016, the FBI got hold of a suspect’s locked iphone. In order to access the phone’s data and help the investigation track down suspects and piece together events, the FBI appealed to Apple to help them circumvent the phone’s encryption. Invoking the 1789 All Writs Act, the FBI served the tech giant a court order to force it to write new software that would allow law enforcement officials to hack suspects’ phones. (Apple, with support from other Silicon Valley behemoths, has strongly resisted the court order on a number of legitimate grounds.) (<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/feb/24/apple-v-the-fbi-why-1789-all-writs-act-is-the-wrong-tool">ref</a>) This case illustrates the relationship between codified law and judge-made law. It can be more practical and beneficial for overarching rules to be vaguely worded with terms like “necessary” and “appropriate”, so that they endure and can be interpreted to apply to a variety of situations. Florian Glatz, blockchain lawyer and software developer defends this position commenting; ambiguous language can be helpful as much as detrimental as seen in the German constitutional case interpreting legislation from the 1950s to protect people from pervasive data gathering in the 1980s. Flexibility in language allows abstract rules to be adapted to a variety of situations which may occur in the real world, something binary machine code is not able to do. (<a href="https://youtu.be/q5V01d3sp80?t=46m10s">ref</a>) Lawrence Lessig references Meir Dan-Cohen who illustrates this idea on a positive note. Often, what people think the law says, is not necessarily echoed by court decisions and judgments. For example, people mostly believe ignorance of the law is not a valid defence, however in practice, judges often give reduced sentences on the basis that a wrong-doer didn’t realise they were breaking the law. Here, the legal ambiguity helps because it incentivises people to know the law, but also protects from punishment in the case of accidental wrong-doing. At the end of the day, lack of clarity can make the law more efficient by outsourcing precision to courts.</p><p>2. <strong>Evading the law is pointless</strong>. First of all, the law isn’t going away. Just because a system or transaction is automated, does not mean the law no longer applies. A vending machine provides a mechanised version of buying a fizzy drink from a shopkeeper, but consumer/merchant contract law still applies, as well as consumer protection policies. Even if we could think up a more complicated scenario, history tells us the State will use the law in however crude way to intervene in automated systems. <em>(See </em><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/dec/09/bitcoin-founder-craig-wrights-home-raided-by-australian-police"><em>here</em></a><em> where the Australian Tax Office decided cryptocurrency should be considered an asset for capital gains tax purposes, and raided Craig Wright’s house).</em></p><p>Second of all, blockchains will need the courts to fill gaps in the implied agreements being carried out by these machine contracts. In the event of unexpected outcomes, disputes will follow that need resolving. Already, we have an example of an unexpected outcome from a smart contract: The DAO heist of 2016. The DAO was a smart contract on the Ethereum blockchain designed to pool funds in a decentralised way for subsequent investments. Unfortunately, the account got hacked and $50 million in Ether was stolen. (<a href="https://www.wired.com/2016/06/50-million-hack-just-showed-dao-human/">ref</a>) Lukas Abegg, an IP lawyer and PhD student researching 3D printing and patent infringement discusses the heist based on three aspects of information: structural (form/shape), syntactic (letters, numbers) and semantic (content/meaning derived by humans). He explains that The DAO was created as pure code with no further legal framework or interference. The syntactic language of the code ruled the organisation. It transpired, someone used the code in a way that was not intended by the creators of the smart contract. Indeed, the INTENT was the semantic layer of the information in the machine code that was missing, which allowed the unexpected outcome. (<a href="https://youtu.be/161_QEHJEgw?t=13m17s">ref</a>)</p><p>Thirdly, in any contract, the State has an implied role of arbiter in the event of a dispute. Traditionally a contract partially removes trust between parties because it binds them in a legal framework that punishes breaches, but a court can also choose not to enforce a contract. Lawrence Lessig claims governments will intervene in the smart contracts they want and/or need to. Smart contracts might remove trust and the State as arbiter, but it is unlikely to accept being excommunicated across the board.</p><p>3. <strong>Escaping the law is often plain wrong.</strong> Sometimes, involvement from the state is wanted. Terms in private contracts are not always in the public interest. The public may want to resist pervasive private contracting which smart contracts would enable. The State has a place in enforcing fundamental public values. Towards the end of the nineteenth century, industrialisation took hold and mass production became an integral part of the economic order. Profits hinged on efficiency and manufacturers brought in uniform, pre-conceived agreements. (<a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-and-comparative-law-quarterly/article/standard-form-contracts-the-contract-theory-reconsidered/81189A86F4699762AF111A3D1D9AC7C3">ref</a>) The classical paradigm of individually negotiated contracts gave way to standard form contracts (‘take it or leave it’) which unfairly reflected the needs of the Offeror. In response to this evolution in contract theory, courts developed legislative tools to help signatories, such as the doctrine of fundamental breach and the doctrine of inequality of bargaining power. (<a href="https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/c771/0e052126683c39dbcf3753aefd77bb4d0666.pdf">ref</a>)</p><p>-</p><p><strong>Are there ways to mitigate the law / code conflicts? Which conflicts matter? Which are to be avoided?</strong> These questions are important because, if left to State forces to answer, their approach would come with “raw, stupid power”, to use Lawrence Lessig’s words. Lessig holds that the (USA) State is fraught with corruption and we (as citizens) must proactively preempt attempts to throttle or disproportionately control blockchain technology to protect business or government interests. If we do not ask ourselves which industries may be threatened by blockchains, we may fall prey to corporate interests determining through influencing policy, which uses are prudent, and which are not.</p><p>Watch the full lecture <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pcYJTIbhYF0">here</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5edfe99b2e84" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[EU Laws Regulating Online Intermediaries [Paraphrased].]]></title>
            <link>https://henryprince.medium.com/eu-laws-regulating-online-intermediaries-paraphrased-ede9d7a581ac?source=rss-d9a16d80944b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ede9d7a581ac</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[copyright]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[europe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-single-market]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Henry Prince]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Jan 2018 16:24:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-14T10:37:16.666Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I read through some EU legislation outlining the liability regime for online platforms and paraphrased it into something easily understandable. Warning: As I’ve simplified the language some important details may be omitted. This is a guide only.</p><h3><a href="http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex:32000L0031"><strong>E-Commerce Directive </strong>(2000)</a></h3><blockquote>-&gt; Article 14)</blockquote><p><strong>Hosting</strong>:</p><p>1. Where user data storage services are provided (i.e. Youtube, Dropbox, Imgur…), member states shall exempt providers from liability for the information stored, on condition that;</p><p>a) the provider has no actual knowledge of illegal content</p><p>b) upon obtaining actual knowledge of illegal activity, acts expeditiously to remove of disable access to the content.</p><p>2. This (paragraph 1) will not apply when the user is acting under the authority or control of the intermediary.</p><p>3. Notwithstanding this, a court may still require an intermediary to terminate or prevent access to an infringing work (in accordance with local legal systems), and member states may still establish procedures to govern the removal or disabling of access to content.</p><h3><a href="http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52016PC0593"><strong>Draft directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market</strong></a></h3><blockquote>- Recital 38)</blockquote><p>Where intermediaries store and provide access to copyrighted works uploaded by users = they are going beyond performing an act of communication to the public. In this case they must conclude licensing agreements with rightsholders, unless they are protected from liability under Article 14 of e-commerce Directive <em>(paraphrased above)</em>.</p><p>In respect of Article 14, it is necessary to verify whether the intermediary plays an active role in promoting or optimising the presentation of content.</p><p>In order to ensure the functioning of licensing agreements, intermediaries <em>[that store and provide public access to large amounts of works uploaded by users]</em> should take measures to ensure protection of said works by, for example, implementing effective technologies.</p><p>This should also apply when intermediaries are eligible for protection from liability under Article 14 of the E-commerce Directive.</p><blockquote>- Recital 39)</blockquote><p>Collaboration between intermediaries <em>[storing and providing public access to large amounts of copyright works uploaded by users]</em> and rightsholders is essential for the functioning of content identification technologies.</p><p>In such cases, the rightsholders should provide relevant and necessary data for this content identification, and the intermediaries should be transparent with rightsholders about what content identification technology is deployed to allow rights holders to assess their appropriateness.</p><p>Intermediaries should divulge:</p><p>- Type of technology used</p><p>- The way it is operated</p><p>- The success rate of identification</p><p>The content identification technology used should also allow rightsholders to get information from the intermediary on the use of their content covered by an agreement.</p><blockquote>- Article 13)</blockquote><p><em>Use of protected works by intermediaries [storing and providing access to large amounts of works uploaded by users].</em></p><p>1. Intermediaries shall, in cooperation with rightsholders, take measures to ensure the functioning of agreements concluded to prevent access to works identified by rightsholders through the cooperation with the intermediary. These measures (ie implementing content identification technology) will be appropriate and proportionate. The intermediary shall provide adequate information on the functioning and deployment of the measures, as well as, adequate reporting on the recognition and use of the works.</p><p>2. Intermediaries shall set up complaint and redress mechanisms for users in case of disputes.</p><p>3. Member states shall facilitate the cooperation between intermediaries and rightsholders through stakeholder dialogues to define best practices, taking into account the nature of the intermediaries, the technology available and its effectiveness in light of technological developments.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ede9d7a581ac" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>